H>adi>th al-Da>r

Muhammad b. Jari>r al-T>abari> narrates in his Tafsi>r and Ta>ri>kh:

Isna>d

Salama -- Muh>ammad b. Ish>a>q -- *Abd al-Ghaffa>r b. al-Qa>sim – al-

Manha>l b. *Amr -- *Abd Allah b. al-H>a>rith b. Nawfal b. al-H>a>rith b. *Abd

al-Mut>t>alib -- *Abd Allah b. *Abba>s -- *Ali> b. Abi> T>a>lib

Ibn Kathi>r (vol. 3, p364) accuses *Abd al-Ghaffa>r b. al-Qa>sim (Abu>

Maryam) of being a Shi*i> and a fabricator of H>adi>th

The fact is that *Abd al-Ghaffa>r b. al-Qa>sim was a companion of Imam

al-Ba>qir (as) and Imam al-S>a>diq (as) [See Khu^i> no. 8226/6604],

considered reliable by Naja>shi>.