YIllHrHTOY TOY KANONIKOY !l1KAIOY EN TQ, …t \ - "-.... ' \ ,

$Page 1: YIllHrHTOY TOY KANONIKOY !l1KAIOY EN TQ, …t \ - "-.... ' \ ,$
YMBOAAI EI THN EPEYNAN TOY npOBAHMATOZ TQN ZXEEQN EKKAHZIAZ KAt dIKAIOY

A 6IAltDOPOflOIHlIl EKKOlMIKEYlLE KAI NEQTEPAI ESEAlSEIl

EN HJ 6IKAIQ THl PQMAIOKAeOAIKHl EKKAHlIAl vno

KQNT ANTINOY d MOYPATIdOY 6 e fl N YIllHrHTOY TOY KANONIKOY l1KAIOY EN TQ nANEnIETHMUJI A6HNQN

KEltIgtAAAION TPITON

AI KATA TOY LlIKAIOY PE

KAI

r e v L x W 7t e pt t wv 7t v e UfL IJ 1 X Wv e e A L e W v x ex 1 a t V 7t e p ( deg3 degV t C ex x deg (1 fL L X e U(1 e w x ex t fL e t ex 0 t v

H eXXO(1fLLXeU(1LC 1OU bpyexVL(1fLOU P E 7tPOOXOCAe(1e fLeYOCAtXC tXVtL-3pocaeLC 00 fLOVOV h Lloaewc ampAAa xext eopiwv tfL1)fLOCtwV tOU 7tAlJPWfLIJtoC PE At ampvtL13pocaeL ex01exL

I --A - 0 lt7tP0(1eIIOr0V 7tOLXLAlthC fLOPrpQ(C XOCL e7te1OC 1)aocv eLC 7tOC(1OClt crxeoov toclt ex01j-AW(1IOLC 1OU 6(1)axeutLxOU xOLvwnxou 7tOALrLXOU xocl 7tVeUfLOCrLXOU yiveL A - A I H 61 A TrLOU 11jlt uU(1ew ALI-epWtEpOC L(1WC oLOC7tL(1tW(1L ev 7tPOXELfLEVCP EtVOCL tl C I I I j I OtL OCL OCVWtepw OCVtLOPOC(1eL oev OC7tE(1X07tOUV 7t(XaOCL EL t Iv (Xvxyevv1j(1W XOCt ampvocveW(1W tou bpyexVL(1fLOU tj) PE xocl tijv texotlj et t0 7tveufLex xext bpYOCVt(1LV t1) ampPXIJLex ExxAYj(1Loc Llev etxov l1AAOCL Me(1L 7tCi(1OCL 6etLXOV xocl 31)fLLOUPYLXOV xexp exXt1) pex 0 h tou 3LXOCLOU

-__ _tY)-EE-xoct -eX-1ijlt-ampAAOLWaOWC

amp(1te fLeYOCAOC tWV AXWV t1)lt LU(1ew txtOte t)je PE xocl yevLXWtepov tij O(1)l1Xdoc AAAa xocl fLept exeLvWv ohLvec e7tl tou xocOocPW 6(1)l1XeUtLXOU 7te13(ou evocvtLOV hXO(1fLLXSO(1ew XtXl tYjC t1)C P E xocl 3LOCrpOOp( tou

Eotuxw 15fLWlt 3La PE 7tOCpefLeLvocv etc tOUlt XOA7tOU oc1hljlt Laxupocl oct xoc1 auvettAe(1OCV

OCUrO 8uIGuHJtV PE ex A6ylttl XIXt SLocMcrew

Ex T(iv ocvwTepw XIXOtcrTOCTOCL criXltpe gTL ol XOCTa exxocrjlLXeocrew PE euroIii vamp d Tlic ocxoAou6oue XiX-TY)yopLCfCmiddot oc) d Tou OCYWvLcrOSVTOCe eVTOe TWV X6A1tWV T1j PE XOCL e1tLSLW-

ampx T(iv ocvocysvvY)crw iXUTT xuptw TYj 6Ejle- - - A) 0 - PE TOt) scrjlOUmiddot r eLC OU OC1tOcrxL evTO OC1tO TY) bull bull XOCL OC1tO-

nAScrocVTIXC LSLIXe OPY)crxEUTLXcX XOLv6TY)TIXC y) EL TOUC OU jl6vov OC1tO Tfie PE oc))a Mt OpY)crxeLIXe ev yeVeL Etc Ta ampVWTepw XIXTY)yO-pLoce SSOV va 1tpocrTE6ouv XlXt ot ex1tp6crW1tOL IIoALTELIXe otTLvec TOV1tEPLOPLcrjlOV TYjc de TIX xoc6ocpamp EXXAY)crLoccrTLXa TWV To XIXPIXXTY)PLcrTLXOV YVWPLcrjllX T(iv ocywvLcr6svTWV e1tt TOU xlX6lXpw 6PY)crxEUTLXOU 1tEStOU XCfTa T1je PE cruvLcrTIXTO XIXTa xIXv6vIX d amppvY)crw XexL TOU opyoc-vLcrjlOU CfUT1ie 336 XlXt T(iv I1UVTEAEcrocVTWV d 1tiXpiXy6vTWV XiXt TOU PWjliXmiddotCXOU L)LXIX[OU ocpLmonAe[ou ltpLA0I10ltp(OC TOU vSOXOcrjlLXLUjlOU XlXt Op60AOYLcrjlOUeV 1tOAAOLC Se xoct -1j crXOAIXltJTLX1j 6eOAOYLIXC XlXt jle66Sou337 To XUpLWTepOJ IXhY)jloc Tffiv cruVLI1TIXTO E1 SLa TYjeci1tE-AeuOepwcrEwc OC1tO TOU xocrjlLXOU 1tVeUjlIXTOC amp7tOXOCToccrTOCcrLV T1je EXXAY)-cr[lXC we T1je XIXT XIXL l)mpxocrjl[ou XQLVWV(IXe TYje ampyoc1tYJC r1je 61t0[1Xe dVIXL OCUTo d 6do TTe EXXAY)cr[lXe

xocOocpme TOU 7t1X1tLXOU OEcrjlOU 6 d1tOOe we crLSY)POUV 1tIXPIX1tS-TOCl1j1lX exoc)u1tTe ExxAY)crLlXv OC1tO OCAY)OOUe lXuTYje crUV[5t1X oumwSY) 1tOCVTWV T(iv OCYWVL-crOevTwv XIXTa 1tEp yUTY)v XlXt jleT XOCTcX T1je eXXOl1j1Lxeucrewe

PE 06ev TYje ampAY)6oue oucrtelt T1ie ExxAY)crLocc 6l TOU Odou XIXL 01tepxocrjl[ou 0PyocvLcrjlOU TOU d1tO[OU XlXt eLvlXL

XIXL TOumpLOpLcrjlOU TYje PE d TOUe TU1tOUe otLVee de xoc6lXpwe eyx6cr(-tLOV 0PYlXvLcr(-t6v 11tOUSOCLOTOCTY) ev 1tpOXeL-

(-tsvltp T(iv (-t0ViXXLX(iv TiXy(-tOCTW1 T1i L)ucrewe 338 xed TOU ex

336 IIp3A W II a u c k amp1 OltA 17 337 IIp3A A De m p f ampv OampA 333 rOU 3L3AtOU An 0 n y mus

Commentarius in Isaiam Venedig 1519 laquoHier spricht der Hass gegen die heidnische Wissenschaft dar Dekretalien dar legistae und decretistae und gegen die aristote-Iisierende Scholastik gegen die theologie philosophantes gegen die Verderbnis der christlichen Spiritualitat sich mit ungebandigter Schroffheit aus Die derbe Sprache der Propheten verfUhrt zu einer unerbittlichen und fanatischen Kritik alIer Stande besonders der feudalen Kleriker)

338 U B e r lie r e L ordre manastique des origines au Xlle siecle Abbaye de Maredsous 1924 OltA IX laquoje crois pouvoir affirmer que l expose

1WV 81jILLOUpyWV 10U ILOVOCXLXOU 1WV KLO1epltnocvwv OTIO 10U EV Gistersium Citeaux 1C) 1098) 339 ampyEou Bepvampp80u 1L0v1jc 10U (1091-1153) 0 wzt

-iv 3LOCV01jOW Auaewl XOC1laquo 10 TIPW10V rOU IB 0 ampy Bepvampp80c 0 TIoc-rlJp 10U ILU-

O1LXLOJOU 1fie Auaewl ITIWC ( etVOCL 0 T1je Almx1je 0e0)OyLOCe340 10U ampytou Bepvampp80u 1)10 TOU OTIePXOOILLOU xod TIVeUILOCTLXOU xd adou ExxA1jOLoce x(Xpocx11jpoe

I I I I Z Il - IXOCL 0 TIpoOompLalLoc TOCUT1jC we XOLVWVLOCe v fI 0011 voc XUPLOCPXYJ 1j ev OCYOCTIYJ 8LOCXOVLCf Ev(XV1L TOU OpeOAOYLalLou xd 10) TIpocYILOC1LalLou (realismus)

I I ) 1 - E Imiddot rI e -OLTLVee w01jYOUi eLe v exxoaILLxeuaw 1I)e XX1jcrLOCe TIpoet-1j Yl UTI OCU10U wxt mepxoaILLOe 11jc ExxAI)a[occ TIAeUpamp 11111 t8ocL1epoce SPLlLu-

1YjT0e xoc1eqlepe1j 0 ampywe Bepvamp80e xocd 11je OXOA(xOTLx1je 0eOAOYLOCe 1OU IIhpou (1079-1142) 10U OTIOLOU 7j 8LOCAeX1LX1j 1Le1e-1pem1o xX1O TOll ampYLOV Bepvampp80v dc OpeOAOYLOILOV xoc1ocO1peqlov1oc 1OC ee-

lLeALOC 11jc TItO1eWC xocl crUieTIWC xocl oco-njc 11je 0eOAOyLOCe 0 Bepvampp80c OTIoc80c -r1je 0eOAoytocC 11jc xocpStoce xocl ltlXL 11jc 0eoAoYLOCe 10U vou laquoT600v ( 0eoc gaov ampY(xTIamp1(XLraquo (In tantum Deus cognoscitur in quan-tum amatur) EtOY)ylje1j veov eI80e ILUO1LXtalLou eXOV10e xev1pov )XL ampTI euOeLOCe 1011 0eov ampAAa 1ov EO1ocupw[Levov XPLO1OV ETIou8ociov dVOCL 10 cr6yypoclL-

r01) mpl 1OU Aoc1peu1sou 0eou (De diligendo Deo) EXOeteL -rlJv ILU-ocU-rou 0eoAoyhv341 tmo 10 TIpiOILltX 1fie ltmo(cxc 8Le1UTI6le1jOocv ampTI61jJeLe

TOU Ay Bepvampp80u TIepl 11jc ouOtw 1OU TIocmXOU eealLou vTIOU8OCLOTOC1OCL we oa ev 1C) oxeltp lLepeL 0 XOCT 0lLwe hTIp6awTI0c 1wv ampvoc-yeVV1j1LXWV TIepl 1fic EXXA1jcrLOCC 8ewv 11je TCepL080l) rocuT1jC 0 lLevoc Joachim von Fiore (t 1203 )342 0 OTIoioc ampTIOXocUTI1LXC) xocl TIPQql1j-

des grandes manifestation de la vie monastigue dans Ie passe est une des pages les plus inwressentes dans l histoire de l Eglise et de celle de la civilisatiOIllJ IIp(l

CB an London 1925 A H a rna c k Das Monchtum seine Ideale und seine Geschichte 6 w v Mo ) p cc-r 0 )

339 IIp(lA S Len sse n Le fondateur de Citeaux S Robert Westmalle 1937 J B M a h n Lordre cistercien et son gouvernement des origines au milieu du XIIIe s (1098-1265) Paris 1945

340 R Soh m Kirchengeschichte lv6 dv f1euroA 99 laquoWie Augustin der der-Mystikjm_

Abendlande))

342 IIp(lA E Ben z Ecclesia spiritalis Stuttgart 19M (SeuroA 3-48 J 0 h so s t H u cJoachim von Floris und die joachistische Literatur Frei

Cotlcordia novi et veteris testamenti Venedig1519 2) Expositio in apokalypsin Venedig 1527 3) Psalterium decem chordarum Venedig 1527

nxip tip tpomp ocOtOV EXXA1)crpoundCI xd 1OU tmxpIXtOUV1O ev VOfLLXOU de

E J J N J J - IT J 0 1tVeUfL(l(1LX1)V lt ev rI 0 1OU e1pou (YJ1tXIX-(l1t0 1OU 1tpwtetou ocyamp1t1) tou Iwxvvou R e1tpound3pML 1tj

tOU T oachim yon Fiore tocrov ou KrxvoVLxoU AtXrxLoU fLe(LcrTI) t3tq 3ta t1) tV(J(xp-

x6Jcrew 1rxut1) tv tip 1tpocr6Jmp tou ampyLOU ltPPrxyxpoundcrfLou t AcroKn (11811 82-1226) tOU ampyx1t1)V 1tpOC 101 Xptcr1ov xrxL tou ampv6p6J-1tOUC XrxL crofL1trxcrrxv -rYjv cruvext xutou f3twfLlX II 1tpo tov Ecrtrxu-pWfLevov Kuptov ampcpLepwcrt tou ltPprxYXLO(OU 1tpO 1trxvtOC Mo etY) 1tpO tou 6rxvxtou tou (he fLeurota cruvex1i X(l(L t(3u6t-cr61j etc evwcrrv xrxL cruVt(l(UtLcrLV fLEtltX tou XPLcrtOU ampcrn etc tac 1tOCAOCfLrxC tou 1to)oc xrxl 1tAEUpOV rxutou va ltgtX1jfL(ItLcrOouv tltX crtpoundyfLrx-tOCtou EcrtrxupwfLevou343bull R tou ampy ltPprxYXLcrxOU etc htcrt1)fL1jV tou Kocvovtxou ALXrxtOU xrxl dc tv )evet 3topyavwcrtv PE I 0 - - 01 )VeurotLX1j xrxL iXPV1jtLXlj XrxL OUtWC emew ottt1jC xocteuvuvcrewc rx Ata t1)C LcrxupotcXt1jC ocutou fLucrttXLcrnx1jlt txcrewc 1tpoc evwcrtv fLEta tou EcrtrxlpwfLevou 3uvrxtotI)trx1tpOC t1jc amp1tOAutp6Jcrewc OUX fLOVOV )ta twv fLecrwv EXXAYcrLw ampAAltx xoc 3La r1)C xrxr amprofLoV

xed 1tpocrcpopiic d rOV XPLcrrOV 0 ( ltPpocyxLcrxoc 6ewpeLrrxt ampc tX1tpocrW1toc xocL rou 0p1jcrxeunxou amprofLtcrfLou ocrrtC tv ecrxxrYJ ampvocMcreL

eLC tWV fLucrr1jptwv amp opoctwv fLecrwv r1j amp1tOAurp6Jcrewc xrxl rIXUt1jC r1je ev rip xocrfLltP OPOC11jc EXXAYcrLrxc344

11jc rxutou txcrewc 1tpOC (l1tepxocrfLtoV xal EXXAYcrtocv ( ltPPIXyxicrxoc cruveteecrev Ipoundcrtw xrxl tfLfLecrwc xocL OI)XL

mxvtwc IlfLwc cr1tOU3IXLWC de xocrocppeucrLv tou fLEcrIXLwVLXOU xpxtou EXXAYcrtIXC345 (3) ltl1tOCpXet OfLw xIXL xoc

amp1t01tVeUfL(Ir01tOL1jcrLv r1jc euroXXAYcrtOCcrtLX1jC 3topyocv6Jcrewc t1j AucrEwe Evip ( l1ocmcrfLoc XIXt Lep(lPxLrx t1j P E 1tpocovroc rOU Xpovou t1t1 fLOCAAOV xrxl [LiiAAOV etc LAUv t1jc exxocrfLLxeucrew xrxtexofLevoL )1tO amp1tepLopLcr10U tm6ufLLrxc 1tpOC xocrampxt1jcrtv 1tAYp0tmiddottjroc tWV xocrfLtXWV ampY(l6wv ( ampy ltPpClyxLcrxo

313 P S a bat i e r Vie de S Franyois d Assise Paris 1931 344 A D e m p f amp creA 294 laquoDas ist die Geburt des religiO-

sen Individualismus die eigene ummittelbare religiose Erfahrung macht Franz von der Vermittlung der Kirche und der Zeitform unabhangig wie unmiUelbar zu Gott))

345 Aampr66L ltJeA 287 laquoDie individuelle Frommigkeit Franzens hat zugleich das Haus der kirche in der Neuzeit gestiitzt und wider Willen das mittelalterIiche kirchenreich gesttirtztn

16

lvetjlocv[061) Ws ISpyocloV T1j (Moc IIpovo[occ 11p0 r1j P E ex T1jc e11OC11eLAou[J1vY) a11oOUv6eOzw T1j TOU e11OCbtLXOU ampYIJOCTOC 1amp1 ltPPOCYXLcrxOCVampv346 ampxocuOXZIOV T1jC

PE LlY)V LepOCPXLOCC 11pOC 1 eXXOOIJLxeUOLV TOC e11OCLTLXOC IJ0VOCXLXQ( tVYIJOClOC TampV 7 TI)V xoct gtreAelocv a11amppV1)oLV TampV XOcrIJLXampV ampyoc6wv TI)V xocl TeAdocv aXlY)IJO(J1)VY)V (lk i)qJLOtOV TI)V TIjc ZUOCYYZALXYjC TeAZdJlY)toc t1jc TeAeLOCC ev XpLoTij) H 11e11oteY)OtC tWV )tL ev ti1l xocrlJCP tolhcp ev -rn (jtPOCteU0IJEVn e1tt Y1)c EXXAY)O(q 0 m(JrOC MVOCtIZL vamp IJLIJYj6n tOV 1tTWXOV XIZL 1tampOXOVtOC IY)Oouv XlZt ouxt t0J XpLOI6v tOV ampVIZ-(JrltXVtCY tampV OCl)TOU 8uvamplJewv Tamp emxbtLxcgt tOCYIJIZtOC tepoc-(Jrtoc 86VIZIJLe XUPLIZPX-1OOCcroc ev Tn eXXAY)OLIZ(JrXn t(JrOplqTYjC

XCYTOC t0 aZOTepov fJlJLoU TOU Mecroc(ltuvoe348 H TltUV tatq Xoca iScrov ete TOCe ltJXeOeLe 7tlZmXOU 6ecrIJou XIZL S1tLcrx011WV WC xoct etc ampAAOUe tOlJ-Zre TIjc eXxAf)OLOCOtLx1jc O7tOU-aIXtIX cruneAeurocroccrlX teAampXWC etc SmxpampTf)crv TIjc 1tlZmxfjc amp7tOAUTIXP-XtlZC Evocamp iOwc ex TWV 1t)eov yeYOVOTwV OU LOVOV t1jc h-XA1)OLOC(JrampX1jC aAAOC XIX t1jc 11ocyxocrlJtOU L(JrOptIXC 1j

TampV amp1txpVYj6eVTwv TOV XOOIJOV IJ0VOCXLXWV S11OCamptLXWV lIXYIJampTWV dc TI)V 7tpoOmk6eLOCV rOV 11tx7tampOIJ0U 11P0C XOCtampXTf)CJW TOU x60IJou I 349 IIIXpoc tocihoc )IJltUC aeov VOC AI]tjl6ij tm (hamp S7tOCampTampXOC tampYIJltXTIX OuveTEAecrocv lJeyampAw xoct et TOU 11VeUlJoctLxOU xoct 16LXOU e11meaOU tou 11AI]-pWIJltXTO Tfj PE XOXAOL ex TampV IJOVOCXLXampV TOOTWV TOCYLOCTltUV ot 0110[01 U110 S11lapOCcrLV T1) tot) Joachim von Fiore xoct U7tO TO XPampTOC snovwv IJUcrTLXL(JrLXampV toccreltuv S110Aeuro1JY)()()(V lJeTOC crtjloapOtI]tO TOV exxocrlJLxeurou6eVTIX 11ymcrlJ0v tOV IIamp11OCV W AVTtXPamp(JrOv350

ZVOCL eurot TI)V 6eIJzALwCJW tOU 11ocmOlJou TOU Bonaventura (t 1274) 0 0110rOc TI)V

- - IA CI - I - E

1Q TOU XOO

F deS e sse vaIl e Histoire geller de l Ordre deS Frallois

et de J eveIutioll de l

350 A De m p f lv aeuroA 331

ft)A U7tO rryv e7t(opflcnv rou loewoou1 rOU ocy lPPOCYXLOXOU (l-rL r0 1rpoexov dVOCL ouxt Yj xupwpxLoc rOU v6fLoUouxt LepocPX[oc ocAI EXXA1)Otoc we xev-rpov XOCL rov XpLcr-r6v361 O()7tOLO( xocroc rov Bonaventura elviXL b fL6vo cfpxLepeu( 0 rou Bonaventura P ct r us 0 I i vi (1248-1298) 0 opX1)yo 1rveufLocroxPocrwv fLeroc Ocpoop61I)ro rOV exxoOfLLXeUJevrix 7tocmOfLov XOCL TI)V rU1rO-7tOtI)0eLOocvXOCL JQfL LXOrCO L1)6etoocv 7tocmxY)v EXXA v ocurov eoptOXEro ev amp1)tOeOeL 7tpOC ocu-r1i evepyouOoc 7tVZUfLOCrLXY)V EXXA1)OLOCV

l5n Yj EXXAI)OLoc xocreOtt) 7t6pv1) 008XOCrOCOtwxwv roue xcmx XptOrov ITOC7toclt dvoct 0 AvrLXPLOrO 0 01r0io 07t0 ro 7tp6o-(lfLoc rli Clukv-rLoc rou ITe-rpou 7tPOCYfLOCr07tOter ro OOCrltXVtXOV ovOpw7toxr6vov OCUoU352 ITocpocroce ampxp6r1)roce l5fLwe tocuroce rou Olivi XClL rwv Aomwv 7tpoop6fLwV fLerClPPUOfLLcreWe 7tZpt ampv xltXrwrepw oci ev-roerwv X6A7tWV r=ij PE aVClvewrLXOCL 7tpoO7tOCOeLOCL OUVeTeAeOocv d( evtcrxucrtV rwv 07tOCOWV rOU emcrxomcrfLou OuvooLcrfLou (episcopalismus

conciliarismus) OL 07t0iOL de amp1rOXOCTocOrocow TYje OCPXOCLiXe OLOC rWV ITOC7tWV eLC roc olxoufLeVtxocc

cruv6oouc ITpcfYfLOCrL loWfLeV exTevecr-repov xocrwrepro 0( 1rpoO1rOCOetocL rou cruvOOtOfLou (hoc rWV 7teptcp1)fLwV fLerocppuOfLtOTtXwV Ouv60wv rWI) IE ocl()voe 7tocpecrxe 7tAetcr-rOCe eA1r(oocc r1Je piXc Tt)e PE de ocPXocpoundocv Lucrruxw l5fLwc 7tOCpOC TO O1rOU-oociov 0 07tOLOV emreAeOocv od 1uvOOOL OCOrOCL tv6tt)rocrY)c PE OLOC T1jc xocOocLpeOewe rWV TPLWV ITOC7tWV XClL Ty)c TOU MocpT(vou E (1417) we rOU XOCVOVtxou XOCL vOfL(fLoU ITcf7tOC rZALXWe XOCL 7tPOO7tcfOeLOC ocl)r1) epounde ev(OxuOiv rOU 7tocmOfLou 8crrt

ex ocoxocroccrrocOeLcrt)c 3uVOCfLet rwv fLerocppuOfLLcrrLX()V uv6owv h6t1)roc r1je ExxA1)crpoundoce xoc1eltpepe OLa -rre ev (]))W Euv60ou

7tOCmcrfLoc amp7teptcr7tocOrOC 7tAeOV ex ecrWrePLXWV cfv-rtOpJOewv 1tepteuro7tecrev d XOCrcfOtoccrtV exxoOfLtxeUerewe XOCL eOXdtt)e 3LOCCPOopiXC XOCL e7tL rWi 7tOC7tW1 0 ex T1je XOCToccrTocOew

3oc r0 lLeAAov p E fLeyocMnpoc 3t6Tt ocLcrJVreAoufLevocL ev -ryj7tePLOXYlZOCUr1)1 7tveUfLOCrtKOCL 081 gltPe-pOV 7tiXcrflL crcppocyt3oc 7tLcrTewe353 bullHev Tn Lucret ampAAol-

351 AUl6(h aeA F H e ] e r amp1 (jet 288 E Ben z Die Geschiohtstheoiogie

derFranziskanerspiritualen des 13 und 14 Jahrhunderts naoh neueren Quellenev Zeitschrift fUr Kirohengesohicbte 52 (1933) 92

353 G S c h n ti r e rkirche und kultur imMitteialter l6[l I-III Paderborn 1929

9EOAOrIA T6110C AB TpounduxoC A 2

18

tOU t0 t0 07t0iov t31)ILLoupyet t0 bull tOU XPLOtOU xocl tOU tOU ampIOpW7tt-IOU tOU Oetou XIX tl7tSPXOOILLOU

aUVLato)V -r1)V 0middot tXtl()UVSUS ex

tWV pound3(wv ot6tou 7tVZUfLottLXWV 87t)wv 0 xotl 0 xotl OsoAoyLoc xotl pound11 auv3uotOILiil ILeta amppLOton-AetOU ampOOUV tWV 3LotVOoUILSVWV sk amp7t0 ev Toll MsOoc(wvoc OLot3ixsto AVotySW1)OLt

Oeioc IOwc xotllhspov hepou

t1jv OuvtItAOUILSv1)v etC OXiljJLV XotteX 7tepL030v tOU amp7tocpOsy-

ILottoC tOU S j g e r s von Bra baD tmiddot laquode ampveu ema1jIL1)C toccpoc evo ampvOpclgt7tOUraquo (cum vivere sine literis mors

sit et vilis hominis sepultura) 8La cppocaewc laquooo8sv 7tept twv OotUILoctwv tou 000) ampcpou 7tepl twv CPUOLXWV (nil de dei miraculis cum de naturalibus naturaliter agimus) H exxoalLtxeuaLt tOU t1tecpeps tijv tXXOOILLXSUOLV 1OU 7t0-ALtLOtLXOU TIiXmu axe80v V1)C1LV 7tveuILoctLxal 8Y)ILLOUPYLIXL ILocALOtot os teX cpepouv 7tpoex6vtwc tOU XoaiJLxou H

XotteX -rljv 7teptooov WC 0 iJIjJLOtOC tOU 7tOALtLaiJou Etc tac axeaeLC Xott t0 dc

IIofLtdoc otv amp7totSAei XotteX 7tepl080v t0

354 R Soh m Kirchengeschichte lII) till ISEA 126 ((Aber war die Bildung der Zeit die kuhn und machtig voranschreitende Renaissance bewe-gung vielleicht im stande die ersehnte kirchenverbesserung zu bringen Ach diese Bildung trug das Heidentum in ihrem Herzen Sie dachte nicht anReforma-

- - sich---iiusser-lieh-der--Macht-der- --kirche --nebst____all_Jbr1Jl__ zu unterwerfen dennmiddotin ihrem

Innersten lebte die Gieichgillltigkeit gegen resse fiir das rein Menschliche Die Renaissance der kunst und Wissenschaft war k e i n e Wiedergeburt der Sittlichkeit gewesen Dies war die Zeit we]che einen Casar Borgia hervorbrachte fur Abbild ihr Ideal und zug]eich ihr Entsetzen Dies war

___ Maciavell seirtenlaquoFiirstenraquo schrieb ein Lehrbuch und zugleich eine Verherrlichung fUr denkaIteste-n

- die Madonnen=und Heiligen-

Nul selten dass

amprcOAUOV xpeXO -rYj 00 XO(( ampVSPWrcLV1) rcpocrwmxo-r1) -r[6EtexL OrcEPeXJ(O OU xpeXOU H Op1)crxdcr XexEcrril xexid AVexYEVV1)crLV

C 1pound I I WLWLXI urcovecrL) fL1) crufLmrcoucroc itpoC-rf)v ltpEpoucrexv ov Xcrpexxt1)pex ou wxexvexyxClcrfLoU PK H OLexOt1) eircotEAd ov

XO(prcov crXOAOCcrtLX1j pESOSLX1j OV eAEVSEpOV fLoVOC XOPWV OU emcrt1)fLOVLXW ampVtLA1)itOU rcepLexofLevOu 1) SP1)-crxetex HeveuSe) emASoucrOC ampAAOLWcrLC d 1)v ultp1)v OU itoAmcrfLou i1j

ocrov ampcrtE tOV ampVttXI)1COV 1) extcrSeXVEexL (3mSo- s bull B rl S -gt gt - I -extex XcrL lercol1) fLa EjJaLW 1) itexpexXOIOU 1)crt t1) all1)lQuxtex tWV crO-

PLXWV YEyOVOrWV tWV cr)vilEOfLEVWV fLe-rd t1) exxocrfLLXEOcrEW Ij PE ex-ltpE0YEL tWV rceptWpWfLfvwv itAClLcrLWV tljc fLEtltX XELpOC epyocrtex ExELVO to OrcOLOV ilEOV va urcOypocfLfLLcrSi tVtexu0ex LVlXL 6tL 0 llexmafL0 S1)fLWUP-yoC exhLOC tYc tOLO(l-1) 00 fLoVOV XexEcrt1) ampI[XexVOC xot ex tWV ucr-repwv VOC ampVtLfLEwrctcrn 1)V OLexO1)V 6ESOfLeuroVOU 6L ou itOV exi rcvEufLexLXOL( SUVeXfLEL ile crXOAexcrLX1) OEOAOYLOC xexomv tSlCf wv SPYOCcrLWV ou Ockam xext TIj 0ewpLoc tou laquoOvofLextWfLOU) (nominali-

I I - - - 0 I smus ) EUpcrxEO EV xexexitWcrEL Xo(L rcexplXxwn IXllex XexL exrpOfLOLWV1) rcl1)pw rcpoc o rcVEUfLex Ij Avexyyevv1j crew et tcrXeX1)v ampcroVeurorceLO(V XIX( SLlXrpSopav itpocrWitOrcO(1)crtV tIj orcOLo( amprzeuroAecrev 0 lleXitOL AM-

0 BOPyLIX (1492-1503) KIX OLOOU utjJwae oorceuro-poXCV ampvcXat1)fLeX oo 0 tv ltDAwpevtCf SLexxexfHfLEYOilofL1)VLXIXVO OeoMyo

I E P WV 0 fL 0 rx 0 10( p 0 A 0( 355 m fLeXt1)V OfLWC amp1Cfl)Sove rrpo PWfLYJV d rcUPWIX x1)poYfLltteX oo w rJAAO ampPXexLOmiddot ou fLExVOLrxV xeXSlXpaLv XIXL ampVexyEVV1)crtV tv rcVEOfLOLL ampypoundcp 1jc EXXA1)ato( xexl OIJ rrlXmxou OEcrfLou H amprreXvf)crL ljc PWfL1)C t06(1) SLamp wv rcopLvwv tpAOyWV ilL if)v IEpamp rrEpLE-(l) - B 0 - 0 Ix -roawfLlX oo c-ex ovrxPOlex rrpocrrrO(voo(JQI XOL O()OV OV p rcov VO( XO(-

xS1j ampVLcrXOPOC ov tv AilOeXPyCp ljc ampfLexPLIX rcEpLmaoVt1X mxmafLov tv OOtOL sZE7IAeuroOV Y CgtpO( xexS d tPOfLEPd 1013 XIX( wV Aome)v LEtIXPPOSfLLOtWV Od ex SEfLEA[WJ t1)v PE XiX( iEPiXPXtexv (dfLIXtLO[LEV1j XIXt aw-cppovOUcrlXlgt 1d [teaoc cr(uI)pto( tx ou 7tveJfLlXtLxOU xocou xO(t

ampitocrovOeaEwc de -1)J dXE 7tEPLeuroASEL Abycp $XxOCfLLcrxEvcrEWe lt9 5vrL txv eurovQe WV XOA7tWV 1IjPE aovzAeurocrSELcriXL ampvexVeuroWmltXL tIXOt1)7tPOcr7tampOZLIXL amprcESdX(1)criXv civLcrxoPCL 7tpo rJLeurocroJ croyxpeX1)aLV OU 7tlXmOfLou circo OU l-tiXl)CPOpou tXXOcrfLLXZUcrEW XiX) fLovovampfLfLecrWt w S 3middot ) bull - exL wfLev XIXWTeuroPW croVEeleurocriXv XIXiX 11)VXPLcrLfLWIXTt)V 7tEpLOOV oo rcpo

355 B t e qgt IX V l 8Q U amp1 cret 521

aLtXfLtXPUPYjOW ampyampvoe de atOCOltuow XtXa fLsltU7tOV t7tWSOLe 013 xtX1 WV Am7t6lV fLstXPpu6fLLOampv COV 7ttXmOfL6v o7tltue laquotA6wv de ttXu6vraquo) xtX66AOU 7tOALdtXV ou XtX( aLa OU

XtX1 6pYjaXSUCLXOU OCVtLfLSltU7tLIT() COV xLvauvov To xocptXxl)pLOixov ou fL6vov fLsCtXPPu6fLtOsltue OCAAaXtXL CampV 6sltupoufLevltuv 6)e rcpoap6fLltUV tXUl)e BtXAatltuV Olivi Fra Dolcino Joh Wiclif Hus XArc 1j0 OqJoapochYj trcWSOLe XtXa COU rctXltLXOU 6sapoli XtXL ou bpytXVLOfLoU PE aLa 07tOLtXe hWso tv XtX1 EXXAYjcrttXe XPLOOU XtXPtXXl)-

COU nOC7ttX 6)e AVLXPLOou H -9jv sxe 0 fLtX 61e fLStXppu6fLtOsltUe Erc 00 trct tXpoundampVIYe xtXtXms06sntXe xrxL mltrxvatXAL 06sVtrxe tx atXqJ60poce 7tAYj6uOfLOoe lie Bopdou EUP6l1CYjlt

EprxOtrx a at ocrcoSAeOfLrxrx iigt (1 CPOfLEPOC A6L ampamp1 8ttXqJ0po-7tOLYjOLC PE ocrco ocpxrxLrxe x01 OC8LrxLpbu EXxAYjOLrxe dc 0 OptOLXOV axtOfLo xed EXXAYjOtoc tv C06-TOe we staofLEV PE elxs fLeXP ou axiOwyoe xrxa 0 fLOCA-AOV 1)01 oce 6SfLe)LWaSLe ocPXae -lie zv XptOigt ocrcoxrxtutjlEltue xtXl amppXLXYje CYje 8LopyrxvwOEltue H trcsA60tiOtX ofLltue tXXOOfLLXWOLlt xrxl 1 aL

OCoLltUOLe oocr(oc EXXAYjOpoundoe dXEI aOuyxptltuc prxYLxWnptX ocrconAeOfLtXtX H fLEIYPP1)6fLLOLe asv fL6vov TIJV bpytX

tv6Cl)o nje P E ocAM XlYlrcpoUXI1AEOS fLeyrx xocOfLrx PE xod CampV 7tP0EOrxVxampv WC 7tpoe TIJV tpfLYjvdrxv 6EfLSALltuaampV

aOYfLampltUV tv XPLO1igt OC7toxoAuJeltue H aLrxLpaOLe Alm-Eupw1tl)C aLa OC7t0axiOEltue tampV bTCoaampv fLErxppu6fLLOEltue oc7tse-

AEaE xcmx iJ-t OCVU7tOAOYLOtOUC OUVEmLoe aLa xrx1 00 fL6vov Eopw1tl)e oca xtX1

OUfLrcOCOlJe ocv6plturc6Yj0c H prxYLx6CYje elc ev yeVEL rcpoOrca6SLtXV CampV fLEtXPPU6lLamptampV OUVLOrxtXL de TIJv rctXpa de tltUV 7tEP t7trx-

xrx1 aLOpyOCVltUOLV amppxrxttXC EXXAYjOLrxe hL fLSYrx-PE middotmiddotamppXiy6vQu-ExXA1jatOi-LlE80fLSVoU-

rcampyECrxL 7tocvtoE xrx1 xrx ampwkyxYjv XIX1 AUOEltUC 0 rcposOtXVtLOfL0C aev xIXa oOO(tXV tXU-rou fLErxppu6fLLOLV PE ouae trcampvoaOV Etc 0 7tVEUfLo xrx1 bpyavltUOLv tic amppxey6vou EXxAYj-

xod rXVLXtXCIXOtampOSltue ercExpocCYjOE 8 taLltuv

356middot IIp(3A H D 0 m b 0 i s Zur Revision des Die Katholizitat der Kirehe Beitrage zum Gesprach zwischen

1957 asA 166

t1tl veoc 6e(1eAtOu(1fvcuv6pfJaxeuCtxwv 0 1t0-mcr(1oc xIXCev6fJcrev 1tAeOV XOAWcgCt ot v6(1ot x01 OL 6ecr(1ot C6tE xot(16vov

(J laquo (1eCOtOIIOVCGU etcoc1t0ipocrtcrCtXOUC 1tOCpocyovtocc otocv Ot evCetOCI(1eVot CfJV 1tpoacr1ttcrtV xocl ocutwv etvoct cruve1terc 1tpoc tocc imtocyac tCUV357bull

IIpo cruve1twc (1etoppuO(1tcreCUe XOCVOVLX1je tltxeCUe Clie PE xaOoqlme TOU 1tOClCtXOU 6p6vou xocl tYje ocutov

OCUA7je E1telaAAet0 ampAAOCtc tOU Opl)axeuttxou xocl tmxpaCl)crte Cwv ocucrtl)pwv amppXwv Oc h OOCU(1oc-toe 3e ol 1tAercrCm CWV (1etoc (1eCocppo6(1tcrtv 7tOC7tWV 3texp(Jf)crocv ta (1e-ytOtoc ampe 1tjoe Co OfJ(1eLOV CoutO twv 1tpoxoct6xcuv tcuv At ampvocvecuttxocl 1tpO-crrcXOetoct tOU 120u x01 130u oclwvoe 3ev cruveCeMcrOl)crocv t1tl (1OCCoLCj) Ete xptcrt(1CUTatfJV 1tepLOOOv tYje ampcrtcptoce tl)C 1) PE lht mxpoc tm-

3tocipOopocv de 3totxoucrocv ExxAl)crtov elcrht t7tOCpxeie ouwf(1ete 1tpoe tx 60voccrl(1ou 3toclkOCPtU-p1jcrecucbull

0 t1tOCV01tAtcr(10e x01 1) tv (tucrtYJpi) 7tocmxCil 1tveU(1octt (1etocppUO(1tcrLe 3toc t1je -ampxtX(11ttou 3YJAov6tt xoct Otoc6epoce 1tPOoccr1tL-crecue 7toccrwv twv xoctoc t0 1tOCpeAOOv 1t0mxwv Stepou xoct amp3ucr6)1tl)t0e 3LCUtc t1je 3toc t1je teAet01tOt1jcrecue tou Oecr(10U t1je lepiXe ex tphou 1tavCC(i tocutoc ta Ikecroc 3t(l)v PE ampvtelketwmcre 3toc-Utptupl)crtv

H ampvtt(1etocppuO(1tcrtc t1je PEbull t1teteuxOl) XUPLCUe 3ta tile (1eyaAl)e tv Tpt3evtCj) 2uv630u (1545-1563) 01tOLoe (1eyLOtl) de ampv1t(1etwmcrw tou 1tpotecrtocvttcr(1ou xocl yevLxwtepav ele 3toctu-1tcumv twv 30Y(1amptcuv twv 61t0 twv 1tpotecrtoVtwv 1tocpep(1l)veuo(1e-vcuv858bull H tv Tpt3evtCj) 2uv030e ampm3e(xOl) (1eTa tOU (10VOCXLXOU tampy-Uttoe twv ll)crouitwv (Societas Jesu tv SJ )359 t0 tcrxup6npov

Mvcuv xoct e1tLAucrw twv 61t OC1JT1jc te8evtcuv H ev Tpt3eVtCj) 26v030e 3tet)1tcucre (1etoc crocipl)velixe xed 1tAl)p6tl)t0e toce OecreLe t1je PE lvocIItt twv 1tpotecrtocvttxwV ocLpecrecuv 1Cept twv 1tfJywv tOU XptcrttocVtcr(10U Iltt 3l)A Ay(oc xocl1) lepa IIopa30me dvoct tcr6tt(1ot1Cept t1je AYLIXe rplXip1je 15tt IXUtJevttxwc ep(1l)veuetIXL (16vov ExxAl)crloce 1tepl C1je

357 W PI 0 chI amp10 all altA 29 35S G S c h rei b e r Das Weltkonzil von Trient Sein Werden und Wir-

ken t6- I-II 1951 359 H S toe c k ius Forschungen zur Lebensordnung der Gesell-

Bchaft Jesu im 16 jhI6- I-II 1910)11 Rene Fulop-Miller Machtund Geheimnis der J esuiten Eine kultul--und Geitesgeschichte Berlin 1929 XOCL

22

ampIJIXP1(IXC XlXt 11]c tWV ocv6pw7twV gtLOC 7tlatew XIXl e7t1UYXIXVOlJtV1)C 7tSpl 1WV e7ttcZ IJUat1)pLWV 1WV ampYLWV WV AeL-

XIXl dx6vwv 1X1hwv 1013 )W6IXpt1)pLOU 7tUpOlt XIXl tWV aUnWpoxIXPt(WV XA7tQ 7tpocT1jv 7tepl gtLXIXLWaSWCgtLgtIXOAIXAlIXV b TPLMvtltj) 2uv6gtou 7tIXPIXt1)pSL 6 H a r n ac k XIXPIXXtt)PLGtLXWlt ampn $OCV IXfYct) gtLIX1U7tw6j 1 II I r( I ll 7tpO T1)lt SIJltpIXVLGSWC t1)lt IJStIXppUVIJLaewc eLVIXL SIX 7tOtS (lVeAS

eX(17tOCaeL gtLIXlJ-IXptuplaswc H ev T pLgtevtlt) 2ovogtolt OC7tsxtI)GS lJeytat1)v (mougtIXL6t1)11X gtLOC 1qv

I - P II r( I 7tepIXL1SpW eeALLV 1OU WfLOtLOXIXVOALXtOIJOU aUIJOA1) 11)lt ou IJ0VOV etlt T1jv ampv1LlJetwmGw Jlt1otppu6IJlaewc IiAAOC xlXl dlt tqv tWV amp7tIXPIXL-

IJthpwv 7tpOC amp7tOXIXgtOCGtIXGW 1oceWC tv tcJl tXxAY)GLC1-O1LXil 0PYIXVLGlJcJl tWV xIXl Aomwv - 6 gtf ( ) (IXVWIJC1ALWV u7t1)PS t GOV G7tOU0 ClLIX wOS VIX IX7tO UtWC IX7tIXPIXt1)tOC

tvgtiAsXqc IJSAe-t) tWV oc7toltpocaswvtjlt 2uv6i)ou tIXUt1)C 7tpolt XCltiXv61jaLV 11)lt 7tSpClLtepw tOU KIXVOVLXOU DLxcdou -rijlt PESGo TOD(XIXLOV

aLOC 11)lt tv TpL8ev1ltj) 2uv6gtou gtLStfjpljOS lJev 1OCC 7tASLGtIXC tWV xu-PLW1EPWV amppxwv $ltP 6gtv t6SIJSALOU10 u7teat1) glJwlt XlXlwpLGlJeVIXC OUaLWaOUlt O7JlJlXcrLIXlt 1sAst6t1)16c tou XIX1IXGtOC07JC lexPL

Okw XCl1OC 7tSPLOgtOV tOCUt1)v ampvoc-gtwpyckvwotlt tlje OCUA1j XOC1ltX toc xuploce ocutYle YPocfLIJOCC gttS11)-

fLexPL opyocvwcrte 1lie LSPOC7tOGtOAYllt spounde 7tocyx6afLLov XALlOCXOC xoc6w XOC 1WV l0VOCXLXWV tocYlJoctwv XA7t H tv TpLaeV1ltj) 2uvogtolt tcJl ()VtL G1JfLOCVtLKW1OC10lt crtoc6IJoc dlt T1jv tcrtoplocl PE tgtLochoctoc gts tOU KOCVOVLXO) DLxodou $1 tocutcJl 8s XOCL ampltpSt1)pLOC crnou8ocLOtOCtWV

t0 ltpUcrLXOV 7tepOCC 1WV 67tOLWV $1 BOCtLXOCVcJl 201080 (1869-70) xoct 81)IJOGLSUGLr tou IJV1)JltLWgtOUlt lpyou laquoCodex Iuris Canoniciraquo

H t7tLi)PClcrLlt 1WV ampVWtEPW 7tVSUIJ-IXtLXWV wlt xoc 11) fLetocP-pu61J[aswlt xocl t1) ampvtLfLS1OCppu6IJlcrswe t7tt T1jv 8LOCfL6pltPWcrLV tWV

6sLeXtwv amptLVOC amp7toccrX0AOUV TIjv tmGt7JIJ1)v teu KOCVOVLxouDLXOC(OU

361 H Fe i n e cre 463

y6VTltiJV tOU 6pOCtOU OCVOPltiJ1tLVOU 1tOCpocyOVtOlt tij Exx)YjO(q xed OltiJfLoctetocX-1) 0PYOCV(iJ(Jtlt ocuTIjlt XOCt XiXt ocVttOtOLX(IXV txxoOfLtxeuOtlt tOU AtxIXtou PE talt ocnt8pocOetlt H 1tPltiJ-

j N f 1)0 - Ci - 1 ItIXPXLX e1ttotltiJtlt 1tOrVtltiJV crxeoov tltiJV ocYltiJvtOvevtltiJv XIXtIX tY)lt CXXOOfLLXeu-OeltiJlt t1jlt PE wlt 1tpolt to tWV EXXA1)OtIXlt XIXL Atxoctou Ouv(-OTIXtO tolho fLev tx veou TIj EXXA1)oLIX wlt tOU XIXt tOX-1)V Odou XIXt 1tVeufLIXtLxOU xXt l1tepxoOfLtoU 0pYIXVLOfLou tOU 61tOLOU xe-rpIXA etVlXt 6 Koptolt xIXL XIXt OCXOAOU((OCV lIXpOtv tOU 8LXIXtou t1j EXx(1)-Otcxc W Odou XIXL 1tVeufLoctLxOU atXIXLOU TOUtO 8e e1 XIXtGlt1tOAefL1)OLV TIj

XIXt T1j OltiJfLIXtetIXx1j 0pYIXv6JOeltiJ TIj EXXA1)oLOC tOU txxoOfLtXeUOevTo 8tXXLOU Gltut1j ELVIXL ae tv 1tpoXetfLevcp t6XltiJ XGltpIXXT1)pt-0ttx6v Iht d fLOVIXXLXa tocYfLIXtGlt w to tWV KtOtepOtGltvwv ampnvGlt 1)011 CXMltiJlt ocrpltiJOtltiJfLevlX d P E oc1t1Jyopeueto ek t1i fLeA1) IXUtWV tOU KIXvo-VLXOU ALXIXlOU 362 ex fLetIXaoOn et IXUta t0 XOOfLLXOV 1tveUfLIX 01tep aLei1te t0 KIXVOVLXOV AtxIXtov ltfETepOL 8e d to KIXVOVLXOV AtXOCLOJ XGltt lat6t1)tIXtou ALXGlttou363bull KGltO UTCepoxov X(1t t6XltiJlt 1tIXPIXOtIXttXOV tp61tOV tac ocrc6yet tWV 1tVeUfLIXtLXWV t1j

t01) 6 AampvtYj ev tigt IX1hou lpycp laquo8e(2xKltiJfLcp8IXraquo 36pound ev to1toOeni tOV BowpampttoV H ( 61tOLO xIXvovoAbyo yuxn texIXl ltr6JfLIXtt

ev tn KOAOCOetaLm 1tP01hLfL1)Oe XOOfLtX1)V IXYA1)V XlXL a)VIXfLLV r t - Ci - fJ 11 lt XIXt eOUGt(1V IXVtt t1) 1tVI)[I(1TtX1) XGltr v(1)OXeUTIX1)lt efLl-(1vuvOeltiJlt otOtt

ampMIXt AifeOt eOXe1tteto W XGltvovoAbyo eveTcveetooc7io TOll x6crfLov tWV 110-fLLXWV ewotWV XIXt ouxl OC1tO tt1 1t1JY1G t1je tv Xptatigt OC1tOXcltAUyeltiJC ELVcltt ae ( (j)vaUIXOfLO dx6VQc tou BovtrpCltttou tv tltI) 1tIX1ttXigt Op6vcp XIXL d xetpoc tOU poundrpoc xed atGltxY)p0OOovtO (ego sum Casar ego sum imperatorraquo 1tpa ex6vGlt tOU BOVLrpGlttLOU

xGltL tv tn KoAampOet MeTa aptfLOn)toC xoctIXrpepetIXt

t1jc ataGltOXGltAt(1 tou Xpt(Jtoi) Xamppw TWV 1tGlt1ttx()V 8expetGltAtltiJv Etvcuak tigt OVtL ev Oltet dlt to crt6fLlX IXUtOU TOU I1STPOU

xIXtIXa(x1)v tou txxoOfLtxeu6fvTo 1tIX1tt0fLOU 1tpo 61 atIXX1)pocroet Iht aev lX)cre TO GltfLOC tou Gltutoe xIXl fLocptupec 1tOC1tGltt XampptV ct7jlt exxoOfLtXeocreltiJ TIj EXXA1)otIX XlXi TOU 1tA1)P6JfLlXtot7jlt EXXAY)O(IX 1lt Xf7jpOV xIXL AIXOV xIXl t7j fLetIXuGltutwv exOp6tY)to EvGltvtt ae tOU rcPOIXO1tt-

362 U Stu t z Die Cisterzienser wider Gratians Dekret Zeitscrift des Savigny-Stiftung fur Rechtsgeschichte Kanonistische Abteilung49 1919

363 An 0 n y mus Disputatio inter clericum et militem Goldstast I 13 (1297) D em p f amp11 lIliA 413

364 Al i g hie riD ant e Divina Commedia tx8Scartazzini Mailand 1898

mou 7totmxi) amp7tOAUtotPXLote AtyLlltou P6)IL(7VOU (Aegidius Romanus) ulLvOUVtOe XotL tX7totLtOUVtOe amp7t6AUtOV 0 aampvt1jlt tXVtL-tampOOeL U7teptampt1jv tlie ev XptOtijl eAeu6eptote 6gte tU-potVVLi3ot 7tiv OOOtIjILO( r0 ()7toiov Oi31jyei de T1jv 07t0i300A6)OLV tWV ampVOp6)7t6)VS65bull

A )Cl - K - A nLlLltX t IVXotVO(POLV tOU O(VOVLXOU LltXotLOU XClL t1jV e7tO(vooOV eLlt rote XO(vot-pwe 7tVeUL1xtLXalt otlhou TC1)yae 07t0 i3LO(7tpe7tWv XotvovoMY6)V 366

illLotLtepoc 7tpoO7tlaquo6etltX tlltq amp7t0 tOU l30u otiwvoe e7tL tijl OX07tijl tje ex veOU OUv1leOe6)lt tOU KO(vCVtXOU aLXCl(OU lLeta tWV XCll TCIeUILO(tLXWV amppXWV ampq amp1 i3sov toiho va KO(ta toolt KCllovoMycult tootoult ot xO(v6-vee i3txO(tou OUv1leovtO(t ampvO(7toO7tlaquoOt6)e lLeta twv xO(VOV6)V t1)e i3ei3o-JZIOU IhL i31jlLtOupyoe O(htoc xO(1 OX07tOe 7t0(Vt0lt ampA1j60ue 1ltXOCLOU EXXA1jOLW i3eov va etVClL 1) i3tOCXOV[ot ti) ampyamp1t1je368 ltH EXxA1ja(O( 6gte1)

I) - - -I-flXO(1 eoXlv XOW6)VLltX tYj OyO(7tYjlt 10( OLO(lLoPcpoutOlt OuveX6)e e7tL 1ll t-O(OeL rlje amp7toXIXAucp6dO1je ampyamp7tYje tou XpLmou tou ltOiOLou to tlie oltj[ml)lt ev ampYamprrn 1ltIXXOVLotlt 8eov va ampxoAou60uv ot e7tl ampVtmp606)7tOL Tou J-ampALOCIX 1le 0 namp7tIXe PWILYje ( a7tOLOe 8tv eIvoct a Cije $1 C7i EXXAYj-crLq wlt o7tepl)cpampv6)lt a nlaquo7tIXC IvvoxevtLoe a3S9 1luvlt4tevo xlXta Co 80xouv xlXl ampveu euMyou IXh(lXe va xotl

N -l lt I N E ) t T ltVot XIXtltxpY1lIV ucpLmlXlZVYjV XOCVOVLX1jV tIje XXIYj(JLIXC tOCLV fM1 eLVo(L 0 8tlaquoxovolt 07t0XpeOOlZVOC VOILLXWC-OL 7tAeimoL CWV xOvovoA6-Y6)V e1lexoVto ()Ct 0 namp7tOCC eiVo(L 1) ampv6)tlaquorlj e7tl ylje OUve7tWe ou-Ilete T1jv va tOV ()1L6)e va OUlLlLoPcpohlXL 7tpolt Co tmxplXTOUV $1 t7i ExxAYjalq 1ltxltXtOV to a7toiov xO(l t6ewpouv ()CL amp7toteAei ev toMoLlt Clje i3YjAov6tL Odov 8(xottov Kotl otOCYj lLev $1 yevLxO(Le YPO(ILILltXilt 1) tVCOlt twv 6A7t6)V Clje PE

xlXl 7tpoCJtlaquo6eLo( 7tpOC xamp60(paLv tou KocvovtxOU aLXot(OU )(0(1 6e(JZA(6)atV O(utou ()1L6)lt i3LelLoPcpw(1)00(v 0P1j-

lt - J lt - -_---- 7tepLOpLOFV6)V etC O(tIYjV XPLttXYjV Cl)e P E ampAAa - VOlLX1jC t0(1)tIjlt nX

cp6)f)eiaO( O((peOtlt tWV BIXAi3(6)V370 (ex tou amppX1)YOS otUtWV nhpou Blaquo)llou L $VecpotVLOf)Yj XotttX t0 i3eamprepol tOU l20u O(poundWvoe OihoL 07tO T1jv

----________QSLIIet3A A De m p f lvO laquov rreA 177 3SS

Joh von FreiburgJoh Mona-

B u iss 0 n IvO amp1 rritA xod passim

ai

370 A B 0 r st die Katharer Stuttgart 1953

eitl8pIXOtv toXupwv itVZUfLIXTOXPIXTLXWV TcXOZWV eitZXeLPYjOIXV OZfLcfJWOLV TOU IXOT()V aitOXAZLOTLXW eitt aOxIJTLx6v m BampA8LOL 00 fL6vov TO xupo TWV fLUOTYjP[wv XAYjPLXWV TOLOlhou lt5e elzwpouv TOU XAYjpnWU T1j PE 00 fL6vov aiteppL-mov Tx OUyxwpoxcXpna TO itUP xAit aAAx xat lOzwpouV exxoOfLLXzu(kiOav PE w TO fLeya OYjplov eccle-siam malignantium Aito T1j XIXO 0 IIampitli I5v ampitZXcXAOUV laquoTOV itpWTOV AnLxpLOTOVraquo ampJtzMxOYj KcuvOTClVt(VZLOV 3w-pexv itJtIXUOeuroVij PE elvaL ExxAYjOpound1X TOU XPLOTOU To lt5e ITcXJtlXve6eurowpouv w laquocapitem omnium errorum)371

MeyocAuTeplXv xot evOoc ltpopeu TWV TOU umjpev 0 Hus iicrxov oct llt5eClL TOU John Wiclif372 tOU oJto[OU TO epyov mpt TIj JtOCltLxrj (1379) elvlXL to umpexov xpmxov epyov tOU fLeOodwvo mpt tou (MfLocTO TOUTOU 0 Wiclif eltL6UfLwv va eJtocvocltpepl T-f]V ExxAYjOtocV ek apxoc(ocv OCOT1j JtVeUfLOCTLX6TYjTIX lt5LeT)JtWOeuro (UOeLC ochLve ex 6efLeALwv TOV Jt1XltLXOV OWfL6v lepocpx(ocv xOl tv yeveL -0 KIiVOVLXOv ll[-XCltLOV 11) PE Tn ev ampvTL6eOeLJtpo TOV Wic1if a A066Yjpo lt5ev tcrx6-JteL ev apxYi TWV ampywvwv TOU de T1j XIXVOVLXrj T9j P E ampAAa d fLSTocpp66fLLOtv 1X0T1) 8La 11) eJtlXv6lt5ou d 1-ljv lt5wPYampVWoLV 11j apxlX(a ExxAYjOtlX373 H I5fLw XOCL 0ltp0lt5p6TIJ amp e06u amppx1j a ampY6lV lXOTOU Jtpo TOU exJtpoOwJtou T1) PE TOV A060Yjpov ek IX7t60XLOLV ex 11) PE KUPLO OT6zot TWV eltL-6eOeurowv TOU XlXTx T1) PE TO KIXVOVLXOV (XQTrj llpoundxlXLOV TO aJtorov XIXT IXUTOV OuveTefeOev d exxoOL(xeumvT1) ExxA1)O[IX xlXL ampmTtAeOe 10 toxup6Tepov 15pyocvov Jtpo TWV eyxGafLtwv eltL3LW-

TOU Jt1XltLOfLou lt5L ) xol lXoto w lSpyocvov TOU 74

371 E C Q mba Storia dei Valdesi Torre Pellice 31) 372 To (3t(3Atoli t00 Wiclif uTractatus de potestate papae))

Iv tWV Ipoundpycuv WII aLlttltplttY[Jltt-rEUo11vcuv mp 00 Itltt1tLxoO 6eO[JoOxltta ov MeOlttlcuvltt

378 IIp(3A W H a u 0 k tvO ampv OeA 17 $ laquoLuther handelte ursprunglich in dem Bewusstsein seiner kirche einen grossen Dienst zuerweisen indem seinen 95 Thesen den Finger auf die Stelle legte an der der Grad der der Idrche am ersohreckendsten zutage trat Nichts lag ihm zunachst ferner alsdie Absicht eine neue Kirche ins Leben zu rufenDer deutsche Augustiner mtinch te lediglich der Verweltlichung der Kirche entgegenwirken Seine urspriingliche Absicht ging Iediglich dahin die Kirche an ihre rein geisthliohe Aufgabe zu errinern und 80 ihre Haltungund iht Ansehen als-Kir c h ein retteml

1l71i IIp(3A F H e i I e r OeA 314

26

CeAeCn xaChauOel tje 1tOAeWe Elsterthor xaCo 20 COU 1520 CO Corpus Iuris Canonici yeyoloc Co orcOtOl 6ewp1j(1) mo Cou Emil Brunner wc fXOl (JeyaAuCepal xat whjc Cjc ll1tO COU Aou61jpou tiiJI 95 OeOe6ll Cou xaCo Crol ampltpeOltUl 375bull Kat aih1) ampx6(J1) 1) COU KavoltxoU ALxa(ou xaCeOCY) etc C0c 1tepLOXOCC t1texpocCY)Oel (JeCapp66(JtOLC ot K(61)Y1)Tat Cou Kavo-vLXOU ALxatou 10 Cpa1toul 1tPOC C1jc t1CtOTf)(J1)C 70U ALXatOU xat 81) Co PWI1aLXOV AtxawlI376bull IIapoc 1au1a rll1tpo1eOtal-1Lxat xow6CY)1Zlt 8sI 1j10 d (J1j OU(Jltp6lVWe XtxL 1tPOC Co 11je VO(JLXjC t1CtOTtj(J1)C ubi societas ihi ius 377 va amp1toxC1jOouv xaL tLVa 0 Aou(1)poC xapax11)p(Oa tb KavovLxov A(xawv 11je PE 1)pyavov 1OU 1)pvet1o xal ampvayxaL6CY)Ca 1OU Kavo-VLXOU ALxatOU 11)1 0PyOCVltUOLV t1j EXxA1)Otac Oewc 1tpOe ExXA1)OLoAoypoundav PE we

xal ampvOpltu1ttV1)V 1tAeUpOCV etc 1=tjc 6da xal ampopoc1ou o Aou(1)po (hL ExxA1)Ota eLvaL amp6pa10c ExxA1)Opounda xa1 a01ov dVcxL laquoXOLvwvtcx 1ttOtewc xcxl 1tveu(Jct1oc dypoundou tv 1at xap8poundaLe) (Societas fidei et spiritus sancti in cordibus) 0 Ao(61)poc 1tapa6ewpet

OAOXA1)pou xcxl 11)11 opa11)v ExxA1)Otav ampUoc etc pLX1jV 1Lva xal 8eutepwouOav O1)(JaOpoundal OO()6AW 6ewpouOa ampAoc(1)1ov 0 Aou(1)po xa1oc Crov 1tcxpexxA(Oewv C1jc PE U1te1teOev tv 1tpOxeL(Jevltjgt d [JeyaAu1epal txetv1)e 1tAOCV1)V

ExxA1)OtaV amp1tO C=tjc ocoplthou OUve1troc xcx1 ouOiav 1tpo 11)11 fmo t1j PE xal ampopocCou ExxA1)Ota 1aoCY) W 1tpo (Je1ocOeOLv 1ouxev1pou 1=tje amp1to opaC1j dc oc6pcx1ovExxA1)0(av378bull 11jc 8LotLpeOew 1a6t1)C C1jc EXXA1)-

I 6 poundI I I EeLI QpaCY)v XaL a paCov xaL 1) 1tp0i0I1)lt 1) xaL aopatOu x-XA1)O(cxlt etvcxL xat 1) ampVC(OTOLX0 TOU ALxatOU 11je EXxA1)Otcxe d Oetov xal ampl6p6l1Ctlol Kat 10 (JSI 6e1ol IpoundxeL taxUI tl Tn

-xtil

375 Ern i 1 B run n e r Das Missverstandnis der Grehe Stuttgart 1951 13) 96 ((Die entscheidende Tat del Reformation Luthers war dieVerbrennung des Corpus iuris Canonieil)

541middot566 E i e h rna n n-M 0 r s d 0 r f lvf) amp1 11) 16 A Hag e n Prin-

378 H D 0 rn b 0 i sZur Revision M fjv ere) 166

sic rcX tije yux1je tou oJeasc To ampV6PN7tivov ev tn 3poundxocov -ri)v cpyamp-v6laiv t1jc ExxAf)aLocc 7tpOe to xcxta x6cr[Lov 3txocov eXA) 51 L3L6tu7tov IIampv6le xcxta OV Aou01)pov t0 eXVOpN7ttVOV ev n 3[-XOCtOv 3ev cruv3eeuroCXL 7tpoe -ri)v eX7tOAUP6laLV wv eXVOp6)7t6lV ampn tXSL 3suts-psuouacxv t1f)[LcxaLcxv crX07tOUV de tv bv6[LcxtL t1jc eXyamp7tf)C 3LcxrfpYjrnvt1jc xcxVOVLXijC ev 7j ExxAYjatq Oih6l ro 7tpcuaOJLXOV KOCVOVLXOV

01) [L6vov 3h eX7tsretEaEv e7tampv030v Eic to amppXEy6vou EXXAI)OtOCC eXAM tije 61dcxc 3tcxLpeOE6lC Odou xcxt ampvOp6l7ttVOU 3LXCXtOU xocteatYj xOOrLXOV 3poundXOCLOV 0 AouOYjpoc xcxtexcxuaE to Corpus Iuris Cano-nici ampAA oct AouOYjpocvcxt xOLv6Yjtse h t7j 1je 3wpYCXyNaE6le cxoampv

va 7tOAMe aOtou R ooaLN3Yje Ou[L-tou OuvtOtOCtCXL 7tpOXSL[Levltp t1je xcxvo-

380VLxije tampSO)e TIle EXXAYjutOCe ampnl OU IIamp7toc de 1ou xOltJ[LtX01Je amppxoncxe 1R PE ampVL3pampOs6le 7tpOe -ri)VU7tO 1amp1 7tpotsarocl1tXWV U7t01t[LYjaLv

l(oct 7tOCpCXeSNpYjatv 1fie o1oc1je EXXAl)OtCXC h6vtatv ItL [LCiAAOV r17t0 ije ev T1Laevtltp xed etpEijc 07tOU3OCL6Yjtoc 1ije ExxAYjatOCe XCXL

t1f)[LOCOtocv tOU ampv016l7ttVOU 7tCXpampyOV1OC XOC( 3LXOC[ou381 Oe XOC1OCXYj1LatL-xwc 7tCX1sl1jpYjltJsv ev 7tpoxzt[Levltp 6xocp3tvciAWe Bellarmin (t 1621) PE dVOCL toou o1octOC bpyocvLa[L6e il7t6le XOCL 382

Y7tO e7t13pocaw 1fie OtOCutYje Tije EXXAYjatOCC 0 XOCp3LVampALOC A 1I0UvOV 7tEpL E t 1Be11armm rrpOStYj etC roV cxx a XXIl)aLOCC O1LltJ[LOV EI

XOCVOVLXOU 0 67tOLOC t1O xoct 0 emxpoctwv [LexpL ev tTI 7tS-1tOx7i tijc OU KOCVOVLXOU ije PE laquoEcclesia est coetus hominum eiusdem christianae fidei professione et eorundem Sacramento-

379 IIp3A H Lie r man n Deutsches EvangeIisches Kirichinrecht Stutt- _ gart 1933 cr1)A 21 laquoAber das Recht bleibt wenn GottistJhmWie in allemileBcne---------

Das unterscheidet von die evangeli-sche Auffassung vom Kirchenrecht grundsatzlich von del katholischen die funda-mentale Satze ihles Rechtes als ius dinvinum auf unmittelbar gottliche Gesetz-gebung zuriick fUhrtraquo

380 O IIpotecrtampvtoct xoc61))lJtocl tou KoclOllxov Atxoclou Gunther Holstein xocl J oh Heckel crUVS3OCAAOl 1lt -ri)I 8tocltp6mcrtll too t0V

xocl Atxa(ou ltXlt69ewlt Aou61)pocllijlt I8tocLnpov sv8twpepol ltPOOXampAecrOCV ocl epyoccr(at too teASl)toc(oU Initia iuris ecclesiastici Protestantium Munchen 1950 xocl Lex charitatis Eine Juristische Untersuchung uber das Recht in der Theologie Luthers Munchen 1953

381 IIp3A M S c h m a u s all cre ft01 _382 R Bella r min Disputationes de controversiis chirstianae fidei

adversus hiuustemporis haereticos (1586-1593) laquoEcclesia enim est coetus homi-num ita visibilis et palpalibis ut est coetus populi Romani vel regnum-Galliae aut respublica Venetorum))

28

rum communione colligatus sub regimijle legitimorum pastorum ac praecipue unius Christi in terris vicarii Romani Pontificisraquo383 Ev Tltl OPLO(Lltl TOUTtp e(LqgttXEveTtXL OtXqgteOTtXTtX emxptXTouOtX TjC 3LtXLpeOeUlC

0ptXTjlt xtXl ampopaTou EXXIJOLtXlt xtXl tXIJTOTeAOUlt 3wpytXvOeUllt T1jlt opocTjc tXuTjlt 7tAeUpocc OihUl ou3dlt ylveTtXL ev Tltl OPLO(Lltl TOUTtp Myolt 7tept T1jlt EXXAY)Olalt amplt (Mou xtXOL3pu(LtXTOlt Oe(LeALUlOevTolt 07t outou tou htXv-OPUl7djOtXVTOlt 1tou TOU 0eou ou3e 7tepl T1jlt OeltXlt 7tpOeAeuOeUllt Tiiw (LUOtYjPLUlV

3e ou3e 7tept TOU OX07tOU gv etvtXL xexAeL(LevY) tvtX eX7tAY)pcrn I I A rt ltY ( I jIev Ttp XOO(Ltp TOUTtp XPLt(J)C oe eV Ttp OpLO(Ltp TOUCtp (xVTLXtXTp07tTLeTtXL Co e7tl7te30v eqgt 00 eoplOxeTo TiJv OxeOeUlv EXXAY)oLOCC xed AL-xolou ev T1j TOU KtXVOVLXOU ALXtXLOU Tjlt PE (LeXPL Tjlt TOU BtXTLXtXVOU (1869-70) XtXL Tyenjc 3Y)(L00LeuOeUllt TOU Codicis Iuris Canonici

H exxoO(LlXeuOLC TOU 7ttX7tLXOU OeO(Loue7tL T1j TOU (mOLOU TO 7toAheu(LtX T1jlt PE eXtXptXxTY)ptoOY) amplt (LovtXPXtx6v TO ampItLxd(Levov elt6v6gtv ampVTL(raquopacreUlv ex Tiiw ampyUlVLOOeltUlV XtXTx eXXOO(LLxeU-OeUllt TYlC PE OOTOL MVtXVCtXL vx XtX1tXCtXyouv ampC ampXOAOUOUle

tX) de 101)lt TOV 7ttX7tLXOV OeO(Lov ampC OeO(Lov OeLou 3L-xtXLou XtXL ampe ampVUlTOCTY)V ampPX1Jv T1je Y-Yle EXXAY)oLac XtXL e7tL(raquoLchoVTtXC

Oe(LeALUlOLv 3Lx T1je eVtXp(LOvlOeUle tXUTOU 7tpOe TO ampAY)Oee 7tveu(LtX Tyenje ev XPLoTltl amp7tOXtXAUoeUllt de TOUlt ll7ttX(raquooue rOU e7tLcrx07tLO(LOU

OUVO(raquoLO(LOU otTLvee e7te3(Ulxov (LeTtXppuO(LLOLV Tje PE OU(LqgtVUle 7tpOlt TO 7toAhtW(LtX Tyenje ampPXO((tXe ExX1)OltXlt (raquoLx Tjc 07tOTtXy1je TWV IItX7twV P(LY)e etc CeXe otxOU(LevLXxe y) Etlt TOUe amp7tOpp(7tTOvtoe 1eAolt

101 7ttX7tLXOV OeO(Lov amplt dvCmOe(Levov 7tpOC Co 7tveu(LO( XtXL 1Yl amppXtX(o(C EXXAY)OLtXlt OlhUl tX) 1WVampYUlvLOOevTUlv

(raquotx Oe(LeALUlOLv TOU 7ttX7tLXOU 6eO(Lou OeOw 10U (raquoLe1U7tUlOev 7tepL

ioult8tro--XUptUlTepOUe 7ttXpOCyOVTac oi1wee OuveTeAeOtXv

1 TO 7tveU(LtX TYle amp7tepwpLOTOU XUpLtXPXLtXC XOCL XtXL 2 XOO(LLXWV dytXOwv Ete TO 7tepLqgtY)(LOV ((De considerationeraquo

TOU 7tpY)v (LtX6Y)10i3 TOU IIamp7ttX Euyevpoundou

383 II Controversia I lib III De ecclesia militante c

OOlt 6 iXO6 xed 6v IM7tiXV we ov laquoampV6liXOV WV ((1)7touPYWVraquo ((summus inter ministrosgt) Meoc crqi08p6I)oe XiXe7tO-MWI)crev b ampy 7tAEOVe(oV xd qnAOpyuppoundiXV iXtwec ampXUPLampPXOUV de xot 6ecr(Jwv iXOOXPiXO-

ampvampyxlV 7tWXdiXC voc ooc xiXexoviXC eX ampV6l1euroPiX ampviXcpep6(Jevoc l3poundCf dc 00C 16youe OU IIepou

XiX xpucr(ov ooX 07tamppxeL (JOLmiddot IS 8e rOUrO crOL 3pound8w(JLmiddot iii 6v6fLiXL Itjcrou XPLOOU OU 7tepmampeL)384 XiXt XiX1euro-

cpepeo Ouvtj6e(iXC TWV lliX7tampv XiXt ampvwTepwv TLAOOXWV T9jC iXUA9jC wv veX cpepouvampv8U(JiXOliXc XPuOou xod amppy6pou m7tOLxLA(JeviXC 8LltX 7tOAUT[-(JWV AWWi xiX6lthc XiXL XiXTamp occ iXOWV OUv08eLiXv TWV 07t6 mpiX-

(l I 1 bullTLWTWV liXliXPWV wcrTe ViX Otj(JLOUPYtjiXLtj eVTU7tWOLC Wlt XiXpOCXTYJpLOTL-XWC b ampywC Bepvampp80c ISTL 0 1lamp7tiXC eViXL b 8Lamp80xoe (JiiMov TOU Mey KWiOTiXVTpoundVOU 1tOCPamp rOU A7t00T6AOU llerpou385bull

H 8L8liaxo)(iX TOU Bepvampp80u amp7te8piXOe amp (JeuroYLOTiX e7tL TOU 1lamp7tOC Euyevlou r xocl amp7tecpepe WpLO(JeviXC dc T9jC 7tiX-mx9jc iXOA1jC eALXWC lS(Jwe ot 1lamp7tiXL eve(JeLviXv de 7tepl 8uo 6ewpIiXv xiXl 7tepL TOU I1amp7tOC ampe TOU tepewc XiXTeX MeAXLOe8ex 8L8ocaxiXAliXV TOU tiy Bepvampp80u euroAtjcr(J6vtjOocv 6e(JeALWOLV TaU 7tocmxou 6ecr(Jou XOCTiX7toM(Jtjcrw OU 7tVeU(JOCToc XiXl TOU XU-PLiXPXLX9jC XiXl AAA 7tepl TOU7tiX7tLO(JOU 7tpoOmk6eLIX ou tiy Bepvampp30u eOpe TOOC OUVeXLOTampC xcd (JampALOTOC ihompe7twv xocvovoA6ywv TOU 120u 130u xiI 140u OCLWVOC xocl xiX6lYYJTWV TampV IIocve7tOTtjpiwv -ijc Bologna xoct TWV I1OCPLO(WV 386

ot 07t0iOL 8LeT()7tWGrItV cr7tOUaiXLO(hoce 7tepl TltIV xiXl 6ptjOxeUTLXWV tPXWv e7tt Tn TWV 07t01wv aeov vamp M1eurou66vtjTIXL

384 ATCaOt y 6 385 R crTCOu3C1tatampt1l 1X)t1l 3t31X0lltClA1X au ampy Bepvampp3au TCpoxoOer (LqClAU-

tpctv tvumoOtll Mv fjcpfJj (lTC Iht 6 Clyta Bepvap3ac )tept Prov fJeropClv 3ex6(Levoc lht amp(Lcp6eplX tamp ampv1jxauv etc (uterque ergo ecclesiae) to TCIIEU(LiXttxbv cpoc 3eav vamp XPlJOt(LOTCOtijtlXt fmo TIjc EXxAlJOtct atamp XetpOC ou OtpClttooau ltlAM tiii tou ieperoc xlXl tjj 3tltXtCly1J au Clotoxpamptopoc KIXtoc tov Bepvap30v 0 IIampTCtXc etlctt bpeut xlXd -rlJv tampLI MeAXLOe3excruyxevprov tv

TJV e eauOClv 0 Bepvampp3o liTCaXClAe1 ov IIampTClXv sacerdos magnus summus pontifex tu princeps episcoporUIlltu haeres apostolo-rum tu primatu Abel gubernatuc Noe patriarchatu Abraham ordine Melchise-dech dignitate Aaron actoritate Moses iudicatu Samuel petestate Petrus unctione Christusraquo

386 IIp3A L B u iss 0 n amp11 OeA 2

30

petestatis 1WV I1cx7tWV e1lt 1oclt OeILeAL6gtlgteLlt euroV10AOClt liyCX1tY)lt xcx OC7t01eAeL ILeytOtYlV 7tpoOrpopocv 1WV ampywVLOOeV1WV ellt 101

10ILeOC 1Yjlt meULiX1LXljlt 10U I1cxmxou OeOILou ot l7tOLm eurovYP(L6-ampyct7tYjV xocl (potestas et caritas) 387 R 7tpOO7tampOeLOC cx1Yn)

t1UVe1eAecrev elt opinionis communis li7torpcxOLO1txwltdlt 101 7tepWpLa(LOv 6jlt li7tOAU1cxPXLcxlt

et8o(Lev amp7t6AU10V XUPLcxpX(OCV erp oc7tctaYlt 1=ijlt un oupocvov x1(aew388 IJVeuro7teLcx 1ljlt u7to1ctlewlt 1cxU1Ys 1Yj 7tcxmxYjlt pienitutinis petestatis de

TYje ampyct7tYjlt etvcxt Iht xcxt epound TOCe 7tepL7tT6gtaete xcxO amplt ou8eurov urp(a1cxTotL vO(LtXOV amp7tcxyope)eTcxt euroveuropyetcx

Ooc liYrXTCl)v Ooc 1WV m-Inwv MeT 18Lcxt1epcxe 8e euro(Lrpampaew 0 XotvovoA6yo Zabarella TO [Jeye60 TYje iuOuvlj eLV(J(L dlt 1OC 7tept7tTwcretlt 10U (Xexv8ex-Ata(Lou10aotmll xcxt TO ampW(Lex etvext f5ljJtcr1ov xcx T1)e

euromx1dveuro1cxt eurorp amp7trXcnllt 11) ExxAy)a(cx389 KexTea1Yj 7te7to(OYat TWV KcxvQvoMywv TexU1Yj (ht eu6uvI) TOU I1ltX7tex P6gt(LYlt euroV 7tept7t16gtcret ocyrX7tYjC xex

euroVVotcxe 8txextocruvYC xcxL euroVTeUOev etC 10 TY)C EXxAYcrtexe 8eurov UrpLO1exTcxt (L6vov 19jc ev

oupexvcj) EXXAYGLcxe linoc xCYl 11)C cr1pexTeUoILeVYjC euro7tL yY)390 revtxw oa va et7t71 Iht Oe(LeuroA(wmc 10 7tcx-

1CtXOU TOU 7tveuLiX10 19j ampXCYTcxcrxeOU TrXcrewlt 7tpOC XUptcxPXLcxv TO 07tOLOV e7teXpC11eL dc 101 euroXxocr(Ltxeu6ev1cx 7tcxmcrILov de 7tveu-(Lot ampyltx1t1)C xcxL euroV ex7tetvwcret 8tcxXOVLcxC oc7te1eAeL 101 7t660l 7trXV1WV

387 etvlXt tv 1tpoxetlLtvltP i]ampvlXtpep6eLOlX epYltX(l(lX tou L Buisson 0 01tototXltXt61tLV e1tweAoult epeJVI)lt f)V 1t7)yrov Iijc mpt680u tltXQTI)lt elltx[peL TI)v btiemiddot xtrov t)(1tpoOampltWV fOUltVeuILIXft)(OU )(601L0u Iijlt AoOewe ot (mOrOt OUVettAe(lIXV etlt tov ltepto-PtOILOV Iijlt ltlXmxljc ampltOAUfapX[lX )(lXL TI)v ivtlXItv Iijc plenitutinis potestatis tou nampltO( el f00 6eLEALamp8et tvfOAOO lijc ampyamp1t7)C )(ltxt f1jc 8t)(O(wcrWYj n XIXPO()(TI)PI(Jft)(roC ItltXpIX-

middotmiddot_-t1J1leimiddotomiddotL Bu issoJliv6ampv creA2JNuf nann waJe5im spaJeI1Mittelaleriiberllanpt die Gewalt zuriickzudr1lngen Ein solches Ringen wird nicht

von Elite des AbendlandtlS die sittlichen Masstabe ffir die Handhabung papstHcher aber auch kOniglicher Gewalt til erkennen Erst dann konnten die Ergebnisse solcher Geistesarbeit geschichtlich wirksam werden)

388 A UT 66 I (leA 329 laquoWie schon gezeigt wurde hatte die opinio

inder Nachfolge Christi zu beacltenraquo 61

I I twv europyOCO eurovtwv XOCt 7tpOOeuroJXo[LeuroVWV uta [LeuroOOU twv atwvwv tI)v euroV tqgt amp)Yj6d euroUaYYeuroALXlt] 7tVeuroO[LaL tOU7tamO[Lou A7to tOU 130uocLw-

rn em3px0euroL xat tlj 3t3aOXaALa ou 1)yoU[Levou Joa-chim von Fiore e3I)[Lwupyf)6Y)Oocv d euroupea Opw[Lata tOU 7tAY)pw[Lato

PE b60uOtocOttxat tampleurot xaL1) eA7tt tlj eAeuroOOzw 1oU ampYYeuroAtXOu 7tOLjdVO (Pastor angelic us Papa angelicus Papa spiritalis Papa evan-gelicus) ( 6laquo exxa6amppYl xat 6x evwOY) EXXAY)Ot()(V Q3e xapa-xtY)piOttxw 7tapatY)peuro1 tlt] 1267 0 [Leya xaL tptAOOOtpO tou [LeuroOoc(wvo Roger Bagon laquoamp7t0 teuroOOapxxov1a hwv 7tpOeurotpY)1zo6Y) amptt xata too Xp6vou 1OO1ou 6il et IU7toc 0 07tOto 6a exxa6amppYl to Kavovt-xov btxaL0v ExxA-I)Otav tOU 0euroou amp7t0 1WV 1euroxvltXO[Lxtwv xat amp7toctwv 1WV vO[Ltxwv b) H eA7tL atI) 7teuropt 1lj eAeuroOOeurow OU Papae angelici avzppL-

Itn xa1laquo ra 1eAt) tOU 7tapeuroA66v1o OCLWVO xat 1a ampPXa tOU 7ta-p6v1O EL eA7tt3a 1aOtY)v ampOtpaAw 3ev evat Suvatov 1laquo OufLlLSttXYl XaL7tii mO1o 7t06wv gVWOLV -rWV EXXAY)mwv391

H Seurou1epa xa1Y)yopta tWV ampywvt06ev1wv xa1laquo 1OU EXXOO[LLXzu6ev-10 7tocmXOU 6zOW)u 101 IIamp7tav 61 ampVW1amp1l)v 1lj ExxAt)O(a E7tz3twxeurov 61 [Leuro1appo6fLtOtV tOU 7tOAmO[Lato lj PR OU[Ltpwvw tlt] 7tOAtteuroOfLa1t tlj amppxata ExxAY)Ota Sta 1lj mo-

1ou IIx7ta euroL ta otxou[Leurovtxil OI)v6Sou H x(vY)Ot alhY) 1OU EmOxomO[Lou OUV03LO[LOU SVLOX06t) L3tq amp7t0 1OU 130u atwvo392 27tou3at6-teuropot ex7tp60w7tot ampveSdx6YJOavol Konrad von Gelnhausen Heinrich von Langenstein Pierre d Ailly [LampALO1OC 8e 0 J Gerson xatDietrich von Niem nxvta 6[Lro 61 6il t3w[Leurov xatw1ep(i) 0 Nikolaus von Cues (Ntx6Aao (1401-1461) euro1WV [LeuroY(O1WV 8LOCVOY)1WV tlj e7toXYj tou Kap7to 1aO) 1OU Ou108tO[LoU 1) OOYXAYJOt xat epyiXOlaL tWV b rn bOOeurot laquootXOU[LeuroVLXWV 2uv68wv)) tYj PE yvwo1wv we [LwopyY)Oav 7tOAAlaquoe EA7t[SOC eurol 100e OuYXp6vou 1WV 6tt 3tv amp7teurotXeuro 7toM 0 xp6voe tlj tEAtXYj xa1LOXOOeuroW tlj ampAYJ60u fLoPtpYj 1OU EXXAY)OtiXOtxou 7tCAmO[LiX1Oe Ofhw 1) 201080 1lj (1409) xat 11je Kwvmocntae (1414-1418) amp11 1) Ev Aylqgt IIveuroO[Lan xat Ou[LtpWVWCrn Kavo-

F Baethgen Der Engelpapst Halle 1933 Herbert G run d man n Die Papstprophetien des Mittelalters Arch f Kulturgescch 19 (1928) 77-138

392 (raquo I M 0 U p (Y t [ 0 u otX01)J-eILX1) EOvo8o xoc IIOC1CLXO 6ecr(J6$ve dIIijp(3A A K nee r Die EntstellUng der Konziliaren Theorie tv Romische Quartalschrift zur christliche Altertumskunde und kirchengeschichte Suppl 11893 K Hi r s c h Die Ausbildung der Konziliaren TheQrie im 14 Jab 1903 F B Ii met z r i e d e r Das Generalkonzil im gr 0 sse n abendland Schisma 1904

32

LXn cruyxpotou[Levt) Lov080c 6gtt KIX60-ALX1j EXXAt)crLOCt ocn e06elIXt ocnOto) XpLltITOU OCnOteAei Utlcrtt)V t) IXu6evtLIXV IHnet bcpet-AOUV f)TCIXX01)V tou IHnoc d ta ocnOcpampOEL otXOU[IZVL-x1jt Luv6800 XIXt ei tocc occpopGOCt ett n(Ottv tii)v OXLO[LamptWV EXXAt)cr(IXt XIXtlaquo te xoct tOC[LeAt) Ta ocnOcpampOeLt tIXOtIX TIjc laquoOIXOU[LeVL-x9jt Ouv680uraquo 1twt 8LOCOt)[L0t PW[LIXLOXIX60ALXOI

LOtOptXOt tOU ntXpeA66vt0c IX1WVO XlXt tWV npwtepylXtWV XtXta middottwv ocnocpocOeWV Luv680u t0) BtXttxocvou (1870)

neuropt 1ttX1tLXOU OCAtX(1)tou xoct J g n a diu s D 0 II i n-g e r m6lXvwt to yeyovbt -rl tWV 80middot([L(hwv

bull XPLOTLIXVLX1jC EXXAY)OLIXt39 To nIX1tLxbv XIX1a tov Dollinger tWV ocnocpocOewv OuI6ampou ocv()()e6t) dt [HOw tou

XIXt OLW1tt)PW [Lev OCAAOC crIXCPWt eXIXpocXtt)pLaet) 6gtt nMvt) XtXt xoctampXPt)OLt bull H 0010amp0 BOCcrLAeLOC (1431-1449 )395 xoct ettnAeOl

euroVLOXUcrEtamp ocnocpampcreLt t1jt el lhL IIoc1tCXC amp1eu t1jt euroYXPLcreuroWt tWI [LeuroAWI t1j otXOU[Leuro1LX1jt Luv6Sou ou8e[L(tXV

twv europytXOLWI tlit OlXOU[IZILx1jcLUI6ampou 8LIXAUcreWC

At OnouampIXL6toctIXL tXOtIXL OC1tOCPOCOeLt tWI [LetlXppu6[LLOttXWV Luv68wv 18uv1)6middot1j01XI 8ultITuxwc va $V tl LlOOeuroL m IIocnocL8toc t1jt

euroV ltPeppamppltf (1438) XtXL croveXe1ltf 8La tlie euroV ltPAwpenltf XIXL teALXWC 8La t9jc 5t)teuro1 AlXnplXIip (1516) laquoOIXOU[IZVLXWVraquo OUv68wl xlXtp66OtXI va

tampc ocnocpltxOeLC twv [LEtOCppU6[LLltITLXWV OuI6ampwv XtXL va euronlXItXcpe-pOUV

Ihpa tlXihtX i)me to 1tveu[LtX tOU t1tLOX01tLO[Lou OUVOampLO[LOU ampAA va zmpoOw7t1jtIXL unO O1tOUSIXLOtamptWV euroxnpoOnwv t1jc

6eOAOYLX1jt OXzljJewt xoct va xocta t0 [LOCAAOV XtXL Hff7t4USocLOteplX 0U011)

eLVIXL to tou NLXOAlaquoOU 10 euronLyptXcpO[Levov Concordantia Ca

ca 0 NLX6AMt ampLOC un ocOtou ocvtXnwx6etOtXI 6ewpLtXV nept too OUVOSLXOU XtXL AeL1OUpr1)[LOCtOt

rianus redivivus Koctaol euronLOXOnLXOt

ganisation Inst St

I OeOflOe OeOfloe OeLOUaLXOCLOU rdv1ee ae ot enLOXOnOL evOCtatamp8oXot 1OU AnoO1OAOU IH1poU xoct (Oot npoe ampM1)AOUe At oclhwv aLOCqgtOpIXt eLVOCL XOC1IXPW aWLK1J1LXOU 00 xol 0 npwTetov 1Lflr)c ampnevefl1)01) ete 1OV tn(OXonoy Pcilfl1)e Myltl 17je OttOewe 1ije nOAewc P()fl1)C tv 1ij)amppXO[CP Xo-OfLCP Ex1oe 1O)ou 6 tntOXo1toc PcilJ1)c ampn01eAet xO1ltX 1OV XOC( 10 xev1pov lmitatis----ijc tXXA1)ClLM1LXijC aWLx1)Oewc fIiiaoc ISfLwe vO(J06nx1) aLxoa1Lx1) apOCa1IJPL011)C 1OU IHno ampqgtopwao dc 11)v EXxA1)OLOV taXOv xed xupoe fLOVOV unO npoUnoOemv xol 1ije eyxp(aewc OCU1ijc uno 17je O(XOUfLevLxijc

Ecclesiae-aLa 1WV exnpoacilnwv whije TeAzwc ae txnpoawnoc 1ije olxOufLzvLxije EXXA1)aLOCe e XOC1a 1OV 1)

2uvoaoc 10 xupOC 1WV ampnoqgtampaewv 1ijeono(oe OOMAWe ex 1ije tyxp[aewe 1OU IIampnoc Movov 3e h 2uvoaoe

aUfLnopcfOtMLv 1OU xYLOU IIveufLO1Oe va 1a -F oOYfLO1O 11)lt tJnoutJocL01OC11) oe eLVaL ev npoxeL(Jevcp n ocnoLC 1ou 1) 1mocu11) uno 1ije OLxoUfLenxijc 2uv6aou OttamaLe 1WV aOYfLamp1WV 1ije Exx)lJa[oeah ytve-rocL xO1 O01opXLXOV 1ponov xAA tv aUflqgtwv[q 1OU nA1)pcilfLO1OC 1ne EXxA1)aLOCe (consensu et legatione omnilflli fidelium)H 2ovoaoe unepxeLttXL 1OU IIampnoc XOC( 6 XpLa1Oe 11)e ExxAIJOloce 2uvenwC6 IIampml1 3h tX01O-

(ipso iur)3) 3zuOuvaLv 1WV Tf)C OLxoufle-VLXljC 2uvoaou ampAACl flOVOV 10 1LfL1)1LXOV 1LfLijC

1f)c OeaZWC ttXuT1)e xocl un O)1WV 1WV nocnwv 11je nepLo8ou 1WV OLxOUfLZVLXC)V 2uvoawv t1)C amppxo[oe EXXAlJcrloc xnOaeLxvoeL XtX1eX TOV Kou-

0U1O fleuroV 1) un tX01WV Oeme 11) unoypocqgt1)e 1WV de TOC nplXX1LxeX 1WV 2uvo8wv Id tOCC unoypoqgtoce 1WV ocXAcov tmaxonwv 1OU1O 8e uno 1WV nocnwv 6ewp1)aLC T1je xnoAlhou aUfL(1opqgtcilaewc 11je EXXA1)a[OCe

01)c xoc tyxcilfLLOV oc011)c 0 IIamptcie aU[Lqgtcilvwcnpoc t1jv 8LaocrrxocA[OCV1OU MVO1OL

voc Tj 1 ampVOC1pepll 1a xnoqgtampaELe 1WV 01xoUfLevLxwv 2uvo8wv amp)) cmAWe veX epfL1)VeOO1) XOC( Ex-reAeCrn ltxur1Xc (pbtestas superintendiae) 2uvenwe 6 IIampnocS ooah npwTetov 6nepoxljc olxou-

0 3tltXTunwaw TOU 8ev eVOCt ampAA amp unepampvw 1WV ampAAWV npw-voe ((Papa non est universalis episcopus sed su per alios primusraquo )

IIoc1pxpxou 1Ije ()A1)e EXxA1)altxe ampveu lS[lwe j I - I E _ 0 l -npltXYfLX1LXIJe eurom 1WV XX11)Otwv ufLoVOV oeuro olOCV1L T1)erl1IWV

2uv030u ampAAa)ed 2uv6aou 18locc ocJ1OU exxA1)-OtIXa1LKIjc mpL-pepdltxc3euro0[leOe1ixL amp IIampnIX XltXPOCX11)fHOtlXWe nocpltx-

9EOJorrA TOllOC AB TaOxoC A 3

YjPEt b 6emv euroV tjj rlotou 2uv68ltgt o(rlV 6eow gxouv XrlL ot 7trltPLOCPXrlL 1 AVrltOA9jlt euroV trltlt rlOtampv Ouv68oLlt396

H 07tOU8rlLOtOCtlJ rlfStlJ tOU 7tOALtEU(LOCtOlt t9jlt EXXAYjOLrtlt xed d8L-Xc1tEPQV 7tepl tampV OxeCJewv OtXOU(LEVLX1jlt Xrlt llocmxou 6e0(LoU 8L8rl-ClXcULrl tOU 7tept tOU 6e(Loct0lt toampou m7tOWYjCJLV OY)-(LrlVtLX9jlt (Lepti3olt tou 7tAYjpc1(Lritolt t9jlt PE OfStw i3e elYjyettrlL 8LrltL b 6ptrl(L-

t9jlt llrl7tLX1jlt amp7tOAUtOCPXtoclt XrlLtampV (LetrlPpU6(LLOtLXampV 2uv6i3wv 8La t9jlt 5Yjlt euroV ArlteprlvCgt (1516) laquoOtxOU(LEVLx1je)) 2uv680u 00 (L6vov 7tp60-XrlLPOlt ampMa XrlL t0iJt rliha (LOLPOCLOlt i3La riJv ev6tlJtrl t9je LutLx1jC EXXAYjOtrtlt H amp7totuXpoundrl tampV (LtrlppU6(LLOtLXampV 2uv6i3wv 7tpOe euro7trlvocqJopocv tou 7tOALteU-(Lrltoe t9je PE dlt t9je amppXrlpoundOCe EXXAYjCJpoundrle wi3yYYjCJev (Leuropoetampv Xrltrl7tO)E(LOUVtwv euroxxoO(Lpoundxeuow tou 7tOC7tLXOU 6e0(Lou oUXL 7tMov de (LEtrlppu6(LLOW ampM de amppVYjOLV xrll rlOtou

y) 0 7trlmxolt 6eCJ(Lolt t6crov Xrltx toue 7tp08po(Loult tampV(LetrlppU6(LLcrtampV BriAi3toue O1ivi Wiclif HUS397 xA7t 6001 XrittOMegt (LiiMov Xrlta 1OUe (LetrlppU6(LLcrtae A066Yjpov xA7t eOptCIXetrlL tv ampVtL6eOeL 7tpbe t0 MYj6elt meu(Lri tou EUrlyyeAbu XrlL amppxodrlv t1je EXxAYjCJpoundrle 8Lopyivwmv m Aomol (Letrlppu6(LLcrtocl xA7t 8LrlqJWVOUVtEC 7tpoe tav AoUOYjpov de 7tAetOtrl OY)(Letrl i3Li3rlClXrlALrllt tou crU(LqJWVOL (Let rlutou de OqJoi3potoctlJv Xrlta tou 7trimO(Lou euro7tWemv XrlL 7tpocy(LritL bull

7tiiOriV 7tpoyevecrteprlv OU (LOVOV 8La olutlJtrl tampv mpl tou poundI - J I ll -l I K veO(LOUtoutQU XPLcrEWV rl1Jrl XrlL OLrlIV OUcrtl)(LritLX1)V twv rlVrl7t1ULVbull rltrl tov Aou67JpoV b 7tocmxoe 6e0(L0e i3ev elXe 6etrlv 7tpOeAeuOLV 8ev 1)t0 6e0(L0c 6etou8LXrltoU ou8e 1) 7tpOe tov lloc7trlv U7trlxoy 1)tG ampvocYXrl(rl 8La crwtlJp(ocv TOOVrlVtLOV (LOCALOtOC tQv llocmxv e6ec1pEL ou (LOVOV OCLpetLXOV ampAa OCLPEOLOCPXYjV toih ocu-ro AItLXPLOtOV H e1tWeOLC tou i3ev ecrtpe-qJetQ OC7tAampe Xrltoc toU ampVtLXPLOtLrlVLXOU tampV lloc7tampv wlt cruvy-6wI (Le i3Li3rlClXrlALOCV tampV 7tpoi3po(Lwv tlie (LetrlPPU6(LtOEWC MAOC Xrlt

--396 tiiiveTtlox6iJwl _

va O) axStlxiii tXI TClX1XOU Oea(Jou PlJall eE to TClXTtlXOV atpat6m8ov

397 KlXtIX tovWiclif tO TCproteioV tou IIstpou eLVa1 xaOapiii meu(J(ttIxij G1)(J(tapoundlXlt XlXt (J1)VLat(xtlXl TCprottiOV tv -iii tOCTCeWOcppoauVll tv -iii ampyiXTC1J KlXt -iii (Xuto6uaq lUYKp(-

tv TCilJpel TCPO Exeilov l)v tXTClXlte

ltxo1-0U 1OOtOU 1OU 7ti1mXOU 6aOfLou 1OU 07tOtOU xltxl 8ev Aoo6Y)pov 1) 1ou0aou ampMOC x60fLoU

To 1tCtrcLxov O1efLfLltX XltXAeuroL1ltXL laquoregnum mundiraquo) Ev 1WV 1euroAeuroU1ltXLWV SpywJ 1OU ltpepeuro TOV 1hAOV laquoKI11oc 1OU 7tl1mOjJou PWJYJe 07t0 1OU

amp7tovefLov1ct1 dc 1OV IIamp7tl1v OL 8UVI11OL 1$ALXWe 1OU 7tl1mOfLou 7tpOe bv EI11I1WJfL6v

At 07teuropfjOALX(XtI101ltX1 Xal lv 7tOAAOL OC7tl1pamp8euroX1OL XpLOaL 1OU x(xL 1WV AOL1rWV fLeuro1l1ppo6fLIO1wvOUVeuro1eA$0(yv 1OU1O fLev de ampVI11po7tljv 1OU 7tQJlt$UfLl11o PE tmou8+7to1euro e7tltxpoc1YJOeuroV fLeuro1l1ppu6fLLOL lOU1O 8e sl S1L fLeuroYI1AUtepav OuO7tdpwOLV LeuropI1PX(I1 11) PE 7teuropl lOV IIamp7tl1v IIpampyfLom 1) 07t0u80w1epl1 oc7t6ltp1101e 1ije ev TpL8evcp Euv680u ev crXeOeuro1 7tpo 1-lJv 6eOLv 1WV 7tP01euroO1I1V1WV 1WV OCpvOUfLeVWV7tcxOl1v 6dou 8lxo(ou l1u6euroV1tl1v 10 fLuO1ftPIOV 1ije d8Ix1)e L$PWOUVYJ XA7t OUV[OtI11O de 1fJv Xl11WXUpWOLV 11jc I1UOeuroV1tl1e 11) ExxAYJO[I1398 Xat fL6vYJ 86vo1111 va epfLY)VeuroUn ampAI16middothwlt Aytltxv rpl1ltp+v evltl XI11OC 1oo 7tp01ZO1ampV1ltXc fLovl18lxyv l1u6euroV1bv OC7t01euroAeuroLampXpLfjwe 1) Ar

()OYfLl1TIXY oc7t6ltpl1m eA+ltp6YJ U7tO 1)c ev Tpl8ev1cp Euv680u iteuroPL 1OU 7tl1mxoG 7tpw1dou E7tto-l)e ou8SfL(I1 eA+ltp6YJ amp7t6ltp11OL 7teuropl 1Yie 7tpOrAeurouOeurow 1lje emOxomxijc eouO(I1e 7tOpa a XI11l1flAYJ6dOI1 07t0 TWV 7tp007t116atct l57tw 6euroOm067j 07tOT1)Euv680ul5middotn emcrxomxy 6euroOfLO (h(ou 8Ixl1[ou TYv OU1WV 8YJA yv potostaten iurisdictiol1is ex6vTwv TWV emcrx67twv a eurou6stl1 7tl1pa TOU IIamp-7t11 ev ampJ1LOeOeuro1 7tpo 100 15gt1 ot e7ttOxo7tOI Sxouv 1-lJveoucr(ctv ophwv OC7t euro06dctc 7tiXpa 1OU XPIO1ou I1ampV1WC (mo 7tOCV1WV 1WV fLeuroAWV ev TpL8evTltp Euv680u 81I1TU7tw6sLO(X I1hmiddotl)(ne 7tpee 1ovl1amp1I1V l57tw ampmxupltilOY) 1OCe amp1)O([lOCOeuroL 1YJ amp7teuro3dxvua 7tI1V1JYUpLXWe 1yv U7t I1U1WV ampv(XYVWPIOLV Tljple nitutinis potestatis 1OU PWfLodou IIov1[([IYJxo 8e b

Dei (1564) I51L 1) Sedes apostolicaew8IMOxcltt0 7tampV1WV 1WV mO1(v WSvYJ TYV xPfLo-8161Y)1Clt 1ije ePfLYJve[a 1(7)v OC7tO([locOIlWV 1WV Euv68wv399 bull

A7to 11)e ev TpL8ev1cp Euv680u fLeXPL lij Euv680) 1OU Bcmxavou (1869- 70) 10 1ampyfLo 10V IYJOollr1WV 1IlAdw a([llepwtJivovde 1OV IIoc7tl1v W yvwO1OV eX1o 1(V 1PIWV tul1yye)lxwv euxwv x(Xl 1euro1ampP1YJv 8f)AOv611 rYj 1UltpAe xat amp7tOAlhou o7to1ayijc d 1OV l1oc7tl1v-ampm8dx6YJ 10 XUPL1S-pOV I57tAOV 7tpoa(mtOew 1li 7tomx1) OC7tOAU1I1PXtl1 Xat XI11ortoAefL+Oew 00 fL6vov 1WV 7tpo1euroO1I1V1ixwv l8e(v aAAa XI1L1OUeuroV1o 1WV X6A7tWV 1Yj P E 1ocOIlWV7tPOC eiPI)Ylxwv(Jsrrwv emxvoilov etC ilIOPYOCVWOLV 1ijr

ExxAYJaLI1C bull

398 TIp13A R Soh ill Kirchengeschichte amp1 asl 158 399 TIpPA H F e i n e eXII asA 11 55

Olhw U1tO tYj yOCAALXOClLXYj EXXA1)OLOC 0UIexA1j61l to ilto (1682) Pel(Lot 001030 1tpa xoc60ptO(Lol tWI tYj YOCAALXOClLXYj Ex-

XAllOtOC To U1tO tYj 0UI680u poundyypOCqlOl OuItocX6h U1tO tOU 3LOCa1j(LOU B tgtl J I I tEPOXllPUXO E1ttOX01tOU ossue gtqlepe Hjl e1tLypocql1)1 laquoteOOocpE 1tPOtoc-Oet tOU YOCAAtXOClLXOU (Qauttuor propositiones cIeri gallicani) Koct ampAAWI -ij U1tO tYj oco6evtloc tWII otxou(LeIILXWII 0U1I63wII xocl OTCO tWI amppxoetWII xocll6l1wI tYj YOCAALXOCIILXYj ExxAllaiocqoo ETCia1) U1tO tYj YIIWOtYj 6pllaxeutLxYj mw tOU LcxIIOe1w(Lou (6e[JIALwtcxL tIj (l1toioc 0 K IOClOelLo XCXL e1tLax01t( tYj 1t6Aew Tpern $1 OAAOCl31q (t 1638) xocl 0 J

t3poundq ev tiigt OuYYpamp(LCXtL tou laquolIepl exXA1)ffLOCOtLXYj tepocpxtocn (1631) (ltL 0 0 1tOC1ttO(Lo eupiOXEtO ampVtL6eOeL 1tpo Ayiocv

xcxl t01l IIoctepcx nj EXxAY)OICX xocl 6tL OU(LqlWIIO ocotou xocl to 1tlleu(Lcx tYj xoc66AOU 8LOPYOCVGlOEW tYj amppXocpoundoc EXXAllOLOC ijto I 401 T I I 1 OLOpyOCVWOL bull oct OCUtOC 7tepmOU Loeoc U1teOT1)pLltev XOCL 0 U1tO to IEUOWVU(LOJ Justinus Febronius 00 XCXL oct t8eocL tou dVOCL yvwOtocl amp Q)e(L1tpOVLOC-vLO(L6) tOU Trier J ohan Nikolaus von Hontheim402bull

At 8eocL OC1JtCXL 1tpo ta tYj e1te3pOCOocl amp 6a r3w- J I I A I I (Lev EL jV e1to(LeI1ll 1tOCpocypOCqlOV e1tLtov CXUtOxpoctopoc T1) Wa1)qF

B (1795-90) 0 01t0i0 6PY)OXeI)tLXa (Letocppu6(LIOeLlt octwe wvo-(Lli061)Oocv laquoIWOllqlLvLO(Lon xocl 8L i1v (LeyLOtoi t - 1 I O r IeouOLOC el t1I UTC OCUtol OCUtOXPOCtopq LOCUtOL 1teptopLO(LO U1tOt jl emopoc-Ow Xup(w tWV amppXWV tYj xocl d tOC TCAeiOtOC tWV XpOCtWV tYj EopGl1tll t81q XOCtOC TOV 19011 oct()voc

At ampxp6T1)Te ()+w d TOC 01t0Ioc 0 xoctoc TOU 1tcxmO(Lou ampywl el Ouv8uocO(Liigt 1tpo TOC ampVOCOtOCTGlOet TOC 01t0Ioc amp1 EupGl1t1J (J(t vOCTCoAe6l1TeLot exOtpocTeOCLxoct yelLxw 1tpO TO TWV aPXWv TYje XA1t 1tpoxA1l6ell 1tVeU(LOCTtXOl XOCo mXVTOC tOLOCUTOC OUVETe-

yYj pW(LCXLOXOC-IIOC1tOlIl tYj

1tOUII d t1JV amp1tOTeAeO(LOCtLXWTepocv XOLVOU TWV 1tPOEPXO(LelWII toiho (Lell ex tYj ampXPampTOU TCOALTeLOXPOCtLCX xoct tWII OCU- 6cxLpetwII tYj TCOALTELCXXYj Et toc xoc6ocpw eXXA1)OLa-

uTC06eOeL tol-o 8e ex tYj 8LCXMuEW twv aVtLXPLOtLOCVLXWI

Introduction auch Sur les chemins d histoire

Le Jansenisme durant la Regence Louvain 1929)33 Die Kirchenrechtlichen Ideen des Febro-

xed OCOEOttXWV ev yeVEt poundi3EWV To Bomxocvov tou (moLou txocV017Y)e TCpoOocp(loitie XOCL twv ixampOtotemiddot euxOCLptwV Elvoct tore TCiXOt i3ev auvociov Vd ocvexfeurotamp))eutov (lovoc-

tltl i$vtt euxoctptOCV tiJ) TCpoOEcpepEto IIpampy(locOt 0 IIampTCOCC IIroe OuvExampAeOev ev BoctxocviJ) xoctd 00 hoc 1869 Ouvoi3ov403

ije PW(lOCCOXOCOOAtXijC EXXAf)Jtaec IIocpd ae tac ocvni3pampOetC Oije ot lmoc()oL ou ocxpampou TCOCTCtO(lOU ot XUXAOt tOU (1)Oocv Vd ex tOU TCepl EXXAt)OLOCC Oe(loctoe to OTCOrOV ocTCetEAErOC ex 15 xecpocAocLwV (lovov a xecp 11 xOCL 12 ampnvoc ocpewpwv de 0 TCOTCtXOV TCpwterOv Ohw Ot (leAY) tije Zuvoi3ou xoctO tp6TCOV TCO-PampAOYOV XOCL TCpWOUOiepov va OCTCOCPOCOtOouv eTCL ivoe 6e(loc0e XWpLeTCpOY)YOU-(levWe va i3061j ete i3uvoctoY)e va OCTCOcpocOtOouv eTC( OU yevtxwtepou

mpt -tije puOewe XOCL ije ouOLOe 1je EXxAY)JtOCe XOL OU XO-OOU TCOAtteU(loctoe OuOlie Eav i3e AY)cp61j UTC Iht TClOUTCOOemc

tlie op61je AuOEwe xoct ou TCept OU TCOTCtXOU TCpwOdou evOt OU yevtxwepou TCEpt 01)e EXxAY)OLOe 6e(l0t0c XO-

rOvoer TCiXc t0 (leye60e njc ocUOoctpeou xoct TCOpocMyou OOCU1)C eVEpydoce IIocpd tocuoc xoct TCOCpd Otc ocnti3pampOece ou 14 TCEptTCOU twv 0U(l(lEtOCOX6nwv etc Zuvoi3ov OU Bocttxocvou PW(lOCtOXOCOOALXWV EXXAYjOtOCOitXWV tAOU-XWV Zuvoi3oc ocfh1) etc i36y(loc tije EXXA1)OLoce t0 ocMOYjtov OU IIampTCOC XOCL 0 TCpW-rerOV eTCt OU(lTCampO1)e ttjc EXxA1)OtOC Ev TI Zuvoi3cp OU BocttxOvoU ou fi6vov eTCE-reUX(1) etc i36y(lOC

OU TCOCTCtXOU OCAAd xoc 0 teAetOe TCOCpOC(leptO(lOe Otje oLxou(levLx1)e Ouvoaou 0tEp1)6dO1)C OUOLocOttxlje 0 IIampTCOe i3ev tmepXEtOOCt xoctd Oae OCTCOcpampOEte tje Zuvoi3ou OU BocOtxCtvou ltXTCAWe ObWU(lEVtXtje Zuvoi3ou Ct)) evocL oxuppoundocpxoe ocut1je ocpou ampAAWOiE 10 1 - n - II I ) 1 -otO to OCAOV1)OV tOU OCTCOC ouoe(lLOC OUVOCLVEOte Ij EyxPtOtC UTCO otXOU(levLX1)C

Petri non ex consensu Ecclesiae404bull

IIoM (lEyocAuOepocv OTCoui3OCtoiYjoc aLd ev yevet i3coc(l6pcpwOw Ciie ()tOpyocvwOewe tlje PE ampTCO 1)v rOU TCOCTCtXOU evexet

UTCO ttje Ouv6i3ou tou BocOtxocvou atOCOOTCWOLC OU i36y(loctOc TCept OU TCOCTCtXOU npwOEtOU XOL i3t ouo IIampTCOCe ampvexYjpux(1) we 0 oLxOU(leVLXOe Oije EXxAYjcrtoce eTCtOXOTCOe (lampAAOV we ( (l6voe ampAY)01)e tje EXXA1)OLOCC eTCLOXOTCOe ecpWatlXOfLevOc aLa Oxei3ov ampTCeptOpLOtOU XIX V1OEWC twv OCTCIXIOCXOU Otjcitie eTCtOXoTCwv XIX eTCtOXOTCWV tlje PW(lOLOXIX6oAt-

403 l1pf1A W v If Ii r man n z u If 0 r b a c h ZurWurdigung des Vatikan KRs 1917 J 0 h F r i e d ric h Geschichte des Vatikanische konzil l6p I-Ill 1877)78

404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY

M]L gt1o(l)ihIlt1lLf Xraquorl3IlfJO (I)L 101Xgtrl(l)d 10

-00 101Xgtrl(l)d 10 Xraquo)oJ(xxir X)X 3 JL

nOL 5131l1(3rl3Q lX)x uLSXgt u(jof30Ilf -2 Il 5XraquooJ(xx3 OOLjd1x)1Ill lXgtx (I)1l9Mo lCrlo3(j

M]L xa r I

Iolloo 513 X)Jrl31lfJO n0L ooXgL

11013 001l9(O fll 1V OOL 11l 3L]3 3L3 001l9(O 5XgtJoX)Adf 13(j031l lX)x

X)Lmlj(j O UgX)L 5JL XgtJoXraquo)dj 1oU(gOg 1XgtLX)91l 5Jrld

O CL13 lX)x (l)rlojllMo j 5XgtJoJ(Xx3 ltgt JLgX)L lXgtx

513 )lUOUfl) 81JUI xapo) (I)91Xgt)[ 1L9 1X)IP 1X)[ nOX1ooro n0L lX)x

OO)3(j 101jr13Q3l lO)ou(XX3 fJ If n0L P n0LltlX) uljrl C13Ilt0 XgtJooo3f If Ln0L

lx)Lx)LoJQXgtx lX)x lOJoJ(XX3 6Xl(OijXgtX01X)rl(l)d If X)X ICLP n0L (I)LSO (

Crlo3ij 1X)I13 5Xraquo)ou(xx3 oOjrl0Arlijod 0UOUfl) 8InI 81)PO) n0L n0L lXgtx 101(jrl3 OOL 1)o(l)J3(3L X)X 3d23 lX)x lltx1L(I)dL13XAOo CLlt2 If laquoP1UOUfl) 81JUI UIa0W0raquo)) ICL 5X)JoJ(xx3 -oOx)x01X)rl(l)d x)X11lX Sl6l If x)Lljij3L 1X)x ll6l 13Lllf X)Llj(j0ijoIlXj IltL 13 3d23 norlo3ij -X)u nOL 1o(l))(3113Q nOIXgtx1LX)H nOL OO1l910r JLSX) H

n0L X)1X)Adl lX)x 1X)113 10 fJ 13 YI)oX)rlJo 1X)113 S1o(

31oW XXIL f 1C1l3Xo 1Oo9l lX)IP 1C1

510l01 If P1UOufl08pnI xapo) 39X)(j 1X)x ( 00Lo1dX -00lmiddot xs) oosrlLl x)x uX1LXX)L 1Y1 11l mooos J 1X)X 1ln v if -I ( t IS

nOIX)X1lX)H n0l (j0l9MS 1 uijOJd(l)1Xgt11X))[ middotX)Jou(XX3 5x

V OOllUVlOI(raquoJ S8

amp1tocpocOeCtlvt1je OuvoBou 01t0 tOU IIocmx ampVltxyxltxLltx m PCtl- E1tLOX01tOL ()cpeLAOV de tae amp1tocpampOeLe t1je opoundXOU[LevLx1jcOUVo-

BOI) W XltxL 1tiXC E1tLOX01tOe t1jc [LLiXe xltxl ampBLltxLPeuro1OU EXXAt)OpoundltxC OoBev teuroAO BLxocLCtl[Lltx ExBoOeCtle amp1tocpocOeCtlVE1tt 1tLOteCtle 8L 6Jv va 8eO[Leucrn tijv EXXAt)OLltxV dxov OL

A1toOtept)[Leurovt) 1ttfOt)e xltxtoc tcl ampVCtlteuropCtl oOmltxOtLX1je Gtxou-OuvoBoe PCtl[LltxtoXltx60ALXn EXXAt)OlCf [Lovov xltxt eucpt)[LLO[LOV

8avltxtltxL JCX CPeuroP7l tov tLtAOV olxou[LevLx1je OUvo80u Ev toie 1tpampY[LltxoLV amp1toteAei 8LltxXOO[Lt)tLXOV tOU k7tLOxomxou 6povou t1je I H 00v080e 8ev OuyxltxAeitltxL EV t7j PCtl[LltxLOxltx60ALx7j EXXA1joLCf 8La va OC1tOCPMLcrn ipso iure tWV OC1tltxOXOAOUVtCtlV tijv EXXAt)OpoundltxV toctYt-t)v yevLXCtl-teuropOCe cpoOeCtle Ai amp1tocpampOeLe atvocL dA1j[L[LeurovIiL 01t0 tOU I1OC1tltx t7j t1je 01t0 tWV EX XOCp8LVIXAlCtlv ev tcp BIXtLXIXVCP OuvteAe06dO1je oi 8e OUV08LXOl XOCAOUVtOCL XIXt OOOlocv tvlX 8La 1tOCpouOpoundoce tCtlV xocl imoypoccp1je tCtlV oc1totej$Oouv tOV 1tIXVt)yUPLXOV BLOC-XOO[LOV ciut1je

OlhCtl xixtom v 17 1tep(1tou [LeOtwv EVOCAAltxyWV xltxl 8LIXXu[LampvOeCtlv ampy()voe tOU IIocmxou 6eO[Lou XIX tWV Imltx8wv [LIXtOe E1thuxev Q 1tIXmO[Loe OCA1je1j ocp eocufov to OUV08L-xov 000tt)[Lltx XIX ocutijv tijv

H 01tO tOU 1tocmO[Lou 8Lex8(x1jOLe xoO[LOXpoctoploce OCVCtltamp-t1je ltxo6evtLIXemiddot XIX tWV 1tOALtLXWV 01tOeeuroOeCtlv(potestas directa in tempo-ralibus) [Letoc TOU 1tIXmxou 6eO[Lou ( Otoxoe tWV eeOeCtlv tWV ampyCtlVLOeeuroVtCtlV xocta EXXOO[LLxeoOeCtle P E 0 6ampVt1je

lOxooe tlie ltxutoxpltxtoplltxe to [LeYIXMtepov amp[LampPtt)[Lltx tOU EXxoO[LLxeu6evt0e 1tltxmO[LOu Ou [LOVOY 811 oclpetLxol we BltxMLOL OCAAOC xocl E1tLOX01tOL tYje PE we 0Wid 0 von 0 s nab rue k 407 tjleu80XCtlvOtocVtlveLOV 8Ctlpeocv Ih EXXA1jOLltx 8La 1tAOU-tou xocl xltx1 poundOxuoe exxoapLxeuo[1euroi1 we (Jt)xocvoppltxcp(ocv 0 Aooet)poe Ocp08po1t)t0c tWV xocioc t1je Ptou gcpeltxOIE xocl elc to 01t0 XplOLV 6euro[Lltx 1WV OxiOeCtlv EXXA1jOLltxe xocl IIoALletoce ele hipltxv ampxpott)toc Apvoo[Levoe 01t0 tWI EXXA1OLOCcrfLXWV AeLtouPYWv ampOX1jcrL v ltXA1jeOUC OuveteuroAeOev xltxtOUOLOCV de

OTCOtltxy1JV t1je tWV 1tPQ-reofltxVtLXWV XOL-

406 IIpf3A W v L oe wen i c h VOcnA 53 407 A D e m p f liv OfiA 191

40

d ijye(Lovoc- Cii)l xwpampv xocl TIjv xoc61tpwow Cou eVCeAampampnOC-poc3txCou xocl CouC who ampVCLXp1OtLOCV1XOU amp(LocCo laquooiS Co xpcho ocu-COU xocl 6pY)OXeLocraquo (cuius regio eius reIigio )408

H PE nocpoi CpO(Lepocvex 30XL(LOCO[OCV OUMAW tmexpY)Oev ex Camp1 nepl ampvwCatY) OCU6eVCLOC X(ll ampnl Campv noA1CELXWV xocl ey-XOO(LLWV tm06tOEwV tY) O(hw a IIanoc IIocuAo IJ Cij) 1559 xocCa

31apxeLocv 3Y)AOV(m CWV epyocOLwv rfi ev TP13tvCcp uvo30u 3101 C1) BOUA-AOC ocuCou laquoCum ex apostoiatus officioraquo ampgt ocvCmp60wn0Cou XPLOCOU enl lt1) enl CWV AOCWV xoct CWV 1n0-OtY)pLxCocl C1jc COU IIanoc knl CWV nOAL-cLXampV m06pound0(uv t1) nepLo30u CocuCY) ampvE3dX6IJOcxvo 30(LY)VLXOCVO Tor q u e-m a d e xocl a Kocp3LVampAwCa j eta n (t 1534) MECpLonx6tOCEPOC m1)p-

0 Kocp3LVMtO B e 11 a r mi n 0 0n010 (LECa tOU F ran z Sua re z 5CL ij ev npoxe1(LtVCP 1jCopotestas indirecta

directiva in temporabibus409 bull at XOCLP01 6(Lw xa6 oG ot IIamprtocL vocVCO va TIjv XOO(LoxpoctOptocv elxov nocptA6EL ampVEmOCpenCe( EVOCVCL tOU nocmO(Lou 3ev toCGtCO (LOVOV 0 npoCeOCGtVCLXO x60(L0c( 6pY)-

(LOVOXpOCCOPLOC tWV IIGtnwv ev lJuOeLnGtp1)A6e xocl GtUCY) ampvemOtpE-1iE( I) OCAAcX xocl CeX e6VLXIX ocnoAutocPXLxoi XpamptY) tIX onoiGt ono TIjv en(3pOCOLV CWV ampPXampV C1) IJLOC(j)Wt(Oew tOV evto tampV e3oc(j)wv tWV rOU eurov yeVeL 6PY)OXEUtLXOi3 eve(j)ocvL06Y)Oocv oct ampnOCLCOUOOCL COUCO (Le tOV nepLoptO(LOV C9jc nGtmx1) ocnoAutGtpXLOC toiho 3e OCOCOVO-(LLOCV CampV enl (LSpou EXXAY)OLWV 6pY)OXEuTLXGtl XLV1)OEL oct YVWOTGt( OnO t0 ()VO(JOC rOCAALXOCVLO(L6 (fgte(LnpOVLOCVLO(LOC IOvOevLOCO(LOC xAn H aampOToccn XPampTOU xocl EXXAY)OLOCC npo t1jc YOCAALXYi enGtvOCOCampOewC

XpOCV ev AOOTPOOUYYOCp(f enl B oct (LECocppu6(LLOeLC COU cmOL-OU ampgt et30(Lev wvoLampcr6Y)OGtv laquoIwOY)P LV to(L6craquo410 IJLIX TWV (LETocppu6(LtOewv COUTWV OC1tY)yopeu6Y) etc TOO XAY)PLXOO va npoO(j)euyouv

a1IX TIjv Icrxov 3e wv nocmxampv ev Tji-

408 lIspl -nj 1rPOSMUGeCilt TOU Spou (Cuius regio eius religioraquo) J He c-k e I Cura religionis ius in sacra ius circa sacra tv KirrchenrecItliche Abhad-lungenherausgegeben von Ulrich Stutz 117)118 1938 (Festschrift U Stutz) GeAbull

ampv GeA 488

Der Josephinismus und seine 1740-1848 middot1943 F M a as s

1951 II (bis 1790) 1953

rWV OCPXWV rou xparoult dlt rOC ExxAljaLQ(lt r6aov OC1t6AUr0lt wan 6a voc d1tYr Exxtf)apoundoc xocreuro-

crrYJ EV rn AuOrpoouyyocppoundq 01 rou Kpocroult ot J6vov ek r0

1tpolt roiho 01t0 TIoAmLOClt evrIrOCAJeVOL

H JtyocAutepoc 5Jwlt E1terpuiampcrOero dlt P E 01tO e1tocvIXOracrew (1789) erretE61 5A()V tWV JeOwv xoctoc

ExxAIapoundw XOCL 6pYJcrxs(oclt ev yeveL ou J6vov ( - rt rt - I oe eOYJJsuOev ocutI) rlV 1tepLOUeJLIXV esIlwOevroult VIXOUlt

ocAAoc XIXL (I) 6pYJaxdocv xlXhspwOocOIX ocvt AoctpdlXv tou op60u Myou Ev OuvsXepoundq e1tsxpa-tIcrIXV cruVrYJPltLxwrepIXL OCPXIXL ocveyvwppound06Y) rOU Ymphou Ovtolt

oc6IXvIX0(oc XIXL 5rL XOCAALteuropot AIXrpdlX dVIXL rwv ocv6pw1t(vwv XIX61x6vtwv (AstOJ6lt) H ev rrpoO1ta6eLIX

0voJa061 laquo6eoqnAlXv6pw1ttuJ0raquo (1799-1801) XIXL 6plOxeu-Jetoc AerrDUpypoundlXlt xA1t Ev teAeL oJU 1it0

rpumx6v on ltXL 8ev Ofhw 1X1 OC1tltXPXltXL rOU 190u IXtWVO

e6pov PE ev EUP6)1trJ ev xlXrlXcrtacreL 0 180 ltxtampv 81Jsucrew xltXta t61tou 1teptouapoundIX (Sacularisation) e1teteAeOe to Jsyltx lpyov XOcrJLX1j 8uvaJew AU1LX1jlt EXXAIOpoundltX XOCL Xottoc rov tP01tOV toutov twv exepoundvwv 1tpoU1t06ecrewv 8La PK e1tt0rpltXteocrewlt rwv

TIpocYJltXrt OrL XltXL rWV XIXtOC x60Jov crtY)PLYJOCrWV PKamp1teteuroAecre 1tY)y1jv

ex tWV vltX1toAeovrdwv e1teA6ono XIXL xaou XIXL rOU ex ALltXrpWrpoundcrowlt 1tVOUJltXrLXOU amp3LXO 01tO tou NOC1tOAeovtOlt JSrltxxdpLmlt rOU TIOC1tOC XA1t 1tavrltx tltxJrIXmiddot e8Y)JLoUpyI0ltXv si t00 AOCOO r1j vocrrotAYLOCV 1tpO otU6evttltxv412 0 TIltX1tt0JOlt evw1tLOl TY)lt XIXtoccrroccrewlt totUtY)

411 IIpf3A B C e ll oc v 80 u eve amp1 (IeA 588 H2 IIpf3A P Lip per t Die Kirche Chtristi 1932 creA 45 e laquoAber nun

ill den Stiirmen der neuen Zeit war wieder alles gefiihrdet und es erschien die Stiirkung der Zentralgewalt nicht mehr bloss als ein politischer oder theoretischer Anspruch der Papste sondern geradezuals einemiddot Lebensnotwendigkeitder Kirche Nicht nur die Verbindung der BischOfe mit Rom sondern auchdieZeritralisie-rung der Untergeordneten Vollmachien lind ihrerTrager wurde in einem Grade versHirkt wie man es his dahin nicht ffir moglich gehalten h3tteraquo

42

[LeY(OtI)J otUtOU Xott Oew tWJ ExocOtote eUJOLXWJ OUJOl)XWJ Ofhw Xottwp-OWOE JOe [LeyOCAot WJ AotWJ U7tep

Xott JOe cXJotyxocOfj tWJ KpottwJ tWJ [Let OXeuroOeWJ Xott

tWJ cXCPOpWOWJ opycXJWOL J Xott t0J tWJ XottOe t[LI)[LoctwJ PE O7tOUaot(ot umjpeJ

tOU IIoc7tot 0 (1846-1878) tWJ KoyxopMtwJ EJ tn (mo(ltl U7tO 7tpoOW7tLXO-

7tX Go err e 8413 K e t tel e r 414 ampJotP[LoJ(-Xott (Koordination) tWJ auo EOUOLWJ XotAn

tn 7t(OteL Xott ExcX to 7tea(oJ tamp1 OI)[LdwJ

OUJOl)xwJ-KoyxopMtwJ To 1870 XWPCgtJ P Exod

EJ tOU 7tot7tLXOU Ote al)A omiddot XottEXtot aLOe tOU

cX7teyU[LJOUto H cXXOUO(ot otthl) Xott 7totpOe t0e U7tO tOU IIot-7tLO[LOU cX7tetEAeOeJ OU [L6JoJ 7tYJnJ PE eXAAOe Xott

7topdotJ E7tt tWJ ta(wJ aUJcX[LewJ H P E eX7tO

umjpeJ eXcpetI)p(ot Evltl PE XottEOtI) EI)Ptl)[LEJI) Xott

EOUO(otJ JOe Ou[L7totPcXOtotO(J EJ t0J IIcX7totJ IIbJ 0 0

7totpOe tOe m otutou amp eXJocYXl) U7tOypotcpEJtot Koyxopaiitot Ie __ tOU

to Xott XpottouOotJ eurovtn P

Xott ExcXOtI) to 7tea(oJ

413 G K a II e n Joseph von Gorres und d deutsche Idealismus 1926 K vKothWEv KetteIer 2octxll1927

XIII 1925

OCUrO 8uIGuHJtV PE ex A6ylttl XIXt SLocMcrew

Ex T(iv ocvwTepw XIXOtcrTOCTOCL criXltpe gTL ol XOCTa exxocrjlLXeocrew PE euroIii vamp d Tlic ocxoAou6oue XiX-TY)yopLCfCmiddot oc) d Tou OCYWvLcrOSVTOCe eVTOe TWV X6A1tWV T1j PE XOCL e1tLSLW-

ampx T(iv ocvocysvvY)crw iXUTT xuptw TYj 6Ejle- - - A) 0 - PE TOt) scrjlOUmiddot r eLC OU OC1tOcrxL evTO OC1tO TY) bull bull XOCL OC1tO-

nAScrocVTIXC LSLIXe OPY)crxEUTLXcX XOLv6TY)TIXC y) EL TOUC OU jl6vov OC1tO Tfie PE oc))a Mt OpY)crxeLIXe ev yeVeL Etc Ta ampVWTepw XIXTY)yO-pLoce SSOV va 1tpocrTE6ouv XlXt ot ex1tp6crW1tOL IIoALTELIXe otTLvec TOV1tEPLOPLcrjlOV TYjc de TIX xoc6ocpamp EXXAY)crLoccrTLXa TWV To XIXPIXXTY)PLcrTLXOV YVWPLcrjllX T(iv ocywvLcr6svTWV e1tt TOU xlX6lXpw 6PY)crxEUTLXOU 1tEStOU XCfTa T1je PE cruvLcrTIXTO XIXTa xIXv6vIX d amppvY)crw XexL TOU opyoc-vLcrjlOU CfUT1ie 336 XlXt T(iv I1UVTEAEcrocVTWV d 1tiXpiXy6vTWV XiXt TOU PWjliXmiddotCXOU L)LXIX[OU ocpLmonAe[ou ltpLA0I10ltp(OC TOU vSOXOcrjlLXLUjlOU XlXt Op60AOYLcrjlOUeV 1tOAAOLC Se xoct -1j crXOAIXltJTLX1j 6eOAOYLIXC XlXt jle66Sou337 To XUpLWTepOJ IXhY)jloc Tffiv cruVLI1TIXTO E1 SLa TYjeci1tE-AeuOepwcrEwc OC1tO TOU xocrjlLXOU 1tVeUjlIXTOC amp7tOXOCToccrTOCcrLV T1je EXXAY)-cr[lXC we T1je XIXT XIXL l)mpxocrjl[ou XQLVWV(IXe TYje ampyoc1tYJC r1je 61t0[1Xe dVIXL OCUTo d 6do TTe EXXAY)cr[lXe

xocOocpme TOU 7t1X1tLXOU OEcrjlOU 6 d1tOOe we crLSY)POUV 1tIXPIX1tS-TOCl1j1lX exoc)u1tTe ExxAY)crLlXv OC1tO OCAY)OOUe lXuTYje crUV[5t1X oumwSY) 1tOCVTWV T(iv OCYWVL-crOevTwv XIXTa 1tEp yUTY)v XlXt jleT XOCTcX T1je eXXOl1j1Lxeucrewe

PE 06ev TYje ampAY)6oue oucrtelt T1ie ExxAY)crLocc 6l TOU Odou XIXL 01tepxocrjl[ou 0PyocvLcrjlOU TOU d1tO[OU XlXt eLvlXL

XIXL TOumpLOpLcrjlOU TYje PE d TOUe TU1tOUe otLVee de xoc6lXpwe eyx6cr(-tLOV 0PYlXvLcr(-t6v 11tOUSOCLOTOCTY) ev 1tpOXeL-

(-tsvltp T(iv (-t0ViXXLX(iv TiXy(-tOCTW1 T1i L)ucrewe 338 xed TOU ex

336 IIp3A W II a u c k amp1 OltA 17 337 IIp3A A De m p f ampv OampA 333 rOU 3L3AtOU An 0 n y mus

Commentarius in Isaiam Venedig 1519 laquoHier spricht der Hass gegen die heidnische Wissenschaft dar Dekretalien dar legistae und decretistae und gegen die aristote-Iisierende Scholastik gegen die theologie philosophantes gegen die Verderbnis der christlichen Spiritualitat sich mit ungebandigter Schroffheit aus Die derbe Sprache der Propheten verfUhrt zu einer unerbittlichen und fanatischen Kritik alIer Stande besonders der feudalen Kleriker)

338 U B e r lie r e L ordre manastique des origines au Xlle siecle Abbaye de Maredsous 1924 OltA IX laquoje crois pouvoir affirmer que l expose














Abendlande))















16






- - IA CI - I - E

1Q TOU XOO















18















Nul selten dass

























1957 asA 166












22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925














Abendlande))















16






- - IA CI - I - E

1Q TOU XOO















18















Nul selten dass

























1957 asA 166












22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925













16






- - IA CI - I - E

1Q TOU XOO















18















Nul selten dass

























1957 asA 166












22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

16






- - IA CI - I - E

1Q TOU XOO















18















Nul selten dass

























1957 asA 166












22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925












18















Nul selten dass

























1957 asA 166












22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

18















Nul selten dass

























1957 asA 166












22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

























1957 asA 166












22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925














1957 asA 166












22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925












22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

22





































ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925
























ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925












ai









26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925








26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

26






-xtil


















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925















28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

28

























30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925












30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

30
























32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925









32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

32
















ganisation Inst St






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925






























ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

















ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925








ExxAYJaLI1C bull

























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925
























404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925












404 F H () i 1e r M eXv GtA 848

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

(MJ 199l-flY




M]L xa r I























40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925










40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925

40










ampv GeA 488


1951 II (bis 1790) 1953















42

















XIII 1925















42

















XIII 1925

42

















XIII 1925

Documents

YIllHrHTOY TOY KANONIKOY !l1KAIOY EN TQ, …t \ - "-.... ' \ ,