209
창조형 연구·기술사업화 창조경제연구회 제20회 정기포럼 발표자 이민화 창조경제연구회 이사장 / 현재호 테크노베이션파트너스 대표 토론자 이공래 대구경북과학기술원 교수(좌장) / 오태석 미래창조과학부 연구성과혁신정책관 국장 / 벤처기업협회 회장 연구성과실용화진흥원 원장 / 신경호 한국과학기술연구원 소장 / 손수정 과학기술정책연구원 연구위원 현재호 테크노베이션파트너스 대표 일 시 2015. 10. 27(화) 14:00~16:00 장 소 서울 창조경제혁신센터 (舊 드림엔터)

창조경제연구회 제20차 정기포럼 창조형 연구 기술사업화

  • Upload
    -

  • View
    1.256

  • Download
    5

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 20

    20

    /

    () / /

    / /

    2015. 10. 27() 14:00~16:00

    ( )

    20

    20,000

    28 12 3 Tel 02-577-8301 Fax 02-577-8302 [email protected] http://kcern.org

    9 791186 480090

    0 3 3 2 0

    ISBN 979-11-86480-09-0

  • 20

    2015. 10. 27

  • Contents 20

    1. 1

    2. 5

    3. 11

    4. 63

    5. 187

    6. 199

  • 1.

  • 1.

    3

    20

    R&D 90% . ?

    . .

    .

    2015 10, 2 .

    . , ? .

    R&D GDP 1 18 .

    .

    R&D 27.1%, 0.8% .

    ,

    .

    ,

    IP

    . R&D 10 .

    . , .

    : 2015. 10. 27() 14:00~16:00

    : KT 1 ( )

    : ()

    :

    14:0014:05 (, )

    14:1014:40

    14:40~14:50 ()

    14:5015:45

    () -

    ( )

    ()

    ()

    ()

    ()

    ()

    15:45~15:55

    15:55~16:00

  • 2.

  • 2.

    7

    2009

    .

    .

    . ,

    ,

    .

    .

    .

    . ,

    .

    .

    .

    .

    . 1.0

    , 2.0 . IT

    . 5

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    . . SNS

    .

    (Think Network)

    .

    .

    . , , , , ,

    . 1 KIST,

    , , , 2

    , .

  • 8

  • 2.

    9

    ()

    1

    (13.9.24)

    (, )

    ,

    2

    (13.10.22)

    M&A

    M&A M&A

    3

    (13.11.26) 3.0

    ,

    ,

    4

    (13.12.17)

    (

    )

    ,

    5

    (14.02.25)

    ,

    / , FDS

    6

    (14.03.25)

    ,

    ,

    ,

    7

    (14.04.29)

    , IP()

    ,

    8

    (14.05.27)

    2.0:

    ,

    ,

    ,

    9

    (14.06.24)

    ,

    ,

    , First Movier(

    ) R&D ,

    R&D

    10

    (14.07.15)

    ,

    , ,

    11

    (14.09.23) ,

    ,

    12

    (14.10.28) ,

    ,

    ,

    13

    (14.11.29) ,

    ,

    CSR,

    ,

    SK

    14

    (15.02.24)IT ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

  • 10

    ()

    15

    (15.03.24)

    ,

    2016

    16

    (15.04.28)

    ()

    ()

    , .

    1000

    17

    (15.05.26)

    ,

    ,

    4

    18

    (15.07.21)

    19

    (15.09.22)

    ,

    M&A

    M&A

    M&A

    M&A

    (11/6)

  • 3.

  • 3.

    13

  • 14

  • 3.

    15

  • 16

  • 3.

    17

  • 18

  • 3.

    19

  • 20

  • 3.

    21

  • 22

  • 3.

    23

  • 24

  • 3.

    25

  • 26

  • 3.

    27

  • 28

  • 3.

    29

  • 30

  • 3.

    31

  • 32

  • 3.

    33

  • 34

  • 3.

    35

  • 36

  • 3.

    37

  • 38

  • 3.

    39

  • 40

  • 3.

    41

  • 42

  • 3.

    43

  • 44

  • 3.

    45

  • 46

  • 3.

    47

  • 48

  • 3.

    49

  • 50

  • 3.

    51

  • 52

  • 3.

    53

  • 54

  • 3.

    55

  • 56

  • 3.

    57

  • 58

  • 3.

    59

  • 60

  • 3.

    61

  • 4.

  • 4.

    65

    20

    2015. 10. 27

  • 66

    2015 20

    : : ()

    28 12 3

    :

    : ,

    : 2015. 10. 27

    : ( )

    :

    : , ,

    : , ,

  • 4.

    67

    71

    . R&D, 79

    . 87

    2.1. () : 90

    2.2. : 92

    2.3. : 93

    2.4. : 94

    2.5. : 99

    . 101

    3.1. 103

    3.2. 109

    . 121

    4.1. 123

    4.2. 130

    . 137

    5.1. 139

    (1) (K-DARPA) 139

    (2) (/) 144

    5.2. 146

    (1) 146

    (2) Two track 149

    5.3. 162

    (1) (K-OCS) 162

    (2) OCS : R&D ( . 2015) 169

    (3) K-OCS 169

    . 171

    175

  • 4.

    69

    Executive summary

    1. GDP R&D ,

    OECD .

    2. 1) 2)

    3) .

    3. ,

    .

    4. K-Darpa

    / .

    .

    5.

    .

    I-Corps .

    .

    6.

    K-OCS .

    3.0 .

    7.

    .

    8. 18 R&D 10% 2

    .

  • 4.

    71

  • 4.

    73

    (1)

    , ,

    - , 2 , 6 2

    2

    515 7.13 2

    ,

    - ,

    - M&A

    , , M&A

    (2) R&D , R&D

    2006 2015 R&D 140 5,000

    2014 GDP 1 . R&D

  • 74

    - SCI (Science Citation Index) 2012 SCI(Science

    Citation Index) 4 7066

    10

    - 13 7,495 12(6,676) 12.3% , *(27.1% 31.2%) 07 30%

    R&D

    - 7.8%

    10%

    * 4(, '12) 70% - (R&D ) 4.15 1.49%

    (, 2014)

    R&D 96%, 47.2%

    1)

    -

    R&D ()

    (3)

    , ,

    , ,

    - 2000 2006 12

    2001 - 2000 2) (NTB)

    R&D

    - 5

    1) 2015 2 R&D 96%, 2) 2009 (KIAT, Korea Institute for Advancement of Technology)

  • 4.

    75

    (4) :

    -

    GEM(global entrepreneurship monitor)

    , .

    -

    -

    ,

    . /

    - ,

    - R&D Technology push

    - R&D

    - (, , , , )

    ,

    -

  • 76

    R&D

    - NIH, , JST A-STEP

    3)

    :

    : Technology Push

    Market Pull

    R&D

    -

    .

    , ,

    ,

    -

    .

    -

    3) 2015.08.18. HelloDD, ?

  • 4.

    77

    (5)

    : K-Darpa

    -

    - /

    - DARPA

    DARPA

    - DARPA Director PM Trust but

    verify ,

    - ARPA

    K-DARPA

    :

    - NIH ,

    - R&D

    -

    -

    - Technology push R&D

    Market pull

    - NSF R&D

    I-Corps .

    - its owl

    , Industry 4.0

  • 78

    Two Track

    - IP ,

    - IP

    R&D

    : K-OCS

    - R&D

    - OCS

    K-OCS

    - 5 OCS R&D

    ,

  • 4.

    79

    . R&D,

  • 4.

    81

    . R&D,

    (1)

    , GDP R&D 2

    - R&D 13 59.3(541.6 ) 6

    , GDP 4.15% (4.21%) 2 (

    , 2015)

    - 2006 2015 R&D 140 5,000

    [ 1] R&D GDP

    : . 2013.

    15

    (, 2014)

    - SCI(Science Citation Index) 2012 SCI(Science

    Citation Index) 4 7066

    10

    -

  • 82

    [ 1]

    Input Output

    R&D 6 43

    R&D GDP 1 20

    6 30

    4 20

    : . 2015

    - 2007 141 2012 172,

    2007 118 2012 197

    - R&D 4.6 6676

    7897 ( 2008)

    - ( ) 27.1%

    R&D

    -

    - 7.8%

    10%

    * 4(, '12) 70% -

    (STEPI, 2009)

    - 2012 1.49% 3.93%

    - 2012 27.1% 36.9%

  • 4.

    83

    [ 2]

    (B)

    (%)

    (B/A)

    (

    )

    (C)

    (

    )

    (D)

    (%)

    (C/D)

    2008

    8,004 1,293 16.2 21 3,553 0.60

    6,466 1,919 29.7 81.4 4,372 1.90

    14,470 3,212 22.2 102.4 7,926 1.30

    17,424 4,398 25.2 2,376 44,543 5.33

    2,110 595 28.2 1,015 5,204 19.50

    19,534 4,993 25.6 3,391 49,747 6.82

    2009

    8,823 1,464 16.6 239.0 317 0.76

    6,424 2,004 31.2 63.9 3,351 1.91

    15,247 3,468 22.7 87.8 6,508 1.35

    17,812 4,565 25.6 1,757 47,555 3.70

    1,956 656 33.5 519 5,077 10.22

    19,768 5,221 26.4 2,276 52,632 4.32

    2010

    11,403 1,576 13.8 39.5 4,644 0.85

    7,036 2,683 38.1 111 5,491 2.02

    18,439 4,259 23.1 150.5 10,135 1.48

    18,303 4,640 25.4 1,764 52,232 3.38

    1,839 580 31.5 576 5,366 10.73

    20,142 5,220 25.9 2,340 57,598 4.06

    2011

    11,733 1,925 51.9 5,645 16.4 0.92

    8,262 3,268 101.3 5,993 39.6 1.69

    19,995 5,193 153.2 11,638 26.0 1.32

    18,303 4,640 1,764 52,232 25.4 3.38

    1,839 580 576 5,366 31.5 10.73

    20,142 5,220 2,340 57,598 25.9 4.06

    2012

    12,482 2,431 58.3 5551.7 19.5 1.05

    12,179 4,245 141.6 7860.5 34.9 1.80

    24,661 6,676 199.9 13,409 27.1 1.49

    19,324 7,349 1,726 53,565 38.0 3.22

    2,065 549 620 6,179 26.6 10.0

    21,389 7,898 2,346 59,744 36.9 3.93

    : . 2014. . p36

  • 84

    (, 2014)

    - 4) 2001 37 2007 47, 2010

    132, 2011 133 2007

    0.4, 2010 0.65, 2011 0.7

    -

    [ 3] (: )

    2001

    56 -

    19 -

    37 -

    494 -

    2007

    47 0.4

    555 2.9

    EU 549 1.8

    2010

    115 1.06

    17 0.18

    132 0.65

    546 4.83

    39 1.5

    585 4.24

    48 1.41

    EU 549 1.9

    2011

    97 0.81

    36 0.51

    133 0.7

    606 4.21

    37 1.54

    643 3.83

    50 1.35

    : . 2014. . p37

    4) (, 2014)

  • 4.

    85

    (2)

    1

    .(

    )

    , ( )

    - 11 1% 1,688 16

    ... 11 SCI(Science Citation Index)

    1% 0.63% SCI(Science

    Citation Index) 5)

    - ,

    -

    ( )

    -

    -

    -

    - ,

    , 5

    1) .

    2) .

    3) .

    4) .

    5) .

    5

    1) .

    2) .

    5) , 2011 11 21 ...

  • 86

    [ 2] :

    3) .

    4) .

    .

    -

    :

    ,

    SCI(Science Citation Index) ,

    ()

    - ,

  • 4.

    87

    .

  • 4.

    89

    .

    [ 3]

    (/, )

    - (, )

    ,

    - (, )

    - .

    , .

    - , ,

  • 90

    [ 3]

    : ,

    2.1. () :

    /

    -

    -

    ,

    - R&D ,

    -

    95% R&D

    (, 2015)

    *100% R&D 2012 89%

    (, 2012)

    -

  • 4.

    91

    [ 4]

    -

    - , ,

    - ,

    R&D , ,

    -

    - 30

    *

    ** (38%), (31%),

    (25%)

    *** , (46%),

    , , (18%)

    -

  • 92

    -

    - ,

    -

    * ( 19),

    (39.2%)

    (32.2%) (, 09 ) (, 2011)

    - ,

    -

    2.2. :

    :

    - , (CDMA, )

    - ,

    - 2000

    : ,

    - 90% -

    -

    -

    -

    : ,

    - 4g 12ton : KIST

    4g 12ton

  • 4.

    93

    - (4)

    , 7

    - 4 6

    2.3. :

    , ,

    (

    , 2013)

    -

    - 31 26

    - 12 118 49 ,

    - .

    ,

    - ,

    * () TLO 7 () 2 , TLO

    5.9( 10.4, 9.4), 1.5, 20%

    (, 2011)

    - 5.0 1.0

    20% .

    . TLO

    - TLO

    * TLO

    * 47%

  • 94

    (TLO)

    -

    2.4. :

    -

    - 5

    -

    (pull model) (push

    model)

    - (Technology Driven)

    , (saturation)

    [ 5]

    : 1~5

  • 4.

    95

    R&D,

    - ,

    - . , ,

    ,

    , ,

    , , linear

    ->->->

    -

    R&D ,

    (linear)

    - ->->->

    interactive innovation model

    - :

    (interactive model) 6)

    [ 6]

    : , ,

    6) 2014.10

  • 96

    :

    -

    ,

    R&D

    [ 7] R&D

    : 2014

  • 4.

    97

    [ 4]

    4 (ICT)

    1,483,

    707.6 , 684

    2012 TLO

    1,557

    900

    2009~2012

    651,

    524

    R&D

    Value-up

    R&BD

    R&BD

    2014

    ,

    2012 3.6 13

    , 64

    CT R&D

    (2012 98, 2009 21)

    R&BD

    ICTBT

    - 5 () 11

    (. 2014)

    - ,

    - R&D ,

  • 98

    2009~2012

    189

    2009~2012 224

    ,

    ,

    ,

    7 2,193

    , 6.57

    (10

    70, 11 28, 12 42)

    ,

    , R&D

    ,

    59%, 392.4

    (R&D)

    4

    (09~12) 256,

    29, 67

    46, 146.7

    ,

    4

    (09~12) 238

    ,

    ,

    886

    (

    130 )

    : . 2014.11.

  • 4.

    99

    , ,

    -

    - , R&D ,

    , , ,

    - .

    -

    - ,

    - 5-10 ,

    1.3%(10) (2

    (), 10.10. 49 )

    * , , (R&BD)

    (10 264) (11 100)

    * 1-2

    , ,

    - .

    ,

    2.5. :

    (, 2008)

    -

    () (Tassey, 1997; pp. 8790).

    * (Conflict of technology value)

    : &

    -

    (suboptimality) (Gustafsson and Autio, 2006).

  • 100

    [ 8]

    [R&D ] [ ]

    : , 2008

    - ,

    .

    (M&A)

    -

    - , 3~4 ,

    .

    7

    - () (bad technology drives out good one)

    -

    , .

    - ,

    .

    *

    - : .

  • 4.

    101

    .

  • 4.

    103

    .

    3.1.

    (1)

    (, 2013)

    1990

    ,

    2000 1 ,

    , ,

    , .

    -

    (: )

    (

    )

    1) 2)

    - ,

    ,

    13 . 2014. 1 .

    -

    * 2000 3

    2004 11 2005 12

    2009 ()

    , , , ,

  • 104

    [ 5]

    (5)

    ( ) ,

    , ,

    * 5

    (7~14)

    (NTB)

    ,

    (15~25)

    (32~34)

    , ,

    (352~358)

    : , 2013, [Online]www.moleg.go.kr

    ,

    ,

    ,

  • 4.

    105

    [ 6]

    (3)

    , ,

    : , 2013

    (2)

    ( , 2013)

    (2013.2)

    (: )

    2000 ,

    5 *

    *

    R&D

    R&D 2000 4

    ,

  • 106

    - (1 ) , , NTB()

    * TP TLO, RTTC

    - (2 ) ,

    * R&BD(),

    - (3 ) ,

    - (4 ) TLO

    - 5 (2015~2017)

    5

    R&D

    - 1) , 2) , 3)

    , 4)

    (: )

    ( )

    , 2

    (2011~2015)

    * (34) 4 ,

    - (1 ) 1) ,

    2) TLO

    () , 3)

    NTIS()

    2 (2011~2015)

    - (2 ) 7

    R&D

    *2 ()

  • 4.

    107

    [ 7]

    1

    (2001~2005)

    (2000.1)

    NTB(

    )

    2

    (2006~2008)

    (2006.12)

    R&BD

    3

    (2009~2011)

    4

    (2012~2014)

    5

    (2015~2017)

    : , 2015

    -

    3 , 6 , 24 , 6

    - 1) 2) 3) 4)ICT

    5) 6)

  • 108

    - R&D

    - () R&D

    - (()) *

    * 1,250

    *(13) 36 (17) 180

    * (12) 40 (17)75, (12)103 (17) 150

    2013

    .

    (, 2015)

    [ 9]

    : , 2013. , KISTEP

    ,

  • 4.

    109

    3.2.

    (1)

    , , ,

    ,

    , , , ,

    ( 9 )

    [ 10]

    : . 2014.06. , . 9

    TLO, RTTC, TLO* , RTTC

    *172(121, 51)

    TLO(Technology Licensing)

  • 110

    TLO

    - TLO

    - TLO

    TLO

    TLO

    - ,

    ,

    31 ,

    [ 11]

    : . 2014.06. , . 9

    - ,

    - 31 32

  • 4.

    111

    NTB, NTIS, IP-market,

    NTB(), NTIS()

    DB

    NTB DB

    * NTB 1.3% (KIAT, 2012), 5

    () NTB R&D

    IP-Market() ,

    *2014 271

    - (SMART3)

    DB DB

    - NTB, NTIS, TDB

    -

    2013 6 -

    -

    1) 2) 3)

  • 112

    , ,

    [ 12]

    :

    2015 17

    -

    1:1

    - (C-Lap)

    .

    - ICT

  • 4.

    113

    [ 13]

    :

    - (2015 7 17 ) 250 , 125

    299 171

    - 1) , 2)

    , 3) ,

    , IP ,

    - 17 99,711 (),

    40 (9 ),

    [ 14] 1:1

    :

  • 114

    (2)

    GDP 18 R&D , , ,

    , ,

    R&D

    - TLO, ,

    R&D

    R&BD ,

    - 1), , 2), ,

    3) 4) 5)

    *

    *2015 , (2015.1)

    , , .

    - ( ) TLO ,

    - ( R&BD ) (06),

    (14)

    - ( ) , R&D

    - 2008 22.2% 2013 31.2%

    -

  • 4.

    115

    [ 15]

    : (2013)

  • 116

    [ 8] R&D

    (ICT)

    ()

    (TLO)

    ,

    (TLO, )

    R&D

    ()

    R&D

    ()

    ()CT

    ()

    : . 2014

    (3) R&D (2015.05)

    R&D

    R&D

    R&D

  • 4.

    117

    1) R&D 2)

    R&D 3) R&D

    ( ) ,

    ( )

    ( )

    (PBS ) *

    *(15) 10,

    ( ) PBS ,

    ( ) (ETRI),,,

    ,,

    ( )

    ( )

    ( )

    (Tenure)

    , (35)

    ( ) ,

    ( R&D) -

  • 118

    ( R&D )

    ( )

    R&D

    ( )

    - () R&D ,

    - () R&D Fast Track (

    )

    () * ,

    - () ,

    (64 )

    - () * , (BM)

    - ()

    ( )

    - ( ) early exit, moving target

    - () , ,

    - ( ) SCI(Science Citation Index)

    - ( )

    - ( ) 3 ,

    - ( ) (: ZEUS)

    R&D

    ( )

    - (: )

    - , ( Think Tank) (KISTEP), (STEPI)

    (KISTI ) ()

  • 4.

    119

    R&D

    1. - ,

    2. R&D

    ,

    CSO (Chief Scientist

    Office)

    -

    ,

    - ,

    CSO

    /

    - ,

    -

    R&D

    - ,

    1.

    ,

    (KISTEP), (STEPI)

    (KISTI )

    ()

    1.

    2. R&D

    -

    ,

    (PM, Project Manager)

    ( ) R&D (18)

    - (project manager)

    (4) R&D 9 ,

  • 120

    R&D

    1. ,

    R&D

    ( )

    69%

    R&D

    20%

    -

    - R&D

    ,

    -

    ,

    ,

    - ( ) early exit

    (

    ), moving target(

    )

    - ( )

    , ,

    - ( ) SCI (Science

    Citation Index)

    1. ,

    R&D

    ,

    ,

    -

    -

    ,

    ,

    -

    ( )

    - ( ) ,

    , 3

    - ( R&D )

    ,

  • 4.

    121

    .

  • 4.

    123

    .

    - 2

    -

    -

    -

    - ,

    - (ETRI)

    ICT R&D ( , 2015) ,

    R&D

    - ,

    , IP

    -

    4.1.

    (1) :

    1 2

    - , 2 , 6 2

  • 124

    - (Mckinsey) (2015)

    [ 16]

    -

    GEM 3

    , ,

    GDP 20,000

    -

    -

  • 4.

    125

    -

    (what) , (Why)

    [ 17]

    (2) :

    R&D, Production, Marketing, Service

    ,

  • 126

    ( )

    7) , 3D ,

    ( ) ,

    ,

    ( ) , , ,

    , ,

    [ 18]

    :

    IP BM

    - , , 3D , ,

    - , , ,

    7) IT

  • 4.

    127

    ,

    - GRP Partenrs 5

    R&D R&D

    (, 2015)

    - OECD(2014) R&D

    - Du et al(2014) R&D

    - (2012) R&D

    R&D ,

    [ 19] R&D

    : , 2015

  • 128

    (3) : IP

    S&P 500 , 1980

    32% 2000 79% (Ocean Tomo)

    - Cisco Intel IBM P&G , ,

    20%

    - 2008

    [ 20] IP

    ,

    ,

    - 300 Ocean Tomo 300

    - Ocean Tomo

    -

    :

    R&D, ,

    - ,

  • 4.

    129

    -

    R&D (value

    chain) ,

    - R&D

    - R&D

    (IP)

    -() IP

    - () IP , ,

    , , BM, TLO

    - IP IP

    R&D

    Trott(2005) Linear models, Coupling model, Interactive

    model, Network model, Open innovation, Social innovation

    - Linear models Technology Push(1) and Market Pull(2)

    1950 1970 R&D(1)

    (2)

    - Coupling model 1980 Push and Pull

    R&D

    - Interactive model1980 1990 R&D

    (Suppliers)

    - Network model 2000

    ,

    - Open innovation

    R&D

    (Spin-off) Open Source( )

  • 130

    [ 21] R&D

    4.2.

    4

    ,

    ,

    , ,

    ,

  • 4.

    131

    [ 22]

    ,

    -

    - ,

    - 20% 80% , ,

    - (

    2.8 )

    - 20% 80%

    ( 90% )

    - , ,

    ,

    - High Risk High Return

    - 100% 1 20%

    10

  • 132

    [ 23]

    [ 24] :

    - ,

    ( )

    -

    () ( )

  • 4.

    133

    ,

    -

    - ,

    - operation Innovation

    ,

    -

    -

    -

    - CEO 20

    CEO

    (Hambrick and Mason[1984], 2[2014])

    -

    -

    [ 25]

  • 134

    [ 26]

    ,

    ()

    - ,

    (Open platform)

    -

    -

    - Darpa

    - ,

  • 4.

    135

    - ,

    -

    -

    -

    , ,

    - : .

    - ,

    ,

    -

    [ 27]

  • 4.

    137

    .

  • 4.

    139

    .

    [ 28]

    5.1.

    (1) (K-DARPA)

    ()

    R&D R&D R&D

    R&D

    , R&D

    -

    - 3 ,

    (, , , , )

    - R&D

    ( R&D 98.1%)8)

    -

    R&D

    8) , , (2013)

  • 140

    ()

    -

    - 9)

    -

    -

    -

    - (2014) R&D 10

    9

    () DARPA, 10)

    DARPA

    DARPA(Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency)

    (catching-up)

    DARPA ,

    (Hub) ,

    DARPA DARPA

    DARPA

    DARPA ,

    9) , , (2013)10) DARPA .

  • 4.

    141

    - DARPA

    - High risk, high pay-off

    ,

    - PM , ,

    (Under Secretary for Acquisition, Technology and Logistics and Director, Defense

    Research and Engineering)

    - ,

    , , ,

    DARPA

    DARPA (Director),

    (Office Director), (PM) 3

    - Dr. Arati Prabhakar 7, 20,

    94 219 6 (Biological

    technologies office, Defense science office, Information innovation office,

    Microsystems technology office, Strategic technology office, Tactical technology

    office) 250 .

    - DARPA ,

    , ,

    - ,

    , .

    DARPA PM(Project Manager)

    PM ,

    , PM

    , Virtual CEO

    - PM ,

  • 142

    - , PM (Technological Surprise)

    .

    DARPA

    DARPA , ,

    - ,

    - , ,

    ,

    - top-down, bottom-up

    ,

    - DARPA

    - .

    DARPA

    DARPA

    R&D

    - PM

    - 20%

    - 65% , 10% ,

    DARPA ,

    - , ,

    , ,

    ,

    - DARPA " " (End-game approach)

    , DARPA

    , ,

    ,

  • 4.

    143

    - , , ,

    DARPA

    DARPA

    - , World Wide Web , RISC , (GPS),

    , (MEMS), Google , GPS, Siri, , PACS(

    ), Digital X-Ray, , , ,

    Saturn

    DARPA in-house , , ,

    DARPA PM

    ,

    peer review ,

    moral hazard

    DARPA

    DARPA

    DARPA DARPA

    - ARPA-E ,

    , ,

    - HS-ARPA

    - IARPA ODNI()

    6 1) 2)

    , 3) , 4) 5)

    6) ( 4, 2013)

  • 144

    (PM)

    ARPA :K-ARPA

    , ,

    ,

    , -

    DARPA ARPA

    K-DARPA

    K-DARPA

    - ,

    PM , , , , ,

    ,

    (2) (/)

    -

    -

    -

    ()

    - NIH

    -

    -

  • 4.

    145

    -

    - R&D

    ,

    ()

    -

    -

    -

    ,

    *

    .

    **

    DARPA

    ()

    - ( )

    - , RFP ,

    - ,

    - , ,

    - ,

    - PBS Lump Sum

    * 1996 PBS(Project Based System) , 1999

    3

    ( / / 2

    ,) PBS

  • 146

    [ 29]

    -

    -

    -

    -

    * (R&D)

    **

    ( 2015.10)

    5.2.

    (1)

    - (Technology Push) (Market Pull),

    (Public Push) (Private Pull)

    -

  • 4.

    147

    NSF I-CORPS Get out of the building, go to the Market11)

    (): NSF $7B, R&D $172B

    R&D

    I-CORPS

    George Washington I-Corps Node 3-6

    on-line off-line , science & technology commercialization acceleration

    program

    (): I-CORPS

    (): Customer and business model development

    ,

    -

    -

    (Lean Startup) ,

    Interactive ,

    (Customer Development) ,

    - , , 100

    - () *

    - , ,

    ( ): ,

    (): I-Corps 232 2

    $45M

    11) (NSF) [Online]http://www.nsf.gov/news/special_reports/i-corps/about.jsp

  • 148

    KIC Start I-CorpS

    (2015.2.10.

    )

    - 3

    - ,

    [ 30] NSF I-Corps

    Its owl 12)

    Its owl

    -

    (): 2007 , , , ,

    ():

    400

    (): 2 120

    (): , ,

    - , , , 4.0 , ,

    12) It's Owl [Online]http://www.its-owl.com/technology-network/strategy/leading-edge-cluster-competition

  • 4.

    149

    4.0: , , ,

    - 4.0 20-30% 4

    ( 4.0)

    (2) Two track

    ,

    9

    4 6

    (R&D) R&BD

    1) 2)

    - , ,

    ,

    -

    -

    - 1998

    ,

    - 2001

    5000

  • 150

    ,

    [ 31] Two Track

    . (IP)

    - .

    .

    (

    )

    - (IP) .

    .

    Two track

    - IP IP

    ,

  • 4.

    151

    [ 32]

    : Hastbacka(2004); 2(2012)

    () :

    - .

    IP (C&D), IT

    (A&D) . IP

    - , 3

    .

    IP

    - 2000 ,

    1980 IP , 1990 R&D

    , 2000

    IP ( 2, 2012)

    - ( ())13) 44%(2010 )

    (

    , 2011), () 10 3%

    13) () 1966 (KIST) , 11 , 14

  • 152

    - () (IP) R&D

    - () ,

    (

    , 2010)

    [ 33] () IP

    : (2010); 2(2012)

    : (1999~2003) (2004~2006)

    -

    2013 R&D 59.3 6, GDP 4.15% 2,

    2012 R&D 1, 2012 PCT 5 ,

    2004 27.3 2013 51

    - IP . 2009

    IP-R&D ' R&D R&D

    R&D

    - IP

    (2009) 3, 1 , ,

    , 2 , 3

    4, 1 /, 2 ,

    3 , 4

  • 4.

    153

    - ( )

    IP() .

    IP (, 2014)

    - (RFP, request for proposal)

    ,

    - IP ,

    IP IP IP IP

    . IP

    - ,

    seed IP

    - R&D , 7~8

    .

    , IP

    - IP , IP

    [ 34] IP

    IP IP

    - IP .

    IP .

  • 154

    [ 35] IP

    [ 9]

    R&D

    NTIS

    R&D

    (09 )

    -

    NTB

    R&BD

    R&D

    -

    R&D

    R&D

    IP

    - (,

    2014)

  • 4.

    155

    IP-Market - -

    -

    ()

    * : , , ,

    : . 2014.12. (IP)

    - ,

    ,

    -

    . ,

    , ()

    [ 36] : ()

  • 156

    on-off

    - .

    . , IP, M&A, (ODM), ,

    (, 2015)

    - 14) , , M&A

    , on-off

    - 17

    [ 37]

    : . 2015. , M&A: . 19

    14) 3 17 (2015 ), , , , , ,

  • 4.

    157

    [ 38]

    : GEM Global Report. 2011

    () :

    () (

    , 2014)

    - , GEM

    Global Report(2011)

    ,

    - GEM Global Report(2011) ,

    ,

    ,

  • 158

    [ 39]

    : GEM Global Report. 2011

    - 70% ,

    - (-)1 , 70 (-)7

    (, 2013)

    - 97 10 , 1,003

    , 16 , 43 , 72.7%

    - 1998 , ,

    - , ,

    ( 1,

    2012)

    -

    . (9 )

  • 4.

    159

    [ 40]

    : 9 (, 2015)

    9

    - 1

    , Macro , STEPPER , Design Thinking Process

    , , O2O

    - 2 , , , ,

    3C, STP , 5Force , Life Cycle

    1

    - 3 / SWOT , STP, 4P(Marketing Mix),

    (CRM), Value, Price, Cost,

    - 4

    ,

  • 160

    [ 41] 9

    - 5 ,

    - 6 , (Seed Money)

    , , ,

    - 7

    - 8 ,

    , ,

    - 9 ,

    ,

    15) . ,

    15) .

  • 4.

    161

    [ 42]

    , ,

    .

    .

    ,

    .

    . ,

    .

  • 162

    [ 43]

    5.3.

    (1) (K-OCS)

    , , , , ,

    ,

    ,

    R&D 1,2

    (OCS) ,

  • 4.

    163

    OCS 16)

    OCS(Office of the Chief Scientist) ,

    , , 150

    , , ,

    - R&D

    R&D R&D

    70 40 , ,

    70 :

    80 :

    90 : IT

    2000 :

    OCS R&D , ,

    OCS , R&D

    (The Ministry of Industry, Trade and Labour) (OCS)

    1974

    - 1984

    OCS

    - OCS ,

    ,

    OCS research funder research policy maker

    - 1990

    OCS

    - ,

    R&D OCS

    ,

    - ,

    16) OCS .

  • 164

    - OCS ,

    ,

    - OCS , OCS

    , .

    OCS

    OCS , ,

    , 2, 2, 2

    -

    - ,

    ,

    - ,

    AVi Hasson

    - 2011 13 ( 4000) .

    OCS 60% R&D Fund , 20%

    MAGNET

    OCS R&D ,

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    bridge

    - OCS

    ,

    () MATIMOP(Israeli Industry Center for R&D)

    R&D MATIMOP non-profit

    . OCS bilateral R&D

    . 3000

    17)

  • 4.

    165

    () (Support for R&D

    transfer from multinational technologies)

    () (YOZMA)

    , ,

    ,

    1991 , 1996 (Government Companies

    Authority) . 200 ,

    . 5,

    OCS R&D R&D

    R&D

    The R&D Fund

    - R&D .

    Chief Scientist

    . 3 500 1000

    . R&D 50% ,

    , ( 3-5%) ' .

    , . , R&D

    , R&D

    17) [Online] http://www.matimop.org.il/newrdinf/company/ compsrc.htm

  • 166

    Technological Incubators

    - 90 ,

    - 3000 ,

    -

    , VC

    - R&D , R&D , business , .

    R&D R&D 85%(2 $ 300,000-$500,000) ,

    ,

    - , 23 , 200 R&D

    12

    -

    . ,

    Pre-seed Fund (The TNUFA Program)

    - TNUFA pre-seed ,

    . , , ,

    , , .

    $50,000, R&D 85%

    Seed Fund (The HEZNEK Program)

    - ,

    - , ,

    -

    2 . ,

    , .

    , 6 , $250,000

    ,

  • 4.

    167

    - 2 100 50%

    . 7

    R&D

    The MAGNET Program

    -

    , ,

    -

    , ,

    - pre-competitive , , ,

    , .

    6000 , 66%

    MINI-MAGNET(MAGNETON) Program

    - MAGNET , MINI-MAGNET

    , . 66%

    NOFAR Program

    - Nofar MAGNET

    ,

    - 90% 10%

    . $ 100,000,

    Support for Research Institutes

    -

    , ,

    , R&D

    , 30 %

  • 168

    Katamon

    - ,

    ,

    - OCS

    ,

    - , OCS .

    ,

    - 1988 OCS R&D

    , R&D

    - 1981~1986 OCS 2 , 1986-88 , 1990

    . R&D time lag

    , R&D OCS

    [ 44]

    : . DB

    Top-down Bottom-up ,

    ,

    , OCS. OCS

    87 ,

  • 4.

    169

    0.7% 2009 2%

    1990 40

    OCS

    .

    OCS

    ,

    R&D R&D

    (2) OCS : R&D ( . 2015)

    R&D R&D

    ,

    R&D OCS

    , ,

    ( . 2015)

    - ,

    3 12 ,

    . R&D

    (3) K-OCS

    ,

    OCS

  • 170

    ,

    - CSAC(Chief Scientific Advisors Committee:CSAC)

    . R&D

    -

    , .

    -

    ,

    -

    .

    ,

    [ 45] K-OCS

  • 4.

    171

    .

  • 4.

    173

    .

    [ 46]:

    R&D , ?

    : () , (

    ) ()

    : () ,

    ,

    ()

    (Market pull) (Technology push) ()

    R&D R&D

    : () , /

    () NSF I-Corps

    , Two-track

  • 174

    IP , (

    )

    : () K-DARPA DARPA / PM

    , NIH

    ,

    Pool () : IP

    :

    () R&D K-OCS

    :

    ,

    .

  • 4.

    175

    , 2011. 2 ()

    , 2011. 4 ()

    , 2009. (), 30

    , 2010. (). 46

    , 2014. 5 ()

    . 2015.05.13. R&D

    , 2014. , KISTEP

    , 2007. , , 2015.

    , 2015. R&D

    , 2013. 5 ()

    , 2013.

    2008. ,

    , 2011. ,

    , 2013.

    , 2012. .

    , 2012. R&D .

    , 2013. K-ARPA . .

    13-18

    , , 2015. Open R&D, . VIP Report, 620(

    ), pp1-18

    , 2013. ,

    , 2015. ,

    , 2013. , KISTEP

    , 2015. ,

    KISTEP

    , , 2013. () , STEPI, 123, 1-34

  • 176

    , 2011, ARPA, DARPA, ARPA-E : , 21 3

    . 2015. R&D 12

    , 2012. R&D ,

    , 2015. , ,

    , 2013. (R&D) ,

    , , , 2014. CEO ,

    , pp981-910

    , 2013. DARPA, LGERI

    , 2013. ,DARPA ,

    . 2013. (R&D) ,

    , 2014.

    , 2014. , 9

    , 2014. , 12

    , 2015.

    , 2013. -

    , 2011. () 2011,

    , 2013. - ,

    R&D

    , 2014. , , R&D

    , 2014. , R&D

    , 2011. , R&D

    , 2014. (IP)

    KIAT , 2011. R&D

    , DB(https://www.google.com/url?sa=t

    &rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=8&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CD8QFjAHahUKEw

    iMsduV68HIAhWHHZQKHbS0Czw&url=http%3A%2F%2Fdb.kosbi.re.kr%2Fdownlo

    ad.asp%3Furi%3D%2Fconvert_files%2FSS0%2FSS03E005_1.hwp&usg=AFQjCNGLTC

    THcs1JB2sweVapxPhE0KqSlw&sig2=QqKzxZceGxy89YZUma4Dnw)

    , 2015. ICT R&D ,

    DARPA, 2015. Breakthrough technologies for national security.

  • 4.

    177

    DARPA, 2013. Driving Technological Surprise: DARPAs Mission in a Changing World.

    DARPA, 2009. Strategic Plan.

    Du et al, 2012. Does open innovation improve the performance of R&D projects?

    Du, J. S., Leten, B., W. Vanhaverbeke, 2014. Managing open innovation projects with

    science-based and market-based partners, Research Policy, Vol 43, pp.828-840.

    Dugan, R., and K. Gabriel, 2013. Special Forces Innovation: How DARPA Attacks

    Problems, Harvard Business Review.

    Dubois, L. H., 2003. DARPA's Approach to Innovation and Its Reflection in Industry,

    National Academy of Sciences.

    GEM Global Report, 2011

    Hambrick, D. C and A. M. Phyllis, 1984. Upper echelons : The organization as reflection

    of its top manager, Academic of management review, Vol 9, No2, pp193-206

    Hastbacka, M. A. 2004. The New Paradigm in US R&D : IP-Driven Product &

    Technology Development, Technology Management Journal

    Nature, 2008. Still in the lead?, News Feature, Nature, Vol.451, No. 24

    OECD, 2014. Industry and Technology Policies in Korea, OECD Publishing

    OECD, 2013. OECD Science, Technology and Industry Scoreboard, OECD Publishing

    Van, A. R, 2008. Fifty Years of Innovation and Discovery, 50 Years of Bridging the

    Gap, DARPA

    Presented at Special Issue Workshop on Open Innovation for Research Policy.

    Trajtenberg, Manuel. R&D Policy in Israel: An Overview and Reassessment TelAviv

    University. NBER and CIAR.

    NOFAR Program for applied academic research in Biotechnology and Nano-technology,

    Technion. (http://www.trdf.co.il/eng/kolkoreinfo.php?id= 318)

    NOFAR Program for applied academic research in Biotechnology and Nano-technology,

    Technion. (http://www.trdf.co.il/eng/kolkoreinfo.php?id= 318)

    Tmura R&DFund, EraWatch (http ://erawatch.jrc.ec.europa.eu/erawatch/opencms/information/

    country_pages/il/supportmeasure/ support_mig_0015)

    Tmura R&DFund, EraWatch (http ://erawatch.jrc.ec.europa.eu/erawatch/opencms/information/

    country_pages/il/supportmeasure/ support_mig_0015)

    Trajtenberg, Manuel. R&D Policy in Israel: An Overview and Reassessment (PDF).

    TelAviv University. NBER and CIAR.

  • 178

    R&D Funds The Technological Incubators Program, Israel Business Connection.

    (http://www.israelbusiness.org.il/financialassistance/ rdfound)

    R&D Funds The Technological Incubators Program, Israel Business Connection.

    (http://www.israelbusiness.org.il/financialassistance/ rdfound)

    http:// www.darpa.mil

  • 4.

    179

    Q:

    :

    .

    . 300

    , TC 200

    . IM0 2016

    ,

    . 200 , KIST Bridge

    . 4g

    12ton . ,

    1 90% . Bridge program ,

    ,

    , .

    Q: (4g 12 )

    70~90%

    100%.

    . 10

    ,

    , ? ,

    , ,

    . ,

    .

    .

  • 180

    Q: ?

    1.

    .

    . .

    . , ,

    .

    ,

    . (A

    D )

    2.

    .

    ,

    .

    . ,

    . R&BD

    B ,

    Q: ,

    , ,

    .

    .

  • 4.

    181

  • 182

  • 4.

    183

  • 184

  • 4.

    185

  • 5.

  • 5.

    189

    [] 2015-10-12

    2014 R&D 630 ( 73

    1745 ) 5 GDP

    2. R&D 18 GDP

    1 .

    .

    3

    43

    (

    ).

    . R&D

    .

    .

    . 27% 34%

    , 10% . 5%

    . .

    .

    90% .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    . (Darpa)

  • 190

    .

    (PM) CEO .

    .

    PM , .

    .

    . .

    .

    4km .

    . (Fun)

    . , .

    .

    .

    .

    . KTX

    .

    .

    .

  • 5.

    191

    [] 2015-10-19

    4g

    .

    .

    .

    .

    18 .

    .

    9

    . 4 6

    (R&D) R&BD .

    .

    .

    .

    . (IP) .

    .

    .

    .

    . IP .

    . .

    .

    .

    3 .

    .

    .

    .

  • 192

    .

    . .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    IP (C&D), IT (A&D)

    . IP .

    IP .

    IP .

    IP .

    .

    . .

    .

  • 5.

    193

    [ ] ,

    2015-10-21

    [] 55

    .

    .

    .

    .

    10 500

    5000 .

    .

    , , .

    . .

    , . 90%

    . .

    .

    . GDP 18 R&D , ,

    , , , . R&D

    .

    OECD .

    ,

    .

    . 3D,

    .

    .

    ,

    . .

  • 194

    .

    .

    . .

    .

    R&D OCS(Office of Chief Scientist

    ) .

    .

    OCS

    .

    3.0 .

    ,

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • 5.

    195

    [] 59 OECD

    2015-10-25

    59 (OECD) . 5 . . , , . .

    , . . . 90% . , . . , . (DARPA) . .

    . . . . . . .

  • 196

    , . (technology push) (market pull) . .

    (NSF) ( I-Corps) . .

    its OWL . 2007 , , , 2 (IoT) 120 . 4.0 . . . . .

    , . . . .

  • 5.

    197

    [] 2015-10-26

    1) 2) 3) 3 . . M&A . .

    . , , ,

    . . .

    . . . 57 OECD . . 90% . .

    R&D 5 R&D , 1) R&D 2) R&D 3) R&D . , .

    1) 2)

  • 198

    3) . . .

    / . . .

    . . . . . I-Corps .

    . 3.0 . 3.0 10% . 40 .

  • 6.

  • 6.

    201

    () 32 ,

    []34 1, []24 1 .

    1. : T. 02-577-8301 E. [email protected] (: )

    2. : () 1005-702-535568 (: )

    1.

    2. 100,000 2

    3. 1,000,000

    4.

    2015

    () ()

    50,000,000 ()

    30,000,000

    10,000,000

    i-KAIST

    ()

    5,000,000

    ()

    ()

    ()

    ()

    2,000,000 ()M&A

    1,000,000 ()

  • 11 2015 10 27

    11 2015 10 27

    ()

    2013-10-0009

    (06302) 28 12 3

    02-577-8301 02-577-8302

    www.kcern.org

    , 2015

    ISBN 979-11-86480-09-0

    20,000