Open Proposals: Pre-competitive Space for Research Community

Open Proposals: A Pre-Competitive Interactive

Space for Research Community

Oksana Gologorskaya, M.Sc.Product Manager, Virtual Home Program, Clinical and Translational Science Institute,

University of California, San Francisco

Learning Objectives

“Crowdsourcing” ideas and proposal development at biomedical institution

Insights from 5 years of practicing

Open Proposals Tool Demo

Invitation to collaborate

Harvesting Ideas in Academia

Request for Proposals

RFP Timeline

Imagine a friendly community…

Add “social” phase to the process

What is different?

Proposal Ideas are shared with community before they are submitted

Everyone knows what everyone else is proposing

Anyone in community can comment on the ideas

Valuable contributors can join proposal teams

Proposal teams can merge

Open Proposal Process

• Share Online

• Discuss & Improve

• Submit for Review

• See Everyone’s Results

acc

ele

rate

.ucs

f.ed

u

First Open Forum

18 ideas

41 comments

acc

ele

rate

.ucs

f.ed

u

First Open Forum: Implementation

Section on existing Drupal website

Simple features:

Post ideas

Comment

Vote

Anonymous participation ok

2009 UCSF CTSI Grant Renewal RFPa

cce

lera

te.u

csf.e

du

High stakes: ideas for $112 M grant

53 ideas

47 comments

We got the grant!

Practical Insight 1: Starting Conditions

•Collaborative audience

•Non-$ motivations to participate

•Support from the top

UCSF CTSI Pilot Awards 2012a

cce

lera

te.u

csf.e

du

28 ideas

292 comments

Participation Increased. Why?

2009 2009 2009 2010 201218 27 53

19 2841 39

47

6

290

Open Forums Participation 2009-2012

Proposals Comments

Behaviors Observed:

Proposals improved

Connections made between participants

Proposals withdrawn

Practical Insight 2: Process Matters

1 2 3 4 518 27 53

19 2841 39

47

6

290

Open Forums Participation 2009-2012

Proposals Comments• Design process to encourage participation

• Manage the audience

First Non-CTSI Challenge

2012 UCSF IT Innovation Contest

Target Audience: All Staff & FacultyCompeting against other solutions

Solutions Considered

Email

Salesforce Chatter

Open Proposals

UCSF Open Proposals Tool

Custom Branding for Opportunity Sponsor

UCSF Open Proposals Tool

Standalone, easy to use space for discussions

UCSF Open Proposals Tool

Transparent & efficient process

Open Proposals Provided:

Transparent & efficient process

Standalone space for discussions

Easy to use

Custom branding for sponsor

IT Contest 2012 - Results48 proposals, 5 awarded

73 people posted 216 comments

Withdrawn/merged proposals: 1

517 unique visitors in active phases

A Hard Learning

Department of Medicine Funding Patient Cohorts 2012Funding to allocate: $200,000

Target audience: DOM Faculty (~620)

Collaborative opportunity: reusing patient cohorts

DOM Funding Patient Cohorts 2012 - Results

14 proposals, 2 awarded

30 people posted 66 comments

Withdrawn proposals: 1

431 unique visitors in active phases

Surprising Feedback

Opportunity Sponsors: “We won’t use it again”

End Users:– Overall experience: 2-dissatisfied / 6 –

neutral / 7 - satisfied– Proposal impact: 2- improved / 7 – no

change / 2- worsened– Team impact: 2- added team members

Practical Insight 3: Supportive Sponsor, Engaged Community

• Make sure the audience understands the process (no, it is not a popularity contest)

• Early ideas have more room for feedback than fully baked proposals

• The audience will not engage without Sponsor’s support

Other types of opportunities that benefited from OP

Building Community to Revamp Medical School’s curriculum

Department Strategic Planning

Administrative Process Improvements

UCSF Open Proposals Toolop

en-p

ropo

sals

.ucs

f.ed

u

Standalone Drupal Website

Integrated with UCSF Single Sign On

Optional IP restricted access

Linked with UCSF Profiles

UCSF Open Proposals UIop

en-p

ropo

sals

.ucs

f.ed

u

1

3

2

5

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

UI: Forum Space1. Sponsor branding

2. Opportunity title/subtitle

3. Intro text – opp. description

4. Opportunity timeline

5. Proposals main feed

6. Forum menu

7. My Proposals shortcut

8. Topic filter

9. Activity feeds

10.Footer menu

11.Search

1

3

2

4

UI: Proposal Page1.Proposal title

2.Proposal view tabs

3.Proposal info

4.Proposal body

1

3

2

4

UI: Adding Proposal

1.Instructions / format requirements

2.Title (required)

3.Taxonomy fields

4.Primary author – if proposal is submitted for someone else

5

7

6

8

UI: Adding Proposal

5. Proposal body

6. Multi-file attachments

7. Single file attachment

8. Post (submit) button

9. Preview button

9

Automation: Updates and Subscriptions

Proposal authors and commenters are automatically subscribed to the updates on their proposal

Forum visitors can “Follow” the forum or its selected proposals

Key Ingredients for Success

• Process

• Tool

• Engaged Community

• Supportive Sponsor

ChallengesHow to engage community?

– Intrinsic vs. extrinsic motivation for community reviewers

Community balance

• Narrow enough

to remain relevant and

collaborative

• Wide enough

to provide valuable input

Benefits of Open Proposals

Open, transparent process

Collaborative space

Efficiency

Better teams

Better proposals

Less Obvious Benefits

Reviewers get not only proposals but also community’s reaction that may inform them as well

Every idea is captured and stays there (usually online) forever…

Active participants build relationships and get noticed

Winning proposals draw more attention

IT Innovations Contest

OpenSocial Gadget Contest

DOM Patient Cohorts RFA

Funding Shared Equipment RFA

CHV Caring Wisely Initiative

2013 CTSI Annual Pilot Awards

Funding Shared Equipment RFA Round 2

UCSF Coursera Course CFP

CTSI 2016 NIH Renewal Launchpad

2013 IT Innovations Contest

DOM 2013 Strategic Planning

CHV Caring Wisely 2 Initiative

2014 Innovations Funding for Education

SOM Dean's Office Bureaucracy Busters

0 5 10 15 20 25

Average comments for winning proposal

Average comments for other proposals

Avg. # Comments, All ForumsWinning vs. Non Winning Proposals

Avg. comments per proposal0

1

2

3

4

5

6

WinningNon Winning

UCSF Open Proposals Today

23 forums Since launch in 2012

700+ proposals

18,000+ visitors

$ 4,000,000+ funding distributed

Shared with 2 institutions

What’s Next?

• Research Administration, Infrastructure, Strategic Planning

• Collaborative Research Opportunities

Thank You

UCSF Open Proposals is managed by the UCSF Clinical and Translational Science Institute (CTSI), part of the Clinical and Translational Science Award program funded by the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences (Grant Number UL1 TR000004) at the National Institutes of Health (NIH).

Special Thanks

Mini Kahlon and Clay Johnston, for introducing the idea and making it come to life

To Brad Bulger, for building the tool

To Cynthia Piontkowski, for creating the tool’s people friendly side

To Leslie Yuan, for support and inspiration, and winning decisions

Special Thanks

To Rachael Sak, for figuring out tricky details of the process and making it a success when most people were skeptical

To Lisa Schoonerman, for help with winning hesitant new customers and for invaluable practical insight

To Anirvan Chatterjee, for the most creative ideas for the tool and its introduction to the bigger world, and for huge help with this presentation

It is literally true that you can succeed best and quickest by helping others to succeed.Napoleon Hill, one of the great writers on success

Publication on Open Proposals

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cts.12147/full

ctsi.ucsf.edu * open-proposals.ucsf.edu

GitHub Project (ask us for access):https://github.com/CTSIatUCSF/dreamcatcher

open.proposal@ucsf.edu

oksana.gologorskaya@ucsf.edu

Contact Us

Media Credits

Noel Hidalgo, Hand made "like us on Facebook" sign. , Flickr

Kfergos, Abstract Lights , Flickr

Sasha Gologorskaya, Friends, Everyday Photos

Ren Kuo, Dreamcatcher, Flickr