4
!"# %&'&( )#*'&%# %+,,&))&+- ./ "#-*0 1/ )+2+* 3/*/ -4/ 5678669 :: ,;< :==79 #- >1-%9 ?*<!9 */!/9 2/" "#$%&'( )*# +,-$. ,/ 0#1#2)3 ,/ 4#1$,3 5$%#2)-& 6)-)# 72%8#$3%)' *-3 )*# 3,&# 9,:#$ ,/ -.;%2%3)$-)%,2 ,8#$ )*# <2%8#$3%)'= +<) )*%3 9,:#$ %3 2,) #>?&<3%8# %2 )*# ;-))#$ ,/ .%3?%9&%2%21 -2. $#;,8%21 %)3 #;9&,'##3 -2. ,//%?%-&3=*#2 )*# &-: !#3),:3 <9,2 - 1,8#$2;#2) !,.' )*# "<$%3.%?)%,2 ), *#-$ -2. .#?%.# ?-3#3 %28,&8%21 39#?%/%? ;-))#$3( %) %3 ), !# 9$#3<;#. )*-) 3<?* "<$%3.%?)%,2 %3 #>?&<3%8# <2&#33 %) !# 9$,8#. )*-) -2,)*#$ !,.' %3 &%##:%3# 8#3)#. :%)* )*# 3-;# "<$%3.%?)%,2( %2 :*%?* ?-3#( !,)* !,.%#3 *-8# ?,2?<$$#2) "<$%3.%?)%,2 ,8#$ )*# ;-))#$= $&& ;#;!#$3 ,/ )*# ?%8%& 3#$8%?# -$# <2.#$ )*# "<$%3.%?)%,2 ,/ )*# %%8%& 6#$8%?# %,;;%33%,2 &%6%'( <2&#33 ,)*#$:%3# 9$,8%.#. !' &-:= +#%21 - 2,2(?-$##$ ?%8%& 3#$8-2) .,#3 2,) $#;,8# 6,",$ /$,; )*# -;!%) ,/ )*# %6%= %-$##$ ,$ 2,2(?-$##$( - ?%8%& 3#$8%?# ,//%?%-& ,$ #;9&,'## %3 :%)*%2 )*# "<$%3.%?)%,2 ,/ )*# %6%= !"#$%&'"&( *"&+, -%.%+ /0# 0$$%1&("' 2, (3"& 4+"#1'"&( 5%+06%& 7891&% 0# $+"#1'"&( %: (3" 5"&(+0; <1#0,0# 4%;,("=3&1= 5%;;">" ?5<45 1& !9"0>9"(" 51(,# 49+#90&( (% !#7# $%&% %+ (3" '*1>3"+ ('9=0(1%& )%'"+&160(1%& 7=( %: *&&+, 0 -%0+' %: .+9#(""# ?-/. /0# :%+""' (% 0=( 0# (3" >%0"+&1&> 2%', 1& #(0(" =%;;">"## .3" -/. %: 5<45 0$$%1&("' -%.%+ 0# $+"#1'"&( /1(3 0 :%9+1,"0+ ("+"2">1&&1&> -"$(""2"+ *&&$ 9$ (% -"$(""2"+ %22%# 3$%& (3" "4$1+0(1%& %: 31# :1+#( ("+" %: %::1=" 1& %22%5 3" /0# 0$$%1&("' $+"#1'"&( %: (3" 1&#(1(9(1%& :%+ 0 #"=%&' :%9+1,"0+ ("+"5 "4$1+1&> %& -"$(""2"+ %65 %227# /& 89&" %95 %2265 5<45 /0# =%&0"+("' 1&(% (3" :">+%# /+1"&(0; -(0(" 3&10"+#1(, ?:/!-3#7 -%0+' %: !">"&(# ?-/! #9==""'"' (3" -/. 0# 1(# >%0"+&1&> 2%',# )"0&/31;"5 (3+"" ?; #"$0+0(" 0'"1&1#(+0(10" =0#"# 0>01&#( -%.%+ /"+" :1;"' 2, 5<45 :0=9;(, """2"+# 2":%+" (3" 5101; -"+01=" 5%""1##1%& ?5-5 !">1%&0; /::1="# -%.%+ "%0"' (% '1#"1## (3" :1+#( (/% =%"$;01&(# 29( /0# '"&1"'# -%.%+ 0$$"0;"' (3" 0=(1%&# %: (3" !">1%&0; /::1=" (% (3" 5-5# *%/"0"+5 (3" 5-5 '1#"1##"' -%.%+<# 0$$"0; 0&' 09(3%+16"' 1(# !">1%&0; /::1=" (% $+%=""' /1(3 (3" 1&0"#(1>0(1%&# 3&'09&("'5 3" 0$$"0;"' (% (3" 5%9+( %: 7$$"0;# ?57 /31=3 +9;"' 1& 31# :00%+# =( 0&&9;;"' (3" 89"#(1%&"' 5-5 +"#%;9(1%&# 0&' $"+"0&"&(;, "&.%1&"' (3" 5-5 :+%" $+%=""'1&> /1(3 (3" 0'"1&1#(+0(10" 1&0"#(1>0(1%&# *"&="5 (31# $"(1(1%&# &))##)$ * >3"(3"+ %+ &%( (3" 5-5 30# .9+1#'1=(1%& %0"+ -%.%+5 1& 01"/ %: (3" "4=;9#10" >+0&( %: !#7# &%&& %: (3" $%/"+ (% 0'"1&1#("+ :/!-3 (% 1(# -%0+' %: !">"&(# % >3"(3"+ %+ &%( (3" 0##9"$(1%& 2, (3" 5-5 %: .9+1#'1=(1%& %0"+ 0 $+"#1'"&( %: 0 #(0(" 9&10"+#1(, 01%;0(" 0=0'""1= :+""'%" ; >3"(3"+ %+ &%( (3" -0;0;1"0 '%=(+1&" 1# 0$$;1=02;" 1& (31# =0#" "#(%$ 4"(1(1%& 3*1-!#%# !& '4() 4* +& >4;), 4* *-.+! +4 %/!0/'1/. +**/0/;1! ;., #2'14<! /! -4+ #3014!/.5 %)% ";! %4.04)).+ 24)/!,/0+/4. +.) ; 6)!/,.+ 4* ; )+;+ #./.)!/+<

CSC v. Sojor.pdf

  • Upload
    corky01

  • View
    10

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: CSC v. Sojor.pdf

!"#$%&'&($)#*'&%#$%+,,&))&+-$./$"#-*0$1/$)+2+*$3/*/$-4/$5678669$::$,;<$:==79$#-$>1-%9$?* < !9$*/!/9$2/"$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$! !"#$%&'(!)*#!+,-$.!,/!0#1#2)3!,/!4#1$,3!5$%#2)-&!6)-)#!72%8#$3%)'!*-3!)*#!3,&#!9,:#$!,/!-.;%2%3)$-)%,2!,8#$!)*#!

<2%8#$3%)'=!!+<)!)*%3!9,:#$!%3!2,)!#>?&<3%8#!%2!)*#!;-))#$!,/!.%3?%9&%2%21!-2.!$#;,8%21!%)3!#;9&,'##3!-2.!,//%?%-&3= *#2!)*#!

&-:!!#3),:3!<9,2!-!1,8#$2;#2)!!,.'!)*#!"<$%3.%?)%,2!),!*#-$!-2.!.#?%.#!?-3#3!%28,&8%21!39#?%/%?!;-))#$3(!%)!%3!),!!#!9$#3<;#.!

)*-)!3<?*!"<$%3.%?)%,2!%3!#>?&<3%8#!<2&#33!%)!!#!9$,8#.!)*-)!-2,)*#$!!,.'!%3!&%##:%3#!8#3)#.!:%)*!)*#!3-;#!"<$%3.%?)%,2(!%2!:*%?*!

?-3#(!!,)*!!,.%#3!*-8#!?,2?<$$#2)!"<$%3.%?)%,2!,8#$!)*#!;-))#$=!$&&!;#;!#$3!,/!)*#!?%8%&!3#$8%?#!-$#!<2.#$!)*#!"<$%3.%?)%,2!,/!

)*#!%%8%&!6#$8%?#!%,;;%33%,2!&%6%'(!<2&#33!,)*#$:%3#!9$,8%.#.!!'!&-:=!!+#%21!-!2,2(?-$##$!?%8%&!3#$8-2)!.,#3!2,)!$#;,8#!

6,",$!/$,;!)*#!-;!%)!,/!)*#!%6%=!!%-$##$!,$!2,2(?-$##$(!-!?%8%&!3#$8%?#!,//%?%-&!,$!#;9&,'##!%3!:%)*%2!)*#!"<$%3.%?)%,2!,/!)*#!

%6%=$!!

!"#$%&'"&()*"&+,)-%.%+)/0#)0$$%1&("')2,)(3"&)4+"#1'"&()5%+06%&)7891&%)0#)$+"#1'"&()%:)(3")5"&(+0;)<1#0,0#)4%;,("=3&1=)5%;;">")?5<45 )1&)!9"0>9"(")51(,#))

)49+#90&() (%) !#7#) $%&%) %+) (3") '*1>3"+) ('9=0(1%&) )%'"+&160(1%&) 7=() %:) *&&+,) 0) -%0+') %:)

.+9#(""#) ?-/. ) /0#) :%+""') (%) 0=() 0#) (3") >%0"+&1&>) 2%',) 1&) #(0(") =%;;">"##)) .3") -/.) %:) 5<45)0$$%1&("')-%.%+)0#)$+"#1'"&()/1(3)0):%9+1,"0+) ("+")2">1&&1&>)-"$(""2"+)*&&$)9$)(%)-"$(""2"+)%22%#))3$%&)(3")"4$1+0(1%&)%:)31#):1+#()("+")%:)%::1=")1&)%22%5)3")/0#)0$$%1&("')$+"#1'"&()%:)(3")1&#(1(9(1%&):%+)0)#"=%&'):%9+1,"0+)("+"5)"4$1+1&>)%&)-"$(""2"+)%65)%227#)

)/&)89&")%95)%2265)5<45)/0#)=%&0"+("')1&(%)(3"):">+%#)/+1"&(0;)-(0(")3&10"+#1(,)?:/!-3 #))7)

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

)3&'09&("'5)3")0$$"0;"')(%)(3")5%9+()%:)7$$"0;#)?57 )/31=3)+9;"')1&)31#):00%+#))=()0&&9;;"')(3")

89"#(1%&"')5-5)+"#%;9(1%&#)0&')$"+"0&"&(;,)"&.%1&"')(3")5-5):+%")$+%=""'1&>)/1(3)(3")0'"1&1#(+0(10")1&0"#(1>0(1%&#)*"&="5)(31#)$"(1(1%&#)

)&))##)$$$) * )>3"(3"+)%+)&%() (3")5-5)30#) .9+1#'1=(1%&)%0"+)-%.%+5) 1&)01"/)%:) (3")"4=;9#10")>+0&()%:)!#7#)&%&&)%:)(3")$%/"+)(%)0'"1&1#("+):/!-3)(%)1(#)-%0+')%:)!">"&(#))) % ) >3"(3"+) %+) &%() (3") 0##9"$(1%&) 2,) (3") 5-5) %:) .9+1#'1=(1%&) %0"+) 0) $+"#1'"&() %:) 0) #(0(")9&10"+#1(,)01%;0(")0=0'""1=):+""'%"))) ; )>3"(3"+)%+)&%()(3")-0;0;1"0)'%=(+1&")1#)0$$;1=02;")1&)(31#)=0#")))"#(%$$$$))))))))

4"(1(1%&)3*1-!#%#))))!& $ '4( )$ 4*$ +& $>4;),$ 4*$* - .+!$ +4$%/!0/'1/. $+**/0/;1!$ ;.,$#2'14< !$ /!$-4+$#3014!/. 5$%)%$";!$%4.04)) .+$24)/!,/0+/4.$+. )$;$6) !/, .+$4*$;$)+;+ $#./. )!/+<)))

Page 2: CSC v. Sojor.pdf

!!!!!!!!!! "#$%&'(!6!'*!+#-#!$%&%5!'2! %3#!4&53#2!(78$9%&'(!)'7#2(&;9%&'(!-$%!'*!*&&+5!8(7#2!>3&$3! ?9>!"'@'2!>9A!9BB'&(%#7!782&(5!%3#!%&"#!"9%#2&9?!%'!%3#!B2#A#(%!$9A#5!B2'0&7#A!%39%!%3#!A$3''?<A!5'0#2(&(5!F'927!A39??!390#!%3#!5#(#29?!B'>#2A!'*!97"&(&A%29%&'(!529(%#7!%'!9!$'2B'29%&'(#!!=(!977&%&'(5!"#$%&'(!6!'*!%3#! ?9>!529(%A! %'! %3#!F'927!%3#!B'>#2! %'!2#"'0#!A$3''?! *9$8?%H!"#"F#2A5!97"&(&A%29%&0#!'**&$&9?A5!9(7!#"B?'H##A!*'2!$98A#?!!!

'"#$%&'(! 6#!! )"#$%&' ()*' *,-.$&' "/' +"1$%).)2' 3"(%*&#! @!!& $ -&' )./.-$ 7&,),$ !&,11$&,' $ +& $ *&11&(/.-$ !' 0/*/0$ '&( )!$ ,.,$ ,4+/ !$ /.$ ,,,/+/&.$ +&$ /+!$ - . ),1$ '&( )!$ &*$,,2/./!+),+/&.$,.,$+& $ 3 )0/! $&*$,11$+& $'&( )!$-),.+ ,$+&$+& $7&,),$&*$,/) 0+&)!$&*$,$ 0&)'&),+/&.! 8(7#2! "#$%&'(! ;7! '*! -9%9A! O9"F9(A9! -?5#! 7$5! '%3#2>&A#! A('>(! 9A! %3#!Q'2B'29%&'(!Q'7#!'*!%3#!O3&?&BB&(#A?!!!

4!!4!!4!!!!

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

!!!!!!!!!!!! .3#! 9F'0#! A#$%&'(! >9A! A8FA#V8#(%?H! 2#B2'78$#7! 9A! "#$%&'(! +W& ! '*! %3#! A8$$##7&(5! ?9>! %39%!$'(0#2%#7!QXOQ!&(%'!:/+"35!+#-#!&%&&#!!:'%9F?H5!9(7!&(!$'(%29A%!>&%3!%3#!#92?&#2!?9>5!+#-#!&%&&!('>!B2'0&7#A!%39%!%3#!97"&(&A%29%&'(!'*!%3#!8(&0#2A&%H!9(7!#4#2$&A#!'*!$'2B'29%#!B'>#2A!'*!%3#!F'927!'*!%3#!A$3''?!A39??!F#!#4$?8A&0#?!!!

'"#$#! 6#! !$*5.).&-%(-.")#! @! .3#! 3(&0#2A&%H! A39??! 390#! %3#! 5#(#29?! B'>#2A! '*! 9!$'2B'29%&'(! A#%! *'2%3! &(! -9%9A! O9"F9(A9! -?5#! 7$5! 9A! 9"#(7#75! '%3#2>&A#! A('>(! 9A! '.3#!Q'2B'29%&'(! Q'7#! '*! %3#! O3&?&BB&(#A#,! !!& $ ,,2/./!+),+/&.$ &*$ +& $ #./' )!/+:$ ,.,$ +& $ 3 )0/! $&*$ /+!$0&)'&),+ $'&( )!$!&,11$7 $' !+ ,$ 3014!/' 1:$/.$+& $;&,),$&*$< - .+!$,.,$+& $') !/, .+$&*$+& $#./' )!/+:$/.!&*,)$,!$,4+&&)/9 ,$7:$+& $;&,),#,!

!!!!!!!!!!!! )#9A82#7! FH! %3#! *'2#5'&(5! H927A%&$A5! %3#2#! &A! ('! V8#A%&'(! %39%! 97"&(&A%29%&0#! B'>#2! '0#2! %3#!A$3''?!#4$?8A&0#?H!F#?'(5A!%'!&%A!-/+#!!-8%!7'#A!%3&A!#4$?8A&0#!97"&(&A%29%&0#!B'>#2!#4%#(7!%'!%3#!B'>#2!%'!2#"'0#!&%A!#22&(5!#"B?'H##A!9(7!'**&$&9?AC!!!

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

X#2&?H5! %3#! -'927! '*! +#5#(%A! '*! :/+"3! 39A! %3#! A'?#! B'>#2! '*! 97"&(&A%29%&'(! '0#2! %3#!8(&0#2A&%H#!!-8%!%3&A!B'>#2!&A!('%!#4$?8A&0#!&(!%3#!"9%%#2!'*!7&A$&B?&(&(5!9(7!2#"'0&(5!&%A!#"B?'H##A!9(7!'**&$&9?A#!!!!!!!!!!!!>3#(!%3#!?9>!F#A%'>A!8B'(!9!5'0#2("#(%!F'7H!%3#!@82&A7&$%&'(!%'!3#92!9(7!7#$&7#!$9A#A!&(0'?0&(5!AB#$&*&$!"9%%#2A5!&%!&A!%'!F#!B2#A8"#7!%39%!A8$3!@82&A7&$%&'(!&A!#4$?8A&0#!8(?#AA!&%!F#!B2'0#7!%39%!9('%3#2!F'7H! &A! ?&A#>&A#! 0#A%#7! >&%3! %3#! A9"#! @82&A7&$%&'(5! &(! >3&$3! $9A#5! F'%3! F'7&#A! 390#! $'($822#(%!@82&A7&$%&'(!'0#2!%3#!"9%%#2#!

Page 3: CSC v. Sojor.pdf

!!"##!"%"&%'(!)*!+,%!-.0.#!(%'0.-%!0'%!123%'!+,%!41'.(3.-+.)2!)*!+,%!5655!12#%((!)+,%'8.(%!9')0.3%3!

&:!#08#!!-%.2=!0!2)21-0'%%'!-.0.#!(%'002+!3)%(!2)+!'%")0%!6)4)'!*')"!+,%!0"&.+!)*!+,%!565#!!50'%%'!)'!2)21-0'%%'5!0!-.0.#!(%'0.-%!)**.-.0#!)'!%"9#):%%!.(!8.+,.2!+,%!41'.(3.-+.)2!)*!+,%!565#!!!!!!!!!!!!!=2!+,%!")'%!'%-%2+!-0(%!)*!%"#"$%&'()'++&,-"5!+,.(!5)1'+!#%2+!-'%3%2-%!+)!+,%!-)2-1''%2+!41'.(3.-+.)2!)*! +,%! 565! 8,%2! .+! 0**.'"%3! +,0+! 0! -0(%! 0=0.2(+! 0! 12.0%'(.+:! )**.-.0#! "0:! &%! *.#%3! %.+,%'! 8.+,! +,%!12.0%'(.+:<(!-/B!)'!3.'%-+#:!8.+,!+,%!565#!!.,%!5)1'+!D1)+%(?!!!

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

0-0/.!+# 0# !+0+ # 4./7 )!/+8# %**/0/01#208#7 # */1 ,# /+& )#(/+&# +& # 4./7 )!/+8;!#=%0),# %*#

> - .+!# %)# ,/) 0+18# (/+&# +& # ?/7/1# @ )7/0 # ?%22/!!/%./# 01+&%4-&# +& # ?@?# 208#

, 1 -0+ # +& # /.7 !+/-0+/%.# %*# 0# 0%2'10/.+# 0.,# *%)# +&0+# '4)'%! /#208# , '4+/9 # 0.8#

, '0)+2 .+/#0- .08/#%**/0/01#%)#-)%4'#%*#%**/0/01!#+%#0%.,40+#!40&#/.7 !+/-0+/%.##!!!!!!!!!!!!! .,1(5! 565! 00#.3#:! +))A! -)=2.O02-%! )*! +,%! 03".2.(+'0+.0%! -)"9#0.2+(! 3.'%-+#:! *.#%3! &%*)'%! +,%!'%=.)20#!)**.-%5!-)2-%'2.2=!0.)#0+.)2(!)*!-.0.#!(%'0.-%!'1#%(!0=0.2(+!6)4)'#!!!B00, 2/0#<) ,%2#D08#E%+# 7 # F.7%= ,#>& .#I& ) # 0) #B11 - ,#J/%10+/%.!# %*#?/7/1# @ )7/0 #

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

#

.,%! 5)1'+! ,0(! ,%#3! +,0+! +,%! =10'02+%%3! 0-03%".-! *'%%3)"! 3)%(! 2)+! =.0%! 02! .2(+.+1+.)2! +,%!12&'.3#%3!01+,)'.+:!+)!9%'*)'"!0-+(!8.+,)1+!02:!(+0+1+)':!&0(.(#!!D)'!+,0+!'%0()25!0!(-,))#!)**.-.0#5!8,)!.(!0!"%"&%'!)*!+,%!-.0.#!(%'0.-%5!"0:!2)+!&%!9%'".++%3!+)!-)"".+!0.)#0+.)2(!)*!-.0.#!(%'0.-%!'1#%(!123%'!+,%!41(+.*.-0+.)2!+,0+!,%!80(!*'%%!+)!3)!()!123%'!+,%!9'.2-.9#%!)*!0-03%".-!*'%%3)"#!!!

.,%! 5)1'+! 3)%(! 2)+! 0='%%! 8.+,! 6)4)'<(! -)2+%2+.)2! +,0+! ,.(! 099).2+"%2+! +)! +,%! 9)(.+.)2! )*!9'%(.3%2+!)*!:/B635!3%(9.+%!+,%!9%23.2=!03".2.(+'0+.0%!-0(%(!0=0.2(+!,."5!(%'0%3!0(!0!-)23)20+.)2!&:!

Page 4: CSC v. Sojor.pdf

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