55

Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

������������ ������������������������ �!�����#"����%$ �!�'&'�#"�"����(

)+*-,/.1032�46572�8:9;2�47,/<10=.'>)+?78@>-*BA�CDC�A

E%FHGJIKE�L�I=M�NIPOQN�R

S/T�U�V/VW�VYX�Z�V\[^]�_�`baKcBS/TKdeaKf�T=aZBghc�f�aKidea�j;aKWeWeVf+klf�dem\aKcbn�do`qpr de`�`bnbs�_�cbi\U't rDuwv3xy�v3z

{:|6}K~3�h���Y~j;aK`�g3�q]�cbV\ic�gh[^[+def�i�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\aKnB]�c�VhmQde��a%dof�X�c�gYnb`bc�_�TK`�_�cba:`�V^ia=f�aKc�gY`ba:ghf���aK�/aKTK_�`�a:Vs��aKT=`�]�cbVi\c�gY[^nlgh`�cb_�f���`�do[+a�� fHg+`qp/]�aK��n�aK`b`�def�i�t7`�U�aKp�TKVf/`�gYdef�g;[+V/��ghW#`qpQ]Da:TKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`�Vc:�BU�deT�U�TKW�ghnbn�d���aKn�Vs��aKT=`�TKV/��a�;�BU�a=nba^T=VQ��a:`qpQ]DaKnia=f�aKc�gYWeWop�TKV\[^aBdef:`q��V���g3mV\cbn@�#TKWeVn�aK��gYf��:V]DaKf'�6Z�WeV\nbaK�+TKV/��alaK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�nBT@gYf^sDaldef/mV\�aK�:gh`�cb_�f���`�do[+aths�_�`6`bU�aTKV\[^]�_�`�gh`�doV\f�n6Vhm\aKcB`bU�a=[�gYcba�[+VcbaBc�deide�'t�ghf���`qp/]�deT@gYWeWop�]�c�VQ��_�TKa�WeaKn�nBa��^TKdeaKf/`lc�aKnbde��_�gYW'V\s��aKTK`B]�c�Vi\c�gh[+n@�7��]�aKfTKV/��a:]�c�Vhm/do��aKnJs�aK`�`baKc%dof�Wodef�def�i^gYf���]�ghc�`bd�ghW7aKmgYWo_Dgh`bdeV\f�VYX�Vs� aKTK`�]�c�Vi\c�gh[+n@tDs�_�`JV\f�TKa�TKVf�n�`bc�_�TK`ba=�'t7aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�nVhX7`bU�denB`qp/]Da�T@ghf�f�V`BsDaJaKmghWe_�gY`baK�'�¡ a=TKaKf/`B��V\cb��def^`bU�don�ghcba3g�U�gYn6X-VQT=_�nbaK�;V\f^TKV\[:s�def�def�il`�U�al`q��V¢f�V`bdeV\f�n6def/`bV¢g%nbV\_�f��^n�p/nb`ba=[£�#¤�al]�c�aKnbaKf/`lg%f�Vhma=W�Bg3p�`bV�ghT�U�deaKm\aB`bU�den3� � `7den6s�gYnbaK�:V\f¥gY����def�il`�U�aBf�V\`bdeVf�VhX6¦�§¨�©=ª'X�c�V[«`�U�aB��V\cb��V\f:¬lV\[^def�ghW­®Vi\doTBghf��¥¯�cbaKn�U�j°­`bVB`�U�aB±�²#�qT@gYWoT=_�We_�n�VhX�]�c�VQVYX�`baKc�[^n�X-Vc�`bU�al¦�©�³�©Kª�ªK´�µ-¶�X�c�ghi\[^aKf/`DVhX�[^V/��gYWhWoV\ideT1S�·��#�BU�a6cba=nb_�We`bdef�iBW�gYf�i_�gYia7]�c�VhmQde��a=ng�[^V\cba¸��f�a��qic�ghdef�aK�;TKV\fQ`�cbV\W�VhmaKc�X�c�aKa�mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�VhX6V\s��aKTK`B]�c�Vi\c�gh[+n��BU�aKf;TKV[+]�ghc�aK�;`bV�`bU�a�a=�Qden�`bdef�i:W�ghf�i\_�ghi\aKnX�V\cB[^aK`�g3�q]�cbV\ic�gY[^[:def�i�� � f°gh����de`bdeVf't/`�U�den�gY]�]�cbV/ghT�U°WeaKf���nlde`bn�aKW�X¹��aKWeW'`�V�gY����de`bdeVf+VhX6def/`baKf�n�deVf�gYW'TKV/��a¢gYf�ghWep/nbden3tdq� a�T3gh]�gYs�deWode`qp�VhX'[+aK`�gJ]�cbVi\c�gY[^n6`�V¢def�n�]�aKT=`lghf��+��aKnb`�cb_�T=`lVs� aKTK`B]�c�Vic�gh[+n¹gY`�c�_�f/�q`bde[^aBdef;g�`qp/]Da���n�g3X�a�[�gYf�f�aKc3t�BU�deT�U;��a�ghWen�V¢_�f���aKcb`�gh�\a�

Page 2: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

º+»Q¼�½%¾��¿7}YÀ [+aK`�gP��]�cbVi\c�gY[^[:def�i�th[+VQ�DghWDWoV\ideTt/f�V\[^def�gYW�WeVideTt/def/`ba=f�nbdeVfDghW'T=VQ��a¢ghf�gYWepQn�den@t/nb`�ghi\aK�;TKV[+]�_�`�gP�`bdeV\f't/cb_�f���`�do[+alTKV/��aJi\aKf�aKc�gh`bdeV\f't�n�pQ[:sDVWedeTBTKV\[^]�_�`�gh`�doV\f

Page 3: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

Á Â#Ã�Ä#Å6Æ^Ç�È^É�Ä1ÊKÆËÃ

j;aK`�g3�q]�cbV\ic�gh[^[+def�iJdonJg:]�gYc�gY��dei[�cba�X�a=cbcbdef�i+`bV+`bU�a¢gYs�deWedo`qp+`bV^gYWoi\Vc�do`�U�[^deT@gYWeWop%TKV[+]�V\nba�]�c�Vi\c�gh[+n�VYXÌg�TKaKc�`�gYdofVs� aKTK`JW�ghf�i\_�ghi\atD`bU�c�V_�i\U£g:]�c�Vi\c�gh[Í�Bc�de`b`ba=f£def£gË[^aK`�g3�qWÎgYf�i_Dghia\� u ]�gYcb`�doT=_�W�ghcbWep+dof/`�cbdei_�def�i:def�n�`�gYf�TKa�VhX�`�U�denTKV\f�TKaK]�`3t1gYf��°`�U�a¢V\f�a���a¥gYcba�defQ`�aKcba=nb`ba=��dof;def°`�U�den���Vc���t�den��BU�aKf�`bU�a�[^aK`�g:ghf���`bU�a�Vs��a=TK`JWÎgYf�i_Dghia�ghcba\��Ï v3Ð`bU�a;ª §\¨¢©3t�V\c�`�U�a:Vs� aKTK`�W�ghf�i_�gYia�den�g+nb_�s�n�aK`�VYXÌ`�U�a¢[+aK`�gËW�ghf�i\_�ghi\aÑ'ghf��ÒÏ yÐ µ�¶�Ó�©�Ô�X�_�f�TK`bdeVfDghW7W�ghf�i\_�ghi\aKn@� uW�ghf�i\_�ghi\aJn�gh`�denqX�p/def�i;Ï v@Ð gh����nB`bU�a�]�V\nbn�dos�doWede`qp:`bV^gYWenbV:def/mV�\aJ`bU�a�i\aKf�aKc�gh`�aK�£]�cbVi\c�gY[^nBgh`lc�_�f/�q`bde[^a\�7¤�a�cba�X-aKcl`�V`bU�donBn�aK`b_�]£ghnlÕ�Ö¨�Ö�×\©@¦�©�Ö\Ø\ªÌ[+aK`�gP��]�cbVi\c�gY[^[:dÙf�i��u [+Vf�i�nbV\[^a^VYX�`bU�a£gY��mghf/`�ghia=n:VhX�[+aK`�gP��]�cbVi\c�gY[^[:def�i°ghf��ÚVYX�de`�n:U�V[+Via=f�aKV_�n¥gYf���`qp/]�a=�ÒmgYcbd�ghf/`:��a

��denb`�def�i_�den�U^`bU�aJX�VWeWeVh�Bdef�i:Ï�gYf��;nbaKa^ÛÜS/U�a@Ý v Þ X�Vclg%TKV[+]�cba=U�aKf�n�dom\a�ghf�gYWop/n�don Ð �v �Bß�à �há-»/â6�h¼�ãJ¡ gh`�U�aKc�`bU�gYf°_�nbdef�i:V\f�a�i\aKf�aKc�ghW7]�cbV/TKa=��_�cba:`�V:nbV\Wom\a�[�gYf/p:��d�ä�aKc�aKf/`ldef�n�`�ghf�TKaKnJVhX�g:]�cbVs�Woa=[£tg�]�cbV\ic�gY[�T3ghf;iaKf�aKc�gY`ba�nb]DaKTKd�ghWedeåKaK�HÏ-ghf���U�aKf�TKa�[^V\cba�a��^TKdeaKf/` Ð nb_�s�c�V_�`�def�aKnBX-Vcla3ghT�U°]�gYcb`bdeTK_�WÎgYcBT@ghn�a� � X`bU�a�W�gYf�i_�gYia�donBT3gh]�gYs�Wea�VYX1aK�/aKT=_�`bdef�i+`bU/_�nli\aKf�aKc�gh`�aK�°]�c�VQT=aK��_�c�aKn@t�`�U�a�]�c�Vi\c�gh[�T@gYf�T�U�V/V\nba���p/f�gY[^deT@gYWoWept��aK]DaKf���def�i�V\f^gJcb_�f/��`�de[^a�mghWe_�a�VhX1g�TKaKc�`�ghdef+mghcbd�gYs�Wea�V\c6aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f't/�BU�deT�U:Vf�aBden6[+Vnb`7n�_�de`�ghs�Woa�`bV%dof/m\V�a\�� f�]Dghcb`�deTK_�W�ghc3t�`�U�denBdenl`bU�a�de��a@g:sDaKU�def���`bU�aJX-_�f�TK`�doV\f�ghW#]�cbV\ic�gh[^[+dÙf�i%TKVf�T=aK]�`JVhXBªKµ�§3ש�Ô;³�Ö¨¸Ó�Ø/µ-§µ-´�Ö¦�t�gYf��U�ghnBsDaKaKf°T=Vf�n�do��aKcbaK��s�a�X-Vcba%dof;g�`qp/]�aK�;n�aK`b`�dof�i£Ï�n�aKa^ÛÜ­'­#æç Þ t�Û ¤è­ r æé Þ t�Û ¤è­ r6ê æé Þ t�Û êJr æç Þ�Ð �

y �Bë ��á�â#~@��á�â7��|7á�ì-á�~�¼�ã'� f�nb`ba3gh��VhX�[�gYdof/`�ghdef�def�i�g¸fQ_�[:s�aKc�VYX�nb]DaKTKd�ghWedeåKaK�'t\s�_�`#cbaKW�gY`baK�'tYnb_�s�]�cbVi\c�gY[^n@t3de`�den'a@gYnbdeaKc`bV:[�gYdefQ`�ghdef:`bU�aKdec�i\aKf�aKc�gh`�Vc@� � f£g:W�ghf�i_�gYialT3gh]�gYs�Wea�VhX6def/mV�/def�i�`bU�a�ia=f�aKc�gY`baK��TKV/��atD`�U�aKcba�den�gYf£gh����aK�s�V\fQ_�nBVhX1sDaKdef�i:ghs�Wea�`bV^ghT=TKaKf/`b_�gY`ba�`�U�aJcbaKW�gY`bdeVf�n�U�de]^sDaK`q��aKaKf°`�U�aJnbp/f/`bU�aKn�deåKaK�°TKV/��a�ghf��+do`�nB]�cbV/��_�TKaKc@Ñ�`bU�anb_�s�c�V_�`�def�aKn:T@gYfHsDa�i\aKf�aKc�gh`�aK��ghf��ís�V\_�f��H`�V£`�U�aKdec:cba=nb]DaKTK`bdem\a°de��aKf/`bd���aKc�n:def�`bU�a;def�de`bd�ghWedeå@gY`bdeVf°n�`�gYia;VhX`bU�a�]�cbVi\c�gY[waK�/aKTK_�`�deVf'tDc�gY`bU�a=cl`bU�aKf°ia=f�aKc�gY`baK��ghf��;n�g3m\aK�°def/`bV:g�nbaK]Dghc�gY`ba%��WeaJVhX1`�U�a�s�_�doWe�;`bc�aKaJX�V\cBW�gh`ba=cTKV[+]�deWÎgY`bdeVf:ghf��^Wedef��/dof�i��­'gYf�i_�gYiaKn:defí�BU�deT�UÚ]�c�Vi\c�gh[+n¢T3ghfÚf�V`:V\f�Wep�s�a;TKV\[^]DVn�aK��ghf��ÚaK�/aKTK_�`baK��s�_�`�gYWon�V£UDg3ma;`bU�a=doc:n�`bc�_�TK`b_�cba

def�nb]DaKTK`�aK�«gh���îX�_�cb`�U�aKc;gh��mgYfQ`�ghi\aKn@�Úï#�^TKdeaKf�T=pÒsDaKf�a ��`bnËX�cbV\[ðmghc�doV\_�n�V]�`�do[+deå@gh`�doV\f�n�`�U�gh`:T@gYfÚs�a;]DaKcqX�V\cb[+aK��/f�Vh�Bdef�i^`�U�a:nb`�cb_�T=`b_�c�a^VhX�`bU�a:TKV/��a\�^¯�V\claK��gY[^]�Weat�ñJc�doa=�ÌgYf��°cba=]�V\cb`bn%dofÚÛÜñJcbd�é\æ Þ t�V\f�g+�Bg3p�`�V;cbaK_�n�a^TKV\[^[+Vfnb_�s�aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�n�VYX�g�fQ_�[^aKc�doT3ghWDX�_�f�TK`bdeVf;def;Vc���aKcl`�V:TKV[+]�_�`�a�de`�nlmghWe_�aJgh`Jg�TKaKcb`�ghdef°]DVdef/`lghf��;`�U�a�mghWe_�aJVYX¹de`�nò �q��de[^aKf�n�deVf�gYW�ic�gh��deaKf/`@t/s�_�`Bdef^nb_�T�U°g��Bg3p:`bU�gY`�`�U�aJTKV[+]�WeaK�/de`qp¢VYX1sDV`bU;aKmgYWe_�gh`�doV\f�n6]DaKcqX-Vcb[+aK�;`bV\iaK`�U�aKcB��V/aKnf�V\`6ic�Vh�Ò�Bde`�U ò �6j°ghdef/`�gYdofDghs�deWede`qp¢Ï�gYf��:def:iaKf�aKc�gYW�`bU�a��BU�VWeaB]�c�Vic�gh[ó��aKm\aKWeV]�[+aKf/`7]�cbV/TKaKn�n Ð s�aKf�a���`bn�X-cbV[�`bU�a]�c�aKnbaKf�TKaJVhX�`qp/]DaKn6Vf�sDV`bU�`bU�aBWoa=maKW�VYX�n�p/fQ`�U�aKn�doå=aK�:TKV/��at�gYf��¢V\f�`bU�aBWoa=maKW�VYX�]�cbVi\c�gY[«iaKf�a=c�gh`�Vc�n@�6¯#def�ghWeWepQt3`�U�aKcbaghc�a^gh]�]�WodeT@gY`bdeVf�nBX�c�V[Ímghc�deV_�nJ��V\[�ghdef�n3tD�BU�deT�U�nba=aK[ô`bV;T@ghWeW#X�V\c�`�U�a:T@gY]�ghs�deWede`qp;`bV;aK�/aKTK_�`�a�g+TKaKc�`�gYdof�X-_�f�TK`�doV\fghnB��aKWeW'ghnBc�aKTK_�c�nba:Vhm\aKcBde`bnBnb`�cb_�T=`b_�c�a��nbaKa^Û ¡ Vå@æ z=Þ X�V\c�aK��gY[^]�WeaKn�def�T=V[^]�_�`baKcBi\c�gY]�U�deTKnlghf���f/_�[+aKcbdeT@gYW�gYf�ghWep/nbden3tghf���Û ¡�r Ý y=Þ X�V\cÌgYf;aK��gh[^]�Woa�def^[�gYT�U�def�alWea@gYcbf�def�i:ghf��;]�c�Vs�gYs�deWedon�`bdeTl[+V/��aKWedef�i��¡ aKT=aKf/`���aKm\aKWeV]�[+aKf/`bnBdef°`qp/]�a�nbp/n�`baK[+nlX-Vcl[+aK`�gP��]�cbVi\c�gY[^[�dof�i�U�g3ma%s�aKa=f�TKaKf/`baKc�aK�Hghc�V_�f��°`q��V+]�ghc�`bdeTK_�W�gYc

[^V/��gYW7WÎgY[:s��Dg�T@ghWeTK_�Wedq�¢±D²«ghf��H±�õ;�+�BU�a:�Dcbnb`%don�g;W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a¢VYXÌ]�c�V/VhXl`ba=cb[^n�X�VcJ`bU�a^[^V/��gYW'WeVi\deT¥S/·Dt'�BU�Vnbaf�aKT=aKnbn�do`qpíTKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�Vc^ö�ghf�f�V\`�gY`baKn;÷@§Yøo´�ÔË]�cbV\]�V\nbde`bdeVf�n^ÏbÛ êJr æç Þ t�Û r6ê Ý v�Þ�Ð �;�BU�a+nbaKT=Vf��ídon%`bU�a+]�cbV/VhXlW�gYf�i_�gYiaX�V\c¢��den�TKcbaK`�a£Wedef�a@gYc¢`�aK[^]DVc�ghWBWeVi\deTt7�BU�Vn�a°[^V/��gYW6V]DaKc�gh`bV\c�ùúgYf�f�V`�gh`�aKn:`bU�a�`bde[^a��qWeaKma=W�n�aK]�ghc�gh`�doV\fÚs�aK`q��aKaKf]�c�V]DVnbde`�doV\f�n�Û ê g3m�æ\ç Þ �7û�V`�U�T3ghWeTK_�Wed']�cbVhm/de��a�g���den�`bdef�TK`�doV\f;s�aK`q��aKaKf�Woa=maKWenBVhX6`�aKcb[+n@t�ghf���`�U�denBaK�/]�W�ghdef�nB`�U�aKdecB_�nbadef�[^aK`�g3�q]�cbV\ic�gh[^[:d�f�i��Ë�BU�a:WeVh��aKn�`@t7WeaKm\aKWÌÝ�t7den�`bU�a+[^aK`�g+WÎgYf�i_Dghia\t'�BU�deT�U�den�_�n�aK�Ú`bV°[;ghf�de]�_�W�gY`ba�`�U�a^`�aKcb[+nVf�WeaKma=W v Ï�`ba=cb[^n%VhX�`qp/]Da^ölüýdof�±D²«ghf���ùíüþdef�±�õ Ð �:�BU�den���cbn�`�WeaKma=W6den�`�U�a:[^a=`�g+W�ghf�i\_�ghi\aJX�VcJ`�U�a:WeaKmaKW yTKV\fQ`�ghdef�def�i¢gYf�V`�U�aKc�nb`�c�gh`�_�[wVYX's�Vh�/aK�°ghf��:TKdecbTKWeaK�;`qp/]�a=n@t/aK`�T��¯�_�f�TK`�deVf�gYW�]�c�Vi\c�gh[+[^d�f�ildef/`baKc�]�cba=`�gh`�deVf^VYX1`�U�aKnba`q��V°TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�Vcbn;ghn�nbdeif�n�`qp/]�a;ö�ü�`�VH³KøeÖhªK©�Ô�³�Ö@Ô\©¢dq� a�#`bV°T=WoV\nbaK�í`baKc�[^n�VhXl`qp/]Da^ü¢t7�BU�doWea^ùíü�don%`bU�a+`qpQ]Da;VhXÓ�ÖhªKµÜÓ�Ö¦�©�Ô+TKV/��at7dq� a�et�de`JTKW�ghn�nbd���aKn�`baKc�[^n�VYXÌ`qp/]Da^üw�BU�doT�UHgYcba^ghn�nbV/TKd�gh`�aK�H�Bde`�U�`bU�a+nb_�s�n�aKÿ/_�aKf/`�`bde[^a�[^V\[^aKf/`@�r Vn�`b]DVf�aK�íTKV/��a;defH±�õô[;g3p°cba X�aKc�`bV�V_�`�nbde��a:TKV\fQ`�aK�/`:mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn@t7ghn�WeVf�i°gYn¢`�U�aKpHghc�a^V\f�`bU�a;n�gY[^a�`baK[+]�V\c�gYWWeaKma=W�t/ghf��^`bU�don�U�gYnBTKVf/`bc�des�_�`ba=�^`bV�de`6X-cbaKÿ/_�aKf/`�Wop:sDaKdef�i:ghn�nbV/TKd�gh`�aK�;�Bdo`�U^`�U�alf�V\`bdeVf+VhX�Ö Ó�©3¦�TKV/��a��¯�Vc�`bU�den�aK��ghTK`cba3ghnbV\f'tD`bU�a%TKVf�T=aK]�`�VYX¹T=VQ��a�def£±�õ�denBV\sQm/deV_�nbWep^s�c�VQgY��aKc@t�gYWoWeVh�Bdef�iJX-Vcl[+Vc�alaK�/]�c�aKnbn�dom\aKf�aKn�n¥gYf��°i\aKf�aKc�gh`bdeV\f°VhXsDaK`b`�aKc^ghf���[+Vc�a¢V\]�`bde[^deåKa=�°cbaKn�de��_�ghW�]�c�Vic�gh[+n¥Ï-ghn:ghWecba3gh��p°V\s�nba=cbma=�ÒdefÚÛ ê g3m�æ\ç Þ�Ð t7s�_�`@t#_�f�Wede�a^±D²Bt#do`%U�ghn�f�VW�ghf�i\_�ghi\aJnb_�]�]DVc�`BX�V\cl[+do�/def�i�VYX6`bU�a�T=VQ��a¢WeaKm\aKWen@t�gYf��°def;]�ghc�`bdeTK_�W�gYc@t�f�V^W�ghf�i\_�ghi\aJnb_�]�]DVc�`BX�V\claK�/aKT=_�`bdeVf�VhX6`bU�aia=f�aKc�gY`baK��TKV/��a��BU�aKc�a�U�g3maJsDaKaKf°n�aKma=c�ghW#]�cbV\]�V\nbaK��nbp/nb`�aK[^nB�BU�deT�U^def�T=Vcb]DVc�gh`�a�`bU�a�gY��mghf/`�gYiaKn�X�c�V[wsDV`�U�W�gYf�i_�gYiaKn3t/[^V\nb`

f�V\`�ghs�Woa�sDaKdef�i�j;aK`�g\j°­�ÏbÛÜj;�BûBS�ææ Þ tQÛ �6ghUDææhs Þ t/ÛÜZBj;�lÝÝ Þ t/ÛÜZBj°S�Ý v�Þ�Ð �7j;aK`�g\j°­+nb`�ghcb`�n6�Bde`bU�`bU�aB]DVn�`b]DVf�a=���hV\]�aKfTKV/��a�`qp/]DaJVhX�±�õ�ghf���n�`bc�aKf�i`�U�aKf�nJ`�U�a�f�V\`bdeVf+`bV:def/`bcbV/��_�TKaJTKWeVnba=�°TKV/��a¢gYnBdo`�nBcba��Df�aK[^a=fQ`���gYnB]�V\nb`�]�V\f�aK�°TKV/��a�BU�deT�U�U�gh]�]�aKf�n:`bV°TKV\f/`�ghdef�f�V�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn���aKT=WÎgYcbaK�íV_�`�nbde��a+VhXBdo`3�°�BU�a^gY]�]�c�VQghT�UíVhXBV_�c���V\cb��den�`bU�a+V]�]DVn�de`ba�

v

Page 4: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

¡ gY`bU�a=cB`bU�gYf�c�a���f�def�i:`�U�a�f�V\`bdeVf+VhX7V]DaKf°TKV/��at���aJc�aKW�gh�^`�U�a�f�V\`bdeVf+VhX7TKWeVnba=�°TKV/��a��¤�alnb`�ghc�`l�Bde`bU;`bU�a�n�p/nb`ba=[VhXB±�²Bt®s�_�`J]�cbVhm/de��a�`bU�a:gh����de`bdeVf�gYW'aK�/]�c�aKnbn�demaKf�a=nbn�sQp�ghWeWeVh�Bdof�i¢`�U�a¢T=VQ��a:`bV;TKVf/`�ghdef°nb]DaKTKd���a=��Vs��aKT=`�mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKnghn�X�cbaKa�Ï�gYf���cb_���do[+aKf/`bn�VYXÌ`�U�den¢de��a3g;U�g3ma^gYWecba@gY��p°sDaKaKfÚTKVf�nbde��aKc�aK�Hdef�Û ¬ldea@Ý v�Þ Ð �;�BU�a�X�gYTK`�`bUDgh`:g^i\demaKf�TKV/��aaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f���aK]DaKf���n�Vf�g^n�aK`�VYX6X�cba=a:mghcbd�gYs�WeaKnl�BdeWeW7s�a�cba��DaKTK`ba=�Hdef£de`�n�`qp/]Da���BU�a:Vs��aKT=`�mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKnl`�U�aK[+nbaKWema=nghc�a;cbaK]�c�aKnba=fQ`�aK�!sQpÚg°n�aK]�gYc�gh`�a°nba=[�ghf/`�doT+T@gh`�aKiV\cbpíVhX�fDgh[^a=n�Ï-ghWenbV�T@ghWeWeaK�ínbp/[:s�V\Wen�Vc^gY`bV[+n Ð t7�BU�deT�U�gY��[^de`bnaKÿ/_�gYWode`qp/���BU�a¢`�cba@gY`b[+aKf/`lVhX6f�gY[^aKn�den�gh��V]�`�aK�'tD�Bde`bU°TKa=cb`�gYdef°[^V/��d���T@gY`bdeVf�n@t\X�c�V[Í`bU�a���V\cb�;Vf�¬lV[+def�ghW'­®VideTghf��^¯�c�aKnbU�j�­°s/p r de`b`bn�ghf��^ñ�gYs�s�g3p^Ï�ÛÜñ r Ý v�Þ tDÛ r ñ�ÝÝ Þ t�Û r de`�Ý v�Þ t�ÛÜñ�gYs�ÝÝ Þ�Ð �#�BU�den6��aKn�deif^T�U�V\deTKaBWeaKf���n�de`bnba=WÙX'��aKWeW�`�V`bU�aÌgY����de`bdeVf#t@def:ghf^Ö��KµeÕ�Ö�×Ö\¦�§hø���§¶hthVYX�defQ`�aKf�n�doV\f�ghW/TKV/��algYf�ghWep/nbden3t@�BU�doT�U���aBghWen�Vl_�f���aKcb`�gh�a�X-Vc'`�U�aBnbde[+]�Wep�q`qp/]�a=�X�c�ghi[+aKf/`�VYX1`�U�a�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a�7�BU/_�n@t���a%T@ghf°ghWen�V:`bcba3gh`BV_�clnbde[+]�Wep�q`qp/]�a=�:TKV/��a�aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�n�ghnB��gY`�g�Ñ�`bU�aKp;T@ghf;f�V\`Vf�Wop;sDa:aKmghWe_�gY`baK�#t�s�_�`JT@gYfHghWenbV+s�a:TKV\[^]�gYcbaK��X�V\clnb`�cb_�T=`b_�c�ghWBaKÿ/_�gYWode`qp°ghf��£��a=nb`bc�_�TK`�aK�Hm/d�g+]�gh`�`baKc�f/��[;gh`�T�U�dof�i�t[:_�T�U�dof�`bU�aln�gY[^a��Ìg3p:ghn�Vf�aB��V_�We����V\cb���Bde`bU^ghf/p¢gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`�n�p/fQ`�gh��`bc�aKa�6�BU�aBs�def���def�iJTKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�n�ghc�aBU�ghf���WeaK�`bU�cbV_�iU�`bU�a°¦�§¨�©;§��=ª µ�b§\³@µ-´�Ö\¦;[^aKT�U�gYf�denb[ VYXÌ`�U�a:[^a=`�g+WeaKmaKWqt#c�gY`bU�aKc�`bUDghf�`bU�c�V_�i\U�TKVf�T=cbaK`�a�c�aK]�c�aKnbaKf/`�gh`bdeV\f�nVc�`bU�c�V_�i\UH÷3§��K´�§��Køe©¢§��KªKµ�b§\³@µ-´�Ö¦�Ï�dq� a��U�dei\U�aKcq�qVc���aKc�ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`Jn�pQf/`�gh��Ñ�n�aKa°Û r ï6éé Þ�Ð �Bkln�dof�i�g�nba=]�ghc�gh`ba:[+aK`�gP��WeaKm\aKWs�def���def�iJTKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=`B`bV���a3ghWD�Bdo`�U:s�def���def�i\n6Vf:`�U�alV\s��aKTK`�WeaKmaKWDU�gYn6s�a=aKf°gh��m\VQT3gh`ba=�:dof°ÛÜS/U�a@Ý v Þ t\ghf��^gJn�de[^deW�ghc'de��a3gU�gYnlghWecba@gY��p^sDaKaKf�_�nbaK�;def�ÛÜj;deWÎæ\Ý Þ ��BU�a�c�aKnb`�VhX1`�U�aJ��V/TK_�[+aKf/`Bdon�Vc�iQgYf�deåKaK�°ghn�X�V\WeWoVh�Bn3�'S/aKT=`bdeVf y denlg�s�cbdea�X7aK�/]�V\nbde`bdeV\f�VYX1`�U�aJ]�cbaKm/deV_�nl��Vcb�:V\f

± ² t1± õ t7j;aK`�g\j°­6t#ghf��H¯�cbaKn�U�j°­��'��_�c�`qp/]�a:n�p/nb`ba=[ðden���aKnbTKc�des�aK�ídef�S/a=TK`bdeVf z t'�BU�doWea:S/aKTK`�deVf�·;TKVf/`�ghdef�nJ`bU�a`bU�aKVc�aK`bdeT@gYW6��aKm\aKWeV]�[+aKf/`Bs�aKU�dof��£de`@� � f�S/a=TK`bdeVf x tD��a%]�cbaKn�aKf/`�`bU�a¢V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghW7n�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKnBVhX�`�U�a�WÎgYf�i_Dghia�gYf��]�c�Vhma:`bU�a^��pQ]Da r cbaKn�aKcbmgY`bdeVfÚghf�� r c�Vi\cbaKn�n:`bU�aKV\cbaK[�� � f/`baKf�n�deVf�gYW6TKV/��a°ghf�gYWepQn�den�den�def/`bc�V/��_�TKaK�ídefHS/aKTK`�doV\fÒç��¯#def�ghWeWepQtY��a�doWeWe_�n�`bc�gY`ba�`bU�aJ`qp/]�a�nbp/nb`�aK[��Bdo`�U^aK��gY[^]�WeaB]�c�Vic�gh[+n@thsDa�X�V\cbaJV_�`�Wedof�dof�i�`�U�a�X�_�`�_�cbaJ��Vcb�:def^S/a=TK`bdeVf���

� ���É����%ŹÆËÈ;Ã^Ç

� f�`�U�den1n�aKTK`�doV\f¢��a�cbaKm/deaK��`bU�a�]�c�aKm/deV_�n7��Vcb�JV\f�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\aKn�X�V\c'[+aK`�gP��]�c�Vi\c�gh[+[:def�i��/�BU�a�[^V\`bdemgh`�deVfBden7`bVlÿ/_�deT��/Wep]�c�aKnbaKf/`�`bU�a�def/`b_�de`bdeV\f�s�a=U�def��:`bU�a�mghc�deV_�n7T@gYWoT=_�Wed�t3f�V\`7`bVJidemaBg���aK`�ghdeWeaK�¢V\c7cbdeiV\cbV_�n1`�cba@gY`bdenba\�6¯�V\c1`�U�den7cba@gYnbVf#t��aWede[^de`�V\_�cbn�aKWemaKn7`�V�V\f�WepJV]DaKc�gY`bdeVf�gYWaK�/]DVn�do`�deVf'thsDaKT@gY_�nbaBde`#��aK[�gYf���n#`bU�a�Wea@ghn�`¹gY[^V\_�f/`�VhX�s�gYT��Qi\cbV\_�f���`�U�aKVc�aK`bdeT@gYW[�gYT�U�def�aKcbp/�¢¯�_�c�`bU�aKc�[^V\cbat#��a���aKn�TKcbdesDa;Vf�Wep;`bU�a:T=Vcba+]�ghc�`JVhXlg^W�gYf�i_�gYiat®s�_�`�def�`bU�a:]�c�aKnba=fQ`�aK�Ha=��gY[^]�WeaKnJ��aVhX-`baKf�ghn�nb_�[+a¢]�c�aKnba=f�TKa^VYXÌT=aKcb`�ghdef£`qp/]DaKn¢gYf��£`�aKcb[ôTKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=`bn@t7Wede�a%dof/`�aKiaKc�n@t#TKVf���de`bdeVf�gYWenlVcJc�aKTK_�c�nbdeVf't#�BU�deT�Ughc�alf�a=aK��aK�;`bV�deWeWo_�nb`bc�gh`�aB`bU�a�]�V\dof/`3� � f;ghf/p¢T3ghnba\t�gh����de`bdeVf�VhX'`�U�aKnbaJ�BdeWeW�f�aKm\aKcB]�c�aKnbaKf/`lgYfQp�`bU�aKVc�aK`bdeT@gYW�]�cbV\s�WeaK[^n3��BU�a^a=��gY[^]�Wea���a:�BdeWeW6_�nba:`�U�cbV\_�iU�V_�`�den�`�U�a:aK�/]DVf�aKf/`�dÎgY`bdeVf�X-_�f�TK`�doV\f't#]�cbaKn�aKf/`baK�ÚsDaKWeVh� defHg;j;def�j°­���Wede�a

f�V\`�gh`�deVf'���������������� ����!"��#%$�&%'(��#%$�&%'(��#�$�)

± �*!"��#%$�) ± #�!"��#%$*)����#��,+�$%- .�#0/1.3254�.6�876� �����:9;# &�/%<

=*>@? ACB�BU�a�X�_�f�TK`bdeV\f�ghW�]�cbVi\c�gY[^[^d�f�iB[^V\`bdemgh`�deVflsDaKU�def��:`�U�a�±D²�T@ghWeTK_�We_�n�don�`bVJaKf�n�_�cbaJ]�c�V]DaKc6nb`�ghi\dof�i�VYX�]�cbVi\c�gY[^n@�#¯�V\caK��gh[+]�Weat\TKVf�n�de��aKcl`�U�a�X�VWeWeVh�Bdef�i�aKÿ/_�demgYWoa=fQ`�VhX7V_�cBa=�Q]DVf�aKf/`bd�gh`�doV\f+X�_�f�TK`�deVf'�

�����%D ���E/F�����G�H������!"��#3$ &%'(��#3$ &%'(��#3$I)± #�!"��#%$*)

�G�H#,�,+H$%- .�# ± ��!"��#3$�)G/.3254�.

23.�$�J K%2HL��,� ���M9;#,&�/%<�G#

± ��!N��#%$�)��O7PL�9Q�R<.�#%S

��f�a�T@gYf°ghcbi\_�a�`�U�gh` � ���%D����R/ denB]�cba X�aKcbc�aK��`bV � ��� sDaKT@gh_�nba�de`lghWeWeVh�BnBg�]�ghc�`bd�ghW�aKmgYWe_�gh`�doV\f^VYX¹`�U�aJX�_�f�TK`bdeV\f^�BU�aKfVf�Wop ò don:�/f�Vh�Bf#t7s�_�`:f�V\`�T'� � f���aKaK�'t¸dofínb_�T�U�g�nbde`b_�gY`bdeVf#t6`bU�a�a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf � ���%D ���R/F# ]�cbV/��_�TKa=n�g�cbaKn�do��_�ghWX�_�f�TK`bdeVf�n�]�a=TKd�ghWedeåKaK�H`�V°TKV\[^]�_�`�def�i^`�U�a ò �q`bU�]DVh��a=c�VhXlde`bn�ghcbi\_�[^a=fQ`UT#� � f�]Dghcb`�deTK_�W�ghc3t'`�U�den�X�_�f�TK`bdeV\f£�BdeWeW6f�V\`]DaKcqX�V\cb[wghf/pJV]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�n6Vc7`�gh�aB��aKTKdenbdeVf�n�gh`7cb_�f/��`�de[^a6s�gYnbaK�:V\f:`bU�aBmgYWe_�a6VhX ò Ñ\dof%X�gYTK`@thde`7��V/aKn6f�V`6aKm\aKf:��aK]DaKf��Vf ò ��gYWeW�`bU�aJTKV\[^]�_�`�gh`�doV\f:nb`�aK]�nJ��aK]DaKf���a=fQ`�Vf ò U�g3ma�s�aKa=f°`�gY�aKf;��_�c�def�i:`bU�aJ]�gYcb`�dÎgYW�aKmghWe_�gY`bdeVf#�

y

Page 5: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

�BU�aB`qp/]�a�nbp/n�`baK[óVhX�± ² ghWeWeVh�Bn'`�U�a�]�cbVi\c�gY[^[^a=c�`bVln�]�a=TKd�X�p¢`�U�a�dof/`�aKf���aK�:n�`�gYidef�ilVYX�V]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�n7sQp�ghf�f�V\`�gY`bdef�inb_�s�`baKc�[^n6VYX�`�U�al]�cbVi\c�gY[ �BU�deT�U^ghc�aB`bV�sDa¢³=øoÖYª ©�Ô\tdq� a�#dof���aK]DaKf���aKf/`�VhX�`bU�a�mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn#X�cbV\[ `�U�aBnb_�c�cbV\_�f���def�i�TKV/��a��BU�aKfí`bU�a+`qp/]�a+nbp/nb`�aK[ T3ghfHT�U�a=T����BU�aK`bU�a=c:`bU�a+�Bcbde`b`�aKfHTKV/��a;TKV\f/X�V\cb[^nJ`�V£`�U�a^n�`�ghi\def�i°nb]DaKTKd���T3gh`bdeV\f't7[�gY�Qdef�inb`�ghi\dof�i¢aKc�cbV\cbnldef/`bV:`qp/]DaJaKcbc�Vcbn3�

VXW"Y(ZG[ ü �B� \ vU] ü_^a`ôücb ] ö�üVXZGdfeg[ Z �B� \ T ]�hi] ±�T#� ükj Zl]mZ ^ Z b ]3|�¾ noZk]3ì�»/~�|�¾ noprqsZ ^ á�â�Z btUu ò5v Z T v [xwzyQ{ �B� \ | ]m{}y T'� ü~�����p(ZG[ � �B� \ hl] ±(T'� ükj Zl]3|�¾ nPZ

�7V���aKTKW�gYcbaJ`bU�gY`Ìg%nb_�s�`baKc�[ Z VYX'`qpQ]DaJüèden6T=WoV\nbaK�#t�±D²�]�c�VhmQde��a=n�`�U�al`qp/]Da�T=Vf�n�`bcb_�TK`bV\clö ghf��:do`�n�def/`bc�V/��_�TK`�doV\f`ba=cb[ |6¾5n t/n�V�`bU�gY` |�¾ nPZ U�ghn�`qp/]�aJölü�Ï�TKV\f�nb_�We`�`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i�cb_�Woa=n�def^¯#dei_�c�a v@Ð � � `�den6def:`bU�den�nbaKf�nbaJ`bU�gY`6`bU�al`qp/]�aTKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`�Vclö!denBghnbn�V/TKd�gh`ba=�^�Bde`bU+TKWeVnba=�^TKV/��a� � f+`bU�a�nb]�dec�do`�VhX'`�U�denl��cb_�f���`�do[+a�T=VQ��alia=f�aKc�gY`bdeVf5�¢def/`baKc�]�cba=`�gh`�deVf't`bU�a�V\]�a=c�gh`�deVf�gYW'nba=[�ghf/`�doT=n���V/aKn�f�V`�]�c�VnbT=cbdes�a�cba=��_�TK`�doV\f�nl_�f���aKcB`�U�a�sDVh��Ñ/sDVh�/aK�;aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�n�gYcba�mgYWo_�aKn@��BU�a^a=Wode[+dofDgh`bdeV\f^X-Vcb[ X�Vc�ö�den ì�»/~�|6¾ n6p�qsZ ^ á-â�Z b ����]DaKc�gY`bdeVf�gYWeWop/t�de`�aKmgYWe_�gh`�aKn Z ^ `bV£g;sDVh�/aK��mghWe_�a\t

`bU�aKf°s�def���nB`�U�a�_�f�cbaK��_�TKaK��aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�_�f���aKc�`bU�gY`Bs�Vh�+`bV p def Z b �6¬�V`bdeTKa%`bU�gY` p denBf�V`lgYf�V\cb��def�gYcbp:mgYcbd�ghs�Wea��de`�n�`�gYf���nBX-VcBghf^_�f�aKmghWe_�gY`baK��³=øoÖYª ©�Ô�aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f'tDc�gh`�U�aKcB`�U�ghf°g%mghWe_�a�#�BU�den�X�ghT=`B[^V`�demgh`ba=n1UDg3mQdef�i�`q��V¢mgYcbd�ghs�WeaTKV\fQ`�aK�/`bn�def°`�U�a�`qpQ]�dof�i���_���i[^a=fQ`3� { X�V\c�V\cb��def�gYcbp;mghWe_�a%mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn@t�ghf�� w X�VcJTKWeV\nbaK��aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f£mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn3� � fVc���aKc�`bV�U�g3ma�]�cbV\]�a=c�n�`�ghi\def�i�t\TKWeVn�aK�^TKV/��aJaK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�nBn�U�V_�We�+f�V`6��aK]�a=f��;Vf^mgYWe_�aBmghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn7X�c�V[ { t\s�_�`�`bU�aKpT@gYf���aK]�a=f��°Vf;aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf°mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�X�c�V[ w ��BU�a�n�`�ghi\def�i¢VYX � ���%D����R/ T@ghf°sDaJ[�gY��alaK�/]�WedeTKde`�dof;`�U�a�X�VWeWeVh�Bdef�iJ�Ìg3p/������%D �����1�����G�H������!"��#3$�&%' ö 9f��#%$ &3'(��#%$R<�)

± #*!"��#%$�)�G�H#,�,+H$%- .�#HD����M9 ± ��!N��#%$�)�/%<.3254�.

23.�$�D ����L��,� ���M9;#,&�/%<�G#

D ���M9 ± ��!"��#3$�)i�O7oL�9;�R<3<.�#%S

u ]�]�WedoT3gh`bdeV\f^VhX � ���%D ��� � gh`Bghcbi\_�[^a=fQ` y ]�c�VQ��_�TKaKnJg�s�Vh�/aK�+X�_�f�TK`bdeVfËX�VcBn�ÿ/_�ghc�dof�i��&�4f�3D ������� ���%D ��� �o���J�K%2�4f�%D ������D ���M9 ± ��!"��#3$�)��O7

9 ±5� !"�G#%$�) � 79 ±5� !N��#%$�)�/%< � <��0<�! ö 9f��#3$8&%'8��#%$E<

� `BT@gYf�`�U�aKf°sDaJaKmghWe_�gY`baK�;def^V\cb��a=cl`bV:sDa�gh]�]�WodeaK�+de`bnba=WÙX��&�4f�,�M9"2%.�$�D ����L,�O4f�%D����8��#,LR<(�J�K%2�4f�������%#3��!���#3$8&%'8��#%$&�4f�����J�K%28��$��8��!���#3$

=*>�= AC��BU�a°±D²ónb`�ghidef�i�VhX � ���%D ��� � �BU�deT�UÚ�Bghn:]�c�aKnba=fQ`�aK�!dofí`bU�a�]�cbaKm/deV_�n:nbaKTK`�deVf'tBWea@g3m\aKn^g�WeV`�`bV�sDa;��aKnbdec�aK�'� � f]�gYcb`bdeTK_�WÎgYc@t�`�U�a:cba=nbde��_�gYW�]�c�Vi\c�gh[+nl`�U�gh` � ���3D ��� � ]�cbV/��_�T=aKn@t7a� iD� 4f�3D ��� tDTKVf/`�gYdef£mgYcbd�ghs�Wea��-X�V\cq�qmghcbd�gYs�Wea�c�aK��deTKaKn3tghf���U�aKf�TKa°gYcba^f�V`:ghn�a��^T=doa=fQ`:ghn�Vf�a:��V\_�We���ÌgYfQ`3�°�BU�a+cba@gYnbV\f't7VhXlTKV\_�cbn�at6den�`bU�gY`�sDVh�Qa=���hTKV/��a+aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�nghc�a:mghWe_�aKn3Ñ�`bU�aKp£T=V[^]�Woa=`baKWep;nb_�n�]�a=f��H`�U�a¢a=mghWe_�gh`�deVf°VYXÌ`�U�a¢a=f�TKWeVn�aK�H`�aKcb[�� u nJ�Bde`bf�aKnbn�aK�Hs/p°`�U�a:aK��gh[+]�Wea�VhX4f�%D���� t\do`�[�g3p�sDa�gY��mghf/`�ghia=V_�n�`bV�U�g3ma�g%iaKf�aKc�gYW']�c�Vic�gh[+[^dÙf�il[^a=T�UDghf�denb[ ^ �BU�aKc�aKs/p�V\f�alT=V_�We�;nb]DaKTKd�X�p+`bU�gY`TKaKc�`�gYdof�c�aK��_�T=`bdeVf�n b def£g+TKV/��a:aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVfHghc�a:`bV;`�gY�a�]�W�ghTKa\�¥�¸XBTKV_�cbnba\t6±�²!ghWecba3gh��p°T=Vf/`�gYdof�n�[+aKT�U�ghf�don�[^nB`�V

�@���G�f�� (¡*¢¤£�¡�¥§¦�¨�¡@£�¡@��¨¡ª©�¥§¦c��«"¬­¡@¨��f¥§¦f®�¬­«"£¡R¨�f¢"¦I¯��f�¨�©f¡ª°�¥§��¥§¦f®}¢¤¦X«"±�¡ª£¢"¨�¥§«¤¦f¢"²G�¡ª¬­¢¤¦G¨¥§³ª�  ��f¥§³��c�³ª¢"¦f��´�«;µG¡@©­¡ªµ�±f£�¡@���¥§«"¦f� ¢"¦f©¢"³@¨��f¢"²§²§¶I£�¡@©f�f³ª¡ª�(¢"²§²�°Q¢¤£�¥§¢"´f²§¡�·¹¸º«"£¹·»°;¢"£»¥§¢¤´G²§¡�£¡ª©f¥§³@¡ª�@¼½¤¾ ¦f©X�f¡@£�¡¤¿"£�¡@©f�f³ª¨¥§«"¦f� ¢"£¡��f¦f©f¡ª£��¨«�«G©}¥§¦À¨��f¡�´f£«"¢"©f¡@£��¡ª¦f�¡R«;¸�Á·ó@¢"²§³ª�f²§�f�@¿;¥¹¼ ¡"¼G¨�f¡ª¶�³ª¢¤¦X«�³ª³ª�f£(�f¦f©f¡ª£(¢­Á�·»¢"´f�¨�£¢"³ª¨¥§«"¦%¼

z

Page 6: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

Ä�¼�Å6»���Æ7»���Ç�á�â�È

w Ñ {zÉFh � vT'� ü8Ê {

w Ñ {zÉ T°�hüp � ü8Ê w

w Ñ {ËÉgp �hü

w Ñ {Iy T#� ü ÉzZ ��Ìw Ñ {�É ±�T#� ükj Z �hü�`ÍÌ

w Ñ {�ÉzZ ^J�hü,`ÍÌ w Ñ {gÉËZ b��Yüw Ñ {�ÉzZ ^ Z bJ��Ì

w ÑG| ÉzZ �Yüw Ñ {�É+|6¾ n6Z �ö�ü

w Ñ {ËÉzZ ^l�ö�ü wzy;p � ü�Ñ {zÉzZ b���Ìw Ñ {�É+ì�»/~�|6¾ nPp1qsZ ^ á-â�Z b ��Ì

ÎkÅ6»/�h��~@á-¾Dâ1��ì¹}=»%Ï���â'~3áq�}

h�Ð ` h ±(T#� ülj ZXÐ `ð±(T'� ülj ZZ ^ Ð ` ±�T#� ülj Z Z b Ð ` � b Û � b¤Ñ T ÞÒZ­Ð ` �

Z ^ Z b Ð ` �

|6¾ n6ZXÐ ` |6¾ n6ZZ ^ Ð ` |6¾ noZ Û Z Ñ p�ÞÒZ b Ð ` �ì-»Q~%|6¾ noprqsZ ^ á�â�Z b Ð ` �

¯'dei\_�cba v �7��p/]�def�i:ghf��°ï7mgYWo_Dgh`bdeV\f:cb_�WeaKn�X�V\cl±�²¸�

·

Page 7: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

{�É(Ó�h � vT'� ü Ó Ê {{ËÉ(Ó T;�Yü

{Iy T#� ü ÓÔÉ(Ó�Z �%Ì{�É(Ó ±�T#� ülj Z �hü�`ÕÌ

{�É Ó Z ^ �hü�`ÍÌ {�É Ó Z b �hü{zÉ(Ó�Z ^ Z b ��Ì

{zÉ Ó%Ö ^ Z �hü{zÉ(Ó:â1»%n�~iZ �ùíü

{�É(ÓÔZ �ùíü{�É(Ó3Ö ^ Å7�h»%×oZ �hü

¯'dei\_�cba y �7��p/]�def�i�cb_�WeaKnBVYX¹±Dõ°�

aKf�T=VQ��a°nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf�n:VhXlTKWeVn�aK�ÚTKV/��at�s�_�`:`�U�aKc�a�den:f�V��Bg3p£`�V�]�aKc X�Vc�[ðnb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f�n:VhXJV]DaKfÚTKV/��a;�BU�deT�Uídencba=ÿQ_�doc�aK�Hdef�`bU�a 4f�3D ��� aK��gY[^]�Wea�:�BU�a:nbVWe_�`�deVf�nbU�V\_�We��s�a:`�V°aK�/`baKf��H`bU�a^f�V\`bdeVf�VhXBTKV/��a^`�V°def�TKWe_���a:f�V`�V\f�WepTKWeVn�aK�^a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n3t�s�_�`ÌgYWon�V�aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�nB�BU�deT�U:[�g3pJTKV\fQ`�ghdef:X-cbaKa�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn@�#�BU�a�±Dõ%�qT@ghWeTK_�We_�nJÛ ê g3m�æ\ç Þ ]�c�VhmQde��a=nnbV\[^a�VhX1`�U�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK�;�DaK�/dos�doWede`qp/�

VXW"Y�Z�[ ü ���(\ vU] ü_^*`ôü�b ] ùíüVXZGdfeg[ Z ���(\ T ]�hl] ±(T#� ükj Zl]mZ ^ Z b ]3â7»%n�~iZl]�Å7�h»%×PZtUu ò5v Z T v [ { ���(\ | ]m{}y T'� ü Ó~Ø����p(ZG[ ��Ù ���(\ hl] ±(T'� ülj Zl]3â7»%n�~i� ^

� Ó3Ö ^ ���(\ hl] ±(T'� ülj � Ó%Ö ^ ]�� Ó3Ö ^^ � Ó%Ö ^b ]3â7»%n�~i� Ó3Ö b ]�Å7�h»%×P� Ó Ï òFÚ Ý Ð�BU�a6[+V`bdemgY`bdeVf�s�a=U�def��¢±Dõ�den'`�VBaKf�n�_�cbaBghf��J[;ghdef/`�ghdefBg�`baK[+]�V\c�gYWh��denb`bdef�T=`bdeVfJsDaK`q��a=aKf¢WeaKm\aKWen�VhX�TKV\[^]�_�`�gh`�doV\f't

X�V\cB`bU�a�]�_�cb]DVn�aKnJVhX1]Dghcb`�d�ghW'a=mghWe_�gh`�deVf'�6S/VDt/X�V\cBaK��gh[+]�Weat`�U�a�TKV\[^]�_�`�gh`�deVf^[;ghc��aK�+`bV:sDa�Vf;WeaKma=W1Ý�nbU�V_�We�;s�aaK�/aKTK_�`baK����cbn�`ldef;`bU�a%nbT�U�aK[+a�VYX6]�ghc�`bd�ghW�aKmgYWe_�gh`�doV\f'Ñ/TKV\[^]�_�`�gh`�doV\f:Vf°WeaKm\aKW v denl]DVn�`b]DVf�aK��ghf��;Vs�`�ghdef�a=� gYnB`bU�acba=nbde��_�gYW�VYX'`bU�a�Woa=maKW�ÝJaKmgYWo_Dgh`bdeV\f't3aK`bT���BU�al`qp/]DaBnbp/nb`�aK[wVYX1±�õwgYWeWoVh�Bn7`�U�al]�c�Vi\c�gh[+[^aKc#`bV���aKTKVc�gh`�al`ba=cb[^n��Bdo`�U`ba=[^]DVc�gYW�ghf�f�V`�gh`bdeV\f�n@�#�BU�aKf;`bU�al`qp/]�a=T�U�aKT��Qdef�i:a=f�nb_�c�aKnl`�U�gh`�`bU�al]�c�Vic�gh[óTKV\f/X�Vc�[^n6`�V�`bU�a�WeaKm\aKWDnb]DaKTKd���T@gY`bdeVf�n3t`b_�cbf�def�i:n�`�ghi\def�i¢a=cbcbV\cbn�dof/`�V¢`qp/]Da�aKcbc�Vc�n@t@� _�nb`Jghn�dof°±D²B��7V°[�gYcb�°`�U�gh`:g°T=aKcb`�ghdefH`�aKcb[ðVYXl`qp/]�a+ü�den�]�V\nb`b]DVf�aK�'t6dq� a�#Vf�`�U�a^n�_�s�nba=ÿQ_�aKf/`^`ba=[^]DVc�gYW6TKV/��a;WeaKma=W�t6±Dõ

]�c�VhmQde��a=nB`bU�a�[+V/��ghWD`qp/]�aJTKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`�Vc�ù!t/�Bde`bU;de`bnBTKV\cbcba=nb]DVf���def�i+defQ`�cbV/��_�T=`bdeVf;`ba=cb[ â7»%n�~ � � f;TKVf/`bc�ghn�`l`bV^±D²BtU�Vh��aKma=c@tD]�V\nb`�]�V\f�aK�°`�aKcb[+nBdof°±Dõ�T@ghf�TKVf/`�gYdef^X-cbaKa�V/TKT=_�cbc�aKf�TKaKn�VhX7mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn�X�c�V[�`bU�a�`�U�a�n�_�cbc�V_�f���dof�i^`qp/]�def�iTKV\fQ`�aK�/`@t�n�V^WeVf�i�ghn�`bU�a=p£ghc�a¢[;ghcb�\aK�;`bV+s�a�Vf°`�U�a�n�gh[+aJTKV/��a¢WeaKm\aKWBÏ�n�aKa^¯#doi\_�cba yÐ � � `�denl`bU�don�]�cbV\]�a=cb`qp�VhX6`bU�aT@gYWoT=_�We_�nB`bU�gY`lU�gYnlghn�nbV/TKd�gh`�aK�°`bU�a�f�V`�deVf;VhXlÖ�Ó�©3¦:TKV/��a��Bde`bU;`�U�a�`qp/]�a%TKVf�n�`bc�_�TK`bV\c�ù!t�def;TKV\fQ`�c�gYnb`l`�V:`bU�a+³KøeÖhªK©�ÔTKV/��a�VYX¹ö dof°±D²B���]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghWeWep/tgJ]DVnb`�]�V\f�aK�+aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�Ï â7»%n�~�Z@Ð don�f�V`6i\aKf�aKc�ghWeWep¥g�mghWe_�atgYn�Ï |6¾ nPZ3Ð ��V_�Wo��sDaldef^±�²¸�7�BU�a

±DõôT@ghWeTK_�Wo_�n¢U�gYn¢n�aK]�gYc�gh`�a;aKmghWe_�gY`bdeVf�cbaKW�gY`bdeVf�n�X�Vc�a@ghT�UíTKV/��a^WeaKm\aKWqÑ6cba=��_�TK`�doV\f�n:[�g3p�U�gh]�]DaKfí_�f���aKc â7»%n�~ defâ7»%n�~ÔZ t�gYWosDaKde`�Vf�Wep^gh`B`�U�a�n�_�s�`ba=cb[^nBVYX Z �BU�doT�U°ghc�aJVf;WeVh��aKc�TKV/��a�WeaKm\aKWenB`bU�gYf Z de`bnba=WÙX���BU�ala=Wode[+dofDgh`bdeV\flX-Vcb[�X�V\c�ù don Å1�h»%×PZ t�BU�aKcba Z den�VhX�TKV/��aJ`qp/]�a� � f/`�_�de`bdemaKWep/t Å1�h»%× den6_�n�aK�^`�V�TKV[+]�V\nbaBTKV/��a

aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�n@t�s/p:nb]�WedeTKdef�i�do`�nÌgYcbi\_�[^aKf/`6def/`bV%`bU�aJnb_�cbcbV\_�f���def�i�`ba=cb[£�6j Vcba�]�cba=TKdenbaKWep/t�`bU�alV]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�ghW�sDaKU�g3m/deVc�VhXÅ7�h»%×PZ nb`�gYcb`�n�s/p;aKmgYWo_Dgh`bdef�i Z Vf�`bU�a�]�cba=mQdeV\_�nJ`bde[^aJWeaKma=W�� � X�`�U�a�]�c�aKm/doV\_�nJdenlWeaKma=W¹Ý�tD`bU�a�cbaK��_�TK`bdeV\f£denlsDV_�f��`bV�]�c�VQ��_�TKa�g�]DVn�`b]DVf�a=��a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf â7»%n�~ÔZ¤Û Ñ/`bU�aKf Å7�h»%× ghf�� â1»%n�~ T@ghf�T=aKW'a@gYT�U^V`�U�aKc3t�ghf�� Z¤Û don�cba=`b_�c�f�aK�;`bV�s�anb]�WodeTKa=�°defQ`�V¢`�U�a�n�_�cbc�V_�f���dof�i^`ba=cb[£t/�BU�doT�U;denlde`bn�aKW�X6VhX1WeaKm\aKW v � � f°T3ghnba=nlVhX6U�dei\U�aKclT=VQ��a�WeaKmaKWen3t�`bU�a�aKmghWe_�gY`bdeVf+VhXZ [;g3p¢]�c�V/��_�TKa�[+Vc�alia=f�aKc�gYW'aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�n3t�n�V:f�V:T@gYf�TKaKWeW�gh`�doV\f^denB]�c�aKnbTKc�des�aK��s/p:`bU�a%V]DaKc�gY`bdeVf�gYW�nbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKn3��BU�aBaK�/]DVf�aKf/`�dÎgY`bdeVf�X-_�f�TK`�doV\f¢def:±�õ�T@gYf:s�a�nb`�ghia=�^ghn6`�U�a�X�_�f�T=`bdeVf � ��� .�Ü(Ý �GÜ(Ý�� s�a=WoVh���#¤�a�U�Vdenb`�`bU�aBU�a=Wo]DaKc

X�_�f�TK`bdeVf � ���(Ý���Ü(Ý�Þ V\_�`bn�de��aJVhX1`�U�a�[;ghdef:TKV/��a�X�VcBsDaK`�`baKc�cba@gY��ghs�deWede`qpQ�

x

Page 8: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

±�T#� ülj Z ÙÐ `ð±(T'� ülj ZZ ^ ÙÐ `ð±(T#� ülj Z Z b ÙÐ ` � b Û � b Ñ T Þ�Z ÙÐ ` �

Z ^ Z b ÙÐ ` �

h ÓÐ ` hZ Ó%Ö ^Ð ` �

±(T#� ülj Z Ó%Ö ^Ð ` ±(T'� ülj �Z ^ Ó3Ö ^Ð ` � ^ Z b Ó3Ö ^Ð ` � b

Z ^ Z b Ó%Ö^

Ð ` � ^ � b

Z Ó3Ö ^Ð ` �â7»%n�~iZ ÓÐ ` â7»3n�~��

Z ÙÐ ` â7»3n�~i�Å7�h»%×PZ ^Ð ` �

Z Ó3Ö ^Ð ` �Å1�h»%×PZ Ó3Ö bÐ ` Å7�h»%×P�

¯#dei_�c�a z �7�l]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�ghW7S/aK[�gYf/`bdeTKn�VhX¹± õ �

�����(Ý ��Ü�Ý�Þi�������������Þ%! ù ��#%$ &%'���#%$3&%' ù ��#%$�)± .I! ù �G#%$�) ± #�!"��#%$*)

����#��,+H$%-�.�#�# .��%$0/.%254�.

2%.�$�J K%26L,�H������ÞË.ß9;#,&0/%<��#

# .��3$ß9Q�%Ü .�J,.�76�%Ü�.�J�LR<.�#%S

�����(Ý ��Ü�Ý��ß!��G#%$,&%' ù 9f��#%$�&%'(��#%$E<à�± #�!"�G#%$�)

#�.��%$ ± ��!"��#%$*)g�3Ü .�J� ���(Ý �GÜ(Ý�Þ�9;#�.��%$��R<á#

��s�nbaKc�maJU�Vh��`�U�al`qp/]DalVYX �����(Ý ��Ü�Ý�� def���doT3gh`ba=n�`�U�aln�`�ghi\def�i�VhX'`�U�aBX-_�f�TK`�doV\f'� r ghc�`bd�ghW�gY]�]�WedeT@gh`�deVf:VhX � ���(Ý �GÜ(Ý��`bV�ghf�dof/`�aKiaKc ò �BdeWeW�]�c�V/��_�TKaJg�X�_�f�T=`bdeVf%X�Vc�]�Vh��aKcbdef�iJs/p ò tVYX�`qp/]Da �G#%$ &%'(�G#%$ t3s�_�`�Vf�`bU�a�nb_�s�nbaKÿ/_�aKf/`�`baK[+]�V\c�gYWWeaKma=W��

&�4f��Ý ��Ü(ÝP�������(Ý ��Ü�Ý��6���J�K%2�4f�(Ý ��Ü�Ý1��# .��%$M9 ± ��!N��#%$�)��87�9;�87â/%<%<O! ù 9Â��#%$ &%'���#%$R<�BU�aJX�_�f�TK`bdeV\f 4f��Ý ��Ü(Ý ��V/aKnlf�V`lT=Vf/`�gYdof;_�f�f�aKTKaKn�n�gYcbp�cbaK��deTKa=n�gYnl��de� 4f�%D���� �}ã�Vh��a=maKc3t�±Dõ���V/aKn�f�V`�]�aKc�[^de`

TKV/aKc�TKdeVf�n�VhX1`�aKcb[+n�sDaK`q��aKaKf°��dÙä�aKc�aKf/`lTKV/��aJWeaKma=Won3t/nbV:de`�don�f�V\`B]�V\nbnbdes�WeaJ`bV���aK[+V`�al`bU�alX-_�f�TK`�doV\f 4f�(Ý �GÜ(Ý `�V¢TKV/��aWeaKma=WlÝ�dofíVc���aKc:`bV�aKmgYWo_Dgh`ba;de`;Ï�`bU�a�`qp/]Da;nbp/nb`�aK[ ��V/aKn:f�V\`¥gYWoWeVh� Å7�h»%× `�V£V/TKTK_�c^VfíTKV/��a;WeaKmaKWJÝ Ð �H�BU�den�denVf�Wop^g�n�V_�f���sDaKU�g3m/deVc��:V]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�ghW#nbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKn�VhX7Woa=maKW7Ý�]�cbV\nbTKc�dosDaKnJg�_�nb_�gYW'aKmgYWe_�gh`�doV\f:VhX6`bU�a�`�aKcb[�t�ghf��;`�U�denaKmgYWo_Dgh`bdeV\f:donB��a���f�aK��Vf�Wep:d�X1`�U�aJ`baKc�[�def^ÿ/_�a=nb`bdeV\f�denBTKWeV\nbaK�'��Z�V/��aJmghWe_�aKn�def�±Dõô¨¢§\¶lTKV\f/`�ghdef+mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn�sDV_�f��V_�`bnbde��aJVYX1`bU�aK[£t/n�V:`bU�a�`qp/]DaJnbp/nb`�aK[£t/TKV\f�nba=cbmgh`�demaKWep/t\X�Vc�s�de��nB`bU�a=docBa=mghWe_�gh`�deVf'�

=*>ä åçæ�èGéêåçëj;aK`�gj°­�TKV\[:s�def�aKn6`�U�alf�V\`bdeVf�n6VhX'TKV/��a¸X�cbV\[ó`bU�a�`q��V�]�cbaKm/deV_�n�nbp/n�`baK[+n@t/nbV%`bU�gY`�]�c�Vi\c�gh[+n7T@ghf+s�a�[�ghf�do]�_�W�gh`ba=�def£`�U�a:nb`qp/Wea:VhXl±Dõ;t's�_�`�T@ghf�ghWen�V�sDa^[;gh��a%`bc�gYf�nbT=aKf��H`�U�aKdec�TKV/��a:WeaKm\aKWen^Ï�Wede�a�TKV/��a:aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�n�VhXl±�² Ð ghf���def]�gYcb`bdeTK_�WÎgYc�sDa^aK�/aKTK_�`baK�'���7V°nbde[^]�Wod�X�p+`bU�a;ghc�i_�[+aKf/`bnJU�aKc�at6��a:V[+do`�`bU�a;j;aK`�gj°­íX-a@gh`�_�cbaKn%X�V\c�TKV/aKcbT=dof�i£TKV/��aaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�n:def/`bV;U�deiU�a=c�TKV/��a^WeaKm\aKWen@t7ghf���]�cbaKn�aKf/`:Vf�Wep°`�U�a:X�c�ghi\[^aKf/`lc�aKWeaKmghf/`�`bV;`bU�aKdec¢aK�/aKT=_�`bdeVf#�;¤�a�X�VWeWeVh�ÛÜZBj°S�Ý v�Þ def^`�U�aJaK�/]�V\nbde`bdeVf#�

ç

Page 9: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

w Ñ {gÉ(Ózh � vT#� ü Ó Ê {

w Ñ {�É(Ó T;�Yüp � ü Ó Ê w

w Ñ {zÉ(ÓÔp �hü

w Ñ {Iy T#� ü Ó�É(ÓiZ ��Ìw Ñ {�É(Ó ±(T#� ülj Z �hü,`ìÌ

w Ñ {gÉ(Ó�Z ^l�hü�`ÍÌ w Ñ {ËÉ(ÓiZ bJ�üw Ñ {�É(Ó�Z ^ Z b ��Ì

w Ñ {ËÉ(Ó%Ö ^ Z �hüw Ñ {zÉ(Ó�í�Z Ú � í ü Ú

w Ñ {zÉ(ÓiZ � í ü Úw Ñ {�É(Ó3Ö ^cî Z �hü

w Ñ {ËÉ(ÓiZ � Vw Ñ {gÉ(Ó�Z ��Û V�Þ

wgï Ó�Ñ�| É Ó Z �hüw Ñ {�É(Ó�Z ��Û ü Þ

w Ñ {zÉ(ÓiZ ��Û ü Þw Ñ {gÉ(Ó�Z �hü

w Ñ {zÉ Ó Z ^J� V wzyQp � V Ó�Ñ {ËÉ Ó Z bJ�hüw Ñ {zÉ Ó ì�»/~h��p1qsZ ^ á-â�Z b �hü

w Ñ {�É Ó Z ��Û í ü Ú Þw Ñ {ËÉ(Ó��fð7â�Z ��Û ü Þ

¯#dei_�cbaJ·��6S/a=Woa=TK`baK��`qpQ]�dof�i¢c�_�WeaKnlVYX¹j;aK`�gj°­��

VXW¤Y�Z�[ ü �B� \ vk] üU^*`ôücb ] Û ü Þê]3í ü Út � u [GZ�ñ v W¤Y�Z�[ V �B� \ vk] ü�` Vò] Û ü ÞVXZ�dfe�[ Z �B� \ T ]�hl] ±(T'� ülj ZU]fZ ^ Z b ]�í�Z Ú ] î Zl]P�fð1â6Zl]3ì-»/~P�gp1qsZ ^ á�â�Z btUu ò5v Z T v [ { �B� \ | ]f{}y T'� ü Ót � u [GZ�ñ�ó u ò5v Z T v [ w �B� \ | ]fwzyQp � V Ó~�����p(Z�[ � Ù �B� \ hi] ±�T#� ükj Zl]3íô� ^ Ú

� Ó%Ö ^ �B� \ hi] ±�T#� ükj � Ó%Ö ^ ]f� Ó3Ö ^^ � Ó3Ö ^b ]�í�� Ó%Ö b Ú ] î � Ó Ï òFÚ Ý ÐX]�fð7â�� Ó%Ö ^ ]3ì-»/~P�gp�qç� Ó3Ö ^^ á-â�� Ó%Ö ^b

j;aK`�gj°­înb`�gYcb`�nl�Bde`bU+`bU�a�]DVn�`b]DVf�a=���hV\]�aKf�TKV/��a�`qp/]�aJVYX�±Dõ;t�gYf��;defQ`�cbV/��_�T=aKnlW�ghf�i_�gYialT=Vf�n�`bcb_�TK`bnJ`bV:c�a���f�a`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i�VhXl`bU�Vnba;TKV/��a;def�n�`�ghf�TKaKn:�BU�deT�UHU�gY]�]DaKfH`�V£sDa;TKWeVnba=�'���BU�a;`qpQ]�dof�i£ghf��íV]DaKc�gY`bdeVfDghW�nbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKn�VhXj;aK`�gj°­íghc�a¢]�c�aKnba=fQ`�aK��def°¯'dei\_�cbaKnJ·;ghf�� x tDc�aKnb]DaKTK`�dom\aKWepQt#ghf��£gYcba�n�de[^deW�ghc6`�V^`bU�Vnba�VhX�±Dõ°tD�BU�deT�U;`bU�aKp�aK�/`baKf���Bde`bU;`bU�a�f�aK�è`�aKcb[ gYf��^`qp/]Da�TKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`�Vc�n@��BU�a:[^V/��gYW�`qp/]�a:TKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=`bVc%VhXÌj;a=`�gj�­Hden í ü Ú �Bde`bU°def/`bc�V/��_�TK`�doV\f°X-Vcb[ í�Z Ú ghf��°a=Wode[+dofDgh`bdeV\f:X�V\cb[ î Z t

TKV\cbcba=nb]DVf���def�i�`�VHùíü¢t â7»%n�~�Z gYf�� Å7�h»3×PZ defÒ±Dõ°�1ãlVh��aKm\aKc@t�j;aK`�g\j°­«gh����n^g°`qp/]Da;cba���f�aK[^aKf/`;Û ü Þ �BU�deT�UTKW�ghn�nbd���aKn+`baKc�[^n+VhX�`qp/]�a°üÍ�Bde`�UÒf�V�X�c�aKa°mghWe_�a;mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn3��¬�V`ba�`bU�gY`^de`:��V/aKn^f�V`^UDg3ma;TKVc�cbaKn�]�V\f���def�iÚ`ba=cb[TKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`�Vc�n@���BU�a�`qpQ]�dof�i���_���i[^a=fQ`Bdef/`bc�V/��_�TKaKn%do[+]�WedeTKde`�TKV/aKc�TKdeVf�X�cbV\[ðÛ ü Þ defQ`�V^ü��J�BU�a¢V\]�]DVnbde`�a¢TKV/aKc�TKdeVf�denghWen�V¢]DVn�nbdes�WeaJdÙX7`bU�aJ`qp/]Da�ü«denk�bTKWeV\nbaK� �D�6Z�WeVnba=��`qp/]DaKn�gYcbaJaKn�nbaKf/`bd�gYWoWep:`�U�Vn�a�`qp/]�aKnB�BU�VnbaJmgYWo_�aKnBT@ghf�f�V`�cba�X-aKcl`�VV_�`bnbde��aJmgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�X-cbV[ýU�deiU�aKcBT=VQ��a�WeaKmaKWen�Ï a� i��7s�gYnba�`qp/]DaKn@t#Û Þ �bghf�f�V\`�gY`baK�+TKV/��a�`qp/]�a=n@tDVc�X�_�f�TK`bdeV\f�nB�Bde`bU^T=WoV\nbaK�TKV/��V\[�ghdef�n Ð ��ï7�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�n�`bU�gY`JT@ghf�s�a^gYnbn�doi\f�aK��g+TKV/��a:`qp/]�a��BU�deT�U£denJTKWeVn�aK��def°`bU�denJnba=f�nbat7T3ghf�sDa¢aKmgYWe_�gh`�aK�_�n�dof�i:`bU�aJW�ghf�i\_�ghi\alTKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=`bVc �fð7â �S/de[^deW�ghc�Wop:`�V°±�²Bt7j;aK`�gj°­ín�]�Wedo`�nJ`bU�a:`qp/]�def�i;TKV\fQ`�aK�/`�def/`bV^`q��V;]�ghc�`bn3� { X-VcJVc���def�ghc�p°mghWe_�a�mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn@t�gYf��

w X-VcJmghc�dÎgYs�WeaKnlVYXÌT=WoV\nbaK��`qp/]DaKn@�Ë�BU�a:Vc���def�ghc�p°mghWe_�a�TKVf/`�aK�/`�den�T=Woa3ghcba=���BU�aKf�T�U�aKT��/def�i£g+`baKc�[ gYiQghdef�n�`�g£Û Þ �ghf�f�V`�gh`ba=��`qpQ]Da� u `baKc�[ðTKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`�Vc ì-»/~P�gp�qsZ ^ á-â�Z b:n�aKcbm\aKn:`bV�dof/`�cbV/��_�TKa+mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKnJdefQ`�V°`bU�a^TKWeVn�aK��`qp/]�aTKV\fQ`�aK�/`@t�nbV:`bUDgh`B`bU�aKp�gYcba�f�V\`BaKc�gYnbaK���BU�aKf;`qp/]�def�i¢T=WoV\nbaK��TKV/��a���_�claK��gY[^]�WeaB�Bde`bU;`bU�a�a=�Q]DVf�aKf/`bd�gh`�doV\f+X�_�f�TK`�deVf^T3ghf°sDaJTKV/��aK�°def�j aK`�g\j°­�ghnBn�U�Vh�Bf;s�aKWeVh���

Page 10: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

±�T#� ülj Z ÙÐ `ð±(T'� ülj ZZ ^ ÙÐ `ð±(T#� ülj Z Z b ÙÐ ` � b Û � b Ñ T Þ�Z ÙÐ ` �

Z ^ Z b ÙÐ ` �

h ÓÐ ` hZ Ó%Ö ^Ð ` �

±(T#� ülj Z Ó%Ö ^Ð ` ±(T'� ülj �Z ^ Ó3Ö ^Ð ` � ^ Z b Ó3Ö ^Ð ` � b

Z ^ Z b Ó%Ö^

Ð ` � ^ � b

Z Ó%Ö ^Ð ` �í�Z Ú ÓÐ ` í�� Ú

Z ÙÐ ` í�� Úî Z

^Ð ` �

Z Ó%Ö ^Ð ` �î Z Ó%Ö bÐ ` î �

Z ÙÐ ` í�� ^ Ú � ^ ÙÐ ` � Ù

�fð7âoZ ÙÐ ` � Ù

Z ^ ÙÐ ` � ^ Û � ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z b ÙÐ ` �

ì-»/~P�gp1qsZ ^ á-â�Z b ÙÐ ` �

Z Ó3Ö^

Ð ` ��fð7âoZ Ó3Ö ^Ð ` �fð7â��

Z ^ Ó3Ö ^Ð ` � ^ Z b Ó3Ö ^Ð ` � b

ì�»/~h��p1qsZ ^ á-â�Z b Ó3Ö ^Ð ` ì�»/~h��p1qs� ^ á�â�� b

¯#dei_�c�a x �6��]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghW'S�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKn�VYXlÏ�g%nbaKWeaKTK`�aK��X�c�gYi[^a=fQ`�VhX Ð j aK`�g\j°­6�

������õ�.�$�KIÞi�������������Þ%!%��ö(��#%$ 'P&%'8��#%$�&%'�ö(��#%$�'���)± .I!ªö(�G#%$ 'I) ± #�!"��#3$�)

����#��,+H$%-�.�#,ö�/�'.%254�.

2%.�$�J K%26L,�H������ÞË.ß9;#,&0/%<��#

ö(÷f.�7�÷�L '.�#%S

������õ�.�$�K%�ß!��G#%$,&%'ø�ªö(��#%$�&%'(��#%$�'��1�± #�!"�G#%$�)

23.�$(Ý�#,��#� ����õ�.�$ K}Þg��� ����õ�.�$ K}Þ

�G#ö ± ��!"��#3$�)�÷(9;� ����õ�.�$ KIÞùö�� '6#R<�'

.�#%S¬lV\`bdeTKa�U�Vh�H`�U�a�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn # gYf�� ������õ�.�$�KIÞ dof%`bU�aBsDV/��p�VhXD`bU�a�X�_�f�T=`bdeVf � ����õ�.�$ K3� ghc�a�`�c�ghf�nqX�aKc�cbaK�+defQ`�Vl`�U�a�T=WoV\nbaK�`qp/]�aBT=Vf/`baK�/`6s/p 2%.�$(Ý t3nbV�`�U�gh`�`bU�aKp:ghc�aBf�V`7aKc�ghn�aK�^�BU�a=f:`bU�aBTKV/��aBa=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf ö ± ��!"�G#%$�)�÷(9;� ����õ�.�$ K}Þiö���'H#R<�'denBT�U�aKT��aK��ghiQgYdef�nb`�`bU�a%TKWeVnba=��`qp/]Da �ªö(�G#%$ &%'(�G#%$ '�� �u ]�]�WodeT@gY`bdeVf+VhX ������õ�.�$�K%� gY`ÌgYcbi_�[^aKf/` y ]�cbV/��_�T=aKnlTKV/��a%TKVf/`�gYdef�def�i¥g�X�_�f�TK`bdeVf+X�V\c�n�ÿ/_�ghc�dof�i��

&�4f��õ�.�$ K6��������õ�.�$�K%�6���J�K%2�4f��õ�.�$�K��,ö ± ��!"��#3$�)��â709;�87ò/%<G'ú!,�ªö(��#3$ &%'(��#3$ '��

� `BT@gYf�`�U�aKf°sDaz�bc�ghf �^gYf���gY]�]�WedeaK�;do`�nbaKW�X��

é

Page 11: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

&�4f�,��Ü%L%#O4Â��õ�.�$ KC�J�K%2�4f�������%#3��!��"�G#%$,&%'O��#3$%�&�4f�����J�K%28��$��8��!���#3$

=*>û ü�ý(æ3þ ÿaåsë�BU�a:¯�c�aKnbUDj°­íWÎgYf�i_Dghia:Û r ñ�Ý\Ý Þ U�ghn�g:n�Wedoi\U/`bWep^��d�ä�aKcba=fQ`���g3m\Vc¸X�cbV\[�`�U�a¢[+aK`�gP��W�gYf�i_�gYiaKnB]�cbaKn�aKf/`baK�ís�a�X-Vcba\� � `den¢f�V`:def/`baKf���aK�Ú`bV�[�gYf�de]�_�W�gh`�a¢V\]�a=f gYf��ÚTKWeVn�aK�ÚTKV/��a� ¡ gY`bU�a=c@t6de`�n:��a���f�def�i�X�a@gY`b_�c�a°den¢de`�n:_�f�deÿ/_�a^U�gYf���Wedef�iVhXlc�aK]�c�aKnbaKf/`�gh`bdeV\fèghf���[;ghf�de]�_�WÎgY`bdeVf�VhX�ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`:n�p/fQ`�gh��`�cbaKaKn+VhXlV\s��aKTK`:W�ghf�i_�gYiaKn��Bde`�U�s�def���def�i°TKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=`bn@��BU�a�nbp/f/`�gY�°VhXB`bU�a�Vs� aKTK`�W�ghf�i_�gYia�denJcbaK]�cbaKn�aKf/`baK�ímQd�g+g^_�nbaKc ����a ��f�aK�í��gh`�gh`qp/]�a\t�Wedo�\a�def�j�­6tDs�_�`J`bU�a:s�def���def�iTKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`�n:VhXB`bU�a:V\s��aKTK`%WÎgYf�i_Dghia:ghc�a:aKf�TKV/��a=�H[^V/��_�WoV^gYWe]�U�g3�qaKÿ/_�demghWeaKf�TKat�_�n�def�i;`bU�a+TKVf�T=aK]�`�VYXÌf�gY[^aKn�gYf��f�gY[^a^ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf'� �w¬Jgh[^a=n^Ï�V\c¢n�pQ[:sDVWen3t1gY`bV[+n Ð ghc�a�g�nbaK]Dghc�gY`ba;nba=[�ghf/`�doT�T@gY`baKi\Vcbpí�BU�deT�UHgh��[+do`�nJaKÿ/_�ghWede`qp�Ñ`bU�aKcba:den�g:TKV\_�f/`�gYs�Wep°def/��f�de`ba%nb_�]�]�Wop�VhX�f�gY[^aKn3tDnbV;`bU�gY`J��a�T@ghf�ghWe�Bg3p/nl]�deT��°ghf�V\`bU�aKc3t�X-cbaKn�U£V\f�at�`�V�]�WÎgYTKa�dof�g]DVnbde`�doV\f;VhX¹gYf°Vs� aKTK`q�qWeaKma=W'sDV_�f���mghcbd�gYs�Wea�6��]�aKc�gh`�doV\f°VhX6f�gY[^aJghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f°]�cbVhm/de��aKnlg�[+aKT�U�ghf�don�[w`bV+aKf�TKV/��aghWeW�`�U�a����qmghc�d�ghf/`bn�VhX6g�`baKc�[��Bde`bU;c�aKnb]DaKTK`J`bV�`bU�a¢ghs�n�`bc�ghTK`�aK�°f�gY[^a��BU�aJnbp/f/`�gY�^VhX6¯�c�aKnbUDj°­�denBidem\aKf^s/p:`bU�aJX�VWeWeVh�Bdef�iJTKVf/`�aK�/`q�-X�cbaKa%ic�gY[^[;ghc@� � f;`bU�a�c�_�WeaKnlsDaKWeVh��t�� denÌg%��f�do`�a

nba=`lVhX7f�gh[+aKn@�VXW"Y(ZG[ ü �B� \ � v e ] ü ^ `ôü b ] Û � v e�Þ üVXZ�dfe�[ Z �B� \ T ]f�z] ±(T'� ülj Zk]fZ ^ Z b ]3ì�»/~k×/��ì T qsZ ^ á-â�Z b ]

â7»/½ �;á-âoZl]m� j Zk]fZ��á�tUu ò5v Z T v [ { �B� \ | ]m{}y T'� ü��� v u dfZ �B� \ | ]m��y ~�����p(ZG[ � �B� \ ��] ±�T#� ülj Zk]f� j �

��]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghWeWep/t�f�gY[^aKnBT@gYf°sDa�`bU�V\_�iU�VhX�ghn�WoV/T@gY`bdeVf�n@�B�BU�a=p�UDg3ma�`�U�aKdecln�aK]�ghc�gh`�a¢`qp/]Da � v e t�gYf��°ghcba�def/`bcbVY���_�T=aK�¢def/`bV�`bU�a�TKV\[^]�_�`�gh`�doV\fJ`bU�c�V_�i\U�`bU�a�TKV\[:s�def�gh`�Vc â1»/½ Ñha3ghT�U¢def/`bc�V/��_�TKaK��f�gY[^a7den�X�c�aKnbU��Y_�f�deÿ/_�at\dq� a\�K��d�ä�aKcbaKf/`X�c�V[�gYWoW�`�U�aJ]�cba=mQdeV\_�nbWep^def/`bc�V/��_�TKaK��Vf�aKn3t�gYf��^denBsDV_�f��;def â7»Q½ �6��f�a�T@gYf;`bU�def��:VYX¹`�U�aJaK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f

â1»/½ �;á-â�Z

ghnBV\]�a=c�gh`�deVf�gYWoWep:ghf�gYWeViV\_�n�`bV^j°­�� nì-»Q~_×Q��ìX�áq �h»� Ï Ð�á-â�Z

aK�/TKaK]�`:`bU�gY`¢`�U�a^`qp/]Da^nbp/n�`baK[�VhX�¯�cbaKn�U�j°­ de[^]DVnba=n�cbaKn�`bc�doT=`bdeVf�n:V\fH`�U�a^V/TKTK_�cbcba=f�TKaKn;VhX � def Z �BU�deT�UÚghc�a^f�V\`cba=ÿQ_�doc�aK�;VhX7cba�X�a=cbaKf�T=aKn@� � f;]�gYcb`�doT=_�W�ghc@t\f�gY[^aKnBghc�a�f�V`BghWeWeVh��aK�+`bV%X�cba=aKWep^Wea@g3ma�`bU�aJn�TKV]Da�VhX'`�U�a���a ��f�def�i â1»/½ � � Xnb_�T�U;g�`�U�def�i���V_�We�:U�gY]�]DaKf't/`bU�alaKn�T@gh]DaK�°f�gY[^a��BdeWoW�VQT=TK_�cBdef:`bU�aJc�aKnbde��_�gYW�`�aKcb[�ts�_�`�`�U�aJ]�cbV\ic�gh[^[+aKc'�BdeWeW�U�g3m\af�V;U�gYf���Wea�Vf�de`@t�ghf��£`�UQ_�n�f�V�T3gh]�gYs�deWode`qp+`bV;[�gYf�de]�_�W�gh`�a�de`�dof�ghf/p;�Bg3pQ��Z�V\f�nbde��aKc�X�V\cJaK��gh[^]�WoaJ`�U�a°Ï�deWeW���`qp/]DaK� Ð`ba=cb[

â7»/½ �;á-â���v���v�yQ����BU�den�`baKc�[�den�nb_�]�]DVn�aK�;`bV�defQ`�cbV/��_�T=a�g%f�aK� f�gh[+a � dof/`�V¢`�U�alc�_�f/�q`bde[^aBaKf/m/decbV\f�[^aKf/`3t`�U�aKf;aKmghWe_�gY`ba v��Úv��� ` y tghf��^cba=`b_�c�f �qy y;��� th�BU�deT�U^T=Vf/`�gYdof�nÌgYf:VQT=TK_�cbc�aKf�TKa�VhX � gYs�V\_�`6`�V¢aKn�T@gh]DaJ`bU�aJn�TKV]DaJVhX'de`bn���a���f�dof�i â7»Q½ �#�BU�aJ�Bg3p¯�cbaKn�U�j°­���a@gYWenB�Bdo`�U;`bU�den�]�cbV\s�WeaK[�den�`bV:c�aKÿ/_�decba�`�U�gh`�`bU�a%cbaK��_�TK` �qy y;��� tsDa�X�V\cba�c�aK`b_�cbf�def�iDt�sDa�T=V_�]�WeaK�;�Bde`bU � `�VX�V\cb[Íg�TKWeVnb_�cbatDVcBfDgh[^a�gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVf'���BU�a%cbaKn�]�V\f�nbdes�deWede`qp:`bV^T=cba@gY`ba�f�gh[+a�ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf�n�donBV\f°`bU�a�]�cbV\ic�gh[^[+aKc@ts�_�`B`�U�al`qp/]DaJnbp/nb`�aK[��BdeWeWDT�U�aKT����BU�aK`bU�a=clghWeW�`�U�aJ`baKc�[^nBghc�a�gY]�]�c�V]�c�dÎgY`baKWep:TKWeV\nbaK�;�BU�aKf;Wea@g3m/def�i¢g%nbTKV\]�aJVYX â7»/½ �¬�gY[^a;ghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f�TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`;VhX¢¯�cbaKn�U�j°­ don � j Z t�ghf��Úde`:U�ghn^g�T=Vcbc�aKnb]DVf���def�iÚ`qpQ]Da;TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�Vc�Û � v e¥Þ Ï �lÐ ��BU/_�n@t�`bU�a+`baKc�[ â7»/½ �;á�â���v�� v�yQ��� den�f�V`���aKWeWÙ�q`qp/]�a=�HdefH¯�c�aKnbUDj°­6t7s�_�`¢`�U�a;`baKc�[^n â1»/½ �;á-â�� j ��v��óv�yQ���ghf�� â7»/½ �;á-â���v��«v�yQ� j ��� sDV`bUHgYcbat®�Bdo`�U£`qp/]DaKn á-â'~�� Û � v e¥ÞÒ� v e ghf��ÒÛ � v e�Þ Ï á-â'~���� v e^Ð cbaKn�]�a=TK`bdema=Wop/�+¬lV`�a`bUDgh`Jf�gh[+a�ghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f£den�gËs�def���aKc3t�s�_�`J`�U�a¢s�dof���def�i:V/TKTK_�c�n�Vf�Wep°g3X-`baKcJ`bU�a¢sDV/��p;VhX�`�U�a¥gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`bdeVf�U�gYn�sDaKaKfaKmgYWo_Dgh`ba=�'��BU�a�V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f°V]�]�V\nbde`ba�X�c�V[Íghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f°denBTKVf�T=cbaK`�doV\f'� � `�nBnbp/f/`�gh�;den Z��á� ghf��;de`bn�V]DaKc�gY`bdeVfDghW�nba=[�ghf/`�doT=n

den�`�V:nbaK]Dghc�gY`baJ`bU�a�`�aKcb[�def^`�U�aJTKWeVnb_�cba Z X�c�V[wde`bnlgYs�nb`�c�gYTK`baK�;f�gY[^a�sQp;ª"�6§ ÓÓ�´�¦×J`�U�gh`�f�gh[+aB�Bde`bU � `bU�c�V_�i\U�V_�``bU�a�T=WoV\nb_�c�a;s�V/��p!Ï�nba=a°`bU�a;V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghW�nba=[�ghf/`�doT=n¢def�¯#doi\_�cbaz Ð �Ò¯�Vc�aK��gh[+]�Weat7d�X�� ��aKf�V`�aKn^`�U�a;`baKc�[��Í\� ���f¡C�¢"¬­¡ ³ª¢"¦À´�¡�©f«"¦f¡R �¥§¨�! �¡#"�£�f¥ ¯�¦­¥§¦f©f¥§³ª¡@�ª¿;´f�f¨�¨�f¡ª¶��f¢Q°¤¡C¨�f¡ª¥§£(©f£¢Q �´f¢¤³%$G�@¼

æ

Page 12: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

ÏT'� ü��& Ð Ê { �('�&{FÉ T#� ü��)�

{}y T#� ü ÉzZ ��Ì*�+� {zÉ T-,�� ü�,.�)� X�V\cÌgYWeWRT�,�Ê ª× Ï Z3Ð�/10 T32{�É ±(T'� ülj Z �hü,`ÍÌ*�+�

{FÉ�Z ^��hü,`ìÌ*�)� {zÉzZ b%�hü��)�{�ÉzZ ^ Z b%��Ì*�)�

{zÉzZ ^J�hü��)& {Iy T#� ü��& ÉËZ b���Ì*�)�{ËÉ+ì-»/~l×/��ì T q Z ^ á�â�Z b���Ì*�+�

{ � ��y;� � � v eMÉzZ �hü���Ï4�65 0Â� 2 Ð{�É+â7»/½ �+á�â�Z �Yü7�)�

{�ÉzZ �hü��)� /10Â� 2 { Ï �QÐ \ � v e{�Éz� j Z ��Û � v e�Þ ü��6�

{zÉËZ ��Û � v e�Þ ü��wÏ4�85 0f� 2 Ð {zÉz� � � v e �+�{�ÉzZ��á� �hü��+�

¯#doi\_�cba�ç��7��p/]�def�i�cb_�WeaKn�X-Vc�X�V\c̯�cbaKn�U�j°­���Z�V\f�nb_�Wo`JÛ r ñ�Ý\Ý Þ X�V\cÌgYf�a=�Q]�WÎgYf�gh`�deVf^VYX1`�U�aJWÎgY[:s��DgJcb_�Wea�

y;�UÉz�lÐ ` � É ±�T#� ülj ZÀÐ `ð±�T#� ükj Z

ÉzZ ^ Ð `ð±(T'� ülj Z ÉzZ b Ð ` � b É Û � b Ñ T Þ�Z­Ð ` � ÉzZ ^ Z b Ð ` �

ÉËZ ^ Ð ` � ^ É Û � ^ Ñ T Þ�Z b Ð ` � É+ì�»/~k×Q��ì T qsZ ^ á-â�Z b Ð ` �

y;�UÉzZXÐ ` � É+â1»/½ �;á-âoZÀÐ ` �

ÉËZ­Ð ` � Éz� j Z­Ð ` � j �

ÉzZXÐ ` � Û j � Û � \�Ï �g� Û Ðª� Û ÉzZ��á�lÐ ` �

¯#doi\_�cbaU��6�l]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�ghW7S/aK[�gYf/`bdeTKn�VhX¹¯�cba=nbU�j°­����BU�aJV\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�Ï ����Û�Ъ�mÛ n��ÌgY]�nB`bU�a%f�gh[+aKn � gYf�� ��Û def �mÛ �

Ï � j.9�j ��v���v�y;���bÐ t'`�U�aKf:� � 9�aKmgYWo_Dgh`ba=n�`bV � j ��v�� v�y 9 � � � fHg;n�aKf�nba\t6`bU�a^V]DaKc�gh`bdeV\fHVhXBf�gY[^a�nb�Bgh]�]�def�i�don�gnbde[+]�WedÙ�DT@gh`�doV\f°VhXl`�U�a^T=Vf�TKa=]�`:VhX�gYWo]�U�g3�qcbaKfDgh[^def�iD�^¤ U�aKfH`�U�a^fDgh[^a;9�den�nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`baK�íX�V\c � dof<�:t7`bU�aKfHf�gY[^a9:defÚ`bU�a�n�aKTKV\f��èghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVfHVYX=� U�gYn:`bV�s�a°c�aKf�gY[^aK�ínbVHghn�f�V\`:`bV�dof�TK_�c^ghf�gYTKTKde��aKf/`�gYWlghs�n�`bc�ghTK`�doV\fÚdofí`bU�anb_�s�nbaKÿ/_�a=fQ`Jn�_�s�`ba=cb[£�BS/def�T=a¥gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVf;denldef/`baKf���aK�°`�V�Õ�´ Ô©B`�U�a¥gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`baK��f�gY[^at/de`B��V/aKn�f�V`�[�gh`�`baKcBa=��gYTK`bWep�BU�deT�U�gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdef�i�f�gh[+aBdon�_�n�aK�£Ï-ghnBWeVf�i�ghn�do`���V/aKnBf�V`�def�TK_�c�_�f�def/`ba=f���aK�°ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf�n Ð t/nbV:¯�cbaKn�U�j°­�[^dei\UQ`6gYn��aKWeW�_�nba�`�U�a�ghWecba3gh��p;g3mghdeW�ghs�Wea � �u n�deWoWe_�n�`bc�gh`ba=�^ghsDVhmat\`bU�aJ¯�c�aKnbUDj°­°[+aKT�U�ghf�don�[ VYX'f�gh[+aKn7[�gh�\aKn�gJ��don�`bdef�TK`�deVf:sDaK`q��a=aKf^`�U�alf�V\`bdeVf�n6VhX'f�gY[^a

def/`bcbV/��_�TK`bdeVf!Ï�TKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=` â7»/½:Ð ghf��íf�gh[+a^ghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f Ï TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK` � j Z@Ð t6�BU�deT�UÚdon�f�V\`:`bU�a;T@gYnba;defÒ±���T@gYWeTK_�Wedqt�BU�aKc�a^W�gh[:sD��gËaK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n¢n�aKcbm\a^`bU�a^cbV\Wea:VhXBs�V\`bU'�;�BU�a:fDgh[^a�def/`bcbV/��_�TK`bdeVf�den¢ghf�a ä�aKT=`qX�_�WeW�V]DaKc�gY`bdeVf#Ñ7aKmaKc�paKmgYWo_Dgh`bdeV\f:VhX1g%idemaKf:`�aKcb[��Bde`bU:f�gY[^aBdef/`bc�VQ��_�TK`bdeV\f^cba=nb_�We`bnB�Bde`�U�gJ��d�ä�aKcba=fQ`BfDgh[^a\�'û�_�`Bf�V\`bdeTKal`�U�gh`���_�a�`bV�`bU�acba=nb`bc�deTK`bdeVf�nB]�W�ghTKaK�;V\f^`bU�a�V/TKT=_�cbc�aKf�TKaKnJVYX1f�gY[^aKn3t`�U�aKnbaJa�ä�aKTK`�nJT@ghf�f�V`�s�aJVs�nbaKc�maK�;def^`�U�aJWÎgYf�i_DghiaBde`�nbaKW�X�t/`�UQ_�n[�gY�/dof�i�¯�cba=nbU�j°­î]�_�c�aKWep:X�_�f�TK`bdeVfDghWq��BU�aBcba=Woa=mghf/`7nbaK`6VYX�cb_�Woa=n6VhX�`�U�aB`qp/]�a=T�U�aKT��Qdef�i�ghf���aKmghWe_�gY`bdeVf���_���i\[^aKf/`bn#VhX�¯�cba=nbU�j°­ don7]�c�aKnba=fQ`�aK�^def¢¯#dei_�cbaKn

ç°gYf�����^�BU�a^`qp/]�a=T�U�aKT��Qdef�i���_���i\[^aKf/`Jf�V`%Vf�Wep£gYnbnbV/TKd�gY`baKn�`qp/]�aKn�`bV�`baKc�[£t�s�_�`�de`¢ghWenbV;�\aKaK]�n�`bc�ghT��£VYXlf�gh[+aKnV/TKTK_�c�cbdef�i:def^`�U�aJnb_�s�`baKc�[^nBghf��+aKf�nb_�cbaKn�`bU�gY`Bf�Vf�a�VhX7`bU�aK[ýWoa3g3maKn�`bU�aJn�TKV]Da�VhX'de`�nB��a���f�def�i â7»/½ _�f�i_�gYcb��a=��s/pgJf�gY[^algYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVf'�7�BU�a1��_���i[^a=fQ`7U�gYn6`bU�alX-Vcb[ {�ÉzZ �hü��6�Íghf��^cba3gh��n3�7dof:T=Vf/`baK�/` { t/`�U�al`�aKcb[ Z U�gYn6`qp/]�aü¢t�gYf��:`bU�a�n�aK`BVhX'fDgh[^a=n>�Íden7X�c�aKnbU+X�V\c Z Ï d�� at\f�V�fDgh[^a=n7X�cbV\[?�Í�BdeWeW�V/TKTK_�cB_�f�i_Dghcb��aK�^s/p:f�gY[^aBghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f^def`bU�a�mgYWe_�aJVhX Z3Ð �7¬�V`�doT=a�`bU�gY`B`bU�aJTKV\f/`baK�/` { T=Vf/`�gYdof�n�f�V\`BVf�Wep:`qp/]�def�iDt/s�_�`lghWen�V�X�c�aKnbU�f�aKnbn�gYf�f�V`�gh`�doV\f�n@�

v Ý

Page 13: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

u n¢gYf£deWeWe_�nb`�c�gY`bdeVf;��a:]�cbaKn�aKf/`¢ghf�aK��gh[+]�Wea�def£¯�cbaKn�U�j°­Ú�Bde`bU�ghf�Vs� aKTK`�W�ghf�i_�gYia�VYX�_�f/`qp/]�aK��W�gY[:s���g%T@gYWÙ�TK_�We_�n3�l�BU�a¢V\s��aKTK`JW�ghf�i\_�ghi\aJnbp/f/`�gh�;denl��a���f�aK��def°j°­���Wede�a��Dgh`�gY`qp/]�a���aKTKW�ghc�gh`bdeV\f'tDs�_�`lde`�_�nbaKn%[^aK`�g3�qWoa=maKW�f�gY[^aghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf�`bVJcbaK]�cbaKn�aKf/`BVs��aKT=`q�qWoa=maKW�W�gY[:s���g�T=Vf�n�`bcb_�TK`@���BU�a6X-_�f�TK`�doV\f 4fL%D(4f$ `�gh�\aKn6ghf:ghs�n�`bc�gYTK`ba=�^W�gh[:sD��g�`ba=cb[Z t�ghf���ghf�V`bU�aKcl`�aKcb[ v t�ghf��;n�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�aKnJ`bU�aJ`ba=cb[ v def+X�Vc�`bU�a�V/TKTK_�c�cbaKf�T=aKn�VhX7`bU�a�gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVf°mgYcbd�ghs�WoaBdef Z �

S�K�$ K�$ � � .62%Kmõ,�7@ K�Ü,���,K�$�õ]BA Kmõ���� �ªK�$�õ ��2%Kmõ]BC �%�,���,2%Kmõò7�2%Kfõ

�3L%#84fL%D(4f$,.6$�!��ªK�$�õ � 2%Kfõ8&3'H23Kmõ�&%'�2%Kfõ��# .��,KO��#

Ý�K54m.H.�D%K����@ K�Ü,K�� '6$] @ K�Ü�.}Þg��'E@ K�Ü,.IÞ]FA Kfõ�L,� '

#�.���DO�G#A Kmõ,D�)f9�4fL3D(4f$�9"K})f9;L7DHDR<3<�$E<]FC �3�ß9N.�/HG�.%��<á� '

9G4fL%D(4f$�.�/á$�Gr4fL3D(4f$,.%�6$R<�BU�a:gh]�]�c�VQgYT�U�VhX�¯�c�aKnbUDj°­í`bVh�Bghcb��nlcba=]�cbaKn�aKf/`bdef�i°s�dof���def�i:TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�n�VhX6`bU�a¢V\s��aKTK`JW�ghf�i\_�ghi\aKnBdenln�do[+deWÎgYc6def

��aKn�deif°ghf��+iV/ghWen6`bV:`�U�gh`�VhX6Õ�´Ù×3Õ�©��JÖ���Ô©���§��KªKµ�b§\³@µ7ªK¶h¦�µ-§JI\t ãJ� u S£Û r ï�éé Þ �'�BU�aKp^sDV`�U�_�nba�g�[+aK`�gP��WeaKm\aKWDs�def���def�iTKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`°Ï f�gh[+a¥gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`bdeVf�defH¯�cbaKn�U�j°­�t1gYf���W�gh[:sD��g^gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVfídofáã�� u S Ð `bV�aKf�TKV/��a+`bU�aK���qaKÿ/_�demghWeaKf�TKaTKW�ghn�n�VYX1`�U�alV\s��aKTK`B`�aKcb[��Rã�Vh��aKm\aKc@t/`�U�alf�V`bdeV\f:VhX'f�gY[^alghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf^def;¯�c�aKnbU�j�­°den���a@gY�aKc�X�c�V[�ã�� u S+def:`bU�gY`de`l��V/aKn�f�V`�U�ghc����Bdecba�defQ`�V:`bU�a�cba=]�cbaKn�aKf/`�gY`bdeVf�`bU�a�T@gY]�ghs�deWede`qp^`�V:nb_�s�n�`bde`b_�`ba�X�V\clsDV_�f���mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn���n�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\fdef£¯�cbaKn�U�j°­ÚU�gYnJ`bV^sDa:]�c�Vic�gh[+[^aK�+sQp�cbaKTK_�cbnbdeV\f�Vf°`�U�a:nb`�cb_�TK`�_�cba:VYXÌ`�U�a�Vs��aKT=`�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a�`�aKcb[+n@�%�BU�gh`J�Bg3p¯�cbaKn�U�j°­HgYT�U�deaKmaKn�`bU�a�gh��aKÿ/_�gYTKp^VYX6cbaK]�c�aKnba=fQ`�gh`�doV\f'tD�BU�deT�U�T3ghf°sDa�WeVn�`�defzã�� u S;def;`bU�aJ]�c�aKnba=f�TKa:VhX�gY����de`bdeVfDghW`ba=cb[ðghf���`qp/]Da:TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�Vcbn°Ï nb]DaKTKd���T@gYWeWop/t#TKVf�n�`bc�_�TK`bV\cbn�X�V\cJ��deno��V\dof/`Jnb_�[^n@t7ghnJV\s�nbaKc�maK�ídef�Û êJr S�æ� Þ def�g;WeVideT]�c�Vic�gh[+[^def�i7nbaK`�_�] Ð �7û�_�`3t3cbaK[;ghcb��`bU�gY`�aKma=f¢d�XQ`�U�a�`q��VlgY]�]�cbV/ghT�U�aKn#[�g3pB��d�ä�aKc'defJ`bU�aKdec1ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVfJ[^aKT�U�gYf�denb[+n@t`bU�aKp^sDV`�U��BdeWeW�cba=ÿQ_�doc�a�nbV\[^a�f�V`�doV\f^VYX1f�gY[^aKn�def�V\cb��a=cB`bV:cba=TK_�cbn�a¢Vhm\aKcB`bU�a�n�`bc�_�TK`b_�cba�VhX6`bU�aJaKf�TKV/��aK�°`�aKcb[��

L M8N;OQPóÆ�Å�OSR��¥Ãù�ËÈ��U�TO� f°`�U�denlnba=TK`bdeVf���a�]�cbaKn�aKf/`�`�U�a�nbp/f/`�gh�;ghf���nb`�gY`bdeT�n�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKnBVhX�V\_�cBTKV\cba�WÎgYf�i_Dghia\t���a�X-aKcbc�dof�i^`bU�a�aK�/]�V\nbde`bdeV\f°VhXdef/`baKf�n�deVf�gYW�TKV/��a�gYf�ghWep/nbden#X�V\c¹S�aKTK`bdeV\f^ç��#�¹gY�aKf:def�de`bnba=WÙX�t`�U�aBTKVc�alW�ghf�i_�gYia�TKVf/`�gYdef�n6TKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`�n6X-Vc6_�f�dÙX-pQdef�i�`bU�af�V\`bdeVf�n�VhX7TKWeVn�aK�°ghf��;V]DaKf;TKV/��aÀ��g%]�cbV\s�WeaK[w�BU�deT�U;[^V`�demgh`ba=�¢`�U�a�a@gYcbWedeaKc���aKmaKWeV\]�[^aKf/`�s�a=U�def��;`bU�aJaK�/`ba=f�nbdeVfVhXl±Dõ def/`bV°j;a=`�gj�­6� ãlVh��aKmaKc3t'V\_�c�f�V\`bdeVf�VhXBTKV/��a+��d�ä�aKc�n�X-cbV[ `bU�gY`�VhXB`bU�a:WÎgYnb`�`q��V;T@ghWeTK_�Wodq�:û�V`�UH±�õôgYf��j;aK`�gj°­;gYWoWeVh��TKV/��a�aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n6`bVJTKV\fQ`�ghdefJX�c�aKa�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn@thghf��¢def�V\cb��aKc7`�V�a=mghWe_�gh`�a�gBT=VQ��aBaK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf#tQj;a=`�gj�­U�gYn�`bV°]�cbVhma:de`�T=WoV\nbaK�#�zãlaKc�at6��a^gh��V\]�`¢gYf�V]�]DVn�do`�a^gh]�]�cbVQgYT�U'��a@ghT�U�TKV/��a+aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVfÚden¢gYWoWeVh��aK�°`�V°TKVf/`�ghdefVf�Wop;`�U�Vn�a�X�c�aKa�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKnB�BU�deT�U£U�g3m\a�sDaKaKf�Woden�`baK��ghn�Ô© Ó�©3¦�Ô©3¦�³3´�©=ª�def°de`bn�`qp/]�at#ghf��°V\f�Wep^`�U�a¢a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n%�Bdo`�Uf�V:��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKdeaKn�gYcbaJaK�/aKTK_�`�ghs�Wea�u n6g��Dcbnb`���aKma=WoV\]�[^a=fQ`3tK��a���aKTKde��aK�:`�Vl��den�gYnbn�VQT=dÎgY`ba�`bU�a�f�V\`bdeVf�VYX*�bmgYcbd�ghs�Woa=n�s�V\_�f���dof%WÎgY[:s��Dg�gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVf�n@��t

X�c�V[�`bU�a�f�V`�deVf;VhXU�qX-cbaKa�mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=nBVhXÌg�TKV/��a�aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f ��tD�BU�deT�U£gYcba�aKÿ/_�gY`baK��def°±�õÍgYf��£j;aK`�gj°­��D�BU�a�[�gYdefcba3ghnbV\f^den6`�U�aBX�V\WeWoVh�Bdef�iD��def/`baKf�nbdeVf�gYW�TKV/��aJghf�gYWop/n�don�V_�i\UQ`�`bV�]�c�Vhm/do��algJ`baKn�`��BU�aK`bU�a=c�`q��VJX�c�aKalmgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�dof:gJTKV/��aaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f£ghc�a���d�ä�aKcbaKf/`�Vcla=ÿQ_DghWq�7�BU�a�c�aKnb_�We`�VhX6`bU�denB`�aKnb`�donBV\s/mQdeV\_�nbWep:f�V\`l]�c�aKnbaKc�maK��_�f���aKcln�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f't�n�V:de`WeV/V�/n�ÿ/_�a=nb`bdeV\f�ghs�Wea�`bV:`bdea�`bU�a�X�c�aKaJTKV/��a�mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn6`�V:V_�`�nbde��a�WÎgY[:s��Dg�ghs�n�`bc�ghTK`�doV\f�n@�7�BU�don�denBf�V`�`bV�n�g3p+`bU�gY`�de`�dende[^]DVn�nbdes�WeaJ`bV�gY���°def/`baKf�nbdeVf�gYW'TKV/��a:ghfDghWep/nbdenl`�V�±DõÍVcJj;aK`�gj°­�� � f���aKaK�'t®`bU�a���denb`�dof�TK`bdeVf�s�aK`q��aKaKf�T=VQ��a¢WeaKm\aKWenVf:�BU�doT�U:`�U�aBTKV/��alT=V[^]Dghcbden�Vf¢gYf��:`bU�a�nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf:V/TKT=_�c�i\demaKn7nbV\[^aBWeaKaK�Bg3p�`�V�s�a=WodeaKm\aB`bU�gY`6`bU�don�nbaK`�_�]^T@gYf:s�aidem\aKf�gJn�V_�f���V\]�a=c�gh`�deVf�gYW�n�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKn@�7Z�V/��a�ghf�gYWop/n�don�donBg%[^aK`�gJWeaKmaKW�V\]�a=c�gh`�deVf't\nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf;VYX'WÎgY[:s��DglsDV_�f��mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn�dof�TKV/��a:aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�n�den�gYf£V\s��aKTK`%Woa=maKW6V\]�a=c�gh`�deVf'�%�BU�a���cbn�`�denJdo[+[^aK��dÎg3`�aKWep^aK�/aKT=_�`�gYs�Weat'`�U�a:nba=TKVf��denJ]�V\nb`b]DVf�aK�'t7nbV�`bU�a:`q��V;�BdoWeW7f�aKm\aKc�dof/`�aKcqX�a=cba�gãlVh��aKma=c@t#U�g3m/dof�i�`�U�aK[ôsDV`bU�`bdeaK��`�V;`bU�a+n�gh[+a�[^a=T�UDghf�denb[ VhXmghc�d�ghs�Weals�dof���def�i¢�BdeWeW'ghWe[+Vnb`�TKaKcb`�ghdef�Wep^��don�`b_�c�s°`bU�a�`�U�aKV\cbp;VhX6`bU�a�_�f���aKc�Wop/def�i:TKV\cba�W�gYf�i_�gYia�Ï�def;]�ghc�`bdeTK_�W�ghc3t/`bU�asDaK`�g�c�_�Wea^Û �¹gYU�ææ\g Þ t/s�_�`lghWenbV�`bU�aJ]�gYc�gY[^aK`�cbdeTKde`qp:VhX6±/�bghs�n�`bc�ghTK`�doV\f;[�g3p�s�a�def+ÿQ_�aKnb`�doV\f Ð �

vv

Page 14: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

�BU�den�gYcbi_�[^aKf/`B[^V\`bdemgh`�aKn�`bU�a¢gY����de`bdeV\f�VYXÌg�nba=TKVf���s�def���def�i:[+aKT�U�ghf�don�[��BU�doT�U;�BdeWeW'sDa�_�nba=�£`�V^TKc�a@gh`�a¥gYf��ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`#X�c�aKa6mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�VYX�TKV/��a�a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n3�7û�_�`@th��a6�Bghf/`�`bVBTKV\[^]�gYcba7V_�c�X�c�aKa�mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=nDX�Vc�def/`baKf�nbdeVf�gYWaKÿ/_�gYWedo`qp/tghf���`�U/_�nBf�aKaK��`bV�cbaKn�Vcb`�`bV°¦�§\¨¢©=ª�Ï nbaKa�X�VcBaK��gY[^]�Wea�ÛÜ����a@æh· Þ�Ð � u ����de`bdeVf�gYWeWop/t3��aJV\]�`B`bV:n�aK]�ghc�gh`�a�`bU�aJV\]�aKc�gh`�doV\fVhXJf�gh[+a:TKcba3gh`bdeV\f Ï U�de��def�i°VYX�g�f�gh[+a Ð t#X�c�V[ô`bU�a�fDgh[^a^gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`bdeVf«Ï cbaKf�gY[^a@gYs�deWedo`qp Ð t'sDaKT@gY_�nba°`�U�gh`:n�aKaK[+n¢`�V]�c�VhmQde��aJn�`bcbdeTK`�Wep�[+Vc�a�a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdemaKf�aKnbn�def°[;ghf�de]�_�WÎgY`bdeVhf:VhX6TKV/��a�ghf��°fDgh[^a=n@t/`bUDghf°d�X6`bU�a%`q��V^gYcba�TKV\[:s�def�aK�;def/`bVg�nbdef�i\Wea�T=Vf�n�`bcb_�TK`bV\c@�B�BU�denBdenB�BU�aKc�a¢��aJaK[^]�WoVhp:`�U�a�[+aKT�U�ghf�den�[^n6VYX¹¬�V[+dofDghW�­®VideT�ghf�� ¯�cba=nbU�j°­�tD�BU�deT�U;��aKcba��aKn�deif�aK�+�Bde`bU�aK��ghTK`�Wop:`�U�gh`�]�_�cb]DVn�aldef:[^def��+Ï�nba=a¢Û r de`�Ý v�Þ gYf��°Û r ñ�ÝÝ Þ�Ð �'¤�a�defQ`�cbV/��_�T=a�gJf�a=�Òn�aK[�gYf/`bdeTBT@gh`�aKiV\cbpVhX6¦�§\¨¢©=ª6�BU�deT�U^ghcbaB`�V�nb`�ghf���X-Vc7X�c�aKalmgYcbd�ghs�Woa=n1def�s�Vh�/aK�+aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�n@���BUQ_�n@t\s�Vh�/aK�:aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf't�gYn6s�a X�Vc�aldef¥±D²BtT@gYf�f�V`�TKVf/`�ghdef;X�c�aKa�mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn3t�s�_�`l��a¢ghWeWeVh��`�U�aK[Í`bV+TKVf/`�ghdefH¦�§\¨¢©=ªKt�_�f���aKcJ`bU�a¢]�c�Vhm/don�deVf;`bU�gY`l`�U�a�V/TKTK_�c�cbdef�iX�c�aKa¢fDgh[^a=n�ghc�a¢Wedenb`�aK��dof�`bU�a�`qp/]�a�VhX�`�U�a�aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf#�¢Z�Vc�cbaKn�]�V\f���def�i\Wop/tD`bU�a�sDVh�Qa=�£`qp/]DaKn¢ghc�a�f�Vh��VhX�`�U�a�X-Vcb[ö�Ï�ü�Û t Þ Ð �BU�aKcba�t�n�`�ghf���n�X�Vc�g;��f�do`�a:nbaK`:VYXlf�gh[+aKn¢gYf��Hf�gY[^a�]�ghc�gh[+aK`baKc�n�Ï `bV�s�a+aK�/]�W�ghdef�aK�íW�gh`ba=c Ð `bU�gY`�`bU�asDVh�Qa=��`�aKcb[�[�g3p���aK]DaKf���Vf'�7�BU�a%nbp/f/`�gh�:VYX6V_�cBW�ghf�i_�gYialden�]�cba=nbaKf/`ba=�£sDaKWeVh���

.U eUY �Z v W"Y�Z�[ V �B� \ vU]WV ^ ` V bVXW¤Y�Z�[ ü �B� \ vU] ü ^ ` ü b ] ö¢Ï ü¢Û§t Þ�Э]XY[Z \ ü ]^]3Y ���jhüVXZ�dfe�[ Z �B� \ T ]f�z]�hl] ±(T'� ülj Zl]fZ ^ Z b ]3|6¾ nPZk]3ì-»Q~�|6¾ nPp1qçZ ^ á-âoZ b ]

� j Zl]fZ_���z]3â7»/½ú� � Vóá-â�Zl][`�Y ��Fj Zk]fZ Û Û§t Þ ÞR]�0Â� j\ Z ^ 2 Z b ]a n T'� ükj Z~��%d U � 9 ��Zkó u ò5v Z T v [ { �B� \ | ]f{Iy T#� ü ]f{Iy v �e�� ü¢Û§t ÞC]f{}y;p �o� ü�Û§t Þb��%egZUó u ò5v Z T v [ �B� \ | ] y;� � VVU�%df�%e�Z v Z�dló u ò5v Z T v [ w �B� \ | ]fwzyY ��

û�a X�Vc�a�aK�/]�W�ghdef�def�i�`�U�aJ`baKc�[ÍTKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�Vcbn3tDWoa=`B_�n���cbn�`B��denb]DaKf�n�a��Bde`bU;`bU�aJTKV\f/maKf/`bdeV\f�nB��aJ�BdeWeW�gYnbn�_�[^a�dof+`bU�acba=nb`JVhX�`�U�a�`baK�/`@��S�do[+deWÎgYcbW�p¢`�V ±D²BtDV_�clW�ghf�i\_�ghi\aJ[�gh�\aKn�g���don�`bdef�TK`�deVf°sDaK`q��aKaKf�Vc���def�ghc�p�Ï�mghWe_�a Ð mghc�d�ghs�WeaKnlgYf��aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f£mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=n@��¤�a�X�_�cb`�U�aKcJ��denb`�def�i_�den�U�sDaK`q��aKaKf�aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f£mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKnlgYf��;aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�n�`bUDgh`BU�g3m\a�aK[^]�`qpf�gY[^a:��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKdeaKn3tlghf��í`bU�V\nba;`bUDgh`�[�g3p°��a=]�aKf��ÒV\fHn�V[^a:fDgh[^a\Ñ6`bU�a:��c�nb`:�/def��HT@gYfHsDa;aK�/aKTK_�`�aK�'tBghf��í`bU�anba=TKVf���T@gYf�f�V`3� � f£ghfDghWeVi\p^�Bde`bUdcJc�do]��a�n�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKnBX�V\c�j;V/��gYW1­®VideTtD��a��BdeWeW1ghWen�V^T@gYWoW#`bU�a%��c�nb`J�/dof��P�b©fe�©gI\´�÷@©VcU��©4e�©�³@µ-§��=øo©3t/ghf��;`bU�a�n�aKTKV\f��°�/def��£¦�Ö\¦ �b©fe�©hI\´�÷3©BVc�¦�Ö\¦ �b©fe�©�³3µ-§��=øo©BmgYcbd�ghs�WeaKnBghf��^aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�n@���BU/_�n@tDg�mgYcbd�ghs�WeaTKV\fQ`�aK�/` { [�g3p�TKVf/`�ghdef^`�U�cbaKa�X�Vc�[^n6VYX¹mgYcbd�ghs�WoaB`qp/]�def�i\n@�}T#� ü!X�V\c�mgYWe_�almgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn3t�ghf�� p �e� ü¢Û§t Þ ghf�� v �e�� ü�Û t Þ X�Vc3tcba=nb]DaKTK`bdem\aKWepQt#cba��DaK�/dom\a^ghf���f�Vf�c�a���aK�/dema:a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn��Bde`bU�f�gh[+a���aK]DaKf���a=f�TKpPt:�J¤�a�T@ghWeW7`bU�a¢`qp/]Da:ü�Bde`bU°g%��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKp�tóghf�§¦�¦�Ö\µ�§\µ�©�Ô;µ-¶�Ó�©3��ãlaKc�atD��aJ_�n�a�ü¢t Ìýghf��;mghc�d�ghf/`bn�`bV�mghc�p^Vhma=clghcbs�do`�c�gYcbp^`qp/]DaKn@t V `�Vmghc�p:VhmaKcBn�de[^]�Weal`qp/]DaKn@t � ti9ht ó ghf��^`bU�a�mghc�dÎgYf/`bn�`bV:mghc�p:VhmaKcBfDgh[^a=n@Ñ T#t W t3j�nb`�ghf��+X�V\c�V\cb��def�gYcbp^mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=nÌgYf��p t � ghf�� v X�V\c�a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf;mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn3�6¯�_�c�`bU�a=c@t/��a�_�nba Y ghf��KkJX-Vc�_�f��/f�Vh�Bf£Ï dq� a\�]�gYc�gY[^aK`�cbdeT Ð nbaK`�nlVhX7f�gh[+aKn@t���t&ót�l X�Vc���f�do`�a:nbaK`�n�VhXBf�gY[^aKn3t�gYf���t:t�m X�VcJf�gY[^a���aK]�a=f���aKf�T=doa=n@t7dq� a�DX�V\cB��f�de`�a:nbaK`�n�TKVf/`�ghdef�def�i^sDV`�U�f�gh[+aKnghf��£f�gY[^a��qnba=`�]Dghc�gY[^aK`�aKcbn3�:�BU�a:]�gYc�gY[^aK`�aKcJTKVf/`ba=�Q` w ghn�nbV/TKd�gh`�aKn�]�gYc�gY[^aK`�aKcbn��Bde`�UÒÔ\´eªonKÖ´�¦�µ�¦�©=ª�ª¥§\¦�¦�Ö\µ�§\µ�´�Ö\¦/ªK�¯�Vcla=��gY[^]�Weat Y ��ÍÊ w ��V\_�We�°[^a@gYf;`bU�gY`�`�U�a�]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKc Y n�`�gYf���nJX�V\c�gYf£_�f��Qf�Vh�Bf°��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKp�nba=`ltónb_�T�U`bUDgh`@��Ï v3Ð tÍTKV\f/`�ghdef�n�f�V�f�gY[^aKn�X�cbV\[ð`bU�a;n�aK`p��t�ghf��«Ï yÐ dÙX�k�Êòt don^g�]�gYc�gh[+aK`ba=c@t6`�U�aKf�kW�� Ê w t6`bV/VD�ï7f�W�gYcbidef�i�ghf^gh]�]�cbV\]�cbd�gh`�alTKV\f/`baK�/`�sQp^g�f�aK�!mghcbd�gYs�Weathf�gY[^a�Vc�]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKc3tden�nb_�s��a=TK`B`bV�ûÌgYcbaKf���cbaKi\`J� n�q�gYcbd�ghs�WeaZ�Vf/m\aKf/`bdeVf'�+`bU�a°f�aK��mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn:ghcba�ghnbn�_�[^a=�H��denb`�def�TK`@t�V\c^ghcba;c�aKf�gh[+aK�ÚdefHVc���aKc+f�V`:`�V�TKW�ghnbUÚ�Bde`bUÚghWecba3gh��paK�/denb`�dof�i�Vf�a=n@�7�7aKcb[+n6�BU�deT�U:��d�ä�a=c�V\f�Wep�def:f�gh[+aKn6VhX'`�U�aKdec6sDV_�f��^mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn7Vc�]�gYc�gh[+aK`ba=cbn�gYcbalT=Vf�n�do��aKcbaK�;aKÿ/_�gYWq�û�_�`lf�V\`bdeTKa�`�U�gh`�µ-¶�Ó�©Kª�§¦�Ô�µ-©��K¨�ªU�6´ µoÕ�§��=ª µ�b§\³@µ-©�Ô^¦�§\¨¢©=ª�§���©�ªKØ%�4n=©�³3µBµ-Ö^¨�Ö��b©�³�Ö¨¸Ó�øe´�³�§µ-©�Ôg�KØ\øo©=ªKt/�BU�deT�U;�BdeWeW�s�aaK�/]�W�ghdef�a=�^�Bde`bU+`bU�a�`qpQ]�dof�iÌ��_���i[+aKf/`@� u nB_�nb_�gYWqtT@gY]�`b_�cba¢g3m\Vde��def�iJnb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf+den���a ��f�aK�;`bV�cba=f�gh[+almghc�d�ghs�WeaKn3t]�gYc�gh[+aK`ba=cbn�gYf��:f�gh[+aKn7�BU�aKf+��aKnbT=aKf���def�i�defQ`�V�`bU�aKdec6nbTKV\]�a\��¯�cbaKa�]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKc�n6VhX1gJ`qp/]DaBüèghc�al��a=f�V`�aK�^s/p ªÅ Ï�ü Ð tX�c�aKa�mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn�VhX6g�`baKc�[ Z s/p ª× Ï Z3Ð t�gYf��;de`bn�X�c�aKa�f�gY[^aKnBghc�a bâ Ï Z3Ð �¤�a�gYcba^f�Vh�wcba@gY��p�`bV���aKn�TKcbdesDa°mghc�deV_�n�f�aK�w`�aKcb[�ghf��í`qpQ]Da;TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�Vcbn+`bU�gY`¢V\_�c�WÎgYf�i_Dghia:def/`bc�V/��_�TKaKn3�

S/de[^deW�ghc�Wep¢`�V ¯�cba=nbU�j°­�t���a¢U�g3m\a¢g:`�aKcb[ôTKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=` � j Z X�Vc�f�gh[+a�ghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f�gYf�� Z_��� X�Vc�f�gh[+a�TKVf�TKcbaK`�deVf'�ãlVh��aKm\aKc@t7`�U�a^`qp/]Da^VhXlfDgh[^a:ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf�def�V_�c%T@ghn�a�UDghn�`�V°s�a+[^V\cba�iaKf�a=c�ghWB`�U�ghf�`�U�a£Û � v e�Þ üwVYX�¯�c�aKnbUDj°­6�S/def�TKa:fDgh[^a=nl`�gY�a�]�ghc�`�ghnJ��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKpÒgYf�f�V\`�gh`�deVf�n�dof�`qp/]�a=n@t#`bU�a�f�gh[+a¢ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf�`qpQ]Da:U�gYn�`�V;s�a^g+s�def���a=cXY[Z \ ü¢t�gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdef�i^`�U�a�V/TKTK_�cbcba=f�TKaKn�VhX6`bU�a¢f�gY[^a � def;`bU�a¢`qp/]Da�ü¢�l¯�VcBa=��gY[^]�Weat�gYnbn�_�[^def�i�X�V\clg:[+V[^a=fQ`�`bU�gY`V_�cBWÎgYf�i_Dghia�U�ghnlg%`qp/]�a%TKVf�n�`bc�_�TK`bV\cBX�V\cB]�ghdec�n@t/`bU�a�`baKc�[^n

â7»Q½ � � Vóá�â�� j ��v�� v�y�|6¾ nP��� ghf�� â1»/½ � � V á�â���v��!v�yQ� j |6¾ nP�����V_�We�;s�V\`bU;sDa���a=WoW��q`qp/]�aK�;�Bde`bU;`qp/]DaKn á-â'~!�SXY[Z \ ö�Ï V Û �YÞ�Ð gYf�� XY[Z \ Ï á-â'~!� ö�Ï V Û �YÞ�ÐbÐ t/c�aKnb]DaKTK`�demaKWep/���BU�a�ÿ/_�ghf/`bd���a=c

v@y

Page 15: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

X U�gYnlghWecba3gh��p+s�aKa=f°defQm\aKnb`�deiQgh`�aK�;def£ÛÜñ�ghsDÝÝ Þ ghf��£Û r de`�Ý v�Þ t/s�_�`Bde`BU�ghnBf�V\`Bs�a=aKf°_�n�aK�°aK�/]�WedeTKde`bWep�dof;`�U�aJ��a���f�de`�doV\fVhX6¯�c�aKnbUDj°­6�r aK`�X�_�cb`bU�aKc���dÙä�aKc�aKf�TKa�sDaK`q��aKaKf°V\_�c�f�gh[+aKn�ghf���¯�cbaKn�U�j°­�den6`bUDgh`B��al��V�f�V`�U�g3maJg�n�aK]�ghc�gh`�a�`qp/]DaJVhX'f�gY[^aKn3t

s�_�`�c�gY`bU�a=c¢T@gYfÒgYnbnbdei\fH`bU�aK[ ghfHgYcbs�de`�c�ghc�p�Ï�n�do[+]�Wea Ð `qp/]�a V � u n¥g;T=Vf�n�aKÿ/_�aKf�TKa\tBf�gh[+aKn�T@gYf�f�V\`¢sDa^mgYWo_�aKn�def`bU�a¢V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghW#nbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKnB��a�def/`baKf���aK��X�VcB`�U�a¢W�gYf�i_�gYiat�s�a=T@gh_�n�a¢de`���V\_�We��f�V`l[;gh�\alnba=f�nba:`�V^TKV\[^]�_�`�aJ�Bdo`�U`bU�aK[£�J¯�V\claK��gY[^]�Weat�dÙX ò den�gYn�g�¦�§¨�©JVhX�dof/`�aKiaKcJ`qp/]Dat�`bU�a¢V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f ò �«v T@ghf�f�V`Js�a�aKmgYWo_Dgh`ba=�°_�f�WeaKn�n ò den]�c�VhmQde��a=�^�Bde`bU°g%��a���f�de`�doV\f'�#�BUQ_�n@t��BU�doWeaJ¯�c�aKnbU�j�­�f�gh[+aKn6T@gYf�sDaJ`bU�V\_�iU/`BVYX1ghnBcba X�aKcba=f�TKaKn3t�V_�c�f�gY[^aKnBghc�a¥¦�Øø ø�b©fsK©��b©3¦�³�©KªKt\dq� a\�'c�a�X�aKc�aKf�TKaKn%�Bdo`�U�V_�`ÌgYf^aK�/`ba=f�nbdeVf#�7¤�al[:_�n�`�de[^]DVn�aB`bU�gY`B`bU�aJ`�U�aKp^f�V`�VQT=TK_�cB�Bde`bU�V\_�`���a���f�de`�doV\fVf:`�U�aBWeaKma=W�Ý��¢`�U�aKp%��f��:`bU�aKdec6_�nba�Vf�Wep��BU�aKf^]�W�gYTKaK�:def¥g�TKV/��aBaK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f£Ï�dq� a�h_�f���aKcBgJsDVh� Ð `�V�nb`�ghf���X�V\c6nbV\[^a]�deaKTKa%VhX1T=VQ��at�V\clghnB]�W�ghT=aKU�VWe��a=cbnBX-Vc�X�cbaKa%mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn@t/�BU�a=cba�`�U�aKp^T3ghf;s�a%_�nbaK�+X�V\cBdefQ`�aKf�n�doV\f�ghW�T=VQ��a¢ghf�gYWepQn�den@��BU�a:Wede[^de`�gY`bdeVf+`bV;nbde[^]�Woa%`qpQ]DaKn�[;g3p^sDa:nbV\[^aK�BU�gY`�ghcbs�do`�c�gYcbp/��¤�a%X�aKWe`JTKV[+]�aKWeWeaK��`bV+��c�nb`�_�f���aKcbn�`�gYf���`bU�a

W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a6sDaK`b`�aKc�sDa�X�V\cbaB��a�a=�Q`�aKf��:de`6ghf���ia=f�aKc�gYWedoå=atQgYf���`bU�a�nbde[^]�Wop\�q`qp/]�aK��X�c�gYi[^a=fQ`#den'`bU�aB[^Vn�`'V\sQm/deV_�n'T�U�VdeTKaX�V\c�gË��c�nb`¢gY`b`�aK[^]�`Jgh`Jdef/`baKf�n�deVf�gYW1T=VQ��a^ghf�gYWop/n�don3���BU�a:_�f/X�Vc�`b_�fDgh`ba�TKV\f�nbaKÿ/_�a=f�TKa�Ï�gY`�Wea@gYnb`�X�V\c�f�Vh� Ð denJ`bUDgh`Jde`sDaKTKV[+aKn�do[+]�V\nbn�dos�Woa�X-Vc�TKV/��a;aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n^`bV�TKV\fQ`�ghdef�X-cbaKa;f�gY[^aKn�VYX�TKV/��a;`qp/]DaKn@t�ghf��í`bU/_�n:V_�c¢W�ghf�i_�gYiat6gY`Wea@ghn�`��BU�aKf^V\]�aKf+TKV/��aJaK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�nlghc�alTKV\f�TKaKc�f�aK�'tDden�g%`q��VY��WeaKm\aKWqthc�gY`bU�aKcB`�U�ghf:[:_�Wo`�d���WeaKm\aKW/WÎgYf�i_DghiaBWede�al±DõwgYf��j;aK`�gj°­��(ãlVh��aKmaKc3tDaKmaKf��Bdo`�U°`bU�don�Wedo[+de`�gh`�deVhf:`bU�a�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a�UDghnla=f�V_�i\U°aK�/]�c�aKnbn�dom\a¢]DVh��aKcl`�V^aKf�T=VQ��a¢[;ghf/pQt/d�Xf�V\`lghWeWqtdef/`baKc�aKnb`�def�i:aK��gh[+]�WeaKn6X-cbV[�[^a=`�g3�q]�c�Vic�gh[+[¢def�iJ]�c�ghTK`�doT=a�u f�V\`bU�a=clX-a@gh`�_�cba���a�TKV\f�nbde��aKcJdenla=�Q]�WodeTKde`�f�gh[+a�]DVWep/[^V\cb]�U�don�[£� u ]�cbVi\c�gY[�[;g3p^�Bghf/`l`�V^[�gYf�de]�_�W�gh`�alTKV/��a

aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�nlf�V¢[;gh`b`�aKc��BU�gh`�`bU�a=docBfDgh[^aB��aK]�a=f���aKf�T=doa=n�gYcbat/V\c�T=VQ��a�aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�nl�BU�V\nba�f�gh[+al��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKdeaKn�ghc�a_�f��/f�Vh�BfHgY`¢T=V[^]�doWea�`�de[^a� u `qp/]�deT@gYW�a=��gY[^]�Wea���V\_�We��s�a;ghf/p�cbaKTK_�cbnbdem\a^X-_�f�TK`�doV\f��BU�deT�UHnbT3ghf�n�VhmaKc:g;sDVh�/aK�`ba=cb[£��¤�U�aKf�do`Ba=f�TKV_�fQ`�aKcbn�g�W�gh[:sD��gJa=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf't®do`BUDghnB`bV+]�W�ghTKa�g!s"��©KªbÕ�f�gY[^a�dof�nb`ba3gh�°VYX¹`�U�a�sDV_�f��°mghc�dÎgYs�Weatghf��^cba=TK_�cbn�demaKWep:TKV\fQ`�defQ_�alnbT3ghf�f�def�i�`bU�alsDVQ��p:VhX'`bU�alW�gh[:sD��g�t3�BU�deT�U^den6de`�nbaKW�X¹g�s�Vh�/aK�+aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf#t/s�_�`���aK]DaKf���def�iVf:`�U�den6f�aK�BWep�def/`bc�V/��_�TKaK�+f�gh[+a�'¯�Vc6n�_�T�U:_�nba=n@t/V_�c6W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a�U�gYn�gJ`�aKcb[óTKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK` `�Y ���j Z VhX�`qp/]�a ]%Y ���jYü�BU�deT�U;donlg%]DVWep/[^Vc�]�U�deTlghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf°VYX¹ghf;_�f��Qf�Vh�Bf^nba=`lVhX6f�gY[^aB��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKdeaKn Y ��deno��V\dof/`�X�cbV\[�g�nba=`BVhX6f�gh[+aKn���#¤�U�aKf;��den6a=[^]�`qp/t3��algYs�s�cba=mQd�gY`baB`bU�aBTKVf�n�`bc�_�TK`bnBdef/`bV `�Y j Z ghf�� ]3Y jhü¢�#�BU�al`�aKcb[ Z Û Û§t Þ Þ den6`bU�aB]�V\Wop/[+Vcb]�U�deTdef�nb`�ghf/`bd�gY`bdeVf't\nb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdef�i^g�fDgh[^aB��aK]�a=f���aKf�T=p°nbaK`ct X�VcBg�s�V\_�f��;]�gYc�gh[+aK`ba=c�def Z �¯#dofDghWeWepQt���a�U�g3ma�g:`ba=cb[ T=Vf�n�`bcb_�TK`JX�V\c�fDgh[^aJn�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f 0f� j\ Z ^t2 Z b\� � `ln�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�aKn¢`�U�a�mghWe_�a�VYX Z ^�X�V\c

f�gY[^a � def^ghWeW/`bU�a�VQT=TK_�cbc�aKf�TKa=nlVhX � dof Z b Vf:`�U�a�³3Ø3�¤�b©3¦�µ7³�Ö3Ô©�øe©@÷3©Køe� � f:]Dghcb`�deTK_�W�ghc3th`bU�a�nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf:�BdeWeW/f�V`�`�gh�\a]�W�ghT=a�_�f���a=c�sDVh�/aKn@���BU�denlden�TKVf�n�denb`ba=fQ`J�Bde`bU�`bU�a�f�V`bdeV\f�VYX�]�c�aKnbaKc�mgh`�doV\f°VhX�TKV/��a¢WeaKm\aKWen@ÑDaKm\aKf/`b_�gYW'X-cbaKa�mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKnX�c�V[ `�U�ala=fQm/decbV\f�[^a=fQ`7VYX Z ^ nbU�V\_�We�:f�V`6sDal]DaKc�[^de`b`�aK�:`bV�T=cbaKaK]+_�f���a=c�V\`bU�aKc�sDVh�Qa=n@�7�BU�den6TKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=`lghWenbV�i\demaKn6_�ng��Ìg3p%`bVJ]�cbVhm/de��aJ©hI\µ-©@¦/ªK´�Ö\¦/ªKt/dq� a\����a���f�do`�deVf�n7X-Vc7f�gh[+aKn@tY�BU�deWoa�nb`�deWoW/_�n�def�iJf�gh[+aKn#X�Vc7`bU�a�´�¦�µ-©@¦/ªK´�Ö\¦�§hø\dof�X�Vc�[�gh`�deVfVhX7`bU�a=doc�de��aKf/`bde`qp/�

ß n��5Ï�Å1ì-»vu�7V°deWeWo_�nb`bc�gh`�a^V_�c¢W�ghf�i_�gYia^T=Vf�n�`bcb_�TK`bn;ghf��í[^V`�demgh`ba�`bU�a^X-_�cb`�U�aKc:��aKm\aKWeV]�[+aKf/`@t7��a^]�c�aKnba=fQ`;g°m\aKcbn�deVfHVYXl`bU�anb`�ghi\aK�ÚaK�/]�V\f�aKf/`bd�gh`�deVf�X-_�f�TK`�doV\fH`�U�gh`:��a;TKV_�We�í�Bcbde`ba;defHV\_�c:nbp/nb`�aK[£� � fÒ`�U�den:aK��gh[+]�Wea:��a°ghn�nb_�[+a^`�U�gh`�`bU�aW�ghf�i\_�ghi\aldenBaK�/`ba=f���aK�°�Bde`�U�`�U�aJs�ghn�a�`qp/]�aJVYX1def/`baKi\aKcbn3�

������Þ��������� ����Þ3! ] ��) ö 9f��#%$*���%�R<�&3'(��#%$ &3' ö 9f��#�$����3�R<ô)` ��) ± .I! ö 9f�G#%$����%�E<E) ± #*!"��#%$�)

�G�H#���+H$%- .�#HD����0/.3254�.2%.�$HD����,.�/r��� ���*Þ Û Û � Þ Þ .ß9Q#�&0/%<

D����,.%�H�,.��#

D����M9".�/�7o.%�ô<.�#3S

v@z

Page 16: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

����� !���#%$,&%' ö 9Â��#%$,&%'O�G#%$R<á�± #�!"�G#%$�)

# .��8K}!"��#%$8�G#2%.�$HD����,.H��� ����Þ Û Û K Þ Þ 9;D ���,K�<á#��#

D����M9 ± ��!N��#%$�) 0 K��,� 2 .�<.�#3S

&�4f�����S .6�������,���J�K%2�4f�(���S�.��

D����M9 ± ��!N��#%$�)��87�9;�87â/%<%<E! ö 9f��#%$ &3'(��#%$R<

�BU�aËX�_�f�TK`�deVf � ��� `�gh�\aKn:ghf�def/`baKi\aKc # gYf��Hi\aKf�aKc�gh`�aKn^ghf�def/`baKi\aKc:f�gY[^a K ���BU�aKfÚde`�T@gYWoWen�`�U�a;U�aKWe]DaKc�X-_�f�TK`�doV\f� ���*Þ `bV:s�_�doWe�;`bU�a�`baKc�[ Z \ |6¾5n Ï �Øh |G|�| h*�w xJy z

ÓhQv@Ð VYX6`qpQ]Da¢ö 9f��#3$��ªK��R< �6¯#def�gYWoWep/tde`Bn�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�aKn�`bU�a�f�gh[+a K �Bdo`�U

g�f�aK�BWep;def/`bcbV/��_�TKaK�°sDV_�f��°mghc�dÎgYs�Wea � t�sDa�X�V\cba�cbaK`�_�cbf�dof�i��B�BU�a%U�aKWe]�a=cBX�_�f�TK`bdeVf � ����Þ denlf�gY[^a��q]DVWep/[:Vcb]�U�deTÑde`�nf�gY[^al]Dghc�gY[^aK`�aKc Y donBdef�n�`�gYfQ`�d�gh`ba=�^�Bde`bU;`bU�a�c�aKWeaKmghf/`B��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKp�nbaK`JghnB]�gYcb`BVhX6`�U�a�gh]�]�WedeT@gY`bdeVf'�¬lV\`bdeTKal`�U�gh`�`bU�alia=f�aKc�gY`baK��cbaKn�do��_�ghWDTKV/��a�X�Vc 4Â�(Ý���S . ��V/aKn�f�V\`�TKV\f/`�ghdef^gYfQp�_�f�f�aKTKaKn�n�ghc�p;cbaK��deTKa=n@t�def:TKV\f/`bc�gYnb`

`bV:`�U�a�± ² m\aKcbn�doV\f;VhX6`bU�aJ]�c�Vi\c�gh[ X�cbV\[�S/aKTK`�deVf y � v � {

ä­>@? |<}�~����#����������}1���>���_������ f�V\cb��aKc�`bVln�`�gY`ba�`bU�a�`qp/]�aKT�U�a=T��/def�i�c�_�WeaKn@tY��a6f�aKaK�^gBT=V_�]�Wea�VhX�gY_��/deWod�gYcbp'��_���i[^a=fQ`�n@��¤�a�nb`�gYcb`7�Bde`bU�`�U�a���_���i\[^aKf/`X�V\c�Ô´eªonKÖ\´�¦�µ-¦�©Kª�ªlÏ dof/`�aKcbT�U�gYf�ia@gYs�Wep^c�a�X�aKc�cbaK��`bV^gYn�s"�b©=ªbÕ�¦�©=ª�ª Ð VYX1f�gY[^a���aK]DaKf���aKf�TKdeaKn@� � `BU�gYnB`bU�aJX-Vcb[

wòÉ tS����BU�aKc�a w denBg�TKVf/`ba=�Q`Bn�`bV\cbdef�i�]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKc�nB�Bdo`�U^`�U�aKdec�X�cba=nbU�f�a=nbn�ghf�f�V`�gY`bdeVf�n@t%t«denlg�fDgh[^aB��aK]�a=f���aKf�T=p°nbaK`3t�gYf����den�g^n�aK`�VhXBf�gh[+aKn@���BU�al��_���i[+aKf/`lden�n�gY`bdenq�DaK��d�XÌf�V\f�a:VhXB`bU�a:f�gh[+aKnBX�c�V[�� gh]�]Da@ghc�n�defPt:t'gYf��£d�XlghWeW7`bU�a]�gYc�gh[+aK`ba=cbn�X�c�V[:tóghc�aJ��aKTKW�ghc�aK�;X�c�aKnbU+X�V\c�� dof+`bU�a%TKVf/`ba=�Q` w �

wòÉ |����wòÉ tS��� ���ÊF�

w�Ég��y tS���w�É t��Q� Y �& Ê w �('�&

wOÉkYRy t����

¯#dei_�c�a�é�� ê done��Vdef/`bf�aKnbn'��_���i[+aKf/`7X�VcBfDgh[^a���aK]DaKf���a=f�TKdeaKn@�

¤�a^aK�/`�aKf��H`�U�a;TKVf�TKaK]�`:VYXl��deno��V\dof/`�f�aKnbn%X�V\c¢f�gY[^a���aK]DaKf���a=f�TKdeaKn^`�V£��done��Vdef/`bf�aKnbn%X�Vc�`qp/]�a=n¥gYf��ÒgYf�f�V`�gh`�aK�`qp/]�a=n@�B¤�a��BdeWeW�_�n�a�`bU�a�n�gY[^a�f�V`�gh`bdeV\f^X-Vc�gYWeW�`bU�c�aKa¢VYX6`bU�aK[�t�gYnl`bU�a���denb`�dof�TK`bdeVf;�BdeWeW'ghWe�Bg3pQnBsDa�TKWea@gYcBX�c�V[�`bU�aTKV\fQ`�aK�/`@���BU�aJ`q��V�f�aK��t�[:_�`b_�gYWeWop�cba=TK_�cbn�dema���_���i[+aKf/`bn�U�g3maJ`bU�alX-Vcb[

w�É ü�� � ghf�� wòÉ ü¢Û§t Þ � �

�BU�aKc�a w den�gËTKVf/`�aK�/`�VYXÌ]Dghc�gY[^aK`�aKcbnJghf���`bU�aKdeclX-cbaKn�U�f�aKn�n¥gYf�f�V`�gh`�doV\f�n@tDü�Û t Þ den�ghfH§\¦�¦�Öµ-§µ-©�Ô£µ-¶�Ó�©@t'gYf�� � denJgf�gY[^a�J�BU�aB��_���i[^a=fQ`�n�gYcba�n�gh`�denq��aK��d�X � ��V/aKnJf�V`�gh]�]�a@gYc�X�cbaKa:def�`bU�a�`qp/]�a�ü¢t®f�VcJdef£`�U�a�]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKc�n�VYX�`qp/]�aü¢tDghf��;`�U�a�f�gY[^aJ��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKp�t�denB��deno��V\defQ`�X-cbV[ý`bU�a�fDgh[^aJn�aK` 0f� 2/t�gYnB��aK`ba=cb[^def�a=��s/p;`bU�a�]�cba=mQdeV\_�nbWep^��a���f�aK���_���i[^a=fQ`�X�V\cB��deno��V\dof/`�f�aKnbnBVYX6��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKdeaKn@�l��s�n�aKcbm\a¢`�U�gh`B`�U�a�c�_�WeaJX�VcB��done��Vdef/`bf�aKnbnBVYX¹fDgh[^aJghs�n�`bc�ghTK`�doV\f;`qpQ]DaKncba=ÿQ_�doc�aKnl`�U�gh`�`bU�a�s�V\_�f��+f�gh[+a ó denB��d�ä�aKcba=fQ`�X-cbV[ý`bU�aJf�gY[^al��al`�aKnb`Jghi/ghdef�nb`3�'�BUDgh`BT@gYf gYWe�Ìg3p/n6sDa�ghT�U�deaKma=��s/pghWe]�UDg3�qcbaKf�gY[^def�i�`bU�a%s�V\_�f���f�gh[+a ó `bV^n�V[+alX-cbaKn�U£f�gY[^at�gYnJ��aKnbT=cbdes�a=��sQp;ûBghc�aKf���c�aKi`[� n!q�gYcbd�ghs�Woa�Z�V\fQm\aKf/`bdeVf#��BU�a�c�_�WeaJX�V\cB_�f�demaKc�n�gYWoWep+ÿQ_Dghf/`bd���aK�;`qp/]DaKnJdof�nbaKc�`bnl`�U�a�]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKc Y def/`bV w t�s�_�`l�Bde`�U�`�U�aJX�c�aKnbU�f�aKnbn�ghf�f�V\`�gY`bdeVf

v ·

Page 17: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

Äl¼�Å�»£¿#á�}f�3¾�á-â�~3â1»/}@}

wòÉ�v � �wòÉ üS� � wòÉ Ì�� �

wOÉ Ï�ü,`ÍÌ Ð � �wòÉ ü¢Û§t Þ � �

wòÉ ö�Ï�ü¢Û§t Þ�Ð � �

wòÉ üS� � �F�\ ówòÉ Ï X�gZ \ ü Ð � �

wzy�Y �;Ï4� yQ�/ÐRÉ üS� � ���Êd�wOÉ Ï ]3Y ���jhü Ð � �

{:â7â7¾�~3��~3»�¿1Ä�¼�Å6»£¿#á�}f�3¾Dá�â�~3â'»�}3}wOÉ üS� � w0É t�� �

wòÉ ü¢Û§t Þ � �

¯#dei_�c�a�æ�� ê deno� Vdef/`bf�aKn�n'��_���i\[^aKf/`�n6X�V\c�`qp/]DaKn�gYf��°ghf�f�V`�gY`baK�;`qp/]DaKn@�

Ï4� yQ�/Ð t/c�gh`�U�aKcB`�U�ghf���_�n�`����7�BU�aJde��a@g�denB`bUDgh`Bg�f�gh[+a � den���done��Vdef/`Q�PX�cba=nbU+X�cbV\[�g%`qpQ]DaJü«d�X1de`���VQa=nlf�V\`BVQT=TK_�cBdefü¢tDghf��;de`Bden�X�cba=nbU;X�V\clghWeW�`bU�aJX�cba=a�]�ghc�gh[+aK`baKc�nBVhX6ü¢���7V¢]�c�aKnba=cbma:`�U�denBdefQ`�aKcb]�cbaK`�gh`bdeV\f't�f�a=�«]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKc�nB[:_�nb`�s�adef/`bcbV/��_�TKaK�°def/`bV�`bU�aJTKV\f/`baK�/`l�Bde`�U^aK�/`ba=f���aK��X�cba=nbU�f�a=nbn�ghf�f�V`�gY`bdeVf#�¤�a�ghWen�Vlcba=ÿQ_�doc�aÌg#��_���i\[^aKf/`D`bV���aKTKde��aBd�X�gBi\dom\aKf�`qp/]Da6üÚdon#��a=WoW��-X�Vc�[^aK��def�`bU�a�f�gh[+a1T=Vf/`baK�/`�°gYf���]�gYc�gh[+aK`ba=c

TKV\fQ`�aK�/` w t�dq� a�D�BU�aK`�U�aKc¢gYWoW7`�U�a�X�cba=a:f�gh[+aKn�gYf��£]Dghc�gY[^aK`�aKcbnJVYXÌüwghc�a¢��aKTKW�ghc�aK��def� Vc w t�c�aKnb]DaKTK`�dom\aKWepQ�Ë�BU�a��_���i[^a=fQ`�cba@gY��n �Ñ wòÉ üô��Xghf��£de`bn%cb_�WeaKn¢gYcba���a���f�aK�HsDaKWeVh����¬lV`�deTKa:`bU�gY`JVf�Wep°`�U�a:f�gh[+aKnlVYXÌ]Dghcb`�deTK_�W�ghcJnbp/[:sDVWen@t�gYf��£f�V`�`�U�aKdecJ`qpQ]DaKn�VhXX�c�aKnbU�f�aKnbn�ghf�f�V`�gh`bdeV\f�nÌgYcbaJcba=Woa=mghf/`�X�VcB`�U�a6��_���i\[^aKf/`3�

�Ñ wòÉ�v ��X�Ñ wòÉ üô��X �Ñ wOÉ Ì���X

�Ñ wOÉ ü,`ÍÌ ��X yQ� � V Ñ w8É üô��X�Ñ w�É Ï XY[Z \ ü Ð ��X

�Ñ wOÉ üô��X t+' ¿#¾(Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾�Ï Ï w:Ð�Ñ wOÉ ö¢Ï ü¢Û§t Þ�Ð ��X

�(' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð �Ñ wzy�Y �� É üô��X�Ñ w�É�]3Y ��Fj@üô��X

¯#doi\_�cba v Ý��#¤�aKWeWÙ�-X�V\cb[^a=��f�aKn�n���_���i[+aKf/`7X�VcB`qp/]DaKn@�

¤�alghWenbV%f�aKaK�+`bV���a���f�a���a3gh�a=f�def�i�Vf:`qp/]DaKn@�7d�X1gJ`qp/]DalTKV\f/`�ghdef�n�gJTKaKc�`�ghdef+nbaK`�VhX'f�gY[^a���aK]DaKf���a=f�TKdeaKn@tD��alT@gYfghWe�Bg3p/n�]�gYnbn�do`lgYnlg�`qp/]�a��Bde`�U g�n�_�]DaKcbn�aK`JVhX6��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKdeaKn�def�n�`ba@gY�'� u nldef;`bU�aJ]�c�aKm/doV\_�n1� _���i[+aKf/`bn3t/U�aKcba%`bV/V:de`[�g3p:sDa�f�a=aK��aK��`�V^ghWe]�U�gP��c�aKf�gh[+al`�U�a¢sDV_�f��°f�gY[^aKnB�BU�a=f°TKV[+]�ghc�def�i¢`q��V X �q`qpQ]DaKn3� � `lT@gYf£ghWe�Bg3p/nBs�a���Vf�a�s/pT�U�V/Vn�dof�i^gJX�c�aKnbU�f�gh[+a ó �¯#dofDghWeWepQt/`q��V^`qp/]DaKnJüþghf���Ì�gYcba^©g�3Ø/´�÷@§Yøo©3¦�µ#dÙX�ü6��� Ì�ghf���Ì8���/ü�� � f�`bU�a%X�_�`�_�cba�`baK�/`3t���a��BdoWeW�de[^]�WodeTKde`�Wop

aKÿ/_�gY`bal`qp/]DaKnB�BU�deT�U�gYcbala=ÿQ_�domgYWeaKf/`@� � `6den���_�nb`bd���a=�^s/p¢`�U�a�X�ghT=`6`bU�gY`�`q��V�`qp/]DaKnlghc�alaKÿ/_�demghWeaKf/`6d�ä;`bU�aKp+��d�ä�a=c�V\f�Wepdef¢`�U�alV\cb��a=cbdef�iJVhX�f�gh[+aKn6ghf��:]Dghc�gY[^aK`�aKcbn�dof�`bU�aKdec6f�gh[+a���aK]�a=f���aKf�T=doa=n@�6û�_�`�f�gh[+a6��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKdeaKnlgYcbalT=Vf�n�do��aKcbaK�nba=`bn@tDn�V:`bU�denBVc���aKc�dof�i:nbU�V\_�We�^f�V\`B[�gh`�`baKc3��BU�a�X�VWeWeVh�Bdef�ilWeaK[+[�gYn'Wea@gh�:`�V¢a=nb`�gYs�WedenbU�[+aKf/`6VhX']�gYc�gY[^aK`�cbdeTKde`qp¢]�cbV]DaKc�`bdeaKnBVhX'`�U�aJ`qp/]�def�i���_���i[^a=fQ`3���BU�den@t\def

v@x

Page 18: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

v ��� vÌØ^����hü_^ ücb1����ÌXbü_^*`ôü�b1����ÌØ^a`ÍÌÀb

ü����%ÌX�gZ \ ü*��� X�gZ \ Ì

ü����3Ì t*'�mö�Ï�ü�Û t Þ Ð ���ö�Ï�ÌËÛ m Þ�Ð

ü����3Ì �(':&]3Y ���jhü���� ]3Y �&�j�Ì

¯#dei_�c�a vv �6S�_�s�`qp/]�def�iB��_���i\[^aKf/`@�

`b_�cbf't���V\_�We�^sDa�def�n�`bc�_�[^aKf/`�ghW�def^]�c�Vhm/dof�i¢`�U�aJ]�cbV\icba=nbn�gYf��^`qp/]Da�]�c�aKnbaKc�mgh`�doV\f+X�Vc�f�gh[+a��q]�V\Wop/[+Vcb]�U�deT�def�n�`�ghf/`�dÎgP�`bdeV\f�ghf���fDgh[^a�TKVf�TKcbaK`�deVf;TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�n�VYX6V_�cBW�ghf�i_�gYia���»3Ï�Ï�� u¡�¢¤£¦¥�wòÉ tS��&¨§J©iªK�('�&+«�¬o­i®¯© wOÉ t��Q� ¢°-¢­wòÉ t ^ �Q�±§[©iª wòÉ t b �Q� £²¥ §J©iª´³W©�µ·¶ £²¥CwOÉ Ï�t ^ 5zt b Ð �Q� ¢

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ«� f�a3ghT�U°T@gYnbatDs/p�g�n�`bc�gYdeiU/`qX�V\cb�Bghc��^def���_�T=`bdeVf;Vf;`�U�a�T@gYcb��def�gYWode`qp:VYX1`bU�a¢gh]�]�cbV]�cbd�gh`�a���aK]�a=f���aKf�T=p£n�aK`@�{

��»3Ï�Ï��v¹<ºt»�ð7|6}K~3á�~¤ð1~=á�¾Dâ£��⹿í� ð�n�á-ì�á-���h¼��ð6¿RÈ(Ï�»/â'~h}W¼¡�¢¤£¦¥�wzy�Y �� É tS��&½§J©iª wòÉ m����v«�¬¾­i®g© wOÉ Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ t Ð �Q&+«°-¢¤£¦¥�wzy�Y �� É ü¢Û§t Þ � � §[©iª w�É mÀ�Q��«�¬o­H®g© wòÉ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ � � «Á�¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ wzyY �� É üQ ¥ «3§[©iªKm�' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð «_§J©iª wòÉ mÃ�Q�v«�¬¾­i®g©d�Ñ w�É Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð Â ¥ «Ä-¢¤£¦¥ tÀ^�'ot­bÅ«�¬o­i®g©íÛ m Ñ Y/Þ tÀ^¤' Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ t­bt«Æ�¢¤£¦¥ ü����%ÌT«.¬o­i®g©�Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü7���DÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ì ¢

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ S/`bc�ghdeiU/`qX-Vcb�Bghc��^def���_�TK`bdeVf+Vf;`bU�a���aKcbdemgh`�deVf^VYX6`bU�a�gh]�]�cbV\]�cbd�gh`�aJcbaKW�gh`�deVf't/_�n�def�i^­�aK[+[�g v � {

��»3Ï�Ï��vÇÈ%¥}wzy�Y �� É� ªÅ Ï ü Ð � � §[©iª wòÉ m��Q�v«.¬o­i®¯© wòÉ� ªÅ Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð � �H¢¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ ¤�a%��cbn�`�n�U�Vh�«`bUDgh` ªÅ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð 'óÛ m Ñ Y/Þ[ ªÅ Ï ü Ð �J�BU�a¢T@gYnba��BU�aKf Y��Ê ªÅ Ï ü Ð denl`�cbdem/dÎgYWqt�nbV;��a¢ghn�nb_�[+a`bUDgh` Y Ê ªÅ Ï�ü Ð �:�BU�aKf ªÅ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð \ÍÏ ªÅ Ï ü Ð./�0QY 2 Ð 5 ªÅ Ïfm Ð ghf���Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ[ ªÅ Ï ü Ð \ÍÏ ªÅ Ï�ü Ð�/!0;Y 2 Ð 5vm;�:û�_�`@t ªÅ Ïfm Ð 'Ém;t�ghf��í`bU/_�n ªÅ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ' Û¿m Ñ Y�ÞJ ªÅ Ï ü Ð �î¬lVh��t7def�nb`�ghf/`bd�gY`bdef�i£­®aK[^[;g y � v t'�Bde`bU6t \ ªÅ Ï�ü Ð gYf��& \ 0Â� 2/t��alV\s�`�gYdof wOÉ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�ÞJ ªÅ Ï�ü Ð�Ð � � �7¯�cbV[óU�a=cbat�_�nbdef�i¢­®aK[^[;g v � y ghf��:`�U�a6��_�nb`�aKnb`�ghs�WedenbU�a=��def�a=ÿQ_DghW��de`qpQt\��a�V\s�`�gYdef�`�U�aJcbaKÿ/_�dec�aK� wòÉ� ªÅ Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð � � �

{

ä­>�= ÊvË���Ê´��Ì��*ͤ�������_��BU�aJ`qp/]�def�iB��_���i\[^aKf/`�VhX1V\_�cBW�ghf�i\_�ghi\alU�gYnB`bU�a�X�Vc�[

�Ñ {zÉ3Î6Z �\ü¢Û§t Þ� `Jcba@gY��n@�Jdef°`�U�a:]�c�aKnbaKf�TKa^VYX�f�gh[+a�TKV\fQ`�aK�/`Ï�t�mghc�d�ghs�Wea�TKV\f/`baK�/` { ghf��°]�ghc�gh[+aK`baKcJTKV\f/`baK�/` w t�`bU�a¢`�aKcb[ Z U�gYn`qp/]�a%ü«�Bdo`�U;f�gh[+al��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKp�tË� u n�TK_�n�`bV[;ghc�pQt/��aJ]�cbaKn�_�]�]DVn�a¢`�U�gh`JghWeW�defQm\VWema=�^TKV\fQ`�aK�/`bnJghcbaJ��aKWeW���X�V\cb[+aK�'�� f;]�ghc�`bdeTK_�W�gYc@t�ghWeW�`�U�aJmghcbd�gYs�WeaKn@t/f�gY[^aKnBghf���]Dghc�gY[^aK`�aKcbnlgYcbaJ��denb`�def�TK`@tDghf��;ghWeW�`bU�aKdecB`qpQ]DaKnJghcba%��aKWeW��-X�Vc�[^aK�'�®�BU�a

v ç

Page 19: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

ÐJ¾Dâ¹}=~3��â'~h}WÑ�×/���há-��|7ì�»�}%��â6¿íâ1�5Ï�»�}t*' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð

�Ñ {FÉ3Î6h � v Û t ÞT#� ü�Ê { t*' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð

�Ñ {FÉ3Î T;�hüHÛ§t Þ

p �e� ü¢Û§t Þ Ê { t�'�m m8' ¿#¾(Ï Ïf Ð 5 ¿'¾(Ï Ï w:Ð�Ñ {�É3ÎPp �hüHÛ¿m Þ

� � V Êd t�' ¿'¾(Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð�Ñ {�É3ÎP� � V Û ��y t Þ

±�Ò �Y��ìq�fð7ì�ð6}J��⹿í�h»��fð7�}=á�¾Dâ�Ñ wOÉ ü ��X �Ñ {}y T'� ü É3ÎPZ ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ

�Ñ {�É3Î ±�T#� ükj Z �Yü,`ÍÌ�Û§t Þ�Ñ {�É3Î1Z ^J�hü�`ÕÌÚÛ§t Þ �Ñ {�É3ÎPZ b��hüíÛ t Þ

�Ñ {�É3ÎPZ ^ Z b%��ÌÚÛ§t Þ

�Ñ wOÉ üô��X �Ñ {Iy T#� ü É3ÎPZ �YüHÛ§t Þ�Ñ {FÉ3Î a n T'� ükj Z �hüíÛ t Þ

ë ¾'¿#��ì-á-~K¼

�Ñ {ÔÓÔÉ3ÎPZ �hüHÛ§t Þ m8' ¿'¾(Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð�Ñ {ËÉ Î |6¾5nPZ �ö�Ï�üíÛ t Þ Ð Û m Þ

�Ñ {�É Î Z ^ �ö�Ï�ü¢Û Þ�Ð Û§t Þ �Ñ {IyQp �e� ü É Î Z b ��ÌÚÛ t Þ�Ñ {�É3Î�ì-»/~¢|�¾ nPp1qsZ ^ á�â�Z bJ��Ì�Û§t Þ

�Ñ {�É Î Z ^ �\ö¢Ï ü¢Û¿m Þ�Ð Û§t Þ �Ñ {}y v �e�� ü¢Û¿m ÞRÉ Î Z b ��Ì�Û§t Þ m �\�Õ�Ñ {zÉ3ÎHì-»/~�|6¾ n v qsZ ^ á�â�Z b���ÌÚÛ§t Þ

¯#dei_�c�a v@y �7��p/]�def�i�cb_�WeaKnBVYX¹`�U�aJTKVc�a�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a¢Ï r gYcb` v3Ð �

f�gY[^a���a=]�aKf���aKf�TKp6tw��aKnbaKc�maKn�X-_�cb`�U�aKc�aK�/]�W�gYf�gh`�doV\f't�sDaKT@gY_�nba;de`JiV/aKn�`�V�`�U�a:U�gYcb`�VYXÌV\_�c�`bc�a@gh`�[^aKf/`JVhXBf�gY[^aKn3�u n�gYWoc�a@gh��p�U�dof/`�aK�'tD��a���V+f�V`�V]DaKc�gY`bdeVf�gYWeWop+`bc�a@gh`Jf�gY[^aKnJghnlmgYWe_�aKn@� � XÌgYf°aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�TKVf/`�gYdef�n�gYf°V/TKTK_�c�cbaKf�T=aVhXlg+f�gh[+atDde`�T3ghf�f�V\`Js�a:aKmgYWe_�gh`�aK�'� ¡ gh`bU�aKc@t�fDgh[^a=n�gYcba�aK[^]�WoVhp\aK�£gYn�]�W�ghTKa=U�VWe��aKc�nJX�V\clX-cbaKa:mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�def£TKV/��aaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�n¢Ï dq� a\�ot/_�f���aKclg�sDVh� Ð t/�BU�aKc�a�`bU�aKcba��BdeWeWDs�a�f�V¥gY`b`ba=[^]�`�nB`bV:aKmgYWo_Dgh`ba�`bU�a=[£t/nbdef�T=a�a=mghWe_�gh`�deVf^VYX1sDVh�/aK�aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�nldenB]DVn�`b]DVf�aK�#� � f;`bU�denBn�aKf�nba\t�Vf�aJ[;g3p¢n�g3p^`bUDgh`lg%��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKp£ghf�f�V`�gh`bdeV\f^VhX6n�V[^a�`baKc�[ ´Îª�§\¦�¶�ªK©@µÖ#s�¦�§¨�©=ªlªKØ/³�Õ;µeÕ�§\µ1µeÕ�©%µ�©��K¨ ³�§\¦Ë��©�ªK§#sK©=øo¶%©@÷3§høeØQ§\µ�©�Ô:Ö\¦�³�©�§hø�ø�Ö#s�µoÕ�©�øo´eªKµ-©�Ô�¦�§\¨¢©=ª�§��b©�Óô��Ö÷3´�Ô©�Ôk�6´�µeÕ^©gIµ-©3¦/ªK´�Ö¦/ªK��BU/_�n@tDd�XatódenJg:f�gY[^aJ��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKp�X�V\c�g:i\demaKf;`ba=cb[ Z def°n�V[+a�T=Vf/`baK�/`3t'ghf/p;nbaK`�m(Ö8tó�BU�deT�U°denl��aKWeWÙ�-X�V\cb[^a=��Bde`bU;cba=nb]DaKTK`�`�V:`bU�a�T=Vf/`baK�/`3t�denlg�mgYWode�+f�gh[+al��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKp;X-Vc Z ghnB��aKWeW���¤�aJ�BdoWeW�s�_�doWe�+`bU�denlde��a3g�dof/`�V¢`�U�a�`qp/]�anbp/n�`baK[Ís/p^ghWeWeVh�Bdef�i���a@gh�\aKf�def�i;Ï�dq� a�/aKf�W�gYcbidef�i Ð VhX7f�gh[+al��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKdeaKn�gh`Bn�]�a=TKd���T�`qp/]�def�i�cb_�WeaKn3�û�a X�Vc�aB]�cbV/TKaKa=��def�i�X�_�cb`�U�aKc3t��a���a���f�aBghf�V]DaKc�gY`bdeVf { Ó Vf%mghcbd�gYs�Wea6TKVf/`�aK�/`bn@� � `#aKc�gYnbaKn�`bU�aBV\cb��def�gYcbpJmghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn

v

Page 20: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

×+� Ï�»�} y;� � V Ñ {gÉ Î Z �YüHÛ§t Þ w�ÉT ªÅ Ï�ü Ð � �

y;� � V Ñ {gÉ3ÎP� j Z ��Ï XY[Z \ ü Ð Û t Þ yQ� � V Ñ {�É Î Z ��Ï XYØZ \ ü Ð Û§t Þ wOÉ� ªÅ Ï�ü Ð � �

y;� � V Ñ {gÉ3ÎPZ.�á� �hüHÛ§t Þ y;� � V Ñ {�É Î.Ù Y Z �hüíÛ t Þ w � �cÉ ü¢Û§t Þ � �

�Ñ {FÉ Î â7»/½ � � Vwá-âoZ �hüHÛ§t Þ

×+� Ï�»�Å�¾�ì-¼�Ï�¾��fÅ�Æ7á�}¤Ï

�Ñ {�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü8Z �YüHÛ§t Þ�Ñ {�É3ÎÝ`�Y ��Fj Z � ]3Y ���jhüHÛ§t Þ

�Ñ {�É Î Z � ]%Y ���jYüHÛ§t Þ wòÉ m���� m8' ¿'¾(Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾�Ï Ï w:Ð�Ñ {�É3Î1Z Û Û¿m Þ Þ ��Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð Û§t Þ

×+� Ï�»�}¤ð7|6}K~3á�~�ð'~3á�¾Dâ1} y;� � V Ñ {�É3Î6Z ^l� V Û§t Þ yQ� � V Ñ {gÉ3ÎoZ bJ��Ì Û �(y t Þ

yQ� � V Ñ {gÉ Î 0Â� j\ Z ^ 2 Z b ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ

»�ð1|7~K¼�Å7á-â�È�Ñ {FÉ Î Z �YüHÛ§t Þ ü����3Ì

�Ñ {�É3Î1Z ��Ì Û§t Þ

¯#dei_�c�a v@z �7��p/]�def�i�cb_�WeaKnBVYX¹`�U�aJTKVc�a�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a¢Ï r gYcb` y\Ð �

X�c�V[ { gYf��;T�UDghf�i\aKnBf�Vf�cba���a=�Qdem\a�aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f°U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don v �e�� ü«dof/`�V:cba���a=�Qdem\a�V\f�aKn v �o� ü¢�Ϫ| Ð Ó \ |

Ï {}y T'� ü Ð Ó \ { ÓÏ {Iy v �e�� ü�Û§t Þ�Ð Ó \ { Ó y v �e� ü�Û§t ÞÏ {}y;p �o� ü�Û§t Þ�Ð Ó \ { Ó yQp �e� ü¢Û§t Þ

�BU�a�`qpQ]�dof�i�cb_�WeaKn�VhX'V\_�c�WÎgYf�i_DghialgYcba�]�cbaKn�aKf/`baK��dof^¯#dei_�cbaKn v@y gYf�� v@z � � f+`bU�a¸X�VWeWeVh�Bdef�il`�aK�/`@t/��al`�cbp:`bV�aK�/]�W�ghdefnbV\[^a�VhX1`�U�a�def/`bc�doT3ghTKdeaKn3t���aKT=don�deVf�nlgYf��;dof/`�aKcb��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKdeaKnJsDaKU�def��°`�U�aJ��aKn�doi\f;VhX1`�U�a�`qp/]Da�n�p/nb`ba=[£�Z�Vf�nbde��aKcJ�Dcbnb`%`bU�a+cb_�Wea%X�Vc¢±��bghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f'�:¬lV\`bdeTKa:`�U�gh`�de`Jcba=WodeaKn%Vf�Vf�a:VYXÌ`�U�a^gh_��/deWed�ghcbp���_���i[+aKf/`bn�X�cbV\[Í`bU�a]�c�aKm/doV\_�nJnbaKT=`bdeVf�`�V^T�U�aKT����BU�aK`bU�aKc�`bU�a¢`qp/]Da:ü VhX�`bU�a:sDV_�f��£mgYcbd�ghs�WeaJdenJ��aKWeW��-X�Vc�[^aK�'�¸�BU�gh`JdenJs�aKT3gh_�n�a:`qpQ]DaKnT@gYf^[^a=fQ`�deVf:f�gY[^aKn�gYf��^]Dghc�gY[^aK`�aKcbn3t�ghf��+de`6U�ghnB`�V¢a=f�nb_�c�aJ`bU�gY`�`�U�aJVf�aKnlgYTK`b_DghWeWep¢V/TKTK_�cbcbdef�i:def:ü!U�g3maJghWecba3gh��psDaKaKf;��aKTKW�gYcbaK�;def^`�U�aJf�gh[+aBTKVf/`ba=�Q`�íghf��+`bU�aJ]�gYc�gY[^aK`�aKc�T=Vf/`baK�/` w t\s�a X�Vc�a�`�U�aJU/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�donXT#� ü!den�]�WÎgYTKaK�;def/`bV`bU�a�mghc�dÎgYs�WealTKV\f/`baK�/`@���BU�aJn�pQf/`�U�aKnbdeåKa=�£`qp/]DalÌó��V/aKn�f�V`BU�g3m\aJ`bV:sDa�T�U�aKT��aK� X�VcB��aKWeW���X�V\cb[+aK��f�aKn�n@t/sDaKT@gY_�nba�`bU�a`qp/]�def�i�cb_�WeaKn�i_�gYc�ghf/`�aKaJdo`3t/]�cbVhm/de��aK�°gYWoWD`bU�a�TKVf/`�aK�/`bn�gYcbaJ��aKWeWÙ�-X�V\cb[^a=�:`bU�aK[+nbaKWem\aKn@�

v é

Page 21: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

¬la=�Q`�TKVf�nbde��aKc�`bU�a�c�_�Wea�X�VcBsDVh���6S/de[^deW�ghcbWep�`�V^± ² t�de`BT�U�aKT��/nl`bU�a�s�Vh�/aK�;aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf Z ghi/ghdef�nb`Bg�mghc�d�ghs�WealT=Vf/`baK�/`{ Ó X�cbV\[ �BU�deT�U�`bU�a�mghWe_�a�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn7U�g3ma�s�a=aKf^aKc�ghn�aK�'� � f^gh����de`bdeVf { Ó T�UDghf�i\aKn6`bU�aBnb`�gY`b_�n�VhX'ghWeW/`bU�aBf�Vf�c�a���aK�/demaaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f^mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn#defQ`�VJcba���a=�Qdem\aBVf�aKn3�7�BU�den7don7sDaKT@gY_�nba�`bU�a�X�c�aKaBaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f^mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn7def Z ghcbalgYWecba@gY��p�aKf�T=WoV\nbaK�s/pHg;sDVh��Ñ�`bU�a=doc�V/TKTK_�c�cbaKf�TKaKn°ghc�a^f�V\`�X�V\c�]�_�c�]�V\nba;VhXJaKmghWe_�gY`bdeVf(�hcba ��aKTK`�doV\f't#s�_�`�c�gh`�U�aKc�X�V\c�TKV\[^]DVnbdef�i�]�deaKTKaKnVhXJTKV/��a°def/`bV�g�W�ghcbi\aKc:Vf�a�èS/def�T=a�sDVh�/def�i£n�_�nb]DaKf���n�a=mghWe_�gh`�deVf't7`�U�a°`ba=cb[�T@ghf�sDa°ghn�nbdeif�a=�èghf/p���aKWeWÙ�-X�V\cb[^a=���aK]DaKf���aKf�TKp°n�aK`�m;���s�nba=cbma+`bU�gY`���a:U�g3ma:`q��V°��d�ä�aKcbaKf/`�`qp/]�def�i\nJX�V\c�`�U�a ì-»/~l|6¾5n a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf'��V\f�a:U�ghf���WeaKn�cba ��aK�/dema^a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n3tdq� a�a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n��Bde`bU^a=[^]�`qp�f�gh[+aB��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKdeaKn@t�gYf��^`�U�aJV`bU�aKcBden6X�V\c�`�U�alf�Vf�c�a���aK�/demaJVf�aKn@� u We`baKc�f�gh`�demaKWep/t��aTKV\_�We��UDg3maldef/`bc�V/��_�TKaK��`q��V�nbp/f/`�gYTK`bdeT@gYWoWep+��d�ä�aKc�aKf/`lTKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=`bn@��BU�a:TKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=` â7»Q½ iaKf�aKc�gY`baKn¢gËX�c�aKnbU�fDgh[^a\t�gYf���`bU�aKf�T�U�a=T��/n3t'_�n�def�i;`bU�a^gY_��/doWed�ghc�p^��dene��Vdef/`bf�a=nbn6��_���i\[^aKf/`3t�d�X`bU�alnbp/f/`bU�aKnbdeåKaK�+`qp/]�aJghf���f�gh[+a���aK]�a=f���aKf�T=p^��V�f�V`6TKV\f/`�ghdef%X�cba=alV/TKTK_�c�cbaKf�TKaKnlVYX�`�U�den6f�aK� f�gh[+a���BU�aBV\]�aKc�gh`�doV\fw � � aK�/`ba=f���nl�Bde`�U � `bU�aJX�cba=nbU�f�a=nbn�gYf�f�V\`�gh`�deVf^VYX1aKm\aKcbp+]�ghc�gh[+aK`baKc�def w �7�BU�den�denBVf�Wep:nbV\_�f��'t/n�def�TKa � denBg�f�aK�f�gY[^a� � `�den�f�aKTKaKn�n�ghc�p^def:Vc���aKcB`�V�`qp/]�a�]�V\nbnbdes�WeaJghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f�nB�Bde`bU:f�gY[^a � dof:`�U�alsDV/��p:VhX â7»/½ �7�BU�alV\]�aKc�gh`�doV\fdenB��a���f�aK�°cba=TK_�cbn�demaKWep°ghn3�

Ϫ| Ð � � \ |Ï wzyY �� Ð � � \ Ï w � �/Ð"yY �;Ïf� y;�/Ð

u n�aK�/]�W�ghdef�a=�^sDa�X�Vc�at/`bU�a�fDgh[^aBghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf^T=Vf�n�`bcb_�TK` � j Z TKcba3gh`ba=n�gJTKWeV\nb_�c�a��Bde`�U � VhX'`bU�a¥÷3§høeØ/©�VYX Z t/`�U�gh`��Bg3pghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�def�i^`�U�a�aKm\aKf/`b_�gYW'V/TKTK_�c�cbaKf�TKaKn�VYX � def�de`3�6¬lV\`bdeTKatDU�Vh��aKm\aKc@t�`bU�gY`l`bU�a�nbde��aJTKV\f���de`bdeVf w�É´ ªÅ Ï�ü Ð � � def`bU�a�`qp/]�def�iÌ� _���i[+aKf/`6denBTKcb_�TKd�ghWq� � `BaKf�nb_�c�aKnJ`bU�gY`B`bU�aJ]�gYc�gh[+aK`ba=cbnBV/TKTK_�c�cbdef�i+dof Z T=V_�We�^f�V`BsDa�nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`baK���Bdo`�Ug%nbaK`BTKV\f/`�ghdef�def�iJ`�U�aJf�gh[+a � � � X1`�U�gh`���aKcbaJ]DVnbn�des�Weat/`bU�a�f�aK�!V/TKTK_�c�cbaKf�T=a¢VYX � ��V\_�We�:s�a�ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�aK�;Vf+`bU�a�Woa=maKWVhXB`ba=cb[^n3t's�_�`�`bU�aKcba+��V\_�We�£sDa:f�V°s�def���dof�i�def�`bU�a+TKVc�cbaKn�]�V\f���def�i°`qp/]Dat7`bU/_�n%T@gh_�n�def�i°_�f�n�V_�f���s�aKUDg3mQdeV\c@�+�BU�acba3ghnbV\f;X�V\cB`bU�gY`BdonB`�U�gh`B`�U�a�ÿ/_�gYfQ`�d���aKcBdef XY[Z Û ü«denBde`bnba=WÙX�g�s�def���aKc@tDghf��;`q��V:f�gh[+a�ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf;`qp/]�aKn��BU�deT�U���dÙä�aKcVf�Wop:def;`bU�a�fDgh[^a=n�VYX1sDV_�f��°gY`bV[+n@t/ghc�a�TKVf�nbde��aKc�aK�°aKÿ/_�gYW��¯�V\cJaK��gh[^]�Woa\t�TKVf�nbde��aKc�`�U�a�X�V\WoWeVh�Bdef�i:`�aKcb[�t�deWoW��q`qp/]�aK��dof�`bU�a:]�cbaKn�aKf�TKa;VYXÌ`�U�a:nbde��a��qTKV\f���de`bdeVf�Vf�`�U�a:`qp/]�def�i

cb_�Woa�X�V\cBf�gh[+alghs�n�`bc�ghTK`�doV\f'�#�.��,KI!"��#%$ò��#

23.�$�J K%2EÞ�� ` ��) ± �*! ö 9f��#3$����%�R<�)�9"KI)��E<�G# Þ Û Û K Þ Þ 9;D ���,K�<.�#%S

�BU�a�`baKc�[�gYnbnbdei\f�aK�^`�Vàß!den�`qp/]�aK�°gYnÌö�Ï4U ò5v Û Y/Þ�Ð ` XY[Z , Óâá ö¢ÏfU ò5v Û Y�Þ Ð t/s�_�`�s�a=T@gh_�n�aJ`bU�aJÿ/_�ghf/`�dÙ�DaKc X denBg�s�def���aKc@t/`�U�den`qp/]�a:denJ`bU�a:n�gh[+a¢ghn�ö�Ï4U ò5v Û Y/Þ�Ð ` X�gZ , Óâá ö¢ÏfU ò5v Û Y�Þ Ð tDX�V\c�n�V[+aJX�cba=nbU�f�gY[^a ó��\ � ���BU�a:`q��V^`qp/]DaKn@t7U�Vh��aKm\aKc@t®aKmaKf`bU�V_�i\U�nb_�]�]DVn�aK��Wep�aKÿ/_�gYW�t#sDaKU�g3ma:��dÙä�aKc�aKf/`bWep�_�f���a=c¢f�gY[^a��q]DVWep/[:Vcb]�U�deT�def�n�`�gYfQ`�d�gh`bdeV\f'� � fH`�U�a���c�nb`�T@ghn�at7`bU�a`ba=cb[ãß Û Û �YÞ Þ c�aKTKaKdem\aKnl`�U�aJ`qpQ]Da�ö�Ï4U ò5v Û �YÞ�Ð ` XYØZ , Óâá ö�Ï4U ò5v Û �hÞ�Ð t/�BU�deWoa�def^`bU�a�n�aKTKV\f��°T@gYnbat�do`�den�`qp/]DaK�£gYnÌö�Ï4U ò5v Û �YÞ Ð `X�gZ , Ó�á ö�ÏfU ò5v Û �YÞ�Ð � ¡ aKnbV\cb`bdef�i�X�V\c¥g�[^V\[^aKf/`J`bV�`bU�a;n�`bdeWeW�_�f���a���f�a=��V]DaKc�gY`bdeVfDghW�nbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKn�VhXJV_�c�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\at7`bU�a�BU�V\Woa+`baKc�[�ß�Û Û �hÞ Þ Ï |�¾ nP�/Ð den�nb_�]�]DVn�aK��`�V£aKmgYWe_�gh`�a^`bV � jBÏ |6¾ n6�/Ð t6ghf��HU�aKf�TKa°Vf�Wop�`bU�a^�Dcbnb`3t�s�_�`�f�V`�`bU�anba=TKVf���`qpQ]�dof�i¥gYs�Vhm\a��BdeWeWDs�a�n�V_�f��'��BU�a^n�de��a��qTKVf���do`�deVf wçÉä ªÅ Ï�ü Ð � � VfH`�U�a^fDgh[^a:ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVfÒgYf��HT=Vf�TKc�aK`bdeV\fHcb_�Woa=n:don%do[+]�V\nbaK��a=��gYTK`bWep

`bVHg3m\Vde��`bU�don:�/def��ÚVhXJ]�cbV\s�WeaK[�gY`bdeT:sDaKU�g3m/deVc@� � `:]�cbaKm\aKf/`bn;`bU�a;]�gYc�gY[^aK`�aKc Y defÚV_�c:]�cbaKm/deV_�n:aK��gh[^]�Woa+`bV�s�adef�nb`�ghf/`bd�gY`baK�°�Bde`�U�`�U�a�f�gh[+alnba=` 0f� 2Qt�n�V^`�U�gh`�`bU�a�fDgh[^a�gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVf°V\f°`bU�a�WeaKmaKW#VhX�`�aKcb[+nB�BdeWoW#s�a%cba���a=TK`baK��s/pg�nbV\_�f�� X �bghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf°V\f�`�U�a�WeaKm\aKW7VhX6`qp/]�aKn3� u T=Vcbc�aKTK`�Wop�`qpQ]DaK��aKÿ/_�demghWeaKf/`BVhX6`�U�a¢ghsDVhmaJTKV/��a���V_�We�;`bU�a=f°s�a`bU�alX-VWeWeVh�Bdof�i��

#�.��,KI!"��#%$ò��#2%.�$�J K%2<Þ�� ` ��å KI) ± ��! ö 9f�G#%$�����GQK��R<E)�9"KI)��E<��# Þ Û Û K Þ Þ 9QD ���,K�<.�#3S

v æ

Page 22: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

u nBgJpa=`�ghf�V\`bU�a=c�]DaKTK_�Wed�ghc�de`qp¢VYX�`�U�al`qp/]�def�i�c�_�Wea�X�Vc�f�gh[+aÌgYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVf't\Vs�nbaKc�mal`�U�gh`�`bUDgh`6de`6��V/aKn�f�V\`6T�U�ghf�i\adef£ghf/p+�Ìg3p+`bU�a�f�gh[+aJ��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKp�t VhX6`bU�a�def/mVWem\aK�^`�aKcb[�Ñ�def;]�gYcb`bdeTK_�WÎgYc@tDde`l��V/aKn�f�V`Jgh`�`baK[+]�`B`bV+cbaK[+VhmaJ`bU�aghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�aK�°f�gY[^a¸X�cbV\[wde`@�7�BU�denBden'��_�n�`bd���aK�;s/p:`bU�a%dof/`�aKf���aK�;def/`baKc�]�cba=`�gh`�deVf°VYX1f�gY[^a�gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`bdeVf�Ï � j Z3Ð ��de`6��c�nb`©3÷@§YøoØ/§µ-©KªJde`bn�sDV/��p Z s�a�X-Vcba:T=cba@gY`bdef�i°`�U�a^TKWeV\nb_�c�a:�Bdo`�U � �:�BU/_�n3t7`bU�a:n�aK`�VYXÌf�gY[^aKnJ`�U�gh`�f�aKaK��`bV�s�a:]�c�Vhm/do��aK��Bde`bU°��a���f�de`bdeV\f�nJdof�Vc���aKcJ`bV;aKmgYWe_�gh`�a^Ï � j Z@Ð denJ`bU�a�n�gY[^a�n�aK`�cba=ÿQ_�doc�aK��X�VcJ`bU�a¢aKmgYWe_�gh`�doV\f°VhX Z do`�nbaKW�X�� � f°V`�U�aKc��Vcb��n@tD`bU�a�`q��V:aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n�U�g3ma%`bU�a�n�gY[^aJ��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKp�nbaK`3��S/de[^deW�ghc6TKV\f�nbde��a=c�gh`�deVf�nJ[^V\`bdemgh`�al`�U�a�`qp/]�def�i^c�_�WeaX�V\cBTKVf�T=cbaK`�doV\f°ghnB��aKWeW����f£g�cbaKW�gY`baK��f�V`�at�`�U�a¢gYs�Vhm\a�aK��gh[+]�WealdenlghWenbV:deWeWe_�nb`�c�gY`bdemaJVhX6n�V[^a���a=�Qdes�deWede`bdeaKn�VhX6V_�clW�ghf�i\_�ghi\a¢Ï TKV[+]�ghc�aK�

`bV^¯�cba=nbU�j°­ Ð �BU�deT�U;c�aKnb_�We`¸X�cbV\[�U�g3m/def�i�f�gh[+al��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKdeaKn%s�a�]Dghcb`�VhX6`qp/]�a=n@tDc�gY`bU�aKc�`bU�gYf���_�nb`�s�a%]�ghc�`lVhX7`bU�a`qp/]�def�i���_���i\[^aKf/`3�¢¬Jgh[+aKWepQtDdef�¯�cba=nbU�j°­�t'`�U�a:X-_�f�TK`�doV\f�±(T j6Ï � jRT Ð [:_�nb`Js�a:`qp/]DaK�Hghn%��aK]DaKf���aKf/`:V\f � Ï�dq� a� �denlf�V\`BX�c�aKnbU�X�V\clde` Ð t�a=maKf�`bU�V\_�iU � denJghWe�Ìg3p/n¸X�cbaKn�U°X-Vclde`�nlsDVQ��p�Ï � j(T Ð � � f�V`bU�aKcJ��V\cb��n3t�gYn�gYWoc�a@gh��p�c�aK[�gYcb�\aK�def�Û r ñ�ÝÝ Þ t/X�c�aKnbU�f�aKnbnJdenBf�V`lg%WeVi\doT3ghW�cba=WÎgY`bdeVf#t�ghf��;`bUDgh`�X�V\cbTKaKnJg�n�V[+aK�BU�gh`�_�f@� _�nb`�dÙ�DaK�°`qp/]�def�i�cb_�WeaJX�V\c�W�gY[:s���gghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf�nlÏ nbaKa�¯#dei_�c�alç Ð �1��s/m/doV\_�nbWep/thgJnbp/nb`�aK[wWede�a�V_�c�n@t\�BU�deT�U:dof�TKVc�]�V\c�gh`�aKn6f�gY[^a���aK]DaKf���a=f�TKdeaKnBdef/`bV�`qp/]DaKn@t�BdeWeW6cbaK[+aK��p�`bU�gY`@t6gYf����BdeWoW�s�a;ghs�Wea:`bV�idem\a^g;[^V\cba�]�cbaKT=don�a;`qpQ]�dof�i°`bV£±(T j�Ï � j�T Ð �°¯�V\c�aK��gh[+]�Wea°Ï�gYn¢ghWecba3gh��pnbU�Vh�Bf Ð ��alT@gYf:aK�/]�cbaKn�nl`�U�gh`6`�U�alc�aKnb_�Wo`�VhX'gh]�]�WepQdef�iJ`�U�den6X�_�f�TK`bdeV\f:�BdoWeW�ghWe�Bg3p/n6s�aB��done��Vdef/`7X�c�V[ � t\def���aK]DaKf���aKf/`bWepVhX7`bU�a%nb`�gY`b_�nB�Bde`�U�c�aKnb]DaKTK`J`�V � VhX7`bU�a�gY]�]�WedeT@gh`�doV\f�gYcbi_�[^aKf/`@�¡ a=`b_�c�f�def�i^`�V^`bU�a¢`qp/]�def�i:c�_�WeaKnJVhX6V_�c�TKVc�a¢W�gYf�i_�gYiat�`bU�a�W�ghn�`lcb_�Woa%��a�TKVf�nbde��aKcJdenB`bU�gY`�X�VcBn�_�s�`qp/]�def�i�� ê _�a�`�V`bU�a�f�gh`�_�cba�VhX6f�gY[^aJ��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKdeaKn��BU�deT�U�T3ghf°sDa¥gYcbs�de`�c�ghc�deWop+��a3gh�a=f�aK�'tD��a�f�aKaK��ghf�aK�/]�WedoT=do`Bn�_�s�`qp/]�def�i+cb_�Wea�`�VTKV/aKc�TKa¢`qp/]DaKnldef/`bV�`qp/]�a=nlVhX7n�gY[^aln�`bc�_�TK`b_�cba�s�_�`BW�ghc�iaKcBf�gY[^aB��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKdeaKn%Vf;mghc�doV\_�n�TKV/��aJWoa=maKWen@�

æ M8N;OlÆ%Å.ç�BU�denBnba=TK`bdeVf�aK�/]�WeVcba=nl`bU�a�`bU�a=Vcba=`bdeT@ghW7]�c�V]DaKcb`�deaKnJVhX1V\_�cl`qp/]DaJnbp/nb`�aK[£t��BU�deT�U;�BdeWeW�s�a%_�nbaK��`bVl��_�n�`bd�X�p+`bU�a�V\]�a=c�g3�`bdeV\f�ghWDnbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKn���a�gYnbTKc�des�a�`�V¢de`3t�ghf��+_�We`bde[�gY`baKWep�]�cbVhm\al`bU�a r cbV\ic�aKnbnJghf��+��p/]Da r cbaKn�aKcbmgY`bdeVf;`bU�aKVc�aK[^nBVYX1V_�cW�ghf�i\_�ghi\a�#¤�a�sDaKi\dof+�Bde`bU;`bU�aJs�gYnbdeT�

��»3Ï�Ï���è�ºt»�~3�fð¹�Y~Gð7�h��ì.¸J�h¾(Å6»/�h~@á-»�}l¾- ÏÐJ¾Dâ'~3»3n�~h}ż¡�¢ ß n'��Æ7��â�È�»´È%¥ ^[« { ^J« w ^t«RtÀ^T§Jég®�³�ê�¬ë§ £ ©i®tª êt¶Kì�®gé#ídî-¬ £ ©�ïð¬o­H®Ï®gµo®gíK®g©3¬oñ!³ ¥ �bÅ« { bÅ« w bØ«Et­b=éh®gñëìò®tóŬ £%ô ®gµ·¶�«§J©iª´ ^Ñ { ^ É3Î�õaZ ��Ì�Û§tÀ^ Þ ¬o­H®g©ð�b\Ñ { b É3Î.öXZ ��ÌÚÛ§t­b Þ#¢°-¢¤÷«»Q�5Ç�»/â7á�â�ÈKÈ%¥ ^J« { ^t« w ^t«RtÀ^�§Jég®!ñJî�êÅñh®W¬¾ñϳWé�®tøHî�§[µ�¬4³�bÅ« { bW« w b[«Rt­b!éh®¯ñ%ì�®tóW¬ £%ô ®gµ·¶�«.§J©Hªd ^PÑ { ^ É3Î�õ�Z �

ÌÚÛ tÀ^ Þ ¬o­i®g©v�bÑ { b É3Î.ö­Z ��ÌÚÛ t­b Þë¢Á�¢¤ù����há���|7ì-»�ÐJ¾�â#~@�h�D�h~3á�¾Dâàú ®W¬�û�ñ[¬%§[©iª ¥ ³Åé�§J©�¶�³ ¥ �¿«��e�¿«â³Wé��e�� ô §Jé £ §�êWµo®>¬·¶�ì £ ©�ï�ñ ¢�ü ­H®g©Ï�Ñ {Iy T-û�ü�Û m Þªy;W û�ü�Û¿m Þ�É3Î

Z ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ�£ íìHµ £ ®gñ¤�Ñ {}y TBûlü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Û§T Ñ W3Þ�Z ��Ì Û t Þë¢Ä-¢�×^�5Ï�»< b¾��ÝùJ���há-��|7ì-»�»�ð7|¹}=~3á�~"ð7~Ká-¾DâýÈ%¥ �Ñ {}y T'� V É3ÎMZ �7üHÛ§t Þ §[©iª ���Ê ¿#¾(Ï Ïf Ð «�¬o­i®g©< yQ� � V Ñ {�É3ÎÛ � Ñ T Þ�Z �hüHÛ§t y;�YÞ

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ û�p;nb`�c�gYdoi\U/`qX�V\cb�Bghcb�;def���_�TK`bdeVf;V\f�`�U�a�nb`bc�_�TK`�_�cba�VhX6`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i:��aKc�domgY`bdeVf#t/_�nbdef�i:n�do[+deWÎgYcbWep%X�Vc�[:_�W�gh`ba=�aK�/T�U�ghf�iat���a@gY�aKf�dof�i^ghf��+TKVf/`bc�ghTK`�deVf;]�cbV\]�a=cb`bdeaKnJVYX1`bU�a�gY_��/deWod�gYcbpl��_���i[^a=fQ`�n@�

{

¬laK�/`:n�`baK]ídon�`bV���a��Df�a;`q��V°f�aK�wV]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�n¢V\fHTKV\f/`baK�/`bn3t {_þ ghf�� {.ÿ t7�BU�deT�U't6`�Vi\aK`bU�a=c¢�Bde`bUí`bU�a;ghWecba3gh��p��a��Df�aK� { Ó tB�BdeWoWBsDa°de[^]DVc�`�gYfQ`%X�V\c:nb`�gY`bdef�i�`�U�a°nb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f�]�cbdef�T=do]�Woa=n:X�V\c:V_�c+WÎgYf�i_Dghia\� { þ�c�aK[^Vhm\aKn:`bU�aVc���def�ghc�p^mgYWo_�almghc�d�ghs�WeaKn�X�c�V[ { t�Wea@g3m/def�i�Vf�Wep:aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f£mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=n�def;de`@� {.ÿ T�U�ghf�iaKn�`bU�a�c�a���aK�/dema%aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVfmghc�d�ghs�WeaKn��Bde`bU;f�Vf�aK[^]�`qp�f�gY[^al��aK]�a=f���aKf�T=doa=n�defQ`�V¢f�Vf�c�a���aK�/demaJVf�aKn@�

Ϫ| Ð#þ \ |Ï {Iy T#� ü Ð#þ \ {_þ

Ï {Iy v �e�� ü¢Û§t Þ�Ð þ \ { þ y v �o�� ü¢Û§t ÞÏ {}y;p �e� ü¢Û§t Þ�Ð�þ \ {_þ­y;p �e� ü�Û§t Þ

Ϫ| Ðgÿ \ |Ï {}y T'� ü Ðgÿ \ {Ôÿôy T#� ü

Ï {Iy v �e�� ü�Û t Þ Ð¯ÿ \ {Ôÿôy v �e�� ü�Û t ÞÏ {}y;p �e� ü¢Û¿Õ Þ Ð¯ÿ \ {Ôÿôy;p �o� ü¢Û¿Õ ÞÏ {}y;p �e� ü�Û t Þ Ð¯ÿ \ {Ôÿôy;p �o�� ü¢Û§t Þ d�Xêt �\7Õ

û�a X�Vc�a¢��aJX�V\cb[:_�W�gh`�a�gYf��;]�cbVhm\a�`bU�a%nb_�s�n�`bde`b_�`bdeVf°]�cbdef�TKde]�WeaKn3t���a�f�a=aK�£g:T=V_�]�Wea�VYX6dof/`�aKcb[+aK��d�gh`�a�n�`baK]�n@���BU�af�aK�/`6WeaK[+[�g�nb`�gh`ba=n6`bU�gY`�g�TKVf/`�aK�/`6�Bde`bU�f�Vf�c�a���aK�/demaBmgYcbd�ghs�Woa=n'den7��a@gY�aKc�`bU�gYf¥g�TKV\cbcba=nb]DVf���def�i%TKVf/`ba=�Q`�dof��BU�deT�U

y Ý

Page 23: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

`bU�aKnba�mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=nÌgYcba�i\dom\aKf^`qp/]�def�iD�1ï¹maKc�p�`�aKcb[�`bUDgh`BT@gYf�sDaJ`qp/]�aK��dof+`bU�a���cbn�`BTKVf/`ba=�Q`�T@ghf°gYWon�V¢sDa�`qp/]DaK�;dof+`bU�anba=TKVf��#���»3Ï�Ï����È%¥ �Ñ { þ ^ yQ{ b É3Î6Z �hüíÛ t Þ «�¬¾­i®g©d�Ñ { Ó^ yQ{ b É3Î6Z �hüHÛ§t Þ#¢¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ û�p�def���_�TK`�deVfÚVf�`�U�a�`qpQ]�dof�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf�VYX Z ��¤�a°]�c�aKnbaKf/`°V\f�WepH`�U�a£T3ghnba��BU�aKf Z \ |�¾ nPZ"Û gYf��ü,\�ö�Ï ü Û Û§t Û Þ Ð �Ï v3Ð û�p+`qpQ]�dof�i¢��a=cbdemgh`�doV\f't��Ñ { þ Ó^ yQ{ Ób É3Î1Z"Û �\ü Û Û t ÛÜÞ �Ï y\Ð û�aKT3gh_�n�a { þ Ó^ \ {.Ó�Ó þ^ t/��a�U�g3m\a��Ñ {ÔÓ�Ó þ^ y;{ Ób É3Î1Z"Û �hü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ �Ï z\Ð û�p+dof���_�TK`�doV\f^U/p/]�V\`bU�a=nbden@t3�Ñ { Ó�Ó^ yQ{ Ób É3ÎPZ¤Û �hü Û Û§t Û Þ �Ï�· Ð ¬lVh��s/p^`qp/]�def�i�cb_�Woa�X�V\c |6¾ n ti�Ñ { Ó^ yQ{ b É3Î�|6¾ n6Z Û �ö�Ï�ü Û Û t Û Þ Ð Û t Þ � {

¤�a¥gYWenbV^c�aKÿ/_�decba^gYf�V`�U�aKc�[+aK`�gËV]DaKc�gY`bdeVfF�°`bU�gY`�VYXÌfDgh[^aJn�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f 0Â� Ñ Z 2 Z¤Û � � `J��d�ä�aKcbnJX-cbV[Í`�U�a:_�n�_�ghWmghc�d�ghs�Wea�nb_�s�n�`bde`b_�`bdeVf�def�`bU�a:X�gYTK`�`bUDgh`�de`�n�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�aKn:`bU�a:fDgh[^a � sQp Z Vf�Wep°V\f�`bU�a:T=_�cbc�aKf/`:TKV/��a^WeaKm\aKW�def Z"Û Ñ`bU�a:VQT=TK_�cbc�aKf�TKa=n^VhX � V\f£U�dei\U�aKc�TKV/��a:WeaKm\aKWen^Ï�dq� a�etD_�f���a=c�s�Vh�/aKn Ð �BdeWeW7f�V`JsDa:`bV\_�T�U�aK�'�+�BU�denJV]DaKc�gY`bdeVfHgYf��£de`�nTKV\cbcba=nb]DVf���def�i:n�_�s�n�`bde`b_�`�deVf;]�cbdef�T=do]�Woa=n��BdeWeW�sDaJ_�nba=��`�VÌ� _�nb`�dÙX-p:`bU�aJV]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�ghWDnbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKn�VhX7`bU�aJ`�aKcb[wT=Vf�n�`bcb_�TK`X�V\c�f�gh[+a'nb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f 0Â� j\ Z 2 Z¤Û � �:�BU�a�V]DaKc�gY`bdeVfJden'T@gY]�`b_�cba�g3m\Vde��def�iI��ghWeWh`bU�a�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn@t3gh`bV\[^n'gYf��J]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKc�nghc�aJcbaKf�gY[^aK�;�BU�a=f���aKnbTKa=f���def�i^def/`bV�`bU�a�nbTKV\]�a%VhX1`�U�a�`�aKcb[�TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`J�BU�deT�U^TKc�a@gh`�aK��`bU�aK[��

�+» a â7á-~@á-¾�â��<ºg×+� Ï�»v»ôð7|6}=~@á-~Gð7~Ká-¾�⤼� £%ô ®¯©�¬4®gé�í;ñ Z §J©iª Z"Û §[©iª<§K©3§[íp® � «�¬o­i®K³Øìò®gé^§�¬ £ ³Å© 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z"Û ³ ¥ ñJî�êÅñJ¬ £ ¬�î�¬ £ ©�ï Z´¥ ³ÅéÏ©3§[íp® �v£ © Z¤Û�£ ñàª-®���©i®tªéh®^óWîWé#ñ £%ô ®gµ·¶ð³ ô ®gé�¬¾­i®1ñJ¬¾éJîâóW¬�îWéh®T³ ¥}Z¤Û §Jñ ¥ ³Åµ²µ ³�Â.ñ ¢

0ÂZ Ñ � 2 h \ h0ÂZ Ñ � 2ÂT \ T0ÂZ Ñ � 2 p \ p0ÂZ Ñ � 2 � \ Z0fZ Ñ � 2W9 \ 9 Ï ���\�9 Ð

0ÂZ Ñ � 2QÏ-±�T#� ükj Z ^ Ð \ ±(T'� ülj 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z ^0fZ Ñ � 2/ϲa n T#� ükj Z ^ Ð \ a n T'� ülj 0ÂZ Ñ � 2 Z ^

0fZ Ñ � 2QÏ Z ^ Z b Ð \ Ï 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z ^ Ð Ï 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z b Ð0ÂZ Ñ � 2QÏ |6¾ nPZ ^ Ð \ |6¾ nPZ ^

0ÂZ Ñ � 2QÏ ì�»/~�|�¾ nop1qsZ ^ á�â�Z b Ð \ ì-»Q~%|6¾ noprqS0fZ Ñ � 2 Z ^ á-â�0fZ Ñ � 2 Z b0fZ Ñ � 2/Ï49�j Z ^ Ð \ 9�j 0ÂZ Ñ � 2 Z ^ � íd§g¶dê�®!®tøHî�§[µ>¬4³9�0ÂZ Ñ � 2QÏ Z ^ � 9 Ð \ Ï 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z ^ Ð�� 9 � íd§g¶dê�®�®tøHî�§Jµ�¬f³9�

0fZ Ñ � 2/Ï â7»/½ 9Y� á�â�Z ^ Ð \ â7»/½ 9h�� á-â�0ÂZ Ñ � 2 Z ^ Ï �K�\�9 Ð0ÂZ Ñ � 2QÏ `CY ���j Z ^ Ð \ `�Y ���j 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z ^0fZ Ñ � 2QÏ Z ^ Û Û¿m Þ ÞÎÐ \ Ï 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z ^ Ð Û Û¿m Þ Þ

0ÂZ Ñ � 2/Ï 0Â� j\ Z ^ 2 Z b Ð \ 0Â� j\ 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z ^ 2 Z b0ÂZ Ñ � 2QÏ 0 9 j\ Z ^ 2 Z b Ð \ 0 9 j\ 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z ^ 2^Ï 0fZ Ñ � 2 Z b Ð Ï �d�\�9 Ð

� f;`bU�aJnbde[+doW�gYc1n�]�decbde`@t/��aJ��a���f�a�`�U�a�n�aK` bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð VhX7f�gh[+aKn�V/TKT=_�cbc�dof�i:dof+`bU�aJ`�aKcb[ Z Vf+`bU�aJTK_�cbcba=fQ`�TKV/��a�WeaKm\aKWq��BU�denli\demaKnB_�nJg��Ìg3p+`bV+TKV[+]�_�`baJ`�U�a�[^def�de[;g3W�nbaK`JVYX¹fDgh[^a=nB�BU�deT�U;[:_�n�`lgh]�]Da@gYc�ghnJg�f�gh[+aJ��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKp°�BU�aKf`qp/]�def�i�`bU�a�`�aKcb[ Z ���� «"¨¥§³ª¡ ¨��f¡�©f¥ �3¡@£�¡@¦f³ª¡�¥§¦À¨��f¡�¦f«"¨¢"¨¥§«"¦%¼

y�v

Page 24: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

�+» a â7á-~@á-¾�â��� £%ô ®¯©K§à¬f®gé#í Z «�¬¾­i®1ñh®W¬ bâ Ù Ï Z@Ð�£ ñ ª-®���©i®tªFéh®tóWîÅé#ñ £%ô ®gµ·¶�ê^¶ð¬o­i®1®tøHî�§�¬ £ ³W©�ñ�ê�®gµo³� ¢�� ®Béh® ¥ ®gé�¬4³ bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð §[ñ�¬o­i®Bñh®W¬¤³ ¥X�c�aKa�f�gY[^aKn�³ ¥ ¬o­i®¬f®gé#í Z�¢

bâ Ù Ï �/Ð \ 0Â� 2 bâ Ù Ï hhÐ \ Õ bâ Ù ÏT Ð \ Õ bâ Ù Ï pDÐ \ Õ

bâ Ù Ï-±�T#� ülj Z3Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð bâ ٠ϲa n T'� ülj Z3Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð bâ Ù Ï Z ^ Z b Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z ^ Ð 5 bâ Ù Ï Z b Ð bâ Ù Ï |�¾ noZ3Ð \ Õ bâ Ù Ï ì-»/~¢|�¾ nPp1qsZ ^ á�â6Z b Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z ^ Ð 5 bâ Ù Ï Z b Ð bâ Ù Ï � j Z3Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð bâ Ù Ï Z��á�/Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð bâ Ù Ï â7»Q½ � � Vóá�â�Z3Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð3/10Â� 2 bâ Ù Ï `�Y ���j Z3Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð bâ Ù Ï Z Û Û§t Þ Þ�Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð bâ Ù Ï 0Â� j\ Z ^ 2 Z b Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z ^ Ð 5�Ï bâ Ù Ï Z b Ð3/10Â� 2 Ð

¬lV\`bdeTKaJ`bUDgh`�`bU�a�X�c�aKaJf�gh[+aKn6VhX6g�fDgh[^algYs�nb`�c�gYTK`bdeVf � j Z ��V�f�V`�aK�/TKWe_���a � �#�BU�aJcba@gYnbV\f�den�TKWeVn�aKWep:cbaKW�gh`�aK�;`bV�`bU�aghWec�a@gh��p%nb`�gY`baK��]�c�V]DaKcb`qp�`bU�gY`7f�gh[+a�ghs�n�`bc�ghTK`�doV\f¥gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`bn�Vf�Wep�g3X-`baKc7`bU�a�sDV/��p�VhX�`bU�aÌgYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVf Z den7aKmghWe_�gY`baK�#��BU/_�n@t#d�X�`bU�a:f�gh[+a � V/TKTK_�c�n�Vf�`bU�a:]�cbaKn�aKf/`¢T=VQ��a:Woa=maKW7def Z t#��a�f�aKaK��`�V;]�cbVhm/de��a:ghf�aK�/`baKf�n�deVf�X�V\c � s�a�X-Vcba ZdenJc�ghf#t�gYf���U�aKf�TKa Z ��aK]�a=f���n�V\f � ��S/de[^deW�ghc�TKV\[^[^a=fQ`Bgh]�]�Wedoa=n�`�V^f�gY[^a�T=Vf�TKc�aK`bdeV\f�gYf��£`�V^f�gY[^a��q]DVWep/[^Vc�]�U�deTdef�nb`�ghf/`bd�gY`bdeVf'��BU�aJX�V\WeWoVh�Bdef�iJ��a ��f�de`bdeVf+denlgh��V\]�`baK�+X�c�V[w¬�V[+dofDghW�­�Vi\deT�ghf�� ¯�cba=nbU�j°­ÚÛ r ñ%ÝÝ Þ �

�+» a â7á-~@á-¾�â��<ºg×+� Ï�»�Ä6�h��â6}¤Å6¾�}Ká-~@á-¾Dâ>¼ü ­i®1³[ì�®gét§�¬ £ ³W©;³ ¥i£ ©3¬4®gégó�­3§J©�ï £ ©�ï;§Jµ²µ�¬¾­i®�³�ótóÅîWé#ég®g©iót®gñ!³ ¥ ©3§[íp®gñ � §J©iª9 £ ©d¬¾­i®!§[é%ï îÅíp®g©3¬H©3§JíK®>ª-®�ìò®¯©iª�®g©ióh¶���ót³W©��¬4®�� ¬��i¬·¶�ì�®���®���ìiég®gñ#ñ £ ³W©3« £ ñ�ó[§Jµ²µo®tª+f�gY[^aB`bc�ghf�n�]�V\nbde`bdeV\fF³ÅéBf�gh[+aln��ÌgY]�]�def�i�«3§[©iª £ ñ�ª�®¯©i³�¬f®tªÝê^¶£Ï � 9 Ð Ï �¸Ð^¢¬�gY[^a�`bc�gYf�nb]DVn�de`bdeVf;denl��d�ä�aKcba=fQ`¸X�cbV\[�fDgh[^a�nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf#�6`bU�aJX�Vc�[^aKc�nb�Bgh]�nl`q��V:f�gh[+aKn�`�U�cbV\_�iU�V_�`�`bU�aJidem\aKf`ba=cb[ÍVcB`qp/]DatDf�V:[�gY`b`�aKcB`bU�a%TKV/��a¢WeaKm\aKW'V\f;�BU�deT�U�ghf/p^VYX¹`�U�a�f�gY[^aKnBV/TKT=_�c@tD�BU�deWeaJ`bU�a�W�gY`baKc�Vf�Wep:��Vcb�/n�Vf;`bU�aTK_�c�cbaKf/`�TKV/��a�WeaKma=W����»3Ï�Ï����<ºt»�~3�h»Qâ�ÈD~GÆ7»/â'á âCÈ_¼¡�¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {Iy T#� ü É Î Z ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ §[©iª�T �Ê ª× Ï Z@Ð «�¬¾­i®g©ð�Ñ {�É Î Z ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ°-¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {IyQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞEÉ3Î1Z ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ §[©iª p �Ê ª× Ï Z@Ð «�¬¾­i®g©ð�Ñ {�É3ÎPZ ��ÌÚÛ§t ÞÁ�¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {Iy v �e�� ü�Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Z ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ §J©iª v �Ê ª× Ï Z3Ð «�¬¾­i®g©d�Ñ {FÉ Î Z ��Ì�Û§t ÞÄ-¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {ÔÿÔÉ Î Z �hüHÛ§t y;�YÞ §[©iª �K�Ê bâ Ù Ï Z3Ð ¬o­H®g©d�Ñ {.ÿiÉ Î Z �üHÛ§t ÞÆ�¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {ÔÿÔÉ3ÎPZ �hüHÛ§t yY/Þ ¬o­H®g©d�Ñ {.ÿ�É3Î1Z �hüHÛ§t Þ

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ«� f�a3ghT�U;T@ghn�at�s/p�g�n�`bc�ghdeiU/`qX-Vcb�Bghc��^def���_�TK`bdeVf;V\f^`bU�aJ��cbn�`B`qp/]�def�i¢��aKcbdemgh`�deVf'� {

��»3Ï�Ï�� u� <º^»�ð1|6}=~@á-~"ð7~Ká-¾�âý¸J�há-â6�háÅ1ì »�}ż¡�¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {�É Î Z ^ �YüHÛ§t Þ §J©iªK�Ñ {}y T'� ü É Î Z b ��Ì�Û§t Þ «3¬o­i®¯©F�Ñ {�É Î Û Z ^NÑ T Þ�Z b ��Ì�Û§t Þ#¢°-¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ { þ ^ É3ÎPZ ^l�hüHÛ¿m Þ §[©iªK�Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ3Î1Z b%��Ì:Û§t Þ «3¬o­i®g©v�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z bJ��Ì:Û§t Þ#¢

yy

Page 25: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

Á�¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ { Ó^ É3ÎPZ ^��YüHÛ¿m Þ §J©iªK�Ñ { b y v �e�� ü¢Û¿m ÞRÉ3ÎPZ bJ��Ì:Û§t Þ «�¬o­i®¯©ð�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v ÞÒZ bJ��Ì:Û§t Þ#¢Ä-¢¤£¦¥ yQ� � V Ñ { ^ É3Î1Z ^J� V Û§t Þ §J©iªK y;� � V Ñ { ÿb É3Î1Z b%��Ì:Û �(y t Þ «3¬o­i®¯©F y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{ ÿb É3Î<0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z bJ��ÌËÛ t Þë¢�BU�al]�cbaK[+don�aKn�dof:`�U�aBX-Vcb[:_�WÎgY`bdeVf%VhX�`bU�aJnb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f:]�cbdef�TKde]�WeaKn���aKn�aKcbm\a�X�_�cb`�U�aKcBaKW�gYs�V\c�gh`�deVf'� r cbdef�T=do]�Woa v Ý�� y

cba=ÿQ_�doc�aKnB`bUDgh`�`bU�aJnb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`ba=��`�aKcb[ Z ^Ìden�`qp/]�ghs�WeaBdef�g%TKV\fQ`�aK�/` { þ ^ t/dq� a��`bU�gY`�de`���V/aKnBf�V`�TKV\fQ`�ghdef^ghf/p�X�c�aKaJmghWe_�amghc�d�ghs�WeaKn3�'�BU�aBdef/`b_�do`�deVf�sDaKU�def��:`�U�den6den1`�U�gh` Z ^�nb_�s�n�`bde`b_�`baKnBghf°©gI�Ó��b©=ª�ª ´ Ö¦Jmghc�d�ghs�Wea p �1ï¹�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf+mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn7[�g3pV/TKTK_�c�Vf;[:_�We`bde]�WeaBTKV/��aJWeaKm\aKWen@t�n�V:`bU�a%nb_�s�n�`bde`b_�`bdeVf;�BdeWeW�TKV]/p Z ^B`bV:[:_�We`�do]�WoaBT=VQ��a�WeaKmaKWenB`�VQVD�7û�_�`l`bU�a�V\cb��def�gYcbpmghWe_�a�mghc�d�ghs�WeaKnJghcba^gYf�T�U�Vc�aK��s/p°`bU�a:`qpQ]Da:nbp/n�`baK[ð`�V;Vf�Wep;`bU�a:T=_�cbc�aKf/`¢TKV/��a:WeaKm\aKWqt1gYf���`bU/_�n Z ^�[:_�nb`�TKVf/`�ghdeff�V\f�aJVhX1`�U�aK[��r cbdef�T=do]�Woa v Ý�� z cbaKÿ/_�dec�aKnJ`bU�gY`l`bU�a�nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdef�i+`baKc�[ Z ^ sDa�`qpQ]DaK�°def°g�TKV\fQ`�aK�/` { Ó^ t��BU�deT�U°TKV\fQ`�ghdef�nBf�V+mghWe_�a

mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn3t�ghf���def;�BU�deT�U°ghWeW'`�U�a�f�V\f�cba��DaK�/dom\a�aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f£mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=nlghcba%`b_�c�f�aK�°def/`bV:c�a���aK�/dema�V\f�aKn3�B�BU�a�c�a@ghn�Vf�nX�V\c1`�U�a���c�nb`6c�aKÿ/_�decbaK[+aKf/`1den�gYf�ghWeV\iV_�n'`bVJ`�U�aBVf�a�def¢`�U�aB]�c�aKm/doV\_�n6]�c�def�TKde]�Wea�#�BU�aBnbaKT=Vf��:c�aKÿ/_�decbaK[+aKf/`6den¹gYTK`b_DghWeWepg:��a@gY�aKf�def�i;VYX�`bU�a�TKV\fQ`�aK�/`@t�n�def�TKa:`b_�cbf�def�i;g^f�Vf�c�a���aK�/dema�mghc�dÎgYs�Wea�def/`bV�gËcba��DaK�/dom\a:Vf�a:ghWeWeVh�BnB[^V\cba�`�aKcb[+nl`�VsDa:`qpQ]DaK��Ï s�aKT3gh_�n�a^f�Vh��`bU�a:mgYcbd�ghs�Wea�T3ghf�s�a:_�n�aK��Vf�`bU�a:TK_�cbc�aKf/`¢T=VQ��a:Woa=maKW�gYnJ��aKWeW Ð � � `�den6��_�n�`bd���aK��sDaKT@gh_�nbaZ ^ n�_�s�n�`bde`b_�`�aKn�gí¦�Ö\¦ �b©fe�©gI\´�÷@©�©hI Óô��©Kª�ªK´�Ö¦Ú÷3§��K´ §��=øo© v ���BU�a;mghcbd�gYs�Wea v Vf�Wep�V/TKTK_�c�n^i_Dghcb��aK�Hs/pHg�s�Vh��t7dq� a�'V\fTKV/��aJWeaKma=WonBn�`bc�doT=`bWep^U�dei\U�aKcB`bUDghf;`bU�aJTK_�cbcba=fQ`�Vf�a\�7�BUQ_�nlghf/p:`qp/]�def�i¢VYX Z ^ldef^`�U�aJ`baKc�[ Û Z ^ Ñ v ÞÒZ b��BdeWoWDU�gY]�]�a=f�def;gTKV\fQ`�aK�/`�def+�BU�deT�U:`�U�aJf�Vf�cba���a=�Qdem\alaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f;mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn6cba=Woa=mghf/`6X-Vc Z ^BU�g3malgYWoc�a@gh��p:s�aKa=f^`b_�cbf�aK�;def/`bV�c�a���aK�/demaVf�aKnBs/p^`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i¢c�_�Wea�X�Vc |6¾ n Ï�n�aKa¢¯#dei_�c�a v3yÐ �¯#dofDghWeWepQt r c�def�TKde]�Wea v Ý�� ·:c�aKÿ/_�decbaKnJ`bUDgh`B`bU�a¢TKV\f/`baK�/`ldef;sDV`bU�`bU�a�n�aKTKV\f��£]�cbaK[+don�a¢ghf���def;`bU�a¢TKV\f�TKWe_�n�doV\f;s�a�VhX

nb]DaKTKd�gYW'X-Vcb[ {.ÿb t�dq� a�/`�U�gh`�do`�nBcba��DaK�/dom\a�mghc�d�ghs�WeaKnBV\f�Wep^U�g3m\a�a=[^]�`qp:f�gY[^a���aK]DaKf���aKf�TKpQ��¬lV\`ba�`�U�gh`B`�U�a�]�c�def�TKde]�Wea��aKn�TKcbdesDaKn:g;�Ìg3p;`�V�c�aK��_�T=a^`bU�a:f�gh[+a¢��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKp�VYX¸g+`�aKcb[ Z b�sQp�nb_�s�n�`bde`b_�`bdef�i£g3�Bg3p;`bU�a:f�gY[^a � ��û�_�`@t#`bU�a�Bg3p¢`�U�aBV]DaKc�gY`bdeVf:VYX'f�gh[+a�n�_�s�n�`bde`b_�`�deVf:den���a���f�aK�#t/do`�[�g3pJf�V`�f�aKTKaKn�n�gYcbdeWep:T�UDghf�i\al`bU�alaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f Z bBde`bn�aKW�X��7¯�V\caK��gh[+]�Weat�T=Vf�n�do��aKc�`bU�a¢T@gYnba:�BU�a=f Z bl\ p def£`�U�a¢T=Vf/`baK�/` { \ p �e� ü¢Û �YÞ �l�BU�a¢n�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f 0f� Ñ Z ^J2 p ]�c�V/��_�TKaKn�g`ba=cb[ p de`bnba=WÙX�t�s�_�`�`�U�aKc�a^denJf�V°`qp/]�def�ip�Ñ {6É3Îòp �DüHÛ Þ ���BU�gh`%donJ�BU/p°��a:cbaKÿ/_�dec�a:`bU�gY`�`bU�a:def/mV\WemaK�°c�a���aK�/demamghc�d�ghs�WeaKn7U�g3m\aBf�V���aK]DaKf���aKf�TKdeaKn3� � f:c�aK`bc�Vn�]�aKT=`@t�`�U�alf�aKaK�^`�V���denb`�def�i_�den�U¢sDaK`q��aKaKf;aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f^mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn7�Bde`bU^gYf���Bde`bU�V\_�`6��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKdeaKn3tD�BU�deT�U;ghc�don�aKn�X�cbV\[þ`�U�den�]�cbdef�TKde]�Weat\�ÌgYn�`�U�al[;ghdef�c�a@ghn�Vf;�BU/p¢��aldef/`bc�VQ��_�TKaK�+f�Vf�c�a���aK�/demamghc�d�ghs�WeaKn�defQ`�V�`bU�a���aKnbdeif+VhX7`bU�aJ`qp/]�aJn�pQn�`baK[Ígh`BghWeWqt\dof�nb`ba3gh�^VYX1n�`�g3p/def�i¢�Bde`�U^Vf�Wop�`bU�a�c�a���aK�/demaJmgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�VhX1±D²B�u f�V\`bU�a=c�V\s�nbaKc�mgh`�doV\f¢VYX�T=cb_�TKd�gYW�de[^]DVcb`�ghf�T=a�den7`bU�gY`6`bU�aBWoV/T@gYW�mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn7VhX'g�s�Vh�/aK�:a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�X�V\cb[óglT=Vf/`baK�/`

{ t\�BU�deT�U^den�aK��ghTK`�Wop:VYX'`bU�a�X�V\cb[ó`bU�alf�gY[^aBnb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f^]�c�dof�TKde]�Wea v Ý�� ·�c�aKÿ/_�decbaKn3t�dq� a� { \ {.ÿ �#�BU�den�T@ghf+a@ghn�doWep�s�anba=aKf't�gYn�ghWeW�`�U�aJcba��DaK�/dom\almgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn��BU�deT�U:�BdeWeW�sDal]�_�`�def/`bV�`�U�alT=Vf/`baK�/`�U�g3ma�aK[^]�`qp�f�gh[+a���aK]�a=f���aKf�T=doa=n¢Ï�n�aKaJ`bU�a`qp/]�def�i:cb_�Woa=nBX�V\c ì�»/~J|6¾ n def ¯#dei_�cba v3y ���BU�denB��V\_�We�°ghWeWeVh��_�nl`�V^_�n�a�`bU�a�[^aK`�g�V]DaKc�gY`bdeVf;VYX¹fDgh[^aJn�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z b�`�V^��a ��f�a�`bU�a:V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghW#nbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKn�VhX�`�U�a�WÎgYf�i_Dghia%TKVf�n�`bc�_�TK`JX�V\clf�gY[^aJnb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f 0fZ ^ j\ � 2 Z bh��BU�aBde��a@g�don7`�V�_�nba�`bU�den7TKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`B`�VJ]�aKc X�Vc�[ónb_�s�n�`bde`b_�`bdeVf�n��Bde`bU�def�s�Vh�\�bghf�f�V`�gY`baK��aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f't�ghf��:`bU�aB]�c�def�TKde]�Weav Ý�� ·^aKf�n�_�cba=n:`bU�gY`�`�U�aKn�a^nb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f�n�T@gYf�s�a:T@gYcbc�doa=��V_�`��Bde`�U�V_�`J`�U�a:]�V\nb`�]�V\f�aK[^a=fQ`%VhXBaKmghWe_�gY`bdeVf°�BU�doT�U�den`bU�a�_�nb_�gYW'V]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�ghW�n�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKnlghn�nbV/TKd�gh`�aK�;�Bdo`�U;s�Vh�/aK�;aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�nldef°±D²B�

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀèu WoW�`�U�aJnb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf;]�c�def�TKde]�WeaKnlghc�aJ]�cbVhm\aK�;sQp:def���_�TK`bdeV\f^Vf+`bU�a%`qpQ]�dof�i���aKc�domgY`bdeVfËX�Vc Z b �7¤�a�]�cbaKn�aKf/`sDaKWeVh�èn�V[^a�VhX7`bU�aJ[^V\cba�dof/`�aKcbaKn�`bdef�i+T@ghn�aKn@���BU�aJTKV[+]�WeaK`baJ]�c�VQVYX1T@gYf;s�aJX-V_�f��+def�`�U�a u ]�]DaKf���do���! �K´ ¦�³@´ Ó�øo©#"%$�d�XÔ�Ñ { þ ^ É Î Z ^ �hüHÛ¿m Þ gYf��d�Ñ { b yQp �e� ü�Û m Þ�É Î Z b ��Ì:Û§t Þ t\`bU�a=fð�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î Û Z ^QÑ p/Þ�Z b ��Ì:Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\ |6¾ n6Z t/�BU�a=cbalÌ8\!ö�Ï�Ì Û Û§t Û Þ�Ð �

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { Ób y;p �e� ü�Û m Þ�É3ÎPZ ��Ì Û Û§t Û Þ �y ��û�aKT@gh_�nba { þ ^ \ { þ�þ^ t/��a�U�g3m\a��Ñ { þ�þ^ É3Î1Z ^J�hüHÛ¿m Þ �z �B¯�cbV[ Ï v@Ð t'Ï yÐ ghf��;`bU�a�def���_�TK`�deVf^U/p/]DV`bU�aKnbden@tH�Ñ { þ ^ y;{ Ób É Î Û Z ^"Ñ T ÞÒZ ��Ì Û Û§t Û Þ �·���û�p�­�a=[^[�g x ti�Ñ { Ó^ y;{ Ób É Î Û Z ^QÑ T Þ�Z ��Ì Û Û§t Û Þ tx �Bghf��^�Df�ghWeWepQt\��a�T3ghf;cba@gYnbn�aK[:s�Wea��Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î�|6¾ n ÏbÛ Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z3Ð �\ö¢ÏÌ Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ t

! �K´ ¦�³@´ Ó�øo©#&%$�d�XÔ�Ñ { Ó^ É3Î1Z ^J�hüHÛ¿m Þ ghf��d�Ñ { b y v �e�� ü¢Û¿m ÞRÉ3ÎPZ bJ��Ì:Û§t Þ t/`bU�aKfð�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z bJ��ÌËÛ t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\ |6¾ n6Z"Û t/�BU�aKc�alÌ8\!ö¢ÏÌ Û Û§t Û Þ�Ð �

yz

Page 26: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { Ób y v �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ3Î6Z Û ��Ì Û Û t Û Þ �y ��û�aKT@gh_�nba { Ó^ \ { Ó þ^ t�s/p+`bU�a�]�cba=mQdeV\_�nbWep^]�cbVhma=�°nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf�]�cbdef�TKde]�Wea:Ï�­®aK[^[;g v Ý�� yÐ tH�Ñ { Ó^ yQ{ Ób É ÎÛ Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û ��Ì Û Û§t Û Þ �

z ��¬lVh�«ghn�nbaK[:s�Woa�s�ghT��+dof/`�Và�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Îí|6¾ n Ï�Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z Û Ð �ö�ÏÌ Û Û t Û Þ�Ð Û§t Þ �! �K´ ¦�³@´ Ó�øo©('�$6d�X y;� � V Ñ { ^ É3ÎPZ ^�� V Û t Þ ghf��Ï yQ� � V Ñ {Ôÿb É3Î6Z bJ��ÌËÛ �(y t Þ t3`bU�aKf y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î�0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z bJ��Ì:Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\ p �û�p°`�U�a:��a��Df�de`bdeVf�VhX {.ÿb t�de`JdonJV\f�Wep°]�V\nbn�dos�Woa�`bUDgh`�`�U�a:mghc�dÎgYs�Wea p Ê ¿#¾�Ï Ï {Ôÿb Ð d�XBde`bnJf�gh[+a¢ghf�f�V`�gh`bdeV\f°denaK[^]�`qp/t/dq�/a�Bd�X p �e� Ì:Û¿Õ Þ Ê {Ôÿb ���BU/_�n3t�s/p;f�gh[+al��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKp���a@gh�\aKf�def�i�tH yQ� � V Ñ {Ôÿb É Î p �3Ì Û§t Þ �7¬lVh��t�s/pUQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden7��a@gh�\aKf�def�i�t\ghf���sDaKT@gY_�nba p \ 0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 p t3��a�i\aK`7`bU�a�cbaKÿ/_�dec�aK�; yQ� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î�0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 p ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ |6¾ n6Z"Û t�ghf��àÌ8\!ö�Ï�Ì Û Û§t Û Þ Ð �� f�`�U�denlT@gYnbatD`�U�a�`qp/]�def�i |6¾ noZ¤Û �3ÌÚÛ �(y t Þ donBV\s�`�gYdef�aK�;s/p^��a@gh�\aKf�def�i:def�U�aKc�aKf/`Jdof;`�U�a�sDVh�^cb_�Woa\�6�BU/_�n@tD��aT@ghf:ghWenbVJ��a=cbdema� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É3Îî|6¾ noZ¤Û �ö�ÏÌ Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ ��Z�Vf�nbde��aKc�dof�i�`bU�gY` 0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 |6¾ nPZ¤Û \ |6¾ nPZ¤Û t\��a@gh�\aKf`bU�aJU/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�denlTKV\fQ`�aK�/`B`bV:i\aK`� yQ� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î�0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 |6¾ nPZ¤Û �ö�ÏÌ Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ � {

��»3Ï�Ï�� uiuýºg¸����h� Ï�»/~@�háq�há ~K¼.¼¡�¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_ÜMZ �/üíÛ t Þ §J©Hªdm £ ñ�§KÂ�®¯µ¦µ)� ¥ ³Wé�íp®tªKª�®hìò®g©Hª�®g©ió�¶Ýñh®Å¬%« £%¢ ® ¢ mã' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð «.§J©Hª £ ñ¥ éh®gñ�­ ¥ ³Wé��v« £%¢ ® ¢3w�É mÃ�Q�v«.¬o­i®¯©�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z ��Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ

°-¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {�É Î Z �hüíÛ t Þ «H§J©Hª �(y 9h� V §Jég®�©ò§Jíp®¯ñ# ©i³�¬.©i®^ót®gñ#ñ^§Jé £ µ·¶ £ ©p*J«�¬¾­i®g©Ï � 9 Ð �Ñ3Ï � 9 Ъ{�É,+ Y.-0/ Î Ï � 9 Ð@Z ��Ï � 9 Ð üHÛeÏ � 9 Ð t Þ

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ ¯#doc�nb`�f�V`�deTKa^`�U�gh`�`bU�a+`bc�ghf�n�]�V\nbde`bdeVfí]�cbV\]�a=cb`qp�Ï�]�cbV]DaKc�`qp yÐ don%`bcbdem/d�ghW6`�V£]�cbVhma+s/p£def���_�TK`bdeVf�V\f�`bU�a`qp/]�def�i;��aKc�domgY`bdeVf�X�V\c Z �;¬Jgh[+aKWepQt�ghWeW6`�U�a:`qp/]�def�i°c�_�WeaKn@t6gYn���a=WoW�ghn�`�U�a^c�_�WeaKnJX�V\c¢gh_��/deWed�ghcbp���_���i[+aKf/`bn�ghc�a�ghc�aVs/m/deV_�n�Wep¢def�n�aKf�nbde`�dom\al`�V¢n��ÌgY]�]�def�i�`�U�alf�gY[^aKn�`bU�cbV_�iU�V\_�`@t\def�ghWeW�`�U�aJTKVf/`�aK�/`bn@t�`qp/]�aKn3t/`baKc�[^nBghf��+��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKdeaKn@��BU/_�nB`bU�a���_���i\[^aKf/`6de`�nbaKW�X6[:_�nb`�sDa�def�n�aKf�n�do`�demaJ`bV:n��ÌgY]�]�def�i�f�gh[+aKn@��BU�a�]�c�V/VhX�VYX¹`�U�aJ��c�nb`�]�cbV\]�aKc�`qp°denBnbV\[^aK�BU�gY`BWeaKnbn�`bcbdem/d�ghWqt/s�_�`�nb`�doWeW#c�gh`�U�aKc�nb`bc�ghdeiU/` X�Vc��ÌgYcb�°s/p^def���_�TK`bdeV\f�V\f

`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i���aKc�demgh`bdeV\f�VhX Z �í¤�a:]�cbaKn�aKf/`^U�a=cba°V\f�Wep�`bU�a;T@gYnbaKn�X�V\c¢fDgh[^a^gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`bdeVf�gYf��Hf�gY[^a��q]DVWep/[^Vc�]�U�deTdef�nb`�ghf/`bd�gY`bdeVf't/ghf���Wea@g3m\al`�U�a�cba=nb`BX-Vc�`bU�a u ]�]DaKf���de���T@ghn�a Z \ � j Z¤Û t��BU�aKc�a�ü�\ XY[Z \ ü Û ghf�� � � V Êd��u nbn�_�[^a ���ÊFm�`bV%aKf�nb_�cbalT3gh]�`�_�cbaJg3mVde��def�iD�D�BU�den6T@ghf^gYWe�Ìg3p/n'sDa�gYT�U�deaKmaK�:s/p¢gYWe]�U�g3�qcba=f�gh[+dof�i � def/`bVJnbV\[^aV`bU�aKc�X�cba=nbU°f�gY[^a�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {�É Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü Z¤Û �hü Û Û§t Þ ghf�� wzyY �� É ªÅ Ï�ü ÛÎÐ � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛoÐ ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ �z ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g z t wòÉ� ªÅ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü ÛoÐ � � �·�� u n�nbaK[:s�WoaJs�gYT��^def/`bV�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒ{zÉ Î Ï � j�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z¤ÛoÐ ��Ï XY[Z \ Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛeÐbÐ ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ Z¤Û Û Û¿m Û Þ Þ �v ��û�pH`qp/]�def�i°��a=cbdemgh`�doV\f't��Ñ {8É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_ÜÍZ"Û ��Ï ] kW�&�jhü ÛÎÐ Û t Þ �BU�a=cba wzy�Y �� É m Û � & ghf��<m Û '¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾�Ï Ï wzyY �� Ð tQgYf��;ü�\ Û¿m Û Ñ k Þ ü Û �

y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z"Û ��Ï ] kW�&�j�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛeÐ ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �

y ·

Page 27: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

z ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g y � v t wòÉ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ m Û Ð ��&ó�·���¬la=�Q`3t�V\sQm/deV_�nbWepQtDÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ m ÛoÐ ' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð �x ���BU/_�nBTKV\f�TKWe_���atH�Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�{ËÉ3Î Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z¤ÛoÐ Û ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ m Û Þ Þ ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ � {

1 243ðO¸Å}�JÄ1ÊKÆËÃ��6587O#9 ��Ã�Ä7ÊKÉ;:

� f�`�U�den'nba=TK`bdeVf%��a6��a���f�a�`bU�a�nb`bc�_�TK`�_�cbaK�:V\]�a=c�gh`�deVf�gYWnba=[�ghf/`�doT=nDX�Vc#V_�c�TKV\cba�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\at@gYf���]�c�Vhma6`�U�a�gh]�]�cbV\]�cbd�gh`�ar c�Vic�aKnbn�gYf��;��p/]Da r cba=nbaKc�mgh`bdeV\f£`�U�aKVc�aK[£��¤�aJnb`�ghc�`ls/p^def/`bc�VQ��_�TKdef�i:`bU�a¢f�V\`bdeVf+VhXl³�Ö¦�µ�b§\³@µ-´�Ö\¦�tD�BU�deT�U;�BdeWeW�s�adef�nb`�cb_�[+aKf/`�gYW1def°��a���f�def�i°`�U�a;÷@§YøoØ/©KªJVhX�V_�cJW�ghf�i\_�ghi\a���BU�a¢de��a@g+denJ`bU�gY`J��a:��V;f�V\`JTKVf�n�de��aKc@t#Wede�a�def�±�²Bt®`bU�gY`ghWeW�sDVh�/aK�°aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�n�ghc�a�mghWe_�aKn3� ¡ gh`�U�aKc3t�def;Vcb��aKcl`�V^sDa�mghWe_�aKn3t�sDVh�/aK�°aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�nJU�g3maJ`�V:s�aá�bTKV\f/`bc�gYTK`ba=� ��tdq� a� f�V`:c�aK��_�TKa=��TKV[+]�WeaK`ba=Wop/t7s�_�`:V\f�Wep�X�cba=aK�ÚVhX¥Ï nbV\[^a Ð f�gh[+a^n�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\fH`�U�aKpÚ[�g3p°T=Vf/`�gYdof#�H�BU�a;f�gY[^anb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f�nl`�U�gh`lgYcbaJT@ghc�cbdeaK�°V\_�`�Ï�dq� a�/TKV\f/`bc�gYTK`ba=� Ð _�f���aKcJg�s�Vh�:def°g�idem\aKf^aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�n�gh`�denqX�p:`q��V:]�cbV\]�a=cb`bdeaKn3�Ï v3Ð �BU�aKp+VQT=TK_�cBVf;`�U�aJTK_�cbc�aKf/`lTKV/��aJWeaKm\aKWq�7�BU�den�denBdef�gYTKTKVc��;�Bdo`�U;`bU�aJ]�c�aKm/doV\_�nbWep:[;gh��a�Vs�n�aKcbmgY`bdeVf;ghsDV_�`�`bU�anb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f�]�cbdef�TKde]�Wea v Ý�� ·�`bUDgh`B`bU�a�mgYcbd�ghs�Woa�TKVf/`�aK�/` { VhX7mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn�aKf�TKV\_�f/`baKc�aK�£�BU�aKf°`bc�g3maKc�nbdef�i:`�U�aJTK_�cbc�aKf/`TKV/��a�WeaKmaKW#VhXÌg�sDVh�/aK�°`�aKcb[�t'§¦�Ô°¦�ÖµBÔ\©KªK³�©3¦�Ô´�¦\×°´�¦�µ-Ö!sKØ%�KµeÕ�©���§¦�Ô!sKØ%�KµeÕ�©��U��ÖJI\©=ª t®donlgYWe�Ìg3p/nBVhX�g¥X�Vc�[ { \ {Ôÿ ��BU/_�n@t�`bU�a%n�ghde�;nb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f°]�cbdef�T=do]�WoaJdenlgh]�]�WedoT3ghs�Weat�gYf��;`bU�a�a=f�TKV_�fQ`�aKcba=�£f�gY[^aJnb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f�nBT@ghf�ghTK`�_�ghWeWep:s�aT@gYcbcbdeaK�íV_�`%�Bdo`�U�V_�`�]�V\nb`�]�V\f�def�i���Ï yÐ �BU�a:nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`baK�Úf�gY[^a�nbU�V\_�We��s�a+TKcba3gh`ba=�ÒV\_�`bn�de��a^VYXl`bU�a+s�Vh�/aK��`�aKcb[�tc�gY`bU�a=cl`bUDghf;s�a=dof�i¢WeV/T@ghW�`�V:de`@��BU�a���_���i[+aKf/`7X�VcBT=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�doV\f;don���a��Df�aK�°def°¯#doi\_�cba v ·�� � `BU�ghnB`�U�aJX�V\cb[

Z=<� `?>

ghf��^[^a3ghf�n3�'d�X1`�U�aJf�gh[+aBnb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf�nBdof+`bU�aJaK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf Z VYX1f�gY[^aKn�ÖµeÕ�©���µoÕ�§¦°µeÕ�ÖYªK©�defKÒgYcbaJT@gYcbcbdeaK�;V\_�`@t/��aVs�`�ghdef@>����BU�aá�b]�c�V`�aKTK`ba=� �;nbaK`�ÚT@gYcbc�doa=n�`bU�a%WoV/T@gYWeWop+��a���f�aK�£fDgh[^a=nlVhX Z Ï nbaKa�`bU�a�TKV\fQ`�c�gYTK`bdeVf�cb_�Woa�X�Vc â1»/½:Ð tghf���denBdef/`bc�VQ��_�TKaK�°def+Vcb��aKcl`�V:TKV[+]�Wep¢�Bde`bU;`�U�a�cba=ÿQ_�doc�aK[^a=fQ`�Ï yÐ X�c�V[�gYs�Vhm\a� u f;aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf Z den�(Ab³�Ö\¦�µ���§³3µ�©�Ôd�X Z <� ` Z � � `Bden�³�Ö¦�µ�b§\³@µ-©�ÔJdÙX7de`�den�Õ3�qTKV\fQ`�c�gYTK`baK�#�6¤�al_�nba�`�U�a�WeaK`b`�aKcB>!`bV:c�ghf�i\aJVhmaKc�®�qTKVf/`bc�ghTK`�aK��aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n@���»3Ï�Ï�� u�¹<º^Ð�¾Dâ'~3�h���Y~@á-¾�âPÄ�»/�fÏ�á�â7��~3á-¾�â���â6¿�Ä�¼�Å6»d¸J�h»�}K»/�f×/��~3á�¾D⤼È%¥ ^ y �bYÑ {ÔÿÔÉ3ÎPZ �hüHÛ§t Þ ¬¾­i®g©K¬o­i®gég®>®�� £ ñ[¬oñ�îW© £ øHîâ®�¬f®gé#íC>=«Øñ[îâó�­p¬¾­3§�¬ Z < ö� `D> ¢FE îWé[¬o­i®¯é#íp³Åéh®[«G> £ ñ.�bH�%ót³Å© ¬¾ét§WóW¬4®tª§J©Hªp ^ y �bhÑ {ÔÿÔÉ3Î >è�YüHÛ§t Þ#¢¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ û�p+dof���_�TK`�doV\f^V\f�`�U�a���a=cbdemgh`�doV\fp ^ y �bYÑ {ÔÿÔÉ3ÎPZ �hüHÛ§t Þ ���BU�a�X�_�WeW�]�cbV/VhX6denBdef^`bU�a u ]�]DaKf���do���T@ghn�a Z \ ì-»/~¢|6¾5noprqsZ"Û�á�â�Z¤Û§Û �

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y �bÑ {.ÿlÉzZ¤Û �ö�Ï�ü Û Û§t Û Þ�Ð Û§t Þ tQgYf��'ty ��aKde`bU�aKc� ^ y �bhÑ {.ÿ�yQp �e� ü ÛRÉ�Z¤Û �Qö�Ï ü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ t\Vc� ^ y �bÑ {.ÿ�yQp �e�� ü Û Û§t Û ÞCÉ�Z¤Û �Qö�Ï ü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ t\��aK]DaKf���def�i�BU�aK`�U�aKcct Û \�Õ�Vc­t Û��\�Õ��

z � u Wen�V:f�V`�doT=a�`�U�gh`�Ï {.ÿ�yQp �e� ü ÛÎÐ \�Ï {IyQp �e� ü Û�Ðgÿ t�gYf��;dÙX}t Û��\�Õ�t/`�U�aKf�Ï {ÔÿRyQp �e�� ü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð \ Ï {}y;p �e�� ü Û Û§t Û Þ�Ðgÿ �·����BU�aKf#t/sQp:def���_�TK`bdeV\f^U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@t/��alU�g3m\aI> Û ghf��J> Û Û n�gY`bdenqX-pQdef�i%`bU�aJ]�c�aKnbTKc�des�aK��]�cbV\]�aKc�`bdeaKn3��Z�V[:s�dof�a`bU�aK[�def/`bVK>�\ ì�»/~�|�¾ noprq > Û�á�â > Û§Û �

T@ghn�a Z \ 0f� j\ Z¤Û 2 Z"Û§Û t/�BU�a=cba � � V Êð ^ y �bh�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y �bÑ {.ÿlÉ3Î1Z"Û � V Û t Þ t/ghf��F ^ y �bhÑ {ÔÿÔÉ3Î1Z"Û§Û �YüHÛ ��y t Þ �y ��û�p£def���_�TK`bdeVf�U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@t#`bU�aKc�a�gYcba:_�f�deÿ/_�aL> Û ghf��M> Û§Û nb_�T�U�`bUDgh` Z¤Û < ö� `N> Û ghf�� Z¤Û§Û < ö� `N> Û§Û t']�Wo_�n`bU�aKp°ghcbaJTKV\f/`bc�gYTK`ba=�£ghf��;]�c�aKnba=cbma�`bU�a�`qp/]DaKn@�

z ��¬lVh��t/��don�`bdef�i\_�denbU;`q��V�T@gYnbaKn3�lÏ v3Э� Ê ¿#¾�Ï Ï4�b Ð tDghf���Ï y\Э�d�Ê ¿#¾�Ï Ï4�b Ð �·�� � f;`bU�a���c�nb`�T@ghn�atD]�deT��L>H\ 0Â� j\8> Û 26> Û§Û � � `�donBT=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�aK�£ghf���UDghnB`bU�a�TKVc�cbaKT=`l`qp/]�def�i��

yx

Page 28: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

T <� `ÍT p <� ` p � <� ` � h <� ` h

Z=<� `D>±(TRj Z <� ` ±�T jG>

Z ^ <� `?>À^ Z b <� `?>­b

Z ^ Z b <� `?>À^O>­bZ=<� `D>

a n TRj Z <� `�a n TRjP>

|6¾5noZ <� ` |6¾ n6ZZ ^ <� `?>À^ Z b <� `?>­b

ì�»/~�|6¾ nPp1qsZ ^ á�â�Z b <� ` ì�»/~�|6¾ nPp1q > ^ á�â > b

Z <� `D>� j Z <� ` � jG>

Z <� `D>Z_��� <� `D> ���

Z < Ú Y[Z \����� `?>â1»/½ � � V á�â�Z <� ` â7»/½ � � Vóá-â >

Z=<� `?>`�Y ��Fj Z <� ` `CY ���jP>

Z=<� `?>Z Û Û§t Þ Þ <� `?> Û Û t Þ Þ

Z ^ <� `?>À^ Z b <� `?>­b � Ê ¿'¾(Ï Ï4 Ð0Â� j\ Z ^[2 Z b <� ` 0f� j\Q>À^J26>­b

Z ^ <� `?>À^ Z b <� `D>­b �F�Ê ¿#¾(Ï Ïf Ð0f� j\ Z ^[2 Z b <� ` 0 >À^ Ñ � 2R>­b

¯#dei_�c�a v ·��6Z�V\fQ`�c�gYTK`bdeVf+cb_�WeaKn¸X�Vc�aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�n@�

x � � f;`bU�aJn�aKTKVf��°T@ghn�atD]�deT��L>�\ 0 > Û Ñ � 2R> Û Û �7û�p+`bU�a�T=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�doV\f;cb_�WeaKn3t Z < ö� `?>��7û�p�­®aK[^[;g v3z � v t/de`�denTKV\fQ`�c�gYTK`baK�#�Bû�p;n�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f;]�cbdef�TKde]�Wea^Ï-­�aK[+[�g v Ý�� · Ð t/de`lgYWon�V:U�ghn�`bU�a%TKVc�cbaKTK`J`qp/]�def�i ^ y b Ñ {ÔÿÔÉ Î0 > Û Ñ � 2P> Û Û �hüHÛ§t Þ � {

��»3Ï�Ï�� u�Ç<º^»�ð1|6}=~@á-~"ð7~Ká-¾�â���â6¿6Ä6�h��â¹}¤Å6¾�}Ká-~3á�¾D⣾- ÏÐJ¾Dâ'~3�h���h~3»�¿ ß n�Å7�h»�}3}Ká-¾�â6}ż¡�¢¤È%¥ >À^!§J©iªS>­b�§Jég®�,� ó^³W©3¬oé^§ØóW¬f®tªH«�¬o­i®¯© 0 >À^ Ñ � 2R>­b £ ñ�,�%ót³W©3¬oé^§ØóW¬f®tª ¢°-¢¤È%¥ > £ ñ�,� ót³Å©3¬oét§WóW¬4®^ªÝ§[©iª �(y 9 �Êd�«�¬o­H®g©HÏ � 9 Ð > £ ñ�,� ót³Å©3¬oét§WóW¬4®^ª ¢

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀv ��û�p:def���_�TK`bdeVf:V\f:`bU�aJ��a=cbdemgh`�doV\fL> b <� `?> b �'ûBghn�aJT@ghn�aKnlghc�aI> b \�T y;pRy;�(y"h%yb|7¾ náZ gYf��^`�U�aKp:TKWea@gYcbWep�n�gh`�denqX�p`bU�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK[+aKf/`bnBVYX¹`�U�a�WeaK[+[�g��®�BU�a�cba=nb`lVYX6`bU�a�def���_�TK`bdeV\f�T3ghnba=n�gYcba�ghWen�V:a@ghn�pQ���BU�a�[^V\nb`�defQ`�aKcba=nb`bdef�i+den�BU�aKfM> b \ 0f� j\T> Û ^ 2U> Ûb � � f�`bU�gY`lT@gYnbatF> Û ^ gYf��V> Ûb ghcba®��T=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�aK�ÒgYf�� � Ê ¿#¾(Ï Ïf Ð ��û�p;dof���_�TK`�doV\fUQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden3t 0 > ^;Ñ � 2R>�Û^ denÌgYWenbV;®��T=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�aK�'t�ghf��;n�V 0 > ^QÑ � 2P> b \ 0Â� j\ 0 > ^QÑ � 2R>�Û^ 2#>�Ûb [:_�nb`6sDa�`bV/VD�

y ��û�p�g+nb`bc�ghdeiU/` X�Vc��ÌgYcb��dof���_�TK`�doV\f�Vf�`bU�a+��aKc�domgY`bdeVf�> <� `W>%� � f�T@ghn�aJ>�\ â1»/½ ó � Vóá-â > Û Ï���a^ghn�nb_�[+asQpíûÌgYcbaKf���cbaKi\`J� ndq�gYcbd�ghs�Woa;Z�Vf/ma=fQ`�deVfÚ`bU�gY` óE�\ �(y 9 Ð t�`�U�aKfX> Û den°Ïf yQó � V�Ð ��T=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�aK�'�«û�pÚdof���_�TK`�doV\fUQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden3t�nbV:den�Ï � 9 Ð > Û t�gYf��;`bU�a%TKVf�T=Wo_�nbdeVfËX�VWeWeVh�Bn@� {

¤�aJT@ghf;f�Vh����a���f�a�V\_�cBnbp/f/`�gYTK`bdeT�T3gh`ba=iVc�p^VYX1mghWe_�a=n@�� �B� \ hl] ±(TRj Zk]f� j ��][`�Y ��Fj Zk]3|6¾ n > ÏY> T=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�aK� Ð

y ç

Page 29: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

Z yQZ ^ � � ` Z Û y;Z Û ^Z y Ï Z ^ Z b Ð��� ` Z Û y Ï Z Û ^ Z b Ð

Z yQZ b � � ` Z Û y;Z Û bZ y Ï � ^ Z b Ð��� ` Z Û y Ï � ^ Z Û b Ð

Z y ÏbÏ-±�T#� ükj Z@ÐI�Ф�� ` Z y Û � Ñ T ÞÒZ Z y a n T#� ükj Z��� ` Z y Û a n T'� ükj Z Ñ T Þ�Z

Z=� `D> Z f�V`BT=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�aK�Z y�|6¾ nPZ1�� ` Z y�|6¾ n >

Z y;Z ^ � � ` Z Û y;Z Û ^Z y Ï ì-»/~�|6¾ nPp1qsZ ^ á-â�Z b Ð��� ` Z Û y Ï ì-»/~¢|�¾ nPp1qsZ Û ^ á�â6Z b Ð

Z y Ï ì-»Q~%|6¾ nop1q |6¾ n > á�â�Z b Ð��� ` Z y Û�> Ñ p�ÞÒZ b Z y Ï â7»Q½ � � Vwá-âoZ3Ð��� ` Ï Z y;�QФyQZZ y;Z��� ` Z Û yQZ Û

Z y Ï � j Z@Ð��� ` Z Û y Ï � j Z Û ÐZ yQZ1�� ` Z Û yQZ Û

Z y Ï Z��á�QÐ��� ` Z Û y Ï Z Û �á�/Ð Z y Ï49�j �ÐH������ ` Z y Ï � 9 Ð@�Z y;Z��� ` Z Û yQZ Û

Z y Ï Z Û Û§t Þ Þ�Ð3�� ` Z Û y Ï Z Û Û Û§t Þ Þ�Ð Z y Ï�Ï `�Y ���j Z Û Ð Û Û§t Þ Þ�Ð_�� ` Z y Û§t Ñ Y�Þ�Z Û

Z yQZ ^ � � ` Z Û yQZ Û ^Z y Ï 0Â� j\ Z ^ 2 Z b Ð.�� ` Z Û y Ï 0Â� j\ Z Û ^ 2 Z b Ð Z y Ï 0f� j\ � 2 Z b Ð.�� ` Z y^0Â� Ñ � 2 Z b

¯#dei_�c�a v@x �6S�`bcb_�TK`b_�c�aK�°V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghW�n�aK[�gYf/`bdeTKnBVhX7`bU�a%TKVc�a�W�gYf�i_�gYia�

��»3Ï�Ï�� u�è�ºg×+� Ï�»�Ä��h��â6}"Å6¾�}=á�~3á�¾DâݸJ�h»�}K»/�f×D»�}=ù���ì�ð7»�}W¼È%¥ §[©à®���ìiég®gñ#ñ £ ³W© �1£ ñ�ñë¶�© ¬ë§ØóW¬ £ ó[§Jµ²µ·¶§ ô §Jµ%îâ®Ø«�§[ñ�ª�®���©i®^ªKêt¶;¬¾­i®1§�ê�³ ô ®_ï�ét§[í;íd§[ét« £ ©;¬¾­i®¤©3§JíK®.ót³W©3¬4®�� ¬_dót³W©3¬ë§ £ © £ ©�ï©3§[íp®gñ �(y 9h� V Êd�«�¬¾­i®g©HÏ � 9 Ð@�T£ ñ!§[µ²ñh³�§ ô §Jµ%îâ® ¢¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ û�p«def���_�TK`bdeV\f«Vf«`bU�aHnb`�cb_�T=`b_�c�aÒVYX � � �BU�a�Vf�Wep!defQ`�aKcba=nb`bdef�i!T@gYnbaHden°�BU�aKf � \ |6¾5n >��ô�BU�aKfÏ � 9 Ъ� \ |6¾5n Ï � 9 Ð >��7û�_�`3t�s/p�­®aK[^[;g v3z � y tDÏ � 9 Ð >!den�TKVf/`�c�ghT=`baK�'t�gYf��;U�aKf�TKa |6¾ n Ï � 9 Ð >!denlg%mghWe_�a� {

u `7WÎgYnb`3t@��aBghcba�dof%]�V\nbde`bdeVf%`bVl��a���f�aBgBn�[�ghWeW��qnb`ba=]�V\]�a=c�gh`�deVf�gYWQn�aK[�gYf/`bdeTKn�Ï nbaKaB¯#dei_�c�a v3xÐ thgYf���]�c�Vhma�`bU�a���p/]Dar c�aKnbaKc�mgh`�doV\f^ghf�� r c�Vic�aKnbn�`bU�aKVc�aK[�X�Vc7`bU�aBTKVc�aB]�ghc�`6VhX�`�U�aBW�ghf�i\_�ghi\a�#¤�a6_�nba Z gYf��¢mgYcbd�ghf/`�n1`�VJ��aKf�V\`balg�nb`�VcbaVhX�f�gY[^aKn7TKc�a@gh`�aK�^��_�cbdef�iJ`bU�aBa=mghWe_�gh`�deVf'� u nb`bV\cbaBVYX�f�gY[^aKn7TKV\cbc�aKnb]DVf���dof�i¢`�V�g�f�gh[+a6TKVf/`�aK�/`>��BdeWoW/sDaB��aKf�V\`baK�s/p Z < �7¬lV\`baJ`bU�gY`B`bU�aJ`�U�aKVc�aK[Ícba=ÿQ_�doc�aKnla=[^]�`qp:mgYcbd�ghs�WeaJghf��+]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKcBTKV\f/`baK�/`bnJghf��;f�gY[^aB��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKp/�

ÄcÆ7»/¾��h»%ÏÃu[�ýºg¸J�h¾(È��h»�}3}J��â6¿6Ä�¼�Å6»ð¸J�h»�}=»Q�f×/��~3á-¾�⤼È%¥ �ÑG| ÉzZ �hüHÛ Þ «�¬o­i®¯©ð® £ ¬o­i®¯é¡�¢­Z!£ ñ!§ ô §[µ î�®[«i³Wé°-¢ ¬o­i®gég®�®�� £ ñJ¬¾ñ� Û Ö<ýñ[îâó�­ý¬o­ò§�¬ Z < yQZ��� ` Z <]\ yQZ¤Û_^H¥ îWé[¬o­i®gé�íp³Åéh® Z¤Û�£ ñ�îW© £ øHîâ®�§[©iªK Û Ñ�| É�Z¤Û �hüHÛ Þ#¢

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ û�p°def���_�TK`bdeVf�Vf�`bU�a���aKc�domgY`bdeVfv�Ñ�| É�Z �DüHÛ Þ �J¤�a�]�cbaKn�aKf/`�`bU�a:[^Vc�a�de[^]DVc�`�ghf/`BT@gYnbaKn%s�aKWeVh���%�BU�acba=nb`lT3ghf;s�a�X�V_�f��^def;`bU�a u ]�]�aKf���de���T@ghn�a Z \ ì-»/~¢|6¾5noprqsZ ^ á-â�Z b\�u nbn�_�[^aJ`�U�gh` Z ^ denJg�mghWe_�a:Ï�V\`bU�aKc��Bdenba�`bcbdem/d�ghW Ð � � f;`bU�gY`lT@gYnba Z ^ \ |6¾ n > ^ t��BU�aKc�aU> ^ donBT=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�aK�'t'gYf��Z < y;Z��� ` Z < y Û >À^ Ñ p/Þ�Z bh�

y

Page 30: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| É >À^l�hü Û Û§t Û Þ t�gYf��'ty ��aKde`bU�aKc��Ñ p �e� ü Û�ÉzZ b �hüHÛ Þ t/Vc��Ñ p �e�� ü Û Û§t ÛÜÞôÉzZ b �hüHÛ Þ t\��aK]DaKf���dof�i^�BU�aK`�U�aKcct Û \�Õ�V\cXt Û��\�Õ��z �BZ�Vf�TKWe_���at�_�nbdef�i�aKde`bU�a=c�­�a=[^[�g v Ý�� y t/V\cÌ­®aK[^[;g v Ý�� z t`�U�gh`��Ñ�| É Û�>À^ Ñ p�Þ�Z b��hüHÛ Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ Z¤ÛØ�á� t��BU�a=cba � � V Êð��u nbn�_�[^aJ`�U�gh` Z¤Û denlg�mghWe_�a¢Ï V`�U�aKcb�Bden�at�`�cbdem/dÎgYW Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| ÉzZ"Û ��Ï XY[Z \ ü Ð Û Þ t�ghf���| É ªÅ Ï�ü Ð � � Ï�sDaKT@gY_�nba ªÅ Ï ü Ð \�Õ Ð �y ���BU�aKf Z¤Û \�9�j �mÛ t/�BU�aKcbaÏ9Y� V Êd�tDghf��d�Ñ�| Éz�fÛ ��Ï � 9 Ð üHÛ Þ �z ��û�p^cba=��_�TK`�doV\f°cb_�Woa=n@t Z < y;Z��� ` Z < y Ï � 9 Ъ�mÛ �·���û�p�­�a=[^[�g v\v � y t�Ï � 9 Ð �Ñ�| É Ï � 9 Ъ� Û'��Ï � 9 Ð Ï � 9 Ð üHÛ Þ �x ��¬lVh��t/sDV`�U ��y 9�Ê ¿#¾(Ï Ïf Ð tDnbV°Ï � 9 Ð á\���ç���û�p^de��aK[+]�V\`baKf�T=p^VhX7nb�Bgh]�]�dof�i�t��ÑG| É Ï � 9 Ð@�fÛ �hüHÛ Þ t�ghf���`�U�aJ`qp/]�def�i¢denB]�c�aKnba=cbma=�'�

T@ghn�a Z \ Z¤Û Û Û¿m Þ Þ �u nbn�_�[^a Z¤Û denlg�mghWe_�a¢Ï V`�U�aKcb�Bden�a�`bc�dom/d�ghW Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| ÉzZ"Û � ]3Y ���j3ü Û t/�BU�a=cba É mÃ�Q��t�gYf��^ü�\ Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Û �y �BS/def�TKa Z¤Û denlg�mghWe_�a\tde`BdenBVhX7`bU�a�X�V\cb[ Z"Û \ `�Y �&�j Z¤Û§Û t��BU�aKcbaÏ& '��ôgYf��;`bU/_�n É m��Q&ó�z ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i�cb_�WeaKn3ti�ÑG| É ÛWÙ,` Z¤Û§Û �hü Û Û Þ �·���û�p�­�a=[^[�g v\v � v t��Ñ�| É Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z¤Û Û ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü ÛoÐ Û Þ tx �BS/def�TKa Z < y;Z��� ` Z < y Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�Z"Û Û t/��aJU�g3m\a¹� _�nb`Bn�U�Vh�Bf;`bU�gY`B`bU�aJ`qp/]�def�i�donB]�cbaKn�aKcbm\aK�'�

T@ghn�a Z \ 0f� j\ Z ^[2 Z b\t/�BU�aKc�a � � V Êd��u nbn�_�[^aJsDV`�U Z ^ denlg�mghWe_�a¢Ï V`�U�aKcb�Bden�a�`bc�dom/d�ghW Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| ÉzZ ^ � V Û Þ t�gYf��d�ÑG| ÉzZ b �hüíÛ �YÞ �y ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g v Ý�� ·�t��Ñ�| É�0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z b��\üHÛ Þ �z ��û�p^cba=��_�TK`�doV\f°cb_�Woa=n@t Z < y;Z��� ` Z < yt0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z bht�n�V:`bU�aJn�`�gh`�aK[^a=fQ`BdenB]�c�VhmaK�#� {

a Â#Ã�Ä.OJÃL:7ÊKÆËÃù�b57PóÆ^ÇKOdcôÃ��65¯çL:1Ê�:�BU�denJnbaKT=`bdeVfí]�cbaKn�aKf/`bn�`bU�a:��a���f�de`bdeV\f�gYf��£`�U�aKV\cbp�VhXB]�gh`�`baKc�f/��[;gh`�T�U�dof�i^Vf�T=VQ��a:aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n@t7�BU�deT�U£den�_�nbaK��`�Vdef�nb]DaKTK`�`bU�alnb`�cb_�T=`b_�c�a�VYX®gYf:Vs��a=TK`�]�cbVi\c�gY[ gYf�����aKnb`�cb_�T=`Bdo`�dof/`�V�de`�n6TKV[+]�V\f�aKf/`6]�gYcb`�n@�6¯�Vc7`bU�a�]�_�c�]�V\nbaKn�VhX'`�U�den��Vcb��th��aBWede[^de`�V_�c�nbaKWem\aKn6`bV%dof/`�aKf�nbdeV\f�ghW�gYf�ghWep/nbden#VhX�Vf�Wep�`�U�aBnbde[^]�WopJ`qp/]DaK�^±/�qT@gYWoT=_�We_�n7X�c�ghi[+aKf/`'VYX�V\_�c7WÎgYf�i_Dghia\��BU/_�n@t/gh��[^de`b`�aK��WepQt3V\_�c6TK_�c�cbaKf/`�cbaKn�_�We`bnBghc�a�X�ghc7X-cbV[�TKV[+]�WeaK`ba\ths�_�`6f�aKmaKc�`bU�a=Woa=nbn@tD��aB]�cba=nbaKf/`�`bU�aK[óU�a=cba�ghn�g¸��c�nb`nb`�aK]°`�Vh�ÌgYcb��nlg%nb`�cbVf�iaKcJghf��;[^V\cba�cbVs�_�nb`Bn�pQn�`baK[��

VU� v�v Z�d ò [fe �B��\ Û¿��T�^R|�|�| T Ó Þê] T ]f�Ë]3h_] ±�T#� V j e�] Ï e ^ Ð Ï e b\� V�Э] a n T#� V j e�]Pe � V Û§t Þ�BU�aB]�gY`b`�aKcbf�Û ��TE^C|�|G|�T Ó Þ ��aKT=WÎgYcbaKnBg�]�gh`�`baKc�f^mgYcbd�ghs�Wea����BU�doT�U:[;gh`bT�U�a=n¹g�TKV/��alaK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf^n�_�s��aKT=`�`�V�TKVf���de`bdeVf`bUDgh`l`�U�a�aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf_� n�X�c�aKa�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKnlghc�a¥gY[^Vf�iÔTE^ y jGj�j y T Ó �¸¤�a��BdeWoW#��aKf�V\`ba�]�gh`�`baKc�f£mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=nB�Bdo`�U°T@gY]�de`�ghW.�ghf��£de`bnJmgYcbd�ghf/`bn3� r gY`b`�aKcbf�n�±�T#� V j e ghf��da n T#� V j e t®[�gh`�T�U°cbaKn�]�a=TK`bdema=WopHg+W�gh[:sD��g�aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVfHghf��Hg����/]DVdef/`aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\fÚVhXB��V[;ghdef°`qp/]�a V �;�BU�aKp���aKT=WÎgYcba°g;mgYcbd�ghs�WeaiT��BU�deT�U�den�WeV/T@ghW�`bV°`�U�a^]Dgh`b`�aKcbf#t6ghf��í��aK[�gYf���`bU�gY``bU�a^sDVQ��p£VYXÌ`�U�a^[;gh`bT�U�a=�£aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVfHT=Vf/X�V\cb[+n�`�V°`bU�a:]�gh`�`baKc�f e �+û�V\_�f��HmgYcbd�ghs�Woa=n@t�Wede�aiTHgYs�Vhm\at1gYcba+`bV;s�a��denb`�def�i_�den�U�aK��X�cbV\[ ]�gY`b`ba=cbf�mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn3t�Wedo�\a^Û¿�:TE^R|�|G|ªT Ó Þ �¢�BU�a¢W�gh`�aKc�]�c�Vhm/do��aKn�g^]�WÎgYTKaKU�V\We��aKcJX�V\cJ`bU�a:[;gh`bT�U�def�i]�c�VQT=aKnbn3Ñ�_�]DVf:aK�/aKT=_�`bdeVf+VhX'gJnb_�TKTKaKn�nqX�_�W�[;gh`�T�U�dof�i�t3de`6�BdeWoW/sDalsDV_�f��:`bV¢gJT=aKcb`�ghdef:aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f'�6�BU�a�X-Vcb[+aKc7den���_�n�`

y é

Page 31: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

T-,�� V ,�Ê { t*' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð�Ñ {@g�Î Û¿��T�^Rj�j�j T Ó Þ � V Û§t Þ \ih��:� XY õ Z \ õ jGj�j XYkjâZ \[j ö�Ï V Û§t y;� ^ y j�jGj y;� Ó Þ�Ð

�Ñ {@g�Île � V Û¿m Þ \ih { ^ mÉ'ot�Ñ {@g Î Ï e � V Û¿m Þ�Ð � V Û§t Þ \ih { ^

t*' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿'¾(Ï Ï w:Ð�Ñ {Iy T#� VQg Î T;� V Û§t Þ \ih |

t*' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð yQ� � V Ñ {Lg Î � � V Û ��y t Þ \ihø|

t�' ¿'¾(Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð�Ñ {@g Î h � v Û§t Þ \ihø|

�Ñ {Iy T#� V ^ g�Î�e � V b7Û§t Þ \ih { ^�Ñ {@g�Î ±�T#� V ^fj e � V ^ê` V b�Û§t Þ \ih { ^

�Ñ {Iy T#� VQg�Î�e � V Û§t Þ \ih { ^�Ñ {Sg�Î a n T#� V j e � V Û§t Þ \ih { ^

�Ñ {@g Î e ^ � V b ` V Û§t Þ \ih { ^ �Ñ {@g Î e b � V b Û§t Þ \ih { b�Ñ {Sg�Î Ï e ^ Ð Ï e bJ� V b Ð � V Û§t Þ \ih { ^ y;{ b

¯#dei_�c�a v ç��#��p/]�def�i�cb_�Woa=nBX�V\c�]�gY`b`�aKcbf�n3�

g+nbp/f/`�gYTK`bdeT:TKV\f�nb`�ghf/`@t#�BU�deT�U�donJdef/`bc�VQ��_�TKaK��s/p£g+]�gY`b`ba=cbf�X-VcJW�gh[:sD��g�aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�n@t6gYf��£T3ghf�[�gY`bT�U°V\f�Wep°de`bnba=WÙX��r gh`�`baKc�f � [�gh`�T�U�aKn�g�fDgh[^a � X�c�V[�`bU�a�i\WeVs�gYW�f�gh[+a�T=Vf/`baK�/`3� r gh`b`�aKcbfÚÏ e ^ Ð Ï e b � V�Ð [;gh`bT�U�a=nlghf£gY]�]�WedeT@gh`�doV\f'Ñ/defVc���aKc�`bV�g3m\Vde�^]DVWep/[^V\cb]�U�doT�`qp/]�aKn�def°]�gh`�`baKc�f�n@tD��a�cba=ÿQ_�doc�a�`bUDgh`l`�U�a�`�U�denl]�gY`b`ba=cbf�]�cbV\nbTKc�dosDaKnJ`bU�a�aK��ghTK`�`qp/]�a�VhX`bU�a�gYcbi\_�[^aKf/`7def^`�U�a�gh]�]�WedeT@gY`bdeVf'�®�BU�al]�gY`b`�aKcbf e � V Û§t Þ n�aKcbm\aKnB`bV�nb]DaKTKd���T@gYWeWop:Wede[^de`7`bU�a�ghWeWeVh��aK�:��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKdeaKnJVhX`bU�a�[;gh`�T�U�aK�;aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�`bV�Vf�WepËtË��BU�a���_���i[+aKf/`7X�VcB`qp/]DaKT�U�aKT��/def�i:]�gh`�`baKc�f�nlUDghnB`bU�aJX�Vc�[

�Ñ {Jg�Île � V Û§t Þ \ih { ^

ghf��:cba@gY��n@�7def�`bU�a�TKVf/`ba=�Q`�VhX'iWeV\s�ghW/f�gY[^aKn��ti\WeVs�gYW�]�ghc�gh[+aK`baKc�n w tgYf��^g�TKVf/`ba=�Q`�VhX�WeV/T@ghWeWep���aKT=WÎgYcbaK�+mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn{ tY`bU�a�]�gh`�`baKc�f e UDghn7`bU�a�`qp/]�a V tYf�gh[+a6��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKpËt!ghf��¢]�c�V/��_�TKaKnBg�cbaKn�de��_�ghWDTKV\fQ`�aK�/` { ^6VYX�]Dgh`b`�aKcbf+mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKnghf��H`bU�aKdec:`qpQ]�dof�in@�í�BU�den�cbaKn�do��_�ghW�TKVf/`ba=�Q`:den�`bV�sDa;]�ghn�nbaK��`�V£n�_�s�n�aKÿ/_�aKf/`^TKV\[^]�_�`�gh`�deVf�n3���BU�a;cb_�WeaKn:VYX�`�U�den��_���i[^a=fQ`�ghcbaJ]�c�aKnba=fQ`�aK��dof;¯#doi\_�cba v ç��7¬lV\`baJ`bUDgh`@t/sDaKT@gY_�nba���a�ghc�a�Wede[^de`baK��`bV:V\f�Wep¢n�de[^]�Wep\��`qp/]DaK�:X-c�ghi\[^aKf/`3th`bU�aWeV/T@ghW�mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�`bUDgh`B`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i�cb_�Woa=nl��aK]DVn�de`Bdof { �BdeWoW�ghWe�Bg3p/n�sDa�Vc���def�ghc�p:mghWe_�a�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn@t�gYf���gYWo�Bg3p/n�n�de[^]�Wep`qp/]�a=�'����f°`�U�a�V`bU�aKcJU�ghf��#t���a���V;ghWeWeVh�èg:s�do`�[^V\cbaJiaKf�aKc�gYWode`qp+dof�`bU�a�T@ghn�a¢VYX6]�gh`�`baKc�f£mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�Û¿�MTE^R|�|G|ªT Ó Þ Ñ`bU�aKp:nb`�doWeWDT@ghf+[�gY`bT�U:Vf�Wep�`baKc�[^n�VhX'n�do[+]�Wea�`qp/]DaKn@t�s�_�`�`bU�a=nbaJ`baKc�[^n�T@ghf+U�g3ma�nb_�s�`baKc�[^n�VhX'[^V\cbaBi\aKf�aKc�ghW�`qp/]�def�i��� f;Vcb��aKcB`bV�def�TKVc�]�V\c�gY`baJ]�gh`�`baKc�f;[�gh`�T�U�def�iJdof/`�V¢`�U�aJTKVc�a�W�gYf�i_�gYiat\��a�a=f�W�ghcbi\al`�U�aJnbp/f/`�gh�+�Bde`bU�g%f�aK�!`ba=cb[

TKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`�Vc3�VXZGdfeg[ Z �B� \ j�jGj ]h�Y��}K»áZ Ù ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z ^ »/ì�}=»�Z b

�BU�a�dof/`�aKf���aK�+V]DaKc�gY`bdeVfDghWDdof/`�aKcb]�c�aK`�gY`bdeVf+VhX �Y��}K» den�`bV�a=mghWe_�gh`�al`�U�a�gYcbi_�[^aKf/` Z Ù `�V¢V\s�`�gYdof^g�s�Vh�/aK�+aK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVf|6¾ n >%th`bU�aKf:[�gY`bT�Um>í`bVJ`bU�aB]�gh`�`baKc�f e � � X�`�U�aB[�gY`bT�U�def�iBden7nb_�T=TKaKnbn X�_�Wqt/de`7TKcba@gY`baKnBghf�aKf/m/decbVf�[^aKf/`'�Bde`�U¢s�def���dof�inX�V\cB`bU�a�]Dgh`b`�aKcbf�mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn3t�ghf��;`bU�aKf°aKmgYWo_Dgh`ba=n Z ^ def�`�U�denlaKf/m/decbV\f�[^aKf/`3� � X6`bU�a%[�gh`�T�U�def�i�XqghdeWen@t/`bU�a�s�c�gYf�T�U Z b den`�gY�aKf#�7�BU�aJ`qpQ]�dof�i:cb_�Wea�X�Vc �h�D}K» don3�

�Ñ {�É Î Z Ù �ö�Ï V Û¿m Þ�Ð Û§t Þ �Ñ�| g Î e � V Û¿m Þ \ih { ^ �Ñ {IyQ{ ^ É Î Z ^ ��Ì Û t Þ �Ñ {�É Î Z b ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ�Ñ {�É3ÎÚ�h�D}K»�Z Ù ¾� J|6¾ n�e h Z ^ »/ìq}K»�Z b���ÌÚÛ§t Þ

��s�n�aKcbm\al`�U�gh`7`bU�aBnbaKTKV\f��:]�c�aK[^denba�VhX �h��}=» cba=ÿQ_�doc�aKnBghf�aK[^]�`qpJmgYcbd�ghs�Wea6T=Vf/`baK�/`3thnbV�`�U�gh`7]�gY`b`�aKcbf�n�T@ghf�f�V`7TKVf/`�ghdefV_�`bnbde��aJmgYWo_�alVcBa=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf°mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=n@�

y æ

Page 32: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

�BU�aJ[^aK`�gJV]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�n�VYX1f�gY[^aBn�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f�gYf��^f�gY[^aB`�c�ghf�nb]DVnbde`�doV\f't�ghn���aKWeW'ghn�`bU�a bâ Ù X�_�f�TK`bdeV\f^Vf+`baKc�[^n3tcba3gh��deWep:aK�/`baKf��'�0ÂZ Ñ � 2QÏ �h��}=»�Z Ù ¾� l|6¾5nne h Z ^ »/ìq}K»�Z b Ð \ Ï �h�D}K»Ý0fZ Ñ � 2 Z Ù ¾� l|6¾5nne h 0ÂZ Ñ � 2 Z ^ »/ìq}K»v0fZ Ñ � 2 Z b Ð bâ Ù Ï �h��}=»�Z Ù ¾� l|6¾5nne h Z ^ »/ìq}K»�Z b Ð \ bâ Ù Ï Z Ù Ð 5 bâ Ù Ï Z ^ Ð 5 bâ Ù Ï Z b Ð

ß n��5Ï�Å1ì-»d¹�7V£deWeWe_�nb`�c�gY`ba^def/`ba=f�nbdeVfDghW�TKV/��a£ghfDghWep/nbden@t7`�U�a+X�VWeWeVh�Bdef�i;aK��gh[^]�Woa=n�]�cba=nbaKf/`bn°g�iaKf�aKc�gYWodeå@gY`bdeVfíVhXJV_�c�VWe�Ha=�Q]DVh�f�aKf/`�dÎgY`bdeVf�X�_�f�TK`bdeVf#� � f�nb`�a@gh��VYXÌ]DVh��aKcbdef�i;Vf�Wop�dof/`�aKiaKc�n@t7��a:T@ghf�]DVh��aKc�X�_�f�TK`�deVf�n�`�V/V�t#d�� a�DU�g3m\a^gËX�_�f�TK`�deVf�gYWTKV\[^]�_�`�def�iUo �`�±�T jDÏpo(T Ð Ó ���BU�aJX�_�f�TK`bdeVfDghW�denB]�ghn�nbaK��`bU�a�TKV/��aJX�V\cBo't�gYf��°ghf;defQ`�aKia=c ò t�gYf��;cbaK`�_�cbf�n�`�U�a�TKV/��aX�V\cl±�T j�Ïpo(T Ð Ó �B�BU�a%do��a@g:denB`bV+U�g3ma%`bU�denBcba=nbde��_�gYW1T=VQ��a¢sDa¢ghn�V]�`�de[^deåKaK�;ghnl]DVn�nbdes�WeatD�BU�deWeaJnb`bdeWeW'T=V[^]�_�`bdef�i�`bU�aaK�/`ba=f�nbdeVfDghWeWep:n�gh[+alc�aKnb_�We`3�¯�V\cBTKV[+]�ghc�denbVf#t��a���cbn�`l]�c�aKnbaKf/`Jg:±�²íma=cbnbdeV\f�VYX1`�U�a�X�_�f�TK`�deVf/�q]�Vh��aKc�dof�i�X�_�f�TK`�deVf�gYW���3� ���%D ���ø! ö 9Â��#%$ &%'���#%$R<á&3'â�G#%$,&%' ö 9Â��#%$ &%'���#%$R<F�± ��! ö 9f��#%$ &3'(��#%$R<�) ± #�!N��#%$�)

2%.�$�D ����Þ,���D ���8q,��� ���3D ��� �1#

��#D ���M9 ± J�!"��#3$�)P9�qM9gÞ�JR<3<%<

.�#%S&6�%�����%D ���M9;D���� ± ��!"�G#%$�)i�XrM/%<����J�K%28��$���D ���M9 ± J�!"��#3$�)P9 ± ��) �(7�9 ± � ) � 7�9 ±5� )G/3< � <¤�R<1939 ± ��) �]rR/%<¤JE<%<â! ö 9f��#3$ &%'(��#3$R<

��s�nba=cbma%`bU�gY`�`�U�alc�aKnbde��_�gYW�]�cbV\ic�gh[wTKV\f/`�ghdef�n�g�WeV`�VhX'_�f�f�aKTKa=nbn�gYcbp;cba=��deTKaKn@� u nBTKV\_�We�^sDalaK�/]DaKTK`�aK�'t�±�õ Ï�ghf��:X�V\c`bUDgh`B[�gY`b`�aKc@t�j;a=`�gj�­�ghnB��aKWeW Ð t/]�cbVhm/de��aKnlg%sDaK`b`�aKcJ�Ìg3p:`�V:nb`�gYiaJ`bU�a�TKV/��a�

�3� ���(Ý �GÜ(Ý�/â! ù 9f�G#%$ &%'(�G#%$R<á&%'8��#3$�&3' ù 9f��#%$ &3'(��#%$R<��± ��! ù 9f��#%$ &3'(��#%$R<�) ± #�!"��#%$*)

2%.�$�J K%2�q,��� ����Ý ��Ü(Ý��P#��#

# .��3$ß9 ± J�!"�G#%$�)P9;�%Ü .�JsqE<�939;�%Ü .�J��R<áJR<3<.�#%S

&6�%�����(Ý ��Ü�Ý�/H9;# .��%$ ± ��!"�G#%$�)��8rM/%<����J�K%28��$���# .��3$ß9 ± J�!"�G#%$�)�9 ± ��)��(7ô9;�(7�/%<3<H9%9 ± ��)��]rR/3<�JE<%<O! ù 9f��#%$ &3'(��#%$R<

� fJX�gYTK`@t3`�U�aKcba�den1gY`�Woa3ghnb`#Vf�a�V`bU�aKc7�Ìg3p�`bVB]�c�Vic�gh[«`�U�denDX�_�f�TK`�deVf�gYWdef¢± õ ����a�T@ghf�a=Wode[+dofDgh`ba#`bU�a�V_�`�aKc'sDaK`�gP��c�aK��aK�X�c�V[w`�U�a�cba=nbde��_�gYW�TKV/��at�gh`�`bU�a%]�cbdeTKa�VYX1��_�]�WedoT3gh`bdef�i�`bU�a�def�f�aKcBVf�a\�

�3� ���(Ý �GÜ(Ý��ß! ù 9f�G#%$ &%'(�G#%$R<á&%'8��#3$�&3' ù 9f��#%$ &3'(��#%$R<��± ��! ù 9f��#%$ &3'(��#%$R<�) ± #�!"��#%$*)

# .��%$M9 ± J�!"��#3$�)�3Ü .�JM9"2%.�$�J K32�D,��# .��%$M9%9;�3Ü .�J��R<áJR<

��#� ���(Ý ��Ü(ÝCÞiD�#

.�#%SE<%<&6�%�����(Ý ��Ü�Ý��O9;# .��%$M9 ± ��!N��#%$�)��8rM/%<3<r�C�J�K%28��$���# .��3$ß9 ± J�!"�G#%$�)�9%9 ± ��)��%rR/%<áJR<17�9%9 ± ��)��%rR/%<FJR<17â/%<O! ù 9f�G#%$ &%'(�G#%$R<

u WeW�`�U�cbaKa%VhX6`bU�a�ghsDVhmal]�cbVi\c�gY[^n�T@ghf;sDa�aKf�TKV/��a=�°def�`�U�a�f�a=�èW�ghf�i_�gYia�gYnB��a=WoWq�7�BU�a���c�nb`�]�cbV\ic�gY[ �%� ���%D���� dennbde[+]�Wep:TKV]�deaK��Wodef�a ��X�V\cq�qWedof�a���BU�a¥±Dõ�ma=cbnbdeV\f �%�����(Ý ��Ü�Ý�/ gYf�� �%� ���(Ý ��Ü(Ým� �BdeWeW'c�aKÿ/_�decba�`�c�gYf�nbW�gh`�deVf�n �3� ���R/ gYf���%� ��� � t\�BU�deT�U;��aJnbU�Vh�!s�a=WoVh���

z Ý

Page 33: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

�3� ���R/O! ö 9f��#3$ &%'(��#3$R<á&%'ò��#%$,&%' ö 9f��#3$ &%'(��#3$R<F�± ��! ö 9f�G#%$ &%'(�G#%$R<E) ± #�!"��#3$�)

2%.�$�D ���H���,� ����#D ���st��,�

��#D ���ß9 ± J�!"�G#%$�)i�:9�t�JR<%<

.�#%S&��%� ���R/�9;D ��� ± �*!"��#%$�)��Xr�/3<1���J�K%28��$���D ���M9 ± J�!"��#3$�)P9 ± ��) �(7�9;�(75/%<%<69%9 ± �*)��]rR/%<áJR<3<0! ö 9Â��#%$ &%'���#%$R<

�3� ��� �ø! ö 9f��#3$ &%'(��#3$R<á&%'ò��#%$,&%' ö 9f��#3$ &%'(��#3$R<F�± ��! ö 9f�G#%$ &%'(�G#%$R<E) ± #�!"��#3$�)# .��,KI!"��#3$O�G#2%.�$�D ���H�*Þg�,�

D ����.6�,� ����Þ Û Û K Þ Þ 9;D ���M9;��ÞËK�<3<�#��#

D ���ß9 ± J�!"�G#%$�) 0 KH��J 2 .�<.�#%S

&6�%����� ��9;D ���M9 ± ��!"��#3$�)��sr�/%<%<����J�K%28��$���D ���M9 ± J�!"��#3$�)P9%9 ± �*)��]rR/%<�JR<17�9%9 ± ��)��]rE/%<FJR<678/3<�! ö 9f��#3$ &%'(��#3$R<

ãlVh��aKm\aKc@t7f�a=do`�U�aKc�VhXB`bU�a;ghsDVhma:de[^]�Woa=[^aKf/`�gY`bd�Vf�n�don%ÿQ_�do`�a:n�gY`bdenqX�gYTK`bV\cbp/t'n�def�TKat7aKm/de��aKf/`�Wop/t#`bU�a:c�aKnbde��_�gYWBTKV/��a:defghWeW�`�U�a¢T3ghnba=n�T=Vf/`�gYdof�nB_�f�f�aKT=aKnbn�ghcbp�cba=��deTKaKn@�¸�BU�a¢c�a@ghn�Vf°denB`�U�gh`���a���V:f�V`�_�`bdeWedeåKaJ`bU�a^´ ¦�µ�©3¦/ªK´�Ö\¦�§høDdof�X�Vc�[�gh`�deVf`bUDgh`l`�U�a�]�gYnbn�aK�£ghc�i_�[+aKf/`BdenlghTK`�_�ghWeWep�g�sDVh�/aK��øo§\¨l��Ô\§¢ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVf't�c�gh`�U�aKcJ`bUDghf°g�[^V\cbaJiaKf�aKc�gYW1a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�VhXgËX�_�f�T=`bdeVf�gYW6`qp/]�a\� � fHg+W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a¢�Bde`�U£def/`baKf�nbdeVf�gYW6TKV/��a^gYf�ghWep/nbden@t®��a:T@gYf���V£g+s�de`Js�a=`b`ba=c@�;¤�a:T@gYf�`baKn�`�`bU�aghc�i_�[+aKf/`�gh`�cb_�f/�q`bde[+alghf��:V\_�`b]�_�`ÌgJ[+Vc�aBV]�`�do[+deåKaK��cbaKn�_�We`�d�X'`bU�a�gYcbi\_�[^aKf/`7denÌg�WÎgY[:s��DgBaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f'�6�BU�don��Bg3p��a�T3ghf;Vs�`�ghdef^`�U�a�[+Vnb`�nbde[+]�WedÙ�DaK�'thd�X1f�V`B`bU�a�[+Vn�`�a��^T=doa=fQ`�cbaKn�de��_�ghW�T=VQ��a�

�3� ��� ! ö 9f��#%$�&%'(��#%$E<á&%'O�G#%$,&%' ö 9f��#%$�&%'(��#%$E<F�± ��! ö 9f��#%$ &3'(��#%$R<�) ± #�!N��#%$�)

Ý�K54�.6�8���D ���ß9 ± ��!"�G#%$�)6�vu,�%�R<á� '

#�.��,KI!"��#%$ò��#23.�$�D ����Þ��,� ����Þ Û Û K Þ Þ 9�u7D�K�<á#�G#

D ���ø9 ± ��!"�G#%$�) 0 KH��� 2 ÞE<.�#%S

.%2 4�.6�%� ���R/���#&6�%�����M9;D ��� ± �*!"��#%$�)��Xr�/3<1���J�K%28��$���D ���C9 ± ��!N��#%$�)f9Q�lr�/%<17�9;�8rM/3<o7â/%<E! ö 9f�G#%$ &%'(�G#%$R<

{

��»3Ï�Ï�� u��È%¥ �Ñ {Sg�Î�e � V Û§t Þ \ih { ^t«.¬o­i®¯© { ^*\ {Ôÿ^ ¢¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ �1c�demQd�gYW�� {

z�v

Page 34: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

ª× Ïp> Ð ' 0 TE^ y jGj�j y T Ó 2Z y >xw�Û �OT�^�|G|�|�T Ó Þ \ih!Ï Z y;� ^ y j�jGj yQ� Ó Ð"y Û¿� �` Ï � ^Cj�jGj � Ó j |6¾ n Û � ^ y jGj�j yQ� Ó Ñ TE^ y jGj�j y T Ó Þ > Ð-Þ

Z y >lw e \ih Z Û y�y bâ Ù Ïp> Ð ':mZ y >xw e � V Û¿m Þ \ih Z Û y�y

Z y T6wPTÀ\ih Z y | Z y;� w � \ih Z y | Z y¤h w h \ih Z y |

Z y >lw e \ih Z Û y�yZ y ±(T#� V jG>lw�±�T#� V j e \ih Z Û y�y

Z y >xw e \ih Z Û y�yZ y a n T#� V jz>lwða n T#� V j e \ih Z Û y�y

Z y > ^ w e ^ \ih Z ^ y�y ^ Z ^ y > b w e b \ih Z b y�y bZ y Ïp>À^O>­b Ð w�Ï e ^ Ð Ï e bh� V b Ð \ih Z b y Ï y ^|{ y b Ð

¯#dei_�c�a v ��7��]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghW#nbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKn�X�V\cB]�gh`�`baKc�f�[;gh`�T�U�dof�i��

��»3Ï�Ï�� u}�ýºg¸����h� Ï�»/~@�háq�há ~K¼°¾- �¸l��~@~3»/�hâ ë ��~h��Æ7á�â�È_¼¡�¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {~g Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü e � V Û§t Þ \ih { ^ «�§J©Hªdm £ ñÏÂ.®gµ²µ�� ¥ ³Åé#íp®^ª;ª�®�ì�®g©iª-®g©ió�¶Ýñh®W¬ë« £%¢ ® ¢ mã' ¿'¾(Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð «§J©iª £ ñ ¥ éh®gñ�­ ¥ ³Wé��v« £ ¢ ® ¢1wòÉ mÃ�Q�v«�¬¾­i®g©�Ñ3Û m Ñ Y/Þ�{Sg�Î�e � V ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ \ihHÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{ ^

°-¢¤£¦¥ �Ñ {@g�ÎMe � V Û§t Þ \ih { ^�¬o­H®g©Ï � 9 Ð �Ñ@Ï � 9 Ð@{Sg.+ Y.-0/ Î Ï � 9 Ð0e � V ÛeÏ � 9 Ð t Þ \ihÍÏ � 9 Ъ{ ^

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ û�p;g�nb`bc�ghdeiU/` X�Vc��ÌgYcb�^def���_�TK`bdeV\f^Vf;`�U�aJnb`bc�_�TK`�_�cba:VYX e � {

kln�dof�i:`bU�aJ]�c�aKm/doV\_�nB`q��V¢WeaK[+[�ghn3th��a�T3ghf°gh_�i\[^aKf/`6`�U�aJ`bU�a=Vcbp+VhX7`bU�a�T=VcbaJW�ghf�i_�gYial�Bde`�U^]�gY`b`ba=cbf°[;gh`bT�U�def�ighf���`�U�a�f�a=�«TKVf�n�`bc�_�TK` �h��}=» � � f°]�ghc�`bdeTK_�W�gYc@t�`�U�a¢S/_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f r cbdef�TKde]�WeaKn�Ï�­�a=[^[�g v Ý Ð t�gYf��;`bU�a r gYc�gh[+aK`bc�deTKde`qpr c�V]DaKcb`�doa=n�Ï�­�a=[^[�g v\v@Ð t/ghc�ala@gYnbdeWep¢a=�Q`�aKf���a=���Bde`�U^`bU�a�gh����de`bdeVf�gYW�def���_�T=`bdema�T@ghn�aKnBcbaKn�_�We`bdef�i%X�cbV\[ó`bU�denBgh����de`�doV\f'�¤�al]�cbaKn�aKf/`�`�U�aJTKV[+]�WeaK`ba=��]�cbV/VhX�nBVYX1`�U�aKnba%Woa=[^[�gYn7dof;`�U�a u ]�]DaKf���de����BU�a�V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghW�n�aK[�gYf/`bdeTKn�X�VcB]�gY`b`�aKcbf�n�den�i\dom\aKf;`bU�c�V_�i\U;`bU�aJf�aK�H� _���i[+aKf/`

Z y >xw e \ih Z Û y�y�BU�deT�U^c�a@gh��n3�6def^g%iWeVs�gYW�n�`bV\cbaJVhX'f�gY[^aKn Z t\`bU�aJ[�gY`bT�U�def�i�VYX�³�Ö¦�µ�b§\³@µ-©�ÔlaK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf~> `bV�`bU�a�]�gh`�`baKc�f e aK�/`�aKf���n`bU�a°iWeVsDghW�nb`bV\cba°`�V Z Û gYf��ÚiaKf�a=c�gh`�aKn°g�nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf y X�V\c¢`�U�a°]�gY`b`ba=cbf/�qmghc�dÎgYs�WeaKn:VhX e � �BU�a;cb_�WeaKnËX�Vc:`�U�den��_���i[^a=fQ`�ghcba%idemaKf+def�¯#dei_�c�a v ��7¬�V`bdeTKaJ`�U�gh`3t/sQp+`bU�aJf�gY`b_�c�a�VhX7]�gh`�`baKc�f;[�gh`�T�U�def�i�t\`bU�aJn�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f y denBVhX6gma=cbp^n�de[^]�Wealn�`bc�_�TK`b_�cba� � f;]�ghc�`bdeTK_�W�gYc@t/`bU�a�`�aKcb[+n�X�cbV\[wde`bnBc�ghf�i\a�f�aKmaKc�TKVf/`�ghdef^mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKn�X-cbV[ýdo`�nB��V[;ghdef'�u n�ghWec�a@gh��p;aK�/]�W�gYdof�aK�'tD`bU�a�]�gY`b`ba=cbf�mghcbd�gYs�Wea¥Û¿�MT ^ |�|G|ªT Ó Þ nbU�V\_�We�°[�gY`bT�U°ghf°aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�>«]�cbVhm/de��aK�°`�U�gh`�>��aK]DaKf���n�Vf�Wep;Vf�mghc�d�ghs�WeaKncT ^ y j�j�j y T Ó ���BU/_�n3t�`bU�a�cb_�Woa%X�V\c�]Dgh`b`�aKcbf�mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=nlaK�/]�WedeTKde`bWep;]�cbVhm/de��aKnJ`�U�a¢c�aKÿ/_�decbaK�T�U�aKT�����S/de[+doW�gYcbWepth`�U�a�]�gY`b`ba=cbf e � V Û§t Þ UDghnB`bV:a=f�nb_�c�a¢`�U�gh`lgYWeW�`�U�aJX�c�aKa�f�gY[^aKn�VhX6g�[�gh`�T�U�aK�^a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf~>«gYcbaJdef

`bU�a���aK]DaKf���a=f�TKp°n�aK`�t:t�gYf��;`bU�a%TKVc�cbaKn�]�V\f���def�i^c�_�WeaJcba���a=TK`bn�`�U�gh`3�7�BU�gh`B`�U�denlT�U�aKT��/n�gYcba�n�V_�f����Bde`�U�c�aKnb]DaKTK`J`�V`bU�a�`qp/]Da�nbp/n�`baK[Íden�`bU�a�[+V`�domgY`bdeVf%X�V\c�`�U�aJX�V\WoWeVh�Bdef�iJ��a��Df�de`bdeVf;ghf��;WeaK[^[;g���+» a â7á-~@á-¾�â<u[�<ºQÄ�¼�Å6»�}= b¾��K»�ð7|6}K~3á-~"ð7~@á�¾Dâ1}żü ­i®F��îâª�ï�íK®g©3¬� É3Î�y � { ª�®g©H³�¬4®¯ñା­3§�¬ y+£ ñ!§�ñJî-êWñJ¬ £ ¬�î�¬ £ ³Å© ¥ ³Wé�¬o­H® ô §Jé £ §�êWµo®gñ £ © { «�§J©Hªð¬¾­3§�¬�¬¾­i®!ñ[î�êWñJ¬ £ ¬#î�¬ £ ©�ï¬4®¯é#í;ñT§[µ¦µo³�Â�³�ótóWîÅé#éh®¯©iót®gñK³ ¥ ³W©�µ·¶:¬¾­i®T©3§JíK®gñ £ ©� ¢KÈ ©Ý³�¬o­H®gé;Â.³Wéhª�ñÏ É3Î�y � {<£²¥¤¥ ³Wé�® ô ®gé%¶vì�§�¬#¬4®¯é#©[� ô §Jé £ §�êWµo®�:� ü�Ê { Â.®1­3§ ô ®!�Ñ�| É3Î�y Ïf� Ð �hüíÛ Þë¢

zy

Page 35: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

��»3Ï�Ï�� u��<º;Ä�¼�Å6»d¸J�h»�}K»/�f×/��~3á�¾DâÝ b¾D�iÅ7��~@~3»/�hâ Ò Ï���~h��Æ'á-âRÈ_¼È%¥ �Ñ {.ÿ^ g=e � V Û§t Þ \ih { b §J©iªv�Ñ {Ôÿ^ É Î >ó� V Û§t Þ §J©iª Z < y >�w e \ih Z Û�y�y «¤¬o­i®g©<¬o­H®géh®´®�� £ ñ[¬oñ� Û Ö <ñJî�ó#­¬o­ò§�¬ Z Û \ Z <]\ §[©iªK ÛôÉ Î y � { b ¢¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ û�p+dof���_�TK`�doV\f^V\f�`�U�a�n�`bcb_�TK`b_�c�a¢VYX1`�U�aJ]�gh`�`baKc�f e �7¤�aJ]�cbaKn�aKf/`l`�U�a�def/`baKc�aKnb`�dof�i:T@ghn�aKn@�T@ghn�a e \�Û ��TE^R|G|�|�T Ó Þ �

v ��û�p�ghn�nb_�[+]�`bdeV\f't �Ñ { ÿ^ g Î Û¿��T ^ |G|�|�T Ó Þ � V Û§t Þ \ih��:� XYk�oZ \[� ö�Ï V Û � , y t Þ�Ð� f;V`�U�aKcB��Vcb��n@t { b \7�Ë� XYk�¾Z \�� ö¢Ï V Û � , y t Þ Ð �

y � u Wen�V:sQp^gYnbn�_�[^]�`�deVf't��Ñ { ÿ^ É Î >!� V Û§t Þ �z ��û�p£Ï y\Ð ghf��;f�gY[^a��-X�V\cq�qmghcbd�gYs�Wea�n�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f�Ï�­�a=[^[�g�·D� · Ð t

yQ� , � V , Ñ { ÿ^ /10 T , � V , 2 É Î Û � ,�Ñ T , Þ >�� V Û � , y t Þ·���û�p^V]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�ghW�n�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKnBVhX7]�gh`�`baKc�f/��[;gh`�T�U�dof�i�t

Z y�e wV>F\ihèÏ Z yQ� ^ y j�jGj yQ� Ó Ð"y Û¿� �` Ï � ^RjGj�j � Ó j |6¾ n Û � ^ y j�jGj y;� Ó Ñ TE^ y jGj�j y T Ó Þ > Ð�Þ� f;V`�U�aKcB��Vcb��n@t�`�U�a�c�aKnbde��_�gYW�nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf y den�def;`bU�donBT3ghnba%��a���f�a=�£ghn

y \�Û¿� �` Ï � ^Cj�jGj � Ó j |6¾ n Û � ^ y jGj�j yQ� Ó Ñ TE^ y jGj�j y T Ó Þ > Ð-ÞX�V\cBnbV[+aBX�c�aKnbU;f�gY[^aKn � , � V , �

x ��û�p^`bU�a�n�gY[^alc�_�Wea�X�Vc�aKmghWe_�gY`bdeVf+VhX7]�gh`�`baKc�f�n@t ª× Ïp> Ð ' 0 TE^Øj�j�j y T Ó 2/�ç���û�p£Ï x\Ð ghf��;TKV\f/`baK�/`Bnb`�cbaKf�i`bU�aKf�def�i£Ï-­�aK[+[�g�æ�� v@Ð t� y;� , � V , ÑG| É Î Û � ,�Ñ T , Þ >!� V Û � , y t Þ t����BU�aKf�Ï-ç Ð de[^]�WedeaKn3ts/p:`qp/]�def�i:cb_�Woa=n

yQ� ,�� V ,�ÑG| É3Î Ï � ^Rj�jGj � Ó j |6¾ n Û � ^ y j�jGj y;� Ó Ñ T�^ y j�jGj y T Ó Þ > Ð � XYk�oZ \[� ö�Ï V Û � , y t Þ�Ðé���ãla=f�TKatD`�gY�/dof�ià Û \7 y;� ,�� V ,7n�gh`bden ��aKn� Û�É3Î�y � { b\t/�BU�deT�U;�ÌgYnBcbaKÿ/_�decba=�'�

T@ghn�a e \�Ï e(Û � V Û¿m Þ Ð �BU�aKc�aÏm8'�tË�

v ��û�p�ghn�nb_�[+]�`bdeV\f't��Ñ {.ÿ^ É3Î >!� V Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^V]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�ghW�n�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKn�X�Vc�]�gY`b`ba=cbf�n3t bâ Ù ÏY> Ð '�m;�z �B¯�cbV[ Ï v@Ð gYf���Ï y\Ð t/s/p^n�`bcba=f�i`�U�aKf�def�i�Ï�­�a=[^[�gYn6æ�� ·¥gYf��°æ�� xÐ t/��aJ�/f�Vh��`�U�gh`

�Ñ { ÿ^ É Î >«� V Û¿m Þ·����BU�aJcba=nb_�We`BX-VWeWeVh�Bn7X�cbV\[ Ï zÐ s/p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@� {

�BU�a^W�gYnb`�]�deaKTKa;`bV°sDa�gY����aK�Úden�`�U�a^V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghW�nba=[�ghf/`�doT=n�X�V\c�`bU�a �h�D}K» n�`�gh`�aK[^a=fQ`3��¯'dec�nb`���a+aK�/`baKf��í`bU�a��_���i[^a=fQ`¹X�VcBTKV\f/`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f'�

Z Ù <� `?> Ù Z ^ <� `?> ^ Z b <� `?> b

Ï �h��}=»�Z Ù ¾� l|�¾ nne h Z ^ »/ìq}K»�Z b Ð <� ` Ï �Y��}=» > Ù ¾� l|�¾ nne h�>À^ »/ìq}K» >­b Ð

zz

Page 36: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

�BU�a�gh����de`�doV\f�ghWDT@gYnbaKn��BU�deT�U;ghc�don�a�def^`�U�aJWoa=[^[�gYn v@y t v3z gYf�� v ·:ghc�a�a3ghnbp+`bV:]�c�Vhma�7¤�aJghWenbV�aK�/`ba=f��°`bU�a�n�[�gYWoW��nb`�aK]Hn�aK[�gYf/`bdeTKn^Ï nbaKa;`bU�a^cb_�Woa=n¢sDaKWeVh� Ð �;¬�V`bdeTKa:`�U�gh`�`bU�a^]�c�aK[^denba:VYXÌW�gYnb`�c�_�Wea^[�gY�aKnJ_�n�a^VYXl`bU�aËX�ghTK`%`bU�gY`�`bU�aV]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�ghW�n�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKn6X-VcB]�gY`b`ba=cbf�n�don���aKT=do�Dghs�Weat�d�� a�/de`�denlghWe�Ìg3p/n�]�V\nbn�dos�WoaJ`�V:`bV%��f��;V_�`3t\X�VcBi\demaKf Z t}>!ghf�� e�BU�deT�U;_�f�deÿ/_�a Z Û ghf�� y t�d�X¹gYf/pQt\n�gY`bdenqX�p+`bU�aJc�aKW�gh`bdeV\f Z y >lw e \ih Z Û�y�y �

Z yQZ Ù � � ` Z Û y;Z Û ÙZ y Ï �h��}=»�Z Ù ¾� l|6¾5n�e h Z ^ »/ìq}K»zZ b Ð��� ` Z Û y Ï �h�D}K»�Z ÛÙ ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z ^ »Qìq}=»ËZ b Ð

Z y >lw e \ih Z Û y�yZ y Ï �Y��}=»°|6¾ n > ¾- l|6¾ nne h Z ^ »Qìq}=»àZ b Ð��� ` Z Û y�y Ï Z ^ Ð

� Z Û y�y j Z y >xw e \ih Z Û y�yZ y Ï �h��}=»°|6¾ n > ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z ^ »/ì�}=»�Z b Ð.�� ` Z y;Z b

¯#dofDghWeWepQt\_�nbdef�i:`�U�aJWeaK[^[;ghn6aKn�`�gYs�Wedon�U�aK�°def+`bU�denln�aKTK`�doV\f't�de`BdenB]DVnbn�des�Wea�`�V^gh_�i\[^aKf/`�`bU�a%]�cbV/VhX7VhX6`bU�a r cbV\ic�aKnbnghf��Ò��p/]�a r c�aKnba=cbmgh`�deVf�`�U�aKVc�aK[ Ï��BU�aKV\cbaK[ v3xÐ `bV�U�gYf���Wea^`�U�a°aK�/`�aKf���aK� WÎgYf�i_Dghia\�H�BU�a;TKV\[^]�WeaK`�a;]�cbV/VhXJden]�c�aKnbaKf/`�aK�£def+`bU�a u ]�]DaKf���de���

ß n��5Ï�Å1ì-»dÇ� f�`bU�don%aK��gh[^]�Woa���a:aKf�TKV/��a;g+X�_�f�T=`bdeVf�`�U�gh`�sDaK`�g3�qcbaK��_�TKaKn:`bU�a^aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�n�]�ghn�nbaK�í`bV°de`¢gYn¢ghfHgYcbi_�[^aKf/`@� u `]�c�aKnbaKf/`3t���aJ��V�f�V`BU�g3m\al]�gYc�gY[^aK`�cbdeTl`qp/]Da�]DVWep/[^V\cb]�U�don�[ def^V\_�cBW�ghf�i\_�ghi\at\nbV:��a�c�aKnb`�cbdeTK`�`bU�den�X�_�f�TK`bdeVf+`bV:V\f�WepaK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\f�nlVYX6`qpQ]Da Ü .3K%2 t/s�_�`B��aJ��V^ghWeWeVh��ghc�s�de`bc�gYcbp+fQ_�[:s�aKc�VhX7f�gh[+aKn�dof+`bU�a=[£�

�ô����D%Ü .�S%L�Ý�.I! ] ��) ö 9;Ü .%K%2}���%�R<�&3' ö 9;Ü .3K%2I���%�ô<E)` ��) ± .}! ö 9;Ü .3K%2I���%�E<E)Ý�K54�.�.,���

D�����9%9 ± ��)6�vuE/��3�R<O�vu ����! Ü .%K%2�<�� 'ß9�7�uR/�! XY[Z �h»/��ìö�Ï �h»/��ì Û �YÞ�Ð G@u �I! ö �h»/��ì 7�<

#�.��,KI!�Ü .%K32â�G#2%.�$�D ���,.�/��HD3Ü .�S%L(Ým. Û Û ��GzK Þ Þ 9�uR/ÝD,K�<

D ���,.%���HD3Ü .�S%L(Ým. Û Û ��GzK Þ Þ 9�u �ô<��#

D ���M9 0 KH�,.%� 2 .�/%<.�#%S

.3254�.6. {

ß n��5Ï�Å1ì-»Kè�BU�denJaK��gh[+]�Wea�den�g°Ï nbaKi\[^aKf/` Ð VYX�`bU�a¢[+aK`�g¥X�_�f�TK`�deVf;X�V\cJnbp/[:s�V\WedoTJ��d�ä�aKcba=fQ`�d�gh`bdeV\f'�J�BU�a%X�_�f�TK`�deVf�`�gh�\aKn�g:f�gY[^aghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVfÒgYn¥gYfÒgYcbi_�[^aKf/`@��`�U�a;s�V/��p�VYXl`bU�a°ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�deVfHden:g°sDVh�/aK�H`�aKcb[ aKf�TKV/��def�i�`�U�a^aK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVfÚ`bV�s�a��d�ä�aKcbaKf/`�dÎgY`baK�#Ñ6`bU�a^ghs�n�`bc�gYTK`ba=�Hf�gY[^a�cbaK]�c�aKnba=fQ`�n:`bU�a:mgYcbd�ghs�Woa��Bde`bU�cbaKn�]�a=TK`:`bV°�BU�doT�U�`�U�a:��d�ä�a=cbaKf/`bd�gY`bdeVf�`�gh�a=n]�W�ghT=a�°¤�U�aKfH`�U�a^sDVh�/aK�HaK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVfHden:g;nb_�[ VYXl`q��V�nb_�sDaK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�n@t�`bU�a^X-_�f�TK`�doV\f^��_�n�`¢c�aKTK_�c�nbaKn+VhmaKc�`�U�aK[��¤�U�a=f�`bU�a:sDVh�/aK�£a=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVfídon�g+sDaK`�gP��c�aK��aK��Ï VhXlg^Wede[^de`�aK�+X�Vc�[ Ð tDde`���cbn�`�cba=��_�TKaKn:de`JsDa�X�Vc�a:cbaKT=_�cbn�dof�i��;�l`�U�aKcf�gY[^aKnBghf��;TKV\f�nb`�ghf/`bnJghc�a�[;gh`�T�U�aK�^def;`bU�aJ��a X�gh_�We`BT@gYnbat��BU�deT�U�`�U/_�nBcbaK`�_�cbf�nl`bU�a���aKc�domgY`bdemaJÝ��¬lV\`bdeTKaJ`bU�gY`�`�U�aJ]�cba=nbaKf/`lW�gYT���VhX7]�V\WepQ[+Vc�]�U�deT�]Dgh`b`�aKcbf�nB]�cbaKm\aKf/`bn�_�n6X-cbV[ýcbaKTKV\if�deåKdef�iDt/WeaK`ÌgYWeVf�aBc�aK��_�TKdef�i^gYWeW

`bU�a�s�a=`�g:c�aK��deTKaKnJ`�U�gh`�TKV_�We�;]DVnbn�des�Wep^V/TKTK_�cJdef;`bU�a�ghcbi\_�[^a=fQ`3�gYWo`�U�V_�iU't�gY��[^de`b`�aK��Wep/tde`BdenB�BcbV\f�i�t���a�T=_�cbc�aKf/`bWepWeaK`B`bU�aK[�]DghnbnB`�U�cbV\_�iU;`�U�a���a�Xqgh_�We`�T@ghn�a�

z ·

Page 37: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

Sô���%� ! ] �*)69 X KI!�Ü .%K32I) ö Ü .3K%2I�ªK.Gi�%�R<�&%'M9 X K}!�Ü .%K%2}) ö Ü .%K32I�ªK.Gi�%�R<á����G��S����3��)` ��) ± .}!f9 X K}!�Ü .%K%2}) ö Ü .%K32I�ªK.Gi�%�R<E)

# .��8K}!�Ü .%K%2 9�7P$%- .6S����3� .�Ü .�#3$��fK�$��G#]t1#�Kmõ�.�7�<��#Ý�K54m.�9N.ED,K�<����D ����K6� ',KI)f9;D����ò/%<] D ���M9(��uR/¤�8r��vu����R<F� '

2%.�$HD����,.�/r�M9;S��G�%� Û Û � Þ Þ 9"K})vuR/%<%<ðD�KD����,.%�H�M9;S��G�%� Û Û � Þ Þ 9"K})vu ��<%<ðD�K

��#K})�D ���M9".�/�r�.%��<

.�#3S] D ���M9%9 ± ��!�Ü�.%K%2I)6��uR/r�%�E<0��u ����!�Ü�.%K%2�<z� '

# .��HD*!�Ü .%K%28��#23.�$�D ���,.�/r�8uR/ýD6D

D ���,.%�H�8u ��G#

S����%� Û Û � Þ Þ 9"KI)�D ����9 0 D��,.%� 2 .ô/%<%<.�#%S

.%254m.HK})f9;D ����+�<{

� � È:Ä6È:Å�O�� Æ�Å��

�BU�aKc�a¢ghc�aJfQ_�[^aKc�V_�n���decbaKT=`bdeVf�nBdef+�BU�deT�U+`bU�a%nbp/nb`�aK[���aJ]�cba=nbaKf/`ba=�°U�aKc�a�T@ghf;sDaJaK�/`baKf���aK�'�6¤�aJWedenb`�nbV\[^aBVhX7`bU�a[^V\cba�do[+]�V\cb`�ghf/`6Vf�aKn@�v � {:�h|7á�~3�h���h¼-Ñ�â7¾�~���ð6}=~¢}KáÏ�Å7ì�»�~K¼�Å6»�}1 b¾D��â7� Ï�»�}Yã ¤�de`bU:`�U�alWede[^de`�gh`bdeV\f�`bU�gY`�fDgh[^a=n6T@ghf+Vf�Wep�s�a�nbde[^]�Wop\�`qpQ]DaK�'t#V_�c�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a�T@ghf�a=f�TKV/��a^V\f�Wep°Vs� aKTK`�]�c�Vi\c�gh[+nJ�Bdo`�U£n�de[^]�Wep\��`qp/]DaK�;X�c�aKa:mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn3�:�BU�denJ[�gh�\aKndo`:g�`q��VY��WeaKm\aKWqt6c�gY`bU�a=c:`bU�gYfÒg�[:_�We`bd��qWeaKmaKW7W�ghf�i_�gYia^Wede�a;±�õ�ghf��Òj;aK`�gj°­�� � `:��V\_�We�HsDa;dof/`�aKcbaKn�`bdef�i�`�Vdof/m\aKnb`�doi/gh`�a�U�Vh�ÍiaKf�a=c�ghWedeåKdef�i�`�U�a£`qp/]�def�i�X-Vc:f�gY[^aKn3tBd�X�]DVn�nbdes�Wea£gY`^ghWeWqt��BdeWeWldef/�D_�aKf�TKa�`bU�a°cbaKn�`;VhX�`bU�aWÎgYf�i_Dghia\tdef^]Dghcb`�deTK_�W�ghc�`bU�aJV\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�nBVhX7f�gh[+alghs�n�`bc�ghTK`�doV\f°ghf��;TKV\f�TKcba=`bdeVf'�6��f�a%T@ghf+do[;ghi\dof�a�c�aK`�gYdof�dof�i`bU�a°n�de[^]�Wea^`qp/]�def�i�X�V\c:`bU�a°sDV_�f��Úf�gh[+a�defí`bU�a X ÿ/_�ghf/`�dÙ�DaKc@t�X�V\c:`bU�a;Ó��b©�Ô´ ³�§\µ�´ ÷@©:mgYcbd�ghf/`3t6Vc^gYWeWoVh�Bdef�ighcbs�do`�c�gYcbp^fDgh[^a=n6X�V\c�´ ¨BÓ��b©�Ô´�³�§\µ�´�÷3© X �qÿ/_�ghf/`�dÙ�DT@gh`�doV\f'�

y �Bë ¾'¿'��ì�~K¼�Å6»J¾� 7â7� Ï�»�}hã6� f�`�U�a�]�cbaKn�aKf/`6ma=cbnbdeV\f�VhX�`bU�a�n�pQn�`baK[�t3f�gh[+aKn�_�nba=�¢def¢gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`bdeVf¢gYf���TKV\f�TKc�aK`bdeVf[:_�nb`7ghWe�Ìg3p/n7sDaBTKVf�n�`�gYfQ`�n@t\def¢V\cb��aKc�`bV�ghTKT=V_�f/`7X�V\c7`bU�aK[ódef�`bU�aB��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKp^gYf�f�V\`�gh`�deVf�n3� � f�V`�U�aKc6��Vc���n@t��a�T@ghf�f�V`7TKV\[^]�_�`�a6�Bde`bU�fDgh[^a=n@Ñh`�U�aKp�T@gYf¢sDaB]�gYnbnba=�^ghcbV\_�f��¢gYn7]�ghc�`1VYX�sDVh�Qa=���hTKV/��aBa=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n3ts�_�`7Vf�TKa_�f/s�Vh�/aK�'tD`�U�aKp�T@ghf�f�V`lsDa�_�nbaK��X-Vc�gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`bdeVf�ghf��°TKVf�TKcbaK`�deVf'��¯�V\cl`bU�donJ]�_�cb]DVnba\t'de`l[;g3p:s�a�sDaKf�a���T=dÎgYW`bV¢gY����gJn�aK]�gYc�gh`�aJ`qpQ]Dal[+V/��ghWede`qpQt3n�g3pU��Ï�ü�Û§t Þ�Ð t\`bV�TKW�gYnbnbd�X�p:fDgh[^a=n1VYX1`qp/]Dalü!Woden�`baK�:def^`�U�al��aK]�a=f���aKf�T=pàtË��BU�aJf�aK�![^V/��ghWD`qp/]�a%nbU�V\_�We�^sDa¢g�n�_�s�`qp/]Da�VhX6ö¢Ï ü¢Û§t Þ�Ð �

z � Äl¼�Å�»�Å6¾Dì-¼�Ï�¾��fÅ�Æ7á�}¤Ï ��â6¿ ~K¼�Å6» Ò Å6¾Dì-¼�Ï�¾��fÅ�Æ'áq�:�h»��mð1�}=á-¾�â�ãJ� f�gË[^aK`�g3�q]�cbV\ic�gY[^[:d�f�i¢W�gYf�i_�gYiat�`bU�a`qpQ]�dof�i°VhXlV\s��aKTK`�]�cbV\ic�gh[^n%don%[�gh��a:]�ghc�`¢VYXl`bU�a+`qpQ]�dof�i°VhXl`�U�a;[^aK`�g^]�cbVi\c�gY[^n@��Z�Vf�n�aKÿ/_�aKf/`bWep/t7nb_�T�UÚgWÎgYf�i_Dghia�U�ghnJg�WeV`BVhX6`qp/]DaKnl`�V:T@ghc�a¢VYX�gYf��;`bU/_�n�f�aKaK��nJn�`bcbV\f�i:f�V\`bdeVf�n�VhX7`qpQ]Da�]DVWep/[^V\cb]�U�den�[£�#�BU�denB�ÌgYnghWecba@gY��pJaKm/de��aKf/`�X�c�V[«V\_�c'aK��gY[^]�Wea7]�cbV\ic�gh[^nDX-Vc'sDaK`�glc�aK��_�T=`bdeVf:ghf��%nbp/[:s�V\WedoT#��d�ä�a=cbaKf/`bd�gY`bdeVf�def¢S�aKTK`bdeV\f¥ç��

·D�Bß n�áq}K~3»/â'~3á���ìJâ7� Ï�»!��â6¿ó~K¼�Å6» ��|6}K~3�h���h~3á-¾�â�ã �BU�a�[+V`�domgY`bdeVf�X�V\c:`bU�den:TKV\[^aKn�X�c�V[ gh_�`�V[;gh`bdeT:TKV/��aiaKf�a=c�gh`�deVf'�HS�g3p£`�U�gh`���a;U�g3m\a�g���gh`�gh`qp/]Da K�D(4 � # t7cba=]�cbaKn�aKf/`bdef�i�`�U�a°ghs�n�`bc�gYTK`:nbp/f/`�gY��VhXJ`bU�a+WÎgYf�i_Dghia\tghf��;`bUDgh`l��a�U�g3m\aJnbp/f/`bU�aKn�deåKaK��ghf£gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`lnbp/f/`�gY�;`bcba=a�X�V\clg�TKaKc�`�ghdef°V\s��aKTK`J]�c�Vi\c�gh[��7¤�a���V_�We�^Wede�aJ`�Vdof/m\V�a�`bUDgh`�]�cbV\ic�gY[ódof�cb_�f/��`�de[^at\dq� a\�h`bc�ghf�n X�Vc�[þde`6def/`bV%do`�n6sDVh�Qa=�^TKV/��a�cbaK]�c�aKnba=fQ`�gh`�doV\f°ghf��:`�U�aKf^a=mghWe_�gh`�a

zx

Page 38: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

do`3� u ]�cbV\ic�gY[ô`bU�gY`:]�aKc X�Vc�[^n�`�U�den:`bc�ghf�n X�Vc�[�gh`�deVf�don�VhX-`baKfícba�X�a=cbcba=��`bV�ghn^g6��m/don�des�Wea^TKV\[^]�deWeaKcª�D� � fÚg[^aK`�g3�q]�cbV\ic�gY[^[:d�f�i¢W�gYf�i_�gYia���a:V\_�iU/`JsDa^ghs�Wea�`bV;de[^]�WeaK[+aKf/`lg:X-_�f�TK`�doV\f J(Ý��mõ � c�aK]�c�aKnbaKf/`�dof�i�g;m/denbdes�WeaTKV[+]�deWoa=c@t6s�_�`:`bU�a�ÿQ_�aKnb`�doV\f�den:�BU�gh`+de`bn:`qp/]�a�nbU�V\_�We�ÒsDa� ��s/m/deV_�n�Wop/t6`�U�a°`qp/]DaKn^VYX�sDVh�/aK�ÚaK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�n`bU�gY` J(Ý��fõ � den^n�_�]�]DVnba=�«`bVÚ]�cbV/��_�TKa£�BdeWeWJ��aK]DaKf��!Vf!`bU�a�ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`;n�pQf/`�gh��`�cbaKa�n�_�]�]�WedeaK�ègYn gYfèghc�i_/�[^aKf/`@tDghf��;`�UQ_�n�`�U�a�c�ghf�ia�`qp/]Da�VhX�`�U�aJX�_�f�TK`bdeV\f°�BdeWoW#U�g3maJ`�V^sDa¢aK�/denb`�aKf/`bd�ghWeWep^ÿ/_�gYf/`bd���aK�'ÑDn�V[^a=`bU�def�i:Wede�aJ�Ý��mõ � !ËK�D(4 � #�&3's�%��)�� C ) ö 9 C � �%�R< � � f/`ba=f�nbdeVfDghW6TKV/��a;ghf�gYWepQn�denlnbU�V_�We��def�TKV\cb]DVc�gY`ba^g+TKaKc�`�gYdof�X-Vcb[ VhXdof/`�aKf�nbdeV\f�ghWD`qp/]�aJghf�gYWop/n�don�ghn���aKWeWqt/ghf��+`bU�gY`���V_�We�:aKfDghs�Weal`�U�aJVs��a=TK`�]�cbVi\c�gY[^n6c�aKnb_�We`�dof�i�X�c�V[ó`bU�a�m/denbdes�WeaTKV[+]�deWoa=c6`bV:sDaJ_�nbaK��dof;f�V\f/�q`bcbdem/d�ghWD�Ìg3p/n�def�`�U�aJcbaKn�`lVYX¹`�U�aJ]�cbV\ic�gh[£�

x �.� »/â1»/�h��ì-áY�»�¿� b¾��fÏH}�¾- ��h»��mð1�}=á-¾�â�ãB� f°ghWeW'`�U�a�[^a=`�g3�q]�c�Vic�gh[+[:dÙf�i�W�gYf�i_�gYiaKnBT=Vf�n�do��aKcbaK��def;`bU�denl��Vc���t���/]�V\dof/`7mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn7U�g3m\aBs�aKa=f^`bc�a@gh`�aK��gYn7Vcb��dofDghcbp;÷3§høoØ/©�mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn@� � f:n�_�T�U�g�nba=`b_�]'t�gJg�X-_�f�TK`�doV\f¢T3ghf:[�gY�ag�c�aKTK_�c�nbdema�T@ghWeW�`�V¢de`bn�aKW�X6Vf�Wep:Vf+`bU�aJTK_�cbcba=fQ`JTKV/��aJWeaKm\aKWqÑ/`bU�a�T3ghWeW�T@ghf;f�a=maKcBsDa��b]DVn�`b]DVf�a=� ��t�d�� a�\sDa�Vf;gU�deiU�aKc�TKV/��aJWeaKma=W6Ï�_�f���aKclg |�¾ n Vc â7»%n�~@Ð � � `���V\_�We�^sDaJdof/`�aKcbaKn�`bdef�i�`bV�defQm\aKnb`�deiQgh`�ald�X1de`�den�]DVn�nbdes�Weal`�V¢U�g3m\a���/]�V\dof/`J©hI Óô��©Kª�ªK´�Ö\¦¢mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=n@�

ç�� {^¿7¿#á�â�È;�h»� b»Q�h»/â6�h»�}Yã ¤�U�deWeaBde`BnbU�V\_�We�^sDa�c�aKW�gh`�dom\aKWep:nb`�c�ghdei\UQ` X�Vc��ÌgYcb�+`bV^gh���^cba X�aKcba=f�TKaKnJ`bV:V\_�c�WÎgYf�i_Dghia\tdo`J[;g3p�sDa:]DVnbn�des�Wea:`bV;idema�`bU�aK[ðg;[:_�T�U°nb`�cbV\f�iaKc�cbV\Wea¢def�`bU�a+[^V/��ghW#nbaK`�_�]'�;¯�V\c�aK��gh[+]�Weat�g+cba�X�a=cbaKf�T=aT@ghf;sDa�_�nbaK�°ghnlg%f�gY[^al�Bde`�U�g%��a���f�de`�doV\fg�¥T@gYcbc�pQdef�i�sDV`bU;`�U�aJaK�/`baKf�n�deVf�gYW'def/X�V\cb[�gY`bdeVf�VhX7de`bn�cba�X�a=cbaKf/`@t�gYn��aKWeW7ghnl`�U�a�dof/`�aKf�nbdeV\f�ghW#dof�X�Vc�[�gh`�deVf:VhX6de`bn�f�gh[+a�Bj;_�T�U°Wede�aJf�gY[^aKn3t�de`ln�U�V_�We�°sDa�n�V_�f����Bdo`�U°cba=nb]DaKTK`�`�Vdof/`�aKf�nbdeV\f�ghW7ghf�gYWop/n�donB`�V^aKf���Vh�«`bU�a�cba X�aKcba=f�TKaKn��Bde`bU;TKcbV\nbn ��n�`�ghi\a:]�a=cbnbden�`baKf�T=at7dq� a\�lghWeWeVh��`bU�aK[Í`bV+TKcbV\nbnJ`bU�aTKV/��a��qWoa=maKW#s�V\_�f���gYcbdeaKn@�¡ aKW�gh`�aK�°`�V^]�c�Vs�WeaK[ðÏ xÐ gYs�Vhm\atD��a%��V\_�We� gYWenbV^Wede�aJ`�V^def/maKn�`bdeiQgY`ba�c�aKTK_�c�nbdema:c�a�X�aKc�aKf�TKaKn3���BU�aKnba���V_�We�;s�acba�X�a=cbaKf�T=aKn¢�BU�Vnba%aK�/`baKf�n�deVf�T@ghf°c�a�X�aKcJ`�V^`bU�a¢c�a�X�aKc�aKf�TKa:f�gY[^aJde`bn�aKW�X�t�s�_�`�]DaKc�U�gh]�nJdef;]�V\nb`�]�V\f�aK��]�V\nbde`bdeVf�nÏ�dq� a�'_�f���aKcJg�s�Vh� Ð �

��Bß â7�há���Æ7á-â�È�~�Æ7»°ì-��â�È�ð7� ÈD»;¾� cÅ1��~@~3»/�hâ¹}Yã�� n�de`B]�V\nbnbdes�Wea�`�V:aK�/`baKf��£`�U�a�]�gY`b`ba=cbf/�q[�gY`bT�U�def�i�[^aKT�U�gYf�denb[w`�Vghf�gYWop/åKaJghf��+��aKn�`bcb_�TK`laK�/]�c�aKnbn�deVf�n�_�f���aKcB[+Vc�aB`bU�gYf�V\f�alW�g3p\aKcbn�VhX7s�Vh�/aKn��zãlVh��`�V¢[;gh`�T�U^gYiQgYdof�nb`�s�def���def�iTKVf�n�`bc�_�TK`bnJWede�a ì�»/~X×/��ì ghf�� ì-»Q~�|6¾ n �

é��Bë ¾'¿'»/ìJ~�Æ1»/¾D�h¼Ú¾� ¢~�Æ7»�ì���âCÈ(ð7� ÈD»�ã ­'ghn�`@t�s�_�`�]�c�Vs�gYs�Wep°[^V\nb`lde[+]�V\cb`�gYf/`@tD��a�nbU�V_�We��s�_�deWe�£[+VQ��aKWenBX�V\cV_�c�`qp/]�a�nbp/nb`�aK[�ghf��^]�_�`�de`6Vf;gJnbV\_�f��+WoV\ideT@gYW/X�V/V`�dof�i�� � fQ`�aKc�gYTK`bdeV\f^sDaK`q��a=aKf;f�gh[+aKn�ghf��^[^V/��gYW/WoV\ideTBU�gYns�aKa=f�VYX'defQ`�aKcba=nb`l`�V¢]�U�deWoV\nbV\]�U�deT@ghW�dof/m\aKnb`�doi/gh`�doV\f�n7X�V\c�ÿ/_�de`�alnbV\[^aB`�do[+a�Ï�n�aKa^Û cJcbd�éÝ Þ ghf���Ûܯ1j�ææ Þ�Ð �7¤�a�U�V]Da`bV:��c�g3��Vf;`bU�donB��Vc���X�VcB`�U�a�X�_�`�_�cba���aKmaKWeV\]�[^aKf/`�n@�

� PóÆËÃËÉ;5PÈ�:7ÊKÆËÃL:� f�`bU�den�]�gY]�a=c���a:]�cbaKn�aKf/`baK�Úg^`qp/]DaK��X�_�f�TK`bdeVfDghW6W�ghf�i_�gYiaJX�V\cJ[^aK`�g3�q]�cbV\ic�gY[^[:d�f�i�t�aK[^]�WeVhp/def�i^g+f�Vhma=W1�Bg3p°`�V��a��Df�a�g�[+VQ�DghW�`qp/]Da�VYX'TKV/��a��¤�a�X�Vc�[:_�W�gh`ba=�:do`�n�n�`�gY`bdeT�gYf��^��p/f�gY[^deT�nbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKnBghf��+]�cbVhm\aK�^`�U�aJTKVc�cbaKn�]�V\f���def�ir c�Vic�aKnbnlgYf��^��p/]�a r c�aKnba=cbmgh`�deVf;`bU�a=Vcba=[£�#�BU�aln�pQn�`baK[�den�sDghnba=��V\f�gY����def�i�`�U�aJf�V`�doV\f:VhX'f�gY[^aKn3tQgYn���aKmaKWeV\]�aK�s/p r de`b`�n�ghf��Òñ�gYs�s�g3p�defèÛ r ñ�Ý\Ý Þ tlÛÜñ r Ý v�Þ tBÛ r de`�Ý v�Þ gYf��èÛÜñ�gYs�ÝÝ Þ t7`�V�`bU�a°±D²#��T3ghWeTK_�We_�n:VYX�]�c�VQVYX�`baKc�[^n%X�Vc�`bU�af�aKT=aKnbn�do`�gh`�doV\f+X�c�gYi[^a=fQ`7VYX�[+VQ�DghW�WeVi\deTÌS/·+Û r�ê Ý v�Þ �'�BU�a�[^V\`bdemgh`�doV\fJX�V\c6TKV[:s�dof�dof�il`bU�al`q��V�nbp/nb`�aK[^n�TKV\[^aKn7X-cbV[`bU�aBWoV\f�ih�qcba=TKVi\f�deåKaK��f�aKaK�:VYX�[^aK`�g3�q]�cbV\ic�gh[^[:def�i�`bVJU�ghf���Wea�TKV/��aBa=�Q]�cbaKn�nbdeVf�n�TKVf/`�gYdef�def�iBX�c�aKaBmghc�d�ghs�WeaKnBÏbÛ ê g3m�æç Þ tÛ �6ghU�æ\æhs Þ t�ÛÜj;�BûÌS�ææ Þ�Ð � � f�V_�cJW�ghf�i_�gYiat�`�U�a:X-cbaKa:mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKnJVYX�g^T=VQ��a^aK�/]�c�aKnbn�doV\fÒgYcba:cba=]�cbaKn�aKf/`baK�Ús/pÚ¦�§¨�©KªK�¬�gY[^aKn�T@ghf�sDa¢V\]�aKc�gh`�doV\f�ghWeWep^`�U�V_�iU/`JVhXÌgYnlcba X�aKcba=f�TKaKn3t6aK�/TKaK]�`�`bU�gY`J`bU�a�`qp/]�a�nbp/nb`�aK[ô]�_�`�n�T=aKcb`�ghdef£Wede[^de`�gh`bdeV\f�nVf�`bU�aKdec�VQT=TK_�cbc�aKf�TKa\�¢¯#decbnb`3t�g�`baKc�[ T@gYf°s�a%aKmghWe_�gY`baK�°V\f�Wep^d�X6de`lTKV\fQ`�ghdef�nBf�V+f�gh[+aKnBVf�`bU�a�WeVh��aKnb`�TKV/��a�Woa=maKWE�`bU�don�denldef;nbU�gYcb]���denb`bdef�T=`bdeVf;�Bde`bU°`�U�a�nbaK[;ghf/`bdeTKnBVYX¹fDgh[^a=nldef°¯�c�aKnbU�j�­èÛ r ñ%ÝÝ Þ �BS/aKTKV\f��'t�f�gY[^aKnBT3ghf�f�V\`laKn�T@gh]Da`bU�a�n�TKV]Da�VhX1`�U�aKdecBTKc�a@gh`�dof�i â1»/½ _�f�i\_�ghc���aK�;s/p�ghf;gh]�]�cbV]�cbd�gh`�a�T=Vf�n�`bcb_�TK`�X�VcJ¦�§¨�©:§��=ªKµ���§³3µ�´ Ö¦���BU�a:nba=`¢VYXÌf�gY[^aKn�Vf��BU�deT�U�g^`�aKcb[ô��a=]�aKf���n:den�c�a���aKT=`baK�Údef£de`�n�`qp/]�def�iD�:¤�a�U�V]Da:`bU�gY`J`bU�den���a=nbdeif���V_�We�

ghWeWeVh� g+[^V\cba%��f�a��qic�ghdef�aK��TKV\f/`bcbV\W�Vhm\aKcJ`bU�a+V/TKTK_�c�cbaKf�T=a�VYX�X-cbaKa+mghcbd�gYs�WeaKn@t'gYf���`bU/_�n�[�gh�\a�`bU�a:WÎgYf�i_Dghia�[^V\cbaaK�/]�c�aKnbn�dom\atDa@ghn�deaKcl`�V¢]�c�Vi\c�gh[�def't�ghf��^[^V\cbaJgh[^a=f�ghs�Wea�`bV%X�_�`b_�cba�aK�/`�aKf�nbdeV\f�n@���f�g�c�aKW�gh`ba=�£f�V\`batDde`l[;g3p:s�a�VhX6def/`baKc�aKnb`JU�a=cba:`bV:��c�g3� g:]Dghc�gYWeWoa=W'�Bde`bU°�Bde`�U gËcbaKW�gY`baK��]�U�aKf�V[^a=f�Vf;�BU�deT�U

V/TKTK_�c�nBdef¢`�U�alaK�/`�aKf�nbdeV\f^VhX'j;aK`�gj°­��Bde`bU:c�a�X�aKc�aKf�TKaKn�ÛÜZBj°S�Ý v�Þ � u cba X�aKcba=f�TKa�def:j;aK`�g\j°­�[:_�nb`7f�V\`6s�aJghn�nbdeif�a=�^g]DVnb`�]�V\f�aK���YTKV/��aJmghWe_�a��BU�deT�U:TKVf/`�gYdef�n6mghc�d�ghs�WeaKn7sDV_�f��:V\f:`bU�a�Ö\Ø/µ�ªK´�Ô\©6VhX'`�U�aBTKV/��a�TKVf�n�`bc�_�TK`bV\c@� � f���aKaK�#t/dÙX�nb_�T�Ug�`bU�dof�i¢V/TKTK_�cbaK�'tD`�U�ghf;`bU�aË� X�cba=a"�:mghc�dÎgYs�Weal[;g3p¢aKn�T@gh]Da�`bU�aJnbT=V]Da�VhX7`bU�a^Ö\Ø/µ�ªK´�Ô\©l±/�qTKV\f�nb`�cb_�TK`��BU�deT�U�def/`bc�V/��_�TKaK�

z ç

Page 39: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

de`@�:¯�VcJ`baKT�U�f�doT3ghW�cba@gYnbVf�n@t7U�Vh��aKma=c@t#`bU�den�ghTK`�_�ghWeWep°T@gYf�f�V\`�sDa:]�c�VU�des�de`ba=�'t'n�V;`bU�a^gY_�`bU�V\cbn�c�aKnbV\cb`�`bV°g+U/pQi\deaKf�deTU�gYf���Wedef�i¢VYX6nbTKV\]�a�aK�/`bc�_�nbdeVf�sQp;ghf�f�V`�gY`bdef�i^g�`�aKcb[Í�Bde`bU;`�U�a�Wedenb`BVhX7X�c�aKa�mgYcbd�ghs�WeaKnBde`BTKV\f/`�ghdef�n3�B�ls/m/deV_�n�WepQt/`�U�denma=cbpH[:_�T�U�c�aK[^def���n¢VYX�`bU�a�V\]�a=c�gh`�deVfÚVhXJf�gh[+a^ghs�n�`bc�gYTK`bdeV\f'� � fH]�gYcb`�doT=_�W�ghc@t�V\f�a^T@gYfÚdo[;ghi\dof�a¢`�U�gh`^g�nbde[^deW�ghcnbT=aKf�ghc�deV°��V\_�We�°U�gY]�]�a=f£d�X���a:`bc�doa=�£`�V�a=�Q`�aKf���V\_�cJWÎgYf�i_Dghia%�Bdo`�U£c�a�X�aKc�aKf�TKa=n@t7`bV/VD�¢¤�a%��V\_�We�°f�aKaK��`�V;cbaKÿ/_�decba`bUDgh`�`bU�a+`qpQ]Da^VYX�ghfíaK�/]�cbaKn�nbdeVfÚghn�nbdeif�a=�H`bV�g;c�a�X�aKc�aKf�TKa°��VQa=n:f�V`�T=Vf/`�gYdofHgYf/p�_�f/s�V\_�f���f�gY[^aKn3t7dof�V\cb��a=c¢`�Vg3mV\de�^nbT=V]Da¢aK�/`�cb_�n�doV\f'� � f°nb_�T�U�g:nba=`b_�]'tD`�U�a�V]DaKc�gh`bdeV\f�VYX6f�gh[+a�gYs�nb`�c�gYTK`bdeVf;��V_�We�;TKV\cbcba=nb]DVf���aK��ghTK`�Wep�`�V:`bU�a[^a=fQ`�deVf�aK�;j;aK`�gj°­�gYf�f�V`�gh`�doV\f�n@��BU�gh`Jghn�do��at���a�ghWenbV:TKV\f�nbde��a=cbaK��TKVf�nb`bc�_�TK`�nlX-Vcl]DVWep/[^V\cb]�U�don�[ódof;f�gY[^aKnBghf��^X-VcBdef/`baKf�n�deVf�gYW'TKV/��a¢gYf�ghWep/nbden3�

�BU�aJX-Vcb[+aKc�]�cbVhm/de��aKn¸X�VcB�Bc�do`�def�i:]�cbV\ic�gh[^n��BU�deT�U°ghcba%]�ghc�gh[^a=`bcbdeTJdef;`bU�aKdec�f�gh[+al��aK]DaKf���aKf�TKdeaKn3�l�BU�a%WÎgY`baKc�denlg]�gY`b`ba=cbf/�q[�gY`bT�U�def�i�[^aKT�U�gYf�denb[ó`bV:TKV\[^]�gYcbat\def�nb]DaKTK`Jghf��;��a=nb`bc�_�TK`�TKV/��a�mghWe_�a=nlgh`�cb_�f/�q`bde[+at�BU�doT�U;��a�T=_�cbc�aKf/`bWepcba=nb`bc�deTK`baK�+`bV�`bU�aBn�do[+]�WepB`qp/]�aK��X-c�ghi\[^aKf/`�VYX�`bU�a�W�ghf�i\_�ghi\a���6gh�\aKf�`�Via=`bU�aKc3t`�U�aKp:ghWeWeVh�£c�aKTK_�c�nbdef�iJVhma=c¹g�n�V_�c�TKaBVhXÏ�g�n�do[+]�Wep\��`qp/]DaK� Ð Vs� aKTK`7]�cbV\ic�gh[��¢g�X�a3gh`b_�cbaB`bUDgh`'��a�U�V]Da��BdeWeW\��f���de`�n1_�nbaBdef�]�c�Vic�gh[+[^dÙf�i�TKV/��a�V]�`bde[^deå@gY`bdeVf�ndef�g�n�aK`b_�]�VhX1n�TKdeaKf/`bd���T¢gYf��;nbp/[:sDVWedeTBTKV[+]�_�`�gY`bdeVf#�

� OB��OBÅ�OJÃ^É�O.:ÛÜZBj°S�Ý v�Þ Z�cbdenb`�dÎgYf�VlZBghWeT@gYif�VDt@ï7_�iaKf�deVlj;V\ii\d�t3ghf��J�Bde[«S/U�a@gYcb�'�Z�WeV\nbaK��`qp/]DaKn#X�Vc'g�n�g3X�a�do[+]�a=c�gh`�dema1j aK`�g\j°­6�

� Ö\Ø%�K¦�§hø7Ö#sB�#Ø/¦�³3µ�´�Ö\¦�§hø ! �bÖ�×��b§¨�¨�´�¦×\t y ÝÝ v �#`bV:gh]�]Da@gYc@�ÛÜZBj;�lÝÝ Þ Z�cbdenb`�dÎgYf�V¢ZBgYWoT3ghif�V�t/ï7_�ia=f�deV¥j;V\ii\d�t/ghf��^¤HghWede���¹gYU�g��#Z�WoV\nbaK�+`qp/]�aKnlgYnÌg%nbde[+]�Wealgh]�]�c�VQgYT�U+`bV�n�gPX�a

do[+]�a=c�gh`�dema:[:_�We`bd��qnb`�ghia:]�cbVi\c�gY[^[^d�f�i�� � fHk�iV�j;Vf/`�gYf�ghc�dqt(�V\n[�a ê � r � ¡ V\Wode[�t'ghf��Úï7[^V�¤�aKWeåKWqtaK��de`bV\cbn@t;�JØ/µ-Ö¨�§µ-§P�6�'§\¦×Ø/§3ש=ª°§¦�Ô ! �bÖ�×���§¨�¨¢´ ¦×t�mV\Wo_�[^a v é xz VhX6�'©�³3µ�Ø%�b©���Öµ-©=ª ´ ¦X�6Ö\¨BÓ�Ø/µ�©����³@´ ©@¦�³�©3t�]�gYiaKn y\x � z ç��/S/]�c�def�iaKc3t y ÝÝÝ��

Û ê g3m�æ\ç Þ ¡ Vh�Bghf ê g3mQdeaKn3� u `baK[+]�V\c�gYW'WeVi\doT�gh]�]�c�VQgYT�U�`bV^s�dof���def�ih�q`bde[^aJghf�gYWepQn�den@� � f£ïB��Z�W�ghcb�\atDaK��de`bV\c@t ! ��ÖPA³�©�©�Ô´ ¦×hªJÖ#sJµeÕ�©� �øo©3÷@©3¦�µeÕK�J¦�¦�Ø/§hø,��¶h¨¸Ó�ÖYª ´ ØQ¨�Ö¦K�#Ö�×\´�³�´ ¦M�6Ö¨¸Ó�Ø/µ-©G�.��³3´�©3¦�³�©@t/]�gYiaKn v éY·f� v æ x th¬la=�û�c�_�f�nb�BdeT���t�¬�aK�=�aKc�nbaKp/t[�\_�Wep v ææç�� � ï�ï6ï�Z�V[+]�_�`�aKcÌS�VQT=doa=`qp r c�aKnbn3�

Û êJr æç Þ ¡ Vh�Bghf ê g3m/deaKn'ghf���¯�c�gYf�� r X�aKf�f�def�iD� u [+V/��ghWhghf�gYWepQn�den�VYX�n�`�gYiaK��T=V[^]�_�`�gY`bdeVf'� � f@�6Ö¦^sH$G¡B©�³�Ö���ÔB"z&3��Ô�¢�|£��[¤¦¥ ! �,�B�¨§[�[¤k¥©�¢�Bªs��¶h¨¸Ó«$�Ö¦ ! �K´�¦�³3´ Ó�øe©Kª�Ö#s ! �bÖ�×���§¨�¨¢´ ¦×K�'§\¦×\ØQ§3ש=ª�� !�¬(! �b­ ®G¯°�;��µY$ ! ©�Aµ�©���ª"�@Ø%�-×6±l©�§\³�Õ��²�F�F�6³,�%���("[´Pµ°"R' � §¦~´°®G®G¯\t�]�gYiaKn y\x éÂ� y \Ý�� u ZBj r cbaKn�n@tD¬la=� r V\cb��t v æ\æç��

Û êJr S�æ� Þ �V[¶a=WoWea ê a=nb]DaKp/cbV_���tB¯�c�gYf�� r X�aKf�f�def�i�t�ghf��ÚZBghcbn�`baKf�S/T�UF¶_�cb[�gYf�f'� r c�do[+de`bdema:c�aKTK_�c�nbdeVfíX�V\c¢U�dei\U�aKcq�Vcb��aKc�gYs�nb`�c�ghT=`lnbp/f/`�gY��� � f ¡ �%ãldef���Woa=pQt/aK��do`�Vc3t ! �bÖ3³�©�©�Ô´ ¦×hª�Ö�s�µoÕ�©@ª�Õ�´»��Ô¢¤�¦�µ-©��K¦�§µ-´�Ö\¦�§hø;�6Ö¦^sK©G��©@¦�³�©Ö¦8ªD¶�Ó�©�ÔL�#§¨k��Ô§l�6§høe³@Ø\øoØ\ª:§¦�ÔS��Ó\Ó�øe´�³�§µ-´�Ö¦/ªK·¦ªi�¨�|�@­ ®¹¸Yºt�]�gYiaKn v ·3Â� v ç z t�¬�gYf�TKp/t1¯�c�gYf�TKat u ]�cbdeWv ææ���S�]�cbdef�i\aKcq�%q6aKc�WÎgYi¢­�¬JZBS�� u f:aK�/`baKf���aK�;maKc�nbdeVf+don�g3mghdeW�ghs�Wea�gYn��7aKT�U�f�deT@gYW ¡ aK]DVcb`BZBj;k¸� ZBS\�bæçP�v y t�ZBghc�f�aKidea�j;aKWeWeVf+klf�dem\aKcbn�do`qp/�

Ûܯ7j°ææ Þ j;aKWem/dof�¯'de`�`bdef�i°ghf�� ¡ deT�U�ghc���­���j aKf���aKWen�VU�f'�K��´»��ªKµ�A ¬ �bÔ©��B£�Ö3Ô§høF�'Ö�×´ ³@��c�We_/��aKc u T@gY��aK[^deT r _�s/�Woden�U�aKcbn3t v æææ��

ÛÜñ�ghsDÝÝ Þ j;_�cb��VQT�U����Dñ�ghs�sDg3pQ�;�dª�Õ�©�Ö��=¶^Ö#sb¤�¦�ÔØ/³@µ-´�÷3©6»�©Y¼6¦�´�µ-´�Ö\¦/ªÔ��´�µoÕ´�½Ap ��@Ø/´�÷3§høe©@¦�³�©3� r U ê `bU�a=nbden@t'ZBgY[:�s�cbde��i\a�k�f�demaKc�nbde`qp/t u _�i\_�nb` y ÝÝÝ��

ÛÜñ r Ý v�Þ j;_�cb��VQT�UM�D�1ñ�gYs�s�g3p£gYf�� u f���cbaK��j�� r de`b`�n@� u f�aK�wgh]�]�c�VQgYT�U�`�V£ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�nbp/f/`�gY�°�Bde`bU�mgYcbd�ghs�Weas�def���def�i��]�#Ö��K¨�§hø%��ª-Ó�©�³3µ�ªBÖ#sb�6Ö¨¸Ó�Ø/µ�´ ¦×t y ÝÝ v ��S/]DaKTKd�gYW�denbnb_�aBdof�U�V\f�V_�c7VYX ¡ V/��û�_�c�nb`�ghWeWq�h�7V�gh]�]�a@gYc@�

ÛÜñJcbd�é\æ Þ u f���c�a@ghn:ñJc�doa=�ÌgYf����°�lf u _�`�V[;gh`bdeT ê d�ä�aKcbaKf/`�dÎgY`bdeVf#� � fÒj�� � c�dlghf��Ýc:�#�6ghf�gYs�at#aK��de`�Vcbn3tO£�§µeÕ�©�A¨¢§\µ�´�³�§Yø ! ��Ö�×��b§\¨¢¨�´�¦×z¾B¡B©�³�©@¦�µ(»�©3÷@©=øoÖ Ó�¨�©@¦�µ ª:§¦�ÔK��Ó\Ó�øe´�³�§µ-´�Ö¦/ªKtD]�gYiaKnJé z � v Ý\é���cJWe_Q��aKc u T@gY��aK[^deTr _�s�WedenbU�a=cbn@t v æ\éæ��

Û cJcbd�éÝ Þ S�gh_�W u ��cJcbde]��\a�(��§\¨¢´ ¦×^§\¦�ÔK��©�³�©Kª�ªK´�µ-¶h�RãJghc�mghcb�;k�f�demaKc�nbde`qp r c�aKnbn3t v æé\Ý��ÛÜ­'­#æç Þ r a=`baKc£­®aKa�ghf��«j°ghc���­�aKV\f�a����]�`�de[^deåKdef�i�j°­��Bdo`�U�cb_�f/��`�de[^a;TKV/��a�ia=f�aKc�gY`bdeVf#� � fC�[¤k¥ ! �|�.�

�6Ö¦tsK©��b©3¦�³�©�Ö¦ ! ��Ö�×��b§\¨¢¨�´�¦×b�'§\¦×Ø/§3ש6»%©KªK´Ù×\¦£§\¦�Ô�¤�¨¸Ó�øe©@¨�©@¦�µ�§\µ�´�Ö\¦�t/]�gYiaKn v3z �� v ·/é�t v ææ\ç��

z

Page 40: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

ÛÜj;deW�æÝ Þ ê gYWea¢j;deWeWoa=c@� u f£aK�/`�aKf�nbdeV\f£`�V�j°­î`bV^UDghf���Wea�sDV_�f��£mgYcbd�ghs�Woa=nBdof���gh`�g:nb`�cb_�T=`b_�c�aKn@� � f ! ��Ö@³�©�©�Ô´�¦\×hªÖ#s�µeÕ�©��'Ö�×\´�³�§hø}� �b§¨�©��6Ö��0¿Yª�±À¡;�?Á+Ö��0¿YªbÕ�Ö Ó�t�j�g3p v æ\æÝ��

ÛÜj;�BûBS�ææ Þ ï7_�ia=f�deV¢j;Vi\idqt\¤HghWede���6ghU�g�t%ÂDdef�a��bï7W�� u s�de��def�aBû�aKf�gYdon�n�g�t�ghf��+�Bdo[óS/U�a@gYcb�'� u f+de��a@ghWedeåKaK�^j aK`�g\j°­6�S/de[^]�WeaKc3tQgYf��^[+Vcba�aK�/]�cba=nbnbdem\a� � fà¸Ø3��Ö�Ó�©�§¦S��¶h¨¸Ó�ÖhªK´�Ø/¨ÍÖ¦ ! �bÖ�×���§¨�¨¢´�¦\×t/]�gYiaKn v æ z � y Ý��t v æ\ææ��

Û ¬ldea@Ý v�Þ j;deT�UDghaKW'¯#WeVc�aKf/`bdef;¬ldeaKWenbaKf#�6Z�V[:s�def�def�iJTKWeVn�a¢ghf���V\]�a=f�T=VQ��a�6k�f�]�_�s�WedenbU�aK�'t y Ý\Ý v �ÛÜ����a@æh· Þ j°ghc�`bdefè����aKc�nb�/pQ� u X�_�f�TK`bdeV\f�ghW�`bU�aKV\cbp�VYX¢WeV/T@ghW�f�gh[+aKn@� � f ! ��Ö@³�©�©�Ô´�¦×Yª£Ö�s@"[´3ªKµ6�J¦�¦�Ø/§høB�¢�|£

�[¤¦¥(�¢�Bª,Av�[¤k¥ ! �|�B�Ä��¶h¨¸Ó�ÖYªK´�Ø/¨ Ö\¦ ! �K´�¦�³3´ ÓDøo©=ª^Ö#s ! ��Ö�×��b§\¨¢¨�´�¦×S�#§¦×\Ø/§@×\©Kª@· !#¬©! �¹ºt']Dghia=n¢·/é��x æ�t/¬�aK� r Vc���t/¬ r t�k�S u t v ææY·�� u ZBj r c�aKnbn3�

Û r6ê Ý v Þ ¯�c�ghf�� r X�aKf�f�dof�i�ghf�� ¡ Vh�ÌgYf ê g3m/deaKn3� u � _���i[+aKf/`�gYW�cbaKTKV\f�nb`�cb_�T=`bdeVf�VhX6[^V/��gYW�WeVideT�À£�§µeÕ�©3¨¢§\µ�´�³�§Yø��µ��=ØQ³3µ-Ø3��©KªJ´�¦��6Ö¨¸Ó�Ø/µ-©G�¨��³@´ ©@¦�³�©3t v\v � x�v\v � x ·QÝ�t y ÝÝ v �D¬lV\`baKnB`�V¥gYf^def/mQde`�aK�^`�ghWe�¥gY`�`�U�a~Á+Ö��0¿YªbÕ�Ö Ó�Ö¦¤�¦�µ-Ø/´�µ�´ Ö¦�´eªKµ-´�³B£�Ö3Ô§høi�'Ö�×\´�³Kª�§\¦�ÔK��ÓÓDøo´�³�§\µ�´�Ö\¦/ª:Ï � j°­ u �Üææ Ð t/�7cbaKf/`�V�t � `�gYWepQtz�_�Wep v ææ\æ��

Û r ï6é\é Þ ¯�c�ghf�� r X�aKf�f�def�i£ghf��HZ�Vf�gYW�ï7WeWedoV\`b`3��ã�doi\U�aKc ��V\cb��aKc:ghs�nb`bc�ghTK`�nbp/f/`�gY��� � f ! �bÖ3³�©�©�Ô\´�¦×Yª^Ö#s^µeÕ�©K�¢�|£�[¤¦¥ ! �,�B�N­ ÅzÅM��¶h¨BÓ�ÖhªK´�Ø/¨ðÖ\¦��#§¦×\Ø/§@×\©J»%©KªK´Ù×\¦Ú§¦�Ôx¤�¨¸Ó�øo©3¨�©@¦�µ-§µ-´�Ö\¦�t6]�gYiaKn v æ\æ�� y Ýé�t u `�W�ghf/`�g�tñJaKVc�id�g�tz�_�f�a v æ\éé��

Û r ñ�Ý\Ý Þ u f���c�aK�èj�� r de`b`�nÌgYf��^j;_�c���V/T�UL���/ñ�gYs�s�g3p/� u [^aK`�ghW�ghf�i\_�ghi\a7X�V\c6]�cbV\ic�gh[^[+def�iB�Bde`bU:sDV_�f��+f�gh[+aKn[^V/��_�WeV�cbaKf�gY[^def�iD� � f ¡ �DûÌgYT��/U�V\_�nba^gYf��@�D��¬��'��Wedom\aKdec�g�t�aK��de`�Vcbn3t|£�§µeÕ�©3¨¢§\µ�´ ³Kª:Ö#s ! �bÖ�×��b§¨d�6Ö\¦]Aª µ�KØ/³3µ�´�Ö\¦]�²£ ! �F"]ÆGÆGÆ°� ! �bÖ3³�©�©�Ô´ ¦×hª�� ! Ö¦�µ�©:Ô\©6�6´�¨�§P� ! Ö��Kµ-ØhקYøÇ� � Ø\øe¶¢"%ÆGÆzÆtDmV\We_�[^a v é z �VYXO�'©�³3µ�Ø%�b©��Öµ-©=ª�´ ¦M�6Ö¨¸Ó�Ø/µ-©G�.��³3´�©3¦�³�©@t�]�ghi\aKn yz Ý�� y\xx �QS/]�cbdef�ia=cq�%q6aKcbW�gYi�t%ãla=do��aKWes�aKc�i�t y ÝÝ\Ý��

Û r de`�Ý v�Þ u f���c�aK�èj�� r de`b`bn3�D¬lV[+def�ghW\WoV\ideT� u ��cbn�`�V\cb��aKc�`bU�aKV\cbp:VYX�f�gY[^aKn6gYf��¢s�dof���def�i�� � f:¬�ghV\�/d�cJVs�g3p/ghnbU�dghf��íû�aKf3�Kgh[+dof�ZJ� r deaKc�TKat�aK��de`bV\cbn3tmª]�¢�F��t#mVWe_�[+a y\y�v3x VhXI�#©�³@µ-Ø%�b©K��Ö\µ�©=ª�´�¦s�6Ö¨¸Ó�Ø/µ-©G����³3´�©3¦�³�©@t]�ghi\aKn y�v æ�� y · y �QS/]�cbdef�ia=c@t y ÝÝ v �

Û ¡ V\å@æ zPÞ ñJ_�deWeWoa=cb[^VS�D� ¡ V\å@ghn3���7c�gYf�nbWe_�T=aKf/`^]�c�VQT=aK��_�c�aKn@tJghs�n�`bc�ghTK`�doV\f��Bde`bU�V\_�`:V]DghTKde`qp/�Ú�1a=T�U�f�deT@ghW ¡ aK]DVc�`ul� � ¡ � v · y �tQj°gYnbn�ghT�U/_�nbaK`�`bn � f�n�`bde`b_�`�aJVhX6�7aKT�U�f�VWeV\ip u c�`bd���TKd�gYW � fQ`�aKWeWedoi\aKf�TKa�­#ghsDVc�gY`bV\cbp/t v ææ z �

Û ¡lr Ý y3Þ ¬lVc�[�gYf ¡ gY[^n�aKp^ghf�� u mQd r X�a�ä�aKc3�lS/`bV/T�U�gYnb`bdeT�W�gY[:s���g�T@ghWeTK_�We_�nlgYf��°[+Vf�gY��n�VYX1]�c�Vs�gYs�deWedo`qp:��don�`bc�dÙ�s�_�`bdeV\f�n@� � f8�6Ö\¦tsH$F¡B©�³�Ö��bÔ�"%®µeÕS�¢�|£��[¤k¥ ! �|�B�¨§[�[¤k¥(�¢�Bª���¶h¨¸Ó«$�Ö¦ ! �K´�¦�³@´ ÓDøo©=ª�Ö#s ! �bÖ�×���§¨�¨¢´ ¦×�'§\¦×Ø/§3ש=ª�� !�¬(! �b­ ÆP"z� ! Ö��Kµ�øe§¦�Ô°� ¬ ¡.�b³|�%�%t/]�ghi\aKn v3x ·f� v ç x th¬�aK� r Vc���t y ÝÝ y � u ZBj r cbaKn�n@�

ÛÜS/U�a@Ý v�Þ �Bdo[ S�U�a@ghc��'� u TKTKV\[^]�WedenbU�[+aKf/`bnlgYf��°cba=nba@gYcbT�UHT�U�gYWoWeaKf�iaKnJdef°[^a=`�g3�q]�c�Vic�gh[+[:dof�i�� � f£¤HgYWedo�+�6ghU�g�taK��de`bV\c@t¹�%�#¤¦¥Bt�m\VWe_�[^a y�v æ\ç�VYX©�#©�³3µ-Ø3��©I�%Öµ-©KªJ´�¦M�6Ö\¨BÓ�ØQµ-©�����³3´�©@¦�³�©3t�]Dghia=n y �Q·\·���S/]�cbdef�ia=c@t y Ý\Ý v �

Û �6ghU�æ\æg Þ ¤HghWede���6gYU�g�� u n�V_�f���c�aK��_�T=`bdeVf�n�aK[�gYfQ`�deTKn�X�Vc�_�fQ`qp/]DaK�HZ�û�¬w[:_�We`bd��qnb`�gYiaJTKV\[^]�_�`�gh`�doV\f'�DVc3t�`bU�a`bU�aKV\cbp+VhX�j;aK`�gj°­�denBf�V\f/��`�cbdemghWq�|�¢�|£D�[¤k¥ ! �|�.�C��Ö\µ�´ ³�©=ªKt z ·DÏ vv3Ð � z ·m�Q· z t v æææ��

Û �6ghU�æ\æhs Þ ¤HghWede�¢�6ghUDg��i£�Øøeµ�´ÈAv��µ�§3ש ! ��Ö�×��b§\¨¢¨�´�¦×z¾;¤�µ�ªKª�Õ�©�Ö��=¶�§¦�Ô¢��Ó\Ó�øo´ ³�§\µ�´ Ö¦/ªK� r U ê `�U�aKnbden3t��lc�aKiV\f°ñJc�gY�/�_�gh`�a � f�nb`bde`�_�`ba�VYX¹S/T=doa=f�TKa¢gYf��;�1a=T�U�f�VWeVi\pQt v æ\ææ��

Û ¤è­ r æé Þ r U�deWedo];¤�deT��/Wedof�at r aK`baKc�­®aKat'gYf��°¯�c�ghf�� r X�a=f�f�def�i�� ¡ _�f/�q`bde[^a�TKV/��a¢i\aKf�aKc�gh`�doV\f£ghf�� j VQ�DghW�� j�­6� � f�[¤¦¥ ! �,�B�d�6Ö\¦tsK©��b©3¦�³�©�Ö\¦ ! �bÖ�×��b§¨�¨�´�¦×L�#§¦\×Ø/§@×\©L»%©KªK´Ù×\¦�§¦�Ôɤ�¨¸Ó�øe©@¨�©3¦�µ�§\µ�´ Ö¦�t#]�ghi\aKn y\y ·f� yz\x tv ææ\é��

Û ¤è­ r�ê æ\é Þ�r U�deWedo]+¤�deT��QWedef�at r aK`ba=c�­�a=at�¯�c�gYf�� r X-aKf�f�def�iDt�ghf�� ¡ Vh�Bghf ê g3m/deaKn@�6j VQ�DghW�`qp/]�a=n�ghnBn�`�gYidef�i�nb]DaKTKd����T@gh`�doV\f�n�X�V\c�c�_�f/�q`bde[^a�TKV/��a�ia=f�aKc�gY`bdeVf#�(�¢�|£Ê�6Ö\¨BÓ�Ø/µ�´�¦\×K��Ø%�K÷3©3¶3ª t z Ý�Ï z a=n Ð t v ææ\é��

c Ë Å¹Æ+Æm�z:

��»3Ï�Ï�� u� <º^»�ð1|6}=~@á-~"ð7~Ká-¾�âý¸J�há-â6�háÅ1ì »�}ż´P$�´ s��Ñ {�É Î Z ^ �hüHÛ§t Þ §¦�Ôà�Ñ {}y T'� ü É Î Z b ��Ì Û t Þ �7µoÕ�©@¦´�Ñ {�É Î Û Z ^"Ñ T ÞÒZ b ��Ì�Û§t Þ $"%$�´ s��Ñ { þ ^ É3Î1Z ^J�hüHÛ¿m Þ §\¦�Ô�Ñ { b y;p �e� ü�Û m Þ�É3ÎPZ b���Ì:Û§t Þ �6µeÕ�©3¦;�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p/Þ�Z bJ��Ì:Û§t Þ $

z é

Page 41: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

&%$�´ s��Ñ { Ó^ É3Î6Z ^l�hüíÛ m Þ §\¦�ÔÏ�Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û¿m ÞôÉ3ÎPZ b���ÌËÛ t Þ �6µeÕ�©3¦;�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z bJ��ÌËÛ t Þ $'[$�´ s� yQ� � V Ñ { ^ É Î Z ^ � V Û§t Þ §¦�Ôà y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É Î Z b ��Ì:Û �(y t Þ �7µoÕ�©@¦K y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É Î 0ÂZ ^NÑ � 2 Z b ��Ì:Û§t Þ $

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ«u WeW�`bU�aJ]�c�V/VhX�nlgYcbaJs/p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;Vf+`bU�a%nb`bc�_�TK`�_�cba�VhX7`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i���aKc�demgh`bdeV\f:X�V\c Z b�¸J�há-â6�háÅ1ì »Ku�ã d�XÔ�Ñ {�É Î Z ^ �hüHÛ§t Þ gYf��d�Ñ {}y T#� ü É Î Z b ��Ì Û§t Þ t`�U�aKfd�Ñ {�É Î Û Z ^"Ñ T Þ�Z b ��Ì�Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b \ h t Z b \ W t Z b \ p Vc Z b \ � ��BU�aKnba�ghcbaJ`�cbdem/dÎgYWqtn�dof�TKa�`bU�a�n�_�s�n�`bde`b_�`�deVf°denJÛ Z ^ Ñ T ÞÒZ b�den�mgYTK_�V_�n@�

T@ghn�a Z b­\�T'�¡ aK��_�TKaKnl`�V:Vf�aJVYX1`bU�a¢ghn�nb_�[+]�`bdeVf�n@�

T@ghn�a Z b­\!± W � Ìc^fj Z t�gYf��ËÌ8\�Ìc^­`ÍÌXb\�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {}y T'� ü y;W �§Ìc^ É3Î6Z ��ÌXb�Û t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ {}y;W �§Ìc^ É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z ��ÌXb�Û t Þ �z ���BU�denBWea@gh��nB`bV:`bU�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK�v�Ñ {�É3Î ± W � Ìc^fj�Û Z ^ Ñ T ÞÒZ ��Ìc^a`ìÌXb6Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ Z"Û�Z¤Û Û �¯�c�V[�`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i���a=cbdemgh`�doV\f�n:X-Vc Z¤Û gYf�� Z¤Û§Û t¸sQp _�nbdef�ií`bU�a�def���_�TK`�deVf�U/p/]�V\`bU�a=nbden@t!�Ñ {øÉ Î Û Z ^"Ñ T ÞÒZ¤Û �Ì Û `ìÌÚÛ t Þ ghf��K�Ñ {�É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T ÞÒZ¤Û Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �'�BU/_�n�X�V\WeWoVh�Bn�`bU�a�c�aKnb_�Wo`3�

T@ghn�a Z b­\�a noW �§Ìij Z �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {}y T'� ü y;W �§Ì É3ÎPZ ��Ì�Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ {}y;W �§Ì É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �z ���BU�denBWea@gh��nB`bV:`bU�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK�v�Ñ {�É3Î a n6W �§ÌijDÛ Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\�Ï |6¾5noZ3Ð ��1c�demQd�gYW�sDaKT@gY_�nbalT ��V/aKnBf�V`BV/TKT=_�cldef Z t�gYf��;nbV:`�U�aJnb_�s�n�`bde`b_�`bdeVfHÛ Z ^ Ñ T Þ�|6¾ nPZ den�mghTK_�V_�n3�

T@ghn�a Z b­\�Ï ì-»/~¢|6¾5nPp1qsZ"Û�á�â�Z¤Û§ÛoÐ �v �B¯�cbV[ý`qpQ]�dof�i¢��a=cbdemgh`�doV\f't/s/p^def���_�TK`bdeVf+U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3ti�Ñ {�É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z¤Û �\ö¢ÏÌ Û Û§t Û Þ Ð Û t Þ �y � u Wen�V:f�V`�doT=a�`�U�gh`3ti�Ñ {}y;p �e� Ì Û Û¿Õ Þ�É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T ÞÒZ¤Û Û ��Ì Û§t Þ V\c��Ñ {IyQp �e�� Ì Û Û§t ÛÜÞôÉ3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z"Û Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ t��aK]�a=f��/�def�i�Vf;�BU�aK`�U�aKc�t Û \7Õ%VcBf�V`@�

z � � f;aKde`bU�a=clT@gYnbat���aJU�g3m\a�`�U�aJcbaKÿ/_�dec�aK�ð�Ñ {FÉ3Î Ï ì-»/~¢|�¾ noprq Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z"Û7á-â Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z¤Û ÛeÐ ��Ì�Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\ � j Z t��BU�aKcbakÌ8\ XY[Z \ Ì Û ghf�� � � V Êd��

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {}y T'� ü É Î Z ��Ì Û Û§t Þ gYf�� wòÉ� ªÅ ÏÌ Û�Ð � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ {�É Î Û Z ^QÑ T Þ�Z ��Ì Û Û§t Þ tz ��nbV:��a6��_�n�`Bcba@gYnbnba=[:s�Wea=�Ñ {�É3ÎP� j�Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z ��Ï XY[Z \ Ì Û Ð Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ Z��á� t��BU�aKc�a � � V Êð��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {}y T'� ü É3ÎPZ ��Ï XYØZ \ Ì Ð Û§t Þ ghf�� wOÉ ªÅ Ï�Ì Ð � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ {�É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z ��Ï XYØZ \ Ì Ð Û§t Þ tz ��nbVl� _�nb`Bc�a@ghn�nbaK[:s�Wea��Ñ {FÉ3Î ÏbÛ Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z3Ð���� ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ â7»Q½ � � Vwá-âoZ �

z æ

Page 42: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {}y T#� ü É3Î.Ù Y Z ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ ghf�� w � �cÉ Ì:Û§t Þ � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ {zÉ Î.Ù Y Û Z ^NÑ T Þ�Z ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ tz ��nbV^gYnbn�aK[:s�Weals�gYT��^def/`bV�Ñ {�É3Îîâ1»/½ � � Vóá-â Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z ��Ì�Û§t Þ t

T@ghn�a Z b­\ `CY ���j Z t��BU�aKc�alÌ8\ ]3Y ��Fj�Ì Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {}y T'� ü É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü8Z ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ {�É Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü Û Z ^"Ñ T Þ�Z ��Ì Û Û§t Þ tz ��nbV:��aJ��aKc�dom\a�`bU�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK�v�Ñ {�É3Π`CY ���j/Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z �DÏ ]3Y ���jfÌ Û�Ð Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ Z Û Û¿m Þ Þ �BU�aKc�alÌ8\�Û m Ñ Y/Þ Ì Û �v ��û�p�`qp/]�def�iJ��aKcbdemgY`bdeVf'tW�Ñ {}y T'� ü É3ÎPZ ��Ï ]3Y ���jfÌ Û�Ð Û t Þ t w�É m����îtQgYf��àm8' ¿#¾(Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾�Ï Ï w:Ð �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ {�É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z ��Ï ]%Y ���j�Ì Û�Ð Û§t Þ tz �Bghf��^X-VWeWeVh�Bn6`bU�a%cbaKÿ/_�decba=�F�Ñ {�É Î Û Z ^NÑ T Þ�Z Û Û¿m Þ Þ ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ì Û�Ð Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ 0Â� j\ Z¤Û 2 Z¤Û§Û t��BU�aKc�a � � V ÊF��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {}y T'� ü É Î Z¤Û � V Û§t Þ ghf��F�Ñ {}y T'� ü É Î Z¤Û§Û ��ÌÚÛ �(y t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ {�É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z"Û � V Û§t Þ gYf��p�Ñ {�É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z¤Û Û ��Ì�Û �(y t Þ tz ��nbV�X-VWeWeVh�Bn6`bU�a%f�aKaK��a=�°cbaKn�_�We`��Ñ {�É3Î<0f� j\ Ï�Û Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z"ÛeÐ 2:ÏbÛ Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z"Û ÛoÐ �

T@ghn�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i%X�c�V[ Ì Û ���3ÌË�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {}y T'� ü É3ÎPZ bJ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ {�É Î Û Z ^QÑ T Þ�Z b ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �z ��kln�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i:`bV�TKVf�TKWe_���atH�Ñ {�É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T ÞÒZ b��3ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\�Ï �Y��}K»áZ Ù ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z¤Û6»/ì�}=»�Z"Û§Û�Ð �v ��û�p�`qp/]�def�i:��aKcbdemgh`�deVf'tH�Ñ {áÉ3Î�Z Ù �/ö�Ï V Û¿m Þ�Ð Û§t Þ t�ghf��d�Ñ�| g�Îne � V Û¿m Þ \ih { ^�ghf��v�Ñ {}y;{ ^ É3Î�Z¤Û �

Ì�Û§t Þ t/ghf��K�Ñ {�É3Î1Z"Û§Û �3ÌÚÛ§t Þ �y ��û�p£def���_�TK`bdeVf�U/p/]DV`bU�aKnbden@t��Ñ {�É Î Û Z ^QÑ T Þ�Z Ù �1ö�Ï V Û¿m Þ Ð Û t Þ t�gYf��ý�Ñ {IyQ{ ^ É Î Û Z ^QÑ T Þ�Z"Û �CÌÚÛ§t Þ t'gYf���Ñ {FÉ Î Û Z ^"Ñ T Þ�Z"Û Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �z ��¬lVh����_�n�`lghn�nbaK[:s�Wea�s�ghT��^def/`bV�`bU�a�cbaKÿ/_�dec�aK�;cbaKn�_�We`@tD_�nbdef�i�`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i¢c�_�Wea�X�Vc �h��}=» �

¸J�há-â6�háÅ1ì »;¹�ã d�XÔ�Ñ { þ ^ É Î Z ^ �hüHÛ¿m Þ ghf��d�Ñ { b y;p �e� ü�Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Z b ��ÌËÛ t Þ t\`bU�aKfð�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î Û Z ^QÑ p/Þ�Z b ��Ì:Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\ h t Z bX\�T#t Z b­\ p Û t�Vc Z b­\ � ��1c�demQd�gYW�tYnbdef�TKa�`�U�aJnb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf�Û Z ^NÑ p/Þ�Z b denBmgYTK_�V_�n@�

T@ghn�a Z b­\ p t/�BU�aKcbalÌ8\ ü ghf��Fm8'�t:�v ��û�p^U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�denl��a@gh�\aKf�def�i�t��Ñ { þ ^ É3Î1Z ^l�hüíÛ m Þ de[^]�WedeaKn>�Ñ { ^ É3ÎPZ ^��YüHÛ¿m Þy �Bghf���`�U�aKfd�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î Z ^ �hüHÛ§t Þ t\_�nbdef�i�s�V\`bU;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den�ghf�����aK]�a=f���aKf�T=p°��a3gh�a=f�def�i��

T@ghn�a Z b­\!± W � Ìc^fj Z t��BU�a=cbalÌ8\�ÌØ^a`ÍÌÀb�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞªyQW �§Ìc^ É3ÎPZ ��ÌXb�Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b y;W �§Ìc^ É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�ÞÒZ ��ÌXb6Û§t Þ �z ��¬lVh�«ghn�nbaK[:s�Woa�s�ghT��K�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î ± W � ÌØ^Âj�Û Z ^ Ñ p/Þ�Z ��ÌØ^*`ÍÌXb�Û§t Þ �

·QÝ

Page 43: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

T@ghn�a Z b­\ Z Û Z Û Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Z¤Û Ì Û `ÍÌ�Û§t Þ ghf��F�Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Z¤Û§Û Ì Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z"Û ��Ì Û `ÍÌ Û t Þ gYf��d�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z"Û Û ��Ì Û Û t Þ �z ��¤�aJf�Vh�£��_�nb`lghn�nbaK[:s�Woa�s�ghT��K�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î Û Z ^QÑ p�Þ�Z"Û Û Z ^QÑ p/Þ�Z¤Û Û Û§Ì Þ Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\�a noW �§Ìij Z �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞªyQW �§Ì É Î Z ��ÌÚÛ t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b y;W �§Ì É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z ��Ì�Û§t Þ �z ��¬lVh�«ghn�nbaK[:s�Woa�s�ghT��K�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î ± W � ÌijDÛ Z ^;Ñ p�ÞÒZ ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ |6¾ n6Z t/�BU�a=cbalÌ8\!ö�Ï�Ì Û Û§t Û Þ�Ð �

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { Ób y;p �e� ü�Û m Þ�É3ÎPZ ��Ì Û Û§t Û Þ �y ��û�aKT@gh_�nba { þ ^ \ { þ�þ^ t/��a�U�g3m\a��Ñ { þ�þ^ É3Î1Z ^J�hüHÛ¿m Þ �z �B¯�cbV[ Ï v@Ð t'Ï yÐ ghf��;`bU�a�def���_�TK`�deVf^U/p/]DV`bU�aKnbden@tH�Ñ { þ ^ y;{ Ób É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ T ÞÒZ ��Ì Û Û§t Û Þ �·���û�p�­�a=[^[�g x ti�Ñ { Ó^ y;{ Ób É Î Û Z ^QÑ T Þ�Z ��Ì Û Û§t Û Þ tx �Bghf��^�Df�ghWeWepQt\��a�T3ghf;cba@gYnbn�aK[:s�Wea��Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î�|6¾ n ÏbÛ Z ^ Ñ T Þ�Z3Ð �\ö¢ÏÌ Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ t

T@ghn�a Z b \ ì�»/~�|6¾ nP�áqçZ"Û6á-âoZ¤Û§Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ3Î6Z¤Û �ö�Ï�Ì Û Û t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þy � u Wen�V¢s/p:`qp/]�def�i���a=cbdemgh`�doV\f't\aKde`bU�aKc��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞªyQ� �e� Ì Û É3ÎPZ Û§Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ Vc��Ñ { b y;p �e� ü�Û m Þªy;� �e�� Ì Û Û§t Û ÞôÉ3Î

Z¤Û§Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ t\��aK]DaKf���def�i:�BU�aK`bU�a=cØt�\�Õ�V\cXt �\�Õ��z ��û�p£Ï v3Ð ghf��;def���_�TK`bdeVf+U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z"Û �ö�ÏÌ Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ·���û�p�Ï yÐ ghf��Hdef���_�T=`bdeVfíUQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden3t>�Ñ { ^ y;{ b yQ� �o� Ì Û�É Î Û Z ^QÑ p/Þ�Z¤Û Û �}Ì Û t Þ Vc�Ñ { ^ y;{ b y;� �e�� Ì Û Û§t Û Þ�É ÎÛ Z ^"Ñ p�Þ�Z"Û Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

x �Bï7de`bU�aKcl�Bg3pQt���_�n�`lghn�nbaK[:s�Wea�s�ghT��p�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î�ì-»/~�|6¾ n6��q Û Z ^ Ñ p�ÞÒZ¤Û7á�â Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z"Û Û ��Ì Û t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\ � j Z"Û t/�BU�aKc�alÌ8\ XY[Z \ Ì Û gYf�� � � V Êð��

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ3Î6Z Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ ghf�� w�É ªÅ Ï�Ì Û Ð � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É Î Û Z ^"Ñ p�Þ�Z"Û ��ÌÚÛ t Þ �z ���BU/_�n@t�cba@gYnbn�aK[:s�Weat��Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î1� j�ÏbÛ Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z"ÛeÐ ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ Z"ÛW�á� t/�BU�aKcba � � V ÊF��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ3Î6Z ��Ï XY[Z \ Ì Ð Û§t Þ t/ghf�� wOÉ ªÅ Ï�Ì Ð � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z ��Ï XY[Z \ Ì Ð Û§t Þ tz ��nbV�X-VWeWeVh�Bn6`bU�a%cbaKÿ/_�decba=�ð�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î Ï�Û Z ^"Ñ p�ÞÒZ3Ð���� ��Ì Û t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ â7»Q½ � � Vwá-âoZ¤Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ3Î.Ù Y Z"Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ t/ghf�� w � �cÉ Ì:Û§t Þ � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î.Ù Y Û Z ^ Ñ p�ÞÒZ¤Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ tz �Bghf���`�U�aKf;`bU�a�cbaKÿ/_�dec�aK�ð�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î â7»/½ � � Vóá�â Û Z ^QÑ p�Þ�Z"Û ��ÌÚÛ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ `CY ���j Z¤Û t��BU�aKc�alÌ8\ ]%Y ���jfÌ Û �

· v

Page 44: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_ÜòZ Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü Û Z ^QÑ p/Þ�Z¤Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ tz �Bghf���`�U�aKf;`bU�a�cbaKÿ/_�dec�aK�'ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3ÎÝ`�Y ��FjQÛ Z ^ Ñ p/Þ�Z¤Û ��Ï ]3Y ���j�Ì ÛÎÐ Û t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ Z"Û Û Û¿m ÛÜÞ Þ t\�BU�aKcbakÌò\«Û¿m Û Ñ Y�Þ Ì Û �v ��û�p°`qp/]�def�i:��aKc�domgY`bdeVf#t �Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞêÉ3ÎHZ"Û �'Ï ]%Y ���jfÌ Û-Ð Û§t Þ t wMÉ m Û �Ã�ðghf��vm Û ' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5¿#¾�Ï Ï w:Ð �

y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É Î Û Z ^"Ñ p�Þ�Z"Û ��Ï ]3Y ���jfÌ Û�Ð Û§t Þ tz ��nbV^gYnbn�aK[:s�Weals�gYT��^def/`bV�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p/Þ�Z¤Û Û Û m Û Þ Þ ��Ï�Û m Û Ñ Y/Þ Ì ÛoÐ Û t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ 0Â� j\ Z¤Û 2 Z¤Û§Û t��BU�aKc�a � � V ÊF��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ3Î6Z¤Û � V Û t Þ ghf��d�Ñ { b y;p �o� ü�Û¿m ÞôÉ3ÎPZ¤Û§Û ��Ì Û �(y t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z"Û � V Û§t Þ t/ghf��d�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p/Þ�Z¤Û Û ��Ì�Û �(y t Þ �z � u n�nbaK[:s�WoaJs�gYT��^def/`bV�`bU�aJcba=ÿQ_�doc�aK�ð�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î<0Â� j\ Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z"Û 2^Û Z ^ Ñ p/Þ�Z¤Û Û �%ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

T@ghn�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i%X�c�V[ Ì Û ���3ÌË�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b yQp �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Z b ��Ì Û Û t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ�Z bJ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �z ��kln�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i:`bV�TKVf�TKWe_���atH�Ñ { ^ y;{ËÉ Î Û Z ^"Ñ p�Þ�Z b ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\�Ï �Y��}K»áZ Ù ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z¤Û6»/ì�}=»�Z"Û§Û�Ð �v ��û�p^��aKc�demgh`bdeV\f't��Ñ { b y;p �e� ü�Û m Þ�É Î Z Ù �ö�Ï V Û m Û Þ�Ð Û§t Þ tQgYf��d�Ñ�| g Î e � V Û¿m Û�Þ \ih {�Û gYf���Ñ { b y;p �o� ü�Û¿m Þ�y;{�Û(É Î Z¤Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ t/ghf��d�Ñ { b y;p �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Z¤Û§Û ��Ì Û§t Þ �

y ��û�pHdef���_�T=`bdeVfíUQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden3t>�Ñ { þ ^ y;{ b É Î Û Z ^QÑ p/Þ�Z Ù ��ö�Ï V Û¿m Û Þ Ð Û t Þ t6gYf��:�Ñ { þ ^ y;{ b yQ{EÛXÉ Î Û Z ^QÑ p�Þ�Z"Û �Ì�Û§t Þ t/ghf��K�Ñ { þ ^ y;{ b É Î Û Z ^NÑ p/Þ�Z¤Û Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ �z ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i�cb_�WeaJX�V\c �Y��}=» tH�Ñ { þ ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ p�Þ Ï �h�D}K»�Z Ù ¾� J|6¾ n�e h Z"Û6»/ìq}K»�Z¤Û§Û�Ð ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

¸J�há-â6�háÅ1ì »;Ç�ã d�XÔ�Ñ { Ó^ É3Î1Z ^J�hüHÛ¿m Þ ghf��F�Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞRÉ3ÎPZ bJ��Ì:Û§t Þ t/`�U�aKfð�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z b��%Ì:Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b \ h t Z b \�T#t Z b \ p V\c Z b \ � ��1c�demQd�gYW�n�dof�TKaJ`bU�a�n�_�s�n�`bde`b_�`�deVf�Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z b�denBmghTK_�V_�n3�

T@ghn�a Z b \!± W � Ì ^ j Z t��BU�a=cbalÌ8\�Ì ^ `ÍÌ b �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m Þªy;W �§Ìc^ É3Î6Z ��ÌXb�Û t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b y;W �§Ìc^ É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z ��ÌXb�Û§t Þ tz �Bghf���`�U/_�n��Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î ± W � ÌØ^ÂjDÛ Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z ��Ìc^­`ÍÌXb�Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ Z"Û�Z¤Û Û �

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞRÉ3ÎPZ Û'��ÌØÛô`ÍÌ Û§t Þ gYf��d�Ñ { b y v �e�� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ3Î6Z Û§Û#��ÌcÛ/Û t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É Î Û Z ^"Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û ��Ì Û `ÍÌÚÛ§t Þ ghf��p�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î Û Z ^QÑ v Þ�Z"Û§Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �z ���BU/_�n�X�V\WoWeVh�Bn�`bU�aJc�aKnb_�We`!�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î ÏbÛ Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z"ÛeÐ ÏbÛ Z ^ Ñ v ÞÒZ¤Û ÛoÐ ��Ì Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\�a noW �§Ìij Z �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m Þªy;W �§Ì É3ÎPZ ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

· y

Page 45: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b y;W �§Ì É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z �%ÌÚÛ t Þ tz �Bghf���`�U/_�n��Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î ± W � Ìùj�Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z ��ÌÚÛ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ |6¾ n6Z"Û t/�BU�aKc�alÌ8\!ö¢ÏÌ Û Û§t Û Þ�Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { Ób y v �e� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Z"Û ��Ì Û Û t ÛÜÞ �y ��û�aKT@gh_�nba { Ó^ \ { Ó þ^ t�s/p+`bU�a�]�cba=mQdeV\_�nbWep^]�cbVhma=�°nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf�]�cbdef�TKde]�Wea:Ï�­®aK[^[;g v Ý�� yÐ tH�Ñ { Ó^ yQ{ Ób É ÎÛ Z ^"Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û ��Ì Û Û§t Û Þ �

z ��¬lVh�«ghn�nbaK[:s�Woa�s�ghT��+dof/`�Và�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É Î |6¾ n Ï�Û Z ^"Ñ v Þ�Z¤ÛoÐ �ö�ÏÌ Û Û t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b \ ì�»/~�|6¾ nP�áqçZ"Û6á-âoZ¤Û§Û �

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞRÉ3ÎPZ¤Û �ö�ÏÌ Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þy ��û�p°`qp/]�def�i:��aKc�domgY`bdeVf#t�aKde`bU�aKc��Ñ { b y v �o�� ü�Û¿m Þ�y;� �e� Ì ÛCÉ Î Z"Û Û � ÌÚÛ§t Þ Vc!�Ñ { b y v �o�� ü¢Û¿m ÞªyQ� �e�� Ì Û Û§t ÛÜÞCÉ Î Z"Û§Û �

Ì�Û§t Þ t\��aK]DaKf���def�i:�BU�aK`bU�a=c�t Û \�Õ�Vc­t Û��\�Õ�tz ��û�p£Ï v3Ð ghf��;def���_�TK`bdeVf+U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É Î Û Z ^"Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û �ö�Ï�Ì Û Û§t Û Þ Ð Û t Þ·���û�pèÏ y\Ð gYf��Údef���_�TK`�deVfHU/p/]DV`bU�aKnbden@t��Ñ { ^ yQ{ b yQ� �e� Ì ÛUÉ Î Û Z ^QÑ v ÞÒZ¤Û Û �*Ì Û§t Þ V\cà�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b y;� �e�� Ì Û Û t Û ÞØÉ ÎÛ Z ^"Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

x � � f;aKde`bU�a=clT@gYnbat���aJia=`B`bU�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK�v�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É^ì-»/~¢|�¾ nP�áq Û Z ^QÑ v Þ�Z¤Û1á-â Û Z ^"Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û Û ��ÌÚÛ t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b \ � j Z"Û t/�BU�aKc�alÌ8\ XY[Z \ Ì Û gYf�� � � V Êð��

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞRÉ3ÎPZ¤Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ gYf�� wòÉ� ªÅ ÏÌ Û�Ð � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �z � ¡ a3ghnbn�aK[:s�Wealdef/`bVDt��Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î6� j�Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û ��Ï XY[Z \ Ì Û�Ð Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ Z"ÛW�á� t/�BU�aKcba � � V ÊF��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞRÉ Î Z¤Û ��Ï XY[Z \ Ì Ð Û t Þ ghf�� wòÉ� ªÅ ÏÌ Ð � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û ��Ï XYØZ \ Ì Ð Û§t Þz �Bghf���`�U�aKfd�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î ÏbÛ Z ^NÑ v ÞÒZ¤ÛoÐ-��� ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ â7»Q½ � � Vwá-âoZ¤Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ { b y v �e�� ü¢Û¿m ÞRÉ3Î.Ù Y Z¤Û ��ÌÚÛ t Þ ghf�� w � �UÉ Ì:Û§t Þ � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É Î.Ù Y Û Z ^;Ñ v Þ�Z"Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ �z �BZ�Vf�TKWe_���a��Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î â1»/½ � � Výá-â Û Z ^"Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û �3ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ `CY ���j Z¤Û t��BU�aKc�alÌ8\ ]%Y ���jfÌ Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞRÉ3Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü8Z¤Û �3Ì Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z"Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �z �BZ�Vf�TKWe_���a��Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î `CY ���j/Û Z ^"Ñ v Þ�Z Û��DÏ ]%Y ���jfÌcÛ Ð Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ Z"Û Û Û¿m ÛÜÞ Þ t\�BU�aKcbakÌò\«Û¿m Û Ñ Y�Þ Ì Û �v ��û�p°`qp/]�def�i:��aKc�domgY`bdeVf#ti�Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞCÉ3Î�Z¤Û �'Ï ]%Y ���jfÌ Û�Ð Û§t Þ t w:É m Û �Ã��t�gYf��ðm Û ' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5¿#¾�Ï Ï w:Ð �

y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û ��Ï ]%Y ���jfÌ Û-Ð Û§t Þ �z �B¯�cbV[ýU�aKcba\t���aJT@ghf;c�a@ghn�nbaK[:s�Weat��Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Ï�Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z"ÛeÐ Û Û¿m ÛÜÞ Þ ��ÏbÛ¿m Û Ñ Y/Þ Ì ÛeÐ Û§t Þ �

· z

Page 46: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

T@ghn�a Z b­\ 0Â� j\ Z Û 2 Z Û§Û t��BU�aKc�a � � V ÊF��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞRÉ Î Z¤Û � V Û§t Þ ghf��F�Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞRÉ Î Z¤Û§Û ��ÌÚÛ �(y t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û � V Û t Þ t/ghf��F�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z¤Û Û ��Ì�Û �(y t Þ �z � u n�nbaK[:s�WoaJs�gYT��^def/`bV�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É3Î<0Â� j\«Ï�Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z"ÛeÐ 2^Ï�Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ�Z"Û Û�Ð ��Ì�Û§t Þ

T@ghn�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i%X�c�V[ Ì Û ���3ÌË�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü�Û m ÞRÉ3ÎPZ bJ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ { ^ yQ{ b É Î Û Z ^"Ñ v Þ�Z b ��Ì Û Û t Þ �z ��kln�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i:`bV�TKVf�TKWe_���atH�Ñ { ^ y;{ b É Î Û Z ^NÑ v Þ�Z b ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \�Ï �Y��}K»áZ Ù ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z¤Û6»/ì�}=»�Z"Û§Û�Ð �v ��û�p^��aKc�demgh`bdeV\f't��Ñ { b y v �e�� ü¢Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Z Ù �\ö¢Ï V Û¿m Û�Þ Ð Û t Þ t\ghf��d�ÑG| g Î e � V Û m Û�Þ \ih {�Û ghf���Ñ { b y v �e�� ü¢Û¿m ÞªyQ{EÛ�É Î Z¤Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ tQgYf��d�Ñ { b y v �o�� ü�Û¿m ÞôÉ Î Z"Û§Û ��ÌÚÛ t Þ �

y ��û�p�def���_�TK`�deVfJU/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3tâ�Ñ { Ó^ yQ{ b É Î Û Z ^QÑ v Þ�Z Ù �ö�Ï V Û¿m Û�Þ�Ð Û§t Þ tKghf��Ï�Ñ { Ó^ y;{ b y;{�Û(É Î Û Z ^;Ñ v Þ�Z"Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ tghf��F�Ñ { Ó^ y;{ b É Î Û Z ^NÑ v ÞÒZ¤Û Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ �z ��û�p^`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i¢c�_�Wea�X�Vc �Y��}K» t��Ñ { Ó^ y;{ b É3Î Û Z ^ Ñ v Þ Ï �h��}=»�Z Ù ¾- �|6¾5n�e h Z"Û7»/ì�}=»�Z"Û§Û�Ð �%ÌÚÛ t Þ �

¸J�há-â6�háÅ1ì »dè'ã dÙX� y;� � V Ñ { ^ É Î Z ^ � V Û§t Þ gYf��� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É Î Z b �ôÌËÛ �(y t Þ tD`bU�aKfý y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É Î 0fZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z b �Ì:Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\ h t Z bX\�T#��1c�demQd�gYW�nbdef�TKa�`bU�a�f�gY[^a�n�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f 0ÂZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z b den�mghTK_�V\_�n@t#ghf��°`�U�a�`qpQ]�dof�i Z b � Ì�Û �(y t Þ [:_�nb`�U�g3ma�sDaKaKf��aKcbdem\aK�;sQp+��a3gh�a=f�def�i�X-cbV[ Z b%��ÌÚÛ¿Õ Þ t�ghf��+`bU/_�n���aJT@gYf gYWenbV���a@gY�aKf;de`Bdef/`bV�`bU�aJ`qp/]�def�i Z bJ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ � ��1c�demQd�gYWoWep�V\s�`�gYdef�aK�;s/p:��a@gY�aKf�dof�i:`bU�aJU/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�denl�Bde`bU {.ÿb dof+`bU�a%]�cbaK[+denba� y;� � V Ñ { ^ ÉzZ ^l�hüHÛ§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \�9h�u WenbV+`bcbdem/d�ghW�n�dof�TKa¢`�U�a�nb_�s�n�`bde`b_�`bdeVf°den�mghTK_�V\_�n@t39ØÊrtógYf��°`bU�a¢`qp/]�def�i�Ì:Û �(y t Þ [:_�n�`BU�g3ma%s�aKa=f£V\s�`�gYdof�aK�sQp:��a@gY�aKf�def�i�X-cbV[ 9h� Ì:Û¿9 Þ t�gYf��;T@ghf;`bU/_�nBsDa���a@gh�\aKf�aK�;def/`bV;9h� Ì:Û§t Þ ghnB��aKWeWq�

T@ghn�a Z b­\ p �û�p°`�U�a:��a��Df�de`bdeVf�VhX {.ÿb t�de`JdonJV\f�Wep°]�V\nbn�dos�Woa�`bUDgh`�`�U�a:mghc�dÎgYs�Wea p Ê ¿#¾�Ï Ï {Ôÿb Ð d�XBde`bnJf�gh[+a¢ghf�f�V`�gh`bdeV\f°denaK[^]�`qp/t/dq�/a�Bd�X p �e� Ì:Û¿Õ Þ Ê {Ôÿb ���BU/_�n3t�s/p;f�gh[+al��a=]�aKf���aKf�TKp���a@gh�\aKf�def�i�tH yQ� � V Ñ {Ôÿb É Î p �3Ì Û§t Þ �7¬lVh��t�s/pUQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden7��a@gh�\aKf�def�i�t\ghf���sDaKT@gY_�nba p \ 0fZ ^"Ñ � 2 p t3��a�i\aK`7`bU�a�cbaKÿ/_�dec�aK�; yQ� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É Î 0ÂZ ^QÑ � 2 p ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \!± W � Ì ^ j Z¤Û t/�BU�aKcbakÌ8\,Ì ^ `ÍÌ b �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb y;W �§Ì ^ É Î Z"Û ��Ì b Û ��y t Þ �y ��û�p�dof���_�TK`�doV\f�U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3t�gYf��HsDaKT@gY_�nba {.ÿb y;W �§ÌØ^ù\ôÏ { b y;W �§ÌØ^ Яÿ t7��a+U�g3maK yQ� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb y;W �§Ìc^ É3Î0ÂZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z¤Û ��Ì b Û§t Þ tz �Bghf��^X-cbV[ýU�aKcba\t�`�U�aJcbaKÿ/_�dec�aK�'ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É3Î ± W � Ìc^fj 0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û ��Ìc^a`ìÌXb���t:�

T@ghn�a Z b­\ Z"Û�Z¤Û Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É3Î1Z"Û ��Ì Û `ÍÌÚÛ �(y t Þ gYf��d yQ� � V Ñ {Ôÿb É3ÎoZ¤Û Û ��Ì Û Û �(y t Þ �y ��û�pÒdef���_�TK`bdeV\f�U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3t� y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É3Î�0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û �ÀÌ Û `ìÌ�Û§t Þ ghf��èghWenbV< yQ� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �z ��¬lVh����_�n�`lghn�nbaK[:s�Wea�s�ghT��^def/`bV y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î Ï 0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û�Ð Ï 0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û§ÛoÐ ��Ì Û§t Þ �

··

Page 47: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

T@ghn�a Z b­\�a noW �§Ìij Z Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb y;W �§Ì É3ÎPZ¤Û ��Ì Û �(y t Þ �y ��û�aKT@gh_�nba {.ÿb yQW � Ì8\�Ï { b y;W �§Ì Яÿ t/s/p^def���_�T=`bdeVf+UQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden3ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb yQW �§Ì É Î 0ÂZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z¤Û ��Ì Û t Þ tz �Bghf��^X-cbV[ýU�aKcba\t�`�U�aJcbaKÿ/_�dec�aK�'ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É3Î ± W � Ìij 0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û ��Ìó��tË�

T@ghn�a Z b­\ |6¾ n6Z"Û t�ghf��àÌ8\!ö�Ï�Ì Û Û§t Û Þ Ð �� f�`�U�denlT@gYnbatD`�U�a�`qp/]�def�i |6¾ noZ¤Û �3ÌÚÛ �(y t Þ donBV\s�`�gYdef�aK�;s/p^��a@gh�\aKf�def�i:def�U�aKc�aKf/`Jdof;`�U�a�sDVh�^cb_�Woa\�6�BU/_�n@tD��aT@ghf:ghWenbVJ��a=cbdema� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É3Îî|6¾ noZ¤Û �ö�ÏÌ Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ ��Z�Vf�nbde��aKc�dof�i�`bU�gY` 0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 |6¾ nPZ¤Û \ |6¾ nPZ¤Û t\��a@gh�\aKf`bU�aJU/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�denlTKV\fQ`�aK�/`B`bV:i\aK`� yQ� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î�0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 |6¾ nPZ¤Û �ö�ÏÌ Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ ì�»/~�|6¾ nP�áqçZ Û á-âoZ Û§Ûq�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É Î Z"Û �ö�Ï�Ì Û Û§t Û Þ�Ð Û ��y t Þ ty ��û�pÒ`qp/]�def�i���aKc�demgh`bdeV\f't�aKde`bU�aKcK yQ� � V Ñ {.ÿb y;� �e� Ì ÛlÉ3Î Z¤Û Û �­Ì�Û �(y t Þ Vc; y;� � V Ñ {Ôÿb y;� �e�� Ì Û Û t Û ÞÔÉ3Î Z"Û§Û �

Ì�Û �(y t Þ th��aK]DaKf���def�i+�BU�aK`�U�aKc�t Û \�Õ�VcXt Û��\�Õ��z ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É3Î<0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û �ö�Ï�Ì Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ �·�� u Wen�V:f�V`�doT=a�`�U�gh` {Ôÿb y;� �e� Ì Û \�Ï { b y;� �e� Ì Û�Ðgÿ t�ghf���d�X}t Û��\�Õ�t {.ÿb y;� �e�� Ì Û Û§t Û Þ \ Ï { b yQ� �e�� Ì Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Яÿ �x �B¯�cbV[Í`�U�aKn�a¢`q��V^aKÿ/_�gY`bdeVf�n�gYf��°def���_�TK`bdeVf�UQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden3t� yQ� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb y;� �e�§Ì ÛCÉ Î 0ÂZ ^NÑ � 2 Z"Û Û �(ÌÚÛ§t Þ V\c y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb yQ� �e�� Ì Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�É Î 0ÂZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z¤Û Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �ç���¬lVh��tK� _�nb`lgYnbnba=[:s�WeaBs�ghT��^def/`bV�`bU�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK�d y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î�ì-»/~�|6¾ n6��q±0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û�á�âE0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û Û �

Ì�Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\�9�j Z¤Û t/�BU�aKcbaÏ9Y� âÊdÒgYf���Ì8\ X

-gZ Ì Ì Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É Î Z"Û ��Ì Û Û �(y t Þ t/ghf�� wòÉ� ªÅ ÏÌ Û�Ð �Q9h�y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É Î 0ÂZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z¤Û ��Ì Û Û§t Þ tz �Bghf���`�U/_�n� yQ� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î 9�j�Ï 0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û�Ð �DÏ X

-gZ Ì Ì Û�Ð Û§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\ Z"ÛW� 9ht/�BU�aKc�aÏ9h�� 8Êd��

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É Î Z"Û ��Ï X-gZ Ì Ì Ð Û �(y t Þ gYf�� wòÉ� ªÅ ÏÌ Ð � � �

y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É3Î<0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û ��Ï X-gZ Ì Ì Ð Û§t Þ �

z �BZ�Vf�TKWe_���a� yQ� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É Î Ï 0fZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z¤ÛoÐ-� 9J��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z b­\ â7»Q½ 9Y� á�â�Z¤Û �

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V­y 9h� :Ñ {Ôÿb É3Î.Ù - Z¤Û ��ÌÚÛ �(y t Þ �y � u Wen�V�t w �9 É ÌËÛ �(y t Þ �Q9Yt�ghf��^`bU/_�n w �9 É Ì:Û§t Þ �Q9h�z ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V­y 9h� :Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É Î.Ù - 0fZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z¤Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ t·���Wea@gh��dof�i¢`�V:`bU�aJcba=ÿQ_�doc�aK�ð y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Îíâ7»/½ 9Y� á-â�0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ `CY ���j Z¤Û t��BU�aKc�alÌ8\ ]%Y ���jfÌ Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü Z"Û ��Ì Û Û �(y t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü60ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û ��Ì Û Û t Þ �z ���BU/_�n�X�V\WoWeVh�Bn3t� y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Îä`�Y ��Fj 0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û ��Ï ]3Y ���jfÌ Û�Ð Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ Z"Û Û Û¿m Þ Þ t�BU�a=cbalÌ8\�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ì Û �· x

Page 48: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

v ��û�p£`qp/]�def�i°��aKcbdemgh`�deVf't� y;� � V Ñ { ÿb É3ÎòZ Û ��Ï ]3Y ���j�Ì Û Ð Û �(y t Þ t w É m¨� ��t7ghf��ým�' ¿#¾(Ï Ïf Ð 5¿#¾�Ï Ï w:Ð �

y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É Î 0ÂZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z¤Û ��Ï ]3Y ��Fj�Ì Û�Ð Û§t Þ �z �BZ�Vf�TKWe_���atH yQ� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É3Î Ï 0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û�Ð Û Û¿m Þ Þ ��Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ Ì ÛeÐ Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\ 0Â� j\ Z¤Û 2 Z¤Û§Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É3Î1Z"Û � V Û ��y t Þ ghf��d y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É3Î6Z¤Û Û ��ÌÚÛ �(yQ�(y t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É Î 0ÂZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z¤Û � V Û§t Þ tz �Bghf���n�V; yQ� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î<0f� j\ 0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û 2 Z"Û§Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b \ 0 9 j\ Z¤Û 2 Z"Û Û t/�BU�aKc�aà9h� 8Êd��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É3Î1Z"Û �G ÚÛ �(y t Þ t\ghf��d y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É3ÎPZ¤Û§Û ��ÌÚÛ ��y 9 y t Þ �y ��û�pHdef���_�T=`bdeVf�U/p/]�V\`bU�a=nbden@t� y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3ÎÉ0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û �( ÚÛ§t Þ t6gYf��: y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3Î 0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û Û �

Ì�Û¿9 y t Þ �z � u n�nbaK[:s�WoaJs�gYT��^def/`bV�`bU�aJcba=ÿQ_�doc�aK�ð y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É3ÎE0 9 j\ 0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z"Û 2:Ï 0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û§ÛoÐ ��ÌÚÛ t Þ �

T@ghn�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i%X�c�V[ Ì Û ���3ÌË�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É Î Z b ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É3Î<0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z bJ��Ì Û Û§t Þ �z ��kln�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i:`bV�TKVf�TKWe_���atH yQ� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb É3Î�0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z bJ��ÌÚÛ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z b­\�Ï �Y��}K»áZ Ù ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z¤Û6»/ì�}=»�Z"Û§Û�Ð �v ��û�p^��aKc�demgh`bdeV\f't� yQ� � V Ñ {Ôÿb ÉzZ Ù �/ö�Ï V Û¿m Þ�Ð Û �(y t Þ thghf��F y;� � V ÑG| g Î e � V Û¿m Þ \ih {�Û gYf�� y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb yQ{EÛ�É Î Z¤Û ��Ì Û �(y t Þ tghf��F y;� � V Ñ {.ÿb É Î Z"Û§Û ��ÌÚÛ �(y t Þ �

y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ { ^ yQ{Ôÿb Éd0fZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z Ù �ö�Ï V Û¿m Þ Ð Û t Þ t\ghf�� y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb É�0ÂZ ^"Ñ � 2 Z¤Û Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ �z ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g v ç�t {�Û \ { \ ÿ �·���û�p£Ï v3Ð ghf���Ï zÐ t� y;� � V Ñ@Ï { b y;{ Û Ð ÿ É3ÎPZ Û ��Ì�Û �(y t Þ �x ��û�p£Ï�· Ð ghf��;def���_�TK`bdeVf+U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3t�gYf��;`bU�aKfíÏ zÐ gYiQgYdof#t� y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{.ÿb y;{�Û É3Î<0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z¤Û ��Ì Û§t Þ �ç��B¯#def�ghWeWepQtYsQp�Ï y\Ð ghf���Ï x\Ð t�gYf��;`bU�aJ`qp/]�def�i�cb_�WeaJX�V\c �Y��}=» t y;� � V Ñ { ^ y;{ ÿb É3ÎE0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2/Ï �Y��}K»áZ Ù ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z Û »/ì�}=»�Z Û§Û Ð ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ � {

��»3Ï�Ï�� uiuýºg¸����h� Ï�»/~@�háq�há ~K¼.¼´P$�´ s��Ñ {áÉ Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü Z �/üHÛ§t Þ §¦�Ô;m ´eª¢§z�6©=ø�øÇA s=Ö��K¨�©�Ô:Ô© Ó�©3¦�Ô©3¦�³3¶+ª ©3µ��Ì´_$ ©¦$�m ' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð �B§¦�Ô;´eªs"�b©=ªbÕ!sKÖ�������´�$�©¦$ wOÉ m ������µeÕ�©3¦

�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z ��Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ"%$�´ s��Ñ {�É3Î1Z �hüHÛ§t Þ �7§¦�Ô �(y 9Y� V §���©¢¦�§\¨¢©=ªm·�¦�Öµ�¦�©�³�©Kª�ªK§��K´Îøo¶:´�¦*ºP�̵eÕ�©3¦

Ï � 9 Ð �Ñ3Ï � 9 Ð@{�É + Y�-0/ Î Ï � 9 ЪZ ��Ï � 9 Ð üHÛeÏ � 9 Ð t Þ

·Qç

Page 49: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ ¯#doc�nb`�f�V`�deTKa^`�U�gh`�`bU�a+`bc�ghf�n�]�V\nbde`bdeVf�Ï `bU�a+nbaKT=Vf�� Ð ]�cbV]DaKc�`qp�don�`bc�demQd�gYW6`bV°]�cbVhma+s/p£def���_�TK`bdeVf�V\f�`bU�a`qp/]�def�iH��aKcbdemgh`�deVfÚX�V\c Z �w¬Jgh[^a=Wop/tBghWeWl`�U�a�`qp/]�def�iHc�_�WeaKn@tJghn;��aKWeW�ghn;`bU�a�cb_�Woa=n;X�Vc;gh_��/deWed�ghcbp;��_���i\[^aKf/`�n�ghc�aVs/m/deV_�n�Wep¢def�n�aKf�nbde`�dom\al`�V¢n��ÌgY]�]�def�i�`�U�alf�gY[^aKn�`bU�cbV_�iU�V\_�`@t\def�ghWeW�`�U�aJTKVf/`�aK�/`bn@t�`qp/]�aKn3t/`baKc�[^nBghf��+��aK]DaKf���a=f�TKdeaKn@��BU/_�n�`bU�a7��_���i\[^aKf/`6de`bn�aKW�X'[:_�nb`�s�a�dof�nbaKf�n�de`bdema�`bV�n��ÌgY]�]�def�i�f�gY[^aKn3�'�BU�don�cba=[�ghdef�n7`�cb_�aJaKm\aKf^�BU�a=f�`�U�alW�gYf�i_�gYiadenBaK�/`baKf���aK�°�Bde`bU;`�U�aJTKVf�n�`bc�_�TK` �h��}=» X-Vc�]�gh`�`baKc�f/��[;gh`�T�U�dof�i�t�ghn�nbU�Vh�Bf�def°­�a=[^[�g v �� y ��BU�a�]�c�V/VhX�VYX¹`�U�aJ��c�nb`�]�cbV\]�aKc�`qp°denBnbV\[^aK�BU�gY`BWeaKnbn�`bcbdem/d�ghWqt/s�_�`�nb`�doWeW#c�gh`�U�aKc�nb`bc�ghdeiU/` X�Vc��ÌgYcb�°s/p^def���_�TK`bdeV\f�V\f

`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i:��aKcbdemgh`�deVf^VYX Z �T@ghn�a Z \ h t Z \�T't Z \ p V\c Z \ � �S/_�s�n�`bde`b_�`�deVf�den�mghT=_�V_�n#Vf�`�U�aKn�a�`�aKcb[+n@t3s�_�`#do`#nb`�doWeW\[�g3pBT�U�ghf�ia6`�U�a6`qp/]�a=n@��ãlVh��aKm\aKc@th`�U�a6i\dom\aKfJ��aKc�domgY`bdeVf�nghcba�Vs�`�ghdef�a=�°_�nbdef�i;g:U/p/]�V\`bU�a=nbdenJVc�gËTKVf�nb`�gYf/`�c�_�Weat�ghf���`bU�a�nb_�s�nb`bde`�_�`bdeVf��BdeWeW'T�U�ghf�ia�`�U�a¢`qp/]DaKnJdef°`bU�aTKVf/`ba=�Q`�n�gYnB��aKWeW'gYnBdof+`bU�a���_���i\[^aKf/`@�

T@ghn�a Z \�±(T'� ü Û j Z"Û t/�BU�aKc�a�ü,\ ü Û ` ü Û§Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {}y T'� ü Û�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_ÜòZ"Û �hü Û§Û Û§t Þ �7ghf��d�Ñ wzy�Y �� É ü Û ��Xb�y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{Iy T#�ÜÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Û É3Î Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�Z Û ��Û m Ñ Y/Þ ü Û Û ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ tz ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g y � z t��Ñ wOÉ Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛoÐ ��X��·��BZ�V[:s�dof�dof�i¥Ï yÐ gYf���Ï zÐ t��Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�{ËÉ Î Ï�±(T'�eÏ�Û m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛeÐ j�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z"Û�Ð ��Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ ü Û ` Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Û Û�Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ Z ^ Z b �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü8Z ^��hü_^*`ôüHÛ§t Þ tQgYf��d�Ñ {�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü�Z bJ�\üU^'Û§t Þ �y ��û�p�def���_�TK`bdeV\f�U/p/]DV`bU�aKnbden@t��Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒ{zÉ3Î Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z ^l��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ üU^*` Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ t�ghf��=�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3ÎÛ¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒZ bJ��Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ üU^ Ð ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �

z �BZ�Vf�TKWe_���atH�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒ{zÉ3Î ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒZ ^ Ð Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z b Ð ��Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �T@ghn�a Z \äa n T#� ükj Z¤Û �

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {}y T'� ü É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü8Z¤Û �üíÛ t Þ �#ghf��d�Ñ wzyY �� É üô��X��y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{Iy T#�ÜÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü É Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z"Û ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ tz �Bghf���s/p^­®aK[^[;g y � z t��Ñ wOÉ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ��X �·��BZ�V[:s�dof�dof�i�`�U�a�`q��V�t/TKV\f�TKWe_���a��Ñ3Û m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î Ï a n T'��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð j�Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z Û Ð ��Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ |6¾5noZ¤Û t/�BU�aKcba�ü�\èö�Ï�ü Û Û t ÛÜÞ�Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ { Ó É Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü Z¤Û �hü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ï { Ó Ð}É Î Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�Z"Û ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü ÛoÐ ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Û Þ �z �BS/def�TKa:Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ Ï { Ó Ð \�ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ�{'Ð Ó t/��a�i\aK`��Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3ÎH|�¾ n Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z¤Û �ö�ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ï�ü Û Û§t Û Þ�Ð�Ð ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ ì-»/~¢|6¾5noprqsZ ^ á-â�Z b\�

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü8Z ^��ö�Ï�ü Û Û t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ tghf��'ty ��aKde`bU�aKcp�Ñ {}y;p �e� ü ÛlÉ Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü Z b �BüíÛ t Þ t�VcK�Ñ {}y;p �o�� ü Û Û t ÛÜÞlÉ Î�Ú ÛØÙ_Ü Z b ��üHÛ§t Þ t���aK]DaKf���def�iÚ�BU�aK`�U�aKc

t Û \�Õ%VcXt Û��\�Õ��z ��û�p£Ï v3Ð ghf��;def���_�TK`bdeVf+U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3ti�Ñ3Û m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z ^Ì��Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ö�Ï�ü Û Û§t Û Þ Ð ÛoÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ·���û�pwÏ yÐ gYf�� def���_�TK`bdeV\f«UQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden3t;�Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�{}y;p �e�ÜÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Û�É Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z b ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ tlV\c�Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{}y;p �e�� Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ Ï�ü Û Û§t Û Þ Ð�Ð�É3Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z b���Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð ÛoÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �

x � ¡ a3ghnbn�aK[:s�Wealdef/`bV;�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î�ì-»/~�|6¾ n6p1q Û¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒZ ^ á�â Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z bJ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ �

·3

Page 50: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

T@ghn�a Z \ � j Z Û t��BU�aKc�a�ü�\ XY[Z \ ü Û ghf�� � � V Êd��u nbn�_�[^a ���ÊFm�`bV%aKf�nb_�cbalT3gh]�`�_�cbaJg3mVde��def�iD�D�BU�den6T@ghf^gYWe�Ìg3p/n'sDa�gYT�U�deaKmaK�:s/p¢gYWe]�U�g3�qcba=f�gh[+dof�i � def/`bVJnbV\[^aV`bU�aKc�X�cba=nbU°f�gY[^a�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {�É Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü Z¤Û �hü Û Û§t Þ ghf�� wzyY �� É ªÅ Ï�ü ÛÎÐ � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ üÀÛ Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ �z ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g z t wòÉ� ªÅ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü ÛoÐ � � �·�� u n�nbaK[:s�WoaJs�gYT��^def/`bV�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒ{zÉ3Î Ï � j�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z¤ÛoÐ ��Ï XY[Z \ Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛeÐbÐ ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ Z¤ÛØ�á� t��BU�a=cba � � V Êð��u nbn�_�[^a\t�ghnBsDa�X�Vc�at�`�U�gh` ���Êdm;t�`bV:a=f�nb_�c�a�T@gY]�`b_�c�a¢g3mV\de��def�i��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {�É Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü Z¤Û ��Ï XY[Z \ ü Ð Û§t Þ �7ghf�� wzy�Y �� Éà ªÅ Ï�ü Ð � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z"Û ��Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ï XY[Z \ ü Ð ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �z ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g z t wòÉ� ªÅ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð � � �·�� u Wen�V�t�Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ Ï XY[Z \ ü Ð \ XY[Z \ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð tx �Bghf�����aJT@ghf°gYnbnba=[:s�Weals�gYT��K�Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�{ËÉ Î ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ�Z"Û�Ð��á� �DÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛoÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ â7»/½ � � V á�â�Z¤Û ��1VHg3m\Vde�ÚT@gh]�`b_�c�at�gYnbn�_�[^a;`bUDgh` � den�g�X�cba=nbU!f�gh[+at�f�V`:V/TKTK_�cbcbdef�iÚdefègYfQpíVhX¢`�U�a°mgYcbd�ghs�Weat�f�gY[^at�V\c]�ghc�gh[^a=`baKc�TKVf/`�aK�/`bn@�

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ {zÉ3Î�Ú ÛØÙ_Ü8Z"Û �hüHÛ§t Þ t/ghf�� w � �(yY �;Ï4� yQ�/Ð�É Ï�ü�Û§t Þ�Ð � � �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti y;� � V Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒ{gÉ Î Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�Z"Û ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛoÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �z �B¯�cbV[�ghnbn�_�[^]�`bdeVf wòÉ m��Q�ôghf���`�U�aJX�gYTK`B`bUDgh` � den�X�cba=nbU't���aJia=` w � �UÉ m�� Ïf� y;�/Ð �·���û�p�­�a=[^[�g y � y t w � �cÉ Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ï ü¢Û§t Þ�ÐbÐ � � t/n�V�X�VWeWeVh�Bn�`bU�aJcba=ÿQ_�doc�aK�x ���Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î�â7»/½ � � Vóá-â Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z¤Û ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ ` kW�� Û j Z¤Û t/�BU�aKcba�ü�\ ] kW�� Û jhü Û ��1V:g3mV\de�:T@gh]�`�_�cba\t�gYnbn�_�[^a!k�den�X�c�aKnbU'�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {�É Î�Ú ÛWÙ�ÜBÚ ÍhÙ_Ü \ Z¤Û �hü Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ Î�Ú ÍhÙ_Ü \ Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z"Û ��Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛÎÐ ÛoÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �z ���BU/_�n@tH�Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�{ËÉ3Π` kW�� Û j�Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�Z"Û ��Ï ] kW�� Û j�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛeÐ ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ Z¤Û Û Û¿m Û Þ Þ t/�BU�aKcba�ü�\�Û¿m Û Ñ k Þ ü Û Ï4k%�BdeWeW�sDa�def/`bcbV/��_�TKaK�°W�gh`�aKc Ð �v ��û�pH`qp/]�def�i°��a=cbdemgh`�doV\f't��Ñ {8É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_ÜÍZ"Û ��Ï ] kW�&�jhü ÛÎÐ Û t Þ �BU�a=cba wzy�Y �� É m Û � & ghf��<m Û '¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾�Ï Ï wzyY �� Ð �

y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z"Û ��Ï ] kW�&�j�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛeÐ ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �z ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g y � v t wòÉ ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ mkÛ Ð ��&ó�·���¬la=�Q`3t�V\sQm/deV_�nbWepQtDÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ m ÛoÐ ' ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 Ð 5 ¿#¾(Ï Ï w:Ð �x ���BU/_�nBTKV\f�TKWe_���atH�Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�{ËÉ3Î Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z¤ÛoÐ Û ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ m Û Þ Þ ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \ 0f� j\ Z ^[2 Z b\t/�BU�aKc�a � � V Êd��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü8Z ^�� V Û§t Þ tQgYf��d�Ñ {�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü�Z bJ�hüHÛ �(y t Þ �

·Qé

Page 51: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

y ��û�p�def���_�TK`bdeV\f°U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3t��Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{�É3Î Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z ^���Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ4V�Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ t�gYf��d�Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�{�É3Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z b��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð Û �(y Û m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �

z �BS/def�TKa V \ Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ4V t\cba@gYnbnba=[:s�Wea�def/`bV�Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î�0f� j\�Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z ^t2¥Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z b Ð �DÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �T@ghn�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i%X�c�V[�ü Û ���hü��

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ {�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ�Ü8Z �Yü Û Û t Þ �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@ti�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ3Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü ÛeÐ ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �z ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g y � x t�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Û ���DÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü�t·���nbV:s/p+nb_�s�`qp/]�def�iDt��Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�{ËÉ3Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z ��Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ ü Ð ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �

T@ghn�a Z \«Ï �h��}=»�Z Ù ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z¤Û6»/ì�}=»ËZ¤Û§Û�Ð �v ��û�p^��aKc�demgh`bdeV\f't��Ñ {�É3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü�Z Ù �ö�Ï V Û m Û�Þ�Ð Û§t Þ t/ghf��K�Ñ�| g�Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü=e � V Û¿m Û�Þ \ih { ^lghf���Ñ {IyQ{ ^ É3Î�Ú ÛØÙ_Ü8Z"Û ��ÌÚÛ§t Þ t/ghf��d�Ñ {FÉ3Î�Ú ÛWÙ_Ü8Z"Û§Û ��Ì�Û§t Þ �

y ��û�p:dof���_�TK`�doV\f^U/p/]�V\`bU�a=nbden@t��Ñ3Û m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ Î Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z Ù �ö�Ï V ÛeÛ m Ñ Y/Þ m ÛÜÞ�Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ t Þ tPgYf��p�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ï {}y;{ ^ Ð�É ÎÛ¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒZ¤Û ��Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ì Ð ÛoÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ tghf��F�Ñ3Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ Î Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z"Û Û ��Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ Ì Ð ÛoÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ �z ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g v �t��ÑG| g�Î�e � V ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ m Û Þ \ihÍÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{ ^@�·���û�p^`qp/]�def�i�cb_�WeaJX�V\c �Y��}=» t3��_�n�`lghnbn�aK[:s�WealsDghT��^def/`bV�`bU�aJc�aKÿ/_�decbaK��Ñ@Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�{zÉ Î �h�D}K» Ï�Û¿m Ñ Y/Þ�Z Ù Ð�¾- l|6¾ n�e h Ï�Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z¤ÛoÐ�»/ì�}=» ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�ÞÒZ¤Û ÛÎÐ ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ Ì Ð ÛeÛ¿m Ñ Y/Þ t Þ � {

��»3Ï�Ï�� u�¹<º^Ð�¾Dâ'~3�h���Y~@á-¾�âPÄ�»/�fÏ�á�â7��~3á-¾�â���â6¿�Ä�¼�Å6»d¸J�h»�}K»/�f×/��~3á�¾D⤼¤¦s. ^ y �b\Ñ {ÔÿlÉ3ÎPZ �hüHÛ§t Þ µeÕ�©3¦¢µeÕ�©��b©�©hI\´eªKµ ª�Ø/¦�´o�3ØQ©�µ�©��K¨8>#��ª Ø/³�Õ:µeÕ�§µ Z < ö� `?>b$O�#Ø3�=µoÕ�©G�K¨�Ö���©H�[>!´eª��b°Ab³�Ö¦�µ�b§\³@µ-©�Ô§¦�Ôà ^ y �bhÑ {ÔÿÔÉ3Î >è�YüHÛ§t Þ $¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ û�p+dof���_�TK`�doV\f^V\f�`�U�a���a=cbdemgh`�doV\fp ^ y �bYÑ {ÔÿÔÉ�Z �hüHÛ§t Þ �T@ghn�a Z \ h t Z \�T't Z \ p V\c Z \ � �¯�V\c�a@gYT�U^VhX7`bU�a=nba�T@gYnbaKn Z < ö� ` Z t�gYf��^`�U�aKp�gYcba�ghWeW�ghWecba3gh��p:TKV\f/`bc�gYTK`ba=�'��S/V���alU�g3m\alaK�/denb`�aKf�TKatD_�f�doÿ/_�a=f�aKnbn3tTKVf/`bc�ghTK`�aK��f�a=nbn@t#ghf��+`bU�a�`qp/]DaKn�gYcbaJ]�c�aKnbaKc�maK�#�

T@ghn�a Z \�±(T'� ü Û j Z Û t�ghf���ü�\ ü Û `ôü Û Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y �bÑ {.ÿ�y T#� ü Û(É3ÎoZ¤Û �hü Û§Û Û§t Þ �y �BS/def�TKa {.ÿ�y T'� ü Û \ýÏ {Iy T#� ü Û�Ðgÿ tDs/p;def���_�TK`�deVf°U/p/]�V\`bU�a=nbdenJ`bU�aKc�a¢a=�Qden�`bnJ_�f�deÿ/_�aK> Û n�_�T�U£`�U�gh` Z"Û < ö� `�> Û tghf���`�U�denB> Û denBTKV\fQ`�c�gYTK`baK��ghf��d ^ y b Ñ3Ï {Iy T#� ü ÛoЯÿùÉ Î > Û �Yü Û§Û Û§t Þ �

z ���BU�aKf;`�U�a�`ba=cb[Î>�\�±(T'� ü Û jG> Û n�gY`bdenq��a=n�ghWeW�`�U�aJcbaKÿ/_�decba=[^aKf/`bnBVYX6`bU�aJWeaK[^[;g��T@ghn�a Z \ Z¤ÛôZ¤Û§Û �

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y �bÑ {.ÿlÉ3Î1Z"Û �hü Û `ôüHÛ§t Þ tQgYf��d ^ y �b\Ñ {ÔÿlÉ3ÎPZ¤Û§Û �hü Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p°def���_�TK`�deVf°U/p/]�V\`bU�a=nbden@t�`�U�aKc�a^ghcbaK> Û gYf��V> Û Û �Bde`bU�`bU�a:c�aKÿ/_�aKnb`�aK��]�c�V]DaKcb`�doa=n@t7ghf���`bU�a�`ba=cb[Ï> den>6\X> Û > Û§Û �

T@ghn�a Z \äa n T#� ükj Z Ûq�v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y b Ñ {.ÿ�y T#� ü É Î Z"Û �hüHÛ§t Þ �y �BS/def�TKa {ÔÿRy T#� üM\ Ï {}y T'� ü Ðgÿ t#s/p°def���_�TK`�deVf�UQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden�`bU�a=cba:aK�/denb`�n¢_�f�doÿ/_�aK> Û nb_�T�UH`�U�gh` Z¤Û < ö� `Ð> Û tghf���`�U�denB> Û denBTKV\fQ`�c�gYTK`baK��ghf��d ^ y �bhÑ3Ï {Iy T#� ü ÐgÿiÉ3Î > Û �hüHÛ§t Þ �

·Qæ

Page 52: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

z ���BU�aKf;`�U�a�`ba=cb[Î>�\äa n T#� ükj%> Û n�gh`�denq��aKnJghWeWD`bU�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK[+aKf/`bnBVYX1`bU�a�WeaK[^[;g��T@ghn�a Z \ |6¾5noZ¤Û t/�BU�aKcba�ü�\èö�Ï�ü Û Û t ÛÜÞ�Ð ��BU�den�den�ghT=`b_�gYWoWep;Vf�a:VhX�`�U�a:s�ghn�a:T@ghn�aKn;Ï�`bV\iaK`�U�aKc��Bde`�U£U/p/]�V\`bU�a=nbaKn:ghf���TKV\f�nb`�ghf/`bn Ð �°s�Vh�/aK��aK�/]�cba=nbnbdeV\f�nTKVf/`bc�ghTK`B`�V:`bU�a=[^nba=Wom\aKn@�

T@ghn�a Z \ ì-»/~¢|6¾5noprqsZ"Û�á�â�Z¤Û§Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y �bÑ {.ÿlÉzZ¤Û �ö�Ï�ü Û Û§t Û Þ�Ð Û§t Þ tQgYf��'ty ��aKde`bU�aKc� ^ y �bhÑ {.ÿ�yQp �e� ü ÛRÉ�Z¤Û �Qö�Ï ü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ t\Vc� ^ y �bÑ {.ÿ�yQp �e�� ü Û Û§t Û ÞCÉ�Z¤Û �Qö�Ï ü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð Û§t Þ t\��aK]DaKf���def�i�BU�aK`�U�aKcct Û \�Õ�Vc­t Û��\�Õ��

z � u Wen�V:f�V`�doT=a�`�U�gh`�Ï {.ÿ�yQp �e� ü ÛÎÐ \�Ï {IyQp �e� ü Û�Ðgÿ t�gYf��;dÙX}t Û��\�Õ�t/`�U�aKf�Ï {ÔÿRyQp �e�� ü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ�Ð \ Ï {}y;p �e�� ü Û Û§t Û Þ�Ðgÿ �·����BU�aKf#t/sQp:def���_�TK`bdeV\f^U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@t/��alU�g3m\aI> Û ghf��J> Û Û n�gY`bdenqX-pQdef�i%`bU�aJ]�c�aKnbTKc�des�aK��]�cbV\]�aKc�`bdeaKn3��Z�V[:s�dof�a`bU�aK[�def/`bVK>�\ ì�»/~�|�¾ noprq > Û�á�â > Û§Û �

T@ghn�a Z \ � j Z¤Û t��BU�aKc�a�ü�\ XY[Z \ ü Û t�gYf�� � � V Êð ^ y b �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y b Ñ {.ÿlÉ Î Z"Û �hü Û Û t Þ t�gYf�� wOÉ� ªÅ Ï�ü Û�Ð � � �y ��û�p�def���_�TK`bdeV\f°U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3t�`bU�aKcba�denl_�f�deÿ/_�am> Û n�_�T�U£`�U�gh` Z"Û < ö� `�> Û ghf��~> Û don�TKVf/`�c�ghT=`baK��ghf���VhX6`bU�an�gY[^a�`qpQ]Da�ü Û �

z ��¬lVh��t/]�doT��S>o\ � jG> Û �T@ghn�a Z \ Z¤ÛØ�á� t��BU�a=cba � � V Êð ^ y �bh�

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y �bÑ {.ÿlÉ3Î1Z"Û ��Ï XYØZ \ ü Û�Ð Û§t Þ tQgYf�� w�ÉT ªÅ Ï ü Ð � � �

y ��û�p�def���_�TK`bdeV\f°U/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�don3t�`bU�aKcba�denl_�f�deÿ/_�am> Û n�_�T�U£`�U�gh` Z"Û < ö� `�> Û ghf��~> Û don�TKVf/`�c�ghT=`baK��ghf���VhX6`bU�an�gY[^a�`qpQ]Da^Ï XY[Z \ ü ÛoÐ �

z ��¬lVh��t/]�doT��S>o\Q> Û[��� �T@ghn�a Z \ â7»/½ � � V á�â�Z¤Û �

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y Ï4 b yQ� � V%Ð Ñ { Î ÉËZ¤Û �hüHÛ§t Þ tQgYf�� w � �cÉ ü�Û§t Þ � � �y ��û�p£def���_�TK`bdeVf�UQp/]DV`�U�aKnbden3t'`�U�aKcba+den�_�f�deÿQ_�aU> Û nb_�T�U�`�U�gh` Z¤Û < ö¯Ú Y[Z \�J�-��� `N> Û ���BU�den#> Û den�ghWenbV;TKV\fQ`�c�gYTK`baK�ghf���VYX1`qp/]Da�ü��

z � r deT��J>6\ â1»/½ � � Výá-â > Û t�gYf��;do`�U�gYnB`bU�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK��]�cbV\]�aKc�`bdeaKn3�T@ghn�a Z \ `�Y ��Fj Z ghf�� Z \ Z¤Û Û Û¿m Þ Þ �

�_�n�`�ghn�`bU�a�]�cba=mQdeV\_�nBT@ghn�aKn@tD`�U�aKnba%`q��V^gYWon�V¢i\V¢a3ghnbdeWep/�T@ghn�a Z \ 0f� j\ Z¤Û 2 Z"Û§Û t/�BU�a=cba � � V Êð ^ y �bh�

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y �bÑ {.ÿlÉ3Î1Z"Û � V Û t Þ t/ghf��F ^ y �bhÑ {ÔÿÔÉ3Î1Z"Û§Û �YüHÛ ��y t Þ �y ��û�p£def���_�TK`bdeVf�U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@t#`bU�aKc�a�gYcba:_�f�deÿ/_�aL> Û ghf��M> Û§Û nb_�T�U�`bUDgh` Z¤Û < ö� `N> Û ghf�� Z¤Û§Û < ö� `N> Û§Û t']�Wo_�n`bU�aKp°ghcbaJTKV\f/`bc�gYTK`ba=�£ghf��;]�c�aKnba=cbma�`bU�a�`qp/]DaKn@�

z ��¬lVh��t/��don�`bdef�i\_�denbU;`q��V�T@gYnbaKn3�lÏ v3Э� Ê ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 b Ð tDghf���Ï y\Э�d�Ê ¿#¾�Ï Ï4 b Ð �·�� � f;`bU�a���c�nb`�T@ghn�atD]�deT��L>H\ 0Â� j\8> Û 26> Û§Û � � `�donBT=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�aK�£ghf���UDghnB`bU�a�TKVc�cbaKT=`l`qp/]�def�i��x � � f;`bU�aJn�aKTKVf��°T@ghn�atD]�deT��L>�\ 0 > Û Ñ � 2R> Û Û �7û�p+`bU�a�T=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�doV\f;cb_�WeaKn3t Z < ö� `?>��7û�p�­®aK[^[;g v3z � v t/de`�denTKV\fQ`�c�gYTK`baK�#�Bû�p;n�_�s�nb`�de`b_�`�doV\f;]�cbdef�TKde]�Wea^Ï-­�aK[+[�g v Ý�� · Ð t/de`lgYWon�V:U�ghn�`bU�a%TKVc�cbaKTK`J`qp/]�def�i ^ y �b\Ñ {ÔÿÔÉ3Î0 > Û Ñ � 2P> Û Û �hüHÛ§t Þ �

x Ý

Page 53: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

T@ghn�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i%X�c�V[�ü Û ���hü��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� ^ y b Ñ {.ÿlÉ Î Z �hü Û Û§t Þ �y ��û�p£def���_�TK`bdeVf�U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@t#`bU�aKc�a:aK�/denb`bn¢>ó�Bde`bU�`bU�a:c�aKÿ/_�decbaK��]�c�V]DaKcb`�deaKn@� � f£]Dghcb`�deTK_�W�ghc3t|> Û UDghnJ`bU�an�gY[^a�`qpQ]Dat�d��/a\�� ^ y b Ñ {.ÿlÉ Î >!�hü Û Û§t Þ t

z ��nbV:_�nba�n�_�s�`qp/]�def�i�`bV:TKV\f�TKWe_���atH ^ y b Ñ {ÔÿlÉ Î >!�hüíÛ t Þ � {

ÄcÆ7»/¾��h»%ÏÃu[�ýºg¸J�h¾(È��h»�}3}J��â6¿6Ä�¼�Å6»ð¸J�h»�}=»Q�f×/��~3á-¾�⤼¤¦s1�Ñ�| ÉzZ �YüHÛ Þ �6µoÕ�©@¦�©3´�µoÕ�©G�´P$ Z ´eª�§+÷@§YøoØ/©H�6Ö��"%$�µoÕ�©G��©�©hI\´eªKµ ªB Û Ö� ªKØ/³�Õ�µeÕ�§\µ Z < yQZ��� ` Z <%\ y;Z"Û�Ñ sKØ%�KµeÕ�©��K¨¢Ö��b© Z¤Û ´Îª�Ø/¦�´¾�@Ø/©�§¦�Ô Û Ñ�| ÉzZ¤Û �\üHÛ Þ $

¸J�h¾�¾- KÀ û�p+dof���_�TK`�doV\f^V\f�`�U�a�`qp/]�def�i���aKc�domgY`bdeVfK�ÑG| ÉzZ �hüHÛ Þ �T@ghn�a Z \�T#t Z \ p Vc Z \ � ��BU�aKnba�gYcbaJf�V`�gh]�]�WedeT@gYs�WeatsDaKT@gY_�nba%s�V\`bU^`�U�aJU/pQ]DV`�U�aKn�donBT=Vf/`baK�/`Bghf��+`bU�aJf�gY[^algYf�f�V`�gh`�doV\f�n6def^`�U�a�gYs�Vhm\a`qpQ]�dof�i¢��a=cbdemgh`�doV\f�gYcbaJaK[^]�`qpQ�

T@ghn�a Z \ h V\c Z \!±�T j Z¤Û �û�V\`bU;`baKc�[^nlgYcba�ghWecba3gh��p:mgYWo_�aKn@�

T@ghn�a Z \ Z ^ Z b�u nbn�_�[^aJsDV`�U Z ^ ghf�� Z b ghc�aJmghWe_�aKn�Ï V`bU�aKcb�Bdenba%`bcbdem/d�ghW Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| ÉzZ ^J�hü Û `ôüHÛ Þ t�ghf��d�Ñ�| ÉzZ b%�hü Û Û Þ �y ���BU�aKf Z ^a\!±�T j Z¤Û t�ghf�� Z < yQZ��� ` Z < y Û Z b Ñ T ÞÒZ¤Û �z ��û�p^nb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f�]�cbdef�TKde]�Wea v Ý�� v t`�U�a�c�aK��_�TK`�U�ghnB`�U�a�n�gh[^a�`qp/]�def�i��

T@ghn�a Z \äa n T#� ükj Z¤Û �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ;T'� ü ÉzZ"Û �hüHÛ Þ ty �Bghf���n�V�t/s/p^n�_�s�n�`bde`b_�`�deVf;]�cbdef�T=do]�Woa v Ý�� v t��Ñ É Û Z Ñ T Þ�Z¤Û �hüHÛ Þ �z ���BU/_�n@tH Û \��n�gh`bden ��aKnl`�U�a�c�aKÿ/_�decbaK[+aKf/`bnBVhX7`bU�a%`bU�aKV\cbaK[��

T@ghn�a Z \ |6¾5noZ¤Û t/�BU�aKcba�ü�\èö�Ï�ü Û Û t ÛÜÞ�Ð �u nbn�_�[^aJ`�U�gh` Z¤Û denBf�V`BTKV\f/`bc�gYTK`ba=�HÏ�V\`bU�aKc��Bdenba Z denlg�mgYWo_�a Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| ÉzZ"Û �hü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ �y ��û�pè­�aK[+[�g v3y tB`�U�aKc�a�aK�/don�`bn;_�f�deÿ/_�a~> Û n�_�T�Uè`�U�gh` Z¤Û;� ` > Û tB�BU�doT�U!def gY����de`bdeV\fÒUDghn;`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i�ÑG| É > Û �hü Û Û§t Û Þ �z ��û�p^cba=��_�TK`�doV\f°cb_�Woa=n@t |�¾ nPZ"Û cbaK��_�TKaKnJaK��ghT=`bWep^`�V |6¾ n > Û t�gYf��;nbV:`bU�a�`qp/]�def�i:den�]�cba=nbaKc�maK�'�

T@ghn�a Z \ ì-»/~¢|6¾5noprqsZ ^ á-â�Z b\�u nbn�_�[^aJ`�U�gh` Z ^ denJg�mghWe_�a:Ï�V\`bU�aKc��Bdenba�`bcbdem/d�ghW Ð � � f;`bU�gY`lT@gYnba Z ^ \ |6¾ n > ^ t��BU�aKc�aU> ^ donBT=Vf/`bc�ghTK`�aK�'t'gYf��Z < y;Z��� ` Z < y Û > ^ªÑ p/Þ�Z b �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| É >À^l�hü Û Û§t ÛÜÞ t�gYf��'ty ��aKde`bU�aKc��Ñ p �e� ü Û�ÉzZ b%�hüHÛ Þ t/Vc��Ñ p �e�� ü Û Û§t ÛÜÞôÉzZ bJ�hüHÛ Þ t\��aK]DaKf���dof�i^�BU�aK`�U�aKcct Û \�Õ�V\cXt Û��\�Õ��z �BZ�Vf�TKWe_���at�_�nbdef�i�aKde`bU�a=c�­�a=[^[�g v Ý�� y t/V\cÌ­®aK[^[;g v Ý�� z t`�U�gh`��Ñ�| É Û�>À^ Ñ p�Þ�Z b��hüHÛ Þ �

x�v

Page 54: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

T@ghn�a Z \ � j Z Û t��BU�aKc�a�ü�\ Ï XY[Z \ ü Û Ð ghf�� � � V Êd��u nbn�_�[^aJ`�U�gh` Z¤Û denBf�V`lg%mghWe_�a:Ï�V\`bU�a=cb�Bdenba Z donlg%mghWe_�a�de`bnba=WÙX Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| ÉzZ"Û �hü Û Û Þ t�ghf���| É� ªÅ Ï ü Û�Ð � � Ï s�aKT3gh_�n�a ªÅ Ï�ü Û�Ð \�Õ Ð �y ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@t�`�U�aKc�a�aK�/denb`bn! Û Ö:ín�_�T�U°`bU�gY` Z < y;Z¤Ûi�� ` Z < \ y;Z"Û§Û gYf��d Û Ñ�| ÉzZ"Û§Û �hü Û Û Þ �z ��û�p^cba=��_�TK`�doV\f°cb_�Woa=n@t Z < y;� j Z¤Û � � ` Z <]\ yQ� j Z"Û§Û t�gYf��·���nbdef�T=aÏ Û Ñ�| Éz� j Z"Û§Û � XY[Z \ ü Û Û Þ t/`bU�aJ`qp/]�def�i�donB]�cbaKn�aKcbm\aK�'�

T@ghn�a Z \ Z¤ÛØ�á� t��BU�a=cba � � V Êð��u nbn�_�[^aJ`�U�gh` Z¤Û denlg�mghWe_�a¢Ï V`�U�aKcb�Bden�at�`�cbdem/dÎgYW Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| ÉzZ"Û ��Ï XY[Z \ ü Ð Û Þ t�ghf���| É ªÅ Ï�ü Ð � � Ï�sDaKT@gY_�nba ªÅ Ï ü Ð \�Õ Ð �y ���BU�aKf Z¤Û \�9�j �mÛ t/�BU�aKcbaÏ9Y� V Êd�tDghf��d�Ñ�| Éz�fÛ ��Ï � 9 Ð üHÛ Þ �z ��û�p^cba=��_�TK`�doV\f°cb_�Woa=n@t Z < y;Z��� ` Z < y Ï � 9 Ъ�mÛ �·���û�p�­�a=[^[�g v\v � y t�Ï � 9 Ð �Ñ�| É Ï � 9 Ъ�mÛ ��Ï � 9 Ð Ï � 9 Ð üHÛ Þ �x ��¬lVh��t/sDV`�U ��y 9�Ê ¿#¾(Ï Ïf Ð tDnbV°Ï � 9 Ð á\���ç���û�p^de��aK[+]�V\`baKf�T=p^VhX7nb�Bgh]�]�dof�i�t��ÑG| É Ï � 9 Ð@�fÛ �hüHÛ Þ t�ghf���`�U�aJ`qp/]�def�i¢denB]�c�aKnba=cbma=�'�

T@ghn�a Z \ â7»/½ � � V á�â�Z¤Û t/�BU�aKcba � � V8�ÊF��v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't� y;� � V Ñ�| ÉzZ"Û �hüHÛ Þ �y ��û�p^cba=��_�TK`�doV\f°cb_�Woa=n@t Z < y;Z��� ` Ï Z < y;�/Ð"y;Z"Û t/nbV:def���aKa=�'ti Û \ Ïf yQ� � V�Ð n�gh`�denq��aKn�`bU�aJc�aKÿ/_�decbaK[+aKf/`bn@�

T@ghn�a Z \ `�Y ��Fj Z"Û ��1c�demQd�gYW�Ñ Z denlghWecba@gY��p�g%mghWe_�a\�

T@ghn�a Z \ Z Û Û Û¿m Þ Þ �u nbn�_�[^a Z¤Û denlg�mghWe_�a¢Ï V`�U�aKcb�Bden�a�`bc�dom/d�ghW Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| ÉzZ"Û � ]3Y ���j3ü Û t/�BU�a=cba É mÃ�Q��t�gYf��^ü�\ Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü Û �y �BS/def�TKa Z¤Û denlg�mghWe_�a\tde`BdenBVhX7`bU�a�X�V\cb[ Z"Û \ `�Y �&�j Z¤Û§Û t��BU�aKcbaÏ& '��ôgYf��;`bU/_�n É m��Q&ó�z ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i�cb_�WeaKn3ti�ÑG| É�ÛWÙ,`úZ¤Û§Û �hü Û Û Þ �·���û�p�­�a=[^[�g v\v � v t��Ñ�| É Û m Ñ Y/Þ�Z¤Û Û ��ÏbÛ¿m Ñ Y�Þ ü ÛoÐ Û Þ tx �BS/def�TKa Z < y;Z��� ` Z < y Û¿m Ñ Y�Þ�Z"Û Û t/��aJU�g3m\a¹� _�nb`Bn�U�Vh�Bf;`bU�gY`B`bU�aJ`qp/]�def�i�donB]�cbaKn�aKcbm\aK�'�

T@ghn�a Z \ 0f� j\ Z ^ 2 Z b t/�BU�aKc�a � � V Êd��u nbn�_�[^aJsDV`�U Z ^Bdenlg�mghWe_�a¢Ï V`�U�aKcb�Bden�a�`bc�dom/d�ghW Ð �v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| ÉzZ ^J� V Û Þ t�gYf��d�ÑG| ÉzZ b��hüíÛ �YÞ �y ��û�p�­�a=[^[�g v Ý�� ·�t��Ñ�| É�0ÂZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z b��\üHÛ Þ �z ��û�p^cba=��_�TK`�doV\f°cb_�Woa=n@t Z < y;Z��� ` Z < yt0fZ ^ Ñ � 2 Z bht�n�V:`bU�aJn�`�gh`�aK[^a=fQ`BdenB]�c�VhmaK�#�

T@ghn�a�nb_�s�`qp/]�def�i%X�c�V[�ü Û ���hü��v ��û�p^def���_�T=`bdeVf;U/p/]�V\`bU�aKn�den@t�`�U�aKc�a�aK�/denb`bn! Û Ö:ín�_�T�U°`bU�gY` Z < y;Z��� ` Z <%\ yQZ¤Û ghf��d Û ÑG| ÉËZ¤Û �hü Û Û Þ �y ��û�p^nb_�s�nb_�[+]�`bdeV\f't/��a�gYWon�V¢UDg3ma� Û Ñ�| ÉzZ¤Û �hüHÛ Þ t/dq�\a�6`�U�aJ`qp/]�aKnJghc�a�]�cbaKn�aKcbm\aK�'�

T@ghn�a Z \«Ï �h��}=»�Z Ù ¾- l|6¾ n�e h Z ^ »Qìq}=»ËZ b Ð �� X Z Ù den�f�V\`lg�mgYWe_�at/`bU�a�T3ghnba%don�`bc�demQd�gYW��7S/V:ghn�nb_�[+a�`�U�gh` Z Ù denlg�mgYWo_�at/dq� a\�'denBVhX7`bU�a�X�V\cb[ Z Ù \ |6¾ n > X�V\cnbV[+alc�aK��_�TKa=�~>��

xy

Page 55: Á Â#Ã Ä#Å6Æ^Ç È^É Ä1ÊKÆËÃreports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2002/CMU-CS-02-123.pdf]gYcb` doT=_ W ghcbWep+dof/` cbdei _ def i:def n ` gYf TKa VhX ` U den TKV\f TKaK]

v ��û�p^`qp/]�def�i���aKcbdemgY`bdeVf't��Ñ�| g�e \ih { ^@t�gYf��p�Ñ { ^ ÉzZ ^l�hüHÛ Þ ghf��d�ÑG| ÉËZ bJ�hüHÛ Þ �y � � X6`bU�a=cba�aK�/denb`�n Z Û gYf�� y nb_�T�U;`�U�gh` Z < y >lw e \ih Z Û�y�y t/`�U�aKf Z¤Û \ y Ï Z ^ Ð �z � � f�nb_�T�U�g:T@gYnbat�s/p°`qp/]Da¢]�cbaKn�aKcbmgY`bdeVf�X�Vc�]�gh`�`baKc�f/�q[�gh`�T�U�def�i°Ï�­®aK[^[;g v æ Ð t/`�U�aKcba:a=�Qden�`bn� Û Ö)Únb_�T�U`bUDgh` Z Û \ Z <]\ gYf��d ÛôÉ3Îly � { ^P�

·��B¯�cbV[�Ï v3Ð gYf��;Ï zÐ ths/p�nb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f:]�cbdef�TKde]�Wea�X�Vc7mgYWo_�a6mghc�dÎgYs�WeaKnBÏ�­®aK[^[;g v Ý�� v3Ð tW Û Ñ�| É Î y Ï Z ^ Ð �hüíÛ Þ �ãla=cba�`�U�a�nb_�s�nb`�do`�_�`bdeV\f�]�cbdef�TKde]�WeaJdenÌgY]�]�WedeaK�;Vf�TKa�X�V\cBaKma=cbp^mgYcbd�ghs�Woa�def�`�U�aJ��V[;ghdef:VhX y �

x � � X6f�V Z Û ghf�� y aK�/denb`@t/`�U�aKf Z¤Û \ Z b\�ç��B¯�cbV[ Ï v@Ð s/p+f�gh[+a���T=Vf/`baK�/`���a3gh�a=f�def�i�t� Û Ñ�| É Î Z b �hüHÛ Þ ��� � f°ghf/p:T@gYnbat�X�c�V[ Ï · Ð ghf���Ï-ç Ð t/��aJU�g3m\a=�Ñ�| É3ÎPZ¤Û �hüHÛ Þ � {

xz