Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
KKU. VeI. J. VoI. II No. I JANUARY - JUNE 2OOI 23
oJ.9de'mr 6h€?e nrr 6a sia sr drueafi usau tfi a E.coli fi ynrtua n n ntriau rd a
" tut{ ?iruutuil'tdgla nt tfl sl{nn{sr g aul[dufl?\:naufig1uil [ultl€l e
Survey of Antimicrobial Resistance of Escherichn colilnfection Found in
Diarrheal Preweaning Piglets from Swine Farms in Khon Kaen Province
luror: uvfli'
fr.:nrryad ar:r:r'
Tanakran Nasril
,3rungKan baracnoo
f,ard'nd qiln:r'
ra:*4r 6rrnruud'
Niyomsak Uppatum2
,latesada Jiwakanon3
ruFr:tun 6':rnruuli',z
tJ:3R'11\t A\:nUfllU"lJ'
Netchanok Jiwakanon2
Prapaporn Tunqthanathanitl
. .. .r,-:. ,, - ,:eir.,,...,;:r f . . .
ullfl$lgo ,,,
rirarirsasqr::alnnndn:frasrfiudrsriouuriruu crnv'lri:lan:*ilnnrf to v'lriu "lurtn
v v '1 G ,..\,-.:,.5..:-..-:/-..--.-".^4- '-. t- ---:-t-:- ^^r: ^^",^X^.,^offo^, r *fiaq{fi?FllJOUtt?lUtllltllUt.i'lVl9l?;iirUtljU-)t"lUplf l l-ePlEiri r"rJPl\tTU nsLuerLclJtU CuLi vtg-ri iti ili"i{ti1j}i J ruvii^ q
'q 6 d 4 'Y
fi fr I ru'[d^[ur,,]ril *n yrtnsr nrrl airtyYud:vr.r'irs r:l o i rf u sinr:6 o arri'l::J ttul nt:d'nnr:l',lril
nr:6n:Ernti it\& n.cotiz0B InTafifirylryirunld'qrnd'rodr{acc:nv 231ri'radrt ua-{qrndrxtrflnflot-J
nilsr TLimethoprim/Sulfamethoxazole, Amoxycilhn, Norfloxacin, Gentamyctn *av Cohstln, lngld'
Srandardized disc diffuslon resr ylyirrilofr6usinr:6iorrrflu 83.1,83.1,33.6,29.3 uav 0 ntrcl'lniu "Lunr:finvrnm:rd'lyliud:yr,t'ir'rnr:6'asrnir:tJttrlnr:6'nnl:ilri:lnll'il v'lrilfildl:t rSou
naoarrLUtruncyfir:Joirfusinr:daar (Norfloxacin, Tlimethoprim/ SulJamethoxazole, Gentamycin)
qsn'Jr (p<0.01) v{rilfildl:sriaurraloprrurl:?:r cirviirrv'{rilffflnrr"ld'r'rfrruaaf,v'izuax.rarrn:c;fi. A , 6 ;1 'qvruiaiidunnr:6arioarrirulafivr4nri'r (ani{u cohstin) 4sn'jr (p<0.0t) v,lri:rfi1l1d'uroiruqnfrilzua}.1
&orur: xranalnu?\u'jt'lrirufii"i'lr,,lfirnnondn:a;ffrilai16uainr:6'ariosrriruqnfinflnd'r (unr{u
coListin) ntn'jr (p<0.0s)vlrilfi1"i'1,l,rfrnonqnqn: apfld"jr16o E. colifin.r6irirr'.r ti*etrroprirn
/ Sulfamethoxazole rrnv Amoxycihn tu:yrirasunyriloit6uoint:fiotrfrnrtrfrivl'udfi'l:rlttllnr:
d'nnl:1,'lritt: -rrn,ld,lnfu : il'r:oitrj'taluant?\ o LnLn vlo\:tflu nndn:
xey*o.-d" : antimicrobral resistanc e, Escbericbia ceii, diarrhea, piglets
nrnitrnar66rivur nru:d'nt uvriagrnni rvrinutd'trtouudu 40002
Department of Pathobiologry ,Faculty oi Veterinary Medicine, IClon Kaen Univelsity, Khon Kaen, 40002
qutlia''trua:tluqo:knd'Er{nrnn;iuoanrflr':uvfia or.vlrvrr; ejrinarfios trol.Juriu 40260
Northeast Regrional Veterinaty Research and Diagnostic Center, Thapra, Khon Kaen, 40260.
Rrni:rrarsrnrani nru:d'nrufl vrrJnrani rtvriruraiuloui!.i! 40002
DepaJtment of Medicine, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Kron Kaen Universlty, Ifton Kaen. 40002.
nrnigraS:inur nru:d'orunvsfl rdsri rurirarn"tla! uritl 40002
Departmeni of Physiology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, I(hon Kaen University, ICron Kaen, 40002.
24 ?1?6l1rfrn?rlryttlf,lfln5 ffi. fld 11 o:iufi t ilnmnil - fiaursu zs++
Fecal samples of diarrheal preweamng pigiets from 10 commerclal swine farms
were collected to determine the percent resistance of. Escberichia coli to 5 commonly used
antmicrobials. This research was done in order to study the relation between the percentage
of antimicrobial resistance and the patterns of farm management. A total of 208 E.coli colonies
isolated from23l feces samples were tested against Tlimethoprim/SulJamethoxazole, Amoxycrllin,
Norfloxacin, Gentamycin and Colistin using a standardized disc drffusion test. The percentage
of resistance to the antimicrobials were 83.1, 83.1, 33.6, 29.3 and 0 respectively. It was found
that farms using isolated farowing barns had higher (p<0.01) percent reslstance to Norfloxacin,
Thimethoprim/Sulfamethoxazole and Gentamycin than those using mixed farrowing barns.
The farms using antimicrobial mixed feeding had higher (p<0.01) percent resistance to all
antimicrobials, except Coilstin, than those usrng antimlcrobial free feeding. The farms
using electrical heater for warming piglets had higher (p<0.05) percent resistance to all
antimicrobials, except Colistin, than those usrng gas heater. This study concluded thal E.coli
had high leve1 of resistance to Tlimethoprim/Sulfamethoxazole, Gentamycin a:rd Amoxycillin,
and there were relations between the patterns of farm management and the antrmicrobial
resistance.
nl:flQ tfiu?a.iQnqn:ne'i uoirinFldoaf ifizirur uJunmla4 rdafidrd'rylullriran:r4o urir,.ruri,j
vw'lrnn4n:finnonfi8an airuru 15 - 30 uJoir6uai nrariauo'u'tri s d'ilord uayannn:airuruqq9g9
-9,-4";,j6),xJutnoLa:{14u.lFl'luR'luLus?'ldilallitt:nufl\naan (Gaskins and Kelley, 1995) arnrnatud'trilnfi.ge^ q ,vl'lifitnan?llldrutd-unTLqndn?Luu?'inouuriluxl (Vaillancourt and Thbbs, 1gg2) nl,jrarnr:fi'a.r
.4 q -j s - q "tdutliud'ltl.4etfreirriryto':nl:Fnu?o'ionqn:ludr.rfi (Christensen and Svensmark, 1gg7; Cutler et2:-. . v -J"qeal., 1992) rfiofiuluarunqeird'atfivirlri'onan:dauurjrurufi'osifiu fifi'nniud nro Escbericbia
coli, Clostridium perfringens, Enterococct.{s durang Isospora szzls, Tlansmlssible
gastroenteritis (TGE) virus ttny Rotavirus (Ge1berg, 1gB9; Hall, 19Bg; Hill, 19Bg; Hoeflng, 1989;
Lindsay, 1989 ; Cheon and Chae, 1996) lu'ff,u3't1r?o$nlilyrlror?0.i1:n n{ofirTnvw'jrrfluaruun
fivirlri'qnqn:nail3l1rya.itdu finilrifirTan da a" coli *az Coccid.ia spp. airu Clostriciium
perfringens uav tansmissible gastroenteritis virus rfluarir,rqnhd'qfivirtri'qn:fiorrfisluursf(ufi
rvjTiu (Cutler et a1., 1992)
KKU. Vet. J. Vol. I I No. I JANUARY - JUNE 2001 25
vila n. coli tflua:,tfie)?o\:o'rn1:fr'osrRa"luqnqn:fivrildr,i'r}J"Luv'lriurd'atan:luil:;turt.' e ' q'; '- n?Lnxrrrnyflo.rrYul:nri'uodrtnirtm'rtaeir.il:fisruL?t u u1 Fl''tua n"dyl'du a Br.i "i fl n Lt tv'l o n1:: n l91) 2
" * -
yerfla{crnLdo E. coli 6oriourd'ru1nfir.,qld'adr.::?oriril1n (Mackinnon, 1998) $avalnua1u:1u.atu
luflscfuv'{ri'jr:yohrnr:1d'uroiru1n8r.t (Duntop et al., 1998b; Mathew et a1., 1998; sunde et a1.,
1998; Marhew er al., 1999) :rilfr.:n?.lilnnd'us'rnflnrvrurnd'o:rrirsl"Luv,lriu (Dunlop et al., 1998a;
Moro er al., l99B) fir,nvfr"Lr,ln r:vlTr,uu rnrrdoartosrfraufrokiuirt'u oiszuntr.[rila e. ,oli dodatr6'ru
qn8nrnnrroi'rfil"i'nluoqluv'lri:rufrrdurioul unviiluzun"Lr,{rflonrrrd'rur,rar"lunr:ldurufron r:ins'r
Fr'ru Fr ?.r r.rio rl ot ri'ul: n
nr:fin:Er"Luntrfl ufiod'o.rnr:nrriloiifiusinr:dolrro.rriio e. colinautfttulnfinfirTntd'
tuv{ri:rqn: unyfinsrfi.l6lrBylaro.:nr:qionr:r,'lrilfrfirjodn:rnr:6osrlo.ru6'a E. cctlilur,'lri:ran:q-Lu rlFtq{u?nljau ttnil
tdAdoiln5iluav?fifll:q
finrErqrny,lri:ran:riorrrir,lud lurn BO - 800 ttri airuru 10 r''lri:r lflur."lrilrds.ldn:ac9
r8s:,rrrirrjuL:JFr:L?.iq: (zu6nan:rdorurru) 4nv,lri:rrnrlrulqn4n:frorq:vu'jrs 21. - 28 iu rrrj.l
y{ririaonrflunaiilnrunh:sruylo.inr:e-ernr:rirunr:rfistfitinnrittriurilu 3 t.J:vtnr 6o ahryruv
I:sriaunnoa urrlrrun*n;*ull:?xl ("rrln" uurrf,sT:.rrSounnonfrfitqvrrvurian::anaor,ttnrifi's.l
nn fi q l,,lrilun; ":rl" ulrafisl:.rr6ounaonfirfisrrrrjan:dlvi'osl{rira fi O r,,lrjl) ::nilnr:"Ldtr{cl
ri1usafiflzuaxrorllr: uLLlritdururayururldrr ("1il1d'" urrsfit lrifinr:zuarsrpiruanfiv!"luo'n4'r:9'q
4n:"luvirdu rniiuilrstirrfulfiflar-;:yrrnra{:n fl g ",'iri:r unv "1*- itrraflsfin'r:2n:rrrfrru
qafifltuorur:*rion:dlvior *rian:rduoan rrnuo'r41:flnan:1u::ririnrsrl:prorirfluil:vairunv{cqgg$ct
uarssfrnrfran?un:Jnl::yrrnsarl:nrl:y.l'rfru fi zr^tri:r) rravl6nr:"Ldnrrrsounntfrotr.i'nmuar
Quqnqn:*:nnaan urrtdly{fitrnyuurtd'},'lufra ild'lrar1r fi e v'lri:r uavld'1r,{ufla fi 2 v,lri}r), ; ,.(9r-r:'r.ivt 1)
rfian iffr n-rorir.rqrn n:0nfifi nn nn:viot rfis"Ludrsriouurirl:rlu *rin rv'lri:r lnunr:6i:ruq9
airuru z n:ana"ruirnr:rfird':a:ir.roqar:yrr:lntda E.coli ltnvairu?u 10 F]:on6i'r1.45lnr:ifilrr-r
orir.laacr:vr:rado coccidia n-,r,fiurirrr-rsosqr:vrfior:rctdo E.cctlil"fii:inlurir6flruoaql:i
crndo.iilrl:viulnzotnrran:c'ruru3-4frrrion:onrfirnhodrrhirYudrfifr:lrLosarrvli"lugq
fiaoetilnno\:fifirirrnda (normal saline) rfra:lo.rnluassr:y$#'iuntiloe.lrrirnisri'os:Jfrrifrnr: rfra: q rr r ; & 6t v ;n:tqutifronraLu4 5SrLl-l lfiug,t?au1.toqa1:Jfl.it4x]glavqnillnl:rv'r1vtrflnr%oLu?urqu?nuvt
rfir sr-r a rirr *dr rfiu1nlaflr o r rt{ol{rfr ovirnr:vrn a or nrruh ria ar d'ruc n6r,rtun:1r t6 urfi'ut
;X6G4&d?uR1: rnL Fr? o u'r{ ry'{o Fr:?qfi1ruo coccrdia arvirnr: tfiloaat-; n n dn:fr'o{ ifi usrnfrunon
26 ?r:6l'nffmuilyrrlrrldn{ ilfl. flfi 11 oriufi t iln:1nil - finursu zs44q
q''ruru 2 - 3 iltaurrsion:an ,irurufriR'u 10 nr:onrioy,lrfu tdl{lufiaonilnno{rurnrfin {i.r
' 6l .! q
- e\ tv c Q q qY,f 6 v r \,a?0u'l.id?1.tL146rJayvl''ln1:n??afilttoR'tu[u?utFlu?nu n1[xlflunqynllclu?unqLLLnutnun?ou't{L?
rarufiRx] 4 o'iFlltga Ltud
;, o , a i<n']:1{vl 1 [rd9l.i:luavtouFtljo{?\']i}tiltnu9}?ou'l'i
ylriru fi'nuarsl:{rioufloopr nr:tdurruaruormr: ufiorornlr{nnnnon:I
0tu?119t?0u'l.l000Dvq
A
DU
C
D
F
F
Li
H
I
K
L!UR
t?11
LtUN
i?ilttun
Iun
t?3.1
:111
:?x.t
i?3.1
LT
td'qvtlJ
t%
quLlJ
id'
Lr.J [S
2 'qvLx.r ls
L:"J L%
LT
zo
ZO
zo
21.
21,
21,
21.
21
21
21
lr tfir
hrlr1*flr
},thilr
Iv'hilr
lv{fir
lv'trlr
lr,"tfir
rifla
rufla
14111?Jt149l : ILPJn
t?3.t =qtL?'
t}.lLt =
ln:ilT =
irfla =
L:.$ t:ou n fl o ail :t tal\] v ttSJ dnT:o n n o f,l tta v tn u{ fl Ragr ^ -J*l:s riaunaonfi rd:rs urinn:dur,los:uri'r urian::onaan uav i6EJsan9qqgdr^61fi nr : zu a ru sr d'r ua ofi v!1u or fi r : irri a n :dufias u:"i a n : rn- a r a n $ a y o'r41 r n nqqclsg
a n :tu : s niil fn rErI: n o d rfl u il : vair u n v vt a1 u t fi er99
1rifi nr:zu alar d'ruc afi illuorur:an:luv'lrinq9
td'r,t a o nlv"hlT nn fl n d Rr99
td'Iv,'l ufrann an an:gs
rf;io6":ocirsanaisruT fl.rri'arrJflrifinr: qvtv'nytdoqrnn-roairtqaarrvtu Lactose ltlacConkey
agar (DIFCot) ura;:jlr5i'01{viqrur,r4fr 37 o.afl1rrarilua tg-z+rirTlr lu{uriourarajurdan1nTafivifi
nhuruvrflu E.colilinTnfiAtr4uro) ,-rrri.oav 1 TnTafi rfronoaord'n"*rrlsfir,^fiunvnr:rios
aararfior16oorrrrs d'rosirslorfig E.colirn"rtnnfilillri'nr:dounaratfiort6oorito.t*avtfioriilri'nr:ciou
aarsrfror16oor$n'r qy6'nrdanlnlnfirdorir}Jvrnaarnrulrsiourriruqasilvt".$ z ritn
nrslu 40 Iu fi a-rqrn rff uel-r aux E. c ol i uri avTnrTafi fi r6onl{ arqndurr naalrnuhriourriruqnfin Inul"i'rtunOrO disc dittusion test (Bauer et al.. 1966) lunr:vro'aou qvld'nrol
! f f - & Q g !e , dt(wile loop) rf,aLnlaflrorifionslunaan*rirfifi sierile normal saline 5 fra66n: udruonJrrtejr
d,\v , , - Y6l.ro ^o' ' -le' 6l
qun:yil'rLFtnrurrllrlu 0.5 McFarland sLandard uai.ialnuu[tdrailuUnruLillila{Lu14noFl
KKU. Vel. J. Vol. ll No. I JANUARY - JUNE 2001
frntri'raurn udrrjrlrflrua.tluq'ruo'r1n:rdasrfi.afifi Mueller-Hinton agar (NCCLS, 1997) rrd'r6'l
rr.rur]uan (antiblotic discs) ns1il ilnpi'roejr{qynndoild'?EJUrfrru1nfir.r 5 tfrpr 6a Colistin,
Norfloxacin, Amoxyciilin, Thmethoprim/SulJamethoxazole, LLflv Gentamycin (Oxiod @) rjlJrfia1i
fiorur.lnfr 37 osnrrrnrfiaarflur.:nr f6-18 rirllr drr:tifiroll11Fl?o\:R1:aonqvrfiloslrriardo
",ttt:rfiorrsinyLnLnfis:An:rEJ.:runrrruhsioulriruqnfivltflorirrl rilu susceptible, intermediate
resistani u^r r"rlrruntnsuodnlsouLflFtnl:aonqvrBrilftnr:ra3ryrfillntaotdo nr:ltoaolvrngold'
tda E. c o tior rnn{ ercc )sszz rilu rir nrl q I rr6'trr url ai rfi u sinr: do sr
ulFrx'xJdixrfiud:yr.r'ir.r:rjrruun.'.d'rn',-rnlri:rfrunnritstiu 3 tJ:vmtl (nhuru:nl:1d1:sriau
:;olunl:ldlrpirucnfiy! *nynr:16'nrrrfounnnnnn:) nllnr:6ou'toitucafiflririnvnitolrda E.coli
ld'nr:rs z x z Tpretld1il:un:r Epi Info version OTprsl{nr:lrnaoilniaurnrf uas llsher's Exact&
test fi'tltluzuanr:naEJrrnjrrflu Z:yri'l 6a susceptible nll total resistant dorarjlzua intermediate
resistant ur:r:tflizunfrrilu resrstant vr"{drnar:6utir intermediate resistant t:Junr:dasr:vrYl
l4il.i?O\:tt0)
,''',HAf)15nfl 60tl''.1 i'
qrn.iruruTFllnflras E.coli z0B Inr1aflfi*unl6'qlnrYradr{oqqr:v 23r rirorirtvi
ej.:n:ra "Lr.i'zua6oqast Norfloxacin 33.6 rrioir6uri Amoxycillin 83.1 rrjoirfiupi Tlimettroprim/
Sutfamerhoxazote 83.1 uloirfiusi $ny Gentamycln 29.33 rrJoirfiusi *nvlrifrTnr1nfrlnlri'zunriada
u1 CoLstin (nt:rtvt 2)
srn Frr:rsfi 3 r:-Jiul rfi al rrj oi r6u sinr:6'o ur ttriavtfr orri'Lflcc-ur"lriufr $nn rirtn-u
(n-n:gru;nr:1d1:srSauuri'lurnnir:rr nr:l"i'frilrjldrrzunrarnr: unvnr:"Ldlr^lrrffairn;}4firnn
qnqn:) nl'jr anr{u Colisrin *n: Amoxycillin tw'jrtrJair6uainr:6aarso.:td'o E.coli fin':u
d'uyl"'uii (p<0.01) rirnhrgruyl:.rrSounaon loslw'jr ilT irvildI:ttiaunaoqidrsuriqn::onnan' : id "
3rrn;trrtqn:rausqn arflnloiisusrnr:nasrsartfio E.coli qtn'jr F<0.01) rttilOretasrrrlqn:
dnfrar:rlniutuT:r iSounaoori':a u^rn.'-dor,',tos rdo F).coli riourpiruqafir.r4nrir (sn i{u
cotistin) finrrl#lrniuij (p.o.os) rir:rnirnr:ldurpiruqnfinzuauorur:luv'irir*nvsfroso.r},innrfria"lr.Xnrruarejunnd.]r lorsvrrjr l,,lrirfifinr:l{urpirucafine.Jfl:.ro'rtl'ricrfirilaii6uainr:dosrriru
^:qnfiflsosufro E.colintn'jr (p<0.0t) r,,lrir:filrjfrnr:kirr6'rucnfinzuaxrorur:utnvv,lrilfit"i'}^h:{rnn
nn4n:a;frurJoiufiusinr:6arrsastda E.coliatn'jr (p<0.05) v'lrilfrld'rtflannnnan:
27
28 m:cr:finlnrnsmcnS ile. flfi tt ailufr I ilnr1nl - fiqursil
nr:r{fi 2 LLdol.it{antrvrndounrrrihriotlr6'ru.qafiyl s tfror torrdo E.coli .iruluvr".ryun
208 st-radrsarnueinyy'lriilfifinrsr e
Colistin Norfloxacin Amoxycilin Trimethoprim/ GentamycinSulfamethoxazoleylrilr
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
K
22
25
29
20
20
17
t'7
2T
1'1
1'7
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
4
18
23
t4
3
9
t2
15
18
9
18 5
52324l16240746601'1 4
t7 1
2352'1 2
19218 1
t7 1
14214911 7
134
0210200270180190160170120 1t
112
150790169218t4 151604917
150420 10180016 10
:?lt zob 125 13 I 173 t4t 61
njofrdud e8.6 1.4 60.1 6.3 33.6 15.9 0.96 83.2 16.4 0.48 83.2 67.8 2.9 29.33
uillaruer : S = qiurugt-roeirrfi}i'runhdosrfil"i'vrnaat
I : qhuru ei'r o rirtfi tri'zu n 6iarirun n1{ eio il'rdld'u or aor
R = clruru n-r a eir.rvilfi'zu n rio rio uriild'vr or a a:-r
nr:r{fi 3 rrjoir6uainr:6i'osrso.rrfi'or'.col;qrn6'radrrfrnornouui.ruannrilflqq:u?,iri:ifrusrnrirrii'u
ansorsnr:1fT:s16ou
tlt fl :xtJ
nr:1#srnroruorfi-r:
lf' 1lfl#
ufior'lv,lnnqngn:
uff'a b{flriirurud'rodx'
Colistin
Norfloxacin
Amoxycilin
Trimethoprim/
Sulfamethoxazole
Gentamycin
1133512088 150 58
55.68d
89.11
9332d
M"32"
2.5
2933d
80.0
75.83d
23.33"
46.67"
89.33"
89.33d
4133d
5.1'7
22.41"
70"69"
68.91d
9.62d
2.86
22.g6b
6g.57b
68.57b
2.96d
1.16
4335b
g1 .zgb
g6.71b
3g" 15d
14111U[149] r ? =q,r"ruruTn1nfl1)6s E.coli firfionlr t-z lnTnfi oion-rodrr qlnd'xori1{
oaal:vvt.ifi xl ovll-t't [lJ tv'r'l v tldo
b =p<0"05, c:p<0.01 ttn: d=p<0.001
KKU. Vet. J. Vol. ll No. I JANUARY - JUNE 2001
alnr!nRl:fin:elnrifiourlunr:\fi nyjrifi'o E.coli 6'asiasr Timethoprim/Sulfame
rhoxazole rr^y Amo>rycilln lrnfrao 6a 83.1 r:loir6usirvirriu dsaonnfro{nille.Jnalnnr:fin:*r6u1
(Nitsten et a1., 1993; Nilsten et al., 1994; Nristen et al., 1996; Teshager et a1., 2000; van Den
Bogaard et aI.,2000) nr:dasrfrrffor"udrjrsvifrns'rnnr:drulroprrdofrfinr:daurqrnttriqn:qjqn; -
qe L6l a 6 ; t frfiascrnfinr:ld'lrn''r nos:ufrnfi do *a; zu duoru'r:vft [u nn: [n uava n: tn n ttloSn:s'r tun;nrrt ql L:0
frosrfilrrn:I:efrordodurlur,dri:rfrorionTurLrtilutrnrutu (Agerso eL al.. 1998: Markowska-Daniel
ard Pejsak, 1999; Websrer, 1990) dsu,rnzund'sndrraonnfrosriuzuafretrd'ruqn6r,r4ntfrnfiupraoil':rio
colistin ufla{srnleifinr:ld'trtfrndinrgrl:nfror rfrsluan::nlriuru:in unvrinl"fiam,l3ozuararur:-'
rfioinrs.rl:Frvio.rrfiu"luqnqn:rfilrorir.rrdsrrvirriu ua:dntunzuarndsfi6osr Colistin fiqr,r;flitir
n?lxl:urr:.ilJrsarirrzorrdo rriu nmrarrr:n"Lunr:nnnvnautffnt6anrtnstootda a.roti:Jrsd'tu
rrlurifirhnol:n (K BB) rrnn'irrr:rfrndufild'uoaorlun:-td (Sogaard and Larsen, 1983; Sogaard et
a1.. 1983) airuurjoirfiusinr:dot-r Gentamvcin uav Norfloxu"rn loodo E.coli wtf,v 29.33 ttny
33.6 u:Joir6usi nr:reilril s'rrTsodlu:yrirfikidt:nnu-n *nvaonndasri'lzuanr::rutrufrairu:r
(Takahashi et a1., 1990; Duntop er at., 1998ai u*iirsvnnr:td'uru"taostfrndlunr::hr*r1:nrirsl
ocirrnir.irrtmud'rffnr:r orqrilullnri'jTfinr:"16r.r Norfloxacin "lul,lrfuqn:1riu'rurin rrnvhifiu:.t
ldzunruluorr,rr:qn:Tn tnruan',ran:rniauur.r:uq firrtv,hiru'ru"ufild'zualarfir:nnani aitullnrlar
ld'lunr::-nrgr1pradnlll#srdrj'larf]u:rrpir u:rurdrrnlr Gentamycin d.ru:i'irtfluurfrnnldrrtiluura'r;qt" Y
u11-J rrn tiluu't11 L:dd'11.i:tJaFl tvl'luu
ruii'irnr:finure:"{dr6onTaTnfi rrlionourfir.r t-z lnrlaflarnrYradrsacql:vdndRi; X ' q v '^j.? ,, T --=--.--^,ylo.rrRsi frn:rqflLrfro E.coli dwrsairuarqtflu E.ct,,ll nrufru{frknot:n utdnt:fin:crfitiruur 16'
t{lr.{rriuf,rnrrld':rnTud"lunr:rit:rronn-nsruvnr:dorrto.rtfi'o E.coti::tt'ilsaravliudfiriol:oruavhi,s-;,d-jr"f'qqus-qAvaA,l
rioL:n r-ra::J'jraraniudfr LririoL:o ilrc;riJu:lca'seirn'ArLunrr6olrtatartWuQvtnot:n (Sunde et
ur, ,nnr, d,o,i,rtrnl-;nrsrl:n {slilnr:rdontdrrrriruiafinfisr da p.cotifilroaou6'oriaa'r
lunr:finrErdqlan6iilnr:d'nnr:1,{rirduprnrirtn-u rfiodrrururnrrrtai:rvliudrirrunnl:tlFrdaLr *' r ,?' " , ;vntrlhnat rnrucnfrv\"to.irto 7.6t Ii til lailrnt:ilon0.irujLFr?tail:Jaauunru0u't'ivld'lu:Jf^lnn0- & " * -i, , ' -6t "qe^ : 2 - Y -r't,nr:firulrnt:oogrto.t tfro 6sors a.: zu at?xrnil turr tu tflo nrifia Ln? 0.r rta n {uu p.rnlr Lrtalnnri
-*-6d&'q':fr'nr+1fl6r rilu rrlsrnr::'t lsru zu nnredaEJr $L.i Frr3rflcd'trnr:d'nnr:l"hi:llxoeitsfr arlr:n tttnn?lll
ru n n si r s riukid'o rc u"Lu r"l r i il fr vf r n r : fi n sr vr'.r r.l l o rvi tiuernnr:fin:*rdairu:nyw'irfifiaruflsi'Erfinr:ir:neitzualri'ltio E.coti luan:6oriosrriru
^&-.aflr?{xlln?u rru :ynlln1:ldurtuy,lril flq{uff6i.rzuallinnan:tn5ilq $avaltldR: ,fufi, (Dualop
et a1., 1998b; Mathew et al., 1998; Moro et al., 1998; SrnOn et a1., 1998; Mathevu et al., 1999;
Moro et al., 2000) ernzunnr:fin:i.r1uFri{dflil'jr sr Norfloxacin, Tlimethoprim/Sulfamethoxazole,
29
30 _ rficr:finluuvunrcari ils. flfi tt ofufi t iln:rnil - fiqursu zsq+
uav Gentamycin fir:Joir6usinr:6'ourrorrda a."oli dstuT:.rriounaoom-iuttun Hrnn'jrluq
T:'sLSounaaeruurJ:?l (p<0.01) rn"{fiqrn$urnmlfinlnenfir}J vru'ir4n:oruilrnqvfirdo n.colt frttx
Fll'rilnaur6{nmon:aru#ou (Mathew et a1., 1998 ; Mathew et ai., 1999) uasnr:rd'sran:o1tl: r 6l ' ! & lv g .i q
rrn:rrri'r an:orufiouqs rfru [onr n'[unr: uan uil6uud''nsruvrotnr:dourro.t tfia Ld'rrnt-u t-sluq9
n:rf,nor zu anr:f,nr*rn{rd firir{srnnr:dnrsrii riru:rrorsofiur uloi'jr rdo{crnnr:a-ornr:6u1
tuv{rilfi unn sirrnlu rtiu n1:n ua an dn:lrihi'rfr n nrrru rnia o ds tflu ar iusreir n'artos nr: rfru'- u s { q v
q^A-i6Yqnfr oi'ruvrrulu nr:fr n rfroros an a n: uSanr: atrfrrr n frt lfluriu noulunr: a nnr:ilu tijau un r{ggs
nr:ayarrdotuT:tr5ou riluoiu (r-rhiaur:arjurtd'irrjtnajlloioeirtd'ruqun-.ifin6imlrirdrrirsoiu)6 u uAd .j^ vl
rilurlq{uvrr.r zuail1nnt-rInvunil.i ti nfi tflaqlnn?1].t ttnnnl.in1unl:an Ll.i t:ouna09l
, , 6 ;a 61 , , d q q y & Anaiur,,'lriufrfinr:1drr6'rucafrilzuail1uarltr:Lu:vn'rn{ cvx.ton:rnr:6ourlo'itfa E.coli
riast Gentamycin, TlimethoprlmZSrUumetfro"azole, Amoxy.*n, u^, Norfloxacin atnir (p<0.01)
r . a -il,g q, A i ' d v ^ - -!
nnxty{'t1x]14L3.l3.tnr1Ltu'tildx.Ja1u1?dnt t.ia1nn1tflnB1lizu'ru}.r1nv{uanv6uvn?lildx.rv'rufitt:JUtf}u?nuuqq
(Dunlop er al., 1998b; lVlathew er a1., 1998; Sunde et a1., 1998) fi:rusru'jrnr:1d'Norfloxacin
zunuluarur:nn:aur:nrixlfr a.coliu'r'id'ru?riuiifrrJnfrrdrrqi6urfirTnlueirld'hikirfra{qrnnnairri'rl9ug
qrnrd'o E.coli aravliurjiiul viorrrhoqjturirld'nrur:nraiqrfidnloi (Nielsen and schlundt, 1992)
{i{flqd'Erlu"fiodrflu6is eirn"rylunr:rrrrnrrlosnTul:nfr'o'r rfiusrn ldorirtltuv'lrirtufla'iliu rfro.rqrn
:rrrnr:rdziran:fruuruiluuavfinrrrrulnisnrrndu rfrofrqvnruniln1?$dor{ornr:tatl:nq9
airiflu6'otfinr:ld'arzuarorur:an:riJuryuyr'rfl''ruru d'.rriuuurTriunr:dourrdorcrnfinr:td'u'rr.rdr.rav&
a1u1r Lul y Fru d{u1q y}.1:J1n?ug
el'r rn fr nr:1d1v{rXr n n 4 n anafi fi zu atllnr:6'o ur Gentamycin, Tlimethoprim/{q
Sulfamethoxazole, Amoxycillin, ttav Norfloxacin to.rrda E.coli riaar qsn'jr (p<0.05)
nr:ld'lv{uflannanan:utu ilil'ilriaelnnr:finsrn*rdnd'rsri'rzuaqrnnr:finvr?o.i Moro rnu9q
nruy, 1998 dr:rss'ru'jrrf,ioanan:#rriari'uornrrtuurrsvfid'n:rnr:6'arjaslrriruqndvltfr0rdurfi'us99
nfuuf,iooeilunnrrnrfroreiu rfrllrntiuadrrfiuludrri'ru (Moro et al.. 1998) olqoBrralpi'irnr:'ld'!9
lviufiannnndR?qudlrlrrntr,i,nrrruoreiuurinnon:kilrnn'irnr:td'lv{firnnanan: orir.rl:ffnrl9qtucqc
q - ) q_ \9'L S 6] 6? ! e6 dt e v
Lunr:a anrl rvro tu an an:]riir nru oreiurilcyduo riri'rnr: rorlql6io uaflo.i ti'u6'a.r rilu eir druu,i9sss
KKU. Vet. J. Vol. ll No. I JANUARY - JUNE 2001
'i r':j::'jt:::':
.^ :i"'' r;." -9l ,-A* 'r:'"toRfl't:oliloil
Agerso, H., Friis, C., and F{augegaard, J. i998. Water medication of a swine herd
with amoxycilln. J. Vet. Pharmacol. Ther. 21(3) : 199-202-
Bauer, A. W., Kirby, W. M., Sherris, J. C., and T\irck, M. 1966. Antriciotic susceptibilrty
tesring by a srandardized shgle disk method. Am. J. clin. Pathol. a5A) .493-496.
Cheon, D. S., and Chae, C. 1996. Outbreak of drarrhea associated wfih Enterococcus
dttrans in plglets. J. Vet. Diagn. Invest. B(1) : 123-1'24.
Christensen, J., and Svensmark, B. 1997. Evaluatton of producer-recorded causes of
preweanrng mortality in Danish sow herds. Prev. Vet. Med. 32(3-4) : 155-164.
Cutler, R. S., Fahy, V. A., and Spicer, E. M. 1992. Preweanlng mortality. In : Diseases of swine
7'h editlon. A. D. Leman, B. E. Straw, W. L. Mengehng, S. D. Allaire, and D. J. Taylor
(eds.). Ames : Iowa State Univ Press. pp. 847-860.
Dunlop, R. H., McEwen, S. A., Meek, A. H., Black, W. D., Friendshlp, R. M., and Clarke' R. C.
1998 a. Prevalences of resistance to seven antimicrobials among f.ecaI Eschericbia
coli of swine on thlrty-four farrow-to finish farms in Ontario, Canada. Prev. Vet.
Med. 34(4) :265-282.
Dunlop, R. Fi., McEwen, S. A., Meek, A. H., Ciarke, R, C., Black, W. D., and Frtendship' R. M.
1998b. Assocratrons among antrmicrobiai drug treatmenls anci anttntcrobial
resistance of fecal Escbericbia coli of swine on 34 farrow-to-finish farms in Ontario,
Canada. Prev. Vet .Med. 34(4) : 283-305.
Gaslans, H. R., and Kelley, K. W. 1995. Immunology and neonatal mortality. In : The
neonatal pig development and survlval. M. A. Varley (ed.). CAB Internatlonal. pp.
39,55.
GelJrerg, I{ 1989. Porcine rotavirus and the probiems it causes. Vet. Med. B4(4) : 449 452
Hall, W. 1989. A review of colibacillosis in neonatal swine. Vet. Med. B4(4) . 428-431.
Hrj-l, Fi. T. 1989. Preventlng epizootic TGE fiom becoming enzootic TGE. Vet. Med. 84 (4) :
432-436.
Hoefing, D. C. 1989. Recogrnizing dianhea caused lry Clostridium perfringens type C.
Vet. Med. B4(4) : 437-M2.
31
32 llicnr#enuflilufi16lq{ il$. flfi 11 o:iuii t tlflt1nil - fiquruu zs++
Mackinnon, J. D. 1998. Enteritis in the young pig caused l:y Escbe4cbia coli. Pig J'
41 : 227-255.
Markowska-Daniel, I., and Pejsak, Z. 1999. Efficacy of a combination of amoxicillln and
clavulanic acid in the treatment of pneumonia of plgs. DTW Dtsch Tlerarztl
Wochenschr. 106(12) : 51'8-522.
Mathew, A. G., Saxton, A. M., Upchurch, W. G., and Chattin, S. E. 1999. Multiple antibiotic
resistance pattems of Escbericbia coli isolates from swine farms. Appl- Envir.
on Microbiol 65(6) :2770-2772-
Mathew, A. G., Upchurch, w. G., and chattin, s. E. 1998. Incidence of antiblotic resistance in
fecal Eschericbia coll isolated from commerclal swine farms" J. Anim. Sci .76(2) :
429-434.
Moro, M. H., Beran, G. W., Griffith, R. W., and Hoffman, L. J. 2000. Effects of heat stress
on the antimicrobiai drug resistance of Escbericbia coli of the intestinal flora
of swtne. J. Appl. IMicrobiol. BB (5) : 836-844.
Moro, M. H., Beran, G. W., Hoffman, L. J., and Griffith, R. W. 1998" Effects of cold stless on
the antimicrobial drug resistance of Escbericbia coli of the intestinal flora of swine.
Lett. Appl. Microbiol 27(5) :251'-254.
NCCLS. Igg7. Performance Standards fol Antimicroblal Disk Susceptibility Tests-Slx.th
Editiou Approved Standard. NCCLs document N42-A6 (ISBN 1-56238-308-6)NCCLS.
Pennsylvania. pp. 5-8.
Nielsen, E. M., and Sctrlundt, J. 1992. Use of norfloxacin to study colonization ability of
Escbericbia coli in in vivo and in vitro models of the porcine $rt. Antimicrob.
Agents Chemother. 36(2) : 401"-407 '
Nijsten, R., London, N., van den Bogaard, A., and Stobberingh, E. 1993. Antibiotic tesistance
of Enterobacteriaceae isolated ftom the faecal flora of fattening pigs. Vet. O.
15(4) : 152-1'57.
Nijsten, R., London, N., van den Bogaard, A., and Stobberingh, E. 1994. Reslstance in faecal
Escbericbia coli isolated from pigfarmers and abattoir workers. Epidemiol.
Infect. 113(1) : 45-52"
Nljsten, R., London, N., van den Bogaard, A", and Stobberingh, E' 1996' Antibiotic resistance
among Escbericbia coll isolated from faecal samples of pig farmers and pigs.
J. Antimrcrob. Chemother. 37(6) :1131-1140'
KKU. VeI. J. VoI. II No. I JANUARY - JUNE 2OOI
Sogaard, H., and Larsen, J. L. 1983. The effect of antibiotics on mannose-resistant
haemagglutination by KBB- and K99-positive Escb erichia coll strains. J. Vet.
Pharmacol. Thet. 6(3) : 187-193.
Sogaard, H., Larsen, J. L., and Christensen, S. 1983. Cohstul inhibition of mannose-resistant
haemagglutination by KBB- positlve and K99-positive Escberichia coll strains. A
prelimlnary report. Zentralbl. Bal<teriol. Mlkrobioi HyS [A] 254(1) : 64-68.
Sunde, M., Fossum, K., Solberg, A., and Sorum, H. 1998. Antibiotic reslstance in Escbericbia
coli of the normal intestinal flora of swlne. Microb. Drug Resist.4(4):289-299.
Takahashr, I., Yoshida, T., Higashide, Y., and Sakano, T. 1990. Susceptibrhties of. Escbeficbia
coli, Salmonella and Stapltylococct.Ls AureLrs isolated from animals to ofloxacin
and commonly used antimicroblal agents. Jpn. J. Antibiot. a3 (1) : 89-99.
Teshager, T., Herrero, I. A., Porrero, M. C., Garde, J., Moreno, M. A., and Domingmez,L. 2000.
Surveillance of antimicroblal reslstance tn Eschericbia coll strains isolated fiom
pigs at Spanlsh slaughterhouses. Int. J. Antimicrob. Agents. 15(2):137-142.
Vaillancourt, J.-P., and Tbbbs, R. C. 1992. Preweaning mortaUty. Vet. CIin. of North Am.
(Food anim pract). B(3) : 685-706.
van Den Bogaard, A. E., London, N., and Stobberingh, E. E. 2000. Antimicrobtal resistance trr
pig faecal samples from the Netherlands (flve abattoirs) and Sweden. J. Antimicrob.
Chemother. 45(5) : 663 671.
Webster, C. J. 1990. Parenteral amoxycilhn/clavulanate in the treatment of drarrhoea ln young
pigs. Vet. Rec. 126(15):363-364
rStt
33