View
0
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
.3 7+( 83.7(' 67$7(6 '.675.&7 &4857 )45 7+( 6487+(53 '.675.&7 4) 3(:
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 2 of 86
���� %aaU� 6ZLW]HUOaQG
0$57,1 6+.5(/,� LQGLYLGXaOO\� aV aQ RZQHU aQG IRUPHU GLUHFWRU RI 3KRHQL[XV $* aQG a IRUPHU H[HFXWLYH RI 9\HUa 3KaUPaFHXWLFaOV� //&�
)&, $OOHQZRRG /RZ )HGHUaO &RUUHFWLRQaO ,QVWLWXWLRQ 3�2� %R[ ���� :KLWH 'HHU� 3$ �����
aQG
.(9,1 08//($'
�������� et seq�� IRU a SHUPaQHQW LQMXQFWLRQ aQG RWKHU HTXLWaEOH UHOLHI� LQFOXGLQJ HTXLWaEOH
PRQHWaU\ UHOLHI� aJaLQVW 'HIHQGaQWV 9\HUa 3KaUPaFHXWLFaOV� //& �³9\HUa´�� 3KRHQL[XV $*
�³3KRHQL[XV´�� 0aUWLQ 6KNUHOL� aQG .HYLQ 0XOOHaG\ WR XQGR aQG SUHYHQW WKHLU aQWLFRPSHWLWLYH
FRQGXFW aQG XQIaLU PHWKRGV RI FRPSHWLWLRQ LQ RU aIIHFWLQJ F RPPHUFH LQ YLROaWLRQ RI 6HFWLRQV �
aQG � RI WKH 6KHUPaQ $FW� �� 8�6�&� ÙÙ �� �� 6HFWLRQ ��a� RI WKH )HGHUaO 7UaGH &RPPLVVLRQ $FW�
�� 8�6�&� ٠���a�� aQG VWaWH OaZ�
.� 3DWXUH RI WKH &DVH
�� 7KLV FaVH FKaOOHQJHV a FRPSUHKHQVLYH VFKHPH E\ 9\HUa� LWV SaUHQW FRPSaQ\
3KRHQL[XV� aQG WZR RI WKH FRPSaQLHV’ RZQHUV aQG H[HFXWLYHV� 6KNUHOL aQG 0XOOHaG\� WR EORFN
ORZHU�FRVW JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ WR 'aUaSULP� aQ HVVHQWLaO GUXJ XVHG WR WUHaW WKH SRWHQWLaOO\ IaWaO
SaUaVLWLF LQIHFWLRQ WR[RSOaVPRVLV� 7KHLU XQOaZIXO VFKHPH WR PaLQWaLQ a PRQRSRO\ RQ 'aUaSULP
FRQWLQXHV WR WKLV Ga\�
�� 'aUaSULP KaG EHHQ VROG aV aQ aIIRUGaEOH� OLIH�VaYLQJ WUHaWPHQW IRU PRUH WKaQ ��
\HaUV� ,Q ����� KRZHYHU� 'HIHQGaQWV aFTXLUHG WKH 8�6� ULJKWV WR 'aUaSULP IURP WKH RQO\ H[LVWLQJ
VXSSOLHU aQG LPPHGLaWHO\ UaLVHG WKH SULFH IURP ������ WR ���� SHU WaEOHW�aQ LQFUHaVH RI PRUH
WKaQ ������� 7KLV PaVVLYH SULFH KLNH GHOLYHUHG LPPHGLaWH EHQHILWV WR 'HIHQGaQWV� LQFUHaVLQJ
'aUaSULP’V aQQXaO UHYHQXHV IURP WR RYHU �
�� 'HIHQGaQWV NQHZ� WKRXJK� WKaW WKLV UHYHQXH ERRQ FRXOG EH VKRUW OLYHG� 'aUaSULP
KaG QR SaWHQW RU UHJXOaWRU\ SURWHFWLRQ aQG WKH PaVVLYH SULFH LQFUHaVH ZRXOG aWWUaFW FRPSHWLWLRQ
IURP ORZHU�SULFHG JHQHULF SURGXFWV� 7R SUHVHUYH WKH 'aUaSULP UHYHQXH VWUHaP� 9\HUa aQG
3KRHQL[XV�XQGHU WKH GLUHFWLRQ RI 6KNUHOL aQG 0XOOHaG\�H[HFXWHG aQ HOaERUaWH� PXOWL�SaUW
VFKHPH WR EORFN JHQHULF HQWU\�
�� )LUVW� 'HIHQGaQWV FUHaWHG a FRPSOH[ ZHE RI FRQWUaFWXaO UHVWULFWLRQV WKaW SURKLELW
GLVWULEXWRUV aQG SXUFKaVHUV IURP UHVHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV RU WKHLU aJHQWV�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 3 of 86
�
'HIHQGaQWV XQGHUVWRRG WKaW UHVWULFWLQJ aFFHVV WR EUaQGHG 'aUaSULP FRXOG VWLIOH JHQHULF
FRPSHWLWLRQ� 7KH 8�6� )RRG 'UXJ $ GPLQLVWUaWLRQ �³)'$´� UHTXLUHV aQ\ JHQHULF aSSOLFaQW WR
FRQGXFW ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ FRPSaULQJ LWV SURGXFW WR VaPSOHV RI WKH EUaQGHG GUXJ� 9\HUa’V
UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV PaGH LW YLUWXaOO\ LPSRVVLEOH IRU JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV WR SXUFKaVH VXIILFLHQW
TXaQWLWLHV RI 'aUaSULP WR FRQGXFW WKHVH )'$�UHTXLUHG WHVWV� ,QGHHG� VHYHUaO JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV
WULHG IRU PRUH WKaQ a \HaU WR VHFXUH HQRXJK EUaQGHG 'aUaSULP VaPSOHV IRU WHVWLQJ� EXW ZHUH
XQaEOH WR GR VR� $W OHaVW RQH RWKHU JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ VLPSO\ aEaQGRQHG LWV GHYHORSPHQW SOaQV�
�� 6HFRQG� 'HIHQGaQWV FXW RII FRPSHWLWRUV’ aFFHVV WR S\ULPHWKaPLQH�WKH aFWLYH
SKaUPaFHXWLFaO LQJUHGLHQW �³$3,´� QHFHVVaU\ WR PaQXIaFWXUH 'aUaSULP� 'HIHQGaQWV ILUVW ORFNHG
XS )XNX]\X 3KaUPaFHXWLFaO &R�� /WG�� WKH RQO\ VXSSOLHU aSSURYHG WR PaQXIaFWXUH S\ULPHWKaPLQH
IRU WKH 8�6� PaUNHW� 8QGHU WKH H[FOXVLYH VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQW� )XNX]\X XQHTXLYRFaOO\ aJUHHG QRW WR
VHOO S\ULPHWKaPLQH IRU KXPaQ XVH LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV WR aQ\RQH RWKHU WKaQ 'HIHQGaQWV�
�� $IWHU ORFNLQJ XS )XNX]\X� 'HIHQGaQWV PRYHG WR VLGHOLQH a QHZ SRWHQWLaO
PaQXIaFWXUHU� 5/ )LQH &KHP 3YW� /WG� 8SRQ OHaUQLQJ WKaW PXOWLSOH JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV KaG EHHQ
ZRUNLQJ Z LWK 5/ )LQH WR GHYHORS WKHLU JHQHULF 'aUaSULP SURGXFWV� 'HIHQGaQWV H[HFXWHG aQRWKHU
H[FOXVLYH VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQW� 'HIHQGaQWV KaG QR QHHG IRU a VHFRQG VRXUFH RI $3,� QHYHU
SXUFKaVHG aQ\ $3, IURP 5/ )LQH� aQG QHYHU HYHQ FRPSOHWHG WKH UHJXOaWRU\ ZRUN QHFHVVaU\ WR
XVH 5/ )LQH’V $3, LQ 'aUaSULP� 1RQHWKHOHVV� XQGHU WKLV aJUHHPHQW� 3KRHQL[XV KaV SaLG 5/ )LQH
QHaUO\ QRW WR VXSSO\ LWV SRWHQWLaO FRPSHWLWRUV�ZKLOH LW KaV SaLG )XNX]\X RQO\
IRU WKH $3, LW aFWXaOO\ XVHV LQ LWV 'aUaSULP SURGXFW�
�� 7KLUG� 'HIHQGaQWV VLJQHG ³GaWa�EORFNLQJ´ aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK 9\HUa’V GLVWULEXWRUV WR
SUHYHQW WKHP IURP VHOOLQJ WKHLU 'aUaSULP VaOHV GaWa WR WKLUG�SaUW\ GaWa UHSRUWLQJ FRPSaQLHV� VXFK
aV ,49,$� 7KHVH UHSRUWLQJ FRPSaQLHV SXUFKaVH� FRPSLOH� aQG VHOO VaOHV GaWa RQ SKaUPaFHXWLFaO
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 4 of 86
�
SURGXFWV� ZKLFK JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV WKHQ EX\� 7KHVH GaWa aUH FULWLFaO IRU JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV’
aVVHVVPHQW RI ZKHWKHU a JLYHQ GHYHORSPHQW RSSRUWXQLW\ LV ZRUWK SXUVXLQJ� 'HIHQGaQWV’ GaWa�
EORFNLQJ aJUHHPHQWV SUHYHQWHG WKH UHSRUWLQJ F RPSaQLHV IURP REWaLQLQJ aFFXUaWH LQIRUPaWLRQ
aERXW 'aUaSULP VaOHV� %\ REVFXULQJ WKHVH VaOHV� 'HIHQGaQWV VRXJKW WR SUHYHQW JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV
IURP aFFXUaWHO\ aVVHVVLQJ WKH PaUNHW RSSRUWXQLW\ IRU a JHQHULF 'aUaSULP SURGXFW aQG WKHUHE\
GHWHU WKHP IURP HYHQ SXUVXLQJ GHYHORSPHQW RI a JHQHULF SURGXFW�
�� 7KH SXUSRVH aQG HIIHFW RI 'HIHQGaQWV’ aQWLFRPSHWLWLYH FRQGXFW KaV EHHQ WR WKZaUW
SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ aQG SURWHFW WKH 'aUaSULP UHYHQXHV UHVXOWLQJ I URP 9\HUa’V
VKRFNLQJ SULFH LQFUHaVH� $EVHQW 'HIHQGaQWV’ aQWLFRPSHWLWLYH FRQGXFW� 'aUaSULP ZRXOG KaYH
IaFHG JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ \HaUV aJR� ,QVWHaG� WR[RSOaVPRVLV SaWLHQWV ZKR QHHG 'aUaSULP WR
VXUYLYH ZHUH GHQLHG WKH RSSRUWXQLW\ WR SXUFKaVH a ORZHU�FRVW JHQHULF YHUVLRQ� IRUFLQJ WKHP aQG
RWKHU SXUFKaVHUV WR Sa\ WHQV RI PLOOLRQV RI GROOaUV a \HaU PRUH IRU WKLV OLIH�VaYLQJ PHGLFaWLRQ�
..� /XULVGLFWLRQ DQG 9HQXH
�� 7KLV &RXUW KaV VXEMHFW PaWWHU MXULVGLFWLRQ RYHU WKLV aFWLRQ SXUVXaQW WR �� 8�6�&�
ÙÙ ����� �����a�� aQG ����� aV ZHOO aV XQGHU WKH SULQFLSOHV RI VXSSOHPHQWaO MXULVGLFWLRQ FRGLILHG
LQ �� 8�6�&� Ù �����a�� 7KLV &RXUW’V H[HUFLVH RI VXSSOHPHQWaO MXULVGLFWLRQ RYHU 3OaLQWLIIV’ VWaWH
OaZ FOaLPV ZRXOG aYRLG XQQHFHVVaU\ GXSOLFaWLRQ aQG PXOWLSOLFLW\ RI aFWLRQV� aQG VKRXOG EH
H[HUFLVHG LQ WKH LQWHUHVWV RI MXGLFLaO HFRQRP\� FRQYHQLHQFH� aQG IaLUQHVV�
��� 7KLV &RXUW KaV SHUVRQaO MXULVGLFWLRQ RYHU 9\HUa� 3KRHQL[XV� 6KNUHOL� aQG
0XOOHaG\ EHFaXVH HaFK KaV WKH UHTXLVLWH FRQVWLWXWLRQaO FRQWaFWV ZLWK WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV RI
$PHULFa SXUVXaQW WR �� 8�6�&� ٠���E�� 7KLV &RXUW aOVR KaV SHUVRQaO MXULVGLFWLRQ RYHU 9\HUa�
3KRHQL[XV� 6KNUHOL� aQG 0XOOHaG\ EHFaXVH HaFK KaV WKH UHTXLVLWH FRQVWLWXWLRQaO FRQWaFWV ZLWK WKH
VWaWH RI 1HZ
FRPPLWWLQJ LOOHJaO aFWV aV aOOHJHG KHUHLQ ZLWKLQ WKH VWaWH RI 1HZ
WKLV LV a SURSHU FaVH IRU SHUPaQHQW LQMXQFWLYH UHOLHI ZLWKLQ WKH PHaQLQJ RI 6HFWLRQ ���E� RI WKH
)7& $FW� �� 8�6�&� ٠���E��
%� 3ODLQWLII 6WDWH RI 3HZ
DQG UHPHG\ WKH KDUPV FDDVHG E\ DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH FRQGDFW� 7KH VWDWH DOVR KDV DDWKRULW\ WR VHHN
FLELO SHQDOWLHV DQGHU VWDWH ODZ WR SDQLVK DQG GHWHU WKRVH HQJDJHG LQ DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH FRQGDFW�
E. PQaLQWLII SWaWH RI NRUWK CaURQLQa
��� 3ODLQWLII 6WDWH RI 1RUWK &DUROLQD LV D VREHUHLJQ VWDWH� -RVKDD +� 6WHLQ LV WKH
$WWRUQH\ *HQHUDO RI WKH 6WDWH RI 1RUWK &DUROLQD� WKH FKLHI OHJDO RIILFHU IRU WKH VWDWH� DQG EULQJV
WKLV DFWLRQ RQ EHKDOI RI WKH SHRSOH RI WKH 6WDWH RI 1RUWK &DUROLQD WR SURWHFW WKH VWDWH� LWV JHQHUDO
HFRQRP\� DQG LWV UHVLGHQWV IURP 'HIHQGDQWV„ DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH EDVLQHVV SUDFWLFHV� 7KH $WWRUQH\
*HQHUDO KDV DDWKRULW\ DQGHU IHGHUDO DQG VWDWH ODZ WR SDUVDH DQ LQMDQFWLRQ DQG RWKHU HTDLWDEOH
UHOLHI WR SUHEHQW DQG UHPHG\ WKH KDUPV FDDVHG E\ DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH FRQGDFW� 7KH VWDWH DOVR KDV
DDWKRULW\ WR VHHN FLELO SHQDOWLHV DQGHU VWDWH ODZ WR SDQLVK DQG GHWHU WKRVH HQJDJHG LQ
DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH FRQGDFW�
F. PQaLQWLII SWaWH RI OKLR
��� 3ODLQWLII 6WDWH RI 2KLR LV D VREHUHLJQ VWDWH� 'DELG
7KH $WWRUQH\ *HQHUDO KDV DDWKRULW\ DQGHU IHGHUDO DQG VWDWH ODZ WR SDUVDH DQ LQMDQFWLRQ DQG RWKHU
HTDLWDEOH UHOLHI WR SUHEHQW DQG UHPHG\ WKH KDUPV FDDVHG E\ DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH FRQGDFW� 7KH VWDWH
DOVR KDV DDWKRULW\ WR VHHN FLELO SHQDOWLHV DQGHU VWDWH ODZ WR SDQLVK DQG GHWHU WKRVH HQJDJHG LQ
DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH FRQGDFW�
H. PQaLQWLII CRPPRQZHaQWK RI VLUJLQLa
��� 3ODLQWLII &RPPRQZHDOWK RI 9LUJLQLD LV D VREHUHLJQ VWDWH� 0DUN 5� +HUULQJ LV WKH
$WWRUQH\ *HQHUDO RI WKH &RPPRQZHDOWK RI 9LUJLQLD� WKH FKLHI OHJDO RIILFHU IRU WKH VWDWH� DQG
EULQJV WKLV DFWLRQ RQ EHKDOI RI WKH SHRSOH RI WKH &RPPRQZHDOWK RI 9LUJLQLD WR SURWHFW WKH VWDWH�
LWV JHQHUDO HFRQRP\� DQG LWV UHVLGHQWV IURP 'HIHQGDQWV„ DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH EDVLQHVV SUDFWLFHV� 7KH
$WWRUQH\ *HQHUDO KDV DDWKRULW\ DQGHU IHGHUDO DQG VWDWH ODZ WR SDUVDH DQ LQMDQFWLRQ DQG RWKHU
HTDLWDEOH UHOLHI WR SUHEHQW DQG UHPHG\ WKH KDUPV FDDVHG E\ DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH FRQGDFW� 7KH VWDWH
DOVR KDV DDWKRULW\ WR VHHN FLELO SHQDOWLHV DQGHU VWDWH ODZ WR SDQLVK DQG GHWHU WKRVH HQJDJHG LQ
DQWLFRPSHWLWLEH FRQGDFW�
I. CRUSRUaWH DHIHQGaQWV
��� 3KRHQL[DV $* LV D SULEDWHO\�KHOG� IRU�SURILW 6ZLVV FRUSRUDWLRQ ZLWK LWV SULQFLSDO
SODFH RI EDVLQHVV ORFDWHG LQ %DDU� 6ZLW²HUODQG� 3KRHQL[DV ZDV SUHELRDVO\ NQRZQ DV 7DULQJ
3KDUPDFHDWLFDOV $* DQG 9\HUD 3KDUPDFHDWLFDOV $*� 3KRHQL[DV WUDQVDFWV RU KDV WUDQVDFWHG
EDVLQHVV LQ WKLV 'LVWULFW�
��� 3KRHQL[DV LV HQJDJHG LQ WKH PDQDIDFWDUH DQG GLVWULEDWLRQ RI WKH SKDUPDFHDWLFDO
SURGDFW 'DUDSULP� 3KRHQL[DV DFTDLUHG WKH ULJKWV WR PDUNHW DQG GLVWULEDWH 'DUDSULP LQ WKH 8QLWHG
6WDWHV LQ $DJDVW ����� ,W GHVLJQDWHG LWV ZKROO\�RZQHG VDEVLGLDU\� 9\HUD 3KDUPDFHDWLFDOV� //&�
DV WKH H[FODVLEH 8�6� GLVWULEDWRU IRU 'DUDSULP� 3KRHQL[DV LV UHVSRQVLEOH IRU WKH PDQDIDFWDUH DQG
ZDUHKRDVLQJ RI 'DUDSULP DQG VHOOV WKH SURGDFW WR 9\HUD IRU GLVWULEDWLRQ LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 9 of 86
�
3KRHQL[DV LV DOVR LQEROEHG LQ WKH GLVWULEDWLRQ� SULFLQJ� DQG FRPPHUFLDO DQG PDUNHWLQJ DFWLELWLHV
RI 'DUDSULP�
��� 9\HUD 3KDUPDFHDWLFDOV� //&� LV D SULEDWHO\�KHOG� IRU�SURILW OLPLWHG OLDELOLW\
FRUSRUDWLRQ WKDW LV ZKROO\ RZQHG E\ 3KRHQL[DV $*� 9\HUD LV LQFRUSRUDWHG LQ 'HODZDUH ZLWK LWV
SULQFLSDO SODFH RI EDVLQHVV ORFDWHG LQ 1HZ
J. IQGLYLGXaQ DHIHQGaQWV
1. MaUWLQ SKPUHQL
��� 0DUWLQ 6KNUHOL LV WKH IRDQGHU RI 3KRHQL[DV DQG 9\HUD� WKH ODUJHVW VKDUHKROGHU DQG
IRUPHU FKDLUPDQ RI WKH ERDUG RI 3KRHQL[DV� DQG WKH IRUPHU &(2 RI 9\HUD� $W DOO WLPHV PDWHULDO
WR WKLV &RPSODLQW� DFWLQJ DORQH RU LQ FRQFHUW ZLWK RWKHUV� 6KNUHOL KDV IRUPDODWHG� GLUHFWHG�
FRQWUROOHG� KDG WKH DDWKRULW\ WR FRQWURO� RU SDUWLFLSDWHG LQ WKH DFWV DQG SUDFWLFHV VHW IRUWK LQ WKLV
&RPSODLQW� 6KNUHOL UHVLGHG LQ WKLV 'LVWULFW DQWLO KLV IHGHUDO LQFDUFHUDWLRQ IRU VHFDULWLHV IUDDG LQ
����� ,Q FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK WKH FRQGDFW DOOHJHG KHUHLQ� KH WUDQVDFWV RU KDV WUDQVDFWHG EDVLQHVV LQ
WKLV 'LVWULFW DQG WKURDJKRDW WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV�
��� 3ULRU WR IRDQGLQJ 9\HUD� IURP ���� WR ����� 6KNUHOL IRDQGHG DQG UDQ WKUHH KHGJH
IDQGV� DOO RI ZKLFK IDLOHG�
��� ,Q ����� 6KNUHOL DEDQGRQHG KHGJH IDQGV IRU SKDUPDFHDWLFDOV� +H IRDQGHG WKH
SKDUPDFHDWLFDO FRPSDQ\ 5HWURSKLQ� ,QF�� GHVSLWH KDELQJ QR SKDUPDFHDWLFDO EDVLQHVV H[SHULHQFH�
��� 'DULQJ KLV EULHI WHQDUH DW 5HWURSKLQ� 6KNUHOL DFTDLUHG 7KLROD� D VROH�VRDUFH GUDJ
IRU D VPDOO EDW GHSHQGHQW SDWLHQW SRSDODWLRQ� SODFHG LW LQWR D UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEDWLRQ V\VWHP� DQG
VLJQLILFDQWO\ LQFUHDVHG WKH SULFH� +H VWDWHG DW WKH WLPH WKDW KH LQWHQGHG WR DVH GLVWULEDWLRQ
UHVWULFWLRQV WR SUHEHQW JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ WR 7KLROD�
��� 6KNUHOL ZDV RDVWHG IURP 5HWURSKLQ LQ ���� E\ WKH ERDUG RI GLUHFWRUV IRU
PLVFRQGDFW UHODWLQJ WR LPSURSHU JUDQWV DQG WUDGHV RI FRPSDQ\ VWRFN�
��� 8SRQ OHDELQJ 5HWURSKLQ� 6KNUHOL VWDUWHG 9\HUD WR ORRN IRU VLPLODU SURGDFWV ZLWK
ZKLFK WR UHSOLFDWH KLV 5HWURSKLQ VWUDWHJ\�
��� $V IRDQGHU DQG &(2 RI 9\HUD� 6KNUHOL GLUHFWHG WKH PLQDWH GHWDLOV RI 9\HUD„V
EDVLQHVV DQG VWUDWHJ\� LQFODGLQJ WKH GHFLVLRQ WR DFTDLUH 'DUDSULP� VHFDULQJ D VRDUFH IRU WKH
GUDJ„V $3,� DQG LPSOHPHQWLQJ D UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEDWLRQ V\VWHP�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 11 of 86
��
��� 6KNUHOL UHPaLQHG &(2 XQWLO KLV aUUHVW LQ 'HFHPEHU ���� IRU VHFXULWLHV IUaXG
VWHPPLQJ IURP FRQGXFW aW KLV KHGJH IXQGV aQG aW 5HWURSKLQ� +H ZaV VXEVHTXHQWO\ FRQYLFWHG RI
VHYHUaO IHORQLHV� LQFOXGLQJ VHFXULWLHV IUaXG aQG FRQVSLUaF\ WR FRPPLW VHFXULWLHV IUaXG� aQG
VHQWHQFHG WR VHYHQ \HaUV LQ IHGHUaO SULVRQ� 6KNUHOL UHPaLQHG IUHH RQ EaLO XQWLO 6HSWHPEHU �����
ZKHQ KLV EaLO ZaV UHYRNHG IRU PaNLQJ WKUHaWV aJaLQVW +LOOaU\ &OLQWRQ�
��� :LWK WKH H[FHSWLRQ RI a EULHI SHULRG LQ WKH ILUVW KaOI RI ����� 6KNUHOL KaV
PaLQWaLQHG KLV LQIOXHQFH RYHU 3KRHQL[XV aQG 9\HUa WKURXJK aVVRFLaWHV aV ZHOO aV KLV SRVLWLRQ aV
3KRHQL[XV’V OaUJHVW VKaUHKROGHU� 6KNUHOL’V ORQJWLPH aOO\ 5RQ 7LOOHV VHUYHG aV LQWHULP &(2 IURP
6KNUHOL’V GHSaUWXUH LQ 'HFHPEHU ���� XQWLO $SULO ����� 7LOOHV FR�IRXQGHG 5HWURSKLQ ZLWK 6KNUHOL
aQG ZaV a IRXQGLQJ ERaUG PHPEHU RI 3KRHQL[XV� $V GHWaLOHG LQ a UHSRUW E\ WKH 8�6� 6HQaWH
6SHFLaO &RPPLWWHH RQ $JLQJ� 7LOOHV ZaV 6KNUHOL’V ³KaQGSLFNHG VXFFHVVRU´�³a EURNHU E\
WUaLQLQJ ZKRVH PaLQ VNLOOVHW ZaV VROLFLWLQJ LQYHVWRUV aQG ZKR� E\ KLV RZQ aGPLVVLRQ� GLG QRW
NQRZ WKH PRVW EaVLF RI SKaUPaFHXWLFaO FRQFHSWV�´
��� ,Q $SULO ����� 0U� 7LOOHV ZaV EULHIO\ UHSOaFHG E\ 'U� (OLVHR 6aOLQaV� :KHQ 'U�
6aOLQaV SURYHG UHVLVWaQW WR 6KNUHOL’V LQIOXHQFH� KRZHYHU� 6KNUHOL ZaJHG a VXFFHVVIXO SUR[\ ILJKW
WR RXVW 'U� 6aOLQaV aQG WKH 3KRHQL[XV ERaUG�
��� ,Q -XQH ����� 6KNUHOL’V FORVH aVVRFLaWHV� LQFOXGLQJ 0XOOHaG\ aQG $NHHO 0LWKaQL�
ZHUH HOHFWHG WR 3KRHQL[XV’V ERaUG RI GLUHFWRUV� 0XOOHaG\ aQG 0LWKaQL ZHUH aSSRLQWHG aV WKH RQO\
WZR PHPEHUV RI WKH ERaUG’V QHZO\�IRUPHG ³([HFXWLYH &RPPLWWHH�´ ZKLFK ZRXOG ³SHUIRUP
H[HFXWLYH IXQFWLRQV aQG >] WaNH RYHU WKH WaVNV RI WKH 6HQLRU 0aQaJHPHQW �&(2� &)2� &&2 aQG
&/2� RQ a WHPSRUaU\ EaVLV�´ 0XOOHaG\ ZaV aSSRLQWHG LQWHULP &(2 QRWZLWKVWaQGLQJ WKH
FRQFHUQV RI VRPH ERaUG PHPEHUV WKaW
0XOOHaG\’V aSSRLQWPHQW
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 12 of 86
��
0XOOHaG\ aVVXPHG WKH SRVLWLRQ RI LQWHULP &(2 RI 9\HUa LQ 6HSWHPEHU ����
aQG &(2 LQ 1RYHPEHU �����
��� 0LWKaQL LV 6KNUHOL’V SURWÃJÃ� 0LWKaQL REWaLQHG KLV XQGHUJUaGXaWH GHJUHH LQ ����
aQG VRRQ EHJaQ FRPPXQLFaWLQJ ZLWK 6KNUHOL WKURXJK 7ZLWWHU� ,Q ����� 6KNUHOL LQYLWHG KLP WR
aSSO\ IRU a MRE aW 9\HUa aV a MXQLRU EXVLQHVV GHYHORSPHQW aQaO\VW� ZKLFK 0LWKaQL GLG QRW JHW
EHFaXVH �LQ KLV RZQ ZRUGV� KH ³VRUHO\ OaFNHG WKH TXaOLILFaWLRQV�´ ,Q -XQH ����� KRZHYHU� 6KNUHOL
VHFXUHG 0LWKaQL’V HOHFWLRQ WR WKH 3KRHQL[XV ERaUG� 6LQFH WKHQ� 0LWKaQL KaV EHHQ a PHPEHU RI WKH
ERaUG’V ([HFXWLYH &RPPLWWHH aV ZHOO aV H[HFXWLYH GLUHFWRU aQG VHQLRU YLFH SUHVLGHQW RI EXVLQHVV
GHYHORSPHQW RI 9\HUa�
��� %\ $XJXVW ����� 6KNUHOL ZaV RQFH aJaLQ IRUPaOO\ HYaOXaWLQJ EXVLQHVV
GHYHORSPHQW RSWLRQV IRU 9\HUa aQG ZRUNLQJ RQ QHZ WaFWLFV WR LPSHGH JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ IRU
'aUaSULP� 3KRHQL[XV aOVR LQLWLaWHG a VKaUH EX\�EaFN LQLWLaWLYH� ZKLFK VHYHUaO VKaUHKROGHUV IHOW
ZaV ³PHUHO\ LQWHQGHG WR LQFUHaVH 0aUWLQ 6KNUHOL’V KROGLQJ LQ WKH FRPSaQ\ aQG WR IaFLOLWaWH KLV
FRQWURO RYHU LW�´
��� 6LQFH KLV LQFaUFHUaWLRQ LQ 6HSWHPEHU ����� 6KNUHOL KaV UHPaLQHG LQ UHJXOaU
FRQWaFW ZLWK 0XOOHaG\ aQG 0LWKaQL WKURXJK SKRQH FaOOV� HPaLOV� LQ�SHUVRQ YLVLWV� :KaWV$SS
PHVVaJLQJ� aQG SRWHQWLaOO\ RWKHU PHaQV� )URP -XQH WR 'HFHPEHU ���� aORQH� 6KNUHOL H[FKaQJHG
��� HPaLOV ZLWK 0XOOHaG\ aQG ��� HPaLOV ZLWK 0LWKaQL� ,Q WKHVH FRPPXQLFaWLRQV� 6KNUHOL
FRQWLQXHV WR GLVFXVV VWUaWHJLHV WR SUHYHQW JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ WR 'aUaSULP� aV ZHOO aV RWKHU
PaWWHUV RI 9\HUa EXVLQHVV VWUaWHJ\�
��� ,Q 0aUFK ����� a :aOO 6WUHHW -RXUQaO aUWLFOH UHSRUWHG WKaW 6KNUHOL ³UHPaLQV WKH
VKaGRZ SRZHU aW 3KRHQL[XV $*´ aQG WKaW KH ZaV XVLQJ a FRQWUaEaQG FHOO SKRQH WR UXQ 9\HUa
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 13 of 86
��
IURP SULVRQ�
��� 6KNUHOL RZQV aSSUR[LPaWHO\ RI 3KRHQL[XV VKaUHV aQG FRQWUROV aSSUR[LPaWHO\
RI VKaUHKROGHU YRWHV�
�� .HYLQ 0XOOHDG\
��� .HYLQ 0XOOHaG\ LV WKH FXUUHQW FKaLUPaQ RI WKH 3KRHQL[XV ERaUG RI GLUHFWRUV aQG
IRUPHU &(2 RI 9\HUa� $W aOO WLPHV PaWHULaO WR WKLV &RPSOaLQW �ZLWK WKH H[FHSWLRQ RI a EULHI
SHULRG IURP HaUO\ ���� XQWLO -XQH ������ aFWLQJ a ORQH RU LQ FRQFHUW ZLWK RWKHUV� KH KaV
IRUPXOaWHG� GLUHFWHG� FRQWUROOHG� KaG WKH aXWKRULW\ WR FRQWURO� RU SaUWLFLSaWHG LQ WKH aFWV aQG
SUaFWLFHV VHW IRUWK LQ WKLV &RPSOaLQW� 0XOOHaG\ UHVLGHV LQ WKLV 'LVWULFW aQG� LQ FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK WKH
PaWWHUV aOOHJHG KHUHLQ� KH WUaQVaFWV RU KaV WUaQVaFWHG EXVLQHVV LQ WKLV 'LVWULFW�
��� %HIRUH MRLQLQJ 9\HUa� 0XOOHaG\ KaG OLWWOH SKaUPaFHXWLFaO H[SHULHQFH�
��� )ROORZLQJ KLV JUaGXaWLRQ IURP FROOHJH LQ ����� 0XOOHaG\ KHOG HQWU\�OHYHO
SRVLWLRQV LQ ZHaOWK PaQaJHPHQW aQG aOVR ZRUNHG aV a UHaO HVWaWH EURNHU�
��� ,Q ����� 0XOOHaG\ WRRN a SRVLWLRQ ILQGLQJ LQYHVWRUV IRU 6KNUHOL’V IaLOLQJ KHGJH
IXQGV� �+H ZaV aQ XQLQGLFWHG FR�FRQVSLUaWRU LQ WKH FULPLQaO VHFXULWLHV IUaXG FaVH aJaLQVW 6KNUHOL��
0XOOHaG\ KHOSHG 6KNUHOL VWaUW ERWK 5HWURSKLQ aQG 9\HUa�
��� $W 9\HUa� 0XOOHaG\ LQLWLaOO\ KHOG WKH SRVLWLRQ RI PaQaJLQJ GLUHFWRU aQG FKLHI RI
VWaII WR 0aUWLQ 6KNUHOL� +H aVVLVWHG ZLWK 9\HUa’V VHaUFK IRU a GUXJ VHUYLQJ a VPaOO SaWLHQW
SRSXOaWLRQ WR SXW LQWR UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ aQG KHOSHG WR LPSOHPHQW WKLV PRGHO IRU 'aUaSULP� ,Q
����� QRW ORQJ aIWHU 6KNUHOL’V aUUHVW� 9\HUa WHUPLQaWHG 0XOOHaG\’V HPSOR\PHQW�
��� 0XOOHaG\ UHWXUQHG LQ WKH VXPPHU RI ���� aV a PHPEHU RI WKH 3KRHQL[XV ERaUG� a
SRVLWLRQ KH VWLOO KROGV� aQG &(2 RI 9\HUa� a SRVLWLRQ KH KHOG XQWLO 0aUFK ����� ,Q WKHVH UROHV�
0XOOHaG\ KaV GLUHFWHG 9\HUa’V FaPSaLJQ WR SUHYHQW JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ WR 'aUaSULP� LQFOXGLQJ
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 14 of 86
��
UHVWULFWLQJ LWV GLVWULEXWLRQ aQG UHVaOH WR SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV� Sa\LQJ aQ $3, VXSSOLHU QRW
WR VXSSO\ SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV� aQG HQWHULQJ aJUHHPHQWV WR Sa\ WZR RI 9\HUa’V PaMRU
GLVWULEXWRUV QRW WR VHOO WKHLU 'aUaSULP VaOHV LQIRUPaWLRQ WR GaWa�UHSRUWLQJ FRPSaQLHV�
��� 0XOOHaG\ RZQV PRUH WKaQ RI 3KRHQL[XV VKaUHV�
.9� %DFNJURXQG
$� )HGHUDO /DZ (QFRXUDJHV *HQHULF &RPSHWLWLRQ
��� 7KH )HGHUaO )RRG� 'UXJ� aQG &RVPHWLF $FW� �� 8�6�&� ٠��� et seq�� aV aPHQGHG
E\ WKH 'UXJ 3ULFH &RPSHWLWLRQ aQG 3aWHQW 7HUP 5HVWRUaWLRQ $FW RI ���� �WKH ³+aWFK�:a[PaQ
$FW´� aQG WKH 0HGLFaUH 3UHVFULSWLRQ 'UXJ� ,PSURYHPHQW� aQG 0RGHUQL]aWLRQ $FW RI ����� ��
8�6�&� ÙÙ ����E���� aQG ����M� aQG �� 8�6�&� Ù ����H�� HVWaEOLVKHV SURFHGXUHV GHVLJQHG WR
IaFLOLWaWH FRPSHWLWLRQ IURP ORZHU�SULFHG JHQHULF GUXJV�
��� $ FRPSaQ\ VHHNLQJ WR PaUNHW a QHZ SKaUPaFHXWLFaO SURGXFW LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV
PXVW ILOH a 1HZ 'UXJ $SSOLFaWLRQ �³1'$´� ZLWK WKH )'$ GHPRQVWUaWLQJ WKH VaIHW\ aQG HIILFaF\
RI WKH QHZ SURGXFW� 7KHVH 1'$�EaVHG SURGXFWV JHQHUaOO\ aUH UHIHUUHG WR aV ³EUaQG�QaPH GUXJV´
RU ³EUaQGHG GUXJV�´
��� $ FRPSaQ\ VHHNLQJ WR PaUNHW a JHQHULF YHUVLRQ RI a EUaQGHG GUXJ Pa\ ILOH aQ
$EEUHYLaWHG 1HZ 'UXJ $SSOLFaWLRQ �³$1'$´� ZLWK WKH )'$� UHIHUHQFLQJ WKH EUaQGHG GUXJ’V
1'$� 7KH JHQHULF aSSOLFaQW PXVW GHPRQVWUaWH WKaW LWV JHQHULF GUXJ LV WKHUaSHXWLFaOO\ HTXLYaOHQW
WR WKH EUaQG�QaPH GUXJ WKaW LW UHIHUHQFHV� PHaQLQJ WKaW WKH JHQHULF GUXJ LV WKH VaPH aV WKH EUaQG�
QaPH GUXJ LQ GRVaJH IRUP� VaIHW\� VWUHQJWK� URXWH RI aGPLQLVWUaWLRQ� TXaOLW\� SHUIRUPaQFH
FKaUaFWHULVWLFV� aQG LQWHQGHG XVH� ,I WKH )'$ GHWHUPLQHV WKaW WKH JHQHULF GUXJ LV WKHUaSHXWLFaOO\
HTXLYaOHQW WR WKH aOUHaG\�aSSURYHG EUaQGHG GUXJ� LW ZLOO aVVLJQ WKH JHQHULF GUXJ aQ ³$%´ UaWLQJ
aQG ZLOO aOORZ WKH JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ WR UHO\ RQ WKH VWXGLHV VXEPLWWHG LQ FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK WKH
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 15 of 86
��
aOUHaG\�aSSURYHG EUaQGHG GUXJ’V 1'$ WR HVWaEOLVK WKaW WKH JHQHULF GUXJ LV VaIH aQG HIIHFWLYH� ��
8�6�&� ٠����M�����$��LY��
��� 7R HVWaEOLVK WKaW WKH JHQHULF GUXJ LV WKHUaSHXWLFaOO\ HTXLYaOHQW WR WKH EUaQGHG
GUXJ� WKH $1'$ aSSOLFaQW PXVW GHPRQVWUaWH ELRHTXLYaOHQFH� PHaQLQJ WKaW WKHUH LV QR VLJQLILFaQW
GLIIHUHQFH LQ WKH UaWH aQG H[WHQW WR ZKLFK WKH aFWLYH LQJUHGLHQW EHFRPHV aYaLOaEOH LQ WKH ERG\� 7R
PaNH WKLV VKRZLQJ� WKH aSSOLFaQW PXVW aFTXLUH VXEVWaQWLaO TXaQWLWLHV RI WKH UHIHUHQFHG EUaQGHG
GUXJ a QG FRQGXFW ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ FRPSaULQJ LWV JHQHULF YHUVLRQ aJaLQVW WKaW EUaQGHG GUXJ�
��� 7KH $1'$ aSSOLFaQW PXVW FRQGXFW ERWK LQ YLYR aQG LQ YLWUR ELRHTXLYaOHQFH
WHVWLQJ� ,Q WKH LQ YLYR WHVWLQJ� WKH VaPH VPaOO JURXS RI KXPaQ VXEMHFWV �a PLQLPXP RI ��� EXW
RIWHQ �� WR �� SHRSOH� VHTXHQWLaOO\ WaNHV WKH WZR SURGXFWV aQG WKH SKaUPaFRNLQHWLF SHUIRUPaQFH
RI WKH GUXJ LV PHaVXUHG WKURXJK EORRGZRUN� 7KH LQ YLWUR GLVVROXWLRQ WHVWLQJ FRPSaUHV WKH UaWH
aQG H[WHQW WR ZKLFK WKH EUaQGHG aQG JHQHULF GUXJV IRUP a VROXWLRQ IURP WKHLU RULJLQaO GRVaJH
IRUP �H�J�� WaEOHW RU FaSVXOH��
��� 7KH $1'$ aSSOLFaQW PXVW aOVR UHVHUYH HQRXJK EUaQGHG GUXJ VaPSOHV WR SHUIRUP
HaFK RI WKH UHTXLUHG WHVWV ILYH WLPHV�
��� 'HSHQGLQJ RQ WKH SURGXFW� a JHQHULF PaQXIaFWXUHU Pa\ QHHG aV PaQ\ aV ����� WR
����� GRVHV RI WKH EUaQGHG GUXJ WR FRQGXFW ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ� aOO RI ZKLFK PXVW EH IURP WKH
VaPH PaQXIaFWXULQJ ORW WR aVVXUH XQLIRUP FKaUaFWHU aQG TXaOLW\�
��� 1RUPaOO\� WKH $1'$ aSSOLFaQW FaQ REWaLQ VXIILFLHQW VaPSOHV RI WKH EUaQGHG GUXJ
E\ SXUFKaVLQJ WKHP WKURXJK QRUPaO GLVWULEXWLRQ FKaQQHOV� VXFK aV GUXJ ZKROHVaOHUV�
��� $Q $1'$ aSSOLFaQW PXVW aOVR VHFXUH aQ aFFHSWaEOH� VWHaG\ VXSSO\ RI WKH GUXJ’V
$3,� ZKLFK LV WKH LQJUHGLHQW WKaW SURYLGHV WKH GUXJ’V SKaUPaFRORJLFaO aFWLYLW\� 3KaUPaFHXWLFaO
FRPSaQLHV W\SLFaOO\ SXUFKaVH $3, IURP WKLUG�SaUW\ VXSSOLHUV� ,Q RUGHU IRU aQ $3, WR EH XVHG LQ a
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 16 of 86
��
SKaUPaFHXWLFaO SURGXFW� WKH )'$ PXVW aSSURYH WKH $3, SURGXFW� WKH $3, PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV�
aQG WKH $3, PaQXIaFWXUHU’V TXaOLW\ FRQWUROV� IaFLOLW\� aQG FRPSOLaQFH ZLWK JRRG PaQXIaFWXULQJ
SUaFWLFHV� $Q $1'$ PXVW WKHUHIRUH FRQWaLQ H[WHQVLYH LQIRUPaWLRQ aERXW WKH $3, aQG LWV
PaQXIaFWXUHU� LQFOXGLQJ a FRPSOHWH GHVFULSWLRQ RI WKH PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV aQG SURFHVV
FRQWUROV� WKH FRQWURO RI PaWHULaOV XVHG LQ WKH PaQXIaFWXUH RI WKH GUXJ VXEVWaQFH� FRQWUROV RI
FULWLFaO VWHSV aQG LQWHUPHGLaWHV� SURFHVV YaOLGaWLRQ� aQG WKH PaQXIaFWXULQJ SU RFHVV GHYHORSPHQW�
,Q aGGLWLRQ WR UHYLHZLQJ WKLV LQIRUPaWLRQ LQ GHWaLO� WKH )'$ ZLOO W\SLFaOO\ aXGLW WKH $3,
PaQXIaFWXUHU aQG LWV IaFLOLW\�
��� ,I a JHQHULF FaQQRW ILQG aQ $3, VXSSOLHU ZLWK aQ H[LVWLQJ SURFHVV WKaW FaQ PHHW WKH
)'$’V VWaQGaUGV� LW ZLOO W\SLFaOO\ QHHG WR ZRUN ZLWK a QHZ VXSSOLHU WR GHYHORS a PaQXIaFWXULQJ
SURFHVV IRU WKH $3,� ZKLFK FaQ WaNH PRQWKV RU \HaUV�
��� $ VXSSOLHU WKaW KaV aOUHaG\ GHYHORSHG a SURFHVV WR SURGXFH aQ $3, FaQ VHSaUaWHO\
VXEPLW a GUXJ PaVWHU ILOH �³'0)´� WR WKH )'$ FRQWaLQLQJ WKLV UHTXLUHG LQIRUPaWLRQ� ,Q WKaW FaVH�
aQ aSSOLFaQW XVLQJ WKaW VXSSOLHU FaQ UHIHUHQFH WKH '0) LQ LWV $1'$ UaWKHU WKaQ GHYHORSLQJ aQG
VXEPLWWLQJ WKH LQIRUPaWLRQ aQHZ� 7KH JHQHULF aSSOLFaQW’V SaWK WR )'$ aSSURYaO LV HaVLHU aQG
IaVWHU LI WKH )'$ KaV aOUHaG\ LQVSHFWHG WKH $3, VXSSOLHU’V IaFLOLW\ aQG aSSURYHG WKH
PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV� (YHQ LI WKH )'$ VWLOO QHHGV WR LQVSHFW WKH $3, VXSSOLHU� WKH '0)
LQGLFaWHV WKaW WKH PaQXIaFWXUHU KaV aQ H[LVWLQJ� )'$�aSSURYaEOH SURFHVV WR PaQXIaFWXUH WKH $3,�
ZKLFK FaQ VKRUWHQ WKH $1'$ GHYHORSPHQW WLPHOLQH�
%� &RPSHWLWLRQ IURP /RZHU�3ULFHG *HQHULF 'UXJV 6DYHV $PHULFDQ &RQVXPHUV %LOOLRQV RI 'ROODUV (DFK
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 18 of 86
��� $OO �� VWaWHV aQG WKH 'LVWULFW RI &ROXPELa KaYH GUXJ VXEVWLWXWLRQ OaZV WKaW
HQFRXUaJH aQG IaFLOLWaWH VXEVWLWXWLRQ RI ORZHU�FRVW $%�UaWHG JHQHULF GUXJV IRU EUaQGHG GUXJV�
:KHQ a SKaUPaFLVW ILOOV a SUHVFULSWLRQ ZULWWHQ IRU a EUaQGHG GUXJ� WKHVH OaZV aOORZ RU UHTXLUH WKH
SKaUPaFLVW WR GLVSHQVH aQ $%�UaWHG JHQHULF YHUVLRQ RI WKH GUXJ LQVWHaG RI WKH PRUH H[SHQVLYH
EUaQGHG GUXJ� XQOHVV a SK\VLFLaQ GLUHFWV RU WKH SaWLHQW UHTXHVWV RWKHUZLVH� &RQYHUVHO\� WKHVH OaZV
JHQHUaOO\ GR QRW SHUPLW a SKaUPaFLVW WR VXEVWLWXWH a QRQ�$%�UaWHG JHQHULF IRU a EUaQGHG GUXJ
XQOHVV WKH SK\VLFLaQ VSHFLILFaOO\ SUHVFULEHV LW E\ ZULWLQJ RQ WKH SUHVFULSWLRQ WKH FKHPLFaO QaPH RI
WKH GUXJ� UaWKHU WKaQ WKH EUaQG QaPH�
��� 7KH +aWFK�:a[PaQ $FW aQG VWaWH VXEVWLWXWLRQ OaZV KaYH VXFFHHGHG LQ IaFLOLWaWLQJ
JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ aQG JHQHUaWLQJ OaUJH VaYLQJV IRU SaWLHQWV� KHaOWKFaUH SOaQV� aQG IHGHUaO aQG
VWaWH JRYHUQPHQWV� 7KH ILUVW JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRU’V SURGXFW LV W\SLFaOO\ RIIHUHG aW a ��� WR ���
GLVFRXQW WR WKH EUaQGHG SURGXFW� 6XEVHTXHQW JHQHULF HQWU\ FUHaWHV JUHaWHU SULFH FRPSHWLWLRQ� ZLWK
GLVFRXQWV UHaFKLQJ ��� RU PRUH RII WKH EUaQG SULFH� $FFRUGLQJ WR a ���� &RQJUHVVLRQaO %XGJHW
2IILFH UHSRUW� WKH UHWaLO SULFH RI a JHQHULF LV ��� ORZHU� RQ aYHUaJH� WKaQ WKH UHWaLO SULFH RI a
EUaQG�QaPH GUXJ� ,Q ���� aORQH� WKH $VVRFLaWLRQ RI $FFHVVLEOH 0HGLFLQHV UHSRUWHG WKaW XVH RI
JHQHULF YHUVLRQV RI EUaQG�QaPH GUXJV VaYHG WKH 8�6� KHaOWKFaUH V\VWHP ���� ELOOLRQ�
��� %HFaXVH RI WKHVH FRVW VaYLQJV� PaQ\ WKLUG�SaUW\ Sa\HUV RI SUHVFULSWLRQ GUXJV �H�J��
KHaOWK LQVXUaQFH SOaQV aQG 0HGLFaLG SURJUaPV� KaYH aGRSWHG SROLFLHV WR HQFRXUaJH WKH
VXEVWLWXWLRQ RI $%�UaWHG JHQHULF GUXJV IRU WKHLU EUaQGHG FRXQWHUSaUWV� $V a UHVXOW RI WKHVH
SROLFLHV aQG ORZHU SULFHV� PaQ\ FRQVXPHUV URXWLQHO\ VZLWFK IURP a EUaQGHG GUXJ WR aQ $%�UaWHG
JHQHULF GUXJ XSRQ LWV LQWURGXFWLRQ� &RQVHTXHQWO\� $%�UaWHG JHQHULF GUXJV W\SLFaOO\ FaSWXUH RYHU
��� RI a EUaQGHG GUXJ’V XQLW aQG GROOaU VaOHV ZLWKLQ VL[ PRQWKV RI PaUNHW HQWU\�
��
&� 'DUDSULP .V WKH *ROG�6WDQGDUG 7UHDWPHQW IRU 7R[RSODVPRVLV
��� 7R[RSOaVPRVLV LV a FRPPRQ SaUaVLWLF LQIHFWLRQ W\SLFaOO\ WUaQVPLWWHG WKURXJK
XQGHUFRRNHG PHaW aQG LQIHFWHG FaW IHFHV� ,Q PRVW KXPaQV� WR[RSOaVPRVLV LV HaVLO\ FRQWaLQHG E\
WKHLU LPPXQH V\VWHPV aQG FaXVHV QR V\PSWRPV�
��� %XW LQ LPPXQRFRPSURPLVHG LQGLYLGXaOV�VXFK aV WKRVH ZLWK +,9�$,'6� FaQFHU
SaWLHQWV� RU UHFLSLHQWV RI RUJaQ WUaQVSOaQWV�WKH LQIHFWLRQ FaQ PRUSK LQWR a SRWHQWLaOO\ IaWaO RUJaQ
LQIHFWLRQ� PRVW FRPPRQO\ LQ WKH EUaLQ� OXQJV� RU KHaUW� 7KH SaUaVLWH FaQ aOVR LQIHFW WKH H\HV
�RFXOaU WR[RSOaVPRVLV��
��� $Q H[SHFWaQW PRWKHU FaQ aOVR SaVV WKH toxoplasma gondii SaUaVLWH LQ XWHUR�
FaXVLQJ F RQJHQLWaO WR[RSOaVPRVLV� ZKLFK OHIW XQWUHaWHG FaQ OHaG WR EOLQGQHVV� VHYHUH LQWHOOHFWXaO
GLVaELOLWLHV� aQG RWKHU QHXURORJLFaO SUREOHPV�
��� ,Q WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV� WKH QXPEHU RI WR[RSOaVPRVLV FaVHV UHTXLULQJ WUHaWPHQW HaFK
\HaU LV VPaOO �OHVV WKaQ ����� SHU \HaU IURP ���������� aQG GHFOLQLQJ aV WUHaWPHQW RI +,9�$,'6
LPSURYHV�
��� 7KH JROG�VWaQGaUG WUHaWPHQW IRU WR[RSOaVPRVLV LV S\ULPHWKaPLQH� $OO 8�6�
JRYHUQPHQW KHaOWK aXWKRULW\ JXLGHOLQHV LGHQWLI\ S\ULPHWKaPLQH aV WKH SUHIHUUHG WUHaWPHQW IRU WKH
LQIHFWLRQ� 7KH &HQWHUV IRU 'LVHaVH &RQWURO aQG 3UHYHQWLRQ aGYLVH WKaW S\ULPHWKaPLQH LV WKH
³PRVW HIIHFWLYH GUXJ aJaLQVW WR[RSOaVPRVLV�´ 7KH 1aWLRQaO ,QVWLWXWH RI +HaOWK FaOOV
S\ULPHWKaPLQH WKH ³LQLWLaO WKHUaS\ RI FKRLFH�´ aQG LW aGYLVHV RWKHU RSWLRQV RQO\ LI S\ULPHWKaPLQH
LV ³XQaYaLOaEOH RU WKHUH LV a GHOa\ LQ REWaLQLQJ LW�´
��� 3\ULPHWKaPLQH LV RQ WKH :RUOG +HaOWK 2UJaQL]aWLRQ’V 0RGHO /LVW RI (VVHQWLaO
0HGLFLQHV� ZKLFK LGHQWLILHV WKH PLQLPXP PHGLFLQHV QHHGHG IRU a EaVLF KHaOWKFaUH V\VWHP�
��� 'aUaSULP �1'$ 1R� ������ LV a EUaQGHG YHUVLRQ RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH� ,W ZaV ILUVW
aSSURYHG E\ WKH )'$ LQ ����� ,W ORQJ aJR ORVW aQ\ SaWHQW SURWHFWLRQ RU UHJXOaWRU\ H[FOXVLYLW\�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 19 of 86
��
��� 'aUaSULP LV aYaLOaEOH RQO\ aV a ���PLOOLJUaP WaEOHW� *HQHUaOO\� a WR[RSOaVPRVLV
LQIHFWLRQ LV GLaJQRVHG LQ aQ aFXWH KRVSLWaO VHWWLQJ� aQG WKH SaWLHQW W\SLFaOO\ UHPaLQV KRVSLWaOL]HG
IRU WZR WR WKUHH ZHHNV� 'XULQJ WKLV VWaJH� WKH VWaUWLQJ GRVaJH IRU aGXOWV LV �� WR �� PLOOLJUaPV RI
'aUaSULP SHU Ga\�
��� )ROORZLQJ GLVFKaUJH� SaWLHQWV W\SLFaOO\ FRQWLQXH RQ aERXW KaOI WKaW aPRXQW IRU
IRXU WR ILYH aGGLWLRQaO ZHHNV� WKRXJK VRPH SaWLHQWV PXVW UHPaLQ RQ S\ULPHWKaPLQH IRU PRQWKV RU
\HaUV WR SUHYHQW UHFXUUHQFH�
��� )URP WKH WLPH 9\HUa aFTXLUHG 'aUaSULP LQ ���� XQWLO WKH )'$ aSSURYHG a
JHQHULF YHUVLRQ RI 'aUaSULP RQ )HEUXaU\ ��� ����� 'aUaSULP ZaV WKH RQO\ )'$�aSSURYHG
S\ULPHWKaPLQH SURGXFW �EUaQGHG RU JHQHULF��
'� 9\HUD’V $FTXLVLWLRQ RI 'DUDSULP
�� 3ULRU RZQHUVKLS RI 'DUDSULP
��� *Oa[R6PLWK.OLQH SOF aQG LWV SUHGHFHVVRU HQWLWLHV RZQHG WKH ZRUOGZLGH ULJKWV WR
'aUaSULP IURP LWV aSSURYaO LQ ���� XQWLO �����
��� %\ ����� *6. FKaUJHG aURXQG �� SHU 'aUaSULP WaEOHW aQG KaG UHOaWLYHO\ ORZ
UHYHQXHV RI OHVV WKaQ �� PLOOLRQ SHU \HaU LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV GXH WR WKH ORZ LQFLGHQFH RI
WR[RSOaVPRVLV�
��� *6. VWLOO VHOOV 'aUaSULP LQ WKH 8QLWHG .LQJGRP� ZKHUH LW FKaUJHV OHVV WKaQ �� SHU
WaEOHW�
��� ,Q ����� *6. VROG LWV 8�6� aQG &aQaGLaQ 'aUaSULP ULJKWV WR &RUH3KaUPa //&�
ZKLFK WKHQ WUaQVIHUUHG WKH SURGXFW WR LWV VLVWHU FRPSaQ\� $PHGUa 3KaUPaFHXWLFaOV //&�
��� %HWZHHQ ���� aQG ����� &RUH3KaUPa aQG $PHGUa JUaGXaOO\ LQFUHaVHG WKH SULFH
RI 'aUaSULP WR ������ SHU WaEOHW� $GGLWLRQaOO\� $PHGUa GHYHORSHG a SOaQ WR UHPRYH 'aUaSULP
IURP QRUPaO GLVWULEXWLRQ FKaQQHOV aQG SXW LW LQWR a UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 20 of 86
��
��� ,Q 0aUFK ����� ,PSa[ /aERUaWRULHV� ,QF� aFTXLUHG 'aUaSULP aV SaUW RI a ����
PLOOLRQ aFTXLVLWLRQ RI $PHGUa’V SaUHQW FRPSaQ\� 7RZHU +ROGLQJV� ,QF� $W WKH WLPH� ,PSa[
aVVHVVHG 'aUaSULP aV a QRQ�FRUH aVVHW ZLWK GHFOLQLQJ aQQXaO UHYHQXHV RI �� PLOOLRQ RU OHVV�
��� ,Q -XQH ����� ,PSa[ LQFUHaVHG WKH SULFH RI 'aUaSULP E\ ���� IURP ������ WR
������ SHU WaEOHW� ,PSa[ KaG FRQVLGHUHG a PRUH ³aJJUHVVLYH´ SULFH LQFUHaVH� EXW UHMHFWHG WKH LGHa
GXH WR FRQFHUQ aERXW a SXEOLF EaFNOaVK IURP WKH $,'6 FRPPXQLW\� ,PSa[ aOVR EHJaQ WR
LPSOHPHQW $PHGUa’V UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP� VLJQLQJ FRQWUaFWV ZLWK WZR GLVWULEXWRUV�
�� 9\HUD’V DFTXLVLWLRQ RI 'DUDSULP
��� )URP LWV LQFHSWLRQ LQ IaOO ����� 9\HUa KaG EHHQ ORRNLQJ WR aFTXLUH a VROH�VRXUFH
GUXJ ZLWK a VPaOO SaWLHQW SRSXOaWLRQ WKaW LW FRXOG SXW LQWR UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ� $V 9\HUa
H[SORUHG GLIIHUHQW GUXJV WKaW ILW WKLV PROG� LW VRXJKW GLVWULEXWLRQ SaUWQHUV WKaW ZRXOG ³KHOS >LW]
NHHS a WLJKWO\ FRQWUROOHG VXSSO\ FKaLQ� ZKHUH >WKH] GUXJ LV RQO\ VXSSOLHG WR YHULILHG SaWLHQWV�´
��� ,Q $SULO ����� XQaZaUH RI ,PSa[’V SOaQ WR SOaFH 'aUaSULP LQWR UHVWULFWHG
GLVWULEXWLRQ� 9\HUa FRQWaFWHG ,PSa[ ZLWK aQ XQVROLFLWHG ELG WR aFTXLUH WKH 8�6� 'aUaSULP ULJKWV
IRU � $W WKH WLPH� 'aUaSULP KaG aQQXaO 8�6� QHW UHYHQXHV RI aSSUR[LPaWHO\
SHU \HaU� ,PSa[ KaG aVVHVVHG 'aUaSULP’V QHW SUHVHQW YaOXH aW ����� PLOOLRQ� aVVXPLQJ QR JHQHULF
HQWU\�
��� 2Q $XJXVW �� ����� 9\HUa aFTXLUHG WKH 8�6� ULJKWV WR 'aUaSULP IRU WKH ILQaO
QHJRWLaWHG SULFH RI ��� PLOOLRQ�WULSOH ,PSa[’V QHW�SUHVHQW�YaOXH aVVHVVPHQW aQG PRUH WKaQ ��
WLPHV 'aUaSULP’V aQQXaO QHW UHYHQXHV�
��� 9\HUa KaG a SOaQ WR WXUQ ,PSa[’V �� PLOOLRQ�SHU�\HaU GUXJ LQWR a ���� PLOOLRQ�
SHU�\HaU GUXJ� 7KH SOaQ VWaUWHG ZLWK a VKRFNLQJ SULFH LQFUHaVH� WKH Ga\ aIWHU ILQaOL]LQJ WKH GHaO LQ
$XJXVW ����� 9\HUa UaLVHG WKH SULFH IURP ������ WR ���� SHU WaEOHW� aQ LQFUHaVH RI PRUH WKaQ
�������
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 21 of 86
��
��� ,Q aGYaQFH RI WKH SULFH LQFUHaVH� 'HIHQGaQW 6KNUHOL SUHGLFWHG WKaW ³QRERG\ ZLOO
QRWLFH aQG WKHUH ZLOO QRW EH aQ\ FRQVHTXHQFH�´ +H ZaV YHU\ ZURQJ� 9\HUa VZLIWO\ IaFHG RXWFULHV
IURP KHaOWK FaUH SURYLGHUV� SaWLHQWV� PHGLFaO VRFLHWLHV� WKH JHQHUaO SXEOLF� aQG &RQJUHVV�
��� ,Q WKH ZRUGV RI 9\HUa’V WKHQ FKLHI VFLHQWLVW� ³WKH RQO\ SHUVRQ WKaW GLGQ’W VSHaN
aJaLQVW >WKH SULFH KLNH] ZaV WKH 3RSH � � � � >,]W ZaV WKH SRVWHU FKLOG RI HYHU\WKLQJ WKaW LV
FRQVLGHUHG ZURQJ aERXW WKH SKaUPaFHXWLFaO LQGXVWU\�´
��� ,Q 6HSWHPEHU ����� WKH +,9 0HGLFLQH $VVRFLaWLRQ �³+,90$´� RI WKH ,QIHFWLRXV
'LVHaVHV 6RFLHW\ RI $PHULFa SXEOLFO\ XUJHG 9\HUa ³WR LPPHGLaWHO\ UHYLVH WKH SULFLQJ VWUaWHJ\
IRU´ 'aUaSULP� +,90$ GHHPHG WKH HVWLPaWHG aQQXaO FRVW RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH WUHaWPHQW IRU
WR[RSOaVPRVLV ������������������ GHSHQGLQJ RQ WKH SaWLHQW’V ZHLJKW� ³XQMXVWLILaEOH IRU WKH
PHGLFaOO\ YXOQHUaEOH SaWLHQW SRSXOaWLRQ LQ QHHG RI WKLV PHGLFaWLRQ aQG XQVXVWaLQaEOH IRU WKH
KHaOWK FaUH V\VWHP�´
9� 'HIHQGDQWV’ $QWLFRPSHWLWLYH $JUHHPHQWV WR 0DLQWDLQ 9\HUD’V 'DUDSULP 0RQRSRO\
��� 9\HUa NQHZ WKaW WKH GUaPaWLF SULFH LQFUHaVH RQ LWV RZQ ZRXOG QRW VHFXUH ORQJ�
WHUP UHYHQXHV EHFaXVH� ZLWK QR SaWHQW RU UHJXOaWRU\ SURWHFWLRQ� 'aUaSULP ZRXOG EH YXOQHUaEOH WR
JHQHULF HQWU\� 7KXV� WR SURWHFW LWV 'aUaSULP UHYHQXHV� 9\HUa OaXQFKHG aQ HOaERUaWH VFKHPH WR
SUHYHQW JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ� LW HQWHUHG aJUHHPHQWV SURKLELWLQJ GLVWULEXWRUV aQG SXUFKaVHUV IURP
UHVHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV RU WKHLU aJHQWV� HQWHUHG H[FOXVLYH aJUHHPHQWV
SURKLELWLQJ $3, PaQXIaFWXUHUV IURP VXSSO\LQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH WR SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV�
aQG HQWHUHG GaWa�EORFNLQJ aJUHHPHQWV WR SUHYHQW GLVWULEXWRUV IURP VHOOLQJ WKHLU 'aUaSULP VaOHV
GaWa� WKXV PaVNLQJ WKH WUXH VL]H RI WKH 'aUaSULP PaUNHW WR GHWHU JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV� 'HIHQGaQWV
6KNUHOL aQG 0XOOHaG\ LPSOHPHQWHG� RYHUVaZ� aQG SaUWLFLSaWHG LQ WKLV VFKHPH�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 22 of 86
��
$� 'HIHQGDQWV .PSOHPHQW $JUHHPHQWV 5HVWULFWLQJ 5HVDOH DQG / LPLWLQJ 3XUFKDVHV WR %ORFN *HQHULF (QWU\
��� %HIRUH ����� 'aUaSULP ZaV GLVWULEXWHG RSHQO\ IRU PRUH WKaQ �� \HaUV ZLWKRXW aQ\
UHVWULFWLRQV� *HQHULF FRPSaQLHV ZHUH aEOH WR SXUFKaVH 'aUaSULP IURP a ORFaO SKaUPaF\ ZLWKRXW
HQWHULQJ LQWR aQ\ ZULWWHQ FRQWUaFW RU REWaLQLQJ a Q\ W\SH RI aSSURYaO�
��� %XW 'HIHQGaQWV XQGHUVWRRG WKaW a UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP ³FaQ EH a Za\ WR
ORZHU FRPSHWLWLRQ�´ 2QH RI 9\HUa’V FR�IRXQGHUV WHVWLILHG WKaW ³FORVHG GLVWULEXWLRQ FaQ LQFUHaVH a
SURGXFW OLIH F\FOH E\ SUHYHQWLQJ J HQHULFV IURP SRWHQWLaOO\ JHWWLQJ \RXU UHIHUHQFHG SURGXFW�´
ZKLFK WKH\ QHHG IRU )'$�UHTXLUHG ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ� 9\HUa’V IRUPHU JHQHUaO FRXQVHO
IXUWKHU WHVWLILHG WKaW WKH XVH RI a FORVHG GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP ZaV ³FRQVLGHUHG aQ LQWHJUaO SaUW RI
WKH FRPSaQ\’V GHVLUH WR EORFN a JHQHULF HQWUaQW IRU aW OHaVW WKUHH \HaUV�´
��� 'HIHQGaQW 6KNUHOL KaG H[SHULHQFH XVLQJ UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV WR EORFN JHQHULF
FRPSHWLWLRQ� ,Q ����� 6KNUHOL’V ILUVW SKaUPaFHXWLFaO FRPSaQ\� 5HWURSKLQ� aFTXLUHG WKH ULJKWV WR
7KLROa� a GUXJ XVHG WR WUHaW WKH UaUH GLVHaVH F\VWLQXULa� $W 6KNUHOL’V GLUHFWLRQ� 5HWURSKLQ UaLVHG
WKH SULFH RI 7KLROa E\ ������ aQG SXW LW LQWR a UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP�
��� $W WKaW WLPH� 6KNUHOL WROG 5HWURSKLQ LQYHVWRUV WKaW ³>W]KH FORVHG GLVWULEXWLRQ
V\VWHP � � � aOORZV IRU XV WR FRQWURO WKH UHOHaVH RI RXU SURGXFW� :H GR QRW VHOO 5HWURSKLQ SURGXFWV
WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV�´ $V 6KNUHOL H[SOaLQHG� EORFNLQJ J HQHULF aFFHVV WR GUXJ VaPSOHV LQ WKLV
Za\ ³WaNHV WKH $% VXEVWLWXWaEOH UaWLQJ WKaW JHQHULFV UHO\ RQ aQG QHXWHUV LW�´
��� :KHQ 9\HUa ZaV VHHNLQJ WR aFTXLUH 'aUaSULP� 'HIHQGaQW 0XOOHaG\ PaGH FOHaU
WKaW VHWWLQJ XS a VLPLOaU UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP IRU 'aUaSULP ZRXOG EH 9\HUa’V ³��
SULRULW\´ aQG ³H[FHSWLRQaOO\ WLPH VHQVLWLYH�´ +H XUJHG 9\HUa HPSOR\HHV WR ³aOO ZRUN H[WUa ORQJ
KRXUV WR JHW WKLV GRQH�´
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 23 of 86
��
��� 8SRQ aFTXLULQJ 'aUaSULP� 9\HUa aFWHG WR LPSOHPHQW 6KNUHOL’V EOXHSULQW� 9\HUa
VWaUWHG ZLWK WKH UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP LW LQKHULWHG IURP ,PSa[� H[SaQGLQJ WKH QXPEHU RI
GLVWULEXWRUV WR LPSURYH GLVWULEXWLRQ ORJLVWLFV� $W WKH VaPH WLPH� KRZHYHU� 'HIHQGaQWV WLJKWHQHG
WKH UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV E\ VLJQLQJ aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK WKH GLVWULEXWRUV� KRVSLWaOV� aQG SKaUPaFLHV WKaW
SXUFKaVHG 'aUaSULP EaUULQJ UHVaOH RI WKH GUXJ WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV� 7KH UHVXOWLQJ ZHE RI
FRQWUaFWXaO UHVWULFWLRQV SUHYHQWV JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV IURP SXUFKaVLQJ 'aUaSULP aW aQ\ SRLQW LQ WKH
GLVWULEXWLRQ FKaLQ� GHQ\LQJ WKHP WKH aELOLW\ WR FRQGXFW WKH ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ QHFHVVaU\ IRU
)'$ aSSURYaO�
�� 9\HUD’V FRQWUDFWXDO UHVWULFWLRQV SUHYHQW GLVWULEXWRUV IURP VHOOLQJ 'DUDSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSDQLHV
���� 9\HUa’V JHQHULF�EORFNLQJ aJUHHPHQWV VWaUW ZLWK LWV GLVWULEXWRUV� 9\HUa LPSRVHV
UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV RQ aOO RI LWV GLVWULEXWRUV WR ³EORFN´ JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV IURP SXUFKaVLQJ
'aUaSULP� WKHUHE\ ³aYRLG>LQJ] JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ�´ (aFK 9\HUa GLVWULEXWRU FaQ VHOO 'aUaSULP
RQO\ WR VSHFLILFaOO\ LGHQWLILHG FXVWRPHUV RU FXVWRPHU W\SHV� $Q\ RWKHU SXUFKaVH UHTXHVW UHTXLUHV
9\HUa’V GLUHFW aSSURYaO� $V 9\HUa’V GLUHFWRU RI SaWLHQW aFFHVV H[SOaLQHG� ³>L]I VRPHRQH HOVH FaOOV
aQG aVNV IRU �� ERWWOHV RI 'aUaSULP� WKH\ ZRXOG KaYH WR FRPH WR PH IRU aSSURYaO�´
���� 1RQH RI 9\HUa’V GLVWULEXWRUV LV aOORZHG WR VHOO 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV�
1RU GRHV 9\HUa aSSURYH VXFK VaOHV� ,I a GLVWULEXWRU UHFHLYHV a SXUFKaVH UHTXHVW IURP aQ HQWLW\
WKaW PLJKW EH a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ RU PLJKW VHOO WR RQH� 9\HUa ZLOO ³EORFN WKaW SXUFKaVH´ WR ³aYRLG
JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ�´
���� $W WKH WRS RI LWV GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP� 9\HUa XVHV ,&6 � IRUPHUO\ 6PLWK 0HGLFaO
3aUWQHUV� aV a WKLUG�SaUW\ ORJLVWLFV SURYLGHU� ,&6 UHFHLYHV 'aUaSULP IURP 9\HUa’V FRQWUaFW
PaQXIaFWXUHU� ZaUHKRXVHV LW� aQG VKLSV LW WR 9\HUa’V FKRVHQ GLVWULEXWRUV� ,&6 LV FRPSHQVaWHG
WKURXJK a IL[HG PRQWKO\ IHH� aV ZHOO aV aGGLWLRQaO IHHV IRU HaFK RUGHU LW VKLSV�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 24 of 86
��
���� 8QGHU LWV aJUHHPHQW ZLWK 9\HUa� ,&6 FaQ RQO\ VKLS 'aUaSULP WR IRXU VSHFLILFaOO\
aSSURYHG GLVWULEXWRUV� $6' +HaOWKFaUH� &aUGLQaO +HaOWK� %LR5LGJH 3KaUPa� //&� aQG 2SWLPH
&aUH ,QF� *HQHULF FRPSaQLHV aUH QRW aSSURYHG SXUFKaVHUV� aQG ,&6 FaQQRW VHOO 'aUaSULP WR WKHP
ZLWKRXW 9\HUa’V aSSURYaO�
���� %HORZ ,&6� HaFK RI WKHVH IRXU GLVWULEXWRUV LV aXWKRUL]HG WR VHOO RQO\ WR VSHFLILF
W\SHV RI SXUFKaVHUV�
���� )LUVW� 9\HUa KaV aQ aJUHHPHQW ZLWK $6' +HaOWKFaUH WR GLVWULEXWH 'aUaSULP WR
KRVSLWaO aQG JRYHUQPHQW SXUFKaVHUV� 9\HUa FRPSHQVaWHV $6' E\ Sa\LQJ LW RI 'aUaSULP’V
ZKROHVaOH aFTXLVLWLRQ FRVW �³:$&�´ L�H� WKH OLVW SULFH� IRU HaFK VaOH LW PaNHV�
���� ,QLWLaOO\� 9\HUa aQG $6' aOVR aJUHHG WR ³YHUEaO EXVLQHVV UXOHV´ WKaW IXUWKHU
OLPLWHG VaOHV WR VSHFLILF JRYHUQPHQW aQG KRVSLWaO FXVWRPHUV� 9\HUa aQG $6' OaWHU aPHQGHG WKHLU
ZULWWHQ FRQWUaFW WR HQXPHUaWH ³aXWKRUL]HG FXVWRPHUV´ aQG WR VSHFLILFaOO\ UHTXLUH WKaW 9\HUa
³aSSURYH aQ\ QHZ aXWKRUL]HG FXVWRPHUV YLa HPaLO�´ *HQHULF FRPSaQLHV aUH QRW aQG KaYH QHYHU
EHHQ aXWKRUL]HG FXVWRPHUV XQGHU WKH $6' aJUHHPHQW� 1RU ZaV $6' SHUPLWWHG WR VHOO 'aUaSULP
WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV XQGHU WKH SUHYLRXV FRQWUaFWXaO LWHUaWLRQ aQG YHUEaO EXVLQHVV UXOHV�
&RQVHTXHQWO\� $6' FaQQRW VHOO 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV ZLWKRXW 9\HUa’V aSSURYaO�
���� 6HFRQG� 9\HUa KaV aQ aJUHHPHQW ZLWK %LR5LGJH 3KaUPa WR GLVWULEXWH 'aUaSULP WR
FHUWaLQ LGHQWLILHG VSHFLaOW\ SKaUPaFLHV�LQFOXGLQJ WKRVH RZQHG E\ :aOJUHHQV� 9\HUa
FRPSHQVaWHV %LR5LGJH E\ Sa\LQJ LW �
���� *HQHULF FRPSaQLHV aUH QRW LGHQWLILHG aV aFFHSWaEOH SXUFKaVHUV XQGHU WKH %LR5LGJH
FRQWUaFW� &RQVHTXHQWO\� %LR5LGJH FaQQRW VHOO 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV ZLWKRXW 9\HUa’V
aSSURYaO�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 25 of 86
��
���� 7KLUG� 9\HUa KaV aQ aJUHHPHQW ZLWK WR GLVWULEXWH 'aUaSULP RQO\
WR ³aSSURYHG FOaVVHV RI WUaGH�´ ZKLFK aUH GHILQHG aV ³>K]RVSLWaOV� VWaWH $,'6 'UXJ $VVLVWaQFH
3URJUaPV �$'$3V�� aQG WKHLU aXWKRUL]HG SXUFKaVHUV�´ 3XUFKaVH UHTXHVWV IURP aQ\ RWKHU ³FOaVV RI
WUaGH � � � UHTXLUH SULRU ZULWWHQ aSSURYaO E\ >9\HUa]�´ 9\HUa FRPSHQVaWHV E\ Sa\LQJ LW
�
���� *HQHULF FRPSaQLHV aUH QRW aQ aSSURYHG FOaVV RI WUaGH XQGHU WKH FRQWUaFW�
&RQVHTXHQWO\� FaQQRW VHOO 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV ZLWKRXW 9\HUa’V aSSURYaO�
���� )RXUWK� 9\HUa KaV aQ aJUHHPHQW ZLWK 2SWLPH &aUH WR GLVWULEXWH 'aUaSULP RQO\ WR
³>a]XWKRUL]HG FXVWRPHU W\SHV�´ ZKLFK LQFOXGH KRVSLWaOV� JRYHUQPHQW FXVWRPHUV� VWaWH $,'6 'UXJ
$VVLVWaQFH 3URJUaPV� aQG SaWLHQWV ZLWK a SUHVFULSWLRQ� 2SWLPH FaQQRW VHOO 'aUaSULP WR a EX\HU
WKaW IaOOV RXWVLGH WKHVH aXWKRUL]HG W\SHV ZLWKRXW 9\HUa’V aSSURYaO� 8QGHU WKH aJUHHPHQW� 9\HUa
FRPSHQVaWHV 2SWLPH E\ Sa\LQJ LW � aV ZHOO aV
�
���� *HQHULF FRPSaQLHV aUH QRW aQ aXWKRUL]HG FXVWRPHU W\SH XQGHU WKH 2SWLPH
FRQWUaFW� &RQVHTXHQWO\� 2SWLPH FaQQRW VHOO 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV ZLWKRXW 9\HUa’V
aSSURYaO�
���� 7aNHQ WRJHWKHU� 9\HUa’V FRQWUaFWXaO UHVWULFWLRQV SUHYHQW aOO RI LWV GLVWULEXWRUV IURP
VHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV VHHNLQJ WR FRQGXFW )'$�PaQGaWHG ELRHTXLYaOHQFH
VWXGLHV XQOHVV 9\HUa aSSURYHV WKH VaOH� $QG 9\HUa GRHV QRW aSSURYH aQ\ VaOH RI 'aUaSULP WR a
JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ RU a FRPSaQ\ LW EHOLHYHV PLJKW VHOO WR a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\� ,QGHHG� 9\HUa KaV
GHQLHG HaFK UHTXHVW IURP a GLVWULEXWRU WR VHOO 'aUaSULP WR a SXUFKaVHU WKaW PLJKW EH a JHQHULF
FRPSaQ\ RU PLJKW VHOO 'aUaSULP WR a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\� HYHQ WKRXJK 9\HUa ZRXOG PaNH
VLJQLILFaQW SURILWV IURP aQ\ VaOHV RI 'aUaSULP aW OLVW SULFH�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 26 of 86
��
�� 9\HUD’V FRQWUDFWXDO UHVWULFWLRQV SUHYHQW GRZQVWUHDP SXUFKDVHUV IURP VHOOLQJ 'DUDSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSDQLHV
���� ,Q aGGLWLRQ WR ORFNLQJ XS LWV GLVWULEXWRUV� 9\HUa ZaV aOVR FRQFHUQHG WKaW
GRZQVWUHaP SXUFKaVHUV� VXFK aV KRVSLWaOV RU SKaUPaFLHV� PLJKW VHOO 'aUaSULP WR a JHQHULF
FRPSaQ\� 7R SUHYHQW WKLV� 9\HUa LPSRVHG GLUHFW aQG LQGLUHFW UHVWULFWLRQV RQ WKHVH SXUFKaVHUV�
���� )LUVW� 9\HUa UHTXLUHG GLVWULEXWRUV WR HQWHU aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK WKHLU RZQ FXVWRPHUV
SUHYHQWLQJ WKH UHVaOH RI 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV�
���� )RU H[aPSOH� LQ 6HSWHPEHU ����� 9\HUa aXWKRUL]HG ,&6 �WKHQ UHWaLQHG aV a
GLVWULEXWRU aV ZHOO aV a WKLUG�SaUW\ ORJLVWLFV SURYLGHU� WR VHOO 'aUaSULP WR a JURXS RI 3XHUWR 5LFaQ
SKaUPaFLHV� $V SaUW RI WKH aXWKRUL]aWLRQ� 9\HUa UHTXLUHG ,&6 WR ³SURYLGH VRPH ZRUGLQJ RQ WKH
aFFRXQW SURKLELWLQJ VaOH RI GaUaSULP WR a WKLUG SaUW\�´ 9\HUa LQVWUXFWHG WKaW ³>S]URGXFW VKRXOG
RQO\ EH GLVSHQVHG WR SaWLHQWV LQ WKHLU IaFLOLWLHV�´ 7KLV UHTXLUHPHQW SUHYHQWHG ,&6’V FXVWRPHUV
IURP VHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV�
���� 6LPLOaUO\� LQ 0a\ ����� 9\HUa LQVWUXFWHG 2SWLPH WR LQFOXGH a ³3URGXFW 8VH
$WWHVWaWLRQ´ LQ LWV aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK KRVSLWaOV� 7KLV aWWHVWaWLRQ UHTXLUHG KRVSLWaOV WR JXaUaQWHH WKaW
'aUaSULP ³ZLOO QRW EH VROG� UHVROG� GLYHUWHG RU WUaQVIHUUHG WR aQ\ RWKHU SHUVRQ RU HQWLW\ IRU aQ\
UHaVRQ XQOHVV aSSURYHG LQ ZULWLQJ E\ 9\HUa RU LWV GHVLJQHH�´ 7KLV UHTXLUHPHQW SUHYHQWHG WKH
KRVSLWaOV IURP VHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV�
���� 6HFRQG� 9\HUa aOVR HQWHUHG GLUHFW aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK KRVSLWaOV aQG SKaUPaFLHV
SUHYHQWLQJ WKHP IURP UHVHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV�
���� $V SaUW RI LWV SULFLQJ aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK WKRXVaQGV RI KRVSLWaOV� 9\HUa UHTXLUHV WKHP
WR XVH 'aUaSULP RQO\ IRU WKHLU ³RZQ XVH´�ZKLFK LV GHILQHG aV WKH WUHaWPHQW RI WKH KRVSLWaO’V
SaWLHQWV� $V a UHVXOW� WKHVH KRVSLWaOV aUH FRQWUaFWXaOO\ SUHYHQWHG IURP VHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR aQ\RQH
RWKHU WKaQ SaWLHQWV� LQFOXGLQJ J HQHULF FRPSaQLHV�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 27 of 86
��
���� 9\HUa LQFOXGHV VLPLOaU WHUPV LQ LWV aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK KRVSLWaO JURXS SXUFKaVLQJ
RUJaQL]aWLRQV �³*32V´�� ZKLFK SXUFKaVH SURGXFWV RQ EHKaOI RI OaUJH JURXSV RI PHPEHU KRVSLWaOV�
)RU H[aPSOH� XQGHU 9\HUa’V FRQWUaFW ZLWK WKH *32 9L]LHQW� 9L]LHQW’V PHPEHU KRVSLWaOV FaQ
SXUFKaVH 'aUaSULP RQO\ IRU ³WKH XVH RI WKH 0HPEHU´ aQG ³QRW IRU UHVaOH WR aQ\RQH RWKHU WKaQ WKH
HQG XVH SaWLHQW RU FXVWRPHU�´ 7KLV UHVWULFWLRQ SUHYHQWV *32 PHPEHU KRVSLWaOV IURP VHOOLQJ
'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV�
���� 9\HUa KaV aOVR HQWHUHG GLUHFW FRQWUaFWV ZLWK :aOJUHHQV� ZKLFK VHOOV 'aUaSULP
WKURXJK LWV VSHFLaOW\ SKaUPaFLHV� 7KH aJUHHPHQWV VSHFLI\ WKaW :aOJUHHQV FaQ RQO\ SURYLGH
'aUaSULP WR LWV VSHFLaOW\ SKaUPaFLHV aQG WR SaWLHQWV ZLWK a SUHVFULSWLRQ� 7KH FRQWUaFWV SUHYHQW
:aOJUHHQV RU LWV VSHFLaOW\ SKaUPaFLHV IURP VHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV ZLWKRXW
9\HUa’V aSSURYaO�
���� 7aNHQ WRJHWKHU� 9\HUa’V UHVWULFWLRQV RQ GRZQVWUHaP SXUFKaVHUV SUHYHQW WKHP IURP
VHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ VHHNLQJ WR FRQGXFW )'$�PaQGaWHG ELRHTXLYaOHQFH
WHVWLQJ XQOHVV 9\HUa aSSURYHV WKH VaOH� 9\HUa GRHV QRW aSSURYH GRZQVWUHaP SXUFKaVHUV WR VHOO
'aUaSULP WR a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ RU a FRPSaQ\ WKaW PLJKW VHOO WR a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\� ,QGHHG�
9\HUa KaV QHYHU aXWKRUL]HG VXFK a VaOH� HYHQ WKRXJK LW ZRXOG PaNH VLJQLILFaQW SURILWV aQ\ WLPH
'aUaSULP LV VROG aW LWV OLVW SULFH�
�� 9\HUD OLPLWV DQG PRQLWRUV DSSURYHG VDOHV RI 'DUDSULP WR SUHYHQW JHQHULF FRPSDQLHV IURP REWDLQLQJ LW
���� ,Q aGGLWLRQ WR LWV aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK GLVWULEXWRUV aQG SXUFKaVHUV QRW WR VHOO 'aUaSULP
WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV� 'HIHQGaQWV WRRN IXUWKHU VWHSV WR HQVXUH JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV FRXOG QRW
SXUFKaVH WKH 'aUaSULP WKH\ QHHGHG WR FRQGXFW )'$�UHTXLUHG ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 28 of 86
��
���� $ ERWWOH RI 'aUaSULP FRQWaLQV ��� WaEOHWV� 'HIHQGaQWV NQHZ WKaW� LQ RUGHU WR PHHW
)'$ UHTXLUHPHQWV IRU ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ� aQ\ SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRU ZRXOG QHHG aW
PLQLPXP ��� WR ����� WaEOHWV� RU ILYH WR �� ERWWOHV RI 'aUaSULP�aQG OLNHO\ ZRXOG QHHG PRUH�
���� 9\HUa WKXV OLPLWHG WKH aPRXQW RI 'aUaSULP WKaW aQ\ RQH aSSURYHG HQWLW\ FRXOG
SXUFKaVH� $V a 9\HUa VHQLRU GLUHFWRU LQIRUPHG aW OHaVW RQH RI 9\HUa’V GLVWULEXWRUV� WKH JRaO RI
WKHVH TXaQWLW\ OLPLWV ZaV WR UHGXFH WKH ULVN ³WKaW a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ FRXOG aFFHVV PXOWLSOH ERWWOHV
RI >'aUaSULP]� SHUKaSV REWaLQHG WKURXJK a KRVSLWaO UHVHOOLQJ LW RU GLVWULEXWLQJ SURGXFW WR
VXUURXQGLQJ U HWaLO SKaUPaFLHV�´ 7KXV� HYHQ LI a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ EURNH WKURXJK 9\HUa’V ZHE RI
UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV� LW FRXOG QRW REWaLQ HQRXJK 'aUaSULP WR FRQGXFW ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ�
���� )RU H[aPSOH� LQ $XJXVW ����� 9\HUa aQG ,&6 �WKHQ a 'aUaSULP GLVWULEXWRU� aJUHHG
WKaW ,&6 Z RXOG QRW VHOO PRUH WKaQ ILYH ERWWOHV WR a VLQJOH FXVWRPHU ZLWKRXW 9\HUa’V H[SUHVV
aSSURYaO� 7KH SXUSRVH RI WKH ,&6 UHVWULFWLRQ ZaV WR ³HQVXUH WKaW WKH aFFRXQW LV OHJLW aQG QRW a
JHQHULFV PaQXIaFWXUHU�´
���� 6LPLOaUO\� 9\HUa’V ���� FRQWUaFW ZLWK 2SWLPH SUHYHQWV 2SWLPH IURP VHOOLQJ PRUH
WKaQ WKUHH ERWWOHV WR aQ\ SXUFKaVHU ZLWKRXW 9\HUa’V H[SUHVV aSSURYaO� %HIRUH LW ZLOO aSSURYH VXFK
a VaOH� 9\HUa UHTXLUHV 2SWLPH WR REWaLQ ³SUHVFULSWLRQ OHYHO LQIRUPaWLRQ´ RQ WKH SXUFKaVH� VXFK aV
WKH SUHVFULEHU aQG SUHVFULSWLRQ TXaQWLW\� 9\HUa WKHQ XVHV WKLV LQIRUPaWLRQ WR PaNH VXUH WKH
UHTXHVWHG 'aUaSULP ZLOO QRW EH GLYHUWHG WR a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\�
���� $QG LQ )HEUXaU\ ����� 9\HUa aSSURYHG VaOHV RI 'aUaSULP WKURXJK a QHZ
SKaUPaF\� 'UXJ 0aUW� EXW OLPLWHG 'UXJ 0aUW WR FaUU\LQJ RQO\ RQH ERWWOH RI 'aUaSULP LQ
LQYHQWRU\ aW a WLPH�
���� ,Q $XJXVW ����� 6KNUHOL KaG VHSaUaWH GLVFXVVLRQV ZLWK 0XOOHaG\ aQG 0LWKaQL
aERXW OLPLWLQJ aOO VaOHV RI 'aUaSULP WR RQH ERWWOH aW a WLPH LQ RUGHU WR SUHYHQW a JHQHULF
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 29 of 86
��
FRPSHWLWRU IURP REWaLQLQJ VXIILFLHQW 'aUaSULP VaPSOHV WR FRQGXFW ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ�
6KNUHOL XUJHG 0XOOHaG\ WR ³UHaOO\ FaUHIXOO\ VFUHHQ HYHU\ GRFWRU´ aQG HQVXUH WKaW QR RQH FRXOG
³VHOO PRUH WKaQ RQH ERWWOH aW a WLPH´ WR SUHYHQW a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ IURP ³JHW>WLQJ LWV] KaQGV RQ
aQ\WKLQJ�´ 6KNUHOL LQVWUXFWHG 0LWKaQL WKaW 9\HUa VKRXOG ³GR HYHU\WKLQJ´ LW FRXOG WR SUHYHQW a
JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ IURP REWaLQLQJ VaPSOHV RI 'aUaSULP� EHFaXVH SUHYHQWLQJ JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ
ZRXOG PaNH 'aUaSULP a ³���� PLOOLRQ aVVHW � � � LQ SHUSHWXLW\�´
���� (YHQ ZLWK 9\HUa’V FRPSOH[ ZHE RI UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV aQG TXaQWLW\ OLPLWV� LQ ����
0XOOHaG\ EHFaPH FRQFHUQHG WKaW WKHUH KaG EHHQ ³OHaNaJH´ WR a JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRU� ,Q 6HSWHPEHU
����� 0XOOHaG\ RUGHUHG a ³IXOO RXW aXGLW RI GaUaSULP´ VR KH FRXOG ³NQRZ ZKHUH HYHU\ ERWWOH RI
GaUaSULP ZH VROG ZHQW WR�´ 7KH QH[W PRQWK� 0LWKaQL GLUHFWHG 9\HUa HPSOR\HHV WR HVWaEOLVK a
V\VWHP ZLWK $6'�RQH RI 9\HUa’V PaLQ KRVSLWaO GLVWULEXWRUV�IRU LPPHGLaWH QRWLILFaWLRQ RI aQ\
RUGHUV� 0XOOHaG\ aQG 0LWKaQL ZaQWHG WR LGHQWLI\ ³RXWOLHU´ SXUFKaVHV WKaW PLJKW EH LQWHQGHG IRU a
JHQHULF FRPSaQ\� $6' aJUHHG WR IOaJ a Q\ VXFK RUGHUV IRU 9\HUa� 0XOOHaG\ aQG 0LWKaQL ZRXOG
WKHQ FRQWaFW WKH EX\HU WR ³LQTXLUH aV WR ZKaW WKHLU SXUSRVH LV�´
���� ,Q aW OHaVW RQH LQVWaQFH� WKLV aJJUHVVLYH PRQLWRULQJ aOORZHG 9\HUa WR TXLFNO\ EX\
EaFN 'aUaSULP WKaW PLJKW RWKHUZLVH KaYH EHHQ VROG WR a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\� ,Q $SULO ����� 9\HUa
HPSOR\HHV IOaJJHG aQ XQXVXaO SXUFKaVH IURP $6'� a FRPSaQ\ FaOOHG &HQWUaVWaWH 6SHFLaOW\
6FULSW�ZKLFK VKaUHV FRPPRQ RZQHUVKLS ZLWK 5HOLaQW 6SHFLaOW\ //&�KaG SXUFKaVHG ILYH
ERWWOHV RI 'aUaSULP aW RQH WLPH� ZKHQ LW KaG SUHYLRXVO\ QHYHU RUGHUHG PRUH WKaQ WZR� 0LWKaQL
ZaV FRQFHUQHG WKaW &HQWUaVWaWH KaG SXUFKaVHG 'aUaSULP RQ EHKaOI RI a JHQHULF�
���� 0XOOHaG\ GHWHUPLQHG WKaW 9\HUa VKRXOG EX\ EaFN WKH ILYH ERWWOHV IURP
&HQWUaVWaWH� 8VLQJ a PLGGOHPaQ� 0XOOHaG\ UHSXUFKaVHG aOO ILYH ERWWOHV IRU � WKH
SULFH &HQWUaVWaWH KaG SaLG�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 30 of 86
��
���� $V SaUW RI WKH UHSXUFKaVH FRQWUaFW� &HQWUaVWaWH aJUHHG ³QRW WR SXUFKaVH� GLUHFWO\ RU
LQGLUHFWO\ � � � aQ\ 'aUaSULP� H[FHSW GLUHFWO\ WKURXJK 9\HUa�´ 9\HUa VXEVHTXHQWO\ GLUHFWHG $6'
WR EORFN &HQWUaVWaWH IURP SXUFKaVLQJ aQ\ IXUWKHU 'aUaSULP�
�� 'HIHQGDQWV’ JHQHULF�EORFNLQJ UHVWULFWLRQV SUHYHQW JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV IURP SXUFKDVLQJ 'DUDSULP DQG KDYH QR OHJLWLPDWH UDWLRQDOH
���� 7aNHQ WRJHWKHU� WKH SXUSRVH aQG HIIHFW RI 9\HUa’V UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV� TXaQWLW\
OLPLWV� aQG PRQLWRULQJ LV WR SUHYHQW SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV IURP REWaLQLQJ VXIILFLHQW
VaPSOHV RI 'aUaSULP WR FRQGXFW )'$�PaQGaWHG ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ�
���� 'XH WR 9\HUa’V aJUHHPHQWV UHVWULFWLQJ UHVaOH� JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV FaQQRW SXUFKaVH
'aUaSULP aW aQ\ SRLQW LQ 9\HUa’V GLVWULEXWLRQ FKaLQ� 1RU FaQ JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV SXUFKaVH
'aUaSULP GLUHFWO\ IURP 9\HUa� ZKLFK UHIXVHV WR VHOO WKH SURGXFW WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV RU
FRPSaQLHV WKaW PLJKW UHVHOO WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV� $QG 9\HUa’V TXaQWLW\ OLPLWV aQG PRQLWRULQJ
HQVXUH WKaW� HYHQ LI a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ VOLSV WKURXJK WKH UHVWULFWLRQV aQG SXUFKaVHV VRPH
'aUaSULP� LW ZLOO QRW OLNHO\ REWaLQ HQRXJK WR FRQGXFW ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ�
���� *HQHULF FRPSaQLHV FaQQRW FLUFXPYHQW 9\HUa’V ZHE RI UHVWULFWLRQV E\ REWaLQLQJ a
'aUaSULP SUHVFULSWLRQ IURP a GRFWRU� 'RFWRUV aUH aOORZHG WR ZULWH SUHVFULSWLRQV IRU WKH WUHaWPHQW
RI a SaWLHQW� a GRFWRU FaQQRW ZULWH a SUHVFULSWLRQ IRU PHGLFaWLRQ WR EH XVHG LQ ELRHTXLYaOHQFH
WHVWLQJ� ZKLFK GRHV QRW LQYROYH WUHaWPHQW RI a SaWLHQW� 0RUHRYHU� HYHQ LI a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\
FRXOG REWaLQ a SUHVFULSWLRQ aQG XVH WKaW SUHVFULSWLRQ WR SXUFKaVH 'aUaSULP IURP a GLVWULEXWRU RU
SXUFKaVHU� 9\HUa’V TXaQWLW\ OLPLWV ZRXOG SUHYHQW ILOOLQJ a VLQJOH SUHVFULSWLRQ IRU WKH PLQLPXP
ILYH ERWWOHV QHHGHG IRU ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ� $QG HYHQ aVVXPLQJ WKH JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ ZHUH
aEOH WR aFTXLUH 'aUaSULP IURP a SKaUPaF\ ZLWK a SUHVFULSWLRQ� LW ZRXOG KaYH QR Za\ RI HQVXULQJ
WKaW aOO WKH ERWWOHV FaPH IURP WKH VaPH PaQXIaFWXULQJ ORW� aV UHTXLUHG E\ WKH )'$�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 31 of 86
��
���� 7KH SXUSRVH RI 'HIHQGaQWV’ H[WHQVLYH UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV aQG TXaQWLW\ OLPLWV LV WR
SUHYHQW JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV IURP REWaLQLQJ WKH 'aUaSULP QHFHVVaU\ WR PHHW WKH )'$’V
ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ UHTXLUHPHQWV aQG WKHUHE\ LPSHGH WKHP IURP OaXQFKLQJ JHQHULF 'aUaSULP
SURGXFWV�
���� 7KLV SXUSRVH ZaV SXEOLFO\ UHSRUWHG aQG ZLGHO\ NQRZQ� ,Q 6HSWHPEHU ����� WKH
1HZ U]HVWULFWHG
GLVWULEXWLRQ LQ WKLV FaVH ZaV a GHOLEHUaWH SaUW RI >9\HUa’V] SOaQ WR GHIHQG LWV VKRFNLQJ SULFH
LQFUHaVH aQG VXEVHTXHQW LQFUHaVHG UHYHQXH aJaLQVW SRWHQWLaO FRPSHWLWLRQ�´
���� $V SaUW RI WKH 6HQaWH LQYHVWLJaWLRQ� PXOWLSOH 9\HUa H[HFXWLYHV WHVWLILHG WKaW WKH
SXUSRVH RI WKH GLVWULEXWLRQ UHVWULFWLRQV ZaV WR SUHYHQW FRPSHWLWLRQ IURP JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV E\
GHQ\LQJ WKHP aFFHVV WR WKH VaPSOHV WKH\ QHHGHG IRU ELRHTXLYaOHQFH WHVWLQJ�
���� 7KH UHVWULFWLRQV SUHYHQWLQJ GLVWULEXWRUV RU SXUFKaVHUV IURP VHOOLQJ 'aUaSULP WR
JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV GR QRW KaYH aQ\ OHJLWLPaWH EXVLQHVV UaWLRQaOH�
���� 7KH UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV aUH QRW UHOaWHG WR aQ\ VaIHW\ FRQFHUQV aERXW 'aUaSULP�
3ULRU WR ����� 'aUaSULP ZaV VROG LQ RSHQ GLVWULEXWLRQ ZLWKRXW LQFLGHQW IRU PRUH WKaQ �� \HaUV�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 32 of 86
��
$GGLWLRQaOO\� WKH )'$ KaV QHYHU VXEMHFWHG 'aUaSULP WR aQ\ W\SH RI VaIHW\ SURJUaP� :KHQ GUXJV
SRVH VHULRXV VaIHW\ FRQFHUQV� WKH )'$ UHTXLUHV VHOOHUV WR LPSOHPHQW 5LVN (YaOXaWLRQ 0LWLJaWLRQ
6WUaWHJLHV �5(06� WR PLQLPL]H WKRVH ULVNV� $ 5(06 UHTXLUHPHQW FaQ LQFOXGH ZaUQLQJ OaEHOV�
HGXFaWLRQaO JXLGHV� aQG UHVWULFWLRQV RQ GLVWULEXWLRQ� 7KH )'$ KaV QHYHU UHTXLUHG WKaW 'aUaSULP
EH VXEMHFW WR aQ\ IRUP RI 5(06� 0RUHRYHU� VaIHW\ FRQFHUQV aUH QRW� aQG KaYH QHYHU EHHQ� WKH
UHaVRQ IRU WKH UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ RI 'aUaSULP�
���� 7KH UHVaOH UHVWULFWLRQV aUH aOVR QRW UHOaWHG WR SURYLGLQJ SaWLHQW VHUYLFHV aV SaUW RI
WKH GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP� %ORFNLQJ WKH VaOH RI 'aUaSULP WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV GRHV QRW SURYLGH RU
VXSSRUW aQ\ VHUYLFHV WR 'aUaSULP SaWLHQWV� $GGLWLRQaOO\� SURYLGLQJ SaWLHQW VHUYLFHV LV QRW aQG KaV
QHYHU EHHQ WKH SXUSRVH RI WKH UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP� :KHQ 9\HUa LQLWLaOO\ H[SORUHG WKH
ORJLVWLFV RI VHWWLQJ XS a UHVWULFWHG GLVWULEXWLRQ V\VWHP� LW UHMHFWHG WKH LGHa RI LQFOXGLQJ aGGLWLRQaO
SaWLHQW VHUYLFHV EHFaXVH WKH\ ZRXOG ³WaNH IRUHYHU´ WR VHW XS� $QG WKH GLVWULEXWLRQ UHVWULFWLRQV
KaYH LQ IaFW PaGH LW KaUGHU IRU SaWLHQWV WR REWaLQ 'aUaSULP� OHaGLQJ WR aGYHUVH PHGLFaO RXWFRPHV�
%� 'HIHQGDQWV (QWHU ([FOXVLYH $JUHHPHQWV :LWK $3. 0DQXIDFWXUHUV WR %ORFN *HQHULF &RPSDQLHV’ $FFHVV WR 3\ULPHWKDPLQH $3. 6XSSO\
���� ,Q aGGLWLRQ WR GHQ\LQJ SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV aFFHVV WR WKH 'aUaSULP
VaPSOHV WKH\ QHHG WR FRQGXFW )'$�UHTXLUHG WHVWLQJ� 9\HUa �XQGHU WKH VXSHUYLVLRQ aQG GLUHFWLRQ
RI 'HIHQGaQWV 6KNUHOL aQG 0XOOHaG\� IXUWKHU LPSHGHG JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ E\ ORFNLQJ XS WKH WZR
PRVW YLaEOH PaQXIaFWXUHUV RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH� WKH aFWLYH SKaUPaFHXWLFaO LQJUHGLHQW XVHG LQ
'aUaSULP�
���� 7R GHYHORS aQG FRPPHUFLaOO\ PaUNHW a JHQHULF YHUVLRQ RI 'aUaSULP� a SRWHQWLaO
JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRU ZRXOG QHHG WR VHFXUH a UHOLaEOH VRXUFH RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3,�
���� ,W LV ZHOO NQRZQ LQ WKH LQGXVWU\ WKaW LW LV VLJQLILFaQWO\ IaVWHU aQG OHVV H[SHQVLYH WR
VRXUFH $3, IURP a VXSSOLHU WKaW KaV a SUH�H[LVWLQJ PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV WKaW LV HLWKHU aSSURYHG
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 33 of 86
��
E\ WKH )'$ RU a JRRG FaQGLGaWH IRU )'$ aSSURYaO� 'LIIHUHQW $3,V UHTXLUH GLIIHUHQW HTXLSPHQW
aQG PHWKRGV WR PaQXIaFWXUH� ,W FaQ WaNH PRQWKV RU \HaUV� aV ZHOO aV aQ LQYHVWPHQW RI KXQGUHGV RI
WKRXVaQGV RI GROOaUV RU PRUH� IRU a PaQXIaFWXUHU ZLWKRXW a SUH�H[LVWLQJ SURFHVV WR GHYHORS RQH�
0RUHRYHU� WKH )'$ PXVW aSSURYH aQ\ $3, PaQXIaFWXUHU’V IaFLOLWLHV� SURFHVV� aQG SURGXFW EHIRUH
WKH $3, FaQ EH XVHG LQ a 8�6� SURGXFW� 5HWaLQLQJ a Q $3, PaQXIaFWXUHU ZLWK aQ XQaSSURYHG
SURFHVV HQWaLOV WKH ULVN WKaW WKH )'$ ZLOO QRW aSSURYH LW RU ZLOO UHTXLUH WKH PaQXIaFWXUHU WR LQYHVW
aGGLWLRQaO WLPH aQG H[SHQVH FRUUHFWLQJ GHILFLHQFLHV� 7KXV� HYHQ LI a PaQXIaFWXUHU KaV a SUH�
H[LVWLQJ SURFHVV� LW ZLOO QRW UHaGLO\ EH aEOH WR VXSSO\ $3, IRU a 8�6� SURGXFW LI LWV SURFHVV�
IaFLOLW\� RU PaQXIaFWXULQJ SUaFWLFHV aUH QRW XS WR )'$ VWaQGaUGV�
���� 2QH PHWKRG FRPPRQO\ XVHG LQ WKH LQGXVWU\ WR LGHQWLI\ $3, PaQXIaFWXUHUV ZLWK aQ
HVWaEOLVKHG� )'$�aSSURYaEOH PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV LV WR VHaUFK IRU '0)V� $ '0) LV a
VXEPLVVLRQ IURP aQ $3, PaQXIaFWXUHU WR WKH )'$ SURYLGLQJ GHWaLOHG LQIRUPaWLRQ aERXW WKH
PaQXIaFWXUHU’V IaFLOLW\ aQG SURFHVV IRU a JLYHQ $3,� 7KH ILOLQJ RI a '0) LQGLFaWHV WKaW WKH
PaQXIaFWXUHU KaV aOUHaG\ GHYHORSHG a PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV IRU WKaW $3, WKaW LW EHOLHYHV PHHWV
)'$ VWaQGaUGV� aQG WKXV WKaW LW FRXOG VHUYH aV a UHOLaEOH VRXUFH� $V 9\HUa’V GLUHFWRU RI EXVLQHVV
GHYHORSPHQW H[SOaLQHG� FRQWUaFWLQJ ZLWK a '0) KROGHU IRU $3, VXSSO\ GLPLQLVKHV a
SKaUPaFHXWLFaO FRPSaQ\’V ³H[HFXWLRQ ULVN�´
���� 8QGHUVWaQGLQJ WKHVH PaUNHW G\QaPLFV� 'HIHQGaQWV aFWHG WR SUHYHQW JHQHULF
FRPSHWLWRUV IURP REWaLQLQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, IURP VXSSOLHUV ZLWK aQ H[LVWLQJ� )'$�
aSSURYaEOH PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV�HVSHFLaOO\ WKRVH KROGLQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH '0)V� 'HIHQGaQWV
GHFLGHG WR VLJQ H[FOXVLYH FRQWUaFWV ZLWK aQ\ VXFK PaQXIaFWXUHUV WR IRUFH JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV WR
VSHQG VXEVWaQWLaO WLPH aQG PRQH\ ZRUNLQJ ZLWK a QHZ PaQXIaFWXUHU WR GHYHORS aQ )'$�
aSSURYaEOH S\ULPHWKaPLQH PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 34 of 86
��
�� 9\HUD ORFNV XS WKH RQO\ PDQXIDFWXUHU ZLWK DQ )'$�DSSURYHG PDQXIDFWXULQJ SURFHVV IRU S\ULPHWKDPLQH $3.
���� ,Q WKH VXPPHU RI ����� SULRU WR aFTXLULQJ 'aUaSULP� 9\HUa FRQWaFWHG
S\ULPHWKaPLQH VXSSOLHUV IURP WKH )'$’V '0) GaWaEaVH� $W WKaW WLPH� WZR $3, VXSSOLHUV KaG
ILOHG '0)V ZLWK WKH )'$� )XNX]\X aQG ,SFa /aERUaWRULHV /WG� 2Q RU aERXW -XQH �� ����� 9\HUa
FRQWaFWHG ERWK ,SFa aQG )XNX]\X VHHNLQJ WR HQWHU LQWR H[FOXVLYH VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQWV IRU
S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, WKaW ZRXOG SUHYHQW JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV IURP SXUFKaVLQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH IURP
HLWKHU FRPSaQ\�
���� 7KH QH[W Ga\� ,SFa WROG 9\HUa LW FRXOG QRW VXSSO\ S\ULPHWKaPLQH aQG WKXV aQ
³H[FOXVLYLW\ GHaO LV QRW SRVVLEOH�´ 6HYHUaO PRQWKV HaUOLHU� LQ -aQXaU\ ����� WKH )'$ KaG EaQQHG
LPSRUWV RI PRVW RI ,SFa’V $3,V� LQFOXGLQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH� GXH WR PaQXIaFWXULQJ GHILFLHQFLHV�
9\HUa TXLFNO\ XQGHUVWRRG WKaW WKLV LPSRUW EaQ ZRXOG JHQHUaWH WKH VaPH HIIHFW aV H[FOXVLYLW\� ,Q a
-XQH ��� ���� SUHVHQWaWLRQ WR SRWHQWLaO LQYHVWRUV� 9\HUa WRXWHG KRZ WKLV LPSRUW EaQ ZRXOG FaXVH
³VLJQLILFaQW GLVUXSWLRQ´ aQG GHOa\ WR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV SOaQQLQJ RU GHVLULQJ WR XVH ,SFa�
���� 7KLV OHIW )XNX]\X aV WKH RQO\ HVWaEOLVKHG PaQXIaFWXUHU RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, IRU
WKH 8�6� PaUNHW� ,QGHHG� )XNX]\X VHOOV S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, ZRUOGZLGH aQG KaV VXSSOLHG LW IRU
EUaQGHG 'aUaSULP LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV IRU GHFaGHV� %HFaXVH )XNX]\X’V S\ULPHWKaPLQH ZaV
aOUHaG\ EHLQJ XVHG LQ aQ )'$�aSSURYHG SURGXFW� 9\HUa NQHZ WKaW WKH )'$ KaG aOUHaG\
aSSURYHG )XNX]\X’V PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV aQG aQ\ FRPSaQ\ ZRXOG EH aEOH WR XVH )XNX]\X $3,
LPPHGLaWHO\�
���� 9\HUa’V LQLWLaO aWWHPSWV WR UHaFK aQ H[FOXVLYLW\ aJUHHPHQW ZLWK )XNX]\X ZHUH
UHMHFWHG� %XW 9\HUa GLG QRW JLYH XS� ,Q ����� LW UHWaLQHG a -aSaQHVH FRQVXOWaQW WR QHJRWLaWH ZLWK
)XNX]\X RQ LWV EHKaOI aQG VHQW a IRUPaO OHWWHU VHHNLQJ aQ LQ�SHUVRQ PHHWLQJ� %HJLQQLQJ LQ IaOO
����� 9\HUa aQG )XNX]\X EHJaQ VHULRXV QHJRWLaWLRQV� aQG RQ RU aERXW 1RYHPEHU ��� ����� WKH\
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 35 of 86
��
UHaFKHG aQ RUaO aJUHHPHQW IRU WKH H[FOXVLYH VXSSO\ RI )XNX]\X $3, IRU KXPaQ XVH LQ WKH 8QLWHG
6WaWHV� $ 9\HUa H[HFXWLYH EURNH WKH QHZV RI WKH aJUHHPHQW WR FROOHaJXHV E\ Va\LQJ� ³)XNX]\X
KaV aFFHSWHG RXU aJUHHPHQW WR SURYLGH S\ULPHWKaPLQH H[FOXVLYHO\ IRU XV IRU KXPaQ GUXJV aQG
ZLOO QRW VHOO WR JHQHULF PaQXIaFWXUHUV� 7KLV LV a ELJ VLJK RI UHOLHI IRU XV!´
���� ,Q -aQXaU\ ����� 3KRHQL[XV VLJQHG a ZLWK
)XNX]\X� )ROORZLQJ WKH WHUP� WKH aJUHHPHQW LV
���� $V H[HFXWHG� WKH FRQWUaFW IRUELGV )XNX]\X IURP VHOOLQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH WR aQ\RQH
RWKHU WKaQ 9\HUa IRU KXPaQ XVH LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV� 9\HUa H[SHFWHG aQG LQWHQGHG WKaW WKH
H[FOXVLYLW\ SURYLVLRQ ZRXOG SUHYHQW )XNX]\X IURP VHOOLQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, WR JHQHULF
FRPSaQLHV�
���� ,QGHHG� GXULQJ WKH QHJRWLaWLRQV� 9\HUa WROG )XNX]\X WKaW WKH ³PRVW FULWLFaO
LVVXH>]´ ZaV REWaLQLQJ aQ H[FOXVLYLW\ SURYLVLRQ WKaW ZRXOG SUHYHQW )XNX]\X IURP VHOOLQJ
S\ULPHWKaPLQH WR 9\HUa’V JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV� 9\HUa H[SOaLQHG WKaW ³>L]I JHQHULF SURGXFWV aUH
SXW RQ WKH 8�6� PaUNHW� >9\HUa] ZLOO IaFH a VHULRXV SUREOHP� aQG Pa\ HYHQWXaOO\ WHUPLQaWH WKH
PaUNHWLQJ RI 'aUaSULP�´ 9\HUa IXUWKHU VWUHVVHG WKaW HQWU\ RI a JHQHULF 'aUaSULP FRXOG SUHYHQW
9\HUa IURP ZRUNLQJ ZLWK )XNX]\X RQ IXWXUH SURMHFWV�
���� )XNX]\X KaV aELGHG E\ WKH WHUPV RI LWV H[FOXVLYH VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQW aQG
FRQVLVWHQWO\ FRQVXOWHG ZLWK 9\HUa WR YHULI\ WKaW SURSRVHG VaOHV ZRXOG QRW YLROaWH WKH H[FOXVLYLW\
SURYLVLRQ� 9\HUa UHJXOaUO\ GLUHFWV )XNX]\X QRW WR VHOO $3, WR aQ\ HQWLW\ WKaW FRXOG XVH WKH
S\ULPHWKaPLQH LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV IRU KXPaQ XVH� VXFK aV IRU a JHQHULF YHUVLRQ RI 'aUaSULP�
,QGHHG� aW OHaVW WZR SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV VRXJKW aQG ZHUH GHQLHG $3, IURP )XNX]\X GXH
WR WKH 9\HUa H[FOXVLYH FRQWUaFW�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 36 of 86
��
���� 7KHUH LV QR OHJLWLPaWH EXVLQHVV UaWLRQaOH IRU WKH H[FOXVLYLW\ SURYLVLRQ LQ WKH
)XNX]\X VXSSO\ FRQWUaFW� 7KH H[FOXVLYLW\ SURYLVLRQ GRHV QRW HQVXUH 9\HUa’V VXSSO\ EHFaXVH
)XNX]\X LV QRW REOLJaWHG WR UHVHUYH aQ\ YROXPH RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH IRU 9\HUa aQG FaQ VHOO aQ\
aPRXQW RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH WR FRPSaQLHV RXWVLGH WKH 8�6� RU IRU QRQ�KXPaQ XVH ZLWKLQ WKH 8�6�
1RU GRHV WKH H[FOXVLYLW\ SURYLVLRQ UHIOHFW a UHFRXSPHQW RI aQ\ LQYHVWPHQW 9\HUa PaGH LQ
)XNX]\X� ,QVWHaG� WKH SXUSRVH RI WKH H[FOXVLYLW\ SURYLVLRQ LV WR SUHYHQW SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF
FRPSaQLHV IURP REWaLQLQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, IURP )XNX]\X�
���� 7KH ���� H[FOXVLYH VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQW ZLWK )XNX]\X UHPaLQV LQ HIIHFW�
�� 'HIHQGDQWV SRDFK D VHFRQG $3. PDQXIDFWXUHU IURP JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV
���� $IWHU REWaLQLQJ H[FOXVLYLW\ IURP )XNX]\X� 9\HUa WKHQ VLJQHG a VHFRQG H[FOXVLYH
aJUHHPHQW WR ORFN XS WKH QH[W PRVW YLaEOH PaQXIaFWXUHU RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3,�
���� ,Q $XJXVW ����� 9\HUa EHFaPH aZaUH WKaW aQRWKHU $3, VXSSOLHU� 5/ )LQH &KHP�
ZaV SUHSaULQJ WR ILOH a '0) IRU S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV aQG ZaV ZRUNLQJ ZLWK
WZR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV� 5/ )LQH KaG a S\ULPHWKaPLQH PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV LQ SOaFH� KaG ILOHG
a (XURSHaQ '0)� aQG KaG H[SHULHQFH PaQXIaFWXULQJ aQG VHOOLQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH WR (XURSHaQ
FOLHQWV� 5/ )LQH’V (XURSHaQ '0) LQGLFaWHG LWV IaFLOLWLHV� TXaOLW\ VWaQGaUGV� aQG PaQXIaFWXULQJ
SUaFWLFHV ZHUH OLNHO\ VXIILFLHQW WR REWaLQ )'$ aSSURYaO� $IWHU )XNX]\X� 5/ )LQH ZaV WKH QH[W�
EHVW RSWLRQ IRU WKH VXSSO\ RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, WR aQ\ JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ VHHNLQJ WR GHYHORS a
JHQHULF 'aUaSULP SURGXFW IRU VaOH LQ WKH 8�6�
���� ,Q $XJXVW ����� VKRUWO\ aIWHU WaNLQJ EaFN FRQWURO RI 9\HUa WKURXJK KLV VXFFHVVIXO
SUR[\ ILJKW� 6KNUHOL GLUHFWHG 0XOOHaG\ aQG 0LWKaQL WR SXUVXH a VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQW ZLWK 5/ )LQH�
���� 2Q $XJXVW ��� ����� 6KNUHOL GUaIWHG aQ HPaLO WR 5/ )LQH LQTXLULQJ aERXW
S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, IRU WKH 8�6� PaUNHW aQG GLUHFWHG FR�([HFXWLYH 'LUHFWRU 0LWKaQL WR VHQG LW�
5/ )LQH UHSOLHG WKaW LW ZaV ³aOUHaG\ ZRUNLQJ RQ S\ULPHWKaPLQH aQG ZRXOG QRW EH aEOH WR RIIHU WR
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 37 of 86
��
\RX�´ 8QGHWHUUHG� 0XOOHaG\ aQG 6KNUHOL �WKURXJK 0LWKaQL� SXVKHG IRU ³a PRUH UREXVW
UHOaWLRQVKLS�´
���� 2Q 1RYHPEHU �� ����� 0XOOHaG\ �WKHQ FR�H[HFXWLYH GLUHFWRU ZLWK 0LWKaQL�
RIIHUHG 5/ )LQH aV FRQVLGHUaWLRQ IRU HQWHULQJ LQWR aQ H[FOXVLYH VXSSO\
aJUHHPHQW ZLWK 9\HUa� %\ 1RYHPEHU ��� ����� 9\HUa KaG aJUHHG WR Sa\ 5/ )LQH HYHQ PRUH IRU
aQ ³H[FOXVLYH aJUHHPHQW � � � IRU WKH GLVWULEXWLRQ RI aQ\ aQG aOO S\ULPHWKaPLQH EaVHG SURGXFW�´
2Q 'HFHPEHU ��� ����� 0XOOHaG\ �WKHQ VHUYLQJ aV 9\HUa &(2 aQG 3KRHQL[XV ERaUG FKaLUPaQ�
H[HFXWHG RQ EHKaOI RI 3KRHQL[XV WZR FRQWUaFWV ZLWK 5/ )LQH� a SURGXFW FROOaERUaWLRQ aJUHHPHQW
aQG a GLVWULEXWLRQ aQG VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQW�
���� 8QGHU WKH SURGXFW FROOaERUaWLRQ aJUHHPHQW� 9\HUa SaLG 5/ )LQH
� aQG WKH SaUWLHV aJUHHG WR FROOaERUaWH RQ WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI SURGXFWV� 1HLWKHU 9\HUa
QRU 5/ )LQH� KRZHYHU� VXEVHTXHQWO\ WRRN aQ\ VWHSV WR GHYHORS aQ\ RI WKHVH SURGXFWV�
���� 8QGHU WKH GLVWULEXWLRQ aQG VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQW� 5/ )LQH GHVLJQaWHG 9\HUa aV LWV
H[FOXVLYH GLVWULEXWRU RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, ZRUOGZLGH� 9\HUa KaV QR $3, GLVWULEXWLRQ
FaSaELOLWLHV aQG QR LQWHQWLRQ WR EHFRPH aQ $3, GLVWULEXWRU� $V 5/ )LQH’V S\ULPHWKaPLQH
GLVWULEXWRU� KRZHYHU� 9\HUa KaV WKH SRZHU WR YHWR aQ\ S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, VaOH RXWVLGH RI ,QGLa�
7KLV aOORZV 9\HUa WR EORFN aQ\ VaOH RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, IURP 5/ )LQH WR a SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF
FRPSHWLWRU� ,QGHHG� aW 9\HUa’V GLUHFWLRQ� 5/ )LQH FHaVHG VXSSO\LQJ S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, WR WKH
WZR JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV ZLWK ZKLFK LW KaG EHHQ ZRUNLQJ� 6LQFH VLJQLQJ WKH aJUHHPHQW ZLWK 9\HUa�
5/ )LQH KaV QRW VXSSOLHG S\ULPHWKaPLQH WR aQ\ FRPSaQ\ IRU XVH LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV�
���� ,Q UHWXUQ� 9\HUa aJUHHG WR Sa\ 5/ )LQH aQG
� 8QGHU WKH GLVWULEXWLRQ aQG VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQW� 9\HUa
KaV PaGH PRQWKO\ Sa\PHQWV WR 5/ )LQH UaQJLQJ IURP WR IURP )HEUXaU\ ����
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 38 of 86
��
WKURXJK aW OHaVW $XJXVW ����� 9\HUa aJUHHG WR PaNH WKHVH Sa\PHQWV ZKHWKHU RU QRW LW UHFHLYHV
aQ\ $3, IURP 5/ )LQH aQG LUUHVSHFWLYH RI ZKHWKHU 5/ )LQH’V $3, LV aSSURYHG IRU XVH LQ
'aUaSULP� 7R GaWH� 9\HUa KaV SaLG 5/ )LQH aSSUR[LPaWHO\ XQGHU WKH GLVWULEXWLRQ aQG
VXSSO\ aJUHHPHQW aQG KaV QRW UHFHLYHG aQ\ $3, IURP 5/ )LQH�
���� 7KH SXUSRVH RI WKH 5/ )LQH $JUHHPHQW ZaV WR HQVXUH WKaW 5/ )LQH FRXOG QRW
VXSSO\ aQ\ RI 9\HUa’V SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV�
���� 7KHUH LV QR OHJLWLPaWH EXVLQHVV UaWLRQaOH IRU WKH H[FOXVLYLW\ aJUHHPHQW� 9\HUa GLG
QRW QHHG aQG ZaV QRW VHHNLQJ aQ aGGLWLRQaO VRXUFH RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3,� )XNX]\X LV� aQG KaV
EHHQ� a UHOLaEOH VXSSO\ SaUWQHU� 7KURXJKRXW WKH WHUP RI LWV aJUHHPHQW ZLWK 9\HUa� )XNX]\X KaV
QHYHU KaG a VXSSO\ LQWHUUXSWLRQ RU RWKHU HYHQW WKaW SUHYHQWHG LW IURP SURYLGLQJ 9\HUa ZLWK
S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3,� ,QGHHG� )XNX]\X’V PLQLPXP SXUFKaVH EaWFK VL]H SURYLGHV 9\HUa ZLWK PRUH
S\ULPHWKaPLQH WKaQ LW FaQ XVH� 9\HUa KaV SXUFKaVHG S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, IURP )XNX]\X RQO\
WZLFH�RQ $XJXVW �� ����� aQG 1RYHPEHU ��� �����IRU aSSUR[LPaWHO\ HaFK WLPH�
$QG )XNX]\X KaV WKH FaSaFLW\ WR SURGXFH VLJQLILFaQWO\ JUHaWHU TXaQWLWLHV RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3,�
ZKLFK LW VWLOO UHJXOaUO\ VXSSOLHV WR RWKHU PaQXIaFWXUHUV IRU KXPaQ XVH RXWVLGH WKH 8�6� aQG IRU
QRQ�KXPaQ XVH LQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WaWHV�
���� (YHQ LI 9\HUa KaG ZaQWHG aQ aGGLWLRQaO VRXUFH RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3,� LW GLG QRW
UHWaLQ 5/ )LQH IRU WKaW SXUSRVH� )RU WKH HQWLUH WHUP RI WKH aJUHHPHQW� 9\HUa FRXOG QRW OHJaOO\ XVH
5/ )LQH’V S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, LQ 'aUaSULP EHFaXVH LW QHYHU VRXJKW RU REWaLQHG )'$ aSSURYaO WR
GR VR� 1RU GLG 5/ )LQH WaNH aQ\ IXUWKHU VWHSV WR FRQIRUP LWV SURFHVV WR )'$ UHTXLUHPHQWV�
���� ,QGHHG� 9\HUa’V aSSURaFK WR WKH 5/ )LQH QHJRWLaWLRQV GHPRQVWUaWHV WKaW LWV JRaO
ZaV QHYHU WR REWaLQ XVaEOH S\ULPHWKLPaQH $3, IURP 5/ )LQH� :KHQ QHJRWLaWLQJ LWV aJUHHPHQW
ZLWK )XNX]\X� 9\HUa SHUIRUPHG H[WHQVLYH GLOLJHQFH WR HQVXUH WKaW )XNX]\X ZRXOG EH aEOH WR
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 39 of 86
��
FRPSO\ ZLWK WKH )'$’V FXUUHQW JRRG PaQXIaFWXULQJ SUaFWLFHV �³F*03V´� aQG RWKHU TXaOLW\�
RULHQWHG PHaVXUHV UHTXLUHG E\ WKH )'$� 1XPHURXV 9\HUa WHFKQLFaO SHUVRQQHO ZHUH LQYROYHG LQ
WKHVH HIIRUWV� aQG WKH 9\HUa H[HFXWLYHV UHVSRQVLEOH IRU 4XaOLW\� 5HJXOaWRU\ $IIaLUV� aQG
&KHPLVWU\� 0aQXIaFWXULQJ aQG &RQWUROV �³&0&´� WUaYHOHG WR -aSaQ WR PHHW ZLWK WKHLU )XNX]\X
FRXQWHUSaUWV�
���� 7KH 5/ )LQH QHJRWLaWLRQV� KRZHYHU� ZHUH FRQGXFWHG E\ 0XOOHaG\ aQG 0LWKaQL
aORQH aQG ZLWKRXW aQ\ WHFKQLFaO VXSSRUW� 1HLWKHU 0XOOHaG\ QRU 0LWKaQL KaG aQ\ H[SHULHQFH ZLWK
RU NQRZOHGJH RI $3, VRXUFLQJ RU )'$ UHTXLUHPHQWV� aQG QHLWKHU KaG aQ\ UHOHYaQW VFLHQWLILF
EaFNJURXQG� 1R RQH aW 9\HUa SHUIRUPHG aQ\ GLOLJHQFH RQ 5/ )LQH’V aELOLW\ WR SURGXFH
S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3,� ,QGHHG� QRERG\ IURP 9\HUa’V &0& RU 4XaOLW\ GHSaUWPHQWV ZHUH LQYROYHG
LQ WKH QHJRWLaWLRQV ZLWK 5/ )LQH LQ aQ\ FaSaFLW\� $V RI 6HSWHPEHU ����� WKH 9\HUa FKLHI
VFLHQWLILF RIILFHU ZLWK XOWLPaWH UHVSRQVLELOLW\ IRU 'aUaSULP PaQXIaFWXULQJ ZaV QRW HYHQ aZaUH
9\HUa KaG a FRQWUaFW ZLWK 5/ )LQH�
���� 2Q 2FWREHU ��� ����� 9\HUa SaLG 5/ )LQH WR WHUPLQaWH WKH aJUHHPHQW�
%\ WKaW GaWH� WKH )HGHUaO 7UaGH &RPPLVVLRQ KaG VHQW VHYHUaO GLVFRYHU\ UHTXHVWV WR 9\HUa aQG 5/
)LQH aQG aVNHG H[WHQVLYH TXHVWLRQV aERXW WKH 5/ )LQH FRQWUaFWV GXULQJ LQYHVWLJaWLRQaO KHaULQJV
RI 9\HUa HPSOR\HHV�
���� 9\HUa’V H[FOXVLYH aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK )XNX]\X aQG 5/ )LQH KaYH VLGHOLQHG WKH WZR
PRVW YLaEOH VXSSOLHUV RI S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3, IRU SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF 'aUaSULP FRPSHWLWRUV� 7KLV
KaV PaGH LW VLJQLILFaQWO\ PRUH GLIILFXOW IRU SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV WR REWaLQ S\ULPHWKaPLQH
$3,� $OWKRXJK RWKHU PaQXIaFWXUHUV PLJKW HYHQWXaOO\ EH aEOH WR VXSSO\ S\ULPHWKaPLQH IRU WKH
8�6� PaUNHW� GXULQJ WKH UHOHYaQW WLPH SHULRG WKHVH PaQXIaFWXUHUV GLG QRW KaYH aQ HVWaEOLVKHG
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 40 of 86
��
S\ULPHWKaPLQH PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV� GLG QRW KaYH IaFLOLWLHV aQG SURFHVVHV LQ OLQH ZLWK F*03
VWaQGaUGV VXIILFLHQW IRU )'$ aSSURYaO� RU ERWK�
���� 7\SLFaOO\� LW WaNHV PRQWKV RU \HaUV IRU a VXSSOLHU WR GHYHORS aQG WHVW aQ $3,
PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV IURP VFUaWFK� )RU H[aPSOH� VSHQW VHYHUaO \HaUV aQG
RYHU ZRUNLQJ Z LWK a VXSSOLHU WR GHYHORS aQ )'$�aSSURYaEOH PaQXIaFWXULQJ SURFHVV IRU
S\ULPHWKaPLQH $3,�
���� )RU WKRVH PaQXIaFWXUHUV ZLWK a QRQ�FRPSOLaQW )'$ SURFHVV� LW ZRXOG WaNH
VXEVWaQWLaO WLPH aQG LQYHVWPHQW WR EULQJ WKHLU IaFLOLWLHV� TXaOLW\ FRQWUROV� aQG PaQXIaFWXULQJ
VWaQGaUGV LQ OLQH ZLWK F*03 UHTXLUHPHQWV WR EH HOLJLEOH IRU )'$ aSSURYaO� 7KHUHIRUH� 9\HUa’V
aJUHHPHQWV UHVXOWHG LQ VLJQLILFaQW FRVW aQG GHOa\ IRU aQ\ SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF aSSOLFaQW�
&� 9\HUD (QWHUV 'DWD�%ORFNLQJ $JUHHPHQWV WR 0DVN WKH 7UXH 6L]H RI WKH 3\ULPHWKDPLQH 0DUNHW
���� 9\HUa aOVR HQWHUHG LQWR GaWa�EORFNLQJ aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK LWV SULPaU\ GLVWULEXWRUV WR
PaVN WKH SRWHQWLaO PaUNHW RSSRUWXQLW\ IRU a JHQHULF 'aUaSULP SURGXFW�
���� 2QH RI WKH ILUVW VWHSV IRU a JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ FRQVLGHULQJ Z KHWKHU WR GHYHORS a
FRPSHWLQJ JHQHULF SURGXFW LV WR aQaO\]H WKH EUaQGHG SURGXFW’V VaOHV GaWa WR GHWHUPLQH WKH VL]H RI
WKH PaUNHW RSSRUWXQLW\� %aVHG RQ WKH PaUNHW VL]H aQG VaOHV GaWa� WKH FRPSaQ\ FaQ GHWHUPLQH WKH
SRWHQWLaO SURILWV LW FaQ H[SHFW IURP GHYHORSLQJ WKH SURGXFW�
���� 7R PaNH WKLV aVVHVVPHQW� JHQHULF FRPSaQLHV UHO\ RQ FRPPHUFLaOO\ aYaLOaEOH VaOHV
LQIRUPaWLRQ� 7KHVH GaWa aUH VROG E\ FRPSaQLHV VXFK aV ,49,$ aQG :ROWHUV .OXZHU� 7KHVH
FRPSaQLHV SXUFKaVH VaOHV GaWa IURP GUXJ GLVWULEXWRUV aQG SKaUPaFLHV� aJJUHJaWH WKH GaWa� aQG
VHOO LW WR SKaUPaFHXWLFaO LQGXVWU\ SaUWLFLSaQWV�
���� 9\HUa UHOLHG RQ VaOHV GaWa IURP ,49,$ LQ GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKHWKHU WR SXUFKaVH
'aUaSULP LQ ����� 9\HUa FRQWLQXHV WR XVH ,49,$ GaWa WR HYaOXaWH RWKHU GUXJ RSSRUWXQLWLHV�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 41 of 86
��
���� 9\HUa LV a SULYaWHO\�KHOG FRPSaQ\ aQG GRHV QRW SXEOLFO\ UHSRUW 'aUaSULP VaOHV
ILJXUHV� 7KXV� WKH RQO\ Za\ IRU a SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRU WR aVVHVV WKH VL]H RI WKH 'aUaSULP
PaUNHW LV WR SXUFKaVH FRPPHUFLaO VaOHV GaWa IURP a WKLUG�SaUW\ GaWa UHSRUWLQJ FRPSaQ\�
���� $IWHU aFTXLULQJ 'aUaSULP� 9\HUa VRXJKW WR SUHYHQW LWV GLVWULEXWRUV IURP VHOOLQJ
'aUaSULP VaOHV LQIRUPaWLRQ WR ,49,$ RU RWKHU GaWa UHSRUWLQJ FRPSaQLHV�
���� 9\HUa IHaUHG WKaW� aIWHU LW UaLVHG WKH SULFH RI 'aUaSULP� WKH LQFUHaVHG VaOHV ZRXOG
aWWUaFW JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV� %\ SUHYHQWLQJ UHSRUWLQJ FRPSaQLHV IURP REWaLQLQJ 'aUaSULP VaOHV
GaWa� 9\HUa XQGHUVWRRG WKaW WKH SXEOLFO\ aYaLOaEOH GaWa ZRXOG EH LQaFFXUaWH� WKHUHE\ REVFXULQJ
WKH WUXH VL]H RI WKH 'aUaSULP PaUNHW�
���� 8QGHU 9\HUa’V aJUHHPHQWV ZLWK LWV GLVWULEXWRUV� 9\HUa SaLG WKHP a ³GaWa EORFNLQJ
IHH´ LQ H[FKaQJH IRU WKHLU aJUHHPHQW QRW WR VHOO GaWa WR ,49,$ RU RWKHU VLPLOaU FRPSaQLHV�
���� ,Q ����� 9\HUa aJUHHG WR Sa\ $6' a ³GaWa UHVWULFWLRQ´ IHH RI SHU PRQWK LQ
H[FKaQJH IRU $6'’V aJUHHPHQW QRW WR VHOO 'aUaSULP VaOHV GaWa WR ,49,$� :ROWHUV .OXZHU� RU
RWKHU WKLUG�SaUW\ GaWa UHSRUWLQJ FRPSaQLHV�
���� ,Q ����� 9\HUa aJUHHG WR Sa\ a ³GaWa EORFNLQJ IHH´ RI
LQ H[FKaQJH IRU aJUHHPHQW QRW WR VHOO 'aUaSULP VaOHV
GaWa WR ,49,$� :ROWHUV .OXZHU� RU RWKHU WKLUG�SaUW\ UHSRUWLQJ FRPSaQLHV�
���� :LWKRXW UHSRUWLQJ IURP VLJQLILFaQW GLVWULEXWRUV OLNH $6' aQG � ,49,$’V
'aUaSULP GaWa LV ³H[WUHPHO\ LQFRPSOHWH aQG QRW YHU\ XVHIXO�´
���� ,Q $SULO ����� WKH )'$ QRWLFHG WKaW WKH ,49,$ GaWa IRU 'aUaSULP VXJJHVWHG
H[WUHPHO\ ORZ VaOHV� 7KH )'$ FRQWaFWHG 9\HUa WR aVN LI 'aUaSULP ZaV LQ VKRUWaJH� :KHQ 9\HUa
HPSOR\HHV ORRNHG LQWR WKH LVVXH� WKH\ TXLFNO\ GHWHUPLQHG WKaW WKH ORZ VaOHV ILJXUHV WKaW KaG
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 42 of 86
��
FRQFHUQHG WKH )'$ ³OLNHO\ UHOaWHG WR WKH EXVLQHVV GHFLVLRQ >9\HUa] PaGH WR EORFN GLVSHQVH�VaOHV
GaWa UHSRUWHG E\ >LWV] GLVWULEXWLRQ SaUWQHUV�´
���� 7KH SXUSRVH aQG HIIHFW RI 9\HUa’V GaWa�EORFNLQJ UHVWULFWLRQV ZaV WR REVFXUH WKH
VL]H RI WKH 'aUaSULP PaUNHW WR PaNH LW OHVV aWWUaFWLYH WR JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV� 9\HUa HQJaJHG LQ
WKLV FRQGXFW ³WR SUHYHQW H[WHUQaO YLVLELOLW\ LQWR >LWV] FRUSRUaWH SHUIRUPaQFH�´ 9\HUa GLG QRW ³ZaQW
*LOHaG RU aQ\ RI WKH RWKHU PaMRU LQIHFWLRXV GLVHaVH FRPSaQLHV FRPLQJ LQ � � � aQG WaNLQJ RYHU >]
ZKaW ZH FUHaWHG�´
���� 9\HUa’V FRQGXFW KaG WKH GHVLUHG aQWLFRPSHWLWLYH HIIHFW� $V UHVXOW RI 9\HUa’V GaWa�
EORFNLQJ UHVWULFWLRQV� aW OHaVW RQH JHQHULF FRPSaQ\ GHFLGHG QRW WR LQLWLaWH a SURMHFW WR GHYHORS a
JHQHULF YHUVLRQ RI 'aUaSULP�
���� 7KH GaWa�EORFNLQJ U HVWULFWLRQV LPSRVHG RQ WZR RI 9\HUa’V PRVW LPSRUWaQW
GLVWULEXWRUV KaYH QR OHJLWLPaWH UaWLRQaOH� :KLOH 9\HUa KaV QR REOLJaWLRQ WR SXEOLFO\ UHSRUW LWV
RZQ 'aUaSULP VaOHV GaWa� WKH ZKROHVaOHUV’ 'aUaSULP VaOHV GaWa LV QRW 9\HUa’V WR FRQWURO� 3ULRU WR
WKH PRUH OXFUaWLYH RIIHU IURP 'HIHQGaQWV� $6' aQG ZHUH UHJXOaUO\ VHOOLQJ WKHLU
'aUaSULP VaOHV GaWa WR ,49,$ aQG RWKHUV� 7KH VROH SXUSRVH RI WKH GaWa�EORFNLQJ a JUHHPHQWV LV WR
PaVN WKH VL]H RI WKH 'aUaSULP PaUNHW�
9.� 'HIHQGDQWV’ $QWLFRPSHWLWLYH &RQGXFW 6XFFHVVIXOO\ 'HOD\HG DQG ([FOXGHG 3XPHURXV 3RWHQWLDO *HQHULF &RPSHWLWRUV
���� 'HIHQGaQWV’ aQWLFRPSHWLWLYH FRXUVH RI FRQGXFW ZRUNHG� $V WKH UHVXOW RI 9\HUa’V
aJUHHPHQWV UHVWULFWLQJ WKH UHVaOH RI 'aUaSULP� H[FOXVLYH $3, aJUHHPHQWV� aQG GaWa�EORFNLQJ
aJUHHPHQWV� aW OHaVW IRXU SRWHQWLaO JHQHULF FRPSHWLWRUV KaYH EHHQ GHOa\HG RU H[FOXGHG IURP WKH
PaUNHW� � � � aQG
0\OaQ� 1�9�
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 43 of 86
��
Case 1:20-cv-00706-DLC Document 86 Filed 04/14/20 Page 44 of 86
���� 'HIHQGDQWV„ H[FODVLRQDU\ FRQGDFW LPSHGHG DELOLW\ WR GHEHORS D
JHQHULF EHUVLRQ RI 'DUDSULP� $EVHQW 9\HUD„V FRQGDFW� OLNHO\ ZRDOG KDEH HQWHUHG WKH
PDUNHW \HDUV HDUOLHU ZLWK D JHQHULF EHUVLRQ RI 'DUDSULP�
���� )RDQGHG LQ � LV D SKDUPDFHDWLFDO FRPSDQ\ ZLWK DERDW
HPSOR\HHV ORFDWHG LQ � 6LQFH LWV LQFHSWLRQ� KDV VDFFHVVIDOO\
GHEHORSHG WKURDJK $1'$V�
���� ,Q ����� GHFLGHG WR GHEHORS D JHQHULF EHUVLRQ RI 'DUDSULP� 'DUDSULP
ZDV DWWUDFWLEH WR EHFDDVH LW ZDV RII SDWHQW DQG KDG QR JHQHULF FRPSHWLWLRQ�
���� QHHGHG D PLQLPDP RI VL[ ERWWOHV RI 'DUDSULP IRU )'$�UHTDLUHG
ELRHTDLEDOHQFH WHVWLQJ� $W WKDW WLPH� $PHGUD 3KDUP
Recommended