22
1 【裁判字號】98,民專訴,157 【裁判日期】990531 【裁判案由】侵害專利權有關財產權爭議等 【裁判全文】 智慧財產法院民事判決 98 年度民專訴字第 157 ○○ ○○ 迴龍精機有限公司 法定代理人 ○○ 永世隆精機有限公司 法定代理人 ○○ 上二人共同 訴訟代理人 楊祺雄 律師(兼送達代收人) 蘇燕貞 律師 廖嘉成 律師 特力屋股份有限公司內湖分公司 法定代理人 ○○ 訴訟代理人 俞大衛 律師 經濟部智慧財產局 法定代理人 ○○ (局長)住同上 訴訟代理人 ○○ 上列當事人間侵害專利權有關財產權爭議等事件,本院於中華民國 99 5 17 日言詞辯論終結,判決如下: 原告之訴駁回。 訴訟費用由原告負擔。 事實及理由 壹、程序部分: 一按「二人以上於下列各款情形,得為共同訴訟人,一同起訴或一同被訴: 一、為訴訟標的之權利或義務,為其所共同者。」,民事訴訟法第 53 條第 1 項定有明文。次按訴狀送達後,原告不得將原訴變更或追加他 訴,但請求之基礎事實同一者,或不甚礙被告之防禦及訴訟之終結者, 不在此限,民事訴訟法第 255 條第 1 項第 2 款及第 7 款亦分別定有明 文。 二本件原告起訴時訴之聲明為:1. 被告應停止侵害原告專利權的全部行 為,包括停止銷售和製造侵權產品等侵權行為,或提供該侵權產品的供 貨來源。2.由原告召回、回收和銷毀侵權的偽劣產品,3 位被告賠償因 原告召回、回收和銷毀侵權行為的經濟損失。3.被告應賠償原告經濟損 失新臺幣(下同)97 萬元。4.被告應賠償原告因本案訴訟發生的相關的 合理費用 3 萬元。5.被告應公開在各大報的頭版明顯處登報道歉,消除

附件1 98,民專訴,157_判決書20140310

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 198,,157990531 98 157

    99 5 17

    53 1 255 1 2 7

    1.2.3 3.97 4. 3 5.

  • 26. 96 12 16 96 12 16 98 12 8 6 30

    99 2 10 1. 165 5%2. 116 99 3 29 2 136

    99 5 11 1 2 18 12 167 99 5 17 2 176

    2 53 1 255 1 2 7

    165

    5%() 95 6 9

    LED I309729 98 5 11 115 6 8 96 98 5 31 Z7 LED 1 http://www.flashlight-hweilung.com/hweilung_ta/ Bicycle.htm

  • 3 OK1 IK-LED5W09

    () 98 9 822 799,806 16 2 5 23 1 8 97 70 98 6 23 72 180 500 3 5 5 3

    () 2 3

    1. 1 : LED 0 2 2 LED 0 2 3 3 2 3 2 98 61 1 2 3 1 1 LED 0 2

    2. 2 7

  • 4 2 3 2 7 1 2 7 94 4

    3.(1)

    LED 30 40% LED 22mm 100 lm LED 1 12mm*12mm=144 6944 lux LED R2=3.14*40mm*40mm =5024() 199 lux 35 LED LED LED

    (2)

    (3) 0 1F 1 2F LED

    (4)

    4.()23

  • 5 2 column 6 12 6 1 6mm 16mm LED 0 2 0 LED 2 0 2 0 1 1 2 0 1

    ()

    () Z7 LED 1 7 93 10 5 1 2 7 1 7

    ()1.

    99 3 29 23 2 3

    2. 3 4

  • 6 3 40 4 Figure 4 is a diagrammatic illustration of myimproved flashlight using a concentrating reflector bulb and a short focallength lens with the lens in the advanced position; 3 2 11spring bracket 7doubleconvex lens 12 3 2 4 44 6 18 However, with some LEDs, use of a reflector, in combination with a lens,may be advantageous. If the LED used has a large directivity angle, forexample, 60, 70, 80, 90 degrees, or greater, the lamp housing 42 can also actas a reflector. LED 60,70,80,90 LED LED 90 LED 2 LED LED+ LED 23 3 2 3 2

    () Z7 LED OK1 TIMAX IK-LED5W09

    ()1. 85 1 60

    2. 85 2 LED LED LED U.S. PATENT 5 60 70

  • 7 85 3 180

    ()1. 22 4 2 3 2-3-22 2-3-23

    2. 2 3 (1) 1

    2 0000000 93 9 3095 6 9 3 0000000 1923 12 18 2 LEDA flashlight has a lens moveable relative to an LEDTwisting the front housing sectionalso adjusts the focus of the beam 2 "ABSTRACT" 1 3 the cap is adapted to change the distance of the lens from a source oflight constructed to throw the rays in a certain direction in order to focusthe light effectively at different distances 3 105175 2 2 1 LED LED 3 2 3 1

  • 8(2) 2 2 1 LED LED 2 LED LED "Other more powerful LED will soonbe available, which may affect lens selection." 2 column5 13 2 3 LED 2 3 2

    (3) 3 3 1 2 4 3 2 2 3

    (4) 4 4 1 2 4 3 2 2 3

    (5) 5 5 1 3 14 1 8 2 3 2 column4 15 3 60 5 2 3

    (6) 6 6 1 2 3 2 column4 15 3 60 6 2 3

    (7) 7 7 1 LED 0mm 32mm

  • 9 2 6 f 8 16mm 3 2 f 2f f 2f 2f 2f f 2f 2f f f 1 6 7 2 3 LED 0mm 32mm 0 2f 2 3

    3. 2 2 3 LED 0 2(1)f

    2f f 2f 2f 2f f 2f 2f f f 0 f f 2f 3 4 5

    (2) 2 3 0 f f 2f

    (3) 3 2-3-212-3-22 2 column 2 33 The lens helps toprovide a uniform and bright light beam, without the need for a reflector LED 2 3

    4. 2 column 6 12

  • 10

    A light beam provided by the flashlight 10 has minimal dark spots. Inaddition, the spot pattern produced by the flashlight 10 is nearly a perfectcircle, throughout the entire range of focus. 2 3

    () Z7 LED OK1 IK-LED 5W09

    ()1. 38

    2. Z7 LED 1 7 1 (1)(2) LED LED LED

    (3)(4)(5) LED

    LED LED LED LED LED

    (6) 1

    3. LED

  • 11

    4.6mm 16mm 0 2

    ()97 3 7 8

    ()

    () 98 10 28

    ()

    000000000N01000000000N02 000000000N01 000000000N02 177

    Z7 LED OK1 IK-LED5W09

  • 12

    1 7 Z7 LED OK1 IK-LED5W09 1 7 1 7

    98 5 11 67 1 93 7 1

    LED LED LED 1 LED LED LED LED LED LED LED LED LED LED LED 2 1 LED LED LED 3 1 LED 4 1 LED 5 1 LED , 6 1 LED 7 1

  • 13

    LED LED 0mm 32 mm 1

    2 2006 12 12 US714343B2 FLASHLIGHT LEDfront housingsection 162090LED50 LED 90 LED 201620 LED1614LED50 LED 16 1416 LED501414 LED50front housing section16 2

    3 1923 12 18 1478282 FLASHLIGHT16(1) 511 511 (1)(6)(1)12(6)11 3 3 2 3 4 3 5

    2 3 1 7

    () 1 1. 1 1 LED (1) LED21 LED 21 LED (1)(3)(5)(3) LED LED LED LED LED LED

  • 14

    LED

    2. 2 LED front housing section 1620 90 2 4 44 45 4 LED 50 LED 90 LED 202 4 1620 2 5 55 59 LED 1614 LED50 LED16 1416 LED501414 LED50front housing section 16 2 2 LED F 2F 2 0 F

    3. 3 16 3 10 3 (1) 5 3 48 51 , 11 5 11(1) (6)(6)(1) 3 51 52 12(6)11 3 2 3 4 3 5 3 1 3 LED LED 2 3 3 1 0 F F 2F 99 3 29 3

  • 15

    0 1F 1F 2F 3 2 4 5 4 5 6 1 7 4 1F 2F0 1F 3 245 0 2F 2 3 3 2 3 1 12 3

    4. 3 4 2 3 reflector LED LED 2 2 33 34 reflector 2 LED

    5. LED 0 1F 1 2F 2 3 2 3 2 3 1 2F 2 3

  • 16

    () 2 2 1 1 LED LED LED 2 2 3 2

    () 3 3 1 1 2 4 3 2 3 2 3 3 2 3 3

    () 4 4 1 1 2 4 16201416 3 2 (6)(1)12(6) 4 2 3 4 2 3 4

    () 5 5 1 1 14(3)14 2 3 2 4 15 3 60 2 3 4 78 2 4 38 43 2016201616 2 78 5

  • 17

    2 3 5

    () 6 6 1 1 2 3 2 4 15 3 60 6 2 3 6

    () 7 7 1 1 LED 0mm 32mm 0 2F 2 8 16mm 2 3 LED 1 32mm 2 3 7

    2006 12 12 US714343B2FLASHLIGHT 2 1923 12 18 1478282 FLASHLIGHT 3 2 16 2 Z7 LED OK1 IK-LED5W09 1 7

    1 7 Z7 LED OK1 IK-LED5W09 1 7

  • 18

    78 99 5 31

    20 99 5 31

  • 19

    98 157

    1

  • 20

  • 21

    :

  • 22

    3