مذكرة تكميلية بدفاع للمحكمة الدستورية العليا 1

bull bullbull

bullbullbull

bullbullbull

~~

frawr mwt ~oJlio~middot~

It Ilfl rrea y~ itJ rr~

4

r ESe iii a hey eI tIIM

ISe ~ IIM PI II1fr

bullbull

bullbull

- L

U riztlll

bull viJllltamp ~ I+JI ~ rJJ ~ul ~ rLoi toJil1 ~IjJ os4t ~Qi~ J+w

wI

4oSJ4 ~ul ~ vi J J-~ oltamp ws4t o~ 1oSll1 ~1H ~IjJJ ~wJ

rJAi - ~JJI ~t~o sljiJ IoS~JJI J~ JAi - 4) ~lloSi)4 1~wJi ~I ItJJlwJJI

-lJ y y rlJ vYlif tl lii1)1 loS JtI r~4 ~IgtH ~lgtij~1 IJJJI JJIJgt ~JJlwJ

oLolgtoJl TLi1 JtlLJ ~IjJ~1 tojSgtJ1 rljJlJ TIJI ~~4lgtij1 IJJ ~ vi ~ y t w~ sly JI ~ 1oSll1 loSi)1 rJ ~ ~I ~I ~~ y ~ pl Iltamp ~~ jlJ

~Ili JI ~I ~ 1oSllIJ IoS~JJI ~J4 ~ loSi)1 ~1Jt~ 1oS~ ~ ~J JtIIoS~JJI ~ ~JJI

- ~~~ IUj dyJ ~ eilyl ~~Lgt y~IJ ~~ js ~~~ OJlJl y

jJIamp C i~ 1d ~aU w JampiiiL ~ I6i lJ ~

J~ rJAi ~JJI v~ ~ul ~ rLoI ~Jill ~IjJ os4t ~~ ~ 1-5 ~Jfo ~1Jt -

~I y~~ bJpl ~JJlwJJI ol~J ~ ~JolJ oLl14~J1 ~~Ib ~1Lij~ IoS~JJI

- -ulgt J- - - q ~ -l tL - I lt-tt Llo I bullbull tl 1_- -tl - -9JJIIltamp I bullbull t jjJ4 - ~r-- - J J r- ~ --- tJJ ( ~ shyM

tltamp ~ ~I ~I Lo Jogtl ~ iiJlJlJ ~Lw ~ylJ y~1 js rlilllltamp ~ ~ 1oSllIJ lA~

IoS~JJI J~ rJ$ JI rJ ~ J~tgtJ - ~I ItJJlwJJI 4oSJt ~Wti ~ 1oS~ LoJ - viJ1

bull 4- ~~4 IJgt J~ ~ ~J ol~J ~ iiLl1 4~J1 ~JJI ~ ~lAij~

IoS~JJI ~ ~JJI ~o sly rJ ~ ~ul 4~~ ~ ~I JLIIoSll1 ~t)1 v~ Lol -

~ UQi$ ~lUl~- utgt ~ - ~ ~ I+JI ~JI ~I y~~J ~Jtl

~~JJI J1JJ4 J)J Lo JJJgt ~J ~ ~Jtl ~JJlwJJI IoS~JJI ~ ~JJI v JI pl yAj

~Iy ~ 1oS~ vJIJoOS ~ Jb oII)1Jgt v~ - ~~ Ji ~~tIJ ItJJlwJJI

M f~ M fer ~--rftySt -l ~ltf ero fl(CII M

I~~~ M ~r I I~~ I~ Iwomiddotmiddot 1Mgt ~ 15 IfOTl I-u -

1lFl5 iYrJ rlinl I~ I~t ~ Mf T~ ~1r9-r ltT oyf1r1 I~

1~Ct I~t ~~ I~n 1gt fo-r~ -1 Irri~ I(rr I1J ~If~ ~it

fl~ -q( Irrli( ~mrg (~) ~t1ti ~ If 1~rrlCt ~ fn rti r r~(~

~~~lripound fUlt(rI tn~ie ~Iflef bull

It1n 11t(iai e I~ ~~fCJ Ol ~ ltgt1J Irr~( frf11 ~ ~fI lri~ ~

I~~~ 61wr fo firl 1 I1J Irr~ rlo ol~fl hw ltO~ I~~~ ~ ~

~~rrI i-r f1 Ifl~[+rl I~~~ r~I( lt i e tfO~r rl(Tflt -1 lt r

M ltiTlt) ~~ f --r ( ( o-tI (n M

gtltT 1~5 ~UTI ~~ ~lmiddotmiddot 1tmiddotI fl atmiddot I I~r ~ I~ICrI

rsfPlt ~1r1~ 0 ~ tTP Ofcm ~ -0 1 ~Un~ f1 Mlt+9j ~ ~ p

1r1~ orrfl hw ffr I~I~~~r4orf1 frw ir ~I~rS r~(~

61m5 (1( (~ I~Ir-fl ~~rrI (~ () O~ ~t Irrg ~~~~

f~i~ frr15 -1 1 WJ fn gtIt Irr~ fC lf1J rlo If~~crri ~trr r ir ~

ltie IrrS Irrli(~ ~~(M ~~~rrI ~1r1~ bull

lri~ f~ rJ f ~1 wro I~ ~I~ ~ 1-1( I~ fgto Irr~ r ~~S ~~~ 1~ rJ ifi r~f(lpound rJ S 1~ ~r ~Irr~ fo-r~g ltrf(P

~

Irrli(~ r l~ht ~S it ~r~it ~Im~ fC (lrr Irr~ 1f ~ fC r

0 bull ~ ~ltro~ r Mt 1~rI~ ~~( 1~5 ~1r1~ 61rl gtI~ tf(lpound IrrS

~ Irrli( fUt~ ~91~ ~ltf- (1( (~ I~1rrrt1 ~~rrI (~ ( )

Im(~ rI~g IM~ f~~wr-CJ 0(1 ~I~~~fln~ ffl ~mrg (w )

~11rl= -f~ ~[f-rITo 1lT~ ~rg~i fi~g ~ Ir-rI~ rm== I~=r

ltt oil( ~flt I~~IM~S ~r~la -rltjl ~I( 1~1i I~~) I~rl r tr lltrr-r ~~rrr rir rfiJ 1lT~ ~~r~ If ITIoS ~ If ~I( ~9l~ f f4 rgt= ~a I~f4 rl1deg1 ~[~ fI=~If rl ~r-e ~ fgtI~ frlr Irr~)

lrffJ I= a1( r TI Im~f ~= ~~~~Mr iTfp fi~ ltffP Iri~

-M bullI= lerr TI( TI Im~ ~1lT~ rr Mfa Irrrr Ie ~sf ofl f~

1 ~r~11C1oS iYrJ rr Irr~) [cIoS ~1l1lT~ ~tltf 71

rf= I= rgt= ~~1-e ~i~fi~g f4 coS rr-rlrre n I~~p)oS IfOlt~ Irr~r~ )bull

f~ ~ ~= I~I~ If) Uli TI( I~rgtr ofl I~r-rrJ r1ir~ Irrl~

( 0( gt0 r Irr~) r rJ rn A~ r r~r~~ 0I ~ A (fI 0 )

~fI== I~Irr~r~

~= I~[ rffl~ 11C17 ~1r4~Irr~r--1Ifrltn rl ~iYr f~rl gt~ ~ ~

~~r ~iilrl ~sTr1 ~Ifl~ [ltfIt+J Irr~r tKIoS rc~ i[l= e~ [f-rITof I= bull

~~ 1~(fI Ul=~ I~ (WI ~tn rrr~r ~I[Oltgt~ Irr~r~ Irll ) f~

fr ~I Irl= ~IfOlt~ Irr~r~ = -( [Fltfr lerr = rgtr ofl ~M ~~r

[nr ~a Iffl~ ) rrf If rr+1 f~rSIMi I~alfrl

Irrl~ f ltn rl ~iYr I~r Ifl~ m=cf1 ) f[ noii -gtc1 JjJ -I~Imrr

TI III [Wf91 I== I~Irr~r--1 Udeg-r fwf I~r rfl~ 11C17 ~r~r~

f~llf) r ~~lt-on f~frrfr iorl~ r= I~l I~ ~= li~ IfltiT wf

Irrf~ ) flrlt1r gt~ ) oyrf~ r~~~fI== ~rfl1 I~r~ ~Irfl~

O~ A iT~ Im~[~~ ~Irfl~ lrcr-= ~11 ) f~ ~rgt= Irr~) Irr~r--1

r~Irltr~ fl[~r I~r~ l~r ~If~11 1 r ffr i lrrlr rrJ rn

Im== ) (IoS gtI= ~ rvsr gtI 1J r ~vo ) fr-o T~~e~ ~lrffJ ~~(

vt ~Iflr 1l~(I ltr( r11~ mlti-p bull

tlrtfr -1(llrrP lyrrS yJ fr Irr~S 1~~ o~llt1lrr~ IM~ r-cr ~o

~OA 1 -( (I~ tff vt rf( Il~ ) bull

fltf tl ( i-tr( Il~ I~y VV ~~ loogtl~ If l I~(I

tl --fi rltr- Irr+ I~H1 y ltj~ Ifr(ll~ 11~ 11~ri ~

l~ gt1(1 Irf F (( ~Irrlf oyrr~ IS 1(1 si oyrr ~bullbullbull ~ l~

n gt1(1 Im~ 1 ((0 Irr~ ~i ~Io 1(1 f ~ Im~~Irrlf bull HAAA

Ji M ~6 ~ (M ~tff f --I rJ ( - r1 ~-liM 10 Irr 1 1middot 11 ~1-M l1i Irrl f bull

~Irr(~ 14)~ 1r1~ rrrleg I~~-( 1e9 I~ r~Irt ~~

IM(I ~~J o-ltI~ I~1r-1r llgtIf ~~Irrle gt1(1lrr~ vt ~(I

-1 rfgt I~~ 0Cflt Irr~ r~S Irr~(~ Ifl~ (1 Irr~ ~~11l~(I f

( I~1f1( rIrr~S (ri ~ ~~ r ~(~ lt-rl ~IA I bull A)

If~~Ircrltl ~~Ir~ bull

Iryen~ ~ r(I yen(I I~ r 1T1~ Irr~(~ lrtl tlTi r 1poundTri~ Iryen~ yen fl (ifr Irr~S Irr~(i1 1(1 0TICf+l 1(1 yen(I ~1 ( ~i ~~I~lt1 rIrr~S

-~ 1(1 I~~r F1~ IfOgtOl Irr~(~ 1Mi 1(1 I~l~ I~~IMyen WT

rrT~ bull

1poundTri~ lrcrltl ~~Ir~ 4)0-lt 11S ~~I~Il I~i IMyen

J f1(1I~ r~(~ 11l~(I (ri Amiddot A~ bull A IM(I ~f ~r IS I~~~

~tmiddoti im~ Icrt (ri ~O-A~--~~11r1 (II iri~ I~S vt f f

-~~ ~ ~slt~ ~slt f1~ lri~ (lIpoundTri~ Iryen~ rr( ltfr ~

forle91~9r~~WJ f bull

-Q shy

bHL~i~ rQ ~I~ b rl~ lr91 CjCI~ r laquobC Irr-r1 bft1tn fltgt10 biQ I~

Irr-r~ 1-2 FTlt1 III~ bllfl~ ~ IQ IF~ M ~ISQ IIITtiQ I~~

-bS k-li~ f ~I I~r fo-t I~rrlf1 b1 I~I1 rli-rl rQQ l~g ftn

I~S1~ b1 ~IP -c~ sr Irlt~ ~rf--H bi~i Ir-Cb~ Irr~~

f ~I I~(f ~KClr cnr IFf 1 rr10 b~11rlt lblillrrr 1Q ~o

-Ir~~ lrefb) 1 0([ Fv IfIi f 1lS lil~~ I~ 11 1~ (11 rbl Irrltso~

f 1-- -fiT 1--ti bull

f~r~Ir cnfr gt1 ~~lrrl~ lrii-re ~Ird ll1t shy

~IrarJ f I~

~-IM f 1il~Q IF~

)-IMf 1il~Q IFnt

]-IMf Im~Q IIYSmiddot

A_ IM f HI~Q IF~~middot

1-IM f Im~Q Irr~ bull

-IMf III~ mn If~Q I~nslr brllt-t 1F~lr

-IM 1il~Q Irsi If~Q I~~Ir brllt-t 1F~lr bull

l~ -IM 11 ~ 1l1~Q IrS bITQ Ir~Q I~nslr brl lt-t 1F~lr

IbF-~FrJ ~

In~ 1 rf shy

~lti6J7 Irr~si b~o ltil F ~I rQ WCO I1SO b~Ir ~-SI blr Wr( ~ 0- bull 4o4o I ~1

k-I~ rtlaquo L 5~1 k-l1lr~Ji Ir(C ~S~ CI1IW ~r IF~ 1l1~t ~IF~Q ~rfi -r~lrrJS middot

- shy

bull bull

Nonf c(r Ul~ I~O --sf bq ~~~ ~INltn Irr~(~ Irr~ e ~

Ifflt-e -sf Irf~Irr~(~ l o ~eJ oii1 ~ilr rtMtlt ~j~ ~1~-e shy

M ~U~~ Irryenrlf 1m -

Irr~(~ U-r r~~1 - bull ~ tlt b1 foaor1 ) lpoundfl~ blrrl~ blfrc ~r4rJ ~~lrir$~ 1ft r(+llfOgto e1m blrgt~e

(~I~Il~r bl~lkf1ft irOi1IrgtO Irr~(~ 1m r(flt-e r~(~

~tlt tI ~ b ~ - --tI _1t1 QrIl I 11 --n11 1 10 1gt1 1- 1T1 11 ~lt1 1 bull

r4~Q ~oicr7 ~ fK ~( ~il 1 ry rl--r gtf ~ ~Q fi l

wo 1rl9 -r ImM1 1ft er-e Ir-r~ Icr ftYr2 a1~ M ~rr f (I -rj ~~6 ~ ~~-JI ltf~ M Il 1 ~ ~Irv-~ ~ ~h- 1middot 1 ~r If ~ t-I W

b~lkf~lt+J+l bWi~1 bull

~~ ~~ bull Krt -Go (~~t bull ~ft - ruth II I ~ 1 I it CWl 1 bull gt1 I~r 0- rim r I

~lyenr ~~Q ~ fj~ ~~If2 Irnr~ 1ft poundI~~ ~oofl~ l

M bt 1Z1 r I~tlt Irr~(~ l ~ ~irr-I~ gt10M ii( 1 ~

il ~~( CW I~ l b~Ifl~~ bull

r-o b1J ~~) blgt1J Irr~( lt09-1) ~lry b~foaorJ Irr~(~

1~1 INltn Irr~(~ ) btyr If~ 1poundltgtOe ~rb1 ~I~tlt 1M fH1 l

Irr~(~ l 1~fiJ oii1 ~ilr rtMtlt fl~~ ~1~-e -r twef rcmiddotJ9llff7 r M bt Ifflt-e 11m~ 1ft i1~1 I~Irr~(~ 1m r ~r I~~

i~ it1 S1O ~mI~ Irvft ~rl1i( ~( if+llr17 bull

b~Clt1 1fC1i( bl~ bltr ~bco-Cr-c b~If ~t IJTltS0 t ~~~J 1fC1i(rr ~ (shy

~ ~~J r1i(i1 I~ Im~~ Ib I~~ i~ i1 S1t Irrtol~ (TQ C1Tf I~

fj lt1( tlln I~middotj~ t ~fIi) ~Q ~-01 1t1rr-~~oaltr(

Irrn 1~1 I~~i-i1 o-fl(~ Ir--rr IMlf iT I~MJ bull

~M~O(g I~ 01 fIJf rm~g ~ISi-c M( t~~r9 I 01 gt1fl ~ ~ ~

rk-1lriOlg -O-sf yenG -tp 1J IfOltgt~ Irr~(il uTi -~rk-t 1rr lt101

~lIP hS eI~ ~ shytrr~G (rJ J ~AA r (~(il-~A ~ bull A

Irr~( 10 ~Wl I~~I~~ ~~1~(2 Ol~

4~ i1 -Of utfJ 1~lkfuf~(il ~llmt I yent f flrr 1T1(g IM~go-c bull

o~ ~J J ef1 -sf IPlto~ o~( ~o~ O~fn (Ot 1t ~-sf Irn~ 10

fj~J I~gItltf II~( ~~it ~oIr if poundltrf 1Ti~ Ir-ltO~ n~ ~g

yen~n i1 gtIt f f( 11 ~10((0 r Ir I~t ~r-e-rr o-c (r ~I~~

1~~MIrlto1~ OtgtfWl ~IS rffllS roiIr~ OltI T1 r-e-rr ih o-c Il~J InoG

I~114il ~ Imcrn I~ ~re I~iT Irk-r 1~-1~ I~(0- yen( ln

9l1t I~~ it ~I~ rlt-Jr ~I~r~~w4~ O~fII ~o

I~~(rJ ~A1~ (~(il ~J DDlt-A(~(il~A

Irr~(

Strs m gtI~ I~~I~t M ~-sf gti ~ fl~ iT ~~OIltgtlJbull

Ir-n1n Irr~(il trs It ~o 1(0lt gt i~rt1~ (fIe ~-(f(9t jI 0 ~t

J o-f~ (htlr ~~ fI~~ ~~~qt~ rcmiddotJ1 If~ 42 ~

91 ~it Ifl~ I~~I~ rt1~Wl ~Q IfOgt ~t Irlt~ Irr~(il I

(Irr~G (rJ ~~ D r (~(l-~J VJDD)

rgtft o+((g -Ol~ ~I yent 1rrltflS irH1I~f1~ 10 I(~I~ ~~I-M

~-Of~ (I~ Oil(~ I N(( Ifff ~ il ~O(2 ~~i-i1 -It-

-v shy

rvr~ ( ~t-Il~f ~Irrf l1 I~~~rC~ f~ri ~~r~f~f ( trf ~

~rr rft ~I~~i~ l1f~E I~r+l fri1ri1 fir1t ri= ~01Irf I~

~I~~i~ I~t= rf~ r1Hj ( ~rrf1 ft= ~ iJ Irrfl1 1rlt1f rf1~

I~~F rf= iK ~~r~II)ltii= frf 10-lt lCrgti fl~Il~r ~rt lefl

~Ilti ( ~~iClr~ rrrfl ~1(Wi o-r~ ~n ~~~frlil~ lt~ f~M~

~I~ri~ ~~ir rr rrr~ ~Ilfl MQ rltf w11~fl~rir ~

kl gtIe -1 1~~lri= I~~~ I~~ri ~fr~ fl~~lr Inr r-= I~rir

poundlt~ fClCH-j ~Ilfl

i)f= ~~= ii l ~Ir~ Irl~ Cgtrn ~h~~CJI 1 ~rpound01 illf~ ~ o~ron ~Il)frl ~iK euro1m w=tf ~(~Irl~ poundSl ~(~Ifl~ 1f l=

f~I~C ~WQ Iffl~ ~~wllm-i= iflo-elon ~~r~ ~1= rf=

Icrlr If efl~ ~~t-II~~

fl~~If ~1r1~ IMJ6j~ I~rI~I~nf f~Oltjr~ 1f o-con

itnf n1 ~~~9-e f ~e f ns-rC1 IltC fI1f ~In1rM fl(YOT ltr f lt-fCQ

ngtI~ 1i1lffl~ 1liri1 (c~ I)~ m-i= ~fl-i= ~Ufl1 I)~~

Imil = I(l~ Itr~rfimrM ~Itrfrr C~1 ~AI I ~ bull 4 ~r~sirlt~ l[iii l-5 r~ ~~ CIlt V~ )

( ~U~ Smiddot tr~1I~1rcCr r( I~r~ 0 ~bull ~ ~~ fTf bull ~C1 II

~ ~ ~ ( ~ttfI f ~ 1 --rr J Irvr It ~ ~fi hmiddot 1m ct 11 I I)~ I~ Iv ~It

i~ rI)~ Irt crJ ~if I= 1 ~e oT-rllrlflg ff ~~IQrfm

yenr nr Imn I~rgtf Oltl~ onli J nr ~~n~ irrlf

1l1~ ir lro-lt~ 11~(illMi r(rl~rIf11lri~ (I~ rootr

~o 11)ltgtlJ r~-fr ~ril bull

(I~e_i rflrre I~~nr 1r1~ r1111 Il~~ r1-i lro-ltIrnt ff gt1~

~1111 ~Irlt 11$1 ~( f-t ~ ~~Ir I(ltgt~ 11~(illMi t

uTr I~~~Irn( lefltir M ~f Irnfr ~r I~~oot ~

09Yit I~11~ irf~ ~~ ~Ir-Ioi 11)~$I lt

rrI~ cflf urgtlt Irgtl~ Il~~ Umiddotmiddotnt IrM~ u~middot Irltrril

I~ irr ~I~~ ~~~ ~ lefrr I~~ Ifoi 1(yenln

1~r ~1111 middot~i p 1~r TI-i ~ ~ Ir-Ioi 1fIC I~~

umiddotmiddot(ril ~q~~ImrJ Im(= bull

lrgtIr Iro-ltIrnt Ilgtl(~ rrl~ ttl o--~ ~roIOJ -ft) IMI~ I~~I t

11~( I~$I I~ Ur$1 Irn( lefltir r ~IT~( ~or I~Ulrr

t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~

Ilgtl(i rrl~ r--r-err I~~ irmJ 1l~rJi Irrrf Imen I I~if ~

~ u(1 Il~ ro (I~ I~IMrr rr-gtlr Iro-ltIrnt I~

~mrs ~ ffs ~ ~~ ( 1+fltllm~r ~f Irf~ 11)~$I ~J Il~

-Irn( rIm~r I~f rrrr I~~~It r(~ 1l~Ir

r--~ w If Il~ shy

l~ Irn( 1ft$I ~ f-t un~r Irfrrrfr ru-frr I~~It r(~ 1J~Ir

- shy

bull bull

(fI~ Ultrlfr 1(lm rros4~ flrfsr 1nIJ I~l-oYii o r~r~ If ~)

fl~ I yen r~l1fl1 ~gt If~rr1~ It 1(Ca( Ca( l~ o-c c~ I~ ~ fwf It O o-c Ipr I~~r~ 1m jrH1

1~~lr Ir ~ oA o-c Ipr I~~( Ca() o-c c~ ~ fPm ~I

fl~ I OJ I~ jr ryfa( eli ~~ 11i~ ~OJ ltTr Mi - o-r-~ iref11 I~~r~ ~ fir ~(Cl r1~11 Ir+I~ rl~I~ltii It

frS ir I~~ 111~ I~~ ~ f11r l~ OJ ~IT11~ I~~ 1 crrJ

IrcrJ rl1fl1 iyr I~~ ~ rCrJ ~rf- ~1 1111~ ~r-srr Im~

~( It It to cfi ) ~ fif I~I~r~1F ir -srr o-c 1~~It ~ Ift+1 ~

1S 1 Mi ~~Ir Ir o-c f~I~wf ~Ipr I~~r~r If JI bull 11 ~~-(a( m~ fITf-f bull 1 ~

( -1 ~I~h I h ~ 1-- 11 ~ ltTrCl ~OA bull

~ (i 4 bull --rrt ( (i 4 fJ a(-~ ~ 11 I~ I~~e ltTt bull IT I I~~e f lrom I(C ~It 11

flrltS 1s4I I~r~ltTr ~1~lr oyrlCl -o r~r f~ bull

~~IrrI~l1fr 11yenIcn) ~ fr~ IfOSdeg 11i~ Ir ~r~1F

r11 I~~ wf oA r -srr Im~ fK ~1F ~ 1 ~I wf ( 1fltT I~~

~~~11i~ ~~(~1 rn 1~~lr In+r r~r f~rgti

rMlt ~1 I~rJ ~rn 1~lr041 r1111 I~~l ~I cfa(

o-rri -srr Ir-gtl flm~ shy

~l1fl1 ~ ~fI ~~-srr IlI-sr Itf rsi Oltim ~ ~T1~~

l1fI11~~~ o-c rl-ri sf Oltim bull fwf OJ s I~~ ~OJ ir ~fi rl~

ffl~ ~~Iro-lt1mt f~S ~ frJ ~r IS o-c Umiddot~~t 1m 1rH1 Kl~

~~r~f~t l(fl~ Ir ~o-r-lri9I rIfl~ 1r1~ fefr (ff ~~

-~ ~ shy

_L

J~JJI ~~ ~ ~~ ~I JIAtI JIjgtJ~1 ~IA ui ~ JI~~I oJJ~ eo ~iJ ~ ~tjJ ~~IJJIJjJ ~IJ ~I~JJI ~~I~lS LoJSJ ~ ~lgtJI

bull ~J~ JJ~~aJJJJI ~lS LoJS

- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ

yyy )twJII~ ~lgtJ Lo~ ~J JA

yyy ~IJ~~J~~I -11 ~L JAJ

yyy toWI ~~t~1 4gtt~ lJ-t JAJ -

uiJ J+w ~WJ ~L JI WIJ ~J~J oJ$Li ~~Lo )twJ1 I~ JAJ -Y

~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~

~I ~~~~fi~ ~Ji ISjJl ~J~JJI ~JA4 )tjij j JJJ U ~L Loi

4~1 J$lill JJ$ OJj eo ~I~~ gtJ ~Y ~J~ aq~H J ~JI JJ$ J~I 4-1 ~rl JJ$ jbJ J$~ ~)J ulgt~1 ~Jto~1 PIJJJJ

~I I~ ~1fi1 rJ$ ~~J~JJI rJJl JSS uylAll rJ ~~ ~i ~ middot PIJJJI

ui J ISJy ~I l+tJ-J ~ ~Iyj J ~lJgtJ J~ J+w LoS l+lSJ ~ JAi

~1oJ ~ at1J$ ISJ Lo jbJ ~ ~~~I~1jlJ1 o~1~)Jtl ~1jlJ1 ~ ~ ~

~IJ~J~

~~JI ~ oJo~ oJ$Li ~one person one vote oJ$Li ui us-~

~WJ ~ ~JJJSw~L ojlilIJ u-itjJ JJi Jo)1 PIJJ J LAJ~ )tpl J~ j1

~~J~~J~ ul~ ~Jl1 ~PIJJJ ~ ~to aJblL J~( oJAgtlAlL

t1~ ~)~ ~J~ ~ ~JJJgtJI ~lli1gtJ1 pLJ ( J4-gt~1 Jgt+lL

bull bull

-i shy

~1tl ~IJJ ~JJ ~IJJ~J r crOjiJl ~~I 4t~ ~IJJ~ I+w ~J ~j

bull 4tJ~-J1 ~I~Ji r ~Itl ~JJ ~IJgt-OJ r abutl ~WIaJljJ

~)s-OJJIJ ~o~lill o~ v-~~I J ~I ~IJ~-JI ui JSjll uoJ

uo JSj ll) JSJ -4iJ lill F rlUo 4jJSI ~ JlbJ JWI ~)s-sA JI r ~I

)IJJJI ~~ui JSjJ r uYlil1 ~J ~ ~)s-~I P ~J

u~ ul JJII ~ )1 r bij rljJ~1 LrS-OSgtj -JJ r ~L ~~~Lgtli-JI

Ji r ~IJJ ~uPjjO ~r ~JyJ ~4109)1 ~LJI ~lJ1 ~~I

~ISJ1J ~ ~)IJ ~lJIJ aJJJJ JI4) J JI r ~I JSLto JI ~Jj

bull ~-lt aLgtj-J1 amp shy

bullbull ~J

iI-Jtsltl 1amp-11 ut IJj tljJl -tl t~ ~I JJI - -J-C middot~tt -19 tljJL IF vr--J J r-~YJ ~JtJJJ- V-u~ J

tJjjj ~ amp1 Jij r 4j~ljO JjlJJJI ~Ji J~ ~~J ~I~i~J ~LJJ - ~511 ~I~IIJJJI

uLSJ1 J~ bwJlo aJJ~ ~JaJ1 rlJJ1 ~ aJ9~ jSJ ~~I ~lill tJjiJ rli

JIjJ4J tJjjiJl ~ JjlJJJI ~ ~Uo~1 uLSJ1 J~~JJ Jij JIjJ4J r ~lJIJ

_( --) -loAl ~~~IJo$IIJ+o ~4i~

~lJ1 JJ ~bwJllIJjJ ~Lgtjl o)IJ jSJ ~I~lill tJjiJ ~Irli ~f

~lj~ JjgtJ rwJ r ~41gtij~ WI ~4~Lil+ll o~li ~lj~ b~-J lt~ )

bull ~JIJ o-gtJ JS ul j iI-~~IJ 4Jt1 ~jS)1 j~1~4itJJ

bull ~511 ~IJJgtoJ4 ulso-JI J~rljlJ-J1 ~I~IJ LoSf

-gti ~ iI-raquo ~i tlJiJl r~ o~ljO iJJ~J aJJJJJ ~JIJ~I ~4rljlJ~1 J

~4OJJ11 ab~1 rwiJ jSljO ) ~Lgtli~1 )IJJJJ 4iJSlI 4t)J~1 ~~I

_gt1 ~)J ul J ~J( aJJJJJ JoJAtI ~)J~1

aJlgt ~ ) 0-gt11 S)IJJI ~ljJSl ~I~I JJ~I JdgtJ i~ljO iJJ~ -y

( 4tJ1J1 ~Lil i~ ~~jSJ

bull bull

bull bull

If~ ~I= $Tr gtI~ F rrlt1f ~If ( f IFrr) fwf IMriY1

~~f~= -welanbw Ja alJald JUles TT flltf ~

I~nf r I~Iflr-e ltfIr -0 ~If l r ~f ~rl1~

Irr~r~ Irf~I~o-r~ Illr ir+o1 ~If~ ~ I= If= I~~

I~Irr~r~ Irf~ rrflt-e r~ri1 ~~ c I~ l ~

~rI~o-rl= If~= l l( - frr-rf) I~o-rl= Imr icr+o1 l ~

Irrl-fs IF~~ ~fltfS iri1 0 tl f furcfr 1~lr f~r rciF

flsr bull ) ~o r 1~1f ~ -oz r If Igtf ~ I~ltflr kl gtI~ $

(r Ime= rIrlto+ri1Irf~ M 1~1f ~If= I~~Ir Of

-rf mrtf ftC~ r~ftr Ir

-r rrIf 11Irr ~Ii i p i rISe ffr~ ~ flmfl

f-o-rl~S ~frs I~~1FltrolJi flrrmltl( nr Irrf l1 IF~~

~a)

Iro-lt1rnr lriltn flrc-rfri1 flr IMltlr I~fltr 1Jf rr1~ (

r -o-rl~S I~ff flF~flr 1iyenln flr-gtl~ 1N1~ iYrr ~

~~rriJ ~I~1Fr1ri1 flFltrol~ ttn7 I~rmiddot

~r~rfl1 I~~m~l fiF ~rmiddot1 ~I~rrrfl1

r -rovr I~r I~I~ IrcriT9 CltI F~rrlr I~UVlon ~

~

iFr I~gtl= Clt~I 1111 I~ l ftr( m~ 1F~7 rrrf-f IF~

fl1 o fre ~1 ~$TJ 1~7 Irgtrl I~frt I~Srf1 f~I~

~ -o-rl~S rovr gtIf ugtinr I~rlrii 1iyenln Ir 1F$Tlr I~rr1~

bullbull

_0 _

1sjlS JJ$ ui ~~)4~jJ ( seine -maritime o)IJJ

t ub1JoO

(y ~I~~ ~)Ii~~1 ~J~I~JIIJJji-tJJI ~I)

~JII~I ampIWII JJI+ILI -y

- ~t ~(r) rlJ oJi ~JA~IJji-tJJI ~~LiJI OJUI ~

Representatives Shall be apportioned among the several states which may be included within this Union

according to their respective Numbers

bullbull lJi d ~ttt I boJl L1IJ jJj lt ~I -JJI Li ~jJ ~ ~U rJ ~r- J - -J-JA J~ Uf J

JJ$ UlJi ~J~1ftl+J1~~Iujtl ( ~JA~I ~yWI rUUJI ~ )IJJJI

bull Jji-tJJI ~C~ ulSJ1

OJ$ - ~IaoSJA~Il-W1 3oSgt4l1 ui ~ ( 4gtyenJJ uJji-tJJI ~Itgt1~ ~JJ

lijigtj 4-iIJJ ~~I~$I ItJJ~ 0JJlJ1 ~ ~~~Ggto)w ~I~

bullrWld~ IoiJJ4 CLoJI ~ Jo~1 ~I 1lA ~~gtJ4 rs ~psi ~ aoSgt4ll ~~J

- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1

only the limited population variances are unavoidable despite a good faith effort to achieve absolute equality or for

which justification is shown

JjIu ~Itl 4llJ1 Jlt ~~)4~La tgtJ ~~~I ~~LgtJI rIb - Jfi bull ~LJJ+t Lo LsJ ~~I~~LgtJI ~ ( ugt~1 UolSJl olJWI J

- shy

IoSJ~J ~JJ-J ~~ ~j~ll ~I aoS~1 ~jib llrb vi JSYJ JJN

~IJ~~ lioJ ~1llrb aoSgtoJ1 ~~Ji ~j ~JJ aaJW1 olJu4 JJ Flgt Ji c SIJUI ~liJJo 6JgtJ~ IoS~1 J~)I vi J~~I ~ ili c rLJ1 d~1

~I ~ rli 10 JS JogtZ dJi y4 ~ ~IM ubJ c jilSlllJ aJlJAJI ~ 6JgtJ ~

d~1 Jo~ ~~IJ~I ~J c rt4tt 111 lojgtJ1 ~I ~1J1fIJ ~LlIJ

rLJ1

rlt mahan aj ~ CIoSJ+o IJIle vi ~I aoS~1 ~J ~jJ ji~jJ

vlJ c a1o4 ~~4olJ ~I~ ~Iyl dttlJJ t1 J~ iJJr ~I c v~

u mahan a~ j J ~c 0Jr4 Y4-w~ ~lS ~ll=awjlll j ~jI~~1 ~ ~

Jlj )IJJJI ~v~ +Igt~ ~lil IoSYJ ~~~lSJ v~ rlthowell

l Jt dl ~( JI~~I ~~j~1 ~WJ~I gti ) lt ~t4J) JI~~I

~J ~I ~I aoSgtoJ1 dl jO~1 ~JJ c ~JJ JJl ~~~IJ ~

one person o~li vi 4JJi c Uo~1 llrb ~ aol+ll cIoSJ 41I ~ a~

~IJ ~IJJI dtLWI UI J~ JAgt jib c WIgt Jgt1 o~1J ~Iii one vote

ii~1 aosgtoJI ~J 6gt 41Jz~1 )IJ)I ~~ a middotgtII f

we reaffirm that the Equal Protection Clause requires that State make an honest and good faith effort to construct districts in both houses of its legislature as nearly of equal

population as is practicable

vi ~~l aJJJJI ~lt ) ~41Jz~1 )IJ)I ~ui ~i aoSgtoJ1 ~J LoS

yj~ ~ 0JY-OJ aJjLo ~J d JUJ aJ~ ~IJ~~ ~lS JI~~1 ~~JM

aJJ)I

-wshy

that (i)n reapportionment cases the burden is on the State to justify deviations from parity by legitimate considerations incident to the effectuation of a rational

state policy ~I~ (377US at 577 84 SCt at 1390)

~t) 100 U1 JIFES tJ JJI JllgtJj~1 ~ tf -tl ~I _ ~I I ~J$j MI -J 4S bull 4J )J ~ M shy

IJJJI ~~ui uo ~ ~~WI cA JSj Lo J a)lill ~Lgtu~1 IJJJI ~

~ ~o JI ~~~JgtJI J~~ JI~I ~O~~~J ~ OJ4~ ~~

~J ~I~IJ ~)~JJI Uo~1 ytgto ~oSgti J arJJ ~t1gtj aJWI ul ~

bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~

vSJ ~o ~~~Lgtu~1 IJJJI ~ ~JJ$ is J~y J4Lgtu~ LJJI ~Ij~

U~I J tt ~IC)J bull ~A r~lw J- A bull IgtUbull cr- c ~JI

uo Ut~IJ AV r~ ~ I~I r~1 ~~o J$lill uo ~OJjJ ~IIA r~1JJJ

LJ1Sw JJ$ ~1 ~~~JgtIJ JAio c~ rJ ~ r~ ~J r~ ~ IJAio ~

JJ$ ~~I ~~~jlijamp 4iJl JgtIJ JAio OJJJ ~JLj1UU bjltl uo ~ Iii ~UI ~ t~

~llbjUl uo Jii ~UI j ~O ~1Sw - In Canada the independent commissions charged with creating federal electoral districts are allowed to deviate by up to 25 percent from the provincial quotas But since 1986

(l~uls LJ A 1iJ ~Lisa Handley JIltgt wlJli) ~b J~~~JJ Challenging the Norms and Standards of Election Administration Boundary Delimitation Standards

- shy

commissions have been permitted to exceed the 25 percent limit under extraordinary circumstances

This provision was used to create five of the 295 seats in the Canadian House of Commons in 1987 and two of 301 seats in 1996 In 1996 one Quebec seat was created with a population 402 percent below the provincial average and one Newfoundland district was created with a population 625

percent below the provincial average ~UI~Lill J -J

~JIjl ~i ~ Yo V4 PS4 ~1gtJj~1 IJJJI ~~JJn Ji~1 jJ~~1

~IJU11 oIJJI r-wJ OJ~ ~ui 1 ~uY11J1 u~l rr ~V4 psi JlJI~11 ~

~aw ~J91~ ui ~~jJl ~U~I -=~I ~I~U~I uylAJJ ~JJ=t1 ~I ~

Y crl ~~JiJ1 JIWI ~~I~10 IJiiSJ IAj~ ~aall ~JlgtJ11 ylJJJI

bull lti t rrJ1 -11 ~~Ijl ~1gtJj11 ~I JJI ~- -J Jgt-i -J ~ -J J -

In Germany like Canada districts are not to deviate from the electoral quota by more than 25 percent It is not until a district deviates by more than 33 percent however that the law requires that a district be redrawn The German legislature which must approve any proposed federal districting plan before it can be implemented often refrains from adopting district modifications recommended by the Electoral Districts Commission until a district deviates by 33

percent or more ~~~LiI J -

jJ~ rJJet -ujJ 0pound pound r~ ~1gtJj11 IJJJI ~J ~L~I O$11J1 ~Jgtj ~

V4 lUi ~~JJet IA~ J ~~11 ~t~IO$11J1 o~ ui ~( Yo ~J1~11

J~~~IW) ~1JU11 ylJJJI us ut0JJ J lJb ~I$IJAJI)1J -= JWI CtJUJI

~4J~ll rJJet ~Jo 0$I1JI o~ ui oJJ~ r as equal as possible (ulSolI

(~i) ulSoll J~~JllJ ~JIJl1

shy

~~~lgtJ1 ~I~I JJ~IJ JoI~1 ~Wtti dlJ vs-~LuJI ~LoS

SlolS ~IJ St~ )~~ cAr r~ ~ ~Lbr ~ -J~lgtU~1 ~UJI ~I~ JUlI

~I~ ~)I)t11 )JigtJ1 rlpl ~ Vgt ~r 4gtliCo bull bull ro 1A)1y ui ~) oJgtIJ ~lgtU1

~Id ~i Jit~J lUi 4gtli tA ~~s ~) Surbiton ujjJ a~ UjJ)JW

tfM ~1)Western Isles ~~I)~I eM -J)jij IJltS middot1 st~ JIJ uoJ1 ~~

)JS tfM ~1)Orkney amp Shetland Ji~~)JiJ (lUi ytu ~Ls JJS uUJ+l1 ~ JSlU (r bull bull ~Ls

The United Kingdom allows even larger deviations in district populations The original standard was set at 25 percent in 1944 But the standard was repealed only two years later The current rule requires that constituencies be as equal as possible but this rule must be balanced against the principle

of respect for local boundaries as much as possible Equi-populous districts can also be disregarded for special geographic circumstances Allowances for natural communities prompted English Boundary Commissioners in 1983 to leave the Isle of Wight with 95000 electors as a single constituency while respect for local London boundaries left suburban Surbiton with only 48000 electors Likewise recognizing the difficulties of island travel the commissioners in Scotland granted the Western Isles (with a population of 24000) and Orkney and Shetland (with a population of

31000) their own representatives

~j~I01) ~J~)jlwgtJ1 S~gtJI ~ ~ll ~~I 01gtJ1 vI~J rJAj 10$ ~J

tI

~~ uo SIgtJI clJj u~ y t ~y y rJ) IJgtJI ~uyli ~~ll I)~I u~

~~litl ui dlj JI)iJ~ ~lilJ ~~J~j ~ ~JI u~~lpoundilIJ J)WI ~~

~j 0~1 ~~~IJ 01gtJ1 I)~ ~JI )JS ui uo I)I~) aJ~ ~ll ~i

r~)fC lt5 o-cn-TI ~mr2 ~ - ~1tT~( r-o t- 0- U~5 K ~ItTS

f~~iC 1 f(r -TI~C ~ltTflr ~c ~~oywr rpound1r-t2 11middotmiddotV( ( 1~2

F4 w dfl 0(1 r-rF4 ~ t Il~1 II

i(F4 ~ Inf~ f1 fIf ~~rc~ ~ltIltTfll fUOltrr i-trrr VV I~ rl

1 ii-rl rltrfr I~l~ i-trr ltW1r-t lrTc I~~tI ll~~ ~tltf 1 f(r

rc-of ---AAA I~ flC I~fC ~~1tTlr2 oywrC bullIS fl~ ---l I~ fflf

1tT(r-t Il~ r+P -V I~ ~1~2 r~ nV ~~ ~1tT(r-t I~~ ISbull

-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~

~~i~iyene J~h~ br~ ~~i~Jri~ bmre bltb( ~rampl

bqrb 1rJ~ ~ ir-fC ~~Jl ~ ~ooCi1lt J~mort bJro-JClf Jmort

~~H~hJ r~~~~IrJ ll(~ ir-v J~(~ (lJA) b (~ )) ~i~(

b~J~r ~(Jfrn ltrJlt bO ~ IrJrb ~ (Jf~ bl~~ ~lt (If~ 0 ~ O~ yen(

J~ J~n~~ ( ~in b~r Jrt1~)

~tryen OJZ ~J(bull bull bull 00 1~or ~re b~l J~ooC ~rb lrni( JITS

ltrJlt ~( Jrl~ ~(Jflt ltr1lt oAAAV ~ b~r J~ ~~Jrrlt J~

bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~

i~rpound1 ~bJ~ ~~rrltJf~ Jmyene J~ ~~( Jrl~ ~4

P1 ~4 (~ m ~( 1~ b~i ~~ Jrl~ JrJ~ ~1lt Jf(Jf~

~~ rfC J~cr if ~~Q J~~f llt (Jf~ r~ J~~

~(~((~] ~( Jrl~middoto b~rpound1~4

JOn J~~ bullbull AA n~b(Jf~ JjOr b~IM~ [~(~~ Jr=r( ((l

(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]

bull l~l~~ l~fF ( ~ l~)

liIP-IIP1shy~m tr rtTtf ~tIt rfl i 1rtlrr

---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull

G O~ ~ ( 1 L ~ c tmiddot 01 ~ r 1[ -f~ t ltt --eo v Jshy

to t - ( ~ ~ k cpound~ Ji -ltf ~ =1middot 1 i~ ~ -I r F ~ 1-f Ib I V Yo It - If - l

Er ~--( it ~ E l-~ c gt C-t -I 0 ~ep te ( c b -~ C L ( c CL

~~ G- [ r n ~ S-n tI~ v V( ~ J ~ ~ C k t Yo

Vmiddot l --Yo -shy I

J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (

~ ~ v 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i t b E ~ l C c lt l f ( 1t 5t ~ 9i a I I bull bull I Yo ~

f -~ Yo C ft - L t ) 1 r tt f ~ i ~i ~ Y If ~ bull omiddot ~ Lmiddot ( 1 v ~ g [ ~r it middott ~ ~ -( -( ~~ -( I~ ~ f7 ~ Lmiddot b ~~ Yo

~ fL c ~~ M c~ ~t ft ~ ~t v C ~ ~ l _ 1 c r c ~ ( ~ ~ C 1gt shy c e Yo (J bull Yo I c -~ ~ =--_ Ji ~ ~ _ -( gt c- -( c -Yo bull I rmiddott I lt ~o ~ ~- c ~4middot5tmiddot ~ ~ ~ G- _euro ~ b

f) 0 ~ P tf t f1~ c C cL I

r ( omiddot bull P s ~- omiddot r ~ Vmiddot ~ ( c-~ t ril 1 t bull ( bull bull bull ~ l~ -~ ~

t C bullbull -~ bull C I

~ ~ ~~ t E ~ ~ ~ middot middot ~ ( ~ middotr e k-~ sshy~ t te ~ c bull t ~ l t~ L -Lmiddot pC C-c tf ~ I --0 _ --1-~ I v _~ e bull ( t i

( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1

l~~~lf~ ~Il~I~~~o-C ~cTr~ltr ~Jlt~ ~r

~l~lri~l~~IrrTIr~Umiddoti~middot

mre l~~f(r I~ ~cr ~If I~~af) I~~r I~ ~

pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~

l~rH~fl~ 1( ~l H~~rl( JIof ~~r( l~lrf~$i

f I~lh ~fJ ~~lf~r El( IMo-C( ~cr lt~ lror(IrgtJ~

rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~

1-~(If~ K2 IptC~ (lf~ r IMo-C~ ~-f~$I ~ K T

It 1FI bull 0] ~1P 1Cl bull

(If~ El( Ifor middot middotOAJ~(

CJf~ Ifor middotoH1 ~(

bull fIIIlm I~~rp

~~pound91~pound91 ~Clf~ I~

~~OZ J~~ ~( (ff I11f J~rrH~r$i 1mof ~~

(v ~ poundfi) ~ 0) ~trr ~(I (I ~O f rolM ~(I ~

~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I

sectl~ ~rerr ~ ~~~Hre H~ ~~ H~~ )(1 f~

Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~

~~ff1 ~(~(I-J1(1 ryofg Hmrb( f( ~f(~ ff1 ~(

bull ~~I~~

H1~

tr~ ~~ ~ ~(I ~~ t1fl ~rr ~rr~~ ry r)~ ~ ~~f Jer ~ McJ H~~ ~re f~tr f ~ ~~( ~

fi9l ~fe ~O) r~ ~~rf)~ H~ fi9l ~f fo ryenie rr~ f(rr ~

~rs ~fl ~~5-tf rffo ~~H~ ~H(r~~~rl(l

bull ~~~I~

P~r ~~~~~~fe rr l~ (Y1lte H~fFe ltlr~

~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~

fJ ~~Hfrsectl ~rryr ~ltr ~t~~ ~ro-~H1~ ry()

bull ~~~er

H~lri ~~r~ ~(I ~~)r (I ~~r bull 1 bull -I

rr 5-t ~~Qtr mK~ ~o-C J1(1 ~~Hf r-rff ~rHr(l

~r oil ~~~r~ ~C1r ~l r~ J1(1 f( fJ ~f~ fA

f~ Hl~ tsr ltr~ ~f~ ~bullbull J ~ 1~ 01 rY(IO1-e

iltor ~rrer~ ~f r~ r ~~ r ~~(I

ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~

~ ~~illr(I ~i~t(I U(irr ~lteJ1~ ~~J 01~ ~

fj ~ -1 C~middot ( o ~ -t1 ~ t k v t

~ f -0 ~ t I [ [ h e- ~o ~ f -~ I [ -h - ltt ~( f _ r- f ~ ~fi cmiddot c bull -f e

L

(fi b t c~middot ( h 0 ~ 1ii -0 shy

r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _

I kmiddot I S L t Ei t [ b (C -~ -c ~ ~ ~ ~ [ 1 t GL ~ -[1 ~ of ~ ~L 1 e ~ t [ ~ eshy

rt t ~~ ~ [ f 1 ( ltt t euro t t t k t 5 B ~ - -~ ( -I c--0 - --1 -[ _ [ I ~ f ~ ~ ~ c -ol --t -f ~ _ -0 -_ bull Iv h f)

~ - -~ 1 [ ~ ~ ~ 7 t ~ ~ h ~ c 1f 1 ~ ~ ~ -[1D 1 ~1 ~ ~ --0 I f sect i ci l ~ ~ ~ -t [l f- -tL lt-(r ~ t -to e --0 h bull ( bullk Q ~ ( (I ~ P I ~ r= ff ( h -~ f I - E

I ~ t f ~ ~ ~ ~ f ~~ f 1 tmiddot ~ ~ -r E ~ f [ ltt t~ ~ -0 _ c C ~ _ h _ _ -0

bullbullbullbull

11lt-~ rI~fie bull f -fir f fit bull

Sii -Mrfrf fit bull tq(~ shy

~

-ushy

bullbull

bullbull

- L

U riztlll

bull viJllltamp ~ I+JI ~ rJJ ~ul ~ rLoi toJil1 ~IjJ os4t ~Qi~ J+w

wI

4oSJ4 ~ul ~ vi J J-~ oltamp ws4t o~ 1oSll1 ~1H ~IjJJ ~wJ

rJAi - ~JJI ~t~o sljiJ IoS~JJI J~ JAi - 4) ~lloSi)4 1~wJi ~I ItJJlwJJI

-lJ y y rlJ vYlif tl lii1)1 loS JtI r~4 ~IgtH ~lgtij~1 IJJJI JJIJgt ~JJlwJ

oLolgtoJl TLi1 JtlLJ ~IjJ~1 tojSgtJ1 rljJlJ TIJI ~~4lgtij1 IJJ ~ vi ~ y t w~ sly JI ~ 1oSll1 loSi)1 rJ ~ ~I ~I ~~ y ~ pl Iltamp ~~ jlJ

~Ili JI ~I ~ 1oSllIJ IoS~JJI ~J4 ~ loSi)1 ~1Jt~ 1oS~ ~ ~J JtIIoS~JJI ~ ~JJI

- ~~~ IUj dyJ ~ eilyl ~~Lgt y~IJ ~~ js ~~~ OJlJl y

jJIamp C i~ 1d ~aU w JampiiiL ~ I6i lJ ~

J~ rJAi ~JJI v~ ~ul ~ rLoI ~Jill ~IjJ os4t ~~ ~ 1-5 ~Jfo ~1Jt -

~I y~~ bJpl ~JJlwJJI ol~J ~ ~JolJ oLl14~J1 ~~Ib ~1Lij~ IoS~JJI

- -ulgt J- - - q ~ -l tL - I lt-tt Llo I bullbull tl 1_- -tl - -9JJIIltamp I bullbull t jjJ4 - ~r-- - J J r- ~ --- tJJ ( ~ shyM

tltamp ~ ~I ~I Lo Jogtl ~ iiJlJlJ ~Lw ~ylJ y~1 js rlilllltamp ~ ~ 1oSllIJ lA~

IoS~JJI J~ rJ$ JI rJ ~ J~tgtJ - ~I ItJJlwJJI 4oSJt ~Wti ~ 1oS~ LoJ - viJ1

bull 4- ~~4 IJgt J~ ~ ~J ol~J ~ iiLl1 4~J1 ~JJI ~ ~lAij~

IoS~JJI ~ ~JJI ~o sly rJ ~ ~ul 4~~ ~ ~I JLIIoSll1 ~t)1 v~ Lol -

~ UQi$ ~lUl~- utgt ~ - ~ ~ I+JI ~JI ~I y~~J ~Jtl

~~JJI J1JJ4 J)J Lo JJJgt ~J ~ ~Jtl ~JJlwJJI IoS~JJI ~ ~JJI v JI pl yAj

~Iy ~ 1oS~ vJIJoOS ~ Jb oII)1Jgt v~ - ~~ Ji ~~tIJ ItJJlwJJI


















~













~fI== I~Irr~r~




























rrT~ bull






-Q shy









~IrarJ f I~

~-IM f 1il~Q IF~

)-IMf 1il~Q IFnt







IbF-~FrJ ~

In~ 1 rf shy



- shy

bull bull

























Irr~( 10 ~Wl I~~I~~ ~~1~(2 Ol~









Irr~(








-v shy
































t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~





r--~ w If Il~ shy


- shy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy


















~













~fI== I~Irr~r~




























rrT~ bull






-Q shy









~IrarJ f I~

~-IM f 1il~Q IF~

)-IMf 1il~Q IFnt







IbF-~FrJ ~

In~ 1 rf shy



- shy

bull bull

























Irr~( 10 ~Wl I~~I~~ ~~1~(2 Ol~









Irr~(








-v shy
































t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~





r--~ w If Il~ shy


- shy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy









~fI== I~Irr~r~




























rrT~ bull






-Q shy









~IrarJ f I~

~-IM f 1il~Q IF~

)-IMf 1il~Q IFnt







IbF-~FrJ ~

In~ 1 rf shy



- shy

bull bull

























Irr~( 10 ~Wl I~~I~~ ~~1~(2 Ol~









Irr~(








-v shy
































t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~





r--~ w If Il~ shy


- shy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy
















rrT~ bull






-Q shy









~IrarJ f I~

~-IM f 1il~Q IF~

)-IMf 1il~Q IFnt







IbF-~FrJ ~

In~ 1 rf shy



- shy

bull bull

























Irr~( 10 ~Wl I~~I~~ ~~1~(2 Ol~









Irr~(








-v shy
































t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~





r--~ w If Il~ shy


- shy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy









~IrarJ f I~

~-IM f 1il~Q IF~

)-IMf 1il~Q IFnt







IbF-~FrJ ~

In~ 1 rf shy



- shy

bull bull

























Irr~( 10 ~Wl I~~I~~ ~~1~(2 Ol~









Irr~(








-v shy
































t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~





r--~ w If Il~ shy


- shy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

bull bull

























Irr~( 10 ~Wl I~~I~~ ~~1~(2 Ol~









Irr~(








-v shy
































t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~





r--~ w If Il~ shy


- shy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy






Irr~( 10 ~Wl I~~I~~ ~~1~(2 Ol~









Irr~(








-v shy
































t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~





r--~ w If Il~ shy


- shy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy
































t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~





r--~ w If Il~ shy


- shy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy














t1 ftW ltrr 11~( I~$I o--~ ~1111 IJ~~ r ~





r--~ w If Il~ shy


- shy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

bull bull





















-~ ~ shy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

_L



- uA11

$

~JP~ aJblI aC~IIJ





~y~ ~J~JJI WJ ~






~IJ~J~





bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

bull bull

-i shy










bullbull ~J















bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

bull bull

bull bull













~a)






~




bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

bullbull

_0 _


t ub1JoO












- ~lgt~ 4JJaJ1




- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

- shy





rLJ1














aJJ)I

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

-wshy







bulloSgt~IJo11

( ~IIA ~o)JP ~I~)

Jlitl~~

-failll 1111 -~








- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

- shy
















shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

shy











tI











-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy








-shy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

bull bull

~J~Jri~








bull ~ lm~~

b~~bJ~~






(Jf~ r~ J~b~M~[(~ en~ rb~~ J)f(]



---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

---

bull bull

G ~ t G- ~~ S L ~ ~ -lt

[ ~ ~ f I - h ~ ~~ t If ~ 1~ ~ [ l f t + c -~ c--

t c t t ~ bull






J G -~ f i t --- 1 1-Ot I

t ~ ~ ( 1 ~ -= ril Yo

c c ~ ~-e ~~ ~ ~ -~~ _ If t Y) -bull V c 1 (








( - 1- I v ~ ~ 1 f b ~~ r 1 tf ~ ~ -t ~ ~ 1 l G- ~ ~ I

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

d~~ 1




pK ~( K2 IptC~ ~~~l~~~~~~~0) ~rP

~~QI~lf~



rIMo-Ch El~ IMo-Ch

~IptC~ bull ool~





bull fIIIlm I~~rp




~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy


~r(Q ~ ~poundfi) ~~J 01~ (I ~~ 1~Uc ~~ 1~ ~(I


Frr f( ~~)~~ ~~(l7 ~~ ~~ f(oi ~Mr ~~~ ~~


bull ~~I~~

H1~




bull ~~~I~


~r r)~ ~ tr ~~ ~ ~ H)~ f r r~ ~


bull ~~~er






ir1~ ~ f ~r~ J ~ -o-e ~~ r~ ~rnf ~~ ~




L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy



L


r ~ f ~ G 1~ r ( t ( t y y -- U _





bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

bullbullbullbull



~

-ushy

Documents

مذكرة تكميلية بدفاع للمحكمة الدستورية العليا 1