ร่าง พระราชบัญญัติ...

ร่าง พระราชบัญญัติ

วิธีพิจารณาคดีผู้บริโภค (ฉบับที่ ..) พ.ศ. ....

(แก้ไขเพิ่มเติมหลักเกณฑ์การอุทธรณ์และฎีกา)

(คณะรัฐมนตรี เป็นผู้เสนอ)

บรรจุระเบียบวาระการประชุมสภานติิบัญญัตแิห่งชาติ ครั้งที่ ๔๕/๒๕๕๘

วันศุกร์ที่ ๑๗ กรกฎาคม ๒๕๕๘ อ.พ. ๕๙/๒๕๕๘

n

I trinqUdiviieuniTinnertriiticut-Pu,vilt-rii

( 4.111V1

Q1 WO. ....

(wileutiiaaiuvaninnovinilqmslnItathI ni)

(nngipuoi' vtiukikama)

(alu ..) (L1171,11AJIAL1IA1flmtuvi

nn5qv155n166a4n1) Lau@lou nfut5lanal via2n 1J5tqv15 ''1,4111i1@ 6/1 -1 itutnunillmal

ktJ5:znuanTraltiQVILLIAn1F1 Lij@lufi G) 1D&& Vilell',110,11 -111;11:41),f1Pillii1 6/JA

11'15i1.1 -1VIVIJY1174),0 61.1@li1151. 5. 2.11.,1f1J,LLIA15TH1f141M1V1EJ (Mn.1 6/TWITY))111/15k1T1 61.11v&&6)

i loofiviA'finn5LLazi,viqNatlr.,n@ullyntyrotity,t -PQ17trr

ViiflflT

1,1,171,%17\i1JIALVI5tYllitTf11,0,rigilT1MVAW`U31 ,11R 1N.P1. l.9&&G)

(o)) filVild11,1'4411^1-111111Vii@441 621i110q1/155f1ILLNtifIRgc:kUilf1F1Vii@filapy155f11 ,11-1 R

LLNIII161(11J311141,11§thql (LIAITAIJIALIJNYI -mma@l)

(b) tinviialinl'&14-rrAlyrinvivii@finn@lfinaqvismILLNunRgqVilswrvii@

maqvislalfrimuesrunKkullnfi lin5t14-11$h 0,LfilAMAIL Charmyi &G))

(GT) uni:Antlouin v6nLnami itaLltinn5Itim4rnFinqvilnwnvii@g41(unLkil.rwm &Iv

IMI51 can Loano151 &)

iviopm

losciliiiin-15LoilvdiVUllviA'nLnwiinn5q1/55n.ILLaqinnoraAJ5n.raan.flmn8

1`817Rnt-unn-r-immil PU41.1431WV155C111,6MAcli ii*T4fl'Iti;1 @ 1

laJMitl1VIV1m114fin aLn-awrihtli'utivviA'ni,nt-uyinqvisnliotnitimAlejt31.nn11,111

ffillgi@W1h11,§1.152AJULF1EJT-ill :e14-16`til.lk1V111115L'71Iffit-ljtgni

iimIn-rtrUfggriNwIlantiiki,Vitnm (waril ..) (Lett ollitilart4ninnokilqinslnItiar.4ni)

(Agutisuidi lazigia)

cti

.... (ailed ifiu Su, vi 61-1Lf1C1.1 61,1

111,11M11111A11.111.101 arionn

tinmwariEnfitimeriiim4nnliilAtitiinviliilnl*rwinfriArimlnvii41

V13.11.1 1M1 &G)11 9/1)glillArlf11.411/11E441 6d@lfilaqV155t-111,1, NIVIMA' qUilflfillatfilaq 1155 t111-1 'M

LLNunmAlquilnRIM_JcAlo (iNanoni m 1110M€ 4)

fillinAlifT1411 .1gA111111_41Vii@441 62.1@lillaq1155f1161, N1.111MqUili1 M 141 @

fainavinaiIIMLLN1,111F1A1 q1B1119 'f@l13115u@tit-v., 191v-Inml*NriLuvitifpiTILLvilthananoinnEi

T8fR15€l.nmymi66IAi4 e (re)) 'n. rh.vicoNunt,Sndnuln

41?I'mvinaqvinnli,LNunmAlqtrilomvii@finaqvint -i.l.frimurayAquiliyi lullItanAfpilerlku-mn56.1

(1`11.11 1(15'1 &Iv 2..11VI5'1 &GT, Lon.mml ilvilmtyrninjt-DiT8fmItunmgquilnm VV.P1. tD&&G)

(5141110111 ct WI6AMI14111 c#k 1111151 cral cre) ri-rtinativictik,EPLiAlo@li'unn4nnfliejvilnaimnaqvinniLLeatn9quiliim

coluriagvindo-nRuNunRA'quilnfliVnfrvIntm -mi@Fh?Tlfi@eulcuciciAluT-ittitilt-PifilictnAjti

liinOitimurvalwiil'lifinOicaEjf-iou-Yucromn-ruiTt-Qt-PlittilnPuvun -i -ipktvihn-m7NN -mo

Tif-wriam N14111VI51

akii/l@li-14111Z11 6617tVAPIBIti@llatifliiellitilA (Q1:11A1 ..)

Litiellbammklriunmtfilm.151AJI17tuuqvint-IILLa4nwra.rthr,a.iwnoilanu

1817n1f1.1'Wr13J661Ai4

linViunnAv-=niiyinnviaiTovinailm -ranwLi -Jar,?Cinlm'rad_li..ann -roi

luLanknIcoinbnuaniinlin151.71PuSvitmut-vignalmraA'otAtnotLaltau 614w,'6t1.4

f-1-156-u-auFra-mu:AnillAvitlulnvulii@Eillymi -nott,tunuriTai

LiNeliFIWVq1131,i1/1i11101n5114n15ii@n5t11161i/tHT1LIgnkVi@UIJUVAI.1 -10

luir-irma@dnerthtFrdnnvi

illiAlltIlIJIICR171Tdii@l1E1114141111.11f1 (£11:11.1i1 ..) ....

(fauzismuoil Ibur;ILvtio)

o 0

onol7d5tnamn5ii@nw.inillmuvrolit-vOltI fiv-i5an41(1Vilrin ..)

(Lviln6YVL6(1m6fI6nuvinn5qvisw1d66arim) 1,01.18flEJ voLon tJuqvig

vihrunon5priai vimhz,snuarniNITcuOLLvilt -ii G) n5n,p11.1 19&&

1,6Villa11711%1.1'IMLItlY117f1AFIT@I5N5551.11611,LI,Vil5TUMCIAM1,V1 0 (Q,171.4-)F15 -n) curvisKmn/r ID&&G)!

L@na-il_ltn@tin-ifiWn11,11i111A152,17111`Clf1),IFIQ171.1171 tlYl1 ~11161N ~~~~1. 51 fl 15

T@l'llti011 -11N1T4101,1,1A1T1 10E.11:116111-da -ITliStlEit N tal.11;816-11Ld A @lhviAl@UtnvunnATm.n

'Ll@l all nanliN aviltn

diiiringunne

UhaimiliilditTnyruLnalnEnivnicinTcygiiiithatrii nInTna.i ificrdt

i@noiliJunotmilfira Inn

trim.141 em rd 1111a1111 -1144101 1015LIAllifi?1EJ

1.111073?1,79151 "J55ilinqa

tnla-nenni'ntl a5lle1rm4 Ltio5alvia

tr1d Armn-1 750.1011

016M5111;15551.1

1,111?Miii115 614

11*.1111.1fV11.11E1 A-ranflonno

i'iVinw-A-run.flvanu c;16-nnurn5g -nlinvano ql_TIOIVItirrin01 -runviano UnTtifltiiin-11 IviEnf-Mitrimm

Li19Ht:Inl-1u5In-m.lh1711-11.1 Li-roviTnynArilingSqatIP'1 -114 Ir. olDsrio-) dtv

NSminu nn:I.J1Tun-aan4 SmInnwiAlln4 Im. o 0)0110)-

tlunoun-animnilonnivikytgiaJunildlortlitiairluthvgalaniiiroillimPLIMAtiii

wwvv.senate.go.th

611.1

lo 141J1E118/119,11PINVI o 631tmece no

IYV1011*11451101.11iinnliVAITTAillniA erlii

MITA fMaillniiazo -nr,d-lk/MAillitlIZITtititp:inlkilttlfiFiquitrin (OVA'

(gilt LiiaJiiia.1146"fiLfnuelinilpyisuliiar,4n1)

(finat vikukiLotio)

MIA 91111A1AVUISIVU

VISZIlen7tipTiViliznilanalkivitnn vim. loctcre

eilfinamlunilii@ilantlivqrthzananginneagcniInnfiliaJuviA

iiiinAlu(P1gurmlunilnqtrhI ni 17,N-11w-11161)

Grl ii@klaihr,n@UniTiti@i5nniiAMI:,19 661.440161ki5nnfiA1 4`Anfi (Q)-Thfil ....

ailriliAin al614 1Pyi 51111 Lia )

• 414u,1Fria.i4n6ii9.kun -15115 1n.flvano - -

• caiffin?inilfilli.gaitmunnntiqnn

thzip@6-11115t5-rociTtliellt7Nnwunfiquilrifi ..) ....

(66rit6tiVankcenmapvinn5qco55t-Laz4ni)

eogiltD&& - 6T1 -

• Lal'AOLFli Erriun151.71fitainTinnoquilnm -

Lan'hvilln.flvaneflicNiv-15t-in

6). tanFlonvin.nE11711.11SIN (Positive law)

vriLmnaio 6H1 Thomas Hobbes - -

b. 611a101,ail.101.1 (Liberalism)

viwi7'1LA0 6m1 John Locke - -

m. La1Film5c1Utiutli (Utility)

WILMT11,1FIV1T@1 Jeremy Bentham -

LLVAW1711.1EJF155U (Justice)

VILRYILFWIt@l John Rawls - -

W111.Tql, (6@)

4U1

• 11,m5nr,iNvilii@nvanE.J1unn5qvis5alua4mInm) - 06) -

• 41@gnliwAl5r,5-rotimgrigfi@n5w*ge:itliliw ..) - cc -

ninennn

: 141tT1 661.74),01i8171V15arlflqU31,11M l9&&G) (0)

fitn o&ocrybaleG) f15f1,21f1L lu&&

i'llIAIT,1;51T17f1J,016r11 0XYIntlyurn5qvis5diLLa4nn 511.1 e Qtiu

nyruilErutl5L's-ruonntlFrik,OLLvimi ())

vv v

(LLAinvitiLIALVIAjilinuAmqviswILLat ' 4 m)

((P1futtwumi" vitti,z,hati@) (me)

: 17.01n1Lm5naliaTii?mtg-ififv,

6mli-mAl5r,5-rnit-1101.8M15comgqtril.fim Wuci ..) (urilnolLA'vt4n6naminn5qms5n.ILLat&'1)

(mt-utillvtal Lti4Lot2) (11:11f3)

dltifli 0

fyliuvrJuarniatiltdiiit-y,

vol

ilAvanieutit-p,,t-Mgcniln.rwilk,iciiiInn (Qtitriti ..)

11.A. ....

(Lifilmfianiiarvi'atnaninilqmsIniiLathini)

(nnedigannii ifh(lima)

6)

toliiontlittimPiTifiwIlanfiquitrin (alTviti (Luileukflutilan46nifineyinilqvisIdauntijni)

(figuttarumi viltiOma)

fillah1111

ill1A15:,1 711r6ityPINT15tInflq1J5lffl (Q1.71.1c11 ..)1/01. (66f1tTLh6i1lref16ntu7i

f115e7g 1/155€1d666~ ° f11) Laugmo fgutil9roci.spcifi mon thz,'Nv16 varuntinily.ruvii

via.lusivarricAtTNIFILLviltni 6) mn,Q1n.i iD&&

iAl0'15tovraffm_74066@5ilinwkR66 ilT-roonfu -4m1vIu (mL1vihm-n)111/15FT1151/1 lv&&c4

o

6). vii'nniluatavivem

6).6) vannil

usilIALLFmnintInttitlit-O-FigiNn5arifi4,1,Viln9 b&&G)

(6)) tinviuoligAmintl-iviii@44m1filaqvis5d.muunmAlejuitrwrvilunaqvinci1,frim

aNufwiiquilnmlittufiqo -mma@l)

(b) ti-vitollvM1*14-rcAllArirr&nvii@441/1@vinagvindiLusrunm(1eI:vilnflvii@

maqvis5t111-11RU11.111f1Flq`uillim gAium.igritiN nnFr4 (1,LflnIALLF1LIM1T1 &o.))

(GT) EntSfAlutiln ii6filfltlIviarltinnitirmt4 m4nfronnywri@41 (snOmrp-151 &AD

1.114151 &cri Lotanmln &)

e.la 1,149Nfl

Imt.iitlginmvilAtli'tniilviA'nmanin -17qvinti.ILLa4n -ora.rihzananviano

1`67N-15n.rim-rannAil 11181,1 2/fm'A'LLrileililiqoltm-,'Tv'theriaqvinaluatmkiiiihajm -14nnv.ikl

nfawrilm.151stilivikiLnuyinlIqvIsmILLpqmlwiquilnp-Nil

m-aunomhlviitnrutiolu - fiu '''14-11A1.4k1V1Y1115L'711117fUfiriill

(1111110111 0)

911415'1 6) 115t51 661)ifv,t-Pcrilonn "vntymiltoPil'8CAN15f1.114qUilf1M ..)

i1011:111/11Itn71 .75171@llildlAqUitilfl (Q1.111f11 ..) ....

(116111137111613.114ninnainilqvisulluaLAni)

(nruzistrumi Auklunia)

fiithiln

loefiLturnvIgn5LLtitstufaiSiLvnno-i-i-mItlfm,t -unm(Iqvilnfl

e. lf3)

113 mtyrnitini .iittyllitilfivhavii'litimnnTuthtn-wilt.15nt NTItiLum_ln

dt. moll-atm-11 sit)

111V151 sil liliW,511.1fIla& -15f1191f115V1LIN5E51111X1f1,1,711.1

b. LC410141110 li11115:1111117i11,0

b.e)

VilaJaJ1F111 ete

16W1df1(P1S1W1J5~f11r1~Vi6~ 141Y1 61 (ill1119111 sn crollIfimal)

8no151 cn liunt,SnFriailvmm?imounmn 51111TtArig 17N

. tD&&6) LLMAVirtifrnli Oi@lthiLVM

"111FJUtT,WilArIV15 -1 &G) 41frorinvrvii@A'-iMNFilaqvinaliiNunaiMinmiLar,

maqvinalginmumunfiquilnfil,Mtifilo"

fiiminalliniI4n1flifiliintrimiafliAltalfmaqvisleitmunAg4ultnn

Viusiaqm5ItilnifnmunAgquilnn

toilthnnan,flvianeiBii@ilguionimail (illanom c Eno

3.11(111 eliEffitSrim-nakuanvm &G) 66vivnt51reicg 1751Nv15tun4eiuil.rim Y M. tD) ar,11,11,i @ nnL91ltifi u uviu

"1.11V151 &o-) nAfrwiniilAnnlJnvii@iletn@lmnaqvindaLeninFliquillifivii@ FilqvindlinFI6LN1 nmA71J3Inm ,if ui4-11AV.i@lAlumifrviv-inFria:dnnorLtotitAil

(017`014 ..)

(iiriltaivaium'A'ninneyinlITosulluazh'ni) (icuzi'sarinti Ltue:hatia)

cn

b.en ri-iviumliuniAndoth nuilmiabiniai@ii@ilnnotignolirdnifiAmintn

Itrthr,011.1

‘OguvridifiguculAnuil m19,1119111 orb 111V111 atm 16 n111V111 (re ivAoluliviituggii

kur&G) (11w8rw151 &uni:Anuipm 1.11(5171 enn L6azIrIVII1cre)

woill liumSnly-m51 3J'1 i15'1 &cn Lota.rom 66villAI5r,7 -itt1tuf0

1.8M-15w-wAlejuillim tv&&G)

fiTtiruocuyrikqiii6ADINikimilhiniRquilnni4linpyinalurunnquittifi

miamlaqmslnifilnumuf144cuitnaJfi -lf1111f111 - 1H

1.111714u 1411110T1J91111fp8J1E1ki3egillOTcu@ki, ouitriliA111111/11:1q44

n'ii@timi@niVA@970.11@inftiahlni b)

9.11V151 b 11 -1411'1414 q1J3111F1171Fi'laq1/155f111,1441.1114q`Uniftflliii@rrlaq1155t1111' 1 F1

LLNI-IfIRF1(11Jili14411/711^1111V1Vi@A41f1M411.437615tYlViktglitiglALJ ELV%11 PUVIllingvianu

,t11/21171Pu@kifi@tiTufievm-,51.174,,401,411_71Pu@cunnmktLalnnAn5n,n@nnrifnann

illvilzyrtn7tvggiTifi@ilannquiThm ..) (Lett MaitilumilunnAniIginslaluar,4ni)

(nnailpumi ttur:itvue)

91 -111A6IAMJ6YI UI.1

111::111111g11 4171"671@ 1 1 f141 41.1i111 fl M &cre)

elcU 1'011,1;1i 6611g1J 4171%s 171 1 al 1 al flUilfl (Wahl ..)

. . • • • •

(cingutt-mami lizmuirrdicirtiFtJuananvanCiiii @ iIiinfigiaiLicvslA dictlnyruncurimunilnqiihIni fniutruki'l)

C° : :

a

c- •

(IX

P

)p

E 0

".

a

" C

az:

g

vc „,,

c c

C--

a

a

tr. C-C

P g

IX

.7

UV,

a

dc° V

p

)aa olz aa

'7 )p

P

DA c°

tre X

c"'

97

a

c- cp

Ac

G 1

10

kg

lc'

Q

•

4-• a

a

Iv' Ire

aZP

V

S k

r"' C

c-

p

a 11,- v° c- t7

a

tIN

IS IX

vaa

1p

P

a

v. a

c

ormiltafiutnibu

-1414 (.-kt,rtrtu) tAtiEn,,b,i4LnitiAttselteroD.R.Lt:r.tnot4

lArrryrtn:46:115Efiviuularauitrin 1NM. to&cre

E

Q

IKor-• (try

aa

S

a) aZ?

V6

a, 1

c

kel - c

P

r- tr.

.e

a

IP •

lr, C

X

X

7

(X

VP

4C°

6

--@

■ •

cP° a

X C

P

-p

,:tp

r?

(G

P

a ('

S

c-- p

m

a

ay.

CG

a p

c- c

• 6-.•

cz G

-g

6

X

6

-C4 la

-4

-11 q

7 p

(-•°.

P

lip

J -

ac,

55

„....

P

S

m

G

G'

(0 G

c

X

- C°

IR

c-CP L- a

a

tr.

X .__.

P -

sip r

vi r

Ac

a

V.

s

X

tr. CP

-p

tr.

a

c- c c

g

.7

c- ,La

P

Im

a

C- tr.

Ir. X

a ir.

P

aa ire X

va

tr.

a

v. c- 9*

(IX

Via 44-• M

C

' A

s

r' -

r, m

c-

C

lm

A 4-• IP

r• C

a

VG tr. r-c

P

la

-1! 0

c c

tr.-. a

Vir: P

aa?

lE

c

a

Ir. (D

M

Iry c--

p

cco

p c

e -

c a

p

C'

"

c- m

Ire

.0

-IC

,„

v- s

WI .0

.- C-

alp

C- C

C-

.7

0

IP E

p

c-

.7

r'S

6

pr.

c_a 1.4

rc7.2 r,-

!S

c-

i3

e

'7 "

V.

-VP

g

e

, ,c

A

p

G

a ''

c

aa --1

C

(5 3a

aS ....

•. ....

P

-. ip

.7

alp

(-0

6

1 P

14

aa X

c-

g m

a;

c-- re

a-, q

S

1--°

.- iir• c

"

P IG

N C

c-

-. CP

tr• aa

..g

c-

a G

c

Ir•

-• ..•

x a

c-

2

g

Ir. P

lIG

g

c-

S

c- 1p

ac

a

c- P

°cP

grew

b

c.ttry,-),o) tatiEn,:rhyLnittAu„se,tetliiinp.ut,ItmAq+

•

• •

1.1A (- KIM) 6U1S11,D

14.1.41.111LIAtvtat.1.6r1IrlifiaLS2Skt„ .1,(..UnV5l6r11111(lat,t3SM. Ltarc

Knitrion.R.unALeNuR.unt

kiLunitricuLet6inc4dimIhrt‘prcprueukriaLs2ski, Lucre

„161g,(6n.cp,t‘tvulErtihourttrnWL1.11;111glAaLt,62U11t4uisrthwurvin

russtA.b.gu,3ertqLpstettiRuLtAs4L? (.0T Lttastriyqilipur„

rumnyvia!artt.LithRit.t.regn (.9G1 t4ltiSflitipLtlISCivtatItelln32.

ILL.V:LM.qt11 LS161,MBII.VBINSV..Ilirtl.C..(4q1U131R U 1,51A1,11

OWA)Cii '1414 14111E16.9pLIIILLNttaVatilIV.111LVASIA.

wup,cyollartearint..t.nacarlatenttegoiLnArtmi4rat6it..vtri:

Itre11112.1-53.SM,LSI4V1.1.LpillOS11.11,111LU2Stv=1ALI

r3LIVAU'Llqn.nt4nikruAn.rtut

„(9G1.14. tut wirisrlD4t4Lrusuttsc,

LL-U13,SltrIletIrIKLP.1,52LIvt (9 utast

pirtiettcp

LaurtinLNNILL.srtvLumsp.ncrnrtrytytgwitllneprttlet

nprpn.ycn.J./..4.1.0.1kto.Ls2sm. G1 LsKrt

wiarvisnit4tri.sql

ptvuttrnutArnitstkeeLwawnwtsisRDpurtmly.issuthuLw

nfbC•IALl4n1A.L.RULM,111:144 GP LsiGren.ycztipLu.

Lu,qeuelLsgsfwen,

touttLpe2.riuh ackt twinthingNwnsLunniLitnituuu.n.D

14yurtmliwutn.u.suteguelersiAutfisrt,Dvurtmininguth

uulettt4trisn.ht4L,RuLkultutismtltsuu :4 Lswt..rt

umtotiti

(--- '''i d

c

-"'

.e =

lic-4 r

,.-

4((

'd 5 ip_.

6

© p

CO e- fx

tc (Z- m

P

dc.

6.--'

P

0

11P \

(-

N.- ifs

-p

T

a©

G

-(X

"P

c'

. P

„

rd rc

..... =°.

r" Ir• c-

c- E

cm,TunemutILLNy.,,soutiZuge..rt2trucut

Lugg..ginutautervuttclitn*pawnsw

n,i.n•eryt4t6e.gnerrttfirttyyintin

(ittnn,n) utrisaitut,rutLet,tSpitlfiVALVASKOLS

•

•

clortLemuuLtAtttacpurtfrOugcrtnit.qvrittrtirun,tAnstu.cuggueutAtcruhe

n.snerrtmly.g.suv,1 wu1.srLiNwurtra11uLlql3tglii,gl.friBSItUallt n,E11,4t4

urtra11 ut.submwcefula14esiett4 uLuut44Lugst,u utia.rt„

rumItReFELLt.42,11itran t-W61 .w.m. tRtisf ibkrusLu4tse.

tofteurtp,L.mmkietil ut4Lrtrtircut,t4uTuRv.1 Ltitut

•

t41110.1),IttanntAtztitmrtfuRILLSgtaLletll

1-13 Lsblut GIT LstaLrtuvuain LstaLrt

ego ,c§1 14.14 14111ERDIVLTIISLNIztaphALLR•Lt2tM.

c71n141ur3stAtorLU,NL116@11litlpq6

Luartesm,e‘ii,14ciart,sni...auwmilnep tv.t.tontc,v144c3,sin,

Lauukt,ti4ncrusrwrtp.mwa!4nprira14i nertItcast,44ri,c,1 reap.

itiii.u,,qttprtLemktt L•trytwttcrtuacey.wtp.sw

ifiEni)

itwurultu411131.1S2Keuwevittatisnr),tputtrintissm.uLt6

ea,L•igt,,t,4B,V4.1..61111.M.A.4.LF1.1-pyirtn.n.,e..rn war q.un.

wruet.i.prilpurnuutNeg.Lagivqe,,stittAIRrionmanvi

Lugrtioimum, Ktutrthramotetrswitierz,Linftiplua -r, p

v,uht,ru" et-nitukki.yAnalitiLuguLl6cap3cest4etpuercump

evitTveptiAuLAILNIqfpuisn.D4wurtrinwLitfUgtil4gLtrA

BSIttl4lt1EflhUlltlf111111S21AbULleip.p (-e utast

VNI:LtSG141,140L1dr4

rtprtir_pualQ,n5lep. gmisuuqut.artp.n.linitttAipc

Lavtptrux,qreLtdutta.T.Lezumer (0 rtm Ltidurtut

LUNI.1.14011c@LMSLNA4.M.BUllgLIEI a Lswist

mratm4,1

1141A1 1:171151.7f1j E015511111.11AgrNSISI FI

3.1 10151 ' frIlZflifIkUilflfl itl?ilaV151t1111Mitlflgellitfl f1 141@ .1 U

filaqviulainifiurunaeuilnfiii4-rrill ifIVIVISOgiMf1011-11 1YI

111:11-ratit-v411iitiltilKu 41.12/1171fiuM11.1n vanui'i4lifIT.iittv rimi`iuii

111:11-enituliitifinKuirut-rilmgvri t.o19rriliziaiw.rminmat n1

DICINVALS2SkrtuttlAR,RuktAQULtett,Snilltii, t..sttut

(9WWCR, *W M. 14111SIVV1113StAttgLIAti3i1341fil.t2SM,

;

;

;

V1,1...4LtipqgLleiBli.131u.s,.44rtesujnoLtirtar,,N4e,slit

LAULM.M.,144LIAurltp nvnil.gLkie,sktwunngt,ttagui

e,slitnissuthuLk3KciaLl4r,stp rtitn,q.mweiy.wutnissikt3uLt4

GSItlilltglot6gLleiCaNLV44GWALAULM*1.4411133U1113LITIZU

ell.Lietninvtukowira2Nrtc,144r,t2NLuquLt,6 nciacut

esint6rtia,1/414.fTeltuartiyuqussutemwesannsutaw

ceit,c,v144epxsuLm.,4444.4,tiLupquihuut nutirtUuelt.

Lart*2Lm.mLubutatiher-Lmtdivni, wan

Lu,qgt,wnt,sp..sp.erzanirtLyea.rtutp.lnci,,v1G-p umut

rtu.c.,u,NuAcemams..,:muustAttsLunNtaagbi Lu,q

,yntut..1 t,u,qn,km,s1.4LLUL`BS1441,1115,1)14...iSLU ®P Lnautreud

Lsitut

orat4141

d

14-0. (-Firm) wulEn.p,ituLr.littAtne,,,A4f41-13,nat,tramcLF

setrasunn.

sLuceiusrmn,,,..mertianga 01=001 ut.u.n,h4,14t,rust-Nv.,a,liMpu.s.,:ut

&rail en

411@klaliIttlaUf111971@llf141

illiNIZT16611417115■1@rlItInfileaTJIA (Q1.711ill ..)

11.fl. .... (1,661,11617imilaiviAjfivineriniIqvi5lcilikat'dni)

(nturiproil vtlil(liaia)

0. ionidualfiLiazillivanuvalnilk

urilnAl.dilinonnulPoltiefiTi5n.nmgejvilnfi

te).1A5A151,11*-IniIN

STIfil-rola0)555L

en. wra.14-IvtifAiiallilf111r1@

vtiol@nnlAiiinllurilttliiutlI11.15tmavanoltfm5t-ulfrrumAilioniln.iw

61#61.1?,,ifil*n@r,A'a,Alum..itipm@lnFila&nri@uLfioliaifiLih?„innliNn5arruoliana& -i

viilAiiiiiLviqNaawnTitioi@lilnn7vtuvrawinfivulfrwruolfsilanl 6o15n1un17qv1s5n.1

fwiejviliwingiuntiticy011kimylLilaviEgvisInILLatcnnwriLvalultilwIltomuLLyil

QITIJ 67;111.ia@mflA'NeiVIAA'finwiliurilnlviaj mrnufilvtliVillviAini,ntotin15TvisIn1

LoqmlwliquilnKilifilm.11.10@flflAi@ll,titiItlYULMEnf0111.1 O CT

o „ e. f11111 6V14Sotrualtv4 ne,

1,15.1

cr. illIZTI@WIAMZATM41Jfil V

11151151117E511JITQIFIC111:11411152661,f1Q;f17111

Alllai011 i 6t1@li b. S

Friaq6i5554ifiCritrrialaullfwinLiltinn5lguilLii@nginnuilNal71Puliiv

er11111 -1U4V0055531

Unili-m-uiLaznim-nan IviEw(11.1

n156-rinum71101555ilivtl66r11Jut -rmi(17€wnni57(y165' cjnoiol 66atvi.151134

*I-117.1nr-Tv7nu66aernm5Fr1a01551aJ G) n5t-vini19&&.

-

gitil@6[1.111110111a1111140

1 2/11ht5111Mlan12161U1@@@ni@f111/1U0

eo. nilitrill@lICUlfiT13JA0169111.1

mtut,n5un-milinIfiwgFisL1A'oltenvi,unnuLeilv,fildill.m.onnu'ilA" -au

1.8-iAlTmulmAlejuilnnac

- m -

doslAfatct

171.19,21f1dTafilitlfg1=11111f111f1t11411

thatallillINIZ11/117f1261:6Firii@llil.11611 41131.11f1 (alUcti ..) INA ....

(11Klet161Nan(18n4ninnain1Iqmsli1i66azhin1)

iiiiniatiBnilmuzisaruollaw171S@ o&oGn/bbc9)

e 111151911 lu&& 6W-117filltififuEn5nin17ntiqn1

b LIM .M.119&& @1.417hIA'nn'15i111 ,15n1/1174,1,01 .671W15t1.116W1J1Iflfl (a.hfrij ..)

(arilTALL5iliv4m.ntuvinlqvlswitardni)

Raltn7nifinntiqiviv15'dviAlwIw71

g-rt7rammfutmunl5ntiqnnU

Lau@lim1.1r,rma.m15frm5gu - d5u1JIllhtlinvansTgAwl5allRylLariliAN -n. ti,r)

IouilqumwiTt7n11.1,1FriaNF157u LLatairroulER -ra.1 t,tuesjilu,11-ivar,C&Jo

Fitutrmlin-inqw:dnlvtlialgrawitraninthenmAllmn -iviTfv,t-Pil

ill1/15t51 6A4,011B1 17N1Ifl.11411 qUilf1M (WI:1LS; ..) (6611.6L161NLIAL

146'nu-quim-iqviswILLmln-1).nlgliTrwrumaE):6'5151.1ilal5r,g -wity,LtunmuitTLCIIJOiL

yntynriffv,t-PiT8M -min4quilnfi vi.m.19&&0)

6-).G) finnoiliA'TiAliAnnwlvii@FI -41Tomilaqvis5alarAufmquilnfiviluila

qvisn,4nimusrunmkrullnfittufiqo Li6liaav)fihltiunmvilviiTulJ111J5r,L -Jaivanu

(1161,60LLhanam 'mfiool)

g LID filwaNin-qn-14'lillnnyivl@4wilTavriaqvinaluesiufmA'qu'illm

VimaqvInalniflusrunOlivlInfiliinnii -ilkiielgumifIroiwInFria& -wriLum7Q,01

661851J5aianarvanEr781Nwmulfi'm661i5 LiTi@lia@RA@lfitin -i5u,tilstRAruct_JITU5nnanonnu

"-ATAI-m1.4-w-raAvoili,LatnvanEri-IP -AmiT6419,maqvisw.141iTt7t-igivrt4 (LailTALLFIll

InviTI&G))

GLG11 EilLSIIM -13.11143J1M1 ctI &Gn Lvvilmr,yrrilqicRT5i115n.1141

1^191. ID&&G)

/Thall,f19111,MA11116111.1/101141.11Ellitill r; Enfl

meev17-Nn1A'iii@i5n.ni,LA'-arimioln.A1 nmailliti5v1111nTtalu

17iLilEntiinlarun15qms7n.lioqn-clud-nm14166-117tufafillIont -i- viuolinqvindifi-rrAirnmll

LLatfiqi'llualiTt:Itufamwalamtlymattgi3mqvinalflUT4,fiLianolimiaquqvintilUi

e -

LiAl@lAvutinqmnfaLat&nnoRAlfilivIn'tJuLnywil *11,01.16o@tif-iunmLfilvt_li'vtllnutalE

fialswitwutnnwiincLa4nicai -n.m@l6ii-riTtliciLmw oraifig-nInl-rufilaOinnuiti@

im.bn

Cii@li,lf1 -15131/1 -M"K115

601111'1611,1,atlATarinfilA1F11,1111Aill3111501/11f111^11, 1, atti5tSVIENa T@Iig11:InlnifilaNF15711.1

lii!wrannviantaldivn - Lilu

ni5N A'-iviumultithanfulliNluwInn-n-di'lrdlln,onnualtnfiu5vuunn5qvInniLLat&In

lud-rivo@l4ii-rt.Ttgovtoiln -n

1-1555116ilowila6iitiSl 11J665n vi-InlajolENTI@T@Iiklmitivuesrufri5q17611 -ruataNtimilAN1u

19&& vii@LauoToiiwutJulnwIltA -Isi.J7E41T.1

1111J5t1.11f1.4 1N.Pi. ls&&d V11.1flT11.14-166.ILLatoiantoloi0,11

taxi OlungniutiaznInnunilq`iislu mutintrifiliammoin4-1

Olon,flvianuatnuIrrun -15N6inu flaainvwrnagmuviwiliAlTm.nuA''a

nvli-IELFitntivr.,vuqvinnILLa°4 -111aiTtr-mlaii-nit-v,fartgoOdlfailaqvisw.‘i

mAii-n7f11,ii6911.4 Lot1,1416-rimfi@-17nnfornw -161

Talmaqvint-1.16166-174),fiLmAtufiq) liumuuhlEiniu,filmviiaa'arthe,ananonnun'civn . an

A-ranvoil (QTToui'A ..)

11. thignIAIR fivnntruoldit1-14-rungutmaJn-nnip44 6

fl tut n7ninl5fkl5f1.111Ji"trdIllitanaripL -181 .8iAlw15n.ilm .r LLvtAil

(LuilmiAllaavA'runalvi

n'iqviswILLaqn-1)1J5tnnfitim-mvilroiNvril -m-rufiLFIEraiolLLA

CriEnfi‘unn@tm,-willqn-umAntNprrtionvuno YI51J AVViga@ofiklfiunlILLfilArtiiVIJI1

IhnnanvInEyT8flanm7yaiwoil6otn.panu'ilPmn6 mfilaqviswlm;iin1I1;u1N6Plb ,

(5-mn917-1& (un6Smilm5-1&4)

1.211@lild lgin1561,filTLIILLFIldial411,1,MMIMMAI.RiTUTNI_TVIlfIVIAflf1151 ,6at

1,11NaT@1111"15E51T174,4ill LLazAlme,Trninjt-tiall LLatLtJullivrai

arunn,NnvInn@lg-t:i L filnri

g1111111`01altfmaJnincp_4111

riquitru ID&&

irt

O

NivinnyaiLhfli'outoleivilnmItdimil@kivauLw -runuii,Ac

lunn5/i-auLviS@Cruilnm@Einl@Wnnimumaow'-1?pil,Al271n -iIm -ivinl -rol7t-gi;i76171Tncun

mges,i1J3Inm lv&&G) 6t16-11,11401/1A'flffifl.1 6111,11f11111@l5f1.116161,01f1911111Alflf15ttnU

Itil@l5CLOT1,15`UP1g1,61Aillrl'AIJ 10Elflflb11,10,11AiLgElliT'UfillJltallLi 171111 Liliom-agit

TwL1-J od111,1timu walu

liimAinLnnerini $`1111u

vionn51.71Pulin.flvansOilnd-n annlaiLati@n@r,LtultatifirivriAmfuml

mn21'15tlilprma.11antAvah621tau,1J -Am6rio -n-iunn51:Ju4kilisnv3n8 totAtihn

6211Jounl611nAvIcitinwinantnvilo21'1a115t11)5tildisli f11J21>1 -runn5€MNI7u1A 1661,1 LanAm

nvantril-rualol (Positive law) V111.1MY13-1AMTE1 Thomas Hobbes, 6614'AM6215iltaJ

(Liberalism) ommnlihrii@l John Locke, winAvi@IIiiiktioVii (Utility) orlifrilliFWIT@1

Jeremy Bentham LLatuAnAom-ymElF15551.1 (Justice) 41 -11.1K7l1JAMIl@l John Rawls

1,1151L'ara441ndn-Avaolliohnilm-yardvu5551., (Justification)lun15171Pul,41

66ar,v-Atunn77iliolurilLanvilln171710%1,41nou1u011n -nA1-n1 n-15171Kulif

nvia.no@tvtit41,1ilarilmv1111fl varamtwinlqaunlviltAmantwillejuilimiLar,c:;thr,nuu

s.ri@livfialliolullocn13/111t1,11-1V1L-1810k/1@lf111171PUlifIVAVIEJelgO fill?i-11PITILIA1,15111.1

Lor,muallgrtai.An.i

A'nttnni-witralnirtaiu4trilim

mtl-nstimPiTiffmlfunmquilfIR vN.Pi. tv&&o) ilv6mnfuvicig-witpatoinoilkd

@lfrviA'n6nf1JvimAlumi4viAlivnarU5nraanvInEJ751NNnIfu -wallnailoivialmi5tn15

• 1..nultuum oilueiiiivrinv-matIniLLen.inmqvilnm LitilmkoN

Fmtrri http://www.supremecourt.or.th auk Lii@itril msn rnrig-in ID&&d.

• It150%1 gloBlriEritlm-inia.im@qjuitrim

tDT) fiarkiWi Ci, VIt11 G)0.

15 1.1JwiT, 5.11dPl Lrimfivint4. ncvianuT8iNTItu -ifli(itiiinm

19&&G)) 14171 o)c)&.

• fll -lf-T1-171 rriwZruv-i5z11)iirjvitirwituul,wriimAtivrifritifivi@quitrim

bilok1911.1 Pir1UDlE1. ?T-ioStrioncvianuflyali"tiilo

11INSVIAVVI (f1110/11^I1JVITUMS: b&e) fianAlfifmli vi171 m0).

- b -

ih@d111,111d

anvm o

alaaiii@Gt@eshErril A'ElTUrig19°A@liis@TLY1KuMAkai

lunIciAvvitigigliitailqVill101.71PU11,11?TiM117iv7141112.iwi -mqvilnfiritiqtht

s5Nw,4'@114-191-all,LtruainlInEillwill tildIA'fvg-wilnd-r -g741,Afv1-Ntpi@lora.mtutIti

Loilinnesjuiltml,A1-nliN4Tvioinumilunld -auLLA 61,1;fqvitndii -runvilui.i1PulAW:thtfIWU

5,V19'mviliityg -ilivt.hittivriLtvutifi' n.pasnufi-ivitivroloinuviiltunnwaviortilA1

lun150invtiwiivraymmidliot'mmaN

"i671915nnn'anLivoiariliVAALriqtrilnmitinnAolfi l efliitim Lotn-nikivLItilfiCcinmviio

nauqVi@

Invilq eta lunnvilquvidel nwI5ri@klnItv°1-1

PasmnilVimIMJA'11711tillY1V15111-111'11fil5P1171614L'ILTILITIEJ145VU117FINc166-15571J

ece

quilswrimi@,1216-11,1-1Vh141,11/11,1qUilnm lionteryamrloviNmotila.ilitaultv6-110uvunn

eInolmehtmijaku@ni,SnmIL97-1

9nt151 coti tinn-ilnuvhfitritioli'olaiowinnnIfiq'thrinuusINnuvinImuLvorun

LmnYiEruejllitnmImullivihmu 1i5@911,ViAlu5tnmi415to1'-nm6h11flu

@d115-1uLLI1 lihinviivioflymiLSEivrisifivzitImviquilnm mion5n4-Inn16'uviunq7ehliu

vi@mui'veiotoulu- lrutegioliimmios,V196udn vittAli-a-Nlvtim.lwrivu Lilossina

olunwrn vildiouA'nilltilmOng7n191-11 olu franOlumn4iiinfllAiticalJuluttl

ii(1117:in@v55il91,Alu cat nutvronmTtroolVunaupf19 fr5VI(f1Junou55f1 lkull6vi1

m-yan,Sovinultrioiiu

n11,141 6/1111,SEJVMES11,1,1,1v@i1171 Filari'llillA

lajlrilli-11611.11Y1V1lifilailg11119fiTIAWICAEMEll'ill @f1 -15a11111.11A4.11111.11,1'11,ViTtl@li -diUMEJ

1119111 Qr6) mi@maqvinfiln-Imaunmquitnm

f.14-41Annyiviio4-411,1,6% tim-aiLon4u4-15@loi@mannA@Tel,iiNgInnoINT:filqnn

1,1Atyviliovh@51VolififivItni5vuE1l1dt*116Pl1de1moutrro 1,110,v0twirlii@1onno

nqueturT-ivitolvii.14oulIvuoi/tifilildnig-Avrinvivilo4 -4n@lizmaqvinnlumunaiez tiiinm

viiamqvinfilrInflueutimMqVilnm

tivilk1011/Tli-111-17151$1"Indn'A-4119r,i1AinfutfiLLoinfoill11J9 -inngtinnEntiltitaki,

1,1A9N171.i IMEJLMAIltlIgi -dutoln -1714J'qairr,N1,tin -ili'uillmEnumkiNnu @np,RTI1J

1 -1LFIE111118 ar,f117q1/55t-tImatris'An1

f1V1.1101,Vilf.itcilfli.T1PulAtJ61,1,111- ?11/11161.0 $'h@EJI 111,1i1i 241VIII:11.11/111f11#11111,111111tallillE114

5t111.15i101 1,t1,15751AE@V:1,5 f1151,@5@lifil E.MilMlaiEIVI -101,02,1f1111JUll'Aflf1 -111A1W1

3J51h61Juainal qaixii:NItinnwhyruoinCA'svnEwilonllallvill@zdJuoittim LLatml4n -m141 qafii,NltinlIm4Q,1m1,1Mnlain115 Ciietmtht@lvill LvidlililuIlifoptifiimiwuu,

teinafiLFIErrtraommArir,%ifrra.,1,wlid@L@triTtinavinfro@lffluvilairvrillunlwilviltimg

14@dnlc,inkl

winAwnilnginnEntlifmilcui utriAvinvanereiniiilal (Positive law) 9111011101f1/104 Thomas Hobbes

Thomas Hobbes vtitii:inhern6lnt-ruiliAzi:Aulod111.1 -in louiAlmoylwfilt

6)&gri €ldtJ h1.Pi. G)b& ifivunmaiiilLitrahe{1JVmitinTans17-ru6i'm (positive law)

6`11161 @n VillnUalEJA'nwt-L1611145i14,4,716111716ttifIV111.11U1AUldTLJEnilitilii@Evi 61,16t1.1

il1Tl1b?1566112hflgil3nFJ5553M1F1 (Natural law) ilikTILL'il@ill @fitiLl6loilh V111.1M12.1Fwl

11@1 Thomas Hobbes ITV Lui411.11 (Will) vii@g'itm (Power) 7611111?{1n

A'@lumii'vqtafii7r-minTunEalndn'

V!,13i.'w1T1141JR7Minilli,tUf11541@ULIN111

nFinim 61761@liLrion71ng151J65stiouLLati,tunlilhailmL vtaiNiA•i-ingvannolilf„

ik-Illda15551g§111MV14 e 1141

nnlii'liulingniumimaraFimdtilvzvtatiV111JalEJA'flwdgf1141f11 1J51q

fid@IAL'A'Nh'illrillPU1111,1J7111.11A01141714/1@lf),2141.118 611011,11.11061

L@O11.1151.1t11/1@lipil@qillf1V111U1:11.121 LLatolw,jnoll

LvigNa (Reason) orL1711 1,RE16t11,11.11fiVLIVII:190AnLiA'-J' "mvu1nalt@lngtan8"

@IVA "1,@411.1151flit@lf1V1.11E1"11111 -1ElEill@n171.1f1.11.1@1

0--ilfvano "6@41ti1nal/1@lf1W19.110" 171,11,11.11EltilM11.11I1Jfilt@l1JSZAJTULI

11,41M1.1' @d111,1f1F) ililv@tiqilLf1911f1T12.1V11.1 -1Eril@lA'Til

11_11V11, MUM 11161E1. fr11111VIIHVOLii@l$11,4 g117411J'AVVII, (f141,11111111,111011: Iv&&) if11.1141f1f11 a,

Gee.

'Thomas Hobbes EJOLTLY -1

(LoiK thr,Rtfftcon-iltilN 1,111711 IMIlf1154f1.1.11411.11,11 (f116111"111141W11: tv&&o)1,11.71

b All law is originally formed by internal, silently operating powers, not by the arbitrary will of

a lawgiver ...law comes from the people, not from the State. See L.B. Curzon. Savigny. the Volksceist

and historical jurisprudence Student Law Review. 23(1998) p.54.

lc. wtriiivit,Atin (Liberalism) 0113017111A01110A John Locke

John Locke fivth.rtInAvierrglnt -Mnffuvicil M.P1. G)bcrib ti1d11 M.P1. G)Grk)

an-runnIn.16n4Iniltartm John LockelkAuuLaJalltl@lnErm Thomas

Hobbes A11171.1 R'ngimiN John Locke 6,u65@46LIN2{nAr115tdr1m1 (Social contract)

*16691noin11,11 bin John Locke lailki@l-i-MvAntmau,swI101vitsoiln -nArtrilvagrnlviti

Lut usiFivitAilvAliudiluerlml@kiriAL@nywla iipt@@nrvanuI,o fi'ai;mnIntru

9i@Svibsoiln-rvvtivilupteuolLn/n41.1.ilk

(Reason) grwi@lli t1ll'ium-rn F1t1l@lLwi'1141

FITILIAM1 John Locke 9t61:111„alnii @l57134 661F1LLatill,51111.11.1@lNIMIlefla IMElh

i'1E 121.m;coiallifnia.1011JM5@lalln14111ifralrualyinallu

lemaA'Th61.1211.71.1 1,1,i1.11M111F1Ml@l John Locke wilimnigiKtiitiLiNS`viBviifinvitLat

vii$,EISu.n1NIAnywia "Lvwlwa" nlInuvl-will "41o'IN

@%i l'1 Li,ar,liim'nFruuoiltiiinlInInirin116uLtunl5a2.1Lilm "Lvicra"

otuyiartp4kr.,klivmAilwinmiLatlajfinxiguluSvri6nutiwEIFru'L'

vi-IriA'Nnwl-wnliarahoiiilm (Liberalism) viumn3JA0621 John Locke nn7'ilwram

1.71Kuleis'n.onrintioinvinAciAnniitraFwInvanutiTuolol (Positive law) wilitn -mnKiftif

nvivitorLfi'ingiorti@l John Locke Wi'liM'Illiglkpi@mgcavinn -i -mminult@lis

loutlw-nitgiotvu-avilliitlutntwi-rulvtfa1,1A'IRLIEJ@:Ji'uLLaz,Lalioi.tufi9r,q.11 LonAwillai

1J7t'algfiviaiilsLii-anrilvroino,nmilueTlnirrum -a -aAnviku annttionylmolidlnitim

lihstiaivroloomhlriun5751pin61vi5oivwlea@ ui66A''a liiinithAol@@nnavanumrilvium

Witlut-nrilhAmm.tiTiion2Afl rilwi'-ialunglIfl TevrinlvmAtAlmaAlmurhillJahwii

"Lvw1N"

61.46thAtioL5u11.4mannn71

m. LicinAmollntlItitiatni (Utility) miamliaiortml Jeremy Bentham

Jeremy Bentham 611trd-ra6lncurtiviu Lrwatit, mm, fi@--iLtt.rtInFlocii.uvitrro

@d-vgrwuviiillmul,Q1AlltILITAOMM_JUIEMI (Utility) jinthlmlinnraidulEA -iviu

14mm/will 1 nwl-wifomutrahmIntlulEnrtIonwrrmA Q1 621 Jeremy Bentham Al

artinqtgnmi?uivinvu (The greatest happiness for the greatest numbers) attnslum-ana-niolAJ

IliSOTJ MART 6G1,11E1. 61161P)141:11 mm& LOU Gimb.

4 1,1JIM%1 661711116 1.110q11. (nilvonvi-ron:

b&&G))

111ww,i, 6rim i'ffrom. JEREMYJKIE:18M m& Gn tv&mm. vr1:1-1bo 111 GG).

litr)SCH1 mm.ifilvig@fiumThiAti -fit (Pleasure and pain) thrintIat1N11ie1@66at

nn5allmIll1dLiililm1111J (Deterrence) Litiolli 6iiiln9InulilATThelglAfil.i

viAmtraLmezrunuvilleAlfn7v0rinn7 66@ior, 6nEritirdiaormitiAilm061,@tilq)

vinavinAmOilnd -n ilvi@uu@@nnTunsvitio4nrimoln -rtmAvAnteimai,ii

mluLvinf/Aut152.-Asttiviailnilmuyni iilv-,61,mn1-m-inwu-ah62{51Juu (Liberalism)

vrawraio 6n1 John Locke 61/171:,1112.1frd -11.1AMJN Jeremy Bentham 1.7ti Ltunnu@l

tiltlEnnitwpru@liflmL °tut

M-13.WIT12A-1 621 John Locke 1:iti illvAntioviinTordol@Rfrimaliewiail@m5filtvin eivi I 1.1`u

iivivi@n57724-Ckfi@Lvw,i,w

6ii@661rahmIntlulottlomm-yagio.n1 Jeremy Bentham 0,01.117iNatJulu6n16‘u

n-nilmTari.T1Pulif

fL2varmn-inloiLvu'aFiml@tfi@n7tullhtitndruolthz,Intlid'rulv4vtluerik teifiaulld'ati

1,1dmJiloim@l.fi'uonnrifiol@cp4-ifianit'Lainnvro@onivigioliolotluluvtki,11m1AAma. ,

nn71.71FitClinvantAlvikufmannvilmrdnittrinIcifyn@tliTtifiTaiia.,m@l7r,vvillyma

ai -111,5f91 1114 -)AmilcvinLNA''Thfl'Ylantln1 - 1@f,1f111 -1111,41@tarltnaultln - nLwronni

61.114-11A1,1,1•I'Aluar,m5kFilawill cp:ovanultliklultruillmalifTnillgannt

vii@Vis nt s753.ifi.4mu 1 rmaltvibluviillialthill (Deterrence) & U1%111.111101

min@niiiihrimhzitarnittlgmLLf4If11.1 "1114-1/11,1"1,1,117111

@'1@ fylnkT15J'ilVILlEfill V111,66 "1JIVOT/J11?1/21,16111101,1i11H1.1" all1L1,1;11@il 611411,1;litplfia

CA@tVITtrthr,luttInAivnanEntuLfloltmiatiluldwvitilltAm., Loz,iilfiquL6% LLtraFio

@77nthr,Imrtinhva,m61,6iYhAnuiitiliTimauralmneathrAndal -nativikuvqn

e. winiimniqiialla., (Justice) 41laJf11111A011101 John Rawls

John Rawls 61J1d1ln8mr1'a@LL361.4 6rio6sie6 ft 1. meiD0) n-y)f-Ttril John Rawls

Lti,,IVnizitamTiliFwiCil miti5512J (Morality) 64661J1E0rillJE)F155711 (Justice as fairness)°

John Rawls uaL5ult65N6a111111 1,601LOU'ill,L'U')F1MaillIFJ1J (Liberalism) @LichlA'ii*Nril

KilLLvill,17181161.1 (Equality) A'-as

.1J5:1-:?11JM5fll flT11.15,frilgranIfl 6-41n -1u 4'16'111%6 mio

6-412JRtilfun

lAiLl@EJ 1 ImslaY-i1dltilm-ra.nvin611nlif1ticALi05l666% mllajoiolol'hwErin Lilavdilutniitfuriu

Im5r,i,t1141,A1Tm17,,,Ast thnnn-infiu Lor/coqoilsihrwlilui,tailfiL

`)"'LLtrifimial John Rawls walryallii,eitivarIfmtviatviliit°1@8

A-Tuvi rob nnuil 1@ali gm.:InfaroiNwialnIdaneaviulAu (nvairmivriuml:

9atiLli111M1161.14fi -I11.16tJUVi161,AIWY1flIJElE111,3.1@`MI-11100,411f1rAlEJIM1A1J 5 tIFJ 1J 11@it,i181

.1 .181,gEn

A'11 1̀:111 11151710i1J 11,ifflpl.1 -1801 -11.161,InFwIGA9'11t1I -W1MAVh6171Ellifill (Equality)

1,0,A1121EilNali5e,lurilloilut@lL6Unh@t-l115r,tuttl (Utility) vriwyruAm

/181 Jeremy Bentham Lii i mtinlais')

LoiralulainfinnitinviTiolmni6n1Pouionnwiliqoli.AmJ — od111,Irl

Inimbma@o--1 mionnIn5t9-itnJltim1iti66r1n -Ani,11d,wa4

ainloantartMtnw,ilinodn11,5 Lot9nrwrianth.1515LVilvil@llimIv

oTtkartlaauputir,

111L1-1114,16:1IIIBL AT1W,MIA' CluillIfl lvd'Ao-) 1°.if1J0-4141,11aA:a.JmIE1=11

?ii-wrYILL`th.15571.11,iwiquilnmItiA'IMIJ rvanufAlm-)T7i

n-176-Alive-AvivillnvInultviane.m.ilun15171kAin,onnmio2-Atviiv7m. ,

AdivatualiTtaunwil'Ilkilinginno

n-Ii-AlLo.nA'nflAnnbAnnfil,$11 1,fiublitarifi@uLLA''atig Lar -Amqvunu

luviqlthtvvififig tiouLt ain11,56111 Slvi11 Lvid-1:1611-nawurtfruinwn1LanAm

eiTilliV,11-nA011 -111V11.1181711111,?111@lrliitIA1Tuillotrdlt, m4

LilaluluttlqvuNA-4n.1 61,11 -A11111110,11.1 -181J'111,611 -A017118'1@@tl1111J -1M

cuonTirril @n9ilt-mlim-narviiminqlthr,qnvilimnAmvillnynnuAilnd -n

nollAnnth 115:1,-Tn7gqic

Sioituvduil n-ilfaiItinfivzITIKulinvanuOilndn -amuLankvvilnvianulm

1:111 dalAto'f@ln7r,vin$C-aum-r1.15taTo5a,-71 Lorin1514u,vah -rvnlnvanuloviloInOiculif

nvil.inu9ticsiColvtlulliii1Q1711liti@MT-11.11,th.Mt11111A1 i:16 .81..1111.1LLA -

lun-n-inPulinviansA'ln131qmiluiLAj'aoi@l1,11`61 2.11 -Tvicili5t, m4?enKtvt@lnvianti

n151,im'IlLi1JF17@llatOillIfi'112,J1§U5151.1

611;f1,6fiquilff115V9thl@thJ1.11,11 -11.11101frlIMcllq08,11TIASILVILITh111.11tWi'llquilffliat

CJIJ5tfl@t1157191i1121

All social primary goods - liberty and opportunity, income and wealth, and the bases of

self-respect - are to be distributed equally unless an unequal distribution of any or all of these goods

is to the advantage of the least favored. See John Rawls. A Theory of Justice. Oxford University Press.

(Oxford: 1973) p.303.

6'1') 6rn 4 5 11 f-1 i. F17 -3.1A1ANM -113J614 -11,171FJ1161,111.171q1411frilliqt715551111F1 1@l4 11

I@ait IviuTraNuircilLviAnp5.1.fit-mi6ntlwrwitfilLvniin.141m NIArialnuU

1.1111111181A 1.9Mnsn. 11117-1md.

— G)e) —

(fiquilnA)*

aimlnftonnuLT.Jolonwi

l*Lhr,naus5TiwithlqtriltlfiWi -ao '4114-161A51.11M91 611.11,§LIMITtlf11501.11,LanV410111i1A-1401:114

f:Ifl J SJ' fuTut t 1'1015015;1M 1,1,at'AV,VIA'1 6161.19k1401@firlalaj6 )11,11,01allItiVIA'1W1f1

fimaistuositifl4l9N9N'1n -rvii@fi -41L6A-a v 4

411711^11f11411111@4'1A'1 621411a41.1P1161J61411aq1151f111,1,NUfW1KAIWIVII@Pilaq 1/5 5 t11111 NINtalfl

q1.13111MillaUf1-11111.1014111510.i 1lTU669111.117111A -11141171111f11.111/50f411:711 ;a16thillAlNY■17 ,1171661:1QQ71

1.5171T1IfInflqUil,flfi tu&&o) 1.11V11-1 fIlIqV1511114 -11,711^11f111 -1111104 -41

11@lfl'IALIAjtill-lOWIJ31114iqVISStintglillaV151t111, 1, N1,1fWali 1JilfThVil@Maq 1157 f11111 f1

LLN1.111nAilfilflff1101.1.1611,11,01VithalgiSA.11,6Villiiild11441f111111111141@f1 -4111111

LLN`LifIKAI MIWIllii@filOVInnInlmumunfilquilnml,giA'Avrinvivilo4-411,t,A-)fl ,flVIN 1 8 14.44,11

lialLtufilo.1%,'"AtulAJrnammtek,t-ii,:"5151171T17f1.11fIqUilM Iv&&o.)1,1101I1 ')71fTiN

LLar,Lil@mAitrilnA(1W-unlAllanInEi400liTumnaLLA')

finu?i-aufiLFIEntilykiwrifovich6'lm -nciu,gFi@VirnaqvinniuNunfliquitrimormagv157n1

filfILLN'unmA"quilnm uar,11.ifynciv21,14m-m4n-11,1,n -v,mli@LA3AtajFilan -lb'n

frliivultyeityPiTiiNnuomquilfw) vi.rai.19&&G) 111V11-1 &o) `4011iflifil fallaq1/15111‘4

114,111flalq1.11111f1111@filaqV155111111MLI,Nldflalkilyi1114411711^11f11.411,11@filA11 1,6A') fif1T1110 -Nill.1

glij@lkfirla411 -10■14 011@l1,17RM1,11VIdt11141 1,114fralAQVIThlkill,LIflnl illitlYillE117111711A1111

11.168'14f1 -11,r110@l6ailitrlY1 14101,1Afpili@f1V14111E1,111EatifilWIAVIcilLhUITULL01514171131%1U

41171W1f1141V1i0 49ezi'1/1@lFilaq1155fIlll,NtlflflqUilDMVii@Frlaq1157fIlfrlf11 ,6Nlif141q13111 M

14-1112411ililfritatIM-1111,SFJWIEWIE`Unn,fitnoninultiutainan6i.mol ,b 1,11M1f11,11)frifirL

mamnfiugi.14-15@o-i@Fil4n -ufi@telifi@n7tun toqt>a,1141lqn-1,1AQvilio1h05l (18'1 11V11

mAdes:rui'InfiC4Fria4nnilvihATI.ratiann tht flMJ61#111111Y111104fIli1491.171.14960 1 101111,9611

A'114j 171fIla8fT1

*nip%vi 'alnqq1,1t111411.11ortuvanuiFiEr -niuniAavaie,Tuitnfi," Imuiciwug

1.11111LIfIder01 1.11/1111101A15N17f1S1V16, 19&&, M111 — esn.

el,fuil.nnii1,Aium7-1401uvils@lnPlr,nousIN Lwilallnurn5toliCilEnslintatioan&m.im'n

flAom-anaJd-iihliuml tilltrilriORM,117Lf116H1f1,T ,11.11E1Q1Tul:T@@flanCii@i1Jfll@l4ViI1W1

01.41,1,91A1 Vi A'1@ f11711 fM411i1j1.1i14-ifiwinwiLLA'-) n151,11,1SIIBT:Famlunn7'& -Pcii@i1J1$11%

vihvti@lvi911,tin-15thtllai vilE1,1,1Liwilmnwinfritilm.491,1i@l@t71A'vm'gorai4nfronm.41 .3n1

Fiw&IPLI1A" LtuLviv,i,viiilTalm-audni11 61,11n1loinalwii

41@nful `412Ji1@41fioSv16l11n15qvintilvliqn -moltim -anonlicithlndtuiJuanavalu

nji1V17f1.1"WITILL61^ilLartiuLW%VilllEJlt AV151-1.1 -WIT1101W1 f117414FiVlBT:M711111.1f1lIqVISIt11

qtfilrim tim-mm-nklinatqfyrkt -uviniall@iluati@nonnuoioll,ffl'kolv,OwnnoLor,

alInt,LtwAlci@th\q-aillinn5touLiliTu Lfiwitingiu-)EnmniLSEnirmliari

?I'lL15i11711 V4nnlA vilmnqi@ln1,iLtullionLviAnnlwil -a@nafill@n15v1111u6dol

14A'nfmA'lnd-1-1171-,vvulTfv,ELliiltiNlIarimcijuilnm ID&&o-) ri-rvitalijm-yagrian7o

cl"@tqvisuilitaaqni$i 41l572J66A'7N1 iquilfwvfiwilury1Jmo Gn &ma villim;ieljviInm61411

n-iliquilflm@t1,Altin95tolilLEIEnEn $iollinanyrtAlaiLtatiornivurunILnit@ln,vnlE,

f ndllh

Finaqvisln.ILLeninKquilnmvii@filaqvislalnm- aromAquillim

6hohVill,lim-nfiv21,1.161m4rn,Lat@aNnikwiavaeltiNyrrhnonnuwiTtli.1 66cfl ~1~ i 111

iongvanuA"\in-rar,pi@uthAt-liyinil@nvantifig*,1

IJItoilm'AlflitliltuthtoivivicilfilAri - vrtaviA'nn171iamBigijmufi@tqms7filuar, &9

4-iivinfrtl-viiO44n@madlliAlifwa?111A Loingia1u@toticpcf1litim-mqvs7n144m1

illa6il'uPta (Referee) 11J tilFrmql (High Court) lkoiLmArAforiionvarmaimCiumil@

6171,1FM1,1(ill% IfilifIl al,M1011f1T1I -WILLMatiPYilflYlliTtflOUN.0

oi@lnlIfi@tiili'olimquiInfiLM@nloltntozinan6111 -Joi,1•)

LV1F11,0@5371.1f115TV1SIV1141fIVITTITIVil@fil?tItOlPilad'll 10EJVIA'flUP)Velttl

v fmqvisIdatt,t1unlli'a6F.J.11@vh@ilbInmi'lvill6dalawoilvi4@lit -m4-wilum`OiviPul,11

adlmoLI-a atli-tniqinlomqvia.iluH L14.1.14@r,&111kQvg-e,ru,k4,141:6@nvanoLvinilvu

Ten5vvi'llAioioSia61hAlAlmniLluardolnn4n1 ndTah 4-11.1-rwit,tva6viion151gumwm

lqfm-niltltilcanuvrtnolAlfvilnwril'uqvIntlAil9iagitit'm d-rum7Fiti:Pnrivi„klnuvil

fnulotutnaluati,tultlonaqi.larufivinnuri - tnim Taalliiviv,iwalum7:61 mPau

Sioll-ro6unn i visInILLar,:01munonnulyiutilllivilinvilEruriunvantriloi -au

mIqvinalia4maqtriinFrum15r,Lvielilmli_litataJIELvwmoIaTuu,Aca '414-attritivelial

ilanmInlr,416vi'AvlBtim-yiNlunn4n1loutTcv,V111 ,41froinnyrn1Fmqvisnlacsrun

10ELMAITCkII121alh@illajn4q:Ai 11 v a

''n-ILLar:11 14- ' n'llA'LiviimAineeN,viliononnEJLI/1111`U IITULIA101.111AMOVIADM011,1.11,1MOltiahldlill

Vtil-11716VIEJWIEJLIAqUililfl

(Oui ..) ....

(dim

loufil,nn-111,1,11,viiiVtivviA'nLnalifinn7qmswILLaz4n -ivrarthtL -)anviunEltfi@n5to

firLumil ImEistingLoAilrilfilAtnthrhifinaqvisItilatmAtiuOinq'nn@tifoli,Al'atifirmTin

mlann owrnufavtii'ullvviALnuvinn5qviswiluat&iumAiviliwilvslfilfryagiomfiklLtu

5r1.114E1Will

0:1@i11115tIlttiTtut-PQ.12.11rifrwITIKulia.lungvia.not,LA J '.11 :601o1.111,92i AI@

Lilei,l,i1MiMhltlunn7lLiii6n.lii`u1.17,17vutiqvi55filLot/&nconwdItInangVainSlt

cAM5t-unmy1J661N5

ki. vinlinq5fmlfunfaulml-ifig.dolm-lailmq3nwitIT,Lar,Av-ilRyantimnn -riAll,t1

661nA'TiAirrinbs166ar,v11lin17.171PuSviBoramp3naimyariloLvA66az6alun 611@tviltinn16-nnu

frmNF15111111,hlfiliTIAT1J1-11$1@d-111WILI -J66MIA.1575LIEJ11.11.1

TI. LitletimatillmMilvimlnllunlIfi@l7n,n0117121frmerApial. ttrunonns

11,in-rviyailkEhlfithuSviBrnvi

nOlqut-tflva.nu ?Iiilringtaiu

: 11112;11111:1MIWIS t ladr&G)

: 14111a@dlik1111ElfliptiOli l

VI VI odfocromnoe) nInona.1

illIntlietstitutgulluqt-TultcutffmgmsuilLiathini Tau

nlitniEru vv

(whil ..)

(Lifilldluaiannth'funnovinilqvislnikiar,41 -11)

(figutigarai vih.t(fiwia)

Toliwnr.,Trirt7cut-FrTifoiltirwileuitrin ..)

(Annicsannii itived'ina)

(6)

g117fIllumarzn=f115ncit4n1

7,15nTwiTtilig

T817N-15nn4quilim

l9&&o.)

f,,ilima@qauLgt 11.5.

0)G9) gaJnI*1,1i lD&&6)

mvu-nvaiihm-thilurummilmoolmot almnuyvtl@lnlIAJwiLnA' -ri

loufAufmaaJmitiiln,flvanu-nA'asT6liffmtnfiges:„ruilnm

1415TiliTti1f1FritlYM7f1JA61.111tht11151,ril Enfillfl -M' llia11661, aZ601111Y111@1

Two tllGllaJaJ1C9151 19d cdunuutiuulm59 Gnb Inom &0) Lon1V151 IJN515551ryilj66Vil

51/1@ifIr1i151,11Utifillf1711;ifl5V.1411A0E101KE.Jd11,11W111.11111tilt11,01LINilfIVInEJ

`4411511415r,fl5t1,1111J5011,flAcl'I 'Vilm511A15nTirtitilf041,11.51Elfi16111tlill=ihdEIDLI

11@1?1,1r1g$117ENTALLIA11116i

IJWY1 vi5t5-rirtYfiiMiiMun'i "vntyrnYtutOtIgii@ilfialmqViinfl

4 111911 ti p)

U5t

1.110.15`1 1,1,1115t511J17ipPid

"mquiinfi"

(G)) Pg61,1415tWillqtrilf1M11@qi16TU14@l4111111.1qUilf1M11111119151 6)0

Vil@VI'lLnonrmu '1'141iTz-,'n@us5NillitAnmfitlifienfiuSvit'vil@vri.7 -Sionun,Qvanu6)..i

6adm-R1nn -milinmAtkviinin15

(to) 61LoilwIlingvailudiErafiwynuiVlovi@r,,Ya -nOuvritrikeioiitiwinaiihril

(g)) nA'LLykrtiall tyl*urildiumAd vna.i (0)) vi18 (1D)

() Aguxil'vtaingv(antrtitmlivniT6TANtingranu5t5 -rtrt7t-tjtv,md

T113%)1141,1111til 6zi1.16)baig1 inA sw4 gAD/tf., flImmATui b&6)

(k2)

gllif11111f1flamun -mq4n9

"qtriInm" miummril quiinmm-lainoultriqi'mm*Jm5NPInfi Lot

livilliElfiT11.15"alql,AEYM100111JfV1111€11,r1E111.1iVIOVi@MT1 1.111114101001;i111@lflatkfil

laillfl@OITEAEJ Ithtnut15?i"113.11ENfllll'i'l(rthtnauqrrorainvilnEriiP)onlilifi5@1

at'Ll'I'vanum-amaleTthtnouni5munonnualu -Jriurana.i5urlovi@PrnIdluvnaCii

LfloCiwinSIA-Athia@KTEJA'm 1018fil -111`i'l Pfl.M11551.1111517151111111fIlaq6■ 5551S111.1q1C1Til -JEJ

5L'61Jutyuivn551nin1vi1atOs551.1

"Ig11^11:1111 -11.161":All'IMlaril lefiaill latlf115g111f11111fIlat)65551JltaiA

Willt;i141.71176111117tYllitItilfil:6i1

1110151 IiiiLigypt7nmaiviTm1-Sili -)utmSopmlun15 -wiltAlquilnm

manlolalauvanu (G))1fidLn'Amk,:uilnR (b) m5-AnuLLat5-nnuyitrumA'nyu (Ln) liwiln4-roarru

i'lLtruni5Wifiln-5ilimalAiii`SToltim -rarhriguLLat5tvri -An15fAlwmin (&) .417Frwalfitona,m5t5-rulThjiigifiliiovrmi@filvito -roNnhts -rwilani

luniTLINFivrL7TVionlmt5m7t-gefit 1J5taiwnginnu@ltoLLatliiig - t.n@Vivrt:11SoLlunywAmewminiuraiiiDap vii@lcgodl Lonal54@thtnuunlAwmalLi'aL9iLiplvidona14 -rovvra-rd

IThfillillATMJ5t5111f1'10111

3110151 cs e4711111MULL9i1j111,f..11,11,411411M111.1Mg A'EslilfltIMIA11061111fil@d11101

(0)) i'lL'in-15i31n1.4-15tkillitmilvnimingvantivilutrituculL@nymnvann (l)

17w6l01tmn1 LLatlAMtnalrlInilywrilnoaltimai (01) g-ILInlginill5tPtytfitutulmilinInvianoLotilifunpluermiltittlii

LotUthtnatillnilmoiarrii Rm. filvrLowthmallaii:laun -in'A

YJ

VY13.1`)5ffiAillvikulknAn.7n1-ru61 6tilE1V1/111M.

g117f1ITUMV1571.1ni7ntr4n1

1r17151 b li,ithtnivna&-ini4-in -norarmr,Trnitnig LLatiSagnn@oon

41@fhVII.101LIA@II'm' fliW711,c.114f151:InUfl@q5fUlf4141.31tWlvihiltioix.ifriamt 9-nn

55511 LLOii@ii'llTOWilfldl'at, k115ilillialintlf11501@ij9g 6H1%iflT11JadiMal

iiDrimuot@liJ5t5 -rum14nimnimnirk,Pil 610,9llormin", 9nvu 11n

iithrplvit,Lifinarynottl5r,frwati5Tdi -M-rtivum.91a-Av7LiSiPulA

3J 1915 1 fl5L'UTUirC7C1.11HqUilDfil1il6111,111_101111111/117t1A 'A66vil

1115t5'riAleif166Mi@fiT1110111@l1J5t5111Fila8l9111.111191 b 11.11116:1174131UYII`All,i1J:FILLat'

'11061111,10viln -nli;c1i -ruvr4,tiPitoilthrananonnu'iN@l5fuw -naJwnlil'inKulmi

1.119151 11,1115filiMpTilatallaqtriIIIMA@LI 311.0190TISItil

1,trUrrAl@6EJ gli.1@6E111@l1J5t511,1PilaqY155atiLLIVAql Liviillillif15L111161f15n7LIAV1Silill0 I

f-mtolv'ithts-umaqvinalca60oplolan5mvrt111,3,HimuT:Frraivii14/1@

miolotimatAunm-15 ato1691,0u

niTt@lumnIA'olnwiriodililluitel'aolan-ruvilo-MtauErrulun56.1filliiimAaolacat.1 unualolguFTTM

Li4@lirmkivraimgLihillghtwynn -lotb n-154-11,Crun1510

'61,161Prlaq1155dallar1M111 NI n

1119151 l'Un5ttlif14 1151fIgqiii@r405t6iltJUI41@t1OViall'Ufl -1Willillif15L'Inti

il@l5Q,11/101,fiTllihEJU

lihnlwrillilikinkuloluum,q-Jaluani@ulTilFrmolittowmfilvrta 61911191 e~ 01915 v 6UEJv

vtiorlmlalknd-ramlnm-railliq@iforoNtic -n:ilitniu

lym11

thr,n@uph'w;klii-wnaJwuuodlllo@Eillvrill 5ILLaqq,qknd-nE74147'ilicinA'@Ivna.n,Luv

(ge)

g'11,111111.1KUtf1551,1f115nq4n1

6.4 L6G114111 ,11.1iblflUlT11.10411/11@i15e1ltUll?111iL6A'1, 1)1?;11filiWilg1 1i 1 aE 51llh11J

liltngus5Nwhatv,tinliA,11cOmillytriiingvanufilvitiovriailtvidAufnmuiontii

l'Un150i -16V1.161V111n5W1Vilt111,aZn559?1@1 3111;i1111r1V151 G< LvtAlthnna

nvino'i8CAN15t1.rwrna1661oi5

MGM 6)0) thtrilm vii@nlInty7-1$1-mktnilo To

thtnaus5r141v7iiesTuilnfiviii'h1au.datti -ikfrileithtnays5rminal@nmili

vin15

CrullnaiotNinwouLwrair,iViliw)viimPratiml ViSeo°UeoGlflsallGl I ifiq1J5vnocu55ri@wli2i115

A'sIndi-dtud-nnmilmlif'ajtv,15tvrillqu'il,nmt -ivqthtnausN./lr:,luilnmalan5tniAuvuum..1

lelHa 1,11UVIEJTLIVi6'nuturiu -JiiviioomaAnd -nU

fi'mnorilklii-wiuvilVd@mloriviA'nyvtAvwCIAotaLlaith -IngifomnN17tauvrillautt,pilil

:711,1Avna.,

anoyi GAD 111t- 15licAW666vi1G11A luni5/115twiii91 (1i5L'il@tprl@rlf@l

115:1111$%UflY1W,WiMIOUf111llii1L1015.1114M11f1 all-1VA111Z011flalliTtAllITIV4A1155511

LIMY) own Tun 141@@1,113:1t1

CA'uvnui,Lar,Vi'aeNT4-,noul5kfikliVelo vilaitiruh111.7m,wil'Opm -mauvriu

Lw)-1

quilnmmio016-ruivillolmhymiqui lnm ~Vie~ 1FJf°111SJ21vt91C91Vi ~1Gle~ FJl~lldv°~1a5vVi71l1a1a ~ 1afl J1

eAlFilfiilluvrtil1PuonCAnni5owl

anom 0.)f 7UERInalM13.1171fillA110115110‘15t5T617Migid141@f10 ,11.FIEAISII

tivrt7tp,t0iiivilmr,rt7EpYriNill -anliftiAu ViostutnalwartlfilarilvrtAli alma

LOunfm-vitaiii@tim-alLi'alt@ FnailinmEiumi@tentiltutoallivramywilLtwatLiio

thulErtiluvilm-nais:65

1.11M51 G)b fMd141 ti fITIllvilvLona9Aulo

vil@i1-13.1@tilAtatitilwa-arvilurmab'141,41,1161quiliwtninktklvilviltin151 -ouvilli41

111.7f11TUFM01,1'ILI Fria@7411,1'4'kullurn5loovi1111151461trialvir,Aumoui'v Ivi5Kyal Im2i15

1,11Twi1a66irm@ilnA mioA@Lyinitilagimvouvilf4ulor116'Iou4Tillii.wmaJ4-AtiLil-ru

(de)

g-n7nutimwr,mufmnqt4n1

fi-animio -an5'A61 -) m-YILLviantnimnammtviAlvilvilt@lCil olflYln15Fiok Y151d conli

viA'nma.iiitiatIttn-ili'll-Tivrum1,51Arhfi -rwuwuolthr, 5-ruvr-41

VIM(1 1J

IgiffntlnaqU'ilnfaidfila 6t141.1

?huil

n-1711a1m;1

an ml owl) Itimalcie;S:thr,naus5fir,Aolr,:ivilnfiviium'gr:juilnHuar, q

115:,mgq5rRilSvitLauo4-11.alviamwifiquilndifplanokilvohifilavilovioena'Aiiiiii6ulet'fri

qt1Tamovs5kLatta4milelvi@FriaiiquilnHitclii6"wo@kfluitmfilaUtAtilinioatra

ailV) G)d irtilPOVivoolnvanEriqhuflYmiveloviom -annlitiviluviirloilu

411,CrufnlotiquiInmvilqiiigitrmloafihvalquilnfcAgutintilifiltrin5mLilEndllhl

61H-Jimh'inDurim-m+lc,i,ViInflvti'011491m41@l4iinfrueivilflpt°414mAol

IoulartolNauaaJwJ5 Liunialfi-jumuLrytalwrn thr,ygiFivrtilliCiu'u5ou 4-161d1dmnyru

fl@lW1161,616'flt4t11:A9111151JSZ11141Vii01111.14 1 1;thl Vtiall0IfYIStatIc1FrMI,1111101.1fi')5

InultiuutnaAmovhaaginfilvilloNli 1,1"ifilaii6nn@i=i'14Tmilufig@@n

wIlla'151fUfl7I:J lunwilm-am5fimillum,n5Rao ii016b1,1

PIAOLAI EWilf111155n1LiimAviamvilooluil?i -rtroolfjfiymivivoliu

ilfrols551.wilumlowlli;itimiaAne.hutin1117,7'ai -ntviomalutrardolquilnovfiorAUTuwkl

61,111411i1119°64 1FINT1555341,11EJLC/IqUililf11,11D041111@AD161 LLY1141.31.11 Mlitilguon

vilviNoviimohnld-yonucimaniruawn

me`' lifialtf11511M5A:a1H5@lquilnm aannimlokiwratilfia.a:n551.1fm

iam5o1(rulinmi'lnonunvianu 'lii1E11195illf1701C1131 ,f1M ilg71.11Vh161,WalLi11.14

ejvilnfluvruCruilnsilA at,lithuri.itv,OLFIErah

rnTul@luar,n154-11,17,11ALLovrtolaronnt4lnlu -liglhlou@tilm

111V151 ()c LIATIA.11,k1910115Z51/11kilTailtlilVlIttl'IHKUitIM (011111 l) W.Pi. I9&`o

(b)

gll'ininiP-ituzn=n95nqt4n1

n15noull@lvil@nwthtilthr,uoLtiowynaumgorwmwviTil@tkliZu

81-aghltiolittuvil:11S'a@lnquillmVjErrhultoo4Drsia unlufmilt@votAolfmvtil

41?Tlut,i,tpolOoiaiaru -iln15nmalol&laiAlwaLAI tivi@n15ia.m5@lquiInmtlai -rou

nr1W1LviloadalT6r,Pal@Nn6iinnuunl

5.u@o-raitujviaJitriiklun -0,11m5@lr,:ruili-mvilabialarnalvilumigIJULYiTIL'oq:dulo

ihmanhrineitfilndiuo -4111m-ruiiLviqknd -ra Pi lc~ v1v

1MV1

LLatvtimrmaA'vd -ralli

limnd16-rin@g14-iwt:nufig?i -aviiiifiEnfiut),mmai%

lun5divarmma1 J

aanfarviloapiT6OuVifialtin -ainimIolquilnmi'unloyanvanu -ilkaunenALHIN

Inml 190 nn541o1f14,Tuilnm Ivink:,11@1$`11u-n@iviiarihwAarAiilou 11,1L-tAn°,1n1TumgoNiiniTt7tviinyivar,Chi tiouvilfilAN

4-111@lA'aliiii@AilitivijuLviolLvvilnwik'DlmV15 -n.414-ito1710TuicoLvt.rtAidi@r,

mlne7a6lll.A-wil1INI:lcubjcinklvilmnom5-41kv,tro6l@1

lvvIfit,t,6,1,419Nollud -ruOulihjn6'olvli@ifoimuqurilA

1.11V151 bo) vrffifiryntgii.24 -11@441-an

INNLI,61 vilovilmariaa14 -1Miya,

1141@-inmAlAA-aiiriEnfiu4 -4101;tillpiiii..anewt6sulatm .64

ilmiaA'1,1ITArcAN-IlfulLvidTtlui§uHA'quilnmolantiuTilAvoci%0

inVIAIN15fIlf1;11

1119151 tgb 6-lieW10106n51'iTYM11,046afInn761a1W1'D ,16'ia\111,ifilUViIv11@r,

ejtvyriumiaulnuirrnii -anCiioilninladiumgqvilm

-i-rviEr-rumkyruilvu4-rumA'ial@qtv,viluriallifivahanFiumi'avtlunlurinci9nilanStau

fnuviA'l

iii@fermliiitIg11101A1,61111'1,11ifmvanoCiunqT@Liatralaignehomillvi`io 11pRaintr1danC/iCritnimnfria LottijoVCiill;flmaivtd-rawil WiFrinT14-1.morliciolum.wa5

611)/FrumErrtal'A'npultlorail7cv,tiginotnor,511rNtiPil ei-n4 d

51ulTuLLar,l0f1015@1.1 1 mnu-malnunwtruLvi lmatnntril:a

g-n:Inllumnatmun -nno4nq

leumnifitiwynAnehmAl'olmemaniulani ,ILFItyagialliii0Slanot,11,11

5-ro@ltA"n566attili11A'Linanlwin1] Lii@maliiIufinorina.1-555fiwill'eTlflit@&@till

fi-rtm612-NvhlAivir'shoOlEra LLat6immtlolatoovriaAT@LLO -allicauvarrulTA -maiEr5

bcn Sjarmiii.14-romannv151 tD19 qill<I4THVZ;

ill.1415@MI11.1;011,1illail4411,110@afilnilEN111.1i11 11@l0E11,11 /Tflill Lot 6-14-willattaWf

mail4-411,111ov]1@z16otano15.141@imoi7ivitiviluvitntiviklyruf/i%@SulifivulodiCluult

@dilviill@Ei111 -naSimanirumm -1561A'

lobo) 1,11V151 tvbID 3J1M5'119bsn 111VI5I bbsql 3,I1V159

1110151 t9bd 66Vi5thA2an,Q143.11Eln1NNr15allfiT11.1661^ilkl116171A11J66fif156 11G1 lan 5591111l 5IOU

aloa.]

1112171 11iff1gari-rotiol111:194iw15onIou612 Lt,

@@ninntnlun4-woullsainmaria.ifilviTA170L'il@n -nlndmull'I'n15 LLatiluvan't.aulusiEnf; .0

1.% 4111E111',14-1La flan H-1 i‘u

11"TI5nauttlo'-)Fi

1,1151161171V15f1,11 Lii@lvvIrittatilLannvii'mriTALMiiimArt:InYu

611 1,11MMMagifIlafiT149.101/11@iiltifiTi&M)MITI,1941f1151,11d1, f1AI E1114fl'IllIUMflalfl'1.11,11 @

Nfi-nuel1u1oehtivicili'ammi'@On6,40

L'ilcuowyn railnERt4llikitc,runlIt'iitinl6L'uLawitviovrt:11X -Ifi -naivanelltivti@ebuloishu

mill MA'

751115 tio ottlaiun151nOin'A 11,11,'N1119riaJil@filliflAt@l

115t51ut1'1n1

LLat41],a0611111,aufhlin15 licamooll'ainl5o@uola.14-1114n -m@l4iLatilotAlLati@til'u

vilomionintin

4-111'4'in5sand-nla.iyi nA'Nvilolnmo -15tg -witv,v911,1@1 Pria@-Ri14-411.1)(41Latiu,filtfillit-rnIt]

Rufrufil, n

LtotlogiLaualaluilailalivitafik,

uotlailamtiojiffninerial1,1/m185t Eft naliit.]

4-Clif115

LT:51, 51 [mil lil@l@llakt151101411,14.11fIlaV11.13.11C1151

ciwi5arlIoulailguotaglovInfiloWi6A@1dh1(1

lifinai14.414-rmliumhont,Suwinoilutifi -ru LicuLivivriai

(c)

g117f111119alt 115%.1n1ntp.4ni

710111W,ILLthaPna@tSitt01.1finliiNiWnil,M41110614U 4111"tkalEalEr)

111017ii@l5Iin

6i1@41LaUlg`UV13.110CitinliliWilaVrannM51 l c 66A'-aithriltrY1d11oiNi5tIn

IATI@-i-)41Lautlm791riu

411inm6t6YVu5aill6G1m avieiliimEagitiiiirri51,idotnA10,1151.417flind -n Wih1i1416au

*J1017Mfi'15t1d1

L10151 1D ?lltiMlliht1101,11anilial'Ul'Ul.1061 0i11115"070171@l5t0 91 111111 M -1

1D lielD'i'WjATUdiltiOata:',ST16011k1LidUn5rintiil@l5nr-rtiol 9rulLnim:114 LLaninTunw,cc-ru

fiTi5i,1iiimalb1l6151atfit17w1711$1 -301,Cg-J

1.11M51

N'AV1 fIlStht nuu n15@onLvu1J col@dTurammeitk viion154-ivilun151,o

manIoLATifoLk@i19ilndl-a@Ooora-n.iviltilEnulAnztolmndhufirtue,„ithr , nou5N

5115a f1151Nr;{ ~ 1d11d1~ 5v6C911d(yl5flc~ 1'JG1f1e~ fJ66f1P1Pl'J1 ~JP~ 1f1Y169J1dG1~5af1rJL155f1 ~ 171d

1.119151 cno 61111E114M1A1141filAllflI9161171q111.1fiquILM61

n159;1a*nmns5N5luiiitni -Ttivihim'Ale.N1Inmb'nluipohlliiironvivnuadrwaiu -)fivfi;1

rivuu,m,naluflgfiaulAICR60,itti C111.161011./1110iEntilArimiI9)tillikl'ilumunivAnrre4 6i151,vimlanItri14Jo6h6111A -ifiott

1:1146113161NEamuf1n1errA6ViN1om'g vil@viloWilonlauritifi -nIntSudiutivio,q4

61141Ciumitntivin .yrul. -111J60 ,11/(19@llifIllfoli ci4M -IllraTINUTLIVIA'nyarALibiihorl.ril

SnaawnAlSi

Cf16) lurnt-i7virmai14-Mihm -ru lirimianvuwjm -nmehuiiu,k1

limuTuvtiAu-i-thr,014w5-41muluv4f -Tulou-nitivinl-mi@Xilitim -alOovi-rikrima

1.110151 f7our77511..1vita1511"IfilMtillJ5tal141011411111iT:MT11.1111711.1LLat@r,

filVilalliftiRT113110101111NOTIDAUfi@tiVii@Vi6"11U

151M51 cnsn

41mk@556LV15f4ilifilang11,11%iUnINEntAlliAr118112(1.11S11,0W113.1i1601.1eIgM ltin

-114-NA'llit,i-rwiLifilltic4m1-noatnat5-ru5 -grwunnfrikyrtrili4 -duil,6 -aym - ulifinam - u 4:: .40

TanfilLolcu-munel-unl -rumaa,m5unl*molpInfi vithom viloywacial lEniolan111,1

vilell'govilmtnyvanruviAiathtnounwiAl@l5nraii ranuvi6n1nriraianvrian55fiviillolNm-rwre:hErm-ruLLatlaio?114

(GO

g-n7n1TuKur,n5unl5nqw:jrn

1119151 lunlAuvarrulai-i-NLAtimiticiFuifvnaltilo691v11@lifiwCiun

1'121 11XmaiAqiiintrillINEJ11,1timyarvii@vitneon -antiffgrwrantiU'via,riol(15umwmln

Fah

lim-mil4TunGtTfitrlDiNu -rualEnriltif@AVi1191

i, flT11.illEJME I.11141Allf410113.1

3J'19159 sn& f1151i111@l5allaVINUM

1:64 @l161VUfrilVZIA@MT171@lMil r1a@t3J41A6AI ou

11W151 snb finao-m@liqmlqw-p-rwlizeMe -rtsitv,InWifranailuLiAlo

IhtnounnTiN'w15atiiiminwia,'LL9iiio111)km -nlnirihm15 -)utimlillaniatim -nwralaufi

1116"tiii@ruol,IXCionerv511arplimSVA -runtOlovitanlirnaniVILLillviioLfilaimmuolu

11@lq1151qt11 .-iiivil@VuTtntu,6In -n

eivi5lqiu-pilvil@ejkantvilimaTalilnWim -nadruilSvitl,MWThun -n

wrour,th,rwil 11atpil6Nilifi1Un9l 13ntviimrVifh1R 1doloumnan551m151J5w15 Pf'1a05553191l31

fq141.1`IFY1A"M5Z11,CJVI1 1J511 1551/31115f110E1F157511

3.119151 am) SJI OU1719JINOTLIVIAflp:11101 .1a1491AidtlatP?11111,AVOalf11%11

u,vim-rulv)

`ViEiliiMV-rirlynnwivrS'@4 -41 vilnmlaolivhOun154-whiktkl'illmuTuvanynalau

61N3i6A316iAioth,t1EyuctILLvilm-n3JEein53J limavi-InlaumEncui4nroi@l111,A'87.11@l'All/T11115

1,10111AIEJTASULLA'7114111,VIIM'Al 1(91011,jk\IU10,0i'D111@

sn

4-tfivi-mv-itia,v,41M1.1109-791a1.01;1

3119151 41.37arnvivi5@ )-414InokScupA'

3119111 clic 11,1M01"114 (111i111fIVINfilgTLINANAVILLITUqUillIflVtitilV1A r1 1fP1713J

LAIEm@oi@muLitilnaienulfiyanStywitonanIN mafig-ru-RuniluTMulitrA'oTwidiivna

Logairmauniew

(6) o)

g11:11 111U9altf1551.1n1 n .6 5g 1 n1

L19151 lun5tilliipmanNovnuLh'oguLLriillniti ITfl111 nrilfrillnylm;ivnuni514115Snr,vt6YP,LtHlfnui.StivritnitditAlliloiNU

lanlOu wra.rdnr:litritrq:AA-ru

anml

qt15:..-,novq5h'i'urwatlfrrari-lounmi@ltalauAl

@yluttuteilliou'Aui-nilLaiatlai@mviTtainA'ugittainwitilltilimilltAmialuakzufln

LIA-noiwinot111111,i‘u3Inmon@iflo61.0)51mgii-Ilinu qtn-rw

-11.di-tats 11'4"Friaiiinmihrowiliqt1,:inouprRofAtiAlAilvaili:.11,tquilnfiumurn5LAT

Iflii1,0EJ411711t11A'1111f1Rill@l'ALIAH/18 -1@lli 1 01,1V1MLLY111fill

VitiFlf111611@lqii5t1101J55N 91a@O@IIPI7'1111i9lt@lr;:1J1111fi117tfl@IJ170 LLavwin

171.1 usim 11;ILL*15:,' nous5NiTu

lAvri5A61Iti21lw175

frITVID1f1h11.1 -)5114i14 1 61C:jklirklc.INOVIVIi@q111071"81.1kli% 11 '4'filAJ4

4'1S111ElilqrsISVII110‘111`11,41'4111Thil'ar111,1f1;19111.11.110111 d's1 (GT) uvilli5zananvnilon'

ii'w15nrwv-na.uvi5 LorSignaam-m1911,1,11.).99'kndl-Jahur:IviltrviIi1'qthtnouprm -rai

1.11M51 eiln-15n5tiiiiivril@li'NLhowinn-nciqthr,nouph@nlnihIou

mulmirtfiEruquilnfilmulajakunniviio@l'hliquilnmbliufiTILLStrviluviloth:arvin

LauLdo@tilli'lmmlailllynolomTwLSErmitifkr,Lrimuriquilfwmion5tylln1561,Aunllti

v .

Ohl K7' Inativiltrcii(ruilnAl(915u Nathtlovilcies,ithamaus5k 1,$11't, an-rutvrAnmluTole.1115r,nolisi@ fnlikictiltnousii@lihmLyrwrnaJtwrityiiicnotiu

d ma@ovurnmenitimagrnitunisfigiaimm-nanSuvriou

n -nri-rrowilLSEnl7m1N@n15allvilonu-)55M11niil

haolLyi-rmlfilLE SminifiLA L iliimatilyrum

LiChiTviiiirtrm

1110151 Lisialla'')N6041rwm`kvii@4-ivitilu4LStmnemvu

m7'121

g-ninl lufifutn7un-m trt4,1

q.zuvrvu vii@uraTtn@lesjui1nRIAtiehtn -aL LLatb.i@l@NMINfiti ai-Aul$111*/fonaiN-rmoon4-41

(6)) iirzithtnuus5ri@on-151J5tnifiLiatiuSwi -alnl -p711@iwihZtonlEhltd winquilnfloTioyinnmviltmlootkrullavninlolunalcifi'muolouil.Nltn@leithtnau p,hs@LN LLgiAtimati@i%ifillyvii@kniNfmpranlind-rrIthlklA rilvTlifymigrnAwni 61"AIRIL61'n ImATilltilA'ftltutuatanlyn@lhAcittutii.Ati 5, 5MVIJSZMVU -Ri

(b) iia*JuratipiMiciniloaldf -AviSv@tjuar:liCiumPluSuA'-ri4611.1U

imiluudquiInmn6Virtaun--NtiiiiniuditlivArtAtiMAIA -alfidTaliiim -ardaoofiu agi tiAtin5tivitiallynnu,fikviAmavdallA ?riaw,IIV-41,111411Ttn@uq5NeZovvilwilLiil 1A-Af1161 LotviinvihirfieW'Eriiq1J5tnDupii9vauFnii-rilt,v150,iti4o4-nniluriiolt)

i14-rin?Taiesitht ei'im-YanJ5indtunlermA'svii(1115tnwqri@laiqi.76q1L4wilfilfl

gluiqfAiilmatrifrNithtn@uprRmiag,4Tulvii-Inlwvrtmlejthtn@uskitin56.111(1

t,Latviln qihtnou a V - prN1a.illlt1ilemAt.614-linvi)Vium'kTuqt15tnouslrmemwt<oulvtli.mwrolia.J4i

ihnnt91 (.1115t noug5h. @m14)16-rul@vhfrluvrtemuN5tnnqlri@ltinwilf415tnous5f1@ vtitii.16'ywiailqnugulounilq@llAiNqi114-41 141@thtfill Lotv6mhz611011114-rtnuiimaSiunifrnri-wroyilvitalupaktUNiionlifilAvInti5trm

Vtun ol'4'-nilailififrKthtn@us5119viioe,„Ifig-ru-mtringuarutolqiJunousrit -ilii(f thtfins5iiwhi'Aylmatointmi'lLiilin -iivinamn7uLLoiiVvv(iprif-rtil

ang17-1 11161i7ie,:rthtnoll5PRillteil@untriAlma V1 ln`~ e@6Vi ~ v@511~ 51nd

Vidiyugainiw(AaQavia@na-g eTuilnm vii@firmEinihuchumviTyl6StrualilkpimaltiviitithtimilTalt),ffialvimfiavicil Lot 1,61AIFYAtemliAlemaillaiLilulmovioniTh5tvillgrayNal Lilaf tim -alui'movil@filavAtimm5 11,1FriaJg-rulv:ioniud-Yu Pulotroi'vut7nalt-rrgitewlA:InTnihanL6.14-1Laui-aai

1, -911.floie,f0tatfitiwulAcilruiitad-ru; LOtAurnIn5tviikni-1 lri'vviNeiFitanlooqiquatL'AufilmouLan.i

t eAtaraumi'ylEISialnilFlemawaralmvritil,1 ,1i-aLi'urdllit,rruviTINE/01.19/1Q1,111 1.9)111T1fliiNflf1Mild

(elm)

gm.inllumnitmunl5ntrt4nq

1.110151 VigV1411.1441111441.11I1W141.11,11PilaT157t1161,atri'laq1 1155flIfilfl 1G1EJ

1,1%111411,Mk'15t111A 9A1M9/16171q11155t1141filAntIVIVII@41A 'neilPilail.A.111144:1,1litffl

1.110Y1 1115TV155fUliAlvni11111,1141X1'21@lfilDMId11461q1.1iII1H

qvinailiJ6wqms5d.dt,osfunaquilnmv(i@filq m vintiln-umunmkuiliwunuluriivruovrt:il

1.11M51

Tonnilliirmilviltrtyrvivalaih,14-naultilvitiolimr,51tntiqm

vynif@ril@Vi,1

1.110151 ItinwliikV157f11011.1i14011,1111q1/155fliV111.11.119111 kV15%-ii

El@Fill4111010341LOUPili'@ILADT@OIR10111155t1101@filaq 1/15W.166NtlflAq UillW1111@faila

g lIndlillRLIMI,111fiktlilfW11,thli'@1JfiUqV155tlitiVllIf15111)`U 63Jomail11 0111 0157Aqv157611

qifillmviimaqvInnliiimUltlf144 q`USIJIMA6IN-15t1n

c,91

qmnal@T@Ii1.24731m19ityvili,N4li'Nvilinomit-pcirpysln,16DfmqvinnIuman4qtfitivimlo

Fliqviu5d,arifluesrunm;i(uilnminuluti-ivruaui-ii'lliTuaoliticifinaiTuvia44161,A' ehtim-alai

Fict44-1121nd-i-niA vt,'qvinn.14wTlla.ii'uqrs5tulu1A

14f-Antiaillat'Z'n15€K14n-aum n m-n . -ruz.mmila@v155damrunmg 9.

pInwvilom-lairvinnlimmurainfiqullnfloyarnImvritILLan55moNlivh1,11onalioriTtiruo

11011i5L'511,1P114111

1.110151 nwii@lwniivnnw961quilnfillifilaqvinalarunmgCluilimivila

Fnaqvinalfrmie.runflquilnfaioxiALillin151iLMOltbmil'a 171'1'11 Wthi0fi9VIIIMIN

&I9 4-ifanin.41v11@4-4111@lfriaqvissnILLe.rufwAviinR

al-,maqvinnImmumun4quilnfilittuil?pl

1.119111 liti.1111111,0111,11111n0 niiiSnItInfl'Aquilnmlurna .frukanlif 171A'uu,rin -15qms56,Lir,m5iiviwnAvilm44incoiau6itom-iaqvi5ItliuunmAquilimum'

maqvinaurimumunmgr,Tuiinfaotiatitilam

(em)

gm InTrumut munl7ngot4n1

lin0Y1 &G) fiovirmaqvinnialunHquilnmvfioenaqvindin -immun4

EJhfwV-riAlyni-rt4ivii@4wilLL6%

n,2vanuirmItvimAuomillaiinTuaviitntfd-n.14-Avuinwrvii@g -4n@vinyinnILI,Nunal

IouFluvio

1110151 &9 Frm:dni@i@fm5anatiiilloilqn-w111.1111V151 &o.)

1111A1M14111111ALIN,WAIIISIEJT/IllTUIJSZIEJVCial515ftit Vii@lAtal,JWIAlkl,16j 1.1fli f110&11

wa5)11@60

mom &Gn vanLnapritor:Vn1511n--diwili'olgrannml filTATI5n1w11

n-niLqm oaomuniTil@muillarlil@aut@vianivrannmi &t9

ShlliV112.1i@fi'1111,10/101tht'511,1fllafl'l

3110151 limgitki'vutitomli:dn1LamirMimilanvanu vilnm4t-r

Sivilfhihrirvilivi`i@gi?Tlt@mnaqms5niviiI@Friaqms7darmlivkliai-rvilvamifiaullirru

mla'&1@n14-1)N6utiviivAntlyk,wrilofiQvia.n8L0t8f1411116,11fivrol441.u@vriaTviswiJ

vilafilaqm55nIniflvrioeilaiftwiu

LIA-J110in561 V1141friAnnvIvii@41A'Avainitilin7vu4-MilcgunFilanifiloi

ti

1110151 licalUY1174101111431)0

1411A

ning5ii-)m51-)fiuu1NlAnntn

1.119151

b& (1g) 1,61,i1

1htlnaf1121,11.1'10767R1WI1M2ILLIAAi1 1,1161FITI3J4'11f.}1.1A'N'Vetifl -laiV4lilWiNFITYSai

4-)La Emnilir-15141@loLiunr,v1-1n15@tillwill@d111,ot,c■iaimm7m15r,Inilli@lejuilnm vih.1

ei-rt.nu esiciTzLNI@vir)m@Fiv4Tvor:Iloi;10-)I mvhvift,14-ii@ILiiowlfitIn-15.6 -1 -dilndl -a

finull@a

(04

gii:inllufifuzn5=n17nqw&l

4-111001 .11n77fiViillklU57Elldilia@ilti14 1,1,?fOl'ilillViVfili TAN(11_)7tfln

arvil@tklii.t7trilneiouliitlifiehoh@iltoleD,Atamvv,Llnwoot:‘uviloalIuoytrifo6'11

311015'1 cif ltanTrai7armiltovrmanm51

vrinM17wiLL6'whi-il (6)) 4'1`Uoilillna:Aillon-mitdwiltolltiiitvivIelmfrn Lotiliviv gainloolofifilau

ii441olmommaJ4-ituduVi tot

(9) dirITILLVilM711J680141Ut@lq.nlliMa.117flikrAgtmOlivihiluvilavioLLyru

vtioepimp*olvtlti4-1Laulajoiturt.itAniolViviiovivamumillilitivriEntrie z

t o lirion7aAtirrnoini7i@nT1Pumgiolufir'sjilvq,mlounti4nLao&UnlErt4A'l m-malmimoioqulInfi Lcud-rt,15-nAluinoion-rJLaltSiErgrilunitriAA'l

4AlLttrild1MilAgv)

1.11(5111 liil'INA'14-41@l1f1,11010111.13.110151 ct lie:0@tqaolLf1114-1Las

Inff171 11.1117filltilailg`41@l4N101VilLIVIcAll d'.64

LLato-N?Ylliejtoolnarmyl UuritI3J-111*A'onli4-.rnlinulintEginalunfi'mtiodoultotillloonari4nani9tmon7g-mi't,

M11.0' 01111Erifi@l@LFianAn -n?ibi

1310111 'DO qii@tlynlovihAntauol@FitAtolifi-iatn:AnviimAEruialal

41A'loolmi0101'13.J1119151 &c9113 ii-wrailfilirlunOnviloarAulatla14-TTaL'And-n A'411,t1A9

lun56101'13J'n58mth

1110151 /30141f11A1.11141111OLLYIULL11911.11A IfflEn@Yaillifili4 -ru@lion6Snm5@61rAut66ila544

idld viaiwiltoomanlE,1,11ena.,Avicuctivoii'uficinail4-iiilsnLkvilotAuuLvdalfi-410134

GlSn ~ 12 unLijorivlin17191errAti-ninri14410109,nuntSnvilovtihtatialiTuLqunl5A'l

ImwralaJelmvtiownOtadotalqto 6tlui-16am:114 mumuliarir,:rvivaplown.u4-1LaulA'mu4nrruififilaninviLm-7 66ar,eltolthJ65 -ivrawilifl

Pi lch firldig-rirmilk4toLarlotroill-irwillivrwilmAifronnwi

(or)

glilnyiumarzn5un-mg*1

1.114151 be ) 11,1f1Sail q66U1911111M1 &.b

@Idtp:M11111.11051 &sql fYIEJIIISUililet:1`ULLViilhifilailfi're7111110f1161,145tErZnMM 1;11 ili ffiTV11A 1

ii@ -i'144\11.11A1AUlnLn62Jom5uf1lv11dGwi5nd -17

(iiiwAjmIolL§u4-1LamY1467-rmviunanlEilia -nAti

/1@lifilail4411,1V,s1:1109111.11.11M1 to1iffilStAva,

maAnntiivilaAwilwrn. maiig-owt7AJOoLainvrill

anovi lun56.14;11@9111.11110151 (b 1^~en5F1G16ilEl7fly(11~lenYIPS1sn~1~11~i5

FYIKM9113.11-J1V1TI &cl IYIEJMUVIT71,11:11J1WiltifiFilafig41141@i11811J5tElt0a141WiT141,10

'i-i?T‘ivt.,icti lvrt71,1vilo4'41utitin9SiFilail441LtfdErLavtJaw -marwm bo -J55M14`ill

3.11M51 Isbo 111V151 19b6.) LLa:canmr bbal LI,Vilti5L'Il'AVV11.1'106k15f1.19M1LILLIN1111147171A'11

ICluvu1aL

1117151 'Dm 11nt1,61111151N@15f1,11

'J6n151 LiimmLvrffl-nari,SsvrIErvfiml@Ifirunoliktrieh ll'i,noFallnativiluuritjm -numl@

quilnFlvtlud-ruynakun154-ami-afi@unllinAnnw -IH'A'

1ilOthifTV11151U191111011i1`W1df1111,14 liMlailgliM41141401J1915n1TADT6n1TtitaiivviTin

4-alnutLatm@aLm-nut-in561,ilothr,lurtiLLvilm-ya.0155511 sirarvi6unLimaiLotiBinwil

rhvitioIouiarimiruortmthrzitifilanl

viAlmhtinintini54-niTunlwrian55mAdimaiV - inoon4-411ictemaii

LriEnii@l1611Thajavil000nmantiCiuryrnaillarillintgriulriloymaisvnu

flThlt:dovilo TArtn-m,Laz,vii'vlEiAteuo14-naulArs.iiivAtimorn

In0

f115171PUV113.14-ifivonw-nmio49A'l

IriMn \D l'uni5inKu4 minn-monfilSiKullJENnvidvin n wiiiimintriuu

iirm@onvantrNiiumkniiiimirtivnaJfiiihAnnwigum-yanSErvnuLLaninnvilvii-Uw111 1i1m1lvnufhfirrin1.J1o1al4Toor:19u141E17f3izfila61Noli@wimanutilPumA11

Diu ~v~ EJ`lai ~l~i~ Jnnnwilti~~ivfi~ufi`l~i

1.11V151 1110116'11tA' 41A111111Tlii1171q011.1410ilfWni,') mliwrrartirnfl

gq`lif11111M-1.1t n5un-15mit4rn

1 iallai14-rul@o@nA'qA116A@

11111116V614101A'lndTM11Wina.141601,110tMJMI6ISif1761111adUIEPOI:i 66li5KIIIINa51111

1.11/16MITZ111

111015 .1 bb

liflY1Pu Lor,117rinA'uvruingtaluii11ifotjfi@uilivi

efi'varialmt In1.151111@l1115

ma Lan

Inuni'svum

g-rt:inl -mm tutn 5mn15 nt-p4n1

v(antivoq Lviqesialuni5115Lnlmlifyi5t5-rwt.ifv1,6'mTud lot,iMNi.1115:,-LruLfiTqrvdn15

w1 iu61-3@d-111-m1-3 Limiln1511-wrratfroPulvitrimiemitotolmiulativilifturnuiAmatiA'l

ma@v)wu6Ylmilmn1wownlr?TtJuna1J55N vi'161/no4-11d'1w;a@sil'unl56i1lv? -4tutr6lali)i'

13i3J -41SIA-rviiaul1 IiiiiMnmqnt,oli'ovalariuvokipuo lanTind 6'21m,11G1°t1aiivavrt1d

1 673.91,ii@k111.1FITILIL111411@01111,@1

CUilflfianDE,,,1111:11,44411,SEJ661 8`UVidirllAll'Illkif1151illti f115i14 11A17166atfiglYILN11115

LeAtmi-15nd11(.11Junotiqkriun*JquilnmilIallAlufi -allivihn551.1 61ailean5:muvio

TIJ1JULVI5191NIMEI5 -31.11J@T)5Z61/10 nfi-nliikz,vultifiwminaiiiitiaaioni5141Sviti,lun5o1

iiialh'ziliiInfifilaufrrOuvntiVli'unmo-MuLEItraulA"-morramml li5V1/60

66atih.l5r,Av1ti1` Al 61.lvitufn5iwnalAvit6nlquiInm flIt' 6 .64 En fill 6i1d8i52i16215iltieiIJ5t flUU

i14-w1hAolmy) IAIT451t

TUt51111.70,46i)tl *T15f1.11fIkUiLfW1 (Q1.711i1 19) 111.M 19&&b'n

1' ei 141.1101.1119) Lviy4al.unlTd5trywilivnr,51n7wilviuvuu LialwInnnvily-w-ilA'-aun-15

fl61' toz4-wilunwAntifi@l5nnlm lufigtileilimolejuilnnfiLtluthtluvtioiquilno

flut85urn5ium@le;uilnfiln@sliiSm Nil@ltatkwiltim'h@omAolfitinQvanuA'lnY1

411.6..A1V151915t51/14,fiY1

G)c 1.9&b

Trel'iNgld1.1111141 6i1a1 6)6no/VIVIIii Ig& 11/11111 co/md

i'vri 03 / 5% iv:114/c10/0.

va -1 15 ,0 '1 dl 06')A flvalusifArit

c-VR/ qvii

1d7Un5S3.fl. 15

IJOLLOO1M1'111

(6)c)

difinlitnalri6ril:iiLaill • tir"1-7.1,1

i-rtinliutat -On -r,o.rarJr)117clit.PLvvitlii

11111'11J. r-y; 7 / 6 r s,

owl

z YI u5 o&ocri/ LiV611 9

g-117frouni"smol5

nvat mocnoo ea

,.."(n5n.D-ww tvtctc

i-11115t5-rn7Qtylultrafivulytin-i5qvis5da,a4nn 5711 e

n5itn:iuu

i141^111'51 6617f,VELTA`Ull@ld 5111 e

kEJFItUti9.11.1V111A1.15teptlif1111811AlitZla

'111",15L'S'ITI%f1,17.40R1Pilaq1155tli6111-11:1tIALP1t4 11.C31. . . . .

l,. :111"15Z511.117f1j011ellt6illal.1115:ti5551.114,1fIgi'laNF15553J (MTLiri . .) 1N.Pi. .

sn. i-11115t5Tirliin,1741V1141J5Z1.11aft2141.1101BrilT15fUlM111.161.1Ail ..)

-

•

111,15.e,5-rtri.ifut-v,74tisrnaLL511 -ruLLat75 .171T15f111416651111,1 (Q1.71hi ..) 1N.P1. . . . .

(LISTIAMILIALIVIA•111,f1f1.1 6iifYI5T/1556,6a11111)

• illTITZ511rktPW\IFIlalli'1101.11194f11,f11,11,10tf11501-15t116-111J5t 1:11FILLarT8ctiV15f111

4I'Vli'llE.711.11/111NUIllatfil5k1511A7111J5tLYWI (aTtril ..) .... (Lu-71.411.aanitAni,nnain -15qvls5t-ii

b.'11115,1,11111k1Q7iijvnaAlJat'alEJLLOrltiiTISfUlFAhat.% 01 E1 ..) 1N.P1. ....

(61.fitT6filailIVIA'flitlf1.1 6Y111 -15q1155t1166W61 111)

• +11115:15-1111%,044'1Pnafili:4@lf1ILLMT8fAiT15C1.1-1MA1 1111/Tlf15 (01111 ..) YV.Pf. ....

(arilTADCALiritnfi.un-i5Tis5niiia4n1)

• ill.115:15-rutifm,Iimmtri -Art.ma.am.umi -matit'fiviwn6lor -r-nruLiat,m5atifli

..) . (1,SlionlailiviA'nintioyin -15q1155nia4n1) Lot,

e. illmuyrtviltutgii-7811h15t-uWiquiliwi (uTtril ..) YV.Pf. .... (66n `UlW3Jl(13J

M'n6ntin1ni5qv155n104ni)

G Q171.1 oi@onniiiititucgiLivilt-il' Lt1.a5@miT1.1

OJ ~Je76?11de757JYV5.57`Ut1tUfUGltlJn ~ 17 5771 e Qtit, mi@LAauti.i.hinvAnnl5iLauillwa

Ltat.17.141n"-iLm5-mbitio -nr,?I' -witij

mon

glilmat-itn159areismoil

11,15. o bivdo e000 viD snoe (11,04far)

1115?115 o Ivbdo eo& (a455/D*

1.71111m4finiltiat mop

thr,natii -mvoulittitInPlgiriailcuifikuilnA ..)

LifistvLfimilvyntl-nat-RITNTilt-u-wwitzitrilnfi Y M. tDMG) AjlGID11111

(G) fliVIIJAM1171111MTIVIlOgiAl101ianaq1151fIlllNliflfiqUilflf11410FIlaqVISIC11111f1

111niDA)

(t9) r11vr1JGltir115i11f111Nvi1mm5o49ATamnav5511111Wunaquilim

vilamiaqvinninimiertinalquilnm (usiintfivLAInnvili &G))

(cn) ofandgulu vininfui tatigniii:ufm4nififirnnyiviiO4-41 (uananciIi t

111071 &sn LI,MM111 -

1.11Vitlfl

ImEntRnilutilvatrtillvanintwriniIqmsmittaqnivnan)5tanangvano

"alkilenfraivitri4 I1 inma4ni ownlulavili'utivvaninfu .virmqvisIttitor,&rilufiquittifilviiifiliunowA4

vlinztraitnfiu .i44'lltillk171111157,1711117q10141

(fn o)

514

(Ouil ..)

....

ImuMunilowinusilTviziliLktvariEriikultkiltuinquitnfi

1114151 "von-rminjigiT4fialIfUlfiClquittin ..)

VOL

1.119151 ViltITUUlaVAVTIATIT1Kuiisnwi -Tutiminluthr,pifiluyediaTnitunwi • •

111V151 sn liunLhfnulullIfwfmalanom

mgrzi,Vitnfi loMG)

"niuli11J4fitanm &G) fiiiimintrivrio4-anammqvisulusrunfikitiittifi

orminqvioninimuninfiMqViinfilittufkim"

MGM 11,9E1raflf1111.111.13.11G111 &G)

loMm uatil'ilifyrawialthiu.vru

":.rwm &G) ni4n-ifi-nlynntrefifivfmlemaqvinnitumnnquilnfi

vilocivqvialdmifitterunfilquilnfi lin5V1iiMiolr5uo1itinminnem4f11v113ruvacgtOli

L6vil1l5v3nan143.11ea51Nv15tu1ti1'113Jurie

anni if liunna.nom co MGM ifcn On1G111 1.6141YMI51lilltal251Nq11f1t1

MA. lo Mm

1110111 b ni*inquilnfillmaqvinalurunfig@ill -mvii@enaqmonlinnuNunfil

quilnffilflifirnnvnliv4IfiDUTIA111,1-mTajgailiftilh lvTIT1Fiumiun.qvantrtiliTIPuoy,f1011 11,145Z111111f1.40,7itillIfTIMUfrilfikrafIMICAN15fUlMfil0&11

miom el litlunuma:dnii'fitriallvramumiTtigiiii

OU?ila1117t1J51.111/AM15

1.11U nilluwil

(bk,)

viltditigraliwenr,l-nrUggarvilit'il@iltinfigeditt-tfi (m.Tufti ..)

(ttileutfiutialviA'nmanifinqvisultu4ni)

ficutiliarual,iii:VAItiftgruoillvanitiki44171kilcuifigetiiinn (atititi ..) MM. .... (6LilintilaniivviAlfunfuvini5qm5Itilaarn1) Gi@Of1TrillTfAiiILV11111F1

tiolwaunr,fiquintuluniurtaiiivozlittitufFi

LualainutnqvincULLaqnionlithn..nanvanuTifi@lItulfrvantril

Dtig11,1Minfilah'nifial

*f1111111Y1171.14-riivi1nvrziolfilaikiku

lialfrnwimnAltiuviA'nniIRrulfilitaztr -wnutlumaq141.11E1n7N1IfIllfi'YllILLAlltrlv autivivai .

U.

%i ..) WM. MA'nt.nclorin-p.qvInniu,at,'"&)

x

1irirslaliTITM1UAll01i'llt1V1Tletili7tn1F111.11111kW1

timmali4ifiviinwivilaggvivuvoliaa,visIniumunfaiquiInfl

miarriaqrsInitrntrainnoleuit.nfilMJAm (iNanom Q1 (iattLfim(1larimli -nmval)) IDA) tiiviumlini4nifilfiriintrimiafi4vemilaqvmlniumunAquilswi

mizminqms5n1f11FILLNIJflficleUitflfi

(Luitsu6i1116134111V111 &G)))

untSmlatitti vIA'fitntugi

LAplinofiklii'ultuuotituiiii4nArTmfiliTutlItananvianErTgfillilllf1T1111.1.1411 (514110111 C (tint.Snanmi d Invm &GI, Ina/1071 &4)

19.& fiwndlifm&rifiiquilimilmaqmnalumnfiviquitnfivilunaqviultilfrn us.lunfigrMInfolfi-rrivilntm41044rivuluilviltlit litilKumungvano

4 41 .4 liiiITIPuwun-lifikvtolnilfiwn.culainfliani b)