37
t, ,!1lwt-lJ@rlIJL rtlA.11 t-@!. @M.1Lrtrtrl!.1t-CI '=" '''l"f' l?' J:l' rlL!. <!l rtC-rtLCI o l?' b ttl 1'1) l?' P °16 ,P '=" '=" m rtlqm rt l1,l€\L rtrl!: rtL t- pU !:!-rt,kJrt@kM. rtL rlL!. 0!P"'I rtc- rt.u1!.u.! t, ,!1lWt-1J @rlIJL rlL!. <!l rlL!. <!l rlL!. <!l rlL!. <!l<!l£i5] rlL!. rlL!. <!l£i5] @l,l rlL!. 0!P£i5] rtC-rtLCI rt.ut-lA.rtC-!. IP' 0 '=" r'O p<!l UCI !2L1rt.um IJ m lIl.LlU U rtL l!lll.!.l,l rtrl R.Ul U'L U it IJ 11 !2U rt l,l LlJL U it t-@ fl.L U . . t-@Wrt¥UL m!.LCI yrt,!,JrtJt.L M.rt 1, ,!1lWt-1J @rlIJL t, ,!1lW t-1J@rlIJLC- [j,Vjf,L!.rl rtrl!.l '" NU.' p !lti.MLU'rtU q <!> LUte. u. ,. '" . . "" '" "" ,l;LUJl,L,l;n e.1! ..... \ (l; S=7 r?J m I

u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

yrtJrtJturtn~Mrt t 1lwt-lJrlIJL djVjfLW~LrllA~L Urt~nLU~

rtlA11 LUJll2L1grt~nLU~ t-

~t)

LT1HLClM~111 M1Lrtrtrl1t-CI= lf l Jl

rlL ltl rtC-rtLCI LRUU~lAomnn~~LRUULUCIlLufJt-nlrtMrtLrllAC- o l b ttl 11) l P deg16 P = =

nLUlAn~n~~LUnfn ~nn m rtlqmrtl1leuroL rtrl1~lA rtL t-~1J11 LULjf~ rt~ult-pUitq~-rtkJrtkM ~

rtL ~rl~LrllA~LUnLlJu~ rtul~lJmmLCI~~lLULjf~LlJu6 rlL 0PI rtc-rtL~LRU~U itt-flLRU~LU

IJ~ rtu1u11~l2nJleuroWrtJrtJtLrtn~Mrtt 1lWt-1J rlIJL dJVifLrl~LrllA~L UnLULif~LUrtW ~mll

rlL ltl rtWL~ lluLUrtuLU~rtKfLif~LnLu UlLmm~rtn~~

rlL ltl rtWL~ (rt~t-M-t-llUrtLU) lluLUrtuLU~rtKfLjf~LnLu ~~Lmm~rtn~~

rlL ltl rtWL~ ~mL1LULif~LflLu ~llLmm~rtn~~

rlL ltlltlpoundi5] rtWL~ CIthLU~nLULjf~LnLu ~~Lmm~rtn~~

rlL ~(O rtC-rtL~ ~uLUrtlJ~Ljf~LnLu ~~Lmm~rtn~~

rlL ltlpoundi5] rtC-rtL~ ~uLULrllA~Lif~LnLu ~~Lfum~rtn~~

ll rlL 0Ppoundi5] rtC-rtLCI rtut-lArtC- IP 0 = rO ~~

(O~~poundi5] Jrt~LlJnU pltl ~rt~rtt poundi5]~~poundi5] LRU~LuIlL~~rt LRU~lIlampmL1n~~~lJll ~~Lmm~rtn~~

LRU~LUCI ~ lL~ ~ 2L1rtum tJ~ IJmlIlLlU~ U rtL llllll rtrl ~1~ RUl ~llL UL RU~ Uit~ IJ11 2UrtllLlJL RU~ Uitt- flL RU~L UIJ~ t-WrtyenULmLCI ~leuroL yrtJrtJtL rtn~ Mrt1 1lWt-1J rlIJL djVjfLrl~LrllA~L UrtLULjf~LUrtU~mllrlc-leuro

ynJrt)fLrtn~Mrt t 1lW t-1JrlIJLC-[jVjfLrl~LrllA~L UrtLULif~LlJLlrtLl~rt rtrll

f~(LLmm~rt~rthGGn NU p ~~~lt9 ltiMLUrtU qltgt LUte LJl~~C91lJco l~~ u

Ytt~jlaUtttl1~tMJtL ~tUNHmlkt[j~J(LtrJiWlt~Ltt lLUJlLlne1

bull rtlt~~ULtMft

(l S=7 rJ m

I

LRU~fLUrampL~~frt LRU~fLUo~IL~~~ltrtumt9u~tm~tiUllHrU~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f~t1I

~ ~Lfh fupoundrtrt~~f Rijl~~L ULRU~Utt~tII~U rt~LU LRU~UttL RU~fLU tML mfLo ~

LRUijUn~~LRUijLLU~MW~h~~~ 5ont amp1 ~4b IF

LroLLlHAMinm~Li W A~LLtrtrHli~ ~ f IF= Jl

on gtPdegJo L~ti~1t~rt~~i

flAMt-A ~I1LrtrHLoL ltl p Itl = fJ

~1t~Il~tLl1i~ -I ((

fLUrtfW fJLUmh f~ortfllrt~ fJfLoL W 1-

fLUrtfW M~~frtrt1 ~rtpoundu19loL 051

fLUrtfW t-At-~ LRer f~ fJfLoLf~uLijfJtJlM ltl bullIlgt

~L~1t~fLLQsmL~LLIt~

fLU itL~tm tJlM~t1I fLUrtf W 11Al1rt LrtoofJl[l ltlltl Ilgt = fO fJ

fLU itL rtmtJlM~t11 fLUrtfW t-fJtJlIfij fMfijfJfLoLf~)1Lijt-f Oltl Illgt f7 I= ~~fJ

fLuitLftI~lmfLUrtfW ~I1Lul1~Jll Lmtl1f~ 9fLoLf~)1LijfJtl~ f

fLUrtfW fijf)1)1U mfftw f~ fJfLoL P ~~ 10 fJ

fLUrtfW L~rtJr fJl1fijf~ fJfLoLf~ULijt-f ~ 0 isI= fJ

fLUrtfW f~h~ rto~frIfJfLoLf~)1LijfJtJlM q I= I 0 I is

fLUrtfW fJ~1I1t9rtLW LljRort~ fJfLoLf~)1LijfJtJlM r Ilgt bullIlgt

fLUrtfW ~rtltLr ~ttLrt f~ fJfLol~uLijt-f P fLUrtfW t-fJtJlIfij UmfLoLf~)1LijfJtJlM~ I= i= fJ I (6

fLUrtfW Rt-M~l1ol1 Ll1omLU f~ fJfL[l 051

fLUrtfWI1Ul~frt fJ~mll pound~rt)19fLoLf~)1Lijt-f ltl

tt1t~fLL~pound

lm(jIlJtL~rt~Mt1 roU~~rJ~i dhfllLrJ~LrJAtLr~ P fbI p In fb fb

rJ~LrJA~Lr~WL~1t~LfL~Atm

on OWdegJo L~ti wgtgtCiOl ltnMumu p(g A~I1LrbMnt P ItI = J fb fb

WgtgtCiOlCiOl ~t-k~

LL Ulll~l U~L u~m~~1t~fLLL UnL~rJl

QJ C C QJ 1~eJ ICl U eJ IJ ~H) 4iJ~ fHl tl11 ~ mil 1U lU VI ]11nJ ~ ~ ()~ f1l1fl1~Ui QJCCQ) 11l1l1~ffU

~1U1U QJcilo 11rJ IWf1l1JU1~~mrrU

1 ~ ~lJU1 ill W1~1 Cl1 U 11b11 VI rJlfll Cl~ 1 ~1U1U Q)() 11rJ u u

1~~lJU1WW1~1 Cl1IJ11blilflUfllM11 ~1U1U Q)C 11rJ u u

1~~lJU1Will1~1 Cl1IJ 11bltl11IJ11n11j1 nl ~1U1U QJ()() 11rJ u u bull

1~~lJU1WW1~1 Cl1IJ11bltl11UW ~1U1U () 11rJ u u u

~1U1U () 11rJ

~1U1U () 11rJ

C a V d Jt cv QlC ~ fltll ~m1l1 fll11 b1f1l1V1 l11t1l111ft 1111 UCllIf111 lClUeJIVI eJ1 lJfll1eJ4 II ~ Nfl f111fl f1ll111 f1

ClflllJ1111V1rJ1ftrJ 1Uc11~IJ~eJ iu

r- ----- -1~~--~ -~ cC tI C

(U1~Cl11~tl1U~ I~111)

NUUyjf1j1rJ~1U tl11U1~blI ~

AltvL-___ ~ i

(f1b1 rJfllCl~ 11111 rJ cpj1 Cl1ii til 1 b~ Cl f11 U ~) ~

N~ 11 11 1rJ~ 1U f111 U1 ~ b1I ~

YIb~fbJllmiddotIbI1~M 1 l 1lwn~ fllJ1 djVj(lffl~lflA~ll-ilb~l1lU

1 A11l Uj( l ~C1 Qfb~ l1l Ut-

(fl~ml ~ ~IbLlVll~llLllUt-)

~ l ml I M~ rllMlllb1flIt-1 ~ P po l

fll () 1t1l1 lfWUllAoml1l1~~lfWUlUIllLlHt-n o 17 ~ rU ttl 57 P 0$

~ 1Mlfl A~lbltlol A 11~Ib ~ ~l U11k11ll1l1lll 1 Il~ 111ll)t1 1fl(1~ A 1l t-~lJ II LUlj(~ IbLllt-~ U1l~ ~ 1J lbkM ~

fll () 1t1l~ flLllU1LllU~fbKklj(~lnlLl ullmm~fbl1~~

fll () 1t1l~ (1~t-M-t-19UfbLU) flLllU1LllU~fbKklj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll () 1t1l~ ~mC1lulj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll ()()~ 1t1l~ 1~hll-il1lUlj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll fCJ) 1t1l~ flLllUfblJ~lj(~lnlLl ~llmmpoundfbl1~~

fll ()~ 1t1l~ flLllklflA~lj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

- ~t-~I1~~f1ijIUflll ~

fll o~~ 1t1l~ 1~t-~Ibt CJ)ff~ J1~llmU P() ~1~~ff~ lRU~lUfll~~fblRU~lUI~ll~~ IfIfbull bull

l Ru~ll~mC1I1~~ ~lJ 11 ~Ilm mfb 11~ ~ l RU~l UI ~ Il~ ~~C1IbLl mi9(~mlI~U~ 1-i1bl111l9 1r ~I~ Rkl~19llfl RU~U1

~ lJ II ~Ufb19lUl RU~U1t-n 1fl ~Il UlJ tl11Llnt1)t1 1fl ( I~A 1l t-~ ~11l Ulj(~IbpoundLlI t-~U 1l~ ~Ibll

1lW t-lJ fllJ 1 t[jj(lffl~lfl A~ll-ilbl Ulj(~ lUIbW~m19 1fl~1

UWklfLU~HlMth(wn t(H1 ~ b~ P I

co ~ 9 ItM LU rtU () Lt Y1 t LClPPGlf()middotDcomiddot t~~ Lt P P1l p

I

lH1~k~~iltUl(i~lArRtJ tLUl$(ttt~lit~Uttl1 gLUnLgY1t~

middotmiddot I

-~

ttLt~~ULtJ1rt (6 8=7 ~

Amiddot

wbulla1Ua1t1n1a lJ111~hun~t1jllfnJ1~t1el~lfljW lUWj~1JjlJjllflhllJn

~ ~HY1 obd~ampamprn 1U~ Ggtamp mJm~Wpound ~ampamprnq

9 liJ~~ht mY 11ff~iJilllf1lS II ~~l1i4 YI~1 ij i4 1 ~m lilffeJIJ N~ fm l~ i4 lJeJltnffn~ lf1lIll1n~1I~~

tnffn~lf1lIlVilff~ ~t~ i41l SlJmiJI1 tinrrm lI~dJIltlffmJ~~rill~ ilf1lSffnm S ~ ~IJl1~WW19~ II ~~ S~~IJUtlcVi9ffnm l ~ to to

~rillhf1lSffnm l1S~~ltJf1lSffn~l wampamp1gtD lUll ri fJiJf1lWi4TI ampamp(I) SliJ~liU~lUlU cVo Sl

d QlGle1IWf1lllUS~9IJ9li4 shy

S~~IJl1~ tytyl9~ fflUlillliYIlfflff9l1 ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflU lilllfl~l1fflff9l ~lUlU

S ~~IJl1~tytyl9 ~ fflllilllf1lSIJ~I1lS1iSfi il ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflllilllf1lSJtytf ~lUlU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytyl9l~ ffllllilllrl1 S~fflffi4fflff9 (f1lS l1nm eJlVleJ l~i4) ~1U lU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytylleJ n fflIllilll~l1 S ~fflffUfflff9 1 ~ lU lU

~ 1 J a ~j I ~ ~ lJnlI ~iuIiI1 UIU ~middotGi1 Lililmilln H1Y1l1flfl U 3J (Imi ~uin tlJ1lJ (IiLL-afl Uu in tlJ1lJ (Ii

ar q U q ar q arar

3JI1iYltn~tJnilIlD)liltJEIilmmJ 1WYiim3Ji1~unWl 4IW)lilUVJ3JTI1W

IV o=l

)WYl 18 shy

T13Jl1YiWfi 2553

lllJJ1iJll

1~Ul11illq1t1il

ill fJ fJl ~middotihn m~ um-l

tlU~U 1 I tlU~U 2

illfJfJl(lr

1~uillfJryl

ill fJ ry1hI illfJfJ1Llfl

JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ lHi1~ 1ll-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J

1Tnflntllll1fltln~

lllJJ1iJlli Y1rJ1P11ll(l f 2 2

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

iUJ

-------------gt-----------j------------+------------f------------f------------f

3 3

4

6

1Tnflntllll1flYiUltl ll1~1iJlliYlrJ1P11ll(lf 19 19

lll~liJllPlltlPllll(lf 2 17 16 35

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

lllJJ1iJllfl l1UfJ~

4 6 53 142 207 1-------------+--- -------+--------

ll1~1iJllf~tl1PllllUPllll(lf

iU 4 3 6 90 159 263

l iUJr1~iU 4 3 6 93 162 269

Vl ~lilIH) tlLtll Vl~1ilV11 U ~ nfflB-J U~l

d ~ J vJshyIl-J Hl bullbullbullbull W11JY1 LtJ fJ W

rtlJ=J1itiit1hU11J~i1L~~n1iifm~1 it11111Jl11V1a1A1it~f ~ OJ

2-jn1V1tJ1~tJj11lrilJ 1mEl~Imnr 1UVljUj2-jjllU nWl ~IV11 ~UVJ2-jDli1

1UVl18 fJ2-J1n~ufi 2553

r~1Jiltlll(ll(ll1 r~1Jll(ll(ll1

ll(ll(ll1uirLnm~ilmJ ll(ll (lI1vir ll(ll(ll1tYl ll(ll(ll1Liln

hJHLnniill1 ~U~1J 1 ~U~1J 2

111EJ l-Ir1)~ 1l)J 111EJ l-Ir1)~ 111EJ l-IrD~ 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J 111EJ l-Ici1~ rl)J 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J

UnAnH1nflun~

iYlmn1~f1alJybLfla

f1l1n~~IJf11illllftlhJ +------------f-----------f----------I j------ ------+-----------+- ---------1------- -----1-shy -----------shy

5J3-l 2 2

UnAnH1nfl-nUlH

iYlmn1~f1aIJYilLfiaf

IYlflt 1Jtil1iVlilllln~~lJlL~1J~L Ylflt 1Jtil1in1~rJ1ifl ~ ---------- +-----------~------------+--- --------f------------I------------I-----------l------------1

16 j------------+----I---------I--------I------++---I

16

Lfljj

IYlflt 1Jtil1ilIIilllln~~lJlL~1J~ii L~nmailflilLLil~f1aIJW1Llllaf

5J3-l

~ 5JIJII~~U

19

19 2

19

21

iI11i1aa lJ ll~i1 11i1Y11UUf1 ~al ll~l

d ~~--~ltfa UlpoundJYI~liipoundJU~

11lJ~ntJtl ~~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ m~n~ b~Wtl~Jl1~~1~VltJ1~tJ~1llJl)dl~tJtl~1nnw

lJtltlWd-J~n1~1~mruru1Ull~ ~ ~

d-J~1~V1tJ1~m1llJl)dl~tJtl~1mnr1WVi~1J~d-J~1~iJ5wl ~1~1(1)iJVJ~fi1tJ tln1~~m~1 2552

tlW~e-J~n1~~mnb~tl1W~ 18 n~Jl1iWfi 2553

~1~jJVl ~r~iJ~~rl~d

~t1 ~1jil(1~ lPIiuw-nlPl btl i bbn i~ 1 ll11 VIJ1 n1i Afl ~ ViJ blPlfli

1 48122420131 W11~1dtl~Vi~nw ~~WA1 20 bd-JtJ 2529 216 iJn~

2 46222420101 W1t1n~Vili ~d~~ruiJ~~Mtfd9

3 VitJ 2510 239 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1A~ nii~ 111~ lPIitJ1tI

3 1471226001041 W11~1d~~d-J1 ~~b~W I 21 ViA 2529 222 iJn~ btlibbni~1ll1 bVIAbllb~~fl1Pl~1~nii~bbllllJbVIAbllb~~n1i(J~ 1PI

gt-bull4 50232790207 W1tJtJItJVlfi U1WdW 18 n A 2518 258 ~ bPlM 5 50232790301 W1mnl tlW~V1fi 13 Vi tJ 2520 311 ~bPlM

6 50232790303 W1tJ~nm~Mnr ~d-J~1bUW 18 VitJ 2525 260 ~bPlM

7 50232790304 W1tJ-nlld1~ ~111d 26 bd-JtJ 2524 281 ~bPlM

8 50232790307 W1tJruNrol ~lJru 23 VitJ 2526 308 ~bPlM

9 50232790308 W1tJrutiVi~ bVltJWd-JWll 10 nVi 2528 365 ~bPlMd9

Q tV ~ QA cl 10 50232790309 W1tJWdwJW ll~~V1fi 11 nVi 2530 315 ~bPlM

11 5023279031 0 W1tJd-JW~-ntJ AI1~dJ 9 nA 2520 315 ~bPlM

12 50232790311 W1tJ~It1 ~1~d-JiW 26 VitJ 2523 276 ~bPlM

13 50232790312 W1tJ~ViiOl-W ll~1-ntJ 19 nVi 2526 258 ~bPlM

14 50232790313 W1tJP1n~ru~1rol U(1)(1)1dlPl 9 ~A 2527 322 ~bPlM

15 50232790314 W1tJ~d-J bnm~ iJtlJJn 7 fiA 2527 315 ~bPlM ~

16 50232790316 W1tJ~d wJ jJ rutJd-J1lltJ 11 fiA 2526 298 ~bPlM

~

17 50232790317 W1tJtl~ru diOlWJldn~ 20 fiA 2527 281 ~bPlM AQ 4lI IV tS

18 50232790319 W1tJtlVlfiVi~ b~tliOlWVI~ 20 fiA 2526 303 ~bPlM

19 50232790320 W1tJ~bll~ fn-Kll~ 21 ViA 2520 275 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bA ij

20 49222840108 IW1t1iJnid-JVI~ b~1bfil I 11 nA 2522 289

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bVIAtllb~~fl1Pl~1~ nii~ bbllllJ~ b~ nVIiflU A~ bb~ Afl ~vh blPlfli

21 149222970101 1~~~n~ u I 18 nu 2528 318

d J -I ~ J_- ~1lltl IV-_--- W1tJVIb1JtJW

UtlJllill~1U1U~~1L~~miAmt1 l1l1111l1A~IIfll1l(1f ~ OJ

~Il1~VltJ1~m1llJiJ) 1fltJflflmn111U~~m~~l~1J trwl rrm11l1JVJ~filn IIV od

)UVl 18 nWl1~Ufi 2553 T~ciUfl~1frCC1 T~ciu1frCC1

1frCC1~1Lnm~nmJ llCC1~1 llCC1LYI U1CC1Lfln

hJnLn1lJ)lI1 fiuciu 1 fiuciu 2

Jl1poundJ ci)~ TllJ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ

trnAnH11l1flYi~flH

iiLlIflfllallrl

fllltln~~1J

i tl~ ~f1lalJf11 allrl oJ a~fllJfllaf1~1ll8Ol~ljWllJl

----------shy ---------shy

- - -- - - -shy ~ ~ -shy -----------shy

-- - -shy - --shy ~ --shy ----------shy

------------shy ---------_

------------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

---shy -------shy

-----------shy

------_--shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

----------shy -shy _------shy

-shy --------shy -----------shy2

--shy -------shy _ _----shy --

-----------shy -----------shy

------shy _shy

----------shy

----------shy

-shy -------shy

-----------shy2

-------_shy7

- - - - - shy ~ -shy8

-------shy

1 1 ---------shy ----------shy

2 --shy ----shy --shy

6 15 - -------shy -----shy

9 17 -------- ----shy ---shy

-------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

--__-------- --shy --------shy _---

--__-------- ---------shy _ ---shy -----shy

-----------shy ------------shy

----------shy --shy -shy -------shy

--shy -

---------shy

-----------_

gtUJ 2 17 16 35

~ gtUJII~~tJ 2 17 16 35

lilmiddoti1i1afJULL~lili1i1mU~n~fJILL~1

d ~~-- ~1Z1fJ UltJt1LutJU

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 2: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

LRU~fLUrampL~~frt LRU~fLUo~IL~~~ltrtumt9u~tm~tiUllHrU~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f~t1I

~ ~Lfh fupoundrtrt~~f Rijl~~L ULRU~Utt~tII~U rt~LU LRU~UttL RU~fLU tML mfLo ~

LRUijUn~~LRUijLLU~MW~h~~~ 5ont amp1 ~4b IF

LroLLlHAMinm~Li W A~LLtrtrHli~ ~ f IF= Jl

on gtPdegJo L~ti~1t~rt~~i

flAMt-A ~I1LrtrHLoL ltl p Itl = fJ

~1t~Il~tLl1i~ -I ((

fLUrtfW fJLUmh f~ortfllrt~ fJfLoL W 1-

fLUrtfW M~~frtrt1 ~rtpoundu19loL 051

fLUrtfW t-At-~ LRer f~ fJfLoLf~uLijfJtJlM ltl bullIlgt

~L~1t~fLLQsmL~LLIt~

fLU itL~tm tJlM~t1I fLUrtf W 11Al1rt LrtoofJl[l ltlltl Ilgt = fO fJ

fLU itL rtmtJlM~t11 fLUrtfW t-fJtJlIfij fMfijfJfLoLf~)1Lijt-f Oltl Illgt f7 I= ~~fJ

fLuitLftI~lmfLUrtfW ~I1Lul1~Jll Lmtl1f~ 9fLoLf~)1LijfJtl~ f

fLUrtfW fijf)1)1U mfftw f~ fJfLoL P ~~ 10 fJ

fLUrtfW L~rtJr fJl1fijf~ fJfLoLf~ULijt-f ~ 0 isI= fJ

fLUrtfW f~h~ rto~frIfJfLoLf~)1LijfJtJlM q I= I 0 I is

fLUrtfW fJ~1I1t9rtLW LljRort~ fJfLoLf~)1LijfJtJlM r Ilgt bullIlgt

fLUrtfW ~rtltLr ~ttLrt f~ fJfLol~uLijt-f P fLUrtfW t-fJtJlIfij UmfLoLf~)1LijfJtJlM~ I= i= fJ I (6

fLUrtfW Rt-M~l1ol1 Ll1omLU f~ fJfL[l 051

fLUrtfWI1Ul~frt fJ~mll pound~rt)19fLoLf~)1Lijt-f ltl

tt1t~fLL~pound

lm(jIlJtL~rt~Mt1 roU~~rJ~i dhfllLrJ~LrJAtLr~ P fbI p In fb fb

rJ~LrJA~Lr~WL~1t~LfL~Atm

on OWdegJo L~ti wgtgtCiOl ltnMumu p(g A~I1LrbMnt P ItI = J fb fb

WgtgtCiOlCiOl ~t-k~

LL Ulll~l U~L u~m~~1t~fLLL UnL~rJl

QJ C C QJ 1~eJ ICl U eJ IJ ~H) 4iJ~ fHl tl11 ~ mil 1U lU VI ]11nJ ~ ~ ()~ f1l1fl1~Ui QJCCQ) 11l1l1~ffU

~1U1U QJcilo 11rJ IWf1l1JU1~~mrrU

1 ~ ~lJU1 ill W1~1 Cl1 U 11b11 VI rJlfll Cl~ 1 ~1U1U Q)() 11rJ u u

1~~lJU1WW1~1 Cl1IJ11blilflUfllM11 ~1U1U Q)C 11rJ u u

1~~lJU1Will1~1 Cl1IJ 11bltl11IJ11n11j1 nl ~1U1U QJ()() 11rJ u u bull

1~~lJU1WW1~1 Cl1IJ11bltl11UW ~1U1U () 11rJ u u u

~1U1U () 11rJ

~1U1U () 11rJ

C a V d Jt cv QlC ~ fltll ~m1l1 fll11 b1f1l1V1 l11t1l111ft 1111 UCllIf111 lClUeJIVI eJ1 lJfll1eJ4 II ~ Nfl f111fl f1ll111 f1

ClflllJ1111V1rJ1ftrJ 1Uc11~IJ~eJ iu

r- ----- -1~~--~ -~ cC tI C

(U1~Cl11~tl1U~ I~111)

NUUyjf1j1rJ~1U tl11U1~blI ~

AltvL-___ ~ i

(f1b1 rJfllCl~ 11111 rJ cpj1 Cl1ii til 1 b~ Cl f11 U ~) ~

N~ 11 11 1rJ~ 1U f111 U1 ~ b1I ~

YIb~fbJllmiddotIbI1~M 1 l 1lwn~ fllJ1 djVj(lffl~lflA~ll-ilb~l1lU

1 A11l Uj( l ~C1 Qfb~ l1l Ut-

(fl~ml ~ ~IbLlVll~llLllUt-)

~ l ml I M~ rllMlllb1flIt-1 ~ P po l

fll () 1t1l1 lfWUllAoml1l1~~lfWUlUIllLlHt-n o 17 ~ rU ttl 57 P 0$

~ 1Mlfl A~lbltlol A 11~Ib ~ ~l U11k11ll1l1lll 1 Il~ 111ll)t1 1fl(1~ A 1l t-~lJ II LUlj(~ IbLllt-~ U1l~ ~ 1J lbkM ~

fll () 1t1l~ flLllU1LllU~fbKklj(~lnlLl ullmm~fbl1~~

fll () 1t1l~ (1~t-M-t-19UfbLU) flLllU1LllU~fbKklj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll () 1t1l~ ~mC1lulj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll ()()~ 1t1l~ 1~hll-il1lUlj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll fCJ) 1t1l~ flLllUfblJ~lj(~lnlLl ~llmmpoundfbl1~~

fll ()~ 1t1l~ flLllklflA~lj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

- ~t-~I1~~f1ijIUflll ~

fll o~~ 1t1l~ 1~t-~Ibt CJ)ff~ J1~llmU P() ~1~~ff~ lRU~lUfll~~fblRU~lUI~ll~~ IfIfbull bull

l Ru~ll~mC1I1~~ ~lJ 11 ~Ilm mfb 11~ ~ l RU~l UI ~ Il~ ~~C1IbLl mi9(~mlI~U~ 1-i1bl111l9 1r ~I~ Rkl~19llfl RU~U1

~ lJ II ~Ufb19lUl RU~U1t-n 1fl ~Il UlJ tl11Llnt1)t1 1fl ( I~A 1l t-~ ~11l Ulj(~IbpoundLlI t-~U 1l~ ~Ibll

1lW t-lJ fllJ 1 t[jj(lffl~lfl A~ll-ilbl Ulj(~ lUIbW~m19 1fl~1

UWklfLU~HlMth(wn t(H1 ~ b~ P I

co ~ 9 ItM LU rtU () Lt Y1 t LClPPGlf()middotDcomiddot t~~ Lt P P1l p

I

lH1~k~~iltUl(i~lArRtJ tLUl$(ttt~lit~Uttl1 gLUnLgY1t~

middotmiddot I

-~

ttLt~~ULtJ1rt (6 8=7 ~

Amiddot

wbulla1Ua1t1n1a lJ111~hun~t1jllfnJ1~t1el~lfljW lUWj~1JjlJjllflhllJn

~ ~HY1 obd~ampamprn 1U~ Ggtamp mJm~Wpound ~ampamprnq

9 liJ~~ht mY 11ff~iJilllf1lS II ~~l1i4 YI~1 ij i4 1 ~m lilffeJIJ N~ fm l~ i4 lJeJltnffn~ lf1lIll1n~1I~~

tnffn~lf1lIlVilff~ ~t~ i41l SlJmiJI1 tinrrm lI~dJIltlffmJ~~rill~ ilf1lSffnm S ~ ~IJl1~WW19~ II ~~ S~~IJUtlcVi9ffnm l ~ to to

~rillhf1lSffnm l1S~~ltJf1lSffn~l wampamp1gtD lUll ri fJiJf1lWi4TI ampamp(I) SliJ~liU~lUlU cVo Sl

d QlGle1IWf1lllUS~9IJ9li4 shy

S~~IJl1~ tytyl9~ fflUlillliYIlfflff9l1 ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflU lilllfl~l1fflff9l ~lUlU

S ~~IJl1~tytyl9 ~ fflllilllf1lSIJ~I1lS1iSfi il ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflllilllf1lSJtytf ~lUlU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytyl9l~ ffllllilllrl1 S~fflffi4fflff9 (f1lS l1nm eJlVleJ l~i4) ~1U lU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytylleJ n fflIllilll~l1 S ~fflffUfflff9 1 ~ lU lU

~ 1 J a ~j I ~ ~ lJnlI ~iuIiI1 UIU ~middotGi1 Lililmilln H1Y1l1flfl U 3J (Imi ~uin tlJ1lJ (IiLL-afl Uu in tlJ1lJ (Ii

ar q U q ar q arar

3JI1iYltn~tJnilIlD)liltJEIilmmJ 1WYiim3Ji1~unWl 4IW)lilUVJ3JTI1W

IV o=l

)WYl 18 shy

T13Jl1YiWfi 2553

lllJJ1iJll

1~Ul11illq1t1il

ill fJ fJl ~middotihn m~ um-l

tlU~U 1 I tlU~U 2

illfJfJl(lr

1~uillfJryl

ill fJ ry1hI illfJfJ1Llfl

JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ lHi1~ 1ll-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J

1Tnflntllll1fltln~

lllJJ1iJlli Y1rJ1P11ll(l f 2 2

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

iUJ

-------------gt-----------j------------+------------f------------f------------f

3 3

4

6

1Tnflntllll1flYiUltl ll1~1iJlliYlrJ1P11ll(lf 19 19

lll~liJllPlltlPllll(lf 2 17 16 35

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

lllJJ1iJllfl l1UfJ~

4 6 53 142 207 1-------------+--- -------+--------

ll1~1iJllf~tl1PllllUPllll(lf

iU 4 3 6 90 159 263

l iUJr1~iU 4 3 6 93 162 269

Vl ~lilIH) tlLtll Vl~1ilV11 U ~ nfflB-J U~l

d ~ J vJshyIl-J Hl bullbullbullbull W11JY1 LtJ fJ W

rtlJ=J1itiit1hU11J~i1L~~n1iifm~1 it11111Jl11V1a1A1it~f ~ OJ

2-jn1V1tJ1~tJj11lrilJ 1mEl~Imnr 1UVljUj2-jjllU nWl ~IV11 ~UVJ2-jDli1

1UVl18 fJ2-J1n~ufi 2553

r~1Jiltlll(ll(ll1 r~1Jll(ll(ll1

ll(ll(ll1uirLnm~ilmJ ll(ll (lI1vir ll(ll(ll1tYl ll(ll(ll1Liln

hJHLnniill1 ~U~1J 1 ~U~1J 2

111EJ l-Ir1)~ 1l)J 111EJ l-Ir1)~ 111EJ l-IrD~ 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J 111EJ l-Ici1~ rl)J 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J

UnAnH1nflun~

iYlmn1~f1alJybLfla

f1l1n~~IJf11illllftlhJ +------------f-----------f----------I j------ ------+-----------+- ---------1------- -----1-shy -----------shy

5J3-l 2 2

UnAnH1nfl-nUlH

iYlmn1~f1aIJYilLfiaf

IYlflt 1Jtil1iVlilllln~~lJlL~1J~L Ylflt 1Jtil1in1~rJ1ifl ~ ---------- +-----------~------------+--- --------f------------I------------I-----------l------------1

16 j------------+----I---------I--------I------++---I

16

Lfljj

IYlflt 1Jtil1ilIIilllln~~lJlL~1J~ii L~nmailflilLLil~f1aIJW1Llllaf

5J3-l

~ 5JIJII~~U

19

19 2

19

21

iI11i1aa lJ ll~i1 11i1Y11UUf1 ~al ll~l

d ~~--~ltfa UlpoundJYI~liipoundJU~

11lJ~ntJtl ~~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ m~n~ b~Wtl~Jl1~~1~VltJ1~tJ~1llJl)dl~tJtl~1nnw

lJtltlWd-J~n1~1~mruru1Ull~ ~ ~

d-J~1~V1tJ1~m1llJl)dl~tJtl~1mnr1WVi~1J~d-J~1~iJ5wl ~1~1(1)iJVJ~fi1tJ tln1~~m~1 2552

tlW~e-J~n1~~mnb~tl1W~ 18 n~Jl1iWfi 2553

~1~jJVl ~r~iJ~~rl~d

~t1 ~1jil(1~ lPIiuw-nlPl btl i bbn i~ 1 ll11 VIJ1 n1i Afl ~ ViJ blPlfli

1 48122420131 W11~1dtl~Vi~nw ~~WA1 20 bd-JtJ 2529 216 iJn~

2 46222420101 W1t1n~Vili ~d~~ruiJ~~Mtfd9

3 VitJ 2510 239 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1A~ nii~ 111~ lPIitJ1tI

3 1471226001041 W11~1d~~d-J1 ~~b~W I 21 ViA 2529 222 iJn~ btlibbni~1ll1 bVIAbllb~~fl1Pl~1~nii~bbllllJbVIAbllb~~n1i(J~ 1PI

gt-bull4 50232790207 W1tJtJItJVlfi U1WdW 18 n A 2518 258 ~ bPlM 5 50232790301 W1mnl tlW~V1fi 13 Vi tJ 2520 311 ~bPlM

6 50232790303 W1tJ~nm~Mnr ~d-J~1bUW 18 VitJ 2525 260 ~bPlM

7 50232790304 W1tJ-nlld1~ ~111d 26 bd-JtJ 2524 281 ~bPlM

8 50232790307 W1tJruNrol ~lJru 23 VitJ 2526 308 ~bPlM

9 50232790308 W1tJrutiVi~ bVltJWd-JWll 10 nVi 2528 365 ~bPlMd9

Q tV ~ QA cl 10 50232790309 W1tJWdwJW ll~~V1fi 11 nVi 2530 315 ~bPlM

11 5023279031 0 W1tJd-JW~-ntJ AI1~dJ 9 nA 2520 315 ~bPlM

12 50232790311 W1tJ~It1 ~1~d-JiW 26 VitJ 2523 276 ~bPlM

13 50232790312 W1tJ~ViiOl-W ll~1-ntJ 19 nVi 2526 258 ~bPlM

14 50232790313 W1tJP1n~ru~1rol U(1)(1)1dlPl 9 ~A 2527 322 ~bPlM

15 50232790314 W1tJ~d-J bnm~ iJtlJJn 7 fiA 2527 315 ~bPlM ~

16 50232790316 W1tJ~d wJ jJ rutJd-J1lltJ 11 fiA 2526 298 ~bPlM

~

17 50232790317 W1tJtl~ru diOlWJldn~ 20 fiA 2527 281 ~bPlM AQ 4lI IV tS

18 50232790319 W1tJtlVlfiVi~ b~tliOlWVI~ 20 fiA 2526 303 ~bPlM

19 50232790320 W1tJ~bll~ fn-Kll~ 21 ViA 2520 275 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bA ij

20 49222840108 IW1t1iJnid-JVI~ b~1bfil I 11 nA 2522 289

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bVIAtllb~~fl1Pl~1~ nii~ bbllllJ~ b~ nVIiflU A~ bb~ Afl ~vh blPlfli

21 149222970101 1~~~n~ u I 18 nu 2528 318

d J -I ~ J_- ~1lltl IV-_--- W1tJVIb1JtJW

UtlJllill~1U1U~~1L~~miAmt1 l1l1111l1A~IIfll1l(1f ~ OJ

~Il1~VltJ1~m1llJiJ) 1fltJflflmn111U~~m~~l~1J trwl rrm11l1JVJ~filn IIV od

)UVl 18 nWl1~Ufi 2553 T~ciUfl~1frCC1 T~ciu1frCC1

1frCC1~1Lnm~nmJ llCC1~1 llCC1LYI U1CC1Lfln

hJnLn1lJ)lI1 fiuciu 1 fiuciu 2

Jl1poundJ ci)~ TllJ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ

trnAnH11l1flYi~flH

iiLlIflfllallrl

fllltln~~1J

i tl~ ~f1lalJf11 allrl oJ a~fllJfllaf1~1ll8Ol~ljWllJl

----------shy ---------shy

- - -- - - -shy ~ ~ -shy -----------shy

-- - -shy - --shy ~ --shy ----------shy

------------shy ---------_

------------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

---shy -------shy

-----------shy

------_--shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

----------shy -shy _------shy

-shy --------shy -----------shy2

--shy -------shy _ _----shy --

-----------shy -----------shy

------shy _shy

----------shy

----------shy

-shy -------shy

-----------shy2

-------_shy7

- - - - - shy ~ -shy8

-------shy

1 1 ---------shy ----------shy

2 --shy ----shy --shy

6 15 - -------shy -----shy

9 17 -------- ----shy ---shy

-------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

--__-------- --shy --------shy _---

--__-------- ---------shy _ ---shy -----shy

-----------shy ------------shy

----------shy --shy -shy -------shy

--shy -

---------shy

-----------_

gtUJ 2 17 16 35

~ gtUJII~~tJ 2 17 16 35

lilmiddoti1i1afJULL~lili1i1mU~n~fJILL~1

d ~~-- ~1Z1fJ UltJt1LutJU

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 3: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

QJ C C QJ 1~eJ ICl U eJ IJ ~H) 4iJ~ fHl tl11 ~ mil 1U lU VI ]11nJ ~ ~ ()~ f1l1fl1~Ui QJCCQ) 11l1l1~ffU

~1U1U QJcilo 11rJ IWf1l1JU1~~mrrU

1 ~ ~lJU1 ill W1~1 Cl1 U 11b11 VI rJlfll Cl~ 1 ~1U1U Q)() 11rJ u u

1~~lJU1WW1~1 Cl1IJ11blilflUfllM11 ~1U1U Q)C 11rJ u u

1~~lJU1Will1~1 Cl1IJ 11bltl11IJ11n11j1 nl ~1U1U QJ()() 11rJ u u bull

1~~lJU1WW1~1 Cl1IJ11bltl11UW ~1U1U () 11rJ u u u

~1U1U () 11rJ

~1U1U () 11rJ

C a V d Jt cv QlC ~ fltll ~m1l1 fll11 b1f1l1V1 l11t1l111ft 1111 UCllIf111 lClUeJIVI eJ1 lJfll1eJ4 II ~ Nfl f111fl f1ll111 f1

ClflllJ1111V1rJ1ftrJ 1Uc11~IJ~eJ iu

r- ----- -1~~--~ -~ cC tI C

(U1~Cl11~tl1U~ I~111)

NUUyjf1j1rJ~1U tl11U1~blI ~

AltvL-___ ~ i

(f1b1 rJfllCl~ 11111 rJ cpj1 Cl1ii til 1 b~ Cl f11 U ~) ~

N~ 11 11 1rJ~ 1U f111 U1 ~ b1I ~

YIb~fbJllmiddotIbI1~M 1 l 1lwn~ fllJ1 djVj(lffl~lflA~ll-ilb~l1lU

1 A11l Uj( l ~C1 Qfb~ l1l Ut-

(fl~ml ~ ~IbLlVll~llLllUt-)

~ l ml I M~ rllMlllb1flIt-1 ~ P po l

fll () 1t1l1 lfWUllAoml1l1~~lfWUlUIllLlHt-n o 17 ~ rU ttl 57 P 0$

~ 1Mlfl A~lbltlol A 11~Ib ~ ~l U11k11ll1l1lll 1 Il~ 111ll)t1 1fl(1~ A 1l t-~lJ II LUlj(~ IbLllt-~ U1l~ ~ 1J lbkM ~

fll () 1t1l~ flLllU1LllU~fbKklj(~lnlLl ullmm~fbl1~~

fll () 1t1l~ (1~t-M-t-19UfbLU) flLllU1LllU~fbKklj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll () 1t1l~ ~mC1lulj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll ()()~ 1t1l~ 1~hll-il1lUlj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll fCJ) 1t1l~ flLllUfblJ~lj(~lnlLl ~llmmpoundfbl1~~

fll ()~ 1t1l~ flLllklflA~lj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

- ~t-~I1~~f1ijIUflll ~

fll o~~ 1t1l~ 1~t-~Ibt CJ)ff~ J1~llmU P() ~1~~ff~ lRU~lUfll~~fblRU~lUI~ll~~ IfIfbull bull

l Ru~ll~mC1I1~~ ~lJ 11 ~Ilm mfb 11~ ~ l RU~l UI ~ Il~ ~~C1IbLl mi9(~mlI~U~ 1-i1bl111l9 1r ~I~ Rkl~19llfl RU~U1

~ lJ II ~Ufb19lUl RU~U1t-n 1fl ~Il UlJ tl11Llnt1)t1 1fl ( I~A 1l t-~ ~11l Ulj(~IbpoundLlI t-~U 1l~ ~Ibll

1lW t-lJ fllJ 1 t[jj(lffl~lfl A~ll-ilbl Ulj(~ lUIbW~m19 1fl~1

UWklfLU~HlMth(wn t(H1 ~ b~ P I

co ~ 9 ItM LU rtU () Lt Y1 t LClPPGlf()middotDcomiddot t~~ Lt P P1l p

I

lH1~k~~iltUl(i~lArRtJ tLUl$(ttt~lit~Uttl1 gLUnLgY1t~

middotmiddot I

-~

ttLt~~ULtJ1rt (6 8=7 ~

Amiddot

wbulla1Ua1t1n1a lJ111~hun~t1jllfnJ1~t1el~lfljW lUWj~1JjlJjllflhllJn

~ ~HY1 obd~ampamprn 1U~ Ggtamp mJm~Wpound ~ampamprnq

9 liJ~~ht mY 11ff~iJilllf1lS II ~~l1i4 YI~1 ij i4 1 ~m lilffeJIJ N~ fm l~ i4 lJeJltnffn~ lf1lIll1n~1I~~

tnffn~lf1lIlVilff~ ~t~ i41l SlJmiJI1 tinrrm lI~dJIltlffmJ~~rill~ ilf1lSffnm S ~ ~IJl1~WW19~ II ~~ S~~IJUtlcVi9ffnm l ~ to to

~rillhf1lSffnm l1S~~ltJf1lSffn~l wampamp1gtD lUll ri fJiJf1lWi4TI ampamp(I) SliJ~liU~lUlU cVo Sl

d QlGle1IWf1lllUS~9IJ9li4 shy

S~~IJl1~ tytyl9~ fflUlillliYIlfflff9l1 ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflU lilllfl~l1fflff9l ~lUlU

S ~~IJl1~tytyl9 ~ fflllilllf1lSIJ~I1lS1iSfi il ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflllilllf1lSJtytf ~lUlU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytyl9l~ ffllllilllrl1 S~fflffi4fflff9 (f1lS l1nm eJlVleJ l~i4) ~1U lU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytylleJ n fflIllilll~l1 S ~fflffUfflff9 1 ~ lU lU

~ 1 J a ~j I ~ ~ lJnlI ~iuIiI1 UIU ~middotGi1 Lililmilln H1Y1l1flfl U 3J (Imi ~uin tlJ1lJ (IiLL-afl Uu in tlJ1lJ (Ii

ar q U q ar q arar

3JI1iYltn~tJnilIlD)liltJEIilmmJ 1WYiim3Ji1~unWl 4IW)lilUVJ3JTI1W

IV o=l

)WYl 18 shy

T13Jl1YiWfi 2553

lllJJ1iJll

1~Ul11illq1t1il

ill fJ fJl ~middotihn m~ um-l

tlU~U 1 I tlU~U 2

illfJfJl(lr

1~uillfJryl

ill fJ ry1hI illfJfJ1Llfl

JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ lHi1~ 1ll-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J

1Tnflntllll1fltln~

lllJJ1iJlli Y1rJ1P11ll(l f 2 2

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

iUJ

-------------gt-----------j------------+------------f------------f------------f

3 3

4

6

1Tnflntllll1flYiUltl ll1~1iJlliYlrJ1P11ll(lf 19 19

lll~liJllPlltlPllll(lf 2 17 16 35

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

lllJJ1iJllfl l1UfJ~

4 6 53 142 207 1-------------+--- -------+--------

ll1~1iJllf~tl1PllllUPllll(lf

iU 4 3 6 90 159 263

l iUJr1~iU 4 3 6 93 162 269

Vl ~lilIH) tlLtll Vl~1ilV11 U ~ nfflB-J U~l

d ~ J vJshyIl-J Hl bullbullbullbull W11JY1 LtJ fJ W

rtlJ=J1itiit1hU11J~i1L~~n1iifm~1 it11111Jl11V1a1A1it~f ~ OJ

2-jn1V1tJ1~tJj11lrilJ 1mEl~Imnr 1UVljUj2-jjllU nWl ~IV11 ~UVJ2-jDli1

1UVl18 fJ2-J1n~ufi 2553

r~1Jiltlll(ll(ll1 r~1Jll(ll(ll1

ll(ll(ll1uirLnm~ilmJ ll(ll (lI1vir ll(ll(ll1tYl ll(ll(ll1Liln

hJHLnniill1 ~U~1J 1 ~U~1J 2

111EJ l-Ir1)~ 1l)J 111EJ l-Ir1)~ 111EJ l-IrD~ 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J 111EJ l-Ici1~ rl)J 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J

UnAnH1nflun~

iYlmn1~f1alJybLfla

f1l1n~~IJf11illllftlhJ +------------f-----------f----------I j------ ------+-----------+- ---------1------- -----1-shy -----------shy

5J3-l 2 2

UnAnH1nfl-nUlH

iYlmn1~f1aIJYilLfiaf

IYlflt 1Jtil1iVlilllln~~lJlL~1J~L Ylflt 1Jtil1in1~rJ1ifl ~ ---------- +-----------~------------+--- --------f------------I------------I-----------l------------1

16 j------------+----I---------I--------I------++---I

16

Lfljj

IYlflt 1Jtil1ilIIilllln~~lJlL~1J~ii L~nmailflilLLil~f1aIJW1Llllaf

5J3-l

~ 5JIJII~~U

19

19 2

19

21

iI11i1aa lJ ll~i1 11i1Y11UUf1 ~al ll~l

d ~~--~ltfa UlpoundJYI~liipoundJU~

11lJ~ntJtl ~~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ m~n~ b~Wtl~Jl1~~1~VltJ1~tJ~1llJl)dl~tJtl~1nnw

lJtltlWd-J~n1~1~mruru1Ull~ ~ ~

d-J~1~V1tJ1~m1llJl)dl~tJtl~1mnr1WVi~1J~d-J~1~iJ5wl ~1~1(1)iJVJ~fi1tJ tln1~~m~1 2552

tlW~e-J~n1~~mnb~tl1W~ 18 n~Jl1iWfi 2553

~1~jJVl ~r~iJ~~rl~d

~t1 ~1jil(1~ lPIiuw-nlPl btl i bbn i~ 1 ll11 VIJ1 n1i Afl ~ ViJ blPlfli

1 48122420131 W11~1dtl~Vi~nw ~~WA1 20 bd-JtJ 2529 216 iJn~

2 46222420101 W1t1n~Vili ~d~~ruiJ~~Mtfd9

3 VitJ 2510 239 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1A~ nii~ 111~ lPIitJ1tI

3 1471226001041 W11~1d~~d-J1 ~~b~W I 21 ViA 2529 222 iJn~ btlibbni~1ll1 bVIAbllb~~fl1Pl~1~nii~bbllllJbVIAbllb~~n1i(J~ 1PI

gt-bull4 50232790207 W1tJtJItJVlfi U1WdW 18 n A 2518 258 ~ bPlM 5 50232790301 W1mnl tlW~V1fi 13 Vi tJ 2520 311 ~bPlM

6 50232790303 W1tJ~nm~Mnr ~d-J~1bUW 18 VitJ 2525 260 ~bPlM

7 50232790304 W1tJ-nlld1~ ~111d 26 bd-JtJ 2524 281 ~bPlM

8 50232790307 W1tJruNrol ~lJru 23 VitJ 2526 308 ~bPlM

9 50232790308 W1tJrutiVi~ bVltJWd-JWll 10 nVi 2528 365 ~bPlMd9

Q tV ~ QA cl 10 50232790309 W1tJWdwJW ll~~V1fi 11 nVi 2530 315 ~bPlM

11 5023279031 0 W1tJd-JW~-ntJ AI1~dJ 9 nA 2520 315 ~bPlM

12 50232790311 W1tJ~It1 ~1~d-JiW 26 VitJ 2523 276 ~bPlM

13 50232790312 W1tJ~ViiOl-W ll~1-ntJ 19 nVi 2526 258 ~bPlM

14 50232790313 W1tJP1n~ru~1rol U(1)(1)1dlPl 9 ~A 2527 322 ~bPlM

15 50232790314 W1tJ~d-J bnm~ iJtlJJn 7 fiA 2527 315 ~bPlM ~

16 50232790316 W1tJ~d wJ jJ rutJd-J1lltJ 11 fiA 2526 298 ~bPlM

~

17 50232790317 W1tJtl~ru diOlWJldn~ 20 fiA 2527 281 ~bPlM AQ 4lI IV tS

18 50232790319 W1tJtlVlfiVi~ b~tliOlWVI~ 20 fiA 2526 303 ~bPlM

19 50232790320 W1tJ~bll~ fn-Kll~ 21 ViA 2520 275 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bA ij

20 49222840108 IW1t1iJnid-JVI~ b~1bfil I 11 nA 2522 289

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bVIAtllb~~fl1Pl~1~ nii~ bbllllJ~ b~ nVIiflU A~ bb~ Afl ~vh blPlfli

21 149222970101 1~~~n~ u I 18 nu 2528 318

d J -I ~ J_- ~1lltl IV-_--- W1tJVIb1JtJW

UtlJllill~1U1U~~1L~~miAmt1 l1l1111l1A~IIfll1l(1f ~ OJ

~Il1~VltJ1~m1llJiJ) 1fltJflflmn111U~~m~~l~1J trwl rrm11l1JVJ~filn IIV od

)UVl 18 nWl1~Ufi 2553 T~ciUfl~1frCC1 T~ciu1frCC1

1frCC1~1Lnm~nmJ llCC1~1 llCC1LYI U1CC1Lfln

hJnLn1lJ)lI1 fiuciu 1 fiuciu 2

Jl1poundJ ci)~ TllJ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ

trnAnH11l1flYi~flH

iiLlIflfllallrl

fllltln~~1J

i tl~ ~f1lalJf11 allrl oJ a~fllJfllaf1~1ll8Ol~ljWllJl

----------shy ---------shy

- - -- - - -shy ~ ~ -shy -----------shy

-- - -shy - --shy ~ --shy ----------shy

------------shy ---------_

------------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

---shy -------shy

-----------shy

------_--shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

----------shy -shy _------shy

-shy --------shy -----------shy2

--shy -------shy _ _----shy --

-----------shy -----------shy

------shy _shy

----------shy

----------shy

-shy -------shy

-----------shy2

-------_shy7

- - - - - shy ~ -shy8

-------shy

1 1 ---------shy ----------shy

2 --shy ----shy --shy

6 15 - -------shy -----shy

9 17 -------- ----shy ---shy

-------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

--__-------- --shy --------shy _---

--__-------- ---------shy _ ---shy -----shy

-----------shy ------------shy

----------shy --shy -shy -------shy

--shy -

---------shy

-----------_

gtUJ 2 17 16 35

~ gtUJII~~tJ 2 17 16 35

lilmiddoti1i1afJULL~lili1i1mU~n~fJILL~1

d ~~-- ~1Z1fJ UltJt1LutJU

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 4: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

YIb~fbJllmiddotIbI1~M 1 l 1lwn~ fllJ1 djVj(lffl~lflA~ll-ilb~l1lU

1 A11l Uj( l ~C1 Qfb~ l1l Ut-

(fl~ml ~ ~IbLlVll~llLllUt-)

~ l ml I M~ rllMlllb1flIt-1 ~ P po l

fll () 1t1l1 lfWUllAoml1l1~~lfWUlUIllLlHt-n o 17 ~ rU ttl 57 P 0$

~ 1Mlfl A~lbltlol A 11~Ib ~ ~l U11k11ll1l1lll 1 Il~ 111ll)t1 1fl(1~ A 1l t-~lJ II LUlj(~ IbLllt-~ U1l~ ~ 1J lbkM ~

fll () 1t1l~ flLllU1LllU~fbKklj(~lnlLl ullmm~fbl1~~

fll () 1t1l~ (1~t-M-t-19UfbLU) flLllU1LllU~fbKklj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll () 1t1l~ ~mC1lulj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll ()()~ 1t1l~ 1~hll-il1lUlj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

fll fCJ) 1t1l~ flLllUfblJ~lj(~lnlLl ~llmmpoundfbl1~~

fll ()~ 1t1l~ flLllklflA~lj(~lnlLl ~llmmfbl1~~

- ~t-~I1~~f1ijIUflll ~

fll o~~ 1t1l~ 1~t-~Ibt CJ)ff~ J1~llmU P() ~1~~ff~ lRU~lUfll~~fblRU~lUI~ll~~ IfIfbull bull

l Ru~ll~mC1I1~~ ~lJ 11 ~Ilm mfb 11~ ~ l RU~l UI ~ Il~ ~~C1IbLl mi9(~mlI~U~ 1-i1bl111l9 1r ~I~ Rkl~19llfl RU~U1

~ lJ II ~Ufb19lUl RU~U1t-n 1fl ~Il UlJ tl11Llnt1)t1 1fl ( I~A 1l t-~ ~11l Ulj(~IbpoundLlI t-~U 1l~ ~Ibll

1lW t-lJ fllJ 1 t[jj(lffl~lfl A~ll-ilbl Ulj(~ lUIbW~m19 1fl~1

UWklfLU~HlMth(wn t(H1 ~ b~ P I

co ~ 9 ItM LU rtU () Lt Y1 t LClPPGlf()middotDcomiddot t~~ Lt P P1l p

I

lH1~k~~iltUl(i~lArRtJ tLUl$(ttt~lit~Uttl1 gLUnLgY1t~

middotmiddot I

-~

ttLt~~ULtJ1rt (6 8=7 ~

Amiddot

wbulla1Ua1t1n1a lJ111~hun~t1jllfnJ1~t1el~lfljW lUWj~1JjlJjllflhllJn

~ ~HY1 obd~ampamprn 1U~ Ggtamp mJm~Wpound ~ampamprnq

9 liJ~~ht mY 11ff~iJilllf1lS II ~~l1i4 YI~1 ij i4 1 ~m lilffeJIJ N~ fm l~ i4 lJeJltnffn~ lf1lIll1n~1I~~

tnffn~lf1lIlVilff~ ~t~ i41l SlJmiJI1 tinrrm lI~dJIltlffmJ~~rill~ ilf1lSffnm S ~ ~IJl1~WW19~ II ~~ S~~IJUtlcVi9ffnm l ~ to to

~rillhf1lSffnm l1S~~ltJf1lSffn~l wampamp1gtD lUll ri fJiJf1lWi4TI ampamp(I) SliJ~liU~lUlU cVo Sl

d QlGle1IWf1lllUS~9IJ9li4 shy

S~~IJl1~ tytyl9~ fflUlillliYIlfflff9l1 ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflU lilllfl~l1fflff9l ~lUlU

S ~~IJl1~tytyl9 ~ fflllilllf1lSIJ~I1lS1iSfi il ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflllilllf1lSJtytf ~lUlU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytyl9l~ ffllllilllrl1 S~fflffi4fflff9 (f1lS l1nm eJlVleJ l~i4) ~1U lU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytylleJ n fflIllilll~l1 S ~fflffUfflff9 1 ~ lU lU

~ 1 J a ~j I ~ ~ lJnlI ~iuIiI1 UIU ~middotGi1 Lililmilln H1Y1l1flfl U 3J (Imi ~uin tlJ1lJ (IiLL-afl Uu in tlJ1lJ (Ii

ar q U q ar q arar

3JI1iYltn~tJnilIlD)liltJEIilmmJ 1WYiim3Ji1~unWl 4IW)lilUVJ3JTI1W

IV o=l

)WYl 18 shy

T13Jl1YiWfi 2553

lllJJ1iJll

1~Ul11illq1t1il

ill fJ fJl ~middotihn m~ um-l

tlU~U 1 I tlU~U 2

illfJfJl(lr

1~uillfJryl

ill fJ ry1hI illfJfJ1Llfl

JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ lHi1~ 1ll-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J

1Tnflntllll1fltln~

lllJJ1iJlli Y1rJ1P11ll(l f 2 2

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

iUJ

-------------gt-----------j------------+------------f------------f------------f

3 3

4

6

1Tnflntllll1flYiUltl ll1~1iJlliYlrJ1P11ll(lf 19 19

lll~liJllPlltlPllll(lf 2 17 16 35

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

lllJJ1iJllfl l1UfJ~

4 6 53 142 207 1-------------+--- -------+--------

ll1~1iJllf~tl1PllllUPllll(lf

iU 4 3 6 90 159 263

l iUJr1~iU 4 3 6 93 162 269

Vl ~lilIH) tlLtll Vl~1ilV11 U ~ nfflB-J U~l

d ~ J vJshyIl-J Hl bullbullbullbull W11JY1 LtJ fJ W

rtlJ=J1itiit1hU11J~i1L~~n1iifm~1 it11111Jl11V1a1A1it~f ~ OJ

2-jn1V1tJ1~tJj11lrilJ 1mEl~Imnr 1UVljUj2-jjllU nWl ~IV11 ~UVJ2-jDli1

1UVl18 fJ2-J1n~ufi 2553

r~1Jiltlll(ll(ll1 r~1Jll(ll(ll1

ll(ll(ll1uirLnm~ilmJ ll(ll (lI1vir ll(ll(ll1tYl ll(ll(ll1Liln

hJHLnniill1 ~U~1J 1 ~U~1J 2

111EJ l-Ir1)~ 1l)J 111EJ l-Ir1)~ 111EJ l-IrD~ 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J 111EJ l-Ici1~ rl)J 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J

UnAnH1nflun~

iYlmn1~f1alJybLfla

f1l1n~~IJf11illllftlhJ +------------f-----------f----------I j------ ------+-----------+- ---------1------- -----1-shy -----------shy

5J3-l 2 2

UnAnH1nfl-nUlH

iYlmn1~f1aIJYilLfiaf

IYlflt 1Jtil1iVlilllln~~lJlL~1J~L Ylflt 1Jtil1in1~rJ1ifl ~ ---------- +-----------~------------+--- --------f------------I------------I-----------l------------1

16 j------------+----I---------I--------I------++---I

16

Lfljj

IYlflt 1Jtil1ilIIilllln~~lJlL~1J~ii L~nmailflilLLil~f1aIJW1Llllaf

5J3-l

~ 5JIJII~~U

19

19 2

19

21

iI11i1aa lJ ll~i1 11i1Y11UUf1 ~al ll~l

d ~~--~ltfa UlpoundJYI~liipoundJU~

11lJ~ntJtl ~~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ m~n~ b~Wtl~Jl1~~1~VltJ1~tJ~1llJl)dl~tJtl~1nnw

lJtltlWd-J~n1~1~mruru1Ull~ ~ ~

d-J~1~V1tJ1~m1llJl)dl~tJtl~1mnr1WVi~1J~d-J~1~iJ5wl ~1~1(1)iJVJ~fi1tJ tln1~~m~1 2552

tlW~e-J~n1~~mnb~tl1W~ 18 n~Jl1iWfi 2553

~1~jJVl ~r~iJ~~rl~d

~t1 ~1jil(1~ lPIiuw-nlPl btl i bbn i~ 1 ll11 VIJ1 n1i Afl ~ ViJ blPlfli

1 48122420131 W11~1dtl~Vi~nw ~~WA1 20 bd-JtJ 2529 216 iJn~

2 46222420101 W1t1n~Vili ~d~~ruiJ~~Mtfd9

3 VitJ 2510 239 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1A~ nii~ 111~ lPIitJ1tI

3 1471226001041 W11~1d~~d-J1 ~~b~W I 21 ViA 2529 222 iJn~ btlibbni~1ll1 bVIAbllb~~fl1Pl~1~nii~bbllllJbVIAbllb~~n1i(J~ 1PI

gt-bull4 50232790207 W1tJtJItJVlfi U1WdW 18 n A 2518 258 ~ bPlM 5 50232790301 W1mnl tlW~V1fi 13 Vi tJ 2520 311 ~bPlM

6 50232790303 W1tJ~nm~Mnr ~d-J~1bUW 18 VitJ 2525 260 ~bPlM

7 50232790304 W1tJ-nlld1~ ~111d 26 bd-JtJ 2524 281 ~bPlM

8 50232790307 W1tJruNrol ~lJru 23 VitJ 2526 308 ~bPlM

9 50232790308 W1tJrutiVi~ bVltJWd-JWll 10 nVi 2528 365 ~bPlMd9

Q tV ~ QA cl 10 50232790309 W1tJWdwJW ll~~V1fi 11 nVi 2530 315 ~bPlM

11 5023279031 0 W1tJd-JW~-ntJ AI1~dJ 9 nA 2520 315 ~bPlM

12 50232790311 W1tJ~It1 ~1~d-JiW 26 VitJ 2523 276 ~bPlM

13 50232790312 W1tJ~ViiOl-W ll~1-ntJ 19 nVi 2526 258 ~bPlM

14 50232790313 W1tJP1n~ru~1rol U(1)(1)1dlPl 9 ~A 2527 322 ~bPlM

15 50232790314 W1tJ~d-J bnm~ iJtlJJn 7 fiA 2527 315 ~bPlM ~

16 50232790316 W1tJ~d wJ jJ rutJd-J1lltJ 11 fiA 2526 298 ~bPlM

~

17 50232790317 W1tJtl~ru diOlWJldn~ 20 fiA 2527 281 ~bPlM AQ 4lI IV tS

18 50232790319 W1tJtlVlfiVi~ b~tliOlWVI~ 20 fiA 2526 303 ~bPlM

19 50232790320 W1tJ~bll~ fn-Kll~ 21 ViA 2520 275 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bA ij

20 49222840108 IW1t1iJnid-JVI~ b~1bfil I 11 nA 2522 289

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bVIAtllb~~fl1Pl~1~ nii~ bbllllJ~ b~ nVIiflU A~ bb~ Afl ~vh blPlfli

21 149222970101 1~~~n~ u I 18 nu 2528 318

d J -I ~ J_- ~1lltl IV-_--- W1tJVIb1JtJW

UtlJllill~1U1U~~1L~~miAmt1 l1l1111l1A~IIfll1l(1f ~ OJ

~Il1~VltJ1~m1llJiJ) 1fltJflflmn111U~~m~~l~1J trwl rrm11l1JVJ~filn IIV od

)UVl 18 nWl1~Ufi 2553 T~ciUfl~1frCC1 T~ciu1frCC1

1frCC1~1Lnm~nmJ llCC1~1 llCC1LYI U1CC1Lfln

hJnLn1lJ)lI1 fiuciu 1 fiuciu 2

Jl1poundJ ci)~ TllJ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ

trnAnH11l1flYi~flH

iiLlIflfllallrl

fllltln~~1J

i tl~ ~f1lalJf11 allrl oJ a~fllJfllaf1~1ll8Ol~ljWllJl

----------shy ---------shy

- - -- - - -shy ~ ~ -shy -----------shy

-- - -shy - --shy ~ --shy ----------shy

------------shy ---------_

------------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

---shy -------shy

-----------shy

------_--shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

----------shy -shy _------shy

-shy --------shy -----------shy2

--shy -------shy _ _----shy --

-----------shy -----------shy

------shy _shy

----------shy

----------shy

-shy -------shy

-----------shy2

-------_shy7

- - - - - shy ~ -shy8

-------shy

1 1 ---------shy ----------shy

2 --shy ----shy --shy

6 15 - -------shy -----shy

9 17 -------- ----shy ---shy

-------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

--__-------- --shy --------shy _---

--__-------- ---------shy _ ---shy -----shy

-----------shy ------------shy

----------shy --shy -shy -------shy

--shy -

---------shy

-----------_

gtUJ 2 17 16 35

~ gtUJII~~tJ 2 17 16 35

lilmiddoti1i1afJULL~lili1i1mU~n~fJILL~1

d ~~-- ~1Z1fJ UltJt1LutJU

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 5: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

wbulla1Ua1t1n1a lJ111~hun~t1jllfnJ1~t1el~lfljW lUWj~1JjlJjllflhllJn

~ ~HY1 obd~ampamprn 1U~ Ggtamp mJm~Wpound ~ampamprnq

9 liJ~~ht mY 11ff~iJilllf1lS II ~~l1i4 YI~1 ij i4 1 ~m lilffeJIJ N~ fm l~ i4 lJeJltnffn~ lf1lIll1n~1I~~

tnffn~lf1lIlVilff~ ~t~ i41l SlJmiJI1 tinrrm lI~dJIltlffmJ~~rill~ ilf1lSffnm S ~ ~IJl1~WW19~ II ~~ S~~IJUtlcVi9ffnm l ~ to to

~rillhf1lSffnm l1S~~ltJf1lSffn~l wampamp1gtD lUll ri fJiJf1lWi4TI ampamp(I) SliJ~liU~lUlU cVo Sl

d QlGle1IWf1lllUS~9IJ9li4 shy

S~~IJl1~ tytyl9~ fflUlillliYIlfflff9l1 ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflU lilllfl~l1fflff9l ~lUlU

S ~~IJl1~tytyl9 ~ fflllilllf1lSIJ~I1lS1iSfi il ~lUlU

S~~IJl1~tytyl9~ fflllilllf1lSJtytf ~lUlU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytyl9l~ ffllllilllrl1 S~fflffi4fflff9 (f1lS l1nm eJlVleJ l~i4) ~1U lU Sl

S~~IJl1~tytylleJ n fflIllilll~l1 S ~fflffUfflff9 1 ~ lU lU

~ 1 J a ~j I ~ ~ lJnlI ~iuIiI1 UIU ~middotGi1 Lililmilln H1Y1l1flfl U 3J (Imi ~uin tlJ1lJ (IiLL-afl Uu in tlJ1lJ (Ii

ar q U q ar q arar

3JI1iYltn~tJnilIlD)liltJEIilmmJ 1WYiim3Ji1~unWl 4IW)lilUVJ3JTI1W

IV o=l

)WYl 18 shy

T13Jl1YiWfi 2553

lllJJ1iJll

1~Ul11illq1t1il

ill fJ fJl ~middotihn m~ um-l

tlU~U 1 I tlU~U 2

illfJfJl(lr

1~uillfJryl

ill fJ ry1hI illfJfJ1Llfl

JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ lHi1~ 1ll-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J

1Tnflntllll1fltln~

lllJJ1iJlli Y1rJ1P11ll(l f 2 2

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

iUJ

-------------gt-----------j------------+------------f------------f------------f

3 3

4

6

1Tnflntllll1flYiUltl ll1~1iJlliYlrJ1P11ll(lf 19 19

lll~liJllPlltlPllll(lf 2 17 16 35

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

lllJJ1iJllfl l1UfJ~

4 6 53 142 207 1-------------+--- -------+--------

ll1~1iJllf~tl1PllllUPllll(lf

iU 4 3 6 90 159 263

l iUJr1~iU 4 3 6 93 162 269

Vl ~lilIH) tlLtll Vl~1ilV11 U ~ nfflB-J U~l

d ~ J vJshyIl-J Hl bullbullbullbull W11JY1 LtJ fJ W

rtlJ=J1itiit1hU11J~i1L~~n1iifm~1 it11111Jl11V1a1A1it~f ~ OJ

2-jn1V1tJ1~tJj11lrilJ 1mEl~Imnr 1UVljUj2-jjllU nWl ~IV11 ~UVJ2-jDli1

1UVl18 fJ2-J1n~ufi 2553

r~1Jiltlll(ll(ll1 r~1Jll(ll(ll1

ll(ll(ll1uirLnm~ilmJ ll(ll (lI1vir ll(ll(ll1tYl ll(ll(ll1Liln

hJHLnniill1 ~U~1J 1 ~U~1J 2

111EJ l-Ir1)~ 1l)J 111EJ l-Ir1)~ 111EJ l-IrD~ 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J 111EJ l-Ici1~ rl)J 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J

UnAnH1nflun~

iYlmn1~f1alJybLfla

f1l1n~~IJf11illllftlhJ +------------f-----------f----------I j------ ------+-----------+- ---------1------- -----1-shy -----------shy

5J3-l 2 2

UnAnH1nfl-nUlH

iYlmn1~f1aIJYilLfiaf

IYlflt 1Jtil1iVlilllln~~lJlL~1J~L Ylflt 1Jtil1in1~rJ1ifl ~ ---------- +-----------~------------+--- --------f------------I------------I-----------l------------1

16 j------------+----I---------I--------I------++---I

16

Lfljj

IYlflt 1Jtil1ilIIilllln~~lJlL~1J~ii L~nmailflilLLil~f1aIJW1Llllaf

5J3-l

~ 5JIJII~~U

19

19 2

19

21

iI11i1aa lJ ll~i1 11i1Y11UUf1 ~al ll~l

d ~~--~ltfa UlpoundJYI~liipoundJU~

11lJ~ntJtl ~~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ m~n~ b~Wtl~Jl1~~1~VltJ1~tJ~1llJl)dl~tJtl~1nnw

lJtltlWd-J~n1~1~mruru1Ull~ ~ ~

d-J~1~V1tJ1~m1llJl)dl~tJtl~1mnr1WVi~1J~d-J~1~iJ5wl ~1~1(1)iJVJ~fi1tJ tln1~~m~1 2552

tlW~e-J~n1~~mnb~tl1W~ 18 n~Jl1iWfi 2553

~1~jJVl ~r~iJ~~rl~d

~t1 ~1jil(1~ lPIiuw-nlPl btl i bbn i~ 1 ll11 VIJ1 n1i Afl ~ ViJ blPlfli

1 48122420131 W11~1dtl~Vi~nw ~~WA1 20 bd-JtJ 2529 216 iJn~

2 46222420101 W1t1n~Vili ~d~~ruiJ~~Mtfd9

3 VitJ 2510 239 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1A~ nii~ 111~ lPIitJ1tI

3 1471226001041 W11~1d~~d-J1 ~~b~W I 21 ViA 2529 222 iJn~ btlibbni~1ll1 bVIAbllb~~fl1Pl~1~nii~bbllllJbVIAbllb~~n1i(J~ 1PI

gt-bull4 50232790207 W1tJtJItJVlfi U1WdW 18 n A 2518 258 ~ bPlM 5 50232790301 W1mnl tlW~V1fi 13 Vi tJ 2520 311 ~bPlM

6 50232790303 W1tJ~nm~Mnr ~d-J~1bUW 18 VitJ 2525 260 ~bPlM

7 50232790304 W1tJ-nlld1~ ~111d 26 bd-JtJ 2524 281 ~bPlM

8 50232790307 W1tJruNrol ~lJru 23 VitJ 2526 308 ~bPlM

9 50232790308 W1tJrutiVi~ bVltJWd-JWll 10 nVi 2528 365 ~bPlMd9

Q tV ~ QA cl 10 50232790309 W1tJWdwJW ll~~V1fi 11 nVi 2530 315 ~bPlM

11 5023279031 0 W1tJd-JW~-ntJ AI1~dJ 9 nA 2520 315 ~bPlM

12 50232790311 W1tJ~It1 ~1~d-JiW 26 VitJ 2523 276 ~bPlM

13 50232790312 W1tJ~ViiOl-W ll~1-ntJ 19 nVi 2526 258 ~bPlM

14 50232790313 W1tJP1n~ru~1rol U(1)(1)1dlPl 9 ~A 2527 322 ~bPlM

15 50232790314 W1tJ~d-J bnm~ iJtlJJn 7 fiA 2527 315 ~bPlM ~

16 50232790316 W1tJ~d wJ jJ rutJd-J1lltJ 11 fiA 2526 298 ~bPlM

~

17 50232790317 W1tJtl~ru diOlWJldn~ 20 fiA 2527 281 ~bPlM AQ 4lI IV tS

18 50232790319 W1tJtlVlfiVi~ b~tliOlWVI~ 20 fiA 2526 303 ~bPlM

19 50232790320 W1tJ~bll~ fn-Kll~ 21 ViA 2520 275 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bA ij

20 49222840108 IW1t1iJnid-JVI~ b~1bfil I 11 nA 2522 289

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bVIAtllb~~fl1Pl~1~ nii~ bbllllJ~ b~ nVIiflU A~ bb~ Afl ~vh blPlfli

21 149222970101 1~~~n~ u I 18 nu 2528 318

d J -I ~ J_- ~1lltl IV-_--- W1tJVIb1JtJW

UtlJllill~1U1U~~1L~~miAmt1 l1l1111l1A~IIfll1l(1f ~ OJ

~Il1~VltJ1~m1llJiJ) 1fltJflflmn111U~~m~~l~1J trwl rrm11l1JVJ~filn IIV od

)UVl 18 nWl1~Ufi 2553 T~ciUfl~1frCC1 T~ciu1frCC1

1frCC1~1Lnm~nmJ llCC1~1 llCC1LYI U1CC1Lfln

hJnLn1lJ)lI1 fiuciu 1 fiuciu 2

Jl1poundJ ci)~ TllJ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ

trnAnH11l1flYi~flH

iiLlIflfllallrl

fllltln~~1J

i tl~ ~f1lalJf11 allrl oJ a~fllJfllaf1~1ll8Ol~ljWllJl

----------shy ---------shy

- - -- - - -shy ~ ~ -shy -----------shy

-- - -shy - --shy ~ --shy ----------shy

------------shy ---------_

------------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

---shy -------shy

-----------shy

------_--shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

----------shy -shy _------shy

-shy --------shy -----------shy2

--shy -------shy _ _----shy --

-----------shy -----------shy

------shy _shy

----------shy

----------shy

-shy -------shy

-----------shy2

-------_shy7

- - - - - shy ~ -shy8

-------shy

1 1 ---------shy ----------shy

2 --shy ----shy --shy

6 15 - -------shy -----shy

9 17 -------- ----shy ---shy

-------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

--__-------- --shy --------shy _---

--__-------- ---------shy _ ---shy -----shy

-----------shy ------------shy

----------shy --shy -shy -------shy

--shy -

---------shy

-----------_

gtUJ 2 17 16 35

~ gtUJII~~tJ 2 17 16 35

lilmiddoti1i1afJULL~lili1i1mU~n~fJILL~1

d ~~-- ~1Z1fJ UltJt1LutJU

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 6: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

~ 1 J a ~j I ~ ~ lJnlI ~iuIiI1 UIU ~middotGi1 Lililmilln H1Y1l1flfl U 3J (Imi ~uin tlJ1lJ (IiLL-afl Uu in tlJ1lJ (Ii

ar q U q ar q arar

3JI1iYltn~tJnilIlD)liltJEIilmmJ 1WYiim3Ji1~unWl 4IW)lilUVJ3JTI1W

IV o=l

)WYl 18 shy

T13Jl1YiWfi 2553

lllJJ1iJll

1~Ul11illq1t1il

ill fJ fJl ~middotihn m~ um-l

tlU~U 1 I tlU~U 2

illfJfJl(lr

1~uillfJryl

ill fJ ry1hI illfJfJ1Llfl

JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ llr)~ JllrJ lHi1~ 1ll-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J JllrJ llr)~ 11l-J

1Tnflntllll1fltln~

lllJJ1iJlli Y1rJ1P11ll(l f 2 2

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

iUJ

-------------gt-----------j------------+------------f------------f------------f

3 3

4

6

1Tnflntllll1flYiUltl ll1~1iJlliYlrJ1P11ll(lf 19 19

lll~liJllPlltlPllll(lf 2 17 16 35

ll1~1iJllfll1U1ll11~1n9

lllJJ1iJllfl l1UfJ~

4 6 53 142 207 1-------------+--- -------+--------

ll1~1iJllf~tl1PllllUPllll(lf

iU 4 3 6 90 159 263

l iUJr1~iU 4 3 6 93 162 269

Vl ~lilIH) tlLtll Vl~1ilV11 U ~ nfflB-J U~l

d ~ J vJshyIl-J Hl bullbullbullbull W11JY1 LtJ fJ W

rtlJ=J1itiit1hU11J~i1L~~n1iifm~1 it11111Jl11V1a1A1it~f ~ OJ

2-jn1V1tJ1~tJj11lrilJ 1mEl~Imnr 1UVljUj2-jjllU nWl ~IV11 ~UVJ2-jDli1

1UVl18 fJ2-J1n~ufi 2553

r~1Jiltlll(ll(ll1 r~1Jll(ll(ll1

ll(ll(ll1uirLnm~ilmJ ll(ll (lI1vir ll(ll(ll1tYl ll(ll(ll1Liln

hJHLnniill1 ~U~1J 1 ~U~1J 2

111EJ l-Ir1)~ 1l)J 111EJ l-Ir1)~ 111EJ l-IrD~ 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J 111EJ l-Ici1~ rl)J 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J

UnAnH1nflun~

iYlmn1~f1alJybLfla

f1l1n~~IJf11illllftlhJ +------------f-----------f----------I j------ ------+-----------+- ---------1------- -----1-shy -----------shy

5J3-l 2 2

UnAnH1nfl-nUlH

iYlmn1~f1aIJYilLfiaf

IYlflt 1Jtil1iVlilllln~~lJlL~1J~L Ylflt 1Jtil1in1~rJ1ifl ~ ---------- +-----------~------------+--- --------f------------I------------I-----------l------------1

16 j------------+----I---------I--------I------++---I

16

Lfljj

IYlflt 1Jtil1ilIIilllln~~lJlL~1J~ii L~nmailflilLLil~f1aIJW1Llllaf

5J3-l

~ 5JIJII~~U

19

19 2

19

21

iI11i1aa lJ ll~i1 11i1Y11UUf1 ~al ll~l

d ~~--~ltfa UlpoundJYI~liipoundJU~

11lJ~ntJtl ~~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ m~n~ b~Wtl~Jl1~~1~VltJ1~tJ~1llJl)dl~tJtl~1nnw

lJtltlWd-J~n1~1~mruru1Ull~ ~ ~

d-J~1~V1tJ1~m1llJl)dl~tJtl~1mnr1WVi~1J~d-J~1~iJ5wl ~1~1(1)iJVJ~fi1tJ tln1~~m~1 2552

tlW~e-J~n1~~mnb~tl1W~ 18 n~Jl1iWfi 2553

~1~jJVl ~r~iJ~~rl~d

~t1 ~1jil(1~ lPIiuw-nlPl btl i bbn i~ 1 ll11 VIJ1 n1i Afl ~ ViJ blPlfli

1 48122420131 W11~1dtl~Vi~nw ~~WA1 20 bd-JtJ 2529 216 iJn~

2 46222420101 W1t1n~Vili ~d~~ruiJ~~Mtfd9

3 VitJ 2510 239 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1A~ nii~ 111~ lPIitJ1tI

3 1471226001041 W11~1d~~d-J1 ~~b~W I 21 ViA 2529 222 iJn~ btlibbni~1ll1 bVIAbllb~~fl1Pl~1~nii~bbllllJbVIAbllb~~n1i(J~ 1PI

gt-bull4 50232790207 W1tJtJItJVlfi U1WdW 18 n A 2518 258 ~ bPlM 5 50232790301 W1mnl tlW~V1fi 13 Vi tJ 2520 311 ~bPlM

6 50232790303 W1tJ~nm~Mnr ~d-J~1bUW 18 VitJ 2525 260 ~bPlM

7 50232790304 W1tJ-nlld1~ ~111d 26 bd-JtJ 2524 281 ~bPlM

8 50232790307 W1tJruNrol ~lJru 23 VitJ 2526 308 ~bPlM

9 50232790308 W1tJrutiVi~ bVltJWd-JWll 10 nVi 2528 365 ~bPlMd9

Q tV ~ QA cl 10 50232790309 W1tJWdwJW ll~~V1fi 11 nVi 2530 315 ~bPlM

11 5023279031 0 W1tJd-JW~-ntJ AI1~dJ 9 nA 2520 315 ~bPlM

12 50232790311 W1tJ~It1 ~1~d-JiW 26 VitJ 2523 276 ~bPlM

13 50232790312 W1tJ~ViiOl-W ll~1-ntJ 19 nVi 2526 258 ~bPlM

14 50232790313 W1tJP1n~ru~1rol U(1)(1)1dlPl 9 ~A 2527 322 ~bPlM

15 50232790314 W1tJ~d-J bnm~ iJtlJJn 7 fiA 2527 315 ~bPlM ~

16 50232790316 W1tJ~d wJ jJ rutJd-J1lltJ 11 fiA 2526 298 ~bPlM

~

17 50232790317 W1tJtl~ru diOlWJldn~ 20 fiA 2527 281 ~bPlM AQ 4lI IV tS

18 50232790319 W1tJtlVlfiVi~ b~tliOlWVI~ 20 fiA 2526 303 ~bPlM

19 50232790320 W1tJ~bll~ fn-Kll~ 21 ViA 2520 275 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bA ij

20 49222840108 IW1t1iJnid-JVI~ b~1bfil I 11 nA 2522 289

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bVIAtllb~~fl1Pl~1~ nii~ bbllllJ~ b~ nVIiflU A~ bb~ Afl ~vh blPlfli

21 149222970101 1~~~n~ u I 18 nu 2528 318

d J -I ~ J_- ~1lltl IV-_--- W1tJVIb1JtJW

UtlJllill~1U1U~~1L~~miAmt1 l1l1111l1A~IIfll1l(1f ~ OJ

~Il1~VltJ1~m1llJiJ) 1fltJflflmn111U~~m~~l~1J trwl rrm11l1JVJ~filn IIV od

)UVl 18 nWl1~Ufi 2553 T~ciUfl~1frCC1 T~ciu1frCC1

1frCC1~1Lnm~nmJ llCC1~1 llCC1LYI U1CC1Lfln

hJnLn1lJ)lI1 fiuciu 1 fiuciu 2

Jl1poundJ ci)~ TllJ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ

trnAnH11l1flYi~flH

iiLlIflfllallrl

fllltln~~1J

i tl~ ~f1lalJf11 allrl oJ a~fllJfllaf1~1ll8Ol~ljWllJl

----------shy ---------shy

- - -- - - -shy ~ ~ -shy -----------shy

-- - -shy - --shy ~ --shy ----------shy

------------shy ---------_

------------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

---shy -------shy

-----------shy

------_--shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

----------shy -shy _------shy

-shy --------shy -----------shy2

--shy -------shy _ _----shy --

-----------shy -----------shy

------shy _shy

----------shy

----------shy

-shy -------shy

-----------shy2

-------_shy7

- - - - - shy ~ -shy8

-------shy

1 1 ---------shy ----------shy

2 --shy ----shy --shy

6 15 - -------shy -----shy

9 17 -------- ----shy ---shy

-------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

--__-------- --shy --------shy _---

--__-------- ---------shy _ ---shy -----shy

-----------shy ------------shy

----------shy --shy -shy -------shy

--shy -

---------shy

-----------_

gtUJ 2 17 16 35

~ gtUJII~~tJ 2 17 16 35

lilmiddoti1i1afJULL~lili1i1mU~n~fJILL~1

d ~~-- ~1Z1fJ UltJt1LutJU

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 7: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

rtlJ=J1itiit1hU11J~i1L~~n1iifm~1 it11111Jl11V1a1A1it~f ~ OJ

2-jn1V1tJ1~tJj11lrilJ 1mEl~Imnr 1UVljUj2-jjllU nWl ~IV11 ~UVJ2-jDli1

1UVl18 fJ2-J1n~ufi 2553

r~1Jiltlll(ll(ll1 r~1Jll(ll(ll1

ll(ll(ll1uirLnm~ilmJ ll(ll (lI1vir ll(ll(ll1tYl ll(ll(ll1Liln

hJHLnniill1 ~U~1J 1 ~U~1J 2

111EJ l-Ir1)~ 1l)J 111EJ l-Ir1)~ 111EJ l-IrD~ 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J 111EJ l-Ici1~ rl)J 111EJ l-IrD~ rl)J

UnAnH1nflun~

iYlmn1~f1alJybLfla

f1l1n~~IJf11illllftlhJ +------------f-----------f----------I j------ ------+-----------+- ---------1------- -----1-shy -----------shy

5J3-l 2 2

UnAnH1nfl-nUlH

iYlmn1~f1aIJYilLfiaf

IYlflt 1Jtil1iVlilllln~~lJlL~1J~L Ylflt 1Jtil1in1~rJ1ifl ~ ---------- +-----------~------------+--- --------f------------I------------I-----------l------------1

16 j------------+----I---------I--------I------++---I

16

Lfljj

IYlflt 1Jtil1ilIIilllln~~lJlL~1J~ii L~nmailflilLLil~f1aIJW1Llllaf

5J3-l

~ 5JIJII~~U

19

19 2

19

21

iI11i1aa lJ ll~i1 11i1Y11UUf1 ~al ll~l

d ~~--~ltfa UlpoundJYI~liipoundJU~

11lJ~ntJtl ~~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ m~n~ b~Wtl~Jl1~~1~VltJ1~tJ~1llJl)dl~tJtl~1nnw

lJtltlWd-J~n1~1~mruru1Ull~ ~ ~

d-J~1~V1tJ1~m1llJl)dl~tJtl~1mnr1WVi~1J~d-J~1~iJ5wl ~1~1(1)iJVJ~fi1tJ tln1~~m~1 2552

tlW~e-J~n1~~mnb~tl1W~ 18 n~Jl1iWfi 2553

~1~jJVl ~r~iJ~~rl~d

~t1 ~1jil(1~ lPIiuw-nlPl btl i bbn i~ 1 ll11 VIJ1 n1i Afl ~ ViJ blPlfli

1 48122420131 W11~1dtl~Vi~nw ~~WA1 20 bd-JtJ 2529 216 iJn~

2 46222420101 W1t1n~Vili ~d~~ruiJ~~Mtfd9

3 VitJ 2510 239 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1A~ nii~ 111~ lPIitJ1tI

3 1471226001041 W11~1d~~d-J1 ~~b~W I 21 ViA 2529 222 iJn~ btlibbni~1ll1 bVIAbllb~~fl1Pl~1~nii~bbllllJbVIAbllb~~n1i(J~ 1PI

gt-bull4 50232790207 W1tJtJItJVlfi U1WdW 18 n A 2518 258 ~ bPlM 5 50232790301 W1mnl tlW~V1fi 13 Vi tJ 2520 311 ~bPlM

6 50232790303 W1tJ~nm~Mnr ~d-J~1bUW 18 VitJ 2525 260 ~bPlM

7 50232790304 W1tJ-nlld1~ ~111d 26 bd-JtJ 2524 281 ~bPlM

8 50232790307 W1tJruNrol ~lJru 23 VitJ 2526 308 ~bPlM

9 50232790308 W1tJrutiVi~ bVltJWd-JWll 10 nVi 2528 365 ~bPlMd9

Q tV ~ QA cl 10 50232790309 W1tJWdwJW ll~~V1fi 11 nVi 2530 315 ~bPlM

11 5023279031 0 W1tJd-JW~-ntJ AI1~dJ 9 nA 2520 315 ~bPlM

12 50232790311 W1tJ~It1 ~1~d-JiW 26 VitJ 2523 276 ~bPlM

13 50232790312 W1tJ~ViiOl-W ll~1-ntJ 19 nVi 2526 258 ~bPlM

14 50232790313 W1tJP1n~ru~1rol U(1)(1)1dlPl 9 ~A 2527 322 ~bPlM

15 50232790314 W1tJ~d-J bnm~ iJtlJJn 7 fiA 2527 315 ~bPlM ~

16 50232790316 W1tJ~d wJ jJ rutJd-J1lltJ 11 fiA 2526 298 ~bPlM

~

17 50232790317 W1tJtl~ru diOlWJldn~ 20 fiA 2527 281 ~bPlM AQ 4lI IV tS

18 50232790319 W1tJtlVlfiVi~ b~tliOlWVI~ 20 fiA 2526 303 ~bPlM

19 50232790320 W1tJ~bll~ fn-Kll~ 21 ViA 2520 275 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bA ij

20 49222840108 IW1t1iJnid-JVI~ b~1bfil I 11 nA 2522 289

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bVIAtllb~~fl1Pl~1~ nii~ bbllllJ~ b~ nVIiflU A~ bb~ Afl ~vh blPlfli

21 149222970101 1~~~n~ u I 18 nu 2528 318

d J -I ~ J_- ~1lltl IV-_--- W1tJVIb1JtJW

UtlJllill~1U1U~~1L~~miAmt1 l1l1111l1A~IIfll1l(1f ~ OJ

~Il1~VltJ1~m1llJiJ) 1fltJflflmn111U~~m~~l~1J trwl rrm11l1JVJ~filn IIV od

)UVl 18 nWl1~Ufi 2553 T~ciUfl~1frCC1 T~ciu1frCC1

1frCC1~1Lnm~nmJ llCC1~1 llCC1LYI U1CC1Lfln

hJnLn1lJ)lI1 fiuciu 1 fiuciu 2

Jl1poundJ ci)~ TllJ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ

trnAnH11l1flYi~flH

iiLlIflfllallrl

fllltln~~1J

i tl~ ~f1lalJf11 allrl oJ a~fllJfllaf1~1ll8Ol~ljWllJl

----------shy ---------shy

- - -- - - -shy ~ ~ -shy -----------shy

-- - -shy - --shy ~ --shy ----------shy

------------shy ---------_

------------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

---shy -------shy

-----------shy

------_--shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

----------shy -shy _------shy

-shy --------shy -----------shy2

--shy -------shy _ _----shy --

-----------shy -----------shy

------shy _shy

----------shy

----------shy

-shy -------shy

-----------shy2

-------_shy7

- - - - - shy ~ -shy8

-------shy

1 1 ---------shy ----------shy

2 --shy ----shy --shy

6 15 - -------shy -----shy

9 17 -------- ----shy ---shy

-------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

--__-------- --shy --------shy _---

--__-------- ---------shy _ ---shy -----shy

-----------shy ------------shy

----------shy --shy -shy -------shy

--shy -

---------shy

-----------_

gtUJ 2 17 16 35

~ gtUJII~~tJ 2 17 16 35

lilmiddoti1i1afJULL~lili1i1mU~n~fJILL~1

d ~~-- ~1Z1fJ UltJt1LutJU

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 8: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

11lJ~ntJtl ~~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ m~n~ b~Wtl~Jl1~~1~VltJ1~tJ~1llJl)dl~tJtl~1nnw

lJtltlWd-J~n1~1~mruru1Ull~ ~ ~

d-J~1~V1tJ1~m1llJl)dl~tJtl~1mnr1WVi~1J~d-J~1~iJ5wl ~1~1(1)iJVJ~fi1tJ tln1~~m~1 2552

tlW~e-J~n1~~mnb~tl1W~ 18 n~Jl1iWfi 2553

~1~jJVl ~r~iJ~~rl~d

~t1 ~1jil(1~ lPIiuw-nlPl btl i bbn i~ 1 ll11 VIJ1 n1i Afl ~ ViJ blPlfli

1 48122420131 W11~1dtl~Vi~nw ~~WA1 20 bd-JtJ 2529 216 iJn~

2 46222420101 W1t1n~Vili ~d~~ruiJ~~Mtfd9

3 VitJ 2510 239 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1A~ nii~ 111~ lPIitJ1tI

3 1471226001041 W11~1d~~d-J1 ~~b~W I 21 ViA 2529 222 iJn~ btlibbni~1ll1 bVIAbllb~~fl1Pl~1~nii~bbllllJbVIAbllb~~n1i(J~ 1PI

gt-bull4 50232790207 W1tJtJItJVlfi U1WdW 18 n A 2518 258 ~ bPlM 5 50232790301 W1mnl tlW~V1fi 13 Vi tJ 2520 311 ~bPlM

6 50232790303 W1tJ~nm~Mnr ~d-J~1bUW 18 VitJ 2525 260 ~bPlM

7 50232790304 W1tJ-nlld1~ ~111d 26 bd-JtJ 2524 281 ~bPlM

8 50232790307 W1tJruNrol ~lJru 23 VitJ 2526 308 ~bPlM

9 50232790308 W1tJrutiVi~ bVltJWd-JWll 10 nVi 2528 365 ~bPlMd9

Q tV ~ QA cl 10 50232790309 W1tJWdwJW ll~~V1fi 11 nVi 2530 315 ~bPlM

11 5023279031 0 W1tJd-JW~-ntJ AI1~dJ 9 nA 2520 315 ~bPlM

12 50232790311 W1tJ~It1 ~1~d-JiW 26 VitJ 2523 276 ~bPlM

13 50232790312 W1tJ~ViiOl-W ll~1-ntJ 19 nVi 2526 258 ~bPlM

14 50232790313 W1tJP1n~ru~1rol U(1)(1)1dlPl 9 ~A 2527 322 ~bPlM

15 50232790314 W1tJ~d-J bnm~ iJtlJJn 7 fiA 2527 315 ~bPlM ~

16 50232790316 W1tJ~d wJ jJ rutJd-J1lltJ 11 fiA 2526 298 ~bPlM

~

17 50232790317 W1tJtl~ru diOlWJldn~ 20 fiA 2527 281 ~bPlM AQ 4lI IV tS

18 50232790319 W1tJtlVlfiVi~ b~tliOlWVI~ 20 fiA 2526 303 ~bPlM

19 50232790320 W1tJ~bll~ fn-Kll~ 21 ViA 2520 275 ~bPlM

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bA ij

20 49222840108 IW1t1iJnid-JVI~ b~1bfil I 11 nA 2522 289

bt1ibbni~1ll1 bVIAtllb~~fl1Pl~1~ nii~ bbllllJ~ b~ nVIiflU A~ bb~ Afl ~vh blPlfli

21 149222970101 1~~~n~ u I 18 nu 2528 318

d J -I ~ J_- ~1lltl IV-_--- W1tJVIb1JtJW

UtlJllill~1U1U~~1L~~miAmt1 l1l1111l1A~IIfll1l(1f ~ OJ

~Il1~VltJ1~m1llJiJ) 1fltJflflmn111U~~m~~l~1J trwl rrm11l1JVJ~filn IIV od

)UVl 18 nWl1~Ufi 2553 T~ciUfl~1frCC1 T~ciu1frCC1

1frCC1~1Lnm~nmJ llCC1~1 llCC1LYI U1CC1Lfln

hJnLn1lJ)lI1 fiuciu 1 fiuciu 2

Jl1poundJ ci)~ TllJ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ

trnAnH11l1flYi~flH

iiLlIflfllallrl

fllltln~~1J

i tl~ ~f1lalJf11 allrl oJ a~fllJfllaf1~1ll8Ol~ljWllJl

----------shy ---------shy

- - -- - - -shy ~ ~ -shy -----------shy

-- - -shy - --shy ~ --shy ----------shy

------------shy ---------_

------------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

---shy -------shy

-----------shy

------_--shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

----------shy -shy _------shy

-shy --------shy -----------shy2

--shy -------shy _ _----shy --

-----------shy -----------shy

------shy _shy

----------shy

----------shy

-shy -------shy

-----------shy2

-------_shy7

- - - - - shy ~ -shy8

-------shy

1 1 ---------shy ----------shy

2 --shy ----shy --shy

6 15 - -------shy -----shy

9 17 -------- ----shy ---shy

-------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

--__-------- --shy --------shy _---

--__-------- ---------shy _ ---shy -----shy

-----------shy ------------shy

----------shy --shy -shy -------shy

--shy -

---------shy

-----------_

gtUJ 2 17 16 35

~ gtUJII~~tJ 2 17 16 35

lilmiddoti1i1afJULL~lili1i1mU~n~fJILL~1

d ~~-- ~1Z1fJ UltJt1LutJU

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 9: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

UtlJllill~1U1U~~1L~~miAmt1 l1l1111l1A~IIfll1l(1f ~ OJ

~Il1~VltJ1~m1llJiJ) 1fltJflflmn111U~~m~~l~1J trwl rrm11l1JVJ~filn IIV od

)UVl 18 nWl1~Ufi 2553 T~ciUfl~1frCC1 T~ciu1frCC1

1frCC1~1Lnm~nmJ llCC1~1 llCC1LYI U1CC1Lfln

hJnLn1lJ)lI1 fiuciu 1 fiuciu 2

Jl1poundJ ci)~ TllJ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ lI1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ 1l1poundJ ci)~ TllJ

trnAnH11l1flYi~flH

iiLlIflfllallrl

fllltln~~1J

i tl~ ~f1lalJf11 allrl oJ a~fllJfllaf1~1ll8Ol~ljWllJl

----------shy ---------shy

- - -- - - -shy ~ ~ -shy -----------shy

-- - -shy - --shy ~ --shy ----------shy

------------shy ---------_

------------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

---shy -------shy

-----------shy

------_--shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

----------shy -shy _------shy

-shy --------shy -----------shy2

--shy -------shy _ _----shy --

-----------shy -----------shy

------shy _shy

----------shy

----------shy

-shy -------shy

-----------shy2

-------_shy7

- - - - - shy ~ -shy8

-------shy

1 1 ---------shy ----------shy

2 --shy ----shy --shy

6 15 - -------shy -----shy

9 17 -------- ----shy ---shy

-------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

-----------shy

--__-------- --shy --------shy _---

--__-------- ---------shy _ ---shy -----shy

-----------shy ------------shy

----------shy --shy -shy -------shy

--shy -

---------shy

-----------_

gtUJ 2 17 16 35

~ gtUJII~~tJ 2 17 16 35

lilmiddoti1i1afJULL~lili1i1mU~n~fJILL~1

d ~~-- ~1Z1fJ UltJt1LutJU

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 10: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

11CJ~ ~1 tJ~El ~~ 1 b~l n1 ~~m~n~b~~El~fl1~I11jY1m~tJ~1llnJJ1~tJEl~NnmI lIElEl~~~m~1~mrurU1U[l~ ~ ~

~I11jY1m~m1llnJJ1~tJEl~-m~nr 1~Y1~1J~~~1~iJtl~rl ~~Wr~iJVJ~D1i1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

El~~~eJ~n1~~mj1briEl1~~ 18 n~fl1~~fi 2553

17 50524660102

W1tJll1~

El1Plm1~J~ 23 ~A 2507 302 v bPl~

18 50524660103 W1tJblltJJll1r1J ElElWI1J1~ 10 ~A 2502 320 V bPl~

19 50524660105 W1tJiJ~b~l~ d9

bn~1eJ~ 1 ~A 2492 243 V bPl~

20 50524660107 W1~~mbull Y1~I1~bn~~ 11 [lA 2503 285 ybPl~

21 50524660109 W1tJjb~m 1JltJ~tJtJlA 1 Y1tJ 2489 313 V bPl~

22 50524660110 W1tJ~n~1 vl1W1bJll 13 n Y1 2519 290 V bPl~

~1 ~1JVl

2

1

2

3

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

~x~iJ~~1 []J

~~ l1pff ]iuru-n (RLn~i~iJ~3Jf1lJvllJ 2

bUi bbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114UPl114lPl~

48723330317 ~UbEln~Y1l~ Vl1~~bull 48723330320 ~UtVl~1~JtJ ~~1J~Eln

~~l1pff]iuru-n] bUibbni3J~liTih VI PlPl114lPl~

145223150232 I~1~~1J1El~~1 ~~fY1~n bUiUni3J~li1~~Unii3J

48223200107 ~rltJ~1D[l Pl~Y1~1tJ

b Uibbni3J~li1~fjUi~Pl114U Pl114lPl~ 48523340149 ~1tJ1wntJ ~lIiJ~~~r1bull

0

48723330310 ~Um~JlbElm~n1~ ~J~bbm

48723330314 ~1~~1JfirufP1if l1~~~DY1~~ ~

48723330315 W1~~~J1~~ D1ll~fl1 48723330318 W1~~J~HW ~~y~1tJbull 48723330321 W1~~1Jn1r1JlW1 jJtA

48723330323 ~1U~1~JllltJY1~ ~1iJ1bi11

48723330324 W1tJ~~~n~ to]bel~

49723330216 W1~~1JrY1lm P1ln~ bull 47223340423 W1tJ~1WY1 iW~

47R23340158 W1tJDW1IJJU 1lltJ~Y1~ i~ I j buibbni3JJli114~1Ol3J Pl114lPlib ~e) n1i~ lPlJU1

28 ijrl

4 Y1tJ

9 DA

13 Y1tJ

9 ~A

27 DA

22 ~A

7 Y1tJ

24 DA

20 Y1tJ

22 b~tJ

20 Y1tJ

28 ~A

14 nA

13 ~A

7 ~A

17 nY1

9 ~A

2513 325

2522 358

2525 262

2523 281

2528 258

2522 267

2513 313

2502 306

2516 260

2516 300

2508 255

2521 303

2525 345

2512 274

2524 236

2520 350

2528 268

2525 214

v bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bP1~

V bPl~

V bPl~

V bPl~

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 11: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

middot ~l~lJVl ~~~iJ~~lrl)

L1J ~bbn ~3-J11l1il rol3-J flf1~ lPI ~h yjfl n1~~lPlJU1

23 50524660111 Ull~l)U ri~lU 23 DfP1 2500 307 yhll~ lJ

I Q 0 ~

24 50524660112 ll~lJlfln~lJ~~bW fll)l~ 22 ~fP1 2517 296 vhral~ q

25 50524660115 UllflUl~llltJ~tJtllfP1 5 ijtJ 2492 338 yhll~

26 50524660117 Ull~d-Jl~ d-Jl~tJiJ~l~1~ 25 nfP1 2496 308 yhll~ q ~

27 50524660118 UllUlnn-W yhiJ~~l~ 21 DfP1 2511 338 yhll~ Q ~ CV ~

28 50524660119 UllllIld-JbWOVlU VlUml(PJl 23 VL fP1 2500 313 ylll~ q q

29 50524660120 UltJ~d-JllltJ tVl~ral1 19 1lfP1 2496 317 yhral~

30 50524660123 Ull~1)~(PJ1Jl~nr mllJrul)~~ru 22 nfP1 2509 315 yhll~ q ~

31 50524660124 UllllJ1dld-Jlral ~(PJ)l 11 iJfP1 2510 310 Y1lll~ s

32 50524660125 UltJ~d-Jun l~lqMVltJ 31 VlfP1 2498 313 Y1lll~ o

33 50524660126 Ullll~fll rJmnll 7 ld-JtJ 2507 273 Y1lll~q

~l~fl ~ J__middot UltJVllUtJU

dl 9J d

l1lJ1fJtlJmiddot lJf1lj[JfwnmC1f11iHJU

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 12: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

-------

------- ---- ---- -------

UtlJ~~auhUJUer-A1L~~n1aAn~1 ~1I11Ji1n1m~V11afiaii~ QI III lU III

l-J1iYlIJ1~1J~1llrlfll1~lJtl~mmr 1UVi~1J~l-J~1l1lt1l-J11 ~j1L11lVJl-JfilU

ltV

lUYl 18 tr

TJl-J1l1ViWfi 2553

TI11UtIT1j1jl

tIT1j 1jlvij-Lnm~ilEJl-l tIT1j 1j1 VIr tIT1j1jl tYl T-I11Uilt1Jhj1jl

I tIT1j1jlLiln

hhLLn1l-l1111 fJUI11U 1

JI1EJ I vtc1)~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ vtc1)~ I T1l-JJI1EJ I vtrD~ I T1l-l I 111EJ I vtt1J~ I T1l-l I JI1EJ I vtt1J~111EJ

tYnfilnHl1l1fltlnJ n11r~n11tlltl

-J------------f------- ---1------ ------+-----------~

n11ui~11~1iiLL~IJ~imm1~al~

n11ui~11~1iiL11l1J~imflD1J~lL~Dq1ii

~UJ 3

tYnfilnHlll1fl~LflH

n11r~n11tlltl 78 11831 _____ ~4____

n11uim1~1iiL1~IJ~imn11jqJil 17 19 ------_+--shy

n11ui~11~1iiLLlllJ~imn11~al~ 12 --- ---1- -- ----f-- --- -- -- f-- _-- __ ---1-middotmiddot ~ 1__ -l- _7

n11uim1q1iiL1~IJ~imn11uim111iYlmn11JIl1ta 13 19

n11uim1~1iiLL~IJ~imflD1J~lli1Dq1ii 12 27 39 - shy

142 2074 1 6 53~UJ

l 143 2111 6 564~nJYI~~U

~J1il~EJ1Jlli~~J1i1Y1lU~n ~EJIll~1

d ~~ d

illlEJ bullbullbullbullbull bullbullU1EJY1~L1JEJU

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 13: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

bull bull

1Jk~~1 tJ~f) ~ ~1 b~iOl n1 ~~ mj1~ b1llf)1111~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf) ~-J mn1

1If)f)ll~n1 ~HJhmU11J~ ~ q ~ ~

~VI1~Vlm~m11lniJJL~tJf)~-J mn11llVl~iJ~~~1~J5~Jl -JVIrJt1UVJ~fi1J t1n1~~nM1 2552

~1f71iJYl

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 1482232302181 ll1-J11Jll-J~f ~Vlfi~~ I 16 ~rI 2524 346

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

49133180219

48223180304

48223180309

48223180311

48223180314

48223180319

48223180320

48223180321

48223180322

48223180325

f)ll~VI~~n1~~nM1bnf)rJll~ 18 n~1l1~llfi 2553 q q

~~1U~~1 ~J

n1jU~Vl1jfjjniDluru-n11l poundntljDiiJmJttJvlu 1bull

1ja bbn a3-l11l1ma~ lPl n1a~J 1j

48223180307 ll1-JllVlfbVik bU~1llVlf 17 ~rI 2521 362

10 1 Fl 2508 360

48223180357 ll1-J11Jf)~i1tJ ~1ij 30 ~rI 2530 368

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1aJ~Vl1afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1a lPl~1lPl q

~ ~ r 48223220211 ll1-J11JllllVlJll llJ1J~HW 13 b~tJ 2524 364

IJ q

48223220220 ll1-J11l1Jt11 fi-Jflln~fi~ 25 ~Fl 2522 386 q q q

n1jU~jInjfjjniDluru-nvHntljDiiJmJitJvlu 2bull 1j abbn a3-l11l1n1alPl ma~J 1j

48223180353 ll1-J11J11m n~~lliliOl 18 ij rI 2525 353 q

48223180363 ll1-Jf)hJ~Hll ~llrl-J 18 VlrI 2512 334 q

48723180219 ll1-JrJ~~1l1 J~~Vlfi 6 b~tJ 2513 332

1ja bbn a3-l11l1 n1 aU~Vl1afiaih bblJ U~11l1 m alPl ~1lPl q

48223220210 ll1tJllVlt1~ bbti-JbVl]j~ 10 1rI 2513 359

48223220224 ll1-J11J11l1J(l fll~Fl~ 7 ~rI 2527 357

q q

f r 48223220225 ll1-J1111Vl~ 1J11t1J-JrI 6 b~tJ 2529 347

q

1J a bbn a3-l11l1 n1aU~Vl1 afianl bblJ U~11l1 n1aU~Vl1aV1 ~VUJ1 na3-lU~l

n1jUjVl1jfjjniDlUrJJ71111bull

1ja bbna3-l11l1 marlPl ma~J 1j ~ Q Ci ~

ll1tJVlllbVlVl 1llfibVl1l~

~ r ll1-J11JiOl-J~nMru bf)tJ~VlJ(l

~ rll1-J11JiOl~Vlllfi VIf)~ bnM~

ll1tJru~n~ flf)llL1JltIS q

IlL cI ~ Q IlL

ll1-J11JVlflllltJ M~(l

~ q

ll1tJVl1l~ b1ltJllt1

ll1tJLVlll~tJ VlllbVi-JIJ IJ

ll1tJnVl~1tJVlfi mll~ll bull q

ll1tJ1l11m VIll~~ IJ q

ell Q ~ I ~

ll1m~f)-J1-JVI rI~f)-Jru~-JrI

17 ~Fl 2525 218

16 VlrI 2522 247

22 ntJ 2519 252

17 nrI 2523 242

6 fiFl 2527 286

31 ~rI 2529 267

15 ijrI 2509 239

12 1rI 2527 261

17 VlrI 2527 266

4 ~Fl 2508 285

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

un~

)~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

~bfllM

I ~bfllM

~bfllM

10

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 14: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

~1~lJVl ~-X~U~~I~J

11 9 j1fl 2523 238 Vi LPllj48223180334 WltJJ ~Wj1 lJ ru LeltJd-J

q ~

2859 nY1 2518 Vi LPlljWll~ 1J Pl1Wfl~ bj1~mll14822318034012

9 j1fl 2521 241Wll~IJ~d-JVld-JltJ bj11W Vi LPllj4822318034313 18 ntJ 2525 23114 48223180344 WltJ~rJ~~ ~d-Jd-JW1 Vi LPlM

5 j1fl 2519 282 Vi LPllj15 48223180345 Wll~~nVl~ rlelWLL(9ll

1 ~fl 2518 274 Vi LPllj16 48223180350 WltJ~~wJlJ mu~Y1 ~Vli

17 48223180352 WltJM melLVlW 28 Ld-JtJ 2510 346 Vi LPlljq q

18 48223180356 Wll~IJeld-J~fj1lJ mield-J)bjJbjJl 10 ~fl 2529 288 Vi LPllj

19 48223180361 WltJellWrJwJlJ Ud-Jd-Jl 26 d-Jfl 2526 323 Vi LPlljq

10pound1148223180365 WllelelWlln(9l ~d-JflJell 24 Ld-JtJ 2514 32720 Vi LPllj

21 48923180131 WllVid-JVim bJVl 25 iJfl 2508 252 Vi LPllj

_QtrQ Q

50233180350 Wll~IJVlPlWtJ LeltJd-JPl~22 15 nY1 2524 300 Vi LPllj

23 50233180401 WltJmnj1 MVllV11b1J 23 nY1 2521 293 Vi LPllj

24 50233180403 Wll~IJnt1)d-Jt1 llln1l1 9 Y1fl 2523 294 Vi LPllj q

25 6 Ld-JtJ 2523 316 Vi LPlM

26 50233180405 WltJflDnm ~IU~~l11 25 Y1fl 2528 292 Vi LPlljq

27 50233180406 WltJ~n~~Weuro J~nwt~1l1 11 ~fl 2524 285 Vi LPllj

28 50233180407 Wll~WVlfii~1 LlLVld-J 4 ntJ 2525 293 Vi LPllj

29 50233180408 Wll~IJlI~Y1~ LVid-JY1t1 7 ntJ 2526 331 Vi LPllj q

30 50233180411 Wll~IJ~~~mt1 ~1lLmj 8 ntJ 2522 312 Vi LPlljlt19 q

31 50233180412 Wll~IJ~t1111111~~ UWVlLLY1l 7 Dfl 2524 286 ViLPllj

32 50233180413 Wll~IJlVI1d-J1Pl VllJVld-JM 7 ntJ 2506 255 Vi LPlljq

33 50233180416 Wll~IJnr~Vl1Wrul Jl~L~m 25 j1fl 2526 259 Vi LPllj

lt19 ~

34 50233180417 Wll~IJCW~W1J (9lJl~Jll 20 Ld-JtJ 2529 279 Vi LPllj

lt19

35 50233180418 Wll~IJCW~Y1~ LLVlWd-JCW 15 d-Jfl 2530 230 Vi LPllj

36 50233180419 Wll~IJ (9lt1 ~ (9l elllell~bjJ 3 ntJ 2526 261 Vi LPllj

37 WltJbj1~f[fllJ ~)d-Jt150233180421 12 Y1tJ 2524 264 Vi LPlljq

38 50233180422 Wll~IJVl~~PliJcl WWVl~n~nWt1l~ 4 Y1tJ 2518 288 Vi LPlM Q ~cv tr

39 50233180423 Wll~IJVlY1J~~CW f1~lIW[fl 6 Y1fl 2519 299 Vi LPllj

40 50233180424 Wll~IJLVl1m tJPlLl 21 ntJ 2525 281 Vi LPllj

41 50233180425 Wll~IJWY1fj1l1 Vint1 24 nY1 2529 295 Vi LPlljq

42 50233180427 Wll~IJW1l~1cl ~t1J 22 ~fl 2524 324 Vi LPlljq

43 50233180431 Wll~IJU~lllfj1lJ ll~Vli 26 iJf1 2517 268 Vi LPllj

44 50233180432 WllUJIlYiY1cl LLrl)re)W 20 nfl 2517 251 Vi LPlljq

I 17 Ld-JtJ 2525[ 290 1__ Y1_LPl_lj_

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 15: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

~1 ~U~ ~~~tJ~~Il1J llEJ

LtI abbna3Jj1l1n1a~ ~ maoKd1tI 7 ~r1 2522 281 YL~~46 50233180434 Inl~IJtJtJJ~~ru 111~~(ijJWD1Vll

27 ~tJ 2516 340 YL~~47 50233180436 Wl1~IJ~rurul9l1 V111n~I1

48 4 Dr1 2527 275 YL~~50233180439 Wl1~IJ~IEJ~ru ~I~~ q q q

287Wl1~IJL~JVl LEJtJd-J~~EJEJ 1 ~tJ 2524 YL~~49 50233180440

15 V1r1 2527 309 YL~~50233180444 WltJ~oJtJ ~1~IP1n~50 A IV tr Q

22850233180445 27 ~r1 2516 YL~~51 Wl1~IJJJllV1~ V1WM~

9 ~tJ 2520 246 YL~~

24 d-Jr1 2516 34353 50233180447 YL~~

54 50233180448 15 ~r1 2512 272WltJ~mVlll LLrlJd-JbW~d-JtJ YL~~ q

50233180449 27 d-Jr1 251955 WltJ~d-JU~ LLVllb~l1 290 YL~~

WltJ~UW ururu~llJ56 50233180450 28 Ld-JtJ 2524 309 YL~~ q ~

57 50233180453 Wl1~IJ~nrubU1 r11lJW 22 V1tJ 2529 278 YL~~ q QI IV q

58 50233180457 Wl1~IJEJn111 llL~m 16 ~tJ 2525 321 YL~~

59 50233180458 Wl1EJ~V1tJ V11~M 4 nV1 2510 312 YL~~

60 50233180462 WII ~1JE)1~tJ1 nEJWd-J ru 8 nV1 2528 309 YL~~

61 50233180464 Wl1~IJLV1JJnru ~EJIIld-J 7 ~tJ 2522 321 YL~~

lVtr cI lVtr

62 50233180467 Wl1~IJ~yenlI~l9lW tJI LtJtJIV1WD 1 Dr1 2523 279 YL~~ q

50233180468 Wl1~I(HEJd-JEJ~ ~WV1fV1~M63 4 nr1 2521 302 YL~~

64 50233180469 Wl1~IJ~WDW1 VlEJn 1n~I 17 V1tJ 2519 269 YL~~

65 50233180470 Wl1~IJJl~W1 n~IYd-JltJ 2 d-Jr1 2528 376 YL~~ Qcr Q tr

66 50933180327 WltJEJJlllIl9l ~~I1~I~ 10 V1tJ 2525 286 YL~~

67 12 nV1 2514 366 YL~~

68 27 V1r1 2526 232 YL~~

69 50033180109 Wl1~IJ~d-Jruyenl1 ~ltJ~EJWld-J 29 V1tJ 2528 323 YL~~q

Q Ocr tr70 506331801 07 Wl1~IJ LlWl~1 r11~1~ 2 ntJ 2529 242 YL~~

71 50633180158 Wl1~IJ~d-Jl~ LLrlJbV1 22 ntJ 2522 251 YL~~q

72 50633180166 Wl1~IJEJ1~tJ1 UJV1WD 27 Dr1 2522 256 YL~~

tV trclcllV tr73 50633180169 WltJlnm~~ru LEJtJd-JMm~ 8 V1r1 2529 299 YL~~

74 50633180174 Wl1fiWtJlWvl lIWnWn 28 nr1 2513 339 YL~~q

A lSlV tr75 50633180181 WltJMLVlll LLV1l~d-Jml9lW 14 19lA 2521 337 YL~~q

76 50633180182 Wltll9lEJI ~W~EJW 24 Ld-JtJ 2508 331 YL~~ 77 50633180183 Wl1~IJtJV1W d-J~lI 30 ~r1 2516 317 YL~~q q

78 50633180185 Wl1~IJ~1runJ1 Y~l9l~lld-JV1~ 25 ~r1 2524 297 YL~~ ~ q

79 48723180213 Wl1~IJ~~~1 d-JWlJ~JlW 6 19lr1 2520 254 YL~~q

Q Q AlV tr 80 148723180214 1WltJ~IJlJl9l l~1L~~~~rutJ V1_L~_~_I 11 d-JtJ 2518 250 1__

1

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 16: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

~1~iJ~ J~~UJ~1~d

Q ~ Q Q tf

81 48723180223 U1tJElJJCl~VIfi V1[1b~tJI~1fl 9 ntJ 2518 258 ~bP11=t

82 48823180125 U11~1dm~l=t1 miEllbbfld 13 ~fl 2525 347 ~bP11=t

83 48823180126 U11UU(9l(9l1 WEl~(9lEln 12 nVi 2521 306 ~bP11=t 84 48823180127 u1tJ~fiVilPl UUVIEII 23 VitJ 2501 258 ~bP11=tq

85 ltV 48823180 128 U11~1dElJVItJ (9lElUm1~ 5 nVi 2527 295 ~bP11=t

ltV

86 48823180139 U11~1d~Vi[lJ1 b~EIIbb~U 18 Vifl 2526 258 ~bP11=t q

87 ltIi48823180141 U11~1dl1Jru bVillJ~ 9 ilfl 2519 265 ~bP11=t

88 48823180150 U1tJViJVilPl tJlU1ViJdlPl 15 ~tJ 2511 304 ~bP11=t

89 48823180151 U11~1dflrJJ1(9l1 ViJ~t~1l1 3 ~fl 2527 255 ~bP11=t

50833180171 U11E1J~1 lEl~iJum 90 3 VitJ 2514 359 ~bP11=t o dl Q tf

91 50833180218 U1tJmUdtJ bJEII~1V1 27 fifl 2524 343 ~bP11=t

92 50933180303 U1tJn[l~Vil bn(9l~1(9l 24 ilfl 2515 362 ~bP11=t

93

50933180306

25 b~tJ 2515 284 ~bP11=t

94 9 b~tJ 2505 303 ~bP11=t

95 15 VitJ 2518 296 ~bP11=t QI CV Q rr

96 50933180307 U1tJfidlllltJ ViJ~1V1 15 nfl 2519 311 ~bP11=t ltV ltIi

97 50933180308 U11~1dUDnJ iJdbVil 10 ilfl 2523 266 ~bP11=t ltV

98 50933180309 U11~1dVi JVIVitJ n~(9lnJtJ11 11 nVi 2525 277 ~bP11=t

99 50933180310 U11~1dViJYiVi~ UdVIEll 31 ~fl 2518 333 ~bP11=t QI rr QI tf

100 50933180311 U11~1dVillJ111Jru ViUfi~lI 16 ~tJ 2527 282 ~bP11=tq

QI QI Q rr101 50933180312 U1tJlld[l 1lVIJd1rulltJ 14 b~tJ 2515 325 ~bP11=t

102 50933180315 U1tJmJtJI bb~1~VIt 4 nfl 2508 365 ~bP11=t

103 50933180316 U11bJru n~~1J 16 [Ifl 2521 298 ~bP11=tlJ

104 25 ~tJ 2509 257 ~bP11=t

105 50933180319 U11~1d1Uj~1 jyen[II1 30 [I fl 2528 296 ~bP11=t

106 50933180320 U1tJ~1 m UnViJ1UiJru 4 nVi 2515 365 ~bP11=tq ~

107 50933180321 2 ~tJ 2525 302 ~bP11=t

108 4 ~tJ 2528 337 ~bP11=t

109 50933180323 U11~1d~ll1~1P1 bb~UVIEII 16 ~fl 2528 291 ~bP11=tq

ltV

110 50933180325 U11~1d~1l1J[IU VidlVIEll 20 ~fl 2527 281 ~bP11=tq

111 50933180328 U1111Jru~VIfi dJJlVIJbll1dtJll1 9 nfl 2504 276 ~bP11=t

112 51933180217 U11~1db~~d~ ~UVIf~dJJrutru 7 fifl 2520 249 ~bP11=t q

113 50R33180105 U11~1dl1rJJrJJ1 P11~1U1 15 nVi 2527 314 ~bP11=t

LtJ ~ bbn nJii1l1 n1~11 ~Vl1 ~fi~nl bbll U-IIii1l1 n1~jruf ~

QI tr OQ(f

1 114 150233210111 1U11~1dUI~nl=tru lEl~m~1V1 Vi

1 22 ~fl 2529 203 1___bP1_l=t_ 1

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 17: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

__

~1~1JV1 ~~~U~~Ild

bJ a bbn aJJ11l1 m aJ~Vlla fian OJ bblJ UI11l1 nlacUru=il

115 50233210133 Wl1~Idd~~rw~ ~()1V1t1 12 ~~ 2529 230 ~bPl~

116 50233210203 Wl1~Idn~IW1 ~~~1 30 ~~ 2526 274 ~bPl~

117 50233210205 Wl1~IdVi~flr ~1d 27 ~t1 2528 356 ~bPl~

118 50233210206 Wl1~IdbUruiOlJJ1Pl ~fll~ 23 ~~ 2523 268 ~bPl~~

5023321021 0 Wl1~Id~JJ m~ VIdn~ 28 n~ 2502 245 ~bPl~119

120 50233210213 Wl1~Id~1VEll ~W~t1 29 iLfigtl 2521 323 ~bPl~

121 50233210214 Wl1~IdflWI~ ~flfl~n~nr 31 iL~ 2524 316 ~bPl~

122 5023321 0216 Wlt1~n~Vlfi lt

~W~ln 16 il~ 2520 296 ~bPl~

123 5023321 0325 Wl1~JJl~ bbddiOlun 9 n~ 2517 329 ~bPl~

124 50833210105 Wl1~IdWfll~~ u()() 9 ~tI 2522 265 ~bPl~

125 50833210116 Wl1~IdmHiln1f u~b~1i~Vlf 1 D~ 2529 270 ~bPl~dl

QcI Q tr

126 5083321 0120 Wl1~Id b~Id () MM~iOlWVI~ 21 bJJtI 2522 233 ~bPl~

127 50833210121 Wl1~Idd1Ml bbrld~~I1 17 il~ 2520 270 ~bPl~ ltV

128 50933210114 iOllflln1Plbflm~blm ud~n 28 bJJtI 2527 228 ~bPl~ ltV ltV 129 50933210115 Wl1~IdW1lrwi()1 dl~~ 23 n~ 2528 348 dl ~bPl~

130 50933210116 Wl1~Id~~JJfl~nr ()1~D 1 JJ~ 2524 291 ~bPl~

131

50933210117 Wl1~nfl~nr itl~m 21 ntI 2515 258 ~bPl~

132 48033210104 Wl1~Id1l1llfll ~1bbllJJ 5 D~ 2518 208 ~bPl~

bhbbnaJJ11l1 maU~VllafianOj bblJ UI11l1 ma[)Cl1 (lbull 133 46023220147 Wlt11l~ViIcl 1l1~~JJlWWvl 22 n~ 2528 253 un~

134 48223220205 Wl1~IdbiOlW~n tJW~W 26 ntI 2528 300 ~bPl~

lJ

135 48223220214 Wl1~IdUPl~W n1ruiOlW~~ll~ 18 ntI 2519 271 ~bPl~

136

~

48223220222 Wl1~Id~W1IJl~ Ul~~~JJ 30 ~~ 2514 325 ~bPl~dl

137 48223220223 Wl1~Id~nrurul ~fllflr 19 ~figtl 2527 290 ~bPl~

138

q QI QI q

50223220118 Wl1~Id~JJ~() bboi~11~ 7 ~~ 2523 275 ~LPl~

139 49R33220114 Wl1~Id~~I~1 ~JJ()fln1~ 13 n~ 2522 267 ~bPl~

140

50R23220149 Wl1~Idn1W~il lJ~tIt~fiWWvl 19 n tI 2524 350 ~bPl~

bj a bbn aJJ11l1nl aU~Vllafian OJ bblJ UI11l1 m aU~VllaVI fYl m naJJ U H~bull bull

141 47123230264 Wl1~Id~lfll d~~rwflrdlVlfll 7 ntI 2528 229 ~bPl~

142 48223230139 Wl1~IdMlfn JJl~tI 1 iL~ 2517 226 ~bPl~ lt io

143 48223230204 Wlt11l1WWVI (Jl bb()1 22 ~figtl 2508 224 ~bPl~

144 4822323021 0 Wl1~Id1lWblJn 11 ~~JJJJ1 3 ~ tI 2529 329 ~bPl~

145 48223230215 Wlt1fllWWvl tlln 10 bJJtI 2526 259 ~bPl~

146 48223230219 Wl1~Id1J5lrulYl ~1~fll 9 ~~ 2527 257 cd Q Q Q

I 147 148223230220 1_W_l_1_~_Id_~_~_rw_J_n_rw_~ 1 15 ~tI 2515 315 ~_b_Pl_~_--J11

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 18: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

bull bull

bull bull

~1~UYl ~~~iJ~~1~J

L11 a bbn a3J1ll1 m alJ~Vl1afiantO bblJ lJJ1ll1 malJ~Vl1 aV1~Vltl1 n a3JlJ~~

148 48223230221 W11~1JllWnrWi1 ~~1W 10 VL~ 2525 267 VhPll=t

149 48223230223 322W1tJJ~pYmr m~uru 13 ntJ 2522 ~bPll=t ~

CIt _ I ==I

150 48223230224 297W1tJVl~~lltJ WWbn~tJI 21 b~tJ 2511 ~bPll=t

151 48223230226 W11~1J1~f(ll1 nWlVlfl 25 VltJ 2520 260 ~bPll=t

152 48223230231 W11~1JVlll~ Pl~Vl1U(l~ 28 b~tJ 2524 216 ~bPll=t

153 48223230232 W11 l~1l1 Vlf1fPl~ 1 n~ 2508 341 ~ bPll=t

154 48223230236 W1mmtJItJ Pl VIWellVlll=t 24 ~A 2523 252 ~bPll=t cv ==I IIV Clt

155 50233230149 W11~1Jn~mru lltJVlbi91ll 10 Vl~ 2528 247 ~bPll=t

156 49E33230212 W11~1Jh~ru1ru rl1V1i1tJ 22 VltJ 2526 295 ~bPll=t

157 28 Vl~ 2515 316 ~bPll=t

158 50E33230136 W11il1l1Vl~ J1illl~ 19 n tJ 2513 336 ~ bPll=t

L11 a bbn a3J~ll1 n1alJ~Vl1afian to bblJ lJJ1ll1 Ael3J oW blPlel ffiantO

159 48123490225 W1tJ~1~~ mrl11~(lf 3 ntJ 2529 210 iJn~

160 50133490158 W11~1J bn Pl1WVlf Ji~1tJ 8 Vl~ 2528 216 iJn~

161 46223490207 W1tJnW~Vl VlfVl~iJ~b~1~ 15 ~~ 2514 326 ~bPll=t09

162 48223490260 W1tJ~~pYn~ n~W9WVlf 11 ntJ 2529 204 ~bPll=t

163 48223490309 W11~1JVl~Vl1WVlf bbrlJ~1~~ 2 Vl~ 2522 219 ~bPll=t

164 48223490401 W11~1Jm11l1 ~J~~ru~1~ 31 fi~ 2526 301 ~bPll=t

165 48223490405 W11~1JIiil1~J~~ru Vl~1u1fn 26 n~ 2527 225 ~bPll=t 166 48223490406 W11~1JIiil~Vl~ bb~1~ru 5 ~~ 2527 216 ~bPll=t

167 48223490407 rl1belmlWru~1~ ~1llhtJ 28 nVl 2527 252 ~bPll=t

168 48223490412 W11~1JWVlf(ll1 b~elnVlell1u 25 n~ 2527 236 ~bPll=t

169 48223490414 W1tJW1Vl ~W~ 11 VltJ 2527 217 ~bPll=t

170 48223490417 W1tJVllpYn ~ iW~ 2 ~~ 2514 283 ~bPll=t

171 48223490419 W11~1J~ll1WVlf il~bi91ll 22 ~~ 2525 213 ~bPll=t

172 48223490421 W1tJ~~n ~WVlfVlell 23 fi~ 2524 278 ~bPll=t

173 48223490422 W1tJ~l=tru W1~ilM 17 ~~ 2522 215 ~bPll=t

174 48223490423 W11~1J~rWm ~~blltJ 24 VltJ 2527 293 ~bPll=t

175 48223490424 W11~1JtJJi9I n~l=tru1~WJ~ 25 (l~ 2521 292 ~bPll=t

Q176 48223490427 W11~1Jn (l~ bb~1J rull 14 VltJ 2528 230 ~bPll=t

177 48223490441 CWltJ~~LL91~ tJJ~JruP11 5 ~~ 2518 212 ~bPll=t

178 48223490443 W11~1J~el~11iil Iiillfn 21 ntJ 2524 247 ~bPll=t

179 49233490340 W11~1J~tJ1WVlf Vl~~Vl1~1 30 b~tJ 2530 225 ~bPll=t

180 50233490245 W11~1J~llll1rWi1 Vlell~WVlf 8 fi~ 2527 318

CVoClt (iQ ltr QI 181 150233490254 I W11Jll~WVl~ el~JII=t

I 1__19 ~~ 2523 294 Vl_bPl_l=t_ 1

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 19: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

~-X~tl~~~1rld

~1~UYl

182 5023349030 1 W1tJl~rlJ iW~ItJ q ~

183 50233490302 W1l~1dnrllVlnJlnl1 th~l q

184 50233490305 W1l~1dUrurlWl~ D~~~dlA q ~

Icr tr Q

185 50233490308 W1l~1d~lVlVm dWbVltJW q

186 50233490310 Q evtr pound

W1l~1ddJl1~11W All~VlD

187 50233490311 W1l~1dbbdd111 htJtJ~

188 50233490312 W1l~1d md~~ru ~~bll q

189 50233490315 W1l~1dl1M1 bbndb~~

190 50233490316 W1tJl1~I1~ AWb

191 50233490317 W1tJ~1WdtJ iWul

192 50233490319 W1l~l1n WWVl~I1~

193 50233490320 CW1tJ~fi~~i ~f)~~ q

194 50233490321

195 50233490322

W1l9l911 U~ruM lJ

196 50233490323 W1l~1del~Vld~~ru l~htl1W

197 50233490325 W1ltl~~Jl1Vl~ lrhn (lJ

198 50233490326 W1l~1d(1dtl~~n1tJ nWVl~~m

199 50533490154 W1l~1dlU~1 1J1W~li q

17 DA 2513 295 ~bPjj

21 ~A 2526 309 ~bPjj

27 VltJ 2525 271 ~bPjj

17 DA 2523 272 ~bPjj

3 nA 2527 286 ~bPjj

28 VlA 2524 361 ~bPjj

15 iJ~ 2531 317 ~bPjj

22 ntJ 2528 296 ~bPjj

27 I1A 2527 299 ~bPjj

29 (lA 2528 265 ~bPjj

28 iitJ 2528 285 ~bPjj

5 ntJ 2527 314 ~bPjj

29 ~A 2518 333 ~bPjj

2 nVl 2525 303 ~bPjj

15 ~A 2524 242 ~bPjj

19 ~A 2520 308 ~bPjj

24 ~A 2525 318 ~bPjj

17 I1A 2527 304 ~bPjj

d ~vJ- -oJilllll W1tJVlbUtJW

1UJlml1~

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 20: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

rru=illjtJ~lUJU~~1bi~n1iP1n~1 l1l11~il1mjrru=il QI ~ IU QI

l-JvI1fjYltJ1~m1DnJ)lf1tJlfll mcl 1U~~ml-J~1~tJ tlWl 91v11~tJVJl-JjJ1il

1UVl18 ~l-JJl1rUlf 2553

hhLLmlJilll

~i1UilttmqjCl

mCCllilrLnJr~iilJl-I

oBui1u 1 oBui1u 2

mCCllilr

~i11JmCCl

mCC11Y1 mCClLiln

tTnAnHl1l1flflLflH

JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ 1118 c1)~ JI18 c1)~ ~l1J JI18 c1)~ ~l1J 1118 c1)~ ~l1J

nl1utyii

iUJ

l W

iUJVI~~U

- - - ~ - - -shy ----shy ----shy -_-----__-shy -shy --------shy -__--_ _--shy ------shy --_ ----------shy -----------shy ---shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-_ - __---------- ---__-_ __ - --_-shy

i1HiliHlU llili1jli1YllU ~ n~fllllill

d tL- ~~ illlffl UlfJY1lUfJU

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 21: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

11blJ~ ntJ~tl ~~1 b~l n 1i~ mn~ b~Wtl~Jl1~vn~VltJ1 ~tJ nllJl]rJ1~tJtl~lnrnr

lItltlW~n1i1~mrunJ111lli ~ ~

~~1~VltJ1~m1llJl]rJ 1~tJtl~lnnw 1WYl~JJi~n~utlwf ~l~~~UVl~Ii1U tJn1i~m~n 2552

tlW~~~n1i~m~1b~tl~W~ 18 n~Jl1~Wfi 2553 bull q

UibJlVl ~bb WWo i~~Ui~1rlrJ~1~JJVl lltl - W1~~n~ ~W b~tlW tJ bn ~ q rn~m~nbU~tJ

1 150223600211

JJfljYfJJnJVlPl

bUabbn~JJ1li1m~UqJ~

I W1l~~~Jl1 b~tlUi~l I

19 fi~ 2508 354 yh~jj

d ~llltl

ll irJl ~tlJJ bb~ ll irJl Vl1Wbl n lltll bb~ rJ

JlA __ vI~ V__-

W1tJVlbJJtJW

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 22: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

iJrunll~UmiddothlJllJ~-dlL~lm~PinHl lIlmiddotln1lilf~u~fl1l1lJfl1l1j]f ~ II IIU 019

~ll1JYlm ~mlllnJ) 1fltJflflmnW1WWj1Jj~j11tJ c1Wl ~1jr) l1ltJYJ~fi1n

00 oltl 00 r )WYl 18 fJW11WWfi 2553

ll 1J 11111

1~~Urll1m()()1

m () () 1 fjrLilJ1~ urJlJ

1lW~U 1 1lW~U 2

ill() () 1~ir

1~Um()()1

m()()llVl mC1jC1j1Lrln

111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 111rJ VI~~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ 111rJ Vlcij~ 1llJ

rnP1nHlmfl~LIlH

n1nJnfl~l~n1N1ilJ

ith~millJf11i1~

UI

to ~

UJVH~U

-------shy -shy --shy ---shy ~ - - - - - -- shy - -shy -----------shy

------------shy ---shy - ----shy ----------shy ----shy ---shy -----------shy ----shy

------shy1

1

1

1

1

1

-----------shy

--------shy --------shy - - ---_shy1

1

1

----shy1

1

1

~iliHH)ULLa~1ililY11lJ fI n~81nil

d jLA--- J~ q

alll8 lJ1UY1LUUlJ

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 23: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

U1J~~1tJ~El~~rll~ln1~~m~n~l~kEl~1l1~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ1~tJEl~jnnw lIElElk~~n1~1~mruru1U[Pl~Uru~[Pl

q ~ ~

~I-11~YItJ1~m1nnlJ 1~tJEl~j nnw 1kY1~~~~~n~1J~wl ~jl-1t)~lJvJ~D1t1 tJn1~~m~n 2552

Elk~~eJ~n1~~mj1l~Elt)k~ 18 n~1l1~kfi 2553 q q

d0 v ~~~1J~~1~J~1~1JIl nEl - k1~~n~ t)k l~Elk tJln~

q

f~l1ipfl~tJpfl~ PliUru-n Pld-9

1Uibbniaj1l1 n1iU n AiPln1Pll ~W

1 1485231001651 k1ml-1~1 ~El1~~~tJ 30 DI 2501 I

~~j~El tu--_ ~____ k1tJIldJtJk

I~llkk d

Vu~tJ

228

1J~lllll v ltil

kn njj-1

vhjjshy

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 24: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

U1d~ntJ~El~~1b~9n1~~mt1~b~klEl~fl1d-ln1V1tJ1~m1llJliJl1~tJEl~~mru lJElEl~d-l~n1~1xm1d 11 ~1tDuru4i [l

d-ln1V1tJ1~tJnllJliJl1~tJEl~~mru 1kl~~tJ~d-l~1~iJ6d-JJl ~~Vl1(9iiJVjd-lfi1il Un1~~n1t1 2552

~ cS ~lVQ cv~

Elkld-l[leJ~n1~n1t1bd-lmklV1 18 nd-lfl1~klfi 2553 q q

- 1 shy

ltdj0 ~ col ~bbklkl iJ~bflV1

~1(9itJV1 ~~~iJ~911ll llEl - kl1d-lM~ 1kl b~Elkl Ubn(9i col q b1l~tJ in~n1t1

f~tIiP(1~IJ P(1~tiIiDJ MniIru-ntil d-9 bull

~11J1ij1l1r~Ua~1I1~U1I1CllP1

3501 1498733302221 kl1tJiJ~blr Vl1f[lr~~~ I 22 bd-JtJ 2504 ~b1t

[l~l9 ~EltJ bb~[l~l9V11klbln ~fN bb~l

d J -I - - rr-shy col

~~llEl fV-shy__ kl1tJVlbtJtJkl

4et et

I1lJ1vm lV1VTUYfU1i

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 25: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

bull bull

CVQ cs vlCi urI

0J~V1NtlfllmiddotHmill1JY1 18 flUfllVJ1) 2553

bull OJ

tllVllJYI lti 110 - Jl~tIfltlbull

j f

I101Y1tllJVJ1) f

fll iVlV~VItI~ INti IV i

1 11 C QJ r

W1EJ jI1f1W lJl11jVlWffQ~ 1 0 1VlM P11JEl~NUllf1JlfUmf1mUElP1ElUlJUlJEl~ Vw ~ I1EllJ~JMUnjfllj1~mL~~

~YJJUl dl~IJElMmrutJ~ 6

QlJlJVl 1 LP1ElU 1Jmlf11J -

L1J1J11JU 2554

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 26: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

middotmiddot- W

~1Ujljf)lj ffmlJWl)mt~~~1lJW11VlL o~-crocr(1)o(1)b fllfJlW (j)(1)(j) 1mffli o~-crocr(1)o(1)b

Vi 1l (()~ff) lflJcicilflJ 1uVi 0Ul iWJ1mJ~ampamp~ dItjC)~ tt~~f11i~~~YlJ1[ W 11ifflil)mb~~~1lJW111~fJtJ~~fljW

fftmJWl)[1 bb~~1~1JJ Wl IJtJtt ~~ N~flliYi llitu lm1ml~ilfJ~1Wflli 1)fJ b~tJ~~~Ymf1 W 11ifflil)fJ

U~~1~1lJW11 IJtJ~rf)fhnJ1i~~U1J5U1tlllmf) ~ V11W fitJ llftW l~tJ~lf~ll b~tJ~ lhd1Vl1hl111f)liri~bff5~ u u

f)liMVlU1VlfJ - ~U lhl 2544 - 2549 U~~ lh~l1ffU ml1f~lfff1fl b~tJl ll~~ MlJtJ~~Wllf~lfWfl1f1bI1UtJ Cj q CJ

PI tJW UW IJtJ~ 111 fJ m1fl11~1)m~tJlil1 Jlfuf)1iY l1i tu -II ~ ~~ ~1~ ~1~ iW 11i ~1i 1)m b~~1~1lJW 1 ~I111Vl fJl ~fJ

illfnf]11(lfJtJ~~fljcl 1U11i~UimllrUt1w11l~ b ~lJU~ (j) (~fljlfl~ - b~fJ1fJW ~ampampd)

(~l51fJfl1ffPIi1 l1i vm ~ll~~ mp1i ~f]flf~BWUU~l)

lJ iitu 115 f)li 11i~1i l)m b~ ~1~1JJ W1 11~fJtJ(l~fljW

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 27: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

The Veto Power ofthe Community Leaders in the Upper Northern Part Of Thailand

1)1 lt ~ lt 2) ~ 1 3) ~ d 4)1 ~ ~ u~IlilU lJI11HlUffflll 4tyllU lllfl 1iff~ lJlJHJU lJ~lllJ u1Jl~HU lllillllUb

I) Pravej Maharattanasakul 2) Boonton Dongthaisong 3) Irnron Maluleem 4) Piyawan Lertpanich

OJ

lJYIfI~poundJij

cg ~QJ ~ e1 d cg QJ j) 910 I d

fllj f1flEJ 11l VfI j ~ W 11] W flljf1flEJ 1 VH1~ 1PlIJ tl~ VlW 1lflJ IfW fll fllI1lHJPl tlW UW IJ tl~ iVw lJU

QJ I ~~cg dcg 1 ~ 1910 I 1Pl tllJ j ~ ff ~ fll W tlf1flEJ 1(1 )flW 11

QJ

flEJ W~ i1W ~lJj ~ ff ~ fI IJ tl~ fl1j llJ W VlW 1lflJ IfWfllflll1 W tl Pl tlW UW q q cu q

(2)tJ j ~ lfl i1 fll1~ ~W llflJ IfW ~ ~ ~i1 TIW 11 ~ tlfll j flTl1 W ~ W 1 V1J1 viif 1111 ~ fll j U~111j j llffll j IJ tl ~ U q

gtI

i] U111 (3)U i11J1i1 ~W 1GJrlJ IfW 1W fll j~PJJW 1GJrlJ IfW 1l11jlJ II ~ ~ l~tl ~ tl fl1j ~PJJW llf1jEJ] f1 l fll j lij tl~ 1 I ~ 0 ~ ~ cl ~ lIJ1

1111 ~ ff ~ fllJ IJ tl ~ lJ j ~ li1 f1( 4 )fI11lJ 1lPl fl Pl1~ Ui11J1i1 J tl~ VlW llflJ IfW bW lflJ IfW 1IJ WI IJ ~1l11 ~ i11 blJ 1111 ~ U q

(5)W~~ 11iIJ tl~ ~W llflJ IfW fllflll1 i1tlPltlW UW ~~~ tltl1W1liif ~~~ 1l1UtJj ~ffj~fitlm~U1W flljU q

d 9J j)o 910 QJ ~ QJ 1 1~ ~o IjVWjIJtl~VlW1 fll1~VlW1 flljl~fllj fijjmfl1J111U11~flljWPJJW1lflJlfW PlVW11~ PlIJtl~VlW1lflJlfW

cu cu cu q cu q

~~~ tl~lW Hi] 1~W 1l1UtJj ~llJ gtI gtI

fllji ~voW 1~W fllji ~VflWfllW lPlV1offUUUbYlJfllEJ WI~~fl bYlJfllEJW~W llflJlfWi1~I1lJPl 108 q U q

fIW tJj~fltluIi1VUflflljlijtl~V1tl~~W 36 fIW illuW ~1mUD1W 36 fIW1l11~mjlJflljl1~D1W36 fIW U ~ U

~ ~~IiWWU~ Il~~tl i tJif (1) ~W llflJlfWlitl~~ fI11lJ 1j11 l fI11lJIi tl~ flljIJtl~lflJlfW i111l11~W U q q

uuumh~~~U11~~tl~l~tlfl11lJ 1~W fij jlJ1 W flljiflmVl11tJj~ 1Vlfl1JeJ~lflJlfW (2) ~ flljW l11~fl U q

fijjmfi1J111m1off1Wf1lflljJtl~lflJlfW (3) ~W1lflJlfW~ 2tJj~lfli1 tJj~lfli1mflfitl ~W1lflJlfW~ q cu q cu q

fl~lW 1U11 ~11l11tl fllff1l1tJj~lf1lfW ~d1W middothlJ1 Wfllj~PJJW11 fl Hfllj~ 1~l JtJ~JflJlfW tJj~lfli1~

fftJ~ fitJ~W llflJ IfW ~ illffW 1Il1 W fllj~ PJJW llflJ IfWIJ tJ~ PlW ltJ~ (4) f1W 61~ VW ~V~~ illlVl V~W tJ 1 W flljcu q q cu cu

tJiUtJj~lflJlfW (5) tJ1WflljI~VW~i~llfi I1tJm~llV~111i1ji1f1l1ii1V I1U~iYtJI~lJ~V~I~Wfllj q q cu q

tJff1ji11~I~ V1 (6) II W 1f1 Pl 3DEPICOS i~W1m1offl~tJflljtJiUtJj ~lflJlfWtJj ~fltJUIi1VUW 1f1~ q q

I~V1fiU fllj~PJJW1 V1f1i11~ tJj~lf1TItJi~v lf1jEJ~f1l fllj~d1W~1lJ IJtJ~tJj~lf1lfW jtJj11f111lJf

1) ~ ~I d~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 lt9 I~lt I1M1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlHUl1llJWI1mll1Jlll1J lJI11ll1Jlll1J~lbfitJ 111Jll11~mW lUIl~mmllu(llJfi

2)3) lt1 bull ~ ~ 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt 9 illffmlllU 1Ju~il1l111fl1Jl~~u~illffUillffl~~EJtJlJWI1llJWI1mll1Jl111J lJI11TYW1111J~1bfitJ ll1JllMmW lUIl~mlJ

nlulllJtl

4) d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 lt9 1 ~ lt ~lJ~f1tl1lJ~lJWI1lTYWlll1J lJI11ll1Jl111J~lbfltJ ll1JlJll~mW lUIl~mlJ~llu(llJfi

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 28: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

2

lWJlJli i1IJ el~fi m h-J J1IJlfW i~ tJiJflljiJBJ~9l1IJU U 1f1~~~flcil1el~1~()1 ~ij~I~el1~l~J1IJl1U 1r

~~IJlI~~ Uelfl()lflUV~mJOijtJfl11IJII9lfl~H1Ul111~ViIl~ lWJUlijjIJ Vli~tJ1m flllflflEJ1

m1IJ1llJlj()1 U fllll11~1U fllj~el~IVleli9l m1IJ1~U el~Vi~~U 1J () ijtJ~hf1tu~~flcil1iJri1U 1 U

~ ~ u

flljiJiIJiJj ~IJl9lj il1U IJel~l1IJl1U u~~i1H~~elm1IJ~11~()j11m~tll YI~1IJ el~U itJtI1tJiillJl~ 1U flljq ltiii q dI8

tJ m ~~IJIJl9l j il1U fllj m el~~ U el~ iJj ~l11l1U el~l~ 1 j ~9llIJ m1IJ~11 ~ ()IJ el~U itJIJl tJ~U el ~nIJ

~ ~

3J 3J bull I lt 3J ~I i dol m1IJ1el~fl~el~ flIJ m1IJ9l el~fllj IJel ~lJ j ~ l11l1U fl m 1fleltll llJ U U tJtl1tJVl fll YIU ~ ()lfl1lU flm~ ()~

11)131 1 1 d 3J lfJ QliY 310 ddo QlJ IQI 3J IJl11lJj~l11l1UlJm1IJ9lel~flljel~ j (7) ~~~ 9lIJel~fU1J1IJl1UVlIJ9lelel1U1()j~IJUel~flIJm1IJflm

IJel~ ~U 1J1IJl1U ~ ()~ 1 lit~U cent)1tJnlJfl1i~ ~ lJfllXel~Uel~l~lmr 1~ 11~~(8) ~i1 ~ ilXUel~iJj ~l11l1U

fllfllY i1el9l el U IJ U Vi iJ ~ elU itJ IJl tJIJ el~ Vl1~ j ll1fllj lcent)U1~~el elflel ~1 ~i~ l() U irIJ1l~ll~ ~U ~fl i~ IJl~

11fllJ W ~~1el ~ fl tlel~ nIJ H~ Uel ~flll fl j~ l11~ lJlcent)l~el~ 1U YI mtJm W iJ j ~l11l1U (i~ nIJ fl ci1 Ill

i~IJl~1J()~JUiJ1l11l111VlUlJel~IIJ1 i~IJl~~IJ1()lflflljl111~iJj~Yljlriel19 nUtJ1tJU ~fl 2549

1J1l1i~IJl~Uel~~ 1fllU1

ABSTRACT

The purpose of the research The veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part

of Thailand was to study (l) desirable qualities of the community leaders in the upper Northern

Part of Thailand (2) types of community leadership influence to government policies formulation

and public administration (3) roles of the community leaders who develop strength in the

community which gives support to Thai economics politics and society (4) differences in the

roles of the community leaders to strength communities and general communities and (5) the

veto power of the community leaders in the upper Northern Part of Thailand compared to the

state power The independent variables were the leaders learning processes leadership

management good governance and community development The veto power of the community

leaders against state power was a dependent variable

This study was a qualitative research The in-depth scheduled Interview method

was used The 108 respondents composed of 36 local politicians 36 Sub district leaders and 36

village committees who were interviewed in person

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 29: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

3

The findings were as follows (1) The community leaders had to understand the

needs of the community be good example and fight for justice to take care of the community

interests (2) Good governance was used in the communitys affairs (3) There were two types of

community leaders the first one was actively leading and opened opportunity for the community

to participate in developing projects while the second one was not interested in developing their

communities (4) The learning center was not adequate to improve the community (5) The

learning media such as local distribution of news stations television radio and newspapers were

a one side fonn of communication (6) The concept of 3DEPICOS was introduced to improve the

communities direction democracy economy peoples participation infonnation culture

organizations by using proactive practices to strengthen the community The differences in

locations culture resources education working perfonnances and willingness to fight for a

better living were factors affecting the communities standard as well as the central government

policy However the success of government policy must be confonned to the needs of people (7)

The veto power of the community leaders against state power depended on their community

leaders who were able to encourage a spirit of aggressiveness towards the wrong orders of the

authority (8) The upper Northern peoples veto power were against the bureaucratic policies after

the end of the Thaksin government in association with the outcomes of the dalliances as they said

that this government was not their representatives The 19th

September BE 2549 Coup

government and its followed Coup nominee government were not considered regitimate

KeyWords

Veto Power Community Leaders The Upper Northern Thailand and State Power

fl1fllMUtl91tlUUUlliwl ijrYj1~1~t1~J1t11~t1~llnj 11l1eJtl~~tlU ~1VlU ~11h~ Vl~W111Vl~

~trI~lhU I~U fJiJfl1fl~ihh d~f1l~91 t111U1U Ifltliif)QlnJ1t1I~U IJtl~ 91Ultl~ llrl~I~U ri1U l1d~

IJtl~J~UUf)lJ lijtl~ lf1Jpoundl~nlIJtl~t1J~IVlf1 iitlU~lJ~Ujnul1I-htl~ 1U r~r1~Vl1~91J ~llrl~Vl1~flmJ

r1~ 1U l~~ ~f N~J Jr111rl~l11r11t1lJ 191 r1tl~J ~t1~11r11lJtl~f)lJ~IJJU 1t1J ~l Vl f1 f)lJ~IJJU 1Yi~1U lJ l~U 1

1llJ1lU ii ri1U J11t1~IJJW 1lJ1 nutl t1~U tlVnUfl11lJ ~1lJ1J tI IJ tl~ ~U 11llJ 1lU l1iifl11lJJ tlU nU 1i1 U q qJ qJ q qJ

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 30: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

4

OJ

fllHihn tftjlJ TI fl il ~~ flll Hrt~1VlV1flljIHnUj~tVlft j11l11~ ~llhl1W m111t~W1 UlJO~ hfllnllltJ ~ ~

JJ 1 lJJ 1 JJl1 ) d lJJlllflWOmVW~ 11 tY1111HlOlilJ1V l1flW Wll1lllWtIJ1 ilOutYjjflHrt~ bOflltYVlil~VHlJW1ll1lllW l1

q q q

l~llU~~ 1lOci1~~tvhl1W r1d1d-J dJLJljJ1Jil-jm~~ 1JJLJ1~1illdJil~1-j h ~

~ )JJ JJ 0 II] ~ ~I I

flljftflm1ilV tjO~ Vlrt~ bllIJO~NW1ll1lllWfllflmWOIlOWlJWUO~bVlV il~luWllO~Vl1~ ~ q

l1 ~ -j 1 W fll j On lJl vii -j Vl ~-j 1IU O-j ~U1ll1lllW fllflmi1 Oll OW lJW ~ii~ EleJ1W1il iTI iTIlJ1rt~l~eJ1W1il ClJ q cIS cIS cu

ii 11fl1l1W IIW 1 VlJl V111 vlrl1tl1V-j1WUrt~Vllfl~lWlJO~j iU1W1vlJlv1U~flljUU 1J~ t~OmlJ ~ II OJ bull

Vl tl ~ fl n lJIJEl ~ uj ~ ll1llW 1J~ f1lJ 1 ~fltll111 1V ~WlW 1~ftj lJ i flil fllj lijO~ Hrt ~ ~~ flll 1 W ~W Vi ltll llW

l1li l1W ~U1ll1l llW 1 lH tY1I ~ Vl ~~ l1~OeJ 1W 1il iTI 1 W mwlll Urt~ Oci1~ lj l11 flll O~ fllVlIW1Vfl~1~ cu ClJ q dSI

11]_1 ~I ~I ~JJ0 Ofl bu l1 rt 1Vllll llW ~ u Wtll 0 ~ Hrt ~flllfllfl 1l111 rt

0

Hl lJ Urt ~ V~ luW fll j HtY1I ~ t1 ~ fl11111l O~fllj IJ 0 ~ q ~

Uj ~ll1llW 1 W fl iJ fl1 fl Urt ~ t~ ll1lllW j 1miWI ~Wtfl ~O~ 1V~ ii fl1111 ~ IItt rt ~ flU flj dh1 ul W Vll~ ~ q

QI 310 QI liJ1J d QIltj3Jo QIo=f

m~lJ1WflljVl PJJW 11lWm~IJO~ NW 1Hrt~Vl WlW1ll1lllW l1 tUllUIJ ~ilW tY11111t1H tY1I~Vlrt ~ bll01W1ilj TIl1j 0 ~ q ~

OJ gtJ

EJlJEJ~ lli VOllilJW 1VlJ1Vi~ TIlJ1rt l11m~ Wl1W 1VlJ1ml1~ 11Wlli t1

~ fl~ O~llOlJli jj II

il1fl fllj fYfllJ 1fl1111t~ W lllUrt ~m1111ilf1tljIJO ~ Utljl11 HW 1~ 11 Vl tllJ ~ 1j HU fljjll Hrt~ I r iI jI

~1W lijvVi ttl Vl~ O~ tY1111j t1~~ f11t1111 1 Wfllj lijV Urt~tYllll~ i1Wfllj lijm~~ih Iv ll~~u

f11t1111 1 W fllj lijv Vl ~~ 1 ~IJO~ ~U1ll1lllWfllfl m i1 OllO W lJ WU tY1I~ 0 OflO ci1~ I j~ OeJ1W 1 il ~ q

i)I ii flj ~ lJ 1W fll j 0 ci1~ h~ vh lr~U1Urt~ll1lllW iiVl ~~ 1~ eJ 1W lil i~ ~U1ll1lllW~WlW 11lW tO~_ cu q ~ cu q

0 ci1 ~ lj ii flll~ ~U1O ci1~ I j ~ ~vh 1 rllll llW VOll ilJ ~U1ll1l llW iil1 ~fl fllj ijlIfllj ll1lllW 0 ci1~ I j ~~ cu q cu q q

tY111 1j t1~Wl W 1ltllllW lrt ~ II U~~ Urt ~ ii irVl n~ il ~ VOll j lJl1~OU UttYli eJ1W 1 il ii l1 ~O lliO ciH I j OJ

j 11111~fllj UtY1I~OOfl 1 W Vll~IlOlJ 1~ UUttYlieJ1W1ili~I11 llOci1~ I j

tYllll~~lWflljlijVt~~iJjlv 1 ~U1ltllllWlWltllllW~t~llU~~iiVl~~1~eJ1W1ili~

2 ~U1ll1lllW 1 WllllllW~t~llH~~iiVl~~ 1~eJ1W1iliTI llmflfll1~U1ll1lllW ~1 IUcu q q cIlt cu q

QJ _I tetQJ

19)tJ1J1~iT-lflflTj 1ilt OJ OJ OJ

fllj lijvfli~u il~fYfllJ11 Wuj~~~W~~~O lUu

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 31: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

5

lJ1111 Ji 1lif11 J UtJl f~ lJ l~ J ~ jI 0 Gj jJ Y d ~ IQI QI

3 ~~ tJ flf)Il1lJ VIlJ1 Yl HUllilJ liU bU f11 J~ IlJ U llilJ liU 1 YfI UlJ II Ul ltJ tJ9l tJf11 J~ 1lJUl

QQ 0 Q Q QI

11Hll1Vl1lt1t1 fl111ilpoundJ

~ QI I Gj amp ~ c 0 amp ei y d d ~ tI J~lilm 11~~f11J mtJf)mmm bUf11JftmnmlU fllUl IN II Yf ~l UtJ1J ~ VI ~ tl U t)U Vf)ml UtJl

11lJU li J J lJftlU Ul tIJ~f)tJlJnlJfl1llJff~~1f)tI~tJ~nv1Uf11J ~~U VI ll Ifi1~U Vi ~lO V~l ~~tJf)1911tJfhl

OlYfl~IVlJ1V ~vllmjll~dh~U Olf6~~~ 3 iJlliltJ fltJ iJl~iltJ~iJtJlll~~iJlliltJlilVUtJlJ

J~Yf-)llOlYfl~ iJl~iltJ~~ 2 ~llJ~l ~~ 2 lilJliU ~1U1U l081911mJN (~t4llilJliU) l1l-Wl~tJl~ )I SI I I

m tJlJfl ~ lJmllJll9lf)~ 1l11l1 Ul~l~ U Vi 1l~~11lJU linlJiltJl () U (Cascio1995 272) ~~ Uf11JI11iJ ~~ 1lJ 1l~~iJ ~~ ll~ iJ~ 1 f1fl1llJlJ ll~tJBtJr~ tJ9ltJlJfl lll1lJ1Uf11JlOVll~~fflJlJ~ i1lU ~ ll~ Uf11JfftJlJ ~tJU f)~ lJ ~

vU VU II U1f1~Il~~Ylq El~ (traceability) J1lJl1l fftJ~flfttJlnlJl9l (Jlh ~ff lf1U tJlf11JlOV

1lt rI ~ jI 0 3Jdd Gj l d jI ~ YfU1V1lml~Yf fltJ HUllilJliU HVIlJlJYllJlYl9lmh~lilliU bU~UYlYflJlJ1UmtJlilJliUl~~ 3

qJ q III IV q

310 I It]V I Q ljl rI flUiJlf)HUllilJliUUtJlll9l~~lilJliU b~llf) UlVf) tJlJ9l ffmlif) tJlJ9l mJlJf11JYflJlJ1U ~J~fflCJJ m

ClJ q q cu IU

QI -=to 310 I d

tJfflJ Uf)liJf)iJ ll~~ HUlf)~lJmli~ SMEs SMLs

lfl ~ tJl iJ tJVi B1 U f11 J10V-W f1 tJ lllJ lJ fflJ illEl Wl~l ~ f) (in-depth interview) lllJ lJ lJ

1flJlff~1l (iJlJ~~ YfUlJ~1i1li2550 357-359) ll~~l~lJlJtI~lmtl~ 1~mllYfU~tIJ~I~UfflJillElWbull 9lllJ f)J tJlJ II U 1f1 ~ 1 U f) 1J10V ~lOV 1JIl1lf)l JYl ~ fftJlJ IllJ lJ fflJ ill El WI~l ~f) nlJf)~lJI911tJvll1 U Olf11~~1~U

ClJ 2 lilJliUlJIlln lilJliUUlUOmfllf1lJU

q 11~~lilJliUUlUlffl

q 1~VfflJillEltU~t4llilJliU

q q cu q

~ lU1U 6 flU l~tJftf)Ellfi tJ lJ f)~ ~tJlUtJlIIlJ lJ fflJ illEl W ll~~ff~1lfl1llJ iTU1 iJ-)lJ1llllJ lJfflJillEl W

ViYl~ ~tJl1U 1oHlJIntJUt4l1 tiloHfflJillElW1911tJV1l

V _I d 1 QJQJ 01 U tJ 1J ~ u ~ lJf] lJ (primary sources) Lf1lJ J 1lJ J 1lJ ~ VmflVf11J fflJ illEl WlllJ lJ

dI I _1 QJ dI 1 1 V QJ dI QJ dI ~iJl~~f)f)~lJ~Ulf1mV(in- dept interview) lJUYlf) ~V llilltllJlJUYlmffVl (tape) 1l~~f)lJiJ~lJUYlf)

jJ Q Q I ti 2 UtJ1J~VJ9lVfJlJ (secondary sources) IUUf)lJflf)Il1iJlmtJf)fflJ J1VllU (document

research) lJIlln ~1Jlhlf11J ~11lJYlllml~f1lJVImllJ1l~~l1UlOV~I~V1oUtJl

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 32: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

7

QI QI ~ dedQI amp QI

Vl1lJ U 1 J1J IfU U tJ 11l U l tJ1 (development) fll J Vl1lJ U 11l tJ11J Vl flVll 1 Vl lfllll1 U (direction)tJll 11 (j fl fl111J

l~ U UJ ~ lfl TI U Il tJ(democracy)lflJ 11 ~ fll1Vl tJ lV1 tJ1 (economy)fll J ij ri1U ltj 11JU tJ1U J ~lfllfU (people

participation) siJ tJ ~ (j fl111J (information) 11lJ U 1i J J 1J (culture) tJ 1 f1 fl J J 1J If U (organization of

community) U(j ~J UJ ~ dJU -hill1 ~tJfl1flril1ijfl111J lsiJ1JU ~1Vl ~ tJ1J~ 11~~ IlJ U 1(strengthening of

community) y Y Y I Y

lf1JlfUijUlJlJ~ 1JlJI UfllJ~IlJUlUtJ1IlUltJ1 I-11U~UtJ~nm111(jl1I1111lJU1iJJ1J VlfVltJlm q

fl111JU fJU IU fllJU J~ fltJlJm~Vl U(j~f111~~J 1lf1JlfU U(j~fllJ~IlJUllf1JlfU ~~ll~UcentltJ1~ 1lJU 1

1l11JU1tJlJl tJiiT1Jlfllfi1JtJ uti11~U l1U 1tJ1JltJUU ~Ili 1nlJfl111JcentltJ1flli UtJ1 lf1JlfU ~ q

q V 1Vo Vo d qV7 m ~lJ1U fllJ U fllJ fiil1Vl(j 1 IltllUll1JiTUtJ1 NUllf1JlfU il~l J1J 111flflliVlIlJUl1l Ul tJ1 11

dO q

~fl111J fl111J fil m J til Ufll J~IlJ U 1 J1J IfU U~1Jlfl111Jfll1 ri lUU ~ IlJ U 1 J1JlfU 11 U fil m J tI

vt1IlUltJ1J fllJi~tJfJ1VllJl1 ~J 1lf1JlfU~11 Ulf1JlfU~liJ1JU~1U(j~~1 U rl1fllJ~IlJUlIlUltJ1ij cu II q cu

fl111J bYlf1UJ U~~~Ui~ fi1JVmiddotmbYll~ l1VlflflU l~tJ1111m~fllJfl111J~1JiU I Uflli~1lJ U1lf1JlfU~l1nU U II II II

8 eJ 1Ul11 f ~ ~ 1H ~ l~ U eJlUl 11 I U flU 1J1f1lJ I ifl ~ 11 m tJ fll i fl1lJfJ 1JVlt]~ m J 1JU tJ 1

UJ~lfllfU fll J ~1lJ UllfYJlI~ fll1 U(j~fllJ~IlJUlfllJ lijtJ1 ~ JtJtJflU IJlJ11l tJri1U flm1 ri1U I 11 ~~

9l J 1 n lJfl111J centltJ1 fll J U tJ1J1J IfU ~ 1 ~1JlI1 (j 11 U fll J J lUU fi1J~ U(j~ t1 J1tJf~ 1J1 (j~ ~ J1J 1111 fl

fllJ l~tJfl~1 115 tJij ~ m~ l~ U Ulll1Jm~lJ1U fll iUtJ1Ui ~ lflTIU1l tJtJ~l1 Uy 11~ 1 l~ tJijfllJ Ii

eJlU 1ilf~fl1flril1 ~1lfl~tJcentllU 111fl ~JlJ1JlfUU(j~J1JlfU lVlJ l~lU 1~tJl1m lif~1J1(jU tJ1Vl1fllU 1

V 0 q d _ 1 0 d q q V V d 1V 0

NU 1lf1J IfU U lf1JlfU VllJ J ~ filJ Nfl fill i 11 UfllJ Vl1lJUllf1J IfU rHU 1J UU 111 ~1JVl(j 1 Il tll Ul11 cu q q q

f~1J1flfll1lf1JlfU~1 U l~tJ1111fllUl111111~mlJ~1fil1JiJ~~tJmrl~1l11JtJll1Jfl~ 11l~~l~U 11~ 1 q q

$I 3J dd QJ I Y

U(j ~ 11 U Ill U 1Vl Vl lf1J IfU fllll 1111 IU U ill d1I

~J 1lf1J IfU 1-11 U 11 ~ 111 11 1l1~ m lJ 1-11fil1J iJ ~ q q

11lm~ Vl1~ ~ J I11111~1 UVll1tJll1Jfl~ q

0ft1JjUI~H

N(jfllJi~tJijfl111JfitJllfl~ tJ1nlJ1IltlUi~fi 1f1U(j~l~U Ulll1Jfi1J1J~~l Ul1I11 H fl1U q

1 dj dl d dl 1 I V 0

1V1tluj ~ tJmiddotm Yl 1 lVl tJ fYfl1l1 fl ill (j flll ill ~ Vl Vl 1lJ i ~fi 1 fl U tJ 1 fll J llJ U NUl lf1JlfU U tJ1fl1flll1 U tJ q II cu II

amplQJ 1 ~ CI 3Jd QI 3J 1amp (I q 3J QJ

IltJUlJU N(jflli111tJ VllJ11 NUllf1JlfUl1~lltJ11JflillClflllill~ 5 i 6lfl111111~Vl-1 I1fil1J1JtIVlIlJUllf1JlfU cu II II cu q

~ QI oClQJ amplQJ jJ cs ee dl jJ QJ 3J Vl1IU Vl l1tJll 1 fitJ UCI ~ f111~ 1fitJIltJtJl11JUJ ~ fiVl1i N(j GJf1fitJll fl CI tJ1fllJ Peter M Senge (1990 tll1

d ~e dGj 3J QI 3J(I QI

111fl Stacey 2000 167-169) UCI~ lfii Vl1fYVlfl (2548 online) VI I1fl111JfilflqjfllJfl111J~~l(j~

910 e9 oG]~ QI ~I od dj)o fl111J film J tI UtJ 1 NU 1lf1J IfU 11111 ~ Vll 11 flliVlIlJUllf1JlfU lJ i ~ filJ NCifillH U tJfl 11 lflU NU 1lf1J IfU cu II q cu q

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 33: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

8

11~1Pi Ell ~ ~ U ~~ij fl 11lJ ~1lJ1H11U fllj)~fllj fl 11lJ ~ ~1111 ~flili11~lI1lJ1~ ~lJtlIJll Ull~~li1JliU ~ qJ qj eu q

~lf1tym lfi1 U VI1lVI t]1l ~ IVi 111U IPiElliJ tiu~1 rriJ j ~)mrlltl~lVIl1li11 ~1U $11 V

1~t11h~tl ~~~ 2 I~Elftfl1l1 iJ j ~ IJ1 VIm1~ ~U 1lilJ liU ~ij ~VI n 11 ~~ Elfllj tllYIU ~ U lvIJ1 viijq qJ q dB

ll~~flljIJ ~11j j llifllj U Elliij IJ1~ 11 IJ 11 ~u llilJliU~ij~VI nll ~~ El fllj tlTY U ~ U lv IJ1 viij ll~~fll joW cu q ~

~ llI 3J ~I 3J ocd GJ QJ 3J I tl

IJj 11j j lliflljU Ell j] IJ1~ l1~IlEl~llJU~U 1ltlJ liU VIlJm1lJ~1lJ1HI bUfllH~fllj m1lJ ~ lJj~IIt]1l

1lU 1 rrl~U ~ VEllJ ilJ11IJ GEl ijfl 11lJ ~llJ 1j f) VI1lfllj IJ ~11 j ij 11 ~fl Ii j j lJ1nlJ1~ 1U fllj ~~ ~U 111

ll~~YrWJU llilJliUllIJIJ~lI1UVm~IIIl ~l~El~fl~ElltlIJ1lU1f1~UEl~~U 1lilJliUmjN~1 mU~lJf1~ ~U q q cu III cu U

f11 ~U1lilJliU1J1UU1i1U ~lIJ~IV~UEl~ ~llJ1ElU1UElV )ll1lmllU ~Vm11flljYr~U1lilJliUmlf

~ q q

I~EllVIU ll~I~UI~El~flljI~VU~ ~mjllltlElU (I~~ II~rlVlf1 2551)q ~

IV cd ~ amp 3J 0 QI GJ 3J jJ del1~ t1tlj~ tllflfl 3 111 El f1fl1I1IJ VI IJ1V1 ~U llilJ liU1U fllj 11 ~ U llilJ liU bI1l U lJ II U l WElIl El fllj

q cu q q

Yr~ U 11f1j 11 ij f111 fll j 1W El~ II ~~ al fllJ U Ell iJ j ~1VI f1 ~~fll ji)V IIIJ 11 lilJ liU I~U mhvfllj iJflm El ~ ~ q

r QI ddd dt amp It]3J1QI d ~d II ~ ~ 11 U 1 V11 ~ U 1V11~ fl VI ~~ IlJ El VI fl lilJ liU 11 ~ 1lU lEl l b~ 1V11 flIJ 11] U fll j ~ ~ m j ~ 11 U 1VI U El~ j

QI

ij IJ 1~ q q q d8

edt= 3Jd d ~ 0 I 111 3J 9J dd 3J 0 3J dGJQI QI I

flm ~VIlJ 11 U 1VI 11] U 11 U Ii fll1 ~ 1fl UJEl V~llJ iJj ~ If) VI b~ II fl 11 U 1VI VI1l El~m ~VI1 11 U 1VI I U fllju ~

1 rrIJ~ fllj IW~ 11 U1~1 U V11~ Iiq j f111 ~~fllj l1ll1U1~~lflri 111~U 1 iJ 1 U ~flll ru~UEll flljYl~ El

U lvIJ1 V111 my lU fl m ~ ~ l 1 iJ Vl VI El ~ ~ U li q

lJ liU 1 ~v 1 ~ ij m llJl~EllJ 1 v ~ tl IJ VIEl ~ ~U ~El ~ fl ~Ell tlIJ

mnf1~UEllf1Il~ftfli iJjfl~ (2550) ljl~li )UVIjf1j (2548) 1l~~VIf1IIj fr~alJYrUIl (2549) ~IIlJ11

1m~~~1lflljIJ~11jj1lifllj1~Uflljj1IJ~1U1111jTd~1Uflm~~~fllji)v VlllIJ11 flljl1ll1Ul~ ~

JJ I t I

11l ~llJU Elli~j llIPiUVl 1~iJ j ~ ~tl ~~ ~11~ 11 IVi l~mj IdElll1l fll~U fll j Yr~ U l~ 1 ~ ij mllJl~EllJlv~

tl1JlilJliUVlEl~~U ~El~fl~El~tlIJ~~~ lUi)VUEl~l~w~ fr~1~6 (2540) ~IIlJ11fl~lfllm~~1U111mvM q

flljmIJfllJUEl~f1U 6flml 1~ ~llJ lj f)l~ U ~ ~ lUEllli11~ lU~ ~U 1LiJ ~flljj1lJflri lJf1UUEll~iJlili1 q eu cu q

lfllllljfljj1mJElVf) lfl~ ~lUI m~~iJlili1flU 11 U

QJ I cd dt amp 3J 0 GJ 3J d ~ 111 t= I

1~t11Jj~tlIflfl 4 111 Elf1fl1l1IJVI lJ1V1 ~U1lilJliU bUlilJliWIU lJllU~ll~ ~ VI1 biJlJmllJllllflllll q cu q q

tlU mh~ 1 j ~~fllj l)V 11 lJ1l ~u 1lilJ liU1U lilJliUloUlJll~lijIJVIIJ 1VI1U fllj Yr~U 11lUW~Il~~Yr~U1 ~ q q

lilJliU 1$l~fl11~U 1lilJ liU ~11iJ ll~ ~V~II lJ11lilJliU~loUlJ 11~lijl1 mm ~~lJll~ijliJ Ill lJ 1Vlllllj ij lU q cu q q oW

I~ V1nU]El fll j ~ l1lU IEll El n IJ1 v1U lJ lJ U El llflj 11 ij f1l1] El ij j 1V1$llllfl fl11j 1V~ 1v 115 El L~ ij 11-6~U q ~

etd ~ Id e1~ ~QId et 1j)I 0

11 j EllJ 11 U liPll1] U 11 WIII El fll j ~ l VI Ull ~ ~ El V1U 1~ VVI 11 ~ lilj ~ flU b~ q QJ

lilJliU ~ij ~u1~ijIJVIIJ1V1mIJil~llJfi~ l1~ijlElfll~Yr~U llilJliU 1rr~lIlUWl 1$llllflfl11 q ~ q

~ 111 ~~et d 0 et 3Jdd 0 liJ 3J d d I QI l

ltlJ liU VI 1 biJ lJ Il m fl fl El IJ VI IJ1 VI VI fll 11 U ~ fl El 11 U1 VI VI flll1 U ~ b1 11] U j ~ 1IJ VIJ El VN li~ 111 U 11 ~ IU VU

ll ltI ltl IIJ G IIJ 3J 3Jl1 3Jl I 3J G I 3Jd dI 0

IlJUmV~flllruElfllljl1jEl blJfl b~ 1liU f11llJUfllUU ~ bl1tylJ1Ufll1~lJGlJIll1U1V1lllm~IIJVIJUEll

VI1ljllifllj El~lJ lijIJ 11~iJtiU~I1U1~llllJ~jlliflljll~~ltlJliUlJElIJI1111V fi~~~Ell IJVIlJ1VI~

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 34: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

9

m~r111)1 l ~eJI1 Ul~~L~W 1)1l~~ihllJJlfW l~uB1J~PllJJ~IlWLeJlihJVllJTVlUeJlm1JJL~W~U1 LlfW

1 JJ JJ ~ 1 1 1 d d d ltV

fllj l1f111JJj UlJllJWlJj~fflJflnru WflljlJj~fleJlJmlfVl U~~JJIlVlff1JJ lJVl1J1VlVltlflm~l11l

L~W I1U1~~ IfJJlfW m~l11l lJVl1J1Vlii~hrl tuJJlm~tJ l1) 1f1lfJJlfWfl1~I11l~U 1UtJl LU1U 1Vl11uri II U II cu eu

damp liJjJ d~ ~ Id d 9JdI 0

1)~l1JJltlVlVllIlWLtJl b~ LlfW U~~l1WffW U~eJ~tl1LffVlll~ tJtlWWLUWffIJ lf11lJ1WJJl1WVllVlfl II IV II q

QI ~ 310 1 3J 3J~ ~dliJ3Io iJd d d m1LjtJW 1~1 ~W1lfJJlfW WlfJJlfWLIJJJUUl b~Vlll1W1VlmlJVllff1JJlJVllJ1Vll1W1Vl 1)~LUWVl

QI QItt 1 1 amp jJ QI ~ tltJmlJWlJtltJ1)1f1lJj~lf1lfW WlfJJlfW GilfftJ~f1~tJlfltIUW1f1~lHll Berlo (1966) Broom U~~bull

ell 1 jJ do liJjJ cI jJddSelnick (1997) Vl 11 lJ Vl1J1 Vl lJj ~ fltJ lJ~ 1t1 lJ Vl1J1VlVlflll1 W ~ b1 (role prescriptions) fI tJl1 W 1Vl Vl

o liJ3Id do I QI I d 1 jJ 0 liJ jJ d 0

flll1 W ~ b1LUW j ~ LlJ tllJ tJ tl1l lf~ L1) W 1 1 lJ fI fI JVl tJ tI 1 W lJ Vl1J1Vl1)~ Il tJ lVlltJ ~ bj 1J1l lJVl1J1VlVlm ~Vl1 I r r I

) tt 31 d ltdo liJ 3J o)cI 11 d ltV

1)H (role descriptions) f1eJ l1W1VlVl1JflfI~ b~m~Vl11)HLJJtJtJ~ WlJVl1J1Vl UJ~lJVl1J1VlVl~flm~l11l

tt jJ d d QI 1 31ct I d 1 0 I](role expectations) f1eJ l1W1VlVl~flm~l11l ~tI~tJW111JflfIJVltJ~ WlJVllJlVlfl1H~m~Vl1tJ~ bj

I til 1

1WUru~Vi~U1lllJlfW111 1ullil~iJlJVl1J1VlmlJl1lff1JJiJ~ ri1W 1l1qj1)~uB1J~l1U lVilllJJVifhl1W~ IJJ

LlJ~ lli 1) 1 l ~ l LVi 1~ fI 1j 1) ~L ~ W fl1j ~ lli ff1JJ 1j tl U B1J~l1 U1~ l~ Ill JJlJVllJ1Vl ~~flfl1~ l11l1)1f1

JI dd dt~ tl131d jJ d IfJJlfW LW tJ l1) 1f1 U 1~ fI 11JJJJ lJJW UI ~ LfftlffJ ~ LlJ m Lm 1~ l1 l1 ~ ~ LtJ tI~ Um lJ Vl1J1Vl Vltlflm~ l1 1l

QI

1) 1f1 IfJJ IfW 1) ~ iJ ~ Vl TIVl I ~ eJ ~U 1IfJJ IfW hiiJ m1JJ li l JW U~ ~ Lfftlff~ ~ elWL ~ W 1J 1) ~ tI ~~flIPlW 1 t1~U 1 q eu q q OJ

QI =130 QIQ jJ QI tII

(results - based management RBM)llJJlfWVlPJJW11lWLeJlLlJW~W1Wflml11jUlJlJlJlLWW~~JVlli

1~fllh~tlUl~ 5 Vl~l111IJtJl ~U1lfJJlfW 1WmflmutJlltJWlJW~iJlftJ~1W11)ojii q eu q di

QI tI jJ d jJ~ QI liJ jJ ~ ~ cdt ~ jJ QI QI I tI l91tl U j ~ ffl fI IJ tJ W ~1 1) tI b~ Ill ffJJJJ 9l ii 1W LVl tJtJ lilJ 1t1f1 1 1JJ ffeJ~ fI ~ tJ l fllJ l9ltllJ j ~ff l fI

q eu di q

~

l1~tJ llimhl1j ~ltJfiUj1t1~JL~tJVl~ffeJlJffJJJJ~~lU~l~tJ lUU

mfltllJlJ~h~lUo8~1 ~11 ~U1lfJJlfu1WlfJJlfU~L~JJU~liJVl~l1~~1W11)ojii ~Jfllji~tI lOW eu q q doll

VllJ 11~U 1llJJ IfW I U llJJ lfU ~L oUJJU ~liJVl ~l1~~1W 11) oj~ 1)1l fllj~~U 1llJJ lfU Uff~l eJtJfI IU fllj lli I j1 I j1

tltJJJ ojlJ ~ 1W 11) oj~ Vi ~l ~ 1U 11) oj~ ~lU fI I1fI UtJ lVlll j llffllj1 W ~W Vi ~1 U 11) Vi 1 -UU m 1) Uj1f1U1 W

~ U IJ eJ l fI Ql1 JJ 1tI L~ tI 1 fllJ fI 11 JJ ff llJ L~ tllJ ~ tJ tI n1tI IU fI 1j fI 1 lJ fJ JJ Vl tl amp1 fI j j JJ U eJl U j ~ If 1If U fI 1j

ltV -l dI I I ltV ltV I] JJl bull I 1 -lVlPJJW1LfljlliimUJ~flljLJJeJl GillJj~lf1lfU WlfJJlfUffJJ~ff b~ UjlJUtJlU tl1J1t1 U~UllUl1jtJ

JJ JJ 0 I] ltl JJ I JJ d I II]1f1H f11j9l1ll m~W1llJJlfW bJJL l1U ~1t1 LlJ11)~ Uff~ l tJtJfI U Vl1l9l HIJ 1JJ 9l1JJ 1tlVl1llJ j~lfllilJ l9ltl

liJ jJ t ~ d cI ~ amp d~d d jJ 0 d d b~ UfI fin I l U j ~ lf1JJ 9l U~ ~ fll J Jlfl ~U U WL fftll LJtJfI 9ll Gil LUU 1 lifllj Vl ~W 1 IfJJ IfWL 11 U 1 1LUU

JJl9l jfllj~lftJlJ li jj JJ9l1JJmj ~tJluj~lf1TIU19ltl fllj Uff~lVl~l1~~VjlJ l~wi fllj~ ~U1lfJJlfU iJ m1JJLl1U lliLl1ullt1fllJojiilijjJJUtu~1JlJ Vllt 2550 1uff~ri1U~JJlflfl11Ll1UI1t1

fln~ ~u 1lfJJ lfU fI~lU ff~lm1JJLl1U1WVl1l 9l j lflU ~lJJfllJ ojiilJ 11 l1 ~ eJ fI U U tJl ojii IU mill ~ eu q bull doll

II iI j1 I I

Ll1 U11 fll j m ~ vh Ll1 ~ 1-UU lliL ~W Uj ~lf1 TIU l9ltll1 ~eJ 1lilftllJ lij jJJ 1lU LUeJl1)lf1 ~u 1lfJJ IfW Vi

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 35: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

bull bull

bull bull

10

ltlJlIU 1~tJ1ilTIfllH~1lfl11lJloU11~~1lJflU ~~ I~H1TI~lJ~~lJrty JH1~mjlJllfUuyh 1M~t-h

lIlJlIUl~U ~ tJt)lJ ~1J UtJl Uj ~lI1l1U 1U lIlJlIU ~lmw lJtJlm1Jlft~11 lItJ l1fl1JUJllrt l~1UUl ~fl~l q q ClJ q u

uBIJli ~ 1U 111 U tJ l ~h tJtJ 1ru 1~m 11 ~ tJ fl1J JVl ty1 ~11J~ l~ tJtJlJ~1Jfllj 1i~ 1U 111 ~j lflU m1lJ~11~UlJtJl jJ jJd QI CQI jJ G] fI C ~ deS

111111UlVl ~l~-HN1U111tJUtJl J Ansit Ramsay (2514 tlll ~U lilUft1j 111jtyllJtJl (2550) Vlftflfll

Vl1Jh~U fllj IIJ~l tJtJ flUtJl Uj~lI1l1U ~11~~tJ~fl1J~lU 111~il11fltJ fl uB1r~ tJ~llI~I~U lij jlJ

mmllll~ampill~ 2 ~11~U ll1lJbU 1U lIlJ lIU ~ l oUlJll~ l1JVl~ l11i~1Ul11 ~U lcentllJ1flfl11~U 1 lll9 ClJ q q dll ClJ

lIlJlIU ~11 U ~H1 fll j 1~ tJVl1J 11 ~U lblJlIU 1U lIlJlIU~IijlJll ~l1JVl ~l11i~1UH ~y 1centl1J1 flfl11~U 1 ClJ ClJ

111fluj~lI1bU 1UblJbU 1lfl~llJtJllJ~lm1lJfl~lI1U ~UVl1lJlli1jru~~~Vl11l1~tJUlIJ1111111uUfllj

q q q dll

lIlJlIU ~11U 11 ~ l I~ tJl11 1fll~ U ~U 1~ Uj ~ J1J ~mff11 ~ 11 1U fll j YrWl U lblJbU 11 U dj U ~ tJtJlJ ~1Jl11J ~tJ ~

bull 1 I I oj I 0 I 1I111 1I I I ~

m~h 1U U llJIJ tJlblJbU ~llfl~~1Ul[11 Ufllj 111 j ll1~mtJl lm~ fllj tJtJlJ ~1Jbull fl1 j~blJbU tJtJ lJ ~1J ~1U 111 ~U 1UtJllU11 ~ tJl111fl1J1Jlj 1J ~l JlJ~ Ifl~ 11 1fl fl11lJ ff11 ~ 11 1 U fllj ~

dI I 11]1 d ltI ltI~ ltI VlWlUlIlUltJlIlfl~ltlJbWl1lIUU bU9I1lJllU1f1~UtJlIJj VllftVlft (2548) llfl~mpml utyty1PWlU

(2548)~Vl1J11 fll jYrWlU l91UltJlIJtJl ~U1blJlIWI ~UflljJ~llJlJ1Jlj1J ~1U ~U 1blJlIU~11 U~ lli ClJ q ClJ q

J11J1j tlYrWl UlblJ lIU 1 Ml IilJll ~ll centl I~ tJl11 1fllli1J1Jlj 1J~lI~ J11J1j tl J~1l m ~ 1J1Ufll j 1J1J lf1~tJUbull irVlll ltlJbU I centl fllj YrWlU 1~ lvt l91 WI tJll~ lcentl IitJl tllfttJfl11lJlf1 ml1 iltJ11 1flflltJ U tJfl ~l ifU ~ll ~ 1J

~lUl11~m tJl1 Ufllj liltJflUB1r~I1~tJlliu B1r~9I1lJU1tJ1JltJ~i ~ I ~9I j lfl1Jf111lJ IitJlfll jIJtJlltlJlIU

lcentl ~lJtJ~fl~tJlfl1JllUl~tJlJtJlitJtJft~lJJ1nw (2543) ~ftml1Vl1J11flUYrWlU1blJbU1J2

j ull1J1JfimUIl1J 1J~BlblJlIUl~U~~I~lJ llfl~j UIl1J1JBlJm1rUfIltJUtJfll~U~~I~lJ ~l~U1l1lJlIU ClJ ClJ q ClJ ClJ ClJ ClJ q

11 hicl ~ 11 QJ cl _IQJ

U eJtfl eJl~ f YI11tf1lfl t11U eJ lflIJ fl11Vi lll1llll1 lf11 f1 nil eJ lI eJ l IJ l t1~1J 1~ YIf1

- ijtJlJUtJllU~I~lU 1tJ1JltJ lliwl (1) tJVllift1J9I1UflljYrWlUlUj~IVlftfl1j1iblJbUI1~tJ

I1~U1W1~UI1l11tJYrWlUlIJtJlUj~IVlftm If ~ll11~ ~11f)tJI1~tJI9111Jfl 1lfl~f11j~11~ 1MlIlJlIU I1~U1U ~ ~

d QI dltlltl jJ fI QI QI

lJll~UVlWlU l91U ItJl Vlj IjlJ 111flfl11lJ 9ItJlflljIJtJlltlJlIU (2) ~Vlli ft1J9I jflljVl Wl U l1tlJbU IJ tJlji1J 1fl

fl1j~l11UfllllJbUtJtJfll~U 3 ~1~1J IcentlWllllJbU~vtl9lWItJl lIlJlIU~fh~lYrWlU111fl~GlJbU~ErlI~ q q q ~

YrWlUl ltlJbU 11l mlJ~l~1Jmj1Jm ~1J1U fllj YrWlUlllfl ~ 1J1TI ~~ fllj ~llflU (3) ltD~ Jj j l1JU j ~lJ1ru

1 MlI1lJ1~ JlJ fl1J ~flll ru ~ lIlJ lIU 1 Ull~ fl~~U 11 (4) ~y 1Jlfl1 ~ tJm ~ Vlj 1l ftfllll11 flUf11jf1111 U ~ ~

U 1tJ1Jl tJ 1M1 H l~ tJU 1U blJ bU ltD~ 11 ~fl J9I j 11 ~ tJfl11 m j lJfllj l~ tJU flU JtJ U ~ 1lJ fl1J ~U 1lIlJlIU 11 ~ tJ q ClJ ClJ q

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 36: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

bull bull

11

- ~tJI1llHmU~IltjiltJa1J~ lcentillfl (1) ~l-h1UJpJJ1U~Ifi~1l~lm111~1llfl~tJ~ltJ~~J1U~WJUl cA Id 3J 3J I rI I 3J 0 cd 1rJ 0 cSQJ QJ

llltJlmflllJ~WUUtJ~~ mlmll~~lJ1~1IIJfll1ru1~l111lflU (2) v-lUlJ1~J1UVWl ~~tJ1~1IIJv-l~1I11H ~ ~ ~ q

1Ufll1~WJU 1J1~J1U m1ftflfnllIJIJ tJ~llJ1~J1U~~WJU111~~~lPIUltJllcenti (3) tJlf1fll1IJ~l111 ~1U

~1IJ~ (tJIJPI) m1ij~ imlfll1tJ1~fld~J1~J1U1U1~~IJ~1IJ~ i~tJnll1U~lflrucnmPIH1UlJtJl~1IJ~ ~

11loWl~tJ1I~1l1l Hm~~U 1l1mjDlUJ1~J1U~ijfl~WJUlP1UltJl (4) 1UlUPIe511f1tJl1~tJijll11~m1~ q ~ q ~

QI ltl rJ rJ d 1 G] jd d ef ltl rJ I

PIm ~U ~ 1IU fllJ1~ J1U 1IJ~1lUl ~ tJ ~ l1 ~fll 1 ll~ flltJ~tJUll~~9ftJlJltJ1IU fll1 ~l1 11ltJ1~J11J1UU tJl ~~J1U 1l~~tJ1~J11J1U~11tJ

oUflltJtHllU~1u f1liflf1tlllltOtI~ fl1 tJ 1 centilln (l) fl 11ftflfn11 ~hJ1~J1U~ Vl 1~tJ1~1IIJ OJ bull

od~ I II] Jd lI]d o~J v-l~1I11H Ufll11lWJU1J1~J1UUtJlPIUltJlllJUlll11~tJ~ 11Vlil~Vl1l111 11~~il~PItJl~m~IJ1Ufll1tJml ~UlJ1~J1U~WJUlJ1~J1U1l1tJ1~1IIJv-lmh~il (2) fl11ftmn11 1tJllIJlJfl11~WJU1J1~J1U3DEPICOS rh1l1 lU q q lU q

J111DlU~flruf111ljiPI~ ~U lcentitJ~ll 11 (3) fl 11 ftflfJ l11fll1 tJ 1~ liJU fl11 ~Il ~ tJ~UtJlJ1~ J1Uf11tJ1 $I m1flfll1 3DEPICOS 11thijtJ1~~~VlTIIl~~lntJU l1~l ll~~ll~~dhijtJ~~VlTIIl~~tf)U tJ~ll 11

(4) m1ftmn11 fl11~WJUlJ1~J1Ui~m~1l1lrl~11J1fl11lm~~UlJ1~J1U~ml~llPIfl~1lnUtJ~1l11(5) m1 bull OJ bull

ftflfJ 1~Ill U 1fll 1 Vlll fll1 lijtJlll IJ IJ tJ 1 ~ J11TI tJ 1 PI tJ1~l111l ~U 111 IJIJ 11J1fll1 II~~ ~U 1IJ tJlJ1~J1U OJ OJ

J d ~ d II 111] I ~ J 0 J 0

lU~llUl ~mm~~IJUtJlml~llJUlJ1~J1UlJ lPItJmflfldlflU (6) m1ftflll1~U1~~J1Ul~tJl1l~~~Ul

J1~J1UJ1UIJVl1m~Il~lMe51UlilfTmflfl11nU ~

QI GljJ3I d 310 rJ 0 131 IQI

fll11lWJU1J1~J1U l1lUWlIJl v-lU1J1~J1Ull~~J1~J1U PItJlU 11tJ1l1~ flfll1 4DEPICOS I~llfl q lU q q

llU1~~fll1~WJU1(developmentDI) YlftVlll (directionD2) tJ1~J11TItJlP1tJ (democracy D3)

tJ1~J11mft111PI1(demographer D4)1ft1ll~f1il (economy E) fll1~~1U~1~UtJlflU1U~~J1U

(people participation p)fimJ~fl11~finformation I)lWJU1i11~ (culture C)tJlf1m~~J1U

(organization of community O)ll~~ml~I~~ll~lIJtJl~~J1U(strengthening community S) ltJ

I~U $IUll IJ IJ U tJl DlU ampl VU i ~ tJilm 1~ r11111~~dJiJ ijtJJU ~fl 11~Il ~ tJ~IVl tJl1~ ~11l IJ 11Vl 1~

Il~tJ~l1~tJ~~~ BtJU il~$tJl11l~W~~ l~~ tJ~ 11 11~~tJ~ll 11 i~tJU11flru cntJ 1~ ~VlTI f111l( efficiency

1 d1 1 E 1) lJ1~1IVl1iv-l~(effectiveness E2) 1l~~lflruCV1fl11~IltJllltJl(sufficiency s) llJUlflruCV1lJ1~1~U

111U tJ l tJ U U fl 11fll l1 U ~ ltl U 111 ~ tJ U ftU tJ fll 1I1 tJ U 1 Vl tJ 1 ~ J11 J1 U Vl fl fl 1 tJ IJ fl 11 il ~ PI tJ l ~ IJ 1U

ml~Il~tJ~1l~~fl11mhlh1U fll1~WJUl~~J1Uf11tJ1$1i111IJIJ DlUamplVU 4DEPICOS 1I1mH1

d I lUtJUllJU1I~fll1

SSc= E j E2(p+i+c+co+4D+E

3)

rJ cc ~ 0 d c rI d 9Jd QI rJ diJ

OJ OJ bull

oW lhtJl~ U m tJ IJ ~~ 1 U fll1 ~WJ U 1~~ J1U U tJl PI UltJl l~tJ1l1l~ lfl 11 ~~~ I~ U ~1~ nU 1U fll 1~WJU1

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall

Page 37: u. f.~,(LLmm~rt~rthGGn. - VRULRU~f,LUr.&L~~f,rt LRU~f,LUo,~IL~~~ltrt'umt9u~t!m~ti.U.llHrU,~tUJ~I~ LRU~~~mltrt~~f,~t!1I ~ ~Lfh fu £rtrt~~f, Rijl~~L UL RU~U,.tt~t!II~U rt~LU L …

12

o 9 v I 9 d V 9 Ii] V rJ d bull I 9Va J V Ii] I d

ItlJliU Vl11l1lJj~li1liU bUltlJliUlJfl11lJlIJ1 bil b~lleJIJUlVlj1~lJmtliJlJj~l~UI111fl bl1fl~ C)Ilt11 lJlJ

mtliJ~~~lfl~l1 fllj11lUNU~IJJUlltlJliU il~IJ1~fl11lJi~lilU ri1UflWU 1U leJiJ1eJU ~flljDBu~ d QI ~ QJ 9J 0 Gj j)d V Gja jJ 3J QJ ~ Gj 3J lJ 3 IJUl91tlU fltl IJUl91tlUUjfl tliJjlJNUllilJliU bl1lJfl11lJlIJ1 bilUU1fl~IJtllfllj1lj1liJ1UeJleJU bl1

OJ bull

l~ U l1llI tlU U11 ~ ll~ eJU ~ IJ tl l lilJliU ~U 191 tlU ~ 1ltl l 1l~ 1llilJliU IX U UiJ iJ ~~IJJ U1 fll eJ hiu U 1~ ~ OJ bull bull

JJ I I I I

4DEPICOS 11U 191 tl U -vi 1l1lJ IJ eJ1eJ N1I 1D Vl ItlJ liU ~ 1l 1 111Dj ~ lVl ft1~ eJlXtlll~lJ1X U -vi ItlJliU tleJ1fl

~IJJU 1191U ltl l U11 ~ tl eJ1fl Utl1I UJI11IJtlllilJliU mi1u WUl rim ~ iJ 1U fl1j Dj ~ li1fllJ il1~ 1lJnU ~~u OJ

UiiW1UflUJ q

a ~W111lmilllJI111Vlm1leJ

ieJeJft ~lJ 1l1jj ru (2543) flli~rolU1itJlUUfllift fl1l1l1JJlIU~flflli~rolU1~ff~~u iVl eJ1ft11l191bull q

D~qjqj 1fl ~ ft11l191 ~EJ~ Uill cVll91 flill~fl~ ft11l191 ~ W111lmrulJ I11iVlm~eJ

VlftVlj ft~~lJ~U1r (2549) fl11JJidM~U~[J1flliU~mii1l1flliIU11tlti (~mflfl~ 2)

fl~ llVlVl1 ~111m1Uflill~mjlJfllj~1JJU1j~iJiJj1lifllj rI -=to ~ _I ~ Q QJ Q QJ iI Q

lHUft1j liljqjllJtll (2550) fllilJflflifl~t1fl~t1UflUflliUitlliil~fllit1fl~t1U fl~llVlVl1

1m lfllj ~~~lJvrfliJ1vl

bull u iJUJl1U ~tlflh1ll (2549)flliU~mi~hu1il flliijfl~ ul[JU1[J flliij~flli1tJ1tlflil ltlf11llj

Dj ~ fl tl1Jfllj 1J j j eJ1 eJI1~m191 jfi Dj ~ ft11lU ft11l191 j ~ EJ ~ Uill cVll91 lJ I11iVl eJ1~ eJj 1lintP111 eJ

tl1llmru iUVlj~iJjm1liDnlJJ1 OJ

d rIa ~ iI cs ~I QI 21 l1lj VllftVlft (2548) lIJJlIUi[JUi fl[J[JUlJUtJIJ mllVlVl1 Vl1lllJUJUJ1

q cu qJ q q uu d rlJ Ii QJ iI Q QI ~

l1lj VllftVlft (2551) ft1jjfl1tJVIi~rolU1t1MtlUfl~llVlVl1 Vl1lllJqjqj1

l1l~ Vllft~ft (2548) tJ~lIW1flli~rolU1-15~U1lilJliU~~iYiJfIUlrltllU~ 20 I91mfllJ 2551 il1fl u cu q q

http wwwphongphitcomindexphpoption=com_contentamptask= viewampid=

tlUfmJ lIUJUJ1Uuu q 11JJU (2548) flliftfl1l1l1JJlIU~~~tl~fl1I~

q Ut1~[JUillfl1ij[JfllfltJU1JJ

q q

fl~llVlVl1 ~irEJi 1VleJ tltlvllC)lI91

CascioWF(l995) Managing Human Resources New York McGraw-HillInc

StaceyRD (2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics The Challenge of Complexity 3rd ed Edinburgh Prentice Hall