28
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

Crist PtolemaicEnvironmentalism Final · 2020. 1. 18. · 6!%! #)" " """""

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • !""

    !"#$%&'()*+,-(.#,&%,"'$(/&(*

    +($%%,*0.(/"*

    !

    "#$!%&'($&)!*+$$,!-.+/!!"#$%"&"!'%0$!(&).!1+.%/!'(+'23%)(.&!(&!)#$!4$33$&(5)('!$+%!).!

    +$6$+!).!)#$!(%1()$/!-.+3/7!8)!-%5!%!-.+3/!)#%)!5)+$)'#$/!6+.0!)#$!9$/()$++%&$%&!1%5(&!).!

    8&/(%:!%&/!6+.0!)#$!;%2'%525!0.2&)%(&5!).!)#$!(+$A12(3/(&?:!%33(%&'$5!%&/!

    '.&B2$5)57!CD!E)#$!(%1()$/!-.+3/:F!.$'20$&$!.6!'.2+5$!0$%&)!)#$!-.+3/!(%1()$/!1D!

    >$.>3$7!G#%)!)#$!'.&'$>)!(0>3($/!1D!$H'325(.&:!1D!-#%)!()!>%55$/!.@$+!(&!5(3$&'$:!(5!)#%)!

    &.%&5!/.!&.)!(%1()7!I&3D!>$.>3$!%+$!(%1()%&)5:!-#(3$!%&(0%35:!>3%&)5:!%&/!)#$!

    &%)2+%3!'.002&()($5!)#$D!'+$%)$!0$+$3D!$H(5)!(&!'$+)%(&!>3%'$5J2&)(3!)#$D!%+$!6.+'$/!).!

    0%,$!-%D!6.+:!.+!1$!'.&@$+)$/!).!5$+@$:!)#$!.$'20$&$7!!

    I$'20$&$!5)%&/5!.2)!%5!.&$!.6!)#$!6(+5)!#20%&!(0>$+(%3(5)('!'.&'$>)57!8)!(5!%&!(/$%!

    '.&5)()2)$/!)#+.2?#!.0())(&?!)#$!%')(.&5!)#%)!+$%3(K$!()J)#$!%55(0(3%)(.&!.6!)#$!&%)2+%3!

    -.+3/J>+$5$&)(&?!()5!0$%&(&?!(&5)$%/!(&!%!>.5()(@$!+$?(5)$+L!E)#$!-.+3/!(%1()$/!1D!

    >$.>3$7F!8)!52??$5)$/!%!,(&/!.6!>+.).A?3.1%3(K%)(.&:!5(&'$!.$'20$&$!(&'32/$/!%!

    '.50.>.3()%&!)$++%(&7((!8&/$$/:!)#+.2?#!()5!3%)$+!)+%&502)%)(.&!(&).!E$'20$&('%3F!M0$%&(&?!

    2&(@$+5%3N:!.$'20$&$!6.+$5#%/.-$/!?3.1%3(K%)(.&J#20%&()DO5!>3%&$)A-(/$!.''2>%)(.&!

    %&/!)#$!.13()$+%)(.&!.6!)#$!-(3/!)#%)!)#$!'.&'$>)!(0>3($/!%&/!)#+.2?#!-#('#!()!-%5!+$%3(K$/7!!

    I$'20$&$!'%&!1$!'#%+%')$+(K$/!%5!%!E'+D5)%33(K%)(.&!.6!'23)2+$:F(((!%!5(?&(6('%&)!5(?&!.6!

    )#$!3./?(&?!.6!%&)#+.>.'$&)+(50!(&).!3%&?2%?$!%&/!)#$+$1D!(&).!1+.%/3D!5#%+$/!>%))$+&5!.6!

    )#.2?#)7!8)!(&/('%)$5!)#%)!#20%&!1$(&?5:!5(&'$!'(@(3(K%)(.&O5!/$12):!#%@$!>+.'3%(0$/!)#$!

  • #""

    5$>%+%)$!%&/!5>$'(%3!>+$+.?%)(@$!.6!)#$!#20%&7!P.+!?$&$+%)(.&5!2&).3/:!>$.>3$!#%@$!1$$&!

    ($+()(&?!)#(5!1$3($6!5D5)$0!%&/!3(@(&?!1D!()5!'.0>%55:!)#+.2?#!'23)2+%3!'.&5)$33%)(.&5!.6!

    '.&'$>)5:!>#(3.5.>#($5:!)#$.3.?($5:!%&/!)#$.+($5:!2&)(3!23)(0%)$3DJ1D!52'#!5$+(%3:!

    (/$.3.?('%3!5$/(0$&)%)(.&5!.@$+!)#$!'.2+5$!.6!0%&D!'$&)2+($5J)#$!%&)#+.>.'$&)+('!1$3($6!

    5D5)$0!#%5!%'B2(+$/!)#$!6.2&/%)(.&%3!5)%)25!.6!E'.00.&5$&5$7E!"#(5!1$3($6!5D5)$0!

    '$+)%(&3D!#%5!%!/(66$+$&)!@%3$&'$!6.+!/(66$+$&)!(&/(@(/2%35!%&/!'23)2+$57!C2)!1+.%/3D!

    5>$%,(&?:!()!>+.6$55$5!)#%)!#20%&!1$(&?5:!1D!@(+)2$!.6!)#$!.5)$&5(13$!5>$'(%3!&%)2+$!.6!)#$(+!

    '.&5'(.25&$55!%&/!5,(335:!%+$!$55$&)(%33D!/(5)(&')!6+.0!.)#$+!5>$'($5:!52>$+(.+!(&!)#$(+!6.+0!

    .6!1$(&?!M-#('#!(&'32/$5!'&(")*+,'+!)#$!%1(3()D!).!+$%5.&:!6.+$5$$!)#$(+!.-&!/$%)#:!%&/!

    )$++%6.+0!@(%!)$'#&.3.?DN:!%&/!$&)()3$/!>+(0%'D!-()#!+$5>$')!).!#%@(&?!)#$(+!(&)$+$5)5!0$)!

    >+(.+!).!%33!$35$7!.'$&)+(50!)#25!'.&5)+2')5!%&!$H(5)$&)(%3!%>%+)#$(/!1$)-$$&:!.&!)#$!

    .&$!#%&/:!#20%&5!%5!%!/(5)(&')(@$!5>$'($5A1$(&?!-()#!5>$'(%3!>+(@(3$?$5!%&/:!.&!)#$!.)#$+:!

    %33!.)#$+!3(6$!6.+05!+$?%+/$/:!0.+$!.+!3$55:!%5!)#$!25%13$!.+!/(5>3%'$%13$!E0$+$3D!3(@(&?7F(@!!!

    .'$&)+(50O5!$&)+$&'#0$&)!(&!)#$!'23)2+$!%''.2&)5!6.+!()5!>$+@%5(@$&$55!%&/!

    %>>%+$&)!&%)2+%3&$55:!D$)!()!(5!&.)!1$D.&/!)#$!+$%'#!.6!'+()('%3!(&B2(+D:!/(55$')(.&:!%&/!

    +$62)%)(.&7!".!(&B2(+$!(&).!%&)#+.>.'$&)+(50!(5!).!%5,!-#%)!,(&/!.6!1$3($6!5D5)$0!()!(57!"#$!

    2&B2$5)(.&$/!'.&@(')(.&!-()#!-#('#!>$.>3$!2>#.3/!)#$!%&)#+.>.'$&)+('!'+$/.!1$3($5!()5!

    '#%+%')$+(K%)(.&!%5!0$+$!1$3($6:!1$'%25$!()!(5!(&!)#$!&%)2+$!.6!1$3($6!).!1$:!%)!3$%5)!-)'%+*

    .+#'":!.>$&!).!B2$5)(.&(&?!%&/!+$3(&B2(5#0$&)!(&!)#$!6%'$!.6!%!1$))$+!%3)$+&%)(@$7!$'(%3!$&)()3$0$&)5:!1D!)#$!52&/+D!$@(/$&'$!%33!%+.2&/!25J(5!).!

    #D>.5)%)(K$!%&!2&/$+5)%&/(&?!.6!)#$!#20%&!-#('#!)#$!$@(/$&'$!%33!%+.2&/!25!52+$3D!

    +$63$')5!.&3D!1$'%25$!#20%&5!#%@$!%+3"!)#%)!$@(/$&'$:!)#+.2?#!%')(.&5!)#%)!)#$(+!5$&5$!.6!

  • $""

    5>$'(%3&$55!#%5!(&5>(+$/!%&/!(&6.+0$/:!).!/.!5.7!G$!6(&/!.2+5$3@$5!)#$&!(&!)#$!%-,-%+/!

    '.&'$>)2%3!5>%'$!.6!%!E1$3($6!5D5)$0FJ)#%)!.6!%&)#+.>.'$&)+(50!%5!8!5,$)'#$/!()!%1.@$J

    -#('#!'%&&.)!1$!'.&@(&'(&?3D!'#%+%')$+(K$/!%5!$()#$+!0$+$!1$3($6!.+!'$+)%(&!,&.-3$/?$7!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    ".!1$!.>$&!).!/(5'$+&(&?!)#$!#(5).+('%33D!'.&5)+2')$/!%&/!+$'.&5)+2')$/!'#%+%')$+!.6!

    %&)#+.>.'$&)+(50Q!()5!%'#($@$/!3$?()(0%'D!%5!%!0%))$+!.6!'.&B2$5)!%&/!.6)$&!@(.3$&'$:!%&/!

    &.)!%!+$523)!.6!)#$!+(?#)623!>+$+.?%)(@$:!.+!&%)2+$:!.6!)#$!#20%&Q!()5!'.00.&5$&5('%3!

    $&)+$&'#0$&)!%5!%!'.+.33%+D!.6!)#$!$+%52+$!.6!)#$!&.%&!M>#D5('%3!.13()$+%)(.&:!

    /(5'2+5(@$!1$3())3$0$&):!.+!)#$!5(0>3$!(&@(5(1(3()D!.6!)#$!@%&B2(5#$/!%)!%33!3$@$35!.6!

    >$+'$>)(.&NQ!()5!@(').+D!%5!%!>$+#%>5!.&'$A$@()%13$:!12)!(&'+$%5(&?3D!(&$5'%>%13$:!#(5).+('%3!

    '.2+5$!-#('#!#%5!1$$&!$&)+%(&(&?!%!)(0$!.6!+$',.&(&?J)#$!)(0$!-#$&!.$'20$&$!-.23/!1$!

    %33!)#$+$!(5!).!5$$L!).!1$!.>$&!).!/(5'$+&(&?!)#$5$!B2%3()($5!.6!%&)#+.>.'$&)+(50!)#%)!(&B2(+D!

    0%,$5!%@%(3%13$:!)#$+$1D!5$$(&?!()!(&!%!&.@$3:!&.&A'.00.&5$&5('%3!3(?#):!(5!).!2&/$+5)%&/!

    )#%)!()!0%D!'.0>$33(&?3D!1$!/$5'+(1$/!%5!E6%35$!,&.-3$/?$7F!!!

    P%35$!,&.-3$/?$!(5!)#$!0.5)!.15)(&%)$!5>$'($5!.6!1$3($6:!6.+!()!)$&/5!).!+$5(5)!

    /(53./?(&?!2&)(3!)#$!@$+D!0.0$&)!-#$&!()!'%&!+$5(5)!&.!0.+$7!"#$+$!$H(5)!&.)%13$!$H%0>3$5!

    .6!6%35$!,&.-3$/?$!5D5)$05:!%,(&!).!)#$!'+$/.!.6!%&)#+.>.'$&)+(50!(&!)#$!2&5-$+@(&?!

    '.&@(')(.&!-()#!-#('#!)#$D!-$+$!#$3/!%&/!)#$!$&)('$0$&)5!.6!?+%&/$2+!)#%)!2&/$+>(&&$/!

    )#$0L!&%0$3D:!)#$!,&.-3$/?$!)#%)!)#$!R%+)#!(5!)#$!'$&)$+!.6!)#$!2&(@$+5$!%+.2&/!-#('#!

    >3%&$)5:!9..&:!%&/!S2&[email protected]@$Q!%&/!%35.!)#$!,&.-3$/?$!)#%)!#20%&5!-$+$!5>$'(%33D!

    '+$%)$/!(&!)#$!(0%?$!.6!*./7!I6!)#$!5%0$!$>(5)$0('!5)%)25!%&/!,(&!'.&)$&)!(5!T25)!,&.-(&?J

    /$$>3D!%&/!%30.5)!(++$62)%13DJ)#%)!#20%&5!%+$!/(66$+$&):!5>$'(%3:!%&/!%3-%D5!'.0$!6(+5)7!

    8&/$$/:!()!(5!)#(5!'.&@(')(.&!)#%)!>%+)(%33D!?+.2&/$/!)#$!3.&?5)%&/(&?!,&.-3$/?$!5D5)$05!.6!

  • %""

    R%+)#A'$&)$+$/!%5)+.&.0D!%&/!;+$%)(.&(50:!6.+!-#%)!%33!)#+$$!6%35$!-%D5!.6!,&.-(&?!#%@$!

    (&!'.00.&!(5!5$36A?3.+(6('%)(.&7!G#$&!;.>$+&('25!-+.)$!)#$!)+%')!)#%)!-.23/!+$62)$!

    =).3$0%('!%5)+.&.0D!#$!3$)!)#$!0%&25'+(>)!5():!@(+)2%33D!2&+$%/:!.&!#(5!/$5,!6.+!M%)!3$%5)N!

    &(&$!D$%+57@!;#%+3$5!U%+-(&!,$>)!#(5!,&.-3$/?$!.6!)#$!6%')[email protected])(.&!5$'+$)!6.+!)-$&)DA

    .&$J%&/!-#$&!#$!5#%+$/!()!-()#!#(5!1.)%&(5)!6+($&/!V.5$>#!U%3).&!4..,$+!#$!/$5'+(1$/!

    )#$!0.0$&)!.6!'.&6(/$&'$!%5!E'.&6$55(&?!02+/$+7F!"#$5$!5).+($5!'.&@$D!)#$!6.33.-(&?L!)#%)!

    5)%&/%+/!1$3($6!5D5)$05:!$@$&!(6!#(?#3D!+$5>$')$/!%&/!5$'2+$3D!$&5'.&'$/:!'%&!1$!

    (&)$++.?%)$/Q!12)!6%35$!,&.-3$/?$!(5!.&3D!'.&6+.&)$/!%)!.&$O5!>$+(37!!!

    ".!'#%+%')$+(K$!%&)#+.>.'$&)+(50!%5!%!M6%35$N!-%D!.6!,&.-(&?!(5!%&.)#$+!-%D!.6!

    5%D(&?!)#%)!()!/$5'+(1$5!)"+,'(4!6.+!0.5)!>$.>3$7!.-$+!)#%)!

    %&)#+.>.'$&)+(50!'3%(057!8)!>.55$55$5!)#$!0.+%3!>.-$+!.6!%3-%D5!>+(.+()(K(&?!#20%&!&$$/5!

    %&/!/$5(+$57!8)!>+.@(/$5!)#$!$'.&.0('!%&/!>.3()('%3!>.-$+!.6!%>>+.>+(%)(&?!-#%)$@$+!

    #20%&5!'%&!25$!6+.0!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/J6+.0!.'$%&5:!6.+$5)5:!+(@$+5:!?+%553%&/5:!'.%5)5:!

    -(3/3(6$:!/.0$5)('!%&(0%35:!?$&.0$5:!.+!)#$!'+25)!.6!)#$!R%+)#7!.'$&)+(50!'+$%)$5!

    )#$!.&).3.?('%3!>.-$+!).!$3(/$!)#$!%')5!.6!)%,(&?!+0!%')5!.6!)%,(&?:!)#+.2?#!)#$(+!'$%5$3$55!

    M50%33!).!0$?%N!$&%')0$&)5!%5!2&+$0%+,%13D!.+/(&%+D7!.-$+!.6!

    ()5!'.00.&5$&5('%3!5)%&/(&?!%&)#+.>.'$&)+(50!,$$>5!>$.>3$!2&/$+!)#$!5>$33!.6!%33!.6!)#$!

    %1.@$7!P.+!)#$!/.0(&%&)!0(&/5$):!-()#!&%+D!%!'.&5'(.25!)#.2?#):!52'#!(5!)#$!+$%3!-.+3/L!-$!

    '%0$:!-$!5%-:!-$!'.&B2$+$/7!(+$J

    -(33!>3%'$!.&$!.2)5(/$:!.+!%)!)#$!0%+?(&5:!.6!$@$+D!#20%&!'321!)#$+$!(5L!%'%/$0(':!>.3()('%3:!

    +$3(?(.25:!.+!'23)2+%37!S.!-#(3$!(&!)#$!0./$+&!5$'23%+!$+%!B2$5)(.&(&?!>.3()('%3!+$?(0$5:!

    +$3(?(.25!/.?0%5:!>.-$+!5)+2')2+$5:!%&/!$@$&!5'($&)(6('!)#$.+($5!.+!6%')5!(5!,.5#$+!%&/!.6)$&!

    >+%(5$-.+)#D:!B2$5)(.&(&?!#20%&!$0>(+$!(5!&.)7!W2$5)(.&(&?!)#%)!+$%3()D!-(33!$%+&!.&$!

  • &""

    '$+)%(&!2&5%@.+D!3%1$357!M('7@(!R&@(+.&0$&)%3!)#(&,$+5!%&/!%')(@(5)5!-()#!/$$>A$'.3.?('%3!3$%&(&?5:!-#.!

    #%@$!'.2&)$+$/!)#$!#20%&!+$?(0$!.&!R%+)#!-()#!)#$!(/$%35!.6!1(.)('!0$01$+5#(>!%&/!

    1(.5>#$+('%3!$?%3()%+(%&(50:!#%@$!1$$&!'%33$/!%33!)#$5$!&%0$57!Y$'$&)3D!)#$(+!>$+5>$')(@$!

    #%5!1$$&!>+.'3%(0$/!/$%/:!/D562&')(.&%3:!.+!>%55Z7!C2)!-#(3$!52'#!3%1$35!(0>+$55!-()#!)#$(+!

    /(50(55(@$!>.-$+:!-$!&$$/!&.)!1$!3$/!%5)+%D!1D!)#%)!>.-$+J6.+!()!/.$5!&.)!+$63$')!.&!)#$!

    5.1+($)D!.6!B2$5)(.&(&?!#20%&!/.0(&%)(.&:!12)!+%)#$+!$@(/$&'$5!)#$!)+$0$&/.25!5-%D!.6!

    )#%)!/.0(&%)(.&!1%',$/!/.213D!1D!)#$!%2)#.+()D!.6!#(5).+D!%&/!1D!'$+)%(&!%30(?#)D!0%)$+(%3!

    (&)$+$5)5!)#%)!1$7!"#$!$5)%13(5#0$&)!.6!#20%&!/.0(&%)(.&J-()#!)#$!>$&$)+%)(.&!.6!

    %&)#+.>.'$&)+(50O5!0D+(%/!)$&/+(35!(&).!)#$!3(6$-.+3/:!&.)!).!5%D!(&).!$'.&.0(':!>.3()('%3:!

    %&/!(&5)()2)(.&%3!>.-$+A5)+2')2+$5J0$%&5!)#%)!)#.5$!-#.!B2$5)(.&!()5!3$?()(0%'D!'%&&.)!

    1$!?(@$&!%2/($&'$!12)!-(33!(&@%+(%13D:!6.+!)#$!)(0$!1$(&?:!1$!-+())$&!.667!P.+!()!'.0$5!/.-&!

    ).!)#(5L!)#$!(/$%)(.&%3!%&/!(&5)()2)(.&%3!5'#$0%)%!.6!#20%&!>+(@(3$?$!#%@$!3.&?!1$$&!

    '#%0>(.&$/!1D!%!/.0(&%&)!'(@(3(K%)(.&!-#('#!#%5!'%+@$/!>3%&$)%+D!+$%3()D!).!+$63$')!)#$!'23)!

    .6!#20%&!5>$'(%3&$55:!52'#!)#%)!1$)-$$&!)#$!S'D33%!.6!%&)#+.>.'$&)+('!(/$%5!%&/!)#$!

    ;#%+D1/(5!.6!?3.1%3!)$++%6.+0(&?:!)#$!#20%&!0(&/!#%5!@(+)2%33D!K$+.!/$?+$$5!.6!6+$$/.0!).!

    )#(&,!.2)5(/$!)#$!1.H!.6!R%+)#!)%,$.@$+!%&/!5$36A%+1()+%)$/!+23$7!!!!!!!!!!!!

    C$!)#%)!%5!()!0%D:!%6)$+!0(33$&&(%!.6!)#$!$0>(+$O5!0%+'#!%+$!)#$!'.&5$B2$&'$57!"#$!

    '.&5$B2$&'$5!%+$!'%33$/!)#$!S(H)#!RH)(&')(.&7!"#$D!%+$!'%33$/!'3(0%)$!'#%&?$:!.'$%&!

    %'(/(6('%)(.&:!%&/!)#$!*+$%)!=%'(6('!*%+1%?$!=%)'#7!"#$D!%+$!'%33$/!3%+?$A5'%3$!/$6.+$5)%)(.&!

  • '""

    %&/!/$5$+)(6('%)(.&7!"#$!'.&5$B2$&'$5!%+$!'%33$/![\\!/$%/!K.&$5!-.+3/-(/$7!"#$D!%+$!

    '%33$/!]\^!.6!)#$!1(?!6(5#!(&!)#$!.'$%&5!%+$!?.&$:!%&/!E$0>)D!6.+$5)!5D&/+.0$7F!"#$!

    '.&5$B2$&'$5!%+$!'%33$/!)#$!5)(63(&?!.6!%&(0%3!0(?+%)(.&5!%&/!)#$!'.&5)+(')(.&!.6!-(3/3(6$O5!

    #.0$!+%&?$57!"#$D!%+$!%35.!'%33$/!)#$!'3.5(&?!.6!)#$!#20%&!#$%+)!).!)#$!5266$+(&?!.6!6%+0!

    %&(0%357!"#$!'.&5$B2$&'$5!%+$!'%33$/!$'.3.?('%3!%0&$5(%:!.&!)#$!.&$!#%&/:!%&/!%!-(/$&(&?!

    -%@$!.6!?+($@(&?!6.+!3.5)!1$(&?5!%&/!>3%'$5:!.&!)#$!.)#$+7!"./%D!)#$!-#.3$!>3%&$)!(5!)#$!

    .$'20$&$!%&/!-#%)!)#$!3%))$+!(/$%!5)%+)$/!.2)!1D!(0>3('()3D!$+%5(&?J)#$!+$%3()D!)#%)!

    &.%&5!3!!(%1()!%&/!#%@$!$B2%3!>+$+.?%)(@$!).!63.2+(5#!#$+$!%5!-$!/.J#%5!1$'.0$!

    0%&(6$5)!1D!)(0$:!)#$!+$@$3%).+:!%5!%!&.%&!#.3.'%25)!)#%)!(5!&.)!$@$&!>$+0())$/!).!1$!

    '%33$/!.&$7!86!%)!)#$!#$%+)!.6!)#(5!T2??$+&%2)!3($5!)#$!%')(.&%13$!(/$%!.6!#20%&!5$36A%>>.(&)$/!

    +23$:!)#$&!%+$!-$!&.)!'%33$/!).!)%,$!%(0_!!!!!!!!!

    !

    1%#23.%%,/*)4##/%*/5/"'(,(,3*45&',*6#&(,(#,**

    P%+!6+.0!)%,(&?!%(0:!%!)-$&)DA6(+5)!'$&)2+D!@.'%3!'.&)(&?$&)!.6!$&@(+.&0$&)%3(50J

    +$6$++$/!).!@%+(.253D!%5!>.5)A$&@(+.&0$&)%3(50:!&$-!$&@(+.&0$&)%3(50:!$'.A>+%?0%)(50:!

    %&/!$'.A.>)(0(50:!%&/!.6)$&!%33($/!-()#!)#$!+$'$&)!>.>23%+!%&/!5'($&)(6('!>()'#!).!+$&%0$!

    .2+!?$.3.?('%3!$>.'#!)#$!!.'$&$J(5!/(5(&'3(&$/!6+.0!/(5>2)(&?!#20%&!/.0(&%)(.&7!

    8&5)$%/!()!.>)5!6.+!)#$!+$%3(5)('!-.+,!.6!3+%+5"*#!&()!,!%&/!.6!+$6.+0(&?!)#$!-%D5!#20%&5!

    $H$+'(5$!>3%&$)%+D!'#%+?$7!`$.A?+$$&5:!%5!8!-(33!+$6$+!).!)#$!$H>.&$&)5!.6!)#(5!>3%)6.+0:!5$$,!

    ).!+$/+$55!)#$!%/@$+5$!'.&5$B2$&'$5!.6!.2+!(0>%')!-#(3$!+$6+%(&(&?!6+.0!'#%33$&?(&?!)#$!

    #(5).+('%3!(0>235$!).-%+/!R%+)#O5!.''2>%)(.&Q!%&/!)#$D!.6)$&!$&/$%@.+!).!+$'%5)!)#$!#20%&!

    >+$5$&'$!(&!%!0.+$!5%&?2(&$!3(?#)7!!!

  • (""

    "#$!&$.A?+$$&!>3%)6.+0!%/0()5!)#%)!)#$+$!%+$!5$+(.25!$&@(+.&0$&)%3!>+.13$05!).!

    ?+%>>3$!-()#:!12)!)#$!#20%&(K%)(.&!.6!)#$!>3%&$)!(5!&.)!.&$!.6!)#$0J3$)!%3.&$!)#$(+!+..)!

    '%25$7@((!"#$!>+.13$05!%+$!'$+)%(&!#%+0623!5(/$A$66$')5!M0.5)!$5>$'(%33DN!.6!(&/25)+(%3!

    '(@(3(K%)(.&:!-()#!'3(0%)$!'#%&?$!252%33D!'.&5(/$+$/!)#$!?+%@$5)7!C2)*)#$!/(5>.5()(.&!.6!

    '(@(3(K%)(.&!).!25$!)#$!R%+)#!%5!)#.2?#!()!-$+$!/$$/$/!%5!#20%&!>+(@%)$!>+.>$+)D!(5!3$6)!

    2&>+.13$0%)(K$/!%&/!)+$%)$/!(&!)#$!B2.)(/(%&!0./%3()D!.6!E&.+0%37F!S.0$!&$.A?+$$&5:!

    +$'.?&(K(&?!)#$!>.55(1(3()D!)#%)!1(.>#D5('%3!3(0()5!0%D!#%@$!1$$&!M.+!0(?#)!5..&!1$N!

    1+$%'#$/!1D!#20%&!$H'$55$5:!5$$,!).!(/$&)(6D!%&/!'(+'205'+(1$!>3%&$)%+D!1.2&/%+($5!6.+!

    ,$D!>%+%0$)$+5!(&!.+/$+!).!525)%(&!%!?3.1%3!$&@(+.&0$&)!)#%)!>+.@(/$5!E%!5%6$!.>$+%)(&?!

    5>%'$!6.+!#20%&()DF!).!'.&)(&2$!()5!.&-%+/:!(6!+$6.+0$/:!0%+'#7!@(((!!

    %&5(.&(50:!%&/!$@$&!'$3$1+%)(&?!()5!62)2+$!

    $H)+%)$++$5)+(%3!@$&)2+$57(H!"#$!R%+)#O5!'.3.&(K%)(.&!(5!&.)!>.+)+%D$/!%5!)#$!$H$+'(5$!.6!

    >.-$+!.@$+!)#$!1(.5>#$+$!).!5$+@$!#20%&!(&)$+$5)5!M%&/!$5>$'(%33D!)#$!(&)$+$5)5!.6!$3()$5N:!

    12)!%5!%!5(?&!.6!)#$!#20%&!+%'$O5!?./3(,$!5)%)2+$7!"2+&(&?!@(+)2%33D!)#$!$&)(+$!?3.1$!(&).!E)#$!

    (%1()$/!-.+3/F!5#.-'%5$5!%!52>$+3%)(@$!B2%3()D!.6!)#$!#20%&:!+%)#$+!)#%&!0%&(6$5)(&?!)#$!

    '2023%)(@$!.2)'.0$!.6!3.&?!'$&)2+($5!.6!/.0(&%)(&?!&%)2+$!1D!)#$!3(?#)5!.6!%!#20%&!

    52>+$0%'(5)!-.+3/@($-7!P%0.253D:!(&!)#$!-.+/5!.6!S)$-%+/!C+%&/:!-$!%+$!%5!?./5:H!%&/J(&!

    )#$!(&)$+$5)5!.6!,$$>(&?!.2+!>3%&$)!%!-.+,%13$!5)%?$!6.+!.2+!2&6.3/(&?!/$5)(&DJ-$!#%@$!).!

    ?$)!?../!%)!()!Ma\\]Q!5$$!%35.!XD&%5!a\bbN7!!!!!!!!!!!

  • )""

    *$))(&?!?../!%)!1$(&?!?./!(&@.3@$5!0%,(&?!)#$!)%,$.@$+!.6!)#$!>3%&$)!525)%(&%13$7H(!

    ".!)#%)!$66$')!.&$!+$B2(+$0$&)!(5!5.2&/!?3.1%3!0%&%?$0$&)!.6!&%)2+%3!+$5.2+'$57!G#(3$!)#$!

    (/$%!.6!E-(3/$+&$55FJ%!'.&'$>)2%3!%&/!>+%?0%)('!+.%/13.',!).!52'#!0%&%?$0$&):!%5!-$33!

    %5!).!)#$!3$?()(0%'D!.6!'.&5)()2)(&?!&%)2+$!B2%!+$5.2+'$5J(5!)(+$3$553D!B2$+($/!1D!)#$!&$.A

    ?+$$&!>3%)6.+0:!)#$!'.&'$>)!.6!E&%)2+%3!+$5.2+'$5F!M%&/!,(&!'23)2+%3!'+D5)%33(K%)(.&5!.6!)#$!

    %&)#+.>.'$&)+('!'+$/.N!(5!3$6)!2&>%',$/!%5!)#.2?#!()5!>%)$&)3D!&$2)+%3!(0>.+)!>2)5!()!

    1$D.&/!/$'.&5)+2')(@$!$H$?$5(57!!

    C$5(/$5!5.2&/!+$5.2+'$!0%&%?$0$&):!%35.!(0>$+%)(@$!6.+!%//+$55(&?!+(5,5J52'#!%5!

    +$5.2+'$!/$>3$)(.&!M6.+!$H%0>3$:!6+$5#-%)$+N!.+!5(&,!.@$+3.%/!M6.+!$H%0>3$:!/%&?$+.25!

    3$@$35!.6!?+$$.25$!?%5$5NJ(5!)#$!/$>3.D0$&)!.6!)$'#&.3.?('%3!(&@$&)(.&5!%&/!5.32)(.&5:!

    -()#!5>$'(%3!$0>#%5(5!.&!'2))(&?A$/?$!)$'#&.3.?($57!M*$&$)('!$&?(&$$+(&?!%&/!

    ?$.&?(&$$+(&?!%+$!>+.0(&$&)!$H%0>3$5N7!"#$!%>>$%3!).!'2))(&?A$/?$!)$'#&.3.?($5!

    %''.0>3(5#$5!)#$!/.213$!)%5,!.6!.66$+(&?!>+.0(55.+D!&.)$5!M-#('#:!(6!$0>)D:!&.!.&$!(5!

    %''.2&)%13$!6.+N:!%&/!.6!5$(K(&?!.-&$+5#(>!.6!)#$!62)2+$!1D!$H)$&/(&?!)#$!%?$A.3/!$H$+'(5$!

    .6!)$'#&('%3!>.-$+!).!%//+$55!>+.13$05!-#(3$!5(023)%&$.253D!%@.(/(&?!+$63$')(.&!.&!

    #20%&()DO5!>.-$+A/+(@$&!0./$!.6!.>$+%)(.&!%&/!.&!)#$!%@%(3%13$!'#.('$!.6!%!0.+$!#2013$!

    >%)#7!9.+$.@$+:!%!>+$/(3$')(.&!6.+!)#$!)$'#&.3.?('%3!&.)!.&3D!5#2&5!-+$5)3(&?!-()#!#20%&!

    >3%&$)%+D!>.3()('5J(&!-#('#!$@$+D)#(&?!6+.0!0.2&)%(&).>5!).!2&/$+?+.2&/!5#%3$!%&/!6+.0!

    ?$&.0$5!).!'3(0%)$!%+$!)+$%)$/!%5!.2+!+(?#)623!)2+6J12):!%)!3$%5)!)%'()3D:!6.+)(6($5!)#%)!

    >3%&$)%+D!>.3()('5!-#('#!)$&/5!).!$&6.+'$!()5!+$?(0$!@(%!)$'#&.3.?('%3!0$%&57!!

    >+.%'#$5:!)#$!&$.A?+$$&!%?$&/%!

    %35.!$01+%'$5!)#$!52+@$(33%&'$!.6!&%)2+%3!5D5)$05!5.!%5!).!5'($&)(6('%33D!0.&().+!'#$0('%3:!

    >#D5('%3:!%&/!1(.3.?('%3!>#$&.0$&%!-()#!)#$!%(0!.6!0%(&)%(&(&?!.+!$%&'(&?!#20%&()DO5!

  • *""

    >+.5>$')57!"#$5$!(&)$+'.&&$')$/!5)+%)$?($5!M0%&%?$0$&):!)$'#&.3.?D:!%&/!52+@$(33%&'$N!

    (&@.3@$!2>?+%/(&?!%&/!6(&$A)2&(&?!)#$!+%)(.&%3(K%)(.&!.6!)$'#&('%3!0$%&5!).!5$+@$!#20%&!

    $&/5:!52'#!)#%)!'2++$&)!'#%33$&?$5:!$5>$'(%33D!)#.5$!-#('#!%+$!'(@(3(K%)(.&A)#+$%)$&(&?:!'%&!

    1$!?+%5>$/!%5!%&!.>>.+)2&()D!).!@$$+!.2+5$3@$5!.2)!.6!/%&?$+!%&/!).-%+/!%!0.+$!5$'2+$!

    %&/!?+$$&$+!#20%&!$0>(+$7!EG$!'%&!.&3D!#.>$:F!%''.+/(&?!).!?$.?+%>#$+!%&/!

    .'$&$!>+.>.&$&)!R+3$!R33(5:!E!)#%)!#20%&!5D5)$05!-(33!'.&)(&2$!)[email protected]@$!(&!)#$(+!

    '%>%'()D!).!'+$%)$!%&/!525)%(&!)#$!1(.5>#$+$!-$!-%&)!%&/!&$$/F!Ma\bb:!b\a]N7!!

    "#$!5)+%)$?D!.6!'+$%)(&?!%&/!525)%(&(&?!%!#20%&A+2&!1(.5>#$+$!+$%66(+05!)#$!

    3$?()(0%'D!.6!%&)#+.>.'$&)+(50:!%@.(/5!(&)$++.?%)(&?!.2+!+$3%)(.&5#(>!-()#!)#$!1(.5>#$+$!

    %&/!()5!-#.3$!$&5$013$!.6!3(6$!%5!%&!$)#('%3!0%))$+:!%&/!+$5.32)$3D!$5'#$-5!'.&6+.&)(&?!

    ?3.1%3!'(@(3(K%)(.&!%5!%!).)%3()%+(%&!5D5)$0!.&!R%+)#7!!

    +.5>$')!%6)$+!%337!+$/%)(.&!.6!)#$!-(3/!

    ,$$>5!25!6+.0!%>>+$'(%)(&?!)#$!1$%2)D!)#%)!(5!>%+)!.6!%33!,(&/5!.6!3%&/5'%>$5:!(&'32/(&?!

    #20%&A5#%>$/!.&$5Q!%&/!.15$55(&?!.@$+!)#$!$H>3.()%)(.&!%&/!'.&@$+5(.&!.6!)#$!&%)2+%3!

    -.+3/!3$%@$5!25!2&%13$!).!+$'.?&(K$!)#%)!&%)2+$!(5!+$5(3($&)!%&/!'.&5)%&)3D!'#%&?(&?!

    %&D-%D7!S2'#!$&@(+.&0$&)%3!+$@(5(.&(50!5$$,5!).!+$/$6(&$!#20%&()DO5!(0>%')!%5!T25)!

    %&.)#$+!1(.?$.3.?('%3!0.0$&)!.6!R%+)#O5!#(5).+DJ%&/!$@$&!%!+$0%+,%13$!.&$Q!%&/!()!

    $&/$%@.+5!).!1%&(5#!)#$!$&@(+.&0$&)%3!132$5!1D!$H)$&/(&?!%!0.+$!.>)(0(5)('!-$3'.0$!).!

    #20%&()DO5!/$'(5(@$!>+$5$&'$7!"#$!0$)%>#.+!.6!)#$!?%+/$&!M.+!.6!?%+/$&$/!>3%&$)N!(5!

    (&@.,$/!).!$&@(5(.&!)#$!>+$5$&)!%&/!62)2+$!-.+3/J)(/D!(&!5.0$!>3%'$5:!.@$+?+.-&!(&!

    .)#$+5:!12)!5)(33!1$%2)(623:!6$'2&/:!+%012&')(.25:!%&/!$@$+!(&!632H7!"#(5!?3.1%3!?%+/$&!(&!)#$!

    0%,(&?:!1.++.-(&?!)#$!-.+/5!.6!"#$!`%)2+$!;.&5$+@%&'DO5!'#($6!5'($&)(5):!=$)$+!c%+$(@%!

  • !+""

    M%&/!#(5!'.33$%?2$5N:!-(33!&.)!1$!E%!'%+$6233D!0%&('2+$/!%&/!+(?(/!.&$:F!12)!%!)%&?3$!.6!

    &%)2+%3!$'.5D5)$05!%3.&?!-()#!3%&/5!6.+!6../!>+./2')(.&:!0(&$+%3!$H)+%')(.&:!2+1%&!'$&)$+5:!

    %&/!5.!.&!Ma\bbN7!"#$!#20%&A/.0(&%)$/!$+%!.>$&(&?!(&/$6(&()$3D!1$6.+$!25!'%&!1$!%&!

    $>.'#!E+(>$!-()#!#20%&!/(+$')$/!.>>.+)2&()DF!MR33(5!a\baN7!8)!(5!%!-.+3/!)#%)!(6!-$!'%&&.)!

    1+(&?!.2+5$3@$5!).!$01+%'$:!%)!3$%5)!-$!'%&!+$5(?&!.2+5$3@$5!).7!P.+!E-#(3$!)#$+$!(5!&.)#(&?!

    >%+)('23%+3D!?../!%1.2)!%!>3%&$)!#.))$+!)#%&!.2+!%&'$5).+5!$@$+!$H>$+($&'$/J&.)!).!

    0$&)(.&!.&$!6+$$!.6!-(3/!6.+$5)5!.+!-(3/!6(5#J()!5$$05!%33!)..!$@(/$&)!)#%)!#20%&!5D5)$05!

    %+$!>+$>%+$/!).!%/%>)!).!%&/!>+.5>$+!(&!)#$!#.))$+:!3$55!1(./(@$+5$!>3%&$)!)#%)!-$!%+$!125(3D!

    '+$%)(&?F!M(1(/7N!!!!

    "#$!5)%)$!.6!)#$!-.+3/!'%>)2+$/!@(%!)#$!?%+/$&!0$)%>#.+!5.2&/5!(&&.'2.25!$&.2?#7!

    C2)!).!(&@.,$!%!/(66$+$&)!0$)%>#.+!6+.0!>.>23%+!'23)2+$:!.>)(&?!6.+!)#$!?%+/$&$/A>3%&$)!

    (0%?$!(5!3(,$!)%,(&?!)#$!132$!>(33:!(&5)$%/!.6!)#$!+$/!.&$:!6+.0!9.+>#$25O!$H)$&/$/!#%&/J

    '#..5(&?!E)#$!13(55623!(?&.+%&'$!.6!(3325(.&!.@$+!)#$!>%(&623!)+2)#!.6!+$%3()D7FH((!"#$!>%(&623!

    +$%3()D!.6!9%)+(HA>3%&$)!(5!)#%)!()!-(33!1$!'#.',A6233!-()#!%?+('23)2+%3!'#$',$+1.%+/5!%&/!

    ?+%K(&?!3%&/5:!;$+%)(.&5:!(&/25)+(%3!$&$+?D!3%&/5'%>$5:!)#$0$!

    >%+,5!%&/!+$5.+)5:!#(?#-%D!5D5)$05:!+.%/5:!%&/!>%+,(&?!3.)5:!1(33(.&5!.6!'%+5!%&/!.)#$+!

    @$#('3$5:!5>+%-3(&?!'()($5!%5!-$33!%5!5212+1%&:!$H2+1%&:!%&/!+2+%3!5$))3$0$&)5:!0%335:!

    3%&/6(335:!%(+>.+)5:!%&/!1$%'#6+.&)!/$@$3.>0$&)7!*3.1%3!)+%/$!%&/!)+%@$3:!-()#!)#$(+!a[de!

    )+%66('!.6!%3+$%/D!#2?$!B2%&)()($5!.6!5)266:!-(33!$5'%3%)$!$&.+0.253DJ%5!-(33!)#$!$&)+.>D!.6!

    &%)2+$!'.&@$+5(.&:!1(./(@$+5()D!3.55:!%&/!&.H(.25!>.332)(.&!)#%)!%''.0>%&($5!)#$0!M5$$!

    X$&K$&!$)!%37!a\baN7!"#$!>+$5$&'$!.6!#20%&5!-(33!1$!$@$+D-#$+$!>%3>%13$!(&!)#(5!-.+3/!

    /$@.(/!.6!%&D!13%&,!5>.)5!.&!)#$!0%>J%!-.+3/!25$/:!0%&%?$/:!0.&().+$/:!?+(//$/:!%&/!

    +$/2'$/!).!1$(&?!,&.-%13$:!-()#!)#$!0%>!()5$36!$@$&)2%33D!)2+&$/!(&).!)#$!)$++().+D7!"#25:!

  • !!""

    .>)(&?!6.+!9.+>#$25O!!+$/!>(33:!)#$!>3%&$)O5!$'.3.?('%3!%&/!$H(5)$&)(%3!>+$/('%0$&)!(5!>3%(&:!(6!

    >%(&623:!).!5$$L!E?%+/$&$/!>3%&$)F!(5!%!$2>#$0(50!6.+!'.3.&(K$/!R%+)#7!$&&(&?!%&.)#$+!(&)$+$5)(&?!'#%>)$+!.6!&%)2+%3!#(5).+D:!12)!#$+%3/(&?!)#$!$&/!.6!%!5213(0$!

    .&$J5.!3.&?!%5!-$!5)%D!)#$!'.2+5$!).-%+/!%!'.0(&?!-.+3/!.6!]:!b\:!.+!0.+$!1(33(.&!>$.>3$:!

    +2&&(&?!%!?3.1%3!'%>()%3(5)!$'.&.0D:!%&/!?.@$+&(&?!1D!)#$!'.&'$()!)#%)!)#(5!>3%&$)!(5!#20%&!

    +$%3!$5)%)$7!".!>%+%>#+%5$!%2)#.+!V.#&!*+%D:!)#$!#.++.+!-$!5#.23/!63$$!(5!0%,(&?!52'#!%!

    #20%&(K$/!-.+3/!(&!-#('#!#20%&5!$&'.2&)$+!.&3D!+$63$')(.&5!.6!)#$05$3@$5!Ma\bf:!bghN7!!!!!!!!!!!!

    "#$!@($-!)#%)!#20%&()D!(5!%&!(&)$?+%3!>%+)!.6!R%+)#O5!&%)2+%3!#(5).+D:!%&/!)#+.2?#!

    .2+!2&(B2$!>.-$+5!-$!%+$!'+$%)(&?!&$-!$H>+$55(.&5!.6!&%)2+$:!(5!%!5)%&/%+/!)#+$%/!(&!)#$!

    &$.A?+$$&!3()$+%)2+$7!"#(5!>$+5>$')(@$!.&!.2+!5#%>(&?!.6!)#$!1(.5>#$+$!&+($)+,'6"0!)#$!

    #20%&!(0>%')J%&/!252%33D!(&!%&!.66#%&/$/!0%&&$+L!1$'%25$!-#%)!(5!)#$!#20%&!>+$5$&'$:!

    %6)$+!%33:!(6!&.)!%!0%&(6$5)%)(.&!.6!&%)2+$_!3$:!5(&'$!-$!,&.-!)#%)!$'.5D5)$05!%+$!&$@$+!5)%)(':!E)#(5!0$%&5!)#%)!&.@$3!

    i%&)#+.>.?$&('!.+!#20%&A(&632$&'$/j!$'.5D5)$05:!6%+!6+.0!1$(&?!%!&$-!>#$&.0$&.&:!

    5(0>3D!+$>+$5$&)!)#$!3%)$5)!'#%&?$5!.&!%!/D&%0('!R%+)#F!Ma\\]N7!S(0(3%+3D:!$&@(+.&0$&)%3!

    T.2+&%3(5)!P+$/!=$%+'$!%55$+)5!)#%)!'.&5)%&)!'#%&?$!(5!%!&%)2+%3!%5>$')!.6!)#$!-.+3/Q!

    E#20%&5!0%D!#%@$!/+%0%)('%33D!5>$$/$/!)#%)!2>:!12)!&.@$3)D!(5!)#$!&.+07FH(((!!

    +.6.2&/3D!'.&)$5)%13$:!

    1$'%25$!>$.>3$!M1.)#!%)!%&!(&/(@(/2%3!%&/!'23)2+%3!3$@$3N!%+$!'%>%13$!.6!$&?%?(&?!(&!@$+D!

    /(66$+$&)!,(&/5!.6!+$3%)(.&5#(>!-()#!&.%&!&%)2+$!%&/!)#$!R%+)#7!8!5210()!)#%)!6%+!6+.0!

    #20%&()DO5!(0>%')!1$(&?!E&%)2+%3:F!()5!'#%+%')$+!52>$+@$&$5!6+.0!%!5>$'($5A52>+$0%'(5):!

    %')(.&%13$!1$3($6!5D5)$0!)#%)!.&3D!+$'$&)3D!#%5!%!0(&.+()D!.6!#20%&!1$(&?5!%-%,$&$/!).!

  • !#""

    %&/!+$'.(3$/!6+.07!G()#!+$5>$')!).!-$5)$+&!'(@(3(K%)(.&J&.-!/.0(&%)(&?!#20%&!%66%(+5J

    6+.0!'3%55('%3!%&)(B2()D:!)#+.2?#!V2/$.A;#+(5)(%&!)#$.3.?D:!).!/.0(&%&)!5)+%&/5!.6!0./$+&!

    5'($&)(6('!%&/!>.3()('%3!)#.2?#):!()5!(&)$33$')2%3!'%&.&!%&/!3$?%'D!#%@$!1$$&!!7")28",%'&5,4!

    %&)#+.>.'$&)+('!M5$$!;+(5)!a\bf!%&/!+$6$+$&'$5!)#$+$(&N7!.'$&)+(50!M.+!#20%&!

    52>+$0%'DN!#%5!5#%>$/!)#$!/.0(&%&)!'23)2+$:!%&/!1.)#!.+'#$5)+%)$/!%&/!3$?()(0%)$/!%!

    >32&/$+(&?!#20%&!1$#%@(.+!).-%+/!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/7!H(@!S2'#!#20%&!1$#%@(.+!'%&!.&3D!1$!

    +$?%+/$/!%5!E&%)2+%3F!1D!$5>.25(&?!%!#%+/'.+$!&$.AU%+-(&(%&!@($-!.6!3(6$!%5!+2)#3$55:!

    '.0>$)()(@$:!%&/!62&/%0$&)%33D!5$36A'$&)$+$/7!C2)!)#(5!-$5)$+&:!>5$2/.A5'($&)(6('!@($-!(5!

    1.)#!&%++.-!%&/!525>('(.253D!5$36A5$+@(&?:!%&/!)#25!'.?$&)!.&3D!%5!%&!(/$.3.?D!%&/!&.)!%5!

    %&!$0>(+('%3!+$>+$5$&)%)(.&!.6!)#$!&%)2+$!.6!3(6$7!

    9.+$!)#%&!6%33%'(.25:!&%)2+%3(K(&?!.2+!>3%&$)%+D!)%,$.@$+!(5!%&!2&-())(&?!6.+0!.6!

    0D)#A0%,(&?:!6233D!(&)$+)-(&$/!-()#!)#$!&$.A?+$$&!$3$@%)(.&!.6!)#$!#20%&!).!?./3(,$!5)%)25!

    %&/!-()#!()5!%+/$&)!/$5(+$!).!'#+(5)$&!%!53('$!.6!?$.3.?('%3!)(0$!%6)$+!E%&)#+.>.57F!9D)#A

    0%,(&?!(5!(&)$?+%3!).!)#$!#20%&!(0%?(&%)(.&:!D$)!)#(5!'2++$&)3D!>+.>.2&/$/!0D)#.3.?D!(5!

    12)!)#$!3%)$5)!5>(&!.&!#20%&(5)('!&%+'(55(50Q!()!(5!%!0D)#.3.?D!-$!-.23/!1$!-(5$!).!2&0%5,!

    %&/!$H.+'(5$7!`%)2+%3(K(&?!)#$!/(56(?2+$0$&)!%&/!(0>.@$+(5#0$&)!.6!)#$!1(.5>#$+$:!%&/!

    5(023)%&$.253D!$3$@%)(&?!)#(5!>%+)('23%+!$66$')!%5!5)$00(&?!6+.0!#20%&()DO5!>.-$+!).!

    '+$%)$!&$-!$H>+$55(.&5!.6!&%)2+$:!(5!%!0.@$!%''.0>3(5#$/!1D!/$A#(5).+('(K(&?!)#$!#20%&L!

    E)#$!#(5).+D!.6!)#$!'.&'$>)!.6!0%&!(5!&$@$+!$H%0(&$/7!R@$+D)#(&?!.''2+5!%5!(6!)#$!5(?&!k0%&O!

    #%5!&.!.+(?(&:!&.!#(5).+('%3:!'23)2+%3:!.+!3(&?2(5)('!3(0()F!MU$++(/%!b]le:!bfbN7!".!(&B2(+$!(&).!

    #20%&()DO5!%&)#+.>.'$&)+('!0./$!.6!.>$+%)(.&!%5!5.'(.A!%&/!>5D'#.A#(5).+('%33D!

    '.&5)()2)$/!(5!).!/(5'3.5$!)#%)!()!(5!!&"!'.&5)+2')$/!0$%&(&?!.6!)#$!#20%&Q!52'#!/(5'3.52+$!

    .>$&5!%!#.+(K.&!-()#(&!-#('#!-$!1$'.0$!.)""!).!5#(6)!(&).!)#$!-.+,!.6!+$'+$%)(&?!.2+5$3@$5!

  • !$""

    %&/!.2+!-%D!.6!3(6$!.&!R%+)#7!"#(5!(5!%!#.+(K.&!.6!#20%&!6+$$/.0!)#%)!'%&&.)!1$!6.+6$()$/!

    -()#.2)!5$@$+$3D!'.&)+%')(&?!)#$!@$+D!5'.>$!.6!-#%)!()!0$%&5!).!1$!#20%&7!!

    G$!%+$!(&!/%&?$+!.6!3.5(&?!)#$!6+$$/.0!).!+$0%,$!.2+5$3@$5!%5!%!'.0>%55(.&%)$!%&/!

    (&)$?+%3!>3%&$)%+D!0$01$+:!(6!-$!$01+%'$!)#$!>()'#!)#%)!#20%&()DO5!(/$&)()D!%5!>3%&$)%+D!

    .@$+3.+/!(5!&%)2+%37!!

    !!!!!!

    0#,)%.,(,3*"4%*,%#23.%%,*'77%'$*"#*"4%*7.(#.("8*#9*/#)('$*:5/"()%**

    8)!(5!&$()#$+!6%'(3$!%&%3.?D!&.+!+#$).+('%3!>3.D!).!2+?$!B2$5)(.&(&?!%&)#+.>.'$&)+(50!(&!)#$!

    5%0$!5>(+()!.6!(&B2(+D!%&/!'.&5'($&'$!)#%)!;%2'%5(%&A'$&)$+$/&$55!#%5!1$$&!'#%33$&?$/7!

    420%&!5>$'($5!52>+$0%'D!%&/!-#()$!+%'(%3!52>+$0%'D!%+$!>+.6.2&/3D!5(0(3%+!%&/:!(&!6%'):!

    .@$+3%>>(&?!5D5)$05!.6!)#.2?#)7!G#()$!52>+$0%'D!/+$-!()5!>.-$+!6+.0!'3%(05!.6!+%'(%3!

    52>$+(.+()D!)#%)!-$+$!>$+'$(@$/!%5!$&)(+$3D!'.00.&5$&5('%3Q!0.+$.@$+:!).!5$'2+$!()5!

    #$?$0.&D:!()!3$%&$/!(&).!)#$!$@$&!0.+$!.1@(.25!+$%3()D!.6!#20%&!52>+$0%'D!.@$+!%33!.)#$+!

    5>$'($5!1D!>.+)+%D(&?!&.&A;%2'%5(%&!+%'$5!%5!%,(&!).!E3.-$+!6.+05!.6!3(6$F!M$5>$'(%33D!

    %&(0%35!52'#!%5!%>$5!%&/!(&5$')5N7!8&$B2%3()($5!1$)-$$&!#20%&!?+.2>5:!.&!)#$!.&$!#%&/:!

    %&/!)#$!?+%&/!#($+%+'#D!.6!)#$!#20%&A&.%&:!.&!)#$!.)#$+:!#%@$!%3-%D5!1$$&!

    $&0$5#$/:!02)2%33D!52>>.+)(@$!6+%0$-.+,57H@!!!

    "#$!&$.A?+$$&!>$+5>$')(@$!%33$?$5!'.&'$+&!%1.2)!(&$B2()($5!1$)-$$&!>$.>3$!%&/!

    %1.2)!)#$!3.)!.6!)#$!-.+3/O5!>..+7!!

    1$)-$$&!>$.>3$!%&/!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!)#+.2?#!)#$!3$&5!.6!T25)('$7!8552$5!.6!T25)('$!%+$!+$5$+@$/!

    M(&!)#$!)(0$A#.&.+$/!-$5)$+&!(&)$33$')2%3!)+%/()(.&N!6.+!)#$!#20%&!/.0%(&:!%&/!0%))$+5!.6!

  • !%""

    5.'(%3!T25)('$!M)#$!?%>!1$)-$$&!'.&520$+5!%&/!)#$!>..+:!.+!)#$!?3.1%3!`.+)#!%&/!)#$!?3.1%3!

    S.2)#N!%+$!T2/?$/!%5!0.5)!(00$/(%)$3D!>+$55(&?7!R&@(+.&0$&)%3!%2)#.+!=%23!4%-,$&!

    +$'$&)3D!@.('$/!)#$!>$+5>$')(@$!.6!)#$!>+(0%'D!.6!5.'(%3!T25)('$!-()#!)#$!6.33.-(&?!%>>$%3L!

    E"#$+$!(5!&.!B2$5)(.&!)#%)!)#$!$&@(+.&0$&)%3!0.@$0$&)!(5!'+()('%3!).!.2+!52+@(@%37!I2+!

    #.25$!(5!3()$+%33D!12+&(&?:!%&/!()!(5!.&3D!3.?('%3!)#%)!$&@(+.&0$&)%3(5)5!$H>$')!)#$!5.'(%3!

    T25)('$!0.@$0$&)!).!?$)!.&!)#$!$&@(+.&0$&)%3!1257!C2)!()!(5!)#$!.)#$+!-%D!%+.2&/Q!)#$!.&3D!

    -%D!-$!%+$!?.(&?!).!>2)!.2)!)#$!6(+$!(5!).!?$)!.&!)#$!5.'(%3!T25)('$!125!%&/!#$%3!.2+!

    -.2&/5mF!Ma\\e:!b]\N7!c%+$(@%!%&/!#(5!'.33$%?2$5!>2+52$!%!5(0(3%+!)#+$%/!.6!+$%5.&(&?L!

    E9.5)!>$.>3$!-.+3/-(/$!M+$?%+/3$55!.6!'23)2+$N!-$3'.0$!)#$!.>>.+)2&()($5!)#%)!

    /$@$3.>0$&)!>+.@(/$5!).!(0>+.@$!3(@$5!.6!?+(&/(&?!>.@$+)Dm!;.&5$+@%)(.&:F!)#$D!'.&)(&2$:!

    E5#.23/!5$$,!).!52>>.+)!%&/!(&6.+0!)#$!+(?#)!,(&/!.6!/$@$3.>0$&)J/$@$3.>0$&)!1D!

    /$5(?&:!/.&$!-()#!)#$!(0>.+)%&'$!.6!&%)2+$!).!)#+(@(&?!$'.&.0($5!6.+$0.5)!(&!0(&/F!Ma\bb:!

    fg:fhN7!R&@(+.&0$&)%3!%&%3D5)5!9('#%$3!S#$33$&1$+?$+!%&/!"$/!`.+/#%25!%+$!.>)(0(5)('!

    %1.2)!)#$!>+.5>$')5L!ECD!ab\\:!&$%+3D!%33!.6!25!-(33!1$!>+.5>$+.25!$&.2?#!).!3(@$!#$%3)#D:!

    6+$$:!%&/!'+$%)(@$!3(@$57!U$5>()$!)#$!'3%(05!.6!9%3)#25(%&!>$55(0(5)5:!)#%)!-.+3/!(5!1.)#!

    $'.&.0('%33D!%&/!$'.3.?('%33D!>.55(13$7!C2)!).!+$%3(K$!():!%&/!).!5%@$!-#%)!+$0%(&5!.6!)#$!

    R%+)#n5!$'.3.?('%3!#$+()%?$:!-$!025)!.&'$!%&/!6.+!%33!$01+%'$!#20%&!>.-$+:!)$'#&.3.?D:!

    %&/!)#$!3%+?$+!>+.'$55!.6!0./$+&(K%)(.&F!Ma\bbN7!!!

    G#%)!52'#!%&%3D5$5!'#..5$!).!(?&.+$!(5!)#%)!>.@$+)D!#%5!3.&?!1$$&!%!5.'(%3!+$%3()D!

    %+(5(&?!6+.0!'(@(3(K%)(.&O5!>$'23(%+!+$3%)(.&5#(>!-()#!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/L!&%0$3D:!.6!@($-(&?!

    &%)2+$!%5!%!'.&)%(&$+!.6!'.@$)$/!+$5.2+'$5!)#%)!'%&!1$!%>>+.>+(%)$/!M)#+.2?#!)#$!$H$+'(5$!

    .6!5.0$!6.+0!.6!>.-$+!.+!.)#$+N!6.+!)#$!'+$%)(.&!.6!-#%)!-$!#%@$!'.0$!).!'%33!-$%3)#7!P+.0!

    )(0$!(00$0.+(%3:!T25)!%5!)./%D:!)#$!2&/$+A'3%55$5!%&/!)#$!>.-$+3$55!#%@$!1$$&!6.+'(13D!

  • !&""

    3(0()$/!6+.0!%''$55(&?!+$5.2+'$5!6.+!)#$(+!.-&!0%)$+(%3!%/@%&)%?$7!8)!(5!)#25!(&T25)('$!

    ).-%+/!)#$!0.+$A)#%&A#20%&!-.+3/J5)+(>>(&?!()!.6!()5!(&)+(&5('!1$(&?!%&/!@%32$:!%&/!

    )2+&(&?!()!(&).!1$(&?A6.+!%&/!@%32$A6.+!>$.>3$!M(7$7!E+$5.2+'$5FNJ)#%)!'.&5)()2)$5!)#$!

    6.2&/%)(.&!.6!5.'(%3!(&T25)('$!%&/!(&$B2%3()D7!!

    o$)!)#%)!6.2&/%)(.&!+$0%(&5!3%+?$3D!(&@(5(13$:!1$'%25$!%!'+()('%3!/(0$&5(.&!.6!#20%&!

    5$36A%-%+/$/!$&)()3$0$&)!).!25$!&%)2+$!%5!-$!-(33!#%5!+,0!!1$$&!).!0%,$!()!)%1..!).!+$?%+/!

    .2+!+$3%)(.&5#(>!-()#!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!%5!8+7'&5*+&4(8'&5*(!*3!!-()#!0%))$+5!.6!T25)('$!.+!

    (&T25)('$7!"#25!)#$!%&)#+.>.'$&)+('!'+$/.:!12.D$/!%3.&?!)./%D!)#+.2?#!52'#!(/$%5!%5!

    E+$5.2+'$5:F!E&%)2+%3!'%>()%3:F!E$'.3.?('%3!5$+@('$5:F!E-.+,(&?!3%&/5'%>$5:F!%&/!)#$!3(,$J

    (/$%5!5>$'(6('%33D!(&/$1)$/!).!)#$!$+%52+$!.6!%&D!'&()'&0'#!0./%3()D!M.&).3.?('%3!.+!

    $@%32%)(@$N!.6!)#$!&.%&!+$%30J(5!3$6)!2&).2'#$/:!%5!(5!()5!>3%(&3D!'.3.&(%3(5)!

    @.'%123%+D7!.+)+%D$/!%5!)#$!

    E/$0.'+%)('F!M$@$+!)#$!12KK-.+/N!5#%+(&?!.6!>3%&$)%+D!3..):!3..)!/$5'+(1$/!0.+$!>.3()$3D!

    )#+.2?#!52'#!'.00.&>3%'$!'.&'$>)5!3(5)$/!%1.@$7!"#$!>..+!-(33!1$!3(6)$/!6+.0!)#$(+!/(+$!

    >3(?#):!5.!?.$5!)#$!>+.0(5$:!%5!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!1$'.0$5!525)%(&%13D!/$?+%/$/!6.+!)#$!

    1$&$6()!.6!%33!>$.>3$7!C2)!%5!8!&.-!)2+&!).!%+?2$:!)#$!>+.13$0!-()#!)#(5!5.32)(.&!).!5.'(%3!

    (&T25)('$!(5!)#%)!()!-(33!&.)!-.+,Q!%&/!(6!()!-$+$!).!-.+,:!()!'.23/!#%+/3D!1$!'%33$/!T25)('$7!!

    S.'(%3!+$3%)(.&5!1$)-$$&!>$.>3$!/.!&.)!)+%&5>(+$!(&!%!@%'220:!/$5>()$!)#$!6%&'D!)#%)!

    )#$!'23)!.6!#20%&()D!#%5!3.&?!'23)(@%)$/!)#%)!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!(5!%!5)%?$!6.+!)#$!?+%&/!5#.-!

    .6!#20%&!%66%(+57!8)!(5!-()#(&!)#$!'.&)$H)!.6!)#$!/.0(&%&)!+$3%)(.&5#(>!1$)-$$&!#20%&()D!

    %&/!R%+)#!)#%)!5.'(%3!+$3%)(.&5!#%@$!1$'.0$!'.&5)()2)$/!%5!0%)$+(%3:!&.+0%)(@$:!%&/!

    #(5).+('%3!+$%3()($57!

  • !'""

    5$(K$/!.+!'.&@$+)$/:!#20%&!+$3%)(.&5!-(33!)$&/!).!0%&(6$5)!)#$!'.+.33%+($5!.6!)#(5!

    0%)$+(%3(K$/!1$3($6L!)#$+$!-(33!1$!'.0>$)()(.&:!$H>3.()%)(.&:!'.++2>)(.&:!5)+2??3$!6.+!%''$55!

    %&/!'.&)+.3:!>.5)2+(&?:!%&/!5.0$)(0$5!M.6)$&_N!-%+!.@$+!%33!0%&&$+!.6!+$5.2+'$57!

    SD5)$0%)('!/(5).+)(.&5!.6!#20%&!+$3%)(.&5!%+$!(&$H)+('%13D!'.2>3$/!-()#!)#$!+$5.2+'(5)!

    0(&/5$)J)#$D!%+$!52>>.+)$/!%&/!(&63%0$/!1D!)#$!+$3$&)3$553D!$&%')$/!+$?%+/!.6!)#$!

    &%)2+%3!-.+3/!%5!%!/.0%(&!).A1$A25$/!6.+!#20%&!>+.6()!.+!%/@%&'$0$&)7!"#$!5.2+'$!.6!)#$!

    /(5>%+()D!1$)-$$&!)#$!#%@$5!%&/!)#$!#%@$A&.)5!)#25!3($5!(&!)#$!'.&'$>)(.&A#$%A)+$%)0$&)!

    .6!R%+)#O5!3(@(&?!1$(&?5!%&/!&.&3(@(&?!)#(&?5!%5!+$5.2+'$5J%&!(++$/$$0%13D!'.++2>)!

    '.&'$>)!-#('#!'.&)(&2$5!).!0%5B2$+%/$!%5!0$+$3D!%!/$5'+(>)(@$!-.+/7!!!!!!!

    G#(3$!()5!>$+@%5(@$!25$!&.+0%3(K$5!():!()!(5!-.+)#!(&@$5)(?%)(&?!-#%)!,(&/!.6!

    +$3%)(.&5#(>!).!)#$!1(.5>#$+$!)#(5!-.+/!5(?&%357!E`%)2+%3!+$5.2+'$5F!(5!%&!%15)+%')(.&!6.+!

    +$6$++(&?!).!%!023)()2/$!.6!)#(&?5!(&!)#$!3(@(&?!%&/!&.&3(@(&?!-.+3/:!-#(3$:!%5!52'#:!+$6$++(&?!

    ).!&.)#(&?!(&!>%+)('23%+L!5(0>3D!>2):!()!(5!%!>3%'$#.3/$+!6.+!/$5(?&%)(&?!)#$!-.+3/!(&!)$+05!.6!

    ()5!/(5>.5%1(3()D!6.+!#20%&!&$$/5:!-%&)5:!/$5(+$5:!%&/!-#(057!"#25:!-#(3$!5$$0(&?3D!%&!

    .1T$')(@$!+$6$+$&)!).!)#(&?5!M.(3:!6(5#:!5.(3:!6+$5#-%)$+:!%&/!5.!.&N:!)#$!'.&'$>)!.6!+$5.2+'$5!

    +$'.&6(?2+$5!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!(&!)$+05!.6!#.-!()!(5!25%13$:!)#$+$1D!$&)(+$3D!1D>%55(&?:!%&/!

    @(%!()5!'$%5$3$55!25$!$+%5(&?:!&%)2+$O5!(&)+(&5('!5)%&/(&?J1.)#!%5!1$(&?!%&/!%5!@%32$7!

    8&/$$/:!E&%)2+%3!+$5.2+'$5F!13.',5!#20%&!)#.2?#)!6+.0!0""'&5!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!(&!()5!

    (&)+(&5('!3(?#)7!EY$5.2+'$5F!(5!)#25!%!3(&?2(5)('!%''.0>%&(0$&)!.6!)#$!%55%23)!.&!%&/!

    $H'$55(@$!$H>3.()%)(.&!.6!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/7!"#$!)+%&56(?2+%)(.&!.6!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!(&).!

    +$5.2+'$5!#%5!'.0$!).!5#%>$!#20%&!)#.2?#)!%&/!%')(.&!%)!52'#!%&!$&'.0>%55(&?!3$@$3!)#%)!

    >$.>3$!3%+?$3D!>$+'$(@$!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!)#+.2?#!)#(5!5(&?3$!6+%0$-.+,L!.6!#.-!()!(5!25%13$!

    %&/d.+!>+.6()%13$7!!

  • !(""

    8&!%!-.+3/!)#25!/(0(&(5#$/:!$&53%@$/:!.+!,(33$/!).!62&')(.&!%5!0$%&5!6.+!#20%&!$&/5:!

    5.'(%3!T25)('$!(5!>+%?0%)('%33D!%33!12)!2&%'#($@%13$:!1$'%25$!>$.>3$!M%5!-$33!$&)()($5!52'#!%5!

    '.+>.+%)(.&5!%&/!5)%)$5!-#('#!%+$!+2&:!%&/!$01+%'$/:!1D!>$.>3$!N!-(33!(&$H.+%13D!1$!(&'()$/!

    ).!/.!-#%)!()!)%,$5!).!>.55$55!)#$!25$623!.+!0.&$DA5>(&&(&?!0$%&5L!3%&/:!6+$5#-%)$+:!

    )$++().+D:!6(5#$+($5:!62+:!?$&$5:!.(3:!'.%3:!&%)2+%3!?%5:!2+%&(20:!)(01$+:!-(3/3(6$!M/$%/!.+!%3(@$N:!

    3(@$5).',:!0$)%35:!0(&$+%357!$+'$(@$/!'.&/2()!).-%+/!

    -$%3)#:!>+(@(3$?$:!%&/!)#$!?../!3(6$:!)#$!?.%3!.6!5.'(%3!T25)('$!(5!3(,$3D!).!+$0%(&!$325(@$7!!!!

    C2)!6.+!)#$!5%,$!.6!%+?20$&):!3$)O5!%5520$!)#%)!5.'(%3!T25)('$!(5!%'#($@%13$!.&!%!

    >3%&$)!.6!+$5.2+'$5J%!>3%&$)!25$/:!0%&%?$/:!%&/!$&?(&$$+$/!).!1$!>+./2')(@$!6.+!#20%&!

    1$(&?57!X$)O5!%5520$:!%3.&?!)#$5$!3(&$5:!)#%)!#20%&()D!+$'.?&(K$5!)#$!6.33D!.6!)#$!2&$B2%3!

    /(5)+(12)(.&!.6!+$5.2+'$5:!%&/!/$'(/$5!).!5#%+$!)#$!5.A'%33$/!'.00.&-$%3)#!M)#$!0./$+&!

    $B2(@%3$&)!.6!)#$!.$'20$&$N!6%(+3D!%0.&?!%33!>$.>3$7!"#(5!)#.2?#)!$H>$+(0$&)!/(5'3.5$5!)#$!

    5$'.&/!+$%5.&!)#%)!5.'(%3!T25)('$!(5!2&)$&%13$!-()#.2)!%!+%/('%33D!&$-!+$3%)(.&5#(>!1$)-$$&!

    #20%&()D!%&/!)#$!0.+$A)#%&A#20%&A-.+3/7!;.&5(/$+!)#$!6.33.-(&?!%&%3.?DL!)#%)!

  • !)""

    >3%&$)%+D!.@$+5(?#)Q!+$B2(+$/:!(&!%!-.+/:!%&!.''2>($/!>3%&$)7!U.$5!)#(5!5'$&%+(.!&.)!

    /$5'+(1$!%!@(').+(.25!#20%&*Y$('#J-()#!%33!()5!0$01$+5!>%+)%,(&?!$B2()%13D!.6!)#$!

    -.+3/O5!+$5.2+'$5_!Y$?%+/(&?!52'#!%&!%/@$&)!.6!5.'(%3!T25)('$:!.&$!0(?#)!T25)(6(%13D!%5,L!

    -#%)!'.23/!)#$!(/$%!.6!T25)('$!>.55(13D!$@$&!0$%&!%)!)#%)!>.(&)_!

    S.'(%3!T25)('$!(5!&.)!%'#($@%13$!%5!3.&?!%5!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!'.&)(&2$5!).!1$!5)+(>>$/!

    .6!()5!(&)+(&5('!5)%&/(&?!%&/!+$'.&6(?2+$/!%5!%!'.33$')(.&!.6!+$5.2+'$57!CD!@(+)2$!.6!)#$!5.+)5!

    .6!$&)()($5!)#$D!%+$:!+$5.2+'$5!&.)!.&3D!$&'.2+%?$:!12)!3%+?$3D!'+$%)$:!)#$!%'B2(5()(@$!

    0(&/5$)!)#%)!2&/$+?(+/5!#20%&!'.&63('):!'.++2>)(.&:!%&/!(&T25)('$7H@(!I&!)#$!.)#$+!#%&/:!

    5#.23/!>$.>3$!%'#($@$!?+$%)$+!0%)$+(%3!$B2()DJ-#(3$!525)%(&(&?!)#$!%&)#+.>.'$&)+('!

    +$>+$5$&)%)(.&!.6!&%)2+$!%5!0%/$A6.+A#20%&5J)#$&!5.'(%3!T25)('$!-(33!'.0$!).!>%55!%)!)#$!

    >+('$!.6!>3%&$)%+D!'.3.&(K%)(.&:!)#$+$1D!$@%'2%)(&?!)#$!7")4*#!"-(!.6!T25)('$!.6!%&D!

    -.+)#-#(3$!5$&5$7!!!

    "#$!R%+)#!(5!)#$!.+(?(&!%&/!(++$>3%'$%13$!6($3/!.6!%33!#20%&!$H>$+($&'$:!)#$!%33A

    $&'.0>%55(&?!'.&)$H)!.6!5.'(%3!3(6$7!420%&()DO5!+2>)2+$!6+.0!)#$!R%+)#!'.002&()D:!%&/!()5!

    )%,$.@$+!.6!)#$!>3%&$)!%5!%&!(&5)+20$&)%3!).)%3()D!.6!.1T$')5A%&/A5$+@('$5A6.+A#20%&A25$:!

    #%@$!>%)#.3.?(K$/!)#$!#20%&!>5D'#$!(&!%!-%D!)#%)!-(33!3(,$3D!'.&)(&2$!).!>+$@$&)!)#$!

    #$%3(&?!.6!(&)+%A#20%&!'.&63(')7!"#$!?+.2&/!6.+!5.'(%3!T25)('$!%&/!-.+3/!>$%'$!(5!,'(")+,,4!

    0(55(&?!-()#.2)!)#$!R%+)#!+$5>$')$/!%&/!+$5).+$/!%5!%!3(@(&?!-.+3/:!%&/!)#$!+$T$')(.&!.6!)#$!

    +$'$(@$/!#($+%+'#D!1$)-$$&!#20%&5!%&/!)#$!+$5)!.6!&%)2+$7!X$)!25!1$!'3$%+!%1.2)!)#$!

    0%?&()2/$!.6!-#%)!(5!'%33$/!6.+L!)#$!+$3(&B2(5#0$&)!.6!.2+!6%1+('%)$/!5>$'(%3!%&/!>+(@(3$?$/!

    (/$&)()D7!!

  • !*""

    8)!(5!%!0%))$+!.6!1$'.0(&?!+$'$>)(@$!).!%&!(/$%!-#.5$!)(0$!#%5!'.0$L!)#%)!)#$!R%+)#!

    (5!&.)!0%/$!6.+!>$.>3$:!%&D0.+$!)#%&!()!-%5!0%/$!6.+!)#$!2&(@$+5$!).!6+%0$!()5$36!%+.2&/!

    %&/!>3%&$)%+D!1./($5!).!'(+'20%0123%)$7!!!!!!

    !

    ;'-(,3*"4%*74%,#&%,'*#.*.%-#$5"(#,'.8*".',/9#.&'"(#,+.13$05!#%/!).!1$!5.3@$/J%&/!5.!)#$D!-$+$:!12)!&.)!1D!%1%&/.&(&?!

    )#$!?$.'$&)+('!>(')2+$!%&/!(&B2(+(&?!(&).!%3)$+&%)(@$57!8&5)$%/:!'.++$')(@$!0$'#%&(505!-$+$!

    %66(H$/!).!)#$!=).3$0%('!0./$3:!52'#!%5!E$>('D'3$5F!-#('#!>.5()$/!%//()(.&%3!'(+'23%+!

    0.@$0$&)5!).!%!>3%&$)O5!5)%&/%+/!R%+)#!.+1()!M)#25!$H>3%(&(&?!)#%)!>3%&$)O5!E+$)+.?+%/$!

    0.@$0$&)FN7!%&'($5!1$)-$$&!)#$!/$%+3DA#$3/A.&).!?$.'$&)+('!0./$3!%&/!

    %')2%3!.15$+@%)(.&57H@((!#$&.0$&%7!C2)!%6)$+!%!0(33$&&(20!%&/!%!

  • #+""

    #%36!.6!3%1.+(&?!).!0%,$!()!#.3/:!)#$!'$&)+%3!3.'%)(.&!.6!)#$!=3%&$)!.6!)#$!420%&5!#%/!).!1$!

    %1%&/.&$/7!

    ! `$.A?+$$&!$&@(+.&0$&)%3(50!(5!#.3/(&?!.&).!()5!.-&!@$+5(.&!.6!=).3$0%('!

    %5)+.&.0D:!&%0$3D:!)#$!'.+$!1$3($6!(&!)#$!+(?#)623&$55!.+!(&$@()%1(3()D!.6!%!#20%&A?.@$+&$/!

    >3%&$)7!R@$&!%5!6%()#!(&!#20%&!+23$!#%5!5.2+$/:!-()#!.'$%&5:!6.+$5)5:!+(@$+5:!?+%553%&/5:!

    5>$'($5:!%&/!'3(0%)$!5%'+(6('$/!).!()5!1.?25!%3)%+:!)#$!&$.A?+$$&!>$+5>$')(@$!5$$,5!).!%//!

    $>('D'3$!%6)$+!$>('D'3$!).!)#$!0./$3!.6!#20%&!?.@$+&%&'$!).!,$$>!()!(&!>3%'$L!&2'3$%+!

    >.-$+:!1(.62$35:!'%+1.&!'%>)2+$!p!5).+%?$:!%&/!5.!6.+)#!).!#$3>!5)%1(3(K$!3$@$35!.6!

    ?+$$.25$!?%5$5Q!?$&$)('!$&?(&$$+(&?!.6!'+.>5!%&/!%&(0%35!).!5.3@$!)#$!6../!'+(5(5:!)#$!

    &()+.?$&!%&/!>#.5>#.+25!.@$+3.%/:!6+$5#-%)$+!5#.+)6%335:!.+!-#%)#%@$D.2Q!?$.&?(&$$+(&?!

    ).!'.>$!-()#!>.55(13$!'3(0%)$!/(5+2>)(.&:!%&/!$@$&)2%33D!+$>2+>.5$/!).!%/T25)!R%+)#O5!

    )#$+0.5)%)!).!6%@.+%13$!5$))(&?5Q!/$5%3(&(K%)(.&!>+.T$')5!%&/!0%55(@$!-(&/!)2+1(&$!%&/!

    >#.)[email protected])%('!(&/25)+(%3!.>$+%)(.&5!).!,$$>!62&&$3(&?!-%)$+!%&/!525)%(&%13$!$&$+?D!).!0%&D!

    1(33(.&5!.6!>$.>3$Q!>3%'(&?!0.&$)%+D!@%32$5!.&!1(./(@$+5()D!%&/!$'.5D5)$0!5$+@('$5:!5.!)#$!

    0%+,$)!0(?#)!5%6$?2%+/!5.0$!+$0%(&(&?!&%)2+%3!%+$%5Q!E/$A$H)(&')(.&F!>+.T$')5!%&/!

    5D&)#$)('!1(.3.?D!6.+!)#$!(&5)%)$0$&)!.6!#20%&A0%/$!1(.3.?('%3!/(@$+5()D!5.0$)(0$!(&!)#$!

    62)2+$Q!%&/!$66('($&)!0%&%?$0$&)!%&/!+$'D'3(&?!).!,$$>!)#$!63.-!.6!+%-!0%)$+(%35!6$$/(&?!%!

    ?3.1%3(K$/!(&/25)+(%3(507!G#%)$@$+!()!)%,$5:!(&!.)#$+!-.+/5:!5.!)#%)!)#$!>3%&$)%+D!%2)#.+()D!

    .6!)#$!#20%&!&$$/!&.)!1$!'.&6+.&)$/7!"#$!&$.A?+$$&!>$+5>$')(@$!-.23/!#%@$!25!

    M$&)#25(%5)('%33D!.+!+$32')%&)3DN!$01+%'$!%!-.+3/!)#%)!(5!0%55(@$3D!'.0>3('%)$/:!0$?%A

    )$'#&.3.?('%3:!$&?(&$$+$/:!+(5,A)$&/(&?:!25$/:!1(.3.?('%33D!(0>.@$+(5#$/:!.@$+>.>23%)$/:!

    %&/!6(33$/!-()#!M$B2()%13DA5#%+$/N!'.&520$+!5)2667!"#$!5.3$!@(+)2$!.6!52'#!%!-.+3/!(5!)#%)!()!

    5%@$5!)#$!#(5).+('%33D!1$B2$%)#$/!>#$&.0$&.&!.6!#20%&!+23$7!!

  • #!""

    "#$+$!$H(5)5!%&.)#$+!>%)#!(&).!)#$!62)2+$:!.&$!-#('#!(5!0.+$!$3$?%&):!0.+$!1$%2)(623:!

    0.+$!$)#('%3:!%&/!0.+$!1$'.0(&?!.6!)#$!#20%&!5>(+()L!)#%)!-(3/!&%)2+$J)$++$5)+(%3!%&/!

    0%+(&$J1$!+$(&5)%)$/!%5!)#$!2&1+.,$&:!+('#A(&A3(6$!)%>$5)+D!-()#(&!-#('#!#20%&!

    '.002&()($5!)#+(@$!(&!(&)$?+%)(.&!-()#!)#$(+!(%1()$/!1(.+$?(.&57!420%&()D!025)!0.@$!

    !$(*!.*(8"*#"&(")!%&/!3$)!)#$!R%+)#!%&/!()5!-#.3$!'.002&()D!.6!3(6$!63.2+(5#!)#$+$:!-()#!257!

    9.@(&?!.2)!.6!)#$!'$&)$+!0$%&5!5'%3(&?!1%',!#20%&()DO5!>+$5$&'$!$&.+0.253DL!+$/2'(&?!

    ?3.1%3!>.>23%)(.&!).!%!6%+!3.-$+!3$@$3!)#%&!()!>+$5$&)3D!(5Q!$&/(&?!.@$+>+./2')(.&!%&/!)#$!

    $H'$55$5!.6!?3.1%3!)+%/$Q!$&/(&?!(&/25)+(%3!6../!>+./2')(.&:!%3.&?!-()#!()5!$'.3.?('%3:!

    $)#('%3:!$&@(+.&0$&)%3:!%&/!>213('!#$%3)#!#.++.+5Q!%&/!'$%5(&?!).!5)(63$!)#$!6+$$/.0!%&/!

    '+$%)(@$!>.-$+5!.6!&%)2+$!1D!>3%D(&?!X.+/A.6A)#$A9%&.+7!=$+#%>5!0.5)!62&/%0$&)%33D:!

    0.@(&?!.2)!.6!)#$!'$&)$+!0$%&5!/(5.-&(&?!)#$!#20%&!52>+$0%'D!'.0>3$HJ()5!13(&/&$55!

    ).!)#$!5)2>$&/.25!(&)+(&5('!>.-$+!.6!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/!%&/!).!)#$!0%/&$55!.6!()5!.-&!#$%+)7!

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

  • ##""

    =%9%.%,)%/*

    "7!!)*?!%-+00'!&+("*?!&0")7+('!&!M;#('%?.:!r&(@$+5()D!.6!;#('%?.!=+$55:!

    a\bf:![gAhbN7!

    V7!U$++(/%:!E"#$!R&/5!.6!9%&:F!(&!c7!C%D&$5!$)!%37!$/57:!B.(")*F8',!0!-84:*A&3*!)*

    C)+&0.!)%+('!&G!M;%01+(/?$:!98"!=+$55:!b]le:!bagAbglN7!

    #$+$:F!F8',K*C)+&0K*;K*J!#K*B!

    fh]!Ma\bb%NL!b\b\Ab\fg7!

    R7!R33(5:!EP.+?$)!9.)#$+!`%)2+$L!"#(5!(&!%!G.+3/!.6!I2+!9%,(&?:F!D"2*J#'"&('0(!b[!V2&$!

    a\bb17!

    R7!R33(5:!E

    ;7!*..'#:!E9$$)!*3.1%3!;.++2>)(.&O5!4(//$&!=3%D$+5:F!"RU*3.1%3:!V23D!a\bf7!!

  • #$""

    V7!*.23/:!C8"*9'0%"+0$)"*!.*9+&!M`$-!o.+,:!G7G7!`.+).&:!b]lbdb]]hN7!

    V7!*+%D:!C8"*J',""*!.*B&'%+,0:*H&*F)!5)"00*+&3*H(8")*9!3")&*94(80!M`$-!o.+,:!P%++%+:!

    S)+%25!%&/!*(+.2H:!a\bfN7!

    =7!4%-,$&:!L,"00"3*M&)"0(!MX.&/.&:!=$&?2(&!C..,5:!a\\eN7!

    47!V.&%5:!C8"*N&!0('#*;",'5'!&!MC.5).&:!C$%'.&!=+$55!b]gldb]hfN7!

    =7!c%+$(@%:!Y7!X%3%5K:!%&/!97!9%+@($+:!E;.&5$+@%)(.&!(&!)#$!.'$&$L!C$D.&/!S.3()2/$!

    %&/!P+%?(3()D:F!L)"+1(8)!$58*O!$)&+,!MP%33!a\bbNL!a]Afe7!!

    "7!c2#&:!C8"*J()$#($)"*!.*J#'"&('.'#*;"7!,$('!&0!M;#('%?.:!)#$!r&(@$+5()D!.6!;#('%?.!=+$55:!

    b]e\N7!

    97!X$&K$&!$)!%37:!E8&)$+&%)(.&%3!"+%/$!U+(@$5!C(./(@$+5()D!"#+$%)5!(&!U$@$3.>(&?!!`%)(.&5:F!

    D+($)"![lh!MV2&$!a\baNL!b\]Abba7!

    97!XD&%5:!C8"*N!3*J-"#'"0:*I!2*(8"*F,+&"(*?+&*J$)7'7"*(8"*B5"*!.*I$%+&0!MX.&/.&:!P.2+)#!

    R5)%)$:!a\bbN7!

    R7!9%++(5:!ER'.3.?D!G()#.2)!G(3/$+&$55L!"$&/(&?!)#$!*3.1%3!*%+/$&!-$!;%33!O`%)2+$:OF!C8"*

    B(,+&('#!bg!S$>)$01$+:!a\bb7!!

    R7!9%++(5:!ER'.3.?DL!Y%?%0266(&!R%+)#:F!D+($)"![h\!Ma\\]NL![g\A[gf7!

    X7!9%+H:!E"#$!U.0(&%)(.&!.6!`%)2+$!%&/!)#$!Y$/$6(&()(.&!.6!=+.?+$557F!8&!F)!5)"00:*>+#(*!)*

    E,,$0'!&G!X$.!9%+H!%&/!C+2'$!9%K3(5#!$/57!M"#$!r&(@$+5()D!.6!9('#(?%&!=+$55:!b]]h:!>>7!a\bA

    ablN7!!

  • #%""

    *7!9.&1(.):!E8!X.@$!`%)2+$7!P.+!)#(5!8!%0!;%33$/!C.2+?$.(5:!Y.0%&)('JR@$&!P%5'(5):F!C8"*

    N$+)3'+&!l!V23D!a\bf7!

    P7!=$%+'$:!E"+2$!`%)2+$L!Y$@(5(&?!8/$%5!.&!G#%)!(5!=+(5)(&$!%&/!G(3/:F!P+,"*A&7')!&%"&(*

    QRS:!bf!9%D!a\bf7!!

    "7!Y$?%&:!

    [eg7!!

    97!S#$33$&1$+?$+!%&/!"7!`.+/#%25:!=!7"*P!$)*9!&0(")0:*F!0("&7')!&%"&(+,'0%*+&3*(8"*

    B&(8)!-!#"&":!$1..,:!a\bb7!

    P7!G%31%&,:!F!,4T'$0U*;!%"*+&3*(8"*I",,"&'0('#*@!),3!M;%01+(/?$L!;%01+(5?$!r&(@$+5()D!

    =+$55:!a\\aN7!

    97!G$&)$:!E;%&!R&@(+.A.>)(0(5)5!S%@$!)#$!9.@$0$&)!6+.0!8)5$36_F!C8"*N,!T"*+&3*9+',!a\!

    +(3!a\bf7!

    U7!G(3'.H:!C8"*9"+0$)"*!.*C'%"0*F+0(:*F)"VD"2(!&'+&*?8)!&!,!5'"0*+&3*(8"*;8"(!)'#*!.*C'%"!

    M;#('%?.L!"#$!r&(@$+5()D!.6!;#('%?.!=+$55:!b]leN7!!

    R7I7!G(35.&:!C8"*

  • #&""

    """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""(!P.+)#'.0(&?!(&!W""-'&5*(8"*@',3:*B5+'&0(*(8"*3.()%)(.&F!Ma\\hL!ahaAa]bN7!!!!

    (((!S25%&!C.+/.O5!Mb]eeN!$H>+$55(.&7!

    (@!8!1$3($@$!8!.-$!)#$!>#+%5(&?!).!%&(0%3!+(?#)5!-+()$+!%&/!%')(@(5)!".0!Y$?%&!Ma\\bN7!

    @!S$$!`('.3%25!;.>$+&('25!6%0.25!EX$))$+!".!4(5!4.3(&$55!=.>$!=%23!888:F!>213(5#$/!%5!)#$!

    =+$6%'$!).!)#$!6(+5)!$/()(.&!.6!H&*(8"*;"7!,$('!&0*!.*(8"*I"+7"&,4*J-8")"0!Mbg[fNL!%!

    +$0%+,%13$!/.'20$&)!(&!$&/$%@.+(&?!).!>3%'%)$!)#$!#(?#$5)!.66('$!.6!?$.'$&)+('!/.?0%:!

    -#(3$!%35.!$H>+$55(&?!?+$%)!)+$>(/%)(.&!6.+!E/%+(&?!%?%(&5)!)#$!+$'$(@$/!.>(&(.&!.6!

    0%)#$0%)('(%&5:!%&/!%30.5)!%?%(&5)!'.00.&!5$&5$:!).!(0%?(&$!5.0$!0.)(.&!.6!)#$!R%+)#7F!

    8&!U2&'%&!b]ehL!afAae7!!

    @(!R&@(+.&0$&)%3!E>2+(5)5:F!.>(&$5!'.320&(5)!9%+?%+$)!G$&)$!(&!%!+$'$&)!5)+(&?(&?!.6!3%1$35:!

    E#%@$!1$$&!)$++(13$!6.+!$&@(+.&0$&)%3(50!1$'%25$!)#$DO@$!%3($&%)$/!)#$!>213('!-()#!)#$(+!

    0(5%&)#+.>(':!%&)(A?+.-)#:!%&)(A)$'#&.3.?D:!/.?0%)(':!K$%3.25:!+.0%&)(':!1%',-%+/A3..,(&?!

    0$55%?$F!Ma\bfN7!S$$!*$.+?$!9.&1(.)O5!-())D!+$5>.&5$!).!52'#!&%0$A'%33(&?!(&!%!+$'$&)!

    N$+)3'+&!>213('%)(.&L!E8!X.@$!`%)2+$7!P.+!)#(5!8!%0!;%33$/!C.2+?$.(5:!Y.0%&)('JR@$&!

    P%5'(5)F!Ma\bfN7!

    @((!EG$O@$!'.0$!)#+.2?#!%!>$+(./!.6!6(&%33D!2&/$+5)%&/(&?!)#$!&%)2+$!%&/!0%?&()2/$!.6!

    #20%&()DO5!)+%&56.+0%)(.&!.6!)#$!$%+)#7!4%@(&?!+$%3(K$/!():!'%&!-$!1$'.0$!'3$@$+!$&.2?#!%)!

    %!1(?!$&.2?#!5'%3$!).!1$!%13$!).!0%(&)%(&!)#$!+%)$5!.6!>+.?+$55_F!"#(5!B2.)$!6+.0!%!4%+@%+/!

  • #'""

    """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""1(.3.?(5)!(5!%!>()#D!(6!1%3/A6%'$/!+$>+$5$&)%)(.&!.6!&$.A?+$$&!+$%5.&(&?7!M;()$/!(&!.+):!%>)3D!)()3$/!E9%&%?(&?!=3%&$)!R%+)#L!P.+?$)!`%)2+$7!R@$&!

    R/$&!(5!R&?(&$$+$/7FN!!

    @(((!c$D!>%+%0$)$+5:!%''.+/(&?!).!)#$!>3%&$)%+D!1.2&/%+($5!>$+5>$')(@$:!(&'32/$!

    %&)#+.>.?$&('!&()+.?$&:!?+$$.25$!?%5$5:!%&/!1(./(@$+5()D!3.55!M5$$!V.#%&!Y.',5)+s0!$)!

    %37!a\\]Q!XD&%5!a\bbN7!8/$&)(6D(&?!5>$'(6('!1.2&/%+($5!)#%)!5#.23/!&.)!1$!)+%&5?+$55$/!(5!

    )#$!.)#$+!5(/$!.6!)#$!'.&'$>)2%3!'.(&!.6!E0%H(020!525)%(&%13$!D($3/7F!8&!1.)#!'%5$5!)#$!

    3.?('!?.$5!%5!6.33.-5L!4.-!02'#!'%&!-$!)%,$!6+.0!)#$!&%)2+%3!-.+3/:!.+!2>!).!-#%)!

    )#+$5#.3/!'%&!-$!>.332)$!%&/!/$?+%/$:!-()#.2)!)#+$%)$&(&?!1..0$+%&?(&?!+$>$+'255(.&5_!

    "#$!0.)(@$!(5!).!$%)!)#$!>3%&$)!%&/!#%@$!()!)..Q!.+:!).!,$$>!?+.-(&?!-()#.2)!'.33%>5(&?7!

    RH>.&$&)!.6!>3%&$)%+D!1.2&/%+($5:!9%+,!!XD&%5:!(5!)#25!B2(',!).!/(66$+$&)(%)$!E>3%&$)%+D!

    1.2&/%+($5F!6+.0!)#$!b]ea!'3%55('!'.&'$>)!.6!E3(0()5!).!?+.-)#FL!E"#$!>3%&$)%+D!1.2&/%+($5!

    '.&'$>)!/.$5!&.)!&$'$55%+(3D!(0>3D!%&D!3(0()!.&!#20%&!$'.&.0('!?+.-)#!.+!>+./2')(@()DF!

    #$!%552+$5!#(5!+$%/$+5!Ma\bbL!]N7!!!

    (H!"#(5!/+$%0!(5!)%,(&?!)#$!0.5)!(00$/(%)$3D!+$%3(K%13$!6.+0!.6!%5>(+%)(.&5!).!0(&$!)#$!

    9..&!%&/!&$%+1D!>3%&$)5:!?(@$&!)#%)!&.!,&.-&!3(6$!6.+05!)#%)!'.23/!1$!$H>3.()$/!6.+!#20%&!

    %/@%&)%?$!$H(5)!-()#(&!R%+)#O5!@('(&()D7!

    H!8+.&('%33D:!)#$!5$$0(&?3D!+$%5.&%13$!'3%(0!)#%)!#20%&!>.-$+!(5!?./A3(,$!(5!13(&/!).!()5!.-&!

    $&)%&?3$0$&)5!-()#!%!0.&.)#$(5)('!'.&'$>)(.&!.6!%!*./:!5.!(0>+.1%13D!%++.?%&)!%&/!

    '%33.25:!)#%)!)#$!*&.5)('5!2&0%5,$/!#(0!%5!%&!(0>.5).+!.6!/(@(&()D!M5$$!V.&%5!b]hfN7!8&!

    %?+$$0$&)!-()#!>+.6$55.+!V.#&!*+%DO5!+$3%)$/!>.(&):!E#20%&!2&(B2$&$55!(5!%!0D)#!($+()$/!

    6+.0!+$3(?(.&:!-#('#!#20%&(5)5!#%@$!+$'D'3$/!(&).!5'($&'$F!Ma\bfL!eeN7!!!!!!

  • #(""

    """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""H(!E8&!)#$!.'$&$!-$!%+$!)#$!'+$%).+5:!$&?(&$$+5!%&/!-")%+&"&(*5,!T+,*0("2+)30!.6!%!

    525)%(&%13$!#20%&!&%)2+$F!MR33(5!a\bb1:!$0>#%5(5!%//$/N7!+$55$/!1D!

    9%++(5L!EG$!%+$!%3+$%/D!+2&&(&?!)#$!-#.3$!R%+)#:!-#$)#$+!-$!%/0()!()!.+!&.)7!".!+2&!()!

    '.&5'(.253D!%&/!$66$')(@$3D:!-$!025)!%/0()!.2+!+.3$!%&/!$@$&!$01+%'$!()7!G$!025)!)$0>$+!

    .2+!+.0%&)('!&.)(.&!.6!2&)+%00$3$/!-(3/$+&$55!%&/!6(&/!+..0!&$H)!).!()!6.+!)#$!0.+$!

    &2%&'$/!&.)(.&!.6!%!?3.1%3:!#%36A-(3/!+%012&')(.25!?%+/$&:!)$&/$/!1D!25F!Ma\bbN7!

    H((!S$$!)#$!$&)+D!%1.2)!C8"*9+()'XL!#))>Ldd$&7-(,(>$/(%7.+?d-(,(dY$/t>(33t%&/t132$t>(33!

    H(((!r&/$+5)%)(&?:!(&!>%55(&?:!)#$!(0>.+)%&'$!.6!(8"*0-""3*!.*#8+&5"!)#%)!#20%&5!%+$!$66$')(&?!

    (5!%&!$&.+0.25!.1625'%)(.&7!9.5)!'#%&?$5!(&!&%)2+$!%+$!&.)!'%)%5)+.>#('%33D!+%>(/:!-#('#!(5!

    -#D!1(./(@$+5()D!)$&/5!).!12(3/!.@$+!?$.3.?('%3!)(0$:!-()#!)#$!$0$+?$&'$!.6!&$-!5>$'($5!

    53(?#)3D!.2)>%'(&?!1%',?+.2&/!$H)(&')(.&!MG(35.&!a\b\N7!9%55!$H)(&')(.&5:!+%+$!(&!R%+)#O5!

    #(5).+D:!%+$!'%25$/!1D!'%)%5)+.>#('!$@$&)5J#20%&()DO5!+%>(/3D!.''2++(&?!%&/!525)%(&$/!

    (0>%')!1$(&?!)#$!'2++$&)!.&$7!!!!!!!

    H(@!RH>+$55(.&5!52'#!E&.@$3!$'.5D5)$05:F!%&/!&$.3.?(505!52'#!%5!!E%&)#+.0$5:F!0%D!1$!

    @($-$/!%5!I+-$33(%&!+$>+$5$&)%)(.&5!.6!)#$!#20%&!+$5#%>(&?!.6!&%)2+$7!R&)()3$/!#20%&!

    1$(&?5!25$!-#%)!)#$D!-%&)!6+.0!$'.5D5)$05:!-#(3$!/(5>3%'(&?!.+!$H)$+0(&%)(&?!)#$!>%+)5!

    )#%)!%+$!(&!)#$!-%D7!P.+!$H%0>3$:!-#%)!R2+.>$%&!'.3.&(K$+5!-%&)$/!).!25$!6+.0!)#$!`.+)#!

    )(.&!52++.2&/(&?!&%)2+%3!+$5.2+'$!?3.1%3!/$%357!S#$!%+?2$5!>$+52%5(@$3D!)#%)!()!(5!&.)!

  • #)""

    """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""T25)!E?+$$/DF!>$.>3$!(&!>.5()(.&5!.6!>.-$+!-#.!%+$!(0>3('%)$/!(&!'.++2>)(.&!5'#$0$5:!12)!%!

    ?3.1%3!&$)-.+,!.6!1%&,5:!'.+>.+%)(.&5:!%&/!?.@$+&0$&)5!-#.!1$'.0$!'.0>3('()!%&/!%35.!

    >+.6()7!G#(3$!*..'#!'3$%+3D!5$$5!)#$!5D5)$0(':!023)(/(0$&5(.&%3!'#%+%')$+!.6!#.-!

    '.++2>)(.&!-.+,5:!$5>$'(%33D!-#$&!>+.6()5!.6!0(33(.&5!.+!1(33(.&5!.6!/.33%+5!%+$!%)!5)%,$:!5#$!

    0(55$5!'.++2>)(.&O5!.1@(.25:!%&/!#$&'$!(&@(5(13$!6.2&/%)(.&J)#$!%')$/A2>.&!%5520>)(.&!

    )#%)!R%+)#O5!>3%'$5!%&/!1$(&?5!%+$!E&%)2+%3!+$5.2+'$57F!"#(5!1$/+.',!%5520>)(.&:!).!1.++.-!

    #(5).+(%&!X$.!9%+HO5!-.+/5:!(5!E5.!.1@(.25!)#%)!>$.>3$!/.!&.)!,&.-!-#%)!)#$D!%+$!%5520(&?!

    1$'%25$!&.!.)#$+!-%D!.6!>2))(&?!)#(&?5!#%5!$@$+!.''2++$/!).!)#$0F!Mb]]hL!a\[Aa\gN7!!!!

    H@((!S$$!c2#&!b]e\L!hlAh]7!