- Home
Documents
- Ausgabe 1.2017 fin - Bonner Rechtsjournal€¦ · ehvrqghuv ghxwolfk ehl m 6w*% ghu lq ghu 6wudi...
6
'HU QHXH M 6W*% ,P -DKU JDE HV EHGHXWVDPH bQGHUXQJHQ LP GHXW JXQJ 9HUJHZDOWLJXQJ³ EHWLWHOWH 6W*% ZXUGH HU K|UW DXFK GLH (LQIJXQJ HLQHU QHXHQ 6WUDIQRUP PLW GHU hEHUVFKULIW Ä6WUDIWDWHQ DXV *UXSSHQ³ M 6W*% 'LH Ä:HU HLQH 6WUDIWDW GDGXUFK I|UGHUW GDVV HU VLFK DQ HLQHU 3HUVRQHQ JUXSSH EHWHLOLJW GLH HLQH DQGHUH 3HUVRQ ]XU %HJHKXQJ HLQHU 6WUDIWDW DQ LKU EHGUlQJW ZLUG PLW )UHLKHLWVVWUDIH ELV ]X ]ZHL -DKUHQ RGHU PLW *HOGVWUDIH EHVWUDIW ZHQQ YRQ HLQHP %HWHLOLJWHQ GHU *UXSSH HLQH 6WUDIWDW QDFK GHQ RGHU L EHJDQJHQ ZLUG XQG GLH 7DW QLFKW LQ DQ GHUHQ 9RUVFKULIWHQ PLW VFKZHUHUHU 6WUDIH EHGURKW LVW³ 'HU +LQWHUJUXQG GLHVHU (UZHLWHUXQJ GHV $EVFKQLWWV 'DV EHWUlFKWOLFKH $XVPD GHU YRU DOOHP YRQ 0LJUDQWHQ 3DUODPHQWDULVFKHQ 8QWHUVXFKXQJVDXVVFKXVV GHV /DQG WDJV 15: 38$ ,96LOYHVWHUQDFKW GRNXPHQWLHUW 'LH |IIHQWOLFKH (PS|UXQJ KDW GD]X EHLJHWUDJHQ GDVV DXFK EHL GHQ $EJHRUGQHWHQ GHV 'HXWVFKHQ %XQGHVWDJV VHU ]X VFKW]HQ ,P 6RPPHU NDP HV ]X EHUSDU WHLOLFKHQ hEHUHLQNQIWHQ GLH ]X HLQHU VFKQHOOHQ 5HIRUP QHQ *HVHW]HQWZXUI GHU %XQGHVUHJLHUXQJ JHJHEHQ GHU LQ 'LH $XWRULQ LVW ,QKDEHULQ GHV /HKUVWXKOV IU 6WUDIUHFKW 6WUDISUR ]HVVUHFKW 5HFKWVYHUJOHLFKXQJ XQG 5HFKWVSKLORVRSKLH DQ GHU +XP EROGW8QLYHUVLWlW ]X %HUOLQ $P 1RYHPEHU LVW GDV Ä*HVHW] ]XU bQGHUXQJ GHV 6WUDI %H]MDN II 5HQ]LNRZVNL 1-: II +|UQOH XQWHQ )Q 6 ]XU *HVHW]JHEXQJVJHVFKLFKWH +|UQOH )Q I GHU 5HLFKZHLWH JHULQJIJLJHUH bQGHUXQJHQ YRUVDK (LQ GHP MHW]LJHQ M 6W*% HQWVSUHFKHQGHU 7DWEHVWDQG ZDU LP 5HJLHUXQJVHQWZXUI QLFKW YRUJHVHKHQ ,P %HULFKW GHV 5HFKWVDXVVFKXVVHV YRP -XOL ZXUGH GLH (LQIK UXQJ GLHVHU QHXHQ 6WUDIQRUP GDPLW EHJUQGHW GDVV 6WUDI WDWHQ GLH DXV HLQHU *UXSSH KHUDXV EHJDQJHQ ZHUGHQ IU GDV 2SIHU PLW HLQHP HUK|KWHQ *HIDKUHQSRWHQ]LDO YHU EXQGHQ VLQG ZHLO GLH 9HUWHLGLJXQJV XQG )OXFKWFKDQFHQ VWDUN HLQJHVFKUlQNW VLQG XQG ZHLO LQQHUKDOE YRQ *UXS SHQ EHVRQGHUH WDWEHJQVWLJHQGH +HPPXQJHQ DEEDXHQGH '\QDPLNHQ ZLUNHQ 'HU $XIEDX GHV M 6W*% RULHQWLHUW VLFK LQ ZHVHQWOL FKHQ 3XQNWHQ DQ 6W*% %HWHLOLJXQJ DQ HLQHU 6FKOl REMHNWLYH %HGLQJXQJ GHU 6WUDIEDUNHLW 6W*% LVW DQZHQGEDU ZHQQ GXUFK HLQH 6FKOlJHUHL RGHU HLQHQ YRQ PHKUHUHQ YHUEWHQ $QJULII GHU 7RG HLQHV 0HQVFKHQ RGHU ZRUGHQ LVW ,Q M 6W*% LVW REMHNWLYH %HGLQJXQJ GHU 6WUDIEDUNHLW GDVV YRQ HLQHP GHU %HWHLOLJWHQ HLQHU 3HUVR QHQJUXSSH GLH HLQH DQGHUH 3HUVRQ ]XU %HJHKXQJ HLQHU 6WUDIWDW DQ LKU EHGUlQJW HLQH 6WUDIWDW QDFK GHQ JHQ ZHUGHQ DXFK GLH DQGHUHQ *UXSSHQEHWHLOLJWHQ EH VWUDIW REZRKO VLH VHOEVW ZHGHU 7lWHU QRFK $QVWLIWHU RGHU WDQ XQG IU GLH DQGHUHQ EHUUDVFKHQG HUIROJWH 2EMHNWL YH %HGLQJXQJHQ GHU 6WUDIEDUNHLW ]HLFKQHQ VLFK GDGXUFK DXV GDVV GLH ]X EHVWUDIHQGH 3HUVRQ GLH 5HFKWVYHUOHW]XQJ ZHGHU LQ LKUHQ 9RUVDW] DXIJHQRPPHQ QRFK IDKUOlVVLJ JH KDQGHOW KDEHQ PXVV ,P 6WUDIJHVHW]EXFK VLQG REMHNWLYH %HLVSLHOH VLQG D 6W*% %HJHKXQJ HLQHU UHFKWVZLGUL JHQ 7DW LP 9ROOUDXVFK 6W*% IHKOHQGHU 1DFKZHLV GHU :DKUKHLW HLQHU 7DWVDFKH EHL GHU EOHQ 1DFKUHGH RGHU $EV 6W*% (U|IIQXQJ HLQHV ,QVROYHQ]YHUIDKUHQV HWF EHLP %DQNURWWGHOLNW 2EMHNWLYH %HGLQJXQJHQ GHU 6WUDIEDUNHLW ZHFNHQ EHL %7'UV GD]X :DOWHU -5 II +|UQOH II %7'UV
Ausgabe 1.2017 fin - Bonner Rechtsjournal€¦ · ehvrqghuv ghxwolfk ehl m 6w*% ghu lq ghu 6wudi uhfkwvzlvvhqvfkdiw qhjdwly dxijhqrpphq zlug -rdfklp 5hq]lnrzvnl ghu vfkolppvwhq 9huluuxqjhq
-
Upload
others
-
View
2
-
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Ausgabe_1.2017_fin.pdfJXQJ9HUJHZDOWLJXQJ³ EHWLWHOWH 6W*%ZXUGH
HU
K|UWDXFKGLH(LQIJXQJHLQHUQHXHQ6WUDIQRUPPLWGHU
hEHUVFKULIWÄ6WUDIWDWHQDXV*UXSSHQ³M6W*%'LH
Ä:HUHLQH 6WUDIWDWGDGXUFKI|UGHUWGDVVHUVLFKDQHLQHU3HUVRQHQ JUXSSH
EHWHLOLJW GLH HLQH DQGHUH3HUVRQ ]XU%HJHKXQJ HLQHU 6WUDIWDW DQ LKU
EHGUlQJW ZLUGPLW )UHLKHLWVVWUDIH ELV ]X ]ZHL -DKUHQ RGHU PLW
*HOGVWUDIH EHVWUDIW ZHQQ
YRQHLQHP%HWHLOLJWHQGHU*UXSSHHLQH6WUDIWDWQDFKGHQ
RGHULEHJDQJHQZLUGXQGGLH7DWQLFKWLQDQ
GHUHQ9RUVFKULIWHQPLWVFKZHUHUHU6WUDIHEHGURKWLVW³
'HU+LQWHUJUXQG GLHVHU(UZHLWHUXQJ GHV $EVFKQLWWV
'DVEHWUlFKWOLFKH$XVPDGHUYRUDOOHPYRQ0LJUDQWHQ
3DUODPHQWDULVFKHQ 8QWHUVXFKXQJVDXVVFKXVV GHV /DQG
WDJV15:38$,96LOYHVWHUQDFKWGRNXPHQWLHUW
'LH |IIHQWOLFKH (PS|UXQJ KDW GD]X EHLJHWUDJHQ GDVV DXFK EHL
GHQ$EJHRUGQHWHQ GHV 'HXWVFKHQ %XQGHVWDJV
VHU ]X VFKW]HQ ,P 6RPPHU NDP HV ]X EHUSDU
WHLOLFKHQhEHUHLQNQIWHQGLH]XHLQHUVFKQHOOHQ5HIRUP
QHQ*HVHW]HQWZXUIGHU%XQGHVUHJLHUXQJJHJHEHQGHULQ
'LH$XWRULQ LVW ,QKDEHULQ GHV /HKUVWXKOV IU 6WUDIUHFKW 6WUDISUR
]HVVUHFKW5HFKWVYHUJOHLFKXQJXQG5HFKWVSKLORVRSKLHDQGHU+XP
EROGW8QLYHUVLWlW]X%HUOLQ
$P 1RYHPEHU LVW GDV Ä*HVHW] ]XUbQGHUXQJ GHV 6WUDI
%H]MDN II5HQ]LNRZVNL1-:II+|UQOH
XQWHQ)Q 6]XU*HVHW]JHEXQJVJHVFKLFKWH+|UQOH)QI
GHU5HLFKZHLWHJHULQJIJLJHUHbQGHUXQJHQYRUVDK(LQ
GHPMHW]LJHQM6W*%HQWVSUHFKHQGHU7DWEHVWDQGZDU
LP5HJLHUXQJVHQWZXUIQLFKWYRUJHVHKHQ,P%HULFKWGHV 5HFKWVDXVVFKXVVHVYRP
-XOLZXUGHGLH(LQIK UXQJGLHVHUQHXHQ6WUDIQRUPGDPLWEHJUQGHWGDVV6WUDI
WDWHQGLHDXVHLQHU*UXSSHKHUDXVEHJDQJHQZHUGHQIU GDV 2SIHU PLW HLQHP
HUK|KWHQ *HIDKUHQSRWHQ]LDO YHU
EXQGHQVLQGZHLOGLH9HUWHLGLJXQJVXQG)OXFKWFKDQFHQ VWDUN HLQJHVFKUlQNW
VLQG XQGZHLO LQQHUKDOE YRQ*UXS
SHQEHVRQGHUHWDWEHJQVWLJHQGH+HPPXQJHQDEEDXHQGH '\QDPLNHQZLUNHQ
'HU$XIEDXGHVM6W*%RULHQWLHUWVLFKLQZHVHQWOL
FKHQ3XQNWHQDQ6W*%%HWHLOLJXQJDQHLQHU6FKOl
REMHNWLYH %HGLQJXQJ GHU 6WUDIEDUNHLW 6W*% LVW
DQZHQGEDUZHQQGXUFKHLQH6FKOlJHUHLRGHUHLQHQYRQ
PHKUHUHQYHUEWHQ$QJULIIGHU7RGHLQHV0HQVFKHQRGHU
JHQ ZHUGHQ DXFK GLH DQGHUHQ *UXSSHQEHWHLOLJWHQ EH
VWUDIWREZRKOVLHVHOEVWZHGHU7lWHUQRFK$QVWLIWHURGHU
WDQXQG IUGLHDQGHUHQEHUUDVFKHQGHUIROJWH2EMHNWL
YH%HGLQJXQJHQGHU6WUDIEDUNHLW]HLFKQHQVLFKGDGXUFK
DXVGDVVGLH]XEHVWUDIHQGH3HUVRQGLH5HFKWVYHUOHW]XQJ
ZHGHULQLKUHQ9RUVDW]DXIJHQRPPHQQRFKIDKUOlVVLJJH KDQGHOW KDEHQPXVV
,P6WUDIJHVHW]EXFK VLQGREMHNWLYH
%HLVSLHOHVLQGD6W*%%HJHKXQJHLQHUUHFKWVZLGUL
JHQ7DWLP9ROOUDXVFK6W*%IHKOHQGHU1DFKZHLV
GHU:DKUKHLWHLQHU7DWVDFKHEHLGHUEOHQ1DFKUHGHRGHU
$EV6W*%(U|IIQXQJHLQHV,QVROYHQ]YHUIDKUHQV
HWFEHLP%DQNURWWGHOLNW
2EMHNWLYH %HGLQJXQJHQ GHU 6WUDIEDUNHLW ZHFNHQ EHL
%7'UV GD]X:DOWHU -5 II+|UQOH II
%7'UV
EHVRQGHUV GHXWOLFK EHL M 6W*% GHU LQ GHU 6WUDI
UHFKWVZLVVHQVFKDIWQHJDWLYDXIJHQRPPHQZLUG-RDFKLP 5HQ]LNRZVNL GHU
VFKOLPPVWHQ9HULUUXQJHQ GHV*HVHW]JHEHUV XQG KDW PLW HLQHP
UHFKWVVWDDWOLFKHQ 6WUDIUHFKW QLFKWV ]X WXQ³
'HU9RUVLW]HQGH5LFKWHUDP6WUDIVHQDWGHV%*+7KR PDV)LVFKHU
NRPPHQWDUGDVVHVVLFKXPÄHLQHSRSXOLVWLVFKJHIlUEWH
'HPRQVWUDWLRQDQJHEOLFKHU6FKXW]EHUHLWVFKDIWLP*HIRO
OH
FKHQHLQHU5HJHOXQJXQWHUKDOEGHU6FKZHOOHGHV9HUGLNWV
GHU9HUIDVVXQJVZLGULJNHLWDXI]X]HLJHQGD]X
9HUVWRJHJHQGHQ6FKXOGJUXQGVDW]"
6FKRQ LP *HVHW]JHEXQJVYHUIDKUHQ EUDFKWHQ $EJH RUGQHWH GHU
2SSRVLWLRQVSDUWHLHQ YHUIDVVXQJVUHFKWOL FKH (LQZlQGH JHJHQ M 6W*%
YRU (V ZHUGH GHU 6FKXOGJUXQGVDW] PLVVDFKWHW XQG MHPDQG ÄZHJHQ
GHU
SHQKDIW³ YHUXUWHLOW 7KRPDV )LVFKHU NRPPW HEHQIDOOV
]XGHP8UWHLOÄHUVFKHLQWXQWHUGHQ$QIRUGHUXQJHQGHV 6FKXOGSULQ]LSV QLFKW
YHUWUHWEDU³ 'HU 9RUZXUI HLQHU 8QYHUHLQEDUNHLW PLW GHP
6FKXOGJUXQGVDW] EHGDUI GHU 8QWHUVXFKXQJ8QVWUHLWLJ VLQG
GLH$XVJDQJVSXQNWH HL
L9P$UW$EV**XQGGHP5HFKWVVWDDWVSULQ]LSDE
]XOHLWHQ±VRGLHHWDEOLHUWHZHQQDXFKLP'HWDLOZHQLJ
SUl]LVH5HFKWVSUHFKXQJGHV%9HUI*$XVGHP6FKXOG
JUXQGVDW]IROJWGDVVHLQH3HUVRQQXUGDQQVWUDIUHFKWOLFK
YHUDQWZRUWOLFKJHPDFKWZHUGHQGDUIZHQQGLHVHU3HU
VRQHLQ6FKDGHQRGHUHLQH5HFKWVYHUOHW]XQJLQGLYLGXHOO
]X]XUHFKQHQLVW
5HQ]LNRZVNL)Q )LVFKHU6W*%$XIOM5Q 6R GLH $EJHRUGQHWH .DWMD .HXO
%h1'1,6 ',( *5h1(1
%73OHQDUSURWRNROOHLQHQ9HUVWRJHJHQGDV6FKXOG
SULQ]LSVDKHQDXFKGLH$EJHRUGQHWHQ+DOLQD:DZ]\QLDN'LH/LQNH XQG8OOH
6FKDXZV %h1'1,6 ',(*5h1(1 DD2
)LVFKHU %H]MDN)Q+RYHQ :HLJHQG)Q
%9HUI*(]XVDPPHQ IDVVHQG/DQGDX $GDP6FKPLGW6FKXPD FKHU
%9HUI*DXVIKUOLFKHU+|UQOH 6II
%9HUI*(
EDUNHLW³EHLJHQDXHUHU%HWUDFKWXQJ"9HUVXFKWPDQGLH
JRULHQ]XNRQNUHWLVLHUHQVRHUJHEHQVLFK]ZHL$QIRUGH
]%GLH9HUOHW]XQJRGHU*HIlKUGXQJHLQHU3HUVRQPLW HLQHU +DQGOXQJ
VDPPHQKDQJ JHEUDFKW ZHUGHQ NDQQ 'DEHL NDQQ GHU
GHP6FKXOGJUXQGVDW]VLQGVROFKH6WUDWHJLHQQLFKWYHU
GHUEHVFKXOGLJWHQ3HUVRQGHU9RUZXUIJHPDFKWZHUGHQ
NDQQHQWZHGHU9RUVDW]EH]JOLFKGHU)ROJHJHKDEW]X
JHKDQGHOW]XKDEHQ
:lKUHQGGLHVHEHLGHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQIULQGLYLGXHOOH
9RUZHUIEDUNHLWXQVWUHLWLJVHLQGUIWHQNDQQPDQGDU EHU GLVNXWLHUHQZDV
DXHUGHP%HVWDQGWHLO GHV YHUIDV VXQJVUHFKWOLFKHQ 6FKXOGJUXQGVDW]HV
LVW 6R YHUZHQGHW GDV %9HUI* GHQ %HJULII GHU :LOOHQVIUHLKHLW GHVVHQ
%HGHXWXQJ XQG QDWXUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH )XQGLHUXQJ LQ
KRKHP0DHNRQWURYHUVVLQG)UXQVHU7KHPDPXVV DEHU DXI GLHVH)UDJHQQLFKW
HLQJHJDQJHQZHUGHQ:HU
DUJXPHQWLHUWGDVVGHUQHXH7DWEHVWDQGÄ6WUDIWDWHQDXV
*UXSSHQ³PLWGHP6FKXOGJUXQGVDW]XQYHUHLQEDUVHLEH
DEVLFKWLJWGDPLWQLFKWGLHLQWHUGLV]LSOLQlUH'HEDWWHYRQ
1HXURZLVVHQVFKDIWHQ 3KLORVRSKLH XQG 6WUDIUHFKWVZLV
VHQVFKDIWXPGLH:LOOHQVIUHLKHLWGHV0HQVFKHQIRUW]X
IKUHQ'LHVHEHWULIIWDOOHVWUDIUHFKWOLFKHQ6FKXOGXUWHLOH
GHQ 7DWEHVWDQG :HU GHP *HVHW]JHEHU PLW %OLFN DXI
M6W*%HLQH0LVVDFKWXQJGHV6FKXOGJUXQGVDW]HV
YRUZLUIWZLOOGDPLWEHKDXSWHQGDVVHLQ3UREOHPPLWGHU
GLQJVGHUGLIIHUHQ]LHUWHUHQ%HJUQGXQJZDUXPM
EDUNHLWDOV%HVWDQGWHLOGHV6FKXOGJUXQGVDW]HVNROOLGLH
8QWHU EHVWLPPWHQ 8PVWlQGHQ DXFK HLQ 8QWHUODVVHQ 2E XQG ZDV
GD]XHWZDPLW%OLFNDXIGLHHUIRUGHUOLFKH*DUDQWHQVWHOOXQJDXVGHP
6FKXOGJUXQGVDW] DEJHOHLWHWZHUGHQ N|QQWH NDQQ IU XQVHU7KHPD
GDKLQVWHKHQ
%9HUI*( 6GD]X+|UQOH
IUbQGHUXQJHQLQGHUVWUDIUHFKWOLFKHQ9HUEUHFKHQVOHKUH+LO OHQNDPS
UH'LHYRUVWHKHQGDQJHIKUWH3DXVFKDONULWLNDQM
6W*%OlVVWGLHVHQ3XQNWRIIHQ'LH(LQVFKlW]XQJGDVV ÄGLH
9HUIDVVXQJVPlLJNHLW GHU 5HJHOXQJ HUKHEOLFKHQ
VHLLVW]XXQWHUVXFKHQ
ZUGHVLFKQLFKWDXIGLH)DVVXQJYRQM6W*%NRQ ]HQWULHUHQ VRQGHUQ DOOHQ
6WUDIQRUPHQ JHOWHQ GLH HLQH
REMHNWLYH%HGLQJXQJGHU6WUDIEDUNHLWHQWKDOWHQ'DKLQWHU
VWQGHGLH7KHVHGDVVHVJHQHUHOOQLFKW]XOlVVLJ VHL LQ
HLQHQ6WUDIWDWEHVWDQGHLQ0HUNPDOHLQ]XIJHQGDVHLQH
)ROJHEHVFKUHLEWGLHGHU7lWHUDXIGHUREMHNWLYHQ(EHQH
QLFKWYHUXUVDFKWXQGDXIGHUVXEMHNWLYHQ(EHQHQLFKWLQ
GLHVVRVLHKWPVVWH]%DXFK6W*%%HWHLOLJXQJ
DQHLQHU6FKOlJHUHLHQWZHGHUDOVYHUIDVVXQJVZLGULJHLQ
VWXIHQRGHUGLH1RUPVRLQWHUSUHWLHUHQGDVVGLHVFKZH
UH)ROJHIDKUOlVVLJYRP7lWHUYHUXUVDFKWRGHUJHI|UGHUW
ZRUGHQVHLQPVVHHVVLFKPLWKLQQLFKWXPHLQHREMHNWL
YH%HGLQJXQJGHU6WUDIEDUNHLWKDQGOH(VLVWMHGRFKQLFKW
EHU]HXJHQGGHQ9RUZXUIGHU9HUIDVVXQJVZLGULJNHLW LQ
SDXVFKDOHU:HLVHDXIDOOH7DWEHVWlQGH]XHUVWUHFNHQGLH
HLQHREMHNWLYH%HGLQJXQJGHU6WUDIEDUNHLWHQWKDOWHQ(U
IRUGHUOLFKLVWHLQHGLIIHUHQ]LHUHQGH%HWUDFKWXQJGLHVLFK
DXIGLH7HLOHGHU1RUPNRQ]HQWULHUWGLHQLFKWDOVREMHNWL
YH%HGLQJXQJJHIDVVWVLQG
'HU%HIXQGÄ9HUVWRJHJHQGHQ6FKXOGJUXQGVDW]³LVWQXU
GDQQEHJUQGHWZHQQVLFKGLH8PVWlQGHGLHGLH(LQRUG
QXQJDOVVWUDIZUGLJHV*HVFKHKHQWUDJHQDXVVFKOLHOLFK
DXVGHUREMHNWLYHQ%HGLQJXQJGHU6WUDIEDUNHLW HUJHEHQ %HVFKUHLEW GHU
7DWEHVWDQG LP hEULJHQ 9HUKDOWHQ GDV VR]LDODGlTXDW LVW OLHJW HLQ
9HUVWR JHJHQ GHQ 6FKXOG
JUXQGVDW]YRU±GDQQZLUGPLWGHUREMHNWLYHQ%HGLQJXQJ
GHU6WUDIEDUNHLWGHU*UXQGVDW]GHULQGLYLGXHOOHQ9HUDQW ZRUWXQJGHV7lWHUV
IUGDV8QUHFKWXPJDQJHQ(VJLEW LP6W*%HLQHQ7DWEHVWDQG
IUGHQGLHVHhEHUOHJXQJHQ UHOHYDQW ZHUGHQ 0LW %OLFN DXI GLH 5DXVFKWDW
D 6W*%OlVVWVLFKVWUHLWHQREHVWDWVlFKOLFKVRJHIlKUOLFK
LVWVLFK]XEHUDXVFKHQGDVVGLHVXQDEKlQJLJYRQGHURE
MHNWLYHQ%HGLQJXQJ%HJHKXQJHLQHUUHFKWVZLGULJHQ7DW LP5DXVFK]XVWDQG DOV
VWUDIZUGLJHV8QUHFKW HLQ]XVWX
)LVFKHU)QM5Q
,QGLHVH5LFKWXQJWHQGLHUW6DDO'LH%HWHLOLJXQJDQHLQHU6FKOlJHUHL
6W*%(LQ3OlGR\HUIUGLH6WUHLFKXQJGHUVFKZHUHQ)ROJH
5R[LQ6WUDIUHFKW$7,$XIO5QDUJXPHQWLHUWGDVV
6W*%QXUDQJHZHQGHWZHUGHQVROOZHQQGLHVFKZHUH)ROJH
YRUKHUVHKEDUZDU'DHUDOOHUGLQJVQLFKW9HUXUVDFKXQJRGHU)|UGH
UXQJGXUFKHLJHQH+DQGOXQJYRUDXVVHW]WYHUODQJWHUQXUHLQHQ7HLO
8PJHNHKUWKlOW3XSSH
GHVPRGHUQHQ6FKXOGVWUDIUHFKWVI
IHQLVW(VJLEWJXWH*UQGHGLHVEHLD6W*%]X
RGHU'URJHQKDUPORVXQGXQJHIlKUOLFKIUGLH8PJHEXQJ
GHV%HUDXVFKWHQVHLQZHQQDXFKEHLGHQHUIRUGHUOLFKHQ
4XDQWLWlWHQQLFKWIULKQVHOEVWDEHUGDVLVWIUGLH5HFKW
IHUWLJXQJHLQHVVWUDIUHFKWOLFKHQ*HIlKUGXQJVGHOLNWVLUUH
OHYDQW$EHUGLH%HGHQNHQEH]JOLFKD6W*%VLQG
QLFKWDXIM6W*%]XEHUWUDJHQ9LHOPHKUEHGDUIHV
)UGLH)UDJHGHV9HUVWRHVJHJHQGHQ6FKXOGJUXQGVDW]
0HUNPDOHGLHYRUGHU5HFKWVIROJHXQGYRUGHUREMHNWL
YHQ%HGLQJXQJGHU6WUDIEDUNHLWDQJHIKUWZHUGHQVWUDI
ZUGLJHV8QUHFKWEHVFKUHLEWGDVGHP7lWHU LQGLYLGXHOO
]XUHFKHQEDULVW,VWGLHV]XEHMDKHQLVWGHP6FKXOGJUXQG
VDW]*HQJHJHWDQ8QWHUGLHVHU9RUDXVVHW]XQJZLUNWGDV
+LQ]XIJHQHLQHUREMHNWLYHQ%HGLQJXQJGHU6WUDIEDUNHLW OHGLJOLFK
VWUDIEDUNHLWVHLQHQJHQG XQG LVW QLFKW JHHLJQHW
GDV9HUGLNWÄYHUIDVVXQJVZLGULJ³]XEHJUQGHQ
'LH REMHNWLYH +DQGOXQJVEHVFKUHLEXQJ LQ M 6W*% HQWKlOW ]ZHL (OHPHQWH
(UVWHQV PXVV HLQH *UXSSH EH
VWDQGHQKDEHQPLQGHVWHQVGUHL3HUVRQHQGLH]XU%H JHKXQJ HLQHU6WUDIWDW
HLQH DQGHUH3HUVRQ EHGUlQJW%H
GUlQJWZLUGZHUÄPLW1DFKGUXFNDQGHU$XVEXQJVHLQHU
%HZHJXQJVIUHLKHLWRGHUVHLQHUVRQVWLJHQIUHLHQ:LOOHQV
EHWlWLJXQJJHKLQGHUWZLUG'DEHLPXVVGLH*UXSSHPLWHL
QHUJHZLVVHQ+DUWQlFNLJNHLWDXIGDV2SIHUHLQZLUNHQ³
GDGXUFKGLH6WUDIWDWJHI|UGHUWKDEHQ%HWHLOLJXQJLVWVR
GLH%HJUQGXQJGHV*HVHW]HVÄQLFKWLP6LQQHGHU
ELV6W*%]XYHUVWHKHQVRQGHUQLPXPJDQJVVSUDFKOL FKHQ6LQQ³ 'DPLW
LVWJHPHLQWGDVV ÄNHLQEHZXVVWHV
'LHV LVWQDFKYROO]LHKEDUZHQQPDQVLFKYHUJHJHQZlUWLJWGDVV
GHQQXUVHKUORVHYHUEXQGHQHQ*UXSSHQHUIDVVWZHUGHQ
VROOHQ8QWHUVROFKHQ%HGLQJXQJHQJLEWHVNHLQH$EVSUD FKHQ DOOHU
QHX+LQ]XNRPPHQGHQPLW DOOHQ DQGHUHQ ,Q
VXEMHNWLYHU+LQVLFKWPXVVGHU7lWHUPLWPLQGHVWHQVEH
*HJHQGLH(LQRUGQXQJGHU7DWKDQGOXQJÄVLFKEHUDXVFKHQ³DOV8Q UHFKW*HLVOHU
)QII'XWWJH PHU +UVJ )6 IU *HSSHUW 6 I5R[LQ )Q
5Q6WHUQEHUJ/LHEHQ+HFNHU 6W*%$XIOD5Q6WUHQJ $XIO5Q
8QGVHOEVWZHQQPDQGHQ8QUHFKWVFKDUDNWHUYRQEHUPlLJHP$O
NRKROXQG'URJHQNRQVXPEHMDKWEOHLEWGDV3UREOHPGDVVGLH+|KH
GHU6WUDIHYRQGHU$UWGHUUHFKWVZLGULJHQ7DWDEKlQJWYJOD
6W*%PLW2:L**HLVOHU)Q6I'XWWJH)Q
6FK|QNH6FKU|GHU6WHUQEHUJ/LHEHQ+HFNHU)Q
6RIU6W*%*HLVOHU)QI5HQJLHU6WUDIUHFKW%7 ,,$XIO5Q
%7'UV
]HLWLJH(LQVFKFKWHUXQJHWZDGXUFK ÄODXWHV*U|OHQ³JHQJHQLFKW DD2
%7'UVNULW%H]MDN)Q %7'UV
GLQJWHP9RUVDW]KDQGHOQ(UPXVVHVDOVRHUQVWOLFKIU
JUXSSHYRUOLHJWGDVVHLQHDQGHUH3HUVRQEHGUlQJWZLUG GDVV 0LWJOLHGHU GHU
*UXSSH QLFKW QRWZHQGLJHUZHLVH
XQG VFKOLHOLFK GDVV HU VHOEVW DOV0LWJOLHG GHU*UXSSH
]XP%HGUlQJXQJVHIIHNWEHLWUlJW
:HULQGLHVHU:HLVHYRUVlW]OLFKKDQGHOWEHJHKWHLJHQHV 8QUHFKW 2E GDIU
EHUHLWV GDV JHPHLQVDPH %HGUlQJHQ
HLQHUDQGHUHQ3HUVRQJHQJHQZUGHNDQQGDKLQVWHKHQ $XVVFKODJJHEHQG LVW
GDVV GHU 7lWHU 9RUVDW] KDW GDVV PLWWHOV%HGUlQJHQV HLQH6WUDIWDW
EHJDQJHQZHUGHQ VROO :HU LQ*UXSSHQ LQGLHVHU:HLVHDJLHUWNDQQVLFKQLFKW
GDUDXIEHUXIHQGDVVVHLQHLJHQHV9HUKDOWHQVR]LDODGlTXDW
XQGXQJHIlKUOLFKVHLXQGHUQXUZHJHQGHU6WUDIWDWHLQHV DQGHUHQ EHVWUDIW
ZHUGH GLH LKP QLFKW ]XUHFKHQEDU VHL
$QGHUVDOVEHLP7DWEHVWDQGGHU5DXVFKWDWD6W*%
EHVWHKWIUM6W*%NHLQ*UXQGHLQHQ9HUVWRJHJHQ
GHQ6FKXOGJUXQGVDW]DQ]XQHKPHQ
M6W*%HUZHLWHUWGLH6WUDIEDUNHLWIU%HWHLOLJWH*H
6WHOOXQJQDKPHQDXVGHU/LWHUDWXUEH]ZHLIHOQGDVVHLQH
JHPHLQHQ5HJHOQIU*HKLOIHQXQGDXHUGHPZHUGHGLH
JXQJL$EV66W*%LP*HVHW]DXVGUFNOLFK XQGVWUDIVFKlUIHQGHUZlKQW
IHKO'LH$QZHQGXQJGHUDOOJHPHLQHQ5HJHOQIU0LWWl
WHUXQG*HKLOIHQVW|WZHJHQGHUDQVSUXFKVYROOHQ$QIRU
GHUXQJHQDQGHQ9RUVDW]DXI]XHQJH*UHQ]HQ)UGLH
*HKLOIHQVWUDIEDUNHLWQDFK6W*%IRUGHUWGLHGHXWVFKH 5HFKWVSUHFKXQJ
GDVV*HKLOIHQ GLHZHVHQWOLFKHQ0HUN
PDOHGHU+DXSWWDWJHNDQQWKDEHQPVVHQ$XFKGLH5H
JHOQGHU0LWWlWHUVFKDIWEDVLHUHQDXIGHU*UXQGLGHHGDVV
3HUVRQHQJHPHLQVDPHLQHQÄ7DWSODQ³IHVWVHW]HQXQGYHU
IROJHQZHVKDOEHLJHQPlFKWLJH+DQGOXQJHQQLFKWHUIDVVW ZHUGHQ M 6W*% VROO
GDJHJHQ DXFK )lOOH HUIDV VHQ LQGHQHQGHU7lWHUQLFKWGDPLWJHUHFKQHWKDW
GDVV
YHQ9RUVWHOOXQJHQYRQGHPZDVPLWGHP%HGUlQJHQDXI UHFKWVZLGULJH:HLVH
HUUHLFKWZHUGHQ VROO GLIIXVZDUHQ
KDEHQ GDVV GDV %HGUlQJHQ GHU %HJHKXQJ LUJHQGHLQHU
DOGHOLNWVHLQDEHUDXFK]%HLQ'LHEVWDKOHLQ5DXEHLQH
SUl]LVHUH XQG SDVVJHQDXH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ GDYRQ JHKDEW
KDEHQZHOFKHNULPLQHOOHQ$NWLYLWlWHQOHW]WOLFKGXUFKGDV
%HGUlQJHQJHI|UGHUWZHUGHQ
%7'UV %H]MDN)Q5HQ]LNRZVNL)Q
'LHVWUHQJHQ$QIRUGHUXQJHQGLHGLH5HFKWVSUHFKXQJLQ GHQ
DOOJHPHLQHQ5HJHOQ IU*HKLOIHQXQG0LWWlWHU DXI VWHOOW VLQG QLFKW GXUFK
GHQ 6FKXOGJUXQGVDW] ]ZLQJHQG
YRUJHJHEHQ'LH%HZHUWXQJGHV8QUHFKWVGHU7lWHUKDQG
OXQJKlQJWQLFKWDQGHU'HWDLOJHQDXLJNHLWGHV7lWHUZLV
*UXSSH KHUDXV HLQH 6WUDIWDW JHJHQ HLQ ,QGLYLGXDORSIHU EHJDQJHQ
ZHUGHQ VROO XQG GDVV GDV 2SIHU ]X GLHVHP
(V LVW DQJHPHVVHQ GHQMHQLJHQ ]X EHVWUDIHQ GHU GXUFK
VHLQH%HWHLOLJXQJDQGHUEHGUlQJHQGHQ*UXSSHYRUVlW]
OLFKGLH%HJHKXQJHLQHV'HOLNWVJHJHQGLH3HUVRQI|UGHUW
XQG]ZDUDXFKGDQQZHQQLKPGLHJHQDXH1DWXUGLHVHV
'HOLNWVQLFKWHUVLFKWOLFKLVWRGHUZHQQVLFKDQGHUH*UXS SHQPLWJOLHGHU
VSRQWDQHQWVFKOLHHQGLHJHPHLQVDPJH
(VLVWLQVEHVRQGHUHYRUKHUVHKEDUGDVVXQWHUEHVWLPPWHQ
NXOWXUHOOJHSUlJWHQ3UlPLVVHQXQGVR]LDOSV\FKRORJLVFKHQ
'\QDPLNHQPDQFKH0lQQHUHLQHJHVFKDIIHQHSK\VLVFKH
'DVVGDV$UJXPHQWGHU9HUIDVVXQJVZLGULJNHLW WURW]GHP
(VZLUGGDPLWNULPLQDOSROLWLVFKEHJUQGHWHQ(LQZlQGHQ
'UDVWLNYHUOLHKHQ'HUYRUVFKQHOOH5FNJULIIDXIGDV9HU
IDVVXQJVUHFKWYHUNHQQWDEHUGDVVGDV*UXQGJHVHW]ZHLWH
6SLHOUlXPHIUJHVHW]JHEHULVFKH(QWVFKHLGXQJHQOlVVW
VDW]³ XQG GHP 8UWHLO ÄLQ MHGHU +LQVLFKW EHU]HXJHQGH
6WUDIQRUP³EOHLEWHLQZHLWHU%HUHLFKIUNULWLVFKHhEHU
OHJXQJHQGHQHVLQGLIIHUHQ]LHUWHU:HLVHDXV]XVFK|SIHQ JLOW
$QVDW]SXQNWHIU.ULWLNXQWHUKDOEGHU
6FKZHOOHGHU9HUIDVVXQJVZLGULJNHLW
D'HU9HUZHLVDXIÄV\PEROLVFKHV6WUDIUHFKW³
*HJHQM6W*%ZLUGQHEHQGHP9HUZHLVDXIGHQDQ JHEOLFKHQ9HUVWR JHJHQ GHQ
6FKXOGJUXQGVDW] HLQZHL WHUHVEHOLHEWHV
,QVWUXPHQWDXVGHP:HUN]HXJNDVWHQGHU
EROLN³6RZHLWGDPLWGLH3URJQRVHLQWHQGLHUWLVWGDVVHV
YHUPXWOLFKQLFKWYLHOH$QZHQGXQJVIlOOHJHEHQZLUGKDQ
GHOWHVVLFKXPHLQHUHDOLWlWVQDKH$QQDKPH'LH*UQGH
6R)LVFKHU)QM5Q 6GD]X*lUGLW]6WDDWIIGHUV
II6WXFNHQEHUJ*$II
6REHUHLWV8OOH6FKDXZV%h1'1,6',(*5h1(1%73OHQDU
SURWRNROO
DQ6LOYHVWHUNRQQWHQQXUIUHLQHQNOHLQHQ7HLOGHU
GHUHQLVWM6W*%QXUGDQQDQZHQGEDUZHQQLGHQWL
LVW9RU DOOHPDQZDOWOLFKEHUDWHQH%HVFKXOGLJWHZHUGHQ YRUEULQJHQ GDVV
VLH QLFKW JHZXVVW KlWWHQ GDVV DQGHUH
*UXSSHQPLWJOLHGHUHLQH6WUDIWDWSODQWHQXQGGDVVDXVLK
UHU6LFKWGDV%HGUlQJHQGHVRGHUGHU2SIHU6HOEVW]ZHFN ZDU
]X EHZHUWHQ VLQG 6\PEROLVFKH$XVVDJHQ ]X WUHIIHQ LVW 7HLO GHU
)XQNWLRQHQ GHV 6WUDIUHFKWV.ODXV*lUGLW] EH
VFKUHLEW6WUDIUHFKWDOVÄYHUEOLHEHQH:lUPHTXHOOHJHVHOO
VFKDIWOLFKLQWHJULHUHQGHU6\PEROLN³
ZUGH ÄV\PEROLVFKHV³ 6WUDIUHFKW HUVW GDQQ ZHQQ HLQH UDGLNDOH
9HUPHKUXQJ ZHLWJHKHQG EHGHXWXQJVORVHU 9RU
VFKULIWHQGHQ%HVWDQGDQ9HUERWVQRUPHQIU%UJHUXQG
5HFKWVDQZHQGHUXQEHUVLFKWOLFKPDFKW0DQN|QQWHVLFK
GDUEHUVWUHLWHQREGDVGHXWVFKH6WUDIUHFKWLQVEHVRQGHUH
GHU8QEHUVLFKWOLFKNHLW DQQlKHUW$EHUEH]RJHQDXIHLQ HLQ]HOQHV*HVHW]
OlVVW VLFK GLH)UDJH RE HLQ*HVHW] ]X
NULWLVLHUHQLVWQLFKWVFKOLFKWPLW9HUZHLVDXIVHLQHSURJ
EHDQWZRUWHQ
E)DOVFKH3ODW]LHUXQJGHU1RUP
DQM6W*% WUlJW'LH1RUP LVW V\VWHPZLGULJSODW
]LHUW6LHSDVVWQLFKWLQGHQ$EVFKQLWWGHUGHQ7LWHO
'DV YRP 7lWHU EHJDQJHQH 8QUHFKW ZHLVW NHLQHQ VSH
*lUGLW]6WDDWXQG6WUDIUHFKWVSIOHJH6]XU%HGHXWXQJYRQ
6\PEROLNIUGDV6WUDIUHFKWDXFK*lUGLW]DD2I
GD GLH7DW QDFK RGHU L6W*%QXU REMHNWLYH %HGLQJXQJ GHU 6WUDIEDUNHLW
LVW 'LH hEHUVFKULIW Ä6WUDI WDWHQ DXV *UXSSHQ³ EULQJW GLHV
HLQHUVHLWV ULFKWLJ ]XP
$XVGUXFNVLHYHUGHXWOLFKWDEHUDQGHUHUVHLWVGDVVGLHVHU
K|UW'HP*HVHW]JHEHU LVW YRU]XZHUIHQ EHUP|JOLFKH
7DWNRQVWHOODWLRQHQQLFKWKLQUHLFKHQGQDFKJHGDFKW]XKD
EHQ'LH0DWHULDOLHQ]XM6W*%YHUZHLVHQGDUDXI
KHUDXVEHJDQJHQZHUGHQIUGDV2SIHUHLQHUK|KWHV*H
IDKUHQSRWHQ]LDOEHUJHQ'LHVLVW]XPHLQHQGDULQEHJUQ
GHWGDVVVLFKGDV2SIHUQLFKWQXUHLQHP7lWHUDXVJHVHW]W VLHKW
VRQGHUQHLQHU9LHO]DKOYRQ3HUVRQHQ VRGDVVGLH 9HUWHLGLJXQJV RGHU
)OXFKWFKDQFHQ IU GDV 2SIHU VWDUN
GXUFKHLQHPRWLYLHUHQGZLUNHQGH'\QDPLNJHNHQQ]HLFK
QHWGLHGXUFKGLHJHJHQVHLWLJH%HVWlUNXQJGHU*UXSSHQ
PLWJOLHGHUJHVSHLVWZLUGXQGGLHGD]XIKUWGDVVGHU(LQ ]HOQH DQGHUHQIDOOV
EHVWHKHQGH +HPPXQJHQ EHUZLQGHW E]ZJDU QLFKW HUVW
]XOlVVW³'LHVHhEHUOHJXQJHQ VLQG DOV SV\FKRORJLVFKH %HVFKUHLEXQJHQ
SODXVLEHO DEHU GHU
6WUDIEDUNHLWLVW]XHQJ'LHVHYHUHQJWH3HUVSHNWLYHLVWQXU GDPLW HUNOlUEDU
GDVV GHQ$EJHRUGQHWHQ GLH YHUJOHLFKV ZHLVH DNWXHOOHQ XQG LQWHQVLY LQ
GHU 0HGLHQEHULFKWHU
$XJHQVWDQGHQ(WZDVPHKU'LVWDQ]]XGLHVHQ$QODVVGH
OLNWHQXQGHLQHEUHLWHUH%HVFKlIWLJXQJPLW3KlQRPHQHQ
GHU*UXSSHQELOGXQJXQGGHV9HUKDOWHQVHLQ]HOQHULQVRO
FKHQ*UXSSHQZlUHQYRU]XJVZUGLJJHZHVHQ
JHQ1|WLJXQJHQXQG(LJHQWXPVGHOLNWHLQGDV6SHNWUXP
VRZRKOGHV9RUKDEHQVGHU*UXSSHDOVDXFKGHUP|JOLFKHQ
6LWXDWLRQVDXVQXW]XQJGXUFKHLQ]HOQH*UXSSHQPLWJOLHGHU
9RUVWHOOEDULVW]%GDVVHLQDEJHOHQNWHV2SIHUEHVWRKOHQ
ZHUGHQVROOGDQQDEHUGLHVLFKDXIEDXHQGH$JJUHVVLYL WlW GD]X IKUW GDVV
HLQ0LWJOLHG GHU*UXSSH ]XVFKOlJW 2GHU XPJHNHKUW NDQQ ]% HLQ0LWJOLHG
HLQHU DXI N|U SHUOLFKH$QJULIIH DXVJHULFKWHWHQ*UXSSH+RROLJDQV GHU
9HUVXFKXQJHLQHUJQVWLJHQ*HOHJHQKHLWHUOLHJHQXQGGLH
*HOGE|UVHRGHUGDV+DQG\HLQHV2SIHUVDQVLFKQHKPHQ
XQGNRQVLVWHQWHU:HLVH HUIDVVWZHUGHQ VROOHQ GDQQEH
GUIWHHVHLQHUEUHLWHUDQJHOHJWHQ1RUPDOVM6W*%
'LHVHZlUHLP$OOJHPHLQHQ7HLOGHV6W*%DQ]XVLHGHOQ
8QGHVPVVWHGLHREMHNWLYH%HGLQJXQJGHU6WUDIEDUNHLW
GLHLQ%HGUlQJXQJVV]HQDULHQQLFKWXQW\SLVFKVLQGPVV
WHQDXIJHQRPPHQZHUGHQ
%7'UV
2E HLQH VROFKH$XVZHLWXQJ GHU 7HLOQHKPHUVWUDIEDUNHLW
VLQQYROOLVWZlUHPLW6LFKHUKHLW*HJHQVWDQGYRQNRQWUR
YHUVHQUHFKWVSROLWLVFKHQ'HEDWWHQ(VJLEWDEHU*UQGH GDUEHU MHGHQIDOOV
QDFK]XGHQNHQ 'DV %LOG YRQ 7lWHUQ XQG7HLOQHKPHUQ GDV GHQ 6W*% LQ GHU
,QWHU SUHWDWLRQ GXUFK GLH GHXWVFKH 5HFKWVSUHFKXQJ ]XJUXQGH OLHJW
JHKW YRQ ]ZHFNUDWLRQDO KDQGHOQGHQ SODQHQGHQ
PLW:LVVHQDJLHUHQGHQ3HUVRQHQDXV'DVZLUGPDQFKHQ
GHP5DVWHU IDOOHQ*UXSSHQGLHHQWKHPPWG\QDPLVFKHV
9HUKDOWHQEHJQVWLJHQXQGGLHDQGHUHUVHLWVQLFKW]HQWUDO
RUJDQLVLHUWXQGJHVWHXHUWVLQGVRQGHUQVLFKVLWXDWLRQVEH GLQJW
IRUPLHUHQXQGVSRQWDQXQGXQJHSODQW DJLHUHQ(V ZUGH VLFK ORKQHQ EHU GHQ
]X VWDUN DQODVVEH]RJHQHQ M 6W*% KLQDXV ]X XQWHUVXFKHQ LQZLHZHLW
5HJHOQ ]X7lWHUVFKDIWXQG7HLOQDKPHVRZLHGHU7DWEHVWDQGGHV
/DQGIULHGHQVEUXFKV 6W*% ]X HQJ DXI0RGHOOH
]XJHVFKQLWWHQVLQGGLHQLFKWGDVJDQ]H6SHNWUXPVR]LDO
VFKlGOLFKHU9HUKDOWHQVPXVWHUDEGHFNHQ0DQPXVVNHLQ
$QKlQJHUHLQHVÄ%HVWUDIXQJVSHUIHNWLRQLVPXV³VHLQXP
VROFKH)UDJHQ]XVWHOOHQ9LHOPHKUVROOWHQVWUDIUHFKWOLFKH
9HUERWVQRUPHQDXIUHDOLVWLVFKHQ$QQDKPHQ]XPHQVFKOL
FKHP9HUKDOWHQEHUXKHQ
6RFKDUDNWHULVLHUW5HQ]LNRZVNL)QM6W*%