Download pdf - Κριτική στην Ομοιοπαθητική

pi

le:////D|/U...ITES/ /oodegr/www.oodegr.com/oode/asynithista/enallakt/kritiki_omoiop1.htm[5/1/2011 10:30:32 pi]

,

: http://www.alopsis.gr/alopsis/omiopa13.htm

" a priori" . . , , , . , , . , , , : " " , , 1990. 2 , ( ) , . , , (bold) .

: ... . "", 20 ... ... "" . , , . : " ", . , , "" " " "" . . ,

pi


- , . " " . , , , " " . , "" , : " . ". , , , . , "" "" ( ) .

( XVI-XVII): , , , . , , , ... " " , - , .

' ... , " ", . ' (!!!) " " (!!!)

: 3: , ... " ()" . , , "". "" ;...

5-6: , ... , , , . , . 18 19, ,

pi


. , , Samuel Hahnemann, - - . ,, . , , : . ( ), : , . , , , , . . . , , ( follow up ) ( ) . , , , , . , . , , ( editors) . ( ;), , . 107 British Medical Journal1991; 302:316-23. , . : At the moment the evidence of clinical trials ispositive but not sufcient to draw denite conclusions because most trials are of lowmethodological quality and because of the unknown role of publication bias" (

pi


). , BMJ , Maastricht . ...

...

7: ... "" ... . , , . , " " , , " !!!".

8: , . ' , : , ... , , : "" . . . , .

15: [ ] : ; ; ; , ;... 16: , ' , ' , ... 18: , , 19: . . , . 23: : , ,

pi


24: Ostrander Prentice Hall, 1970 [ ]: , , 30.000 98%. - , ( ) - . . , , !!! !!!

( 2 . ):

26: 1. -. 2. -. 3. ( , , ) 29, 44-45: , RamanaMaharishi Ramakrishna , . 8. [ ;] , , , , , , , ( ). ;;;

( 4 . ):

80-84: Kent , " ". . ) , , , ... ) ,

pi


) , ' , ... , ... , , . , . ... . , , . ... Kirlian , . . Kirlian ... : "" ( "vis vitalis" ) , , . ' (!!). " " , , " " (!!!). Kirlian ( ) (!!). " " " " Kent " (!!!) [ ;;] "... , . , , " "; (!!).

, . , , , - h2-. , . , h2

pi


( IL-4 5). ( IgE), . , -, Th1- , ( IL 2 -), . , , IgE, , IL 4, 13 IFN-, . : ) ( , D2-PGD2, , TNF- C4-LTC4),) IL 5, 3, GM-CSF, RANTES, MCR-3 -1 -, ) IL 3,MCP-3 MCAF. , , , ( VCAM-1) . IgE . , ( ) . Reilly ( ) Lancet 1994,344, 1601-06. Reilly ( ) : ) ( ) ) , , ( ) , , ' ., Reilly . Reilly : A difference in visual analogue score (of overall symptom) in favour ofhomeopathic immunotherapy appeared within one week of starting treatment and persisted forup to 8 weeks (p=0.003). There were similar trends in respiratory function and bronchialreactivity tests. , p=0,003 : , p ( ;). .. : IgE antibodytitles tended to increase throughout the study with a greater but not statistically signicant risein the homeopathy group. , : IgE . Lancet (!!) -- ...

pi


... ( ) , , (.. J Immunol 1992 ;149:1432. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1991; 88:637. Annu Rev Immunol 1992; 10:411. Blood 1989;73:1504. J Exp Me d 1990; 172:1577. J Immunol 1993; 151:2390 Gastroenterology 1997;112:1307 -1997; 112:193).

( 5 . ):

95-96. 1. 4. , . , ,

3. ... 5. , ... [ (!) ] " " "" , "" , " " , , , , , , , , ,, , , , , " " . " "; , " " ; , , ; ; " " ; , , " "(!!!).

pi


( 6 . ):

99-102, 104-107, 108. , , ... : 1) (.. ) . 2) ' ... "' " . ' , ? , . " " , , , , . ..

... , ; ... , , ... o , , , . : Similia similibuscurentur, S. Hahnemann " To ". , ... ( , ) ""... ", "...Samuel Hahnemann: ... , ... ... Samuel ""...

6. ...3. ' : , "' " 6. Hahnemann ( ), - provings-

pi


... , , : ( ;) "' " () () ( ) ?(!!!) ? (!!). , , , ( ), . . , , , . ; " " ( , , ) , . ' . "- " , , . , " " , , ... (!!!!) ? , (!!) " " ( , !) , " provings'', . " provings" , , ...

( 7 . ):

111-114: , , , , ( ) . ' Hahnemann , . Hahnemann , . , . , , " ", , , ,

pi


, ' ' ...

, , . Avogadro 24x , 12 c. 12c [ 1/10 1/100, "" "", " x " "c", )]. , 24 x 12c, . ? , , . 100.000c 100.000c 1/1000, 100.000 , ...

, . ' . , . , ' . "" . " " , , ... " " , , - -, .

: , Avogadro . , ' . , , ... , (;) ; (): . , , . , ( ), , "" .

pi


. , - , 2 (.. ( ) , 2 , .

( 9 . ):

138-9, 140-41, 144-5, 147. Hahnemann . , . ( ' ). - , . Hahnemann "" ,, ... , ... ' . - ( ;)- " , ' ". "" (!!) : , ... Hahnemann , , - . ... ( ""). , , ... Hahnemann , ' ... -, . , . , , , , . ' . ' , , , ...

pi


"" " " , , , ,, , , " " "" , , " " ... " " ... (!) ;... ...:" , . , 20 , . , Medorrhinum, . , , . ' , ,"", , . ' : " ;". Medorrhinum "... : . ; ( vo , ) "" : " DNA, , "... "" , . , () , " " (;;), !!! ( !), , " "(!!) ( ;;;). , ( ) ( !!), . , , ...

pi


( 11 . ):

169, 172: , ' , nosode [ ] , [ ]... nosodes (Medorrhinum), ( Syphilinum), ( Tuberculinum), ( Inuenzinum), (Hydropbobinum) ... , ... " " , , ( ;) " " " , - "!!! , ,

253, 254, 255: ... , , .... ... , ' .. . ... ( ): , , , , Gravis, , .., , , ... " " ( ) , , , , " " : 225, 228: Materia Medica. () () , . ..., , ... "" , -, (!!). , , ;

pi


; 2 , , , , , 1 . 281-282: , . ( , , , ...) ... (!!!)

. ... . , 1992.

97: ( ): , . , , , ... , , , , , . , , : , , , . . : , , . , , . , , . : . 1953. 174-5: " , , , , . ' , - - , "". ... , , , ' , . , . [ ] , , . , , . " ". , , ,, , , , "...

pi


, " ? , " . ( )... , ...

2 : , , . , , , 123-138, Lycopodium ( . Hahnemann). : Lycopodium . ... Lyc. , , ... Lycopodium . , ... , . , ... , , ... , . To Lyc. . ' , , ... , , , , ... , , . , ... ' , , , ... Lyc. . , , , , . Lyc. . ' , Lyc. . Lyc. ... Lyc. , . . , . ... ... "" , " Hahnemann", (!!!) . o

pi


...

. . .

3 : 53: , , ' ' . , . Krishna Menon, , 85: , , ... 86: ' '. . : , ... . , ... , ... , ... , ... "", : ... 97: . . , , , "" , . , ... ' "" () ... 101-103: ' , , , ... , ' , , , , , , , , . , ... , , "" , ' ... 104-105: " " ,, ... , " ", ... - - ,

pi


. ; !!!

, , , "". , - , , . , - , , .

: 10-8-2007.

: 10-8-2007.

Local Disk