Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

  • Upload
    dg

  • View
    217

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    1/26

    NAVAL ARCHITECTURE OCEAN AND MARINE ENGINEERING

    NM916

    Systems Availability & Maintenance

    Dr I. Lazakis

    Coursework 1

    Maintenance Applications in Maritime &

    Chemical Industry

    Gkoumas Dimitrios

    Reg. No. 201580394

    Stais Giorgos

    Reg. No. 201582379

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    2/26

    2Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    This document is the coursework/project coversheet for all NAME classes conducted at University of

    Strathclyde for academic year 2015-16. Please do the following when submitting your coursework:

    Staple a completed printed copy of this form to every piece of coursework/project work

    you submit for classes in the Department of Naval Architecture & Marine Engineering.

    Avoid the use of document containers such as cardboard or plastic covers,

    document wallets, ring binders or folders (unless otherwise instructed by the class

    lecturer).

    We do not wish to discourage students from discussing their work with fellow students and

    collaborating in solving problems. However you must ensure that your submitted work distinguishes

    your own intellectual contribution. The key point is that you must not present the results of another

    personswork as though they were your own.

    SUBMISSION

    DETAILS

    Please ensure that the details you give are accurate and completed to the best of your knowledge.

    Registration Number :201580394 Name : Gkoumas Dimitrios,Registration Number:201582379 Name:Stais Giorgos

    Class Code :NM916 Coursework Title: Maintenance Applications in

    Maritime and Chemical Industry

    Lecturer: Dr . I. Lazakis

    Declaration

    I have read and understood the University of Strathclyde guidelines on plagiarism.

    http://www.strath.ac.uk/media/ps/cs/gmap/academicaffairs/policesandprocedures/student-

    guide- to-academic-practice-and-plagiarism.pdf

    I declare that:

    1. This is my coursework/project assignment. This is the version that I am submitting for

    assessment. I understand the penalties of plagiarism.

    2. Wherever published, unpublished, printed, electronic or other information sources have

    been used as a contribution or component of this work, these are explicitly, clearly and

    individually acknowledged by appropriate use of quotation marks, citations, references and

    statements in the text.

    Signature: _ Date of Submission:

    http://www.strath.ac.uk/media/ps/cs/gmap/academicaffairs/policesandprocedures/student-guide-http://www.strath.ac.uk/media/ps/cs/gmap/academicaffairs/policesandprocedures/student-guide-http://www.strath.ac.uk/media/ps/cs/gmap/academicaffairs/policesandprocedures/student-guide-http://www.strath.ac.uk/media/ps/cs/gmap/academicaffairs/policesandprocedures/student-guide-http://www.strath.ac.uk/media/ps/cs/gmap/academicaffairs/policesandprocedures/student-guide-http://www.strath.ac.uk/media/ps/cs/gmap/academicaffairs/policesandprocedures/student-guide-
  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    3/26

    3Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    Table of Contents

    1. Introduction 4

    2. Chemical Industry 52.1 Serious Accidents in Chemical Industry 5

    2.2 Substances present in facilities to be maintained 8

    2.2.1 The Corrosion hazard 9

    2.3 Maintenance Methods 10

    2.3.1 Planned Maintenance System 10

    2.3.2 Corrosion Monitoring 11

    2.3.3 Risk Based Inspection 13

    2.3.4 Reliability Centered Maintenance 13

    a. Hazop Analysis 14

    b. Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) 15

    c. Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) 15

    3. Maritime Industry 16a. Corrective Maintenance 17

    b. Preventive Maintenance 18

    c. Predictive Maintenance 18

    d. Opportunistic Maintenance 19

    3.1 Reliability Centered Maintenance 19

    4. Summary Table 20

    5. Conclusion 22

    6. References 23

    7. Appendix 25

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    4/26

    4Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    1. Introduction

    One of the largest industries in the world is the chemical industry. The alone

    shipments in 1990 was 309 billion dollars while in 2000 the amount reached to 460billion dollars. This industry is one of the biggest industrial sectors in Europe as well,

    with sales of 530 billion euros and a workforce of 1.2 million people. A wide variety of

    substances were produced by chemical factories which are very essential for use in a

    very broad range of applications in all sectors of the economy. The main chemical

    substances are:

    Base chemicals (petrochemicals, basic inorganics and polymers) produced in

    large volumes.

    Specialty chemicals (auxiliaries for industrial processes, active ingredients for

    the pharmaceuticals industry and plant protection, paints & inks, biocides, and

    dyes) produced in lower volumes.

    Consumer chemicals (perfumes ,cosmetics, soaps and detergents).

    The safety regulations in chemical industry are some of the strictest compare to

    other industries. Due to the very aggressive substances, the high pressures and

    temperatures and the stress which placed on equipment, regular revision, servicing

    and maintenance is required. The size and the type of the plants are major factors

    which designate the maintenance procedures as they often require complete shut-

    downs.

    Large-scale production is mostly run as continuous operation while small-scale

    production, often run as a batch operation. In both productions there are technical

    systems like chemical reactors (which have to withstand high or low temperatures and

    pressures), separation devices (filtration, distillation, etc.), and fluid systems for liquids

    and gases (valves, tanks, pumps).

    The maintenance workers must meet the safety regulations and be aware of the

    risks and dangers because of the complexity nature of chemical plants. In addition, in

    many cases they come into close contact with a broad variety of hazardous chemicals.

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    5/26

    5Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    2. Chemical Industry

    2.1 Serious Accidents in Chemical Industry

    The BHOPAL Accident 1984

    December 2nd, 1984. The main tank of the herbicide production unit in Bhopal was

    damaged as a result 20 tons of highly toxic methylisocyanate to leak out. The toxic gas

    spread into the residential areas in a very short time. The number of fatalities few hours

    later were more than 7,000 and more than 20,000 totally. 100,000 people suffered

    permanent injuries and approximately 570,000 people suffered acknowledged healthdamage.

    The PIPER ALPHA Accident 1988

    Morning of July 6th 1988, Piper Alpha was a large offshore platform in the North

    Sea, the compressor A was turned-off for maintenance. A relief valve was removed for

    maintenance too. A worker closed the open pipe provisionally in the end of his shift as

    he did not finished the work. On the operation document has noted that the compressor

    was not ready. The fatal mistake was that the document was delivered to the safety

    department, without the status of the compressor become known to the head of

    production. In the same day the compressor B failed suddenly and as the production

    staff assumed that compressor A was ready to operate so the gas was transferred to

    the compressor. A huge explosion occurred and three tons of gas per second leaked

    out. The construction started to melt very fast and the platform finally collapsed. 167

    people died in the inferno.

    The Williams Olefins Plant explosion 2013

    Apetrochemical plant was located inGeismar,Louisiana.The catastrophic failure

    of the central heat exchanger triggered a huge explosion. Two workers were killed and

    more than 100 injured. The effects of the explosion were felt several miles away.

    Investigations was launched by TheU.S. Occupational Safety and Health

    Administration (OSHA) and the U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation

    Board (CSB) in order to determine the cause of this failure.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrochemicalhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geismar,_Louisianahttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louisianahttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Occupational_Safety_and_Health_Administrationhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Occupational_Safety_and_Health_Administrationhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Chemical_Safety_and_Hazard_Investigation_Boardhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Chemical_Safety_and_Hazard_Investigation_Boardhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Chemical_Safety_and_Hazard_Investigation_Boardhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Chemical_Safety_and_Hazard_Investigation_Boardhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Occupational_Safety_and_Health_Administrationhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Occupational_Safety_and_Health_Administrationhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louisianahttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geismar,_Louisianahttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrochemical
  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    6/26

    6Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    Fig1. Summary Table of serious accidents in chemical industry (1974-2003)

    (Source: Application of Risk and Reliability Methods for Developing Equipment Maintenance StrategyJens P. Tronskar Ph.D., 30 November 2004, DNV)

    It is obvious that in industries such as chemical with dangerous substances, accidents

    could be fatal and quite serious for the surrounding environment. Well organized

    maintenance is quite important not only for the facility but also for the workers safety.

    Many times pitfalls can be overlooked but with systematic analysis many of the past

    accidents could have been prevented. Often, errors and mistakes in maintenance

    procedures lead to averse changes in the plant.

    Fig2. Frequency of accidents regarding the phases of maintenance.

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    7/26

    7Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    Fig3. Significant causes and contributing factors of 93 accidents.

    (Source: Maintenance and Changes, INTERNATIONAL SOCIAL SECURITY ASSOCIATION (ISSA),2007)

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    8/26

    8Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    2.2 Substances present in facilities to be maintained

    The possibility of come into contact with hazardous substances in chemical plants is

    huge for the maintenance workers. The useof hazardous and dangerous products,

    the emissions from substances as a result of operating activities, and substances that

    may be presentin production facilities that are maintained, are the three most common

    sources. Some major categories of substances that are regularly encountered are:

    In petrochemicalinstallations, residues of crude m ineral oi l, which may contain

    carcinogenic polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

    A usual problem in oil refineries is the potential emission of the toxic gashydrogen su lph ide(H2S).

    Heavy metalssuch as mercury may be also present. The most common

    locations for mercury accumulation are separators and heat exchangers. In this

    situation, regular monitoring of mercury and chlorine gas is essential.

    During maintenance procedures, for instance during plant shutdowns, workers

    certainly come into much closer contact with and hazardous substances andproduction equipment than during normal operations. Constant contact with those

    substances or emissions could be due to opened machinery, pipes and valves.

    Fig4. Maintenance operation in progress

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    9/26

    9Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    2.2.1 The Corrosion hazard

    Corrosion is a major problem for the chemical industry. In 2000, the total capital

    expenditures for the chemical industry was approximately $15 billion, with $604 million

    to $1.8 billion annual corrosion costs. For the petrochemical industry, the total capital

    expenditures was $1.8 billion with $73 million to $220 million per year in corrosion

    costs.

    In the past few years, with many efforts and new methodologies, the industry has

    concentrated on minimizing the costs and corrosion failures. One solution is the use of

    corrosion-resistant alloys. There are also some other techniques such as the

    implementation of corrosion monitoring, and the use of planned maintenance.

    Fig5. Corrosion effects in various components

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    10/26

    10Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    2.3 Maintenance Methods

    2.3.1 Planned Maintenance System (PMS)

    In order to avoid failure and damages by corrosion, chemical industries use the

    method of planned maintenance by regularly replacing plant equipment etc. This

    maintenance procedure is essential and constitutes the final phase of control.

    Scheduled shutdown periods must take place for the planned maintenance to begin

    so as to inspect the equipment and the mechanism. Decisions about which tools and

    equipment must be replaced or refurbished should be taken during the maintenance.

    Industries try to organize shutdown periods with short duration in order to minimize the

    losses since the inspection and maintenance costs are high. The competed

    department is responsible to schedule the maintenance well in advance.

    Fig6. Factors contributing to a policy of planned maintenance.

    (Source: CHEMICAL, PETROCHEMICAL, AND PHARMACEUTICAL, Michael P.H. Brongers & Ivelisse Tubens)

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    11/26

    11Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    2.3.2 Corrosion Monitoring

    In the Corrosion Monitoring method by using probes, which more commonly

    are either mechanical or electrochemical appliances, we can continuously take a

    large number of measurements in combination with some other ways like sentry

    holes, UTM, crack detection and of course visual examination which can assist us

    to check the rate of corrosion on each system. The main disadvantage of the

    probes is that in few cases return error readings due to various deposits. All these

    corrosion sensors should be installed in areas where the risk is high and could

    cost a lot of money in case of malfunction.

    There are two types of corrosion monitoring: the continuously one and at regular

    scheduled intervals. The benefits of the first one, is that we can take immediateactions once we see something abnormal. On the other hand in the second one,

    in case something goes wrong between two scheduled intervals nobody are going

    to notice it so the results are not so efficient. Finally the periodical monitoring is

    usually carried out during turnaround.

    Fig7. Techniques for monitoring corrosion in a process plant.

    (Source: CHEMICAL, PETROCHEMICAL, AND PHARMACEUTICAL, Michael P.H. Brongers & Ivelisse Tubens)

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    12/26

    12Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    Below some techniques of corrosion monitoring method in chemical industry are

    described, including their Advantages and Disadvantages.

    Fig8. Corrosion monitoring techniques

    (Source: CHEMICAL, PETROCHEMICAL, AND PHARMACEUTICAL, Michael P.H. Brongers & Ivelisse Tubens)

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    13/26

    13Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    2.3.3 Risk Based Inspection (RBI)

    Risk Based Inspection and is a methodology applied in the Chemical Industry as

    part of their Process Safety Management. Plans for inspections, refurbishment, repairs

    and displacements are based on the risk assessment of this maintenance strategy.

    This inspection is done so as to manage assets and equipment which is exposed to

    dangerous chemicals and pressure in a safe way. Those chemicals must be kept inside

    of pressure boundaries as per their original design criteria.

    Key Benefits of Risk-Based Inspections :

    A more economic method compared to traditional inspection, usually by usingmeans of nondestructive testing (NDT)

    More credible equipment and plant operation.

    Determination of the operational risks related to equipment, via material

    degradation Reduction of the downtime

    Through the application of RBI analysis, materials of construction are considered to

    identify the frequency of inspections that should take place as well as the type of

    damage that can lead to failure, where it may occur and the cost-effective inspectiontechniques. Higher priority for inspection are given to the items with a high probability

    of failure and subsequent impact than items that are of low impact. This method allows

    a more rational application of inspection resources. The main resources are focusing

    on specific and several assets that it is more likely to present a risk to the facility.

    2.3.4 Reliability Centered Maintenance (RCM)

    Hundreds of chemicals are produced every day and are used globally for making

    consumer goods and not only, thats why the chemical industries are extremely

    diverse.

    For years, companies have concentrated on making their equipment more reliable,

    and on correcting perceived problems with technology. Unfortunately while the use of

    better and advanced technology has usually resulted in huge increases in productivity,

    ways and methods for the prevention of major accidents have not indicate the same

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    14/26

    14Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    development. Recent reviews show that the most significant contributors to accidents

    are either the human errors or the lack of adequate management systems. Reliability

    Centered Maintenance (RCM) is being extensively used into this industrial area,

    fulfilling strict regulations and development criteria.

    Techniques

    The methods approved byOccupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)

    include:

    Hazard and Operability Analysis (Hazop)

    Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA)

    FTA, or Fault Tree Analysis.

    All of them are included into the RCM process used in chemical companies.

    a. Hazop Analysis

    In the Hazard and Operability Analysis method all variables and parameters of a

    system are checked thoroughly in order to identify possible deviations from the initial

    ones which can cause operation failures. Each time there is a deviation, the team:

    Takes the decision whether any resultant of interest would conclude from

    reliable causes of the deviation,

    Specifies all the features that secure the system from possible deviation,

    Suggests ways to minimize the possibility of the deviations.

    The findings of a Hazop Analysis are usually recorded in a work-sheet which includes

    the most important entries such as: Deviation, Likelihood causes, Actions required,

    Actions Distribution, Safeguards, Team suggestions etc.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupational_Safety_and_Health_Administrationhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupational_Safety_and_Health_Administration
  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    15/26

    15Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    b. Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA)

    The FMEA method is a qualitative approach which implicates all the possible failure

    modes of a system and the effects of them. All these effects are extensively evaluated

    and documented in order to find possible ways to minimize the chance of this failure.

    Due to the fact that the FMEA method is centered on component breakdowns, few

    problems which have to do with the process chemistry could be bypassed. On the

    other hand, this method is more accurate in non-reactive chemistry such as blending,

    coating, crushing etc. The main advantage of this method is that it provides an

    analytically awareness of possible failures of a system.

    c. Fault Tree Analysis (FTA)

    FTA is a method for designating the connection between the human mistake and

    appurtenance failure once something is not working properly in a system. This method

    depict the joint of some failure events which have as a result the complete system

    breakdown, known as Top Event.

    By using this method, we can easily identify how often a system failure take place

    but on the other hand this frequency doesnt assist us to recognize the main reason

    which caused the system damage. In order to portray this method we usually use a

    fault-tree diagram where the top event or root is placed in the top and show us the

    main malfunction and below are all the possible causes based on AND and OR gates.

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    16/26

    16Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    3. Maritime Industry

    Nowadays most of the world products are transported by ships with more than

    million seafarers employed on them. As a result properly maintained vessels is a

    must in order to prevent the asset itself, cargo carried and the environment from any

    kind of pollution. So various maritime regulatory and administration authorities joint

    together in order to impose a list of regulations that all vessels must comply to secure

    their seaworthiness.

    Maintenance approaches for each ship manager/operator are different and

    extensively described in ISM Code and Planned Maintenance System (PMS) but

    generally can be split in three major categories as per BS 4778:

    Corrective ( or failure-based maintenance including breakdown)

    Preventive ( or schedule-based maintenance)

    Predictive ( or condition-based maintenance)

    Fig9. Maintenance types diagram

    (Source: Systems Availability & Maintenance Hand-outs, Dr .I . Lazakis)

    Whenever crew are planning to perform any kind of above maintenance plans in

    any machinery item they have to follow some steps:

    Plan the work Prosecute a Risk Assessment Arrange workshop/tools

    Shutdown the item Perform the repairs works Test the item Delivery for

    operation

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    17/26

    17Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    Below more details for each type of maintenance plans are described:

    a. Corrective Maintenance

    This type of maintenance is often used when there is a suddenly breakdown of amachinery item for example a ballast pump shaft. The advantages of this type of

    maintenance are the below:

    Only required spares parts are used

    Minimize the expenses especially for vessels which are going for scrap

    On the contrary the disadvantages are quite more:

    Depends on the machinery item sometime ship and crew safety is exposed

    In case of spare parts unavailability the costs are multiplied

    Item working efficiency is decreased and lifecycle is shortened

    The quality of repairs are poor due to fast decisions

    b. Preventive Maintenance

    This type of maintenance is known as Planned Maintenance System (PMS). In this

    type all maintenance works are carried out as per OEM Instructions on a time-basedintervals for example every 1500 running hours or on calendar-based intervals for

    example every 6 months. Even if the spare part is in good working condition, it should

    be replaced when it reaches the interval limitation. The disadvantage of this method is

    that sometimes the spare parts can be used again and minimize the overall cost but in

    order to avoid future breakdowns are replaced.

    c. Predictive Maintenance

    This type of maintenance is based on the Condition Monitoring of each item by

    collecting data from various sensors/gauges, analyze them and react accordingly. By

    this way we have a lot of advantages. Firstly, only minimum spare parts are used,

    suddenly breakdowns are eliminated and crew have more time for the rest works which

    might be more important. The most common ways to collect data for the CM are the

    below:

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    18/26

    18Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    o Lubricant Analysis: Crew onboard take various lube oil samples from various

    critical equipment (Main Engine, Aux Engines, Stern Tube, Thermal Oil etc.)

    and send them to external laboratories for extensive analysis. Depends on the

    results Technical Superintendent and Chief Engineer can take the required

    actions.

    o Vibration Monitoring: By using various sensors, engine crew can monitor the

    vibration of various equipment (TurboCharger, Pumps etc.) and if the results

    are above the limits then they will take some further actions for example:

    Turbine Bearing Housing Replacement.

    o Physical Measurements: Engine Crew take various periodic measurements

    mostly as per ISM Code in order to examine the condition of the item. Such

    measurements are crankshaft deflection, bearings clearances, rotor axial

    position, shaft bearing temperatures, sterntube bearing temperatures and wear

    down, Megger Test etc. Except from the main machinery items some of the

    auxiliary ones require extra care. As a result crew also takes various

    measurement from Coolers, Heaters, Pumps, Fans and Filters.

    o Visual Inspection: Engine Crew perform periodic inspection to various critical

    places. Such as crankcase, bedplate structure, thrust bearings, vibration

    dampers, ducts etc.

    There are some other types of maintenance which either not commonly used

    onboard ships or they combine all above types together. Some of them are:

    d. Opportunistic Maintenance

    In this type, maintenance is take place when there is free time for crew and the system

    is not in operation mode. For example an unplanned overhauling of a purifier by

    replacing all tear and wear parts despite the scheduled major overhauling as per PMS.

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    19/26

    19Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    3.1 Reliability Centered Maintenance (RCM)

    In this type, maintenance procedures are scheduled based on a qualitative risk based

    method in order to find the optimum balance between the three majors types of

    maintenance.

    In any case, as it is compulsory each vessel to maintain the minimum safety

    standards, Classification Societies in order to ensure that they have established

    onboard periodical machinery renewal surveys on a regular basis which are:

    Annual Inspection

    Intermediate Inspection

    Special Survey/ Dry-docking Inspection

    Below we can see an example of daily maintenance hours of engine crew:

    Fig10. The Ship Crews maintenance Hours

    (Source: Shields et al. 1996)

    Finally if the vessel has an approved type of Machinery Maintenance Plan, some

    of the machinery items can be credited for survey based on examination by the Chief

    Engineer which has as an advantage the reduction of Class Surveyor onboard visits

    and less Classification Fees.

    In Appendix I are shown which items can be credited by Class surveyor and

    which by ships Chief Engineer.

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    20/26

    20Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    4. Summary Table

    ChemicalIndustry

    MaritimeIndustry

    Corrective Maintenance performedonly in case of a

    component failure. Usefulin case a specific

    component is at the

    completion of its lifetime

    Applicable in the maritimesector as well, for instancelaid-up ships or ships close

    to be scrapped

    Preventive Applicable in both sectors, performed on calendarbased intervals

    o PMS Chemical plants use themethod of planned

    maintenance by regularlyreplacing plant equipment

    The main maintenancemethod in maritime

    industry.

    o KPI Not applicable in thechemical industry

    Implemented mostly innew-building ships

    o TMSA, ISM Not applicable in thechemical industry Highly applicable by tankercompaniesPredictive Maintenance takes place when the maximum intervals

    reached. The various applicable techniques in eachsector are presented below:

    o RCM

    o RBI

    o ConMon

    o CMMS

    Opportunistic This method is used in both industries when anunplanned opportunity becomes available

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    21/26

    21Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    Reliability tools &Techniques

    Both sectors use those tools but due to high complexityeach industry selects the most adequate ones

    Qualitative tools

    o FMEA

    o HAZOP

    oSWIFT Quantitative tools

    o FTA

    o Monte Carlo

    Rules / Regulations Very strict rules due tothe hazardous working

    environment (contact withdeadly substances and

    fatal accidents)

    Strict rules depending onthe type of the vessel andthe navigation area. Vary

    among countries

    Personnel training High level trainedpersonnel

    Well trained personnel

    Spare Parts Easy accessible aschemical plants are

    located on-shore

    Impossible when thevessel is underway

    Responsible personnelfor maintenance

    Ship crew, externalworkshop, shipyard

    Maintenance department

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    22/26

    22Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    5. Conclusion

    To conclude, it must be mentioned that the role of maintenance is utmost

    importance in both Chemical and Maritime Industry as it keeps all the equipment in

    good operation condition avoiding any stoppages, increasing items lifecycle and the

    most significant, to reach the desired productivity. Both maritime and chemical are

    quite complex industries so an advanced and well organized maintenance is valuable

    for the smooth operation of a vessel or a chemical plant respectively.

    However that there are differences between the methods and the tools which are

    used for maintenance. One of the main differences between these two sectors is thatin Maritime one, the onboard crew have to monitor the condition, proceed with regular

    intervals, analyze and evaluate the data at their own criticism as the technical

    department is located far away without being easy contactable any time. Another

    importance difference is the availability of the spare parts which in maritime industry it

    could take many days to reach to the vessel something that may cause great loss of

    earnings due to this delay. In order each company to maintain the imposed standards,

    customers satisfaction, highest quality in the most cost efficient way sometimes

    combines more than one of the above mentioned maintenance methods but on

    different way.

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    23/26

    23Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    6. References

    1. Optimization of Preventive Maintenance in Chemical Process Plants, DuyQuang andMiguel Bagajewicz, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, May 2010

    2. Chemical, Petrochemical and Pharmaceutical, Appendix V, Michiel P.H Brongers and

    Ivelisse Tubens

    3. Best practice for Risk Based Inspection as a part of plant integrity management, TWI and

    Royal & SunAlliance Engineering, 2001

    4. An expert system for reliability centered maintenance in the chemical industry, D.J.Fonseca and G.M. Knapp , Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Alabama,

    2000

    5. Application of Risk Based maintenance with life and financial assessment on fossil-fired

    power plants, Akio Fuji, Hruki Eguchi, Chie Fukuoka, Tatsuro Tanoue, Research

    Laboratory of Ishikawajima-Harima Heavy Industries Co, 2015

    6. Maintenance and Changes, INTERNATIONAL SOCIAL SECURITY ASSOCIATION

    (ISSA), 2007

    7. Application of Risk and Reliability Methods for Developing equipment Maintenance

    strategy, Jens P. Tronskar ,DNV , November 2004

    8. Maintenance and hazardous substances- maintenance in the chemical industry.

    European Agency for Safety and Health at work

    9. Maintenance and Changes in Plants with High Safety Requirements ,ISSA, 2007

    10. Study of existing Reliability Centered Maintenance (RCM) approaches used in different

    industries, N. Cotaina, F. Matos, J. Chabrol, P. Pete, University of Madrid

    11. Development of Ship Maintenance Performance Measurement Framework to

    Assess the Decision Making Process to Optimize in Ship Maintenance Planning,

    Yousef Alhouli, 2011

    12. Inspection-based Preventive Maintenance, Paul Dean, Shire Systems Limited

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    24/26

    24Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    13. Machinery Planned Maintenance and Condition Monitoring, LRS, Shipwright,

    March 2013

    14. Good Maintenance On Board Ships, ClassNK, January 2015

    15. Considerations for Classification Societies with Respect to Vibration ConditionMonitoring (VCM), Maryon Williams-John McNeil, 2011

    16. Probabilistic risk assessment of condition monitoring of marine diesel engines,

    Dikis Konstantinos-Lazakis Iraklis- Turan Osman, 2014

    17. Risk-Informed Regulation of Marine Systems Using FMEA, US Coast Guard

    Marine Safety Center

    18. International Maritime Organization, Solas, 2014

    19. Internation Maritime Organization, International Safety Management (ISM)Code and Guidelines on Implementation of the ISM Code 2010, 2014

    20. International Association of Classification Societies, IACS

    21. System Availability & Maintenance Hand-outs, Dr. I. Lazakis

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    25/26

    25Stais Giorgos|Gkoumas Dimitrios

    7. Appendix

    Fig11. List of Machinery items examined by Surveyor and C/E

    (Source: Lloyds Register Ship Right March 2013)

  • 7/25/2019 Coursework 1 Stais Gkoumas 97.5%

    26/26

    Fig12. Continuous of the List of Machinery items examined by Surveyor and C/E

    (Source: Lloyds Register Ship Right March 2013)