36
di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing, skipping and sliding : analysis of the non-smooth dynamics of the DC/DC buck converter. Early version, also known as pre-print Link to publication record in Explore Bristol Research PDF-document University of Bristol - Explore Bristol Research General rights This document is made available in accordance with publisher policies. Please cite only the published version using the reference above. Full terms of use are available: http://www.bristol.ac.uk/pure/about/ebr-terms

di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

  • Upload
    vutu

  • View
    218

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing, skippingand sliding : analysis of the non-smooth dynamics of the DC/DC buckconverter.

Early version, also known as pre-print

Link to publication record in Explore Bristol ResearchPDF-document

University of Bristol - Explore Bristol ResearchGeneral rights

This document is made available in accordance with publisher policies. Please cite only the publishedversion using the reference above. Full terms of use are available:http://www.bristol.ac.uk/pure/about/ebr-terms

Page 2: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

������������ �����������������������������������������! ������#"%$'&�(�)�"*�+,��-."�"�&�(/�� ����-0�!12�3"*$4&�(�)6587:9;5<7 =�>�1?�@12"*BAC)���&�)��

D�EGFIHKJMLNHPORQFTSUEVFILWJBXGY[Z]\WFIH_^2OR`ULWL�a;EGS,L�bdc_EVS�Z]\,EGeBfWSWQgh^�Xi�jlknmporqtstu2knv!sxwryWz[vp{}|~v�knk�qt|~vp{���oIs���knu�oIst|~���T�� vp| �!k�q��t| s���wryU��qt|~�tstw}���p��qt|~�tstw}�h�P���d���l��� �?� �R��n�����ww}�hwryU��oIst�pk�u�oIst|~�Tor�N���|~knv��nk��n� � vp| �!k�q��t| s���wryU��oIs����G��oIs��������2�I�W�R� � � �R�¡�¢N£¥¤r¦T§G¨}¤�©«ª�v¬s���|~��mpormVk�qn��­�k�mpqtwT�|~®pk�orv'orv¯or� ��st|~�Tor�;|~vp��|~{}�!s�|~v�stw°st�pk�w}±p��k�q²�!kn®v�w}vp�~|~vpknorq]±Gk��¯o���|~w}³pq]wryPs��pk�±p³���´*��w}v!�!k�qtstknqRorvp®B�~|~vp´�st�p|~�?­l| st�*st�pk��tst³p®��*wrylo�­x|~®pk�q���µor�t��wry,mp|~k��nk¥­x|~��k¥¶��tu2wwrst���²���²s�k�u2� � �xyKstk�ql|~v!stq�w�®p³p��|~vp{2s���k]±p³���´;��w}v!�!knq²s�k�q�u2w�®pk��Norvp®±por��´{}qtw}³pvp®·�U­�k�®pk�����qt|~±Vk¸st�pk�u2w}�ts?y_or����|~v¯oIst|~vp{�yKkToIst³pqtkn� wryx| s�� ®��v¯oru2|~�nor��±Gk��¯on�|~w}³pq �¹ k�st�pk�v2|~v�stq�w�®p³p��k�s���kl�twr¶��nor�~�~kn®]{}q�orº�|~vp{?orvp®R���~|~®p|~vp{l��w}�~³�st|~w}vp�[orvp®¸®p|~�t�n³����Ws��pk�|~q,q�w}�~k�|~v®�k�stk�q�u2|~vp|~v�{¸u�orv��dwryUs���k ±�³p��´;��w}v!�!k�qtstknqn» ��®��v¯oru2|~�nor�hw�®p®p| st|~k�� � ª�v�m¯orq²s�|~��³p�µorqn�Go¸�~w��Tor�u�orm�|~�·�tst³p®p|~k�® ­x�p|~��� k¥¼mp�µor|~vp�N�pwn­Cst�pk[{}q�orº�|~vp{�±p| yK³pqt�ToIst|~w}vp�h�nor³p�tk����porq�m�s�³�q�vp|~vp{xmGw}|~v�st�|~v�st�pk2±p| yK³pq��noIst|~w}v*®p|µor{}q�oru«wry�mVk�qt|~w®p|~�Rw}q�±p| st� � ��w}qtk�wT�!k�qT�h­�k¸���pwn­½�pwn­¾s���kn�tk�w}q�±p| st�or����³pu]³p�µoIs�k]w}v�stw�o¸���~|~®p|~vp{¸stq�oT¿tk��¥s�w}q²��st�pq�w}³p{}�%o%À���m�|~q�or�~�~|~vp{}Á;ÂÄÃ�ÅÆ!ÇTÈ�Æ�É!É}ÂÄÊË]����k�v¯orq�|~w ��P�pk2�²s�qt³p�¥s�³�q�k2wryP��³����Bod®p|µor{}q�oruÌ|~�?®pk�q�| �!k�®Corvpor� �st|~�nor�~� �Corv�®C|~�?���pwn­xv*stw;±Gk2���~w}��k�� �qtk��µoIs�k�®�s�w;st�pk2orvpor� ���t|~��wryP�pw}u2w���~|~vp|~� ±p| yK³pq��noIst|~w}vp� � �P�pk¸q�k��t³p� s��?orqtk¸����wT­xv%stw;u�oIst���mGk�qtyKk��¥s�� ��­x| s��dv�³pu2k�q�|~�nor���t|~uR³p�µoIst|~w}vp� � �x��k���³p®�®pk�vR¿²³pu2m2s�w¸�µorqt{}k¥¶����nor�~k����porw}��orvp®�st�pkÍpvp{}k�q�k�®��tstq�³���st³pqtk�wryUst�pk�qtkn�t³p� st|~vp{2oIs²s�q�or��stw}q�orqtk�or�~��wRk�¼mp�µor|~vpk�® �

Î \WJ�FnϸÏIHÄÏIcKQ�РÑ�J�SNÒ�^TeBJhJGÏT\�LNghSUEVeCH�Ó�^¸JVÔxÏI\WQ�Õ�Z2ÖGÕ�ZØ×W`UÓrÙ�Ó!J�S·Ú�Q�FTÏTQFÎ QfNÏTQe%×[Q�F�Û�ÛNY�ÜÝ�Ý·Þ

Page 3: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Ûß[à/á!â�ãäpåxælç�èGã�é²å[âê¥S¬FTQ�Ó!Q�S·ÏCgVQEVFI^Y�e%`,Ór\4FIQ^TQEGFrÓr\ëQ�ì[J�FnÏB\UEV^*×[Q�Q�S'^Tf,QS�ÏMH_S4H_ShÚVQ^nÏTH_í�EGÏTH_SWí�ÏI\WQ�LNghSUEGeBH�Ó�^JGÔî^TJGÒ¥Ó�EVcKc_QLïÕ�Z2Ö¯Õ�Zñð�òUóIô«Ó!J�ShÚVQ�FTÏTQFI^¾`,^nQ�LïHKS:f,J¯õRQ�FöQ�c_QÓ!ÏTFIJVSWH�Ó�^÷ùø¸\WQ�^nQú^ngN^nÏTQ�eM^EGFIQ�`U^TQLÌõ2\WQ�SUQ�ÚVQFûÏI\WQ�FIQîH�^ûÏI\WQ°SWQ�Q�L'ÔüJVF�EVLpý�`,^�ÏIHKSWí¬Eëí�HKÚ�Q�SÌÕ�Z:ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGíVQ�ÏTJöE4cKJ¯õRQ�FÚ¯EGc_`WQV÷?DîE¯ÏT\UQ�eME¯ÏIH_ÓEGc_cKg�YhÏT\WQg�Ó�EVS�×[Q�LNQ�^TÓ�FTH_×,Q�L�×hgûfUHKQ�Ó!Q�õ2H�^TQ�^TeBJhJGÏT\�^TgN^�ÏIQ�eM^¸JGÔ?þ;Õ�ÿ]^�Y^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WHKSUí�×[Q!Ï�õRQ�Q�S�Ï�õ]J�LNHÄì�Q�FIQ�S·Ï;cKH_SWQEVF;^TgN^�ÏIQ�eM^�õ2\WQ�SWQÚVQF�Eûc_H_SWQEVF�Ó!J�e%×WH_SUEGÏTH_JVS�JVÔ�ÏT\WQ^Tgh^nÏTQe ^nÏIEGÏTQ�^?Ó!FIJ�^I^nQ�^�EGSûEVfWfWFIJVfWFIH_EGÏTQcKg�í�HKÚ�Q�SBf[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó2fWH_QÓ�Q�õ2H�^nQ�Ò�c_HKSUQEGF�FIQ!ÔüQFTQSUÓ!Q�^TH_íVSUEVct÷

Ñ�JVSUcKH_SWQEVF�fW\WQ�SUJVeBQ�SUE;H_SUÓ!c_`ULNH_SWí�×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�S*EVSUL*Ór\,EGJ�^�\UEpÚ�Q ×[Q�QS*ÔüJ�`WSUL*HKS*ÏT\UQ2×W`UÓrÙEGS,L�FTQc_EGÏTQ�L�Ó!J�S·Ú�Q�FTÏTQFI^d×,JVÏT\îSh`WeBQFTH�Ó�EVcKc_g�EVSUL�Q � f[Q�FIH_eCQS·ÏIEGc_c_g�×hg�E�S·`Ue%×[Q�F;JGÔ]EV`NÏT\WJ�FI^� � Y��NY�ÜpÞ·Y�Ü � Y�Ü��NY�ÛNÜVY2ÛWYdÞhY�ÜÝ��÷�WJ�F�Q � EGeBfWc_QVYdHKÏ�\UEV^�×,QQ�S ^n\UJ¯õ2S ÏT\UEGÏ�×hg Ú¯EGFIghHKSUíÏT\UQMQ � ÏTQFTSUEVc�ÔüJVFrÓ!H_SWí�ÚVJVcKÏIEVíVQ�Y�ÏT\WQCÔü`WS,LWEGeBQ�S·ÏrEGc?f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�ÓM^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVS ��ÏI\WQûLNQ^TH_FTQ�L ^nÏIEGÏTQBHKSeBJ�^nÏCEVfWfWc_H_ÓE¯ÏTH_JVS,^���`WSULNQFTí�J·Q�^%EVSëHKSUHÄÏIH_EVc]f[Q�FIHKJNLöLNJV`W×UcKH_SWí ÓEV^IÓ�E�LNQV÷îbRÏB\WH_íV\WQF�ÔüJ�FIÓ�HKSWíÚVJ�cÄÏrEGí�Q^YhÏT\WQ�`,^n`UEVcPf[Q�FIHKJNLhÒ¥LNJV`U×WcKH_SWíMFIJV`NÏIQ�H_^dHKS·ÏIQ�FIFT`WfWÏTQL�×hg�EVS�EG×WFI`WfNÏ�QSWc�EGFIíVQ�eBQS�Ï�JVÔÏT\UQ�FIQ^T`WcKÏTH_SWí������������!ó������CÓr\UEGJVÏTH�Ó�E¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ!ÏTJVF�÷îø¸\WQ�^ngN^nÏTQe�ÏI\WQ�S¬^�ÏrEGFTÏI^%ÏTJ Q�ÚVJ�cKÚ�Q�EGc_JVSUíE������ �!�"�!ó�������Ór\,EGJGÏIH_ÓîE¯ÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏIJVFMJNÓ�Ó�`Wfhg·H_SWí4EVfWfWFIJ � HKeME¯ÏIQ�c_g"#%$�'&)(+*,���BHKSÌfW\UEV^TQî^TfUEVÓ�QV÷-�Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó�EVSUL Ór\UEGJVÏTH�Ó�E¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ}ÏIJVFr^M\UEpÚ�Q�EGc�^nJ½×[Q�QSØLNH_^IÓ!J¯Ú�Q�FIQL'E¯Ï�cKJ¯õRQ�FMH_SWfW`NÏ�ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGíVQ�^�YÓ!JhQ � H�^nÏTH_SWí õ2HÄÏI\ ÏT\WQëÔü`WSULWEVeCQS·ÏIEGcC^�ÏrE¯ÏIQVY�EGc_×[Q�HKÏîõ2HÄÏI\ ^neMEVcKc�×,EV^THKSU^�JGÔûE¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ}ÏIHKJ�S � � ��÷.2Q�Ó!Q�S·ÏM^nH_e%`Uc_EGÏTH_JVSU^%×·g¾ÏI\WQ0/UFI^nÏCEV`NÏT\UJVFBEGSULëÓ�JGÒ�õ]J�FTÙ�Q�Fr^ � � ��Y \UEpÚVQMÔüJNÓ�`U^T^TQLëJVSö^T`UÓr\4E132 �4���65 &�(�*7�¸Ór\UEVJGÏIH_Ó;E¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ}ÏIJVF�÷98 HKÏT\UHKS�ÏT\UH_^¸fUEVFIEVeBQ!ÏTQF¸FTQíVH_JVSPYNE%Ô²EGeBHKc_gûJVÔxÏT\UFTQQ!Ò�f,QFTH_JNLNH_ÓJVFI×WHKÏI^�Ór\,EGFrEVÓ}ÏIQ�FIH_^TQLî×hg°LNHKì�Q�FIHKSWí�Sh`We*×,QFI^�JGÔ�^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí·^�f[Q�F%f[Q�FIH_JhLPYlõ¸EV^�ÔüJ�`WSUL°ÏIJ�×,QJVFIí�EVSWH�^nQ�LûEGc_JVSWíCE:�<;,=��4�+���>=�*?��ð@= AròB�Tó�� 1 =C(�*"D+=C�����4���*÷RÑ�`WeBQFTH�Ó�EVc[QÚhH_LNQSUÓ!Q;fWFIQ^TQ�S·ÏTQ�Lû×[Q�c_J¯õ^T\WJ¯õ�^?ÏI\UE¯Ï2E%^TH_eCH_c�EGF¸^nfWH_FrEGc�^�ÏIFT`UÓ!ÏT`WFIQ;`WSULNQFTc_HKQ�^?ÏI\WQ;c_EVFTí�Q�FE/,ÚVQ!ÒGF�J�SWQ�Ór\,EGJGÏIH_ÓdFTQíVH_JVS�EVc_^TJU÷

þdÏT\WQFëFTQ�Ó!QS�ÏëõRJVFIÙ ×hg ÏI\WQ /UFr^�ϬEG`NÏI\WJVFëEVSUL Ó!JGÒ�õRJVFIÙVQ�Fr^ � ����\UEV^4Ó!JVS,LN`UÓ}ÏIQLïEVSEGS,EGc_g�ÏIH_ÓEGc�H_ShÚVQ^nÏTH_í�EGÏTH_JVS�JGÔ�^nJ�eBQ�ÏT\WQ%^TH_eCfUcKQ�^�Ï�f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó�J�FT×WHKÏI^¸H_S�ÏT\UQ�×W`UÓrÙ�Ó!JVShÚ�Q�FTÏTQ�F¸×hgEGS,EGc_gh^TH_SWí;EVSMEGfWfWFIJVfUFTH�E¯ÏIQH��IJ= 1 ó 2 =�*!�K�L��;[÷�ø¸\WH�^�eMEGfUfWHKSUí�LWQ^IÓ!FIHK×[Q^�ÏI\WQ�Ó!H_FrÓ!`WHKÏ LNghSUEGeBH�Ó�^ÔüFIJVeÌJ�SWQ ^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WH_SWí2HKS,^�ÏrEGS·Ï�ÏTJ2ÏI\WQ?SWQ � ÏY¯EGSUL;H�^xÓ�cKJ·^nQcKg;EGSUEVcKJ�íVJV`,^UÏIJ2eMEGfWfWH_SWí·^P`U^TQL;H_S�ÏT\WQ^nÏT`ULNg�JGÔ�JGÏI\WQ�FdfWHKQ�Ó!Qõ2H_^TQ�^neBJhJGÏI\�^ngN^nÏTQ�eM^2^T`UÓr\�EV^2H_eBfUEVÓ!ÏdJ�^IÓ!H_c_c_EGÏTJVFr^ � ÜVYxÜVÜVYPÜ�M��÷ONd^THKSWíÏT\UH_^�EVfWfWFIJ�EVÓr\xYGÓ!JVS,LNHÄÏIHKJ�SU^lÔüJVF�H_SB/USWHKÏTQ2c_JNÓ�EVch^nÏTFIQ!ÏrÓr\WH_SWí�HKS*ÏT\WQ�LWg·S,EGeBH_Ó^�õ]QFTQ¸LNQ�FIH_ÚVQLCEGS,LÏT\UQP/UFr^�ÏRf,QFTH_JNLhÒ¥LNJV`W×UcKH_SWí�×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�S�EVÓÓ!`WFrE¯ÏIQ�c_g*LNQ�ÏTQ�Ó}ÏTQ�L�÷JQ�J¯õRQ�Ú�Q�F�Y�E¯Ï]fWFTQ�^nQS·ÏYhEGc_eCJ·^�ÏEGc_c�JGÔ�ÏT\UQ�LNghSUEGeBH�Ó�EGc�JNLWLWHÄÏIHKQ�^2eBQ�S·ÏTH_JVSWQ�L�EV×,J¯Ú�Q�FIQ�eMEVHKS�`WSWQ � fUc_EVHKSWQ�L�÷ø¸\WQ�eMEGH_SûEGH_e JVÔ�ÏT\WH�^ f,EGf[Q�F?H�^�ÏIJ�íVH_ÚVQdEVSûEGSUEVcKg·ÏIH_ÓEGcWQ � fUc_EVSUE¯ÏIHKJ�SCJVÔ�ÏT\WQ�`WSWQ � fWc�EGH_SWQ�LfW\WQSWJVeBQSUE4H_S«ÏT\WQ¾×W`UÓrÙØÓ�JVShÚVQFnÏIQ�F�LNghSUEGeBH�Ó�^YdÔüJ�F�HKSU^nÏIEVSUÓ!Q ÏT\UQ¾^T`ULWLWQ�SúQ�SWc�EGFIíVQeCQS·ÏÏTJ¾E'/,ÚVQ!ÒGF�J�SWQ�Ór\,EGJGÏIH_Ó�E¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ}ÏIJVF�÷"8°Q�EGc�^nJ°^nQQ�Ù°ÏTJ°`WSUÓ�J¯ÚVQ�F%ÔüQEGÏT`WFIQ^CJGÔdÏT\WQ�LNghSUEGeBH�Ó�^H_S ÏT\WQ°c�EGFIíVQ!Ò¥^IÓ�EGc_Q�Ór\UEGJVÏTH�Ó�FIQ�í�HKJ�SöÏI\UE¯Ï�eMEpg¬EVfWfWc_g¬ÏTJ4õ2H�LNQF�Ó�c_E�^T^TQ^�JGÔ%^Tgh^nÏTQe�÷ þ�`WFeME¯ý�J�F;E�Ór\WHKQÚVQeCQS·ÏdH_^�ÏIJ�LNQ�^TÓ�FTH_×[Q�ÏT\UQB^nÏTFI`UÓ!ÏT`WFIQ%JVÔ?ÏT\WQCJV×,^nQFTÚ�QL�^TfWHKFrEGc_c_HKSWí�×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�SLNH�EGí�FIEVeB^�×hgCEGSUEVcKgN^THKSWí�E�SUQEGFI×hg%Ó!JVÒ�LWHKeBQ�S,^nH_JVSNÒ�Ï�õRJ;f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó2^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSxY�E�^TJ�Ó�EVcKc_QL0���>=CD+=�*?�ÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIgV÷ Î `UÓr\ME;ÏTFrE¯ý�QÓ!ÏTJ�FTg�FIQ�eMEGH_SU^�ÔüJ�FJ/USWHKÏTQ2ÏIHKeBQ2õ2HKÏT\WH_SBÏT\UQ�LNH_^IÓ!J�S·ÏTH_S·`UHÄÏ�gC^nQ�Ï?JGÔ[ÏT\WQLNHKì[QFTQS·ÏTH�EGc�Q�R·`UEGÏTH_JVSU^ � Ý+��÷�ê�ϸõ2H_c_c�ÏT`WFIS�J�`NϸÏT\UEGÏRÏI\WQ�`WSNÔüJ�c_LNH_SWíBJGÔ�^nc_H�LNHKSUí*c_QE�LW^RSUE¯ÏI`WFIEVcKc_gÏTJB^TfWHKFrEGc[×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�S�LNH�EGí�FIEVeM^�YhEGSUL�\UEV^RECÓ!c_J�^TQ�EGS,EGc_JVíVgCõ2HKÏT\�ÏT\WQ�EGSUEVcKgN^TH_^]JGÔ Î \WH_c S SWH_ÙVJ¯Ú\WJ�eCJNÓ�cKH_SWH�Ó�×UHÄÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVSU^T�t^nQQ � Ü6U+��YNÔüJ�FRQ � EGeBfWc_Q)�}÷�ê�Ï2õ2H_cKc�×[Q�^n\UJ¯õ2SûÏT\,E¯Ï¸ÏT\WQ�c_HKe*×U^RJGÔlÏT\WQ^TfWHKFrEGc�\UEpÚVQ]^n\UEVFTf�ÏI`WFISWHKSUídf[JVH_S�Ïr^�YGÓEG`U^TQL�×·g�^TJGÒ¥Ó�EVcKc_QLV�W�4��&6=�*!�]×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVSU^YpHt÷ QV÷�õ2\WQ�S�ÏT\WQc_HKSWQ�EGF2Ó!J�e%×WH_SUEGÏTH_JVS�JVÔxÏI\WQ;Ï�õ]JB^ngN^nÏTQe3^�ÏrE¯ÏTQ�^¸fUEV^I^TQ^ ÏT\WFIJV`Wí�\ûÏI\WQ�Ó!JVFISWQFRJVÔPÏT\UQ�f,QFTH_JNLNH_ÓFIQ!ÔüQ�FIQ�S,Ó!Q�^nH_íVS,EGc�÷

Î HKS,Ó!Q ÏT\UQ JVFIHKí�HKSUEVc�fWFTQfUEGFrE¯ÏIHKJ�S JVÔ ÏI\WH_^ØfUEGf[Q�F õRQ \UEpÚVQú×[QÓ!J�eBQ EpõREVFTQ«JGÔ°ÏT\WQH_SULNQ�f[Q�S,LNQ�S·ÏûFIQ�c�E¯ÏTQ�L4õRJVFIÙ½×hg�X?`UEVSY� 1 �+�[Z � Û�M�dJ�Sö×[JVFrLNQFnÒ¥Ó!J�cKc_H_^TH_JVSë×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVSU^CH_S'ELNHKì[QFTQS·Ï�×W`UÓrÙîÓ�JVShÚVQFnÏIQ�F�Ó!JVS\/UíV`WFrE¯ÏIHKJ�SP÷Bø¸\WQ�H_F�õ]J�FTÙ�Y�õ2\WH�Ór\°H_^�c�EGFIíVQcKg�Sh`WeBQ�FIH�Ó�EGc�YPfW`WÏI^íVFrE�FHKSUíû×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�SU^;HKS°Õ�Z2ÖGÕ�Z Ó�JVShÚVQFnÏIQ�Fr^�õ2HKÏT\WH_S ÏT\WQCíVQSWQ�FrEGclÔüFIEVeBQ�õRJVFIÙ�JVÔ]^nJVÒ�ÓEGc_cKQ�L×[JVFrLNQ�FTÒ�Ó�JVc_cKH�^THKJ�Sû×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�SU^RJhÓÓ!`WFIH_SWí*H_S�EGFI×WHÄÏIFIEVFTgBfWH_QÓ�Q�õ2H�^nQ�Ò�^TeBJhJGÏT\�^ngN^nÏTQeB^÷�ê¥S�ÏT\WQHKF

Page 4: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

�Q � EVeCfUcKQ�YxÏI\WQûQ�SUc_EVFTí�Q�eBQ�S·Ï¸ý�`WeBfëJNÓ�Ó�`WFI^�×,Q�ÔüJVFIQBÏT\WQ�E�Ó�Ó�`We%`Wc�E¯ÏIHKJ�S¾JGÔ2f,QFTH_JNLhÒ¥LNJV`W×UcKH_SWí�^EGS,L�H�^2LNH_FTQ�Ó}ÏTc_g�EGÏnÏIFTH_×W`NÏrEG×Wc_Q;ÏTJMECíVFrE�F�H_SWí]�ü×[JVFrLNQ�F2Ó�JVc_cKH�^nH_JVS7� ×UHÄÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVSP÷�ê¥S�Ó!J�S·ÏTFrEV^nÏYhHKSJV`UF�FTQ�^n`UcÄÏr^�íVFrE�FHKSUí�fUc_EpgN^�E�eBJ�FTQû^T`W×U^TH_LWH_EVFTg FTJ�cKQ�Y�EVSUL°ÏT\WQ�eBEVHKS¾ÔüJNÓ�`U^%JVÔ¸ÏT\WQûfUFTQ�^nQS�ÏfUEVf,QF2H_^2J�S�EVS�`USNÔüJVc�LNH_SWíMJGÔ�^nc_H_LWHKSWí,÷

ø¸\WQ�FTQ�^�Ï2JVÔlÏI\WQ�fUEGf[Q�F2H�^2J�`NÏTc_HKSUQL�EV^RÔüJ�cKc_J¯õ�^�÷�b�Ô�ÏTQ�F�HKS·ÏIFTJNLN`UÓ�HKSUí*ÏI\WQ�×W`UÓrÙ�Ó!J�S·Ú�Q�FTÏTQFeBJNLNQ�c[HKS_^rÛWY�õRQdõ2H_cKc[×WFIHKQ6`UgBFTQÚhHKQõöÏI\WQ;eBEVHKSûÔüQE¯ÏI`WFIQ^]JGÔPHKÏI^RLNghSUEGeBH�Ó�EGc[×[Q�\UEpÚhH_JV`WF]HKS'^��W÷ê¥S�^TJ*LNJ�HKSUí�õ]Q�õ2HKc_c[HKS·ÏTFIJNLN`UÓ�Q�eBJVFIQ�Ó�EVFTQ�Ôü`Wc_cKg*ÏT\WQ;Ó!J�SUÓ!QfNÏI^]JGÔPí�FIEWF�H_SWí�EGSUL�^nc_H_LWHKSWí*HKSûÏT\WQfWFIQ^TQ�S·Ï�Ó!J�S�ÏIQ � Ï÷�ê¥Sa^�UBEBc_JNÓ�EVc�eBEVf�õ2H_c_cP×,Q*LNQ�FIHKÚ�QL�õ2\WH�Ór\�Q � fUc_EVHKSU^¸\UJ¯õ«í�FIEWF�H_SWí*ÓEG`U^TQ^^T\UEGFIf�ÏI`WFTSUHKSWí�f[JVH_S�Ïr^�HKS ÏT\UQC×UHÄÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVS°LNH_EVíVFrEGe#JGÔRf,QFTH_JNLNH�Ó*J�FT×UHÄÏr^�÷L^�bMÏI\WQ�S¾Ó!J�S·ÏIEGH_SU^ÏT\UQdeMEGH_SûFIQ^T`WcÄÏr^?JVÔ�ÏT\WQ�fUEGf[Q�F]JVSûEGS�`WSNÔüJVc�LNH_SWí%JVÔP^nc_H_LWHKSWíC^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVSU^Y�^T\WJ¯õ2H_SWí�ÚhH_E�Q � fWc_H_Ó�HÄÏÓ!J�SU^nÏTFI`UÓ}ÏIHKJ�S�JVÔ�^TJVc_`NÏIHKJ�SU^2SWQ�EGFd^TcKH�LNH_SWíM\WJ¯õ Eû^TfWHKFrEGc�×UHÄÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVS�LNH�EGí�FIEVe EGFIH�^nQ�^�÷�^ � õ2HKc_cEVLULNFTQ�^T^lÏI\WQ�^n`,LWLNQ�S;ý�`WeBfCÏTJ�c�EGFIíVQ¸^IÓ�EGc_Q2Ór\UEGJ·^�EGSUL%ÏT\WQ�^nÏTFI`UÓ!ÏT`WFIQ¸JGÔ[ÏT\WQ¸FIQ^T`WcÄÏIHKSUí�Ór\,EGJGÏIH_ÓE¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ!ÏTJVF�÷OlH_SUEVcKc_gVY9^}Þ*õ2H_cKc�LNFrEpõúÓ�JVSUÓ�cK`,^nH_JVSU^dEGSUL�J�`NÏTc_HKSUQ�Q � ÏTQSU^THKJ�SU^�JVÔ�ÏI\WQ�ÏI\WQ�J�FTg�ÏTJ�Eõ2H�LNQ�F�Ó�c_E�^T^¸JVÔlfWH_QÓ�Q!Ò�õ2H_^TQ�^neBJhJGÏI\�^TgN^�ÏIQ�eM^÷cPàedgfihkj'lKmnj'lpo�ç�è)q¬è�å,â,r7h·ä�ã)h·äb�S�QcKQeCQS·ÏIEGFIgû×W`,ÓrÙ�Ó!J�ShÚVQ�FTÏTQF2Ó�EGS�×[Q�HKeBfWc_Q�eBQS�ÏIQL�H_S�EMÓ�HKFrÓ!`UHÄÏ�EV^�FTQfWFTQ�^nQS·ÏTQL�HKSk�H_íU÷ÜV÷Mø¸\WH�^�Ó!J�SU^TH_^nÏI^;JGÔ2E�×UEV^TH�ÓtsTuwv Ó!H_FIÓ�`WHKÏYlE�LNH_JNLNQMEGSUL°E�^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí�QcKQeCQS·Ï÷Mø¸\WQûEGH_eJGÔ�ÏI\WQ�Ó!H_FIÓ�`WHKÏdH_^2ÏTJûeMEGH_S·ÏIEVHKS�EMLNQ�^nH_FTQ�L�ÚVJVcKÏIEVíVQ�YNcKJ¯õRQ�F¸ÏI\UEGS�ÏI\UE¯ÏdfUFTJ¯ÚhH�LNQL�×hg�ÏI\WQ�H_SWfW`NÏ×UEGÏnÏTQFTggxûYGEVÓ!FIJ�^I^�ÏI\WQRcKJ·EVL�FIQ^TH�^�ÏrEGSUÓ�QwsC÷lø¸\WH�^�Ó�EVS%×[QRE�Ór\WHKQÚVQ�L�×hg�EGfWfWFIJVfUFTH�E¯ÏIQ�c_gdÏI`WFTSUHKSWíJVSûEVSULCJGì�ÏT\WQ;^nõ2HKÏIÓr\zy¸Y·^nJ�ÏI\UE¯Ï]ÏT\WQ�Ó!H_FIÓ�`WHÄÏ]H_^ FTQf,Q�E¯ÏTQ�LNc_g�ÔüJVFrÓ!Q�LC×·g*ÏT\UQ�Q � ÏTQFTS,EGcNÔüJ�FIÓ�HKSWíÚVJ�cÄÏrEGí�Q�^TJV`WFrÓ!Q]xM÷ ø¸\WQ�^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WHKSUí¾E�Ó}ÏIHKJ�SöH�^B`U^T`UEGc_cKgöHKeBfWc_Q�eBQS�ÏIQLöÏT\UFTJ�`WíV\'E{-?`Wc�^nQ

|} ~ � ~ � ~ ��

�� �

� � ��� ���

�� �� ��

�)��)�� �����

��

� � ����� ��

����)�

���6�V�t�����!�4���6 ¢¡��}'£�¤B¥�¦ � § ���w¨"���}'©�ª[£)«�¥�¬ � § �6��­_�)�

®°¯>±!² ¦4³K´G©��P�pk?jJµ·¶rjJµ�±p³���´��nw}v!�!k�qtstk�q �8 H�LhÏT\4D�JhLW`Wc_EGÏTQ�L¸� -E8ØD_��ÔüQ�QLW×UEVÓrÙ c_Epõ�÷ ÑdEVeCQcKg°E�cKH_SWQ�EGF%Ó�JVe%×UHKSUEGÏTH_JVS¾JGÔRÏT\UQMÏ�õ]J^Tgh^nÏTQe ^nÏIEGÏTQ�^�Yº¹W»��C¼��%½¸¾!¿�À��3¼��?Á0¾WÂ@¹,�3¼��H�üH_SBÏT\WQ�fWFTQ�^nQS·Ï?õ]J�FTÙþ!¿�½ ÜWÄ�¾WÂH½�M!�}Y·H_^]Ó!JVeBfUEVFTQ�Lõ2HKÏT\öEîíVH_ÚVQS4EV^TgheCeBQ�ÏTFIH_Óû^IEpõ¸ÏTJhJVÏT\Å�²FIEVeCf7��^THKí�SUEGcRJGÔdE�^T^THKí�SWQLëf,QFTH_JNL�Æ EV^C^T\WJ¯õ2S½HKS/Uí,÷�ÛN÷ ø¸\WQ�Ó!H_FrÓ!`WHKÏC^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\PYEy¸Y�H_^%ÏT\UQ�S½ÏI`WFTSUQL¾JVS4õ2\WQ�SWQÚVQF�ÏT\WQ�FIEVeBfë^nH_íVSUEVc ×[QÓ�JVeBQ^

Page 5: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

U

�� � � Ç

� �È Ç¢É

ÊÊ �]ËÍÌ �

�È ¦ ��Î É Ì È ¦ �kÏ É Ì È ¦ �_Ð É Ì¦ Ì

Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ Ñ� � � � �)È ÇÒÉ

���ÇÒÓ Ç ÓJÔ�Õ Ç ÓJÔnÖ� � � �

�� ¦\×  ¢Øt�B���¢Ù>¡�Ú

®°¯>±!² ¦4³gÛ·©x��s�orvp®¯orq�®�jJµ·¶rjJµ���w}v��!k�qtstk�qiÜ ¹ �Ìw}mVk�q�oIs�|~vp{2��w}vp®�| s�|~w}vp��Ý[w}v�k |~u2mpor��sPmGk�qmGk�q�|~w�® �íVFIQEGÏTQF2ÏT\UEVS�ÏI\WQ*Ó�JVe%×UHKSUEGÏTH_JVS�JVÔ�ÏT\WQ*Ï�õ]J�^�ÏrE¯ÏTQ�^�EVSUL�ÏI`WFTSUQL�JVì°õ2\WQS�ÏT\UQ*FrEGeBf�^THKí�SUEGcÔ²EGc_c�^%×[Q�c_J¯õ ÏT\WH�^CÓ!JVe*×WH_SUE¯ÏIHKJ�SP÷"QdQ�SUÓ�QVY?Eî^Tõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWíîJNÓÓ!`WFr^�õ2\WQSWQ�Ú�Q�Ft¹W»��C¼��%Ó�FTJ·^T^TQ^�ÏT\WQFrEGeBfa�²Q�HKÏT\WQF�õ2HKÏT\WH_S�ÏT\WQ�FrEGeBf�f,QFTH_JNL�J�F2E¯ÏP¼E½ Þ�ÆPÄOÞk½ ܺÄIÛBÄ�ß�ß[ßà�}÷á Z�âºZäã7å� 1 �6��æ_(�Dº�@���ç=�*!�8 \WQ�ÏT\WQFMÏT\WQ ^nõ2HKÏIÓr\¬H_^ûJVS'JVFMJVì�YRÏT\UQ�×W`UÓrÙöÓ�JVShÚVQFnÏIQ�FMÓ�EVS¬EVcKõ¸EpgN^C×,QîLWQ^IÓ!FIHK×[QL'EV^ME^TQÓ!J�SUL�J�FILWQ�Fdc_H_SWQEVF�^TgN^�ÏIQ�e�Y�õ2\WJ·^nQC^�ÏrE¯ÏTQ�^�EGFIQ�ÏT\UQCÚ�JVcKÏIEVíVQù�E�Ó!FIJ�^I^2ÏT\UQBÓEGfUE�Ó!HKÏTJ�FY�EGS,LÏT\UQ�Ó!`WFIFTQS·ÏOÀ]EGc_JVSWí*ÏT\WQ�H_SULN`,Ó}ÏTJ�F÷?ø¸\UQ�Q�R·`UE¯ÏIHKJ�SU^]ÏIEVÙVQ;ÏT\WQ�ÔüJ�FTeè ¹è ¼ ½êé"¹\ë+sVv Á�À�ëWvìÄ �nÜ)�è Àè ¼ ½êé"¹\ë+ukÁîí M HÄÔï¹:ð¸¹�ñW�C¼��E½ òLÁ�ó��3¼ReBJNL0Æì� ��þìiJ�xtë+u HÄÔï¹:ô¸¹�ñW�C¼��E½ òLÁ�ó��3¼ReBJNL0Æì� ��þ;Ñõ�}÷

ÿ%R·`UE¯ÏIHKJ�Sk��Ü��H�^ J�SWcKgBJ�SWQ�f[J�^I^nH_×WH_cKHKÏ�gMEGeBJVSWí*E�Ó!c�EV^I^ JVÔ�×W`UÓrÙMÓ!J�S·Ú�Q�FTÏTQFI^YVeBJNLNQ�c_c_QLM×hgþ;Õ;ÿ ^¸JGÔlÏT\WQ�ÔüJ�FTeö÷ ½�ø:ù ¿ ÷ ÁûúT¿�ü9Ä HKÔi¾!¿ ÷ ¿JÁ�¾W ÷ ÂTôý¹�ñW�C¼��}Yù  ÷ ÁûúõÂ6ü9Ä HKÔi¾!¿ ÷ ¿JÁ�¾W ÷ ÂTðý¹�ñW�C¼��}Y ��ÛW�õ2\WQFTQ�H_S�J�`WF�Ó�E�^nQ ÷ ½þ� ÷ ¿ ÷ Â���ÿ"½î�C¹ÍÄ4ÀÒ��ÿëEGS,L�Ð

ù ¿ ½ ù Ûg½�� M é�Üë+uÜë�v é�Üë\�CsVvV��� Ä

úT¿ ½�� Ü+ë+uM � Ä úõÂH½�� MM��¾!¿ ½ ÜºÄ ¾WÂH½ M\Äüi�C¼��E½ xLÄ ¹�ñº�3¼��%½�ò�Á ó,�C¼]eBJNL Æõ���

Page 6: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

bê�Ï H�^?FIQ�c_Q�Ú¯EGS·Ï?ÏIJ�f,J�HKS·ÏRJV`NÏ?ÏI\UE¯ÏREGcKÏT\WJ�`WíV\BõRQ�õ2HKc_c,Ó�JVSU^TH�LNQ�F�ÏI\WQ�ÓEV^TQ2JGÔ�ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGí�Q!Ò¥Ó!JVS·ÏIFTJ�cKc_QLÓ!J�ShÚVQ�FTÏTQFI^t��¾!¿g½ ܺĢ¾WÂý M�H_Sý��ÛW�4�}Y�ÏI\WQBFTQ�^n`WcKÏI^;LNQ�^TÓ�FTH_×,Q�L�H_SîÏI\WQ^TQCfUEGf[Q�F�Ó�EVSî×[Q*Q�EV^THKc_gíVQSWQ�FrEGc_H�^nQ�LMÏTJMEVS·g�JGÏT\UQ�F�Ó!J�S·ÏTFIJVcP^nÏTFrE¯ÏTQíVgk�3¾!¿Ä¢¾WÂ��0�}÷WJVF�ÏI\WQûFIQ�eMEGH_SULNQF�JGÔRÏT\WH�^�fUEVf,QF�õRQBÏIEGÙ�QCÏT\WQûf,EGFrEGeBQ!ÏIQ�F�Ú¯EGc_`WQ^�eBJVÏTH_ÚpEGÏTQ�L ×hgîÏT\WQQ � f[Q�FIHKeBQS�ÏrEGc�c_HÄÏIQ�FrE¯ÏI`WFTQ � ���÷�ê¥S�f,EGFTÏTH�Ó!`Wc�EGF�Ðu ½ÌÛWMCe�QÃÄ vî½�UhÞ� ·�Ä sY½ÌÛ�Û��ìÄÆ ½ UºMºM� P^nQ�Ó+Ä ò]½ ÜVܺß~ÞWbVÛ��º�WM�ݺb��tÄ ó�½ Ü��ºMVÝ\ßàbVÛW�W�UÜ�M�gë¯^TQÓ�Ä � �º�EGS,L0x�{��ÜbBÄ�U!Mº���C÷á Z á Z��K�C#%*n= 1 =C(+*n��PJhJ�Ù·H_SWíûEGÏ2ÏT\WQCÓ!JVShÚ�Q�FTÏTQ�F¸Q)R�`,E¯ÏTH_JVS,^�Y,õ]Q�õ2H_cKc�^TEpg�ÏT\UEGÏ�ÏT\UQ%^ngN^nÏTQe:H�^�H_S�ÏT\WQBþìiöfW\UE�^nQõ2\WQSBÏT\WQ;Ó�EGf,EVÓ!HKÏTJ�F�ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGíVQ2H�^?c�EGFIíVQF�ÏT\UEVSBÏT\WQdFIEVeCfû^TH_íVSUEVctYº¹7�C¼��Oðû¹ ñ �3¼��}YNEVSULBHKSBÏI\WQ�þ;ÑfW\UE�^nQ�HKÔi¹,�3¼���ôý¹ ñ �3¼��}÷

b�eBJVSWí°ÏI\WQ�^nõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí·^�Y]õ]Q�õ2H_cKcdLWQ@/USWQ��T��å+*�ó 2 �4(+*,(¯ò?������IJ= 1 ó 2 =�*!�û�üJVF ù Ò�^Tõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí!�EV^�^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WH_SWí�ÏIEGÙhH_SWí�fWc_E�Ó!QBõ2HKÏT\WH_S½E�FrEGeBf°Ó!gNÓ!c_QVYxEVSUL����W��IJ= 1 ó 2 =�*?�ûEV^;J�SWQBJhÓÓ!`WFIFIHKSWí�E¯Ïe%`UcÄÏIHKfWc_Q^ÃÞ�ÆïJGÔ¸ÏT\UQûFIEVeBf½f,QFTH_JNL{Æ�÷�ê¥S½õ2\UE¯Ï�ÔüJ�cKc_J¯õ�^�õRQ�^T\UEGc_c c�EG×[Q�cR^nJ�cK`NÏIHKJ�SU^�JVÔV�nÜ)�×hg�f,EGH_FI^2JVÔ?HKS·ÏIQ�íVQFI^Ã�! aÄ�Þ°�}Y[õ2\WQFTQVÞ½H_SULNH�Ó�EGÏTQ^�ÏT\WQ%S·`Ue%×[Q�FdJVÔJÆ2Ò�^Tõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí�^dEGSUL" ÏT\WQSh`We%×[Q�FBJVÔ ù Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí·^�÷öþ;ÓÓ�E�^nH_JVSUEVcKc_gVY�×hgëEGS,EGc_JVíVg¾õ2HKÏT\öHKeBfUE�Ó}ÏMJ�^IÓ!H_cKc�E¯ÏIJVFr^�õRQ�^T\UEVcKcFIQ!ÔüQ�F¸ÏIJ ù Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí·^2EV^T=��H;\��ó 1 �REVSUL Æ2Ò�^Tõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí�^¸E�^H� 1 �4(Vð�(+�!ó�(�;7=²óH;n(+=�* 1 �}÷Õd`WFIH_SWí«^nÏIEVSULWEGFrL J�f,QFIEGÏTH_SWí«Ó�JVSULNHKÏTH_JVS,^�Y*ÏT\WQ'^Tgh^nÏTQeñQ�ÚVJ�cKÚ�Q^ EGc_JVSWíúE Æ2Ò�f,QFTH_JNLNH�Ó^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVS½Ór\UEVFIE�Ó}ÏTQFTH�^TQL ×·g°JVSUQ ù Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí�f[Q�F*f,QFTH_JNL�Y�Ht÷ QV÷�JVSWQ ù Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí�EVSUL¾JVSWQÆ2Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí�JNÓ�Ó!`UFTFIHKSUí�LN`WFIHKSUí�Q�EVÓr\ Ó�gNÓ!c_Q%JGÔ]ÏT\WQCFrEGeBf ^THKí�SUEGc�÷�ê¥S E�LWLNHKÏTH_JVSîÏTJ�ÏT\WH�^Y�ÏT\WQÔüJVc_c_J¯õ2HKSWíBJVÏT\WQF�^nHKÏT`UEGÏTH_JVSU^2EVFTQ;f[J�^I^nH_×Wc_Q:�²^TQ�QV�HKí,÷n�º�!Ð# eBJVFIQCÏT\UEVS¾JVSWQM^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WHKSUí�JNÓÓ!`WFr^�LN`WFIHKSUí�ÏI\WQMJVSUQCf[Q�FIH_JhL°JVÔ]ÏI\WQMeBJhLW`Wc_EGÏTH_SWí�FIEVeBf

^THKí�SUEGcE���*òB� 1 = ;,���O;�òB�à��=�*!�)���# ÏI\WQ½^ngN^nÏTQ�e�Q�ÚVJ�cKÚ�Q^�EGc_JVSWí'EöíVQ�SUQ�FIH_Ó"Þ�Æ2Ò�f,QFTH_JNLNH_ÓîJVFI×WHKÏY�Ór\UEGFrEVÓ!ÏTQ�FIH�^nQ�L ×hg$ ù Ò^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WH_SWí�^�f,QF�f,QFTH_JNL�÷ 8 Q¾õ2H_cKc�FIQ!ÔüQF�ÏIJ¬^T`UÓr\ÌE¬^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVS«E�^�E �&%z�' "Ä4Þ°�a(���ð@= 1 ��# ÏI\WQ�Ú�JVcKÏIEGí�QMeBH_^I^nQ�^�J�SWQ�J�F%eBJVFIQûø)(h^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WH_SWí�^0�Ò�Tô+= ;º;7=�*?��fW\WQ�SUJVeBQ�SWJ�SÍ�}Y ¹,�3Þ�Æõ�:ð¹ ñ �3Þ�Æõ�*�# ÏI\WQ½ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGíVQ¾í�FIEWF�Q^�ÏI\WQ½FTQ�ÔüQ�FIQ�SUÓ�Q¾FIEVeCf ^THKí�SUEGc�EGÏ�ÏTH_eCQ4HKSU^nÏIEVS·ÏI^�e%`UcÄÏIHKfWc_Q^�JGÔ�Æ�<���4�)&6=�*!�)�}Y?¹7�CÞ�Æõ�E½ ¹�ñº�3Þ�Æõ�!÷lê¥SMf,EGFTÏTH�Ó!`Wc�EGF�YGõRQ2õ2HKc_c,^IEpg �,+ 1 �6��*7���pE�í�FIEWF�H_SWí�JNÓ�Ó!`UFTFIHKSUíÔüFIJVe3J�`NÏI^TH�LNQ�ÏT\WQ�FrEGeBfPYNõ2\UHKc_QL=�* 1 �@��*,�+��ÏT\UEGÏ2ÏIEVÙ·H_SWíBfWc�EVÓ�Q�ÔüFTJ�eïÏT\WQ�H_SU^TH_LWQV÷# EVS%H_SB/USWHKÏTQ¸Sh`We%×[Q�F�JVÔ,H_eCf,EVÓ}Ïr^�JhÓÓ!`WFr^�õ2HÄÏI\WH_S%ÏI\WQR^IEGeBQRf,QFTH_JNL�JVÔUÏT\UQRFrEGeBfz�¢���>=CD+=�*?���*�SWJVÏTH�Ó!Q;ÏT\,E¯Ï�f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�ÓK���>=CD+=�*?��ÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIHKQ�^REVFTQ�EGc�^TJCf[J�^I^THK×Wc_Q-�Ñ�JGÏIH_Ó�Q�ÏI\UE¯Ï�YWEV^?FIQ�f[JVFTÏTQ�LMH_S � �WY[Ü�Û)��Y·ÏT\WQ;×W`UÓrÙMÓ!J�ShÚVQ�FTÏTQF]LNghSUEVeBH_Ó^]ÓEGSû×[Q;^nÏT`,LNHKQ�Lû×hg

`U^THKSUíûÏ�õRJ�LNHKì[QFTQS�Ï�Ï�ghf,Q�^dJVÔ LNH_^IÓ!FIQ!ÏIQ%eMEGf,^�÷dø¸\UQ%ÔüJ�FTeBQ�F�Y,ÓEGc_cKQ�L�E'� 1 �4(Vð�(+�!ó�(�;7=²ó��L��;�Y�H_^LNQ6/USWQL�E�^ ÏI\WQ�eMEGfWfUHKSWíBJVÔlÏI\WQ;Ï�õ]JM^Tgh^nÏTQe ^nÏIE¯ÏIQ^Y·�3¹,�3¼��@Ä�À��3¼��4�}YWÔüFIJVe JVSWQTÆ2Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí*ÏTJÏT\UQ�SWQ � ÏÐ �3¹/.·Ä�À0.B�213ä�3¹/.-4 ¿ Ä4À0./4 ¿ �ø¸\WQMc�E¯ÏTÏTQ�F�YPõ2\WH�Ór\°ÏIEVÙVQ^�ÏI\WQMSUEGeBQMJVÔõ=��H;\��ó 1 ����;[Y�H_^�HKSU^nÏTQ�EVL°LNQ@/,SWQL¾EV^;ÏI\WQMeMEGfWfUHKSWíÔüFIJVe ÏT\UQ;f,EGH_F¸Ó�JVSU^TH�^�ÏIHKSWíCJGÔ�EGS ù Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWíCHKS,^�ÏrEGS·ÏY6587*YWEGS,LûÏI\WQ�Ó!JVFIFIQ^Tf,J�SULNH_SWí*^TgN^�ÏIQ�eÓ!`UFTFIQ�S·ÏYBÀ07 ½�À��!587T�}YNÏIJBÏT\WQ�SUQ � ÏÐ�!5 7 Ä�À 7 �213ä�!5 7 4 ¿ Ä�À 7 4 ¿ �bd^?FTQf,J�FnÏIQL*HKS � ���YV×hg%`U^TH_SWí�ÏT\WQ2H_eBfUEVÓ!Ï?eMEGfBHÄÏ?H�^�f[J�^I^nH_×Wc_Q¸ÏTJ�í�HKÚ�Q¸Ó�JVSULWHÄÏIHKJ�SU^�ÔüJVFP=�*)#E*Í= 1 ���(�ó��+� � 1 ��� 1 ó 2 =�*!�*JGÔ]ÏT\WQCfW\UE�^nQB^TfUEVÓ�QV÷�ø¸\WH�^;JhÓÓ!`WFr^;õ2\WQ�SîÏT\WQBÚ�JVcKÏIEGí�Q%LNQFTH_Ú¯E¯ÏTH_ÚVQCH�^�Q)R·`UEGc

Page 7: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

t t

t

t

m(c)

v v

v

(a)

(d)

(b)

t t

multiple A-switchings

external grazing internal grazing

sliding

t0 1 0

m+1t

t

v

®°¯>±!² ¦4³:9h©ÍÜUw}�t��|~±p�~k,±Gkn�pon�|~w}³pq4Ý<;_o*=huR³p� st|~mp�~k?>x¶��²­x| s�����|~vp{}�T�@;_±/=6A:;_�CBt�*=Nw}qt±p| s<;K| sWq�k�mGknoIs��| st��k�� y�oIyKstk�q¸s�­�wC�x¶��t­x| st���p|~vp{}�D=¥�E;K��=¸orvûw}q�±p| s¸­x�p|~�����t´|~m��;�E;K®/=RmGw}����|~±��~k�{}q�orºn|~v�{Borvp®�t�~|~®p|~vp{ �

ÏTJûÏT\UEGÏ�JGÔ�ÏI\WQ%FrEGeBf�E¯Ï�ELÆ2Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí,YWH�÷ Q�÷ ö¹,�C¼���½ ö¹ ñ �3¼��!÷Ã� Î Q�Q � �NY � Y,b�xÔüJ�F�EûLWH_^IÓ!`U^I^THKJ�SEGS,L�EGc�^nJBÔüJ�FdEGSUEVcKg·ÏIH_ÓEGcxLNQFTH_Ú¯E¯ÏIHKJ�S�JGÔ�×,JVÏT\�eMEGf,^dEGS,L�ÏT\WQHKF�`U^nQ%HKS�c_JNÓ�E¯ÏIHKSUí�EGSUEVcKg·ÏIH_ÓEGc_cKgf[Q�FIHKJNLhÒ¥LNJV`U×WcKH_SWí�×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�SU^?EVSULCSWQÓ�Q^I^TEVFTg�Ó�JVSULNHKÏTH_JVS,^�JGÔ�Q � H�^�ÏIQ�SUÓ�Q¸ÔüJVF E;íVH_ÚVQSBf,QFTH_JNLNH_ÓJVFI×WHKÏ÷à�FxàHG�r7h·ä)rPé hJI å?K¸ã)f9hko�ç�è)q¬è�å,â,r7h�äpã)h�äMLONûçlâ�æih�äQP'RPé²âTS°æURPâTVXWëé²èYNø¸\WQ¬LNghSUEGeBH�Ó�^ JGÔ"�nÜ)��\,EpÚVQ4×[Q�QS�LNQ�^TÓ�FTH_×,Q�L H_S�^TJVeBQöLNQ�ÏIEVHKcCHKS�ÏT\WQ¬c_HÄÏIQ�FrE¯ÏT`UFTQ�Y%×[JGÏT\Sh`WeBQ�FIH_ÓEGc_cKg«EGSUL Q � f[Q�FIH_eCQS·ÏIEGc_c_g � �UYHUWYì�NY%ÜpÛhY � YõbNY�Ü � Y;ÛWÜGY;Û��÷ ê¥SúÏT\WH�^î^TQÓ!ÏTH_JVS õ]Q^T`WeBeBEVFTH�^TQ*ÏI\WH�^�õRJVFIÙ[YPÔüJhÓ�`U^I^nH_SWí�JVS°ÏT\UQûFTQ�^n`UcÄÏr^�×·gîÏT\WQ:/UFI^nÏ�EG`NÏI\WJVF*EGSUL¾Ó!JVÒ�õRJVFIÙVQFI^dHKS� � Ynb��÷J8°Q�õ2HKc_cPfWFIQ^TQ�S·Ï2HKS�ÏT\UQ�fWFTJNÓ�Q^I^2^nJ�eCQ�SWQõ«eBJ�FTQ�LNQ!ÏrEGH_cKQ�L�S·`UeCQFTH�Ó�EVc�FTQ�^n`UcÄÏr^�÷

ø¸\WQ�J¯ÚVQFIEVcKc�×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVS�LNH�EGíVFrEGe:JGÔ�JV`NÏIfW`NÏdÚ�JVcKÏIEVíVQT¹7�C¼���EVí�EGH_SU^nÏ2HKSWfU`NÏ�Ú�JVcKÏIEGí�QVx H_^^T\WJ¯õ2S½HKSýlH_í�^÷kU,YJbW÷îø¸\WQ�^nQ�õ]QFTQMJ�×NÏIEVHKSWQ�L½Sh`WeBQ�FIH_ÓEGc_cKg°×hg°^TH_e%`Wc�E¯ÏIHKSWí�ÏT\WQ�Ó!J�S·Ú�Q�FTÏTQFQ�Ú�JVc_`NÏTH_JVS�J¯Ú�Q�FõbWMWMºMBFIEVeCf Ó!gNÓ!c_Q^�ÔüJVF;QEVÓr\�Ú¯EVcK`WQ*JGÔ�ÏI\WQ%H_SWfW`NÏ�ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGí�QgxMY�^�ÏrEGFTÏTH_SWíMÔüFIJVeEî^TfWFIQE�L¾JGÔ�H_SWHÄÏIH_EVcRÓ�JVSULWHÄÏIHKJ�SU^�Y��C¹QZºÄ4À[Z�\ � ÜVÜºß UÍÄ�ÜpÛBß �+�^] � M\ß UnÄ�M\ß �+��÷�b2Ô�ÏIQ�FME�ÏTFrEGS,^nH_Q�S·Ï*JVÔ�WMºMWM*FIEVeBf�Ó�gNÓ!c_Q^YNÏT\WQ%ÚpEVcK`UQ�JGÔ�ÏT\WQ�Ú�JVcKÏIEVíVQ�E¯Ï�Q�EVÓr\]Æ2Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWíBEGSUL ù Ò�^Tõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWíBõ]QFTQ^nÏTJVFIQL�EGSULMJ�SWc_gCc�EV^nÏ�Ü)MWM�^nÏTFIJV×[J�^IÓ!J�fWH�Ó�EGSUL ù Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí*f,J�HKS·ÏI^RfWc_JGÏTÏTQ�LûH_SL/UíU÷ UCEGSUL:/UíU÷b*FTQ�^nf[QÓ!ÏTH_ÚVQcKg�÷WJVF�^T`6_ûÓ!H_Q�S·ÏIcKg�^neMEGc_c°xMYWÏT\WQ�J�SWcKg�FTQ�Ó!`WFIFIQ�S·ÏR×[Q�\,EpÚ·H_JV`UF2JV×U^TQ�FIÚVQ�LûH�^�EB^�ÏrEG×Wc_Qa`L��ܺÄ�Ü)�JVFI×WHKÏ÷ bd^�ÏT\UQ°H_SWfW`WÏ�Ú�JVcKÏIEVíVQ°H_^�H_SUÓ!FIQE�^nQ�L ÏT\UFTJ�`WíV\ x ½ Û�UnßàbNÜ � ÏT\WH�^�f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó°JVFI×WHÄÏ`WSULWQ�FIíVJhQ^ E f,QFTH_JNLhÒ¥LNJV`W×UcKH_SWíÌÓEV^IÓ�EVLWQ½õ2\WH_Ór\ EVÓ�Ó�`We%`Uc_EGÏTQ^îHKS·ÏIJþ�²^TeMEGc_cC^IÓ�EVcKQ��Ór\UEGJ·^�÷Q�J¯õRQ�Ú�Q�F�YpÏT\WQ2`,^n`UEVcU^TQ�R·`WQ�S,Ó!QRÔüJVF�`WSUHÄÒ�eBJhLUEGcWeMEGf,^�H_^?^T`ULWLWQ�SWc_g%H_S·ÏTQ�FIFI`WfNÏTQ�LC×·g*EGSMEG×WFI`WfNÏ

Page 8: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Þ

11.4

11.6

11.8

12

12.2

12.4

12.6

12.8

23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33®°¯>±!² ¦4³\bW©���³p��´%��w}v��!k�qtstk�qR±p| yK³pqt�ToIst|~w}v%®p|µor{}q�oru«wry�c*or{!or|~v��ts)d¬|~v*st�pk2�²s�qtw}±Vw}�t��w}mp|~�ÜWw}|~vp�norq@ek���k��¥st|~w}va;_oIyÄs�k�qEf g,hi=W���pwn­l|~v�{]��w}u2mGk¥s�|~vp{ oIs²s�q�or�¥s�w}qt�T�¯o�mGk�q�|~w�®2®pw}³p±p�~|~v�{]qtw}³�s�kxs�w���¯orw}��orvp®ds���k���³p®p®�knv;knv��µorq�{}k�u2k�v�slorq�w}³�vp®dkj"l}�Cm lon

11.7

11.8

11.9

12

12.1

12.2

12.3

15 20 25 30 35 40®°¯>±!² ¦4³qph©l��³p��´���w}v!�!knq²s�k�q�±�| y_³pqt�noIs�|~w}v�®p|µor{}q�oru¬yKw}qrcd��oru2mp�~k�®;oIsE>x¶��²­x| s�����|~vp{¸mGw}|~v�st�;_oIyÄs�k�qaf s,hi=RwT�!k�qdo%�~w}v�{}knqtd�¶�q�orvp{}k�st�¯oIs�s���k�mpq�k¥�|~w}³p�¸Í¯{}³pqtk �vu wrstk;s��poIsdst�pk�mGk�q�|~w�®�¶®�w}³p±p�~|~vp{}��orm�mVknorq�w³¯or®�q�oIst|~�C|~v�st�p|~�;m�q�wr¿²k���st|~w}v�orvp®�v�wrs�k%s��pk�ͯvpk%�tstq�³���st³pqtk%wry st�pk�µorqt{}k¥¶����nor�~k����¯orwrst|~�?q�k�{}|~w}v�yKw}q�dyxzl}�Cm lon

Page 9: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

�Q�SUc_EVFTí�Q�eBQ�S·Ï�JGÔ[ÏT\WQ2FIQ^T`WcKÏTH_SWíK���L�+���Í��ó��+����Ór\,EGJGÏIH_Ó¸EGÏnÏTFrEVÓ!ÏTJ�FlÔüJ�FEx|{ �·ÛBß ��U·ÛY�*÷�bRÏ?Ú¯EVFTH_JV`U^õ2H_SULNJ¯õ�^PJVÔ\x�Ò�Ú¯EVcK`WQ�^Pc_Q^I^�ÏI\UEGS�ÏI\WQPý�`UeCfxYG^nQÚVQ�FrEGc��UY � EGSULûÜ�ÛpÒ�f[Q�FIHKJNL;f,QFTH_JNLNH�Ó?EGSUL�Ór\,EGJGÏIH_ÓE¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ!ÏTJVFr^�õ2HKÏT\�^TeBEVcKcV×UEV^THKS,^�JGÔWE¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ}ÏIHKJ�SU^�EGFIQ�JV×U^TQ�FIÚVQ�L�ÏIJdÓ!JhQ � H�^nÏPõ2HÄÏI\�ÏT\WQ�Ôü`WS,LWEGeBQ�S·ÏrEGcLNghSUEVeCH�Ó�^K��ÏI\WQ�g EGfWf[QEVFdc_HKÙ�Q*f[JVH_S·ÏI^;HKS·ÏIFTJNLN`UÓ�QL�×hg�E�×UEVLîfW\WJGÏIJNÓ!JVfUHKQFdH_S"�HKí,÷VU�}à���x^TQ�Q� � ��ÔüJVF2eBJ�FTQ�LNQ�ÏIEGH_c�^�÷

0.4

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

0.7

0.75

0.8

11.6 11.8 12 12.2 12.4 12.6 12.8

i

v

0.35

0.4

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

0.7

0.75

0.8

11.7 11.8 11.9 12 12.1 12.2 12.3

i

v®°¯>±!² ¦4³�~N©��Norqt{}kd�t�nor�~k2���¯orwrst|~�;oIs²s�q�or�¥s�w}qRyKw}q)d$j�l�s*�PÝt;�o*= oIs)�P¶��²­x| s�����|~vp{�mGw}|~v�st���;K±/=�oIs�>P¶��t­x| st���p|~vp{dmGw}|~v�st�T�Vst�pk¸®¯or�t�pk�®*�~|~vpk q�k�mpqtk���k�v�st��s���kR���~|~®�|~vp{��~|~vpkR��w}q�qtk���mGw}vp®p|~vp{stwRstq�oI¿²k��¥s�w}qt|~kn�x±Gk�|~vp{¸s�orv�{}knv!sxs�w¸st�pk�q�oru2m�c � ;i�'= �WJVFEx ð¸��ÛBß ��UhÛg�[�+� �!����ó��+�[�?Ór\UEVJ�^�H_^�ÏI\WQ�SBJ�×U^nQFTÚ�QL*EGSUL%ÏT\WQ�Ó�JVShÚVQFnÏIQ�F�^�ÏrEGFTÏI^�QÚVJVc_ÚhHKSUíEGc_JVSUí'ÏT\WQ¬Ór\UEGJVÏTH�Ó½E¯ÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏIJVFîLNQfWH�Ó}ÏTQ�L H_S lH_íU÷ � ÷ Ñ�JGÏIH_Ó�QëÏI\WQ4Ó!`UFTH_JV`U^ ^�ÏIFT`,Ó}ÏT`UFTQëJVÔÏT\UH_^B×WFIJ�E�Lë×UEVSUL¬E¯ÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏIJVF�÷ 8 \WQ�S'ÚhH_Q�õRQL4EGÏû^�ÏIFTJ�×,J·^TÓ�JVfWH�Óûf[JVH_S·ÏI^Y?ÏT\UQ�E¯ÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏIJVFC\UEV^EL/,ÚVQgFJVSWQ%ÏTJVf[JVc_JVí�g"�t^nQQ�ÏT\UQÃ/UÚ�Q%LWEVFTÙ F�J�SWQ^dHKSalH_íU÷ � �²E!�}Y�EGS,L � ÜpÛ)��ÔüJVFdeBJ�FTQ%LWQ!ÏIEVHKc�^��}÷D�J�FTQJ¯ÚVQ�F�Y�õ2\WQS°ÚhH_Q�õRQL¾E¯Ï ù Ò�^Tõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí�f,J�HKS·Ïr^:��/Uí,÷ � �ü×Í�4�;õ]QMSWJVÏTQBÏI\UE¯Ï�ÏI\WQûE¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ!ÏTJVF\UE�^�E�/USWí�Q�FIQL�^nÏTFI`UÓ}ÏI`WFTQ�EVSUL�H�^dÓr\UEVFIE�Ó}ÏTQFTH�^TQLû×hg�Ó!J�SU^nH�^nÏTQ�S·Ïd^nÏTFIQ!ÏrÓr\WHKSUíMHKS�ÏI\WQt-�J�HKSUÓEGFX�QfWc�EGH_SP÷J-?c_JGÏTÏTH_SWí�íVFrEGfU\U^�JGÔx^TJVc_`NÏIHKJ�SU^�YW/UíU÷WÞhY·FIQ�ÚVQ�EGc�^�ÏT\,E¯Ï ÏI\WH�^J/USWí�Q�FIHKSUí�H_^REV^I^TJhÓ�H_EGÏTQ�L*õ2HKÏT\e%`UcÄÏIHKfWc_Q ù Ò�^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WH_SWí�^�JNÓ�Ó�`WFIHKSWí�H_SMJVSWQ2JVÔ,ÏI\WQO/UÚ�Q2f,QFTH_JNLW^�J¯õ2H_SWí;ÏTJ�ÏT\UQ2ÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏTJ�FTg�×[Q�H_SWíÓ!c_J�^TQ;ÏTJM^TcKH�LNH_SWík�²^TQ�QK^ � ×[Q�c_J¯õØÔüJ�F�eBJVFIQ;LNQ�ÏIEVHKc�^��!÷

ê�ÏCH�^Cõ]J�FnÏI\·õ2\UHKc_Q�ÏIJ SUJGÏTQ�ÏT\,E¯ÏY]EV^TH_LNQ�ÔüFIJVe6ÏT\UQ�^TeMEGc_cÄÒ�×UEV^TH_SNÒ�JVÔ�Ò�EGÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏTH_JVS �UY � YdÜ�ÛpÒf[Q�FIHKJNLNH�ÓBõ2HKS,LNJ¯õ�^�YxÏT\WQMJ�×U^TQ�FIÚVQL°LNghSUEVeCH�Ó�^L�²HKS,Ó!c_`ULNH_SWí�f[Q�FIHKJNLhÒ¥LNJV`U×WcKH_SWí�EGS,L°Ór\,EGJ�^��dÔüJVFx ô��·ÛBß ��UhÛîH�^�EVcKc;JGÔ�Ï�ghf[Qý��ܺÄ8�à�}Y2ÏI\UE¯Ï�H_^�JVSWQ ù Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWíëf[Q�F�f[Q�FIHKJNL�÷�ø¸\UQî^n`,LWLNQ�SQ�SUc_EVFTí�Q�eBQ�S·Ï;ÓEGS°×,Q�^�Ï�×[QBÓr\,EGFrEVÓ}ÏIQ�FIH_^TQL�×·g�ÏI\WQBf,J�HKS·Ï�E¯Ï�õ2\WH�Ór\îÏI\WQMEpÚVQFIEVíVQ�Sh`We%×[Q�F�JVÔù Ò¥^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WHKSUí�^ûf[Q�F�f,QFTH_JNL'JVS'ÏI\WQîJ�×U^nQFTÚ�QL¬E¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ}ÏIJVFL/,FI^nÏ�íVJhQ�^ûEG×[J¯ÚVQ½Üû�t^nQQ_�HKí,÷��!�}÷Ñ�JVÏTQ�ÏT\UEGÏ*ÏI\WH�^LR�`,EGS·ÏTHKÏ�g¾FTQ�EVÓr\WQ�^*Eîf,Q�EGÙëE¯ÏMEGFIJV`USUL x ½ ��UÍß �WUU÷½ø¸\WH�^BÓ!JVH_SUÓ�H_LNQ�^%õ2HKÏT\ÏT\UQ*fUEVFIEVeBQ!ÏTQFdÚ¯EGc_`WQBE¯Ï;õ2\WH_Ór\ õ]QCÓ�EVS Ó!J�eBfW`NÏTQBE0b¯Ò�f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó%JVFI×WHÄÏ;õ2\WH�Ór\ý�²EVfWf[QEGFr^��¸ÏTJ^TcKH�LNQVYVÏT\UEGÏ H�^?×[QÓ!J�eBQ¸ÏIEGSUíVQ�S·Ï�ÏIJ�ÏT\WQdFIEVeCf'�3/UíU÷·Þ\�²Ln�4�}÷�ê¥SME�ÔüJ�FTeMEGcW^TQ�S,^nQ�YGÏT\UH_^?ÏTFrE¯ý�QÓ!ÏTJ�FTgeMEpgî×[Qûc�EG×[Q�c_cKQ�L�`L�[� Ä�bW�!Y�EVSUL¾Sh`WeBQ�FIH_ÓEGc_cKgîõ]Q�ÓEGSa/USUL¾SUQEGFI×hg�`L�' "Ä�bW�;JVFI×WHKÏI^�ÔüJ�Fq EGfUfUEGFIQ�S·ÏTc_g�EGFI×WHÄÏIFIEVFTH_c_g�c�EGFIíVQV÷ì�HKí,÷�ÞûLNQ�fWH�Ó}Ïr^�Ï�õRJ�^T`UÓr\�f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó*^nJ�cK`NÏIHKJ�SU^÷�Ñ�`UeCQFTH�Ó�EVcKc_gÏTFrEVÓ�HKSUíB^T`UÓr\�^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSU^2E�^�EBfUEVFIEVeCQ�ÏTQFRÚ¯EVFTH_Q^¸\UE�^2fWFIJ¯ÚVQ�L�EBÓ!`Ue%×[Q�Fr^nJ�eCQ�ÏrEV^TÙ�÷ ORQÓ�EV`U^TQJGÔRÏT\UQûSWJVSWÒ�^TeBJ·JVÏT\WSUQ^I^�JGÔV��Ü)�!Y�^nÏIEVSULWEVFIL¾Ó!J�S·ÏTH_S·`,E¯ÏTH_JVS¾Ó!JNLNQ�^�^T`UÓr\½EV^�b�N�ødþïõRQ�FIQBSWJGÏÔüJV`USUL�ÏIJ;Ó�JVf[QV÷�ê¥SU^�ÏIQE�L�õRQ]\UEpÚ�Q]Ó�JVe%×UHKSWQ�L�E;^nH_eBfWcKQRSh`WeBQ�FIH_ÓEGcN^T\WJhJGÏTH_SWí;EGc_íVJVFIHKÏT\We ×UE�^nQ�LJVSëE�ÚpEVFTH�EG×UcKQ�^nÏTQfNÒ¥^nH[F�Q�YlÚ¯EGFIH�EG×Wc_QûJVFrLNQF%bdLWEVeM^�eBQ!ÏI\WJNL �²Ñ�b�� FTJ�`NÏTH_SWQz�6�M���C�X�B��EGc_c_HKQ�Lõ2HKÏT\'ÏT\UQ�ÏT\UQ�FTJ�×W`U^nÏûSWJVSUcKH_SWQEVF�^TJVc_ÚVQ�F Î Ñ Î�� ÿ � Ü)b��÷î�HKí,÷]ݽ^T\WJ¯õ�^û^TJVeBQ�fWFIQ�c_H_eCH_SUEVFTgÓ�EVc_Ó�`Wc�E¯ÏTH_JVS,^C^T`Wí�íVQ^nÏTH_SWíîÏT\UEGÏCÏI\WQ^TQ /UÚVQ�Ò�f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó�JVFI×WHKÏI^CcKH_Q�HKS'EGS¬EGfWfUFTJ � H_eBEGÏTQ�LNJV`U×WcKQ

Page 10: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Ý^TfWHKFrEGc�E�Ó�Ó!`Ue%`Wc�E¯ÏIHKSWí�JVSîÏT\WQû^TfWH_FIEVcKc_H_SWíûÏIFIEGý�QÓ}ÏIJVFIgV÷%ÑdJGÏIQ*ÏI\WQMÓ!J�FTSWQFI^;H_SîÏI\WQB×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�SLNH�EGí�FIEVe�Yhõ2\WH�Ór\�EGFIQ;ÓEG`U^TQL�×hg�í�FIEWF�H_SWí%×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVSU^÷

bØ^nH_eBHKc�EGF]^�ÏIFT`UÓ!ÏT`WFIQ�JVÔ�f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó2J�FT×UHÄÏr^?EGfWf[QEVFI^?HKSûE�LWQ!ÏIEVHKc_QLBSh`WeBQFTH�Ó�EVcWHKShÚ�Q^nÏTH_í�E¯ÏIHKJ�S� � �UJVÔ[ÏI\WQ¸ÏT\UFTQQ!ÒGF�JVSUQ�Ór\UEGJVÏTH�ÓREGÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏTJ�F?Ó!JVÒ�Q � H�^nÏTH_SWí�õ2HÄÏI\BÏT\WQ�eMEVHKSB×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�SM×WFrEGSUÓr\*ÔüJVFx� �tÛ+UÍÄIÛ�UnßàbW�}Y�^TQ�QL�HKí,÷�UU÷Bø¸\WQBQ � H_^nÏTQSUÓ!QBJVÔ¸E�õ2\WJVc_QCÔ²EGeBH_cKg�JVÔ]ÏI\WFIQ�Q!Ò�f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó%J�FT×UHÄÏr^�YÓ!JhQ � H�^nÏTH_SWí�õ2HKÏT\°ÏI\WQMÓr\UEGJVÏTH�Ó%FIQ�í�HKeBQVY�õ¸EV^;J�`NÏTc_HKSUQL�÷Bø¸\WQ^TQM^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVSU^;õRQ�FIQC^T\WJ¯õ2S�ÏIJ�×,QJVFIí�EVSWH�^nQ�L�EGc_JVSWí�E�^TfWHKFrEGc�×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�S LNH�EGí�FIEVe�Y,FIQ�fWFIJNLN`UÓ�QL�\WQFTQBEV^ì�HKí·^�÷�ÝUY�Ü�MW÷�ê¥S � � ��YÏT\UJV`Wí�\PYhÏT\WH�^�^nÏTFI`UÓ}ÏI`WFIQ;H�^2c_Q!Ô�Ï�`WSUQ � fWc�EGH_SWQL�÷

11.6

11.8

12

12.2

12.4

12.6

12.8

0 0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002 0.0025 0.003 0.003511.6

11.8

12

12.2

12.4

12.6

12.8

0 0.0002 0.0004 0.0006 0.0008 0.001 0.0012 0.0014 0.0016 0.0018 0.002

11.6

11.8

12

12.2

12.4

12.6

12.8

0 0.0002 0.0004 0.0006 0.0008 0.001 0.0012 0.0014 0.0016 0.0018 0.00211.6

11.8

12

12.2

12.4

12.6

12.8

0 0.0002 0.0004 0.0006 0.0008 0.001 0.0012 0.0014 0.0016 0.0018 0.002®°¯>±!² ¦4³��·©M�Nq�oI¿²kn�¥stw}q�|~k��Rm��~wrststk�®�or�]{}q�ormp���RwryUc/;i�'=]yKw}q:d�j�lon�m l�l����}��;_o*= �ö���¯orwrst|~��tw}�~³�st|~w}v·�J;K±/=�A:;�sCB[s*=�orvp®q;_��=�A:;t���CB[s*=[mGk�q�|~w�®p|~����w}�~³s�|~w}vp�^;K®/=���;_vpknorqD=��t�~|~®p|~vp{ mGknqt|~w®�|~�stq�oT¿tk��¥s�w}q²�ê¥Sîõ2\UEGÏ;ÔüJ�cKc_J¯õ�^�õ]QCõ2HKc_c�ÏTFIg�ÏTJ�Q � fWc�EGH_S EVSUEGc_g·ÏTH�Ó�EVcKc_g�ÏT\WQM^nÏTFI`UÓ}ÏI`WFIQ%JGÔ]ÏT\WQM^TfWH_FIEVcKc_HKSUí×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�S�LNH�EGí�FIEVe�÷8ø¸\UQöÙ�Q�g ^n\UEVcKcC×[QöEØc_JNÓ�EVc*EGS,EGc_gh^TH�^�JGÔMÏI\WQö^Tc_H_LNH_SWíÌÏTFrE¯ý�QÓ!ÏTJ�FTg

EGfUfUEGFIQ�S·ÏTc_g;JV×U^TQ�FIÚVQ�L;ÔüJVF xî½Å��UÍß �º�VÝ�ÝW�W÷�QdJ¯õ]QÚVQ�F�YÏT\WQ¸EGSUEVcKgN^TH_^lH_SL^�bd^n\WJ¯õ�^xÏT\,E¯Ï�f,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó^TcKH�LNH_SWí�ÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIHKQ�^�EGFIQûJGÔ�Ó�JGÒ¥LNHKeBQSU^nH_JVSWÒtÏ�õRJ�ÔüJVFC^ngN^nÏTQ�eM^%JGÔ¸ÏT\WQ�ÔüJVFIeê��ÛW�%EGSUL¾Ôü`UFnÏI\WQ�FeBJVFIQûLNQ!ÏrEGH_cKQ�L°S·`UeCQFTH�Ó�^%^n\WJ¯õ�^;ÏI\UE¯Ï�ÏI\WQMÏIFIEGý�QÓ}ÏIJVFIg�H_S"/,íU÷�Þ�H�^�SWJVÏÃR·`WHÄÏIQz`L�[� Ä�bº�;×W`NÏH�^�`L�' "Ä�bW�RÔüJ�Ft c_EVFTí�QV÷�ø¸\WH�^�^nÏTFIJVSUíVc_g�^T`WíVí�Q^nÏI^¸ÏI\UE¯Ï���Ü)��H_^;^T`6_ûÓ!H_Q�S·ÏTc_g�Ó!c_J�^TQ�ÏTJMÏI\WQ*Ó�JGÒLNH_eBQ�SU^THKJ�SNÒ�Ï�õ]J�f[JVH_S·Ï ÏTJ*Q�SUEV×Wc_Q�Q � fWc�EGSUEGÏTH_JVSMJVÔPHÄÏr^]LNghSUEVeBH_Ó^?H_SMÏTQFTeM^]JGÔPE�c_JNÓ�EGc[EGSUEVcKgN^TH_^E�^Tc_H_LNH_SWíûf[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó%JVFI×WHÄÏ�÷dê�Ï;H_^;^n`,Ór\îEGS�EVSUEGc_gN^nH�^2ÏI\UE¯Ï�ÔüJVFIeB^dÏT\UQ%eMEGH_SîÓ!J�S·ÏTQ�S·Ï;JGÔO^�bW÷g^ �ÏT\UQ�SMÏI`WFTS,^�ÏTJ%E�fUEGFTÏTH�EGcWQ � fWc_EVSUE¯ÏIHKJ�SPYV`,^nH_SWí�ÏI\WQd^IEGeBQ¸ÏT\WQJVFIgVY�JGÔ�ÏT\WQH/USWí�Q�FIQLB^�ÏIFT`,Ó}ÏT`UFTQ�JVÔÏT\UQg/UÚ�Q!ÒGF�JVSUQ%^�ÏIFIEVSWíVQ�EGÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏTJ�F÷P�H_FI^nÏY,ÏT\UJV`Wí�\PY,õRQ�ÏI`WFIS�JV`WF;E¯ÏTÏTQ�S·ÏIHKJ�S�ÏTJ�EVS�`WSNÔüJ�c_LNH_SWíJGÔ�íVFrE�FHKSUí%×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�SU^÷

Page 11: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

�M

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

2.2

2.4

15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39®°¯>±!² ¦4³¡ h©��l�!k�q�or{}k v�³pu]±Vk�qPwry�>x¶��t­x| s����p|~vp{}�t¶�mVk�q²¶�mGknqt|~w®�w}vds��pk oIs²s�q�or�¥s�w}qn�Vor{!or|~vp�tsUd¢lण åxè-VXP¥VWâTVXP!R�N�é'NBå¦K�S,ä�V�§Vé²âTS�HKí,÷¸Ü�M�^T\WJ¯õ�^�ÏT\WQ�×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�SBLWH_EVíVFrEGe�JVÔ,ÏI\WQ©¨�����Ä��º�!Y·E�^?FIQ�f[JVFTÏTQLCH_S � � ��÷�ê�Ï]H�^?Ó�cKQ�EGF�ÏI\UE¯ÏEBíVFrE�FHKSUíMõ2HÄÏI\�ÏT\WQ�ÏIJVf�JVÔ�ÏI\WQ�FrEGeBf�HKS�ÏT\WQ�ÏI\WH_FIL�f[Q�FIHKJNL�H�^¸ÏIEVÙhHKSWí�fWc_E�Ó!Q�EGÏdQE�Ór\�Ó�JVFISWQ�F�ü×Uc_E�ÓrÙB^Tf[JGÏI^]H_S:/Uí,÷]Ü)MWY_ÜVÜV÷�ø¸\WQ�JGÏT\UQ�FRf,J·^T^THK×UHKc_HÄÏ�g�YNE�íVFrE�FHKSUí�E¯Ï ÏI\WQ;×,JVÏnÏTJ�e3Ó!J�FTSWQF JVÔ�ÏT\WQFrEGeBf�H_^lSWJVÏ�J�×U^nQFTÚ�QL�÷ Î JdõRQ FIQ^nÏTFIH_Ó!ÏxJV`WF�E¯ÏTÏTQ�S·ÏIHKJ�S�\WQ�FIQ?ÏIJd×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVSU^xõ2\WQ�FIQ]Edf,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVS½í·EGH_SU^�EGS¾Q � ÏIFIEî^nõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí �²HKeBfUE�Ó}Ï���HKS½HKÏI^%c_E�^�Ï*f,QFTH_JNL�Y�LN`WQMÏIJîE�íVFrE�FHKSUí�õ2HKÏT\ÏT\UQ�ÏTJ�fP÷�8°Q%^nQQ�Ù�ÏTJ�LWQ�eBJVSU^nÏTFrE¯ÏIQ�ÏT\,E¯Ï�ÏI\WH_^�SWQ�Ó!Q^I^IEGFIHKc_g�Ó�EV`U^TQ^�HKÏI^d×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�S�LNH_EVíVFrEGeÏTJ�Q � \UHK×WHKÏ�E�^T\UEVFTfîÏT`WFISWH_SWí�f[JVH_S·Ï�JVFûó�(+��*7�6�}÷*b ^THKeBH_c_EVF�fW\WQ�SUJVeBQ�SWJ�S Ór\UEVFIE�Ó}ÏIQ�FIH_^TQ^�ÏT\WQ^TfWHKFrEGc�JVÔ b¯Ò�f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó;JVFI×WHKÏI^2LNQfWH_Ó!ÏTQ�L�H_S /UíU÷�ÝU÷

ê¥S�õ2\UE¯Ï�ÔüJ�cKc_J¯õ�^2õRQ�õ2H_cKc�Ó!JVS,^nH�LNQ�F�ÏT\WQ%ÓEV^TQ�JGÔ�Ï�õRJ�/UÚVQ�f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó�J�FT×UHÄÏr^dÓr\UEVFIE�Ó}ÏTQFTH�^TQL×hg EGSØQ � ÏIQ�FISUEGc�EGS,L HKS·ÏIQ�FISUEGc;íVFrE�FHKSWí4FTQ�^nf[QÓ!ÏTH_ÚVQ�c_gV÷ ø¸\WQ^TQîJ�FT×UHÄÏr^�EVFTQ cKJNÓ�EGÏTQ�LØE¯Ï�ÏT\WQÓ!J�FTSUQ�Fr^�JGÔ�ÏI\WQB^nfWH_FrEGcl^T\WJ¯õ2S�H_S'/Uí,÷;ÝU÷;Ñ�EGeBQ�c_gVY[ÏI\WQ%f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó*JVFI×WHÄÏ�Ór\UEGFrEVÓ!ÏTQFTH�^nQ�L�×·g�EVSQ � ÏIQ�FISUEGc�íVFrE�FHKSUí�f[JVH_S�Ï�H�^;ÏT\WQMJ�SWQCcKJNÓ�EGÏTQ�L EGÏVxp½ ��ÛBßµÞ+��ÝVݺ�ºbBÄ4À Z ½ Mnß bVÝVݺbºbNÜ�õ2\UHKc_QCÏT\WQJVSUQ�Ó�JVS·ÏIEVHKSUHKSWíCEGS�HKS·ÏIQ�FISUEGc�íVFrE�FHKSUí*H�^RcKJNÓ�EGÏTQ�L�EGÏ�x ½ b��nß bWMWMWMºMWܺÄ�À Z ½ Mnß~Þ��W�UÜ�MVÝU÷xÑ�JVÏTH�Ó!QÏT\,E¯Ï�H_S�×[JGÏI\�Ó�EV^TQì¹ Z H_^�/ � Q�L�E¯Ï¸ÏT\WQ�ÏIJVf�JGÔlÏT\WQ�FrEGeBfPYN\UQ�SUÓ�QV¹ Z ½ ÜpÛBß~Û�Þ � ÜݺMW÷

O]g�f[Q�FTÏT`WFI×WH_SWíBÏT\WQC^ngN^nÏTQe:H_S�EMSWQHKí�\·×[JV`UFT\WJhJNL�JGÔ�ÏT\UQ^TQ�íVFrE�FHKSWíCÏIFIEGý�QÓ}ÏIJVFIHKQ�^¸HÄÏ�Ó�EVS×[QëJV×U^TQ�FIÚVQ�LØÏI\UE¯ÏîÏT\WQëc_JNÓ�EVc�ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGíVQ¾eMEGf FIQ�eMEVHKSU^�cKJNÓ�EVcKc_gØc_HKSUQEGF�Y�õ2\WH_cKQëÏT\WQ4Ó�`WFIFTQS�ÏJVSUQ�H�^BÓr\UEGFrEVÓ!ÏTQ�FIH�^nQ�L½×hgëE ^T\UEGFIföÓ�JVFISWQ�F�÷ëø¸\WH�^CH_^CÏI\WQ�ÓEV^TQ�ÔüJ�FB×,JVÏT\öÏT\WQ{=�* 1 �6��*7�+��EGS,L�,+ 1 �6��*7�+�UíVFrE�F�H_SWíûfU\WQ�SWJ�eBQ�SUEUY�E�^�^T\WJ¯õ2S�H_S'/Uí·^�÷CÜ�Û�EGSULëÜ��ûFIQ^Tf[QÓ}ÏIHKÚ�Q�c_gV÷TQ�QFTQ�Y�E�^neMEVcKcf[Q�FTÏT`WFI×UE¯ÏIHKJ�SkªCH_^�EGfWfWc_H_QL�ÏIJMÏT\WQC^ngN^nÏTQe:H_SWHKÏTH�EGclÓ�JVSULWHÄÏIHKJ�SîEGSUL�ÏI\WQ�Ú�JVcKÏIEGí�Q�EGSUL�Ó�`WFIFTQS�ÏH_S�ECSWQHKí�\h×,J�`WFT\UJ·JNL�JGÔlÏT\WQ�í�FIEWF�H_SWí*Ú¯EVcK`WQ�^2EGFIQ�fWcKJVÏnÏIQL�÷

ê¥S�^TQ�Q�ÙhH_SWí*ÏTJBEGSUEVcKgN^TQ�^T`UÓr\�eMEGf,^�YNõRQ;^T\UEVcKc�Ó!J�SU^TH_LNQF Ï�õRJB^nH_eBfWcKH�/UQ�L�eMEGfUfWHKSUí�^Rõ2\WH�Ór\Ó�EVfNÏT`UFTQ2ÏI\WQTR�`,EGc_HÄÏrE¯ÏTH_ÚVQ�ÔüQE¯ÏI`WFIQ^?J�×U^TQ�FIÚVQLCH_Sz�HKí·^�÷¸ÜpÛ�EGSUL�Ü��W÷�ø¸\WQ�FTQ�^n`WcKÏI^ JV×NÏrEGH_SWQLMEVFTQQ�R·`UEVcKc_gûÚ¯EGc_H�L�ÔüJ�F2×,JVÏT\�ÏT\UQ�HKS·ÏTQFTS,EGcPEGS,L�Q � ÏIQ�FISUEGc�í�FIEWF�H_SWíUY·ÏI\WQ�Ï�õ]JMÓEV^TQ^¸^nH_eBfWc_g�c_QEVLWHKSWí

Page 12: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

ÜVÜ

12.16

12.18

12.2

12.22

12.24

12.26

12.2762

12.3

12.32

12.34

24 28 32 34.3399 38 42 46 50

(11111)m

(11011)m

(01011)m

(01012)u(01112)u

(11112)u

(11013)m

(11113)m

(11014)u

(11015)m

sliding

other spiral

®°¯>±!² ¦4³:«h© u ³pu2k�q�|~�nor�!��w}v�st|~v�³¯oIs�|~w}v2wryQsI¶�mGknqt|~w®�|~��w}q�±p| st�T�r���pwn­l|~v�{�mpqtkn�~|~u2|~vporqt��k¥�|~®pk�vp��kyKw}q]o���mp|~q�or�~�~|~vp{�±p| yK³pq��noIst|~w}vB®p|µor{}q�oru �a¬ q�±�| s��]wryl®�| ­�k�qtknv!sRs��mGk��2orq�k2s�or{}{}kn®B­x| st�Cst�pkv�³pu]±Vk�q�wry¸|~u2m¯or�¥s���w�����³pq�qt|~vp{�|~v�knor���îwryRst�pkCÍp�!kCmVk�qt|~w®p��orvp®îst�pk*�~k�s²stknqa®#w}q¡¯or����w}q�®�|~vp{�stwd­x�pk¥st�pk�q�s���k¸|~vp| st|µor�N�nw}v�®p| s�|~w}v��]orqtkRor±Gwn�!k¸w}q�±Gk��~wT­°st�pk]knv�®�¶�wryĶ�s���k�¶�q�oru2m�~|~v�k©;Ocq°'�n�Cm �!���:=�qtkn�tmGkn�¥st| �!k�� � � ÜWw}|~v!s�� |~vp®p|~�noIstkn®C±�����q�w}�t��k��T�h�[w�³¯orq�k��]orvp®C®p|µoru2w}v�®p�orqtk�k¥¼por�¥slv³pu2k�qt|~�Tor��q�k���³�� s���­x�pk�q�knor�x�~|~vpk��xqtk�mpq�k���k�v!sx�nw}vI¿tk��¥s�³�q�k�®�|~v�stk�q�mGw}�µoIst|~w}vp� �

ÏTJ*LNHÄì�Q�FIQ�S·Ï ^THKí�SU^�JVÔ[ÏI\WQdÓ�J·Q8_ûÓ!H_Q�S·ÏI^�JVÔ�ÏT\WQ�eMEVfU^?LNQFTH_ÚVQ�L*×[Q�c_J¯õ�÷i8 Q�H_S·ÏTFIJNLN`UÓ!Q¸Ï�õRJ�c_JhÓEGcÓ!JhJ�FILNH_SUEGÏTQ�^ngN^nÏTQeB^'�'± ¿ Ä ÷ ¿ �}YV�!± Â Ä ÷  �M^TJ°ÏT\UEGÏMÏT\WQv±UÒ�Ó�JhJVFrLNHKS,E¯ÏTQ�EVSUL ÷ Ò¥Ó!JhJVFrLNH_SUE¯ÏIQ�EVFTQFIQ�c�E¯ÏTQ�LûÏIJBÏT\WQ�^TgN^�ÏIQ�e3Ú�JVcKÏIEVíVQ�EGSUL�Ó!`UFTFIQ�S·Ï2FTQ�^nf[QÓ!ÏTH_ÚVQcKg�÷?þ�S�ÏI\WQ�×UEV^TH�^¸JGÔxÏI\WQ�Sh`WeBQ�FIH_ÓEGcQ�ÚhH�LNQ�S,Ó!QVY[HKÏ;H�^2ÏI\WQ�S f,J·^T^THK×UcKQ�ÏIJ�Ó�JVSU^nÏTFI`UÓ}Ï�Ï�õ]J�EGfWfWFIJVfUFTH�E¯ÏIQg-�JVH_SUÓ�EVFX�Q�c_JNÓ�EGcleMEGfU^�õ2\WH�Ór\E¯Ï�E�Ó!FIHÄÏIH_ÓEGc�fUEGFrEGeBQ�ÏTQ�F;Ú¯EGc_`WQ� ½ M�\UEpÚVQCE:/ � Q�L�f[JVH_S·Ï;JVÔ ÏT\UQ�H_F�Ó�JVeBf[J�^THÄÏIHKJ�SPYP^nQQK�H_íU÷Ü6U,÷ 8 Q�Ó!J�SU^�ÏIFT`,Ó}ÏRÏ�õ]JK-�JVH_SUÓ�EVFX�Q�^TQÓ!ÏTH_JVSU^:²ì¿dEGS,Lz²HÂ�E�^]LNQfWH�Ó}ÏTQ�LûH_Sz/,íU÷¸Ü6UCEGSUL�Ó!JVS,^nH�LNQ�FÏT\UQ�Ï�õ]JBeMEGfU^J³ ¿�ÐY²ì¿´13µ²H开 ³ Â�Ð-²HÂ�13µ²ì¿ß �CU!�Ñ�J¯õ�Y[õRQ*EV^I^T`WeBQ�ÏT\UEGÏ�õRQ*EVFTQ%Ó�JVSU^TH�LNQ�FIHKSUí�Eû^TeBEVcKc�Q�SUJV`Wí�\�f,QFnÏI`WFT×,E¯ÏTH_JVSîJGÔ�ÏT\UQ%íVFrE�FHKSUíÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIg�H_S ×[JGÏI\îfW\,EV^TQ*EGS,L�fUEVFIEVeCQ�ÏTQF;^TfUEVÓ�Q*^T`UÓr\�ÏI\UE¯Ï�EGc_c�ÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏTJ�FTH_Q^díVJ¯Ú�Q�FISWQL�×hg³  \UEpÚ�Q;ÏT\WQ%^IEGeBQ�Sh`We*×,QF�JGÔ ù Ò¥^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WHKSUíMHKS�ÏI\WQ%^IEGeBQ�JVFrLNQ�F�÷?ê¥S�^T`UÓr\�EMÓ!H_FIÓ�`WeM^�ÏrEGSUÓ�QVY³  e*`U^nÏ ×,Q;^neBJhJGÏI\ûEGSULMEVcKcUÏT\WQ�fWH_QÓ!Qõ2H_^TQ�c_HKSUQEGF]×,Q\UEpÚhHKJ�`WF?H�^ Ó�JVS·ÏIEVHKSWQ�LBHKSBÏI\WQdeMEVf ³ ¿ ÷Q�QSUÓ!Q¸õRQRÓEGS%ÏIEGÙ�Q ³  ÏTJ�×[Q2Edc_JNÓ�EGc_c_g�cKH_SWQEVFleMEVf �²`WSULNQF�E;SWJ�S*LNQíVQSWQ�FrEVÓ�g�E�^T^T`WeBfNÏIHKJ�SÍ�}÷Ñ�J¯õ¬õRQ2\UEpÚVQ2^TJVeBQRÔüFTQQLNJ�e�H_SBÏT\WQ�Ór\WJ�H_Ó�Q2JGÔ�cKJNÓEGcUÓ�JGÒ�JVFrLNHKS,E¯ÏTQ�^O�!±,¿�Ä ÷ ¿@��EGS,L �'±Í开 ÷ Â)��EGS,LÏT\h`U^¸õRQ�EGFIQdÔüFIQ�Q;ÏIJBÓr\UJ·J·^nQ

³ Â�ÏTJB×[Q�ÏT\WQ�H�LNQ�S·ÏTHKÏ�gV÷P�tb�cKÏTQFTSUEGÏTH_ÚVQcKgûõRQ�eMEpgûÓ!JVS,^nH�LNQ�FRÏI\UE¯Ï³ ¿]ÏIJ�×,Q¸ÏI\WQ�eMEGfCÔüFIJVe ÏIHKeBQ�H_SU^nÏIEVS�ÏrEGSWQJV`U^Tc_g%E¯Ô�ÏIQ�F�¶ÍÆ�Y¯ÏT\UQ2ÏTH_eBQ�HKS,^�ÏrEGS·Ï?JGÔ[ÏT\WQdíVFrE�F�Q�Y¯ÏTJÏTH_eBQ�H_SU^nÏIEVS�ÏrEGSWQJV`U^Tc_g*×[Q!ÔüJ�FTQ��·¶ìÁ_Þ°�¢Æ ÔüJVF¸EGS0Þ�Ò�f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó�J�FT×UHÄÏ�÷ �tN�SULWQ�F]ÏT\WQ�^nQ�Ó!J�SULNHKÏTH_JVSU^

Page 13: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Ü�Û

¸¹ º»¼½

¾¿ ÀÁ Âà ÄÅ ÆÇ ÈÉ ÊË ÌÍ ÎÏ ÐÑ ÒÓÔÕÖ×ØÙ

ÚÛ

(17)

(19)

(15)

(21)

(23)

(25)

(27) (29)(31) (33)(35)

(13)

(11)

(9)

(7) (5)(3) (1)

11.75

13.38

13.50

16.83

17.71

18.15

18.42 21.29

21.45 23.09

23.94

24.80

25.01

32.60

32.71

34.59 Vin

v

(100)m

(110)m

(010)m

(011)u

(112)m

(113)u

(114)m

(115)u

(011)l

(111)m

(111)u

(011)m

(012)u

(112)u

(113)m

(114)u

(115)m

18.66

21.52®°¯>±!² ¦4³¸´@ÜN©Ý;_oIyKstk�q\f g,h´Þ:;'ßàB'l*=���| y_³pqt�noIs�|~w}v�®p|µor{}q�oru � z�or����{}q�orºn|~v�{�±p| yK³pqt�ToIst|~w}v�|~�qtk�mpq�k���k�v!s�k�®�±!��oR±p�µor��´��tmVwrs

Page 14: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Ü��ááââ ããää ååææ ççèèé2éé2éê2êê2êë2ëë2ëììííîîïïðð

ññòò óóôô õ2õõ2õö2öö2ö

÷2÷÷2÷ø2øø2øù2ùù2ùúúûûüü

ýýþþ ÿÿ�� ������������ ���� ������������������ ���� ���� ������������

�������������������������������� ���� !! ""## $$%% &&''

(1)21.45

(2)

(115)m

(3)

18.41888019

(4)

(114)u

(5)

23.08802931

(6)

(113)m

(7)

17.70852037

(8)

(112)u

(9)

32.59802

(10)

(012)u

(11)

34.59011172

(12)

(011)m

(13)

32.71246615

(14)

(111)m

(15)

13.49654974

(16)

(011)l

(17)

11.75238095 MAIN

(18)

(100)m

(19)

13.37574119

(20)

(110)m

(21)

21.28976130

(22)

(010)m

(23)

25.01012624

(24)

(011)u

(25)

24.79785521

(26)

(111)u

(27)

16.827327

(28)

(112)m

(29)

23.937480

(30)

(113)u

(36)

SLIDING

(35)

21.5207439

(31)

18.154710

(32)

(114)m

(33)

18.66444

(34)

(115)u®°¯>±!² ¦4³ý´�´G© ;_oIyKstk�q�f g,hi=)(Goru2|~� ��wrytÞ:;'ßàB'l*=���w}�~³�st|~w}vp� � z�or����{}q�orº�|~vp{�±p| yK³pq��noIst|~w}v�|~�qtk�mpq�k���k�v!s�k�®�±!��oR±p�µor��´��tmVwrs

Page 15: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Ü6U

12.265

12.27

12.275

12.28

12.285

12.29

12.295

-0.0005 -0.0004 -0.0003 -0.0002 -0.0001 0 0.0001 0.0002 0.0003 0.0004 0.00050.59

0.595

0.6

0.605

0.61

0.615

0.62

0.625

0.63

0.635

0.64

-0.0005 -0.0004 -0.0003 -0.0002 -0.0001 0 0.0001 0.0002 0.0003 0.0004 0.0005®°¯>±!² ¦4³k´)Û·©+*[w}� s�or{}kq;K�~k¥yKsD=]orv�®B��³pq�qtknv!st;_qt|~{}��sD= �~w��nor��u�ormp�T�XcQ;Os,�E=]orvp®-,[;Os,�T=?�� �+.or��st�pk�|~vp| st|µor����w}vp®�| s�|~w}vp�xwryUo Í��!k�mVk�qt|~w®p|~��w}q�±p| s����¯orq�or�¥stknqt|~��k�®�±!��k¥¼stk�q�v¯or�h{}q�orº�|~vp{¸orqtkmGk�qtst³pqt±Vk�®�±!��orv�oru2w}³pv!s . ;ic0/21 c0/43 . B5,6/718,6/43 . = �

12.22

12.24

12.26

12.28

12.3

12.32

12.34

-0.0005 -0.0004 -0.0003 -0.0002 -0.0001 0 0.0001 0.0002 0.0003 0.0004 0.00050.695

0.7

0.705

0.71

0.715

0.72

0.725

0.73

0.735

0.74

-0.0005 -0.0004 -0.0003 -0.0002 -0.0001 0 0.0001 0.0002 0.0003 0.0004 0.0005®°¯>±!² ¦4³]´C9h©)*[w}� s�or{}k¡;_�~k¥yÄs0=?orvp®C��³pqtq�k�v!st;Kq�|~{}�!sD=?�~w��nor��u�ormp�T�JcQ;�s,�T=]orv�®9,[;Os,�T=��� �). �or�Pst�pk�|~vp| st|µor�·��w}vp®p| st|~w}vp��wryUo Íp�!k�mGknqt|~w®�|~��w}q�±p| sP���porq�or�¥s�k�qt|~ºnk�®�±!�d|~v�stk�q�v¯or��{}q�orº�|~vp{2orqtkmGk�qtst³pqt±Vk�®�±!��orv�oru2w}³pv!s . ;ic / 1 c / 3 . B5, / 18, / 3 . = �õRQ;c_JhJVÙMÔüJ�FO/ � QL�f[JVH_S�Ïr^¸JGÔ�ÏT\WQ�eMEVf�²T¿�EGc_JVSWQ�Yhõ2\WH_Ór\�õRQ�EV^I^n`WeBQ;ÏTJBÏrEGÙ�QdÏI\WQ�ÔüJVFIe±ÍÂõ½;:J±,¿EÁ=< ÷ ¿JÁ?>� JÄ �<bW�÷ ÂK½ ø è ± ¿ ÁA@ ÷ ¿ Ä HÄÔE±  ô MWY¾J±�¿EÁ?B ÷ ¿+Ä HÄÔE±ÍÂVð M � � �õ2HKÏT\C:7ÄD<ÄD>+Ä è ÄE@!Ä¢¾,ÄDB°Ä� �z��YWfUcK`U^�\WHKí�\WQ�F2J�FILWQ�FRÏTQFTeM^YNõ2\WH_Ór\�õRQ;H_íVSUJVFIQ�H_S�õ2\UE¯Ï¸ÔüJVc_c_J¯õ�^�÷WJVF2f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó;JVFI×WHKÏI^YNõ]Q�^TQ�QÙL/ � QL�f[JVH_S�Ïr^2JGÔ ³ ¿2F ³ ÂG÷?ø¸\UQ�FIQ!ÔüJVFIQVÐ÷  ½ ÷ ¿ ½HG÷ Ä�±  ½�± ¿ ½IG± ��Þ��EGS,L�õRQ�íVQ�ÏÐ G± ½ <

Ü�éJ: G÷ Á >Ü�éK: JÄ � �º�

EGS,L G÷ ½ øML:NG÷ Ä HKÔ L<OG÷ Á L>� "ô MWYLè G÷ Ä HKÔ L<OG÷ Á L>� "ð MWY �tݺ�

Page 16: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Ü)b

2

(0,0)(0,0)

2

1

Σ

Σ

21 Π

Π

2

1

1

x

y

x

y

®°¯>±!² ¦4³ ´8bN© �����knu�oIst|~��®p|µor{}q�oru��t�pwT­x|~vp{îs���k���w}vp�tstq�³p�¥st|~w}v'wry�o_ÜUw}|~v��Torq@ek�u�ormyKw}qMk¥¼stk�q�v¯or�;{}q�orº�|~vp{ �QP Ö |~�Bs�or´}k�v'|~u2u2k�®p|µoIs�k�� �¾oIyKstk�qBs��pk�{}q�orº�|~vp{ st|~u2k�|~vp�²s�orv!s, ;SR-�C3UT0=DB c/;VRY�U3CT0=���orvp® P Õ |~�R��w}u2k�wrst�pk�q�ÜWw}|~vp�norqCekd��k��¥s�|~w}vû�~w��Tor��stw%st�pkdmGknqt|~w®�|~�w}qt±p| slon­Po���y_qtw}u4st�pk�{}q�orº�|~vp{R|~vp�ts�orv�s

õ2\WQFTQ L:7Ä L<)Ä L>+Ä Lè ÓEGS�×,Q�J�×NÏIEVHKSUQL�ÔüFTJ�eïÏT\UQ�Ó!JVS,^�ÏrEGS·ÏI^RH_S�Q)R[÷P� � �!÷Ñ�JGÏIH_Ó�QCÏT\UEGÏ;ÏI\WQM^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVSU^�JVÔ]Q�R·`UEGÏTH_JVS¸�²Ýº�;EVFTQB^�ÏIFTJ�SWíVc_g�LNQf,QSULNQ�S·Ï�J�S�ÏT\UQMÚpEVcK`UQCJVÔ

ÏT\UQ*^IÓ�EGc_H_SWíûÓ!J�SU^�ÏrEGS·ÏI^ L:7Ä L<)Ä L>�Ä Lè EGSUL�ÏI\WQ%eMEGfîfUEGFrEGeBQ!ÏIQ�F� �÷dê¥S�fUEGFTÏTH�Ó!`Uc_EVFYWHKÔ)W L:XWçÄYW Lè WÍð ÜVYÿ%R[÷�ÝCõ2HKc_cP\UEpÚ�Q;Ï�õ]JM^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVS�ÔüJVF´ aôýMMEVSUL�SUJB^TJVc_`NÏIHKJ�S�ÔüJ�F� "ð¸M]�²^TQ�QT/Uí,÷2Ü)bW�!÷

y0 1050-5-10

0

60

50

40

30

20

10

0

-10 Ymu

00-2-4-6-8-10

y

0

10

8

6

4

2

0®°¯>±!² ¦4³K´Cph©¦�hw��Tor�h��ormp��or�4Z��}orqt|~k��ê�Ï�H�^�FTQcKQÚ¯EGS·Ï�ÏIJöf[JVH_S·Ï�J�`NÏ�ÏT\UEGÏY�EV^�HÄÏ�H�^�Ó!c_QEGFIc_g¬J�`NÏTc_H_SWQLÌHKS /UíU÷ Ü)bNY�ÏT\WQ¾c_JhÓEGc

×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�SïLNH_EVíVFrEGe JVÔ�ÏI\WQØeMEGf fWFIJVf[J�^TQL fWFIQ^TQ�S·ÏI^½E Ó�JVFISWQ�Fë^TH_eCH_c�EGF¾ÏTJ ÏI\WQØJ�SWQ^fWFIQ^TQ�S·ÏTQ�L HKS /UíU÷ Ü)MW÷ Q�QSUÓ!Q4ÏT\WQöfWFIQ^TQ�SUÓ�Q½JGÔ�^TQ�ÚVQFIEVc%^T\UEGFIfúÏT`WFISWH_SWíÌf[JVH_S·ÏîHKS ÏT\WQ×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�S�LNH�EGí�FIEVe�JGÔPf[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó�^TJVc_`NÏIHKJ�SU^]ÓEGSM×[QdQ � fUc_EVHKSWQ�LûEV^]E%Ó�JVSU^TQ�R·`WQSUÓ!Q2JVÔx^nQÚVQ�FrEGcíVFrE�FHKSUí�fW\WQSWJVeBQ�S,EW÷�ê¥SûÏT\UQ�Ó�E�^nQ�JGÔ�ÏI\WQì�GÒ�f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó2J�FT×UHÄÏRõ2\WH_Ór\�íVFrE�F�Q�^ EGÏ�x ½ �·ÛBßµÞ+��ÝVݺbWYLNH_FTQ�Ó}Ï�Sh`WeBQ�FIH�Ó�EGc�H_ShÚVQ�^�ÏIHKí·E¯ÏTH_JVS¾^T\WJ¯õ�^;ÏT\UEGÏY[W L:\W°½:Þ?ß �W�ºM � ð:ÜWÄ]W Lè W°½#ܺßKÜ�U!b��_ð ÜB\WQSUÓ!QÏT\UQ�Q � H_^nÏTQSUÓ!Q�JVÔ�Ó�JVFISWQ�Fr^RHKS�ÏT\UQ�×WHÄÔü`UFIÓE¯ÏTH_JVS�LNH�EGí�FIEVe3EV^¸fWFIQLNH�Ó}ÏIQL�×hgûÏT\UQ�EGSUEVcKgN^TH_^÷

Page 17: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Ü �^Pण åxè-VXP¥VWâTVXP!R�N�é'NBå¦K�NCP²é²æ�é²âTSyVWâlæ�V�N@N�åPèVé VNã�hhæ'æURPâUVXW4é²è-NWJ�cKc_J¯õ2H_SWí�JV`UFlSh`WeBQ�FIH�Ó�EGc·Ó�EVc_Ó�`Wc_EGÏTH_JVSU^YpHÄÏ�õRJV`Wc�L�EGfUf,Q�EGFPÏI\UE¯Ï�ÔüJVF�Ó!QFnÏrEGH_S�Ú¯EGc_`WQ^lJGÔnxØÏT\WQFTQEGFIQ¸^nJ�cK`NÏIHKJ�SU^lõ2\WH_Ór\CFIQ�f[QE¯ÏIQLNc_g�Ó!FIJ�^I^lJ¯ÚVQ�FlÏT\UQRFrEGeBf*õ2HÄÏI\C^TeMEGc_c·Q � Ó!`WFr^nH_JVS,^xJ�S%Q�HKÏT\UQ�F?^TH_LNQEGS,LMEV^%x EVfWfWFIJ�E�Ór\WQ^�E�Ó�FTHKÏTH�Ó�EVcWÚ¯EGc_`WQ�ÏI\WQ^TQ�Q � Ó�`WFr^nH_JVSU^�ÏTQ�S,LCÏTJgFQ�FIJ�eMEGíVSUHÄÏI`ULNQdEVSULCÏTJ%E^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVS�õ2\WH�Ór\�^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WQ^¸J�S�EVSUL�JGì�H_SB/USWHKÏTQcKg�JGÔ�ÏTQSP÷P�²b FIJVc_Q;ÚVQ�FIgû^THKeBH_c_EVF¸ÏTJB\WJVeBJNÓ!c_H_SWH_ÓJVFI×WHKÏI^�HKSÌÏT\WQ°LNghSUEGeBH�Ó�^÷ � 8°QîSUJ¯õ#^TQ�QÙ¬ÏTJ4J�×NÏIEVHKSØ^T`UÓr\ÌE4^nJ�cK`NÏIHKJ�SÌEGS,L'ÏTJ¬Ó!JVS,^nH�LNQ�F^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSU^�õ2\WH�Ór\�c_HKQCÓ!c_J�^TQ�ÏTJ�HÄÏ�÷;ø¸\UH_^;H_eCeBQ�LNH_EGÏTQcKg�c_QEVLU^d`U^dÏTJ�ÏT\WQBLNQFTH_Ú¯E¯ÏTH_JVS�JVÔ]EûeMEVfFIQ�c�E¯ÏTH_SWíCÏT\UQ�ÚVJVcKÏIEVíVQ�EGSUL�Ó�`WFTFIQ�S·Ï�E¯Ï2ÏI\WQ�×[JGÏnÏIJVe:JGÔ�ÏT\WQ�FrEGeBf�ÏTJBÏT\,E¯ÏdE¯Ï2ÏI\WQ�ÏTJ�f�� ³ _V` »��}Yõ2\WH�Ór\�ÏIEGÙ�Q^]ÏT\UQ�ÔüJVFIe3JGÔ�EBLNJV`W×UcKQ�^TfWH_FIEVc �t^nQQT/UíU÷¸Ü � ÷8 QBõ2H_cKc�ÏI\WQ�S½LNQFTH_ÚVQ�Y�HKSý^ � YPE�eMEVf�ÔüFIJVe ÏI\WQCÏTJVf°JGÔ]ÏT\WQBFrEGeBfî×,EVÓrÙ�ÏTJ�ÏI\WQB×,JVÏnÏTJ�e� ³ a _V`Db �;EGSUL ^�ÏI`ULNg�HKÏI^�Ó!J�eBf,J·^nHKÏTH_JVS õ2HÄÏI\îÏI\WQBeBEVf LNQ�^TÓ�FTH_×[QLîEV×,J¯Ú�Q%H_S J�FILWQ�F�ÏTJ�Q � fWc�EGH_SÏT\UQ�^nfWH_FrEGc�×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�S�^nÏTFI`UÓ!ÏT`WFIQ�JV`NÏIcKH_SWQL�H_S�ÏT\WQ�fWFIQ�ÚhH_JV`U^¸^TQÓ!ÏTH_JVSU^÷

v

Σ

Σ

loc

glob

t

®°¯>±!² ¦4³ ´@~N©��´}k¥st���Bwry�st�pk¸s�­�w;u�orm��?yKq�w}u st�pk2±Gwrststw}uúwry�st�pk2q�oru2m�stw;st�pk¸stw}mBorvp®�|~��k��!k�q���o

c Z�âºZäã7�>=CD+=�*?�T;n�@��=C()D+=²ót�6(��µò 1 =C(�*\�b6^nc_H�LNHKSUí¸Þ�Ò�f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�ÓîJ�FT×UHÄÏ�H_^�J�SWQ ÔüJVF�õ2\WH�Ór\Ź,�CM!�{½ï¹7�CÞ�Æõ�}YìÀ��CM!�a½ïÀ��CÞ�Æõ�ûEVSULÌÏT\WQÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIg Ó!J�HKS,Ó!H�LNQ^�ÔüJVF�M�ô ¼Lô Æïõ2HÄÏI\ëÏT\UQ�fUEVFnÏ%JVÔ2ÏT\WQ�^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí Ó!gNÓ!c_Q�Ó�JVeBfWFIH_^THKSUíECFIEVeBf ¹7�C¼��%½�¹�ñº�3¼��@Ä Med¸¼fdûÆPÄ �nÜ�Mº�õ2\WQFTQ ¹�ñW�3¼��w½¸ò�Á ó?¼�ß �nÜVÜ)�

Ñ�J¯õ�Y�HÄÏxH�^�SWJVÏxLNHi_MÓ�`WcKÏxÏTJ�^TQ�Q�YH_S�ÏT\UQ EG×U^TQ�S,Ó!Q�JGÔWEGShgdE�LWLNHKÏTH_JVSUEVcV^nÏTFI`UÓ}ÏI`WFTQ�J�FPH_S·Ú¯EVFTH�EGS·ÏI^JGÔ�^TgN^�ÏIQ�eM^�JGÔRÏT\UQMÔüJVFIe ��ÛW�;ÏI\UE¯Ï*^T`UÓr\½E�ÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIgî^n\UJV`Wc�L¾×,Q�JGÔ2Ó!JGÒ¥LNH_eBQ�SU^THKJ�SëÛN÷0UJVFQ � EVeCfUcKQ�Y�ÏI\WH_SWÙhHKSWíBJVÔxÏT\UQ;H_SWHKÏTH�EGcPÓ�JVSULNHKÏTH_JVS�JGÔ�E*^TcKH�LNH_SWíB^nJ�cK`NÏIHKJ�S�EGÏRÏI\WQ;ÏTJ�f�JGÔlÏT\WQ�FrEGeBfPY

Page 18: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

ÜpÞÏ�õRJîfUEVFIEVeCQ�ÏTQFI^CEGFIQ�FIQ�R·`WH_FTQ�L½H_S4JVFrLNQF%ÔüJ�F*ÏI\WQ�^nJ�cK`NÏIHKJ�SöEGÔ�ÏTQ�F]�3Þ�éúÜ)�¢ÆïÏTJ¾^IE¯ÏTH�^nÔüg¾ÏT\WQÓ!J�FTFIQÓ!Ï�¹a�+*7DìÀ ÏTJBc_HKQ�ÏrEGSWí�Q�S·Ï¸ÏTJCÏT\WQ�×[JGÏTÏTJ�e JGÔ�ÏT\UQ�FIEVeCfx÷

O]gCÚ¯EGFIghHKSWí�Ï�õRJ�fUEVFIEVeBQ!ÏTQFI^YVS,EGeBQ�c_g%ÏI\WQdH_SWfW`WÏ]ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGí�QPx EGSULBÏI\WQdc_J�E�LCFTQ�^nH�^�ÏrEGSUÓ�QHsH_S ��ÛW�}YVõ]QRõ]QFTQ]HKS,LNQ�Q�L*EV×WcKQ]ÏTJ�LNQ�ÏTQ�Ó}Ï?^nQÚVQFIEVcVf[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó¸^nc_H_LWHKSWí�ÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIHKQ�^�÷Pê¥SCfUEVFnÏIH_Ó�`Wc_EVFYõRQ*c_JNÓ�E¯ÏIQL EûÏI\WFTQQ!Ò�f,QFTH_JNLNH�Ó*^TcKH�LNH_SWí�^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVS EGÏTxp½ ÛWM\ß ��ÛW�W��U?b-�%Ä4s ½þUºMnßKܯÞ+�WÜ)��ÛY�;÷;b/UÚ�Q;f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó�^TcKH�LNH_SWíBJVFI×WHKϸõ¸EV^2EVc_^TJ*ÔüJV`WSUL�ÔüJ�FPxî½Å��UÍß ÛW� � ÞGÛGÝJ�EÄ�s ½«ÛNÜºß � Ý � �WMWÜ��;÷8 Q ÏT\WQFTQ�ÔüJVFIQîÓ!J�SUÓ!c_`ULNQ ÏT\,E¯Ï�ÏI\WQ¾^ngN^nÏTQ�e �nÜ)��õ2HÄÏI\ØÏT\UQ J�FTH_íVH_SUEGc�fUEGFrEGeBQ�ÏTQ�F�Ú¯EGc_`WQ^�C�!�BH�^�Ó!c_J�^TQVY¸ÔüJ�Fzx { �WUnß �Y��ÏTJöE½Ó!JGÒ¥LNH_eBQ�SU^THKJ�SNÒ�Ï�õ]Jë^TgN^�ÏIQ�e Ó�JVS·ÏIEVHKSUHKSWíöE bpÒ�f,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó^TcKH�LNH_SWíúÏTFrE¯ý�QÓ!ÏTJ�FTg�Y*H_S ÏT\WQ ^TQ�SU^TQ¬ÏT\UEGϽE ^TeMEGc_cMf,QFnÏI`WFT×,E¯ÏTH_JVS JGÔ{�CxLÄ�sT�°FIQ^T`WcKÏI^¾H_S E^Tgh^nÏTQe�f[J�^I^nQ�^T^TH_SWí�^n`UÓr\ME�Ó!JVÒ�LWHKeBQ�S,^nH_JVSNÒ�Ï�õRJdÏIFIEGý�QÓ}ÏIJVFIgV÷ Î HKeBH_c_EVFTc_g�ÏI\WQP�¯Ò�f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó¸FTQíVH_JVSPYLNQfWH_Ó!ÏTQ�L4H_Sû/,íU÷¸bWY�ÔüJVFLx {�ÛNÜWß MY� EGfWf[QEVFI^*ÏIJîÔüQQ�c¸ÏT\UQhgTíV\WJ·^�Ïji�JVÔdÏT\UQ�JVÏT\WQFM^nc_H_LWHKSWí^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSBÔüJ�F%s ½ UºMnßKܯÞ+�WÜ)��ÛY�;÷PÑ�`WeBQ�FIH�Ó�EGc_c_g%õRQ�\UEpÚVQ¸ÔüJ�`WSULBQÚ·H�LNQSUÓ!Q2ÏI\UE¯Ï]ÏT\WQõ�¯Ò�f,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó^TfWHKFrEGc�H�^¸e%`,Ór\�c_Q^I^�Ó!J�eBfWcKQ�ÏTQ;ÏT\,E¯Ï2ÏT\UQÃbpÒ�f,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó;J�SWQ�õ2\WH_Ór\�H_S�ÏI\WQ�c_HKí�\�Ï2JVÔlÏI\WQ�EGSUEVcKgN^TH_^H_Sz^�bN÷ U�×[Q�c_J¯õ4H�^�Ó!J�SU^nH�^nÏTQ�S·Ï�õ2HÄÏI\*HKÏ?×[Q�H_SWí;Ôü`WFnÏI\WQ�F?Epõ¸Epg;ÔüFTJ�e ÏT\WQ2Ó�JGÒ¥LNHKeBQSU^nH_JVSWÒtÏ�õRJdf[JVH_S·Ï÷WJVF;ÏI\WQBFTQeBEVHKS,LNQ�F�JGÔ ÏT\WH�^�^nQ�Ó}ÏIHKJ�S õRQC^T\UEVcKc�EV^I^T`WeBQ%ÏI\UE¯Ï�E�Ï�õ]JVÒ�LWHKeBQ�S,^nH_JVSUEVclÚ�QÓ!ÏTJVFJGÔ]fUEGFrEGeBQ!ÏIQ�Fr^t� xLÄ4sV�dH_^�EVcKc_J¯õ]Q�L�ÏTJ�Ú¯EGFIg�EGSUL�ÏT\UEGÏ�EGÏ�� x+k)Ä4slk��dÏT\UQB^TgN^�ÏIQ�e#Q � \WH_×WHKÏI^�EVSÞ�Ò�f,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó�^TcKH�LNH_SWíCÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏTJ�FTg�÷

Ñ�JGÏIQûÏI\UE¯Ï�Y EGc_JVSWí Eî^TcKH�LNH_SWíîf[JVFTÏTH_JVS½JVÔ�E�^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSPY�ÏI\WQ�LNHÄì�Q�FIQ�S·ÏIH_EVc]Q)R�`,E¯ÏTH_JVS½H�^*SWJGÏfWFIJVf[Q�FIcKgëLWQ@/USWQ�L�÷ý- FTQ�^nQS·ÏTc_g½õ]Q�õ2HKc_c�Ó!J�SU^nÏTFI`UÓ}ÏME ^Tc_H_LNH_SWí½^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVS¬EV^BEîc_H_eCHKÏûJGÔ�eCJ�FTQÓ!c�EV^I^TH_ÓEGc,^TJVc_`NÏIHKJ�SU^�Y·×W`NÏRÔüJVF]ÏT\UQ�eBJVeBQS�ÏRõ]Q;fWFIQ^T`WeBQ�ÏI\UE¯Ï¸^n`UÓr\�E*^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSMQ � H_^nÏI^¸EGS,LMõ]QSWJ¯õ«cKJhJVÙ�E¯Ï�^nJ�eBQ;JVÔ�HKÏI^�fWFTJ�f,QFnÏIHKQ�^�÷JUFTJ�eïÏT\WQ�^TgN^�ÏIQ�e �nÜ)�!YWõ]Q�\UEpÚ�Qè ¹è ¼ �3¼��%½ é ¹,�3¼��sVv Á À��C¼��v �nÜ�ÛW�EGS,L�õRQ�HKeBeBQLWH_EGÏTQ�c_gû\UEpÚ�Q;ÏT\UEGÏ�HÄÔJM9dý¼fdýÆÌÏT\WQS�ÔüJVF�^TcKH�LNH_SWíÀ��C¼��E½�ÀÒñ��C¼��%½ òs Á ó!¼s Á óBvìÄ �nÜ��º�JV×,^nQFTÚhH_SWí%ÏI\UE¯Ï À�� Mº�E½ òs Á ó\vìÄ À��CÆõ�J½�À�� Mº�·Á ó!Æs ß �nÜ6U!�Ñ�J¯õÌÔüFTJ�eïÏT\UQ�^ngN^nÏTQ�e:Q�R·`UEGÏTH_JVSU^T�tÛº�}YWõRQ�\UEpÚ�Qè Àè ¼ �C¼��%½Yé ¹,�3¼��u Á x unm �C¼���Ä �nÜ)bW�õ2\WQFTQ m �3¼��w½ Ü�HKÔi¹,�3¼��Oôý¹�ñW�C¼��¸EGSUL m �3¼��w½�MCHÄÔJ¹,�3¼���ð¸¹�ñW�C¼��}÷

ÿ%R[÷ ��Ü)�º��LNJhQ^�SUJGÏî^IE¯ÏTH�^nÔüg ��ÜbW��EV^�ÏT\WQë^TeMEGc_c�Q � Ó!`WFr^THKJ�SU^�JGÔMÓ!`WFIFIQ�S·ÏY�õ2\WH�Ór\úEVFTQf[Q�FTÏT`WFI×UE¯ÏIHKJ�SU^*JGÔ�ÏI\WQ�^Tc_H_LNH_SWí¾^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVSë\UEpÚ�Q�LNQFTH_Ú¯E¯ÏIHKÚ�Q^*õ2\WH_Ór\¬LNJîSUJGÏCÏTQ�S,LëÏIJ_F�QFTJ°EV^�3À�� Mº��Ä4¹7� Mº�4�q3 �CÀGñW�CMº�@Ä�¹�ñº�CMº�4�}÷kU`WFnÏI\WQ�FIeBJVFIQMHÄÏ*H_^%`WSUÓ!c_QEVF�ÔüJVFCE�^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVSë^IE¯ÏTH�^nÔüg·H_SWí �nÜ�Mº�fWFIQÓ�H_^TQ�c_g'õ2\WQ�S«HÄÏ�H_^�JVSÌJVF�JGì�÷ ølJ4FIQ^TJVc_ÚVQ�ÏT\WH�^�õ]Q¾^n\,EGc_c;EVHKe ÏTJ'^TJVc_ÚVQ�Q)R,÷ �nÜ)bW�ûHKSEGS ��$�6�4�6�!��Dî^TQ�S,^nQ�×hg4H_S·ÏTQíVFrE¯ÏTH_SWí���ÜbW�BJ¯Ú�Q�FCÏT\UQ�f,QFTH_JNL Æ#JGÔ;ÏT\WQ�FrEGeBfP÷ ølJëLNJ¾ÏT\WH�^Ó�EVc_Ó�`Wc�E¯ÏTH_JVS õ]QME�^T^T`WeBQCÏT\UEGÏ�LW`WFTH_SWí�ÏT\UH_^;ÏIHKeBQBÏT\UQûÓ!JVShÚ�Q�FTÏTQ�F;H�^%þ;Ñ�ÔüJ�F�EûÏIHKeBQMH_S·ÏTQ�FIÚ¯EGco Æ�EGSUL¾þì ¬ÔüJVF�ÏT\WQBH_S�ÏIQ�FIÚ¯EGcO��ÜHé o �¢Æ�÷�Ñ�J¯õ H_S�ÏIQ�í�FIEGÏTH_SWí"�nÜ)bW�dJ¯ÚVQF�ÏI\WQ*f[Q�FIH_JhL_Æ�EGS,L`U^THKSUí]�nÜ�M!��Ò���ÜVÜ�REGSULa��Ü�U!�]õ]Q�\,EpÚVQó!Æs ½ é ò7Æu é ó?Æ Â

Û�u Á x u o Æ �nÜ � �ÏT\h`U^ o ½ Üx � óBus Á�ò�Á ó?Æ

Û � �nÜpÞ��

Page 19: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Ü��ø¸\WQ*fUFTQ�LNH_Ó!ÏTQ�L o ÔüJVF�LNHKì�Q�FIQ�S·Ï�ÚpEVcK`UQ^;JGÔ?ÏI\WQBHKSUfW`NÏ�ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGíVQtx:EVíVFIQ�Q^df,QFnÔüQ�Ó}ÏIcKg�õ2HKÏT\

Sh`WeBQ�FIH_ÓEGc�J�×U^nQFTÚ¯EGÏTH_JVSU^YN^nQQ�ø�EG×UcKQBÜV÷p §G¢rq>³V´V©ÍÜ[qtk�®p|~�¥s�k�®dorvp®�w}±p��k�q²�!kn®2�ror�~³pk���wryts���w}u2mp³�stkn®dor�~w}vp{�;Kvpknorq0=,�t�~|~®p|~vp{�mGw}qtst|~w}vp�wryWstq�oI¿²k��¥s�w}qt|~kn�n��yKw}qP®p| ­Vknqtk�v�sP�}or�~³�kn�lwryNs���k�|~vpmp³�sx�!w}� s�or{}k2d �ª�v�mp³�sx�!w}� s�or{}k2d Ü[qtk�®p|~�¥s�k�®ls ¬ ±p�tknq²�!k�®us u w � >x¶��t­x| s����p|~vp{}�P®pk¥s�k��¥stkn®l�� � ��� � � n�n*��� � � n�n*�}� �����l}� � ��� � � np�n��g � � np�n��g ��s}�lon � l�l � � l}�on*s � � l}�on!� �on*ll�s � ��� � � l!�}�ol � � l!�}�ol ��g��n*� � ��� � � l�l���� � � l}����� �}���

øxJCÓ!JVeBfWc_Q!ÏIQ�J�`WF2Ó�EVc_Ó�`Wc_EGÏTH_JVSûõRQde*`U^nϸLNQ�ÏTQFTeBH_SWQK� x k Ä�s k �!÷?ø¸\WH�^]õRQP/,SUL�×hgMc_JhJVÙhHKSUíE¯Ï�ÏI\WQû^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVS½E¯Ô�ÏIQ�F�HKÏ�\UE�^�cKQ�Ô�Ï�ÏT\UQBÏTJVf¾JVÔ]ÏI\WQûFrEGeBf°EVSUL¾^nJ�cKÚhH_SWí���Ü�;õ2HÄÏI\¾ÏT\WQMH_SWHKÏTH�EGcÓ!J�SULNHKÏTH_JVSU^ À��3Æõ�E½ òs Á ó!Æs Á ó\vìÄ ¹7�CÆõ�E½¸òLÁ�ó?ÆPßø¸\WQ�Ú¯EGc_`WQ�JVÔt�Cx+k+Ä4slk���H�^*ÏT\WQS4í�HKÚ�Q�Së×hga/USULNH_SWí°Ú¯EGc_`WQ^CJGÔÃ� xLÄ4sV�*^n`,Ór\ëÏT\,E¯ÏCÔüJVFB^nJ�eCQH_S�ÏIQ�í�Q�F�ÞîõRQ�\UEpÚVQÀ��CÞ�Æõ�J½ òs Á�ó\vìÄ ¹,�3Þ�Æì� ½�ò �nÜ��º�c Z á Zäã�(+�µò 1 =C(+*n��ó6��(�6� 1 (����>=CD+=�*?�Ñ�J¯õ õRQ%Ó!J�SU^TH_LNQF�ÏI\WQ�ÔüJ�FTe JGÔ�ÏI\WJ�^TQ%^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSU^dõ2\WH�Ór\�cKH_Q*Ó�cKJ·^nQ�ÏIJ�Eû^TcKH�LNH_SWí�^TJVc_`NÏIHKJ�SP÷�øxJLNJCÏT\UH_^2õRQ�Ó!J�SU^nH�LNQF�^neMEGc_cPÓ!J�S·ÏTH_S·`UJV`U^RÔü`WS,Ó}ÏTH_JVS,^wvw�C¼��¸EGSULyx%�C¼��¸^nJCÏI\UE¯Ï¹7�C¼��%½ òLÁ�ó?¼·ÁAv��3¼��@Ä �nÜݺ�À��C¼��:½ òs Á ó?¼s Á�ó\v�ÁAx%�3¼��@Ä ��Û�Mº�õ2HKÏT\;v��3¼���EGSULzxw�3¼��û^TeMEGc_ct÷ ø¸\WQ�Ôü`WSUÓ!ÏTH_JVSU^yv��3¼���EGSULzx%�C¼��M\UEpÚ�QîLNHKì[QFTQS·Ï�^neBJhJGÏI\WSWQ�^T^fWFIJVf[Q�FTÏTH_Q^YBHKS fUEVFnÏIH_Ó�`Wc_EVF½EV^a¹7�C¼��½Ó!FIJ�^I^TQ^îÏT\WQ FrEGeBfþ¹ ñ �3¼�� ÏI\WQ'Ôü`WSUÓ!ÏTH_JVSIvw�C¼��°\UEV^½ELNH�^TÓ�JVS·ÏTH_Sh`WJV`,^2^nQ�Ó!JVS,L�LNQFTH_Ú¯E¯ÏTH_ÚVQ�YWEGSULyx%�C¼��¸EBLNH_^IÓ!J�S·ÏTH_S·`UJV`U^�/UFr^nÏ2LWQ�FIHKÚ¯E¯ÏIHKÚ�QV÷

Î `W×U^nÏTHKÏT`NÏIHKSUíMHKS·ÏTJûÿwR[÷O��ÛW�Rí�HKÚ�Q^öv��C¼��E½êé vsTv Á xv Ä ��ÛNÜ)�öx%�3¼��O½êé vu Á x u m �C¼�� é òu é ós é ó?¼u Ä ��ÛVÛW�õ2\WQFTQ�SUJ¯õ m �C¼���½ Ü�HÄÔ�v��3¼��õôÅM�EGSUL m �C¼��O½îMMHÄÔ�v��3¼��õðÅMU÷�b�cKÏT\WJ�`WíV\�õRQ*ÓEGS�^TJVc_ÚVQ:��ÛNÜ)�EGS,L ��ÛVÛº�xQ � EVÓ}ÏIcKg%×,Q�Ï�õ]QQ�SM^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí·^�YGÏT\WQ�FIQ^T`WcKÏTH_SWí�Q � fWFIQ^I^nH_JVS,^�EVFTQ2Ó�JVeBfWc_Q � EVSULBLNJ�SWJGÏE¯ì�JVFrL�e%`UÓr\�HKS,^nH_íV\·Ï÷E.dE¯ÏT\UQ�F2eBJVFIQ�HKSNÔüJ�FTeMEGÏTH_JVS�H_^¸í�HKÚ�Q�S�×·g�EGS����å+�P; 1 ( 1 =²ó���;W;7��(���ó 2 ÷øxJúLNJÌÏI\WH�^ fUFTQ�^n`WeBQ4ÏT\UEGϾEGÏ°^TJVeBQëÏIHKeBQ ¼ Z ï�CM\Ä4Æõ��õRQö\,EpÚVQ?v��3¼ Z �Ž MúEGS,Lx%�C¼ Z �_½ ª ð MWY�õ2\UQ�FIQ�ª¾H�^�^TeMEGc_ct÷ WFIJVe �tÛWÜ)��EGSUL ��ÛVÛº�MõRQî\UEpÚ�Q�ÏT\UEGÏ öv ð M4EGS,LÏT\UQC^TgN^�ÏIQ�e H�^dÏI\h`U^;HKSWHKÏTH�EGc_c_g þìiR÷,8 \WH_c_^nÏ{v ðYM�EVSUL�^TeMEGc_ctY�ÏI\WQ�SîÏTJ�ÏT\WQBc_QEVLWHKSWí�JVFrLNQ�FõRQ;\,EpÚVQ;ÔüFTJ�e �tÛWÜ)�REGS,La��ÛVÛº�?ÏI\UE¯Ïöx%�3¼��%½îé òu é ós é ó?¼u}| é[~O�%�C¼��

Page 20: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

ÜÝõ2\WQFTQ)~����3¼��Oð¸M%H�^?ÏI\WQ�EG×U^TJVc_`NÏTQ�Ú¯EGc_`WQ�JVÔPÏT\UQ�í�FIE�LNHKQS·Ï÷?þ�×U^nQFTÚ�Q2ÏT\,E¯ÏRÔüJVF]ÏT\WQ;fUEGFrEGeBQ�ÏTQ�FÚ¯EGc_`WQ^0�C�!�Tó?Æ�ë�u ½ Û � ß_ÜݺM�UNÞ �y� ò·ë�u Á ónë+s ½ � UhÞBß bWMVÝ�Ý�Uº��^nJ�ÏT\UEGÏ öxØH�^�ÚVQFTg SWQEVFTc_gÓ!J�SU^nÏIEGS·Ï�Y·õ2\UHKc�^�Ï�v ð¸M�÷EQ�QSUÓ!Q;ÏTJME*ÚVQFTgMí�J·JNL�EGfWfWFIJ � HKeMEGÏTH_JVSPYhõRQ�\UEpÚ�QdÏI\UE¯Ï�YNHÄÔ7v�ð MWÐx%�3¼��w½$ª]~ � �C¼ Z �@�C¼ éa¼ Z ��ßê�Ô�õ]Q�H_SWHÄÏIH_EVcKc_g�E�^T^T`WeBQ;ÏT\UEGÏ�v � x?YWÏT\WQS�H_S·ÏTQíVFrE¯ÏTH_SWí'�tÛWÜ)�REGS,L"��ÛVÛW�Rí�HKÚ�Q^vw�C¼��%½ Üv �C¼ é"¼0Z�´�XªìéM~O�w�C¼0Z� �3¼ié{¼ Z �

Û � ßþ�×U^TQ�FIÚVQ�ÏT\WQS�ÏT\UEGÏ�vw�C¼ ¿ �E½ÅMCõ2\WQ�S¼E½ ¼4¿�½�¼ Z Á Û-ª~O�w�3¼0Z+�EGS,L�LN`UFTH_SWíBÏT\UQ�HKS·ÏTQFTÚ¯EVc�¼ Z dý¼fdû¼4¿¯Y�vw�C¼��RÏIEVÙVQ�^ ÏI\WQ�eME � H_e%`We:ÚpEVcK`UQv��7�E�T½ ª Â

Ûºv�~ � ßWJ�F´ª � ÜdÏT\WH�^¸H�^RÓ�JVSU^TH�^�ÏIQ�S·ÏRõ2HKÏT\�ÏT\WQ�J�FTH_íVH_SUEGc[EV^I^n`UeCfWÏTH_JVSU^ReMEVLNQ;JVSyvw�C¼��}÷?D�J�FTQJ¯ÚVQF]E¯Ï¼w½ ¼4¿;õRQ�\UEpÚ�Q�^TH_eCfUcKg�ÏT\UEGÏ�x%�C¼���½ é�ªh÷�þ�ÚVQF2ÏT\WH�^�gT\UEGcKÔ?Ó!gNÓ!c_Q�iBõRQ�ÏT\h`U^d\UEpÚVQT/,íV`WFIQ^2JVÔv��3¼��2EVSUL�xw�3¼��2E�^2LNQ�fWH�Ó}ÏIQL�H_S]�H_íU÷¸ÜpÞN÷-θ2C

α: β:

1t

δ

-θ2 δ

2

δ

δ-

0t1t0t

®°¯>±!² ¦4³K´C�h©[z,�!w}�~³�st|~w}v;wry��¦;i�'=xorv�®��?;i�'=�wT�!k�qxst�pkf��Æ0� � Ç��!ÇE� ��;i��/CB � Õ =WJVFw¼wð¸¼4¿RÏI\WQ;ÚpEVcK`UQdJGÔ�v��3¼�� ×[QÓ!J�eBQ^?SUQ�í�EGÏTH_ÚVQdEVSULBÏI\WQ;^TgN^�ÏIQ�e ^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UQ^2þ;Ñ�÷·ê¥SMÏT\WH�^Ó�E�^nQ;ÏI\WQ�íVFrEVLNH_Q�S·Ï¸JGÔ�x½Ór\UEGSWí�Q^]ÔüFIJVe3SWQí�EGÏTH_ÚVQ;ÏTJBf[J�^THÄÏIHKÚ�QV÷.2Q�f[QEGÏTH_SWíCÏT\WQ�fWFIQ�ÚhH_JV`U^2EVFTí�`WeBQ�S·ÏI^Rí�HKÚ�Q^vw�C¼��%½ Üv �C¼ é"¼ ¿ �@��~Q4P�C¼ ¿ � �3¼ é"¼4¿6�

Û é ª��EGS,L xw�3¼��%½îé�ªOÁA~ 4 �3¼4¿6�@�3¼ éa¼4¿@�@Äõ2HKÏT\ ~ 4 �3¼��E½ x u é òu é ós é ó?¼u Äõ2\WQFTQ�õRQ;SUJGÏTQ:�t^nH_íVSUHç/,ÓEGS·ÏTc_g\� ÏT\UEGÏw~ 4 �C¼��OðýM*ÔüJ�F2ÏT\WQ�f,EGFrEGeBQ!ÏIQ�F¸Ú¯EGc_`WQ^V� �º�}÷

Page 21: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Û�Mê¥S�ÏI\WH�^�Ó�E�^nQ;õ]Q�\UEpÚ�Qlvw�C¼  �E½ÅMCõ2\WQ�FIQ¼  ½�¼ ¿ Á Û-ª~ 4 �3¼4¿6�

EGS,LK��vf��ÏrEGÙVQ�^RHÄÏr^2eME � HKe*`We3Ú¯EGc_`WQ�JVÔ��v��0�7�E�V½ ª ÂÛWv�~ 4 ß

ø¸\WQûÓ!J�eCfUcKQ�ÏTQMfWH�Ó}ÏI`WFTQMJVÔ¸Ôü`WSUÓ}ÏIHKJ�SU^{v«EGSULKx'HKS¾ÏI\WQMH_S�ÏIQ�FIÚ¯EGcE¼� �C¼0ZºÄ4¼  �;H�^�ÏT\WQSëEV^FIQ�f[JVFTÏTQL�H_S]�H_íU÷¸Ü��U÷

t 0

α:

t 1 δ

δ

∆∼δ

t 2

δ

2θ+

t 0

β:

θ-

δ2

2C

2C

δ2θ-

θ

δ2

+

®°¯>±!² ¦4³ ´C h© zU�!w}�~³�s�|~w}vîwryw�¦;i�'=%orv�®M��;O�'=�wT�!k�q�;i��/�B � Ö =�� ���pwn­x|~vp{�st�pk�|~q����nor�~|~vp{}��or�yK³pvp�¥st|~w}vp�xwry .!�ø¸\WQ*J·^TÓ�HKc_c�E¯ÏTH_JVS,^�ÏI\WQ�S°FTQf,Q�E¯Ï;ÔüFTJ�e ¼õ½î¼¢ÂCõ2HKÏT\ E�^TcKH_íV\·ÏTc_g�c�EGFIíVQ�F�Ú¯EGc_`WQ*JVÔ�~ � EVSULîE

^TcKH_íV\·ÏTc_gM^neMEVcKc_Q�FRÚ¯EGc_`WQ�JVÔ�~Q4¸÷ þ�×U^nQFTÚ�Q�ÏI\UE¯Ï2LN`WFIHKSUí�ÏT\UQ�FrEGeBf�Ó�gNÓ!c_Q�~O�°EVSUL�~Q4½J�SWcKgBÚ¯EGFIg^TcKH_íV\·ÏTc_gMÔüFIJVeïÏI\WQ�eBQEVS�Ú¯EVcK`WQ�^¸JGÔ~ � ½ òu Á ós Á ó?Æ

Û�u ��Û��º�EGS,L ~�4�½ x u é òu é ós é ó!Æ

ÛWu ��Û+U!�ø¸\·`,^�õRQM^nQQ%ÏI\UE¯Ï�ÏI\WQBSUE¯ÏI`WFIQ*JVÔRE�^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVS Ó�cKJ·^nQ*ÏTJ�^TcKH�LNH_SWí�H_^;J�SWQBõ2\WH_Ór\°J�^IÓ!H_c_c_EGÏTQ^

Q�HKÏT\UQ�F¾^nH�LNQ¬JGÔMÏT\UQ¬^TcKH�LNH_SWí«^TJVc_`NÏIHKJ�S�EGSUL�õ2\WH�Ór\ \UEV^°EÌ^TeMEGc_cCEVeBfWcKHKÏT`,LNQ�ªØHKS�x:EGS,LEGS E�^ngheBfNÏTJVÏTH�Ó�EVcKc_gëe%`,Ór\Ø^neMEGc_c_Q�FûEGeBfWc_HKÏT`ULNQîJGÔ¡ª  ë\�tÛWv�~ � �BJ�F�ª  ë\�tÛºv�~ 4 �BH_S�v]÷«ø¸\WQ

Page 22: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

ÛNÜgnõ¸EpÚVQcKQSWíGÏI\�iMJVÔ ÏT\UQCJ·^TÓ�HKc_c�E¯ÏTH_JVS LNQÓ�FTQ�EV^TQ^�õ2HÄÏI\¾EVeBfWcKHKÏT`,LNQMEGSULî\UEV^�ÏT\UQCeBQ�EGS°ÚpEVcK`UQCJVÔ� YWõ2\WQFTQ � ½ Û/ª~Q4 Á Û-ª~O� ½ Û/ªB�5~ 4 ÁA~ � �~Q4�~�� Äõ2\WH�Ór\�`U^nH_SWí'�tÛW�º�¥Ò���Û+U!� íVH_ÚVQ�^� ½ Û/ª+xu Ü�¡ ¢ Á¤£¥ Á¦£ ÿ ¢ �6��§ ¢ 馠¢ 騣¥ é©£ ÿ ¢ � ß ��ÛWbW�

Ñ�JGÏIQ�ÏI\UE¯Ï � H_^�fWFIJVf[JVFTÏTH_JVSUEVcPÏTJ�ªMEGSULî\WQ�S,Ó!Q�ÏI\WQ%Sh`We*×,QF�JGÔ ^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WHKSUí�^dLW`WFTH_SWí�ÏT\WQf[Q�FIHKJNL]M9dý¼fdûÆúH_^�fWFTJ�f,J�FnÏIHKJ�SUEGc,ÏTJ�Ü+ëQªh÷

ø¸\WQ�eCQ�EGS�ÏTH_eBQ�^nf[Q�S·Ï;þ;ÑúH�^¸ÏT\WQSÜ� Û/ª~ 4 ½ ~ �~ 4 ÁA~ � ½ Üx �Bò�Á óBus Á ó?Æ

Û � Äõ2\WH�Ór\�H_^¸fWFIQÓ�H_^TQ�c_gMÏI\WQ�Ú¯EGc_`WQ�JGÔ o Æ Ó�EVc_Ó�`Wc_EGÏTQ�L�ÚhH�E �nÜpÞW�}÷c Z«ª!Z��K�@��=�$+� 1 =C(+*{(¢A 132 �Ã��(�ó��+�°�L��;ORg�`U^nH_SWíMÏI\WQ%FIQ^T`WcKÏI^�JGÔ�ÏT\UQ*fWFIQ�ÚhH_JV`U^d^nQ�Ó}ÏTH_JVSîõ]Q%ÓEGS�SUJ¯õ LWQ�FIHKÚ�Q%EMeMEGf�ÔüFIJVep¹,�CMº��EGS,LÀ��CM!�?ÏIJL¹7�CÆõ�REGSUL À��3Æì�}YN×hgûc_J·J�ÙhHKSWíBH_S�EBSUQ�H_íV\h×,J�`WFI\WJhJhL�JGÔ�ÏT\WQ�^Tc_H_LNH_SWíM^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSP÷

ê�Ô ¹,�CM!�%½¸ò Ä À��CMº�E½ òs Á ó\vìÄÏT\UQ�S�õ]Q�EVFTQ�JVS�ÏT\UQ�^nc_H_LWHKSWíû^TJVc_`NÏIHKJ�S�EVSUL�Ó�JVSU^TQ�R·`WQS·ÏTc_g

¹,�3Æì�E½ ò�Á ó?ÆPÄ À��3Æõ�J½ òs Á óBv�Á ó?Æs ß8 Q�SUJ¯õ#Ó�JVSU^TH�LNQ�FMÏI\WQ�Q�ì[Q�Ó}Ï�JVÔ�eBEVÙhHKSWíë^TeMEGc_cdf[Q�FTÏT`WFI×UEGÏTH_JVSU^BÏIJ½ÏT\UQ EG×[J¯ÚVQ�H_SWHKÏTH�EGcÓ!J�SULNHKÏTH_JVSU^÷�øxJûLWJ*ÏI\WH�^�^nQ�Ϲ,�CM!�E½ òLÁ�¹­¬4Ä À��CMº�E½ òs Á ó\v Á À®¬EGS,L ¹,�3Æõ�E½ ò�Á ó!ÆûÁ ¹°¯\Ä À��CÆõ�E½ òs Á�ó\v�Á ó?Æs Á À®¯nÄõ2\WQFTQT¹°¯MEVSULzÀ±¯MEVFTQ;fWFIQ^T`WeBQL�^TeBEVcKc�÷�PQ!Ï¥²ì¿2×,Q�ÏT\WQ�cKJNÓEGcÍ-�J�HKS,Ó�EGF��Q2^TQÓ}ÏIHKJ�SL¼J½ÅM 4 �²eBJhL:Æõ��õ2HKÏT\�Ó�JGÒ�JVFrLNH_SUE¯ÏIQ^P�CÀ²¬�Ä�¹­¬G�}YNEGS,L²HÂ�×,Q�ÏT\UQ�c_JhÓEGc�-�JVH_SUÓ�EVFX�QM^TQÓ!ÏTH_JVS�¼t½pM � �üeBJNL�Æõ��õ2HKÏT\4Ó�JGÒ�JVFrLNH_SUE¯ÏIQ^:�CÀ®¯nÄ�¹°¯!�}÷°ø¸\WQ�S^T`WfWf[J�^TQ�ÏI\UE¯Ï¸ÏI\WQ�eBEVf�ÔüFIJVe3ÏT\WQ�×[JGÏnÏIJVe3JVÔxÏI\WQ�FIEVeCf�ÏTJCÏI\WQ;ÏTJVf�H_S�ECSWQHKí�\·×[JV`UFT\WJhJNLûJVÔ^TcKH�LNH_SWíCÏIEGÙ�Q^RÏI\WQ�ÔüJVFIe³ _V` » Ð-² ¿ 3 ² Â Ä �3À ¬ Ä4¹ ¬ ��13ï�3À ¯ Ä4¹ ¯ �E½þ�5³7�3À ¬ Ä�¹ ¬ ��Äo�:�3À ¬ Ä�¹ ¬ ����ß ��Û � �ê¥SMõ2\UEGÏ�ÔüJVc_cKJ¯õ�^�õRQ�LNQ�ÏTQ�FIeBHKSUQ2ÏT\WQHF�Q�FIJ�^�EVSULMEV^TgheBfNÏTJVÏTH�Ó2^TÓEGc_HKSWí�JVÔ\³*EGSUL\� H_SBÏT\UQ2ÏT\WFIQ�Q^TQ�fUEVFIEGÏTQ�Ó�EV^TQ^¸õ2\UQ�S À²¬TYB¹­¬TYWJVF2×[JGÏI\�EVFTQ;Ú¯EGFIHKQ�L�×hg�EGS�EGeBJV`WS·Ï�ªtð¸MU÷

Page 23: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

ÛVÛc Z«ª!Z�âWZµ´E��6�+¶0· À ¬ $+�+��å+=�*?� Î `UfWf,J·^nQCSWJ¯õ ÏI\UE¯Ï�õRQC^TQ!ÏV¹ ¬ ½ M�EVSUL�Ú¯EGFIg'À ¬ ÏT\WFIJV`Wí�\ EVSH_S�ÏIQ�FIÚ¯EGcWõ2\WH�Ór\MH_SUÓ!c_`ULNQ�^%MW÷�ø¸\WH�^?H�^?JVÔ�Ó�JV`WFr^TQ2Q�R·`WH_ÚpEVcKQS·Ï�ÏTJ%^TQ!ÏTÏTH_SWíg¼ Z ½ÅM�HKSBÏI\WQdfWFIQ�ÚhH_JV`U^Ó�EVc_Ó�`Wc�E¯ÏTH_JVS,^REVSUL À®¬°½$ªh÷

ê¥SWHÄÏIH_EVcKc_g�ÏIEGÙ�Qaª�ð�MW÷¸bd^tªCH�^�FIQLN`,Ó!QL�ÏI\WQ�FIQ�õ2H_cKcl×,Q%EK/,FI^nÏdÚ¯EGc_`WQaª�¸ ^n`,Ór\�ÏT\UEGÏ�ÔüJVFdEíVH_ÚVQS�H_S·ÏTQíVQ�F[¹ Æ ½�¹ � ßWFIJVe:ÿ%R[÷��tÛWbº�Rõ]Q�^TQ�Q;ÏT\,E¯Ï2ÏT\UQ�FIQ;H�^�EBÓ!J�SU^nÏIEGS·Ï´ ¾^n`UÓr\�ÏT\,E¯ÏÆ ½ØÛ°¹kªB��~Q4kÁº~O�i� Ü~ 4 ~ � | �ª ¸ ¹'Ä^TJ*ÏI\UE¯Ï ª�¸Å½ Æ 4¹ ßWJ�F¸ÏT\WH�^2Ú¯EGc_`WQ�JGÔ^ª�¸ õRQ�\UEpÚ�Q;^THKeBfWc_gûÏI\UE¯Ï¹°¯7�3Æõ�J½ÅM\Ä À±¯n�CÆõ�E½�ª�¸ÃÄEV^RÏI\WQ�^Tgh^nÏTQe3\UE�^2EGS�HKS·ÏIQ�íVQF¸S·`Ue%×[Q�F�JVÔlQ � Ó�`WFI^TH_JVSU^RQ�HKÏT\UQ�Fd^TH_LWQ;JVÔlÏI\WQ�^TcKH�LNH_SWíM^nJ�cK`NÏIHKJ�SP÷Ñ�J¯õÌHKÔ^ª%H�^¸FTQ�LN`UÓ�QL�ÏT\WQFTQ�H�^2EK/UFr^�Ï2Ú¯EGc_`WQ¡ª ¸ 4)»¼ ^T`UÓr\�ÏT\UEGÏÆ�½;¹ � Á Û-ª ¸ 4 »¼~ 4 Ä^TJ*ÏI\UE¯Ï ª ¸ 4 »¼ ½ Æ 4¹�Á ½E¾ ß

ê¥S�ÏT\UQ*H_S·ÏTQ�FIÚ¯EGc^ª ¸ 4 »¼ ô ª ô ª ¸ ÏT\WQBLNQÚ·H�E¯ÏIHKJ�SîJVÔ�v¬ÔüFTJ�e F�Q�FIJûí�J·Q�^�ÏT\WFIJV`Wí�\îEû\,EGcKÔÓ!gNÓ�cKQ�õ2HKÏT\Cv ô¸MW÷?bRÏ2ÏT\UQ�Q�SUL�JGÔlÏT\WH�^2\UEVcÄÔ�Ó!gNÓ�cKQlv��3Æõ�E½ÅMWYhÏI\·`,^�E¯Ï�ª ¸ 4 »¼¹ ¯ �CÆõ�J½ MnÄ À ¯ �3Æõ�E½îé�ª ¸ 4)»¼ ßbRÏdEGS�EGfWfWFIJ � HKeMEGÏTQ;eCH�LhÒ�f,J�HKS·Ïtª ¸ 4 »¿ ^IE¯ÏIH_^nÔüghHKSUíª ¸ 4 »¿ ½ Æ 4¹�Á ¿½E¾ ÄÏT\UQ�ÚpEVcK`UQ;JVÔ[��vf�dÏrEGÙVQ�^¸HÄÏr^2eME � H_e%`We3Ú¯EVcK`WQ�YW^nJCÏI\UE¯ÏdEGÏ2ÏT\WH�^2Ú¯EGc_`WQ�JGÔ^ª¹ ¯ �3Æì�E½îé Ü

Ûºv�~ 4 ª ¸ 4�»¿ Ä À ¯ �CÆõ�J½ Mnßê�Ô�ª H_^öSWJ¯õ FTQ�LN`UÓ�QL ÏIJ ª ¸ 4 ¿ ^nH_eBHKc�EGFö×,Q\UEpÚhHKJ�`WFëJNÓ�Ó�`WFr^ëQ � Ó�Q�fNÏöÏT\UEGÏhv ð MW÷

Z]JVe*×WH_SWHKSUí�ÏT\WQ�^nQ�FIQ^T`WcKÏI^�í�HKÚ�Q^�EVSCQcKQeBQ�S·Ï JGÔPE�^TfWH_FIEVcKc_HKSUí�^nÏTFI`UÓ!ÏT`WFIQ2JVSBÏI\WQÃ�3¹ ¯ Ä�À ¯ ��fWc�EGSWQHKÔEª ¸ 4 ¿ ô�ªtô�ª ¸ YUE�^2LNQ!ÏrEGH_cKQ�L�HKS]�HKí,÷2ÜÝBEGSUL�Û�MU÷

ê�Ô õ]Q*cKQ�Ϫ�13äM�ÏT\UQ�S�ÏI\WH�^;^TQ�R·`WQSUÓ!Q*FTQf,Q�E¯Ïr^�ÏI\WFTJ�`WíV\ EGc_cO�t^n`X_MÓ�HKQS·ÏTc_g�c_EVFTí�Q)�¸H_S·ÏTQ�í�Q�FÚ¯EGc_`WQ^¸JVÔ�¹ë÷

Ñ�J¯õïÓ!J�SU^nH�LNQF�ÏT\WQ�Ó�EV^TQûJVÔ´ªaô MW÷�ø¸\WQ�Ó!`WFIÚVQ�^�JGÔ�v«EGSULJxÌEVFTQM×,EV^TH_ÓEGc_cKgîÏT\WQ�^TEVeCQÏT\UJV`Wí�\ûLNH_^TfWc�EVÓ�QL*ÏT\WFIJV`UíV\B\UEGcKÔxE�Ó!gNÓ�cKQ�÷lê¥SMÏI\WH�^ Ó�E�^nQ¸ÏI\WQ�Ú¯EGc_`WQ�^?JGÔ�ª �¸ fWc�Epg�ÏI\WQd^IEGeBQ2FTJ�cKQEV^RÏI\WQ�QEVFTc_H_Q�F¸Ú¯EGc_`WQ^¸JVÔEª 4¸ õ2HÄÏI\ ª �¸ ½Yé Ü 4¹ ½Yé�ª 4¸ Ä

Page 24: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

��

2c

N+1/4

δ

δ

δ-

θ -θθ2c+

δ2N+3/4

N+1/2

N+1

Nfi

vf

®°¯>±!² ¦4³:´@«h©�z,�~knu2k�v!s�wry,s���k]�tmp|~q�or�~�~|~vp{R�tstq�³p�¥st³pq�kRor��mpqtkn®�|~��stk�®�±���s��pkRorv¯or� ���|~�T�¯­x�pk�qtk.�À j���Á@;SZO©=DB . À Ô,Õ Ã�Ä j ��Á@;VZOÂh3��EÁjÅ Ô =0B . À Ô,Õ Ã Ö j ��Á@;SZOÂh3���ÁjÅ Ô =0B . À Ô Æ Ã±Ä j�4Á@;SZOº3M��ÁjÅ Ô 3��EÁjÅ�Ç�=

N+1δNδ

N+1/2

y=xi v

δ δ

y=x2/2cθ

δ

N+1δ

ff

®°¯>±!² ¦4³gÛQÜN©È,�É�orv�®c�Édk¥�!w}�~³�st|~w}v�or�Py_³�vp�¥s�|~w}vp�xwry . or�Pmpqtk�®p|~�¥s�k�®�±!��s��pk?orvpor� ���t|~�H_S�ÏT\,E¯ÏdÏI\WQ�g�EVFTQ%ÚpEVcK`UQ^�JGÔ)ªCÔüJ�F�õ2\WH�Ór\�ÏI\WQ�FIQ*H�^;EGS�H_S·ÏTQ�í�Q�F�S·`Ue%×[Q�F;JGÔ J·^TÓ�HKc_c_EGÏTH_JVSU^�^n`,Ór\ÏT\,E¯Ï�HKÔEªV½$ª ¸ ÏT\WQS]¹ ¯ �CÆõ�J½ MBEVSUL À ¯ �3Æõ�E½�ª ¸ ÷

ê¥S�ÏI\WH�^�Ó�E�^nQ;õ]Q�\UEpÚ�Qª �¸ 4)»¿ ½êé Ü�! 4¹ ÁØÜë¡~ � � Ä ��Û�Þ��ª �¸ 4 »¼ ½êé Ü�! 4¹ ÁöÛºë¡~��9� Ä ��Û��º�ª �¸ 4wÊ¿ ½êé Ü�! 4¹ ÁöÛºë¡~��zÁØÜë]~Q4J� Ä ��ÛGݺ�õ2HKÏT\_¹ ¯ �'ª ¸ 4)»¼ �P½ M\ÄõÀ ¯ �'ª ¸ 4)»¼ �P½�é�ª �¸ 4�»¼ Äì¹ ¯ �'ª ¸ 4)»¿ �P½ é�ª ¸ 4 »¿ ëB��ÛWv�~O�i�@ÄõÀ ¯ � ª ¸ 4)»¿ �P½M\ÄO¹ ¯ �'ª ¸ 4�Ê¿ �E½�ª ¸ 4[Ê¿ ëB�tÛºv�~Q4 �@Ä�À ¯ � ª ¸ 4wÊ¿ �E½ÅMW÷

Z]JVe%×UHKSWH_SWí�ÏI\WH�^*õ2HKÏT\ëÏT\WQ�fWFIQ�ÚhHKJ�`U^�FIQ^T`WcKÏI^%õ]Qz/USUL¾ÏI\UE¯ÏB×hg Ú¯EGFIghHKSUí�ª�ÏT\WFIJV`UíV\4EVS

Page 25: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Û+UH_S�ÏIQ�FIÚ¯EGc2õ2\WH�Ór\öH_SUÓ�cK`ULWQ^�F�QFTJ°õRQ�ÏIFIE�Ó!Q�JV`WÏMEVS �²Q�c_Q�í·EGS·Ï��*LNJV`U×WcKQ�^TfWH_FIEVc¸HKSöÏT\WQ �C¹ ¯ Ä�À ¯ �fWc�EGSWQ�YWEV^2LNQfWH�Ó}ÏTQ�L�HKS'�HKí·^�÷ ÛWÜVYUÛ�ÛN÷

12.255

12.26

12.265

12.27

12.275

12.28

12.285

12.29

12.295

12.3

12.305

12.31

-0.05 -0.04 -0.03 -0.02 -0.01 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.050.58

0.59

0.6

0.61

0.62

0.63

0.64

0.65

0.66

-0.05 -0.04 -0.03 -0.02 -0.01 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05®°¯>±!² ¦4³�Û!´G©�*,w}� s�or{}kE;K�~k¥yKsD=Worvp®R��³pqtq�k�v�s�;Kq�|~{}�!s0=Nk¥�!w}�~³�st|~w}v2oIsWs��pk�stw}mRwry¯st�pkPq�oru2m or��, � |~��rorq�|~k�®�­x�p|~�~kTc � j"� � �P�p|~��ͯ{}³pq�k�­�or�x�nor�~��³p�µoIstk�®�³p��|~v�{¸k w³¯oIst|~w}v�;²��=�oIsxst�pk?m¯orq�oru2k�stk�q�ror�~³pk��lv�kTorqPstw¸���~|~®p|~v�{�;Ol*=�­x| st�dkj�lon�m l�l����}�}� �

0.58

0.59

0.6

0.61

0.62

0.63

0.64

0.65

0.66

12.255 12.26 12.265 12.27 12.275 12.28 12.285 12.29 12.295 12.3 12.305 12.31®°¯>±!² ¦4³�Û�Û·©[jlw}³p±p�~k���m�|~q�or�!s�q�or�nk�®¸±!�?|~v?s��pk^;ic�ÉYBË,�É�=hmp�µorvpk�­x�pk�vf, � |~�h�}orq�|~k�®Rorvp®:c � j"� �µ�w}u2mp³s�k�®;�t|~u2|~�µorq�� �]s�wRÍp{}³pq�k?���c Z«ª!Z á Zµ´E��6�n¶�¶0·w¹ ¬ $����å+=�*!� Î `WfWf[J�^TQ�SWJ¯õ ÏI\UE¯ÏBõ]Q:/ � À ¬ E¯Ï�M�EGSULëÚpEVFTga¹ ¬ �²^TQ�Q0�H_íU÷Û��!�}÷JWFIJVeïJ�`WF¸fWFIQ�ÚhHKJ�`U^¸EGSUEVcKgN^TH_^]HKÏRÔüJ�cKc_J¯õ�^]ÏT\UEGÏ2HÄÔi¹ ¬ ðýM*ÏT\UQ�S ¹ ¬ ½�ª  ëB��ÛWv�~O�9�}÷EQdQ�SUÓ�QVY^TQ!ÏnÏIHKSUí ªV½ÍÌ ÛWv�~6��¬EðýMnÄ

Page 26: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

ÛWbõRQ;FIQLW`UÓ!Q;ÏT\UH_^¸ÏIJMfWFIQ�ÚhHKJ�`U^¸Ó�EVc_Ó�`Wc_EGÏTH_JVSU^÷ Î H_eCH_c�EGFIcKgûHKÔ ¹ ¬ ô¸M*ÏI\WQ�S�^TQ!ϪT½îé Ì édÛºv�~M��¬Jô¸MÏTJ½J�×NÏIEVHKS¬ÏI\WQ�JGÏI\WQ�Fû\,EGcKÔ;JVÔ�ÏI\WQî^TfWHKFrEGc�÷'ÏT\UQîLNJV`U×WcKQ�^TfWH_FIEVc2×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�S'LWH_EVíVFrEGe H�^ûEV^×[Q!ÔüJVFIQ�EGSUL�eMEGfU^]ÔüFIJVe�¹ ¬ ÏTJ�¹ ¯ ÷E�HKí,÷�ÛW�*^T\WJ¯õ�^]ÏT\UQ;Ú�JVcKÏIEVíVQ�EVSUL�Ó!`WFIFTQS·ÏRQÚVJVc_`NÏIHKJ�S�EV^O¹ ¬H�^¸ÚpEVFTH_QLP÷c Z«ª!Z«ªºZµ´E��6�{¶�¶E¶j·J�º�6*7�6�4�+� =�*Í= 1 =C����ó�(�*7D+= 1 =C(+* Ñ�J¯õ ^T`WfWf[J�^TQ�ÏT\,E¯Ï�õRQ%Ú¯EVFTg À ¬ EGS,L'¹ ¬ HKSîEeBJVFIQ�íVQ�SUQ�FrEGc�õREpgBÏI\WQ�S�ÔüJ�Fd^nJ�eBQì¼0Z�õRQ�\UEpÚVQ��üHKÔ ¹ ¬ ð¸M!�}йÃéaÀ ½ Üv �3¼ié"¼ Z �@� ªTé ~ �

Û �3¼ éa¼ Z �4��ÄÀ®¬9½�ªìéK~ � �3¼ é"¼ Z ��ÄÔüJVF�ªCEGS,Lz¼ Z ÏIJM×,Q�LNQ�ÏTQFTeBH_SWQL�YNõ2\UQ�FIQgMtô¸¼ Z ô Û/ªWë]~ � EGSUL�õRQ�ÓEGS�fW`NÏP¼%½�MU÷.2QEVFTFrEGSWí�HKSUí%õRQ;\,EpÚVQ�^nH_eBfWc_gªT½ÏÎ À ¬ ÁöÛWv�~ � ¹­¬4Ä � �WMº�õ2HKÏT\]¼0Z�íVH_ÚVQS�×hg ¼ Z ½ �3À®¬�é ª��~O� ß

ê�Ôi¹ ¬ ô¸MCÏT\WQS�^nH_eBHKc�EGFIcKgªT½ Î À ¬ é½ÛWv�~ 4 ¹­¬4ß � �WÜ)�ê¥S�õ2\UE¯Ï¸ÔüJ�cKc_J¯õ�^¸õ]Q�õ2H_cKcxFTQ�ÔüQ�F¸ÏTJ ªT½ Î À ¬ ÁhÐK�3¹ ¬ �@Äõ2\WQFTQ M�ôzÐK�3¹­¬G�E½ ø ÛWv�~O�°¹ ¬ Ä HÄÔ ¹ ¬ ðýMédÛWv�~ 4 ¹­¬�Ä HÄÔ ¹­¬JôýM ß � ��ÛW�8 Q�Ó�EVS4SWJ¯õï`,^nQ�ÏT\WQ�FIQ^T`WcKÏI^CJGÔ�ÏI\WQ�fWFIQ�ÚhHKJ�`U^CÓ�EGc�Ó!`Uc_EGÏTH_JVSëÏIJ°Ó�JVeBfW`NÏIQ�ÏI\WQ�LNQ^TH_FTQ�LeMEGfP÷TQ�QFTQ�ªMH_^�fWFIJVf[JVFTÏTH_JVSUEVc�ÏTJ�ÏT\WQCeMEGí�SWHÄÏI`ULNQ*JGÔEÀ±¯�EVSULkª  ÏTJ�ÏT\UEGÏ�JGÔE¹°¯,÷;ø¸\WQ*Ú¯EVcK`WQJGÔ9¼ Z í�HKÚ�Q^ ÏT\WQ�fW\,EV^TQ�JVÔlE%f[JVH_S·ÏRJ�SûÏI\WQ�LNJV`W×UcKQ�^nfUHKFrEGcJ�üõ2\UH_Ór\�H_^Rc_Q^I^R^TH_íVSWH�/,Ó�EVS·Ï]ÏI\UEGS�ÏT\WQÚ¯EGc_`WQ�JVÔ�ª��!÷�Ñ�JGÏIQ�ÔüFIJVe �C�ºMº��ÏI\UE¯Ï HKÔ·À®¬PEGS,L�¹­¬lEVFTQ2JVÔ�Ó�JVeBfUEVFIEV×WcKQ�^TeMEGc_cUeMEGí�SWHKÏT`ULNQ�ÏT\WQS�ªH�^�EV^TgheCfWÏTJGÏIH_ÓEGc_cKg�LNQ�f[Q�SULWQ�S·Ïd`Wf[JVS]¹­¬?EVcKJ�SWQV÷?ø¸\WH�^2FIQ^T`WcKÏ�H_^2H_eBf,J�FnÏrEGS·Ï�õ2\WQS�Ó�JVe*×WHKSUHKSWíÏT\UH_^¸eMEGf�ÔüFTJ�e ÏT\WQ�×[JGÏTÏTJVe JGÔPÏI\WQ�FIEVeCf�ÏTJCÏT\UQdÏIJVf�õ2HÄÏI\�EC^n`U×U^nQ)R·`WQ�S·Ï¸íVc_JV×UEVc,eMEGf�ÔüFIJVeÏT\UQ�ÏTJVf�JVÔxÏT\UQ�FIEVeCf�×UE�ÓrÙMÏTJCÏT\UQ�×,JVÏnÏTJ�e�YUEV^2Ó�JVSULN`,Ó}ÏTQ�L�HKS�ÏT\UQ�SWQ � Ï�^n`U×U^nQ�Ó}ÏIHKJ�SP÷c Z Ñ7Z¤� 2 �ì�W��(Vð��+�i�L��;���*7D0��+º= � 1 �6*[ó��K(¢Aw;n�@��=C()D+=²ót�6(��µò 1 =C(�*\�8°Q�SWJ¯õ Ó�JVSU^TH_LWQ�F?ÏI\WQ;Q!ì�QÓ}ϸJGÔ�ÏI\WQdí�cKJ�×UEGc[LNghSUEGeBH�Ó�^ ÔüFTJ�e ²  3 ² ¿ J¯Ú�Q�Fõ�CÞ�é°Ü��f[Q�FIHKJNLW^H_SîEûSWQHKí�\h×,J�`WFT\UJ·JNL�JVÔ EGSkÞ�Ò�f,QFTH_JNLNH�Ó%^TcKH�LNH_SWíûÏIFIEGý�QÓ}ÏIJVFIgV÷2ê�Ï�H_^;EûSh`WeBQFTH�Ó�EVcxJV×,^nQFTÚ¯E¯ÏIHKJ�SÏT\,E¯Ï*õRQ�ÓEGS4Ór\UJ·J·^nQ�E�^n`X_MÓ�HKQS·ÏTc_g¾^TeMEGc_c]SUQ�H_íV\h×,J�`WFI\WJhJhL¾JVÔd^n`,Ór\4E�ÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIg H_Së×[JGÏT\fUEVFIEVeCQ�ÏTQF�EGSUL'fU\UEV^TQ�^nf,EVÓ!Q ^n`UÓr\¬ÏI\UE¯Ï�ÏT\WQîLWg·S,EGeBH_Ó^ûH_S'ÏT\WH�^�SWQ�H_íV\h×[JV`WFI\WJhJNL¬LWJ½SWJGÏ`WSULWQ�FIíVJîEVS·g¾í�FIEWF�H_SWí�^%Q � Ó!QfNÏ*H_SëÏI\WQ�f[Q�FIH_JhL4JGÔ2ÏI\WQ�FrEGeBf4Ó�gNÓ!c_Q�õ2\WH�Ór\öÓ�JVFIFTQ�^nf[JVSULU^�ÏTJ

Page 27: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Û �

12.273

12.274

12.275

12.276

12.277

12.278

12.279

12.28

12.281

11.748 11.749 11.75 11.751 11.752 11.753 11.754 11.755 11.756 11.757 11.7580.6

0.605

0.61

0.615

0.62

0.625

0.63

0.635

0.64

11.748 11.749 11.75 11.751 11.752 11.753 11.754 11.755 11.756 11.757 11.758®°¯>±!² ¦4³TÛQ9h©È*,w}� s�or{}k¥;K�~k¥yKsD=�orvp®d��³pq�qtknv!s^;Kq�|~{}�!s0=�k¥�!w}�~³�st|~w}v;oIsPst�pk�stw}m�wryNst�pk�q�oru2m�or�rc �|~���rorq�|~k�® � µ�w}u2mp³�stkn®���|~u2|~�µorqt� �RstwRͯ{}³pqtk?���ÏT\UQ�^TcKH�LNH_SWíîf[JVFTÏTH_JVS4JGÔ2ÏT\UQ�J�FT×WHKÏ÷aQ�QSUÓ!Q�Y�ÏT\WQ�Sh`We%×[Q�FCJGÔd^Tõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí�^%J¯ÚVQF�ÏT\UQa�CÞ"é Ü)�FIQ�eMEGH_SU^dÓ�JVSU^nÏIEVS·ÏdEGSUL�ÏI\WQ%í�cKJ�×UEGcxeBEVf

³ a _V`Db ÐM²  3 ² ¿ H�^dE�LNHÄì�Q�J�eBJVFIfW\WH�^ne õ2\WH�Ór\�õ]QÓ�EVS�EVfWfWFIJ � HKeME¯ÏIQdÏIJû^n`X_MÓ�HKQS·Ï2E�Ó�Ó�`WFIE�Ó!gM×hgûHKÏI^2c_H_SWQEVF¸ÏTQ�FIeM^�YW^TQ�QT/,íU÷¸Ü � ÷³ a _S`Eb Ð-²HÂ�3µ²ì¿Ä � À ¬¹ ¬ � ½ ù � À ¯¹ ¯ � Á ú � ¿  � Ä � �W�º�õ2\WQFTQ 9¿�½ÅxYéax+k�EGS,Lz ·Âõ½ s é{slkp÷WJVF?ÏT\WQTbpÒ�f,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó2^Tc_H_LNH_SWí�J�FT×UHÄÏ]Ó�JVeBfW`NÏIQLBQ�EGFIcKH_Q�F EGÏwx ½ �WUnß~Û�� � ÞGÛVÝ\Ä�s ½ÌÛNÜWß � Ý � �ºM�ÛõRQõ/,SUL�ÏT\UEGÏ ù ½�� éPM\ß~ÛWb M\ß Uº�éPM\ß U�Ý M\ß M �EGS,L ú ½�� Mnß M·ÛWb éPM\ß MWÜ)�Mnß M·ÛWb éPM\ß MWÜb � ßÑ�JVÏTQ½ÏI\UE¯Ï ù EGS,Lîú�EGFIQ½SWJ�SNÒ�^TH_SWíV`Wc�EGF�õ2\UH_Ór\ H�^îEVcKc%ÏT\UEGÏ H�^�FIQ�R·`WH_FTQ�LÌÔüJ�F�ÏI\WQëc_HKSWQ�EGFEGfUfWFTJ � H_eME¯ÏTH_JVS�JGÔ ³ a _S`Eb ÏTJB×,Q�Ú¯EVcKH�L�÷ê¥S�JVFrLNQF ÏIJC^TQ�QÙCf[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó;^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVSU^]HKS�E%SUQ�H_íV\h×,J�`WFI\WJhJhLûJGÔl^TcKH�LNH_SWíCõ]Q;Ó!JVS,^nH�LNQ�Fw/ � QLf[JVH_S�Ïr^ JVÔ

³ a _S`Eb F ³ _V` » ÷ Î H_SUÓ!Q)~�ÒëEVFTQ�EVfWfWFIJ � H_eME¯ÏIQ�c_g*Ó!J�SU^nÏIEGS·Ï�Y�HKÏ]H�^ FIQE�^nJ�SUEG×UcKQ¸ÏIJ%EV^I^n`UeCQÏT\,E¯Ï ÏI\WQ2Ôü`WS,Ó}ÏTH_JVS,^�³*EGSUL�� H_S_��Û � �?EGFIQ2fUEGFrEGeBQ!ÏIQ�F?H_SULNQf,QSULNQS�Ï�Y·EVSULBÏI\UE¯Ï]EVcKc,fUEGFrEGeBQ�ÏTQ�FLNQf,QSULNQ�S,Ó!Q�EGfUf,Q�EGFr^¸Ú·H�E*ÏT\WQ�eMEGÏTFIH � ú H_S��C�W�!�}÷EQdQ�SUÓ�QVYWõRQ�íVQ!ϳ a _S`Eb F ³ _V` »�ÐfÓ ÀDÔ ÂDÕ¬¹ Ô ÂDÕ¬ Ö 13 ù Ó ³7�3ÀDÔ ¿�Õ¬ Ä�¹�Ô ¿�Õ¬ ��:�CÀ Ô ¿±Õ¬ Ä4¹ Ô ¿±Õ¬ � Ö Á ú � ¿  � Ä � ��U!�

Ñ�JGÏIH_Ó�QBÏT\UEGÏ�õ2\WQ�S¾õRQBf,QFnÏI`WFT×½E�^TcKH�LNH_SWí�^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVS �3¹­¬H½ MnÄ�À®¬O½�Mº��×hg EVS°EVeCJ�`WS·ÏaªíVH_ÚVQS�×hg_� �WÜ� õRQ�Ó�EVS�õ2FIHKÏTQ;ÏT\UEGϳÍ�CÀ²¬4Ä�¹­¬<�2{º×H�'ª���Ä �:�3À®¬4Ä�¹­¬<�2{ÙØì�'ª�� � �ºbW�õ2\WQFTQ�õ2HKÏT\n× EGS,LyØ'õRQ�H_SULNH�Ó�E¯ÏIQ�ÏT\WQ�Ôü`WSUÓ}ÏIHKJ�SU^w³ûEVSULv� EV^¸Ôü`USUÓ}ÏIHKJ�SU^2JGÔ^ªh÷]ÑdJ¯õ�YNFTQ�Ó�EVcKcÔüFIJVeïÏI\WQ�^TÓEGc_HKSUí�^V�C�ºMº�!Y·�C�WÜ�REGSUL�ÏT\UQ�ÔüJVFIe3JGÔ�³ûEGSULv��ÏT\,E¯Ï2ÔüJVF´ ¿ ½$  ½ÅMWY

cKH_e:^T`Wf[×û½;Úz�'ª��@Ä cKH_e:^T`Wf{Øû½©Ú:� ª  �@Ä EV^�ª¡3 MnÄ

Page 28: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Û�Þõ2\WQFTQ ªT½ Î À ¬ ÁhÐK�3¹ ¬ �@ß�PJhJ�Ù·H_SWí*ÔüJVF2f[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó�JVFI×WHKÏI^¸H_S�E*SUQ�H_íV\h×,J�`WFI\WJhJhL�JGÔ�ÏT\WQ�^Tc_H_LNH_SWíM^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSPYUõ]Q�^TQ!ÏÀ Ô ¿�Õ¬ ½ À Ô ÂEÕ¬ ½ G À�Ä ¹ Ô ÂDÕ¬ ½ ¹ Ô ÂEÕ¬ ½�G¹7ßÎ `W×,^�ÏIHÄÏI`NÏTQ�L�HKS·ÏTJ'� ��U!�!YNÏT\UH_^¸ghH_Q�c�LW^�YWÏTJBcKJ¯õRQ^nÏ2JVFrLNQ�F¸H_SvªhYG ÀK½�:\¿�¿®×P� GªW�°Á=<6¿�¿o 9¿JÁ=<6¿¢Â8 ·ÂwÁ�¨��'ª  ��ÄG¹K½�:?Â�¿®×P� GªW�°Á=<�Â�¿o 9¿JÁ=<�Â4Â8 ·ÂwÁ�¨��'ª  ��Äõ2\WQFTQ GªV½ Ì G À  Á=ÐK�DG¹?��÷�ø¸\·`,^�YWõRQ�JV×NÏrEGH_SG¹B� éº<�Â�¿o 9¿�éº<�Â�Â* ·ÂH½;:!Â�¿®×?Û Ì �Ë<�¿4¿� 9¿EÁ?<�¿¢Â� ·Â�  Á=ÐnG¹ìÁ�¨��'ª��EÜLÁ ¨�� ª  �@ß � � � �Ñ�JVÏTQ¸ÏI\UE¯Ï?ÏI\WQ�FIHKí�\·Ï�\,EGSULB^TH_LNQ¸ÔüJ�F� 9¿P½� ·ÂH½ M�H�^�fWFIJVf[JVFTÏTH_JVSUEVchÏTJ{³7�DG¹B��fWc_JGÏTÏTQLBH_SL�HKí�`WFTQÛ��BEVSUL�^IÓ�EVcKQ�^2EV^�Ý G¹�E�^{G¹�3 MW÷

øxJöQ � fWc�EGH_S ÏT\WQ¾J�×U^nQFTÚ�QL LNghSUEVeBH_Ó^�JVÔ%Q�HKÏT\WQF�ÏI\WQ{�¯Ò�f,QFTH_JNLNH_ÓîJVF'bpÒ�f,QFTH_JNLNH�Ó�^nfUHKFrEGc×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�S�LNH�EGí�FIEVe J�×U^nQFTÚ�QLBH_Sk^��WYhõ]Q;Ó!J�SU^nH�LNQFR^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVS,^ JVÔ%�C� � ��ÔüJ�F) ·ÂH½Åsýé]s k{Þ½ MEV^�/ � QL�EGS,L�Ó!JVS,^nH�LNQ�F�ÏT\WQ�Q�ì[Q�Ó}Ï;JGÔ�Ú¯EGFIg·H_SWí\ ¿ ½ xYé{x9ß�ÏI\WFTJ�`WíV\]FQ�FIJU÷OlH_íU÷�Û�Uû^n\WJ¯õ�^^TÙVQ!ÏrÓr\WQ^;JVÔ ÏT\UQMcKQ�Ô�ÏnÒ�\UEGSUL¾^TH_LWQCÚ�Q�Fr^n`,^dÏI\WQBFTH_íV\·ÏTÒ�\UEVSULî^TH�LNQCÔüJVF�ÏT\UFTQQBLWHÄì�Q�FIQ�S·Ï�Ú¯EGc_`WQ^�JVÔxM÷�ø¸\WQ�EVSUEGc_gN^nH�^�JVÔ�/ � Q�L¾f,J�HKS·Ïr^�ÏT\UQ�S¾ÔüJVc_c_J¯õ�^�E�^nH_eBHKc�EGFCEGFIíV`WeBQS�Ï�ÏIJ�ÏT\UEGÏ*JVÔ]ÏI\WQîÜ�Ò�ÕeMEGf'EGFIH_^TH_SWíîH_S Î \WHKc<S SWHKÙ�J¯Ú½\WJVeBJNÓ!c_H_SWH_Ó�×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVSU^ � Ü6U+��÷¬ÿ]EVÓr\½ÏIHKeBQ�ÏI\WQ�^�ÏIFIEVHKí�\�ÏCcKH_SWQFIQ�fWFIQ^TQ�S·ÏTH_SWí�ÏI\WQ;cKQ�Ô�ÏnÒ�\UEGSUL�^nH�LNQ;fUEV^I^TQ^ ÏT\WFIJV`Wí�\�E%Ó�JVFISWQ�F]HKS�ÏT\WQ;íVFrEGfU\ûJGÔPÏI\WQ;FTH_íV\·ÏnÒ�\UEVSUL^TH_LNQ�õRQ�e%`,^�Ïd\,EpÚVQ�EBíVFrE�FHKSWíC×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�SP÷]bdc_^TJUYUHKS·ÏTQFI^TQÓ!ÏTH_JVSU^RÏIJ¯õREVFILU^O¹­¬i½ MCSUE¯ÏI`WFIEVcKc_gH_eCfUcKgîE�íVFIQEGÏTQF�Sh`We*×,QF;JVÔ]H_S·ÏTQ�Fr^TQÓ}ÏIHKJ�SU^�õ2HÄÏI\îÏI\WQBFIEVeCfx÷%ø¸\WQ�FIQ!ÔüJ�FTQCõRQCÓ�JVSUÓ�cK`ULWQ%ÏI\UE¯ÏÏT\UQ�×WHÄÔü`UFIÓE¯ÏTH_JVS�LNH�EGí�FIEVeïcKJhJVÙN^Rc_HKÙ�QT�H_íU÷ ÛºbN÷�Ñ�JVÏTQ;ÏT\UEGÏ2ÏT\WQ�LNJ�`W×Wc_Q�^nfUHKFrEGc�H�^¸HKSUÓ�JVeBfWc_Q!ÏIQV÷ê�Ô?H_SU^�ÏIQE�L�õ]Q*\UEVLîÓ!JVS,^nH�LNQ�FIQL�EûFIEpg�HKSîfUEGFrEGeBQ!ÏIQ�Fd^TfUE�Ó!Q�ÏI\UE¯Ï;fUEV^I^TQL�fWFIQÓ�H_^TQ�c_g�ÏI\WFIJV`Wí�\x+kÄ�slk¸ÏT\UQ�S�õ]Q�õRJV`Uc_Lz/USUL�ECf,QFnÔüQ�Ó}Ï�YUÓ!J�eCfUcKQ�ÏTQ�LNJ�`W×Wc_Q�^TfWH_FIEVct÷8 Q�õ2H_cKc�SWJ¯õØLWQ�FIHKÚ�QdÏI\WQ�^TÓEGc_HKSWí·^ JVÔxÏI\WQ�HKS·ÏTQFI^TQÓ!ÏTH_JVSU^]×[Q!Ï�õRQ�Q�S�ÏT\UQ�^TfWH_FIEVc[EVSUL�ÏT\WQVx�ÒE � H�^�H_S{/UíU÷�ÛWbW÷�ø¸\UQ^TQûHKS·ÏIQ�Fr^nQ�Ó}ÏTH_JVS,^�EGFIQMíVH_ÚVQS°×hg ÏT\WQ�f,J�HKS·ÏI^%HKS{/,íU÷�Û+U�EGÏ%õ2\WH�Ór\¾ÏT\WQc_Q!Ô�ÏnÒ�\UEVSULë^TH_LNQ�EGSUL¾ÏI\WQ�FIH_íV\·ÏnÒ�\UEGS,L°^TH�LNQ�JVÔ�Q�R[÷ �C� � ��×[QÓ�JVeBQMÏrEGSWí�Q�S·ÏY�õ2\WH�Ór\½ÔüFIJVe�ÏT\WQíVQJVeBQ!ÏIFTg�JGÔ�ÏI\WQ%FIH_íV\·ÏnÒ�\UEGS,L�^nH�LNQ%JNÓÓ!`WFr^dEGÏdÏT\UQCÓ�JVFISWQ�F�JVÔ�ÏT\WQCfWH_QÓ�Q�õ2H�^nQ*cKH_SWQEVF�Ôü`WS,Ó}ÏTH_JVS×2÷J8°Q�õ2HKc_cPFIQ!ÔüQF¸ÏTJCÏT\WQ�Ú¯EVcK`WQ�^2FIQ�c�E¯ÏTQ�LûÏIJCÏT\WQ�^nQ�f[JVH_S·ÏI^¸×hg�`U^TH_SWíCÏT\WQ�^T`W×U^IÓ!FIHKfWÏOÀr÷WFIJVe ÏI\WQûEGS,EGc_gh^TH�^�fWFTQ�^nQS·ÏTQL°H_S°ÏT\WQûfUFTQÚ·H_JV`,^�^nQ�Ó}ÏTH_JVS¾õRQMÙhSWJ¯õ ÏI\UE¯Ï)×¦à ªhYx\WQSUÓ!QÔüFIJVe3Q)R,÷P� � � � õRQ�JV×NÏrEGH_SPYNÏIJCc_J¯õRQ^nϸJ�FILWQ�F�ÐG¹­¬�éJ<@Â�¿� 9¿�éJ<@Â4Â8 ·Â�á;â6ª�¬ � �·Þ��õ2\WQFTQ ª ¬ ½ �ã<6¿4¿� 9¿EÁ=<6¿¢Â8 ·Â��  Á=ÐK�DG¹­¬<� � �W�º�EV^¸í�HKÚ�Q�S�×hgûQ�R[÷P�C�UÜ)�!÷ UFTJ�e3Q�R[÷P� �·Þ��REVSUL�Q�R[÷��C��Ûº�Rõ]Q;ÏI\WQ�S�JV×WÏIEGH_SPЪ ¬ é¸�ã<6¿�¿o 9¿EÁ=<6¿�Â* ·Â�� Âä ÛWv�~­å ½�âXª�¬ÍÁ=<�Â�¿o 9¿EÁ=<�Â�Â* ·Â � �Vݺ�Q�Q�S,Ó!QVY¯HKÔWõRQ Ú¯EGFIg�J�SWc_g� ¿ õ2\WH_cKQ]ÙVQ�QfWH_SWí�  / � Q�L�YGEV^xHKS�ÏT\WQ¸Ó�E�^nQ?JVÔNÏT\WQR^nfUHKFrEGc·LNH_EVíVFrEGeEVÓ!ÏT`UEVcKc_g�J�×U^nQFTÚ�QL HKS°ÏI\WQMQ � f[Q�FIHKeBQ�S·ÏrEGc Ó�HKFrÓ!`WHKÏYlõ]QûÓEGS¾Ó!J�SUÓ!c_`ULNQBÏI\UE¯Ï�ÏI\WQMÚ¯EGc_`WQ\ ¬ ¿ E¯Ïõ2\WH�Ór\�EGS�HKS·ÏTQFI^TQÓ!ÏTH_JVS�JNÓ�Ó!`UF2H_^¸í�HKÚ�Q�S�×·g�Ð ¬ ¿ á�æ�ª�¬7Áûv© ·ÂwÁhÚz�! ·ÂCª�¬¢Ä,ª ¬ Ä�  �

Page 29: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

Û��õ2\WQFTQ�æ EGSUL0v EGFIQdÓ!J�SU^nÏIEGS·Ïr^?QE�^nH_c_gCJ�×NÏIEVHKSUQLûE�^ Ó!J�e%×WH_SUEGÏTH_JVSMJGÔxÏT\WQ;Ó!JVS,^�ÏrEGS·ÏI^ HKSa�C�VÝ!�}÷

Î J%`WS·ÏIHKc<ªuç ·Ât�²Ht÷ QV÷�Ô²EGFRQ�SUJV`Wí�\BÔüFTJ�e ÏI\WQ�^Tc_H_LNH_SWí*f,J�HKS·Ï�� õRQ�íVQ�Ï ÏT\,E¯ÏRÏ�õ]J%^T`UÓÓ!Q^I^THKÚ�QH_S�ÏIQ�Fr^nQ�Ó}ÏIHKJ�SU^¸JVS�JVSWQ�^TH_LWQ�JGÔxÏI\WQ�^TfWHKFrEGcP^IÓ�EVcKQ�E�^�Ð ¬ 4 ¿¿ ¬ ¿ ½ ª�¬ 4 ¿EÁ¸v© ·Âª�¬ÍÁýv© ·Â { ª�¬ 4 ¿ª�¬ �CUºMº�lH_SUEVcKc_gûÔüFIJVe:ÏT\WQ*EGSUEVcKgN^TH_^¸FIQ�f[JVFTÏTQ�L�H_S�ÏT\UQ�fWFIQ�ÚhHKJ�`U^2^TQÓ}ÏIHKJ�S�õ]Q�ÙhSWJ¯õ«ÏT\UEGÏ�ª+à�Üë�¹ÏT\UQ�FIQ!ÔüJVFIQ�õ]Q�í�Q!ÏÐ ¬ 4 ¿¿ ¬ ¿ à ¹ ¬¹+¬ 4 ¿ ½ ÜOé Û¹e¬ÍÁöÛ �CUUÜ)�õ2\WQFTQU¹ ¬ H�^*ÏT\WQ�Sh`We%×[Q�FMJVÔ;^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WH_SWí°Ór\,EGFrEVÓ}ÏIQ�FIH_^TH_SWí�ÏT\UQ�c�EV^nÏMf,QFTH_JNL4JVÔ�ÏT\UQ�f,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVS¬`WSULNQFTí�JVH_SWí E°í�FIEWF�H_SWíý�tÓ!JVFISWQF��*EV^CõRQ�`USNÔüJVc�LëÏI\WQ�^TcKH�LNH_SWí¾JVFI×WHÄÏ�÷öÑdJGÏTH�Ó!Q�ÏI\UE¯Ï¹+¬ 4 ¿�½;¹+¬ÍÁöÛ*HKS�ÏI\WQ�LNJV`U×WcKQ�^TfWH_FIEVcPÓ!JVS,^nH�LNQ�FIQLa�²^TQ�Qì/Uí,÷2Ü�M!�}÷�b�c�^nJ,YNõ]Q�í�Q!Ï 4¬ 4 ¿�é� 4¬ ¬ é� ¬ � ¿ { ª�¬ 4 ¿Oéyª�¬ª ¬ é ª ¬ � ¿ { Ü�é U¹ ¬ ÁöÛ �CU·ÛW�õ2\WH�Ór\4Ór\UEVFIE�Ó}ÏTQFTH[F�Q�L°\WJ¯õ ÏT\WQ�HKS·ÏIQ�Fr^nQ�Ó}ÏTH_JVS,^�JGÔ2ÏI\WQ�^TfWH_FIEVc õ2HKÏT\4ÏT\WQ x�Ò�E � H_^*^TÓEGc_Q�EV^*õ]QEGfUfWFTJ·EVÓr\�ÏT\WQ�^TcKH�LNH_SWíBf,J�HKS·Ï�÷

i

E=E

E < E

E > E

s

s

s

v

®°¯>±!² ¦4³�Û�bN©:�·k�yÄs��¯orv�®%�t|~®pk�;_®¯or�t�pk�®*�~|~v�k,=P����qt|~{}��s²¶��¯orv�®%�t|~®pk�;K��w}�~|~®��~|~v�k,=xwry�k w � ;Ol�g*=or�Ud°|~���}orqt|~k�®Î JVeBQ?fWFIQ�c_H_eCH_SUEVFTg�S·`UeCQFTH�Ó�EVcGFIQ^T`WcÄÏr^PH_SULNH�Ó�EGÏTQ�ÏI\UE¯ÏlÏT\WQ�^nQ ^IÓ�EVcKH_SWí·^PEGFIQ?H_SULNQ�Q�L�JV×U^TQ�FIÚVQ�L

H_SÌÏI\WQë^ngN^nÏTQe ��Ü��õ2HKÏT\ fUEVFIEVeBQ!ÏTQF�ÚpEVcK`UQ^{�C�!�}÷ Z]JVSU^TH�LNQ�F�ÔüJVF�H_SU^nÏIEVSUÓ!Q°ÏT\UQ½íVFrE�F�H_SWí·^JNÓ�Ó�`WFTFIH_SWíîE¯Ï*ÏT\WQ�Ó!J�FTSWQFI^%JGÔ2ÏI\WQ �GÒ�f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Óû^TfWH_FIEVctY�c�EG×[Q�c_cKQ�LöÛ·Þ?Ä4�UÜûEGSULû�ºb�H_Sý�H_íU÷4Ü)MWYõ2\WH�Ór\½õ]QMõ2H_c_c SUEVeCQ�õ2HÄÏI\¾ÏT\WQ�^T`W×U^IÓ!FIH_fNÏI^�ÜWÄIÛ�EVSUL���FTQ�^nf[QÓ!ÏTH_ÚVQcKg�÷ Î H_SUÓ�QMÏT\WQ�Ó!Q�S·ÏIFTQûJVÔÏT\UQBLWJV`W×Wc_QM^nfUHKFrEGc�H�^�cKJNÓ�EGÏTQ�L EGÏVx k á:ÜÝnß ÝhÞ�bNY�õRQ*\,EpÚVQ� 9¿t½ xõ¿Héûx k ½ �\ß_Ü6UNÞ � Þ+U�EGS,L^THKeBH_c_EVFTc_g� ·ÂH½ ÜWß ��Û�M·Û���Ý\Ä� 4èO½ Üºß �UÜ�M � ÷�ø¸\UQ�SPY ·Â 9¿ ½ Mnß b·Þ+�\Ä 4è ·Â ½ÅM\ßµÞGÛõ2\WH�Ór\%Ó!J�eBfUEGFIQ?õRQ�c_c·õ2HKÏT\%ÏT\WQ]fWFIQLNH�Ó}ÏIQL�Ú¯EVcK`WQ�^PÔüFIJVe Q)R,÷��3U,Ü)��JVÔÍMW÷àb2EVSULgMW÷ � Þ¸FTQ�^nf[QÓ!ÏTH_ÚVQ�c_g�5¹ ¿ ½ÌÛ\ÄE¹  ½ U!�!÷?b�c�^nJ,Y 4è�éy ·Â  éy ¿ ½ÅM\ß �W�W�

Page 30: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

ÛGÝ

45 6

12 3

3 EE-21

- E-

E+ E

E E-E

-E-

+ E+

®°¯>±!² ¦4³KÛ/p·©�ª�v��nw}u2m��~k�stk ®pw}³p±p�~k ��mp|~q�or�N±p| yK³pq��noIst|~w}v�®p|µor{}q�oru � �P�pk |~v!s�k�q��tk���st|~w}vp��wryUst�pk�tmp|~q�or�~�n��d Ô� B[d Ç� w}±Vk¥��st�pk?���nor�~|~vp{}�^;Onp��=Porvp®�;in!�*= �õ2\WQFTQ�ÏI\WQ EVSUEGc_gN^nH�^�fWFIQLNH�Ó}Ïr^PE2Ú¯EGc_`WQ?JVÔ\M\ß �W�W�U÷Pø¸\WQ^TQ Ó�JVeBfUEGFIH�^nJ�SU^�EGFIQ�íVJhJNL�íVH_ÚVQS�ÏI\UE¯ÏxÏT\WQJVFI×WHKÏI^lEGFIQ?^�ÏIHKc_cVÔ²EVFPÔüFIJVe«ÏT\WQR^nc_H�LNHKSUíd^nJ�cK`WÏTH_JVSU^÷xbëeBJ�FTQ ÓEGFIQ!Ôü`Wc·EGSUL�Q � ÏTQ�S,^nH_ÚVQ Ó�JVeBfW`NÏrE¯ÏIHKJ�SJGÔ�ÏI\WQ^TQ�^IÓ�EVcKH_SWí�^�ÔüJVF?ÏI\WQìb¯Ò�f[Q�FIH_JhLWH_Ó2^TfWH_FIEVcUH�^?H_SûfWFIJVíVFIQ^I^�EGS,LBõ2HKc_c,×[QdFIQ�f[JVFTÏTQ�LCQ�c�^nQõ2\WQ�FIQV÷éxàëêPã�äQVWâTSÍhíìCãã�äQVWèGã�åUäQNø¸\WQ%EVSUEGc_gN^nH�^¸JGÔ�ÏT\UQ�fWFIQ�ÚhHKJ�`U^�^T`W×U^TQÓ!ÏTH_JVS�Ó�EVS�Q�EV^THKc_g�×[Q�Q � ÏIQ�SULWQL�ÏTJû^T\WJ¯õ«ÏT\WQ%Q � H_^nÏTQSUÓ!QJGÔ Î eMEVcKQ�\UJVFr^nQ�^n\WJhQ�LNghSUEVeCH�Ó�^dJVS" �^Tghe%×[JVc�^�õ2\WQFTQ¡ {�Cxt�2H�^2ÏT\UQ�eME � HKe*`We S·`Ue%×[Q�FdJVÔH_S�ÏIQ�Fr^nQ�Ó}ÏIHKJ�SU^;õ2HÄÏI\îÏI\WQBFIEVeCf JGÔRf,QFTH_JNLNH_ÓC^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSU^;õ2HKÏT\WH_S ÏT\WQM^TfWHKFrEGc�EGÏ�E�fUEVFnÏIH_Ó�`Wc_EVFìxÚ¯EGc_`WQ{�²Ó}Ô�÷�ÏI\WQ�Ó!J�FTFIQ^Tf,J�SULNH_SWí EVSUEGc_gN^nH�^*JGÔ Î \UHKc<S SUHKÙ�J¯Ú½\WJVeBJNÓ!c_HKSUH_Ó�×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�SU^ � Ü)����!÷4ê�ÏõRJV`Wc�LB^nQQ�e ÏT\UEGÏ�ÏT\WQ�FIQ!Ò�H_S¯ý�QÓ!ÏTH_JVSMeBQÓr\UEVSWH�^ne J¯ÚVQ�FEb�f[Q�FIH_JhLU^?Ó�EV`U^nQ�^�ÏT\UH_^?LWg·S,EGeBH_Ó^�ÏIJ�×,Q^nÏIEG×UcKQ�÷�ø¸\WQ%Ï�õRJ0R·`WQ�^�ÏIHKJ�SU^;cKQ�Ô�Ï�ÏTJ�×,QCQ � fWc�EGH_SWQL EGFIQ�ÏI\WQC^T`ULWLWQ�S�ý�`WeBf H_S·ÏTJûÏI\WH�^gbpÒGF�JVSUQE¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ!ÏTJVF2EGÏ�xÝ{ ��Û\ß �WU·Û*EGSUL�ÏT\WQT/,SWíVQFTQ�L�^nÏTFI`UÓ}ÏI`WFIQ;JVÔxÏI\WH_^dÓr\UEGJVÏTH�Ó;EGÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏTJ�F÷î Z�âºZ¤� 2 ��ï}òB�H; 1 (L����� �º�Ã��ó��+���Có 2 �W(+�WFIJVe#ÏI\WQMEGSUEVcKgN^TH_^�EVSUL�ÏI\WQBS·`UeCQFTH�Ó�EVc�Q�ÚhH_LWQ�SUÓ�Q*fWFIQ^TQ�S·ÏIQL�H_S ÏT\WQBfWFIQ�ÚhH_JV`U^�^TQÓ}ÏIHKJ�SU^;õ]QÓ�EVS�Ó�Q�FTÏIEGH_SWc_gûÓ!J�SUÓ!c_`ULNQ;ÏT\,E¯Ï�E*LWJV`W×Wc_Q�^nfWH_FrEGc�×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�S�LNH�EGí�FIEVe JGÔ·/UÚ�Q�f,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó�JVFI×WHKÏI^H�^RÓ�JhQ � H_^nÏTH_SWí*õ2HÄÏI\ûÏT\UQ;eMEVHKSû×UHÄÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVS�×WFIEVSUÓr\ûõ2\WQSûÏI\WQ;^TgN^�ÏIQ�eïQÚVJVc_`NÏIHKJ�S�ý�`WeBfU^RJVS·ÏTJÏT\UQÃbpÒGF�JVSUQ;EGÏnÏTFrEVÓ!ÏTJ�F¸LWQ�fWH�Ó}ÏIQL�HKS /Uí,÷ � ÷

bd^K/UFr^�ÏMÓ!J�S¯ý�QÓ!ÏT`WFIQL4HKS � bNY � ��Y õRQ�SUJGÏTQ�ÏT\,E¯Ïû^n`,Ór\îý�`WeBf¬JNÓ�Ó!`UFI^Cõ2\WQSëÏT\UQ�Ór\,EGJGÏIH_ÓQ�Ú�JVc_`NÏTH_JVS�FTQ�^n`UcÄÏIHKSWí*ÔüFIJVe ÏT\UQ;f[Q�FIH_JhL�LNJ�`W×Wc_HKSWíBÓ�E�^TÓEVLNQõ/UFr^�ϸíVFrE�FQ^ ÏT\WQ�FrEGeBf�Q � ÏTQ�FISUEVcKc_gV÷8 \WQSBÏT\WH�^�JNÓ�Ó�`WFI^YGÏI\WQ�Ór\UEVJGÏTH�Ó¸Q�Ú�JVc_`NÏTH_JVSB^nÏIEGFTÏI^�ÏIJ�ÔüQ�QcNÏT\UQ�HKS\`U`WQ�S,Ó!Q2JGÔ�ÏI\WQ¸Ô²EGeBH_cKgCJGÔ7/UÚVQf[Q�FIHKJNLNH�Ó�`WSU^nÏIEG×UcKQ�^TJVc_`NÏTH_JVSU^CJ�FTí·EGSWH�^nQ�LëEGFIJV`USUL½ÏI\WQ�LNJV`W×UcKQ�^TfWHKFrEGc¸×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVS'LNH_EVíVFrEGeFIQ�fWFIQ^TQ�S·ÏTQ�LîH_S �HKí,÷�ÝU÷�ø¸\WQ^TQMJVFI×WHKÏI^�EVFTQMÓr\UEVFIE�Ó}ÏIQ�FIH�FQL�×hg e%`WcKÏTH_fWc_Q ù Ò¥^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí·^�EGS,L^TÙ·H_fWfWH_SWí·^]\UQ�SUÓ�Q;E�^RÓ�JVSB/,FTeBQL�×hg�/UíU÷?Û � Y·ÏT\WQ�Sh`We%×[Q�F¸JVÔl^nÙhH_fWfWH_SWí�^Rf[Q�F¸f[Q�FIHKJNL�^T`ULWLWQ�SWc_g×[QÓ!J�eBQ^2LNHKì[QFTQS·Ï2ÔüFTJ�e�F�QFTJMEV^¸õRQ�Ó!FIJ�^I^]ÏT\WQ¸ý�`WeBf�×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�S�ÚpEVcK`UQV÷

Page 31: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

�WM

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39®°¯>±!² ¦4³VÛQ~h© u ³pu]±Gknq�wryW�t´|~m�mp|~vp{}�PwT�!k�ql�������¸mVk�qt|~w®p�xor��st�pk?|~vpmp³�sP�!w}� s�or{}k)dî|~���}orq�|~k�®f g,hb�c�^nJ½H_S �HKí,÷ Û·ÞhYRÏT\UQîÓr\UEGJVÏTH�Ó�E¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ}ÏIJVFM×[Q!ÔüJ�FTQ�EVSUL E¯Ô�ÏIQ�FMÏI\WQûý�`WeBf H�^�^T\WJ¯õ2S¬ÔüJVF

LNHKì[QFTQS·Ï�Ú¯EGc_`WQ^MJVÔ�ÏI\WQ�H_SWfW`NÏ�ÚVJVcKÏIEVíVQ'xM÷ 8 Q Ó�EGS ^TQ�Q�ÏI\UE¯ÏûÏI\WQîEGÏnÏTFrEVÓ!ÏTJ�FM×,Q�ÔüJVFIQ�ÏT\WQQ�SUc_EVFTí�Q�eBQ�S·Ï�ÏIEVÙVQ^?fWc_E�Ó!Q�YVH�^?c_JhÓE¯ÏIQLCHKSûE�FTQc_EGÏTH_ÚVQ�c_g%^TeMEGc_cU^TÓEGc_Q2JGÔ�ÏT\UQ�fW\UE�^nQ2fWc�EGSUQV÷�bd^ExH�^�H_SUÓ!FIQE�^nQ�L�^TÙhHKfUfWHKSUí�^2õ2H_cKcl×,Q�Ó!J�eCQ%eCJ�FTQ*EGSUL�eBJVFIQ�ÔüFIQ�R·`WQ�S·Ï�E�^¸ÏT\UQ�ÔüFIE�Ó}ÏrEGcxQ�LNíVQ�JVÔ�ÏT\WQÓr\UEVJGÏTH�ÓdEGÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏTJ�FREVfWfWFIJ�E�Ór\WQ^ eCJ�FTQ�EGS,LûeBJVFIQ�Ó�cKJ·^nQcKgBÏI\WQ�Ú�Q�FTÏTH�Ó�EVc,c_HKSUQ�Ó�JVFIFTQ�^nf[JVS,LNHKSUí�HKS/Uí,÷�Û�Þ*ÏIJ�^TÙhHKfWfUHKSWí,÷HQ�QSUÓ!Q*HKS�ÏT\WH�^�^TgN^�ÏIQ�e:ÏT\WQdý�`WeBf�ÏIJ�Ór\UEVJ�^�ÓEGSWSWJVÏd×[QCÓr\UEVFIE�Ó}ÏIQ�FIH�FQL×hg�EBc�EGFIíVQ!Ò¥^IÓ�EGc_Qd×UHÄÔü`WFrÓ�EGÏTH_JVS{�üQ�÷ í,÷�íVFrE�F�H_SWí?�?HKÔ�EM^TH_SWíVc_Q�f,QFTH_JNLNH_Ó�J�FT×UHÄÏ�÷ .dE¯ÏT\UQ�F�YNÏT\WQ¸ý�`UeCfJNÓ�Ó�`WFI^�EGÏ�ÏI\WQBfUEGFrEGeBQ!ÏIQ�F;Ú¯EGc_`WQCÔüJVF�õ2\WH�Ór\�ÏT\UQCH_ShÚ¯EGFIH_EVS�Ï�eBQE�^n`WFIQ%JVÔ ÏI\WQBf,J�FnÏIHKJ�SîJGÔ ÏT\WQÓr\UEVJGÏTH�Ó�E¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ}ÏIJVF*ÏT\UEGÏ�Ó!FIJ�^I^nQ�^*ÏT\WQ�^TÙhHKfWfUHKSWí¾c_HKSUQ�×[QÓ�JVeBQ^ûf,J·^nHKÏTH_ÚVQ�÷'ø¸\h`U^ME�Ó�Ó�`WFIEGÏTQcKgLNQ�ÏTQÓ!ÏTH_SWíMSh`WeBQ�FIH_ÓEGc_cKgBÏI\WQ�fUEVFIEVeCQ�ÏTQFRÚ¯EVcK`WQ�JVÔlÏI\WQ¸ý�`WeBf�H_^RÔüFrEG`UíV\·Ï2õ2HÄÏI\�LWH _ûÓ!`UcÄÏ�g�÷

0.4

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

0.7

0.75

0.8

11.8 12 12.2 12.4 12.60.4

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

0.7

0.75

0.8

11.8 12 12.2 12.4 12.6®°¯>±!² ¦4³]Û/�·© µ��porwrs�|~�;oIststq�or�¥stw}q2±Vk¥yKw}q�kq;�d j�l}�Cm lon8�)=]orvp®�oIyÄs�k�q©;Od j$l}�Cm n*�*�2=?st�pk�t³p®p®pk�vMk�vp�µorqt{}knu2k�v!s � �P�pkd|~vYð¯³�knv��nkdwryxs��pk2Íp�!k¥¶�º�w}vpk��µorq�{}k����nor�~kdoIs²s�q�or��stw}q¸|~� ���~kTorqt� ��|~��|~±��~k

Page 32: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

�WÜî Z á Z¤� 2 �w#E*?�º�6�4��D�� 1 �}òUó 1 òB�4�

0.35

0.4

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

0.7

0.75

0.8

11.7 11.8 11.9 12 12.1 12.2 12.3

3

sliding

1

2 64

5 7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

line

®°¯>±!² ¦4³TÛQ h©·µ��¯orwrst|~��oIs²s�q�or��stw}q�y_w}q<dkj"l�s*�°orvp®�ñ�j��}�Cm �0ò�w}vdst�pk^>P¶��t­x| st���p|~vp{ u�orm ��P�pk�Ípvp{}k�q�k�®��tstq�³���st³pqtk�|~�P�|~��|~±��~k�s�w}{}k¥st�pk�q�­x| s���st�pk?| s�k�q�oIstk��lwry,o?s���mp|~�nor�hstq�oI¿²k��¥s�w}q²�

ζ γ v

sliding line

l

i

5

4

3

2

1

l

l

l

l

®°¯>±!² ¦4³HÛ/«h©�����pk�u�oIst|~�lqtknm�q�k���k�v!s�oIst|~w}v�wry·st�pkxÍpvp{}k�q�k�®��tstq�³p�¥st³pq�kxwry·st�pk�oIs²stq�or�¥s�w}q�­x�pk�vw}±���k�qt�!k�®�w}vds��pk�>P¶��t­x| st���p|~vp{Ru�ormø¸\WQ]^nÏTFrEGSWí�Q?E¯ÏTÏTFrEVÓ}ÏIJVFPFIQ^T`WcKÏTH_SWí2ÔüFIJVe«ÏT\WQ]eBQÓr\UEVSWH_^Te LNQ^IÓ!FIHK×[QL%EG×[J¯ÚVQ�\UE�^�Y�ÔüJVFlÚ¯EGc_`WQ^

JGÔ�x Ó!c_J�^TQ�ÏIJ x k Y�E�ÚVQFTg�LNH�^�ÏIHKS,Ó}ÏTH_ÚVQt/USWí�Q�FIQL�^nÏTFI`UÓ!ÏT`WFIQV÷�ø¸\WQCE¯ÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏIJVF;H_^�fWFIQ^TQ�S·ÏTQ�L�HKS/Uí,÷�ÛW��H_SMÏT\WQ;Ó�E�^nQ�JVÔ°x ½ �!bBß MY� EGS,L:s ½«ÛVÛBß MY�4ÏIJVíVQ�ÏT\WQF?õ2HKÏT\�E%^nQ)R�`UQ�SUÓ�QdJGÔ�HKÏTQFIEGÏTH_JVSU^JGÔ�EB^nH_SWíVc_Q�f,J�HKS·Ï�÷EWJVF¸ÏI\WH�^�^�ÏIFT`,Ó}ÏT`UFTQ�ÏT\WQ�×,EV^TH_Ó�ÔüQEGÏT`WFIQ^2ÓEGS�×,Q�LWQ^IÓ!FIHK×[QL�^TÓr\UQ�eME¯ÏIH_ÓEGc_cKgEV^�H_S_/Uí,÷%ÛGÝUY[õ2\UQ�FIQ9ó6¬�ÄõÀ�½3ܺß�ß·��FTQfWFIQ^TQ�S·Ï;E�^nQ)R�`UQ�SUÓ�Q*JVÔE/USWí�Q�Fr^dQ�EVÓr\�JVÔ õ2\WH�Ór\î\UE�^;EÔüFrEVÓ}ÏrEGc�ÔüJ�FTe H_SëÓ!FIJ�^I^�Ò¥^nQ�Ó}ÏIHKJ�SP÷�þ�S°ÏT\UH_^C^TÓr\UQ�eME¯ÏIH_ÓMEVS½HÄÏIQ�FrE¯ÏTQMõ2\UH_Ór\½\UE�^%E�^TQ�R·`WQSUÓ!QûJVÔù Ò¥^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WHKSUí�^�J�S ÏI\WQûFrEGeBfPY�\UEV^�HÄÏr^T/UFr^�Ï*^Tõ2HKÏIÓr\WH_SWí�E¯Ï%E�f[JVH_S·Ï%JVSºóC¿¯YlHKÏI^*^nQ�Ó!JVS,L J�Sºó�ÂGY

Page 33: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

��ÛHKÏI^%ÏT\WH_FIL4JVS?ó è EGSUL4Ó!JVS·ÏIHKSh`WQ�^%J�S½ÏT\WH�^C^nQ)R�`UQ�SUÓ�Q�`WS·ÏTH_c¸HÄÏCcKQ�EpÚVQ�^�ÏT\UQ�FrEGeBf4EGS,L½FTQ�ÏT`WFISU^ÏT\UFTJ�`WíV\�ÏT\WQ�E�Ó}ÏIHKJ�S�JVÔxÏT\UQ�eBEVf

³ a _S`Eb ÷ø¸\WQ�FIQ�EGFIQ�Ï�õRJBLNH_^nÏTH_SUÓ!ÏTH_ÚVQ�ÔüQEGÏT`WFIQ^¸JVÔlÏI\WH�^�^TÓr\UQ�eME¯ÏIH_Ó�üH�� Q�EVÓr\�JGÔxÏI\WQT/USWí�Q�Fr^¸H_^2EM^nÏTFrEGH_íV\·Ï¸cKH_SWQ�JVÔ�LNQ6/USWQL�í�FIE�LNHKQS·Ï@��üH_H�� ÏI\WQ�/USWíVQFI^lõ2\WQS*fWFIJGý�Q�Ó}ÏIQL�×,EVÓrÙ�H_S�ÏIQ�Fr^nQ�Ó}Ï�E¯Ï?Edf[JVH_S·Ï�JVS�ÏI\WQ2^nc_H�LNHKSUí�c_HKSUQ¸EGÏ�E�ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGí�QÚ¯EGc_`WQ+ôKôýòû�üQÚVQ�S�ÏT\UJV`Wí�\�HKÏTQFIEGÏTQ�^¸JVSWc_gûc_HKQ�JVS�ÏI\WQT/USWí�Q�Fr^ ÔüJ�F�¹zðûò�÷W`WFTÏT\WQF2Sh`WeBQ�FIH_ÓEGcPÓ�EVc_Ó�`Wc�E¯ÏTH_JVS,^R^T\WJ¯õÌÏT\UEGÏdEV^�x|3 x k# ÏI\WQ�íVFrEVLNH_Q�S·Ïr^]JVÔlÏI\WQT/USWí�Q�Fr^¸^�ÏrEpgMÏT\WQ�^IEGeBQY�# ô*ÏIQ�SULW^2ÏTJKò�÷8 Q�SWJ¯õ eMEVÙVQMÏI\WQMÔüJVc_c_J¯õ2HKSWí EV^I^nQFnÏIHKJ�SîÏI\UE¯Ï�Y�HÄÔ� ¬ H�^�ÏI\WQûíVFrEVLWHKQS�Ï�JVÔ2ÏT\WQ:/USWíVQFeó ¬

ÏT\UQ�S ¿ ½ Üs é ~ �Û+ó Ä �CUº�º�  ½ Üs Á ÜÛ+ó ÜÜë¡~ � ÁØÜë¡~ 4 Ä �CUWU!� è ½ Üs é Ü

Û+ó ÜÜë¡~ � ÁØÜë¡~ 4 ÁØÜë]~ � Ä �CU!bW��CU � �

õ2HKÏT\�EGS�JV×hÚhHKJ�`U^2Ó!J�S·ÏTH_S·`,E¯ÏTH_JVS�JGÔ�ÏT\WH�^�^TQ�R·`WQSUÓ!Q�÷øxJ�^nQQ%õ2\hg�ÏT\WH�^;H_^dÏT\UQCÓEV^TQ*Ó!J�SU^TH_LNQFdÏI\WQCeCJVÏTH_JVS�JVÔ f[JVH_S�Ïr^dJ�SîE�^�ÏIFIEVSWíVQ%EGÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏTJ�F÷

ø¸\WH�^Cõ2HKc_c¸Ï�ghfWH_ÓEGc_cKg½H_SUÓ�cK`ULWQ�f[JVH_S·ÏI^Bõ2\WH�Ór\4H_eBfUEVÓ!Ï*ÏI\WQ�FIEVeCföFTQf,Q�E¯ÏIQLNc_gë^n`,Ór\ëÏT\,E¯ÏCÏT\WQÚ¯EGc_`WQ^�JGÔ�À ¯ EGSUL{¹ ¯ E¯Ï�ÏI\WQûÏIJVf¾JGÔ¸ÏT\UQûFIEVeBf¾EVFTQMQÚVQSWcKg°LNH�^�ÏIFTH_×W`NÏIQL½EG×[JV`WÏ�ÏT\WQ�JVFIHKí�HKSP÷Ñ�J¯õ Ó�JVSU^TH�LNQ�F�ÏT\WQCf[JVH_S�Ïyõö ½ ³ a _V`Db �CMnÄ4Mº�!÷�ê�Ôwx3EGS,L_s LNHKì[QF�ÔüJ�FTe x k EGSUL"s k ÏI\WQ�SîÏT\WH�^f[JVH_S�Ï�õ2H_cKc?Ï�g·fUH_ÓEGc_cKg�SUJGÏ�×,QûEGÏ�ÏT\WQB×[JGÏnÏIJVe�JGÔ ÏI\WQMFrEGeBfý�t^nQQ�/UíU÷��WM!�}÷ Î ÏIEVFnÏIHKSWí�EGÏUõö E

γ ζ

v=i=

continued backwards

i=i

i=i

v=

2

1

z~

i= isi *

OFF state trajectory

trajectoryON state

OFF

®°¯>±!² ¦4³�9/Üh©?�hw�noIst|~w}v�wryVst�pk�mGw}|~v!sPoIs�­x�p|~���´c)jU÷?orvp®���³p±���k w³�knv!sP|~v!s�k�q��tk���st|~w}vp�Por�~w}vp{st�pk?q�oru2mÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIg%H_S_�²^IEpg\��ÏT\WQ�þì ^nÏIEGÏTQdH_S·ÏTQFI^TQÓ!ÏI^?EGÏRE�c�E¯ÏIQ�F f[JVH_S·Ï÷�ê�ÔxÓ!J�S·ÏTH_S·`UQLB×UE�ÓrÙ·õ¸EGFrLW^uõö

Page 34: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

�W�õ2H_cKcNc_HKQ2J�SCEVSMþì �^nÏIEGÏTQRÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏIJVFIg�õ2\WH_Ór\CõRJV`Wc�L%\,EpÚVQRHKS·ÏTQFI^TQÓ!ÏTQ�L�ÏI\WQ¸FIEVeCfBE¯Ï?E;ÚVJ�cÄÏrEGí�Qô�LNHKì[QFTQS·Ï;ÔüFIJVe ò�YPõ2\UQ�FIQ*ÏI\WQûÓ!`UFTFIQ�S·Ï�JGÔ ÏI\WQû^TcKH�LNH_SWí�^nJ�cK`NÏIHKJ�S H�^TÀH½ À k ÷�þ�×U^nQFTÚ�Q�ÏI\UE¯ÏEV^eô�3 ò�Y9À¡3 À k EVSUL��Cx:Ä4sV�a3 � x k Ä4s k �}÷�ø¸\WH�^�f[JVH_S·Ï%FIQ�fWFIQ^TQ�S·ÏI^;ÏI\WQûeBQEVS½f,J�HKS·Ï%JVÔù Ò¥^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WHKSUí�^¸JGÔlÏTFrE¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏTJ�FTH_Q^RJ�S�ÏI\WQ�^�ÏIFIEVSWíVQ�EGÏnÏTFrEVÓ!ÏTJ�F÷Z]JVSU^TH_LWQ�F�SWJ¯õ¬EGSBEpÚVQ�FrEGí�Q?ÏIFIEGý�QÓ}ÏIJVFIg�JVS*ÏT\UQ�E¯ÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏIJVF�ÏT\,E¯Ï ù Ò¥^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WQ^�EGÏE¹K½;ô;õ2HKÏT\Ó!`UFTFIQ�S·Ï�À k Á ªh÷?ø¸\WQT/UFr^�Ï�^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\�JVS�ÏT\WQ�FrEGeBf�H_^¸ÏI\WQ�S�EGÏ2ECc�E¯ÏIQ�F¸ÏTH_eBQ%Û/ªWë¡~ � E¯Ï�Ú�JVcKÏIEVíVQ

¹K½øôHÁ Û/ªó~ � Äõ2HKÏT\�Ó!`WFIFIQ�S·Ï À ¿ ½ Û/ªó~ � s é ª�Á À k ß8 Q�^TQ�Q;ÏT\,E¯Ï�Q�c_H_eCH_SUEGÏTH_SWí\ª%õRQ�\UEpÚVQ

À ¿ ½�� Üs é ~O�Û�ó � �C¹ÃéºôW�°Á À k

ø¸\WH�^2íVH_ÚVQ�^]ÏT\WQ�Q)R�`,E¯ÏTH_JVS�JGÔ�ÏT\UQõ/,FI^nÏ�/USWí�Q�F�÷?ø¸\WQ�SWQ � Ïd^Tõ2HKÏIÓr\�H_^2EGϹK½øôHÁ Û-ªó~O� Á Û/ªó~Q4õ2HKÏT\�Ó!`WFIFIQ�S·Ï ÀÒÂ�½ Û-ªó~O�9s Á Û-ªó~Q4Js Á ªPÁ�À k^TJ*ÏI\UE¯Ï ÀÒÂH½�� Üs Á Ü

Û+ó ÜÜë¡~��zÁØÜë]~Q4 � �C¹géJôº�9Á À k

íVH_ÚhHKSUí�ÏI\WQBQ�R·`UE¯ÏIHKJ�SîJVÔ ÏT\UQB^TQÓ�JVSUL_/USWí�Q�F�÷%ø¸\WH�^�EGFIíV`WeBQS�Ï�Q � ÏIQ�SULW^;ÏIJ�EVcKc /,SWíVQFI^÷%ø¸\WQÔüFrEVÓ}ÏrEGc�^�ÏIFT`UÓ!ÏT`WFIQ%JVÔ�ÏT\WQBEVÓ!ÏT`UEVc·/USUíVQ�Fr^�H_^;LN`WQ%ÏTJ�^TeMEGc_c�Ór\,EGJGÏIH_Ó�ÚpEVFTH�E¯ÏIHKJ�SU^�H_S�ÏI\WQCE�Ó}ÏI`UEGcf[JVH_S�Ï�JVÔ�^Tõ2HÄÏrÓr\WH_SWíMEG×[JV`NÏ2ÏI\WQ�eBQEGSx÷WJVF�x ½Å�ºbBß MY� õ]Q�\UEpÚ�QdÏI\UE¯Ï�ôq{ ÜVܺßKÜ�EGSUL�ÏT\UQ�EV×,J¯Ú�Q�Ú¯EVcK`WQ�^¸EGíVFIQ�Q�Ó!c_J�^TQ�c_gMõ2HKÏT\�ÏT\WQÓ�EVc_Ó�`Wc�E¯ÏTQ�L�EGÏnÏIFIE�Ó}ÏTJ�FI^÷ù à l*å,â�è-PtçUN�é²å[âTNÎ J�eCQ�EGSUEVcKg·ÏTH�Ó�EVcWQ � fWc�EGS,E¯ÏTH_JVSBJVÔ�ÏT\WQ�SUJVSWc_HKSUQEGF ×,Q\UEpÚhHKJ�`WF?JGÔ�ÏI\WQ�Õ�Z2Ö¯Õ�Zö×W`UÓrÙBÓ!J�S·Ú�Q�FTÏTQF\UE�^2×,QQ�S�J�`NÏTc_H_SWQL�÷2ø¸\WQ%HKeBf[JVFTÏIEGS,Ó!Q�JVÔ�LWH_^IÓ!J�S�ÏIHKSh`WJ�`U^2fW\UQ�SWJ�eCQSUEM^T`UÓr\�EV^2í�FIEWF�H_SWíûEGS,L^TcKH�LNH_SWí�\UE�^�×,QQ�SëQ � fWc_EVHKSUQL¾EGSUL°ÏI\WQûQ � H�^nÏTQ�S,Ó!QûJVÔ2E�LWJV`W×Wc_Q�^TfWH_FIEVc?×WHKÔü`WFIÓE¯ÏIHKJ�SëLNH_EVíVFrEGeeBJGÏIHKÚ¯E¯ÏIQLBEGS,EGc_g�ÏIH_ÓEGc_cKg�÷�ø¸\UQ¸Ôü`WSULWEVeCQS·ÏIEGc,SUE¯ÏI`WFIQRJVÔ�JV`WF?EVSUEGc_gN^nH�^�^�ÏIFTJ�SWíVc_g%^T`WíVí�Q^nÏI^�ÏI\UE¯ÏÏT\UQ^TQ�ÔüQE¯ÏI`WFIQ^ûEVFTQ�ÏIJ½×,Q�ÔüJ�`WSUL¬H_SØE¾e%`UÓr\'õ2H�LNQ�F�Ó�c_E�^T^BJVÔ�fWHKQ�Ó!Qõ2H_^TQ�^neBJhJGÏI\ ^ngN^nÏTQ�e�÷ø¸\WQ�íVQSWQ�FrEGc_H�^TEGÏTH_JVS½JGÔ�ÏT\WQ�^nQ�fW\UQ�SWJ�eCQSUEîÏTJ¾JGÏI\WQ�FL-�J¯õRQ�F*ÿ cKQ�Ó}ÏIFTJ�SWH_Ó^BÓ!JVShÚ�Q�FTÏTQ�Fr^%^T\UEVcKc×[Q*EVLULNFTQ�^T^TQL�H_S�Ôü`WÏT`WFIQ%õRJVFIÙ�÷db�c�^nJ,Y[^TgN^�ÏIQ�eM^�JGÔ�ÏT\UQ�ÔüJVFIe �tÛº�2õ2HKÏT\ E�^neBJhJGÏI\î^nõ2HKÏIÓr\UHKSWí^THKí�SUEGc¸H_SU^�ÏIQE�L4JVÔdÏT\UQ�FrEGeBf¬Ó!JVS,^nH�LNQ�FIQLö^n\UJV`Wc�L4×[Q�^�ÏI`ULNH_QL¬H_S¬LNQ�ÏIEVHKc�^�÷¸8°Q�Ó�JVS¯ý�Q�Ó}ÏI`WFTQÏT\,E¯ÏdÔüJ�F;^T`UÓr\î^TgN^�ÏIQ�eM^2ÏI\WQCHKS·ÏTQFTS,EGcxí�FIEWF�H_SWíMfW\WQSWJVeBQSWJVS�õ2H_c_cl×[Q*FIQ�fUc_E�Ó!QL�×hg�^�ÏrEGSULUEGFrL^IEVLWLNc_Q!Ò�SWJNLNQ�×WHKÔü`WFrÓ�E¯ÏIHKJ�SU^÷�ø¸\UQ^TQ�EVSUL�JGÏI\WQ�F2H�^T^T`WQ�^2EGFIQdÏI\WQ�^n`U×Ný�QÓ!Ï�JGÔ�Ó!`WFIFTQS·ÏRFIQ^TQEVFIÓr\P÷

Page 35: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

��Uì�è)qPâ�åMI\PChhæUS7hMW hhâ�ã@Nø¸\WQ¬EG`NÏI\WJVFr^�õRJV`Wc�L c_HKÙ�QëÏIJØÏT\,EGSWÙ Õ�F÷ �;Q�FrEGFrL�þ�cKH_Ú¯EGF�YÃN�SUHKÚ�Q�Fr^nHKÏIEGÏa-�JVc_HKÏTQÓ�SWH�Ó�E LNQZRE¯ÏrEGc_`WShg�EUY�ÔüJVF�ÏI\WQMFTQfWFIJhLW`UÓ}ÏIHKJ�S JVÔ%/Uí·^�÷�Ü)MWY?Ü�ÜBEVSUL°\WH�^�Ù·H_SUL°\WQcKf½EGS,L°E�LNÚhH_Ó�QV÷ûbdc_^TJUYD�LWO¬H�^?í�FIEGÏTQ!Ôü`UcWÏTJCÕdF�÷JWFrEGSUÓ�Q^IÓ!J¡�?E�^TÓEWYº,EVÓ�JVcKÏ?�E�LNH[ê¥SWí�Q�íVSUQ�FIH_EUYWN�SWH_ÚVQFI^THKÏIE\S·LNH Î EGc_Q�FISWJUY^TQLNQ�LNHxORQSWQ�Ú�Q�S·ÏTJCÔüJVF¸ÏI\WQ�ÔüFI`WHÄÏTÔü`WcxLNH�^IÓ!`U^I^nH_JVS,^¸JVS�ÏT\WQ�Õ�Z2Ö¯Õ�ZØÓ�JVShÚVQFnÏIQ�F¸fWFIJV×Wc_Q�e�÷

Page 36: di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997 ...research-information.bristol.ac.uk/files/2995268/bcanm_97r9.pdf · di Bernardo, M., Budd, C., & Champneys, AR. (1997). Grazing,

�ºbú hMKGh·ä+h·â�èWhMNf �0hìµ��pq�|~�U��³p®p®¸orvp®�(¯k��~| ¼]j�³�¼ � µ��¯oIs²s�k�q�|~v�{?orvp®¸q�k��µoIstk�®R±Gk��¯on�|~w}³pq[|~v]|~u2m¯or�¥sUw}����|~�~�µoIs�w}qt� ��û �Âü�þýÈÿ��²Æ}Ê��±ý��� �!Æ0��� � ÇTÂV�TÈ«�� � ÊGÉ � Ê���Qlon���Ý l�g�s �@l}�����W�����on �f �,h �R� µ��¯or´�q�or±porqts��!��� � ÜWw�®p®¯orqT�xorv�®�� � ��orvpk�q_¿²k�k � ��| y_³pqt�noIs�|~w}v�±Gkn�pon�|~w}³pq�wry�s���k�±p³p��´M��w}v!�!knq²s�k�q �������� ÿ��²Æ}Ê��¥Æ!ÇTÈ_ � Ê�� � Ê û���� ��� � � ��ÇnÈ�� � ʯÂ_Ç����h�}��Ý n*l�� �8n�n���W������g �f l,h�� � � � � � jlkTorv�k�orv�®Bj � µ ��� oru2|~�~� � ��vpor� ���t|~�T�N�t|~uR³p�µoIst|~w}vCorv�®Ck¥¼�mGk�q�|~u2k�v!s�or�[�tst³p®��*wryP���¯orw}�R|~v�st�pk±p³���´���w}v!�!k�qtstknq ���������Cû ��� ��� � � ��ÇTÈ�� � ʯÂ_Ç��!��ÅY��ÇnÂ_Æ0� Â"��È#�%$ � ÊE�®� �5�TÊGÇã�T�¯m¯or{}k��rn*���&�8n*�}���N������� �f noh�� � � � � � j�knorvpkMorvp® j � µ �!� oru2|~�~� � ª�v��ts�or±p|~�~| s��!�]�t³p±�¶��porq�u2w}vp|~���T� orv�® ���porw}�%|~vîmGwT­�k�q�k��~k��¥s�qtw}vp|~��²���²s�k�u2� �'������� ÿ��²Æ}Ê��¥Æ!ÇTÈ_ � Ê�� � Ê û���� ��� � � ��ÇnÈ�� � ʯÂ_Ç����/s)Ý ��g�� ���g}���N������� �f s,h�� � ®p|p��knqtv¯orq�®�wp�!� � � � µ��¯oru2mpvpk¥��T�0( � ��orqtwry�or�~wp�*� � ���~|~k��~u2wp�}orvp®f( � *�or�t�no ��u w}vp�~|~v�kTorqWmp��knv�w}u2knvpo|~v?���~w}��k�® �~ww}m?®p�4¶I®p��±p³���´���w}v��!k�qtstk�q ��û � � Dz�²��É!ÂÄÊË(�*),+ � �.-0/21�) � Ê¡� ÂÄÊ­��Æ��*+2�}ÊGÆ}ÃRÂKÇ �,ÂKÊ � � ��ÇnÈ�� � ʯÂKÇ�°����È«�TÃ���·��Ý s��&�@s�g��N������g �f g,h�� � ®p|W��k�q�vporq�®pwp�Gz � (¯w}����or�n�.� �Y¬ �~| �}orqn�Gorvp®u( � *[or���no � �k���w}vp®¯orqt��±p| y_³�q��noIs�|~w}v���orvp®���|~{}��mGknqt|~w®�|~�w}qt±p| s��[|~v¸�!w}� s�or{}k���w}v!s�qtw}�~�~k�®d±�³p��´2��w}v��!k�q²s�k�q �%� ʯȫ� �¥ÊGÆ}È� � ÊGÆ0�.3 ��4 �¥ÊGÆ0� � � 5x � 4 �²Ç�Æ}È� � Ê���Æ}ÊGÉ6$ ��Æ � �1üÈ � Æ¥Å!ÅY��Æ(�87I�U�����!� �f ��h�� � ®p|���k�q�vporq�®pwp��( � ��orq�wry_or�~wp�?� � ���~|~kn�~u2wp�Uorv�®n( � *�or�t�To �:9 ³¯or�t| ¶�mGk�q�|~w�®p|~�2±Gkn�pon�|~w}³pq��¸|~vC®p�4¶I®p���w}v!�!knq²s�k�qt� ���������Cû ��� � � � � ��ÇTÈ�� � ʯÂKÇ �!��ÅY��ÇTÂKÆ�� Â"��È;$ � ÊE�®� �5�TÊGÇã�T�h������g �f �,h�� � ®p|U��k�q�v¯orqt®pwp�°( � ��orqtwry�or�~wp�-� � ���~|~k��~u2wp�Gorvp®{( � *�or�t�no � ��­x| st���p|~vp{}�n�·±�| y_³pqt�noIs�|~w}vp��orvp®����¯orw}��|~v®p�4¶I®p�?��w}v!�!knq²s�k�qt� � ª�z[z,z��Nq�orvp��or�¥st|~w}vp�xw}vVµ�|~q���³p| st�Porvp®��!���²s�k�u2��¶,ªGÝ](¯³pvp®poru2knv!s�or�·�P�pk�w}qt��orvp®�lmpmp�~|~�noIs�|~w}v��2;Äs�w�orm�mVknorqD=¥�h������g �f �,hd� � ( � (W|~�~|~mpmGwT� � +? <�� �5�nʯÈ�Â_Æ0� ��= 4 Æ!È_ � Ê�� � ÂÄÈV�'+�Â"�¥Ç � ʯÈ_ÂKÊ 4>�(4 � �  Ëj�ÈV��Æ}ÊGÉ?�VÂKÉ�� � �%� �~³!­�k�q��l�Tor®�knu2|~�Ü,q�k����n�·���}�}� �f ���,h;� � (¯w!or�~k � ��v¯or� ��st|~�Tor�,®pk¥s�k�qtu2|~v¯oIs�|~w}v*wryP±p| yK³pq��noIst|~w}vp�?|~vCorv*|~u2m¯or�¥s?w}����|~�~�µoIs�w}q � û �Âü�þý�ÿ��²Æ}Ê��±ý ��� ��ý� � Çjý@� � ÊGÉ � Ê���Qlon���Ý l�s�l �@l�gonp�W�����on �f �}�0h;� � (¯w!or�~k orvp®�� � � � ��|~�t�pw}m � ��| y_³pqt�noIs�|~w}vp�x|~v�|~u2m¯or�¥sxw}����|~�~�µoIstw}q�� � ) � Ê¡� ÂKÊ­��Æ(�A+2�}ÊGÆ}ÃRÂKÇ ���Qg)Ý �}��s �������������on �f �n�,hdz � (¯w}����or�Porvp®�� �Q¬ �~| �rorq � ��st³p®���wryh���¯orw}�P|~v¸s��pk�±p³p��´¸��w}v!�!k�qtstknq �?������� ÿ��tÆ}Ê��¥Æ!ÇnÈ� � Ê�� � ÊB$WÂC�²Ç 4 ÂÄÈ��Æ}ÊGÉD�°����È6�TÃ2�!E ��F�G@4 ÊGÉ!Æ!Ãf�TʯÈ�Æ0�4ÿO�Y� � �®�dÆ!ÊGÉHPÅ!Å­� ÂKÇ�Æ}È� � Ê����/n*l)Ý~��l ���s��h������g �f ��l,hHÜ � ��or�tm¯orq�®���� ��� ormpq�or����orvp®?� �8u |~��w}�~|~� � ��| y_³pqt�noIs�|~w}v¸m��pk�vpw}u2k�v¯o�vpknorq��pw}u2w��n�~|~v�|~���t��tstknu2��ÝWo�s�­�wr¶m¯orq�oru2k¥s�k�qlorv¯or� ���t|~� � 3Yý��VÈ�Æ}È�ý û �����±ý~�/l�s)Ý g}�!�����r�!��N���}�on �f � nohHÜ � ���~knv�®p|~vpvp|~vp{¸orvp®Vµ � ��m¯orq�qtwT­ � �·w�nor�Norvp®�{}�~w}±¯or�h±Gk��¯on�|~w}qxvpknorql�pw}u2w����~|~vp|~��w}qt±p| s�� � 3 ��4 �¥ÊGÆ0� � ��VÈ�Æ}È�ÂC��È�ÂKÇ�Æ0� û �Y����Â_Ç����/l�s)Ý gon*s �@g���g��N���}�on �f ��s,h�� � � � j � ÜWwn­�k��~� � ���!��±�q�|~®du2k�st�pw�®dyKw}qPvpw}vp�~|~vpknorqPk w³poIs�|~w}vp� � ª�võÜ � �lor±�|~vpwT­x| stº!�pkn®�| s�w}qn�I) 4 Ã����¥Â_Ç�Æ0�J �nÈV� � É��È� � �!) � Ê¡� ÂKÊ­��Æ(�!N� Ë��LK��²Æ}ÂKÇ � =�4 Æ}È� � Ê�� � ��w}q�®�w}v�orvp®���qtknor���·�h���!�o� �f ��g,hìµ � �R� �x�tk � µ��¯orw}�·yKq�w}u�oP±�³p��´��²­l| st���p|~v�{lqtkn{}³��µoIs�w}qhw}mGk�q�oIst|~vp{x|~v�®p|~����w}v!s�|~v�³pw}³p�Nu2w�®pk ��� ʯȫ� �¥ÊGÆ}È� � ÊGÆ0�3 ��4 �¥ÊGÆ0� � �H$WÂ"�²Ç 4 ÂÄÈ2ÿ �Y� � �®�dÆ}ÊGÉ%�Å�Å­� Â_Ç�Æ}È� � Ê����G�}�)Ý ��g�l ��!�r���W�����on �f �T��hìµ � �R� �P��k � (W�~|~m¬±�| y_³pqt�noIs�|~w}v orv�®'���¯orw}��|~v¬s���q�k�k¥¶��ts�oIs�kî±Gww}�²s��²­x| s�����|~vp{½q�k�{}³p�µoIstw}q�� �M�N�����ÿ��²Æ}Ê��¥Æ!ÇTÈ� � Ê�� � ÊO$WÂ"�²Ç 4 ÂKÈ#�;Æ}ÊGÉP�°����È6�nÃ�?E ��F�G�4 ÊGÉ�Æ}Ãf�TʯÈ�Æ0��ÿO�Y� � �®�ûÆ}ÊGÉQPÅ!Å­� ÂKÇ�Æ}È� � Ê�����np��Ý~��g ���l��h�����on �f �n�,hìµ � �R� �P��k?orvp® ¹ � µ � � � µ��¯orv � ª�vp�ts�or±p|~�~| s��;orvp®;���¯orw}��|~v�oR��³pq�qtk�v�s²¶�u2w�®pk���w}v�stq�w}�~�~k�®���³p´���w}v!�!knq²s�k�q ��������Cû ��� ��� � � ��ÇnÈ�� � ʯÂ_Ç�����ÅY��ÇnÂ_Æ0� Â"��È#�?$ � ÊE�®� �5�TÊGDz�n�·�}�}�}�¥¶��}�}�T��Ý g��}� �@g���l��U������s �f ���,h�j � � �G¹ w}� yt�·� � *,k�q�{}�pk��tk!�horvp®C� � � � ��orv�®pk�q�� � ��| y_³pqt�noIs�|~w}v�wry�mGwT­�knq�k��~k��¥s�qtw}vp|~�¸��|~q���³p| st� � 3 ��4 �¥ÊGÆ0�� �?Èü�]� G �²Æ}Ê>R0� ÂKÊ � Ê���È�ÂÄÈ 4 È«�T�Ql�l��n�iÝ ��s!���@�������N������g �f ���,h'� � �,³¯orv·��� � ��orvpk�q_¿²k�k}�}z ¬ stsn�!orvp®2� � � � �[w}qt´}k � ��w}qt®pk�qt¶���w}�~�~|~��|~w}v�±�| y_³pqt�noIs�|~w}vp�W|~v?s���k�±p³p��´���w}v!�!knq²s�k�q �������� ÿ��²Æ}Ê��¥Æ!ÇTÈ_ � Ê�� � ÊS$WÂC�²Ç 4 ÂÄÈ���Æ}ÊGÉ%�°����È6�TÃ2� � 18� 4 K�ÃRÂÄÈ�È6��É�È � 7r�·�����!� �f ���0hdª �IT oIyKq�orv!�dorvp®�� � ��k�v�¶��[or´}wT� � �����porw}��u2w�®pk���wryU��³�±�¶��¯orqtu2w}vp|~��w}�t�n|~�~�µoIstw}q��P|~vd��³pq�qtknv!sxu2w®�k�m�­xu±Gw�w}�tsl�nw}v!�!k�qtstk�q�� ���N�����Uû���� ��� � � ��ÇnÈ�� � ʯÂKÇ ����Å���ÇnÂ_Æ0� ÂC��È��D$ � ÊE�±���5�TÊGDz�n�h������g �