13
WHY IS COPERNICUS INTERESTING FOR THE HISTORIAN OF JEWISH THOUGHT AND CULTURE? One historian’s search for “real” issues.

Copernicus and Jewish Thught

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Copernicus and Jewish Thught

WHY IS COPERNICUS INTERESTING

FOR THE HISTORIAN OF JEWISH

THOUGHT AND CULTURE?

One historian’s search for “real” issues.

Page 2: Copernicus and Jewish Thught

1 Issues of Reception

• No room for apologetics!• No “appropriation” of Copernicanism in the

sense that I understand the term.• Is there a typical reaction?

Page 3: Copernicus and Jewish Thught
Page 4: Copernicus and Jewish Thught
Page 5: Copernicus and Jewish Thught

והנה בזמננו זה המציא התוכן הגדול קופערניקוס ציור אחר מהבנין עולם אשר נקרא תכונה חדשה...והתועלת היוצאת מהבנין החדש הם באמת רבים עד לאין

מספר אבל אין כאן מקום לפרשם כולם רק התועלת הכללית הוא שאין אנו צריכין לומר שיש גלגל היומי המתנועע במהירות רב ממזרח למערב ומכריח כל הכוכבים עמו כי המהירות הזה אי אפשר לצייר בשכל כאשר השמש הוא הכוכב היותר גדול

ויתנועע סביב הארץ בכ"ד שעות כל כך היקף גדול וכן שאר הכוכבים ודי בזה למתחיל בחכמה זו

In our own time the great astronomer Copernicus came up with a different conception of the world-structure, which is known as “the new configuration”… The advantages of the new structure are indeed many, even innumerable, but this is not the place to explain them all; just the general advantage, which is that we don’t need to say that the sphere of daily motion moves from east to west with great velocity, forcing all of the stars along with it. Indeed, such a velocity is inconceivable, given that the sun is the largest star, yet makes such a great circuit around the earth in 24 hours, and so also the rest of the stars. This is enough for a beginner in this science.

Page 6: Copernicus and Jewish Thught
Page 7: Copernicus and Jewish Thught

2 “Background” Issues

It was obvious to astronomers in antiquity and the medieval period that the sun plays a role in the motions of all of the planets—even if this fact is not a part of the “Ptolemaic system”.

Many Jewish thinkers of varying background and tendencies took a deep interest in theoretical astronomy—it was a “real issue” for them.

Page 8: Copernicus and Jewish Thught

Let N be an integer number of tropical years, R an integer number of planetary circuits in longitude, and A an integer number of synodic periods. Then, for the outer planets, N=R + A. Good numerical approximations were already known in early Babylonian astronomy.

Otto Neugebauer, HAMA, I, 150-151.

Page 9: Copernicus and Jewish Thught

From an anonymous, incomplete, unpublished medieval Hebrew philosophical text:

גם שלמות מהלכם כמהלכו כי הנה מהלך כל אחד מג' כוכבים העליונים המחובר מגלגלו היוצא

…ומהלך גלגל הקפתו שוה למהלך השמש

their full motion is like its [the sun’s], because the motion of each of the three superior planets, which is the sum of its motion in the epicycle and in its own orb, is equal to the motion of the sun…

Page 10: Copernicus and Jewish Thught

3 Transmission, Migration, and other Modes of Cultural Transfer

• Massive movement eastward of educated Jews from Iberian peninsula to Italy, the Ottoman Realms (and back to Italy)

• Movement back and forth between Poland and Italy

• Constantinople—Venice axis, Constatinople—Venice—Crete triangle

Page 11: Copernicus and Jewish Thught

To look at Islamic civilization as a transmitter of science is to view it from a point outside it…herein, precisely, is the danger that lurks for the Islamist who allows his own choice of research problems to be unduly determined by facts of transmission, however important these may be…the hypothesis seemed plausible that Copernicus might have been influenced by his Islamic predecessors…

But what about the significance of the new models for the history of Islamic astronomy itself? What do we learn from them about the scientific outlook motivation of Islamic astronomers?

A.I. Sabra, “The Appropriation and Subsequent Naturalization of Greek Science in Medieval Islam.”

Page 12: Copernicus and Jewish Thught
tzvi
Page 13: Copernicus and Jewish Thught

Yitzhak ben Shmuel AbÙ-l-Khayr