Upload
stellablue
View
6.680
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Why we must all preserve The Right to Choose.
Citation preview
Health Choice, Vaccine Choice
Why we must all preserve the Right to Choose
Vermont Coalition for Vaccine Choice
• Volunteer ci8zen advocates – Parents, grandparents, physicians, nurses, teachers, midwives
– Nonpar8san, nondenomina8onal; we have members all over the poli8cal and religious spectrum
• Came together in 2012 to preserve Vermont’s “philosophical exemp8on” to vaccina8on – 1979 law enacted when school vaccina8on laws were wriIen
– Allow a parent to refuse one of more vaccines aLer being fully informed on risks of procedure
Backdrop
• Health Reform focus on pharmaceu8cal supply • Vermonters (and others) tend to pursue more natural alterna8ves to wellness
• Liberty being restricted in unprecedented ways from many angles, 9/11
• Vaccines being pushed on a worldwide basis as THE key growth segment of pharma and “the economy”
Liberty: “The Conversation”
"It’s not a le+-‐thing, it’s not a right thing – it’s an American thing. We Americans need to start talking to each other.”
Vermonter Audrey Pietrucha, - http://greenmountainscribes.wordpress.com/2013/08/15/on-liberty-starting-the-conversation/
Health Liberty / Health Choice
“I am not anti-vaccine; rather I am pro-health, pro-informed decision-making and pro-individual liberty.” (link)
-‐ Stephanie Foisy Mills, DC, (NH)
Raw Milk
• hIp://farmtoconsumer.org/raw_milk_map.htm
Individual Rights and Informed Consent
Individual Rights and Informed Consent May, 2013: Portland, Oregon voters strike down fluoride
Individual Rights and Informed Consent “Right to Know” / GM Food
Individual Rights and Informed Consent Vaccines / “Immuniza8ons”
“The microbe is nothing, the terrain is everything.”
• French physiologist, Dr Claude Bernard (1813-‐1878) • Pasteur claimed that the microbe caused the disease • Béchamp maintained that the disease, the disturbed func8oning of the organism enabled the microbe to thrive.
• Pasteur’s approach, which won the day, demands that in terms of treatment methods, the pathogenic microbes must be aIacked by external means
Recommended reading: hIp://www.samanthaflower.co.uk/phdi/p1.nsf/pages/1080:PDF_Bechamp_Pasteur.pdf/$file/PDF_Bechamp_Pasteur.pdf
The Immune System
• A complex network of specialized cells and organs that dis8nguishes between self and foreign molecules inside the body.
• A malfunc8oning immune system can cause allergies or arthri8s and can fail to stop the growth of cancer cells.
Immunology
hIp://plato.stanford.edu/entries/biology-‐self/
R
Organs of the Immune System
Tonsils and adenoids
Lymph nodes
Bone marrow
Appendix
Lymphatic vessels
Lymph nodes
Thymus
Peyer’s patches
Spleen
Lymphatic vessels Lymph nodes
R
Cells of the Immune System Bone graft
Multipotential stem cell
Hematopoietic���stem cell
Platelets
Macrophage
Erythrocytes Eosinophil
Neutrophil
Megakaryocyte
Mast cell
Basophil
T lymphocyte
Natural killer cell
Dendritic cell
B lymphocyte
Lymphoid progenitor cell
Myeloid progenitor
cell
Monocyte
Marrow
Bone
R
The Immune System
and the Nervous System
Thymosins
Macrophage
B cell
T cell
Thymus
Brain
Bone���marrow
Neuroendocrine and autonomic pathways
Immunotransmitters (feedback, regulation and modulation)
Lymphokines Monokines
Balance is Key to a Healthy Immune Response
Dr. David Jockers
Revolving door
hIp://www.geke.us/VennDiagrams.html
Federal Liability Shield US Childhood Vaccine Injury Act – Limited civil lawsuits against vaccine manufacturers aLer DPT, polio seIlements.
– Began in 1988 (DPT, polio, MMR).
– Vaccine Injury Compensa8on Program/Tax • Funded via $0.75 “vaccine excise tax.” • Vaccine Injury Table (legal presump8on of causa8on for
certain vaccines and condi8ons).
• $2.7 billion paid out for vaccine injuries. Sta8s8cs reports: hIp://www.hrsa.gov/vaccinecompensa8on/sta8s8csreports.html#Stats Search/read claims reports: hIp://www.uscfc.uscourts.gov/search_vaccine
2013
+2 vaccines IN UTERO
(flu and Tdap), +Adult vaccine push
* *
* discon8nued
Pharma (AAP) Claim: “The Science is Clear.
Vaccines are Safe and Effective”
NOVEMBER, 2012
Why provide a warning if the paMent or parent cannot say no?
Are Vaccines Perfectly Safe? “Unavoidably Unsafe”
hOp://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/09-‐152.ZS.html
The Vaccine Injury Table – Legal presump8on of causa8on for certain vaccines and condi8ons, including: • Brain damage • Paraly8c disorders • Anaphylaxis • Seizures • See more at: hIp://www.ebcala.org/unanswered-‐
ques8ons/vaccine-‐epidemic#sthash.slRG4L8Z.jxJtRQuN.dpuf
Institute of Medicine Report, 2011
• Independent review of the current epidemiological, clinical, and biologic literature
• There were no recommenda8ons, only findings
Findings in 2011 Report:
• 85% of reac8ons studied had inadequate data • Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence
Over 25,000 Reported Reactions/Yr
VAERS data Only 1-‐10% of Rxn are reported
Are Vaccines Effective? Pertussis: One example
• Vermont's vaccina8on rates have consistently increased over the years (including in 2011/2012).
• Many other states and countries have also seen a resurgence of pertussis. Theories/science: – Vaccine failure – Emergence/selec8on of new strains
• The na8on's top health authori8es have officially stated that exemp8ons have played no part
• 90% of Vermont pertussis cases had been vaccinated – Silent reservoirs of infec8on
hIp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/ar8cles/PMC2863393/. hIp://www.ima.org.il/imaj/ar06may-‐2.pdf hIp://blindedbythelighI.blogspot.com/2013/01/the-‐perfect-‐storm-‐how-‐increase-‐in.html hIp://www.beyondconformity.co.nz/_blog/Hilary's_Desk/post/Whooping_cough_and_chameleons/ hIp://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/ar8cle/6/5/00-‐0512_ar8cle.htm
Vaccines: No liability, Gov’t “cooperation” “Vaccines are no longer a sleepy, low-‐profit niche in a booming drug industry…
The lure of big profits, advances in technology and growing government support has been drawing in new companies…”
“It's going to be characterized as a golden era, says Emilio Emini, Pfizer Inc.'s head of vaccine research.”
Addicted to Drugs
• World drug market is nearing $1 trillion – Vaccine market
• $87 bn by 2022 • High margins (no liability)
• US consumes 60% of pharmaceu8cals – Direct to consumer marke8ng – “the worried well” and seniors
• No new an8bio8cs developed • Chronic disease skyrocke8ng – Especially in our children
“Affordable Care” Act
• All approved vaccines must be covered • 2% bonus to hospitals that make the vaccina8on rate “goals”
• Increased reimbursement for vaccine administra8on
• Pharmacists (new Vermont bill for age 7 and up)
The Vaccine Gravy Train • DHHS largest federal agency $$$ • CDC $$$ • NIH patents • 80% of the Vermont Health Department comes from Federal Grants
• 100% of the vaccina8on program comes from Federal Grants
• Na8onal Childhood Vaccine Injury Act • “Affordable Care” Act
Healthcare versus Sick Care Farmer versus Pharma
• Current healthcare system is broken • Vermont is one of the healthiest states in the US, but pharmaceu8cal and
insurance corpora8ons have far too much influence on our medical system. – Sick care and pharmaceu8cals – Skyrocke8ng costs – Affronts to our freedoms
• Vermont’s health care policy should be shaped by our choices and by the Hippocra8c Oath of first do no harm
• Every Vermonter has a right to clean water, clean air, pure food, and access to medicines – including natural medicines, vitamins and supplements that cannot be patented
and sold for profit • TODAY, primary care physicians in Vermont include DC’s, ND’s and MD/DO
The Hippocratic Oath
• One of the oldest binding medical documents • “I will apply diete8c measures for the benefit of the sick according to my ability and judgment; I will keep them from harm and injus8ce. I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody who asked for it, nor will I make a sugges8on to this effect.”
• Chemotherapy/Pharma?
Should We be Concerned? • Every US manufacturer/supplier of pediatric vaccines has pled guilty to fraud within the last 3 years. – Bribery of doctors – Lying to the FDA – Hiding clinical trial data – Fraudulent marke8ng – For products for which they can be held liable…
hIp://www.omsj.org/blogs/bribery-‐big-‐pharma hIp://www.vaxchoicevt.com/wp-‐content/uploads/2012/08/pharma-‐fraud-‐update8-‐29-‐2012.docx hIp://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/washington/story/2012-‐03-‐05/health-‐drugmakers-‐fraud-‐fines/53372792/1
“This is yet another example of a drug manufacturer that makes unsubstan8ated claims about drug benefits, despite the danger of such statements to the public. This office is commiIed to pursuing companies who violate our consumer protec8on laws and expose Vermonters to harm,” said AIorney General Sorrell on the Pfizer seIlement in 2013.
Pharma Fraud
• Lyrica remains a blockbuster drug for Pfizer despite unlawful promo8on. – hIp://vtdigger.org/2013/02/19/ag-‐sorrell-‐announces-‐that-‐pfizer-‐will-‐
pay-‐vermont-‐611000-‐as-‐part-‐of-‐zyvox-‐and-‐lyrica-‐seIlement/ – hIp://seekingalpha.com/ar8cle/1516292-‐biIer-‐pill-‐of-‐expiring-‐
patents-‐to-‐swallow-‐for-‐pfizer
Who Is Going to Protect You…?
Be an Informed Health Consumer
• Read pa8ent informa8on for prescrip8on meds.
• Read the fine print before signing a contract. • Read food labels. • Take 8me to ensure you are making informed decisions on any health choice you make.
Why are we not Better Informed About Vaccines?
• Vaccines are for-‐profit pharmaceu8cal products.
• Vaccine makers and those who administer them have been granted total liability protec8on by the federal government.
• Vaccines are meant to ar8ficially induce the immune system to produce an8bodies.
What is in that vial? hIp://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/pubs/pinkbook/downloads/appendices/B/excipient-‐table-‐2.pdf
Hepatitis B Vaccine (3 hrs after birth)
• Babies: 3 doses recommended
• Vaccine Court findings: – Systemic Lupus
– Mul8ple Sclerosis Be Aware! No Warning
appears in government required literature.
Forced Vaccination
• An example of extreme governmental viola8on of bodily sovereignty, health liberty and parental rights.
• Fully informed, voluntary health choices and your fundamental human rights are being deliberately challenged.
• Time is running short.
Forced Medication
• Already being “tested” in Courts – Vaccines – Psychotropic and ADHD Drugs
• 2006: "Principles" governing forced treatment of adolescent children, Art Caplan (again) -‐ hIp://virtualmentor.ama-‐assn.org/2007/01/oped1-‐0701.html
– Chemotherapy • Slaughter of the Innocent by Jenny Marsh • hIp://www.alterna8vehealth.co.nz/cancer/chemo/sheep.htm
HealthCare is a Human Right
End Corporate Personhood
Emergency Powers Act
“This is not about individual rights, it’s about Public Health”
“Exemptions” / Opt Outs
www.NVIC.org and www.NVICadvocacy.org
*childhood vaccina8on only!
Individual Rights and Informed Consent
• There is no Federal requirement for informed consent rela8ng to immuniza8on
• State laws govern the power of the health department and the rights of ci8zens to “opt out”
• Childhood vaccine exemp8ons are “under aIack” • Adults need to be aware their rights are unprotected without specific legisla8on
• Conscien8ous Objec8on
Vaccines / “Immuniza8ons”
Flu Vaccine Mandates
Proof s8ll needed to jus8fy pushing flu jab on healthy individuals! Good overview: hIp://barbfeick.com/vaccina8ons/vaccines/flu_vaccine.htm
Maine • LD 694 (HP 523) "An Act To Encourage Transparency in Disclosing the Ingredients in Vaccina8ons for Children to Parents and Guardians" Sponsored by Representa8ve Andrea Boland
• LD 941 (SP 287) "An Act To Prohibit Mandatory Immuniza8ons" Sponsored by Senator Douglas Thomas
Wisconsin • Bill AB247: prohibits any employer, including the state and local governments, from demo8ng, suspending, discharging, or otherwise discrimina8ng against an employee or contractor for refusing to be vaccinated against seasonal influenza
Bills to add Conscientious/Philosophical Exemptions
• New Jersey: A1368 • New York: A 6359, S 3934
Vermont: “Healthiest State” 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012
Healthy Behaviors lead to Healthy People • Exercise • Smoking
• Alcohol • Pure Water
• Pure Air • Whole Foods
Vermont, 2011 3 fatalities after vaccination (VAERS reports)
February, 2011 – Boy, age 5
• Epilepsy and cerebral palsy
• Shots: DTaP, IPV, VZV
• Found dead in bed 20 hours aLer vaccina8on
December, 2011 – Girl, age 7
• Healthy
• Shots: Fluzone
• Died 5 days later of “myocardi8s of unknown e8ology”
December, 2011 – Male, age 52
• Medical history unremarkable except for psychiatric disorder
• Shots: HepA/B combo (“twinrix”)
• Died 21 days later of liver failure
Alarmist?
• “Of course, it’s important for parents to understand the risks and benefits, and I have absolute respect for their right to make their own decisions… But I don’t think that being alarmist contributes to overall public health. Vaccines have saved countless lives.”
–Harry Chen, Vermont Health Commissioner
as quoted by Seven Days Newspaper, 1/11/2012
Not Good Enough?
• “Although many children in Vermont have had most of their vaccinations, little more than 60 percent have had all of the doses for all of the vaccines recommended for their age group.”
–Harry Chen, Vermont Health Commissioner
as quoted by Seven Days Newspaper, 4/27/2011
Vermont, 2012 • Effort to remove Vermont’s philosophical vaccine
exempMon – Vermont Dept. of Health Immuniza8on Advisory CommiIee
– Allopathic Medical Industry Lobbyists
• Pfizer • Vermont Associa8on of Hospitals and Health Systems (VAHHS)
• American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP)
• Fletcher Allen • Vermont Medical Society
– Vermont Ethics Network
– Coordinated statewide media/PR campaign star8ng in 2011
Vermont: Act 157 of 2012
• Vaccine Exemp8ons preserved – Overwhelming 133-‐6 house majority vote.
• Grassroots Voices of The People – This upset George Till (D-‐Jericho):
• “They were in the building every day, in people’s faces*.” • Claims that whooping cough outbreak due to exemp8ons.
• Health Dept. directed to focus on educa8on, using: – “evidence-‐based educaConal material provided by the department of health regarding immunizaCons, including informaCon about the risks of adverse reacCons to immunizaCon”
* Slate Health and Medicine Online ar8cle -‐ 2/21/2013
Vermont • Exemp8ons (philosophical and religious) since 1979
• 2012: BaIle to keep exemp8ons • Senate: 25-‐4 to remove philosophical exemp8on • Thousands par8cipated in their own democracy • House: 133-‐6 voted to keep philosophical exemp8on
• Con8nued “witch hunt” and tracking of all refusers
Divide and Conquer
Medical Politics at School
Efforts to s8r fear of outbreaks, divide communi8es Financial Rewards and Punishments School “Health Liaisons” Access to records through LDS (Dept. of Educa8on) Bill to force consolida8on of school districts/enhance the concentra8on of decision making power “Voices for Vaccines” – nonprofit, pharma-‐supported parent corpora8on encouraging parents to speak out and discriminate against vaccine refusers
Parental Rights at Stake
• “the government’s interest in protecCng children from geFng the measles should trump parents’ interest in making medical decisions for their kids”
• Parents making informed choices = acting in child’s best interest. • Using public education or employment to force medical political agendas restricts our liberty.
• August 2013 Media Blitz • 5 other ar8cles in Vermont alone • Gray Media Co. of Boston
2013 Vermont Bills • H.138 / S.102 (Till, Mullin)
– Transfer of power from Legislature to Health Commissioner/Agency (loss of democraMc voice)
– Forced Vaccina8on if rates drop below “90% Trigger” • Includes Adult employees, Volunteers and Children • For any ONE vaccine • School by School
– How do you determine which 10% get to exercise their rights?
– Unvaccinated already go home during epidemics.
Is Preventative Care as Simple as “A Lifetime of Vaccines”?
• Marketing vaccines to pregnant women • 36 shots by age 6 (kindergarten) • 17 more shots for adolescents • 10 more shots for adults • 300 vaccines in the “pipeline”
Vaccines are Not Seat Belts
• They are more like air bags. • They can/do go off at the wrong 8me or explode too forcefully.
• They can cause death or disability. • That is why most vehicles today have switches to turn airbags on or off, and why Vermont allows philosophical exemp8on.
Informed Consent • You have the right to be given full informa8on about the benefits and risks of a medical treatment before agreeing to the treatment.
• You have the right to voluntarily agree or to refuse to the medical treatment.
• Nuremberg prohibits scien8fic experimenta8on without informed consent.
• United Na8ons declara8on on bioethics and human rights in 2005.
hIp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/ar8cles/PMC2352998/ hIp://history.nih.gov/research/downloads/nuremberg.pdf hIp://portal.unesco.org/en/ev.php-‐URL_ID=31058&URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&URL_SECTION=201.html
Intensive Lobbying for Vaccine Mandates
• Mandatory Flu vaccines (NJ, MT, IL, MO, CT, PA)
• Mandatory Meningi8s vaccine (IL, KS, NE, MO, NY, TX, TN) • Mandatory HPV (Human Pappilloma Virus) vaccine (NY, KY, SC,
GA, FL)
• Mandatory Hepa88s vaccines (MN) • Mandatory TDaP vaccine (NE, VT)
• Plus: – Bills to allows addi8onal prac88oners (e.g. optometrists or pharmacists) to
administer vaccines (CA,NC, GA, OH, OR, NJ, VT)
– Elimina8on of parental consent requirement for some vaccines (NY, TX)
– Restric8on or removal of exemp8ons (OR, NJ, VT
– Restric8ve changes in vaccina8on tracking system (ID, ND, MT, TX)
What’s Next?
• 300 vaccines under development • More vaccines to be added to the “schedule” • Pediatricians “firing” pa8ents • Adult vaccina8ons as a pre-‐requisite for employment: – Vermont Teachers – Vermont Health Care Workers
• “Ethical” arguments against parental choice
Genetic Modification
• GMOs are “gene8cally modified organisms” – Plants or animals created using gene splicing techniques of biotechnology (also called gene8c engineering, or GE).
– Merges DNA from different species, crea8ng unstable combina8ons of plant, animal, bacterial and viral genes that cannot occur in nature or in tradi8onal crossbreeding.
– FDA: “all vaccines and biological products contain contaminating DNA derived from the cell substrate used for manufacture”
Our Microbiota
“The history of science, and in parCcular medical science, is a history of progress and change over Cme. The medical orthodoxy of one generaCon is viewed as quaint history by the next generaCon. The great thing about science is that it is subject to constant reflecCon, experimentaCon and self-‐correcCon. There will be advances in medical science and today’s orthodoxies will no doubt be viewed differently in the future.”
-‐ Vermonter Mitchell Pearl
What Can You Do?
• Register for updates through www.NVICadvocacy.com
• Talk to your lawmakers
• Broadcast widely the need for conscien8ous objec8on clauses – Childhood vaccina8on programs
– Employment – Emergency Powers
Thank You!