7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
1/22
INTERNATIONAL TAX DEVELOPMENTS
- GLOBAL & REGIONAL- INDIA
IFA Conference - Mauritius
10th & 11th May 2012
CA P.V.S.S.Prasad
Hyderabad, India
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
2/22
Page 2
AGENDA
FINANCE BILL 2012INTERNATIONAL TAX PROPOSALS
ROYALTIES
WITHHOLDING TAXES
TAX RESIDENCY CERTIFICATE (TRC)
ADVANCE PRICING AGREEMENT (APA)
GENERAL ANTI AVOIDANCE RULE (GAAR)
INDIAMAURITIUS TAX TREATY (DTAA)
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
3/22
Page 3
ROYALTY S.9(1)(vi) of IT Act 1961.
Explanation 2 to clause (vi) of sub-section (1) of section 9 : Royal ty"means consideration (including any lump sum consideration but excluding any consideration
which would be the income of the recipient chargeable under the head "Capital gains") for
(i) The transfer of all or any rights (including the granting of a license) in respect of a patent, invention,model, design, secret formula or process or trade mark or similar property;
(ii) The imparting of any information concerning the working of or the use of, a patent, invention, model,
design, secret formula or process or trade mark or similar property;(iii) The use of any patent, invention, model, design, secret formula or process or trade mark or similar
property;
(iv) The imparting of any information concerning technical, industrial, commercial or
scientific knowledge, experience or skill;
(iva)the use or right to use any industrial, commercial or scientific equipment but not including the
amounts referred to in section 44BB;(v) The transfer of all or any rights (including the granting of a license) in respect of any copyright, literary,artistic or scientific work including films or video tapes for use in connection with television or tapes for usein connection with radio broadcasting, but not including consideration for the sale, distribution or exhibitionof cinematographic films; or
(vi) The rendering of any services in connection with the activities referred to in sub-clauses (i) to (v);
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
4/22
Page 4
ROYALTY Finance Bill 2012
Amendments in Finance Bill 2012: (retro.) 01/06/1976
Explanation 4.Consideration for transfer of all or any right for use or right to use a
computer software, (including grant of a licence) irrespective of medium of transfer,
constitutes royalty u/s 9 (1) (vi)
Case laws neutralised: DIT Vs. Ericson A.B., New Delhi, (2011) 16 taxmann.com 371 (Delhi),
Motorola inc (SB) 95 ITD 269
Explanation 5. Royalty u/s 9(1)(vi) includes consideration in respect of any right,
property or information, whether or not its possession or control with the taxpayer, it is
used directly by the taxpayer, or its location is in India.
Case law neutralised: DIT Vs. Ericson A.B., New Delhi, (2011) 16 taxmann.com 371 (Delhi)
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
5/22
Page 5
ROYALTY Finance Bill 2012
Explanation 6.Term process u/s 9(1)(Vi) includes transmission by satellite
(including up-linking, amplification, conversion for downlinking of any
signal), cable, optic fibre or by any other similar technology, whether or not
such process is a secret.
Case law neutralised:Asia Satellite Telecommunication Co. Ltd. 332 ITR 340
(Del)
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
6/22
Page 6
ROYALTY OECD MCC
Paras 1217 of the MCC on Art.12 provides guidance as to what is
royalty/ business profitssoftware payments.
Amndt. makes sale of copyrighted article resulting in royalty under
domestic law (Expln-4).
Payment for information/ databases is royalty- domestic law
Amndt.(Expln.5)
Transmission by satellite is a process whether or not a
secretdomestic lawAmndt. (Expln.6)- whether or not in
the possession / control of payer (Expln.5)royalty.
- para 9.1 of Art.12 of MCC holds otherwise.
Most software payments/telecom services come within tax net unless protected
by treaty or source rule exclusion u/s 9(1)(vi)(b)/(c) of domestic law
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
7/22
Page 7
Sec.195 Withholding Taxes
Explanation 2 to Sec.195 (1)
Obligation to deduct tax u/s 195((1) applicable to all persons, whether resident or nonresident,
whether or not the nonresident has a residence, place of business or business connection in India: or
any other presence in any manner whatsoever.
Applicable retrospectively from April 1, 1962:
Case law neutralised: Vodafone International Holdings BV Vs UOI 341 ITR 1 (SC)
payments from nonresident to another nonresident covered without exceptions
I nsertion of S.s 7 to Sec.195
To provide that class of persons or cases (to be notified by CBDT) responsible for making payment to
a nonresident, whether or not such payment is chargeable under the Act, shall make an application
to the AO to determine the appropriate proportion of sum chargeable.
Case law neutralised: GE India Technology Centre P.Ltd 327 ITR 456 (SC)
unwelcome compliance burden running contrary to the principle of charging section affecting
non- resident payees.
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
8/22
Page 8
Tax Residency Certificate (TRC)
Sec. 90 & 90A amended to provide that a nonresident to whom tax
treaty applies shall necessarily obtain a certificate with prescribed
particulars from the Govt. of such country of which he is a resident.
TRC essential to claim relief under treaty, but not a sufficient conditionfor availing benefits.
Effective from financial year 2012-13.
CBDT cir. 786 providing that Mauritian TRC was sufficient to avail
benefits of IndoMauritius DTAA was upheld by SC in Azadi Bachao
case , now neutralisedVodafone case followed for amendment.
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
9/22
Page 9
Advance Pricing Agreement
Insertion of Sec. 92CC and 92 CDAdvance Pricing Agreement
(APA) - Effective from 1st July 2012 in relation to intl.
transactions.
- Board to enter into APAs with approval of Central Govt.
- ALP/ manner to compute ALP
- void if obtained by fraud/ change in law
- modified return on basis of APA
APA shall be valid for such years- in no case shall exceed five
consecutive years.
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
10/22
Page 10
Advance Pricing Agreement
Board to prescribe scheme- forms , procedure etc.
Unilateral / bilateral APAs ?
How effective the Directorate would be is the key for success
Provides certainty for the future
Reduction of double taxation not certain unless bilateral APA
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
11/22
Page 11
GAAR
Insertion of ChapterXASec.95-102- General Anti Avoidance Rule
The provisions of this Chapter may apply to any step in, or a part of, the
arrangement.
Impermissible avoidance arrangement (IAA) means an arrangement, the main
purpose or one of the main purposes of which is to obtain a tax benefit and it
- creates rights and obligationsnot at arms length
- results in abuse/misuse- provisions of this Act.
- lacks/ deemed to lack commercial substance- not ordinarily applied forbona fidepurposes
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
12/22
Page 12
GAAR
Presumptiontax benefit- main purpose- unless proved otherwise.
Even if a step in, or a part of, the arrangement, is to obtain tax benefit, - main
purpose gets tainted.
Deemed to lack commercial substance if
- substance/ effect of arrangement as a whole differs
significantly from individual steps
- round trip financing
- accommodating party
- offsetting/ cancelling each other
- disguises the value, location, source, ownership
- location of asset/ residence of any party for obtaining tax benefit
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
13/22
Page 13
GAAR
Following not to be considered for commercial substance
- period for which the arrangement exists
- payment of taxesdirectly/ indirectly
- fact that an exit route is provided
criteria for substance test of Vodafone case overruled
Consequencesnot exhaustive
- disregard / combine / recharacterise any step in/ part or whole
- treating IAA as not entered into
- disregard accommodating party
- deeming persons connectedas all one and the same
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
14/22
Page 14
GAAR
Consequencesnot exhaustive
- reallocation among the parties to the arrangement
any accrual, receipt, expenditure etc.
- place of residence/ situs of asset to be determined- look through any corporate structure
- equity may be treated as debt or vice-versa
- capital as revenue and vice-versa
Guidelines/ procedure to be prescribed.
Board has formed a six member committee to draft guidelines etc.
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
15/22
Page 15
GAAR v. DTAA
Section 90(2) provides for opting for IT provisions only when
more beneficial
Position judicially recognised in 263 ITR 706 SC and 267 ITR654 SC
Section 90(2A) provides that notwithstanding anything contained
in sec 90(2), provisions of Chapter X-A to apply to the assessee,
even if such provisions are not beneficial to himto override tax
treaty.
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
16/22
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
17/22
Page 17
Latest Case law Indo Mauritius Tax treaty
Subsidiary of UK coy in Mauritius held shares in India coy, sold the same to German coy
and claimed exemption of capital gains in India as per Article 13(4) of DTAA. Revenue
argued that beneficial owner is UK coy and claimed that IndoUK tax treaty would
applyAAR held that as per Azadi Bachaos case of SC shares sold by Mauritius sub is
exempt from capital gains in India per Art.13(4)
- Ardex Investments Mauritius Ltd., in re [2011] 16 taxmann.com 84 (AAR)
Mauritius shareholder in an Indian coy transferred shares pursuant to a buy back
arrangement whereas other shareholders i.e. US & Singapore coys did not subscribe to
the share buy back. No dividend paid by Indian coy since 2003 and allowed the reserves
to grow in view of DDT. AAR accepted Revenues contention that buy back scheme is a
tax avoidance scheme and held the same as colorable device. Income from buy back was
held to be taxable in India as dividends and disallowed claim of capital gains exemption
under Art.13(4) of DTAA
- XYZ India in re [2012] 20 taxmann.com 89 (AAR)
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
18/22
Page 18
Latest Case law Indo Mauritius Tax treaty
Sale of compulsory convertible debentures (CCDs)(Issued by India coy) by
Mauritius coy was claimed as exempt from capital gains under Art.13(4) of
DTAA. AAR applied Look at test of Vodafone ruling to lift corporate veil
and found subsidiary to be puppet of holding company and denied exemption
under DTAA. Held that sale of CCDs would result in accrual of interest and
thereby taxable by under Art.11 of DTAA
-Z Mauritius [2012] 20 taxmann.com 91 (AAR-New Delhi)
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
19/22
Page 19
Indo Mauritius tax treaty - way forward
Vodafone case Look at principle being applied as substance test in denying
treaty benefits
GAAR would be invoked in all DTAA cases where substance is poor
GAAR wider than LOB
Any person claiming benefits of DTAA must establish
Commercial substance
legitimacy of Mauritius entity
Activity report of Mauritius entity
More economic activity expected in Mauritius through intermediate holding
coys in future.
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
20/22
Page 20
Indo Mauritius tax treaty - way forward
Finance Secretary R.S. Gujral clarified in an interview on GAAR provisions
- FIIsLong term capital gains - no issue as there is no tax in India.
- FIIs - Short term capital gains taxable if no tangible activity/trading in Mauritius -
becomes impermissible arrangement and GAAR would apply - overriding DTAA -
if tax paid GAAR would not be invoked.
- GAAR is only prospective w.e.f 1st April, 2012 - no reopening of old assessments.
- Onus of proof on tax payer - however many safeguards like permission from Commissioner
and then further reference to GAAR panel are proposed in the Bill.
- Whether GAAR panel includes independent third party is being examined.
Representation by various Chambers to attach onus on the Revenue to prove that
there is impermissible arrangement, lest every transaction would be questioned.
TRC - Azadi Bachaos case overruled by GAAR and amended S.90/90A.
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
21/22
Page 21
Indo Mauritius tax treaty - way forward
News Flash
- Govt. may dilute GAAR regulations by prescribing thresh hold of
150 million rupees ($2.9 million)
- Govt. may defer implementation of GAAR by one year
- Fin.min official says that the Govt. did not have Participatory
Notes(PN) of FIIs in mind when introduced provisions in Budget
regarding underlying asset transfersno capital gains tax
- Finance Minister said that he may modify some provisions of
GAAR
- Substantial commercial interest in Mauritius critical for
availing treaty benefits
(SourceEconomic Times)
7/28/2019 IFA Mauritius
22/22
Page 22 35
THANKYOU