ENGINEERING PROJECT MANAGEMENT - …site.iugaza.edu.ps/ajamassi/files/2011/03/Engineering-Project...ˆ " ˘˘ ˆ Value management Value planning Value engineering Value review Pre-investment

! " # $%

&'' ()*+,- ,, ./ 0- ! ! !1 *'+2-*+ $1

&* 3+* 0++ +-. ** 14 1 . -

*'2+0

$1

&* -*- 5 *' 1 -- ! 6 0-01

&,* ()0 50'3 0

7 6 %8 -3*33 9

&'5 ()0 0 35 ,

: 1 1 7 ; 1 *5++/

1 4/

"

"

1 "4

1

4 "4

*/* : ? *

*/ ?

*/0 ? 0

*/' ? -

*/- ? 3

*/, ? ?4 5

*/3 ? **

! "

/* . *,

/ ; *,

/0 7 6!

/' C 6!

/- >4 0

/, D 3

/3 4 +

/+ +

# $$ % #&

0/* . 0

0/ 0

0/0 ? 00

4

0/' ? 4 03

0/- 05

0/, > 05

0/3 > '0

' (!) ''

'/* ; ''

'/ E ',

'/0 . '5

'/' E2 -

'/- E -

'/, E -0

'/3 : D (:E!) -0

'/+ 2 (>) :E! --

* + *,

!"

-/* 4 -+

-/ 4 (.1) ,

-/0 ,

-/' 4 ,0

-/- ,-

-/, 2 ,,

-/3 . ,3

-/+ 4 ,+

-/5 .1 ,5

-/* ! 4 30

-/** 4 3-

-/* 4 +

" - ,"

,/* = ? +,

,/ +3

,/0 ? ++

,/' = +5

,/- = 5*

,/, ; 5

,/3 : 50

,/+ 1 4 ? 5+

,/5 > *

4

. &*

3/* *-

3/ *3

3/0 . *5

3/' D **

3/- D ? **5

3/, **

3/3 . *0

3/+ > *'

, % .

#

+/* *3

+/ ? *3

+/0 ? *+

+/' $ *5

+/- *0*

+/, *0'

+/3 *0-

/ #.

5/* *03

5/ *0+

5/0 *',

5/, *',

5/3 *'3

& 0 ! 1! *"

*/* ? *-,

*/ 4 *-3

*/0 : 4 4 *-5

*/' > ? 4 *,*

*/- 6 *,0

*/, 4 D *,'

*/3 1 61 *,,

*/+ " 61 *,3

*/5 *3

4

) .'

$

**/* " *3'

**/ = *3-

**/0 *33

**/' *35

**/- ? ?4 *+

**/, *+

**/3 ? *+,

**/+ > *50

**/5 : *5'

**/* ! *

**/** 2 '

) 2! &"

$

*/* : ,

*/ 3

*/0 +

*/' 2D **

*/- *

*/, : 4 *0

*/3 : 4 *'

*/+ : *-

# 23!!

#

*0/*

*0/ 0

*0/0 -

*0/' . " ? 0*

*0/- : 0

*0/, 4 00

*0/3 " 0'

*0/+ 0,

' 2 #,

%&

*'/* > 0+

*'/ $ 05

*'/0 7 '*

*'/' : '0

4

*'/- ! ? '3

*'/, ; --

*'/3 -3

*'/+ . -5

*'/5 ; ,*

* !$$) "'

*-/* ,'

*-/ 4 ,-

*-/0 ,,

*-/' : ,5

*-/- 72 3

*-/, : ? 4 3-

*-/3 ? 4 33

*-/+ +*

*-/5 : +-

*-/* +3

" 45 !$$) /&

*,/* 5

*,/ : 5*

*,/0 5

*,/' 5+

*,/- ! 0

*,/, 0

*,/3 00

*,/+ 0-

. + - + !67+ $ #&.

*3/* 03

*3/ ; ? 0+

*3/0 05

*3/' 0**

*3/- ? 0**

*3/, 0*0

*3/3 " 0*'

*3/+ ? 0*-

*3/5 ? 0*3

*3/* > ? 0*3

"

*3/** 0*5

*3/* 14 4 ? 0*

*3/*0 : =. 00

*3/*' : 4 4 00

*3/*- =. $% 0-

*3/*, 0,

*3/*3 0+

*3/*+ = F4 05

, $ 8 $ ! ###

*+/* !2 ? 000

*+/ . ? 00-

*+/0 ? 00,

*+/' $% 2 ? 003

*+/- $ 00+

*+/, .4 005

/ 2+$ ! #'

!"

*5/* 7 4 G 0'*

*5/ : 4 0'-

*5/0 = 0',

*5/' 1 0'3

*5/- 24 0'5

*5/, 0-*

*5/3 : 0-

*5/+ 0-0

*5/5 0--

& -!! 8 #*.

/* : 0-+

/ 9 ? 0-5

/0 ? F 0,

1 " 5 0,'

." 03

"

8

. ?

4 ? ?4

/ . 4

?

24 = 4

*5+ ( =/ >

.D

! = C! *5+)/

*55- 4 4

/ 1 ? ! ,35

$%2 1 ? !

#

? / :

4 4

4 (;) ? /

!

? / 4 4

4

2 / :

4

? / : 4

4 4 ? 2

4

*55-/

:

/ :

4 4

4 / ?

? 4 ? 4 ?

? 4 4 / :

"

4

4 ? / :

? ?/

9 8 6!

: 8 ! =. !1!

? ! 4

$4 / 1 $4

?/ C 2

? 4

/ C /

C ; = /

2 5; ; !1 ? !2

4 $4 /

? ! $!.:/

!

; ! ; 4 D

/ 7 9 *

"4

/

4 / C ?

> .!. H ! IJ

;:>J ;:.J $ ' -

=/ C 4 ; 4

$4 / C

4 /

) 1 ! ; !. !1! !.E1

9

; 4 $!.:/ 1

44

?

$% 4/

= ) ! 1.1 !2

4 $4 / 1

%;

. 2

4

; ; ; : ! ! . 6/ .

! C 4

! ! % ! ! ;4 7/ .

: 4 7J ; % L .!

5/

: "

! "

4

/ . 4

4 4 /

9 8 66+

1 1

17 1

1; 1 ;4

1;> 14

1; 1 ;4

1! 1 ? !

1 ()

7

7

; FF4

FF

FF

: FFFF

: FFF

E D

: FF

> 2

>: FF

: FF

1 F

.. . . (:")

; 4

. "

6 4

;! ;FFF

;: ;FFF

;!= ;

; ;

;:> ; 4 : >

;=1 ;

;.; ; . ;4

"4

;=! ;

;! ; "

;:. ; : .

>; > ;4

9; " 9 ;

. .

.1 4

. .4

. 4

! 4

FF

. FFF

E. 4 D "

>

$ $

61 4

=: =FFFF

=.;. =M M . .M

()

9$. 9

C! C !?I 4

.= . =

.: . ?

.>> .

!; ! ;

E E

E=; E

>$= >44

1

!

. "

6 ? 4

6 4

:! :4

:< :

:E! : D

:$ : 4

$9= $ 9

61 6

6 6

6! 6

6 6

6> 6 4

7 7

7!9 7 ! 9

7:1 7

7: 7

"4 1

4

! "

#

$ $

$

%

& "

'

$

( ) )

(

(

*

+

(

# (

(

&" ,

-

-

-

-

(

$

-

$

$ &"

# ) .#)/ 0+$

&

"

01 $ # &

./ "

2 * #

3 + ) .3+4567/ &

"

%

,

-

-

-

-

-

(

#) &

"

01 $ # &

"

3 + ) .3+ 4567/ &

"

(

)

# # 8

)

#

9

(

*

$ .'77:/

% '' *

(

( +

% ''

(

#

; * #

(

$ % ''

(

$

%

&

"

(

)

9

"

& "

<

$

) (

=

# # :

%

!

, )

>

% ''

+

> (

=

>

% ''

0

(

%

(

4 * #

( (

% ''

% ''

#

$

(

$

% ''

)

#

&

" % '2

% . /

? $

( @ ? 3

? ! @

$

# # 6

)

0

$

+

( .

/ .

/

)

(

% '8

(

!

(

Possibleaddedvalue

Pre-project Project Operation

Decidewhat you

want

Designand

construction

Earning

Opportunity

Costof late

change

# # 7

#

$

"

#

% ';

(

-

&"

. 3 '778/

'5 * #

(

)

$

!

"

)

(

B

( C

#

(

# # ''

$

( &"

$

>

-

( $

!

9

+

C

9 $

*

'2 * #

#

(

)

& "

9 )

)

(

(

+

>

)

! )

(

) (

# # '8

%

+

!+ (

#

) & "

( $

(

!

!

! "

#

" +

+

)

#

"

'; * #

( $

( $

$ !

) 9

"

+C .'77:/

# ' .* BD +/3 + (

$# .'77A/ $ % ; $ # !

3+ 4567 .2555/ &

# 3 + )?

# .'776/ #

2 ?

"! % .'774/ ' (

2 # C

?#) .2555/ &

# $ % #

) 0 > #$

+ BD .'77A/ #

3 +?

= .2555/ '

)$ # 8 ?

0B)> .'77;/ # " * (

0 B ) > 9 BE

+C #$ 3 B? .'7A7/

2 ?

# # ':

!"#$ %

!"&$

!"'$ !"($

"#

"#

( ) ' !*++,$-

"

*,

!"#$

!"&$

"&

% %

!"'$

"'

%

!"($ !".$

"(

"(

"#

%

/ 0* "& "'

1 "'

%

"#

"#

!

$ "#

"

!

$

" # *2

"

Val

ue m

anag

emen

t

Val

ue p

lann

ing

Val

ue e

ngin

eerin

gV

alue

rev

iew

Pre

-inve

stm

ent p

hase

Unb

udge

ted

Bud

gete

d pr

ojec

ts

Inve

stm

ent p

hase

Impl

emen

tatio

nO

pera

tion

End

of a

sset

s

Con

cept

Pre

-fea

sibi

lity

Fea

sibi

lity

App

rais

alP

rocu

rem

ent

trai

ning

Ope

ratio

nD

ecom

mis

sion

ing

Clo

se o

ut

Def

ine

proj

ect

Def

ine

proj

ect

appr

oach

Dev

elop

ap

proa

ch/d

esig

n

Fee

dbac

k

Dev

elop

de

taile

dap

proa

ch

Pro

cure

men

tan

d tr

aini

ng

Han

dove

r/po

st p

roje

ct e

valu

atio

n

Nex

t pro

ject

Strategy: Corporate, Business & Project

*3 ' & #

% 4

5

% /

! $ 6

(

%

!$ !1#

) 7 & *++,$

%

!*$ -

%

!0$ -

%

!8$ 9-

!:$ '-

!;$

* + ":

08

+

/ 8

/

5

8

!

8 3

8

!

"6 / +

! "

+

*

?

,

7

'

0

/

!

"#8"1

#

'

$%

* ;

9'

0

;

9

$% ?

* ;

? ?

?A+

+

0

1) / +

$% !

* ;

$ %

B

B

<

/

;

0 0

*

* '

,

,

,

$ %

'

- ( ,

,

,

*

C

<

* '

,

0

& '

*

3

DE *

9

0 .)

+ /F $#@66%

D B

F7 $#@@.%

B

> 9F $#@@6% C > ?

* + 1"

!

"

#

"

" #

$

% !

% #

& ! '()*

++

,

"

-.

-(.

" -".

*

- .

/

/

/

/

/

(

#

"

$

#

" %

01 2$3435

4 $ 6 $6

555755+ 84 " +

$6 555 " #

& &9:555 " #

6

, +3

/

2

" *

!

/

% #

/

" #

% #

$6 555

(

; ; ,

,# , ,

( #

(

" *

!

%

%

&!

! % (%

; %

( #

% "

'; () +

(

#

) "

% "

+:

)

)

"

% %

" ;

, +4

%

"

%

"

"

+8 & ,

!

"

/

"

" #

#

!

- . - .

- .

!

#

*

> /

!

/

/

% /

" %

, +

$

%

"

*

% %

%

#

( #

%

"

* % #

% #

"

*

/

/

/

/

/

?

% ")

"

!

"

"

"

35 & ,

%

!

6

"

, *

!

*

#

-

. " *

%

#

&!

&! #

%

, 3

&!

!

!

6 %

#

@

#

"

!

#

A "

%

" *

/

!

"

> $ %

" %

#

#

#

$

"

3: & ,

!

# "

!

" / !

%

%

0 #

$

2$ 3435 , 5: *

/

/

% /

!

/

%

/

"

%

% "

% & '(

" -". *

, 3B

%

"

"

#

%

+B "

" " *

) /

/

/

" /

/

"

" " *

/

/

"

3+ & ,

/

/

% /

% /

/

!

#

#

C

% *

/

% /

%/

/

/

) * " '*+(

" 85

5

!

# "

2,@

$

2,@*

"*

(

2,@*

!

"*

!

2 2,@ " #

2,@* #

"*

@

2,@*

"*

2,@*

"* #

" 2,@

" 2,@

9

2# "#

( (

" &*

@*

( (?

, (#

!

@

-.

;

@%

# " 2,@ *

F #

"

%

AG -8. & H 9 $

G2$3435 -84. 2 $ G2$=+B -:. 2 $

G(#" (A -&. -+.

1 , 9 I%

# D

$6555= -4. # 6>

$> D6% A$ -8.

!"#

$ !"

!%# &

'()

( *

+ *

,-

*

*

%

#

# $

+

!

* .

%

$

.

!*

$

/

$

$

*

%

$

*

! ,0

!

! !"# *

!"

!" +

!%#

+

$

*

$

*

$

+

$

!%

!"

$

1 ,2 $

!"

!"

$

* *

34 ! 5

%

+

$

*

*

$

* !"

*

$

!

$

!%

1

!"

!

" #

!

! 32

$

!"

$

!"

% !" 6

!" 1 *

!"

!" !%

+

$ * !"

$

%

$ !"

$

!"

*

$

*

!"

$ *

7

!" !"

+

.

!"

38 ! 5

$

!"

9%" 20:4 $

; "

+

*

+

!

"

# $

+

+

*

++)

9> !"

*

5

9>) & &

7 + " &

+# !"

3? ! 5

$ 9% @ ! 5 " @!5"# ;

! A '

) %

!"

$

+

#

#

#

$ *

+

B

*

!"

$

+ * $ +

"

+ +

*

$ +

$ + +

C

/

*

! 3,

; +

"

*

*

%

*

$

!"

7

" ; )

* * *

$

!%

$

+

!%

$

!"

C

/+

*

!" D

$ *

!%

!" #$

$ *

33 ! 5

9

* !"

$

* %

* *

$

$ *

$

1 *

+ $

$

$

"

% #

1

$

$

$

! 3:

& +

1 *

'

) +

E +

%

&

$ !%

$ 6

*

$ 6

*

"

' ) !

')

1

"

*

"

$

$

)

$

3- ! 5

$

!%

$

"

$ *

' ( )

. + !%

+ $

"

!% !" ') $

+

+ *

;+ !"

;+

*#

%

;+

* 1

+

"

$

!%

% & $ +

! 30

& $

*

1

*

+)

'! & " *

$

( & $ +

+

+ +

$

# " (

$

*

.

E

+

$

$

(

+

:4 ! 5

$

$

*

% +

9 !"

"

* # $

+ $

2# &

1

8# !

$ ) #

42 4

# 2

# $

+ * '*)

=# &

+ $ & "

?# $

* !A#

!A ) =

2&) ,2

& ) #

) #

! :2

,# & !A $

.

' ) * $

!A

+

. +

"

*

1

$ *

+ * +

* $

*

F

*

/ 20:2# 9% D %

$ * + / * 244

( * --

*

" *

+ + *

+

* 1 *

+

B

/)

:8 ! 5

( $ / * *

2 24 *

$

F

!" 20-4

$

$ *

*

" *

+

!"

* # # )

! +

9

$

!"

$

') ')

$

*

+ $

& +

$

! :=

$ +

$

*

7

#

+

"

*

!"

"

"

*

" !"

.

!"

!"

C

"

!%

" !"

$

!%

* 24G

!"

,4G $

!%

:? ! 5

& + 6

!%# ')

#

1

;" *

6

=+ 2 4 ,8 +

E

$

6

;"

=+ 2 4 ,= #

$

+

6

$ *

')

7

! :,

$

+

@

)

'()H .

!

!

$

+

+ 5

$

1

*

*

+

% *

$

$

*

$ '()

6

:3 ! 5

*

$;#

*

E +

1 *

+

$

1 +

+

6 *

(

+ + + $

* * +

& ') ')

$

&

$

*#

1 * (

%

(

! ::

E +

$

" *

, $

$

1 *

E +

"

+

+

, $ ')

+ $ + +

+ 1 *

5

*

$ + '

+) $

*

$

E

:- ! 5

$

$

*

$

% B +

+

$

$

+

$

+ + $ +

'

) 7$5#

'

) 7$"#

$

$

!"

!%

!"

! :0

6

$

+ !"

$ +

$

$

!

+

"

!"

!"

E !"

')

!%

7 !"

+ !%

+

) +

# " !%

)

)

) !%

!% $ !%

2008 % + --./0

-4 ! 5

$ 200?

% ::,4 2003 !@ %.

2? 442 %. 2? 444

!"

!% E

!%

$

!%

$ %. 2? 442

6

/+ !%

$

%. 2? 442

!%

1 ,8

!%

!

$ !%

"

+ +

+ $

! -2

+ )

* *

$ )

%. 2? 442

$

*

#

"

%. 2? 442

#

$ !% %. 2? 442#

-8 ! 5

$

)

$

"

$ )

7

1

* '1 ! 2 ! ./3

! 45 )

.

$

#

"

!%

+

$

*

$ !%

$

.

) !% $

! -=

$

I

$

1

" +

!%

$ !%

5

)

"

*

%. 2? 442 7

*

$ !%

$ +

!%

-? ! 5

+)

/ / ;+ 1! E

!

" "

" "##

" "

$

" "

"

$

# $

"

$

%

#

"

"

&'

%

#

$

( ') "

* $ +! "

&+, "

"

-!

.

(

)

,

/

( &0

1

2

3

*

*

. ( "

$

,) " 14

5

" !

"

#

"

" "

" " "

" " $

6 "

"

"

" "

78 )9&1:

" ;

# #!

"

!

"

" "

&& -

( "

% !

$

!

/

<

"

=

"

$ "

7): / 7/>:

7,: 8#

71: %##

72: /

7: <

7': <

70: <

7&: <

$ "

$

"

$

!

6 $ "

! 3

"

! $ ABB 6

3

9 -

" 3

-

6 6

% " #

%

! !

"

" -!

"

! BB

BB

- "

7C(: 78(: "

?" !

/ -

$ "

#

" #

"

$

"

$ B @ B "

!

!

.# @ " !

@

D @ "

" ""

< #

"

@ "

" "

6

# @ #

" "

"

@

"

$

$

" "

#

9, -

$

""

!

7CC:

78>:

"

D "

!

" @

7 "

: ;

7 8> # "

:

E +

"#

( " )@) "

" #" C

"

$

6 !

#

!"

$

$

"

$ "

$

"

( 91

< "

"

$

"

E

" "

E

$ "

#

"

%

$ "

$ "

"

"

" $ "

$

"

"

C F C G D

" D !

# )4

# ),4

" )4

%

"

6

"

#

"

"

;

# "

;

;

< @

$ " "

! "

$

" "

$ "

! ""

"

"

@

"

;

+#

;

" ;

"

;

-!

! "

9' -

"

# 3

"

;

!

$ !

! $

+!

!

$ ! !

!

! " "

7 : ! 7#

:

/ !

#

( * 7(*:

- . C 3 7-.C3:

- . 7-.:

#

6 $ 6

!

( "

#

/ "

-

# $ %"

$ #

!

" @

+! 7 :;

7

: 7

#

: 7!

"" :

$

#

"

!

$ "

! " #

" # !

$ -. "

, + )2

" , #"

D

" " "

$ #

$

"

"

E !

" @

6 #

3 C

"

#

! H) ! "

9& -

! #

" "

I"II 7.%%$ : #

" $

.%%$ #

< #

"

"

(

?"

;

"

% "

# #

#

"

" $

$ @

" " #

" ;

"

"

;

"

;

" !

!

#

( 99

!

"

"

& '(

$ "

D "

< "

"

" "

.

( " #

! " (#

#

$

"

( @

7 :

;

#" #

;

+!

;

# !

;

;

+

) -

$ "

@

"

" ;

# # "

+

* "

*

" " "

B *

#

3

#

% "

" @

" " !

;

"

;

;

( ))

* "

$ "

/ =

*

@

"

" ! #

C@

*@

D

/

#

"

"

/@ #

@

-@

<

( "

* "

"

( "

"

), -

@

;

! ;

" ;

"

$

"

* @ #

" !

@ " #

!

*#" @ "

"

@

@

" #

@

@

* @ -

* =

3 7-*=3:

'

5 C 7)99: & %' & -

= / 7 .:

$ $ D ')I, , )

!

"

"

# " #

# $

#

$

%

#

& '

! (

)*

Maximum A

Most likely B

Minimum CEst

imat

ed r

ange

of c

osts

(m

)

Actualcost

Feasibility studyDesign

TenderConstruction Claims

settlement

A

B

C A

B

C

Feasibilitystudy

Tender Settlement

A B C

+

), -

#

#

.

+# /

# #

. 0

#

1 #.

" $

# "

$

#

- #

2

#/

#/

#/

"/

"

$

#

#

" !

# 1 .!

3 3 - )

#

"

1 . 1 . 45!

"

$ (

#

" (

$

#

6

(

2

/

7 "

# #

8 # 45

#

$

# # "

$

9 ((

#

#

( (

(

6

(

# : #

(!

); -

# #

$ #( (

"

"

#

#

"

0

2

#/

9 /

" /

#

1

#.

" # #

# #

7

# # 2

/

/

/

/

/

#

:

2

/

#

3 3 - )

/

#

#

!

&

. # 4

#2

(

" #

#

#

" # #

$

$ .

$ ( ( (

" 8

# (#

9 " 2

.

/

" (

/

"

/

/

6 " " /

) -

" /

/

(

! "/

/

$

#

# #

2

/

&" #

" "2

!

!

!

"

$

#

# $

.

(

( #

3 3 -

8

# 3

#

#

!

#

! =

0

%! 3

$

# 1.

" (

$

1.

A! 8

"

" # $

$

6

B! 7

1#.

#

#

1 .

9

# 1 . 1 . 1#.

" 2

/

/

6# 6/

#

1 .

3 3 - A

= "2

"

66(

/

1 . /

/

/

/

/

"

=

"2

" !/

!/

6#

!/

"

#6

!

& # # "2

# /

/

/

/

#

# /

#

#!

( .

(

$ 2

1.

# 2

/

B -

#

:

$

#

#

8

#

(

1.

# #

(

"

!

#

#

%!

" . (

=

!

A! "

#

B!

"

3 3 - *

# #

# (

#

"

$ #

(

$

(

(

/ # "

( "

!

(

#

$

"(

"

!

$

45

# $

#

" # ! 1(.

, -

:

C

# 1 .

# # "

" !

#

# 0

>@

"

&

#

#

$ # (

$

"

(

# 1 .

(

# $

#

#

$ # 1.

$

#

.

"

1.

#

#

#

&

#

3 3 -

$

#

#

$ (

#

= (

$

"

(

#

#

#

?

#

3

" ?

3

#

1# .

# 4 "

$

$

; -

#

0

: #

#

#

$ " ( ( (

#

" #!

$

# $

#

9 #

"

:

"

9

C #

#

3 3 -

0 #

: 2

- D 3 E +# E 7 E - E #(

9 #

#( #(

( # 5

(

A)F ,)F . / (

%)F B)F

.

#

(

& $

-

"

5

"

. $ >@

# (

#

7 (!

%) -

(

: (

(

#

(

9

"

:

> (

#

45 (

( (

#

$

(

;)F

3

(

3 3 - %

%)F

#

#

#

(

(

.

#

#

(

:

3

(

$

$

: (

#

$

(

(

3

#

3

#

#

"( GAF

)*G F

#

# , A(

%% -

#

$!

:

.

#

$

$

"

"

#

#

(

(

# (

#

" $

(

$

#

$

/ 0 #

7

#

7

#

3 3 - %A

3

#

# #

45

:

# # #

(

"

# $

# #

1".

# "

:

(#

% &

"

:

#(

"

#

" #

0

F

. >@

BF *F

(# (

$

%B -

0

2

/

/

/

#

A

: 3

3 + 4 :&

!"#$%&

'

$"

' (

")*

'

+ ,

'

-

+

'

-

.

(

+

+

")$ /

0

1

+ +

+

+

(

( +

+ ' +

( 2

0 . 2 (

3"44 ""

-

(

(

+

(

+

-

+

")#

-

+

(

+

5

5

6

+ 7

- +

'

-

"84 /

-

+

-

-

5

-

+

- +

+

+

-

(

"8"

$)

+

9 +

5

0

+

'

! 5 : "#$$&

"8) /

7

-

'

+

-

+

+

' -

+

;

+

- 6

- 6 5

(

5

5 ( +

-

(

"

,

+

>

(

.

"82

+

(

#

5 ?- : >@ !"#$$& )

1 ; @ ; A @ !"#$%&

/ /

: @/ !"##2&

; A 5; / : / !"##$& !

! ! " # !#! $! %

6

!

"# "#

"#

$%

$% &

!

'()

*

* !

*

!

!

!!

*

&

'++ !

'+++ ,

"#

'(- .

/

!

0

1 2' .

* !!

3 !

1 24

*

!

!

!

5

$1 2(%

3

!!

!!

'(2

6

3

'7+ .

/

3

!

$1 27%

!

!

!

"8

9#

!

1 27

" #

"# *

" #

"1 #

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

a

b

a

b

a

c

d

e

c

f

g

f

g

f

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90Days

Hou

ses

Assumptions: hand-over every 5 days 2 foundation teams (a-b) 3 structural teams (c-e) 2 finishes teams (f-g) duration: 75 days(*) Initial durations set atmultiple of 5 days

Foundations Structure

Buffer

Finishes

75

:

'7'

Clo

se r

oad

Tem

pora

ryfe

ncin

g

Bre

akup

and

rem

ove

deck

Rem

ove

balla

stS

caffo

ldin

g

Rem

ove

scaf

fold

Bur

nup

and

rem

ove

stee

loffs

iteLo

wer

stee

lwor

kto

road

Exc

avat

e

Red

uce

win

gw

alls

and

abu

tmen

ts to

fin

al le

vels

Rem

ove

tem

pora

ry

fenc

ing

Reo

pen

road

Cle

ar s

ite a

nd

dem

obili

se

Pie

rre

inst

atem

ent

AB

CD

Brid

ge s

pan

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Time in weeks

Fin

al g

radi

ng a

nd s

hapi

ng

1.

2.

3.

Red

uce

win

g w

alls

and

abu

t to

final

leve

ls

Re-

open

roa

d R

emov

e te

mpo

rary

fenc

ing

'74 .

/

3

!

2'

$'% 6

$4% &

$(% * 1 ';

9

$'% & !

! < !

= 2'

(D

$4%

=

>

*

(D *

!

?

' @ 0 G

'77 .

/

= ?

.

?

F6F.F0F>

$(% 1 (

(- 4 8

!

F6F1FGF>

=

$'% *

"#

8

$4% *

!

$(% 6 ?

$7% 6

E

" #

$;% .

'7;

!" "

*

?

!

!

/ 6

*

8

!

,

!

=

1

$ %&

!

!

!

*

,

!

'7)

!

@

*

/

:*E=H

:. /

*

$%

0 8

*

!

$

%

&

$8

$ %

C !

! $ %

*

1

" # $

%

# C

9 @

9 6 9

.5

!

! "!#

6

/

/ 6 !

*

#

5

.

3

'72

* #

!

$ */%

!

1 !

*/

,

@/:

1 !

$.5 % &

!

!

?

$0=*%

@

9 @

9 6 ?

!

9 @

9 ? $ % 9 6 *

';+ .

/

9

$ !

%

*

"@ *#

*

&

!!

8

9 /

!

1

$

% 9 C

9 C

9

<

I *

8

9 * 9 8

9 8

9

$!

%9 , ! 9

& @ . : 58 $'2-(% 8 :

'("

!" #$

!

! E

!

$% $%

3 -4

1 <

&

1

5 ' D+ !

5 ;+ !

); !

1 4+ !

8 -+ ! ';+!!

: '++ !

!% &

!

'D

. 'D

$%

3

*

#

J;+ +++

9

C$%

'

# ( K4 1 '- '

(

'4 47 : '4 (; & 7 (

D C * D () C ** 7 ;D- 6 ( ;D2 & ( D

'+ / 7 2'' 6 4 )-'4 & ( 2

'( . ; '4'7 / '- '+'; C *** 7 )'+

'D C *L 7 '(';') / 4+ '('- 6 * D 7''';

'2 6 ** '4 'D'-4+ * D '7'D')'-4' ( '24+

$%

6

. 4+ J777 +++

. < M ') 'D JD++ +++

/ 6 '- JD++ +++/ C M '7 'D J)++ +++

';7 .

/

!)

=

1 2'

$'%

.

$4%

!

"

#

#

#

"

$%&

#

#

#

"

#

#

#

'

(

)

!

$*&+ , -

. .

/ 0-

1

2

(2 $3$)

(45')

(607-)

(6071)

1 0 , 4 5 $%+

('071)

2 $38 -

(-5)

(6071 607-) '

(05)

(6071 '071) '

() (6'0)

'

1

$%9 4 1 :

(-1) (6071/607-)$33 5 $33

(01) (6071/'071)$33 5 $33

!

-

;

' ;

-

"

- ( ) -

-

=

-

!

2

:

'

'

-

. -

!

(2 $3>)

"

$&3 4 1 :

#

#

#

#

( )#

$

'

" #

:

0

110

100

90

80

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

0

55%

Manpower peak

Design progress

Approximate technical manpower:May vary by job (determinedby design co-ordination)

53%42%

27%

15%

7%3%

42%

30%

20%

10%

3%0 20 40 60 80 100 120

Job duration (%)

Tec

hnic

al d

esig

n m

anpo

wer

(%

)100

50

0

Des

ign

prog

ress

(%

)

1 0 , 4 5 $&$

"

2 $3? -

- -

1

2

2

1

100

80

60

40

20

00 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34

Time

Pro

ject

cos

t (%

)

Planned progress

" -

$&8 4 1 :

$ %&

2 $3%

"

7

$ 0

1 0 , 4 5 $&>

@

>

'

:

'

-

4

1

-

'

4 (45')

- :

,- 0 4 45'

$&? 4 1 :

'/

1

1

- -

&3 333 ?+%3' 8*% 333 ?*33

4 %33 333 &333

= ??3 333 &333

1 0 , 4 5 $&%

: 6; >3A

!

!

) * *

'

6071 '071

7

'

8

9

,

45'

45' !

6

;

45'

'

+ ,! *

$38

4

2 $3& -

$38 -

1 0 , 4 5 $&+

333 8%33 39>

1 $%33 $+33 $$>: 8>33 8833 3*&4 *33 &33 3&&0 >33 >33 $33

' -

$&9 4 1 :

0

-

? ?93

> >83

- !

$%

?93 ?

%3A

? ?93

'

'

! **A

**A

**A **A

**A

!

45'

6

1 0 , 4 5 $&*

0

: ,-

B : 45'

: 4

.

!

,-

2

,- $ $ 833

(0C)

$8 - $8

,- B (,-B2)

833 333

8?3 333

$3> 0 !

3*& *

( 4/

: 4

'

1

$ $3 333 $9 333 3%%

8 ?3 333 %3 333 393> &3 333 +3 333 39&? %3 333 ?9 333 $3?

% ?3 333 >3 333 $>>& 83 333 $% 333 $>>+ $3 333 9 333 $8%

9 * 333 $3 333 3*3* $ 333 8 333 3%3

8?3 333 8%$ 333 3*&

$+3 4 1 :

$>> 3%

45'

$+

$&

-

-

-

7

$&

' >3 333

3>> 0

45'

'

>

-

0

$$ 333 333

"

#

#

#

#

#

;

"

#

#

#

7

- .!!

-

45'

'

45'

D

: @ ($***) ! " 8 2 1E

= B ($**&) ! " # - E F= ($**+) ! " :B @ E

1 0 , 4 5 $+>

!" "

"

#$%

&'

!

!

(

"

"

!

"

(

" "

!

)*+,-

)-!.)-

'

/"

"

0 0 1 #$2

3

"

( "

!

!

"

4

"

"

3

"

(

.

56

#$7 1 4

(

&/'

)( ###-

)#- /

0 0

0

'" 0

0

8

/

0 0 1 #$$

)9- /

/

:

)

-

);- /

(

/ "

0

>

&>'

)( ##9-

"

"

"

'

"

)-

:

'

0

: @

: @

: @

: " @

:

@

: )-

@

: )-

@

!

@

+

B

3

! "

3

3

3

3

3

" 3

3

3

' 3

"3

3

"3

3

3

3

" 3

!

1

(

0 0 1 #=#

"

( ##;

>

&"'

&!"'

& C ' & '

" &'

)

- "

B

!"

"

"

&'

D

"

' ) "

-

#=9 1 4

0 0 1 #=;

"

1

)4

-

"

&

'

" "!" )

!" "

"!"- !

"

!"

!"

"!"B

"!"

!" "

"

"

!

D

5 !"

!

" '

#=% 1 4

!" "

"

"

'"

'"

"

!"

!" 56

56

&

' 4

) !"

"

-

) -

!

)( ##%- +

(

+

"

( "

#=7 1 4

+

0 0 1 #=$

"

(

"

B

3

3

3

"

1

"

"

B

!

' 3

!

3

! 3

3

3

3

#== 1 4

' 3

3

3

$ #

!

56 +

!

' !

!"

"

4

%

4

:

' '

1 '

"

" !"

'

8

0 "

0

"

'

4

#?A 1 4

*

'

(

'

'

8 ' "

"

"

4

B

3

)

!

-3

0 0 1 #?#

"

3

#

&'

#$

0

(

" #$

/

!

0

0 '

0 0 1 #?;

1

E

"

% &' '

&"' &' &'

)*+,-

"

) -

)

-

'

"

F

:

& '

& '

#?% 1 4

&' &'

0

+

1 "

3

1

' & "

'

& '

!!

" B

"

3

3

3

3

'

B

3

"

3

!

F"

0 0 1 #?2

" 3

3

3

"

"

"

'

"

"

'

)" - 1

)&'-

'

)&

'-

"

0

"

'

0

"

"

"

0 0 1 #?$

:

!

&"'

&' (

" &

'

) &'-

5

"

' "

' '

" B

3

3

3

3

" B

)

-3

3

3

'

"

' 5

#?= 1 4

"

"

"

) -

'

*

'

"

'

( ##2 2A!

2A

H#2A

2A!2A

H#2

H#;2

H#2$2

H#72

#AG #7$G

2AG

)%2G-

B

0 0 1 #??

"

B

3

3

3

3

3

'

9AA 1 4

0

B

" 3

"

"

( ##7 "

"

( )

&' &' *

&"' "

* &'

"

"

0 0 1 9A#

4

1

>

0

4 "

"

& ' +

"".

3

!

8 !

"

B

!

&:

@'

!

) - 8

@ 8

@ 8

0 0 1 9A;

@

3

1 "

0

"

#??;

*

" <

&' &' ( "

"

"

"

"

1

" "

9A% 1 4

" "

"

#

* >4F : 0

!

"

# $

%

&

$

'

(

"

) #

*(

)

! $

# #

+

!

# ,

-

"

+

# #

# #

+

+ .

+ "

/ +

+

0

1

# # "

2

# -

2

- 2

2

2

+ $- 2

) .

$

. 3 *4

!

1

+

2

2

2

2

0

1

#

2

2

.

+

$

!

/$+ /

-+ 5

#

-

#

$

#

*6 5

$ 0

$ # 7

!

,

#

$ !

!

$

3 $

$

$

$ )

) /+

$

$

#

!

$

+

!

#

.

7

,

-# #

#

!

$ 7

. 3 *8

+ 0

9

+ "

!

5 :

! :

7

% ! #

)

!

!

$

1

-

;

$1

2

#

* 5

$ 0

# $ !

#

#

: #

$

$ $

# 1

#

2

#2

"

2

+ 2

"

! # "

$ +

$

+

!

"

) # '

!

# #

"

. 3

$ "

$ # !

+ #

$

"

+

$

"

! $

" 1

# 2

2

2

#2

2

- 2

$

# # 7

!

#-

)

#

/+

A

"

5"

$

& 5

$ 0

,

/+ $ +

)

+ )

$

!

-

)

! 1

" 2

2

2

2

$2

2

2

$

#

)

) $

$ #

" 9

$

! $

!

1

. 3 '

"

$

2

#

$

)

1

-2

# -# @[email protected]

-2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

- 2

/-+

!

!

- $

-

3 $

!

!

1

2

#2

2

2

+ # 2

( 5

$ 0

!

!

!

!

#

/

+

)

#

1

2

#2

)

A

"

! -

$ -

- 9

"

$

!

+ )

# # $

. 3 4

!

!

#

$ $

! " #

!

!

$

!

,

!

!

#

9 $

)

1

2

2

2

#

$ 2

)"

!

6 5

$ 0

! "

$

!

"

!

!

# B

!

!

!

"

!

"

"

A

!

!

1

2

2

#2

" 2

)

!

# !

. 3 8

"

+

!

B

# )

)

#

#

!

!

$

)

)

C

)

C

. C

;

C C

C

)" C

C

)" C

3 C

)

C

.

C

3 C

9

C

9

C

* 5

$ 0

$

9

9

=

!

%

#

%

; ! 88

! ! ! D

! >= 88' "# $ 0B , D

. 3

!

"

# $

%

&&&

' (

)

*

+

!

*

+

'

,

!

!

) " -.% &&/

0 1

1

2

'

* % 345678

) 9 3456&8 (

-

2 $ (

,

+

:

&&; ) '

" $

)

) 9 3456&8

!

9

%

3

-

2

-

)

2

%

"

3

2 )

)

2

)

3

!

3455=8

+

?

3

!

%

+

:

3

!

0 +

3455;8

!

!

)

@

&/A ) '

! # $

'

!

!

,

!

0

9

9

) " -.% &/4

)

2

,

" % &

"

)

!

'

"

!

-

&/& ) '

,

2

)

)

2

)

$

' (

2

0

!

) " -.% &//

"

:

0

!

: 2

(

!

$

0

!

%

!

"

2

(

+

: B +

3+ 455;8

+

C

$

$

$

2

)

2 ?

0

'

2

2 )

0

2

?

* &&

2

C

$

$

$

2

$

$

+

* % B' 345678 & #

+ 0* 3455;8 + #

+ B 3455;8 !" #

+0#

&/7 ) '

+ 3455=8 "? )

" D

) E 9 , 3456&8 $# % &' ( + F , D #

* ,' 3455/8 ) * "8 $ & ) ) #

, 3455;8 * ! + *

% )

*

) " -.% &/>

!

"

#

$%&

'

" (

#

)

*

+

"

, -.- // "

"

#

"

#

0 $%1

+

2

+

3-4

+

//

$.5 6 0

3$4 '

7

"

7

' +

)

"

, -.$

3-4 8

3$4

0 $.-

3%4

+

"

3.4

+

+

+

)

, -.$ "

$.$ 6 0

9

36(74

:

3'(74

3 4

7 3"(74

6(7 '(7 3 "(7 4

3;(74

6(7 6(7 '(7 ;(7

-1

#

7

)

7

6

3 4 6

# ) +

$.. 6 0

3 4

6

7

3

4

;

+ #

+

, -.%

0 $.=

"

"

#

#

+

7

3 4

;

9

3 4:

> 34

:

:

:

:

:

:

:

:

:

:

$.? 6 0

+

34

34

,

)

34 3

4 + +

3 4

+

@

3 4

3

4

"

+

3 + A

4

0 $.

"

#

# #

" +

7

+ #

3 4 )

3

4

+ #!!

!! +

3 4

, -..

, -.=

)

$.& 6 0

3

4

7

*

A

7

A

#

7 0+ 3704

)

70

"

,

) +

3, -.?4

+

34

6 +

"

3

4

$=5 6 0

!

0 $=-

3

4

/

3

*" 4

;

;

+

9 )

B

+

)

+

;

3

4

@

;

$=$ 6 0

34

" +

*

* -5 ;

"

6

*

3 4

6

3

4 +

3C,4 # C,

C,

9

0 $=%

3 4:

3 4:

3 /

4:

3

4:

3

4

C,

3-4 :

3$4

+

3%4

" (B

# +

C, 3, -.

+

#

C, +

+

C,

! #$

"

,

9

, #

3

4

'

# +

* 3

4

#

0 $==

#

3 4

#(

( (

+

#@

0 ) 3-1=.4

:

+

) +

,

3 4

"

#

+

D #

6

+

)

3 4

+ 0

3 + *

3 04 @ -11.4

$=? 6 0

" %

"

9

7

3+

4

+

+

3

4 E

,

7

+

3

4

7 #

+

# 2

3

4

0 $=

7 +

3

4

+

* +

*

+ ,

0

+

+

;

-1&1

$=& 6 0

8 >

6 >

7

6

@

7

0

D +

8

@

>

E

"

D

*

7

,

E

, +

(

;

7!

*

+

6

/

3 -1&14

& '

"

,

,

!

0 $=1

" 9

7

#

+

+

7

#

;

3 4

7 #!

3

# + 4 )

# 3

# 4

+

!

3-4

#

$?5 6 0

3$4

3%4

:

3.4 #!

,!

!

3

4

" !

/

(

9

:

: #

A

,0

+

" ,0

+

,0

+

,0

3 4

,0

,0

,

+ +

)

+

,0

" 3,"4 "

#

*

+

$?$ 6 0

,0 E

,"

,0 *

,0

," ,0

3 +4

*

+ +

+

3-1&14 ! "#$ %

" G 3-11

!

"

# $

%#$&

#$

'()

%*+,& ,

,

-

,

*

*

+

$

.

.

,

/

,

#

0 # '(1

+

.

+

,

*

*

'(( 2 * #

+ 313

$

$

$

2

$

4

5

5

5

# 6

+

+

3

3

7 '

, '

0 # '(8

4 3998 + 1: 31;

'(< 2 * #

:

!

%3998&

#

5

-

$

0#

-

4

%3& 5

%'& 5

%:& 5

%)& 5

%1&

5

0# 0 ,

%3& +

0 # '(9

%'& +

%:& =

%)& 0

"# !

.

%3& "

%'&

%:& "

"

6

6

0

2

%)&

'8; 2 * #

$ %

& + 31'

31>

-

Influence on total construction costs (%)

65% 25% 10%

5% 10% 85%

Appraisal andproject definition

Design andcontracts

Construction andprocurement

Client andspecialistconsultants

Design team

Contractors and suppliers

Actual expenditure during each stage (%)

" 4 3999 + )

,

$

-

2

,

/

.

% &

2

?

7 7

"

?

*

*

'8' 2 * #

*

@

*

"

%

&

0 # '8:

!

0#

0 %3999& 4

5

5

2

#$

0# 0

%3999& 4

5

5

5

-

0

$ 2 . #$ 6""

= A 0#

0 %3999& 4

5

5

5

'8) 2 * #

313

$ %

B

%3999& +

31:

$

%3999& %+ 31)&

4

5

5

+

+ 311

0 # '81

&

*

*

*

*

@

=

@

=

0

#

0

4

0

4

0

4

0

4

0

4

0

4

0

4

0

4

A

C"

C"

C"

0

C

"

C"

C"

*

C"

C"

C"

*

C"

C

"C

"

!

5

C"

5

'8( 2 * #

' %

*

2

0

.

+ 31(

!

*

A

C

Project value chain

Feasibilityvalue

Corporatevalue

Businessvalue

Designvalue

Constructionvalue

Commissionvalue

Operationalvalue

4 3999 +

Info

rmat

ion

Hum

an r

esou

rces

Pro

cure

men

t

Dev

elop

men

t

Org

anis

atio

n

Brie

fG

ener

atio

nE

valu

atio

nC

omm

unic

atio

n

Des

igne

r (c

onsu

ltant

) Info

rmat

ion

Hum

an r

esou

rces

Pro

cure

men

t

Dev

elop

men

t

Org

anis

atio

n

Est

imat

ete

nder

Con

stru

ctio

nC

omm

issi

onin

gO

pera

ting

Con

trac

tor

Info

rmat

ion

Hum

an r

esou

rces

Pro

cure

men

tD

evel

opm

ent

Org

anis

atio

n

Ope

rate

Mai

nten

ance

Ren

ewal

Tra

nsfe

r

Ope

rato

rIn

form

atio

nH

uman

res

ourc

esP

rocu

rem

ent

Dev

elop

men

tO

rgan

isat

ion

Cor

pora

teB

usin

ess

Pro

ject

Ass

et

Clie

nt

Info

rmat

ion

Hum

an r

esou

rces

Pro

cure

men

tD

evel

opm

ent

Org

anis

atio

n

Cor

pora

teB

usin

ess

Pro

ject

Ass

et

Clie

nt

Pro

mot

er v

alue

sys

tem

- (

Str

ateg

ic)

Mul

ti-va

lue

syst

em -

(Tac

tical

)

Dec

isio

n to

con

sult

Use

r va

lue

syst

em -

(O

pera

tiona

l)

"

%

*

&

4

3999

+

G3;;7';;

'

*

,

+ 318

4

1 3;

:

6

A

"

A

+

%,*&

,*

A +

4

5

5

5

!

%A*2&

#$ 0 *

0 # '

' * 4 - 3999

'

) ! !

,

2

*+,

6 %';;;&

"

A@

=

2 #), 0 6 * *

?

A@

D

C *+, *

*+,

0 # '

#"02

A

,

,?0"$

*+,

#"02

.

,

A

*

" ';>

6

6

0

'

A

"

#

,

"

A

,

*

0 # '

,

,

#

( 2

'

,

,

,

$

+ 31<

+!

6 $ ! * F D # * %';;;& % $& ' + D $2D

(

) $ ( * E 3999 '71)3- D C $ # %3999& ' ' +

( , 2 D # 3

4????? # %3998& ( $ '

+ * * = C %3999& , -

( *$

A =

" E %399

!" # $

%& ' ()** +

,-

#

,-

&

.

&

/*!

'

. .

(

+

.

.

,

.

0

1

1

2

2

2

.

3 # & /*)

0

' 1

1

1

1

1

% ' 1

1

1

4

&

2

0

1

1

1

(+

5

4

6

/*/ 7 $

8 & 9 0

'

(3

:

)**;+

,# 4 & 7 ()**)+ 0

& 4 ()**)+

0

'

7 8 (7 )**?+ 0

3 # & /*@

4

7 8

9

3

.

% ' % '

6

A

2

9 )=)

%' %'

4

4

/* 7 $

:

B

'

B

3

#0 7& )**C

3 # & /*;

Documents

ENGINEERING PROJECT MANAGEMENT - …site.iugaza.edu.ps/ajamassi/files/2011/03/Engineering-Project...ˆ " ˘˘ ˆ Value management Value planning Value engineering Value review Pre-investment