Upload
shobromy
View
41
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
المشكلات العملية في دعوى التعويض في القضاء الإداري السعودي
Citation preview
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
w WOKLF JA*U iuF u
uF `UCI
b b wu U{ fi
fi `UCIK wUF bNF*U fb WO uC
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
WbI*vK rK wKB sdUA bL w bL bFU d o(U vC c tK bL(
bF U fi5FL t t vK bL pIK dO UF `UCI w `u rU; U dEM w UUCI u WU w iuFU rJ( Sd?C u iuF Vu w UNCF qL JA* s bbF dO `UCI
fitU tu bb% YO su q bF QD) u dC c v vC c qFH w d iF qLi?u?F?? d?b?I?? o?KF JA UM uJ b UL dOG qF szb qF sb* qF
fitLO YO s Xu YO s t uJ;iuF u w d_ bO WU rU; U wIOD lu w d WJzU JAw JA*U oKF ULO WU WuF e rUE u w W rU; U dEM wQ?D?) u?M? o?KF d JA VU s bB c wId* QD) bb jd
fidC iuF r WOR* TAM* wBAwBA QD) s nK q bb% d U wBA QD) s uM c UM UL
tM Q c
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
lC p w ` UCI UJ WJUA* WKb* lzUu UdNE WOKL JAWOUO( dOG* bO e d U dF U UUM* c w dI* buI U* s
L?z U??% d?UF* lzUu uMW?L?z?* u?K?( l?C?O b* w dJH UL v UfiWOdA u_ s bL*
WOLKF U* iF Y s lC w u{u* c w WUJ v UM l U cs WKu uN c v U% w iuF U w rJ( bM UN Ud sJ1 w
fibbF JA* c u UN uL s d_ c nMJ U ` 5U
wId* QD) bb% WKJA _ u;?L? Ubb% w WuF dO w JA* sQ?D?) VJd qIF wId* QD)
d?b? c? n?u?* u QD) VJd c U/ WU WOBA od* dCK V*U b WORLK Vu* dC l U tOz dQ d9Q tO qLF od* cs? v?K? r? QD) u bb uK( s Y UM wB QD wId QD QD) q
fiiuFU eK WOR* lIdOUF* c bF wId* QD) s wBA QD) eOOL UOF l{ dA U bI u? Wb w WU V UMU uN c qKJ r UNOu u WN rNM qJ _uK( s YU _ UI* w rN U/ b buI bOI tUJ w ` UCIU uKO1 sc dA ` sJ r cN b vK WF q JA* lzUuK WLz*
bb% WOR*U oKF ULO `UCI UJ WIOI s dF dEM bd vfi'5?? ?J?A?* c? q?( w?{U?I? UN 5F sJ1 w dOUF* c w Y q
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
ficQ UNM Q dOUF* vK rJ( sJ1 v wBA pc wId* QD) WOU
wId* QD)W?b??K? t?z W? b? t?L?O?E?M `u od* dOBI v VM c qK) ur d `u 5KUF s tJ sL dEM dB QD) c VJ c u t od*Uw? d?E?M?U? `U?CI h od* oU vK lI dC s WOR*U pc dF
iuF ufi'wBA QD)
vK WOR* lI QD) VJ c hA dOBI v dC tO VM c qK) uOB tIUUB WU WUF rU; uJ U) tU s iuF ` Q eK U
ub dEMfi'U??_ s? h?? U?? q?F? s? r?U t b$ 5U( w QD) v dEMU`UM tM QD) lI WOHO WD U tDd c hA tJd wId* QD) w sJ
cOHM tHO ULN0 tUOod* UNR w WKB* oOI% tU XU tzU s d_ Wb S tKF vK d{ Vd U p vK WOBA WKB* fO tO VM c
iuF Ub qLfi' 'iuF `UC `UCI ULD bL ULOK fi ' wdF dJH WF '
`UCI wLK uL fi ' 'fi'dU b `UCI uK( V bU fi ' WOFU UuD* ' 'XF bL fi
`UCI Uub WOFU UuD* 'fi iuF ` UC wHM tKb fi l{u* fH 5IU 5Fd* fH 'WOdF WCNM '
fi oU bB* wHM tKb fi '`UCI UF uUI w jOu dHF rU f bL fi '
WOdF WCNM 'fi
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
Lz t b$ o U vKWuF QAM wId* QD) wBA QD) 5 jK b U UY?? v dAU l U c iuFU eK* WOR* bb% w r ULNMO eOOL we??K?* b?b?% w?{U?I? l?O?D?? v sQD) 5 eOOL UNDu sJ1 ju{ dOUF sw WOKLF JA* qI UNId s w 'nu* hA ' od* iuFU
fiVU cN oKFu bb% bM UN bd t sJ w{UIK WeK XO dA Ud w dOUF* cn?K??? b lzU s ub w bu UL WF WdbI WDK w{UIKK QD)
fid v u s p
wId* QD) wBA QD) 5 eOOL dOUF _ UOF*
wB UOF* c WOHOu tU ` ` UM nu* b WOM bBI U vK uIs? Q?D?) u? Z??M??? w?{U?I vK fiQD) VJ c nu* WO hA oKF t_
QDK WuJ* dUMF ub lzUfi'OB QD) dFOtM UB qLF nB U WOBA eM s dF U U
`U?D?_ p?K? q?? d?B b tuN tHFC U s nAJ w WOBA WHBUu nu* b `w bBI vK fR c WOuO rNUO w U d_ UNJd wWUJM qOJM wHOu tKL ` s bB nu* w{UIK 5 S tHO UL U1
t? q?O? UOF u WOBA eM UOF vL 'dOdO wdH rUF UOF* cN U 'fiUd w wId* QD) wBA QD) 5 eOOLK
o?U bB* Uub XF bL fi dE UM R fi 'WF 'dU b ' oU bB* wLK uL fi fi'
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
q?L??? w?B?? Q?D? tQ ub w rJ WOB P oOI% sdU d{QD) c ZzU nu*fi'
O?I?d? Q?D) dFt?K?L? `U?M? u?B? Q?D??K? W{d uJ c nu* tJ U UULN oOI% q s qLF U t tO bN c dG oOI% bB t w?? W? W?N WOR0 w{UI rJ QD) c q s "UM dC S pc tHO
d{_ d eK nu* UNFfi'
WOBA eM UOF bIUNHA WuFB s WOH u WOM bBI WOBA eM UOF* c bI w qOr? t? U?L? fiq?_ v?K? U?( i?F? w? W?O?M s WOM `u 5 WKU b l{
bI bb% tu{d{ bB b nu* tJd sJ1 c rO QD) WQ* ?OQ WOBA `UD_ UB w l{u sdU`U?CI UJ r WOM s vK U
w?U??U? W?U s dO W vK t_ wId* QD) U sL{ tF{ v Vc `UCI UJ s XU u U 5 dA t uI U 5 iUM v R UOF* c oOD Sfi'
wU UOF*O?B?? dF QD) vMF0 WHOu s UBH UOF UOF* c vLt?KB sJ U
U uJ b UBH c WUF WHOu U suMF UUfi' oU bB* uK( V bU fi ' oU bB* wHM tKb fi fi'fi' oU bB* UM R fi ' `UCI fiuHB bF fi qOK s fi ''
WOdF WCNM fi oU bB* wHM tKb fi ' oU bB* wLK uL fi 'fi' `UCI UDF R fi l uu wdH rUF UOF* cN U 'WCNM '
WOdFfi
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
U qBHM* QD) UM lzUu d `UM w{UIK sJ1qJA UBH c dN UU_ s qLF cN UOI VKD wHOu qLF UOCI XU u UL dU Ufi'
`UL VDA UbK UU w 5R* b UB vK UEM h p UU_ b r VDA R* c U U d rNO du c U_5??U?M? U? p s t dONA v UB c U& r t dN c
?B?H?M QD dF dO_ qLFUU R??* U?O WHOu UL s fO t_ WHOu s Uc WFL `U tM fO wHOu qLF UOCIL rN dN sL dONAU
fiUNOK uBM* wHOu qLF U UB bF hAu?M?F? qBHM* QD) UU?? w? b?M? q?L?F U oIO WOHOu Uu s U
OG qLFU UOI ` UM nu* sJ b dG wHOu qLF]{d t vUM nu*U d UU b; dG s d b uJ?BHM qLF uJ pc d d v WHOuK U
uMF WHOu UL sUfi'
WHOu s UBH UOF bIW?H?Ou Uu WKB* `UD_ q wBA QD) U s bF t UOF* c VOF
I?O?O?C? q?1 c WLO `UD XU u vb?b Ut?O?K? ou wBA QD) dzb `UD_ dz lOu v R t_ t qLF bF UOF* c S pc ` UCI UJ
OB QD) dF WOBADO U u v UWHOu U s tUBH U d: U?B?? u?J? s?J?1 c? r?O?? QD) U 5OF b oU UOF* UA UOF* c
oU bB* UDF R fi 'fi' oU bB* wLK uL fi ' oU bB* ULD fi tO U 'fi'
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
WHOu Uufi'
YU UOF*O?B?? d???F QD) UH WUG bN UOF UOF* c vLn?u* U v U
O?G]U?b? tz s vo?O?I?% v? b?N? U?/ t?O? qLF c UF od* b l oH WU WOB UUfi'
s?L?{ qb w UNIOI% U uM* b_ b oOI dB b nu* U SdF pc UNM tKB sJ1 YO tHO UL w bM QD S W tHO UD
fiwId QD tQ rJ( sJ1 UF od* v WuM* `UD_ sO?G??? w b_U WHOuU UN W d oOI% bBI nu* dB U]v?
Q e lOD WU( c w w{UI S WU W U q s U UNIOI% od*UDK qLF u WO s QD Q nu* S d vMF0 wB QD QD)
WHOu c UDK qG UbM Q tMJ tHOfi'
WUG UOF bInu* dB U vK wBA QD) dBI t_ VOF t UOF* c WU r
dO U ULN qF dF q WU bI0 rN uN jI WO ` uOB QD wUU Ub?O?F QD) s bN U v nuLK WdOBI WOR* tM ZMw b s
oU bB* Uub XF bL fi ' oU bB* wHM tKb fi 'fi' oU bB* ULD ULOK fi l fiw UOF* cN U '`UC dUA e fi '
iuF fL 5 WFU WFD 'fi o?U bB* wLK uL fi ' o?U bB* UM R fi 'W?LJ; rJ '
dB0 UOKF Wflfl rd WOCI WM fi
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
O?B?? Q?D? n?u?* Q?D? U v U( s dO w t `UCI 5rd UrO QD) U w tO sfi'
QD) WU UOF u ld UOF*fi'O?B?? Q?D) UOF* c dFt??J? c? q?L?F vd YO WU s W mK U
p?c? t?U?D?K? b? v?D? uK cN nu* _ WOzUM rzd UB v nu*s? Q?D?) U U UNOF nu* qL w WOBA `UD_ s WLO `UD_ dFQ?D? b?F? t?S? W?O?M?O? u?B? t??H?O? U?N? R u nu* UNJd w WDO `UD_
OIdUfi'
u wIOD lu w cQ rO QD)v_v_v_v_v_U QD nu* TD LO UHu 5R* b rN u UL U WdU U
fiqOWOUWOUWOUWOUWOUOuU QD nu* TD L?O UU Ub d u UL tUDK b pc
fio t b d_ b tJK1 jzU bN tOd iF `UdWUWUWUWUWUuJ nu* tJ c qFH uJ uBI W1d XU `u WOzUM W1d U
q??I? d?CU WUF rzd s d_ `UA ud W1d WHOu UL vKb
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
UOF* bIWQ U_ w QD) WU WQ _ `UCI U& nU t UOF* c VOF
O?B?? r?O?? Q?D?) d?F uN `UCIK d WdbIs? W?O?zU?M W vK U Uu?J? c? Q?D?K WMU t UL WUO?B?? Q?D? WIKD bUI dF WOzUM W1d U
QD) qO s nu* UNOQ w WOzUM W1d dF WOBA nu* WOR Vub?L? XJ WHOuU WKB WM XU wBAW?LO W vK uD
p UNU b r WOB dF sJ1 ` UD_ iF d_ W QD) sBHM UOId QD) uJ b d WN s WHOu U s iF w tU rd U
w{UIK WdbI WDK u WUNM w p ld U(fi's?J?1 `U?C?I? d? b? d?N? w WOL d_ WF_ dOUF* w pKQ?D?) w?I?d?* Q?D) 5 eOOLK WdbI tDK V dOUF* c b v `uK w{UIK
fie q lzU V tU qU* eM w wBAfiWOLKF bzUHK ULdc sJ U UO d UOF bu dOUF* c VU
OId QD) dF bIF nu* tJ UUF U wHOu tKL ULN R t OB dF tS tD oOI Q WHOuUWOU lzUu iF nOOJ w b* QD U
Q?D bF tSO?B?? QD bF tS bIF* s bIF v `U bB U UQ? UtMfi'
U_ c wId* QD) wBA QD) 5 eOOLK wu{u U v ` uK r
oU bB* Uub XF bL fi l{u* fH oU bB* ULD ULOK fi 'fi' oU bB* UM R fi ' \fi'
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
s? l?OL qU vK lI e U S nu* qU vK lI c e u vK uIO?B?? Q?D? bF tUD w QD) S lL: dq?L?F? h?zUB s e U U U
OId QD dF QD) S UN jd wHOuUfi'Ue `UD UMN u{u b uLG sUOF* sc vK cR U W vK
O?B? bF UNO QD) WHOuU jd? U?M uM b q Uu?N ULOKFK UfiwHO Vu t r wB QD
WO Wb w rUE* `UC w wId* QD) u?d? b?N? v rUE* `UC c b9 U?J?( v?K? WUF WOzUCI WUdU
d sJ r pc WO WFdA tOK9 w b 5LK* u`UC u b$ U wM bN cM rUE*fiWuF WOdF WJKL* w uO v bF s
w?I?d?* Q?D?) U?N?M? d?N?E?M WO Wb w Xb w UUCI iF u u`UC UNU_ rUE* tM hA WOR wBA QD) tM Wb WORU ru uFd d_ _ w Wb WOR 5LC `UC vL iuFWb od s od dOO V rN XI( w d{_ s iuFU WUDLK rUE* w{U
qLF V qLF `UM od* c wHu s b QD fi'W?O?C? d?{_ i?u?F s Wb WOR r wId* QD) UNO d w UUCI s
d q UbM tM tK w{ bOu s bU bzUI UNK q bF W1c WKO s
oU bB* UM R fi ' \ _ UOF* VU u wLK U d b 'fiwU UOF* VU u w
`UCI b qOUL fi ' ' 'U fi dU b w UEM w `UCI u WOdF WCNM 'fi
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
M u?d dJM b uLK r tuU rN tM Uw? s wK q bU tKF U gO od s rN XI( w d{_ rNM ldO WKOI c v tM tK w{ VUu?_ s? r?N? V?O? U? `U?b? r?N? u? U?* t?F rNO Vc r W lb
VKJ WGKO s rN{u t v rNu s rN{ufitM vI c `Uu ' u?d? U?d?U? b? rUE* `UCI iuF W UIF rJ( c s hK
s b QD) c gO bzU s l c wId* QD) s WOR0 rJ tHMtHO V tKL WQ `UM tJ b wHu bfi'
e?e?Fb s dL WHOK) t rJ U `UG iuF W 5 lL& w UUCI sfiwuB WOC w tM tK w{
u d dL `U bILKE sLO s b q tUB BK Uw{ dLF UI UtM tK
uKE dO ubuKE dO ubuKE dO ubuKE dO ubuKE dO ub rJU UrJU UrJU UrJU UrJU U U bI U bI U bI U bI U bI FFFFF OOOOO bbbbb uKE b uKE b uKE b uKE b uKE b p U dL UI
fiwFO{ pK*b s bOu wMB qd UtKb vH tO bu 'Wb UJK2 q wuB db wM re U dL UI
d? VJO db s UNd re* UI fififi WFO{ pK*b s bOu=v WFOC CuF tIH nF{ t vDF wMLO cUfi'
UBU pK*b s bOu b c dIK ` UG W WOCI c s dNE WuM dO UA s 'flfi'aU b dUI fiWd_ WOKJ WJ ' oU ld* iuF ULD ULOK fi ' oU ld* U fi 'fi' W?OUDK UJ_ U* ' dJH ' ' W?OUDK UJ_ vKFu fi'
gU wK( wU vHDB dUM 'fi
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
WDK WDu `d ULF w d u dA dO odD d_ b UJK2fiW
UA bJ tI WUD* w tIH U nF{ qd `UD w iuF W dNE ULfitFO{ bI dH
I? w{UI o U2 ZMq?2 U*U uEM* ub lzU WdbI tDK Uo?d?* W?O?R??0 r?J t qLF V qLF `UM wId* QD) VJ W WDKW1c WKO w bOu s bU WKI s { c QD) c s X w d{_ iuFiuF qL% tM wB UN WO WKOI d s bbF q b v tD uu
fiWb fOz V tIH nF{ tCuF vMLO WFO{ d rJ( w WdbI WDK c C UL`d?A?U tUJK2 v WFOC c r{ w WOB `d UU rI r pK*b s bOu
Ud c UJ UNB tMJ wMLO s`d U b w d v WDKU c_ sJ1 c UOF* S pc iuF dU rJ( UJ UJKL* ` UHD w WLOK
O?I?d? Q?D? dF QD) w tIH bu q w t`U?M? nu* q s tUO - U*U UQD) s rKJ UbM d UOF* c CO od* dOO V qLF V qLF
fiWbK wU u; w tM WOR UM wBA
uF `UCI UJ w wId* QD) WN tJd c bIF QD) rUE* u q s iuFU UNO rJ w U( s`UIU uI UbM p wId QD QD) U vK 5UI* WNu w UI* U U2 WuIF* b* U b v WbI* WFb qUI UI* s bI* ULC UD
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
OId QD bF c dCLO Ud{ U2 UBK* d w dOQ tOK Vd UbIF w wU dDUfi'
WOR* u vK wMM wId QD u vK WR b w UJ_ s pcrJ( e UbM WdOBIWbK WB
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
p? W?F??? q?L?% U vK QA c w tUJ U b rUE* u uJ pct?M?O? W?O???? W u dC oI% uu 5F U/ QD) WN UJ dH U?A?M? w? d?B??M? 'W?F? qL% WdEM c oOD U WN qL 5
p tU U PAM* u dD WUS dA*fi'UC UNK s QD u vK iuFU XLJ w UJ_ sXU
Hu w XK9 d{Q U: UM* U WU v _ bF UOK U?C UNLO UH WU WIDM* s rNUM VU?d q s rNUM nA s
s uQ* WF qL% U vK 5b* iuF eK WN fififiUN 5KUF nu*QD u dC u WU( c w iuFK wHJ 'e dC Q WOdA bUI
WN sfi' WN q s 'rO QD) u vK XQ rUE* u UJ C o U2Y?O? W?F??? q?L% U vK 'wId* QD) XU UL fisdCLK iuFU rJ vdC b sJ QD UM sJ r u v qL d{_ s iuF WN qLW?F?? q?L??? w?U?U dA qLF uI XU u v d_U U XI(UJ s bM vK uI rUE* u UJ C p s dC oI% U*U c UNUL
fiWOKJ bu w tIH
WOR UM wBA QD) bb% WKJA wU u;Ud `wA vK rJ( U U*p WU wBA QD) uB sJ1 tS uB s
rd rUE* u rJ 'flfl WM oOu Wu fioU ld* ' rd rUE* u rJ 'fl WM oOu Wu fioU ld* '
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
wKLF lu w u Ub wId* QD) UuB WN tM Q c QD)Q?D?) p?c? W?d?H? h??A? W?OR UM U tu wBA QD) uB UMMJ1 pc
fiU tu WOR UM wBAv? d?C? t?O? V?M c qK) tQ wBA QD) UMd Wb Wb w o be??K? r? s? t?I?U? v?K? W?O?R?* lI TU) qFH 5 VJ c hA dOBI
ficU WUF rU; w WB
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
od* WNufi'tKLF od* ` b tKLF od* ` b tKLF od* ` b tKLF od* ` b tKLF od* ` b V U qLF UOI s lM9 UbM uB c qL
ULOKF l{ s UMU d_ VOB d{ nu* c vK Vd t UOI UNOKU?F? o?d?D? w? u?u* WOzUdNJ u; dD) UHK
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
Wb)fi'
wBA QD) s WOR UD L t rK* sWHOuU UN WK w UNOHu* WOBA ` UD_ s Q
fiUN Q w WUFv?N?? b?I? UNM W&UM d{_ s Q WOBA `UD_ s WHzU UM sJb nu* U bM dC* WUL w tM W UNM WOR v `UCI b?UI cN qLF v `UCI U& V tOK ud bM iuF qL% tbw? t?_ b?U?I c ib wKLF lu wBA QD) wId* QD) 5 qBH bUU?H? q?L?? s?J? b qF bu dC b w PD) dA b U( iF
F? sQD)b?u? w?U?M? b? p? UL sQD) 5 eOOL UOF u{ b VU c ULz R* u nu* uJ UbM WbFUO t UL U dOO QD) s iuF rO U
U?O? i?u?F rQ?D?) 5? l?L? v? `U?C?I? Q pc firO QD) s d UwId* QD) wBAfi'
w?B??A? Q?D?) s? W?O?R v wzUCI qLF t& d wzUC uD w t bO vCI wId* QD) du s Y v WU( b t WOM dC b s rdU
UNU_ UNLOK tO uNF* d* bd wU WU w WOR0fi'W?H?Ou uJ c wBA QD) s WOR0 vC t rJ( c vK k*
o?U bB* wLK uL fi wId* QD) u w l 'u?K( V bU fi ' oU bB*fi'
oU bB* wHM tKb fi 'fi' aU Ud w Wb fK rJ 'flfl Z bB* wHM tKb fi w uc '
oUfi'
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
`U?C?I? d? d UJ w t q tUJ U nu* b 5 XF{ w wfiqLF U u nu* tJ u v WOR* c
wK ULO Udc U b wBA QD) s WOR c cQD wBA QD) VU U WU OId U
u?J?O? w?I?d?* Q?D?) w?B??A? n?u?* Q?D? 5? u bM WU( c QAMUF ` UCI U WOU fi WNu w ` UCI U v_ Uu dCLKeK WU( c w 5d iuF vK uB( dCLK fO tH nu* WNu w
?U? i?u?FU Q?D?) u?F?H? V?U?M? U?0 n?u?* v?K? ud UN sJ1 p bF w QD q d W UO eM bM `UC p w qBH dC b w wBA
WOR* iNM dx sQD) dG dC suJfi'qLF `UM VJd* wBA QD) WU
W?O QD nu* VJd UbM p dC* uI( qC UL{ q s WU( cd?{ b?% q?LF `UM Wu UUO WOUJ UULC U bW?OR QAM
OB QD) U u dC* WNu w d UU iuF lb U dCLK iuF mK d nu* vK bF ULO ld r nu* U WOUJ b{ tMR vfi'
Q VJd* wBA QD) WU W?O?R??L? od* Q XU qLF U lI w 5Hu* `UD s Qo?d?* w?BA tD UJ w nu* b u rN dA WdA WOR* s uM c q qLF U l wBA QD) U u v tUDK tKzU
oU bB* uK( V bU fi 'fi' oU ld* qOK s fi uHB bF fi 'fiUbF U '
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
V u lI WU d w uHu* UNb w WUF UO u oKFd{VJ wB QD UMN wLd t s_ q tJd c QD) qI dOGK
vK WOR* u ld p r VM wId QD bu od* WUM0QD) VJ c nu* vK p bF uF iuF lbfi'
Is TUM iuF s WOR0 rJ( w{UIK sJ1 WIU UK UU? w?B QDq?L?F? `U?M? q?U?F? t?J wBA QD) U wId QD t
qLF UDK qG tKzU od* Q tUJ - wBA QD) U od* qfiqLF UD U u wHOu
w tIH w wBA QD) s WOR ? t?K?FH dC qB c u dU* qFHK dU* vK dC w tIH Vd
U d h qF qb WDfi'U?LC s R* u qFHK dU* S dP d{ b QD vK Vd Sw? u?J? p?c? d?C? b? w? u?_ dR* u dC WK u dU* _
dU* v rJ( nO{ V* dU* lL dC UL{ s WR*fi'd? dH p UB?? l? nu `U r odD w w d U
i wB QD QD _ lb u dU* vK uJ ULC S d{ tUQ dU dU* u c lb bu r U U dHM r tMJ nK v vC dH( _
oU ld* Uub XF bL fi ' oU ld* uK( V bU fi 'fi' ULC WdE wKOe W fi ' oA dJH 'fi U* ' d?zUEM U_ wuO WObF UJ_ WK s w?K( wU vHDB '
dzUEM U_ rO$ s wK( WR 'fiqOu eeFb oOI%
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
u? ? V??? U?d?H? s?LC w w S tHM d w hA jI fidU*
v?L?? U? u? q?F?H dU UbM UNb nu* tJd c QD) w V bd? b?? c u V* QD)l?I? n?K UF V `w nK v R
F5? q?K?? t?KFH nK qB c u U qU qFH d WDu U/ tM V* u U qF nK tKFfi'
sJ WOB WHB nu* UNJd w `UD_ q dC w W XU Uod* Q nu* tJd Wb) ` UM nu* tJd c QD) wId QD UNUB
uJ sJ1 `UD_ cNfiUNO U? XU d?O? R?? dO tuJ U UNO dU* 5LC cF tS UNO U
n?u?* s qFH 5 WD qK r b V* sLC UMN dF dO uuu?J? d?A? d?O?GU o( c dC nu* uJ dA dOGU o( c dC
Dd U nu*tKL WN Ufi'F V* dU* sLC bU Q dU* V u XUF U WU w p U
U?L?N?S? d?U??* q?F?H? W?O U dU*U qLF U U dHU qLF U2 VULC w UdAfi'
o?zU c UNKOGA bM dNE uO UN W1b UO UM U u U p U oU bB* wKOe W fi 'fi' wd u* o U uLC w 'fld?OA cN* 'aU b dO WdF* '
fl bG UULC lL 'aU b wU vO 'fi'aU b WdO) WFD* ' ozUI( 5O wFKe 'flwub WOU dOJ dA 'aU b dO WdF* '
fl W?b? s? wMG* 'aU b wK( wU vO WOdF VJ `UO 'fl' dUI bb WUH WFDfi
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
B?? f? tMJ tU b_ WU WKB `UC w V UO Q UMN U? UNHudU tHu ozU Q Ur? w fHM tIKF iuF R
fip bF ozU vK uFbLF r sU{ dU* o U Wdu wId* QD) sLC U '
bF bLFU sLC V* wId* QD) d tOfi'U?N?OHu b s QD) U u WO Wb U dU* WOR UIOD sW1c wM WKO w WKI bOu s bU q UbM Ud o U wB QD tQ nu
u?d? t?M? d U u tM wB QD vK `UMi?u?F vKI W XKL% 5LK* uM UNHK w u_fi'
C? p UIOD s Ut? t?M tK w{ eeFb s dL WHOK) v UJ r dA dL t{uF b td 5LK* gO UN dL t{ w Ufi'
d? U?b?M? g?O? b?zU? u? U?N?UL b QD s Wb WOR b p s CW?b? X?K?L?% p?c? t?O? Q?D? w?B?? d? p? u? _ c? s d*U uM
fiiuF
uF `UCI UJ w wBA QD) s WOR WOdA WOFd* _ wdH dB* tMd s uE d uF ` UCI dFbu w tUJ_ UM bu w{UI U bF pc WU_ ` dU eOL tUJ_
U* 'fiWObF UJ_ WK s U* 'fiWObF UJ_ WK s WuM dO UA s 'flfioU ld* ' d) nu u ' dUI WOHK WFD* 'fi
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
b?u?I? t?u? W?M? t?K? d? s UJ wN D UNuA ne UNOQ WLJfiVc* tI w WOKJ
t? b?$ w?B??A QD) s WOR0 oKF ULO rUE* u UJ v udUO o UL wId* QD) s WOR*U UI* `UCI s dOG cQ]s p UM
C dN Wb w _ u; vMF0 WF qL% b dJH cQ t U QD s "UM iuF qL w wS WF qL% uNH u c _ t U U
UL_ s ` u iuF ` vK b_ UN_ UN 5KUF ` UD WF qL w w U?c?O?HM rI r s UB W dI WU*w?Id* QD)U '
fi lU nu* s tK wB QD u vK uI WN q s QD UM sJ r u iuFU t UJ w vC rUE* u ULWOR0 rJK rUE* u U& bR U u QD dU
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
iuF dbI X bb% WKJA YU u;W Ub w `u iuFU rJ( uJ UbM `UCI U WOKLF JA* s
dE iuF dbI X WOR* U u v UN X s dOG UHK* rO _ w?I?d?* Q?D?) `d? d?C b s uM bF bB b c wzUCI rJ( b
u UUU tM Q c wBA QD)fiUU? i?u?F??U? w?{U?I e w UEM d b iuF dbI w WUF bUI
bq?L?F? U?U?S? d?C s iuF bI wUE h UM U S rEM* q s UbI hI U w WdbI WDK pK1 wLOEM dbI cN eK w{UI S
hMU b; iuFfi'b?I? u?J iuF w WUF bUIO?MO uJ u sJ r?J( uJ Q U
d?A?* dO qLFU qB 5F d `Q rJ dC q tOK XU U v U( USCuF dF d Ud{ uJ b c dCK U uMF UUfi'
vK rJ UF `UCI `UCI w `u w{UI vK lM1 t bO?O qLF ?O?Q? 5?F d ` u UNNu U`U?C?I? s? I b vK U
b?I? u?J? dC s iuFt?u? s? d?EM dB dC d p `uU U uMF Uc? _ WbbN WdG vK rJ lOD w{UIU U
`u? u?% b?U?I? c? s?J? 5?F? q?L?F UOI vK dU dO odD UU UMF 'iuF oU bB* ULD ULOK fi ' oU bB* UdA UF fi ''
`UCI w jOu UM nU fi WM wdF dJH 'fi U* h uLC 'flfidB* wb* uUI s
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
v?K? Y?( d?? q?O??? c? w? w?{U?I pK1 wMOF iuFU UNH e c vK `UM dF wdH `UCI U( iF w tOKC_ wMOF iuFU? d? `Q? d?Q? w{UIU q s U `b UM uJ UbM bUIv?K? b?F?? v?M?F qL% dO WU s U* `b t nB U* tOK XU U v U(
rNUd d_ uI UEMfi'dC dOUF WU du bF W WORLK dQ iuFU rJ( UM u dC
L?U? u?J? b dCU iuFU UB rJ( w sFD r v q?F s U b? d?C? o?? U?L? W?O?R? UM wBA QD) wId* QD) s `u
dU uJbR uJ dA UL iuFU rJ dU dO U S QDK WOM IIOUL U S UC iuF UU dC uJ V UrNUOQ d dH U
U?U U Sd?C? u?J? Wb w UEM tOL ed0 q b uJ iuF UuIMU dbIK fi'
w? p? v?K? i?u?FU rJ( bM w{UI UNOd b WIU dOUF* ciuF S U* dC dbI oKF ULO WKJA W dO uIMU dbI WOKU dO p
bI dbI UJ0 w{UI U WuN s tMuMF* dCU oKF ULO u WKJA* sJ UuL ` UCIUnu tUM WuF WOdF WJKL* w dB w Ud w ` u U
r?J?( vK WUNM w d_ dI t bO dC s uM c s iuFU oKF ULO bbfiuM c w uIMU dC dbI WOUJ iuFU
oU bB* wHM tKb fi ' \ dB w ` UCI rJ 'flfl Z fi' oU bB* UM nU fi ' oU bB* wHM tKb fi ' fi'
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
U? t?M? U?u?A? s? UNB U dU r VOB U tM uMF* dCC? t?M? W?FL `c dF p U dA dF VOBu?FA VOB U U
Vd r u tOK bF* dCLK XU o vK `bU jd U tM WHUF UM(t U d{ U( `b c vKfi'
iuFK w{UI dbI dOUF tDK d w{UI S iuF bI b c wUEM hM bF WU ww u_ iF bOI WDK UNMJ cOHM WOHO iuF mK dbI w WFu WdbI
u_ c s wzUCI aU UL w Uc dC `UCI UNOK fid) q v p w ud r dC bI0 uJ iuF i?u?FU rJ q_U rJ( t wb* tK U2 bQ rJ w{UI
r?N?M? d?C? w? 5?dA* 5 iuF `V lu uI t pc vCI UM UfitH dC*
dC b0 iuF dbI bM dFU QD)U fO dC c jd iuF fiO fJF dO d{ rO QD) s ZM bI tb QD) WU fO
v?? wId* QD) uJd bF ULN 5CuF vK uB( t u dC* QD) VJ c nu* vK ud t u iuF ` Q XU S wBA
fitO V V?? s? tU U U s dC* o( U iuF dbI bM wd w{UI
w?{U?I?U? t? b?B? tUO d dOOG w dC dOQ b WOBA dC* WU 'e UB jOu uNM db fi ' wdF d `UO 'fi
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
Od iuF bIW* dE p w Ufi'iuF dbI X
V?? s? tU U U s szb o( U qLA w{UI q s iuF dbI bMtU WOBF WOB tU dC* hA W* dCU WDO; dE Ud li?u?F?? c dbI X ld tO w{UI bO d) q p ld WOU* WOKzUF
UuM Xu uJOWUB U{_ p qFH u Xu fO rJ( b uO rJ( X dC dbI cF WbF dQ U dC* qL WbF s fO dOG
qLJ v dC bb% UJ 5 v XR iuF rJ( Ufi'`UCI U dC u uO fO rJ( b uO iuF bb% w dFUu?O? i?u?F?? d?b?I? _ dC u uO iuF dbI bM rJ se s d U b`w? q?J? U?F_ UH u se c w VUGU WbF bu l vUL rJ( bb? r?J?( b? `U?C?I? U? `U 5 dO WOM d u uIM WLO UH
L?J? w{UI b S WU* rOI c wd w{UI vKU w iuF u w t U U w wb*U o( d{ s I tS U? UU( Ub uJ
dO 6dO XFH UF_ _ U 5 U WbF s tS pc rJ( b uO iuF w{UI bIfidB Ud w ` UCI t cQ U c '
oU bB* ULD ULOK fi ' oU bB* uK( V bU fi ' ' oU bB* UM nU fi U* h dE ' U* dB* wb* uUI s fl
fiiuF dbI bM rJ( w w{UI WDK s ULKJ bI pc oU bB* wLK uL fi ' fi' o?U? bB* wHM tKb fi 'd?O? U?NUL s Wb WOR UB U dU fi '
iuF `UC fiWbUF WOdF WCNM UbF U 'fi
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
U?N? r? w WIdD iuF dbI WOHOJ oKF ULO WdbI WDK pK1 w{UIW?d?H?? U?F? v?K? b? W?F? i?u?F mK lb rJ tK iuF l
F?? iuF WId 5F c u w{UIUs?b?* t eK c bIMU bI dEK UOd' sb* s b c XMF szb U c dC bI p w U'
W?O?R?? p? s? U? t?u WdOBI WOR* w WUF bUI u wU* iuFUC WdOBI wMOF cOHM u UNO q_U WbUF WOR*
i?u?F?? w? q?_ 5?F d `Q rJ( tOK XU U v U( US d_UG?K? uJ`e? w?Q? u? W?d?OBI WOR* w U* s Ut?{d?H? e vK dK
iuFU ` Uu vK U dA V dOGU d{ bF e u UEMu_ lOL w bIMfi'
w tIH w iuF dbI X w UL tMOF `wA u rbM q_ iuF dbI X w Vc* `UNI nK
uu U VBGbI b?? v UB tS tN tMOF `wA cF U tOK OK U q* uOLO U WLOI UWLOIU iuF U ULO `UNIH U
UUH UJ* Ue U ` UO_ rO {UH `wA U ULO uHK UL UuBG iuF qHK UfiU
u?B?G?* 5? q?O?B?H?? v?K? i?u?F dbI X u `UNIH tO V U WKL dcwK ULO nK*
u* p vMF w 'fl fidB* wb* uUI s I?OKF dB* wb* uUIK WOUC dc* ' U* vK Ub?B* wLK uL fi w uc
oUfi'
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
wHM( Vc* w wHM( Vc* w wHM( Vc* w wHM( Vc* w wHM( Vc* w O?K?? uBG* U X? t??L?O? V?& tS u t fO u_ s lDI U
fiVc* `ULK 5 tO WLOI dbI`b dC* q s VKD X t_ `UCI X uJ WLOI v Vc WHOM u
fiWuB)V???U? V U/ `wA nK _ VBG uO WLOI bI v Vc nu u
fitu uO WLOI bI VBG u q_ b cXu t_ u_ s q* UDI X w bI WLOI v Vc s( s bL
fiq* ` s eF tO b cO?LO uBG* U U?H? d XUH u_ w q t fO UdF Ufi
`ULKF 5 c wHfiVBG u V& WLOI WHOM u
fi`wA N u V& WLOI UUB UH nK u WLOI tO V& nK* Vc* `ULK 5 Ufi'
wJU* Vc* w wJU* Vc* w wJU* Vc* w wJU* Vc* w wJU* Vc* w OK VBG u tLO V& VBG w OLO UfiU
N u tLO V& nK* fi'
u?* oU bB* wd 'fl o?U bB* wFKe 'fllzb wUUJ ' lzUMBfl dB0 WOUL WFD ' WM 'fi
WONIH 5uI e s 'dbK dOJ dA 'aU b dO b s WU WJ ' oU bB* wub WOU gUNfl oU bB* qOK Vu UD( 'flfi'
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
wFUA Vc* w wFUA Vc* w wFUA Vc* w wFUA Vc* w wFUA Vc* w O?K?? uBG* U s? q??* U?D?I? u? v? V?BG u s t WLO vK V& tS U
fiVBGU bF* d u_OLO uBG* U finK u v VBG u s t WLO vK V U
OK U nK u tLO V& nK* OLO UUfi'wKM( Vc* w wKM( Vc* w wKM( Vc* w wKM( Vc* w wKM( Vc* w
OK uBG* U fiu_ s q* UDI u tLO V UOLO uBG* U WLOI u X v VBG u s t WLO vK V U
fiuBG* U UL{ WKUM( nK u tLO V& nK* fi'
ddddds? W?LO vKQ iuF dbI V t WKUM( WOFUA tO V U VBG w
L bF*U WUJ WLOI X u_ s q* UDI u v VBG XvK fit
fiVc* UH u nK uO WLOI bI UHK* w
uF `UCI UJ w iuF dbI X QD s iuF dbI X bb% w WF WdbI WDK w{UI pK1
U?; wMG VOD) wMOdA 'fl d?B0 wK( wU vHDB 'W?UN wKd U;fl oU bB* cN* dOA 'aU b WO WJ* 'flfi'
wMG* Wb s 'flU?M?I UA wuN fi'aU b WOdF WuNL WJ dUM 'flfi'aU b Wb( dBM WJ '
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
W?O?N?I?H? V?c?* w? `U?L?K?F? ` W?D?K c UD dOGU oK d{ s tM rM Uc fJF WJKL* w rUE* u UJ WO WFdA UJ vK fR* UN
wK U p s Vc* w WONIH `U c_ UNM C bb UJ wH WJK*rUE* u rJrUE* u rJrUE* u rJrUE* u rJrUE* u rJI uJ uIH* u* s iuF I fO bIH bM UNLOI UU
W?U? w? t? v?K? `U?N?I?H? u?N?L oH b VB bIH _ bUF bM UNLOI u UJ w WLOI dF VB fi'
w eM q uIH* u* dF tO w WLOIU iuF dbI X rJ( s CfitO bI c Ue UJ* w ub
tU U U s dC* o( UL uJ d{_ s iuF tM C d rJ wQD p s fiub ` UC t cQ rK WKL; d{_ s iuF U V s
W s dQ bIF WLO iOH qLF s WOb* UI s XU WNdQ r fififidU WOKF d{ s tU UL UI* iuF Vu c UBK* d
diuF w UI* WOIQ vCI fififiWKL; U_ s iuF vK ub UJ d) ddI b cfi'
`UD s iuF s WJKL* w `UCI t cQ U bR oU rJ( w dU* WII; d{_ s uJ tOK uH WOU U wb*U oKbR U
& rK WOUL d{_ s iuF UdfiUNO WUNK rUE* u UJ t UC ub UJ sd{_ wU* iF W w UND) iuFU WN e
L?U bF t_ _ U s wb* iuF t wb*U WU) U WIKF*U rd rUE* u rJ 'flfl WM fioU oOu Wu rd rUE* u rJ 'flfl WM fioU bB*
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
C q tOd UNO V w d{_ s uF pc QD) w s t vb U* UM?O? uJ UL iuF _ tOK XU U v U( US eK WNb?I uJ Ub
CuF wbLK WN bbI UlI tS pc p vK wb* o d{_ s UCuF wb* o pc fififitOK XU U v U( U b tIU vKU bM d U
I? b?I iuF _ `UMb?F? t?K?L U o W bN bM u UF_ UUNzUM U pfi'
UNL WOzUCI U* iF tM C rJ( cd?C? V?U t dC UI w dC* WLU b iuFU rJ( bM vd t
fi tO X c dC b vK iuF uJ pc WN tM Q cq?? t?O?K XU U v U( US UNeK r bIM iuFU e rJ(
uL `UCI tOK d U c _ WN QDfiUI U iuFU rJ( tI( c nK u wULK bN bM u UF_ U
bI WLOI S WONIH Vc* w `UNIH UL tOK d U u wb* pK0 WNfinK uO
rd rUE* u rJ 'flfl WM fioU bB*
b wu U{ fi
bF ? d lO '
W9U)tUOu tzU r UO wK ULO lKD Y c uD w o U s
tUIOD s UEM tOL U V bI eU ` e u iuF t?M? Q?? nu* tJd c wBA QD) WN q s wId* QD)
u UNHuUL s u* WOR UFU tKB w{UIK sJ1 c wBA QD) U 'tfiVu ` w dOBI WO 'WOB WOR nu* tM QO WHOu UL s
UM UM b wId* QDK b UOF vK dI r `UCI d Q wId* QD) bb% r UNO WNu* UI r dOUF Wbd w{UIK UNM
t?M? Q?? c? w?B??A? Q?D?) wId* QD) 5 qBHK WdbI tDK UL bM UNfiWdOBI WOR
b w WOR q u wBA QD) wId* QD) s "UM dC C Q UL tFU UL s u* WOR WdOBI WbI WOR uJU
OQ UNJK9 w ` UO_ qF s "UM dC sQ UNU w dH QD u vK UfiWdOBI WOR
b t s? w?B QD u vK fQ c wId* QD) s iuFU rJ ud qF UL rOU_ vK UNUL WO WbfitM tK w{ bOu s bU l
oKF ULO WONIH Vc* t cQ U vK tUJ fR uF `UCI UOK* w nK u bIM iuFU rJ( rO U tu d{_ UHK* s iuFU
fi`UNIH UL u UL UOLOI
uF `UCI U iuF u w WOKLF JA*
bF ? d lO '
O?U? `U?C?I? U?J w wU* iuFU tO rJ uMF* dC r Ui?uF d uMF* dCU w tIH w U pc cQ r oU w td
fitJd R cF U/ bIMU?? b?I? w?H?M( Vc* w 5UBU bIM iuF d s `UNIH s bOv
d? w? w?J?U?* W?d s s UL b WuJ u UA w r_ uVOD d wU dG bI tO fO cfi'
d UL uMF* dC s iuF u v ub; ` UNIH bM d c vKdeF w b UL lL: w bzU dF dC WLO V bI rU( v uu
fiU*U UL vK WUd qIF lOM* WbF sB WJKL* w ` UCIU VON UM
) U U?U?C?I? u? V?? U?NHOMB bF UuL w WOzUCI tzU b u UDfiVCM s d u c u*U `UCI c uL vK bU dO uJ v
5*UF tK bL( Uu dfit t vK bL tIK dO vK tK vK
oU bB* u* wd 'fl oU bB* UULC lL bG '' wU bF w d wLKF Y WK WM 'WFU WFdA WOK UbB
fidI