27
' , , ...... r J '- r J GlJii¥tf:l@ '- r =Ftl J GlJi!t!tt '- r J , ' !!r-GlJ¥iftf:l m! i} it '- it M IfiJ I & '3il Y-11¥:1 •• •• •• ••• •• Y •••• ••••• ·• 'fI ¥ ' if !it XnlI ••••. 'j , w- .. (lI) ! ! I

a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

Dqr~ifliff~JmfGlJ~~~fM~mlOO8~fi yent~GlJgHJwfifJl~liitfiifjbk lJli)fjGlJmm11JfifC$f-~ r Mffitt~lI4 J -r ~~J GlJiiyentfl -r ~GlJ

=Ftl J GlJittt -r fiyen1~nli J GlJf~~ JIJGlJ~~~~i~~~l r-GlJyeniftfl ~ ~~yenmYi~~~~~~~fiW-~f~gJmyenGlJyenIU

~~UMIit~M~~Umit~~~fim~ ~mmmit~GlJ~~~~~D~~~Jlit~Jm-G

f~~~m i~Jsect~~ni~~it -it~M~IfiJ ~Iamp3il Y-11yen1 ~UIpoundjn~~ ~Q~~~~~~~U~~~it~~~~W~~~~

~it-~~~~~bullbull~MMIit~~~m~~~~~~ m~w~lyenIo~~~i~m~IDmI~~MM~~~~

~it~GlJD~~~aIU~mryenbullbull~it~~ m~mM~~MY~~~ittt~~~~itmM

~~~~il~fi-~~~~amplyenImGlJ~~~~ilm Msect~oU~il~Mfibullbull~bullbullbull~GlJ$~~ ili~M~W~mIJGlJ~YM~it~fiJmm~yenbullbullY GlJ~~~~MGlJM~yenm~gWM~~yen~~m~

il~U~~~~~v~~m~itMM~W~ ~

~WlfiJ ~bullbullbullbullwww~bullbullbullbullbull middotbull middotWlWit1nt~ fI yen if it~XnlI bullbullbullbull j It+rl$lt~ w-~~

(lI)

I

0 (I8 )

~~~~~bullbullfflffibullbull~~~~e~bullbullbullffi~~M~~~bull bull fflff1l71tP)J~~~rmr~~mm Rffl~liI~~~~Ifp~~~z)i~ mtJ[J~~0

bullbull~Ifp~)ifiWB~A=-~~fiOOampffiUm~m~IfpW Jfl~~mJb il)i~f]j~~ -3FfJtfi~tt$llf]jfljtzl Biamp~tJ[JPAIEtJi ~m~o

~bullbull~$~bullbullfflbullbull~~~bullbullA~~R~~fi~1I71tffM ~bullbullbullffibullbull~M~~flfl~~ff1l71tfi~bullbullrmttm~~~z m~~~~~fflbullbullff~1I71too~~~)irr~Ifp~Ifp~~~~mJb z~bullbull~MWmfi~ttM~flM~~zl~~~bullbull~Ifpz)ifi~

R~atplusmnttJitJjfl~lJffl ~a~IfFHj~~~mUfUM ~tlDMjf~t1HjzljifilJ

~Mm~z~~mmiddot~~bullbull~fi$ffimW~m~~mofla~~ ~~~~t1~~mbullbullfflz~~tJ[JPA7Hfi WHj~1I71tf~rmffIM PAIJ~~z m~)iWjf~~~~bullbull~zffirm~~ljM bullbullbull~~A~mmJibullbullbull~~ bullbull~Ifp R~1iIfjgtHm~~~ 0

x~~~~~~-~oo~~~=~~bullbullffl~~~~~~t1~~ mz~~~~~~~)ifi~~m~~~bullbullfflff1l71t~~~I~m~~

M~t1~~~~ffl~~W~~m~~~~~~m~bullbull~m~H bullbull ~m~1iI~~~mm~~ampmflljM~~zlmli~Mjf~~~t1~~bullbull~ Z~bullbullJlU ~~t1Hzlj1J Rtbullbull~rna 0

921 ~t1~$$~~t$~1iI~f~~~~t ~m 921 ~Jl~1yenJ

~bullbullffl~~~~~bullbull~~$~m~~m~~~~Ifi~~$~t1~~~ ~zif)ifi~jff ~~fpmElbullbullfJT~tJl~~efjl~~mIfi~rtJt~bullbull~ 3~~~~~~~~~~ffl~~bullbull1yenJ~~

-middot2mlli~~Bm~~M bullbull~~bullbull~m~~w ~~~~~~m~bullbull~ili~~~m~~~mRt~~ffl~bullbull~

bull 4500 ~ f~~$~ffl~m~~ 53 ~~Ei$~~ 2800 ~ f~~$~tft~~~

~ 32 WEi~t~~m~~JlU~f~ 300 ~ 0 fi91~4ifj~ii~~ yen~IiEffij~ Ei~tQ Hj~fl~~IyenJ~bullbull~m~~~~~~~Ei~t~~m~mbullbull g~

fi~~~~mili~ili~fibullbull ~~~8~~Hj~bullbull mbullbull~~ ~rJIm fl~)i-jj11171t 0

=~~m~~N~~MA~mUW~m~ ~~fi~W~~Mm~fi~~~~a$~m~~a$~~~~

-2shy

0

(19 )~=-~~~m~ff~~~bull~n ~~~~~~~li~~~~~~~~~Bm~~~~wzm ~~~~ bullbull~~~bullbullbull~~~mz~~wam~~~mabullbull o ~~ff~~~m~g~ffl~~ftbullbull~m~~~a~~~~W~~~~~ jt~bullbull~ 0 yen~a~t~ 1B~~Jur)~~~~ OJY~~w~~msect~Wlffi

bullbull~~~mfltEla~lf 0

~middot~~~ampU~mbullbullRM~W~~~~Mbullbull~n~m~sect~~sect ~IJ~ti~ ~ffl~~W~a~t~~a~trnr) 4-6 Jj~~~wm~~9 ~a5ir) 1-3 ~~

~~W~ffl~bullbullbullbull ~~~~~~8~~m~plusmnbullbull ~~ampB~ ~~~~m~~Bm~~bullbull~~wZa~~~amp~~mHm-Am~ m~bullbullh~~o~9OJ~~wmffl~~M~B~~~~~~~~w ~Jlltftm~7fjV middot 4 fsecttffj reg~m (f9lI~DiI~t~ )~~~ 72-78 ~B~~~wm mbullbullamp~~~79~~bullbullVo~a~gmiddot~$~~~~~63~~~~~~~Wffl

ft~ middot ~~t$~liiIjJWj)~~~3W 10 ~~JjJm~Jutftbullbull~ ~~ bull EI3~~~~z~0

~~~~w~aHMmiddot~~~ffl~~~~w~bullbull~~w~~~m~ ~fMU1ljm~~-V~~~ 0

m~mffbullbull~M~~m~ Rm~wmmzff~~~wmfflz~~fi~~~B~~~wm

m~~~ROJ~~~-~~~~~B~~W~a~$mR~bull bull ~~=~~~wza~~ttmiddot5~Ma~z~~~~7fjplusmn_tt r)amp~~flIfiJj~~~sect 0 6 -=RU~~wit~a middot~t5~w~mmH (~MbullbullmH~~7middot bullbullwbullbull~-g~m~~~lim~Jj~~

8 ~ff~li 9 ~F~mJllIO r)ampmH~it) DfgImB ( ~MDfgI~~f II ~m

I~nI 12) j)amp~mffJi (~M~J~bullbull~~m ~Jfl~~tiamp~m j)amp1J[lji~ )~~~~~itfil 0

a~middot-li~~~middot=bullbull~Abullbull~middot=M~a~~~~ middotmW~A~OJ~Rmm~$~middotaffli~~~~~Abullbull~zMmiddot~ ~JjllI~z~~ffBlRJlnfi~~~ 0

-middot~m~m~ff~_e(I~-)

(-)~M~Jl~4hfJftfJt~tJl~1fA~Jt ~~~~Jj~~~W~ffl~~~~middotm~~bullbullbull~tf~~m

ti~~~~amp~~~7fjJj~~~~~~~flm~~osect~~~~~

~~ ~~~$jtli[ijzJlJ~OJ~1~ ft5~~~~~1t1JD3~it 250gal j)~

~1~~middot~m~~~~n~mB~~M~~JjJm~~JjIfi~~

3shy

(20 )

iWD~jlUmampit~~Sli1lll~Jl~ lilift1treg59tJ3t~~Jbliit~~ ~Uit~~ ~JUjUDi1lll~UtpoundM~ 0 ffitpound 921 ft1t~~ t ~ttJU7ili-li~ ft59trUregm 400gaJ p)tregIglt ~f(Arrfpound~IIIUP)f($ft(jfamprrJh $7it~~~Uf mltl~jJIj ~JjPJTff~~WWi~VijJG~~ftiW t m9~UOJB~tlJMft~ It $JtaIlftrft~i1lllo

~~1pound~~bullbullftItPJT~regItJ3tbullbullft~~OJiliit~ ~m~ffregW~JU7o~~m-OJ~lli~ftmregItJ3t~Itregffiff

~regg~ffili~g~~tw~mftmreg~~~~~~~m

tlD~tfiregjl~ffibullbull11fiff 2765 011 bull ffittItI3t11fiff 5 amp bull ~t1firegftm ~ffibullbullili 9549 011 bull ffilt~W~JU 6 amp lamp1poundUI1~JUftmit~~reg~m ffmyen bull amp~Jfft4tregwHiSfi1JB~JE 0

f(- 1f 1f j-~~i-t-)J~9amp)JHlt~Ji2titj-f(lJoiiJi1t II iE ~ ItJ ii

1466 1341613519 3972 8674 9432 16832 19488

17241 1776 326 3702 14417 5736 11216 10826

1106614809 3392 9720 2824 1068215313 6908

15583 2878 8774 13596 914615823 4678 13824

9549 68452 3665425080 10132 6562 12214 12812

141046300 9038 16294 463327737 35308 51172

20798 247527812 8194 8630 26104 39938 29166

43970531 17100 30248 31176 42282 989966

1343 34496 61076 983 1533 41554 63900 51782

340101535 27538 42002 27018 585941958 36840 27466 370502153 46530

2630 25780 56322 77442 23058 31266 488862845

4525 17328 16898 29836 4688 7620 2485815738 4771 3619451942 50160 3551 20816 2569015330 3582 12926 2210818250 3931 19398 43868 34866 3817 10970 23070 15684

178242765 11628 18752 3194 33550 74990 62416

348003974 21102 35146 7986 18620 142665450

6802 4192 20720 14810

-4

I

gshy

yenflff~1ilfiyen~ttllfiil-l_rlt(~)

o wlJ~~~flY-i ~3f~ ~~bullbull~bullbullbull~~middot~plusmn~~M~3f~~bullbullmwlJ~~bullbull~~~middot~ ~IplusmnM ( 98 3f 8L 3f IL 3f pound9 rfler~flfHHFJ~~~ ) LElJ~l~~wlJ ~~bullbull~rnJ~mf~Jtf~~$ i6iS 0 iiI1W~~ru~~flY-img~WW

~~~W~~~~~yen~iiI1lJW~~plusmn~~m~OO~~m~OO~~ m= m2- m~-~gmmiil1w~~rflW~~yenIZ6~

yenf+1-ltlYf IJ tJ-if~i1t~iff~Jjlt fi~on(-=-)

OZ)

(22)

~~$~bullbull~3ftMmbullbull3 bullbullbull~ampbullbull~~~~~N B~~~~mbullbullm~~~~~mM~~~~~~~~~o

(tm)~~~4h~~itrJisectll~Jt ~xntAt~4h~~itrJ1t~J$ll ~~~~~bullbullbull~~~m~mfibullbullI~~~~~bullbullM~~

~ffM~m~~~~~~gmiddotm~~~~~bullbullti~~~M~~~~~~ffi~ ~~~~~~5tt~f~~Elfm~fj~ JlU~~fflH)~A~il1ri~ 0 1fpound~~

~5t~~~~~$~~m~~~~~~~~~1fpound~~~~~~~~~~ ~lliWI~pound~1fpound~~m~~~m~~w-~~~m~il1ri~ffo =lt~~tfiitllz~ ~~~~~mz~~M~~m~~~~~~m~~amp~~~~~~~~

~~~~mw-~~~T~~~ (A=) ~~-B~~~mz~~~~1fpound~~~m~~~~~~~Abullbull

~-x~-m~ru5t~p~~~~~7~~o

m~ ~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot _sectJt~~~g~t~z~~1JDJ) ~~~~~~Abullbull~~M~M~~~~ff~x~~~~N~ M~m~ bull j~ru~NEHT~tt ~~JlIj~7~~ 0

~~-B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~Ail1ri~-~

~+A-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-m~ruffA~tt~~ffi ru~P~tt~~~7~~o

~~H~~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot mlt~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~A~x~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JDm~M~~~~~m~j~ruffA~tt~~ffiru~N~ttmiddot~~~

7~~o

~~~B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~A~il1ri~-~

~+A-ff~~bullbull~~~~m~-~~sect-m~ru~~~~ ~ffli~tt ~~f)JlUru5t~Pittt ~~~7~~ 0

~~ Hfamp~bullbull5ti13tB~~~~~~~Mz~~ flHt~~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~Ax~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JD~~~ru~ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~~M~~~sectbullbull ~~~~ru~~lIJ~~ffli~ttffi~ ~~ffiJlrjru5t~p~ffi ~~~ 7~~o

~~~~~~mz~~~~~-Am-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-ffl ~ru~bullbullffA~tto

m~~bullbull~~~~~~~~~Mz~~middotm~~~w~bullbull~~~m ~~~~~Abullbull~~M~~~~~~~ru~li~ttyen~~ 15~~13tJlU~~15~m~ 0

~~E~~$mz~~~~~-Am-ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~-~

6shy

shy I

Ii i --L shy i

degY~~MI~~~~~~~~~mm~~~~~B~~~~

~~~~~~~Mm~~m~Hm~~W~~Y~amp~~m~~~q~0~

V~W~~~~~Wm~~8yen~W~~~ti~~~ampmiddot~WBW~~ ~yenm~~~~~ID~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~amp~~~~~~secto~

~Yg~~f~1$ r ~n~~J ~tt~E1JYH~$~fbfbWti~l~ID ~~trDqnM1amp~ ampH~slz0~~ijWfEyen~ nM1amp~~WEEyenm~j ~~W-0~wFr

o ampnnl~JifE yen~~$nMyen~4=~-qIllID~~~~ID lW~Yijg~$~Jilm~~~ yenm~g

~~~_~yen~Y~~yen_Jilmm~~~~B~m~~~~~

o~Jif~yen~~~~~$yenm-~$~~-~~~m$

~W~Byen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~V~~

deglW~ Yyen~$~~~m~~yenm~g~H~_~yen~Y~~yen_JiI

mm~~~~B~m~~~~~IDmiddot~U~~m~~middotM~~

deglW~YByen~m$yenm-~~~m~fu

~~WfuByen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~ oyen~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~yen~M~m~Wyen~Y~~~~E~m~~~~m~~

~~~~Ufu~~bullbullm~WB~~~~~M~~~~~~N lW~~~~$yenm-~yen-~Jilmm~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~

olU~Jif~~~nt~~$nMyenmWti sect~~~~~m~~~yenm~g~H~~yenbullbullY~B~~~~ ~WMm~~~~~ID~~~_~~~~~~JiIbullbull~~~N

oyen~JifByen~~~~$$yenm-~~~

(poundZ)

(24)

f---+------+----j-----t---j----+------r------I

x o

o o o

o x ( o

o x x x

111 tl5 ~

8

(25 )n=-~~~~~mff~~~~~~~

( ~~~i~~1m~~ J

a~~m~I~~ffa~~~h=-~~~ffMampffig~

ffi~I~Wm~~~~m~~~mAmbullbull Dffimff~~~m~~~ ~H~bullbull$~wnm~W~~~Nmm~fi~~~~RMft~m~ ~~~mm~m~0~~Hm~~~~tt~m~M~MMW~5li~I fF 0 n~JJHT~bullbull~fsect$fJ~M~~-= 0

-=- JJlAtJ( 1amp -pound ~~EIlbj i-4--k-tt

JJl1=r$~ plusmn Jl J73 ~ ~ Z ~

921 tf(lUpoundfj1=r~ ~J

1~lttltttI 21iUnllrfjJfTm5EIimt~

IffiH 3llX tHI~Jlmtt H~Ptbsectra~Ii03llt~J1i 5tt~tf(sect~mm~~ It jJjJf)Ut~li

I ~5IUUdl~ g~HI~UIH1mH fiJ ~Ptbm 5E 2$mf~Ff~~ ~AE-N 3~111flUtMz=1-5E~~ 4=1 1IJ ~ ~Jlt~HJII JJrt ~~ bull ~ij~1f IlN ( fI JJrt l tt fl Ii 1Bl$mff~ )

5fljiJEJ01tI~5Inf~tf(sect~B9ltjpli~li Mz1m $1f~mJllJ1[iIl~

921 tf( ~ft~1[iIl~ 1J1J~

1 1[ fT mBHIl1=r 1t JlIJ m5EIi 1[iIlmt~

2 ill lzJili ~ tItiHft ~~ 3 m Jfill JlIJ ii 4mIDl1[iIl~ft

1fl9J~amp~$IIl~ ~fiti~1m~ij~ij~ ~ 0ffi1JlIl~

2fBtllJrn5E1W~ 1mplusmnIiJ$fEl 3fl1J rllJ~J 1m$1amp51sectraiIltm~OO~Ii 41m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ j1~tplusmnlt 5fj~ff1J~m~=1JE 6fj~ 13 iW JilE1[iIl~ftB91[Ji-- r 3llt~llUr~1llG J fJEj ~ij~i~

tf( f3t~1I1[iIlllt iampii IittllUlmllffi

---------shy

lmJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2~tf(~lIitm~~ 3mJlIJ t~~JIl1li 4~~~tf(~jilUlm 5~~fiM~tf(~ 6ilHfj~i$ rfjiJi 3( ~ 7[5fRltf( ~1fplusmntt~~ --------------------_ -

I fIji1[~ tf( 2fIji1[~tf(~ ffij~~~OOmifi~fI 3D~ 1Jj~$~ EI ~JIltlIUl~~ ffij~~~~mIDII

ii4~liff~~JI

R~~a~~ffig$fJ~~M~fim~~mff~bullbull~I~~~$ ~m~~~m~~m~~amp$~~~~~bullbull~M~a~~~~~~m lIt~~~~grrtJ(Iplusmn~j7g$m~ 0

~~b - Jlt tfR-~ BN$~lL~~~~JH~ ~l5lf~~~ Jm~ifBaJfJ ~imW $~m~~~~~~$l5lm~~~~o

lNJH~ $f7J~Af1~~~ N~it~$~a~~~ftpfT~~ f ~1JDjJ~ Jt~~JH~~ 0

-9shy

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 2: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

0 (I8 )

~~~~~bullbullfflffibullbull~~~~e~bullbullbullffi~~M~~~bull bull fflff1l71tP)J~~~rmr~~mm Rffl~liI~~~~Ifp~~~z)i~ mtJ[J~~0

bullbull~Ifp~)ifiWB~A=-~~fiOOampffiUm~m~IfpW Jfl~~mJb il)i~f]j~~ -3FfJtfi~tt$llf]jfljtzl Biamp~tJ[JPAIEtJi ~m~o

~bullbull~$~bullbullfflbullbull~~~bullbullA~~R~~fi~1I71tffM ~bullbullbullffibullbull~M~~flfl~~ff1l71tfi~bullbullrmttm~~~z m~~~~~fflbullbullff~1I71too~~~)irr~Ifp~Ifp~~~~mJb z~bullbull~MWmfi~ttM~flM~~zl~~~bullbull~Ifpz)ifi~

R~atplusmnttJitJjfl~lJffl ~a~IfFHj~~~mUfUM ~tlDMjf~t1HjzljifilJ

~Mm~z~~mmiddot~~bullbull~fi$ffimW~m~~mofla~~ ~~~~t1~~mbullbullfflz~~tJ[JPA7Hfi WHj~1I71tf~rmffIM PAIJ~~z m~)iWjf~~~~bullbull~zffirm~~ljM bullbullbull~~A~mmJibullbullbull~~ bullbull~Ifp R~1iIfjgtHm~~~ 0

x~~~~~~-~oo~~~=~~bullbullffl~~~~~~t1~~ mz~~~~~~~)ifi~~m~~~bullbullfflff1l71t~~~I~m~~

M~t1~~~~ffl~~W~~m~~~~~~m~bullbull~m~H bullbull ~m~1iI~~~mm~~ampmflljM~~zlmli~Mjf~~~t1~~bullbull~ Z~bullbullJlU ~~t1Hzlj1J Rtbullbull~rna 0

921 ~t1~$$~~t$~1iI~f~~~~t ~m 921 ~Jl~1yenJ

~bullbullffl~~~~~bullbull~~$~m~~m~~~~Ifi~~$~t1~~~ ~zif)ifi~jff ~~fpmElbullbullfJT~tJl~~efjl~~mIfi~rtJt~bullbull~ 3~~~~~~~~~~ffl~~bullbull1yenJ~~

-middot2mlli~~Bm~~M bullbull~~bullbull~m~~w ~~~~~~m~bullbull~ili~~~m~~~mRt~~ffl~bullbull~

bull 4500 ~ f~~$~ffl~m~~ 53 ~~Ei$~~ 2800 ~ f~~$~tft~~~

~ 32 WEi~t~~m~~JlU~f~ 300 ~ 0 fi91~4ifj~ii~~ yen~IiEffij~ Ei~tQ Hj~fl~~IyenJ~bullbull~m~~~~~~~Ei~t~~m~mbullbull g~

fi~~~~mili~ili~fibullbull ~~~8~~Hj~bullbull mbullbull~~ ~rJIm fl~)i-jj11171t 0

=~~m~~N~~MA~mUW~m~ ~~fi~W~~Mm~fi~~~~a$~m~~a$~~~~

-2shy

0

(19 )~=-~~~m~ff~~~bull~n ~~~~~~~li~~~~~~~~~Bm~~~~wzm ~~~~ bullbull~~~bullbullbull~~~mz~~wam~~~mabullbull o ~~ff~~~m~g~ffl~~ftbullbull~m~~~a~~~~W~~~~~ jt~bullbull~ 0 yen~a~t~ 1B~~Jur)~~~~ OJY~~w~~msect~Wlffi

bullbull~~~mfltEla~lf 0

~middot~~~ampU~mbullbullRM~W~~~~Mbullbull~n~m~sect~~sect ~IJ~ti~ ~ffl~~W~a~t~~a~trnr) 4-6 Jj~~~wm~~9 ~a5ir) 1-3 ~~

~~W~ffl~bullbullbullbull ~~~~~~8~~m~plusmnbullbull ~~ampB~ ~~~~m~~Bm~~bullbull~~wZa~~~amp~~mHm-Am~ m~bullbullh~~o~9OJ~~wmffl~~M~B~~~~~~~~w ~Jlltftm~7fjV middot 4 fsecttffj reg~m (f9lI~DiI~t~ )~~~ 72-78 ~B~~~wm mbullbullamp~~~79~~bullbullVo~a~gmiddot~$~~~~~63~~~~~~~Wffl

ft~ middot ~~t$~liiIjJWj)~~~3W 10 ~~JjJm~Jutftbullbull~ ~~ bull EI3~~~~z~0

~~~~w~aHMmiddot~~~ffl~~~~w~bullbull~~w~~~m~ ~fMU1ljm~~-V~~~ 0

m~mffbullbull~M~~m~ Rm~wmmzff~~~wmfflz~~fi~~~B~~~wm

m~~~ROJ~~~-~~~~~B~~W~a~$mR~bull bull ~~=~~~wza~~ttmiddot5~Ma~z~~~~7fjplusmn_tt r)amp~~flIfiJj~~~sect 0 6 -=RU~~wit~a middot~t5~w~mmH (~MbullbullmH~~7middot bullbullwbullbull~-g~m~~~lim~Jj~~

8 ~ff~li 9 ~F~mJllIO r)ampmH~it) DfgImB ( ~MDfgI~~f II ~m

I~nI 12) j)amp~mffJi (~M~J~bullbull~~m ~Jfl~~tiamp~m j)amp1J[lji~ )~~~~~itfil 0

a~middot-li~~~middot=bullbull~Abullbull~middot=M~a~~~~ middotmW~A~OJ~Rmm~$~middotaffli~~~~~Abullbull~zMmiddot~ ~JjllI~z~~ffBlRJlnfi~~~ 0

-middot~m~m~ff~_e(I~-)

(-)~M~Jl~4hfJftfJt~tJl~1fA~Jt ~~~~Jj~~~W~ffl~~~~middotm~~bullbullbull~tf~~m

ti~~~~amp~~~7fjJj~~~~~~~flm~~osect~~~~~

~~ ~~~$jtli[ijzJlJ~OJ~1~ ft5~~~~~1t1JD3~it 250gal j)~

~1~~middot~m~~~~n~mB~~M~~JjJm~~JjIfi~~

3shy

(20 )

iWD~jlUmampit~~Sli1lll~Jl~ lilift1treg59tJ3t~~Jbliit~~ ~Uit~~ ~JUjUDi1lll~UtpoundM~ 0 ffitpound 921 ft1t~~ t ~ttJU7ili-li~ ft59trUregm 400gaJ p)tregIglt ~f(Arrfpound~IIIUP)f($ft(jfamprrJh $7it~~~Uf mltl~jJIj ~JjPJTff~~WWi~VijJG~~ftiW t m9~UOJB~tlJMft~ It $JtaIlftrft~i1lllo

~~1pound~~bullbullftItPJT~regItJ3tbullbullft~~OJiliit~ ~m~ffregW~JU7o~~m-OJ~lli~ftmregItJ3t~Itregffiff

~regg~ffili~g~~tw~mftmreg~~~~~~~m

tlD~tfiregjl~ffibullbull11fiff 2765 011 bull ffittItI3t11fiff 5 amp bull ~t1firegftm ~ffibullbullili 9549 011 bull ffilt~W~JU 6 amp lamp1poundUI1~JUftmit~~reg~m ffmyen bull amp~Jfft4tregwHiSfi1JB~JE 0

f(- 1f 1f j-~~i-t-)J~9amp)JHlt~Ji2titj-f(lJoiiJi1t II iE ~ ItJ ii

1466 1341613519 3972 8674 9432 16832 19488

17241 1776 326 3702 14417 5736 11216 10826

1106614809 3392 9720 2824 1068215313 6908

15583 2878 8774 13596 914615823 4678 13824

9549 68452 3665425080 10132 6562 12214 12812

141046300 9038 16294 463327737 35308 51172

20798 247527812 8194 8630 26104 39938 29166

43970531 17100 30248 31176 42282 989966

1343 34496 61076 983 1533 41554 63900 51782

340101535 27538 42002 27018 585941958 36840 27466 370502153 46530

2630 25780 56322 77442 23058 31266 488862845

4525 17328 16898 29836 4688 7620 2485815738 4771 3619451942 50160 3551 20816 2569015330 3582 12926 2210818250 3931 19398 43868 34866 3817 10970 23070 15684

178242765 11628 18752 3194 33550 74990 62416

348003974 21102 35146 7986 18620 142665450

6802 4192 20720 14810

-4

I

gshy

yenflff~1ilfiyen~ttllfiil-l_rlt(~)

o wlJ~~~flY-i ~3f~ ~~bullbull~bullbullbull~~middot~plusmn~~M~3f~~bullbullmwlJ~~bullbull~~~middot~ ~IplusmnM ( 98 3f 8L 3f IL 3f pound9 rfler~flfHHFJ~~~ ) LElJ~l~~wlJ ~~bullbull~rnJ~mf~Jtf~~$ i6iS 0 iiI1W~~ru~~flY-img~WW

~~~W~~~~~yen~iiI1lJW~~plusmn~~m~OO~~m~OO~~ m= m2- m~-~gmmiil1w~~rflW~~yenIZ6~

yenf+1-ltlYf IJ tJ-if~i1t~iff~Jjlt fi~on(-=-)

OZ)

(22)

~~$~bullbull~3ftMmbullbull3 bullbullbull~ampbullbull~~~~~N B~~~~mbullbullm~~~~~mM~~~~~~~~~o

(tm)~~~4h~~itrJisectll~Jt ~xntAt~4h~~itrJ1t~J$ll ~~~~~bullbullbull~~~m~mfibullbullI~~~~~bullbullM~~

~ffM~m~~~~~~gmiddotm~~~~~bullbullti~~~M~~~~~~ffi~ ~~~~~~5tt~f~~Elfm~fj~ JlU~~fflH)~A~il1ri~ 0 1fpound~~

~5t~~~~~$~~m~~~~~~~~~1fpound~~~~~~~~~~ ~lliWI~pound~1fpound~~m~~~m~~w-~~~m~il1ri~ffo =lt~~tfiitllz~ ~~~~~mz~~M~~m~~~~~~m~~amp~~~~~~~~

~~~~mw-~~~T~~~ (A=) ~~-B~~~mz~~~~1fpound~~~m~~~~~~~Abullbull

~-x~-m~ru5t~p~~~~~7~~o

m~ ~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot _sectJt~~~g~t~z~~1JDJ) ~~~~~~Abullbull~~M~M~~~~ff~x~~~~N~ M~m~ bull j~ru~NEHT~tt ~~JlIj~7~~ 0

~~-B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~Ail1ri~-~

~+A-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-m~ruffA~tt~~ffi ru~P~tt~~~7~~o

~~H~~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot mlt~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~A~x~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JDm~M~~~~~m~j~ruffA~tt~~ffiru~N~ttmiddot~~~

7~~o

~~~B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~A~il1ri~-~

~+A-ff~~bullbull~~~~m~-~~sect-m~ru~~~~ ~ffli~tt ~~f)JlUru5t~Pittt ~~~7~~ 0

~~ Hfamp~bullbull5ti13tB~~~~~~~Mz~~ flHt~~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~Ax~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JD~~~ru~ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~~M~~~sectbullbull ~~~~ru~~lIJ~~ffli~ttffi~ ~~ffiJlrjru5t~p~ffi ~~~ 7~~o

~~~~~~mz~~~~~-Am-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-ffl ~ru~bullbullffA~tto

m~~bullbull~~~~~~~~~Mz~~middotm~~~w~bullbull~~~m ~~~~~Abullbull~~M~~~~~~~ru~li~ttyen~~ 15~~13tJlU~~15~m~ 0

~~E~~$mz~~~~~-Am-ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~-~

6shy

shy I

Ii i --L shy i

degY~~MI~~~~~~~~~mm~~~~~B~~~~

~~~~~~~Mm~~m~Hm~~W~~Y~amp~~m~~~q~0~

V~W~~~~~Wm~~8yen~W~~~ti~~~ampmiddot~WBW~~ ~yenm~~~~~ID~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~amp~~~~~~secto~

~Yg~~f~1$ r ~n~~J ~tt~E1JYH~$~fbfbWti~l~ID ~~trDqnM1amp~ ampH~slz0~~ijWfEyen~ nM1amp~~WEEyenm~j ~~W-0~wFr

o ampnnl~JifE yen~~$nMyen~4=~-qIllID~~~~ID lW~Yijg~$~Jilm~~~ yenm~g

~~~_~yen~Y~~yen_Jilmm~~~~B~m~~~~~

o~Jif~yen~~~~~$yenm-~$~~-~~~m$

~W~Byen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~V~~

deglW~ Yyen~$~~~m~~yenm~g~H~_~yen~Y~~yen_JiI

mm~~~~B~m~~~~~IDmiddot~U~~m~~middotM~~

deglW~YByen~m$yenm-~~~m~fu

~~WfuByen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~ oyen~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~yen~M~m~Wyen~Y~~~~E~m~~~~m~~

~~~~Ufu~~bullbullm~WB~~~~~M~~~~~~N lW~~~~$yenm-~yen-~Jilmm~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~

olU~Jif~~~nt~~$nMyenmWti sect~~~~~m~~~yenm~g~H~~yenbullbullY~B~~~~ ~WMm~~~~~ID~~~_~~~~~~JiIbullbull~~~N

oyen~JifByen~~~~$$yenm-~~~

(poundZ)

(24)

f---+------+----j-----t---j----+------r------I

x o

o o o

o x ( o

o x x x

111 tl5 ~

8

(25 )n=-~~~~~mff~~~~~~~

( ~~~i~~1m~~ J

a~~m~I~~ffa~~~h=-~~~ffMampffig~

ffi~I~Wm~~~~m~~~mAmbullbull Dffimff~~~m~~~ ~H~bullbull$~wnm~W~~~Nmm~fi~~~~RMft~m~ ~~~mm~m~0~~Hm~~~~tt~m~M~MMW~5li~I fF 0 n~JJHT~bullbull~fsect$fJ~M~~-= 0

-=- JJlAtJ( 1amp -pound ~~EIlbj i-4--k-tt

JJl1=r$~ plusmn Jl J73 ~ ~ Z ~

921 tf(lUpoundfj1=r~ ~J

1~lttltttI 21iUnllrfjJfTm5EIimt~

IffiH 3llX tHI~Jlmtt H~Ptbsectra~Ii03llt~J1i 5tt~tf(sect~mm~~ It jJjJf)Ut~li

I ~5IUUdl~ g~HI~UIH1mH fiJ ~Ptbm 5E 2$mf~Ff~~ ~AE-N 3~111flUtMz=1-5E~~ 4=1 1IJ ~ ~Jlt~HJII JJrt ~~ bull ~ij~1f IlN ( fI JJrt l tt fl Ii 1Bl$mff~ )

5fljiJEJ01tI~5Inf~tf(sect~B9ltjpli~li Mz1m $1f~mJllJ1[iIl~

921 tf( ~ft~1[iIl~ 1J1J~

1 1[ fT mBHIl1=r 1t JlIJ m5EIi 1[iIlmt~

2 ill lzJili ~ tItiHft ~~ 3 m Jfill JlIJ ii 4mIDl1[iIl~ft

1fl9J~amp~$IIl~ ~fiti~1m~ij~ij~ ~ 0ffi1JlIl~

2fBtllJrn5E1W~ 1mplusmnIiJ$fEl 3fl1J rllJ~J 1m$1amp51sectraiIltm~OO~Ii 41m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ j1~tplusmnlt 5fj~ff1J~m~=1JE 6fj~ 13 iW JilE1[iIl~ftB91[Ji-- r 3llt~llUr~1llG J fJEj ~ij~i~

tf( f3t~1I1[iIlllt iampii IittllUlmllffi

---------shy

lmJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2~tf(~lIitm~~ 3mJlIJ t~~JIl1li 4~~~tf(~jilUlm 5~~fiM~tf(~ 6ilHfj~i$ rfjiJi 3( ~ 7[5fRltf( ~1fplusmntt~~ --------------------_ -

I fIji1[~ tf( 2fIji1[~tf(~ ffij~~~OOmifi~fI 3D~ 1Jj~$~ EI ~JIltlIUl~~ ffij~~~~mIDII

ii4~liff~~JI

R~~a~~ffig$fJ~~M~fim~~mff~bullbull~I~~~$ ~m~~~m~~m~~amp$~~~~~bullbull~M~a~~~~~~m lIt~~~~grrtJ(Iplusmn~j7g$m~ 0

~~b - Jlt tfR-~ BN$~lL~~~~JH~ ~l5lf~~~ Jm~ifBaJfJ ~imW $~m~~~~~~$l5lm~~~~o

lNJH~ $f7J~Af1~~~ N~it~$~a~~~ftpfT~~ f ~1JDjJ~ Jt~~JH~~ 0

-9shy

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 3: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(19 )~=-~~~m~ff~~~bull~n ~~~~~~~li~~~~~~~~~Bm~~~~wzm ~~~~ bullbull~~~bullbullbull~~~mz~~wam~~~mabullbull o ~~ff~~~m~g~ffl~~ftbullbull~m~~~a~~~~W~~~~~ jt~bullbull~ 0 yen~a~t~ 1B~~Jur)~~~~ OJY~~w~~msect~Wlffi

bullbull~~~mfltEla~lf 0

~middot~~~ampU~mbullbullRM~W~~~~Mbullbull~n~m~sect~~sect ~IJ~ti~ ~ffl~~W~a~t~~a~trnr) 4-6 Jj~~~wm~~9 ~a5ir) 1-3 ~~

~~W~ffl~bullbullbullbull ~~~~~~8~~m~plusmnbullbull ~~ampB~ ~~~~m~~Bm~~bullbull~~wZa~~~amp~~mHm-Am~ m~bullbullh~~o~9OJ~~wmffl~~M~B~~~~~~~~w ~Jlltftm~7fjV middot 4 fsecttffj reg~m (f9lI~DiI~t~ )~~~ 72-78 ~B~~~wm mbullbullamp~~~79~~bullbullVo~a~gmiddot~$~~~~~63~~~~~~~Wffl

ft~ middot ~~t$~liiIjJWj)~~~3W 10 ~~JjJm~Jutftbullbull~ ~~ bull EI3~~~~z~0

~~~~w~aHMmiddot~~~ffl~~~~w~bullbull~~w~~~m~ ~fMU1ljm~~-V~~~ 0

m~mffbullbull~M~~m~ Rm~wmmzff~~~wmfflz~~fi~~~B~~~wm

m~~~ROJ~~~-~~~~~B~~W~a~$mR~bull bull ~~=~~~wza~~ttmiddot5~Ma~z~~~~7fjplusmn_tt r)amp~~flIfiJj~~~sect 0 6 -=RU~~wit~a middot~t5~w~mmH (~MbullbullmH~~7middot bullbullwbullbull~-g~m~~~lim~Jj~~

8 ~ff~li 9 ~F~mJllIO r)ampmH~it) DfgImB ( ~MDfgI~~f II ~m

I~nI 12) j)amp~mffJi (~M~J~bullbull~~m ~Jfl~~tiamp~m j)amp1J[lji~ )~~~~~itfil 0

a~middot-li~~~middot=bullbull~Abullbull~middot=M~a~~~~ middotmW~A~OJ~Rmm~$~middotaffli~~~~~Abullbull~zMmiddot~ ~JjllI~z~~ffBlRJlnfi~~~ 0

-middot~m~m~ff~_e(I~-)

(-)~M~Jl~4hfJftfJt~tJl~1fA~Jt ~~~~Jj~~~W~ffl~~~~middotm~~bullbullbull~tf~~m

ti~~~~amp~~~7fjJj~~~~~~~flm~~osect~~~~~

~~ ~~~$jtli[ijzJlJ~OJ~1~ ft5~~~~~1t1JD3~it 250gal j)~

~1~~middot~m~~~~n~mB~~M~~JjJm~~JjIfi~~

3shy

(20 )

iWD~jlUmampit~~Sli1lll~Jl~ lilift1treg59tJ3t~~Jbliit~~ ~Uit~~ ~JUjUDi1lll~UtpoundM~ 0 ffitpound 921 ft1t~~ t ~ttJU7ili-li~ ft59trUregm 400gaJ p)tregIglt ~f(Arrfpound~IIIUP)f($ft(jfamprrJh $7it~~~Uf mltl~jJIj ~JjPJTff~~WWi~VijJG~~ftiW t m9~UOJB~tlJMft~ It $JtaIlftrft~i1lllo

~~1pound~~bullbullftItPJT~regItJ3tbullbullft~~OJiliit~ ~m~ffregW~JU7o~~m-OJ~lli~ftmregItJ3t~Itregffiff

~regg~ffili~g~~tw~mftmreg~~~~~~~m

tlD~tfiregjl~ffibullbull11fiff 2765 011 bull ffittItI3t11fiff 5 amp bull ~t1firegftm ~ffibullbullili 9549 011 bull ffilt~W~JU 6 amp lamp1poundUI1~JUftmit~~reg~m ffmyen bull amp~Jfft4tregwHiSfi1JB~JE 0

f(- 1f 1f j-~~i-t-)J~9amp)JHlt~Ji2titj-f(lJoiiJi1t II iE ~ ItJ ii

1466 1341613519 3972 8674 9432 16832 19488

17241 1776 326 3702 14417 5736 11216 10826

1106614809 3392 9720 2824 1068215313 6908

15583 2878 8774 13596 914615823 4678 13824

9549 68452 3665425080 10132 6562 12214 12812

141046300 9038 16294 463327737 35308 51172

20798 247527812 8194 8630 26104 39938 29166

43970531 17100 30248 31176 42282 989966

1343 34496 61076 983 1533 41554 63900 51782

340101535 27538 42002 27018 585941958 36840 27466 370502153 46530

2630 25780 56322 77442 23058 31266 488862845

4525 17328 16898 29836 4688 7620 2485815738 4771 3619451942 50160 3551 20816 2569015330 3582 12926 2210818250 3931 19398 43868 34866 3817 10970 23070 15684

178242765 11628 18752 3194 33550 74990 62416

348003974 21102 35146 7986 18620 142665450

6802 4192 20720 14810

-4

I

gshy

yenflff~1ilfiyen~ttllfiil-l_rlt(~)

o wlJ~~~flY-i ~3f~ ~~bullbull~bullbullbull~~middot~plusmn~~M~3f~~bullbullmwlJ~~bullbull~~~middot~ ~IplusmnM ( 98 3f 8L 3f IL 3f pound9 rfler~flfHHFJ~~~ ) LElJ~l~~wlJ ~~bullbull~rnJ~mf~Jtf~~$ i6iS 0 iiI1W~~ru~~flY-img~WW

~~~W~~~~~yen~iiI1lJW~~plusmn~~m~OO~~m~OO~~ m= m2- m~-~gmmiil1w~~rflW~~yenIZ6~

yenf+1-ltlYf IJ tJ-if~i1t~iff~Jjlt fi~on(-=-)

OZ)

(22)

~~$~bullbull~3ftMmbullbull3 bullbullbull~ampbullbull~~~~~N B~~~~mbullbullm~~~~~mM~~~~~~~~~o

(tm)~~~4h~~itrJisectll~Jt ~xntAt~4h~~itrJ1t~J$ll ~~~~~bullbullbull~~~m~mfibullbullI~~~~~bullbullM~~

~ffM~m~~~~~~gmiddotm~~~~~bullbullti~~~M~~~~~~ffi~ ~~~~~~5tt~f~~Elfm~fj~ JlU~~fflH)~A~il1ri~ 0 1fpound~~

~5t~~~~~$~~m~~~~~~~~~1fpound~~~~~~~~~~ ~lliWI~pound~1fpound~~m~~~m~~w-~~~m~il1ri~ffo =lt~~tfiitllz~ ~~~~~mz~~M~~m~~~~~~m~~amp~~~~~~~~

~~~~mw-~~~T~~~ (A=) ~~-B~~~mz~~~~1fpound~~~m~~~~~~~Abullbull

~-x~-m~ru5t~p~~~~~7~~o

m~ ~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot _sectJt~~~g~t~z~~1JDJ) ~~~~~~Abullbull~~M~M~~~~ff~x~~~~N~ M~m~ bull j~ru~NEHT~tt ~~JlIj~7~~ 0

~~-B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~Ail1ri~-~

~+A-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-m~ruffA~tt~~ffi ru~P~tt~~~7~~o

~~H~~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot mlt~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~A~x~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JDm~M~~~~~m~j~ruffA~tt~~ffiru~N~ttmiddot~~~

7~~o

~~~B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~A~il1ri~-~

~+A-ff~~bullbull~~~~m~-~~sect-m~ru~~~~ ~ffli~tt ~~f)JlUru5t~Pittt ~~~7~~ 0

~~ Hfamp~bullbull5ti13tB~~~~~~~Mz~~ flHt~~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~Ax~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JD~~~ru~ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~~M~~~sectbullbull ~~~~ru~~lIJ~~ffli~ttffi~ ~~ffiJlrjru5t~p~ffi ~~~ 7~~o

~~~~~~mz~~~~~-Am-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-ffl ~ru~bullbullffA~tto

m~~bullbull~~~~~~~~~Mz~~middotm~~~w~bullbull~~~m ~~~~~Abullbull~~M~~~~~~~ru~li~ttyen~~ 15~~13tJlU~~15~m~ 0

~~E~~$mz~~~~~-Am-ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~-~

6shy

shy I

Ii i --L shy i

degY~~MI~~~~~~~~~mm~~~~~B~~~~

~~~~~~~Mm~~m~Hm~~W~~Y~amp~~m~~~q~0~

V~W~~~~~Wm~~8yen~W~~~ti~~~ampmiddot~WBW~~ ~yenm~~~~~ID~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~amp~~~~~~secto~

~Yg~~f~1$ r ~n~~J ~tt~E1JYH~$~fbfbWti~l~ID ~~trDqnM1amp~ ampH~slz0~~ijWfEyen~ nM1amp~~WEEyenm~j ~~W-0~wFr

o ampnnl~JifE yen~~$nMyen~4=~-qIllID~~~~ID lW~Yijg~$~Jilm~~~ yenm~g

~~~_~yen~Y~~yen_Jilmm~~~~B~m~~~~~

o~Jif~yen~~~~~$yenm-~$~~-~~~m$

~W~Byen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~V~~

deglW~ Yyen~$~~~m~~yenm~g~H~_~yen~Y~~yen_JiI

mm~~~~B~m~~~~~IDmiddot~U~~m~~middotM~~

deglW~YByen~m$yenm-~~~m~fu

~~WfuByen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~ oyen~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~yen~M~m~Wyen~Y~~~~E~m~~~~m~~

~~~~Ufu~~bullbullm~WB~~~~~M~~~~~~N lW~~~~$yenm-~yen-~Jilmm~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~

olU~Jif~~~nt~~$nMyenmWti sect~~~~~m~~~yenm~g~H~~yenbullbullY~B~~~~ ~WMm~~~~~ID~~~_~~~~~~JiIbullbull~~~N

oyen~JifByen~~~~$$yenm-~~~

(poundZ)

(24)

f---+------+----j-----t---j----+------r------I

x o

o o o

o x ( o

o x x x

111 tl5 ~

8

(25 )n=-~~~~~mff~~~~~~~

( ~~~i~~1m~~ J

a~~m~I~~ffa~~~h=-~~~ffMampffig~

ffi~I~Wm~~~~m~~~mAmbullbull Dffimff~~~m~~~ ~H~bullbull$~wnm~W~~~Nmm~fi~~~~RMft~m~ ~~~mm~m~0~~Hm~~~~tt~m~M~MMW~5li~I fF 0 n~JJHT~bullbull~fsect$fJ~M~~-= 0

-=- JJlAtJ( 1amp -pound ~~EIlbj i-4--k-tt

JJl1=r$~ plusmn Jl J73 ~ ~ Z ~

921 tf(lUpoundfj1=r~ ~J

1~lttltttI 21iUnllrfjJfTm5EIimt~

IffiH 3llX tHI~Jlmtt H~Ptbsectra~Ii03llt~J1i 5tt~tf(sect~mm~~ It jJjJf)Ut~li

I ~5IUUdl~ g~HI~UIH1mH fiJ ~Ptbm 5E 2$mf~Ff~~ ~AE-N 3~111flUtMz=1-5E~~ 4=1 1IJ ~ ~Jlt~HJII JJrt ~~ bull ~ij~1f IlN ( fI JJrt l tt fl Ii 1Bl$mff~ )

5fljiJEJ01tI~5Inf~tf(sect~B9ltjpli~li Mz1m $1f~mJllJ1[iIl~

921 tf( ~ft~1[iIl~ 1J1J~

1 1[ fT mBHIl1=r 1t JlIJ m5EIi 1[iIlmt~

2 ill lzJili ~ tItiHft ~~ 3 m Jfill JlIJ ii 4mIDl1[iIl~ft

1fl9J~amp~$IIl~ ~fiti~1m~ij~ij~ ~ 0ffi1JlIl~

2fBtllJrn5E1W~ 1mplusmnIiJ$fEl 3fl1J rllJ~J 1m$1amp51sectraiIltm~OO~Ii 41m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ j1~tplusmnlt 5fj~ff1J~m~=1JE 6fj~ 13 iW JilE1[iIl~ftB91[Ji-- r 3llt~llUr~1llG J fJEj ~ij~i~

tf( f3t~1I1[iIlllt iampii IittllUlmllffi

---------shy

lmJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2~tf(~lIitm~~ 3mJlIJ t~~JIl1li 4~~~tf(~jilUlm 5~~fiM~tf(~ 6ilHfj~i$ rfjiJi 3( ~ 7[5fRltf( ~1fplusmntt~~ --------------------_ -

I fIji1[~ tf( 2fIji1[~tf(~ ffij~~~OOmifi~fI 3D~ 1Jj~$~ EI ~JIltlIUl~~ ffij~~~~mIDII

ii4~liff~~JI

R~~a~~ffig$fJ~~M~fim~~mff~bullbull~I~~~$ ~m~~~m~~m~~amp$~~~~~bullbull~M~a~~~~~~m lIt~~~~grrtJ(Iplusmn~j7g$m~ 0

~~b - Jlt tfR-~ BN$~lL~~~~JH~ ~l5lf~~~ Jm~ifBaJfJ ~imW $~m~~~~~~$l5lm~~~~o

lNJH~ $f7J~Af1~~~ N~it~$~a~~~ftpfT~~ f ~1JDjJ~ Jt~~JH~~ 0

-9shy

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 4: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(20 )

iWD~jlUmampit~~Sli1lll~Jl~ lilift1treg59tJ3t~~Jbliit~~ ~Uit~~ ~JUjUDi1lll~UtpoundM~ 0 ffitpound 921 ft1t~~ t ~ttJU7ili-li~ ft59trUregm 400gaJ p)tregIglt ~f(Arrfpound~IIIUP)f($ft(jfamprrJh $7it~~~Uf mltl~jJIj ~JjPJTff~~WWi~VijJG~~ftiW t m9~UOJB~tlJMft~ It $JtaIlftrft~i1lllo

~~1pound~~bullbullftItPJT~regItJ3tbullbullft~~OJiliit~ ~m~ffregW~JU7o~~m-OJ~lli~ftmregItJ3t~Itregffiff

~regg~ffili~g~~tw~mftmreg~~~~~~~m

tlD~tfiregjl~ffibullbull11fiff 2765 011 bull ffittItI3t11fiff 5 amp bull ~t1firegftm ~ffibullbullili 9549 011 bull ffilt~W~JU 6 amp lamp1poundUI1~JUftmit~~reg~m ffmyen bull amp~Jfft4tregwHiSfi1JB~JE 0

f(- 1f 1f j-~~i-t-)J~9amp)JHlt~Ji2titj-f(lJoiiJi1t II iE ~ ItJ ii

1466 1341613519 3972 8674 9432 16832 19488

17241 1776 326 3702 14417 5736 11216 10826

1106614809 3392 9720 2824 1068215313 6908

15583 2878 8774 13596 914615823 4678 13824

9549 68452 3665425080 10132 6562 12214 12812

141046300 9038 16294 463327737 35308 51172

20798 247527812 8194 8630 26104 39938 29166

43970531 17100 30248 31176 42282 989966

1343 34496 61076 983 1533 41554 63900 51782

340101535 27538 42002 27018 585941958 36840 27466 370502153 46530

2630 25780 56322 77442 23058 31266 488862845

4525 17328 16898 29836 4688 7620 2485815738 4771 3619451942 50160 3551 20816 2569015330 3582 12926 2210818250 3931 19398 43868 34866 3817 10970 23070 15684

178242765 11628 18752 3194 33550 74990 62416

348003974 21102 35146 7986 18620 142665450

6802 4192 20720 14810

-4

I

gshy

yenflff~1ilfiyen~ttllfiil-l_rlt(~)

o wlJ~~~flY-i ~3f~ ~~bullbull~bullbullbull~~middot~plusmn~~M~3f~~bullbullmwlJ~~bullbull~~~middot~ ~IplusmnM ( 98 3f 8L 3f IL 3f pound9 rfler~flfHHFJ~~~ ) LElJ~l~~wlJ ~~bullbull~rnJ~mf~Jtf~~$ i6iS 0 iiI1W~~ru~~flY-img~WW

~~~W~~~~~yen~iiI1lJW~~plusmn~~m~OO~~m~OO~~ m= m2- m~-~gmmiil1w~~rflW~~yenIZ6~

yenf+1-ltlYf IJ tJ-if~i1t~iff~Jjlt fi~on(-=-)

OZ)

(22)

~~$~bullbull~3ftMmbullbull3 bullbullbull~ampbullbull~~~~~N B~~~~mbullbullm~~~~~mM~~~~~~~~~o

(tm)~~~4h~~itrJisectll~Jt ~xntAt~4h~~itrJ1t~J$ll ~~~~~bullbullbull~~~m~mfibullbullI~~~~~bullbullM~~

~ffM~m~~~~~~gmiddotm~~~~~bullbullti~~~M~~~~~~ffi~ ~~~~~~5tt~f~~Elfm~fj~ JlU~~fflH)~A~il1ri~ 0 1fpound~~

~5t~~~~~$~~m~~~~~~~~~1fpound~~~~~~~~~~ ~lliWI~pound~1fpound~~m~~~m~~w-~~~m~il1ri~ffo =lt~~tfiitllz~ ~~~~~mz~~M~~m~~~~~~m~~amp~~~~~~~~

~~~~mw-~~~T~~~ (A=) ~~-B~~~mz~~~~1fpound~~~m~~~~~~~Abullbull

~-x~-m~ru5t~p~~~~~7~~o

m~ ~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot _sectJt~~~g~t~z~~1JDJ) ~~~~~~Abullbull~~M~M~~~~ff~x~~~~N~ M~m~ bull j~ru~NEHT~tt ~~JlIj~7~~ 0

~~-B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~Ail1ri~-~

~+A-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-m~ruffA~tt~~ffi ru~P~tt~~~7~~o

~~H~~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot mlt~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~A~x~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JDm~M~~~~~m~j~ruffA~tt~~ffiru~N~ttmiddot~~~

7~~o

~~~B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~A~il1ri~-~

~+A-ff~~bullbull~~~~m~-~~sect-m~ru~~~~ ~ffli~tt ~~f)JlUru5t~Pittt ~~~7~~ 0

~~ Hfamp~bullbull5ti13tB~~~~~~~Mz~~ flHt~~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~Ax~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JD~~~ru~ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~~M~~~sectbullbull ~~~~ru~~lIJ~~ffli~ttffi~ ~~ffiJlrjru5t~p~ffi ~~~ 7~~o

~~~~~~mz~~~~~-Am-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-ffl ~ru~bullbullffA~tto

m~~bullbull~~~~~~~~~Mz~~middotm~~~w~bullbull~~~m ~~~~~Abullbull~~M~~~~~~~ru~li~ttyen~~ 15~~13tJlU~~15~m~ 0

~~E~~$mz~~~~~-Am-ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~-~

6shy

shy I

Ii i --L shy i

degY~~MI~~~~~~~~~mm~~~~~B~~~~

~~~~~~~Mm~~m~Hm~~W~~Y~amp~~m~~~q~0~

V~W~~~~~Wm~~8yen~W~~~ti~~~ampmiddot~WBW~~ ~yenm~~~~~ID~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~amp~~~~~~secto~

~Yg~~f~1$ r ~n~~J ~tt~E1JYH~$~fbfbWti~l~ID ~~trDqnM1amp~ ampH~slz0~~ijWfEyen~ nM1amp~~WEEyenm~j ~~W-0~wFr

o ampnnl~JifE yen~~$nMyen~4=~-qIllID~~~~ID lW~Yijg~$~Jilm~~~ yenm~g

~~~_~yen~Y~~yen_Jilmm~~~~B~m~~~~~

o~Jif~yen~~~~~$yenm-~$~~-~~~m$

~W~Byen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~V~~

deglW~ Yyen~$~~~m~~yenm~g~H~_~yen~Y~~yen_JiI

mm~~~~B~m~~~~~IDmiddot~U~~m~~middotM~~

deglW~YByen~m$yenm-~~~m~fu

~~WfuByen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~ oyen~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~yen~M~m~Wyen~Y~~~~E~m~~~~m~~

~~~~Ufu~~bullbullm~WB~~~~~M~~~~~~N lW~~~~$yenm-~yen-~Jilmm~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~

olU~Jif~~~nt~~$nMyenmWti sect~~~~~m~~~yenm~g~H~~yenbullbullY~B~~~~ ~WMm~~~~~ID~~~_~~~~~~JiIbullbull~~~N

oyen~JifByen~~~~$$yenm-~~~

(poundZ)

(24)

f---+------+----j-----t---j----+------r------I

x o

o o o

o x ( o

o x x x

111 tl5 ~

8

(25 )n=-~~~~~mff~~~~~~~

( ~~~i~~1m~~ J

a~~m~I~~ffa~~~h=-~~~ffMampffig~

ffi~I~Wm~~~~m~~~mAmbullbull Dffimff~~~m~~~ ~H~bullbull$~wnm~W~~~Nmm~fi~~~~RMft~m~ ~~~mm~m~0~~Hm~~~~tt~m~M~MMW~5li~I fF 0 n~JJHT~bullbull~fsect$fJ~M~~-= 0

-=- JJlAtJ( 1amp -pound ~~EIlbj i-4--k-tt

JJl1=r$~ plusmn Jl J73 ~ ~ Z ~

921 tf(lUpoundfj1=r~ ~J

1~lttltttI 21iUnllrfjJfTm5EIimt~

IffiH 3llX tHI~Jlmtt H~Ptbsectra~Ii03llt~J1i 5tt~tf(sect~mm~~ It jJjJf)Ut~li

I ~5IUUdl~ g~HI~UIH1mH fiJ ~Ptbm 5E 2$mf~Ff~~ ~AE-N 3~111flUtMz=1-5E~~ 4=1 1IJ ~ ~Jlt~HJII JJrt ~~ bull ~ij~1f IlN ( fI JJrt l tt fl Ii 1Bl$mff~ )

5fljiJEJ01tI~5Inf~tf(sect~B9ltjpli~li Mz1m $1f~mJllJ1[iIl~

921 tf( ~ft~1[iIl~ 1J1J~

1 1[ fT mBHIl1=r 1t JlIJ m5EIi 1[iIlmt~

2 ill lzJili ~ tItiHft ~~ 3 m Jfill JlIJ ii 4mIDl1[iIl~ft

1fl9J~amp~$IIl~ ~fiti~1m~ij~ij~ ~ 0ffi1JlIl~

2fBtllJrn5E1W~ 1mplusmnIiJ$fEl 3fl1J rllJ~J 1m$1amp51sectraiIltm~OO~Ii 41m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ j1~tplusmnlt 5fj~ff1J~m~=1JE 6fj~ 13 iW JilE1[iIl~ftB91[Ji-- r 3llt~llUr~1llG J fJEj ~ij~i~

tf( f3t~1I1[iIlllt iampii IittllUlmllffi

---------shy

lmJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2~tf(~lIitm~~ 3mJlIJ t~~JIl1li 4~~~tf(~jilUlm 5~~fiM~tf(~ 6ilHfj~i$ rfjiJi 3( ~ 7[5fRltf( ~1fplusmntt~~ --------------------_ -

I fIji1[~ tf( 2fIji1[~tf(~ ffij~~~OOmifi~fI 3D~ 1Jj~$~ EI ~JIltlIUl~~ ffij~~~~mIDII

ii4~liff~~JI

R~~a~~ffig$fJ~~M~fim~~mff~bullbull~I~~~$ ~m~~~m~~m~~amp$~~~~~bullbull~M~a~~~~~~m lIt~~~~grrtJ(Iplusmn~j7g$m~ 0

~~b - Jlt tfR-~ BN$~lL~~~~JH~ ~l5lf~~~ Jm~ifBaJfJ ~imW $~m~~~~~~$l5lm~~~~o

lNJH~ $f7J~Af1~~~ N~it~$~a~~~ftpfT~~ f ~1JDjJ~ Jt~~JH~~ 0

-9shy

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 5: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

gshy

yenflff~1ilfiyen~ttllfiil-l_rlt(~)

o wlJ~~~flY-i ~3f~ ~~bullbull~bullbullbull~~middot~plusmn~~M~3f~~bullbullmwlJ~~bullbull~~~middot~ ~IplusmnM ( 98 3f 8L 3f IL 3f pound9 rfler~flfHHFJ~~~ ) LElJ~l~~wlJ ~~bullbull~rnJ~mf~Jtf~~$ i6iS 0 iiI1W~~ru~~flY-img~WW

~~~W~~~~~yen~iiI1lJW~~plusmn~~m~OO~~m~OO~~ m= m2- m~-~gmmiil1w~~rflW~~yenIZ6~

yenf+1-ltlYf IJ tJ-if~i1t~iff~Jjlt fi~on(-=-)

OZ)

(22)

~~$~bullbull~3ftMmbullbull3 bullbullbull~ampbullbull~~~~~N B~~~~mbullbullm~~~~~mM~~~~~~~~~o

(tm)~~~4h~~itrJisectll~Jt ~xntAt~4h~~itrJ1t~J$ll ~~~~~bullbullbull~~~m~mfibullbullI~~~~~bullbullM~~

~ffM~m~~~~~~gmiddotm~~~~~bullbullti~~~M~~~~~~ffi~ ~~~~~~5tt~f~~Elfm~fj~ JlU~~fflH)~A~il1ri~ 0 1fpound~~

~5t~~~~~$~~m~~~~~~~~~1fpound~~~~~~~~~~ ~lliWI~pound~1fpound~~m~~~m~~w-~~~m~il1ri~ffo =lt~~tfiitllz~ ~~~~~mz~~M~~m~~~~~~m~~amp~~~~~~~~

~~~~mw-~~~T~~~ (A=) ~~-B~~~mz~~~~1fpound~~~m~~~~~~~Abullbull

~-x~-m~ru5t~p~~~~~7~~o

m~ ~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot _sectJt~~~g~t~z~~1JDJ) ~~~~~~Abullbull~~M~M~~~~ff~x~~~~N~ M~m~ bull j~ru~NEHT~tt ~~JlIj~7~~ 0

~~-B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~Ail1ri~-~

~+A-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-m~ruffA~tt~~ffi ru~P~tt~~~7~~o

~~H~~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot mlt~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~A~x~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JDm~M~~~~~m~j~ruffA~tt~~ffiru~N~ttmiddot~~~

7~~o

~~~B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~A~il1ri~-~

~+A-ff~~bullbull~~~~m~-~~sect-m~ru~~~~ ~ffli~tt ~~f)JlUru5t~Pittt ~~~7~~ 0

~~ Hfamp~bullbull5ti13tB~~~~~~~Mz~~ flHt~~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~Ax~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JD~~~ru~ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~~M~~~sectbullbull ~~~~ru~~lIJ~~ffli~ttffi~ ~~ffiJlrjru5t~p~ffi ~~~ 7~~o

~~~~~~mz~~~~~-Am-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-ffl ~ru~bullbullffA~tto

m~~bullbull~~~~~~~~~Mz~~middotm~~~w~bullbull~~~m ~~~~~Abullbull~~M~~~~~~~ru~li~ttyen~~ 15~~13tJlU~~15~m~ 0

~~E~~$mz~~~~~-Am-ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~-~

6shy

shy I

Ii i --L shy i

degY~~MI~~~~~~~~~mm~~~~~B~~~~

~~~~~~~Mm~~m~Hm~~W~~Y~amp~~m~~~q~0~

V~W~~~~~Wm~~8yen~W~~~ti~~~ampmiddot~WBW~~ ~yenm~~~~~ID~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~amp~~~~~~secto~

~Yg~~f~1$ r ~n~~J ~tt~E1JYH~$~fbfbWti~l~ID ~~trDqnM1amp~ ampH~slz0~~ijWfEyen~ nM1amp~~WEEyenm~j ~~W-0~wFr

o ampnnl~JifE yen~~$nMyen~4=~-qIllID~~~~ID lW~Yijg~$~Jilm~~~ yenm~g

~~~_~yen~Y~~yen_Jilmm~~~~B~m~~~~~

o~Jif~yen~~~~~$yenm-~$~~-~~~m$

~W~Byen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~V~~

deglW~ Yyen~$~~~m~~yenm~g~H~_~yen~Y~~yen_JiI

mm~~~~B~m~~~~~IDmiddot~U~~m~~middotM~~

deglW~YByen~m$yenm-~~~m~fu

~~WfuByen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~ oyen~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~yen~M~m~Wyen~Y~~~~E~m~~~~m~~

~~~~Ufu~~bullbullm~WB~~~~~M~~~~~~N lW~~~~$yenm-~yen-~Jilmm~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~

olU~Jif~~~nt~~$nMyenmWti sect~~~~~m~~~yenm~g~H~~yenbullbullY~B~~~~ ~WMm~~~~~ID~~~_~~~~~~JiIbullbull~~~N

oyen~JifByen~~~~$$yenm-~~~

(poundZ)

(24)

f---+------+----j-----t---j----+------r------I

x o

o o o

o x ( o

o x x x

111 tl5 ~

8

(25 )n=-~~~~~mff~~~~~~~

( ~~~i~~1m~~ J

a~~m~I~~ffa~~~h=-~~~ffMampffig~

ffi~I~Wm~~~~m~~~mAmbullbull Dffimff~~~m~~~ ~H~bullbull$~wnm~W~~~Nmm~fi~~~~RMft~m~ ~~~mm~m~0~~Hm~~~~tt~m~M~MMW~5li~I fF 0 n~JJHT~bullbull~fsect$fJ~M~~-= 0

-=- JJlAtJ( 1amp -pound ~~EIlbj i-4--k-tt

JJl1=r$~ plusmn Jl J73 ~ ~ Z ~

921 tf(lUpoundfj1=r~ ~J

1~lttltttI 21iUnllrfjJfTm5EIimt~

IffiH 3llX tHI~Jlmtt H~Ptbsectra~Ii03llt~J1i 5tt~tf(sect~mm~~ It jJjJf)Ut~li

I ~5IUUdl~ g~HI~UIH1mH fiJ ~Ptbm 5E 2$mf~Ff~~ ~AE-N 3~111flUtMz=1-5E~~ 4=1 1IJ ~ ~Jlt~HJII JJrt ~~ bull ~ij~1f IlN ( fI JJrt l tt fl Ii 1Bl$mff~ )

5fljiJEJ01tI~5Inf~tf(sect~B9ltjpli~li Mz1m $1f~mJllJ1[iIl~

921 tf( ~ft~1[iIl~ 1J1J~

1 1[ fT mBHIl1=r 1t JlIJ m5EIi 1[iIlmt~

2 ill lzJili ~ tItiHft ~~ 3 m Jfill JlIJ ii 4mIDl1[iIl~ft

1fl9J~amp~$IIl~ ~fiti~1m~ij~ij~ ~ 0ffi1JlIl~

2fBtllJrn5E1W~ 1mplusmnIiJ$fEl 3fl1J rllJ~J 1m$1amp51sectraiIltm~OO~Ii 41m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ j1~tplusmnlt 5fj~ff1J~m~=1JE 6fj~ 13 iW JilE1[iIl~ftB91[Ji-- r 3llt~llUr~1llG J fJEj ~ij~i~

tf( f3t~1I1[iIlllt iampii IittllUlmllffi

---------shy

lmJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2~tf(~lIitm~~ 3mJlIJ t~~JIl1li 4~~~tf(~jilUlm 5~~fiM~tf(~ 6ilHfj~i$ rfjiJi 3( ~ 7[5fRltf( ~1fplusmntt~~ --------------------_ -

I fIji1[~ tf( 2fIji1[~tf(~ ffij~~~OOmifi~fI 3D~ 1Jj~$~ EI ~JIltlIUl~~ ffij~~~~mIDII

ii4~liff~~JI

R~~a~~ffig$fJ~~M~fim~~mff~bullbull~I~~~$ ~m~~~m~~m~~amp$~~~~~bullbull~M~a~~~~~~m lIt~~~~grrtJ(Iplusmn~j7g$m~ 0

~~b - Jlt tfR-~ BN$~lL~~~~JH~ ~l5lf~~~ Jm~ifBaJfJ ~imW $~m~~~~~~$l5lm~~~~o

lNJH~ $f7J~Af1~~~ N~it~$~a~~~ftpfT~~ f ~1JDjJ~ Jt~~JH~~ 0

-9shy

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 6: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(22)

~~$~bullbull~3ftMmbullbull3 bullbullbull~ampbullbull~~~~~N B~~~~mbullbullm~~~~~mM~~~~~~~~~o

(tm)~~~4h~~itrJisectll~Jt ~xntAt~4h~~itrJ1t~J$ll ~~~~~bullbullbull~~~m~mfibullbullI~~~~~bullbullM~~

~ffM~m~~~~~~gmiddotm~~~~~bullbullti~~~M~~~~~~ffi~ ~~~~~~5tt~f~~Elfm~fj~ JlU~~fflH)~A~il1ri~ 0 1fpound~~

~5t~~~~~$~~m~~~~~~~~~1fpound~~~~~~~~~~ ~lliWI~pound~1fpound~~m~~~m~~w-~~~m~il1ri~ffo =lt~~tfiitllz~ ~~~~~mz~~M~~m~~~~~~m~~amp~~~~~~~~

~~~~mw-~~~T~~~ (A=) ~~-B~~~mz~~~~1fpound~~~m~~~~~~~Abullbull

~-x~-m~ru5t~p~~~~~7~~o

m~ ~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot _sectJt~~~g~t~z~~1JDJ) ~~~~~~Abullbull~~M~M~~~~ff~x~~~~N~ M~m~ bull j~ru~NEHT~tt ~~JlIj~7~~ 0

~~-B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~Ail1ri~-~

~+A-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-m~ruffA~tt~~ffi ru~P~tt~~~7~~o

~~H~~bullbull~~B~~~~~~~Mz~~ middot mlt~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~A~x~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JDm~M~~~~~m~j~ruffA~tt~~ffiru~N~ttmiddot~~~

7~~o

~~~B~~~mz~~~~m1fpound~~~m~~~~~A~il1ri~-~

~+A-ff~~bullbull~~~~m~-~~sect-m~ru~~~~ ~ffli~tt ~~f)JlUru5t~Pittt ~~~7~~ 0

~~ Hfamp~bullbull5ti13tB~~~~~~~Mz~~ flHt~~~~t~z~~1JD ~~~~~~~Ail1ri~~Ax~~~~A~~~~~~~m~ 1JD~~~ru~ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~~M~~~sectbullbull ~~~~ru~~lIJ~~ffli~ttffi~ ~~ffiJlrjru5t~p~ffi ~~~ 7~~o

~~~~~~mz~~~~~-Am-ff~bullbullMbullbull~~~m~-ffl ~ru~bullbullffA~tto

m~~bullbull~~~~~~~~~Mz~~middotm~~~w~bullbull~~~m ~~~~~Abullbull~~M~~~~~~~ru~li~ttyen~~ 15~~13tJlU~~15~m~ 0

~~E~~$mz~~~~~-Am-ff~$bullbullM~~~~m~-~

6shy

shy I

Ii i --L shy i

degY~~MI~~~~~~~~~mm~~~~~B~~~~

~~~~~~~Mm~~m~Hm~~W~~Y~amp~~m~~~q~0~

V~W~~~~~Wm~~8yen~W~~~ti~~~ampmiddot~WBW~~ ~yenm~~~~~ID~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~amp~~~~~~secto~

~Yg~~f~1$ r ~n~~J ~tt~E1JYH~$~fbfbWti~l~ID ~~trDqnM1amp~ ampH~slz0~~ijWfEyen~ nM1amp~~WEEyenm~j ~~W-0~wFr

o ampnnl~JifE yen~~$nMyen~4=~-qIllID~~~~ID lW~Yijg~$~Jilm~~~ yenm~g

~~~_~yen~Y~~yen_Jilmm~~~~B~m~~~~~

o~Jif~yen~~~~~$yenm-~$~~-~~~m$

~W~Byen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~V~~

deglW~ Yyen~$~~~m~~yenm~g~H~_~yen~Y~~yen_JiI

mm~~~~B~m~~~~~IDmiddot~U~~m~~middotM~~

deglW~YByen~m$yenm-~~~m~fu

~~WfuByen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~ oyen~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~yen~M~m~Wyen~Y~~~~E~m~~~~m~~

~~~~Ufu~~bullbullm~WB~~~~~M~~~~~~N lW~~~~$yenm-~yen-~Jilmm~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~

olU~Jif~~~nt~~$nMyenmWti sect~~~~~m~~~yenm~g~H~~yenbullbullY~B~~~~ ~WMm~~~~~ID~~~_~~~~~~JiIbullbull~~~N

oyen~JifByen~~~~$$yenm-~~~

(poundZ)

(24)

f---+------+----j-----t---j----+------r------I

x o

o o o

o x ( o

o x x x

111 tl5 ~

8

(25 )n=-~~~~~mff~~~~~~~

( ~~~i~~1m~~ J

a~~m~I~~ffa~~~h=-~~~ffMampffig~

ffi~I~Wm~~~~m~~~mAmbullbull Dffimff~~~m~~~ ~H~bullbull$~wnm~W~~~Nmm~fi~~~~RMft~m~ ~~~mm~m~0~~Hm~~~~tt~m~M~MMW~5li~I fF 0 n~JJHT~bullbull~fsect$fJ~M~~-= 0

-=- JJlAtJ( 1amp -pound ~~EIlbj i-4--k-tt

JJl1=r$~ plusmn Jl J73 ~ ~ Z ~

921 tf(lUpoundfj1=r~ ~J

1~lttltttI 21iUnllrfjJfTm5EIimt~

IffiH 3llX tHI~Jlmtt H~Ptbsectra~Ii03llt~J1i 5tt~tf(sect~mm~~ It jJjJf)Ut~li

I ~5IUUdl~ g~HI~UIH1mH fiJ ~Ptbm 5E 2$mf~Ff~~ ~AE-N 3~111flUtMz=1-5E~~ 4=1 1IJ ~ ~Jlt~HJII JJrt ~~ bull ~ij~1f IlN ( fI JJrt l tt fl Ii 1Bl$mff~ )

5fljiJEJ01tI~5Inf~tf(sect~B9ltjpli~li Mz1m $1f~mJllJ1[iIl~

921 tf( ~ft~1[iIl~ 1J1J~

1 1[ fT mBHIl1=r 1t JlIJ m5EIi 1[iIlmt~

2 ill lzJili ~ tItiHft ~~ 3 m Jfill JlIJ ii 4mIDl1[iIl~ft

1fl9J~amp~$IIl~ ~fiti~1m~ij~ij~ ~ 0ffi1JlIl~

2fBtllJrn5E1W~ 1mplusmnIiJ$fEl 3fl1J rllJ~J 1m$1amp51sectraiIltm~OO~Ii 41m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ j1~tplusmnlt 5fj~ff1J~m~=1JE 6fj~ 13 iW JilE1[iIl~ftB91[Ji-- r 3llt~llUr~1llG J fJEj ~ij~i~

tf( f3t~1I1[iIlllt iampii IittllUlmllffi

---------shy

lmJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2~tf(~lIitm~~ 3mJlIJ t~~JIl1li 4~~~tf(~jilUlm 5~~fiM~tf(~ 6ilHfj~i$ rfjiJi 3( ~ 7[5fRltf( ~1fplusmntt~~ --------------------_ -

I fIji1[~ tf( 2fIji1[~tf(~ ffij~~~OOmifi~fI 3D~ 1Jj~$~ EI ~JIltlIUl~~ ffij~~~~mIDII

ii4~liff~~JI

R~~a~~ffig$fJ~~M~fim~~mff~bullbull~I~~~$ ~m~~~m~~m~~amp$~~~~~bullbull~M~a~~~~~~m lIt~~~~grrtJ(Iplusmn~j7g$m~ 0

~~b - Jlt tfR-~ BN$~lL~~~~JH~ ~l5lf~~~ Jm~ifBaJfJ ~imW $~m~~~~~~$l5lm~~~~o

lNJH~ $f7J~Af1~~~ N~it~$~a~~~ftpfT~~ f ~1JDjJ~ Jt~~JH~~ 0

-9shy

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 7: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

shy I

Ii i --L shy i

degY~~MI~~~~~~~~~mm~~~~~B~~~~

~~~~~~~Mm~~m~Hm~~W~~Y~amp~~m~~~q~0~

V~W~~~~~Wm~~8yen~W~~~ti~~~ampmiddot~WBW~~ ~yenm~~~~~ID~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~amp~~~~~~secto~

~Yg~~f~1$ r ~n~~J ~tt~E1JYH~$~fbfbWti~l~ID ~~trDqnM1amp~ ampH~slz0~~ijWfEyen~ nM1amp~~WEEyenm~j ~~W-0~wFr

o ampnnl~JifE yen~~$nMyen~4=~-qIllID~~~~ID lW~Yijg~$~Jilm~~~ yenm~g

~~~_~yen~Y~~yen_Jilmm~~~~B~m~~~~~

o~Jif~yen~~~~~$yenm-~$~~-~~~m$

~W~Byen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~V~~

deglW~ Yyen~$~~~m~~yenm~g~H~_~yen~Y~~yen_JiI

mm~~~~B~m~~~~~IDmiddot~U~~m~~middotM~~

deglW~YByen~m$yenm-~~~m~fu

~~WfuByen-WY-Jilmm~~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~ oyen~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~~yen~M~m~Wyen~Y~~~~E~m~~~~m~~

~~~~Ufu~~bullbullm~WB~~~~~M~~~~~~N lW~~~~$yenm-~yen-~Jilmm~~~-m~M~~~~~~~~~

olU~Jif~~~nt~~$nMyenmWti sect~~~~~m~~~yenm~g~H~~yenbullbullY~B~~~~ ~WMm~~~~~ID~~~_~~~~~~JiIbullbull~~~N

oyen~JifByen~~~~$$yenm-~~~

(poundZ)

(24)

f---+------+----j-----t---j----+------r------I

x o

o o o

o x ( o

o x x x

111 tl5 ~

8

(25 )n=-~~~~~mff~~~~~~~

( ~~~i~~1m~~ J

a~~m~I~~ffa~~~h=-~~~ffMampffig~

ffi~I~Wm~~~~m~~~mAmbullbull Dffimff~~~m~~~ ~H~bullbull$~wnm~W~~~Nmm~fi~~~~RMft~m~ ~~~mm~m~0~~Hm~~~~tt~m~M~MMW~5li~I fF 0 n~JJHT~bullbull~fsect$fJ~M~~-= 0

-=- JJlAtJ( 1amp -pound ~~EIlbj i-4--k-tt

JJl1=r$~ plusmn Jl J73 ~ ~ Z ~

921 tf(lUpoundfj1=r~ ~J

1~lttltttI 21iUnllrfjJfTm5EIimt~

IffiH 3llX tHI~Jlmtt H~Ptbsectra~Ii03llt~J1i 5tt~tf(sect~mm~~ It jJjJf)Ut~li

I ~5IUUdl~ g~HI~UIH1mH fiJ ~Ptbm 5E 2$mf~Ff~~ ~AE-N 3~111flUtMz=1-5E~~ 4=1 1IJ ~ ~Jlt~HJII JJrt ~~ bull ~ij~1f IlN ( fI JJrt l tt fl Ii 1Bl$mff~ )

5fljiJEJ01tI~5Inf~tf(sect~B9ltjpli~li Mz1m $1f~mJllJ1[iIl~

921 tf( ~ft~1[iIl~ 1J1J~

1 1[ fT mBHIl1=r 1t JlIJ m5EIi 1[iIlmt~

2 ill lzJili ~ tItiHft ~~ 3 m Jfill JlIJ ii 4mIDl1[iIl~ft

1fl9J~amp~$IIl~ ~fiti~1m~ij~ij~ ~ 0ffi1JlIl~

2fBtllJrn5E1W~ 1mplusmnIiJ$fEl 3fl1J rllJ~J 1m$1amp51sectraiIltm~OO~Ii 41m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ j1~tplusmnlt 5fj~ff1J~m~=1JE 6fj~ 13 iW JilE1[iIl~ftB91[Ji-- r 3llt~llUr~1llG J fJEj ~ij~i~

tf( f3t~1I1[iIlllt iampii IittllUlmllffi

---------shy

lmJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2~tf(~lIitm~~ 3mJlIJ t~~JIl1li 4~~~tf(~jilUlm 5~~fiM~tf(~ 6ilHfj~i$ rfjiJi 3( ~ 7[5fRltf( ~1fplusmntt~~ --------------------_ -

I fIji1[~ tf( 2fIji1[~tf(~ ffij~~~OOmifi~fI 3D~ 1Jj~$~ EI ~JIltlIUl~~ ffij~~~~mIDII

ii4~liff~~JI

R~~a~~ffig$fJ~~M~fim~~mff~bullbull~I~~~$ ~m~~~m~~m~~amp$~~~~~bullbull~M~a~~~~~~m lIt~~~~grrtJ(Iplusmn~j7g$m~ 0

~~b - Jlt tfR-~ BN$~lL~~~~JH~ ~l5lf~~~ Jm~ifBaJfJ ~imW $~m~~~~~~$l5lm~~~~o

lNJH~ $f7J~Af1~~~ N~it~$~a~~~ftpfT~~ f ~1JDjJ~ Jt~~JH~~ 0

-9shy

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 8: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(24)

f---+------+----j-----t---j----+------r------I

x o

o o o

o x ( o

o x x x

111 tl5 ~

8

(25 )n=-~~~~~mff~~~~~~~

( ~~~i~~1m~~ J

a~~m~I~~ffa~~~h=-~~~ffMampffig~

ffi~I~Wm~~~~m~~~mAmbullbull Dffimff~~~m~~~ ~H~bullbull$~wnm~W~~~Nmm~fi~~~~RMft~m~ ~~~mm~m~0~~Hm~~~~tt~m~M~MMW~5li~I fF 0 n~JJHT~bullbull~fsect$fJ~M~~-= 0

-=- JJlAtJ( 1amp -pound ~~EIlbj i-4--k-tt

JJl1=r$~ plusmn Jl J73 ~ ~ Z ~

921 tf(lUpoundfj1=r~ ~J

1~lttltttI 21iUnllrfjJfTm5EIimt~

IffiH 3llX tHI~Jlmtt H~Ptbsectra~Ii03llt~J1i 5tt~tf(sect~mm~~ It jJjJf)Ut~li

I ~5IUUdl~ g~HI~UIH1mH fiJ ~Ptbm 5E 2$mf~Ff~~ ~AE-N 3~111flUtMz=1-5E~~ 4=1 1IJ ~ ~Jlt~HJII JJrt ~~ bull ~ij~1f IlN ( fI JJrt l tt fl Ii 1Bl$mff~ )

5fljiJEJ01tI~5Inf~tf(sect~B9ltjpli~li Mz1m $1f~mJllJ1[iIl~

921 tf( ~ft~1[iIl~ 1J1J~

1 1[ fT mBHIl1=r 1t JlIJ m5EIi 1[iIlmt~

2 ill lzJili ~ tItiHft ~~ 3 m Jfill JlIJ ii 4mIDl1[iIl~ft

1fl9J~amp~$IIl~ ~fiti~1m~ij~ij~ ~ 0ffi1JlIl~

2fBtllJrn5E1W~ 1mplusmnIiJ$fEl 3fl1J rllJ~J 1m$1amp51sectraiIltm~OO~Ii 41m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ j1~tplusmnlt 5fj~ff1J~m~=1JE 6fj~ 13 iW JilE1[iIl~ftB91[Ji-- r 3llt~llUr~1llG J fJEj ~ij~i~

tf( f3t~1I1[iIlllt iampii IittllUlmllffi

---------shy

lmJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2~tf(~lIitm~~ 3mJlIJ t~~JIl1li 4~~~tf(~jilUlm 5~~fiM~tf(~ 6ilHfj~i$ rfjiJi 3( ~ 7[5fRltf( ~1fplusmntt~~ --------------------_ -

I fIji1[~ tf( 2fIji1[~tf(~ ffij~~~OOmifi~fI 3D~ 1Jj~$~ EI ~JIltlIUl~~ ffij~~~~mIDII

ii4~liff~~JI

R~~a~~ffig$fJ~~M~fim~~mff~bullbull~I~~~$ ~m~~~m~~m~~amp$~~~~~bullbull~M~a~~~~~~m lIt~~~~grrtJ(Iplusmn~j7g$m~ 0

~~b - Jlt tfR-~ BN$~lL~~~~JH~ ~l5lf~~~ Jm~ifBaJfJ ~imW $~m~~~~~~$l5lm~~~~o

lNJH~ $f7J~Af1~~~ N~it~$~a~~~ftpfT~~ f ~1JDjJ~ Jt~~JH~~ 0

-9shy

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 9: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(25 )n=-~~~~~mff~~~~~~~

( ~~~i~~1m~~ J

a~~m~I~~ffa~~~h=-~~~ffMampffig~

ffi~I~Wm~~~~m~~~mAmbullbull Dffimff~~~m~~~ ~H~bullbull$~wnm~W~~~Nmm~fi~~~~RMft~m~ ~~~mm~m~0~~Hm~~~~tt~m~M~MMW~5li~I fF 0 n~JJHT~bullbull~fsect$fJ~M~~-= 0

-=- JJlAtJ( 1amp -pound ~~EIlbj i-4--k-tt

JJl1=r$~ plusmn Jl J73 ~ ~ Z ~

921 tf(lUpoundfj1=r~ ~J

1~lttltttI 21iUnllrfjJfTm5EIimt~

IffiH 3llX tHI~Jlmtt H~Ptbsectra~Ii03llt~J1i 5tt~tf(sect~mm~~ It jJjJf)Ut~li

I ~5IUUdl~ g~HI~UIH1mH fiJ ~Ptbm 5E 2$mf~Ff~~ ~AE-N 3~111flUtMz=1-5E~~ 4=1 1IJ ~ ~Jlt~HJII JJrt ~~ bull ~ij~1f IlN ( fI JJrt l tt fl Ii 1Bl$mff~ )

5fljiJEJ01tI~5Inf~tf(sect~B9ltjpli~li Mz1m $1f~mJllJ1[iIl~

921 tf( ~ft~1[iIl~ 1J1J~

1 1[ fT mBHIl1=r 1t JlIJ m5EIi 1[iIlmt~

2 ill lzJili ~ tItiHft ~~ 3 m Jfill JlIJ ii 4mIDl1[iIl~ft

1fl9J~amp~$IIl~ ~fiti~1m~ij~ij~ ~ 0ffi1JlIl~

2fBtllJrn5E1W~ 1mplusmnIiJ$fEl 3fl1J rllJ~J 1m$1amp51sectraiIltm~OO~Ii 41m$1f~~5Itt r~fiJ j1~tplusmnlt 5fj~ff1J~m~=1JE 6fj~ 13 iW JilE1[iIl~ftB91[Ji-- r 3llt~llUr~1llG J fJEj ~ij~i~

tf( f3t~1I1[iIlllt iampii IittllUlmllffi

---------shy

lmJllJ~tf(~jiii~mi 2~tf(~lIitm~~ 3mJlIJ t~~JIl1li 4~~~tf(~jilUlm 5~~fiM~tf(~ 6ilHfj~i$ rfjiJi 3( ~ 7[5fRltf( ~1fplusmntt~~ --------------------_ -

I fIji1[~ tf( 2fIji1[~tf(~ ffij~~~OOmifi~fI 3D~ 1Jj~$~ EI ~JIltlIUl~~ ffij~~~~mIDII

ii4~liff~~JI

R~~a~~ffig$fJ~~M~fim~~mff~bullbull~I~~~$ ~m~~~m~~m~~amp$~~~~~bullbull~M~a~~~~~~m lIt~~~~grrtJ(Iplusmn~j7g$m~ 0

~~b - Jlt tfR-~ BN$~lL~~~~JH~ ~l5lf~~~ Jm~ifBaJfJ ~imW $~m~~~~~~$l5lm~~~~o

lNJH~ $f7J~Af1~~~ N~it~$~a~~~ftpfT~~ f ~1JDjJ~ Jt~~JH~~ 0

-9shy

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 10: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(26 )

2~Jl~Qt~ Jtg1Jf~WJ fplusmnliiUJlbi~slH~- ft~fplusmnliiUIlftfi$ 1W~lE~5IfF ~~fiEl3prz~H-~1KtEMpound1lf 1W~ft~~rzfplusmnWl~~~j 0

3~lUJl j~Jflz -ilplusmnWl tpOJfj~~fl ~1~1I1fflflyen19l1 Pfi~lz2 r plusmnIi 1ffl~~~J ~1Jf~m~~fiflyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWl1Jf~m~m~~~J ~ fplusmnWlmrn~~flyen~Pfi~lz2rfplusmnWlmrn~~J~amp~~sectfi~2sect~W~ m~a~amp~bullbull~Aj~~- m~fl~~~M~bullbullfplusmnWlm~~m ~2~o

4JJl1Wft~g fplusmnliI~OJfj~EI3przAre1lf WiampJfif ilrm ~lIIa~tlJ~~ 5[~~sectaflfU1Jrtu iITi~rz~~OJfj~~ielRJ iyenJJJ~~mruU1i~ 0

s~m~~~2ampmfi~~~~~~~~bullbullbull~~rm~n~ iampJfif1TiampbullbullPfifjM~_~A mruU1i~~mOJfj~Jfmililfi1WW1 OJfj~ilshyM1~ft~tljml5t 0

5jty~~fyenj JltpPmAplusmn~~rm~tU ~rz~ME~7m~fj 0

6pm~mm -fplusmnWltp~~mml5tamp~ffi1RJ Prz~OJfj~1Z91i1A~~miSl ~~bi~~w~ bi~B~A~m~bullbull~~iITimmfplusmnWlm milo

~~~ ~~~~~~Jf~$~wm~~~~z~~~~milregm-M1m~M ~o

l~zJfDlyenljiil1Tm~~fjtpyen1~ampJtg1JiampJfif(1Pfi) tp~Jtg1JiampJtgiamp ~Pfi mrn~~~Il~~~ mm~bullbullUlyenljitEm1W~~-ml5tr ~iampJfif~fj~~lz r lyenl-li1D J ~M~~Ajl~~$ 0

2ffiIlyenljiJf~~1W~~ mrn~ffibi~~ampil1T M1J11JJtg~ilf1lift~~f1 m1it tsectn1~A~Jfllt1Tiamp~~I)j3~ sectj~HBm~~llwmilIfF 0

3mil~~~~fl j)mrn~~mf9lJ ~friJm1ltfI m-bullbulljUmiddot~ m-bullbull~ Em~~ bullbullbullA~m~hfriJl5t~fplusmnliIWl~oam~~~~biJtg ~ biJtgm~ ~~ft~ ~~~w~ ~j jJtg~~ampm~~~ ~j~mbltlDaJjH~Jfsect $tmflfU1J~ 0

~~~ ~~~~M~bi~rm2~~~~fplusmnWl~tp~hbi~rm ~~m-1WPfio

lbi~rmBitt~ bi~rm~JB~-~1a] ~fj~-1BmmciITi fUllAB~itt~ Ami m~~JjUi P~~~tlJl~1Jf~H~IJlgfl ampJlrmB1Wltt~~mf~~ 0

2biilrm1Whjtit nl~51mi~~JIbullbull~JfJI~$t M1JDJm~~~rfl~~1m

bi~~~~~M~MWfFil1T~~~~rmB1WhfFftaJflo 3bi~rm1W~~Ilplusmn2~Il~mtEr~1JfJrAJ2~Il~~

~bullbull2~~~~~~rAJie~Pfi~m~~~rm~rzmm~~ bullbull~ilrm2~~sect~Pfi~m~flbullbullIZ9U~Ru~~rmmM~ ~~~ftt(WlJ3~1ijjtit~$Wlmffl 013

10 shy

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 11: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

n=-~~m~~~ff~~m~~~ (27)

~-lZ9 lIf~ij FjJU~A tzOmt~fmB~~ ~1J~~iUlt ~Um~ltftB~fmt~tA tbhijM~~fplusmn~It~ msectiWltftB~fm~AZ~fditsectIfg~ 0

l~fmli tt~~famp ~Wlmtt~1JmB~Jrim~ ~~Jmtl0m 1999 ~~bullbull~W~~~~~n~m~fi~mm~bullbull~~8~amp ~aitlrf ~1famp91~~ilA 0

2~~A~~ ~~tHplusmnliIi5t~1RJ ~~tbhWJZ~fm~~Qj)fnJftm)w~~~B gZ~~WJi5~Bo

3J~~1mB$yenfI~ ~~cp$~fm~Jlt~tt~~cp$yenm amp~tt~tflt~t7 W1milfiftfampmI~~It~~~ffin~~~~~JW~bullbullbullJ ~$jt~o

4jIlj fS~~QtzOfnJf)t~ ~Jtf~~~fmlY-JjIlj fSf)t~f6~O~- ~Jl~~fmlY-JjIljfS~ tplusmnflm~~~Ij~fU~ fi~~Ul~tplusmnflm ~U~~fm~fl1JW~~U6bfj~~ ~R fi5EUl~fu~~rJ~ ~U~~~RXtf5l~~~kJ1MZtflrEfJ~ 0

~-K ~~~~M~~m~~mlimm~mm~amp~~~mA~It~IY-J~~CP

~1t~lY-JtbhWJ~mW~Mlimtbh~~~M~~RXIt~m1Jo liNfirdl~J)~-3amp tttfJj1L=-~It~f1fi~WIJ~1i+-=1~m~ r ~1iI

Ji5~~~~~~mlimZIRJ~~It~~mW~~mW65EZm~ampItplusmntt mm~1t~fI ~M~m~5l~m~wplusmnttmiddotmiddotmiddot J ltCPfiti~tl~li9~Ji~~~ ~m~m~J)~-~~~~1m~-~~~~~M~~o

27Pamp~m~m~~ ~-1m~~tplusmnWlCP 7Pamp~~ZiNfif1Ujl$U+j)J ~~W~~m~m~8tbh~~M~~~~o

3WiNfira~flfift Ji5jX1~ilfi~~ ~~~~-ItUl tQ]fj~~~=1t Ul~~~=EUlmm~~IY-Ji5t~-~fi~m~~~fI~t~~o

~- ~~jf~iJf ~~fiHpoundfnJJlY-Jmw tbh~~jJF~ ~1t~famp~~fJj~m ~~~~IY-J~tlmiddotm~~ww~fnJ~J~W~~~RIt~

IY-Jn o

lJi5~1Jw It~W~1~~J~Rm-=B1i+ -=B1i+~~~~ ERiB~~IfFfj~1JJjl(I~fj~1J~1Jl ~~~fj~1Jjtjj~rj~~fU~ ~WlI~ ~$f7 1iti14~

2Ji5~IiW Ji5~~CPBiiE1Jl~ Jlt$f711Jl~~fit~WJfJ 1F1Q~ iL~JlOO B~m~~~w ~RX~~Ji5~JiOOfj 0

3~IIiM1t~f~pt ~m5ElI~~Q]Iil]mt~h5I~m~~kfifli~~ Ji5Sf~~ fIlJ~~QtzDfnJfljffl 0

4fi~Jih51~XfampJi5Q]~~~mm~~OO~~iNfi~ttbullbullh5I~

~IY-J~jl tzD~fm~$n14~~R1gfUIY-J~m~ ~1J~~RX~~ltiUr~~ 1J~~If~ 0

- 11shy

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 12: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(28)

tE~fJ1JHjIUIHI iJiIJ B9 ~litr liff~f6m sect ftI~~zB9~iJiIJ -sectm~llfiiJ IJamp 5Ilim bullbull~~ft~~ml~~fiiJfi~Z~m~tE~~OO~fiiJ~~~ ili i~~OfiiJMttfJ J)amp~llfiiJs f~raWAplusmn~1irJi liff~f6mml~iJiIJZ~0

itJJJ)mJUIlbullbullbullm~lY3ftmlHraquo1i bull secttEmMH~fitpJJltlts fAWbullbull~mtp ~lftfJ~~~J)sl~rdjbullbullbullft~~ml ~lt bull liff~HtlHmft~~J)~1~~bullbull0

mlIfFJfffMJJjqI~fJ ( JIl=) llz~m1lJlJ)~f~mlll ~UfIgbullbullIIJ~J)~PirD Htt~jJf~fZIJ)lJampsf~rdjbullbullml l~~fjJlfjtlt f~lUm~Fffi~ ~ttBml~1ime~It Ht~~~~mB9mmtfi~~~1j MlHtIHJj JlZmf~lIm~iJiIJ ~1jHlmIfFfIga~IJflJh bull ~~liff~m~itiU~lzZ~~1j m ~itiUm~~~[9

m ~iJ ff Ifj fI illJ fI illJ Ii lI6

11l1~ tbb WIf 1iG h~m~euroiflillJ h~mbullbull~~~n~~tbb~~R

2 JHENJ~Ii~I 11 slflll( 11=) _mil1JitbbWlfflillJ ~~1iG~~~~bullbull~W~Ii~

31l1~~I1ir Ii ~ tbbil1ffffliflillJ ~~~~fffflih~tbb~~~1~tbb ~~~IR~fJj

4~~J~fiD~III~~R fiD~milRflillJ ~euroiil~~ ~~~m ~~ ~m euroiw1iG~Jm~AfiD~

5~IUJi~1Ji~A ~ilim~AflillJ iI~flbullbullil1Jislfl~Rm~~~7 11m

6~7~im1lm lImmftflillJ ~7bullbull~~lIm~m~~

7J~~11~JHJfjij ~jijEtt fl1iG ~11f1illJ ~7rtMPo 1JD1IJampM~

8a~Ii~~-BiJl a~liilfllliU ffi~~~~~~~-~Ii~~~m~w iIHil(l1l

9m~ffi~i)Ulii ffUfI illJ Bi JI Vit~ ilRBiJl$tlI~~Ff

- 12 shy

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 13: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

pound1shy

o

B

itfi

1 itmJlr I middot------

1 I (6Z)

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 14: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(30) iJIhi J3ilJt 1iIJEii

8 fjFfI

middot1 Jamp~MU~fjFf

+fjFf 2

1t~~ff~UmZyenMI t

~ru~ ~

fgFf3 J~]l1mMbltlj

fjFf

lyenFf4 ffil1mZyenA

fjFf I I

t

1I1f- 1 It Ull-lIlf-iiLll fjpf 1-1 ilMMHcfjpf ~~~eiH5- 3i~D~ 921 Sl~151~IHcSl~1t751~m

~751~~~~151~zil~~~OO~rr~~o~~ft151~~~ ~il1Jf bull ~U~fjpf 1-2 Ll3J 0

- 14

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 15: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

-SI shy

LSE ---lt

ojft

H~g~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~L~WHbullbull~~~-bullbull E1~fi$fqif~Y4lltr7~ UfeinU1~~ lJtlii~0if~~~MiStljHlmm ~bullbullbull~~01Jtlii~~~bullbull~~~o~L~W~EE~~~~0R bullbullbull~~ bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~~~~bullbull~~~~E~~iStlJtlii~0 ~I~M

omM~~~~~~m~MWplusmn~WU~~~

W~~~bullbullm~0bullbull~5~bullbull~~~~~~E~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~o$~bullbull~~~~~~~bullbull~~ ~0 y~~-bullbull~~~mfitf -plusmnYjft~ r 4~lftliE=tJ ~ r 4V~

fPIifbullbull~ntrE~J ~ r 4V~ifE~J ~~f~- ~iStbullbull~~ pound-1 ~M ifiiff pound-1 ~isecttUfitf 11~~1inm~~~ij

fu~~~bullbull~~bullbullbullW~~E~-~lii~~~o~~W~bull bull ~f~~~bullbull~bullbull~~~mm~m4yen~~~a~mw 0~U~~W~~~~f~M~~bullbull~~~~~iStbullbull~m ~1~M (If)

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 16: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(32)

~Vf 2 ~4-tt11~filjif~Jtft mft 2-1 2-3 ijlztJl~Wmfifii

1-tp9ifiifjiij~~fi~JlUB9JJE lSfl~ijlz~~ij ~~tJl~J

~2EB tE~mijffib~mjJJ~~fi3tNU~ bull iIIHl~Aplusmn~RlZij~fiVij f~flWm ijlS~ lS~~A~ffibilW~iI~f1j~~ij~gij~1t ~lTtsectglS~fff~m1amp tie tB~A~ bull ilRlZ~J~ 0

3~~RlZ~iI~~ ~zjJI3tlaj~RlZ fJJ~ijm~~1tzf$WA~~O~

liooan~wzf$wmtibullbull~am~~f$~Mbullbulla~middot~ ~~~~~~ijti~~~~~~M~~RlZ~o

~fJ~JU~ ~ ~ W IK ~ W

vt~ ampw~~plusmn bullbull ~mg plusmnvtflifiiHf ~mvtflifi1 fi f4 ~1iiJ~1

~~I~ti$m ampw~~~~~~m mm ilt~~IiiJ~1 lJJJIKtflir l lIJIK lfJUffi tEl 11M f4 1iiJ~1 lJJJIKEfJlliiJ~1

i$f$iIlmm~ ampW~~i$f$tElIIMf4 WHfi tflifi1t

16IilFrIlO ampW~~16MlfmllMf4 IHjliiJ~at

fjft 2-4 mijtsectrUIll~ m~JH~~tE~mijtsectglS~mft Iim~B91iaf$trIlA~M m_R~M~fii~lS~tpm~mijIi~~mij$~fff~

1gtlff1JJ~RlZ U~r15W~tsectruJ~ruJ 0

2bull~A~ 0

3tplusmnWifJlH~ 0

4mtElrm~$3~iIA~ 0

5~W~mijzij~~~~W~~im 0

mft 2-5 ~Jiljl1JtJR3IEjl(ii~~~ EB~ffitplusmnB~lmtliltsectRmij3JfF aiO ~~iJjWRlZ~ bull ~j~~l) rB9~JlUrtJRjI 1 mijff-$9il~ 2~txjI1J~~~ (ffib~tibullbullbullgt)0 0

3tplusmn1l~~~~~ 0

4mij~IJUlm131amp~~ 0

- 16shy

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 17: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

n=-~~~~~mffbullbull~~M~~~ (33)

~Jt-~tif)cWWfii~mVff~

i fjFf= 2-1

t~m~tbb ilffUlbJi

t fjFf= 2-2

f1J ttg ]JUiu ~

t fjFf= 2-3

iR1Gfifi~Ji

t fjFf= 2-4

m~~1i IDI[~

t fjFf= 2-5

~~~~~t11J wH

~iJf 3 ~~~ifjtiJil~iJf

fjFf 3-1 flfftmi9ti flfftm~fsectlU1m9t bull m~7tWJJit9tJHHtHjmi bull fifiD ~JiltpoundiRlJjrdl1m$OO9t1mWm~jj$1t1i bull JllJfiDJilJifllIPs[ fflfjFf

3-2 ~rr 0

fjFf 3 -2 tftiittWlJ 19cJE ~m-sectbullbull9t$E~~rr~bullbullbulle~~$E~m~~$a~mtpound

$~ill~offi~7t~JEili~~~OO9tE~~$o~~e~~~

$fjFf~$~rr~m~Mo~-ffl~bullbullJJit9t~-

_ [l3J1IJffl~tfi~9tJlG~~9t a ~fsect~m~~~A 0

- 17 shy

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 18: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(34)

m ~ ~EIHm ilJfj~WIplusmnl~ ~ iii

~~- 8flil1oJ gpoundillm 8flil1oJil1oJ~M~~~_bullbullbullM~~ (fil1oJtgyenlpoundftffia1JE

m~= jfiMltltil gpoundillm~

bullbull ~bullbullM~_bullbull~~~Iplusmnl~bullbullbull mEil1oJ~~~yenI~bullbull~ili~Amillm Wg~~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~~ lil~~j1IJAJIJ~Ao

~~-= jfiMltIUl gpoundillmiampff bullbullbull~Imbullbullbull ~~~~j1IJ~~Iplusmnl~ iampff~oili-~Eil1oJ~~yenImiddot~Amil 1m~gpound~~~~A~illm~gpound~ff~ ~lil~~iampff~lil~~~Amo

~~gg jfiMltliil gpound _ iampff ~bullbull

~~~~~~~ ~mEil1oJ~~yenI~A ~illm~gpound~~~~A~ilImWg~~ ff~~~~~iampffW~bullbull~~~~~A ot o

~~=rumh~~~m~~~~~~A~W~~W~~~flM~A~~ a~~~~~~oom~o~~~~~~~~~~ ~n~

~UJJj~AttftB~~~WJ~WiJl~ 0

- 18 shy

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 19: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

61

o~~~ifM~iifEIWinlrm=tt~HWY1 EfyenJlttMm ~~IrrY1=fJ4~Wm~M~~rJ2~ff~mrl1fi$ 1lJ413rl1fif~ ~-v if~

o~

~~iifltrl~Y1 ~~-l=ifi~ID~~WHiW mJ~~~jzIii mJtsJ~zIii V-V if~ o q~ijfJr~MjJ~Y~ ~Y~

m~~~~~ bullbullY~m~~~~~~~bullbullbullf~~M~~ ~if~ orWifsectf(e

~YID~~Mm~bullbullI~~W~~fu~~~8M~~~MI~ Gtfmm~Ym~m~Y1m~i~~1PY1 lmmn~~ 1fi~lil~~m z-v if~

om~IlJ4~m

~M r m~~~J r ~~~~~~~J i2lJ18 ~ifmyen~ m~~~lifm I -v if~

~Gtfmm~~~wm~~~~~~mGtfm~sect

(if8 ~-tt V -In

C~)------- r

----8

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 20: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(36)

flIPJisect $shy ~mlJ4sect )ll sect rrr ~JU~ ~illUttell

rm~li iIE~Lm~ftamp_~ ~n_

ifit~ ItO lEi tj ~~if

1m~1fiB 1m

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp _19IJ ~t_ 1Sl-t Nj(jJU~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl 1Sl-t IJ~~ttj(m I~~if

Nj(fg~ ~iI~4tIfj

m~fJl Atif1f1Jt m mjifg~ ~iI~3lltIfj

m~fJl iIE~~~ftamp_19IJ ~-t_

ttj(~g1i~

ilmji$1 Njfg~ -iGttNj(

~HfJl~plusmn~ fJl

ZP~~lfUli19lJ~plusmn i1lli$mrHI~JE

~lJffJUf~ IIf Lm fJl ~11 sectrrrfl~m~~ bull tI3J~teurot~lIll

~~tmz~~mj(~~

if~fJl if~N$ ~lJ4NM~1I1f ~~fJlM~M

~~iltJlISl~ fJl

1m(~~iI~~j(IIf~~middot1m~ fmrJJfJg it(nlfilJ~LI ~11 )

j(iiJl)l~ 921 ~m~1rr fI~

fllliUi flJflll ~il18~o ~~JmJlllNlIlo

bull

bull

bull

+

mFf4-1

jI~fImijrmbull

mFf4-2

mmfl1M~UJ

mFf4-3

iJMm ~JiU~Uili

mFf4-4

ijll11U4

fjFf 4-5

~iUjft~JJgtUI

- 20shy

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 21: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

n=-~~~~~ff~~~~~ (37)

~IIf 5 -vH~IIf

sect~~aw~bullbull ~m~~~~mm~o

sect~~1 WMm~~~~~bullbull~M~~~bullbull~0~bullbullbullbull~~

sect~5~ ~~~~bullbull~~~M~~~fi~~a~~~~bullbull ~

~Llr31Umfltsectlffl~ ~f~tlB~~~~~~ ~U~7C~LlJ]Ut3~~ 0

1fi~ El3iampJampfijitlPfiflmm-~Jtf91J J1t1J~fifl~ sect

~fJ~51ttJf~~~~ ttwumf 0

2rdlfi~ El3iampJampjitI~m tJf~m~~~ft~Jtm sect~(5f~ fJ~~fE 0

~fyenli f~fii~fyen

f 5-]

Mi fti PJT lIlH~iHi i

~ 5-2

~f1~11~tiUb i

8 ~IIf 6 ~Jt-EJt~IIf sect~ 6-1 m~m~WM EI3DJil~Mm~~~1i)jtl~~$~m~JiHtHIWm

Jif~fU~ 0 tfM~~WmJif ~UiM=r~Arfj~ 6-20 fjFf 6-2 ~~~~~m~ WmJif~~~~~[EJ ~flJtfrj~ JJj~Mm~ ~

~~~m~ ~m~~~IHgm~~flj~ mf~1V 0

- 21 shy

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 22: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(38)

tl ~ VItN ~1iJ] J ~

tl~- lilmJUfi- iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3ilmj~-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

ri1ilmj~~sect EI iIii Ji iamp 1FJ ~ rAllI ampif~

Ii ~ tJ~ l( fit ~ il EI 11

ilmj~ampHft~ tJ~ ~~J3 ~tJ~ lJ il ~JlUr~~fit

tl~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I11 3bull~III1-if~ 4ilmj~-ttftllli~

W~~- r 10 lIs11i(f ~if~ri1~11111 ~~

~IIIU~Wif~

l(m~~lfG~ il mj~ illJHli iIiiJiffZi1JiiVlt N

~~= lilmj~-iamp1FJ 2ilmj~-~1I1t1 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~II-ttftllm~

_tl~=rIO(fWtt ftllli~i1JiiJri1~ IIIUUf

~lIl1tJ~~-~~rr~~i1Jii

bull ~ 1111 amp ~li tJ~ l( ~1i~fEHf

~~119 Iilmj~- ~1I1t1 2bull~1I-iamp1FJ 3bull~III1-if~ 4bull~III1-ttftllm~

ilmj~RlItl1 ~lIatt~ [~

lIaipound~

~~~jJRtfflj ~II bull mlJ J3 Ii~ amp fl( ft IH ~ ilfitW~1I1t1

fi~~3 m~~fi~~~I~~~m~bullbullbullbullgo f~~ 6-4 ~mmiddotlig~W$~ll ~ 921 ~~~m~bullbullbullbullfjt1Jfg B~W-ttB

ttBtffjrllljJfiiY(1iU~fj7EjJtIjpound~Jiij [ffl ~ttBm1JAIIg 0

Gp

fll 6-3 fJl 6-4

JJi ttll7ltl1 fJm~Bf

- 22shy

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 23: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

iipound~yij~iI

~-L ~~J

~$~ilm

pound-L~m

t J$Ir~~miipoundmt

l-L ~~J

t ~

Iiir~j1yeniLij ~

t-L~m

Sf

t

o if~gij OM fillii fi~~gijE1~$ 0 fill~fillY-1g~fill-=F~~yenIiijlilifnt fill-=F~~yenUijlifJ2Qr pound-L tl~

o if~ pound-L tliSiUfiM fillti~~$ 0 Iif~

fill~fill~E1Nm~~R~g~filltim2Qr~m~~~Mif~m~~ii 4i fPf~~-amptfill-=F~~~OM fillii~ EI filliiHifillti$E$ tliSi~~~M l-L tl~

o if~l-L tlmufiM fillti~fill-=Fij~$ l fill -=Fij~~Sl1 iIfiyen~Ii OMf(~~flJlliijf(lilbkY-1W fill -=Fjgfif 1-L tl~

Ifl1~~f-ijf ~ L iflf

(6pound)

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 24: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(40)

~l~ad~m~bullbullbullbullbullA~~~~~~~BmbullbullRbullbullM~ m~bullbull~bullbull~~ft~~bullbull~bullbull~mB~~Dbullbullbullbull~ffi$ffi ~~~madftM~~~~~~ff~W~~~ft~~o~W~~~~~

~~~$ID~Abullbull~W~m~~~bullbullbullA~~S~~M~a~~ ~~~~~~B bullbullbull~~M~~~~~I~~I~~~amp~~~~~m ~o~ft bullbull~bullbull~~~~~~~A~mbullbull~mad~R ffMW~~~bullbull ~bullbull~0~e~~S~~~MW~bullbullbullbullbullff~

W5~ffUlJJruj0amp 11 ~W~lIlmW5~ 0

~~~~m~~~~ma~~~ttttbullbull~~~~~ftm ~~~bullbull~m~bullbull~bullbullmfi~adnbullbullbull~~m~~~n~0~ lE1m~~~$~ ~bullbull~~~JL~if~fI~mbullbull~~ifllJl~1NltJL

~ao~~W5~m~S~~~~ffi~~~bullbull middot~~~~~~bullbullM ~WtmtJ~~m~ 0 sectWJ~m31311m~mJh~Jlt~~M18~~~ ~mwltt

~W5~Jltm~~m~m~~A~~~bullbullm~B~mbullbull~ bullbullt~o

sectWJ~~1~fiR~m~m~a~~ft~0ISfI~middot~M

~tt~m~~fIbullbullm~AmI~~~~~~fimiddotru~~mm~~mw ~~~~18~~~~x~bullbull~~~~~~ bullbullbull~bullbullm~~ m~bullbull~o~~bullbull~~n~~~~~fimI~o

ffMbullbullmI~~~Jltru~n~A~fi~~mmiddot~ffB~Mfi ~jJPlm~fi~~~ ru~m~~IL~fIAtbullbullfum oxbullbullru ~~W~bullbull~filll~fiffimmiddot~~~~~A~ffAB~Mfi fI~o =bullbullbullbulltJ~11fI~JltffU Htft~11~~~~~fi~~Iib~fflU ~ij~18tt ~bullbullbullbullbullJltffU~~~mbullbullbullfiwadMnbullbullbull~~o

-~~~M~m~~~18~m~M~~~~~~pmd

tJ~umIfP~~fi 0

1m fi~~~~~~~1Jamp51~r~m tJmmfll ~fll~~1Jamp5[~ra~ ~mM~mmm~~~mm$~amp~~~~~~~

f~m~~Wim~d 0

n~~m~~m~~~~~fi~~~mffl~~~18~pound~~ffl itEadllJl~-~~o

- 24

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 25: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(41)n=-~mm~~~ff~~m~~~

( ~~3t1lX J lpqiamplIi( 1999) bull ft= -1lJJltJUlBlI01J 0

2pqiamplIi(1999) bull It=-JJlt~Zl5IiMJ1i 0

3pqiamp$(1999) bull It=-MU~ifullJJlt~IiMjf(itMJD 0

4pqiamplIi(I999) bull JJf~tlilliMjfpqi~rampfFmfB 0

5pqiamplIi(I999) bull It=-IlJJfJJfilM~1f$fFmJE 0

6 pq iamplIi( 1999) It=-ifullZtlM~fJJIiM~IJ~II5 0

7pqiamplIi(1999) JJf~UOti)(rtJ)amptlilliMmlJJ~A~II~1i 0

8Biamp~(1999) MttfjmftUf1M~fJJzi1llmJErl~yenoom- Biamp~JJf~IiMmlJJ~AitMm bull 9pqiamplIi(l999) ~IU~IlJJf ilIrtJl1jJJfltl1fiJf~~ii- pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull lOpqiamp$(t999)921 ~~ifullM~fJJIlsectItI1f pqiamplIiM~iJf~Pfi bull 11~3iiW( 1997) (miful1Htll~~~7tfi--3~~~) bull m=1iIii ~rullililii middot pp651-6 12iftRJIt(2000) bull ~ra~~ilIrtJJ~JJfilliM-~3fJ~IJz~Mbull iampifuiamplyenTliiplusmn~Jt bull

(it l J IJtbullbull~pqiamplIiitMW~RiJf~r~IJJf~M~mW~z~~~Jz$re~ 2 middotiamprayenifuiamp~~f5f l1BjImpflJJilUlitflllIJlI~f5fmiddota-Jttt1iyen~Mm~MIlii iampifuiamplyenTmplusmnJHiJf~

t 3~1tI1f~~bullbullrtJbullbull~~ItI1fil~~7187iIItI~~sect7~w~msectW~amp~~M~m ~~-=$re Mi~~mM~fJJflltw(BiampiI~Z~ mMZU bull fR~8U bull M~fFft8U FIHU~ bull ZJiwHfJlII8U liwHfj lIIZg~~sect~BUt7tfimiddot ~fJJPJbullbullbull~ 3t-JlPjlW iI~tSZl5ZiH~lIW~91J-W~middot =5~Ik 8773() JltfllijfJJ1i5t~P)IUIM~fJJ1IitHJJzfJ~ W-ft61~rg~ttl r Zl5~J r-1aJ bull

4 lpqM~i1Il~jfzmJE~61I 63 fFpJfttlE5tmJE1ampM~ttfimllIJrp Zft(pound611 71 fF1t1lit~tMttl~ ~ (pound611 78 fF3t-1t1lit~jtM~~ iilrJU~I 86 fFtpoundfjtMttll1lJ McM~iJf~PfittlItl1f~M~fJJmz mIDPJ~~bull m~ttlifft~UIJ7 0

5-~oo~M~fJJ(pound~fi~Im~JlP~~f1M~fJJIyenT~~z~ifu~tt~filtl1fmiddotlpq-~~~M~fJJM~

W~~Bifubullbull~Mc~~~~ifu~ttl~ttmiddotoo~MM~(poundm~jf~~flltmJE~~m~ifubullbull~ ~ii-W~fjr-~~Wr-~~~ZJlt(pound~fR~1f~~rpr-~~~R~~W~~fR~jfZ~tto

6 (poundifullrpIlJjMWi61UitiIttMttl~~f171tJlJ ~~~~MfJJttl~ 0lJtD~tjIpoundmJJfmttlitimU ~~middot~MitimrtJ~~rpUttlbullbull ZJi~~~amp~tjlrtJttl~~~~R~IIJjM~~~oo itimUttl~~5rp~amp~rp~ttl~~~~ifun~~~~IIJjM~~middot bullbullM~Pfittl~~MD )F (poundR~IIJjMWifll~1i1ifuilttlM~fJJ~lUllljlJ~~1ftttl1~ D)fIIJjM~~~M~fJJ1)JlIIttlIi~ ~o

7 bullbullM~PfittlItl~MD)F~m~fJJrp61~~~~M~~~~~~MfF71if~~=~Jlt ~~~~mM~ttlmll~bullbull~1ir-~laquoffig~jf~I~m~r-ampsectttlm~middot~~mllti fjrmmiddot

8 l3M~~z~Miim~it~~jf jtm~jtL$mM~ JfIJ~~i~~~f1jtflmJiJj i~ifu ~~M~tlIDW~middot~~-m~~~~~OO~~~~~~m-JiJ~mtt~~~$M~m $ramllllmtt~B~~fJ~ bull

9~~TOO~m~ttl~~~~ttzfjm~mttlfj~~~~m~Ilg~tt~~~~~ti oo~Jg~bullbull

10 EB~-~(pound1iQ~M~ Miij~F~fRlyenTiItttl~ ~mM~~sect1fflIJJZilm ~Bt~~VJ~jf

- 25 shy

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 26: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(42)

~~yen~~M~~~m~~~fi~~fim~~~o l1~m~m~n~~~~~~plusmn~bullbull~~~~~~~~plusmn~oom~m~~~~plusmnB

ffJJl3fH~m fI~~flPA~~JtIbullbullmit~ taplusmn~1ftki6II~~ieUyenlc~middotmiddotmiddot ~lf ol5il

12~mmI~~~~~~~~~mI~~~~~~bullbullI~~m~o 13 1E1EtjJ1tln~~~$tlJ~1+1~~mm=IlE 1lt~~$tlJ~1 +1~~mm=1oJlt ~itl~ n=-1tl~~1tl~~mE~w~~~~~mo

14W~~~m1tl~ft~~~~~$~~~T~~$~middotm~~~~~~fl~~~~o~~~~ Jft(2000)~rdl~Wi$$JI~~sm-S~~~~IM 0

- 26

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy

Page 27: a~.~.m~I~~.ff,a~.~~h=-.~.~~ff.M&ffig.~,nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/bitstream/140.119/8592/2/land_159.pdf~=-.~.~~m~.ff.~~.~.• ~n (19 ) ~."~~~."@~~.~li~~~~~'~.~~~*Bm'~*~.~~wzm .~.~~~' ••

(43)n=-~~~~~~tt~~~~~~

A Discussion on Building Damage Reshysponsibility and Reconstruction Mechanshy

ism of the 921 Earthquake

Chin-Oh Chang Chien-Wen Peng Ding-Shuan Chang

Keyword 921 Earthquake Building Damage Responsibility Reconshy

struction Mechanism

Abstract

This research tries to establish a more efficient procedure to clarify the responsibility of

building damage in the 921 earthquake We found that most buildings damages were cause

by natural disaster but still few had deficiencies in the stage of design construction or

usage Besides since the mechanisms provided by government were not enough to encourshy

age the speed of reconstruction we also establish some principles and in accordance mechshy

anisms of reconstruction

The authors are Professor Department of Land Economics National Chengchi University Assistant Professor Department of Real Estate Management Sez-Hai Institute of Technology and Commerce Department of Public Finance Lecturer Jin Wen Institute ofTechno[ogy

- 27shy