V » X
* ^
sr*
V
> Y
i «
•W
i ro
r t «
rrn
r < ^
r t s
rvi
Mr jbJi
« JA*.'I ULU
Jbfr
A . o- 1 o W) iO^
(iijj>. ^ajIL iilii)
A-pUldl
jj j jj)
(i«lj«Jl
if iji jkii
A-JUic .-.!/.<. - . T
UI iilii .r
: iilii . t
- jLJl jjl . »
AiUu .1
t_jJVI .V
.A
CiU->JI
jjU . ^ r
<>
^ _ a AjAjj Ajj d i j J*A <>» o.ia. j ojj
Subaltern ^J— jJI djLJ jj U i-ij*j U
SjlSlI Ajji rtJjtb jJ4J*-all (jja.j>all JaLuji .
jl c-jj — j£^ J!Jjl — J (51 (*fcpl (J^J cH1 ' <- C/' •"
Vj — A jL-ala.lj ji t
Ajc.Ula.VI
l ,«A j 'Studies
LjJjLuj U15 ,Ji]l 4 Miog oil AjcUJa.VI Cjlaill (j* .»A jjc. j (j-
-l jA jloll lljLoiljjJ L^\l
4 — jljjj — a 4 — SjaJI ajA- AjjjiJI j AjAi
t,. .<-iil oil '"il'nil oMl
(JJ — j]jj 4 - clSlj 4 - jV'flU ajtlll 4_ui aJni9J aj I " >'"•-
(ji Ub^a SAjjoiLJ ojSa (jx jjjSiJI «.VjA Jjilajl j
aajll *LjaC.i 4^1 jj]b JjljJJ Jl i^jjaJ Jaxu jj ll ^J
jjjj — II j — jlajVI (JJ JJ — *H iJ-^ ' '--1* ' . C *
4JaLJL)
CJl _ Jjj" jii :4jllall <lli«ll ^i ILU JILJI li* J- tlja.1 ^J
»J^-) :
.rr-rr
V I V
^V I ,\" -* 9 • 111 U l ^
|P
115 * WTTV/ •
A? V I 5
rT-afO « — O
r* P'Pfp
-
no*q
BT
*r«
^
^c
IT'
fT?
'nfc-nn
IjtTr
f^?1
jjmT*
- JJJ <J—^- JSJ^
rJjjj-S" iy,Jj*jVij>
<JJJ a <i5lUl
L$j
J (J__J «lft) — ui aAljjSj (jJ l
oOa.1 j <j' j <• "'•*•" Lgjl jjJajl j
Jii (jLjjj JL» JjJ
^ -Mii
V
4*1 jiiB jj Jl JS ob
(jj •
U jaaiuiVI Aj^J V pj ljuaj .i j-o / **J j
JS c-jLua. (jl»j jll ASlkJ AjxjSJI Oj>i V
J f jXJl <iV J jL«l-.VIj
4 jL«la.VI (j-ai-i <>a2j I jj 4ji -Laji- ciljAi jlj
l) A) V
ui js i jJ^ J AJ
jjji 1 JSLUI
o^lA
VI Qlj SibaJ)
J^Jj tJliiVl t>
Lui.1 dlJA
j* r1 t l
i «'' l Jji*
U—«
9 > A
JJ^ - .ill t_
j j>
<JJJA jl Oaj t(jiai
ij jjjlkiJl JU!
>a • jS J j «1 UAji
IJ* JOAJJ *(jJJ>-a-ll
Ui ji IJI tjSlj . .jl
jiiboU "ft
«-kl>ll
<<o
Ja. jll yj j jJC.
^ -» «-- <uiflj
Ajla.yi <ljLa-a i - LiA
jA
Vjj jo^T A
lliij ?tjjljll jJlc. i— Jijl > ^ A\I ._aa
AjyijOAll a^A *Lij) JjVI J*iaill i_la.L-aj
] »jl*iyi '''«;••• jj
liA Q! KU jjjaj (j-1 JJ o^ cr ' *£$-^ CiLal jj"
7- ^ «l.Ulj >(jjj.ajflll jjj^jj^tt]! AJ-JJ^-OJ r- Aj UiS A
P (jApbJl «-i*Jill J jii l j »IS 1 dilc. jilll j tliLol j-iVI j -ij ?Jl j -aJ ULia
4-alSI j <j.%ll <i»jall SjjL ,J lAiaLJl j Ajaall tJC- llw UJ Ji Ctf-^1 C^'
,l£ ijui xj
-Ljaji- j ll Sjlill Ajui i a^^tla Ajial
»juib L_ SJHJ (S J j
i_iAlall I JA
,- *_ui j
t>j -history from belowxj
jjiui_pJl !)l£ jV i
jg8.nl I !lUa. (jJa«-<>
jLuj jl£ IJIj jjjJixJl jjjall • " _i
I «$ U.' A-UuLuii j 5jjA_j
* ' *^* t.UmJj .<3jau«jl j
,. uilj > nil
C. jj .jj Ajl; ^7- (JjlJ t<-l j /«ij A-LQj£aJl tJjLiuuj Jl (JaJ J
t_j»Jiir <xK jl UA (-JJj*j j! ^j V j .It i JJI
JUl ?rlhi no
J I. <iu
(jii_j _^ajl
dLuil jJ c-ib
jjSill A jaJl ft JA j
- "' _jl "?T
4"n\tftAj <jUxj xjUll (jAb>JJ (jj-
A-jUill i_ijb>j t '« i n'l jl
(JC. jlaill tj^ojj <jl j] jJSLJuo (
.- _ A j 4_— a^x AjcLu
(5 j__£Lo a__Al (JA a.li.1j
lUbfui jjl jSij (jl lift Ajjjjll C_
l Jj <_i >U ftjiLj ^LuuVb ^A Jj
H«;y- ''«;•! I^A ,JA {£. jib jSl
l »_>«11 Ui
ixJl Jix
Jb>x J
oOA
rfn T^ rf — to
" "TIP J1? VT
X V
\lJi'' 5^ • 7^ IITI * l\i.v * )r' B iC*
ffO
t 11 1"1'1'1-1 T15P 57^?
t ir^**irf> rFr0 rKrft fr0 uq™**? T~~^PI ' ?? *^° IF I1"!? V'.v^ " '" l"1** IF1 5THJ IF-l 1X71 *
Ip^T^TP (pTTyfO |J - n
.j tCaLaj JjfiLa <Jj i -ui a 4-UigJl fti ^AJI Cljjj-a (jl CJJJJC.I
3 Jj ji oijjl ij Jl SjLil <ji 02LJ ^1 l jl Jc. til j
. J-laJJ S_JJJA]| A-iL&xJl o-l$-' (3- V ^ "' *-^-' J 4-cJS Jii. jl Ifl ...1 ..wl j|
t£ jjlb ji «i_>JL) 4il*lJ tillj u,.b..Lil tilUufui JULa
^c . -t ^ ie ,.,\ell L'IJ i.l^ 'ill jLxx] t Xjlj
^lliiiu, Jjlii ^J^jj .sovereign subjectjli . ijJLj l$Uj.i jljjc- J Jjlj l JI>JI
^^j — II t*lLJjj — ui (CjjL
J — Si ( aa—Jill ( "J"'--— (Jc-li"
^ ^*"*1 '*' JJ C f * •i-'JC- (JJ '" ' ' A u a (?JJJ (jl ^J
Jc-li JJA.J <]Lu>
ji Jl 4ji.ii.Ull <JloiJl a
b Jl * it-Tl.nj V UjaJ J ,*
Ajj (jc-
J So'..... IJja.j (Jc-lill IJ^J (jl JAiaJ V IfriSJj ' JSluui Jfrli <jl£ Ajli
« '->"' -"J« -^ '' f- 4jjj a^Jj JJ ' ^
'/;•••; 7-tJjlall J J .1 (j,<r\« 1 jjfr jl jlaJl (jc. ^ _ n j (jl jj
XA.U'I (ji jj-i'un'1 V <j J ''SP'JJ I <3^^J ' J J^ ' <"i "il J
Jl llijia, jjba. (j^lVi «illi!j . j>Jl AJ|JJ J
' l''''^Aj c^J ' *J^4J ' ' "U (j'
ol j e j&ill »^A j t-UuiJ (jc ^J&Jj (£ Jll Jc-lill (juJj 2;1"
u ( ill voaJill i — " jUll" j*j subject <*1S jl ^kj <±
^ j-Jajx Jix "^ jjjDjJ" 4yui3 tllSjll J J«J LaS - jluiJl J ji J_axJl
.i xjll ji
t(iK" J (ji lWii.iJ V A^lljll jlj (3*1 Lf^ ^IJ^1 j&m- (^ li-oLi I J]
ji y^L-jJI CJjaui A.ulc.i IjM j Laj Ijil* oj- 1 U ?1 1 *V> Jjlj tJ&i «-ip
xjljll Cj_»x^a 1'^.j.^A. (Xjljll <Jjj* a A^axa'l l_Ju£ : ji.1 JSLlj (Jljjujl JluiJ ji 1 Vl
f <Ljja till jiui Ola kliL
J ail
Axu
U^j-ity J
pi Jill ^oiaJ
lll IJA
Si j-Jl V1
Lp — *i U* L.
> a< «.-*!! an..
l'p
PT
VT(
' tfir f?
','*"'*
ll^rl ' 11 V' ' '
I
f
TT"*>
* —
S (jr— "
fFri i 1 f^
t ir — ^? r*— re? — IJT^T * —
5^ tr^-c — ?P
enfcr^__rTI Tr rO f i»t> » r r^(^rcf> nrTj-
?5lr iff
•Trcr
iP fr
w Cl ^
ro* in
r^n -gO
- 9 A_iul4J JlAj jl Ajllll (« jWunJ V c? _>=>•' « J^ *JJ 't-$^nSJ vllLaKJLlj 4 J-% ill
5 — .JAA'VI AJ JjLJ LjUaiJ ji
.*> j-vj]l jA (_)UaaJl lift jl (jiajjtij jl (_. t?J V Aji ( ic. t«jjlj]l Ajl
i_il - Lti. ,J -K'j ji •<U'i...j V J3 jlS I jlj .<jjo4J jc. Ajfl Jj«j ,.£] xjUl
^ — 3 AJJ — a o. ..u ji .U"....'. V Ijil ()ri*J V la* jli
r-^-oj J3 j i '_>*•' SJ_^ui4 j^J (' "'j A^^ j]
J3 jA jl (iJllSbk. (JlljjuaJ (jnogj ul jl t<*iu»ljA j* JJ (a-ojLU ll ( _ 1! ITV II jlo .J V
djlAa.'VI >*« ( c. -Uuiij jj Ja ~^j^-' j' <4-!ljalj V
IJA
tT ' 'j
v ' -
(_ylc. j Jj
jUll ji ^joj ji oj V dli yJj AiLi.1 j
iAjAwijll A^Lull (_flc. Ijjbc-ljjjj
jj jj ji AIJJ fc tUru
u' ^j-aJl JlaJI
i £jfcll ^Uaiu.1 lit Ajij ^JSjJ ji
V ill (j^t-^ »*H /-J»J £J I ji
Aj£]j Jailb ^JSij jljll jlfl -ISL,
ia I J] j iAijjtj i-iiSjj AJ]J t' \mnj Jj*Jl I A <-ili ji ^ J>all ^ylc
. jljJl (jjJj j>all jk ^X£ll j i'iinj V ( ill ji ftJj* cillJ jlfl ttillJ J>JI
iajjjJl .LjlaaJl AJ ? iajj jl Liljl (jill J ._*A]| (_paj«JI I JA J*j
l_j 1 a'-V iL_*jtJ
jx
ejlSJl AoJi ^Sj t_JjiJl i A-iAplSVl iaUjjVl l^'nofti JtuijJj <£J\jll C
»lauVI I^A jl ( Jl jjAj ji L_laJ t JUJl j- ji.i jSLai ^S
,. — 3 X-*^ AJ (_>Jjlj AjJ^ I lIjLuxLaJl (ji (j»j <4 JJC- j Vjj>o u' j
...\ £| JiaVI J i j-J . B i klfiUj VJ -ipl
JJl AjtiS a J^'t.J jL«j iS jtill liU jj ObtiS SJjl jll jl£aVl
cte r* v-_ fes » r "* ,— •— -
^T ^ P C r V r« ,° £ v.> c i 1 1 1 E *• If I
car KBifmim
- ' r «i 1 1
v L
-
V
u_
-
c.t.
B: ;**•• t- p .c r c-r u S £. > 6. T:U- . .f — C- ^ »p_
'. if L .•'!f I. f
c- 91 n> « .ft ,
g
L , (T 1— ^-^ »c —
O —T3O
- ^ -r c• CD I »
p ;4 EV. 11
5> L: v <!' r T»»< —• .tr .»• NX »L i*-*r «r (? ^ Ki C. t»u "• c~
.-F v 5- 1 L
. : V / { I. £ V t (f
&oo
"Hi5'
T3O
• 1Et
j' o* Ic-jj j*AjLuc.lj
x - a
l J 6- J
AjjJaJl 2U...1I Ujk JL; •••••'
j|j_ji J — jS Ajjljll ^jLj.JI ei Jl (jjJj t j*ia)l ( ji-i «jL»-J ji
x^all JJjJj ^JLl <]ja. Laj jLuuyi oLa. >laIJ J AjjjaJl <IaLJl AJJJ (Jj
tljl—tlAJl J_l« t£j! — i djx Jl j^Jjj J ..iki..ij ( JJI
A <JJJaJl AJaLol] duiluiV) l-JJfrJl t^JJuj jLuAla.ba .Aax-nkll Jjjl jillj
.» «"l><lll SUa. (jJxU (Ja.1 ,jx A«Jjl-illj j»UJall jLa-a J
^ _ Ic- jj
jjj .AjjixUJl <jc.Lua.VI CjUill jja'in (jjJill jl £jljJl ^Jjti <jlj
Ji - , »'<•' la <jV fto& 11 jjyi AJaSj
Sj t «j A^JVJ (jl >J JI (j 9 (La
(jjj _ all > "'- tljLoj (jllc- (€a]l A-jlall dljj-o X.4JX.LJ jjl * iKini'i V i_5_>^-' * J^V J'
iJ
U
V*
g :iii.; A,, ^ ,-x: «^ . « j _ s -a A-dj.. , t,-,...,.-
'-•«J^U: . 'j^^f^-c^"" **£**•* '•'^•J:-. 5 • • .-'^..
Dipesh Chakrabarty, Habitations of Modernity: Essays in the Wake of SubalternStudies (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2002), 3-19.
Ranajit Guha, ed., A Subaltern Studies Reader, 1986-1995 (Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press, 1997); Ranajit Guha and Gayatri ChakravortySpivak, eds., Selected Subaltern Studies (New York: Oxford University Press,1988); Gyan Prakash, "Subaltern Studies as Postcolonial Criticism," TheAmerican Historical Review 99, no. 5 (1994): 1475-1490.
Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, "Can the Subaltern Speak?" in Marxism and theInterpretation of Culture, eds. Gary Nelson and Lawrence Grossberg (Urbana:University of Illinois Press, 1988), 271-313.
:(Jk AjjiaJI A-iiaLuJaiVI iiLJI SjSJ j .-tJ \^Jk\j idUjill ^« OjJC J^C. jSjS Jj.aj«\
Michel Foucault, An Introduction, vol. 1, The History of Sexuality, trans. RobertHurley (New York: Pantheon Books, 1978); Michel Foucault, Discipline andPunish: The Birth of the Prison, trans, Alan Sheridan (New York: PantheonBooks, 1977); Luther H. Martin, Huck Gutman, and Patrick H. Hutton, eds.,Technologies of the Self: A Seminar with Michel Foucault (Amherst: Universityof Massachusetts Press, 1988).
Michel Foucault, Naissance de la biopolitique: cours au College de France (1978-1979), edition etablie sous la direction de Francois Ewald et Alessandro Fontana,par Michel Senellart (Paris: Seuil/Gallimard, 2004); Michel Foucault, Securite,territoire, population: cours au College de France (1977-1978), edition etabliesous la direction de Francois Ewald et Alessandro Fontana, par Michel Senellart(Paris: Seuil/Gallimard, 2004); Michel Foucault, "Society Must be Defended: "Lectures at the College de France, 1975-76, ed. Mauro Bertani and AlessandroFontana, trans. David Macey (New York: Picador, 2003), 253-63.