Acumen Publishing Central Works of Philosophy Vol. 1, Ancient and Medieval (2005)

Central Works of Philosophy

! "#! " $

Central Works of Philosophy

Edited by John Shand

%&'()

%'$*#+

%,'$-+

%.'$$ +')

%'$$ +'/(

Central Works of Philosophy Volume 1Ancient and Medieval

Edited by John Shand

0#1*2!!

$!"3+- (

!!(

(!4&4 5#*+3"6&6/ !"

2*3- &7..8&9 :;2*3- &7..8&,7 :!";

(!"!34!

Ancient and Medieval Philosophy: Introduction &"

1 Plato: Republic &7#$%

2 Aristotle: Nicomachean Ethics .8&

3 Lucretius: On the Nature of the Universe 8>'

4 Sextus Empiricus: Outlines of Pyrrhonism >$"$

5 Plotinus: The Enneads &&>$'$

6 Augustine: City of God &.()

7 Anselm: Proslogion &8>"

CO N T E N TS

8 Aquinas: Summa Theologiae &>. *&

9 Duns Scotus: Ordinatio &?

10 William of Ockham: Summa Logicae .(#

?&

@A"6 A!+A@) ! ! (6 +

@46!"*,"6 "

$ $A+A6 (!-

.-/0

(

+@)*1+2222#!"-3*+

+@$(66!"-+&-#

)*@ $ 6 ! " (

CO N T R I B U TO R S

3B6!" "

!# 4#+A6!.&0+#

*4@) 6!

" $++! 6 ! '#

+!%

#$4 $+

$ "

!!A "!C " ! !2 "# +&!63

D$! " 2 " " !D ! !+ ! E! ( 1 +

"E" FG6 !D! 4 !!! ! !" +,!644 -1

5! "HH$ " !

PREFAC E

! !+ .!I 16" *#

$ !" "!! D" +!*+""-+

!!! + 8!+= ! !

(

& "" E (! E $ " + !+?!1)!"(#(

$E "

E+ 7 !AE (J

-# 2(J E (+>!I+

Ancient and Medieval Philosophy

John Shand

!"#$% &

!!!'(#)

**+,,-.%/,,.% /,,.% +,,.% $0*. . 1.%.*

' 2345/35-.%6

7 8

0

4JOHN SHAND

&

'*

*

&99 *

#*)$

-

* : '*$$)

9*8$*1 *9

#23+;/;;-.%6#*

/ANCIENT AND MEDIE VAL PHILOSOPHY: INTRODUCTION

# 7- '#

# #

$ * ' *#9

*0 8 $*$$* $

3JOHN SHAND

9 1 8 $$$

1

781*

@ANCIENT AND MEDIE VAL PHILOSOPHY: INTRODUCTION

$88 )

+JOHN SHAND

5ANCIENT AND MEDIE VAL PHILOSOPHY: INTRODUCTION

!**

8$

&-

0$@@-.%@,,.%9*B0C!B0C"90*B0C

!0.0A*

0A0

$A&0

9 A&

>JOHN SHAND

' ' "#$%

#0D."!#%:!$**"2;;@@-.%6%1*

' A (!

1 A E !*)$BC*(( & "

$! #$%24,,.%6*

A '*

;ANCIENT AND MEDIE VAL PHILOSOPHY: INTRODUCTION

0#$%'*)' 24,35,.%6 1

* 1&

71 & 7"'$%' *$$

)2A6))#8$)&)8

$ A *

9)8"*BC#9)

&).*

!7 . 9 .* 9

,

JOHN SHAND

% * %! 7 %.

!.9**A*

)

!7

ANCIENT AND MEDIE VAL PHILOSOPHY: INTRODUCTION

(18-.

8

**

$8.$*$

#

4

JOHN SHAND

'9*F0

/


!'&)

!2/@@3/,.%60%

.10%.&.*)*. !%1*A1* *

3

JOHN SHAND

1 $A!71

BC$A$

9!

! B CA1$8A$ABC-$$ 9$ $$

ABC$9$$$8A$ $9A$!'244@5/6

)

@


$ %7%*B*C

$

!

-$*$$A71$*!'!&

&

=

G BC $

+

JOHN SHAND

$1A!!$!2$

6$2$

#6

9'1

A*

# *

A7

B@/3;6

8 )

'2!62!'6)

7* ) A$&*)

*

BC )

7$$$)

A7AG#

E

5


$'

$ B)

7 C $B)

7C $ $ & $!$*"1 )

*&*A &

$#$*)

7*$9

A9*

E

-*

>

1

Plato

Hugh H. Benson

7

$

'*

!9E9-

!345-.%1!! 7 1

A!! #

!# #23+;/;;-.%6$!/;;-.%!/>5-.% !

!

%$! /35-.%

! #

;

PLATO: REPUBLIC

23/3,3-.%6*A!!

A quick outline of the Republic

7AE-9 7*#

9 # $

B8*FC''

8*$

* 8$

#%

'B FC& #"E'B*

FC..'BFC99-9#A!

-

4,

HUGH H. BENSON

979 9 7

4

PLATO: REPUBLIC

44

HUGH H. BENSON

-K999#0#

4/

PLATO: REPUBLIC

C6

43

HUGH H. BENSON

"9$2//>//;6

HI !

4@

PLATO: REPUBLIC

B

4+

HUGH H. BENSON

45

PLATO: REPUBLIC

) 26$26

4>

HUGH H. BENSON

-9L

4;

PLATO: REPUBLIC

/,

HUGH H. BENSON

46 A

/

PLATO: REPUBLIC

723/43//3//5;6

H,I #

/4

HUGH H. BENSON

=

=

//

PLATO: REPUBLIC

&$

"23/;33,3/;33,6

H+I &$

*'233,33336

H5I .' 2 6

H>I .'

=&

*

/3

HUGH H. BENSON

*

/@

PLATO: REPUBLIC

)$

9

/+

HUGH H. BENSON

Justice as welcomed for its own sake

-9K#* *

/5

PLATO: REPUBLIC

8 #*%$

$$*1*#,@>/6

HI 23>,6H4I .

23>,3>6H/I *

6

/>

HUGH H. BENSON

H3I *6

H@I *6

H+I I )*23>46H;I )*23>46H,I #* 46HI #/6

"!#2@>/@>>6

HI 2@>/6H4I 2@>/6H/I

2@>/6H3I $

$2@>/@>@6H@I *

$*2@>+6

H+I * $2@>+6

H5I )*$2@>+6

H>I #56

) ' '$-9K*

/;

PLATO: REPUBLIC

0

3,

HUGH H. BENSON

-K#=*A#A7 A#

235@35+6

3

PLATO: REPUBLIC

8

34

HUGH H. BENSON

2@,;@6'88-%'*. 8#*B

*C2@,+;6.* 2 6 2626268 # 2@3@56 9

*2@5>60#**

3/

PLATO: REPUBLIC

:8*

"0#%E?--

33

HUGH H. BENSON

-.PE(#;;3%&E?)$G .M:;55B M C'%(

@5.M;>3B 71:C#%(

/[email protected]:;3"0#%)$)$G .9:;+4'#%&)"0P= .0.P!(;+3%&0*'%"

:(0;5B!8 7FC#K262;56@4+8A08264,,,%*"0A26.

.

G 8A;5>B=-KC'+,%

4/;8A;;,B=-KK99C9!#%26

>@@.

.

G 8:-;/5B!: 7C/>+;/AM.-;5/%"0P= AA:!26;;4%&0.(.0269

9E19;;@%&)$)$G =.1;;+%)!.

.

G =.;[email protected]%+45/=0;>3 EM G =026;;4"!%.

.

G*

=0;;4B(M 7C9"!

%0=26//5.

.

G :M(;5B9 7GFC#K262;56@5+@:(M;>5-!%)$)$G :E0;@"#%&0)$. E

! ;;;. # '* % EM

G E0;4@0#%4": E;;@%E?0 0;>@!%&99E1 ;>5"'#/*'!%&

)!(0 =0;+/"0.1*"

#%E

?1P00.(.;>>%2!*"'!#%&0 EM

G 0(1;;>',%&0E?)$G #(;5B!8 7C#K262;56/@@#AL;>,B8A 7C%3/53

3,/#A4,,,4*%5'5)$-

3@

PLATO: REPUBLIC

# 26;+B C9%*"

)!%1

*P1.26@5@>33 EM G

KA;+@B(0 C9/$%'0-

26;E?1

KA26;5%*'

#*!E?(

KA26;5%*'

#*5%5%#'!E?(

KA;5BM1C#K262;56++;@

KA;;5 % 9E?.G

E ;5+%2$!99E1E ;5;'%&099E1E ;>3B.A 7C4#

#%/;/344E ;>+B07.C'+,%443+

Further reading

A$%0M-262)$)$G ;,46%%&A:!A26299E1;;46.( . 0 M : . % 6 29 9E1 ;;56 # 26 %1

1."

)!#%2 EM G ;+6 * 7!2;>6. 2;+360 2;>>6 2;5;6 =2;+@6 2;>36 **36BC - KK99 K 2;+@6 8 2;;,6 E

2;;;6$

2

Aristotle

Paula Gottlieb

! " #$%&"'"("'#$")*%!

"+,

-"#.%/0,

0 -. %$""

%##0 ,

" +0"%1,

00"%"-.,

" 2%,"03-.4*"" ,%&"0

,","

%

" "

0 $

5

ARISTOTLE: NICOMACHEAN ETHICS

""""0", 0 "

0"3&677789

:;;64% 0

0%"$0",,,"%

PAULA GOT TLIEB

$ " " 0%9 , " 0 0 + + , " " " B0: "%

7


!00%$""3:;;64%

""" 3 "4%1 "%"%

D;

PAULA GOT TLIEB

Ethical virtue and the doctrine of the mean

0%F0

,0%0")& 0 " %$0

0"0%0*"%

D6


")%)""

,"(

+""

"0%*"00%&"0

"03%%67750C677:4"*"%

D:

PAULA GOT TLIEB

!"*, *34 ",0*-/"(.-"!&.- .""3%%:;;4%

Particular ethical virtues

9"-"."00" 0 " " %&"0-.00 " "% B)+0

,0""

"%)"$-.0"*

0"

"0%9)000%"0",0 " % 0 0"

0

" " 0 " " 0"%"$"0*

0 *0, % 9 ) $ " " " 0 " +, %& " 0 &0"*%+3"4*%$%9))E$"0""

%9)

D


$"""003/0:;;62 %:4%"*"00%

+

0 % "0"*%B

0%""%9,"0%'"*"%$"' " "* " " 0% "0"0%

000"+"0%

Voluntary action

00"0 " 0 34

" 0 0 % $00"%9)0 > " " "3,6758 674%=0$""

D

PAULA GOT TLIEB

" + $"

"%""""$""0I%C%$")367DJ52@74"$,

",)+%

,",),0%&00",%",",,"%"0,

,0%

6


"""%="%"0""2-C34".3

:

PAULA GOT TLIEB

,$")0"

0 +"%0 3"%


"*""""""

"%9""0"0

+""%10"+0"3

67;2:;@;86775265@:64%"-" ."$

%

PAULA GOT TLIEB

Happiness revisited

"

"0%0"," 0 "3400)"03400)"3400)"0%>0"0"""

,?

,

D


="%1""0$,""">,"0"03A

PAULA GOT TLIEB

)%

5


PAULA GOT TLIEB

1I%!%6776%-

7

3

Lucretius

.1

Harry Lesser

Introduction: Lucretiuss method

C 0"0"77DD !%A,""8

0 0 0 %&"""0,"

""% """,0""%&,"7-=B"."-=B"G0.")

,05;;;%0""!36@:56 !400","!"""-#/.""%00C0

! " %& " "

, "8,)"

5;

HARRY LESSER

8

,:-.3%5;4%&""""%0

A"0"%&0"!%!$",0"C$0*"+"0"""""0

%

""C$""!%10 C %

56

LUCRETIUS: ON THE NATURE OF THE UNIVERSE

"

,63;@6;64%",0%

5:

HARRY LESSER

"00

%9)"" %

5


"

, 6@ " %#"

,00

) C$ " , %

, D

,:0%

,"

%

5

HARRY LESSER

08"% " ) 36 7D""%4%9 % %!0,8*%"0*",%""366;;""%4%="""0"0""%""")

03%%4)")%!0)0)""366""%4%"0%90)%

5D


,%(C"00%

5

HARRY LESSER

""2")

" 0 0 "%

,"""%""%""""" "3") +

400)00 , % )")""3""%4%"""3;""%4%"%9>"%"""," " ""35;;""%4""*20"%&0C""%

55


"""

"#"(*"0@" " 0@"" " C%C$""*

%00""%&0"""3""%4%& """*%)

,%+0""""%"0"",+)%)""0""+"*@@,%H*8

8,%""""00""">",3%%4)""00"" " %

""%3=

,D::@5;D4%36@4)%"

+""0"""8",%0+0)"""%""0"3:@48 0 " " - , 0.3:7:@:48+

,"03D@48"""+0* " 3:@4%)"")35::@::8 7:@6;4% 9 " " 0 "

5

HARRY LESSER

""+""

""3564%)0""*

%1%

57


%1"0"0 % "3""4%0" 0 ""0""""000%"0""35""%4""%00

">"%

;

HARRY LESSER

0)00"20"")""0"+03D6D@;4% "" "0"0,"003D67D@:8:65@:4%

Comment

6


,C$"0"%&+"""

"""""3" 04 % " "" C "

2)"""

"""%)"36;;:""%4("%"+"08 " ) , "+%"*+"%C@@")"0** ) " " %%&0C",0"!

""0"0%9""")"%

:

HARRY LESSER

"!%&

")*%

"C,0%,)

"0"%""""%"0,""*%0"

0%9""0%

" 0 %0"%"0C,*"

"0"

0

,""0%&"8

,35;""%4""0, %&

"""0)""

"B%""0%C%

1%=

,6"0"0%C$),

@@00,0 0 *% 0" %,0 , 020"0"C0"%1,""%00""%"C$0

","0 ,0)


" "00%#%0"C"0"%

The nature of consciousness

/0"C$

,"!"0""36:""%86@;8D6@D86@:4%0,","3@7D4%0"2" " % $ 0 0%9"""

"0)"80""36@74%BC,&-.,""

""-".2"0)%""

"0%=*0">"

%/""8"$"%C"")*0"%"0"@0"

HARRY LESSER

=0C$"*"%

,37@64%

D


0"%""0"%

%!0 " 0 """80"

%= " 8$ 0%-"0"

".365"C3%44%

Discussion of Lucretiuss arguments for the mortality of consciousness

C"%&"2

,6*))8

,366@54""%

HARRY LESSER

%"C+0,"00)"3

,

4%/C-.+

0"")"""E

5


"% )"%4(C$,"",,8"""%#20"3#0

0,"4,0,%0,

%

HARRY LESSER

000""0"720"

"",""%1C$%0

",*%""2"""% )"3DD@574%")80"03:@4%

7


C!"%

4

Sextus Empiricus

R. J. Hankinson

!

"#

## $ % %

#& '%

" !

" && # $# (

#

Sextus the empiricist

)&

&

**+$

&' *,(#-. /0(-++12'&"&&(#&0##

"2 & (#

+

SEX TUS EMPIRICUS: OUTLINES OF PYRRHONISM

0, )2,& 3 3 &!# 4550#2 6#7 ###

#

&

&&"# %

&"#& #&'"&8#3

3

&"02#& #

) &" & !

" '& "

#9

" #/0+:;13

:

R. J . HANKINSON

The origins of Pyrrhonism

33 #8

6 ?/

#/

# 70+=2/ *9 6- 7(#&

&& "

# 0(-1;312

# #&&"

#

/ " & #

)5")&"

# # &"#/&& %@1

##

&= #/, &

#8 / # +=&0 *2##&&02

A* &

/8 80

8:=:3:B2 &

#& #&

8& & #&*# *0:+3+:*2#082 " &'#0#&&

" #2& &

;


% # +

8/ -++8 8"&/*#

6#7)

+:

8'#86#&7##/+;% 6C7 #&)

C 7 &2$ 8 0

# 8 55#2&

02 +

:2 )

&& 6&&#

&

70++1;2

+

R. J . HANKINSON

The Modes of Agrippa

% )C

C0++1

++


#

C FC>G&

" # # #

& & CF

+:

R. J . HANKINSON

20&2&

& )A C C'&9"&"&&

6 #& &&&70++B;32### A

67#"#

#@&8&

##

0

6( 7&2,

&

"&

& 0 2@

#67 F #G &

+;


6%"&& #%&7 J #67& F# G@&

0+++2

)# @6

#70++B=2 # &' 8 6# 7 0 +::1' 6( 7&2 /'

#:0 #9# # 3 83 /@+::+3>2 0

2#&

672@8"602#0# 270+::12&/6 & 70 6) 72C80*2"#@

676

70+::=3B' =+>3=>2'6#7

"# 0 2#'67 & #5) "

&8 &8#"

+


#&/70+:+=29#/#0#

/2 0+:+=3+2 #/' #&&

"

&&0

672

The criterion

6#7 0+:

+1

R. J . HANKINSON

0:+;2#& -# #"6)# /702

' & :B### 0+:+32@6#7#9#

#

#'67#67'67 6## #70:+>2&

&:

) 6#70:+1@6& &&72

"#@# I, ##

@

0#2'0L *&L# 2'&0 29#0:+B2) #@

) & #

%

&

#9#'

& & &

"& ##&A

#

#&

&&&' ## ) # '&& & 9# & # 0:+3:2

,C 8#&

06)C 8#728#C

+=


#*

&

'&:+B

) #0#2' ### #8 #3

# 3 0#&2#)

#" 0;1B+2:::3

+B

R. J . HANKINSON

9& # 0 :=

+


# # 0#&&

" &2& #& A #@## & #

#

& # 0:++=3:2)9 0#### @6!7&2' &02# #&&

&"&02 ;;& ) #& #@6& ##

# 70:+::2:+;

++

R. J . HANKINSON

#6#7@6 #&7 0 :+BB2) # #

6# 70

2

#)&" &"# #

God and causes

) ":' "0

@::2";&!6 70;:2)# #,020,I2 #9#0;;2 56

#&

70;:2)02'#

&

06) 72

/& J#& # #!'

0 2;1## &&',& !#&I

A&

&&&&&& &&&

# # ' &' &&&"F&G '!&"# &

&&# 0;+3++2

+++


) # # & #

)#";=0;+;3;2 & ###

&& 0;+;3+3=2)#

"#&

'!

"&

Physics

)#0

@;;3+1=2

++:

R. J . HANKINSON

&

# , #

# #@/)&8, 3#0;;2'02&$ &

&&&

# 9';

++;


6#7&++# & A #

#@

#

# & '&"& &FG#

F*G

F(G# 0;+=>2

C # 0 &2#

#

0;+=12) " ##0 2A # 6 # ##70;+=' +

++


Notes

+ ,

!0)+& ,*#@*#/

8QEQ+

++=


Q+B6/ (7 $ QCAEC 02+1+3B+J @J /

Q +B: 6) /7 *$ ,+3:

Q +B; 68 " *7 & , & C A02+"*8@ * /

CA+B6*-,I7 $ QCAEC 02:3>;J @J /0+B;2

CA02+B;&,&"*8@ * /

K!+;;,/-*-*#

C8@,/0R2

K!+;>,/-*-*#

C8@,/0R=3B2

K!+;1,/0-*-*#

C8@,/0R3++2

K!+3:

++B

R. J . HANKINSON

8/#/#A

C+68H& N@C7

*

8)#%%02::>3>*#@*#/

,"KQ+>&,-@K#,"KQ+=6) 71=3;:,"KQ:;6#7&,%&02>3B2 )C 0+2 9 C 8# 0+B2

"# '80+B12J"#

+B2A

0+B2' 9 &0+B:2A0+=2' ,"0+=2

++

5

Plotinus

&

Stephen R. L. Clark

Introduction: text and context

& /0:

+:

STEPHEN R. L . CLARK

' ##

&&&

& #0

,E&5+1

+:+

PLOTINUS: THE ENNEADS

& K/ &, ! !% & & #,& # #

6

F K&&G& #70+@8#+113BB@+;+2," 9 K , &

#& #&" /86%#70+;+@8#+113BB@ + ;2$ # " 0&2 & #

& " % &

#

# / # &

/ & & "&/ & 0

&

9/F+3:+G67 F::3G& F

+::


On beauty

& #&"/%

&"&

&" #/

#

&,0R%H;3>2#0RH%+3;2-

#) /@6 &"#

##" #70B+: @8#+113BB@+:2&/ 6#&"7&C&

/"&&&&"4/&&"#&&

0%1F+G2&%

#&"&&& "0#)$#0HBF;+G20%%%>F>G260%BF>+G22

%#//#

& ,&

/, &/

## A#/&& #@A# ) # # & &" A $ J

#@&J

!#&/

670

8 8 &&6 7676#7/"/" 9"&&6&" ###70%1F+G25/"&@

+:;


,&&)#

J

#J "

8&"

JJ &&

,&&&

)# J &C &)I

6,, 7@0++:@>2

/#0#&@#

# 0H F>G>'

*"+122J /# &

& && " I18&## # I&

# #0# 'H%=F;BG::2) &67

#

&

8

8

#

& % / #5 0 #2 #

6&

#" " # &70%1F+G: 2)

# 68#&#70%1F+G::1 28 ### " / " @ 6 / " M &M&"" &" 70HBF;+G+; 2

+:+B ;26J 70%1F+G1:+26A##

#7 0HB F;+G

+:>


&)

# ##

))

,A/#5/0J

%@&&2#67% 02"# A0%2#& ##!0 J2#"&

#0/@"$1>2

A & & # F &

#G' &' # # # & 8 " & " 0%1F+G1:1 2

%

6#7@J

6#7 #%##%J

J"&!6&7# 0%1F+G=1 2#& J#0%1F+GB+B '

HF>G+:+ 2B#

0%1F+GB 2$# &

6

&

# & #7 0%1F+G=+1 2

8 & 8 & & "# & 0%1F+G=;< 2

8#

0%1F+GB+= 2#0 2)!&

"6#& "#7

&6 A

#!)&70%1F+G

+:1


8 # &' & /& %

Ontology and therapy

/ / / &) ### 9#)#" 33&%#

#

0%HFBG>2 9 #0 &

&"&

&@H;F:; 2#### &/"&" & && ,&&&

&I,&&

## &&"&

I,#

#I,&& &I)

#02# 0

2&) ##5 &8 && ##

) # & /

#67&

#

&/0

C:+246& 70# 6 #72& 7% &

0 6 72##6#70&//!J2%

+:=


@ ) # ##@

&

6 & # 70%1F+G;B 28 0& #I2"#&

""67 H# & ##$"#

# '

#6 7

U#9# /" # #)####"

/ &/#&"# " #

5

%& "#&"# &"&&& &

#8 %#%

?"&'

# "&"" 0H%=F;BG;>2

* &/ " " #0 &

H+F+G28A,J!@&

## ,%## A#), & & %# "& # )

# $ & " ##) #&%&&

"

+:B


8 ## &@0%%+B2 ##

#C&

6 #7 0%B F>+G+> :> 2 @ & "%J*# %' & ##

)# && & &"# 0%%%:F

+:


9&)&&&&

&%8#&@

/F& ##G9" 9%## ##&A#6&"7&" &'&&&& 8 & # & & &

#9 &"&!

08#EC"+1@:=2

% 6 & &7 &

&$&&/ 6 & ###&70%HBF1GF:;G= 2

)6&77 %&&&&&&'#&&

)#'

&&"67 %6&

3 FG&9 3

+;


&70HBF;+G++; 2

0%1F+G::=267 &"

)# # #&"

#&"## ' "&

#&

0H%=F;BG++:< 2

68 8"## "# #70%%%:F;+ 2++

)#'

+:)

%%;F>:G2% #&"6# #70%%;F>:G=+:2#&&"# 68#

& ) & & ##70H%=F;BG+::; '

%%%;F

+;+


0

%%:F+

+;:


&

&&&

"

"9# # J UJ& UC&""&,& & U 0Q+B@+:BB 2

)"9# # # &&&&,#&& ##$@

%

&&

&& " % FG

#

"# &

#& 0$+>1@++:+2

$&6% N#& 70H+F+G$&

# # #8&

#

&

)

3&&

"#

#A)

J

# #@

&

55 & &&"# #6 7# #

8##/

%#

-##

#

#& N

"#&@"& ##& &

8

##&& 0HBF;+GB 2+1

+;;


-# #

#&"# #

## @&"

70%1F+G; '

/"$1>B;2

The ethical dimension

)& /670J+126/&

&"70"+11@:+=2+=67

H

0%:F+G< 2&

/ 5K ##&

$ &" 9 & # " & & )&" 90%%%:F

+;= @8#+113BB@+

+;>


802/##6&

"# "# 70%%%:F

+;1


#7C " &/"

0%%%1F:1G11> 2 &" #0

2 )

J &&)

A),&&&& I$#

'

&&

D##

-##"#&"&

#& & 0%1F+GB:: 2

)6&

#7##8& #

# 8#D

Notes

+ /0:;:3-;1*2&/ # *7 & $ 1&& &" # #0

*":2

: )

&&-## 80/+ @8#+113BB@+>; ' 2

; 67# ##"&

C,

/

' &"&&&J&

#/

%0+B+ # "H%/&& &@ 6) #" # 70/::1 @8#+113BB@+=2

> )## # "CN 6# &70CN++@29#55#

CN#0%1F+G2

1 #0

&2 "

+;=


# % & / 6& 7 #"##&

## &"

= 2& ,0

2+

+;B


Bibliography

8/:;&$/,3&&4-@("&

8#8,02+113BB0&-*--@,

8#8, +1= 6/7 &*$ 9

+>3:1B*#@*#/

8#8,EK8C"+1*(9-@(-#E)

8"CQ02+B;:;-3+*#@*#/*#N::"/).8 J,@

//("Q4+>.0*4&D"@-/( Q +B1 6/ ) %#7 " )

Q/C"02>>31

+;


$)+:.-@("&$+>1.$

8AC02-@K#EN#/

Further reading

A &&8,8# - * - 0-@ , +113BB2 CNQ(0,&@/#++'# +>1A2

&

8J&0+1G%HBF1GH%FGH+F+GH:F++G%:F+G%;F:G%H;F:=G%%%BF;G2(JC)0+;2# #-QA/A6 70##2'%1#

%H=),%%%+

%H:,H)0(#%HB ,-J / # 8# 0+1=2 *# 0::2 ("0+>2!0+

6

Augustine

Christopher Kirwan

Introducing the man and the work

! "# $ $

%

$" $ $&

'

%&

( $( ' ')$*+,-./0'$'$ " " $$$

' $

AUGUSTINE: CIT Y OF GOD

/0$$(10$

/ 23 23$+4 51 %

$&$ 6 6 " 1 7$$/

%

23 &$ !/$-,8

"$1 $$9$/01 $7:;4./0" 0

$ %::/0& /

*

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

/ 2/3 $$78 $$

00$

$

()=7$ 10$ 0 $$

A (A

# /0%;:$+*&1

A5$ $'$$$' /$ 5 .:+/0$

/ 5 > /$ ,

, %

-' &

( /@8$# /,$

'7', $

:


/ $ %?**;&$ /,%1:):&$%

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

=%A::%,4E;

+


E&$,D$ //D/-0D/D /D%D$ G G&$ 'D %H( $ &,>%/@$&

/B'1C>$

>'

).#%9$&0$293/$9/$D//$6,69$

$5"% /B'1C> ')&"$"B%*&2

3$$

Augustine as a philosopher

2,3

+$

2IJ$ IJ73%:4&- %?*&$ % ?& .

58%D$4*?&'

%$ &-

*/0

",.$IC.9J$ 0

/$-A

"$)2

I J3%;:$

"$1#@% & #@-,"$'$23

# %.%;;+):

4

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

8 23/$

- )%&%&

%&$#$$ %*:&$##

5$

# . $

%?&%;$**&$

%&$$

$ )$$ $ $ % '2$3$E?&$#%$K%;;;&&$% $K%*&&$'%,$

-&> $ > $ $8 !

/ C " #

The sources, title, and structure of City of God

$$. ,8.' $ 2 IJ3 D ) @$ #$ 4

E


%$D$ *:/0$&$,%7 'D$&$,8 ,%*:*G:

?

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

(

;


&$ %*E$##:?+0*):$6 :+)4

+

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

%2 3& ! %2 3& 2!3%%&4;E$$**E&$

+


%

23$

$>%;;?):?&&$. $( 7% -$*&

$"$DA

% ;*& = "8 %> *E):

+*

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

#$ %! 4*+?$ ?+*?& "$ 2'IJ3%;+&' - > %;??) / & B%*&

Political authority: City 19

$$$ ,8273%1:)&."23

23 D$' $$$%D23&

%,$/:)**7;;4)/&$%;

+:


$;&2!$ A3%&

9'% &$23

$ 9%:E+7:)4&5$ ##%! :+&

Creation and time: City 12

#$ 2 #3 %***G*&%',8 $

*:G*&

+

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

$#% *

++


Evil and the will in Augustines doctrine of the Fall of Man: City 1214

7# .$$ 23

23$ "23",81E)(8&$)$2 $

$ 3$2

IJ IJ$

3 %?;*&23

% & %K;??&'

$ %&

D2

IJ3%;:$C$ ./ 7 2

3%7):&

+4

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

%&A)0$ $ B % *& .B$'$ A*8)23$ $

%*4&

$ $23%*E& !7

%*****&

## - %;;+)*4

+E


Free will: City 5.9 and 5.10

"' %&

%&$ 78

'$% &$%&5$

$%&% &

%&/8%&$%&'/$$

$2

3%+;*&2

3$% &

/

$$ C'$ 7) 2 3$ 2

73%+;*##:*&$2

3%+;:&" /$23%+;*&%

+?

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

%23$ +;& $ 2

7$ 3%+&"$ $

+$

%&6

%

$ 8 +& +#

C8

%23$+&)

"IJ

$

$$ $

!I J

%+&

"$$2 $3$

!)$782

$ 3%#&

C"%&

'%23&)' ''''' 5 $ 2

3$'$

+;


$$3$

4

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

>$ $ $, %-&9./0'

-$ '

%23&- 8 $ $$ -

$$

- 8 " 2L

83$-N'

$

#)

$$

$$$ $2>$'"$ 93%&0. $

%,:;E:$:$$+**&$823$2"3$

%-K;?;)/&

B8)

B$2323$ (*$2$- $- .$' 32

"$I

J3%2$3B;4

4


8

%$ ( '$& % 23$

23$$ $ $

D

23&

5$,$ %*&

The highest good: City 19

" % A3##25

I $ /JA3 " ; /

5

% &$$2

IJ

3%;$$' ;?

4*

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

, $)

$IJ

$ $'IJ$

%*$*G:$**G**$(:+&

5)

$ %

'A

4:


$ &AC $

$)0% ''

$ $ &AC

$ $ $%$$

$ &A %;:&

2 3 )%& %*& 23%:& @8# $ N$$

;:@%:&

!

%(4&,8$@8$-%&%,$#-):&$7283%7;4)+***;423 ':23@8%:&%#$! E+*&C8B:**%C8B;?E)+4+*&"$$8%*&%K;;&$"$)%&

/$ $$ %

= &%&

((%:EE$:4*+$*&

71$ %/+):+

4

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

Notes

253

"23$0 D

4+


9/ $$D-$1=B%&%$B/)/N,$;E$;+:

44

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

9 %?/0&,D$/-0D*$.**6,69+$.

## ##%:??$:;-%/$@")N@$;E&$-.!RD55%6O). '>$;4&$%"$"6)5$;;:&

( (#%:?E

4E


.$,1D;;+!4 5/ )/ N,

/$>;+;$!)5N,I/./0J

/ ;E # 3,- # ! $>%&B LH)%.)$;)5N , I/'*/0J

B $51*2-)C113$

4 & 7$ 1BR7 D %&$?D%:9$;;&D)7(

5 $ - R - %& *: 9. $ : C)/,

5$B;?+2C-3$2(22$+EE

4?

CHRISTOPHER KIR WAN

$;

4;

7

Anselm

John Marenbon

"$8'C7$ /*%&::

$ C $'$$ !.8

O

C "

$ $7$>$

Anselms times and the background to the Proslogion

$ ::;$ . 4$ $/7 ,$

E

JOHN MARENBON

,

9$$

$$$%

&' 8 $/$ #%$$

&

) $ %&

-D$

8$. !#'%9 ;??&$$

$@5$

'$,8 $D /$ .%+*& $ $ '$

D

'' C

$ 9 -$ " %-& ,$ #'.'

.$% ?E$ -%;;)4+&*&$ $)A27'3#$

$ #A %*)? $&$ ' " $$$ $ $

$

B8$$D$

$. $(/$

E

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

.8 $

! "

$/. $$9$8$D$'

.0%5;;4)

E*

JOHN MARENBON

!A

/()

-

E:

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

A9$

!7 $ $ $

$' /

E

JOHN MARENBON

#%

$ $$ !

$

!$

&$$7

$ 7$(

23$$

!/ * :$ $ $ C" 7

$

E+

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

# $9

,%,)++)&$$

)29

$7

3IJ 9

2

3$2$

3 5$

$$

2

39

8'$ )

9$ %&$"'

$

8 )

%& 7

I,J%*& "23$%& I,J

%:& 9

2

I,J

3%& -

I*$:J

9

8%+& -

I,J

%4& $

') %E& "

$ $$

I4J

%?& - I$+$EJ

%;&

I?J

E4

JOHN MARENBON

%& "

I6+$

J

%& 7 I$J

-%*&$%4&%E&$%*&$$$23$

$ $ $ %*& $'8.%'89-&"(%/::&$

23$23'$" )

$ $IJ

$ %/::$+*)+

EE

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

%4 &-

O$ ! ' )

%&$$

'

K8 2 3

2 3 %; +;?.G.4*4&$ ! 8$ !

%C;;+):

E?

JOHN MARENBON

9

8$

%!

8&9

%+&$

%

9

'2

3"

%E&9

8

)

. A/$

E;

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

$ # ;4 , ;E&

$$!$

'$ '$

$ " 7$ %+&

$)

$ %1 "$ :)?

?

JOHN MARENBON

9

$

$7$

A"#9

$$

%:);

?

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

'$($' ) 7 $' $#-$ D ($

.$

'$

($ ! ' $ ' $$ $ 78' ) '$

#"/E$

%4& 7%E& 7

,786,%4& $ %E&$7$ $

%E&%+)

?*

JOHN MARENBON

?:

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

%?& "!7%;& "!7I

J

$$#'!%?&%;& $%?)*E

?

JOHN MARENBON

! 78$

'!! 7

.%**&

"! 7$

!! $ 7!

?+

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

D23C7

2'3 $ $

'/# $$.80 78$ . $8" $$%> *:):4

.8

8.$ $'

785$

?;

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

$

7$ 7 $ % 7 5 %;;+&&$$

$7$ $

/*:$

$'

Anselms second thoughts

"

$$$$

AC$

#(>$ !

$B$-

(D ($

;

JOHN MARENBON

.

.

. $.%$'&$ ."

7"$$

" $ /$

239

$ )

97

$

$$'7$

%)*

;

ANSELM: PR OSLOGION

,%*+&$ $ !$

;*

JOHN MARENBON

5$=;;4D).5$=>;E* !! >

$>6)>

N,5$ = R />7 %& ;4? (0$ 4 ! 9 .D)>

K$7;;? -,,=9#*>-* #D).

K$7*2-8,

), 1$"">N3$(( $=5%&$4;

Documents

Acumen Publishing Central Works of Philosophy Vol. 1, Ancient and Medieval (2005)