17
February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment Vessel Internal Investigation Results

Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

February 28, 2019

Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc.

Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power StationUnit 2 Primary Containment Vessel Internal Investigation Results

Page 2: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

RPV

Scope of investigation unit access

Approx. 7.2m

1

1. Primary containment vessel internal investigation overview

Primary Containment Vessel(PCV)

Control rod drive mechanism(CRD) replacement rails

Pedestal opening

Pedestal

Platform

Control Rod Drive mechanism (CRD)housing

Worker access opening

Subfloor

Position from which investigation unit was lowered

The investigation unit was lowered from the same location as the previous investigation (January 2018) to investigate the primary containment vessel (PCV).

During this investigation we purposely let the investigation unit come in contact with the deposits at the bottom to observe the behavior of said deposits. Video images, and dose and temperature readings were also obtained from locations closer to the deposits than previous investigations.

Containment vessel penetration pipe to be used (X-6 penetration)

Scope of the PCV Internal Investigation

Page 3: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

Bottom of pedestal

垂直断面図

Extendable pipe

CRD housing

Fallen grating

CRDreplacement rail

CRD交換機Platform

2. Contact locations during the investigation(1/2)

We classified deposits touched during this investigation into the following three groups to summarize the results: ①Pebble-like※1 deposits ②Stone-like※1 deposits ③Deposits assumed to be parts of internal structures

※1 We defined “pebble-like” as having apparently a clear shape and “stone-like” as not having such a shape.

Investigation location

Investigation location (taken in January, 2018)

Pedestal center

Area at the bottom of pedestal that can be investigated.Bottom-2

Pebble-like deposit Bottom-6

Deposit assumed to be parts of

internal structures

Bottom-3Stone-like deposit

Bottom-4Pebble-like deposit

Bottom-1Pebble-like deposit

Bottom-5Pebble-like deposit

2

Page 4: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

CRD交換機

垂直断面図

CRD交換機

Pedestal centerTop of platform-3Stone-like deposit

Top of platform-1Pebble-like deposit

Top of platform-2Stone-like deposit

Top of platform-4Deposit assumed to be

parts of internal structures

3

2. Contact locations during the investigation(2/2)

Extendablepipe

Fallen grating

Platform

CRD housing

CRDreplacement rail

Bottom of pedestal

Investigation location (taken in January, 2017)

Page 5: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

4

3. Investigation results (Bottom of pedestal)(1/3)

Conditions at the bottom-2Conditions at the bottom-1

It was found that pebble-like deposits can be moved.

Pedestal center

Area at the bottom of pedestal that can be investigatedBottom-2

Pebble-like deposit

Bottom-4Pebble-like deposit

Bottom-1Pebble-like deposit

Conditions at the bottom-4

Investigated on February 13, 2019

Investigation location (taken in January, 2018)

Page 6: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

5

Conditions at the bottom-6Conditions at the bottom-5

Bottom-6Deposit assumed to be

parts of internal structures

Bottom-5Pebble-like deposit

3. Investigation results (Bottom of pedestal)(2/3)

Area at the bottom of pedestal that can be investigated

Pedestal center

Investigation location (taken in January, 2018)

It was found that pebble-like and structure-shaped deposits can be moved.

Investigated on February 13, 2019

Page 7: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

6

While grasping deposit After grasping deposit

It was found that the stone-like deposit did not move. And, the video showed no contact marks left on the deposit.

Conditions at the bottom-3

Pedestal center

Bottom-3Stone-like deposit

Grasping with finger (left)

Investigation unit was hoisted while it grasped the deposit, but it did not move (right).

3. Investigation results (Bottom of pedestal)(3/3)

Area at the bottom of pedestal that can be investigated

Investigation location (taken in January, 2018)

Investigated on February 13, 2019

Page 8: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

7

3. Investigation results (Top of platform)(1/3)

Conditions at the top of platform-4Conditions at the top of platform-1

CRD交換機

Pedestal center

Top of platfotm-1Pebble-like

deposit

Top of platform-4Deposit assumed

to be parts of internal structures

Investigation location (taken in January, 2017)

It was found that pebble-like and structure-shaped deposits can be moved.

Investigated on February 13, 2019

Page 9: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

Top of platform-2Stone-like

deposit

Conditions at the top of platform-28

3. Investigation results (Top of platform)(2/3)

Pedestal center

Investigation location (taken in January, 2017)

Grasping with finger (left)

Investigation unit was hoisted while it grasped the deposit, but it did not move (right).

Investigated on February 13, 2019

While grasping deposit After grasping deposit

It was found that the stone-like deposit did not move. And, the video showed no contact marks left on the deposit.

Page 10: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

Top of platform-3Stone-like

deposit

Conditions at the top of platform-3

9

3. Investigation results (Top of platform)(3/3)

Pedestal center

Investigation location (taken in January, 2017)

It was found that stone-like deposit did not move. And, the video showed no contact marks left on the deposit.

While grasping deposit After grasping deposit

Investigated on February 13, 2019

Grasping with finger (left)

Investigation unit was hoisted while it grasped the deposit, but it did not move (right).

Page 11: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

Additional

locations

where the

unit was

stopped

during the

investigation

of deposits

Deposits(concept drawing of distribution area)Area where deposits

were investigated

Measurement

pointⅡ

Measurement

point Ⅲ

Measurement

point Ⅰ

Measurement

point ⅣMeasurement

point Ⅴ

Measurement

point Ⅵ

Measurement

point Ⅶ

4. Measured dose and temperature

Measurementpoint

Dose rate※1,2

[Gy/h]

Temp.※2

[℃]

Ⅰ 6.4 23.2

Ⅱ 6.8 23.1

Ⅲ 6.5 23.1

Ⅳ 7.0 22.9

Ⅴ 7.2 22.8

Ⅵ 7.5 22.9

Ⅶ 7.6 22.9

【Reference:Outside the pedestal※3 】Dose rate:Max. 43[Gy/h]Temp.:Max. 23.7[℃]

※1:Calibrated with Cs-137 radiation source※2:Error:Dosimeter: ±7%

Temp. Gauge: ±0.5℃※3:Reference value because measurement

equipment is housed inside the investigation unit

Positions where pan-tilt camera

stopped in the previous

investigation

Temperature was approximately constant regardless of measurement height.

Dose inside the pedestal tended to increase as we approached the bottom of pedestal.

10

Approx. 0.15m

Approx. 0.05m

Approx. 0.1m

Approx. 1.0m

Approx.0.65m

Approx. 0.6m

Page 12: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

11

5. Summary In preparation to remove fuel debris we have made attempts to ascertain conditions

inside the reactor through internal investigations, researched and developed grasping and cutting mechanisms, and deliberated the practical application of R&D achievements in the field.

The following information was obtained from this contact investigation:

1)Characteristics of fuel debris

We have tried to deduce the characteristics of fuel debris in the course of deliberating methods for grasping pebble-like fuel debris and methods for removing stone-like fuel debris that entail cutting the debris.

During the contact investigation we found out that it is possible to grasp and move pebble-like deposits and structure-shaped deposits, but also that there are hard stone-like deposits that cannot be grasped.

By moving the camera closer to the deposits than ever before we obtained images that will help us estimate the shape and size of deposits.

2)Information about the environment inside the Primary Containment Vessel

We confirmed for the first time that dose levels tend to increase as we approached the bottom of the PCV inside the pedestal. And, as observed during the previous investigation, it was confirmed that dose levels inside the pedestal tend to be lower than outside the pedestal, and that temperature is approximately constant regardless of measurement height.

We will leverage this information to deliberate future internal investigations and fuel debris removal methods (such as locations for removal, device design, etc.).

Page 13: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

Reference: Measurement points of reference dose rate

12

Measured in 2017(estimated from noise of camera image)

Measured in 2017(calculated by integral dosimeter)

Measured during this investigation Measured for reference during this investigation※1

* Measured in January, 2018 × Measured for reference in January, 2018※1

※1:Reference value because measurement equipment is housed inside the investigation unit

Rough position of guide pipe (when inserted or withdrawn)

Rough position of guide pipe (when extendable pipe extended)

Lower thanApprox.10Gy/h

footing Approx. 70Gy/h

Approx. 80Gy/h

Approx. 70Gy/h

Not exceeding approx. 10Gy/h

PCV

X-6 penetration

CRD rail

Pedestal

Suspendedceiling

Approx. 0.7m

Approx.0.9m

Approx. 6.8m

6.4Gy/h※2

(Measurement point Ⅰ)

28Gy/h19Gy/h※2

42Gy/h43Gy/h※2

CRD housing

15Gy/h13Gy/h※2

×

Approx. 2.6m Approx. 0.9m

Approx. 1.2m

Approx. 0.4m

20Gy/h18Gy/h※2

7Gy/h(Measurement point a)

× × ×

×

19Gy/h13Gy/h※2

※2:Measurement points used during this investigation are not all the same as the previous investigation because of the differences in investigation unit specifications.

Page 14: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

Outside of PC(Inside the reactor building)

Platform

Alternative shield

Isolation valve

Extendable pipe

Guide pipe

PCV

Cable drum

Tip bending control unit

PCV penetration pipe

(X-6 penetration)

Platform

Alternative shield

Pedestal

Guide pipe

PCV

Tip bending control unit

PCV penetration pipe

(X-6 penetration)

Reactor building

Reactor buildingFiled office

Field office

Investigation unit is controlled from the remote operation room.

During investigation unit installation

During investigation

Field workers insert and withdraw the investigation unit, install cable drum, and extend/retract the extendable pipe, etc. in front of the X-6 penetration.

※Structures not relevant to the PCV internal investigation have been omitted.

・Exposure dose on February 13, 2019(Investigation date)Planned:3.00[mSv/day] Actual:Avg. 0.26[mSv/person] Max. 0.68[mSv]

Reference: Positional relationship between work area and dose measurement area

13

Outside the pedestal Inside the

pedestal

Inside the PCV (Dose measurement area)

Pedestal

During remote operation of the investigation unit, field workers retreat to a low-dose area in order to avoid unnecessary exposure.

Lowering and raising of the investigation unit, camera/light operation and dose/temperature measurements are all performed by remote control from the remote operation room.

Isolation valve

Page 15: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

14

Reference: Previous investigation results (January, 2018)

Worker access openingBottom of pedestal

垂直断面図

Telescopic investigation device

CRD housing

CRD rails

Middle work platform

Cable tray

CRDreplacement mechanism

Platform

Measurement pointa

Measurement point b

Measurement pointc

Measurement pointd

Approx. 0.3m

Approx. 0.4m

Approx. 1.0m

Approx. 0.6m

Platform top

Bottom surface of pedestal

Approx. 3.2m

Measurementpoint

Dose rate※1,2

[Gy/h]Temp.※2

[℃]

a 7 21.0

b 8 21.0

c 8 21.0

d 8 21.0

【Reference:Outside the pedestal※3 】Dose rate:Max. 42[Gy/h]Temp.:Max. 21.1[℃]

※1:Calibrated with Cs-137 radiation source※2:Error:Dosimeter:±7%

Temp. gauge:±0.5℃※3:Reference value because measurement

equipment is housed inside the investigation unit

Fallen grating①

Fallen grating②

Page 16: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

15

Reference: Environmental impact(1/2)

There was no impact on the surrounding environment from radiation during the internal investigation of the Unit 2 primary containment vessel conducted on February 13.

During the investigation a boundary was formed to prevent the gases inside the containment vessel from leaking into the external environment.

No significant fluctuation in data from monitoring posts and dust monitors were seen neither prior to, nor after, the investigation.

Data from monitoring posts and dust monitors near site boundaries can be found on our website.

URL:https://www4.tepco.co.jp/en/nu/fukushima-np/f1/index-e.htmlhttps://www4.tepco.co.jp/en/nu/fukushima-np/f1/dustmonitor/index-e.html

• Radiation levels include contributions from radiation sources other than those inside the primary containment vessel.

(Reference)Website Excerpt

Page 17: Fukushima Daiich Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 …...February 28, 2019 Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings, Inc. Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station Unit 2 Primary Containment

16

Reference: Environmental impact(2/2)

During the internal investigation of the Unit 2 primary containment vessel conducted on February 13 plant parameters were continuously monitored and no significant fluctuations were seen in the temperature of the primary containment vessel neither prior to, nor after, the investigation. There were also no changes in the cold shut down status of the reactor.

Primary containment vessel internal temperature data can be viewed on our website.

URL:https://www4.tepco.co.jp/en/nu/fukushima-np/f1/plantdata/unit2/rpv_index-e.html

(Reference)Website Excerpt