144

แนวทางการบริหารจัดการผู้ป่วยวัณโรคดื้อยา พ.ศ. 2558

  • Upload
    -

  • View
    207

  • Download
    8

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

แนวทางการบริหารจัดการผู้ป่วยวัณโรคดื้อยา พ.ศ. 2558

Citation preview

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    a

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    b

    2558

    2,500

    116 ()

    . 10120

    /.

    New Funding Model

    ISBN 978-616-11-2512-7

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    c

    ( )

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    d

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    e

    (Abbreviation)

    1

    1.1

    1.2

    1.3

    2

    2.1

    2.2

    3 :Mono-,Poly-Multi-drugresistantTB

    3.1

    3.2

    3.3

    4

    4.1

    4.2 /

    4.3

    4.4

    4.5

    4.6

    5 XDR-TB

    5.1 Pre-XDR-TB XDR-TB

    5.2 (Palliative cares)

    6

    6.1 HIV

    6.2

    6.3

    6.4

    6.5

    i

    jm1

    2

    3

    5

    778

    17

    17

    20

    25

    29

    29

    30

    34

    37

    44

    47

    51

    51

    54

    57

    57

    64

    70

    71

    71

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    f

    7

    7.1

    7.2

    7.3 (Multidisciplinary care)

    (DOT)

    7.4

    7.5

    7.6

    7.7 .

    8

    8.1

    8.2

    8.3

    8.4

    8.5

    8.6

    1

    2 XDR-TB

    3 molecular assay

    4 (DST)

    solid media liquid media

    5 solid media liquid media

    6 PMDT

    75

    75

    78

    78

    83

    84

    85

    86

    89

    89

    90

    92

    93

    94

    94

    99

    101

    105

    109

    114

    115

    119

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    g

    1.1

    2.1 X-pert

    MTB/RIF R

    3.1

    3.2

    3.3

    3.4

    4.1 /

    4.2 Mycobacterium

    tuberculosis

    4.3

    4.4

    6.1

    6.2

    6.3

    6.4 paradoxical IRIS

    6.5

    6.6 Anti-TB drug U.S. FDA class

    6.7

    7.1

    4

    9

    19

    23

    24

    26

    31

    35

    38

    44

    60

    61

    61

    63

    69

    71

    72

    87

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    h

    2.1 MDR-TB

    2.2

    4.1

    4.2

    6.1

    6.2 (MDR-TB)

    7.1

    12

    13

    30

    34

    67

    68

    83

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    i

    ()

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    j

    1.

    1.1

    1.2

    1.3 .

    1.4

    1.5

    1.6

    1.7

    1.8 .

    1.9

    1.10

    1.11

    1.12

    1.13

    1.14

    1.15

    2.

    2.1

    2.2

    2.3

    2.4

    2.5

    2.6

    2.7

    2.8

    2.9

    2.10

    2.11 ()

    2.12

    2.13

    2.14

    2.15 .

    2.16

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    k

    2.17 .

    2.18

    2.19

    2.20

    2.21

    2.22

    2.23

    2.24

    2.25

    2.26 .

    2.27 .

    2.28

    2.29

    2.30

    2.31

    2.32 . /

    2.33 /

    2.34 /

    2.35 /

    2.36 /

    3.

    3.1

    3.2

    1)

    2) .

    3.3

    1)

    2)

    3) .

    4)

    5)

    6)

    7)

    8)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    l

    9)

    10)

    11)

    12)

    13)

    14)

    15) 11

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    m

    3TC lamivudine

    ABC abacavir

    AFB acid-fast bacilli

    AFRIMS Armed Forces Research

    Institute of Medical Science

    ALT alanine transaminase

    Am amikacin

    Amx amoxicillin

    Amx/Clv amoxicillin/clavulanate

    ART antiretroviral therapy

    ATV atazanavir

    AUC area under the curve

    AZT zidovudine

    Bdq bedaquiline

    CBC complete blood count

    CD4 cluster of differentiation 4

    CD8 cluster of differentiation 8

    CDC-US Centers for Disease Control

    and Prevention (USA)

    Cfx clofazimine

    Clr clarithromycin

    Cm capreomycin

    Cr creatinine

    CrCl creatinine clearance

    CRP c-reactive protein

    Cs cycloserine

    CSF cerebrospinal fluid

    CXR chest x-ray

    CYP 450 cytochrome P450

    d4T stavudine

    ddI didanosine

    ddC zalcitabine

    DHFS dihydrofolate synthase

    DHHS Department of Health and

    Human Service

    Dlm delamanid

    DOT directly observed therapy

    DR-TB drug resistant tuberculosis

    DRV darunavir

    DST drug susceptibility testing

    E ethambutolECG electrocardiography

    EFV efavirenz

    Eto ethionamide

    FDA Food and Drug Administra-

    tion

    FL-DST first-line drug susceptibility

    testing

    FLDs first-line anti-tuberculosis

    drugs

    FQs fluoroquinolones

    FTC emtricitabine

    (Abbreviation)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    n

    H, INH isoniazid

    HIV human immunodeficiency

    virus

    IC infection control

    IDV indinavir

    IFN- interferon gammaIGRA interferon gamma release

    assay

    IL interleukin

    INR international normalized

    ratio

    INSHI International Network for

    the Study of HIV associated

    IRIS

    IOM International Organization

    for Migration

    Ipm/Cln imipenem/cilastatin

    IRIS immune reconstitution

    inflammatory syndrome

    IRS immune recovery syndrome

    K, Km kanamycin

    LAMP loop-mediated isothermal

    amplification assay

    LED light-emitting diode

    Lfx levofloxacin

    LTBI latent tuberculosis infection

    LPA line probe assay

    LPV liponavir

    Lzd linezolid

    MDR-TB multidrug resistant tubercu-

    losis

    Mer/Clv meropenem/clavulanate

    Mfx moxifloxacin

    MIC minimum inhibitory

    concentration

    MODS microscopic observation

    drug susceptibility

    NA not available

    NNRTIs non-nucleoside reverse

    transcriptase inhibitors

    NRTIs nucleoside reverse

    transcriptase inhibitors

    NSAIDs nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory

    drugs

    NTM nontuberculous

    mycobacterium

    NTP national tuberculosis

    control programme

    NTRL national tuberculosis reference

    laboratory in bangkok,

    Thailand

    NVP nevirapine

    O, Ofx ofloxacin

    P, PAS para-aminosalicylic acid

    PCR polymerase chain reaction

    PIs protease inhibitors

    PPIs proton pump inhibitors

    PMDT programmatic management of

    drug resistant tuberculosis

    Pre-XDR-TB pre-extensive drug resistant

    tuberculosis

    PT prothrombin time

    PTC provincial TB coordinator

    Pto prothionamide

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    o

    R rifampicin

    RNA ribonucleic acid

    RTC regional TB coordinator

    RTV ritronavir

    S, Sm streptomycin

    SL-DST second-line drug susceptibility

    testing

    SLDs second-line anti-tuberculosis

    drugs

    SLIs second-line injectable drugs

    SQV saquinavir

    TAD treatment after default

    TB tuberculosis

    TDF tenofovir

    TDR-TB total drug resistant

    tuberculosis

    Thz thiacetazone

    TNF tumor necrosis factors

    Trd terizidone

    TST tuberculin skin test

    UV ultraviolet

    VL viral load

    WHO World Health Organization

    XDR-TB extensive drug resistant

    tuberculosis

    Z, PZA pyrazinamide

    ZN Ziehl Neelsen

    .

    ..

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    p

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    1

    (multidrug resistant tuberculosis, MDR-TB)

    isoniazid (H, INH) rifampicin (R) .. 1970 (.. 2513)

    fluoroquinolones (FQs) .. 1990 (.. 2533)

    (extensive drug resistant tuberculosis, XDR-TB)

    (directly observed therapy, DOT)

    DOT ..1996 (.. 2539)

    (cure) (relapse) (drug resistance)

    1 (first-line anti-tuberculosis drugs, FLDs)

    2,000-4,000

    2 (second-line anti-tuberculosis drugs, SLDs) MDR-TB

    200,000 XDR-TB 1,000,000

    HIV

    98-100 MDR-TB 60-80

    XDR-TB 44-50 HIV

    MDR-TB XDR-TB 1 MDR-TB

    71 XDR-TB 83 (1)

    1.1

    1.2

    1.3

    1

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    2

    1.1(2,3,4)

    Primary drug resistant TB

    Acquired drug resistant TB

    fall and rise phenomenon

    acquired drug resistant TB

    susceptible resistant

    Drug resistance among new TB cases

    1

    acquired drug resistant TB primary drug resistant TB

    Drug resistance among previously treated TB cases

    3 1)

    2) acquired drug resistant TB 3)

    (re-infection with resistant bacilli)

    acquired drug resistant TB

    Combined drug resistant TB

    combined drug resistant TB

    Mono-resistant TB

    Poly-resistant TB MDR-TB

    H R H ethambutol (E), R streptomycin (S), E S, H

    E S

    Multi-drug resistant TB (MDR-TB) H R

    H R

    Pre-extensive drug resistant TB (Pre-XDR-TB)

    MDR-TB FQs second-line injectable drugs (SLIs)

    Extensive drug resistant TB (XDR-TB)

    MDR-TB FQs SLIs kanamycin, amikacin capreomycin

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    3

    (totaldrugresistantTB(TDR-TB)WHO

    )

    1.2

    (5) 3.5

    (95%CI 2.2-3.5%) MDR-TB 20.5

    (95%CI 13.6-27.5%) 9 (95%CI 6.5-11.5%) MDR-TB

    (XDR-TB) .. 2013

    (.. 2556) XDR-TB 100 (5)

    .. 2013 (.. 2556) 480,000

    210,000 (5)

    MDR-TB .. 2013 (.. 2556)

    MDR-TB 45

    8.5 17

    71 48 (median:

    59.5%) ( .. 2011)(5)

    4 MDR-TB

    MDR-TB 2 MDR-TB

    20 4

    1 .. 2540-41 (.. 1997-1998)(6)

    2 .. 2544-45 (.. 2001-2002)(7)

    3 .. 2549-50 (.. 2006-2007)(8)

    4 .. 2555-56 (.. 2012-2013)(9)

    4 1.1

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    4

    1.1 (nationalanti-TBdrugresistance

    surveillance)(6-9)

    Drugresistance

    1

    (..1997-

    1998)

    2

    (..2001-

    2002)

    3

    (..2006-

    2007)

    4

    (..2012-

    2013)

    Drugresistanceamong

    newcases

    - Any resistance 25.4 14.8 15.7 16.83

    - Mono H resistance NA 5.3 5.65 6.54

    - Mono R resistance NA 0.3 0.87 0.12

    - Any H resistance 12.4 9.5 9.7 12.21

    - Any R resistance 5.72 1.4 2.6 2.22

    - MDR 2.01 0.93 1.65 2.03

    Drugresistanceamongprevi-

    ouslytreatedcases

    - Any resistance NA 39 51.0 39.29

    - Mono H resistance NA 4.1 5.2 9.69

    - Mono R resistance NA 1.7 0.5 3.57

    - Any H resistance NA 30.8 44.3 29.59

    - Any R resistance NA 22.7 35.1 23.98

    - MDR NA 20.35 34.5 18.88

    NA = not available ()

    MDR-TB 5-7(2,3,10) MDR-TB

    .. 2012(11) (.. 2555) MDR-TB

    1,760 800 960

    300-400

    MDR-TB

    126 MDR-TB

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    5

    248, 327 366 2550, 2551 2552 XDR-TB

    5-8 40-50(12)

    (genetic mutation)

    (man-made phenomenon)

    (clinical practice) (programmatic TB management)

    (4)

    .

    (DOT)

    .

    (mal-absorption)

    .

    1.3

    MDR-TB 2.03

    1)

    (previously treated patient) relapse, after failure of first treatment with

    FLDs after failure of retreatment regimen with FLDs after loss to follow-up(3)

    2) 3 3)

    MDR-TB MDR-TB

    rapid test R HR /

    (standardized

    MDR-TB regimen)

    (individualized regimen) (strictly DOT)

    (13)

    . 90

    . 70

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    6

    1. Chang KC, Yew WW. Management of difficult multi-drug resistant tuberculosis and

    extensively drug resistant tuberculosis: update 2012. Respirology 2013; 18: 8-21.

    2. Caminero JA, ed. Guidelines for clinical and operational management of drug-

    resistant tuberculosis 2013. Paris, France: International Union against Tuberculosis

    and Lung Diseases 2013, 15-9.

    3. World Health Organization. Companion handbook to the WHO guidelines for the

    programmatic management of drug-resistant tuberculosis. Geneva, Switzerland:

    WHO; 2014: 17-22.

    4. World Health Organization. Guidelines for the programmatic management of

    drug-resistant tuberculosis, emergency update 2008. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO;

    2008.

    5. World Health Organization. Global tuberculosis report 2014. Geneva, Switzerland:

    WHO; 2014: 54-73.

    6. Payanandana V, Rienthong D, Rienthong S, Ratanavichit L, Kim SJ, Sawert H.

    Surveillance for anti-tuberculosis drug resistance in Thailand: result from a

    national survey. Thai J Tuberc Chest Dis 2000; 21: 1-8.

    7. World Health Organization. Anti-tuberculosis drug resistance in the world: report

    No.3. Geneva, Singapore: WHO; 2004.

    8. , , .

    3 .. 2549-50

    1 .. 2540-41 2 .. 2544-45.

    2551; 34: 30-9.

    9. .

    4 .. 2555-2556.

    10. Chuchottaworn C. Extensively drug resistant tuberculosis (XDR-TB) in chest disease

    institute, 1997-2005. J Med Assoc Thai 2010; 93: 34-7.

    11. World Health Organization. Global tuberculosis report 2013. Geneva, Switzerland:

    WHO; 2014: 132.

    12. .

    2550-2552.

    13. . .

    : , 2554.

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    7

    (drug susceptibility testing, DST)

    (priority setting)

    (cost effectiveness) (quality) (reliability)

    2.1

    (any drug resistance) (MDR-TB)

    MDR-TB 3

    MDR-TB

    (1)

    2

    2.1

    -(Previouslytreatedpatients)

    -3

    -(Newpatients)

    2.2

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    8

    2.1.1 (previously treated patients)

    - (after failure of retreatment

    regimen with FLDs)(2)

    (chronic case) retreatment

    (DOT) MDR-TB 85

    - (after failure of first

    treatment with FLDs)(2)

    5 MDR-TB

    50 10-90

    DOT

    (extent of disease)

    - (relapse)

    (early

    relapse) retreatment MDR-TB

    50 MDR-TB

    10

    - (after loss to follow-up)(2)

    2.1.2 1 3

    MDR-TB

    2.1.3 (new patients) MDR-TB

    - MDR-TB MDR-TB index

    case MDR-TB

    index case MDR-TB

    - MDR-TB /

    - MDR-TB

    MDR-TB

    2.2

    2.2.1 (smear microscope)

    ZiehlNeelsen (ZN) (light microscope)

    (fluorescent microscope)

    light-emitting diode (LED) smear

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    9

    5,000-10,000 /(3,4)

    2.2.2 screening test real-time PCR

    Xpert MTB/RIF

    rifampicin 100

    smear 131 /

    (5,6) R

    (follow up specimen)

    meta-analysis(7) Xpert MTB/RIF

    (sensitivity) 95 (specificity) 98

    R 2.1(7)

    2.1 X-pertMTB/

    RIFR(7)

    TypeofanalysisMedian(%)pooled

    sensitivity(95%CrI)

    Median(%)pooled

    specificity(95%CrI)

    Xpert MTB/RIF

    R (

    sensitivity 17 555

    specificity 24 2,414 )

    95 (90-97) 98 (97-99)

    Xpert MTB/RIF

    smear (22

    9,008 )

    88 (84-92) 99 (98-99)

    Xpert MTB/RIF

    smear (23

    7,151 )

    68 (61-74) 99 (98-99)

    CrI (credible interval) = the CrI is the Bayesian equivalent of the confidence interval

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    10

    meta-analysis(7) X-pert MTB/RIF R

    pooled sensitivity 86% (95% CrI, 53-98) pooled specificity 98% (95% CrI,

    94-100)

    pleural fluid pooled sensitivity 43.7% (95% CI, 24.8-64.7%) pooled specificity

    98.1% (95% CI, 95.3-99.2%)(7) CSF pooled sensitivity 79.5% (95% CI, 62.0-90.2%)

    pooled specificity 98.6% (95% CI, 95.8-99.6%)(7)

    2.2.3 (gold standard)

    2.2.3.1 (culture and drug

    susceptibility testing)

    - (culture)

    (gold standard)

    (non-tuberculous mycobacteria, NTM)

    10-1,000 /

    (8,9,10) 2

    . (solid media)

    ogawa Lowenstein-Jensen 6-8

    (contamination rate) 2-5

    . (liquid media)

    BACTEC-MGIT 960 2-3 100

    /(9) yield solid media 10

    contamination rate 10

    smear (no

    growth) digestion & decontamination

    identification M. tuberculosis

    - (DST)

    . 1 (first-line DST, FL-DST)

    4-5 H, R, E, S pyrazinamide (Z) ()

    (MTB isolates) indirect test (gold standard)

    proportion method 3-4

    1-3

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    11

    DST R H

    S, E Z

    R

    (strain)

    (reproductive fitness)

    strain (10-20 mutate strains) conventional DST

    molecular technique

    R ( FQs SLIs) molecular technique

    conventional DST(11)

    . 2 (second-line DST,

    SL-DST) solid

    automated liquid system amionoglycosides, polypeptides, FQs

    para-aminosalicylic acid

    (PAS), ethionamide (Eto), cycloserine (Cs)

    1 (FL-DST) MDR-TB

    2 (SL-DST)

    2.2.3.2 Line probe assay (LPA) genotype MTB-DR plus

    H R

    2

    (gold standard) MDR-TB

    160 cells(12) smear

    (culture isolated) (13)

    LPA R 91.7 96.6

    H 70.6 99.1

    MODS (microscopic observation drug susceptibility)(14, 15) LAMP (loop-mediated

    isothermal amplification) assay(16)

    MDR-TB

    smear 24

    solid media 9-12

    liquid media 3-5 LPA smear

    MDR-TB 1-2 smear

    liquid media 2.1(17)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    12

    2.1MDR-TB(goldstandard)(17)

    1. MDR diagnosis with soild culture & DST

    2. MDR-TB diagnosis with liquid culture & DST

    3. MDR-TB diagnosis with line prode assay, liquid culture & DST

    Microscopy24 hours

    Microscopy24 hours

    Microscopy24 hours

    Solid culture6-8 weeks

    FL-DST3-4 weeks

    FL-DST1-3 weeks

    FL-DST1-3 weeks

    MDR-TB diagnosisAfter 9-12 weeks

    MDR-TB diagnosisAfter 3-5 weeks

    MDR-TB diagnosisAfter 3-5 weeks

    MDR-TB diagnosisAfter 1-2 days

    Line probe assay +24 hours

    Line probe assay -24 hours

    Liquid culture2-3 weeks

    liquid culture2-3 weeks

    MDR-TB

    3

    MDR-TB

    molecular test LPA Xpert MTB/RIF ( molecular test

    culture DST)

    - LPA MDR-TB 1

    MDR-TB MDR-TB

    FLDs SLDs

    - Xpert MTB/RIF R

    culture DST

    2

    Xpert MTB/RIF

    . MTB detected, R resistance R MDR-TB

    MDR regimen

    . MTB detected, R resistance not detected

    MDR-TB 1

    . MTB detected, R resistance indeterminate

    R () 1

    DST

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    13

    . MTB not detected NTM culture

    identification 1

    . invalid or error X-pert

    MTB/RIF invalid/error 1

    DST

    conventional DST

    (individualized MDR regimen)

    (migrant worker)

    liquid solid culture FL-DST 4 ( LPA

    )

    2.2

    2.2

    Assess the risk of MDR-TB

    1) all retreatment TB cases (TAF, TAD, relapse)2) during TB treatment, smear+ at M3, M53) new TB cases, contact with MDR-TB

    new TB cases with HIV+,prisoners, migrants, HCWs

    individualized drug regimen (depend on DST result)

    Culture & DST (or LPA if possible)

    Start FLD regimenwhile waiting for DST

    result

    LPA X-pert MTB/RIF* Culture & DST*

    Non MDR MDRMTB, RR

    MDR regimenRepeat

    X-pert MTB/RIF**Start or continue

    FLD regimen

    invalid/error-MTB, R not resist-MTB, R indeteminate-MTB not detect

    Molecular test

    * 2 2

    ** repeat FLD regimen

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    14

    DST (transient

    resistance)(11)

    H 4-5

    colony

    DST

    smear

    culture DST

    MDR-TB

    1. . ,

    2. :

    ; 2556.

    2. World Health Organization. Companion Handbook to the WHO Guidelines for the

    Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO;

    2014: 17-22.

    3. Toman K. How many bacilli are present in a sputum specimen found positive by smear

    microcopy? In: Frieden TR, ed. Tomans tuberculosis: case detection, treatment and

    monitoring, 2nd ed. China: World Health Organization; 2004: 11-3.

    4. Toman K. How reliable is smear microcopy? In: Frieden TR, ed. Tomans tuberculosis:

    case detection, treatment and monitoring, 2nd ed. China: World Health Organization;

    2004: 14-22.

    5. World Health Organization. Policy statement: automated real-time nucleic amplification

    technology for rapid and simultaneous detection of tuberculosis and rifampicin

    resistance: Xpert MTB/RIF system. WHO; 2011 (WHO/HTM/TB/2011.4).

    6. World Health Organization. Rapid implementation of the Xpert MTB/RIF diagnostic test:

    technical and operational How-to practical considerations. Geneva, Switzerland:

    World Health Organization; 2011: 6.

    7. World Health Organization. Xpert MTB/RIF assay for diagnosis of pulmonary and

    extrapulmonary TB in adults and children. Policy update. France: WHO; 2013.

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    15

    8. World Health Organization. Laboratory services in tuberculosis control, part III: culture. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO; 1998: 9.

    9. Yeager H Jr, Lacy J, Smith LR, LeMaistre CA. Quantitative studies of mycobacterial population in sputum and saliva. Am Rev Respir Dis 1967; 95: 998-1004.

    10. DeunAV.What is the roleofmycobacterialculture indiagnosisandcasefinding?

    In: Frieden TR, ed. Tomans tuberculosis: case detection, treatment and monitoring, 2nd ed. China: World Health Organization; 2004: 35-43.

    11. Caminero JA, ed. Guidelines for clinical and operational management of drug-resistant tuberculosis. Paris, France: International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Diseases; 2013: 13-70.

    12. Hain Lifescience GmbH. GenoType MTBDR plus, instructions for use. Germany; 2014.13. Luetkemeyer AF, Kendall MA, Wu X, Loureno MC, Jentsch U, Swindells S, et al.

    Evaluation of two line probe assays for rapid detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, tuberculosis (TB) drug resistance, and non-TB Mycobacteria in HIV-infected individuals with suspected TB. J Clin Microbiol 2014; 52: 1052-9.

    14. Pandey B D, Poudel A, Yoda T, et al. Development of an in-house loop mediated isothermalamplification(LAMP)assayfordetectionofMycobacteriumtuberculosis

    and evaluation in sputum samples of Nepalese patients. J Med Microbiol 2008; 57: 439-43.

    15. World Health Organization. Implementing tuberculosis diagnosis: policy framework. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO; 2015 (WHO/HTM/TB/2015.11).

    16. Moore DA, Mendoza D, Gilman RH, ed al. Microscopic observation drug susceptibility assay, a rapid, reliable diagnostic test for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis suitable for use in resource-poor setting. J Clin Microbiol 2004; 42: 44327.

    17. World Health Organization. Policy framework for implementing new tuberculosis diagnosis. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO; 2010.

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    16

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    17

    3.1

    1

    5 3.1(1,2,3,4)

    1: 1 (first-line oral anti-tuberculosis agents)

    isoniazid (INH, H), rifampicin (R), pyrazinamide (Z), ethambutol (E)

    (drug susceptibility testing, DST)

    2: (injectable anti-tuberculosis agents) capreomycin

    (Cm) aminoglycosides kanamycin (Km), amikacin (Am) streptomycin

    (S) Km Am S

    Km Am (ototoxicity) S

    Km Am cross-resistance

    Km Am

    Cm Km

    aminoglycosides

    3: (fluoroquinolones) levofloxacin

    (Lfx), moxifloxacin (Mfx) ofloxacin (Ofx)

    MDR-TB Lfx Mfx Ofx ciprofloxacin

    3:

    Mono-, Poly- Multi- drug resistant TB

    3.1

    3.2

    3.3

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    18

    drug-susceptible drug-resistant TB

    cross-resistance

    4 : 2 (oral bacteriostatic second-line

    anti-tuberculosis agents) para-aminosalicylic acid (PAS, P), cycloserine (Cs), terizidone

    (Trd), ethionamide (Eto) prothionamide (Pto) Eto

    MDR-TB 2

    Eto PAS 3 Eto, PAS Cs Pto

    Eto Trd Cs

    5: (anti-tuberculosis agents with unclear

    efficacy in treatment of drug resistant TB) clofazimine (Cfz), linezolid (Lzd), amoxicillin/

    clavulanate (Amx/Clv), thioacetazone (Thz), meropenem/clavulanate (Mer/Clv), imipenem/

    cilastatin (Ipm/Cln), high-dose isoniazid (16-20 mg/kg/day) clarithromycin (Clr)

    MDR-TB

    1 4

    4 XDR-TB

    Lzd MDR-TB

    XDR-TB 80 MDR-TB

    50 XDR-TB(5,6)

    Pre-XDR-TB XDR-TB linezolid (600 ) 1

    XDR-TB

    ()

    1) Lzd, 2) Cfz,

    3) Ipm/Cln, 4) Clr, 5) Amx/Clv, 6) Thz 7) high-dose INH

    MDR-TB, Pre-XDR-TB XDR-TB bedaquiline

    (Bdq)(7) delamanid (Dlm)(8) Interim policy Bdq

    Dlm MDR-TB, Pre-XDR-TB XDR-TB

    5

    . (proper patient inclusion)

    18 /

    / Dlm

    Bdq 65

    . (informed consent)

    .

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    19

    .

    . (active pharmacovigilance)

    3.1(1,2,3,4)

    (//)(/)**

    1:

    First-line oral

    agents

    - Isoniazid (H, INH) 5 300

    - Rifampicin (R) 10 450-600

    - Pyrazinamide (Z) 20-30 1,000-2,000

    - Ethambutol (E) 15-20 800-1,200

    2:

    Injectable agents

    - Streptomycin (S) 15 750-1,000

    - Kanamycin (Km, K) 15 750-1,000

    - Amikacin (Am) 15 750-1,000

    - Capreomycin (Cm) 15 750-1,000

    3:

    Fluoroquinolones (FQs)

    - Levofloxacin (Lfx) 15 500-750

    - Moxifloxacin (Mfx) 7.5-10 400

    4:

    Oral bacteriostatic

    second-line agents

    - Ethionamide (Eto) 15 500-750

    - Prothionamide (Pto) 15 500-750

    - Para-aminosalicylic acid (PAS, P) 150-200 8,000-12,000

    - Cycloserine (Cs) 15 500-750

    5:

    Agents with

    unclear efficacy in

    treatment of drug

    resistant-TB

    - Linezolid (Lzd) - 600

    - Clofazimine (Cfz) - 100

    - Imipenem/cilastatin (Ipm/Cln) - 500-1000 b.i.d.

    - Clarithromycin (Clr) - 500 b.i.d.

    - Amoxicillin/clavulanate (Amx/Clv) - 875/125 b.i.d.

    - High-dose isoniazid (High-dose H)* 16 600-800 OD

    - Bedaquiline (Bdq) - 400 OD

    2

    200 OD (3

    )

    22 ***

    - Delamanid (Dlm) - 100 b.i.d.

    24

    * High-dose isoniazid (High-dose H) INH (>1% 0.2 / 1 / INH) High-dose H INH (>1% 1 / INH)***** prolong QT Cfz, FQs, Dlm, azole, anti-fungal drugs

    additive QT prolongation

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    20

    3.2(1,2,9)

    1 Sm

    2 1

    H, R, Z Sm bactericidal activity E bacteriostatic activity

    2 bactericidal activity FQs,

    aminoglycosides polypeptide

    1

    2

    (intensive phase) (maintenance phase)

    3 4

    2 3

    MDR-TB

    (intensive phase) 3 4 (maintenance

    phase) 2 3

    MDR-TB

    (drug resistance survey)

    standardized MDR-TB regimen of NTP

    individualized regimen

    20

    MDR-TB

    .

    .

    (standardized MDR-TB regimen of NTP)

    6 4 5

    3

    20 18

    .

    . 1

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    21

    . high quality DOT

    . (AFB smear)

    (culture) 6 8

    2

    .

    .

    4 2 3

    18 24

    3.2.1

    MDR-TB(buildingregimenformono/polyDR-TB)(1,2,9)

    1 : 1 (H, R, Z, E)

    2: FQs 1 (Lfx, Mfx, Ofx)

    3: 4 1 2

    injectable agent 1 (Km, Am, Cm, S)

    3.2.2 (buildingregimenfor

    MDR-TB)(1,2,3,6,10,11,12)

    1 : 1 (Z, E)

    2: FQs 1 (Lfx, Mfx) injectable agents 1 (Km, Am,

    Cm, S) Lfx Km

    3: 2 (Eto, Cs, PAS)

    2 4 6 ( 1)

    4 : 4 6 2 3

    5 (Lzd, Cfz, Mer/Clv, Ipm/Cln, Clr, Amx/Clv, Thz, High-dose H)

    5 Lzd

    1 (6)

    3.2.3

    (buildingregimenforPre-XDR-TBandXDR-TB)(1,2,4)

    1: FQs 1 (Lfx, Mfx) injectable agents 1 (Km, Am,

    Cm) XDR-TB FQs FQs

    Mfx FQs Pre-XDR-TB injectable agents

    Cm

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    22

    2: 2 (Eto, PAS, Cs)

    4

    3: 5 (Lzd, Cfz, Mer/Clv, Ipm/Cln, Clr, Amx/

    Clv, Thz, High-dose H) 2 4

    Lzd 1 (6)

    bedaquiline(7)

    XDR-TB

    FQs injectable agents

    treatment after failure (TAF)

    >6Km5LfxEtoPCs/>14LfxEtoPCs

    treatment after relapse treatment after default (TAD)

    2HRZES/1HRZE/5HRE

    3.2 3.3

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    23

    3.2(1,2,3,4)

    **

    E H, R, Z 6 2HRZ/4HRH R, Z, E 6-9

    12

    6-9RZE

    2RZE/10RE

    H S R, Z, E 6-9

    12

    6-9RZE

    2RZE/10RE

    H E (S) R, Z, FQs 6-9

    12

    12

    6-9RZLfx (Ofx)

    2RZLfx (Ofx)/10RLfx (Ofx)

    2RZLfx (Ofx)/10RZ

    Z H, R, E 9

    9

    2HRE/7HR

    2HRES/7HR

    H Z R, E, FQs 9-12

    12

    12

    9-12RELfx (Ofx)

    2RELfx (Ofx)/10RLfx (Ofx)

    2RELfx (Ofx)/10RE

    H Z

    E

    R, FQs, Injectable ( 3-6

    ), Plus X*18 >3K

    5RLfx (Ofx)P(Eto, Cs)/

    12-18 RLfx(Ofx)P(Eto, Cs)

    R H, E, Z, FQs 18 2HEZLfx (Ofx)/16HLfx (Ofx)

    2HEZLfx (Ofx)/16HE

    R Z (

    E)

    H, E ( Z), FQs, Injectable

    ( 3 )

    18 >3K5HLfx (Ofx)E(Z)/12-18 HLfx-

    (Ofx)E(Z)

    R Z

    EH, FQs, Injectable ( 3-6

    ), Plus X*18 >3K

    5HLfx (Ofx)P(Eto, Cs)/

    12-18 HLfx(Ofx)P(Eto, Cs)

    MDR with

    any drug

    resistance

    Injectable, FQs, Eto, P, Cs 20-24 >6K5LfxEtoPCs/>14LfxEtoPCs***

    (

    )

    FQs Lfx Ofx

    X* Eto, PAS Cs

    ** rifampicin resistance ofloxacin rifampicin

    efflux pump resistance ofloxacin

    *** vitamin B6 100-300 mg/day second line drug Cs

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    24

    3.3(13)

    Treatmentafterrelapseor

    defaultTreatmentafterfailure

    MDR-TB

    2HRZES/1HRZE/5HRE >6K5LfxEtoPCs/>14Lfx

    EtoPCs

    DST* individualized regimen

    *DST = drug susceptibility testing

    DST FLDs SLDs

    2

    DST DST

    DST 3-4 DST

    . (transient resistance) H

    H

    H

    H colony

    H

    . (functionally receiving only one drug)

    4 H R, E, Z, S maintenance phase

    HR R 2

    R rapid test Xpert MTB/RIF R

    MDR-TB regimen mono-resistant regimen

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    25

    3.3(1,2)

    .

    . (sputum AFB smear)

    . (sputum culture)

    2

    . 3

    6 6

    Sputumsmearconversion

    sputumcultureconversion

    sputumconversion 2

    2 30 sputum conversion

    MDR-TB culture conversion

    culture conversion

    4 culture conversion

    18 6 8

    20 3.4

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    26

    3.4(2)

    ,

    2-3

    ,

    culture conversion 4

    2

    (

    3 )

    3 6 6

    Serum creatinine ( 1-3

    HIV )

    Serum potassium ( 1-3

    HIV ) Cm Dlm

    Thyroid stimulating

    hormone (TSH)

    3 ethionamide/protionamide

    / PAS ( thyroid hormone )

    Liver enzymes 1-3 pyrazinamide

    HIV Bdq

    HIV

    CBC Lzd CBC 2

    HIV AZT

    Lipase Lzd, d4T, ddI, ddC

    Lactic acidosis Lzd ART

    E 2

    ECG Mfx, Cfz, Bdq, Dlm

    2, 12, 24 (

    hypothyroidism electrolyte imbalance)

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    27

    1. . .

    2. : ; 2556.

    2. World Health Organization. Guidelines for the programmatic management of drug-

    resistant tuberculosis. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 2008 (WHO/

    HTM/TB/2008.402).

    3. Chang KC, Yew WW. Management of difficult multidrug-resistant tuberculosis and

    extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis: Update 2012. Respirology 2013; 18: 8-21.

    4. Caminero JA, ed. Guidelines for clinical and operational management of drug-resistant

    tuberculosis. Paris, France: International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease;

    2013: 13-70.

    5. Cox H and Ford N. Linezolid for the treatment of complicated drug-resistant tuberculosis:

    a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2012; 16: 447-54.

    6. Sotgiu G, Centis R, DAmbrosio L, Alffenaar JW, Anger HA, Caminero JA, et al. Efficacy,

    safety and tolerability of linezolid containing regimens in treating MDR-TB and XDR-TB:

    systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur Respir J 2012; 40: 1430-42.

    7. World Health Organization. The use of bedaquiline in the treatment of multidrug-

    resistant tuberculosis: interim policy guidance. Geneva, Switzerland: World health

    organization; 2013 (WHO/HTM/TB/2013.6).

    8. World Health Organization. The use of delamanid in the treatment of multidrug-resistant

    tuberculosis: interim policy guidance. France: World health organization; 2014 (WHO/

    HTM/TB/2014.23).

    9. World Health Organization. Guidelines for the programmatic management of drug-

    resistant tuberculosis 2011 update. Geneva, Switzerland: World health organization;

    2011 (WHO/HTM/TB/2011.6).

    10. Chaiprasert A, Srimuang S, Tingtoy N, Makhao N, Sirirudeeporn P, Tomnongdee N, et al.

    Eleven-year experience on anti-TB drugs direct susceptibility testing from Siriraj Hospital,

    Thailand. Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis 2013; 77: 241-4.

    11. Chang KC, Yew WW, Tam CM, Leung CC. WHO group 5 drugs and difficult multidrug-

    resistant tuberculosis: a systematic review with cohort analysis and meta-analysis.

    Antimicrob Agents Chemother 2013; 57: 4097-104.

    12. Reechaipichitkul W. Multidrug-resistant tuberculosis at Srinagarind Hospital. Southeast

    Asian J Trop Med Public Health 2002; 33: 570-4.

    13. World Health Organization. Treatment of tuberculosis guidelines. 4th ed. Geneva,

    Switzerland: World health organization; 2010 (WHO/HTML.2009.420).

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    28

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    29

    4.1

    (M. tuberculosis) 2 1

    log phase

    107-108 2

    dormant phase ( 4.1)

    (1,2)

    INH Sm

    4

    4.1

    4.2 /

    4.3

    4.4

    4.5

    4.6

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    30

    (solid caseous material) (semi-dormant)

    R

    PZA PZA

    (intensive phase) (105

    )

    (continuous phase)

    (1,2)

    4.1(1,2)

    High

    Speed of

    Continuous

    growth

    DormantAcid

    inhibition

    Spurts of

    metabolism

    Bacterial growth

    Low

    INH(R, S)

    PZA R

    B C

    A

    D

    4.2/(3)

    4.1

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    31

    4.1

    /

    (

    3)

    Dru

    gAbso

    rption

    Cmax

    g/ml

    MIC

    g/ml

    Distribution

    Metab

    olis

    mEx

    cretion

    Ison

    iazi

    d

    (H)

    (

    )

    ,

    Cmax

    1-2

    5.4+

    2.0

    (rapi

    d

    met

    abol

    ism

    )

    7.1+

    1.0

    (slo

    w

    met

    abol

    ism

    )

    0.02

    -0.2

    acet

    ylat

    ion

    (

    auto

    som

    al d

    omin

    ant):

    slow

    ace

    tyla

    tors

    , rap

    id a

    cety

    lato

    rs

    sl

    ow a

    cety

    lato

    rs

    2-4.

    5

    r

    apid

    ace

    tyla

    tors

    0.75

    -1.8

    75-

    95

    Rifa

    mpi

    cin

    (R)

    90

    -95,

    Cmax

    1.5

    -3

    (

    )

    14.9

    10.

    05-1

    80

    ent

    eroh

    epat

    ic c

    ircul

    a-

    tion,

    dea

    cety

    latio

    n,

    activ

    e m

    etab

    olite

    ,

    hepa

    tic e

    nzym

    e in

    duce

    r

    2-5

    (

    )

    30

    65

    Pyra

    zina

    mid

    e

    (Z)

    ,

    Cmax

    2

    38.7

    +5.9

    16-5

    0

    (pH

    5.5

    )

    5

    hydr

    olys

    ed

    hydr

    oxyl

    ated

    5-hy

    drox

    ypyr

    a-

    zino

    ic a

    cid

    9.5

    3

    Etha

    mbu

    tol

    (E)

    70

    -80,

    Cmax

    2-4

    0.97

    21-

    5

    40

    15

    alde

    hyde

    dic

    arbo

    xylic

    met

    abol

    ites

    3-4

    ,

    75

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    32

    Dru

    gAbso

    rption

    Cmax

    g/ml

    MIC

    g/ml

    Distribution

    Metab

    olis

    mEx

    cretion

    Stre

    ptom

    ycin

    (S)

    ,

    Cmax

    < 1

    25-5

    02-

    8

    34

    2.3

    -4

    ,

    90

    Oflo

    xaci

    n

    (Ofx

    )/

    Levo

    floxa

    cin

    (Lfx

    )

    Mox

    iflox

    ain

    (Mfx

    )

    ,

    Cmax

    < 2

    3.0

    6.21

    +1.3

    4

    4.34

    +1.5

    1

    0.5-

    2.5

    Ofx

    , Lf

    x

    M

    fx

    /

    Ofx

    5-7

    .5

    , Lfx

    6-8

    ,

    Mfx

    12-

    13

    ,

    Cycl

    oser

    ine

    (Cs)

    ,

    Cmax

    3-4

    10.0

    35-

    20

    pep

    tidog

    lyca

    n sy

    nthe

    sis

    10

    Ethi

    onam

    ide

    (Eto

    )

    ,

    Cmax

    1-1

    .5

    2.16

    2.5-

    10

    m

    ycol

    ic a

    cid

    H

    1

    .92

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    33

    Dru

    gAbso

    rption

    Cmax

    g/ml

    MIC

    g/ml

    Distribution

    Metab

    olis

    mEx

    cretion

    Para

    amin

    o-

    salic

    ylic

    aci

    d

    (PAS

    )

    60-6

    5,

    Cmax

    6

    21.4

    1-10

    fo

    lic

    acid

    1

    Kana

    myc

    in

    (Km

    )/

    Amik

    acin

    (Am

    )

    Capr

    eom

    y-

    cin

    (Cm

    )

    IM

    Cm

    ax 1

    -2

    35-4

    52-

    4

    Km, A

    m

    2.3-

    4

    Cm

    4-6

    Line

    zolid

    (Lzd

    )

    Cmax

    1-2

    12.5

    1-4

    oxid

    atio

    n

    m

    orph

    olin

    e rin

    g

    4.9

    Beda

    quili

    ne

    (Bdq

    )

    Cmax

    5

    400

    mg

    1

    Cmax

    = 5

    .5

    0.03

    CYP3

    A4

    a

    ctiv

    e

    N-d

    esm

    ethy

    l m

    etab

    olite

    (M2)

    173

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    34

    4.3

    R 1 108 H, S, E, PAS,

    Km 1 106 Eto, Cm Cs 1 103

    108 S 10-100

    (4)

    (5) 4.2 (6,7)

    4.2 rifampicin subunit RNA polymerase RNA 95

    -subunit rpo B gene

    4.2(5)

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    35

    4.2 Mycobacterium

    tuberculosis(6,7)

    Minimal

    inhibitory

    concen-

    trations

    (MICs)

    (/

    )

    H mycolic

    acid

    0.02-0.2 katG

    inhA

    catalase-

    peroxidase

    enoyl ACP

    reductase

    50-95

    8-43

    R RNA polymerase

    RNA

    0.05-1 rpoB -subunit of RNA polymerase

    95

    Z

    16-50

    (pH 5.5)

    pncA nicotinamidase/ pyrazinamidase

    72-97

    E arabinosyl transferase

    arabinogalactan

    1 -5 embB arabinosyl transferase

    47-65

    S ribosome 30S

    subunit ribosomal S12

    protein 16S rRNA

    mRNA

    2-8 rpsLrrs

    gidB

    S12 ribosomal

    protein

    16S rRNA

    rRNA

    methyltransferase

    52-59

    8-21

    Am/

    Km/

    Cm

    ribosome 30S

    subunit 16S rRNA

    mRNA

    2-4 rrs 16S rRNA 76

    FQs DNA gyrase

    (topoisomerase II)

    topoisomerase IV

    chromosomal

    replication

    0.5-2.5 gyrA

    gyrB

    DNA gyrase

    subunit A

    DNA gyrase

    subunit B

    -subunit of RNA polymerase

    75-94

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    36

    Minimal

    inhibitory

    concen-

    trations

    (MICs)

    (/

    )

    Eto mycolic

    acid

    2.5-10 etaA/ethAinhA

    flavin

    monooxygenase

    37

    56

    PAS PAS folate

    synthesis antagonist

    folic acid

    0.5-2 enzyme

    dihydrofo-

    rate (DHFS)

    mutation

    inhibits DHFS

    enzymatic

    Unknown

    Cs cell wall synthesis

    cycloserine

    D-alanine

    cell wall synthesis

    peptidoglycan

    synthesis

    L-alanine

    D-alanine

    D-alanine 2

    D-alanine-D-alanine

    5-30 D-alanine

    mutation

    inhibition of

    alanine racemase

    and D-alanyl-D-

    alanine synthetase

    Unknown

    Lzd 23S RNA

    50S ribosomal

    subunit

    0.125-0.5 23S RNA

    mutation

    ribosomal

    inhibition

    Unknown

    Bdq proton pump

    mycobacterial ATP

    synthase

    ATP

    0.03 AtpE gene

    mutation

    ATP

    synthase subunit C

    Unknown

    Dlm mycolic

    acid

    0.006-0.024 Rx3547

    gene

    mutation

    unknown Unknown

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    37

    4.4

    ( ) ( )

    ( )

    (8) 4.3

    - aminoglycosides

    serum creatinine

    - (electrolyte wasting) Cm

    serum potassium

    Cm

    - (hypothyroidism) PAS Eto

    10 TSH

    TSH 3

    3 6

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    38

    4.3

    (8)

    *

    1. Seizure

    ()

    Cs(3%)(9),

    H, Lfx, Mfx, Ofx

    1.

    2.

    - Phenytoin loading

    dose 1

    maintenance dose 300 ./

    - Vaproic acid

    initial dose 10-15

    ././ maintenance

    dose 20-30 ././(10)

    - Phenobarbital

    loading dose 10-20 ./.

    20 (maximum dose

    30 ./.) loading

    dose 12

    maintenance dose

    1-3 ././

    1 2

    (11)

    ( phenytoin INH)

    3. pyridoxine 200

    ./

    4.

    5.

    6.

    1.

    MDR-TB

    2.

    /

    3.

    MDR-TB

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    39

    *

    2. Hepatitis

    (

    )

    PZA(1%)(9),H

    (0.1-0.6%)(12),R

    (0-1.6%)(12),

    Eto (2%)(8), Pto,

    PAS, E

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    1.

    2.

    3. Renal

    toxicity

    (

    )

    Cm(20-25%)(9),

    Km (3.4%)(9), Am

    (3.4%)(9), Sm

    (2%)(9)

    1.

    2. 3

    (

    )

    3.

    4.

    1.

    2.

    4. Optic

    neuritis

    (

    )

    E(

    30./

    ./

    18%)(9)H, Eto, Pto

    1.

    2.

    3.

    1. etham-

    butol

    5. Bone

    marrow

    suppression

    (

    )

    Lzd(12.5%)(13) 1. Lzd

    2.

    CBC

    300 ./

    3.

    CBC 2

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    40

    *

    6. Hearing

    loss and

    vestibular

    disturbance

    (

    )

    Sm(1.5%)(9),

    Km(1.5%)(9),

    Am(1.5%)(9)

    1 .

    ()

    2. Cm

    3. 3

    4.

    5.

    1. amio-

    glycoside

    baseline

    2.

    3.

    7. Hypo-

    thyroidism

    (

    )

    PAS,Eto,Pto 1. thyroid

    hormone (levothyroxine)

    50-100

    / 6-8

    (maximum: 300 /

    ) euthyroidism

    2.

    1.

    2. PAS Eto

    Pto

    8.Gastritis

    (

    )

    PAS,Eto, Pto 1. H2-blockers

    ranatidine 150 . 2 ,

    PPIs omeprazole 20 .

    (antacid)

    2.

    3.

    1.

    2.

    2

    3

    3.

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    41

    *

    9. Peripheral

    neuropathy

    (

    )

    INH( 500 ms

    2.

    - ECG

    - Bdq QTc

    > 500 ms

    - QT

    prolongation

    - potassium,

    calcium magnesium

    -

    QT prolongation

    1. QTc < 440 ms

    QTc > 440 ms

    (cardiac arrhythmias )

    torsades de pointes

    QTc

    > 500 ms

    2. FQs

    QT prolongation

    Mfx

    Lfx

    Ofx

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    44

    4.5(importantdruginteractions)

    1-5 MDR-,

    Pre-XDR-, XDR-TB 4.4

    4.4

    1:First-lineoralanti-tuberculosisagents

    INH(16,17) - INH carbama- zepine CYP 2C9 CYP

    3A4 - INH phenytoin

    CYP 2C9

    - carbamazepine, phenytoin

    -

    INH

    R(17,18,19) - single protease inhibitor (PI) atazanavir (ATV), lopinavir (LPV), ritonavir (RTV) PI AUC 80

    - dual PIs 1. saquinavir (SQV)/ritonavir (RTV)

    2. lopinavir (LPV)/ritonavir (RTV) (Kaletra)

    3. super-boosted LPV/RTV (Kaletra)

    -

    - 1. SQV 400 mg + RTV 400 mg 2

    2. LPV/RTV (Kaletra)

    4 (200 . LPV 50 . RTV) 2

    3. super-boosted LPV/RTV (Kaletra) 2 (200 . LPV 50 . RTV) + 300 . RTV 2

    - efavirenz (EFV) - EFV1. 50 . 600

    ./2. 50 . 800

    ./

    - nevirapine (NVP) -

    - azole (ketoconazole, itraconazole)

    - - fluconazole

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    45

    R(17,18,19) - warfarin - INR prothrombin time (PT) warfarin

    - digoxin - digoxin digoxin

    - - high dose estrogen (50 )

    - sulfo- nylurea (glyburide, glimepiride,

    glipizide) (20)

    -

    R FQs efflux pump (21)

    2:Injectableanti-tuberculosisagents(16,19)

    SmKmAmCm

    - amphoteri-cin B, cephalosporin, cyclospo-rin, cisplatin, furosemide vancomycin

    -

    Cm - neuromuscular blocking agents non-depolarizing muscle relaxant vecuronium

    - non-depolarizing muscle relaxant neuromuscular function

    3:Fluoroquinolones(22)

    Ofx LfxMfx

    - didanosine (ddI) aluminium, magnesium FQs

    - 2

    - warfarin - INR PT

    - theophylline - theophylline

    4:Oralbacteriostaticsecond-lineagents

    PAS(8,16) - digoxin - Eto

    - hypothyroidism

    Eto- acetylation

    isoniazid isoniazid

    - digoxin - liver enzymes

    - thyroid hormone (levothyroxine)- INH

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    46

    Eto

    Pto(16)- Cs

    neurotoxicity

    -

    - PAS

    - B6 (200 ./)

    -

    - liver enzymes hypothy-

    roidism Eto

    PAS

    Cs(16) - Eto INH

    CNS Cs

    - Cs

    - B6

    -

    5:Agentswithunclearroleintreatmenttodrugresistance

    Cfz(8) - Cfz weak inhibitor CYP

    3A4

    - Cfz R

    time to Cmax

    drug interactions

    dapsone, estrogen A

    -

    Lzd(8,16) - buspirone,

    mereridone, fluoxetine

    serotonin 5-HT1 antagonists

    serotonin syndrome

    -

    Clr(18,23) - EFV, NVP

    clarithromycin

    -

    :NewdrugsforMDR-,Pre-XDR-,MDR-TB

    Bdq(24) -

    CYP3A4

    ketoconazole LPV/RTV

    Bdq

    toxicity

    R enzyme inducer

    Bdq

    drug interactions

    -

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    47

    HIV HIV

    Bdq

    Dlm(25) - drug-drug interaction

    Dlm TDF, EFV

    LPV/RTV

    Dlm

    HIV

    MDR-TB Dlm

    ART

    -

    4.6(newdrugsintuberculosis)

    linezolid (Lzd), bedaquiline

    (Bdq), delamanid (Dlm), sutezolid (PNU-100480), PA-824(15)

    MDR-, Pre-XDR-, XDR-TB

    4.6.1 Linezolid (Lzd)

    Lzd oxazolidinones

    (Food and Drug Administration, FDA) Enterococcus faecium

    vancomycin

    M. tuberculosis 23S RNA 50S ribosomal subunit MIC

    0.125-0.5 ./. 600 ./

    300 ./

    ()

    (15)

    4.6.2 Bedaquiline (Bdq)

    Bdq diaryquinolones

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    48

    (MDR-TB) .. 2555

    ATP 5.5

    concentration dependent killing

    AUC/MIC

    400 . 1 2 200 . 3

    / 22

    QTc interval QT

    interval prolongation (24)

    4.6.3 Delamanid (Dlm)

    Dlm nitroimidazoles Otsuka

    Pharmaceutical delamanid M.tuberculosis MIC M.tuberculosis 0.006-0.024 / post-antibiotic effect QT interval

    prolongation electrolyte disturbances(25)

    1. Mitnick CD, McGee B, Peloquin CA. Tuberculosis pharmacotherapy: strategies to

    optimize patient care. Expert Opin Pharmacother 2009; 10: 381-401.

    2. Mitchison MA. Basic mechanism of chemotherapy. Chest 1979; 76: 771-81.

    3. Douglas JG and McLeod MJ. Pharmacokinetic factors in the modern drug treatment

    of tuberculosis. Clin Pharmacokinet 1999; 37: 127-46.

    4. Canetti G, Froman S, Grosset J, Hauduroy P, Langerova M, Mahler HT, et al. Myco-

    bacteria: laboratory methods for testing drug sensitivity and resistance. Bull World

    Health Organ. 1963; 29: 565-78.

    5. Courtesy of CDC/Dr.R Butier; Janice Carr, NIAID/Krista Townsend. Available from:

    http://www3. Niaid.nih.gov/topics/tuberculosis/whatis TB/Scientific illustrations/

    multidrug Resistant illustration.htm [Cited 2014 August 5].

    6. Zhang Y, Yew W. Mechanisms of drug resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis.

    Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2009; 13: 1320-30.

    7. Telenti A and Iseman M. Drug-resistant tuberculosis: what do we do now?. Drugs

    2000; 59: 171-9.

    8. World Health Organization. Guidelines for the programmatic management of

    drug-resistant tuberculosis. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 2008

    (WHO/HTM/TB/2008.402).

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    49

    9. American Thoracic Society, CDC, and Infectious Diseases Society of America.

    Treatment of tuberculosis, MMWR 2003; 52 (RR11): 1-77.

    10. Leong WF, Judi C, Leean JA eds. Mims. 124thed. Thailand: Tims (Thailand) Ltd;

    2011.

    11. Phenobarbital [Internet]: Drug.com. Available from: http://www.drugs.com/dosage/

    phenobarbital.html#Usual_Adult_Dose_for_Seizures [Cited 2014 August 5].

    12. . :

    (antituberculosis drug-induced hepatotoxicity: incidence, mechanism and

    management). 2555; 7: 197-204.

    13. Roongruangpitayakul C, Chuchottaworn C. Outcomes of MDR/XDR-TB patients

    treated with linezolid: experience in Thailand. J Med Assoc Thai 2013; 96: 1273-82.

    14. Riddle RW, Bignall JR, Citron KM, Somner AR, Shera M, Stewart ME, Schonell A.

    A Comparison of the toxicity of prothionamide and ethinamide: a report from the

    research committee of the british tuberculosis association. Elsevier Inc., Tubercle

    1968; 49: 125-35.

    15. World health organization. Companion handbook to the WHO guildelines

    programmatic management of drug-resistant tuberculosis. Geneva, Switzerland:

    World Health Organization; 2014 (WHO/HTM/TB/2014.11).

    16. Charles F, Lora L, Morton P, Leonard L. Drug information Handbook 15th ed.

    United states of America. Lexi-comp; 2007-2008: 96-7, 431-2, 664, 942-4.

    17. World Health Organization. Treatment of tuberculosis: guidelines for national

    programmes. 4th ed.; 2009. Available from: http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publica-

    tions/2010/9789241547833_eng.pdf. [Cited 2010 May 1].

    18. (). : .

    : ; 2555: 198-209.

    19. CDC. Managing drug interactions in the treatment of HIV-related tuberculosis;

    2007. Available from: http://www.cdc.gov/tb/TB_HIV_Drugs/default.htm [Cited

    2014 July 1].

    20. Yew WW. Clinically significant interactions with drugs used in the treatment of

    tuberculosis [online]. 2002. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/

    pubmed/11888353 [Cited 2014 July 1].

    21. Louw GE, Warren RM, Gey van Pittius NC, Leon R, Jimenez A, Hernandez-Pando

    R, et al. Rifampicin reduces susceptibility to ofloxacin in rifampicin-resistant

    Mycobacterium tuberculosis through efflux. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2011; 184:

    269-76.

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    50

    22. Oliphant CM and Green GM. Quinolones: a comprehensive review. Am Fam

    Physician 2002; 65: 455-64.

    23. Coyne KM, Pozniak AL, Lamorde M, Boffito M. Pharmacology of second-line

    antituberculosis drugs and potential for interactions with antiretroviral agents.

    AIDS 2009; 23: 437-46.

    24. World Health Organization. The use of bedaquiline in the treatment of multidrug-

    resistant tuberculosis: interim policy guidance. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health

    Organization; 2013 (WHO/HTM/TB/2013.6).

    25. World Health Organization. The use of delamanid in the treatment of multidrug-

    resistant tuberculosis: interim policy guidance. France: World Health Organization;

    2014 (WHO/HTM/TB/2014.23).

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    51

    5.1Pre-XDR-TBXDR-TB

    (extensive drug resistant tuberculosis,

    XDR-TB)

    (World Health Organization, WHO)

    (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, CDC-USA) .. 2006 (.. 2549)

    (MDR-TB)

    aminoglycoside FQs

    ..

    2549 .. 2549(1)

    5.1.1 (Pre-XDR-TB)

    (XDR-TB)

    (XDR-TB)

    ( H R) FQs (Ofx, Lfx, Mfx)

    second line injectable drugs (SLIs) Km, Am, Cm

    (Pre-XDR-TB)

    ( H R) FQs (Ofx, Lfx, Mfx)

    second line injectable drugs (SLIs) Km, Am, Cm

    5.1.2 (Pre-XDR-TB) (XDR-TB)

    H, R, Ofx Km Am

    molecular technique line probe assays (LPA)

    5 XDR-TB

    5.1 Pre-XDR-TBXDR-TB

    5.2 (Palliativecares)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    52

    LPA

    Ofx / Km

    LPA Ofx / Km

    5.1.3 (Pre-XDR-TB)

    (XDR-TB)

    Pre-XDR-TB XDR-TB

    Cs Eto

    Pre-XDR-TB second line injectable drugs (SLIs) / FQs

    (Pre-XDR-TB)

    (XDR-TB)

    4 20

    (Pre-XDR-TB)

    (XDR-TB)*

    1: /

    - aminoglycosides Km, Am, Cm /

    - FQs Lfx, Mfx /

    - second line oral anti-tuberculosis drugs Eto, Cs , PAS

    2:

    4

    - Lzd 300-600 ./ /

    - Cfz 100 ./ /

    - Ipm/Cln 500-1000 . 2 /

    - Clr 500 . 2 /

    - Amx/Clv 875/125 . 2 /

    - High-dose H** 16 ././ 800 ./

    3: Bdq Dlm

    - Bdq 400 .(4 100 .) 14

    200 .(2 100 .) 3 22

    - Dlm 100 . 2 24 :

    *

    ** high-dose H INH (>1% 0.2 /

    1 / INH) high-dose H INH (>1%

    1 / INH)

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    53

    (Pre-XDR-TB)fluoroquinolone

    1. Mfx Mfx 400 ./

    Mfx

    Mfx

    2. Lzd 600 ./

    600 ./ 300 ./(2,3)

    3. Cfz 100 ./ (4,5)

    4. Km 15 ././ 1,000 ./

    5. 3

    Bdq Dlm

    (Pre-XDR-TB)aminoglyoside

    1. Lfx 500-750 ./

    2. Cfz 100 ./ (4,5)

    3. Cm 15 ././ 1,000 ./

    4. 3 Lzd

    Bdq Dlm

    (XDR-TB)

    1. Mfx Mfx 400 ./

    Mfx

    Mfx

    2. Lzd 600 ./

    600 ./ 300 ./ (2,3)

    3. Cfz 100 ./ (4,5)

    4. Cm 15 ././ 1,000 ./

    5. 3

    Bdq Dlm

    5.1.4

    3

    Lzd CBC 2

    (optic neuritis)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    54

    Cm BUN, Cr

    electrolyte potassium

    Cm

    Cfz

    Bdq Dlm

    active pharmacovigilance

    5.2(palliativecare)(6,7)

    MDR/XDR-TB

    MDR/XDR-TB

    (quality of life)

    5.2.1 MDR/XDR-TB

    4

    . DOT

    .

    1

    .

    1 smear

    () smear

    .

    .

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    55

    . HIV

    HIV

    5.2.2

    MDR/XDR-TB

    . smear 8 10

    .

    . 2

    . (respiratory insufficiency)

    5.2.3.

    .

    . 2

    .

    .

    .

    5.2.4

    MDR/XDR-TB (palliative cares)

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    56

    . (disused atrophy)

    .

    5

    1. Revised definition of extensively drug-resitant tuberculosis. MMWR Weekly 2006;

    55: 1176.

    2. Sotgiu G, Centis R, DAmbrosio L, Alffenaar JW, Anger HA, Caminero JA, et al.

    Efficacy, safety and tolerability of linezolid containing regimens in treating MDR-TB

    and XDR-TB: systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur Respir J 2012; 40: 1430-42.

    3. Roongruangpitayakul C, Chuchottaworn C. Outcomes of MDR/XDR-TB patients

    treated with linezolid: experience in Thailand. J Med Assoc Thai 2013; 96: 1273-82.

    4. Cholo MC, Steel HC, Fourie PB, Germishuizen WA, Anderson R. Clofazimine: current

    status and future prospects. J Antimicrob Chemother 2012; 67: 290-8.

    5. Dey T, Brigden G, Cox H, Shubber Z, Cooke G, Ford N. Outcomes of clofazimine

    for the treatment of drug resistant TB: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J

    Antimicrob Chemother 2013; 68: 284-93.

    6. World Health Organization. Guideline for the Programmatic management of

    drug-resistant tuberculosis. Italy: WHO; 2006 (WHO/HTM/TB/2006.361).

    7. World Health Organization. Palliative care: symptom management and end-of-life

    care. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2004 (WHO/CDS/IMAI/2004.4).

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    57

    6.1HIV

    6.1.1

    CD4

    immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome (IRIS)

    6 (1-7)

    CD4

    6

    6.1 HIV

    6.2

    6.3

    6.4

    6.5

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    58

    367 /..

    IRIS

    Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS)

    guidelines .. 2557

    CD4 CD4 50

    /.. 2

    CD4 50 /..

    Karnofsky score (body mass index,

    BMI) 2-4

    8-12

    CD4

    CD4 50 /.. 2

    CD4

    50 /.. 2

    2-8

    CD4

    2-4

    6.1.2

    R

    CYP 450 efflux multi-drug transporter p-glycoprotein

    non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTIs) protease

    inhibitors (PIs) Eto CYP 450

    Eto aminoglycoside

    tenofovir (TDF) 6.1

    .

    HIV TDF + emtricitabine (FTC) + efavirenz (EFV) TDF + lamivudine (3TC) +EFV

    .

    . TDF nucleotide reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NRTI)

    creatinine clearance

    . TDF +

    lamivudine (3TC) + EFV

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    59

    . Abacavir (ABC) + 3TC + EFV NRTIs

    zidovudine (AZT) TDF

    ABC hypersensitivity reaction

    nevirapine (NVP) ABC NVP

    . AZT + 3TC NRTIs

    EFV NVP

    . Efavirenz (EFV) NNRTI

    NVP

    EFV

    . NVP NNRTI

    AZT + 3TC

    CD4 250

    /.. CD4 400 /..

    . Lopinavir (LPV)/ritonavir (RTV) PIs

    800/200 .

    24 . 400/100 . 12 .

    . Darunavir (DRV)/ritonavir (RTV)

    800/100 . 24 .

    . NVP EFV NRTIs

    2-4 NVP EFV

    NNRTIs

    . R

    NNRTIs PIs TDI aminoglycoside Cm

    renal toxicity AZT Lzd anemia d4T

    Lzd peripheral neuropathy LPV/RTV Bdq

    toxicity TDF, EFV LPV/RTV Dlm Dlm

    . aminoglycoside FQs

    TDI renal toxicity, AZT anemia

    d4T peripheral neuropathy first line ART MDR-TB, Pre-XDR-TB

    XDR-TB AZT+3TC+EFV

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    60

    6.1

    NRTIs

    +

    NNRTIs

    NNRTIs

    Tenofovir/emtriciabine*

    Tenofovir/lamivudine

    Efavirenz Lopinavir/

    ritonavir

    Abacavir/lamivudine

    Zidovudine/ lamivudine

    Rilpivirine

    Nevirapine

    Atazanavir/

    ritonavir

    Darunavir/

    ritonavir

    Raltegravir

    Elvitegravir

    *

    6.1.3

    rifampicin (R)

    6.1.3.1 R

    6.1.3.2 R

    R CYP 450

    efflux multi-drug transporter p-glycoprotein NNRTIs PIs

    . NNRTIs EFV NVP

    . PIs

    - PIs NNRTIs EFV NVP

    integrase inhibitor ( raltegravir)

    - NNRTIs integrase inhibitor

    R

    R R

    MDR-TB, Pre-XDR-TB

    XDR-TB AZT+3TC+EFV

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    61

    6.1.4

    CD4

    CD4 6.2

    6.3

    6.2

    CD4 6

    12

    6 12 CD4

    > 350 cells/mm3 VL < 50

    copies/mL 1

    .

    2

    (viral load, VL)

    3

    6

    VL < 50 copies/mL

    1 VL > 50

    copies/mL

    6.3

    ALT

    - 3

    Creatinine (Cr) 15-20

    15-30

    15-30

    1

    -

    50

    50 . indinavir

    (IDV) 6

    - TDF IDV

    6

    Total Cholesterol,

    Triglyceride,

    Fasting blood

    sugar

    1

    1

    - < 35

    1 /

    - < 35

    2 /

    - < 35 2

    /

    ( .)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    62

    Urinalysis 1

    1

    -

    50

    IDV 6

    - TDF IDV

    6

    6.1.5 (immune reconstitution

    inflammatory syndrome, IRIS)

    CD4 CD8

    immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome (IRIS)

    immune recovery syndrome (IRS)

    paradoxical IRIS

    unmasking IRIS

    paradoxical IRIS

    International Network for the Study of HIV-associated

    IRIS (INSHI) paradoxical IRIS (8)

    6.4

    prednisolone placebo

    TB paradoxical IRIS prednisolone 1.5

    ./. 2 0.75 ./. (9)

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    63

    prednisolone

    placebo

    prednisolone

    c-reactive protein (CRP) cytokines interleukin (IL)-6,

    IL-10, IL-12, interferon-gamma (IFN), tumor necrosis factor (TNF) chemokines prednisolone paradoxical IRIS

    1.5 ./. 2

    4 unmasking TB IRIS

    6.4 paradoxicalIRIS(8)

    I. 2

    1.

    2.

    2

    II.

    3

    1 2

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4. (serositis)

    1.

    2.

    3. (peritonitis)

    III.

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    64

    6.2

    primary tuberculous infection

    () AFB

    (primary drug resistance TB)

    acquired drug resistance TB

    MDR-TB (10)

    28 34

    MDR-TB 5.7 3.8 (11,12)

    6.2.1

    1 3

    2

    (index caes)

    80-90(13)

    80 AFB

    (rapid drug susceptibility testing)

    line probe assay Xpert MTB/RIF

    (14-16)

    (17)

    .

    .

    . 1

    .

    6.1(17)

    AFB

    6.2.2

    6.2.2.1

    MDR-TB 15-18

    (18,19)

    5 (20) INH

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    65

    R INH

    INH R(21) (MDR-TB)

    6.2(21)

    6.2.2.2 (17)

    6.2.2.2.1 1 MDR-TB (monoresistant

    polyresistant-TB)

    INH 6-9 RZE 2RZE/10RE

    FQs

    R 2 4 INH,

    E, FQs ( Lfx Ofx) PZA 2 INH E INH FQ

    12-18

    1 MDR-TB

    FQs / 1 2

    12-18 (22)

    6.2.2.2.2 MDR-TB

    6.1

    4 1

    6.5(17,23)

    4 (1) 1

    (2) 2 Am Km (3) 3

    FQs Lfx Mfx Ofx ciprofloxacin (4) 4 2

    1 4

    4

    5

    1 MDR-TB

    Km5LfxEtoCs (PAS) (Km

    5 = kanamycin 5 , Lfx = levofloxacin, Eto

    = etionamide, Cs = cycloserine, PAS = para-aminosalicylic acid) PAS

    MDR-TB PAS(23) PAS

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    66

    4 (17)

    6

    4

    6

    (17,23,24)

    3-4

    18

    20

    (23,24)

    .

    . Directly observed therapy (DOT)

    .

    .

    PAS

    2

    6.5

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    67

    6.1 (17)

    ()

    Xpert MTB/RIF

    RIF Inconclusive

    //

    1

    ()

    * 1

    ( ) /

    /

    * Xpert MTB/RIF rifampicin

    1

    ( )

    2

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    68

    6.2 (MDR-TB)(21)

    MDR-TB

    ?- - -

    - TST IGRAs- /-

    - ( 1 )- -

    12

    1-2 6 2 (

    )

    - -

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    69

    6.5 (17,23)

    ././

    /

    1

    1

    Isoniazid

    Rifampicin

    7-15

    10-20

    300 .

    600 .

    hepatotoxicity

    hepatotoxicity, rash, flu-like

    symptom

    Ethambutol

    Pyrazinamide

    15-25

    30-40

    1.2

    2

    optic neuritis (rare)

    hepatotoxicity,

    arthralgia, rash

    2

    Amikacin

    Kanamycin

    Capreomycin

    15-20

    15-30

    15-30

    1

    1

    1

    ototoxicity,

    nephrotoxicity

    3

    Fluorquino-

    lone

    Ofloxacin

    Levofloxacin

    Moxifloxacin

    15-20

    7.5-10*

    7.5-10

    800 .

    750 .

    400 .

    insomnia

    arthralgia

    4

    2

    Ethionamide 15-20 1 hepatotoxicity, hypothyroidism

    Cyclocerine 10-20 1 psychosis, convulsion,

    paraesthesia, depression

    PAS 150-200

    (

    2-3 )

    1.2 diarrhea, hypothyroidism

    5

    3

    (

    )

    Linezolid 10-12** (1 ) - myelosuppression,

    peripheral neuropathy,

    lactic acidosis

    Clofazimine 3-5 (1 ) - skin discoloration, xerosis

    Amoxi/clavulanate

    - gastrointestinal intolerance

    Thioacetazone 5-8 (1 ) - gastrointestinal intolerance,

    dermatitis, thrombocytopenia,

    agranulocytosis

    Imipenem

    - drug rash, convulsion

    High-dose INH 15-20 (1 ) - hepatitis, peripheral

    neuropathy

    Clarithromycin 7.5-15 ( 2 ) - gastrointestinal intolerance,

    prolonged QT syndrome

    * 5 Levofloxacin 7.5-10 ./. 2

    ** Linezolid 10 10-12 ./. 2

    GI disturbance

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    70

    6.3(managementduringpregnancyandbreast-feeding)

    urine pregnancy test

    second trimester

    (22)

    FLDs SLDs class C FDA Class

    ( 6.6)(25)

    aminoglycosides Sm, Km Am ototoxic teratogenic effect

    Cm ototoxic teratogenic effect

    FQs, Eto unclear efficacy teratogenic effect

    SLDs 4 FQs 1 Cm

    Km second trimester

    first trimester 3

    B6 150 ./ B6

    FQs

    B6 withdrawal

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    71

    6.6 Anti-TBdrugsU.S.FDAclass(25)

    Safetyclass Drug

    A -

    B ethambutol, amoxicillin/clavulanate

    C

    isoniazid, rifampicin, pyrazinamide, fluoroquinolones, ethionamide, prothion-

    amide, para-amionosalicylic acid, cycloserine, capreomycin, linezolid, clarithro-

    mycin, clofazimine

    D streptomycin, kanamycin, amikacin

    X -

    (22) guidelines(25)

    6.4(liverdysfunction)

    ( PZA) hepatotoxicity E aminoglycosides hepatotoxicity

    FQs hepatotoxicity hepatotoxic effect

    4 PZA

    PZA

    6.5(renalinsufficiency)

    6.7(22)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    72

    6.7 (22)

    CrCl2 6

    6. (transferred out)

    6

    7.1.2.1 (final outcome)

    PMDT 08

    1. (cured)

    3 30

    2. (treatment completed)

    3

    3. (treatment failed)

    2

    .

    (culture conversion)

    . (culture reversion)

    . FQs SLIDs

    .

    4. (died)

    5. (lost to follow-up) >2

    6. (transfer out)

    7. (on treatment)

    8. (not evaluated, NE)

    * 8

    ** (treatment success)

    AFB

    2 3 6

    6 2

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    78

    7.2

    DR- TB

    (TB03)

    1 . . . .

    2 PMDT 03

    2 TB 03 DR-TB center (./

    ./.)

    .

    DR-TB center

    3

    6

    1. PMDT 07 3 (detection)

    (enrolment ) DR-TB 1

    6-9

    2. PMDT 07/1 (interim results) 3

    6 2

    PMDT 07 15-18

    3. PMDT 08 (final outcomes) 12

    2 PMDT 07 ( 4 cohort/)

    36-48

    7.3(multidisciplinarycare)

    (DOT)(2,3)

    2

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    79

    DR-TB

    7.3.1

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    1.

    2. (unit dose)

    3.

    4.

    5.

    ()

    1.

    2.

    3. HIV

    4. /

    5. (DOT)

    6.

    7.

    /

    1.

    2.

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    80

    3.

    4.

    (infectioncontrol,IC)

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    1

    5. IC

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    (ProvincialTBcoordinator,PTC)

    1.

    2.

    DOT

    3.

    4.

    (PMDT 07, 07/1, 08) (./.)

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    81

    (RegionalTBCoordinator,RTC)

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4. (PMDT 07, 07/1, 08)

    7.3.2 (case management)

    2

    1. second line drugs

    (DOT)

    2.

    (on the job training)

    (DOT)

    3.

    7.3.3 (DOT)

    DOT (directly observed therapy)

    2 4

    6 20

    (DOT)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    82

    7.3.3.1 (DOT watcher)

    1. (accountability)

    2. (accessibility)

    3. (acceptance)

    (patient support)

    7.3.3.2

    (DOT corner)

    (packet)

    (initial phase) ( 6 )

    (DOT)

    .

    .

    .

    (treatment card/DOT card)

    . 10-15

    .

    .

    .

    .

    . ( 1 )

    (maintenance phase)

    14 (DOT)

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    83

    7.4

    2

    4

    6 20

    2

    10 30

    DOT DR-TB

    DR-TB

    DOT

    7.1

    7.1

    ./ .

    .

    ../

    ./

    ./.

    ./.

    ./.

    (comprehensive)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    84

    . 2

    ./.. DOT

    .

    .

    (refer/transfer) case conference

    ./. ./..

    DOT ./.

    ./.. (.)

    DR-TB

    DR-TB

    2 team approach

    community based clinic based

    (patient center)

    7.5

    2 20

    1.

    (true sputum) 2 . () 2-5 .

    2. ()

    1

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    85

    3. 2 (spot

    sputum) 2 (collected

    sputum)

    4.

    ()

    - (3% normal saline nebulization)

    (

    )

    - /

    (biopsy)

    5.

    (ice pack)

    7.6(2,3)

    (close contact)

    (indoor living space)

    ..

    2

    .

    .

    .

    .

    . DR-TB

    .

    DST 2.2 ( 2)

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    86

    . DR-TB

    tuberculin skin test (TST)

    IGRA Test

    2 smear,

    culture DST Xpert MTB/RIF

    (AFB smear) rifampicin

    .

    DR-TB DR-TB

    . 2

    .

    7.7 . .

    2550 2558 .

    (4) 13

    1.

    - FLD: H 100 , R 300 , R 450 , Z 500 , E 400

    , E 500 , S 1

    - FDC: H 100 + R 150 , H 150 + R 300 H 75

    + R 150 + Z 400 + E 275

    - SLD: Km 1 , Ofx 200 , Lfx 500 , Eto 250 , P 1 ,

    Cs 250

    XDR-TB .

    .

    2.

    - AFB 6 3 () course

    - 5 course

    - Standard package Alternative

    package 7.1(4)

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    87

    7.1 *

    Package &

    Remark

    Standard package

    Solid/Liquid

    culture & DST

    Alternative package

    molecular assay

    + Solid culture

    (DST)

    Re-treatment

    group

    Relapse All case

    (AFB + or -)

    AFB +ve only

    Package

    Treatment after

    default

    On-treatment

    group

    3

    AFB +ve only AFB +ve only

    Pre-treatment

    group with

    risk factors

    Household MDR TB All case

    (AFB + or -)

    AFB +ve only

    Prisoner

    TB with HIV positive

    : * 3-3[4] 89 . 2558 (4)

    .. 1 course ( .

    )

    - . solid liquid culture

    ( DST) 16 course .

    . molecular assay

    3. . . .

    4. . . .

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    88

    1. .

    .. 2556. 2. :

    ; 2556.

    2. .

    .. 2556. 2. :

    ; 2556.

    3. World Health Organization. Companion handbook to the WHO guidelines for the

    programmatic management of drug-resistant tuberculosis, Geneva, Switzerland:

    World Health Organization; 2014 (WHO/HTM/TB/2014.11).

    4. .

    2558:

    . 1. : ; 2557.

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    89

    (1)

    MDR-TB 1.65

    MDR-TB 34.5 .. 2549 XDR-TB .. 2550(2)

    .. 2536

    68-85(3-6)

    39.4-86.4(7-8)

    (9-11)

    (11)

    8.1

    2-10

    (12)

    .

    .

    8

    8.1

    8.2

    8.3

    8.4

    8.5

    8.6

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    90

    .

    (13-17)

    8.1.1

    (18)

    (sputum induction) (bronchoscopy)

    (endotracheal intubation) aerosolized pentamidine

    (wound irrigation) (

    )(19)

    8.1.2

    (20)

    8.2

    3 (21)

    8.2.1 (administrative measures)

    .

  • Guideline for Programmatic Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis

    91

    (13)

    (21)

    .

    .

    smear 24

    . (21)

    (22)

    1-3

    .

    (bronchoscopy)

    .

    (airborne droplet nuclei)(23)

    (21)

    .

    tuberculin skin test (TST)

    interferon gamma release assay (IGRA)

    .

    .

  • Gu

    idelin

    e for

    Pro

    gram

    matic

    Man

    agem

    ent o

    f Dru

    g-Resi

    stant

    Tube

    rculos

    is

    92

    8.2.2 (engineering controls)

    12

    (21)

    (12)

    (smoke tube tracer test)

    (24)

    8.2.3 (respiratory protection)

    1 particulate respirator(22) N95, N99

    8.3

    . (triag