13
ljYtlr 4 a d9 n1:?tnttv11l0ltcr ^- il I e 1 e v . v frl:2ruri o{ n .ll ! d'lu: ?!x0 ing { dou lu fi1:ut}J 1:do rufl nu "l d{fl o dlun i 1 l; 4 v 4 erav ^ 49 'rrr.] rrnvluyrfllt flfiu'llJrso!flnu1nuYrq5 4?tulorduoflnn'lt?tfit 1st410{a n{:lunvlouono tuu t,io cl 4 d v dfl anuorn l! tunlt?[nt1st41,0u0 flltaau nld'tu[1lu{ruuu10:r1u nlu?ufldl,9t?0u1.1 rira66vrnaoulunl:Irnnun{uuufi rd' fl?luu1n3t u'llo.:nldflgl rira6sr'vrnaorlunr:rlon[[0{[[urroyl fl at?rJns[[uuldu.rlxufila'{do{ (Sum of Squares) , j i .- fitlqAufl ,Iruuriu{tuufito.:dort (Mean Square) 'd,a o.:fl'luH {n?lulijuoa:c (Degree of Freedom) --i uBdln mIsdflafltstltI.05 -^l uudlnqml{do9rYr:snu .01 x S.D. n t p F SS MS df llYtu tlYru ItYtu rtYlu uYtu Itvlu llYlu lrllu ltYtu uylu uYtu a ay R1fld1t0 ontr?tnt]vfi1o 4 d 9 rrq o u9 I u fl n01fl n1:lfl u:?u:?ur0{0 {?!0 tnfl :?ndouR?ludriu:0r10'r[[uud0u01!a{:fi d r7oryn unrrJ:rl.lnilar1o{o lnol#}J:un:tofi6rirrBrgrJ nrrl.irniu nt:lfluoflont:irn:iEf tt t a' -! 10unu roonl u3floun{u noud r Hanr:irn:ryrirTolam-r}iro{dnoxrrxxdoxorrr noud z Ho nr:irn :rv tinl:i riru i u n uoo g {ouu 1u nr: 13 r r: ao ruf; nu'r t; d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 . 4. {i 4 t I e doluf,n!1 f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul :youdnu1fuilrJ5 fluunnlrjlflfl tJ:sdun1:Bi tunl:u0un{1u un s 1u 1n1o.r d01u dnu 1

z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

ljYtlr 4

a d9n1:?tnttv11l0ltcr

^- il I e 1 e v . vfrl:2ruri o{ n

.ll ! d'lu: ?!x0 ing { dou lu fi1:ut}J 1:do rufl nu "l d{fl o dlun i 1

l; 4 v 4 erav ^ 49 'rrr.]rrnvluyrfllt flfiu'llJrso!flnu1nuYrq5 4?tulorduoflnn'lt?tfit 1st410{a n{:lunvlouono tuu

t,io cl 4 d vdfl anuorn l! tunlt?[nt1st41,0u0

flltaau

nld'tu[1lu{ruuu10:r1u

nlu?ufldl,9t?0u1.1

rira66vrnaoulunl:Irnnun{uuufird'

fl?luu1n3t u'llo.:nldflgl

rira6sr'vrnaorlunr:rlon[[0{[[urroyl

fl at?rJns[[uuldu.rlxufila'{do{ (Sum of Squares)

, j i .-fitlqAufl ,Iruuriu{tuufito.:dort (Mean Square)

'd,ao.:fl'luH {n?lulijuoa:c (Degree of Freedom)

--iuBdln mIsdflafltstltI.05-^luudlnqml{do9rYr:snu .01

x

S.D.

n

t

p

F

SS

MS

df

llYtu

tlYru

ItYtu

rtYlu

uYtu

Itvlu

llYlu

lrllu

ltYtu

uylu

uYtu

a ayR1fld1t0 ontr?tnt]vfi1o 4

d 9 rrq o u9 I ufl n01fl n1:lfl u:?u:?ur0{0 {?!0 tnfl :?ndouR?ludriu:0r10'r[[uud0u01!a{:fi d

r7oryn unrrJ:rl.lnilar1o{o lnol#}J:un:tofi6rirrBrgrJ nrrl.irniu nt:lfluoflont:irn:iEftt t a' -!10unu roonl u3floun{u

noud r Hanr:irn:ryrirTolam-r}iro{dnoxrrxxdoxorrr

noud z Ho nr:irn :rv tinl:i riru i u n uoo g {ouu 1u nr: 13 r r: ao ruf; nu'rt;

d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut

fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5. 4. {i 4 t I edoluf,n!1 f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul :youdnu1fuilrJ5 fluunnlrjlflfl tJ:sdun1:Bi

tunl:u0un{1u un s 1u 1n1o.r d01u dnu 1

Page 2: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

49

^ Jyflanr:?lnrlsfilo a

i - re inroau l Hnfl 1: ,)rnt'l3l.t.rio am1 tl lxo{FtooltttulldollftltJ

fl1rr.r 4 diu?urla;rir9oun;torqi3rouIurudouo'uJ o'-urunmrurng :sd!nr0i1unrilfrd6{ru4

ltavlu lalotdo 1u flnu 1

n:333:1Un 1:

01u?u 50uds

l. rvlf,

1'1U

fi fu.1

t02

231

30.60

69.40

:?IJ JJJ 100.00

z. rJ:c arnr:oilunr:rJ g'u6rru

rl:saunr:nirlou

il:vcrnr:oilrn

100

233

30.00

70.00

5 ?tJ 333 100.00

43. tJ ln1o.rdoluflRu]

lUlnlnn

lUlnnAt't

lUrA r fu

77

104

152

23.10

3t.zo

45.70

:?IJ 333 100.00

i r n n r :'r'r 4 fifl n {'i1 #n o I uu I a o u o r I ri a u lu q ril uuran tn'.r (iooav ol.lO)

lnuirl:vaunr:oilunr::Jnu5.:ruurn (g0uas zo.ool drilfruGrruoqlluanruf,nurrumlnd

(iosas +s.zo)

Page 3: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

50

sroud z nanr:irn:rsrinr:fi riruialtorn:dooulunr:uirr:enrufinur frrrinla e I

dlUntlUtlA?tUYtfl 1:flnU1 :vOUflnUl$UYt!:

,4,;,eorrt{ 5 fl1[aau f,?ulu u.ulju tJl9rt! 1u r[0v: rou n1:! d?u: ?rJ10{n; rl fl0u [un]tut11'lt< vs. v t ) 4 r < u

d01uflnu1 d'tnndlun{1ur1er1rufl n1:flnu1ur&orJflnurnumqr tnu:?rl

n:333n1:1Jt1{ 1:.1'luclo1ufl fl !1 t S.D. : s filr

9a1. AtUfl 1:U:'H',l:.:',lU?Xln',l:

z. rYrunr:uinr: {ru.:x :rri19a

3. nlunlru:1{1:{luqnnne a &lll,

4. fl1unl: :t4',l: {',tUYll t1J

0.63

0.62

0.58

0.57

u1fl

tJ1n

u'1fl

utn

4.43

4.21

3.50

3.70

:?U 3.96 0.32 lJ1n

nrnnltlr 5 rrdo.:'ir nrrfi .i?uiattx o{nl {dou1untru3fi r: eoruf, ns r dln-nt;

tiruh{ruurny{-ufinr:f,nuril:cnrfinurf,umq3 1nu:ruo{lu:vniuurn ( x :3.96) N40fi0r:olldfrrseAd'.irflu:rudru nu'jr o{lu:;niu!rn?lndtu BrGoIrirrn6urrnlrn'hJnrr?ou.l oYuduu:n

n, t, - ,'[drrri drunr:uinr:rruirrnr: (x :4.43)dtuflr:tl;fi1:ttu.:u :slrE (x = 4.21)Jh, -6'runrr1lrr lr{1uYr? trl (x -3.70)

Page 4: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

5l

t99r'rr1{ 6 n1rQn0 d?u[1J u{[lJ1r! lnr!'lu udu tsoun 1r!d?u: ?r,1o rn! 4alou tun'r:u:141:

12 4 , I qdo]uflflu't d{nndlun{lur19t1Iuflnttflnu1 :souflnulnuflq: olunl:u1141:{'lu?x1fl'l:

n:3339A91U n 15 U5 fi 1:.11U ?Ytfl 1:

i s.D. :vdu

l. nltnlflun!19t:n1un1rflnu110.:doluflRU'r492. n 1:11fl U1fi A n fln: dOlU flnU 19r',t!n ?1tl n 0{ n 1l

1O{Unt:UUrlAvl!nU

3. nr:0-nri'r:vuu:J:vduqornrnnruluaoruf, nur9114. n1tdtl{lft:0tJ1uYl1{?tln1:flu11u?u{1un1{ "l

5. n1:ulTflnlutudolufln!'tI a d .9 'ra6. fl15ttutuu'tf,1un'l:f,fiulttnuo'1Y71 tfitln4[:uu

z. nr:l{fl orvrnlulatuasrnio,rirunr:rSuuigir.r "l- ;l ,8. flt:0au5tu1fl1flYl[00n0fl1:r:uu50u1'1[11u'tudu

:s949. nlt d'rld:!n0nr:llY{flu'lFr[:uu nln n1u

^-" L - , d'10. nlt ?iu Iuaur: uuoul {[Iu:suu

4.51 0.59 !1nrqn

:.t1flTfln4.63

4.48

4.65

4,64

4.29

4.39

4.10

4.36

4.23

0.59

0.61

0.60

0.58

1.01

0.84

t.34

0.92

t.02

utnj

l.l"tflltd0

u'lflYtd9

!1n

!1n

tJ 1fl

111fl

111n

t?lJ 4.43 0.63 uln

0rnn 1:r.r 6 ltfl o{'jr nt:iriau j :rLr o{n; {doulun15r3v r: ao rufi ns r d{n-nCi a t

drrinrrunnyr-ufrnr:Finur :vorrflnut6'um13 drunr:tirr:rruilrnr: Iou:ruo{'[u:gd'u!rn.--zl-ct,,!r,'E.iA(X=4.43)[U01ln1tBl][tJU:1Ul0 1111']'l d?u tfi[U0q tUtEnul,ln cU.i[:U{d191Ufl1[AAUn'ln

lrnhjnrrlou : dud'uu:n kiud nr:a$xrnSoriruyrr.:irrnr:nfurrj':urrusirr I tx = +.os)

n15fi[ f,n1uludo1uffnur(t:4.64)rlavn]tliorurflf,nqn:dorufinutatun?1!dorrnl:

10{ufll:UuunsTllxu ( X - 4.63)

10

Page 5: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

5?

t9q-911r'r'r 7 fl1raau d?uru u'! [1ru ! lnt! 1u ttastvn n 1:!al?u: ?1110 'lflg {d0u tunl:tl:fi'l:

d .i 4 | 1 v aedn ludnu l dinn 6llu n tlu[191l{ur nl:fl nu'llJ:vn!fl nu ]numu: 6lun'll u t lt.l lu

{lJ:s!101

n:33310 drunr:riur:lru.:u :vrtrol

; S.D. :gNU

l. n1:riluunulourudrunr:13ur:ru :cur0l

1o.rdo1uf,nu1

2. nr: o-nrirunurrnco-nn-{'r! :curorrJ:vrirfl

l. nr:1{':rrJ:sr'r*r"'r,,^uu"'udrirnunl{

4. n1:n:?ndounl:ld{uil:s!1ruxo.1d0ruf,n!1

s. nr:il:srfiunnnrrdrlfiu{ru{u rs!1ol

6. nr:tru'nufl anr:1{.:lnl:vlrorto.:doruf,nur

7. nr: o-nrir:vuruinri: ruiu-: rudruto renruf,nut-:8. nr:er:?0dourirytsnr:ir-dru ro{coruf,nsr

-.1 -q s v i a a9. n1:oncronntl{?elquacnlR0lc nluludfrluflnu'l.1.,' u e 410. n1:n:'tn d0unt:0nry0tnt 1{?dfllraualn cvr

10{do1uf,nu1

4.42

4.48

4.28

4.M

4.48

4.03

4.16

3.77

4.12

0.57

0.59

0.57

0.70

0.64

1.07

0.86

1.44

0.99

uln

111fl

lJ1fl

!1n

ltlR

l,1n

!1n

lJ1fl

!1n

3.97 1.07 u1fl

:x1l 4.21 0.62 u lir

nrfl n15r'r 7 rrdn vi1 nr:iri:u ja!rsln; {aoulunr:rLinr:aorufi nur fi.r6'ol; a t

tirrin.:rurtnvlufrnr:dnu r:l: solfinu r6'uvrq3 drun r:u3nr:.:ru {u 5s!r0r lno:rlo{lu: c nix u r n ( x : +.z t ) rd o n' o r : sn rfl u : r o do n u'j r o { 1 u : r nir rL r n rl n rlo d.: 6 u.: n rrl ri r rq i s

rrnrrn'hinrriou 3 rirn-ru:n 'lduri n r: o-nrirrrHu uac 6'a#{{u il: s ru rsrrJ: y o"ril t x: +.+s)

nr: :s rfi u fl an r:rirru'u nu lr :J :yu ru ( x = 4.48) uasnlrnr?0dor nr:1d'ruil: srror

1o{eorudnsr <x= q.aa)

Page 6: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

53

,i,i9t't:lrt 8 fll[flnu d?uluu{[uulJln:!'tu lrnv:vn1lfl]tu6l']u: ?1J10{fl! rldou tunllu:111:

la a edo1uf,nul d{nodlun{rurll9r1rumn1:flflu'l115uo!flnulnumrJ: n1ufl1:u:111:.1'luqflflo

n:333drunr:ri ur:.:rurlnna

x s.D. t3fi"'u

I . n'r:1lr vluufl?1!n0{fl15 flgrlarqflaln:

luanrufnrr

2. n'r:?1.:rlfluo-n:1fi]a-{1o{n;unslna1n5

lucorufinur; -. ,3. n1:[6luolfialn: rl.tu1vdlJfl unlrltrl.r{{1u

. vi4. n'l: n'lfiuonlt cfiu tYtl0{nulo.:luanrufinu t-;5. n 1:1101: ol1Yt1{ ?uud1fi: x l nna T n: g Yt1fl't1u Hn

tudolufln! 1

6. nr:fr-sr:ol1n?r!6fl ?rrJxoulrrin:unsqnatn:

luaorudnsr-i,

fl 1:1t01:0l1rnu?nun1t t0uulu,t otfi;tlnvqfra1n:

lucoruflnurt a 19 4 ,/ ,

fl1r d.r[d:rJ tfin; [[nyIn a 1n: tJ n ? ]ufl't't11u 1

luirr*r,ri" d, "ntt tol.f 'l ?dnn'l:110 tr1Ju dlfi:lJn; tragqn d 1n:

luaoruflnur

n r:rJ : rrn^un r:il fr uGna I ru tol n guasqna 1n:

luaoruf,nur

u'1fl

3.32 0.75 runnr.r

3.67 0.97

runnr.:

ru na r.:

lJ1n

3.47

3.39

3.7s

0.90

0.88

0.8 7

3.50 0.67

3.52 t.O2

7

8

9

!1n

3.56 0.91 u'1fl

3.36 0.64 runar.r

3.45 0.59 runor.r

t0

t'ru 3.50 0.s8 !Tn

!lfl nr:'r.: 8 ud6{'ir nr:fi dru i:lr o.:ni {fl oulun r:riil r:anruf, ns r d{n-nI A < | I q a,druhrrunrnnufrnr:Finsr :soufinurfiuvrqS drunr:l3vr:rrurlnnn lnu:uro{lulvniu!ln

,:: __-. :l ^ d , , ,q . , - A 4( x = 3.50) [lJ0 n1:Al][1]tJt',tUlIO y{U?109IlJ:yt{U lUnn',l{lras:sdtlrnryttriil B.:i5u{

rirrs6uorn!rn'lililrdou 3 iirniuu:n 'lduri nr:drnunnr:sr#rdto.rnuro{lueorudnsr

10

u'1fl

Page 7: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

54

,.i,it,gl-tt-trt 9 Rlrqau fl?uluu.lruulJ10r:!'ruua&:v61ln1:rJd?ur?rJ10':nJ4dou tun1rur11'r:

j i a t 4 q 4e a ilr'dn1ufin!t d{flnd1un{lurt,9rvruTn Itdflu'tu:vo!fln! lnurq: fl'lun DUt l.t'l:.t tuvt't tlj

t a d,h,Fl'ru fl"t: u:l.t'l:.r'tu Yt'l t1l

x s.D. :vn'u

l. nr:ri1fi unidun-sri r{hrurotoraoruf,nvr

2. nr:,ir'orirununaqmdto.:aorufnur

3. nt:dtt141fl0lvn::lnr:doruflnur

4. nr:rioru-r:vuurloryauavar:aulylflro.r

corufinsr

5. nr::l:vrrdrn-u#firn::urloseorudnsr

6. nr: :yarulrunirnirurrunrouon

z. nr:frorirIn:rnr:uinr:luruludrurir.: t- r;A e a8. n r:0qYrlYt!llruu?dq n?Rolcyr lnul{o.:n

nr:dnuro, 's a9. nttnnuld'tdnfll:tl.trlnun[:uu

10. n1rf,oli151u{1urJ:cdrilro{aorudnur

4.09

3.70

3.60

3.95

3.65

3.45

3.64

3.72

3.60

3.57

0.81

0.87

0.88

u'ln

lllfl

lJ1fl

!1n

!tn!1n

0.85

0.67

0.81

l.l0

uln

u'ln

ru na r.t

uln

0.93

0.72

0.70

5'tlJ 3.70 0.57 !1n

ninnr:r'r 9 uaovir or:i rirui utosn: fiaoulunlru3 ?nrdoruenur f,.:n-aritfnlru4 A I t 4 u a, ^ &h,<rln u n'r:flnul :snxflnu'lnuflq: nlunr:utfilr.l luyl? ttj tnu:1xoq tu:snuljlft ( x - 3.70)

ul- dt e - Aru-o-nrt0lrrilu5rorionu'jrarulnqjoqjlu:vniuurn6orrnGu{enuritra6urrnlrn'1ilrir9 o s h, ' . ae @ J I a -u0u 3 dlnu[[:n lntln fl1:n]fiun?duylflu ulll.tlJ1ul ot d0lufinu 1 ( x = 4.09) fll:flflu1

tr4et,cuurl0ualrnsfl'l:dulyrfl,t 0'tdfi'luflnu1 ( x - 3.95) uatnl:0n?ilyts[1]uuidfl nlfi0llii; e sYt[fl0'],rlo.:nunl:fln!1 ( x: 3.72)

(i=r.zs) n1: :vrfiunxrxelornr:n;uorqnaln:lufloluf,n! r ( x = 3.67) uovnr: rirrai rb?ngunrrlnarn:inerutirrnr?rluilriu ( x : r.sol

10n:333

Page 8: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

55

fl oilfi 3 anr:irn:rv#uJ3uurfi uunr:ieiaui'lutorng{aoulunr:rinr:la 4 e

doluAR!r d.:riodruhsrur,uflfiufinr:finu ril:voxfin!r,0"'umU; r"ruunnurrg :sernt:ni

lunr:rJfrlGlruuarrurnxo{d01 finu1

fl rrr.i l0 nnnr:rrBuurfi uunr:irtrui,ttrto.rng{aoulunr:uimr:dnruf,nur f,.rriotiru-n'rluIA

rrnfi uff nr:f, nu rrJ:vnlfnulr"'uvrrli r'ruunnrlrnf,

rufl

nr:13rr:lrucoruflnur YIU

(n=102)

fifui

(n:231)

t P

x S.D i S.D.

I - n r: r G r.r r:.: ru iryr n t:2. nr:uitr:rruu :surnr

3. n1:r? l:.r1uqnna- ih,

4. nl:u:lr 1:{ lUYt? tll

4.46

4.28

3.46

3.79

0.66

0.63

0.62

0.58

0.70

1.28

-0.76

1.89

0.54

0.57

0.49

0.55

4.41

4.19

3.51

3.66

0.48

0.20

0.45

0.06

:1U 4.00 0.27 3.94 0.34 t.M 0.15

* u-o ti r nlnr yr r r afi n'fi : y n-r .os

trAuvslnn1:1.: 10 [[dn.:?1 n'l:lJd?u5?!'ti0{n; 4dou tunT:urfi ]: darufl nul d{n6

ji 4 td'lun{'lu[10ty{uytn'l:f,flul1Jty0lJflflurnumu:01[[unnluly{fl tnut?tJuann1{flu0u].t lulJ

-^ i - dt I t I t auudlnExnl{dnn ruofl01:Br1r1Ju:lunt y{u?'l 61ufl15u:111:flu?11n1:6lun'DU:11'rt

{lu{r :urtr0l drunr:ri n r:.:ruqnna uardrunr:uirr:uun-a'lil unnrir.rriuotjr,r'hjiu-u

drria.rvrr.:a66

Page 9: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

56

I I 4 vu. v9nt l.t I L{nfl l:lllt uurYrulJnl:1.ld1u: ?uloln; qld0u tun'l:u:141: d01uflflul dinndlufl ilu

,l; t ?alrnfl-ufi fl r:AnulrJ:vnlf, nu r6'uvrq3 n"ruunnrrr.i:vdunr:oilunr:rJ6uT lru

rJ:caunr: B11u nr: rJfr ri6lru

adfl 1: U : 11',1:':',lU dO',lU fl n! 1

u00

(n:100)

u1n

(n=233)

p

t s.D. x s.D.

l. n1:1l3firr.r1uilrn1:

2. n1:u3r.r1r{'ru{urJrs!rsl

3. n1: 3fi1:{luqnna- ir,

4. fl',t 5 U 511 1t {',tU Yr ? tll

4.48

4.27

3.47

3.78

0.53

0.56

0.49

0.54

4.41

4.19

3.51

3.66

0.67

0.64

0.62

0.58

0.93

1.06

-.064

1.76

0.35

0.29

0.52

0.08

:?TJ 4.00 0.25 3.94 0.35 1.44 0.15

n'rfl en:'r': I I [rd6{'ir nr:fi riauiarLto{n: rldoulunr:uir r: aoruf, nu r frrn-nlAattdddlUn{1U[ln UYrn1:flnU1 :COrJflnUlnUTq: i',luunn',rUlJ:vdUnl:Ol tUn1: 01J9r'1',1U

--:iL-ctyteln u: ?uugrflsr1{nu0u1{ [lJU uud]niuvl'1.tflo9r n101,{0lt lrtlu:'lufilu y{u?'l rilun,llu:l.t'l:

a L a I a .:hI{lU?nln1: n 1Un1:U I t41t.tlU.t1llJt3 U10l f,',l ntt :141tt',tUInnA OlUn',l:Xtl.t',15.:',1l.rfl ? tlj

[[nnnl {nu0u1{ trJtJuud'lnfljvt'l tdogr

t

.riudrrYol m r r ai n'fi : c o"ri .os

Page 10: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

51

er-n'r{r 12 r{6nr:u-Eulrrfiurnr:fi riruiarLtorn: daoulunr:rLi ur:aoruf,nur d'.rrinriru-n.rrul; a s

ltny{ um n l : fl nu 1u 5 s o ufl n! 1 nu 7l q : i'llrufl nlllt u1n fl o Ilfl nu l

fl1:lJ:}t 1: 't 1U dOlUf,n! 1 SS df MS F P

1. fl 1:1J t l.t 1: { lU ? r]n lt: g ?t?1.:flau

nlulunri!

1.91

131.31

2

330

0.95

0.40

2.40 0.09

t'ltJ 133.22 332

2. n1:u: 1:.11U{

:s14'r'l{flau

nrulunii!

u:v!101

8.26

l19.61

2

330

4.13

0.l6

I1.39 0.00*+

,?lJ 127.87 332

4.47

I t0.l6

2

330

2.24

0.33

6.70 0.00*t

: ?TJ t14.64 332

a JIl '4. n1: :11'l: nluYl? ttj

rvn'jr{adu

nrolundil

4.51

105.33

2

330

2.26

0.32

7.07 0.00**

:'tlJ 109.85 332

R111: ?lJ

5slt?1{ na!

nrulilnri!

1.40

34.17

2

330

0.70

0.10

6.77 0.00,r*

i?}J 3s.57 332

* * u-udrdtur r r efier^fi : cniu .o t

3. n1:x3 r:.rluqnna

:efi21{nqtJ

nrolun{r

Page 11: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

58

!lnerr:'r'r 12 udn gi1 nr:ideui rlto{n t daou1unr:ui r:ao ruf, nu r d{n-oZA I t a v a <dr n lrulrfl lr-uytn'l:f,n!'l : !oudnu ]nufl U: o'luunfl lx.lJutadolufl nul tnu: ?llltnnfi linu

--i - i - dt e I eotirrfiriudrn"'rgurra66fi:snlu .01 [rJ=o

-n r:olrlilu:rudlu flu?r drunr: ;fir:{lu'tl.t tc!]019 a &t r

nrun1:ut1,11:.:1uunno unv61un'ltLl:fi1:I1u1l? ttJ rrnn911{nuou1{lJuudlnqm'l{don;-Ttsnu .01 rY?u6'lun15u:lt'l:{1u?T1nt:tlnnnl{nu0u1{ tu!uudlnn mlldo0t

srln{ 13 Hanrll iuurfiuxrirrq6u:ruri nr:iriruielto.:nrdaoulunr:u3 trflo1uf,nu1

drn-nriru-n.:rurtndufinr:f,nurrl:vouf,nurfruvrrli dtuunntrtutofloruf,nut lnu:rru

1U10tAn 1U1nnd1'1 nuinlilrd1U1A10{flO1UflnU1 t

4.02 4.01 3.89

1U1orAfl

1U1oflA1.t

lurolnr$

4.02

4.01

3.89

0.00 0. 131

0.12x

--i* uuf,1fi6uYl1{f,fl nfl :vau .05

rlfl nr: r.r 13 [(do{'ir nr: fi drui :ruto{n: rldoil1ufl r:uirr:aorudnsr fr{fineA 4 , a o a +rllun{lurxn uYlnttflnul tu0uflnuliulrqt f1[[unnMu1nfloluflflu1[nu:?lJ 11lJ?1

Addn'luflnu'r.uu'lorannl rflnl dfllr'ntu1o I nt rYoludflu nrxr lnfl n 1iflltdf]1uflflu 1. u]n tHflJ

- ^^i s e o d "

"rlflnn1{nu0ulirljuudlfifuYl']rrYo9rlrtunu .05 t6ufi;4d0u tud0]uflfru1tu19[af][!ng

< d' ' 4 | 4 Odn ]uflflu lflu'lonat I ud?lr:'l! tunl: :t4'r5do't fln!"t u]fln?]d0'l1rdflult ul0 tt4ilr

Page 12: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

59

enrrrr l4 Hnnr:r iuurfiuuriln6tr: ru{ nr:firiruiautorn3{aoulunr:rirr:dnruf;nur

f,.:rindrrin.:ru rtg'dufi n r: f,nu rrJ: couf,nu rt'uvtqi rirttu nerrrtu rn doludn! lr unr:r3rr:'tru{ 5vu1ol

1U1nrAfl41U1n10.:rYOtUflnU',l x

4.42 4.0s

1,UlntAn

1U 1n nA 1{

lU lO lfiiu

4.25

4.42

4.05

-0.16 0.19r

0.36r,

* uudlftfl m1{d09l14: gfill -05

n1fl n1: 1.i 14 rrdn {'i1 nr:i riau ie!ro rng {aou1u nr: ui fl r: coru fl nu r

dl n-n ri r rin l r u nr n du fi n r : f, n u r il : s o u f, n s r r-u n q3 rir uu n n r rr r u r n a n r u fr n s.l

drunr:l3rr:.:ruw :surtu vrrjr aoruf;nurturorf,nniuaoruf,nurturnlrqj aoruf,nur

turnnnrrrirdnruf,nurturolnqj unnsir6'uotirrfiriudr6'ryvrr.ra6nfi:vri'u.os lnun;{aou

lucoruf,nsrrurnrf, n uavcoruf,nurrulonarr fi eieui'rllunr:u3rr:lrurr :slrol

! rnn'irao ru fi ns rturnlnqj

en:t.r ls nonr:uJiuurfiuurirn6u:ruq'nr:firiauiaurLo.rng(aoulunr:rirr:aoruf,nurli

d{ nn d lu n {1u [1n u fl n]5 flflu lrJ: g0 uflnu r! u Ylq: tluunnt!1u1ndo1uflnu1,a61Ufl1rU: 1:.t',lUqflflA

lU',lOrdn rurnflar{ turnluqjA11J1610tdOtUflnU1 t

3.5 6 3.33 3.5 8

1U10rAfl

tu1nnn1.1

ruralnql

3.56

3.33

3.58

0.23* -0.01

-0.25*

* riudrritymr.: a6o^fi : y6'r .os

tu10nnt.l turnlnqj

4.25

Page 13: z u t; - RBRU · d{nn fl 1ufl 't llJn 911ruyrnltfl n! 1 :yo!dn! l0uytut fl oild 3 fl n n i 5 irn : rc ?friliuurfi uu nr: fi riru i r! I o{nr rld ou lu nrru?H r5 doluf,n!1 . 4. f,{nndlun{lurlnytuyln1tf,nul

60

1U10nd1n

nrn{ 16 ,{onr:nJiuurfiurlrirrniu:ru{ nr:idruirutorn;{aoulunr::Liur:aoruf;nur

#r rin d r rin r r u rt n nru fi n r : fi n u r rl : c o rr f, n u r,0"'u vr rli dr u u n n r u t u r o a o r u fi n u r9 a Jr r

0'lufl 1:u:141:t'luvl? tlJ

xulnxo{do1uf,nu1uuln[an l,U',rnno1.: 1ulnlilq'

i3.78 3.82 3.57

1U1ntAfl

t ulnnal{

3.78

3.82

3.57

-0.04 0.20t

0.25t

d1* uu n iu Yt't't 46fifi:sdr.os

0 1fl n 1: r { t o ua n l'ir n r : i ri ru j : rL t o.r n ; {eo u lu n r : ui il r : a o r u f, n s r dr n-n

l; I tdruhr rurtnfiufi nr:f, nu ril:snlfrnur6'uvrq3 o'ruunnrlrurntoleoruflnur drunr:- &ur I a d auirr:'rrunialil fl 'i1 doruiinurrurnrfi nriuanrufinurrurnlrai dorudnulluronar.:

a A o o- |

riu ao ru fl n u rt u ro ln oj un nei r.r riu o d r.rfi riu d rflq m l{ d o nfi : s iu .os l n u n g {a o u

lueorufinurturardn unvanruflnulrlu'lnnnr{ iriruirrlunr:u3il1r.:1uyl-?'hJ !rnn.i1

d01 flnul1uln l 0J

t9 luv01nn1:1rt 15 dn{'tl n r:rJdzu: 2tJ10{n! 4dou tu n1:u ttJ 1t6lo1ufl n! 1 d{fl n

4i 4 t a ed1Ufl.! lUrlnlrUYtn1: f,nU 1 :sO!flnU1nU14q: r1[rUnnlU't U16dftlUflnUl nlUn]:!tt4',l:

14dva4.:lU

U nn O 11 U ? 1 dOlU fl nU 11U lAlA fl n U dOlU f, fl U 11U lAna 1 I dO',lU fl nU 11U',lnfl A 1.:

--;y.1n1rdnluf,fl}r11u10 tl.ttu rrofln 1inuofl1{lruudlfltuYt1.:dfl0tt4:v6u .05 tnun:Hdou tudoluf,n}l1d4a

1U]nrnfl [rnydoluflnu'r1u'ln t iliufl?u:? lunl:u:r.r1:l'lu1flfr0!1nn?1d01uf,nu1

turnlvqj