Er:.Af~TMENT Ot THE !N'lER!O~? OFc·;cf OF ttH:: SCUC!TOk

. Office of the Fleld Sollciror 686 'f"t?d>r rid rh.d ldft1g, Ferr Sn.ell ing

Twin CH.i.6!'., f'titmlH4nt.a 551H

Hcmr:ir.;::t k ,1o~~ph P, .'Milanm.::3k.1 .lm.t~ ~d ~·,:.,:_:r ~"··i /\t Lt.:)r·rtt~y

W~':,H:,::r·n ,1:,,,trl.ct cf :-1id1t(¥'.t1 313 Fe~t!t·r.a_;. Hui~.i_ttH:/. t,.;r:.1~1d f.\1pl~L~;j ;i~t~·-·,ii~ ... rt: :.i9502

l I Pl,1v:;u-"' £,Jrgive th.:- Jr,l!\y J.n rr.1spc».;,1cU11g to y~m· rti:L'.t,~t i~:q,ii-q1 rt;~(l,:r..:.Hn~

the :-;~,ti!:l ,)f tn,Hvi1.h.16l hKti.am:1 tu hmit a.nd. fbh, ,.end ;,ipcc.iJ!,::!!!Uy (;,Jit,"· cend.n~; qu,!st.if~tH, re.1"1ed by Ht, Ge;o!;',ge t-.nth011~,-. i..1 m~mbct ,,f thi.,· }:,:n:'.':t•.liJ:::-Yi ~Hr.'.'-;{~iu, Ott,'il._,a Association. W~ ~ril! fon:arding;, ;:t)p')I' f \,)'.n 1..-''i.l~~ tc th.:: l)~E?&u. as ~1~11e of the qui:of'ltiOt):5 ral~.Ate to fa~t,lMJ •''JifV't.i» wi '1o!h:i.::J1 Wt'! !u:ve ,,o ird:or11u1 t i(,n, ~P~'-"Ci t: :f.,:;\lll.U.y t r.~e inquiry :r•nc:,1ud,:. rht 11 tUI,tu:: lel~m', t..Je 1tdll try t.o n~i:qn:;;11d to the •?thcu: Q\i~tltl,1-rt§ l.:.,~xvd,·:,::.l;::,-.

I

1. 'nf'h,t ,,, ," th<.! 11:,1:.U:vi.duill !ClgJH:$ of h~di11M'1~, •;,·he, ~:ro tit,;)l. ~'.,'i.'Jfil.tJ,.;:1.·f:

c,f '\11,•· l rt.be ot c,~~J:u~i~Y of ti'ldJ1a::u1? i· .. , ! •"' 1 '1 "1"' ._,1..- "'"'e "'''"' "',I\' f' 'ii 1. ·{t•·s.~..Jt "'"t~· .,,, · ,· ~ .,, ,J.,,..,. •· ·:1 ' , • •· •s1·'·(··· ·""it"'""'~ ,', ~ t, , t. ~ -ti J,~ ~ wl'$!., w~ *' ·.. l,".'I,· <t.. ~ ;&: .t..

1.1,, • ..,,\; 4!;. ~~i..,a .,. A .,, di.. 01A :! ,, ¥,,, -.J,--... ·• t:.4- 1-.. -I .l 1. ll'1 ~ .... 1;:t,v. , :.s1·~;~·/~

p· '..h, or co•u.n.ity JW:Y n~v;::irt.hc'l'.!tl1Ui1 b~ ~Hg:l.h/1:~ Uu; {;f..~rt.:1i:4 h,.u,~ftu and ;J.aitfil.t~,el;i! ~1.l~tili~ti,1t(;!d by Uu, f\r1'l's1.,a\J ~r.,f LiJ.;ii.im, r,f fair$, such dfl ,(:'<,d~c.~tiO"~ 1:!ro:d.r,~;a;·~~ 1 €;1:i.p ZP~Wf. ~~.i·!E t~ t;i,i,n,:-:.e, t;:-.dning of a voc.;1ti,::;;i1 .. d Ci' tech:rdc~l 1lil:tme .• .?,00 a v~.d.ety of ,Jth;;:r it.@t-vic~s. 'rhtiy ~:-.. d.rl tttit, hc:~lilviir, bil fn.1tH:l€:it-~o p~r:tcipat~ in or Si,h~n ln ,:t'ibtu ,iaeid.v:Ht"® ot 1:r-.H:i,2,t. ~:r,~·l'.:.ar:t.y ,·,,- b4'neHt frc,~ pr.~,r.u~ Ol\l'li!t~t.M by i11ir for the h,:-.thrtf'i.r. of a p·!:.·s-.. il':~,,lm.r t·t:f\i<t or ~k~~~ (.,:.-tfti.;,:.j tt:<41,.. Ii:·\\ ·t-f:E{t)"

ah l.e to etet.ibliish hll;<! ti.n;;;:e.cH:t'y ,;ci u pstt-i .. t:Ul.B!.r roU al~~ th,,;~~ 'lib,;.n:-~ 1n th(" di1u:dhutt~n of ~~.ardbl ~d(i by thr1 l.n4Laa fttd.ff'i:Ji

I !I "J

-I l I I

! I

Co,;,.mlsaim1, Tht1e Nor-tJ~·~t.:"r1 Mill'thit~ Ott~:i A~sod.at:if,n t,;:; a . g10111, or.g*.rdx~ fo:t tht-~ ,,ur.poiH~ :of p6rtlclp-;:1tt tni in siitd, 3Wl \ \

.''!.wa td, rmrl is 01..1t l.il. ?~J~ral.ly ~~l!iJ:&i.t~ Ir,d !Sin ~o~~~-t7tH:?_~ lal@.t~~ <\ .:rr t db:. >k,-etlng11 h~t;;.n ~eld ~Uh t~i~ tr,c.ui) f,;,,r th;;i f!i.ll'£''1t:Jil,"~. '1 of t:i;;id.,i.inw: ~~~i®ta.nee? la itt'·~p,u:-.tt.iti~ <.1f .sl roH for ,Ji!J!tt·ihtd:f.~1 ' of th~ ,~W<Atd, . . ' ·.

•.. / . 2. What lltH: id.~ t.ndlwid~~iHl l'ij.M.~ ~ ~4 htdf.!'M'h hi. t'~f~:;!:',~ii.l~:::1t "(.~')

fi.;;hin~ mi,d iHmtin~ li'l. th~ St~t1.: of Miehiian? .

"'"-'

H~ h.,s nc, .i.m.Hvid~l rlghu ~T.' t~~ @.s tre1.1t.y hunth1; &<M~ t:t<:'lhit~,,m :r:i.~~d:M ,'.H,'i' tdb1.il :!n ,.r..~turll) &ld ici.ot individt~L A trii~\?- 'i'lw,y p"<"ntlt ,ir rl~11.y the !i!),:.:,tch:~1 of ~ueh d.tht.s, I.\B w~.ll a.a t~tul~t:('I: Hii .ax?.rc l~w, Sile :fa:r di€1cu~~:h,i,~ of th~ nahH."!ii of ~,1.;:..h tnuil:ty

Wtiit,:,,foot '"'· [l\d.t~d :.n!il,.tfll)f; --·-·-,.,,·~-·,..,--·c--,'f--f ... ~-=•-~~'¢.,.J,t

\

LT036293

Exhibit A

Case 1:15-cv-00850-PLM-PJG ECF No. 312-2 filed 03/28/18 PageID.3272 Page 1 of 2

.. ;,stf'~.· . ··. ·-J~tJ, \:,·~ffe,,f;;"!i·',i .. ~-""""'* "" . .:I'.-· ·.·*' ,!!'·, ., :J·_,r.:.-::-.·,. P9711' '~::?;i:.~t, 4 .,~ .. .+7-~t*'.,1; ~ j;l'.•t:t'.!'}'_;i:.y,,,~,-'111. ,lf'~lf},~,;;p~~ ".ii .P...,, ---:.~

- ' J',,~uil,,~.._.,,t,.~:i.,; - -·A,~

f't'1frli 1'~'111 1if :t\fft~,i~tO.S".l.t:!~ l .. d; . !• f.!~~it~i.:i, •o 1 .. ~A ~ ;.~ , , -~~~•~:~_ii~ ... ~~:i_.,..tt~i< .... f~t li1 ~ ~--;~-'M-.,_~""

:_;t,.Jl1tt~:aJ 165 .r.Sur1:p,, :,~,, t~1rt.a.,.tf,}tll1~~ ~i~~l'Ja..:11, .,.,9 ui,Sij. \.A~:l~)., - I.I ' -·11!";"<"",''"'-"'"~-~-.:-~-......x;:);._~~~~ • Wt• are ,dso e-odwsin~ for )u·ur t~f::i'f,~e;~ ~tit,,ilea 11'J:·f s~)!id.t;;:;;r'lll

1Jpin1ons dlfre.li:ng ~11ith tb0 i~t~.U$ :lt!i S.tEi£¥:SU~t1!i11!\lj!t~,~"J.;tt,!~!2,a M ... 36284, 62 I. fL 196 (195$) ~ ~'l!l Ofi~1ll:l{:~r:~~ti~r, ttt.~ftln1;tJkltf~ts :~,e~hiy_~£.Jl-1!fl~5!. ~!~r.i.~ . N·•n ~~6~a7~·is·9~·:t:o~:-·6"tf1'1'1t5f)7]i!;iti,. __ ~tat:¥~ .. <?.~ .. ti':.~- M1,.;_£!~!~~,J1~J:PJ~.!!.Ur!?.,,z.t-~~ ~~-lcMrvati<m, M-3MHi2 (197)),, 4,n,d J~di~aif:.dJHl ......._.. ... _"_·~---·- ·: -ia,..__~.,, .... """~-1-,;;.~i1¥>'~~~

p~~. of fl~ :l.£1.~~~~-JEJ!.ian_~J;,~~--l!~~:~l.~$!':Ji~!~![\&L., lf 1 ,,.,...... · bv it.s M~mbc0,ri:J Withiu t:hil'.t !t)-w1d11nti(':'.$ _ of t::t~ l..t't'l-~dt l;&}t,..; Rt~r\;i_,_1:~<lll_t:itHl~ .... ~-~ ........ .,,..._....., .. _...,.,._,"'"'"""'-a.-~"""""'''~">~,,_~.,...,_~"""'-"'i<'l',U~;'.,.~"°'l/<!o...._ ....... ~-.;,,.,,.-11,i.~~f"'PS~~,r,..>..,..,.;;.>-,·..o."'A°!.'"4'f"""~~~"\..,fft.,,,.ay\ • ._~.!·

a?ld to EMorc~ 111.<rtJ~ l<t$~~~li1lt:§.or:a .'-i:ttdliiii1t tu Mt1,~;z,ir~. f~•,.,168.~i (.Ht:li' • 1" ,_ I d •• ,.,._..,__ ..... ,_-.,.,,,..., __ .,..,,__ _ __.4 __ ~~~""(--&--•-,..,r~L~".\~~-!-,,--..---........~~ ' · J >

lul are 1..mVon, jn th~ p,,oad.t.1.Qn that U~8tY dght1111, t.,ll tA.~t e.,d f:t~ii ar .. , tdi'Hll h, r1,sit,,.i1:~~ ~,;r.a-4 t.~ ~-''-'~rebit e;jf aucli f'!~"t.te f!l.,..1! b,~ 1~-i.~ by tii~ li!~,\',i'.!J , 41ubjt'1G.!t:. to t,u.,~h c.i.re.t;H.d,~u• ~d ,~-H::;;:i~~)l..;~~ 'il:,lc.h ~3; tJe imp-,,sed by th~ tt!be. Al5i indivit\ual ~u1lJ. M'~o •~·

xl.ght~ un bi::-1 O'i'i'1't$ t~nl~"*li lHl ciculd e,~M,1a--::h eoe&ett.0-1: ~,tth ti

fN,nticul.1t (dJ,d ot· b1ilii$'4iif ~lld. fU'.Jttft.vJT i:asta.bUeh th&t lt 1,~ t~ tn•·,,ty ;:·1t:ht oi. rbat tr:.U»iWJ. -~r h~~ mitdl' h0 e.x:erct.:w('j rllt1,i 1;."ht~it ii"" i,s autho.t :L:ed to ~~,J.\~C1!t~~ ..

;1, 'w"bi.t \f}(lti!-d b~ hJ~ J,/JltM:fJt, ;).,11 .t!Wl il.\'fffi~·w• tfttN to ~!.Ii\ r.~ ~'4a

in-\fo.lvtr,g u,~:· ll~::, M:ilb l~r-1~~1 , . · .. Unlr.:i>rl h-0 '"~tn.U !Hc:~~12 - ~,•~:r: of t.he, 1t~y JtJ..U@ {!;1JJiil~u~n,-. w.:~ ... ~ul•l h,,rv,,;; i.H) tUt~,'!!~t lHtt1t4b.t'i.t~ .. · li' -~ ~i~ t,,f.l b6e~B ~ ~If-.*-,~t:

of ti!C':.t:+.• ,ll.h~r 'fr,di~ gr~p~ ~ ~t\t:1~.f•d:;,t,n, ~or.;1cl~i~t1. ot t~ p'l.'~M:fl( H !: J.s4!lt iJ;U T#(ii'Jl•J ~~n-e WI .V,!11.~te puc.e-«ltmt t~t) !:~i~t

gr~r h'.i. i.::1.1.tmfo1t; a.nd. 4'i;$la.blisb~.nt 4~.h !'i;;1H:"-' u ttv.tly ~'1 '.rui:'fi!l~ whl..:,h b· hi ttrrn c::)ui.,-t 'th~tt ~.A!!tc:!u1e.; Tb;i,,.1 t,;t:~U ~ti pa:rdctil,:td.:, t n~<1: wi'.l.n1 the g.rrm;; which t~e j'1'!n¢iil 4:n111 @:f th.~ d~AtQ:t:!.~1' i:-~.

th~ rt·t,,Jlt:.iii:f> brvwbt~d 1..n tt~, 11t1J~tion, hfj.$llill• 6.IS:'1?1~t i;!f!~;t1i·i~t;;~i,t, •

ta~ w~>L, l d '"iav(:. n<i rt~M· t~ $J2'tllt'C.l~ f=l'~J. tt'•fr.l\lt'!f V:4~"\ct{, t,~ ..l"1:.td f i ~,h.

"' • lifi '111:'Dd:~~ h~ upc~ljllBte. t~ ti>tt ... ~•~ ffllG ·t,,~r,~ 11110,~r;it'il,,~ tu .:~, "°t(!l,Q: ;),&;; ;J...Q;. .... ,J\:li>t;;{t b,l ~Ht' ~t~llllw ~ h~: ~~;I' ~)b.$1; ~Ji~\-~ .. , ·._, J •. ,., .. j ,-i,i~it,.'· r .1·• """''"' ,,,..,,.,~,t,t, k.,,, ,.,_:':!b=. ~ •. ,,,._,,. .. ·,",,.,.,,-~.J~, .s- .. ,,.\=·•"'·""·"'·•-r~• ,:, f:o gist· -.....l~O·..: ~. l!!a.4"~·1 ff '-"'-.,.,.. ,.,..,..i;;,9 ll,t:>·'l'J;!i,'f• .,.. V".1> ~~ ~~,;;r,~~·'lli-''~ ~~i.,\...,~®'f~-..ir~'i'lff",· o.l",~-"'·

c~~H:c. Th~ lttigiltio,..~. ,,t et,..i.:r", ""• uot dttectly C:i<!~'i. tt!3 Ott.::~.,u-1.w. H~ tm".,;'~~¥li/t-, it hi ~r,1.~,.~¢Mfw1J ~i'.nl::;;:l~ed~ l~ ~1};:;tttl-t ti>~ iDU.;h ,~:::,Bier f,J;r th$ Ott~·i1~~ t;dh~ tQ ~•ta\il,h1h tW".&l: it~ ~:r.;:~. le ,~ ; h~m,.,~d d.afy ti!1 tlti-•t ~~~\,\~ Lt'ia~t't~ .. ;;;.1.n~tn.~ t:h, .,1:~t}itt t:U:i~:t:t•"'·' t·,1.~ t'"i".th~nbip of th,~ i)t.flll:''l\f,\11 tir:1t1~ ~;)ult t:l~.:;in., f\!NlJ ~.L,rt:l~l<ii tt,;{tf./1.li

,dr5h ... a\$hjlfh1.:t c;:: ... l:v tt; t'iti~~il.;,rtt(B-1. by tt~ uib~ it~•lf ~

. w~ ,U'E\ foN~Y,:l_ti:;;,,. ~- C(~),' ,,f. fv.'~l~ i.~tt;'1il\$," ill~ ~o tl!ri~ !.cl'~~ t?';i' t,:A~ h-<1>.:it,,;;;~ ~­J:a..;U,in AH all:'.'!:, f M' U;d.>' :.:,~afsJt,:i.1it;l!f hw.f;;ti ~- t,(;~tr (.l;~i;t~~, -~ •~ ~~i'!.t.t<~, ~"1.A 41~~ for ,,.,mJ; info1•1,r,1:1tU.tr:l ;\\lls ti.l$f'~t, h'*·~~e. ~~ t~ bUltttY ~11,d s.-t~f!~J c~ Joi€ i'-1 .11!').,, t,). i!ltt~ ~ i,\,t, ,hit,:iH ~iz ~t1i.~:~ tTitll,~~;UJ U.

LT036294

Exhibit A

Case 1:15-cv-00850-PLM-PJG ECF No. 312-2 filed 03/28/18 PageID.3273 Page 2 of 2