322
! "# 1 , !"#$ %& () !"*"’ +, -# . /#, 0 1&$ 2 " . 3 " ( 4’ 56 78 9, :;6<3 3 =# !" #$ %&’ (’ )$ * > ? ;2 #"@A$ 3 B B) C"D$ " ( # 6 3 !, E # # F2G H3H 3 " C"D$ , 3#6 4 +," & - ./ 01 "# 23 #!" #(" 4 I? I J"K 3 +, -# 7 ,) L :3 ,#56 7#$ #6 86 56 !" 4 M N 9*$ B ) O, 3# 3 ";P 3 &P 3 (Q 9* !" +" : ;#$ ;#< 4 R M ,# #S O #: . (3#; : =. >: ?$ " ’#$ > O#@ , " (3#; CT8G ’# 4, P P " 3 " U F" 5# @A B#," #9C#" #56 D#2 0N V $ ;2 A #:"/ :< W$ #"@ ) TWA ( Z6 1&$ 3 H #"(3 # K"P#$ #"(3 43) [G !6; B#: #"(3 !) ,E$ "# +," 6 F?. ?2 #6 +’ 2 I? R < \3 ]6$ (3#; )# 3 ^#._ : 4a#b " 2 "< H ;7 !" G#5" ?2 #56 !" ,3 > c 4#( 3 :*( E/8 %& 43 #( dK B #"@A$ B 5Q’ # E#O 3 /8 9e/ , . [3 #3 ) / 3 5< H7 *# +3 RN ( # () ) !_ . !"&b/ # ; ," 4 *#6 < I#6 7’ 4 0I 0 O#@ 9f B) G%P # g , 3 78 3 - 3 3 3% ) ’J # 0NR

ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

1

� ��������� ���������� ���� �� � ������ � �� � � ���� ,�� ���� �� �����

���������� ����� �� � !"�#$ ��%�&� ���' �( �) !"*"' � ��+, -#��� �.����/#, ����� ��� �� � ������ ����� ��������� �����

01� &$ 2�"� �.��� �3 ����" ���(�� 4 ��'56� �78��� 9 , � �:�;6<3 ��3��� =#�� �� ���� � ���!" ���#$%&��' ��(' ���)$� �*�

�>

?�;��2�#"@A$ �3B�� B)��� C"D�$ ���" ���(� �� #� ���6� �����3 !���,E#�� ���������� �����# F2G ��H3�H ���3�� ���" C"D�$ �����, ��3#6����� 4 ���

��+,"��& -��� ���.�/ 0��1 ��"��#�2��3� � � �� # ����!" �#(" ���4

I?

IJ"K� �3 ��+, -#��� 7 � �,)��� ��L��:���3 �,#56 ��7�#$ ���#�6 8���6 ��56 ��!"��4

M�

N9��*$ B� )� ��O, ��3���#� �3 ��";�P �� ��������3 �&��P �3 ���( �Q �� �9�*� ���� ������!" � ��������+" ���: �;#���$� ;# < ��4

R�

M�����,�#� ������ �� �#S� ���O�� � ���#:� �.�������� �(3#;�� ��:���� �=�. >��: ����?$ ��"��� ��'��# $ � �

���

>��O�#@�����,�� ����" ����� � �(3#;�� CT8G �'#� 4 , �P��� �����P�� �"� �3 "�� ��U��F"�� �� ��5#� � @�A����B#," � #9�C#" �'���� ��#56 D#2����

�0N

V$ �;��2�A�#:��"/ ��:<� �� W�� $ #"@)TWA (Z6� �� 1��&$ �3 ��H���� �#"(3�� �#� �K"P#$ �#"(3�� ��43)��[��G �� !6;� B#:� � �#"(3�� ��

��� �!)� ��,E$� ��"��# ��+," ���6�� F��?. �� �? 2���� ��#6���+'� �2�

�I?

R� <�� ����� \��3� ]�6$�� �� ��(3#;���� �)#� �3 ^�#._� �:4���a#b ����"� 2� ���"<�� ����H�� �� ;7�� ���!"��� G#5" ��? 2���� �#56 ��!" ����,3 �����

�>�

�c4�#( �3 �:�*( E�/8�� ���%&� 4����3 ��#( dK� B�� �� #"@A$���� B�� �� 5Q�' �� #� E���#�O� � ��'��3 �/8�� 9��e/ ,��.���� [�3 ��� #��3 ��)���

����� ��/�� ���3� ��5< �H��7 �*�# ���+�3 ����

�RN

���(��� ���#��( �) )� !��_� �� �� �.��� � !"&b�/ ������# ���;���� �� ��, " ������4 ���� �*��#�6���< �I#6� �7�'��4

0I�

�0�O�#@�9��f� B)��� ���� �� �G�%�P� ������� �' #� ������ g �����, 3���78��� �������3 ������ -��3 �3 3�%���)���

�'�J� ��#�

0NR

Page 2: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

2

��������� ���������� ���� �� ���� � ����

������ ,!���"##���$ %&#'#

��� ����:صاحب امتياز�� ����� ������������ � ������

��:ولئمدير مس���� ����� ����

� ����: سردبير !�"�#���� ����

���� ���% #�"$�: مدير داخلي

��"�&: ويراستار انگليسي '$�(�)

*���:كارشناس اجرايي ��"��

,,,+:شمارگان

���-,,,,+:قيمت تك شماره

����0 /�#�.�: آرايي تايپو صفحه

صفطرح روي جلد �1#� ������: حاتو

و ليتوگرافي ��� �����: چاپ�� 2�����

��:اشتراك 3���"� ��. -����

[email protected]:ي٢٢322322322322كيپست الكترون

�4�� 5� / ���� 6������ �����7 �� '�*� &�� )ISC(�� '��$��".

�� '� �#���� �� / �$�� 2��41� ���� �� '�� &�� ir.SID.WWW;�� '��$.

���� ��� � �� ��� � ���� ����/�/������ ������ ���� !�"�"�#

$ ��� ��%� � ���#&�' ()��* �+�' �,-�.��'�� /��� 0� .

������:����� � !��"# ,�� $��"�� � �%&��� '(�� �)*��"# ,+,�- �%�.# �%/�)0:1�222�344256� ���7841�83��90 . ��1288��83��

������ ���� ��� �� ��

Page 3: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

3

�g4h� 3��P #�H3 ��E\3�H ��������� ��"���3��#f$ 4�:���3 0)�#�� ��&�8i #�'3 g��#f$ 4�:���3 E����j��� ��H3�H ��������� 3���� ?g�� <�#"� �� ���� 1"�P #�H3 E��������� ��"���3U�#6$ 4�:���3 Ig��O� -�6G #�H3 �� �#�3��E��"<�� ��������� 3����U�#6$ 4�:���3 Ng���#"� ����� #�'3 E�#"(3�� ��������� ��"���3U�#6$ 4�:���3 Mg������� F��) #�H3 E��������� 3����$ 4�:���3 U�#6 >��k"�G %a� #�'3 g��#f$ ��� [�" 4�:���3 E��������� 3���� Vg��� H ���# #�H3 E��"�#$ ��������� 3������#f$ C�&� !"�#$ 4�:���3 RL��"�G3�%K� "�� #�H3 E��"<�� ��������� 3����U�#6$ 4�:���3

�cg���#f� l�,�#"�� #�H3 E��"<�� ��������� 3�����m�3 �� �<�G �;�����#� � !�#� � �U��

��g�%,� n��$ #�H3 9#��3��� E��"�#$ ��������� ��"���3U�#6$ 4�:���3 �0g�3�#� �_#"�G #�H3 E��"<�� ��������� 3����C�&� !"�#$ 4�:���3 ��#f$

������� ���� �����

Page 4: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

4

صفحه عنوان

!"�#$ ��%�&� ���' �( �) !"*"' � ��+, -#��� �.������������� ����� �� �/#,

����� �� � ^�2&� E�� 6G �%b�� 43�)#6'� 43�)�

1� &$ 2�56� �"� �.��� �3 ����" ���(�� 4 ��' ��78��� 9 , � �:�;6<33��� =#�� ��

9���� ��G %K� EO���� �%�� 4 "� E�%��� �_�

�>

�;��2�#"@A$ �3B�� B)��� C"D�$ �"���!���,��(� �� #� ���6� �����3E#�� ���������� �����#

F2G ��H3�H ���3�� ���" C"D�$ �����, ��3#6�� 4 ������

�%,� n��$ E���#"� ����� ��O� -�6G ��

�<�6/� ��G E��"�G3�%K� "��

I?

J"K� �3 ��+, -#��� 7 � �,)��� ��L��:���3 ";a %o "���E�6"6a p� %a E %K��;a��

M�

9��*$ B� )� ��O, ��3���#� �3 ��";�P �� ����������3 �&��P �3 ���( �Q

�T�_� #6'� E43�) %K� ��G E3��P�3���#�� E1"G�%�� 1"�� ��

R�

�����,�#� ������ �� �#S� ���O�� � ���#:� �.��� ������ �(3#;�� ��:����

G7�%P E���#f� )#��#� E���%"�� ��W%,

���

��O�#@�����,�� ����" ����� �(3#;�� CT8G �'#��F"�� �� 4 , �P��� �����P�� �"� �3 "�� ��U��

�;"G ��G��(3�)Eq"�� ��"T�S"� ���)#� E�";a 8"<43�)

�0N

$ �;��2�A�#:��"/ ��:<� �� W�� $ #"@)TWA (3�� ��#"(Z6� �� 1��&$ �3 ��H����43)�� #� �K"P#$ �#"(3�� �� ��

[��G �� !6;� B#:� � �#"(3��

��� �K�� � �r�� E���#"� ����� E[�#f,� a�� E����� �< G �f�<� 6G 4 "a�

�I?

� <�� ����� \��3� ]�6$�� �� ��(3#;���� �)#� �3 ^�#._� �:4���a#b ����"� 2� ���� ���"<�� ����H

E�f�<� 6G �";a %K� E�3��/ �%b��1o�� � %K���� F";�

�>�

�:�*( E�/8�� ���%&� 4����3 ��#( dK� B�� �� #"@A$4�#( �3 ,� #� E���#�O� � ��'���� B�� �� 5Q�' ��

��3 �/8�� 9��e/�.���� [�3 ��� #��3 ��)���

�%�#' 3�#� E�#/�� �#;� E�_#"�Gs3�o�#�%/ 43�)

�RN

�(��� ���#� �� �.��� � !"&b�/ ������# ���;���� ���( �) )� !��_� ��

���&� 3��3�� E�b� �_� "%a4��� E#o��C"a���

0I�

9��f� B)��� ��O�#@���� �� �G�%�P� �� g �����, 3�������� �' #� ������78��� �������3 ������ �3 3�%�

��3��)���

���:� �6"b 0NR

����� !��"

Page 5: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

5

�� �������U�#6$ 4�:���3 t��������� ���� u�

� (" %/�K4L)<�,�'��� ���' M�/��/�K4 N �� � ��#)"� � �"�, +� ���7 � @�� � ���/�" ��)," �5# J'� � �$��� ���A .�" P�Q �1R��" � (" ��� ��%/�K4 S��)' �T ��. �/�

� $�1 ������T ����#, � # !1 � ����' 322322322322٥٥٥322@���6 �� ��/�.� �$�,�'��� U )&".

�L��H �<�o� :VWVW� �$��� @�� X��J' �#�� �� � ��. Y���� ;"�T ��� �:��N< ��� T @�� ��T �

>�� " �T ��. ������< ��'��� �$��� @�� �� ���$� � Z#3� ��/.[WVW�&5' ��?Q �� �2�$�� �R��" )�]T �&5' �$ � ;7� �&5' ^� (-��� � � �#?1

�"�, +���. ���)$�� .`WVW�!a7 ���� ^� �� b�� �2��" G2�c" MA4 da6 �e/[�)'�$ �N/ �� �#N.�6 �N)"

������. 0�� � � �g ��c$ � 7�� � �!a7 e/V�)'�$ �'���� ���7 � �)" ���A �#?1 ��.hWVW�2��" � �2�$�� ���J' >�$�� �D(" ���$ ��� @�"i�/ ���.eWVWF�' � �T �2��" YE5�� ��i��)Word 2003WXp 2001 ( ���N�/ �N �.� ��. �#?1�&5'���A >�$�� ��)T .

jWVWR��" k�' ;#7� �R��" ;"�. ��. �)���l4 �(Original Article)�.�.mWVW�� �R��" Ve�,E' ���(1 ��. n��1 �!a7 )����+1 � >���: �5)6� �.(oWVW��2��" P�Q �� =4 `� � (" �� �&5' ��� ���7N��,5N��' ��N#)<� �� @�J 5N" p>�

Y��A �/��< ���3.0L4�K� 9v�2� C"D�$ :

VW[W�!a7 F�� � >�� )�!a7 @��,� MTitle Page ( �5N# J'� � �N$��� �N �)5N��;"�. :�:�� ��A���'�< F�' � F�' ��2��" @��,� �N� ��,5N��' ZN#3� -��� � �.��"� ���A ��� �

��,5��' �E#'��)E2� Y54 -��� � ��J'��� � �a 1 �@�A�,5��' 5" p�%/�KN4 F�N('� ;N!" �>�>�p5" �2��" )b�� �� (�1 ��.� �2��" >�$�� r��.

���� ��#��$���%�

Page 6: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

6

Page 7: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

7

[W[W�!a7 �N.� ��N# T ��� T � �5# J'� � �$��� �7D< ;"�. ��� F��?Q � F�$ .�7D< �� �2��" [esX�� � ���N" �g�N/ �N @� �)N" �� � �.��' �)�# �� T �N)��� ��N/ � �N/

�(#)' �.� ��. ���.� ��#A .`W[W���" ;"�. �)5�� �2��" ;7� �.� ��� �:�� 2�:�$�� � ����" � @� g�/ � �2t5" @�# �).lA ��/.

w"2K$ B��:X�� � ���" �Z#�!1 u�� Z#3� u�. � "�: ��/ X�� � �'��' � ���"� ��/��. �)��A ��T � ���"� ;# !1.

����� �)x����:(�)��� ;"�T u�. Z#�!1 ��/.dK�:�)��� I?" ��E' u�. ;"�. ��/�5���" �)��� � @� ��NJ�� ��N 2�c" �� ;N7�6 ��/

�)��� �2��)6� ����T @�# �gD)<� ����" � v�)�" ����" �#5a1 � �#:�1 �(#)' ��/ �N���� � ��#A �)��� �� ;7�6 ��/��?,�#4 Z#�!1 ��/.

#r�$:� �'�5T �A� �).�� Y2�<� Z#�!1 F�('� �� I#�)5"�#w ��� �N2��" ��?)'� �� ��'� ��� �'����3 @�'���� ;��.

hW[Wq����:��!' � �T� X�� � B�," I#x,1 APA �" �.�.eW[W=E� �.� ����. � @��,� ����� y��" >���: � �/�����' ��/.`W�����!1 �t#/ F�� �� >��3 �� � (" �2��" uD7� �� � >��3)UN2z" �N#�t1 �N (�� � ����

� ���! " � �2��" @��� =4Y$� ��l " @.hW2�p5"��?� � ��. 0�� G2�c" Y!7 Y#�" @�A�,5��' �� ��,5��' �.�.eWY$� ���� l<�" ;"�T �T� � � (" ��:��," �� ���a)$� .

Page 8: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

8

دانشگاه هاي نوين روانشناختي پژوهش فصلنامه هيأت تحريريه

مي تبريز، وظيفه و گرامي كه زحمت خود داند از همكاران فاضل

و با راهنمايي اوري مقاالت را بر عهده داشتهد و اند هاي ارزنـده

و اعتالي علمي مجله افزوده و ابراز نظر خويش بر غنا اند، تجليل

.سپاسگزاري كند

�������� �� �� ��������� ���� ���� �������

����� �� � !��"#� $� %�&' �������

��(�"�� ��)%! *+� ��������������� ���� ���� �

�,��' ��"��- $� %�&' �������

��(�&! �� �.� ��������� ���� ���� �������

���/� $�0�&! ���1 %�&' �������

��"�� ���2� ! $� ���' ��� 3��1 �������

��.� ! �4����$ $� ���' 5 6� 7��' �������

� �� �3�8� (��&9 �� %�&' �������

����:! �� *��;1 ��������� ���� ���� �������

��&� � �&�&� �� ���� ��������� ���� ���� �������

���+���� ����"�� <����"= �������

��� ���& > �� �.�:? ��������� ���� ���� �������

�� #���� ��#�� ��������� �%��� ���S% �� ������� ���3�,.

�$�#& '�� ��$��(

Page 9: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

9

)*+& ,�-!� ����$ ��-!� ) � ���� ��#*.� �$�/ )0 1 �2�/ �)3�& ��4���$56

����� �� � ^�2&�z

�� 6G �%b��{

43�)#6'� 43�)�|

4 "SQ

@�"��$ �� ����� Y#2� � F�('� ������* �� �C� ���� �A�'� Y#a#��" �/ � {. -�)$� � �.��" �.��"� Y#a#� � ���i5 �#|t1 �@�� "���lA .�� �� g�/ -�)$� �c�� �$�� � 2�c" �

�� �'� Y#�1 @�� " ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � � {. .��� �J)5��/ �a#7�1 �Z#�!1 ��� ������4 � � {. -�)$� �"�,�$�4 Z��� �� @� ���D�� )},��=α(� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� �

�����4 )},��=α(B�:����A ���� .��� 1�}��a' ,� � @�A��" >��: Z�� ���"� �'��' @���. �&)'�.

�)���� ��� @��' �/ � �a," �c�� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � � {. -�)$� �# � � ������� ��:� ����, " .�c�� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � �C�i#� b#!" i: � � {. -�)$� �� � �"��1

�, " � �a,"�'��� ��� .%#4 �?,1�,#��,,���� �A�'� Y#a#� �#a" ��/ � %�' ����!" �� � ����" � �,)5/ %�' �)��a� �,'��1��%%#4 �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� ���##{1 ���,,� �,# .

h��(�� "�'�:���� �A�'� Y#a#��� {. -�)$��'� Y#�1 �I " �.

1N��#�'���.��� F� � � �'� Y#�1 ���A i���1 ��J�'�� )>�p5" ��,5��' (Email:[email protected]

2N�.��� F� � � �'� Y#�1 ���A �����)$� i���1 ��J�'�� 3Ni���1 ��J�'�� �.�� �$�,.��� ��(�'��

Page 10: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

10

�� 2�

� ;w��" ��/ �� �� F��" �� Y$� �#A��� ���� � Y$� B��. ��#5 �� {. -�)$���1�$ � �/�" ���3 �#|�1 Y!1 ���+)3� � ����):� u�c �� ����� ����" @�Q � �/�

�" �5 ��� �� �" �A�'��" � {. -�)$� ��� @��/ � �A�'� y��' �J�� �� �'��1 �,� ��(�� -�)$� Y�5')���C$� �}�}(.� @� �� �� ���� G$�," Y# *� @��,�

� ��:� � ��� ���. �" �#� 1 ���� �A�'� Y#a#�Y��*� � �i#J'� @�" ��. ����� ���<� c" � �)�# XD1 � ��� Y�$ � �� �?'� ��" H�$ �1 �/�)��'�� $ ���� .( �('� ��

� 7� � �: �� @�� " �����"�$ ���1�" �5!" X���4 � X��"� @�"��$ ��/ ��'�.'� ��� �� ��lA�|� ;9�5" � ����*�" � �:�1?#� � � {. -�)$� � �: �� ��A�'� Y#a

�" Y#�/� i9�6 �����.�.

@�"��$ �� ����� ��C �� � �|z" ;"��� �� �C� �� Y$� @�"��$ �� -�)$� ��/Y$� ���� ���3 �c< �� " �� �� ����� �� ���#5 Y.��? � Y"D$ .�/� �� ��!2 ���

�'�"��$ ��)�� � 7� �6��" �� �C� � @�"��$ �� @� ��|� � -�)$� k�*�" �#<� ;���1 Y$� ��.)@�#9�*� �����.(B3��" �� �� � ���� �a," ����� � {. -�)$�

@���: ��/�"�#4�" @�"��$ � ��� �:�)" �� ���l4�'���$ .@�5 �� Z#�!1 S��)'��� )�}}� (�� I�� �@�,���� ��� � 3�� ��/ �,�i/ ;#�!1 G�$ � {. -�)$� ���� @��'

DC�" � ���� �A�'� Y#a#� %/����. �" ��� Y#�� � Y#a#� %/�� � �)"D$ �.�C5,Q�� �� 2�c" S��)'�)�}}� (� @�C.i4 �@�� " ���� @��' �C��"� ���� ��

� ;w��" ��� � �,)5/ �:��" ��R� � {. -�)$� � �@��A��� �� >�� ;{. �$ @��,���1� ��!)" �R��� �� � {. -�)$� ��!2��. ��,�'� .c" S��)' �#,��/ %&��' � 2�

��� ����<)���� (�" @��'�,)5/ �:��" R� � {. ���� � �'� Y#�1 @��#� ��/�.

@�,���� Y.��� � �,/� ��+1 �, " � ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � � � U�� 1 �� ��� Y#� c" �� @�"��$ ��NY$� ��< ��� b���. � b#!" �'��� � �C�i# .Y<�,. ����"�

2- Kuchinsky 1- Wilson

Page 11: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

11

�A�'� Y#a#� � y��" @�)" �"� Y$� ��. ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � Y�5' �?:�1 ;�3 � {. Y��*� � b�1�" �,#"� ��� �� �)��A ���7 ���#�!1 �)�# � Y$� ���!" ����

Y$� ���)�'�������}}� .( 1 �, � ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � �:�1tX�� � �#� �� ���/" @�A�A� �� @�"��$���? � � {. Y��*� �1 ���$ �� � �/� %��i�� �� @�,���� ���

@� ���,�< � Y����" �(#)' ��� %/�� ��� �� �.�' -�)$� � ��. �)�# ��� �� �/)�@��#. @R������(.X�� ���)? �� �C� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� �� @�,#��� >�+6 �/

� �#,��/ � ��� )$� � @�,���� ����?J' � l: ��� @�"��$ ��� �)? ��C �� G5 Y$�)����"���}}�(.@�)2�� � 2�c" Z��)�}}� (X�J' G:�" ���� �A�'� Y#a#��

��? ���1�� � @�"��$ � ��� � Y�5' @�,���� Y��" ��&�|� � �'��� Xi#J'� � �����'�"��$ �"��. .@�/�1�)�}}� (� 2�c" �� @�� " ���� �A�'� Y#a#� �,#"� �� ��

�" �a," �#|t1 @������ �A�'� Y#a#� � �' �)'�" @�� " � {. -�)$� ���� @��' -������ .

@��,� � �?'� �� �('� �� � �'� Y#�1 @�� " �.���4 � �)#�1 %�' � �:�1 ��" �5!" X���4 � X��"� I)5#$ I?" i: �� Y#�1 @�� " � {. -�)$� ��'�.

�" �'�#� � ����� �|� �'��1%'�� � �.��"� Y#a� � ���� �� ���lJ @���"� ��:� Iw�����)$��@�?: U )&" ��/���� �� ��. ��(1 �� � ��/ @� I#� 1 @���� ���� � �/

��' �x' � ��c," @��,Q ��< ��< ��/l" � ���K' �����):� b���. � �## 1 �l2 ��$� � {. -�)$� �c$)�'� Y#�1 @�� " (�c�� �## 1 ����� �A�'� Y#a#� � @�

�" ����*��� .� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � � {. -�)$� �C#9�('� �� �� �'�A��: ���. �$�� U )&" ���#�!1N��-�)$� �c�� �,#"� �� ����!" ��#5 ���#�!1 �"� �'�

� � � {.N��A F�('� ���� �A�'� Y#a#N" Y$� �)N�,#"� ��� �� Z#�!1 ��7 �� Z�!�"�.�.

���? � �'� Y#�1 @�� " �'��� � ��5: Y"D$ � �|�" ;"��� � Z#�!1 ��� ��

2- Morin 1- Radunche 3- Terhune

Page 12: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

12

@� ���� �A�'� Y#a#�1 �/t�" �#�@� ���$�,. � �� ���. �,#"� � �)? b���. �/G$�,"%,1 �� ��� � �c#!" �� X��� @�� " Y#2� � ��� ��1� � {. ��/ I/��

�"��..

@�� " ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � � {. -�)$� �c�� �## 1 Z#�!1 ��� � 7� g�/@�(����� @�)$� �'� Y#�1�� �3�. .�AK�� � �:�1 � �*�6 Z#�!1 �� �J,/�� ��/

�" �)<���4 X��� @�� " � {. -�)$� u�c$ �$�� � �@�)$� ����):� ��� � ��.c�#a#� � � {. -�)$� � {. -�)$� �� � � ���� �A�'� Y)� �%�' ���� �� �)��a�

�C�i#� b#!" �Y#2�p5" �%�' ����!" �%�' �J'�A�� �%�' (���� �A�'� Y#a#� ��" ���3 %(,$ ���"�" �&�" �?)'� �� � ��#A �� {. -�)$� �� � ��� �� ���.

%#4 �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#��" �,#��,,�

�� B�� 4 ���NK�a#7�1 k�' �� %/�W�" �J)5��/ ���� �� �.� �'��#" X�� � @� ��/B�: ��� � �����A �����}��.�< ����+1 X�� � �� �'� Y#�1 @�� " �� �a' ��

Y��A F�('� ��'�. �&)'� .;"�. �)�53 �$ �"�,�$�4 ����D�� ���� B�: X��$� � ���� �A�'� Y#a#� �"�,�$�4 ��"��� ���D�� @�)2�� >�" -�)�@�)2�� ���� (

�]#$� � {. -�)$� ����'�)$� �"�,�$�4 �)��]#$� V��o (�"�.� .��� ���"� � "�: �'� Y#�1 @�� " �# � ;"�. �%/�K4)@� � ��" (@�(����� @�)$� �$ �/ �� �3�.

>�$ �� ��"� � Z�c" �� Y$� � #+!1 Bc�"�}W����� 1 ��� ���}�" �a' �� �.� ��� 1 �@�A��" >��: -�$� ��}��'� Y#�1 @�� " �� �a' )�3�. @�(����� @�)$� (

� � #+!1 Bc�" �$ �/ ���. �&)'� ���"� �'��' @��,� .����� �## 1 Y?:�"�,�$�4Y$� ��. ���a)$� �.��� Y����" �#1�$� �x' �� �/ .������4 �## 1 ��x," ��"�,�$�4 @�#" �� �/�} �a' � G��* ����A %&4 ����"�� ���7 ��� ��"� Y$�

� ��� � {. -�)$� �"�,�$�4 ;� ��� ���'��� ��a2� Z���)},��=α(�� �"� Y$�� G��* ���� �A�'� Y#a#� �"�,�$�4 ;� ��� ���'��� ��a2� Z��� �� ��"� Y$�

Page 13: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

13

� ���)},��=α(�"� Y$� .���� ;# !1 � ��i(1 ��x," �� �/ �� �a#7�1 ��"� %& ��<�.�<�. � �#J'�#" �,'�" �i��" ��/ � ����'�)$� g��!'� ;�" �A�,���4 ��/

�. ���a)$� �/�����' � >���: .�#*�� �#�t1 �� � �� ��x," � ����,)$� ��"� %& �� �/@�"�� ���. ���a)$� �'�A�,Q @�#$�A� � �� �< �@�$�#4 �J)5��/ G��* ��/ .

������

�]#$� � {. -�)$� ����'�)$� �"�,�$�4 -�$�������" ��� �� �/ �� �� ����� @��1���<-�#�" ��c$ ��?Q �� �C� �� ����" ��. G5� ��#)"� -�$�� � {. -�)$� ��/

��� ���3 ���. -�)$� � b$�)" -�)$� �� #�� -�)$� �-�)$� @�� .-�$� ��� � Y#5,: G56� �����)�� ��" �� @�@(�)$��" ��,�'�. .����. ��/�����' � Z�c"

����� � ����,}� %Y��.�-�)$� @�� @� @�A�,,� ��,�%�� #�� -�)$� �,�%� ���. -�)$� � �,)5/ b$�)" -�)$� ������'��' �� � � ��� ��:� @� ��/

�� �2�6 �� �Y.��'�},�%Y��. �-�)$� @�� ��" @�A�,,���,�%����� -�)$��'��' �� � �,)5/ � #��Y.��' ��:� ���. � b$�)" -�)$� ��" ��/ .� 2�c" ��� ��

�� @�'� �� � #�� � {. -�)$� �c$ � � ��� ��,�%� @���" �� ���,�%���)�#�" @�i#"�.� .����. >���: Z����� � @���" � {. -�)$� �#J'�#" )���,�� (�)�#

{. -�)$� �#J'�#" �� � @�'� � )���,}� (�"�.� .�� � {. -�)$� �#J'�#" �#,��/@�'� �� �C�i#� b#!" � )��,�� (@���" �� %�' ���� �� � �� �)��,�� (���$ ��

Y$� �)�# � {. -�)$� �� � .

Page 14: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

14

��3�%�)�(�*<�� )� 5� # �3 ���) -#��� }�.� ��+, -#��� ��

��3�%�)0(-#��� }�.� �*<�� )� 5� # �3 ��3#� ��+, -#��� ��

Page 15: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

15

7� P)�(-�"2� 43#� � ��+, -#��� ��"&� =�#K�� � �":��"����) �3 �� ��

7� P)0(43#� � ��+, -#��� ��"&� =�#K�� � �":��"�-�"2���3#� �3 �� ��

��D�� ����. >��: ���" @��' � � {. -�)$� ��/�#{)" �# �/� Y#a#� @�,#��� � %/�K4 ��� �� ���� �A�'����, " � �a," �c�� �7�� ���� ��:� ���� .

)}}�/}, p=���/}Wr=.( �c�� ��:� � �,�" IC6 ��� � �� �a7 ��� ��� ��,�, " � � {. -�)$� �# ��� �#9t1 ���� �A�'� Y#a#��"��.)}�/}p<.(

3� &$ 1/� a #j'� a �":��"� 3�� ����� =�#K�� � {. -�)$� V`[ o�V�e Ve[,s� [`,jsm %�' ���� �� V`[ Veh[[o,[� e,oh

�%�' �)��a� V`[ Vs`�[h,Vj,jje %�' �J'�A�� V`[ Vs`j[V,Vm j,`hm %�' ����!" V`[ VV`o[`,`� e,[je

Y#2�p5" V`[ VV`�[j,eo j,Ve` �C�i#� b#!" V`[ V`hh[o,ej j,�[e

3� &$ 1/� a #j'� a �":��"� ����� =�#K��3�� � {. -�)$� Vms m�[s` Ve`,Vh [[,�sj %�' ���� �� Vms Vhh[[o,j[ e,[V`

�%�' �)��a� Vms Vsh`[e,je m,[sm %�' �J'�A�� Vms Vs`�[`,hh j,[jV %�' ����!" Vms V[he[h,�h e,moh

Y#2�p5" Vms V[hV[j,[h e,h` �C�i#� b#!" Vms Vsh`[h,[e m,jm`

Page 16: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

16

7� P)?(� ��+, -#��� ��#"+�� �"� �:�;6% ���' �( �) !"*"'

�(�������' �( �) !"*"'

@�$�#4 G��* s,heVW����" P**s,ssV � {. -�)$�

��� 1 `s[

**��&� ~.� �3 ���3)c�/c<p(

����. >��: ���D����" @��' � {. -�)$� �� � �# ��/�)�%�' ���� ��� �%�' �J'�A�� �%�' ����!"Y#2�p5" �%�' �)��a� (� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� �

@�,#�������� H�� ����" F��1 �� �(#)' �� ���� ��:� ��� �, " � �a," �c�� �7�� �, " �c�� ��:� � �,�" IC6 ��� � �� �a7� {. -�)$� �� � �# ��� )���� ��

�%�' ����!" �%�'� �%�' �J'�A��Y#2�p5" �%�' �)��a� (���� �A�'� Y#a#� ��" �#9t1��. .�A�'� Y#a#� � � {. -�)$� �� � �� �C�i#� b#!" �# �c�� ��?,1

Y5#' ���� �, " � �a," �c�� %/�K4 ��� �� ����) .���/}, p=}��/}r=.( �����,�, " �c�� ��:� F�� � �,�" �a7 ��� ���" ��� �� � �C�i#� b#!" �# ��� Y#a#�

�" �� IC6 ��� � �#9t1 ���� �A�'� ��.)}�/}>p.( 7� P)I(���' �( �) !"*"' � ��+, -#��� 3�&�� �"� �.���

�AK���/���� ��

%�' � �)��a�

%�' �J'�A��

%�' ����!"

%�' Y#2�p5"

b#!"�C�i#�

@�$�#4 G��*s,VoeWs,hoWs,`omWs,eVVWs,V�[Ws,shj ����"P**s,ssV **s,ssV **s,ssV **s,ssV **s,ssVs,h[h

Y#a#� �A�'����� ��� 1 `s[ `s[ `s[ `s[ `s[ `s[

>���: Z�� e�j�m%#4 ��� �� {. -�)$� �� � b$�1 ���� �A�'� Y#a#� �,#�. ��:� ��#{)"�,Q @�#$�A� �� .� �c< �����" �c< G#��1�, " ��� � ����

.��� b�1�" ���� �A�'� Y#a#� �<� )},}}�p= �},}}�=)��,���F(.(G��*

Page 17: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

17

� ��� �'��' �'�A�,Q �J)5��/},����" @��' ������1 �� �/���%Y#a#� ='����� ���" �'��' �� ���� �A�'���. ���� �#*�1 � {. -�)$� �� � �c< G#��1 � �'��1 .

%#4 �� �'�J'��/�" �,#�/ F��1 ��.�J)5��� ��/ � � {. -�)$� �� � �# ���#{)"�� �a," ���� �A�'� Y#a#� .�A�'� Y#a#� � %�' ����!" � �# �9i: �J)5��/

� � �# �9i: �J)5��/ �#,��/ � �����, " ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � %�' �)��a� ���Y$� .�" ;# !1 ��� -�$���� Y��A �(#)' �#,Q @��1 �?,1 %#4�,#��,,���/ ��#a"

� � %�' ����!" �� ��" � �,)5/ %�' �)��a� �,'��1��%�A�'� Y#a#� ���##{1 ��%#4 ���,,� �,# .%#4 �#� I?$ �� �2�6 ���,#��,,� �/)�J'�A�� ��C�i#� b#!"

Y#2�p5" � %�' ������ �%�' (�%�.� �".7� P)N(��"�#(� 7 � �o8�

>�" R��l("R("��lR��. ;�� 1 ����'�)$� g��!'�Vas,em[ s,`[o s,`Vh V[,hVh

a." ��#"+����"�4 ��') :!��@ �� 2�(E2� ���'��� E2� �:��(�3 E�S�U"� J"K� E�� E!"<��;�2� 43� K� � 2� ����*'

7� P)M(x���� ANOVAb

9������ ��%�� �3�)� 9�P�3 9������ �":��"� FSig $�A�@�# [[Vhm,`s� j`j�V,[Vo [`,�e[**as,ssV

��'��#3� hehjV,m`o [�e Veh,Vso ;� jmjs�,shj `sV

" ��#"+����"�4 ��') :!��@ �� 2�(E2� ���'��� E2� �:��(�3 E�S�U"� J"K� E�� E!"<��;�2� 43� K� � 2� ����*'

b.�8� #"+��:�( �) !"*"'

Page 18: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

18

7� P)>(F��#_ a��"�#(�

3�� �����#"i F�#_ F�#_3�� �����B=�#K�� ��.�3�� �����Beta

tsig �:�;6%�TUP

Y�| ����" V[[,VV� h,�h� W[h,j�V **s,ssV W%�' ������ s,soWs,VeV s,s[�Ws,e[�Ws,e�m s,VoeW

�%�' �)��a�s,jseWs,V`h s,[o`Wh,e`W**s,ssV s,hoW�J'�A��%�' s,s`h s,Vej s,sVe s,[V� s,o[m s,`omW

%�' ����!" s,�V�Ws,Vme s,`hhWe,[emW**s,ssV s,eVVWY#2�p5" s,VoVWs,Ve s,smWV,[seWs,[[� s,V�[W

�C�i#� b#!" s,Vh[ s,VsV s,sm[ V,hs` s,Vj[ s,shj

.a�8� #"+�� :�( �) !"*"'

��"�� � dK��#"(

#)' ���)�?" � �#2���(�# �� Y$� ��� Y$� ��"� Y$� � �*�6 Z#�!1 �� �� �� ���� ��:� �c�� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � � {. -�)$�)� � {. -�)$� �# B3�� ��

@�,#��� � %/�K4 ��� �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#����, " � �a," �c�� �7�� ��:� ��������(��� �A�'� Y#a#� �� {. -�)$� %��i�� � �(#)' �� ��" %/�� �%/�� � � ���

�" %��i�� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� @���� .�2�J# ���#�!1 S��)')����(� #�� ���K')����(�'�3�< ����� )����(�>��'�� i���)2� �)����(���'�4 �)�}�}(@�5 �� �)�}}�W

�}}�(�,A�)'�"R ��%'���C�/ )�}}�(@�#5,$ �-�2��� )�}}�(����AY3�1�@�$��'� )���� (@���C�/ � >���� �)��� � �2� ����� �'��&�/ � H��c'� �)��� ��� �

)�}}� (����' Y��c" .

���� ��:� �c�� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � %�' ���� �� �# �*�6 � 2�c" Z�� .��� %�' ���� �� �#{)" �# B3�� @�,#��� � %/�K4 ��� �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#���

�� �7���, " � �a," �c���� ��:� ���� .%'���C�/ � @�'�/ ���#�!1 S��)')����(��'�1)�}}�(������ ��2��2 �]$��)�}}�(�'�3�< �@���C�/ � ����)���� (�)��� ��� �

Page 19: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

19

���� �'��&�/ � H��c'� .�" �,#"� ��� �� �)��� F�('� �� 2�c" Z�� Y��A �(#)' @��1� ���#' �'��#)�4 � X��"� � �: �� � {. ���� ���|� %/�� � �(," �5)'� �� ;�3 ��

�" ��� ���#' ���� �A�'� Y#a#� ���? � %�' ���� ���" -�$� ��� � ���. @��1�" �;{. � �5)'� �� ;�3 X��� @�� " �'��#)�4 � X��"� � Y��A �(#)' �� �|� @��1

��� �� � ��� %/�� �� X��� @�� " �� %�' ����@� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� Z��� �� �/�#�& ���? .

� �# �*�6 � 2�c" Z��� %�' �)��a� ���� ��:� �c�� ���� �A�'� Y#a#�.��� ��/�#{)" �# B3��� %�' �)��a� @�,#��� � %/�K4 ��� �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#�

���, " � �a," �c�� �7�� ���� ��:� ���� .�)��� � �)��� ����/�'�3�< �� ����/N@���C�)���� (%'���C�/ � ��� �)�}�} (/N���� �'��&� .� ��� �##�1 ��N�#*�

�"�"�'� I#x,1 � �� YaA @��1�++&1 X��"� ��/)����Y"�< ��* ��/ (��K��-D����� � ��J#�" ��/ � X���4 � X��"� I)5#$ b$�1 �)#�1 � �$�,�'��� ��/

� %'�� ���? g�/���?" ���6 ��#' � G$�,)" X��� @�� " ��/���" @�. @��1� � �� �.�' � {. -�)$�@� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � ��� %/�� �� %�' �)��a� �� �/

�#�& ���? .

�#{)" �# �*�6 � 2�c" Z�� ���� ��:� �c�� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � %�' �J'�A�� .�" B3�� ���/�#{)" �# YaA @��1� %�' �J'�A�� ���� �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#�

@�,#��� � %/�K4���, " � �a," �c�� �7�� ���� ��:� ����.� @�'�/ � 2�c" S��)'%'���C�/ )���� (�@�$��'� � Y��1 ���A)���� (�'�3�< �@���C�/ � ���� )���� (�

���� Y��c" �*�6 � 2�c" �)��� .aA ��� �#*�� ��� �##�1 �� �/�A� � X��� @�� " Y�" ��#.��� @� -�$� � �� �2�7� �� F�('� ��� ��< Y���#4 ��� �� ��'� � ��'�.

@� �� ��� b#!" �� �� ���/��)�� �� �/�A� � �,/��" ��x)'� �/ �� ��'� �� �/�A� � ����@� � {. U���� @��,��" �5!" �/� �)5'�� � ��.�Y��2��x)'� � � {. ��/ �1�

Page 20: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

20

@� �� �$��" ���" ���� b#!" �� ���" ����� �/ %�' �J'�A�� � {. %,1 ;"�� �,'��1�,,� ��� ��< ���� �A�'� Y#a#� ���? � � %/�� �� .

�� ����� ��:� �c�� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � %�' ����!" �# �*�6 � 2�c" Z���" B3��� %�' ����!" ��/�#{)" �# YaA @��1 A�'� Y#a#� %/�K4 ��� �� ���� �

@�,#��� ����, " � �a," �c�� �7�� ���� ��:� ���� .��� � �)��� ���N�)��/�'�3�</ � ����N@���C�)���� (%'���C�/ � ��� �)�}�} (���� �'��&�/ .�(#)' ��

�" � ��� @����" �%�' ����!" � �� �.�' � {. -�)$� %/�� ��x," � YaA @��1 ��&1��K1��)$� ����x)'� ���" �� X��� @�� " ���1 =6 ��(�� �� B'�" �G$�," ��/

@� �� @����"@� �Ca1 � �/ b���. ��(�� � � �'�. �Y$� �#!7 �Q @� ���" �� �/ �� X��� I " �C,�� -�56� � �'�� �# �� �� ��� ;!" �� �J,/��/�' -�56� � c"

@� �� Y$� I#?$ �$��" � ���" Y#���"�,,� ��(�� �/ .

B3�� �� ���� ��:� �c�� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � Y#2�p5" �# �*�6 � 2�c" Z���"� Y#2�p5" ��/�#{)" �# YaA @��1 @�,#��� � %/�K4 ��� �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#����, " � �a," �c�� �7�� ���� ��:� ���� .�� �4��� �A�'� � ���� b���. ���? ��#,

� 2�c" ��F�� ��� @��' g�� �� Y���6 �� @���C�/ @�)$�4�$ � �(," ���� ;!" ��� ��i'� %��i�� ���C�/ F�� �" @���C�/ � Y�5' Y#2�p5" -�56� ���(#)' �� ��.

� D)� �c< -�)$� ��" �'R�� �" %��i�� ��� ;!" �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � ����" %/�� ���)�-�,.�' �}}� .(��)' �#,��/�'�3�< � �*�6 � 2�c" S@���C�/ � ����

)����(���� �'��&�/.

%/�K4 ��� �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � �C�i#� b#!" �#{)" �# �*�6 � 2�c" Z���c��Y.��' ��:� �� .�# �c�� ��:� � �,�" Z#�!1 ��� �� IC6 ��� �(#)' ��

�" �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � �C�i#� b#!"��. .$�x' S��)' >�$ �� �� � " �(,�}}��� " �5$�" b$�1 �,��� Y.��? �� 2�c" �)��� � Y��A F�('� ��� b#!"

���� Y��c" �*�6)�-�,.�' �}�} .(�'�3�< �)��� � �*�6 � 2�c" �)��� �#,��/ � ����

Page 21: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

21

@���C�/)���� (�" �5�/�'�.� .� YaA ��� �#*�� ��� �##�1 ���" �x' ��$�� �� ���#5 ��� b#!" � b�1�" ;"��)�+&. � $�1 � >D�)$� �Y3��� �,'�" (�"�,'��1

b#!" �� �.�' � {. -�)$� ��:� � �)6 �� ���lJ �#|t1 ���� �A�'� Y#a#� ���C�i#� �.� R� ���� �A�'� Y#a#� .

�� {. -�)$� �� � �*�6 � 2�c" Z�� %#4 �� ���� �A�'� Y#a#��" �,# � �,,� F��1�J)5��/ �a," ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � � {. -�)$� �� � �# ���#{)" �� ��/Y$� .�#,��/ � ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � %�' ����!" � �# �9i: �J)5��/ �2�

� � �# �9i: �J)5��/�, " ���� �A�'� Y#a#� � %�' �)��a�Y$� ��� .�)���� 2�c" @���C�/ � ��� � 2�c" � �*�6 )�}�} (�/���� �'��& .@� ��%#4 �?,1 �� �:�,# ��,,�� � %�' ����!" �� � ��#a" ��/�" � �,)5/ %�' �)��a� �,'��1��%���##{1 ��

%#4 �� �A�'� Y#a#��,,� �,# .%#4 �#� I?$ �� �2�6 ���,#��,,� �/)b#!"Y#2�p5" � %�' ������ �%�' �J'�A�� ��C�i#� (�%�"#)' �� �.� � @����" �(

R�p5"� � %�' ����!" � � ��� @� �,.� �).�� ��)�# �:�1 %�' �)��a��,.� � �� ��� �a," ���|� �� ��#J�#4 Y?: ���/��C/�� ��7��.��/ >��" @��,�

�@�i#" G$�,1 ���Q �AK�� � �D#+!1 b#!" ��/��#' � ��� ��(1 � �.��"� ��/�.� �)�� ��� )�, ���.� �)�# %�' �)��a� (Y# �3 � $�1 � ��#' ��� � �'�5'� ��/

���� ��)�# F���" Y#,"� � �.� Y7�� �#"t1.G$�,1 � Y�5' �)�# �:�1 � �(#)' ���@�i#" �AK�� � �D#+!1 ���� b#!" ��/��#' � X��� @�� " ��(1 � �.��"� ��/

�"�a2z" @��1;�" ���� �A�'� Y#a#� ��/Y# �3 � $�1 Y7�� �#"t1 � �'�5'� ��/�#�& ���? �� F���" Y#,"� � �.� .

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :[�/VV/V`�s �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :Vm/s[/V`�V �2��" X��l4 r���1:[h/sm/V`�V

Page 22: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

22

q���� References

��2�J# ��1��!")����(.@��A��T ���T �A�'� Y#a#T � ��T @�"��$ ����):� �: %�' �$���'�<��T �) ,7 ��/)�3�. @�(����� @�)$� ����" � 2�c"(��&��P�3#���H ����, ����. ����

��}�.

�'�3�<����� ��1�" ������� -��� �$�1�#��#' �� 5" ���'��6� �x,")����(.-�)$� �c�� �$��@�)$���# �� ;w�. @���)$�4 ���T �A�'� Y#a#T � � {.�� 5" ��/��#' G&)," ��/ �������

���D� Fb ����. �`m

-� >��'� �2�. �>� @��#. @R��.)����(.���;�� J���� � ���'��' ���� !�#� � � ���!" ��:�1 �!" � �$�����9�7 �� �)2�� Y����" X��"� i��" �I)a/ P�Q.

� � �@�#9�*�)����(.����� ���� !�#� �)���#�" ����)�� ����� !�#� �(�>�� P�Q�@��?1 :@�"��$�'�5'� F� � G)� ����1 � � 2�c" )Y�$(���W�.

-��.�>��'�� ����)2� �Y�i#2�)���� .(��+, -#��� :^�#._� � -#��� !�#� ����)��� 3#� ��#� ��:��< �*�"Dw I:�)"���4 �>�� P�Q @��?1 :�1�� �����)'�.

��'�� $ �����)����(.����)�� ����� 3�6f� � ���' �( �) !"*"'��@��?1 ��' �Y����" ��C�'�� ��}W��.

� #���2��.�" ���K'��Q��c� �# $�#" ��;A�#(" ��������?Q �2�/ ���A)����(.5���" -�)$� �c$ �%& @� @���)$�4 � {.@�)$���# U )&" ��/ �@���� �E.i4 F� � ��J�'�� � �1 ��/ ����

��#�� ��8�� ���f%P $�� �r,U [��G 4�:���3 ����. �����? ���������.

�%&��' X�?" ��������< �#56)����(.;"�� �$��;"�� � � {. ������� ��/ ��'���?J' ��/ ;{.@� y��1�� �����/� @�)$�?. �'� Y#�1 ��" @��#� � {. ��C �� � �/ ���� ��� ��"%'5"k%<� ����. ���� ���W��.

Anonymous (2007). Work-related Stress, European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, www.eurofound.europa.eu.

Anonymous (2009). Working Conditions and Quality of Life in Spanish Workplaces, European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, Information@ eurofound.europa.eu.

Page 23: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

23

Censidine, Gillian, Callus, Ron. (2001). The Quality of Work Life of Australian Employees-The Development of an Index.university of Sydney.

Corral.Antonio, Isusi.Iñigo (IKEI, Spain) (2003). European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, Quality of Life in the Spanish Workplace, www.eurofound.europa.eu.

Gray-Toft, P.A., & Anderson, J.G. (1985). Organizational Stress in the Hospital: Development of a Model for Diagnosis and Prediction, Health Services Research, 19(6 Pt 1), 753-774.

Hannon. John, Huang. Ing-Chung, Lin. Cheng-Chen (1994). The Mediating Effects of Pre- and Post-Assignment Activities on the Quality of Work Life of Expatriates: Evidence for Managers in the P.R.C. Purdue CIBER Working Papers, Center for International Business Education and Research Purdue University, pp 2-20.

Kuchinsky, C. (2006). The Most Stressful Jobs in America Stress in the American Workplace, Retrieved June 8, 2009 from the World Wide Web http://www.Associatedcontent.

Lamontagne.Anthony D, Keegel. Tessa, Louie. Amber M, Ostry. Aleck, Landsbergis. Paul A. (2007). Asystematic Review of the Job-stress Intervention Evaluation Literature, 1990-2005, Vol 13/no 3, www.ijoeh.com

Morin, E,M. Morin, W. (2003). Quality of Work Life and Firm Performance:The Case of Teknika, HEC Montreal, Department of Management, Canada.

Osipo, S.H. (1998). Occupational Stress Inventory Revised Edition (OsI-R) Professional Manual, Odessa, fla: Psychological Assesment Resources, inc.

Panari. Chiara, Guglielmi. Dina. (2010). Can an Opportunity to Learn at Work Reduce Stress? A Revisitation of the Job Demand-control Model, Journal of Work Place Learning, Vol. 22, Iss. 3; pg. 166.

Radunche, R. Loosee, B. Jegek, Uh. Khairuddin, ID. (2006). An Analysis of Quality of Work Life (QwL) and Career Related Variables, American Journal of Applied Science 3(12): pp 2151-2159.www. scipub.org

Scott, E. (2010). Chronic Job Stress Is a Risk Factor for Heart Disease, The New York Times Company

Page 24: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

24

Turner, D. (2007). Boost Standards' Call by Ofsted Private Sector Hit by NHS Demand; [London 2nd Edition], Financial Times, London(uk),pg.6.

Terhune, M.N. (2006). A Study of Demographics and Gob-related Categories That Schools with Indigenous Populations, Doctor of Education in Education, Montana State University.

Virick.Meghna, Lilly; Juliana, Casper; Wendy (2007). Doing More with Less; An Analysis of Work Life Balance among Layoff Survivors,Career Development International, Bradford: Vol. 12, Iss. 5.

Wilson, BP. (2006-2007). Implications of Work-life Balance and Job Stress, Human Solutions™ Report, pp 16-22, www.humansolutions.ca

Wu.Hui, Zhao, Yang, Jia-Na. Wang, Wang. Lie. (2010). Factors Associated with Occupational Stress among Chinese Doctors: A Cross-sectional Survey, Int Arch Occup Environ Health, 83: 155-164.

Walton, R.E. (2005). Quality of Work Life (QWL) Measurment, www.syn.dgn.com

Walton, R.E. (1973). Quality of Work Life "What Is It?" Management Review Fall; p 11-21.

Page 25: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

25

7�.� 8% 9:! '�� ����$ $( ) �4�� )�;0� �/ � )<-=:�( ���>?-�� �&(�;� @�A� ���

9���� ��G %K�z

O���� �%�� 4 "�{

�%��� �_�|

4 "SQ I5#'�C" �� ���$��' � ��'@�(#/ � U���� I#x,1 ��/I)5#$ ��/1 Y!1 �� �.����4 ��/t���3 �#|

����)<� � Y"D$ ��: �DC�" >D�)<�,�'��� ��/�"�'��A .�$�� g�/ � �*�6 %/�K4;�� 1 %�'��$ �# �c�� �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,�>D)<� ��. � �J)5�2� ��/ g�+" ��/

�. F�('� ���".��)$�� ��� �� >D)<� � D)�" ��" ���# �� � Y5#��7 ��/ ��� �� ���" g�+"�'��� Y��. %/�K4 .Y��. ��@�A�,,���$ -�#�" �. �)$��< �J)5�2� ��/>�5A�i )AAI(�

�)'��1 �'�(#/ ���A�' -�#�")TAS-20 (��#)�� ��. �<�. �)ASI(�,,� ;#�C1 �� .���� ��/X�� �� ���a)$� � %/�K4��/�a#7�1 � ���"� ;# !1 � 5 $ ��#{)"�,Q @�#$�A� � �� 1 ��1��"

�,)��A ���3 �$�� ���" .%/�K4 S��)'>D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' � ���� �J)5�2� ��$ �� ��� @��' g�+" ��/

c�� ���"���$ � Y.�� �a," �����' �J)5�2� ��/)��A�$�� � ��,):� (��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' �>D)<�c�� ���" g�+" ��/��,).�� Y��" .�'�(#/ ���A�' �� ��� @��' �#,��/ %/�K4 S��)'

��$ �# �c��>D)<� ��. � �J)5�2� ��/ g�+" ��/�" ;�� 1 �� ���"�,� .�(#)' �� %�' ;�� 1�" �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,�I5#'�C" G56 � @��1��/@�Q ���,)" @�(#/ �� � 7�� ��(�� ��/

���' �##�1 �'�(#/ � �"D� b��� ;#?51 � �'�"�� ��< ��a,".

h�� ��(� "�':��J)5�2� ��'�(#/ ���A�'��#)�� ����" g�+" >D)<� .

1N@��?1 ��J�'�� ��)$� )>�p5" ��,5��'(Email:[email protected]

2N@��?1 ��J�'�� ��,#2� �$�,�'��� �.�� -�,.��� 3N@��?1 ��J�'�� ��#�'��

Page 26: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

26

�� 2�

%/�K4���� @��' �/�A�'�"�� �# �� �'��c�� ���" g�+" � �'��� ��/ �,1�J,1 �� ���� ��:�)�=#'���4 � ���)$� �;5�[ss` .( �,����' �2��)6� %�' X��l4 ��� � �R�

�J)5�2�V���� ��:� ���" g�+" >D)<� ��#A ;C. �,���� �� )aw ����� � ��� ��)$�V`oj ��#56��4 � �'�"��#" ����� �V`os .( � �@�����4 ���x' �� �/��A

Y?: ����� �� ���?'� ��+<@��� ��#A U# * �J)5�2� �� �'��) " ��,)5/ �����4�" ���" g�+" �c< �� ���� �)��A ���3 ��� ����� �#2�� @���� �� ��.)����

V��V .( Y'R�� �x' �)V��e (����G#$� �;�!)" ����" � ;C2� g�+" � Y�5' ��l4�J)5�2� ��/��#' �� Y aw��. @�. ���7 � �� @� ���" � ;C2� g�+" � �� �'�

�" @���: ���,+"�,,� .�a," �a��� I#x,1 Z��� �� R��)6� ���� �' �J)5�2�)����'�(#/ �A�'�"�� %/�� ��x," � ���" g�+" >��" (�$ �����" g�+"�" �(," ��.

)���1��1 � =����� ���J,2 ������� �-�]$��[sse ���" � ���2 ��a2�4 ��2�,C" �[ss` .( @���C�/ � �2�,C")[ss` (��$ �# �c�� �� �� ��,���� �2�" �J)5�2� ��/

���" g�+" � >�5A�i);C2� �K�� � (� � ��" �i#J'� �� �'��� @��' � �'��� �$�� -�)$�)@�#.�'�'�(#/ �A�'�"�� %/�� ��x," � (� �J)5�2� ��$ �# �c�� ��

�c$�� %�' ;C2� g�+"���� ��.

�" ��#"�' �J)5�2� ����" � ����' �# �a��� �'�#4 ��.)���2�V�j� .(��2� )V�j� (���:���: ��)�� �� Y$� ��) "[� �����' �#2�� @���� �� ��. ��w� ���)�� I)5#$ � #$�

�J)5�2�`�" I#x,1 ��. .� ��� Y$� ���C �� ���)�� ��� � Y�3��" @���� Y$���3 ���� �� Y���6�J)5�2� ���J' �� �1�'�� � �1h�" ��#"�' ��. .��#. � @��/

)V�om(���" @R�5A�i �J)5�2� �,���� U�� 1 ��x," � �� ���� �J)5�2� �� 2�c" �� �'��� ���3 ��J'�� �� �J)5�2� ��$ �$��,):� ���e��A�$�� �j'��� �&�" �� N�.

2- proximity 4- attachment figure 6- ambivalence

1- attachment 3- attachment behavioral system 5- avoidant

Page 27: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

27

�" ���3� ���i' b��� �)6�� � ���� ��&.�� � �,,��" U�� 1 ������ @��,� �'�.� ���)�� Y# �3 ����� ���" ��(1 �� ��)�� ����: ��c*� � �,)5/ @��J�� �,,� .

�,):� ������,'��J' �? 1 � Y#�#�7 ���" �� �A .��� ����� H�#).� ��A�$�� ������" ��(1 �� ��� �� -�1 >�6 �#� �� ��'��� Y#�#�7�,,�.

�)������� @��' ��/�K4 ��/��7�+&" ������' �J)5�2� ��$ �� �'����,):� ��Y$� B��. ;C2� � �)5�� @����#)����4 � @�5C: ��. ��,#�'�&'��[ssh .( Z��

�)�����$ �# ���. ��� ��/ �c�� ���" g�+" >D)<� � @R�5A�i �� �J)5�2� ��/���� ��:� .�c�� ��� �� ��J�� ;"��� �� Y$� ���$ �c< �c�� �� �c�� ��� ��� �"�

;�� 1 %�'��'��� ��,,��" �x' � ���:�" �/��. Z�� �)<�,�'��� ��/�#{)" �$��'�(#/ ���A�' ;�" �� )"V��$ �# �c�� �� >D)<� � �J)5�2� ��/ g�+" ��/

;�� 1 %�' ���"�,.� �).�� ��,,� .

�'�(#/ ���A�')�-�,a#$V�m`�-�,a#$ � �#�' �V�ms(���(1 �� ���$��' � �� @�# @�(#/ I#x,1D�� �/�" H��. .� ��?Q �� ���$��' � ��' � ��'�(#/ ���A�'

�" �&�" u�. ��� ���. :�# @�. ;9�3 i���1 � ��$�56� @�# �� ���$��' � ��$�56� @��� �#*�1 �� ���$��' ��'�(#/ �J)&#J'�� �'� ������� � ��$�56�

Y?: � �,#� �)<�,. ��$ ����!" ��5(1 ��/�,���� �@��J����#A�'��# W��!" ��!"[)�����4 � ��J ��� #1V��m.(

>D)<� ��� ��c< ;"�� �'�(#/ ���A�'� ��5: � �'��� ��/�" ���. ���)�����V`om �U2�V`om �@���C�/ � �� #1 �V��m .( �DC�" � �'�(#/ ���A�' �#

���� ��:� �c�� �+&. �#)�����V`oo �Y�$� � >�?'�� ��'�J" �U2�[sso .(��$ � �� �'�(#/ ���A�' �c�� ��#�#4 �� 2�c" @��' ��,):� � ��$ �+&. �# ��/

���� �'�)�=1��A� � �'�J" �Y�$� �>�?'��[ssm .(;C2� �)�# g�+" � �'�(#/ ���A�' >D)<� �Y$� b�1�" ;C2� g�+" ��/)���# � ����� ����'�$ ���#[sso��'�� �����1 �

2- stimulus-bound, externally orientated cognitive style 1- Alexithymia

Page 28: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

28

�-��#2 � @�#2�$[ss� �;?'�� � ���� �[ssj .( �#he�1jmg�+" �7�� @�A�,,���. �)<�,. �'�(#/ ���A�' I�D� ����� �;C2� �'�)� �����2�� �i#�$ �@��� ���$ �@���

�@���C�/[sso�� �=������ �-��2 ��-�/R�� � ;��52 ��,�1V��m .( �/��. �� ���� @��'� �� ;C2� g�+" >D)<� @�"�� S��)' �'�(#/ ���A�' �� �'� �a," ���7

1 Y!1t�" ���3 �#| �/�)�C$������ � -��A ��C$�C2���V�V��e �@���C�/ � -��2 �V��m .(� 2�c"�� ��� @��' �+" �� ���" � �)5�� @���" ���" �� �� �,Q �� �7�&.�

�" g�+" ���"�" g�+" ���" �� �?,1 �� ������ �� �,,��A�' ��,,� @�(#/ �'�1)��#.�[ssV .( >D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' Y��" �c�� %/�K4 �,Q S��)' �#,��/

1 �� ;C2� g�+"t���� �#� �'�)�F�)52�/ � ��5$V��m �" � iJ,#"�� ���. ��, ���/ ������"V�oo.(

��$ �# ��J�� ��$ ������ ��:� �c�� i#' �'�(#/ ���A�' � �J)5�2� ��/ .%/�K4,#"� �� ��. F�('� ��/�c�� ���$ @��' �'�(#/ ���$��' � �J)5�2� ��/

�����AK�� �� �'���$ �� �'�(#/ ���$��' � y��" ��/ �)�# �����' �J)5�2� ��/ Y$�)�����V`oo�#,:��� ��5���1 � ��)4 � �#Q��4 �[ssV ;�� A�A ��A�,�

�YA��1 � Y5���:[ss[ ;�@����� � �A�i��1 ������ �@��?,#]$� ��J,#2� ������[ssh ;��$�� � ����2� ��1�]5��� ��Q����)'�"[ssh .( i�#: � F��'�)V��h (�A���'�< ;"���

�'��� �$�� �� �'�(#/ ���$��' � b�1�" .@��' %/�K4 @� S��)' �� �'����� �� ��� b#!" ����. ��i ���/ �� � ��� �"��' � F����' �'�(#/ � �'��5: �x' �� �� �'�

@�(#/ ���$��C.� ��" ���"� �" ;�� � Y '��" �/�Y2�6 � Z��" �'�(#/ ��/ @�.��' ��� ���(1 �� �(#)' �� � �'�#A�@�(#/ �" Y6���' �/�'�. .����.� ���@���� � �/

Z�"�$ ���� �� ����A�$�� � �'��J' � Y$� �C�" @�(#/ ���� ��� G$�," ��/��. �?)," ��$�56� .@���C�/ � ��#'����)V��� ( 2�c" �� �� �'��� X��iA��(1 ����� @���(�'���N�'��"�� �U# * ����" Y�3��" 7�+&" ��/��,#"� �� �����.�

1- Ziolkowski, Gruss & Rybakowski

Page 29: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

29

�AK�� ���$�56� �����'��� @��' �'�(#/ ���$��' ��/ .���2 � �"���)V��e (�'��) " � �,� �:��" Y5C. � �� @��� -�56� �'�JQ ��#A��� �'��1 �" �����' �J)5�2� ��

���$ ����/ �'�(#/ ���$��' � D)� ��� �� �,#"� .����)V`oo(�# ����� ���'���� �J)5�2� ��$�a2�" � �'�(#/ ���$��' � �# � ����, " �a," �c�� @� ��/

��$�a2�" � �'�(#/ ���$��' � ��A�$�� � ��,):� �J)5�2� ��/c�� @� ��/�Y��" ���� ��:� ����, " .�" ��,):� �J)5�2� ��$ �� ��� ���' %/�K4 ��� S��)' �'��1

� y��" ���##{1"��$�56� U#7�1 �� ����.� "��$ �� �2�6 �� ��,� �##�1 �� � y��" ���##{1 Y5'��1 ��A�$�� �J)5�2�"��$�56� ���$�,. �� ����.� "�"�Ca1

�,#� "�,� �,# %#4 ��.

�" >��'� �� �'�A�� ���/ �*�6 %/�K4 ��)aA %#4 ��/�K4 �/��. � ��,)$� ��,� :c�� �$�����$ ��. � �'�(#/ ���$��' � �J)5�2� ��/>D)<� ����" g�+" ��/

;�� 1 %�' �$�� ���$ �# �c�� �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,� ��. � �J)5�2� ��/>D)<����" g�+" ��/ .�)��� � ��x' ��x6D" � �:�1 � �� ��:�" ��/�K4 ��/

,#"���#*�� ��$�� ���" k�*�" �'�. �$�� ��� u�. � %/�K4 ��� ��/ :VW��$ ���� �J)5�2�>D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' �c�� ���" g�+" ��/����� �a," �[W

��$ �����' �J)5�2� ��/)��A�$�� � ��,):� (>D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' � ��/���� Y��" �c�� ���" g�+"�`W>D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' ���" g�+" ��/

c�������� Y��" hW�# �c�� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��$ >D)<� ��. � �J)5�2� ��/��/ �" ;�� 1 �� ���" g�+"�,�.

B�� �� ��#P� B�� � ���%� E����� �&��P:� D)�" @���" �%/�K4 ���"� � "�:

>D)<�� :��" ���" g�+" ��/ ;"�. �@��?1 �� ���" g�+" @�"�� i��" ��?Q � ��,,� ��c," �����?. ���" g�+" @�"�� �#,# �o. ���c," �����?V[��c," �����?. �

Vm �#1 �'�"� � 7�� �� �� �� I#�. ���" g�+" @�"�� i��" �o�@�� �1 o���� �

Page 30: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

30

�'�� ���� � :��" i���" .;"�. %/�K4 ��� �'��'V[[ X�� � �� �� ��" ���# �2��)" �� :��" G56 � � �,���/V�&)'� ��. ��� �'�"� ���� �� H�� i���" �

�'�. .�D"�'��"�� ���� Y?: ���/ D)� �� �,1���� �� �. �)��A �x' �� �'��' � �/ ;3��6 �).�� ����" g�+" >D)<� �Vm�����6 �je� @�'��< ���'��1 ��$ >�$

>D)<� �� >D)<� �).��' ��).�'X��iA ��< -�$� � �J�� ����/ ��/ � @����# �/�'��4 �� ��. Y�| ���D�� ��)5 Fi )5" �� �$ � ��* ���$ �).��' � @����# ��

�.� ��� @�. .%/�K4 �� �'��' ��� 1;�� 1 %�' �� ���/�" �$�� �� ��,,� �,,� ;3��6 ���Vss �.� �a' )������ � �'�/���V`oh .( �)��A �x' �� � � �-�$� ��� �

���. ��� ��/��# "V[[ �*�6 %/�K4 �� ��" ���# �'��� Y��. .�,$ �#J'�#"�'��"�� �/e/`[�,"�� � >�$ V��1j`��# " g��!'� � >�$ [V/o�� .� �� �'����#

�"�,�$�4 ��'�. %/�K4 ���� �x' ���" ��/��# " -�$� �� �� �� %/�K4 ��/�'��� ;#�C1 ����a'� ���7 � �����(".

��� ����U�� 7�;(�U� �:�;6<3 -�"2�)AAI:( �">�5A�i �J)5�2� -�#[���" �� ���a)$� � �� �

�J)5�2� @�"�� ��#. � @��/)V�om (�'��' ���" �� � �)<�$Y# �: �� ���/ �'���� ��/ Y$� ��. �����(,/)�����V`oh:[sVV(@�"�� ^� �Ve��$ �$ � Y$� �2�z$

J)5�2�N'� �� �� ��A�$�� � ��,):� ����� �N���� ��/e�:�� ����E#2)I� � #<=V�I�=[�b$�)"=`���� �=h���� � #< �=e(�"�(,$ .�'��"�� ���' �����6 � ;3��6 ��

-�#�"��� G#1�1 � @�"�� ��/e�[e�� �/��< .%$�4 ���'��� ��a2� G���*��/ -�#�"���'��' �� ���" �� ��A�$�� � ��,):� ����� ��/����(�'�� )Vho=n�ojs

��)<�j[s54�(�'��"�� ;� ��� G#1�1 � �/oe/s�oh/s�oe/s@���(�'�� ��� ��)<�oj/s�o`/s�oh/s�54 @���(�'�� ��� �oh/s�oe/s�oj/s�� �. ��$�!"

/ �'��'N�'��� �'�5�`" �< NA�i �J)5�2� -�#�NY$� >�5 .�# �J)5��/ G���*

2- Adult Attachment Inventory 1- consecutive referrals 3- internal consistency

Page 31: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

31

���' �'��' �� ��/`ss�'��"�� �� ��a' 7�� � Y�' �� �� �/�%(,$ ��� �)a/ ��?Q ���"���� �����4V�. ��$�!" .��$ ���" �� G���* ��� � ��,):� ����� �J)5�2� ��/

�'��"�� ;� ��� ��A�$�� G#1�1 � �/om/s�o`/s�oh/s��� ��)<� @���(�'�� oj/s�o[/s�oe/s�54 @���(�'�� ��� �oo/s�o`/s�o`/s�'��' �� �. ��$�!"

Y��*� ���"���� �����4Y$� -�#�" %& .����)!" �����[>�5A�i �J)5�2� -�#�" ���' �# �J)5��/ G���* %(,$ � ���" �$�,�'��� @�++&)" �� �a' ��i'�4 ��/

Y��A ���3 �$� .�*��$ ��� >��,� Z���1 G�� � ��,):� ����� �J)5�2� ��/ G#1�1 � ��A�$��os/s�jV/s�em/s�. ��$�!" .@�"i�/ �����`�J)5�2� -�#�"

-�#�" @�"i�/ ���:� Z��� �� >�5A�i ��/"�+&. �# �DC�" "�"��< Y"�6Y#�$� �4�� "�'��' �� ���" ��`ss�'��"�� �� ��a' ������ �/�..G���* S��)'

�'��"�� ���' �# �� ��� @��' @�$�#4 �J)5��/ ��� � ���� �J)5�2� ��$ �� �/-�#�" ����, " �a," �J)5��/ �&. �# �DC�" ��/)��jV/sW=r�1o`/sW=r(�

-�#�"��� � ����, " Y��" �J)5��/ ��< Y"�6 ��/)��`�/s=r�1 hV/s=r(���� ��:� .�'��"�� ���' �#��$ �� �/-�#�"��� � �����' �J)5�2� ��/ �# �DC�" ��/

����, " Y��" �J)5��/ �&.)��[j/s=r�1 he/s=r(-�#�" ��� � ���< Y"�6 ��/�"� Y$� � ����, "�#w �"� � �a," �J)5��/ .@��' S��)' ��� -�#�" ���� ����� ��,/�

Y$� >�5A�i �J)5�2� .� i#' ;"��� ;# !1 S��)' �J)5�2� ��$ ;"�� �$ �## 1 ���$ ����� ���A�$�� �J)5�2� ��$ � ��,):� �J)5�2� ��$ �����h�J)5�2� -�#�"

1 ���" �� >�5A�it��� ���3 �#�)�����V`oh:[sVV.(

�����$ ����" ���(�� -�"2�)TAS-20(:�)'��1 �'�(#/ ���A�' -�#�"e)� ���4 ���J ��� #1V��h (@�"�� ^�[s���$�,. �� ����.� -�#�"��� �$ � Y$� �2�z$

��$�56�j��$�56� U#7�1 �� ����.� �m�,#� �Ca1 � �o4 -�#�" �� �� N�:�� S, ����E#2

2- content validity 4- construct validity 6- difficulty identifying feelings 8- externally oriented thinking

1- test-retest reliability 3- concurrent validity 5- Toronto Alexithymia Scale-20 7- difficulty describing feelings

Page 32: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

32

�� ��E#2 ���'V)�D"�� U2�&" (���' �1e)�D"��Z���" (�"�(,$ .�� i#' ;� ���' �����' B�:�" ��$�!" � � �'�(#/ ���A�' ��� -�#�"��� �$ ��/��. .�AK�� ��/

��)'��1 �'�(#/ ���A�' -�#�" �(,5'��W[s%/�K4 �� 1 � �$�� �� )" ��/t��. �#� Y$�)���J � �� #1 �����4[ssV �[ss`��g�)$� � ���'�" �='�J#A ���2�4 [ssh ����,4

�����4 � �� #1 �>��,"V��j����J � �� #1 [sss .( ���A�' -�#�" �$��� �&5' ���)'��1 �'�(#/W[s)����� [ssm(� �;� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��� ���'��� ��a2� G���* �

�Ca1 � ���$�56� U#7�1 �� ����.� ���$�56� ���$�,. �� ����.� -�#�"��� �$ G#1�1 � �,#�oe/s�o[/s�me/s�m[/s�< �'��� �'�5�/ �'��' �� �. ��$�!"

Y$� -�#�" .�)'��1 �'�(#/ ���A�' -�#�" ���"�� �� �����4W[s�'��' �� ��jm�� �)a/ ��?Q � 7�� � Y�' �� �� ��a')ms/s=r�1mm/s=r(;� �'�(#/ ���A�' ���

-�#�"��� �1 U )&" ��/t�. �#� .�)'��1 �'�(#/ ���A�' -�#�" @�"i�/ �����W[s�-�#�"��� �# �J)5��/ G56-�#�" � @�"�� ��� ��/�'�(#/ X�/ ��/V�)5�i? �

�)<�,�'���[�)<�,�'��� �A�'�"�� �`1 ���" � �$�� tY��A ���3 �#� .G���* S��)'�'��"�� ���' �# �� ��� @��' @�$�#4 �J)5��/ � ;� �'�(#/ ���A�' -�#�" �� �/

�'�(#/ X�/)ssV/sP< �ms/sW=r(�)<�,�'��� �)5�i? �)ssV/sP<�jo/sW=r(�)<�,�'��� �A�'�"�� �)ssV/sP<�hh/s=r(���� ��:� ����, " �J)5��/ .G���*

-�#�"��� �# �J)5��/�'�� ����, " i#' H�� ��/�#{)" � �'�(#/ ���A�' ��/ .S��)'��#��1 � "�� ;# !1h�� ����.� ���$�56� ���$�,. �� ����.� ;"�� �$ ��:� i#'

$��� �&5' �� �� �,#� �Ca1 � ���$�56� U#7�1�)'��1 �'�(#/ ���A�' -�#�" �W[s1t�'��� �#�)�����[ssm.(

��#)�� ��. �<�.)ASI(W��#)�� ��. �<�. e)� �J)" �R�#$�� ��"�)2� �@D C" �������V��[ �R�#$�� � �C$��R �@D C" �V�oe ("N��6�+Q ��N�,N�� Y$� ��

2- psychological well-being 4- exploratory factor analysis

1- emotional intelligence 3- psychological distress 5- Addiction Severity Index

Page 33: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

33

��,: �� �1��D��$ �DC�" �� �� �� @����# �A�'� U )&" ��/�Y��. ���" g�+"�" ��'����(,$ .Y# *� ;"�. �,#"� Ya/ �� �� ���# Y# *� ��#)�� ��. �<�. ��/

�" � � {. g�+" � ���" g�+" ��C.i]'��� ��'�'�3 �����):� � �A���'�< ��C.i4 ��2�" ;C2��(,$ .�,#"� ��� �� F��� �/ �� �� �DC�" � I9D� ��" � ��. ��'����� �/

�" ��#(,$ �).lA ��� �$ � ��� >����. .�� ��. �9��� ��i� ��� �� %����� ���,Q@�� ������)�� � ��:�1 U )&" ��/��. � ��. �<�. %����� �?'� @�#" �� �� ��'�

Y�R ��#)��V� ��1�� ;#2� ���� ��)�# ����� �@�� �1)�@���C�/ � @D C"[ssj .( �# ��#)�� ��. �<�. ����' �,"��s�1VY$� )�@D C" � Y'�4 �Y#a��A �@�JC"

V�oj .( @���C�/ � @D C")V�oe (. �����4 � ����� ��/�K4 �� �� ��#)�� ��. �<��'��� X��iA ���)5A �,#2� � ��/�K4 ����� � ��) " ���i� �� @� � �'��"��.

������

>��: ��V��$ �# @�$�#4 �J)5��/ =��1�" � �'�(#/ ���A�' ��J)5�2� ��/>D)<� ��.Y$� ��. ���� @��' ���" g�+" ��/ .@��/�" ��/��" �� ��� ��.

�#{)" �# b����, " �/ �'��� .�#*�� �S��)' ���1 �� %/�K4 F�$ �1 >�� ��/t�" �#��,,�.7� P)�(�� ��#"+�� �"� ���#" �:�;6% W�#$��

#"+�� ����" ���(�� 78��� 9 ,3��� =#�� �� ���� �J)5�2� `j/W** hV/sW**

��A�$�� �J)5�2� hh/s** `j/s** ��,):� �J)5�2� `s/s*hs/s** �'�(#/ ���A�' W`h/s**

*~.� �3 �:�;6%cN/cp<!�� ��3��&� .**~.� �3 �:�;6%cc�/cp<!�� ��3��&� .

;�� 1 �|� �$�� ��x," � @�#$�A� ;# !1 S��)' �c�� �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,���. � ���� �J)5�2� ��$ �# <�N>D)��/ >��: �� ���" g�+"[. ���� @��' N��

1- ASI-Lite

Page 34: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

34

Y$� .>�" �� @�#$�A� ;# !1 S��)'V�" @��' � �'�(#/ ���A�' �c�� �� �/�>D)<� ��. � ���� �J)5�2� ���" g�+" ��/[e�/s� Y$� V/e='����� �� �7��

>D)<� ��.� �� ���" g�+" ��/�" �##�1 ����, " ����,� .>�"[�c�� @�i#" 5�2� ��'�(#/ ���A�'>D)<� ��. � ���� �J) �|� ���� �� =4 �� ���" g�+" ��/

;�� 1�" @��' �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,��/� .>�" �5���" �V�[�" �&�" �� ��. %��i�� ��� �'�(#/ ���A�'R2@�i#" � sjh/sY$� ����, " @�i#" ��� �� ��.

)sjh/s∆R2=�mee/o∆F=�ssh/s=P.(�" @��' >�" ��� �� �/�h/j�� �7�� >D)<� ��. ����' �� ��. ��/��" ='�����;�� 1 �|� b$�1 ���" g�+" ��/ ��,,�

�" �##�1 �'�(#/ ���A�'��..

7� P)0(7 � -��� #� ��"�#(� 1"�K$ x���� ��0

7 � RR24 , 1� &$ ∆R2∆FPV[e�/sseV/ssjm/s[oh/hsVj/s[`j`/sVVs/ssjh/smee/ossh/s

>�"VW%#4 ��/�#{)" �# :���� �J)5�2� � �'�(#/ ���A�'

>�"[W%#4 ��/�#{)" �# :;�� 1 �|� � ���� �J)5�2� � �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,�>D)<� ��. �##�1 �� �'�(#/ ���A�'���" g�+" ��/

>��:`>�" -�$� � �� @�#$�A� ;# !1 ����'�)$��#w � ����'�)$� G���* V�[�'�" @��/� .>�" �� @�#$�A� G���*V�" @��' �'�(#/ ���A�' �� �/�

)[j[/sβ=��V�/[=t(���� �J)5�2� �)[m/sWβ=��s/`W=t(�"���7 � �,'��1>D)<� ��. ='����� ����, "�,,� �##�1 �� ���" g�+" ��/ .>�"�� @�#$�A� G���*

[�" @��' �'�(#/ ���A�' �� �/�)`h`/s=β�eh`/=β(��' ��. ='����� �'��1>D)<� ���� �J)5�2� �"� ��,� �##�1 �� ���" g�+" ��/)[hs/sW=β�Vj/hW=t(�|� �;�� 1 �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,�)jh�/s=β��e�/[=t(���. ='����� ����, " ���

Page 35: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

35

>D)<��" �##�1 �� ���" g�+" ��/D)<� ��. ����� �J)5�2� %��i�� � �, � ��,�>��/ >D)<� ��. ��'�(#/ ���A�' %��i�� � � %/�� ���" g�+" %��i�� ���" g�+" ��/

�"��� .>D)<� ��. �c�� @�i#" ���A�' b$�1 ���� �J)5�2� � ���" g�+" ��/�" ;�� 1 �'�(#/>D)<� ��. �c�� @�i#" �, � ����A �J)5�2� � ���" g�+" ��/

i#" � �����, " ���7 � �������� �J)5 �'�(#/ ���A�' @�.7� P)?(7 � -��� #� ��"�#(� 1"�K$ 3�� �����#"i � 3�� ����� F��#_ ��0

7 � BSEβTPY�| `Vj/V`seh/[WW ho`/jssV/s

�'�(#/ ���A�' smo/ss[m/s[j[/s�V�/[ssh/s���� �J)5�2� so[/sWs[V/s[m/sW�ss/`WssV/s

Y�| V[V/Vhss�/[WWs`s/mssV/s�'�(#/ ���A�' Vs[/ssjj/s`h`/seh`/VV[j/s���� �J)5�2� sme/sWsVo/s[hs/sWVj/hWssV/s

;�� 1 �|��'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,� sVj/ssse/sjh�/s�e�/[ssh/s

;�� 1 �|� �$�� ��x," � @�#$�A� ;# !1 S��)' �c�� �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,�2� ��$ �#>D)<� ��. � ��A�$�� �J)5� >��: �� ���" g�+" ��/h���� @��'

Y$� ��. .>�" �� @�#$�A� ;# !1 S��)'V�" @��' � �'�(#/ ���A�' �c�� �� �/�>D)<� ��. � ��A�$�� �J)5�2� ���" g�+" ��/[e�/s� Y$� V/e�� �7��

>D)<� ��. ����' ='����� " ���7 � �� ���" g�+" ��/�" �##�1 ����,�,� .>�"[>D)<� ��. � ��A�$�� �J)5�2� ��'�(#/ ���A�' �# �c�� @�i#" �� ���" g�+" ��/

;�� 1 �|� ���� �� =4�" @��' �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,��/� .>�" �5���" �V�[%��i�� G�$ �'�(#/ ���A�' �� ��. �" �&�"R2@�i#" � [hm/s��� �� ��. �7��

@�i#" Y$� ����, " )[hm/s=∆R2�emh/h[∆F= �ssV/s=P.(�" @��' >�" ��� �/� ��m/[h>D)<� ��. ����' �� ��. ��/��" ='����� �� �7�� b$�1 ���" g�+" ��/

;�� 1 �|��" �##�1 �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,���..

Page 36: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

36

7� P)I(7 � -��� #� ��"�#(� 1"�K$ x���� ��0

7 � RR24 , 1� &$ ∆R2∆FPV[e�/sseV/ssjm/s[oh/hsVj/s[ejV/s[�m/s[hm/semh/h[sss/s

>�"VW%#4 ��/�#{)" �# :��A�$�� �J)5�2� � �'�(#/ ���A�' >�"[W%#4 ��/�#{)" �# :;�� 1 �|� � ��A�$�� �J)5�2� � �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,�

���" g�+" ��/ >D)<� ��. �##�1 �'�(#/ ���A�'

>��: e>�" -�$� � @�#$�A� ;# !1 ����'�)$��#w � ����'�)$� G���* V�[@��' �� �"�/� .> �" �� @�#$�A� G���*V�" @��' �'�(#/ ���A�' �� �/�)[j[/s=β�

�V�/[=t(��A�$�� �J)5�2� �)`V/s=β�Vm/`=t(>D)<� ��. ='����� g�+" ��/�" �##�1 ����, " ���7 � �� ���"�,,� .>�" @�#$�A� G���*[�" @��' �� �/�

�'�(#/ ���A�')e``/sβ=�j�h/`=t(��A�$�� �J)5�2� �)h[�/s=β��mh/`=t(�;�� 1 �|� �#,��/ �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,�)��e/sβ=�e[e/j=t(>D)<� ��. ='�������/

�" �##�1 ����, " ���7 � �� ���" g�+"(#/ ���A�' %��i�� � �, � ��,� ��. �'�>D)<��" %��i�� ���" g�+" ��/��� .>D)<� ��. i#' ��A�$�� �J)5�2� %��i�� ���/

�" %��i�� ���" g�+"��� .>D)<� ��. �c�� @�i#" �J)5�2� � ���" g�+" ��/�" ;�� 1 �'�(#/ ���A�' b$�1 ��A�$����..

7� P)N(�"�#(� 1"�K$ 3�� �����#"i � 3�� ����� F��#_ 7 � -��� #� ���0

7 � BSEβTPY�| `Vj/V`seh/[WWho`/jssV/s

�'�(#/ ���A�' smo/ss[m/s[j[/s�V�/[ssh/s��A�$�� �J)5�2� so�/ss[o/s`V/sVm/`ssV/s

Y�| e`o/V�ss�/[WWm[j/�ssV/s�'�(#/ ���A�' Ve�/ssh`/se``/sj�h/`ssV/s

��A�$�� �J)5�2� jVm/sVee/sh[�/s�mh/`ssV/s�'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,� ;�� 1 �|�s``/ssse/s��e/se[e/jssV/s

Page 37: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

37

;�� 1 �|� �$�� ��x," � @�#$�A� ;# !1 S��)' �c�� �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,�>D)<� ��. � ��,):� �J)5�2� ��$ �# >��: �� ���" g�+" ��/j���� @��'

Y$� ��. .;# !1 S��)' >�" �� @�#$�A� V�" @��' � �'�(#/ ���A�' �c�� �� �/�>D)<� ��. � ��,):� �J)5�2� ��$ ���" g�+" ��/[ee/s� Y$� �/h�� �7��

>D)<� ��. ='������ �� ���" g�+" ��/�" �##�1 ����, " ����,� .>�"[@�i#" D)<� ��. � ��,):� �J)5�2� ��$ ��'�(#/ ���A�' �c��>=4 �� ���" g�+" ��/

;�� 1 �|� ���� ���" @��' �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,��/� .>�" �5���" �V�[�&�" �" %��i�� ��� �'�(#/ ���A�' �� ��.R2@�i#" � Vjo/s@�i#" ��� �� ��.

Y$� ����, ")Vjo/s=∆R2�oee/[e=∆F�ssV/s=P.(�" @��' >�" ��� �� �/�o/Vj��� �� �7��>D)<� ��. ����' �� ��. ��/��" ='�� �|� b$�1 ���" g�+" ��/

;�� 1�" �##�1 �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,���..7� P)M(7 � -��� #� ��"�#(� 1"�K$ x������0

7 � RR24 , 1� &$ ∆R2∆FPV[ee/ssh�/ssje/sV`s/hsVo/s[ho`/s[V`/sVjo/soee/[essV/s

>�"VW�/�#{)" %#4 ��# :��,):� �J)5�2� ��$ � �'�(#/ ���A�' >�"[W%#4 ��/�#{)" �# :��A�'N#/ �N�|� � ��,):� �J)5�2� ��$ � �'�(

;�� 1>D)<� ��. �##�1 �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,����" g�+" ��/

>��:m>�" -�$� � �� @�#$�A� ;# !1 ����'�)$��#w � ����'�)$� G���* V�[�" @��'�/� .>�" �� @�#$�A� G���*V�" @��' �'�(#/ ���A�' �� �/�)[ee/s=β�

ojm/[=t(��,):� �J)5�2� �)[�/=sβ�em/h=t(�"='����� ����, " ���7 � �,'��1>D)<� ��.�,,� �##�1 �� ���" g�+" ��/ .>�"�� @�#$�A� G���*[�" @��' �/�

�'�(#/ ���A�' ��)m�[/`=β�hVe/e=t(��,):� �J)5�2� �)jVo/s=β�shj/h=t(�;�� 1 �|� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,�)jmo/`W=β�soe/eW=t(���. ='����� ����, " ���

Page 38: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

38

>D)<��" �##�1 �� ���" g�+" ��/>D)<� ��. ���A�' %��i�� � �, � ��,� ��/�" %��i����� .>D)<� ��. i#' ��,):� �J)5�2� %��i�� ���/ %��i�� ���" g�+"

�"��� .>D)<� ��. �c�� @�i#" ���A�' b$�1 ��,):� �J)5�2� � ���" g�+" ��/�" ;�� 1 �'�(#/>D)<� ��. �c�� @�i#" �, � ���. �J)5�2� � ���" g�+" ��/

� ��,):����� �J)5 �'�(#/ ���A�' @�i#" � �����, " ���7 .S��)' -�$� �;# !1#$�A� ��/;�� 1 %�' �@���$ �# �c�� �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,��J)5�2� ��/

>D)<� ��. �1 �%/�K4 F��?Q �#*�� �, � ����" g�+" ��/t�" �#���..7� P)>(7 � -��� #� ��"�#(� 1"�K$ 3�� �����#"i � 3�� ����� F��#_ ��0

7 � BSEβTPY�| `m�/Vejm`/V___V�h/�ssV/s

�A�'�'�(#/ �� smj/ss[m/s[ee/sojm/[sse/s��,):� �J)5�2� sjh/ssVh/s[�/sem/hssV/s

Y�| eoV/s[oh/`___Vmm/sojs/s�'�(#/ ���A�' V`[/V[s�/sm�[/`hVe/essV/s

��,):� �J)5�2� oVj/s[s[/sjVo/sshj/hssV/s;�� 1 �|��'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,� sjh/sWsV`/sjmo/`Wsoe/eWssV/s

dK���"�� ��#"(

>D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' � ���� �J)5�2� ��$ �� ��� @��' %/�K4 ��� S��)'��/ ��$ � ����, " �a," �c�� ���" g�+" �����' �J)5�2� ��/)��A�$�� � ��,):� (�

>D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�'��� ����, " Y��" �c�� ���" g�+" ��/�'.��� S��)'>D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' �# �� ��� @��' �#,��/ %/�K4 ���" g�+" ��/

���� ��:� ����, " Y��" �c�� .�#*�� G#1�1 � �� S��)' ��� �� %/�K4 F�$ �1 >�� ��/1t�" �#��)��� � � �,,�%/�K4 ��/ � �3 ��/)�����V`oo��@���C�/ � ����

V`oo �V`oj�1 ��@���C�/ � �5��[ssV��-��#2 � ����1 [sse �@���C�/ � �A�,� �[ss[��@���C�/ � -�]$�� [sse����#. � ��#5� V��� �@���C�/ � ����� �[ssh�

Page 39: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

39

�@���C�/ � �2�,C"[ss` �@���C�/ � �Q����)'�" �[ssh (G56 � ��'��� Y��c"�" �##�1 ��� �R��)6��'�.:

���" �/�&$�4 � Y#$�56)�'��� ��?� � �� ���� �� �#2�� Y�3��" �� �'�5� �� (Y2�6 ��## 1 ����� �'�(#/ ��/ � �c�� � U���� I#x,1 X�� ��#A��� � 7� ��,,�

Y$� @��J��)���2�V�j���@�1�1� V�oe��Y'�,1 V�oo .(�" @��' �/��. �� �,/�/�" �$ �� =4 @�����'N�'��' Y����� � Y�5' �J ��/r$�4 � �: �� �'��# ��/

��?Q�" ��#4 ��#A�$ � Y#$�56 �G3��" ����� � ���,,� .�'��' ��� �� I?" ���' �/�A�'�"�� I#x,1 X��"��" �������' ��/ �,,�)�@�51�� � � A�AV��m .( @�����

�" ��(1 �#2�� G3��" �� I(5," � �,#? �/�&$�4 �����" � �,,� ���� �� �'��"�� )"@�(#/ >����� Y��" ��/�"�#4 �/ .�� ��'����" �/�&$�4 � Y#$�56 �-�$� ��� �

�" �5!" ���� �J)5�2� ��"��" �� >�6 �#� �� �'�.)���2�V�j� �V�oo��@���C�/ � ¡��5,��V�mo(�� ���� �J)5�2� ��$ ����)$� � ;#C�1 Z��� �� �

<� �� U���� I#x,1 ��� �� F�R ��'�C"� ������" ���3 �� ��#)�,/� .��,�'��1 ��� ��/ � ��' @� � 7� �+&�" �� ��� �'�(#/ ���A�' � ���� �J)5�2� ��$ �a," �c��

I#x,1 ��< �� �'��1�' Y$� �'�(#/ ��A)�� )���[ss[(�" �##�1 ��,� .��J�� ��$ ���J2� � �'����" �/�&$�4 � Y#$�56 �� �'��1�' � U * � ��,5�' Y�3��" ��)�� �

�����' �J)5�2�)��A�$�� � ��,):� (�" �?),"���?" >�!1 B'�" � ��." ��/z�|�" �a��� I#x,1���A .@�(#/ I#x,1 � X����4 ����$��C.� ��$�,.�� �� ���$��' �� �/

�" �5!" ��,5�' Y�3��" ��� >�+!" �����' ����� ��.)�����V`oo.(

�)����' �#,��/ ��/�K4 ��/���� @���(1 �� �'� �� �'��3��" � ����� ��/@�(#/��' @��' �� @����/��' ���� � �,/�@�(#/ �� �'�5� �� ��,,� >�6 �� ��/

;C. � >�!1��' Y#�$� � �� ���� ��#A@�(#/ � � �,$�,. ��)�� �< ���� ��/��'�" ��,,�1 �'��1t�� ;6��" �� �a��� I#x,1 � Z#�� ��#| �.� �).�� �A�'�

)��� #1 � ��JV��m .( i�#: � F��'� %/�K4 S��)')V��h (�� �� �'����� �� ��� @��'

Page 40: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

40

b#!"��. ��i ���/ �� � ��� �"��' � F����' �'�(#/ � �'��5: �x' �� �� �'�@�(#/ ���$��C.�Y2�6 � Z��" � ��" ���"� ;�� � Y '��" �/ ��� �� @��#'�(#/ ��/

��'@�(#/ ��(1 �� �(#)' �� � �'�#A�" Y6���' �/�'�. .����.� ��� @���� � �/Z�"�$ ���� �� ����A�$�� � �'��J' � Y$� �C�" @�(#/ ���� ��� G$�," ��/

��. �?)," ��$�56� .%/�K4 @R�5A�i � @�'��:�' ���" �� ��. F�('� ��/)� ���1�� ���#.V��h��i1���. � ��,#/ V��h (���� @��' �J)5�2� ��$ ����� ����� �� �'�

�#��4 u�c$ ������" X��iA �a," U���� �� ��1 �@��J�� � IC!)5" b��� � �,,��" � :��" �?'� � Y���6 Y����� ��� �'�(#/ �A�'�"�� B3�" �� �'�5� ���3� ��,,�

�"�'��$ .��� � �5���" �� ������' �J)5�2� ��$ ����� �������#��4 u�c$ �/ �� ��1�" ��(1 �� Y��" U����I#x,1��< ���'��1 �� � �,,� ���$ � �A��5�� ���c*� ��A

�" @��' �'��1�' �a," U���� �,/�)�����4V�o[ .(�)��� ��� Z�c"��(1 ��/ ��/�## 1 ���' ����� �'�(#/%,� �� ��,,�%,� �$��' �� ������ ��� �'�(#/ ��/

�",��,.1 ��� � 7� �)5t��(1 @� G56 � �� Y$� ��� �J)5�2� ��$ ����lA�#| �/�" ;C.>�" Z��� �� � �'�#A�" �'��� ���C'��� ��/�" ����)$� � �'�. �,��)�"�

��,#2�]$� �V��h .(%,� � ���� �J)5�2� ��$ �G#1�1 ��� ������,�'��1 � �/��/ ��$ � �'�(#/' �J)5�2� ��/%,��$��' � �����������'��1�' � �/ �� �'�(#/ ��/

�" ���3 y��1���'�#A.

��$ �a," �� Y��" ���#|�1 ��)$�� �� I#x,1 � �����' � ���� �J)5�2� ��/@�(#/ � U���� �/)���2�V�j���@�1�1� V�oe ��Y'�,1V�oo(�" ���$ �c�� @��1��/

>D)<� ��. � �J)5�2� g�+" ��/��� �#:�1 i#' �� ���" .�� Y�5' ���" �?:�1�" ��� �'��� ��/��#' I#x,1��< ��. �'��� ��/��)<�$ � ���' F�('� Y#���" � ��A

�'�#J' ;E. ��)�� �'��� >�),T � b�1�" .�'��# ��#.� � ��"� � ����� ��� ��(#)' ���" ��#4 �J)5����#. �� �C� ���" g�+" � �,,��: ��/ �?'� �'��� ��/����� @��

�" �5!"��. .Y���6 G : �� ���� �J)5�2� ����� ��&.� ��� ����):� ��/-�)$� � � ��"�" ���a)$� �'�(#/ ��/ �J)5�2� ����� ��&.� �� �2�6 �� ��,,�

Page 41: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

41

X�� �� �����'�$ �,'�" �J�� ��/�Y# 3�" ��� � � ��" ��� ���� �� ;C2� g�+" �/�" ���A�'�#)���#. � @�'�V��e �@���C�/ � -�]$�� �[sse � >���� �;5� �

�=1���[ssm �@���C�/ � �2�,C" �[ss` .(�R��)6�Y���6 ��()5: ����):� ��/-�)$� � �?:��" F�J,/>D)<� � D)� �c< ���� ����� �� �'�(#/ ��/ g�+" ��/

�" %/�� �� ���" �/�)�@���C�/ � ����V`oj.(X�J' ������' ��&.� �� �a," ��/�" G#$� �?'� ��< Y"�6 � �� �'��� @�.��< ��"���� ���"�'�$� .U# * ��< Y"�6

�,#"��" ���" �)�# g�+" ��$�" �� �"��3� ���. %/�� � -�)$� ;�� 1 ��� �'��1 ��#A ���7 �a," U����)�@���C�/ � ;5�[ssm .( �J)5�2� ^�$ ����� ��&.�

�����'��� �J)5�2� ���J' �� �J)���6 � Y��" ��5(1 �=C�� �.�Y��" I5(1 ����" %��i�� �� ��"������< � ��,�.�����< -�56� �" ��� ��� � � �/� �1 �,�

��#. � �� ��< �a," U���� �,���' ;�� 1 ��'��$ ��)���#. � ��#5�V��� .( �����" �-�$� ����< � ��,�.�����< -�56� @��1I5#'�E" �� �E� @��,� � �� ��"�� ��/

Y��A �x' �� ���" g�+" ¢�$ � D)� ��. %/�T � ��lA�#|t1.

>D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' �c�� ��+< ���" ����" g�+" ��/ ��� @��1@�(#/ �� �,):� ��� ��� ��#)�� ���" �� ��� u�c" �� >��)6��" g�+" �a," ��/�'�.

^�T ��� � ��"@�(#/ �� Z��� ��� �� �T �,,T��#J � 7�� �a," ��/ .�#�/ � v�T �-�$�)V��V (��(1 �� Y$� ��) "Y���1 �,�1��3 ��/ ��� ��#)�� ��� ��,,T

Y# 3�" �� �� ��� �T Y$� ���?'��" ��� �a," �'�(#/ ��/�,,T .Y�#: ��)$�� �#�/ ��)V��h #" ���# ����"�/�#4 �� ;�' � ��@���E�/ � ��"� ����" ����C[ss[ (��� @��'

�A��5�� � ��c*� %/�T g�/ � ���J'�"�� ��< �,'�" �@���J'��� ���" g�+" �T�" ���7��#A .@���C�/ � �E$�T����)V�oo (�" ;E2� g�+" �T �'��) " �/�� �'��1

Y# 3�" �� �#E51 ���-�)$� ��/'�(#/ ���A�' � D)�" ����� �� �� �(#)' �� � �.� �g�+" �,��.�< ��(1 � �,T ;#?51 �� ����� ��� �"DT � �'�(#/ y��1�� ;E2� g�+"

��. �?)," ���" ��� � �J)5�� � Y��?' �� ;E2�)�@����[ss` .( @���E�/ � �� #1

Page 42: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

42

)V��m (�� ���/� ��� XD1 �� Y$� �C�" �'�(#/ ���A�' � D)�" ����� �'��) "" ��$�56� ��/��)�� � ��!" ��/���� g�+" �@���< @�Q �2���� Z��� �� ��< �a,

��,/� @��' %,��� ��#)<� .I#x,1��< �� ��' �'��) " �?'�@�(#/ ��A ��,���/ ��/�$ �@���< >D)<� � �� �'�(#/ ���A�'�@�� ���'�C1 ��/��)�� ����" g�+" � �i��

�" �##�1 �*�" ���3 �,�)���[ss[ .( ��Y# 3�" �� G w� @�(#/�A�' ����� �� �('� ��/�" @��' �� 2�c" � �'��� �� c"�' -�56� ����):� �'�(#/ ���A�' %��i�� � �� �/�

�" %��i�� �+&. �# �DC�" ���)�����V`ooU2�(�� �'��) " @���!" �� �C �� ���? �� � -�)$� � � ��" ��� �/���� � ;C2� �� ����� ��� ���a)$� �+&. �# ��

�"�R��)6� �� �,,��">D)<� ��. %��i�� �'��1 @�(#/�A�' ����� �� ���" g�+" ��/�,� �##�1 �� .%/�K4 �� ���" g�+" >D)<� ��. � �'�(#/ ���A�' �# �c�� ��/

Y$� ��. X��iA i#' �#�#4)�@���[ss` �@���C�/ � ����1 �[sVV � ��5$ ��F�)52�/V��m��@���C�/ � �, ���/ V��V.(

��$ �# �c�� �'�(#/ ���A�' �� ��� @��' %/�K4 ��� S��)' � �J)5�2� ��/>D)<� ��.�" ;�� 1 �� ���" g�+" ��/�,� .�� %/�K4 F��?Q �#*�� �S��)' ���

�" �#��1�,� .;�� 1 %�' �J)5�2� ��$ k�' G56 � �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ��,,� Y���1 �� U# �1�">D)<� � D)� ��. � ��. %��i�� �� %/�� �� ���" g�+" ��/

�"�" �##�1 ��� u�. � ��/���. :�'�(#/ ���A�' ��.� ���� �J)5�2� �� �c���. ��1 Y!1t�AK�� �#|I#x,1��< ��� ��� ��,�'��1 ;�" �J)5�2� �� ��$ ��� ��/ � ��A

@�(#/ � U���� I#x,1�" %/�� ��/� � ���;�� 1 �| ��$ �# �c�� �� @� ��,,��" �)�� i#' ���" g�+" >D)<� ��. � ���� �J)5�2���. .t1�#|h/j���A�' ��7��

� �5���" �� ���" g�+" >D)<� ��. � ���� �J)5�2� ��$ �# �c�� �� �'�(#/1t�#|m/[h1 � ��A�$�� �J)5�2� ��$ ��7�� t�#|o/Vj�J)5�2� ��$ ��7��

,):�" ��zY$� �##�1 ��� �� .���A�' ��.� �����' �J)5�2� ��$ �� �c���. ��1 Y!1 �'�(#/t�AK�� �#| ��� ��� ��,�'��1�' ;�" �J)5�2� �� ��$ ��� ��/

Page 43: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

43

I#x,1��<@�(#/ � U���� I#x,1 � ��A�" %��i�� ��/;�� 1 �|� � ��� �� @� ��,,�D)<� ��. � �����' �J)5�2� ��$ �# �c���" �)�# i#' ���" g�+" >��. .

I5#'�C"1 ��/t�" �� �'�(#/ ���A�' ���lA�#| �'�"����< �#*�� -�$� � @��1)�@��i'��V�oe(@�(#/ �� ���� ����� � �"D� b��� ;#?51 � �a," ��/)�C$������

�@���C�/ �V�oo (��� �#*�1 .g�/ � ��)� ���" g�+" ��'�"����< �#*�� Z���<�A�'�"�� ��J'�"����" ���7 �)<�,�'��� ��/� � ��#A >D)<� � ��< S���1

�" ;���1 ���" g�+"��. .� 7�� �#*�� Z��@�(#/ �� ��#A �����#)�� ���" ��a," ��/@�(#/ �� �,):� ����" g�+" �a," ��/�" ^�T ��� � � �'�. ��� �� �T �,,T

@�(#/ �� Z���J � 7�� �a," ��/1 �"� ���#tY���1 �#| � @�"i�/ ���" g�+" ��,,�-�)$� �� � 7�� ��(���" D)�" ���" g�+" >D)<� � �� �� �/ ���$)�v�TV��V .( �

Y# 3�" �� ���" g�+" ��a��� � �"D� b��� ;#?51 �#*�� -�$�-�)$� ��/ ����" Y3�" %"��� � �� �'�(#/ ���A�' � D)�" ���� �1 �'�$� �'��) %"��� ��� ���$ �

�,� ���3� �"DT � �'�(#/ y��1�� .� %"��� � @�"i�/ ���" g�+" �,��.�< ��(1 ��. �?)," ���" ��� � �J)5�� � Y��?' �� ��a��� � �"D� b��� ����3� ��,�'��1

)�@����[ss`.(

��?1 �� ���" g�+" @�"�� i��" ��?Q � �� %/�K4 ��� ���"� � "�: ���!" @�">D)<� ����� @���" �?,1 �� %/�K4 � 2�c" ���" �'��' ���. ��'�� ���" g�+" ��/

Y��. @�� G ���� ��N" �%/�K4 �� @�A�,,NY����! �5!" %/�K4 ��� ��/�"�'�. .��� D)�" @����# Y# �: ;� � S��)' I#� 1 �� Y$� F�R �-�$� ��

>D)<�#)6� ����" g�+" ��/��. y�.

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :[m/se/V`�[ �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :[s/so/V`�[ �2��" X��l4 r���1:[h/VV/V`�[

Page 44: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

44

q���� References

� ���!" �����)V`oh(.7�;(�U� �:�;6<3 -�"2� �����������/�K4 X��iA �@��?1 ��J�'�� .

� ���!" �����)V`omU2� .( � �)<�,�'��� �A�'�"�� ��A��5�� ���c*� � �'�(#/ ���$��' �c���)<�,�'��� �)5�i?�U�#6$ 4�:���3 ��������� ���� �Vs�hsWVm.

� ���!" �����)V`om.(� �'�(#/ ���$��'��$����� ��/������ !,� f� 7�o� �`��V�sWVoV.

� ���!" �����)V`ooU2� .(�+&. �# �DC�" � �'�(#/ ���A�' �[��G � ��������� ������"�#$ �`e�VhjWV[�.

� � ��!" �����)V`oo.(�'�(#/ ���$��' � �J)5�2� ��/ ��$��� ���������� �� �[h�osWj`.

� ���!" �������*� ���)$� � ���? ����aw )V`oj .(��$ �5���" � D)�" @����# �J)5�2� ��/>D)<�D)�"�#w ����� � ���" g�+" ��/��S,U �3 �� �`V�[mVW[je.

�*� ��#56��4 ����!" ��'�"��#" �� ���!" �����)V`os .(%�' ������4 �� �A���'�< ��/�#{)">D)<� ����" g�+" ��/��������� � ��� �� �`�e[Whj.

Y(6 ��'�/��� �*��#�6 ������ ��2�)V`oh .(B�����;�� [��G �3 �� ���#�" ���@�?a7� :�/�J�'�� ��?: .

Ainsworth, M.D.S., Blehar, M.C., Waters, E., & Wall, S. (1978). Patterns of Attachment: A Psychological Study of the Strange Situation, Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

Bagby, R.M., Parker, J.D.A., & Taylor, G.J. (1994). The Twenty-item Toronto Alexithymia Scale: I. Item Selection and Cross-validation of the Factor Structure, Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 38, 23-32.

Bagby, R.M., & Taylor (1997). Affect Dysregulation and Slexithymia, In G.J. Taylor, R.M. Bagby, & J.D.A. Parker (Eds.), Disorders of Affect Regulation: Alexithymia in Medical and Psychiatric Illness (pp. 26-45). Cambridge: University Press.

Berenbaum, H., & James, T. (1994). Correlates and Retrospectively Reported Antecedents of Alexithymia, Psychosomatic Medicin, 56, 353-359.

Page 45: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

45

Besharat, M.A. (2007). Reliability and Factorial Validity of Farsi Version of the Toronto Alexithymia Scale with a Sample of Iranian Students, Psychological Reports, 101, 209-220.

Besharat, M. A. (2011). Development and Validation of Adult Attachment Inventory, Procedia- Social and Behavioral Sciences, 30, 475-479.

Birt, M., Sandor, V., Vaida, A., & Birt, M.E. (2008). Alexithymia, a Risk Factor in Alcohol Addiction? A Brief Research Report on Romanian Population, Journal of Cognitive and Behavioral Psychotherapies, 8(2), 217-225.

Bowlby, J. (1969). Attachment and Loss: Volume 1. New York, NY: Basic Books, Inc.

Bowlby, J. (1988). A Secure Base: Clinical Applications of Attachment Theory, New York: Basic Books.

Berman, W.H., & Sperling, M.B. (1994). The Structure and Function of Adult Attachment, In M.B. Sperling, & W.H. Berman (Eds.), Attachment in Adults: Clinical and Developmental Perspectives, New York, London: The Guilford Press.

Brennan, K.A., & Shaver, P.R. (1995). Dimensions of Adult Attachment, Affect Regulation, and Romantic Relationship Functioning, Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin, 21, 267-283.

Bretherton, I. (1985). Attachment Theory: Retrospect and Prospect, In I. Retherton & E. Waters (Eds.), Growing Points of Attachment Theory and Research, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 50, 1-2, Serial No. 299, 3-35.

Caspers, K.M., Cadoret, R.J., Langbehn, D., Yucuis, R., & Troutman, B. (2005). Contributions of Attachment Style and Perceived Social Support to Lifetime Use of Illicit Substances, Addictive Behaviors, 30, 1007-1011.

Cassidy, J., & Shaver, P.R. (1999). Handbook of Attachment: Theory, Research, and Clinical Application, New York: Guilford Press.

Cecero, J.J., & Holmstrom, R.W. (1997). Alexithymia and Affect Pathology among Adult Male Alcoholics, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 53(3), 201-208.

Page 46: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

46

Cook, D. (1991). Shame, Attachment, and Addictions: Implications for Family Therapists, Contemporary Family Therapy, 13, 405-419.

De Rick, A., & Vanheule, S. (2006). The Relationship between Perceived Parenting, Adult Attachment Style, and Alexithymia in Alcoholic Inpatients, Addictive Behaviors, 31(7), 1265-1270.

Evren, C., Sar, V., Evren, B., Semiz, U., Dalbudak, E., & Cakmak, D. (2008). Dissociation and Alexithymia among Menwith Alcoholism, Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences, 62(1), 40-47.

Fonagy, P., Gergely, G., Jurist, E., & Target, M. (2002). Affect Regulation, Metallization, and the Development of the Self, New York: Other Press.

Fukunishi, I., Sei, H., Morita, Y., & Rahe, R.H. (1999). Sympathetic Activity in Alexithymics with Mother’s Low Care, Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 6, 579-589.

Gergely, G., & Watson, J.S. (1996). The Social Biofeedback Theory of Parental Affect-mirroring: the Development of Emotional Self-awareness and Self-control in Infancy, International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 77, 1-31.

Haviland, M.G., Hendryx, M.S., Cummings, M.A., & Shaw, D.G. (1991). Multidimensionality and State Dependency of Alexithymia in Recently Sober Alcoholics, Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 179(5), 284-290.

Haviland, M.G., Shaw, D.G., Cummings, M.A., & MacMurray, J.P. (1988). Alexithymia: Subscales and Relationship to Depression, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 50, 164-173.

Hazan, C., & Shaver, P. (1987). Romantic Love Conceptualised as an Attachment Process, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52, 511-524.

Hindy, C.G., & Schwarz, J.C. (1994). Anxious Romantic Attachment in Adult Relationships, In M.B. Sperling, & W.H. Berman (Eds.), Attachment in Adults: Clinical and Developmental Perspectives, New York, London: The Guilford Press.

Kassel, J.D., Stroud, L.R., & Paronis, C.A. (2003). Smoking, Stress, and Negative Affect: Correlation, Causation, and Context across Stages of Smoking, Psychological Bulletin, 129(2), 270-304.

Page 47: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

47

Kassel, J.D., Wardle, M., & Roberts, J.B. (2007). Adult Attachment Security and College Student Substance Use, Addictive Behaviors 32 (2007) 1164-1176.

Khantzian, E.J. (1985). The Self-medication Hypothesis of Addictive Disorders: Focus on Heroin and Cocaine Dependence, Am J Psychiatry, 142, 1259-1264.

Kooiman, C.G., Vellinga, S., Spinhoven, P.H., Draijer, N., Trijsburg, R.W., & Rooijmans, H.G.M. (2004). Childhood Adversities as Risk Factors for Alexithymia and Other Aspects of Affect Dysregulation in Adulthood, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 73, 107-116.

Kraemer, S., & Loader, P. (1995). Passing Through Life: Alexithymia and Attachment Disorders, Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 39, 937-941.

Kreitler, S. (2002). The Psychosemantic Approach to Alexithymia, Personality and Individual Differences, 33, 393-407.

Laos, G., Fremaux, D., Otmani, O., Lecercle, C., & Delahousse, J. (1997). Is Alexithymia a Negative Factor for Maintaining Abstinence? A Follow-up Study, Compr Psychiatry. 38, 296-299.

McLellan, A.T., Alterman, A.I., Cacciola, J., Metzger, D., & O'Brien, C.P. (1992). A New Measure of Substance Abuse Treatment: Initial Studies of the Treatment Services Review, J Nerv Mental Disorder, 180, 101-110.

McLellan, A.T., Luborsky, L., & Cacciola, J. (1985). New Data from the Addiction Severity Index: Reliability and Validity in Three Centers, JNerv Mental Disorder, 173, 412-423.

McGahan, P.L., Griffith, J.A., Parente, R., & McLellan, A.T. (1986). Addiction Severity Index, Composite Scores Manual, Philadelphia, The University of Pennsylvania, Veterans Administration Centre for Studies of Addiction.

McNally, A.M., Palfai, T.P., Levine, R.V., & Moore, B.M. (2003). Attachment Dimensions and Drinking-related Problems among Young Adults the Meditational Role of Coping Motives, Addictive Behaviors, 28, 1115-1127.

Page 48: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

48

Meganck, R., Vanheule, S., & Desmet, M. (2008). Factorial Validity and Measurement Invariance of the 20-item Toronto Alexithymia Scale in Clinical and Non-clinical Samples, Assessment, 15, 36-47.

Montebarocci, O., Codispoti, M., Bruno Baldaro, B., & Rossi, N. (2004). Adult Attachment Style and Alexithymia, Personality and Individual Differences, 36, 499-507

Nemiah, J.C., & Sifneos, P.E. (1970). Psychosomatic Illness: A Problem in Communication, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 18, 154-160.

Palmer, B.R., Gignac, G., Manocha, R., & Syough, C. (2004). A Psychometric Evaluation of the Mayer-Salovey-Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test Version 2.0., Intelligence, 33, 285-305.

Pandey, R., Mandal, M.K., Taylor, G.J., & Parker, J.D.A. (1996). Cross-cultural Alexithymia: Development and Validation of a Hindi Translation of the 20-item Toronto Alexithymia Scale, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 52, 173-176.

Parker, G. (1982). Parental Representations and Affective Disorder: Examination for a Hereditary Link, British Journal of Medical Psychology, 55, 57-61.

Parker, J.D.A., Taylor, G.J., & Bagby, R.M. (2001). The Relationship between Emotional Intelligence and Alexithymia, Personality and Individual Differences, 30, 107-115.

Parker, J.D.A., Taylor, G.J., & Bagby, R.M. (2003). The 20-item Toronto Alexithymia Scale: III Reliability and Factorial Validity in a Community Population, Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 55, 269-275.

Pierrehumbert, B., Bader, M., Miljkovitch, R., Mazet, P., Amar, M., & Halfon, O. (2002). Strategies of Emotion Regulation in Adolescents and Young Adults with Substance Dependence or Eating Disorders, Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, 9, 384-394.

Rasheed, A.H.E. (2001). Alexithymia in Egyptian Substance Abuser,Association for Medical Education and Research in Substance Abuse, 22, 1.

Rothbard, J.C., & Shaver, P.R. (1994). Continuity of Attachment across the Life span. In M.B. Sperling, & W.H. Berman (Eds.), Attachment in

Page 49: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

49

Adults: Clinical and Developmental Perspectives, New York, London: The Guilford Press.

Rybakowski, J., Ziolkowski, M., Zasadzka, T., & Brzezinski, R. (1988). High Prevalence of Alexithymia in Male Patients with Alcohol Dependence, Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 21(2), 133-136.

Sifneos, P.E. (1973). Prevalence of Alexithymic Characteristics in Psychosomatic Patients, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 22, 255-262.

Taylor, G.J., & Bagby, M. (2000). An Overview of the Alexithymia Construct, In R. Bar-On & J.D.A. Parker (Eds.), The Handbook of Emotional Intelligence (pp. 263-276). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Taylor, G.J., Bagby, R.M., & Parker, J.D.A. (1997). Disorders of Affect Regulation, Cambridge: University Press.

Tennant, C. (1988). Parental Loss in Childhood: It’s Effect in Adult Life, Archives of General Psychiatry, 45, 1045-1050.

Torberg, F.A. & Lyvers, M. (2005). Attachment, Fear, Intimacy and Differentiation of Self among Clients in Substance Disorder Treatment Facilities, Journal of Addictive Behaviors.

Thorberg, F.A., Young, R.M., Sullivan, K.A., & Lyvers, M. (2009). Alexithymia and Alcohol Use Disorders: A critical Review, Addictive Behaviors, 34, 237-245.

Thorberg, F.A., Young, R.M., Sullivan, K.A., Lyvers, M., Connor, P., & Feeney, G.F.X (2011). Alexithymia, Craving and Attachment in a Heavy Drinking Population, Addictive Behaviors, 36, 427-430.

Troisi, A., D’Argenio, A., Peracchio, F., Petti, P. (2001). Insecure Attachment and Alexithymia in Young Men with Mood Symptoms, Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases, 189, 311-316.

Uzun, O. (2003). Alexithymia in Male Alcoholics: Study in a Turkish Sample, Comprehensive Psychiatry, 44(4), 349-352.

Vanheule, S., Desmet, M., Meganck, R., & Bogaerts, S. (2007). Alexithymia and Interpersonal Problems, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 63, 109-117.

Page 50: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

50

Vungkhanching, M., Sher, K.J., Jackson, K.M., & Parra, G.R. (2004). Relation of Attachment Style to Family History of Alcoholism and Alcohol Use Disorders in Early Adulthood, Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 75, 47-53.

Walant, K.B. (1995). Creating the Capacity for Attachment: Treating Addictions and the Alienated Self, Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson.

Ziolkowski, M., Gruss, T., & Rybakowski, J.K. (1995). Does Alexithymia in Male Alcoholics Constitute A Negative Factor for Maintaining Abstinence? Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 63(3), 169-173.

Page 51: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

51

�=��%���B�� �(C�$ C1;�6 D�E� ��4�� ��� )-:� ) ��$( ��&)��06 '�5F����4�� D�E� )-��& ���(�:��$ � )-��� ��$ ) ����G

�%� ��H(;H ��$(��)�5 � �� ���#"� �����z

�%,� n��${

��O� -�6G�� |

��"�G3�%K� "���

�<�6/� ��G�

4 "SQ /�K4 ��� F�('� �� g�/ %���? �� �/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"�� Y<�,. � @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� ��&�|� �5���" �'��' ��/

G�� @����� @����" @�(#/ �)<�,. I#x,1 ��/���/�� � �)<�,�'��� �'����4 �,/� ��'�"�� i���1 �?. ��.��. � 2�c" ��� ��%'�� @����" ;"�. ���"� � "�: ���(1G�� @���"� ��'�"��J.��"� �,/��� i���1 �?. ���,�)$� ��/ .���:� �� =4

@� �# �� �-�)$� ���c*� ��A��5�� �"�,�$�4 ��� 1 ��/js���A �� �� � ��. �&)'� ����+1 ��#. � �a' `sI#5�1 ��a' �'�. .�� �� @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� @�"�� ���� ^� >�� ���Ao�5 : [��� Y����� ��)��$ .F�� ���A ���" �#�/ >�� ��

��� �� �� �/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"�� Y<�,. �5 : Y�/ .�"�,�$�4 ;"�. %/�K4 ��� �� ��. ���a)$� ��/��i�@�(#/ I#x,1 ��/���/�� �)<�,.)CERQ ( -�)$� � ��c*� ��A��5�� -�#�" �)DASS (�� .�� ���a)$� � S��)' ;# !1

��7 ��#{)"�,Q ='�����T ;# !1 X��Y��A �.;�)5" ��/�#{)" ��&�|� �� ��� @��' S��)')� @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"��/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"�� Y<�,. (�A��5�� �)5�� ��/�#{)" �)sV/e=F�s`/s=p(��c*� �)[m/m=F�sV/s=p(�

-�)$�)Vm/Vs=F�ss/s=p(�, "Y$� ��� .�" �����,X�� �� YaA @��1� �'�"�� ��/ Y<�,. � @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"�'��� �1��a)" ��& �|� �/�#{)" ��� ��� � �/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"�� .�� �5���"����A ��� @��' �)5�� ��/�#{)" �� �/

�"�, " ���A �� �# �/ �#J'�#" ���a1 -�)$� � ��c*� ��A��5�� ��/�#{)" �� �� �/� ���A Ba' � ���a1 ��� � Y$� ����Y$� @�(#/ I#x,1 X��" .�'��"�� ��� ��)�# �#|t1 X�� ��� �, �Y$� �).�� �/ .�" @��' S��)' k��(" �� �� �,/�

�" @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"�G�� @����� @����" �)<�,�'��� �'����4 %/�� �� �'��1��. B3�� �|�" �,/� ��'�".� "�H ��(h��:�/� � �,)�" �'�"�� Y<�,. �@�(#/ I#x,1 �@�(#/ �)<�,. I#x,1 ��/���/�� ��)<�,�'��� �'����4� �/�A�

G���,/� ��'�".

1N��)$�i���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� � �)#�1 F� � ��E�'�� �$�,�'��� 2N$�,�'��� ��#�'�� i���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� � �)#�1 F� � ��E�'�� �3N��)$�i���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� � �)#�1 F� � ��E�'�� �$�,�'��� 4Ni���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� � �)#�1 F� � ��E�'�� �$�,�'��� ��)$� 5i���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� �++&1 ��)T� ��(�'�� N)>�p5" ��,5��'([email protected] Email:

Page 52: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

52

�� 2� >�6 ��� � ��'���'��� ���" �)<�,�'��� ��/�"�#4 �"�i2� �A�'� �a," ��/������ �Q�A�

�" %��i�� �� �)<�,�'��� �'����4 >��)6� �"i" ��/��$�)$��,/� .��(�� ;"��� �� �C��'�< �� -�)$�Y$� >� " �'��� �2�1 ���� .�����4�'��� ��'��1�' ����� @����� ���2�� ���

�" �5!" �"i" ���$�)$� ���A)g��� A ��,)��� @�5C: �V�V��s (���� ���2�� �G���'��� �DC�" �� �a )&" k��'� � G w� �,/� ��'�" W�" ���� � �� � ����):� �� �'�.

R� u�c$ G:�" ��3�� �<��" �,��2�� �'����4 �� �����A .��� �'�(#/ �DC�" ;"�. �/ �DC�" ��2�" � ���� �DC�" ����.�'� �#��4 Y��*� ��'��J' � �A��5�� �-�1 �,'�"

�#�/ ��.��"� U#2�C1 � y��"�i� �#��4 u�c$ ���� ���)�� � =a'�" =a' �'�.)��# )���D @��� � @�5"�# ��[�V�om@�5�� �`�V��m.(�" @��' �/��. ��� �,/� �'��1�' �� �/�

� �����'�< ;�Y�3��" �?,1 @��,� � �� ���2�� �K�� �'����4 ��,)5/ � 3�� @�A�,,��" ��(�� �2�" � ����):� ��'��5: ��)<�,�'��� �,�)�"�51 � i1���.h�[ss`(���c*� �

�� � #$� �� �,)5/ � ��. I�D� �A��5�� � -�)$��" X��iA ���2 �'�.)�=������$�����A�"�#$ � �'�#2 �=#)a��4 ��'�#2 ��,��A��e�[sVV.(

G�� @����� @����" ����� ���$ � Y�5' ��)�# �)<�,�'��� �'����4 ��,/� ��'�"�" @��' ����'�<@� �� ��Q ��,/� �,)5/ @��'����� � 7� @��3��" �/)� @��#2�$ �=��

�'�"���j�[ss`����a2 ���C 4 Y2���4 �m�[ss`.(Y2�6 ��,/� @��1�' @����� @����" ����$ ���" @��' ���� @����� @����" � Y�5' ��)�# -�)$� � �C.i]'��� �*�" �@���4 �"� ��,/�

G#$� �|� �#,Q��' @��' �� ���� ��. �## 1 Y#2�p5" ���a1 � Y$� �C�" �"� ��� �� ��,/����� Y#�1 >��3 ���.� y��" ���2�� �� ���/ ��� .Y#2� � �� �R�� " @���4 ��T ��Q ��/

�" �#A�� �)�� �)�3��" �'�.)@R�4 �� C$�� =��/ �o�V��oiJ,#)$�/ ���[ss`.(

����2�� ��� �� -�)$� �� Y$� ���� @��' i#' �� 2�cN" �<� S��)' ��J�� g�� ��

2- Zeitlin, Williamson & Rosenblat 4- Schwartz & Tsumi 6- Weiss Sullivan Diamond 8- Cuskelly, Pullan & Hayes

1- Quittner, Glueckauf & Jackson 3- Dyson 5- Karasavvidis, Avgerinou, Lianou, Priftis, Lianou, & Siamaga 7- Pelchat, Lefebvere & Perreault 9- Hastings

Page 53: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

53

�,):� �"�#4 �).�� ��l4�'G�� @����� Y5#' �,/� ��'�")@�$������ ��2�� i1�� �V�V��[ .(� �T �, " ��� ��" �x'%#4 ��� )" ��/��$�)$� G#��1 ��$��,# ��,,�

�.� ��c*� � -�)$� ��(1 >��)6� .�� ����'�< �"��� � ���2�� �D#+!1 �c$G�� @����� ���2�� ��c*� � -�)$����� �#|t1 �,/� ��'�".�R� �c$ �#,��/

�" ���2�� �� ��. ��(1 -�)$� Y����!" �� -�56� �,'�" �,/� ;"��� � �'��1@��[����):� ���i'� �`���,�<�' �h��?� ��� �/�� Y$� �C�" � �.� y��" �'��' �.� ��c*� ��/)����4 �� #$�� ����"�:�" ��'�'�� �e�[sse.(

%#4 �Q @� -�$��. ���.� �1�" �� �.� >�p5" �#)5&' ���" �� YaA @��1�" �� 1 ���� �'�(#/ ���A��$Y$� ���� �+&. �5a" �� ��,���' � ��. .�� ���"

�)$��< � �/��#' @�# >�p5" �%�' ���Y$� ����'�< ����� ���$ � ���� ��/ .�� ��Y#2�p5" ��� �#J,$ �� Y � � g��� �)��� %/�� G w� b��� ���$ ��/�" �# �� ��'��.

Y���6 ����'� �� %# Y$� �C�" ���" ����� �� Y���6 � ���" �1�� ;���1 -�$����� � ��. ��,,�Y7�� �).�� �� �� ���� @�$���?" G5� ��� G$�," ��/ � �/Y#2� � �� Y����"�" �� >D�)$� � F�('��$ �� ���/���� �� ��,"�('� .�J�� g�� ��

c$ �|� ���� @���� � �'��� ���� �R� �Y���6 � �/ �:�1 �Y$� �C�" �a��� ��/�.� �).��' ��< ���� � ���� .@����" �� �'����� �>��" ��� �,)5/ ���5�� @�.

� �5���" �� ����):� � �)<�,. @�� ��)<�,. ��/������ �� �DC�" �� ����'�@��' ��,)5#' ���5�� @��'����" �� �'������"�,/�)Y���� >�C$� �@�# Aj�[ss`.(

�$�� @�)" ��� 2�c" �)<�,�'��� @��' �"�/� �TI#x,1 ��#5 %�' @�(#/�,"�� �� ��?"���)5A �" ��� �)<�,�'��� ��/�"�#4 �� �� �,�)@�: � -��Am�

[ss`(��?" ;"�� � ����## 1 �)"D$ ��).�� ��E �� Z��" ���D"� 1 ����):��Y$)��"�T� ��)�#$ ����i��o�V��e �@�5]"�1��V��V (���' ��@���RD)N<�

2- feeling of being restricted 4- dissatisfaction 6- Glidden & Schoolcraft 8- Cicchetti, Ackerman & Izard

1- Koller, Richardson & Katz 3- social isolation 5- Majumdar, Da Silva Pereira & Fernandes 7- Gross & Jhon

Page 54: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

54

@�����A��5�� �,'�" ��. ���$ � ��c*� ���i'� �RD)<� � ����):� @�� ���$��. �,'�" ����E/i �y��1�� �'��J.�<�4 ��)�� ����)���'i��V��@���E�/ [ssV.(

�N��x'�N" �#��1 @�(#/ ��/� �" ������ �� �#5a1 �JN'�JQ �� �,,� ������ �� ��" �.� �).�� �" �'�(#/ r$�4 �� ��?" ������ �'��1)��.[�[sse .(�� � ������

-�#�" �� �/ �� ���a)$� �|�" �a," �a��� %/�� �� �C�£�2��i#� � �.��iA��< ��/ Y$� ��. �)<�,.)�,5��`�-��A �[sso(� �)<�,. ������� �� �J�#�/ ���a)$� � �

�'��� Y"D$ ����)�@�: � -��A[ss` (Y$� ����/ �'��� G#$� �� �,#��4 u�c$ �);#J�� � �,2�� ����&)��h�[ss�.(

�" @��' ��/�K4 � ��x' �,#�#4 ���$ �� �'����4 � � ��" ��� �T �/�-�)$� � �)<�,�'���Y# 3�" �� �.�' ��/���?" ����.� ��/ ;#�3 �� �)<�,. ��/ ��lA�#|t1 �/�A� �/�Y$� .�/�A� �/� ��, " �:�1 @��� ��K�� ��,���/ ��@�"�

� ��'�,� �2�< ��%#4����� �����3 Y$� )���� W���� ;�' � ��� i"�# �� �>�J$;��i#1e�[ss[ .(�/�A� �/� Fi )5" ��/���/�� ����)�� �)<�,. ��K�� �)<�,.���

��� i���)" @��� �,���� �:�1 Y$� � ����' �<���#A� : � ���#4��" ��,/�����Z < �a," W�C� �a,"W� %���A r$�4��/ @��J'��,,� ��A��� ����: �������4��C�� @�(#/ ���/ �,��.�< �(," �"��.)B�," @��/.(

�R� k�#. � �:�1 ��'����4�)<�,�'��� ��/ �# �� G�� @����� @����" ��'�"�,/� �a," ���|� �@���E �� �@� �A���'�< � �����/��" �x' � ��"�< ����� ��$�

� �/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"�� Y<�,. �,'�" �'�"�� ��/���/�� G2�3 �� �)<�,�'����" @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"��.� ��J/�� @����" ��� �'��� Y.��? �#"t1 �� �'��1.��

%/�K4 ��:� F�� � �:�1 � ��J�� ��$�(1 ��/�,#"� �� ��� ��� ��&�|� �5���"�" �x' � ����* ��/�K4 �#,Q F�('� ��'�"�� X���$���|� @�i#" �1 N��& X��"�

2- Scherer 4- Eftekhari, Zoellner & Vigil

1- Eisenberg 3- Ochsner 5- Segal, William & Teasdale

Page 55: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

55

@�(#/ I#x,1 F�' � �T ����4�' @�"�� �MBCT�/�� �� �Y$� ��. �'����4 ��� @�(#/ I#x,1 �)<�,. ��/���/�� � �)<�,�'�����. �$�� ����� .�� ���a1 �)���

@� ��&�|� �,#"��'��' �� �/Z#�!1 �)5�� ��/�#{)" ��� � � �'���� ��/���!�� 1 �" � Y.�� �/��< ��?" �����T � ��x' �'��� Y.��? ���6 @�++&)" � �'��1

,T ^�T%&�|� �1 �'� ��T � � ���T �&)'� �� @�"�� ���1�.

B�� � 3����

B�: X�� � �:�1 � �*�6 %/�K4���� ������#' k�' �� ��/ � �/��A �# ��(1%#4=4 � @�"���� @�"�� .�#*�� � g��/� � �:�1 � ���$ �� ��� ���/�K4 ��/

u�� k�' �� u��� �:�1 � � �����T ��/ �c$ ��!2 � � � c�" k�' �� �@�"� � �� �J'���£ k�' �� �� 2�c" ���" .

���%� B�� � ���%� E�&��P�#"( G�� @�T��T @����" ;"�. �%/�K4 ��� ���"� � "�:�� i���1 �?. �,/� ��'�" .Y?:

Y$� -�)$� ���c*� ��A��5�� �"�,�$�4 ��)� ��x' ���" �'��' � ���)DASS ( ���G�� @�T��T @����" �i���1 �?. ���,�)$� -���" �� ;#+!1 � ;w�. �,/� ��'�"

@� �# �� � ��. ��:� ��� 1 �/js�+#&�1 ��6�+" � �"�,�$�4 ��� S��)' -�$�� �a' �'�. �&)'� .���A �� �� ����+1 ���7 � �Y��*� l<� �� =4 ��� 1 ���`s��a'

�'�. ��iJ��:.�� �"�,�$�4 =]$ -�)$� ���c*� ��A��5)DASS (���< �-�#�"��/ � :�� ��,/� ���&�' ���< %'��$ �)<�,. I#x,1 �"�,�$�4 @��J�� %'��$ � ���J'�

�. ��:� @�(#/ .�� �� @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� ���� ^� >�� ���Ao�5 : V[s��#3� ���'��� �� �$�,�'��� ��)T� ��(�'�� �x' ��� .�� I/ �J�� ���Ao:�5 V[s

��#3��,)��A ���3 �/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"�� Y<�,. X��"� Y!1 �� .F��1� �� � -�)$� ���c*� ��A��5�� �"�,�$�4 ����� X��"�)DASS (���< �-�#�" ��/

� :�� ��,/� ���&�' ���< %'��$ �)<�,. I#x,1 �"�,�$�4 @��J�� %'��$ � ���J'��. ��:� @�(#/ .�� ���,�" �1�5���" ��.� �� ��/.

Page 56: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

56

B������ � ��

X�� Y<�,. � @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� X�� �� ;"�. %/�K4 ��� �� � <��" ��/�"�'� ��5 : ���7 �T �� �/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"���.��"� ��/W��� �� �'�"��

Y$� ��. �����.7� P)�(���" C"D�$ B)��� 9�;�P ����K�

9�;�P �,)��� ����K�9�;�P >�� ��A��� �I���"�# �� ���?" ��� �����Q@�(#/ ���" �� Y$�� ��/ � ����" ��,"��T �/

@�(#/���'�| � �#2�� ��/.F�� @�(#/ ���lA F�'@�(#/ ��/�" ;�� �'�JQ �/@�(#/ ��,,T�" ^�T �" � �/�,,T.F�$ @�(#/ ��T��T � U#7�1�/

F��?Q G#$� @��� %/�T ���l4@�(#/ ��a," ��/ I(,4 �"�'� X��"�@�(#/ � ��(1 @��� %��i�� ��� �i��Y#2� � Y$�?� �#?1 �Y��" ��/ ��/

�l2%& I�. @�(#/ �� @�. �/���'���� ��/ I)a/ @�(#/ I#x,1 � ����" I)�/ @�(#/ I#x,1 � ����"

7� P)0(��(� �� #� ���6� �����3 !���, 9�;�P ����K� 9�;�P 9�;�P �,)��� ����K�

>�� �����< Y���/ :@� �$��� ��3��" ��/�A� � %��� �� @���< F�� B'��" � �).�� �����$ :����1 ��'�/�A� �/� =a,1 ��#3� �� �@� �$��� ��3��"� ��C�� ��/

��$�56� F�$ =a,1 �/�A� �/�)Y��6 �� @� �:(a,1 � %�� ����1 ��'�/�A� �/� Y��6�=

Y# 3�� �� �E� i���1 ��,��.�< ��(1 I���1 @��T �&�" F��?Q �*�6 @�"� �� @�'�" �3� :��#3� S,4 �/�A� �/���3��" �@�#,. �� @��� ��/��" ��

U��!1 ��'�/�A� �/� �)�� ��� ��)5�'�)<�,. ��/ I(,4 @��� ���:� � �)���l4 :� �#.�" �@� � =a,1 �� �/�A� ��)5�' ��3��"� ��E�� �$�� � @�"

� �3 ��/ �,# %#4

Page 57: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

57

I�. Y# 3�� ��C���,)5#' �/ :����1 �Y# 3�� �� �E� i���1 �@� � =a,1 �� �/�A� ��)5�' ��3��"Z <��A��� � ��C�� ��/��iJ��: ��/

I)a/ �" �'�JQ�F��� ;�� � F��< �� �� Y�3��" ���)? I'��1 :�=a,1 �� �/�A� ��)5�' ��3��"@�@�(#/ � ��C�� ��/��7 ���� �Z < � Y#2� � �# y��1�� ���$�,. ��/��'��$ �,���� ;6

I)�/ ��,�� �� ��#A ��C ��� ��. �)��A ��� �� �i#Q @� �� ���a)$� :��3��" �@� �$��� ��3��"���� ;� ���" ����?'W�A�'� �� ��. ��� ���/i#Q �Q�� ��,)5/ �,�.��� ��#5 @�1

����1�"��,� ��� ��. � �'��1

q%P ����U��9�G8b� ����

B�: ��)$�� ���"�,�$�4 �*�6 %/�K4 F�('� ��� ����* ���D�� ���� ��/ -�)$� ���c*� ��A��5��)DASS ( @�(#/ I#x,1 �)<�,. ��/���/�� �)CERQ (

Y��A ���3 ���a)$� ���":

-#��� E^�#._� E�(3#;�� ������# )DASS:( �#�" � ��c*� ��A��5�� --�)$�)DASS-21 ( >�$ �� ��'����2 b$�1 �TV��eI/ � �:�1 � �� �A��5�� �.�4

����'� � U�� 1 ��x," � ���c*� ���$ ��#A �� ���. �)<�$ �A��5�� � ��c*� ��/Y$� ��. ���a)$� @� �� %/�K4 ��� .����(" �-�#�" ��� �B3�� �� -�#�" �$ �� ��

� �(,$��<����'� ��� �T Y$ Y2�6 ��#A � ��c*� ��A��5�� ��a," �'�(#/ ��/Y$� ��. �6��� -�)$� .���' �.��' -�)$� �� �A��5�� ���c*� ��Q� �'��"�� �A�

Z 1 �� � �$ ���' ���� � #< � �� ���' ���� �^� ���' �'i �� IT �,�iA �A� ��a7Y��A �/��< .%$�4 ��� �� -�#�" �/ 4 ��"�'�" ��+)<� ��< � �� >�z$ S, � ��/�

-�#�" �� ��� ���' ����7 �#�/� -�)$� � �A��5�� ���c*� ��/ �" Y$� ���)I.�/ ���,3 � ��#� �����V`�s .(� 2�c" �� I.�/ ���,3 � ��#� ����)V`�s(�

� "�� ;# !1 �� ���a)$� � @� ����� � �'��� �'�5�/ Z��� �� -�#�" ��� ���)�� �I/ ���:� � vD" ����� @�"�� @�"� -�)$� � �'�� ��c*� �^ �A��5�� ��/

Y$� �)��A ���3 �$�� ���" ���. v���� .-�#�" �'��� �'�5�/ ��/DASS � ������ ���'��T ��a2� �� ���a)$� �� �'� :�A��5�� -�#�"mm/s��c*� -�#�" �m�/s�

Page 58: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

58

-�)$� -�#�"mo/s. ��x," � �#,��/ �TD" ����� �$��DASS ���:� �� �I/ %$�4 @�"� ��. ���a)$� ��. v���� -�)$� � �'�� ��c*� �^ �A��5�� �"�'

Y$� .�A��5�� -�#�" �J)5��/DASS^ �A��5�� @�"�� � ms/s�J)5��/ ��'�� ��c*� @�"�� � @� ��c*� -�#�"jm/s� @� -�)$� -�#�" �J)5��/ �

��. v���� -�)$�h�/s�J)5��/ ��� �"��1 �T ��� �c$ �� �/ssV/s>P����, " �,)5/ .%$�4 ��1�T F�� �� %/�K4 ��� �� �"�'DASS �T [V>�z$ )��� >��$ Ya/

-�#�" �/ (�. ���a)$� �����.

������# C"D�$ �����, ���")CERQ(:�"�,�$�4 �-�#�" ����,Q ���� Y$� S���� ��C5a'��A b$�1 �� @��?,#]$� �)[ssV (�� � �Ca1 ��!' ������ ��x," �

-�)$� �� ��,,����?1 ��/���<� ��(1Y$� ��. �#?1 �A�'� ���.gD<� ���$�"�,�$�4��/ � ��"���T���E.� ���7 �# ��E�� ��� �>���� � 3�� ��i���1

;��3 ��'��'�. �"�,�$�4 ��� ��E�� ��� ��=4��^���(1 �a," ��B��3� G#$� �������� �"�,T.��� �"�,�$�4 ^���i� �.��iA��< Y$� ����� �`j���" �"��!' �� �.�

�:�� S,4 -�#�" -�$�� @� � r$�4���� ���3 ��#�/ �1 iA�/ �� ��.��� ���:��"�,�$�4 � #< @�$� Y$� ��� ������ V[>�$ �R�)I/����� ��(,? �I/

�:Y# �,#2� ��/ (;�3 ���a)$� �"�.� .�"�,�$�4 I#x,1�)<�,. @�(#/)CERQ (����� ����< -�#�" Y$�.S,4 ���< -�#�")��(" i���1 �Y��" ��(" i���1 �X��l4

�"�'� ���A��� ��&1� �Y��" ��(" ������ ��i��(��� %$�4�"�' ^�$��/ I#x,1@�(#/�)<�,. ��A��$ ���?Q ���<�J�� -�#�" )� :�� ��,/� ���&�' ���< %'��$���J'�

@��J�� %'��$ �(^�$��/ @�(#/ I#x,1 �)<�,. ��A��$�' �,)5/ .���< �/ -�#�" �/ ���' ����� �/ � ��. ���� ����' �)5 B�: Z��� �� �� Y$� ����� ��?Q �����

���<�,"�� �� -�#�" �� ��)h�1[s(��" Y$���� .;� B�:�,"�� �� ����' �� ��`j�1Vos�" ���3 ��#A .�����' �/��� ����� %$�4�"�' VV���' �'�A��: �"�'��1

Y����� �,T .� "�� ;# !1 �� ���a)$� � @���� �� -�#�" ��� �����4 � ���)<�$ ������� ��a2� G��* �� ���a)$� � @� �����4 � Y$� �)��A ���3 �#�t1 ���" ��#��1 ��� ���'�

Page 59: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

59

���< �� F��� �/ �# �/ -�#�"jh/s�1o[/sY$� ��. X��iA )�����V`oj .( �a$��)V`oe (Y$� ���� �$�� �'���� @�'��:�' �� �� -�#�" ��� �����4 � ���)�� .G��*

���< ��� ���'��� ��a2� X�� � �����4 �@�(#/ I#x,1 �a," ��/���/�� -�#�"mo/s/�� -�#�" ���< ��@�(#/ I#x,1 Y��" ��/���o`/s-�#�" ;� ��� �oV/sY$�

Y$� ��"� .-�#�" ���)�� G��*oe/sY$� ��. X��iA .�� �"�,�$�4 ��� �#,��/Y��*� � G$�," �����4 � ���)��Y$� �����<� �'���� �,/�� �� ���a)$� ��� ��& .��

���< �� %/�K4 ����� ��� �a," @�(#/ I#x,1 -�#�"��/���/�� ���� �)<�,. I#x,1�. ���a)$� @�(#/.

43�3 1"�K$ � ��U�$ B�� �

���� ;# !1 � ��i(1 %/�K4 ��� �� � ��/F�' �� ���a)$� � ��"� Y$� ��i��VjSPSS �Y��A ���7 ��#{)"�,Q ='������ ;# !1 X��.

������

%#4 @�. Z�!" � �:�1 ���������T ;# !1 � y��" ��/ �$�� Y?: �='��5���" Y��A F�('� ��#{)"�,Q ='������T ;# !1 @�"�� �� <��" X�� �� ��&�|� ��

>���: �� @� S��)' ��`�hY$� ��. ����� .7� P)?(B�� 9�#@� �;��2� ��#� 4#"+�� �Q W�������H 1"�K$ x���� #� �����3 ��

��;��� ��#"+��

#@� ���)� B)��F#� �3�)� �P�3�"_ �.� �3�)� �P�3��&� ~.����3���A ��D#4 �|�hs/s�o/`mhVss[/s

>��: ��:��,"`�" @��' G#T�1 � ���a)" ���|� �'�"�� X�� �� �� �/� �'��� �)5�� ��/�#{)")p<0/01 .( >��:h��� �� ��#{)"�,Q ='������� ;# !1 S��)'

���' �5���"� �� �� �)5�� ��/�#{)" ��/�" @��' �'�"�� X��/�.

Page 60: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

60

7� P)I(B�� 9�#@� 4#"+�� �Q W�������H 1"�K$��;��� ��#"+�� #� �����3 ��

��;��� #"+�� q6�� ��%��9������

�P�3�3�)�

�":��"�9������ F

~.� ��&����3

������$�

�A��5�� mh/hoVmh/hosV/es`/ss�/s��c*� hj/mhVhj/mh[m/msV/sV`/s-�)$� �j/VVm V�j/VVm Vm/Vsss/sVm/s

��< %'��$ [`/VoV[`/Voem/`sj/ssm/s�,/� ���&�' h[/eVh[/eo�/s`e/ssV/s

� :�����$ m`/VVm`/VVo/sjj/sssh/s@��J�� %'��$

���A

he/[sVhe/[she/[V[/sse/s

>��: �� 0��," S��)'h�" @��' � �� �/� ;�)5" ��/�#{)" ��&�|)X��"��/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"�� Y<�,. � @�(#/ I#x,1 (�A��5�� �)5�� ��/�#{)" �

)sV/e=F�s`/s=p(��c*� �)[m/m=� 0sV/s=p(-�)$� �)Vm/Vs=F�ss/s=p(�, "Y$� ��� .�" �����,X�� �� YaA @��1 � @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� �'�"�� ��/

Y<�,.�'��� �1��a)" ��&�|� �/�#{)" ��� ��� � �/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"�� .

7� P)N(4�#( �3 ��;��� ��#"+�� �":��"� �P�) �;��2������3 ��

4�#(��#"+�� 9��*$�":��"�

3�� ����� ��.��":��"�

~.� ��&����3

5���A�� se/[W�V/ss`/s��c*� e`/[W�`/ssV/s-�)$� Vo/`WVss`/s

��< %'��$ [e/VWjj/ssj/s�,/� ���&�' jo/sWm[/s`e/s

� :�����J'� `o/soo/sjj/s

@�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� �'�"�� Y<�,. �/� � �,)�"

�/�A�

@��J�� %'��$ `[/VWoh/sV[/s

Page 61: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

61

>��: �� 0��," S��)' -�$��e���A ��� � �� �5���" ��/�)5�� ��/�#{)" ���" @��'�#J'�#" ���a1 -�)$� � ��c*� ��A��5�� ��/�#{)" �� �� �/� �� �# �/

�, " ���AY$� @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� ���A Ba' � ���a1 ��� � Y$� ��� .��� �, ��'��"�� ��� ��)�# �#|t1 X��Y$� �).�� �/ .�" @��' S��)' k��(" �� �� �,/�

#/ I#x,1 X��"��" @�( G�� @����� @����" �)<�,�'��� �'����4 %/�� �� �'��1��. B3�� �|�" �,/� ��'�".

��"�� � dK��#"(

�'�"�� Y<�,. � @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� X�� �� �� �'��� @��' %/�K4 ��� S��)'G�� @����� @����" �)<�,�'��� �'����4 � �1��a)" �#|t1 �/�A� �/� � �,)�" ��'�"

� �,/��'�� .��� �"� �R��)6� �;#2� �#�t1 X����/ I#x,1 @�(#/ ��� ��/�A� >�),� �uD7� ��'�(#/ �a," ;7�6 ��b��� �# ����� i���1 ���,���1 � �� �

�/�A��� �;#C�1 ��5 : �;C. �/��A ����(#)' ��:� �R���1 �|z" �# ���� ��� Y$� .S��)' %/�K4 �*�6 @��' �"�/� ��X��"� I#x,1 @�(#/ ��K�� ��

%/�� �A��5�� %&�|��1��� Y$�.���. ���� ;#2� ����'�"�� Y$� ����)<�$ �,.�� ���� ����#,C1��/ ���)�� ���a)$� �"�,� .����(#)' �5�/ ��)������/

Y$� ��@��' �����'� X��"� �J)a/ ���?"��/�" �C#)C2��� �'�"�� ��)�� ��1 �'�@�"�� �A��5�� �"i" �"�('�#)i,#�� � @�$ >�," �-��" ��,#2V�[ss`.(

���� @��' U )&" �� 2�c"G�� @�T��T @����" ��T �'� � �5���" �� �,/� ��'�"�" @��' ��)�# �)<�,�'��� �'����4 ����� @�T��T @����" �,/�)� Y��� ��,'�"

iJ,#)$�/[�[ssh�^#' ��T��`�[sso(��Y<�,.��/ ^�$� ��" ��/��"���T��< � �� %#4 ;"��� � �: �� ���2���,#�" ���. � �)<�,�'��� �'����4 ��,,T �,��)� iJ,#)$�/

2- White & Hastings 1- Lynch, Morse, Mendel son & Robins 3- Neece & Baker

Page 62: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

62

@���V�[ss[.(����$ @�(#/ I#x,1 �� T ������" ��+1 �� Y$� ����� �#|t1 ��.-�)$� ��/������ � ���A��$ �� � ���� �'��5: � �'��� Y"D$ � %�' �A�'� ���

���� ��?" .� � #+!1 ��E �� ��)"D$ ��/�"�#4 %��i�� � @�(#/ I#x,1 �� Y#���"� Y$� ����/ � {. >D)<� � @�(#/ I#x,1 �� ���'��1 F�� �=E�� ��'��� ��/

.� ���c*� � �)#+& ... Y$� b�1�")�2�' ����2�W�i���. � ��E$�/[�[sVs � i1��A ��"��`�[ssh .(�#A�� � Y#�$� � 2�c"h)[ss� (�" @��'@�(#/ I#x,1 �T �/� ��/

��)"D$ ��� ��?" ��!�� 1 ��,"��#'�����# ����� ����� �# �� �K�� �"i" ��/���� .

�" �����,YaA @��1��Ix'��< �� �7�< ;C. @�(#/ I#x,1 Y$� ��&)=#1�C$�2 =1�� �e�[sss (�@�(#/ �� ����� @���' ��A� � @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� ��/

@� � �|�" @�"� ��,T � X��l4 � �a," � Y��"�" �/@� @��� Y"D$ �'��1 ��1�� �� �/ ��&)�"�T � U���j�[ssm .( � @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� �����?" � ��,���1 ���/

�" �#Tt1@� ����T �T ��. �A�'� ^�$ X���4 ��'�(#/ �DE�" X��l4 � �(," �/@�(#/ ��� �� U2�&" ;�� F�('� �I2�$ ;#?51 � Y��?' �� �T ���. �a," ��/

�" �(," ���##{1 ��.)@�?,#2m�[sss .(@� Z���1 � @�(#/ I#x,1 X��"� �#,��/ �/ �x' �� �����1�T g��/� �)��A�, � ��"Y#2� � F�('� ���"�l2 ��/ � �'���� %&

����1� ��,A -�56� � I�< � � ��" Y?: ���/ ...�"� ��" ��/���/�� �'��1 ��|�" ��@� ��#)<� �� �� �/� ���3 �/)�@�?,#2V��`.(

�)��� � %/�K4 ��� S��)'%/�K4 ��/�'�<��!" � �,56 ����� ��/)V`�V(���,#T� �"����"�4���o)[sVs(�;��TW�i #$ ��2�� @��� �����/ )[ssj(Y#�$� ��#A�� �)[ss�(@���E�/ � >��1�� ����&1� �)[sVV(@���C�/ � �!2�7 �)V`�s (�5�/

��6� � ��$��2�� �@���4 ���� ��'����' � 2�c" S��)' � �)V`o� (Y$� �5�/�#w.

2- Aldao, Nolen-Hoeksema & Schweizer 4- Smyth & Arigo 6- Dimeff & Koerner 8- Berking, Meier & Wupperman

1- Brown 3- Gratz, K.L. & Roemer 5- Tice & Bratslavsky 7- Linehan

Page 63: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

63

Y����!" ���" %/�K4 ��� ��/� 1 @�C"� F�� � @��1�)��� I# Y# �: � �/���A ���$ � �"����" ��?,�#4 � ��� ���.� ���,�)$� ��/X�� ��. @�(#/ I#x,1 ��/

�'��' ���$ ��� � �/�A� �/� � �,)�" �'�"�� Y<�,. ���J�� �)5�� ��/�#{)" � �/��. ��� ��� � .�)����" �*�6 %/�K4 ��/�"�'� Y5��T ��� �1�!�� 1 �'��1��/

@�(#/ Y����" � � <��"G�� @�T��T @����" ��� �/ �'����4 ;�� 1 ��x," � ��'�"@� �)<�,�'����.� �).�� �/.

���iJ$�]$ :��J�'�� �� �$�,�'��� �++&1 ���)�� �2�$� �� 0�&)5" � 2�c" �������5" �� �l � ��� i���1� ;"��� �"��1 ��/�� @����" � ��J�'�� @R�p5" �K�� @���

G���" ���iJ$�]$ �'��#�7 i���1 �?. �,/� ��'�"���A.

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :s[/sj/V`�[ �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :V�/Vs/V`�[ �2��" X��l4 r���1:Ve/sV/V`�`

Page 64: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

64

q���� References

���/� ����� ,56����a : ��'�<��!" F��?.)V`�V .(�#|t1 X��"� ���?" Ix' ���: @�(#/ �,)�" � ��)�� �'�"�� ^#)E2��� ���$�$� D)�" ����� �g�+"�$ ����"���� ��������� ��"<�� �)Ve(`�hVW``.

? �@���� �@��w� �Ix�� ��!2�7��"�� ��6��#$ ����6� ������)V`�V .(�$�� @�i#" ��&�|� ��X�� X��"� I#x,1 @�(#/ �,)�" �>�" �,���� -��A ���)�� �'�"�� I�D� � �#)C2���

�@���(�'�� �'�(#/ �DE�"���� 9�2"2K$ [��G �S,U �� �)�Vh[ �ehWh�.

I.�/ ���,3 ��:�/ ���#�F��? ����� � �)V`�s .(^� �'�"�� ���A ��&�|� �5���" � ��#6�1 �Q��4 ���* �� =4 -�)$� >D)<� @����'�: @��5�/ �'��� ���� %/�T �� ���)�� �)<�,. ����

��������� �h�V�[`N`e.

@�� $ �����)V`oj .(4�( �3 ��G �.���!fP E����" �;��2� E�#"(3�� E�;�P 2� �#"( � ��"�)���� ���" C"D�$��������3 ����" �< % @���4 ���C�'�� ��$�,�'��� �).� �.�� �$�,.��� �"�'

i���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� � �)#�1 F� �.

>�) ���6� �-��� ���$��2��� ��# $ �@���4���� ���!" ��'����')V`o� .(X��"� ��&�|� �5���" ��/#. @����'�: @��� Y"D$ � @�(#/ I#x,1 � �/�A� �/� ����#���"<�� ��������� ���� �[�h�

m[WjV.

����� ��a$��)V`oe .( �� ��c*� � �A��5�� � @�(#/ I#x,1 �)<�,. ��/���/�� �c�� �$��%'�� �@��<�� ��/��� )$� ����,/�� i���" @���"��� �3�."a ��H3�H ����j����j�h�o�[WomV.

Aldao, A., Nolen-Hoeksema, S., & Schweizer, S. (2010). Emotion-Regulation Strategies across Psychopathology: A Meta-analytic Teview, Clinical Psychology Review, 30, 217-237.

Berking M., Meier, C., & Wupperman, P. (2010). Enhancing Rmotion-Regulation Skills in Police Officers: Results of a Pilot Controlled Dtudy, Behav Ther, 41(3), 329-339.

Campbell-Sills, L., Barlow, D.H., Brown, T.A., & Hofmann, S.G. (2006). Effects of Suppression and Acceptance on Emotional Responses of

Page 65: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

65

Individuals with Anxiety and Mood Disorders, Behaviour Research and Therapy, 44, 1251-1263.

Cicchetti, D., Ackerman, B.P., & Izard, C.E. (1995). Emotions and Emotion Regulation in Developmental Psychopathology, Development and Psychopathology, 7, 1-10.

Cuskelly, M., Pullan, L., & Hayes, A. (1998). Parenting & employment Decision of Parents with a Preschool Child with Disability, Journal of Intellectual & Developmental Disability, 23, 319-332.

Dimeff, L.A., & Koerner, K. (2007). Dialectical Behavior Therapy in Clinical Practice, New York: Guilford Press.

Dyson, L.L. (1997). Fathers and Mothers of School-age Children with Developmental Disabilities: Parental Stress, Family Functioning, and Social Support, American Journal on Mental Retardation, 102, 267-279.

Eftekhari, A., Zoellner, L.A., & Vigil, S.A. (2009). Patterns of Emotion Regulation and Psychopathology, Anxiety, Stress & Coping: An International Journal, 22, 571-586.

Eisenberg, N., Cumberlan, A., Spinrad, T.L., Fabes, R. A., Shepard, S.A., Reiser, M., Murphy, B.C., Losoya, S.H., & Guthrie, I.K. (2001). The Relations of Regulation and Emotionality to Children's Externalizing and Internalizing Problem Behavior, Child Development, 72, 1134.

Etxeberria Arritxabal, I., García Soler, A., Iglesias Da Silva, A., Urdaneta Artola, E., Lorea González, I., Díaz Veiga, P., & Yanguas Lezaun, J.J. (2011). Effects of Training in Emotional Regulation Strategies on the Well-Being of Carers of Alzheimer Patients, Rev Esp Geriatr Gerontol, 46(4), 206-12.

Garnefski, N., Kraaij, V., & Spinhoven P. (2001). Negative Life Events, Cognitive Emotion Regulation and Emotional Problems, Personality and Individual Differences , 30, 1311-1327.

Glidden, L.M., & Schoolcraft, S.A. (2003). Depression: Its Trajectory and Correlates in Mothers Rearing Children with Intellectual Disability, JIntellect Disabil Res, 47 (4/5), 250-263.

Gratz, K.L., & Roemer, L. (2004). Multidimensional Assessment of Emotion Regulation and Dysregulation: Development, Factor Structure, and

Page 66: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

66

Initial Validation of the Difficulties in Emotion Regulation Scale, Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment, 26, 41-54.

Gross, J.J., & John, O. P. (2003). Individual Differences in Two Emotion Regulation Processes: Implications for Affect, Relationships, and Well-Being, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 85, 348-362.

Hastings, R.P. (2003). Child behavior Problems and Partner Mental Health as Correlates of Stress in Mothers and Gathers of Children with Severe Autism, J Intellect Disabil Res, 47 (4-5), 231-237.

Hastings, R.P., & Brown, T. (2002). Behavior Problems of Children with Autism, Parental Self-efficacy, and Mental Health, American Journal on Mental Retardation, 107, 222-232.

Karasavvidis, S., Avgerinou, C., Lianou, E., Priftis, D., Lianou, A., & Siamaga, E. (2011). Mental Retardation and Parenting Stress, International Journal of Caring Sciences, 4(1), 21-28.

Koller, H., Richardson, S.A., & Katz, M. (1992). Families of Children with Mental Retardation: Comprehensive View from an Epidemiologic Perspective, Am J Ment Retard, 97, 315-32.

Linehan, M.M. (1993). Skills Rraining Manual for Treating Borderline Personality Disorder, New York: Guilford Press.

Linehan, M. (2000). Cognitive-behavioral Treatment of Borderline Personality Dosorder, New York: Guilford Press.

Lynch, T.R., Morse, J.Q., Mendel Son, T., & Robins, C. (2003). Dialectical Behavior Therapy for Depressed Older Adults: A Randomized Pilot study, Am J Geriatric Psychiatry, 11, 33-45.

Majumdar, M., Da Silva Pereira, Y., & Fernandes, J. (2005). Stress and Anxiety in Parents of Mentally Retarded Children, Indian J Psychiatry, 47(3), 144-147.

Neece, C., & Baker, B. (2008). Predicting Maternal Parenting Stress in Middle Childhood: The Roles of Child Intellectual Status, Behavior Problems and Social Skills, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 52, 1114-1128.

Ochsner, K.N, & Gross, J.J. (2008). Cognitive Emotion Regulation: Insights from Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, Current Directions in Psychological Science, 17, 153-158.

Page 67: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

67

Pelchat, D., Lefebvere, H., & Perreault, M. (2003). Differences and Similarities between Mothers’ and Fathers’ Experiences of Parenting a Child with a Disability, J Child Health Care, 7, 231-247.

Quittner, A., Glueckauf, R.,. & Jackson, D. (1990). Chronic Parenting Stress: Moderating Versus Mediating Effects of Social Support, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 59, 1266-78

Scherer, K.R. (2005). What Are Emotions? And How Can They be Measured? Soc Sci Inf, 44, 695-729.

Segal, Z.V., Williams, J.M.G., & Teasdale, J.D. (2002). Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy for Depression: A New Approach to Preventing Relapse, New York: Guildford Press.

Schwartz, C., & Tsumi, A. (2003). Parental Involvement in the Residentialcare of Persons with Intellectual Disability: The Impact of Parents’and Residents’ Characteristics and the Process of Relocation, Journal of Applied Intellectual Disabilities, 16, 285-293.

Smyth J.M., Arigo D (2009). Recent Evidence Supports Emotion-Regulation Interventions for Improving Health in At-risk and Clinical Populations, Curr Opin Psychiatry, 22(2), 205-10.

Tice, D.M., & Bratslavsky, E. (2000). Giving in to Feel Good: The Place of Emotion Regulation in the Context of General Self-control, Psychological Inquiry, 11, 149-159.

Weiss, J. A., Sullivan, A., & Diamond, T. (2003). Parent stress adaptive Functioning of Individuals with Developmental Disabilities, Journal on Developmental Disabilities, 10, 129-135.

White, N., & Hastings, R.P. (2004). Social and Professional Support for Parents of Adolescents with Severe Intellectual Disabilities, Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, 171, 181-190.

Zeitlin, S., Williamson, G., & Rosenblat, W.P. (1987). The Coping Stress Model: A Counselling Approach for Families with Handicapped Child, JCouns Dev, 65, 443-6.

Page 68: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

68

I��� $( )*+& ,�-!� >� )&1;�6 ��� W)��<� �(

��";a %o "�z

�6"6a p� %a{

�;a %K��� |

4 "rQ

�/� ����/ ��)�� Y����" � 7� �6��" �� �E� @�"��$ �� @� ��|� � -�)$� k�*�" ��#<� Y$� ���� ��+)<� ��< � �� �'�"��$ .���"�$ �'R�$ Y"D$ @���� Y � � �)aJ,/ ��/

:�'��5 W� {. -�)$� ;#2� � ;{. �##{1 � ;{. v�1 � @�'� �����T %/�T �@�,T��T �'��� �" Y$� �����.�9��� � @�,T��T � {. -�)$� ��,,T ��(�� ;"��� �$�� ��x," � Z#�!1 ���

Y��A F�('� � {. -�)$� >�" .� i���1 ��J�'�� @�,T��T �# � ;"�. Z#�!1 ���"� � "�: ��� 1�Vo ��� 1 � ���"� �'��' I(6 � �a'[m`�" �a' �.� .����D�� ������A ��i�

�� �)<�$ Z�!" �"�,�$�4 .����'� ��/�#{)" ;# �1 ��x," � � "�� ;# !1 X�� �� ��. ��#A ��� 1 � ������A ���a)$�Vs�'�. �&�" � {. X�)$� ��(�� ;"�� .;"��� ���$�,. �� �

. -�)$� ��,,T ��(�� � ;"��� �� ^� �/ ���lA�|� @�i#" �"���� @�"�� �� ���a)$� � �� {Y��2�� ��� u�. � � 2�c" ���" ����� � {. X�)$�����A ��, :VW�'�"��$ ;"���[W�,/��

�'�"��$ Y�� �`W�'�"��$ ��" b< hW%�' ���� �/eW���)<�$ ;"��� jWY#,"� F�� � {. /�2�"mW������4�'oW��b� ���� �# �W� %�' �J)5��. VsW� {. b���. � Z#�c1 .

��� "�H ��(h:i���1 ��J�'�� ��/�J�'�� b#!" ��.��"� b#!" �� {. -�)$�.

1�(�'�� N��)�� ��"���)2�� Y������� �"D� ��J�'�� ��2i���1 ��J�'�� �� � ��#/ ��� � �����)$� N)>�p5" ��,5��'(Email:[email protected] 3�,.��� N�" �.�� -���)2�� Y�

Page 69: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

69

�� 2�

»-�)$�V«^�����4 � T ��'�?: Y$� ���#�/ ;#2� %/�K4 ��/ ����� ��$�� -�)$� � � {. ���6����+)<� �)��� Y$� �@��J�/�K4 ����� �/�"�#4 �

�.�' ����� ����4 �Y.��? �'��� �'��5: ������ %.�� ��/ ����� ���� �'� .�" >� � �� �C� -�)$� YaA @��1 ���6 ���1 ��/�K4 ��/)hssss �#�/ �� Z#�!1

�/� (>�$ �� ��#"�' -�)$� �+� �� �#<� @�3 � Y$� ��� �#<� ��/ �'�)���� � ;#2��[�

[ssh� ;�' � �@�5#2� �`�[ssm .(��/���� �� �).lA >�$ �$ �� ��)$�� �#�/ �� X��iA @�� " �� ����. -�)$� �� �� ��< �'��J' �@���!" �� ����� ��� �U )&"

���� %/�K4 ���" ��� �� � ���� ���� ��'� ���� F�('� ���/ �'�)������ ��V`oh@�Q �h�

[ss[iA�/ �e�[ssj���2�1 �j�[ssm�' � �G!" ���/�� �� ;���]'�"� � @�A���V`oo(����1�� �l2 $N�cY.��? �'��� b#!" ��T ���x," $�1N���5? � �/�TN%

�,�i/��/ ���+)3� ���* �@��� �.�' ��-�)$� � {. Y#�/� � 2�c" ���� �������4 ��%# ��%#4 �)5:� �"���$.

-�)$� � {. �"�'��1 �)3� ���/� �T�# ��/�*��1 � {. �>�),T @�i#" �,"��T ���?'� �*�� 1 ��:� �).�� �.� )�2��� � ����#'m�[ssV .( -�)$� � {.

�E� ��S��� ���1 ����4 �/��b#!" ��/ � {. ����� b��� �# ���� Y$� )�Y2�)����A �$�)#4 � ���� �@���#2��o�[sss (k�' -�)$� ��/ �� {. ��:�1 �#!"b��/

U )&" �� {. �"�,'��1 ���a)" ���J���/ �,.�.��b#!" ��/ �.��"� i#' �;#2� b���. ��< b#!" ��� ��/ -�)$� ��/ �7�< ��:� �'���.

����4 =���1 ���6 �� -�)$��" =���1 �� �'�5� � Y$� B��. �� ���4 �� �,,���/ ���� �� � U )&" �� �'�i#" �J�/ ���a)" �'�"� ��/���. �1 U#a< �� �� � {. -�)$�

2- Carlyle and Woods 4- Chan 6- Talbert 8- Gueriltault, Kalichman, Demi &Peterson

1- Stress 3- Allison 5- Hughes 7- Newbury-Birch & Kamali

Page 70: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

70

���� X��iA �'� .%/�K4 Z�� �C� =���1 �U )&" ��/���� �� ��. F�('� ��/ �� ��$� ���6-�) �" �5!" @�?: ��� X��"� F�$ �� � ��. ��'��� ���)�� �@�A�,/�

���6 �=���1-�)$� ��. � � %,1 �4 �� Y$��)�@�5#2�[ssm .( u�c$ �� 2�c"���� X��iA @�� " �# �� �� �A��5�� � � {. �)��*��' �� ��R� �" � �'� YaA @��1

Y$� �� " ;{. �� ��& -�)$�)������ ��V`oh(.

b#!" �� �'�"� �1 �1 � �,.��' �����<� �'��� � ��5: Y"D$ � Y#,"� �� ��T ��/#/ ��E� >�{).� �� �'�"�t�'�5'� ���#' Y#�1 � X��"� �� �#w ���"� � �� � �

��� �E�"�#w X��"� �2�� g��/� � @�#�& Z�!1 ����' g�c " �? )" � �+&)"�" �/��< �3� �� . G2�3 �� ��'.��J�'�� @�'�� �T Y?: @� �� �/ Y#�1 � �� � ��/

�K�� Y#�/� ����� �,)5/ � "�: ��#' ���" �+&)" �'�5'� ���#' ��,,T � �,)5/ ��Y���/ %�' ��J�'�� �� ��'� �. �Tl)" ���;#?51 � ��,,T �E�i#� ���� ���� �� ��,,T

@�,T��T � �+&)" �'�5'� ���#' �E Y5#' @� ���2�T ��,#"� �T Y$� ��J�'�� �" I/��� �� �'�5'� ���#' �2� 1 � �.� �'��$ .

���� @��' ���#�!1 Y��*� @�i#" ��� �a," �#|t1 � {. -�)$� �R� @�i#" �� �'� � {.)���6�����K'�$��4 � @�#'���� V`�s(��: @�i#" �� {. ���:)����?"V`oe(�? 1 �

@�,����)���QV�[ssj(Y#3D< �)���6�����K'�$��4 � @�#'���� V`�s(��C �� �@�,����)����?"V`oe���)��$ �V`ms (@�"��$ ��C �� � ��)��?' �����.

%/�K4 � ���#�!1 �� X�E,T � �$�� � �:�1 � �� �. �&�" �).lA ��/�,#"� �� @��J�/�K4 ��T� %�' F�?� � ��� 1 �.�' �'��� ��/ ���� ��/)� F�J,�����

§�� � �#4[�[ss�(��T Y#/�" �)��,��:�)2����V`mm (@���E�/ � Y$�4�$)�v���[ss`�@�#,# " ����i*�#� ���a : �� ;�' � V`�s(B#��1 � �i�)$� � H��6 �� {. ��/

)�N��,��:�)2���V`mm (1�� �N<�' � @� y��N. v�1 �� {. ���,�N� � ;{N� {. ��E �

2- Duraisingam 1- Chuic

Page 71: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

71

���� F�('� �� �1��#�!1 ��/�#{)" �� ��#T�1 �� � �'�A��: ���7 � @�,T��T �'� .�$�� ��" �x' � �#,Q ��Tl" ���#�!1 �2��:� � �:��< ��/���T �� ���#�!1 ��T� �T �$�

Y$� �)��A ���7 ��/���� @� ��< �,/�� � �:�1 .b#!" ���$ �� i#' @���� �� ��/���#�!1 �.��"��#w � {. -�)$� �#|t1 Y#�/� � �:�1 � �l2 �Y$� ��. F�('� �?��"

��J�'�� ��/�K4 � �.��"� �����:� ;"��� � Z��� �� �1 Y$� @� � Z#�!1 ��� ��/ � �� � Yp#/ ����� � y��1�� �� �� � {. -�)$� �� �|�" ;"��� ��� � X��

��)��?' � �/� ���3 �$�� ���" ��J�'�� �� � Yp#/�#w b#!" �� �� � {. -�)$� >�" �.��"�W�/� �9��� �/�J�'�� .

Y$� ���.� ��#5 -�)$� uDc7� �� Z#3� �a�� 1 � �)��� Y$� )-�� ������)2� ��:�1 �:��<���4 V`oe .(���" Z#3� U�� 1 F�� � ��#�/ � {. ���� � y��" ��#��

Y$� ��� �:��" @� �1�� �A�#�#4 �� uDc7� ��� �� .���?Q � uDc7� ��� �� ����Y$� �)��A ���3 ���a)$� ���" U )&" X�� )�� ���$� §R��" �v��"V�� ;�' �

�����" � �����:�#$V`oe :(V�v�!" ^� @��,� :� @�. �:��" � �|��6 ^� ��� � r 1 � 3�� ^� ...[r$�4 ^� @��,� � :@��� ���##{1 �)<�,.)��6 (���# �� b�1�" �

���� �)�"i" .(`v���� ^� @��,� � :@�� ���i)'� �##{1 � �#� 1 ^� �� �"���" �"�Y���6 ���$ @�� � b#!" �,#� ������ ^� Y$� �E�" ��. F�('� �)<�,. X�� ��/

����A G#1�1 ��� � ��. ��#A�$�.� ��,,T.h;��)" %,T�� ^� @��,� � :^�� �6�� �� ��,���� ;��@�" .�J�� g�� ���#2��4 ������2[)[ssm (-�)$� ��

�� G#$� �� ��5: �'��� �"�� �,'�� ��� ����< @��' �"�/� ��(#)'�������1 ��Y# 3�" ��/ %2�Q �i#J' ��;{. �"�"�J,#� ��.�)[ss` (-�)$� �� � {.%,��� ��/ �C�i#� ��a��� ��,��.�<�' �"�� �'�� �(#)' � 1�D" �# �,"��� �

%c#!" ��� ����� ����,"��#' ��/ � {. �� �)�# Y# �3 ��/ �,"��� �,)5/)�;�' ����,#"� V`oe.(

2- Paw Lik &z Kienlen 1- Schaufeli, Maslach & Mark

Page 72: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

72

B�: ���,�� 1 �" -�)$� U� @��1#-�)$� �� ��� @� � {. �'�A�/ r$�4 �'��5: �'��� �� "��Y$� �TF�J,/ ��A��$ @���' ��� �'��1 ����/����b#!"

� {. ;7�6 "���. .��� " r$�4��'��1 ����7 ��/��)�� ���,�<�' A��#@�. �����/��)�� Y'��<�i#"� ¡���6 �"��+"#Y�/� ���T#�����/��'��5: U )&" �

�)6 ���" ��� -�)$� �,T � {. �Y��*� � {. ���E �� ��� I#�)5" �c�� �).�� ��E� ���a2z"��/ �|z" ��,��� �Y"D$ ���� Y$�.

v�!" >�" � �'��� ���� � y��" U��� 1 �� ���#5 I/ ��,/ �Q�AW�� r$�4 >�"»�2���" @��1 «� ;"� 1 @���: ^� �� �)�# �� ���� �2� ����� �,1�J,1 y��1��

�" �x' �� � ��1�'�#A .R �x' �-����V)V�oh (»���� � �'��� ���� �� � T ���" ���.� �DE�" � �'��� ���� �� �T Y$� ��� �DE�" ���$ �� @� i���1 �:� � �,T

�" ���� I)5#$ � �T ���/�����" �:�1 ��?'� ��� �� I)5#$ %,T�� � ��.��. «)�-����R V�oh .( �� >�" ^� ��� �� I?" �a2�" �$ U�� 1 ��� �'��� �����Y$�

�"�/� :VW�" ���� I)5#$ ^� � �T ���/���� ��. .[W� E. � �&. �T �x' ��� 1N" v�� �� ������ �� ���?N��,T .`WI)5#$ @� r$�4 Y#�/� .A �R�7�N�" �)a �T ��.

�" ���� I)5#$ ^� � �T ���/���� ����� Y2R� >�� 1 F�� �� @���1 F�� � ��!�� 1 ��.���2�6��T �" ���� �c�' ^� � �T �,)5#' �'��# ��/��#' �,��� ����7 �/���� �����'�.

' �# >�� 1 �(#)' �)�# �E N�" �'��� ;"��� � �'��# ��/��# �� ��� ^� �T �,.��" �� I)5#$�'��$ .�x' � �c#!" ��/������ � %,T�� �� ��� -�)$� @�i#"

��E2�� � -����R[)V�oh (������ � �2���1 ��J2� �� � �/������ �� �� �)<�,. ��/���� �J)5 �?'� � ��)�� ��� ��:�" B�," .

�)$��,��/�a )&"������" ;"��� -�)$�����:� ����� 2��"�����1���?'� � u�. ���Y$�:;"��� @��'�"��$�@��� ;"��� �'�"��$�I/ � �'��# ;"��� I/ ���2��" � ��< ��'��� ;"��" I#5�1 �i(" � �� )" ��/�1 �'�.#>��5`)[ssj .(

2- Folkman 1- Lazarus 3- Teasdale

Page 73: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

73

%/�K4 �/�1��"� ��E# ��(1 ��� �� ��. �����[ss`�'�$ � �Q �[�[ssV ���� @��' �'� ��2��" ��� �� ^� �/ �T �,)5/ %�' ����� �'��� ���� �,���� �� �/ .v����

Y$� ���)$� ���)�� � �)<�,. ��'� U )&" Y# *� � ��< ��: �� ���?1 .�� ���" ������ Y# *� ��� �� %,T�� � I)5#$��$� >�� 1 Y# *� � ����� �.�� .

�'��1 � ���#�)5" �T Y$� I?" Y?: ��� �� ��Tl" %,T����|t1 ��� �1� %," � �/#�"����lA .%,��� �� �� />�� 1 B*� ^� ��$ � �� I)5#$ ���� �,)5/ �'���A��$ �

" H�$ � T ��/���� %/�T � �)�#��,/� .%,��� �/����� �,)5/ �'���A��$�' �J�� |t1 �T �� ��)�# ��'�| �DE�"#��" ��:� � ��'��� ��� �1� B*� � �a," ��'��� .

>�� 1 F�?a" � �#�. ��#5 �'��� ��/���� �� >�" ��� �T �Y$� � #�� @�?: �� �1�#6 �'�T)V�[� (Y$� ���T U#7�1 �� @� .Y$� ���3 ��� � >��:� � H�� F�?a" :»^�

" >�� 1 F�� ��Q� �T �'�"� I)5#$�" � $ ��.�� ����� �� >�� 1 �1 �,����� Y$�«.,��/#� ���,�" %/�K4 �/���#�#4 �'�� �@�# %'���E�/ �'��T �T���� ���T ��

F�� G$�,1 �# ����� b#!" �@��'�"��#4 �.�' "���.)� ������"���� �� ;�' �"Dw�������� V`�s(.

�� @��� @�"��$ ' �/#i;"��� " ��� )"��,'��1 �(," ���� -�)$� �'��A �T��@� � �: "�@��1 ���� ����" ���' ���.�)�����$�� ���[sso :(;"��� y��" ��#$Y$'�"��$�)�����" �^�< �����' ��Y<���4 ��/ ���(�: F���" �(...�;"���

y��" ���/�,���� @�"��$)�����1�� �U# * ���<�� U# * ����� ��E �� �...(�;"��� y��" �@�"��$ �D#E�1)iT��1 %# ���6��I#�+1 ���#A ��'�E"� v�'�

��� ��1�� �Y���#4 �(...���;"� ���" ��E�i#� )@���� ��'�E"� �E�i#� �G$�," �$���7 ������ ��"�A �A��2� ��/ �.(...

,��/#�� ��5�1 �#I�,��� "��� �J� {. -�)$� G:�" �� �"��� �'�."�� � �)5�� ;"��� �)$� �� � @��1N!" � �)5�� ;"��� � ��#5�1 b#I�,��'���'

2- Chen & Sung 1- Bakker, Demerouti, De Boer & Schaufeli

Page 74: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

74

)����V��� .(" ��� � �)5�� I?" ;"��� ���1 � @��1#+&. n# *� �Y#���):� Y���+)3�����A�"� ;"��� �#1 ��$ �=,: �,'�" �t!" � �)5�� ;"��� �� � ;/#� b

"����!" @�Q #���{: b#������' ���.� ) .@D4��V�V�m[ .(7�+<#��+&.#)�1 �)$� �� � �)5��#+&. n#)�A�B5�1#I�,�"���. .1 �����#+&. n#YA�

2�#�����<� ;�� �� �AK��/��£�'� �).�� �,'�" ����: Y�3� �������: �� �� ��J 7�6�)$ �#�i�:��'��+� �#� � F�J,/��� Y�7�+< �� #� ����&" ��|� ;��" �� �J

-�)$� �/���"��� -�)$� ��+< � �/� {. �$�#Gl4���#�)��� Y�5' �� 1#+&. n#YB����� �� ��" @��' �,)5/ F��� ��,/�)��|� 2 ������ V`o` �

� ������"���� �"Dw ������� V`�s ���� �V���.(

��D� "��� ����l" ;"��� ��$� �,'�" #Gl4���)@�����('��(��A��#�����?" �/)1#� �5����� ��2�'��A �F� A�[�[sse(��� �� ;�3 ��< Y��$ ����" �)1#�F� A� � �5

� ����� ��2�'��A[sse .(,��/ Y$� ��lA�|� -�)$� ��#��(1 ��/���� ��:��" �� �/��)�� � @�.���A��$�' �Y$��<�� ��/��{" ��)%�' ��� 1) (�����4 � F�J,#� �

§��`�[ss���� ���[ssV$��A ��V`oV(� ����� u�. F�� � ���D�� ����� ��U�3� ���7#Z)%�' F�?�) (�����[ssV(!" �#� b#i�C���� )�����[ssV (; � ��

{. -�)$��"��,.�.

<� ����!1 �� #� ���� "��� �J��,'�" Y#5,:)��� �}}� Y/i' �� ;�' � ���� �9�#5��(," ���V`mo�56 ����������(�$ �)��� ������"�� �"Dw ������� ���}(

� #+!1 ���")���� � 2 � ���|���� ���2�� � � '�#� Q ����� ���(," � �5#9� ������ ������"���� ��"Dw ������� ���}(�'�"��$ �c$ �)��� �}}� �� ;�' � Y/i'����� (�F��&)$� k�' )��� [ssVY/i' �� ;�' � �����(1 �t;/)9�#5��

"�(,��V`mo(� �{)" @��,�#�/��� 1 �;" ��,,�# {. -�)$� @�i���. ��� �'� .

2- Tyssen, Vaglum, Gronvold, Ekeberg 1- Caplan 3- Duraisingam

Page 75: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

75

���#�!1 �� Y$� ��� � F�R Y#5,: ���" �� �)�2� �� �'��� ��:� ��J�� �1��a1 �� �# ��=,: @��' � {. -�)$� ��!2 �� ��'�'� )��� �g�)$� ���5 #A ��# a,��

�Q��4�/V�[ss`�����: �@����!"��� ���� � �V`om� ������"���� ��"Dw ������� V`�s��� �[ssVY/i' �� ;�' � �V`me.(

�� 2�c" �a )&" ��� �## 1 ;"��� -�)$�����;{.� �/ !"#b�/���� ���" �� >��" @��,� � Y$� ��. F�('� U )&"-�)$� ;"��� ��������" � @���)$�4 �

�,'�":�).��' >�),T ���T ��� ���T �R� ��/��#' ;{. �b��� �)���6 �U# * �?:��" �-��1 ���" �@����# U )&" ����?�& �)�3��" Y$� ��. ���.� �T��

� �: I?"���1 ;"��� -�)$� ��,,T��(�� � {. ��@���)$�4 �AK����/ {.�@��/"��.�)���(," � �5#9�V`mo��� ���V`m`:�� ��@���C�/ �V`�V .(,��/#�� �

@�A�,'�� ���")0�6"�#,��@���C�/ �V`o�(�'� @��,"��� �)"#������V`oh (�"�x'#@�)��#�@���C�/ � �[ss��)��$ ���V`ms ('#�!1 i#1���Y$� �)��A ���7

� �� �?'� ��� �� �! ����" ��' �2���(,A .

!" ��#b�/�.��"� �@�"��$ �� ��/�.��"� �/�J�'�� ��'#�!1 i#1��a)" ����Y$� ��. F�('� .�. -�)$��" ���.�<�' G3��� �'��1��,���1 �� ������ �� � =

6��# �1 �� ��)$� �#�'��1 � �,� U��).� >��)'� �� �� �� #3����1 � �� �%/�� ����� =�/� ." -�)$���� �� � �'��1�$�$� Z�� �� #a#��1 Y��/�C �?'� =:� >����A� �C,

1�" -��"�'R�� ���1 ���6 �-�)$� �� = ��#�*� Y$� �C�" ����>�{).� �� �� Y� ���%/�� ���6 ��� � �����52� G:�" �"� ���. -�)$� F�� �:�� �� � ��. �� ��

� �� Y$� �C�"#a#A��� � -��" ;"� 1 Y#��/�C -�� -D� ��)��������V`oh �1�6� ��:�1��V`oh���2�1 �[�[ssm .(� ���|� -�)$�����'��A��� �-��" � #� ��

!"#b�A��#������ ����/ � .J)5<�a," X�J' ��A��� � Y�5' #�"���� Y�� �@�����1 �� @�$��"�� � =��/��� ��(�a," �<� @�'� �� �� �� ��,)5/ ����� �)�������

2- Tolbert 1- Winefield, Gillespie, Stough, Dua, Hapuarachchi

Page 76: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

76

C1�$ �#�UV�om�/�� �� ;�' � ��G!" ����]'�"� �@�A���V`oo .($ ��* ��#I)5.��"���?,1 � ��"��"���� � ��C �� �'��1� * @�$��" #)" �� UtG:�" � �,� �|

�i���w %#" � ��� �� Y�#�: @�i��:����. @�'� ./ ���� � b�� -�)$�#� � ���$�#�' G��� �C ��'�$���(�'�� �' @�#� ��|� i����'���$ � �� @�'� � ���� �

A��$���/#'�(��"���� Y�� ��).� @��� Y$� �� �@�'� #X��"� U * �F�('��$ � H�" H�$#�/� .���)' ��$ ;� ��< ��' � �S#.��"� I)5�)" �� t" �|����$)��� ��[sss �

�/�� �� ;�' ��G!" ���]'�"� �@�A���V`oo.(

���� �&�" �� �.��"� ��/ b#!" -�)$� B�," �� ���� 1 �U )&" �� 2�c" �'� .I?" �� �<� >��" @��,� ������ @�� " -�)$� B�," ���1�� �'� :%'�� � =���1

�i#J'� �3�� @���"�)�@�5#2�[ssm(3� ����� �%'�� >�),� � Y��)��� @���"�)-�,�����V�[ssm(�@�. ���"� ��� Y3� ����� ������ ;9�5" � � {. Y���#4 F�� �

>D�)$� F�� ����2�� � ;��)" ;"� 1 ����.�)�iA�/[ssj(�i#J'� @���� �)��#'�)'�i#��QR� � �'�Q �2�4[�[ssj �@�Q �[ss[ (X��"� �Y2�� g�� �� ���!" Y���6

��$�� �"�'� �� F���" ���##{1 ����: �.��"� ����*�" �� �/�A� @���� ������'%'�� �����'� �DC�" �-D� ��)<�$ � y��" �DC�"�-D� �J,/��/ �' �@���"

)�#2���`�[ssVF�J,#$R�#���"�� �h�[ss[ (F�� � ��� �� ���).� ��)5 �'�"��$ �: ���" ��$ �� �DC�" ���)����� ��#"�1 �[sssG:� ����4V`mm .(��� � ���

��'�C"� � ��� � y��" ;9�5" ����5"�' �A���'�< � ����):� ����+)3� Y# *�%'�� ���)�� �DC�" � �$��"���6 Y#6D7 � �J)5��. �@���"� �#��4 �@�� " ��

%'�� �� ;#+!1 �i#J'� @��I?" �� ��'�"� ���� � @���"�� B�," ���1 �� @�� " -�)$�" �5!" @���� �'�.)� A�$ �)� ' � �"�� ��]1V`�s ������ � ���� ���#�6 �

V`oj .( �� @�� " -�)$� �'��� � ��5: I9D� ��,#"� ��� �� ��:�" B�," ��* ������� ��C. �'� :$N" I<� �����N� �#��4 ��"���� -�56� �Y#'��+� ��"i" ��/��� ���

2- Antoniou, polychroni & Vlachakis 4- Kumarakulasingam

1- Kokkinos 3- Forlin

Page 77: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

77

�,)5/ @�� " -�)$� ����� �� �<� �A��5��) .�@�5#2�[ssm(

gD<� ��+1 ���#�!1 �F��� �a )&" �TF�('� �)��A�'� @��' ���� �'� �T�R�� " -�)$� ��/ � {. ���# ����� ;w�. ��b#!" ��/ ��/�J�'���1R� �����$ b#!"Y$�/.>�1��V�)[ssV(��]5 #A ��%2�� �� #a,�� g�)$� ���9�)[ssV(��� #a,�� ��5] #A �g�)$� ��9� ��Q����4�/)[ss[(� @�5E: ��" ���[)[ssj (@��' �'��� �T�����

��#/ �� � ��J�'����/ � �Iw� ��+1 F��� �,�" �IT-�)$� @�� ;{.@�. ���:�1 �b���. ��< IT�6 ���J�'�� �/��;#�3 >D�)$� ;�� �)�# ������ �)�# ��� ����� ��#/ ��� � ��>�$ ��/ �#<� �;#2� ���##{1 ���7 �)��A Y$�#$ ��-��/ >���� ��. b$�1 ����(" Y����"��/ @DT ���c$ ��/���T @�?: �H�$ @��� �)�# �?'� �Y�$ ��/��?' �#w��)2� ��7�+<���$ ��� ��?'� %��i�� �c$

-�)$� ��/ � {. ����� ��3 �����A Y$� .��;���� �/� V��s%/�K4 ���)5A�����J�'�� �� � ��#/ ����� ��� ��/Vh���T F�('� Y��A .S��)' ��� %/�K4 @��'

��� �T�.�' -�)$� �����##{1 y��" ��#9��"�'��/ ��1�� �XD1 ��� @�#$� ��:�� �� ���)$� �# ����� ��#/ �� � ��� ��J�'���/��#5 R� ��)���)$�" ��� ��" ��)$�" ;' �`�[sso .(

���$�� )� � '�#� Q �� ;�' � ���2�� V`o�(@��' ��� �T� 7����1 B�," -�)$� � {. ����� ��#/ ��� � ;{. ��� ���A Y$�.=4��@���/�*��1 A���'�<������

�DE�" ��'�"� ��2�" y��1�� �@��J�� B�," �J�� -�)$� � {. @�'� Y$�.� #a,�� �@���E�/)[ss` (;�R� ��(�� � 7� ���� ��b#!" ��T i#' ;"�. F�('� ����#�!1

Y����!"��/ ��'�"� y��1�� �@��J�� � �=���1 �$��T�� ���/�*��1 @���(�'�� �'��.

�N��#)V��j ('#Ni"N�� �� Y$� ��) N/ ���N2� � �� � ��#N;#�� 1 'N%���/

2- Jackson & Rothmann 1- Cottrel 3- Mostert, Rothmann, Mostert & Nell

Page 78: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

78

����):� ��< ��;#�3 �Z#�!1 �=���1 �9��� �2��" �YT�. ����/��,#�$ ����,/��@���(�'�� �... ��,1 ��#�#4 ��'�:�,Q �����(1 �"�,���')� � '�#� Q �� ;�' � ���2��

V`o�.(

@�56� �FR� ��a'�A �8����V)[ss�(��� 2�c" -�)$� � {. ����,�< � {. �# �t#/ �/�J�'�� ���,)<���4 �i2�".� "��� �� �'��� �&�" ��< Z#�!1 �� �?'�

�,'�" %�' Y����" �y��1�� @��I(6 �,#J,$ ���� U# C1 ���)�" F�?� %�' ����� ������� " �#1�$� � {. -�)$� ��z�,)5/ �|.

�� Z#�!1 �� ���('� �� �Z#�!1 g��/� ��)$�� �� � ��. @�# ��'� � �:�1 � �7�< �#*�� ���� � {. -�)$� ��,,���(�� ;"��� ���$�,. >��'� � �"� ���)�

Y$� �).��' .�� ��� �$�$� �R��$ ��#*�� ����� ��: �Y$� �$�� ;�3 Z#�!1 ���.

-�)$� ;"��� ��,"��T i���1 ��J�'�� �� � ��#/ ���� � {. ���

�Y$� �'�JQ �� -�)$� ;"��� Y��2��

B������, %/�K4 k�' �� �*�6 %/�K4 Y$� ��� �,#"� ��/ .@�,T��T �# T ;"�. ���"� � "�:

��� 1 � i���1 ��J�'���Vo ��� 1 ��� �� �T Y$� �a' h`j � �� � ��#/�#w ��� �a' ho[�" �� � ��#/ ��� �a' �.� .@�A��" >��: -�$� � �'��' I(6[m` ����� �a'

��� 1 ��� �� ��V[� � �� � ��#/�#w ��� �a' Vhh�" �� � ��#/ ��� �a' �� �,.��'��' X�� ����� ��#A�'����A �&)'� ����+1 �� .

���� ������A ���#' ���" ��/ �)<�$ Z�!" �"�,�$�4 �� Z#�!1 ��� F�('� Y?: ��-�)$� ;"��� Ia2�&" �D"�T �1 I����" �D"�T �� ��& S,4 ��E#2 U#� -�$� � �� ��

����A ���a)$� ��� ��. �6��� .����� ���l" �"�,�$�4Vss�" >��$ F��� �/ �� �.�

1- Ahsan, Abdullah, Gun Fie, & Alam

Page 79: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

79

��A ��N�. -�)$� ;"��� � ��/N.� � {N���� ��� ./�K4 ��� ��N��/��i� ����� %����'��+#+< %(,$ @��1 � ��#A ;�)�" �@�A��< b$�1 �"�,�$�4 �� �x' ���" ��/

1 ���" ��J�'�� @�$�,.��T � �#1�$� �tY��A ���3 �#� .�"�,�$�4 �����4 �## 1 ��x," ��/�a)$� ���'��T ��a2� X�� ��F�' �� ���a)$� � �� ����A �� ��i��spss ���'��T ��a2� �

I)�� ����(" ��� � {. -�)$� �"�,�$�4 ��/os/s-�)$� ;"��� �"�,�$�4 ������oo/sY$� ��R� �����4 �� �T�6 �/�7�� �T ����A .

������

���� �#& 1 ���#|t1 ;"��� � -�)$� � y��" ��/�#{)" %/�T � �/ ;# !1 �� ��lA��. ���a)$� ����)�� � "�� .X�� � Y 1�� @�"�� �� ��)� ;"�� ;# !1 F�('� �� ;�3

KMO�. ���a)$� �/�#{)" �# � T �J)5��/ �#&�1 ��� .;"�� ��� 1 �## 1 �� �/����A �&)'� �� �)�# ^� �� �?'� �K�� ����" �T � ��1 � Y��A ���7 �i��T Z��� .

@�#$� ����. ���a)$� =T����� %<�Q �� ���$ � "�� ��)<�$ � .%<�Q �� � ;"����i � "�� ��/�� G56 � ��/ �� �1`./;"�� ��#2�� �#{)" �/ ��� v�)�" ��/

�'�. ���lJ"�' .

;"�� ���$�,. �� � ��1� @�"�� �� �� {. -�)$� � T ��/ ��� i#' �"���� ��� �/ ���lA�|� @�i#" �## 1����A ���a)$� � {. -�)$� � ;"��� �� ^.;# !1 � ��i(1

����F�' b$�1 �/��i��SPSS Y��A ���7 .

X�� � Y 1�� @�"�� �� ;7�6 S��)'KMO ����. >��: ��V� Y$� ��. 0�� ����" �E,�� � �:�1KMO �" ^� � ^��i' �, " �)��A �x' �� � �#,��/ � �.����

1�� @�"�� @���" Y ��/�#{)" �# �2��3 ;�3 �J)5��/ �T Y.�� ��?�� @��1 �#2������ � �).�� ��:���� G$�," ;"�� ;# !1 F�('� ��� ;7�6 ��/�'�.

Page 80: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

80

7� P)�(B�� � !�$��� ���)� KMO��+, -#��� ��#"+�� ����G 1"�K$ �� ]�6$�� �3

B��KMO �� 2�KMO �6�#2$ ��H q�#� �3�)� �P�3 ~.�7�%�a�

�V/s�e/�mVh [[VV ssV/s

7� P)0(4 , n�#O��� 1���G )� 5� # 4��� B)�� � W������ #�3�2�

� 1��G F�#_ 1���G �0?INM>VR�c

�K�� X��� se/V�m`/`oe/[e[/[[[/[mV/Vj[/Vhj/V`m/V[o/V='����� �7��

;T hh/[oem/e[j/hmj/``V/`ee/[h[/[V�/[se/[�V/V

v��).� �7�� hh/[osV/`h[o/`osh/h[`j/he�V/hm`h/ese`/e[eo/ehe/ej

>��: ��[��. 0��&)$� ;"��� �� �� �/ �K�� X��� � ='����� �����" ���. ���� Y$� .�����" @��' >��: ��/������1 >�� ;"�� �� �/� [o�##�1 �� ='����� �7��

�"�)�" �7�� � ����'�" @��' ���. 0��&)$� �'�A �� ;"��� �� �/�ej�� �7�� �,,� �" �##�1 � �: �� ='����� .

��� 1 �^� �� �1R� �K�� �����" -�$� �Vs�'�. ���$�,. ;"�� .;"�� �"�$� �/��i � "�� ��/�� -�$� � �T �� �1`./u�. � �. �## 1V�'�"��$ [������4�' `

�'�"��$ ��" b<h�'�"��$ Y�� � �,/�� e%�' �J)5��. j���� �# y��1�� m��)<�$o%�' ���� �� {. Y#,"� F�� /� �2�"Vs>��: �� �T �'�. �## 1 �H��c'�

`�a2z" ����. G#1�1 � ����. �a2z" F�' � �/��. 0�� �/�'� .

Page 81: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

81

7� P)?(1��G �����#"+�� �� ]�6$�� �3 4 , ����:��� ��#��� ��-��+,

��� J� 1��G-�

��� �� �� 1��G ����)�� 1��G

�#"� � ��x)'� N�)��� ��1��

� H��6 �c$ N�i�)$�

�(���1 %/�T NH��6 ���< @��1 F�E6� �� ���a1 N

� �#1�$� �3��6@��,"��T

� �#'��3 �� ��a &1 � ���:� N�����"

F�� ��T �).�� NW�AK�� �A���'�< ��/

##{1 N��T b#!" �� Y#2�p5" �� {. b���. �4 �� �4 ���##{1 N

����'�< ��� ^� ����# N��� �� @��T �E� � �J)5�'�� N

@� ��T �� >�+a'� N

�J�� ��: � ���: �� >��)'� N

X��� �# ���A��$�' N� ��� ��/ X�����J�'�� ��/

@���E�/ Y���6 F�� N)�� � �/��� @�� ��� 1 �� N� �/���

��J�'�� ��/��� � N�DE�" � �$©� �?:�1

Y���#4 ��� �$ � B'��" ��:� N����� �#A�4 � Y$� �����" � �#'��3 N

b#!" �� ����*�#w >�),T � ���x' N��J�'��

�$�#$ @�,#��� F�� N)�'��J'�$�#$ ��/(H���" � U# * b��� N)=#9�(

g�c '� ;�3�#w �����" NF�� N���� I/ ����� ����i" � H��6 ���51

�+&1 N�6 �� %# ����A I#�+1 �� iT��1 N��:� F�� � ��#A

YT���" �b�6$�� 1��G 2� �:�;��, 1��G ����)�� l�#� 1��G =#9� � �c�� N

� �c�� N@���E�/

� �c�� N@�)$����

�5�/ X�J' N��� ��T � Y�5'

Y$��<�� Nª#�' � �* ��/ �����

���T �' ���"���T � X��"� N@�. ���).� GE1�" N

� -�56� N@��T �.��� @�#$� �� Y ?" @�. F��1 N

��/��T F�('� ��� ���" Y ?"�����

�(�'�� � � �,"��T � ���)$� � ���<� N@���(�'�� � �c�� �� �DC�" N

� {. ��< �DE�" �� Ni���1 ��J�'�� @�� �'��

Y# " �� �5'�()"�' ��:� N� U )&" ��/�(�'�� @��,�

�t#/ �#w ��� � �t#/ ��3 �$ ��:� N�(�'�� � �� �

Page 82: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

82

@���E�/ b$�1 ��J#$ @�#�T N k�:� ��� @�� @��: N)@���(�'��([ G 1��G��+, !"��� /

�<��

2� ���� 1��G ������ 1��G

� ��� �� -�1 N���E#

�'��J' N��/���+)3�

;!" �� ���� N��T ;!" � Y"�3�

��T �,#J,$ NIT N�T�!1)� X��� F�� � @� � ���,)��(

�A�'� � ���T ��/���� �#|t1 N�7�+<

�'�< �� ��T F�('� N��T b#!" b��* � �����" N

�J�� � ��J�'�� ��T Y��$ �'��&�/�' N@�"��$�/

�+&1 -�$� � �/�'�"��$ N�� )" ��/�� ����J�'

;{. Y#2�p5" �� ;"�T �/�A� N;{. � y��1�� �� ;�� >D�)$� N

W%#4 �� � �.�� ��*�� g��/� ���' u����. �i��

��+, J��#, �� w"6.$ 1��G ����5" @�i#" N�" ���T ��#' �c$�� �T ���/��#A F�('� Y5��.

�A�'� ;!" b���. N)� �J,/��(... � ��"� � � �� F�i)2� N����)�� � �,�

Y#2� � �� YT�. N�" ��iA� ��J�'�� b$�1 �T �!��a1 ��1���� ��/ ��.

�<���!�6$� � � ��3���� 1���G � �� F;a#� 4�:���3 �3 -#��� 4 ��H1��G !"%��

��1� ���a1 �)��� ���;"�� �# ���� ��/ �� � ����A ���a)$� �"���� @�"�� �� �'�A�� ;"��� �(#)' >��: �� Y#�/� G#1�1 � � {. -�)$� ��,,T ��(h�e��. �9���

Y$� .

7� P)I(�� �#� ���)� )� 1o�a x����

�' ����� 3� &$ �3�)� �P�3 ��&� ~.����3 s[o/mms [m` �ssV/s

Page 83: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

83

7� P)N(�6$� ��+, -#��� 1���G � ��

1���G �6$� �'�"��$ ;"��� V`/o

�'�"��$ Y�� � �,/�� �m/j�'�"��$ ��" b< je/j

%�' ���� �/hj/j���)<�$ ;"��� hh/j

� {. Y#,"� F�� /�2�" oe/h������4�' ;"�� os/h

���� �# y��1�� `s/h%�' �J)5��. [V/`

� {. b���. � Z#�c1 ;"�� [s/`

>���: � �:�1 �h�e�)' �� ���:� �� ;7�6 S��� @�"�� �" @��' �� �"���,/� � {. -�)$� ;"����1�1 ��� � #��1� G�,���A ��:VW�'�"��$ ;"��� [W� �,/��

�'�"��$ Y��`W�'�"��$ ��" b< hW%�' ���� �/eW���)<�$ ;"��� jWF�� � {. Y#,"� /�2�"mW������4�'oW���� �# y��1�� �W� %�' �J)5��. VsW�c1 #Z

��. �� {. b�.#" �##�1 � ��� ��Y$� ��. �)<���4 ;"��� �� ^� �/ ���lA�|� @�i .�� � �:�1��!1 g�/ �C,#-�)$� >�" �9��� � -�)$� ��,,T��(�� ;"��� ��, ��1� Z

{.�" �Y$� �� >�" @��1����' �9��� �� �.

Page 84: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

84

1S,)�(��+, -#��� ���f� 7 �

��"�� � dK��#"( ���� ;# !1 � ��i(1 Y�53 �� ��'� -�$� � �/ � {. -�)$� >�" ;"��� �. @�#

�" �! �?'� ���" �� �� Y$� ��� ����" ;"�. G#1�1 � i���1 ��J�'�� �� ��. .

��1� � �'�"��$ ;"��V`/o�-�)$� ��(�� �� �|z" �$�$� ;"�� �#2�� @��,��. ���iA� � {. .�a2z" �� �E� �'�"��$ ;"�� @�"��$ ^� Y#���" I?" � #< ��/

�" �����" @�"��$ Y����" � ��� g��/� � �1 �/� ���7 ��|z" ��"��3� Y5��R�p5" �l2 ��$� ��< � c" I/��� ��� u�. � �� �1��#?�1 Y$� �)5��. ��J�'�� @

Page 85: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

85

Y$�#$ �9��� �G$�," ��)<�$ ��(�� ��'��� �� � ����(" Y2i," � @t. �� �,#? ��/I � �9���E. � �.� Y?:������,� � %'�� I#�+1 ���T ��� G$�," b#!" ��(�� ��#A

�g�c '� ;�3�#w �����" ;�� 1 � gl6 �YT���" ��� Y?: �#!7 ��/��E/�� �9����'��J' @�� �# �@�#/�J�'�� �$�#$ ��/ ��#A�4 � Y$� �����" � �#'��3 gl6 � �:�1

Dw�. �DE�" � Y��,�� ���c," ���<� ����� �#1�$� �� ���a)$� �@ �� � y��1�� ��(�@�"��$ ��Y ,7 %& � �: �� �J�� ��/ �@�,T��T ��E �� %(,$ ��/��# " uD7�

��J'�� ��'�#" @����" �+)'� � �&)'� �� ����� b��* � b��� Y#�T�6 gl6�+&1 X�J'Y54 �&)'� �� �6 �� %# ����A �����' �7�< v��" � ��#' �T ���/

H�� Y<���4. ��� 2� � ���x' gl6 ����� I/ ����� ����i" � H��6 �� ���51 Y?: ;{ � G$�," Y���#4 B'��" @�� �# �� � �)$�T ���J�'�� b#!" �� ����*�#w >�),T

��J�'�� ���T �2�7� .§�� � �#4 � F�J,�����)[ss�(v��� �)���a : �� ;�' � �@�#,# " ����i*�#�V`�s(���� �)[ssV (�$��A �)V`oV (� �: �� �� %�' ��� 1

�'��T @��,� ��T b#!" �� �'��� ���� B�," .i,#��)V`�V (�� b��� �� �.�' �'��� ���� � @�)$���� � U# * �c�� �).�� �H���" � U# * b��� �).�� � �� ��T b#!"

Y#2�p5" @��T >�!" �� �DE�"�'��T I#5�1 ��#w � �/ .�)��� � �:�1 � ��Tl" ��/�" ��(�� �� �|z" %�' � {. @���E�/ �� �.�' �'��� ���� �T ���' >R�)$� @��1

���� � {. -�)$� .���� b$�1 �T ��#�!1 ��)[ssV (�� Y$� ��. @�# ��. F�('� ��< Y$�4�$ ^� I?" ��#7�+< �� �E� ;� 2���)$� @��� �� �� ���'��1��/

Y$� �.�� � �*�� .��" � T ��� �)$� @��1 ��,,T��(�� �'�"��$ ;"��� �T Y.�� >R�" �'�"��$ k�,)" � �� )" ;"��� �#|t1 Y!1 � {. -�)$� ���7 � ^� �/ �T �,.�

�:�1 � �).�� ��J�'�� ���T � �� c"�' ���|� ���#T�1 � �/��A ���7 � i#' � �'�A��:R�p5" b#!" �� �/���� k�' ��� X�)5A �� ��#A� : ��� �� b��� @�" ��� ��T�'��<.

��1� � �'�"��$ Y�� � �,/���m/j-�)$� ;"�� �#"�� @��,� � @�,T��T �# ���. �&)'� i���1 ��J�'�� .��#.�T �T �'��J�/�K4 �AK�� �'�@�"��$ ��/ �� Z��" ��/

� �,,T @�# X��� Y���$ � ���3 � �,/�� F�?a" � ��E" ��� � ����� ���, " ��/

Page 86: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

86

�1�#*�����T �#Tt1 �'��� �J)5�� �?'� � @�"��$ ���T ���#' �T �'� )�i,#��V`�V ����)��$V`ms ����?" �V`oe .(����� � Y$� ���3 ��3 �'�"��$ �,/�� �'��) " �T

� �/� %��i�� �� @�'� ��)�� F�E!)$� � ���lJ �|� @�,T��T �? 1 � �?:�1 ;�3 @�i#"��" � �#'��3 ��� �,#�'�:�.� ��$� ��� .��$� >�),T I)5#$ �� �1�|z" �)6 �

�,T ;�� @�"��$ .�1��7�� �" ��� �.� Y��" � ��3 �,/�� �T ���� ����� �T ��.��" F�('� �T ��'� �,/� F�('� �56� �!' � �� ��"� � �).�� ��)? -�56� �,/� .��

��? � �)? ��E �� G:�" �(#)' �" ��)�# ��� ��. .��i����? %���? � �(," ����. �/��< ���� %��i�� � �A�'� �)? Y#a#T � �A�'� �c$ .�)? �A�'� >�6 �#� �� �

����'� @��1 %��i�� � ��E� �.� ��� �" @�5'� ���T � �� ��. .� �,/�� ��R�7��" �A�'� @� �� �T �c#!" �� @�5'� v�� X�� ��A��� g� " � ���� ���.� �,T � �/

)��Y$� �� .�Y$� �)��A ���7 �'�"��$ �,/�� ���" �� �T ��� )" U��� 1 � �:�1 ��" ����(" � �'�"��$ �,/�� �YaA @��1 X��� �� �� � ��#*�� ������)�� ��/��� ��/

�" ���.� @�"��$ � IT�6 v�)�" ��/��(,/ �,T .�C)aC.� �� � ����6� ���� �#4 )V`�[ (�(#)' � Z���" S��)'����� Y$� Z#�!1 ������� @�# �?'� �'� �,/�� �� �'�

�.� �).�� %�' � {. -�)$� �'�"��$ .

��1� � �'�"��$ ��" b< je/j��(�� � �|z" �$�$� ;"�� �#"�$ @��,� � �R�7� �. �&)'� -�)$� @�"��$ @� ��" b< � I#�)5" �J)5 �'�"��$ �/ Y# 3�"

�:� �� Y#���" F�� � �����" ��" b< �#!7 �� -�)$� ��(�� �� ��|�" %�' �'��1Dw�. �# ������' �a�� @�"��$ @� @.�� #a,�� ��5] #A �g�)$� ��9� ��Q����4�/)[ss[ (

��1� �� �#<t1 �T �,)����� i#'��" �'��� �DE�" ��(�� G�$ �@�,T��T F��" ��. .i,#��)V`�V (���< ��T b#!" �'��� ���� ��J2� �� � {. �� #��1 �� ��� �T �� ��& �K��

�9�'��1 Y�5' � ��� � @���' ���� Y#2�p5" %��/ ��(�� B�," �� �E� @��,� � ���.����' u�c" �'��� �����'� .

Page 87: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

87

��1� � %�' ����hj/j��. �&)'� �,�iA �#"��?Q @��,� .Y#�/� i#' �,�iA ������� � {. -�)$� ��(�� �� �7�< .$�� %�' Y#$�56 �� ��T �6 �� %# �,#J,

�� �T ��� %�' ���� ;"��� �� @�,T��T �7�+< �A�'� �� @� �a," �#|t1 � ��J�'���" �?'� %/�T �� gl6 Z��� Y$�T �?'� -�)$� �� @��1 .-�)$� %/�T ;"��� �� �E�

�" X��� � v�!1 � ���T G#w�1 � {. Y<�$ � X��� �,/�� ��(�� � �l2 �.� ��2�$ ��(���" G$�," �.��� ��/'��1 ��� �� @� �)6 � %/�T �� ��J�'�� ���T -�)$�

�� �# �� ����)$� ���7 .@D4�T � �'��)V�m` (�, " � �a," �c�� ��#�!1 �� �'���' ��/��" @�,T��T �'��� Y"D$ %�' � �a#T � �«�T �� �,#J,$ �# �� ����)�

� ������"���� �� ;�' �"Dw ������� V`�s .( i,#��)V`�V (� �� %�'�� �,#J,$Y$� ����' ��� " ��T b#!" ������� �a," ;"��� �� �E� @��,� .

��1� � ���)<�$ ;"���hh/j�-�)$� �,�iA �#�(,4 @��,� �� � {. ��� .������ � ;�� >D�)$� ��c�� � �� i���1 ��J�'�� ��)<�$ ���? � uD7� � y��1�� ��

���7 � g��/� @���' �&�" �;{. � �c�� �� @��� X��"� � �/�A� �X��< ;{.�+&1 -�$� � �/�'�"��$ � @�,T��T ��� �*���" ���J�'�� �� �/ -�)$� �� @��1

Y$�T ��. ��(�� .�����$�� b$�1 ��. F�('� ���#�!1 � �:�1 � ��)[sso(� �'�� �@D4�T)� �� ;�' ��"Dw� ������"��� �������V`�s (i,#�� �)V`�V (�� %�' F�?�

�. @��,� ��T b#!" �� �'��� ���� ��(�� B�," � �:.

��1� � �2�" � � {. Y#,"� F��oe/h��(�� � �|z" -�)$� ;"�� �#��. @��,� � �. �&�" � {. -�)$� .�2�7� �� �E� B3�� ��' � {. -�)$� ��(�� ;"��� ���1 ���

Dw�. ��� �2�" � � {. Y#,"��" @�"��$ @�" �T �.�R�p5" Y5�� �#��1 Ba,�� @�,���' F��3� ;E�" B�� Y?: �� �� F�R .�T �,)��� Y$� S��)' ��� � ;C5#" � ��/

��� @� � �3D� ��� �� � �'��� Y$�� �� ��< ;{. ��"��� �E,�� ��:� � @�� "����� H��6 ��T �� ��'� ��)�# ����):� Y#�#6 � ���)�� @�/��< � �'��,�<�' ��'�E"� �

Page 88: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

88

�,)5/ .�,��:�)2����)V`mm (� �i�)$� � H��6 �� �.�' �'��� ���� �# �T ��� @��'���� �J)5��/ � {. ��E �� .

��1� � ������4�'os/h����A �&)'� -�)$� ��(�� � �|z" ;"�� �#�)a/ @��,� � .�,'�" � "����J�� ��: � ���: �� >��)'� �)��A ���3 ���?1 ���" � � {. Y#,"� F�� N

� ���:� ��T b#!" �� Y#2�p5" �##{1 � {. b���. �4 �� �4 ���##{1 ��T �� >�+a'� @�� � ������4�' ��� �����" � �#'��3 �� U &1�" ��J�'�� �� �1��| ��. .�"�,�&

�"�'� � Y����" @�"��$�T �i�� �/��T ��T� @��]$ � ��$� F��&)$� F�� ���" �� ��YT�. ��" ���T ��(1 � �+&1 �3�� ¬ ���T� �'�a$t)" �T �7�+< ��/ ��� �,.�

��J�'�� ��,"� Yp#/ �T Y$� ��. ��J�'�� ��$� �#w �# w�. �# �� -�)$� %��i�� �/�" G$�," ��/��E/�� �9��� � < �6 �� ��:�" -�)$� �� �,'��1�,/�E ����� � # .��

�" R� �� -�)$� �T �,)5/ � "��� �i: �2�7��#w >��)'� � ���(�: ���� � �l2 �'� U���� u�. �� ���T Y<�,. ����� � �x' G6�7 ����� ��"� >�p5" �+)'� � �&)'�

�" ��< >��)'� � ���(�: �� @��1 �� ������4 � ���| ��� � �)$�T ���T ���" � ��/��. -�)$� %/�T ��)��?' � ��J�'�.

��1� � ���� �# y��1�� ;"��`s/h�. �&)'� �,�iA �#�)�/ @��,� � .Y����"�" ��J�'�� � ��!' �U���� u�. U�� 1 � uD7� � ���)�� G$�," �,/�� ��(�� � �'��1

��/�J�'�� @���E�/ �c�� ��c,#�/ � -�9�" � =#9� � ���<� ��#. -�)$� �� ����� ;� ��#A� : ��"� ��:� .i,#��)V`�V (���< ��T b#!" �'��� ���� ��J2� ��

�).�� �H���" � U# * b��� �).�� � �� ��T b#!" �� b��� �� �.�' �'��� ��/����#2�p5" @��T >�!" �� �DE�" � @�)$���� � U# * b���Y�'���' I#5�1 ��#w � �/ .

�$��A)V`oh (!1 �� ���' @���� i���1 Ya' %�R�4 YT�. @�,T��T �# �� ��< Z#� � ���A��$ �b#!" � ��� �# �A� � Y$� �c#!" � ���� ;"��� ;7�6 -�)$� �T

�" �'��� ���� ��(�� ��.� �).��' ��:� Z�c1�,T.

Page 89: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

89

��,�'��1 �� %�' �J)5��. ��1� � %�' ��/[V/`�&)'� �,�iA �#�?' @��,� � �. .��$©��" �,�3D� ��J�'�� �DE�" B�� � �,'��1)Y$��<�� gl6 �ª3�,)" ��/

� G$�," ���"���T � X��"� ��(�� (... B'��" @���' g�� � �)� @��� �? � X���U���� F�('� Y?: ���T Y7�� @��� �@�,T��T ��E �� (��,�'��1 � �4 ��< %�' ��/

�# �� � =a' � ���)�� ��(�� � � ����" � {. -�)$� @�� %�' �J)5��. � �,'��1�,,T ��#4 �$�)$� ��< .i,#��)V`�V (�� ���� ��(�� B�," ��< %/�K4 �� �)�53 ��

�%�' ��� 1 � F�?� � �: �� @�"��$ �� %�' � y��" B�," ;"�. �� ��T b#!" B�,"���6 Y���#4 � �3�1 � y��"� %# Y#2�p5" @��� � �: �� �� � ��� � ���'��1 �6 ��9�'��1 Y�5' � Y#2�p5" @���'�" %��/�,)5'��.

��1� � � {. b���. � Z#�c1 ;"��[s/`;"�� ���<� � �#�/� @��,� � @�,T��T �# �� � {. -�)$� ��,,T��(��)�� � �t#/�#w � �� � �t#/ (i���1 ��J�'��

�. �## 1 .�' �� ;"��� ���$ � Y�5' ;"�� ����'�����<� ��)�T %.���� ��:� ��" �"�'� � @��1��1�T � ��)5" �i�� �A�'� G$�," b#!" ��(�� Y?: ��"�, � ��"

�'�< ��(�� � �: �� ���T ��� ��/�J�'�� v�?. ��(�� � �E5" Y���1 ��'�"��$ ��/���� ��:� � �� @�#/�J�'�� � {. -�)$� %/�T .�" �#,��/���� b���. @��1 ��

Z�c1 @�"��$ @�,���� �/��� � �)#+&. ��/��#' � ��"�i2� � �� ��� �##{1 �����" �,#"� ��� �� � �.� �).��Y��A ��� ��J�'�� ;<�� ����� �� @��1 .

R�p5" %�' �E,�� � �:�1 � ��J�'�� ��,"� Yp#/ � ��J�'�� @���: F�x' �� �/�F� � ����� ��#5 ����,� � ���#�!1 �|� � �|z" A�� ;"��� �##{1 �� ��l � Y$� �'�A

�" Y$�#$ -�$� � @��1��" b< � �/ �"�'� @���: �� ��#x,1 ��/ ��/e�� � �2�$ �K1��)$��, ��/"Y.�� ;"��� ��� I#x,1 � �##{1 �� � uD7� �� �� �#|t1 ���)�# ��.

��++&1 ��1D#+!1 Y# *� � �)5 �'�"��$ �/ @�,T��T $�Y"�< ��� �;/t1 �" ;�!)" �� �7�< �'��� ��/���� � �/��#' ��#w � Y#5,: �" �T �'�. ��� Y5��

�"�'� �?'� B�� ��+< �� � ���$�,. �)$�� � ;"�����. �i�� .^� ���:� ��J�#/

Page 90: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

90

� c" ��A��� � ����' @�"��$ ^� ��/��3 �"��1 Y��*� � >��3 ���" ��< �"�'�Y5#'.

�" ��?,�#4 �++&1 ;E. � k�*�" ��� �Z#�!1 �9��� ���7 �� ��. � �1 F�� ��� �R��$ �R� I(6 ���� ��#A F�('� �)�# ���"� �'��' � �)�T ��/�«#{)"

�'��"�� ���E�/�" �?'� ��� 1 Y�� � �/ ��. .�)? �#,��/ u�c$ �� Z#�!1 Y$�E"� �1 ��#A F�('� �++&1 � �i(" ;E. � �'�"��$ U )&"B"�: �5���" @� S��)' �1

�"�'� � ����A I/���Y# 3�� � �� @�i���'�. �,.� �?'� B�� Y?: �� ��)�# ��/ .���" �#7�1 Y��?' %/�K4 �T ��. ���)5A �c$ �� i#' �?��" ��/��J�'�� �� ��1 ��/

��J�'�� �� ;{. �� �.�' ��/���� �5���" @�E"� �1 ��#A F�('� ��c," " U )&" ��/�5# �'�. ���$�,. �|z" �)����" �#��1 � �)�A.

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :[�/s/V`�[ �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :Vh/Vs/V`�[ �2��" X��l4 r���1:[[/sV/V`�`

Page 91: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

91

q���� References �2����� ����6�����:�#$ �@�#'���� ���K'�$��4 ��"�+ " )V`�s .(�c�� Y#3D< �'�"��$ �Y��*� � {.

� -�)$� � {. ���# @�,T��T @�"��$ ��?: ������T @�)$� -����4)�$ ������� ����&�o ���������/����)�� �7 �I)�/ ����. F�� >�$ �ohWmV.

�������"��������,a$� ���!" ������� �"Dw )V`�s .(Z��," �# �c�� ����#���{: n#1 ��)#+&. Y# *� ����):�W���+)3� ��#���A�"� ;"��� �-�)$� �� {.������ [��G ���� ����. �e�

�7:VeVWVej.

��,#"� �1��� )V`oe .(���#� �.��� -#��� ��+, !��� ���' �O�1K� ��' �������' 43����� ������# ������%"��� �,)��� #f, ��#f$@���4 ��"�' �$�,.��� ��J�'�� ��.�� �)5�i? �

@��?1 ��&�'��1.

� � ����|������ 2 ��6� ����)V`o` .(� 2�c" b��� ;��)" �AK����/ �)#+&. �-�)$� � {. ��b#!" ����������� 7�o� f�!,�3 ������>�$ �I�. ����. Y5# �IC� �Y5# ��F�� �

��.

�"�+ " ���a :���#� ;#���$� ���������� �@�#,# " )V`�s.(�#|t1 ������ @����" �@�i#" -�)$�� {. @�,���� ��J�'�� ���� �6�� �"D$� @��?1 H�.�������� �G�%�P� �� �>�$ �F��?Q ����.Vs�7 �Ve`WVjj.

�*�"Dw �� '�#� Q�F�,? ���2�� )V`o�(�5���" -�)$� � {. ��"�T��. �� �,/� �# ����� �t#/ �� � ��J�'����/ ���� �"D$� ���)2������ [��G ��"�#$>�$ ��F�$ ����.��7 �V[mWVho.

��/� ��,#"� �:�6�� w��Q �F�w�*��4 �-��� ������ �����,a$� ����� �������#$ ��5���1 ��G5' ���,$ i"�/)V`o� .(�U"� ���#���#f$ #f, ��( ���� �3 ��+, -#��� �����#� ��Y����" �� 2�c"

�"�x)'� ����. e)V:(�7VVoWV`s.

��)(" ���#�6���/� ������ � � ���!" ����� )V`oj .( I9D� � B�," �@�i#" -�#�" ��(" �����(,/ U# C1�$ � ����� �� @�� " -�)$�)TSS(�������� 4 S���3 ��������� ������� [��G � ��

U�#6$ 4�:���3 ��"�#$ �F�� >�$ �j�``WV.

Page 92: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

92

�a#)$� �i,#��)V`�V.(»����)�� �����«� @�#9�$��4 � � �F�$ � : ���!"�#$ ������@��?1 :�)��%/�K4 �J,/�� ��/.

�-�� >��'�.�����)2� �i#2�)V`oe(-#��� ��+,��:�1 ��:��<���4 �*�"Dw������)'� �@��?1 �1���P�Q >��.

G:� �*���!" ���4)V`mm .( ��#"�3 ��+, -#��� ��U"� �� -�� � ����)�� �P �.��� ���#�����#"�3��<�3 ���@���4 ���#. ��J�'�� �)#�1 F� � � �$�,�'��� ��C�'�� �.�� �$�,.��� �"�'.

����?. ��"����)� ' � A�$ ����� ��]1)V`�s .(%�' ;�� 1��,,T ��"���T��< ���c�� �# -�)$� � {. �Y"D$ �'��� �Y��*� @�,T��T � {. ^'� �����7 i���1���' !�8� ������������

o�����. [.

@���4 ��5#����#.�� ���(," )V`mo .(-�)$� �$���C.i4 ����" @�,���� � {. ��/ �� ;w�. @�)$���#�).��? ��"�< � �C.i4 F� � ��J�'�� �.��"� ��/�����' :[��G � ���������

��"�#$ ����� � ��� ��E����.Vm�Vo�heWeh.

���!" ���)��$)V`ms(.!�#� � � ���)�� E��'�3 ��������� Y����" X��"� i��" @��?1 �F�� P�Q ��)2��.

�*��#$ ������:�#$��# $ �����" ���?.)V`oe .(�A��$�� � {.:��/�K4 ��Y��. ��a6 Ya' �,: �������� [��G !�#� � ��#������� �>�� ����.[��omWj`.

�# $ �� "�.)V`os .(����� !,� f�I/���?Q P�Q ��.� �����)'� �@��?1 �.

��1�" ���/���G!" U$�� �@�A����@�"� Y��,� ���4 �2�)V`oo .( �-�)$� Y����" �.��"� ���� �#|t1� " ��"���� ��/��� � � {. -�)$� � �@�[�D� �3 �� ��������,)��� �� ����. �o�

�V`e.

i���4 ��,��:�)2����)V`mm .( !"�� E2� [�f�� � ���&$ )� �,�� ��+, ����� ������ �.��� ���#�E!�# #� E��H ��r% ���+, 3#r�%G � ����)�� f&$ �� ��+, 9�&"�#$ � 3U%��3 � s�2a E�

�#�� �)����3�� q���o ���H��H��3�� -�� !H#, ��@���4 i���1 ��J�'�� ��.�� �$�,.��T �"�'.

����� ��/)V`m`(���#� ��U"� �( "�$ �,�� )�J"K� ��H �]�6$�� �����(3��#� ������# ��+,

1i�, �3O��� !6/�#��� 4��� ������%"��� #f, 3U��@���4�"�' �$�,.��T ��.�� ��J�'�� F� � �E.i4 @����.

Page 93: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

93

8��#�� ��:�� ��,#$ ��p#2���� A �����"���'��"� � $�������*� �ac+" ��'����� )V`�V .(�$�� �c�� �AK����/ � {. ��c$ -�)$� � {. ��@���)$�4 @�)$���#�.��"� ��/

��J�'�� F� � �E.i4 @�)$��T������# �� � : �m����. [e��7j`Weh.

=��� ������ ��)V`oh .(��%�&� �3 -#��� ��f�������6� �1�6� ���+," ��:�1 �������)'� �@��?1 �.�.

�.�� �$��A���1�#" �X�� ��'�" )V`oh .( �c�� � i���1 Ya' %�R�4 YT�. @�,T��T -�)$� �$��G#$� � @����l4I/ >�" -�$� � �'��5: � �'��� ��/ ��� �'��<Wb#!" ������ �����3 �

����.V[�V`)�$�,�'��� �R��" �K��(�7 �jVWms.

� � ����?")V`oe .(����)�� � ��&�o ����������@��?1 :;J,:.

��#," �����#a$ �����#")V`oh .( �� ����' ���%G !�8� ~.� � ��+, -#��� ~.� �.��� �;��2���#�� ��� 5��� 3#� �� ���K$ � �� ��;a�@���4 $�,�'��� �.�� �$�,.��� �"�' ��C�'�� �"��� �

�)�?�#?. ��J�'�� �)#�1 F� �.

�Y/i' �*���!")V`me (���#� ��U"� �q���� -#��� ��+, ��#� � �,)��� -��� ������@���4�"�' �$�,.��T �.�� ���A F� � �)#�1 ���$�,�'��� ��J�'�� ���#..

��� ���/ .;#5#$ �;C5#" �� .0)V`o[ .($ E����$ E�,)��� !�#� �1%G � w"2K ��!"�#$ ��:�1 �-����#$�#"��� �����:�#"��� ��J�'�� ��'.

I��" ���� ���#56��!" �@����!"��� ��#*�" �����: )V`om .( � {. -�)$� � �'�"��$ �? 1 �c��@�)$���# @����" ��@�?a7� �C.i4 F� � ��J�'�� �.��"� ��/�!�8� !�#� � ���� ���� �VV

����.``�7 �joWj`.

��#$ ��C)aC.� �� � ��*� ����6� ���!" ���� �#4 ��$�3��{7 )V`�[ .( � �'�"��$ �,/�� y��1��@�)$���# @���)$�4 �� @��� Y"D$ � � {. -�)$� �����?. �'�.�� � �:�/ ��/ ��"<�� ����

������ � �����# �V`�[ ;[)`: (e`Wj`.

Abdi H, Shahbazi L (2001). Correlation between Occupation Stresses in Nurses' Intensive Care Unit with Job Burnout, Journal of Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences and Health Services (3) 9, 58-63.

Page 94: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

94

Ahsan, N., Abdullah, Z., Gun Fie, D.Y., Alam, S.S. (2009). Satisfaction among University Staff in Malaysia: Empirical Study, European Journal of Social Sciences, 8 (1).

Allison M.G. (2007). Identifying the Types of Student and Teacher Behaviors Associated with Teacher Stress, Teaching and Teacher Education. 23, 624-640.

Antoniou, A.S, Polychroni, F. & Vlachakis, A.N. (2006). Gender and Age Differences in Occupational Stress and Professional Burnout between Primary and High-school Teachers in Greece, Journal of Managerial Psychology, 21 (7), 682-690.

Bakker, A.B., Demerouti, E., De Boer, E. & Schaufeli, W.B. (2003). Job Demands and Job Resources as Predictors of Absence Duration and Frequency, Journal of Vocational Behavior, 62: 341-356.

Chuic Chu, I.C. (2006). The Impact of Social Support and job Stress on Public Health Nurses Organizational Citizenship Behaviors in Rural Taiwan, Public Health Nursing, 23(6): 496.

Cottrell, S. (2001). Occupational Stress and Job Satisfaction in Mental Health Nursing: Focused Interventions Through Evidence-based Assessment, Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 8, 157-64.

Duraisingam, V. & Pidd, K & Roch, A.M. (2009). The Impact of Work Stress and Job Satisfaction on Turnover Intentions: A Study of Australian Specialist Alcohol and Other drug Workers, Drugs, Education, Prevention and Policy, V: 16 & I: 3-P: 217-231

Forlin, C. (2001). Inclusion: Identifying Potential Stressors for Regular Class Teachers, Educational Research, 43, 235-245.

Gillespie, N.A., Walsh, M.J., Winefield, A.H., Stough, C.K., & Dua, J.K. (2001). Occupational Stress within Australian Universities: Staff Perceptions of the Determinants, Consequences and Moderators of Work Stress, Work and Stress, 15, 53-72.

Gueriltault-Chalvin, V., Kalichman, S.C., Demi, A. & Peterson, J.L. (2000). Work- Related Stress and Occupational Burnout in AIDs Caregivers: Test of a Coping Model with Nurses Providing AIDs Care, AIDs Care,12 (2), 149-161.

Page 95: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

95

Hughes, J.C. (2006). Teacher Stress, Teacher Efficacy, and Standardized Testing: A Study of New York City Public School Teachers, Unpublished Ph. D. Dissertation, University of Fordham.

Jackson, L.T.B. & Rothmann, S. (2006). Occupational Stress, Organizational Commitment, and Ill Health of Educators in the North West Province, South African Journal of Education, 26, 75-95.

JRPJR Caplan R.D. (1972). Organizational Stress and Individual Strain, In A.J. Marrow, ed., the Failure of Success. New York: AMACOM.

Kalia M. (2002). Assessing the Economic Impact of Stress: The Modern Day Hidden Epidemic, Metabolism, 51(6): 49-53.

Kokkinos, C.M. (2007). Job Stressors, Personality and Burnout in Primary School Teachers, British Journal of Educational Psychology, 77 (1), 229-243.

Lazarus, R.S., & Folkman, S. (1984). Stress, Appraisal and Coping, New York: Springer-Verlag.

Li CY, Chen KR, Wu CH, Sung FC. (2001). Job Stress and Dissatisfaction in Association with Non-fatal Injuries on the Hob in a Cross-Sectional Sample of Petrochemical Workers, Occup Med.; 51(1): 50-5.

Mostert, F.F.; Rothmann, S.; Mostert, K. & Nell, K. (2008). Outcomes of Occupational Stress in a Higher Education Institution, Southern African Business Review, 12, 102-127.

Newbury-Birch, D. & Kamali, F. (2001). Psychological Stress, Anxiety, Depression, Job Satisfaction, and Personality Characteristics in Preregistration House Officers, Postgraduate, Medical Journal, 77, 109-111.

Osarieme Abbe, O. (2008). Modeling the Relationship among Occupational Stress, Psychological/Physical Symptoms and Injuries in the Construction Industry, Unpublished Master of Science Dissertation, Berea College.

Robyn, R.M. Gershon, Briana Barocas, Allison N. Canton, Xianbin Li and David Vlahov (2009). Mental, Physical, and Behavioral Outcomes Associated with Perceived Work Stress in Police Officers, Criminal Justice and Behavior 2009 36: 275, the Online Version Found at: http://cjb.sagepub.com/content/36/3/275

Page 96: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

96

Teasdale, E.L. (2006). Workplace Stress, Post-Traumatic Disorders, a Sociopolitical Perspective, Psychiatry,V 5, issue 7, PP: 251 -255.

Tolbert, M.D. (2007). No Teacher Left Behind: A Predictive Model of Teacher Stress and Coping, Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, University of South Carolina.

Tyssen, R. & Vaglum, P. & Gronvold, N.T. & Ekeberg, O. (2005). The Relative Importance of Individual and Organizational Factors for the Prevention of Job Stress during Internship's Nationwide and Prospective Study, Medical Teacher, V: 27-I: 8-P: 726-731

Winefield, A.H., Gillespie, N., Stough, C., Dua, J., Hapuarachchi, J.and Boyd, C. (2003). Occupational Stress in Australian University Staff:Results from a National Survey.

Page 97: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

97

���2� )-�=J ���C;� 1� )A�& ���($�6�� $( $( � �0K ������;4� �( �.��J

�T�_� #6'�z

43�) %K� ��G{

�3���#�� 3��P|

1"G�%�� 1"�� �� �

4 "SQ ���a1 �5���" �*�6 %/�K4 g�/ �� �)#5,: ��/ X�/ �� �+&. ��/����� �� �'�A�,Q ��/

�� @���(�'�� � "�: .��� 1 ��x," ���[jo �a' )Voh � @�oh��" (�'�5'� F� � @���(�'�� �� �'��' X�� �� ���a)$� � i���1 i��" ��' F�#4 ��J�'�� ���� ��#A �.�< � �� � 6�"�,Q �� � ��

�'�. �&)'� ����+1 ��#. �1 �. �)$��< �'��' ���A @���(�'�� �� ���D�� ������A ��� ��"�,�$�4X�/ ;"�. �� �'�A�,Q ��/o���< #�"��c," ��"D� �� �'�� X�/ -�W��*���

�'� �����#$�" ������ W@��� ����,: @�#" ����� Y #�� � ���� �,,� ;#�C1 ��� �'����A .���� ='������� ��#{)"�,Q ;# !1 X�� �� ���a)$� � �/)MANCOVA ( ���3 ;# !1 ���"

�,)��A .���a1 ��$ �|� ���"� >�),� �� =4 �� ��� @��' S��)' �, " ��/ ����� �# ���� ��/�"D� �� �'�� X�/ �� ��" � @� @���(�'�� �+&.�X�/ �'�W����,: X�/ @�#" �����

X�/ @��� ���� �X�/ Y #�� �'����A Y.�� ��:�.���' �#J'�#" �� ��" @���(�'�� ��/���< ��� �"��1 -�#�" �� @� @���(�'�� �)�# �/ .K4 S��)' �2��" ��� �����" �*�6 %/�Y��A ���3 �! .� "�H ��(h��:X�/ ���a1 ��'�A�,Q ��/ @���(�'�� ��)#5,: ��/.

1N@�(����� ��' F�#4 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� ���A ��#�'�� �3�.)>�p5" ��,5��'(Email: [email protected] [email protected]

2N��' F�#4 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� ���A �����)$� @�(������3�. 3N#�'�� @�(����� �'�" �#?. ��J�'�� ��4Ni���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� ���A �����)$�

Page 98: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

98

�� 2�

���a1 k�*�" ���'��1 �� �)#5,: ��/ �/� ��,#"� �� ��< ��� k�*�" �� X�/�! ��)�5' G6�7 �# �� i#J'� Y$� ��'�" �3� ���� ����� �#,��/ � @��x')�����

�}}�,#C" �X�)�������#2 �������I���$ ������� .(�,/�� �)�# �� F��" �/���a1 ��� � �7�< �3D� �'��� �/)@�A�/���}}� (� � ��,#�#4 ;# !1��� Iw�

��/�K4 )@�]2�/�������]#2 �������(���a1 �,#"� �� ;"�� Z���1 �� �)#5,: ��/���'��1 �� � � X�/����' ��:� ��< ��/ .

� ���/� >� %/�K4 �).lA ��/ ��/���a1 ���� )" ��/����� �� �)#5,: ��/���� ���3 �$�� ���" �� @��J�� � @�.��< X�/ �� ����� �'� .@�A�/ >��" ���)���� (

��J�'�� @���(�'�� �?'� ��/ �� �� �� ���a)" � 2�c" ����� Y����" �C��"� ��/�).�� Y$� ���� X��iA �� �'� .��� ��Y����" �� �� 2�c" �1 �� ��. �)$��< @�A�,,�

� �� @�'� X�/ � @���" X�/ ����2�� X�/ �#,��/ � @�.��< X�/ � � ���7�,,� ����� .�)�� �� @�.��< X�/ ����' @���" � �5���" �� @�'� �� ��� @��' S��)'

�" ����� �6 �� �,,�)���}%�, " S��)' ����" �� ��� (������1 ��� �,).�� ��� ��/ Y$� @�.���" X�/ �� �1R� @�.��4 X�/ .g� �)���� (� �?��" %/�K4 i#'

Y��� Y$� �?��" S��)' � � ��� F�('� ��, 1�C$� @���(�'�� ��� .��� �� @���"�� �,).�� ��� %/�K4 @�'� �� �1R� ��# " g��!'� I#' ���6 �� �?'� �.�/ ���'

�" �.� .$� � @���" � �@�.���" � ��� �� @�.��< @�'� ���. ����� X�/ -��" @�.��4 � ��� �� @�.��< �'��� .@���" � @�.��4 �� �)�� �� @�.��< X�/ @�'�

�" ��+1 @�.���" �� �)�# �� @�.��< X�/ �'��� .��#��$�)$� ��})���� (���"N'�� � "�: �� �� � 2�cN' @���(�N�� ��,2��#. �)$��< �?'� ��N/ �1 �� ��N����� X�

2- Mackintosh 4- Swim 6- Halpern 8- Beloff 10- Stacey

1- Deary 3- Lynn 5- Hogan 7- Lippa 9- Byrd

Page 99: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

99

�'��� ���C1 ��,,� ����� �� @�.��< �#,��/ � �/��< .g� S��)' i#' %/�K4 ��� �� )���� (�.�/ �x' �� @����" @� �� ���" �)��A �x' �� @���4 �� �)�� �. ���C1 ��'�. .

�" �C� @���" �'��� @��'��/��< �� ��1R� X�/ �?'� �� �'��� .�2�6�� ��� @�'� �� �.�/ ����' �� �?'� ����� � ��,)5/ ��� �.�/ ��!2 �� @�.�/��< � �?'� �� �,).��

�� @�.�/��< � ���� ����" �� �1R� @�.��4 .'���� F�? i2����)���� (�� i#'Y����" �@�.��< X�/ �1 Y$��< @�)5 J'� �� � {. ���A S,4 ��" � @� @�A�,,�

��1� �� @��A�i���" � ��i��4 ����2�� �,,� ��, .�� �)�# �� @�.��< X�/ @���" @�'�)��� ��� �� ��� (@�.���" �� �)�# �� @�.��4 X�/ =,: �� �/ �)��� �� ��� �}� (��1� �'�� ���� ��, .g� S��)' �#�t1 ��)���� (�$�)$� � ��# �)���� (

��i��4 �?��" ��� � ��1R� �.�/ ��/����� �/)�}� (���" � �5���" �� ��i �/)��(�'�� ���� Y����� .�#�t1 X�/ �$�,�'��� �� 2�c" �,#�#4 �� Y# 3�� ��� Iw�# �

�" ���a1 �� �,� �/���a1 �C,�� �� ����' ��:� � � X�/ �� �)#5,: ���'� � #< �/Y$� .���� �" @��' �� @���" X�/ ��1� ��� @���(�'�� >�6 �,/� .Y,�)���� (i#'

���a1 ��� �#�t1 �� �#2�� �)#5,: ��/ .� X�/ �+&. ����� S��)'��� ��(�'�� ��� �� �� @� �� ���6 ��, 1�C$� ='�5#2 ����Y����" �� X�/ �� ��" @�A�,,�

� @�.��<�, " ��� �" @�'� �� �1R� ���� �.�)�/��� ��� �� �/�}� .( ���A ;���1� @�.���" �� �1R� �� @�.��4 X�/ �#,��/ �'�� ���� ��,)��� ��� ��

�/��} .(���� @�#" X�/ �1 �. �)$��< %/�K4 ��� �� �� �"�J,/ >�6 @�.��< ���� ��1� �� �" �C� @���(�'�� ��,,� ��, @�#" X�/ @�.���" �� �'��� �� ��1R� ����

�'��� @�.��4 � �5���")}�/��� ��� �� ��/�}� .( � F�?'��� �J�� � 2�c" �� ��@�5#A�)���� (�������i ��� �� @��'����� � @�.��< X�/ �1 �,)$��< >�$

� ��1� @�.��< ���2�� X�/ ��: �,,� ��, .�� � �3 �� 2�c" � �)$�� I/ S��)' .����N#' � 2�c" �Ni@���" /NX�.��<N@���1� @�'� �� �1R� �� N�'�� ���� ��,)�}� ��

2- Bennett 1- Rawles 3- Gasson

Page 100: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

100

����}� .(�)<� @����� �� �1R� �� �54 @����� X�/ @�'� I/ � @���" I/ �#,��/ ��1� �'�� ���� ��,)�}� ��� �� �}� .( X�/ �+&. ����� �� 2�c" �� �<� S��)'

>��: ���Y$� ��. �7D< .@��/ >��: �� �� �����" ��/��" ��/����� ��/ ��. � X�/ �R� @����� � @����� �@��/��< �@���4 ��� �#,��/ � ��< ��� �K��

Y$� �#J'�#" .� �����1 S��)' ��� ��Y����" ��/ �� ���< ��� � ����' ��: @�A�,,� �� 2�c" ��� ��)��@�5#A � F�?'��� � 2�c" i:���� (>��)6� � �� �'�� @���(�'��

�" �#J'�#" �R� �?'� X�/ ���� �.� .>��:��@��' �� Y# 3�� ��� �*�� ����" ��1� �#J'�#" �� �/� � @�'� �#,��/ � @���" �+&. ��,��1� �#J'�#" ��,

���i' @�.��4 X�/ @�.���" �1 Y$� �1.7� P)z(�":��"� �#�� �;��2� !fP B� ��O, ��3���#� 9�&<�.� )� ��#� x���� �

�&<�.� ���) ��3#� 9��*$ g� )���� (�, 1�C$� )�}�=N()���=N(

��< �/��} �/��� �/����" �/��� �/��� �/�W��4 �/��� �/��� �/�W

�$�)$� � ��#)���� (�, ���#' )�}�=N()���=N(��< �/��� �/��� �/}W���" �/��� �/�}� �W��4 �/��� �/��� �/�W

�/��< �/��� �/��} �/�W���� �/��� ��� �/�

Y,)���� (�, 1�C$� )��=N()��=N(��< �/�}� �/��� �/�

@�?2�" � � ��)���� (�,2��� )�}=N()��=N(��< �/�}� �/��� �/�

����'� ��. ��#A �/�}� �/�}� �/}Wi2��� � F�?'���)���� (@�)5 J'� )���=N()��=N(

Page 101: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

101

��< ��/��� ��/��� ��/����" �/�}� ��/�}� ��/}��4 ��/��� }�/��� ��/�

@�5#A � F�?'���)���� (@�)5 J'� )���=N()��=N(��< ��/�}�

)��=N(��/�}�

)��=N(��/�

�54 @����� ��/�}� �}/�}� }�/��)<� @����� ��/�}� ��/�}� ��/}W

i2��� � F�?'���)���� (@�)5 J'� )��}=N()��=N(��< ��/��� �}/��} �/�

����'� ��. ��#A ��/���/��'�/�� � ���� �F�?'���)[ss[ (@�)5 J'� )��=N()��=N(��< ��/�}� ��/��} ��/�

�54 ���� }�/��� ��/��� ��/�W�)<� ���� ��/��} ��/�}� ��/�W

Y����" �� � �3 �� 2�c" �� �� @�.��< � � X�/ �1 �� ��. �)$��< @�A�,,��,,� ����� .>�$ �� �� 2�c" ��� X�/ �+&. ��/����� �$�� � �#<� ��/ ��/

�'�A�,Q)�'���A������ ����� (�� X�)5AY$� �)� .�)' �>��" ����i#9�� ��F�?'��� �)�}}� (���a1 X�/ �� �+&. ����� �� �)#5,: ��/ @�'��:�' �# �� �� �'�A�,Q ��/

�'��� �$�� �2�{1�4 .���#*��� �� � X�/ �� �54 @�'��:�' �� ��� @��' �?'� S��)'@�#" ������ Y #�� � �'�6�� ����� �1R� �� @�.��< �'����A��1� @��)<� �� ��,

�" �,,� .��1�" � F�?'����)�}}� (@��' ��+" � �5# J'� @���(�'�� � "�: �� i#'X�/ � @�.��< � � X�/ �1 �'��� ;���1 @���" �� �'��� g�/ ��"D� ��/ ��,�iA

�,,� ����� @�'� �� �1R� �� �C#'�C" ���'��1 � ��C)� ����� .@�Qe)�}}� (� "�: ��'��%/�� ���� @���"�N)' ��� � �#Q �� ����,N1 �� Y��� Y$� �(#N���a �)#5,: ��/

2- Neto 4- Mottabu

1- Gardner 3- Ruiz 5- Chan

Page 102: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

102

��c," X�/ ��W@�#" � �*��� ���� ��:� ���� .�� �� @�.��< @��54 %/�K4 ��� ����c," X�/W�2�6�� �@��)<� �� �1R� �*��� ��< @��)<� �� X�/ �� �� @�.

@�#" ��1� @��54 �� �1R� ���� �'�� ���� ��, .%'�� � "�: �� �c$�)" ���� @���"� �a��. i#' �'����)���� (@��� X�/ �x' �� @��)<� �� Y$� ���� X��iA � ����

������ X�/ �x' �� @��54 � �'��� ��1� @��54W�'��� ��1� @��)<� � ����� .��� %/�K4 ���X�/ �J�� k��'� ��!2 ��, " ���a1 =,: �� @�#" �/ ���' ��/��" ����

Y$� .��D� �F�?'����� # ��)���� (��i � "�: �� i#' �� �,)��� �5# J'� @R�$��c," X�/ �, � X�/ U )&" k��'� �� �C� �� �?,1W�, " ���a1 �*��� �� ����

���� ��:� @�'� � @���" ��/����� �# .��X�/ �� �� �,).�� ��� @���" %/�K4 �����c,"W�'�����<� @�'� � �5���" �� ��1R� �*��� .

%/�K4 ���a1 � y��" ��/ �,!," �� Y$� @� �� ���6 i#' X�/ �,#"� �� �,$ ��/ �� ������1 �.����" >�) " =]$ ����� ��,1 � #< G#. Y5&' >�$ � �2� ��.

���6 �1 ��< %��i���}�" �"��� �J2�$ �2��6 �� �C,�� �1 ��/��}Y�� ��Q� �J2�$ �" ��. .��i �<��� �� Y�� ��� � Y$� �#J��Q ��#5 Y�� ��' @���� @� �� �2�$

� ��)�# ��.�" ��< ��#A .I?" %/�� ����� �)C' ���1 ��i �<��� �� �/ ��2�$��' ���'��1 ��� %/�� ���a)" ��/ @�"�� �� �/ < ��/Y$� �� .@�"�� �#x' ���/

�" @��' ��)�� %/�� ���D�� � @�A£�� �,/� .@�"�� ��1�� �x��6 ��/ ���'��1 � ��"� ������ � ����� �" %/�� Y��$ �,��)�@�A�/�}}� .(%/�K4 �#,��/ @��' �/

X�/ ��/����� �� �'��� ���a)" @�A�'�#A��� � #+!1 ���4 -�$� � �'�A�,Q ��/�" �.�);#1���}}}��#. ������� .(X�/ U )&" k��'� ���##{1 �C,�� � �:�1 � �� �/

X�/ ��/���� � Y$� �C�" U )&" �#,$ 1 ����� �� �'�A�,Q ��/t�#| ����� ����lJ ��I/ �#{)" @��,� � @���(�'�� �$ �*�6 %/�K4 �� �/��< ;# !1 ���� �C�� �� �##{1

��"� ���7 � @� �|� �1 �.��. >�),� �� gl6 �.

2- Bailey 4- Shearer

1- Clark 3- Teele

Page 103: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

103

�" ��/�K4 �,#�#4 � �:�1 ����a1 �$�� �� YaA @��1 ��/����� �� �)#5,: ��/X�/ � � � X�/ ���" �� �+&. �3D� ���" � I?" k�*�" �� �'�A�,Q ��/

�" U )&" ��/���� @��J�/�K4 �.� .�6 ��� Y#�/� ;#2� ��� � ���. %/�K4 �� �����x' � �/��� �� Y$� ���< �,�* ��/����� �.i#J'� � ���)�� ��/�"�#4 X�/ �����

�'��� ��?")�9�����}}} .(�" X�/ �+&. ��/����� ���� � @�i�� ���|� �'��1F����< �� �� %&N.� �).�� ��C �� � �cN�,)���"�Q-­4������#"�'��� �NF�?�����1�"���}}� .(���a1 Y#�/� � �:�1 � �+&. ��/����� �� �)#5,: ��/X�/ @���(�'�� � "�: �� @�,��1 ��/�K4 �#,Q �C,�� � Y��,� � � �'�A�,Q ��/

X�/ ��/����� �1 Y$� @� � �*�6 %/�K4 �����, �Y$� ���' F�('� �'���� ��/� � "�: �� �� ��" � @� @���(�'�� �'�A�,Q�,� � 2�c" @���(�'� .���� g�/ �&�"

�" >��$ ��� r$�4 � ��#)$� �*�6 %/�K4 @���(�'�� �# ��� �� �.� �� ��" � @� u�c" X�/ k�' Y�/ ��"D� �� �'�� X�/ �, � �'���A ���x' �� ��.��c,"W

�'� �����#$�" ������ ��*���W@��� ����,: @�#" ����� Y #�� � ���� �'����A4�� =�, " ���a1 �$ �|� ���"� >�),� ��' �� ���� ��:� ����

B��

�'��' X�� � ���"� �'��' �� "�: ���#A ��� 1 %/�K4 ��� ��[jo �a' )��� � @� ����" (@���(�'�� � �: �� i���1 i��" ��' F�#4 ��J�'�� �'�5'� F� � @���(�'�� ��

�).� X��"� ��5# J'� @�� ��$�,�'��� ��/%#4 ��#�� ������" ��'�)5� � �'�)5��"�'� � Y����" �����):� F� � ��$��� >�$ �� �'�A��� Y����" � �.��"� �i��

� #+!1�}W���� �,)��A ���3 � 2�c" ���" )�'��' ���A �,$ �#J'�#"[[� >�$ h��# " g��!'� � � ��"[o/e.(�'��' X�� �� ���"� �'��' �&)'� ��� �#A���� �� ��

�.�< � 6�"�,Q �� �. ���a)$� ����+1 ®�#. � ��.

2- Chamorro-Premuzic 4- Moutafi

1- Dweck 3- Furnham

Page 104: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

104

�� ��U�� %/�K4 ��� ��B�: ��� ���D�� ���� ��X�/ �.��iA ��< �"�,�$�4 �'�A�,Q ��/

�. ���a)$� .�"�,�$�4 ���Vh`b$�1 �2�z$ ;#�� ������� ���)�}�}(%(,$ ��� Y$� ��. �#?1 �'���A ���?,�#4 X�/ k�' Y�/.���' ��� �"�,�$�4 ��� �� ���lA

S,4 -�#�" �� �R�z$ r$�4 �:�� �. ���a)$� ��)��#�/=��R�� " �=���)�5' �=��� �Y3� �/=�� ����'=�.(������� � ;#�� �� Y$� ��� � F�R)�}�} (��C��� ��

� ��c,"X�/ �.��iA ��< -�#�" � $�1 ��� ���"� ���� ���a)$� �'�A�,Q ��/�'�� .��� G6�7 �x' �� ���a)$� � ��)� �� ���7 -�#�" ����)!" ����� @��x' �� �/

;# !1 ���:� �� � � ���� �$�� � -�#�" � $�1 ��� �� ���"� ��/ �'�� ������ .���*�)���} (-�#�" ��� U )&" ��/��� � "�� ;# !1 �� �"�,�$�4 .��� �(#)' �� ;# !1���#��4 � "�� �� ;#2� � >��$ �� �1�/}��� � ��)�" � "�� �� �#,��/ �

�'�. gl6 ;"�� �� �� %# .>�z$ ��� 1 �'��� �'�5�/ X�� �� ;7�6 S��)' � �/)���'��� ��a2� G���* (���< �� F��� �/ ���"�� �� �-�#�" � �/ >��: ������ @��'

Y$� ��. .���< Y�/ ��� �� �� �/ X�/ -�#�" �"��� �� �'���A �'�A�,Q ��/� Y$� ��. ���� �#*�1 �+)&" ���7)�������� � ;#���}�} ��'���A ����� �

Y#�$����}}� �U#$ ����� ������2�a2�� ����}}�:(

�"D� �� �'�� X�/ :Y#$�56 ;"�. �"D� �� �'�� X�/ �� ���)aA @�� � @�� ��#A��� ���'��1 ����).�' � @�� �� ���a)$� � ��� � G2�3 �� @�#���'� ��/ ���

g��/� � ��#)$� Y?: @�'� �7��" ��� � @��J�� � ��< �7��" @�'��?� ��� �|�"�" ��< �.� .�"�'��� �@�A�,5��' �� �,)5/ �'�5� �# �� @���,&$ � �� . �@���J'

�A�" �C� �'�� �'��� ��R� �"D� X�/ �,� .

," X�/N��cW�*��� :," X�/N��cW. �*��� N� Y � >�7� ��� ���'��1 ;"�

2- Korkmaz 4- Woolfolk

1- Yesil 3- Smith

Page 105: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

105

� �DC�" � ;9�5" ;# !1 ���'��1 � Y#��� ��2� " >R�)$� ���'��1 ���c," ���7 ��# �� F�('� ��*��� � ����" �*��� �.� .������ ��c," X�/ ��J��W� �*���

�" ���.� ��c," �Ca1 � �����)$� >R�)$� ��/�J2� �#&�1 ���'��1 �,� .X�/ k�' ����" ����1 �*��� � �� � �Ca1 � G w� ��. .

���#�#$�" X�/ :��� ��#$�" �,/� X����4 ���'��1 ;"�. ���#�#$�" X�/��/ � �/�J2� ���$�,.� ���'��1 �#,Y$� �)6 � �/�J2� ��� @��]$ ���< � ����

0�� � ���#�#$�" ��/�J2� �$�� � ��' � @����� �� ���?" ��/�J2� ��� >�),� ���lA�" ��#$�" �.� .X�/ � ����" ���)<�$ G w� ���#�#$�" X�/ �'���A �x' -�$� �

���� �'�� �� �"D� .

�'� X�/W���,: :�'� X�/W����6 �� �'��/�" ���a)$� ���'��1 ;"�. ���,:5" �� ;6 ��� @� �"��1 �� �)�53 �� ���a)$� ���'��1 ��#.� � @��� ��� � @�t�� �2

�" ������� �� �#2�1 �.� .

����� X�/ :��,: ����'�� ���'��1 ;"�. ����� X�/ �/� �� �#'� ����� ��/ � ��"� ��#9i: �#&�1 ���'��1 ���< � �,/� ��� � ������ ¢�#.� �##{1 � I5(1

�$ �Ca1 ���'��1 �#,��/ �" �� �.� .

@�#" X�/ ���� :@�#" X�/ �i#J'� ��/�+3 ��� ���'��1 � ���� �D���1 � �/�" ���.� �?'� � %&�|� ;"� 1 � @��J�� �,� .�Q �?'� �C,�� �, � �J�� ��&.� ���

�" ��� JQ ��,/� F�('� �,'��1�" ���3� �c�� @��J�� � �#'� � �'� �2��)6� %,��� ��,,��" �,):� �i#Q �Q �� ��'��� Y$�� �� �i#Q �Q �Y5#Q �?'� �'��� �$�56� �Q � �,,� .

�" @�C"� X�/ k�' ��� � ����� �1 �/��,,� ��� @��J�� � ��|�" ��� .@�#�"/ @�����" � @�����)$�#$ �@�#'�6�� �@�A�,.���@�#" X�/ �J� ��#' �� ��R� ����

�'��� .

Page 106: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

106

@��� X�/ ���� :@��� X�/ -�56� �� @�. ��A� ���'��1 ;"�. ���� �i#J'� ��/ �/�" �A�'� %&�|� Y���/ � ��< >�#"� ��.�)���'��1 ��#)5/ �5� �Q �C,�� �)5'�� �/

�'��1�' �g�/ � �/���� �Y5#Q �� ��. ��/ F��� @�)��/ � �Q ��'� �Q �� ������ �$�56�" �,):� �i#Q �" @��' %,��� �'�JQ U )&" b���. �� � ��#,� �#/� .(

Y #�� X�/ �'����A :Y #�� X�/ �/��" ���'��1 ;"�. �'����A�� Y #�� �� �/�J2� F�x' ��� ;9�3 i#�1 ��� �� @��" ��#'� � � #�� ��/ ��'��#w � ��'� ����:�" �# @�.

�)<�$ ��#.� ��.�)$� � @�5'� Y$� ��" �?'� @��� ��, �.� .

7� P)0(43#� ��#� ����)�)�� ����� � �*<� F��#_ -�"2� B� ������# �� ���( �Q ��

43#� -�"2� �7��� 3� &$ ��*<� F�#_ ����)� )�� ����� �'�� �� �"D� X�/ Vhoo/smm/s

��c," X�/W�*��� [V�e/so�/s$�" X�/���#�# Ve�V/smo/s�'� X�/W���,: ��s/soj/s

����� X�/ Vm�h/sm`/s@�#" X�/ ���� Vjom/sjo/s@��� X�/ ���� Vm�V/so`/sY #�� X�/ �'����A Vo�`/so[/s

����� �

���� ���"� ;# !1 ��� ���a1 � y��" ��/���< ����' �� �)#5,: ��/ -�#�" ��/"�,�$�4X�/ �.��iA��< �;# !1 ��'�A�,Q ��/�� ��#{)"�,Q='�����)MANCOVA (

�. ��:� .�*��a" �� �c&1 F�� �� @�,#��� �� =4 �@�"�� ��� ��/���< ����' -�#�" ��/ U )&"�� �$ � �)5�� ��/�#{)" @��,� I/ �#{)" @��,� ;# !1 ���� �C�� �� �##{1

�..>��: `@�"�� S��)' �,Q ��/�" @��' �� ��#{)" �/�.

Page 107: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

107

7� P)?(x�������)� �� �#"+�� �Q43#� -�"2� B� �,��U(3�� ������# �� �� ���( �Q!";�P -��� #�

#@� ���)� [�� B)�� �� 2�Fd.f �#�

4 , d.f �.�

~.� ��&����3

��$� ������S"S*$

�$ ��D#4 �|� VVh/sVes/ho[eo sssV/sVVh/s��"RiC �� �� ooj/sVes/ho[eo sssV/sVVh/s

�,# )/ �|� V[�/sVes/ho[eo sssV/sVVh/s��i��� ���1���� V[�/sVes/ho[eo sssV/sVVh/s

Y#5,: ��D#4 �|� Voo/shem/mo[eo sssV/sVoo/siC �� ����"R oV[/shem/mo[eo sssV/sVoo/s

�,# )/ �|� [`V/shem/mo[eo sssV/sVoo/s��i��� ���1���� [`V/shem/mo[eo sssV/sVoo/s

>��: �� �� ��c'��/��" ��/��" �, " ���a1 ��. � @� @���(�'�� �# �������' ;�� 1 �� =4 ��" ���< �� �$ ��/ -�#�" X�/ �.��iA ��< �"�,�$�4 ��/ ��/

���� ��:� �'�A�,Q)���/}=λ�iC �� ����"R ���/�=)�����(F�}}}�/}P< .( �"��� ���� ='����� ;# !1 ����)ANOVA (� �)5�� �#{)" �/ � ­� #�E1 @�"�� @��,�

�,Q ='������� ;# !1 �. F�('� ��#{)" .>��:�@�"�� S��)' �1 ��/ ;# !1 ��#{)"���< �� �� ='����� -�#�" A ��< �"�,�$�4 ��/X�/ �.��i �" @��' �'�A�,Q ��/ �/�.

7� P)I(x���� 1o�a )� ���)� �� F9��*$ ���#� ��#� �3 ��";�P ��43#� -�"2� B� ������# �� ���( �Q ��

���, ����� �� 9�#""+$ q����

��%�� 9������)SS(d.f

�":��"� 9������)MS(F

~.���&� ���3

��$� ������S"S*$

X�/�"D� �� �'�� hoj/emVhoj/emmVh/s`��/sss`/s�$ ��c," X�/ W�*��� m[o/jee Vm[o/jee hme/[VVm/sss�/s

���#�#$�" X�/ j�j/Vj[h Vj�j/Vj[h sVj/Vsss[/ss`j/s�'� X�/ W���,: Vjj/ehj VVjj/ehj �jj/msse/ss[�/s

����� X�/ oe[/VVj Voe[/VVj e`[/shjj/sss[/s@�#" X�/ ���� eos/omVeos/omVmm/V[m�/sssh/s@��� X�/ ���� �mm/hVm V�mm/hVm je�/`sem/ssVh/s

Page 108: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

108

Y #�� X�/ �'����A h[[/`hj Vh[[/`hj omh/VVm[/sssm/s�"D� �� �'�� X�/o�[/Vs�V Vo�[/Vs�V eeo/V`sssV/ssh�/s

��c," X�/ W�*��� �os/ojV�os/oj`[o/sejm/sssV/s���#�#$�" X�/ eeo/ehVeeo/eh``j/sej[/sssV/s

�'� X�/ W���,: ses/joV Vses/joV �`h/�ss[/ss`j/s����� X�/ [e[/�[V[e[/�[h[s/seVo/sss[/s

@�#" X�/ ���� �oV/jjV V�oV/jjV o�h/oss`/ss`[/s@��� X�/ ���� emm/[[jj Vemm/[[jj ohs/V�sssV/ssms/s

Y#5,:

Y #�� X�/ �'����A [sh/`Veo V[sh/`Veo soj/VmsssV/ssjV/s�"D� �� �'�� X�/ome/[V`hV [je e`e/os

��c," X�/ W�*��� h`�/ms[se [je �[j/[jh ���#�#$�" X�/ h��/h[�oj [je [V`/Vj[

�'� X�/ W���,: sm`/VoVjo [je ee�/jo����� X�/ jeh/eo[[� [je m`e/[V�

@�#" X�/ ���� h[m/V�m[` [je h[o/mh@��� X�/ ���� o[V/`s[mh [je [he/VVh

�c<

Y #�� X�/ �'����A heh/ho�o[ [je o`�/Voh �"D� �� �'�� X�/sss/j[oess [jo

��c," X�/ W�*��� sss/�j�jes [jo /���#�#$�" X� sss/e`��`s [jo

�'� X�/ W���,: sss/[`j``` [jo ����� X�/ sss/moVeV[ [jo

@�#" X�/ ���� sss/VVsV�[�[jo @��� X�/ ���� sss/Vsjhjje[jo

;T

Y #�� X�/ �'����A sss/Vs[mhss[jo

;# !1 �/ >�� k�' ��c< >�),T ���� �#!+1 X�� �� ���a)$� ��'���V�� �c$ssj[/s�. @�"�� )ssj[/s=o÷se/s.(@��/ >��: �� �� ������/��"

�" ���a1 ��. �, " ��/ �"D� �� �'�� X�/ �� ��" � @� @���(�'�� �# ����)���/��=)�����(F�}}}�/}P<(�X�/ �'�W���,: )���/�=)�����(F�}}�/}=P(�

�/X@�#" ���� )���/�=)�����(F�}}�/}=P(�X�/ @��� ���� )��}/��=)�����(F

Page 109: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

109

�}}}�/}P<(�X�/ Y #�� �'����A )}��/��=)�����(F�}}}�/}P<(���� ��:�.��" � @� @���(�'�� ����' �#J'�#" �5���")>��:�(�" @��' �#J'�#" �� �/�

���' �"��1 �� ��" @���(�'�� ��/-�#�" ���< ��� �" @� @���(�'�� �� �)�# �/ �.�.7� P)N(=�#K�� � �":��"� 43#� ��"&� -�"2� B� �,��U(3�� ������# �� ���( �Q ��

!";�P -��� #� -�"2� 43#� �!";�P �":��"� 3�� ����� =�#K��

�'�� �� �"D� X�/ ;�eh/hm[Vm/�@� sm/hj�he/o��" m�/ess[`/�

��c," X�/ W�*��� ;��s/em`[s/Vj@� [e/emjmV/Vj��" ``/e�e[h/Ve

���#�#$�" X�/ ;��o/h[�ms/V[@� ms/h`hmj/VV��" hs/hVmV�/Ve

�'� X�/ W���,: ;�hm/[ohm[/o@� e�/[mVse/o��" `o/`s�m�/o

����� X�/ ;��h/eVos[/Vh@� h[/eVh�m/Vh��" sm/e`hm�/Ve

@�#" X�/ ���� ;�e`/j`mhs/o@� e`/j[jV�/o��" mV/jejee/o

@��� X�/ ���� ;�s`/j[[V�/VV@� os/e�heh/Vs��" �s/jj`e[/VV

Y #�� X�/ �'����A ;�[�/jsVVo/Vh@� m[/emVjs/Vh��" �`/je``�/V[

1- Bonferroni

Page 110: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

110

��"�� � dK� �#"( ���' �#J'�#" �� ��� @��' S��)' ���< ���� �� ��" @���(�'�� �+&. ����� ��/ -�#�" ��/

X�/ �" @� @���(�'�� �� �)�# �'�A�,Q ��/ �.�.S��)' � �5�/ � @��&�/ S��)' ��� �� � �3 �� 2�c" .%/�K4 ���� @��' �/ ��1� � ;���1 ��" @���(�'�� �� �'� �1R� ��,

'�'��� @�'� � �5���" �� @�.��< �.�/ ����)�i2��� � F�?'���V��e �V��� �g� �V��[ �Y, �V��j ��$�)$� � ��# �V��` �@�?2�" � � �� �V��e � ���� �F�?'��� �

��'�/��[ss[ .(� �?��" S��)' i#' @���(�'���#w � "�: �� Y$� ��"� Y$�)�@�A�/V�mo �@�5#A � F�?'��� �V��o .(� �2�6 �� S��)' ��� �" Y$� %/�K4 �� ��� @��' �/

�" ���a1 �,/� @�"�� �� � � ���' -�$�� �)#5,: ��/ ��'� �6 �� �,/� ������ ��/ Y$�)�@�A�/[ss` .(>�6 �" u�c" >��$ ��� ���a1 ����'� �Q �1 �� ��. �)#5,: ��/

����'� � ��. ����� X�/ �� H��c'� X�/ � 3�� ��/�'��� .%/�K4 i#' �,#"� ��� �� ���/ Y$� �)��A F�('�)� ��V@�?2�" ���������i2��� � F�?'��� V��� .( � � �� �>��" ���

@�?2�")���� (@�"�� �1 �,)$��< ��" � @� @���(�'�� �� �� F�3�� ���' � @�A£�� ��/WAIS�� ���� ��,,� ����� �� @�.��< X�/ =]$ � �,,� ;"�� �� �'�� ���3 �?'�

����'� ����' �,,� �5���" I/ � �� ��. ����� � ��. ��#A .�� ��� @��' S��)'� �#,��/ � @�'� �� �1R� ;� �� @���" ��/������, " ��� X�/ �� �1R� ����

����'� �� �?'� ��. ��#A .�, " �2� �� �#��4 @�'� ��/����� �Q�A� ���' ��� .S��)' �����" �)5:� �� @�.��< X�/ ����� �� �� �'�'� B*��1 � �'���" ��C1 �| ���$.�,Q �/

%/�K4 Y$� F�R ����� X�/ � � 3�� X�/ �1 ��#A F�('� �,#"� ��� �� ��)�# ��/Z#3� ����3 � ������ �1 �/� ���3 �5���" ���" �'���� � "�: �� �� @���" � @�'� ��. �1

���7 �,#"� ��� ����#A .

���a1 �� ��� @��' �#,��/ S��)' �, " ��/ @���(�'�� �+&. ��/����� �# ���� " � @�NX�/ �� �� '�� ��/N� �� �N�"D�'�N�W:N����, @�#" �N���� @��� �N��� �

2- Mulhern 1- Reilly

Page 111: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

111

Y #�� �'����A���� ��:� .���� X�/ �� @�'� � @���" ��/����� �# >�6 X�/ ��������c,"W�, " ���a1 ���#�#$�" � �*��� Y.��' ��:� ���� .�"D� X�/ � y��1�� ��

�5� �F�?'��� �'�� ��V�1�� �[��"�Q �W�"��$ � ����#"�4 `)[ss� (� F�?'��� �#,��/ ���1�")[ssh (�'�� �)��� Y$� �?��" S��)' �.%/�K4 ���� �Q�A� ���� X��iA �/

�� �'���, " ���a1 ����' ��:� @�'� � @���" �� �"D� X�/ ����� �� ����)S��)' �%/�K4 ��. � :��" �"��" %& �� �/ .(�" @��' I/ ��x' �,#�#4 �$�� �� �� �/�

>�$ >�� ���?" �� @��)<� �.� ��/ �" %#4 �"D� ��/ ���a1 ��� �"� ��,)�� �<��� �1 �/� �'��:�' � �)6 � I� S���1�" �# ��'��)�@�A�/[ss` .( �# �� G2�w ��A��� �)6

�" �x' � i#' � "�: ����� ���?" �� @�'� �� �.� ��� �$� ��'�1� @���" �� �"D� ��/�" �x' � �����, %# �� @�.��< ���'��1 �"D� X�/ �,#"� �� ��" @���(�'�� �� �$�

���� ����� �'�.�K4 � ��x' �,#�#4 �$�� �" @��' ��/ �/� ��1� ���a1 ���1��� ����c," � ����� X�/ �� @���"WY$� �*��� )�@�A�/[ss` �F�?'��� � i#9�� ��)' �

[sso �@�Q �[ssV ��a��. �V`oh �� # � ��D� �F�?'��� �V��� .(����� ��� ��� S��)'���a1 �,#"� �� %/�K4 ��c," X�/ � ����� X�/ �� �)#5,: ��/W*��� � �

%/�K4 ���$ S��)' � ����x)'� gD< �� �J�� ��/���� �� �/ .%/�K4 S��)' gD<� �a��. �*�6)V`oh (%'�� � "�: �� ���� X��iA @��?1 �?. �c$�)" Bc�" @���"�

@��� X�/ �x' �� @��)<� �� Y$� ������ X�/ �x' �� @��54 � ����W� ����� �'��� ��1� U2�&" =,: .%/�K4 ��@��� X�/ @���" �*�6 X��iA ��1R� ����

�, " ���a1 I/ @�'� � @���" ����� X�/ �# � �'�� ���� � ���� �"�#' Y$� .��Y #�� X�/ F�?'��� � i#9�� ��)' S��)' � �5�/ i#' �'����A)[sso (�54 @�'��:�'

��1� @��)<� �� �1R� �� @�.��< �'�� ���� ��, .@�#" X�/ �� �2� gD<� ����%'�� �*�6 %/�K4 S��)' �� �1R� �� @�.��< @��)<� �#Q �� ����,/�� ���� @���"�

��1� @��54 �'�� ���� ��,)�@�Q[ssV .(�, " ���a1 �*�6 %/�K4 �� �� �,Q�/ ����

2- Arteche 1- Keser 3- Swami

Page 112: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

112

�'� X�/ �� @���" � @�'� ��/����� �#W� ���,: Y$��"� �� �� @�.��< @���" ���1� @�'� �� �1R� X�/ k�' ��� �'�� ���� ��, .���� %/�K4 ���� �� >�6 ���a1 �/ ��/�, " X�/ k�' ��� �� �)#5,: Y$� ���' X��iA ��� .�" �x' � �� �J,/�� ;"��� �$�

X�/ ����� �,.� ��lA�#|t1 �'�A�,Q ��/ .

���a1 �#5a1 �� �)#5,: ��/X�/ �� I?" �)C' �,Q � Y$� F�R �'�A�,Q ��/��. �:�1 :���� B���1 �� �C,�� Y5&' � ���� ��:� �.�]�/ �)#5,: ���A �� ��/

���a1 �R�� " �" X��iA �#J'�#" ;C. � �/��A ��/ �)aA �� �"�J,/ �����, ���.�" ��1� @�'� �� �1R� �"D� X�/ �x' �� �� @�.��< @���" ��. ,�" �� �,,� .@�A�,'��<

�+&. ��/����� �� �,.� �).�� �� y��,)$� ��� Y$� �C�" ��/ �� �1R� @���" ��/�" @�'� �.� .�2�6�� �(#)' ��� �� Y5#' Y$�� ��#A .���l4�##{1 �� Y$� ��� Y# 3��

B���1 � ���� ��:� ���A �/ �� ���� � ���A �� ��/;�3 ��� �x6D" �� �.�]�/ ���'� .���a1 �� Y$� ��� �J�� �)C' �1��a1 �, � ��,�� �##{1 @�"� >�� �� Y$� �C�" �/

Y$� �C�"`s�� �.� �).��' ��:� �1��a1 �#,Q ���"� �"� ��.� ��. Y�| %#4 >�$ ����a1 ��#J��Q ��� �'�. �)�� �/ .���a1 ��� �� Y$� @� �� ���6 �/��. ��/

" �##{1 @�"� >�� �� �/��A��,��)�@�A�/[ss`.(

S��)' � �*�6 %/�K4 S��)' �� ��& �'��&�/�' � ����{" ;�R� �� �C�%/�K4 ����'� ��i� �� �.� ;#2� ��� � Y$� �C�" � �3 ��/ �� ���a)$� ���" ��#A

%/�K4 ��� ��' @�5C� �/ �.� .%/�K4 G w� �� �� ���D�� ������A ��� � �3 ��/ ��(,? �,!,"X�/ ����� ��� �� �"�,�$�4 �� �*�6 %/�K4 �� �2� �'�A�,Q ��/

�:�� -�#�" k�' �" ��?,�#4 �����, �Y$� ��. ���a)$� ��, %/�K4 �� ��. ��/ ������A �"�,�$�4 Z��� �� �#,��/ � ��(,? �,!," Z��� �� I/ ���D�� ��

���� � ��. � ��/ � ���" U )&" X�� �� �� ��"� Y$���#A ���3 �5���" � �$� .

@��J�/�K4 �� �<�)�� # � ��D� �F�?'��� >��" ���V��� (�" @�# i#' �,,��, " S��)' ��� �� ���a1 �,#"� �� ��� ��2�3 ��/�J2� �J'�# @���" Ba' � �)#5,: ��/

Page 113: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

113

%�' ����� � "�: �" �)#5,: ��/ �.� .��� �� �" ��?,�#4 �� %/�K4 �� ��. ��/ �� X�/ ����� �� �)#5,: ��2�3 ��/�J2� %�' ��#A ���3 �$�� ���" �'�A�,Q ��/.

���a1 �� Y�!7 ����� ��� ��,p�c" ���'��1 �� �)#5,: ��/ k�*�" �� U )&" ��/�! � I?" �#"� �-D� ��'�< �� ����� �+&. ��(1 �R�� " �?'� � Y$� i#J'� ���

Y# 3�" ��,#"� �� ���� ��/���a1 ��'��� �K�� ��/��� )$� �� X�/ �� �)#5,: ��/Y?: Y$� �)? �����,4 �S��)' I#� 1 Y# �3 %��i�� K%/� ����� ��� � �?��" ��/

��i ���A @���(�'�� � @�'��:�' �>�$ ��J�'�� � �/ ��. F�('� �J�� ��/ .�)? �#,��/��6�+" � �a#� �� 2�c" Y$� Y����" � Z#�� ��/ @���' �&�" Y?: @�A�,,�

��/����� �� �/��� ��� ���lA�#|t1 ��!' �#,��/ � X�/ ����� ����� ��/�����#A F�('� X�/ �� ����� �+&. .

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :Ve/sj/V`�V �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :Vh/Vs/V`�V �2��" X��l4 r���1:so/sV/V`�[

Page 114: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

114

q���� References

���� ����*�) .V`�s .(B� �,��U( 3�� ������# ����G ������ � ����� ���#� #�3��( ���( �Q ��B� ���O� ����� ]�6$�� ��(��� �� � "(3�� ��3#S��� � ��"�O, �� 4�:���3 ��������3 �#

��� [�" ���/�K4 X��iA .�3�. @�(����� @�)$� ��' F�#4 ��J�'��.

� � �U#$ ����) .V`oh .(�#"(3�� 43���#� � ���#� ��� :B�� � P � C� / ���@��?1 :@����.

� � �U#$ ����) .V`oj .(���� �,��# ��������� :B)��� � �#"(3�� ���������)C�, ��#��(�@��?1 :@����.

��a��. �56 �.�4.)����.(� 2�c" �1�"��" ���x' X�/ �'�A�,Q �'���A �� �,#"� k�*�" ��/ �$�� ����A��$ %'�� @���"��������� ������ �� �,)���������W��.

Beloff, H. (1992). Mother, Father and Me: Our IQ. The Psychologist, 5, 309-311.

Bennett, M. (1996). Men’s and Women’s Self-estimates of Intelligences,Journal of Social Psychology, 136, 411-412.

Byrd, M., & Stacey, B. (1993). Bias in IQ Perception. The Psychologist, 6,16.

Chamorro- Premuzic, T., Furnham, A., & Moutafi, T. (2004). The Relationship between Estimated and Psychometric Personality and Intelligence Scores, Journal of Research in Personality, 38, 505-513.

Chan, D.W. (2001). Assessing Giftedness of Chinese Secondary Students in Hong Kong: A Multiple Intelligences Perspective, High Ability Studies, 12, 215-234.

Deary, I. (2001). Intelligence: A Very Short Introduction, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Dweck, C. (2000). Self-theories: Their Role in Motivation, Personality, and Development, Philadelphia, PA: Psychology Press.

Furnham, A., & Gasson, L. (1998). Sex Differences in Parental Estimates of Their Children’s Intelligence, Sex Roles, 38, 151-162.

Furnham, A., & Mottabu, R. (2004). Sex and Culture Differences in the Estimates of General and Multiple Intelligence: A Study Comparing

Page 115: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

115

British and Egyptian Students, Individual Differences Research, 2, 82-96.

Furnham, A., & Rawles, R. (1995). Sex Differences in the Estimation of Intelligence, Journal of Social Behaviour and Personality, 10, 741-745.

Furnham, A., & Rawles, R. (1999). Correlations between Self-estimates and Psychometrically Measured IQ, Journal of Social Psychology, 139, 405-410.

Furnham, A., Clark, K., & Bailey, K. (1999). Sex Differences in Estimates of Multiple Intelligences, European Journal of Personality,13, 247-259.

Furnham, A., Keser, A., Arteche, A., Chamorro-Premuzic, T., & Swami, V. (2009). Self and Other-estimates of Multiple Abilities in Britain and Turkey: A Cross-cultural Comparison of Subjective Ratings of Intelligence. International Journal of Psychology, 44, 434-442.

Furnham, A., Reeves, E., & Budhani, S. (2002). Parents Think Their Sons Are Brighter Than Their Daughters: Sex Differences in Parental Self-Estimations and Estimations of Their Children's Multiple Intelligences, The Journal of Genetic Psychology: Research and Theory on Human Development, 163, 24-39.

Gardner, H. (1983). Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences, New York: Basic Books.

Gardner, H. (1999). Intelligence Reframed, New York: Basic Books.

Halpern, D. (1992). Sex Differences in Cognitive Abilities, 2nd edn, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ.

Hogan, H. (1978). IQ Self-estimates of Males and Females, Journal of Social Psychology, 106, 137-138.

Hogan, T. P. (2003). Psychological Testing: A Practical Introduction, New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Lippa, R. (1994). Introduction to Social Psychology, Brooks-Cole, Pacific Grove, CA.

Lynn, R. (1994). Sex Differences in Intelligence and Brain Size, Personality and Individual Differences, 17, 257-271.

Mackintosh, N. (1998). IQ and Human Intelligence, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Page 116: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

116

Neto, F., Ruiz, F., & Furnham, A. (2008). Sex Differences in Self-Estimation of Multiple Intelligences among Portuguese Adolescents, High Ability Studies, 19, 189-204.

Reilly, J. & Mulhern, G. (1995). Gender Difference in Self-estimated Intelligence: The Need for Care in Interpreting Group Data, Personality and Individual Differences, 18, 189-192.

Shearer, B. (1999). Multiple Intelligences Developmental Scales: Multiple Intelligences Research and Consulting, Retrived February 02 from http//:www.angelfire.com

Smith, M.K. (2002) Howard Gardner, Multiple Intelligences and Education,Retrieved online 06/01/2009 at: http://www.infed.org/thinkers/gardner.htm.

Swim, J. (1994). Perceived Versus Meta-analytic Effect Sizes: An Assessment of the Accuracy of Gender Stereotypes, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 66, 21-36.

Teele, S. (2000). Rainbows of Intelligence: Exploring How Students Learn, California Corwin Press, INC.

Woolfolk, A.E. (2004). EducationalPsychology, (9th Ed.). Pearson, International Edition.

Yeşil, R., Korkmaz, Ö. (2010). Reliability and Validity Analysis of the Multiple Intelligence Perception Scale, Education, 131(1). 8- 32.

Page 117: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

117

���2� C;� 1� )A�& ���($�6�� $( )-�=J ��� $( � �0K ������;4� �( �.��J

�T�_� #6'�z

43�) %K� ��G{

�#�� 3��P�3��|

1"G�%�� 1"�� �� �

4 "SQ ���a1 �5���" �*�6 %/�K4 g�/ �� �)#5,: ��/ X�/ �� �+&. ��/����� �� �'�A�,Q ��/

�� @���(�'�� � "�: .��� 1 ��x," ���[jo �a' )Voh � @� oh��" (�'�5'� F� � @���(�'�� �� �'��' X�� �� ���a)$� � i���1 i��" ��' F�#4 ��J�'�� ��#A���� �.�< � �� � 6�"�,Q �� � ��

�'�. �&)'� ����+1 ��#. �1 �. �)$��< �'��' ���A @���(�'�� �� ���D�� ������A ��� ��"�,�$�4X�/ ;"�. �� �'�A�,Q ��/o���< ��c," ��"D� �� �'�� X�/ -�#�"W��*���

�'� �����#$�" ������ W@��� ����,: @�#" ����� Y #�� � ���� �,,� ;#�C1 ��� �'����A .���� ='������� ��#{)"�,Q ;# !1 X�� �� ���a)$� � �/)MANCOVA ( ���3 ;# !1 ���"

�,)��A .���a1 ��$ �|� ���"� >�),� �� =4 �� ��� @��' S��)' �, " ��/ ����� �# ���� ��/�"D� �� �'�� X�/ �� ��" � @� @���(�'�� �+&.�X�/ �'�W����,: /X�@�#" �����

X�/ @��� ���� �X�/ Y #�� �'����A Y.�� ��:�.���' �#J'�#" �� ��" @���(�'�� ��/���< ��� �"��1 -�#�" �� @� @���(�'�� �)�# �/ .���" �*�6 %/�K4 S��)' �2��" ��� ��Y��A ���3 �! .� "�H ��(h��:X�/ ���a1 ��'�A�,Q ��/ @���(�'�� ��)#5,: ��/.

1N@�(����� ��' F�#4 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� ���A ��#�'�� �3�.)>�p5" ��,5��'(Email: [email protected] [email protected]

2N��A �����)$� ��' F�#4 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� �@�(������3�. 3N@�(����� �'�" �#?. ��J�'�� ��#�'�� 4Ni���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� ���A �����)$�

Page 118: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

118

� 2� �

���a1 k�*�" ���'��1 �� �)#5,: ��/ �/� ��,#"� �� ��< ��� k�*�" �� X�/�! ��)�5' G6�7 �# �� i#J'� Y$� ��'�" �3� ���� ����� �#,��/ � @��x')�����

�}}�X�),#C" ��������#2 �������I���$ ������� .(�,/�� �)�# �� F��" �/���a1 ��� � �7�< �3D� �'��� �/)@�A�/���}}� (� � ��,#�#4 ;# !1��� Iw�

��/�K4 )@�]2�/�������]#2 �������(���a1 �,#"� �� ;"�� Z���1 �� �)#5,: ��/���'��1 �� � � X�/����' ��:� ��< ��/ .

�/� >�� �� %/�K4 �).lA ��/ ��/���a1 ���� )" ��/����� �� �)#5,: ��/ @��J�� � @�.��< X�/ �� ��������� ���3 �$�� ���" �� �'� .@�A�/ >��" ���)���� (

��J�'�� @���(�'�� �?'� ��/ �� �� �� ���a)" � 2�c" ����� Y����" �C��"� ��/�).�� Y$� ���� X��iA �� �'� .Y����" �� �� 2�c" ��� �� �1 �� ��. �)$��< @�A�,,�

'� X�/ � @���" X�/ ����2�� X�/ �#,��/ � @�.��< X�/� �� @� � � ���7�,,� ����� .�)�� �� @�.��< X�/ ����' @���" � �5���" �� @�'� �� ��� @��' S��)'

�" ����� �6 �� �,,�)���}%�, " S��)' ����" �� ��� (�� �,).�� ��� ��/ ������1 �Y$� @�.���" X�/ �� �1R� @�.��4 X�/ .g� �)���� (� �?��" %/�K4 i#'

���Y��� Y$� �?��" S��)' � � ��� F�('� ��, 1�C$� @���(�'�� .��� �� @���"�� �,).�� ��� %/�K4 @�'� �� �1R� ��# " g��!'� I#' ���6 �� �?'� �.�/ ���'

�" �.� .@���" � �@�.���" � ��� �� @�.��< @�'� ���. ����� X�/ -�$� ��" @�.��4 � ��� �� @�.��< �'��� .@���" � @�.��4 �� �)�� �� @�.��< X�/ @�'�

�" ��+1 @�.���" �� �)�# �� @�.��< X�/ �'��� .��#��$�)$� ��})���� (���"N'�� � "�: �� �� � 2�cN' @���(�N. �)$��< �?'� �� �� ��,2��#N/ �1 �� ��N����� X�

2- Mackintosh 4- Swim 6- Halpern 8- Beloff 10- Stacey

1- Deary 3- Lynn 5- Hogan 7- Lippa 9- Byrd

Page 119: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

119

�'��� ���C1 ��,,� ����� �� @�.��< �#,��/ � �/��< .g� S��)' i#' %/�K4 ��� �� )���� (�" �)��A �x' �� @���4 �� �)�� �.�/ �x' �� @����" @� �� �� �. ���C1 ��'�. .

�" �C� @���" �/��< �� ��1R� X�/ �?'� �� �'����'��� @��'� .�2�6�� ��� @�'� �� �.�/ ����' �� �?'� ����� � ��,)5/ ��� �.�/ ��!2 �� @�.�/��< � �?'� �� �,).��

�� @�.�/��< � ���� ����" �� �1R� @�.��4 .� F�?'��� i2����)���� (�� i#'Y����" .��< X�/ �1 Y$��< @�)5 J'� �� � {. ���A S,4 ��" � @� @�A�,,� �@�

��1� �� @��A�i���" � ��i��4 ����2�� �,,� ��, .�� �)�# �� @�.��< X�/ @���" @�'�)��� ��� �� ��� (@�.���" �� �)�# �� @�.��4 X�/ =,: �� �/ �)��� �� ����}� (��1� �'�� ���� ��, .g� S��)' �#�t1 ��)���� (�$�)$� � ��# �)���� (

�4 �?��" ��� ���i� ��1R� �.�/ ��/����� �/)�}� (���" � �5���" �� ��i �/)��(�'�� ���� Y����� .�#�t1 X�/ �$�,�'��� �� 2�c" �,#�#4 �� Y# 3�� ��� Iw�# �

�" ���a1 �� �,� ���a1 �C,�� �� ����' ��:� � � X�/ �� �)#5,: ��/ ��'� � #< �/Y$� .���� ��1� ��� @���(�'�� >�6�" @��' �� @���" X�/ �,/� .Y,�)���� (i#'

���a1 ��� �#�t1 �� �#2�� �)#5,: ��/ .� X�/ �+&. ����� S��)'��� ��(�'�� Y����" ����� �� �� @� �� ���6 ��, 1�C$� ='�5#2 ���� X�/ �� ��" @�A�,,�

� @�.��<�, " ��� �" @�'� �� �1R� ���� �.�)�/��� ��� �� �/�}� .( ���A ;���1� @�.���" �� �1R� �� @�.��4 X�/ �#,��/ �'�� ���� ��,)��� ��� ��

�/��} .(���� @�#" X�/ �1 �. �)$��< %/�K4 ��� �� �� �"�J,/ >�6 @�.��< ������1� �� �" �C� @���(�'�� ��,,� ��, @�#" X�/ @�.���" �� �'��� �� ��1R� ����

�.��4 � �5���" �'��� @)}�/��� ��� �� ��/�}� .( � F�?'��� �J�� � 2�c" �� ��@�5#A�)���� (�������i ��� �� @��'����� � @�.��< X�/ �1 �,)$��< >�$

� ��1� @�.��< ���2�� X�/ ��: �,,� ��, .�� � �3 �� 2�c" � �)$�� I/ S��)' .����N#' � 2�c" �Ni@���" /NX�.��<N@�R� ����1� @�'� �� �1 N�'�� ���� ��,)�}� ��

2- Bennett 1- Rawles 3- Gasson

Page 120: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

120

����}� .(�)<� @����� �� �1R� �� �54 @����� X�/ @�'� I/ � @���" I/ �#,��/ ��1� �'�� ���� ��,)�}� ��� �� �}� .( X�/ �+&. ����� �� 2�c" �� �<� S��)'

>��: ���� ��. �7D< Y$.@��/ >��: �� �� �����" ��/��" ��/����� ��/ ��. � X�/ �R� @����� � @����� �@��/��< �@���4 ��� �#,��/ � ��< ��� �K��

Y$� �#J'�#" .Y����" ��/ �� ���< ��� � ����' ��:� �����1 S��)' ��� �� @�A�,,� �� 2�c" ��� ��)��@�5#A � F�?'��� � 2�c" i:���� (>��)6� � �� �'�� @���(�'��

�" �#J'�#" �R� �?'� X�/ ���� �.� .>��:��@��' �� Y# 3�� ��� �*�� ����" ��1� �#J'�#" �� �/� ��1� �#J'�#" � @�'� �#,��/ � @���" �+&. ��, ��,

���i' @�.��4 X�/ @�.���" �1 Y$� �1.7� P)z(��3���#� 9�&<�.� )� ��#� x���� �":��"� �#�� �;��2� !fP B� ��O, �

�&<�.� ���) ��3#� 9��*$ g� )���� (�, 1�C$� )�}�=N()���=N(

��< �/��} �/��� �/����" �/��� �/��� �/�W��4 �/��� �/��� �/�W

�$�)$� � ��#)���� (�, ���#' )�}�=N()���=N(��< �/��� �/��� �/}W���" �/��� �/�}� �W��4 �/��� �/��� �/�W

�/��< �/��� �/��} �/�W���� �/��� ��� �/�

Y,)���� (�, 1�C$� )��=N()��=N(��< �/�}� �/��� �/�

@�?2�" � � ��)���� (�,2��� )�}=N()��=N(��< �/�}� �/��� �/�

����'� ��. ��#A �/�}� �/�}� �/}Wi2��� � F�?'���)���� ( J'�@�)5 )���=N()��=N(

Page 121: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

121

��< ��/��� ��/��� ��/����" �/�}� ��/�}� ��/}��4 ��/��� }�/��� ��/�

@�5#A � F�?'���)���� (@�)5 J'� )���=N()��=N(��< ��/�}�

)��=N(��/�}�

)��=N(��/�

�54 @����� ��/�}� �}/�}� }�/��)<� @����� ��/�}� ��/�}� ��/}W

F�?'��� i2��� �)���� (@�)5 J'� )��}=N()��=N(��< ��/��� �}/��} �/�

����'� ��. ��#A ��/���/��'�/�� � ���� �F�?'���)[ss[ (@�)5 J'� )��=N()��=N(��< ��/�}� ��/��} ��/�

�54 ���� }�/��� ��/��� ��/�W�)<� ���� ��/��} ��/�}� ��/�W

" �� � �3 �� 2�c" ��Y���� �� @�.��< � � X�/ �1 �� ��. �)$��< @�A�,,��,,� ����� .>�$ �� �� 2�c" ��� X�/ �+&. ��/����� �$�� � �#<� ��/ ��/

�'�A�,Q)�'���A������ ����� (Y$� �)��� X�)5A .�)' �>��" ����i#9�� ��F�?'��� �)�}}� (���a1 X�/ �� �+&. ����� �� �)#5,: ��/ Q ��/ @�'��:�' �# �� �� �'�A�,

�'��� �$�� �2�{1�4 .���#*��� �� � X�/ �� �54 @�'��:�' �� ��� @��' �?'� S��)'@�#" ������ Y #�� � �'�6�� ����� ��1� @��)<� �� �1R� �� @�.��< �'����A ��,

�" �,,� .��1�" � F�?'����)�}}� (�' ��+" � �5# J'� @���(�'�� � "�: �� i#' @�X�/ � @�.��< � � X�/ �1 �'��� ;���1 @���" �� �'��� g�/ ��"D� ��/ ��,�iA

�,,� ����� @�'� �� �1R� �� �C#'�C" ���'��1 � ��C)� ����� .@�Qe)�}}� (� "�: ��%'�� /�� ���� @���"�N)' ��� � �#Q �� ����,N1 �� Y��� Y$� �(#N���a �)#5,: ��/

2- Neto 4- Mottabu

1- Gardner 3- Ruiz 5- Chan

Page 122: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

122

��c," X�/ ��W@�#" � �*��� ���� ��:� ���� .�� �� @�.��< @��54 %/�K4 ��� ����c," X�/W�2�6�� �@��)<� �� �1R� �*��� X�/ �� �� @�.��< @��)<� ��

@�#" ��1� @��54 �� �1R� ���� �'�� ���� ��, .%'�� � "�: �� �c$�)" ���� @���"� �a��. i#' �'����)���� (@��� X�/ �x' �� @��)<� �� Y$� ���� X��iA � ����

������ X�/ �x' �� @��54 � �'��� ��1� @��54W�'��� ��1� @��)<� � ����� .��X�/ �J�� k��'� ��!2 �� %/�K4 ��� �, " ���a1 =,: �� @�#" �/ ���' ��/��" ����

Y$� .��D� �F�?'����� # ��)���� (��i � "�: �� i#' �� �,)��� �5# J'� @R�$��c," X�/ �, � X�/ U )&" k��'� �� �C� �� �?,1W�, " ���a1 �*��� �� ����

���� ��:� @�'� � @���" ��/����� �# .X�/ �� �� �,).�� ��� @���" %/�K4 ��� ����c,"W�'�����<� @�'� � �5���" �� ��1R� �*��� .

%/�K4 ���a1 � y��" ��/ �,!," �� Y$� @� �� ���6 i#' X�/ �,#"� �� �,$ ��/ �� ������1 �.����" >�) " =]$ ����� ��,1 � #< G#. Y5&' >�$ � �2� ��.

���6 �1 ��< %��i���}�" �"��� �J2�$ �2��6 �� �C,�� �1 ��/��}Y�� ��Q� �J2�$ �" ��. .J��Q ��#5 Y�� ��' @���� @� ����i �<��� �� Y�� ��� � Y$� �# �2�$

� ��)�# ��.�" ��< ��#A .I?" %/�� ����� �)C' ���1 ��i �<��� �� �/ ��2�$��' ���'��1 ��� %/�� ���a)" ��/ @�"�� �� �/ Y$� ��< ��/ .@�"�� �#x' ���/

�" @��' ��)�� %/�� ���D�� � @�A£�� �,/� .@�"�� ��1�� �x��6 ��/ � ��" ���'��1� ������ � ����� �" %/�� Y��$ �,��)�@�A�/�}}� .(%/�K4 �#,��/ @��' �/

X�/ ��/����� �� �'��� ���a)" @�A�'�#A��� � #+!1 ���4 -�$� � �'�A�,Q ��/�" �.�);#1���}}}��#. ������� .(X�/ U )&" k��'� ���##{1 �C,�� � �:�1 � �� �/

Y$� �C�" U )&" �#,$X�/ ��/���� � 1 ����� �� �'�A�,Q ��/t�#| ����� ����lJ ��I/ �#{)" @��,� � @���(�'�� �$ �*�6 %/�K4 �� �/��< ;# !1 ���� �C�� �� �##{1

��. >�),� �� gl6 ���"� ���7 � @� �|� �1 �. .

2- Bailey 4- Shearer

1- Clark 3- Teele

Page 123: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

123

�" ��/�K4 �,#�#4 � �:�1 �1���a1 �$�� �� YaA @�� ��/����� �� �)#5,: ��/X�/ � � � X�/ ���" �� �+&. �3D� ���" � I?" k�*�" �� �'�A�,Q ��/

�" U )&" ��/���� @��J�/�K4 �.� .��� � ���. %/�K4 �� ���6 ��� Y#�/� ;#2����x' � �/��� �� Y$� ���< �,�* ��/����� � ���)�� ��/�"�#4 X�/ ����� �.i#J'�

�'��� ��?")�9�����}}} .(�" X�/ �+&. ��/����� ���� � @�i�� ���|� �'��1F����< �� �� %&N.� �).�� ��C �� � �cN�,)���"�Q-­4������#"�'��� �NF�?�����1�"���}}� .(���a1 Y#�/� � �:�1 � �+&. ��/����� �� �)#5,: ��/X�/ Y��,� � � �'�A�,Q ��/ @���(�'�� � "�: �� @�,��1 ��/�K4 �#,Q �C,�� �

X�/ ��/����� �1 Y$� @� � �*�6 %/�K4 �����, �Y$� ���' F�('� �'���� ��/�,� � 2�c" @���(�'�� � "�: �� �� ��" � @� @���(�'�� �'�A�,Q .���� g�/ �&�"

�" >��$ ��� r$�4 � ��#)$� �*�6 %/�K4 �� �# ��� �� �.�@���(�' �� ��" � @� u�c" X�/ k�' Y�/ ��"D� �� �'�� X�/ �, � �'���A ���x' �� ��.��c,"W

�'� �����#$�" ������ ��*���W@��� ����,: @�#" ����� Y #�� � ���� �'����A �� =4 �, " ���a1 �$ �|� ���"� >�),� ��' �� ���� ��:� ����

B��

�'��' X�� � ���"� �'��' �� "�: ���#A ��� 1 %/�K4 ��� ��[jo �a' )��� � @� ����" (@���(�'�� � �: �� i���1 i��" ��' F�#4 ��J�'�� �'�5'� F� � @���(�'�� ��

�).� %#4 X��"� ��5# J'� @�� ��$�,�'��� ��/ ��#�� ������" ��'�)5� � �'�)5��"�'� � Y����" �����):� F� � ��$��� ����" � �.��"� �i�� >�$ �� �'�A��� Y

� #+!1�}W���� �,)��A ���3 � 2�c" ���" )�'��' ���A �,$ �#J'�#"[[� >�$ h��# " g��!'� � � ��"[o/e.(�'��' X�� �� ���"� �'��' �&)'� ��� ���� ��#A � ��

�.�< � 6�"�,Q �� �. ���a)$� ����+1 ®�#. � ��.

2- Chamorro-Premuzic 4- Moutafi

1- Dweck 3- Furnham

Page 124: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

124

�� ��U�� %/�K4 ��� ��B�: ��� ���D�� ���� ��X�/ �.��iA ��< �"�,�$�4 �'�A�,Q ��/

�. ���a)$� .�"�,�$�4 ���Vh`b$�1 �2�z$ ;#�� �������� ��)�}�}(%(,$ ��� Y$� ��. �#?1 �'���A ���?,�#4 X�/ k�' Y�/.���' ��� �"�,�$�4 ��� �� ���lA

S,4 -�#�" �� �R�z$ r$�4 �:�� �. ���a)$� ��)��#�/=��R�� " �=���)�5' �=��� �Y3� �/=�� ����'=�.(������� � ;#�� �� Y$� ��� � F�R)�}�} (��C��� ��

X�/ �.��iA ��< -�#�" � $�1 ��� ���"� � ��c," ���� ���a)$� �'�A�,Q ��/�'�� .��� $� � ��)� �� ���7G6�7 �x' �� ���a) -�#�" ����)!" ����� @��x' �� �/

;# !1 ���:� �� � � ���� �$�� � -�#�" � $�1 ��� �� ���"� ��/ �'�� ������ .���*�)���} (-�#�" ��� � "�� ;# !1 �� �"�,�$�4 ��� U )&" ��/ .��� �(#)' �� ;# !1���#��4 � "�� �� ;#2� � >��$ �� �1�/}/ ���� � ��)�" � "�� �� �#,��

�'�. gl6 ;"�� �� �� %# .>�z$ ��� 1 �'��� �'�5�/ X�� �� ;7�6 S��)' � �/)���'��� ��a2� G���* (���< �� F��� �/ ���"�� �� �-�#�" >��: �� �/����� @��'

Y$� ��. .���< Y�/ ��� �� �� �/ X�/ -�#�" �"��� �� �'���A �'�A�,Q ��/� ��7 Y$� ��. ���� �#*�1 �+)&" �)�������� � ;#���}�} ��'���A ����� �

Y#�$����}}� �U#$ ����� ������2�a2�� ����}}�:(

�"D� �� �'�� X�/ :�� ���)aA @�� � Y#$�56 ;"�. �"D� �� �'�� X�/@�� ��#A��� ���'��1 ����).�' @�� �� ���a)$� � ��� � G2�3 �� @�#���'� ��/����

g��/� � ��#)$� Y?: @�'� �7��" ��� � @��J�� � ��< �7��" @�'��?� ��� �|�"�" ��< �.� .�"�'��� �@�A�,5��' �� �,)5/ �'�5� �# �� @���,&$ � �� . �@���J'

�" �C� �'���A �'��� ��R� �"D� X�/ �,� .

," X�/N��cW�*��� :," X�/N��cW. �*��� N�� ���'��1 ;"� � Y � >�7� �

2- Korkmaz 4- Woolfolk

1- Yesil 3- Smith

Page 125: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

125

� �DC�" � ;9�5" ;# !1 ���'��1 � Y#��� ��2� " >R�)$� ���'��1 ���c," ���7 �" �*��� ��# �� F�('� ��*��� � ��� �.� .������ ��c," X�/ ��J��W� �*���

a1 � �����)$� >R�)$� ��/�J2� �#&�1 ���'��1�" ���.� ��c," �C �,� .X�/ k�' ����" ����1 �*��� � �� � �Ca1 � G w� ��. .

���#�#$�" X�/ :��� ��#$�" �,/� X����4 ���'��1 ;"�. ���#�#$�" X�/� ���'��1 �#,��/ � �/�J2� ���$�,.Y$� �)6 � �/�J2� ��� @��]$ ���< � ����

��' � @����� �� ���?" ��/�J2� ��� >�),�0�� � ���#�#$�" ��/�J2� �$�� ����lA�" ��#$�" �.� .X�/ � ����" ���)<�$ G w� ���#�#$�" X�/ �'���A �x' -�$� �

���� �'�� �� �"D� .

�'� X�/W���,: :�'� X�/W����6 �� �'��/�" ���a)$� ���'��1 ;"�. ���,: � �)�53 �� ���a)$� ���'��1 ��#.� � @��� ��� � @�5" �� ;6 ��� @� �"��1 �t�� �2

�" ������� �� �#2�1 �.� .

����� X�/ :��,: ����'�� ���'��1 ;"�. ����� X�/ �/� �� �#'� ����� ��/ � �,/� ��� � ������ ¢�#.� �##{1 � I5(1 � ��"� ��#9i: �#&�1 ���'��1 ���<

�$ �Ca1 ���'��1 �#,��/ �" �� �.� .

@�#" X�/ ���� :/@�#" X� �i#J'� ��/�+3 ��� ���'��1 � ���� �D���1 � �/�" ���.� �?'� � %&�|� ;"� 1 � @��J�� �,� .�Q �?'� �C,�� �, � �J�� ��&.� ���

�" ��� �" ���3� �c�� @��J�� � �#'� � �'�JQ ��,/� F�('� �,'��1 �2��)6� %,��� ��,,��� ��'��� Y$�� �� �i#Q �Q �Y5#Q �?'��" �,):� �i#Q �Q �'��� �$�56� �Q � �,,� .

�" @�C"� X�/ k�' ��� � ����� �1 �/��,,� ��� @��J�� � ��|�" ��� .@�#�"@�#" X�/ �J�/ @�����" � @�����)$�#$ �@�#'�6�� �@�A�,.��� ��#' �� ��R� ����

�'��� .

Page 126: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

126

@��� X�/ ���� :@��� X�/ �� @�. ��A� ���'��1 ;"�. ����-�56� �i#J'� ��/ �/�" �A�'� %&�|� Y���/ � ��< >�#"� ��.�)���'��1 ��#)5/ �5� �Q �C,�� �)5'�� �/

�'��1�' �g�/ � �/���� �Y5#Q �� ��. ��/ F��� @�)��/ �Q �� ������ �$�56� �Q ��'��" �,):� �i#Q �" @��' %,��� �'�JQ U )&" b���. �� � ��#,� �#/� .(

Y #�� X�/ �'����A :Y #�� X�/ �/��" ���'��1 ;"�. �'����A�� Y #�� �� �/�J2� F�x' ��� ;9�3 i#�1 ��� �� @��" ��#'� � � #�� ��/ ��'��#w � ��'� ����:�" �# @�.

�)<�$ ��#.� ��)$� � @�5'� Y$� ��. �" �?'� @��� ��, �.� .

7� P)0(43#� ��#� ����)�)�� ����� � �*<� F��#_ �-�"2 B� ������# �� ���( �Q ��

43#� -�"2� �7��� 3� &$ ��*<� F�#_ ����)� )�� ����� �'�� �� �"D� X�/ Vhoo/smm/s

��c," X�/W�*��� [V�e/so�/s���#�#$�" X�/ Ve�V/smo/s

�'� X�/W���,: ��s/soj/s����� X�/ Vm�h/sm`/s

@�#" X�/ ���� Vjom/sjo/s@��� X�/ ���� Vm�V/so`/sY #�� X�/ �'����A Vo�`/so[/s

����� �

���� ���"� ;# !1 ��� ���a1 � y��" ��/���< ����' �� �)#5,: ��/ -�#�" ��/X�/ �.��iA��< �"�,�$�4 ;# !1 ��'�A�,Q ��/�� ��#{)"�,Q='�����)MANCOVA (

�. ��:� .�� �� @�,#��� �� =4�*��a" �� �c&1 F�@�"�� ��� ��/���< ����' -�#�" ��/ U )&"�� �$ � �)5�� ��/�#{)" @��,� I/ �#{)" @��,� ;# !1 ���� �C�� �� �##{1

�..>��: `@�"�� S��)' �" @��' �� ��#{)"�,Q ��/ �/�.

Page 127: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

127

7� P)?(x�������)� �� �#"+�� �Q43#� -�"2� �,��U(3�� ������# ��B��� ���( �Q!";�P -��� #�

#@� ���)� [�� B)�� �� 2�Fd.f �#�

4 , d.f �.�

~.� ��&����3

��$� ������S"S*$

�$ ��D#4 �|� VVh/sVes/ho[eo sssV/sVVh/siC �� ����"R ooj/sVes/ho[eo sssV/sVVh/s

�,# )/ �|� V[�/sVes/ho[eo sssV/sVVh/s��i��1��� ����� V[�/sVes/ho[eo sssV/sVVh/s

Y#5,: ��D#4 �|� Voo/shem/mo[eo sssV/sVoo/siC �� ����"R oV[/shem/mo[eo sssV/sVoo/s

�,# )/ �|� [`V/shem/mo[eo sssV/sVoo/s��i��� ���1���� [`V/shem/mo[eo sssV/sVoo/s

>��: �� �� ��c'��/��" ��/��" �, " ���a1 ��. � @� @���(�'�� �# �������' ;�� 1 �� =4 ��" ���< �� �$ ��/ -�#�" X�/ �.��iA ��< �"�,�$�4 ��/ ��/

���� ��:� �'�A�,Q)���/}=λ�iC �� ����"R ���/�=)�����(F�}}}�/}P< .( �"��� ���� ='����� ;# !1 ����)ANOVA(� �)5�� �#{)" �/ � ­� #�E1 @�"�� @��,�

�,Q ='������� ;# !1 �. F�('� ��#{)" .>��:�@�"�� S��)' �1 ��/ ;# !1 ��#{)"���< �� �� ='����� -�#�" X�/ �.��iA ��< �"�,�$�4 ��/ �" @��' �'�A�,Q ��/ �/�.

7� P)I(x���� 1o�a )� ���)� �� F9��*$ ���#� ��#� ;�P �� �3 ��"43#� -�"2� B� ������# �� ���( �Q ��

���, ����� �� 9�#""+$ q����

��%�� 9������)SS(d.f

�":��"� 9������)MS(F

~.���&� ���3

��$� ������S"S*$

�"D� �� �'�� X�/hoj/emVhoj/emmVh/s`��/sss`/s�$ ��c," X�/ W�*��� m[o/jee Vm[o/jee hme/[VVm/sss�/s

���#�#$�" X�/ j�j/Vj[h Vj�j/Vj[h sVj/Vsss[/ss`j/s�'� X�/ W���,: Vjj/ehj VVjj/ehj �jj/msse/ss[�/s

����� X�/ oe[/VVj Voe[/VVj e`[/shjj/sss[/s@�#" X�/ ���� eos/omVeos/omVmm/V[m�/sssh/s@��� X�/ ���� �mm/hVm V�mm/hVm je�/`sem/ssVh/s

Page 128: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

128

Y #�� X�/ �'����A h[[/`hj Vh[[/`hj omh/VVm[/sssm/s�"D� �� �'�� X�/o�[/Vs�V Vo�[/Vs�V eeo/V`sssV/ssh�/s

��c," X�/ W�*��� �os/ojV�os/oj`[o/sejm/sssV/s���#�#$�" X�/ eeo/ehVeeo/eh``j/sej[/sssV/s

�'� X�/ W��,: �ses/joV Vses/joV �`h/�ss[/ss`j/s����� X�/ [e[/�[V[e[/�[h[s/seVo/sss[/s

@�#" X�/ ���� �oV/jjV V�oV/jjV o�h/oss`/ss`[/s@��� X�/ ���� emm/[[jj Vemm/[[jj ohs/V�sssV/ssms/s

Y#5,:

Y #�� X�/ �'����A [sh/`Veo V[sh/`Veo soj/VmsssV/ssjV/s�"D� �� �'�� X�/ome/[V`hV [je e`e/os

��c," X�/ W�*��� h`�/ms[se [je �[j/[jh ���#�#$�" X�/ h��/h[�oj [je [V`/Vj[

�'� X�/ W���,: sm`/VoVjo [je ee�/jo����� X�/ jeh/eo[[� [je m`e/[V�

@�#" X�/ ���� h[m/V�m[` [je h[o/mh� X�/@�� ���� o[V/`s[mh [je [he/VVh

c<�

Y #�� X�/ �'����A heh/ho�o[ [je o`�/Voh �"D� �� �'�� X�/sss/j[oess [jo

��c," X�/ W�*��� sss/�j�jes [jo ���#�#$�" X�/ sss/e`��`s [jo

�'� X�/ W���,: sss/[`j``` [jo ����� X�/ sss/moVeV[ [jo

@�#" X�/ ���� sss/VVsV�[�[jo @��� X�/ ���� sss/Vsjhjje[jo

;T

Y #�� X�/ �'����A sss/Vs[mhss[jo

� �#!+1 X�� �� ���a)$� � ;# !1 �/ >�� k�' ��c< >�),T ��� �'���V�� �c$ssj[/s�. @�"�� )ssj[/s=o÷se/s.(@��/>��: �� �� ��� ���/��"

�" ���a1 ��. �, " ��/ �"D� �� �'�� X�/ �� ��" � @� @���(�'�� �# ����)���/��=)�����(F�}}}�/}P<(�X�/ �'�W���,: )���/�=)�����(F�}}�/}=P(�

X�/ @�#" ���� )���/�=)�����(F�}}�/}=P(�X�/ @��� ���� )��}/��=)�����(F

Page 129: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

129

�}}}�/}P<(�X�/ Y #�� �'����A )}��/��=)�����(F�}}}�/}P<(���� ��:�.��" � @� @���(�'�� ����' �#J'�#" �5���")>��:�(�" @��' �#J'�#" �� �/�

���' -�#�" ���< ��� �"��1 �� ��" @���(�'�� ��/ �" @� @���(�'�� �� �)�# �/ �.�.7� P)N(=�#K�� � �":��"� 43#� ��"&� -�"2� �B� �,��U(3�� ������# ����( �Q ��

!";�P -��� #� -�"2� 43#� �!";�P �":��"� 3�� ����� =�#K��

�'�� �� �"D� X�/ ;�eh/hm[Vm/�@� sm/hj�he/o��" m�/ess[`/�

��c," X�/ W�*��� ;��s/em`[s/Vj@� [e/emjmV/Vj��" ``/e�e[h/Ve

���#�#$�" X�/ ;��o/h[�ms/V[@� ms/h`hmj/VV��" hs/hVmV�/Ve

�'� X�/ W���,: ;�hm/[ohm[/o@� e�/[mVse/o��" `o/`s�m�/o

����� X�/ ;��h/eVos[/Vh@� h[/eVh�m/Vh��" sm/e`hm�/Ve

@�#" X�/ ���� ;�e`/j`mhs/o@� e`/j[jV�/o��" mV/jejee/o

@��� X�/ ���� ;�s`/j[[V�/VV@� os/e�heh/Vs��" �s/jj`e[/VV

Y #�� X�/ �'����A ;�[�/jsVVo/Vh@� m[/emVjs/Vh��" �`/je``�/V[

1- Bonferroni

Page 130: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

130

��"�� � dK� �#"( ���' �#J'�#" �� ��� @��' S��)' ���< ���� �� ��" @���(�'�� �+&. ����� ��/ -�#�" ��/

X�/ �" @� @���(�'�� �� �)�# �'�A�,Q ��/ �.�.S��)' � �5�/ � @��&�/ S��)' ��� �� � �3 �� 2�c" .%/�K4 ���� @��' �/ ��1� � ;���1 ��" @���(�'�� �� �'� �1R� ��,

�'��� @�'� � �5���" �� @�.��< �.�/ ����')�i2��� � F�?'���V��e �V��� �g� �V��[ �Y, �V��j ���$�)$� � ��#V��` �@�?2�" � � �� �V��e � ���� �F�?'��� �

��'�/��[ss[ .(� �?��" S��)' i#' @���(�'���#w � "�: �� Y$� ��"� Y$�)�@�A�/V�mo �@�5#A � F�?'��� �V��o .(� �2�6 �� S��)' ��� �" Y$� %/�K4 �� ��� @��' �/

�" ���a1 �,/� � � ���' -�$�� �)#5,: ��/@�"�� �� ��'� �6 �� �,/� ������ ��/ Y$�)�@�A�/[ss` .(>�6 �" u�c" >��$ ��� ���a1 ����'� �Q �1 �� ��. �)#5,: ��/

����'� � ��. ����� X�/ �� �'��� H��c'� X�/ � 3�� ��/ .%/�K4 i#' �,#"� ��� �� ���/ Y$� �)��A F�('�)� ��V@�?2�" ���������i2��� � F�?'��� V��� .( � � �� �>��" ���

@�?2�")���� (@�"�� �1 �,)$��< ��" � @� @���(�'�� �� �� F�3�� ���' � @�A£�� ��/WAIS �'�� ���3 �?'� �� ���� ��,,� ����� �� @�.��< X�/ =]$ � �,,� ;"�� ��

����'� ����' �,,� �5���" I/ � �� ��. ����� � ��. ��#A .�� ��� @��' S��)'�� �#,��/ � @�'� �� �1R� ;� �� @���" ��/�����, " ��� X�/ �� �1R� ����

����'� �� �?'� ��. ��#A .�, " �2� �� �#��4 @�'� ��/����� �Q�A� ���' ��� .S��)' ����" �)5:� �� @�.��< X�/ ����� �� �� �'�'� B*��1 � �'���" ��C1 �|� ���$.�,Q �/

%/�K4 Y$� F�R ����� X�/ � � 3�� X�/ �1 ��#A F�('� �,#"� ��� �� ��)�# ��/Z#3� ����3 � ������ �1 �/� ���3 �5���" ���" �'���� � "�: �� �� @���" � @�'� ��. �1

��#A ���7 �,#"� ��� ��.

���a1 �� ��� @��' �#,��/ S��)' �, " ��/ @���(�'�� �+&. ��/����� �# ���� " � @�N�� ��X�/ '�� ��/N� �� �N�"D�'�N�W:N����, @�#" �N���� @��� �N��� �

2- Mulhern 1- Reilly

Page 131: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

131

Y #�� �'����A���� ��:� .���� X�/ ������ X�/ �� @�'� � @���" ��/����� �# >�6��c,"W�, " ���a1 ���#�#$�" � �*��� Y.��' ��:� ���� .�"D� X�/ � y��1�� ��

'�� ���5� �F�?'��� �V�1�� �[��"�Q �W�"��$ � ����#"�4 `)[ss� (� F�?'��� �#,��/ ���1�")[ssh (�'�� �)��� Y$� �?��" S��)' �.%/�K4 ���� �Q�A� ���� X��iA �/

�, " ���a1 �� �'�� ����' ��:� @�'� � @���" �� �"D� X�/ ����� �� ����)S��)' �%/�K4 �"��" %& �� �/��. � :��" .(�" @��' I/ ��x' �,#�#4 �$�� �� �� �/�

>�$ >�� ���?" �� @��)<� �.� ��/ �" %#4 �"D� ��/ ���a1 ��� �"� ��,)�� �<��� �1 �/� �'��:�' �" �# �� �)6 � I� S���1 �'��)�@�A�/[ss` .( �# �� G2�w ��A��� �)6

�" �x' � i#' � "�: ����� �� �.� ��� �$����?" �� @�'� ��'�1� @���" �� �"D� ��/�" �x' � �����, %# �� @�.��< ���'��1 �"D� X�/ �,#"� �� ��" @���(�'�� �� �$�

���� ����� �'�.�" @��' ��/�K4 � ��x' �,#�#4 �$�� �/� ��1� ���a1 ���1��� ����c," � ����� X�/ �� @���"WY$� �*��� )�@�A�/[ss`)' ��F�?'��� � i#9�� ��

[sso �@�Q �[ssV ��a��. �V`oh �� # � ��D� �F�?'��� �V��� .(����� ��� ��� S��)'���a1 �,#"� �� %/�K4 ��c," X�/ � ����� X�/ �� �)#5,: ��/W� �*���

%/�K4 ���$ S��)' � ����x)'� gD< �� �J�� ��/���� �� �/ .%/�K4 S��)' gD<� �a��. �*�6)V`oh (%'�� � "�: �� ���� X��iA @��?1 �?. �c$�)" Bc�" @���"�

@��� X�/ �x' �� @��)<� �� Y$� ������ X�/ �x' �� @��54 � ����W� ����� �'��� ��1� U2�&" =,: .@��� X�/ @���" �*�6 %/�K4 �� X��iA ��1R� ����

�, " ���a1 I/ @�'� � @���" ����� X�/ �# � �'�� ���� �� ��� �"�#' Y$� .��Y #�� X�/ F�?'��� � i#9�� ��)' S��)' � �5�/ i#' �'����A)[sso (�54 @�'��:�'

��1� @��)<� �� �1R� �� @�.��< �'�� ���� ��, .@�#" X�/ �� �2� gD<� ����%'�� �*�6 %/�K4 S��)' �� �1R� �� @�.��< @��)<� �#Q �� ����,/�� ���� @���"�

��54��1� @�'�� ���� ��,)�@�Q[ssV .(�, " ���a1 �*�6 %/�K4 �� �� �,Q�/ ����

2- Arteche 1- Keser 3- Swami

Page 132: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

132

�'� X�/ �� @���" � @�'� ��/����� �#W� ���,: �"� Y$� �� �� @�.��< @���" ���1� @�'� �� �1R� X�/ k�' ��� �'�� ���� ��, .���� 4 ���� �� >�6%/�K ���a1 �/ ��/�, " X�/ k�' ��� �� �)#5,: Y$� ���' X��iA ��� .�" �x' � �� �J,/�� ;"��� �$�

X�/ ����� �,.� ��lA�#|t1 �'�A�,Q ��/ .

���a1 �#5a1 �� X�/ �� �)#5,: ��/ I?" �)C' �,Q � Y$� F�R �'�A�,Q ��/��. �:�1 :���� B���1 �� �C,�� Y5&' 5,: ���A �� ��/� ���� ��:� �.�]�/ �)#

���a1 �R�� " �" X��iA �#J'�#" ;C. � �/��A ��/ �)aA �� �"�J,/ �����, ���.�" ��1� @�'� �� �1R� �"D� X�/ �x' �� �� @�.��< @���" ��. �" ��, �,,� .@�A�,'��<

�+&. ��/����� �� �,.� �).�� �� y��,)$� ��� Y$� �C�"� �1R� @���" ��/ ��/ ��" @�'� �.� .�2�6�� �(#)' ��� �� Y5#' Y$�� ��#A .���l4�##{1 �� Y$� ��� Y# 3��

B���1 � ���� ��:� ���A �/ �� ���� � ���A �� ��/;�3 ��� �x6D" �'��� �.�]�/ �� .���a1 �� Y$� ��� �J�� �)C' �1��a1 �, � ��,�� �##{1 @�"� >�� �� Y$� �C�" �/

Y$� �C�"`s$�� �.� �).��' ��:� �1��a1 �#,Q ���"� �"� ��.� ��. Y�| %#4 >�����a1 ��#J��Q ��� �'�. �)�� �/ .���a1 ��� �� Y$� @� �� ���6 �/��. ��/

�" �##{1 @�"� >�� �� �/��A �,��)�@�A�/[ss`.(

S��)' � �*�6 %/�K4 S��)' �� ��& �'��&�/�' � ����{" ;�R� �� �C�%/�K4 ����'� ��i� �� �.� ;#2� ��� � Y$� �C�" � �3 ��/ �� ���a)$� ���" ��#A

%/�K4 ��� ��' @�5C� �/ �.� .%/�K4 G w� �� �� ���D�� ������A ��� � �3 ��/X�/ ����� ��� ��(,? �,!," �� �"�,�$�4 �� �*�6 %/�K4 �� �2� �'�A�,Q ��/

�:�� -�#�" k�' � ��. ���a)$� ��,�" ��?,�#4 �����, �Y$ %/�K4 �� ��. ��/ ������A �"�,�$�4 Z��� �� �#,��/ � ��(,? �,!," Z��� �� I/ ���D�� ��

���� � ��. � ��/ ��#A ���3 �5���" � �$�� ���" U )&" X�� �� �� ��"� Y$� .

@��J�/�K4 �� �<�)�� # � ��D� �F�?'��� >��" ���V��� (�" @�# i#' �,,��, " S��)' ��� �� ���a1 �,#"� �� ��� ��2�3 ��/�J2� �J'�# @���" Ba' � �)#5,: ��/

Page 133: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

133

%�' ����� � "�: �" �)#5,: ��/ �.� .��� �� �" ��?,�#4 �� %/�K4 �� ��. �� ��/X�/ ����� �� �)#5,: ��2�3 ��/�J2� %�' ��#A ���3 �$�� ���" �'�A�,Q ��/.

�� ��� ��,p�c"���a1 �� Y�!7 ��� ���'��1 �� �)#5,: ��/ k�*�" �� U )&" ��/�! � I?" �#"� �-D� ��'�< �� ����� �+&. ��(1 �R�� " �?'� � Y$� i#J'� ���

Y# 3�" ����a1 �,#"� �� ���� ��/ ��'��� �K�� ��/��� )$� �� X�/ �� �)#5,: ��/Y?: Y$� �)? �����,' I#� 1 Y# �3 %��i�� 4 �S��)K%/� ����� ��� � �?��" ��/

��i ���A @���(�'�� � @�'��:�' �>�$ ��J�'�� � �/ ��. F�('� �J�� ��/ .�)? �#,��/��6�+" � �a#� �� 2�c" Y$� Y����" � Z#�� ��/ @���' �&�" Y?: @�A�,,�

/����� �� �/��� ��� ���lA�#|t1 ��!' �#,��/ � X�/ ����� ����� ��/��� ����#A F�('� X�/ �� ����� �+&. .

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :Ve/sj/V`�V �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :Vh/Vs/V`�V �2��" X��l4 r���1:so/sV/V`�[

Page 134: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

134

q���� References

���� ����*�) .V`�s .(B� �,��U( 3�� ������# ����G ������ � ����� ���#� #�3��( ���( �Q ��B� ���O� ����� ]�6$�� ��(��� �� � 4�:���3 ��������3 �#"(3�� ��3#S��� � ��"�O, ��

��� [�" ���/�K4 X��iA .�3�. @�(����� @�)$� ��' F�#4 ��J�'��.

� � �U#$ ����) .V`oh .(�#"(3�� 43���#� � ���#� ��� :B�� � P � C� / ���@��?1 :@����.

� � �U#$ ����) .V`oj .(���� �,��# ��������� :B)��� � �#"(3�� ���������)C�, ��#��(�@��?1 :@����.

��a��. �56 �.�4.)����.(� 2�c" �1�"��" ���x' X�/ �'�A�,Q �'���A �� �,#"� *�"k���/ �$�� ����A��$ %'�� @���"��������� ������ �� �,)���������W��.

Beloff, H. (1992). Mother, Father and Me: Our IQ. The Psychologist, 5, 309-311.

Bennett, M. (1996). Men’s and Women’s Self-estimates of Intelligences,Journal of Social Psychology, 136, 411-412.

Byrd, M., & Stacey, B. (1993). Bias in IQ Perception. The Psychologist, 6,16.

Chamorro- Premuzic, T., Furnham, A., & Moutafi, T. (2004). The Relationship between Estimated and Psychometric Personality and Intelligence Scores, Journal of Research in Personality, 38, 505-513.

Chan, D.W. (2001). Assessing Giftedness of Chinese Secondary Students in Hong Kong: A Multiple Intelligences Perspective, High Ability Studies, 12, 215-234.

Deary, I. (2001). Intelligence: A Very Short Introduction, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Dweck, C. (2000). Self-theories: Their Role in Motivation, Personality, and Development, Philadelphia, PA: Psychology Press.

Furnham, A., & Gasson, L. (1998). Sex Differences in Parental Estimates of Their Children’s Intelligence, Sex Roles, 38, 151-162.

Furnham, A., & Mottabu, R. (2004). Sex and Culture Differences in the Estimates of General and Multiple Intelligence: A Study Comparing

Page 135: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

135

British and Egyptian Students, Individual Differences Research, 2, 82-96.

Furnham, A., & Rawles, R. (1995). Sex Differences in the Estimation of Intelligence, Journal of Social Behaviour and Personality, 10, 741-745.

Furnham, A., & Rawles, R. (1999). Correlations between Self-estimates and Psychometrically Measured IQ, Journal of Social Psychology, 139, 405-410.

Furnham, A., Clark, K., & Bailey, K. (1999). Sex Differences in Estimates of Multiple Intelligences, European Journal of Personality,13, 247-259.

Furnham, A., Keser, A., Arteche, A., Chamorro-Premuzic, T., & Swami, V. (2009). Self and Other-estimates of Multiple Abilities in Britain and Turkey: A Cross-cultural Comparison of Subjective Ratings of Intelligence. International Journal of Psychology, 44, 434-442.

Furnham, A., Reeves, E., & Budhani, S. (2002). Parents Think Their Sons Are Brighter Than Their Daughters: Sex Differences in Parental Self-Estimations and Estimations of Their Children's Multiple Intelligences, The Journal of Genetic Psychology: Research and Theory on Human Development, 163, 24-39.

Gardner, H. (1983). Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences, New York: Basic Books.

Gardner, H. (1999). Intelligence Reframed, New York: Basic Books.

Halpern, D. (1992). Sex Differences in Cognitive Abilities, 2nd edn, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ.

Hogan, H. (1978). IQ Self-estimates of Males and Females, Journal of Social Psychology, 106, 137-138.

Hogan, T. P. (2003). Psychological Testing: A Practical Introduction, New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Lippa, R. (1994). Introduction to Social Psychology, Brooks-Cole, Pacific Grove, CA.

Lynn, R. (1994). Sex Differences in Intelligence and Brain Size, Personality and Individual Differences, 17, 257-271.

Mackintosh, N. (1998). IQ and Human Intelligence, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Page 136: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

136

Neto, F., Ruiz, F., & Furnham, A. (2008). Sex Differences in Self-Estimation of Multiple Intelligences among Portuguese Adolescents, High Ability Studies, 19, 189-204.

Reilly, J. & Mulhern, G. (1995). Gender Difference in Self-estimated Intelligence: The Need for Care in Interpreting Group Data, Personality and Individual Differences, 18, 189-192.

Shearer, B. (1999). Multiple Intelligences Developmental Scales: Multiple Intelligences Research and Consulting, Retrived February 02 from http//:www.angelfire.com

Smith, M.K. (2002) Howard Gardner, Multiple Intelligences and Education,Retrieved online 06/01/2009 at: http://www.infed.org/thinkers/gardner.htm.

Swim, J. (1994). Perceived Versus Meta-analytic Effect Sizes: An Assessment of the Accuracy of Gender Stereotypes, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 66, 21-36.

Teele, S. (2000). Rainbows of Intelligence: Exploring How Students Learn, California Corwin Press, INC.

Woolfolk, A.E. (2004). EducationalPsychology, (9th Ed.). Pearson, International Edition.

Yeşil, R., Korkmaz, Ö. (2010). Reliability and Validity Analysis of the Multiple Intelligence Perception Scale, Education, 131(1). 8- 32.

Page 137: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

137

)-��&��" ���$��� �� ��L" $�;�� � ) ��< ����$ )0(�="� ��< �� �)!�!�

���%"�� ��Gz

���#f� )#��#�{

W%, 7�%P|

4 "SQ �c�� �## 1 g�/ � %/�K4 ���%#4 i#' � ��C� ���&�' � �'��J' � �)<�,.��� ��/��� �,# �

�##�1�#w � �1��' @�J'��' �1��'�$�$� �A��5�� ���$ ��� ��,�" ��. F�('� �/ .%/�K4 �� �*�6k�'�a#7�1 W�� �J)5��/��he)Vo� ��" [m@�(�$� �A��5�� � D)�" ����$

�� ���a)$� � X���'��'�#A�-�)$� �� �'�. �&)'� .$�4��"�,�#'�� #5,4 Y2��� �'��J' ��/ �r$�4 -�#�"��/����&�' Y<�,.��� �`s������ �a," � Y��" ��/��� -�#�" ��C� ���&�'

�­ �A��5�� ��'��� ;#�C1 �� .@�$�#4 �J)5��/ S��)'�,.��� ��/��� �# �� ��� @��'�)< �a," � Y��"����� ��:� ����, " �J)5��/ ��C����&�' ��. � ��C� ���&�' �����

�# �#,��/ �J)5��/ �1��'�#w � �1��' @�J'��' � ��C� ���&�' ��. Y��" �����, " ��:�Y.��)sV/sP<.(��)' ���D��$�A� �� ;7�6 S#������ @��' �'�A�,Q @���1#{)" G#�/��

���&�' ��.�'��J' ��. ��[j��� �� �7����'��' ='��/�1��' ��w#1��'�����1##" ��,�,�)sV/sP<.(�)����/Y<�,. F�$ �c$ ���lA�|� �� ���6 )Y<�,.��� (Y<�,. F�� �c$ �)�Ca1 ��$ (��C� ���&�' ���" ��Y$�.

h��(��� "�' :'��' ���C� ���&�' ��'��J' ��)<�,.��� ��/���N���/�1��'�#w � �1��' �A��5�� .

1N�,#2� �$�,�'��� �.�� -�,.��� )>�p5" ��,5��'(Email:[email protected] 2N'��� ���A ��#�'�� �������� �«"D� ��J�'�� �$�,� 3N�)�? �#?. �C.i4 F� � ��J�'�� �����)$�

Page 138: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

138

2���

���)<�,.��� ��C�� � �� � ����� �� Y$� ��� ��2� �#)6���' F�� �� ;��/�/#'�(�" ��)��A�Y<�,.��� �� �'�. �/��J2� � �?'� �7�< ���/�&$�4��/#'�(��

��(1�/�'��� ��" �(,"�/ F���1 G:�" �� ��.#a," @�(���1 ���/��� Y�a," �"���. .��F��,$ �J2� �")<�,.�W?:�1 �"`" ��'��< �'��J' ;"�. �� ��.����&�' �

�C�����1 �:�1 �#��. Ye���/�� ��/�x,1��< #�����)�� ��/�� ��"���'���A��$�' Y$�)i2�j�[ss� .(�)<�,. F��,$W� ���5�� ����� �� �?:�1 ;"�. ���� ���7

���&�'�J' � ��C� �:�� �Ca1 ��$ ���' �� Y$� �'� Y$� ��'�" )�i2� [ss� .( F��,$�)<�,.W�" �.�' �+&. ��/��� � %'�� �� �?:�1 �� �/��� � %'�� ��� �"� ���.

�c#6 �� � �,)5/ �)<�,.��� Y#/�" ��!2��� ����� �2�� " ��/ ���3 @�?: � ��< ��'�'�#A.�,)5/ I?" ��#5 ��� k�' �� ) :V(�� @�. �#A�� F�i2 ����� Y��" ��/�����,:�)<�,. F��,$ �� ���/W�?:�1 )F�. @��J' ��< I�D� ����� �" �A� �>��" ���

Y��A I/��&' �����' �� ��?" ��/i#Q (�)[(�������� �a," ��/>�),� �c< ����l4�' ��$�56� � ��C�� Y#�/� ��)�' ��< �/� � �2�),� �>��" ����" ��c*� �� F�� �'��1

�,� �'���� ��") (�i2� [ss� .(

�)<�,. F��,$ �7�,� U�� 1 ��W�" ���5�� ����� �?:�1 ���&�' �� YaA @��1 �C���£�� ��"��� Y$� ��,Q � �� �" ���.� �Ca1 k�' ��2� �,�����2�w @��,� �

���5�� � @�<�Q �S�$ ��C��&$�4 �� ��,,���4 Z < � #�5/ �" �)<�,. �,)��'�.)���]���V��m (" �x' � ���C� ���&�' �$��'��J' � ��i' y��1�� �C��,.� �).�� .

'��J'��('� @��,�#����" �5!" ����+1 � ��C�� �� ��'�A � �� ��.��a," ���a��� ��!2��R��)6� � �'���'��A w#�;�3>�),�.����6 ��C�� �'�J,��� XD1 �� �;6

����� �2�5"1���*�" �4 �� �,)5/ #"�N�' �?'� �@�C"� �"� Y$� F� "��� �#�� %��

2- inner experiences 4- rumination 6- Wells

1- responding 3- cognitive-attentional syndrome 5- fixated attention 7- Rippre

Page 139: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

139

4#a," �"������ ��:� )�����V�� �#@�5,[���4 ��C5,��� ���]���V�o` .( � ��D��)<�,. F��,$W�'��' �?'� ����5�� ����� �� �?:�1 ;#�3 �� ���/)5<�J� ��"���

�" ��(1 �� �'��5: ����6 @�. �,��'��� ��,� �� �,�W�)��6e���� F�' �)�2� ��'��' ����� �<��'��� �����# ���)" W�)��6j�" @��' �,/� .�$ �� �i#' ���J)a.����/

@���< �� i#')I� �� ���<�4���<(B��. � ������� �� ����� ��/�;�3 ���##{1 �x6D"��< ��/�J2� �� �����" @��' � ��,/�����'� �� %# �� �� ���� >�� "

�"� ��Q� �� �,��<�" ���<�'�.�'��' @��,� Y!1 I�D� ��� �R�� " ��1��' ��/��)$�" ��,�'�.)@���)�� � �#(2�/m�[ss`�����$ � @D4�� o�[ssm .( � ��D�

�����'��' � �$�$� �A��5�� ���� �� ����� �)<�,. ��/ i#' �1��'�#w ��" D)�" �'�.�" � �: �� �� X�J' � @��1��C� ���&�' ���< � Y�5' �a," ���,A -�56� ��C�� �

i���1 �DC�" ������<I#�+1 ���#A ��� ���.�)��C��"� �$�,�'��� ��('�[sss .("#4 @�i#%#,�A�'�.��'��' � I9D� �/�� H�� @��,��@��,� Y!1 >D)<� �

A��5���)<�,. F��,$ -�$� � �W?:�1 ���� �� >D)<� �;"�. ���� ���7'��J'��C� ���&�' ��%/�K4 �� Y$� �/�4#�#$� ��. ���� @��' �Y)�;�" �a$��

�@���C�/ �V`om .(%/�K4 � F��" �)�2��/��� �� �Y$� ��,Q ��' %/�K4 �#�� i�)$����x' >�" @�"�� �%'���C�/ � i2� )V��h($�� � ���/��� �c�� �

)<�,.����a," � Y��" ������ '��J' ��C� ���&�' ��" � #'��J' @�i������ ���&�' ��������4 ���5�� ��)<� � �: �� ���'��%/�K4 �" �/�=,#C1�� %/�K4 � @��1��

-�2�"Vs)[sse (:��:�4�4 � i2� �#�)[ssV �[ss` (J)5��/ �� ��� ���.��)��" �#� �����$ ��/��)���'�.%/�K4 �� ���#5 i#' �'��J' ���" �� %/�K4 � �: �� �/

F��)$�($Vs��51 �VV�@�2�V[ ��C$���V` )[sss (@��'��,/� I/�.�4 �'��J' ����&�'

2- Robinson 4- Depree 6- psychomotor agitation 8- Kaplan & sadock 10- Moulds 12- Tsao 14- Craske

1- Brokovek 3- Pruzinsky 5- psychomotor retardation 7- Halgin & Whitbourne 9- Watkins 11- Segerstorm 13- Alden

Page 140: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

140

C����$ �|� � ���,)5/ �A��5�� � D)� � �'��J' .��J�� ��/�K4 ��i1��V�@���C�/)[sV[ (�� i#'� 2�c" ��� � ��< ejo � �� ���# e� �:�� ���a)" �#&�1

�#&�1 � ��. ��)5 ���A �� �� �'�#$� �(#)' ��� � �'�� ��. ��)5 �A��5�����$ ��$�$� �A��5��� �'��J' �'��' �c�� >D)<� ��� ��/���� ����, " Y��" .���$

���A ��� �� ��c3�� �#&�1 � �'����# �� ����� %/�K4 ��� �� �+#&�1 ��/�'�� ����]'��� � �#A��� ��c*� >D)<� ����5�� ��� �� ��c3�� ��#,".

%/�K4 k��(" �����$ @��,� � �� ��C� ���&�' � �'��J' ����#5 ��/ ��/;C. �� �)<�,.��� ��/��� �� �)��A ;C.1 �A��5�� F���1 � ��#At�#|�)��� ��lA�"� �'�

�" �x' �� 2�c" �$��K�� �|� ���" �� �� �� �� �/ � ��C����&�' � �'��J' ���lA�'��'Y$� �)��J' ���7 �A��5�� I�D� � �/.�c�� �## 1 g�/ � �*�6 %/�K4

�,.��� ��/�������� �a," � Y��" �)< � �'��J' @�i#" � ��C� ���&�' � �'��J' �/ � ���$ �� ��� �J)5��/ �$�� i#' � ���5�� ����� ��C� ���&�'��@�J'��' �� �)$�

Y$� ��. F�('� �$�$� �A��5�� �1��'�#w � �1��' .�� 2�c" ��D�%#4 �,# �/ ���l4J' ��,�" � I9D� ��� �� �)$� �J�� g�/ �A��5�� � @��D)�" ��C� ���&�' � �'��

Y$� %/�K4 ���.

B��

B�: ���)�� � � ���#, �g�/ �x' �� �*�6 %/�K4���� ���� k�' �� �a#7�1 �/�� �J)5��/.�'��' ��� 1 � ��he���)Vo� ��" [m@�(�$�$� �A��5�� � D)�" ��

� "�:� :��"�,,�@�Ai]'��� %& � �#56 F�"� @�)$���# �C.)k(�#,# � ���/@��?1 �?. �c$ �� -�$� �������D" ��/DSM-IV-TR ���' @��� G5� �

;3��6Vm��BDI[�'��' � #$� ��� ��#A�. %,�iA �-�)$� �'.� �'��' ���A �����-�$� �D"�$ ���� ��/ [s �1 ee�).�� �>�$ �D#+!1 �1 ;3��6 @���4 D�-I(,4

2- beck depression inventory 1- Kertz

Page 141: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

141

��� g�+" F�� �����)� I(,4�"�,�$�4 ���:� F�J,/ �A��5���* ��/�%/�K4 ��/ ��� � �'�"�� ���� ���� F��1� F�� �Y$����' ;3��6 @���� Vm��BDI ���A ����

�" ��/�K4 � �'�.����$ ;#�3 �� 0��< ��/ �D" � #$� �#'�" )����#. (� ���� �� �� �)�� ���' �%/�K4 ���:� >�� �� �#'�" ���Vm��BDI�A��5���* ��/���� g�+" �

�"�,�$�4 ���:� F�J,/�'�. �" 0��< %/�K4 �� �/.��)�5' ��� 1 � �:�1 � �R��$ ���� �"�,�$�4|� >�),� Y?: i#' � ����# k�' Y � � @����# �#��4 Z < � �/ Z < ���lA�

�"�,�$�4 �R��$ � r$�4 � ��/j� 7�� Y���� � �"�,�$�4 Y?: ���� �'�"� %$�4 ���:� F�i2 ���7 �� �� � @����# Y6��)$��"�' �� �/[����A ��:� Y�' �,Q �� .

�"�,�$�4 ������� �/�� �'� :

������# 5�� �(3#;�� )BDI(:@��� b$�1W�1W@���C�/ � � )V�jV(%(,$ ��� Y$� ��. ����1 �A��5�� ��..�� k��(" �� @�"�� ��� [V���" �'��' � b�1�" ���/

�" ;#C�1 U )&"�" �)$��< �'��"�� �� ��:� F�J,/ �� � ��.�'��' ��� ��. ��. �� �/ -�#�" �� G56�h�:�� �� ��s�1`�:�� �,"�� � �,� ��,���' ;3��6 �# �/s�1

j` ���' �A��5�� ���. ��#5 u�c$ �� �?,1 �"� ���� ���3 ��/hs��es��" Y$���� .����' >�� " ��� �,"�� �� ���#�#w ��A��$�' ����� � �,#2� �x' �� ���5�� ����� V[�1hs

���� ���3)���'��"V��m .(�'��' � ��c,"�#w ��/��� ���$�,. ��� � b�1�" ��/�" �A��5��r$�4 ��5' �#5a1 �� @��1 ��/BDI �� �� ����" �� ���/ � ��� ���a)$�

���" �� �'��"�� �� �1��7���' @� � b�1�" ��/ `�" �.� �)��A @��,� � @��1�,#"�;C�" ��� �� 1 ���)���'��"V��m .( �­)V��j(@�"�� ��� ��� ���)�� �`/s��

�Y$� ����� Y$� .@���C�/ � �­)V�oo (J)5��/����" � @�"�� �#�:�� -��,��/#�� @�) �A��5�� �)m`/s(�" � �#(,$��< -��A��5�� ��'�� )mj/s(� � ��"#A��5�� -��+&. �"�,�$�4 #)�?:��,Q �"#�1�5,)mj/s(�Y$� ����� Y$� .��

����?" � ��C. I/ @����)V`m` (�R� �� @� �����4 G��*m`/s�Y$������ �'�.)��� �1��' @�J'��' ��. %(,$ Y?: @� X� �c�' � �:�1 � @�"�� ��� ��5' �#5a1

Y$� ��. ���a)$� �$�$� �A��5�� �1��'�#w.(

Page 142: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

142

��� -�"2�����O�� ���)RRS(:�2�' b$�1W��$ ��/ )V��V (��. �)<�$[[���� >��p$.�,"�� �� >��$ �/ � r$�4 V)�:� �#/ � (�1h)��#�/ ������1 (���' � Y$�

�" �# " �� ��C� ���&�' @�i#" ���� � ��,� .�����4 �$�� ��x," � ���'��� ��a2� @� �'���oo/s�1�[/sY$� )��J[�@���C�/ �V���Y$�: �`��2� �h�V��m � �2�' �

@���C�/V��`�2�' �W=���� � ��$ ��/V��� (c" �� ��R� ���)�� �� �#,��/ �� 2��2�' �,'�" Y$� �����<� U )&"W���" � ��$ ��/e)V��V (%#4 ���)�� �� �$�� �� �#

�����'�.

������# �"����";� !<��� ���#:� M)PSWQ:( �##" b$�1m� #" �o�Ai)" ������� �)V��s (�. �)<�$ .�����Vj�,�iA S,4 ���A � ����� %���A %(,$ ��� Y$� ��

�� �'��J'�,"�� �� ������ � �� ���' Vj�1jh���� .�R��$V�`�o�Vs�VV���' ���lA ���' � �'��� -�C "Y$� �)�# �'��J' ��, " � R�.b$�1 @���� �� @�"�� ���

���#.���� ��#J)$�)V`oe (���'��� ��a2� G��* ����� �� ��. �$��oj/s� ����"����h�)a/ mm/sY$� ./@�"i�/ ����� @�"�� ��� �#,��h�/s@�"�� �

���� � ��c*�)���#.���� ���#J)$�V`oe(.

��# ����!���,�#� �c?c)MCQ-30:( -�#�" ��`s���A ��� �(,$��< ��Y���1�� � i2� b$�1 �� Y$� @�.�Ca1 ���"�� ��� ��/��� �$��W@�1��/VV)V��m (

Y$� ��. �)<�$ .�� @�"�� ���r$�4 ��� �� � ��C#2 U#� �� ���/V)I)5#' Z���" (�1h)I����" �D"�� (;"�. � ���e���< ����� Y��" ��/��� -�#�">�),� ��'��J' ���l4�'

Y$� �)<�,. �/�A���< � �C� >�),� � ��#' ��)<�,. @�,#��� ��c< �.���' �± � �"�,�$�4 Y<�,.��� `s���< ����' B�: ��#�N"-�� �/�" Y$� ���G��* ����� ��

2- Bagbay 4- Alloy 6- beck depression inventory (BDI) 8- Meyer 10- Metzger 12- Catwright-Hatton

1- ruminative response scale (RRS) 3- Just 5- Marrow 7- beck depression inventory (BDI) 9- Miller 11- Metacognitive questionnare-30 (MCQ-30)

Page 143: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

143

���'��� ��a2�m[%�1�`%���< ���-�#�"���#. b$�1 @���� �� � Y$�/���� ��#J)$�)V`oe (���'��� ��a2� G��*�V%���< ��� � ;� ���-�#�" �/mV/s�1

om/sX��iA ��. �) +< ��c*� -�#�"� -�#�" ;� �J)5��/ � Y$� h`/sY$� )���#.�#J)$� ���� ��V`oe.(

����� -�"2�4����3 !6j� ��#S� ���O�� �)PBRS:( ����(" �� ��Vj�� �� �,�iA � 2�c" �� @����# Y��" ��/����#:��: �4�4 � i2� )[ssV (�. �#?1 ��� �)��A �t�'.

r$�4 �� ��C#2 U#� �� -�#�" ��� ��/V)I)5#' Z���" (�1h)I����" ���� � #< (�����' ������� �� �� Y��" ��/��� @�i#" ��� �± � �" @��' ��C� ���&�' �/�.���|

@� �'���o�%� ��� � R� @� ���"���� ���)�� �oe%�� .�����, " ���a1 �#,��/� 7�� ���)a/ %. �'�"� ��' ��/��" ��.>�� -�#�"��� � @� @�"i�/ ���)��

MCQ �, " � Y��" ��� ��� �h`%�, " �J)5��/ Z��� �� @� ���J�/ ���)�� � ����� �RRS )e`(%وBDI )he(%Ya7 �A��5�� �)h`(%��"� Y$�)�4�4 � i2�

��#:��: [ssV .(

����� -�"2�4����3 �*�� ��#S� ���O�� �0)NBRS:( Vm @����# X��iA �� �,�iA ����� ���5����� �," �)<�,.��� ��/ i2� � �#:��: �4�4 b$�1 � 2�c" �� �a)[ssV (�. 0��&)$�.r$�4 �� �� ��C#2 U#� �� -�#�" ��� ��/V)I)5#' Z���" (�1h)� #<I����" ���� (��' � �������� �� �� �a," ��/��� @�i#" ��� �± � ���C� ���&�'

�" @��'�/�.���� ��� ;"��� ;# !1 �'��' �� �� ���/�i ��� @��' ���5�� @����# �� Y��A � �� �� ;"�� �� @�"�� ��� ��V`@� ���iA h/jj%�" �## 1 �� ='��������.

���&�' @�� ��" � >�),� ;�3�#w � y��1�� �� >�� ;"�� �� ��C� )NBRS1 ( ��# S��)' F�� ;"����C� ���&�' ����):� � ���� )NBRS 2 .( ��� ���'��� ��a2�

��N;"�� �� �os%�o`%N��)�i2� � �#:��:�4�4[ssV .( �� =4 @�"�� ���V[���" ��

2- negative beliefs about rumination scale (NBRS)

1- positive beliefs about rumination scale (PBRS)

Page 144: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

144

�� ���)���, " � R� ���"��� ����� �����< .)�� �#,��/ ;"�� �� ����,).�� ��< ��� .-�#�"��� �� � @� @�"i�/ ���)��MCQ )�� �a," ��/�������'��J' (G#1�1 �jj%

�`o%��"� Y$�)�i2� � �#:��:�4�4[ssV .(

������

$�� Y?:��/��� �c�� �)<�,.��� �a," � Y��" �'��J' ����� ��C� ���&�' ���� ��.�{)" �#�� �/���� �$�C� ���&�' ��. �c�� @��� �&�"�'��J' ���

�/�1��' @�J'��' �� ���A �� �� ��w �#1��'��A��5�� �$�$� ��$ �� ���X�� �� �JJ)5��/�4#Y$� ��. ���a)$� @�$�.7� P)�(:�;6% � "� ���#"+�� �"�#�����,�#� �)*��� !6j��(��#:� 9 , ���9 , E

#S� ���O�������� E���$�6������ ���i"$�6�#�(3#;�� �

#""+�� �*�� ���� 4����3���#:�

�*�� ���� 4����3

����O���#S�

!6j� ���� 4����3���#:�

!6j� ���� 4����3

����O���#S�

������$�6� ������� ��

�$�6�#"i N

RPRPRPRPRPRP��J' ��.�'Ve/s`V/sV/sWho/s[o/sse/s*`e/ssV/s[�`/sses/sVe[/s`V�/she

��.����&�'��C�

Vo/s[V/s**h/sssj/sVm/s[h/s**hV/ssse/s**e`j/ssssV/s**eh`/ssssV/she

٠/(٠, * P< ٠١/٠** P

�)'� !1 �� ;7�6 S#���� ;�/�" @��' �%/�K4 ��/�:

VW#�/��� ��)<�,.��� �a," ����&�' ����� Y��" ��C��� ��. � ����$ �J)5��/�" �� ����, " Y��" # @�#�. ��/��" ���5�� @����)�1�1#Ghs/s=r�hV/s=r�

sV/sP<(� � ���/��� �Q�/ �� �, " ��)<�,.��� �a," ��i�� Y��" ��%�������&�'��C� �'#�. i�" �1���$ �� ���.���,��/ �J#���" �� Y��" ��� �# ��

�C� ���&�'�c�� �'��J' ��. � �Y.�� ��:� �����, " Y��" )`e/sr=�se/sP< ( ��

Page 145: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

145

2�6�����, " �c�� ���#�/��� ��)<�,.��� �a," �'��J' ����� Y��" ����. �'��J'���' ��/��" )sV/s<p.(

[W#/ �#1��' @�J'��' �� F��C��w �#1��'��A��5�� �'��J' ��. � ��c�� ����, "���:� ����')se/s<p.(

`W#�C� ���&�' ��. ��#�'��' � ���5�� @�����/�1��' �)e`j/sr=�sV/sP< (�'��' ��/�w#1��'��)eh`/sr=�sV/sP< (J)5��/�����, " Y��" ���:�

� � ������, " ���i�� � �� ����&�' ��. %��C� ��'��' ��/�1��' �w �#1��'����1���� � ��� ����'� ��i�" %���,�.

�� �?'��� Y� 1##�5' I?$ ���/�{)" �� �#�/��'��J' ��. ����&�' ��C��4 �� �#%#,�1��' @�J'��' �w �#1�,��A��5�� ���� � ��@�� >�"�' �*��a" Y

I/ F�� �c<��'�A�,Q )VIF=1($�A� �� #{)"�,Q @�#���. ���a)$� @�"i�/ .

U2� ( 1##�5' I?$ � �c�� ���/�{)" �� �#�/��'��J' ��. ���&�' ��. ���C���1 �� ##4 � �#%#,�{)" #�D" �)�'��'�/�1��' �(.

7� P)0(����� �o�$ "*��#(� 7 � "��

q6�� �":��"�

9�������P�33�)��F

~.���3��&��

R���( �Q

#_�6$ F""�)R2(

#_�6$ F""� &$�4 , 1)R2(

$�A�#@�h/h�[3����'�" jj/eh[

m[/ossV/seh/s[�/s[j/s

>��: � �:�1 �[�*�J)5��/ G��'�A�,Q @��' ����, " �c�� ��,/�#��1 �#Gc<�{)" #�/��'��J' ��. ����&�' ��. ���C� �{)" � #�'��' ��/�1��' �Y$� .

)eh/sR=�m[/o=)[�h�(F�sV/sP< (�, �[j��� �� �7�� ��'��' ='��/�1��' ��$�#��1 � #� G�{)" �� �#�1 �##" ����.�* ���1 G##� ��� �[�/s"��.�.

Page 146: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

146

7� P)?(�#(� 7 � �� ]��#� 9�G8b� "�#� ��� "�"������� ��$�6� �(3#;�� 78��� �4 �� 3�� ����� F��#_ 4 , 3�� ����� F��#_ �#"+��

B�.���� ����� Βt

~.� ��&����3

Y�| ����" `�/VW[�/[Wjsm/sWehm/s�C� ���&�' ��.�V[/ss`h/sess/seV/`ssV/s

'��J' ��.�s[h/sshs/ssoj/sjsV/see/s

>��: �� ��:�" ���D�� � �:�1 �`" �x6D" �{)" �?,1 �� ��.#���&�' ��. ��C��)es/s=β({)" � ����, " �|�#�D" �)�'��'�/�1��'�A��5�� >D)<� �(Y.��

)sV/sP< (" ��Y5'��1es4 �� @� �� �7�� #%#,��,� .

( 1##�5' I?$ � �c�� ���/�{)" �� �#�/��'��J' ��. ���&�' ��. ����C���1 �� ##4 � �#%#,�{)" #�D" �)�'��'�/�w#1��'���)<�,. ��(.

7� P)I(����� �o�$ "*��#(� 7 � "��

6��q�":��"�9������

�P�33�)��F

~.���3��&��R���( �Q#_�6$ F""�

)R2(#_�6$ F"" &$ ��1

4 ,)R2($�A�#@�ej/`sV [

3����'�"`V/``h[se/�ssV/seh�/s`sV/s[jo/s

>��: � �:�1 �h�*�J)5��/ G�@��' ��� �'�A�,Q ��,/� ����, " �c�� #���1#c< G�"{)#�/��'��J' ��. ����&�' ��. ���C� �{)" � #�'��' ��/�w#1��'��

Y$�)eh/sR=�se/�=)[�h�(F�sV/sP< .(�, �[j��� �� �7�� ��'��' ='��/�1��' ����1##" ���,,� .�* ���1 G##� ��� �`s/s"��.�.

7� P)N(�#(� 7 � �� ]��#� 9�G8b� "�#� ��� "�"������� ��i"$�6�#�78��� (3#;���

4 �� 3�� ����� F��#_ 4 , 3�� ����� F��#_ �#"+�� B�.��3�� ����� Β

t~.� ��&����3

Y�| ����" s`/�eej/eWj[/VVV/s�C� ���&�' ��.�``/sso`/seo/ssoo/hsssV/s

'��J' ��.�sjV/sWs�m/ssoo/sWj[/sWe`/s

Page 147: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

147

��* Z����) G�>��: �� ��:�" ����'�)$�e" �x6D" �{)" �?,1 �� ��.#��. ��C� ���&�'�)eo/s=β({)" � ����, " �|�#�D" �)�'��'�/�w#1��'��A��5�� >D)<� �(

Y.��)sV/sP< (" ��Y5'��1eo�'��' �� �7�� �/�w#1��'��4 �� #%#,��,� .

dK���"�� ��#"(

�)'�� � ��D� ;7�6 S��C,��6 ����Y��" �c�� � ����, " #�/��� ��)<�,.��� �)a," � Y��"�(����� �C� ���&�'��C� ���&�' ��. � � �� #� D)�" @����

A��5���$�$� �,��/ �� #���&�' ��. b�� �� ��� @��' ���C� �Y$� ���3 1��' @�J'��'�w �#1��' ��))<�,.�(A��5���4 �� #%#,�2� �,� �'��J' ��.����3

4 �#%#,�/#�� F��C������' @�J'��' �.���&�' ��. �)�2� �C���'��' ��/�w#1��'����" �� �� ��'��' � �5�/�1��' �4 �)? ��)�5' #%#,�"��,� .�)��� �� �)�2�

%/�K4 ��� �� �� ��'�:�Y��" ��/��� �# ����, " � Y��" �J)5��/ ��"� Y$�������" ��< �� Y$� �'��J' ��. � ��C� ���&�' �� �# �.�]�/ � �/��A �'��1

�.� ��C� ���&�' � �'��J' �#{)"�%/�K4 �"��1 �� �,Q�/ �)C' ��� � �#�#4 ��/�'���' @���� .�/��� �. ��/��" �� ��c'��/�)<�,.��� �a," � Y��" ����&�' �����

�C�� �� #' ��. � ���5�� @�����C� ���&��� �� � �#J)5��/ @���������, " Y��" � �� �'��� @��'����)���)' � �/�%/�K4 S�/�:��:�4�4 � i2� #�)[ssV (' �#i��)���/�

C1��#-�2�" � =,)[sse (W@��' ��J)5��/ ��,/��)<�,.��� ��� ����, " Y��" ��C� ���&�' ����� Y��"��C� ���&�' ��. � � �� #�'��&�/ �'�� ���5�� @����

���� .)$����x' >�" �)<�,.��� �A��5�� ����A Y/��. ��/�� �'��' �%/�K4 ��/" ���� @��12��)6� ; � @��,����'��&�/ ����� ��� .�$ ����� �J#�/��� ��

)<�,.����a," � Y��" �'��J' ����� �'��J' ��. � � �� #�c�� ���5�� @�����, "�������' Y�� .���� %& ���)���/��)' � %/�K4 �@���C�/ � i1�� %/�K4 S

)[sVV ('��&�/��«"� ����' ��'�: �)���>��: �� ��. X��iA [��6 �� �J)5��/ �� � ����, " Y��"#�/��� ��)<�,.��� ��C� ���&�' ����� Y��" �'��J' ��. � ���

#" Y$� ���5�� @�����t1 �'��1 #������)���/�@���C�/ � F��)$�($ )[sss (,�"�

Page 148: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

148

.�]�/ ��'��J' ��C� ���&�' ��D)�" �� �A��5�� � @��$�$� ��.� .%/��"#'��J' @�i��/���� g�+" ��w� �� �A��5���* �)�/���� ��c*��* ���<�

SSRI (� � %/�K4 �'��' ����� �<� �C,�� � �:�1 �� ���� @��C' �� Iw� ��� F�� �J�� ��$ �� � �'�� ���� k��. �� �/���� ��� g�+" ��A��5�� ��� �'�"�� ���)�� �(#)' �� � �R��$ ��� 1 � �'��J' ����� �)<�,.��� ��/��� %(,$ ��i� ��:�

����)���< �� %/�K4 ��� ��-�#�" F�� � >�� ��/MCQ-30 Y$� ��. ���a)$� (���"�2��)6� ; � �� @��1Y5'�� ��/�K4 �'��&�/ F�� ��� .

�� J)5��/ ���"�1��' @�J'��' �w �#1��'��A��5�� �'��J' ��. � ����&�' ��C��#A��5�� � D)�" @�����' �#4 i#%#,�A��5�� @�J'��' ��,�" � ����{)"#�)' ��/����6 %/�K4 S�1��' @�J'��' �)$� �� �/ ����, " �c�� �� �w �#1��'��

A��5����C� ���&�' ��. � �' �#4 @�C"� i#%#,�l4������,�" � @�J'��' ���C� ���&�'��� .�$ �� �«"� ���'��J' ��. �J�/ � #1��' @�J'��' �� F��C���

w#1��'������, " �c�� �4 @�C"� � Y.��' #%#,�/#� �� F��C���,�" � @�J'��' ��{1##'��J' ��. ������' ��:� Y..�)' �� ;7�6 S<� �%/�K4 �� %/�K4 � �:�� �/�a$��@���C�/ �)V`om (@��' �� ��,/��C� ���&�' ����, " Y��" �c�����. � �A��5�� @�J'��' �)���' �#4 @�C"� i#%#,����,�" � @�J'��' �����&�' ��.

�C��Y$� @��&�/ ������A �,Q�/ �/�' � ���a)" �'��' #F�� iCa1 #@�J'��' �1��'�w �#1��'��%/�K4 �� �a$����" �"� �@���C�/ ��� 1 � �5#1DC�" � �� I�

" �:��"��,� .�'��' X�� �� ���a)$� �'��' ����� ���$�)�/ F�� i#' � -�)$� �� ��#A�,#"� �<� ��X�� ��#A��C �� ��lA�#|t1 �R��)6� ��/ ��C� ���&�' >�),� ��/

����)�c$>��" @��,� � �D#+!1 (Y����!" ���" %/�K4 ��� ��/ � �.��'��' X�� �� ���a)$�Z#3� ���i� � ����+1 ��#A �)<�,.��� ��/��� %(,$ ��� �1

%/�K4 ���:� �� �'��J' ������" �#7�1 ��,�� ��/��..

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :V[/sj/V`�[ �&5' Y����� r���1�?' �2��" �� :s[/s�/V`�[ �2��" X��l4 r���1:[`/VV/V`�[

Page 149: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

149

q���� References

�����$.0 �.� �����$ �.� �) .V`om .(�S,Uk���� �o8� :������ [��G /��"<�� �S,Uk����)��Q E[��fQ[�3 �P(Eg ��:�1 .���*� .@��?1 :�,�:��)�� 7� @�� � �|� ���)'� r���1[ssm.(

���#.����� ���#J)$� ) .V`oe .(������ 78��� ��Q3 ����%"� �"� �3 �����,�#� ������ �;��2� L����f� 3�#�� � #���� ^�#._� 78��� E�#6P@���4 ��"�'��,#2� �$�,�'��� �.�� �$�,.��� ��C�'��

���#. ��J�'�� �)#�1 F� � � �$�,�'��� .

� ���'��" ) .V`oh .( ����� ��� ��%���)[�� ��Q(Eu ��:�1 .�a��.�.�4 .F �.�&C#' .@��?1 :�&$)�� 7� @�� � �|� ���)'� r���1V���.(

� �i2�) .V`�s .(�(3#;g�� � ^�#._� �����,�#� ����3 ��%G ��%�g�� )F�� P�Q(�X ��N:�1 .��!"@��?1 ��'�< :%'�� ����)�� 7� @�� � �|� ���)'� r���1[ss�.(

� ��#(2�/.P �.- �@���)�� �.� �) .V`o� .(F"�� ����� ����,)C�* ��Q(E� ��:�1 .�#$ ���«�!"@��?1 :@���)�� 7� @�� � �|� ���)'� r���1[ss`.(

� ��a$��.g ��"��? �.u ����!" �.)V`oj .(��C� ���&�' :��A��5�� F��� � ��w������������ [��G �V����� [�jm�1m`.

American Psychiatric Association (2000). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th ed., Text Revision). Washington, DC: Author.

Bagby, R.M., Rector, N.A., Segal, Z.V., Joffe, R.T., Levitt, A.J., Kennedy, S.H., & Levitan, R.D. (1999). Rumination and Distraction in Major Depression: Assessing Response Pharmacological Treatment, Journal of Affective Disorder, 55, 225-229.

Brokovic, T.D., Robinson, E., Pruzinsky, T., & Depree, J.A. (1983). Preliminary Exploration of Worry: Some Characteristics and Processes, Behavior Research and Therapy, 21, 9-16.

Just, N. & Alloy, L.B. (1997). The Response Style Theory of Depression: Test and an Extension of the Theory, Journal of Abnormal Psychology,106, 221-229.

Kertz, S,J., Bigda, P., Joseph S., Rosmarin, D.H., Bjorgvinsson, T. (2012). The Importance of Worry across Diagnostic Presentation: Prevalence,

Page 150: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

150

Severity and Associated Symptoms in Partial Hospital Setting, Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 26, 126-133.

Kirkegard, T.D., Yung M, Mimi, C., Soren, Z., R. (2003). Rumination-Relationship with Negative Mood and Sleep Quality, Personality and Individual Differences, 34, 1293-1301.

Nolen-Hoeksema, S. (2000). The Role of Rumination in Depressive Disorders and Mixed Anxiety/depressive Symptoms, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 109, 504-511.

Nolen-Hoeksema, S., & Davis, C,G. (1999). “Thanks for Sharing That”: Ruminators and Their Social Support Networks, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 77, 801-814.

Nolen-Hoeksema, S. & Morrow, J. (1991). A Prospective Study of Depression and Posttraumatic Stress Symptoms After a Natural Disaster: The 1989 Loma Prieta Earthquake, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 61, 115-121.

Nolen-Hoksema, S. (1991). Responses to Depression and Their Effects on the Duration of Depressive Episode, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 100, 569-582.

Papageurgiou, C., & Wells, A. (2001a). Metacognitive Beliefs about Rumination in Recurrent Major Depression, Cognitive and Behavioral Practice, 8, 160-164.

Page 151: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

151

�$�-&; ) �4�� ���"� )����B� � )0(�="� DM?� 8��/�� ��� 8��N"���!6 �� �& �J�;� �� �;J; '�� $(

�;"G ��G��(3�) z

q"�� ��"T�S"� ���)#�{

�";a 8"<43�)|

4 "SQ

1 �$�� �*�6 %/�K4 g�/t��A��5�� I9D� ��� ���).�' �'�(#/ ���$���� �#| �#"� �c$:��" @�'��:�' ���� G#$� � ��. �.�'��' ��x," ��� ��`s� ��. �:��" @�'��:�' �� ��a'

���A �� �� � ��. �&)'� �#"��� �)5�i? @�"��$ %.�4 Y!1 G#$�Ve� ����"�� ��a' �,)��A ���3 >�),�.Y��. �"��1%#4 � 6�" �� �� @�A�,,�=4 � @�"��@�"�� �@�"�� ��/

�#"� -�#�" � � �A��5���'���' ;#�C1 �� ����,$�.�� �).�' k�' �� ���).�' ����� X��Y��J' ���3 �.��"� �#,Q Y!1 ���A ���A �"� �. ���� X��"� ����"�� ���A ����� � .

���� ;# !1 � ��i(1 ��. %/�� �� ���).�' ����� �� ��� @��' ='������ ;# !1 X�� � �/�:�' �#"� �c$ %��i�� � �A��5�� I9D�1 G#$� � ��. �:��" @�'�t���� Y��" �#| .� �:�1 �

�" �*�6 %/�K4 S��)'� �� ���).�' �'�(#/ ����� X�� @��1��#. @��,��@�$� �� I��,�i/ �Y5'�� �#"� �c$ %��i�� � �A��5�� I9D� ���? �� B#$� ����� Y# �3 � �"� ��� � �|�" .���

�" X����" � �������� �� �'��1��#A ���3 @��J'�"�� @��� �:�1 ���" �A�'� �a," B��3� � � .

h����(� "�' :��A��5�� ����).�' �'�(#/ ����� ��#"� G#$� @�'��:�'����.

1�)#�1 F� � ���A ��$�,�'��� ��#�'�� ��#"��� ��J�'�� �� � ��#/ ��� NEmail:[email protected] 2N�)#�1 F� � ���A��$�,. @��� ��#�'����#"��� ��J�'�� �� � ��#/ ��� 3-�,.��� N�"��� �$�,�'��� �.��

Page 152: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

152

�� 2� G#$� ¡���6 �,#�&1 ��� >�� k�#. @�i#" U )&" �� 2�c" �� �� ��[j�1[/�[�7��

�� � @���" ���m/Vm�1V/om@�'� ��� �7�� Y$� ��. X��iA )��'����' ���4�� ���$��2��� � ��#A ���3 V`�s .( � @����� �� ��#' �� %# �C��"� ��!)" �R��� ��

G#$� �|��6 �� ;3��6 @�'��:�'������ ���� �C�i#� ���a)$��$ �#x' �� Y��� � ������/ ��5,: ��A���'�< Y'��< �Y�6� � ���� ��A�,'�� ��: �'��$ ���$ %1��B��(��� #�� G#$� ��" �� �C.i4 ��: b���.���� ��(1 �� ��#�7 Y$�� �� �����'�

�x6D" ;�3 �C.i]'��� I9D� i#' �?'� F��?Q �� ������1�� �=4 -�)$� >D)<� �K���!'�$ ��V)PTSD (�" @��' ���,/� )�, #4��[�� #�`�� )$�� � �� J'�h�[ssm .( ��

�: � 2�c" @����@���C�/ � ����3 �)V`om (�" @��' i#'�/� ��e/em@����� �7�� )``� @��)<� �7�� m/[`@��54 �7�� (G#$� ������ �� ;3��6�A�'� >�� �� �� ��@�.

���� ��(1�'� .b���. ���$ � D)� �R� �c< �� " �� G#$� � ��. �:��" �����/ � ����� ���� �� I/ �C.i]'��� � �C.i4�'��� ���3 �2�5A�i I.G#$� @����� ����

�RD)<� ���$ � �!'�$ �� =4 -�)$� >D)<� � D)� �R� �c< �� �2�5A�i ���� ����#1�C��$ ��#)�� � Y#+&. )@�5'�:e��/��j�@���m��#)5'� � i ���$�o�V��� (�

G#$� ;"��� � ��(" @�. �:��" �c<�" ���3 ���'�#A )� #a)������'�Vs�) � � ��� �VV�[ss` .(�)��A ���3 G#$� �� " �� �� �'�'��:�' �� =4 -�)$� >D)<� �c< >��)6� �'�

���� ��:� @����� ���" g�+"�$ � �$�$� �A��5�� ��!'�$ )����V[���?2�V`�� ��'������Vh�[sVs .(G#$� @����� XD1 �� I�� ��J�� ���� �DC�" �c< >��)6� ����

������< ��� �'��� �� �2�5A�i � �'��:�' �� �'���C)��,: ��)��.

2- Copeland 4- Anglod & Costello 6- Cohen 8- Smailes & Berstein 10- Anda 12- Ford 14- Connor & Fraeh

1- Post-traumatic stress disorder 3- Keler 5- Johnson 7- Brown 9- Whitfield 11- Dube & Felitti 13- Elhai

Page 153: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

153

%,��� ��� �#2�� �D<��" X��� ��� ����:� ;�R� �l2 �� G#$� �� =4 ��6 ��/@��� ��/�"�#4 ��� @��� �Q�� �� ��#A� : �#"� � @�'��:�' � @����� ��:� %&

���� )��/�� [ss[ .(

,: �� �C� �� Y$� ��"� ��:� � �"��� Z���1 ��� @��J'�"�� �# �� ����"�����/@�"�� ��)�" G2�3 �� �� ��< �'�(#/ ��(1 ��. ���� ���:� B:��" � �� Y$� ��� �/

G#$� ��(1 � ����' @�# ��� �@�� �)aA � �).�' Z��� �� �� ��< ����,C �i�� �'�(#/ ����� � g�� " ��VY$� �)aA � �).�' Z��� �� .�C� @��,� � F�?a" ���

�##{1 ��/�,���� ����&���1 @�"�� �� @��,� Y!1 �� �#2�� ��� � ���� �'R�� ���).�' �� �'��� %�R�4Y$� ��. u�c" �c$�� ��/ )��'�c $ ��?� ���6� ��'��"�

��?2���� �� #� � �a(' V`�s .( �� ��?" %�' �)aA�' �'�(#/ ��(1 � �����<��,:�" �?'� ����� � ���� �" Y"D$ U )&" ��/|� �'��1�.� �).�� �'�"�� ���.

%/�K4��#. �� )" ��/��'��5: �� )" ��/�"�#4 � ��'� U )&" ��/ �)<�,. � �'�(#/ ���� ���3 �$�� ���" �� �?'��'� .��� �� �� Y$� �, " ��� � B3�� �� �'�(#/ �����

Z#�� ��< �� @��J�� ��� ���).�' �� ���)aA ���7 � �� ��< �'�(#/ ��(1 ���1����' @�# )�'�Q � �C �,4[�[ssm .( �� U )&" B�," �� �� ���).�' �'�(#/ �����

@��,� � @� »�).�' ��� �"�'�`«�" ���;# � �C �,4 b$�1 �� �#)5&' ��� ��.h

)V�oj (Y$� �)��A ���3 %��"�� ���" .

�J'�# �).�' �� Y$� ���� @��' �� 2�c"e�5: Y"D$ ���? � �(," �'��� � �'��" ����� �� � #$� U#� @�#" ����. )I ? �� � �C#j�[sse��2���1���m�[ssj .(

�'��' �� ���).�' �'�(#/ ����� ��&�|� � y��" �����"�� ;�" �'�)$���# ��/�"i" �,J2 ���o���5#1�"�� Y��1�������!1 ���� F��,$��l4Vs� � �� ��� F��,$ �

2- Pennebaker & Chung 4- Beall 6- Baikie & Wilhelm 8- chronic pelvic pain 10- irritable bowel syndrome

1- emotional disclosure 3- writing paradigm 5- experssive writing 7- Frattaroli 9- rheumatoid-arthritis

Page 154: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

154

Y$� �)��A ���3 �$�� ���" I$� )=��/V��#$��|[��� � i��a"�/>`�[sse.(���$� <��" X�� ��� ����i" ���? ��'�#A� �� �)<�,�'��� � �'��5: Y"D$ ���" �� ���,��� I)5#$ ��C �� �� )@���C�/ � ¡�h�V��m�� �,#2�)$� �@���C�/ V��h���)4

@���C�/ �e�[ssh(����� @�< )���j�[sss(����� ��C�� �� ���? ���? Y��$ � ���I<� )�$�@���C�/ � Y��m�V����=#5'���o��C �#4 �V��[�� ��,�� @���C�/��

[sso (Y$� .��x��6 ���? �� ������ i#' �.��� ��C �� � � #+!1 >� " %��i��Y$� ��. X��iA )i2� � ��D�Vs�[ssV�i2�C#' � @����VV�V��o � ��C$� �

@���C�/V[�[ss` .(�' � <��" ����� �� �� 2�c" �<� � �'��� Y"D$ ���? �,'�" �).%'�� ��� �C�i#��" Y���6 �!'�$ �� =4 -�)$� >D)<� ���$ � @���"��,�

)� ���,��A @���C�/V`�V��j�=���" � @� $�Vh�[ssh .(��� � -��"Ve )V��� (��@�"�� �� �'��� @��' ��< %/�K4 ����� -�)$� %/�� ��� ���$���� � �,)�" ��/

�� ��.�" ����� ��..�1�'�#:Vj@���C�/ �)[ss�(�'��' �� ��. �?:��" @�'��:�' �� ��� �+&. B��3� ����� �).�' �'��� @��' G#$� � �� �1DC�" � y��" �a���

���� ��(1Y$� �|�" �?'� @�"� ��,� ��/���/�� �� �'�.@�)$� � ��1�� ����,��A)V��j (�).�' ���C� �� �'��� @��' ��" � ��. ��+1 ��"��1 ���" ��[s��|� ��#3�

�" I/��� �� ��,"��$�,�.%��"�� �).lA �/� �±� � �).�' �#{)" ��'�A�'�A ��/��#$� �(#)' ��� � � ���� u�. �� �a��� ��#�(1 ����� �)aA � Z#�� �?:��" �� �'�

��/��)�� �&)'� � �'��� � ��5: Y"D$ ���? � �+&. �6��" �(," �)��� X��$ "N�'�.N�)�,4 �C# ,V��m .(��$��N����N�V`���R� � Y5# �Vh )[sse (1�� ��N� y��

2- Thoresen 4- Booth & et al 6- Crow 8- Francis 10- Klein & Boals 12- Scott & et al 14- Sloan & Marx 16- Giannotta 18- Klest & Allard

1- Hariss 3- Humphreys & Faul 5- Petrie & et al 7- Smyth & et al 9- Weinman & et al 11- Cameron & Nicholls 13- Greenberg & et al 15- Meadows & Foa 17- Freyd

Page 155: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

155

Y'�#< ��"��1 � ����� �# �� �)<�,�'��� �J)a.� � �'��5: �)"D$ �# �c����' S��)' ��'�(#/ ���$���� � <��" ��&�|� �� k�' ��� �� �).�' U# C1 �� ��� @

Y$� �|�" �A��5�� I9D� � ��c*� �'��5: ����# @�J'��' �##{1.�,4��C ��C#�W�$DAV�$DA �)V��o (��).�' k�' �� � 2�c" �� �� ��� �� �'���(�'�� �,)���

:��" �,).��' �� � <��" ��� �� �/��A � �5���" �� �,).�' �#1�"��1 ��(1 � �)�� � �,).�� ��1R� �,��� r$�4 � Y.��? i��" .� S)," ���$���� �� ��� @��' �J�� �)��� Y#1�]/ @�#$�,#5��� � �)? �,��� r$�4B�" >�),� ���A � �5���" �� ��. )� ��)4

�@���C�/ V��e.(

� @�����a��� �� �� �,)5/ G#$� ��Q� @����� � �: �� Y$�4�$� � Y$�4�$ ��,)5/ F��!" ���2�� ��#�7 b��� � Z�� ��'����" .�RD)<� �� ���2�w @����� ���

���A ���� �� �J)5�� -�56� ��,����' ��a����" S'� �i��A� � �'��,"��#' �«�: ��� �,)5/ �a��� � �'��#�7 y��1�� .�A��5�� �'�#A�� @� � @�'��:�' ��� �� � 9�5" �� �C�

$� ��#"��' �Y.���� X��iA @���!"� �#"� �� �'� ���� y��1�� �A��5�� � �a," ���)I#2 � �'��[�[ss� .(�)$� �� �� ������ � ���A��$ �� �'��� ���3 �#"� �� ��1R� ��,

-�56� � -�)$� �� ��'��� ��1R� �)5�i? ��,)5/ �1�'��1 �)a.� ��/ ��)? ���'��1Y# 3�" �� ������ ����/�'��' � �'�����<� �A�'� U )&" ��C.i]'��� ��/ �� ��)��

�" @��' �#��4 �#"� � ����� �,/�)Y'i4`�[sVV .(�A��5�� G w�Y5���#w ��/ �)<�,."N�� @��,� � �,'��1N. ���� �#*�1 �'�����#"� �C±a1 @���N�'��' � �'� �A��5�� ��/

�"� @� :��" �#"� %��i�� � �'��1 ���Y#���"��. @�"�� �i#"�.�� �� ��� � �:�1 �@�� � <��" �� ���a)$� �,#"� �� ���'� %/�K4 @���� �).�' ���7 � ��$�56� �i��

� � Y$�4�$� @�'��:�' �# �� �)<�,�'��� �DC�" ���? ��+< �� Y$�4�$ �'�(#/ ���$���� X�� ��&�|� �$�� �4 �� �*�6 %/�K4 Y$� ��. F�('� ��

� Y$�4�$� @�'��:�' �� �A��5�� %/�� � �#"� %��i�� �� �).�' Z���N�Y$�4�$

2- Wong & Lim 1- Kiecott-Glaser 3- Pezent

Page 156: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

156

Y��A F�('� .��� �� Y$� ��� �*�6 %/�K4 � 7� >��$ ���. �)aA G2�c" � �:�1 ��#"� %��i�� ��A��5�� I9D� %/�� � ���).�' �'�(#/ �����G#$� @�'��:�' �� ����

1t����� �#|

B��

%/�K4 k�' �� �*�6 %/�K4 u��%#4 ����"�� ��/=4 � @�"�� >�),� ���A � @�"��Y$�.

��3��)��

�54 @�'��:�' �# � ;"�. ��/�K4 � "�:VoWV[G#$� �2�$ >�$ �� �#"��� �?. ���� V`�s '�� �)5�i? @�"��$ %.�4 Y!1 �� ��N�."� � "�: � ��� @� ���ms�a'

�"�.� .�D" -�$�� ���,/�� �#"��?Q ��. �x'���(1 �&5' �+#&�1 ��/>D)<� ���"� � �+#&�1 >D)<� �#&�1 �@�"��$ �.i]'��� b$�1 �'��� ��/

�'�� ���� Y����� �!'�$ �� =4 -�)$� .@�#"��ms��� 1 � %.�4 Y!1 �a' `s�a' �&)'� ���$ ����+1 ���7 ���A �� �� ��. �Ve�,)��A ���3 >�),� � ����"�� ��a' .

��U��4)� �� ���#"(

5� �(3#;�� ������# :����� �"�,5.�4 ���[V�" ���" >�$ �� �� �.�V�mV ���" Y$� �)��A ���3 �x'���(1 .X�J' �"�,�$�4 ����'��' � �/����'� �� �A��5�� ��/ ��#A

�"�,� ."�,�$�4 >��$ �/� �: ��?Q -�#�" �� ;"�. � �A��5�� ��� Y$� �� �� @� �,"��s�1`�Y$� ��. G1�" G#1�1 � �"�,�$�4 ��� �� ���' ;3��6 � �����6

j` �sY$� .�$��� ��/ ���)�� �� ���6 �"�,�$�4 ��� ���)�� �,#"� �� ��"� ;��Y$� ��i� ��� G$�,".� 2�c" ������'��� ��a2� G��* ��A��5�� �"�,�$�4 U#+,1 �

G#1�1 � �om/s�o`/s� 7�� � ���"�� �� G��* �`��� �)a/ e���(�'�� �54h�/sY$� ��. X��iA .�" @��' U )&" �� 2�c" ���< � �"�,5.�4 ��� �� �/�

��A��5�� -�#�" �,#" �)#+&. �?:��,Q �"�,5.�4��1�$ ��C �� � ��"������<

Page 157: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

157

��$��" ��#"��'�U��!1Y$� �)5��/ �����< ����� � �)<�,. ��/ )���:� � ���c����#�6 V`os.(

"�� -�"2�)HS:(����,$� b$�1 @R�5A�i �#"� @�i#" �## 1 Y?: -�#�" ��� )V��V (. �)<�$NY$� �� .�����V[" I)�� N��� �.�o���3 ���a)$� ���" @� I)��

�"��#A.h�a2�" � y��" @� I)�� � ��iA���hY$� ��A�lA �a2�" � y��" �J�� I)�� .�:�� S,4 -�#�" �� �� ���a)$� � �'��"���� ��C#2 �� )I����" �D"�� �1 Ia2�&" �D"�� (

I)�� �� ���/ � �� ��< Z���1�" @��' �/�/� .����,$� )[sss����!"�#. �� ;�' � V`oo (����4 ��$�!" �� �� ���'��� ��a2� G��* �#"� -�#�" ;� �oj/s� ��� �

��iA���o[/s��A�lA � �oh/s���� Y$� � .@�.�� )[ss[ (��a2� G��*o[/sG#1�1 � ��A�lA � ��iA��� �� � ��� � -�#�" ;� ���oV/s�jj/s��� @��' .��

���#. b$�1 -�#�" ��� �����4 @������a :�#" � ���� )V`oe (��� �Vss� �a' ���iA��� �a2�" ��� ���'��� ��a2� G���* �� ��. F�('� @���(�'��mV/s��� �

��A�lAjm/s��"� Y$�.

�#P� B��

%#4 � 6�" ���@�"�� �"�,5.�4��A��5�� ��/ Y��. F��1 ��#)<� �� �#"� �� @�A�,,�����A Y�| S��)' � Y��A ���3 %/�K4 .�� <��" � 6�" �� � @� �� =4 �� X�� ���

��� �� �. �)$��< �?'� �� � ���� X��"� ���A ����� � �� �).�' k�' �� ���).�'��!" � ���� �&)'� �� < �3�1� �).�' �� I6�i" ��/��7 � �: �� �c#!" ��/

�" @��,/� � ��'� �/ � ���� %/�� @�C"� �6 �1 �� @�#����� Y�6�i" @�� �� �$��@��� gl6 @��� ��4 �� @�� b< ��� �/ � �)a/ �� ��" � �� ��� ��� � �,5��,

�,/� F�('� Y��$ I#' ;3��6 .Y��J' ���3 �.��"� �#,Q Y!1 >�),� ���A �"� .��� ���).�' ����� X�� ����� >�),� ���A ����� �� F��C�#/ � ��" ��� �±� �� �, "

=4 � 6�" �� � � <��" ���� F��1� �� =4 ��' �)aA �i#Q(" @�"�� �A��5�� @�i#" ����

Page 158: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

158

�. �#"� �TY�"�,5.�4 b$�1 @�A�,,� Y��?' �� � Y��A ���3 %(,$ ���" ���l" ��/���� ��/�=4 � %#4 �� ��"� Y$�F�' �� ���a)$� � @�"����i�� spss � ��i(1 �. ;# !1.

������

%#4 u�� � 2�c" ��� �� %/�K4 u�� �� �('� ��=4 � @�"�����A � @�"�� >�),� �Y$� �)��� ���"� ;# !1 � ��i(1 Y?: S��)' �� �. ���a)$� ='������� ;# !1 �� �/

� ���/Y$� ��"� ��� >���: �� �'�A��: ���.

7� P)�(9�#%� 3�� ����� =�#K�� � �":��"� 4�#( �3 �(3#;��7#��' � ���)� ��

���)� " ���)� W #"+�� 4�#(��":��"� � =�#K��3�� �����":��"�3�� ����� =�#K��

>�),� o/`�hm/Vh[/hVje/Vh%��"�� hj/[`h/V[V[V/Vs

�A��5��

;� j`/`Vj`/Vej/[j`[/V�

%#4 � 6�" �� >�),� ���A �A��5�� �#J'�#" >��: Z��=4 � @�"�� � @�"�� G#1�1o/`��[/hV�� ."�� ���A ��� �����" ��� �� �1��7 �� G#1�1 � %��hj/[`

�V[�� .@�2 @�"�� S��)' -�$� � )�[/`=F,eo/s=P(%#4 ����3� � �,�"�����/ ='����� �'�5�/ � �����1 @�� >�"�' � y��" @�"�� �� ���a)$� ��� F�R b���. ��/

Y.�� ��:� ='������� ;# !1 .7� P)0(�(3#;�� CT8G 9 , W�������' 1"�K$ x����7#��' � �����)� 4�#( �3

�#"+�� �P�3�3�)�

�":��"�9������

F�#_ F

��&�3��� ������$�

���$�����

%#4@�"�� V`j/Vh`j `h/`sssV/se[�/sV�/��A Y���� Vhh/`Veo m`/jjssV/smV[/sV

Page 159: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

159

1 � y��" ='������� ;# !1 S��)'t�� �A��5�� I9D� ��. � ���).�' ����� �#| >��:[Y$� ��. �9��� .���a1 ���A �� �# �� ��� @��' ='������� ;# !1 @�"���, " ���� ��:� ���� )`h/`s, F=ssV/sP< (�Y5'��1 �'�(#/ ����� �� ����

��. %��"�� ���A �� �A��5�� �#J'�#" �x6D" ;�3 %/�� ��� .� ��� ���"� @��1VU�� �� ;# !1 ��� Y3� �, � �Y$� ���a1 ����, " ��/Vss�" �7�� �.� .��� ��

1 ;# !1t%#4 �#|Y$� ��. ��?" @�"��.@��/ >��: S��)' �� ���[�" @��' �/��'��"�� �A��5�� ����' ��'��#3� �#J'�#" �# ���a1 >�),� � %��"�� ���A �� �� �/

1 ��?" �� =4t%#4 �#|Y$� ����, " @�"��.1 ��� @�i#"t/��A �#| �mVY$� ��� �7�� .�J�� ����� �mV����� � y��" ���A �� �A��5�� I9D� ����' ���a1 �7��

Y$� ���).�'.7� P)?(4�#( �3 "�� 9�#%� 3�� ����� =�#K�� � �":��"�7#��' � ���)� ��

" ���)� W ���)� #"+�� � 4�#( �":��"� 3�� ����� =�#K�� �":��"� �� =�#K��3�� ���

>�),� e`/`eh`/VoV`/`eej/V�%��"�� om/h[[j/V[hj/hoj/m �#"�

;� [/`�o`/Veo/hVso/Vj

>��: Z�� `%#4 � 6�" �� >�),� ���A �#"� �#J'�#" =4 � @�"�� G#1�1 � @�"��e`/`e�V`/`e�� .�2�6 �� G#1�1 � %��"�� ���A ��� �����" ��� ��om/h[�hj/ho�� .@�2 @�"�� S��)' -�$� �)o`e/s=F,`j�/s=P(%#4 ����3� � �,�"

���='����� �'�5�/ � �����1 @�� >�"�' � y��" ��/ ��� F�R b���. ��/Y.�� ��:� ='������� ;# !1 @�"�� �� ���a)$� .

7� P)I(7#��' � �����)� 4�#( �3 "�� 9�#%� W�������' 1"�K$ x����

���#"+ �3�)� �P�3�":��"�9������F�#_F���3��&��$� ��������$�����@�"�� %#4 V`/hsj jm/es[e/sVmh/sj`V/s

�/��A Y���� V[[/h[`h sm/e�ssV/sjoj/sV

Page 160: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

160

1 � y��" ='������� ;# !1 S��)'t>��: �� �#"� �c$ � ���).�' ����� �#|hY$� ��. �9��� .� ;# !1 @�"���, " ���a1 ���A �� �# �� ��� @��' ='������ ����

���� ��:� )jm/eF,s[e/sP<.(����� ��� Y5'��1 ���).�' �'�(#/ ����� ����. %��"�� ���A �� �#"� �#J'�#" �x6D" ;�3 %��i�� .� ��� ���"� @��1j`�Y$�

���a1 U�� �� ;# !1 ��� Y3� �, � ����, " ��/j`" �7�� ��.� .;# !1 ��� ��1t%#4 �#|Y$� ��. ��?" @�"��.@��/ >��: S��)' �� ���h�" @��' �# ���a1 �/�

�'��"�� �#"� ����' ��'��#3� �#J'�#"1 ��?" �� =4 >�),� � %��"�� ���A �� �� �/t�#|%#4Y$� ����, " @�"��.�/��A �#|�1 ��� @�i#"joY$� ��� �7�� .�J�� ����� � jo

Y$� ���).�' ����� � y��" ���A �� �#"� ����' ���a1 �7��.

��"�� � dK��#"(

I9D� %/�� � ���).�' �'�(#/ ����� ��&�|� �$�� �*�6 %/�K4 �� g�/�� �#"� %��i�� � �A��5�� .%/�� �� ���).�' �'�(#/ ����� �� ��� @��' S��)'

� %&�|� �#"� %��i�� � �A��5�� I9D�Y$.���).�' �'�(#/ ����� �� �, " ��� �Y$� ��� �|�" ����"�� ��/��A �#"� %��i�� � �A��5�� I9D� %/�� ��.��� S��)'

%/�K4 �)��� � I#�)5"�#w � I#�)5" ���7 ��]2 ��/ )V��m(�i2� � ��D� )[ssV(�Y#�$� )V��o(�@���C�/ � R���' )V`�s(��,1��A )[sse(����6� � �'�c $ ��?�

@���C�/)V`�s(��,��" � �,#�)[sss(�@���C�/ � ���,��A)V��j(� @� $� �=���" )[ssh (��'�#: �)[ss� (���� �'��&�/.%/�K4 ��� G w����� @��' �/�� �'�

;�3 �A��5�� I9D� %/�� � �: �� ��'��� � �a��� S��)' �� ���).�' �'�(#/ ������'�� ��'�!)"� ��I9D� � ��J PTSD �Z < ���? � -�)$� ���� ��#5 %/�� � ���<

�C�i#� � �'��� Y"D$ ���? �,'�" ��)"D$ ����i" ��A��5�� ��. ����, " %/��%'�� ��� �"��1 ���$ � @���"�)PTSD(�Y$� %&�|� .��� # !1��� � 2�c" ;�

Y#�$�)V��o (��. ��(�� �|� �� ��� @��' ��� � ������� #$� �'�(#/ �������!2 �� ���).�' �)"D$ ��� �'��� �D<��"���$ �� �� �� �'�5� � ���" ����'�

Page 161: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

161

�'�� ���� ���a)$� �'��� � ��5:.�"����� y��1�� ���� ��&�|� �� YaA �#,Q @��1Z#�� ���� �,���� �Q�/ �, � ���� @� Z�� �� �)�# @� Y��" ���|� �.� �1Y$.�,4

�)5C. � �'�(#/ ����� �R�� �� Y$� �).�� ��?�� ���).�' ����� ��!' ���" �� �C �'��� � �'��5: �DC�" Z��� ��� �� � ��. �'��� ���� %/�� G:�" ������ �,����

�" %/�� ���/� .@�(#/ ���� ��#'�| �� ��J'�� G:�" ��� � G2�3 �� ��$�56� � �/��(1 � �/��������#. � ��. �'�(#/ @�"��$ ��/�" �##{1 �� �?'� l: �� � �/��/�

)�@���C�/ � k��� V`�s .(���$ G:�" ��$�56� � ��C�� �).��?J' �a&" ��� XD1 ��/���� G2�3 �� �?'� �± (1 � �(," ��'��� �'�(#/ ��(1 ���$ � ��. �?'� ��C��

�" �,/� ��/���&�' � I6�i" �)$��<�'��A�)�'R � �,A�V�V��e.(�" �x' ��$� ��� �AK�� �� �C�� @����� �)5:� ��/�.� �"��1 � ��. �:��" Y$�4�$� � Y$�4�$ .

�i� � �+&. >�),� -�56� %��i�� � ����/ �).�'Y$� ����/ i#' =a' )�,#2�)$���@���C�/ V���.(X�< �%,# %��i�� ������� �,���� �)5C. I/ ���,# �-�56�

�i� � �+&. >�),��" ��� =a'%��i�� �#"� � %/�� �A��5�� I9D� �,���� .

� ��" ���/�� @��,� � �).�' �� ���a)$� �� Y$� ��� � ���)���" ���� �� ����� �'��1 �'��� � �'��5: � c" �' ��/�"�#4 ��� ����' �"���� �A�'� �a," ��(1 � ��������

��(1 �������' ��#J�#4 .�� �C� @��,� � �� �'�(#/ ����� @��J�/�K4 �� �<�Y#��� @�� R� �@��� Y.��? ���1�� ��/���/�� -�56� Y��?' �� � �)<�,. ��/

���� ���3 �$�� ���" �)<�,�'��� �)5�i?�'� .�" �� �'D(#/ ����� k��(" �� @��1�X�� �� �C� @��,����'��$ ����$ ��/I���(1 � � ��" � �������� �� �|�" � �,�i/

G#$�%#4 %�' �� Y5'�� �A�'� ����'�"�� %�' � @� ��'�#AY$� F��" X�.��1 �'�(#/ ���$���� �� Y$� ��� �x't���� �A�'������* �#| .����� ��x' ��!2 �

. � �'�(#/N/�� G:�" ������ �,���� �)5CN��� ��� �� � -�)$� %N�DC�" �� Z" �'��� � �'��5:N��/�� .$ ��N' ��� �J�� ��N���x "N� �� Y$� u�cN@�(#/ ���� �/

1- Wagner & Lane

Page 162: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

162

�/�'�"��$ ��#. � ��. �'�(#/ ��(1 �� ��J'�� G:�" ��� � G2�3 �� ��$�56��" �##{1 �� �?'��/� )��)#4V�¡�[��C �,4 �V��o�;J#$ � �C �,4`�V�����QD$�h

��C �,4 �[ssm.(���� F�J,/�@�(#/ � ��$�56� � 3�� �£�� ��/Y<�$ @�C"� �/��/� @�"��$�'��� Y��?' �� � �/� I/��� �� �?'� G�5" ��/������ � �'�(#/ ��(1 ���$

�"���$ )��C �,4 V��e.(�).�' �'�"�� � �'��#J�#4 ����� �� ��. F�('� �� 2�c" ���"�6�" Y���" ��?,�#4 � �,��)a.� ��(1 ��� �� �).�' �� �,��" ��$ Y"D$ �'��1

��&� ���? �� �'��� � �'��5: .���D @�(#/ ��� �� �).�'Y# 3�� � �/ @�"��#4 ��/-�)$� ����<���� ��1�� %��i�� � �(,"@�(#/ ��"@�(#/ %/�� � �a," ��/ ��/

�" Y��"��. .� �����,� Y$� �C�" �)a.� ��(1 � �?:��" ��" ��1�� �����.� ��'��� �)<�,�'��� .���"�, �� >�6 �/ � �)a.� ��(1 � �?:��" F�('� ��$

Y$� @��� Y"D$ ��1�� � ����/ �'�(#/ .������$ �" ��� �� ��J�� �2��)6� ��.�� Y$� ��� ��. ���? � �(," ���).�' ����� ���/ �).�'�%,# %��i�� � ��1��

���< X�<��,# �i� � >�),� -�56�Y$� =a'.k�' ����7 ��$��C.���< �).�'G#$� ��!" � �?:��" �� ��J��Y$� �� )��,#2�)$� ���R ��C �#4 � ���" V����

�@���C�/ � k��� �� ;�' V`�s.(����� ��#5 �/��. �C.i4 � �$�,�'��� ��#�� ������ ��:�-�)$� � �a," ��(1 �� � �� �'��� � �'��5: Y"D$ ���. ������ ���

�" �:��" ;C�"���$ .������� ���x' -�$� � �B��3� ���" �� @�i' g�6 � ��C�� ��C�� ��� @�. ��C.� �� >�« � ���7 � �/� �� Y$� ��� Fi )5" �A�'� I?" ��#�(1

�� �1 i#' ��� � �,� ��#A� : ��$�56� ����� �� ��< ��< �)<�,�'��� � �'��5: .%/�K4 �����b�1�" ��/ Y����!" ���(#)' � �5���" ��� Z�!" ��/�� ��#A .

� g�7 @����� � %/�K4 � "�: @�� ���!"Y����!" �� Y$�4�$� � Y$�4�$��/ �� %/�K4 ��� �J��.Y$� ��. F�('� @����� ��� g�7 ��� � @�Q �*�6 %/�K4�

.�)��� ��� � ��. �:��" �J�� ����� � I#� 1 ;�3 @� ��/��.��' G#$ ." ��?,�#4N���.

2- Both 4- Slatcher

1- Petrie 3- Seagal

Page 163: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

163

��. �$�� @����# ��� � �� ��"��1 � ��. �:��" � ����� ���$ �� �5���" ��� .�c$ ���)��� ��x'�" �*�6 %/�K4 ��/���x' �,'��1�/�'�(#/ ���$���� � y��" � � �

���6 �� �"��� Y"D$ �DC�" � @� y��1�� � �).�' k�' �� �� �a��� � �'��5: ��/�,,� �#:�1 �1�?: �� .

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :V�/sj/V`�[ �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :Vm/s�/V`�[ �2��" X��l4 r���1:[o/VV/V`�[

Page 164: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

164

���q�References

�'�c $��?� ���6� ,�'��"� ��5!" ,�2��? 2��� ��2� ,�a(' ��#56��!" ,� #� ����!" ,��?")V`�s .( �'�(#/ ����� ��&�|�)���).�' � ���)aA (�A��5�� I9D� � ,��c*� -�)$� �

@���(�'�����"<�� ��������� ���� �h)o(.eVWe�.

�����3 ��: ����5' ����� �F��� ����' ����� ���' ��#"��� ����' ����� ����������!" ��,#56 �D#2 ��a��. �����)C�� ����"��� 5" )V`om.(G#$� ¡���6 �'����� @� �)<�,�'��� ���|� � �A�'� ���

��" @����� �� �� �$VmWe���'�"�� �?. �2�$ �3�6f��V[)V(�[ssWV�s.

���:� ��*�"Dw �� a$�� ���c� ���#�6 >��: )V`os.(>��$ � "�� ;# !1� �"�,�$�4 ��/ )BDI-21 (���/� @���Q �#?. ��J�'�� ��(�'�� @��54 ��� � ���"�#$ [��G ��������`)`(�h�

jjWh�.

�2� ��'��"�����6� �8� ����� � ���$�" ����(2 ��!")V`oj .(1 �$��t���).�' �'�(#/ ����� �#|R� �A��5�� I9D� � @���(�'�� �� >� � �x��6 Y#��� � �A��5�� ���3 �� �������

���������� !�8� �����. �>�� ����h.`sWV�.

�������!" ,���5< � " �� � ,����52���7 ���aw,>D:�#$.�# ����2��,���?)V`oe .( �$��1t� @����� �a��� � ���)�� �RD)<� %/�� � >� � ��J'�"�� ��#$�" �#| � Y$�4�$

Y$�4�$����������� ���� �`o,)Vs([,[[[W[`V.

�k��� ��#56 ������. ���/�� ��#2� ��)(" )V`�s.(� �$��$� I9D� ��. � ���).�' ������|�� � @�� D)�" �A��5��-��$� >D)<W���:� ���"<�� ��������� �����`)h(�`hW[m.

���#.���� ,��a :�#" ���7 ,��6��#$)V`oe .( �� ����2� ��3#6�� �� ���� "�� �"� �.��� ���#�)�#", 4�:���3 ��������3 �"� �3 -#��� ��@���(�'�� �'��� Y.��? ��,#�$ �#"�$ VV[WVVs.

� ��6� �R���' ���6� ���4=��/ ��A� ���,?" ��a'��i� �� �� ,@�AK")V`�s .( ����� � <��" ��&�|�@��� >D)<� ����� @����# ������ � -�)$� %/�� �� �'�(#/�,1�[��G 4�:���3 �������

[#fP �S,U ����. �I?' ���� �[�hVWhm.

��'����' ���!" ���4�� ���($ ���3 ���#A ��#56 ���$��2�� -��� )V`�s.(X�� ��&�|� ��/%'�� �)<�,�'��� I9D� %/�� �� �#���A�2�/ ��(" X����4 � �)<�,. X����4 @�"�� @���"�

G#$� � ��. �:��"���"<�� ��������� �����`)VV(�e[WhV.

Page 165: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

165

R���' ,� � �� ���6���4 ,�3��. ���6� ,��#(' ���/�� ,=��/ ��A� ��5��� ,@�AK")V`�s .(1t�#| � X��"�I5#'�C" ����� � �A��5�� ��. %/�� � ���).�' �'�(#/ ���� @����# ����� ��/

���5����%�G ������ �3L�����3 ���� ,I/�(/ >�$ ,����.�`,VWVV.

Baikie, K.A., & Wilhelm, K. (2000). Emotional and Physical Health Benefits of Expressive Writing, Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 11, 338-346.

Booth, R.J., Petrie, K.J., & Pennebaker, J.W. (1997). Changes in Circulating Lymphocyte Numbers Following Emotional Disclosure: Evidence of Buffering? Stress Medicine, 13 (1), 23-29.

Cameron, L.D., & Nicholls, G. (1998). Expression of Stressful Experiences through Writing: Effects of a Self-regulation Manipulation for Pessimists and Optimists, Health Psychology 17 (1), 84-92.

Campbell, RS, & Pennebaker JW. (2003). The Secret Life of Oronouns: Flexibility in Writing Style and Physical Health, Psychological Science, 14, 60-65.

Chesvens, J. (2000). Hope and Depression: Light through the Shadows, Academic Press, Handbook of Hope, Chapter 17, 321-340.

Copeland, W.E., Keler, G., Anglod, A., & Costello, E.J. (2007). Traumatic Event and Posttraumatic Stress in Childhood, Arch Gen Psych, 64, 577-584.

Crow, D.M. (2000). Physiological and Health Effects of Writing about Stress, Southern Methodist USA.

Eaton, L, G., Doherty, K.L. & Widrick, R.M. (2007). A Review of Research and Methods Used To Establish Art Therapy as An Effective Treatment Method For Traumatized Children, The Arts In Psychotherapy, 34, 256-262.

Ford, J.D., Elhai, J.D. Connor, D,F. & Frueh, B.C. (2010). Poly-Victimization and Risk of Posttraumatic, Depressive, and Substance Use Disorders and Involvement in Delinquency in a National Sample of Adolescents, Journal of Adolescent Health, 46, 545-552.

Francis, M.E., & Pennebaker, J.W. (1992). Putting Stress Into Words: the Impact of Writing on Physiological, Absentee, and Self-reported Emotional Wellbeing Measures, American Journal of Health Promotion 6 (4), 280-287.

Page 166: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

166

Frattaroli, J. (2006). Experimental Disclosure and Its Moderators: a Meta-Analysis, Psychological Bulletin 132 (6), 823-865.

Giannotta, F., Michele S, Wendy K, Silvia C. (2009). Results of an Italian School-based Expressive Writing Intervention Trial Focused on Peer Problems, Journal of Adolescence. 32, 1377-1389.

Greenberg, M.A., Wortman, C.B., & Stone, A.A. (1996). Emotional Expression and Physical Heath: Revising Traumatic Memories or Fostering Self-regulation? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 71 (3), 588-602.

Harris, H.A., Thoresen, C.E., Humphreys, K., & Faul, J. (2005).Does Writing Affect Asthma? A Randomized Trial, Psychosomatic Medicine, 67, 130-136.

Johnson, J., Cohen, P., Brown, J. Smailes, E., & Bernstein, D. (1999). Childhood Maltreatment Increases Risk for Personality Disorders in Early Adulthood, Arch Gen Psychi, 56, 600-606.

Klein, K., & Boals, A. (2001). Expressive Writing Can Increase Working Memory Capacity, Journal of Experimental Psychology, General, 130 (3), 520-533.

Mallay, J.N., & Dipl, B.A. (2002). Art Therapy, an Effective Outreach Intervention with Traumatized Children with Suspected Acquired Brain Injury, The Arts in Psychotherapy, 29, 159-172.

Meadows, E.A., & Foa, E.B. (1999). Cognitive behavioral treatment of Traumatized Adults, In: Saigh, P.A., Bremer, J.D., Bremer, J.D. (eds). Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: a Comprehensive Text, Needham Heights, MA, Allyn & Bacon, 376-390.

Pennebaker J.W, & Chung CK. (2007). Expressive Writing, Emotional Upheavals, and Health, In H. Friedman and R. Shilver (Eds.), Handbook of Health Psychology, New York: Oxford University Press.

Pennebaker JW. (1995). Emotion, Disclosure, & Health; Washington, DC, US: American Psychological Association.

Pennebaker, J.W., & Beall, S.K. (1986). Confronting a Traumatic Event: toward an Understanding of Inhibition and Disease, Journal of Abnormal Psychology 95 (3), 274-281.

Pennebaker, J.W., & Seagal, J.D. (1999). Forming a Story: the Health Benefits of Narrative, J. Clin. Psychol, 55, 1243-1254.

Page 167: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

167

Petrie, K.P., Booth, R.J., & Pennebaker, J.W. (1998).The Immunological Effects of thought Suppression, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75, 1264-1272.

Petrie, K.J., Fontanilla, I., Thomas, M.G., Booth, R.J., & Pennebaker, J.W. (2004). Effect of Written Emotional Expression on Immune Function in Patients with Human Immunodeficiency Virus Infection: a Randomized Trial, Psychosomatic Medicine 66 (2), 272-275.

Pezent, G.D. (2011). Exploring The Role of Positive Psychology Constructs As Protective Factors Against The Impact of Negative Environmental Variables On The Subjective Well-Being of Older Adults, Dissertation of PhD, Texas A&M University.

Scott, V.B., Robare, R.D., Raines, D.B., Konwinski, S.J., Chanin, J.A., & Tolley, R.S. (2003). Emotive Writing Moderates the Relationship between Mood Awareness and Athletic Performance in Collegiate Tennis Players, North American Journal of Psychology 5 (2), 311-324.

Slatcher RB, & Pennebaker JW. (2007). Emotional Expression and Health. In Susan Ayers, Andrew Baum, Chris McManus, Stanton Newman, Kenneth Wallston, JohnWeinman, & Robert West (eds), Cambridge Handbook of Psychology, Health and Medicine (pp. 84-87), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Sloan, D.M., & Marx, B.P. (2004). A Closer Examination of the Structured Written Disclosure Procedure, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 72 (2), 165-175.

Smyth, J.M., Stone, A.A., Hurewitz, A., & Kaell, A. (1999). Effects of Writing about Stressful Experiences on Symptom Reduction in Patients with Asthma or Rheumatoid Arthritis: a Randomized Trial, Journal of the American Medical Association, 281 (14), 1304-1309.

Weinman, J., Ebrecht, M., Scott, S., Walburn, J., & Dyson, M. (2008). Enhanced Wound Healing after Emotional Disclosure Intervention, British Journal of Health Psychology, 13 (1), 95-102.

Whitfield, C.L., Anda, R., Dube, S., Felitti, V. (2003). Violent Childhood Experiences and the Risk of Intimate Partner Violence in Adults, J Inter Viol, 18, 166-185.

Wong, S.S., & Lim, T. (2009). Hope Versus Optimism In Singaporean Adolescents: Contributions to Depression and Life Satisfaction, Personality and Individual Differences, 46, 648-652.

Page 168: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

168

� �=��%���;<�� �� O�$� ��B ��<!��3 )TWA($( )-H$��� ���0(�� �P:! �� 7��.��(1�� �� )��J�� ���0(�� ��� := C�< � ���0(�� ���

�;*� ����� �K�� � �r��z

���#"� �����{

� a�� [�#f,|

����� �< G �f�<� 6G 4 "a��

4 "rQ 1 �5���" � 2�c" ��� �� g�/t-�#3 ��J2� � =���1 �#|T���" ��#A��� � ��A � ;"� 1 �� �)

^�$���� � ��#A��� ��/�� F� � � Y�5' X�J' � ��#A��� ��/ .�� ;E�)" Z#�!1 �'��'Vsm%'�� �T ��� i���1 �?. ����,/�� F�$ -DT ��?Q ��"������+1 ��� �.�< �� ��

�'�� ��. �&)'� ���"� � "�: .-DT �� �E�� �/-DT � >�),T ���A @��,��� ��/ � �J���A @��,��'�. ��!2 ����"�� ��/ .� ���' Y����� �� �),$ ��#. � X��"� >�),T ���A

���A ����"�� ��/)V(-�#3 ��J2� � =���1 ���A)[(-�#3� �,)" �!#*�1 ��A @��,�H�� �"�'� �)`(�'���' Y����� �� �)T���" ��#A��� .���� � #+!1 Y���#4 @�"�� � #$� �/� �-�#�" �F^�$ �"�,�$�4 � F� � � Y�5' X�J' �. ������A �!#:�1 ��#A��� ��/ .

%'�� ��� @��' ��#{)"�,Q ='����� ;# !1 S��)'�T �'���"� -�#3 ��J2� � ��#A��� � ��A =���1 �)T���"��.���A � �5���" �� �'�-�#3 ��/H�� @��,� � �,)" �!#*�1 ��A � �"�'�

1Ni���1 ��J�'�� �)#�1 F� � ���A ��)$� 2Ni���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� ���A ��)$� 3N1 ��J�'�� �)#�1 F� � ���A ��#�'��i��� 4N��J�'�� �)#�1 �$�,�'��� ���)T� ��(�'��i���1 )>�p5" ��,5��' (Email:[email protected]

Page 169: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

169

���� >�),T��/�'��� ��)? ��#A��� .���� �#-�#3 ��J2� � =���1 ���A ��/ ���A � ��A�, " ���a1 �)T���" ��#A���Y.��' ��:� ���� .^�$ �|� ��E,�� �:�1 ;�3 �)E' ��/

1 ��#A���t�, " �#|���� � ����%'�� ��#A��� ��/I/ �Y.��' @���"� ���A � @� ;"� 1 �#,Q�, " ���a1������� � �%'�� ��#A��� ��/���' @��' @���"� .@��' ='������T ;# !1 S��)'

���A �# �T ����, " ���a1 F� � � Y�5' X�J' �� >�),T � ����"�� ��/����' ��:� ��� .��)��� ��� � �:�1�" ��?,�#4 ��/-�#3 �� ���A��A �/�� =���1 �� �.��"� ��J2� @��,�

DT ��#A���-%'�� �)? � #+!1 Y���#4 Y?: F� � ��/��. ���a)$� @���"�.h��(��� "�H :-�#3 ��J2� � =���1-�#3 ���A��)T���" ��#A��� ��,)" �!#*�1 ��A

����X�J' ���#A��� ��/ F� � � Y�5'.

�� 2� >�$ ���" Y���6 ��A��� ��� �� �#<� ��/%'�� b$�1 ��. �)<�$ %'�� �� ��. @���"�

Y# 3�" ���$ � >��)'� ;�3 � ��� �,"��$�" ��#A��� ��/�.� .� �� ��?" ;"���" ��� @�� " ��� � I?� �,,� ��(�� ��#A��� k�' ��� ��� �c���. �1 �,�

Y$� @�'� b$�1 ��. u�c" �$�� ����*�" .��)!" =���1 %'�� @�#" ��� �� W1 � � 7� ����,� ����� I " �K�� =���1 F�J,/ �� %'�� ��)!" >��)'� �� %#��'��

���� �7�< Y#�/�)� w�� ��� �V�[ssh .(-�#3 �� ���a)$���A%'�� �� ��& �/=���1 ��)!"W�" �� Y$� �K�� �� F� � I#/�a" �'��1�%'�� � �|�" ����/� >��)'� @���"� .

%'�� G w��,#"� @���"��" I#/�a" ��#A��� ��� ��Y5�� �� �,.��' � ;C ��$�,.�'���' ��i#� � ��#. .5" ;6 ��� �|�" X�� ��t�� @�� " �� Y$� ��� ��:�" �2

���N-�#3 Z3 %'�� � �,.��' I#/�a" �# ��AN%'�� � �� ��(�� �c�� @���"�N�,, .-�#3��A�" ��� � ���: G2�c" ��. � �3 %'�� l: �'�$� � ���i)'� I#/�a" �K��

%'�� �(#)' �� ����A�, " I?� � ��� � ���3 @���"��" I#/�a" ����'��A.

1- Yilmazoglu

Page 170: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

170

-�"/�#(�,)��� ��

�R�� " @�� "%'�� ��� ��#�#4 � ���.� I#/�a" v�� ;#?51 ��� -�#3 �� @���"���A �" ���a)$��,,T .-�#3 �A���A� ��?�� �.� ���"�x'�#w @�'� ��/%'�� � @���"� �

�" ��:���� .��DA)V��h (�)T U# E1 ;# !1 � �$DT =���1 � F� � �$�� ��/%. ;6��" �'�� ��. �&)'� �'��' @��,� � �T �'�� "-�#3 ��J2� �'�A �� ��A

a2�" � @�� " �1 ��T ����1�� �� @� �$�� G)T @���"�x' ���a)$� ��� ����,/�� @��,�-�#3�A��'�#A ��E F� � X��"� �� �/ .-�#3 � =���1��A��#. � �/ ��DA �T ��

)V��h (���x' � #$� Y$� ���T u�c"��'��$ ��/����AV�, " ��#A��� �;��� ���[�� 5 $�#'�A ��#A��� G1��"`Y$� ��. Y���6 .� =���1 ��� I?" ���J2� @��,� ��l2

-�#3 ��#.� � X��"� �� ��A Y$� �)��A ���3 ���a)$� ���" F)��T�h�[sse .( ��DA)[sso �@���E�/ � �? 2���� �� ;�' �V`�s (%. ;6��" ��J2� �'�ATWAe� ��

Y$� ���� u�c" ��� ���7:

V(���. �)<�"� �)5�� �� ���/ F�?a" �9���[(F�?a" � ����" �� ��J'�� �-�#3`(�AK�� ���$�,. F�?a" ��C.� ��/ �-�#3 � g�/h(��� Y��c" %���'

�AK�� �, � �-�#3 F�?a" � g�/ F�?a" �# ��?��1 @��� @��' � -�#3 F�?a" ��/�AK���" b�1�" g�/ F�?a" ��/ ���.e(-�#3 @��� @��' �i:� �# ��A)@�#

Y����!"-�#3 �� ��:�" ��/�x' ���" ��A(�j(�7D<�(#)' � ���$ ����� ��#Aa"g�/ F�? .����7 %. � 6�"�Q ���' �9��� Y?: �" Y5#2 ���a)$� � I " �� �.�

�" @�,#��� @� ��-�#3 ;6��" �� �� �/ ��� �)��A ���3 �:�1 ���" ���� ����'� � ��AY$�.

@�A��� � �� �� Z#�!1 ��j)[sso (-�#3 � =���1 ��J2� �� ���a)$� �#|�1 ��A)TWA(

2- Ausubel 4- Akman 6- Teaching with Aanalogy

1- constructivism 3- Gagne 5- Teaching with Aanalogy 7- Dellber& Duzgun

Page 171: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

171

3 �$�� ���" �)#5��)C2� I#/�a" ��#A��� ��NY��A ��� .�� ;7�6 S��)' @��' Z#�!1%'�� �� ��� ��C �� �)#5��)C2� I#/�a" � y��1�� �� ����"�� ���A @���"� �� ��)?

%'���'��� >�),� ���A @���"� .�)��� � Z#�!1 ��� �� ;7�6 S��)' �� ;7�6 ��/;#?51 %�' � �,�" � �3 �� 2�c"-�#3 ��� �� X��"� �A�,,� ��#A��� �� ��A

I/ �� � I#/�a"���� ���$ .����)[sse (1 ��#�!1 �� i#'t��J2� Z��� �� X��"� �#|-�#3 � �� �)���#4 ��A%'�� X�J' � � #+!1 Y���#4 ��#*��� � Y�5' @���"�

��� ���3 �$�� ���" .%'�� ��� @��' Z#�!1 ��� �� ;7�6 S��)' �� ���a)$� � �� �'���"�-�#3 ��J2��" X��"� �)���#4 ��A%'�� � �5���" �� �,,# �),$ X�� � �� �'���"�

�" ��� �� �$�� G2�c" �� ��)? ��C �� �'�#A�'��� �*��� � y��" @�"�� .��#�� �Y$�A ��1 � ;��1V)V��h (-�#3 ��(1 � ���: ���D�� �# y��1�� ��(�� � ��A

%'�� � 3�� ��#'� � y��"�" ���: G2�c" @�. G2�: ��� @���"���. .

��'���� �#"(3��

��#A��� ��E��� @��,� � �#<� �/��,Q �� �)T���" ��#A��� ���/�� X��"� �� �|�"�" u�c" �$DT�.� .���A ��)T���" ��#A��� � �T Y$� �'��#A��� �� �EQ�T ��/

�J��E���" ��T ��#1 ���7�2�5" �1 �,,T � �� �,/� F�('� �� �a# E1 ��,,T ;6 �� �� �,�� Y$� �T�)�" g�/)�"�#' � i1��[�V��s .(@�5'�: ��#�� �`@���E�/ �

)[sss�� ;�' ��>��3� [ssh (��' ���!" �7�< ��#. � �)T���" ��#A��� �E ��.X�� �� � #$� ����("�" @�� " @� Z��� �� �T Y$� �/ �b���. � G$�,)" �,'��1

�'�#A ��E �� @� �� � E. ��< �a5 � � Y# 3�" .� �)T���" ��#A��� X�� �#|�1 ���" � 2�c" ���,Q �� @��#A��� � #+!1 Y���#4Y$� �)��A ���3 �$�� .i��� F�/h�

%'���E�/)V�o[ (�� �� ����a'� � �)�3� ��)T���" ��#A��� ��/���/�� �|� ��#�!1 ��-DT�'��� ���3 � 2�c" ���" F� � ��/ .@��#A��� �T ��� @��' Z#�!1 �� ;7�6 S��)'

A��� ���ANG5T �$�� G2�c" � y��1�� �� ��)�# ���D�� �)T���" ��#"N��,���'.

2- Artz & Newman 4- Humphreys

1- Thiele & Treagust 3- Jhonson

Page 172: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

172

���V)[sss �>��3� �� ;�' �[ssh (%'�� ��� @��' ��< Z#�!1 �� i#' � �T �'���"��" X��"� �)T���" ��#A��� X��%'�� � �5���" �� �,,# �),$ X�� � �T �'���"�

�" Y����� �� G2�c",,T���' ��" G5T F� � �� ��R� ��/�,,T .��J�� ��$ ���" @��' Y$� �)��A F�('� @���� �� �T �1��#�!1 Bc�" �� �)T���" ��#A��� �/�

�c$�)")�����V`mm���'� ,TV`mo ��)"��T �� ;�' �V`oj (����,/�� Bc�" �)��,#�"V`mm ���T ��(1 �V`m� ����*� �V`mj ��)"��T �� ;�' �V`oj (1tY���#4 � �)��" �#|

%'�� � #+!1���� @���"�.

�#"(3�� 56�

��$��#A��� ��/[%'�� �c$�� �#{)" �� @��,� � @���"��" �� � 2�c" �� �'��1��#A ���3 �$�� ���" U )&" �.��"� ��/�J2� � �/���/�� ��& �|� � y��" .��$

��� �� ����� Y�| � �K�� ��� )$� ��#A��� ����D�� X����4 ��/�'�"��$ �������� �Y��5" ;6 � �Ca1t�" �2 �.�)�#2`�),#: �h�V��� ��9�i< �� ;�' �V`oe .( ��#A��� ��$

Y# 3�" �� ���D�� X����4 ��� ��� �!#:�1 ��#. Y$� �K�� ��#A��� ��/)�1��2�e�[sso .( ������ ��#A��� ^�$ >�" � Z�c"W����#,. W�����4 /�5"R��� �� �����

�" ���� ���7 �� �� ��#A��� G2�c" ��#A��� ��$ Z����,/� .�<� >��" @��,� ��" �#:�1 ����� ����� �� �2�6 �� �'�#J ��� @��� ��J' �� @��� X�A Z��� �� �,/��" �#:�1 �J���'�#J ��� @��� F�('� ��� �� �,/� .@��' �� 2�c" �<� �� ;7�6 S��)'

�" � y��" ��/��#' �)<�$ ����� � ��x," � �.��"� ���" ���A��$ � H��c'� �T �/�^�$%'�� G w� ��� U )&" ��#A��� ��/" @���"�zY$� ��� �|)����i< �� ;�'V`oe .(%'���$ � @���"�N�" �7�< ��#A��� ^N Y$� �EN1 F�('� �N� �$�� U#2�E

�'����] U )&" ����*�" ��#A���)v�a2�j�[ssV ������+" �� ;�' �V`oh .(4%/�K�" @��' �/^�$ �T �/�%'�� ��#A��� ��/�AK�� �� �E� @��,� � @���"���/

2- learning style 4- Ginther 6- Woolfolk

1- Arbab 3- Liu 5- Alberta

Page 173: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

173

� <��" ��&�|� � ����1 �.��"� ��/t�" �#| ���lA)�E#'�: � ;J�RV�[ssj �� ;�' �������+"V`oj (�" @� �%'�� � #+!1 Y���#4 ='����� �� ��& �'��1 �� @���"� �,T �#:�1)�,#56�2� � G5' ���K'V`oV ������+" �� ;�' �V`oj .(

[��G �� !6;� B#:�

���#<� �.��"� ���#�!1���� � � �a��� ��/X�J' �K�� ���� Y$� ��.i���)" �/��/�#{)"1 �� �a��� t�R��)6� � �#|%#4 ���� ���$ � ��#A��� �,#��/�#{)" ����'� � �/

�'��� Y#�/� �)<�,.)R���[�V�oo .( ;�� ��Ca1 ��#. � F�?a" �� @��,� � X�J'�� �N" y��" ����� ��)N���. .X�J'1 �<� -�$�� �/N���� ;C. ��#A��� ��(�"�'�. .F� � � Y�5' X�J'"F� � � Y�5' �����4 � � � �a," � Y��" -�56�

Y$�")�2���A � R����`V�oe .( � Y��" X�J' �� Y$� ��� �� ���6 �� 2�c" ����I?" F� �%#4 ;"�� ���1�,#-D� �� Y��. ��� ��,,� F� � ��/)���#'h�V��m (

@�"�� �� ;7�6 ��C �� ��" F� � ��/ �.�)@�5�#$ � @�'��e�V�oe .(-D� ��/%'�� � �3 ��(1 �F� ��" �J�� ;"��� ���$ � F� � @�� " �F� � ����� @���"� �,'��1

%'�� X�J' �1 F� � � Y�5' @���"�t�'��lJ �#|)�"��2 � >��"m�V��o .(I?" ���1%'�� �� Y5/ ��� F� � � Y�5' X�J' � 2�c" �� �)C' � ;���1 F�� �� ;���1 @���"�

��" �$��" �� �� F� � ��#A�� ���i# �� �3D� �� � �?'� �� Y5#' �#,Q ��� � �'��"� �'��A �$��" ���� F� � -�� � Y�5' �#2��)��2���A �R���V�oe .( G5� � @�,#���

Y#���" ��(1%'�� �F� � X��"� k��. �� Y��" -�56� �).�� � i#"� �� @���"�Y#���" � Y�5'�(1 �� @�.Y<�$ �/��< ����#"� ��,�� �� �� � � .�?'� ���� ��,

g�/ Y��" X�J'/��< G5� F� � � Y�5' �,"N'� ��� F� � ��#A��� � ��� �,N�� �?�� �/��< �,��.�< �A�'� @���� F��1 .�a," X�J' F� � -�� �� �?'� �A� ��#,��/

�J' � ��� �,/��< �,):� F� � ��#A��� �� �,.� �).��@�,��/ F� � � Y�5' �a," X

2- Koballa 4- Neathery 6- Morrell & Lederman

1- Liegle & Janiki 3- Crawley 5- Cannon & Simpson

Page 174: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

174

�A�'� �� Y��� �/��< � $�1 @�.)��#2� � @�5]�#$V�V��s .( ����� ���)5A ���#�!1%'�� X�J' �$�� � @�� " �:�1 F� � � Y�5' @���"� G : ��< � �� F� � @�#�"

Y$� ���� .%'�� �3D� %��i�� ��x," � F� � X��"� � y��" B"�(" �� @���"�XD1 Y$� �)��A ���7 F� � =���1 uD7� Y?: ���/)�#2[�V��o .( � �,��R�/

�5' �'�.`)V�o[ (�)<���4 ;"��� �� ���� 1 ������A �X�J' � �� �'� %'�� @���"�� Y�5'���� �c�� F� � .��#. �;"�. ;"��� ���1 �@�� " X�J' �=���1 ��/t�#|

��$ ��$ �=,: ����2�� ����� � "�: ��A��� �� {. Z9D� �@��#A��� �)<�,. ��/Y$� Y���#4 � F� � .�" @��' �)��A F�('� �� 2�c" X�J' � X��"� ��#. �� �/�

%'��1 F� � � Y�5' @���"�t���� �#|.

��/�)#4 �h)V�o[ (Y���#4 @�"�� �� �� �'��#A��� �'��� @��' ��< Z#�!1 ���" G5� ��R� ����' F� � � #+!1 i#' X�J' @�"�� �� �,,���, " ��� ���' ����

�" G5� ��R��,,� .���1�e)V�mo ��:�$�� �� ;�' �[sso (� 2�c" ������� X� �� � #+!1 Y���#4 � �3D� �# y��1��%#4 F� � � �3D� �� Y����,# Y���#4 ��,,�

���' ��Y$� F� � ��/ .�" @��' �)��A F�('� �� 2�c" �$�� � X�J' �# �� �/� ��:� y��1�� � #+!1 Y���#4 � F� � � Y�5' X�J' �# �#,��/ � �.��"� ��#.

�R��)6� � �����" F� � � Y�5' X�J' @�"�� ���' Z��� �� %#4 � @��1 Y���#4 �,# Y<���4 @��#A��� � #+!1)�:�$��j�[sso (I#�+1 � =���1 ��$ ���#A ��/

I?" @�� " �.��"�%'�� X�J' �� �|�" ;"�� ���1Y$� F� � � Y�5' @���"� );4 � =���:m�[sse .(�R��)6� F� � � Y��" X�J' � @�����-D� �� Y��� ���/

�"��� k�*�" � @� �� �� �'�.�" �#A�� ��#A I " Y���6 �� ��'�.N@�� " � �'�����<� �" @��' ��< �� �����' � ��C)� =���1 ��/���/�� �� ���a)$� �� �,/�)=1�� � ����"o�

V��[ .('���' �$�� ����*�" =���1 ��� �3�#).� � @�,#��� ��� � @��1 �� �'�� "N�

2- Lin 4- Hough, Piter 6- Adeseji 8- Myers & Fouts

1- Oliver 3- Halladyna & Shanghnessy 5- Atwood 7- Jarvis & Pell

Page 175: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

175

��#. ���" ���a)$� �)�� >� � =���1 ��/ ���a)$� >� ��#w =���1 ��#. �� �)�# � �,,��">��$ � � �,,�%'�� ��/ @���"����' r$�4 �|�" ��� �,/�)@�5� � @��#$V�

V��j .(%'����"�Y.�� �,/��< �a," X�J' F� � � Y�5' �'�� " �#,Q @� .@�� " ���3 ������ ���" �� ���D�� �9��� �J'�JQ � ���� �:�1 @�A�'�#A��� ��/��#' � �"����

�"�,/�.

%/�K4 �� � =���1 ��&�|� �?,1 Y$� �)��A F�('� ���T �� 0��< �� �T ���/-�#3 ��J2����� � ��A#A��� ��/Y$� �)��A ���3 �$�� ���" �� .�+3 Z#�!1 ���

1 �$�� � ��D� ����t-�#3 � =���1 ��J2� �#| �)T���" ��#A��� � �5���" �� ��A���� �-�#3 �� ���a)$� � "� 1 �|� �F� � � Y�5' X�J' � ��#A��� ��/��A ��/

��$ � �� �)T���" ��#A��� � �.��"��� �!#:�1 ��#A��� ��/%'���� � @���"���/ �/� ���3 �$�� ���" ��#A��� .

7���w"2K$ ��

V(1t-�#3 ��J2� � =���1 �#|���� � �)T���" ��#A��� � �5���" �� ��A ��/%'�� ��#A����Y$� �'�JQ ���a)" �!#:�1 ��#A��� ^�$ ����� @���"�

[(1t-�#3 � =���1 ��J2� �� ���a)$� �#|A��� � ��A X�J' � �)T���" ��#%'���" �'�JQ F� � � Y�5' @���"���.�

B�� �� ;E�)" �'��'Vsm%'�� �)<� ��"�VhWV`�#6�' ����,/�� F�$ -DT ��?Q �2�$[

� #+!1 >�$ �� i���1 �?.�sW�V� �T ��� �.�< ����+1 ����'�� ��. �&)'� �� .

���� }#b

��#' u�� �� � 2�c" ��� ������A ���a)$� ����"�� .� -DT ��?Q� ����+1 ���@��,�

1- Obsorn & Simon

Page 176: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

176

AN���T ���A � ����"�� ��/N�'�. �## 1 >�), .��"�� ���A ��N^� ��)[m�a' (-�#3 ��J2� �� ���a)$� � F� � I#/�a" �� ����"�� ���A �� ��. =���1 ��A)[e�a' (

%'��1 ��A -�#3 @���"� ���A�� ��'���' Y����� �"�'� H�� @��,� � �� �,)" �!#*� �$ ����"��)[j�a' (�� � �. ���� X��"� �)T���" ��#A��� X�� � F� � I#/�a" >�),T ���A)[��a' (�),$ ��#. � �x' ���" I#/�a")�!#*�1 (�. =���1 .

�� �)5�� �#{)" �� � ;�)5" �#{)" �� �� ;C�)" Z#�!1 ���.��#. U )&" ��/��$ � =���1���� � ;�)5" ��/�#{)" �!#:�1 ��#A��� ��/ X�J' � ��#A��� ��/

�'��� ;#C�1 �� �)5�� ��/�#{)" F� � � Y�5' .Y���#4 @�"�� � 2�c" �� �� ��#. � #+!1)v��W%'�� (^�$ �"�,�$�4 �X�J' -�#�" ��!#:�1 ��#A��� ��/

� %'�� ��� � F� � � Y�5'�. ��:� @���" .����. >��: �� � 2�c" ��� ��/�K4 u��)V(Y$� ��. ���� %���':

7� P)�(���� }#b [�#(��3 4�#( " ���)� � ����H W ���)�

����"��V��#. � #+!1 Y���#4 @�"�� F� � � Y�5' X�J' -�#3 ��J2� � =���1��A��#. � #+!1 Y���#4 @�"��

F� � � Y�5' X�J'

����"��[��#. � #+!1 Y���#4 @�"�� F� � � Y�5' X�J'

�!#*�1 ��A -�#3 �9����,)"

��#. � #+!1 Y���#4 @�"��F� � � Y�5' X�J'

����"��`��#. � #+!1 Y���#4 @�"�� F� � � Y�5' X�J' �)T���" ��#A��� ��#. � #+!1 Y���#4 @�"��

F� � � Y�5' X�J'

>�),T 1 Y���#4 @�"����#. � #+! F� � � Y�5' X�J' �),$ =���1 ��#. � #+!1 Y���#4 @�"��

F� � � Y�5' X�J'

4)� �� ����U���#"( �� �)$�?� �Z#�!1 ��� ��ma2z" �� ��#. �� � F�?a" ��#*�1 ��� �$�� �)� @

@� -�#3 �� �/�. �#?1 �'�� ���� ���a)$� ��A ./�a" =���1 ����� ����3 ��x," � I#�N$� �� N�:��&) N��#. �-�#3 1 X�� �� ��AN" ����� �## N�.R ����)!V)V�me (

1- Lawshe

Page 177: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

177

�. ���a)$� .�� X�� ��� ��o� F� � -�� I " ����3 @��,� �1 �. �)$��< @�A�,,��a#� �$ ��C#2 -�#�" �� )Ia2�&" �F���' ��x' �I����" (�� ���a)$� �� �� @�.��< �x'

.��# -�#3 �,���' FD�� �:��&)$� I#/�a" =���1 ��� ��A .��.R >�"�� -�$� � �c$ �� �:��&)$� �� � I#/�a" �� �� �/ ��� ����)!" ����� Y�5'se/sp<

�, "�� ��� .@�"�� �� ���D�� ������A ��� ��J�� ��$ �� � #+!1 Y���#4 ��/ X�J' -�#�" � �!#:�1 ��#A��� ^�$ �F� ��. ���a)$� F� � � Y�5' .�R��$

��!" b$�1 %'�� � v�� �c#6 �� �� F� � I#/�a" � � y��"�����A �#?1 @.=]$j���A�$ � @�� " �� �a' ����� � �'��� ���3 �$�� ���" �� @�"�� ���)!" F� � ��/

1 �� @� ����)!"t�'��� �#� .���T X�� � F� � � #+!1 Y���#4 @�"�� �����4 @�$������[sG#1�1 � %'�� � v�� �c#6 ��� js/s�j[/s����A ��$�!" .

%'�� ��#A��� ^�$ %(,$ ��� �*�6 Z#�!1 g�/ � �:�1 ��"�,�$�4 �� @���"� ^�$§�� �!#:�1 ��#A��� ��/[�. ���a)$� .� ��C#2 -�#�" �� §�� �"�,�$�4

� ��$ �$ �� Y$� ��. ����1 ���A ��?Q � Y5#� ����#,. ������� ��#A�� �����4 /�" ����'� �� �5"R��#A .@����� Z#�!1 �� �"�,�$�4 ��� �����4 � ���)��`)[sss ;�' �

@�1����h�[sVs (1 ���"tY$� �)��A���3 �#� .b$�1 ��)� �"�,�$�4 i#' �*�6 Z#�!1 ����!"��� �1 �$ ��#)<� �� ���7 ����� �## 1 Y?: =]$ ��. ��:�1 @G6�7 @��x'

1 ���" @� ���7 ����� �1��##{1 � �T Y��AtY��A ���3 �#� .� @�"�� �'��� �'�5�/ ���'��T ��a2� G��* �� ���a)$�om/s1 �T ����A ��$�!" t@�"�� ���$ ����� � ��#�

�" ��Tl"�.� .� ��� �T �. ��$�!" ���"���� X���� ���a)$� � @�"�� �����4mj/s����A.

�"�,�$�4 @���!" Z#�!1 ��� �� Y�5' X�J' ����� ��N����1 �� � �,)<�$ F� � ����A-�#�" �� @� ��/' ��/N�"�. � ��,� ��#*��� � Y�5' X�JV)V�mj (' �NX�J

2- Barch 4- Erton

1- Lawshe 3- Doyran 5- Fennema & Sherman

Page 178: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

178

����A�i1 � �)2�$ ��#. � Y�5'V)[ssh ($��'��� ���a) .�� ;E�)" �"�,�$�4 ��� `s�a#� S,4 ��E#2 -�#�" �� � ���A)�D"�T�D"�T �Ia2�&" �F���' ��x' �I����" �I����"

Ia2�&" (%'�� X�J' �T ��F� � ��"������< �,#"� �� �� @���"� )`s�[j�Vh�V`�Vs �`(F� � -�� � �3D�)[m�[V�V����m�V(�� ����.�F� � -)[o�[h�Vj �VV�h(F� � ��,"��$)[��[e�[`�[s�Ve�V[�j�e(F� � ��c*� �)[[�o�[ (�" ����'� ��Y��A .���A �"�,�$�4 ��� �� ��/[�j�Vs�V`�Vh�Vm�[V�[e�[�

%'�� �a," X�J'�" ����'� �� @���"�%'�� � Y��A���A ��� �� �� �/ � �� �'���"� �/ ���' �,).�� ;"�� Ya2�&"e�" G5� �'��� .���A ��/`s�[o�[m�[j �[h�[`�[[�

[s �V��Vo�Vj�Ve�V[�VV���o�m�e�h�`�V%'�� Y��" X�J' F� � � �� @���"��" ����'�%'�� � Y��A���A ��� �� ���/ � �� �'���"� ���' �,).�� ;"�� Y����" �/e�" G5��'��� .R����' ���1%'�� @�"�� ��� �� �� ���" @���"� �,,� G5� �,)5'��1

Ves�#��4 ����' ���1`s�� .���A �R� ����' �#J'�#"=4 �� �/ X�J' @�"��%#4 ����' �#J'�#" �� F� � � Y�5' � F� � -�� � �?'� Y��" X�J' �� ���6 @�"��

���A �#��4 ����' �#J'�#"=4 �� �/J' @�"�� ����' �#J'�#" �� F� � � Y�5' X�%#4�. �)��A �x' �� �a," X�J' @��,� � @�"�� .�"�,�$�4 ����)!" � ���7 �����

>���­� � �(,5'��� �#1�$� �� �a' �� � �)#�1 �$�,�'��� @�++&)" �� �a' �� b$�1���41 ���" ���##{1 �t�. ���"� ��:� ��� � Y��A ���3 �#� .'��� �'�5�/ � �"�,�$�4 �

���'��T ��a2� G��* �� ���a)$�o[/s1 �T����A ��$�!" t�� @� ���$ ����� � ��#� .I/,Q���"���� X�� �� ���a)$� � �"�,�$�4 �����4 G��* ��#mV/s�T �. ��$�!"

�� �2��3 ;�3 G��*.

�#P� 4�",

1 ��NT �*�6 Z#�!N-D �/�1 ���NA � ����+N����"�� ��/�N1 ��N��J2� � =���-�#33 �9��� ���AN-�# �,)" �!#*�1 ��AN�� @��,�N� �)T���" ��#A��� ��"�'� H�

1- Salta & Tzougraki

Page 179: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

179

�'����A �## 1 >�),T ���A .����"�� ���A I " �V)-�#3 ��J2� � =���1��A (���N�,/�� � ��!#*�1 �.��"� �5 : ^N������ F�R ��/ ��J2� � =���1 ��!' ��

-�#3�. ���� ��A .1 �.��"� S#C4 =]$t�� F� � @�� " � @�++&)" b$�1 ��. �#��,T ���a)$� �?'� �� �x' ���" I#/�a" =���1 F�J,/ �1 Y��A ���3 �� ��#)<� .���A ��

����"��[)-�#3 �9���� �,)" �!#*�1 ��A�"�'� H�� @��,� (� �� I#/�a" I "X�� %'�� �� =]$ ����T =���1 �),$�" @���"�-�#3 �1 Y$��< �T �,)" �!#*�1 ��A

�" ���� ���3 �?'� ��#)<� ��� �.�,,T � 2�c" �"�'� H�� Y#2� � @��,� .����"�� ���A �� `)�)T���" ��#A��� (%'�� � �� I#/�a" �)T���" ��#A��� X�� � I " @���"�

�" X��"���� .�A���" =���1 �),$ X�� � �x' ���" I#/�a" i#' >�),T ���..����,��T >���­� �� ;�3 Z#�!1 ���%#4 �����"�� ��/@�"�� Y���#4 � y��" ��/

���A F��1 �� F� � � Y�5' X�J' � ��#. � #+!1�. ��:� �/ .I#/�a" X��"� �� � �x' ���")>�"�'�� G#T�1 � ��1� �'�#4 ���1� ��/ (Q ��N�5 : ��?he3�N��# ���

=4@�"�� ��Tl" ���A ��?Q �� F� � � Y�5' X�J' � ��#. � #+!1 Y���#4 ��/Y��A F�('�.

������

���� ;# !1 � ��i(1 ��� Z#�!1 ��� ��F�' �� �/ ���"� ��i��SPSS (17) �. ���a)$� .����. >��:)[(D)<� ����' ����'�)$� g��!'� � �#J'�#"%#4 g=4 �� @�"�� @�"��

�������A �� �� %'�� � v�� ��#A��� ��/ ^�$ �$ -�$� � >�),T � ����"�� ��/�" @��' ���4 � ����#,. ������� ��#A����/� .>��: �� 0��," ���D�� � �:�1 �

)[(%#4 gD)<� ����' �#J'�#" �#=4 �� @�"������ @�"�� � v�� ��#A��� ��/%'�����A ���a1 ���4 � ����#,. ������� ��#A��� ^�$ �$ �� >�),T � ����"�� ��/

���A �� ^� �/ �� �2� ���� ��:� ��#A��� ^�$ ��!2 � >�),T � ����"�� ��/%#4 gD)<� ����' �#J'�#" �# ����4 � ����#,. �������=4 �� @�"������ @�"�� ��/

" ;�3 ���a1 %'�� � v�� ��#A����x6D��' ��/��" ����. .

Page 180: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

180

7� P)0(��"�g�� =�#K�� � �":g" =8��� 9�#%� 3�� ���W )� ���)���3 � \�3 ���)� �3 4�#(7#��H � �����)� ��

4�#( �� 43)�� �#"(3��

�#"(3�� Z6� �K"P#$

�":��"� ��.���"&�

3� &$���%�

v�� ����#,. ������

���4

oe/eV/j

j

hV/[s[/[[V/[

-�#3 � =���1��A

%'�� ����#,. ������

���4

h[/hV/ho/`

V`/V[m/V[[/V

[m

v�� ����#,. ������

���4

`/VVoe/s

[o/Vhh/[V`/`[e

-�#3 �9�����A �,)" �!#*�1

%'�� ����#,. ������

���4

j`/V[o/VmV/s

o/sho/ssj/V

v�� ����#,. ������

���4

hm/mV/mh/j

[je/[m/[

)T���" ��#A��� �

%'�� ����#,. ������

���4

VV/ehh

Vj/Vme/Veo/V

[j

v�� ����#,. ������

���4

``/`mm/hm[/[

[h/`[m/`m/V[�

>�),T

%'�� ����#,. ������

���4

VV/`mm/[eh/[

j�/VVj/[``/[

$�� ��� ��'�" @�"�� �� Z#�!1 >�� >��$ �)MANOWA (�. ���a)$� .�� ;�3 @�"�� ���:�)MANOWA (='����� =��1�" �,J�/ �*��a"W� #$� � ='������T

Page 181: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

181

Y��A ���3 �$�� ���" =T� F� ���"� .�, " F�� ����F=T� F� @�"�� �� 1t� ��#�='����� =��1�" �,J�/ �*��a"W�" ='������T�.� .I/;7�6 S��)' � �:�1 � �#,Q ����. >��: �� �T @�2 @�"�� ��)`(���� ='����� ���� �*��a" Y$� ��. �9��� ��/

���A �� %'�� � v�� ��#A���1 ���" >�),T � ����"�� ��/tY��A ���3 �#� .7� P)?(W������ �#��#� �_�#*� ���#� ��#� ��< ���)�43)�� ���#"(3�� ��

3)��4�#"(3�� �� Fdf1df2��&� ~.����3v�� [/sVV�e`e/V%'�� VV/sVV�esj/s

�, " �## 1 Y?: ^�$ � ���A ;"� 1 � �!#:�1 ��#A��� ^�$ ����A ���|� �������� � �!#:�1 ��#A����. ���a)$� ��D#4 @�"�� �� ��#A��� ��/ ;7�6 S��)' �T

���A �# ��� @��' ;3��6 �/���� �� �E� �� ��#A��� ��/)%'�� �� v�� (�, " ���a1��� )[e/s=Eta�ssV/s=P�sh/VV=F(190,6 ) (^�$ ��!2 � �2� ���� ��:� ��#A��� ��/

���� �# ���4 � ������ �����#,.���A ��#A��� ��/ ���a1 >�),T � ����"�� ��/�, " ���)s`/s=Eta�Vj/s=P�j`/V=F(190,4 ) (:�����' �� .A � "� 1 �|� �#,��/N���

#A��� ^�$ �N�, " �!#:�1 ����� )s[/s=Eta��m/s=P�`j/s=F(190,12 ) (��'�.� .����. >��: �� ;7�6 S��)')h(Y$� ��. �9���:

7� P)I(43)�� 4#"+�� �Q W������ 1"�K$ �3 ��8" ���)� �� 2��#"(3�� ��

���)�B)��F�3�)� �P�3�3�)� �P�3~.��������A��D#4eV/ss[/VVjV�sssV/s[e/s

��#A��� ^�$��D#4sj/sj`/VhV�sVj/s`s/s���A*��#A��� ^�$��D#4sh/s`j/sV[V�s�m/ss[/s

;# !1 ��D#4 @�"�� �� ��"� Y$� S��)' � �:�1 �|� � y��" ��/�# ��� �'��"���/����. >��: �� ;7�6 S��)' �T Y��A �$�� ���")e(Y$� ��. �9��� .;# !1 S��)'

%#4 gD)<� ����' ��� ��#{)"�,Q ='������=4 �� @�"����� @�"��v�� ��#A��� ��/

Page 182: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

182

���A �� %'�� ��" @��' >�),T � ����"�� ��/���A �# ���a1 �T �/���� �� �/��/ �v�� ��#A��)hm/s=Eta�ssse/s=P�s`/[o=F(95,3) ( %'�� �)`�/s=Eta�ssV/s=P

�j[/[s=F(95,3 )(�, "�" ����.�.7� P)N(43)�� #� 4�#( 9�#@� 4#"+�� �Q W������ 1"�K$ x�����#"(3�� ��

#""+$ q���� SS dfMSFPEta ���A v���/es[`j`/Vjms`/[ossV/shm/s

%'��s�/VeV``�/ej[/[sssV/s`�/s�c< v���o/ejm�e �m/eWWW

%'��jm/[`V�eh`/[WWW

���A �# ���a1 �5���" Y?:%#4 gD)<� ����' �#J'�#" �� �/=4 �� @�"�� @�"������ �� ;7�6 S��)' �T �. ���a)$� �'��a, ;�� 1 @�"�� �� %'�� � v�� ��#A��� ��/

>��: ����.)j(Y$� ��. �9��� .@��/�" ��/��" �T �'�A��. ����' �#J'�#" �#%#4 gD)<�=4 �� @�"������ @�"�� ��J2� X�� � =���1 ���A v�� ��#A��� ��/

-�#3���A � ��A-�#3 �9��� ��/�, " ���a1 >�),T � �,)" �!#*�1 ��A ��:� ���%#4 gD)<� ����' �#J'�#" � ���� �� @�"��=4%'�� @�"�� � =���1 ���A @���"�

-�#3 ��J2����� �� ��A gD)<� ����' �#J'�#" �� �)�# %'�� � v�� ��#A��� ��/%#4=4 �� @�"��%'�� @�"�����A @���"�-�#3 �9��� ��/ >�),T � �,)" �!#*�1 ��A

�"�.� .�T �,Q �/ %#4 gD)<� ����' �#J'�#" �#=4 �� @�"�� @�"������ ��/-�#3 ��J2� X�� � =���1 ���A %'�� � v�� ��#A����)T���" ��#A��� ���A � ��A

�, " ���"� ��!2 � �2� ���� ��:� ���a1Y5#' ��� .I/����' �#J'�#" �# �#,Q%#4 gD)<�=4 �� @�"������ @�"��-�#3 �9��� ���A %'�� � v�� ��#A��� ��/ ��A

��A � �,)" �!#*�1�� �)T���" ��#A��� ���A � >�),T� �)T���" ��#A��� ��/�, " ���a1 >�),T ���A%'�� � ���� ��:� ��� �5���" �� �)T���" ��#A��� ���A @���"�

���A �-�#3 �9��� ��/%#4 gD)<� ����' �#J'�#" >�),T � �,)" �!#*�1 ��A @�"��

Page 183: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

183

=4 ������ �� ��R� @�"���� ��#A��� ��/�'��� %'�� � v.�#�/ ��!2 � ������������' �#J'�#" �� >�),T � �)T���" ��#A��� ���A �# �%'�� � v�� ��#A��� ��/

%#4 gD)<�=4 �� @�"���, " ���a1 @�"�� gD)<� ����' �#J'�#" � ���� ��:� ���%#4=4 �� @�"��%'�� @�"��� �� �)�# �)T���" ��#A��� ���A @���"� @���"� %'�

�" >�),T ���A�.�.7� P )M(" =8��� 9�#%� �":��"� �"� 9��*$ �""&$ ��#� ���#*�� 1� &$ ���)� )� ���)�

W 43)�� ���)���3 � \�3 �#"(3�� �� �#"(3�� 43)��4�#(�4�#(0~.� ��.� �":��"� ��"&� ��&����3

v�� ��J2� � =���1-�#3��A

-�#3 �9�����A �!#*�1 �,)"

��#A����)T���">�),T

oo/hVV/VW

hh/[

jm/sjm/sje/s

ssV/sj/s

ss[/s-�#3 �9��� ��A

�,)" �!#*�1 �)T���" ��#A���

>�),T ��/eWh`/[W

jo/sjj/s

ssV/sss`/s

�)T���" ��#A���>�),T ej/`jj/sssV/s%'�� ��J2� � X��"�

-�#3��A -�#3 �9���#*�1 ��A �!

�,)" ��#A����)T���">�),T

m�/[`V/sW

[o/V

h`/sh[/shV/s

ssV/sVsV/s

-�#3 �9��� ��A�,)" �!#*�1

��#A����)T���">�),TV/`WeV/VW

h`/shh/s

ssV/sssh/s

�)T���" ��#A���>�),T e�/Vh[/ss[/s

*P<0/01

='������T ;# !1 �� Z#�!1 F�� >��$ �$�� ���)ANCOVA (�. ���a)$� .�$�� @�"�� ���:� �� %#4����� �1�"��" ��/ �*��a" �� �c&1 F�� �c< ��/

='����� �,J�/ �@�� �/)`[/s=P�Vj/V=F(105,3) (G#. �,J�/ �@�#$�A� ��/ )oj/s=P�[h/V=F(101,3)(Y��A F�('�.

����. >��: )m(�#J'�#"=4 ��. ;�� 1 ��/� Y�5' X�J' @�"�� �� F� � -�#3 ��J2� � =���1 ��/��A-�#3 �9��� ���A ��#A��� ��,)" �!#*�1 ��A

Page 184: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

184

�" @��' �� >�),T � �)T���"�/� .@��/�" ��/��" �T �'�A���A ���A � >�),T ��/-�#3 �9���=4 �� �,)" �!#*�1 ��A ����' �#J'�#" F� � � Y�5' X�J' @�"���'��� ��R�.

7� P)>(�":��"�W 4 , 1� &$ �� � �����)� �� 4�#( �3 [��G �� !6;� B#:� ���)�7#��H ��;��� #"+�� :[��G �� !6;� B#:�

4�#( �":��"� ��"&� ��.� � =���1 -�#3��A

-�#3 �9����,)" �!#*�1 ��A �)T���" ��#A���

>�),T

�j/VVV V`/VVh jo/VVV [[/VVj

oo/VVe/[j/[

oe/V

����. >��:)o(^1 ='������T ;# !1 S��)' � Y�5' X�J' � ���A �|� ��#{)"�" @��' �� F� ��/� .�, " F�� � �:�1 � @�"�� ����F)hh/s=Eta �`/s=P�

[[/V=F(1.4.],3)(%#4 ����' �#J'�#" ;�� 1 �� � ���a1 �F� � � Y�5' X�J' @�"�� ���A �#=4 �� >�),T � ����"�� ��/ X�J' @�"���, " F� � � Y�5'Y5#' ���.

7� P)V(Z$W�������H 1"�K$ x����[��G �� !6;� B#:� #� 4�#( #@� �#"+��

#""+$ q���� SSdf MSFPEta � � � Y�5' X�J' @�"�� %#4Foe/o�m[Voe/o�m[[V/ohsss/shh/s

���A [�/s`V/V`s[[/V`/ss`/s�c< em/VVsosVsh eh/Vsj WWW

��"�� � dK��#"( >�$ ���" Y���6 ��A��� ��� �� �#<� ��/%'�� b$�1 ��. �)<�$ %'�� �� ��. @���"�

Y# 3�" ���$ � >��)'� ;�3 � ��� �,"��$�" ��#A��� ��/�.� ./ �� Z#�!1 �)$�� �#�1 Y.�� �+3 �*�6t-�#3 ��J2� � =���1 �.��"� ��E��� �� �#| ��#A��� � ��A

Page 185: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

185

^�$ � ;"� 1 �� �� �)T���"���� � �!#:�1 ��#A��� ��/ X�J' � ��#A��� ��/�/� ���3 �$�� ���" F� � � Y�5'.

�)���%'�� ��� @��' Z#�!1 ��� �� ;7�6 ��/� I#/�a" �T �'���"� X�� � �� �$�-�#3 ��J2� � =���1�" Y����� ��A%'�� � �5���" �� �,���' �T >�),T ���A @���"�

�),$ X�� �)�!#*�1 (�" =���1 �?'� � I#/�a" =4 �� ��R� ����' �#J'�#" ��.@�"���" G5T %'�� � v�� ��/�,,T .�" @��' ���#�!1 ���� 1 �� ;7�6 S��)' �/�

���a)$� ���, " I?� %��i�� G�$ F� � ��#A��� � =���1 �� ��A -�#3 �� I#/�a" ����" ��#�#4 �� � ���A)�Y$�A ��1 �@�5���/V��`�'� �V�V��`�R ���DA �[�

@�5�#A`i,#T��/ �h�V��j .( �'� ��#�� �)V��` (-�#3��A �� �,)5/ �����4 ��i� �/�" ;#?51 �� @�#�?� � ����,,� .@���!"�" ��?�� �J�� F� � ��#A��� �� �� �'���

-�#3��A�" �,"��$ �"�?a" �##{1 ��� �/ �,.�)��1 �@�5���/ �Y$�AV��` �;��1 �;�� @�e�Y$�J��1 �V��e .(-�#3 >R�)$� �#,Q I/�" ��A �2t5" ;6 � ��� �'��1

�,� ;#?51 ��)Y���j�V��V .(�x6D" ;�3 �/��. ��J�� ��$ ��:� �� �� ���� ��%'���� @���"� -D� �:��" �1DC�" � ���i)'� � ��#�#4 I#/�a" I?� �� F� � ��/

�,)5/)�@�A��� � �� ��[sso .( �� �+&. ��(1 � ª3�,1 �� I#/�a" ��� G w��" ��"��� �A�'��,.� .Y5�� � ^�i#� �C ��#. �� �?,1 �' ;C�" ��� I/ �$�,.

�" ��/��"���A .���� <��" ª3�,)" ��#9i: ����� I#/�a" ��� � �� w ����� ��/-�#3 �?'� �# �� �� Y$� �)��A ���7��A �##{1 ����x' ��(�� ��� ��,"��#' ��i� �/

Y$� ��� >R�)$� � F�?a" ��� ��,/� >�")�#2 � ���Qm�[sse�,2�� �o�[ssj.(

%'�� �T ����A �&�" Z#�!1 ��� ��1 ���A @���"�-�#3 ��J2� � =��� � ��A���� >�),T ��#A��� ��/N%'�� �� ��)?@���"� AN3 �9��� ���N-�#�,)" �!#*�1 ��A

2- Law 4- Hawkins 6- Duite 8- Roland

1- Wong 3- Gibson 5- Venville 7- Chiu & Lin

Page 186: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

186

�'��� .��/�T�1 � ��DA Z#�!1 �� ;7�6 S��)' � �)��� ���V)V��o (���� �'��&�/�' .��.�/�T�1 � ��DA ��#��)V��o (-�#3 �9��� ��� Fi#'�C" ���)? �,)" �!#*�1 ��A

Y$� �.��"� Y5��� .-�#3 �� ���AK�� ��!#*�1 ��A � ���"�x' ��c -�#3 ��/�AK���" ���� Y��c" g�/ ��/ >� � �,/� ���$���+1 � �"D� ��/�,���� ���.

�"� ��� � �'�. �/�,�����" Y���6 �� �J��J� ;��)" ����,,T .-�#3��A ��/�" I/��� ��#A��� ��� ��,�.��� �,#"� �!#*�1�,,� .���"�x' Y��c" %���' �

�AK�� -�#3 � g�/ I#/�a" ��/�-�#3 ������� � �"DT ���7��A�" �/ �,'��1�� �,,� ;#?51 �� �#*�1 � y��" �)<�,. ��/�,�����" �)��� �#,Q �##�1 �T YaA @��1

-�#3 =]$ �����A =���1 �'��,&$ X�� � �$�� I#/�a" ��)� �*�6 Z#�!1 ����A %'�� � ���*� Y#2� � ^� @��,� � �,)" �!#*�1 �9��� I#/�a" � 2�c" Y?: @���"�

�"%'�� �E,�� � �,�" Z#3� ���D�� � �.-�#3 @���"� 2�c" �� ��. �9��� ��A ����T�)5'��1 �T ��� �� � �'� ��T �2�6 �� ����' ��:� �,,T v�� �� ��. �9��� ��J2� �'�

%'���E�/ � ��DA)V��m (%'�� ��� � ��< Z#�!1 �� Y?: I?' -D� @���"��i:� ;"�. �� >� $ � y��" I#/�a" =���1��� �?,1 �� �?'� ��C �� � >� $ � 7�

-�#3 � �,)�" �)"$� ��A�'��� ���a) .%'�� �� G#1�1 ��� �� >�),T ���A @���"�%'�� � �'��� Y����� �x' ���" I#/�a" ����� ����'�)$� �!#*�1 �)" ���A @���"�

-�#3 � �,)�" �)" ����"�� �� ���� �5���" �'�<��� �� � �� >� $ �� �)���#4 ��A�'��T � 2�c" .%'�� ��� @��' Z#�!1 �� ;7�6 S��)'-�#3 � �,)�" �)" �� �'���"���A

� Y����� �� �)���#4N%'�� � �5���" �� �'��'���"�N@�� �!#*�1 �)" �?,1 �� �-�#3�'���� ��� � �� >� $ ����� ��. �9��� ���D�� ���)�# �'�'��< �� ��A .��,

���A �# ���a1 �*�6 Z#�!1 �� ����-�#3 ��J2� �9��� ��/�!#*�1 ��A � �,)" �" �� >�),T ���A � �"�'� H�� @��,� ���a)" �!#*�1 ��#. �#x' � "��� � @��1

I " ����1�� �D"� 1 � @�� " W%'�� ��T �#:�1 ��"� .�# ���a1 �J�� ��$ ��"N1 ���A �� %'�� � v�� ����' �#J'�#N-�#3 ��J2� � =�����J2� �9��� ���A � ��A

1- Takahashi

Page 187: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

187

-�#3� �,)" �!#*�1 ��A�" �� �"�'� H�� @��,���'��$ ��E��� -�$� � @��1 ����A%'�� >� � %�' � �:�1 � �-�#3 ��J2� � =���1 ���A @���"� � I?� � v�� �� ��A

���D�� � @�#�& �, ")�U#$ �� ;�'V`oj (��T �##�1.

J'�#" �# �T ��� @��' Z#�!1 ��� �� ;7�6 �)������A %'�� � v�� ����' �# ��/-�#3 ��J2� � =���1�, " ���a1 �)T���" ��#A��� � ��A����' ��:� ���� .�:�1 �

-�#3 ��J2� � =���1 �T ��� � ���x' �� ���� �� �/ �)T���" ��#A��� � ��A��'��$ ��#A����)��� �#,Q ��'��� ����AY5#' ��x)'� �� ��� �� .4�Q�� � ����#2���V

)V��[ �@�5���/ �� ;�' �V��[ (X�� X��"� -�$� ��.��"� ��/[��'��$ �� ����A-�#3 �� Y���6�" ��?,�#4 ��A-�#3 �� �,,���� )$� � ��A`���x' �# Y$� �C�"

%'�� � � ���� ��(�� y��1�� ;�� ��A�'� @� �� �� ���#'� �� �, " �)<�$ �� @���"��",'�$� ���� �,,�N�.1 �?'� t" �#�N�����'� �,,���: ��/N%'�� �� �� �� @���"�

-���" �:��" @� � F� � ��/���� ���3 �?'� �"�?a" �c#6 �� 0��< G w� �'�. .��� �A�����'�-�#3 � #$� �/ � �����A ��� �)6�� � �'��A �)5��/ ���" ��/�J2� � ��A

%'�� I?��" %��i�� k�*�" �� @���"���� .��c," ���x' � Z�c" �J�� ��$ ���E51�J�� �.� �����1h� �'��' @��,� YT���" ����A b$�1 %'�� �A�'��$ �� ��

�" �56 � ��#A��� I?" b���. �� �E� ����):� ���)�U#$ �� ;�'V`oj (��#A��� �� �)T���"��'��$ �.��"� ��#. @��,����A�1 ����):� t���� � �)��" �#|��#A��� ��/

%'�� ���� @���"�)@�£����e�[ss[.(

�)��� ��%'�� �T �� ��� �*�6 Z#�!1 �J�� ��/ �� �)T���" ��#A��� ���A @���"����A � �5���"-�#3 �9��� ��/� �,)" �!#*�1 ��A �� >�),T � �"�'� H�� @��,�

=4�)��� � �T �'��T G5T ��)�# ����' %'�� � v�� @�"��/Z#�!1 �� ;7�6 ��)����[sss �>��3� �� ;�' �[ssh �@�£���� �[ss[(�)��,#�"V`mm�(1 �N���T �V`m� �

2- pedagogy 4- Vygotsky

1- Oliveria & Cachupuz 3- humor 5- Vaughan

Page 188: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

188

����*�V`mj ��)"��T �� ;�' �V`oj (���� �'��&�/ .%/�K4��. F�('� ��/ �����A��� X������ @��' �)T���" ��# Y���#4 �c$ @�� R� ��� X�� ��� �T �'�

%'�� � #+!1k�*�" �� @���"� �Y$� �#a" � #+!1 U )&" u�c$ �� � U )&" ��/���A �E'� y�. � �'�. Y���1 ���� b$�)" ��#A��� ���4 � �/)���D$�V�V��V ;�' �

�U#$ �� V`oj.(

� �T����A �&�" �*�6 Z#�!1 ��%'�� �!#:�1 ��#A��� ^�$ �| � @���"����� � ���A � @� ;"� 1 �#,��/�, " ��#A��� ��/Y5#' ��� .1 �����t^�$ �#|

���� � ��#A����)��� ��#A��� ��/���� ��:� ��3�,)" ��/ .�)��� � Z�c" Z#�!1 ��/@�5 '[%'���E�/ �)�'� �� ;�'`�[sso(�#4 � ��#A��� ^�$ �# �� #+!1 Y��

���� ��:� y��1�� @��#A��� .�?'� � ^�T � @�.��< ��#A��� ^�$ �� @��#A��� �/�A����?" �.� ���!#:�1 ��#A��� ^�$ � G$�,)" � y��" ��/ ��E �� � @�.

1 � #+!1t�" Y��" �#|���lA .��� � �T � # !1��� -�$� �h[F�('� ����"�� � 2�c" ��� ����A �&�" Y��A��#A��� ��E��� � G$�,)" �� G2�c" �T �'��#A Y����� @�.

�"��#A��� ^�$ �T Y$� �'��#A��� �� �)? @�.��E �� �,,T ��E��� � ��$�,1 @�. ����' =���1)@��h@���E�/ ��V��e ��'� �� ;�' �[sso .( �� ;7�6 S��)' �>�6 �#� �� �'� Z#�!1)[sso (�" @��' ^�$ ��!2 � �T �/����� �# ��#A��� ��#A��� ��/

�, " ���a1 @��#A�������' ��:� ���� .�" �. u�c" �T ��'� � �:�1 � �� �YaA @��11 F�� �*�6 Z#�!1t��/��E��� � @� � "� 1 �|� F�� �#,��/ � ��#A��� ^�$ �#|

%'�� ����' �#J'�#" v�'� ���a1 � =���1 U )&"^�$ �� @���"� ��#A��� ��/&"�" ��?,�#4 ��� ��, ����� �c�� U ) �)��� u�*� ��� ��)�# ���#�!1 �T ���A

��#A ���7 �*�6 Z#�!1.

���A �# �T �. �&�" Z#�!1 F�� >��$ �$�� � �� >�),T � ����"�� ��/' @�"��N1 F� � � Y�5' X�JN�, " ���a����' ��:� ���� .$ ��N����� ��J��N�)��/

2- Nilson 4- Dunn

1- Slavin 3- Renou

Page 189: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

189

�" @��' Z#�!1 �a#7�1���A ����' �#J'�#" �# �T �/���J2� � =���1 ����"�� ��/ -�#3 ��� �#J'�#" �# ���a1 �2� ���� ��:� �i#Q�' ���a1 �)T���" ��#A��� � ��A���A���A � �/-�#3 �9��� ��/),T � �"�'� H�� @��,� � �,)" �!#*�1 ��A �1 >�����'�� Y$� �x6D" ;�3 ��-�#3 �9��� ���A � >�),T ���A ��T ���� �!#*�1 ��A

Y��" X�J' G#1�1 � �"�'� H�� @��,� � �,)" �/ �'��T X��iA F� � � Y�5' ��1�,Q ���a1 ��� ��T�, " ���"� ��!2 � �/��' ����,.� .���� � 2�c" ��)[sse (i#'

��' �#J'�#" �#%'�� ��� =���1 ���A @���"� -�#3 ��J2� �� >�),� ���A � ��A�, " ���a1 ��#*��� � Y�5' X�J' -�#�"����J' ��/��" ����.��J�� ��$ ��

�:�$��)[sso (%'�� X�J' Y����" @��,� � ��#�!1 �� �� F� � � Y�5' @���"�5" ;6 �.��"� ���/�� Z���t%'�� �T ��� @��' �2 @���"� Y����� �� � ����"�� ���A

X�J' ���,���Y��" ��#. -�� � Y�5' @�.����A �1 .I/�)��� �#,Q �� ;7�6 ��/ Z#�!1)�@�£����[ss[X�� �V�V��m (�)T���" ��#A��� ��E��� �� Y$� ��� �� �T�6

%'�� X�J' �1 ��#*��� � Y�5' @���"�t���� Y��" �#| .�)��� �#,Q � y��1�� �� ��/�" ª3�,)" %# � IT�##�1 @��1��T u�c" ��� ��/ :F� � � Y�5' X�J' ��E,�� >��

"%'�� � Y$� F� � � Y�5' �����4 � � � �a," � Y��" -�56� F�� �� ;���1 @���"��" �$��" �� �� F� � ��#A��� � ;���1 �'��"�)�2���T � R���[�V�oe (@�#" ��� �� �

1 ��#.N?,1 =���� �N' � �$��" �|�" ;"��� �� �EN%'�� X�J F� � � Y�5' @���"��"1 �@�� " X�J' �#x' ��J�� ;"��� �T �2�6 �� �.�t��$ �=,: ����2�� �#|

��$ Y���#4 � F� � ����� � "�: ��A��� �� {. Z9D� �@��#A��� �)<�,. ��/)��5' �'�. � �,��R�/V�o[ (�" �T�'��� ��:�' �,'��1�## 1 %���,,T X�J' �� ��

%'���,.� �).�� F� � � Y�5' @���"� .�T ���� ��:� >��)6� ��� �*�6 Z#�!1 �����A �R� ����' �#J'�#"-�#3 �9��� ��/ � �"�'� H�� @��,� � �,)" �!#*�1 ��A

�## 1 ;"��� ��� �� ���� 1 �� �.�' F� � � Y�5' X�J' @�"�� �� i#' >�),T��,,T .�N�.� �� ���a)$� ��T ��� F��N��i'� ��/N����� ����� k�,)" ��#ANI/ � ���$ ^�#,Q

2- Crawley 1- Brush

Page 190: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

190

�£�2��)"�" k�*�" ^� ����� U )&" ���#�!1 ���a)" ��/�)��� � �(," �'��1 ��/ª3�,1 ��� ;6 ��� �T ��. ��?�" � ª3�,)"F�?� B�� � �/1 � ��#' �/ ���#�!

�" ��,�� �� Z#3� � I(5,"�.� .

-�#3 ��J2� � =���1 ��&�|� ����� Z#�!1 �T ��� � �:�1 � �#2�� ��� ��A�" F�('� @���� ���T �� ���'��' � �*�6 Z#�!1 Y$� F�R ��#A ��!2 � � U )&" ��/

1 �).��tE1 @�5E� @�� " � � � #+!1 U )&" B���" �� � Y#5,: �#| �E,�� �1 ��. ����)��� -�$� � @��)a2z" � ���#�!1 ��� �� ;7�6 ��/�@�"��$ �� �$�� G)T @�/�

-�#3 Ix,"��A��?,�#4 ��$�� G)T �� ��. u�c" ��/ �� � ���A �9��� �����T ��/�, " ��#A��� ��� ���J2� �#,Q �� ���a)$� Y#�/� @�� " ��� ��J�� ��$ � ���

I#/�a" Z#��-DT ���iA� � ���.� � ���i)'� ��A��T �� �/��. ��E.� �.��"� ��/ .

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :[V/s`/V`�V �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :Ve/so/V`�V �2��" X��l4 r���1:V`/sV/V`�[

Page 191: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

191

q���� References

@�#"�� ����i<)V`oe .(56��#"(3�� ��E-�2�Q :-�2�Q � �?.�' �"D$� ���� ��J�'�� �����)'�.

� � �U#$ ��T�)V`oj .(�,��# ���������E@��?1 :��A� ��'.

T�*���!" ��)"��)V`oj .(1t���?" �.� � �)T���" ��#A��� �#|��):� ��/� #+!1 Y���#4 � �����"�#$ [��G � ��������� ���� ����. �I)a/ � �$ ����. �V� �eeW`�.

�2�� �? 2������#6� ���+'� ��!)���,E$� �������#' ��?2���� )V`�s .(-�"/ ��#� �,)��� ���:<� �#(��&� �#"(3����3�# %���/ ��� � F� � X��"� � �2������ �#1 �%#TV`�s.

"���: ������+)V`oj .(���f*� ��2� 9�#@� )�T��� � !��� (�(��� �#� ��#"(�#� �3��� ��43)�������, �� L!;�) �#"(3�� �*b�G����,���)T� �2�$� �� �)#�1 F� � ��E�'��

i���1 ��J�'�� �$�,�'���.

Adesoji, F.A. (2008). Managing Students’ Attitude towards Science Through Problem-solving Instructional Strategy, Anthropologist, 10 (1), 21-24

Akman, C. (2005).The Effects of Instruction with Analogy-enhanced Model on Ninth Grade Student’ Function Achievement and Attitudes toward Mathematics, Retrieved April 17, 2010 from: etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12606581/index.

Alberta, A. (2008). The Relationship between Learning Style and Student Success in a Distance Education Program, Retrieved March 21, 2011 from:library.athabascau.ca/drr/download.php?filename=MDE/lewis-nancy.

Arts, A.F., & Newman, C. (1990). Cooperative Learning, Mathematics Teacher, 83, 448-449

Brush, T.A. (1997). The Effect on Students’ Achievement and Attitudes When Using in Learning Systems with Cooperative Pairs, Educational Technology, Research and Development, 45(1), 51-64.

Chiu, M.H., & Lin, J.W. (2005). Promoting Fourth Graders’ Conceptual Ehange of Their Understanding of Electrice Current Via Multiple Analogies, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 42,429-464.

Page 192: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

192

Dilber, R., & Duzgun, B. (2008). Effectiveness of Analogy on Students’ Success and Elimination of Misconceptions, Retrieved Janurury 25, 2011, from: http://www.journal.lapen.org.mx.

Duit, R. (1991). On the Role Analogies and Metaphors in Leaning Science, Science Education, 75, 649-672.

Erton, I. (2010). Relation between Personality Traits, Language Learning Styles and Success in Foreign Language Achievement, Retrieved March, 2011 from: www.efdergi.hacettepe.edu.tr/english/.../İSMAİL%20ERTON.pd

Fennema, E., & Sherman, J. (1976). Fennema-Sherman Mathematics Attitudes Scales: Instruments Designed to Measure Attitudes towards the Learning of Mathematics by Females and Males, Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 7, 324-326.

Glynn, S.M., Takahashi, T. (1998). Learning from Analogy-enhanced Science Text, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 35(10), 1129-1149.

Glynn, S.M. (1994). Teaching Science with Analogy: A Strategy for Teacher and Text Book Authors, National Reading Research Center, Reading Research Report No. 15. Retrieved Nowembe14, 2010 from: www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/detail?accn-

Glynn, S., Law, M., Gibson, N., & Hawkins, C. (1996). Teachers and Text Book Authors, Available At: http://currv.edschool.virginia.edu/go/clic/nrrc/scin html

Glynn, S., Russel, A., & Noah, D. (1997). Teaching Science Concepts to Children: The Role of Analogies, Available at: http://www.coe.uga.edu./edpsvch;3

Haladyna, T., & Shaughnessy, J. (1982). Attitude towards Science: A Quantitative Synthesis, Science Education, 66, 547-563.

Harrison, A.G. (1992). Evaluation of Model for Teaching Analogies in Secondary Science, Retrieved November 8, 2010 from: espace.library.curtin.edu.au/dtl_publish/gen01-era02/22/11315.html

Harrison, A.G., & Coll, R.K. (2008). Using Analogies in Middle and Secondary Science Classroom, Available at: www.amazon.com › ... › Education › Elementary Education - Cached

Page 193: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

193

Harrison, A.G. & Treagust, D.F. (1993). Teaching with Analogies: A Case Study in Grade-10 Optics, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 30, 1291-1307.

Hough, L.W. & Peter, M.K. (1989). The Relationship between Attitudes towards Science and Science Achievement, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 19, 33-38.

Humphreys, B., Johnson, K.T., & Janson, D.W. (1982). Effect of Cooperative, Competitive and Individualistic Learning on Students’ Achievement in Science Class, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 19, 351-356.

Iqbale, M. (2004). Effect of Cooperative on Achievement of Secondary School Students in Mathematics, Available at:www.ijar.lit.az/pdf/9/2011(1-139).

Jarvis, T., & Pell, A. (2005). Secondary Pupils of Different Abilities Response to an E-mission Simulation of the Montserrat Volcanic Eruption, Paper Presented at the American Education Research Association, Montreal, CA.

Koballa, T.R. (1988). Attitude and Related Concept in Science Education, Science Education, 72, 115-126.

Koballa, T.R., Jr., & Crawley, F.E. (1985). The Influence of Sttitude on Science Teaching and Learning, School Science and Mathematics, 85, 222-232.

Morrell, P.D., & Lederman, N.G. (1998). Students 'Attitude School and Classroom Science: Are They independent Phenomena? School Science and Mathematics, 98(2):76-83.

Renue, J. (20008). A Study of Perceptual Learning Styles and Achievement in a University Level Foreign Language Course, Retrieved February 8, 2010 from: beepdf.com/.../a_study_of_perceptual_learning_styles_and_achievement_in_a_university_.html

Roland, N. (2006). Hydrodynamic Analogy to Energy Losses in Capacitors, Phys., Educ.41, 217-218.

Page 194: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

194

Salta, K., & Tzougraki, C. (2004). Attitudes toward Chemistry among 11th Grade Students in High Schools in Greece, Science Education, 88(4), 535-547.

Thiele, R.B. & Treagust, D.F. (1994). The Nature and Extent of Analogies in Secondary Textbooks, Instructional Science, 22, 61-74.

Thiele, R.B., Venville, G.J. & Treagust, D.F. (1995). A Comparative Analogy in Secondary Biology and Chemistry Textbooks Used in Australian Schools, Research in Science Education, 25,221-230.

Vaughan, W. (2002). Effects of Cooperative Learning on Achievement and Attitude among Students of Color, Journal of in Educational Research, 95(6), 356-364.

Wong, D.E. (1993). Understanding the Generative Capacity of Analogies as a Tool for Explanation, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 30(10), 1273-1290.

Yilmazoglu, C. (2004). Effect of Analogy-enhanced Instruction Accompanied with Concept Maps on Understanding of Acid- base

Concept, Available at: etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12605247/index.pdf.

Page 195: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

195

�� '���� $�-"$ Q�$(� R�:�$�)0(�="��" $( S���T� ��� 1 :8% ���$�;V�W )4 �������� �6$�H� ���

�3��/ �%b��z

�f�<� 6G �";a %K� {

1o�� � %K���� F";�|

4 "rQ ���3 �#|t1 Y!1 �� ��� �)<�,. ��/��)<�$ ����2�� ��)�� �� �a," v���� �"� D)� � )5" �� �� � �/�

G#$��" �)<�,�'��� ��/6 %/�K4 �� g�/ ����$����6�� �('�#" %�' �## 1 �*� �#2�� �"���T�' ��/��c*� � �A��5�� � �,��2�� ��)�� v���� �# y��1�� �� ��.���"� � "�: ��� �a#7�1 %/�K4 X��

;"�. @���(�'�� �# T����� :��" @���(�'�� ��,#$ � �� ��J�'�� �����" iT�" � ��,,T �?. �@���/ >�$ �� V`�[�� .���. ���a)$� �,#2��#w � �,#2� �'��' �� �� %/�K4 ��� ;"�. �,#2� �'��' �

j� �,#2��#w �'��' � �a' V`h�� �a' .�'��' X�� �� �,#2� �'��' �&)'� Y?: � -�)$� �� ��#A �� �,#2��#w �'��' ����.�<��� 6�"�,Q ���. ���a)$�.y��1�� �"�,�$�4 �$ �� %/�K4 ��� ��

2�� @�"�� ��T��4 �,��SCL-90-R'�� ����6�� ��1�T F�� ��. ���a)$� .�����/�� ���a)$� � @�#$�A� ��#{)"�,Q�'�. ;# !1.����6�� �('�#" %�' �� �T�6 %/�K4 S��)' y��1�� �� �#2�� �"���T�' ��/

����6�� � �� ��c*� � �A��5�� � ���2�� ��)�� v����/ Y#"��!" �"���T�' ��/ �J'�J# ��'�(#G#$� �����):��J)5�� ���* � Y�5' ���l4 /�����6�� ���$ �� %# �'�(#/ ������ � �)��aT �/

��c*� � �A��5�� � ���2�� ��)�� v���� y��1�� �('�#" �'�� .�)��� G$�,"�' ��/��)�� ��� @��' �/���2��)�6 �� %# Yx��!" � U# * Y�3��" (;E. �$� ��#AG#@��'��� �� �'��� � �)<�,. ���l4

����� ���i5 %�' ����6�� �('�#" %�' �## 1 �����, � ���2�� ��)�� v���� �# �#2�� �"���T�' ��/G#$��" �'��� �RD)<� @�"�� � ��#J�#4 �� �)<�,�'��� ��/�.� �#a" �'��1.

� "�' ��(h�� :%# Yx��!" �Y�3��" ����2�� ��)�� v��������6�� ��6 �� �A��5�� ��#2�� �"���T�' ��/ ���c*�.

1W�"����< ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� �.�� -�,.��T )�'�>�p5" ��,5 (Email: [email protected] 2W�'�� #@��?1 �"����< ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� ���A ��3W��)$� �@���/ M�,#$ � �� ��J�'�� �$�,�'��� ���A ��

Page 196: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

196

�� 2� � ����'�< ����"�^Q�T @��,�" �"� ���1z�K�� ��J��: �� ����):� ;# !1 �6�� ���1�| ��

�$�� ��G#$� �� 2�c" � �/ ����):� �$�,.�Y$� �����<.���4 � �T ����x' �� ��� ��/�J2� � v��T �#)5&' ��(1 %�';E. �� �A���'�< �����1� � �����!'� ��#A

ST���)��1 �/t� ���" � ��4 � �c�� �� v��T �#2�� ��(1 �T �'��� ��� � �'��� �#T �D"� 1 � ���2�� b$�1 �� �a��� � �'��� ��/��#' ��*�� �J'�JQ�@�?,1 �' I/� ��

��+&�" �E �� ��� �)#+&. ��)<�$ �� �� ��)�� ��/�J2� ���� ���u�� � ��/ �i���"�,,T)����'V`oh.(�" Y���6 ��+1 ��� �� ���#5 ���#�!1 ^�$ �T �,,T

�" �A��5�� � ��c*� � )5" �� ����� �����'�< ��< �D"� 1�,T)��>��" @��,� �>�/i J'� �^2�� -�#" �V�[sse ��T�Wv�1�4 �F�J2��W�A�/ � ���� ��,#T �F�?E4[

)[sV[(.�)��� Y$� S��)' ��� � i#' ���#�!1 �<�Y�3��" � ��c*� �# y��1�� �T �'� �,)5/ y��" ��J�� ��/�#{)" � � �).�� ��)�T u�*� ���2�� �#��4 )�T��4 � ����T`�

V��h���J,# #T �� 5T� �;�#1 �i#2 �� ;�' � �h�[sse .( @��' �7� " ���#�!1 B3�� ���"���/�,���� �� �/����2�� ;"� 1 �# b�� �� WG#$� � �'��� @� G3� )" �'��� ��/

��#�#4 ��#5 ��,)5/ � ��'��� %�' @�#" ��� �� i#' ��J�� ;"��� � Y$� ��+1 �� �1�>��" @��,� � �?'� y��1�� � @��'��� Y<�,. � �Ea1 ��#. � ���a)$� �$ �� �Y aw

��#. @� >��'� � � @��J��� ��(1 �T ��" @��' �� ��< �� ����):N��|� �,/��" ���lA)�)$�eV��VI#/ �-�� �� ;�' � �j��)$� �[ss` .( B3�� �� � �/�J2�

;E. G�$ �T ���2�� Y$���' ��/��)�� �#2�� @��3��" � � c"�' ��(1 ��#A)�����2�� ����" �)�# (�">�" �� ���.�" ��#<� �'��� ��T��T ��/Y<�,. ���. ��� ��/

�" �|� @��J�� � ��< � Y�5' �/��� � ����� � � ���� ���3 �#|t1 Y!1 �� �� ����lA�'����4 � U���� I#xN,1 ��� I?" I5#'�EN" ^� B'�" �(#)'�N" �/ �.� �c< � ���A

2- Backer- Fulghum, Patock- Peckham, king, Roufa & Hagen 4- Liss, Timmel, Baxley, Killingsworth 6- Russ, Heim

1- Hale, Valk, Engels & Meeus 3- Caredo & Parker 5- Westen

Page 197: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

197

G#$��" %��i�� �� �)<�,�'��� ��/�/� .�)<�,. ;"��� �� �)$� @� ���$�,. �����,. ��(�� ���� �#2�� �a," ��(1 �(#)' �� ����RD)<� � D)� � )5" �� ��� � ��

�"�" ���$��1 ����� �� ��c*� � �A��5�� �,'�" �1RD)<� �,#"� �� �" %'�� � �'�,� ��� .

� -�$� >�" G#$����l4W-�)$� ��G#$��$�,. �'��� %/�K4��/ ����� %�' ;"��� y��" �����'�< ���@��,� ;"�� �,#"���$ ��G#$����l4 ��� ���" �$��

���� ���3�'� )�1�T � =��/V�[ss[.(� ���x'[)V�mj�=��2�� �� ;�' � �� i E'�=���"`�[sV[ (G#$� ;"� 1 �� ;#+a1 �#2���)<�,. ���l4W�� -�)$� .���) "

����6�� �� �"���T�' %'�� ��)<�$ � �a��� �RD)<� �,#"� �����/h�)5�� �T �,)5/��. G5T ����� @���� >�� ���'�.�'��e)V��h(�@���C�/ � � ���)V�mj (�

@��J��)���2� �>��" @��,�j�V�oo (�Q��]C� ���" @�# � ���� ���$����6�� �,���/ �#2�� �"�����'m)EMSs (�" �.� ���� �# �D"� 1 Z��� �� ����� @���� >�� ���,��

�" ;C. �� ���J2� �Y$�� ��,�� ��(1 �#5a1 ��� ��� ���,/�� �� �,/� .�5���" ��G#$� >�" �����6�� ��)<�,. ���l4� �#2�� �"�����' ��/ � �#3 ���3 � �����< �y�.

����*�" � �?'� ���� ��,)5/ �a," U���� �� ��R� �c$ ��(�� ��)5/ �,'�" �A�'� �� �,)5/ y��1�� �� Y#�#�7 � >D�)$�)� 1 � �'�� ��,��: �Y#�.�o�V��e.(

�'��)V��s (�" >R�)$�����6�� �T �,T Z#�� �#2�� �"���T�' ��/ �c$ ���1�" ��:� � �T��T @���� �� �T �,)5/ �1�"���� � Y�| >�7� � �,)5/ Y<�,. ��,��

�" F���1 �2�5A�i �A�'� �� �" �&�" ���� ��"���T�' � � �,�� �'�. .�'��)[ss` (����6�� Y$� ��) "��(1 �(#)' �� �� ���/��. ��(�� ����� � Y$� �C�" ��'�

���!" �"i" �RD)<� � 7� �)$I�,.� .��.�<�' B��3� N����(" ��(�� ��� �"i" � �,

2- Beck 4- Schema 6- Bowlby 8- Schmidt, Joiner, Young & Telch

1- Harris & Curtin 3- Roelofs, onckels & Muris 5- Young 7- Early maladaptive schema

Page 198: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

198

�" @��J�� � ��< ���" �� �iT�" ��/���g�c '� ;�3�#w �/��� ��� �T ��. �"�.�.�/��� F�x' ���V��� ��� ��)�� � ���D�� X����4 ���,/�� �T��T @���� �� ��S���1

�" X�)5A�" �"���T�' � Y#��1 ��,���'�. .����6�� �T �"�J,/ �#2�� �"���T�' ��/ ��" >��" ��)," @�(#/ �� �6�c$ �'�. I#�)5"�#w �� I#�)5" � ��. >�E.� � �(,"

�J)a.� �� �a )&"g�+"�$ ���c*� ��A��5�� �#x' �)<�,�'��� ��/ ��*�� 1 ����" �" @� >��"� � ���� �# ��.)F�J'�/ � ='�/ �>����'[�[sse.(

�'��)V���(2�� ��(1 k�' ��?Q �� Y$� ��) " ��� �,1���� �� ���� ��:� �#VW�"���' �/��#' @��' �*�� �(#)' �� ���'��� ��/��" ��:��,�� .��:� �)3� �"���' ���

�"F���' b#!" � ���� ��)�� � c" ��(1 ��< �#2�� b#!" �� ���� �� ��� ��,,�;C. �������6�� ��#A�" ��� � �'�(#/ Y#"��!" �,'�" ���/��. .[W�� G#$�

�" G:�" ���� � �� 1 � G#$� ��"�7 �@��� ��*����6�� �� �� ��. �,'�" ����G#$� �F�. � ��' �����)����#A ;C. ��* � Y�5' ���l4 .`W� c" ��(1

Y# 3�" ���2�� ��6 �� %#�" I/��� ��< ���� ��� �� ����� ��'�C"� � �/ �,,�)������� �/ ��� @� >�� " �6Y$� �#a" (;C. ��� ������6�� ��#A �,'�" ���/

�J)5�� /�H��!)$� ��)��a� /��i�" ���� �� ��,"��. .�6 �� %# @����� �����. X���'��. �).�lA ���� �6 �� %# ��'��'� .��#' ��� @����� ��� �'�(#/ ��/

Y$� ���' ������ ��c," Y����!" � >D�)$� .�� %# ���2�� ���� �A�'� �� �6 ����� ;�� � ������ Y�3��" �?'� �� � ���� Y2�<� �?'� �� �?'� �6 �� %# �C,�� �� �'�

���� >D�)$� �?'� � � �).�lA �����'� .hW�#2�� ��(1 �#"��?Q ���&)'� ���$�,'��/ ����6�� �� �A�'��" �� �"�����' ��/?" ����� � ��&)'� ���$�,'��/ ���$ �A�'� I

Y$� .� �����" �'��� �� ���2�� ��)�� � ��$�56� ���C�� ��&)'� ����,� .

�'�� )V��h (�" >R�)$�� @��3��" � �#2�� �D"� 1 �� �,� �.� � ���" � ��4 �K������6��>�" �� �)<�,. ��/�N" ��� �A�'� �� �#2�� ������ ��/�,� .�#,NQ B3�� ��

2- Nordahal, Hans , M & Hangum , I 1- Belief system

Page 199: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

199

�D"� 1 X����4 ��� ���J2� �#2�� �D"� 1 �" �5!" �� ���A��$ ���.)��� ���CN$� �V�oo ��1�� � =��/ �� ;�' � �[ss[ .( ����4)V�m� (�" ��?,�#4 �� �,�

�" �&�" �6 �� %# Yx��!" � I� Y�3��" � �,��2��$� �'�.G#�� @��'��� ���l4�" %��i�� �� �A��5�� � �� �,/�)B�," @��/.(

�" ���3� ;"� 1 �?'� � v��T �T �,)5/ ������ �#2�� �R�� " ���2���,T .��)���" v��T �� �'��� Y"D$ � =a' � ���)�� ��(�� G�$ v��T � ���2�� G$�," � ��.

���2�� � c"�' �D"� 1 =E��W@��'��� �� �'��� Y"D$ � ��� �)#+&. ��)<�$��" �a," �|���. .����6�� �a," ���7 � ���2�� ��)�� v���� �(#)' �� B3�� �� ��/

�" ;E. @��'��� �� �"�����'�" �T �'�#A ���3 �#|t1 Y!1 ��,�� �� �� ��� ��)�� �,'��1;E. ��� � ����G#$� ��#A�'��A �?'� �� �)<�,�'��� ��/.'�y��1�� �� %# ��

�" �|� �?'� �'��� �DE�" ��� �� @��'��� � ���2�� ��)�� �� @��'��� v���� ��!' ����lAY$� �?'� � ���2�� .�" ��#�7 � ��'��l4 �� ��< ���2�� B3��" �/�A �E'� >�6 �,'��

��' ������ �'�J,�� �� ��< ���2�� @��'����,,T .�� �,��2�� ��)�� v����#�6Y���" �T ���� ���.� %,��2�� � �� y��1�� �J'�JQ � k�' �� �'��� v���� >�!1 � �'��1

� ���� ���3 �#|t1 Y!1 �� �� ��,�� �����lA �|� �'����c<G#$� �� ²� @���� �� �� ���l4 ����' ����1 ��)i"��� �='��TV�[ss[ �@���E�/ � @���/�� �� ;�' � �V`�s.(

=��/ �1���)[ss[(����/�K4 �y��1�� � 2�c" ��x," v���� b��� ��,��2������6����/ �"�����' �#2�� �I9D� �A��5�� ��@��: @R�5A�i ���� �(#)' �'�#$�

�� ��/���6�� �'�� ��y��1�� �# b��� �,��2�� v���� ��. )�#��4 Y�3��" v������2�� �6 �� %# Y��a6 v���� � ���2���(�I9D� �A��5�� %�' �c$�� ���('�#"

�'���.����� @�#" ����6�� ��?Q �����)�# ='����� �����< ��+)<� �'��� ����� �'�� ��:��'/G#$� ������' �2�),���< �F�.���l4 ��J)5��/��)��a�.� 2�c" ���

�� �)��A F�('� I2�$ ����� ��� � ����7.

1- Adams

Page 200: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

200

�" � �#A@�$��,$ � ����V)[sse (^�$ �# y��1�� @��,� � ��/�K4����4�'���^�$ ��)<�,.)����6����(%/�K4 ��� g�/ �T �'��� F�('� �A��5�� �

^�$ �# y��1�� �$���� ��c*� � �A��5�� �:�� � �)<�,. .%/�K4 ��� S��)'G#$� � �a," ��/ ���2�� ��/�J2� �� �� Y<�,. %�'��� @��' �'��� �$�,. �#,��/ �

F��1 � ��A��5�� �#e����6�� � �� � Y.�� ��:� �c�� �'�� �"���T�' ��/������ � � �?,1 ���. ��c*�/��' ���� �J)5��/ �6 �� %# �J'� � X�A.

�#2�� @��3��" � �#2�� � c"�' ��(1 B3�� �� )���" � ��4 ����" ��T� �� (>�" ���/���. ��#<� �'��� �"���T�' Y#2� � ��. U# �1 �J�� ����� � �E��i' @� >��'� � �T �'�

Y6���' ��$�56� I#x,1 ��� I?" I5#'�E" ^� B'�" ��.� �c< %��i�� � ��,,TG#$��" �'��� ��/��. .

%/�K4����6�� y��1�� �$�� � ���#5 ��/G#$� � �/ ����� �� �)<�,�'��� ��/�4 �,)<��)i,���/ � � "R �>��" ���[�[ssmi1��/ � i)'�� ���)#4 �;#)5�2 ��,�� �`�

[sV[(%/�K4 �<� �#,��/ �;E. � @��'��� � ���2�� ��)�� y��1�� �$�� � �/ ��#AG#$��'� �)<���4 �)<�,�'��� ��/)��52�A ���� @�� �=)��A �>��" ���h�[ss� �

#/ � @�5,#2�� ��)$�C,2;e�[ssm�"���� � =��2 ������$� ��1��� �j�[ssV .( @�,T�1%/�K4���� �� 0��< �� I/ @� ���'� ��/����6�� �AK�� ����� �#2�� �"���T�' ��/

� F�('� �)<�,�'��� I9D� k�,)" k��'� � ���2�� ��)�� �# �c�� �� �('�#" ^� @��,�Y$� ��. .�" @��' �T ���� ��:� ��/��.�/�����6�� �#2�� �"���T�' ��/�7�< ��

�� ���)�� � �a��� �DE�" k��'� ������,)5/ �#A�� )�=��2�� �=���" � i E'�[sV[(�Z#3� �$�� ��� �T �1��#�!1 �#,��/G#$� � D)�" ����� ���A �� �� �1 ��/

Y$� v�'� ��#5 �,.� ���T ���a)$� ���� ����� � �)<�,�'��� .'NS��) � y��"1�� ���#�!1N'��� �)<�,�'��� �DE�" � �,��2�� ��)�� y��N� �� ��3�,)" S��)' i#' @��

2- Lumley & Harkness 4- Geerts, Van Os, Gersma 6- Carter, Sbrocco,lewis & Friedman

1- Mcgin, Cukor & Sanderson 3- Renner, Lobbesteal, Peeters, Arntz & huibers 5- Lancaster, Pollinson & Hill

Page 201: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

201

Y$� �).�� ����/ .�����,�" ��x' >�" �� ����6�� @� �� �T ��T ��� @��1 ��/G#$� � ���2�� ��)�� �# �c�� �� �)<�,. �('�#" �� @��,� � �#2�� �"���T�' �$�,.

�" ;�� �'����,� .�T Y$� ��� %/�K4 g�/ �����, ����6�� %�'��T�' ��/ �"� �#2�� ���A��5�� � �,��2�� ��)�� v���� �# y��1�� ���@��'��� ��c*� �/� @��' .

B��

����� ���%� � �&��P

�a#7�1 X�� �� %/�K4 ��� ��WY$� ��. ���a)$� � # !1 .%/�K4 ��� ���"� � "�:� :��" @���(�'�� � �,#$ � �� ��J�'�� @���(�'�� �# T ;"�." iT�" � ��,,T �����

� #+!1 >�$ �� �,#$ � �� ��J�'���[WV`�V �� .�,#2� �'��' �� �� %/�K4 ��� ��Y$� ��. ���a)$� �,#2��#w �.�'��' X�� �� �,#2� �'��' �&)'� Y?: �� ��#A

� :��" ����� �� -�)$� ��� � @���/ ��,#$ � �� ��J�'�� �����" iT�" � ��,,T��' �� �,#2��#w �'��'�'��#A�.�<��� 6�"�,Q ���. ���a)$� �� �� ���7 ��� �

>�� � 6�" :�# ��o�,#$ � �� ��J�'�� ��E�'�� )�,� ����4 F� � ��E�'��W��$�,?" F� � � ��+)3� � �E.i]"����#4 ���#. ����� " � �,/ ��'�5'� F� � � ��#�� �������T

����):�(�h�,� ����4 F� � ��E�'�� W�,?" F� � � ��+)3� � �'�5'� F� � � @�#�� ��$�'�N. �&)'� ����):� .F�� � 6�" :-DT ^� G&)," ��E�'�� �/ �� � 6�" ��� ��

�����A �&)'� ����+1 ��� .F�$ � 6�" :»�'��"�� �&)'��/«�-DT �&)'� �� � �'��"��� %/�K4 ��/�'�. �&)'� �'�� ���� � ����+1 ��� .�� �� ��� %/�K4 �

�#*�� @�Q �'��' I(6 �## 1 �� ���$ �� Z#�!1 ��/se/s=�j/V=Z�x' �� >��)6� ��� � �����A ���a)$� @��T�T >�"�� �� �'��' I(6 ����� Y?: � �. �)��A

��c<�e/s)se/s=α(='����� �[e/s�#J'�#" ���a1 ��/sm/s��� 1 [[o � �a' �'��' I(6 @��,��. ����� .

Page 202: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

202

�� ��U��

@�"�� � ^'�� ����6�� ��1�T F�� ��T��4 �,��2�� y��1�� �"�,�$�4 �$ �� %/�K4 ��� ��)SCL-90-R (Y$� ��. ���a)$� :

�<� :��� <�� ]�6$�� ��U���)PBI(:����� -�#�" ���[e�T Y$� I)�� �����4 b$�1@��� � ��,# 4�1[)V�m�(� � Y$� ��. �)<�$ ���" � ��4 �� ��&.� v���� ������

>�� �� ��<Vj�A�'� >�� >�$ �" @�.�����4 ��c�� � ��lA�#|t1 � I?" � ���" ������ �� @��'��� � ���2���,T )����J,# #T �� 5T� �;�#1 �i#2[sse .(-�#�"�����/

@�:���" � ��4 F�� VW���52� �� Y�3��" [W�2�� ������ Y���6��Y$� )�2��+'���#" �����#.V`o�.(�" �J)aA �� � ��'��� ���6 @��:�' ��,T �� �R�� " �?'� �� �� � �,,T

�"�,�?� .=C ," I� Y�3��" ����'��� ��,,T��� � ��$ �T Y$� �,��2�� ��,,��'� ��,.� �).�� @�.�'��� � ���T �:�1 � �,.� �|� t�," �E'� @��)��T��4V��s �;�' �

�=��� ��[ssV �@�w��� ��:�1 �V`om(.=C ," �6 �� %# Y��a6 � �� R� ����' >�),� �T Y$� ����" � ��4 ��,'�" ��+1 � �,)5/ ��,,T ����' ^� @�.�'��� �,,T

Y$��,)5/ @�.�'��� �A�'�" v��T � �J)5�� ;"�� �.Y��a6 � �� �#��4 ����'=C ," �6 �� %#2�� ��,,��" S���1 �� >D�)$� � ����� �T Y$� �,���,,T )�i#2

����J,# #T �� 5T� �;�#1[sse .(Y�3��" � ��� � 7� �$�� ���'��T ��a2� �[/sW�`/sY��a6 � ��� �jj/sWom/s�"�.� .�"�,�$�4 ��� ����� ��6�+" Z��� �� �je�R� �J)5��/ � �'��"�� ����' ����' � ��6�+" ������ @�"�� Y$� ��. �

�'����" Y#3��" ��� ���'��T ��a2��s/s�'���4 Y�3��" ����s/s������ Y���6 ��� �'����"oe/s������ Y���6 ��� �i#' �'���4 oe/s�"� Y$� � )�2��+'���#" �����#.V`o�.(b$�1 �"�,�$�4 ��� ���:� S��)' @���� �� �.�'� ��)V`oe (�'�� ��� @���(

���"���� �����4 ����')�)a/ ��?Q (�� �'����" Y�3��"o`/s�� �'���4 Y�3��" �m�/s��� @��'.���"���� �����4 ��$�!" � �� Y���6 ������ )>�),T(�'����" o�/sY���6 � �

2- Parker, Tupling, Brown 1- Parental Bonding Instrument

Page 203: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

203

�'���4 �������`/s��"� Y$�)� @�#���. �@���E�/V`�s .(�*�6 %/�K4 �� G��* �,��2�� �'�#4 �"�,�$�4 ���'��T ��a2�m`/s��"� Y$�.

^:l��� 4���a#b 4�$�' [#� ������# )SQ–SF:( ��i� �� �"�,�$�4 ��� me�2�z$ ����6�� %(,$ ��� -�#�" �� ��� � ��C#2 U#� � �#2�� �"�����' ��/j�:�� ��

��»�" ����� b w �D"�� �1 �" ����� Y$�� �D"�� «�:���" ��,��. .�'��)V��o (� 7� �"�,�$�4 F�� ��� �� �� �"�,�$�4 ���)F��[se��)�� (��� �6��� .�"�,�$�4

�'�� ����6��)SQ–SF ( ������ ���Ve�. �)<�$ �#2�� �"�����' ����6�� .�#2�� � B:�� B"�: %/�K4�AK�� �Y#�$� b$�1 �'�� ����6�� �"�,�$�4 �(,5'��� ��/

� 1 � �'�� ��,��:V)V��e (Y$� �)��A ���7 .�/ ��� ��� @��' � 2�c" ��� S��)' �� ���a2� G��* ��#2�� �"�����' ����6��o`/s)�1 �)��#' >�!1 ��< ����6���j/s�

��' ����6��/#2��#w Y# �: �� @�"�� �� G��* � F�. �# �,es/s�1o[/s(�����< � Y$� ��"�-�#�"�'��� @��' ��R� �'��� ���| � �����4 ��#2�� ��/ .���

�'��' �� ���a)$� � @��J�/�K4 F�('� ;"�� ;# !1 � �� ��< %/�K4 S��)' �,#2� ��/�'��� .����6�� �� ��� @��' S��)' ����1 �,#2� ��/��� -�$� � �'�� �� ���/ ����

Y.�� �'��&�/ ���#3� ���.@�� � �� #1 ��2 �� 2�c")V��� (�� �,#2� �'��' �� �� �#2��)$�Vj ;"�� ��� ��� Y$�Ve�'�� b$�1 �D�3 @� ;"�� )V��s (�� ��. u�c"

���� ��< �'��� ���| �'�� ����6�� �"�,�$�4 �� ��� @��' �?'� � 2�c" �)�'�� ��@���C�/ [ss` .(/�/� b$�1 @���� �� �"�,�$�4 ��� �����(,)V`oh (��� �`om

��J�'�� @���(�'�� �� �a' �'��� �'�5�/ �� Y$� ��. F�('� @��?1 ��/��"�,�$�4 �� �'z" ����� �� ���'��� ��a2� �� ���a)$� ��m/s��l" ����� �� �o/s�Y$� ��"� Y$� .

�*�6 %/�K4 �� �$�4 ���'��T ��a2� G��* �"�,�'�� ����6�� ��1�� F�� �`/s��"� Y$�.

n:���)�)SCL-90-R(:�T Y$� �E.i]'��� �#&�1 ��/��i� ���1 ���a)$��4 �� �E�

1- Telch

Page 204: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

204

;"�.�sY$� �'��� I9D� ��#.��� ��� >�z$ .I9D� U )&" �� � @�"�� �������#-��$� ��'��5: Y��E. ;"�. �'��� ��/W����:� �;��)" b��� �� Y#$�56

'��� � � �#9�'���4 �Ea1 ��*�" -�1 ���J.�<�4 ���c*� ��A��5��N�� �� ����]��"-�#�" �� %/�K4 ��� �� �T ��#A-��$� ��/W�;��)" b��� �� Y#$�56 ����:�

�. ���a)$� ��J.�<�4 ���c*� ��A��5��Y$� �.�" @�"�� ��� �� ���a)$� ���� @��1 �����# ����� �� �� I2�$ ��� �#&�1 .�� @���E�/ � =#1�A��� b$�1 @�"�� ��� �#2�� F��

>�$V�m`;# !1 � ��i(1 � �,#2� ��#�(1 -�$� � � ����A ��� " �(,5'��� ��/�#?1 b$�1 @� ���?' F�� � Y��A ���3 �x'���(1 ���" >�$�� @�A�,,TV�mj F�' �

D� ��.�x' ���(1 Y$�?� �'��� I9)SCL-90-R (����A ��� " .y��1�� @�"�� ���i,#E4�/ I9D� Y5#2 ^Q � �E��i'V)HSCL (���� .� @�"�� ��� �T Y$� ��. Y�|

�,#"� �Q��Q �� �##{1Y$� -�56 � #< ��� � �,#2� ��/ .X�� � �����4 �,#"� ���2�1�' @�"����)V�ms (��� �� @�"�� ��� i#'�s���#�a' F�('� �)a/ ^� � 7�� � �'���

��� .��T� �# R� �J)5��/ ����� G���* mo/s�1�s/s��� �'� )������#"V`e� .(�������#" b$�1 @������ �T �$�� )V`e� (� @�"�� ��� ���)�� � �����4 �$�� ��x," �

���[[hV���# �a' �����4 �����A F�('� I2�$ ����� � ��) " ��'���-�#�" F��1 �� @�"���/�� �)�# �#9�'���4��E�� � �*�" -�1 �Y"�+< ��,�)$� �os/s ���$ ���)�� � ��� �

@��' ��"� Y$��" @�"�� �T �� G2�c" ��� ��,/� �'�$ � #$� ^� @��,� � �'��1 �/� �#&�1 �'����#w �� �� �'��� @����# ��<)����#7V`oV .(�*�6 %/�K4 ��

G��* �"�,�$�4 ���'��T ��a2�)SCL-90-R(��m/s��"� Y$� .��� �� %/�K4 ������� ;# !1�/%/�K4 ��. ���a)$� ��#{)"�,Q @�#$�A� �� ���� �"��1 ���/ � %/�K4 F�' � #$� ���"� ��i��SPSS����A ;# !1 � ��i(1 .

������

�" @��' �"�A�� @�#$�A� ;# !1@��N� ���� � �� �/�����6�� � �#2�� �"�����' ��/

1- Hapkins symptom check list

Page 205: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

205

�� �) G��* �@�#$�A� �2�� " �� �A��5�� � ���" Y�3��" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,�hV/sW�[j/sW�'�(#/ Y#"��!" ����6�� ��� �##{1 @�i#" ��� �Y��� %/��

)Vm/sW=Beta ( ����):� �J'�J#)`V/s0=Beta (�J)5�� /�)��a� �)Vo/s=Beta (G#$� ��* � Y�5' ���l4)V`/s=Beta ( �'�)&$�$ ��/��# ")V`/sW=Beta ( ��<

U# * �����'�)[s/sW=Beta ( �c$ ��se/s�, " Y$� ��� .�" @��' S��)' ��� �/�����6���J)5�� �����):� �J'�J# ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/ /��)��a� �

G#$�� U# * �����'���< ��'�)&$�$ ��/��# " ���* � Y�5' ���l4 �#{)" @��,�Y$� ��lA�#|t1 �A��5�� � ���" Y�3��" �# �('�#" .Y�3��" �# �('�#" �#{)" �#,��/ �� �) G��* �@�#$�A� �2�� " �� �A��5�� � ��4`V/sW�Vj/sW��� �Y��� %/��

" ����6�� ��� �##{1 @�i#" �'�(#/ Y#"��!)V�/sW=Beta (�����)��)V`/sW=Beta(����):� �J'�J#)`e/s=Beta (�J)5�� /��)��a�)Vo/s=Beta (G#$� ���l4 ��* � Y�5')V�/s=Beta (��# " �'�)&$�$ ��/)V[/sW=Beta ( �����'� ��<

U# *)V�/s=Beta ( �c$ ��se/s�, " Y$� ��� .@��' S��)' ����"����6�� �/���/ � ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����'�J)5�� �����):� �J'�J# �����)��/���)��a� G#$����l4

� U# * �����'���< ��'�)&$�$ ��/��# " ���* � Y�5' �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,�Y$� ��lA�#|t1 �A��5�� � ��4 Y�3��".

7� P)�(@� �""&$ ��#� ��"�#(� ��:<� �o8�4���a#b ����"� #!6/�#� �"� ����'�� ���(3#;�� � �� <��

#"+�� Adjusted R SquareBStd.Error Beta TSig

7�� [�( :���" Y�3��" Vm/sjs/sWs�h/shV/sWhh/jWssV/s[�3 [�( :

���" Y�3��" he/s`�/sWsoV/s[j/sWmo/hWssV/s�'�(#/ Y#"��!" mh/VWem/sVm/sWsj/`Wss[/s����):� �J'�J# m�/[e�/s`V/sm`/hssV/s

�J)5�� /��)��a� [V/`��/sVo/s[[/`ss[/s

Page 206: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

206

G#$���* � ���l4 hm/[o[/sV�/ss[/`ss`/s�'�)&$�$ ��/��# " �V/sW`o/sV`/sWh`/[WsVj/sU# * �����'���< VV/[j`/s[s/s`m/`ssV/s

7�� [�( :��4 Y�3��" s�h/sh[/sWso�/s`Vh/sWm`/hWssV/s[�3 [�( :

��4 Y�3��" hh/s[V/sWsmm/sVj/sWmm/[Wssj/s�'�(#/ Y#"��!" �s/VWe�/sV�/sW[h/`WssV/s

�����)�� mo/sW``/sV`/sW`h/[Ws[/s����):� �J'�J# so/`js/s`e/sVo/essV/s

�J)5�� /��)��a� [V/`s[/VVo/sVh/`ss[/sG#$���* � ���l4 eh/[o`/sV�/sse/`ss`/s

�'�)&$�$ ��/��# " oe/sW`�/sV[/sW[s/[Ws`/sU# * �����'���< sm/[jh/sV�/s[h/`ssV/s

�" @��' �"�A�� @�#$�A� ;# !1����6�� @��� ���� � �� �/�����' ��/ �#2�� �"� �@�#$�A� �2�� " �� �A��5�� � ���" �6 �� %# Yx��!" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� �

�� �) G��*[o/s�Vh/sY#"��!" ����6�� ��� �##{1 @�i#" ��� �Y��� %/�� �'�(#/)Vj/sW=Beta (�����)��)Vm/sW=Beta ( ����):� �J'�J#)`h/s=Beta (

�J)5��/��)��a�)V�/s=Beta (G#$� ��* � Y�5' ���l4)V�/s=Beta ( ��/��# " �'�)&$�$)Ve/sW=Beta ( U# * �����'���<)V�/s=Beta ( �c$ ��se/s�, " ���

Y$� .�" @��' S��)' �������6�� �/�� ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/ �����)���J)5�� �����):� �J'�J#/�� ��)��a�G#$��'�)&$�$ ��/��# " ���* � Y�5' ���l4

�A��5�� � ���" �6 �� %# Yx��!" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� � U# * �����'���<Y$� ��lA�#|t1 .����6�� @��� ���� � �#,��/� �#2�� �"�����' ��/ �('�#" �#{)" @��,�

�* �@�#$�A� �2�� " �� �A��5�� � ��4 �6 �� %# Yx��!" �# �� �) G�`�/s�[[/s�'�(#/ Y#"��!" ����6�� ��� �##{1 @�i#" ��� �Y��� %/�� )Vm/sW=Beta (

Page 207: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

207

� ����)��)VV/sW=Beta ( ����):� �J'�J#)`V/s=Beta (�J)5�� /��)��a�)Ve/s=Beta (G#$� ��* � Y�5' ���l4)Vo/s=Beta ( �'�)&$�$ ��/��# ")Ve/sW

=Beta ('���< U# * �����)Vo/s=Beta ( �c$ ��se/s�, " Y$� ��� .S��)' ����" @��'����6�� �/�� ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/ �����):� �J'�J# �����)���J)5��/�G#$� ��)��a� �����'���< ��'�)&$�$ ��/��# " ���* � Y�5' ���l4

�� %# Yx��!" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� � U# *Y$� ��lA�#|t1 �A��5�� � ��4 �6 .7� P)0(4���a#b ����"� #@� �""&$ ��#� ��"�#(� ��:<� �o8� !D��K� �"� ����'�� ��

�(3#;�� � �� <�� a )� "� #"+�� Adjusted

R SquareBStd.ErrorBeta TSig

7�� [�( :���" �6 �� %# Yx��!" sm[/sho/sV[/s[o/sVV/hssV/s

[�3 [�( :���" �6 �� %# Yx��!" h`/s[h/ss�h/sVh/sem/[sV/s

�'�(#/ Y#"��!" j[/VWeo/sVj/sWm�/[Wssj/s�����)�� s`/VW``/sVm/sWVm/`Wss[/s

����):� �J'�J# sV/`js/s`h/ss`/essV/s�J)5�� /��)��a� `o/`s[/VV�/s`V/`ssV/s

G#$���* � ���l4 h�/[oh/sV�/s�m/[ss`/s�'�)&$�$ ��/��# " s[/VW`o/sVe/sWjo/[Wsso/sU# * �����'���< sV/[jh/sV�/sV`/`ss[/s

7�� [�( :��4 �6 �� %# Yx��!" Ve/sjj/sVVs/s`�/ssh/jssV/s

[�3 [�( :��4 �6 �� %# Yx��!" ho/s`�/ss�/s[[/s�e/`sssV/s

�'�(#/ Y#"��!" je/VWej/sVm/sW�m/[Wss`/s�����)�� jj/sW`[/sVV/sWsj/[Wsh/s

����):� �J'�J# mh/[eo/s`V/smV/hssV/s

Page 208: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

208

�J)5�� /��)��a� j[/[s[/VVe/sem/[sV/sG#$���* � ���l4 `m/[oV/sVo/s�h/[ssh/s

�/��# "�'�)&$�$ �s`/VW`m/sVe/sWm�/[Wssj/sU# * �����'���< �o/Vj[/sVoV�/`ss[/s

�" @��' �"�A�� @�#$�A� ;# !1����6�� @��� ���� � �� �/� �#2�� �"�����' ��/� �� �) G��* �@�#$�A� �2�� " �� ��c*� � ���" Y�3��" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,�

h[/sW�`j/sW/�� �'�(#/ Y#"��!" ����6�� ��� �##{1 @�i#" ��� �Y��� %)Vj/sW=Beta ( �J)5N�� /�N �)��a�)[s/s=Beta (G#$� ��* �N Y�5' ���lN4)[V/s=Beta ( �'�(#/ ������)Vm/s=Beta ( �c$ ��se/s�, " Y$� ��� .S��)' ���

@��'�"����6�� �/�� ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/�J)5�/�G#$� ��)��a� ���l4Y�5' ��c*� � ���" Y�3��" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� � �'�(#/ ������ ���* �

Y$� ��lA�#|t1 .����6�� @��� ���� � �#,��/� �#2�� �"�����' ��/ �('�#" �#{)" @��,� �� �) G��* �@�#$�A� �2�� " �� ��c*� � ��4 Y�3��" �#[h/sW�V`/sW%/��

�'�(#N/ Y#"��!" ����6�� ��� �##{1 @�iN#" ��� �Y���)[V/sW=Beta (�N ����)��)Vh/sW=Beta ( ����):� �J'�J#)[e/s=Beta (�J)5��/��)��a�)V�/s=Beta (

G#$� ��* � Y�5' ���l4)Vj/s=Beta ( �c$ ��se/s�, " Y$� ��� .@��' S��)' ����"����6�� �/�� ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/�J)5�� �����):� �J'�J# �����)��

/�G#$� ��)��a�� ��* � Y�5' ���l4��c*� � ��4 Y�3��" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� Y$� ��lA�#|t1.

7� P)?(4���a#b ����"� #@� �""&$ ��#� ��"�#(� ��:<� �o8� !6/�#� �"� ����'�� ��_� � �� <��^�#.

#"+�� Adjusted R Square BStd.Error Beta TSig

7�� [�( :���" Y�3��" Vj/seh/sWso[/sh[/sWeV/jWssV/s[�3 [�( :

Page 209: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

209

���" Y�3��" `[/shj/sWsmo/s`j/sW�e/eWssV/s�'�(#/ Y#"��!" `o/VWe`/sVj/sWjh/[Wss�/s

�J)5�� /��)��a� V[/`�V/s[s/shs/`ssV/sG#$���* � ���l4 es/[mh/s[V/s`e/`ssV/s

�'�(#/ ������ [�/Vhm/sVm/sm`/[ssm/s7�� [�( :

��4 Y�3��" seV/s[m/sWsm�/s[h/sWhj/`WssV/s[�3 [�( :

��4 Y�3��" [o/sVe/sWsme/sV`/sWsV/[Wshj/s�'�(#/ Y#"��!" oj/VWem/s[V/sW[h/`WssV/s

�����)�� mh/sW`[/sVh/sW[j/[Ws[e/s����):� �J'�J# ��/Veo/s[e/shs/`ssV/s

�J)5�� /��)��a� oo/[�e/sV�/sss/`ss`/sG#$���* � ���l4 o�/Vo[/sVj/s[o/[s[`/s

�'�(#/ ������ om/sho/sV[/sm�/Vsme/s

;# !1�" @��' �"�A�� @�#$�A�����6�� @��� ���� � �� �/� �#2�� �"�����' ��/ �@�#$�A� �2�� " �� ��c*� � ���" �6 �� %# Yx��!" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� �

�� �) G��*[e/s�Vm/sY#"��!" ����6�� ��� �##{1 @�i#" ��� �Y��� %/�� �'�(#/)V�/sW=Beta ( ����)��)Vm/sW=Beta ( ����):� �J'�J#)[`/s=Beta (

�J)5�� /��)��a�)V�/s=Beta (G#$� ��* � Y�5' ���l4)Vj/s=Beta ( ������ �'�(#/)V�/sW=Beta ( �c$ ��se/s�, " Y$� ��� .�" @��' S��)' ��� �/�����6��� ��'�(#N/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/� �����):� �J'�JN# �����)���J)5� /

�G#$� ��)��a�� �'�(#/ ������ ���* � Y�5' ���l4 �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,�Y$� ��lA�#|t1 ��c*� � ���" �6 �� %# Yx��!" .����6�� @��� ���� � �#,��/��/

�2�� " �� ��c*� � ��4 �6 �� %# Yx��!" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� � �#2�� �"�����'G��* �@�#$�A� �� �) `�/s�`h/s����6�� ��� �##{1 @�i#" ��� �Y��� %/��

Page 210: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

210

�'�(#/ Y#"��!")Vm/sW=Beta ( ����):� �J'�J#)[`/s=Beta (G#$� ���l4 ��* � Y�5')Vo/s=Beta ( �'�)&$�$ ��/��# ")V`/sW=Beta ( �'�(#/ ������

)[[/s=Beta ( �c$ ��se/s�, " Y$� ��� .S��)' ����" @��'����6�� �/� ��/G#$� �����):� �J'�J# ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/��# " ���* � Y�5' ���l4

� ��4 �6 �� %# Yx��!" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� � �'�(#/ ������ ��'�)&$�$Y$� ��lA�#|t1 ��c*�.

7� P)I(4���a#b ����"� #@� �""&$ ��#� ��"�#(� ��:<� �o8��!D��K� �"� ����'�� �^�#._� � �� <�� a )� "�

#"+�� Adjusted R SquareBStd.ErrorBeta TSig

7�� [�( :���"�6 �� %# Yx��!"sjs/s`o/sVs[/s[e/sme/`ssV/s

[�3 [�( :���"�6 �� %# Yx��!"`V/s[j/ss�[/sVm/so[/[sse/s

�'�(#/ Y#"��!" jh/VWej/sV�/sW�e/[Wssh/s�����)�� o�/sW`V/sVm/sWoh/[sse/s

����):� �J'�J# mj/Veo/s[`/ss`/`ss`/s�J)5�� /��)��a� oV/[�h/sV�/s��/[ss`/s

G#$���* � ���l4 oj/Vo[/sVj/s[j/[s[e/s�'�(#/ ������ h`/Ve`/sV�/sms/[sso/s

�� [�(7:��4 �6 �� %# Yx��!"Ve/seo/ss�e/s`�/sVj/jssV/s

[�3 [�( :��4 �6 �� %# Yx��!"`h/seV/ssom/s`h/so�/essV/s

�'�(#/ Y#"��!" h�/VWeh/sVm/sWmh/[Wssm/s����):� �J'�J# os/Vej/s[`/s[[/`ssV/s

G#$���* � ���l4 [s/[m�/sVo/smm/[ssj/s�'�(#/ ������ ms/VeV/s[[/s``/`ssV/s

�'�)&$�$ ��/��# " os/sW`o/sV`/sWsm/[Ws`�/s

Page 211: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

211

��"�� � dK��#"(

��� �� �� k�*�" ��� �$�� � 2�c" ��� �� �" �+3����6�� �#2�� �"���T�' ��/ ��# y��1�� �� �('�#" @��,�� ���2�� ��)�� v���� ��c*��A��5�� �@��'��� ;��

�"�#< �� �,,� .��� @��' %/�K4 S��)'����6�� ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/�J)5�� �����):� �J'�J# /�G#$� ��)��a��'�)&$�$ ��/��# " ���* � Y�5' ���l4 �

� U# * �����'� ��<�'�� �A��5�� � ���" U# * Y�3��" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� .�/����6�� �#,�� ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/ �����):� �J'�J# �����)��

�J)5��/�G#$� ��)��a� �����'���< ��'�)&$�$ ��/��# " ���* � Y�5' ���l4� U# *�'�� �A��5�� � ��4 U# * Y�3��" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� .����6�� ��/

� ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����'�����)���J)5�� �����):� �J'�J# /��)��a� �G#$�� U# * �����'� ��< ��'�)&$�$ ��/��# " ���* � Y�5' ���l4 �#{)" @��,�

�'�� �A��5�� � ��4 � ���" �6 �� %# Yx��!" �# �('�#" .

�)���%/�K4 � �/ �� ��A��$ � �3 ��/)��>��" @��,�=��/ ��1�� �[ss[�������T �Y���� #)$�T ��[ss� ��"@���E�/ � �#A �[sse�=���" � i E'�� �=a2�� �

[sV[ .( %/�K4 ��=��/ ��1�� )[ss[ (���6�����/ �'�� ��y��1�� �# b��� �,��2�� v���� ��. )���2�� �6 �� %# Y��a6 v���� � ���2�� �#��4 Y�3��" v����(�

I9D� �A��5�� %�' �c$�� ���('�#" ���,)..����� @�#" ����6�� ��?Q �����)�# ='����� �����< ��+)<� �'��� �A��5�� � ��. v���� �,��2�� ��)�� � y��1�� �� �

��/ ����6�� ��,).�� �('�#" %�'�'�/G#$� ������' �2�),���< �F�.���l4 � ��* ��J)5��/��)��a��� .� #)$�T � ������T �Y��� )[ss�' � ��� ;� �=��2��

�=���" �i E'�[sV[ ($�� �� i#'N��� �T �'��� @��' ��< �N�,��2�� b��Z��� ;E.����6�� ��#AG#$� �� �/���� �|� �� �'��� �$�,..

���� ;# !1 � �#,��/����6�� �� �. �&�" �/ ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/�J)5�� /�G#$� ��)��a�� Y�5' ���l4� �'�(#/ ������ ���* �('�#" �#{)" @��,�

Page 212: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

212

����6�� � ��c*� � ���" U# N* Y�3��" �#N ��'�(#N/ Y#"��!N" �N"�����' ��/��J)5�� �����):� �J'�J# �����)�� /�G#$� ��)��a� � ��* � Y�5' ���l4

�'�� ��c*� � ��4 U# * Y�3��" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,� .�� ��D�����6� ��/� ��'�(N#/ Y#"��!" �"�����'�J)5�� �����):� �J'�J# �����)��/���)��a�

G#$�� �'�(#/ ������ ���* � Y�5' ���l4 %# Yx��!" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,��#|t1 ��c*� � ���" �6 ������6�� � Y$� ��lA ��'�(#/ Y#"��!" �"�����' ��/

G#$� �����):� �J'�J# �'�(#/ ������ ��'�)&$�$ ��/��# " ���* � Y�5' ���l4��'�� ��c*� � ��4 �6 �� %# Yx��!" �# �('�#" �#{)" @��,�.

�" @���E�/ � �#A)[sse (i#'���2�� ��/�J2� �� �� Y<�,. %�' � �a," ��/G#$���� @��' �'��� �$�,.�'.2���=���" � i E'� �=� )[sV[ (�� �$�� � y��1

����6�� ��J)5�2�� �)<�,. ��/ �,#2� �'��' �� �)<�,�'��� I9D� �� �a )&" k��'� ����6�� @� �� �� �,)<���4 @�'��:�'� �"���T�' ��/ �# b��� �� �('�#" @��,�

�<�. �� @R�5�/ � �DE�" � ���)�� � �a��� �DC�" � �J)5�2� Y#a#� ��/ �)��A �x'�..S��)' @��'� ����6�� �������1�� /� ��� y��1�� �� �('�#" �� @��,�

� �����' �J)5�2� �# �" ;�� �a��� �DC�" � @R�5�/ �DC�"�,T .� ��i(11N�)�# ;# ! '� �� ��� @��' �|� ���N"���T�' U )&" k��N�����6��/ �� �/Nk�' �� �

G#$��'��� �$�,. )D)<� ;�" �a��� �RD)<� �, � � ��A��5�� � ���c*� �R;&" ��/��)�� � �:�1 ��' �RD)<� �,'�" ���)�� �RD)<� (�,)5/ �#A��.

� 1 � ��'�� ��,��: �Y#�.� ���#�!1V)V��e (����6�� �� ��� @��' �J)5�� ��/��' �/� F�. �� ��� b�1�" �$�$� �A��5�� >D)<� �#&�1 � �?:�1 ;�3 ���

����6�� �� �2�6G#$� �� b�1�" ��c*� >D)<� �#&�1 � ��* � Y�5' ���l4 .����(" � 2�c" �� ������6�� �� �� ��< �F�. � ��' � �:�� �#2�� �"���T�' ��/

��#��4 �2�),�N�$� � ��)��a�NG# ���l4N�� ��J#('�#" ��* �N" �cN@�#.N��# ��/

1- Schmidt, Joiner, Young & Telch

Page 213: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

213

��'���A��5�� ��. � ����4 �� )��1�� � =��/[ss[.(

I#1 �#,��/V)[sVs (����6�� ��� @��' �J�� ��/�K4 �� %�' �#2�� �"���T�' ��/^�$ v���� �# y��1�� �� �('�#"�'��' � ����4�'��� ��/ �� Y#+&. >D)<� ��/

�E,�� � �'��� @R�5A�i@������' � ���" ��$ �� F�A �a��� �'Y#+&. �RD)<� ��/ k�'A�B�'��' � ��4 ��$ �� F�A �a��� @���� � ��� � Y.�� y��1�� >D)<� ��/

k�' Y#+&.CY.�� y��1�� .

�, �'�� �x' �)[ss` (�#2�� @��3��" � v��T �a," ��(1 �(#)' ��)��K�����2�� (����6�� � �/��� ����2�� G$�,"�' b��� ��$�$� ��/@�?: � ��< ���" �� ���

�" ;E. �"���T�' ���7 � @�"��#4�)�� � ��#A ���Ea1 �� ���/�J2� ���7 � �)���" Y#��1 �"���T�' ��/��)�� � ��. U��!1�" F���1 � �'�.Y#+&. �iT�" �)5/ � �,��

�" ;C. �� �'��� �RD)<� ��/�.

�" %/�K4 ��� S��)' �##�1 �����6�� YaA @��1��� �'�(#/ Y#"��!" ��/�" ;C. ������ �� ����):� �J'�J# ��2��/ �Y�!" ����| �Y#,"� � �?'� ��#' �� ��#A

%#4 ;�3 ��#. � F��)6� � X��l4 ��$�56� �).�lA @�#" ��Y$� ���' �*�� �,# .����6�� �������'�< �� �/�" ��:� � ���/U# * �,��2�� Y�3��" ��/��)�� �� ���

� ���2�� � Y$������" ���N$ ��a��� �6 �� %# � ��)��� � �<�N,1 ���i," ��A>�),��,)5/ ��,,� .����6�� �J)5�� ��//�G#$� � �)��a� i#' ��* � Y�5' ���l4

����'�< ��� ���/�" ��:��" %/�� �� ���� =a' � ���)�� �� ��� �6 �� %# ��,/��" Yx��!" ���� ����)5'��)' �C,�� �� �,, �� @��# ��/��� F�('� ��� �� ���� �'�

�,,� Z���1 ����'�< .%# ���2�� ��)�� �(#)' �� i#' �'�)&$�$ ��/��# " ����6��>�),��" ��(�� B3�1�4 � ��,,���. .-�56� �� ��: ��' � �(," ����6�� ���

Y��*� b��� �� Y���#4 ���,�.����" �'��,"��. .=C ," �� �,��2�� ��)�� �#,��/;CN. ��� �N.� �'��� ��� � U# * Y�3��" ��,,N� �'�(#N/ ������N ����6�� ��#A

1- Thimm

Page 214: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

214

�" ������ �� ��< �+&. ��/��#' @�# � Y��" ��'�(#/ ����6�� ��� ����� ����� ���.�"����6�� ��� ��,,���� ���7 �� �/�" � ��� @�. �� � )5" �� ��� � ��. >� � ;C

�" ��c*� � �A��5�� � D)��'��$.

�� Y$� ���)$� �#*�� ��� � �a��� �RD)<� ��(�� ��� �)<�,. ��/��E����" ���� ���2�� � �#2�� ��(1 � �T �'� " � �/�#5a1r$�4 �c$�� �'�.�,)5/ �'�(#/ ��/

���7 �a," ���7 � �T ���D�� X����4 ��"�" ���#AG#$� ;"�� �'��1 ���l4G#$� F���1 � D)� ����.� �'��� ��/.

��"���#"(

�)��� -�$� ��" �x' � �/ ��)�� ��!' �#|t1 Y!1 ��#5 ����� �'��� G#$� k�' �T �$� @��'��� � �� ���2��� �c��� �K�� � ����'�< %�' ��� � Y$� ��� �T��T ���� �� ���2��

� ��a2z" @��, %#4 �� %# ��'��� ��� �A�'� � �'R�� � ��A�'�" ���|� �T ��/�" �'��4���$ .G#$� � b�1�" � G$�,"�' ��/��)�� Y�#�6 �� ���2�� �)<�,. ���l4

;E. ������6�� ��#AG#$� � �"�����' ��/ ���i5 %�' @��'��� �� �)<�,�'��� ��/��'��� '�#" %�' �## 1 �����,����6�� �( � ���2�� ��)�� v���� �# �#2�� �"���T�' ��/G#$� ��.� @�'�T � iT��1 %��i�� � �)<�,�'��� ��/)��#2�� @��3��" ����2�� �K�� (

G#$� �)<�,. @�"�� � ��#J�#4 ���.� �#a" ����� �)<�,�'��� ��/.

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :[m/sm/V`�[ Y����� r���1�&5' �2��" ���?' :[s/Vs/V`�[

�2��" X��l4 r���1:Vm/V[/V`�[

Page 215: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

215

q���� References �56 ��/�)V`oh.(l��� ������# 4�$�' [#� ����G ������ ���#�)SF-SQ(�@���4�,.��� �"�' �$

�9������ �"D� ��J�'�� ��.��.

n# #� �=���)V`om .(��;�� ,�@��?1 �@�w��� �#�?" ��:�1 �:�,�:�� �����)'�.

8� �)� �@���/����� 5" ����!" ���'�"�$ ^"�#$)V`�s(.$ %�'�^� �,��2�� �'�#4 ��J)5�2� ��/�5,: ��#)�� �� ����,4��<���"<�� ��������� �����$ >�$ �����. �F`.

;$�� ��D#A� ����" ������ �G,�� �@�#���. I��T ��9������ ����)V`�s .(����6�� �$�� �'�#4 � �/� I9D� ����� �� � H�Q �� #�� @�� � @��:�' @��)<� �� �,��2�� ���+� ���?).�4 ��� ����

)�)�? �#?. �E.i4 F� � ��J�'�� ��/�K4 � ("(�. �I/�i'�. >�$ ����V� �`sW`o.

������ �Y"�?. ��*�# � ��)�| �'��$ ��'��*� )V`o�.(�$�� �c�� ��$��/ ����4�'��� �����6����/ �"���T�' �#2���9�&<�.� ��"�#$ ���������� �VV)[(�[ehW[`�.

�2��+'���#" u�� �����#.)V`o� .(�;��2� �P�$ ��U"� � [�f�� 1%K$ E�� <�� ��"�#$ ��:<� ���O��� �3�#r� -���� �� 8�6� ����%"�L8�6�#"i 3�#�� �� ��%G�@���4 �$�,.��T �"�' �$�,�'��� �).� ��.��

���#�!1 � F� � �6�� �"D$� ���� ��J�'�� ��"���.

�).�� ����')V`oh .( �;�m� ���� }#b E3�"�G� �� 43����� ��"�#$ ���:<� �"� ]�6$�� ���#�B����3�"� iT�" � �)5�i? F� � ��J�'�� ����" � �J)5�� � g�+"�$ %/�K4 � X��

��&�'��1.

Backer-Fulghum, Lindsey M. Patock-Peckham, Julie A. King, Kevin M. Roufa, Indsay, Hagen, Leslie (2012). The Stress-response Dampening Hypothesis: How Self-esteem and Stress Act as Mechanisms between Negative Parental Bonds and Alcohol-related Problems in Emerging Adulthood, Addictive Behaviors, 37, 477-484.

Liss, Miriam; Timmel, Laura; Baxley, Kelin; Killingsworth, Patrick (2005). Sensory Processing Sensitivity and its Relation to Parental Bonding, Anxiety, and Depression, J Personality and Individual Differences, 39. 1429-1439.

Hale, William W. Valk, Inge Van Der. Engels, Rutger, Meeus, Wim (2005). Does Perceived Parental Rejection Make Adolescents Sad and Mad? The

Page 216: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

216

Association of Perceived Parental Rejection with Adolescent Depression and Aggression, Journal of Adolescent Health, 36, 466-474.

Harris, A.E., & Curtin, L. (2002). Parental Perceptions, Early Maladaptive Schemas, and Depressive Symptoms in Young Adults, J Cognitive Therapy and Research, 26, 405-416.

Mcgin, Latak, Cukor. Daniel, Sanderson. William, C. (2005). The Relation between Parenting Style, Cognitive Style and Anxiety and Depression, Cognitive Therapy and Research, 29, 219-242.

Nordahal, Hans M. Hangom, I.A. (2005). Early Maladaptive Schema in Patient with or Withhout Personality Disorder), Clinical Psychology and Psycho Therapy, 12, 142-149.

Roelofs, Jeffrey. Onckels, Linda. Muris, Peter. (2012). Attachment Quality and Psychopathological Symptoms in Clinically Referred Adolescents: The Mediating Role of Early Maladaptive Schema, J Child Fam Stud.

Russ, Eric. Heim, Amy, Westen, Drew. (2003). Parental Bonding and Personality Pathology Assessed by Clinician Peport, Journal of Personality Disorders, 17(6), 522-536.

Schmidt, N.B., Joiner, T.E., Young, J.E., & Telch, M.J. (1995). The Schema Questionnaire: Investigation of Psychometric Properties and the Hierachical Structure of a Measure of Maladaptive Schemas, Cognitive Therapy and Research, 19, 295-321.

Thimm, Jens C. (2010). Mediation of Early Monality Disorder Symptoms, J. Behav. Ther. & Exp. Psychiat, 41, 52-59.

Young, Jeffrey E. KloskoT Janet S. Weishaar T. Marjorie E. (2003). Schema Therapy: A Practitioner's Guide, New York: The Guilford Press.

Young, J. (1990). Cognitive Therapy for Personality Disorders: A Schema- Focused Approach, Sarasota, FL. Professional Resource Exchange Inc.

Young, J.E. (1994). Cognitive Therapy for Personality Disorders: A Schema-Focused Approach, Sarasota: Professional Resource Press.

Young, J.E. (1999). Cognitive Therapy for Personality Disorders: A Schema- Focused Approach, 3 rd.ed., Professional Resource Exchange.

Lancaster, Gillian, Rollinson, Lynn. Hill, Jonathan (2007). The Measurement of a Major Childhood Risk for Depression: Comparison of the Parental

Page 217: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

217

Bonding Instrument (PBI) ‘Parental Care’ and the Childhood Experience of Care and Abuse (CECA) ‘Parental Neglect’, Journal of Affective Disorders, 101, 263-267.

Geerts, Erwin. Van Os, Titus. Gerlsma, Coby (2009). Nonverbal Communication Sets the Conditions for the Relationship between Parental Bonding and the Short-term Treatment Response in Depression, Psychiatry Research, 165 .120-127.

Carter Michele M. Sbrocco, Tracy. Lewis, Evelyn L. Friedman, E.K. (2001). Parental Bonding and Anxiety: Differences between African American and European American College Students, Anxiety Disorders 15, 555-569.

Lumley, Margaret N. Harkness, Kate L. (2007). Specificity in the Relations among Childhood Adversity, Early Maladaptive Schemas, and Symptom Profiles in Adolescent Depression, Cogn Ther Res, 31:639-657.

Renner, Fritz. Lobbestael Jill, Peeters, Frenk. Arntz, Arnoud. Huibers, Marcus (2012). Early Maladaptive Schemas in Depressed Patients: Stability and Relation with Depressive Symptoms over the Course of Treatment, Journal of Affective Disorders, 136, 581-590.

Gunty, Buri. (2008). Parental Practices and the Development of Maladaptive Schemas Online Submission, Paper Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Midwestern Psychological Association, Chicago, 33 pp.

Page 218: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

218

���0 $( ;<-20 F)3?�� ����#.� �$��$( )���0 X�� C�$ �! ��B�� ���8 �( )3?�� ����3 &$ �� F) ���! � )-/$��� C�$ �� 9K;/ ��1;�6

��!;-� ��( ���G �-�( �%�#' 3�#�z

�#/�� �#;�{

s3�o �_#"�G�#�%/ 43�)|

4 "SQ �! X�� �$ �#|t1 �$�� �%/�K4 ��� ���:� �� g�/���A �� �J)aA ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �Q�� ��/

%'�� �3D<� ����3 �.� � ��3D<� ����*�" ����� �'��,&$ � �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �)����" X�� � @���"��� .Y$� ��x," � ��c," �'��)<� �c$�)" -���" �# � �# �� �g�/ ��� � ���VoX�� � �$��" �� �@��?1

'�'��%'�� @�#" �� =]$ ��. �&)'� ����+1 ��#A �����+1 ���lA�� � �&)'� X�� Z��� �� � @� F�� ���4 @���"�mm ����"�� ���A �� G2�3 �� �a' )�� G��" �/��A �![`���A �� �J)aA ��a' �� G��" ��Q�� ��/[j�a' (�

���A ���A)�� G��" ��'��,&$ X��[o�a' (�,)��A ���3 .%#4 ��(1 u�� �� Z#�!1 ���:� Y?:@�"��W=4@�"���. ���a)$� ���A ���A � .%'�� �3D<� ����3 %(,$ ��x," �%#4 �� @���"�=4 � @�"�� U�� 1 @�"�� �� �@�"��

;��5")DIT ( Y��A ���3 �#�t1 ���" @� �����4 �<�. � �. ���a)$�)oj/s=α.(%#4 ���:� �� =4 � <��" �@�"��"����A �� �J)aA ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �! ;"�. �.�� �'��,&$ � �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �Q�� ��/

��" � �3D<� ����*�" ����� I "V[���A � G#1�1 � �5 : ���A �� �J)aA ��/��A �! ��/ � �Q�� ��/�. �9��� �'��,&$ .����@�"�� �� ���a)$� � �/ ��/t;# !1 ���1� ��� @�5��� ;�� @�"�� �='������ ;# !1 �='�������/

��� ��l(" � ��. ���lA Y"D�)�� �< (�� �. ���� @��' � �. ;# !1 :���A �� �J)aA X�� �� � �Q�� ��/�, " � Y��" �#|t1 ��/��A �!%'�� �3D<� >R�)$� �.� � �����).�� @���"�).��' ��#|t1 �'��,&$ X�� � �'� ����A �� �J)aA X�� �#|t1 �Y$�%'�� �3D<� >R�)$� �.� � �Q�� ��/ �)�# �/��A �! X�� �#|t1 �� �@���"�

���A �� �J)aA � �/��A �! ���A �� ���� �Y$� ��� �� ��3D<� ����3 �1R� � 6�" � ��1�� �x' �� ��Q�� ��/�).�� ��)? ��C �� ��'��,&$ ���A ���� � �5���"�, " ���"� �x' �� �� �'��� ��� .='������� ;# !1 �#,��/

� �/��A �! ���A �� ���� �3D<� ����3 �� ��. ��(�� Y��" ���##{1 �� ��� @��'���A �� �J)aA ��Q�� ��/%#4 ���:� �� �.�' @�"��DIT���A �� Y��. �C �Y$� ����' @�"�� ���" � ���,.� ���/�� G�$ ����"�� ��1�

Y$� ��. �?'� �3D<� ����3.� "�H ��(h��:��3D<� ����3 �.���� " ���A �� �J)aA ��/��A �! ��3D<� X�� � �Q�� ��/

�'��,&$ ��)����".

1N�)#�1 �$�,�'��� ���)��X���4 � X��"� �� 2�c" ��J�/�K4 �� � ��#/ ��� �)>�p5" ��,5��'(Email:[email protected] 2N@��?1 ��J�'�� ��)$� 3N-��" Y#�1 ��J�'�� ��#�'��

Page 219: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

219

�� 2� �3D<� Y#�1V%'�� �3D<� �.� � ��� ���"� �� ����� �� @���"�F�x' ��/ �'�"�� ��/

���� � �).�� ���3 �)#�1 .w�G6�7 G ��3D<� Y#�1 �� �'��) " Y#�1 � I# 1 @��x' ���� �Y$� ����* ��"�»Y#�1[Y$� �3D<� ��1�� ��"� «)��)#4 � Y$�/`�V�mV �

������ ��:�1V`o� (�� �Y$� �3D<� ��"� � I#/�a" �� � �" �����/ ��$��" b#!" ��$�$� �� �3D<� Y#�1 �� ���g�/ ���1� Y#�1 ��/.�" ��� ���)�����h�V�oo �

���,���� � �$��e�V��h .(�K�� Y#�/� i#' �$�,�'��� ���6 �� �3D<� Y#�1���� �� .��>�A�� �" �x'j)V�so�a#. �� ;�' � �m�V�o�(�����):� �$�,�'��� ����#, �2�5" �

���� @��� �3D<��Y$� � "�: .3D<� �.� ��3D<� Y#�1 I?" �� � �� �C�Y$� �.���x'F�?a" �U )&" ��/���$���� Y$� � �3D<� �.� �� �1��a)" ��/�'� .G w� �����x' ����3 � X�J' ���)�� �#x' ��#3D<� �� ��� � %#��� ��/)>R�)$� (�:�1 ���"

�)��A ���3 �'�)��a#.V�o� .(���x'��.� ��/W�)<�,. o�£�#4 ���x' �#x' ����� � �Vs �)�#1 Y<�,. �t�" �#� �,,�)� � �"�1 �i9����' �Y$��#VV �[sss (�� �'��) " �

X��� G5� >��)'� �� �c#!" ���#|t1 I#�)5" l<� ;7�6 �%'�� k�' �/ � �3D<� ��/ �'��# b#!" � �/� >� � ;"� 1 �� �.�' �C �Y5#' ��� �'��� F�x' � �'��# �"�

� �'��# ��(,/ @�. �'��� � Y$�Y<�$ Fi )5" �� �'��# ��(,/ ����� ���Y<�$ ��< ����� ���W�" l: �� �:��< �"� �� �" �x' �� ��,� �lJ/� �� �� �'�#A

�'��� �,���� �����$V[ �)<�,. ��/��)<�$ �� Y# 3��)u�������/V` (�'�� ����$Vh

u�������AK�� � �/�" ���7 Y# 3�� �� 3�1 � �/��#A .�X��� ���A��� ��� ���/ >R�)$� F�x' �� � C. ��3D<�N��� ��� ���b:�N/ �� Y$� ����)NY<�,. � F�J�

2- education 4- Duric 6-Mc Dougal 8- Cognitive- Developmental 10- Kohlberg 12- assimilation 14- accomodation

1- Moral education 3- Hirst and Peters 5- Oser and Rieshenbach 7- Shaffer 9- Piaget 11- Rest, Narvaez, Thoma & Beabeu 13- Schema

Page 220: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

220

�" >�!1 �'��� �.� ;6��" G56� ����.���x' ��/ � ���#A��� ��: � �)<�,. @�.�,V��,: �" �#�t1 Y# 3�� ���(,/ ��/ �,,�)��$��V��m (�" ��� ��� �,,�

��� Z��� �� ����Y<�$ �� Ix," �,���� �� �'R� � �����):� Ix' ���,��� ����3 ����" Y����" ����"�� �#*���" ;��' @�"��#4 ��#'� ��� � � �,� ��.)�'�'W�� C,��

V��h .(���x' ����.� ��/W����� �3D<� �.� ��)<�,. ��� Y$:»�'��� %��i��X��� @�.���#, �J,/�� ��/ «��»;C." ��#A >�),� ��� �'��� ��/��# ��)�� «

)���� �V�jo (��»%,# �� ��� �Ca1 ��J2� �a#� � ����� �/�'�"��$��/ �� � 7�6 I�Q �� �� �3D<� �.� � �3 ;6��"���)5A ���'��" �Q��]C� ��1�,� «)��2��[�

iJ# ���� �`�"��#2 �h�V�o` .(

@��,� � �£�#4 �#$D� � 2�c"3D<� ����3 ���� �)V�`[(�� ���#5 ��,�" �%/�K4@��� ��/� �3D<� ����3 �.� ���6 �� �)<�,.�" ���. ���)� i,#1���

U��Ae�V�mh@�)'� � =�� �j�[sse (���x' �:�1 ���" I/ ��,/ �� ���x' �@�����4 Y$� �3D<� >�!1)�Q�'Vm �V��m .( F�x' �2i," � �� �3D<� ����3 �.� ��£�#4

��X��" ����� �# b��� � �/Y<�$ >�+!" �� @� � Y5'�� b#!" � �/� ;"� 1 ��� ����):�)@��J�� � �c�� (�" �x' �� � F�J�/ ��3D<� ����3 �� �� ��) " � Y��A

�" >�!1 �)<�,. � �'��� �.� ���)����/o�V�m� .( �x' �� HD<� ��£�#4 �x' ��Y���� �, " � >�$��< @�������� �2� Y$� @R�5A�i �� ��i ��/ � �� @� �1

Y����" � ���C�/ �2i,"Vs �" �x' �� ��< @R�5�/ ��'�#A .�� ��� @��' ���3D<� ����3 �� @����� ���a)$� �J'�JQVV�" ���#4 �2�!1 �,���� ���' �� ��,� .

�� ����h�2� e�3D<� %#4 ���� �� �J2�$ V[ �" �$ �Y�5' ��� ��� ����3 � �/�A� �� �?'� �� ����' ��' Y�����,� .��)�� ��/��" Z��� �� ���� ��� ��?)'� ��@�T��T

2- Colby 4- Lieberman 6- Krebs & Denton 8- Hoffman 10- Cooperation 12- premorel

1- construction 3- Biggs 5- Kurtines and Grief 7- Nucci 9- obedience 11- moral rule

Page 221: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

221

>�5A�i @���������3 ��)�� �� �# �1 � �1 ��#4 ����3 � Y�5' ��)�# �/�A� ��?'� �,"�" �,T)��a#.V�o� .(��#4�A� HD<� ��3D<� �.� � 6�" �#2�� ��£�#4 �x' ��VY$� .

@�����Vs� �,)5/ �'��# � Z c" X��� ����� ��� ����3 �� �'�� ��) " �2�$ ��'��� �##{1 �� �?'� @��1 .� Y$� >�5A�i ���)3� �#|t1 Y!1 �� 6�" ��� �� ����

X����" �#7�1 �� �� �'�J'��/ �� �/�" �,� �,#� S��)' � �� �3D<� ����3 � ���l4 ����' �'��,Q �:�1 Y#' � � Y$� i���)" ��)�� �� �.�')�'�'W�� C,�� V��h .( �� ����

�J'��� ;"� 1 Z��� � ��)�# �)<�,. Y#��� G5� � ���$�� F��)6� �@R�5�/ � F�� � 6�")��#4 ��< HD<�[(�" Y$���� .�"� �� ��� ����3 �� 6�" ��� �� ������' Z c"�" �� �?'� �� Y$� ��) " � �'�� �;�� �,#� �"�#4 � ��D� � ��� �##{1 @��1

F�('� �� ;�� �� ���� �,/� Y2�6 � Y#' ��" �:�1 i#' �����,� .�.� �����,<�N1 �(#)' ��£�#4 �x' �� �3DN;"� ���� �# ��/`Y$� .;"� 1 ��� Z��� �� ��� ��/���;6�" �#2�1 ���/�" �x' � �'�a+," �� �,��,$� .

��� �)V�j� (��� X�)5A � uD7� �� �£�#4 ���x' .�� �� ��) " �£�#4 @���/ �� Z��� �� �����(1N�� X�� ���< ��/N. �� �3D<� I#/�a" ��� � @��� �CN;C

�";"�� �� �£�#4 �x' ���" �3D<� �.� �,$ ;6��" �"� ��/� �,���� ����� @��' � ��� �1�" ��+1 �£�#4 �� �i#Q @� �� �)�# � #< ��3D<� >�!1�" >�� ������ .�x' ��

���?" �.� ���D<� >R�)$� i#' � �Ca1 ��/ � ���a)" ;6��" �� ��� �lA Fi )5" ��3��#. g� " � Y$� �2��)" �)�# � �,)5/ �3D<� ����*�" ����� �Ca1 �� �7�<

@�5'�� �� ;6��" ��� �/�" �� ��� 7 ��� �,,�)��a#.V�o�:e`s .( ��� �)��2�� ���� � �V�om (�c$ �$ ����� �3D<� �Ca1 �� ��� @��'h����� �c$ �/ �[

� 6�"e"N��.� .>�� �c$)���� %#4 HD<�j(>R�)$� �.� F�� � >�� ;6��" ;"�.Y$� �3D<� .�3D<� >R�)$� ��c$ ��� �� ���N" ���!" �� Z�D� �N�Y!1 � ��.

2- Autonomous 4- Level 6- Pre-Conventional

1- Heteronomous 3- Interpersonal 5- Stage

Page 222: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

222

��3 �#|t1�" �#�,1 �� �Y$� @��J�� ��" ���)�� �� �3D<� � Y$�� ��)�� � �i��A �'���.� ��� B��," Y"�< �� �� .F�� �c$)���� HD<�V(;6��" ;"�. �`�h�"� �.�

�" Y?: �##{1 @��J�� � �c�� Y�$ � ���� Z�D� �� �3D<� >R�)$��/� .��)��' �� �< ��)�� �� Y# �1 ��3D<�Y$� @R�5�/ � ����'�< �x .�4 �� �c$ ��� �� ���

1 G5� � ����x)'� �����):� ����3 Y����tY$� @��J�� �#9 .�3D<� >R�)$� F�$ �c$)������� HD<�[�2�7� �� `(Y$� I�. � I(,4 ;6��" ;"�. .��/��� �c$ ��� ��

�" ;���1 �3D<� >R�)$� @�'�� � ���� �+&.3D<� ��)�� ���. �H��6 � �:�1� ��X���'�5'� >�7� �� �/N�'�J�/ �)�'�?: (" U�� 1N��)$��< � "�: � ��� �� � ��.

�" �,,� Y# �1 �?'� �� ��.)U#c2h�[sss .(

Y$� ��� u�. � �a2�" �$ ��'������ �3D<� �.� � ��� � ��C���)��$��V�oj :( �3D<� ����3 %(,$ � U#7�1)���� TV�eo2��� ���� � � ��V�om(��C��� �

��c," k��):�e)��$��V��m (�� ��3D<� ����3 �.� � �#|t1 g�/ � �3D<� Y#�1 ��" y��" %/�K4 ��� k�*�" ���. .�Dj)V�j� (�x' ��� �� ��< ��)�� �2�$� ��

�/��A �! Z��� �� �� ��� @��' ���� F�('� ��� �m)'� � �3D<� ��/�� " ����� ����" ���. Y���/%'�� @��1 �� ��1R� ;6��" � �� @���"��'�$� �3D<� ����3 .��

@�)$�� G2�3 �� �� �3D<� ��/�� "�'��"�� � �*�� ��/�/�9��� ����� ��� �?'� � ��T�" ����3 @�)$�� @�"�?3 ��)�� @�� �3D<��'��� .�'��"�� ���' �� " �� �/

�3 �3D<� >R�)$��" �� �� �� � �'�� ��. �6��� �)<�,. ��� 1 ��2� ��� �� �,)��A� 6�" �� �1R� � 6�" ��Y.�� ���3 @� �� �3D<� �.� �x' �� �'��"�� �� �'�� �� .

$� k�' ��� � @��� X�A �� ��� @��' ;7�6 S��)'N>R�).� %��i�� G�$ �/N��'��"�� �3D<�>R�)$� ��� � �. �/� ���/�" ;�� �'�� �1R� � 6�" �� �� ����

)���� � � �D � �#,� ��J' i#'V�me.(

2- Post- Conventional 4- Latif 6- Blatt

1- Conventional 3- Principled 5- Just Community 7- Group Disscussion

Page 223: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

223

;7� �� �/��A �! X�� �6��� �� ��� ��)<�,. ��� 1VY5: ��$ �� @� �� �� �C����*�" >�7�[� �3D<� ����3 �.��" ���.���� .I?" �;7� ��� ���1

>�� 1 I#/�a" X�)5A � �)<�,. �.� ������$���:`� ��.� ���x' �� �)<�,. �2�� 1 �� �1R� ���'� �� �3D<� >R�)$� �9��� �� �3D<� >�!1 �@� Z�c" � Y$� �£�#4 �,/�

�'�,� �.� �c$�" �.�' Y$� �����. .�(," %,1 �#2�1 � �� 7�6 �)<�,. ��� 1�"�" �)&#J'�� @� �|� � ��� �� ��.�,� ;6 �� ��� 1 �1 ��. .��(�� ��� ��� �

��� 1 �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �! �� ��3D<� >�!1 ��1�� � �)<�,. ��� 1 i#"���� ���a)$� .� �� ��3D<� ��/�� " ���" �� �!�)<�,. �J,/��/�' ��(�� Z��h�

�" I/��� �� �3D<� >R�)$� �1R� � 6�" � ��1�� ���:�" �,�)�J,#)5� � �#,� ��J'e�V�em .(�" @� Z��� �� ��� �� Y$� �,/� ��� 1 ���' ��)<�,. �J,/��/�' �.��

X�J' �#�,� ���3� �J,/��/ �X��)�� � �/ . ;6��" � >��)'� �� ����4 ��� �#x' ��1R��" ;�� ��i#2�1���,� .���3 ��� ��#)<� �� ��1�,"��#' ��/��i� ��1R� �3D<� ;6��"

�"@� � �1 �/��,� Y���/ �� �2�5" ;6 ��* �� ��< ��)�� �/ .Y��. �! �� @�A�,,��" �:��" �1R� �c$ �3D<� >R�)$� � �� �'�"� ��3D<� ��/�� " ���" �� � ��'�.

��$�" l: @� ��A��� � �'�.�" ���3 %$�4 ���" �� ��< � �3 ��/ �,/�)�#,� ��J'����2� � ����#2� �U $ �j�V��o �U#c2 �[sss.(

%/�K4 �3D<� ��/�� " ���" �� �/��A �! �#|t1 ����� ��. F�('� ��(1 ��/ �� @���C�/ � ��� � � #$� � �3D<� >R�)$� �)��D �#x'V�j� � �D �

���� �V�me@�),� ���� � ���2�� � �U2� m��#]$� �W�#�� o��"��#2 �V�mm (�T�6�! �� Y$� @� ����" �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �3D<� >R�)$� � �)��" �#|t1 �'��1

'��N% @���"�N ��: �NN���lJ ." ����� �! X�� ��N<� ��/�� N'�� ��3DN%@���"�

2- postulate 4- Cognitive dissonancae 6- Self, Olivarez and Baldwin 8- Speacher- Dabbin

1- Cognitive conflict 3- Equilibration 5- Festinger 7- Fenton 9- Discussion

Page 224: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

224

�" ���3 �! ���" �� �3D<� ��/�� " � ����*�"�" � �,/�>R�)$� �,.�� ��< ��/��,/� �#*�1 ����� �,,� �#:�1 �� @� � �,,� ��#4 �� " ��� � 6 .I " X�� ��� ��

)�J.��"� (�" � $ �� Y$� �2R�)$� �� �1R� � 6�" �� �� �,� �9��� �2R�)$� �,�%'���" �9��� ���A �� ��"��,,� . �� H��c'� X�� ������D�V�" ��#"�' ��.)�R

���[�V�mo��'�. �W;����`�[ssh ��1��� �� ;�' �h�[ssh .( �� 2�c" �� X�� ��� �� #1 � @��#2�$ ��)V�m[(��� � � �D �)V�me(�"��#2 �)V�me(�a#. �)V�mh (�...

�)��A ���3 ���a)$� ���" ��� �R� �'�)V�mo (B�: �#)5&' �� �C� ����, ���" � �/' � ���� �$�� �� �?'� ��3D<� Y#�1 �� 2�c" ����)'� ��"��� �X�� ��� �� ���� @��

�, " �.� ��" �(," �3D<� >R�)$� �� �����. .����" �� 2�c" ��c�� �#�/ ����2 � � 54R �Y���'� b$�1 ��J��e)V�o`(�,#�2 �j)V�oV(='��R �m)V�os (�

Y$�)V�m� (Y$� ��. F�('� .�� ���6 H�� ��/���" �� ��. �$�� �� 2�c" G w� Y$� @�3D<� ��/�� " ����� �! ��N�, " �.� � �� �(," �3D<� >R�)$� ���

�" ��.)��"�1 � Y$� � �#,� ��J'V�oj.(

�"�1 � Y$� �� �DC$�o)V�oe (;# !1��� �� =4�ee ���a)$� � �� ��(1 � 2�c" ��;9�5" U�� 1 @�"��)DIT(Vs �1� 2�c" G w� �� �,)��A �(#)' ��� ��. F�('� �� ��

���� ���a)$� Y#+&. � �)<�,�'��� �.� � �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �!�, " �#|t1 �3D<� >R�)$� ��1�� �� ��'�� � �� �1� 2�c" �� �2�6 �� ��,).�� ����

'�5'� F� � �����):� F� � -���N' �|�" �'�� i���)" ���#�� � �N�'��� .���#|t1� <��" � �,)�" ��/�"�'� ���#|t1 �� ���'� ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �! �.� ��/

�'R�� �D<��" � ��� �)�# Y#+&. �.� � �)<�,�'��� �� �1V[� �5���" �� ��)a/ �D<��"V[W`�)a/ ' ��)�# �#|t1 ���N�,).�� .�;# !1��� ��� ��[�� <��" �� ���" �/

2- lockwood 4- Vezzuto 6- Leming 8- Schlaefli, Rest and Thoma 10- Defining Issues Test

1- Plus- one matching 3- Schonert- Reichl 5- Enright, Lapsley & Levy 7- Lawrence 9- Meta Analysis

Page 225: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

225

! X�� ��N3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �N'�� ���� ���a)$� �N��V��� ����" �"�'�@��� �.� ��/�,. � Y#+&. � �)<m�"�'� �� ���" �����):� F� � -��� ��/

�'�� �)��A ��? .� �� ��� G#1�1 � �H�� �� 2�c" ��� �|� ����'� b$�)"hV/s�`j/s�s�/s@��� �.� � �/��A �! X�� �� @�� �|�" �� ���6 �� �Y$� �)<�,. .

�"�1 � Y$�)V�oj (,)��� Y$� �?��" S��)' � i#'�.i,#J#/V)V�os (���" ��%/�K4 �$�� �"�'� k�' �$ �# ��3D<� X���4 ��/)��/�� " ����� �! ;"�.

@��� X���4 � �3D<� X���4 G#��1 ��3D<� �"�'� � ��#(,$ �)<�,. X���4 ��/����):� �� 2�c" �$�� �"�'� @��� �� �3D<�(�! �� ��� @��' � �. ;��3 i���1 �

" �����X�� ���$ �� �)? �3D<� ��/�� �" �(," �3D<� �.� � �/��. .

��. F�('� �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �! X�� �� ���a)$� � ��J�� �� 2�c"�'� .@��J�� � ��2��)V�mm (�3D<� >R�)$� �� ��"� ��:� � ���##{1 ��/ �� �'��� @��'

� Y$� ��� Y��" ��/��A �! �� Y��. �|� ���#.�! �9��� �� I " � #$� �/r'�$ Z����/�jV[�'�� �##{1 I?" ;"��� �� ������$ .���`)V�mj (�� ��� @��'

�" �'�JQ%'�� @��1 � 6�" �� �� @���"�h� 6�" � �3D<� ����3 e��j����,/�� ��� .� <��" �� 2�c" �� �C�@�)��� � i�#A �i)���� � #$� �|�" ��h)V�os (��. F�('�

Y$� i���)" � 6�" �##{1 � ���#�)5" �.�3D<� >R�)$� �.� ���)�# � 2�c" ��� ���'��"�� ��� �?,1 �� �"� Y$� ���/`/V�#��4 � 6�" �'�� ��< ��)�/ �� �1 .�4e

)V��s (�a2�" I#�)5" =���1 Z��� �� �� ��� @��'���?" ��/ ��3D<� >R�)$� ��/)���?"�/%�' �Zc," ���#AjY2��� �(%'�� ��C �� ��3D<� >R�)$� �� @���"�

�, " �##{1�� ���� ���� .�,#2m)[ss` ��,#2 �� ;�' � �[ssj (�! �� ��� @��'�|� ����'� ����� ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��AoY$� �?:�1 ;�3)hs/s=r(� �

�" �)&$� @� ��� �a," �|� ����'� @��1���A �� i#' �Y�� ��&�|� �� U )&" �,$ ��/

2- Probing 4- Berkowitz, Gibbs and Broughton 6- Role- taking 8- effect size

1- Higgins 3- Boyd 5- Penn 7- Lind

Page 226: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

226

���)5A ��/����� � Y$� �����<� ���������):� F� � �$�� ����*�" �� ��W���� �'�5'� .� iJ,#"���'����� � -�'���DT �=T���"V)[sVs (�9��� �� �'��� @��'

X��"� ����� �! ��5 : �� Y��. � �3D<� >�!1 ��3D<� >R�)$� � y��" ��/b<� ���7 � �3D<� ��/�� "[�c$�)" � ����)� I " Y#�1 �).� @���(�'�� � �

)='�5#2 ����(�, " ��1�� G�$ �D<� >R�)$� ���' ���A ��?'� �3N���� .�'��)5"��`

)V��` (��1�� G�$ ������56 HD<� -�� �� �����56 @���(�'�� Y��. �� ��� @��' �, "�. �?'� �3D<� >R�)$� �c$ ��� .����#2� � ����2� �U $)V��` (�� �'��� @��'

I #� ���" �� �3D<� �! ��5 : �� �C.i4 @���(�'�� Y��.y��" �.��"� ��/ �. �?'� �3D<� >R�)$� �c$ ��1�� G�$ ��C.i4 =���1 � .U#c2)V��� (�! �#|t1

��� �$�� �� ���$���� F�� >�$ @���(�'�� �3D<� >R�)$� � �3D<� ��/�� " ���" �� � �?'� �3D<� >R�)$� �� ��� @��' ��, " ���Y$� �)��� %��i�� ���� .� 2�c" �� ��

��J��)�U#c2[sss(���$���� � y��" �3D<� ��/�� " ���" �� �! �#|t1 ���3D<� >R�)$��j>R�)$� �c$ �� ��� @��' � ��� �$�� �� ���$���� ��(�'��

=4 �� �?'� �3D<�� @�"�� %#4 � Y�5' �@�"���, " ���Y$� �)��� %��i�� ���� .

�� ��� � ���x' � �� �/���)'� �<� �� �x,��7 Y$� ��. ���� �3D<� �.� ���)@�J# #A � �#,� ��J' ���" ���h�V�o[ �@�)'� � =�� �[sse �;���1 �V�o` Y$� �

�@��J�� �V���I�� � Y��/ �F�/��A �W����� e�[sso(�! �� �D � ��� � X�� �Y$� ��. B3�� ���)'� ���" @��J�/�K4 �<� ��$ �� i#' �3D<� .i)����)V�o[(�

@��J�� � i)����)V�os(X�� � 7� Zc," �"H��c'�V"+���� ���3 ���)'� ���" ���'� .���" �)$��< I " �� ��D X��%'�� ��. �1R� � 6�" �� �3D<� >R�)$� � �� @���"�

�,� �:��" .� ��C Y$� ���.� �)$��< ��� Y�:� �?,1 �' �@���C�/ � i)���� �x' ���" �x'�$�@�. ����):� �),$ ���x' � �)�# ��'�� ��� j.� ���x' �1 ���� Z�c1N��

2- Online 4- Gilligan 6- Socialization

1- Commings, Maddux, Cladianos & ichmond 3- Armstrong 5- Graham, Haidt & Rimm- Kaufman

Page 227: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

227

.N1 � ����7 �� I " �� ���� � � �£�#4 �)<�,N� �.� ���!>�" Z���1 @� ���$�"�,� .�,#2)[ss` �,#2 �� ;�' � �[ssj (��/�� " ����� �! ��� �,#�'�: X��

uDc7� � �� @� � ����' �9��� �3D<�"i'�)5'�� X�� ��� �/�� " ����� �!V"��� "Y$� ����' .�|� ����'� ���� � � �D X�� � �5���" �� �X�� ��� �� ��� @��' �,#2

��3�" �#2�1 ��1 F��)6� �, � ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �! � 7� �a2�" �� ���� �,�� �� �:�1 �R� �c$ � ��'�:�� ��<��" ��� ��#A)��,#2 � �#,� ��J' i#'[sse.(

�$��)V�oj (���< ���< � ��3D<� �! ��� ��� � X�� �� Y$� ��) " Y$�� ���#�+1)�'R��� ("� 1 ���' �#��1 �� ���� �# �#!7 ;��)�� �� � �,�

����/��[=���1 )I " ��/���,/� (��'Y$� ����/ ��C� �#� 1 � �� ��� �� � �/�� .F�?a" �� ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �! ��: � ��"�3D<� @��)aA"`�" ���a)$� � �,�

��C� �#� 1 �� �,):� ��� F�?a" ��� �� Y$� ��) "h�|�" Y$� )��V� .( ���" ����,/�� �� ;7� �� �3D<� @��)aA���'��1 � ���)�� �� �'�� �3D<� � ����):� ��/

�" �#��1 �� ����X�� �� %# @� >��. �,"�� � �,�Y$� �J�� ��/ .

��/�� " ����� �! X�� @�� �|�" ����� �� 0��< �� 2�c" �� �C,�� Iw�# �R�)$� ��1�� �� ��3D<��" �x' � �Y$� ��. ���� @��' �3D<� >��/�K4 @�,� �1 �$�

�� ��N%'�� ���" �� ��� �'� @�"���� @���"�NY$� ���' F�(e/ � �N2� �#�N�! �;#

2- strategic 4- Indoctrination

1- The Konstanz Method of Dilemma Disscussion 3- Moral Discourse

eN���#<� �)�2�%/�K4 �<� @�"���� �� ��. F�('� @����� � �a5 � X��"� �"�'� �Q��Q �� �� �/%/�K4 ��+& ��'� �#|t1 �� ���/ ��/�K4 k��):� X��)Community of Inquiry (����3 � �� �����,� �� 6 ��%'�� �3D<� ��/���� �$�� @���"� �'�)� �#,� ��J'

�"�i< � F��" ���a7 �����" �V`o�(�'��� y��1�� �*�6 %/�K4 k�*�" � ���3 �.���" ����� ���6 �1 �� ��/�K4 k��):� X�� ��@�)$�� G2�3 �� �.��"� ���" �Y$� �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �! �� ��� � � �D X��%'�� � �a5 � ��/ �� ;�3 �� �� @���"�

���A �Q��Q�)��A ;C. �&�" ��/ �9��� ��'��"��. .%'��%$�4 ����� �X��"� ��* ��A � YaA Z��� �� @���"� �� ��. u�c" ��/@�)$���" Y$� ������ � ��a5 � ��/�" k��� ��< ��#�� �� ��,�����A � ��,,��" %2�Q ;��" ��/�"�� �� ��< ��c< ��,,� ��C' ��,��

�" �.�� �� I?�" ����*�" ��)��� � � �,,���1 ��/��" Y$� ���,�� .%'�� ;���1 ���/�K4 k��):� � 7� g�/ �'��J.��� � @���"��" �.� ���� Y#3D< � @�#���'� ��!' �?,1 �' ���/�K4 ���� @�� I��6 G�$ � @� �� � Y$� �/�" ;�!1 �#x' �3D<� >�7� ��C �,�

�" � $�1 i#' @��J�� � F��)6� � ����" ���7 � $ �@��J�����.@��J�� � ����" )V`o� (k��):� X�� � �a5 � X��"� �� �'��� @��'%'�� �3D<� ����3 �.� � ���/�K4Y$� �).�� �)��" �#|t1 ����)� I(,4 @���"�.

Page 228: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

228

��,/ ��3D<� Y#�1 ���6 �� �|�" � <��" �2i," � ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A�)5��. ��J��:�"�'� �� ��� �.��"� ��/ ;�� � ��|�" ���a)$� @� �� � ����' �" ���

��'��� .X��� S���1 � ��#3D<� X��"� ���/�K4 � ��(1 �/��. � �:�1� �� �/ Y$� �,)�" �'��,&$ X�� � ��"��� -���")�����T � �#,T ��J'V`mo (� �R��)6� �

Y$� F�R ������ �3�� ��#3D<� X��"� �� Y$� ;#2� �#�/.

��$ ��%/�K4 �J�� ���� @��' ��"� ;�� � ��/ ��/��A �! � ��D� �� �'��)����" X��"�V���A �� =���1 ����$ � �5���" �� ��)����" ��#. � �Q�� ��/

X���'��,&$ � �: �� � X��"� ��/[���� ��)�# ������ �.%/�K4���D$� ��/`

)V��j �V�om �V��s �V��V �V��h (�" @��' �/� �� �)����" X��"� X�� �� �)? �/��A @�#" b��� ��)? � #+!1 Y���#4 � ��'��,&$ X�� � �5���")Y$��

���a1 Y��" X��l4 ��J���/ �).�� � �/(...�i� �� �:�1 � �)$�� k�' ��)�# =a'X����" �(," y���'� ���' %��i�� � �'��R�$ F��" ��/��. .Y � @�5'�: �@�5'�:�)$�h)[sss(���" �� =4 ��ss ��)����" ��#A��� X�� �� �'��� @��' %/�K4

X�� �� �1�|�"Y$� ��� �)�3� �� ���� ��#A��� ��/ .�)����" ��#A��� "�)$� @� �X�� ���" ���.� �.��"� ��/%'�� ��� �,� �� ��J��J� ��#A��� � ��� ��� @���"�

���A�" ��� I/ � �Q�� ��/�,,� ")����D$�V��h .( ;"� 1 ;"�. �)����" ��#A���%'�� �'���C�/��"�W%'��� ��< �$�� k�*�" ���" �� ��"�����: %& @��,� ��l4�'

���� ��NY$� =���1 �,)@�J#�e�V�o��1��� �j�[ssh .(#A��� ��N����" ��N��)"%'�� ���$ � ��< ��#A��� @�'�$� �����6 � ��� @�A�'�#A���"����C�/ I/ � �@���

�"�,,� .$� Y����� �� =4 �?'�NA � ;� 2���)N����" I#5�1 �Q�� ��/ ��� ��'�.�" ��� U#2�C1���� F��1 �1 �,,��� ;"�� �� U#2�C1 � �,�?a �� G c" ���A N�,, .� $

���� ��/ �� �Y$� ��� �?'��AN� %.�� �� ���N$ �J��CN�'�� ��) "��,�3D� V`mj.(

2- Recitation- Presentation 4- Johnson, Johnson and Beth Stanne 6- Vezutto

1- Cooperative instruction 3- Slavin 5- Kagan

Page 229: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

229

������" �3� ���A �� ��" �,Q �1 �)a/ �,Q �R�� " ���A ���?" � �,'�"��/�K�� � ���" �)<�"� �?'���C�/ @��J�� � �,'��) �1 ��.�,,� �.���?" ����� �,1���� �/ :X�A

@��J�� ���x' � �:�1 � �#a" ��!#*�1 �9��� �>� � @���) "����D$�V��h ��J' i#' �@�52��4 � Y$��� � �#,�V�V��o .(X�� � �)����" ��#A��� X�� �� ���a)$� �5���"��/

� �'��,&$ �#x' ��),$ X��"� ...u�� �� ���a)$� �����"�� ��/�" @��' �/� ��jVY#���" � ��),$ X�� � �5���" �� ��)����" ��#A��� X�� �� ���a)$� ����" �� �7��

�)��� Y$� �?:�1 @���. �� ��'�[m���� ���a1 �����" �� �7�� X�� �� �# ��@��' ���" �� �?,1 � ��' ��/��" �� �),$ X�� Y#���" ��,/�)@��/.(

���" ��#A��� ���" ���)��� � $�1 �1��a)" ��/��C��� ��)��'� .���D$�)V��V (�� ���� @��'h�)��A ���3 ���a)$� ���" �)����" ��#A��� �� � 7� X�� �� �'�

�� �,1���� :���A%'�� ��#1 Y���#4 ��/ ��#A��� X�� ���#1 ���5" � Y�3� �@���"�#a 1 X��J' � Y9��3 �I#1 �� �)��A ���� �� ����a'��)����" �� .X�� @�#" �� ��/

���A X�� �H��� ���#1 Y���#4 ��/���)5A ��� �#|t1 � �)��A ���3 �$�� ���" ��1Y$� ��#$� ���|� � � #+!1 Y���#4 � �?'� Y��" .X�� G w� ��#A��� ��/

��#1 Y���#4 >�" �#x' ��)����")����D$�V��s �V��h(���A Fi )5" ���/h�� ��a' '��%���'��1 �� �� Y$� �'���"��,)5/ �����<� �1��a)" ��/ .%/�K4 �<� �� �#x' �/

��i'��[)V�oe(���)'�� �`@��J�� �)V��s (��#/�" �h)V��V (���A �� ��a' �� ��/�" ���a)$� ��.)����D$�V��h (X�� �<� ���/�� �#x' �/e)V�oj(� @�5'�: �

@�5'�:j)V�o�(@�J#� �m)V�o�(@���. � @���. �o)V��[ (���A �� i#'����'� � ���/��/ �" ���a)$� ���a)" ��.)�@�52��4 � Y$��� � �#,� ��J'V��o �@��J�� � @�5'�: �

[sss.(

2- Dansereau 4- Maheady 6- Johnson and Johnson 8- Sharan and Sharan

1- Faust and Paulson 3- Fantuzzo 5- Cohen 7- Kagan

Page 230: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

230

Y���1 �����):� �.� ��/��A �# b��� � ����� ���#|t1 ��)����" ��#A����i�%'�� ������< � =a'%'�� ;���1 ���? �@���"���1�� ��$��" � @���"��

�$DC�/ ��/��(,/%'�� b 51 -�56� ��)? � #+!1 ��C �� Y?: �� �/ � @���"���" ��$��" �� %��< Y.�'�$X��� � �:�1 � �)$����' � Y�� ��R�$ F��" ��/

�" ��: � ���lA )����D$�V��V .(@�C$� � @�5 ' �@�5'�: ��"�����" �@�5'�:V

)V�oV �����" �� ;�' � �V��s (%/�K4 ;# !1��� �� ��)����" ��#A��� � y��" ��/ ���. ���" ���#�!1 �# �� �� �'��� @��'VsoA��� �� �� ���" ���a)$� �)����" ��#

Y$� ��. �(," �1R� � #+!1 Y���#4 � �� ��. .�]#)$� � iJ,#2�)$�[)V�oj � �@��/ �� ;�' (�� �� �'��� @��'o�� ���" �@�"�� �� �� ����" ���a)$� �$D� ��/

��� >�),� ���A �� �)�# ��)����" ��#A��� ���A � #+!1 Y���#4 ��C �� ��� ��.� i#' �� =a' �i� � �$��" � Y�5' X�J' ��)$�� ����K' b��� �,#"� �� ���A ��

�� �)? ���A ���A.

Y$� �).����� �)��" ���#|t1 i#' �3D<� �.� �� 2�c" �� �)����" ��#A��� .i)����)V�os(i�#A � i)���� �)V�o` (�2���1 ��J)aA �� �'��� @��'`���� �# �

��)? �@R�5�/ ���A%#4 ��,#Y$� �3D<� ����3 � 6�" �##{1 ��,,� .�� �"�x' �?'�Vo >���1 )�Q��]C� �#x'�5���" � %�R�4 ����1 ����$ (��,: �� �'��� �6��� �� ���/

@��)aAh���� �# @��)aA �� �'��� @��' � �,)5/ ����1�� ����A �/)@R�5�/ (���# �#|t1 �-D� -��" ��/��)aA � �5���"%'�� �3D<� >�!1 � 6�" �##{1 � ��)@���:

���� S2�� .�! >D< �� �� �'���(�'�� ��'�� ��#$�' �3D<� >�!1 � �3D<� ��/>R�)$� ��'�# ���C1 ;#�3 �� ���/��)���" F�('� ��,��A ��/ ���' �� �C,�� �� �'���

�1� �: ���Ae�" �#A�� �C' ���'�,. ��'�# @� �� �� �'�. �� ��,��A �x'���" ���' �1���/�.�)��� ��1�� ��3D<� >�!1 �x' �� �� �'���(�'�� �"��� ��'�� �1 ��J)aA

2- Stallings and Stipek 4- Discourse

1- Johnson, Maroyama, Johnson, Nelson & Skon 3- Transactive 5- Collective monologue

Page 231: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

231

�" ���a)$� �1�# ����'��)��Q�'V�om :�V���,1�T � �#,/ ����� � �#,� ��J' i#' �V�[sss .(%/�K4� ��/ i)���� b$�1 ��"� ;��)V�os �V�oe(@���C�/ � i)���� �

)V�os(�J,#$� �i�#A �[�2�� �`)V��[ (�" @��' ��'�# %�' � @R�5�/ �#|t1 �� �/�� ��. �#2�11�� �� ��! ���A ����� � #$��������� ���$ �3D<� >R�)$� �c$

��� � � �D �� Y$� �i#Q @� �� %#)V�me (���� I#$�1 @R�5�/ %�' � �'�Y$� I " %�' �� �)�# ��#5) .��,#2 � �#,� ��J'[ssj .(� �x," ��� ���" �x' �$�

����� � �)�# �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �! �J)aA � �)����" ��#A��� ��/ �# X�)5A ��)����" ��#A��� �Q��Q �� �3D<� >R�)$� � ���� � G$�,1 @R�5�/

�" ��#4 ��)�#�,�.

��A��� �$���)����" ��#A��� ���6 �� ��. F�('� ���#�!1 � ��x' ��/WB�: ���" i#' ��#3D<�Y$� H�� ��, .��� � i)����h)[ss`(�" ���.� ��� �,,�

�)����" ��#A���%," �.� �e���?" � �3D<� %'�� ����):� ��/ �#|t1 �@���"����?" ���? � �)����" ��#A��� � ���� ����� ���C�/ � ��*�� 1 ;+� � ;6 ��/

�" �(," �)�#��. .�1���)[ssh(;#?51 ��� ��|�" X�� �� �)����" ��#A��� ����?" ����1 � �.�� "�: ��/�,54j�&" ���x' ��� �.� ��,���� �� Y����" � U2

�" @�A�'�#A��� k��):� � -�� -D� ;���1�'�� .Y,5,��m)[ss` (�� Y$� ��) " i#'�" ���? �� ���< � "�: � ����):� ��)�� ��)����" ��#A��� ����� �# �'�#4 � ��&

�" Y���1 �� � "�:�,� .��2�/ � @�5'�: �@�5'�:o)[ssm (�� �,)5/ ��� ��� �1%'�� @��� �,.� ��$��" � 7� g�/ � Y$� @�. ����):� ���' ��3D<� Y#� @���"�

X��� �X�J' ��/%�' ��/X�� � �/����'�< ��)�" �:� �� Y$� @�?: ����� ��/ ��/�" �,/�� � � "�: �k��):��.� .� 7� ��x," ��� ���#� 1 �@�. ����):� ��,: ���1�

)Y#��1 (X���D<� %," � �/3N$��" � Y$� �N" �A� �N�Y#�1 ���6 �� �/��<�3D<�

2- Basinger 4- Bier 6- Prosocial 8- Holubec

1- Walker, Hennig & Krettenaver 3- Fuller 5- Character 7- Vincent 9- Inculcation

Page 232: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

232

��� I/��� �c���. � �,� ��+1 �3D<� k��):� �2i," � �� ��< ��� ��.� �|�" �� �%'���)�3��" � Y��" b��� @���"�V)�'R�p5" (I/ ��$D� ���3� ��< @�� " � �/

Y$� �)����" ��#A��� ��#A��C Fi )5" �� ��� B��3 �#|t1 � �,,� .

�" @��' ��/�K4 �/��.Y# 3�" �� �@��J�� � Y��" b��� �� �/� ��#A��� ��/�" � $�1 �)? �)����" ��� �� � �������A ��'��$ ��A�x' �� �3D<� @�. ����):� ��[

b#!" ���" ��� �)�# �)����" ��#A��� ��/�/� .Fi )5" ��3D<� ����3 ¢��1����A��� � �:�1 ��)<�,. � �3D<� >R�)$� �1R� u�c$ �� ���a)$� � � @��J�� ��/

��A��� ��� � @�� �� � @�'� ��A�x' @���� �56U2�&" ��/Y$� .b���. ���" � $�1 �)�# H�� ;"�� �$ �/ ��)����" ��#A����,�� .@�5'�:)V�oV �� ;�' � �

��Q�'V�om:�s(Y#���" �3D<� �! �� ��#�� %#4 �� �x' ��� �-D� �� �i#"���/ " ��� �$��N�/ ��/��)<�$ �� �� �/�N�)����" g�`��$ �#1����"� ���� ��

�"�'� .K4 �/��.�" Y���6 @�5'�: ����" ��� �� ����� ��/��,� .

�a2z" � ����� �#|t1 �)����" ��#A��� �� Y$� @� �� ���6 �,#�#4 �$�� ��/�#x' �3D<� �.� Y#6D7 �.����?" �%," ��/���?" � ��� 1 B�� ��/ ��/

%'�� ����):� ���� @���"�)���� � i)����[ss` �[sse .( Y,5,�� �x' ��)[ss`(�%'�� ��#)<� �� �)7�� �)����" ��#A����" ���3 @���"� G3��" �� �'�#J ��� �1 �/�

�,.� ���A ����� ���$ ��/��#' � ��$�56� .@�5'�: � @�5'�:)[ss� (��/��.���� ������A�" @��' �� �'� �� �)�3� ��#A��� � �5���" �� �)����" ��#A��� �/�

# ��#5 �#|t1 �������A��� �)��A �x' �� � �3D<� >R�)$� � ��)� ��J�� ��/�'��� .�" ��#4 ��)�# �.� �3D<� >R�)$� ��)����" ��#A��� b���. �� ����'� � �,�

� ��� ��|��m/s��`/s�)����" ��#A��� �5���" ��� G#1�1 � W��#A��� � ���� �)����"WY$� ��"� Y$� � �)�3� ��#A��� )�`mV .( �J�� �C� ��� �<�. ���g� " ����A��� �)��A �x' �� �, � �3D<� �.� ��/ � Y$� ��� ���J�� ��/jh/s�

2- Constructivism 1- Caring 3- Cooperative goal Structure

Page 233: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

233

jV/sY#2� � �� Y��. �� �, " ��� � ��� %# G1��" � �)����" ��#A��� ��/� � �� Y��.Y#2 ��A��� �)��A �x' �� ��� ��� Y#��� ��)�3� � ���� ��#A��� ��/

�" %��i�� �� @��J���/� .��#� ���A� ��,���� �x' ��W�� @�� �'�́� �,���� V)[sVV(��" ��&1� �� �3D<� �2�5" ;6 ��C��� ��)����" ��#A��� �� �'�)$�� b��� �c$ � �,�

i�� �� �3D<� ����*�" ��#A����" %���/� .@��J�� � U $)V��o (�! �#|t1���A ����"�Q�� ��/[�'��� �$�� �C.i4 @���(�'�� �3D<� �.� � �� .�?'�

�3D<� >R�)$�m[� >�$ �� �� �2�� � 2�c" �� �C.i4 ��(�'�� V��V �1 V��o ���A �� �3D<� �! �� Y��. �� =4 � %#4 �� �Y��� �"��� ���" �� �Q�� ��/

��" � �� �'���(�'�� �'��� @��' � �'��T �$�� �C.i4 ;��5"[s�)�# �� Y��$ �?'� �3D<� >R�)$� �� ��'�� ���� Y��. ��3D<� ;��5" ���" �� �! ���A ��

�, " %��i���� ��"� ��:� � ����.

%/�K4 �� � �/��A �! X�� �� �)����" ��#A��� X�� ������ ��� )" ��/$ X��Y$� ��. �5���" �'��,&`.�" �"� @� �� �� ��/�K4 �#/ @�,��1 YaA @��1

X�� ������ >R�)$� ���6 �� �'��,&$ � �)����" ��#A��� ��/��A �! ��/� � Y$� ���' ��/��" �� �)��J' ���7 ��,.� ��. �5���" �3D<��" �x' �� �$�

%/�K4.� �� H�� X�� �$ ������ �5���" �� �3 ��/%'�� �3D<� ����3 �@���"�Y$� ����' �x' �" .5" ������,tX�� �$ �# �� �� Y$� ��� %/�K4 ��� �$�$� �2

���A �� �! ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �! � �)����" ��#. � �Q�� ��/��1�� G�$ �� F��� ��'��,&$�����3 � 6�" �##{1 � @���"� %'�� �3D<� >R�)$�

�3D<�@��" �/ ���.

2- Small group case study discussion 1- Kowino, Agak, Obiero- Owino & Ongunya `N�" >��" @��,� � �#2�� � ��#�)V�me �U#$ �� ;�' � �V`m�:`�j (� �:�1� �� �/��A �! X�� � �'��,&$ X��

�D"����'� �� 3�� ���D�� @�"�� ��/� ������� ��/����'� � R� �c$ �Ca1 @��' � �'��� �5���" I/� Xi#J'� � X�J' ��/'���N�� �� �[V" � �� �5���" N�� �'��,&$ X�� ��. F�('� � 3�� ���D�� @�"�� �DV[��� �/��A �! X�� �� �)? ���" ��h�� � �'�� I/ ;�" X�� �� ��� ���" e&$ X�� �� �)? �/��A �! X�� ���" �� �'��, .��m������� �D" � �� �5���"

�� � �� �'��,&$ -�� �� �)? ����" F��1 �� �/��A �! X�� ��. F�('� R� �c$ �Ca1 ��� X�J' �D" � �� �5���" �� �/��A �! X�� ��. F�('� Xi#J'�m� � �'�� I/ ;�" X�� �� ��� ���" �� �� ��� �'��,&$ X�� �� �)? ���" ���" �� �

�� �)? �'��,&$ X��.

Page 234: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

234

B��

g�/ � �:�1 � �%/�K4 ��� �� ���a)$� ���" Z#�!1 X�� k�*�" Y#/�" � �/%#4 ����"�� u�� ����a)$� ���" u�� � ��(1 X�� �%/�K4@�"��W=4� @�"��

���A ���AVY$� .Y#�1 X�� �$ �#|t1 �5���" �4 �� %/�K4 ��� �C,�� � �:�1 �D<�%'�� �3D<� ����3 >�!1 � �3 ���a)$� H�� u�� �� �7�< ;C. �� ��� @���"�

�,).�� ��:� ���A �$ @� �� �� �. :���A ���A � ����"�� ���A �U2� ����"�� ���A .;C. �� u�� ��� �����'VY$� ��. ���� @��' :

212121

TzTRTyTRTXTR

1S,)�(�*��� 3��� �����)� }#b ��3�%� �� ��� �3 43

���A �� �'��� Y����� �� ;�)5" �#{)" �� �7�< u�c$ � � U2� ����"�� ��/�'�� ���a)" I/ � ��)#/�" :��/�� " ����� �/��A �! X�� �� " �� U2� ���A

���A �� �J)aA X�� �� " �� ���A � Y��A ���3 �3D<� ��#. � �Q�� ��/D<� ��/�� " ����� �)����"Y��A ���3 �3 .>�� " X�� �� " �� i#' ���A ���A

�c$�)" -���" �� �3D<� ����*�" =���1)�'��,&$ (Y��A ���3.

��3��)��

%'�� ��/ �� Y$� ����� %/�K4 � "�: ��x' �<�. @�)$�#� F�� ���4 �)<� @���"� ��c," �)2�� �'���� -���" �� ��Vo;#+!1 � @��?1 �?. X���4 � X��"� >�{).�

�,).�� .%'�� ;� ��� 1 � X��"� ����� �� ��. Y����� ��"� � �:�1 � ���l" @���"� ���c," X���4Vjs� G2�3 �� �� �'�� �a' Vh� @�)$�#� hV@�"��$ -�� -D�

�'�� �)��� .��� ��#' ���" ���"� �'��' '�N%/�K4 ��� F�(1 � NX�� � �:� y��" ��/

1- Pretest- Posttest, with Control group

Page 235: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

235

�. �&)'� ����"�� �� 2�c" ��� �'��' I(6 ��$�!" � .�� 2�c" �� �'��' I(6�" ���3 ;"�� ��?Q �#|t1 Y!1 ����"����#A :U2�W�, " �c$ ����)�a2�( �W='�����

� "�:)2δ(0 �W@�"�� @��1 )�) ��?," ��β−1(� �W�# ���a1 �� �'�i#" 1M�2M�,� U�� �� @� Y$� ;��" Z�!" �� .� "�: ��# " g��!'� � �A� ���a1 ���

���. I#5�1����' � #$�d�" ���� %���' �" ��#"�' �|� I(6 � ��.��. :

δ

|| oMMd

−=

%/�K4 �� �'��' I(6 ��$�!" ����, " �c$ ��� ��)� �����"�� ��/ ����)a(�@�"�� @��1)β−1(��� ��#)<� �� .I(6 ��$�!" � ��x' ���" �|� I(6 ���7 ��� ��

;"�� �|��'��' I(6 � �)��A ���3 �:�1 ���" �/�" �## 1 G$�," ���. .���$ ��� �1a)$�>��: �� ����/�� � #$� � ��. ����1 ��/V)V�oj � @�A��� ��"�$ �� ;�' � �

����(6V`m�:V�s (Y$� .�, " �c$ ��*�6 Z#�!1 �� ����)a(� ���se/s�x' �� �. �)��A) :se/s=a.(�## 1 ��� �C,�� � �:�1 � �J�� g�� ���:� �7�< ������3

���' @��x,�6�7 ��/���,/� � �:�1 � ��)�@�52�#. �#x'V�oo �%,"�#� ��:�1 �V`o[(@� ����" �[s/s�)�� �� �)os/sβ≥WV(�#&�1 @�C"� �1 �. �)��A �x' ��

��. �#��1 �.� �).�� ��:� �� 3�� �� �1��7 �� ����a1 .@���!" �J�� ��$ �� �CQ�� � ��|� I(6 � �'�� �,�3D�hs/s�4���� Z�� ���7 ��� �� ��'�� ��/

�/�� >��:)�@��J�� � �"�$ � �#,� ��J'V`m�:V�s �`me (�'��' I(6 � �� >�� "[`�����(" � ���A �/ ��� �a' j���� � � �� ��#' ���A �$ �/ ��� �a'

�" G#1�1 � ��� @�"�� @��1 � @��1oj/sY��� Y$� .

�'��' �&)'� ��x," ��.�< X�� �� %/�K4 ��� ��#' ���" ���"� ��. ���a)$� ��Y$� u�. ��� � ����� �'��' ;6��" :k��(" ����� ��x' �<�. @�)$�#� )�����

�'�� �c$�)" F�� ���4 -D� �$ ;3��6 (�. �&)'� �@�)$�#� �� ���3 �#3 � .��J'�

1- Cohen

Page 236: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

236

����A @�� �)�/ Y���� ��x,"�/>�� " � Y�5' �� 2�c" ���" ��/�)"���4 �x' �� %'�� @������A @���"��. F��3� �/ .X�����A @��� >�� " ��� �a )&" ��/ ��:� �/

�. �&)'� ����+1 ���lA�� X�� �?'� �# �� �� ����)��"�/V`mo .( �C,�� � �:�1 ��'��"�� �����+1 ���lA�� X�� ��� �/� ����+1 �'�A���A ���A � ����"�� ��/

�" ��lA��� i#' ����"�� ;�� � �'�.���A � ����+1 ����" ��+)<� �/ ��� ����X�� ���$ � Y�5' ��)�# Y�i" X�����A @��� >�� " ��/���� �/ .���lA�� ���

%'�� ����+1���A � @���"�%'�� ��/-D� @���"�� �� ���/ �&)'� ����+1 ���.� ��'�� ������. ����+1 ��� �� �����+1 ����� >��: �� ���a)$� � � �'�. ���lA

�'��"�� F�$ U2� ����"�� ���A � F�$ �� ����A ���A � �/)�/��A �! (�� � ����"�� ���A � �J�� F�$)���A �� �J)aA�Q�� ��/ (�'�. ��lA��.

9�G8b� ����3#( ����U��

;� ��#&$ ���)�1��:%'�� �3D<� ����3 %(,$ ��x," � �� @���"� U�� 1 @�"��;��5")DIT (�. ���a)$� .����3 >�!1 �,#"� �� Y$� ���#�!1 ;7�6 @�"�� ���

Y$� �3D<�)�Y$�V�m` �V�m� �@��J�� � iJ,#"�� �[sVs .(DIT�,�iA�,Q �'�"�� ���� G��" �j�/� �� � Y$�� " V�ms��" ���)5A ��� ��� 1 � �)��A ���3 ���a)$� ��

%/�K4 � µ2� � ��. F�('� ��i� ��� �� ���a)$� � �� ���/Vsss �/�7 � Y$� %/�K4 �� %# �� �'��"�� ��i/hs��. ��#(,$ @� � @�?: ���� ���6 �2�$ �/ � �'�Ves

�" F�('� @� �� ���a)$� � %/�K4 ��.)�Y$�V��h�� � iJ,#"�� �� ;�' � ��@��J[sVs .(�" �)$��< �'��"�� �� @�"�� ��� �� � � �'��& �� �/�� " �� F��� �/ ��.

=]$ � ��/� r$�4 �#< �� � ;C. � �@�)$�� � 7� @�"�?3 %,��� ���" �� �2��$ �� �� �/ Y#�/�V[I#�+1 �� �� �2��$ �" ���3 �:�1 ���" �2�5" ;6 � ��#A �� ��#A

���7 �"�D7� "�1"���� ��#5 "�,� ��, �:�� .;6��" �>��$ �/ � y��" �D�:�" ��� " �� �3D<� ����3 >�!1 U )&"�,,� .>��$ ��, ��1� �J'�JQ �����, �/

�" ��'��"�� � #$� ���a)$� ���" �3D<� >�!1 �2��1 �� ��� ��J��: �## 1 ��� �'��1 ��#A ���3)�@��J�� � � �DC$�V�oe � Y$� �@��J��V��� .( ��� " �/ @���4 ��

Page 237: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

237

I?" �� ���" ��?Q ��� �'��"���:�� ����" ���1��1� �� ��. ��,����' ��, .�� �� �/�&)'� ����" @�# �� �'��"�� >R�)$� ��!' ��/�,� .��" �x' k��(" �� �$�hs

�.� ���� @�"�� � ���J&$�4 ��� Y3� ��#3� .DITa)" ���' ���,Q Y$� � ����"g�� " �� �/� �J'��' ��?'� ���1P)�2�7� ���'(V�3D<� >R�)$� g� " � Y$�

�������3���[)�2�7� (Y$� .���'P�1 �a7 �� Y$� �+<�. ��e�7�� �2i," � �>R�)$��" �#5a1 ���/ Y#�/� @�i#" �����, � �,)5/ �������3 ��� �c$ �� �� ��.

����3 ��� ��x6D" � 6�" ���e��jI#�+1 �� �'��"�� �x' �� �3D<� �.� ��#A�" =C ," �� �3D<� ��/�� " @�"��#4 �,�)�@��J�� � Y$�V��� �@��J�� � iJ,#"�� �

[sVs .( Y$�)V�oj (�7�� ���'P>�� " es�2�7� HD<� �c$ g� " �� �)�# �� )���� =4 (�"�'�� .�'�p2 � �4�� �-�1��4R�`)[ssj (�, " ���##{1 ���' �� ���P��

�" �3D<� ����3 �.� �'��' �,'��)�Y$� � �#,� ��J' i#'V��m.(

%/�K4�<�. ����� ��� )" ��/@��� ��/ �(,$DITY$� ��. F�('� .� Y$� @��J��)V��� (���� @��' ����� �� �'�DITY$� �,)�" ��� u�. � �D" Ya/ � :

��A �# ���lA i���1����A � �,$ ��/Y���#4 �U )&" �.��"� ��/ �c�� ��2�� ��/-�#�" ����'��1 %(,$ ��/ �c�� ��3D<� Y#�1 �D<��" � Y#$�56 ��)<�,. ��/

� "�: ��)�� ��,54hI#�+1 ����6 � c" ��#AX�J' � �c�� ����&)'� ��/ ��/�����4 � �$�#$ .�����)V�m� ����� �� ;�' � �V`me(>R�)$� �# �� ��� @��' �

�� ;7�6 ����' � ����� � �"D� >R�)$� ����i)'�DIT���� ��:� �c�� .Y$�)V��h �@��J�� � iJ,#"�� �� ;�' � �[sVs(�����4 �<�. �DIT �� ���a)$� � ��

@�"�� �J)5��/W�6�� ��'��� �'�5�/ � @�"���� os/s���� X��iA Y$� .�5������ �i,#e)V�mo' � �N������ �� ;�V`me ('��� @��'N� �� �N@�"�� �, F�DIT ����� �

Y$� �'��� �'�5�/ .�� �����4 G���* �,"��mV/s�1o[/s"N �#{)N��.�5����)V�om�

2- Prosocial 4- Post Conventional

1- P- Score (Prinicipled Score) 3- Dellaportas, Cooper and Leung 5- Davison and Robins

Page 238: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

238

������ �� ;�' �V`me (���' �����4 �� ��� @��' �2�7� HD<� ��/DIT Z��� �� �� �1R� ����"���� X��ms/sY$� .�����)V�m� (@�"�� Z��� ��W@�"���� DIT � �

�����4 G��*o`/s�'��� �'�5�/ �o[/sY��� Y$� .

�<�.@��� ��/ �(,$DIT��. ��)," �$��� @�� � �� �1� 2�c" �� i#' �'�Y$� ��. X��iA .�����)V`me (@�"�� ���' �c�� �$�� Z��� ��DIT @�"�� �

@�"�� Z��� �� @� �����4 G��* � Y$��� @�"�� �� ��� @��' �£�#4 ���i)'� �Ca1W���(" @�"��o`/s� ��� @� �'��� �'�5�/ �o[/sY$� .�����)V`m` (G���*

���"���� �J)5��/DIT ;6��" �� �� e�h�`�[� ��� G#1�1 � om/s�j`/s�m[/s�m[/s���� X��iA Y$� .@�# # :)V`m[ (���A ���,Q ��C �� �# �� ��� @��' i#'

� {.)@�)$�4�$ � @����" �@��A��� (� r$�4 ��DIT�, " ���a1 ����� ��:� ���� .��%/�K4 �����4 G��* i#' �*�6DIT � ��� �'��� �'�5�/ Z��� �� oj/sY$� �

Y$� ��$�," �<�. �� �"� .@�"�� �)�2�DIT �)��A ���3 ���/���)'� �� " �� i#' Y5#' I/��� >�(" ��� �� �?'� @�# Y7�� �� Y$�)� Y$� � �#,� ��J' ���" ���

�@��J��V��m ��,#2 �V��e.(

�3#( ����U��1� &$ ��#"+�� �� ]��#� 9�G8b� ���4 ��':;�� 1 ��/�#{)" �� ��,,�%'�� � #+!1 Y���#4 � �?�.�/ ������1 �$ �� �,1���� u�� ���@���"� .������A ���

%'�� � #+!1 ��'��4 ��:��," �� ���a)$� � ������1 �$ ���" �� ���D�� �@���"�)$� �?'� �2�1 r���1N���1 �� � 0��& � 2�c" ���:� r)%#4 ���:�@�"�� (��� � �. �5�

�. ��$�!" �����1 �$ G#1�1 .%'�� X�/ %(,$ ��x," � �� �� 2�c" ���" @���"�=��1�" @�"���" ��:� �/��A ���7 � �� @��� ��'���#4 ��/�. ���a)$� ��. .���

� �� ���a)$� � �� #+!1 Y���#4 �#{)" ����� ���D�� ������A%'�� � #+!1 �"�'����"� Y��A ���3 ;�� �D" � ��$�!" ����' >� " �;�3 � #+!1 >�$ F�� � >�� Y�' ��.

w"2K$ ��#P� ��� ����+1 ���lA�� �� =4 %'��@���"� � �$ ����A %#4@�"�� ;��5" U�� 1)DIT (���

Page 239: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

239

�'��"�� �3D<� ����3 %(,$�'��"�� �?�.�/ i#' ��. ��:� �/� �/ @�"�� � #$� =��1�"�. ��#(,$ @��� ��'���#4 ��/ .�$ � � #+!1 Y���#4 � y��" ���D��

����A 0��&)$� �?'� � #+!1 ��'��4 ��:��," �� i#' �����1.

����� � ���$ � @� @��#� �# �� �� ����A �$ @�� " �X��"� ���:� �� %#4 �2�� �D#+!1)�.�� �$�,.��� �6 �� (�&)'� � �� �.��"� ��A��� �� ��'�� ��.

��� �$ ��")VoY��$ (�'��� Y��. ��. ;#C�1 .��" � ���A �$ =]$V[�5 : e/V�)��$ *�,)��A ���3 ��� u�. � =���1 U )&" X�� �$ �� " ��.

�. ��:� �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �! X�� �U2� ����"�� ���A �� .��)�' �'��" � �:�1�%/�K4 � ��x Y���/ � ��:� ;� 2���)$� �#�#4 ��/ ����� �!

Z#�� ��J�$�4 � �#2�� ��J�$�4 ���/�� �� ;"�. ��3D<� ��/�� " ����1 =]$ ��.�AK�� � �:�1�X��� k�' � �J,/�� ��/ �,#�#4 � ��J' � � ��! ���" �3D<� ��/

���#�!1�%'�� �'��) �� G$�," �3D<� ��/�� " ��#A�� �3D<� ��� 1 �� �� @���"�. �#?1 ��,� .

%/�K4 -�$�� � ����"�� ���A �� �� �J)aA Y���/ � ��:� ;� 2���)$� �#�#4 ��/���A�. ����1 �)����" ��#. � �Q�� ��/ .%'�� =]$ �����"�� ���A ��� @���"�

���A >�" Z��%'�� ��#1 Y���#4 ��/@���"�V)����D$� V��h �V�om (%. � ���Ah���A �� � ��a' `�'�. I#5�1 ��a' .

;��5" U�� 1 @�"�� =4 ����A �$ �� X��"� @���: F��1� �� =4)DIT(��� �� ��. ��:� ���A �$ �/ ��� �.��"� ���� F��1� �� =4 .���� =]$��A ��/ ��. ����

�'�. ;# !1 � �'���Ai"�.

������

�)��� %& �� �� %/�K4 ��/�" �9�����. :U2�W�)��� 3 � y��" ��/N�3D<� ����

1- Student Teams-Achievement Divisions (STAD)

Page 240: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

240

�W�)��� �3D<� >�!1 � 6�" � y��" ��/ .�)��� �"��� �� �x' �� U2� %& ��/�"�'�lA :� 7� >��$ � r$�4 ��x," � �%/�K4 )����� �/��A �! X�� �$ �# ��

A ��3D<� ��/�� "N���A �� �J)a �� F��� ��'��,&$ � �)����" X�� � �Q�� ��/G�$ ��1�������3 �c$ %'�� �3D<�@���"� �"����A(��C �� %'��@���"� �$���A

%#4 Y# 3�" �� ��=4 � @�"��@�"�� ����(" �� ���a)$� � �3D<� ����3 @�"�� ��/F�' �)5 ���"� ���i��SPSS @�"�� ;"�. t� ��� ���l(" @�"�� �='����� ;# !1 �

@�5��� ;�� @�"��)���J ,$ � n�� �=��[ssh� � ��:�1 �����7 � ����V`oo(�. �5���" �.>��: ��e�+&�" ����A �� �3D<� ����3 ����' ���"� ��/

%#4 Y# 3�" �� ���A ���A � ����"��=4 � @�"�� @�"�� S��)' � @�"��t�5���" ������A �3D<� ����3 ���##{1%#4 �� �/=4 � Y�5' @�"��Y$� ��. ��� @�"�� .�

%'�� �3D<� ����3 ���' �## 1 ��x," ���' �� �@���"�P@�"�� DIT �� �. ���a)$� �� ��"� @�#" � @� ��� �D�3.

7� P)�(���)� x���� t9��e/ �3 4 , 3���� 9�#""+$ �;��2� ��#� ��3 �/8�� �� ��)���" �� !6;� ���)� W �3 4�#(���)�

4�#(��/8�� 9��e/ #"+���":��"��":��"�1_�*$�t�P�3�3�)���&����3%#4@�"�� [[/[� �'��,&$ =4@�"�� jo/[m

ee/VjV`/s[m ehe/s

%#4@�"�� sh/[o�/��A �!

=4"��@�hj/`[h[/hWVoo/[W[[ shs/s

%#4@�"�� ee/[h ���A �� �J)aA ��/�)����" X�� � �Q��=4@�"�� [V/`V

jm/jWjos/`W[e ssV/s

���� >��: ��/V�" @��' =4 ���##{1 �/�%#4 � Y�5' @�"�� ��� @�"�� ���A�, " �'��,&$���A �� �� �"� �Y5#' �����A �� �J)aA � �/��A �! ����"�� ���/

Y$� ����, " �Q�� .%'�� ����' �#J'�#" �'��,&$ ���A ��=4 �� @���"� @�"���)��� %/�� �3D<� ����3���A �� �J)aA � �/��A �! ���A �� �� �"� �'���Q�� ��/

%'�� ���' �#J'�#" %��i�� �/�.=4 �� �3D<� ����3 �� @���"�I#)5/ @�"�� .�)C'

Page 241: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

241

G2�:X�� �� Y$� ��� �1���A �� �J)aA ��/��A �! X�� � �5���" �� �Q�� ��/%'�� �3D<� ����3 �.� � ��)�# ���#|t1���a1 � Y$� �).�� @���"� ��)�# ��/

=4 ���' ��%#4 � Y�5' ��3D<� ����3 @�"��Y$� ���� ��(�� @�"��.

$�� ��x," �N' �� ���A �$ �# ���a1 �N' ;*�a1 �xND<� ����3 ��� �� �3%#4=4 � @�"�� @�"��)���'P@�"�� DIT(�� ='����� ;# !1 @�"�� �� ��/��

>��: �� @� S��)' �� �. ���a)$�[Y$� ��. �9���.7� P)0(" 1_�*$ ��K< )� 4�#( �� �;��2� W������ 1"�K$ ��"��W � ���)� ���)�

�/8�� 9��e/ W������ q6��9������ ��%���3�)� �P�3 9������ �":��"� F��&����3

���A �#�/���A @����/

;�

��j/�mh Vo�/�sVV Voe/��oj

[mh mj

h�o/hom mm`/V[V

ss`/h*s[[/s

*cN/cP<

���� >��: ��/[�" @��' ����3 ���' ;*�a1 �x' �� ���A �$ �# �� �/��3D<� %#4 ��=4 � @�"������ ��:� ���a1 @�"�� .� �:�1� �='����� ;# !1 S��)'

���A �� ���" �� ;3��6 �# ���a1%#4 ����' ;*�a1 �x' �� �/@�"��W=4@�"���, " ��3D<� ����3Y$� ��� .�5���" @�"�� �� ���a)$� � �'�A�,Q ��/HSD ���1

)>��:`(�'��,&$ ���A �� �# ���a1 �� ��� @��'W���A �� �J)aA ��Q�� ��/�, "Y$� ��� :)s[V/sP<�`V`/oW=J=I(.�'��,&$ ���A �# ���a1W��/��A �!

�, " �2� Y$� ��:�1 ;�3 �,Q�/Y5#' ��� .7� P)?(���)� HSD" 1_�*$ �3 9��*$ ��K< )� 4�#( �� �;��2� ��#� �'�$ ���)�g

W �/8�� 9��e/ ���)� 4�#(�;��2� �� �":��"� 9��*$��":��"� 3�� ����� ��.����3��&�

�'��,&$ W�/��A �! �j�h/eWVseh/`Vhs/s�'��,&$ W���A �� �J)aA �Q�� ��/ [V`h/oWsseh/`*s[V/s

�/��A �!W���A �� �J)aA �Q�� ��/ [hh`/[WVeoo/`meo/s*cN/cP<

Page 242: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

242

�)��� ����" @��' �/�'��"�� �3D<� ����3 �� ��. ��(�� ���##{1 �� �/� ��/aA ���A ������A �� �J)=4 �� ��Q�� ��/%#4 � Y�5' �@�"�� �� �)�# �@�"��

�, " ���a1 @� � � Y$� �'��,&$ ���A �! � �'��,&$ ���A �� �# i#' ����� ����%'�� �3D<� ����3 �� ��. ��(�� �##{1 �x' �� ��/��A ���A Ba' � ���a1 �@���"�

�, " ���a1 ��� �2� ����� ��:� �/��A �!Y5#' ���.

�%#4 Y# 3�" �� �� ���A �$ �3D<� ����3 ���##{1 �5���" � �$�� ��x," =4 � @�"�� �3D<� ����3 @�"��)���' ;*�a1P%#4 �� @�"��W=4@�"�� (@�"�� ��

@�5��� ;�� ���)"���4�#wV��1� ��� Y"D� ��/Ya: ��. ���lA ��. ��: ��/)F�' �)5 ���i��SPSS (�a)$� �. ��)�;J#$ � �#,� ��J'V�ej ������ ��:�1 �V`m[:

�m .( >��: �� ;# !1 ��� S��)'hY$� ��. �9��� .7� P)I(� ��;'�' 1�� ���)� x���� g� ��#g4#%� o�3 1_�*$ �;��2P" �3 � ���)�

W �/8�� 9��e/ ���)�

4�#(����,�

�6$� E�*�� ��)4#%�" E���)�

)� #$v�� W ���)�(

�6$� E!6j� ��)4#%�W ���)�

)� #$v��" ���)�(

�6$� E���;� ��)" 4#%� ���)�

�� ���;� W ���)�(

W ���)� ��f��

" ���)���&����3

�'����� ohVj[�V/VWV�m/s �'��,&$ [o =n��1� B�:�/eh [hW

�'����� soVemVh/[W*ssm/s �/��A �! [`=n��1� B�:�/s`jW

�'����� sVsVjseV/`W*ss[/s ���A �� �J)aA ��/�Q��[j=n��1� B�:�/seeW

*c�/cP<

���� >��: ��/h�" @��' �� �� �/�[���A ����"�� )���A �� �J)aA � �Q�� ��/�/��A �!(���' �P%'�� �3D<� ����3 =4 �� @���"��@�"��%#4 � Y�5' �@�"��

1- The wilcoxon matched- Pairs Signed Ranks

Page 243: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

243

�, " ���"� �x' �� �� �).�� %��i��Y$� ��� .��1� ��'��,&$ ���A ���" �� �a," ��/)=4 �� ���' %/��%#4 � Y�5' @�"��@�"��(�[��1� ��� � �,)5/ Y��" ��/

=4 ���' ;*�a1%#4 � @�"�� @�"���, " ���"� �x' �� ��3D<� ����3Y5#' ��� .����)���@��' i#' �/���A �� �J)aA � �/��A �! X�� @�� �|�" ��,/� �� ��Q�� ��/

%'�� �3D<� ����3 ���' ¢��1��Y$� �'��,&$ X�� � �5���" �� �@���"�.

W�)��� �3D<� >�!1 � 6�" � y��" ��/ :��3D<� �.� �� � �� �C� � 6�" @�"�� �� ��C �� -�$�� �� Y$� �3D<� ����3DIT ;6��" � Z�c" �j�'�A

�" �## 1 ��� � �3D<� ����3��. .>��: ��e�3D<� ����3 � 6�" �'����� �%'��/ ��� @���"�N���A �� �� �A � ����"�� ��/N%#4 Y# 3�" �� �� ��� � @�"��

=4�� @�"��NY$� ��. �.7� P)N(��3 �/8�� 9��e/ ��a#� �����#� ���)� W !"&/�� �3 4�#( �� �eG ��)���

4�#(���#( dK� 4�#(�3 �:�*(5Q�' �����#�O�

�/8�� 9��e/ 1a�#� �/8�� 9��e/ 1a�#� �/8�� 9��e/ 1a�#� ���,��

�*"o�$ ���� `he`he`he

�'����� VVjjVVmojV�`�7�� `/hj/j�V/[jo/`h/jeo/`sh/[V�/jmm/Vs

���� �$�� >��: ��/e���� � @� ���a1 �>��: ��/[�� Y$� @� �� ���6 �'��"�����A ��� ��/%#4 �� �3D<� >�!1 � 6�" �x' �� �/=4 � @�"�� �@�"��

�'��"�� �� ��)�# �7�� �2� �'��� �1��a)" Y# *�/ �� ����A �$ �/ ��/Y# 3�" �� �%#4=4 � @�"�� �3D<� ����3 F��?Q � 6�" �� ��3D<� >R�)$� �x' �� @�"��

�,)5/ ��� � .>��: ��j�'��"�� �7�� � �'����� �>�!1 � 6�" �x' �� �� ���/=4 �� �3D<��).�� >�i' �� �� 7 �@�"�� %#4 � Y�5' �@�"�� ����3 � 6�" �� �'�

��'�" Y�| �?'� �3D<�Y$� ��. ��� �Y$� .

Page 244: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

244

7� P)M(��3��)� o�3 � �����#� W �3 �/8�� 7�K$ ��a#� #D� )� �' 4�#( �� ��E���)� " �� !6;���,�3 7�U� �� 3�&o E���)� ��

��3��)� �' ��� �/8�� 7v ��� 4 ��� !��@ �f��

!��

��3��)� �' ��� �/8�� 7v ��� ��a#� 5� �f��

U������� �� !��

��3��)� �' � �/8�� 7v �����a#� �3 �f�� ����� ��U��

!��

��3��)� �' ��� �/8�� 7v ��� ��a#� 5� �f��!�� ����� �'

��3��)� �' ��� �/8�� 7v ���

��a#� �3 �f�� ����� �'

!�� 4�#(�

�����#� o�3�����#� o�3 �����#� o�3�����#� o�3 ���#��� o�3 �/��A �! Ve[V/jemh`/`sV`h/hWWW

���A �� �J)aA��/�Q��

Vj e`/jV�j/`hVoh/`WWW

�'��,&$ VjVh/emh[o/VhWWm[eVem/`

���� >��: ��/j�'��"�� �� ��)�# �7�� �� Y$� @� �� ���6 ���A �� ��� ��/���A �� �J)aA � �/��A �! ��Q�� ��/ � 6�" �� �� �� ��3D<� ����3 �x' ��

�).�� �� 7�'� .%'�� �� ��)�# �7�� �J�� g�� �� �x' �� ��'��,&$ ���A ��� @���"��).�� >�i' � 6�" �� �� �� ��3D<� ����3 � 6�"�'� .�$�� �)�# ��/)>��:VV(

��/��A �! ���A �� �� Y$� @� �� ���6`%'�� �� �a' �" �� @���"� � 6`����3 � 6�" � �3D<�h�h� 6�" �� �a' h�e�V� 6�" �� �a' `�e�).�� �� 7 �'� .��

��)����" X�� � �J)aA ���A`%'�� �� �a' � 6�" �� @���"�`�h�j� 6�" �� �a' h�e� 6�" �� �a' �� �`�eY$� �)��� ��1�� .

7� P)>(��3��)� �����#� ��4�#( )� 5�# ��a#� )� �f�� �/8�� 7v ��� �' E�?��I�...!�� 43#' !�#�"

��3��)� 7v ��� �' ��� ��a#� )� �f�� �/8��?��I

!�� 43#' !�#�"

��3��)� 7v ��� �' ��� ��a#� )� �f�� �/8��I��

N!�� 43#' !�#�"

��3��)� 7v ��� �' ��� �f�� �/8�� ��a#� )�?��N

!�� 43#' !�#�" 4�#(�

�'����� �7�� �'����� �7�� �'����� �7�� �/��A �! `V`hh/VmVh/h

���A �� �J)aA�Q�� ��/`e/VVj[`Vo/`�'��,&$ `m/VsVe/`W

Page 245: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

245

�� �3D<� ����3 � 6�" �� ���##{1 �x' �� ���A �$ �# ���a1 �$�� ��x," �%#4 � @�"��=4>��: �� @� S��)' �� ��. ���a)$� ��� ��l(" @�"�� �� �@�"��o

Y$� ��. �9���.7� P)V(��g( �� ��' ����� ���)� ��"g$ #D� )� 4�#g�3 �/8�� 9��e/ ��a#� �3 #""+

W " �� !6;� ���)����)�

�� 2� �3�)� �P�3 ��&� ~.� ��3)��#b �3(@�$�#4 ��� ��l(" )a(joo/Vmos[h/s����' Y$�� Y�5' mh`/[sosso/sb< � b< y��1�� ho�/VsVssV/s

�'��"�� ��� 1�/mm

���� >��: ��/o�" @��' � 6�" �� �##{1 @�i#" �x' �� ���A �$ �# �� �/�%#4 �� �3D<� ����3=4 � @�"�� �, " ���"� �x' �� �� ���� ��:� ���a1 @�"�� ���

Y$� .��� ������1�� �� ����"�� ;�� @�� �|�" �� ���6 �/��3D<� >�!1 � 6�" �'��"�����A ��� ��/���A �� �J)aA � �/��A �! ��/�" �Q�� ��/�.�.

%#4 ���:� �2��)6� I?$ �## 1 ��x," �=4 S��)' �� �3D<� ����3 @�"�� @�"���. ���a)$� ='������ ;# !1 �� .��)� ��x," ��� � ��/�#{)" �# �J)5��/ G��*

�. ��$�!" � 7�)>��:�(.7� P)R(1� &$ ��#"+�� � ��;��� #"+�� �"� ���#" �:�;6% F��#_ 4 ��'

�#"+�� " ���)�

�/8�� 9��e/W ���)�

�/8�� 9��e/#f6,��%��2$ ��

!�#�" ��"�K$

�3D<� ����3 @�"�� %#4 W*[�o/ssVe/ss`V/sVs[/s�3D<� ����3 @�"�� =4 WWsV[/ssse/sVVo/s

�?�.�/ WWWVsh/ss[j/sW�����1 �$ WWWWVVo/sW

� #+!1 Y���#4 WWWWW

>>=nc�/cP<=*a

Page 246: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

246

���� >��: ��/�%/�K4 ��� �)5�� �#{)" �# �� Y$� @� �� ���6 )����3=4 �� �3D<�@�"�� (;�� 1 ��/�#{)" ��,,� �)� #+!1 Y���#4 ������1 �$ ��?�.�/(

�, " �c��;# !1 �� �����, �����' ��:� �������A �5���" ��� �� ���/ �x' �� �/=4 �� �3D<� ����3�" F�('� @�"�� ��/�#{)" ���"� >�),� � ���#' ���. � H��

Y5#' ='������� ;# !1 �� ���a)$� .�C,�� � �:�1� ��J�� ��$ ��%#4 �#@�"��=4 ��, " �J)5��/ ��3D<� ����3 @�"������ ��:� ����)sV/sP< �[�o/s=r(�5���" �

���A=4 �x' �� �/ ����3 @�"�� %#4 ���"� >�),� Fi )5" ��3D<� ����3 @�"��Y$� ='������� ;# !1 X�� �� ���a)$� � �3D<� .����@�2 @�"�� � y��" ��/V���

��a" �$��='����� ���� �* >��: �� �/V`Y$� ��. �9��� .7� P)�c(W������ �#��#� �_�#*� ���#� ��#� ��< ���)� �

4)� �����< 4�����3�)� �P�3��3�)� �P�30��&� ~.� ���3�'��"�� �3D<� >�!1 � 6�"%#4 �� �/@�"��[e`/s[mhmmm/s�'��"�� �3D<� >�!1 � 6�" �� �/=4@�"��[jj/s[mhmjm/s

���� -�$�� �C,�� � �:�1 � >��: ��/Vs�, " �c$ ��3D<� ����3 �����'��"�� �� �)�# �/se/s���� �Y$� �� ='����� ��c< ���� �*��a" �%/�K4 ��/

����' >��$ ��� �� ���A �$ �#�'� .�'��"�� �3D<� ����3 ='������� ;# !1 @�"�� �/ ��%#4=4 � @�"�� >��: �� ����A �$ �/ @�"��VVY$� ��. ���� @��' .

7� P)��(" �3 �/8�� 7�K$ ��a#� #D� )� 4�#( �� �;��2� W�������' 1"�K$ � ���)�W ���)�

W������ q6�� 9������ ��%���3�)� �P�39������ �":��"� F��&����3��. �#!+1 >�" soo/h``j[/Vss�/ess`/s

Intercept hoo/VVVhoo/VV[[�/h[ss/s=4 �� �3D<� >�!1 � 6�"@�"��ohm/VVohm/Vm�/jsVV/s

���A sj[/`[e`V/Vj[m/esse/s�c< oj/V�m`[m[/s;� V`[� mm

1- Leven

Page 247: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

247

���� >��: ��/VV�" @��' =4 �� �3D<� ����3 @�#$�A� �� �/� � @�"��#4%�, " @�"�� Y$� ���)sVV/sP< �m�/j=F(.���� Y$� @� �� ���6 i#' >��: ��/

=4 �� �3D<� ����3 �� ���A �$ ���a1 ��%#4 ���|� gl6 �� =4 �@�"�� @�"���, "�, " �|� � Y$� ����'��"�� �# ;"�� ��� ������� ��:� �/ .�)��� ��� �� ���6 �/

�. ��(�� ���##{1 �� Y$� @��'��"�� �3D<� ����3 �� ��� �.�' ��$�� ���" ��/%#4 ���:� �� ��. �9��� ����"�� ;�� � Y$� ����' @� ���)!" � ���,.� � @�"��

���A ����"�� ��/)���A �� �J)aA � �/��A �!�Q�� ��/ (�, " �#|t1 � ������1���%'�� �3D<� ����3 Y$� �).�� @���"� .

��"�� � dK�"(�#

��� @��' %/�K4 ��� �� ;7�6 S��)':

U2� :X�� �� �� ���a)$�"�3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �! "�"���A �� �J)aA��/ �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �)����" X�� � �Q�� "� �5���" ��"����� �'��,&$ X��

�3D<� ����*�" "%'�� �3D<� >R�)$� ��)" F�� ���4 �)<� @���"� �)��" �#|t1 �c$�" @�'� �3D<� ����3 ¢��1�� � �.� G�$ � ������. .

:=4 �� �3D<� ����3 � 6�" �x' �� ���A �$ ����� �# %#4 � Y�5' @�"���, " ���a1 �@�"���'��"�� �� ��)�# �7�� � ���� ��:� ���"� ������A ��� ��/ ��/

����"��)D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �! �� �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �J)aA � �3���A�Q�� ��/(�).�� �� 7 � 6�" �� �� �� ��3D<� ����3 � 6�" �x' �� ��'�)`e

� �/��A �! ���A �� �7��e/`o���A �� �J)aA ���A �� �7�� �Q�� ��/ (�� ��'��"�� �� ��)�# �7�� �;��" g�� �'��,&$ X�� ���A ��� ��/)j/[o�7�� (���

�).�� >�i' � 6�" �� �� �� ��3D<� ����3 � 6�" �x'�#/ �C'� >�6 � �'� �� F���������).��' Y��54 �3D<� >R�)$� �x' �� �����"�� ���A �� �'�.

Page 248: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

248

0:���A �� �J)aA X�� �#|t1%'�� �3D<� ����3 �.� � �Q�� ��/ �@���"�� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �! X�� �#|t1 �� �)6 � @� �� %# � Y$� �)�# I/ �3D<

��1���%'�� �3D<� ����3 �c$ �" �(," @���"���..

�)��� U2� %& >�� Y�53 � �/��A �! X�� �#|t1 � �� �%/�K4 ��� ��/%'�� �3D<� >R�)$� ��1���" y��" �'��,&$ X�� � �5���" �� @���"� �'��" � ���.

%/�K4 S��)' � %/�K4 ��x'Y$� �,/��/ ��#�#4 ��/ .���" �� �� �'�J'��/%/�K4 ��� � � �D �Y.lA �x' �� �#�#4 ��/)V�me (�/��A �! �� �'��� @��'

�, " Y���#4 � ��3D<� ����*�" ������" �(," �3D<� >R�)$� �� �����. .��2�� @��J�� �)V�mm (�)��� i#'���� �9��� ���/�" @��' �� �'� �/�%'�� Y��. �� @���"�

�" ��1�� �� �?'� �3D<� >R�)$� ��/��A �!�/� .i,#J#/)V�os (�� ��� @��' i#'�" �3D<� >R�)$� �.� G�$ ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �!��. .� � �DC$�

@��J��)V�oe (;# !1��� �� =4ee%/�K4 �� ��(1 )��#'��(1 (Y#�1 ���6 �� ��3D<����� �9��� ��/��.�" @��' �� �'� ��3D<� ��/�� " ����� �/��A �! �/�

�" �3D<� >R�)$� �.� ��"�('� .@��J�� � � �DC$� � #$� � ��. ���" �� 2�c")V�oe (�� �,1���� :@�)$���V)V�m�(%���4 � ��� Y# � �[)V�mj(�'R� �`)V�os(�

@�)$�4h)V�m�(�AR�A �e)V�mo(@�$�2�'�� �j)V�oV(�a#. �m)V�mo(���a'�/ �o

)V�os(� ��� ��)V�oe(��� �� �Vs)V�oV(�2��� �VV)V�os(;��," �V[)V�m�(� �, 4�� �%���4V` )V�m�(�" ��i,�Vh )V�os(=��$ �Ve)V�mo(�,���� �Vj)V�os(�$ ��'�Vm

2- Fleetwood & Parish 4- Preston 6- Donaldson 8- Hanford 10- Kenvin 12- Manville 14- Mc Kenzie 16- Codding

1- Bridston 3- Boland 5- Gallagher 7- Shafer 9- Riley 11- Farrelly 13- Copland & Parish 15- Sachs 17- St. Denis

Page 249: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

249

)V�os(��D� �e)V�mo(���� �j)V�me(���'�4 �m)V�me(���#4 �o)V�me(�>�J#$�

)V�mh(�1 �¡�Vs)V�mh(=��A �VV)V�mm (����V[)V�mh(i"��� �V`)V�o[(��D� �)V�m�(@�)��� � �K#2 �Vh)V�oV.(

�)��� @��J�� � � � #$� � �H�� ���#�!1 S��)' � ���" ���/)V�m[(����� �)V�mh(=��/ �)V�mj(�"��#2 �)V�me(�"�1 � Y$� �)V�oj(i)���� �)V�os �V�oe(�

� i)���� i�#A )V�o`(@��J�� � iJ,#"�� �)[sVs(�,#2 �)[ss` �[ssj(�'��)5"�� �)V��`(@��J�� � U $ �)V��`(U#c2 �)V��� �[sss(Y$� ��. �9��� �.@�� �|�" ;#2�

%'�� �3D<� ����3 � �3D<� ��/�� " ����� �! ���:� �?'� � �� Y$� ��� @���"��"�2�5" ;6 �/�1 �� �3D<� ��/Y7�� � �,,� ����>R�)$� ��� � l: ��/ ��/

�2�� �3D<��" �9��� @R�5�/ ��$ �� �� ��1�" ���3 �?'� ��#)<� �� �� ��.�/�.

�)��� U2� %& F�� Y�53���A �� �J)aA X�� �#|t1 � �� %/�K4 ��� ��/ ��/%'�� �3D<� >R�)$� �.� � �)����" ��#. � ^Q�T�5���" �� @���"� X�� �

�" y��" �'��,&$%/�K4 S��)' � %/�K4 ��x' �'��" � i#' ���. �#�#4 ��/Y$� �,/��/ :���A �� �J)aA ��£�#4 �)<�,. �.� ���x' � �:�1� X�� � �Q�� ��/i: ��)����"�X�� ��#A��� � @� >D< �� ��'�#A��� �� Y$� � "� 1 � >� � ��/ ��/

�" Y$� ��1�|�" � I?"�� �#�t1 ��'��,&$ X�� � �5���" �� @� Y#���" ;#2� � �%�' � �)<�,. ��� 1 ;7� � X�� ��� �.� � ��lA�|� ��/�,���� �� �� Y$� ��#A

� �3D<� �.� � �)<�,.�" ���.�'�� .

�)��� i#' �)����" ��#A��� ��x' �Q��Q � �:�1� %/�K4 �� %& ��� ��/�" �#:�1��. :D$� �x' �� ���)V��s �V��V �V��h �V��j(@��J�� � @�5'�: �)[sss�

[ssm(@�5'�: � @�5'�: �)[ss�(���� �����A I#1 �Q��Q �� �/��/ � Y���#4���

2- Coder 4- Piwko 6- Troth 8- Walker 10- Laisure and Dacton

1- Clark 3- Panowitsch 5- Siegal 7- Geis 9- Adams

Page 250: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

250

��� ��)�"�"g�/ � �1 �,,�� � �,$� ��)�" ��/ �� �,)5/ �(��)' >��'�N�.��< Ba'N�� ���$ � @�N��� �l2 Y$� ���A Ng�/ � ��#)$� �����/ ���A ��)�"

�,)5/ �����<� ��)�# Xi#J'� � F�(5'� �� .@��J�� � @�5'�: �x' �� ��J�� ��$ ��)[ssm(��� � i)��T� �)[ss` �[sse(� ��1�� )[ssh(@��J�� � �,���T �)[sVV(�

� �:�1 ��)<�,. � �3D<� >R�)$� �1R� u�c$ �� ���a)$� Fi )5" ���#3D<� ��#A�����A�����A��� ��� � @�� �� �@�'� ��A�x' @���� �56 � � @��J�� ��/ U2�&" ��/

���. �� �� �Y$� ���A ����� ���$ %�' %#4 �� %# @��� ��� ���#A��� b;"�� ��/ ��)����"�" @��' ��< �� ��)�# �.� H�� ��/�/� .��x' �'��" ���"

�" @��' �)����" ��#A��� ���6 ��� @��J�/�K4 F��� �# �� ��A��� ��� �� �/�� ����6 Y$� ��. �)���l4 ��<)�Y,5,�� � �#,� ��J'[ss` ��Q�' �V�om @�5'�: �

�@�5'�: �[ss�.(

�$���" @��' ��"� ;�� � ��/%/�K4 �� �/� ���a)$� �#|t1 ���" �� ����� ��/���A �� �J)aA X�� �� ��3D<� ����3 �.� � �)����" ��#A��� ��#. � �Q�� ��/

�/��A �! X�� �� �5���" ��+&)-D� ;� (���A �� �J)aA �� �Q�� ��/ ���#�!1 �<� �� �Y$� ��"�#' ;��)�: � @�5'�: �@�5'[ss�(��#A��� �#|t1 �

�� ��� �� �Y$� ��. �5���" �)�3� �� ���� ��#A��� � �3D<� >R�)$� � �)����"%/�K4 ��� S��)'%/�K4 � �:�1� ���� ��� �� ���i' ��)�5' ��/ � U $ � �: �� ��1

@��J��)V��o (�" ���"��. .�5���" �#/ ���Tl" %/�K4 �� �)�2���� �# �� �� ������A �� �J)aA � �/��A �! X�� %/�K4 �l? " �Y$� ��"�#' ;�� � �Q�� ��/

���A �� �! �#|t1 �$�� � �� Y$� �1��#�!1 ��� " �� �C� H�� �.� � �Q�� ��/$�NY$� �)<���4 �3D<� >R�) .�� �C.i4 @���(�'�� Y��. �� �'��� @��' �?'�

�!���A ����" ��/� ��Q�� ��/�, " ��� �#|t1 �?'� �3D<� >R�)$� � ������1�� G�$ � �).�lA��" �?'� �3D<� ����3 ��..

Page 251: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

251

�)��� �� �J�� %& %/�K4 ��� ��/) %& (�3D<� ����3 � 6�" � ��%'���" y��" @���"��" @�# � ��.�3D<� >R�)$� �� ��. ��(�� ���##{1 ��/ �� �,� %'�����A �� @���"� ����"�� )���A �� �J)aA � �/��A �!�Q�� ��/ (� Y��"

%/�K4 ��x' �'��" � i#' �Y$� ��� ��� 7)��A�����1�� ����� ��� � � �£�#4 ��/��3D<� >R�)$� (%/�K4 S��)' �Y$� @��&�/ � �3 ��/ :��� � � �D)V�me(�@��J�� � ��2��)V�mm (� �1��##{1 ��/ �� �'��� @��'%'�� Y��. �|� � ��� @���"�

Y$� ��� � "�C1 � Y��" ��. ��(�� �?'� �3D<� >R�)$� �� ��/��A �! .���)V�mj(i)���� �)V�os(@��J�� � � �DC$� �)V�oe(��� �R �)V�mo (�"�1 � Y$� �)V�oj (�)��� i#'���� �9��� %/�K4 ��� S��)' ���" ���/�'� .�� 7 � Y��" ;#2�@�� �

�� �.�' ���##{1 ��� �� Y$� ��� �@���"� %'�� �3D<� >R�)$� �� ��. ��(�� ���##{1� �Y5#' I#/�a" ��#A�����' ;�)," I " � #$���' �x��6 � �C)" � ��. �C ��.�

����3 �/�'�"��$ ����� � � 3�� �)<�,. ��� 1 �� �.�' � 3�� �##{1 � �3D<� ��/R�)$� ��J2��'��"�� �3D<� >Y$�/.

�)��� �� ��& %/�K4 ��� ��/)0 %& (�" @��' �� �� �J)aA X�� �#|t1 ������A%'�� �3D<� >R�)$� �.� � �Q�� ��/ I/ �/��A �! X�� �#|t1 �� �@���"�

%/�K4 ��x' �'��" � �Y$� �)�#)��.� ��C���W���x' � ��#3D<� � �)<�,. �)����" ��#A��� (Y$� �,/��/ :��.� ��C��� ��x' �Q��Q � �:�1�W��)<�,.

)��£�#4 ���x' �� I? "V�`[ (��� 1 ;7�)��2�� 1 (@R�5�/ � ��� ;"� 1 ��)<�,.%�' �Y$� �3D<� �.� �$�$� ��/������$ �� ���#A .�J)aA X�� �� �C,�� � �:�1�

���A �� �/��A �! � �5���" �� ��Q�� ��/���i' ���: ;"� 1 �-D� ;� � �1�'R������ �# ��1�� ���A I/ �" ��:� �6 ���)�� � I " ��/���,/� � ���

�" �C�"��A��� Z�� ��$� �£�#4 ��/)V�`[(��� � �)V�oj (�#" ���x' Z�c" �)V�`h (1 �� ;7�6 ���#|t1 ������' ;��)" %,� �����N/ � ��� ;"� N�@R�5�

� 1��%�' �,���� ��1R� �c$ �3D<� >R�)$� �9��� �� �.�' �)<�,. �,.� � ��#A

Page 252: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

252

��,���� ��� �|� � � ���� �3D<� ����3 �.� � ��)�# ���#|t1 ���J�� ��A�x' � @�.�" ��1�� �3D<� >R�)$� �c$��� .

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :Vh/se/V`�V �&5' Y����� r���1'�2��" ���? :[s/s�/V`�V �2��" X��l4 r���1:[o/sV/V`�[

Page 253: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

253

q���� References ��"�� ���J ,$ � ������� �n�� �DC#' �=��)[sse.(1"�K$43�3 ����#� �� ��������� ��

-�.� .-�.-��� � �(��< ��:�1 �>�� P�Q �@���� �����)'� �@��?1 ����7 � � � ����V`oo.

�?2� ����(6 � -��� �@�A��� ���/� ��"�$)V`m� .(B�������� [��G �3 w"2K$ �� ��@��?1F�$ P�Q ���A� �����)'�.

�'�#$ �;J#$)V�ej .(������ [��G ��#� �#����� #"i ���� ����� U$�� ��:�1 ��J�'�� �@��?1 �� �F�� P�Q ��������� �"D�V`m[.

� � �U#$ ����)V`oj .(�,��# ������������A� �����)'� �@��?1 .

��'�?" �����?.)V`oh.(���P�� ,� ��������� :�<�K$ ��( �3�>�� P�Q �I � ��' �@��?1 .

�: ������� �@�52�#..)V�oo .(������ [��G �3 ����� 7v ��� �:F�� � :���"� y��,)$�.��:�1%,"�#� �*�# � .�������� �"D� �6�� �/�J�'�� ��?: �����)'� �@��?1 .@�)5�1 �F��?Q P�Q

V`o[.

D#)$ ��,�3D�)V`mj .(�)����" ��#A��� � �/�J�'�� =���1 .�� ��"�#$ �� ����. �I(,4 >�$ �V�[�7 �:mjWe�.

���' ���:�3)V`mm .( �5���" �X�/ �=a' �i� �@�!)"� �� G �1 �x' �� �3D<� ����3 �.� ;6��"���+)3� ��J��: � � #+!1 ��C ��W���/� �?. �c$�)" F�� � >�� >�$ @���"� %'�� ����):� �

���� ��"�#$ ��������� ,�� ����,��' ���� ����/� @���Q �#?. ��J�'��.

�#!� ������)V`m� .(B�� #"@A$ �;��2� $ �� #""+$ #� 2� ��*�� � ��#( dK� E���#�O� W����3 B#:�= � 3�� C�&� �� !6;� ��)������%��� 7�� 7�� ���3 -�3 �,)�� ���X��iA

X���4 � X��"� ����� �Y#�1 � I# 1 ��C�/�K4 ���/�K4 u��.

����4 ������)V`me.(��3 �/8�� �� P� ,� ���#��P �� �� �.��� � ��)������ � ����)�� �X���4 � X��"� ����� �Y#�1 � I# 1 ��C�/�K4 ��/�K4 u�� X��iA.

����4 ������)V`o`.(s8�� ����������F�� P�Q ��A� ��' �@��?1 .

�#��: ������)V`m` .( u�c$ � ��?" ��J��: �X�/ ��3D<� ����3 �.� ;6��" �# �c�� �$��%'�� @�#" �� �D#+!1�4 @���"���@���(�'�� � @�)$�#� F�� �����,/�� F�$ �����)� I(,4 ��/

Page 254: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

254

���/� I " Y#�1 i���".��#%Q "f, 4�:���3 ��"�#$ ��������� ,�� ����,��' ���� ���� )���.

Uc2 �#56 �����)V`os .(����P � ����P�� �3 ���3 � �,)�� E�/8�� ,� �P�Q �@�'��: � " @�"��$>��.

��,5!" ��?Q �#')V`mo .(X������x' �� �3D<� ��/��$�,�'��� U )&" ��/ ��"�#$ [��G ��#�� �@��?1 ��J�'��.

����4 ��"�i< � �� 5" �F��" ���a7 ���+,"�#$ �����")V`o� .( X��"� �"�'� ���:� �#|t1 �$��%'�� �3D<� ����3 �.� � ��/�K4 k��):� X�� � @����� ��� �a5 �@���"� I(,4 ���4

����/� �?. ����)��3�' � #S*$ ������� ��7 �>�� ����. �>�� >�$ :V[mWVs[.

� ,)$� ������� ���)#4 � ���#/ �;4 �Y$�/)V�mV .(!"�#$ w.�� :�*;�� 4�:� )� !"�#$ [�f*� 1"�K$��"�K$��>�� P�Q ��J,/�� � �� � �����)'� ������ ��/�� ��:�1V`o�.

� ���#6 ��"�/)V`mo.(������ �� �3 ����� ]�6�����F��?Q P�Q ��$��4 ��' �@��?1 .

Armstrong, M. (1993). Ethics and Professionalism in Accounting Education: A Sample Course, Journal of Accounting Education, Vol. 11, pp. 79-92.

Aspin, D., (2000). A Clarification of Some Key Terms in Values Discussion, in M. Leicester, C. Modgil, and S. Modgil, (eds). Moral Education and Pluralism, Falmers press.

Berkowitz, M.W., (1985). Peer Conflict and Psychological Growth: New Directions for Child Development, San Francisco: Jossey- Bass.

Berkowitz, M.W., (1982). The Role of Discussion in Moral Education, Paper Presented at the International Symposium on Moral Education, Friburg,Switzerland, September, 1982.

Berkowitz, M.W., (1980). The Role of Transaction Discussion in Moral Development: The History of a Six-year Program of Research-part II., Moral Education Forum. Vol. 5, pp. 15-27.

Berkowitz, M.W. and Bier, M.C., (2003). Character Education Literature Review, Available at web: www.character.org.

Berkowitz, M.W. and Bier, M.C., (2005). What Works in Character Education: A Research Driven Gide for Educators, Character Education

Page 255: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

255

Partnership. University f Missouri-st. Louis, Washington, DC. Available at Web: www.character.org.

Berkowitz, M.W., and Gibbs, J., (1983). Measuring the Developmental Features of Moral Discussion, Merrill- Palmer Quarterly, Vol. 24, P. 399-410.

Berkowitz, M.W., Gibbs, J., and Brughton, J., (1980). The Relation of Moral Judgment Stage Disparity to Developmental Effects of Peer Dialogues, Merrill- Palmer Quarterly, Vol. 26, pp. 341-357.

Blatt, M., (1969). Studies on the Effects of Cassroom Discussion Upon Children’s Moral Development, Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation.

Blatt, M.M., and Kohlberg, L., (1975). The Effects of Classroom Moral Discussion Upon Children’s Level of Moral Judgment, Journal of Moral Education, Vol.4, No. 2, pp. 129-161.

Boyd, D. (1976). Education toward Principled Moral Judgment: An Analysis of an Experimental Course in Undergraduate Moral Education Employing Laurence Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Development, Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, Harvard University.

Broughton, J., (1978). The Cognitive-developmental Approach of Morality: A Reply to Kurtines and Greif, Journal of Moral Education, Vol 7, No. 2, P. 81-96.

Cazden, C.B., (1988). Classroom Discourse, Portsmouth. NH: Heinemann.

Colby, A., and Kohlberg, L., (1987). The Measurement of Moral Judgment, Vol 1: Theoretical Foundations and Research Validation, New York, Cambridge University Press.

Colby, A., Kohlberg, L., Fenton, E., Speicher- Dubin, B., and Lieberman, M., (1977). Secondary School Moral Discussion Programes Led Social Studies Teacher, Journal of Moral Education, Vol, 6. No. 2, pp. 90-111.

Colby, A., Kohlberg, L., Biggs, J., and Lieberman, M., (1983). ALongitudinal Study of Moral Judgment, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 48 (Serial No. 200).

Cummings, R., Maddux, C.D., Cladianos, A., and Richmond, A., (2010). Moral Reasoning of Education Students: The Effects of Direct Instruction in Moral Development Theory and Participation in Moral

Page 256: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

256

Dilemma Discussion, Teacher College Record, Vol. 112, No. 3, pp. 621-644.

Dellaportas, S., Cooper, B,J., and Leung, P., (2006). Measuring Moral Judgment and the Implications of Cooperative and Rule-based Learning, Accounling and Finance, Vol. 46, p.1-18.

Dillon, J. T., (1994). Classroom Discussion, In T. Husen and T.N. Postlethwaite (eds). The International Encychopedia of Education, Pergamon Press.

Duric, L., (1988), Essentials of Educational Psychology, UNESCO.

Dembo, M.M., (1994). Applying Educational Psychology, Longman.

Faustt, J.L., and Paulson, D.R., (1998). Active Learning in the College Classroom, Journal of Excellence in College Teaching, Vol. 9, No. 2, p. 3-24.

Festinger, L.A., (1957). Theory of Cognitive Dissonance, Row, Peterson and Company.

Galbraith, R.E., and Jones, T.M., (1976). Moral Reasoning: A Teaching Handbook for Adopting Kohlberg to the Classroom. Minneapolis, MN: Green haven Press.

Gall, M.D., And Artero- Boname, M.T., (1994). Questioning Dtrategies, In T. Husen and T.M. Post Lethwaite (eds). The International Rncyclopedia of Education, Pergamon Press.

Gibbs, J., (1995). The Cognitive Developmental Perspective, In W.M. Kurtines, and J. L. Gewirtz (Eds). Moral Development: An Introduction (pp. 27-48). Boston; Allyn and Bacon.

Gibbs. J.C., Basinger, K.S., and Fuller, R., (1992). Moral Maturity: Measuring the Development of Sociomoral Reflections, Hillsdale, NJ, Erlbaum.

Gibbs, J., Schnell, S., Berkowitz, M., and Goldestein, D. (1983, April), Relations between Formal Operations and Logical Conflict Resolution, Paper Presented at the Biennial Meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Detroit.

Gilligan, G., (1982). In A Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Page 257: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

257

Graham, J., Haidt, J., and Rimm- Kaufman, S.E., (2008). Ideology and Intuition in Moral Education, European Journal of Developmental Science, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 269-268.

Kagan, S., (1989). Cooperative Learning Resources for Teachers, San Juan Capistrano, CA: Resources for Teachers, Available at web.

Kohlberg, L., (1984). Essays on Moral Fevelopment, Vol. 2, The Psychology of Moral Development, New York: Harper and Row.

Kohlberg, L., (1968). Moral Development, In D.L., Sills (ed), International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, Vol. 10, New York: Macmillan Company and the Free Press, pp. 483- 494.

Kohlberg, L., (1969). Stage and Sequence: The Cognitive Developmental Approach to Socialization, in D. Goslin (ed). Handbook of Socialization Theory and Research, Chicago, IL: Rand McNally, pp. 347-480.

Kohlberg, L., (1975). The Cognitive Developmental Approach: New Developments and a Response to Criticism, Paper Presented at the Meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Denver, March 1975.

Kohlberg, L., (1975). The Cognitive-developmental Approach to Moral Education, Phi Delta Kappan, Vol 56, p. 670-677.

Kohlberg, L., (1958). The Development of Modes of Moral Thinking and Choice in the Years 10 to 16, Doctoral Dissertation, University of Chicago, Chicago, 111. pp: 17-125

Kowino, O.J., Agak, J.O., Obiero- Owino, C.E. and Ongunya, R.D., (2011). The Preceived Discrepancy between the Teaching of Charistian Religious Education and Inculcation of Moral Values amongst Secondary School Students in Kisumu East District, Education Research and Review, Vol. 6, No.3, pp. 299-314.

Krebs, D.L., and Denton, K., (2005). Toward A More Pragmatic Apporach to Morality: A Critical Evaluation of Kohlberg’s Mode, Psychological Review, Vol. 112, No. 3, pp. 629- 649.

Kurtines, W., S, and Greif, E.B., (1974). The Developmen of Moral Thouht: Review and Evalucation of Kohlberg’s Approach, Psychological Bulletine, Vol. 81, No. 8, P. 453- 470.

Page 258: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

258

Hersh, R.H., Paolitto, D.P., and Remier, J., (1979). Promoting Moral Frowth: from Piget to Kohlberg, New York: Long man.

Higgins, A., (1980). Research and Measurement Issues in Moral Education Interventions, In R. Mosher (Ed). Moral Education: A First Generation of Research and Development, pp. 92- 107, New York: PRAGER.

Hoffman, M., (1979). Development of Moral Thought, Feeling and Behavior, American Psychologist, Vol. 34. No. 10, pp. 958-966.

Hoffman, M., (1977). Moral Internalization: Current Theory and Research, Advances in Experimental Psychology. Vol. 10, pp. 86-115.

Johnson, D.W., and Johnson R.T., (2009). An Educational Psychology Success Story: Social Interdependence Theory and Cooperative Learning, Educational Researcher, Vol. 38. No. 5, pp. 365-379.

Johnson, W.D., Johnson. R.T., and Beth Stanne, M., (2000). Cooperative Learning Methods: A Meta-analysis, University of Minnesota, Available at web.

Johnson, D.W., Johnson, R.T. and Holubec, E., (2007). Cooperative Learning and Moral Education, The Newsletter of the Cooperative Learning Institute, Vol. 22, Iss. 1, pp.1-8.

Latif, A., (2000). The Relationship between Ethical Dilemma Fiscussion and Moral Development, American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, Vol. 64, pp. 126- 133.

Latif, D.A., (1999). Using Ethical Dilemma Case Studies to Develop Pharmacy Student’s Moral Reasoning, Journal of Pharmaceutic Teaching, Vol. 7, pp.51- 66.

Lind, G., (2006). Effective Moral Education: The Konstanz Method of Dilemma Discussion, Hellenic Journal of Psychology, Vol. 3, pp. 189-196.

Lind, G., (2005). Moral Dilemma Discussion Revisited- the Konstanz Method. European Journal of Psychology, February 2005, Available at web: www.uni-konstanz.de/ag-moral.

Lind, G., (1995, April). The Meaning and Measurement of Moral Competence Revisited, Paper Presented at Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco.

Page 259: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

259

Lockwood, A.L., (1978). The Effects of Values Clarification and Moral Development Curricula on School-age Subjects: A Critical Review of Recent Research, Review of Educational Research. Summer, Vol. 48, No. 3, pp. 325-364.

Murray, F.B., (1990). Cooperative Learning. In N. Entwistle (ed). Handbook of Educational Ideas and Pratices, Routledge, London.

Narvaez, D., (2002). Does Reading Moral Stories Build Character? Educational Psychology Review, Vol. 14, No. 2, pp. 155-171.

Nucci, L., (1997). Moral Development and Character Formation, In H.J. Walberg and G.D. Haertle (Eds). Psychology and Educational Practice, Berkeley Maccarchan, P. 127-157.

Nucci, L., (1987). Synthesis of Research on Moral Development, Educational Leadership, February, pp. 86-92.

Nucci, L., and Turiel, E., (2009). Capturing the Complexity of Moral Development and Education, Mind, Brain and Education, Vol. 3, pp. 151-159.

Nunner- Winkler, G., (1994). Moral Development, In T. Husen and T.N. Postlethwaite (eds). The International Encyclopedia of Education, Pergamon Press.

Oser, F.K., (1997). Acquiring Sttitudes and Balues. In L.J Saha (ed). The International Encyclopedia of the Sociology of Education, Pergamon Press.

Oser, F.K., (1986). Moral Education and Values Education: The Discourse Perspective, In M.C. Wittrock (ed). Handbook of Research on Teaching,Merican Education Research Association.

Oser, F., and Reichenbach, R., (1994). Moral Education: Philosophical Issues, In T. Husen and T.N. Postlethwaite (eds)., The International Encyclopedia of Education, Pergamon Perss.

Pen, W.Y. Jr., (1990). Teaching Ethics- a Direct Approach, Journal of Moral Education, Vol. 19, pp. 128-138.

Piaget, J., (1932). The Moral Judgment of the Child, Translate by: M. Gabain, New York: Free Press, 1965.

Page 260: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

260

Rest, J.R., (1979). Development in Judging Moral Issues, University of Minnesota Press. Minneapolis, Minnesota.

Rest, J.R., (1986). DIT Manual. (3th ed). University of Minnesota, Center for the Study of Ethical Development, Minneapolis.

Rest, J.R., (1986). Moral Development: Advances in Research and Theory.PRAGER. New York.

Rest, J., (1973). The Hierarchical Nature of Stage of Moral Development, Journal of Personality, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 86-109.

Rest., J.R., Narvaez, D., Bebeau. M., & Thoma, S., (1999). A Neo-kohlbergian Approach: the DIT and Schema Theory, Educational Psychology Review, Vol. 11, No. 4, pp: 291- 324.

Rest J.R., Narvaez, D., Thoma, S.J., and Bebeau, M,J., (2000). A Neo-Kohlbergain Approach to Morality Research, Journal of Moral Education, Vol. 29, pp. 381-396.

Rest, J.R., Narvaez, D., Thoma, S,J., and Bebeau, M.J., (1999). DIT 2: Devising and Testing A Revised Instrument of Moral Judgment, Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol. 91, No. 4, P: 644- 659.

Rest., and Thoma, S.J., (1986). Educational Programs and Interventions, In J.R. Rest (ed), Moral Development: Advances in Research and Theory, PRAGER. New York.

Rest, J.R., Thoma, S,J., Narvaez, D., and Bebeau M,J., (1997). Alchemy and Beyond: Indexing the Defining Issues Test, Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol. 89. No. 3, pp: 498-507.

Rubtsov, V.V., (1994). Social Interaction and Learning, In T. Husen and T.N. Postlethwaite (eds). The International Encyclopedia of Education, Pergamon Press.

Schlaefli, A., Rest, J.R., and Thoma, S.J., (1985). Does Moral Education Improve Moral Judgment? A Meta-analysis of Intervention Studies Using the Defining Issues Test, Review of Educational Research, Vol. 55. No.3. pp: 319-352.

Self. D.J., Baldwin, D.C Jr, and Olivarez, M., (1993). Teaching Medical Ethics to First-year Students while Using Film Discussion to Develop Their Moral Reasoning, Academic Medicine, Vol. 68, pp. 383-385.

Page 261: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

261

Self, D.J., Olivarez, M. and Baldwin, D.C., (1998). The Amount of Small-group Case- Study Discussion Needed to Improve Moral Reasoning Skills of Medical Students, Academic Medicine, Vol. 75, No.5, pp. 521-523.

Shaffer, D.R., (1989). Developmental Psychology, (2th ed). Brooks Cole pub. Company, Wadsworth, Inc.

Slavin, R. (1990). Cooperative Learning: Theory, Research and Practice, Needham Heights, Mass: Allyn and Bacon.

Slavin, R.E., (1994). Educational Psychology: Theory and Practice, (4th ed), Allyn and Bacon.

Slavin, R.E., (1996). Research on Cooperative Learning and Achievement: What We Know, What Are Need to Know, Contemporary Educational Psychology, Vol. 21, pp. 43-69.

Slavin, R.E., (1987). Students Motivating Students to Excel: Cooperative Incentives, Cooperative Tasks, and Student Achievement, In H.F. Clarizio, R.C. Craig and W.A. Mehrens (Eds). Contemporary Issues in Educational Psychology (5th ed). Mc graw-hill, International Edition.

Slavin, R., (1991). Synthesis of Research on Cooperative Learning, Educational Leadership, Vol. 48, No. 5, pp. 71-82.

Sprinthall, N.A., Sprinthall, R.C. and Oja, S.N., (1994). Educational Psychology: A Developmental Approach, (6th ed). Mc Graw- Hill Inc.

Tomlinson, P., (1992). Moral Judgment and Moral Psychology: Piaget, Kohlberg and Beyond. In L. Smith (ed): Jean Piaget, Critical Assessment, Vol, 1. Routledge, London.

Turiel, E., (1998). The Development of Morality, In W. Damon (chief ed)., Handbook of Psychology, Vol. 3. Nancy Eisenberg-John, willey.

Turiel, E., (1983). The Development of Social Knowledge: Morality and Convention, Cambridge University Press.

Vezzuto, L.A., (2004). How Young People Develop Character, A Conceptual Framework with Descriptions of Promising Practices, Institute for Character Education, Learning Support unit.available at web.

Page 262: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

262

Vincent, P., (2003). Developing Character in Students; A Work Book for Teachers, Parents and Communities, Chapel Hill, NC; Character Development Publishing.

Walker, L.J., Henning, K.H., and Krettenauer T., (2000). Parent and Peer Context for Children’s MoralR Development, Child Development, Vol. 71, No. 4, pp. 103-104.

Wark, G.R., and Krebs, D.L., (2000). The Construction of Moral Dilemma in Everyday Life, Journal of Moral Education, Vol. 29, p. 5-21.

Page 263: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

263

)!$�� )0Y����� )4= ��$ ����!�G �.W�3 �����$ �6 �� ��T$ 1� )0 1 ���&� 3��3�� z

�b� �_� "%a4���{

C"a� #o���� |

4 "SQ %/�K4 �*�6 ���x," ���)�� ����$��� �"�,�$�4 Y# ��3);����A ��C��(��c�� @��Y��*� ���A�'� ���# %'��@���"� �?. �54 �� i���1 ��� #+!1 >�$ �VW�s>�{�" �;#+!1 �'�� ���7 Y��A.��#�/ ��x," ��� 1 hVj �a' %'����"� �54 �X�� �'��'��#A �.�<���@��,�

�'��' �&)'� �..�����a)$� ���"�,�$�4 hs�2��$ Y# ��3 �e�2��$ Y��*� ���A�'� �����" �?'� ��:� ����" ��i(1 �1;# ! ���3 Y��A .=4�����:� ;# !1 � "�� G��* ���)�� oh/s�Y$�

��"� Y$� �������)�� ���" �2��3 Y$�.��� �$�� ����� ���$ �r$�4 ���� >�z$ ��-�#�" Y# ��3 ���,Q ;"�� k��.� ��. Y$� ��X�� ;# !1 �a2z"��/ � 7�)pc(���a)$� ��. Y$�.����a)$� ����#. Q%<� ;���)" ���:�1 ��*��a"��/ ;# !1 �� "�� �7�� �##�1 ='����� �G#. �����' ��Y��?' m;"��)@�# ���$�56� ���3 �'��)aA g�c '�����l4 F�)!" @���. H��6 ���< �¶�:����� -�56� �)6�� ��y��1�� ��@��J�� ���l4���)'�(0��&)$� ����A .����� I/s`j/hs�7�� ='����� ���#�1 �"�,�.=��1�" � "�� @��' ��� ��;"�� IC� ����� ���)�# �� � "�� �I?$ @�i#' �����$ ;"���/�)�# ��.��c,#�/ ��� @�,#��� ������� ��i� %/�K4 ������� @�"i�/

���a)$� �.�@��' ��� ��Y��*� ���A�'� ��#/�������<-�#�"�/���< $�4�"�,� Y# ��3 �J)5��/ �����, " Y.��' i( ���<-�#�" -�56� �)6�� ��y��1�� �@��J�� );"��j.(�<� �� �

�. �#?1 �"�,�$�4 ��� ��7�� ��(,/.��(h�� � "�':�AK���(,5'��� ��/Y��*� �Y# ��3 ����A�'�.

1N��5"�A �6�� ���� ��J�'�� �����)$� 2N��C,1 �6�� ���� ��J�'�� �����)$� 3N����'� � %(,$ �.�� �$�,.��C� �(,5'��� ��#Ai��" @��?1 �6�� �"D$� ���� ��J�'�

Email:[email protected]

Page 264: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

264

�� 2�

A�'��%2�Q�4 ���"����'�A��Y$� ����� F��" ��< ��� 3�"#Y�/�U )&" #���������):������ "�#�,.��,Q#� 3�"#Y�/��/#��#I@�"���� ��

�)$��<�/�H��6 k���" ����Y!1k� �2� ���3 A#��.�, ��C'� ��� iA�'���.� <���!1#;�/��l]���.�).��' ��3#Y��,Q#� 3�"#Y�/�@�5'� ����)��A

�5:��"��ª�'���#��� �b��� ���):��I2�$�' "��,� )��) "���V`om.(

-�$�� ��)���/�%/�K4�/��� )" 5#�������C/i��/��/��)���g�!," ��7�+< ��@�'��:�' ����2�#;���:� "������@�'��:�' �@�'��: ���3 �'�)aA

�� �:�G$�," ���'���'.@��:�' �@��: �'��/��< ��@��J ������< �'�('� � $�"��,� �F��1 �)$��<�/������#@��Qk���" ��Qk���"�' r$�4 Y��" �/�.4#�"�

,Q#�Y���� �'������������?'�YY"D$ '�����?'� ��B�1 @�� "�: ������ " �?1�����3 "��/�.���,����:� ��3#Y����� �'��1��F�R �����������B3��#�'�,

� 3�"#Y�/�#'�����"��'��1 %,1������������ �,.� ����( �,� �������lJ/� � ���? �i�=a' ���,�<�������A�'����� �,� )2#@�, �#� V�[sse���:�1

D����V`oh.(

�� B"��: @��)" �4#��)��� �/��������X��"��/����K����i���%3 ��#Y�� ����� ������1 "�#�,, ��� 4#Y��� B"��: ��< �Y"D$ �R�6 )<�,�'����

@�"��" ��< "���'�. C�"�����:� ���� ���Y$� �������� �"�����" y��1�� ��3#Y��*��Y��A�'���/�K4����7 �)��J' Y$� ���%/�K4 ����� p5"

���� Y$� �����#� ��3#Y��*��Y��A�'���c�� ��:� ����� �)�2� ���� p5" y�," �����/��< �� ������ p5" >�� ����!1#Z��: ;�3 2��3��Y$� ���.

�, ����C, �"�,�$�4 ��3#Y)���A�;���C�[(��#����A �'��' ��������)�� �������.�.

2- Ricky & Gmbryl 1- Linden Field

Page 265: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

265

�C����<�.�/�Y.��? '�����"#@�i �*��Y��A�'��Y$�.%/�K4�/�F�('� ��. ��"�#�,�*��Y��A�'����#�@�'��:�' @��' ���� Y5/ ���*���,�)�

@�'��:�' �@�'��: ��A�'��"�#�,X�)5A �,"�� �*��@�'� Y����6�/�@�A�'�A ��+)3������):���$#$���J,/���Y$�.��i��%%,1�/��DC�" ��)����

"��'#������c*� A��5������� �: ��|� a,"��*��'�)���A�'��Y$� ��4#�/�"��@���/ %/�� 6��#�Y����" �:�����):���@�� 1 ����)�� ���):���/��< Y.��

)-�'�V�V��`��;�' �� AR#��/#�,�[�[ssV(.

���� �� 2�c" F�('� ��. ��"��� ��3#Y���/������w�F�('� ��. Y$� .��:�1 �|t1#��,/�� ��;C.A#�� ��3#a" �Y#��/��< �� ��$���� ���.��

�<�. ��3#Y��� "�: ��@�� ����� ���� ��<#�.�� ��-�$� ���%/�K4 ����7 $���"#@�i ��3#Y%'��@���"� ��1�i���c�� @���*��Y��'�A��@�'� Y$�.

� �:�1 ����C, k�*�" ���" $�����,: �������l2 ����� ?1#�r$�4 ���%$�4�/�����"�����*�Y$�:

W���#�>��$�/��"�,�$�4 ��3#YJ,/��/���:� ����� W�������(" >��$�/��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y�����)�� ���������<� �Y$� W�������(" >��$�/��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y�������F�R �����<� �Y$� W���#��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y��*��Y��A�'���c�� ��:� �����

B��

���u�� %/�K4 7�1#a�W���)���Y$� ���-�$� >�7� ���S(,5'����F�('� ��. Y$�.

� "�: ���"� ��� %/�K4 ;"�. �"��1 %'��@���"� �54 Bc�" @�)$�#� �?.1i���

2- Hyvbnr & Laglyn 1- Anas

Page 266: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

266

��1�i��>�$ +!1# ��VW�s��� Y$�.

�� ���%/�K4 �4#��?,� ,���1#���#>�V)[ssm(���� 1 hVj �a' ��%'��@���"� Bc�" �#@�)$� �?. ��1�i�@��,� �'��' �&)'� �'�..����&)'� �'��' g� " � "�: ��X�� �'��'A#���.�<�����a)$� �..�������7 ����)� ��Z��," �?.

��1�i�$��c," [�h�e���� ���+1��&)'� ��. =]$ ���/��c," � ���)��A ��(" ������� X��"� �X���4 �?1#�"�$��-���" ��:�" ���/��c," ����7 ���+1����$��" 1##���A��.���?'��Y�"�,�$�4�/����" '�x��"#@�%'��

@���"� �/����-���" ��1�B�..

��U��4)� �� ���#"(

������# !"&b�/:���A�;���C�)V�me(��i�����%(,$ ��3#Y�)<�$�'� �T ;"�. hs���" Y$�.��� @�"�� ���$Y�53 ;#E�1 ��. Y$� ��/���" ^�

Y# 3�" �TFi )5" ��)�� ����/ � ��3#YY$� ��@��' �"�/�.��Y�53 >�� ���'��"�� �)$��< �"��. �T@�i#" ���. �)6���' ��< ��F�J,/ �:��" @�. ���� Y# 3�"�/�G56 ^�-�#�" �:����, S,4 �,�iA��@�# �,,�.��Y�53 F�� �'��"�� ��� >��)6� ��� ��)�� ��< ����'�,Q ��Y# 3�"��/ �T� ��. ���3 ��#A �

6G5�:����, S,4 �,�iA��@�# �,T.����� �"�,�$�4 ���' �)�T �'��' ��3#Y�)�# Y$�.

�� �x' @�i#" ���)�� �J)5��/ ����� �# ���"��/ ��� @�"�� ��J��E� ��:� ����.���)�� � "�� ���"��/ U )&" @�"�� �# `�/s�1ms/sX��iA ��. Y$�.�#,��/

�J)5��/ ���'��/ ��@�" �S��)' ������ ������ �T��a�� %�' ��� ����� ����/��" ���T ��'�� hj/s�� )��"��?V`me.(

;# !1 ;"��� b$�1 ;����A ��C�� )V�me(@��' ��� �T��� -�#�" ����� �����

1- Fidel & Tabaknyk

Page 267: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

267

��R� Y$� ����'��1 ���lAi���1 �# ����� B��3 R� ��#��4 ������.G��* ���)�� ���@�"�� �X�� ��a2� ���'��� ���#'�� @��T ���" �$�� ���3 �)��A Y$� ��G#1�1

m/s�o`/sb$�1 ;����A ��C�� )V�me(X��iA ��. Y$�.

�� %/�K4 ���(6 )V`o[(����a)$� ����a2� ���'��� ���)�� �"�,�$�4 ��oo/s������ ���T Y$�.�,"�� �'��� ����� �"�,�$�4 �# os�1hss �"�.� �T���'

�1R� @��'��,/� ��3#Y�#��4�1�"�.�.

���:� ��� �"�,�$�4 ����7 �/��A �����a'� ;�3 ��:� �"�.�.

������# !��_� )��( �) #���3 ���#:�3:�"�,�$�4 �*��Y��A�'����b$�1 ����,V�@���C�/ )V�oe (��1����. �Y$� �"#-�e���" ��Y$� )�/���" ���D"��

Ia2�&" V�1D"�� I����"m.(��������,"�� 2��)6�����'�/�����"�,�$�4 ��e�*��Y�4#���1`e�*��YR� {)"#��/��< ��.�����" �4����@�"�� �*�G�a2� ��� om/s��*�G�"������=4��[��" ��� o[/sX��iA ��. Y$� )����,�

�@���C�/V�oe.(

�,��� �@���C�/ )V�oe(=4���,#�� @�"�� ��C$� ������" �K�� ��� 1 ;"��� k�i)'� ��. �� 1##��'���'.����@�� �-�$� %/�K4 �ax"�)V`o[(�*�G�a2�����'���

������@�"�� ��� oe/s��4�����"�������� 7�� j/�)a ��� oh/s��� Y$�.

4�", �#P�

l<� �� "��"�'�/�F�R Y?: ���6 ��-���" �=]$ ��:���"�,�$�4�/� ��3#Y��*��Y��A�'����%'��@���"� ���� �c$�)" -���" .N�?��1��i��:��@�"�� �

���7 �/��A Y$�.��)� �# � %'���'���"� ��Y?: @�"�� �&)'� ��.��'� ��H�1���/ 2�<���J.��"� ��A ������ =4��$�N����) '��"����/���$�:����< ���x," ��N��(

A��"����@�'� �/��N%��c*� *�1#1�!������ ��!' r$�4/�N�N��R��$ �9���

1- Daynr

Page 268: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

268

�..=]$ �"�,�$�4�/#��?'� ��1�B�..����* ���x," ?51#;����3���y��1�� �� �#�-���" ����:� ���� �"���)��)'�� "�@�i���" ���a)$� �..

������

������6�G� ������# !"&b�/:��� 1##����)�� @�"�� ��X�� �a2�����'��� ���a)$� ��. Y$� ������a)$� �����X�� ����" ���)�� ����"�,�$�4 ��%/�K4 �*�6 oh/s

�Y$� ��"� Y$� �������)�� ���" 2��3�Y$�.

;# !1 ;"��� b$�1 ;����A ��C�� )V�me(@��' ��� �T��� -�#�" ����� ����� ��R� Y$� ����'��1 i���1���lA �# ����� B��3 R� ��#��4 ������.G��* ���)�� ��� @�"�� �X�� ��a2� ���'��� ���#'�� @��T ���" �$�� ���3 �)��A $�Y��G#1�1

m/s�o`/sb$�1 ;����A ��C�� )V�me(X��iA ��. Y$�.

�� %/�K4 ���(6 )V`o[(����a)$� ����a2� ���'��� ���)�� �"�,�$�4 ��oo/s������ ���T Y$�.���@��' "��/� ����)'�S%/�K4 �*�6 �5�/ "��,.�.

1"�K$ ����G 3��� ������# !"&b�/

;�3 ����:�� !1#; "���F�R Y$� �*��a"�/��������Y�'�. :

����'� �'��':���)?���Y2�6 ����'� ���'��' ����1R� ��Ves ��� �Y�5' Y$�I�e���" ������/{)"#���:� �).�� �.�.

;"��l4����1�"�=J)5��/�:���@����1�"�=J)5��/���� !1#;;"�� G$�," �� 1 ��. ��� ;3��6 ���� 1 �J)5��/ `/s=r���)�# ��:� �).�� �.�.@�"��

����YY 1��V������!2 ��"������, " �.�)se/s<p(�����" �#�5-"#C2���#�[

j/s���1R� �.�.

�c< @��:��@��:��;# !1 ;"�� -�$�� �J)5��/ �Y$� F�R Y$� ���c��

2- Kaiser Mayer Olkin(KMO) 1- bartlett test of sphericity

Page 269: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

269

#�{)"#�/� c<��.�.

��4�/��#��/���": !1#;;"�� �C�" Y$� ���4�/-�56 �.�.

7� P)z(4)� �� KMO!�$��� !��#' ���)� ��"�� �

#;"' ���)� �� 2�)���3#� ���%� !��*'( ���/��< ����" ���/�}�}

����� �:�� ��� Y 1�� Y���� @�"�� �����, " }}}/}

��'�,Q >��: V@��' "���/� ����" KMO )�a��Y�'��'�����(��� ohs/sY$� .���,���a��Y�'��' �����G$�," � 1�"���. �'#i�����%/�K4

@�"�� ����YY 1�� se/s<pY$� ��@��' "��/� ��� !1#;;"�� ����, " Y$�.

u�� .#G��� �������' X����/����K����(" hs2��$ ��"�,�$�4 ��3#YY$�.�������' ����' ��%���� ��. Y$�.

��3�%�)�(

Page 270: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

270

�� u�� .#G��� "�@��1 y��,)$� ��� ��I?$ ;"�� Y5&' ������='� ;�{)"#�/� J��Q#����I?$ �$��;"���/��)"�iY$� .��� 6�" � �� �-�$� X���

���7�� ��K ����='� �u�� .#G��� 1 ���� m;"�� �,�"� 1##��+&�"�/��?'�����3 �)��A Y$� .��%/�K4 � ��*�6 ��x," )$�#����� 1�U;"���/�*�G���

� `s/s�@��,� �6�+' �� "�����x," �..���� �@�$ �4���)'�S6;7� ����:�� !1#; "�����<�.�/����@����.� �� ��. ����(" %$�4�/��� 1 m

;"�� 0��&)$� �.�����I/�)�� s`j/hs�7�� ����='� ���1##�"��,�.;"�� >�� s[V/Vj�7�� ����='� ;�����?'�Y;"�� I)a/ Vhm/e�7�� ����='� ;�{)"#�/� ��:�1#�"���� ���/�����?'� ��>��: [@��' ���� ��. Y$�.

7� P){(����� �#Q ����G ��� � 9������ �5� )� #��"� 4��� B)�� �� 1��G

1��G 1' W������ o�3 �%'�#$ o�3

� ���/� ��}/�� ��}/��� }��/� ���/� ���/��� ��}/� �}}/� ���/��� ���/� ��}/� }��/�}� ���/� ���/� ���/��� ���/� ���/� ���/��� ���/� ���/� }��/�}

� ��x," �Y$� @���� ��)<�$���, " �����" �����/����" !1#;F�R �Y$�;"���/�0��&)$� ��. ����a)$� ��%<�Q ����� �=��� �/��!"��:��>��)'� ����

�1�" ���.�=��)<�$ �� �;7�6 >��: `@��' ���� ��. Y$�:

Page 271: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

271

7� P )|(1��G W�#$�� �*<m� 1"�K$ B�� �� 4 , n�#O��� ���#Q )� &� ��o� ��

7��� 1��G7��

1��G[�3

1��G[��

1��G[��fQ

1��GC��

1��GC�,

1��GC�*

�} ���/}�� ���/}�� ���/}W�� ���/}�} ���/}� �}�/}

�� ���/}�� ���/}W�� ���/}W�� ���/}W�� ��}/}�� ���/}�� ���/}�� ���/}W�� ���/}�� ���/}�� ���/}�} ���/}�� ���/}�� ���/}�� ���/}�� ���/}�� ���/}� ���/}

�� ���/}�� ���/}�� ���/}

Page 272: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

272

�� ��}/}� ���/}

�� ���/}� ���/}� ���/}

�� ���/}� ���/}

�� ���/}� ���/}

�� ��}/}� ���/}

�} ���/}� ���/}

�� F�3�� ����1�"�=����" ���y��,)$� "���.:

;"�� >�� �1�1#G�� "����R��$ `s�Vj�``�`m�[s�e�[[����"��A#����m>��$ ��;��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y���X��< ��+)<� "��/�.�

$����R��$ ���;"�� @��' ���� �.��#@���$�56� ��"��(,$.�� "����R��$ `s�Vj�``�`m�[s�e#�)� ��e/sY$�.

;"�� �F�� �R��$ `V�`h�`[����"��A#����`>��$ ��;��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y���X��< ��+)<� "��/�.�$����R��$ ���;"�� @��' ���� �.��

���3 �'�)aA ��"��(,$.�� "����/�$>��$ #�)� ��e/sY$�.

;"�� �F�$ �R��$ `o�V��[V�VV�[m����"��A#����e>��$ ��;��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y���X��< ��+)<� "��/�.�$����R��$ ���;"�� @��'

���� �.��g�c '�l4�����"��(,$.�� "����R��$ `o�V�#�)� ��e/sY$�.

Page 273: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

273

;"�� ��?Q�F�R��$ `��`j�hs�[o�`e�[`�[j�Vo����"��A#���� o>��$ ��;��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y���X��< ��+)<� "��/�.�$����R��$

���;"�� @��' ���� �.��F�)!" @���. H��6 ��< ��"��(,$ .�� "����R��$ `� �`j�hs�[o#�)� ��e/sY$�.

;"�� ,4�I( �R��$ j�Vh�[��Ve�Vm�h�[h�����"���#A ��j>��$ �� ;��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y���X��< ��+)<� "��/� .�$����R��$ ���;"��

@��' ���� �.���¶�:���� ���"(,$�.�� � "�� �R��$ j�Vh�)�# ��e/sY$�.

;"�� �I�. �R��$ `�[�V[���V`�V����"��A#����j>��$ ��;��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y���X��< ��+)<� "��/� .�$����R��$ ���;"�� @��'

���� �.��-�56� )6�����y��1�� ���@��J ��"��(,$.�� "����R��$ `�[�V[ ��#�)� ��e/sY$�.

;"�� �I)a/ �R��$ [e�m�Vs�o����"��A#����h>��$ ��;��"�,�$�4 ��3#Y���X��< ��+)<� "��/�.�$����R��$ ���;"�� @��'

���� �.�����l4���)'� ���"�(,$.�� � "�� �R��$ [e�m�Vs�)�# ��e/sY$�.

�( �) )� !��_� �� !"&b�/ �.��� �""&$

�� ��*�6 %/�K4 ���$�� ������ k�' ���J)5��/ �� @�"i�/ �F�� hs2��$ � ��3#�*� �"�,�$�4 � Y�A�'� �� Y��. ���a)$� .�)' ��*� �� ��� @��' S�A�'� �� Y�/ �#�����< �� ��"#-� ��3 �"�,�$�4 ��< � �/#J)5��/ Y�����, " �i( Y.��'

���<�"#)6�� -�56� -��� � y��1�� �� �@��J);"��j.(�*�J)5��/ G��*� ��� YA�'���" ���< � #)6�� -�56� -��� � y��1�� �� �@��J);"��j(�"�,�$�4 �� ��3#��� Y)Vs/sW=r("�" @��' �� �.���*� �/��A�'� �� Y����< � �"#-�

)6�� -�56��� � y��1�� �� �@��J);"��j( ��3 �"�,�$�4 ��#-�C " �c�� Y����, "����� �, �)�� R� � " �N���< �����"#)6�� -�56� -��1�� �� N� � y���N@��J

Page 274: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

274

);"��j( ��3 �"�,�$�4 ��#�*� Y�A�'� �� Y�" � #@�iVs/s�4#�" �����.

1��G ��#� [#� 7� P �"f$������# �!"&b�/

� 1 ��x," �#5a1 � �#���' ��/����' Y$� F�R ���� �/ �/�� F�< ��" �� #$��#@��� ��.�Q��Q � ���� ���" ����' �5�/� Y$� � �/ .� �� ��+�"��" �#F�' �� -�

�" ��'��< ��(,/ ��� ��.��5' B*� �� Y$� ���� �� ��� ��1�" ��B:�" ���A � G$�,"#�,� @� .��� �� Y$� @� G$�," B:�" ���A�"��c," �'�A � �'��1�@� �

��"���. �5)��"�/V`oV .( ���" ���'F��/�7�� ����' ��/�'��"�� F�< �� �/�/�7������1 �" ;�" @��' �� ��.�'��"�� �7�� �,Q ��/���4 �/#��� ���' �� �17�+<��'��� ���3 .� ��1�1 �#" �).�� � G#J'�#���' ��/�" ��� �/ F�< �@��1

*�#�5' Y�� ����� �� �7�� �,Q ��� �&�" �� �� �J)5�� ��J��)�� �� �#�)���'��� �� � Y�5' .>��:VhWh�7�� ��1� � ����'��� �� ����< �"#-��/�

�"�,�$�4 ��3 #�� �"�,�$�4 ;� � Y�" @��' �'��' ���A ��/�.7� P)I(�6$� � [�� 9�#%� 43#� � o�3 ��-�"2�!"&b�/ ������# 1' � �

�6$�� o�3

9�#%� 1��G�

9�#%� 1��G0

�#%� 91��G?

9�#%� 1��GI

9�#%� 1��GN

9�#%� 1��GM

9�#%� 1��G>

1' 9�#%�������#

e VV ` o V` VV Vs j mj Vs Vh e � Vj V` VV m oj [s Vj m VV V� Ve V` o �o `s Vo o V[ [V Vj Vh � Vsm hs [s Vs V` [[ Vm Ve Vs VV[ es [V VV Vh [h V� Vj VV VVj js [` V[ Ve [e [s Vm V[ V[V ms [h V` Ve [j [V Vo V` V[j os [j Vh Vm [o [` [s Vh V`V �s [o Ve Vo `V [e [[ Ve V`o �e `s Ve V� `` [m [` Vj Vhh

Page 275: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

275

dK���"�� ��#"(

� g�/�$�� %/�K4 ����AK��/�@��� (,$� ��3 �"�,�$�4 #� @� �c�� � Y�*��A�'� �� Y�%'�� �� �� c�" �54 @���"�� B#��1 �?. @�)$���. F�('� i.�� =4��:����� �"�,�$�4 �hVj%'�� �a' >��$ @���"��/��?' �� � gl6 G$�,"�' �Y

�"#i(1 ���" -�� !1� �#Y��A���3 ;.

� � r$�4 ���� �� >�z$ ����� ���)�� �� %/�K4 ���" ��i� ���)' �Y$� �����<� �S��:� �� ;7�6��� � �� @�"�� �hVj%'�� ��A ��:� ��"��" @��' ����� �:�1 � �/�

�����' �C,��lA��"�,�$�4 ��3 #2 ���7 � Y#1�C�V2��e"��� �l2 ��.�� 1##��a2� X�� �� @� ���)�����. ���a)$� ���'���

� �� ���a)$� � �� Y$��� ���)�� ����" X�� ���*�6 %/�K4 �� �"�,�$�4 �oh/s�"� Y$� � �� Y$� ��2��3 ���" ���)�� ��Y$� .

���$�� ���� ��� � r$�4� ���$ � ��3 �"�,�$�4 �� >��$ �#;"�� �,Q �� Y !1 X�� �� �Y$� ��. k��.�#�a2�" ;�/� 7� ��. ���a)$� . !1 �� ���a)$� �#;

"���. � �#�"� )" %<�Q ��m� ���. 0��&)$� ;"�� ��m;"�� s`j/hs�� �7�� ����{)" ;� ='�##�1 �� �/�##" ���,� .������ #��� �� @�,����� �� %/�K4 ��i� ��

�*� �� ��� @��' � �. ���a)$� @�"i�/�A�'� �� Y�/ � #�����< �� ��"#-���< � �/�"�,�$�4 ��3 #J)5��/ Y�����, " ����< i( Y.��' �"#)6�� -�56� -����

� � y��1���@��J);"��j.(�*�J)5��/ G��*� �A�'� �� Y����< � �"#-�56� -�)6���� � y��1�� �� �@��J);"��j( ��3 �"�,�$�4 ��#��� Y)Vs/sW=r("��� �.�

" @��'��*� �/��A�'� �� Y����< � �"#)6�� -�56� -��� � y��1�� �� �@��J);"��j( ��3 �"�,�$�4 ��#����, " -�C " �c�� Y���� �.

��:� �� ;�3� !1 # "�� ;��a� ��'��' Y�������� @�"��� ����'� �� ���a)$� � �Y��:� Y 1��� !1 # "�� ;�:�1 #�l4�Y$�� .�1�"� "�� =���� @��' ��:

Page 276: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

276

VW��hs$ >��$ #�" �/�# ��3 -�#�Ym;"�� � >��$ �J)5��/ IC��3�� ���� @��,� �»#��$�56� @� «�. �&�" .�A�Q#i���� �/� �� ��� �D"�� ��# �Y$�

@� �� @�� � ��#����)$��< �� @�"� �/ ��#" ��'��1 #�"�'"�J#��� � ���� ��" ��< � 1 ����!"�,� U#�J �'�3��7 ;��" ��� � � �#�" �C� �Q �� ��,�#$�56� �Q � ��

�����.�.�� �����$ ��� �"� �����1 Y$� �C�" �� ��Q �.��' �'��&�1 �� �� ��< #�3�� ��$�56�N #/� Y$� �� @�)N#� ���. �� Y��(. �#Q @�#i�@�)'��� �� �� ��

"�.� �).��' ��lA#� ������� �� �����/ ������� X��"� ��. � �. �� �'��,Q �� 3�� �#�$�56��.� �).��' #�� ������ � ��,Q �# 3��" ��!+1 �� ��. #�"� ��,.� ���� �#@�

�2��" -�56����� � �� Y$� ���1 �" ��'��1#@� ����J ��#���.#�� -�56� @�'�"����w� "�,� -�56� ��. �� ��.#a���� � ��$�56� @�)'��� �� ���� ���� ��:�

� Y$����,)5/ Y$���' �.,Q ��#)2�6 ��" ��{2 �� ���a)$� � �'��1#���3� y��1�� �1�$�56� � ����� � �� @�)�" �� @��J#��lJ @���.

[W�F�� ;"�� ` � ���� >��$ #�J'�»�)aA �' ���3 «Y$� .�('� ����A�'� �� ����):����� Fi )5" �����" Y�� H��6 I/ �� Y$� �� @� �� ��� H��6 I/ � @��J��

A ���3 �:�1 ���"#�)aA �' ���?" ���C��"�R �� �/����" #A�'� �� ��� Y�+&. ����):��Y$� X� .��� �/��� ����� ��< �� ��������/� � �/�. ����� #A�'� �����

���iA� ��< �����" �� Y$� F�R � Y$� ���� �,� -�56� �� �� � g��/� ������ �/���?" �� ��. �/��< ���� ;C�" ��� >��)6� � �?'� @�. �������/�7�< ����a)$�

� ��< �'��) �1 �,�5" �� �#�$�," ���� �� ��iA� ��< ����� �J' �Y$� ��.@�5'� �����)<� �#/�A� � ������� ." ��< ����� -�$� ���+1 �'��1#I�/���� �A�'� ��.� �).�� .

���+1 �#I5 ����" �� �/#9i: �����/��4 � ��i ����" �#" ;"�. �� Y��� ��'� ���. '�" @��,� �� �� �� �� ��+1 �)<�$#� ���� �� ��< �����!' � ��5" �lA �� #�� ���. �).��� .���,Q#"��3� ��' ���" �)aA �' ���?" #Y$� ��.

Page 277: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

277

`W�F�$ ;"�� e � ���� >��$ #�J'�»g�c '�l4���«Y$� .�DE�" �<� ��:��,):� @�5'� �A�'� �� B'��" �Y$� ��l4�' . �J'�JQ �� �T ���� �� ��� �� � ���<�

�" F�T�' � ����< Y5E. ^. @�� �.� �).��' �/�A� B'��" ����'�" .��� �T Y$�:�1 ;7� �" ��T � ��7 � ���� � B'��" � �������� �� ;�!1 � ��7 �� =4 � ���

@� ��� �� ��� �DE�"g�c '� �/ Y#���" � ��#)$� ��� �� ��� � ��T ��#4 ���l4���' ����/.��� g�c '� ����� �T �'��� ��� � @�$�,�' � "�: �� ����� ���$ � Y�5' ��l4

��? �A�'� �� ��)�# �.� �� @��J�� Y�5' � � �'�����<� ��)�# Y"D$ �� �,"�"�'�. .%,T�� G1��" � ����:� ���##{1 � �DE�" ���" �� ����� ��� �#,��/

G$�," �" @��' ��1Z��� ��� �� � �,/��" ;�!1 ;�3 ��< ��� �� ���.� b���. �'��$ Y$� Z��" ����� ��"� �� ��� �.

hW�F��?Q ;"�� o � ���� >��$ #�J'�»��< H��6 @���. F�)!" «Y$� ."�J,/�" k��� ��< H��6 �� ���,�#� � ��< � B3�� �� ��" �? @��J�/�#� F��)6� � ���� @��J

#"� ��< � Y�5' �)��J'�#i��.A�'� ��'�A � @��� ��/ �� #� ��J���� @��J'�('�'#� I/ � @�"��< I/ �<� Y$� �I�('� �@��J#��/��< ���<#�. I.� �).lA

�� Y$�#� � ���< H��6 �� @��" @��J�H��6 � �� ���"� � � �).�lJ' F��)6� ��. � ��.��)����,,� ."�J,/ �� � ��. �� ��' @��J��A#���)�� �� ��Q �?'� G$�,"�'

1t|#a," ����" ��. � �{1 Y7�� B3�� �� ����lA##" G $ �?'� �� �� uD7� � ��,�#�.�1'�"��� H��6 �� �.� ���C' ª�' �� @��J#��� Z6 ��. ����� ���� �#,� ��#�.

eW�I(,4 ;"�� m � ���� >��$ #�J'�»�¶�:����«Y$� .�¶�: k��� �, � �����< H��6 �� G$�," � �'�3��7 �I#�)5" ��#. � �T %��< ��$�56� � ��E�� @�# � ����. F�('� .�¶�: ������,)5/ ;9�3 F��)6� @��J�� � ��< ��� ��� .� �,)5#' ; a," @�'�

�)$��< � �T ��� ��*�" F��)6� @��J�� ��/��#' � �/��' ���:� ��'��lA @��J�� �,/� � �,,T ���a)$��$ �?'� ���,,T ���3� y��1�� @�'� � �'��/�3 ��#. �.

Page 278: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

278

jW�I�. ;"�� j � ���� >��$ #�J'�»)6�� -�56��� � y��1�� �� �@��J «Y$� .��:�" �@�5'�����):� �Y$� � � ='� � y��1�� �T ����* �� @��J�A�'� ���� ��

" ���.���� .' -�56�#�7 ��.� " � ��#2��/ � �'���/���/ ��� � ���D� �@��J ����T ��E��� : �� �/�A�'� ����):� ��" ���.���' ��������:� H���� �� �)$�<�

Y$� @�5'� . @�5'�N!" �� �±2�1 �� � #b�/�"N" ���3 U )&N�A#��.!" �/#c���'�A�����E. � �.� �� ���/��� )$� �Y$� �|z" @�5'� .k��):��E�� �� �!" �#b�/

�." �������./#'�5'� �N�4 Bc3 � #�/�'��.�A � �'�)$�� N�A#��%"��� -�56� �'��,T .� ���i'����' �#����4 FD$� �T Y$� #Y$� �).�� �� @� �� �� %'��� .@��

�@��J�� � y��1�� �&�@�5'� ��/��� )$� �� �' ���C. ���. .� � �c�� �����@��J+&. ��,/����#D<� � YY$� ����� H.� @�� @�5'� �A/����� � HD<� ��

���):���?'� � ;��� A�'��$� � Z��"�' �r 1 #Gl4������� .

mW�I)a/ ;"�� h � ���� >��$ #�J'�»l4 ���)'����«Y$� .C.�'#l4 �� Y5�X����.� ��� ���)'� I�/ ��)6 �Y5��?' �� ��)," �A� �' �56 Y#)$�� � Y��?�� � �

�����] �x' .g�6 @��� >��3�/�5��" �i.�A ��. � �� @�)1�/��).� �� ��"� �,��.�<��,��� �"� ��� �/��&' � (1 � �Q �/ #���" �)�#�� "�: �� Y"���)'� "���� �

�: ����� �/�#$ �?'� u�� �� ��)a#l4 @D�� ���4 @��,� � � ���Ca1 #�l4�'��'� �� �- "�: �J,/������� �.�J)5��. � ;��1 F�J,/ � @�5'� �� �'��1�' �� ���'��1 �!��/

����" u�c" �" � ���A#� @������ � ��" �#Y"l4���)'����"Y$�� .���!7 ��� #��)5 @���' I/��� � Fi " ��� ������)'��� �A� �� Y$� G$�," ���� ���4 G$�," ��

��@�$� �&. ��" �1��'�� �'��1 "�C1�� �� ��< ���' �� �� � ��� Y� ����)," �� �'����3 � �C�1�'#���� ;� i.'��) �A�#��,Q �#2�!1 ��$ �� �� #�'� �����/���<

Y#���" � ��< � {. � ���� �A�'� �� ��J'� ��#,� ��(���" Y$� ��#J��Q ��/�#��.

��4 �N/�KN�� � %�%'�� � @���"�#$�N'�)���7 Y$� �)��A �.,N������� 1#Il4���%'�� � @� � u�c$ @���"��@�C"� �Jl4�' �#Y5.�?. �� �*�6 %/�K4

Page 279: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

279

��1�Y$� ��. F�('� i.���,����a1 � �:�1 � ���/�J,/�� ����):� ����+)3� ���� 1#I��)���$ � �/�@�C"� �/�?. �l4�' �#Y5.4#" ��?,���� ��.���� # @�,#)��

��A��$ ���)�� � Y�5'���� ����)�� X�� �� ����"���� ���, ���:� �@�"�� ����� '�"� � 7�� ���� �� �1 ��. ���a)$� U )&" ��� ���4 � ���| Z����' @�"�� #�&�" i

��..

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :[j/so/V`�[ �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :Vo/VV/V`�[

�1�2��" X��l4 r��:[o/VV/V`�[

Page 280: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

280

q���� References ����� ��"��? )V`me .(X�� �5���"�¶�: ��/%'�� � ���"�I� @���"� � �'�)$�#� �)<� �¶�:

��#. �� �/��A � ���� �����" ��/ �@�?a7� �?.���� 4 S���3 E ,�� ����,��' �������6b�6b ��8G 4�:���3 ��"�#$ [��G � ���������.

�*���!" ��2D: )V`mj .(X�� �|� �$��Z�"�$ �.��"� � �'�"�� ��/ �'D�� �A�#"�� � ���l4�¶�:�#w ��/��)�� @�"�� ���¶�: ��/��)�� X��"� � ��� ��'�������� #�'3 ���� [��G 4 S���3 E�-� � !"�#$ 4�:���3 ���;��.

�� 5" ����(6 )V`o[ .(�¶�:�i� �����%'�� �� � #+!1 Y���#4 � =a' ����� � X�/i#1 @���"����� ��#f$ 4�:���3 ��"�#$ [��G � ��������� 4 S���3 E ,�� ����,��' ����.

F ����.Y'�£)V��[ .( !���, � ���",)��L�����3 ����� �����P�� � ��!" ���� ������< ��:�1 ��#�$�� ��,���� )V`o[ .(@��?1 :�.� �����)'�.

��)&" �����) " )V`om .(3�P� )�#��X���� �����)'� �>�� P�Q �.

�� 5" ����(6 )V`o[ .(�¶�:�i� �����%'�� �� � #+!1 Y���#4 � =a' ����� � X�/i#1 @���"����� ��3 E ,�� ����,��' ������#f$ 4�:���3 ��"�#$ [��G � ��������� 4 S�.

� ���#6 ��"�/ )[ss` .(������ [��G �3 �%�G B�� !���,@��?1 �:-��4.

� ���#6 ��"�/ )[ssm .(������ �� �3 ����� ]�6����@��?1 �F�$ P�Q �:����1 � � 2�c" @�"��$��J�'�� �'�5'� F� � G)��/)Y�$.(

>� ���� �����'�| .)V��m .(�3#���' ���;���� )�"�/ � ���#6 ��:�1 .(�F�$ P�Q �����)'�@��?1 ��J�'��.

Schimmack J, Radnakrishnan P, Oishi SH, Dzokotov & Ahadis. Culture (2002). Personality and Subjective Well-being: Intergrating Process Models of Life Satisfaction, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 82: 582-593.

Page 281: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

281

�$��� C1;�6 )����B���$ �� )��#-J� ��� �� �$�-"$ Z )-��& ($�6� �� 8��/>?-�� ��������$( �$�-"$ 8 �( $( (;# ��1;�6

���:� �6"bz

4 "SQ >D)<� k�#. @�i#" �'�i� � �:�1�@��� ���)�� ��/%'�� �� ���'�"� @�++&)" �#�t1 � @��

���?" X��"� ��&�|� �$�� �*�6 %/�K4 F�('� �� g�/ �F�J,/��� � <��" � �#&�1 ���/ �)<�,. ��#. � ����):� N�'��' %/�� � ���)��>D)<� ��/��/@��� ���)�� �� ���'

%'���� @���"� .�*�6 %/�K4 X�� Y$� ����"��K4 ��� �� �)�� ��� � u�� u�� �%/�%#4 @�"��N=4�� �/�"�� ��#J#4 � 6�" �#,��/ � >�),� ���A � @�"�� .���"� � "�:

%'�� �"��1 �� %/�K4>D)<� � @�,x" ����N)� I�. � I(,4 ���4 �)<� @���"� ���)�� ��/@��� � #+!1 >�$ �� ���J,2 �?. ���'�[WV`�V�" ;#C�1 �'��� .��� 1`s��� �� �a' %'��

�'��' X�� � @���"��.�< ��#A� 6�"�,Q �� �� ���$ ����+1 ��#. � � �&)'� ����+1 ���'�. �/���: >�),� � %��"�� ���A ��.>D)<� %(,$ �����/@��� ���)�� �/�#$ �� ���'

�. ���a)$� ���� ���)�� .���?" X��"� �"�'� ����):� ��/�C2�� �� ��Vm��" � �5 : �����A �9��� %��"�� ���A ����� ��� ��" �.���� ;# !1 Y?:B�: ��/ @�"�� �� ��. ����

����'� ='������� ;# !1�. ���a)$� ��C" ��#A .���� ;# !1 �� �� ��� @��' %/�K4 ��� ��/=4 � 6�"�'��' @�i#" �� �>�),� � %��"�� ���A �� �# ���#J#4 � @�"��>D)<� ��/ ��/

��)��@��� ����� ��:� ����, " ���a1 ���' .X��"� @�� �|z" � �:�1 ����?" ����):� ��/�'��' %/�� ��>D)<� ��/@��� ���)�� ��/%'�� ���'�" �����, �@���"� X�� ��� �� @��1

�"�'� ��,� �����' ���a)$� -���" ��$� ��/.� "�' ��(h��:>D)<�@��� ���)�� ��/��'�����?"����):� ��/ ���� �)<�,. ����N���)�� .

1N@��: @��J�/�K4 ��J.� ���E,1 �6�� ���� ��J�'�� ��,#2� �$�,�'��� �.�� �$�,.��T Email:[email protected]

Page 282: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

282

�� 2�

�2�� � @����� %,����;"�� � ���1 � X���4 Y?: F�R Y#��� �>�!1 ��'�C"� ���1Y$� � �)5��. ���7�" I/��� �� �R��� ���1� � ������$ .�)# 3�� �"� @�++&)" �T

v��T �@�@���� �'��� ��� Y$� �T��T ��N/I/ �N,'�" @�T ��' >�!1 @�,Q �,�����a1 �/�. @�,��1 ����� @����� >�!1 @���: �� ��� � �a#� ��!2 �� ���� ��/I��.

�<� ��@�T��T ����� ���$��' ��' ��,/� ��5: �>D)<� ����� �J�� �<� ��/N �'�(#/ �,)5/ ���)�� �TB'�" ��>�!1 � #�� �?'� ��,: ����/ . U )&" ��)<�,

� ����):� ��a��� ���)�� �"��..���� @�,T�1 ��,�a )&" ��/ >D)<� ��� ��/���)�� ���7 �)��A Y$� .�� ��@��J�/�K4 >D)<����)�� ��/ ���� � �)$���i >D)<���/ ���)�� @������'V)�A��5��[��c*� k��'� ��/`(�>D)<� ��/

@�� ���)�����'h)��)��@�'�3 �'��J.�<�4 ��)�� � �,C. (����' I#5�1�'� )� ���,<�R��C$�e�[ssV.(

>D)<���/ @��� ���)�����' �)��A��� � ��� ��< @��� �� ��$�$� �� �1DC�" �'��� ���3�" ���� ��< @�. ����� � �(," � �'�. � 7� �)5/ �?'� >D)<� Z < ��

@�(#/ Y$�)�J��� � �C��)$�j�[ss`��),# � �" �m�[sse .(�'��' ��� �$�,.>D)<�-�56� ��'�#A��� ���2�w �/���,� �����6 ��/ �-�1 ������� �����):� ��#A

Y$� �"i" ���'� � Iw ��6 �� %# �J)5�2�)��J# $ � @�?'���o�V��m .( >�!1���'��1@��� ���)�� �DC�" %��i�� Y � ���� �)<�,. ��/�� �� ���' @�"�

���'��1 � ���� ��#)$� �Y$� ��. �)5'���" ���3 �� �� �)<�,. ��/ �1 ���$��c*� � �a," ��/������%#4 � ����� ��� � �� ��>�#< � �� � �,� �,# �� �����4

�����] �?'� ���")��)'��[ssm .(

2- Depression 4- Externalizing behavior disorders 6- Stricker & Widiger 8- Rosenhan & Seligman

1- Internalizing behavior disorders 3- Anxiety 5- Achenbach & Rescorlar 7- Mc clintock 9- Rosenhan & Seligman

Page 283: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

283

@�i#" k�#. >D)<���/ @��� ���)���� ���' �T��T >D< �,"�� ���# �� e�1[s �7�� �#�&1 Y$� ��. ���)� 5T ��@���E�/ [sse@�� � �:��� ��C5a'�A �

�)��V�[sse�#a / ��,#4 �=��� � @�5 ' �I#/ N �� ��#)$�[�[ss� ������Q ��5"�� ��#)$�`�[sVs(>D)<� ��� �� �?:�1 ;�3 �7�� @��J�/�K4 �� �<� ���)�� � �� ��/

>�$ �1 � >�!1 >�� ���" �����4 �2�5A�i ��/ ��/�"�#4 � �,'�"@��� ��� ��� ����" ����/ � �'���);#a�/ � @�5"�$ ����h�[ssj ��'� �[ssm .(��D� ��R� k�#.

>D)<���/ @��� ���)������' �T � "�� Y#�/� �$�� ��� >D)<��/���" �)�# ��,TY$� ��� �T��� �DE�" ��lA �,)5#' ��#$ �)$�#4 ��� ���(" >D)<� ����/��|�

���� �1�" �%,T u�c$��� ����)�� ��'��5: �)<�,. �@�T��T �'�(#/ ���:�" �'��lA)���5�� ���,T ��"�)4e�[ss[��@�$��/ �'��� ��� #1j�[sse ��>��,T

� � �����$� ���'D� ������$m�[ssh �i'�: � =����� �¡������ ��� To�[ssm (��� >��)6� Y��?' D)� ���$�>D)<�@��� ��/�)<�,. ���" %��i���,/� )� ^��,2��

�,#T��V��h�U2���� v�DT �Vs�[sss .(

G w� @�T��T �@�'��:�' >D)<� � D)�"��/ @��� ���)�����'����� ���$�56���� �a," �@��J�� � ���)��� �"�,,T .���)�# �����" @�� " ��$DE�/��/ @�'�

�� ��� �"�,,T ���Y7�� �(#)'��/ �.��"� @�'� %/�T �"���)�$ ���� � �52�N,#5��VV�[sVsi��" �V[ �[sse���)5��Q �V` �[sse.(��� ��x," �N �����N, ��

%'��>D)<� �� k�' ��� � D)�" @���"�Y# 3�" ��/ �� �/ Z��" -�� -D� ��/���?" ��� ��,.� ����* ����):� ��/@R�5�/ � @�� " ����x)'� �)<�$ ������ ���

�,.� ���� ��)��,1 � @�� �� #" ���#4 ��(��/ ��,#"��Vh �[sso .(�N" �1��� �"�A ��@��1

2- Pine, Helfinstein, Bar-Haim & Nelson & Fox 4- Bayer, Sanson & Hemphill 6- Hudson, Deveny & Taylor 8- Colman, Wadsworth, Croudace & Jones 10- Rudolph, Dennig & Weisz 12- Mize 14- Cumming, Higgins, Pierce, Miller, Boone &Tandy

1- Garnefski, Kraaij & Van-Etten 3- Ramsawh, Chavira & Stein 5- Essau, Conradt & Peterman 7- Kendall, Safford, Flannery, Schroder & Webb9- Ollendick & King 11- Bruyan, Cillessen & Wissink 13- Christopher

Page 284: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

284

���"� ��#'� �� �� ���' u�c" �#,Q��#. ��#A��� �@��J�� � ���<� G$�," ��/� ����� ���$ � y��1�� ����3�y��1�� �� ���?" �).�� � � ��� � ��� ���� �# ��/ Y$� ����* Z��" �A�'�)@D4�� � Y$� ����)$�V�[ssm .(>�$ �� �� @�,Q ��/

���?" �#|t1 �$�� �#<�X��$ ��/��)�� ��� � ����):� ��/�,#"� �� �C� �)��� ��/Y$� %/�K4 ���'.%/�K4 �� �)$� ��� ��x' ��J)$�< ?a" �/���?" F� ����):� ��/

@�5)" �,'�" �a )&" @���!" b$�1 �� Y$�[)V�o` (���#2� � F�.�A`)V��� (�Y$� ��. ��?,�#4���?"��/ ����):�h����(" G2�3 �� ��/��)�� �)<�"� ��.����

Y$� ��. �)��A �x' �T��� �����3 �"� ���$ @��J�� �c�� %&�|� �).�� �����/��)�� "�'>�� ����):� ������< ����'.���?" ��� @�� ���� Y# �3 �>D�)$� �/

X��$ ��� � ��#�& ���? �� �A�'� � c" Y#a#� � �X��l4 � ����):� �J)���%,��,)5/ I?" ���� ��(,? ��� .���?" ��� �� �� ���'��1 � ��� �� ����):� ��/

Y#2� � �� Y����" � ���� ��#A��� �@����/�" �#|t1 �A�'� >�� �� �!��a1 ����lA .���?" �� ���$��'Y# �3 � �/ ��/�"�#4 � @�. �:��" � �(," �G$�," ����):� ��/

��$��" �� 0��<� ��#��4 � #+!1 ��C �N� �@R�5�/ b$�1 @�. ��� �N,'�" �a,"�.�A>D)<� ��?� Y��?' �� � Y��,: � F�: ���#A�" �)<�,�'��� ��/ ��.)�#56

����i'�<V`�[.(

��? Y#�/����?" �� ��,"X��$ ��/��)�� ��� �� ����):� ��/>�$ �� ��)�����/ �c#6 ��� �� � "t1 ;�3 ��/����)$� ����� ���< � @��J�/�K4 �:�1 G : � �#<�

� �Y$� �����A%/�K4 S��)' �� ���� �"�'� �9��� �#J��Q �#|t1 �� �'����� ��/X��"����?" >D)<� @�"�� � ��� @�i#" %/�� �� ����):� ��/@��� ���)�� ��/���'

���� Y��C6 .�� @�,Q�$�C5���C$��4 � ��Re)[sV[(� ;# !1��� � 2�c" �� �� ���?N" X��"� k�*�">DN)<� � @��D)�" � ����):� ��/ �7�,� � �C.i]N'��� ��/

2- Matson 4- Social Skill

1- Stewart, West & Coplan 3- Gresham & Elliott 5- Vyskocilova & Prasko

Page 285: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

285

>�" ���)�� � �,)�" �'�"�� ��� � �y���" ����):� Y���1 � �6D7� ���<�� ����$���?" X��"� �� �,)��� Y$� �(#)'>D)<� %/�� Y?: �� �|z" �"�A ����):� ��/��/

>D)<� �,'�" �C.i]'�����/X��$ >D)<� ��J)����'Y$� ���c*� � �� < ��/ .�������� � @�� �F�.�AV)[sso (���?" X��"� k�*�" � ;# !1��� �� �� ����):� ��/

>D)<� � D)�" @����� ��'�(#/ ��/NS��)' ;"�. �� ���)�� mm�� � 2�c" >�$ ��/V��s �1 [ssj Y$� ����):� �J)5��. �� ���? �Y��. �� @�A�,,�

����'� �#J'�#" � �%/�K4 �|� `[/s�,)��� Y$� .�" �#,��/ [)[ssj (;# !1��� �� �J�����?" X��"� ��&�|� >D)<� @�"�� �� �� ����):� ��/ ����)�� N �'�(#/ ��/

����'� �#J'�#" � �|� `e/s��� @��' .-���" �� �#2��)$� �"�'� ���:� � i#' X��"� ��/"���?��/ ����):� ��� %'��� �@���"��� I?" ��"��3� �� �C� @��,� Y?: ��#J�#4 �� F��3� ���T��< ����� � T F�� Y#���" ���" �#�t1 ��A�'� ��.)�2��`�

[ssj(.��� � @�� �F�.�A)[ssj (���?" ��/�K4 �� @��,� � �� ����):� ��/%'�� ��� ��iJ��: ��/��)��@���"��'��� ��?,�#4 �c< �� " �� .���?" ��� �?'� �/

�� ��V[>D)<� � D)�" @�'��:�' � @����� � �)a/ �'��� I# 1 ���)�� N �'�(#/ ��/ .���?" ���Y$�� �I�< ��?" ;"�. �/�� �|z" y��1�� � ��:� ���� ���� .@���4 ��

���� ;# !1 �� =4 X��"��� �,)����� @��J�/�K4 ��/���?" X��"� � ����):� ��/��� ��/�#{)"� �).�� �)��" �#|t1 ��. ���� �3��c'� ������ � �,)5'��1 ����� ��� ��

�,�� Y$� ��$�,".��"��� �a��.)V`�s (�#|t1 �$�� � ����"�� ��/�K4 �����?" X��"�X��$ � ���)�� N �)<�,. ��#. � ����):� ��/%'�� �J)������"� @

%#4 u�� � �54 ��,#�'=4 N @�"��Y<���4 >�),� ���A � @�"�� .=4 %/�K4 ��� �����?" �.��"� �"�'� �9��� ����#" ���)�� N �)<�,. ��#. � ����):� ��/ S��)' �F�

����?" X��"� ��&�|� �J'�# ��"� Y$�X��$ ���? �� ����):� ��/ �J)���%'���54 ��,#�' @���"��� .�#56 � ��xN' ��4)V`om (��/�KN4 �� u�� � ����"��

2- Magg 1- Cook, Gresham, Kern & Barreras 3- Fuller

Page 286: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

286

%#4=4 � @�"�����?" ��&�|� �$�� � ����A ���A � @�"�� � ����):� ��/%'�� ��< Y"�6 � ��c*��,)<���4 � �w� @�)$�#� @���"� .2�c" ��� S��)' @��' �

���?" X��"� �� ���%'�� ��< Y"�6 %��i�� � ��c*� %/�� �� ����):� ��/@���"� Y$� ��� �|z" %��"�� ���A.� ")V`oj (@��,� � �� ��/�K4"���?" X��"� �#|t1��/

>D)<� %/�� �� @�)$�� �� ���a)$� � ����):�%'�� ���)�� N �'�(#/ ��/ �)<� @���"�I�/� @��1 �#,$ �,V`�1V�@��?1 �?. >�$ "��� F�('� .��. %/�K4 ��� �� �����"���s%'�� I� �)<� ��"�>D)<� ����� �,/� @��1 ����+1 ��#. � � �&)'� ���)�� ��/

���A �� ��he�'�. ��iJ��: >�),� � %��"�� ��a' .%��"�� ���A ���m�5 : ���?" X��"� ��x," � � <��"�):� ��/�a2z" �� @�)$�� �� ���a)$� � ��� �,'�" ���/

X��$ � �A��5�� ���c*��. F�('� ����):� �J)����' .�� ��� @��' S��)' @���4 �� %/�� �����, " ��� � >�),� ���A � Y�5' %��"�� ���A ���)�� N �'�(#/ �DC�"

Y$� �)��� .�"��#)V`oo (@��,� � ��/�K4 ��"?" X��"� �#|t1��� � ����):� ��/%#4 � ����):� Y��a��a2z" -�$� � � #+!1 Y���#4 ���##{1 �,# Y��a� ��/

����):� "���?" X��"� �"�'� �� �� ����):� ��/V[X��"� �%��"�� ���A � �5 : Y$� ���� .���?" X��"� �� Y$� ���� @��' %/�K4 S��)' ���? ��� ����):� ��/

�a2z"�,'�" ���/Y9�: �X�J' %��"�� ���A �� ��"������< � �A�#,1 Y����" �����Y$� ��. .%/�K4 � �2��:� ���" � �����,B�: �� �� ���. F�('� ��/ � � ��,

��" �x'Y?: �$� %/�� �'��'��/ >D)<�@��� ���)�� ��/��#J�#4 ����' ���"i" @�. ���� �2��)6� k��'� >D)<���/ �����/X��$ ��/��)�� %��i�� � �)������? ��D"� 1 ���?" X��"�>D)<� � D)�" ����� � ����):� ��/ ��/ ���)��@���Y$� u�c" ����* �� @��,� � ����'.

���?" X��"� ���X�� @����� � ����):� ��/���� ��:� ��� )" ��/ .�� �C�X��X�� ����� � i���)" ��J'�"�� ��/�/�)<�,. �NY$� ���)�� .>��� � P�$

)V��h (��� ��� -�$� Y<�,. ��/�,���� �.�]�/ �� �� ����)��C��(U���� �)@�(#/�/(��)�� �)>���� (���� ���3 �:�1 ���"�'�.��� ����)$� � � <��" �� ����X�� �� �� �/

Page 287: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

287

�" �&�"Y$� ��)�� �'��� I#x,1 � �#�t1 �?'� �� �� ��. .��#. �� �C���� �� �/���� �)<�,. N���?" X��"� ��� ���)����" �����):� ��/��AVY$� )-� � ��#2�[�

V��V .(�����' Y���6 ��#. ��� �� �� �1� 2�c" ��:� � � � ��� �'� )� � 4� ��"�R����/`�[sse� 5'�A �h�[sseY#2�� �N�# � �$��Q � ���,: NX��e�V��V����, �j�V�mm�'�/�" �m�V�mm(�" �x' � �"� ��:�1 ���" ���� ����'� � ��#. ��� �� �$�

��" ��#. �� ���a)$� � ��� ���#�!1 � �)��J' ���3 @���!" � @�++&)" ���7 ��A%/�K4 F�('� ������, Y$� �)��A @����� ����* �� @��,� � Y$� ��� �� ���/

Y$� u�c" .J�� �)C'���?" X��"� �#|t1 �� Y$� � p5" ��� � �:�1 �����):� ��/>D)<� %/�� �@��� ���)�� ��/ ��. ������ ���' � ��#J#4 ���� �� �� ����'

Y$� .X��"� �#|t1 �$�� g�/ � �*�6 Z#�!1 �� ��� �����?" ��#. � ����):� ��/ �)<�,.N�'��' %/�� � ���)�� >D)<� ��/��/@��� ���)�� Y$� ��. F�('� ���' .

B��

� 2�c" �� �*�6 %/�K4Y$� ����"�� .%#4 u�� �%/�K4 ��� �� �)�� ��� � u��@�"�� N=4�� �/�"�� ��#J#4 � 6�" �#,��/ � >�),� ���A � @�"�� .%/�K4 ��� ��

���?" X��"���c*� � ;�)5" �#{)" @��,� � ����):� ��//A � �A��5���.���#A /��. �)��A �x' �� �)5�� ��/�#{)" @��,� � �A��5���'� .

" }#b ��3�%�W g ���)��#":" ��a#� � 7#��' 4�#( �� ���)� �#":" W ���)� 12�;� #"+�� " ���)� ^�O��� 4�#(�

T3T2XT1RE%��"�� T3T2WT1RC>�),�

2- Busse 4- Gansle 6- Bandura 8-

1- Coach 3- Lorman, Deppler & Harvey 5- Collet-Klingenberg & Chadsey-Rusch 7- Mahoney

Page 288: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

288

B�� � ���%� E�&��P���%��#"( %'�� �"��1 �� %/�K4 ���"� � "�: � @�,x" ����)� I�. � I(,4 ���4 �)<� @���"�

>DN)<�@��� ���)N�� ��/� #+!1 >�N$ �� ����J,2 �?. ���' �[WV`�V ;#CN�1 �"�'��� .�'��' X�� �� %/�K4 ��� ���.�< ����+1 ��#A� 6�"�,Q �� ���a)$� ���. .i��" � �w �H�. ��,: �>��. �'�J(,4 �6��' �# �� ��)� �� �� ���7 ��� �

��?.[�Z��," ��� �� ��:�" -���" �# �� =]$ � �. �&)'� g��+1 � ��c," j1 � i#' �$��"�. ���iA� g��+ .���2�� ��#)<� �� ���� ���)�� �/�#$ Y$�?�

%'�����4 @���"� -���" ��� I�. � I(,4 ��/)`[o �a' (Y��A ���3 .�� =4 Y��?' ���"�,�$�4 ;#�C1>D)<� X� ���' � �:�1 � � �/@��� ���)�� ��/ �/�#$ �� ���'

��c*� ��� ���� ���)��/�A��5��)�(�.�A ���#A/�A��5��)e(��� 1 �`s�a' �'�. �/���: >�),� � %��"�� ���A �� �� g��+1 � � �&)'� .

4)� �� ����U���#"(

�3�' ������ ��"�:�� u�� ��� ������ ���)�� �/�#$VF�� ����(" �� �����" ��/�. ���a)$� ���,<� .��� >D)<� F���'�(#/ ��/N���A �� �� ���)�� ,�����/

@��� ���)�� �DC�"@�� ���)�� �DC�" ����N' ������ �DC�" ���N$ � ���N'�" �,�)�R��C$� � ���,<�[ssV .(

B"�: � ���1������4 �� �C� ���� ���)�� �/�#$ � %(,$ ��/��i� ���1>D)<� �#&�1� ����� ��/�" ���.� �2��3 ;�3 ���)�� � ����� �� �� ��� �����<

Y$�)�'���'�� �F��)$���)$� � F��)$�[�[sse .( Y# �: �� @�"�� ��� �����(,/ �� ��� �'��� �'�5�/ G��* ��'���� �DC�" -�#�"@��� ���)�����' � ��� oj/s

)��c*�/�A��5��me/s�.�A ���#A/�A��5��m`/s(�. X��iA .���"���� ���)��)���# � 7��e�1o�)a/ (�c$ �� �J)5��/ G���* ��N/ �� ��� @��' i#'se/s����, "

2- Youngstrom, Youngstrom & Starr 1- Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL)

Page 289: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

289

�,)5/)��9�,#"V`�s .( -�#�" ��� ��'��� �'�5�/ G���* %/�K4 ��� �� -�#�" �DC�"@��� ���)�����' � ��� mm/s)��c*�/��A��5� ms/s�.�A ���#A /�A��5��

j`/s(�. ��$�!".

�� ��#P� 4�",:�� HD<� >�7� Y���� � ���(" G5� � �J,/��/ F�('� �� =4���?" X��"� �"�'� �%/�K4 �� �� ����):� ��/Vm@�'�� �� ��" �� ��" � �5 :

�. F�('� @�'��:�' � @����� ��C� X���4 .�� ��#A� : ��x," � �@�"�� �'�?A�' Bc3�5 : �� �� � �)a/ �� ���� �� �)a/ �$ �� ��)a/ �� �� �$ �>�� �)a/ �$ �� �� �/

�. ��iA� �)a/ �� �5 : �� �'���4 �)a/ .���?" �$�� �"�'�@����� �|z" ��/�C2�� V

)V�o`(;"�. �� ����?" @��� �/���/ �;"� 1 ����3� �-�� -D� � y��" ��/� � @��J�)@��J�� � X��$(Y$�� ����?" Y��?' �� � ���� ��" ��/���Y$�

�. ���� X��"� .��� �� ���a)$� � �"�'� ��� �)<�,. ����N���)�� )��" ��#.��A ()�>��� � P�$V��h(� 6�" �$ �� �� �

WX��"� ���?" ���C1 � ����1 ��"D� ��/,#"� �� �'���&54 �9��� � �/ F�('� ����?" �. ���� X��"� �/)�-� � ��#2�V��V .(

>�� �5 : :�"�'� �7�,� � ���,.�)Y��. ���"�"�'� �Q��Q � @�A�,,� ) .(he��#3� (F�� �5 : :y��1�� F�?a" � �)<���4)X�� �U�� 1@� ��/������ � y��1�� ����3� ��/ .(

)js��#3� (F�$ �5 : :B�:F�?a" ��,���?" � � � ���,.� =]$ � y��1�� -D� � y��" ��/

-�� ) .he��#3� (F��?Q �5 : :���?"���?" � �)<���4 �-�� -D� � y��" ��/ @��� X�A )�U�� 1

���?" �2��" �� � ���,.� �@�#,. � @��� X�A �# ���a1 @��,� � ��#J#4 � �:�1 ��/���?" �� Y�53 ��@��� X�A ��/>� � ) .(js��#3� (

I(,4 �5 ::�"��� ���?"��/ � y��" -D� �)<���4 �-�� � ���?" �� Y���� ����)$�

1- Walker

Page 290: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

290

I ")���#4 F�i2 @�"��#4 �! �I " G'�: �� ��)$� �9��� ���,��� Zc," ����1 �U�� 1I " ��)� � �/�a. ����)$� ��) .(js��#3� (

I�. �5 : :������?" �"���?" � �)<���4 �-�� -D� � y��" ��/ ��� ���)? �9��� );� 2���)$� �� ���#4 @�"��#4 �! �U�� 1 ����" ���$�,. ��).�' �i#��4 � I " ��/

��� ���)? �9��� � �|z" �a," � Y��") .(js��#3� (I)a/ �5 : :���?" � �)<���4 �-�� -D� � y��" ���?" �"��� �����" �� ���#4

-�� -D�)F�i2 � ���, ��� Zc," @�"��#4 �! �-�� -D� �#'��3 ���$�,. �U�� 1�" �#'��3 Y���� � �(," �� �����" @�"��#4 �! �-�� -D� �#'��3 ¢��:� � ���A

�" -�� -D� �#'��3 ���:� �� >D<� � U * ��� �� �����" �#,��/ ����A���&54 � �)<���4-D� �����" Y���� F�� � Y���� �') .(js��#3� (

I)�/ �5 : :B�:���?" ��,���?" � � � ���,.� � -�� -D� � y��" ��/ ��/;"� 1 ����3� �$�$�) .@�"� :he��#3� (

I?' �5 : :���?"�#w y��1�� ���?" � �)<���4 �;"� 1 ����3� �$�$� ��/ �"D�)�#w y��1�� U�� 1D��a2z" � �)<���4 �@� ��/������ � �" ��"D��#w y��1�� ��/

@� �#5a1 �� @�. �'��1 � @� @�� � ���,.�) .(js��#3� (I/� �5 : :���?" �"���;"� 1 ����3� �$�$� ��/ :���?" � �)<���4 ��2�C" ��/

)���?" @�"��#4 �! � ���,.� @��� X�A ��/)F��?Q �5 : �2��:� ���"(���?" ���/Y�' Y���� � ��2�C" �"��� ���'��1 �@��� r$�4) .(js��#3� (

I/���� �5 : :B�:���?" ��,���?" � ���,.� � ;"� 1 ����3� ��/ y��" �$�$� ��/@��J�� � �/���/ �) .he��#3� (

I/����� �5 : :���?" � �)<���4 @��J�� � X��$ ��/)� X��$ F�?a" U�� 1�����3 � �� �D�: � ��� � Z#3� �&)'� F�i2 ���,��� Zc," ����1 �@� ��/�����

@�"��#4 �! ������" �� ���#4 ;�R� @�"��#4 �! �� c" y��1�� �� ��#. ��/ @��� =�2 �#!7)�'�)$�� =�2 � ����):� =�2 (F�#4 �@� ��/) .js��#3� (

I/�i#$ �5 : :B�:���?" ��,�/���/ ��/���?" � � � ���,.� =]$ � @��J�� � ��/ Y$����� ) .he��#3� (

I/���?Q �5 : :���?"Y$�� ��/Y$�� F�?a" U�� 1 ���� ����1 �@� �$�!" � ���

Page 291: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

291

%#4 �@��� �#(�1 � U�� 1 �@�� �,&�2 ��)$��� �/�� F�i2 ���,��� Zc," �� @�. F�3@��� ���� � �)$��) .js��#3� (

4 �5 :I/�i'� :B�:���?" ��,Y$�� ��/���?" � � � ���,.� =]$ � ��� ��/� ��"��) .he��#3� (

I/�i'�. �5 : :���?"� ��" ��/ ���,��� Zc," ����1 �@� ��/������ � U�� 1 ������?"� ��" ��/>����4 �� ��#A� : ��� �� ��< B*��" �'����� @�# � ��< H��6 @�.

# b����X�� ��� " ������ ��" ���a)" ��/��) .js��#3� (I/�a/ �5 : :B�:���?" ��,� ��" ��/��) .he��#3� (

%'�� k��(" �����A �� �� �/ @���"� � �� �� ��� �$ >�),� � %��"�� ��/%#4 @��,�=4 @��,� � �� �� �@�"�� � ��"�� Y.lA �� =4 i#' �<� �� � @�"��

��,)��A ���3 ������ ���" ��#J#4 � 6�" @��,.���� ;# !1 Y?: �� ��"� Y$� ��/�<�. �� �a#7�1 %& ����,)$� %& �� � ����'�)$� g��!'� � �#J'�#" ��'����� ��/

@�"�� ������'� ='������� ;# !1�. ���a)$� ��C" ��#A .

������

�a1 ��:� � �,�" %/�K4 �#*�� �$�� ������A @�#" �� �� �%/�K4 �'�A�� ��/>D)<� %/�� �,#"�@��� ���)�� ��/����'� ='������� ;# !1 @�"�� �� ����' ��#A

�. ���a)$� ��C" .Y��. ���A �� �;# !1 ��� �� %/�K4 �� ��,,�)� %��"�� ���A>�),� (��# ;"�� @��,���c*� ��/�#{)" � �'��"��/�.�A � �A��5����#A/

%#4 � 6�" �� �A��5��� @�"��=4 � 6�" �� � X��]�/ �#{)" @��,� ��#J#4 � @�"���'�. �)��A �x' �� �'��"�� @��� ;"��� @��,� � .�<�. �$�� � ��)� �a#7�1 ��/

>��: �� %/�K4 �'��'VY$� ��. �)<���4 .

Page 292: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

292

7� P)�(��� #"+�� �3 7#��' � ���)� 4�#( �*"o�$ �� ���,78���3 ������ ��3�%�

" ���)� W ���)� �#":" �#"+�� 1a�#� Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD

>�),� m`/�m�/s[m/Vsom/V�`/Vse`/V ��c*�/�A��5�� %��"��e`/�jh/sos/eVh/[ss/ees/[>�),� m`/ems/shs/j`e/Vhm/jsj/V �.�A��#A/�A��5��

%��"���`/eoo/shm/`[h/V[m/`[o/V>�),� �`/Veho/Vjj/Vjj`/V[s/Vm�`/V >D)<����)�� ��/

@������' %��"��hj/Ve`e/V[j/�m`/[[j/o`�/`

>��: S��)'V�" @��' ���a1 �%��"�� ���A ��� � <��" �"�'� �9��� �� =4 �/���c*� �#J'�#" �� ���C.�/�.�A � �A��5����#A/��� %��"�� ���A �� �A��5

=4 � 6�" �� >�),�� ����� ��:� ��#J#4 � @�"����c*� �#J'�#" �� ���� /=4 � 6�" �� � <��" Y����� �� =4 %��"�� ���A �A��5�� � @�"��os/e� 6�" �� �

� ��#J#4eY$� �)��� %/�� .�.�A �� %/�� ��� �'����#A/;�3 i#' �A��5��Y$� ��/��" .�>D)<� �#J'�#" �##{1 �'�� ��� �����' �@��� ���)�� ��/ ���A ���'

%#4 ;6��" �� �� >�),� � %��"��=4 �@�"��Y$� ��. ���� @��' ��#J#4 � @�"��.

Page 293: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

293

���a1 Z#3� �$�� Y?:����'� ='������� ;# !1 @�"�� �� ���. ��/��" ��/ ��#A >��: �� @� S��)' �� �. ���a)$� ��C"[AY$� ��. X��i.

7� P)0(x���� �o8� 1"�K$ 4)� �� W�������'78��� 1��G ��#� �#S� �#"(������ �����3 3�%�

9�#@� #""+$ q���� �P�3�3�)� F~.����3��&� ��c*�/�A��5�� V[VV/[Vh�/s

��c*�/�A��5�� ���A V�s`/[Vss/s@����'��"��

�c< [m���A VVe�/hjsss/s �#�'��"�� �c< [m

�.�A��#A/�A��5�� V[oe/se�o/s�.�A��#A/�A��5�����A V[os/sjsV/s

@����'��"��

�c< [m���A VsoV/ejsss/s �#�'��"�� �c< [m

c�/c<P

Page 294: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

294

�<�. �H�� >��: �� ��. X��iA S��)' � �:�1�F��. ��/��" �����, " �c$ ������c*�/�A��5��)sss/s=P�Ve�/hj=F(�.�A ���#A/�A��5��)sss/s=P�soV/ej=F(�" @��'���A �# �� �/����� ��:� ����, " ���a1 �/ .�" �����, @��1

� �,�" %/�K4 �#*�� � Y$� ��� �|z" � <��" �� Y��A �(#)' X��"� ��&�|����?"��� � ����):� ��/� N �)<�,. ����>D)<� %/�� � ���)���/@��� ���)�� ���'

Y$� ��. �)���l4 .�)��� �#,��/ �� �.�' ��. ��(�� ���|� ��� @��' �*�6 �#*�� ��/=4 ;6��" �� � <��"�,).�� �)�| �'�� @�"� Y.lA � ��#J#4 � @�"��.

��"�� � dK��#"( ���?" X��"� ��&�|� �$�� g�/ � �*�6 %/�K4��):� ��/��� � �� ����

�)<�,.N�'��' %/�� � ���)�� >D)<� ��/��/@��� ���)�� %'�� �� ���' @���"��. F�('� .���� ;# !1 S��)' X��"� �� ��� @��' %/�K4 ��� ��/���?" ����):� ��/

��� �N �)<�,. �����'��' %/�� �� ��|z" X�� ���)�� ��c*� ��//� �A��5���.�A�#A�/Y$� �A��5��.%/�K4 S��)' � %/�K4 ��� S��)' ��/ ��"��� �a��.

)V`�s(��#56 � ��x' ��4)V`om(�� ")V`oj(�"��# �)V`oe(��$�C5�� � ��R �C$��4)[sV[(�@���C�/ � ���)[sso(������� � �$�" �>��/V)[sso(��"

)[ssj(���'�'�/[)[ssj (��� � @�� �F�.�A �)[ssj (�Y$� �5�/ ��� �"��1 ��%/�K4���?" X��"� ��&�|� � �/>D)<� %/�� � ����):� ��/ ���)�� ��/

@���Y$� ��. ���.� ���' .

@�,Q���?" �� U * �'��� @���� ��. F�('� �� 2�c" �� �� ��� �����):� ��/�.�A � �A��5�� ���c*� � )5"%,��� ��: � �(#)' �� � ���� ��#A � G$�,"

��/������ �A�#,1� �J)a.� � ��� �N" @��' %,��� �?'� � %���1�/� .�>�� " ��� ���?" �� U * ;#N2� � ��N� �� �'�"�y��1�� da6 � ����N3� �N ���3 ����):� ��/

2- Hernandez 1- Harrell, Mercer & DeRosier

Page 295: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

295

��' � c"a.� ��Q� �'�(#/ ��!2 �� �.��" ��#4 ���5�� Z < � ��. �J)�,�.�����, G#$� ��:� � �:�1 �@��� ��/�.�A � �A��5�� ���c*� �,'�" �)<�,.� ���#A �x'

�"��,/����� ��/��)�� ��?" X��"� �$����,� � ��� �,'�" ��#A)������[ss`(�"�A �X�"�< �� c" ��/��)�� Y���1 Y?: �� �|z"��/��)�� @���X��$ Ix' � �)����'�/�

%'�� �'�(#/Y$� @���"� .

�"�'� ��&�|� �##�1 ��"���?"����):� ��/ "�'��' %/�� ��>D)<� ��/ ��/@��� ���)��%'�� ���'G6�7 � @�a2z" �@���"� ��J'�"�� @�,� �'��) " ���#5 @��x'

����?" X��"� �"�'� �� �)�� ���X�� �����):� ��/�," ���?" ���? ��� ��$ ��/�'��' ���? �#,��/ � ����):� � ����1���.�A � �A��5�� ����c*� ��/ Y$� ��#A

)�" ��Q��� � ��/ ���p2V�[ss� .( �#,��/ %2�Q � � ���$�,. �,'�" �)<�,. @�,����A��< @�#�����A��< @��� I#� 1 � �a," ��/ ���� y��1�� ;#2� � Y��" ��/

�Y<�,.%'�� ���)�� � �'�(#/ ���##{1 � �,)5'��1 ��)�� � @�(#/ ���A @���"��'�. �(," %��"�� .

�" �J�� �,##�1 �9��� Y?: �� ��. �)<�"� I#/�a" @�#�� ���+1 � Y#�/� � @��1 ���' ���.� �.��"� ��5 : �� �� %���' G2�3 ��)i'�:[�V��j�,��$� �`�V�oe �

Y5#9���,#2h�V�mm .(�>D)<� �@��� ���)�� ��/ ����3� �� �1DC�" ��:� ���'�" X��iA @��D)�" b$�1 �����):� b�����. .��(1 � �����' Y#2� � �� Y��. �

���,� �Y��" �'�5'� b���%'�� �� ����):� ���i'� � ��#A >D)<� ��� � D)�" @���"�Y��� %/�� .�" %���' ���� � ��D�)7�� �'��1Y# 3�" ��(1 � ���C1 ��� �� �/

Y# 3������ ��:� � �A�'� ��/ .%'�� �'�(#/ �# &1 � �� ��� �� �� ���? �@���"��'��'>D)<� ��/ ���)�� ��/@������'��)�� H�a1� .� %�R�4 ���#' �:�� %���'

���$ �a," U���� �� �#a+1Y$� @�?,4 � ��. .a+1 �� ����' ��:� �����1 � �#-�56� � U���� �� @��� %�R�4�" ���#�/�' � ��. ���$ ��a," ��/ ���? � �'��1

2- Jones 4- Lindkvist

1- Wood 3- Schechner

Page 296: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

296

�'��'>D)<� ��/@��� ��/��. �(," ���' .@�� �,���� @��) ���.-�56� �i�� � �/%&�|� �� �'�(#/ %�R�4� �"�'� �,���� ���1 �� ���#5 �� �� ��Q �Y5'�� ��J'�"�

��/��)�� � �� �� �'����� �DC�" ����"@������'�" ;$�)" �" �'�. � @��1@�� �� �?'� �'��1�'@�(#/ �i����� Y�5' ��< ��/ .��.��"� �"�'� >���� �� ��

%'��Z#�� ��� �,)5'��1 @���"�@�(#/ �� ��1� ��< @�A�'�A U���� � �/��'��� Y$�x6D" ;�3 ��J.�<�4 �,'��) �1k�*�" �� ����� � y��1�� �� �� ���" ��(1 �/ �,,�

�#�,1 ����� �'��J' @�� ��J'�"�� �,���� �Q��Q �� ��)��A ���3 ����3 ���" � @�.@���" �"� ��� � ��,,� �i�� �"�'� �#|t1 �� �|z" ;"��� �� �C� @��,� � @��1

J'�"�� ��"���?"����):� ��/ "Y5��J'.

�" k��(" ��X��"� YaA @��1 ���?"��/ ����):� ��G#��1 �'�,� ��. Y$��� ������ ��� G5� �# b������� �, "���� y��1�� �#!7 ���.�� Y$�� �������� ��< �X���4 @��� ���/��)�� ��< �3��c'� ��� �"�,�)�i����� � �$�" �>��/V�

[sso .(���?" � ��#)$� �� Z#��1 F�� ����1 @���" ����):� ��/G#$� �'��1 ��/>�� 1 �� ���C.� ��'�(#/ �'��� ��a��� ����$ ���� �)#+&. .@�� @�����

���?" ��#A��� ����C�/ �I2�$ Y�3� ���:� ���� �I2�$ b��� ����3� �� ����):� ��/I#�+1< H��6 �� k��� � ��#A�� �,/��< @��1�' �� .@�,Q @��' �*�6 %/�K4 S��)' ��

Z��� �� ��� X��"� ���?"��/ ����):� �%'���" �@���"�@��1 @�'� ���,���� ������):� � @�. ��(�� y��1�� G$�," ����):� ������ �� � � "�: �(#)' %/��

>D)<� ���)�� ��/@������'���� ��'�$�.

�$� � �#,��/�)��� -�" %/�K4 ��� ��/ � ��#J�#4 ��� �� Y��A �(#)' @��1>D)<� @�"��@��� ���)�� ��/�" �@����� �� ���'X�� @��1 G#$��#w �'�"�� ��/

X�� ��iJ��: �� @�$��#�,1 �,'�" @�$� G#$� � ��< ��/Y'��< � �'� ��/ ��/�N" ���� -���" �<� �� I/ ��,/ �� �"D����' ��. .�� ���)�� ��� � �����,�5)��

1- Harrell, Mercer & DeRosier

Page 297: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

297

���?"��/ �����):� ��!" � 7� >�!1 �����):� ;C.��#A b��� �����):� ���1��;"� 1 Y#a#���/ �����):� X��$�J)��� ����):� ��)6 Y"D$ @��� ��� ����.

�" ���)�1=)��� �=J����� �� 4�� �����-�/ �V�[sse(�" �@��1 � �#!7 X��"����?" F���"� �� ����):� ��/���' ��� " ����* �� @��,� .��x)'� -�$� ��� �

�"���?" X��"� �����"�'� ;�C" ��,: �� @��,� � ����):� ��/ �.��"� ��/��. �)��A �x' �� -���" �,#"� �'��) X���4 � X��"� G#1�1 ��� � �1," ��/ � G$�

@��� Y"D$ �D)�� ��� ��C!)5" X���4 � �)<�,."��< "%'�� �� I/��� @���"�����.

Y����!" ���" �*�6 %/�K4 ��/ F�� � �+#&�1 ��6�+" F�('� F�� � @��1�����(,/ �.��"� �"�'� � �$�)$����?" ��.���' ���.� �"� ����):� ��/ .��� �

�" ��?,�#4 -�$� �� ��.%/�K4 �"�'� �� �+#&�1 ��6�+" F�('� ��* �� ��/���?" X��"���. ���a)$� i#' �"� ����):� ��/ .�'��' @�� �+!," �#,��/

%'�� � %/�K4%'�� �,$ U#� ��)<� @���"��� �� ���a)$� � �@���"���� �� ����� i#' � <��" �"�'� X��"�Y����!" @��,��� " �*�6 %/�K4 ��/�" ��� �'��A

�" ��?,�#4%/�K4 �� ��.I#� 1 @��1 � ����" ��� @��� ��!2 � �1� ��/ � ���l4� ���D�� ��,wY$���. ���i�� ��"�.

�#2�� �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" :[j/so/V`�[ �&5' Y����� r���1�2��" ���?' :se/VV/V`�[ �2��" X��l4 r���1:V[/s[/V`�`

1- Teodoro, Kappler, Rodrigues, De Freitas & Haase

Page 298: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

298

q����References

��"��# ��+,")V`oo .(�#|t1 ���?"��/ ����4�'��� �@����" @��54 �'�)5� D)�" ��RD)<��'��$��� ��. �Y"D$ �'��� ���#.��/ �)#�1 @���/���� �%�G ���� !,� f� 7�o������>�$ �����. �I/����[)h[(�VseWVVh.

�#56 � $��� ����i'�<)V`�[ .(4��� ��)�"� �� �����P�� � ��'3�' B)��� � ��������� @��?1 ���' ���� �����)'�.

i���4 ���"��� �a��.)V`�s .(���?" X��"� �#|t1 �$���)<�,. ��C��� � �,)�" ����):� ��/ /%'�� ���A��$ � ���)�� ��,#�' @���"��T��j��� 3�#�� ��������� ����. �>�� >�$ �V�heWjj.

I��" �� ")V`oj .(�#|t1 X��"� ���?"��/ ����):� ����a)$� ��@�)$�� ��%/�� ���)�� �RD)<� %'�� @���"� <��)G����'�" �,/� X��"���l4 �#,$ V`�1V�>�$ �?. @��?1����� ����

����,��' ,�����J�'�� F� � �)5�i? ���&�'��1 @��?1.

�{7� ��9�,#")V`�s .([#� ��%��� �����'��6��� ��#�$ #� ���6� ��� [�D� ��� � �� �� �@��?1 :X���4 � X��"� �� 2�c" ��J�/�K4.

�� ���x'�#56 �@�� ��!" ���4)V`om .(���?N" ��&�|��i� � ��c*� � ����):� ��/ =a'%'�� �� �w� @�)$�#� @���"��������������� �3 �� ������. �[��eWVVj.

Achenbach, T.M., & Rescorla, L.A. (2001). Manual for the ASEBA School-Age Forms & Profiles. Burlingron, VT: University of Vermont, Research Center of Children, Youth & Families.

Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Towards a Unifying Therapy of Behavior Change, Psychological Review, 84, 191-215.

Chiu, A.W., McLeod, B.D., Har, K.H., & Wood, J.J. (2009). Child-Therapist Alliance and Clinical Outcomes in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Child Anxiety, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 50(6): 751-8.

Christopher, R.T. (2005). Disruptive Behavioral,.Disorder, In: Sadock BJ ,Sadock VA, Editors, Comprehensive Text Book of Psychiatry, 8 th .ed. Philadelphia: Williams and Wilkins, 3205-3216.

Page 299: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

299

Collet-Klingenberg, L., & Chadsey-Rusch, J. (1991). Using a Cognitive Process Approach to Teach Social Skills, Education and Training in Mental Retardation, 26: 258-270.

Colman,I., Wadsworth, M.E.J. Croudace, T.J., & Jones, P.B. (2007). Outcomes Following Assessment for Internalizing Disorder in Adolescence, The American Journal of Psychiatry, 164, 126-133.

Cook, C.R., Gresham, F.M., Kern, L, Barreras, R.B., Thornton, S, & Crews, S.D. (2008). Social Skills Training for Secondary Students with Emotional and/or Behavioral Disorders: A Review and Analysis of the Meta-Analytic Literature, Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders, 16: 131-44.

Cumming, T.M., Higgins, K, Pierce, T, Miller, S, Boone, R, Tandy, R. (2008). Social Skiils Instruction for Adolescents with Emotional Disabilities: a Technology-based Intervention, Journal of Special Education Technology, 203: 19-33.

Elliott, S.N., & Busse, R.T. (1991). Social Skills Assessment and Intervention with Children and Adolescents: Guidelines for Assessment and Training Procedures, School Psychology International, 12: 63-83.

Essau, C. A., Conradt, J. & Peterman, F. (2002). Frequency, Comorbidity and Psychosocial Impairment of Specific Phobia in Adolescents, Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 29: 221-231.

Fanti, K.A. (2007). Trajectories of Pure and Co-occurring Internalizing and Externalizing Problems from Age 2 to 12: Findings Fromthenichd, Study of the Requirements for PhD Degree, Georgiastste University.

Fuller, A. (2006). A Blueprint for the Development of Social Competencies in Schools, www.andrewfuller.com.au.

Gansle, K.A. (2005). The Effectiveness of School-based Anger Interventions and Program: A Metaanalysis, Journal of School Psychology, 43: 321-341.

Garnefski, N., Kraaij, V., & van Etten, M. (2005). Specificity of Relations between Adolescents' Cognitive Regulation Strategies and Internalizing and Eternalizing and Externalizing Psychopathology, Journal of Adolescence, 28, 619-63.

Page 300: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

300

Gresham, F.M., Van, M.B. & Cook, C.R. (2006). Social Skills Training for Teaching Replacement Behaviors: Remediating Acquisition Deficits in at-risk Students, Behavioral Disorders, 31, 363-377.

Greshman, F, & Elliott, S. (1999). The Social Skills Rating System,Criclepines MN: American Guidance services.

Harrell, A.W., Mercer, S.H, DeRosier, M.E. (2008). Improving the Social-behavioral Adjustment of Adolescents: the Effectiveness of Social Skills Group Intervention, Journal of Child and Family Studies, 18, 378-387.

Hernandez, H. (2006). Social Skills Training: A Comparison of a 12- Week Training Program to a 24- Week Training Program, European Neuropsychophrmacology, 152, 152-155.

Hudson, J. Deveny, C. & Taylor, L. (2005). Nature, Assessment and Treatment of Gneral Anxiety Disorder in Children, Pediatric annals, 34, 97-106.

Jones, P. (1996). Drama as Therapy: Theatre as Living, New York: Routledge.

Kendall, P.C., Safford, S., Flannery, Schroder, E., & Webb, A. (2004). Child Anxiety Treatment: Outcomes in Adolescence and Impact on Substance Abuse and Depression at a 7.4 Year Follow up, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 72, 276-287.

Lindkvist, M. (1977). Sesame Research at Good-mayes with Long Stay Schizophrenic Patients, Re-trieved September 28, 2006 from: http://www. Badth. Org. uk/Research/.

Loreman, T., Deppler, J., Harvey, D. (2005). Inclusive Education, Australia, Allen & Unwin.

Maag, J.W. (2006). Social Skills Training for Students with Emotional and Behavioral Disorders: A Review of Reviews, Behavioral Disorders, 32, 4-17.

Maag, J.W. (2006). Social Skills Training for Students with Emotional and Behavioral Disorders: A Review of Reviews, Behavioral Disorders, 32, 4-17.

Mahoney, M.J. (1977). Reflections on the Cognitivelearning Trend in Psychotherapy, American Psychologist, 32, 5-13.

Page 301: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

301

Matson, J.L., Rotatori, A.F., & Helsel, W.J. (1983). Development of a Rating Scale to Measure Social Skills in Children: The Matson Evaluation of Social Skills with Youngsters (MESSY), Behavioral Research Therapy, 21, 335-340.

Mc Clintock, S.M. (2005). Relationship of Internalizing Behavior Problems to Intelligence and Executive Functioning in Children. Master of Science, The University of Texas Southwestern Madicall Center at Dallas.

Mize, J. (2005). Social Skills Intervention and Peer Relationship Difficulties in Early Childhood, Quebec: Centre of Excellence for Early Childhood Development (1-7). Available at: http://www.child-encyclopedia.com.

Ollendick, T.H. & King, N.J. (1994). Diagnosis, Assessment and Treatment of Internalizing Problems in Children: The Role of Longitudinal Data, Journal of Counseling and Clinical Psychology, 6, 917-928.

Pine, D.S., Helfinstein, S.M., Bar-Haim, Y., Nelson, E., and Fox, N.A. (2009). Challenges in Developing Novel Treatments for Childhood Disorders: Lessons from Research on Anxiety, Neuro Psychopharmacology 34, 213-228.

Ramsawh, H., Chavira, D.A., & Stein, M.B. (2010). The Burden of Anxiety Disorders in Pediatric Medical Settings: Prevalence, Phenomenology, and a Research Agenda, Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 164, 965-72.

Rosenhan, D.L. & Seligman, M.E.P. (1997). Abnormal Psychology, Third Edition, NewYork and London: W. Norton & Compny; 1997.

Rudolph, K.D., Dennig, M.D., Weisz, J.R. (1995). Determinant and Consequence of Childrens Coping in the Medical Setting: Conceptualization, Review and Critique, Psychological Bulletin, 118, 328-357.

Sapp, M., & Farrell, W. (1994). Cognitive-behavioral Interventions: Applications for Academically At-risk and Special Education Stu-dents, Preventing School Failure, 38, 19-24.

Schechner, R., (1985). Between Theatre, and Anthropology, Philadelphia: University of Philadelphia Press.

Page 302: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

302

Stewart, T.C., West, R.L., & Coplan, R. (2007). Multi-agent Models of Social Dynamics in Children, Cognitive Systems Research, 8, 11-14.

Stricker, G. & Widiger, T.A. (2003). Handbook of Psychology, NewJersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc; 2003.

Teodoro, M.L., Kappler, K.C., Rodrigues, J.L., de Freitas, P.M. & Haase, V.G. (2005). The Matson Evaluation of Social Skills with Youngsters (MESSY) and its Adaptation for Brazilian Children and Adolescents, International Journal of Psychology, 39, 239-246.

Vyskocilova, J, Prasko, J. (2012). Social Skills Training in Psychiatry, Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 54,159-170.

Walker, H.M. (1983). The ACCESS Program: Adolescent Curriculum for Communication and Effective Social Skills: Student Study Guide, Austin, Publisher, Pro-Ed, 1983.

Walker, H.M., Ramsey, E, & Gresham, F.M. (2004). Antisocial Behavior in School: Evidencebased Practices, Psychological Bulletin, 133, 149-182.

Wood, J.J., Chiu, A.W., McLeod. (2003). Child Anxiety Disorders, Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, University of California.

Youngstrom, E, Youngstrom, J.K., & Starr, M. (2005). Bipolar Diagnoses in Community Mental Health: Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist Profiles and Patterns of Comorbidity, Biolgical Psychiatry, 58, 569-575.

Zeng, G. (2007). An Exploratory Investigation of the Internalizing Problem Behavior among Children from Kindergarten to Third Grade,Dissertations available from ProQuest. Paper AAI3271843. http://repository.upenn.edu/dissertations/AAI327184.

Page 303: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

303

�� ������� t��������� ���� u�U�#6$ 4�:���3

' � . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . �;#"(� < ' ��� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .

�%/� =�#>. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

56� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .?" @"�%�" A)- . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . � . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .

+�B � @"�%�" C$���)�� � � �E (�%/�� C�$��� ' G�" +�888/38� ��� �- )� � .�� �� I /�J +� "� �(KL- M�- N�" )$��"(<7�4477837�883 ' $� �� $��"�� +- $O. � �� $��"�� � �%&��� '(� �)P��"# +�Q�� �- R� � #�

S��T =�#> +�� @"�%��" '��. ��UK �"�� +� "� V&. SW" � ���"� ����� � !��"#)&� � � ��".

�� ��:+,- �%.# � �� $��"�� � �%&��� '(� �)P��"# X����� � !��"# X�����

�%/�)K:1�222�344256� :���7841 Y83�� 9K . :��1288�Y83��

R&���%PZ" N/� :[email protected]

Q��Z-&� ��Z"

Page 304: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

304

Relationship between Job Stress and Quality of Work Life in the Physical Education Teachers of East Azerbaijan Province

* Y. Badriazarin (Ph.D) ** F. Abdavi (Ph.D) *** A. Akbarzade (M.A)

Abstract Quality of working life (QWL) is one of the necessities of individual in the in organizations and occupational stress of teachers, makes a great impact on educational quality. The present study aimed to examine the relationship between job stress and quality of work life in the physical education teachers of East Azerbaijan Province.

This study wasconducted with a conelational research method. Data were collected by using quality of work life questionnaire with reliability (α=0.91) and job stress questionnaire with reliability (α=0.87). 302 samples were selected according to Morgan table. Findings showed that on the whole there was negative and significant relationship between job stress and quality of work life. All dimensions of job stress, with the exception of the physical environment had negative and significant relationship with QWL. The only useful predictors of QWL were role boundary and role insufficiency that could predict 26% of QWL changes.

Keyword: Job stress; Quality of work life (QWL); Teacher; Physical education.

* Associate Professor, Physical Education and Sport science, University of Tabriz, (Corresponding Author) ** Assistant Profesoor, Physical Education and Sport science University of Tabriz *** M.A Student, University of Tabriz

Page 305: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

305

Moderating Role of Alexithymia in Relationship between Attachment Styles and Severity of Substance Use Disorders

* M.A. Besharat (Ph.D)

** S.N. Noorbakhsh (M.A) *** R. Rostami (M.D)

Abstract Processing systems are influenced by dysfunctional mechanisms of emotion/affect regulation and produce serious health problems as well as psychological disorders. The present study amied to investigate the moderating role of alexithymia in relation between attachment styles and severity of substance use disorders. Therefore, one hundred and twenty two men with substance use disorders were included in this study. All participants were asked to complete the Adult Attachment Inventory (AAI), the Torento Alexithymia Scale (TAS-20), and the Addiction Severity Index (ASI). Date were analyzed by descriptive statistics and moderated hierarchical multiple regression method. Findings showed that secure attachment style exhibited a significant and negative association with alexithymia and severity of substance use disorders, while insecure attachment styles (avoidant and ambivalent) showed positive significant association with alexithymia and severity of substance use disorders. Also, the result showed that alexithymia moderated the relation between attachment styles and severity of substance use disorders. Consequently, the moderating role of alexithymia can be explained in terms of several mechanisms including distance from negative emotions, self-medication as wells facilitating verbal and emotional communications. Keywords: Alexithymia; Attachment; Substance use disorder; Addiction.

* Full Professor, University of Tehran , (Corresponding Author) ** M.A.Clinical Psychology, University of Tehran *** Associate Professor, University of Tehran

Page 306: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

306

Comparison of the Effectiveness of Emotion Regulation Training and Mindfulness based Cognitive Therapy in

Psychological Distress and Cognitive Emotion Regulation Strategies in Mothers of Children with Mental Retardation

* M. Beyrami (Ph.D) ** T. Hashemi (Ph.D) *** A. Bakhshipour Roodsari (Ph.D) **** M. Mahmood Aliloo (Ph.D) ***** A. Eghbali (Ph.D)

Abstract The aim of this study was to compare the effectiveness of emotion regulation training and mindfulness based cognitive therapy in psychological distress and cognitive emotion regulation strategies in mothers of children with Mental retardation. The study population in this quasi-experimental study, included mothers of children with mental retardation in Tabriz exceptional school. Conducting depression, Anxiety, and Stress Scale. 60 people were randomly selected and were divided into two groups (30 people in per group). One of the experimental groups received emotion regulation training over a period of 2 months and 8 sessions. During the same period, another group was educated with mindfulness based cognitive therapy. Instruments used in this study included, the Cognitive Emotion Regulation questionnaire and Depression, Anxiety, Stress Scale. The data were analyzed by multivariate analaysis of covariance. Results: The results showed that emotion regulation training, and mindfulness based cognitive therapy had a significant effectiveness in depression, anxiety and Stress.

* Associated Professor of Psychology, University of Tabriz, ** Associated Professor of Psychology, University of Tabriz *** Associated Professor of Psychology, University of Tabriz **** Professor of Psychology, University of Tabriz ***** Student of Psychology, University of Tabriz, (corresponding author)

Page 307: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

307

Therefore it could be concluded that emotion regulation training and mind fullness based cognitive therapy had a different effectiveness in these variables. Pairwise of dependent variables showed that mean differences between two groups were significant and comparison the emotion regulation training is more effective. On the whole, emotion regulation training could be effective in reduction of the psychological distress in mothers of children with mental retardation.

Keywords: Emotion Regulation; Mindfulness based cognitive therapy; Psychological Distress; Cognitive Emotion Regulation Strategies.

Page 308: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

308

Job Stress Model in Educational - College Setting * S.S. Hosseini (Ph.D Student) ** H. Habibi (Ph.D) *** M. Hassanpoor (M.A)

Abstract In recent decades, the subject of stress and its effects on organization has been one of the main topics of organizational behavior management. Annually enormous investments due to the lack of psychophysical health, efficiency reduction or job quitting and the loss of jobs is lost due to job stress. The present study aimed to investigate the reasons of job stress and to present a job stress model. Study population included 918 University of Tabriz staff members and the sample size was 273 people. Data were collected by using a researcher made questionnaire. In order to reduce the measured variables factor analysis was used, and 10 factors were identified as the factors of job stress. After identifying the factors of stress, using the Friedman test the impact of each factor on job stress was prioritized as follows: (1) organizational factors: (2) organizational culture and context: (3) organizational policy: (4) roles pressure: (5) structure factors: (6) lack of job security / financial: (7) instability: (8) interpersonal relationships: (9) role competence: (10) adaptation to work requirement.

Keywords: Job stress, Educational setting, College setting, Tabriz University.

* Ph.D Student, Public Administration Allameh Tabatabai University ** Assistant Professor and Faculty Member, University OF Tabriz (Corresponding Author) *** M.A Public Administration

Page 309: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

309

Sex Differences in Self-Estimates of Multiple Intelligences in University Student Population

* A. Rezaei (Ph.D) ** A. Mohammadzade (Ph.D) *** J. Mesrabadi (Ph.D) **** K. Esmaeilpour (Ph.D)

Abstract The purpose of the present study was to compare sex differences in self-estimates of multiple intelligences in university student population. Therefore, 268 students of humanities (184 females and 84 males) from Payame Noor University Tabriz branch were randomly selected, using stratified and multiple stage cluster sampling. For collection, data they were asked to complete the multiple intelligences Inventory that included 8 subscales (verbal/linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, musical, bodily-kinesthetic, intrapersonal, interpersonal, naturalistic). Data were analyzed using Multivariate Analysis of Covariance (MANCOVA). Results showed that statistically controlling of age effect, there were significant differences in self-estimates of male and female students verbal/linguistic, bodily-kinesthetic, intrapersonal, interpersonal, naturalistic intelligences. Mean scores of male students in these subscales were higher than female students. In this paper, results of the present study were discussed.

Keywords: Multiple Intelligences; Sex Differences; Student.

* Associate Professor, Department of Psychology, East Azerbaijan Payame Noor University (Corresponding Author) ** Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, East Azerbaijan Payame Noor University *** Associate Professor, Azerbaijan Shahid Madani University **** Assistant Professor, Faculty of Psychology, University of Tabriz

Page 310: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

310

Relationship between Worry, Rumination and Metacognitive Beliefs and Major Depressive Symptoms

* A. Soleymani (M.A) ** F. Sohrabi (Ph.D) ** J. Shams (Ph.D) Abstract The present study aimed to determine the relationship between metacognitive beliefs and worry and rumination. Also, this study aimed to predict vegetative and nonnegative (cogniting) symptoms of major depressive disorder (MDD) based on these two constructs. This study was conducted with a creational research method. 45 patients (18 male and 27 female) diagnosed with MDD were selected using convenience sampling method. The completed Pennsylvania state worry questionnaire ruminative response scale metacognitive questionnaire-30 negative and positive beliefs about rumination scale, and Beck depression inventory results of pearson correlation showed a significant correlation between positive and negative metacognitive beliefs about rumination and severity ruminative thoughts. Besides, there was a posiive significant correlation between ruminative thoughts and vegetative and non vegetative symptoms in MDD (p<.01). Furthermore, multiple regression method results showed that the combination of ruminative thoughts and being worried explained 26 percent of vegetative and non vegetative (cognitive) symptoms (p<.01). Results suggested the effect of the third level of cognition (metacognition) on the second level (style of thinking) in rumination. Keywords: Metacognitive beliefs; Worry; Rumination; Depression and non vegetation symptoms.

* M.A in Clinical Psychology (Corresponding Author) ** Associate Professor, Psychology, Allameh Tabatabe University *** Assistant Professor, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences

Page 311: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

311

Effectiveness of Written Emotional Disclosure in Symptoms of Depression, Hope Level in Adolescents Exposed to Trauma

* A. Issazadegan (Ph.D) ** F. Mikaeeli Manee (Ph.D) *** L. Hosseinzade (M.A)

Abstract The aim of this study was to investigate the effectiveness of written emotional disclosure in depression symptoms and hope in adolescents exposed to trauma. Therefore 30 subjects with exposure to trauma were selected from Uromiyeh Behzisty Organization and they were assigned in two experimental and control groups (15 people in each group). All subjects completed the Beck depression inventory and Hope scale in two stages, pre-test and post-test. The open-ended writing type of writing disclosure method was instructed to the experimental group, however, the control group did not receive such a training. Results of analysis of covariance showed that writing disclosure had a positive effect in reducing the severity of depressive symptoms and promotion of hope level. Consequently, writing disclosure method could be considered as a low-cost, efficient, and effective method with in the improvement of depressive symptoms and hope. Therefore, it could be considered, by psychotherapists for encountering and coping with negative life events.

Keywords: Written emotional disclosure, Depression, Hope.

*Associate Professor Psychology, University of Uromiyeh (Corresponding Author) ** Associate Professor, Psychology, University of Uromiyeh *** M.A Psychology

Page 312: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

312

Comparison of the Effect of Teaching with Analogy and Cooperative Learning in Interaction with Learning Styles on

Learning Outcomes and Attitude towards Science * E. Fathi Azar (Ph.D) ** M. Bayrami (Ph.D) *** Sh. Vahedi (Ph.D) **** V. Abdollahi Adli Ansar (Ph.D Student )

Abstract The propose of this study was to a compare the effect of teaching with analogy model and cooperative learning in interaction with learning styles based on learning outcomes and attitude toward science course. The sample of the study consisted of four classes, 10 student in 3rd grade schools, which were selected by a random cluster method.

One of the classes was assigned to the control group, and the other three classes were assigned to the experimental ones. The control group received traditional instructional method and experimental groups received: (1) teaching with analogy model, (2) textual elaborated analogy as extracurricular, and (3) cooperative learning. Data were collected through science achievement test, attitude toward science scale, and preference learning style inventory. Results of multivariate analysis of variance showed that students thought with analogy and cooperative learning had better learning outcomes than textual elaborated analogy as extracurricular and control groups. There was not a significant deference between teaching with analogy group and cooperative learning one in terms of learning outcomes. It is important to mention that the learning styles had

* Professor in Educational Psychology, Tabriz University, (Corresponding Author) ** Associate Professor in Educational Psychology, Tabriz University *** Doctoral Student in Educational Psychology, Tabriz University

Page 313: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

313

not a significant effect on learning outcomes. Also its interaction with groups did not show a significant deference on learning outcomes of the students. Results of analysis of covariance showed that there was not a significant deference between experimental and control groups on attitude toward science course. Based on the findings, it is recommended to use analogies as instructional model in science course teaching and learning classes for better academic improvement of students.

Keywords: Teaching with analogy model; Cooperative learning; Textual elaborated analogy; Learning outcomes; Attitude towards science course.

Page 314: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

314

Relationship between Preceptions of Parental Behavior and Depression and Anxiety in Children: Mediating Role of Early

Maladaptive Schemas * F. Gannadi (M.A) ** M.H. Abdol’lahi (Ph.D) *** M. Yarmohammadi Vasel (Ph.D)

Abstract Negative perceptions of parental behavior affects a person's cognitive structures and makes him susceptible to psychological pathologies, The aim of this study was to determine the mediating role of early maladaptive schemas in relationship between parental perceptions and depression and anxiety in children. The present study condacted with a correlational research method. Statistical population included all normal students and students referred to counseling center of Bu Ali Sina University of Hamedan in 2013. In this study, both clinical and non-clinical samples were used; the study sample included 69 clinical people and non-clinical 134 people. Clinical sample was selected by convenience sampling and non-clinical one was selected through a multistage cluster method. The instruments used for data collection were Parental Bonding Instrument SCL-90 questionnaire and short form of the Young questionnaire. Data were analyzed using multivariate regression method. The results showed that early maladaptive schemas had a mediating role in relation between perceptions of parental behavior and depression and anxiety in children. Besides, maladaptive schemas of emotional deprivation, social isolation/alienation, vulnerability to harm, dependence/ incompetence, and emotional inhibition mediated more than the other schemes in

* M.A Psychology, Kharazmi University, (Corresponding Author) ** Associate Professor, Psychology, Kharazmi University *** Assistant Professor, Psychology, Bu Ali Sina University of Hamedan

Page 315: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

315

relation between depression as well as anxiety. Results showed that inappropriate behavior of parents (poor caring and overprotection) played an important role in formation of cognitive and mental vulnerability in children; therefore, determining the mediating role of early maladaptive Schemas in the relationship between perceptions of parental behavior and psychological pathologies can be useful in the prevention and treatment of mental disorders.

Keywords: Perception of parental behavior; Caring; Overprotection; Early maladaptive Schemas; Depression and Anxiety.

Page 316: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

316

Effects of Three Methods of Group Discussion about Moral Dilemmas, Dialogue In-small Groups and Lecturing on the

Improvement of Moral Judgment in Second Grade High School Female Students

* F. Karimi (Ph.D) ** Kh. Bagheri (Ph.D) *** A.R. Sadeghzadeh Ghamsary (Ph.D)

The purpose of this research was investigating the effects of three methods of group discussion in the classroom about moral dilemma, dialogue about moral dilemma in cooperative-small groups and lecturing about moral issues the improvement of students’ moral judgments. Therefore, by random sampling, one high school amongst all high schools of 18 education districts of Tehran was selected and 77 students of that school were randomly selected and assigned to two experimental groups (group discussion, included 23 people and dialogue in small groups included 26 people) and the control group (lecture method included 28 subjects). Research method was experimental pretest-pottest with a controlgroup. For the assessment of moral judgment, Defining Issue test (DIT) was used both in pretest and posttest. The reliability index of this scale was verified (∝=.86). Conducting pretest the treatments included group discussion about moral dilemmas, dialogue in cooperative-small groups about moral dilemmas and lecturing by teacher about moral issues were presented to experimental and control groups respectively for 12 sessions. Data were analyzed by t-test for independent groups, ANOVA, ANCOVA, Wilcoxon test for matched-pairs signed-ranks and chi square. The results indicated that: group discussion and dialogue in

* Faculty Member of Research Institute of Education (Corresponding Author) ** Professor of Philosophy of Education, University of Tehran *** Associate Professor of Philosophy of Education, University of Tarbiat Moddaress

Page 317: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

317

small groups had positive and significance (x2) on the improvement of moral reasoning of students but lecture method had no effect on moral reasoning, Besides, the effect of dialogue in small groups was more than group discussion on students’ moral reasoning. And both group discussion and dialogue groups had a better performance than lecturing grouping terms of higher level of moral judgment, which was statistically significant. Also, results of analysis of covariance showed that the positive changes in moral judgements in group discussion and dialogue groups were not due to conducting OIT pretest and familiarity with the test, rather, participating in experimental groups had cause the improvement of moral judgment.

Keywords: Moral judgment; Moral dilemma; Group Discussion; Dialogue in cooperative-small groups; Lecturing.

Page 318: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

318

The Study of Psychometric Properties of Strictness Questionnaire and Its Relationship with Life Satisfaction

* D. Manavipour (Ph.D) ** H.R. Vatankhah (Ph.D) *** N. Rahimpour (M.A)

Abstract The objective of the present study is to examine the psychometric properties of strictness questionnaire and its relationship with to life satisfaction among students. The population of this research was all during 2011-12 academic years. Therefore 416 students were chosen by a cluster sampling. They completed strictness and life satisfaction questionnaires. Results of factor analysis showed that the validation coefficient was 84. Principal components analysis was used to examine the validity. Using varimax rotation and considering the assumptions of factor analysis, percentage of variance, and the plot, 7 factors (expression, the power to say no, flexibility, respecting one’s rights, assertiveness, feeling more comfortable with others, having the capacity to be criticized) were extracted that totally the 40.036 percent of the variance. Factor matrix revealed that the first factor had the highest load factor and its contribution more than the other factors. Also, concurrent validity was used to ensure the validity of the research instruments, which revealed that life satisfaction did not have any significant correlation with the subscales and with the strictness questionnaire except with feeling more comfortable with others (sixth subscale). Finally, percent norm was presented for the questionnaire. Keywords: Psychometric properties, Strictness and life satisfaction.

* Assistant Professor, Islamic Garmsar Azad University, (Corresponding Author) ** Assistant Professor, Islamic Tonekabon Azad University *** M.A Islamic Tehran Azad University

Page 319: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

319

Effectiveness of Social Skill Training with Cognitive-Behavioral Approach in Reducing the Symptoms of

Internalizing Behavioral Disorders in Students * T. Yegane (M.A)

Abstract According to in creasing the prevalence of internalizing behavioral disorders in students and experts’ emphasis on early diagnosis and intervention, aim of the present study was examining the effectiveness of social skill training with cognitive-Behavioral Approach on Reducing Symptoms of Internalizing Behavioral Disorders in Students. The method of the research is experimental and research design was pretest, post-test with control group and a two-month follow-up. Statistical population included all female elementary students in 5th and 6th grades with internalizing behavioral disorders in Langrood city in 2012-13 academic years. 30 individuals were selected by random multistage clustering and divided in two experimental and control groups. In order to evaluate the internalizing behavioral disorders, child behavior checklist was used. Walker social skills training curriculum was presented in 17 sessions during two months for members of experimental group. Repeated Measures ANCOVA was used for data analysis. Results indicated that there was a significant difference between the rate of symptoms of internalizing behavioral disorders in both control and experimental group in post-test and follow up stages. Based on the effectiveness of social skill training in the reduction of symptoms of internalizing behavioral disorders, it could be used besides school formal curriculum.

Keywords: Internalizing Behavioral Disorders; Social Skills; Cognitive-Behavioral Approach.

* M.A.Clinical Psychology, Islamic Tonekabon Azad University

Page 320: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

320

Relationship between Job Stress and Quality of Work Life in the Physical Education Teachers of East Azerbaijan Province

1

Y. Badriazarin (Ph.D); F. Abdavi (Ph.D); A. Akbarzade (M.A) Moderating Role of Alexithymia in Relationship between Attachment Styles and Severity of

Substance Use Disorders 17

M.A. Besharat (Ph.D); S.N. Noorbakhsh (M.A); R. Rostami (M.D) Comparison of the Effectiveness of Emotion Regulation Training and Mindfulness based Cognitive Therapy in Psychological Distress and Cognitive Emotion Regulation Strategies in Mothers of Children with Mental Retardation

43

M. Beyrami (Ph.D); T. Hashemi (Ph.D); A. Bakhshipour Roodsari (Ph.D); M. Mahmood Aliloo (Ph.D); A. Eghbali (Ph.D)

Job Stress Model in Educational - College Setting 61S.S. Hosseini (Ph.D Student); H. Habibi (Ph.D); M. Hassanpoor (M.A)

Sex Differences in Self-Estimates of Multiple Intelligences in University Student Population 91A. Rezaei (Ph.D); A. Mohammadzade (Ph.D); J. Mesrabadi (Ph.D); K. Esmaeilpour (Ph.D)

Relationship between Worry, Rumination and Metacognitive Beliefs and Major Depressive Symptoms

111

A. Soleymani (M.A); F. Sohrabi (Ph.D); J. Shams (Ph.D) Effectiveness of Written Emotional Disclosure in Symptoms of Depression, Hope Level in

Adolescents Exposed to Trauma 125

Issazadegan (Ph.D); F. Mikaeeli Manee (Ph.D); L. Hosseinzade (M.A) Comparison of the Effect of Teaching with Analogy and Cooperative Learning in Interaction with Learning Styles on Learning Outcomes and Attitude towards Science

143

E. Fathi Azar (Ph.D); M. Bayrami (Ph.D); Sh. Vahedi (Ph.D); V. Abdollahi Adli Ansar (Ph.D Student) Relationship between Preceptions of Parental Behavior and Depression and Anxiety in

Children: Mediating Role of Early Maladaptive Schemas 171

F. Gannadi (M.A); M.H. Abdol’lahi (Ph.D); M. Yarmohammadi Vasel (Ph.D) Effects of Three Methods of Group Discussion about Moral Dilemmas, Dialogue In-small Groups and Lecturing on the Improvement of Moral Judgment in Second Grade High School Female Students

195

F. Karimi (Ph.D); Kh. Bagheri (Ph.D); A.R. Sadeghzadeh Ghamsary (Ph.D)

The Study of Psychometric Properties of Strictness Questionnaire and Its Relationship with Life Satisfaction

241

D. Manavipour (Ph.D); H.R. Vatankhah (Ph.D); N. Rahimpour (M.A) Effectiveness of Social Skill Training with Cognitive-Behavioral Approach in Reducing the Symptoms of Internalizing Behavioral Disorders in Students

259

T. Yegane (M.A)

Contents

Page 321: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

����� ���� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

321

Journal of Modern Psychological Researches Vol. 9, No. 33, Spring 2014

Founder: University of Tabriz Faculty of Education & Psychology Editorial Manager: M. Bayrami, Ph.D Editor-in-Chief: A.H. Mehryar, Ph.D Executive Manager: T. Hashemi, Ph.D Assistant Editor: N. Mashinchi Adminstrative Manager: Y. Nejati Typeseting: V. Jahedfar Cover and Text Designer: T. Sadati Printed by: Tabriz University Press Address: Journal Office, Faculty of Education & Psychology, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran Post Code: 5166614776, Tel: 0411-3392075, Fax: 0411-3356009 Web: www.tabrizu.ac.ir

Editorial Board:

G. Afrooz, Ph.D A. Alipour, Ph.D J. Babapour Kheiroddin, Ph.D M. Bairami, Ph.D A. Bakhshipour, Ph.D J. Ejei, Ph.D T. Hashemi Nosratabad, Ph.D P. Kadeevar, Ph.D Z. Khanjani, Ph.D M. Mahmoud Aliloo, Ph.D A.H. Mehryar, Ph.D A.R. Moradi, Ph.D

Page 322: ˇ ˆ /#,ˆ˙tabrizu.ac.ir/Files/Content/No_33.pdf · ˇ ˆ˙ ˝˛ ˚ ˜ ˘ 2 ˘ ˇ ˆ˙ &#’# ˜$ %## ! ˆ" ,˚˜ ˝˛ ˘ˇ ˘ ˆ˙˝ ˛ ˙˝ ˇ˚ ˛ ˆ˜ :

���� ����� �������� ���� �� ���� ��� �� ��! " #

322

Journal of Modern Psychological Researches �University of Tabriz �

Vol. 9, No. 33, Spring 2014 �

Relationship between Job Stress and Quality of Work Life in the Physical Education Teachers of East Azerbaijan Province

1

Y. Badriazarin (Ph.D); F. Abdavi (Ph.D); A. Akbarzade (M.A) Moderating Role of Alexithymia in Relationship between Attachment Styles and Severity of

Substance Use Disorders 17

M.A. Besharat (Ph.D); S.N. Noorbakhsh (M.A); R. Rostami (M.D) Comparison of the Effectiveness of Emotion Regulation Training and Mindfulness based Cognitive Therapy in Psychological Distress and Cognitive Emotion Regulation Strategies in Mothers of Children with Mental Retardation

43

M. Beyrami (Ph.D); T. Hashemi (Ph.D); A. Bakhshipour Roodsari (Ph.D); M. Mahmood Aliloo (Ph.D); A. Eghbali (Ph.D)

Job Stress Model in Educational - College Setting 61S.S. Hosseini (Ph.D Student); H. Habibi (Ph.D); M. Hassanpoor (M.A)

Sex Differences in Self-Estimates of Multiple Intelligences in University Student Population 91A. Rezaei (Ph.D); A. Mohammadzade (Ph.D); J. Mesrabadi (Ph.D); K. Esmaeilpour (Ph.D)

Relationship between Worry, Rumination and Metacognitive Beliefs and Major Depressive Symptoms 111A. Soleymani (M.A); F. Sohrabi (Ph.D); J. Shams (Ph.D) Effectiveness of Written Emotional Disclosure in Symptoms of Depression, Hope Level in

Adolescents Exposed to Trauma 125

Issazadegan (Ph.D); F. Mikaeeli Manee (Ph.D); L. Hosseinzade (M.A) Comparison of the Effect of Teaching with Analogy and Cooperative Learning in Interaction with Learning Styles on Learning Outcomes and Attitude towards Science

143

E. Fathi Azar (Ph.D); M. Bayrami (Ph.D); Sh. Vahedi (Ph.D); V. Abdollahi Adli Ansar (Ph.D Student)

Relationship between Preceptions of Parental Behavior and Depression and Anxiety in Children: Mediating Role of Early Maladaptive Schemas

171

F. Gannadi (M.A); M.H. Abdol’lahi (Ph.D); M. Yarmohammadi Vasel (Ph.D)

Effects of Three Methods of Group Discussion about Moral Dilemmas, Dialogue In-small Groups and Lecturing on the Improvement of Moral Judgment in Second Grade High School Female Students

195

F. Karimi (Ph.D); Kh. Bagheri (Ph.D); A.R. Sadeghzadeh Ghamsary (Ph.D)

The Study of Psychometric Properties of Strictness Questionnaire and Its Relationship with Life Satisfaction

241

D. Manavipour (Ph.D); H.R. Vatankhah (Ph.D); N. Rahimpour (M.A) Effectiveness of Social Skill Training with Cognitive-Behavioral Approach in Reducing the Symptoms of Internalizing Behavioral Disorders in Students

259

T. Yegane (M.A)