124 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
Paola Tartakoff
Between Christian and Jew:Conversion and Inquisition in the Crown of Aragon, 1250-
1391
Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2012,
209pp, ISBN9780812244212
äžäžã®ã€ããªã¢å島ã¯ãããªã¹ãæããŠãã€æã
ã€ã¹ã©ãŒã ã®äžå®æã®ä¿¡åŸãåæã«ååšããå Žæ
ãšããŠç¥ãããŠãããå島åéšã®ããªã¹ãæåŸã
æ¯é ããå°åã«ã€ããŠã¯ããšãã« 11äžçŽä»¥éã®
ããªã¹ãæåŸãšãŠãã€æåŸãšã®å ±åïŒãã®é¢ä¿ã
å¹³åçãåŠãã¯æªããŠããïŒãããç¥ãããŠãã
ãšããã§ããã11äžçŽãã 13äžçŽã«ãããŠå島
åéšãéã ã¹ãªã ã«å¯ŸããŠåŒ·ç¡¬ãªæ 床ããšããã«
ãã«ç³»å¢åãæ¯é ããŠããããšããã£ãŠã11äž
çŽä»¥éãŠãã€æåŸãå€ãæµå ¥ããããã®ãããå€
æ°æŽŸã®ããªã¹ãæåŸãšãå°æ°æŽŸãªããç¡èŠã§ããª
ãååšãšããŠã®ãŠãã€æåŸãå ±åãããšããç¶æ³
ã圢æãããã®ã§ããããã®äžäžäžåŸæã®ã¢ã©ãŽ
ã³ãã«ã¹ãã£ãŒãªã£ã«ãããããªã¹ãæåŸãšãŠã
ã€æåŸãšã®å ±åç¶æ ã¯ãäžäžè¥¿æ¬§ã«ããªãã¯ç€ŸäŒ
ã®äžã«ãããŠã¯ç¹åŸŽçãªç¶æ³ã§ãããšæããããŠ
ããããšããã£ãŠãç 究è ã®é¢å¿ãåŒããšãããš
ãªã£ãŠãããäž¡è ã®é¢ä¿ãå ±åã®å®æ ãæå亀æµã
å ±åã®çµçãšãã®èæ¯ãªã©ã«ã€ããŠãå€ãã®ç 究
ãèç©ãããŠããã
æ¬æžã¯ããã¥ãŒãžã£ãŒãžãŒå·ç«ã©ãã¬ãŒãºå€§åŠ
ã®å©ææã§ãã Paola Tartakoffã«ãã£ãŠèãããã
å°éã¯è¥¿æ¬§äžè¿äžå²ããšãã«ã¢ã©ãŽã³çåœã«ãã
ããŠãã€æåŸãç°ç«¯å¯©åã®åé¡ã«é¢å¿ããããšã
ãããšã§ããããã®é¢å¿ã«åºã¥ããŠæžãããæ¬æž
ã¯ãäžäžåŸæã¢ã©ãŽã³ã«ããããŠãã€æåŸãšããª
ã¹ãæåŸãšã®é¢ä¿ãæ±ããã®ã§ãããäžè¿°ããäž
矀ã®ç 究ã®äžã«äœçœ®ã¥ãããããã®ã§ããããäž»
ã«äž¡æåŸã®ãéãã«ååšãã人ã ãã€ãŸãæ¹å®è
ã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠãŠããç¹ãç¹åŸŽçã§ããïŒãªããæ¬
çš¿ã§åã«ãæ¹å®è ããšèšã£ãå Žåã«ã¯ãŠãã€æã
ãããªã¹ãæãžæ¹å®ãã人ã ãæãããšãšããã
ãã®ãããªæ¹å®è ãäž»ããç 究察象ãšãããŠãã
ããã§ããããŸããæ¬æžã§ã¯ããã£ããããªã¹ã
æã«æ¹å®ããåŸãŠãã€æã«åŸ©åž°ãã人ã ãæ±ãã
ãŠãããã圌ãã®ããšãæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯ãåæ¹å®è ããš
åŒã¶ããšãšããïŒãèè ã¯ãæ¹å®è ãäž»ãšããŠæ±ã
ã€ã€ããæ¹å®è ãçã¿åºãããèæ¯ãæ¹å®è ã«å¯Ÿ
ããããªã¹ãæåŸã»ãŠãã€æåŸã®æ 床ãæ¢ãããš
ã§ãåœæã®ã¢ã©ãŽã³ã«ãããäž¡æåŸéã®é¢ä¿ã«ã€
ããŠæ°ããªã¢ãããŒããå瀺ããããšãå¯èœã§ã
ããšãã趣æšã®ããšãè¿°ã¹ãŠãããäž¡æåŸéã®é¢
ä¿ã«ïŒãïŒé¢å¿ãåãã§ãããšæãããããããŠã
èè ã¯ç°ç«¯å¯©åãšããå Žãéžãã§ãããããããã
æ¹å®è ãåæ¹å®è ã®çœ®ãããç¶æ³ã瀺ããã®ã§ã
ããšåæã«ãæ¹å®è ãä»ããããªã¹ãæåŸãšãŠã
ã€æåŸãšã®é¢ä¿ã®æãããå ŽãšããŠããšããããš
ã§ãããšæãããã
èè ã®èšå®ãã察象幎代ãç¹åŸŽçã§ããããµ
ãã¿ã€ãã«ã«ããéããæ¬æžã§ã¯ã1391幎ãŸã§
ã®æ代ãäž»ã«æ±ãããŠããã1391幎ã«ã¯ãã«ã¹
ãã£ãŒãªã£ã»ã¢ã©ãŽã³äž¡åœã®å€ãã®éœåžã§ãŠãã€
æåŸã«å¯ŸããŠè殺ã»ç¥å¥ªãèµ·ãããããã«ãå€ã
ã®è ã匷å¶çã«æ¹å®ãããããããã®åŸããŠãã€
æåŸã®å ±åäœã¯äžæŠåèããããã®ã®ãåºæ¬çã«
ã¯ã1391幎ã¯ã1492幎ã®ãŠãã€æåŸè¿œæŸã«åã
ãŠã®æµããçãŸããã¿ãŒãã³ã°ãã€ã³ãã§ãããš
ãããŠãããæ¬æžã§æ±ãããã®ã¯ããããåã®æ
代ã§ãããæ¬æžã§æ±ãããæ¹å®è ãã匷å¶çãªæ¹
å®ã«ããããªã¹ãæåŸãšãªã£ã人ã ã§ã¯ãªããåº
æ¬çã«ã¯èªçºçã«æ¹å®ãã人ã ã§ãããåŸæ¥ãã€
ããªã¢å島ã«ããããŠãã€æåŸåé¡ã«ã€ããŠãæ¹
å®è ãç°ç«¯å¯©åãæ±ããšèšã£ãå Žåã«ã¯ã察象ãš
ãªãã®ã¯ã1391幎以éãã¿ãŒãã³ã°ãã€ã³ãã
çµãŠçžå¯Ÿçå¯å®¹ãšããç¶æ³ã厩ããåŸã®ã³ã³ãã«
ãœã§ãããçæš©ãé¢äžã㊠15äžçŽæ«ã«èšçœ®ãã
ãã¹ãã€ã³ç°ç«¯å¯©åæã§ãã£ããããããèè ã¯
ããããåã®æ代ãèšå®ããèªçºçãªæ¹å®è ãç
æš©é¢äžä»¥åã®ç°ç«¯å¯©åæã察象ãšããŠè«ãé²ããŠ
ããããã§ãããèªçºçãªæ¹å®ãäž»ã§ãããæ ã«ã
æ¹å®ããããã¯åæ¹å®ã®åæ©ãããã«åãã説åŸ
ã®ããæ¹ããã®èæ¯ããããã£ãããšãåé¡ã«ã
ãå¯èœæ§ãçãããèè ã®ããæ°ããªã¢ãããŒã
125æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
ã¯ã1391幎以åãšãããçžå¯Ÿçã»æ¯èŒçã«èŠãŠ
ãªãå¯å®¹æ§ã®ãã£ãæ代ã察象ãšããããšã§ãã
ãããå瀺ããããšãããããã
ããŠãæ¬æžã«ã¯ãäž»äººå ¬ãšã§ãããã¹ã人ç©ã
ååšãããã¢ã©ãŽã³ã®éœåžã»ã«ã©ã¿ãŠãŒåºèº«ã®ãŠ
ãã€æåŸã§ãã£ã圌ã¯ã1340幎 12æã«ã«ã¿ã«ãŒ
ãã£ã§ããªã¹ãæã®æŽç€Œãåãããã©ïŒãããã«
ç±æ¥ããã«ã¿ã«ãŒãã£èªåïŒãšããåãäžããã
ãïŒæ¬æžã«å£ãã以äžã§ã¯åœŒã®ããšãæ¹å®åŸã®ã
ã©ãšããåã§åŒã¶ïŒã1341幎ãã¢ã©ãŽã³ã«æ»ã£ã
ãã©ã¯ããŠãã€æåŸããåæ¹å®ãããã説åŸãã
ãŠãã€æã«åŸ©åž°ãããããåæ¹å®ã説åŸãã人ã
ãšãã©ãç°ç«¯å¯©åã«ãããããŠããããã®ç°ç«¯å¯©
åã®èšé²ãæ®ã£ãŠãããæ¬æžã§ã¯åœè©²èšé²ãå²æ
ãšããŠçšãããšåæã«ããã©ãã¡ã®ç©èªãæ¬è«ãž
å ¥ã£ãŠããããã§ã®ããã°å ¥ãå£ãšããŠå©çšããŠ
ããã®ã§ããããã®ãããæ¬æžã®æ§æã¯ããç¹æ®
ã§ãããããªãã¡ãæ¬æžã®äž»éšã¯ 3éšã«åããã
ãŠããããããããã®éšã®æåãšæåŸã«ãã©ãã¡
ã®ã±ãŒã¹ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãã»ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã眮ãããŠã
ãããããŠããã®ã»ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã§æ¬è«ïŒããã§ã¯ã
ã©ãã¡ã®ã±ãŒã¹ã¯ãããŸã§ãè«ãè£åŒ·ããå ·äœäŸ
ãšããŠæ±ãããŠããïŒãæã¿èŸŒããšããã¹ã¿ã€ã«
ã«ãªã£ãŠããã
以äžã§æ¬æžã®å€åœ¢çãªéšåã倧ãŸãã«èª¬æãã
ããšã«ãªããã以äžã§ã¯äžæ©é²ãã§æ¬æžã®å 容ã«
è¿«ããå 容ã®çŽ¹ä»ãšæ¬æžã®è°è«ã«å¯Ÿããè©äŸ¡ãã
ãããšãšãããã
æ¢è¿°ã®éããæ¬æžã¯ 3éšãããªããããããã®
éšããã©ã®ã±ãŒã¹ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãã»ã¯ã·ã§ã³ãšæ¬
è« 2ç« ãå«ãã§ããããã©ã®ã±ãŒã¹ã«é¢ããŠã¯ã
ã§ã«äºäŸã®æŠç¥ã®çŽ¹ä»ãæžãŸããŠããã®ã§ã以äž
ã§ã¯æ¬è«éšåã«éã£ãŠå 容ã玹ä»ããããšãšããã
第 1éš âBefore the Tribunalâã§ã¯ãäž»ã«ããŠãã€æ
åŸãæ¹å®è ã察象ãšããç°ç«¯å¯©åã®ç¶æ³ããã®è
æ¯ã«ã€ããŠããã©ã®ã±ãŒã¹ãäž»ããäŸã«ãšããªã
ããè«ããŠããã第 1ç« ã第 2ç« ã® 2ç« ãå«ãŸããã
第 1ç« ã¯ âDefending the Faithâãšé¡ãããŠããã
ãŠãã€æåŸã¯ãæ¬æ¥ãç°ç«¯ãã§ã¯ãªããç°æåŸã
ã§ãããç°ç«¯å¯©åã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšã¯ãªãããªãããããã
æ¬ç« ã«ããã°å€ã㯠13äžçŽãããŠãã€æåŸãç°
端審åã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšããŠæ±ãäŸãããã14äžçŽã«ã¯ã
ç°ç«¯å¯©åå®ãã«ããŒã«ã»ã®ãŒãç°ç«¯å¯©åã®æåŒæž
ã®äžã§ããŠãã€æåŸããŠãã€æããã®æ¹å®è ã«ã€
ããŠãç°ç«¯å¯©åã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšããŠæããŠããããªããŠ
ãã€æåŸãæ¹å®è ãç°ç«¯å¯©åã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªã£ãã®
ãããããæ¬ç« ã®äž»ããããŒãã§ããããããã
ãããŸããŸãªçç±ã®ãã¡ã§æ¬æžãæãéèŠããŠã
ãã®ã¯ããŠãã€æåŸãæ¹å®è ã«åæ¹å®ãä¿ãããš
ã§ã«ããªãã¯æäŒã«ææãäžããããšãåé¡èŠã
ãããããšããçç±ã§ãããæ¹å®è ã®ååšã¯ãã«
ããªãã¯æäŒã«ãšã£ãŠã¯ããªã¹ãæã®ãŠãã€æã«
察ããåªäœã瀺ããšããéèŠãªæå³ãæã€ããã
ãã£ãŠããŠãã€æåŸãåæ¹å®ãä¿ãããšã¯ãããª
ã¹ãæã®ä¿è·ã®ãããé²æ¢ãããã¹ãã§ãããšã
ãããã§ãããæ¹å®è ã¯ãã®åæ¹å®ã®å§ãã«å¿ã
ãããšã眪ãšãããŠããã
第 2ç« ã¯ âFrom Resistance to Surrenderâãšé¡ãã
ãŠãããç°ç«¯å¯©åã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªã£ããŠãã€æåŸãã¡
ãã©ã察å¿ãããã«ã€ããŠæ±ãããŠãããå ·äœç
ã«ã¯ããã©ã«åæ¹å®ã®èª¬åŸããããŠãã€æåŸãã¡
ãäŸã«æããããŠãããçæš©ã«ããååãèŠè«ã
ãäŸïŒãŠãã€æåŸã«ã¯ãšãªãŒãå®åãå°ãªããª
ãã£ãããšããå¯èœã§ãã£ãæ段ã§ããïŒãããã£
ãããšèªçœãããŠå³ããè¿œåãåŠçœ°ãéããäŸãª
ã©ã玹ä»ãããŠããããªããæ¬ç« ã§ã説æãããŠ
ããéããæçµçã«ã¯æ¹å®ãæå¹ãªæ段ã§ãããã
ãã©ã®ã±ãŒã¹ã§åŠèªãç¶ãããŠãã€æåŸã¯ããã
ããã®æ段ã¯éžã°ãªãã£ãããã§ããã
第 2 éš âAt the Front of New Lifeâ ã§ã¯ã1391 幎
以åã®æ¹å®è ã®ç¶æ³ãæ¹å®ã®åæ©ãªã©ã«ã€ããŠè«
ããããŠããã第 3ç« ã第 4ç« ã® 2ç« ãå«ãã
第 3ç« ã¯ âBetween Doubt and Desireâãšé¡ãããŠ
ãããæ¹å®è ã«å¯ŸããŠãããªã¹ãæåŸãã¡ã¯ãæ¹
å®ãç©æ¥µçã«æè¿ããç®ãšãæ¹å®ãããŠããªãäž
身ã¯ãŠãã€æåŸãªã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšããçãã®ç®ãš
ã®äž¡æ¹ãæã£ãŠãããç« é¡ã®æå³ããã®ã¯ãã®ã
ãšã§ãããããã®çãã®ç®ã®ããããæ¹å®è ïŒã
ããã¯ãã®åå«ïŒã¯ããããŸã§ãæ°ããªã¹ãæåŸã
ãšããŠãéåžžã®ããªã¹ãæåŸãšã¯åºå¥ãããŠããã
äžæ¹ãæ¬ç« ã§ã¯ãããªã¹ãæåŸã®ãæ¹å®ãããã¯
æ¹å®è ã«å¯ŸããèŠæ¹ã ãã§ãªããæ¹å®è ã®æ¹å®ã®
126 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
åæ©ãæ±ãããŠããããã®åé¡ã«ã€ããŠãèè ã¯ã
æ¹å®è ãæ¹å®ãéžãã ã®ã¯ããŠãã€æåŸå ±åäœå
ã§ã®å¯Ÿç«ã»äžåãé¿ããããã ã£ãã®ã§ã¯ãªããã
ãšãã説ãæ瀺ããŠãããå± äœå°ããé ãé¢ãã
åå°ã§æ¹å®ãåããã±ãŒã¹ãååšããããšïŒæã
ã°ãã©ããã¢ã©ãŽã³è¥¿éšã«ã©ã¿ãŠãŒã®äœäººãªããã
é ãã«ã¿ã«ãŒãã£ã§æŽç€ŒãåããŠããïŒãããã®
説ãè£åŒ·ããè«æ ãšãããŠããã
第 4ç« âHomeward Boundâã§ã¯ãæ¹å®åŸã®æ¹å®
è ã®çµéšã圌ãã®ããããç¶æ³ãè¿°ã¹ãããŠã
ããæ¹å®è ãã¡ã®äžã«ã¯ãããªã¹ãæåŸã«ååç
ãªå§¿å¢ãèŠãããŠãã€æåŸãç°ç«¯å¯©åæã«åçºã
ããããŠãã€æåŸã«å¯ŸããŠå®£æããããããè ã
ãããããããå€ãã®æ¹å®è ã¯ãæ¹å®ã«ãã£ãŠã
ç¶æ³ãæ¹åããããã§ã¯ãªãã貧å°ç¶æ ã«é¥ã£ãã
èè ã«ããã°ããã®ããšãæ¹å®è åŽã®åæ¹å®ãžã®
åæ©ãšãªã£ããšããããšã§ããã
第 3éš âBy the Fireâã¯ã第 2éšãäž»ã«ããªã¹ã
æåŸãšæ¹å®è ãšã®é¢ä¿ãæ±ã£ãŠããã®ã«å¯Ÿããäž»
ã«ãŠãã€æåŸãšæ¹å®è ãšã®é¢ä¿ãæ±ãéšãšãªã£ãŠ
ããããããã£ãŠããã®éšã«ãããŠãèè ã¯ãæ¹
å®è ã®ããšãããŠãã€æåŸåŽããã®èŠæ¹ã«å³ãã
圢ã§ãèæè apostateããšåŒã¶ããšãå€ãã第 5ç« ã
第 6ç« ãå«ãã
第 5ç« âApostasy as Scourgeâã§ã¯ããŠãã€æåŸã
ã¡ãæ¹å®è ïŒèæè ã«å¯ŸããŠãšã£ã察å¿ã«ã€ããŠ
è¿°ã¹ãããŠããã第 4ç« ã§è¿°ã¹ãããŠãããšã
ããæ¹å®è ãã¡ã¯ãå³æ¹ã§ããããšãã¢ããŒã«ã
ãããããããªã¹ãæåŸã«å¯ŸããŠååçã§ãäžæ¹
ãŠãã€æåŸã«ãšã£ãŠã¯æµå¯Ÿçãªè¡åããšãã±ãŒã¹
ãå€ãããã«å±éºãªååšã§ãã£ãããŸããææ³ç
ã«ãããŠãã€æåŸã«ãšã£ãŠæ£æã¯å€§çœªãšèããã
ãŠãããç¹ã«ããªã¹ãæãžã®æ¹å®ã¯åé¡ãšèãã
ããŠããããã®ããããŠãã€æåŸã¯æ¹å®è ãæµèŠ
ããç©ççã«æ»æããããšã¯ãŸãã§ãã£ããšããŠ
ãã䟮蟱çãªæ 床ããšã£ãããçžç¶æš©ãå¥å¥ªãã
ããããšããããšã§ããã
第 6ç« âRecruiting Repentanceâã¯ãç« é¡ã®ç€ºã
éãããŠãã€æåŸã«ããåæ¹å®ã®èª¬åŸã«çŠç¹ãåœ
ãŠãç« ã§ããã第 5ç« ã§è¿°ã¹ãããããšã®è£è¿ã
ãšããããããæ¹å®è ããŠãã€æåŸã®åŽã«åŒãæ»
ãããšãå ±åäœã®å®å šã«è³ãããããŸããå®æ
äžãåã§ãããšèãããããšèè ã¯è¿°ã¹ãŠããã
ãã£ãšãããã©ã®ã±ãŒã¹ã¯ããã©ãåæ¹å®ãããŠ
ãŠãã€æåŸã®å ±åäœã«å床è¿ãå ¥ãããšããããš
ã§ã¯ãªãã£ãããã©ã¯ãããªã¹ãæãæ£æããã
ãšãå ¬èšããŠç«åã«åŠããããã°éãæãããã
æšèª¬ããããšããããšã§ãããåæ¹å®ã説åŸãã
ãŠãã€æåŸã«ã¯ããã©ãïŒçããç¶æ ã§ïŒãŠãã€
æåŸå ±åäœã«è¿ãå ¥ããæ°ã¯ãªãã£ãã®ã§ããã
ãã®ããšããããŠãã€æåŸã¯ãããªã¹ãæåŸãžã®
䟮蟱çã»ææŠçãªè¡šçŸãšããŠãåæ¹å®ãåæ¹å®è
ãå©çšããŠãããšããããšã窺ãããããšããã®
ãèè ã®äž»åŒµã§ããã
ã€ã¥ããŠãæ¬æžã®è°è«ã«å¯ŸããŠè¥å¹²ã®æ¹è©ã»è
å¯ãå ããããšãšãããã
æ¬æžã®ç®çã«ã¯ãå è¿°ã®éããæ¹å®è ïŒããã
ã¯åæ¹å®è ïŒã軞ã«ãããªã¹ãæåŸãšãŠãã€æåŸ
ãšã®é¢ä¿ãæ°ããªã¢ãããŒãã§æããããšããã
ãšãå«ãŸããŠãããåŸæ¥ã¯ãæ¹å®è èªäœã«ã€ããŠ
ã®ç 究ïŒãã£ãšã 15ïœ 16äžçŽä»¥éã®ã³ã³ãã«ãœ
ã察象ãšãããã®ãå€ãïŒã¯ãããšããŠããæ¹å®
è ãéããŠäž¡æéã®é¢ä¿ãæèçã«æãããšãã
ç 究ã¯ãå¿ ãããå€ãã¯ãªãã£ãããã®ç¹ã§ã¯ã
èè ã¯ç¢ºãã«æ°ããèŠç¹ãå瀺ãããšããããšã
ã§ãããããã£ãšããèè ãçµè«ã§åŒ·èª¿ããŠãã
ã®ã¯ãæ¹å®è ãåæ¹å®è ãšããååšãããããã®
å®æã«ãšã£ãŠããäžæ¹ã®å®æã«å¯Ÿããåªäœã瀺ã
蚌æ ããããŠããããšããããšã§ããããããèª
äœã¯ãã»ã©ç®æ°ããææã§ã¯ãªãã
ãšã¯ãããæ°ããã¢ãããŒããèŠç¹ãèšå®ãã
ãããšãã£ãŠãå¿ ãããæ°ããçµè«ãå°ãããã
ãã§ã¯ãªã以äžããã®ç¹ã¯æ¹å€ãã¹ãããšã§ã¯ãª
ãã§ããããããããæ¬æžã®äŸ¡å€ã¯ãå°ãªããšã
ãã®ãäž¡æåŸã®å¯Ÿç«é¢ä¿ãšããæèã«ãããæ¹å®
è ã®æå³ããšããè«ç¹ã«é¢ããŠããã°ãæœè±¡çã¬
ãã«ã§ã®çµè«ããããã®å ·äœæ§ã®é«ãèšè¿°ã«ãã
ãšããããæ¬æžã¯ããã©ããã®åšèŸºã®ãŠãã€æåŸ
ãã¡ãšãããããçšåºŠè©³çŽ°ãªç°ç«¯å¯©åèšé²ã®æ®ã
人ç©ãã¡ãç»å Žäººç©ãšããŠæ§æãããŠããããã®
ããã圌ãã«é¢ããå ·äœçãªèšè¿°ãå šäœã«å€ãã
ãã®çµæãçµè«èªäœã¯ãã€ãŠããèšãããŠããã
127æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
ã®ãšå€§å·®ãªããšããŠããããã§èšãããŠããç¶æ³
ããããªããã®ã§ãã£ãã®ãããšãã«ããŠãã€æ
åŸãæ¹å®è ã®åæ¹å®ãšããè¡çºãããªã¹ãæåŸã«
察ããåªäœãæµå¯Ÿå¿ã®è¡šæãšããŠå©çšãããšãã
ãšãã«ãããªãæ æ§ã§æ¹å®è ã«æ¥ããã®ããšãã
ããšã«ã€ããŠãå ·äœçãªã€ã¡ãŒãžãåŸãããšãå¯
èœã§ããã
ãããšåæã«æ¬æžã®ææãšããŠè©äŸ¡ãããã¹ã
ãªã®ã¯ãæ¹å®è ã®æ¹å®ã®åæ©ã«ã€ããŠã®æ€èšã§ã
ããããã®ç¹ã«ã€ããŠããåŸæ¥ããŸãç 究ã¯ãã
ãŠããªãã£ããšæããããç°ç«¯å¯©åã®å³çœ°ãéã
ãã¹ãæ¹å®ããŠããŸãã±ãŒã¹ããã£ããšããããš
ã¯ãæ¬æžã§ãäŸãæããããŠããããäžè¬ã«æ³å®
ã®ããããæ¹å®ã®çç±ãªããåæ©ã§ãããããã
åè¿°ããããã«ãæ¬æžã§ã¯ããŠãã€æåŸã®å ±åäœ
ã®äžã§ã®å¯Ÿç«ããéããããšããããšãæ¹å®ã®å
æ©ãšãªã£ãŠãããšããããšããçžåœãªåéããã£
ãŠè«ããããŠããã
ãã¡ãããæ¬æžã®è°è«ããåã ã®æ¹å®è ã®å
æ©ãçŽæ¥çŸããŠããå²æã«åºã¥ããŠããããã§
ã¯ãªããæ¬æžã§æããããŠããã®ã¯ãããšãã°ã
ãããŠãã€æåŸããŠãã€æåŸã®å ±åäœããæé€
excommunicationãããåŸã«æ¹å®ãããšããããš
ãèšé²ããŠããå²æãªã©ãããã°éæ¥èšŒæ ã§ããã
ãããã£ãŠããã®çµè«èªäœãæ£ãããã©ããã«ã€
ããŠã¯ããªãæ€èšããäœå°ããªãããã§ã¯ãªãã
ããããæ¹å®è ã®æ¹å®ã®åæ©ã«é¢ã㊠1ã€ã®ä»®èª¬
ãå瀺ããããšããç¹ã«ãããŠã¯ãæ¬æžã«äŸ¡å€ã
èªããããšãã§ããã
ãã ãèè ã®é¢å¿ã®æåšã«ç«ã¡è¿ã£ãŠã¿ããšã
ããªã¹ãæåŸãšãŠãã€æåŸããããŠæ¹å®è ãšã®é¢
ä¿ãšããèŠç¹ã«ãšã£ãŠãæ¹å®ã®åæ©ã®ç 究ãã©ã®
çšåºŠæå³ãæã£ãŠããã®ããšããããšãåããã
ããšã«ãªãããæ¹å®ã®åæ©ã«ã€ããŠèè ãè¿°ã¹ãŠ
ããã®ã¯ç¬¬ 3ç« ã§ãããããªãã¡ãããªã¹ãæåŸ
ãæ¹å®è ãçãã®ç®ã§èŠãŠãããšããããšãè«ã
ãç« ã§ããããã®æ¹å®ã®åæ©ã«ã€ããŠã®æ€èšãã
ããšããšã¯ãã®æèã§è«ããããŠããããšã§ã
ããããªãã¡ãæ¹å®è ãçã«ä¿¡ä»°äžã®çç±ããæ¹
å®ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããŸã§çŸäžçãªäžå©çãéã
ãããã«æ¹å®ãããšããããšããããªã¹ãæåŸã
çãã®ç®ãæã€ããã«ãªã£ãçç±ã§ããããšãã
ã®ãèè ã®è«ã§ããããã®è«ãå°ãããã«ãæ¹å®
ã®åæ©ããä¿¡ä»°äžã®åé¡ã§ãªãã£ããããšãèšã
ããšã¯å¿ èŠã§ãããšããŠããå ·äœçã«äœãåæ©ã«
ãªã£ãŠããããŸã§ç©æ¥µçã«è«ããå¿ èŠããã£ãã®
ãã¯çåããªãããã§ã¯ãªããããããã®ç¹ã«ã€
ããŠã¯ãããèªäœãäž»é¡ãšããŠèšå®ããŠæ±ã£ãæ¹
ããæ¬æžå šäœã®è°è«ã®æ¹åæ§ãæ確åããäžã§ã¯ã
ãŸããã®æ¹å®ã®åæ©ã®æ€èšã®äŸ¡å€ãããé«ããäž
ã§ã¯ãããã£ãããã«ãæãããã
ãã 1ã€ãæ¬æžãçµè«ã«ãããŠåŒ·èª¿ããŠããã
ãšããããããã¯ãäžèšã§ããã°ãå¢çã®çžå¯Ÿåã
ãšããããšã«ãªããã1391幎ãšããæéäžã®å¢
çããããŠããã¬ããŒå±±èãšãã空éäžã®å¢çã®
çžå¯Ÿåã§ããã
1391幎ãšãã幎ã¯ãå è¿°ã®éããã¹ãã€ã³ïŒã€
ããªã¢å島ïŒã®ãŠãã€æåŸã®æŽå²ã«ãããã¿ãŒã
ã³ã°ãã€ã³ãã§ãããšäžè¬ã«èªèãããŠãããã
ã®ç¹ã«ã€ããŠã¯ãèè èªèº«ãæ瀺çã«ã¿ãŒãã³ã°
ãã€ã³ãã§ããæšèšè¿°ããŠããããã®ããšèªäœã
åŠå®ãã趣æšã§ã¯ãªããšèãããããå®éãæ¬æž
å·»æ«ã®çšèªéã«ãããŠããæ¹å®è ãè¡šãã³ã³ãã«
㜠conversoãšããèšèã«ã€ããŠãç¹ã« 1391幎以
éã®æ¹å®è ãããèªã§ãããšããããšã泚èšãã
ãŠãããèè ã 1391幎ååŸã§æ¹å®è ã®æ§æ Œãç¶
æ³ã«äžå®ã®å·®ãããããšãèªããŠããããšãèªã¿
åããããããããã®äžã§èè ã¯ã1391幎ãè¶
ããŠå ±éããç¶æ³ãååšããããšã匷調ããŠã
ããããšãã°ã15äžçŽæ«ã®ã¹ãã€ã³ç°ç«¯å¯©åæ
ã§ã¯ããŠãã€æåŸãæ¹å®è ãåæ¹å®ãããŠããŸã
ããšãåé¡èŠãããŠãããã1492幎ã®ã«ããªã
ã¯äž¡çã«ãããŠãã€æåŸè¿œæŸä»€ãããã®åæ¹å®ã®
å§èªã®å±éºãæé€ããããšããå°ãªããšãå ¬åŒã®
çç±ãšãªã£ãŠããããã®ããŠãã€æåŸã«ããæ¹å®
è ãžã®åæ¹å®ã®å§èªãåé¡èŠããèãæ¹ã¯ãèè
ãæ¬æžç¬¬ 1ç« ã§æããã«ããããã«ã1391幎以
åã®ç°ç«¯å¯©åæã§ãå ±æãããŠããèãæ¹ã§ã
ããæ¬æžã«åŒçšãããŠãããã«ããŒã«ã»ã®ãŒã®ç°
端審åã®æåŒæžã«ãè¡šããŠããèãæ¹ã§ãããã
ã®ããã«ãæ¹å®è ããŠãã€æåŸã«å¯Ÿããããªã¹ã
æåŸåŽïŒç°ç«¯å¯©åæã®èŠæ¹ã¯ã1391幎ã®ååŸã
128 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
éããŠé£ç¶æ§ãæããŠããããšããã®ãèè ã®äž»
匵ã§ããããã§ããã1391幎ãã¿ãŒãã³ã°ãã€
ã³ãã§ãããšããèŠæ¹ãäžè¬çã§ãããæ ã«ãå
幎ãè¶ ããé£ç¶æ§ã«å¯Ÿããé æ ®ã¯æãèœã¡ãã¡ã§
ãããæ¬æžã¯ããã®ç¹ã«é¢ãã泚æãåèµ·ããã
ã®ãšãè©ããããšãã§ããã
åãè©äŸ¡ãã空éçãªå¢çã®çžå¯Ÿåãšããç¹ã«
ã€ããŠãå¯èœã§ãããæ¬æžã§æ±ãããã®ã¯ã¢ã©ãŽ
ã³çåœã§ããããã«ã¹ãã£ãŒãªã£ããã¬ããŒä»¥å
ã®è¥¿æ¬§è«žåœã«ããæ¹å®è ã®çœ®ãããç¶æ³ãªã©ã«ã€
ããŠé¡äŒŒæ§ãããããšãéæã§åŒ·èª¿ãããŠããã
ãŸããæ¬æžã¯ããªã¹ãæåŸãšãŠãã€æåŸã®é¢ä¿ã
æ±ã£ãŠããããããªã¹ãæåŸãšã ã¹ãªã ã®é¢ä¿ãš
ã®éã«é¡äŒŒæ§ãããããšãçµè«ã§ç€ºãããŠããã
èè ãèšããšããããŠãã€æåŸãšã ã¹ãªã ã¯ãã®
çµãŠããæŽå²ã瀟äŒçã»çµæžçãªç¶æ³ãç°ãªãã
ããåŸæ¥ã¯å¥ã ã«ç 究ãããã¡ã§ãã£ããããã
ããããªã¹ãæåŸãæ¯é ãã瀟äŒã«ãããŠååšã
èªãããããã€ããªãã£ãšããç«å Žã§ãããå ±é
ã®ç¶æ³ããã£ãã¯ãã§ããããã®ããã«ããŠãè
è ã¯ããã€ãŠé£ç¶æ§ãèŠèœãšãããã¡ã§ãã£ãè«ž
ç¹ã«ã€ããŠãé£ç¶æ§ã®ããããšãæ確ã«ç€ºããã
ã®ã§ãããæ¬æžã¯ãåŸã«ç¶ãç 究è ãã¡ã«ãšã£ãŠ
ã¯ããã®é£ç¶æ§ãæèããå¿ èŠãããããšã説ã
ããã®ãšããŠã®æ矩ããããšãããã
ãã ãé¡äŒŒæ§ã»é£ç¶æ§ã¯ããããããããããš
ã瀺ããã ãã§ã¯ååãªæå³ããªããªããããã
ãã©ã®ãããªã¢ãããŒããå¯èœã«ãªããã©ã®ãã
ãªæŽå²åãæããã®ããæ¬æžã§ã¯ãã®ç¹ã«ã€ããŠ
ã®èšåã¯ãªããç©è¶³ããªããæãããããšããã§
ãã£ãããã£ãšããããã¯æ¬æžã®ããŒãã§ã¯ãªã
ãšããããšã§ããããæã ã®ä»åŸã®èª²é¡ã§ããã
以äžã¿ãŠãããšãããæ¬æžã«ã¯ãç©è¶³ããªãã
æããããéšåãå€å°ã¯ãããã®ã®ãäžäžåŸæã€
ããªã¢ã«ãããããªã¹ãæåŸãšãŠãã€æåŸãšã®é¢
ä¿ãšãããããã°å€å žçãªããŒãã«å¯ŸããŠãæ°ã
ãªèŠç¹ã®å¯èœæ§ãåŸæ¥ã¯èŠèœãšãããã¡ã§ãã£ã
åé¡ç¹ãæ瀺ãããšããç¹ãè©äŸ¡ããããšãã§ã
ãããäžèªã®äŸ¡å€ã¯ããã
ïŒå±±ç°èäžéïŒ
äœè€å ¬çŸèãäžäžã€ã¿ãªã¢ã®å°åãšåœå®¶çŽäºãšå¹³åã®æ¿æ²»ç€ŸäŒå²ã
京éœå€§åŠåŠè¡åºçäŒã2012 幎 10 æåãA5 å€ã
v ïŒ 326 é ã3800 åïŒçšãISBN978-4-87698-224-0
ãšãŒãããã®çºå±ãšã®æ¯èŒãåæãšããæ¥æ¬ã®
æŠåŸæŽå²åŠã«ãããŠãã€ã¿ãªã¢ãç¹ã«è¿äžä»¥éã®
æŽå²ã¯ãè¿ä»£åã®ã¢ãã«ãæ瀺ããªããåœæ°åœå®¶
ã®åœ¢æã«å€±æãã姿ã匷調ãããŠããããããã
次第ã«åœæ°åœå®¶ããå°ããªè«žå°åããããã¯ãã
倧ããªäžçãžãšãæŽå²èªèãšãã®åè¿°ã®æ çµã
å€å®¹ãã1970幎代以éã®ç€ŸäŒå²ã®éçãåããŠã
80幎代ããã€ã¿ãªã¢ã¯æŽå²çèå¯ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšããŠ
èŠçŽãããå€æ§ãªé¢å¿ã«ããåå¥å®èšŒçãªç 究ã
èç©ãããããšãšãªã£ãããããŠè¿å¹Žã§ã¯ããã
ããç 究ã®ææãåå°ãšãã€ã€ãã€ã¿ãªã¢ãèå°
ã«æ¹ããŠåœå®¶ã®ãããããåããããã¿ãåºããª
ãããŠãããããã§å±éãããè°è«ã¯ããã¯ãã€
ã¿ãªã¢äžåœå²ã®æ çµã«ãšããããªããè€æ°ã®å°å
åœå®¶ã«ããåºåæ¯é ã®å€æ§æ§ããå°äžæµ·ã«ããã
æ¯é åãèŠéã«å ¥ããåœéæ§ã«å¯ãã ãã®ãšãªã£
ãŠããããŸããã€ã¿ãªã¢æ¬åœã«ãããåœå®¶å²ç 究
ã«ãããŠããè¿äžåœå®¶ã¯ãè¯ãããªéœåžã®æ代ã
厩å£ããèªç±ãè¡°éããããšã§å°å»ºçãªåäž»ã«ã
ã統治ãããšãããããšããåŠå®çãªèŠç¹ããã
ã€ãŠã¯ãšãããããŠãããããããããããè¡°éã
è«ã¯ã1970幎代以éãç¹ã« G. ããããªãŒãã«ã
ããåäž»ãé åå è«žéœåžã蟲æéšã®åšå°éå£ãšã
ããè«žå¢åã®åè¡¡ãåºç€ãšããå°ååœå®¶ã¢ãã«ã®
æ瀺ãå¥æ©ã«ãèŠãããŠããããšãšãªãããŸãã
C. ã®ã³ã¹ãã«ã°ã«ä»£è¡šããããã¯ãã¹ããŒãªã¢
ã 70幎代ã«éçããè¿ä»£åœæ°åœå®¶ã®èéã«äž»çŒ
ãããå·šèŠçãªæŽå²èŠ³ã«ç矩ãæããããããã®
ãã¯ãã¹ããŒãªã¢ã®ææ³ãçšããåºåæš©åå ã®è«ž
å°åã«ããå¯æ¥ãã圢ã§å®æ ãæããã«ããå°å
åœå®¶ã®åå¥å®èšŒçæ€èšããããã¿ãç 究ææãã
è¿å¹Žå¢å ããŠããã
æ¬æžã¯ããããã€ã¿ãªã¢å²ç 究ã®ååã«ãã
129æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
ãŠãåéšã€ã¿ãªã¢ã«äžäžåŸæ以éå±éããããã©
ããšãã®æ¯é è ã§ãããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£å®¶ãäžå¿
ãšããå°ååœå®¶ã®æç«éçšãèå¯ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšããŠã
ããç¹ã«ãéœåžåœå®¶ããå°ååœå®¶ãžã®ç§»è¡ããå ±
åæ¿ããåäž»æ¿ãžã®æ¿æ²»åœ¢æ ã®å€åãã倧éœåžã«
ããäžå°éœåžãšåšèŸºé åã®åã蟌ã¿ã®çµæãšããŠ
ãšãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããè«žéœåžãšã®éããããã¯èŸ²
æéšãªã©ã®åšèŸºå°åå ±åäœãšã®éã®ãçžäºäº€æµãš
ãã®é²å±ã®éçšãšããŠåæ çã«èå¯ããããšãã
æ¬æžã®ç¹è²ã§ããããçžäºã®ææçéã®ãªãã§å
æããªãããããã«ããšã¥ãå¹³åã圢æãããã
ãšã§ãé åå ã®è«žå¢åã®åè¡¡ã確ç«ããããã®è«ž
å¢åã®åè¡¡ããé¢ä¿ãåºç€ãšãªã£ãŠãåºåç秩åº
ã圢æããããŸãç¶æãããŠããã®ã§ããããã
ãã秩åºåœ¢æã®éçšã®å®æ ãæããã«ãããã
ã«ãæ¬æžã§ã¯çŽäºè«çèŠç¹ãåãå ¥ããããè«žå¢
åéã®å©å®³é¢ä¿ã®è¡çªãšããã®èª¿æŽãšå解ãèç©
ãããŠããããšã«ãã£ãŠã挞次çã«åœå®¶çæ¯é ã
確ç«ããŠããããŸãæãããŠããããŸããå°ååœ
家ã«åŸå±ããªããããéœåžããã¯ãåšèŸºé åã«å¯Ÿ
ããŠåªè¶ããŠããããšããããããªãŒãã®ã¢ãã«
ã§ã¯ãšãããããªããããªãçŽäºãšå解ã®åœäºè
ã§ãã£ãè«žå¢åã«ããå¯æ¥ããŠèå¯ãããããšã
ãŠãæ¬æžã§ã¯ãã¯ãã¹ããŒãªã¢ã®ææ³ãç¹°ãè¿ã
çšããããŠãããããã«ãããå ·äœçãªäºäŸã®é¢
ä¿è ãã¡ã®æŽ»åãããã®ååãæå±ãšãã£ãããŒ
ãœãã«ãªæ å ±ãšãšãã«ãåæ çã«ææ¡ããããšã
å¯èœãšãªã£ãŠããã以äžã§ã¯ãæ¬æžã®åç« ã®å 容
ãèŠçŽããå±éãããŠããè°è«ã玹ä»ããŠããã
ãŸãåºç« ã§ã¯ãæ¬æžã®ãããªèå¯å¯Ÿè±¡ããäžè¿°
ã®ããã« 12äžçŽãã 15äžçŽã«ãããŠã®æ代ã®å
ã€ã¿ãªã¢ãç¹ã«ãã³ãã«ãã£ã¢ãšãã°ããå°åãš
ããããšãè¿°ã¹ãããŠããããã®æ代ã¯ã€ã¿ãªã¢
åéšããäžéšã«ãããŠèªæ²»éœåžåœå®¶ãç¹å®ã®åºå
æ¯é æš©åã®äžã«çµ±åãããŠãããå°ååœå®¶åœ¢æã®
åæ段éã«ãããããŸãæ¬æžã§ã¯ãéœåžåœå®¶ãã
å°ååœå®¶ãžã®é ååç·šæã®å±éããåºåç秩åºã®
圢æã®éçšã§ãããšãšãããŠãããããã«ãã®è
å¯ã«ãããŠã¯ãè€æ°ã®éœåžã蟲æã«ååšããŠãã
å°åå ±åäœããããã¯åšå°å£äœã®éã®äºããšãã®
解決ããããŠå¹³åãšç§©åºã®åœ¢æãæ€èšãããçŽäº
è«çèŠç¹ãçšããããšã説æãããã
ç¶ã第 1ç« ãã³ã ãŒããšåºå秩åºãã§ã¯ãå°å
åœå®¶ãžãšç§»è¡ããå段éãšããŠãéœåžã³ã ãŒãæ
ã«çŠç¹ãããŠãããã³ãã«ãã£ã¢ã»ããšã¢ã³ãã«
ãããŠã®ã¡ã«æ¯é çäžå¿éœåžãšãªããã©ãããã
ã§ã«ãã®ææããåšèŸºå°åãç¹ã«ããšã¢ã³ãã®å ±
åäœéçŽäºã«ãããäžäœã®ä»²è£è ãšããŠããã®åœ±
é¿åãåšèŸºã³ã ãŒããžãšæ¡å€§ããŠãã£ããããã§
èè ã¯ã仲è£ãšããæ段ãããã©ãåŽããã®äžæ¹
çãªåœ±é¿åã®åŒ·åã»æ¡å€§ã®ãã£ãããšããŠã¿ãã
ãã§ã¯ãªããããšã¢ã³ãã®å°å瀟äŒã®å®æ ãšãã
ã«ãã£ãå¹³å圢æã®æ段ãèå¯ãããããããã
ãããèªäž»çãªç§©åºåµåºéçšã®å±éã®åž°çµãïŒ19
é ïŒãšããŠã¿ãèŠç¹ã®éèŠæ§ãææãããæ¬ç« ã§
㯠12äžçŽæ«ãã 13äžçŽååã«ãããŠã®ãã©ãéœ
åžæ¿åºã®å ¬çææžå²æéãããšã«ã仲è£è ãšããŠ
ä»å ¥ããåå®ã«ã€ããŠèå¯ãããããããã§ã¯äº
æ¡ã«äœããã®åœ¢ã§é¢äžããŠããéåœäºè ã®è«žå¢å
ãåå ããŠãããè€éãªå©å®³é¢ä¿ã®äžã§åæã圢
æãããŠããããŸãã2ã€ã®ããšã¢ã³ãéœåžã®å€
åéã«ãããå¯æ¥ãªååäœå¶ãèå¯ãããåå°å
å éšã®åå¥ã®éœåžéé¢ä¿ã®éèŠæ§ãæ瀺ãããã
ãã®ãããªæ çµã®ãªãã§ã®ä»²è£è£å®ãšã¯ãå®ã¯ã
ã©ããäžæ¹ã®åŽã«ç«ã¡ãå°åå éšã®å©çé¢ä¿ã«åŒ·
ãå¹²æžãããŸãæ絶ããçžææ¹ãšã®æŠéç¶ç¶ãæ£
åœåããããã®ãäžçš®ã®éå ·ãšããŠå©çšãããã
ãšãæãããšãªãããŸãæ¬ç« ã®æåŸã®ç¯ã¯éœåžé
é¢ä¿ã®ã¯ããŸã«ãã£ã蟲æéšã®èå¯ã«ããŠããã
éœåžãåºç€ãšãã仲è£å¶åºŠã«å¯ŸããåŸãããšãæ
åŠããåšå°å ±åäœã®å®æ ãæããŠããã
ã§ã¯ãéœåžé仲è£å¶åºŠãæ©èœããªãã£ã蟲æéš
ã®ç€ŸäŒã«ããã秩åºåœ¢æã¯ãããªã圢ã§ãããªã
ããã®ãã第 2ç« ããæºéœåžãå ±åäœã®åœ¢æãšçº
å±ãã§ã¯ãåç« æ«ã«ãŠæ瀺ãããåé¡ã«å¯ŸããèŠ
æš¡ã人å£ãäžå¿å°æ©èœãããæºéœåžããšãã°ãã
ãããªèªæ²»ç蟲æéèœã«ã¶ãŒã¬ã®ãåœäºè ãšãªã£
ãçŽäºã®å ·äœäŸãæ€èšãããå ±åäœççºå±ãšé¢é£
ã¥ããªããèå¯ããããã«ã¶ãŒã¬ã¯ 12äžçŽæ«ã«
ã¯ãã§ã«èªæ²»ã確ç«ãã14äžçŽåŸåã«ããããŸ
ã§ä¿æããŠãããèè ã¯ãã®ãã¡ãå ±åäœãèªæ²»
ãçºå±ãããŠãã 13äžçŽã«ã€ããŠãæ¡äŸéãã
130 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
ãšã«ãã®å éšçµç¹ã®å®æ ãæããã«ãããããã§
ã¯ã«ã¶ãŒã¬ããå€éšããæãå ¥ããããã¹ã¿ãåœ
å±ã®çµ±å¶äžã«ãããç¬èªã®å眰èŠå®ããã¡ããŸã
è¿é£å ±åäœãšã®å€ç亀æžããããªãèœåãä¿æã
ããå å€åæ¹ã«å¯ŸããŠã®ç§©åºã圢æãç¶æããäž»
äœã§ãã£ãããšãæãããã次ã«ãã®çºå±ã®å¥æ©
ãšãªã£ãåæ§ã®éèœãšã®å䜵ããµãŸããããã«å
ç«ã€ææã®äž¡éèœéã®çŽäºãèå¯ãããããã®çŽ
äºã¯åæ¹ã®éèœã«ãã£ãæåºæäŒã®æš©éäºãã«ç«¯
ãçºããŠããããäžä¿ã®äœæ°ãã¡ãæäŒãäžå¿ã«
ããé£äººå£äœãšããŠçµéããã³ã ãŒããšããŠçŽäº
ã®äž»äœãæ ãããã«ãªããäžæ¹ã§èè ã¯ãäž¡éèœ
å éšã§ã¯å 掟äºãããã®å æŠãèµ·ãã£ãŠãããã
ã®å 掟ãå®ã¯ãµãã€ã®éèœã«ãŸããã£ãŠé£çµããŠ
ãããã®ã§ãããšèª¬æããããããã人ç亀æµã¯
è¿é£éèœã«ãæé ãæã¡ãå 掟ã«åãããŠéèœé
ã®çŽäºãäž»å°ããåšå°ã®å°è²Žæå±€ã«ãããã®ã§
ãã£ããã«ã¶ãŒã¬ã®çŽäºã®äŸã¯ããããã瀟äŒé
å±€ã®åœ¢æãšãã芳ç¹ããã®ãå ±åäœãšçŽäºãšã®é¢
ä¿ãæ瀺ããŠããã
第 3ç« ã代å®ãšä»£å®åºãã§ã¯ããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£
家ã«ããåºåæ¯é åïŒããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£åœå®¶ãïŒ91
é ïŒïŒã®åœ¢æã«ãããåæ段éããç¹ã«ãã«ã¬ã¢
ãäžå¿ãšããæžè°·éšã»èŸ²æéšã察象ãšããŠèå¯ã
ããããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£åœå®¶ã®ä»£å®ã®æŽ»åãšãã°ã§
ã«ãã£ãšã®ãããªãŒãã®å 掟æäºã軞ãšããåšå°
éå£ãšã®é¢ä¿ãæ€èšããã代å®åºã®å®æ ãæãã
ã«ãããããŸã 14äžçŽåŸåã«äœæããã 3ç·šã®
代å®åºã®æ¡äŸéãæ€èšãããèè ã¯ä»£å®ã®è·åã®
å ·äœçå 容ã¯å ±éããŠããäžæ¹ã§ã代å®ã®åšå°ç€Ÿ
äŒã«ãããæ矩ä»ããç°ãªã£ãŠããç¹ãææãã
ãã®ææã®ä»£å®åºå¶åºŠãåšå°ç€ŸäŒã®çŸå®ã«å·Šå³ã
ããæµåçãªãã®ã§ãã£ããšããŠããã次ã«èè
ã¯ããã«ã¬ã¢ã®åœ¹äººãšã®éã§äº€ããããæžç°¡éã
å²æãšããŠçšããåšå°ç€ŸäŒã«ãããå ·äœçãªä»£å®
ã®æŽ»åãèå¯ããã代å®ãã¡ã¯åœå®¶ãã城çšãªã©
ã®è²¡æ¿çæ©èœãæåŸ ããŠæŽŸé£ãããããçµæãã
åšå°äœæ°ã®åã§ã¯ç¡åã§ãã£ããäžæ¹ã§ãåšå°ç€Ÿ
äŒã«ãããå 掟äºãã«ãããŠã¯ãã°ã§ã«ãã£ãã
ã¯æµãšããŠãã®ãããªãŒãããã¯ãã®èåŸã«ãã
åœå®¶æš©åã®äœçŸè ãšããŠãããããã¿ãªãããŠã
ãããã®æ代ã®ä»£å®ã¯ãå°ååœå®¶ã«ããæ¯é ãšåš
å°ç€ŸäŒã®æ¿æ²»æ å¢ã®æ¥ç¹ã«äœçœ®ã¥ããããŠããã
çŸå°ã®çŽäºã«ãããŠãäž¡å 掟é£å¶ã®è¡åãæ£åœå
ããã²ãšã€ã®åè·¯ãšãªã£ãŠããããšããããã
第 4ç« ãå 掟ãšãã¯ãå 掟ãã§ã¯åå°åã®å 掟
ã®å®æ ããåšå°ç€ŸäŒã®å©å®³é¢ä¿ã«çµã³ã€ãããã®
å€åãåæ ãã€ã€ãããåºãç¯å²ã§ã¯å°ååœå®¶ã
ãããè¶ ããåœéé¢ä¿ã®ãªãã§ããããã«çµåã
ããã®ãšããŠãåæ çã«èå¯ããŠããããŸããè
è ã¯ããããå°åçå 掟ãšãã®æäºã®æµåçãªå®
æ ããä»å°åã®é éŠåœ¢ææã«ããããã§ãŒããšäºº
ççµåé¢ä¿ã«å¯Ÿããæ¯èŒäŸãæ瀺ãããã®ãšãã
ãŠãããæ¬ç« ã§ã¯ãã«ã¬ã¢ã®å 掟æäºãèšè¿°ããã
14äžçŽåŸåãã 15äžçŽåé ã®å¹Žä»£èšãããããª
å²æãšããŠçšããããŠãããããã§æãããçŽäº
ã¯ãåšå°å°éå£ïŒå°åçå 掟ã«å¯Ÿããããã¯ãå 掟ã
ïŒ142é ïŒïŒã«ããå±æçãªãã®ãšã倧éœåžè²Žæã«
ãã£ãŠããããå°éå£ãåå¡ãããããã倧èŠæš¡
ãªãã®ãšã® 2çš®é¡ã«å€§å¥ããããããããéœåžã®
åäž»å°ç貎æã¯é éã®å±±å²³éšã®ãã¯ãå 掟ãçµ±äž
çã«ææ¡ããŠãããã家çã®æŸç§ã軞ãšããçµæž
掻åãèæ¯ãšãããå 掟ããšã®äººççµåã®ç¶²ã®ç®
ãéœåžé åå éšã«åºç¯ã«åºãã£ãŠããããã¯ãå
掟ã¯èªçºçã«çŽäºãæ¡å€§ãããããšããã£ããã
ã®ç¶æ³äžã§ãçµæžæŽ»åãšããŠã®äž¡å 掟éã®ç¥å¥ªè¡
çºãçŽäºã«ç¹ããäžæ¹ã§ãããããã®è³ç£ã®ä¿è·
ãéããŠååäœå¶ã確ç«ãã秩åºã®åœ¢æãšç¶æã®
æ©èœãå 掟ãæ ãããšã«ããªã£ãããŸãèè ã¯ã
å 掟ãè¶ è¶ããåšå°éå£ã«ããããã¡ã©å±±ã®å¹³åã
ãšãã 1399幎ã®äºäŸãæ€èšããåçŽãªäºé 察ç«
çå 掟æäºãšããå³åŒã§ã¯æããããªãå®æ ãæ
æãããããããå®æ ã«å¯Ÿå¿ãããããå 掟ã¯éœ
åžã®äž»å°å±€ãšãã¯ãå 掟㮠2ã€ã®æ°Žæºã§ãå éšã®
å¹³å圢æãšç¶æã®æ©èœãé«ããŠãããç¹ã«åšå°ç€Ÿ
äŒã«ããããã¯ãå 掟ã®å°åççµæã匷åããã
ããšãšãªãã
第 5ç« ãåšå°çå 掟ãšå°å圢æãã§ã¯ãããã
ãå°åãšå 掟ã®é¢ä¿ã®å®æ ãããã«ã¬ã¢é åå ã®
æºéœåžã¢ã«ã¡ã³ããšãã®åšèŸºã®ã€ããŒãã£æžè°·å°
åã察象ãšããŠãå ¬èšŒäººææžãçšãããããã¯ã
ãªèŠç¹ããèå¯ããããã¢ã«ã¡ã³ã㯠13äžçŽã
131æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
éããŠã³ã ãŒããšããŠã®èªæ²»ã確ç«ããæºéœåžãš
ããŠã®å°äœããã«ã¬ã¢ããèªããããããã®èªå¯
ã®èæ¯ã«ã¯ãåšèŸºéèœã®ç¬ç«ãšããã«ããæåºæ
äŒæé ã®è¡°éããŸããã«ã¬ã¢ã«ããé åç·šæã®ç¢º
ç«ã®æå³ããã£ãããã®çµæå°åã¯çŽ°ååããã
ãã®çŽ°ååãããè«žå°åã«ãåå°ã®ææãçµæžæŽ»
åãžã®åå ãšãã圢ã§ãéœåžäœæ°ãåå ¥ããŠãã
ã®ã§ããããã®å°åäžåž¯ã¯ã®ãããªãŒããšããŠå
掟ççµåãä¿æããŠãããæžè°·å°åã«åºãæé ã
ãã€å®¶ç³»ãã¢ã«ã¡ã³ãã«åºç€ããã€æå家系ãã
å 掟ãäž»å°ãããã«ã¬ã¢è²Žæ家系ãšãšãã«ãå°å
ã®æ¯ç¹ç©ç£æ¥ãžã®è³æ¬æäžãäžå¿ã«åŒ·åºãªäººççµ
åé¢ä¿ãç¶æããŠãããããããªãããå 掟ã®ãª
ãã«ã°ã§ã«ãã£ãšãé¢ä¿ããã€å®¶ç³»ãåºçŸãããŸ
ãæ¯ç¹ç©ç£æ¥ã®çºå±ããåšå°ã«ãããå 掟çã«ã¯
äžç«ãªäžè«ãæ¥è ã®æé·ããããããããšã«ãã£
ãŠããã¯ãåç« ã§ã¿ããããªãå°åççµåã«ãã
å 掟ççµåã®çžå¯Ÿåããããããšãšãªãã
æåŸã«çµç« ã§ã¯ããŸãæ¬æžã®åç« ã®å 容ãå確
èªããããèè ã¯æ¬æžã®çµè«ãšããŠããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³
ãã£åœå®¶å éšã§ã¯ãå°å瀟äŒã§ã®æåºæäŒã®ãã
ãªå€§æé ã®è§£äœãšãããã«ç¶ãé ååç·šãšå ±åäœ
ã®åŒ·åãããããç掻ã®å ŽãšããŠè«žå°åã®å®å®ç
ãªç·šæãæ±ããããç¹ããããŠé ååç·šã®éçšã§
ãå 掟ãåªä»ãšãã人ççµåã¯ç¶æãããåšå°ç€Ÿ
äŒã®å®å®ãã¯ããæ©èœãšçµæžæŽ»åã«ãããååäœ
å¶ã圢æãããç¹ããã®ãµãã€ã®åŸåãå ±åããŠ
ããããšã説æãããæ¬æžã§å±éããããããªã
ãã¯ãã®èŠç¹ããã®èå¯ã«ãã£ãŠãããããåã€
ã¿ãªã¢ã«ãããå€æ§ãªå°åè«žå¢åã®é¢ä¿ã«ããšã¥
ãåºå秩åºåœ¢æã®å®æ ããäžè¿äžãšãŒãããã«ã
ããŠã©ãäœçœ®ã¥ããããä»åŸã®æ¯èŒç 究ãåŸ ã¡ã
ããšããŠãæ¬æžã¯ç· ããããããŠããã
ãŸãæ¬ç·šã®åŸã«ã¯ãéç« ãç 究å²æŠèŠ³ãéœåžã³
ã ãŒãããå°ååœå®¶ãžãã眮ãããŠãããéœåžåœ
家ããå°ååœå®¶ãžã®ç§»è¡ã«é¢ããç 究å²ãæŠèŠ³ã
ããŠãããããã§ã¯æ¬çš¿åé ã§è¿°ã¹ããããªãæ¥
æ¬ãšã€ã¿ãªã¢ã®äž¡åœã«ãããŠãã€ã¿ãªã¢ã®å°ååœ
家ãã©ããšãããããŠãããããšããç¹ãæ代ã
è¿œã£ãŠãŸãšããããŠãããããèªäœãéåžžã«åè
ã«ãªããšãšãã«ãæ¬æžã®åé¡æèãšç 究ææ³ãã
ãæ·±ãç解ããæå©ããšããªã£ãŠããã
以äžãæ¬æžã®å 容ã®æŠèŠ³ã§ãããæ¬æžãéèªã
ãŠãŸãæããããšã¯ãè°è«ã®å±éã®æ確ãã§ããã
æ¬æžã®äž»é¡ã§ãããå°ååœå®¶ã«ããåºå秩åºåœ¢æã
ã¯ãå éšã«ååšããè¡çºäž»äœãå€çš®å€æ§ã§ããã
ãšããããšãããã°é£è§£ãªèª¬æã«ãªã£ãå¯èœæ§ã
ãã£ãã ããããããæ¬æžã¯å°ååœå®¶ã®å身ã§ã
ãéœåžåœå®¶æãã段éçã«åè¿°ãéå§ããåç« ã«
ãããèå¯ã«ãã£ãŠæããã«ãªã£ãç¹ãšæ®ããã
åé¡ãç« æ«ã«è¿°ã¹ã次ã®çŠç¹ãæ確ã«ããããšã«
ãã£ãŠãè°è«ã®å±éãç解ããããããé æ ®ããª
ãããŠããããŸããç¹ã«èå¯å¯Ÿè±¡ãéœåžãã«ã¬ã¢
ã®é åã«ç§»ãã第 3ç« ãã第 5ç« ã«ãããŠã®å±é
ã¯ãã°ã§ã«ãã£ãšã®ãããªãŒãã®å 掟éé¢ä¿ãšã
ã®åšå°ç€ŸäŒã«ãããæ矩ãšåœ±é¿åã®å€é·ããé ã
è¿œã£ãŠå¯Ÿè±¡ãçµãããšã«ããæ確ã«ã€ã¡ãŒãžãã
ããšãã§ãããåœå®¶åŽã®äž»äœã§ãã代å®ãã¡ã®æ¥
åãå°é£ã«ããŠãããåšå°ç€ŸäŒã®å 掟éæäºãã
ãããã®å éšæ§æã¯æµåçã§ãããå°åå šäœã«åœ±
é¿åããã€å€§å 掟ãšåšå°ç€ŸäŒã«å¯æ¥ã«é¢ããå°å
掟ãšããäºå æ§é ãæã£ãŠãããšããå®æ ããã
ãŠãã®å®æ ã詳现ã«æ瀺ããå ·äœçäºäŸãããã
ã段éçãªèª¬æã«ãã£ãŠãèè ãäžäžåŸæã®å°å
åœå®¶ã®åœ¢æãšçºå±ãæ¯ããèŠçŽ ã§ãããšäž»åŒµã
ããäºãã«çžå¯Ÿåããã人çãªå 掟ççµåãšå°çž
çãªå°åççµåã®çžäºé¢ä¿ããå®åããšããªã£ãŠ
é®®ããã«æãåºãããŠããã
ãŸããã€ã¿ãªã¢äžäžå²äžã§ã¯éŠŽæã¿æ·±ãã°ã§ã«
ãã£ãšã®ãããªãŒããšããäž¡å 掟ã®é¢ä¿æ§ã«ã€ã
ãŠãèè ã¯éœåžåœå®¶ããå°ååœå®¶ãžã®ç§»è¡æã«ã
ããŠã¯ããã®å 掟å éšã®æ§æã®å®æ ã¯åçŽãªãç
åžæŽŸå¯Ÿæç掟ããšãããããªå³åŒã§ã¯ãªããåšå°
瀟äŒãéœåžã«ãããå±å°çãªæ å¢ãšã€ã¿ãªã¢å
島ããŸãããããšããŸããšãŒãããèŠæš¡ã®æ¿æ²»å
åãåæ ãããæµåçãã€åççãªãã®ã§ãã£ã
ãšææããããã®å 掟ççµåãããããããªãã
ããå°å°åïŒå°åïŒäžå¿éœåžïŒå°ååœå®¶ïŒåœéé¢
ä¿ãšããåæ°Žæºã®æ¿æ²»çäž»äœãæ¥åããæ©èœã
æã£ãŠãããšãã説æã«ã¯ãæ°é®®ãªé©ããèŠããã
ãŸãã第 4ç« ä»¥äžã§ç€ºãããããã«ãçµæžæŽ»åã®
é²å±ã«ãã£ãŠã人ççµåã匷åãããåæã«åšå°
132 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
瀟äŒã®çãå°åã«ããã確å®ãªå¹³åã®ä¿éãæ±ã
ãããããã«ãªããããå 掟ççµåã¯å°å°åã®çµ
åã«çžå¯Ÿåããããèè ã¯ãã®ç¶æ³ãã人ççµå
ãšå°çžççµåãææ©çã«çµåããªãããå°åã®å¹³
åãšç§©åºã®åœ¢æã«ããé©ãã圢ãžãšå€åããéçš
ãšãšãããããããããäž¡å 掟ãæäºãæšé²ãã
ã ãã§ã¯ãªããåšå°ç€ŸäŒã®ã¬ãã«ã§æ¬¡ç¬¬ã«ç§©åºç¶
æãæ ãããã«ãªãããšãã説æã泚ç®ãã¹ãã§
ãããã
äžæ¹ã§æ¬æžã«å¯ŸããŠãæµ åŠã®èº«ã§ã¯ããããç
åã«æããç¹ããµãã€æããŠããããããŸããåœ
家ãšåšå°ç€ŸäŒã®çžäºé¢ä¿ã®èª¬æã«æ¯èŒããŠããã®
ãã®ã®å ±åäœãç¹ã«éœåžå éšã«ããã秩åºåœ¢æãš
ç¶æã«ã€ããŠã®èª¬æã¯ãè¥å¹²åžèã§ããããã«èŠ
åããããç¹ã§ããããã®ç¹ã¯ãæ¬æžã®äž»çŒãå°
ååœå®¶ã«ããåºå秩åºã®åœ¢ææã«ãããããéœåž
ã®äžåã®äžå¿æ§ãïŒ95é ïŒãšããæ çµã§ã¯æãã
ããªããåšèŸºé åã®åšå°éå£ãšã®é¢ä¿æ§ã«çœ®ãã
ãŠãããããä»æ¹ããªãããšã§ãããšãèããã
ããããäŸãã°éœåžç€ŸäŒå éšã§ã®ç§©åºã®åœ¢æã«
ãšã£ãŠéèŠã§ãããã蚎èšãå眰ãªã©ã«ã€ããŠã®
èå¯ã¯å¯èœãªã®ããããããéœåžå éšã®ç§©åºåœ¢æ
ã«ã€ããŠããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£åœå®¶ã®æ¯é åã«çµã¿èŸŒ
ãŸããååŸã§å€åã¯ç¡ãã£ãã®ããã€ãŸããéœåž
ã³ã ãŒããäžäœæš©åãšããŠã®å°ååœå®¶ã«ããæ¯é
ããã©ã®ããã«åãå ¥ããã¿ãããã®ç€ŸäŒãé©å
åããŠãã£ãã®ãããã®éçšã«å¯Ÿããèè ã®èŠè§£
ããæ¬æžã®æèã®ãªãã§èªãã§ã¿ãããšåŒ·ãæã
ãã®ã§ãããããã«æããå°ååœå®¶ã®äžéšã«å±ã
ãéœåžã³ã ãŒãã«é¢ããèå¯ã¯ã第 1ç« ã第 2ç«
ãæ ã£ãŠãããšã¯ãããããŸãã第 3ç« ç¬¬ 2ç¯å
é ã«ãããŠããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£å®¶ã®æ¯é ãåãå ¥ã
ãéã®ããã«ã¬ã¢ã®ç¶æ³ãç°¡åã«èª¬æãããŠããã
ãã ããã¯ãåŸåéšã§å®æ ãæ瀺ãããå°åã«ã
ããäž»äœå¢åã®ã²ãšã€ã§ãããäžå¿éœåžã§ãã£ã
ãã«ã¬ã¢ã®å éšã®åæ çç¶æ³ããããã¯åœå®¶æš©å
ãšã®é¢ä¿æ§ã¯ãããªããã®ã§ãã£ãã®ãããã®è©³
现ã説æãããããšã§ããåœå®¶ãããéœåžãããåšèŸº
é åããšãã 3è ã«ããåºå秩åºã®æ®µéçãªãã
ããã¯é¡åçãªèŒªéãã3è éã®åè¡¡é¢ä¿ããã²
ãšã€ã®å°åãèå°ã«ããæããã«ãªã£ãã®ã§ã¯ãª
ãããšæãããã
ãŸããèè ã®ããå°ååœå®¶ãšããæ¯é 圢æ ãã
åºå秩åºã®åœ¢æã«å¯ŸããããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£å®¶ïŒã
ããã¯åœå®¶åœå±ïŒã®äž»äœæ§ã«ã€ããŠããããç©æ¥µ
çã«èª¬æããå¿ èŠããã£ãã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšæã
ããèè ã¯å è¡ç 究ãã²ããéœåžãã£ã¬ã³ãã§ã
äžå¿ãšããå°ååœå®¶ãšããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£åœå®¶ã®æ¯
èŒããïŒ93-94é ïŒã匷åãªäžå¿æ§ãæãããã£
ã¬ã³ãã§åœå®¶ãšå€å çæ§é ãç¶æãããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³
ãã£åœå®¶ããšããå¯Ÿç §çãªæ§è³ªã説æããŠããã
æ¯é äžã«ããéœåžãäžå¿ãšãã€ã€ãåšèŸºé åã«ã
ããå€æ§ãªåšå°è«žå¢åãåå¥ã«ææ¡ããŠããããš
ããç¹åŸŽã¯ãæ¬æžã«ãããŠæããã«ãªã£ãéãã§
ãããã§ã¯ãããããå€å çé åæ¯é æ§é ããšã
ã«è³ã£ããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£å®¶ã®ãæ¯é ã®è«çãšã¯ã
ããªããã®ã ã£ãã®ã ãããããŸããå€å çãã€
ããããã«ãŸãšãŸãã€ã€ãã£ãæ¯é é åããåäž»
æš©åã®äžã§å€å°ãªããšãå æ¬çã«æããæå³ã¯ç¡
ãã£ãã®ã ããããããªãã¡ããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£åœ
家ãå ¬çè«žæš©åã®ããšã©ã«ããŒæ§é ã«ãããŠäžäœ
ã«ç«ãšããšããéã«ããããªãè«çãçšããŠèªã
ãæ£åœåããã®ãïŒãããã¯ããããè«çãã®ã
ã®ãå±éãããªãã£ãã®ãïŒããšããç¹ããæ¬æžã«
ãããŠèª¬æãããŠãããšã¯ããé£ãããã«æãã
è©è ã¯ããŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£å®¶ããããã¯éœåžãã©ã
ãåŸã ã«æ¯é åãåºããŠãããªãã§ããã¯ããã®
æ¯é é åããããããªãããäžäœçãªãã®ãšããŠ
æèãã段éããã£ãã ãããšèããããããã
äžäœæš©ååŽã®ãããã°ãåœå®¶åããšã§ãããã¹ã
ã€ã¡ãŒãžã«å¯Ÿããåæ代人ãã¡ã®è°è«ã«ã€ããŠã
ãã®æç¡ãå«ããŠæ瀺ããããšã¯ãä»å°åã®è¿äž
çåœå®¶ã«æ¯ããŠããã®ãŽã£ã¹ã³ã³ãã£å®¶ã®åºåæ¯
é åããåœå®¶ããšããŠã©ãäœçœ®ã¥ãããããšãã
åé¡ãèããéã«éåžžã«åèã«ãªã£ãã§ãããã
以äžæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯ãæ¬æžã§å±éãããŠããè°è«ã®æŠ
èŠãšãããã«å¯Ÿããè©è ã®èŠè§£ãè¿°ã¹ããå 容ã®
äžæ£ç¢ºãŸãã¯äžç確ãªç¹ã¯ããã£ã±ãè©è ã®æµ åŠ
ãã«ç±æ¥ãããã®ã§ãããæ¬æžã®ææã¯å°åç 究
ãšãããã¯ããªèŠç¹ãããè¿äžçåºå秩åºåœ¢æãš
ãããã¯ããªåé¡ãæ±ã£ãç 究ãšããŠã倧ããè©
䟡ãããã¹ããã®ã§ãããäžäžæ«æã®ã€ã¿ãªã¢å°
133æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
ååœå®¶ãããããã¯çŽäºç 究ãå°éãšããæ¹ã ã
ã§ã¯ãªããããåºãç¯å²ã§ã®é¢å¿ããæ¬æžãæã«
åãããããšãé¡ããæ¬è«ã§ããå°ååœå®¶åœ¢æã®
éçšã®èå¯ãããã®ç 究ææ³ãéåžžã«åèã«ãªã
ããšã¯ããšãããããŸã ãè¡°éãããã£ãŠèªãã
ãããšã®å€ããåŸæ¥ã®è¿äžä»¥éã®ã€ã¿ãªã¢å²ã«å¯Ÿ
ããã€ã¡ãŒãžãèŠãè°è«ããæ¬æžã§ã¯å±éãããŠ
ãããå°åã«ãããåå¥ç 究ã®é²å±ã«ãã£ãŠã蟲
æéšã®èªç«æ§ãæãããšãªã£ãããŸãåŸæ¥ã®éœåž
ïŒèŸ²æã®äºé 察ç«ã®å³åŒãè¶ããè«žéœåžéã®é¢ä¿
ãçµã¶å°å°åãå 掟ççµåããåœå®¶ã«çµã³ã€ããŠ
èå¯ããããšã®éèŠæ§ããæ¹ããŠåãããŠãããã
ãŸããã§ãŒãç 究ãåªä»ã«ããŠãèè ã匷ãé¢å¿
ããããæ¥æ¬å²ã«ãããç 究ææãå€ãåŒçšã玹
ä»ãããŠãããæ¥æ¬äººç 究è ã西æŽå²ãç 究ãã
ããšã®æ矩ã«ã€ããŠãæ¹ããŠèããããã®ç€ºåã«
å¯ãã§ããç¹ãä»ããŠããããã
ïŒæ£®ãæ°å€ªïŒ
çæšä¿æèãè¿ä»£ãšãŒãããã®åœ¢æå人ãšåœå®¶ã®è¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã ã
åµå 瀟ã2012 幎 8 æåãåå å€ã256 é ã
2100 åïŒçšèŸŒïŒãISBN978-4-422-20336-2
äœæ ãè¿ä»£ã«ãããŠãšãŒãããã¯èªç¶ç°å¢ã®é¢
ã§åªããã¢ãžã¢ã«å¯ŸããŠçµæžçåªäœã«ãã€ããšã
ã§ããã®ãããã®ããŒãã¯ãé·å¹Žã«ãããè°è«ã
ããŠããã1970幎代ã«ã¯ããšããã¥ãšã«ã»ãŠã©ãŒ
ã©ãŒã¹ãã€ã³ã«ããå·¥æ¥åœã«ãã第äžæ¬¡ç£å茞åº
åœã®åŸå±åã«åºã¥ãè¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã è«ãããŸãã
è¿å¹Žã«ãããŠã¯ã欧米ã«ãããã°ããŒãã«ãã¹ã
ãªãŒã®å°é ã®äžãã±ãã¹ã»ãã¡ã©ã³ãã«ããã倧
åå²ãã話é¡ãšãªããæ§ã ãªèŠå ã«ããã倧åå²ã
ãæå±ãããããã«ãªã£ãããã®ãããªäžãæ¬æž
ã¯ããã®å€§ããªããŒãã«å¯ŸããŠããŠã©ãŒã©ãŒã¹ã
ã€ã³ã«ããè¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã è«ãšã¯ç°ãªãããå
人ãšåœå®¶ã®ç¹ããªãæ°ããªè¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã ãã
æ çµã¿ãšããŠããããŸã§ç 究察象ãšããŠã¯èŠéã
ãããŠããç¡åœ¢è²¡ãç¹ã«æ å ±ã«çç®ãããããŸã§
ãšã¯ç°ãªãèŠç¹ããã®ã倧åå²ããæèµ·ããŠããã
以äžãåç« ã®å 容ãç°¡åã«çŽ¹ä»ããŠããããã
åºç« ã§ã¯ãå šäœã®æŠç¥ã瀺ããããšãšãã«ãã倧
åå²ãè«ã«é¢ããŠã®èè ã®èŠè§£ã瀺ãããŠããã
èè ã¯ãã倧åå²ããã16äžçŽãã 19äžçŽã«ãããã
é·æéã®éçšãšããŠæããäºã€ã®æ®µéãèšå®ããŠ
ãããç¹ã«ããã®ç¬¬äžæ®µéãšããŠãè¿äžã«ããã
ã¢ã ã¹ãã«ãã ãäžå¿ãšããæ å ±æµéã·ã¹ãã ã®
æ§ç¯ãšããã«äŒŽãæ å ±ã®é察称æ§ã®å°ãªã瀟äŒã®
圢æãéèŠããŠããããã®ãããªå¶åºŠçåªäœã®ã
ãšã第äºæ®µéã«ãããç£æ¥é©åœãèµ·ãã£ãããã
ãšãŒãããã¯çµæžçåªäœã«ç«ã¡ãããšããŠããã
èè ã®æ瀺ããã倧åå²ãã¯ãæ å ±ãšããç¡åœ¢
財ã«æ³šç®ããªãããŠããç¹ãç¹åŸŽçã§ããããŸãã
次ã®ç¬¬ 1ç« ã§æ瀺ãããŠãããã®ãšæ¯èŒãããšã
ãã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãã€ã®ãªã¹ã«éããããããåºãç¯å²ã«
é©å¿ã§ãããšããç¹ãç¹åŸŽãšããŠããããããã
ãããèè ã®äž»åŒµããå¶åºŠçåªäœããååšããã®
ãã©ããã«ã€ããŠã¯ãã¢ãžã¢åŽã®ç 究ãéèŠãš
ãªã£ãŠããã§ãããã
第 1ç« ã§ã¯ãã倧åå²ãè«äºãšããŠã©ãŒã©ãŒã¹
ãã€ã³ã®è¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã è«ã®èå¯ãéããŠãæ¬
æžã®æ çµã¿ãšãªããå人ãšåœå®¶ã®ç¹ããªãè¿ä»£äž
çã·ã¹ãã ãã®ç 究å²äžã®äœçœ®ä»ããè¡ã£ãŠããã
èè ã¯ãåŸæ¥ã®è¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã è«ããåœå®¶éã®
é¢ä¿æ§ãã䞻暩åœå®¶ã®åœ¢æãèªãäžã§è©äŸ¡ããªã
ãããçµæžæŽ»åã®æ ãæããæ å ±ã»ååã®æµéã®
軜èŠãããã«è¿äžã«ç£æ¥è³æ¬äž»çŸ©ãé©çšããŠãã
ç¹ãåé¡ãšããŠææããŠããããã®åé¡ç¹ãè£å®
ããåŸæ¥ã®è¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã è«ãšã°ããŒãã«ãã¹
ããªãŒãé¢ä¿ã¥ãããã®ãšããŠãæ°ããªè¿ä»£äžç
ã·ã¹ãã è«ãäœçœ®ä»ããŠãããããã«ãã¹ãã£ãŒ
ãŽã³ã»ãããã¯ã®ãååé£éãã®æŠå¿µãåãäžãã
ååæµéãšæ¯é ïŒåŸå±é¢ä¿ãçµã³ä»ããããšã§ã
ãã®åŠ¥åœæ§ã匷調ããŠããã
èè ã®æå±ãããå人ãšåœå®¶ã®ç¹ããªãè¿ä»£äž
çã·ã¹ãã ãè«ã¯ãåŸæ¥ãåçŽãªæ¯é ïŒåŸå±é¢ä¿
ã ãã§èªãããŠããååœéã®é¢ä¿ããæµéã®æ¯é
ãšãã芳ç¹ã«çç®ããããšã§ãè£å®ããã ãã§ãª
ããè¿äžãšè¿ä»£ã®é£ç¶æ§ãå·§ã¿ã«ç€ºããŠããããŸ
ããã¢ãžã¢ã®çžå¯Ÿçèªç«æ§ãšã®é¢ä¿ã«ãããŠããšãŒ
134 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
ãããè«žåœã«ããæµéã®ææ¡ã¯ããããã«åãäž
ããããŠããããããã倧ããªæ çµã¿ã«ãããŠæ±ã£
ãŠããç¹ããéèŠã§ãããšæããããããããã
ã®ãããªååæµéã®å®äŸãæ€èšŒããã©ã®çšåºŠé©çš
å¯èœããšããããšãä»åŸã®èª²é¡ãšãªãã§ãããã
第 2ç« ã§ã¯ãè¿äžåæã«ãããå人ãããã¯ãŒ
ã¯ã®æ¡å€§ã«ã€ããŠè«ããããŠãããèè ã¯ãèªèº«
ã®è¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã ã®èµ·ç¹ãããã«ã®ãŒå²å®¶ã®ã
ãªã¥ã¬ãæå±ãããã¢ã³ããŠã§ã«ãã³å人ã®ãã£
ã¢ã¹ãã©ãã«æ±ãããã®å人ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®æ¡å€§
éçšãããè¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã ã®æ¡å€§éçšã§ãããš
䞻匵ããŠããããã®ãã£ã¢ã¹ãã©ãéããŠãå
æ¥ã»éèã®äžå¿éœåžã§ãã£ãã¢ã³ããŠã§ã«ãã³ã
ããåæ¥æ å ±ãæè¡ããåæ¹ãšãŒãããã®äž»èŠéœ
åžã«ç§»è»¢ãããå質çãªåæ¥ç©ºéã圢æãããçµ
æãåå°åã®çµæžæé·ãä¿ããããšèè ã¯äž»åŒµã
ããç¹ã«ãã¢ã ã¹ãã«ãã ã¯ããã®å®æçå¯å®¹æ§
ãããç°æåé亀æã®äžå¿ãšãªãããã®äº€æãé
ããŠãããã«ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãæ¡å€§ãããããã«è
è ã¯ãã¢ã ã¹ãã«ãã ã®åžå Žã®æ§æ Œã®äžã€ãšããŠã
æ å ±ã®ã¹ããŒãã«ãšããŠã®æ§æ Œãåãäžããè¿äž
ã«ãããã¢ã ã¹ãã«ãã ãäžå¿ãšããæ å ±æµéã·
ã¹ãã ã®åœ¢æã«ãããšãŒãããçµæžã®æé·ã«å¯Ÿã
ãå¯äžã䞻匵ããŠããã
ãã®ç« ã«ããããã¢ã³ããŠã§ã«ãã³å人ã®ãã£
ã¢ã¹ãã©ã«ãããå質çåæ¥ç©ºéã®åœ¢æãšãåæ¹
ãšãŒãããã®çµæžæé·ã®çºå±ãšã®é¢ä¿ã¥ãã¯éèŠ
ã§ãããããããèè èªèº«ãææããŠããããšã§
ã¯ããããå欧ã«é¢ããŠã®èå¯ããåŸã®çµæžæ Œå·®
ãèããäžã§ãå¿ èŠãšãªã£ãŠããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã ã
ãããã¢ã ã¹ãã«ãã ã«ãããŠãç°æåé亀æã
ãããªãããŠãããšããç¹ããããŸãè¿äžã«ãã
ãŠã¹ãã€ã³ããã©ã³ãã«ãæ¯é ããŠãããšããç¹
ããããäŒæããŠããªãã£ããšã¯èãã«ãããä»
åŸãåæ¥ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®æ¡å€§ãšããã«äŒŽãåæ¥æ
è¡ã®æ®åéçšã®ãã詳现ãªç 究ããæ±ããããã
第 3ç« ã«ãããŠã¯ãæ å ±ã®ãããŒã«çç®ããã°ãŒ
ãã³ãã«ã¯é©åœã®çµæžå²çæ矩ãèå¯ããŠããã
åŸæ¥ã掻çå°å·ã®æ矩ã«ã€ããŠã¯ãæåçåŽé¢ã
匷調ãããŠããããããã掻çæè¡ã¯ãæ å ±äŒé
ã®ã¹ããŒãã®åäžã«ã¯å¯äžããªãã£ãããæ å ±ã®
äŒéæ§åŒãããå£é ããããæåãã«å€ãã£ãçµ
æãæ å ±ã®æ£ç¢ºæ§ãé«ãŸããååŒã«ããããªã¹ã¯
ã®äœæžã«å¯äžããããŸããå人ã®æåŒæžããåæ¥
æ°èã®å°å·ã容æã«ãªããåæ¥ã®ããã¥ã¢ã«åãš
å ±ã«ãæ å ±ã®é察称æ§ãæžå°ãããšããç¹ã匷調
ããŠãããèè ã¯ãåç« ã«ãããå人ãããã¯ãŒ
ã¯ã®æ¡å€§ãšããªã©ã³ããäžå¿ãšããæ å ±æµéã·ã¹
ãã ã®æ§ç¯ãšããããæ å ±é¢ã«ãããå¶åºŠçåªäœ
ããã¢ãžã¢ã«å¯ŸãããšãŒãããã®åªäœã«ã€ãªãã£
ããšäž»åŒµããŠãããããã«ããã®ãããªç€ŸäŒã圢
æãããããšã«ãããæ°ããªå人ã®åå ¥ã容æãš
ãªããã³ã¹ã¢ããªã¿ã³ãªå人ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã圢æ
ãããããã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®åœ¢æãã䞻暩åœå®¶æ
ç«ã®åæãšããŠäœçœ®ä»ããŠããã
èè ã¯ã第 1ç« ã§ãšããããããããã¯ã®ãå
åé£éããããã®ç« ã«ãããè°è«ãšçµã³ä»ããæ°
ãã«ãæ å ±é£éããšããæŠå¿µãæå±ããååæµé
ã«ãããæ å ±ã®ãããŒã®éèŠæ§ã ãã§ãªããæ圢
財ãšç¡åœ¢è²¡ã®çžäºäŸåé¢ä¿ã匷調ããŠããããã®
ãæ å ±é£éããšããæŠå¿µã¯ãä»åŸãæ å ±ãç 究察
象ãšããŠããããã§éèŠã«ãªã£ãŠããã ãããã
ããããã®æŠå¿µã«ãããæ å ±ãç 究察象ãšããŠå
ãäžããé£ãããè¡šããŠããããã«æããããæ
圢財ã«é¢ããŠã¯ããã§ã«ç ç³ãã³ãŒããŒã®ããã«ã
ãã®å·¥çšã«ãããé¢ä¿æ§ã«ãã£ãŠãåœå®¶éã®é¢ä¿
ãæãããšãã§ãããããããè¿äžã«ãããæ å ±
ã®äŒéã®éçšã«ãããŠããã®ãããªé¢ä¿ãæµ®ãã³
äžããã®ããšããçåãæ±ããããããªãã
第 4ç« ã§ã¯ã䞻暩åœå®¶ã®åœ¢æãšå人ã®é¢ä¿ã«ã€
ããŠåãæ±ãããŠãããè¿å¹Žã®ã財æ¿ïŒè»äºåœå®¶ã
è«ã®çºå±ä»¥éãåœå®¶ã®æŠè²»èª¿éèœåãéèŠèŠããã
åœå®¶è²¡æ¿å²ããã®ã¢ãããŒããé²ãã§ãããæ¬ç«
ã«ãããŠã¯ããããªãã¯ïŒãªãã©ã€ãšã³ã«ããè±
ä»è²¡æ¿æ¯èŒãããšã«ãã€ã®ãªã¹ã®ç¹ç°æ§ã匷調ã
ãããç¹ã«ããäŸå€çãªã€ã®ãªã¹ããšãã°ããæ¿
åºèŠæš¡ã®è¥å€§åã«ãã£ãŠãå ¬å ±è²¡ã®æäŸãåžå Žã®
ä¿è·ãšãã£ãåœå®¶ã«ããçµæžãžã®ä»å ¥ãç©æ¥µçã«
è¡ãããããšããçµæžæé·ãä¿ããç£æ¥é©åœã®å
æãšãªã£ããšäž»åŒµããŠããã
ãŸãã䞻暩åœå®¶ã®åœ¢æã«ã¯ãæµ·å€ããã®åé
ãäžå¯æ¬ ã§ããããã®ããã«ã¯è³æ¬ã®ç§»åãæ
135æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
ãåœé貿æå人ã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãå¿ èŠã§ãã£ãã
èè ã¯ããã®ç¹ãããè¿äžããåœå¢ã®ãªãå人
ã®äžçãšåœå¢ã圢æãããåœå®¶ããéå±€çã«å
åšããäžçãšããŠäœçœ®ä»ããŠããããããŠãè¿
代ãžã®ç§»è¡ã®éçšã«ãããŠããšãŒãããè«žåœã¯ã
å人ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãªã©ã®åœå¢ãè¶ãã瀟äŒççµ
åãåœå®¶ã®ã·ã¹ãã ã®äžéšã«åãå ¥ããåžåœã
圢æããã®ã§ããã
æ¬ç« 以éã«ãããŠã¯ãæ確ã«æ å ±ã«é¢ããŠåã
äžããããŠã¯ããªããã®ã®ãèè ãéèŠèŠããŠã
ã䞻暩åœå®¶ãšåœé貿æå人ã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®é¢ä¿
ã¯ãåœå®¶ãžã®è²žä»ãšããç¹ã ãã§ã¯ãªãããã®è²ž
ä»ã®åæãšããŠã®ä¿¡çšãšããé¢ã«ãããŠãæ å ±ã
éèŠãšãªã£ãŠããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã ãããããŸããæ¬
ç« ã«ãããŠç€ºãããããã«ãåœæã®åœå®¶ã¯ã財æ¿
é£ã®ãããåµåäžå±¥è¡ã床ã ç¹°ãè¿ããŠãããã¹
ãã€ã³ã®å Žåã«ã¯ããžã§ããŽã¡äººå人ã«å€å€§ãªè¢«
害ããããããŠãããããããããã®ãããªäºæ
ãåé¿ããããã«ãåœå®¶ã®è²¡æ¿ç¶æ³ã«é¢ããæ å ±
ãããããã¯ãŒã¯ãéããŠæµããŠãããšæãããã
ãã®ãããªèŠç¹ããã財æ¿ïŒè»äºåœå®¶ãè«ãšãæ
å ±ã®é¢ä¿ãã¿ãŠããããšããä»åŸã®èª²é¡ãšããŠé
èŠã§ã¯ãªãã ãããã
第 5ç« ã§ã¯ããšãŒãããè«žåœã«ãã倧西æŽçµæž
ã®åœ¢æãšæ¡å€§ã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠãããŠãããèè ã¯ã
ååœã®è²¿æã瀺ãäžã§ãåœå®¶ã«ããèŠå¶è²¿æãšã
ãç¹ã«ãããŠå ±éæ§ãèŠåºããŠããããã®ããã
ãªãã€ã®ãªã¹ã ãããæ©æã«ç£æ¥é©åœã«æåãã
ã®ããšããåé¡ã«å¯ŸããŠãæ¬åœãšæ€æ°å°ã®é¢ä¿ã®
èŠç¹ããèå¯ãè¡ã£ãŠããããããããæ€æ°å°ç©
ç£ããä»åœã«ãããŠã¯ããã³ãã«ã¯ãªã©ãžå茞åº
ãããã®ã«å¯ŸããŠãã€ã®ãªã¹ã¯ããã®å€§éšåãæ¬
åœã§æ¶è²»ããåŸåã«ãã£ããšããç¹ã«æ³šç®ããæ¬
åœãšæ€æ°å°ã®é¢ä¿ãä»åœã«æ¯ã¹ã匷åºã§ãã£ããš
䞻匵ããŠããããŸãããšãŒãããå 貿æãå«ã貿
ææ§é ãæ¯èŒãããšãä»åœããèŠå¶è²¿æãšèªç±è²¿
æã䜵çšããŠããã®ã«å¯ŸããŠãã€ã®ãªã¹ã¯ãèªæµ·
æ³ã«ããããã®å€§éšåãèªåœè¹ã«ããè¡ã£ãŠããã
以äžãããèè ã¯ãã€ã®ãªã¹ã®ç¹ç°æ§ããèªåœã®
å©çã®ããã«æ©èœããåžåœãäœãäžãããšããç¹
ã«æ±ããŠããã
ãŸãåžåœé貿æã«ç®ã移ããšãã»ãã¡ã«ãã£ã
ãäžå¿ãšããå人ãããã¯ãŒã¯ããååœã®å€§è¥¿æŽ
åžåœãç¶æããããã§éèŠãªåœ¹å²ãæ ã£ãããšã
瀺ãããŠããããããã18äžçŽã«å ¥ããååœã
èŠå¶ã匷ããäžããããã®æŽ»åã¯æããããåœå®¶
ã«ãã管çãé²ããããã
è©è ã®ç 究äžã®é¢å¿ããæãé¢å¿ãæ±ããç« ã§
ãããååœã®è²¿æãç°¡æœã«ãŸãšããããŠããã倧
å€å匷ã«ãªã£ããèè ãã倧西æŽè²¿æã«ãããå ±
éæ§ãšããŠãããŠããèŠå¶è²¿æã«é¢ããŠã¯ãæ¬æž
ã§ãè¿°ã¹ãããŠããããã«ãåœå®¶ã®ããã¯ã¢ãã
ãå¿ èŠäžå¯æ¬ ã§ãã£ãããã®ãããè¿å¹Žã®ã¹ãã€
ã³å²ã«ãããŠã¯ãåœå®¶ã«ããèŠå¶ãã貿æéãå¶
éããã®ã§ã¯ãªããé·è·é¢è²¿æã«ãããååŒãªã¹
ã¯ã®è»œæžã«ãããŠéèŠã§ãã£ããšããã (1)ããã
ãããã®èŠå¶ã 18äžçŽã«åŒ·åãããããšã«ããã
å人ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãä»ããåžåœé貿æãæžå°ãã
ãšããããšã«é¢ããŠã¯ãçåãæ®ãããããã18
äžçŽäžè以éãã€ã®ãªã¹ã®ããªãŒããŒãã®ããã«ã
åžåœé貿æãäžéšåæ³åãããããšã«ãããæ°ã
ãªãããã¯ãŒã¯ã圢æããããšã£ãŠããã£ãã®ã§
ã¯ãªãã ããã (2)ã
第 6ç« ã§ã¯ããã©ã³ã¹é©åœæŠäºãããŠã£ãŒã³äœ
å¶ã®åŽ©å£ãŸã§ãçµæžå²ã®æèããè«ããŠãããè
è ã¯ããªãã€ã®ãªã¹ãããã¬ãªã³æŠäºåŸã«ãã²ã¢
ããŒãæ¡ãããšã«æåããã®ããšããåé¡ã«å¯Ÿã
ãŠããã³ãã³ãã¢ã ã¹ãã«ãã ããã³ãã«ã¯ã®é¢
ä¿ã®å€åã«åå ãæ±ããŠãããã¢ã ã¹ãã«ãã ãš
ãã³ãã«ã¯ã®äž¡éœåžãããã©ã³ã¹ã®å é ã«ããã
ãã®æ©èœãäžæçã«å€±ã£ãããšã«ããããã³ãã³
ãå°é ããããšã«ãªãããã以éããã³ãã³ãäž
å¿ãšããã€ã®ãªã¹åžåœã®ã·ã¹ãã ããäž¡éœåžã®ç©
æµã·ã¹ãã ãå æããŠãã£ãããŸããæŠæäžã«ã
ããŠãã€ã®ãªã¹ã¯æãå®å šãªæè³å ãšãªãããã®
è³éã«ãããã¯ã©ãŠãã£ã³ã°ã¢ãŠããåé¿ããç£
æ¥é©åœãå¯èœã«ãªã£ããšäž»åŒµããŠããã
ãŸãããŠã£ãŒã³äœå¶ã®çµæžçèŠç¹ããã®èå¯ã«
ãããŠã¯ããã®äœå¶ã®æå³ã«åããŠãååœãåœå®¶
äž»å°ã®ããšå·¥æ¥åãæšãé²ããããã«éæ²³ãéé
ã®å»ºèšãé²ãã çµæããšãŒãããã«ãããŠçµ±äžåž
å Žã®åœ¢æãä¿ãããããããã©ã³ã¹é©åœä»¥åã®ç¶
136 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
æ ãæ£çµ±ãšãããŠã£ãŒã³äœå¶ã®åŽ©å£ã«ã€ãªãã£ã
ãšèè ã¯äž»åŒµãããäžæ¹ãã©ãã³ã¢ã¡ãªã«ã§ã¯ã
ãšãŒããããšã®çŽæ¥è²¿æãæšé²ãããä»åœããã®
çŽæ¥æè³ã«ããçµæžçèªç«ããããã ããã®çµæã
ã€ããªã¢å島ãšã©ãã³ã¢ã¡ãªã«ã®çŽåž¯ã¯åŒ±ãŸãã
ç¬ç«éåãæãããšãããã
æ¬ç« ã«ããããã€ã®ãªã¹ã®ãã²ã¢ããŒåœå®¶åã«
é¢ããèè ã®èŠè§£ã¯ããã®èŠå ãã€ã®ãªã¹ãšå€§éž
åŽã®é¢ä¿ã®èŠç¹ããè«ããŠããç¹ãèå³æ·±ãããŸ
ããè¿äžããç¶ããäžéœåžã®é¢ä¿ãæŠäºã«ããå€
åãããã³ãã³ä»¥å€ã®äºéœåžããã€ã®ãªã¹åžåœã®
ãµãã·ã¹ãã ã«äœçœ®ä»ãããããšããç¹ã«é¢ããŠ
ã¯ãèªç±è²¿æåžåœäž»çŸ©è«ãšèŠªåæ§ãããã®ã§ã¯ãª
ãããšæãããããŸãçµæžå²ã®èŠç¹ããã®ãŠã£ãŒ
ã³äœå¶ã®èå¯ã¯ãåŸæ¥æ¿æ²»å²ã®èŠ³ç¹ããã®èå¯ã
äž»æµã§ãã£ããããååœã®å·¥æ¥åãšçµ±äžåžå Žã®åœ¢
æããäœå¶ã®åŽ©å£èŠå ãšãã䞻匵ã¯ãæ°é®®ã«æã
ããããäžæ¹ãã©ãã³ã¢ã¡ãªã«ã®ç¬ç«éåã«é¢ã
ãŠããã®åæãšããŠçµæžçèªç«ãååšããããšã«
ã¯åæãããããã®åŸåã¯ãŠã£ãŒã³äœå¶ä»¥åã®ã
ã©ã³ã¹é©åœæŠäºæã«ã¯ãã§ã«ååšããã®ã§ã¯ãªã
ããšæãããã1796幎ããã®ã€ã®ãªã¹ãšã¹ãã€
ã³éã®æŠäºã«ãããŠãã€ã®ãªã¹ã®æµ·äžå°éã«ãã£
ãŠãã¹ãã€ã³ãšã©ãã³ã¢ã¡ãªã«éã®è²¿æãæ¥éã«
è¡°éããäžæ¹ã§ãã€ã®ãªã¹é æ€æ°å°ãšã©ãã³ã¢ã¡
ãªã«éã®è²¿æéãå¢å ããŠãããšäž»åŒµããç 究ã
ååšããŠãã (3)ããã®ãããã©ãã³ã¢ã¡ãªã«ã®çµ
æžçèªç«ã«å¯ŸãããšãŒãããã®åœ±é¿ã¯ãä»åŸã®èª²
é¡ãšãªãã®ã§ã¯ãªãã ãããã
çµç« ã§ã¯ããããŸã§ã®ç·æ¬ãšãšãã«ã19äžçŽ
以éã«ãããæè¡é©æ°ãšã€ã®ãªã¹åžåœã·ã¹ãã ã®
圢æãåãæ±ã£ãŠãããæè¡é©æ°ã®äžã§ããç¹ã«
é»ä¿¡ã¯ãæ å ±äŒéã¹ããŒããšãæ å ±ã®æ£ç¢ºæ§ãå
äžããååŒãªã¹ã¯ãèããäœæžããããšããç¹ã«
ãããŠãçµæžçæ矩ããã€ããŸããéèé¢ã«ãã
ãŠãããã³ãã³ãäžå¿ãšããéæ¬äœå¶ã®æ®åãå€
è§æ±ºæžã·ã¹ãã ã®åœ¢æã«å€§ããªåœ¹å²ãæãããã
ãã®ãããªé»ä¿¡ã®æ®åã¯ãåŸã«æ¿åºäž»å°ã§æšãé²
ããããããã®ç¹ã«é¢ããŠãèè ã¯ãæ å ±æµéãã
è¿äžã®å人ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãåªä»ãšããæ¯èŒçèªç±
ãªãã®ãããåœå®¶ã®çµ±å¶ã«ãããããšããããšã
匷調ããããã®çµæãåæ¥æ å ±ã®äžå¿å°ã«å¯ŸããŠã
ä»å°åãåŸå±ãããæ°ããªæ¯é ïŒåŸå±é¢ä¿ãæ§ç¯
ããããšæšå®ããŠãããããã«ããã®è°è«ããžã§
ã³ãã«ãã³è³æ¬äž»çŸ©ãšçµã³ä»ããã€ã®ãªã¹ã¯ãäž
ççµæžã®æé·ããèªåœã®çµæžæé·ãšçµã³ä»ããã·
ã¹ãã ãæ§ç¯ããããšã§ãè«å€§ãªå©æœ€ãåŸãããš
ã«æåãããšäž»åŒµããŠããããã®ãããªã·ã¹ãã
ã圢æããããšã¯ã17äžçŽã®ãªã©ã³ãã«ã¯äžå¯
èœã§ã¯ãã£ããã®ã®ãã€ã®ãªã¹ã®çºå±ã«ã¯ããªã©
ã³ãã®ååšãéèŠãªäœçœ®ãå ãããšããè¿äžãšè¿
代ã®é£ç¶æ§ã«èšåããæ¬æžã¯çµã°ããŠããã
æ¬ç« ã«ãããŠã¯ãé»ä¿¡ãééã®æ·èšããæ¯é ïŒ
åŸå±é¢ä¿ãè«ããŠãããæ¬æžå šäœãéããé¢ä¿æ§
ã®åŒ·èª¿ãããã«ãããŠããªãããŠããããŸããžã§
ã³ãã«ãã³è³æ¬äž»çŸ©ãçŽæ¥æè³ã«ãŸã§é©çšããã€
ã®ãªã¹ã®åœå®¶ãšããŠã®æ§æ Œãç¹åŸŽã¥ããŠããç¹ã¯
éèŠã§ãããšæãããã
æ¬æžã«ç®ãéããŠç¬¬äžã«æããããšã¯ãæ¬æžã®
æ±ãæ代ãšå°åã®å¹ åºããšãæ±ãå 容ã®è±å¯ãã§
ãããããã«ããããããŸãšããããªãããæ°ã
ãªæ çµã¿ãäœããåæ§ç¯ãè¡ã£ãŠãããšããããš
ã«é¢ããŠã¯é©åããããããªããæ¬æžã¯ãèè ã®
䞻匵ãããå人ãšåœå®¶ã®ç¹ããªãæ°ããªè¿ä»£äžç
ã·ã¹ãã ãã®åœ¢æéçšã«æ²¿ã£ãŠæ§æãããŠããã
2ç« ãã 3ç« ã§æ瀺ãããæ å ±ã®é察称æ§ã®å°ãª
ã瀟äŒã®åœ¢æãåºç€ãšããŠã4ç« ãã 6ç« ã«ãã
ãŠã䞻暩åœå®¶ã®åœ¢æã倧西æŽçµæžã®æ§ç¯ãããã¬
ãªã³æŠäºä»¥éã®çµ±äžåžå Žã®åœ¢æãæãããŠããã
è¿äžã«ãããå人ã®äžçãšåœå®¶ã®äžçã®éå±€æ§ã
æ§æã®äžã§ã瀺ãããŠããããŸãåç« ã«ãããŠã¯ã
é¢é£ããè¿å¹Žã®æ¬§ç±³ã®ç 究ãç°¡æœã«ãŸãšããããŠ
ãããè¿äžã®çµæžå²ã®å ¥éæžãšããŠãé©ããŠãã
ã ããã
æ¬æžã®å 容ã«é¢ããŠãæãéèŠãªã®ã¯ç¡åœ¢è²¡ã
ç¹ã«æ å ±ãäžå¿ã«æ±ã£ãŠãããšããããšã§ããã
èè ã®æ瀺ããè¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã è«ãšããããæ
çµã¿ãšããã倧åå²ãè«ã¯ã第 1ç« ã§è¿°ã¹ãããŠ
ããè¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã è«ãšã°ããŒãã«ãã¹ããªãŒ
ãé¢ä¿ã¥ãããšããç¹ã ãã§ãªãããããŸã§èŠé
ããããã¡ã§ãã£ãç¡åœ¢è²¡ãšãå人ã®ãããã¯ãŒ
ã¯ãããããã¯ã®ãååé£éããåºãšãããæ å ±
137æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
é£éããšããæŠå¿µã§ç¹ãåãããŠããç¹ã¯éèŠã§
ããããŸããèè ã®äž»åŒµããæ°ããªè¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹
ãã è«ãšãŠã©ãŒã©ãŒã¹ãã€ã³ã®è¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã
è«ãšã®æ¥åã«é¢ããŠãçµç« ã«ãããŠæ瀺ãããåœ
家ã«ããæ å ±çµ±å¶ã«äŒŽããåæ¥æ å ±ã®äžå¿å°ãšä»
å°åãšã®æ¯é ïŒåŸå±é¢ä¿ã®åœ¢æã¯ãç£æ¥è³æ¬äž»çŸ©
ã«åºã¥ããŠã©ãŒã©ãŒã¹ãã€ã³ã®è¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã
è«ã§ã¯æŽã¿ã¥ããè¿äžããè¿ä»£ãžã®ç§»è¡ã®äžã€ãš
ããŠéèŠã§ã¯ãªãããšæãããã
次ã«ãæ¬æžã«å¯ŸããŠãç£æ«ãªããšã§ã¯ãããã
åé¡ç¹ã 2ç¹ã»ã©ãšããããŠã¿ããã
ã²ãšã€ã¯ã第 2ç« ãã 3ç« ã§åãäžããããæ
å ±ã«é¢ããéšåã§ã®ã¢ãžã¢ã®æ±ãã§ãããæ¬æžã®
倧ããªåé¡èšå®ãšããŠã¯ããªãè¿ä»£ãšãŒããããã
ã¢ãžã¢ã«å¯ŸããŠçµæžçã«åªäœã«ãã€ããšãã§ãã
ã®ããšããããšããããããã倧åå²ããåæãš
ããŠè°è«ã¯é²ãã§ããããã®ç¬¬äžæ®µéãšããŠãã
ãããŠããæ å ±ã®é察称æ§ã®å°ãªã瀟äŒã®åœ¢æã«
é¢ããéšåã«ãããŠããšãŒããããã©ã®ããã«ã
ãŠãã®ãããªç€ŸäŒã圢æããã®ããšããããšã«é¢
ããŠã¯ãäºç« ãå²ãèå¯ãè¡ãããŠããããããã
ãã®äžæ¹ã§ãæ¯èŒå¯Ÿè±¡ã§ããã¯ãã®ã¢ãžã¢ã«é¢ã
ãŠã¯ãç°¡æœã«ãã®ãããªãã®ã¯ãªãã£ããšåãæš
ãŠãããŠãããèè ã®åé¡èšå®ãããããšããã®
äž¡è ã®æ¯èŒãéèŠã§ã¯ãªãããšæããããæ¬æžã«
ãããŠãã©ãã³ã¢ã¡ãªã«ãªã©ã«å¯Ÿãããã¢ãžã¢ã®
èªç«æ§ã«ã¯è¥å¹²ãµããããŠãããããã®èªç«æ§ã«
ã¯ããã¡ããç¬èªã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãååšãããã
ããæ å ±ã®äº€æãªã©ãè¡ãããŠãããšèããã
ãããã®ããããã®ç¹ã«é¢ããŠããå°ãå ·äœçã«
æãäžããã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãã£ãããšæãããã
ãã 1ç¹ã¯ã倧西æŽè²¿æã«ãããæ å ±ã®éèŠæ§
ã«é¢ããŠã§ãããæ¬æžã§ã¯ãç¹ã«æ å ±ã®éèŠæ§ã
åç« ã§åŒ·èª¿ãããŠãããããããåžåœé貿æã«ã€
ããŠè§ŠããŠãããšããã§ãã»ãã¡ã«ãã£ã ãäžå¿
ãšãããããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ã€ããŠã¯è¿°ã¹ãããŠããã
ã®ã®ããã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯å ã«ãããæ å ±äŒéã«é¢
ããŠã®åè¿°ã¯äžååã§ããããã«æãããããšã
ãã®ãã倧西æŽè²¿æã®åœ¢æã«ãšã£ãŠãæã倧ããª
åé¡ã¯ããã®æ å ±äŒéã®é ããšãããã«äŒŽãäžæ£
確æ§ã§ãã£ããšããããŠããã確ãã«ããšãŒãã
ã倧éžåŽã«ãããŠã¯ãã¢ã ã¹ãã«ãã ãäžå¿ãšã
ãæ å ±æµéã·ã¹ãã ã¯ã§ããŠãããšããŠãããã
ãã»ãã¡ã«ãã£ã ã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãžã®èšåã ãã§ã
倧西æŽè²¿æã«ãŸã§æ¡å€§ããã«ã¯ç¡çãããããã«
æãããããã®ããã倧西æŽãæãã æ å ±ã®é£ã
åãã«ã€ããŠè§Šããå¿ èŠããã£ãã®ã§ã¯ãªãã ã
ããã
以äžãå šäœã俯ç°ã§ãããšã¯èšãé£ãããå 容
ã®çŽ¹ä»ãšãæ¹å€ãè¿°ã¹ãã
èè ã®æ瀺ããæ°ããªè¿ä»£äžçã·ã¹ãã ã¯ãã°
ããŒãã«ãã¹ããªãŒãšãŠã©ãŒã©ãŒã¹ãã€ã³ã®è¿ä»£
äžçã·ã¹ãã ãé¢ä¿ã¥ããè¿äžããè¿ä»£ã«ããã
ãŸã§ã®ãšãŒããããçµæžå²ã®èŠç¹ãããç¹ã«æµé
ãšæ å ±ã«çç®ããæããŠããããã®ãããªæ°ããª
æ çµã¿ãäœãåºãããšã¯å°é£ã§ã¯ããããæ¥æ¬ã«
ããã西æŽå²ã®æ矩ãåãããäžãå¿ èŠãšããã
ã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšæãããã
èš»
(1) Xabier Lamikiz, Trade and Trust in the Eighteenth-
Century Atlantic World: Spanish Merchants and their
Overseas Networks, Boydell Press, 2010; Jeremy Baskes,
Staying Afloat: Risk and Uncertainty in Spanish Atlantic
World Trade, 1760-1820, Stanford University Press,
2013.
(2) Adrian J. Pearce, British Trade With Spanish America,
1763-1808, Liverpool University Press, 2008.
(3) Ibid.
ïŒæŸææ ä¹ïŒ
äžå£åœ°ã»ç°ç䌞äžéç·šèããŠãŒã©ã·ã¢å°å倧åœã®æç¶ççµæžçºå±ã
ããã«ãŽã¡æžæ¿ã2013 幎 4 æåãA5 å€ã
x ïŒ 254 é ã4500 åïŒçšãISBN978-4-623-06617-9
ãå¯äžã®è¶ 倧åœãã¢ã¡ãªã«ã®ãäžæ¥µæ¯é ãã¯çµãã£
ãã®ã ããããè¿å¹Žã® BRICSã®å°é ãç®ã®åœã
ãã«ããŠãããšãããæããããåŸãªããäžåœã¯ã
ãã 30幎ã»ã©ã®éã«çå®ã«çµæžåãã€ããé«ã
138 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
çµæžæé·çãç¶æãã2010幎ã«ã¯æ¥æ¬ã® GDPã
è¿œãæããäžç第 2äœã®çµæžå€§åœãšãªã£ãããŸãã
ãã®çµæžæé·ãšäžŠè¡ããŠãè¿å¹Žã¯å€äº€ã§ããã®å
åšæãå¢ããŠãããä»åŸã®äžçæ å¢ãèããäžã§ã
ã¢ã¡ãªã«ã»ãšãŒãããã»æ¥æ¬ä»¥å€ã®åœãšããŠã¯äž
åœã ãã§ãªããã€ã³ãã®ãã¬ãŒã³ã¹ã«ã泚æãæ
ãå¿ èŠããããããç¥ãããŠããããã«ãã€ã³ã
ã¯ã€ã®ãªã¹ã®æ€æ°å°æ¯é äžã«ãããã€ã®ãªã¹åžåœ
ã®å©å®³ã®ããã«çµæžçã«æŸåãããäœãçµæžæé·
çãäœåãªããããé »çºãã飢é¥ã貧å°ã«èŠãã
ã§ããããããã1991幎ã®çµæžèªç±åæ¿çïŒNEPïŒ
以éãã€ã³ãã¯é«ãçµæžæé·çãç¶æããçå®ãª
çµæžæé·ãéæããŠããããã·ã¢ã¯ã以åã®ãœé£
ã®ãããªåœ±é¿åããããšã¯èšãé£ããã1990幎
代ã®å±æ©ããäœãšãè±ããåœå ã®è±å¯ãªå€©ç¶è³æºã
è»äºåãäžéšã®æ§ãœé£è«žåœãå«ãç·©ãããªå¢åå
ãæã€å€§åœãšããŠåŸ©æŽ»ãã€ã€ããããã®ããã«ã
æ°ããªè«žåœãå°é ããŠããçŸåšãåŸæ¥ã®ããã«ã¢
ã¡ãªã«ã»ãšãŒãããã»æ¥æ¬ã®åãã ããèŠãŠããŠ
ã¯ãä»åŸã®äžçæ å¢ãèªã¿è§£ãããšã¯ã§ããªãã
äžåœã»ã€ã³ãã»ãã·ã¢ã® 3åœãä»åŸãããã«çµæž
æé·ããŠãããåœéçãªåœ±é¿åãå¢ããŠããã®ãã
ãããšããå šãéã®çµæã«ãªãã®ãã«ãã£ãŠãä»
åŸã®äžçæ å¢ã¯å€§ããå€ãã£ãŠããã ããããã®
ããã«ããç§ãã¡ã¯å°é ããŠãããããè«žåœã®å
åã«æ³šæãæãå¿ èŠãããã
æ¬æžã¯ãäžåœã»ã€ã³ãã»ãã·ã¢ã® 3åœããã³ã
ã®ä»ã®å°å倧åœããäžçã«å¯ŸããŠã©ã®ãããªã€ã³
ãã¯ããäžããŠããã®ãããŸãéã«ãã©ã®ãããª
圱é¿ãåããŠããã®ããæããã«ããããã«ãã
ã¯ãçµæžã»åœééèãå¶åºŠèªç±åã»äŒæ¥ã·ã¹ãã ã
åŽåã»æ Œå·®ãè³æºã»ç°å¢ãšããåŽé¢ããæ€èšãã
ãããè«žåœãå°å倧åœãšããŠã®å°äœãç¶æã»çºå±
ã§ãããã®äžé·æçãªå±æãæããŠãããå°é ã
ãŠããè«žåœã®ä»åŸãèããäžã§æé©ã®æžãšèšãã
ã ããã
æ¬æžã®æ§æã¯ä»¥äžã®éãã§ããã
åºç« ããå°å倧åœæ¯èŒç 究ã®èŠåº§ãâŠç°ç䌞äžé
第â éšãå°å倧åœã®ãã¯ãçµæžåå
第 1ç« ãå€è²šæºåã®èç©ãšã°ããŒãã«ã»ã€ã³ãã©
ããããã³ã¹ããããããããããâŠç°ç䌞äžé
第 2ç« ãå·¥æ¥åââãã®äžæçè©äŸ¡ããâŠäžå£åœ°
第⠡éšãäžåœã»ã€ã³ãã»ãã·ã¢ã®å¶åºŠæ§ç¯
第 3ç« ã察å€éæŸã®æ¿çãšçµæ
ããããããããããããâŠéééäºã»äžžå·ç¥é
第 4ç« ãããžãã¹ç°å¢ãšè£œé æ¥äŒæ¥ã®ããã©ãŒã
ããããã³ã¹ããããããâŠå è€ç¯€å²ã»äœè€éåº
第⠢éšãäžåœã»ã€ã³ãã»ãã·ã¢ã®åŽåãšæ Œå·®
第 5ç« ãåŽååžå Žåé¡ãããããããâŠäœè€éåº
第 6ç« ãå°åçµæžæ Œå·®ããããããããâŠæéç
第⠣éšãå°å倧åœã«ããããšãã«ã®ãŒãšç°å¢
第 7ç« ãç³æ²¹åžå Žæ¿çãããâŠæ¬æçæŸã»çŽ°äºé·
第 8ç« ããšãã«ã®ãŒäŸçµŠããããããâŠå äºäŒžæµ©
第 9ç« ãæ°åå€ååé¡ãããããããâŠäºå±±åº·å
çµç« ããæç¶ççµæžçºå±ã®å¯èœæ§ãããâŠäžå£åœ°
以äžã®ããã«ãåç« ããšã«è«è ãç°ãªã£ãŠãã
ã®ã§ãåç« ã§ã¯äœãåé¡ãšããŠããã®ãããããŠ
ã©ã®ãããªçµè«ã«è³ã£ãã®ããããŸãã¯ç°¡åã«ãŸ
ãšããäžã§ãããããã«ã³ã¡ã³ããä»ããšããã
ãã¡ããšãããã
åºç« ã¯ãäžåœã»ã€ã³ãã»ãã·ã¢ïŒä»¥äžã3åœãšããïŒ
ãã¯ãããšãããŠãŒã©ã·ã¢ã®å°å倧åœãçºå±ã»å®
çã§ããæ¡ä»¶ã¯äœãªã®ãããããŠããã劚ããã
ããªäžå®èŠçŽ ã¯äœã§ããã®ããšããæ¬æžã®åé¡æ
èããŸãè¿°ã¹ããããã®åé¡ãæããã«ãããã
ã«ãå°å倧åœã®å ±éæ§ã«æ³šç®ããäžã§ã3åœãæ¯
èŒãããšããæ¹æ³ããšãããšã説æãããŠããã
第 1ç« ã§ã¯ã3åœããååœã§ã¡ã«ããºã ã¯ç°ãª
ããã®ã®ãå€è²šæºåãèç©ããããšã§ãã°ããŒã
ã«ã»ã€ã³ãã©ã³ã¹ã«å€§ããå¯äžãããŸããããšå
æã«ãã®ãããªå€è²šæºåã®å¢å ã¯ã3åœã®çµæžã«
ãšã£ãŠå€§ããªè² æ ã匷ãããã®ã§ãã£ãããšãè¿°
ã¹ãããŠããããããŠç°çã«ããã°ãä»åŸã®ã·ã
ãªãªãšããŠããããŸã§éãå é²åœãäž»å°ããŠãã
çµæžãšæ°èåœã«ãã£ãŠäž»å°ãããŠãããããŸã§ãš
éã£ãçµæžãèããããããæè¿ã¯åŸè ãžã®åŸå
ãèŠãããããšãææããŠããã第 2ç« ã§ã¯ãèª
ç±åæ¹é©è·¯ç·ãæ¡çšããã®ã«ãé¢ããããäžåœãš
ãã·ã¢ã®éã«ã¯ãªã倧ããªå¯Ÿæ¯ãçŸããã®ããã
ããŠãã®äžã§ã€ã³ãã¯ã©ã®ããã«äœçœ®ã¥ãããã
ã®ããšããåé¡ãæããã«ããŠãããäžå£ã®çµ
è«ã«ããã°ãäžåœã§ã¯ãä¿®æ£ã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ã¯ãã³
139æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
åãå·¥æ¥åãè¿œæ±ããã®ã«å¯ŸããŠããœé£ïŒãã·ã¢
ã¯ã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ã¯ãã³åå·¥æ¥åãæç¶çã«è¿œæ±ãã
ããæŸæ£ãããããããã«ã¢ãã«ã«ãã£ãŒåœå®¶ã
ãè±åŽã§ããªããŸãŸã®ç¶æ ã§ãããšãããã€ã³ã
ã«é¢ããŠã¯ãç¬èªã®ããã¹ãã»ã¢ãã³åãå·¥æ¥å
ãé²è¡ããŠãããšè¿°ã¹ãããŠããã第â éšãå°å
倧åœã®ãã¯ãçµæžååãã§ã¯ãå·¥æ¥åã«é¢ããŠã
ãªãã€ã³ãã§ã¯ç¬èªã®ããã¹ãã»ã¢ãã³åãã®å·¥
æ¥åãé²è¡ããã®ããšãããšãããçåã®ãŸãŸã§
ããããã€ã³ãã§ã¯ã蟲æ¥ããå·¥æ¥ãžã®åŽååã®
移転ã«ããå·¥æ¥åãšããè¿ä»£çµæžæé·ã®äžè¬çãª
åã¯èŠåºãããããã«ã€ã¹ã®è»¢æç¹ããã€ééã
ããå€ç¶ãšããªããã¡ã«ããµãŒãã¹æ¥ã倧ããªæ
å³ãæã€ãããªãã¹ãã»ã¢ãã³çæ æ³ãçŸåºããŠ
ãããïŒ43é ïŒãšããéãããã®ã€ã³ãã®å·¥æ¥çº
å±ã®çµè·¯ã¯ãããŸã§ã®äžçã§ã¯èŠãããªãã£ãã
ã®ã§ããããã®èŠå ã¯äœã§ããã®ããæ確ã«ãã
ããšã¯ãã€ã³ãã®å·¥æ¥åãèããäžã§æçãªããš
ã§ã¯ãªãã ãããã
第 3ç« ã§ã¯ã3åœã®å¯Ÿå€éæŸã®æ¿çãšãã®çµæ
ã«ã€ããŠãæ¯èŒãè¡ãããŠããããã®çµæãééã»
äžžå·ã¯æ¬¡ã®ãããªçµè«ã«è³ã£ãŠãããããªãã¡ã
茞åºç£æ¥ã®æ¯èãšå¹Œçšç£æ¥ã®ä¿è·ãåæã«éæ
ããæçµçã«ã¯é«ãéæŸåºŠãå®çŸããäžåœãšãç³
油以å€ã®èŒžåºç£æ¥ãè²æããããéé¢çšéå£ã足
ãåŒã£åŒµã£ãçµæãå®éã«ã¯ééçãªè²¿æäœå¶ã
圢æãããŠããŸã£ããã·ã¢ããããŠã€ã³ãã¯äž¡è
ã®äžéã«äœçœ®ãããšããããšã§ããã第 4ç« ã§ã¯ã
3åœã®ããžãã¹ç°å¢ã®éãããååœã®è£œé æ¥ã®çº
å±çµè·¯ã«äžãã圱é¿ãåæããäžã§ã補é æ¥ã®çº
å±ã®æç¶å¯èœæ§ã«ã€ããŠèå¯ããŠãããå è€ã»äœ
è€ã¯ã3åœã®ããžãã¹ç°å¢ã®è£œé æ¥ãžã®åœ±é¿ãèš
éåæã«ãã£ãŠæããã«ãããã®åæãã次ã®ã
ããªå°æ¥å±æãæããŠãããäžåœã®è£œé æ¥ã¯ãæ
è¡åãåäžãããªããåœé競äºåãé«ããŠããã®
ã§ãåŸã ã«é«ä»å 䟡å€åãã補é æ¥äŒæ¥ãè²ã£ãŠ
ãããšãããã€ã³ãã®è£œé æ¥ã¯æè¡åãå°ããã€
é«ããŠãããã€ã³ãã©ã®æªæŽåãªã©ããžãã¹é»å®³
èŠå ãåŸã ã«æ¹åãããŠããããšããã挞é²çã«
補é æ¥ã®ååšæã¯é«ãŸã£ãŠãããšãããæåŸã«ã
ã·ã¢ã®è£œé æ¥ã§ããããããžãã¹é»å®³èŠå ã®å€ã
ãæ¿åºã®å©æš©æ§é ã«æ ¹ãããŠãããæ¥éã«æ¹åã
ããããšã¯æåŸ ã§ããªãã®ã§ãå°æ¥å匷ãæé·ã
ãŠããããšã¯é£ããããšã®ããšã§ããã第⠡éšãäž
åœã»ã€ã³ãã»ãã·ã¢ã®å¶åºŠæ§ç¯ãã®ããžãã¹ç°å¢
ã®ç« ã§ç¹ã«æ°ã«ãªã£ãã®ãããã·ã¢ã®ããžãã¹é»
害èŠå ã® 1ã€ãšããŠãåŽåè ã®è³ªããæãã£ãŠã
ãããšã§ãããã€ãŸããèåçïŒãã·ã¢ã®èåç
㯠2009幎æç¹ã§ 99.6%ãã€ã³ãã®èåç㯠2006
幎æç¹ã§ 62.8%ïŒã 25æ³ä»¥äžã®åœæ°ã®å¹³åå°±åŠ
幎æ°ïŒ2009幎æç¹ã§ãã·ã¢ã¯ 9.8幎ãã€ã³ã㯠4.4
幎ïŒã«ãããŠããã€ã³ããå€§å¹ ã«äžåã£ãŠããã®
ã«ãé¢ããããããžãã¹é»å®³èŠå ã«é¢ããè©äŸ¡ã®
å¹³åå€ãã€ã³ããäžåã£ãŠããç¹ã§ããïŒãã·ã¢
㯠2.350ãã€ã³ã㯠0.943ïŒãããããç¹ãèæ ®ã«
ããããªãã°ããã·ã¢ã®è£œé æ¥ã®å°æ¥ã¯äºæ³ãã
ãŠããããããã£ãšæããã®ã§ãããšèãããã
ã®ã§ã¯ãªããã
第 5ç« ã§ã¯ãè³éæ Œå·®åé¡ãšéçšåé¡ãšãã 2
ã€ã®å€§ããªåé¡ãå®èšŒçã«ç 究ãã3åœã®åŽååž
å Žåé¡ãæ¯èŒããŠãããäœè€ã«ããã°ãäžåœã¯äœ
å°åŽååã®æ¯æžåé¡ãã€ã³ãã¯éå±€éäžåè¡¡åé¡ã
ãã·ã¢ã¯åŽååäžè¶³åé¡ãååœã®åé¡ãšããŠçŸã
ãŠããŠããã®ã§ãæç¶ççµæžçºå±ã®ããã«ã¯ã3
åœãšãããããåé¡ã解決ããããšãå¿ èŠã ãšã
ãŠããã第 6ç« ã§ã¯ã3åœã®åœå çµæžæ Œå·®ã®è¶šå¢
ãšãã®èŠå ãã人å£ãšç£æ¥ã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠãŠãæ¯èŒ
åæãããŠãããæéã¯ã3åœã®å°åçµæžæ Œå·®ã®
ã¡ã«ããºã ã¯å ±éããŠããããäž»èŠç£æ¥ãšå°åçµ
æžæ Œå·®ã»ç£æ¥éç©ã»äººå£éäžã®çšåºŠã¯ 3åœéã§ç°
ãªãããã®çžéã 3åœã®çµæžçºå±ã®åºææ§ãè¡šã
ãŠããããšã«ãçæããã¹ãã§ããããã®çžéã®
ããã«ãæç¶ççµæžçºå±ãç®æã 3åœãåãçµã
課é¡ãç°ãªããšçµè«ã¥ããŠããã第⠢éšãäžåœã»
ã€ã³ãã»ãã·ã¢ã®åŽåãšæ Œå·®ãã®åŽååžå Žåé¡ã®
ç« ã«ãããŠãå®æãè³éæ Œå·®ãçã¿åºã 1ã€ã®èŠ
å ãšãªã£ãŠããããšãå®èšŒãããã®ã¯ãæå€ãªçµ
æã§ãã£ããå®æã¯ããã«ããŠè³éæ Œå·®ã«åœ±é¿ã
äžããŠããã®ã ããããäœè€ãææããŠãããã
ã«ãæ€èšèª²é¡ã® 1ã€ã§ããããå®æãæãã圹å²
ã«ã€ããŠã®ç 究ãåŸ ã¡ããã
第 7ç« ã¯ããŠãŒã©ã·ã¢ã® 2倧ç³æ²¹ç£åºåœã§ãã
140 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
ãã·ã¢ãšãµãŠãžã¢ã©ãã¢ã®æŠç¥å±éããããŠåžå Ž
ãšããŠã®äžåœã»ã€ã³ããšã®ç³æ²¹ã»ã¬ã¹ãéããŠã®
é¢ä¿ãæããã«ãããŠãããæ¬æã»çŽ°äºã«ããã°ã
ã€ã³ãã«å¯Ÿãããã·ã¢ã»ãµãŠãžã¢ã©ãã¢ã®ç³æ²¹èŒž
åºã«é¢ãã姿å¢ã¯ãäž¡åœãšãè¯å¥œãªé¢ä¿ãç¶æã
ãããšããŠããã®ã«å¯ŸããŠãäžåœã«å¯Ÿããããã¯
äž¡åœã®éã§ç°ãªã£ãŠãããšãããããªãã¡ããµãŠ
ãžã¢ã©ãã¢ã¯ã巚倧åžå Žãã§ããäžåœã匷çã«æ
èããŠããã®ã«å¯ŸããŠããã·ã¢ã¯å®å šä¿éäžã®èŠ³
ç¹ããç³æ²¹ã®éžäžèŒžéãæãäžåœã®æ¿çã«å¯Ÿã
ãŠãæ éãªå§¿å¢ã厩ããŠããªããšããããšã§ããã
第 8ç« ã§ã¯ãäžåœãšã€ã³ãã®ãšãã«ã®ãŒäŸçµŠé¢ã«
ãããããã«ããã¯ã®æç¡ãšããã«å¯Ÿããäž¡åœã®
åãçµã¿ã«ã€ããŠãäž¡åœã®äž»èŠãšãã«ã®ãŒã§ãã
ç³çã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠãŠãè¿°ã¹ãããŠãããå äºã¯ã
äžåœã§ã¯ç³çäŸ¡æ Œã®åžå Žåãé²ãã ããšã§äŸçµŠäž
ã®ããã«ããã¯ã解æ¶ããããšã«æåããç³ç以
å€ã®ãšãã«ã®ãŒæºãžã®ç§»è¡ãé²ã¿ã€ã€ããããã€
ã³ãã§ã¯ç³çäŸ¡æ Œã人çºçã«äœããŸãŸæããããŠ
ããããã«ç³æ²¹ç£æ¥ã®æè³ãæ£èãããéå°äŸçµŠ
ã®ç¶æ ã§ããããšãã«ã®ãŒäŸçµŠãããã«ããã¯ãš
ãªã£ãŠããããšãæããã«ããã第 9ç« ã§ã¯ãæ°
åå€ååé¡ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãããŠãããäºå±±ã¯ãæ°
åå€ååé¡ããã³å¯Ÿçã«é¢ããåœé亀æžãžã®å¯Ÿå¿
㯠3åœã§ç°ãªã£ãŠãããããã®äžã§ãå ±éç¹ãèŠ
åºãããšãã§ãããšããããããŠãèŠåºãããšã®
ã§ããå ±éç¹ããã3åœãåœéçãªæ°åå€å察ç
ã«å¯ŸããŠç©æ¥µçãªå§¿å¢ããšãå¯èœæ§ãäœããšãã
ããšãææã§ãããããããªãæ°æž©ã®äžæã«ããã
3åœã«æªåœ±é¿ãåºãã°ãããã®åœãæå°ç圹å²ã«
転ããæ°ããªåœéçæ çµã¿ãæåŸ ã§ãããšãè¿°ã¹
ãŠããã第⠣éšãå°å倧åœã«ããããšãã«ã®ãŒãš
ç°å¢ãã§ã®ç³æ²¹åžå Žæ¿çã®ç« ã§ã¯ãä»åŸã®çµæžçº
å±ã«äžå¯æ¬ ãªãšãã«ã®ãŒã®å®å®çäŸçµŠã確ä¿ãã
ãäžåœã»ã€ã³ããšãåžå ŽèŠæš¡ã®å€§ããªäžåœã»ã€ã³
ããåžå ŽãšããŠç¢ºä¿ãããç³æ²¹èŒžåºåœãã·ã¢ã»ãµ
ãŠãžã¢ã©ãã¢ãšããåçŽãªå³åŒã§ã¯èªããªãããš
ãæ¹ããŠç¢ºèªãããŠãããå 容ã§ãã£ããäŸãã°ã
äžåœã¯ãšãã«ã®ãŒã調éããéã«ã¢ã¡ãªã«ã®ãã¬
ãŒã³ã¹ãèããŠéžäžèŒžéã«å·çãããããµãŠãžã¢
ã©ãã¢ã§ã¯äžåœãšã®çµæžé¢ä¿ãæ·±ããŠãã¢ã¡ãªã«
äŸåã®å®å šä¿éæ¿çãè±åŽããããšãããããŠã
ãããšããããšãã«ã®ãŒæ¿çãèªãéã«ã¯åœéæ¿
æ²»ã®èŠ³ç¹ããèããããšãå¿ èŠã§ããããšãåã
ãããã ãã¢ã¡ãªã«ã®ã·ã§ãŒã«ã¬ã¹ãããŸã å®çš
åãããŠããªãããæ¥æ¬ã®ã¡ã¿ã³ãã€ãã¬ãŒããª
ã©æ°ããªãšãã«ã®ãŒããçŸåšæ³šç®ããå§ããŠããã
ãããã¯ä»ããã«ããšãã«ã®ãŒåžå Žã«åœ±é¿ãäžã
ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããšèããããããä»åŸã®ååãäº
枬ããå Žåããã®ãããªæ°ããªãšãã«ã®ãŒã®ç»å Ž
ã¯ããšãã«ã®ãŒåžå Žã«ãããªã圱é¿ãäžããã®ãã
èããå¿ èŠãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã ãããã
çµç« ã§ã¯ããããŸã§ã®ç« ã®ãŸãšããšã3åœã®æ
ç¶ççµæžçºå±ã¯ä»åŸãå¯èœãªã®ããšããæ¬æžã®
ããŒãã«ã€ããŠã®çµè«ãè¿°ã¹ãããŠãããäžå£
ã¯ãäžåœã®èŒžåºäž»å°ã«ããæé·ãšå€è²šæºåèç©ã®
çµã¿åãããã€ã³ãã®å€è³å°å ¥ãšçµæžã®ãµãŒãã¹
åããããŠãã·ã¢ã®èŒžåºä»£éã®èç©ãšãããåèµ·
ããæ¶è²»ããŒã ã«ããæé·ãšãã 3åœããããã®
åŸæ¥ã®ããæ¹ã§ã¯ãæç¶ççµæžçºå±ã¯å°é£ã§ãã
ãšããããã®è§£æ±ºçãšããŠãæããããŠããã®ã
ãå éäž»å°åã®çºå±çµè·¯ãžã®è»¢æãïŒ246é ïŒã§ã
ããããããããžãã¹ç°å¢ã®æŽåãåœå åŽååžå Ž
ã®å¹çåãåœå å°åæ Œå·®ã®è§£æ¶ãªã©è§£æ±ºããªããŠ
ã¯ãªããªãåé¡ãå±±ç©ããŠããããšãè¿°ã¹ãããŠ
ããããŸããããäžã€ã®è§£æ±ºçãšããŠæããããŠ
ããã®ã¯ããå°å倧åœéã§ã®è²¿æååäœå¶ã®æ§ç¯ã
ïŒ247é ïŒã§ãããæè¿ã® 3åœã®çµæžé¢ä¿ã®åŒ·å
ããããäœããã®å¶åºŠçãªååäœå¶ããã§ããã
ãããšã¯éçŸå®çã§ã¯ãªããšããã
以äžã®ããã«æ¬æžã¯ããŠãŒã©ã·ã¢å°å倧åœã®æ
ç¶ççµæžçºå±ã«ã€ããŠæ§ã ãªæ¹åããæ€èšãããŠ
ããããšãç¹åŸŽã§ãããããã®ããŒããæ±ãäžã§
äžå¯æ¬ ãªãã¯ãçµæžååã¯ãã¡ããã®ããšããšã
ã«ã®ãŒäŸçµŠãæ°åå€ååé¡ãªã©ãããã¢ãããŒã
ãããŠãããæç¶ççµæžçºå±ãèããäžã§æ°ããª
èŠç¹ãæäŸããŠãããŠããããŸããæ¬æžã¯èšéå
æãè¡ãããŠãã第 4ç« ã第 5ç« ãã¯ãããšããŠã
åç« ã§å³ãè¡šãæ°å€ã䜿çšãããŠãããåç« ã®äž»
匵ãããåãããããããé æ ®ããªãããŠããã
以äžãæ¬æžã®å 容ãèžãŸããäžã§ã3åœã®å°æ¥å±
æã«ã€ããŠè©è ãªãã®èããè¿°ã¹ããã
141æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
ãŸãã3åœã®äžã§äžçªå è¡ããäžå®ãªã®ã¯ãã·
ã¢ã§ããããæ¬æžã§ããã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ã¯ãã³åå·¥æ¥
åãæã«ã¯è¿œæ±ãããããŸãããæã«ã¯æŸæ£ãã
ãããããšã«ãã£ãŠãäžåœãšéã£ãŠè£œé æ¥éšéã
çºå±ãããçµæžå šäœã掻æ§åãããæ³¢åå¹æãã
ãŸãæããªãç³æ²¹ã»ã¬ã¹ã®èŒžåºã«äŸåããã¢ãã«
ã«ãã£ãŒåœå®¶ãšãªã£ãŠããŸã£ãããšãçµæžçºå±ã®
åååãšãªããã補é æ¥ã®å°æ¥å±æã«ã€ããŠãã
ããžãã¹ç°å¢ã®é»å®³èŠå ã«é¢ããè©äŸ¡ã®å¹³åå€ã
äžåœã»ã€ã³ããšæ¯ã¹ãŠçžå¯Ÿçã«é«ãå€ã瀺ããŠã
ãããšãããçºå±ããèŠèŸŒã¿ãèãããšãæãã
ã«ãããŠããããã·ã¢ã®å°æ¥å±æã¯æ±ºããŠæãã
ãã®ãšã¯èšããªãããšãªããšããã·ã¢æ倧ã®åŒ·ã¿
ã§ãããšãã«ã®ãŒããä»åŸã®ãã·ã¢çµæžã®ååã
å·Šå³ãã 1ã€ã®ãã¡ã¯ã¿ãŒãšèãããããä»åŸã®
ãšãã«ã®ãŒéçºã«ã€ããŠã¯ãæ¢é±ã®é ããæè³äž
足ãšããåé¡ãããããŠãããã®ã®ãæè³äžè¶³ã®
äžå ã¯ãå®å®ååºéã®ããã¡ã§ç³æ²¹ã»ã¬ã¹äŒæ¥ã®
å©çã®å€§åãçšåãšããŠåžãäžããŠããããšã«æ±
ãããããã®ã§ããããšãã«ã®ãŒããã·ã¢çµæžã
æ¯ããŠããããšãèæ ®ãããšãããããæè³äžè¶³
ãæ¿åºãæŸã£ãŠãããšã¯èããããªã (1)ããããã
ãšãã«ã®ãŒéšéã«äŸåãããã·ã¢ã®çµæžäœå¶ã¯ã
ãšãã«ã®ãŒäŸ¡æ Œã®äžèœã«ãã£ãŠå€§ããªåœ±é¿ãåã
ããããå®å®çãªæç¶ççµæžçºå±ãéæããã®ã¯ã
é£ãããšèšããããããªãã
察ããŠãä»åŸãå®å®çãªçµæžçºå±ãäºæ³ããã
ã®ãäžåœã§ããããæ¬æžã§ã¯ãæ¹é©éå§ä»¥åŸãä¿®
æ£ã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ã¯ãã³åå·¥æ¥åãè¿œæ±ããããšã«
ãã£ãŠãäžçã®å·¥å Žããšãªãããšã«æåãããŸã
ä»åŸã®è£œé æ¥ã®æç¶çãªçºå±ã«ã€ããŠããäœè³é
ã§åªç§ãªåŽåè ã«äŸåããåªäœæ§ã¯äžé·æçã«ã¯
倱ãããŠããããæè¡åã®åäžãèŠãããããšã
ãåŸã ã«é«ä»å 䟡å€åãã補é æ¥äŒæ¥ãè²ã£ãŠã
ãããšãæããã«ãããããŸããäžåœã§ã¯æ¹é©é
å§ä»¥éãééãéè·¯ãæ²³å·ã空路ããã€ãã©ã€ã³
ãšãã£ãã€ã³ãã©éçºãæšé²ããã茞éèœåã倧
å¹ ã«äŒžã³ãåžå Žçµæžåã®çºå±ãæ¯ãã圹ç®ãæã
ããã2008幎以éããäžåœæ¿åºã¯å€§èŠæš¡ãªæ¯æ°
åºæ¿çãçºåãããã®å€§éšåãã€ã³ãã©å»ºèšã«æ
å ¥ããããªã©ãã€ã³ãã©å€§åœãžã®éãéé²ããŠã
ã (2)ãããããã€ã³ãã©ã®æŽåã¯ãããªãåæ¥æŽ»
åã®æŽ»çºåã«è²¢ç®ãããšæããããããããæžå¿µ
ææããªãããã§ã¯ãªãããã®æžå¿µææã® 1ã€ãš
ããŠèããããã®ã¯ã人å£æ§é ã§ãããäžåœã§ã¯
人å£å¢å ãæããããã«ãäžäººã£åæ¿çããè¡ã£
ãã®ã«å ããŠãçŸåšãé«éœ¢åãé²è¡ããŠãããåœ
é£ã®äºæž¬ã«ããã°ã2030幎ååŸãå¢ã«ããŠãé€
ã人å£ãšé€ããã人å£ã®æ¯çãé転ãããšããã
ããããæ¥éãªå°åé«éœ¢åã¯ããããŸã§äžåœã®çµ
æžæé·ãæ¯ããŠããåŽååã®æžå°ãšå¹Žéãå»çä¿
éºãšãã£ã瀟äŒä¿éºã®ç¶æãå°é£ã«ããåŽé¢ãæ
ããŠãã (3)ããã®åé¡ãäžåœã¯ã©ã®ããã«è§£æ±ºã
ãŠããã®ã ããããäžåœã®ä»åŸã«æ³šç®ãããã
æåŸã«ã€ã³ãã§ããããä»åŸãããªãçµæžçºå±
ãããå¯èœæ§ãé«ããšèãããããæ¬æžã§ããçµ
æžçºå±ã®çœåŒåãã補é æ¥éšéã«ãããŠã1990
幎代以éãæè¡åãå°ããã€é«ããŠããããšãã
ãµãŠãžã¢ã©ãã¢ãä»åŸãããªããšãã«ã®ãŒéèŠã®
䌞é·ãèŠèŸŒãŸããã€ã³ãããšãã«ã®ãŒã®èŒžåºåžå Ž
ãšããŠåŒ·çã«æèããŠããããšãæããã«ãã
ãããããã«å ããŠãã€ã³ãã®äººå£æ§æããŸãã
ä»åŸã®ãããªãçµæžçºå±ãæ¯ããäžã§æå©ãªæ¡ä»¶
ã§ãããšèãããããçŸåšãã€ã³ãã§ã¯è¥å¹Žã«ãª
ãã°ãªãã»ã©äººå£æ°ãå€ããé«éœ¢ã«ãªãã°ãªãã»
ã©äººå£æ°ãå°ãªããšããçæ³çãªäººå£æ§é ã«ãªã£
ãŠããã人å£ããŒãã¹ã®ã¡ãªãããååã«äº«åã§
ããã ããããŸããGDPã«å¯Ÿããæ¯çã 15ïŒ å
åŸã§æšç§»ããŠãã補é æ¥ã«ãããŠãã2011幎ã«
ã€ã³ãæ¿åºãæ¬æ Œçãªè£œé æ¥æ¯èæ¿çãåºæ¬æ¿èª
ããå°æ¥çã«æ¥å¢ãããšèããããåŽåå人å£ã
åžåããããã®è£œé æ¥ãè²æãããšåæã«ããã€
ãã¯æ©åšãåœå ã§çç£ã§ããããã«ãããšããç®
æšãç«ãŠããã (4)ããã ãããããªãçµæžçºå±ã®
ããã«ã¯ã解決ããªããã°ãªããªã課é¡ãããã
ãšããŸãäºå®ã§ããããã® 1ã€ããã€ã³ãã©ã®æª
æŽååé¡ã§ããããåŸã ã«æ¹åãããŠããŠãããš
ã¯ãããã€ã³ãã®ã€ã³ãã©ã¯ãŸã ãŸã ååãšã¯èš
ããããã®ããšãçµæžæé·ã®åŠšãã«ãªãããšãäº
æ³ãããŠãã (5)ããããã課é¡ã解決ã§ããã°ã
å°æ¥ãã€ã³ãã¯çŸåšã®äžåœã«åããšãå£ããªãçµ
æžå€§åœãšãªãããšãäºæ³ãããã
142 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
瀺ãããŠãããæ¬æžã«ãããŠãèè 㯠21äžçŽã«ãµ
ããããããŒãåžåœè¡°äº¡å²ãå¿åããŠãããææ¥
æ°èïŒ2013幎 6æ 16æ¥ä»ïŒãç®åãã«ããã§ã«è€
æ°ã®æ°èãªã©ã§ãæžè©ãçºè¡šãããŠããããŸãã¯
ç°¡åãªçŽ¹ä»ãè¡ã£ãåŸãå人çèŠè§£ãè¿°ã¹ããã
æ¬æžã¯åºç« ãçµç« ãé€ã 6ç« ãæç³»åé ã«æ§æ
ãããŠãããåºç« ãäºäžäžçŽã®ããŒã衰亡å²ãã§ã¯ã
ã®ãã³ã¯èšããŸã§ããªãã1990幎代以æ¥äž»æµãš
ãªã£ãŠãããå€ä»£æ«æãè«ãšãç°ãªãæŽå²åã®æ
瀺ã課é¡ãšããããããŒãã¯è¡°äº¡ãããå€ä»£ãšã
äžäžãšãç°ãªãç¬èªã®ãå€ä»£æ«æããšãªã£ããšã
ãããŒã¿ãŒã»ãã©ãŠã³ã«å§ãŸãè°è«ã§ã¯ç€ŸäŒãå®
æãéèŠãããããèè ã¯ãã¯ãæ¿æ²»çæ çµã¿ã
ããéèŠã§ãããšããããã ããåŸæ¥ã®ããã«åž
åœã®äžæ žã§ããå°äžæµ·é åããã§ã¯ãªããããªã
ã³å³¶ãã©ã€ã³å·ããããŠå·åšèŸºãªã©ã®èŸºå¢ããã®
èŠè§ã«æ°ãã解éã®äœå°ããããšè¿°ã¹ãããã
第 1ç« ã倧河ãšæ£®ã®ããŒãåžåœââ蟺å¢ããèŠ
ãäžçåžåœã®å®åââãã¯ãè¡°éã®å段éã§ãã
åžåœæçæãã倧河ãšæ£®ã®ã蟺å¢ããåæ§æãã
ãã®ã§ãããã«ãšãµã«ä»¥æ¥ã®èŸºå¢ç²åŸã®éçšãè¿°
ã¹ãããåŸããã®åŸã®åžåœæ¯é ã®æ§åŒãè¿°ã¹ãã
ããã©ã€ã³å·ããããŠå·ã®ãããªèªç¶åœå¢ããã
ãªã¢ãã¹ã®é·åããªã¡ã¹ã®ãããªé²å£ã¯ãåŸæ¥ã
確åºããè»äºå¢çç·ãšããŠæããããŠããããã
ããªããããã€ã¿ãã«ãŒã®ããŸãŒã³ãšããŠã®åœå¢ã
ãšããèãæ¹ã«åºã¥ããŠãåœå¢å°åž¯ã¯åžåœã®å å€
ã瀟äŒçã»çµæžçã«æ¶æ©ããŠããããšãè¿°ã¹ãã
ããå ±åæ¿æ以æ¥ããããŒã人ã§ãããããšãæ
ãå€æ¥è ãå¯å®¹ã«åãå ¥ããŠããããŒãã¯ããã®
å°ã§ããæ°ããããŒã人ããåãå ¥ããŠããããš
ã瀺ããããæåŸã«ãè¿ä»£ã«æŽå²çã«æ§ç¯ããã
ãã²ã«ãã³äººããã²ã«ãã³æ°æããšããæ°æïŒnationïŒ
ãåææŠå¿µãšããŠçšããããããŒã人察ã²ã«ãã³
人ãšããäºé 察ç«å³åŒããšã¯ç°ãªã解éãæ瀺ã
ãããšãç®æšãšãããã
第 2ç« ãè¡°éã®ã圱ãââã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£ãã¹
倧åžã®æ¹é©ââãã§ã¯ãåžåœè¡°éã®ç«¯ç·ãã³ã³ã¹
ã¿ã³ãã£ãã¹ 1äžã®æ¹é©ã«èŠåºããããšãããã
éäŸããã£ãªã¯ã¬ãã£ã¢ãã¹ãšåœŒã®äž¡è ã®æ¹é©ã«
ãã£ãŠãäžäžçŽã®å±æ©ããå æããããå°å¶åäž»
ããŠãæ¬æžã®ããŒãã§ããæç¶ççµæžçºå±ã«ã€
ããŠã§ãããããå éäž»å°åã®çºå±çµè·¯ãžã®è»¢æãã
ãããŠãå°å倧åœéã§ã®è²¿æååäœå¶ã®æ§ç¯ãã
å¿ èŠã§ãããšããæèŠã«ç°è«ã¯ãªãããã ãåè
ã¯ãŸã ãŸã 課é¡ãå€ããä»ããã«çæã§ãã解決
çã§ãªããåŸè ãåœå¢åé¡ãªã©è§£æ±ºã§ããŠããªã
åœå®¶éã®ä¿äºããç¯ããååäœå¶ãç Žå£ããå¯èœ
æ§ãããããšãèæ ®ã«å ¥ããå¿ èŠãããã ããã
æãããŠã3åœã¯æç¶çãªçµæžçºå±ãããŠãã
ãã®ã ããããæ¬æžã¯ããã®ããŒããèãããã
ã§æé©ãªæžã§ããããšã¯çããªããä»åŸã®äžççµ
æžã®ååãšå±æã«èå³ã®ããæ¹ã«ã¯ãããããã
ãã 1åã§ããã
èš»
(1) åäºæ圊ã»æºç«¯äœç»å²ç·šãçŸä»£ãã·ã¢çµæžè«ãã
ããã«ãŽã¡æžæ¿ã2011幎ã68é ã
(2) 浊ç°ç§æ¬¡éã»å°å³¶çã»æ¥æ¬çµæžç 究ã»ã³ã¿ãŒ
ç·šãã€ã³ã VS.äžåœââäºå€§æ°èåœã®å®åæ¯èŒãã
æ¥æ¬çµæžæ°èåºç瀟ã2012幎ã39-51é ã
(3) 倧æ³åäžéãèããŠããã¢ãžã¢ââç¹æ ã®æ§
å³ãå€ãããšãããäžå ¬æ°æžã2007幎ïŒå è€åŒä¹ã»
äžåäžæ ¶ç·šãçŸä»£äžåœçµæžè«ããããã«ãŽã¡æžæ¿ã
2011幎ã183-192é ã
(4) 浊ç°åæ²æžã35-38é ã
(5) å°ç°å°ä¹ç·šãã€ã³ãçµæžïŒæé·ã®æ¡ä»¶ããã¢ãž
ã¢çµæžç 究æã2009幎ã39-66é ã
ïŒè¥¿å±±çåŸïŒ
æ°å玹ä»
åå·é«å¿èãæ°ã»ããŒãåžåœè¡°äº¡å²ã
岩波æžåºã2013 幎 5 æåãæ°æžå€äžŠè£œã228 é ã
760 åïŒçšãISBN978-4-00-431426-4
æ¬æžã¯è¡šé¡ãããæãããªããã«ããšãã¯ãŒãã»
ã®ãã³ã®å€§èã«å¯ŸãããªããŒãžã¥ã§ããã18äžçŽ
ã®ã®ãã³ãã²ã«ãã³äººãšããªã¹ãæãããŒãåžåœ
ã®è¡°äº¡ã®åå ãšèŠåããŠä»¥æ¥ãæ°å€ãã®åŠèª¬ãæ
143æžè©ã»æ°å玹ä»
å¶ïŒdominatusïŒããå§ãŸã£ããšè©äŸ¡ãããŠããã
èè ã¯éšå£«éçŽãéçšããåè ã®æ¹é©ã圌以åã®
åªç§ãªè»äººçåžãã¡ã®å瞟ã®å»¶é·äžã«ãããã®ãš
è©äŸ¡ããŠãéšå£«èº«åã®è·ãå èé¢è°å¡ã«éæŸãæ§
æ¥ã®äŒçµ±ã«åŸ©ããã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£ãã¹ 1äžã®æ¹é©
ãšå³»å¥ããŠããããã®äžã§ãåŸã®æ¹é©ã«ã€ãªãã
ã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£ãã¹ã®æ¿æ²»çã»è»äºçéçšã確èª
ããããã©ã€ãŽã¡ã«ãšç«¶ã£ãŠããå¯åžæ代ããã¬
ãªã¢ãæ ¹æ å°ãšãã圌ãæ¯ããã®ã¯åå°ã®æåè
ã§ãããçåžã¯åŸã«åœŒãããå èé¢æ Œããšéããã
åžåœå šäœãæ¯é ããåå©è ãšããŠèšãã æ±æ¹ã§ã¯
çŽå±ã®å®åãçšãã匷åãªçåžæ¿æ²»ãæã¡ç«ãŠã
ããšãã§ããäžæ¹ã§ã西æ¹ã§ã¯åšå°ã®æåè ãžã®
é æ ®ãããå èé¢è°å¡ïŒåŸã®ã»ãããŒã«è²ŽæïŒãš
ã®äŒçµ±çãªå調é¢ä¿ã®äžã§æ¿æ²»ãè¡ãããããã«
ãªã£ããšãããããã®æ±è¥¿ã§ã®éãããåŸä»£ã®è¥¿
æ¹ã«ãããåžåœã®è¡°éã®é å ã«ãªããšãããã
第 3ç« ãåŸç¶è ãã¡ã®äºãââã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£
ãŠã¹äºäžã®éçšââãã§ã¯ãã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£ãã¹
1äžã®åŸç¶è ã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£ãŠã¹ 2äžã®æ²»äžãæ±
ãããã倧åžã®æ»åŸã«èŠªæã»æåæ¿æ²»å®¶ã殺害ã
ããçµæãåžåœæ±æ¹ãç¶æ¿ããã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£ãŠ
ã¹ 2äžã¯åŒ·åãªçåžæš©åãæã€ããšã«ãªã£ããã
ãããããã¯å®åã»å®Šå®ã«äŸæ ãããã®ã§ããã
æ¡å ãããå èé¢ã®æåè°å¡ãå ããåŽè¿ãã¡ã«
ãã£ãŠåŸä»£ã®æ¿æ²»ãå·Šå³ãããé å ãšãªã£ããšã
ãããåŒã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ã¹ã殺害ãåžåœè¥¿æ¹ã®åžäœã
ç°å¥ªãããã°ãã³ãã£ãŠã¹ãç Žã£ãåŸãç°å¥ªåžã«
ååããçŸå°ã®ååè ãå·æã«ç²æž ããããã«ã
ã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£ãŠã¹ã¯è¥¿æ¹ã§æ¯æãåŸãããšãã§
ããªãã£ãããµãµã³æãã«ã·ã¢ã«å¯ŸåŠããããã«
æ±æ¹ã«èµŽããªããŠã¯ãªããªãã£ã圌ã¯ããã®ä»»ã
幎å°ã®åŸåŒãŠãªã¢ãã¹ã«èšãããšã«ãªãã
第 4ç« ãã¬ãªã¢ã§çãŸããçåžââãèæè ã
ãŠãªã¢ãã¹ã®ææŠââãã§ã¯ãæ£åžãšããŠã®åšäœ
æéãçãããã«è»œèŠãããŠãããŠãªã¢ãã¹ã«å¯Ÿ
ãã5幎ã«äºã圌ã®å¯åžæ代ããå°çšã«æããå
è©äŸ¡ãè¡ãããããã®æ®µéã§ã¯ããŸã ããŒãã®çµ±
å¶åã¯è¥¿æ¹ã«ãåãã§ããã®ã§ããŠãªã¢ãã¹ã¯æ¯
èŒç容æã«ã¬ãªã¢ãåç·šããåå°ã§ã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£
ãã¹ 1äžä»¥æ¥ã®çŸå°ã®æ°èæåè ã第äžã®æ°ãã
ããŒã人ããç©æ¥µçã«ç»çšãããã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£
ãŠã¹ 2äžã¯å¯Ÿãã«ã·ã¢æŠäºãžã®æŽå©èŠè«ããŠãªã¢
ãã¹ã«è¡ã£ããããããå«ã£ãã¬ãªã¢åºèº«è ãå€
ãå«ãå µå£«ãã¡ã¯ããŠãªã¢ãã¹ãæ£åžãšä»°ãã§ã
ã¯ãŒãã¿ãæ¢è¡ããã察決ãåã«ã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£
ãŠã¹ãç æ»ããããããŠãªã¢ãã¹ã¯èªè»ãçããŠ
æ±æ¹ã«èµŽããéããªã察ãã«ã·ã¢æŠäºã§ææ»ããã
第 5ç« ãåãåºã倧å°ââãŠã¡ã¬ã³ãã£ãã¢ã
ã¹æã®è©Šç·Žââãã§ã¯ããŠãªã¢ãã¹åŸã®åžåœã®æ··
ä¹±ãæåºãããããŠãªã¢ãã¹ã®æ»åŸãåžäœã«å°±ã
ããŠã¡ã¬ã³ãã£ãã¢ãã¹ã¯åŒãŠã¡ã¬ã³ã¹ã«æ±æ¹ã
å§ããèªãã¯ãŠãªã¢ãã¹ã«ããè»äºåã®åŒãæã
ã§äžå®å®åãã西æ¹ã§èŠéããã圌ã®æ»åŸãåŸç¶
è ã®å®®å»·ã§åããã£ãã®ã¯ã第äžã®æ°ããããŒã
人ãã§ãã£ããäžå®å®åãã西æ¹ã§ã¯ã蟲æ°ãã¡
ã¯åšå°ã®æåè ãé Œãããã«ãªãããããŒãåžåœ
ã®çµ±æ²»ããéé¢ãããç¬ç«åŸåãæã€çµåäœãã
圢æããããæ°æ倧移åãåŸã®éšæåœå®¶ã®åºç€ãš
ãªã£ãŠãããããã«ä»æ¥ã®ç 究ãèžãŸããŠããŽãŒ
ãæãå§ããšãããã²ã«ãã³ãè«žéšæããé¢åé
æ£ãç¹°ãè¿ãç·©ãããªéå£ããšããã¹ããšæã
ãŠããæ°æ倧移åãã®åè©äŸ¡ãè¡ããããé説ãš
ã¯ç°ãªããå®æ ã¯ã倧移åããšåŒã°ããã»ã©ã®èŠ
æš¡ã§ã¯ãªããå€ãèŠç©ãã£ãŠãæ°äžäººèŠæš¡ã§ãã
ãšãããããããåé¡ãšãªãã®ã¯ããããŠæž¡æ²³åŸ
ã®ãŽãŒãæã«å¯ŸããããŒãåŽã®å¯Ÿå¿ãå£æªã§ãã£
ãçºã«ãè€æ°ã®ãšããã¹ã察ããŒãã§é£åž¯ããç¶
æ³ãçãŸããããšã§ãã£ããšãããããã®ç¶æ³äžã
ãŠã¡ã¬ã³ã¹ã¯ãåäžãããŽãŒãæãåŸèšããããš
ãããã378幎ã«ã¢ããªã¢ããŒãã«ã§å£æ» çãªå€§
æãå«ããåžåœæ±æ¹ã¯æ··ä¹±ç¶æ ãšãªãã
第 6ç« ãçŠè§£ããåžåœââã西ãã®æåŸââã
ã§ã¯ãã¢ããªã¢ããŒãã«ã®æŠã以åŸã®ç¶æ³ãè¿°ã¹
ããããæ±æ¹ã®æ··ä¹±ã¯ããªãã·ãŠã¹ 1äžã«ãã£ãŠ
åãããããã®ã®ã圌ã®æ»åŸããŽãŒãæã¯åã³ç§»
åãå§ãã西æ¹ã«åããããšãšãªãã幎å°ã®çåž
ãæŽãåŽè¿ã«ããçè³ãããŠããæ±è¥¿äž¡åžåœã¯å¢
çé åãããã£ãŠå¯Ÿç«ããŠããããã«ãååããŠ
ãŽãŒãæã«å¯Ÿå¿ã§ããªãã£ãããã®ããã西æ¹ã®
ããŒãè»ç·åžä»€å®ã¹ãã£ãªã³ã¯ã€ã¿ãªã¢ãå®ãã
ãã«è¥¿æ¹èŸºå¢ãæŸæ£ããããåŸãªãã£ããããã®
144 ãããªãã¯ã»ãã¹ããªãŒ
ããšã«ããããŒãã¯ãåžåœãã§ã¯ãªããªã£ããšã
ããããã®é ããæ°ããããŒã人ããšãªã£ãŠãã
ãŽãŒãæåºèº«è ã«å¯Ÿããææ¥åŸåãæä»çããŒã
䞻矩ããé¡èãšãªããåŸæ¥ã®å¯å®¹ãã¯ããŒããã
倱ããããã³ã³ã¹ã¿ã³ãã£ãã¹ã®ãããªåŒ·åãªç
åžãšã®ç¹ããã«ãã£ãŠå°é ããŠããã第äžã®æ°ã
ãããŒã人ãã¯ãçåžæš©ã®åŒ±äœåã«ãã£ãŠåŸãçŸ
ã倱ã£ããšãããã408幎ã«ã¹ãã£ãªã³ã倱èã
ããšã西åžåœã¯ãŽãŒãæãæ¢ããããšãã§ããªã
ãªãã410幎ã«ããŒãåžã¯ç¥å¥ªãããããšã«ãªãã
çµç« ãããŒãåžåœã®è¡°äº¡ãšã¯äœã§ãã£ãããã«
ãããŠããŸãè¿°ã¹ãããã®ã¯ã¢ããªã¢ããŒãã«ã®
æŠãããå ã 30幎ã§è¥¿æ¹ã®æ¯é æš©ã倱ã£ãããš
ã§ããããã®åå ãšããŠããã€ãŠåžåœãçµ±åããŠ
ãããããŒã人ã§ããããšããã¢ã€ãã³ãã£ãã£
ã倱ãããæä»çã€ããªãã®ãŒã«å ããããšãæ
ããããããã®çµæãæ±æ¹ã§ã¯åŒ·åãªçåžæš©åã«
ãã£ãŠåœå®¶çµ±åã¯ç¶æããããã®ã®ããããæ¬ ã
西åžåœã¯èªå£ãããšçµè«ä»ããããã
çŸåšã®ç 究ååãèžãŸãã倧ããªããŒã¹ãã¯ãã£
ãŽãšç·»å¯ããšãå Œãåããæ¬æžã®æ矩ã¯æããã§
ãããæ¬æžã§ã¯ç°¡åã«ãã觊ããããŠããªããæ
ä»çããŒã䞻矩ããšããªã¹ãæãšã®é¢é£ã«ã€ããŠ
ããã®ãã³ã®å å 説ã®çŒãçŽãã§ã¯ãªããããªã¹
ãæããŸãåææã«äžå¯å®¹åããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããš
ã®èŠéããè¿°ã¹ãããŠããã倧å€èå³æ·±ããäºå
ãããŠãã次äœãžã®æåŸ ãé«ãŸããšããã§ããã
æ¬æžã«é¢ã㊠1ã€ææããŠããã¹ãã¯ãææ°ã®
ç 究ãå©çšããŠããããã«ã5é ã«ãããŠããã
ããåŠçã®åŸåãšã¯ç°ãªãããšè¿°ã¹ãããŠããã«
ãæãããæ¬æžããŸã 21äžçŽãšãŒãããããã®
èŠè§ãã倧ããªåœ±é¿ãåããŠããç¹ã§ãããã倧
æ²³ãšæ£®ã®ããŒãåžåœããšããèŠè§ã¯ããããŸã§ããŒ
ãã®èŸºå¢ãããã¯å€éšãšäœçœ®ã¥ããããŠããè±ç¬
ããå«ãã EUçãšãŒãããã®çŸç¶ã«èŠªåçã§ã
ãããã«æãããããã æ¬æžã 21äžçŽã®ããŒã
åžåœè¡°äº¡å²ã®åè¿°ã§ãã以äžãããã¯å šãåŠå®ã
ã¹ãç¹ãªã©ã§ã¯ãªãããšã¯èšããŸã§ããªãã
æ¬æžã§ããã®åªå€±ã衰亡ã®åå ãšããŠæããã
ããããŒã人ã§ãããã¢ã€ãã³ãã£ãã£ã«ã€ããŠ
ã¯ããããŒã颚ç掻æ§åŒããè»éãšçµã³ä»ããå®
äœçãªãã®ã ãšäœçœ®ã¥ããããŠããããã®ç¹ã¯é
åžžã«èª¬åŸçã§ããããã«æããããããããåã
å ¥ãããšæ¬¡ã®ãããªçåã«æãè³ããããã§ã¯ã
ã©ãããŠããŒã人ã¯é·å¹Žã®å¯å®¹ããæ¥éã«å€±ã£ãŠ
ããŸã£ãã®ãããã€ãŠã®ãããŒã人ããããã¯å
è ããã®äœè£ã§ãããã¢ããªã¢ããŒãã«ã®æŠã以
éãæ¥éã«è»äºçã«åŒ±äœåããããããããã®äœ
è£ã倱ããããšèããã¹ããªã®ãããããããã
ã®ã¢ã€ãã³ãã£ãã£ãšè¡°äº¡ãšã®é¢é£ã¯ããäºãã
ãäºãã®åå ã§ããçµæã§ããçžäºäœçšã§ããã
ãã«æãããã
å ±åæ¿æãç 究ããŠããè©è ã«ãšã£ãŠããå€éš
è ããããŒã人ããšããŠåãå ¥ããŠãã蚱容床ãš
ããåé¡ã¯èå³æ·±ããéåžžãåçåžæŠäºã®åå ã¯ã
察å€æŠäºãªã©ã«ããå©çã®ç¹ã§æå©ãšãªã£ãããŒ
ãåžæ°æš©ãåçåžãèŠæ±ãããããã®èŠæ±ãããŒ
ããæåŠããããã§ãããšãããŠããã4äžçŽåŸ
åãŸã§ç¶ãããŒãã®ãå¯å®¹ããã®äŒçµ±ã«ãããŠã
ããã¯äŸå€çäºé ãšããŠäœçœ®ã¥ããããã¹ããã
ãããšãä»ã®çç±ãæ³å®ãåŸãã®ããæ¬æžããå
ããç¥çè奮ã¯å®¹æã«ã¯éãé£ãããã§ããã
ïŒé·²ç°çŠæïŒ