38

2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d
Page 2: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

!"#$%&'()*+!

("#$%&%'(!)*+%(,)

!,-./!,0#122!#1345&()!

!#63#7-18"&93:

Page 3: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d
Page 4: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

!"#$"#!

!

!"#$%&'()*+(,$""*-"."/#0$#01+2/,3456$3%7256$38$3$%9!"#$%:;$,$"<%=/#$%)%(<$%,$">?268(@,8;$5*A/4#&%1#$%<"B@,C/,D72&'()*+(,$"EFGHIJ$1/GK$,G( @,<*6<"2$,$"<%=/D7 2)%(<$%#L5=/.#$%+*F8("!0.(Decision MakingM.:4@:N#5"01+2/,J)H0/>?1O3K8$3$%9<?4#H?4@G,OF2.>?19=/H&P"H5%=@/,3=/8;$5*A:4@01:;$!<2#$%)%(<$%,$"&%18)56$38;$H%L0/*"01:;$!<2)%%?NH&Q$<3$GC/,/,5R#$%:4@6$,O62 <"*,8=/H?K3"4-0B,OF2#?K$69B,.56$38;$5*A.56$3<3$G./,5R&%1#/).%7&S$J.&%1HS:>?1C*-"+/".+?/F0"H:5"(5C/,#$%+*F8("!0.HJ=@/!<2D72:4@8"!0";$O&TB#U$>?1&%1GN#+R!V2!"#$%&'()*+(,$"OF2/GK$,H<3$183>?1H#(F&%1EGV"R87,8NF+K/:$,%$V#$%

#?NK36(0*G>?1J*W"$#$%H%4G"%72.................................................................................................#/,XY#/)%3.#%3:4@F(" ..................................3#%$53.2558

Page 5: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d
Page 6: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

!"#$%&!!

'()"!*+",!-"*%&./01"#2%3!4(56 1

*+",',"7./01"#2%3!4(56 3!/0*89#:1/$./01"#2%3!4(56;; 5!#<9=$$./01"#2%3!4(56 7!9#:>?@./01"#2%3!4(56 13!.%A(2/(5(1"#2%3!4(56 15!>@*(4*1"#2%3!4(56! ! ! ! ! !!!!20!!">'2B@CD2%3!4(56E43FG"3 22!!#B9 23

$##H"(B1#,!!

=E(?"F!!=E(?"F@CD;I 15 !=E(?"F@CD;J 19

!!

Page 7: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d
Page 8: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

!"#$%&'()*+!

("#$%&%'(!!)*+%(,)

Page 9: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d
Page 10: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

!"#$%&'()*+!

(Decision Making)

!"#$#%&"#'"()(*+,,-$.(/012$#%&"#,3"4*5(678"'7%9':;9,<=26'>;?@">#12/?@">A">"#BCD<:.!E<)(!"#?%F@%4?#"<&G/=D6F,(A">"#B=.FA%(),HF2678"'#@F4#I@/B1!=26'CD<4&>"<A>/4JK96:3")&26'?G!"#A">"#B*#.$=.@HF2:.(=86!"#4*D;97(C*D':;94!%FLMN(6718=D6F4@D"/CD<4>K96!D8"@BM'$:$":&(2":;9L6'012$#%&"#(.N(/&(2":;9)(!"#=.FA%(),4*5($:$"::;9>;?@">A3"?.OCD<,3"4*5(678"'7%9':;9H>8A">"#B&D;!4D;97'HF2/PM9'012$#%&"#?@#QR!Q(4:?(%?F2"(!"#=.FA%(),4JK964J%9>J1(:.!E<CD<?@">A">"#B:;9,<S8@7)&2012$#%&"##@>:.N'012*T%$.=%'"(A">"#B*T%$.=%'"(HF2678"'>;*#<A%:U%V"J>"!7%9'LMN(

,-".'/",%0123!"#$%&'()*+!

4:J/A'@(!%==%J.(U-G/WXYYZ[/&(2"/\] /HF2!D8"@BM'?@">

A">"#B)(!"#:3"'"(&#K6!"#$#%&"#'"(@8"/(6!,"!$-??D,<=26'>;?@">#12/?@">A">"#B)(!"#*T%$.=%'"(CD2@/A%9'A3"?.O6;!*#<!"#&(M9'^F74_J"<L6'012$#%&"#/?K6/!"#=.FA%(),/WDecision Making]/:;9BK64*5(&(2":;9A3"?.OL6'012$#%&"#/!"#=.FA%(),4*#;7$4A>K6(&.@),L6'!"#*T%$.=%'"(/C>2C=8$-??D:.9@H*!IH>86",&D;!4D;97'4#K96'!"#=.FA%(),HF2(.$C=8$-??D=K9(LMN(>"!I,<>;//!"#=.FA%(),)(4#K96'=8"'/`/6718=D6F4@D"

Page 11: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

2 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 2

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

Page 12: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

3!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 3

!"#$%$#&'()*#+,-./0123

!"#$%"&'("$)*+,-#"./)0'123!456#78"%9%:+:"-/:2;!<=>?290:%8"#"./)0'123!&5$%"&!("=@A2/8,#".B.1>".-"2=@A2,C8"-&"#;DE:B.1>"./:,-&5$%"&=+:"3!32$%"&'("$)*+,-#"./)0'123!F7<&5>7)##".32#"./)0'123!90:,C8"-GE#/:,-;=>&"<'&;HI6-&52)#%1J"#".>7"C48"290:'.K@$%"&>&"C+,-#"./)0'123!9%:;0)-25L

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

Page 13: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

4 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 4

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`a6 &!"#$%&'()*+&1"(;<=)&7>R':27(>FKJ\O3'>$1(>?@%!$2ABA]3A27(>M73GWX1(VE)E)#^7(>&1>DE7(>7S(12%M2:F()7(>GH$'@?$I=J)?@Q)E;O9'2TDQ2b(2V3E"O8V9(:!(>FKJN%3>@'B(7*#>)!>3()E)#^7(>&Tc?$7>>"VE)'Y##8M8R78Y9"! B(77(>FKJ"K\O 3A13#:("1"(;%@)789(:V3()?32&TE!>YGN%3:9(7(>?@%!$2AB&1"(;<=)&7>R':27(>&A27(>C8DE7M2:F()GH$'@?$FKJ%KFKJ!Y%B(718(;&d&F()C8DE7FKJN%3T$B(>e(E;9()%KM83::9(&BR]9:;M73NVGWX1(A27(>GH$'@?$)(2A13'>>8YCGP(1"(;VE)E)#^7(>N%3

!

!

Page 14: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

5!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!

!

!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!

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

"# %&'<.=1%>?@+:AB,9!",-./0123'ODP%CB,&D"E=C(K0LHCBK0LG8CBJ78,!+.HQ+,-R'D\R7+K0LG8CBG-/HI%J$%-S%$Q+X%=</87>+TD"E=+"'O]?%'Z,"BH"8+BX>E"E((B+%(=#"?CB'#^GI="".(=#"?CB'OK,Z%Z>T0X>E!IKT+=+"(=#"?CB'O.NLC=Q+7%/D\R7+</8]-/!?+ODP%D\R7+O"NLCBCE<"=YH+.+"@7+X%!K+BX=8<F</8@U=G8CB

Page 15: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

6 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 6

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“'C12$D1?*!"#$” <21>76&8)*BJ,'C12!"#$S"SB4-./?*!+;B!<3I+1)K(FB!<3I+1)K(<$6/& 9:4,);<1)?*3JB0;$F? !2A/%V%+10-./?*SB4)J,9@")*V>W$(21++CD1!0.>")*V>W$( +1)3JB0;$F?

Page 16: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

7!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 7

!"#$%&'%()*+#,-./01234%'%(567#8"!952:/+(,."(1234%;&%<+=2%!9+(>-:/3?@A,;&%<"B%9C+DE"FGC !"#$%#&'()*+,-./0.0102+DE"#$%&'%()*3,-01234%'%(567#8"!9<,=2:<1G+',-.&'6H3%/+G>:'IF5BJ<B3(%H0GG6KL*3,-:%99C+'87=MN"!"F5BGC3%/+G>:'O7.J<B#%<%(P;%7;C+";&%<"B%9C+DE"=:/F5BGC3%/+G>:'$%.!52#$%&'%()*76/'GB%&I01234%'%(567#8"!99M/J<B;&(567#8"!9!7IQIG/JD9"'&B%9C<,=2:<1G3,-"B%+R>-:P>:<%''&B%3,-<,:.1B

&34/55617%#&89:!;0<=2!

'%(567#8"!9+DE"'89'((<3,-+'87=MN"J725G:7+&G%!"'%(DA8H658/%" '%(567#8"!9"6N"I:%9'(C34%O7.HS;;G+K,./;"+7,.&T(>:+DE"'GS B<HS;;GUM-/9C52:/K89%()%+DE"F5BGC'(),JDI(1DFHH=:/'%(567#8"!9IIO7.P>:+:%94%"&";"3,-(B&<567#8"!9+DE"+')V*",NO7.#B&"!TWB9CF.'+DE"IXI(1DFHHI76/",N

>?2%#&89:!;0<=@:A5BCCDC0E:*A$ ("#$%&%$'()!$*+%,%-#!.(/%#0)I !R2#4%T(6H'%(567#8"!9!"+(>-://B%.I QI 3,-01234%'%(567#8"!9J72'4%T"7J&2GB&/T"2%FG2&I T(>:+(>-:/+(B/7B&"YS'+Y8"3,-J<B<,+&G%K:#4%T(6H'%(D(M'@%T%(>:'6HHS;;G:>-"

Page 17: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

8 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 8!

!

!"#$%!#&'()*+$,-./01$23455678%2&5.7$%29!

!"#$%&'()*+,&-./001234-50)2&4-678 Individuals

Decision Making972:;)!"#$%&'()*+<=50)0)2&4-67>?@AB"!"#$%&'()*+2:;)>?@A4C*!1@D(&!%.:EFG"H1IA#".<@=J?1K&@&4!6L"0)=MC)7AB"*G@2!(&06"J#6&2#N6H1IJ4:#I'(AO(P"3*)!"#$%&'()*+

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

Page 18: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

9!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 9

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01-02,3$32/01-02,345-2653$/7/8)$025-.$320&9):;'(&&<(3&=>?3'(@A/!"#$)3A%&'()*+,-.BC,*&@03&/BC,=DE#.-D3F0&9)BC,G&$:H;-HI@&5-<(1261+4@2JA/-@KE(3&61+4@2JAL+.(MH5<)3AGN3O+,0M3.M1(P;'/O+,Q(5/ RST/(3&61+4@2JAL+.JD,8,).H6@GE#=%U2<6@J2=4E.$8,3$<3(/)3AJD,&'**=4E.$8,3$<3(=(@2:&"#$02"#$0&9)&'**4)$J243<8)$(MH5<QM,-Q65:-3<4N3:1F8)$=&9#)$GE#61+4@2JA

RSR/(3&61+4@2JAL+.8,).H6@=%U2=)(>12GV/:9)(3&GE#GH(:2 J2(MH5<=0W2?,)$6,)$(12L+.O<5<E8,)81+Q.,$J+/7//// RSX/(MH5<*H::MGE#=8,3%&'DH<&5-<(12=42):-3<:@+=0W2QM,-J0,BC,*&@03&2N3<3JD,=%U28,)<CM%&'()*(3&61+4@2JA65)O% 4HY3-+E/8H2G)$A12G&V/ZR[[\]/02,3/^_ -^`a/O+,(M53-b"$/8,)+EQM'8,)=4E.8)$(3&61+4@2JA/L+.(MH5<O-,/+1$2Ec

!"#$%!#&'()*+$,-./01$2'3456748839:!"#$%#&'()'*+'%#',$-)".)/-&%,)'),0"/1))

///////GN3J0,O+,&1*8,)<CM=?9#)%&'()*(3&61+4@2JA<3(8"c2/ZInformationa/=?&3'=(@+A3(:-3<:@+=0W28)$:20M3.de3.GE#Q6(653$(12/<E%&'4*(3&;VQM':-3<DN323FJ2+,32653$/7

Page 19: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

10 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 10

!"#$%&'(&)*+,+#-,.(%/#0)*+!#1$*2#3)2&456%#78A great number of perspectives) 9#1,3:;1<#=>4?*)*+,.(!@A'-B,#(,.(-#2B<*%3C<+.D@2#3$%-B7E7$*2#3)2&456%#7>*CA<1=#2F-#G.2$*2/HB--@43IF92#3JK!@A%/#2%/#0 !"#$%&>4?*2#323ILH&*$%&>2.(,+#-,.(3.>3.A-<0B#1)312/&#78Intellectual stimulationM7$*F.A1)4/2$%-B-.$GB>N@01),B>NCA<$G&$*2#3L:(F.*$=$*,3:;1*:;* !"#$%&OP&-@FB+*3B+-$*2#3L:(F.*$=>2.(,+#->Q&#$=+B#!"#'-=R1L:(F.*$=<0B#1*:;*78Understand) )/I>2.(2#30<-3:9)/I,+#->GCA<SC<$*2#3L:(F.*$= 2#3L:(F.*$=T(02/HB->4?*Q&<OP2N:*!@A-@3B+-2:*3I%+B#19H,,/LB#17E7$*2#3O/:2(:*$%&2#3!"#1#*43IF9O/F"#>3U=L#-!@A'(&L:(F.*$='4)/&+78Commitment)

!"#$%&'!#()*+,-.%/0123.')4567! F-#G.22/HB-9#1,*<#==IN0#0#-F3&#1<.!D.N/>%*C<2#3S2>S@01$*2/HB-7>GB*7%:+%*&#<#=$%&OP&$L&9:1,:99:6G#>Q&#3B+-43R2V#%#3C<>4?*2/HB->NCA<3B+-L:(F.*$=7)LB%:+%*&#-:2=I0C*0:*2#3L:(F.*$=Q<1L*><1%3C<N0#0#-T*&-*&#+$%&,*<CA*7E7>%U*(&+0

Page 20: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

11!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 11

!"#$%&'()*+,&-!./012"+)3"45'60!"#$%&'()*+*)#7&%89:;)0"<2*+=>Satisficing?=@9)9:;+7A5B)!"#$%&'()*+*)#7&%89:;'1AC$/'1D.=>Optimizing?=A<#"7'1"E(!*)!./01<-"-"19:;+7+8!"#5#7E/19:;-F&A-FG2C#F2H!AH:-I!%) '1"E(!*)!./012"+<-"-"1C.:!A.: ;-IJK"1L%&@-MIC#F2JK"1@$!@-!L2I!./01 +NI<-"-"1J(&ACO)45*)93")2IA&:-K!%8'1"E(!J)2F;) P=A<F;2#%!Q"JK"1A5B)2%)C)N;I2%)A&:-K!%)L2I!./014KM=5#"!R!"#ST):GA#:-!K0"=“<K!1"!."!45U=>groupthink)

!"#A8:;-IA8)*)A5V"C1"-=>Goal displacement)

A5B)2:!5#"!R!"#ST9:;2"+A!(&LNG)A1F;21:!"#$%&'()*+,&-!./01 AE0) A1F;21:!"##7&1JK"1J(&ACO)A<F;2$%&'()*+,&-1/0IA5V"459:;<-"-"1C"K(W:!"#@!M5XYC"@.MKA!(&!"#,$M@-MI!%)2-0"I#/)@#I=*)9:;'/&A5V"C1"-+7A5.:;-)45A<F;2A2"E)7!%)@.7#%!Q"C)M"L2I$%KA2I,&-410')*+AC$/D.2:!Z["-C)N;I !"#$%&'()*+,&-!./01+7A':-AK."1"!A)F;2I+"!$M2I<-"-"1C"LM216.*CM4&M1"!9:;'/& @.7+7$M2I*EMAK."*)!"#<(+"#S"2-0"I.7A2:-&=#28J28=A<F;2*EM5#7!28!"#$%&'()*+9:;H6!$M2I

Page 21: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

12 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 12

!

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email protected]>?"1I%&J-D3=F./0'+&12+)3#!2/04-)2+) ;1"-OG3N!"#$%&'()*+2"34#%53!6174D"1B%&R-C3!%)*)4D"14(&<;6)B?34)R$0.J4)*)&C")4D"1#FCN4D"14(&N1/11?3B?3R$0.J4) 4D"1B%&R-C3$0"3NVN<!(&P&C;."-Q)(&N4=?NWCognitive conflictXN;1"-OG3N4D"1B%&R-C3!%)*)&C")4D"1#FC4D"1<BC"*+*)89:;")%5) 1/11?3*)89:;"H7>R$!$0"3!%)R.J WAffective conflictXN;1"-OG34D"1B%&R-C3H7><!(&+"!?"#1YU4D"1,!#KN4D"1P10M?*+$0"3NV &%3)%5)*)!"#$%&'()*++G3$C?34I")G3OG3$%D3")1"!!D0"$%D2/44.;#=?<#=>?3'0D)$%D

Page 22: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

13!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 13

!"#$%&'()*'&+,-./*$+012%,1+0&+*&+3, (!"#$%&'()"(*

#&+',)-),.)

!"#$%&'()*+,-.&- /01 !"#'234'#(5*674!(&!"#8'&3/9"5/(&46:),-.+;8!7<=>6"?4,/)(/,-.*@74A0.1!#;$B7)*675-/9"5/(&#(4#(.55"!,-.'B&?/01?!"##;&5'513?CBrainstormingD?65"EFG3?!"#*67!HB25/)46H2")%I)8'&3/9"5/(&46 :)*675"!,- .' B&4!- .E9!%J<=>6")% I)? *)'K"A89&H715L13!"##;&5'513/9#+;5-'K"A,-.M524<N),"3!"#?M525-9(!O$(!&&%) P&E<H21E*674<N)M<1E2"3Q##5&",-.'B&8'&3/9"5/(&46:)1E2"3!97"3?R?*67M&7<#(5"SL13/9"5/(&5"!?R?#295!%)#;692"3JB//H$2"3?R?6H-!4H-.E3/9"5L%&8E73!%)1%)+;,T"*674!(&9(!O$(*),-.<#;@B5?6H-!4H-.E3!"#9(A"!UV9(+"#SV?Cavoid criticizing) /9#8'&3/9"5/(&46:)11!5" Cexhaust ideas) 8H;W'5W'")/9"5/(&46:)L138$2H;/)4L7"&79E!%)?Ccombine ideas)

4&5*6789)$%&:;0'+<-=*

!"#$%&'()*+L13WX7J#(6"#8$2H;#;&%J+;5-/9"58$!$2"3!%)$"5H%!US;L13<=>6"8H;'F")!"#SV#1JL7"3YG.3+;,T"*67WX7$%&'()*+5-L715XH8H;/9"[email protected]%.)*)!"#$%&'()*+,-.8$!$2"3!%)

Page 23: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

14 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 14

!"#$%&%'()*+,-'./0123,4%'56"$789:5%&!;',$'<%,23,-=>?%

(Problems Structure) 334/-@8ABA-'./01 CD6EFG68HIA/2:'8681I, 2551, ?8<% 146-147)

!"#$%&'()**+,-./01/2(03!"#$%"$#&'()#*+,&-.)

/-@84%'56"$789:1JK/4JK#L2<3,46*,%81JK1M%3#N+/-@8-'.:M%A4%'56"$789:)**&J!;',$'<%,:.&J?O64/4DPI)O.26Q85381JK(N44M%?8"RL<3#+%,S6"/:8 !"#3%::./'J#4L+%A4$567(/89:1;6<=)**+,)**)>6#3)#*/#0--&'(1&%2.2*3.) TUK,&64:./-@8?8<%1JK23,VN<*'7?%''."6*5<8)O.?6L?8<%,%8984%'"N)O9?<,%85+%,AWA1JK1M%0%#98?8+L#,%8"M%/878R-3#+%,'%*'XK8)O.5',/-Y%?&%# ?"#$%&'()**@+A+,-./01/2(0#343."#$%"$#&'(

)#*+,&-.) /-@84%'56"$789:1JK/4JK#L2<3,46*/'XK3,1JKR&+R"</47"2UQ8-'.:M% R&+$%&%'(L%,)V8RL<O+L,?8<%A&64/4JK#L46*38%;51JK&J;L%&R&+)8+838A)O.5<3,3%Z6#2<3&NO:%4$0%G)L"O<3&-'.43*4%'9S<L7:%'D>%D23,VN<56"$789:A!"#3%::./'J#4L+%A7(/89:1;6<=)**@+A+,)**)>6#35*3( !( 6#*/#0--&'( 1&%2.2*3.) TUK,&64:.1M%!"#VN<*'7?%''."6*$N, ( (

(

Page 24: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

15!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 15

!"#$%&'()**+,-./01.213(.#4!"#$%!%&'()*')("+%,(-./"#&) !"#$%&'()*+,$-./012345'6785&9%&'()*+,$-.:;;<0=>'9+'?&9 :@6%&'()*+,$-.:;;A<5<0=>'9+'?&9B=*3!"#$"CD7&:;;E+</01!'&+&<&'F$G&7@)%!%HIJ:@6K)L$(2$-$%&':%?"CD7&<&"'63M%(J%);+58$7$N19K29"CD7&B-$KH6/01E4?()*+,$-..6(?29-O?8,.&'HD&HK29($-$%&':%?AK"CD7&20%+58$7$N19BPN19<)%.6!"#$"CD7&/01!%,*KNL$%);E4?;',7&''6*);+49:@6'6*);%@&9

)567(89:-#;#$1<=79>?.+(1@AB2C6DE%

>AF6@?6D6+(1@AB2C6DE

%&'()*+,$-.!"#$7$?&/01K29E4?;',7&'/01!"#$%'6;8$%&'B(ProcessQB:@6(?29<0%&'R,.&'H&K?2<4@(5&9BSB235&9'2;>2;B.&%$)L$.N9/G&%&'%G&7$*/&9!@T2%:@6!@T2%/&9/01*0/01+M*KNL$<&R'?2<$G&A"+45%&'"U,;)(,(52A"BPN19:$8>8&<>,*K29$)%8,O&%&'A*?:;59K)L$(2$

%&'()*+,$-.:;; <0=>'9+'?&97'T2<0:;;:E$

%&'()*+,$-.:;;

%N19=>'9+'?&9!%&'()*+,$-.:;;

A<5<0=>'9+'?&9 7'T2A<5<0:;;:E$!!

Page 25: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

16 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01%!234506*!1.7809:!%) ;&95%6-,<!#4=-)!"#$%&'()*++4/08-"/>$!$?":!%)*)&.")!"#+%&!1@?/AB:>$?14A%C)$B)DEF):!#3GD!@3H1=@$#IDJKLMIDN)."DKO-KJP ,&.!1?"-QR:A%C)$B)*)!"#$%&'()*+,-.DD&%:)0C !"#$%&$'%()*+,-(%./01234&%0(56%3(789:;+,-(%

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`+,&.:?"9D7<T)$.)D&%:)%C)!"#!S"N)&<UVN">14-(78#"4NG'"7N$@AB:<UVN"+R:7<T)A%C)$B)506/08-"/'S"8%V/"!506'@&$?B!"#$%&'()*+AB:XY.=#(N"#

Page 26: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

17!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 17

!"#$%&$'%()*+%,-./0$12%,3#+456789:;$:<=>(%

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

,<9@:-0=+!K*->,L456,-;<(=:P@F1-0-*01-,23F-@!<#%0?C-@DEDFA$:>J8(;0(456,-:-029H2F1-0-*4*>!"+2&<F-@!<#%0?C-@ EDOP$@!4N2;2=F-@0-*21-456,-74.'C0-*;0(7BDJ2B9H2?%22AH&'(?93.+2J::>=+!K*->,L;<>4*>!"+2=C-F-@!<#%0J3.-"-*/;0(7B456,-73(3AFA$.Q3 F-@!<#%0J3K=*:>31-!2+20-*0C%2;<>,<9@D"A0-*J8(0*>)=20-*89$@2H1-,290!M#$%M+:-*W-/P@&<3A;<>&<!.AGJ2;?C<>F-@!<#%03(=GD2%0:-02AH:>?(%@M+:-*W-3(=G=C-0-*?93.+2J:J2F-@!<#%0,2P$@GC%".C@&<0*>F)?C%456,-%#$2 ED ?-""-73(

Page 27: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

18 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 18

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

Page 28: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

19!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 19

!

!

!

!

.

!"#$%&'()*+*,-.#/0#1#2%3/-456#17!

!

!"#!$"%&'()*%"+,-./01#"-%23"0%45678()*%"

!"#!$"%&'9"80,:7!4;"8<=<9>?@-ABC+!C()*%"

!"#(#-0D/&E,9"80,:7!4;"8<=<9>?F'C!$"%&'F.C

4G'3/&A@0,:7!9>?0%D"-3D9>?35'

(#-0D/&E,9>?0!/'@"!9"80,:7!&GH&<=

'$"0&/&!"#4"D9"80,:7!9>?4G'3/&A@

Page 29: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

20 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 !"#

!"#$%#&'()*+,%$-.#

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

Page 30: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

21!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 21

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

Page 31: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

22 !"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 22

!"#$%&'()*)+","-.,&"/012)3'456789:,;9<=#>)=?4&)3'@*,<#*"#2)3.,6A#3",)@,-B>63C4$.&70'"(9(@*9(53?5D!"E'"(9FG*@%G3",2)3.,6A#3", .4@''"(/01>+"?@H2)3'4567?5D!"EI?J)I89:,'45672,"=84K'9(B7"D 3-LMI?,I/+"3",$,>N",/018=0#A'@,IO4B/+"3",$,4@'PDB8=0#A'@,I70'"((A7%@A)#6"38%K7$-O4B)G>(B;7670'"(*@3?@*I70'"(9(BQ578EJ1)O'&;29RH."9(B-+"I'"(9(BQ57=@3'46"A'6)$.&8'G='"(8(0#,(S&O4BE@T,"%,8)3$,'4567IO4B89:,'"((6A7'@,$,'"(?G=O4B'"(%@=>G,$-8EJ1)O'&9RH."2)3/073",UV13>)=?4&)3%6),<#*"#2)3.,6A#3",%,I

!"#$%&'()%*+!,-./0,+12"+ >"8.%52)3?A"7CG=E4"=2)3'"(%@=>G,$- '"(%@=>G,$-*"3?(@W3)"-;76$Q6'"(%@=>G,$-/01=0/01>5=I2VW,)#S6'@*("#4B8)0#=%6"3X

/01/+"$.&8'G=?A"7CG=E4"=IY8*H-A((DI*5H$-8EKQ(Z[\\]^.,&"_`I;=&O'6 1. '"(%@=>G,$-/012"=2&)7S4/01=0I.(J)702&)7S4;768E0#3E) [^ '"(%@=>G,$-/01708A4"-+"'@=I.(J)8(63(0*2"=?A"7(B7@=(BA@3 _^I'"(%@=>G,$-/0170)G/aGE4)J1,82&"?()*3+"/+"$.&8'G=)?%G.(J)8),8)0#3;92&"3$=2&"3.,V13 4^I'"(%@=>G,$-*,?A"7(S&>V'II)"(7DbII8Q6,II?A"7<4! ?A"7<'(aII?A"7.43II89:,%&,

Page 32: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

23!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 23

!"#$!

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

Page 33: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d
Page 34: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

!""#$%&'"(!!

!"#$%&'($)&*+,)-%./01234.!"#$$%&'#($%&!)*+,$%&-".$%&'#($%&-/0+1( $%&2&1!%&34&$1'5/67%/$%&8,9:''42#/;/5675'8%9:#;<=(04.$%)#>;57?@"8%: ((((A)B@+#$%&'7?@C6;D@+9D. >;5(E#C"$6--659"F)'./011G4.$%&<#(61/5'.8H">7I=J(01(E6#?@87(0113K (((((((A@$(http://www.stou.ac.th/offices/rdec/udon/upload/socities.html.

&9LM59"F'(>NA%"9";"'./011O4.=><1$&&?)*+,$%&.$%)#>;57?@"8%: ((((((,%6P9;Q<5%6:";'(/ORRO4(AS@$9T. ,%%D#8'(U-A6"T@./012V4.)*+,$%&-".$%&'#($%&./5675'8%9:#;<=(G4.$%)#>;57?@"8%:( (((((((%C7E@E'". >,WXAC%%&(,)XYA>5W!%./011G4.$%&<#(61/5'5/)*+,$%&.8H">7I=J(01( ((((((E6#?@87(0113,A@$(http://www.bloggang.com/viewdiary.php ? id = ajarnbe.

C%5A"'(,)P%@897CT<./012V4.)*+,$%&-".$%&'#($%&.Z;)7F@"<:7?@C6;D@+9D (((((((%@![9\C]+DJ+#$%&'.( ^6%65%(5#̂ '^%<U%A"'.(/012_4.J#8'$@%`+a$@%A9T$@%.(/5675'8%9:#;<=(_4.$%)#>;57?@"8%: (((((((7?@C6;D@+9DF)%$6A,9&*6-D'.( E786T(,@#U7./012V4.)*+,$%&-".$%&'#($%&./5675'8%9:#;<=(24.$%)#>;57?@"8%: C6;D59b"'. E)[@CT<(N)";J#A9";%'./01114.@%0.ABC/D%-".$%&'B*5'.J),+%@!F@"<:7?@C6;D@+9D ((((((((%@![9LJ),+%@!F@"< 7?@C6;D@+9DE)UN;9DF%%7@F6%@!./012V4.)*+,$%&-".$%&'#($%&./5675'8%9:#;<=_4. ((((((("";,)%<:!C"5675'

Page 35: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d
Page 36: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d

!"#$%&'()*+,!

!

*-./0123,!!

1. !"#$%##&''()*+,-.%/0($1- 234,5"!1#6"06,-786,90: 2. !"-;"1<0,=>"''?0@/=: !%6/0%<#"609=AA*$5"!"B6"0<C(&> )%1)!4"6*=D:-"!1C$"6"0E*@<%F!"6"0 786,90: 6,-786,90:

!"#$%&'()*+,!

GH'!"#."I=<%!JK''<*,#<%!JK !%6/0%<#"609=AA*$5"!"B6"0 6,-786,90: LH'!"#$%#$"B''(M0CB0%6>K !%6/0%<#"609=AA*?NC9%OC6"0

6,-786,90:

Page 37: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d
Page 38: 2decision - DOL!"#$%&'()*+,-./01023,456037 5!5!"#$%&'(!)*!"(+&,-./0123!!"#$%&'()*"+,-.!/0'123456'7%8+99:-994;'?+!@ab cb,&d"e=c(fcb=+"g-/hi%j$!?+.0cb,&d"e=c(k0lg8cb#i$+"m+#ch")d