32

x O UQ Cq · 2012-07-30 · x Qov m VQ R o t Q P B C rw wU O UQ Cq k U y oW vO OwQw v w tR p U tw WwQ Q vt B Q ICM u Hu O u twO x Ov y t yO Q o xD WQ U v m xQwO R r v TwQO UQ O Q

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

�rrtr�u�� xQovm � � VQ�Ro ��rt �Q�PBC�rw�wUt� �xO�UQ Cq�kt �xr�ktQU� �yy�oWv�O �OwQw ��yvwtR� p��Ut w �yWwQ Q�v�tU ���B Q� � ICM���� u�yH u�v�O���� Qu�twO� �xOv�� ��y���tyOQo ���� Q xDWQ �U�vWQ�m �xQwO R�r�v� TwQO �UQQ� OQoR�tQ�H Q�v�tU u�tyORv�B u�wN�Qi� u�Q�� ���� Q VRwt�Tv�Qivm u�tWW� �SwrwB wD w xUOvy Q�v�tUu�rw�� QwWm ���� Q Tv�Qivm u�tQ�yJ w �U� QwWm ���� Q R�r�v� Q�v�tU u�tyOR�U� QwWmw �U�vWu�Q�� �xv�W�B �UQQ� ��yV��ty xrUrU� u�Q�� RtQ utHv� Tv�Qivm u�twO xr�kt u�wN�Qi�raOtLt QDmO�tra xt�v�oOvR �xYqN� ��y xt�v�oOvR w Rm �Qt�iQat RwQt� �D u� ��yOQw�DUO���� Q utHv� �����vW�� OyWt�UwOQi x�oWv�O���� Q swra xOmWv�O �xJN� Q�D� O�Svxrr�O�aQwBu�QW�v w u�ir�wt R� CwaO ��L�Yt u�ULtqe xR��H � C����� Q �xyO� ��y �yo � s��NwCU��� u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� ��yxt�vQ� R�C��tL� C�aq � �Qw�OQo� x�aq �� ���� Q Q�F�u�Q�� sra G� wQD xR��H u�tHvB u�wN�Qi� C�Q��eD �yo �� QwWm �� wHWv�O ���� Q xk��Ut u�tDiysQi� �U�vWQ�m �xQwO ZLt w ���� Q xDWQ TwQO �QovR��� �xO�UQ ��yxt�v w Q��N���QwWC��wYt xYqN ���� Q xDWQ�U�vWQ�m �xQwO R�r�v� TwQO ��wDLt OQwt QO�HvUQ�vu�DUNv ��yRwQ �xJN� Q�D� �m�vwQDmr� CqHt� uwo �vwo �C�� QWv �iQat ����QH�u��t�L� ���� �v�rv�wv xR��H w ROr�i p�Ot u�oOvQ�� C����� Q ��Q� p�� �xR��H� ROr�i p�Otu�Q�� ���� Q utHv� ��yQ�v�tU w �yUv�Qivm s� wkD � u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� �kwkL ���a� w

xJ QwWm ���� Q xat�H QO�OQPo�t

��yy�oWv�O OWQ��U�vWQ�m �OwQw uwtR� ��yxJQDiO �� RwD R�TB��QwW pqLv� R� TB QwWm VRwt� w VHvU u�tR�U xm OW swratxOQm sqa��DUD�ki �Q �OwQw uwtR� w xOQtW svDet �Q �kwt �R� Qxt�vQ�xrtH R� OW�� xDW�O �r�qOVHvU u�tR�U CU� umtt xD�r� �CU�xm ���y�UQQ� j�� �� w CU� QDCL�Q ��xrLQtl� �DUD uwtR� xmv����� QkD K� QWD w CUD uwtR� w �yvD �DUD uwtR� CU� xOQw� pta x�

�OvQw��t Q�� x� �Q u�Um� �H��Dv

Qwmvm �DUD uwtR� xr�U u�OvJ x� QHD ��� �OW�� u�vJ xm s�vmZQiTB QO j�ta lQO R� Q�Qi w �L�U �Q�oO�� u� ��D QO w �QU�QUTB u�� R� ��� �CU�v �i�m �yv�DUQ��O QO xUOvy XwYN� ���� Q�xUOvy w Q�H �R�r�v� ��yx��k pODUt �Q�oO�� x� �D�eQ u�� wHWv�O

�O�O Ovy�wN u�Wv

xUOvy �� w xUOvy �v��t TwQO R� uwJ xm s�O�O xDWPo ��yr�U QOxvwoJ �OwW�tv VUQB OWQ� �U�vWQ�m �OwQw uwtR� QO p�Uv�Qi�Ou�� wHWv�OTB u�� R� ��� �Ovvm�t T�B� u�WOwN pwk x� �Q TwQO u���r��tD wr�U ��yx��k w uwQ�w CW�ov x��k �Q�oO�� w pqODU� x�

�CW�O Ovy�wN

xt�vQ�Nu�Q�� ���� Q utHv�

�� pUrUt �xQ�tW ����� R���B �� �xQ�tW �� p�U

Q�v Q� R xm CU� u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� ��Q�N �x� QWv xt�vQ�N�OwW�t QWDvt pYi Qy u���B QO utHv� ����QH� ��QwW

�CU� O�R� PN��t QmP �� �r��t pkv

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� �R��Dt��L�YO�Ry� �Oyt �pw�wUt Q�Ot

u��v�twD I�OQot �Q��OQU

QoRQ� �ra �x� Q� QLD C���yu��v�twD I�OQot�t�QN OtLt

�Ovyv�Q�R O�WQx�wNv��rU u� QUv�Jr�kOt ��Q�ra�tU�� lt��U

�u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� QDiO � SRP�TEX ��v�JiwQL�Q��DN� xv�Ui� �xQ�tW u�� Q�mty

��i�LY w �A�J ��i�QowD�r� u�UL s�t� x�oWv�O C�Q�WDv� w A�J �xUU�wt

���� �S�Q�D�C���� Q u�DUw� pN�O �OvR u�Ns� Qm u����N u�QyD

u�Q�� ��� Q utHv� �xv�NQ��O���� �� �DUB jwOvY

������� w ������� �������� �Q��tv w uirDiranmath�ims�ir �l�vwQDmr� CUBhttp���www�ims�ir �x�orRvt

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N �

xO�UQ Cq�kt

��rt �Q�PBC�rw�wUtO�Svu� Q� OwaUt

arian�mail�znu�ac�ir

�xar��t CtLR CU� umtt xm ��xrYwLQB �xOvv�wN R�u� �U��U sa w uLr Q �N x� OR�U Q�wty OwNQ� �Q xr�kt u��CU��U xv w CU� CU��U py� xv xOvQ�ov �sy�wN�t QPal�r �CU� �QDQw�vyB w p�Y� �xYQa nvyQi w sra �Q�ov��w� Qt p�L Qy QO wCU� uO�O w uOw� R� sQHq �yhQL�NQ�CU� u�DU�O u�� syi ����DL� �QW xwqa� �s�W�� xm Qw QyKQ QO CU� �WqD xr�kt u�� ���r xRvD w �v�Wvx�W�L xvCU� TwULt �t u��t QO u� �r�N ��H xm ���yiQL R� �awv�Q �t �twta CmQL w Q�DiQ CU� umtt �yv� �xQ�� QO woDio w

�Ovm QDrt�m �tm

uqm KQ� R� ��xO� Ro� QDiO C�aw�wt pNOt R� h�OQ wO�CU� u�vJ � QwWm C����� Q p��Ut �UQQ�

u�v�O���� Q �Q�mty rH w ���U�vW ��QwWm R� GQ�N s�kt �v�Q��

�rrtr�u�� ��y���DQ� xaUwD ��

QDiO u�� r��t xQ�� QO �t�H �FL� CYQi OwN �kwt x� O��Wu� w�va u��t R� Q�N� u�wva wO Q� CU� �QPo p�P xDmv �O�� sy�Qi

�Cw�iDt ��x� w�R R� w QDiO u�� Q��U�wO Q� dr�� �m� Qt� �D�k�kLD xHOw� ���� Q�t�DBU syOR�� EO�wL R� Oa�OQ��r�t ��� OwOL x� QqO OQ��r�t ��� OwOL R� w Ci�� V��Ri� Q��Q�w �t�v h�Oy� xHwDt QDW�� xHOw� V��Ri� u�� xD�r� ��O�UQ QqOR� �Q�OCyH ��yOQ� Q�m pt�W �QFm � xm �i�Oy� �CU� �Y�N �traG��Q ��vO ��H xty QO uwvm �sy xm �m�U x� hQ�aDt C�k�kLD xRwLTwULt Q�F� xFO�L u�� Ow� QDvt O��� xmCUwQv�� R� w OwW�t R�vCU��OwR x� R�v ��vO �D�k�kLD ��y�Q�oCyH w C�k�kLD xvLY Q� �Q OwN�yQwWm �t�v w �U��U���wQV��Q� xFO�L u�� xm xvwov�ty OyO u�WvOW Hwt xrtH R� w OQm Q��U� C�Q��eD VwNDUO CaQU x� R�v �QQ�Qk �FO�wL OvD ��yu�QL� ZQat QO �t uwJ ��xDi��v xaUwD ��yQwWm�Q �yu� �tra xS� w� w �a�tDH� w �rt C�OwHwt CU� umtt xm OvQ�o

�OyO Q�Qk �DNU C�t�r w C�Q��Nt �� wQQOwQ

p�P QO jwi h�OQ wO GQO ��tvQwO R� Q�UiD l� xtOkt u�� ��R� �WQ�Ro ��QwWm C����� Q p��Ut �UQQ� uqm KQ R� ��xO� Ro� QDiO �sy�Qi O�Ry� �Oyt QDmO Cty x� xm CU� �C����� Q OQ�W�B �rt �xD�tm� ��yC�r�ai

�CWo QWDvt u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� hQ R� ���� x�tOviU� QO w CU� xOW�u�Q�� l� R�i Tv�Qivm �x�L�DDi� �v�QvNU ��QwYvt ��Q QDmO R� s�kQ� pkv �

����� u�DU��D �u�HvR x�oWv�O ��Dw�F Tv�Qivm

uwvm � sy ��QU�QU uwtR� QO x� QHD xty u�� R� Oa� xmCU�r�HuwtR� p��kt QO �OwW�t VqD �DUD uwtR� hPL QO x�v�H xty Qw� x�

�OwW�t sqa� �DUD CQwY x� OWQ� �U�vWQ�m �OwQw

u� wOD xm O�DUy �r�t �CU� �y�oWv�O �R� Qxt�vQ� �swO �w�wtw� CU� xOW pwLt x�oWv�O l� x� ���� Q swra TwQO ��yxt�vQ����v�wD QOkv� x�oWv�Ol� ��� �Qo�O �y�oWv�O x� �Q��O ���� Q TwQOQO�m u�wD OL QO �ki �� w O��tv �R� Qxt�vQ� x�v�H xty Qw� x� xm OQ�O

�OQm Oy�wN �R� Qxt�vQ� OwN xk�rU �� w �WRwt�

�YYND ��yUv�Qivm QO �rY� TwQO xt�vQ� xm CU� u�� Q�Dv�OQwt �Q �yxt�vQ� u�� pwwUt x�oWv�O w OwW u� wOD u�YYNDt �UwD w�y�wNQv CyH �Q u� xt�vQ� p�tmD R�TB C��yv QO w OyO Q�Qk xHwDp�ta� w O�it C�Qv pwYL R� TB w O��tv p�UQ� �yy�oWv�O xty x���yywQo X�N ��yYYND p�L u�a QO �O��tv u� wOD �Q xt�vQ� ��yv��Q��DN� u�wva x� OL�w �� OwOL QO �va� �OvW�� xHwD OQwt ���� Q

�OwW xO�O Q�Qk �yy�oWv�O Q��DN� QO

�rai VwQ �CU� �QDmO ��yxQwO �OwQw uwtR� �swU �w�wtxDiQ�PB QO �QDW��Tv�W x�oWv�O Qy u�� wHWv�O ��� QkD xm CU� u�vJ�QDtm �rw�k Tv�W u� R� GQ�N u�� wHWv�O w x�oWv�O u�ty QO uOWhrDNt ��yy�oWv�O QO uwtR� OQwt TwQOCaUw p�L u�a QO �OvQ�O

�CU� O�� R Q��U�

uwtR� OWQ� �U�vWQ�m xQwO �t�Rr� TwQO R�CU� QDy� OQwt u�� QOxHwD O�t� x� �OwW u�Um� u��r�w�O ��Q� VQ�PBTv�W �D O�� pta x�

�xrr���Wv� �jwi OQ�wt x� QwWm ���� Q xat�HQ��OQU

� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

C� wkD x� u�Q�� �� �DUwO w KrY R� �rrtr�u��C��tL C� wkD CyH QOumtt j� Q�l� xm �iOy �OR�OQB� QwWm R� GQ�N QO u�Q�� �tra x��k �a�v�Q�� ���� Q u�OvtWv�O �� u�Q�� ���� Q xat�H �tra x���Q C� wkD u��tra ���wQ xv�QovQwOC� wkD sy wCU� u�yH xWwo Qy QO QkDUt Q��D

���vO ���� Q ��yutHv� w�yv�tR�U �� �rrtr�u��

��yQwWm QO um �U �v�Q�� QH�yt uw�r�t OvJ �p�YiDQ�B �r�qO x�u�Q�� R� C��tL QO �QFwt w p�ai ��q w x��k �a x� p�O�D �m� Qt� w �B wQ�sy u�� �OQ�y�Q �Q��OD �� xm�r�L QO �Ov�xOWv u�Q�� x� x�ov Ow�y� wQy �v�Uv� ��ywQ�v xm OW�� xar��t p��k w pwkat �y�oO�O Ov�wD�tu� QH�yt w OvDU�v u�tRQU u� ��yQyW w �yCWO u�vm �U �yvD �Drth�Oy� x� CtON QO �Dt�k�P �v�Uv� ��yx��tQU uwJ Ovv�wD�t R�v

�OvwW xOv�wN�Qi QwWm �rt �i�vt w �v�Uv�

OwN ���QH� w �vi OwOLt Q��U� C�QwOkt OL QO utHv� xm sv�O�t�� QDW�� q�tDL� w� �CU� xDW�OQ� Q�Ut wO u�� x�Q QO xOvRQ� ���ys�oVQDUo �� sy utHv� sQ�wO�t� p�L u�a QO �t� ���tra �iQYC�v u�tyOwN Q�OkD p��k C��� QHD R� �wv u�� T�mav� �� sy w �yC�r�ai xvwov����Q� �Q ���� Q xat�H O�L� xty s�kDUt w K� QY �Qmity w COa�Ut

�Ovm O�OtDU� �ys�o xvwo u�� � �U�w�t �U�

x� u�yH Q�vm w xWwo QO �Q��U� Q��D �v�Q�� �� �v�Q�� u�v�O���� Q�CU�yv� �iQat w ���U�vW pw� syt s�o �OvrweWt VywSB w Q�mx� �w� Qt �wvDt p��Ut QO �yv� �Qmity w CmQ�Wt rH swO s�oQO A�J ��Q� xr�kt CU�wNQO ��yv� xrtH R� �CU� QwWm ���� QC�Qv x�kv CU�wNQO ��Qw�O ��Q� xr�kt ��HQ� �pN�O �tra CqHtCyH QwWm pN�O C�� QWv w CqHt p�UQ� q��kDt sy w C��� QHD ws�Ok� u�� �� x�Qty ��v�Uv� w �tra ��Qmi ���wQC� wkD w xv�tR O�H��xaUwD w wHDUH ��Q� ����� Q utHv� QDW�� pta CaQU w �tOkW�BQo�O prt ���� Q ��yutHv� �� �tra C��U�vt w C�ty�iD R� �awv

�CU� u�tRwQt� ��yR��v x� pta w syi QO �QwQ� �t�o

R� �WN� QwWm R� GQ�N QO u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� w xat�H Q� wYDR� Q�PoQ�F�D w syt �WN� sy Q� wYD u�� w CU� u�Q�� �tra Q� wYD�CU� RwQt� ���vO QO �t xat�H R� �rrtr�u�� lQO w �krD ��tvQwOC�YNW dwr� R� ��xv�Wv sy p��Ut R� x�vH u�� QOEL� w Q��OD w KQ�

�CU�t xawtHt w utHv� �rt �Q�PBC�rwwUt w�����

����y���Woy�Q w �yCYQi sy xmCU��Dkw xty ��ywRQ� u�� �t� wsra py� sy w OvW�� OwHwt �CU�t C�Q��DN� xvt�O R� GQ�N �NQ� xm����QW Qy QO �yv� CtLR w jWa GvQDUO xm OvQ�PB� w Ov��� u�v�t��

�Ow� Oy�wN �rt ��yxDNwOv� R� ��xQ�NP

sQ�wO�t� w CU� xOQm pkv ut ��Q� �Q �yWqD u�� R� �LQW �Jv�N R� Ra ��k� ��OR�U xO�t� sy Q�WDv� ��Q� �Q u� R� �WQ�Ro

��� ��xO� Ro� QDiO QO ���� Q xat�H �wQV�B w RwQ p��Ut w u� w�vaQO Ov�wD�t �yC�r�ai xvwo u�� R� �W�v �tra �iQY C�Q�Dv� R� Q�e x�Ow�y� OYk x� VqD �� Q�Ut QO uDW�OQ� s�o �x�wN�v x�wN �p�L u�a

�OW�� sy u�Q�� �tra xat�H w u�Q�� x� �rrtr�u�� x�ov

uwO� �rt w �U��U syt s�tYD I�y �RwQt� xDiQW�B �t�wH QOsy w �a�tDH� w �tra u�R�OQBx� Qv w u� QmiDt C��tL w xv�wDWB��yutHv� �yv� xrtH R� xm �vwo �vwo �vOt ��yO�yv w �yu�tR�UC��tLu�� �CU�v QwOktCU� �atH ���DQ� p��Uw sy w �y�oWv�O w �traw �y�oS� w x� �v� xm OvDUy �awvDt ��yQ�Ri� �k�w QO �yv�tR�U w �yO�yv��y�Ov�x�q w �yVN� QO �Q xat�H O�L� j�iD� x�� Qk �Dw�iDt C�kraDUL �sy �yv� hQ�aDt ��yOQmQ�m R� �m� w Ovvm�tl�miD �� wDQOwDxQ�� QO OwN VWwB CLD ��yC�atH ���wt sqa� w Q�R�� u�mt� �R��v�yO�yv w �yu�tR�U u�� ��Q� w ���wt GDvt �CU� RwQ w �Q�H p��UtC�L�HQD �a��� ��yxv�tR QO xD�r� w �rt Oa� QO KQ�t u� QmiDt sy wQHvt �rUt ��yCQOk �i�vt u�yvB w �O�B C�e�r�D w �ovyQi X�N��DQD u�� x� xm �rta �OwW�t pta� ��Q� �yCrwO stYt sRa x�w CaQU x� �CU�v Qiv OvJ �� l� s�tYD x� �mDt u� OYk uwJ wxm CU� �R�J u� C�y�t u�� �OwW�t �vDiQ�PB w xHwt �oO�U x��rta �pta sRa xrLQt x� �Q �Qe u�yH R� �WN� w �m� Qt� xRwQt�U�vt Vvm �w ��NDv� ��Q� �t w CU� xOv�UQ swrat V���tm w xS� wqt�m u�� w s�W�� pi�e u� QF� w �Q�opmW Ov��Qi j�kO CN�vW R� O���v�rrtr�u�� ��yx��wD uwJ �t�y�it R� �t Q�UiD xmv�� R� CU� pkDUt

�CU� xvwoJ u� Ovv�t w �� Qe pwO �Q�taDU� ��yOQmrta w

u�� QO �CU� u�� p�wU l� w s�DUy C�a�w u�� QO uwvm � syw C�mQLD w x�kQDtQ�e EO�wL xOW R�e� ��yu�iw� O��OvD QO ����QW��Q� RwQ Qy �k� ���QW CU� umtt xm �rrtr�u�� �rUt ��yCU��UC�t�qD w �rt�Qi �O�YDk� w �U��U ��yC��kQ w OwW QDCNU �tC�ty�iD w sr�U ��yC��kQ xvt�O uOQm QDOwOLt xJ Qy u�tm QO �t�vx� u�Q�� ���� Q xat�H w utHv� ���CU� prt xty sOQt �tra w �v�Uv���yC�iQ w u�W R� O��� QwWm xHwt w �tra ��yO�yv R� �WN� u�wva�H�Qt w �yO�yv Q� �QwOkt OL QO �C�Ft �Q�PoQ�F�D ��Q� OwN ��v�wDC�Uv �� �OW�� pi�e �m� Qt� w �B wQ� QO xS� w� u�yH �y�oWv�O w �tra��yVqD pYL�t w xv�tR Q� s�a C�rm u�� Q�PB�vR� Qo C�Q�F�D x�EO�wL �xHwD �� �j�kLD w Q�m xDU� ��yj��� QO �DL �OwN �traQ�N� p�Ul��� QO QwWm OWQ� u�Q�Otsy w sOQt sy xm�awkwr�ptDLt���yxt�r Ea�� Ov�wD�t xm Qw�v�ty Ov�xDW�O �Qv� O�ONQ s�� xQ�wtyOv�wD�t OOQo �t ��BxR�D�U�QmwtO w�a�tDH� p�yvwv ��yxv�t�U Q� �OHw �tra pt�mD OvwQ w xaUwD Q�QtDU� QO �Qo�O ���kv� w Q�N�D Hwt

�OwW QwWm ���� Q

Ov�wD�t �DrwOQ�e w pkDUt �O�yv u�wva x� u�Q�� ���� Q utHv�

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N �

u�wva CLD xDa�U l� �v�QvNU �� �xQovm u�� �Q�RoQ� COt QO��yxv �tR QO QwyWt u� v�O��� � Q �Uw D �Plenary Lectures�

u� oO vQ � ��y � v�Q vNU u �� x rtH R� x m O �OQ o x ��Q� ��� � Q hrDNt� v�Q vNU ��! O�Oa D u�vJty �O vOw � � v � r v�w v w ROr �i ��yp�Ot�atH �UwD �Invited lectures� u�wvaCLD ��xk�kO GvB wpyJ�waOt u�v�O���� Q u�� xrtH R� xm O�OQo x��Q� ��vO �wN u�v�O���� Q R�u�W��� Ow� �m� Qt� wOQ"B x�oWv�O pYq� �v�Q�� O�DU� �O�yW QwUiwQB�# QO �v�QvNU u�� �OvW���t R�v u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� �Q�NDi� w�a

�Ow� xOW s�UkD Q� R CQwY x� VN�

xUOvy $!��Qiv #� O�Oa� x� Qv $� ��Qiv %� Q�H $� ��Qiv �� j�vt $�xUOvy w �rDNt xUOvy $� ��Qiv #� �SwrwB wD $� ��Qiv ��� p�Uv�Qi�OR�r�v� $% ��Qiv ��� V��tv x� Qv w �r ��yywQo $& ��Qiv &� �Q�H��Qiv �� �a��D R�r�v� w �yQorta Q�H $# ��Qiv %� �k�kL w �rDNtC�kDWt �� p�Uv�Qi�O CqO�at $�� ��Qiv ��� p�tDL� w Q�t� $����ytDU�U w � rwtat p�U v�Qi �O CqO� at $�� ��Qi v ��� � �RHC����mQD $�! ��Qiv ��� ���� Q l� R�i $�� ��Qiv ��� �m�t�v�O$�& ��Qiv &� �OOa R�r�v� $�� ��Qiv �� QDw�Bt�m swra $�� ��Qiv %���Qiv �� C����� Q VRwt�$�% ��Qiv ��� swra QO C����� Q OQ� Q�m

�Qiv �� C����� Q M� Q�D $�#

w ��xk�kO xOR v� B � v�QvNU CQwY � R� v xr�kt ���� u�vJty�O�OQo x��Q� C����� Q ��yxv�tR �t�tD QO QDUwB

w ��Dm x�oW ��t v � �� B Q � �xQovm u �� ��vH ��yxt� vQ� xrtH R���yvtH v� u�vJty �Ow � hrDNt u�QW� v �Uw D ��� � Q CqHtOwN ���a� x�rm �� CUWv l� ��RHt CQwY� �m� Qt� w uOvr ���� Q

�OvOwtv Q�RoQ�

Mathematical �Zentralblatt Math u � rww U t xwq a �Q�RoQ� �xOW A�J Cq�kt u�oOvvmOkv Q�NDi� x� �v�ty�tl� Review

�OvOwtv

�Oa � xQovm xm O �OQo sqa� �tUQ �R� v xQovm u �� x�t�DDN� QOOW Oy�wN Q�RoQ� ��v�BU� QwWm QO �ICM����� u�yH u�v�O���� Qu�� QO p�ai CQwY� xm OW CU�wNQO �u�yH u�v�O���� Q s�tD R� w

�Ov��tv CmQW xQovm

Vvtv�Q�� �rau�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xOv��tvTQOt C�� QD x�oWv�O ���� Q VN� Q��Wv�O w

VQ�Ro

u�yH u�v�O���� Q �rrtr�u�� xQovm�ICM����

u�J � ���� x�tQw� QyW � C��er x�tO�OQt �

��y���tyOQo xrtH R� �ICM� u�yH u�v�O���� Q �rrtr�u�� xQovmxHwD �� �OOQo�t Q�RoQ� Q��m� p�U Q�yJ Qy xm CU� ���� Q syt�rrtr�u�� x�O�LD� Cki�wt w p�k xQwO R� xDiQo CQwY �R� Qxt�vQ� x�umB QyW QO w u�J QwWm QO ICM���� ��IMU� u�yH u�v�O���� QQ�yJ OwOL �xQwO u�� QO �O�OQo Q�RoQ� �Q�H p�U x�tO�OQt QN�w� QOOYQO �� OwOL xm OvDW�O Qw�L u�yH QU�QU u�v�O���� Q R� Qiv Q�RyQiv �� OwOL u�Q�� R� w OvO�O�t p�mWD �v�J u�v�O���� Q �Q �yv�

�OvOw� xOQmCmQW u�O���� Q

nv��J� ��k� u�J QwytH T��Q xm xQovm u�� x�L�DDi� xUrH QOFields and� �v�rv�wv w ROr�i ��yxR��H CW�O Qw�L R�v u�tR

�OW �Oy� u�O���� Q xU x� �Nevanlinna Prizes

p� wv xR��H �� R�QDty w�CU����� Q xR��H u� QDQ�Dat xm ROr�i xR��Hxm u�O���� Q OvJ ��l� x� Q��m� p�U Q�yJ Qy �CU�yxDWQ Q��U ��Q����� Q QO xDUHQ� Q��U� �Q�F� w OvW�� uU p�U pyJ QFm �OL ��Q�O

�OwW�t �Oy� OvW�� xOQm QWDvt

�OvOw� Qiv wO �xQwO u�� QO ROr�i xR��H u�oOvQ�

QwWm QO ��xUUwt R� LAURENT LAFFORGUE QwUiwQB $��Institut des Havtes Etudes Scienti�ques� s�v� xUv�QiO�H�� w �Langlands program� QO s�aCiQW�BCra x� xm Ow�xR��H u�� Ci�� QO xDU��W �R�r�v� w O�Oa� x� Qv u�� O�OH ���DQ� l�

�O�OQow�a w pYq��UwQVLADIMIR VOEVODSKY QwUiwQB $�x� Qv xaUwD Cra x� xm �m� Qt� uwDUv� QB xDiQW�B C�ar��t xUUwtx� Qv x� O�OH C�aq�� j� QRD w �Q�H ��yxD� Q�w QO �Swrwtwywmsqa� xD�r�' �O�OQo xR��H u�� Ci�� QO xDU��W �Q�H xUOvy w O�Oa�ROr�i xR��H Ci�� QO CyH u�O���� Q l� �ki �xOv�� xQwO R� O�OQoMADHU QwUiwQB ��v�rv�wv xR��H xOvQ� u�vJty (�OW Oy�wN��NDv�Ow� �m� Qt�CUwJ�U�t�DavY xUUwt w�a w pYq��Ovy SUDAN�Ow� xO�v�UQ s�Hv� x� QDw�Bt�m swra xv�tR QO �� wN Q��U� ��yWywSB xmu�v�O���� Q �rrtr�u�� x�O�LD�T��QT�r�B QwUiwQB�UwD u�W�� xR��H

�O�OQo �Oy� u�yH

��yQ�m l� Qy R�v u�O���� Q xU u�� �xQovm u�� �Q�RoQ� pw� QO�OvO�O x��Q� xDa�U l� �v�QvNUl� �� �Q OwN

� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

Q�Qk �UQQ� w EL� OQwt Q� R p��Ut �sOw� u� w�a R�vv�Hv�� xm ����CiQo

�Ovm�t OQ�w �v�DUQ��O VRwt� Q� �Q ���y��U� xJ �rai Qwmvm $��U� u� uOQ� u�� R� Qwvt x� �Qwmvm ��Q� �rLx�Q xJ OQwt Qy QO $�

�OwW�t O�yvW�B�v��V�B O��� �y��U� u�� pL ��Q� VQwQB w VRwt� �Q �D�mQ�OD xJ $�

�Ovm�OQ�O �y�oWv�O VRwt� Q� �Q ���y��U� xJ �rai Qwmvm $!

�OwW�t O�yvW�B�U� u� uOQ� u�� R� ��Q� �rLx�Q xJ OQwt Qy QO $�QO Ov�wD�t ��yv� R� ���mQD ��� s�Om �Q�v�tU x� xOW x��Q� ��yLQ� R� $�

�OW�� QFwt Qwmvm Cqat pL CyHpL ��Q� uw�U�tm ���yv pLx�Q �xOW KQ�t EL��t x� xHwD �� $&

�CU�J �Qwmvm pmWt

�QU�QU Qwmvm ��Q� �O�yvW�B ��yLQ� Q�v�tU u�� QO u�vJtyR� �OvOw� xO�UQ A�J x� �Cq�kt xawtHt ��Dm QO xm Ow� xOW x��Q�VHvU u�tR�U �wU R� xOW x��Q� KQ� ��O�yvW�B ��yLQ� xrtHwHWv�O VQ�PB �k���D xar��t� KQ� u�� u�wva �Ow� QwWm VRwt�u�� QO �Ow� �QU�QU uwtR� O�OH KQ� w uB�S w u�J ��yQwWm QO��yQwWm QO wHWv�O Vv� Ro xwLv R� �D�aq�� w Q�t� x��Q� ut� KQ�KQ� u�� xmCU� xOwtv x��Q� O�OH �LQ�VHvU u�tR�U �uB�S w u�JC��y � wYD R� Oa� w xDWo s�vD xL�q l� CQwY� Q��L p�L QOKQ� u�� T�U� �OW Oy�wN p�UQ� �tqU� ��QwW TrHt x� CrwOx�rm w GQ�N �D��kQ Cr�L R� �twta TwQO xm xDiQo Q�Qk �v�t u�� Q�CmQW �twta TwQO uwtR� QO Ovv�wD�t ��yy�oWv�O x� OwQw u��r�w�O�CU� Q�Dat p�U wO �D u� G��Dv ���YvOL uDW�O CQwY QO w xOQmhPL �Qwmvm ��yUqmVy�mEa�� ��D��kQCr�L R� TwQO u�� hPL

�OW Oy�wN �yxO�wv�N ��Q� �yxv� Ry Q�� Vy�m w �v�t�D u�trat

u��r�w�O �r�YLD j��wU QF� �KQ� u�� QO Qo�O syt w xOta Q��eDQO nvy�ty ��yvwtR� �Q�RoQ� CQwY QO �CU� wHWv�O VQ�PB QOxQtv QO ��yvwtR� u�� G��Dv ��y�oWv�OV�B xQwO �� x�UwDt xQwO u���Bj��wU Q�F�D �Ow� Oy�wN QFwt �yy�oWv�O x� OwQw ��Q� u��r�w�O pmuOv�wN �kta w u�DUQ��O x� QDW�� xHwDEa�� �x�UwDt xQwO �r�YLD

�OwW�t u��r�w�O

qFt �Ow� Oy�wN �YYND TQO OvJ R� �yvD �QU�QU uwtR�l� R�i ����� Q TQO xU R� �yvD ��vi ���� Q xwQo u��r�w�O uwtR�

�Ow� Oy�wN �t�W w

p�Ut w �yWwQ �UQQ� Q�v�tU ���B Q��yy�oWv�O �OwQw ��yvwtR�

Ov��Qi wU l� R� xm �yy�oWv�O �OwQw ��yuwtR� �� ��DQt p��Utw xO�O Q�Qk Q�F�D CLD �Q �y�oWv�O �WRwt� w �twta xQwO �WRwt�w u�v�wH �U��U w �a�tDH� �ovyQi ��v�wQ CtqU Qo�O �wU R�VQov w xv�U�vWQ�m w j�kO �UQQ� x� R��v �xDN�Ov� Q�N x� �Q �yxO�wv�N

�OQ�O u� �ivt w C�Ft C�QF� x� j�ta

��yy�oWv�O �Q�mty �� u�yiY� C����� Q xv�N �T�U� u��Q��u�yiY� VQwQB w VRwt� u�tR�U w u�yiY� �DavY w u�yiY���yvwtR� p��Ut w �yWwQ �UQQ� Q�v�tU �Q�RoQ�CyH �Q sRq C�t�Ok�u�� �tra xD�tm w OvO�O Q�Qk OwN Q�m QwDUO QO �Q �yy�oWv�O �OwQwCwaO u�QvL�Y w u�trat �u�kkLt s�tD R� ��yo �VNB �� �Q�v�tU�� �D��yv �Ov��tv x�Qa Q�v�tU QO x��Q� ��Q� �Q OwN�k�kLD Cq�kt �D OQmx�tQP� ��C��er �� M� Q�D R� Q�v�tU u�� ��yy�oDUO R� ��a�C��tLu�� QO xOvvmCmQW O�Qi� �O�OQo Q�RoQ� u�yiY� x�oWv�O QO %� p�U�QwWm ��yy�oWv�O R� �v�oOv��tv �QDUwB w Cq�kt u�oOvyOx��Q� �Q�v�tUVHvU u�tR�U R� �v�oOv��tv �QwWm �tra ��yvtHv� R� �v�oOv��tv

�OvO�O�t p�mWD VQwQB w VRwt� w QwWm VRwt�

�R� OvOw� CQ��a Q�v�tU �rY� C�aw�wt�� QHD �� �Qv ��y� wJQ�yJ ��v�tQ� O�OH ��yrLx�Q x��Q� �hr�

Qwmvm �k���D xar��t��Qwmvm ��a�tDH� w �OQi� �v�wQ �U�vW�U� �G

Qwmvm �WRwt� w �O�YDk� ��a�tDH� ��ovyQi O�a�� �O

�YYND ��yvw�U�tm �CW�O �OQ�y�Q hOy Q�v�tU u�� xm �Hv� R��O�OQo p�mWD Q� R u� w�va ��

�yOQ�y�Q w �WRwt� �U�vW�U� uw�U�tm ���yOQ�y�Q w �v�wQ �U�vW�U� uw�U�tm ��

�yOQ�y�Q w �O�YDk� w �a�tDH� �U�vW�U� uw�U�tm ��wHWv�O VQ�PB QO �yy�oWv�O w VQwQB w VRwt� Vkv uw�U�tm �!

�y�oWv�O Cq�YLD xt�O� ����kD �R�Uxv�y� uw�U�tm ��

R� �m� QO OwN xkqa �� w XYND ULQ� xOvvm CmQW O�Qi�xDU�wN OQ�wt �xUrH u�OvJ �� w �OvDW�O C� w�a �yvw�U�tm u���UwD C�Qv �Ov��tH R�TB w OW xO�O MU�B ��yvw�U�tm u�� R� xOW�q�� x� syt C�mv ��yvw�U�tm u�rwwUt OQoR�t QO ��yvw�U�tm u�rwwUt�O�yvW�B ��yrLx�Q w C�Qv u�� xm OW QQkt w O�UQ u�oOvvmCmQW x�rm�OQ� xQy� C�Qv u�� R� R�v u�tR�U �D OOQo sqa� QwWmVHvU u�tR�U x�x� C�Qv u�� T�mav� R�TB xm OvO�O pwk R�vVHvU u�tR�U u�oOv��tvxQ�tW uw�U�tm QO xvwtv u�wva x� �Ovm xO�iDU� �yv� R� �tDL �u�tR�U

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N

�U�vWQ�m �xQwO R�r�v� TwQO �UQQ� OQoR�t���� Q xDWQ

x�W�L QO ���� Q �U�vWQ�m xQwO R�r�v� TwQO OQwt QO OQoR�t wOQyW QO x�t Qw� QyW syOR�� w syv QO u�Q�� ���� QTv�Qivm u�twUw�UxOvvm Q�RoQ� xD�tm O�yvW�B x� xm �yOQoR�t u�� QO �O�OQo Q�RoQ� OyWtw C�k�kLD �swra CQ�Rw hQ� R� xm �D�Q��DN� ��DU�Q QO w Tv�QivmOt�RwQ w p�OaD �Q��eD CyH xR�tt C��y ��Q�O ��yy�oWv�O x� �Qw��viOtLt QDmO �oOvv�OQo w �CU� xOW xO�O �U�vWQ�m xQwO TwQO uOwtvuS�� QDmO ��Qvy�tU�k Qy�� QDmO u���k� O�OQo Q�RoQ� u��LrYtp�Y��Jr�kOt ��Q�ra QDmO �xvovR�Qwy ��QO�tL QDmO �xvovR�Qwy ��������� uty� QDmO �po����t�m �ra�HQ QDmO ���Lt u�UL QDmO��rq O�wH QDmO �xO�RsqU� u�ULtqe QDmO ��t��k Qk��OtLt QDmOQDmO �u�kyOO�Sv xr�O� QDmO ��J��J OtLt ��k� ��OU� xr�u�t� QDmOQDmO ��v�LwQ�QiaH O�Ry� QDmO �u�tO�W uqUQ� QDmO ��v�QiaR QiaHx� w OvDW�O Qw�L u�� R�HL u� Q�W QDmO sv�N w u�kyO �raOtLtu�� x��Q� h�Oy� w �U�vWQ�m xQwO R�r�v� TwQOh�m w sm OQwt QOEL�OvtHQ� u�Q�mty u�� C�Qv x�kv R� �WN� p�P QO �OvDN�OQB TwQOV�B�W�B w CU� xOW Vv� Ro �x��Wt �� u�Um� C�Q�y � hPL ���

�O�r��t VRwB pwk w pkv QO �r�tDL� p�mW� xvwoQy R� xOvQ�ov

�y�oWv�OTwQO �R� Qxt�vQ� �xD�tm ��ovyQi�qkv� R� Oa���Qvy�tU�k

�O�OQo u� wOD u�tR u RwQ C���� Q �� �U�vDt ��xt�vQ� w OW p�mWD�yxt�vQ� QO �Q sRq CqwLD xm CU� xO�UQ u u�tR uwvm � ut Q�v x��ymHwt w x� Qwi R�r�v Qo � ��vt �s�vm OtRwQ �Q �yxt�vQ� w xO�O s�Hv�Oy�wN QDW�� u�� wHWv�O ���Q�m �OwW �U�vWQ�m �xQwO C���� Q OQ�w�r�tmD Cq�YLD ��Q� RmQtDt Q�e Vv� Ro hr�Nt �v�Hv�� �OWOvm�t ��NDv� �Q x�oWv�O s�Om wHWv�O s�Om CU�v swrat �Q� R sDUyOQ�w �ymHwt w x� Qwi R�r�v Qo � �Ow� s�y�wN �ywQRQ Q�oQO xQ�wty w�OW Oy�wN QDW�� u�� wHWv�O ���Q�m �OwW �U�vWQ�m �xQwO C���� QRmQtDtVHvU �rw RmQtDt Q�eVv� Ro ji�wt ut �xvovR�Qwy� uS��

�wN Tv�U�r l� xm x��B TwQO �QU l� svm�t O�yvW�B �sDUy�OwW xOv�Hvo xt�vQ� QO �OW�� xDW�O C�aq�� st�v�t u�wva x� O����Q �v�at peW� XNWt Q�m xJ ��� Q V��Qo Qy OW�� swrat O����D��U�Lt ��NQ�H TQO l� svm�t O�yvW�B ��vt �OQ�O p��vO x��U�vWQ�m �xQwO �Q��H� xt�vQ� �RH �� RH p�Uv�Qi�O CqO�at R�v wu��CN�OQB u x� O��� �OD�� xm �r� �wU ut Q�v x� ���Lt u�UL �O�����CU�J pmWt �r� Qo � �OvQ�O pmWt �rai R�r�v TwQO �� xmCU�

�OwW �y�wNQ�v u�� wHWv�O w O�D�U� R� svm�t O�yvW�B

�Ow� Oy�wN �yx�tyU ��wv� hPL �KQ� u�� Qo�O QwLt

CU� u� �B QO VHvU u�tR�U xm CU� u�� �KQ� u�� Qo�O xDmv�yy�oWv�O x� �Q Vv� Ro �xDN�OQB u��r�w�O �tra VHvU x� QDW�� xm

�Ovm Q�Po �w

�v�QvNU CQwY� Cq�kt x��Q� �Q�v�tU u�� Qo�O ��yxt�vQ� xrtH R��O�OQo x��Q� hrDNt ��yv�tR QO w �R�wt CQwY� xm Ow� QDUwB w

�x� u�wD�t �yv� xrtH R� xm O�OQo Q�RoQ� R�v OQoR�t u�OvJ u�vJty��yWwQ OQoR�t w Qwmvm �U�vW�U� OQoR�t �Qwmvm xJN� Q�D OQoR�t

�OQm xQ�W� u� Ro��H

�O�Di��t j�iD� Q��u�rw� ��Q� �Q�v�tU u�vJ �Q�RoQ� xmv�� x� xHwD ��Q�v�tU u�� ���B Q� u�Q�mQOv�CUO R� O��� xm CU� �� wN Q��U� CmQL

�OQm �v�OQOk w QmWD

R� �m� u�wva x� R�v QwWm VRwt� VHvU u�tR�U xmv�� R� wu�� G��Dv xm OwQ�t Q�Dv� �CU� xDW�O p�ai Qw�L u�oOvvmC��tL

�OwW �k�w O�it Qwmvm pmWt pL QO Ov�wD� Q�v�tUVvtv�Q�� �raTQOt C�� QD x�oWv�O ���� Q VN� Q��Wv�OQ�v�tU QO u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� ���QH� ��QwW xOv��tv w

� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

xOv�� ��y���tyOQo

�SwrwBwD w xUOvy Q�v�tU u�twO� �� x�tuty� �����

Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O �QDw�Bt�m swra w ���� Q �xOmWv�O

x�oWv�O ��i�L u����N �u�QyD �Q�v�tU �xv�NQ��O �DUB �v�Wvxv�NQ��O �QDw�Bt�m swra w ���� Q �xOmWv�O �Q��mQ�t� �DavY

�SwrwBwD w xUOvy Q�v�tU u�twO

�� ����� �uirD����� �Q��tv

geotop��aut�ac�ir ��m�vwQDmr� CUB

http���www�aut�ac�ir�SGT����� �C��U �w

�q�� x� CQUt p�tm �� w p�aDt QO�k x�oQO x� T�BU w OtL ��x�tuty� �� �r� �! R� �SwrwB wD w xUOvy Q�v�tU u�twO �xm Ov�UQ�tQ��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O QDw�Bt�m swra w ���� Q xOmWv�O QO ��%�Q�v�tU CwaO QwWm GQ�N R� Q� R u�v�O���� Q uwvm �D �OOQo�t Q�RoQ�

�Ov�xDiQ�PB �v�QvNU x��Q� ��Q� �Q

xUv�Qi $ u�Q�� CNRS R� xO�RQ�m � QwUiwQB $�xUv�Qi uw�r �r�a ��QUWv�O R� �eR QwUiwQB $�C� wm C� wm x�oWv�O R� u�Q�i QwUiwQB $�lJ RrQ�J x�oWv�O R� �mUr�wm QwUiwQB $!

�v�twQ �Rwm p� x�oWv�O R� uwQ�t QwUiwQB $�

�v�QvNU x��Q� CyH QwWm pN�O O�D�U� R� �NQ� R� �Q�N� �vt��O�UQ Oy�wN �q�� x� ��wHCi�� QO R�TB xmCU� xOt� pta� CwaO

�R� OvDQ��a Q�v�tU u�� ��yxt�vQ��twta w �YYND ��y�v�QvNU �hr�

OQoR�t ���u�mt� CQwY QO� x�oQ�m �G

��Dm x�oW��tv �O

x� j��U RmQtD O��� O�OH �R� Qxt�vQ� QO ut Q�v x� ��Jr�kOt ��Q�ra

xDW�O �yxt� vQ� pwL D w Q��e D QO pta �O�R �yy�oW v�O w OR � Q sy�CU� syt O�OH TwQO O�H�� w xt�vQ� �Q�PB h��av� xwqa x� �OvW���Q R�r� v TwQO R� l�J�y ut Q� v x � �xvovR�Qwy� ��QO�tL

�wHWv�O xm OW�� ��xvwo x� xt�vQ� O��� xwqa x� �OQm hPL OwW�tv�� � Q OWQ� �U� vWQ� m Qwm v m QO O v�w D � ZLt �� � Q �wN

�Tmax� w Ovm CmQW �OQ� Q�mw u�DUQ� �O TwQO u� � �ovy�ty l � O �� � �po����t�m �ra�HQ

u�� wHWv�O �SQv� w Ckw hqD� R� u�wD� �D OQm O�H�� �y�oWv�O TwQO�Owtv �Q�owrH �Q�QmD ��yrYiQU uOv�QPo QO

xt�O� ��Q � ��U�U� �� � Q �U�vWQ�m �xQwO ��yxt� vQ � ��rq O�wH

��wN T�vWQ�m l� C�� QD ��Q� xv �CU� xOW u� wOD p�YLD�U� vWQ� m �xQwO TwQO s v m�t O� y vW � B �xO�RsqU� u�ULtqe

�Q�H �R�r�v QO OwN j�qa x� xHwD �� Ov�wD� wHWv�O �D OvwW �Ov�xDUO�O��tv ��NDv� �Q �Q��DN�� TwQO ��� w Q�t ��OQ� Q�m

w �OvQ�O T� QOD ��Q� �i�m C�i�m �t u�UQOt �� �u�tO�W uqUQ�

�CU� xOQmv Qwy� u�UQOtha Q��N x� �t CqmWt R� ��a� ��QO w ��oDUw�B w OL �l� QDt ��y��i � R�r�v QO svm�t O�yvW�BQO �n�r p�QoDv� �QOk w xQ�eDtl� ��wD p�QoDv� w jDWt �� R�r�v

�OwW T� QOD xQ�eDt OvJ ��wD p�QoDv� w jDWt � R�r�vx� � ��� Q R�r�v QO �ytQi EL�t svm�t O�yvW�B ��J��J OtLt

�OwW pkDvt xUOvy VN� TwQOO �� � �y v C�i�m w u � Qt D pL C�a�U h�rm D �u�kyOO�Sv xrr�O�

O �� � TwQO pwL D w Q��e D w �R � Qxt� vQ � QO ��vt �OwW XNWt�OvQ�o Q�Qk Q�vOt �r�kDv� w u�ty�t u�� wHWv�O

�� � Q R � r� v R� p�k �Q �Sw rw B w D CU� �U� vt ��OU� xrr�u�t�

�Ovvm T� QOD�CU� �wN R�r�v TwQO �vwvm ��wDLt ��v�LwQ�QiaH O�Ry�

��OL�w � ��NQ�H ��H x� u�yiY� x�oWv�O QO �t ��v�QiaR QiaH

�UwQO xwqa x� �s��xO�O O�yvW�B �Q �OL�w � ��NQ�H TQO wO OL�w �� OwOL QO� ��� w �Q�O��UL �O�YDk� ��R�Uxv�y� �xt�� Ovv�tOa� Oy�wN�t xm �� wHWv�O �D s��xOQm xi�� �Q��DN� TwQO x� �QQO sRq �tra u�wD OwW Q�m Q�R�� OQ�w xrY�iq� p�YLD R� Ce�Qi R�

�OW�� xDW�O �Q �Q�m uwo �vwo ��yxRwL

u��LrYtp�Y OtLt

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� �xOv��tv

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N �

u�Q�� ���� Q VRwt� Tv�Qivm u�tWW���� �� �D ��������

�xv�NQ��O �v�Wv� sHvB xk�� � VQwQB w VRwt� u�tR�U � pOat u����N � R�Q�W

�R� Q xt�vQ� �U�vWQ�m

����� ������ � Tm �i w uirD

V� wN ��y�� QO x� u�OQopYDt V�B R �O�WN� xm Vv�O xQ�k

u�tWWu�� R�t xm OQ�O Q�NDi�TQ�i u�DU�VQwQB wVRwt� u�tR�UutHv� �Q�mty R� �DU�Q u�� QO �OW�� QwWm ���� Q VRwt� Tv�Qivmw QwWm ���� Q u�trat �WRwt� w �tra ��yutHv� w u�Q�� ���� Q

�CU� Q�OQwNQ� R�Q�W x�oWv�O

��Q�RoQ� u�mtR�Q�W u��ovyQi �y�iQ �WRwt� RmQt �QL u����N � R�Q�W

�Tv�Qivm h�Oy��QwWm ���� Q u�trat �WRwt� ��yDQ�yt uOQ� q�� $

��xiQLVv�O p�kDv� QFwt ��yWwQ wT� QOD u� wv ��yxw�W �� ���vW� $�u�trat

�xat�H QO ���� Q nvyQi ��kDQ� w xa�W� $�VywSB w j�kLDnvyQi QDW�� G� wQDCyH QOU�vt ���i O�H�� $

�Tv�Qivm ��yxt�vQ���YYND w �twta ��y�v�QvNU

��WRwt� ��yx�oQ�m w OQoR�t �Q�RoQ��R�Q�W �N� Q�D w �vO�O ��kv R� O�OR��

��tra �xD�tmp�a�tU� ��TQ�i VQwQB w VRwt� u�tR�U xOv��tv� CvUL� OtL�x�oWv�O� u��Ow�y� O�wH QDmO ��u�QyD srat C�� QD x�oWv�O� u��r���QoOwQO wr�v�H ��R�Q�W ���� Q utHv� xOv��tv� ��we�� �raOtLt ��R�Q�WVywSB u�tR�U xOv��tv� Q�oDUQ VQ� ��R�Q�W ���� Q utHv� xOv��tv�QO�L ��R�Q�W ���� Q utHv� xOv��tv� �w�Q s�HvO�U ���w�Dt CQ�Rw��QOtLt ��R�Q�W x�oWv�O QO u�Q������ Q utHv� xOv��tv��v�Oy�ROy�R�tra��yutHv� xOv��tv� sOkt�v��rUu�UL ��R�Q�W x�oWv�O� �QyBUVRwt� u�tR�UT��Q� �Qy�� OtLtr�O�a ������ Q u�trat �WRwt� w�t�a xO� Qi ���tra xD�tm Q��O� �������� uty� ��TQ�i VQwQB w��TQ�i VQwQB w VRwt� �v�Uv� ���vt w �R� Qxt�vQ� �VywSB uw�at��QyR w �TQ�i VQwQB w VRwt� u�tR�U xOv��tv� �� wtQ�m u�ULtqe

��DWy�O�yW x�oWv�O� �� wo

�Q�v�tU �Q�RoQ� ��QwW ���a��xOmWv�O T��Q� u�kyO �Oyt $�

u��OQHwQ� QY�v $�O���O�� RwQy� $�

�Q�v�tU Q��O� �w�Q xrr�OU� $!�r�a O�Lw $�

����QOtLtQ�t ��DQt $�

�Q�v�tU �tra xD�tm ���a��College de France � CNRS xO�RQ�m � uUL $�

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O� u��OQHwQ� QY�v $��Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O� O���O�� RwQy� $�

�R� Q�D x�oWv�O� u��v�twD I�OQot $!�R�Q�W x�oWv�O� �tW�ys�mL �Oyt $�

�Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O� �DtLQ O�yQi $��Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O �Q�v�tU Q��O� �w�Q xrr�OU� $&

�u�QyD x�oWv�O� �Ovyv�Q�R s�LQ $%�C����� Q w �Qv l� R�i C�k�kLD RmQt� �QiY s�QOB $#

�TQOt C�� QD x�oWv�O� �v�W�m Qk��OtLtO�U $���Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O� ����QOtLtQ�t ��DQt $��

�u�tQm Qvy�� O�yW x�oWv�O� �Qvy uS�� $��

�Q�v�tU ���QH� ��QwW ���a��t��i�v� xrr�u�UL� O�U $� u��OQHwQ� QY�v $� OvtHQ� Q�t�hUw� $��QeY $& �v��tQ Q�m ��ra $� u��mQD ��DHt $� O���O�� RwQy� $!��QwW Q��O� ����Q OtLtQ�t ��DQt $# �r�a O�Lw $% �i� QW

u�WwQir�v �QyR $�� ����QH�

� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

�� xQ�tW �x�aq��QwWm ���� Q R�r�v� Q�v�tU u�tyOR�U

���� OviU� ����

u�yiY� x�oWv�O ����� Q xwQo

���� Q xwQo � u�yiY� x�oWv�O � u�yiY� ��v�Wv������� �DUB jwOvY

��������� ��� �uirD��������� ��� �Q��tv

analysis�ui�ac�ir ��m�vwQDmr� T�tDhttp���www�ui�ac�ir�analysis �C��U �w

��yQ�v�tU h�Oy� jkLD ��DU�Q QO �p�aDt Ovw�ON R� Cv�aDU� �����Lt O�H��CyH w���� QVv�O K�U�qDa� Qwvt x� ��YYNDQ�v�tU u�tyOR�U �GQ�N w pN�O u�v�O���� Q Qv pO��D ��Q� U�vtx�oWv�O ���� Q xwQo QO ��%� x�tOviU� �� w �� ��yRwQ QO R�r�v���y�v�QvNU r�k QO Q�v�tU u�� ��yxt�vQ� �OOQo�t Q�RoQ� u�yiY�x��Q� ���xk�kO ��� �YYND ��y�v�QvNU w ���xk�kO ��� �twta���� QutHv� xDUw�B ���a�� u�Ovtxkqa swta R� xr�Uwv�O� �OOQo�txv�t�tY ��r�tmD Cq�YLD u�� wHWv�O w �tra C��y ���a� �u�Q������ Q xvq�UCUWv u�� OwN��� wB w p�ai Qw�L �� �D O��tv�t CwaO

�OvR�U QD�ve �Q QwWm

xOvvmQ�RoQ� xD�tm��r�HQ �ra ����v�J �Oyt ��rw��� QwB ��QOtLt �sa� O�aU�u�Q�tQ�t O�Ht �xO�R� QmWr OwtLt ��v�QiaR QiaH �����Q x� w�Lt��r�mw x�UOk �u��DN� wv �QeY �OvtHQ�xv�Wkv uULt �O�y�v u�UL

O�OQo Oy�wN sqa� �xQ�tW x�aq�� QO �r�tmD C�aq��

�xr�kt x��Q� CyH �O�yvW�B ��yQwLt

����� Q VRwt� C�i�m w C�tm x� �w� Qt ��yxv�tR s�tD $

j� Q� x��Q� w C����� Q QO G��Q ��yVRwt� �U�vW�U� $�u� KqY� CyH

�u�trat CtON ut�VRwt� ��yxQwO �UQQ� w Okv $QO xOvQ�oO�� Vkv�� VwQ R� xO�iDU� ��yx�Q Qo�O CQ��a x�

������ Q �yOO�� Ov��Qi

����� Q p�ai T� QOD VwQ R� �tra xvwtv x��Q� $

��k�vt QmiD �yOv�t�U QO u� K�LYVRwt� w ���� QVkv $

u�wN�QiQwWm Q�H Q�v�tU u�tyORv�B

x�tQ�D QwWm Q�H Q�v�tU u�tyORv�B Ov�UQ�t �q�� x� �DkwWwN R�Q�� ��R� Q�v�tU �Q�RoQ� u�rwwUt OwW�t Q�RoQ� uq�o x�oWv�O QO ��%���yxUUwt w �yy�oWv�O �tra C��y ���e� u�kkLt w u�Qv�L�Y��yxr�kt x��Q� ��Q� �r�tmD Cq�YLD u�� wHWv�O w QwWm �r�aVRwt�

�Ov��tv�t CwaO Q�H xv�tR QO OwN

�OW Oy�wN sqa� ���k�aDt Q�v�tU OQwt QO QDW�� C�aq��

w O�yvW�B xvwoQy Ci�� QO ��Q� �Q OwN �oO�t� Q�v�tU xv�NQ��O�OQ�O�t sqa� Q�v�tU �Q�RoQ� QO Q�v

�DUB jwOvY � swra xOmWv�O � wHt�v u����N � CWQ ��v�Wv���

���� � � ����� �Q�ovQwO w uirDe�mail� algebra�guilan�ac�ir

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

VvtQ���WN s �m ���tra xD�tm QO ���� Q utHv� xOv��tv� u��vwDwDxOv��tv� �QiY s�QOB ���tra xD�tm QO u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xOv��tv��raO�U ���HQ Q�m ��ra ���tra xD�tm QO u�Q �� ��� � Q utH v�wQUN �OvtDwk �Oyt ��vwUy�W Ow�O �xOvywQi MQiO�U ��vULQ�t��wUwt ��QO�U �u�QO�Q � O�wH �VwQiTt �raOtLt �xO�Ru�UL

��OvUQwN ��Q�Oyt ��v�Qy��vUL�CHL

�xr�kt Ci�� QO w s�vC�F �Ov�u�tRx�Qty x� u� xO�mJ w pt�m xr�kt �s�vC�F sQi p�UQ� Cryt u� QN�

�OW���t ��%� CWy��OQ� �� CmU�O

�OvwW�t �Qw�OTv�Qivm QO x��Q� ��Q� pt�m ��yxr�kt �yvD xm ���Hv� R�xr�kt xO�mJ x�Qty x�SRPTEX ��LATEX Q�Ri�sQv �� �Q OwN xr�kt �i�rR�DW�B CUB �UwD w xO�t� �Q�U �� OwOL QO xv�o �OH nQ� l� QO�Tv�Qivm QO CmQW �� xr�kt VQ�PB xH�Dv �O���tv p�UQ� �xNUv wO QO�Cq�kt �O�UQ Oy�wN �q�� x� ��k�aDt s�vC�F sQi pwYw �DQD x�

�O�UQ Ovy�wN A�J x� Tv�Qivm VQ�Ro QO �Qw�O R� TB

��yxv� R����������yOwN C� w�a jL xm u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xDUw�B ���a� s�vC�F jLp�� Q &�)��� Ov�xOQm CN�OQB �Q��� � Q utH v� w�a Q �e �t ra C� �y ���a� s� vC� F jLp�� Q���)��� u�Q��x� p�eDW� �y�wo x��Q� ��� �r�tmD Cq�YLD u�� wHWv�O s�vC�F jLp�� Q ��)��� �p�YLDp�� Q �&�)��� Qiv Qy ��Q� pt�m ��Pe xv� Ryp�� Q %�)��� �yvD Q�yv xv� Ryp�� Q ��)��� x�oWv�O x�o��wN QO Ct�k� xv� Ryp�� Q ��)�����UQ�i �� �U�rov��Tv�Qivm Cq�kt xawtHt Qy ��y�

Ovv�wD�t u�Ovtxkqa �u�y�Qty u�mU� u�mt� C�OwOLt x� Qv�UQQ � R� T B CU� �y �O � �O vQ�O sqa� �Q OwN u�y�Qty O�Oa D�q�� x � � ����� M� Q�D �D QFm �OL � ��y v xH�D v �yDU�wNQOj���t �yxv� Ry CN�OQB x� C�Uv Ovv�wD� �D O�UQ Oy�wN u����kDtXwYN QO �yHw x vwoQy CN�OQ B R� �i�r �Ov ��t v s�Ok� pwOH

�O���tQi �Q�OOwN Tv�Qivm xv�NQ��O �� �ovy�ty uwO� u�y�Qty

h�QYv� xm �DQwY QO �yvD ��r�t w �Q�O� CqmWtCra x� �vt�OOQo sqa� � x�tQ�D �� M� Q�D R� p�k �D T v�Qivm QO CmQW R�

�OwW�t OQDUt xOW CN�OQB ��yxv� Ry

O�OQo Oy�wN sqa� �xQ�tW x�aq�� QO �r�tmD C�aq��

�� xQ�tW �x�aq��QwWm ���� Q Tv�Qivm u�tQ�yJ w �U

���� Qw� QyW ����

�swra xOmWv�O ���� Q xwQo

OwQy�W �DavY x�oWv�O

QwWm ���� Q Tv�Qivm u�tQ�yJ w �U xv�NQ��O ��v�WvOwQy�W �DavY x�oWv�O �swra xOmWv�O ����� Q xwQo

���� �DUBOm ��� �DUB jwOvY

� �� ���� �� �uirD� ��������� �Q��tv

imc���shahrood�ac�ir ��m�vwQDmr� CUBwww�shahrood�ac�ir��imc�� �x�orRvt

��yUv�Qim h�Oy� jkLD ��DU�Q QO �p�aDt Ovw�ON R� Cv�aDU� ��O�H�� CyH w ���� Q Vv�O K�U �qDa� Qwvt x� ����� Q xvq�U�U �GQ�N w pN�O u� v�O��� � Q Q v pO�� D ��Q � U�vt ���LtQO ��%� x�tQw � QyW QO ���� � Q �rrtr�u�� T v�Qivm u�tQ�yJ w��yxt� vQ � �OOQo�t Q�RoQ � OwQy�W �DavY x�oW v�O ��� � Q xwQor�k QO w xOw � C����� Q ��yxN�W xty xO vQ�oQ� QO T v�Qivm u ����� �YYN D ��y� v�QvNU w ���xk�kO ��� �twta ��y� v�QvNU���a�� u�Ovtxkqa swta R� xr�Uwv �O � �OOQo�t x ��Q� ���xk�kOu� � wHW v�O w �tra C� �y ���a� �u�Q �� ��� � Q utH v� xDUw � B��� wB w p�ai Qw�L �� �D O��tv�t CwaO xv�t�tY ��r�tmD Cq�YLD

�OvR�U QD�ve �Q QwWm ���� Q xvq�U CUWv u�� OwN

Q ��U w s� vC� F jL O �� � T v�Qivm u �� QO CmQW x � u�Ovtxkqax� OwQy�W �RmQt ��rt lv�� �� � �Q�H ��UL x� �Q �yxv� RypY� w R � Q�w OwQy�W �DavY x�oW v�O �Y�YDN� ��yOt�QO s� vM� Q�D �D QFm �OL s� vC� F xOW p�tmD sQi x�Qty x � �Q �m v� �V�i

�Ov��tv p�UQ� xv�NQ��O TQO� x� ��� �� ���

�xOvvmQ�RoQ� xD�tmw �WRwt� Cvw�at� KD�i �Oyt ��x�oWv�O CU�� Q� ��HQ Q�m ��ra��x�oWv�O �r�t w �Q�O� Cvw�at� xO�RO�Qt �ra ��x�oWv�O �WywSBCU�� Q� �tU�k xrr���L ��x�oWv�O �� wHWv�O Cvw�at� s�Ov� ��Q�QiY s�QO B w �T v�Qivm pmQ� �O� �vULQ�t �raO�U ��xOmW v�O

�u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xOv��tv�

����QH� w �tra xD�tmxR��i ���tra xD�tm QO u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xOv��tv� s�vm�v xrr�OU�

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

xr�kt u�wN�Qi u�rw�u�Q�� RtQ utHv� Tv�Qivm u�twO

u�QyD � h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O�� x�tQyt �� w ��

� Tv�Qivm xv�NQ��OC�Q��Nt C�k�kLD RmQt � �r�tW QoQ�m u����N ��yDv� � u�QyD

�������� �DUB jwOvY � u�Q�� RtQ utHv� �u�Q��

�� �������� Q��tv ������� � ������ �uirD

E�mail� iscc�����isc�org�ir �l�vwQDmr� CUB

Tv�Qivm u�twOh� QW�DavY x�oWv�O �Q�mty �� u�Q�� RtQ utHv�C�aq�� �C����DQ�C�vt�ui wVv�O xa�W� w qDa� �OWQhOy �� �Q OwNR� OvDQ��a Tv�Qivm x� x��Q� p��k ��yaw�wt �Ovm�t Q�RoQ� QDw�Bt�m w

�Q�ovRtQ ��ysD� Qwor� p�rLD w �L�Q� ��Q�ovRtQ QO C����� Q ��yOQ� Q�m �

C��U�Lt �oO�J�B x� Qv �O�rm C� Q�Ot w C� wy Q�RL� ��Q�ovRtQ ��ypmDwQB �

�QwY ��yWwQ �R�U syQO ���wD w p�D�H�O ���t� �

�D�vt� ��ypOt w �yQ�DN�U �lU� Q ���� RQ� �

�yOQ�Ov�DU� w �D�vt� �Q�PoDU��U ��twta O�rm Q�DN�UQ� R �

�m�vwQDmr� C�vt� �vwv�k w �kwkL EL��t �ut� ��ysDU�U ���� RQ� �

OvtWwy CQ�m w Q�Ri�CNU C�vt� �pt�a sDU�U w Q�Ri�sQv C�vt� �xOQDUoh�� w C�Q��Nt C�vt� �

xm�W C�vt� ��UQDUO pQDvm w VD� Q�w�O �

Pwiv X�NWD ��yWwQ ��m�vwQDmr� pwB w CQ�HD ���DQt C�aw�wt Q��U �

�syt ��yM� Q�D%� u�OQwQi �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � xr�kt pY� Ci�� QO%� Q�D �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � xH�Dv sqa�%� O�OQt �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���yv xNUv Ci�� QO

u�tQ�yJ w �U s�vC�F sQiQwWm ���� QTv�Qivm

�C�UvH ��oO�wv�Ns�v $� �s�v $�xN�W QmP � � �y�oW v�O x� DQ ��r�YL D lQOt u � QN� $�

��YYND� �QDmO �wHWv�O � �tra C��y w�a

�OWQ��U�vWQ�m �wHWv�O� u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xDUw�B w�a

�Q�m pLt uirD w CtON pLt xUUwt �� x�oWv�O $!

��x�Qty ��� pRvt uirD xQ�tW w �DUB �v�Wv $�

� Q��tv w �m�vwQDmr� CUB $�� sDU�v �sDUy xr�kt x��Q� ���kDt $&

� �UQ�i � �U�rov�� ��v�QvNU x��Q� u�� R�� sDUy Tv�Qivm VQ�Ro QO xr�kt A�J ���kDt

�xr�kt u�wva $%xt�t� Cm�UO x�Qty u� xO�mJ w pt�m xr�kt $#

� CU�v � CUy� �i�YwD$�tra � �WywSB$�tra �xr�kt �wv $��

AMS���� �aw�wt �Ov�xOQ $��Ct�k� pLt x� R��v � x�o��wN � Ct�k� pLt $��

� sQ�Ov�������������� ���kDt OQi Q� xwqa u�y�Qty O�OaD $��

��yxv� Ry$�!p�� Q s�vC�F jL

p�� Q �Pe xv� Ry

p�� Q x�o��wN QO Ct�k� pLt xv� Ry

p�� Q Tv�Qivm Cq�kt �xawtHt ��y�

p�� Q �tH

x NQw t ���������� xQ� t W x � � m v� � V � i pY�$��lv�� #���� �Q�H ��UL x� ������������ dr�t x� �����������x�oW v�O �Y�YDN� ��yOt�QO s� v x � OwQy�W �RmQt �rt

�CU� xt�t� OwQy�W �DavY

�M� Q�D ����t�

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

��xv�tR QO C�ar�t �vwvm �w w �yOQw�DUO �xv�W�B

p�L w xDWPo QOVywSB ��ywQtrk w C�aw�wt u� QDtyt w �yDmt �Qo�O ��yxRwL C�k�kLD QO �yv� Q�F�D w

�U�vWu�Q�� C�UUwt w CqHt �syt Cq�kt w �y��Dm �iQat �p�L w xDWPo "�U�vWu�Q�� C�ar��t Okv �

��� w �k�irD ��N� Q�D ��r�rLD ��i�YwD ��UQQ� ��yxw�W �xOv�� ��yxt�vQ� �

�tra ��yxwQo �� �ywQtrk�u�mOwm �QY�at �O�OH �s�Ok� u�Q�� C���O� $�

u�Q�� O�YDk� $�u�Q�� �U�vW u�DU�� $�

u�Q�� swra M� Q�D $!�rLt M� Q�D w �N� Q�D ���i�QeH w u�Q�� ���i�QeH w M� Q�D $�

u�Q�� QO C�� QD w s�raD $�u�Q�� QO �a�tDH� ���wQ w C��U�vt �u�Q�� �U�vW xat�H $&

��YwYN ��twta� u�Q�� jwkL $%u�Q�� �rrtr�u�� w �U��U ���wQ $#

u�Q�� �U�vWu�� R w �v�Q�� ��yu�� R $��u�Q�� �U�vWsOQt w sOQtnvyQi $��u�Q�� QO u�iQa w sqm w xiUri $��

�v�Q�� Q�F� �U�vWxNUv w �U�vW��Dm $��u�Q�� QO �tqU� swra w hQ�at $�!

u�Q�� Qvy $���t�v u�U�vW u�Q�� p�wL� w Q�F� �t�H �UQQ� $��

u�OvtW�Ov� xOQDUo w QFwt w p�aiCmQ�Wt w xv�tr�a Qw�L R� O��v�w �D�ar��t xk��U ��Q�O xm �U�vWu�Q�� u�QoWywSB w u�QvL�Y wO�it C�aq�� ��Q�O �� w QY�at w O�OH �U�vWu�Q�� xQ�� QO �D�k�kNDx� �OvDUy xOW O�� xRwL OvJ �� l� QO �U�vWu�Q�� xv�W�B OQwt QO

�Ovm�t p��kDU� �tQoR� l� Qy x� �w� Qt u�kkLt w u�U�vW u�Q�� xm OwQ�t Q�Dv�u� wOD OwN x� �w� Qt xRwL QO �L�HQD �Q u�WDq�kt xv�oVW ��yxRwL

�Ov��tv x��Q� w�� l� EL��t uwt�Q�B �xRwL l� u�U�vW u�Q�� Cq�kt R� xty u�� ���OW�� xv�tr�a Okv w xR�D ��yxDmv �w�L xJv�vJ R�v Qo�O xRwL OvJ

�OwW�t p��kDU���yOQw�DUOu��� Q� xwqa�v�Q�� u�U�vWu�Q�� xmCU��Qw�O�� u���WR� �m� Q�F� �iQat �� w �v�Q�� C�k�kLD w C�ar��t xv�tR QO OwN �OQi�UQQ� x� xm CU� xDU��W �DL w Ovv�wD�t ��v�Q�� s�v x� u�U�vWu�Q��Dmt l� R� �tra p�rLD �� w �v�Q�� Q�e u�U�vW u�Q�� Q�F� Okv wVW ��yxRwL R� l� Qy QO �U�vWu�Q�� ���� RQ� R�v w �U�vWu�Q��

�OvR�OQB� �Q�N� uQk xU wO QO �xv�o

�U�vWu�Q�� O��v��� u�wN�Qi

��yV��ty xrUrU��yOQw�DUO w �U�vWu�Q�� �xv�W�B �UQQ�

RwQt� �D u���� �����

��U�vWu�Q�� ��yV��ty �t��O xv�NQ��O �v�Wv�Lqi O�yW u����N �TwOQi d�� �QYa�rw u����N � u�QyD

�� xQ�tW xwmQ�W xJwm ��x�v�QiaR�

��� � �uirD ����� �Q�ovQwO

Email�irfo�iranologyfo�or�ir

URL�www�iranology�net

w�U�vWu�Q�� wQtrk QO xDi�� s�Hv� ��yVywSB R��y�o � xmv�� x� QvC�k�kLD w C�ar��t xt�O� ��Q� �Q�wDU� x��B �yv� xv�tr�a Okv w���� RQ� R�vxrUrU �Q�RoQ� �U�vWu�Q�� O��v� �CU� �U�vWu�Q�� ��y�Qw�wv w �v�Q��w �U�vWu�Q�� C�ar�t �xv�W�B �UQQ�� u�wva �� �Q ���yV��ty��Q� OwN Q�m QwDUO QO �Q��L u�tR �D �yv� R� pY�L ��yOQw�DUO

xRwLVW QO �yV��ty u�� �CU� xO�O Q�Qk ��%� w ��%� ��yr�U�Q �U�vW u�Q�� C�ar��t �vwvm ��w w �yOQw�DUO w xv�W�B �xv�o �OHw EL� OQwt �Q� R KQW x� �wQtrk xORv�W R� l� Qy QO w xv�tR GvB QO

�OvyO�t Q�Qk �UQQ�

�yQwWm Q��U w u�Q�� ��yxRwL

xQ�k x�W ��yQwWm w u�Q�� xRwL $��x�UwQ �x�mQD �R�kik �u�DUv�ei� ��RmQt ���U� ��yQwWm w u�Q�� xRwL $�

�kQW ��B wQ��� wvH w �� Qe ��RmQt ��r�tW ����B wQ� ��yQwWm w u�Q�� xRwL $�

���k� Qi� w �� Qa ��yQwWm w u�Q�� xRwL $!�uB�S �u�J xS� w x� w xrtH R�� QwO Qw�N ��yQwWm w u�Q�� xRwL $�

x�Uwv��k� w ��RvwOv� ��Rr�t�RmQt w �r�tW ��m� Qt� ��m� Qt� w �O�v�m ��yQwWm w u�Q�� xRwL $�

�� wvH w

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

O�DU� s�ONDU� p�rO x� �Q OwN p�YLD QN� x�t xORv�B u�W��w OvOv�QPo ��r�QDU� O��qO� x�oWv�O QO �u�Qwt s��r� w QwUiwQB �V��tvy�Q

�u�wva �� OwN xr�UQ R� ���� p�U QO �Hv�tySemigroup Actions and Weak Almost Periodicity

�OvDWoR�� OyWt x�oWv�O x� w OvOQm ��iO

p�U QO w �Q��Wv�O xHQO x� ��&� p�U QO O�Svxrr�O�aQwB O�DU��OvO�OQo p��v �O�vU� xHQO x� ��&&

��yxQwO QO T� QOD Qt� Q�vm QO ���QH� ��yDUB Q� xwqa QDmO�wHWv�O � w OWQ� �U�vWQ�m �wHWv�O !� R� V�� ��U�vWQ�m��yy�oWv�O QO T� QOD x� pweWt u�v� QFm � xm Ov�xOwtv C�� QD �QDmO

�OvW���t QwWm

xm OvW���t �QDmO �wHWv�O � ��Q�O u�W�� R�v Q��L p�L QO�OvDUy OwN �WywSB xQwO uOv�QPo p�L QO

x� u�wD�t �yv� xrtH R� xm OvW���t R�v �OOaDt Q�F� ��Q�O O�DU���Q� j�vt �sra �twtaCN�vW ��k�kL R�r�v� ��yWwQ ��y��Dm xtHQDR�V�� �Q�DU�Q� w w ��t�kQ� QDmO �Q�mty �� �q�� x� Qv �u�v�O���� Q

�OQm xQ�W� Qo�O h�r�D �� xtHQD ��

QO xm OQ� s�v �WywSB KQ� w �tra xr�kt �yyO R� u�wD�t u�vJtyO�Svxrr�O�aQwB O�DU� �CU�v �yv� x� uDN�OQB ��Q� �r�Ht QYDNt u��u�wD�t u��t u� QO xm OvQ�O ���vW� C����� Q R� �irDNt ��yxN�W ���wULt u�W�� XYND xm �a��D R�r�v� w l�vwtQ�y R�r�v� R� xDWPo��rDNt R�r�v� �C����� Q M� Q�D w xiUri ����� Q j�vt x� OwW�tC�aw�wt u�� QFm � QO xm OQm xQ�W� p�tDL� x� Qv w p�Uv�Qi�O xUOvy

�Ov�xDW�O R�vT� QOD

��Q�PB�v�oDUN ����wD uwJ�� wm�vX��YN �yv�� s�tD R� ��OHs�a w X�N ORv�� R �u�W�� C�Lt w h�r w T� QOD x� xkqa w jWa

�CU�

CWy��OQ� �� QO jqN� w sra RwQiQB d�QJ u�� xm TwUi� OY w�CWo Qwvsm �Ret xDmU QF� Q� ��%�

pta CLD OyWt s��k u�DUQ�t�� QO x�tCWy��OQ� �% QO u�W��R� w OvOQ� QU� �Wwy�� p�L QO x�tl� x� � Qk w OvDiQo Q�Qk �L�QHOvDiQo Q�Qk xHr�at CLD u�QyD w OyWt ��yv�DUQ�t�� QO �yQ�� u�tR u�

�OvQ��t QU x� pRvt QO Q��L p�L QO w

xm s� Q�wO�t� w s� Q�O Cr�Ut �Q u�W�� pH�a ��iW �Dm� OR�� R��OOQo OvtxQy� u�W�� OwHw R� �OOHt Ov�wD� QwWm �tra xat�H

QwWm ���� Q Tv�Qivm u�twUw�U �Q�RoQ� xD�tmOyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O

�yxt�v�oOvR w Rm �Qt�iQat

O�Sv xrr�O�aQwB �raOtLt QDmO �tra �xt�v�oOvR �xYqNOyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O �swra �xOmWv�O C����� Q O�DU�

�CUNv hQLu� R� xv �Ov�t�t �yxQ��N QO O�� �D u�WO�� w s�v nQR� u�OQtOvwW�B xm �tra lQ�Ot x�U�w x� xv w Ov�xOR sy x� �DQyW xm CyHC�F w uOv�t ��Q� �yxQ��N xm wQ u� R� QDW�� xmr� O���t u�v� �t�U�

�OvH�DLt u�v� x� �yxi�L QO uOW

w sqm �� u�v� �Q� R OvQ�O �QD��iQ x�o��H sra u�OQt R�� u��t u�� QOOwN uwt�Q�B u�yH R�V� wN uDNwU �� w OvWN��t �y�o �V� wN srkOa� �yr�U xm Ovv�t�t �v�oQ�DU x� w Ovvm�t ���ORuwUi� w ���ORpyHVRw R� xm ���yxQw�U� w Owtv s�y�wN T�UL� �Q u�v� u�WNQO wrqD

�Ov����tv �OvRo u�Q�oRwQ CWPo w u�Q�� w O��

x� xO�O u�tQm QO ���� p�U QO O�Svxrr�O�aQwB �raOtLt QDmOu�tQm QyW QO �QV� wN x�UwDt w ���OD�� Cq�YLD �w �OwWo u�yH

�Ov�QPo

x� u�QyD x�oWv�O R� C����� QTv�U�r PN� R�TB ��!� p�U QOx�oWv�O C����� Q xUUwt OQ�w ��&! p�U QO wCiQ �R�� QUCtONu�ULtqe QDmO u�wQO�W Cty x� xUUwt u�� �OW srat C�� QDT�U�D �yy�oWv�O ��Q� ���� Q TQOt u�t�D Qwvt x� w L�Yt

�Ow� xOW

OyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O s�ONDU� x� �UQOt xQwO u���B R� TB�OvOwtv T� QOD x� �wQW x�oWv�O u�� ���� Q xwQo QO w OvOt�QO

�r�YLDTQw� R� xO�iDU� �� ���� p�U QO �C�r�ai p�U xU R�TB�OvO�OQo u�DUrov� sR�a p�YLD xt�O� ��Q� OyWt x�oWv�O swra CQ�Rw

xN�W QO �Q ���� QTv�U�r jwi �pU�mw�v x�oWv�O QO �OD�� u�W��uDiQo ��Q� ���� u�DU��D QO u� R� TB �OvOQm Ci�� QO �a��D R�r�v�l�vwtQ�y R�r�v� xDWQ QO w OvDiQ u�DUrov� pwB Qw�r x�oWv�O x� �QDmO

�OvOQm j�kLD x� �wQW OQHt

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

s��N ���� Q utHv� �� ���vW�

Ckw ���a� OOt x� ��&# p�U x�tOviU� QO s��N ���� Q utHv��atHVqD �� w �s��N �r�aVRwt� xUUwt� QDw�Bt�m w ���� Q utHv�w KqY� �� xUUwt Ckw C� Q�Ot C��tL w �v���DWB �u�� wHWv�O R��tra ���i w K�U ��kDQ� �rY� hOy �� pkDUt ��xt�vU�U� s�vD

�CiQo pmW x�oWv�O w u�� wHWv�O

QO w �� wHWv�O �iQY �O�yv u�wva x� s��N ���� Q utHv� O�yvQO xm OW p�mWD s��N �r�a VRwt� xUUwt h�Oy� OQ�W�B ��DU�QxDN�vW xUUwt ��yrmWD u� QDr�ai R� �m� u�wva x� R�v Q��L p�L

�CU� xOW

Q�Dat �tra Cq�kt s�vD w x�yD utHv� �rY� h�Oy� R� �m�uO�O Q�Qk VWwB CLD j� Q� R� u�� wHWv�O ��yWqD p�L u�a QO wpN�O QO hrDNt �tra ��yxt�vxS� w w C�� QWv Q�WDv� R� C��tL wxOt� OwHw x� utHv� p�mWD C�R�wt x� xm ��DrO x� QWv xrtH R� xUUwt

�OW���t $ Ow�

p�mWD �� �s��N���� Q utHv��tUQ u�oQ� u�wva x� R�v �DrO x� QWvQ�WDv� QO �aU s��N ���� Q u�� wHWv�O Q� ptDWt ��x� Q� QLD C��y�Q�mty �� uwvm �D xm �OQ�O �xt�vsQD� Q��m� x�t xU Qy QO OwN x� QWv�CU� xOW xQ�tW wO �kwt x� Q�WDv� x� jiwt x� Q� QLD sQDLt C��y

�OwW�t xYqN Q� R u� w�va QO x� QWv �rm CU��U

�CQwY x� Cq�kt GQO

C����� Q �vOv�wN r�t w �HQt Dm R� r��t �Qw�OQo $

�tra C��y sQDLt O�D�U� R� Cq�kt �Qw�OQo $

xtHQD Dm �� CvQDv�� R� O�R� Cq�kt� ���� Q uwDt xtHQD $�xOWv

w xOW xDN�vW u�mtq� �DL C����� Q u�oQR� �� x�L�Yt $�QHt

�WywSB $ �� wHWv�O Cq�kt Q�WDv� u�Ovtxkqa R� CwaO $

�YYND ��yxQovm w �yW��ty ��yUv�Qivm �tra Q��N� GQO $��� C����� Q sra

� �x� QWv �R� xDiQoQ�s��N ���� Q utHv� �WywSB � �YYND �xt�vy�o

�UwOQi x�oWv�O ���� Q swra xOmWv�O xJN� Q�DOyWt

xrtH R� xwQo xU �� OyWt x�oWv�O swra xOmWv�O ��!� p�U QO�� Qt �Q��O�DU� x�DQt R� �tra C��y w�a �O�OaD �� w ���� Q xwQoQO xwQo u�� uq�YLDr�dQ�i u�rw� �OW p�mWD �WRwt� T�vWQ�m w

�OvOW jiwt �U�vWQ�m lQOt PN� x� !! p�U QO ���� Q xDWQ

QO w CU� xO�O xDNwt�Vv�O R�v Q�t� xDWQ QO &� p�U R� xwQo u��Q�t� xwQo wO &� p�U QO w OW s�UkD ���� Q w Q�t� xwQo wO x� �& p�U���� Q swra xOmWv�O p�mWD w OvOW �OH swra xOmWv�O R� ���� Q wC��y w�a !! ��Q�O ���� Q swra xOmWv�O Q��L p�L QO �OvO�O �Q�� Qt w �� Qt �QwWv�O �� �Q��O�DU� �& �Q��Wv�O & �O�DU� #� �traxOmWv�O u�� �Q�O� QO�m �CU� �WRwt� T�vWQ�m ! O�OaD w �Q��WRwt�p�U QO xOmWv�O u�� u�� wHWv�O O�OaD �OW���t OvtQ�m !� pt�W

�R� Ow� CQ��a l�miD x� %�$%� �r�YLD�Q�t� OWQ� T�vWQ�m Qiv �& ����� Q �QDmO Qiv �� �Q�t� �QDmO Qiv %�QwWv�O Qiv � ��OQ� Q�m w ZLt ���� Q OWQ� T�vWQ�m Qiv �&Qiv �!& �Q�t� �U�vWQ�m Qiv ��% �Q�t� �QwWv�O Qiv � ����� Qw �OQ� Q�m ���� Q �U�vWQ�m Qiv ��� w ZLt ���� Q �U�vWQ�m

��Q��O �U�vWQ�m Qiv ��

�! ��yr�U QO �DQD x� Q�t� w ���� Q OWQ� �U�vWQ�m ��yxQwO&� w �# ��yr�U QO �DQD x� Q�t� w ���� Q �QDmO ��yxQwO w �% w

�OvOW T�U�DQwWm ���� Q Tv�Qivm u�twUw�U �Q�RoQ� �xD�tmOyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

C��aq���� �Qw�OQ���o

��DU�Q QO u�Q �� �tra lQ�Ot w C�aq�� RmQt O v�UQ�t �y�o � x �C�aq�� xa�W� w �yOv�tR�U ��Qw�OQo xv�tR QO OwN h�� w s�Hv�QO QwWm �tra C�aq�� OQwmQ ���)��� R� V� � uwvm � D �tra�QwWm OWQ� u�YYNDt w u�kkLt C�aq�� pt�W hrDNt ��yxv�tR��yQ� v �tU w �yxQovm ��yV ��ty Cq� kt �u�Q �� �D rwO ��yWQ�R o��yxR� D xO�mJ w u�Q �� ��yxt� vu� �� B x � �w � Qt C�aq�� ��rN�Ox� xm �CU� xOwtv �yOv�tR�U �Q �WywSB w �WRwt� Rm �Qt j�kLDCU� �vDio �OW���t ���� R�� p��k www�irandoc�ac�ir ��v�WvTQDUO QO Q� wYD �� uDt s�tD CQwY x� C�aq�� u�� R� ���yWN�

�CU� xDiQo Q�Qk u�QoWywSB w u�kkLt

C�aq�� u� QN� p�UQ� ut�CU� OvtWy�wN Qwvt u�ty x�xDi�� s�Hv� �D�k�kLD ��yLQ� w u�kkLt �OQi C�YNWt x� �w� QtQ�WDv� u�mt� ��D�aq�� x�o��B uOQm Ot�RwQ ut� �x�oWv�O u� �UwD�Q �t w O� Qw� s�Qi RmQt u�� ��yxt�vrYi QO �Q x�w� Qt C�aq�� u� QN�

�O���tQi �Q�� xat�H QO �v�UQ�q�� h�Oy� QDy� jkLD CyH QO

xQ�tW �� RmQt u�� u�U�vWQ�m QDW�� �y�o � xvwoQy Um CyH�Ow� Ovy�wN �� woMU�B xO�t� � �� �rN�O� ���� uirD

�v�Q�W O�yQiC�aq�� w O�vU� Q�Ot

���� Q utHv� ��yxt�vQ� R�C��tLu�Q��

w xDUw�B ���a� XwYNt OQR nvQ� C� w�a O�OH CQ�mR� �xQwO ���a� xty ��Q� xDU��w ���a� XwYNt O�iUnvQ

�xt�vQ�N �� x�Qty w QO�Y �� x�tQw� QyW u���B �D �� x�tQyt pw�sQi xm �v�Um ��Q� �CU� xOW p�UQ� �� pUrUt �xQ�tW�OwWCi�� QO �� �xt�vQ�N � RwD R� Oa� u�vC� w�aCU�wNQOCQwY x� �� Oa� �xrHt �� x�Qty w QO�Y C� w�a CQ�m ���k�aDt

�OW Oy�wN p�UQ� �O�Qiv�

C� w�a u�Q�� ��� Q utHv� ��yxt�vQ� R� C��tL x�Q u� QDv�U�O�v�UQ �Q�� �Q OwN utHv� ��i�r �CU� u QO

�y�yo �

�C������������ Q x�������yO

w �OQi �oOvR uwo �vwo O�a�� QO C����� Q uwRi�RwQ C�ty� �U x�xat�H xm p�rO u�� x� R�v w �Qw��vi w swra �� u�l�ORv ���DQ� w�a�tDH�QO u�oOvvmCmQW �CU� xOw� u�yH QO C����� Q Q�OtJQB �RwQ �tx�tu��� CUNv RwQ xO u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� �twta �tHt u�tm� w�UCW�O�t�Qo ut� OvQ�O Q�Dv� w Ovt�v�t C����� Q �xyO �Q p�U QyCyH w OwW C��tL C����� Q uOQm �twta ��yxt�vQ� R� xyO u��QO C����� Q �r�aD w VQDUo QwWm x�v�H xty xaUwD x�Q uOQm Q�wty

�OQ�o Q�Qk �yQ�m xLwrQU

�L�Yt u�ULtqe xR��H���� Q Q�F � u�QW�v w u�irwt R� CwaO

QDmO O�� xOvR �tra s�kt R� p�rHD Qwvt x� u�Q�� ���� Q utHv��k�ta Q�F�D xm QY�at Q�yW sr�a w u�O���� Q L�Yt u�ULtqe����� Q Q�F� �qDa� CyH w Ov�xDW�O u�Q�� QO C����� Q VQDUo QOQF� u� QDy� xOvQw� O�OB x� L�Yt u�ULtqe xR��H s�v x� ��xR��H���� Q Q�F� u�QW�v w u�irwt R� xr�Uwu�O� �Ovm�t ��a� ���� QxrY�i QO xOW QWDvt �i�r�D Q�F� R� xNUv wO OwW�t CU�wNQOutHv� �v�Wv x� �%�)��)�� �Q�O� RwQ u���B �D ��Q %�$&& ��yr�U

�OvDUQi� u�Q�� ���� Q�r�tH ��Q�raxR��H �tra �xD�tm T� Q

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������

�x�����������aq��

�k�kL sQDLt ���a� �x�rm C�YNWt CU� Q�v QO�v�Um w �� x�tQw� QyW u���B �D �� x�tQyt pw� �xQwOOv���tQO utHv� C�w�a x� �� x�tOviU� u���B �D xmutHv� x�orRvt QO u�vJty w ��a� ��tvy�Q ��Dm QO

�OwW QmP �http���www�ims�ir

�wv ��oO�wv�Ns�v w s�v �R� Ov�CQ��a C�YNWt u��CtON pLt w �tra �x�DQt ��r�YLD �xDWQ �C�w�au�WD�YNWt OvDU�v p��t xm �v�Um R� ��p�YLD ���x�tOviU� u���B �D OwW�t ���kD O���� q�� HQt wO QO

�OvR�U rt �Q utHv� �xv�NQ��O ���Dm ����

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N �

u�Q�� sra G�wQD xR��H u�tHvB u�wN�Qiw sra u�H�wQt ��yWWwm R� �v�OQOk ��Q� u�Q�� sra G�wQD utHv��xat�H �tra K�U ��kDQ� ��Q� �R�Uxv�tR w C�r�ai x� swta j� wWD���yu�tR�U )�v�Um x� w �Ovm�t Q�RoQ� �Q sra G�wQD �xR��HxQwOu�tHvBVQDUo w sra uOQm �v�oty ��Q� �Q �yC�r�ai u� QDQFwt w u� QDy� xm��a� ��xS� w R��wH �tU�Qt �� Ov�xO�O s�Hv� �tra nvyQi w QmiD

�OQm Oy�wN

R� sa�� �kwkL w �k�kL X�NW� x�rm R� u�Q�� sra G� wQD utHv���yORt�v Qo�O �� w OwN xm Ovm�t CwaO ��DrwO Q�e w �DrwO ��yO�yv�u�R� Qxt�vQ� �u�L�Q� �u�Q�PoDU��U �sra u�oOvRwt� u��t R� QvOQwt�v�Wv x� �Q xv�tR u�� QO p�ai ��yO�yv w �sra G� wQD QO u�Q�Pox��tQU

�Ov��tv �iQat utHv� xv�NQ��O

��yORt�v ��y�oS�w ��w QmiD VQDUo �sra uOQm �v�oty CyH QO C�r�ai xk��U ��Q�O ���� w sra x� u� R� ���yVN� �� xat�H uOQm Ovtkqa �� w ��traVv��

��tra ��yD�r�ai��iQat u�tR QO O�yv uOw� p�ai)uOw� C��L O�k QO ��

�OwHwt �tUQ ��yWwQ �� Cw�iDt w Qw�wv OQmrta ��Q�O ��

��yORt�v �iQat u�tR � ��%� QP��� �D QFm �OL

��yORt�v �iQat ��Q� �QwQ� C�aq�����OwN T�tD uirD xQ�tW w O�yv s�v )OQi �oO�wv�N s�v w s�v ��

hQat uirD xQ�tW w C�YNWt�iQat �rY� p�rO ��

CQwY QO� xv�tR u�� QO xOW �QH� ��yKQ� �� KQ� C�YNWt ���u�mt�

ORt�v OQmrta �UQQ� QO u�Qw�O x� xm �Qo�O C�aq�� xvwoQy �!�Ovm ltm xOW �iQat

�xR��H ��Oy� ���%� u�DUtR

w Gr�m u�� � �qkv� u����N �u�QyD �utHv� xv�NQ��O �v�Wv�DUBOm �� � lqB ��u�wQ�Wwv��O�aU O�yW xJwm �QYa�rw

������������� �DUB jwOvY

��� �uirD

���� Q xk��Ut u�tDiywCU��QwWm ��wHWv�O

xD�tm sQDLt T� �Q � ��� �O �k DOtLt ��k� %�)�%)�! M � Q� D QO��yOL�w ��UwQ x � QwW m � � wHW v�O ��� � Q C� k ��Ut �tra�� wHWv�O ���� Q xk��Ut u�tDiy w CU�� Ov�xOvOQm sqa� ���� Qu�Oty ��v�U �raw� x�oWv�O QO %� p�U x�t CWy��OQ� QO QwWmQO xwQo u� sQDLt u�O�DU� CmQ�Wt xm �H v� R� �OW Oy�wN Q�RoQ �u�� �i�m K�U ��kDQ� QO �� wHWv�O ���� Q xk��Ut Cq�wU KQ�u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� �wU R� �oOv��tv x� �CU� srUt �Qt� C�k��UtQO �D sQ�O �aODU� xwQo u� Ovtxkqa u�Q�mty R� �r�a��vH �Q�mty �� wQO �Ov��tv s�Ok� C�k��Ut xt�vu��� � Ov� ���w�T�U�Q� p�wU KQ��D QFm �OL �pL x�Qty x�� Cq�wU �D OwW P�ND� ���DQD OvOQm ���kD u���BVQ�PB xwLv �OOQo p�UQ� utHv� TQO� x� �Q�H p�U x�t �O u���B

�OW Oy�wN sqa� ��k�aDt xk��Ut QO CmQW "u��r�w�O

� �

� �

���� Q utHv� C�Q�����eD �yo �u�Q�������

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xUU�wt C�Q��eD �yo �� ���xQ�tW x� xOW C�F

MQw t �O�a � tw ta tH t �xU r H DQwY O� v DU� x �w �rY� TQR�� CtU� wri�U u�UL ��k� ���������NDv� pO�r��ra TQR�� CtU� �OwtLt u�oSt sv�N

�OvOW

�Q�HDQ�e C�UU�wt w �yDmQW C�F xQ�O�

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

���� Q �rrtr�u�� Tv�Qivm QO p�Ut� u�DU��D u�Q�� ���� Q�OvOwtv CmQW OW Q�RoQ� u�J QwWm QO xm

��OQmyO s�vy� s�y�Q�� QDmO u���k� w Q�Wt xQyJ� QB sv�N $p��v �oDUWvR�� Q�NDi� x� �R�Q�WxO�Rxrr�C�� �OytOtLt

�OvOt��OwtLt u�oSt�DWy�O�yW x�oWv�O QO utHv� xOv��tv

OyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�Ou�wva x� u�� R�HL u� Q�W QDmO sv�N Q�mQU ��%� x�tu��� QO $�OvOW ��NDv� OyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O ���� Q xwQo Q�Ot

u��LrYtp�Y OtLtOyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O QO utHv� xOv��tv

xQwO ZLt ���� Q xDWQ TwQO �QovR���U�vWQ�m

u�� Okavt %�)�%)�� MQwt ��)&)�&%� xQ�tW O�OQ�Qk T�U�Q�sQDLtCU�� Q w �Qw��vi w C�k�kLD �swraCQ�Rw�WRwt� sQDLtCvw�atpwwUt OyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O ���� Q xwQo �OyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�OQO wCU� xO�OQo �U�vWQ�m xQwOZLt ���� Q xDWQ TwQO �QovR���yv� x�QaC�i�m w R�r�v� �UQO O�wt ��wDLt KqY� ��Q� w �DU�Q u��Q�v�tU u�tyOR�wO u�oOvvmCmQW R� �atH �HvUQv x� p�P Cq�wUOyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O ���� Q xwQo u�Q�mty w u� ��yOQ� Q�m w R�r�v��OW xO�O Q�Qk CU� xOW xDN�vW QwWm �tra �k l� u�wva x� xm��y��wH OwW�t CU�wNQO ���� Q R�r�v� TwQO sQDLt u�UQOt R�Qvx�kv xvwoQy w CU� xt�t� xm �HvUQv sQi QO GQOvt Cq�wUQ�Ot x� �CiQo Oy�wN Q�Qk xHwD OQwt �Q�os�tYD QO �v�t�t xm � Qo�OOyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O QO ���� Q utHv� xOv��tv �� ���� Q xwQoQ��LDU� x� p�P KQW x� ���� RQ� G��Dv R� �WN� �vt� �Ov��tv p�UQ��p�wU xQ�tW �DQD x� AJ x� CU�Q R� O�Oa�� OUQ�t u�OvtxkqauwO� OYQO w u�ir�Nt OYQO �u�ki�wt �D�Uv OYQO u�ki�wt OYQO

��OyO�t u�Wv �Q Qv

� # $ �� $ �� $ !�� $� � # $ �� $ �# $ �#� $�� �� $# $ �%$ !�� $� � � $�� $ �% $ ��� $�� � $ �# $ �� $ ��� $& � & $ !� $ �! $ ��� $���� $ �# $ �� $ &� $% ��� $ �� $ �# $ �%� $!� # $ # $ �& $ ��� $�� � & $ �� $ �! $ !�� $#�# $ �& $ �� $ !%� $�! ��� $ �% $ �� $ ��� $��� � $ � $ � $ #�� $�� � % $ � $ �! $ ��� $��

�� $ !� $ �� $ �%� $�� ��� $ ! $ �� $ ��� $��

xO�UQ ��yxt�v w Q��N�

�R�Q x�oWv�O����� Q xDWQ OWQ� �U�vWQ�m u�� wHWv�O R� �QU u�rw� $��%� x�t Qyt QO x�Wv�tQm �R�Q x�oWv�O QO �OQ� Q�m V��Qo

�OvDN�OQB p�YLD x�

xk��U p�U �� R�V�� �� x�Wv�tQm �R�Q x�oWv�O ���� Q xwQo�� �OQ� Q�m w ZLt V��Qo wO QO ���� Q xDWQ QO T� QODT� QOD �OQ� Q�mV��Qo �OWQ� �U�vWQ�m �wHWv�O ! VQ�PB

�CU� xOwtv R�e� �Q �r�YLD ��kt u�� QO�W� wQO �kDOtLt�R�Q x�oWv�O ���� Q xwQo Q�Ot

Q�wR�U srat C�� QD x�oWv�O��%� x�tQyt syOiy RwQ QO Q�wR�U u�DUQyW C����� Q xv�N $Qw�L �� w Q�wR�U srat C�� QD x�oWv�O QD�D �it� pLt QOw u�Q��O R� �O�OaD w QyW C�t�kt R� ��a� �x�oWv�O T��Q

�OW K�DDi� ���� Q xDWQ u�Rwt�Vv�O w u�� wHWv�O�O�WQ x��QtQ�wR�U srat C�� QD x�oWv�O QO utHv� �xOv��tv

�DWy�O�yW x�oWv�Op�U ��Q� �Qvy uty� QDmO w �t�y�Q�� �OytOtLt QDmO u���k� $x� ��D�ar��t CYQi R� xO�iDU� Qwvt x� %�$%� �r�YLDx�oWv�O w �O�v�m QO wDvQwD QyW lQw� x�oWv�O sR�a �DQDu�W�� �m�vwQDmr�CUB TQO� �OvOW �u�DUrov� QOl� wQ�w

�O���t Q� R QOmebrahimi�cc�sbu�ac�ir

ebrahimi�mathstat�yorku�ca

bhonary�cc�sbu�ac�ir

honary�maths�warwick�ac�uk

Q D mO ��k� x m xwQ o �Q D mO �wHW v�O VywS B �Q �tL s v�N $�OvQ�O xOyaQ� �Q V�xr�UQ ���tvy�Q �t�y�Q�� �OytOtLts�ovtQ� � sR�a QwWm R� GQ�N �WywS B xQwO uO v�QPo ��Q �

�OvOW u�DUrov�

�v�t�B �tra C��y w�a u�wva x� �Q�vt ��DQt QDmO ��k� $�OvOwtv �wQW ���� Q xwQo QO �Q OwN C�r�ai

QO ���� Q VRwt� OWQ� �U�vWQ�m �OwQw u�twO p�YLD $�OW R�e� wHWv�O � �� �Q�H p�U Qyt

QDmO ��JKqY� R�ovJ QDmO ��v�Qwy�W OtL� QDmO u���k� $utHv�T��Q O�Ry� �Oyt QDmO ��k� w uULr�w���H�L u�UL

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

R�r�v� TwQO ��wDLt OQwt QO �HvUQ�v sQi���� Q xDWQ �U�vWQ�m �xQwO

�OwW x��Q� �OL�w � TQO wO CQwY x� C���� Q �v��t TQO ���

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

CQwY x� ��N Q�H OL�w � ��OL�w � ��NQ�H l� ��H x� ����OOQo x��Q� �OL�w � TQO �

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

x��Q� Q�H w R�r�v u�YYNDt UwD �w�vD x� ��NQ�H TwQO ����OOQo

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

O�OH l� R�i s�v �� �OL�w � TQO l� x��Q� ��� Q xDWQ QO ���QO �a��D R�r�v x�o��HV��tv w u� wvl� R�i ��yR�Ov�sWJ �iQat ��Q�

�OOQo x��Q� l� R�i

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

O�� R l� R�i x�oW��tR wl� R�i OL�w �� x��Q� ��� Q xDWQ QO ����O��� p�rkD OL�w � x� CU� QDy� �CU�

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

w pBt ��m�Dt�Dt �lD �UQ�B Ovv�t ��� Q ��yQ�Ri�sQv �� ���vW ����OOQo x��Q� � w � ��� Q x�oW��tR s�v �� �OL�wl� TQO wO QO ���

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

�y�oWv�OV�B TQO QO xm u�� x� xHwD �� OL �t�yiD EL�t ������ Q pYiQU R� OwW�t xar��t R�r�v TwQO QO �yOa� w CU� xOt

�OwW hPL � �twta

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

C�a�w Ow�y� ��Q� �Qo�O C�O�yvW�B w C�Qv xJv�vJ �QmWD ut��O���tQi swkQt �O� Q�O TwQO

�x�oWv�O s�v ��oO�wv�Ns�v w s�v

� �v�Wv

E�mail�

u��LrYtp�Y OtLtOyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O QO utHv� xOv��tv

C�tOkt pt�W xm OL�w � VRQ� �� �D�tOkt ��� Q R�r�v TQO ���OwW xOv�Hvo �UQO xt�vQ� QO CU� �SwrwB wD

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

X�wN u QO xm OL�w � VRQ� �� �D�tOkt �a��D R�r�v TQO l� ���OwW �UQQ� ��N ��yQorta w CQ�r�y ��y��i �Q�OtQv ��y��i

�OOQo x��Q�

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

sOa w xDa�U � ��yUqm QO u�� wHWv�O uOW xDUN x� xHwD �� ��QO OL�w � ��H x� sHL �U�vt Q��eD �� R�r�v TQO ��wr�t ���Q�m

�OOQo x��Q� OL�w xU

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

�SwrwB wD Ovv�t���yt�v R� � w � �� R�r�v ��H x� TwQO �Q�Pot�v QO ���OwW xO�iDU� ��� w �Q�OQ� R�r�v xR�Ov� x� Q�v ��D�tOkt

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

��� Q R�r�v s�y�it Q� x�mD ��H x� �twta ��� Q TwQO QO ���OwW O�m��D OQ� Q�m w C��U�Lt �wQ

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

QDtm �yv pm pOat xm �v�� wHWv�O ��Q� R�r�v �t�y�it TQO u�rw� ���OwW ��NDv� �twta ��� Q TwQO uOv�QPo R� Oa� CU� �� R�

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

�OOQo x��Q� x��k C��F� uwO� �twta ��� Q TwQO ��

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

�OOQo x��Q� OL�w � VRQ� �� �D�tOkt l�vwtQ�y R�r�v TQO l� ��

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

uDt �� �D�tOkt l�vwtQ�y R�r�v w �D�tOkt �a��D R�r�v TwQO ���OwW x��Q� �UQ�i u��� �� �rw �U�rov�

�sQ�Ov �Qv �sir�Nt �ski�wt �D�Uv �ski�wt qt�m

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

T��Q �OQm QmWD s�Ok� u�� R� �QwW �OWC��Qk u�Q�� ���� Q�Q�RoU�BU �v�� Qk xO�wv�N R� �QwW hQ� R� OvOQm sqa� utHv�

�OQm Ovy�wN

�y�oQ�m �� wV��ty x� �w� Qt C��D�mt R� ��xNUv OW QQkt $�wOyt QDmO ��k� Q��DN� QO O�YDk� w C����� Q� xv�tR QO�DavY x�oWv�O QO �Q u� �Q�RoQ� C�tOkt �D OQ�o Q�Qk �Q�t�

�OvR�U sy�Qi h� QW

CyHC����� Q xyO uWH �Q�RoQ� �� utHv�T��Q O�yvW�B R� $Cki�wt w p��kDU� p�U Qy x�t u��� QO C����� Q uOQm �twtaTB w OwW KQ�t utHv� �twta �tHt QO O�yvW�B u�� OW��yu�tR�U w xv�NDQ�Rw �Q�mty �u� j�kO u�tR � wYD R�uWH u�� QDywmW�� xJ Qy �Q�RoQ� QO �Q�mtyCyH �w� Qt

�OwW rH

���� Q VN� T��Q ���� �qwH x�t �� MQwt CwaO $QO CmQW CyH utHv� T��Q R� u�DUwOvy xDmrm x�oWv�OOwW�t Q�RoQ� %� x�t u��� QO xm C����� Q OQ� Q�m sw� RwBtUCmQWCyH �Q�t� �wOyt QDmO �Ovtxkqa OW Q�Qkt w KQ�t

�OwW sqa� �v�QvNU O�Q�� w

u�Q�� �tra ��yutHv� uw�U�tmT��Q %�)��)�� MQwt xt�v $w C��Oy w �v�yH p�U ��rt O�DU Qwt� �Q�o�B XwYN QOutHv� xv�NQ��O x� x�t O�OQt QO xm C����� Q ��yxv�N CQ�vpY� R� O�OHt p��kDU� ut� �QwW �OW KQ�t Ow� xO�UQOwN Q�m QwDUO QO �Q utHv� xv�NQ��O C�v�mt� �UQQ� �O�yvW�B

�OwW P�ND� ��Dkt s�tYD �Oa� CUWv QO �D O�O Q�Qk

xv�y�t ��yV��ty xD�tm T��Q u�tO�W uqUQ� QDmO ��k� $VQ�Ro OvOQm sqa� w OvO�O VQ�Ro �D� u�v�QvNU xQ�� QO utHv��U�rov� w �UQ�i Cq�kt pt�W O�rHt wO QO �yV��ty u��CmQL u�� QmWD R�Q�� ut� �QwW �CU� A�J xO�t� xOW x��Q�

�CUv�O utHv� ��yC�r�ai M� Q�D QO Q�oOv�t �Qt� �Q

xD�tm T��Q w utHv� T��Q x� �DUQyi x��Q� ut� �QwW $xHwD �� O�O xR�H� QwWm �� wHWv�O ���� Q C�k��Ut �trax�t Qyt pw� xQwO ��Q� �Q xD�tm u�� ���a� Q�m v�wH x�u�ULtqe �QDmO u���k�� �Ovv� RoQ� %! x�t Qw� QyW u���B$%�xN�W pwwUt u�wva x� Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O R� xO�RsqU�C����� Q w �Qvl� R�i xUUwt R� �mvQwB ��QOtLt �R�r�v�x�oWv�O R� uULr�w��G�L u�UL �Q�H xN�W pwwUt u�wva x��kD OtLt w �Q�mD�� xN�W pwwUt u�wva x� �DWy� O�yW

��QwW C��wYt �xYqN���QH�

CUWv u�tHvB w CU�� �u�tQ�yJ w CU�� �u�twU w CU��Qw� QyW u���B $ &# x�tQyt "p�w� xQwO u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� ���QH� ��QwWQw�L �� %�)�%)�# �%�)�&)�� �%�)��)�# ��yRwQ QO %� x�t

�OW p�mWD u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� ���QH� ��QwW sQDLt ���a��R� Ov�CQ��a CUWv xU u�� C�t�tYD w �yWQ�Ro sy�

��y���tyOQo�Q�RoQ�ptar�QwDUOOvOQmp�kD u��v�twD QDmO��k� $sDiy �D sHvB R� xm �yV��ty xD�tm VQ�Ro x� xHwD �� �Q utHv�p�mWD Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�OVQiD OL�w QO &% x�t O�OQNx��Q� ���QH� ��QwW x� �Q u� � wYD CyH w Ovvm u� wOD OW

�OvyO

Vvtv�Q�� �ra QDmO ��k� w OwN CmQW VQ�Ro utHv� T��Q $QO xm �Q C����� Q �v�yH x�O�LD� TqH� u�tyOQ�yJ QO�v�yH xQovm �Q�RoQ� VQ�Ro R�v w OW p�mWD ��yov�W QyWOvOwRi� w OvO�O x��Q� �Q umB QyW QO ����$u�v�O���� QxDW�Ov utHv� ��Q� �r�t Q�� xvwoJ�y �yQiU u�� xv�DN�WwN�OvOQm �Q�RoU�BU xOt� pta x� ��yVqD R� ��a� �CU�Q�m C����� Q Q�Hiv�� ��Dm xtHQD utHv� OQm Cki�wt �QwWQO xm �Q xUv�Qi �OQ� Q�m wZLt ���� Q ��yutHv� lQDWt�UQ�i u�Ovtxkqa Q��DN� QO CU� xOW QWDvt ���� p�UxSwQB u��OvDiQ�PB u�tO�W uqUQ� QDmO ��k� �OyO Q�Qk u�� R�Q u� �� QU ��QH� xwLv w OvyO Q�Qk OwN Q�m xt�vQ� QO �Qu���k� utHv� wO u�� ��UwQ �� OvOQm p�kD R�v w Ovvm �UQQ�utHv� �� �Q�mty xwLv OQwt QO �QD pW�t wC�tW�Or�w pW�t�OvQ�o� T�tD lQDWt ��yV��ty �Q�RoQ� w u�Q�� ���� QICM wIMU �Oa� xUrH QO OvOQm �Q�wO�t� Q�y � u�W���Qw�L u�Q�� OwW�t Q�RoQ� ��v�BU� QO ���� p�U QO xmx��Q� Qmi x� uwvm �sy R� �v�Q�� u�v�O���� Q w OW�� xDW�O p��ai

�OvW�� q�� C�i�m �� �Dq�kt

�v�U �raw� x�oWv�O sQDLt T��Q %�)��)�� MQwt xt�v $u�tDiyw CU�� �Q�RoQ� CyH x�oWv�O �oO�t� XwYN QO�QwW �OW KQ�t %� p�U QO QwWm�� wHWv�O���� Q xk��Utxk��Ut s�Hv� ��Q� �Q %� p�U x�tCWy��OQ� QN�w�T�BUut�

�CUv�O U�vt

O��xOvR OvRQi �v�� Qk uUL QDmO ��k� %�)��)�� MQwt xt�v $C�i�r�D R� OrHCiy��Oy�XwYN QO�v�� Qk sU�kr�w�� O�DU�OrH Q�yJ w pyJ w C����� Q M� Q�D xv�tR QO O�DU� �k�kLDutHv� xv�N��Dm x� O�DU� x� jraDt �HQ�N ���� Q ��y��Dm R�

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

X�YND Q��N x� �DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O uqwwUt R� �QwW $QmWDL�Yt u�ULtqe QDmO xR��H x� p�� Q uw�r�t GvB dr�t

�OQm

pw� RwQ xO �QwW %�)��)�� QO �twta �tHt x� �wYt wQ�B $w CUv�O U�vt C����� Q xyO u�wva x� �Q p�U Qy x�t u���u��r�w�O u��t R� utHv� T��Q �D OQm �iQat �Q Qiv CWyxt�vu��� x�t xU QFm �OL C�Ot hQ w OyO p�mWD ��xD�tm��QH� xwL v w xyO u �� sU�Qt w h�Oy� OQwt QO �tHUvtOwN uwOt ��yO�yvW�B w Ovm � wYD w u� wOD �yv� �QU�QUOv�CQ��a O�Qi� u�� �OvDUQi� ���QH� ��QwW x� O���D CyH �Q

�R��QDmO u���k� w ��DWy�O�yW x�oWv�O� �� wo �QyR QDmO sv�Nx�oW v�O� lWR B O�tL ��u�H vR x�oW v�O�O�S vu� Q� OwaUt� v�Oy�ROy�R QO �L ��s k x� oW v�O� �J v�N R � Ra ��u�Q y D�UwOQi x�oWv�O� u��LrYtp�Y OtLt ��R�Q�W x�oWv�O�xrr�O��a w �u�yiY� x�oW v�O� �yrr�O�a ��Q�ra ��OyWt

��h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O� u��OwtLt

x�oWv�O ���� Q xOmWv�O sQDLt CUQB QU %�)�&)�& xt�v $���� Q xOmWv�O ��QwW w xU��Q C��y �oO�t� OQwt QO OR�utHv� xvq�U ��yUv�Qivm R� �m� �Q�RoQ� CyH x�oWv�O u��utHv� T��Q R� T�BU ut� ���QH� ��QwW �OW KQ�tOtL� �QDmO u���k� �oO�t� R� �q�� Um R� TB CU�wN�xvq�U ��yUv�Qivm �Q�RoQ� CyH xO�RsQm �raO�t� w �v�kLsHvB w�U sQ�yJw�U ��yUv�Qivm u�v�� R�t ��oO�t� �DQD x�

�OvvmXNWt %� w %! �%� ��yr�U QO �Q sDiyw�U w

QDmO��k��iQatXwYNQOOwQy�Wx�oWv�O sQDLtT��Q xt�v $Q��O u�wva x� x�oWv�O u� ���� Q xwQo sQDLt Q�Ot �vULQ�tut� �QwW �OWC��Qk QwWm ���� QTv�Qivm u�tQ�yJw�Uu���k� �OyWt�UwOQi x�oWv�O� u��vwDwD xR��i QDmO sv�NT�BUs�QOB ��u�et�O x��B swra xOmWv�O� VvtQ���WN s �m �QDmOx�oWv�O� s�vm�v xrr�OU� ���O��v� ��yWv�O x�oWywSB� �QiYx� �Q �OwQy�W x�oWv�O� ��HQ Q�m � �ra w �OyWt �UwOQiw O� RoQ� Tv�Qivm u�� �tra xD�tm QO OwN u�oOv��tv u�wva

�OQm wRQ� �Q u� jiwt �Q�RoQ�

sm R� �q��UmCyH OQmCki�wt �QwW ��r�k C��D�mt wQ�B $C����� Q �v�yH p�U �rt O�DU R� xOv�t�k�� ��yQ�m h�m wOvwW �iQat CQ�Rw �WywSBCvw�at x� �ywmW QwYvt ��k��� x�Qty �Q �yQ�m pt�m CUQyi pwwUt OQi �Q�mty �� u�W�� wx�yD �QwW�Oa�CUWv QO KQ�CyH ��yxv� Ry OQw�Q� w lQ�Ot�)���% xQ�tW xt�v x� MU�B QO r�t u�� OW Q�Qk �Ovvm�OwW Tmavt �QwYvt ��Q QDmO ��k� %�)�&)�% MQwt

�tra xD�tm T��Q u�wva x� srat C�� QD x�oWv�O R� �����O��Ov�xOQm Ci�� QO R�v �Q OwN s�mL� w xOW ��NDv�

C�k�kLD �swra CQ�Rw u�vw�at ��QwW %�)!)�% MQwt x� wYt $�HQ�N w �rN�O C�k�kLD R� xO�iDU��wU OQwt QO �Qw��vi w

�OW C��Qk Q� R KQW x�

C� � F� w �w�wt �UQQ � w O �OQ D O�H �� R� T Bp�mW� x �� xOW s�H v� � D� k � kL D xO� i DU��wU�t�Dv� C�irND x� �oO�UQ ��yC��y �hrDNtu�a QO xOvvmxO�iDU��wU �� �tra C��y ���a�U�vt w ���k OQwNQ� u�O�DU� CtQL C��aQ

�Ov��tv

QO xOW xDiQ�PB ��yD�rwwUt �T�BU ut� utHv� T��Q $�u�tO�W �u��v�twD �u��vwDwD �QDmO �UwD xDWPo CUWv OvJ�Q�wO�t� Q�y � w OvOW Qw�O�� �Q �Q�t� �wOyt w �Jr�kOtx� �Q u�WOwN C�t�Ok� xH�Dv QDOwR xJ Qy u�Q�woQR� u�� OvOQm

�Ovv�UQ� �QwW �q��

���� Q utHv� T��Q C�tWOr�w pW�t QwUiwQB Q�N� xt�v $Q�Qk xOW s�Hv� C�t�Ok� u�� QH QO �QwW �OW C��Qk xUv�Qip��Ut CU�wN u�tO�W QDmO ��k� R� T�BU ut� w CiQoutHv� uDrw�� xawtHt x� �w� Qt Ov� OQwt QO w OvQ�o� �B �QQ��U� ����QW �� xm �#&# �D ��%&�� R�e� R� xUv�Qi ���� QOvR�U �r�t �Q u�QyD x�oWv�O OQ�o� Q�Qk Q��DN� QO Ov�wD�t u�U�u�QyD x�oWv�O ��NDv� �OwW xO�iDU� xOt� V�B CYQi R� �D� wYD ��Q� j�iD� x� v�wH �UQQ� R� TB Qwvt u�� ��Q�

�OW

w xNUv ����QO Q�t� w ���� Q xt�vxS�w A�J O�OHD �� �QwW $�UwD ��y�oWv�O QWv RmQt �wU R� �r�UQ� O�OQ�Qk ���t�xD�tm OW QQkt ���DQ� u�� QO �OQm Cki�wt �utHv� Q�Oxv�RN�v�� R�� �� xt�vxS�w �Oa� A�J xm OyO ���DQD utHv� �v� RoxS�wu� QO w OW�� x�Qty O�OH ��yxS�w uOwRi� w OwHwt ��yxS�w

�OwW QvO�OHD �rwY� CQwY x�

OQwt QO �QwYvt ��Q QDmO ��k� %�)�&)�# MQwt xt�v $��yvtHv� ��Q� QHi O��v� u�tDN�U R� xk��VW O� QN u�mt��� �QwW w OW C��Qk p�� Q OQ��r�t CU�� dr�t x� u�Q�� �tra��yvtHv� ��%� p�U xHOw� R� OYQO �� �D �� X�YNDQ�y � �Q�RoU�BU ut� wCki�wt Qwvt u�� ��Q� u�Q�� �traC�v�mt� R� Ov�wD� OwN syU x� C�Uv utHv� Qy OQm �Q�wO�t�

�Ovm xO�iDU� u�tDN�U u��

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

utHv� Oa� xQwO xDN�yQi ��yxQyJ �iQat w V��ty u�twU�Ovm �i�� Vkv QFwt Qw� x� Ov�wD� u�Q�� ���� Q

XwYN QO �QwYvt QDmO ��k� ��vH �)�#�� xQ�tW xt�v $QO �w� Qt �v�Qov OW QQkt w C��Qk �WywSB C�Q��Da�Vy�m

�OwW �� RwD ��Uw K�U QO w Tmavt VQ�Ro�

�tra ��yvtHv� uw�U�tm sQDLtT��Q �)�#&& xQ�tW xt�v $�Q�Pox��tQU swRr w C����� Q xv�tR QO xDmv GvB ut�Dt u�Q���OvyO MU�B Qw� Rt xt�v x� utHv�T��Q OW QQkt wC��Qk u� QO

QO �r�tmD Cq�YLD RmQt QO utHv� �oOv��tv XwYN QO $Q�Uv�wN OL�w QDw�Bt�m w ���� Q xOmWv�O �u�HvR x��B swraO�R� x�oWv�O u�Oty OL�w ���� Q xwQo w u�yiY� x�oWv�Osv�N Q�mQU ��kQ���tvyQ Q�t� QDmO ��k� �� ��DQD x� ��tqU�

�OW Cki�wt �OU� s�Qy� ��k� w CN� RwQ�i xO� Qi

���� Q R�r�v� Q�v�tU u�tyOR�U VQ�Ro A�J x�ltm CyH $Q�Oxv�RN OW Cki�wt OwW�t Q�RoQ� u�yiY� x�oWv�O QO xm

�Ovvm R� Q�w �w� Qt ��UL x� p�� Q uw�r�t xO dr�t utHv�

C�Q�WDv� �Q xv�y�t V��ty VQ�Ro �UQ�i VN� OW Cki�wt $j�� OrH �wQ Ct�k �Ovm A�J xNUv ���� QO �t��iutHv� �UwD �w� Qt GQ�Nt w u��aD �t��i C�Q�WDv� p�wQC�O�ytD u� VwQi OQwt QO OW QQkt u�vJty �OwW u�t�D

�OQ�PB CQwY sRq

xm utHv� ���a� ��tvy�Q A�J w u� wOD CyH OW Cki�wt $��y�QwW ��yxQwO s�tD QN� p�U QO DQt Qw�x� TB u�� R�u�� QO w Ovvm s�Ok� xv�NQ��O T��Q OW Oy�wN s�Hv� ���QH�

�OvwW OvtxQy� R�v �tU�� QDmO ��k� C�Qv R� ���DQ�

C�v�mt� Q� xwqa OWCki�wt uDrw� Q�� QB w �kwt x� A�JCyH $uDrw� ���QH� Q�Ot Vvtv�Q�� QDmO ��k� Q��DN� QO xm xv�NQ��Ou�wva x� p�� Q uw�r�t l� dr�t swRr CQwY QO �OQ�O Q�Qk

�OwW CN�OQB uDrw� sQDLt Q��OQU x� x�wNvD

��yW��tyVQ�Ro xm OvOv�UQ ��a� �q�� x� u�tO�W QDmO ��k� $�U�rov� �Qo�O w�UQ�iCq�ktpt�W�m� OrHt wO QO xv�y�tT��Q �UwD xm �yxv� Ry OQw�Q� x� xHwD �� �CU� A�J xO�t�CyH u�mt� CQwY QO OQm x�YwD �QwW OW x��Q� xv�NQ��Ox� �w� Qt OrH �QW�v u�wva x� utHv� �C�Q�WDv� �R�Ov�x�Qx� xm ���yxNUv RH� w Ovm QWDvt w A�J �Q �UQ�i Cq�kt�Q OwN �Q�wO� Q�e C�� QWv OvwW�t ��Oy� OwOLt CQwYuDiQo �xrtH R� CqmWt OQwt QO utHv� T��Q �OWwQi��OvOQm C�LY �� RwD w A�J ��rt xv�N��Dm xQ�tW �RwHtu���k� R� xS� wx� w OW Q�DU�wN �Q �w�wt QDW�� xar��t �QwW�Q�N� x�YwD x� xHwD �� OQm CU�wNQO u�tO�W w O�Ry� QDmO�OvQ�o� s�tYD OvyO�t s�Hv� xm �D�ar��t w �r�k C�� wYt

w uDrw� x� Q� QLD C��y ��yDUWv xQ�� QO Vvtv�Q�� QDmO ��k� $R� w OvO�O VQ�Ro xOW s�Hv� ��yQ�m w ��a� QvOQwt h�Oy�Cq�kt �Qw�O Qt� QO �� QUD CyH OvOQm ���kD C��y hQ��Q�O� QN utHv� xv�NQ��O ��Q� U�vt QvmU� x�oDUO l�

�OW � wYD O�yvW�B u�� �OwW

VQ�Ro �Jr�kOt w O�Ry� �Vvtv�Q�� ��Qiv xU xD�tm OW QQkt $p�U �rt O�DU R� xOv�t�k�� ��yQ�m �� ���DQ� QO xv�NQ��OT��Qs�w w C� Qwt�t x� �w� Qt ��yxt�vu��� R�v w C����� Q �v�yH�Ovvm �UQQ� �Q �xv�NQ��OT��Q �O�yvW�B �u�OvtQ�m �Q�Q���Ovy�wN �QH� p��k �QwW C�� wYt xrRvt x� xD�tm u�� C�� wYt

�Ow�

CyH �GQ�N x� �Qm �P u�UL QDmO ��k� CQi�Ut x� xHwD �� $C�kiwt �wRQ� w QmWDut� �QwW ��D�ar��tCYQi R� xO�iDU�u�wva x� TB u�� R� OQm ���kD u�tO�W uqUQ� QDmO ��k� R�

�Ov��tQi CmQW �QwW C�UrH QO �rY� w�a

�Q Q�oOv�t ��yxQyJV��ty Q��O R� xO�UQ xt�v O�Ry� QDmO ��k� $��yxt�vu��� R� �q�� �Q�RoU�BU ut� �QwW �OvOQm C��Qk�Q�RoQ� CyH OQm �Q�wO�t� Q�y � w CUv�O sRq �Q �w� Qt

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

x��B swra s��B��OQ� Q�m x��B swra xOmWywSB �tra xt�vQ�N

�OQ� Q�m x��B swra xOmWywSB $ �y�oWv�O O�yH �R��Dt� L�Yu�ULr�p�kt ��DHt �pwwUt Q�Ot

��%� Qw� QyW ��� xQ�tW $ swO p�U

�OQi ��Q��VQwQB ��rt u�tR�U �u�QyD ��rL xtqa u�DUQ��O �WRwt� RmQt xt�vQ�N

u�WNQO ��yO�OaDU��QiaH �OytOtLt �pwwUt Q�Ot��%� O�OQt ��� xQ�tW $swO p�U

� �

�DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O ���� Q xwQo $ �tra xt�vrYi�DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O ���� Q swra xOmWv�O �R��Dt�L�Y

��%� Q�y� �� xQ�tW

��xQ�wy�t Q��U C�Q��Nt �u�D�B wvwQ� �xOvU� wv

�Q�OH p�i�QU� $ l �mL OtLt �u�tHQDt��%� u�DU��D �pw� A�J

� �

s��N ���� Q utHv� �WywSB $ �YYND xt�vy�os��N ���� Q utHv� �R��Dt� L�Ys��N �r�a VRwt� xUUwt �QvQ� RQ�wUl��J OwaUt �pwwUt Q�Ot

��%� x�tQw� QyW �� xQ�tW $ swO p�U

� Journal Sciences of Islamic Republic of Iran

Volume �� Number � Summer ���� Tabestan ����

� Journal Sciences of Islamic Republic of Iran

Volume �� Number � Autumn ���� Payis ����

C�� QWv �iQat�Ovm�t �iQat �Q utHv� QDiO x� xO�UQ �C�� QWv w �Dm �xt�vQ�N

C�� QWv w �Dmxt�vQ�N�

���� Q u�trat �WRwt� w �tra ��yvtHv� x�O�LD� �R��Dt� L�YQwWm

sOkt�v��rU u�UL �pwwUt Q�Ot��%� u�DU��D w Q�y� �� xQ�tW

xt�vQ�N�u�DU� ��yv�DUQyW ���� Q u�trat �WRwt� w �tra utHv� �QW�v

u�QyD�yrr�u�a ��Q�ra �pwwUt Q�Ot��%� R���B w u�DU��D �& xQ�tW

QwWm ���� Q �tra ��yvtHv� �x�O�LD� �xt�vQ�N�u�yiY� x�oWv�O ���� Q �tra utHv� �pw� xQ�tW R��Dt� L�Y

�v�t� �i�Yt �pw� xQ�tW pwwUt Q�Ot��%� O�OQN �� xQ�tW

QO QwWm ���� Q �� wHWv�O �tra ��yvtHv� V��ty u�rw� VQ�Rou�yiY� x�oWv�O

QO QwWm ���� Q �� wHWv�O �tra ��yvtHv� ��yD��ai OQmrta VQ�Ro��%� p�U

���� Q VRwt� OWQ���WRwt� �R� Qxt�vQ� u�tR�U �VQwQB VRwt� CQ�Rw �R��Dt� L�Y

�WRwt� ltm C�Q�WDv� QDiOxO�Ru��H�L ��Q�ra �pwwUt Q�Ot

�& xQ�tW $��%� p�U )syORwv p�Uu�Q�� QO���� Q VRwt��k���D xar��t s�Hv� CQwQ� �Q��OQUCW�OO����yx�oO�O �u�Q�� QO �UQO ��y��Dm h�r�D xJN� Q�D ��yQwWm Q��U ����Q�ovs� wkD w s� wkD Q� ��xtOkt ��R�� x� Qv �xUOvy VRwt� u� wvC��wQ �lWQ�� O�DU� R� �O�� ���UL ��Dm u�irwt u�wva x� �yxJ�x� MU�B )Q�N � ���OD�� C����� Q T� QOD w Vv�O� ��Dm Okv �u�trat

�yxt�v

�r�a C����� Q ��� OrH C����� Q hQ�atr�xQ��O�u�tr� ���� Q O�D�U� R� �atH � u�irwt

QwB�U�� ��Qtqe �xtHQD��%� pw� A�J �QH�yt QWv

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

ROr�i p�Ot u�DUNv ��yRwQ �xJN� Q�D��v�o� Q s��Q pQ�m

xJN� Q�D �t� �OvU�vW�t �Q ROr�i p�Ot �yxW�B ���� Q xty�QYDNtKQW xr�ktu�� �Ovv�O�tv xty �Q u�u�DUNv ��yRwQ�CU� C����� Q �rrtr�u�� xat�H QO ���yO�O� wQ w �u� OrwD R�

�OW QHvt u� OrwD x� xm

ROr�i RrQ�J u�H��vO x� �Ckw u� ��ra ��O�v�m � w� Q�Dv� uDr�ty QO �%�� QO ROr�i�Ov�OQo�t �Q �� Qenv�m u����N �� xQ�tW QO sQJ xR�et VQOB �Ot��oOvR �kQWnv�m u����N ��� xQ�tW QO �m�ORv u�ty V�xO�wv�N wxm �H u� �Ov�xOW Zwa �CU�yCOt u�tDN�U wO Qy� �OvOQm�tu�tyt sy xv�N �O� QN RmQtl� �CU� uUmH u�O�t q�L �Ow� xR�etOW p�YLDr�dQ�i wDvQD x�oWv�O R� �%%! QO ROr�i ��xOW �O�t�Q ��QUu�� �PH q�tDL� �CiQ Rv�mB�yRv�H x�oWv�O x� p�YLD xt�O� ��Q� w��m� Qt� ��yy�oWv�O u�� �Rv�mB�y Rv�H x�oWv�O �kwt u� xm Ow� xOW�Q u� ���� Q xt�vQ� �OQm�t O�m �D VywSB Q� QDW�� xty R� �r�tWxDN�U �Ow� �Hu� xm �%%� �D �%&� ��yp�U ��� QDU"wr�U � "H� "H��y��wH V�xt�vu���B u�wva �CiQo �QDmO �%%& QO ROr�i �Ow�dny

dxn� x

my xrO�at u�at p�QoDv� �� ��y��wH w �O�tv u���B ��

A�J Tm�DtDtw� p�vQwH um� Qt� QO �%%� QO xt�vu���B u�� �Ow�QO �vor� Gr�m x� Oa� w �O�O TQO Rv�mB�yRv�H QO p�U wO ROr�i �OW

�CiQ ��vwr�UvBOw� ���Q�v �r�tW ��m� Qt� QO C����� Q �kwt u� ��w R� ROr�iEQ� �� �CiQ �B wQ� x� Q��N u�ty x� ��CU� lQO p��k qt�m u�� w�xOCUv�wD �V�xv�OYDkt �oOvR w �Ow� xO�UQVv�Or�w R� xm �QYDNt

�Ov�t� �B wQ� QO �Q Oa� p�UQO u�vJty �rw u�rQ� QO �DOta� Ov�QPo �B wQ� QO xm ���yp�UC�ty� x� VO�kDa� w CW�Po w� Q� �k�ta Q�F�D �T� Q�B w u� "ov�D�o��yxW�B���� Qu� QDoQR� R� �Q��U� �� �OQm QDsmLt �Q���� QVywSB�vW� �p "Uv"y w Tmwi �T�QDWQ� w �Tw�v� Qi �u�rm xrtH R�� u�tR u�Qta xOv�t�k�� �� xm �O���Qo �Q�H ���wD x� V���� Q j�qa w �OW�DUwO �OQm QWDvt xv�tR u�� QO �O�� R ��yxr�kt C����� Q QOV� Q�m�OQm Q�QkQ� ��O�wU xW�B���� Q� Qr"ir n �D�t �DUo �� sy �Qtar�s�O�t�O�v�m x� wDvQD x�oWv�O QO xS� w TQOt l� u�wva x� ��#�� QOutHv� w�a �#�# QO �Ov�t �H u� V�oOvR u���B �D w �CWoQ�QDW�� �OW uOvr �Dv�rU utHv� w�a �#�� QO w ��O�v�m �Dv�rU���vW� x�WO�B u�OvJ �� OwW�t xDio w �Ov�QPo�t �B wQ� QO �QVDq��aD�OQmCmQW Ow� xO�O O�wU x�WO�B xm s�W �v�tyt QO �CW�O �YNW

uwo �vwo

�m�vwQDmr� CqHtQv R� xJ �Q �Q�otWJ CqwLD �WywSB xRwL x� QDw�Bt�m OwQw�q�� Qv R� xJ w CU� xO�O CUO x� xm �awvDt �Q�Ri�sQv C�v�mt�xm�W w �m�vwQDmr�CUB �Q�N� OQwt QO �CU� xO�OQoHwt �v�UQw QD �� QU �QD ��Uw ���DQ� Hwt �CvQDv�� s�a xQDUo ��� �w �v�yH�R�Ht ��yxv�N��DmV��O�B�iQ� R� �CU� xO�OQo u�kkLt QD K�LY�m�vwQDmr�Dm xOvQ�oQ� QO �OwN �ve xO�ar�jwi ��yw�WQ� Q� xwqa xm��v�UQ�q�� xRwL QO �Q �O�OH syU �OvDUy �m�vwQDmr� CqHt w�CU� xO�O X�YDN� OwN x� �xOW O�rwD C�aq�� xw�v� x� xHwD ��Ciy pt�W �WN� �u�J QO u�v�O���� Q �rrtr�u�� xQovm QO R�v p�Ut�xOvyO u�Wv xm CW�O X�YDN� �m�vwQDmr� C�Q�WDv� x� �v�QvNU

�CU� �w�wt C�ty�

���� Q �m�vwQDmr� xrHt u�rw� xm CU� QmP x� sRqCq�kt xm OQ�O s�v New York Journal of Mathematics

CQ��a u� �URL �v�Wv �Ovm�t A�J �Q ��q�� K�U QO �WywSB�R� CU�http���nyjm�albany�edu

Zentral w Math Review QO �m�vwQDmr� �WywSB CqHt QFm �Ovv�t �OvwW�t Okv blatt Math

� Electronic Research Announcement

� Representation Theory

�##! p�U R� �Q �yv� w OR�OQB�t CqHt u�� ����WRQ� x� R�v ISIxLqt �Q http�www�isinet�com�CU� xOv�Hvo OwNCUQyi QO

��O���tQiOvv�t OvwW�t �Qw�O �DvU �DQwY x� �twta CqHt u��

R� ��a� �Documenta Math w New york J� of Math

Print� �B�J CQwY x� Advances in Geometry Ovv�t �yv��WywSB CqHt R� ��a� xwqa x� �OvwW�t QWDvt R�v �VersionOvv�t OvQ�o�t Q�Qk u�OvtxkqaTQDUO QO u�o��Q CQwY x� �m�vwQDmr�

�Journal of Integer Sequences

�vqw� �xrHt w ��Dm Q�WDv� u�ovU xv� Ry u�Q�� QO xOvQ�ov Qv x�C�OwOLt ��yv� A�J ��yxQwO uOw� svt�v �CqHt A�J Q�Dv� uOw�x� Q� QLD C��y C�UrH p�mWD Cq�at ��yxrHt C�OrHt w C�LiYw OyO�t jwU �m�vwQDmr� Dm w CqHt A�J �wU x� �Q �t ��� w�WRwt� w �WywSB ��yxRwL xm OUQ�t Qv x� xDU��W �DU�Q u�� QOxr�kt u�oOvyOx��Q� R� C��tL �� �r�a VRwt� C�UUwt w �yy�oWv�OOn Line �� CD CQwY x� xm ���y��Dm R�v w �m�vwQDmr� CqHt QO

�Ovv�UQ �Q�� O�OH �vOtD xirwt u�� VQDUo x� �OvwW�t x�Qau��LrYtp�Y OtLt

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

sU� x� Ot� OwHw x� �tra �D��tL O�yv l� pUmwQ� QO p�U u�p�t� �wUv�Qi xW�B���� Q u� T��Q xm ��WywSB �rrtr�u�� C��y�u�DUQ�Ht$V� QD� �u�tr�� �RmQt ��yCQOk C� w�a �OD�� �Ow� Qm�B�rrtr�u�� x�O�LD� x� �vt u�� w �Ow� �wvtt u� QO �x�mQD w u�DUQ�er�u�rw� QO ��#�� QO x�O�LD� u�� �OQm C��QU sy �w�s���� C����� QxOW OrwDt nQw�T�QDU QO nvH R� TB u�v�O���� Q �rrtr�u�� xQovm���yZ�QDa� �*Tma Q� xv CU� s� �U�� xO�R w�s��� TB� �Ow���yx���Q xty� �Cio �OQ�y I� �H �OWv jiwt �t� �OW Ovr�Q��N x� �u�� uDio ut Qv x� ��� OOQoQ� p�k pmW x� �k�kO O��� �traxDUHQ� ��yxQyJ R� �Q��U� (�#�%' p�UQ�B xm ��xv�ktL� r��tQrir$n �D�t �CU� �QwQ� �Ov�xOQm QWDvt xUv�Qi w u�DUrov� �traO��� QO xm Ow� �Qopta QOk u� �t� OQm swmLt �� wk �Q OQ� CU��U syOQU OvD C�U�UL� xm �v�tR Qot �OQm CwaO O���v �Q �RmQt ��yCQOk

�(�' �� xLiY �OW�� xOWCUWv QO Ovv�wD� �RmQt ��yCQOk xm u�� QU Ow� �O�� R xWk�vt�CQ�yvR�� �B p� w uUm�O �� p� �xv �� Ovvm CmQW lQ� w�v QO �Oa��yu� �OvOw� nQw�T�QDU xQovm QO w�s������m� Qt� $VN� ��yxOv��tvQy �OyO p�mWD lQ� w�v QO �Q V�Oa� CUWv OvOQm CwaO xQovm R�OW swrat �#�� �D �OvOw� xOQmv CQwWt T�s��� �� OQwt u�� QO OvJR� �r�tC��tL OLDt Cq��� QO �xQovm xv���QoOQ� ��yCU��U Q��N x��v���DWB T�s��� u� R�TB �tm w �Ow� Oy�wNv Q�m QO lQ� w�vCUWv

�(�' �# xLiY �CiQo TB �Q CUWv u� R���NDv� �#�! xQovm ��H u�wva x� wDvQD �#�� QO ROr�i VqD ����yCQOk OQ� �� xQovm �Q�RoQ� R� �� wN T�UL� ROr�i �Qy� �OW��� QkD w� �OwW Q�RoQ� p�L Qy x� xQovm Ow� xDiQo s�tYD �t� �CW�Ov �RmQt�Q�PB�v�oDUN Qw� x� Oa� p�U wO �� w O�O u�tR�U �Q xQovm xvDl�I�y �U��U CqmWt Q��N x� ��kwt u� �OwW jiwt xQovm �D OQm Q�m

�Ow�v C�kiwt u�� ��Q� �Dv�t�CmQW u� QO xW�B ���� Q !!! �Ow� jiwt �ak�w wDvQwD xQovmOvJ Qy �Ow� nQw� T�QDU ��yxOvvmCmQW Q��Q� wO R� V�� xm �OvOQm�Ow� nvH R� V�B ��yxQovm QO �yxOvvmCmQW O�OaD R� QDtm sy Rwvy�OvOw� xO�O�DQD uy�x�Q �� ���trmV�D� Q� x� �WOQo xQovm u�� p��vO x�x� CWoR�� QO w �Ow� xO���wNv W u�OvJ w� �Ow� u� QO sy ROr�i xmx� �Q V�B ��yp�U u�wD RoQy u� R� TB �OW pDNt V��DtqU wDvQDxQovm xt�vxr�kt uqBJ�Hltm �� CUv�wD u�� OwHw �� �OQw��v CUO�OW QWDvt nQR� OrH wO QO ��#�% QO xt�vxr�kt u�� �Ovm s�tD �Q

�RmQt ��yCQOk ��yxW�B���� Q xm Ow� ��vr� QO �#�% QO xR�DT��Q� xrQmv�B xQD�wr�U xm u�� p��vO x� �OvDWoQ� �rrtr�u�� xat�H x�OvtCQOk ���a� Qo�O xm �Q���yD�OwOLtCiQo s�tYD ���r�D�� R� w�s���w Qm�B ��a� u�� u� QDsyt �OQ�o� xO�O�v Ovvm p�ta� OvDU�wN�t w�s����DUQB QU x� �v�tr� C��y �Dkw� OvOw� �To�vm p� Q��o � w�s� �� pmQ��O

�v�rwUwt �� �YNW C�kqt l� ���v�r�� �#�% �rrtr�u�� xQovm QO w�CW�O

���� Q VywSB uO�O OWQ ��Q� �Q�PB�v �oDUN Qw� x� ROr�i�VywSB R�C��tLrH ��Q� �B wQ� R�CWoR�� R�TB �tm �O�Wwm�txHOw� l� OQm �v�k �Q CrwO w� �OW xQm �Pt OQ�w w� Q�Dv�� TrHt ��Q�QkQ� wDvQD x�oWv�O ��Q� p�U Q� QqO &���� Q�Okt x� xS� w �WywSBu�� �Ow� QqO ���� R� QDtm O�DU�l� xvq�U Ot�QO xm � �kwt u� �OvmO��v� w VywSB �rt C��y T�U�D x� V��yVqD �Ow� �Diovy skQ�rt C��y x� �Oa� VywSB �rt C��y �O�t�Hv� sy w� Q�Dv� VywSBQO swra �rt O��v� ��Dty xm �OW p�O�D �O�v�m �UOvyt w swraVywSBsy �OL �D �VywSB R� ROr�i ���k C��tL O��W �CU� xOLDt Cq���xOv��tv Qrir n �D�t �OW�� xOw� Qrir n �D�t �� V��DUwO Q�F�D CLDx� O��� q �mU n �y�Ow� OkDat xm �Ow� srymDU �qmUny QO �Wv��Q�oQO �Q OwN w �O��� X�YDN� K�U u� QDq�� QO O�R� VRwt� wVywSB

�(�' �� xLiY �Ovmv lQOt w u�LDt���� �UQ�� �O�v�m �Dv�rU xUUwt x� ROr�i ��yQ�m R� Qo�O �m��Ow� xOQm T�U�D �%!# QO nv�t"ri OQ�iv �U �Q u� xm �OwW�t �w� QtQ�WDv� ��Q� �Q�R�� x� �Q u� O�Wwm w Ow� u� T��Q �#�� �D �#�# R�pwB w u�tR �Ovm p�O�D �ak�w VywSB ��Q� �RmQt R�v w��tra Qmi���a� ��Q� Ovm �v�k �Q xDUHQ� ��yxW�B Vv�O �D OQm hQY �O�� Rx�vW ��y�v�QvNU VDU�� Q xQwO �� +Ovvm �v�QvNU sOQt w xUUwtl� u�wva x� ���UQ� R� ROr�i Q� wYD �Ow� �w�Lt Q��U� �yWR� �OvtWRQ� Q��aD ROr�i xUUwt O��W �t� +OWv �rta ��WywSB RmQt�tra lQO V��Ri� xv�tR QO sy Rwvy ���UQ� �OW�� w� ��y�� wQ��y�v�QvNU Q��N x� xS� w x� w �CU� p�ai hrDNt ��yx�Q x� swta

�CU� QwyWt ��yQy R�Oa� x�vWm� q�L� V�twta

�x�O�LD� w �s��U��� �yxW�B ���� Q �rrtr�u�� �xQovmC����� Q �rrtr�u��

p�U Q�yJ Qy hQ� u�� x� �%#& R� �C����� Q �rrtr�u�� xat�H�rrtr�u�� xQovm ��v�yH nvH wO Q��N x� xikw wO �� RH� Q��l�

�Ow� M� QwR QO xQovm u�rw� �CU� xOQm Q�RoQ� �Q �yxW�B ���� Q�D��L C����� Q QO �rrtr�u�� �Q�mty O�H�� ��Q� M� QwR CUWvw pmW xQ�� QO xQovm Qy QO �OvOw� u�OQoOwN �Oa� ��yxQovm �Ow�R� V�B �D VwQ u�� �OW�t xDiQo s�tYD �Oa� xQovm ��yxOvvmQ�RoQ��� s��U�� w �OQm Q�m �� wN x� �u� R� TB �DL w �pw� �v�yH nvH

�Ov�t� xOvR CUv�wD �#�# R� TB CqmWt OwHw

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

Q�Okt w �OWv xO�O ���DQD u�vJ �Qy� O���� u� xQy� w sRq x��tQU�CU� ��m� Qt� QqO #��� OwOL� �O�v�m QqO ����� xR��H u�� �rai

�CU�v U�vDt C����� Q QO xR��H u�� Q��Da� �� qY� xm�CN�OQB �yxR��H u�rw� ���a� ��Q� �R� Qxt�vQ� Q�m x� ROr�iTBUV�B CUQO �OQt p�U u�ty Cw� QO w OW Q�t�� �#�� xt QO �t�R� �m� �OQm sqa� �Q V�C�Yw ROr�i w Ow� VQ�vm Gv�U �nQt R��OwW xi��� p�Ot jwOvY x� QqO !&��� xm Ow� u�C�Yw u�� OQ�wtuiO w� Q�Dv� xJ�� QO �� Qe xQvm x� hQWt uDr�ty u�DUQwo QO ROr�iu�� Qot �OW�� CUv�wD�tv QDxO�U u�� R� VQ�knvU �CU� xOW�wQ �ki� Qw� x� nvU u�� �Ow��tv Q�m QO �Q�k nvU qY� xmxDWwv �ki V� wQ w �Iv�� �� QO Iv�� �� �OwOL xR�Ov� x� �CU� u�tR

��#�� Cw� # nQt ��%�� xt $�! OrwD �ROr�i RrQ�J u�H�xQovm x� M� QwR QO p�U u�ty Q�t�DBU QO �Q ROr�i O�yvW�B G�vU�h�mQ � �O �H pt�W ��xD�tm w OW � wY D O�yvW�B �OQm x ��Q���Q � �yxO vQ � u�rw� u�a D ��Q � ��o �m � D w ��Q"w "U �u�DQ�m �" ���O��"D�Q�mw ��O vqvi TQir� TQq �yu� �OW p�mW D ��#��� wrU� xQovmw OW nvH xQ�� wO xv�iU�Dt �OvO� RoQ� �Q ���m� Qt� Tqo �O �UH�CUwJ�U�t G� Q�tm QO� �#�� �D �yxW�B ���� Q �rrtr�u�� xQovmnQ� pU xDr� w ��wUv�Qi TDQ�wW u�Qr xQovm u� QO �OWv p�mWD��� ROr�i p�Ot ��yxOvQ� CUQyi �OvOW ROr�i p�Ot ��yxOvQ� �SwQv

QO OwW�t �Q �u�WQ�m R� �y�Dwm h�YwDp m �� t �C i� � http���elib�zib�de�IMU�medals�

w D vQ D QO ���� u �wS QO RO r � i s � R B t U QO � m UQ � D U� v tQF� p�rLD x� u� QO xm ROr�i RrQ�J u�H E�Q�t� u�wva �� xOQm �v�QvNUQO syu�� �xDN�OQB sDU�� uQk���� Q wl� R�i Q� ROr�i p�Ot ��yxOvQ�http���www��elds�utoronto�ca�aboutus�FieldsMedal

Monastyrsky�pdf

�O�vm �wHQ (!' x� u�vJty �CUy

p�Ot OwN

��� smCUO VRQ� x� ��q� pt�W O��� p�Ot Qy Ow� xDio ROr�i&)� Q�k x� qFt �OW�� xDW�O sy ��xLqt p��k xR�Ov� w �OW�� QqOx� u�� R O�UQ�t Qv x� �p�Ot �rrtr�u�� C�y�t Q��N x� �QDt�Dv�U�Q �y�oS� w u�� �k�w QO p�Ot �OW�� �v�vw� �� u�Dq O��� u� QO xDiQ Q�mC�ty� OQwt l� sm CUO QO u� �rwB VRQ� ���#�� QqO x�� OQ�OVvR R� TQir� �swO nvH u���B GQt w GQy QO �CU� xDW�O �D��Lw� �Ovm lQD �Q Ovqvi uQm �� �ki �� Ci�� xR�H� w Ow� xO�Di� �OHCUv�wD �DQD u�� x� w �CW�Po wQo �Q u� w OQm j�J�k �Q VROr�i p�Ot��yCUwO ��a� ltm �� �Oa� xD�r�� �OwW jLrt VvR x� M� QwR QO

��CiQo TB �Q p�Ot V��U��wU�OwW�t�Q� �O�v�m�Dv�rU xv�N��Q�QO p�U Q�yJ Qy p�Otu��

u�Q��L �OW ur�U OQ�w �Ow� �vUt OQt �kwt u� xm � CQ�r�y O� w�O�Ow� xDio CQ�r�y xm u�vJ �OvOQm j� wWD COW x� �Q �y u� w OvOW Ovr�C����� Q C�y�t hqN ��rt ��yD�OwOLt xS� w x�� �D�OwOLt Qy�

�CU�

Ea�� w �OR u� x� �tyt x� Q� �w�s��� uwQO O��Dt ��yx�oO�O u��sy �Um �OwW O�OB�v qta wrU� �#�� xQovm u�tR �D w�s��� OW�#�� QO s�Hv�QU �OW xO�R xQ�� wO �#�� QO w�s��� �OWv hU�DtV��rai x�o��H x� �srymDU xQovm �Q�DN�U C���RH QOVkv ��i�� ��

�Ci�� CUOROr�i �p�Ot

�wQW �rrtr�u�� xQovm xD�tm u� QO ROr�i p�Ot OwN xJN� Q�DT��Q ROr�i �OQm CUQO �#�� Q�t�wv QO wDvQD x�oWv�O xm �OwW�tROr�i q�tDL� �OvOw� xD�tm Q��O Gv�U p"� � "H VQ�mty w �xD�tmQO xR��H u�� xOW C�F QmP u�rw� �t� �xOw� ��xR��H u�vJ Qmi x� q�kx� Qwi �! M� Q�D x� �CU� xD�tm ��yCUWv R� �m� xUrH CQwYwO ��Q � QqO ���� OW � wY D� �xUrHCQwY u �� QO ��#��xO�O �Oa� ���� Q �rrtr�u�� ��yxQovm QO xm OwW xDiQo Qv QO p�Ot���� Q �rrtr�u�� xQovm ���QH� xD�tm �OD�� �Q �yR��H u�� �OW Oy�wN���� �O�O Oy�wN C���� � Q �rrtr�u�� x �O�L D� �Oa � w ��yxW� BxOv�t �#�! xQovm ��yxv� Ry xty QUm R� Oa� xm Ow� �R�J �Qy� �QqOxm OQm xQ�W� ROr�i ��#�� x� wv�S QO �xD�tm �Oa� CUWv QO �Ow����r�D�� �u�tr� �xUv�Qi xOta ���� Q ��yxat�H �v���DWB R� p�Ot Qmi

�CU� Q�OQwNQ� OLDt Cq��� w �T� wUKQ� sy �Q �O�yvW�B p�Ot CWB pwY� ROr�i �CUWv u�ty QOxm OwW�t xO�O ���yxW�B ���� Q x� p�Ot xm xOa�k u�� �Wvt �OQmOvJ Qy �p�Ot� xm CU� CQ��a u�� �DOa�k �OvW��v p�U pyJ R� QDQ�B��Q� j� wWD CU� Q�Qk �xOW s�Hv� q�k xm CU� �Q�m CW�OoQR� ��Q�R� QDW�� VqD ��Q� �m� QLD w ��yxOvQ� hQ� R� Q�m u� QDW�� OQ�W�BQDy� ��yxOvQ� Q�m QmP QO� �OyO�t xt�O� w� �OW�� sy u�Qo�Ov�H�QwO R�ov�Q�p�HvH �vt� �� Q�mW� ��yxU��kt R� w Ow� ��DLtCU�uO�O x� s�tYD xm Ovm xO�U �Q Q�m CQ��a u�� �� Ov�wD�t xD�tm �OQm�yxDi�� CUO �oDUHQ� Q��N x� �ki xv �X�N ���yxv�tR QO p�Otsy �yxv�tR u�� QO QDW�� ��yCiQW�B x� j� wWD xmr� �xOw� xv�tR u� QO�Ow� sy V�B p�U xO ��yO�O� wQ Q�QmD u�Qov ROr�i� �xOw� Qv OQwtw �rrtr�u�� umtt OL �D O��� �yp�Ot C�y�t� �OwRi� Cra u�ty x�� � �xUUwt �QwW m sU� O �� � v �wL v I�y x � �OW� � �YNW Q �eQO p�Ot �ROr�i p��tD u�� OwHw �� xD�r� �OQw� p�Ot u�� QO �Q �YNWr�H �CiQo s�v ROr�i p�Ot ��#�� wrU�� OW xO�O xm �Q�� u�rw�CUNv �� O��� T��Q� �OW xDiQo s�tYD CUWv u�ty QO xm CU�s�wO R� u�v�t�� ��Q� �y�Q u�mt� CQwY QO w Ovm C�LY �O�v�m Q� Rw

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N �

C����� Q ��Q� p�� xR��H

p�� l� Qvy Rr�v �s�vm C� wkD �Q swra w C����� Q O��� �t�V�B p�U CU� wO x� l�ORv xm CU� �rrtr�u�� �v�O���� QQO �rrtr�u�� ��xR��H �OQm jrN sra u�yH QO Q�oOv�t �Q�F�C����� QC�ty� Q�CU� �O�m �D OvtWv�O u�� s�v x� C����� Qu�QoWywSB w u�� wHWv�O j� wWD ��Q� CU� ��xO�Q� Qov�Wv w

�sra u��

QO w� �CU� wrU� x�oWv�O QO SwQv Q� Rw CUNv nQ�vDrwDU u�vNU u���� pO�at� uwQm uw�r�t ��� dr�t SwQvCrwO OQm sqa� �v�QvNU u�ty�CU� xO�O X�YND p�� xR��H �Q�Pou��v� ��Q� ��m� Qt� QqO uw�r�tOy�wN ��a� C����� Q QO xR��H u� QD�r�a u�wva x� p�U Qy xR��H u��

�OWxOmWv�O QO u�v�O���� Q R��ywQo�UwD xR��Hu���L�Q� w O�yvW�Bp�� xR��H O��v� �xt�vQ� j�� �CU� xOW s�Hv� wrU� x�oWv�O ���� QQ�m x� R�e� ���� p�U QO p�� l� Qvy Rr�v OrwD OQor�U u�tDU� wO QOO��v� �UwD xmCU� SwQv uwQm uw�r�t ��� O��v� x�rw� x��tQU �Ovm�tGQ�Nt w wQw� Q�Ry %�� pO�at xR��H dr�t u� OwU R� w xOW �Q�Pox��tQUp��w� QO p�U Qy p�� xR��H ���a� sU�Qt �OW Oy�wN u�t�D ��v�HT�vWQU O�Qi� w xR��H u�oOvQ� �� xOvQ� u� QO w OwW�t Q�RoQ� u�wS x�tu�vO���� Q R� pkDUt xD�tm l� �UwD �y�O�Ov�m �Ovvm�t �v�QvNUxD�tm u�� �Ow� Oy�wN p�� xD�tm �� ���yv s�tYD w xOW u�at �rrtr�u��xOv��tv l� �SwQv C���O� w swra u�DUovyQi xOv��tv � pt�W Qiv � R�l� w SwQv �r�a VRwt� CQ�Rw xOv��tvl� �SwQv C���O� w swra utHv�xHwD Ovm�t VqD SwQv CrwO �OwW�t p�mWD wrU� x�oWv�O xOv��tv

�xmU�wQ ��Q� w� �CU� �Rv "m�tC�"DQ� ����O�v�m R�UxtUHt R� u� KQ��OQm ��NDv� �Q TO�tWQ�Tmal� ���trm x�oWv�O QO xawtHtl� R�OwW�t �Q u�� �xOt� Tma QwO �t�Q Qa�W Tw�r�v�t R� �v�Dq uDt� �wW u�yH Qq�U w �QPo� OwN Vv�O OL R�� �OQm xtHQD u�vJpw� uQk x� �w� Qt Tw�r�v�t Astronomica ����� QO CQ��a u��

�CU� u�vJ R�Qi u�� pt�m xtHQD �CU� xOt� �Oq�t

�w �wQ� q�� u�tU� R� �y�wN�t wD +CU� �ON wD VqD hOy�Q CWwvQU u� Vv�O ���xOW xO�R CWwvQU x� O�kt OvJ Qyu�yH Qq�U w �QPo� OwN Vv�O QL R� �y�wN�t wD +�����u�vJ �Ovm�t u�Q�H �����t xm �W�O�B �Q u�� GvQ ��wW

���Ot� Oy�wNv CUO x� �y��� RoQy �oQR� ��yxDi����(�' R� �U�rov� xtHQD�

���yxW�B ���� Q� �OQm xtHQD u�vJ OwW�t �Q p�OtCWB uDt��a� xDUHQ� Q�F� Q��N x� ��Q p�Ot u��� �OvOw� xOt� OQo u�yH xty R� xmxv�wDU� uwQO xQm Q�Owtv l� w Q�e nQ� l� uDt u�� CWB �OvOQm�CU� xOw� TO�tWQ� Qwo �wQ Ov� wo�t xmCU� �ovU p�t xm �CU�

�H�Qt��� Elisabeth Crawford� �The beginnings of the No

bel institution the science prizes ����������

Cambridge University Press Cambridge and

Editions de la Maison des Sciences de l�Homme

Paris �����

��� Olli Letho��Mathematics without borders a

history of the International Mathematical

Union�� Springer Verlag New York ����

��� Raymond Clare Archibald� �A semicentennial

history of the Amreican Mathematical Soci

ety ���������� American Mathematical Soci

ety Semicentennial Publications Vol� I Amer�

Math� Soc� Providence RI ���� �reprinted

����

��� Michael Monastyrsky� � Modern mathmatics in

the light of the Fields medal�� A� K� Peters

Natick MA ����

��� G� p� Goold Loeb Classical Library Harvard

University Press �����t�QN OtLt �xtHQDu�HvR x��B swra QO �r�tmD Cq�YLD RmQt

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

�OW���t l�D�tDU�U x�oO�O QO C��F w �j�ta O�O �xO�J�B ��ym�vmD

hwQat xt�v QO �#�& p�U QO Q��u�rw� ��Q� xm ROvrovr xt�vQ�Ovr� ��yxQ�ov� R� ��xawtHt �OW KQ�t p� w xQOv� x� ROvrovr �AQo�Om� x� C����� Q R� ���yxN�W xJ Ovm�t �v��V�B xmCU� xv�R�wQBQDW�� Oa� ��yr�U pw� QO xt�vQ� u�� C�ty� �OW Ovy�wN QDl�ORv�wULt nQR�C�kiwtl� u�CiQW�B QO �tOk Qy uwvm � w OW u���tv

�OwW�t

wQOv� �UwD �##� xyO QO ROvrovr xt�vQ� �U�U� ��ytOk R� �m�p� w $�Qwt�W $ �t��v�D x�UOL C��F� w �tQi x��k u� QN� C��F� �� Rr��w�� �UOvy ����W� xm ��w��� ��ytN xm Ow� u�� x�UOL �OW xDW�OQ��yv�� xm OvQ�O QqwOt ��ytQi �� �m�ORv ���DQ� �OvDUy ���ULX�wN�Ov�xOt� ���� Q R�r�v� R� �Dw�iDt ��yxN�W R� xm OvDUy �QD�wDt ���wDx� Qv xm Ov���t lQ�OD �Q ���y���DQ� u�vJ R� ��xm�W ROvrovr xt�vQ�sy x� �Q �R�r�v� R�� l�iQwtwD� ��ytQi w �O�Oa� x� Qv R�� �wr�o V��tv

�OyO Ovw�B

x� Qv QO j�ta G��Dv R� �m� QO u�wD�t �Q ROvrovr x� Qv xW� QsyOiy uQk QO �tQi u�tR x� xm Ci�� �a� Qt pO��D uwv�k �va� O�Oa�xOW C��F� �%�� p�U QO Tw�o V� QOQi pQ�m �UwD w OOQo�tQ�s�UkD QO Ckw xJ l CU� u�� O�Oa� x� Qv QO �tyt p�wU �CU��a� Qt pO��D uwv�k �CU� pt�m �� Qt xOv�t�k�� �Qo�Om� x� pw� OOa wOxOv�t�k�� uOw� pt�m �� Qt �OvW�� pw� OOa wO q w P Qo � xm Ovm�t u����CU� p Q� q s�UkD xOv��k�� uOw� pt�m �� Qt �� ��DQt q Q�p s�UkDC��F� � Tw�o OwN� xOW �O�B xr�Ut u�� ��Q� �O�� R ��yD��F� xmv�� ��O�Oa� x� Qv R�t�Q�QU� s�mL� R� �m� uwv�k u�� ��Ow� xOQm x��Q� Cw�iDtQ�m x� QD�twta ��yDr�L ��Q� xm Qo�O pO��D u�v�wk �OwW�t �wULt�OWhWm �#�� xyO QO u�DQ� p�t� w �o �m �D �H ��D �UwD OvwQ�t�Q pO��D �rm uwv�k xvwoJ xm Ow� u�� ROvrovr xt�vQ� ��yxR�ov� R� �m�xm ROvrovr �QU�QU Q �vD� �OwQ Q�m x� Ov�wD� OQwt Qy QO xm Ci��QO �yvD xv �Q pO��D u�v�wk R� pt�m lQO u�� �OW C��F� nQwiq �UwDu�O�t l� �OyO�t CUO x� �a��D ��yv�O�t QO xmr� O�Oa� x� QvQUm CQwY x� ���wD pt�W xmCiQo Qv QO ��xawtHt u�wD�t �Q �a��Dsy �� u�wD�t �� wo O�Oa� Ovv�t �Q �yQUm u�� �CU� ��xrtHOvJ wOl� �a��D u�O�t Qy ��Q� nQwiq �OQm s�UkD w j� QiD w �Q� w �tHl�iQtwD� ��ytQi w u� �v�wr�o xwQo V��tv u�� j�kO ����DQ� xkrL

�Ovm�t x��Q� u�O�t u� x� xDU��w

Q�t�Oqw �UwD xOW s�Hv� ��yQ�m Q� �Q OwN Q�m T�U� nQwiqu�rw� nQwiq �CU� xOQm Q�wDU� ��##� ROr�i p�Ot xOvQ�� Oriv� QOxm O�O s�taD �Qw� �Q Oriv� QO G��Dv u�wD�t xvwoJ O�tyi xm Ow� �Um

�OyO CUO x� �Q �a��D ��yv�O�t QO ROvrovr Q �vD R� �rt�m Q� wYD

�Q�Pov��v� �Ovm rH swra w C����� Q x� V�B R� V�� �Q �twtaxOW s�Hv� h�Oy� u�� x� uO�UQ O�t� �� SwQv CrwO �UwD p�� xR��H����� QVywSBC� wkD �swra p�YLD x� u�v�wH xkqaV��Ri� �CU��VRwt� w sra �t�L QwWm u�wva x� SwQv QwWm x� �rrtr�u�� xHwDrH

x� swta xkqa u�Oki Oy�W �Qe u�yH R� �oQR� VN� xRwQt�Ov�wD�t p�� xR��H �Q�Pou��v� �CU� swra p�YLD x� u�v�wH xS� wp�YLD Q� OW�� ���eQD w C����� Q w sra C�ty� Q� OW�� �O�m �Dw O���D OQwt CaQU x� xR��H u�� p�rO u�ty x� �u� QO VywSB wx�O�LD� w �B wQ� ���� Q utHv� �CU� xDiQo Q�Qk �tra pi�Lt C��tL

�OvDUy xR��H u��t�L u�rw� �RH C����� Q �rrtr�u��

x�W �UwD �#�� p�U QO s�v u�ty �� ��xR��H xm CU� QmP p��kTB �rw Ow� xOt� OwHw x� �SwQv w O�wU x�O�LD� ��wQv�tQi �swO Q�mU�CUO x� �#�� p�U QO xk�vt wO uOW �OH w x�O�LD� u�� CUmW R��� l� x� u�wS x�t p��w� QO p�U Qy p�� xR��H �OW xOQBU �Wwt�QiwQw� Q�Ry %�� pO�at xR��H dr�t �OW Oy�wN ��a� u�O���� Q OvJ

�CU��Ovyv�Q�R O�WQ �xtHQDu�HvR �x��B swra QO �r�tmD Cq�YLD RmQt

���� �v�rv�wv �xR��H w ROr�i p�Ot u�oOvQ�

�� QO u�v�O���� Q �rrtr�u�� xQovm x�L�DDi� sU�Qt �� u�tRty�v�rv�wv xR��H w ROr�i p�Ot u�oOvQ� �u�J umB QyW QO ���� CUwo �OwD� Cwy wD�DUv� R� nQwiq u�Qwr x� T�U� u�� Q� �OvOW sqa�xDiQW�B C�ar��t wD�DUv� R� �mUO�ww Q�t�Oqw w xUv�Qi l�i�Dv��U�SwrwvmD wD�DUv� R� u�OwU wyO�t x� w ROr�i p�Ot �m� Qt� uwDUv� QB�QYDNt KQW �CiQo jraD �v�rv�wv xR��H �m� Qt� �MIT�CUwJ�U�t

�O���t Q� R QO O�Qi� u�� �tra ��yQ�m R�

ROr�i p�Ot �nQwiq u�Qwr�yHwDp��kCiQW�B xOvQw�O�OB �Laurent La�orgue� nQwiq u�QwrROvrovr Q�o �Qi Q �vD C��F� �� �Q Q�m u�� w� �CU� ROvrovr xt�vQ� QOR� xO�iDU� nQwiq Q�m xYNWt �CU� xO�O s�Hv� �a��D ��yv�O�t ��Q�

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

lJwm ��yxmD xvwoJ xm OvyO�t u�Wv �Swrwtywm ��yywQo �CU���yWwQ �OvQw��t OwHw x� �Q QDoQR� ��Wl� w OvwW�t pYw sy x��yv� R� �m� xm OQ�O OwHw QDmJwm ��yxmD u�� h� QaD ��Q� �vwo �vwow s�y�it xDi�� s�taD �Swrwtywm x� Qv �OW���t u�mD �Swrwtywm�m� �Ov�OQo�tQ� �yywQo x� Qv u�� R x� �Q l� SwrwB wD ���W� ��yxO�Opm��t �UwD xm CU� K �m� SwrwB wD x� Qv �Swrwtywm x� Qv ��wv� R�xHwD r�H r�t �CU� xOW ��O�� ��#�� ROr�i p�Ot xOvQ�� ��D��m� SwrwB wD x� Qv w u�mD �Swrwtywm u�� �wk ���DQ�l� xmCU� u��

�OQ�O OwHw K

�OvDUy �Q�H ��yxD� Q�w xar��t OQwt ���W� ��Q�H xUOvy QO�O�OaD lQDWt ��yxW� Q xawtHt �xO�U u�� R x� �Q�H xD� Q�w l�h��av� p��k �m� SwrwB wD ���W� pFt �yxD� Q�w �CU� ��xrtHOvJOv�xOt� OwHw x� �SwrwB wD QO xm �Swrwtywm ��yx� Qv xH�Dv QO w OvDU�v

�OvDU�v �Q�H xUOvy U�vt

��yx� Qv �D Ov�xOQm VqD u�v�O���� Q p�U pyJ ��� QkD COt x�x� Qv COt u�� QO �OvR�U� �Q�H xUOvy ��Q� ��U�vt �SwrwtywmG��Dv T�U�Q� �mUOww xmv�� �D Ow� xOW xDN�vW pOt u� QDy� K �Q�Hl� w�Dwt �Swrwtywm O�OH x� Qv u�rUwU xQOv� �UwD xOt� CUO��Swrwtywm u�� l�ORv ���DQ� l� ��SwrwB wD Ovv�ty �OQm ��O�� �Q��xv�tR u�vJty �mUOww �OQ�O OwHw K �Q�H x� Qv w l� w�Dwt��yxD� Q�w ��Q� �Swrwtywm O�OH ��yx� Qv u�wD�t xmCU� xOQm sy�Qi

�OwW h� QaD XNWt ��yR��v T�U�Q� �Q�H

Q� �v�t l�OvDwQo x� Qv O���D QO nQR� s�o l� �mUOww Q�mxm �mUOww ��yWywSB G��Dv R� �m� �CU� C����� Q �ov�o�xm CU� Qvr�t xQ�ov� pL OwQ�t Q�tW x� w� ��Q� �Q�otWJ C�kiwtxH�Dv u�� �Ow�K �Q�H x� Qv QO �Qmi xreWt u� QDtyt xyO xU ��Q���wr�o �Swrwtywm xrtH R� hrDNt ��yxv�tR QO R�v ��r�H ��yOQ� Q�m�mUOww �OQ�O�rDNt �Q�H ��yxD� Q�w �Swrwtywm w �a� Qt ��ytQi�SwrwB wD QO OwHwt �wk ��yQ�R�� R� u�wD� xm CU� xOQm ��O�� �WwQQO q�tDL� w� Q�m p�rO u�ty x� w OQm xO�iDU� R�v �Q�H ��yxD� Q�w QO

�CiQo Ovy�wN Q�Qk ��HQ� OQwt QDW�� xOv��

Tv�U�r �OW OrwDt x�UwQ QO �#�� u�wS ! QO�mUOww Q�t�Oqw�Q ���� Q QDmO w �#%# p�U QO wmUt �DrwO x�oWv�O R� �Q ���� QhrDNt C�UUwt w� �OQm PN� �##� p�U QO OQ�wQ�y x�oWv�O R�wD�DUv� w OQ�wQ�y x�oWv�O ��uwDUv� QB� xDiQW�B C�ar��t wD�DUv� Ovv�tx�oWv�O�traC��yC� w�a x� �##� p�U QO w xOQm Q�mlvqBTm �txUQOt x� Ckw s�tD O�DU� xHQO �� ���� p�U QO w Ot�QO CUwEQwv

�OW pkDvt uwDUv� QB xDiQW�B C�ar��t wD�DUv� C����� Q

x��Q� O�OH �UOvy Q�DN�U l� OwN Q�m u�� �� ���DQ� QO nQwiq�OwW XNWt QDW�� xOv�� QO u� C�ty� CU� umtt �DL xm OQm���RU� Q�F�D QY�at C����� Q CiQW�B QO nQwiq G��Dv w C�k�kLD

�CU� xDW�O

�OW OrwDt xUv�Qi �vwDv� QyW QO �#�� Q�t�wv � QO nQwiq u�Qwrw OW p�YLDr�dQ�i �#%� p�U QO T� Q�B Qw� QB wU p�tQv pwm � R� w�xUv�Qi �tra C�k�kLD �rt RmQt QO jkLt u�wva x� �##� p�U QO�Q�H xUOvy �wQ OwU $T� Q�B x�oWv�O R� �t�D x�Qty x� Q�m x� pweWtx�oWv�O R� �Q ���� Q �QDmO �##! p�U QO nQwiq �OW ���UL wC����� Q �O�DU� xHQO x� ���� p�U QO w OQm PN� OwU $ T� Q�B

�O�UQ xUv�Qi l�i�Dv��U OwD� C�w�O wD�DUv� QO

ROr�i p�Ot ��mUOww Q�t�OqwR� �m� jr�N �Vladimir Voevodsky� �mUOww Q�t�Oqww� �CU� Q�N� xyO OvJ QO �Q�H xUOvy QO RQ�� w syt ��yDiQW�B�OyO s�taD �Q�H ��yxD� Q�w x� �Q �Swrwtywm O�OH x� QvCU� xDUv�wDw �R�UxO�U w OQHt qt�m s�y�it �� Q�m QO ���v�wD �mUOww xYNWtCUOx� G��Dv �OW���tTwtrt p��Ut x� p�O�D w �yv� uOQm Q�PBh��av�p�Ot xOvQ��l�OvDwQo QOv�Umr� ��yQ�m QO xW� Q �mUOww �UwD xOt�Q�tW x� wQW�B w QwUH �v�v�O���� Q l�OvDwQo �OQ�O ��#�� ROr�i�OH Qy� x� xN�W OvJ Ov�wD�t �OQHt s�y�it j�ta lQO �� xm OwQ�t����W� CW�O xO�ka l�OvDwQo �Ovm jLrt sy x� �Q C����� Q sy R���yxN�W QO hrDNt s�y�it xW� Q xm OvQ�O OwHw �motive s�v x�u�� ��yw�Dwt uDi�� QO �aU l�OvDwQo �OvDUy C����� Q Cw�iDt�ov�o� Q� �v�t l�OvDwQo x� Qv �CW�O xUOvy w O�Oa� x� Qv��yQ�m lQLt u�vJty w xDW�O C����� Q pm Q� �a�Uw Q�F�D C����� Q

�CU� xOw� �mUOww

����W� �CU� xOW Qy� �SwrwB wD QO CUNv �Swrwtywm swyitw xQ�vJ �xQm Ovv�t ���yR�J OvQ�o�t Q�Qk xar��t OQwt �SwrwB wD QO xmOwW�t xar��t ���W� u�� R� �Y�wN wCU� QDq�� O�a�� QO �yv� C�y��WtQ��eD �uOW xO� Q� xv w� uOW sN �� w uOW xOQWi �uOW xO�Wm QF� QO xm�� x� RHD ��Q� CU� �WwQ �Swrwtywm x� Qv �xO�U u�� R x� �Ovvm�tvQDxO�U �yv� lQO xm QDmJwm ���RH� x� �m� SwrwB wD ���W� uOR � QkD

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

swra QO xQtRwQ ��yQ�m QO hrDNt p�mW� x� q�� �wv R� p��UtC�ty� u�OwU ��yx� Qv p�rO u�ty x� w OvwW�t Qy� �Qw��vi w

�OvQ�O �O�� R �OQ� Q�m

CU� xO�O s�Hv� u� QO ��xOta ��yQ�m u�OwU xm �Qo�O CtUkQO �O�� R Vkv �yRtQ u�� �OW���t ��N K�LYD ��yRtQ x� Qv�wQ �k�Uwt ��� R� CQwY Qy x� �yv� uOQm xQ�NP w �yt��B C�vt�Qy QO �OvQ�O ��xQ�wy�t w �DvQDv�� C����DQ� �D xDiQo xOQWi lU�OQO ���y��N Ov�wD�t xm OQ�O OwHwC� R�Q�B �v�at Q�Okt ����DQ� p�v�m�Q�ovRtQ �y��N uOQm sm ��Q� VwQl� �Ovm O�H�� �r�UQ� ��yt��B�rw� s��B ��wDLt u�ty �� QD�vqw� ��yt��B p�UQ� w �yt��B uOQm Om ��xOvQ�o �OwWv O�� R �r�N ��y��N Q�JO xOW RtQ s��B l� Qo � �CU�u�� �O��� CUO x�rw� s��B x� w OQ�� u�� �Q �y��N ���WoRtQ �� Ov�wD�t ��N K�LYD� sra Qvy �Ovm�t O�� R �Q �r�UQ� ��yt��B pw� VwQQO OwHwt C� R�Q�B Q�Okt w s��B pw� V��Ri� u�� �rO�aD xm CU� u����yRtQ OvwW�t xO�iDU� Qwiwx� xm �yRtQ R� ��xDUO �Ovm O�H�� p�v�m!� COt x� �Ov�xOW �iQat �#�� xyO QO xm OvDUy uwtrwU$O� Qxm OvwW K�LYD Ovv�wD�t �Dkw �ki �yRtQ xm Ow� u�� Q� ZQi p�U��ytD� Qwor� O�rwD �� u�OwU �OvW�� ��N �v�at Q�Okt ��Q�O QFm �OL�QDW�� Q�Okt �� �Q uwtrwU $ O� Q ��yRtQ xm O�O u�Wv O�OH ���WoRtQ

�OQm K�LYD u�wD�t R�v �y��N R�

w� �OW OrwDt Ovy TQOt QO �#�� Q�t�DBU �� QO u�OwUwO�t�Qw��vi wD�DUv� R� �#%& p�U QO �Q QDw�Bt�m swra QO B�Tech� xHQOx�oWv�O R� �##� p�U QO �Q QDw�Bt�m swra �QDmO xHQO w wv�ryO QO OvyxOmWv�O Q��Wv�O Q��L p�L QO u�OwU �OQm PN� �rmQ� QO ��vQi�r�m�MIT CUwJ�U�t �Qw��vi wD�DUv� QDw�Bt�m swra w jQ� �UOvyt

�OW���t�Ovyv�Q�R O�WQ �xtHQDu�HvR x��B swra QO �r�tmD Cq�YLD RmQt

�v�rv�wv xR��H �u�OwU wO�tswra hrDNt ��yxv�tR QO �Madhu Sudan u�OwU wO�t�Ov�xrtH u� R� xm CU� xO�O s�Hv� �U�U� w syt ��yQ�m QDw�Bt�mw Q�PB� QkD Q�e �R�Uxv�y� p��Ut ��Dq�tDL� xOvwW ���� RQ� ��yD��F�

���N K�LYD ��yRtQ

�CU��Dq�tDL� xOvwW���� RQ� ��yD��F� u�R�OQBx� Qv R��m� u�OwUu�� j�� �CU� xOW xO�O ���� Q xQ�Ro l� ��Q� �D��F� O�vm ZQiCQwY x� C��F� j�vt xm OQm �U� wvR�� �Qw� �Q u� u�wD�t x� Qv�� Ov�wD�t ��� RQ�� l� �OwW xQ�NP QDw�Bt�m QO �ymwr� R� xr��vOl�C��F� xm Ovm u�at q�� �r�tDL� �� xr��vO u�� ���a� R� �NQ� �UQQ���� RQ� �UwD xm ���ymwr� O�OaD xm CU� r�H �Q�N �� CU� CUQO

�CU� lOv� �ymwr� pm O�OaD x� C�Uv OvwW�t �UQQ�

�T� �j�i �w� ��QwQ� �T� �u�OwU ��yxr�kt QO x� Qv u���s� w ��Qi�U �T� ��v�wDwt �Q� �T�w�r �p� �Ovwr ��U �QU�wOrou�W�t utHv�� ���� p�U QO �CU� xDi�� xaUwD w KQ�t �Q"o"Rsqa� pOwo xR��H xOvQ� lQDWt Qw� x� �Q q�� QO xOQ�t�v O�Qi� x�U�Lt

�OQmQ�PB� QkD Q�elQO QO�tyt ��yQ�m �Qo�Ou�kkLt x�Qty x� u�OwU�� ��DQt Q�m u�� �CU� xO�O s�Hv� X�N p��Ut R� �NQ� ��wH uOw�P �CU� NP Q��Q� P ��� �CU� QDw�Bt�m swra QO �U�U� p�wU l� �oO�U x���D��U�Lt OwHwt ��yWwQ �� xmCU��r��Ut xty xawtHt �oO�U x�� �CU� QD CNU� p��Ut pt�W NP w OvDUy pL p��k��ysD� Qwor� C��U�Lt �oO�J�B x� xm OQ�O �vi �vat l� xO�U� ��CU� ��xr�Ut NP QO CNU� xr�Ut l� �OQ�O ���DQ� �QDw�Bt�mI�y �rw CU� ���� RQ� p��k �oO�U x� uOW �O�B R� TB u� ��wH xmxOWv xDN�vW uwvm �D ��wH u�� uOQw� CUOx� ��Q� ��xO�U sD� Qwor���Q� xv�y� ��wH uDi�� OvtR��v NP CNU p��Ut R� �NQ� �CU���xDUO O�vm ZQi �p�Ft u�wva x� �OvDUy C����mQD QO ��xr�UtxDUOQ� R u� QDoQR� �CU� xOW xO�O �y�vDt ��yxawtHt R� �y�vDt�R�J �OQ�O w�a OvJ CU� �yD u� QO xawtHt wO Qy l �QDW� xm��Q� � QkD uOQm �O�B xm CU� u�� Ov�xO�O u�Wv u�Qo�O w u�OwU xm��wH OwN uOQm �O�B �DNU u�ty x� p��Ut �wv u�� ��Q� xv�y� ��wHxOvwW ���� RQ� ��yD��F� �� �m�ORv ���DQ� xH�Dv u�� �OW���t xv�y�

�OQ�O �Dq�tDL�

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� �kwkL ���a� w u��t�LR� u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� ���QH� ��QwW �Ov�xOQm C��tL u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� ��yC�r�ai R� OwN ��y�v���DWB w �ymtm �� Q� R ��yO�yv w C�UUwt

�CU� Q�RoU�BU xv�t�tY OvtWRQ� ��yC��tL u��

�Qw� vi w C�k�kLD �swra CQ�Rw �tra ��yvtHv� uw�U�tm��OyO�t X�YND OwN VWwB CLD �tra ��yvtHv� R� s�Om Qy x� Zwaq� ltm u�wva x� �Q �er�t xr�U Qy uw�U�tm u��

u�QyD �xkvt �Q�OQyW �

xO�O Q��eD C����� Q u�DUw� x� �Q lQ�B u� s�v w X�YND utHv� xv�NQ��O x� �Q u�QyD O��� CHy� lQ�B QO �k�w u�tDN�U u�QyD � xk�vt �Q�OQyW�CU�

QwWm �tra ��yWywSB ��QwW �

�CU� xOWCN�OQBltm u�� R�v p�Ut� �Ovm�t �Oy� u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� x� �er�t p�U Qy QwWm �WywSB w �tra ��yD�r�ai R�C��tL QO �QwW u��

��� u�UL s�t� x�oWv�O �s�t� x�oWv�O C�Q�WDv� �x�oWv�O u� sQDLt T��Q Cki�wt w u�UL s�t� x�oWv�O ���� Q xwQo sQDLt ���a� �Q�o�B w utHv� T��Q O�yvW�B x�

�CU� xDiQo xOya Q� �iQYt Pe�m x� �w� Qt ��yxv� Ry RH� �yxv� Ry x�rm p�kD �� �Q utHv� xt�vQ�N A�J w �i�QowD�r pL�Qt s�Hv� u�UL

�kwkL ���a�x�tQyt �D ��%� x�tQyt xQwO ���%� x�tQyt �D ��%� x�tQyt xQwO QO Q� R �WywSB w �WRwt� ��ovyQi Rm �Qt w �r�a VRwt� C�UUwt w �yx�oWv�O�OwW�t�v�OQOkC�UUwtu�� QOutHv� u�oOv��tv w uqwwUt ��UwQ R� �Ov�xOQmC��tLu�Q������ QutHv� R� ��kwkLC� w�ajLCN�OQB �� ��%�

���� x�tQyt �D ���� x�tQyt �xQwO ���� x�tQyt �D ���� x�tQyt �xQwO

�wvH u�QyD OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O � l �Q� OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O OyWt OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O � Q�Uv�wN QDw�Bt�m w ���� Q �xOmWv�O

�RmQt u�QyD OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O �tra ��yQ�v�tU QDiO u�Oy�R OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O � u�oU�QwN OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O

u�oU�QwN OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O � O���sQN OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O R�Q�W OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O � QDU�W OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O

xmQ��t OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O � R�Q�W OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O xmQ��t OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O � x�Wv�tQm OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O

��RmQt u�tR�U�Qwvs��B x�oWv�O � OyWt OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O Qwv OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O � OvQt OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O

�Q�Uv�wN QDw�Bt�m w ���� Q xOmWv�O� u�yiY� x�oWv�O �QyRr� x�oWv�O � x�twQ� x�oWv�O � u�Oty OL�w �tqU� O�R� x�oWv�O

TQOtC�� QD x�oWv�O � R� Q�D x�oWv�O TQOt C�� QD x�oWv�O � OyWt RmQt Qwvs��B x�oWv�O

Q�wR�U srat C�� QD x�oWv�O � u�QyD srat C�� QD x�oWv�O u�QyD srat C�� QD x�oWv�O � u�H��� QP� srat C�� QD x�oWv�O

Oy�W x�oWv�O � u�HvR x�oWv�O � �R�Q x�oWv�O �DWy� O�yW x�oWv�O � u�HvR x�oWv�O � �R�Q x�oWv�O

u�yiY� �DavY x�oWv�O � u�tQm Qvy�� O�yW x�oWv�O Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O � u�yiY� �DavY x�oWv�O

�Uw�u�Or�Q�YvxH�wN �DavY x�oWv�O � Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O h� QW �DavY x�oWv�O � �Uw� u�Or�Q�YvxH�wN �DavY x�oWv�O

u�W�m x�oWv�O � sk x�oWv�O � OyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O OR� x�oWv�O � sk x�oWv�O � OyWt �UwOQi x�oWv�O

���y� M�W �r�a VRwt� xUU�wt � OR� x�oWv�O � u�oRtQy x�oWv�O u�HvR �x��B swra QO �r�tmD Cq�YLD RmQt ����y� M�W �r�a VRwt� xUU�wt

R� Q�D x�oWv�O u�Q�� �x��B swra C�k�kLD RmQt

�� ���� x�tQP� � xQ�tW �� p�U

� �

u�Q�� ���� Q utHv� xt�vQ�N ��

utHv� ��yQ�v�tU w �yUv�Qivm �s�wkDu�Q�� ���� Q

�SwrwBwD w xUOvy Q�v�tU u�twO �Q��mQ�t� �DavY x�oWv�O ���%� x�tuty� �! $ ��

���� Q R�r�v� Q�v�tU u�tyOR�U �

u�yiY� x�oWv�O ���%� x�tOviU� �� $ ��

QwWm ��wHWv�O ���� Q C�k��Ut u�tDiy w CU�� �

u�Oty �v�U�raw� x�oWv�O ���%� x�tCWy��OQ�

u�Q�� Q�H Q�v�tU u�tyORv�B �

uq�o x�oWv�O ���%� x�tQ�D �% $ �#

u�Q�� ���� Q Tv�Qivm u�tQ�yJ w �U �

OwQy�W �DavY x�oWv�O ���%� x�tQw� QyW % $ ��

u�Q�� R�r�v� Q�v�tU u�tyOQ�yJ �

u�Q�� CavY w sra x�oWv�O ���%�

u�Q�� Q�H Q�v�tU u�tyORv�W �

R�Q�W x�oWv�O ���%�

���� Q R�r�v� Q�v�tU u�tyORv�B �

u�DUJwr� w u�DU�U x�oWv�O ���%�

�SwrwBwD w xUOvy Q�v�tU u�twU�

R� Q�D srat C�� QD x�oWv�O ���%�

QwWm ���� Q Tv�Qivm u�tHvB w �U�

R�wy� u�QtJ O�yW x�oWv�O ���%� x�tuty�

Q�H Q�v�tU u�tyOiy �

u�DUJwr� w u�DU�U x�oWv�O ���%!

QwWm ���� Q Tv�Qivm u�tWW w �U�

OR� x�oWv�O ���%! uty�

QwWm ���� Q Tv�Qivm u�tDiy w �U �

R� Q�D srat C�� QD x�oWv�O ���%�

�SwrwBwD w xUOvy Q�v�tU u�tQ�yJ �

x�twQ� x�oWv�O ���%�