Hidhayathul Anam Ila Ziyarathul Auliyal Il Kiram

8/8/2019 Hidhayathul Anam Ila Ziyarathul Auliyal Il Kiram

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hidhayathul-anam-ila-ziyarathul-auliyal-il-kiram 1/119

!

!

aqkibk<Kz<!neil<!.!-zi!\qbivk<kqz<!nu<zqbi!-z<!gqvil<!.!oh/k/Lal<lK!hig<gI!siaqH!fi%I!

Hk<kgl<!Okjuh<hMOuiI!okimIH!ogit<tUl<!;[email protected]

!

1

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

ohiVtmg<gl<!!kjzh<H! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!hg<gl!!

F~z<!Nvl<hl<! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 13! !

uzq!we<huI!biI@! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 14! !uzqBz<zia<uqe<!lgk<Kul<! ! ! ! ! ! 16!

l <euq!]iQH!Lpg<gl<! ! ! ! ! ! ! 18!

Gzq <kie<!Ohikje!! ! ! ! ! ! ! 18!

Gk<hqe<!ohVjl! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 19!

uzqbqe<!Nvl<hl<! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 22!

lv{k<kqx<gh<hiZl<!abik<K{<mi@! ! ! ! ! 23!

hk<kqiqjgbqz<!outq!uf<k!osb<kq! ! ! ! ! 35!

u Qzi!Okmzili@! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 38!

u Qzi! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 56!

gxilk<K!d{<mi@! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 6:!

gh<V?!\qbivk<K!%Mli@! ! ! ! ! ! ! 84!

\qbivk<kqe<!yPr<G!Ljx!! ! ! ! ! ! 94!

gHjv!Lk<klqmzili@! ! ! ! ! ! ! 98!

ogic!Wx<xzili@! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! :8!

dI^|!)gf<K~iq*!fmk<kzili@! ! ! ! ! ! ::!

OfIs<js!osb<bzili@! ! ! ! ! ! ! 217!

gHVgtqz<!OhiIju!OhiIk<kzili@! ! ! ! ! 221! !

sf<kel<!H,szili@!H]<hl<!Ohimzili@!! ! uisjek<!kqvuqbr<gt<! sil<Hvi{q!Hjg!Ohimzili@!

LcUjv! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 225!!



!

!


Hk<kgl<!Okjuh<hMOuiI!okimIH!ogit<tUl<!;[email protected]!

2

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!!

aqkibk<Kz<!neil<!.!-zi!\qbivk<kqz<!nu<zqbi!-z<!gqvil<!

aqkibk<Kz!neil<!.!-zi!\qbivk<kqz<!nu<zqbi!-z<!gqvil<!!! wz<zih<!HgPl<!nz<zia<Ug<GvqbK/!!^zuik<!wEl<!gVj{Bl<!^zil<! wEl<! =Omx<xLl<! wl<ohVlieiI! Lal<lK! L <khi!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! lQ kqZl<! nuIgtK!gqjtbqeI?!OkipIgt<!njeuIgt<!lQ kqZl<!d{<miukig/!!! -g<gizk<kqz<! gx<OxiIgtqz<! sqzI! d{<jlg<G! lixig! uq]lh<!hqvsivR<!osb<uK!uVf<kk<kg<gK/!gz<uqbqe<!Le<Oex<xk<kiz<!fe<jlgt<!hz!d{<migqbqVh<hqEl<!-g<gzqBgk<kqz<!d{<jlg<Gl<?!sk<kqbk<kqx<Gl<!hR<sligOubqVg<gqe<xK/! nk<kjgb! uq]lh<! hqvsivr<gTt<!

nUzqbig<gjt?! Gk<HliIgjt! fqf<kqh<hKl<?! gh<V! \qbivk<jk! Ägh<V!u{g<gl<!nUzqbih<!H,j\}!we!-pqk<Kg<!%XuKl<?!gxilik<Kg<gjtg<!Ogzq!osb<K!hpqh<hKl<!ye<xiGl</!!! d{<jljb! nxqbikuIgt<?! kie<! nu<uiX! hqkx<xqk<!kqiqgqxiIgote<xiz<?!nxqf<kuIgt<! %m!d{<jljbg<! %xiK! uib<&c!-Vh<hK!kie<!uqf<jkbig!-Vg<gqe<xK/!! hîK!Gph<hk<kqx<G!nR<sq!oltelig! -Vh<huIgt<! Sbligk<! kr<gt<! nhqh<hqvibr<gjtg<!%xiuqm<miZl<!ng<%x<jx!lXk<K!Le<OeiIgt<!ogiMk<kqVg<Gl<!Ähk<ui}!wEl<! liIg<gk<! kQIh<jhbigqZl<! wMk<Kg<! gi{<hqg<gziOl/! nke<!

giv{lig! nuIgt<! d{<jljb!d{If<K! Ofvie! hijkbqz<! fmg<g!nE%zlibqVg<Gl</!nuIgtK!uq]lh<!hqvsivk<kqz<!gx<OxiIgt<!kr<gt<!guek<jks<! osZk<kiK! g{<&ck<kelibqVh<hK! OfIjlbe<X/! Ohbe<!wxqBl<! gz<Zl<! nhibk<jk! uqjtuqg<Glijgbiz<! njkk<! kMk<K!fqXk<k! Ou{<Ml</! nu<uiOx! uq]lk<kelie! hqvsivk<jkk<! kMk<K!fqXk<kq! olb<!-e<eoke!lg<gTg<G!wMk<Kjvk<Kg<! gim<m!Ou{<cbK!gmjlbiGl</!!! uzq! we<huI! biI@! ne<eivK! lgk<Kul<! biK@! uzqbqe<!Nvl<hole<e@!lUk<Kg<Gh<!hqe<El<!nuIgTg<G!abik<K{<mi@!gxilk<!

wEl<! nx<Hkr<gt<! gi{<hqg<g! nuIgTg<G! uz<zjlB{<mi@! nuIgt<!hiz<!u^Q zi!wEl<!dkuq!Okmzili@!fim<m!Okm<mr<gjt!fqjxOux<xqg<!ogiMg<g! nuIgTg<Gk<! kk<KuL{<mi@! gHVg<G! wkqOv! jggm<c!^qbivk<Ks<! osb<bzili@! ogic! Wx<xzili@! d' <! .! gf<K~iq!fmk<kzili@! OfIs<jsgt<! osb<bzili@! gHXgjtObi! nux<xqe<!uisx<hcgjtObi! Lk<klqmzili@! OhiIju?! H,?! H]<hl<! Ohimzili@!



!

!



3

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

we<he!kx<OhiK!uquikk<kqx<G!dvqbjubibqVg<gqe<xe/!-ju!Ohie<x!Jbuqeig<gjt! oktqf< <K! okiqb! GINe<?! akQ K?! -\<lid?! gqbi^<!ogi{<Ml<?! siqk<kqv! Nkivr<! ogi{<Ml<! nk<kim<sqgt<! kVgqe<Oxil</!!nxqUjmObiI!nxqf<K{Ig"!!! uqtr<g! sg<kqbx<OxiI! tiaqI?! hik<kqe<! -u<uqv{<Ml<!yVr<Ogbjlf<k! nxqRI! ohVlg<gtie! d{<jl! dzlig<gtqml<!Ogm<Mk<!okvqf<Kogit<g/!!! ÄÄfQr<gt<! nxqbikuIgtibqVh<hqe<! )L]iakiUjmb*! nxqU!ohx<xuIgtqml<!Ogm<Mk<!okiqf<K!ogit<Tr<gt<}}!we<hK!kqVljx!)27;54*!OhikjebiGl</!!

uzq!we<huI!biI@!!! nzzia<uqe! gm<mjtgjtBl<! x^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgtqe<!OhikjegjtBl<!sqvOlx<ogi{M!ÄÄkQe<}}!wEl<! se<liIg<g! ofxqbqz<! fmf<K?! ]iQnk<.kiQgk<.agQgk<! wEl<!le< qzgjth<!hch<hcbigg<!gmf<K?!-Xkqbqz<!lniqhk<!wEl!siSuk!Ohiqe<h! uQm<jmbjmfK! fqk<kqb!\Qujeh<! ohx<xuIgOt! nzzia<uqe<!nUzqbig<gtiuiIgt</!!! wl<ohVlieiI! x^|Oz! giQ l<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<?! ÄÄfie<! gz<uqbqe<! hm<m{l< < </! nzq! nke<! uibqz<}}! we<hkigk<!kr<gtK! uiiqsig! o^b<bqKei! nzq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjts<!Sm<cg<!gim<cBt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄnxqRIgOt! fhqliIgtqe<! uiiqSgt<}}! we<hK! lx<oxiV! fibg!uig<gqbl</!!! nu<uiX!olb<bxquqe<!LkqIs<sqbiz<!fhqgt<!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK! uiiqsigg<! %cbuIgjth<! hx<xq?!ÄÄwe<Ejmb! s&gk<kiIgtqZt<t! nxqRIgt<! heQ! - <xibQ zqZt<t!fhqliIgjth<! Ohie<xuIgtiuI}}!we<hkig!fhqgTg<gvsI!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!kqVuib<!lzIf<kVtqBt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄweK! âihik<! OkipIgt<! fm<sk<kqvr<gjth<! Ohie<Xt<tiIgt</!!

nuIgTt<! wujvg<! ogi{<M! hqe<hx<xqeiZl<! fQr<gt<! OfIupq!ohx<xuIgtiuQ Igt<}}!we<hkigUl<!fhqgm<kqzgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!)lq]<gik<K*!!! fhq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK! d{<jl!uiiqsigUl<?! nxquqe<! uibqzigul<! kqgpg<%cb! o^b<bqKei! nzq!



!

!



4

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! lx<Xl<! âihig<gt<! -e<El<!OuX! ohiqbiIgtqz<! fqe<Xl<! Nvl<hlie! Ne<l! sf<kkqbigqb!Ä^qz< qziuqe<}! okimIH! ogi{<M?! nEhu! upqgjth<! hx<xqb!liIg<gr<gjtk<! okiqf<okiPgqb! giv{k<kiz<?! Ä-z<Lz<zKeeQ}! wEl<!-jxsiIhqzqVf<K! nVth<hMl<! olb<R<Rie! hig<gqbl<! ohx<xiIgt</!!ose<x! gizk<kqb! fhqliIgt<! L0\qîk<K! wEl<! nx<Hkr<gjt!gi{<hqk<kjkh<! Ohiz<! -uIgt<! gxilik<K! wEl<! nx<Hkr<gjtg<!gim<ceiIgt</!ohVlieiI!Lal<lK!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgtK! dk<kqvjuh<! ohxg<%cb! kqV]<c! uib<f<kuIgtib<!uip<f<kiIgt</! nuIgtK! Wuz<! hqvgivl<! dzgqe<! hz! higr<gTg<Gl<!ose<X!ÄÄkQe<}}!SmI!ogiPk<kqb!lgie<gTg<Og!-g<gijz!nUzqbi!we<x!ohbI! upr<gq! uVgqxK/! -uIgOt! fibgl<! Lal<lK! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgTjmb!hqvkqfqkqgt<!d{<jl!uiiqSgt</!!! ÄdlK! -jxue<! Huqbqz<! fqpjz! wu<uiX! hvh<hqbqVg<gqe<xie<!we<hjk!fQ I!hiIg<guqz<jzbi}!)36;56*!weUl<!ÄÄH,lqjb!fil<!uqiqh<hig<gq!)nkqz<*! ljzgjt! Ljtgtib<! Ng<guqz<jzbi@}}! )89;7?8*! weUl<!

N{<mue<! keK! hiqSk<kk<! kqVljxbqz<! %xqBt<tie</! ! -ju!nUzqbig<gjth<! hx<xqb! Gxqh<Ohbil</! -k<kjgb! olb<bcbiIgjtob!-jxue<! Äfqpz<}! )tqz<Z*! we<Xl<?! ljz! )\qhiz<*! we<Xl<!uV{qk<Kt<tie</!)'a|z<!hbie<!kh< Q I!olik<kl<!21!higr<gt<!d{<M/!nkqz<! 5.uK! higl<! 2::.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<?! 21.uK! higl<! 3:4.uK!hg<gLl<!Ofim<mlqMg*!!! ÄÄweK! ncbie<! fhqzie! u{g<gr<gjtBl<! uqVh<Hme<! Oh{qs<!osb<hueig! fQ r<gi! u{<{ligq! weK! LMGkjzh<! ohXl<! u{<{l<!ofVr<gq! fie<! nuje! Ofsqg<Gl<! ntUg<G! NgquqMgqxie</! ! fie<!

nuje!Ofsqk<Kuqm<OmOebieiz<!nue<!Ogm<Gl<!gikigUl<!.!hiIg<Gl<!g{<{igUl<! .! hqcg<Gl<! gvligUl<! .! fmg<Gl<! hikligUl<! fie<!NgquqMgqOxe<}}! we<X! nz<zia|kNzi! %Xukig! akQ K! Gk< qbqz<!uf<Kt<tK/!)âQa|z<!Hgiiq*!!! hXzie! u{g<gr<gjts<! osb<uKme<?! fhqzie! u{g<gr<gjtg<!ogi{<Ml<! N{<mue<! hqiqbl<! jug<Gl<! ujvbqz<! gzh<hx<x! uqklig!u{g<gl<! osb<K! nuetuqz<! heiuigq! -v{<mx<x! fqjzjlbqzigq!uqm<miz<!nuVjmb!osuq?!g{<?!&g<G?!fig<G?!jg?!giz<!-e<El<!-kv!dXh<Hgt<! njek<Kl<! N{<mueK! osiz<?! osbz<! outqbiGl<!

kier<gtigqe<xe/! nju?! nueK! osbz<gjts<! osb<gqe<xe/!!N{<muEjmb! fim<mk<kqZt<tjubjek<Kl<! ne<eiI! &zl<!fqgPgqe<xe/! N{<muEjmb! sg<kqbieK! nsziGl</! ncbiEjmb!sg<kq! N{<mueiz<! nVm<ogijmbig?! -vuzigg<! ogiMg<gh<hm<mkiGl</!!nUzqbig<gt<! nz<zia<uqe<! ne<hqz<! )lah<hk<kqz<*! jlbzie!giv{k<kiz<! -f<ks<! sg<kq! nuIgTg<Gh<! hig<gqblieK/! ! weOu!



!

!



5

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

-jxueK! gm<mjth<hc! nR<sqh<! hbf<K! kg<uis<! osb<K! o\bl<!ohx<xuIgtiehcbiz<! nuIgt<kie<! fhqliIgTjmb! uiiqS!hik<kqbk<kqx<Giqb!nUzqbig<gtig!uqtr<Ggqe<xiIgt</!!! hzkvh<hm<m! nf<k^<Kg<gjt! djmbuIgtig! uzqliIgjt!nz<zia<! Ng<gqjuk<K! lieqmIgjt! Ofvie! hijkjb! uqm<Ml<!upqkuxq! fisljmbikqVg<Gl<! ohiVm<M! upqgim<cgtigUl<!-vm<sgIgtigUl<!nuIgjt!nz<zia<!Ng<gq!juk<Kt<tie</!!

uzqBzziauqe!lgk<Kul!!! uzq! we<El<! hkl<! Äuzi}! we<x! &zk<kqzqVf<K! hqxf<kjlbiz<!nh<hkk<kqx<G!silQ hl<?!sim<sqbl<!we<X!ohiVt<hMl</! ÄÄleqke<!weK!-vgsqbl<?!fie<!nueK!-vgsqbl<}}!)nz<-e< iE!^qIiQ?! une qIVa|*! we<X! nz<zia<! %xqbkig! akQ K! GK^qbqz<!uf<Kt<tK/!!! lieqmje!-jxue<!keg<Gh<!hqvkqfqkqbig<gq!dzgqZt<t!wz<zig<!gVlr<gjtBl<!nue<!usl<!yh<hjmk<K!nujek<!keg<Gl<!ke<Ejmb!sqV]<cgTg<Gl<! -jmOb! fMjlblib<! fqXk<kq?! sqV]<cgt<!N{<muEjmb! k\z<zqjbg<! ogi{<M! giqf<K! Ohigilz<!gih<hix<xg<%cb! kqjvbig! Ng<gqbqVh<hkiz<! lieqme<! N{<muEjmb!dZ~aqb<bk<Kjmb! k\z<zqbqz<! outqbigq! uqm<mie</!!dZ~aqb<bk<Kjmb! k\z<zq! yVueqz<! outqbieiz<! nue<!N{<mueqmk<kqz<! osif<klie! sqz! hkuqgjth<! ohXuie</! ! nu<uqkl<!ohx<xKl<! nue<! dzgk<kiI! sgzVg<Gl<! Äxa<lk<}! kigq! uqMuie</!!NgOukie<?!nUzqbig<gt<!N{<mueK!hqvkqfqkqgtig!-Vg<gqe<xeI/!!! wr<rel<! fhq! giQl<! ^zzz<zia|! njzaq! u^zzl<! nuIgt<!

dzgk<kiIgTg<G! nVmhqtl<H! )xa<lKe<zqz! NzlQe<*! Ng!-Vg<gqe<xiIgOti! nr<reOl! nUzqbig<gjt! N{<mue<!ngqzk<kiVg<G! gqVjhbitvigh<! Huqbqe<! g{<! d{<mig<gq!-Vg<gqe<xie</! Njgbiz<?! nuIgTl<! nuEjmb! hqvkqfqkqgtigOu!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt<?! nuIgt<! osiz<uK! nz<zia<! osiz<uKkie</! nK!nz<zia<Ujmb!ncbiiqe<!fiuqzqVf<K!outqbieiZl<!siqOb!we<hkig!l^<euQ .]iQ hqz<! oltziei! Lal<lK! \ziZk<kQ e<! 'lq!xa<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!nuIgt<!uzqBXk<kqg<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! x^|Zg<G! upqh<hMuK! nz<zia<Ug<G! upqh<hMuoke<Xl< <?!x^|Zjmb!gvk<jk!nz<zia<!ke<Ejmb!gvole<Xl<?! x^|Zz<ziaq!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! wxqf<k! l{<j{! nz<zia<! kiOe!wxqf<kkiBl<! GINe<! ]iQ hqz<! gi{h<hMl<! Nbk<Kgotz<zil<!



!

!



6

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

fhqohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgTg<G!diqbkibqVf<k! OhikqZl<?! Gk<HliIgt<?! NiqhQ e<gt<! .! gilzQ e<gt<! .!nUzqbig<gt<! îzqaQ e<gt<! NgqObijvBl<! siIf<kjuOb/! Woeeqz<!-uIgt<!njeuVl<?!ÄÄdzlig<gt<!ne<hqbig<gTjmb!uiiqSgt<}}!we<x!akQKh<! hqvgivl<?! kqVk<K~kI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgtK!d{<jl!uiiqSgtiuI/!!! ÄÄfie<! nz<zia<Ujmb! ytqbqz<! fqeXLttue<;! sgz!u^<Kg<gTl<! we<Ejmb! ytqbqz<! fqe<XLttju}}!)nelqe<E~vqzziaq! .! uGzZj]bqe<! lqeE~iQ*! we<X! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! %xqbqVh<hjk!Nvibf<K{If<OkiI!yVuiX!nxquI/!!! sqV]<cgt<! njek<Kl<! fhqgt<! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgTjmb!O\ikqbqz<!sl<hf<kh<hm<mkibqEl<?!nf<k!O\ikq!N{<mujes<!siIf<kOkbil</!!wf<k!u^<KUg<Gl<!ogiMg<gh<hmik!uqjz!lkqg<goui{<{i! li{qg<gligqb! hGk<kxqU?! hjmh<Hgtqz<! Olzie!

hjmh<higqb! -e< ie<! wEl<! lieqmEg<G! lm<cZOl! ogiMg<gh<!hm<cVg<gqxK!we<hK!oum<m!outqs<slig!uqtr<gg<!gqmg<gqe<xK/!nf<kh<!hGk<kxqjug<!ogi{<M!lieqme<?!fie<! wEl<!neieqb<bk<jkh<! Ohig<gq!uqm<miz<! kiqh<hm<cVh<hK! fhq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgtqe<! F~I! we<El<! O\ikqh<! hqvgisOlkie</! nr<reOl! nlz<!osb<K! nf<k! F~vqz<! kiqhm<cVh<huIgt<! uzqliIgt<! %m<mk<jks<!OsIf<kuIgtiuI/! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!djmb! hqvkqfqkqgtiuI/! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<<!nuIgTjmb!hqvkqfqkqgt<!dt<vr<gk<kqz<!)agQ gk<kqz<*!nz<zia<Ujmb!hqvkqfqkqgOtbiuI/! -uIgjth<! hqe<hx<Xkz<! OfI! upqbiGl</! Woeeqz<?!

-uIgotz<ziVl<! nz<zia<Ujmb! n <li^qhik<K! outqbiGl<!lt<aV!)kiel<*!Ng!-Vh<hkiz<!-uIgt<!nueK!hqvkqfqkqgtibqVf<K!a|g<Lgjt! outqh<hMk<Kgqe<xiIgt</! -uIgTjmb! fim<ml<?! osiz<?!osbz<! njek<Kl<! nuEjmbkibqVh<hkiz<! -e<euIgTg<G!upqh<hMkz<! agQ gk<kqz<! nuEg<G! upqh<hMkOzbiGl</! -uIgTg<G!lix<xR<!osb<kz<!nuEg<Og!lix<xl<!osb<kziGl</!!

! -jxuEl<! GINe<! ]iQ hqz<?! ÄÄx^|Zg<G! upqhmmuI!fqs<sblig! nzzia<Ug<G! upqhhmmuviuI}}! )5;91*! we<Xl<<?!ÄÄwuoeiVue!nzzia<Ug<Gl<! x^|Zg<Gl<! liX! osb<uiOei!nue<! fqs<sblig! oumm! outqs<slie! upqOgmczieie<}}!we<Xl<?! ÄÄY?! =lie<! ogi{<muIgOt"! nz<ziaUg<G! upqh<hMr<gt</!-eEl<! x^|Zg<Gl<! dr<gtqz<! fqe<XLt<t! giiqb! gIk<kIgTg<Gl<!)kQjeh<! hvh<hg%cb! dzlig<gTg<Gl<?! nUzqbig<gTg<Gl<*!upqh<hMrgt<}}! )5;6:*! we<Xl<! %xqBt<tie</! )kh< Q I! ghQ I?! 4.uK! higl<?!



!

!



7

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

354.uK! hg<gl<.kh< Q I! 'a|z<hbie<?! 2.uK! higl<! 735.uK! hg<gl<!gi{<g/*!!! Äwe<Ejmb! nUzqbig <gt<! weK! hiqum<mk<kqx<GttqVh<huIgt</!!

wejek<!kuqv!OuX!biVl<!nuIgjt!nxqb!lim<miIgt<}!we<x!akQ K!GK^q!nUzqbig<gtqe<!lgk<Kuk<kqx<G!fx<sim<sqbig!-Vg<gqe<xK/!!

!!OlZl<?!l <eu!]vQH!LprGujkh<!hiVrgt<;.!!ÄÄnUzqbig<gt<!N{<muEg<G!dgh<hieuIgt<!.!

! nf<kvr<g?!hgqvr<g!uq]br<gjt!nxqf<kuIgt<!.!

Lkzg<gie!nz<zia<Ug<G!nUzqbig<gt!g{<{icbieuIgt<!.!

nUzqbig<gt!nz<zia<uqe<!osif<klie!!

! g{<{icbig!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt<!.!

yuouiV!uzqBl<!F~a|!njzaq^<^zil<!

! djmb!gh<hz!we<X!nxq!

-uIgjt!Ofsqk<kiz<!fisl<!we<El!out<tk<kqz<!

! fqe<Xl<!kh<hqk<Kg<!ogit<uib<!

nz<zia<UmeqVg<gh<!hqiqbLt<tuIgt<!

! nUzqbig<gTjmb!sLgk<kqz<!-Vh<hiIgtig!.!

nUzqbig<gTjmb!sLgk<kqz<!fqe<Xl<!uqzgq!

! -Vh<hQIgOtbieiz<?!dt<vr<gkkqz<!

nz<zia<ju!uqm<Ml!kie<!!

! uqzgq!-Vg<gqe<xIgt<}}!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

! ! ! ! Gzq^kie <!Ohikqg<gqe<xkiuK!;.!!

! ÄÄnUzqbig<gTjmb! Lfkijejbh<! hx<xqh<! hqch<hkqz<!hbl! Ou{mil/! Woeeqz<?! F~a|! njzaq < zil<!nuIgOticVg<jgbqz<! out<tk<jkh<! hx<xqb! ns<sl<! wkx<G"}}! NgOu?!-jxue<! ne<X! ne<hqb<big<gjtg<! ogi{<M! fmk<kqbux<jx! wz<zil<!-eX! nUzqbig<gjt! ogi{<Mkie! fmk<Kgqe<xie</! nuIgjt!Le<eqm<Om! dzgLl<! fqjzohx<xqVg<gqe<xK/! ! Njgbiz<! ÄÄuzqjb!



!

!



8

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

nxquK! nzzia<ju! nxqujkuqm! lqgg<! gcel<}}! we<hkig! 'a|z<!hbie<!higl<!:?!642.uK!hg<gl<;!higl<!21?!hg<gl<!:!%Xgqe<xe/!!

Gk<hqe<!ohVjl!

! dzgqz<! Wg! gizk<kqz<! hz! w{<{qg<jgBt<t?! hzujg!

hck<kvrgt<! djmb! nUzqbiggt! .! GKHliIgt<! .! nh<kizgt<! .!nUk<kiKgt<! .! Fghig<gt! .! F\hig<gt! we<x! hkuq! djmbuIgt<?!dzg! LcU! fit<ujvbqz<! -Vf<Ok! uVuiIgt<! we<Xl<?! agQgk<kqz<!=VzjgBl<! g{<gi{qh<huIgt<! nuIgt<! kioee<Xl<?! nuIgjt!Le<eqm<Om! hzib<?! L Qhk<Kgt<! uqzg<gh<hMukiBl<! akQKgt<! hz!gi{h<hMgqexe?!ne<eiI!njeuVg<Gl!Gk<Oh!nkqhviuiI/!ne<eijv!ogtK!we<Xl!osizzh<hMl</!!-K!hx<xqb!Nkivr<gt<!hz!-Vh<hqEl<!sqzux<jx!lm<cZl!-r<Gg<!Gxqh<hqMuK!OhiKoleg<!gVKgqe<Oxil</!!! ÄÄN{<mui"!we<!lQ K!fhqliIgt<!fmf<K!kqiqf<kiIgt<?!nuIgTg<Gh<!hqxG! fhqgt<! ohVlie<!Lal<lK!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgjts<! Slf<kqVf<Oke</! kx<OhiK! nuIgTl<! ose<X! uqm<miIgOt?!fie<!keqk<Kuqm<OmOe?!we<!lQ K!wf<k!fhqBl<!-z<jzOb}}!we<hkib<!H,lq!hqvzihqk<K!-jxueqml<!Ljxbqm<Mg<!ogi{<mK/!!! Äfie<! sqz!nUzqbig<gjt!nEh<HOue</!nuIgtK!-Vkbr<gt<!fhqliIgtK! -Vkbr<gjth<! OhizqVg<Gl</! nuIgt<! BgLcU! ujv!

de<! lQ K!sR<siqh<hiIgt<}! we<X!N{<mue<! H,lqg<G!nxquqk<kie< < < <<; we<x!-u<uq]bk<jk!îzqaie?!-jxbVt<!Ofsvie?!ohiqbiI!yVuI!klK!dzg! bik<kqjvbqe<! OhiK?! fqk<kqb! \Q uEjmb! a\<vk<! gqZX!njzaq <^zil<! nuIgjts<! sf<kqk<k! slbl<! ne<eijvg<! Ogm<Mk<!okiqf<K! ogi{<mkig?! ÄluiaqHz<! l\Q K! hQ ! leigqhq! ]iaqz<alQ K}!wEl<!gqvf<kk<kqz<!gi{h<hMgqxK/!!

! ÄÄnf<k! nUzqbig <gt! Wgk<kqz<! 551! OhIgt</! nuIgTt<!

F\hig<gt! 411?! Fghig <gt! 81?! nh<kiz<gt! 51?! ngqbiIgt<!

21?! dxhig<gt! 8?! ne<uiIgt<! 6?! nUk<kiKgt<! 5?!

Lgk<kiIgt<! 4?! GKH! yVuI/! Gk<Oh! njeuVg<Gl!

nkqhviuiI/! -e<eijv! ogtK! we<Xl! osiz<zhhMl</!

-uIgTt<! biVl<! lv{liuiIgtibqe<! nuIgTg<gMk<k!

)kv\i*! hck<kvk<kqzqVh<huIgt<! nf<k! ^<kiek<kqx<G!

lix<xhhMuiIgt</! ! nr<r{l<! hkuqbqz<! dbIk <kh<hMl<! OhiK?!

gp<h<hck<kvk<kqZt<t! F\hig<gt! gizqbiGlqmk<kqz<!

îzqaQe<gtie! L^<zQl<gtqz<! yVuI! nf<kk! kiek<kqz<!

nlIk<kh<! hMuiI}}! we<X! gqZX! njzaq <^zil<! nuIgt<!



!

!



9

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

%xqbkig! leigqHGk<hqz<! l\Q kq^<j^bqK! ]ia|z<! alQ kqz<!li{qg<gh<H,ibqqz<!lUzqkqf<!fi%iqb<bqz<!lIgkq}!we<x!gqk<kihqz<!likqa|I!v^|z<!nz<zilK]<!j]G!^kg<gk<Kz<ziaqz<!giaqiqb<bq <!^qk<kQ g<gq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK!sQ mI!nz<zili!NiqHhqz<zia<!la<&K! kQ hq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTl<?! luiaqHz<!l\Q K! hQ ! leigqhq! ]iaqz<alQK! wEl<! gqk<kihqz<?! gibz<hm<m{k<kqz<!hqxf<K! gQpg<gjvbqz<! nmr<gq! -Vg<Gl<! lih<hqt<jt! ozh<jh! Nzql<!we<x! nz<zilk<Kz<! hitqz<! j^bqK! Lal<lK! NiqHhqz<ziaq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTl<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! -ju!Ohie<x!hz!nH,Iu!uqtg<gr<gjt!Äl\<&!nk<KI!vîbqz<!3.uK!higl<!375.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!Äxk<Kz<!La<k<kiI}!-bx<xqb!nz<zili!-HE! NhQ kQ e<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! uqhvlig!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!! OlZl<! -lil<! ]0vieq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!Änz<buig<gQ k<K! uz<! \uiaqI}! we<El<! gqvf<kk<kqz<! Gk<HliIgtqe<!

kv\i?!hkuqgjt!uquvlig!wPkqBt<tiIgt</!!-e<El<?!-lil<!-HE!a\I! lg<gQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! kr<gt<! Ähkiui!akQkqb<biuqZl<}!uqvquig!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<?!we<Ejmb!dl<lk<Kgtqz<!fix<hK!fhIgt<!fhq!-HviaQl<!njzaq <^zil<! nuIgTjmb! -Vkbk<jkBjmbuIgtib<! we<Xl<!-Vf<Ok! uVuI/! nz<zia<kNzi! nf<k! fhIgjtg<! ogi{<M!H,Ozigk<kqz<! uiPhuIgjt! uqm<Ml<! hq{qgjth<! Ohig<Guqh<hie</!nuIgTg<gig! ljpjbh<! ohipqbs<! osb<uie</! ne<euIgjtg<!ogi{<Mkie<! H,Ozigk<kqZt<tuIgTg<G! dkuq! Hiqbh<hMl<! we<hkib<!

wl<ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! kqVuib<!lzIf<kVtqb!akQ K!khxieQ bqz<!gi{g<!gqjmg<gqe<xK/!! Gk<Hg<Og!ogtK!we<X!ohbI/!nuI!yVuVg<Gh<! hqe<! yVuvig!uVuiI/! hjmh<Hgjt! wz<zig<! gVlr<gtqZl<! ne<eiI! -vm<sqg<gg<!%cbuvig!-Vh<hkeiz<!ogtK!we<X!ohbI/!ne<euVg<G!uzl<?!-ml<!-Vhg<gr<gtqZl<! nvsIgTg<G! -Vh<hKOhiz! -V! njls<sIgt<!dt<teI/! ogtK! djmb! dk<kvU! ogi{<M! uzK! hg<glqVh<huI!ljxUzgr<gtie! NzLz<jgH?! NzLz<! lz%k<jk! fqVugqk<K!uVgqe<xiI/!-mK!hg<glqVh<huI?!outqBzglie!NzL]<]aikk<jkg<!

g{<gi{qk<K! uVgqe<xiI! we<x! uqhvk<jk! OuZ~I! hig<gqbik<K^<!îzqaik<K!nvhqg<!gzisijz!lk<vî!^<kihgI?!a\<vk<?!nz<zili?!j]G! nh<Kz<! ua<aiH! îaqH! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgtK!Rie!GV!a\<vk<!NiqH!hqz<ziaq?!nz<zili!j]G!]ia<!Laqbqk<kQ e<! îaqH! OuZ~iq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!



!

!



10

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

\uiaqV <^|Z~g<G! wEl<! gqvf<kk<kqz<! 225.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<! -K! Ohie<x! uqhvr<gt<! 'a|z<hbie<! kh< Q I! higl<! 3?!hg<gl<! 474Zl<?!-HE!nvhq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M!uqhvligs<!osiz<ujk!nxquqg<gh<hMgqxK/!!

! ÄÄnfkvrg?! hgqvrg! Nhk<Kg<gtqz! fqeXl<!Gk<HliIgjtg<!ogi{Om!N{mue!ngqzk<jkh<!hiKgik<Kg<!ogit<gqxie}}! we<X! kh< Q I! 'a|z<hbie<! :.uK! higl<?! 213.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! OlZl<! uqhvligk<! okiqb! L\<k<kaqK?! aihqT! nai! kQ ok!fhuqb<bi?! -lil<! j]G! \ziZk<kQe<! ^|B,k<kq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! -bx<xqb! iqîzi.nz<.ghVk<kiz<Z! nziU\|kqe<!Eghi.uz<.ng<k<kihq.uz<.nu<k<kikq.uz<.nh<kiz<! we<x! F~jzBl<!

nz<zili!hgQ a<!-HE!NhqkQe<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!-bx<xqb!l\<LnKI!vîbqz<!F~jzBl<!Ofim<mlqMg/!!! nUzqbig<gTt<!-V!uGh<hiV{<M?!yV!uGh<hiI!N{<muEjmb!hijkbqz<! g]<mh<hm<Mk<! ok{<ck<K! nuetuqz<! ke<jebpqk<K!heiuigqbuIgt</! -uIgTg<G! g <hQ! we<X! osiz<zh<hMl</! lx<x!uGh<hiI! Nzl<! nIuia<! wEl<! Ne<l! Ozigk<kqOzOb! N{<mueiz<!OkIf<okMg<gh<! hm<muIgt</! -uIgTg<G! Änk<kibQ}! we<X! %xh<hMl</!!Gk<H! ogtKgt<! nk<kibQ ! uGh<jhs<! OsIf<kuIgOt/!)\uiaqV^< |Zg<G!225.uK!hg<gl<!hiIg<g*!

!! Gk<H! we<x! hkk<kqx<G! ÄLjt}! ÄKVul<}! we<Xl<?! ogtK! we<x!hkk<kqxG! Ä-vm<sqh<huI! .! fibe<! Ofim<mlqMl<! ^<kiel<}! we<Xl<!ohiVjth<! hbg<gq! fqx<hqEl<?! nux<xqe<! nf<kvr<gl<! hz! nVl<ohVl<!-vsgqbh<!Hjkbz<gjtk<!ke<Et<!nmg<gqbkib<!njlf<K!gqmg<gqe<xe/!!-e<euIgt<! &zligk<! kie<! Lkzue<! ke<eqVg<jgjb! nxqg<jg!osb<b! Ou{<cbkqVg<gqxK! ne<Oxz<?! nR<Rie! -Vt<hmIf<K! &c?!ngqzl<!nf<kgivk<Kt<tip<f<K!hip<hm<Mh<!OhiMl</!!! -jxue<! ke<ecbiIgTg<G! ntqk<Kt<t! jgl<lixqtg<g!oui{<{ih<! ohVl<! nVm<ogijmgt<! nk<kjejbBl<! yV! km<cZl<?!Gk<jh! nEh<hqk<! kf<k! nVm<ohVr<ogijmjb! lx<oxiV! km<cZl<!juk<K!sQIK~g<gqh<!hiIh<Ohilibqe<?!Gk<hiz<!ohx<x!gqVjhbtOu!gek<K!LXgq!fqx<gg<! gi{<Ohil</!-e<eijvh<!hx<xq!-jxue<!GINe<!]iQhqz<?!ÄÄfqs<sblig! nz<zia<! djmb! nUzqbig<gTg<G! hbole<hKlqz<jz!gujzobe<hKlqzjz}}!we<hkib<!)21;73*!nVtqBt<tie</!!



!

!



11

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

uzqbqe!Nvl<hl<!!! n'hqbie! nz<zia<kNzi! ngqzk<kqz<! keg<Gh<! hqvkqfqkqbigs<!osi'hqbie! o^b<bqKei! nHz<h]I! Nkl<! njzaq < zil<!nuIgjt!d{<mig<gqeie</!!

! ÄÄzibîZ! nh<kQ ///! we<Ejmb! ncbie<! fhqzie!u{g<gr<gjtBl<! uqVh<Hme<! Oh{qs<! osb<hueig! fQr<gi! u{<{ligq!weK!LMGkjzh<! ohXl<! u{<{l<! ofVr<gq! fie<!nuje! Ofsqg<Gl<!ntUg<G! NgquqMgqxie<///}}! we<x! akQK! Gk< qbqe<! hc! Nkl<!njzaq <^zil<! nuIgt<! GIH.hxibqZ?! GIH.fuihqZ! nlz<! osb<K!fqxh<hliehcbiz<! nz<zia<Ug<G! gzqhiuibqVf<K?! dzgk<kqe<!giiqbikqgjt! fmk<kq! uf<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</! nuIgtqz<! fqe<XOl!h]iqb<bk<oke<El<! lEuIg<gl<! -Xkqk<! kQ Ih<H! fit<! hiqbf<kl<!outqbigqg<!ogi{<Om!uVgqe<xK/!!

! o^b<bqKei! Nkl<! njzaq < zil<! nuIgt<! dt<vr<gk<kqz<!uqzibk<Kl<! outqvr<gk<kqz<! Fhu<uk<Kl<! djmbuIgtibqVf<kiIgt</!!nuIgTg<Gh<! hqxG! hz! fhqliIgt<! outqbigq! -Xkq! fhqbig!wl<ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!Okie<xqeiIgt</! wl<ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgTg<Gh<! hqxG! fhqbqz<jzbijgbiz<! nuIgt<! hiz<! hgqvr<glig!-Vf<k! Fhu<uk<! nf<kvr<gligq! nf<kvr<glig! -Vf<k! uqzibk<!hgqvr<glibqx<X/!!njks<!Slf<kuIgt<!kie<!nUzqbig<gtiuI/!!NgOu!fhqBjmb!LcU!uzqBjmb!Nvl<hliGl</!!! Fhu<uk<kigqb! fhqk<Kuk<kqz<! okimIH! Lcujmf<K!uqm<mhcbiz<!yu<ouiV! gizk<kqZl<! fhqbqe<! hqvkqfqkqbig! yVuI! fqbleligqe<xiI/!!nk<kjgbuI!BgLcU!fit<!ujv!Wx<hm<Mg<!ogi{<OmbqVh<hI/!!nuOv!N{<muEg<G! LMGkz<! ohx<x! uzq?! %m<mk<kqeVg<G! -lil<?! nuOv!OfIupq! gim<mg<%cb! aikqBl<! la<kqBliuiI/! ! uzK?! -mK! -V!hg<gr<gtqZl<! ne<eiVg<G! njls<sIgt<! -Vg<gqe<xeI?! nuIgTl<!uzqliIgtigOu! -Vg<gqe<xeI! we<hkig! oltziei! Lal<lK!\ziZk<kQ e<! 'lq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! l <euq! ]iQ hqz<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! Änz<zia|kNzi! fhqliIgTg<Gk<! keK! kqVuseligqb!uaqjbg<! ogi{<M! hbqx<sqbtqk<kie</! ! nUzqbig<gTg<G! okb<uQg!dkqh<higqb! -z<aijlg<! ogi{<M! hbqx<sqbtqg<gqxie</! ! nUzqbig<gt<!fhqliIgTjmb! fqVuigh<! ohiXh<hitIgtigUl<! hqvkqfqkqgtigUl<?!uiiqSgtigUl<! DpqbIgtigUl<! -Vg<gqe<xiIgt</! -k<kjgb!fz<zcbiIgOt! dzgh<! hqvj\gTjmbUl<?! dzgk<KjmbUl<!givqb <kIgtigUl<! dzgk<jk! fqjzh<! ohxs<! osb<huIgtigUl<!



!

!



12

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

-Vg<gqe<xiIgt</! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<Om! dzgLl<!fqjzohx<xqVg<gqe<xK/! ! nuIgt<! sqV]<cgjt! NThuIgtigUl<?!olb<h<ohiVtqe<! hqvkqfqkqgtigUl<! -Vh<hK! Hxk<Okix<xk<kqz<! ne<X!dt<vr<gk<kqOzbil<}}! we<hkig! ki\|z<! nu<zqbi! o^b<bqKei!La<bqk<kQ e<! nh<Kz<! gikqV! \Q zieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! hk<a|Ivh<hieqbqz<! dhOksqk<Kt<tiIgt</! ! weOu! ne<eiOv!sIu!-vm<sgI?!ne<eijvh<!ohiXk<Ok!sgz!Ozigg<!giiqbikqgotz<zil<!Sx<xqbiMgqe<xe/!ne<eijvg<!ogi{<Om!nz<zia|kNzi!dzgr<gjtg<!gig<gqe<xie</! ne<eiOv! la<kQ! we<Xl<?! gik<kLz<! nUzqbi! we<Xl<!osiz<zh<hMl</! ne<euI! gizk<kqz<! ne<eiIkie<! gik<kLz<! ne<hqbi?!o^b<bqKei!Lal<lK!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgtqe<!hkuqbigqb! lgile<! la<&kiuqz<! kiqhm<cVh<huI/! ne<eiOv!gzQ hk<Kz<zia<!we<x!okb<uh<hqvkqfqkqbig!-Vg<gqe<xiI}}!we<hkig!NiqH!xh<hieq! a\<vk<! o^b<bqK! nh<Kz<giQl<! \qbzq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!-e< ie<!gilqzqz<!%XgqxiIgt</!

!

! lv{k<kqxghhiZl<!abik<K{mi@!!! -k<kjgb! kk<Kuk<jkBjmbuIgt<! lv{qk<K! l{<O{iM!l{<{igqh<! Ohib<!uqMukqz<jz"!dmz<gTl<!fsqh<hkqz<jz?!\Quqbk<kqz<!-Vf<kK!OhizOu!gHvqZl<!smzl<!OgiIju!GjzbilzqVg<Gl</!!! ÄÄne<hqbig<gTjmb!dmz<gjtk<! kqe<hjk!-jxue<! fqs<sblig!H,lqg<G! axilig<gquqm<mie<}}! we<X! fhqgiQ l<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq!u^z<zl<!kqVuib<!lzIf<kVtqBt<t!akQ K/!nH,kiU,K!.!-HE!li\i!.!

jhagQ!Lkzqb!âQaie!gqvf<kr<gtqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!! !NgOu?! nuIgt<! \Q uqbk<kqz<! wh<hcbqVf<kiIgOti! nh<hcOb?!

H,Ozigk<jk! uqm<M! ljxf<k! hqe<Hl<! gHiqz<! -l<jlg<Gl<! lXjlg<Gl<!lk<kqbqZt<t! Nzl<! lqkizigqb! hI\gqz<! dzgLcU! fit<! ujv!abik<kigOu!-Vh<hiIgt</!!! ÄÄnz<zia<Ujmb! hijkbqz<! )hQ^hQzqz<*! oum<mh<hm<muIgjt!lUk<kieuIgote<X! osiz<zikQIgt</! nuIgt<! abik<jkBjmbuIgt</!Neiz<?! nxqblim<CIgt<}}! )3;265*! we<Xl<?! N{<muEjmb! hijkbqz<!oum<mh<hm<muIgjt! lv{qk<kuIgt<! we<X! fqjeg<gUl<! Ou{<mil</!!Neiz<! nuIgt<! \Q uEt<tuIgt</! N{<mue<! hg<glqVf<K! iq <jg!ogiMg<gh<! hMgqxiIgt<A! Nef<klig! -Vg<gqxiIgt<}}! )4;27:?281*! we<Xl<!nz<zia|kNzi!GINe<!]iQhqz<!kqVUtl<!hx<xqBt<tie</!! OlOz!g{<m!Nbk<kqx<G!uqtg<glig?!L]<iqg<Gme<!Bk<kR<osb<K!oum<mh<hm<M! ]aQ kieiZl<! siqA! kl<Ljmb! fh< |me<! Nk<liIk<kqgh<!



!

!



13

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

OhiI! osb<K!njk!oum<c! uQ p<k<kqeiZl<! siq?! -v{<MOl!hQ hQ z<kie<}}!we<X!olb<R<Rie!osi'hI?!j]Gz<!ng<hI?!La<bqk<kQ e<!-HE!nxhq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!kr<gtK!kh<^Q iQ z<!2.uK!higl<?!248.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! -u<uiOx! j]G!- <libqz<!ag<gQ! h' Q! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! kr<gtK!kh< QI!'a|z<! hbieqz<! 3.uK!higl<! 237.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!osiz<zqBt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<! -u<uiOx! kh< Q I! nxibq |z<! hbie<?! kh< Q I!a|jê<?!kh< Q I! n Q Q ! Ngqbux<xqZl<! uVgqe<xe/! ! -u<uixigOu?! nz<zili!gipQ! keiUz<zi! hieqhm<C! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTl<!k^<gqvKz<!lUk<ki.uz<.GH,iq!we<El<!gqvf<kk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! -u<uixig! nz<zia<uqe<! hijkbqz<! ]aQkieuIgt<!kk<Kuikqgjth<! ohikqf<K! O\ikqouitqbqz<! Jg<gqbligquqMgqxhcbiz<!abik<Kt<tuIgt<! fibeqml<! iq^<G.d{U! ohXgqxiIgt</! ! yV!

-z<zk<kqzqVf<K! lX! -z<zk<kqx<G! liXgqxiIgt</! ! -kx<gq{r<g?! ke<!fH^qe<! Ohiqz<! hQ^hQ z<! osb<K! ke<! fH^qz<! os<Zgqe<xuIgtqe<!abik<kieK! lUk<kqz<! abik<kib<?! ytqObiM! ytqbib<! OsIf<Kg<!ogit<ukib<!osiz<zh<hMgqxK/!!! yV! slbl<! fhqgt<! Ogilie<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<! kH,g<G! Bk<kk<kqz<! oux<xq! ohx<X! o\bOhiqjgBme<!âihig<gt<! sgqkl<! lkQ ei! fgVg<Gt<! Fjpf<k! OhiK?! ÄÄsqxqb!OhiiqzqVf<K!ohiqb!OhiI!ntuqz<!lQ {<Mt<Otil<}}!we<X!%xqeiIgt</!!

! dmOe?!âihig<gt<?!biv^|zz<zia<"!-h<OhiK!hQ hQ z<!osb<K!kqVl<hqOeil</!-jkuqm! ohiqb!hQ hQ z<! biK!we<X!uqeu?!ohVlieiI!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<! ÄÄfH^|me<!OhiviMuKkie<!ohiqb! )hQ hQ z<*! Ohivim<ml<}}! we<X! uqjmbtqk<kiIgt</! ! -f<k! akQ K!jhagQ?! -a<bi! dZ~lqk<kQ e<?! kh< QI! 'a|z<! hbie<! Ngqbux<xqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄnz<zia<Ug<G! upqhm<M! ke<Ejmb! fH |me<! OhiI! HiqhuI!wuOvi?!nuOv!uQvI}}!we<x!akQ Kl<!lq]<gik<kqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!

! weOu?! hQ hQ zqz<! OhiIHiqf<K! dbqIk<! kqbigl<! osb<k!]|akig<gTl<?! fH^|me<! OhiI! okiMk<K! oux<xqbjmf<k!lgiEhiuIgTl<!lUk<kqx<Gh<!hqe<Hl<!abik<jk!djmbuIgt<!we<hK!Ge<xqe<! Olzqm<m! kQhl<! Ohiz! okiqbg<! gqmg<gqe<xK/! -f<k! n <kquiv!nch<hjmbqOz!jlbqk<Kgt<! Ogm<gqe<xe.! hiIg<gqe<xe.! Sx<xk<kijvBl<!ne<hIgjtBl<!nxqgqe<xe!.!^ziLg<Gh<!hkqZl<!osiz<gqe<xe!we<El<!



!

!



14

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

uq]br<gt<! hx<xq! akQ Kgt<! hzux<jxg<! Gxqh<hqm<M?! -lil<! ^|B,k<kq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ]va| < |K~iqz<! uqiquig!wMk<Kjvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! -KOu! ^|e<ek<K! uz<\link<kiiqe<! WOgihqk<k! ngQ kiouEl<!ogit<jgbiGl</! jlbqk<Kg<G! d{IU! -Vh<hkiz<kie<! lUk<Kg<Gh<!hqxGl<?! gHiqz<! )Nzl<! n\< iLg<Gl<! Nzl<! nIuia|g<Gl<! -jmOb!Nzl<! hI\g<gqz<*! Ogt<uqgTl<?! hiuH{<{qbr<gTg<Gk<! kg<g!hzihze<gTl<! Wx<hMgqe<xe/! nux<xqx<G! nk<kjkb! d{Is<sqgt<!-z<jz! weqe<! fe<jl! kQ jlgTg<Gt<t! hzihzje?! SgKg<gk<jk!wu<uiX!nju!nEhuqk<kxqb!LcBl<@!!! lv{k<kqx<Gh<!hqxG?!gz<!gvMgjth<!Ohiz<!Ogm<mxqb!sg<kqbqz<jz!we<X! w{<[uK! ]Q bi?! L0k<k^qzi! Ohie<x! upqogm<m!%m<mk<kiIgTjmb!ogit<jgbiGl</!!! ÄÄjlbqk<K! osuqObx<giK! we<X! %Xgqxue<! ljmbEl<!

)\iaqZl<*! upqogm<muEl<! )LzaqKl<*! Nuie</}}! we<hkib<! fie<G!lKaHgjtBjmb!^|e<ek<! uz<! \link<K!dzlig<gt<! njeuVl!WOgihqk<Kg<!%xqBt<teI/!!! hk<V! Bk<kk<kqz<! lv{qk<k! Gh<hiIgTjmb! hqOvkr<gt<!Guqg<gh<hm<cVf<k! -mk<kqx<G?! OhiI! Yb<fk! hqe<H! fhq! ohVlieiI!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! ose<X! nr<G! fqe<X!ogi{<M!nh<hqOvkr<gjt! Ofig<gq! ÄÄwr<gt<! fibe<!%xqb!uig<Gxkqjb!fir<gt<! d{<jlbigh<! ohx<Xg<! ogi{<Omil</! dr<gt<! fibe<! %xqb!uig<GXkqjb! fQ r<gt<! d{<jlbigh<! ohx<Xg<! ogi{<CIgti@}}! we<X!

Ogm<mOhiK! nr<G! ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgTmeqVf<k! dlIhiX~g<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!ÄÄbi!x^|Zz<zia<"!lv{ljmf<OkiI!wr<rel<! kr<gt<!uiIk<jkgjtg<!Ogm<hiIgt<@?! we<X! uqeuqeiIgt</! nkx<G! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! ÄÄdr<gjt! uqm! nuIgt<! fe<xigg<!Ogm<hiIgt</!dr<gTg<G!outqg<giK!d{<M/!nuIgTg<G!Ne<liIk<ks<!osuqB{<M?!nkeiz<!nuIgt<!wz<ziux<jxBl<!Ogm<gqxiIgt<}}!we<hkig!uqjmbtqk<kiIgt<?!we<X!âQ a<!L <zql<!gqvf<kk<kqz<!uVgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄjlbqk<K!deK! hikvm<jsbqe<! sh<kk<jkBl<! %m! Ogm<gqe<xK}}!

we<hkig!âQa|z<!Hgiiq?!âQa<!L^<zql<?!nH,kiU,K?!f^bQ !Ngqb!gqvf<kr<gtqz<!uf<kqVg<gqe<xK/!-K!sl<hf<klig!nOfglie!akQ Kgjt!Gxqh<hqm<M!nkquqiquig?!]va|^< |K~I! hQ ]vaqz<! lUk<ki! uz<! GH,I!we<x! F~zqz<! -lil<! ^|B,k<kq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!



!

!



15

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! dkiv{k<kqx<gig! sqz! fqgp<s<sqgjt! -r<G! %XuK!ohiVk<koleg<!gVKgqe<Oxil</!!! fhq! hqvie<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<! yVujv!-^<zik<kqe<!hiz<!njpk<k!OhiK!nuI?!Gpf<jkh<!hVuk<kqz<!-xf<K!Ohie! keK! lgjt! dbqI! ohxs<! osb<kiz<! =lie<! ogit<ukigg<!%xqeiI/! ng<Gpf<jkbqe<! gHVg<Gs<! ose<X! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!ng<Gpf<jkjbg<!%h<hqm<M!njpk<kiIgt</!!dmOe!ng<Gpf<jk?!Änch{qf<Oke<}!we<X!lXolipq!%xqbK/!!kqVl<hq!dzGg<G!uvg<%cb!w{<{L{<mi!we<X!Ogm<miIgt</!Änz<zia<Ujmb!x^|Oz"!N{<mue<!lQK!sk<kqblig!weg<G!nk<kjgb!w{<{lqz<jz/!-l<jljb! uqm! lXjljbOb! Olzigg<! gi{<gqOxe<}! we<X! hkqz<!%xqbK/!!! -u<uvzix<jx! -lil<! jhagQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<!kzibqzqz<!osiz<ukib<?!a|\<\Kz<ziaq!nzz<!NzlQe<!533.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!nz<zili!o]b<G!B,SHe<ehaieQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!

ne<a|!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄfhqliIgt<! \Q uEt<tuIgtig! -Vg<gqe<xiIgt<?! nuIgt<!gHVgtqz<! )hI\gqz<*! okiPK! ogi{<MlqVg<gqxiIgt<}}! we<X! ne <!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! jhagQ ! akQ Kg<!gqvf<kk<kqz<!iquibk<Ks<!osb<bh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! )dkiv{l<*!&î!njzaq < zil<!nuIgt<! osl<jl! fqxlie!Olm<ce<! lQ Kt<t! gHiqz<! fqe<X! okiPK! ogi{<cVf<kjk! lq0vi\<!djmb! -vuqz<! x^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!

nuIgt<!g{<miIgt<!we<x!akQ K!ne^<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M!âQa<!L^<zql<?!f^bQ !gqvf<kr<gtqz<!iquibk<Ks<!osb<bh<!ohx<xqVg<gqxK/!!! ÄÄfhqliIgt<?! ]|akig<gt<?! nUzqbig<gt<! NgqObiI!abik<Kt<tuIgt</! nuIgTjmb! gHVgtqz<! nuIgt<! okiPK!ogi{<Ml<?! a\<\|! osb<K! ogi{<Ml<! -Vg<gqe<xiIgt</! -r<rel<!âQaie! akQ Kgt<! uf<kqVg<gqe<xe}}! we<hkib<! -lil<! xlzQ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! %Xukig?! nz<zili! -lil<! o]b<G!SjzliEz<! \lz<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!

nz<HK~aik<Kz<! na<lkqb<bi! :1.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<! nz<zili! j]G!aÊz<! nkuq! lq <iQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!l]iiqGz<! ne<uiI! 78.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<?! nz<zili! j]G! B,SHe<!ehaieQ!lq^<iQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!]uiaqKz<!ag<G!7:.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!ujvgqe<xiIgt</!!



!

!



16

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! )dkiv{l<*;! lg<gi?! lkQ eiUg<gqjmOb! fhq! giQl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! ose<X! ogi{<cVg<jgbqz<?! &î!njzaq <^zil<!nuIgt<!gikqz<!jgjb!juk<K!kz<hqbis<!osiz<zqg<!ogi{<M! nI\|g<! Yjmjbg<! gmf<K! ose<X! ogi{<cVf<kjkh<!hiIk<kkigUl<?! nuIgtK! fqxl<?! Lcbqe<! -zm<s{l<! hx<xqBl<!uqhiqk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<! B,E <! njzaq < zil<! nuIgt<! gl<htq! \qh<hiUme<!ose<eqx! ym<mjgbqz<! ]i]iZh<k<! we<Elqmk<kqz<! Yjmjbg<! gmf<K!ose<X! ogi{<cVh<hjkg<! g{<mkiBl<! ym<mjgbqe<! &g<g{ir<gbqX!OhiQ k<k! lvk<kqe<! fiiqeiz<! osb<bh<hm<cVf<kK! we<Xl<! kqVUtl<!hx<xqBt<tiIgt</! -f<k! akQK! -HE! nh<hi^<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! âQa<! L <zqlqz<! iquibk<Ks<!osb<bh<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄnz<zia<Ujmb! nUzqbig<gt<! fqs<sblig! liqh<hkqz<jz/!!Neiz<! YI! -z<zk<kqzqVf<K! lX! -z<zk<kqx<Gs<! osz<gqxiIgt</}}! we<x!

akQjk?! a|\<\k<Kz<! -^<zil<! -lil<! Lal<lK! g < izQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!nIhbQ e<!akQK!we<x!F~zqZl<?!-lil<! hg<Vk<kQe<! xi\Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! kh< Q I!ghQI!4.uK!higl<!:6.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! )dkiv{l<*;! hqvhz<blie! uzqBz<zia<! nH,^bQ K! gIvi\<!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! lg<giuqzqVf<k! gizk<kqz<! yV!uizqhiqe<! jlbqk<K! hE~j]hi! uiszqz<! -Vf<kK/! njk! nuIgt<!dx<XOfig<gqeiIgt</! ÄÄnH,^bQOk"! N{<muEjmb! OfsIgt<!\Q uEt<tuIgt</!nuIgt<!Yiqz<zk<kqzqVf<K!lX!-z<zk<kqx<G!osz<uOk!

lv{liGl<! we<hjk! nxqbuqz<jzbi@}}! we<hkib<! nf<k! jlbqk<K!sqvqh<Hme<! osiz<zqx<xil</! -f<fqgp<s<sqjb! -lil<! \ziZk<kQe<! ^|B,k<kq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ]va|^< |K~I! 97.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! ^|hqb<big<gt<! )nUzqbig<gt<*! lUk<kiukqz<jz/! weqEl<!leqkIgTjmb! outqvr<glie! hiIjujb!uqm<Ml<! ljxgqxOkbz<ziK!Ouxqz<jz/! Woeeqz<! nuIgjtBl<! lUk<kieiIgote<X!osiz<ukx<gigOu/!!

! L]iaqkQ e<?! Lag<gqgQ e<gTjmb! dmz<gTl<! OgiIju!GjzbiK/! Gk< qbie! 'a<! fqs<sblig! yVOhiKl<! npqbiK/! ! -K!Ohiz<! gqbilk<! ujv! abik<Kl<! npqbiK/! -k<kjgb! abik<Kl<!'a|l<!djmb!gHiqz<!)NzLz<hI\gqz<*!\Q uEt<tuIgtigOu!-Vh<hI/!nuIgTjmb! kqOvgl<! dzgqzqVf<kK! OhizOu! -Vg<Gl</!-h<hkuqBjmbuIgt<!nf<kvr<glie!abik<KmOe!-Vh<hiIgt<?!'a|z<!



!

!



17

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

GK^qBmElqVh<hiIgt</!lv{qk<kqx<gh<hiZl<!H,lqbqz<!fmf<K!kqiquiIgt</!nu<ulbl<! wf<k! leqkVl<! nuIgjtg<! gi{<hiIgt</! ! nuIgTme<!Ohsqg<! ogit<tUl<! osb<uiIgt</! nuIgjt! -e<eiove! okiqbuviK/!nuIgt<! fice! Ohiokz<zil<! gHvqz<! ljxf<K! uqMuiIgt</!nuIgTjmb! kqOvgk<jk! l{<?! HP?! H,s<sq?! Jui! lqVgl<! wKUOl!kqe<eiK/! NkqLkz<! nf<kl<! ujvbqz<! abik<K/! 'a|?! \q <L!-l<&e<XmEl<! -Xkqfit<! ujvbqzqVh<hiIgt</! nuIgt<!HuqbqzqVg<jgbqz<! df<kqbqe<! gQpqVf<K! &s<osPl<hq! &jtg<Ogxq!outqh<hMuK! -bx<jg/! gHiqz<! -bx<jgg<G! lix<xligOu?! &s<S!OlzqVf<K! gQ p<Ofig<gqs<! osz<Zl</! -keiz<! big<jgbpqbiK!)ubqx<xqzqVg<Gl<!sqSg<gTg<Gl<?!osiIg<guikqgTg<Gl<!-u<uiOx*!gHiqz<!\Q ujeh<! ohx<xuvibqVf<kiz<! \Q uEg<Gt<t! -zm<s{r<gt<! ye<XOl!GjxbiK}}!we<hkig!lqInk<Kz<!L]iaqkQ eqz<!osiz<zh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! ÄÄuzqBjmb! gHjv! yVuI! ^qbivk<Ks<! osb<kiz<! nujv! nf<k!uzq!nxquiI/!nuI!^zil<!osie<eiz<!uzq!nkx<Gh<!hkqz<!osiz<uiI/!nuVjmb! gHVg<G! nVgijlbig! yVuI! kqg<G! osb<kiz<! nf<k!

uzqBl<!OsIf<K!kqg<V!osb<uiI/!zi-zia!-z<zz<zia|!wEl<!kqg<jvs<!osb<kiOzi!nf<k!uzq!sl<ler<!ogim<c!dm<giIf<K!kqg<V!osb<huVme<!OsIf<K!kqg<V! osb<uiI/!nUzqbig<gt<! lUk<Kg<Gh<! hqxGl<!abik<Kh<!ohx<xuIgOt/! lUk<kqe<! &zl<! nuIgjt! yV! uQm<jm! uqm<M! lX!uQm<mtuqz<! kqVh<hh<! hm<cVg<gqxK/! abik<kqz<! nuIgjt! sr<jg!osb<uK! Ohiz<! lUk<kqZl<! sr<jg! osb<bOu{<Ml</! yV! uzq!lUk<kieiz<!ne<eiI!Ohiqz<?!ne<hqbi!nUzqbig<gTjmb!nIuia|gt<!okiPl<}}! we<hkig! Gk<H! xh<hieQ?! -lil<! nh<Kz<! ua<aiH! ]0vieQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! khgik<Kz<! Gh<vi! higl<! 3!hg<gl<!76z<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!

!! ÄÄ^qbivk<Ks<! osb<b! lqgUl<! Wx<xlie! fit<! kqr<gt<?! uqbipe<?!out<tq?! seq!-f<! fie<Glig! -Vg<Gl</!\|l<Nk<! okiPjgg<Gh<! hqe<H!^qbivk<Ks<!osb<uK!lqgUl<!sqxh<hiekiGl<}}!we<X!hkiui!Nzl<gQiqbqz<!uf<Kt<tK/!!! ÄÄlUk<kieuIgt<! out<tqg<gqpjl! -vuqZl<?! out<tqg<gqpjl!LPOfvr<gtqZl<?! seqg<gqpjl?! gijzbqZl<?! wf<k! Ofvr<gtqZl<!\qbivk<K! osb<huIgjt! nxquiIgt</! -kx<gig! nf<Ofvr<gtqz<!^qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK!L <kah<hiGl<}}! we<hkig!l]iiqGz<!ne<uiiqz<!

uf<Kt<tK/!!! ÄÄlUk<kieuIgt<! ^qbivk<Ks<! osb<bg<! %cbujv! nxquiIgt<?!Ohs<jsBl<! Ogm<hiIgt<! weX!akQ Kgtqe<! &zl<! nxqbh<hm<cVg<gqxK}}!we<hkiBl<!l]iiqGz<!ne<uiiqz<!osiz<zh<hm<Mt<tK/!!



!

!



18

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ÄÄjlbqk<kieK! ke<jeg<! Gtqh<him<MhuIgjtBl<! Slf<K!osz<huIgjtBl<?! gHVg<G! LMgq! fqx<huIgjtBl<! nxquiIgt<!Ohs<Sg<gjtBl<! Ogm<hiIgt<}}! we<X! hkiui! Gh<viuqz<! kzQ z<!nk<kim<sqgTme<! fgz<! osb<bh<hMgqxK/! OlZl<! -u<uiOx!]va| <^|K~iqZl<?!]va|hI\gqZl<!uqiquig!fgz<!osb<bh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! j]Gz<! ng<hI! La<bqk<kQe<! -HE! nvhq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! uhik<kie! hqxG! nuIgOt! kr<gtK! uQ m<cx<G!uf<kiIgt</! kr<gtK! out<tim<cjbg<! g{<M! nutK! Sg!osb<kqgjtBl<! fqjzjlgjtBl<! uqsiiqk<kiIgt</! wz<zi!uq]br<gjtBl<! nut<! suq <kivlig! wMk<Kg<! %xqeit</! ! nuIgt<!nutqmlqVf<K! uq]br<gjtg<! Ogm<Mk<! okiqf<K! ose<xiIgt<! we<hkig!H^|^|z<!aqg<gl<!djmb!]vaqz<! -lil<! j]G\|f<kq! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! %Xukig! ^Nkk<Kk<! kijve<! 513.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gTg<G! N{<mueiz<! nVth<hm<cVg<Gl<! gxilik<K!

nkqsbk<kqe<! ohiVm<miz<! 'aieqbk<kie! sg<kqjbg<! ogi{<M!abik<kqZl<! lUk<Kg<Gh<! hqxGl<! nuIgt<! outqh<hm<M! dzgqz<!fmliMl<! sg<kqB{<M}}! we<hkig! -lil<! \ziZk<kQ e<! ^|B,k<kq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!nz<ghVk<kiz<Z!nzi.U\|kqz<!Gk<hq! uz<! nh<kiz<?! we<x! F~zqZl<?! -lil<! o^b<bqK! ]aiHk<kQ e<!na<lK! a|jêQ! aluQ! aehQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! fhaik<Kz<! GIhquz<! -k<kqîz<?! we<x! F~zqZl<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqz<! ohVl<hiOziI! uhik<Kg<Gh<! hqxGl<!

gHVgtqzqVf<K! Hxh<hm<M! outqOb! OhigUl<! osb<gqxiIgt</! kqVl<hUl<!gHVg<Gt<! lQ tUl<! osb<gqxiIgt</! Ohiguv! nuIgTg<G! wk<kjgb!kjmBlqz<jz}}! we<hkig! nz<Gk<H! -lil<! ]0xieq! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! zk<kibqHz<! lqee<! 2.uK! higl<! 255.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄfhqgiQl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgjtk<!kr<gtK!lUk<kigqh<! Ohie! âihig<gtqe<! nIuia|gt<! sgqkl<! wz<zi!dzgr<gjtBl<! SObs<jsbigs<! Sx<xq! uVujk! nUzqbig<gt<!g{<%migg<! g{<cVg<gqe<xiIgt<}}! we<hkig! -lil<! g < izq!

vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!Nkivk<Kme<!%Xujk?!kh< QI!'a|z<!hbie<!higl<!21?!hg<gl<!::z<!gi{zil</!!! -kx<gikivlig! uhik<Kg<Gh<! hqxG! fqgp<f<k! sqz! sl<hur<gjtg<!gi{<g;!!



!

!



19

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! -lil<!nh<Kz<!ua<aiH!]0vieq! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! ^qbivk<Ks<! osb<ukx<gig! o^b<bqk<! dlI! -HE! hiiqZ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! gHV! ]iQ Hg<Gs<!ose<xOhiK!nr<G!nuIgjtg<!gi{ikhcbiz<!kqVl<hquqm<miIgt</!HqxG!dlI! -HE! hiiqZ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! -lil<!]0vieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! -ml<! ose<X! Okjujb!Le<eqm<M!outqOb! ose<xqVf<kkigk<! okiquqk<K!le<eqh<Hg<! Ogiiqbkig!-lil<!]0xieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgOt! kr<gTjmb!ÄzkibqHz<!lqee<}!2.uK!higl<!255.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! o^b<bqK!j]G!nh<hi^<! LI^Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjt! seqg<gqpjl! $iqObikbk<kqx<G! Le<El<?! o^b<bqK!-HxiaqLz<! n0v\<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjt!out<tqg<gqpjl! lg<iqHg<Gh<! hqe<Hl<! o^b<bqK! big<%k<KI! nI]Q!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjts<!osu<uib<g<gqpjl!ZaVg<Gh<!hqe<Hl<!nuvuIgTjmb!gHVg<Gs<!ose<X!^qbivk<Ks<!osb<Bl<!hcBl<!nuIgotz<OziVl<! Gxqh<hqm<m! nf<k! Ofvr<gtqz<! kie<! gHiqz<!

N\vibqVh<hiIgote<Xl<?! -u<U{<jljb! ngg<g{<j{!djmbuIgjtk<! kuqv! lx<oxuVl<! nxqblim<miIgtijgbiz<?!gHVgtqz<! nuIgt<! -Vg<gOu! osb<gqe<xiIgt<! we<x! w{<{k<Kme<!g]<hqz<zikuIgt<! osb<bOu{<Mole<Xl<! o^b<bqK! nzq! hkuq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!dhOksqk<kqVh<hkig!Olx<osie<e!zikbqHz<!lqee<!nOk!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! NgOu?! -xh<H!we<hK!npqUg<Giqbke<X/! ! sqz! hck<kvr<gjtg<!ogi{<m!Jmkk<Ku!liXkziGl<! .! yV! fqjzbqzqVf<K! lX! fqjzg<G!Le<Oexqs<! osz<ukiGl</! Woeeqz<?! Nk<li! npquqz<zikK/! -xh<Hl<!

hqxh<Hlx<x!fqjzbqZt<tK/!!! -lil<! g < izQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!gQ lqbiOb.^Nkk<! hQ cjgbqz<! Gxqh<hqMl</! ÄÄlE]<{e<!neikqbz<zeibqEl<! Lcux<xfqk<kqbe<}}! wEl<! ohie<! olipqbqzqVf<K?!lv{k<OkiM! leqkeqe<! uip<g<jg! Lcujmf<K! uqmuqz<jz! we<x!d{<jl! outqbigqe<xK/! fqIbi{k<kqeqe<X! yV! Hkqb! uip<g<jg!dkbligq! nK! we<Xl<! npqbi! fqk<kqblib<! fqe<X! fqzuk<!okimr<GgqxK/! \mUzgk<jkh<! hx<xq! fqx<Gl<! H,kOkgk<kqe<! SgOhig!-e<hr<gtqe<! uisz<! njmhm?! sgz! FgIs<sqgjtBl<!

nf<kvr<gk<kqzqVf<K! nEhuqk<K! uf<k! nf<k! lE]<be<! we<x!Sbl<ohiVt<!$m<sllib<g<!gqiqjb!Hiqb!sg<kq!ohXgqe<xK/!hq{q?!&h<H?!ktIs<sq?!-bzijl!Lkzqb!kr<gm?!sr<gmlqe<xq!lxkqbx<x!LPleqkh<!h{<Hl<!nueqz<!njlf<K!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!



!

!



20

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! -u<Uzgqz<!sR<siqk<K!uf<kK!OhizOu!wz<ziuqklie!Hze<gTl<!ukqbk<kg<g!Obig<gqbjkBjmbueib<!NGl<!OhiK!OkgLl<!nux<jxk<!okimIf<Ok! fqx<Gl</! ! -l<jlbqz<! H,k! G{k<kqe<! lqjgh<hiz<! 'a|!dmZg<Gt<!ljxf<K!gi{h<hMuK!Ohiz?!lXjlbqz<!'aieqb<bk<kqe<!lqjgh<hiz<! Okgl<! 'a|g<Gt<! ljxf<K! gi{h<hMl</! aqîH! we<x!Ogt<uq! g{g<gqx<Gl<?! hiu! H{<{qbk<kqx<Ogx<x! hzi! hze<gTg<Gl<!-k<OkgOl!ohiXh<hig!uqtr<Gl</!!! ÄÄnz<zia<uqe<! sqV]<cgTt<! weK! O\ikqOb! Lke<jlbieK}}!we<X!ohVlieiI!fhqgiQ l<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!nVtqBt<tiIgt</!!! weOu?! ytquigqb! F~I! we<El<! yOv! n <kquivk<kqzie!dbqI.dmz<! we<x! -u<uqV! u <Kg<gTl<! ye<Oxiomie<X! Jg<gqbh<hm<M!ljxuKl<?! outqh<hMuKl<! Ne<l! sg<kqlqg<gh<! ohiqbiiqmk<K!nkqsbqg<gk<kg<g!gVlle<X/!!

! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqmk<kqz<! ^<K~zk<kqx<Gl<?! $m<Slk<kqx<Gl<! lk<kqbqz<!hqvliklie! uqk<kqbisl<! ye<Xlqz<jz/! ! $m<Slk<Kt<! ^<K~zl<!nmr<GuK!ne<eiiqmk<kqz<!yV!ohiqb!gVlle<X}}/!!! nz<zia<uqe<! olb<bcbivie! nUzqbig<gt<?! kir<gt<!sqV]<cgtqe<! hiIjubqzqVf<K! ljxb! fiMl<! OhiK! lv{l<! we<x!OhiIjug<Gt<! HGf<K! ogit<uKl<?! nmg<gl<! osb<bh<hm<m! hqe<!^<K~zk<jk!$m<Slk<Kt<tmg<gq! gHVgtqzqVf<K! outqOb! Hxh<hMuKl<!ne<euIgTg<G! wtqkie! gVlliGl</! ! N{<mue<! nuIgTg<G!nk<kjgb! kk<Kuk<jkg<! ogiMk<Kt<tie</! -k<kqbikq! giv{r<gjtg<!

ogi{<M!lv{k<kqx<Gh<!hqe<El<!nUzqbig<gt<!\Q uEt<tuIgt<?!npqbik!Okgk<jk! djmbuIgt<! gqiqjbgt<! HiqBl<! sg<kqBjmbuIgt<! wek<!okiqb!uVgqe<xK}}/!!! ncbqx<g{<m!fqgp<s<sqgOt!-kx<Gh<!Ohikqb!sie<XgtiGl</!!! a\<vk<! gqZV! njzaq < zil<! nuIgt<?! -liLz<! n0zl<!nH,aeQ hi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK!u0T!l\<zqSg<Gk<!kqef<OkiXl<! gijz! Oujtbqz<! N\vigq! ]iQ nk<Kjmb! -z<Lgjtg<!gx<X! uf<kiIgt</! -lil<! nuIgt<! uhik<kie! hqxG! nf<k! l\<zqS!

fjmohxuqz<jz/! gqZX! njzaq < zil<! nuIgt<! N{<mueK!dk<kvU! ohx<X?! abik<kqz<! fmf<kK! OhizOu! lUk<Kg<Gh<! hqe<Hl<!-liLz<! n0tl<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! gHV!]iQHg<G! yu<ouiV! gijzbqZl<! ose<X?! ]iQ nk<Kjmb! -z<Lgjtg<!Ogm<Muf<kkig! -lil<! -HE! \u< Q! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! Ähkibqd}! wEl<! hqg<a|g<! gqk<kihqz<! uVgqxkig!



!

!



21

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

j]G!aÊz<!nkuQ! lq <iQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!l]iiqg<Gz<!ne<uiI!7:.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! fie<G! lKaHjmb! -lil<gTt<! yVuvigqb! na<lK! -HE!al<hzq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK!^qbivk<kqx<Gs<!ose<x!Gk<H!xh<hieQ !ogtK^< lkieQ ?!Laqb<bqk<kQ e<!nh<Kz<!gikqV!\Q zieq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ne<eiVjmb! gHX!]iQHg<ogkqOv?! nkHme<! fqe<X?! ÄÄn < ziL! njzg<Gl<! bi-lilz<!gqvil<}}! )sr<jgg<Giqb! -lil<! nuIgOt*! we<X! njpk<K! ^zil<!osie<eiIgt</!dmOe?!gHV!]iQ H!-v{<migh<!hqtf<kK/!-lil<!nuIgt<!O\ikqh<! hqvgisk<OkiM! outqOb! hqvse<eligq! ogtKz<! n0tl<!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjtg<! gm<ck<! kPuq! Nzqr<geR<!osb<kiIgt<! F~vieQbie! hiqum<mk<jkh<! OhiIk<kq?! ÄÄo^b<bqK! nh<Kz<!gikqOv?! ]iQ nk<Kjmb! -z<LgTl<?! agQ gk<Kjmb! -z<LgTl<!kr<gt<hiz<!ai\k<kigqe<xe?}}!we<X!hgIf<K!uqjmohx<X!ljxf<kiIgt</!-s<sl<hul<! Äha<\k<Kz<.n^<xiV}! gqvf<kk<kqz<! nxquqh<H!osb<bh<hm<cVh<hkib<! Äkh<iQ \|z<gik<kqI}! 51.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<?! Äh <Zz<!

gqkiH}! 23:.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<!at<vk<! o]b<G!nh<Kz<ag<!Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtqe<! Ä\|h<kKz<!n^<xiI}!F~zqZl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! Gk<H^< lie<?! -lil<! nh<Kz<! ua<aiH! ]0xieQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!%Xgqe<xiIgt<;.!!! ÄÄfie<! weK! GVfikI! )d^<kiK*!a\<vk<! o^b<bqK! Lal<lK!]eiuq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTme<! nz<Gk<H]<]aQ I?!o^b<bqK! na<lK! hkuq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK!

kIgiUg<G! ^qbivk<kqx<gigs<! ose<xqVf<Oke</! ! nu<ulbl<! weK!d^<k<kikuIgt<! gHV! ]iQ jh! Le<Oeig<gq?! ÄfibgOl"! -e<e!giiqbk<jk!Le<eqm<M!lq <Vg<Gh<! Ohigh<! hqvbi{libqVg<gqOxe</!uqjm!ogiMk<kEh<Hr<gt<}!we!uq{<{h<hqk<K!fqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄnz<zia<uqe<! lQK! kug<gz<! juk<kuvib<! Ohib<! uVg}}! we<x!fz<uig<G!gHVg<Gt<tqVf<K!outquf<k!sh<kk<jk!weK!outqvr<glie!-V!giKgjtg<!ogi{<Ml<!fe<G!Ogm<Ome<}}!we<hkig/!!! -u<uvzix<jx! -lil<! ]0xieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!

nuIgt<! zkibqHz<! lqee<}! 2.uK! higl<?! 291.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! nlQ Vz<!L0lqeQ e<?!o^b<bqKei!nH,hg<gI!^qk<kQ g<G!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!uhik<kiGl<! OhiK?! ÄÄwe<Ejmb!\eiîju!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgTjmb!Lhivg<gie!



!

!



22

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

njxbqe<!Le<eiz<!juBr<gt</!gkU!kqxg<gh<hm<M?!nH,hg<gjv!dt<Ot!ogi{<M! uiVr<gt<! we<X! dk<kvU! uf<kiz<! lm<cz<! nu<ujxbqOzOb!nmg<gl<! osb<Br<gt</! -e<Oxz<?! ohiKg<gHV^<kiek<kqz<! nmg<gq!uqMr<gt<}}! we<X! u^qb<bk<Ks<! osb<kqVf<kiIgt</! nu<uiOx!osb<bh<hm<mK/! H,m<mh<hm<m! njxuibqzqe<! Le<H! \eiîju!jug<gh<hm<mOhiK?!uibqz<!gkU!kieigOu!kqxf<K!ogi{<mK/!!! ÄÄOkipjvk<!Okipiqml<!nEh<hq!juBr<gt<}}!we<x!dk<kvU!HeqkI!fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK! vUti!]iQhqzqVf<K! outquf<kK/! nu<uqkOl! nr<G! nmg<gh<hm<miIgt</!-u<uvzix<jx! -lil<! hg<Vk<kQ e<! xi\Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! kh< Q I! ghQ I?! 6.uK! higl<! 796.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! %Xukib<!Äkh<iQ a|z<! nk<gqbi! hQ .na<uizqz<! ne<hqbi}?! higl<! 3?! hg<gl<! 487.z<!ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! -k<kjgb! fqgp<s<sqgt<?! Nkivr<gt<! -e<El<! wu<utOui!gi{<hqg<gzil</! dzgk<kiI! biuVl<! Wx<xqVg<Gl<! -lil<gt<!

sl<hf<fkhm<mux<jxBl<?! nju! hx<xqb! nr<gQ giqg<gh<hm<m! )L0k<khvie*!Nkivh<H,Iulie! gqvf<kr<gjtBOl! Nkivr<gtigg<! gi{<hqk<Kt<Otil</!ne<hqbi?! nUzqbig<gt<! lUk<Kg<Gh<! hqe<Hl<! abik<Kt<tuIgt<!we<hkx<G!Olx<%xqb!dkiv{r<gOtiM!-e<El<!-v{<M!kVgqe<Oxil</!!! dkbgqiq! Lkz<! n <kgqiq! ujv! hqvhz<bljmf<K?! dzgl<!yh<Hg<ogi{<M! YkquVl<! ÄkzibqZz<.jgxik<}! -bx<xqb! nz<zilk<Kz<!hgQ a<?!NiqHz<!gilqz<!Lal<lK!-HE!SjzliEz<!\|^|zq]<!]iKzq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! w{<{qg<jgbx<x!gvilk<Kg<gtqz<!fqe<Xl<!ye<X!\ilqUz<!gxilik<!2.uK!higl<?!276.uK!

hg<gk<kqz<!gi{h<hMgqxK/!ncbqz<!njkg<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<Otil</!!! Gk<H]<!]aQI?!j]G!Lal<lK!-HE! SjzliEz<!\^|zq]<!]iKzq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! aq\<iq! 981.uK!uV]k<kqz<! uhik<kigq?! $b <hm<m{k<kqz<! nmg<gh<hm<miIgt</! 88!uV]r<gTg<Gh<! hqxG! aq\<iq! :58.uK! uV]l<! nuIgtK! gHjvk<!Oki{<mh<hm<mK/! ! nu<ulbl<! nuIgtK! kqOvgl<! )khe<*! nmg<gl<!osb<bh<hm<m! slbl<! wu<uqklqVf<kOki! nu<uqkOl!dXh<hqz<! wk<kjgb!OskLl<?! liXhiMlqe<xq/! ghe<! K{qbqz<! %m! l{<! ym<milzqVf<kK?!nf<kk<! kqOvgl<! g <K~iq! uijmBme<! glp<f<Kg<! ogi{<cVf<kjkg<!

g{<[x<x! kqvtie! \er<gt<! Ohvis<siqbh<hm<M! lbr<gq! fqe<xeI/!!N{<muEjmb! hijkbqz<! ]aQkieuIgt<! -xf<kuIgt<! nz<zI/!nuIgt<! \Q uEt<tuIgt</! nuIgTjmb! H,k! dmz<gjt! l{<!kqe<eiK/! HPh<H,s<sq?! JuilqVgr<gt<! wKUOl! kQ {<miK! we<X!nz<zia<Ul<?! x^|Zl<! %xqbuig<Ggjt! olb<h<hqg<Gl<!nk<kim<sqgtigOu!nuIgt<!gi{h<hm<miIgt</!



!

!



23

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! OlOz! Gxqh<hqm<m! sl<huk<kqe<! OhiK! ng<%m<mk<kqx<G! sqzI!Osikqh<hkx<oge<Ox?! usQgvk<Kme<! O\ikqh<! hqvgislig!-zr<gqg<ogi{<cVf<k! nf<k! uzqBz<zia<! nuIgTjmb! kqVLgk<kqz<!uqvjzjuk<K! nPk<kqh<! hiIk<keI/! uqvz<! hm<m! -mk<jks<! $p<f<K!osf<fqxlig!-vk<kk<kqe<!nxqGxq!gi{h<hm<mK/!uqvjz!wMk<kKl<!nf<k!dkqvg<gm<M!dmzqz<!hvuq!ljxf<kK/!!! hqxG! nuIgtK! hiqSk<kk<! kqVOleq! Nh<hqiqg<giuqZt<t!olivig<OgiUg<G! wMk<Ks<! osz<zh<hm<M! nr<G!nmg<gl<! osb<bh<hm<mK/!nuIgtK!gHV!]iQ hqz<!-e<X!ujv!^zuik<kqe<!hvg<gk<jk!Le<eqm<M!g^<K~iq! uijm! glp<f<K! ogi{<cVg<gqxK/! fit<OkiXl<!Nbqvg<g{g<giOeiI! ^qbivk<kqx<gigs<! ose<X?! kzibqZz<! jgxik<jk!Ykq!fx<OhXgjth<!ohx<X!uVgqe<xeI/!! !

fhq! ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK!âihik<! OkipIgtie! a\<vk<! a|jkhk<Kz<! bleQ ! vzqbz<zia|!

kNzi! ne<a|! a\<vk<! nh<Kz<zia<! -HE! \ihqVz<! ne<siiq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! Ngqb! -VuVl<! ]aQkigq! -xig<gqz<!hGkiK! fgVg<Gs<! slQ hlig! Nx<Oxivk<kqz<! nmg<gl<!osb<bh<hm<cVf<kiIgt</! hqx<gizk<kqz<! out<th<! ohVg<giz<! -V!gHVgTg<Gl<! Oskl<! Wx<hm<mK/!nju!Nx<xqz<!&p<gqh<! Ohib<! uqMOli!we<x! hQkqBl<! d{<mieK/! nK! slbl<! -xig<gqz<! Nm<sqHiqf<k!nlQIjh^z<!)lg<gi!]iQ H!a|jÊjmb!lge<*!dzlig<gtqml<!hk<ui!)liIg<gk<! kQ Ih<H*! uir<gq! nu<uqV! gHVgjtBl<! Oki{<c! wMk<K!nux<jx!OuX!-mk<kqz<!nmg<gl<!h{<{!Wx<hiM!osb<kiI/!-u<uq]bl<!uqtl<hvh<! hMk<kh<hm<mK/! dzgqe<! fizi! hg<gr<gtqzqVf<Kl<! -zm<sg<!

g{g<gie! \er<gt<! Gxqh<hqm<m! Okkqbqz<! nr<G!N\vibqeI/! nu<uqV!gHVgTl<! 2411! uVmr<gTg<Gh<! hqxG! Oki{<mh<hm<M! nu<uqV!smzr<gTl<!outqOb!wMg<gh<hm<M!dbIf<k!Olj\!lQ K!jug<gh<hm<me/!kqOvgk<kqz<! wu<uqk! OhkLl<?! liXhiMl<! gi{h<hmuqz<jz/! uqbIju!osim<m!nu<uqV!Lgr<gTl<!ytqh<hvgisk<Kme<!-zr<gqe/!!! njeuVl<! -g<gim<sqjbg<! g{<M! Ohvis<siqbk<kqz<! &p<gqh<!OhibqeI/! giiQ ! yVuI?! ÄÄnz<zia<Ujmb! hijkbqz<! oum<mh<!hm<muIgjt!lv{qk<kuIgote<X!fQ r<gt<!fqjeg<gOu{<mil</!nuIgOti!\Q uEt<tuIgt</! N{<mue<! hg<glqVf<K! nuIgTg<G! d{utqg<gh<!

hMgqxK/! njkbVf<kq! nuIgt<! sf<Oki]lig! -Vg<gqxiIgt<}}! we<x!gVk<Kt<t!GINe<!Ouk!uig<jg!Yk!Nvl<hqk<kiI/!!! nkx<G! nk<kim<sqbigg<! g{<Le<! hqvk<kqbm<slig! nu<uqV!fikig<gtqe<!hiqSk<kk<!kqVOleqgt<!-Vg<Gl<!gim<sqjb!Ofig<Gl<!OhiK!-f<k!Nbk<!nu<ublf<kie<!nVth<hm<K!Ohiz!gi{h<hm<mkil<"!



!

!



24

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! hqxG! nr<G! %cbqVf<k! \esLk<kqvl<?! njzgt<Ohiz<! nMk<K!fqe<X!okiPK!hGkiKg<G!31!jlz<!K~vk<kqz<!hipjmf<K!-Vhqtuigh<!hqtf<K! gqmg<Gl<! gq <xi! Ogim<jmg<Gs<! slQ hlig?! âihq! ^z<lie<!hiI Q! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! gHV! ]iQ Hg<G!nMk<ki{<jlbig! lx<oxiV! gm<cmk<kqEt<! nu<uqV! âihqgTl<!fz<zmg<gl<! osb<bh<hm<Mt<tiIgt</! -f<fqgp<s<sq! Nr<gqz! uVml<! 2:43.z<!fjmohx<xK/! hk<kqiqg<jggt<! hzux<xqZl<! -s<Oskq! outqbqmh<hm<mK/!lkxi^qz<!outqbqmh<hm<m!klqp<h<!hk<kqiqjg!j^Hz<!-^<zilqZl<?!um!fim<ce<!dVKh<!hk<kqiqjggtqZl<!-u<uqhvl<!outquf<Kt<tK/!!!

hk<kqiqjgbqz!outq!ufk!osb<kq!!! 7.22.2:75?!F~Vz<!-^<zil<!klqp<!uivh<!hk<kqiqg<jgbqz<!ÄuimilzI}!

we<x!hGkqbqz<! ÄÄ- <zik<kqe<!nkqsb!fqgps<sq}}!we<x!kjzh<hqZl<!

uf<Kt<tjkBl<!Ofim<mlqm<Mh<!hiVr<gt</!!ÄÄ-kv! Oksr<gtqe<! -vi\ir<gh<! hqvkqfqkqgTl<! -vig<!

nvsir<gk<kqe<! sIu! nkqgiiqgTl<! kqv{<cVg<g! ]ia<jhsz<!nvsVg<ogkqOv!Lke<!Lkzig!a\<vk<!a|jkhi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! hiqSk<k! hqOvkl<! gqOve<! )hivf<K~g<gq*! &zlig!H,lqbqzqVf<K! nkq\ig<gqvjkbig! nh<hcOb! K~g<gh<hm<mK/! nf<k!\eiî!^<covs<sI! )uqiqh<Hh<! hzjg*! lQ K!npgib<!njlf<K!uqm<mK/!hqe<eI?! gqOveqzqVf<K!^<covs<sjvk<! keqOb! hqiqk<K?! njk!lim<sqjl!kr<gqb! ]ia<jhsz<?! Lh<k<kqOb! n0\l<?! -vig<?! KVg<gq! \efibgh<!ohiK!njls<sI!lq^<V!-tuvsibqVf<K!hi'g<!LkziOeiI!Okit<!lQ K!K~g<gqs<! ose<X! npgqb! g{<{ich<! ohm<mgolie<Xg<Gt<! juk<keI/!-kx<Gh<hqe<!a\<vk<!\ihqI!hqe<!nh<Kz<zi!nuIgtqe<!hiqSk<k!OleqBl<!nmg<g^<kzk<kqzqVf<K! -Ok! ujgbqz<! npgqb! Ljxbqz<! outqbqz<!wMg<gh<hm<mK/!

!hiqSk<k! Oleqbqe<! ghe<! K{qBl<?! nuIgtK! Lgk<kqzqVf<k!

LcBl<! nh<hcOb! nh<hPg<gqe<xq! -Vf<ke/! -h<ohiqObiIgtqe<!hqOvkr<gjtg<! g{<muIgt<?! ÄÄ-ju! 2411!N{<MgTg<G!Le<E{<mie!hqOvkr<gt<! kili@}}! we<X! fl<h! Lcbuqz<jz/! Neiz<?! hqv <kih!Ole<jl! lqg<g! Okgr<gt<! -v{<M! nz<zK! &e<X! l{q! Ofvk<kqx<G!Le<Oe!-xf<Khm<muIgtqe<!Okgr<gjth<!Ohie<Ox!Hk<kl<!Hkqbeuib<k<!oke<hm<me/! -K! lm<cZlz<z/! hqv <kih! -V! ohiqbiIgtie!âihig<gtqe<! Ofk<kqvr<gt<! -v{<Ml<! kqxf<kqVf<ke/! nju! fz<z!htqr<G! Ohie<x! hthth<Hme<! oke<hm<me/! -jkg<g{<m! ng<gl<!hg<gk<kqzqVf<k! hg<kIgt<! nuIgtqe<! g{<gjt! Lk<kqbqmk<!KcKck<keI/!Neiz<?!wuVg<Gl<!-kx<gie!nElkq!gqjmg<guqz<jz/!



!

!



25

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! liohVl<!mig<mIgtie!juk<kqbIgt<!hzI!-f<fqgp<s<sqjbg<!g{<M!kqMg<gqm<meI/! ye<Xl<! Hiqbilz<! kqjgk<keI/! hqv <kih! fqgp<s<sqbqe<!OhiK! hqvhzlie! o\Ile<! g{<! mig<mI! yVuI! -Vf<kiI/! -uI!-f<fqgp<s<sqbqe<! OhiK! ohiqb! NIuk<Kme<! hr<G! ogi{<miI/! nuI!-k<kjgb! Okix<xk<jkg<! g{<mKl<?! hqv <kihh<! ohiqbiIgtie!âihig<gtqe<! hqOvkr<gt<?! g{<{ich<! ohm<cbqz<! jug<gh<hm<cVg<Gl<!fqjzbqOzOb! nuVg<G! ye<Xl<! Hiqbilz<! -vig<! hqvkl! Lh<k<kQ!nuIgTjmb! gvk<jkh<! hqck<Kg<! ogi{<M?! ÄÄkr<gTjmb! liIg<glie!-^<zil<! sk<kqblieKkie<}}! we<hkx<G!-f<k!âihig<gtqe<! ohVjl!lqg<g! fqgp<s<sqjbuqm! OuX! we<e! Nkivl<! Ou{<cbqVg<gqxK@! -Oki!biEl<! L <zqlib<! uqm<Ome</! Äzi! -zia! -z<zz<zia<! Lal<lKI!v^|Zz<zia<}!we<X!%xq!L^<zqligq!uqm<miI/!!! -k<kjgb! sf<kIh<hk<kqz<! kqjvh<hml<! hqcg<Gl<! yV! o\Ile<!gl<oheq?!nkqg! okijz!K~vk<kqzqVf<okz<zil<! -f<fqgp<s<sqjbg<! gi{!uf<kqVf<kuIgTg<Gh<! ohiqb! dhgivl<! osb<kK/! hqv <kihh<! hml<!

wMg<Gl<! gl<oheqbiI?! -vig<! nvsiqe<! nElkq! ohx<X! kr<gt<!oszuqOzob!yV!giiqbk<jks<!osb<keI/!!! nmg<g^<kzk<kqe<! OlOz! -VF~X! nc! dbvLt<t! fie<G!gl<hi^<gtqe<! lQ K! Wxg<Gjxb! Lh<hK! nc! fQ tLl<?! -VhK! nc!ngzLLt<t! omzquq]e<! kqjvgjth<! ohiVk<kqeI/! -keiz<! nr<G!GPlqbqVf<k! -zm<sg<g{g<gie! lg<gt<! fqe<xu{<{ligUl<?! nlIf<k!u{<{ligUl<! hqv^<kih! nmg<g^<kzr<gqtqzqVf<K! ogtvulqg<g! -V!âihig<gtqe<! hqOvkr<gjtk<! kqxh<hjkBl<?! outqOb! wMh<hjkBl<!kr<gtqe<! g{<gtiz<! fqkiqselib! fz<z! Ljxbqz<! gi{! sf<kIh<hl<!

gqm<cbK/!!! lXfit<!hg<kiK!fgiqZt<t!sqeqlig<!gim<sq!sijzgtqz<!wz<zil<!-f<fqgp<s<sq! kqjvbqmh<hm<M! lg<gTg<G! gi{<hqg<gh<hm<mK/! -u<uq]b!fqgp<s<sqg<Gh<! hqe<H! hg<kik<! fgiqOzOb! yV! ohiqb! ogif<ktqh<H!Wx<hm<mK/! ntux<x! ujgbqz<! B,kIgTl<?! gqxq <kuIgTl<! kr<gt<!GMl<hk<kiVme<! wu<uqkg<! gm<mibLlqe<xq! ht<tquibqz<gTg<G! uf<K!-^<zik<jkk<! kr<gt<! lelix! Wx<Xg<ogi{<meI/! fqkiqselie!-f<fqgp<s<sq!h{<jmbg<giz!uvzix<X!Wmz<z/!!

! -K! flK! gizk<kqOzOb! flK! g{<gtiz<! fqkiqselib<g<! g{<m!yV! fqgp<s<sqbiGl</! -k<kjkgb! nkqsbl<! gq/hq/2:43/! Nl<! N{<cz<!fmf<k!yV!uq]bliGl</!-f<fqgp<s<sqjb!yu<ouiV!lkk<kqeVl</!ne<eqb!fiMgjts<! siIf<k!hz<zibqvg<g{g<gie!lg<gTl<! g{<{ivg<!g{<meI/!ngqzk<kqZt<t! hz! hk<kqiqjggt<! -K! Gxqk<K! uqOs]lib<h<! hqvSvl<!osb<ke/!ne<xqBl<?!-u<umg<g^<kzr<gt<!ohbI!okiqbik!yV!sqzjvs<!



!

!



26

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

siIf<kkz<z/! -Xkq! fhqbil<! Lal<lK! v^|Zz<zia<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtqe<! nk<kqbf<k! f{<hIgtie! -V!âihig<gtqe<! hqOvk! fqgp<s<sqbiGl</! nuIgt<! biove<hjk! L <zql<!dzgl<! Le<eOv! nxqBl</! nuIgt<! wk<kjgObiI! we<hjk! L <zql<!dzgl<! Wx<Xg<! ogi{<Om! -Vg<gqxK/! kx<slbOli! Nbqvg<g{g<gie!lg<gt<! hqv <kihh<! Hkqb! nmg<g^<kr<gTg<Gs<! ose<X! kiqsqk<K!uVgqe<xeI}}/!!! -ju! Ohie<x! -e<El<! hz! nx<Hkr<gjtbxqb!NuZt<tuIgt<!nz<zili! j]G! B,SHf<! fhaieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgtK!Ä\ilqBz<!gxilik<}!wEl<!F~jz!Ofim<mlqMuiIgtig/!!! WOki! osix<hh<! OhIgt<! lm<Ml<!-k<kjgb!hkuqbjmf<Kt<tiIgt<!we<X! w{<{qg<ogit<tOu{<mil</! ÄÄWgxh<hqz<! NzlQ eVm<gitie! Oujp!hr<gitI!Ogic///Okglpqbik!fx<higl<!hjmk<k!lisqk<kIgtef<kr<Ogic}}!we<hkib<!G{r<Gc!l^<kie<!siaqH!uzqBz<zia<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTl<!wMk<Kg<!gim<cBt<tiIgt</!WeOu?!Olx<osie<e!hz!

sie<Xgjtg<!ogi{<M!ne<hqbi?!nUzqbig<gtK!smzr<gt<!lUk<kqx<Gh< <!hqe<El<!npqbiK/!nuIgt<!abik<Kt<tuIgt<!we<hK!oktquig!nxqb!Lcgqe<xK/!!! GINe<?! akQ K?! -\<li0?! gqbi <! Ngqbeux<Xg<G! Lx<xqZl<!lix<xlig! ne<hqbi?! nUzqbig<gTg<G! oltk<kqx<Gh<! hqxG! wk<kjgb!sg<kqBl<! -z<jz! we<Xl<! gHVgTg<Gt<! wZl<Hg<! %MgtibqEl<!gqjmg<Gli!we<hOk!sf<Okgl<kioee<Xl<?!nuIgtK!dOvill<!dt<hm!lcf<K! dg<gqbqxf<K! l{<O{iM! l{<{igquqm<mK! we<Xl<! %xq!uqk{<muikl<! osb<huIgt<! -eqObEl<! nxqU! ohXuiIgtig"!

nxqRIgjtbMk<K!nxqbijljbh<!Ohig<gqg<!ogit<uiIgtig""!!!

u^Qzi!Okmzili@!!! nUzqbig<gtqml<! u Qzi! OkMkz<?! dkuq! OkMkz<?! -vm<sqh<Hk<!OkMkz<?! fim<m! Okm<mr<gjt! fqjxOux<xqk<! kv! Ogm<mz<! Lkzqbe!ouz<zl<!%miK!.!nju!]qIg<giGl<!we<X!uq]bl<!nxqbikuIgt<kie<!%xqk<!kqiqgqxiIgote<xiz<?!njk!leKg<Gt<!ouXk<K!Oukjeh<hm<Mg<!ogi{<cVg<Gl<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtqe<!uiiqSgt<!weh<!hik<kqbjk!ogi{<miMl<!oltziei!oltzuqgt<?!nf<k!\er<gTg<G! d{<jljb! dhOksqk<kqVh<hiIgtieiz<! Ole<jlbig!-Vg<Gl</! njk! uqMk<K?! uq]blxqf<k! nuIgt<! uib<ohik<kq!hiviLglig!-Vh<hK!kVlle<X/!!



!

!



27

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ÄÄnUzqbig<gjt! fqjeU!%Iukiz<!nz<zia<uqe<! gqVhigmim<sl<!d{<migqe<xK/!fim<m!Okm<mr<gt<!jg%Mgqe<xe}}!we<hkib!j^bqKz<!NiqhQ e<!a\vk<!nHz<!gi^ql<!\|jeKz<!hGkikq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!kqVuib<!lzIf<kVtqBt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqmk<kqz<!dkuq!obik<kijs!Okmzil<!we<X!hzlie!Nkivr<gjtg<! ogi{<M! ^|e<ek<K! uz<! \link<kqeIgtiz<!dXkqh<hMk<kh<hm<cVg<g?!nUzqbig<gtqmk<kqz<!dkuq!Okmg<%miK!we<X!-g<gizk<kqz<!yV!fuQ e!%m<ml<!Wx<hm<cVg<gqxK}}!we<X!Ns<siqbk<Kme<!j]G! nh<Kz<! ag<G! Lak<kqKk<! kqa<zuQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! Än]qnk<Kz<! zl<Nk<.kI\|li! lq]<gik<}! 4.uK!higk<kqz<! oktqUhmg<! %xqbqVh<hkig! Äh <Zz<! gqk<kih<}! 22:.uK!hg<gk<kqz<! j]G! ]ia<! Laqb<bk<kQe<! siaqH! OuZ~iQ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! ne<hqbi?! nUzqbig<gjtg<! %h<hqm<M!dkuq! -vm<sqh<Hk<! OkMuK!âihig<gt<?! kihqbQe<gt<?! îzqaQ e<gt<?! L\<kaqkig! dzlig<gt<!

NgqObiIgTjmb! gqiqjbgjtg<! ogi{<M! NGole<hK! <kqvlig<gh<!ohx<xqVg<gqe<xK/! -jk! -e<giI! osb<uK! nxqbijlbiGl<}}! we<hkib!lkxi <!Lh<kq!nz<zili!la<&K!siaqH!nuIgt<!hk<a|z<!ag<!73.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! N{<mueqe<! hqvkqfqkqBl<?! lieqmuIg<gk<kqe<! Nkq! kf<jkBlie!Nkl<!njzaq^< zil<!nuIgt<?!lzg<%k<Kjmb!Nzk<kqzqVg<jgbqz<!nz<zia<uqe<! gm<mjtjb! outqvr<gk<kqz<! lQxq! fmf<kOhiK! nuIgt<!fi^|k<Kjmb!Nzligqb!-u<Uzgqz<! -xg<gh<hm<miIgt</! ne<X!Lkz<!SliI!Le<E~X!uVmr<gt<!klK!Gx<xk<jk!le<eqg<GliX!N{<mueqml<!

hqjp! ohiXg<gk<! OkcBl<! nr<gQgiqg<gh<hmuqz<jz/! fhq! Lal<lK!L^<k<khi!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgTjmb!u^Q ziju!ogi{<M! hiule<eqh<H! nr<gQ givl<! gqjmg<gg<%Ml<! we<X! w{<{l<!nuIgTg<G! d{<mieOhiK! ÄÄ-jxui! )Lal<lK! Ngqb*! -f<kh<!hqt<jtbqe<!ohiVm<miz<!)Nkl<!Ngqb*!-f<kk<!kgh<hEjmb!hqjpjbh<!ohiXk<kVt<uibig}}!we<X!u^Qzi!)sqhiiqS*!OkceiIgt</!!! dmOe?! nuIgTg<G! hiule<eqh<H! gqjmg<gh<! ohx<xK! we<X!aig<gql<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! âQ a|!L^<k<kk<vg<gqZl<?! jhag<gQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!

kzibqZe<EHu<uiuqZl<!iquibk<Ks<!osb<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ^|Haie!lUzqKjmb!Lkz<!aqg<gibk<kqZl<?!lx<Xl<!hqvhzlie!gqvf<kr<gtqZl<!-u<uqhvl<!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!!



!

!



28

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! -e<eLl<?! ÄÄLal<lK! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<?! nzq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|?! hik<kqli!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<ai?!aê<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|?!a|jê<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! NgqbuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! u Q zik<! Okcbke<! ohiVm<miz<!N{<mue<! Nkl<! njzaq^< zil<! nuIgTg<Gg<! gqVjh! osb<kie<}}!we<X!fhq!giQ l<!Lal<lK!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!kqVuib<!lzIf<kVtqbkig!-HE!nh<hi <!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<! ogi{<Mt<t! iquibk<K?! kh< Q V! KIVz<! le<K~iqz<! -lil<!^|B,k<kq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! OlZl<?! ÄÄLal<lK! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<?! nzq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|?! hik<kqli!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<ai?!aê<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|?!a|jê<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! NgqbuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! Nkl<! njzaq < zil<! nuIgt<!u^Qzik<!Okcbjk!Le<eqm<M!nuIgtqe<!kUhi!yh<hg<ogit<th<hm<mK}}!we<hkib<! F <ak<Kz<! l\izq <! 3.uK! higl<?! 418.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/!

!! -e<eLl<! hzlie! êjkg<! ogi{<M?! Lak<kqK! kh<xieQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!iquibk<Ks<!osb<gqxiIgt</!!!! we<eoueqz<?!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!KNg<! Ogm<Gl<! ohiPK!kr<gTjmb!ag<jgg<! ogi{<Ml<! kr<gTg<G!Le<E{<mie! fhqliIgtK! ag<jgg<! ogi{<Ml<! KNg<!Ogm<cVg<gqxiIgt</!!! ngqz!dzgk<kqx<Gl<!nVm<ogijmbigUl<?!sgz!hjmh<HgjtBl<!

le<xic! gjv! OsIk<K! -vm<sqg<Gl<! ut<tzigUl<! nuIgt<! -Vf<Kl<!nuIgOt! kr<gjtg<! ogi{<Ml<?! lx<Xl<! fhqliIgjtg<! ogi{<Ml<!u Qzi! Okc! -Vg<gqxiIgt</! lx<OxiIgt<! wh<hc! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M!u^Qzik<!OkmilzqVg<g!LcBl<"!-u<uqkl<!-lil<!^|Hg<gq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! ! nuIgTjmb! ]qhi! d < qgil<! we<x! F~zqZl<?!-lil<! -HE! a\Vz<! lg<gQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTjmb! \u<aVz<! Let<tl<! we<x! F~zqZl<! osiz<zh<hMukig!ÄÄnHtZ^<!^zuik<K}}!we<x!gqvf<kk<kqz<!wMk<Kjvg<gh<hMgqxK/!!! -r<G!gueqg<g!Ou{<cbK!biokeqz<?!nz<zia<Ug<G!gzQ hiUl<?!

NkqfhqBl<?! NkqhqkiUlie! Nkl<! njzaq < zil<! nuIgt<!N{<muEjmb! YI! WuZg<G! outqvr<gk<kqz<! liX! osb<k! yV!Gx<xk<jk!u Q ziuqe<xq! le<eqg<gh<hmuqz<jz! we<xiz<?! giz!LPuKl<!g{g<gx<x!Gx<xr<gt<?!hiur<gt<!Hiqf<K!uVl<!fl<Ohie<xuIgt<!ne<hqbi?!nUzqbI?! gilqzQe<gtqe<! u qziuqe<xq! =Omx<xl<! njmuK! wr<rel<@!we<hOkbil</!



!

!



29

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! )bi! nb<Baz<zkQe! NlEk<kGz<zia.uh<k<k%! -jzaqz<!u^Qzk<k////*!!! ÄÄY?! =lie<! ogi{<muIgOt"! fQr<gt<! nz<zia<juh<! hbf<K!ogit<Tr<gt<?! OlZl<?! nuetuqz<! u Qzi! Okcg<! ogit<Tr<gt<}}!we<hkig!-jxue<!keK!hiqSk<kk<!kqVljxbqz<!%xqBt<tie/!)6;46*!!! ÄÄN{muetuqz<! OsVukx<G! u Q ziju! ogi{<Ombz<ziliz<!OuX!upqbqz<jz/!u^Q ziuqe<!kik<hiqbl<!nUzqbi!gilqzQ e<gOt}}!we< <X!Olxosie<e!kqVljx!use!uqtg<gk<kqz<!kh< Q I!'a|z<!hbie<!3.uK!higl<!499.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!uqbig<gqbiel<!osb<bh<!ohx<xqVg<gqe<xK/!!! wuEg<G!)x^|Zz<zia<!lQ K*!lah<hk<K!-z<jzObi!nuEg<G!=lie<!-z<jz}}!we<hkigUl<!akQ K!uf<Kt<tK/!!

!! ÄÄwe<Ejmb!xa<lk<K!djmb!%m<mk<kiI!)nUzqbig<*!gtqmk<kqz<!dr<gTjmb! Okjugjtk<! Okch<! ohx<Xg<! ogit<Tr<gt<}}! we<x!akQ jk! jhag<gQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ^|ee<!Gh<xiuqZl<! kh<xieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! L0\l<!nu< k<kqZl<?! nhQ bQ K! Gk<iQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M!iquibk<Ks<!osb<gqxiIgt</!-f<k!akQjkOb!-lil<!leiuQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!]va|!\ilqd^< gQ I!2.uK! higk<kqZl<?! Lz<zi! nzq! giiQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<!]va|Jez<!-z<lqZl<!wMk<Kjvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄfqs<sblig! nz<zia<Ujmb! ncbiIgt<! sqzI! -Vg<gqe<xiIgt<?!\er<gTjmb!Okjugjt!fqjxOux<Xukx<oke<Ox!nue<!nuIgjts<!osif<kh<hMk<kq! juk<kqVg<gqe<xie</! kr<gTjmb! Okjugjth<!H,Ik<kqbig<gqg<! ogit<ukx<gig! \er<gt<! nuIgjt! n{<MuiIgt</!nuIgt<!nz<zia<uqe<!Oukjejb!uqm<Ml<!ns<sl<!kQ If<kuIgt<}}!we<x!akQK!-HE!dlI!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M!khxieqbqz<! uVukig! nz<\ilqd^< gQI?! 2.uK! higl<?! hg<gl<! 89z<!wMk<Kjvg<gh<!ohx<Xt<tK/!!

!!

)-ki!kab<bIk<Kl<!hqz!d&Iq?!



!

!



30

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

h^< <k<kbQ E~lqe<!na<zqz<!GH,iq*!!! ÄÄgVlr<gtqz<! kqjgh<hjmf<K! uqMuQIgOtbieiz<! gHVgjt!djmbuIgjt! )nUzqbig<gjtg<*! ogi{<M! dkuq! Okcg<!ogit<Tr<gt<}}! we<X! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<! %xqb! akQ K?! nh<Kz<zia<! -HE! l <U,K! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! Lak<kqK! -HE! nhqk<Ke<bi!gI]Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! )uhik<K! aq\<iq! 392*! nuIgt<!iquibk<Ks<! osb<ukig?! k <iQ a|z<! nu<kg<! .! kI\|li! ]va|! hI\g<!hg<gl<!42:.z<!wMk<Kjvg<gh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! -e<eLl<?! OlOz! Gxqh<hqm<m! akQK! hx<xq! ^qvi\|z<! L0lqeQe<?!]va|JEz<-z<L?! ava|! hI\g<?! g\iek<Kz<! \zizQ?! hkiui!îKz<zhQh<! Lkzqb! gqvf<kr<gtqZl<! nxquqg<gh<hm<Mt<tK?! we<hkig!Kz<hgiI! jakiqb<bi! 324.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! Lx<gizk<K! Lh<kQ ! Lh<kqz<!hi\qz<! jakI!]ia<! gikqiQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!

!! OlZl<?! ]va|JEz<! -z<L! 64.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! -lil<! Lz<zi!nzq! giiQ! lg<gq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTl<?! kh< Q I!'a|z<!hbie<?!6.uK!higl<?!491.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!dl<kk<Kz<!Lh^<^qiQ e<!j]G! - <libqz<! ag<gQ! h'^q! 'lq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTl<! k <iQ a|z<! nu<kg<hQ ! kI\|li! ]va|z<! hI\g<! 42:.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!Nkivk<Kme<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! Olx<g{<m! akQjk! Gk<uK^<! îzqg<gQ e<?! ^|h<kk<Kz<! NiqhQ e<?!Sz<kie<! hia|!uzqb<Bz<zia<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!

La<gLz<! Hgviuqz<! wMk<kxquqk<kqVh<hKme<?! ÄÄnUzqbig<gt<! H,lqbqe<!gQ p<! keqk<K! gz<uk<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</! nuIgTg<G! ns<sole<hkqz<jz/!nuIgt<! N{<muOeicVg<gqxiIgt</! lE?! \qe<! bivigm<Ml<?!OkjuBjmbuIgt</! uq]bk<jkBjmbuIgtie! nUzqbig<gtqe<! gHV!)slikqg<Gpq*! gTg<Gs<! osz<zm<Ml<"! nh<hch<! Ohigqe<x! nuIgTjmb!g]<mr<gotz<zil<!fQ r<gq!-zGuigquqMl<}}!we<hkigg<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄlieqmEg<G!WkiuK!g]<m!f]<ml<! Wx<hm<miz<!nue<!nUzqbi!dz<zig<gtqz<! yVujvg<! %h<hqm<M! dkuq! Okmm<Ml</! nf<kuzq!dbqOvicVf<kiz<! ofich<ohiPkqz<! gix<X! nuVg<G! wm<cjug<Gl</!

nz<zK! nuI! RiekqV]<c! )g]<H*! &zl<! okiqf<Kogit<uiI/! NuI!lv{qk<Kh<! OhibqVf<kiz<! uieuI! )lzg<G*! nuVg<G! nxquqk<K!juh<hiI/!nuI!N{<mueqmk<kqz<!sqhiiqS!Okc!fquIk<kq!osb<K!kVuiI/!-u<uiX! gilqzQe<gt<! %m! lzg<gqe<! nxquqh<hqe<xq! kir<gtigOu!Ogm<Mg<ogit<gqe<xiIgt<}}! we<X! akQ kqz<! uVukig! ]va|! hI\g<gqz<!



!

!



31

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

gi{h<hMgqxK! we<X! hk<a|z<! ag<G! 212.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!osiz<zh<hMgqxK/!!

!!!! ÄÄwuVjmb! giz<fjmh<! hqvi{qbiuK! gi{ilx<! Ohib<uqm<miz<?!Änz<zia<uqe<! ncbiIgOt?! nz<zia<! dr<gTg<G! fz<zVt<!hizqh<hieig?! kir<gt<! weg<G! dkuq! osb<Br<gt<! we<X! %h<hqm<Mg<!OgTr<gt<}}! we<hkig! dt<t! akQjk! -HE! nh<hi <! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M!iquibk<Ks<!osb<bh<hMgqxK!we<X!aq <Ee<!a Q eqz<!nxquqg<gh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! WuVjmb! giz<fjmh<! hqvi{qbiuK! gim<ce<! hg<gl<! uqv{<Omic!uqm<miz<?! ÄÄnz<zia<uqe<! ncbiIgOt! njkh<! hqck<K! fqXk<Kr<gt<! .!nz<zia<uqe<!ncbiIgOt!.!njkh<hqck<K!fqXk<Kr<gt<!.!nz<zia<uqe<!ncbiIgOt! njkh<hqck<K! fqXk<Kr<gt<! we<X! %uq! njpg<gm<Ml<!we<hkig!dt<t!akQ K?!-HE!l <U,K!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! iquibk<Ks<! osb<bh<hMgqxkigUl<! Olx<hc!aq^<Ee<!a Q e<!gqvf<kk<kqz<!ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/!!

!!!!! ÄÄwuVg<giuK! dkuq! Okjuh<hMlieiz<! nz<zia<Ujmb!ncbiIgOt"! weg<G!dkuq! HiqBr<gt<"!nz<zia<Ujmb!ncbiIgOt"!weg<G!dkuq!HiqBr<gt<"!nz<zia<Ujmb!ncbiIgOt"!weg<G!dkuq!HiqBr<gt<"! we<X! %xm<Ml<}}! we<X! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq!

u^z<zl<! kqVuib<! lzIf<kVtqbqVg<Gl<! akQ K! kh<xieQ .aq^<Ee<!a^Q e<.âQa<!-HE!nuiei!Lkzie!gqvf<kr<gtqz<!uf<Kt<te/!!! -K! hx<xq! Nkivl<! Äu Q zi! \zQ zi}! hg<gl<! 219Zl<!ÄKvV^< eqb<bi.hQ.xk<kq!nzz<!ua<aihqb<bi!hg<gl<! 44.Zl<?! Äh <Zz<.



!

!



32

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

gqk<kiH}! hg<gl<! 243! Zl<! hk<a|z<! ag<G! hg<gl<! 82! Zl<!ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! Olx<%xh<hm<m! akQ Kgtqz<! gi{h<hMl<! )-hiKz<zia<*!nz<zia<Ujmb!ncbiIgt<!we<hkx<Gg<!gVk<K!L^<zqlie!leqkIgt<!.!L^<zqlie!\qe<gt<!.!lzg<Ggt<!.!iq\iZz<!jgH!.!)ljxf<K!uiPl<!leqkIgt<*!.!nh<kiz<gt<!.!nUk<kiKgt<!.!Gk<HliIgt<!LkzqbuIgOt/!-uIgt<!dbqOvicVh<hqEl<! siqOb?! lv{qk<kqVh<hqEl<! siqOb!-uIgjt!njpk<K!dkuq!Okch<!ohXkz<!NGl<!we<hkx<G!OlOz!osiz<zh<hm<m!akQKgOt! Ohikqb! Nkivr<gtiGl<! we<hkib! Ä-a<gig<Gz<agibqG}!we<x!F~zqz<!ujvbh<hm<cVh<hkig?!ose<jeh<! hqvkl!Lh<kQ ! oltziei!oltzuq! nz<ai\<! Lal<lK!ahQHz<zzi! siaqH! guIe<ol{<M! sQ h<!gi\Q!na<z!^|e<ek<K!uz<\link<!nuIgtK!hk<ui!.!kI!.!hbiOe!.!\ui <! - <k<kql<kiK! .!ne<hqbi! .! u! .! nUzqbi! dz<ziaq! wEl<!hk<uis<! sie<Xl<?! Äu Q zi! \zQ zi}?! hk<a|z<ag<G! Lkzqb! F~x<gTl<!%Xgqe<xe/!!

! OlZl<! -u<uixie! nk<kim<sq! Ähvg<gik<Kz<! -l<kiK! .! zq! .!na<zqz<!.!-^<k<kql<kik<}!we<x!F~zqZl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄgihqIgt<! uqg<vgr<gjt! N{<muEg<G! -j{big! Ng<gq?!kr<gtK! Okjugjt! njugOt! Sblig! fqjxOux<Xgqe<xe! we<X!gVkq! nux<xqe<hiz<! dkuq! OkMgqxiIgt</! L <zql<gOt! ne<hqbi?!nUzqbig<gjt! N{<muEg<G! -j{big! Ng<gqjug<gilz<!N{<mueK! n <li! ^qhik<K! outqbiGl<! lt<aI! Ngg<! gVkq?!nuIgtqml<!dkuq!OkMgqxiIgt</!!

! uqg<gqvgr<gjtg<! %h<hqm<muIgt<! f]<muitqgtibqeI/! ne<hqbi!nUzqbig<gjtg<! %h<hqm<muIgt<! o\bl<! ohx<xuIgtibqeI}}! we<X!Gk<uk<K^<!îzqg<gQ e<?! oltziei?!nz<ai\<! o^b<bqK!]ia<!dlI!îaqH! gikqiq! jakvihikQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!kh< QI!g]<Hz<!GZ~hqz<}!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ]ihqbQ ! lKahqe<! -lil<! Lal<lK! -h<E! -k<iQ |]<! ]ihqbQ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! osb<bKei! -lil<! &^z<!gizql<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! gHV]iQHg<Gs<!ose<X!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<Bl<! OhiK!nf<ks<! sr<jgbie!gHjv! Ofig<gq?!

ÄÄfqs<sblig! -K! hqvik<kjegjt! Wx<X! yh<Hg<ogit<th<hMl<! we<X!nEhuk<kqz<!hiQ m<sqg<gh<!hm<m!ytmkliGl<}}!we<X!djvk<kiIgt</!!! -u<uquvk<jk! nz<zili! o]b<G! nh<Kz<! ag<! kqa<zuQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Än]q! nk<Kz<! zlNk<!kI\|lKz<! lq]<gik<}! 2.uK! higl<?! 744.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<?!-lil<! -HE!



!

!



33

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

o\t^Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Ä^h<uk<Kz<! ^h<ui}!uqZl<?! o]b<G! Lal<lK! lt<aI! fg<]hf<kQ! kqa<zuq! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ÄKIVz<! Let<tl<}! uqZl<! %Xukig?!Lh<kQ !nz<zili!la<&K!siaqH!lk<xi q!nuIgt<!^qz<Gz<!Lnt<tl<?!49.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!wMk<Kjvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄ-liLz<!n0tl<! o^b<bqKei!nH,aeQ hi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! gHV! ]iQ H! kqm<mlig! flK! Ljxh<him<jmg<!Ogm<M! Okjugjt! fqjxOux<xqkv! uz<zkibqVg<gqe<xK}}! we<hkig?!gz<Zjmf<kiZl<! osiz<Zjmbik! nz<zili! -lil<! -HE! a\Ilg<gQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Äjgvik<Kz<! .! aqîeqz<}!%Xukig?! nz<zili! Lh<k<kQ ! la<&K! îaqH! lkxi Q ! nuIgt<!hk<a|z<!ag<G!89!uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄ-lil<! o]b<G! l0'Hz<! gIgQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<!hvgk<Ks<!osb<bh<hm<m!leqkIgTt<!OlzieuIgt</!NuIgtK!gHV!]iQ H!fqs<sbligh<!hiQm<sqk<K!Osikje!osb<bh<hm<m!nuqp<kliGl</!

WuoviVuI?! nf<kg<! gHV! ]iQ hqzqVf<K! )klK! Ke<hl<?! KbI! uqzg!Ou{<Mole<x! w{<{k<Kme<*! biokiV! u <k<Kju! wMh<hOvz<! nuvK!hzib<!L^Qhk<Kgt<! fquIk<kqbig<gh<hMl<}}! we<hkig?!j]Gz<!-^<zil<?!Jg<giqb<bz<! ne< iiQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!Ä]va|iqîzk<! kqz<.Gj]iqb<bi}uqz<! Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tkig?! NiqHhqz<zia<?!]ia<! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! îaqH! OuZ~iq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<!Äh^<Zz<.gqk<kih<!226.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! a\<vk<! o]b<G! l0'Hz<! gIgQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgtK! uhik<K! aq\<iq! 312/! nuIgtK! nmg<gk<kzl<! hGkikqz<!

-Vg<gqxK/! nuIgt<! Ou{<MOgiTg<Gh<! hkqz<! ntqg<gg<! %cbuIgt</!nuIgtK!gHV!]iQjhg<!ogi{<M!hGkiK!uisqgt<!hq{q!Ofib<!fQr<g!]qhijuk<! Okch<ohXgqe<xeI/! nf<kg<! gHV! ]iQ H! nEhuH,Iuligh<!hiQ m<sqg<gh<hm<m! sR<sQuqbiGl<}}! we<X! -lil<! nHz<gi^ql<! Gj]iQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! j]Gz<! - <zil<! Jgiqb<bz<! ne<siiq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! -VuVl<! kr<gt<! iqîzig<gtqz<!ujvf<kqVh<hkib<?!nz<zili!Lh<k<kq!la<&K!îaqH!lkxi^Q !nuIgt<!Ähk<a|z<ag<G!91.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!wMk<K!nxquqg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! -u<uixig! -lil<! bihqbQ! bleq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!

nuIgTl<! osiz<ukig!nz<zili!j]G!B,SH!fhaieQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! Ä\ilqdz<! gxilk<kqz<!nUzqbi}!3uK!higl<!378.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqMgqxiIgt</!!! Gk<Hz<! ng<hI?! j]G! nHz<aê<! nzqb<B]<! ]iKzq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! 6.uK! gzQ hi?! nz<Gk<H!



!

!



34

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

o^b<bqK! ]l<Sk<kqe<! aehqb<bqz<.aluqb<bq]<.]iKzQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!kr<gtK!uhik<kqe<!Oujtbqz<?!ÄÄOkjuBt<t!wuVl<! we<Ejmb! gHVg<G! uf<K! nuvK! fim<mr<gjtg<! Ogm<hOvz<!nux<jx!fie<!fqjxOux<xqk<!kVOue</!Woeeqz<!weg<Gl<! )Okjujbg<!OgiVl<*! nuVg<Gl<! -jmbqz<! yV! Ltl<! l{<Ot! K~vl</! ke<jes<!siIf<kuIgjt! yV! Ltl<! l{<! kMg<Golbieiz<! nue<! N{<!hqt<jtbe<X}}! we<X! osie<ekig!nz<Gk<H!-lil<! nh<Kz<.ua<aiH]<!]0xieQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! Äkhgik<Kz<.Gh<xi}! 3.uK!higl<?!97.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! nz<Gk<H!o]b<G!Lal<lK!-HE!na<lK!hIgz<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!ÄÄfie<!gHiqzqVf<K!outquf<K!dziug<!%cb!kÎvhik<okEl<! sg<kqjb!djmbue</! wuVg<OgEl<!ai\k<K! fim<m!Okm<ml<?! -Vg<Glieiz<?! we<! Lgk<kqx<ogkqOv! uf<K?! we<eqmk<kqz<!Okjugjtg<! Ogm<hivibqe<?! fie<! fqjxOux<xqk<! kVOue<}}! weg<!%xqbqVg<gqxiIgt<! we<hkig! -lil<! ]0vieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<?! khg<gik<K?! 3.uK! higl<?! :4.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!

nxquqk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄwuoviVuVg<G! klK! Okjugt</! fim<m! Okm<mr<gt<?! fqjxOux!Ou{<Mole<xqVg<Glieiz<?!nuI!^|vk<Kz<!hik<kqai?!Nbk<Kz<!GI^Q ?!nzl<! f]<va< |vi! -jugjt! Ykq?! nux<xqe<! kuijh! Gk<Hz<!ng<k<kiH?! a\<vk<! n]<j]G! nh<Kz<! gikqV! \Qzieq! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTg<G!ntqg<gOu{<Ml<?!hqxG!hGkiK!kqjsjb!Le<Oeig<gq! hkqoeiV! wm<omMk<K! juk<K?! Äbi! o^b<bqkQ! nh<Kz<!gikqI}! we<X! hk<K! uqMk<kl<! njpk<K! Ou{<c?! klK! fim<m!Okm<mr<gjtg<!Ogm<g!Ou{<Ml<}}!we<hkib!-lil<!o]b<G!\ziZk<kQ e<!

^|B,k<kq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Ägqk<kiHI.va<li.hqk<kqh<hq.uz<.aqg<li}!we<x!F~zqe<!395.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! OlOz! g{<m! uq]br<gjt! fil<! -r<G! Np<f<K! sqf<kqg<g!Ou{<cbK! nusqbl</! -^<zik<kqe<! sm<m! kqm<mr<gjtk<! okiGk<Kg<!ogiMk<K! ÄlKaH}ju! Wx<hMk<kqk<! kf<k! -lil<! ]i0hQ bq! Lal<lK!-HE!-k<iQ <!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!sm<m!fqH{Igtigqb!-lil<!-HEa\I! lg<gQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|?! -lil<! Gj]iQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|?! -lil<! \g<giqb<bbz<! ne< iiQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! NgqbuIgTl<?! nz<Gk<H! ]l<Sk<kQe<!

aluQ !lq^<iq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|?!nz<Gk<H!Lal<lK!-HE!na<lK! hIgz<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! Ngqb! Gk<HliIgTl<!gHVgjtg<!Gxqh<hqm<M!-u<uiX!%xqBt<tiIgote<xiz<! Ofib<!fQr<gUl<?!uXjl!uqzgUl<?!uqbihivl<!uqVk<kqbigUl<?!fiM!ospqg<gUl<?!fqg<gia<!Lkzie! fz<z! giiqbr<gt<! lr<gtlib<! fjmohxUl<?! OkjugjtBl<!



!

!



35

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

kivitlig!u^Q zi!&zl<!Ogm<Mh<!ohxzil</!We<!u^qziuigg<!Ogm<Mh<!ohxg<%miK!we<hOk/!!! -jubjek<kqx<Gl<! Oll<hm<M?!nUzqbig<gTg<ogz<zil<!nvsvie?!nz<Gk<HI!vh<hieQ?!uz<!ogtK^<!^lkieQ !o^b<bqKei!Laqb<bqk<kQ e<!nh<Kz<! gikqV! \Qzieq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!ÄJb<eqb<bi}uqz<!%xqBt<tjkh<!Hk<kqsizqgt<!hck<Kh<!hbejmuiIgtig/!!! nuIgt<!dhOksqk<Kg<!%XuK!biokeqz<;.!!! ÄÄfQ ! Ykqh<! hck<k! Hk<kgr<gjt! uqm<MuqM/! Woeeqz<! nf<k!nUzqbig<gTjmb! fmh<Hg<gt! nOfgg<! gqk<kiHgtqz<! fqe<Xkie<!Wx<hm<Mt<te/! wr<gTjmb! upqg<Gl<! nf<k! nUzqbig<gt<! kie<!upqgim<cgt</! fil<! NkvU! juh<hkx<G! ne<euIgOt! OhiKlie!Hjkbz<gt</!!! nf<k! nUzqbig<gjth<! hqe<hx<xqbue<! OfIupq! ohXuie</! wue<!

hqe<hx<xuqz<jzObi!nue<!upqogm<mie</!!! NhqkQ e<gt<! wz<OziVl<!nf<k!nUzqbig<gjtOb!hx<xqh<! hqck<Kg<!ogi{<miIgt</!nf<k!nUzqbig<gt<kie<!leqkove!lkqg<gh<hMhuIgt</!! nuIgtqe<!kqVs<sLgk<jk!fQ !hx<xqh<!hqck<Kg<ogit</!!! dzgk<kiIgt<! hqvkqh<! hqvObi\er<gt<! ohXukx<G! nf<k!nUzqbig<gOt!yKr<Gl<!kzr<gtiGl<}}!we<hOk/!!! n]<o]b<G! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! -HE! nxhQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!

ne<a|!nuIgt<!-lil<!hGXk<kQe<!xi\Q !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTg<G!dhOkslig!wPkqbkiuK;!biokeqz<;.!!! ÄÄwl<leqke<! d{<jl! we! sikqg<g?! kIg<guikl<! Hiqujk! uqm<M!outqh<hmuqz<jzObi?! nl<leqke<! nUzqbig<gtqmk<kqz<! yV! OhiKl<!H,v{! =lie<! djmbueig! lim<mie</! Woeeqz<?! nf<k! leqke<! kie<!gx<x!osix<h!gz<uqjb!wz<jzbqz<zikkigg<!g{<M?!nf<k!nx<hk<jkOb!KVuq! Nvib<ukqz<! keK! Olzie! ubjkh<! Ohig<gcg<gqxie</! Nsz<!Ofig<gk<jk!njmf<kueig!lim<mie<}}!we<hOk/!!

! -lil<! na<lK! -HE! al<hz<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|?!j]G! - < |k<kQ e<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! Ngqb! -VuVl<!kGkq!uib<f<k!sqxf<k!-V!Lak<kqKgt<?!-e<giVg<Gh<!hqxOg!-uIgt<!nUzqbig<gtqe<!nf<kvr<gh<!OhXgjth<!ohx<xiIgt</!!



!

!



36

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! -lil<! na<lK! -HE! al<hz<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!!nuIgt<! a\vk<! nH,al<\i! hGkikQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTjmb! l\<zq qz<! dm<giIf<k! hqxGkie<! -lil<! nuIgTg<G!ngg<g{<gt<!kqxf<ke/!!! -lil<! na<lK! -HE! al<hz! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! klK! GlivVg<G! osb<Bl<! dhOksk<kqz<?! ÄÄlgOe"!nUzqbig<gt<! hiz<! yV! ohiPKl<! ogm<m! w{<{l<! ogit<tiOk"!nuIgTjmb! sguisk<jk! yV! OhiKl<! lxf<kqVg<giOk"! nuIgt<!nglqbk<kqe<! ohig<gq]r<gjt! nxqf<kuIgt<?! fiOli?! nu<uiX!nxqf<kqvik!KvkqI]<msizqgt<}}!we<X!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! o]b<G!-^< |k<kQe<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|?!Gk<Hz<!ng<hI!nHz<aê<!nzqb<B]<!]iKzQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!djmb!sguisk<kiz<!ohVl<!OhXgjth<!ohx<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gt<! kie<! agQ gk<jk! djmbuIgt</! NuIgTjmb!

OfIjlg<G!-KOu!OhiKlig!nk<kim<sqbiGl</!lx<xuIgt<!ouXl<!hpg<g!upg<gr<gtqz<! ngh<hm<Mg<! ogi{<M! gqmg<gqe<xeI}}! we<X! o]b<G!-^< |k<kQe<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! osiz<zqg<!ogi{<cVh<hiIgt</!! d{<jl!-u<uixqVg<g?!Äu^Q zi}ju!fqvigiqg<gg<%cb!uvl<H!lQ xqb!%m<mk<kiIgt<?! ne<hqbig<gjt?! nUzqbig<gjt?! biv^|zz<zia<"!biuzqb<bz<zia<"! we<he! Ohie<x! osix<gjtg<! ogi{<M! njpg<gg<!%miK! we! hzlig!uquikl<! Hiqgqe<xiIgt</! kr<gtK!GVm<Mk<kelie!-k<kjgb! uqk{<miuikk<kqx<Gs<! sikgligh<! hqe<uVl<! kqVg<GINe<!user<gtqe<!gVk<jkk<!kuxie!Ljxbqzig<gq!kr<gTg<Gs<!sikglie!

Nkivr<gt<!we!leh<hiz<!Gcg<gqe<xeI/!!! )hzi!kk<Dlnz<ziaq!nake<*!we<x!83;29!GINe<!Nbk<kqx<G?!ÄÄweOu?!nz<zia<Ume<!wujvBl<!u{r<gikQ Igt<}}!weUl</!!! )ÄÄuzi! kk<d! lnz<ziaq! -ziae<! Ngv! zi! -zia!-z<zia|u*!we<x!39;99!GINe<!Nbk<kqx<G! ÄÄnz<zia<Ume<! OuoxiV!fibje!fQ I!u{r<gikQ I!nujek<!kuqIk<K! )u{g<gk<Kg<Giqb*!fibe<!)OuX*! -z<jz}}! weUl<?! ^|e<ek<K! uz<\li! nk<K! Lh < qiQ e<gt<!gVk<Kk<! okiquqk<kqVg<g! u^Q ziju! fqvigiqg<gg<%cb! Olx<osie<e?!

ngQ kih<! hqsgqb! %m<mk<kiIgt<?! Olx<g{<m! -V! Nbk<Kg<gTg<Gl<!ÄÄfQ r<gt<! nz<zia<Ume<! OuoxiVujvBl<! njpg<gOu{<mil<}}! weUl<?!ÄfQ I! nz<zia<Ume<! OuoxiV! fibje!njpg<g! Ou{<mil</! nujek<!kuqv! )u{g<gk<Kg<Giqb*! fibe<! )OuX*! -z<jz}}! weUl<! nIk<kl<!gx<hqk<K! kr<gtK! uqk{<miuikk<kqx<G! Nkivr<gim<m! Lx<hMgqe<xeI/!



!

!



37

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

-ju! Ohie<x! ÄÄzikk<d}}! we<X! uvg<%cb! lx<x! Nbk<Kg<gjtg<!ogi{<Ml<!-uIgt<!-u<uiOx!OlxOgit<!gim<Mgqe<xeI/!!! njpk<kz<?! uqtqk<kz<?! %h<hqMkz<! we<x! uiIk<jkgTg<Giqb!gVk<Kme<! kqVljxbqz<! ÄKN}! wEl<! hkl<! sqz! -mr<gtqz<!hqvObigqg<gh<hm<cVg<gqxK/!Äu{r<Gkz<}!we<x!gVk<KmEl<!kqVljxbqz<!sqz!-mr<gtqz<!ÄKN}!wEl<!hkl<!hqvObigqg<gh<hm<cVg<gqxK/!!! ÄKN}! wEl<! osiz<zqx<G! -Vuqklie! ohiVm<gt<! dt<te/!u{g<gk<jkh<! ohikqf<kqz<zik! sikiv{! njph<H?! uqtqh<H?! %h<hqMkz<!we<x!ujgh<!ohiVt<!ye<X/!!! -hikk<K! wEl<! u{g<gk<jkk<! ke<Et<tmg<gqg<! ogi{<m!hqvik<kjebie!nIk<kk<Kme<!%cb!ohiVt<!lx<oxie<X/!!! Lf<kqb! ujg! hx<xq! -jxue<! keK! hiqSk<kk<! kqVljxbqz<!)dk<U!-zi^hQzq!xh<hqg<ghqz<!aqg<lk<kq!uz<!lu<!-tk<kqz<!aêk<kq*!

!! ÄÄ)fhqOb*! fQ I!dlK! -vm<sgEjmb! hijkbqe<! hiz<!aqg<lk<jk!)uqOugl<*! ogi{<Ml<?! npgqb! dhOksk<jkg<! ogi{<Ml<! njph<hQ vig*!we<X!%Xgqe<xie</!)27;236*!

-u<usek<kqz<! Ädk<d}! we<x! KNh<! hkl<?! u{g<gk<jkh<!ohikqf<kkibqz<zik!nIk<kk<kqz<!Änjph<hQ vig}!we<X!upr<gh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! Hqf<kqbK! hx<xq?! u Q ziju! Nm<Oshqg<Gl<! ohiVm<M! fqvigiqh<OhiI!nk<kim<sqbig! wMk<Kg<! gi{<hqg<Gl<! Nbk<Kg<gtqz<! u{g<gk<jkh<!ohikqf<Kt<t!gVk<kqz<! hqvObigqg<gh<! ohx<xqVg<Gl<! KNg<gjth<! Ohiz<!

nz<zia<Ume<! OuX! okb<uk<jk! u{r<g! Ou{<miole<hOk/!-h<ohiVjtOb!OuX!Nbk<Kg<gTl<!uqtg<gqg<!gi{<hqg<gqe<xe/!!! fQ r<gt<! nz<zia<jube<xq! kr<gTg<Gh<! hqvObi\ek<jkbiuK!kr<gmk<jkbiuK! osb<b! -bzikux<jx! )-hikk<Ks<! osb<K*!u{r<Ggqe<xiIgt</! )21;29*! we<Xl<?! -ju! Ohie<X! -kv! Nbk<Kg<gt<!%XujkBl<!sqf<kqk<Ks<!sQ I!K~g<gq!Nvib<f<K{<Ig"!!! weOu?! ne<hqbi! nUzqbig<gjt! njpk<Kg<! %h<hqMkz<! %miK!we<hkx<G! Nkivr<gtig! wkqiqgt<! %Xl<! Nbk<Kg<gtqZt<t! ÄKN}!

uieK?! nz<zia<juk<! kuqvUt<tju! okb<uk<! ke<jlg<G!diqk<kieju?! u{g<gk<kqx<G! hik<kqvlieju?! we<X! gVkqBt<t!nuqSuisqgt<! uq]bk<kqz<! kie<! ohiVf<Kol! bz<ziK?! agQgk<kqz<!wz<zil<! nz<zia<! yVujeg<! ogi{<Om! fjmohXgqe<xe/!!okb<uk<ke<jlg<G! kGkqBjmbie<! u{g<gk<kqx<Gh<! hik<kqvuie<!nujebe<xq!OuX!wuVlqz<jz!we<X!uqSuisl<! )=lie<*!ogi{<Mt<t!



!

!



38

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

L^<zql<gt<! ne<hqbi?! nUzqbig<gjt! uqtqk<K! njpg<Gl<!uq]bk<kqx<G! Lx<xqZl<! ohiVf<kiK! we<hK! biVg<Gl<! okiqf<k!outqh<hjmbie!uq]bliGl</!!! ÄÄdr<gtqz<! sqzI! sqzjv! njph<hOk! Ohiz! dr<gTg<gqjmbqz<!x |jz! njph<hjk! fQ r<gt<! Ng<gqg<! ogit<tikQ Igt<}}! we<x! )35;74*!Gxqh<Hme<!%cb!kqVljx!useolie<X{<M/!!! kh< Q I! gi\qe<! .! kh< QI! 'a|z<hbie<! îuQ ! Lkzqbux<xqz<!nxquqg<gh<hm<Mt<thc?! -ke<! kik<hiqbl<! biokeqz<! dr<gTt<! sqzI!sqzjv! g{<{qbg<! GjxuigUl<?! sikiv{ligUl<! njph<hjk! Ohiz!fhq! ohVlieiI?! x^|Oz! giQ l<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgjt! njpg<gilz<! g{<{qbk<KmEl<?! liqbijkBmEl<?! bi!x^|zz<zia<"! bi! ahQ hz<zia<"! bi! fhqb<bz<zia<"! Ohie<x! npgqb?!g{<{qblie!uiIk<jkgjtg<!ogi{<M!njpg<g!Ou{<Mole<hOk/!!! sqz! sf<kIh<hr<gtqz<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!

nuIgjt!njpk<kz<!-hikk<kqx<G!nusqbliekiBl<!Ngq!uqMgqxK/!!! )n < ziL!njzg<g!nb<Baf<!fhqb<B*!! ÄÄnVjl!fhqbuIgOt"!dr<gt!lK!^zil<!d{<miukig}}!we<X!

nuIgjt! njpk<kz! nk<kaqb<bik<kqz<! nusqblie! giiqbliGl</!

nk<kaqb<bik<K! -u<ujph<hqe<xq! H,Ik<k qbigiK/! nk<kaqb<bik<kqe<xq!

okiPjg!H,Ik<kqbigiK/!-jk!gueqk<K!Ofim<mlqm!Ou{<Ml/!

!

! NgOu?! L <zql<gt<! %h<hqm<mjpg<Gl<! uqtqh<H?! njpk<kz<!sqzOujt! NGlie! giiqbliBl<! sqzOujt! gm<miblie! giiqbliBl<!

njlf<Kt<tK! we<hK! Olx<osie<e! Nkivr<gjtg<! ogi{<M! fe<G!okiqbuVgqxK/!!! nz<zia<ju! njph<hkx<G! KN! we<Xl<?! lx<xuIgjt!njph<hkx<G! Äfqki}! we<Xl<! osiz<zh<hMl</! -f<kk<! kivkl<lqbk<jk!nxqbikhc!Äbix^|zz<zia<!.!bi!uzqb<bz<zia<!bi!Laqb<bk<kQ e<! .!bi!j]G}!Ohie<x!hkr<gtiz<!njpk<kz<!NgiK!we<hkigk<!okiqbik!ke<jl!ogi{<M!ua<aihqgtig!sqzI!%Xgqe<xeI}}!we<hkig!a\<vk<!]ia<! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! îaqH! OuZ~iQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<!h <Zz<!gqk<kihqz<!-lil<gjtg<!ogi{<M!nxquqg<gqe<xiIgt</!

!! OlZl<! -k<kjgb!uqhvk<jk!nz<zili!Lh<kQ! la<&K!îaqh<!lkxi Q! nuIgTl<! hk<a|z<! ag<gqz<! %xqBt<tiIgt</! weOu!u Qziju! Le<eqm<M! ne<hqbi?! nUzqbi?! gilqzQe<gjt! njpk<Kg<!%h<hqMkz<!yVg<giZl<!-jx!u{g<glib<!lixquqmiK/!]qVg<Gl<!nz<z/!!



!

!



39

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! n <aiH <.^|h<hiuqZt<t! xhQ N! -HE! gHz<! ne< iiQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!xquibk<Ks<!osb<gqe<xiIgt<;.!!! ÄÄfhq!ohVlieiI!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgOtiM!fieqVf<Oke</! UZs<! osb<ukx<Gk<! k{<{QI?! lq <uig<G?! sQ h<H!ujgbxig<gjt! wMk<Ks<! ose<X! ogiMk<Oke</! ns<slbk<kqz< <! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! we<je! Ofig<gq! -l<jl?!lXjlg<Giqb! fzuie! giiqbr<gtqz<! deg<Gk<! Okjubieux<jx!we<eqmk<kqz<Ogt<}}!we<X!osie<eiIgt</!!! ÄÄkr<gTme<! osiIg<gk<kqzigq! -Vh<hjk! Nsqg<gqe<Oxe<}}! we<X!%xqOee</!!! ÄÄ-k<OkiM! -e<El<! Ouoxe<e! Okju@}}! we<X! lQ {<Ml<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!uqeuqeiIgt< </!!! ÄÄ-Okbz<ziK!Ouoxie<Xl<!Okjubqz<jz}}!we<X!djvk<Oke</!

!! OlOz!Gxqh<hqm<m!akQ K!âQa|!L^<zql<!.!-HE!li\i!L0\l<!ghQI! kh<vieQ ! .! n]q0! nk<Kz<zlNk<! Ngqb! gqvf<kr<gtqz<!%xh<hm<cVg<gqxK/!!! -f<k! akQ kqz<?! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<?!deg<Gk<!Okjubiejk!we<eqml<!Ogt</!^|uiz<!osb<!we<X!%xqbK!-l<jl?!lXjlh<!OhXgjt!ntqh<hjkg<!Gxqg<gqe<xK!we<hkig!akQkqe<!uqiqUjvbitIgt<!ujvgqe<xiIgt</!!

! j]G!nh<Kz<!ag<G!Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! -f<k! akQ kqe<! ]vaqz<?! ÄÄ-l<jlBl<! lXjlBl<!dr<gtiz<! gqjmk<k! se<liek<kqz<! fqe<XOl! d{<mieju?! OlZl<?!zu<a|gzl<!djmb!gz<uq!dr<gtqe<!Rier<gtqzqVf<Ok!d{<mieju/!!

!

!! )h-e<e! lqe<! \|kqgk<! Ke<bi! utIvk<kai.ulqe<! dZ~lqg<g!-z<lz<! zu<aq! uz<gzlq*! we<X! g Q kk<Kz<! Hikiuqz<! -lil<! H,îq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! osiz<zqbqVh<hjkBl<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!



!

!



40

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ÄÄN{<muEjmb!dk<kqvU!ogi{<M!ÎuOv!Nzl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! -l<jl?! lXjlbqe<! nVm<ogijm!fq0lk<Kgjt! ntqg<gqe<xiIgt</! nu<uixig! ntqg<g!uz<zjlBjmbuIgt<}}! we<hOk! ^|e<ek<! uz<\link<kiiqe<!uqSuisliGl</!!

!!

)ne!gi^qLe<!uz<zia|!B0k<kQ*!!ÄÄogiMg<gqe<xue<! nz<zia<?! hr<G! juh<hue<! fie<}}! we<X! âQ a<!Hgiiqbqz<!gi{h<hMl<!akQjk?!-lil<!-HE!a\I!lg<gQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! ]va|! al< qb<bi?! 2:3.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!wMk<Kjvk<K! ÄÄN{<mue<! keg<Gs<! osif<kliBt<t! d{utqk<kz<!dt<hm! nxqU?! Riel<?! upqh<hiM! Lkzqb! wz<ziuqklie!ohig<gq]r<gtqe<! siuqgjtBl<! keg<Gh<! hqvkqfqkqBl<?! )ahQH*!OkipVlie! fhq! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!usl<! ogiMk<kqVg<gqe<xie</! nuIgt<! hr<G! juk<Kg<! ogiMg<gg<!%cbuIgtig!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt</!nuIgt<!&zligOu!sgzLl<!ntqg<gh<!hMgqe<xe}}!we<hkig!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! OlZl<?! HK~ak<kz<! na<lkqb<bi.hQ.lqeaqz<! Lal<lkqb<bi?! 9:.uK!hg<gk<kqz<?!nz<zili!j]G!Sjzlie<!\lz<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTl<!-h<hcOb!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!

! ÄÄnz<zia<! yVujek<! kuqIk<K! OuX! biiqmLl<! wf<kuqk!dkuqBl<! OkmOu!%miK}}! we<x!uikk<kqx<Gs<! sqzI!-b<big<g!f0HK.u-b<big<g! f <k<kbQ e<}}! we<x! )2;5*! Nbk<jk! Olx<Ogitigg<!gim<MuKme<?! fhqObi?! x^|Ozi?! Gk<Ohi?! uzqObi! biVg<gibqEl<!zihf]<mk<jk! d{<mig<Gl<! sg<kqB{<ome<X! fl<HuKl<?! nuIgtqml<!dkuq! OkMuKl<! liohVl<! Gx<xl<! we<hkib<! uqiqUjvBl<! %Xgqe<xeI/!-K!nuIgtK!nxqbijljbOb!gim<Mgqe<xK/!!! Woeeqz<?! ^|vk<Kz<! hik<kqai?! nl<V.faQ ?! Wuz<.uqzg<gz<?!lîbqz<gjt!uqm<Ml<! fQr<gqbK?!nkqz<! gm<Mh<hm<mkz<z}}! we<X!kh< Q I!

na<lkqb<bi!%Xgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄWuz<?! uqzg<gz<! )nl<V?! faQ *!djmb!Nbk<Kg<gt<! GINeqz<!Jf<K~Xl<?!akQ kqz<! &uibqvLl<! gi{h<hMgqe<xe/!-b<big<g! f0HK.u.-b<big<g! f^<k<kbQe<}}! we<x! )2;5*!Nbk<K!nkqz<! OsIf<kkz<z}}! we<X!u^Qzi!\zQ zi?!57.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!osiz<zh<hMgqxK/!



!

!



41

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! OlZl<!nOk!hg<gk<kqOzOb?!de<je!yVuoee<E!dXkqogi{<M!deK! u{g<gk<kqx<G! de<eqmOl! dkuq! OkMgqe<Oxil<! we<hOk! 2;5!Nbk<kqx<Gh<! ohiVtiGl</! we<hkig! o^b<bqKei! -HE! nh<hi <!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! -g<iqli!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! iquibk<Ks<! osb<ukigg<!Gxqh<hqmh<hm<Mt<tK/!!!! -u<uixie! uqtg<g! uqhvk<jk! ^qvI\|z<! aqkibi! 88.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?! îbqg<gk<Kz<! lUk<KuJEz<! abik<kqZl<?! kh< QI!lkiiqg<gqZl<!gi{<g/!!! NgOu?! Wuz<! uqzg<gzqz<! Osvik! ye<jxs<! osb<kz<! NGole!uqtr<gg<! gqmg<gqe<xK/! -f<k! Nbk<K! Wuz<?! uqzg<gZjmbK!nz<zuijgbiz<?! ne<hqbi! nUzqbig<gt<! hiz<! dkuqobik<kijsk<!Okmg<! %mioke<hkx<G! NkivligiK?! dkuq! Okmg<!%mioke<xqVg<Golbieiz<! )u <k<kbQ E! hq < Hiq! u^< zik<kq*! .!

ohiXjljbg<!ogi{<Ml<?!okiPjgjbg<! ogi{<Ml<!dkuq!OkMr<gt<}}!we<x! Ouk! uig<Gl<?! )uh<k<k%! -jzaqz<! u Q zk<k*! ÄÄnuetuqz<!u^Qzijuk<! Okcg<ogit<Tr<gt<}}! we<x! )6;46*! Oukuig<Gl<!uf<kqVg<giK/! )dk<Zhz<! auibq\! -zikuqI! va<lk<kqlqe<! dl<lk<kQ *!we<Ejmb! xa<lk<K! djmb! %m<mk<kiI! )nUzqbig<*! gtqmk<kqz<!dr<gTjmb! Okjugjtk<! Okch<! ohx<Xg<! ogit<Tr<gt<}}! we<x!akQKl</!!! )-ki!kab<bIk<Kl<!hqz<!d&Iq!h^<k<kbQ E~!lqe<!na<zqz<!GH,I*!ÄÄgVlr<gtqz<! fQ r<gt<! kqjgh<hjmf<K! uqMuQIgOtbieiz<! gHVgjt!

djmbuIgjt! )nUzqbig<gjt*g<! ogi{<M! dkuq! OkMr<gt<}}! we<x!akQKl</!!! ÄÄwuVjmb! giz<fjmh<! hqvi{qbiuK?! gi{ilx<Ohib<! uqm<miz<?!nz<zia<uqe<! ncbiIgOt?! nz<zia<! dr<gTg<G! fz<zVt<!hizqh<hieig?! kir<gt<! weg<G! dkuq! osb<Br<gt<! we<X! %h<hqm<Mg<!OgTr<gt<}}!we<x!akQ Kl</!!! ÄÄwuVg<giuK! dkuq! Okjuh<hMlieiz<! nz<zia<Ujmb!ncbiIgOt"! weg<G!dkuq! HiqBr<gt<"!nz<zia<Ujmb!ncbiIgOt"!

weg<G!dkuq!HiqBr<gt<"!nz<zia<Ujmb!ncbiIgOt"!weg<G!dkuq!HiqBr<gt<"!we<X!nuI!%xm<Ml<}}!we<x!akQ Kl<?!!! lx<Xl<!-ju!Ohie<x!akQ KgTl<!uf<kqVg<gk<!Okjubqz<jz/!!



!

!



42

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! Lag<gqGz<! aehqb<bq?! n]<.j]G! nh<Kz<geq! fihz< Q !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! kql]<G! fgiqz<! ^zQ li! we<x!-mk<kqz<! GINe<! ]iQ Hg<G! uqbig<gqbie! uqtg<gl<! osb<Kg<!ogi{<cVg<jgbqz<?!)bi!nb<Baz<zkQ e!NlE~!-^<k<kbQ E~!hq^<^h<iq!u^< zik<kq*! ÄY?! =lie<! ogi{<muIgOt"! ohiXjljbg<! ogi{<Ml<?!okiPjgjbg<!ogi{<Ml<!dkuq!OkMr<gt<"}}!we<x!)36;264*!Nbk<jks<!Sm<cg<gim<c?! ÄÄN{<mujek<! kuqIk<Kh<! hqxiqml<?! dkuq! Okmg<%miK!we<X! osiz<gqxuEg<G! -K! vk<kiGl<?! nh<hcs<! osiz<gqxue<! gihqvigq!uqm<mie<?! Woeeqz<! GINEjmb! f < |g<G! )oktquigUl<?!outqh<hjmbigUl<! uf<Kt<t! WuZg<G*! lix<xlig! -Vg<Gl<!giv{k<kqeiz<?!Okjugt<!fqjxOux!nUzqbig<gjtg<!ogi{<M!dkuq!OkMuOk!sqxf<k!upqbiGl<}}!we<X!%xqeiIgt</!!! uqhvk<jk! nz<zili! j]G! B,^|He<! ehaieQ?! lq <iQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! ]uiaqKz<! ag<G! 362.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!

! ÄÄ\Q uqb!gizk<kqz<!dkuq!OkMukx<G!wuIgt<!kGkqbieuIgOti!nuIgtqml<! uhik<kqx<Gh<! hqxGl<! dkuq! Okmzil<}}! we<hkig! -lil<?!a|\<\k<Kz<! - <zil<?! g < izQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! nz<zili! j]G! nh<Kz<! ag<G! Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! Än]qnk<Kz<!zlNk<.kI\|li!lq]<gik<}!Lkz<!higk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄg]<m! gizk<kqz<! nUzqbig<gtqmk<kqz<! -vm<sqg<Gl<hc! dkuq!OkMkz<!%Ml</!lUk<Kg<Gh<!hqxGl<!nuIgt<!-vm<sqh<Hk<!kvg<%cbuIgt</!Woeeqz<?! ne<hqbig<gTjmb! L0\qîk<Kl<! nUzqbig<gTjmb!

gxilik<Kl<! lUk<Kg<Gh<! hqxGl<! uqMhm<Mh<! Ohig! lim<mi/! NuIgt<!abik<Kt<tuIgt</! hI\Gjmb! Nzk<kqz<! okipUl<! osb<gqe<xiIgt</!a\<\|l<! osb<gqe<xiIgt</! -u<uiX! Nkivlie! akQ Kgt<!uf<kqVg<gqe<xe}}/!!! Olx<! osie<e! uqhvl<?! nz<HK~aik<Kz<! na<lkqb<bi! :1.uK!hg<gk<kqz<?!nz<zili!j]G!^|jzliEz<!Jlz<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgTl</! ]uiaqKz<! ag<G?! 7:.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! nz<zili!j]G! B,^|He<! ehaieQ! lq <iQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTl<!wMk<Kjvk<kqVg<gqxiIgt</!

!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqmk<kqz<! dkuqOkMl<! uq]b! sl<hf<klib<! Äg]<H}!)gz<Hg<g{<*! djmb! l]ibqGgjtg<! ogi{<Mt<t! iquibk<Kg<gt<!nOfgL{<M/! -K! hx<xq! gqkiHgtqZl<?! iq izig<gtqZl<! hgqvr<glig!nxquqg<gh<hm<Mt<te/!!



!

!



43

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! uikk<kqx<G! lVf<K{<M/! hqcuikk<kqx<G! lVf<kqz<jzbikziz<!hqcuiklig! lXh<huIgTg<G! nju! hqvObi\er<! ogiMg<glim<mi/!Njgbiz<?!nK!hx<xq!-r<G!wPk!Ou{<cb!nusqblqz<jz/!-k<kjgb!hqcuikk<! ke<jljb! uqm<Ml<! N{<mue<! fl<jlg<! gih<hix<xqg<!ogit<uieig"}}! we<kig! j]Gz<! aqf<K?! nh<Kz<! ag<! Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?! Än]qnk<Kz<!zlNk<!kI\|li!lq]<gik<}!higl<!4?!hg<gl<!486.z<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! lg<iQ H! Oksk<kqz<! uZh<hlie! hgQ aiBl< <?! hqvhz<blie!NiqhiBlqVf<k! o^b<bqK! na<lK! -HE! JI'g<G]<! ]iKzQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!%Xgqe<xiIgt<;.!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gt<! abik<kqz<! osb<Bl<! dkuq! uZh<hieki@!oltk<kqx<gh<hiz<! osb<Bl<! dkuq! uZh<hlieki@}}! we<X!j]G! nHz<!nh<hi^<! at<vlQ ! nuIgt<! we<eqml<! uqeuqbkx<G?! oltk<kie! hqe<H!nuIgt<! HiqBl<! dkuqkie<! lqgUl<! uZh<hlieK}}! we<X! %xqOee</!weK!-f<k!uqjmjb!nuIgt<!yh<Hg<ogi{<miIgt<!we<hOk/!

!! uqhvl<!Än]qnk<Kz<!zlNk<!kI\|li!lq]<gik<}!2.uK!higl<!744.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!! ÄÄoltk<kqx<Gh<! hqxG!nUzqbig<gtqmk<kqz<!dkuq!Okmziole<hK!lqGklie!l]ibqGliIgtqe<!kQ IlieliGl</!!! NiqhQ e<gtqz<?! dzlig<gtqz<! lqGklig! OhIgTjmb! ngQ ki!)fqI{bl<*!-KOukie<}}!we<hkig!-lil<!j]G!nH,^bQ K!^zlQ !aehQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!]va<!hI\g<gqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!

! OlZl<?! nuIgt<! nkqz<! oltk<jk! -V! ujgbig!uqhiqg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄoltk<Kg<Gh<! hqxK! 'a|! fqk<kqblieK/! npqux<xK/! Neiz<!-f<k! outqvr<glie! kqOvgl<! npqf<KuqMl</! -uIgt<! silie<bIgtie!nuil<gt</! -uIgt<! hqxVg<G! dkuq! osb<b! sg<kq! ohx<xuIgt<! -K!yVujg/! oltk<kqx<Gh<! hqxG! 'a|l<! npqbiK?! dmZl<! npqbiK/!dt<vr<glie! dbqVmZme<! abik<KmOl! we<XlqVh<hI/! -uIgt<!ne<hqbi?! nUzqbig<gt<?! dbqOviM! -Vh<huIgTg<G! -uIgt<! dkuq!osb<b!sg<kq!ohx<xuIgt</!-K!lx<oxiV!ujg/!

!! âQaie!akQ Kgtqz<!-kx<Gh<!hzlie!Nkivr<gT{<M/!-jk!wuVl<!lXg<g!sg<kq!ohx!lim<miIgt<}}!we<X!nuIgt<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!



!

!



44

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! u Q zi!.!sqhiiqS!.!-^<k<kql<kiK!.!-^<k<kqgiki!.-^<k<kq]<hi!.-^<k<kq!Nei!Lkzqb!hkr<gt<!hzuqklig!-Vh<hqEl<!-ju!gVk<kqz<!ye<Ox/!!! yk<kijs!Okmz<?!sqhiiqS!Okmz<?!dkuq!Okmz<?!-vm<sqh<Hk<!Okmz<?!Ofib<! fquiv{l<! ohxk<! Okmz<?! dhgivl<! Okmz<! Lkzqbe! LjxOb!nux<xqe<!hkh<ohiVtiGl</!!!!!!!

u^Qzi!!! u Q zi! &e<X! ujgh<hMl</! dkiv{k<kqx<gig! nu<ujggjt!

ncbqz<!gi{<g/!!! ÄÄN{<mui"! o^b<bqK! nh<Kz<! gikqX! \Q zieQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!ohiVm<miz<!we<!hq{qjb!fQOb!fQg<Guibig}}!we<X!wz<zil<!uz<z!-jxueqml<!-jxR<sq!Ou{<MuK!yV!ujg/!!! ÄÄbiLaqb<bk<kQe<"! Laqb<bk<kQ e<! N{<mjgbuIgOt"! we<! hq{q!kQv! fibeqml<! hqxiIk<kje! HiquQIgtig"}}! we<X! uq{<{h<hqk<Kg<!ogit<uK!-e<oeiV!ujg/!!! ÄÄbi! Laqb<bk<kQe<"! bi! ogtKz<! n0tl<"! )ogtKz<! n0tl<?!Laqb<bk<kQ e<! N{<mjgbuIgOt"*! kir<gt<! nz<zia<uqe<!hqvkqfqkqbigUl<?! nueqz<! fqe<Xl<! kk<Kuk<jkh<! ohx<xuIgtigUl<!-Vg<gqe<xQIgt</!Nehcbiz<?!kir<gte<xq!weg<G!OuX!gkqbqz<jz/!we<!hq{qjbk<!kir<gOt!fquIk<kqg<g!Ou{<Ml<}}!we<X!Ofvcbig!Ou{<Mkz<!osb<K!lx<oxiV!ujg/!!! -u<uixig! &e<X! uqkligg<! Ogm<hKUl<! NGl</! -f<k! &e<Xl<!ye<Xkie<}}! we<hkig! -lil<?! L\<k<kaqK?! kgqb<Bk<kQe<! ^|Hg<gQ ?!]ihq-b<bq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ]qhid < qgil</!245.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! Äne<hqei?! nUzqbig<gt<! N{<mueK! n <li?! ^qhik<Kg<gt<!outqbiGl<! lTaIgt</! N{<mue<! ntqk<kqVg<gg<%cb! kk<Kuk<jk!outqbig<gqk<kv!uz<zuIgt<!we<x!w{<{k<Kme<!Ofvcbig!ne<euIgt<!hiz<! flK! Okjugjtg<! Ogm<gzil</! N{<muEl<! ne<euIgTg<G!nk<kjgb! sg<kqjbg<! ogiMk<Kt<tie<}}! we<hkig?! lkxi^<! Lh<k<kq?!



!

!



45

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

guIe<ol{<M! gi\Q ?! nz<ai\<! Lal<lK! ahQ Hz<zia<! îaqH!nuIgTl<?! nz<ai\<! Lal<lK! klQ l<! îaqH! Nzql<! Lh<kq!nuIgTl<?! gi\q! djhKz<zi! îaqH! nuIgTl<! lx<Xl<! hz!dzlig<gTl<?!Lh<k<kqgTl<!hk<ui!ogiMk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! -r<relqVg<g?! ÄÄN{<muEg<Gh<! hbh<hMujkBl<?! nuEg<G!upqhMujkBl<!hx<xqh<!hqck<Kg<ogit<uQI"!!! nz<zia<juk<!kuqIk<K!biiqmLl<!hbOli?!NkvOui!ogit<tikQI"!sIuOkjugjtBl<! nz<zia<uqe<hiz<! yh<hjmk<K?! nueqmOl! wz<zik<!OkjugjtBl<! Ogm<hQ vig"! nz<zia<! nz<zikux<xqe<! lQ K! NkvU!jug<gilz<!nueqmOl!fl<hqg<jg!ogit<uQ vig"}}! we<hkib<! o^b<bqKei!Laqb<bqk<kQe<! nh<Kz<! gikqX! \Q zieQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! kr<gtK!lUk<kqe<! OhiK!kr<gt<! lgeiI!o^b<bqK!nh<Kz<!ua<aiH! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTg<Gs<! osb<k!u^qb<bk<jk! wMk<Kg<! gim<c?! ne<hqbi! nUzqbig<gt<hiz<! dkuq!OkMkz<!%miokeg<!%Xgqe<xeI/!

!! -kx<G! Ä- <k<kqNek<.agQ gQ}! we<X! ohbI/! GINe<?! akQ K!ogi{<M?! Ä- <k<kqNek<.l\i^Q }! NGlie! giiqbOl! we<hjk! a\<vk<!ogtKz<! n0tl<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! nxqf<Ok!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt</! lg<gt<! nuIgt<! hiz<! dkuq! OkcbjkBl<?!OkMujkBl<?! lUk<kqx<Gh<! hqxG! Okmh<OhiujkBl<! nuIgt<! okiqf<Ok!-Vg<gqxiIgt<?!Njgbiz<! -jk!nuIgt<! uqzg<gUlqz<jz/!wk<kjgb!Okjugjt! lg<gt<! nuIgtqml<! OkceiIgt</! nux<jx! nuIgt<!wu<uiX! fqjxOux<xqg<! ogiMk<kiIgt<! wEl<! uqhvr<gt<! nuIgtK!siqk<kqvr<gtqz<!%xh<ohx<xqVg<gqe<xe/!

!! nuIgt<!-vm<sqh<hkqz<!uZh<hlieuIgt</!N{<mue<!nuIgTg<G!-vm<sqk<K!dkuqosb<bg<!%cb!kk<Kuk<jkg<!ogiMk<Kt<tie</!!! o]b<Gei! Gk<Hz<! ng<k<kiH?! ogtK^<! ^lkieQ ?! la<H,H!^|HaieQ ?!Laqb<bqk<kQ e<!nh<Kz<!gikqV!\Qzieq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! hqe<uVliX!%xq! -Vh<hjkBl<! yh<hqm<Ms<! sQIK~g<gqh<!hiIk<K!d{<jljb!d{Vr<gt<"!!! )- <lQ.g.-^<lqz<!n0tl<*!

!! ÄÄ)fim<m! Okm<mr<gjt! fqjxOux<xq! juh<hkqz<*! weK! kqVfill<?!uZhhlie! N{<mueK! )-^<Lz! n0tl*! okb<uQgk<! kqVfilk<jkh<!Ohie<Xt<tK}}!we<hK!nuIgTjmb!ohie<olipq/!-u<uqhvl<?!Nkivlie!hqvhz<blqg<g!ÄleigqH}!gqvf<kr<gtqozz<zil<!gi{g<gqmg<gqe<xK/!!



!

!



46

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! jakvihik<kqe<!Lx<giz!Lh<k<kq!oltziei!oltzuq!Lal<lK!^bQ Kgie<! îaqH! nuIgTl<! -K! sl<hf<klib! ogiMk<Kt<t!hk<uiuqZl<!-Khx<xq!uqtg<gh<hMk<kqBt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<! -lil<?! nh<Kz<zia<! bihqbQ ! bleQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK!ÄGzi^k<Kz<!lhigqI}!wEl<!gqkihqz<!j^b<bqKei?!^|z<k<kiEz<!nUzqbi?!o^b<bqK!La<bqk<kQe<!j]G!nh<Kz<! gikqV!\Qzieq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! osiz<z! fie<!Ogm<Omoee<X!o]b<G!dlVz<!h^<îI!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtk<!okim<Ml<!iquibk<K!nxquqg<gh<hm<Mt<tK/!we<eoueqz<;.!!! ÄÄwuoeiVue<?!yV!L Q hk<kqz<!sr<gmk<kqz<!ngh<hm<Mg<!gqmg<Gl<!OhiK! nue<! we<jeg<! ogi{<M! vm<sqh<Hk<! OkMuieibqe<! nuje!uqm<Ml<!nf<k!L^Qhk<jk?!sr<gmk<jk!fQ g<gh<hMl</!!! OlZl<?! biviuK! uVk<kk<kqz<! ngh<hm! OfIf<kiz<! we<jeg<!ogi{<M! vm<sqh<Hk<! Okmm<Ml</! nuje! uqm<Ml<! nf<k! uVk<kk<jk!

fQ g<gh<hMl</!!! -e<El<! biviuK! yV! )ai\k<K*! fim<mk<jk! fic!nz<zia<kNzi! ntuqz<! we<jeg<! ogi{<M! u Q zi! sqhiiqS!Okuieigqz<!nf<k!ai\k<jk!nuEg<G!fqjxOux<xqg<!ogiMg<gh<hMl</!!! OlZl<! wuoviVuI! -v{<M! vg<nk<K?! yu<ouiV! vg<nk<kqZl<!^|vk<K! hik<kqaiUg<Gh<! hqxG! ^|vk<K! -g<zi <?! )Gz<a|uz<zia|!naK!^|viju*! 22! uqMk<kl<! Ykq! okiPK!^zil<! ogiMk<k! hqxG!fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgjt! fqjeU%If<K!

nuIgt<!Ohiqz<!^zuik<Kl<!^ziLl<!osiz<zqbkx<gh<hiz<?!we<Ejmb!filk<jk! ds<siqk<k! u{<{l<?! keK! fim<mk<jkBl<! fqjeU!ogi{<mueig?! -vig<G! Oksk<ktuqz<! 22! wm<M! wMk<K! juk<kieigqz<!nf<k!ai\k<jk!fqjxOux<xqg<!ogiMg<gh<hMl<}}!we<hOk/!!! -kx<ogih<h!a\<vk<!o]b<G!nh<Kz<!ag<G!Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Ä\|h<kKz<! NkiI}! we<x!F~zqZl<?! -lil<! Lz<zi! giiQ ! lg<gQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<?! ÄÄF <ak<Kz<! gik<kqVz<! hik<kqI}}! we<x! F~zqZl<!wMk<Kjvk<Kt<tiIgt</!

!! -e<eLl<?! Gk<Hivh<hieQ?! ogtKz<! n0tl<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!kr<gtK!lg<gjt!Ofig<gqg<!%xqbjkh<!hiVr<gt<;.!!! nuIgt<?!kr<gt<!lg<gjt!Ofig<gq?!we<je!uqm<Ml<!osz<Zr<gt</!outqvr<gk<kqz<! fie<! dr<gTme<! -Vg<gqe<Oxe/! dt<vr<gk<kqz<!



!

!



47

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

lx<oxiVuEme<! -Vg<gqe<Oxe/! weg<Gl<?! dr<gTg<Gl<! -kv!sqV]<cgTg<Gl<! -jmOb! uiek<kqx<Gl<! H,lqg<GLt<t! K~v!uqk<kqbislqVg<gqxK/!we<je!-kvIgjt!Ohiz<!Dgqg<g!Ou{<mil</!!! fie<! dr<gt<! Bg<kqg<G! nh<hix<hm<mue</! we<eqjzjb! fQ r<gt<!biVl<! nxqblim<CIgt</! fie<! dr<gjtuqm! dbIf<k!ds<sfqjzbqzqVg<gqOxe<}}!we<X!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<?! kr<gt<! GlivI! o^b<bqK!nh<Kz<! \h<hiI! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtg<! %h<hqm<M?! ÄÄfQ I! dxr<Ggqe<xQ vi?!uqpqk<kqVg<gqe<xQvi@! we<eqz<! fQ I! heiuigquqMl</! uqpqh<hjmuQ I}}! we<X!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<! nuIgt<?! ÄÄN{<mueiz<! weg<gVth<ohx<x! ngg<!g{<j{g<!ogi{<M!fie<!-u<Uzjgg<!jgbqZt<t!yV!gMjgh<!Ohiz<!gi{<gqe<Oxe<}}!we<Xl<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!

! nk<kjgb! la<H,H! ^|Haieq?! l0]|g<Gxa<lieq! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! djvk<Kt<t! jhk<K! )osb<Bt<*! gjth<!hiVr<gt</!

!!!

! wuoviVuI! fl<jl! dgf<K! flK! -mk<kqx<G! uVgqxiOvi! nuI!fibgk<kel<! ohx<x! fikig<gTjmb! Ogim<jmg<Gt<! HGf<K! fl<Ljmb!giIliek<kqzigq!lqGkqbie!sl<hk<jkh<!ohx<Xg<ogit<uiI/}}!!



!

!



48

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!!! ÄÄwe<Ejmb!LiQ Kg<G!wu<uqklig!hbr<gvLl<!uf<k[gilz<?!fie<!nuje! nuEjmb! gVlr<gtqz<! wf<kuqklie! kQr<Ggt</! hzib<!L^Qhk<Kgt<!uvilz<!hiKgik<Kg<!ogit<Oue<}}/!

!! ÄÄwe<Ejmb! LiQ Ok"! deg<G! fz<livibl<! d{<miukig"!de<Ejmb! Okjugt<! njek<jkBl<! deg<G! fqjxOux<xqk<kVuke<!Ohiqz<! deg<Gs<! Osihel<"! BiokiV! gVlk<jkh<! hx<xqbiuK! fQ!uqbi%zljmf<K! Kg<gqk<kueig! -Vh<hibieiz<?! nu<Oujtbqz<! fie<!weK!aql<lk<! wEl<!K{qs<sz<! ogi{<M!deg<G!dkuq! osb<K!fie<!de<je!vm<sqh<Ohe<}}/!!! ÄÄwe<Ejmb! LiQOk"! we<jeh<! hx<xqh<! hqck<Kg<! ogit<"! we<je!uqSuisqk<kueig! -Vf<Kogit<"! nh<hcbieiz<! fie<! de<je!

-u<UzgqZl<!lXUzgqZl<!gih<hix<XOue<}}/!!! ÄÄwe<Ejmb!LiQ K!nR<sq!fMr<Gl<!Oujtbqz<!nueK!ns<sk<jk!fQ g<gq!jug<Gl<!hiKgiuzie!fie<!-Vg<gqOxe</!wz<zi!uqklie!hqk<eis<!OsikjegtqzqVf<Kl<?! ohiz<zir<GgtqzqVf<Kl<! fie<! nujeh<! Oh{q!hiKgik<Kg<!ogit<Oue<}}/!



!

!



49

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! ÄÄwe<Ejmb! LiQ K! gqpg<gqOzi?! Olx<gqOzi! dt<t! wf<k!DiqzqVh<hqEl<! nueK! njph<hqx<G! fie<! uqjvf<K! ose<X! dmOe!nuje!-vm<sqh<Ohe<}}/!

!!! ÄÄwk<kjgb! g]<mk<kqZl<?! hbk<kqZl<! fQ ! we<eqml<! dkuq! OkM/!wz<zig<! giiqbr<gtqZl<! fie<! deg<G!dkuq! Hiqf<K!-vm<sqg<g! weK!aql<lk<Kme<!N\viOue<}}/!!

!!! biVg<giuK!biokiV!uVk<kl<! uqbi%zl<!d{<mibqVg<Glibqe<?!nuIgjt!uqm<Ml<!nf<kk<!Ke<hl<!KbI!uqbi%zr<gjt!fie<!fquIk<kq!osb<K! ogiMk<K! nuIgTg<G! -vm<sqh<Hg<! ogiMg<Gl<! dkuqbigUl<?!gqVjhbigUl<! Ngq! -Vg<gqOxe</! Nkziz<?! weK! osr<Ogijzg<!Gxqk<Kg<! gm<cbl<! %XkozEl<! sr<g! fikl<! gqpg<G?! Olx<G!wh<hGkqgtqZl<!yzqk<Kg<ogi{<Om!-Vg<gqe<xK}}/!!!

!!

!!

ÄÄwe<Ejmb! LiQK! dkbgqiqbqOzi! nz<zK! n <kgqiqbqOzi!nz<zK!Npqb! sLk<kqvk<kqe<! ncuivk<kqzqxr<gq! fqe<Oxi?!Ngibk<kqe<!ds<sqbqz<! fqe<Oxi! wf<fqjzbqz<! we<eqml<! dkuq! nhbl<! Okc!njpk<kiZl<! dmOe! fie<! nujeg<! gik<K! -vm<sqh<Ohe</! we<je!



!

!



50

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

wkqIk<K!upg<giMl<!nk<kje!OhIgjtBl<!sl<giqk<Kk<!kQIh<Hs<!osb<Bl<!%iqb!uitig!fieqVg<gqOxe<}}/!!

!! ÄÄ-h<OhiK! osie<e! osix<gotz<zil<! ohVjljb! fic! fie<!osiz<zuqz<jz/! N{<mueqmlqVf<K! nu<uiX! osiz<Zl<hc! uf<k!dk<kqvuqe<! hqvgivl<kie<! fie<! osie<Oee</! Woeeqz<?! \er<gt<! weK!agQ g<gk<jk!nxqukx<gigOu}}/!!

! ÄÄnu<uixie! uiIk<jkgt<! wjkBl<?! -jx! sLgk<kqzqVf<K?! fQI!osiz<Zl<!.!nR<s!Ou{<mil<!.!uqzibk<kqEjmb!dbIf<k!keqh<!ohVl<!nf<k^<k<kqz<! fQ I! fl<Ljmb! uzqbig! -Vg<gxQ I! we<x! dk<kqvU!uf<Okbz<ziK!fie<!osiz<zuqz<jz}}/!!! a\<vk<!ogtKz<!n0tl<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!-u<uiX!uig<GXkq!osb<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</!osie<ekx<!ogih<h!osbzqZl<!osb<K! gim<cBt<tiIgt</! osb<K! ogi{<Om! -Vg<gqe<xiIgt</! Ole<jl!lqg<g! nuIgtK! -f<ks<! sk<kqbuig<Ggt<! ÄHB,tik<KI! vh<hieqb<bi}!Ohie<x!F~x<gtqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xe}}/!

!! keqh<! ohVl<! kGkq! hjmk<k! nf<k! n{<{z<! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjt! uqbf<K! Hgp<f<K! hivim<ch<!Hgp<lijzbig?!!! ÄÄn{<m!OgicgTOliI!hf<okeg<!jgg<Gt<!! ! nmg<gq!uqjtbimuz<zQ I"!! ngqzOli!OvpqjeBl<!NMr<gxr<GOhiz<!! ! Nm<c!uqjtbim!uz<zQ I"!! l{<mzk<!k{<mjv!njpk<kVgqVk<kqOb!

! ! juk<K!uqjtbim!uz<zQi"!! l{<{gLl<!uq{<{gL!l[juk<!Kjtk<kkqe<!! ! lim<c!uqjtbim!uz<zQ I"!! g{<ck<k!gMgqz<!wPgmjzh<!Hgm<cg<!! ! gzg<gq!uqjtbim!uz<zQ I"!! gVkiqb!sqk<okz<zil<!uz<zfQ I!ncjl!we<!



!

!



51

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ! g{<Le<!uVsqk<kqz<jzObi"!! f{<mtf<kqM!fipqbiuOei!OkuiQ I!! ! fz<zcg<gitigqBl<"!! fx<G{r<Gc!ogi{<m!hiK]iuie!GV!! ! fike<!Laqb<bqk<kQ Oe"}}!we<Xl<?!! ÄÄosiz<zie<!Lpg<glqm<OmizlqM!OukLR<!! ! osie<eKmeqe<e!lqe<eR<!! SVkq!Lkzigl!Hvi{gjz!Obikqb!! ! Sozigr<gote<!osiz<ZOge<"!! hz<zibqvl<!Ogicb{<m!hgqv{<mLe<!! ! hikhr<gblz<zOui"!! hiqH,v{ief<kOl!BeK!Lcobeh<!! ! hgIuKl<!ohib<biGOli"!! uz<zioeEl<!ohbI!deg<Gt!kz<ziK!! ! lx<xuI!klg<GLtOki"!! uieuI!kqef<kqel<!uf<Ke<hkl<!h{qBl<!

! ! lgqjl!osiz!uiBL{<Omi"!! fz<OziI!klg<gziokz<ziI!klg<Glje!! ! fzqZkx<!ogtqkiGOli"!! fx<G{r<Gc!ogi{<m!hiK]iuie!GV!! ! fike<!Laqb<bqk<kQ Oe"}}!!! we<Xl<?! olb<R<Rie! Oljk?! nz<! NiqHz<gilqz<?! G{r<Gc!l^<kie<!wEl<!a\<vk<?!^|z<kie<!nh<Kz<!gikqV!NzQl<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!

! NgOu?!wuovuI!kqiqgv{!Sk<kqBme<?!nhib!Oujtbqz<?!nhbf<!Okc! ÄÄwf<k! OujtBl<! biLaqb<bqk<kQ oee<X! -bl<hqOeiIg<Ggf<K!nf<fk<k!Oujt!uf<Kkuq!osb<Ouoee<xVt<!osb<kQ I"!-f<k!fz<Oujt!-Koujt! OujtbqK! slb<! uf<okeg<! gVt<! HiquQI!Laqb<bqk<kQ ei{<mjgOb"}}! we<X! njpk<Kg<! %h<hqm<M! dkuq!OkMgqe<xeOvi! ne<euIgt<! jgogiMk<Kg<! gih<hix<xh<hMuiIgt<!we<hkqz<!gqR<sqx<Xl<!sf<Okglqz<jz/!!! wz<zig<! Gk<HliIgTg<Gl<! sg<gvuIk<kqbie! a\<vk<! Gk<Hz<!ng<k<kiH?! ogtKz<! n0tl<?! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!

ne<a|! nuIgt<! fqjzhx<xq! -KgiXl<! Ohsq! uf<Okil</! nuIgtK!Wuzitz<gtie?!oki{<mIgtie?!Wjeb!Gk<HliIgTl<!%m!kr<gtK!ne<hIgTg<G!dkuqHiqBl<!Nx<xz<!ohx<xqVg<gqxiIgt</!!! âQa|z<! Hgiiqg<G! ]va<! wPkqbqVg<Gl<! -lil<! ]aiHk<kQ e<!G^<k<kzieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! d^<k<kiK!



!

!



52

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

Gvfikvigqb?!a\<vk<!-lil<?!j]G!na<lK!nHz<!nh<hi^qz<!LI^q?!JI'g<gq?!lg<iqhQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!%Xgqe<xiIgt<;.!!! ÄÄwe<Ejmb! LiQ Kg<Gg<! g]<m! f]mr<gt<! Wx<hm<M! nue<!km<mpqf<K! kqjgk<kqVg<Gl<! slbl<! fie<! nujeh<! hiKgik<K!NXkztqh<Ohe</}}!!! ÄÄ-e<El<! -bzijl?! g]<ml<?! hbr<gvl<! d{<mie! OhiK!we<Ejmb! LiQK! Äbi\I'g<"}! we<X! we<! ohbjvs<! osiz<zq!njph<hiOeibieiz<!fie<!uqjvf<K!uf<K!hiKgih<Ohe<}}/!! !! -u<uqhvl<?!a\<vk<!]ia<!nh<Kz<!n^Q <!Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuQ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! ÄH^<k<kiEz<.Lak<kqkQeqz<}!Gxh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt<! we?! Äne<uiVz<! -f<kqhia<.hQ .az<zq! fqkibq! .! bi!x^|zz<zia<}! we<x! F~zqe<! 3:.uK! hg<gk<kqz<?!a\<vk<! Lh<kq!]ia<!na<lKiqti!gie<!gikqiQ !hOvzQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!

!! lgk<Kulqg<g! fikig<gtie! nUzqbig<gt<! kUaQ kqe<!giuzIgtie! Lk<kgQe<gt</! uv-b<bQ e<gt<! wz<zil<! Äu Q ziju}!wu<u{<{l<!hx<xqh<!hqck<Kt<tiIgt<!we<hjkh<!hqe<!uVl<!uq]bk<jkh<!hck<K!d{Is<sq!ohXOuilig"!!

!!! wl<ohVlieiI?! ]hQdz! Lk<eqhQe<?! xa<lk<Ke<! zqz! NzlQe<?!fhqgt<! kqzgl<?! o^b<bqKei!Lal<lK?! x^|Zz<ziaq!^zzz<zia|!njzaq!u^zzl<!nuIgjt!a\vk<!ogtKz!n0tl<!vzqbzzia|!kNzi!ne<a|!njpk<Kg!%h<hqm<M!!! ÄÄN{<muEjmb! Okipvie!nVjl!ahQHz<zi!nuIgOt"!weK!jgjbh<! hqck<Kg! gih<hix<xq! nVt<uvig?! weK!-bzik<! kejlg<Gk<!krgjtbe<xq! giIliel<! wegG! biVl<! -z<jzOb"}}! we<X! %xq!

ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtql<! u^Qzi!OkceiIgt</!

!



!

!



53

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! ÄÄsqV]<cgtqotz<zil<! lgih<! ohVl<! sqOv]<mlieuIgOt"!Ohvihk<K?! -mIgt<! uf<Kx<xOhiK! nhbf<! Okc! yKr<Gukx<G!kr<gjtbe<xq! weg<G! OuX! biVl<! -z<jzOb"}}! we<X! N]qg<Og!x^|z<?!-lil<!Lal<lK!H,îq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!Äg^Q kk<Kz<!HI<kiuqz<}!dkuq!OkcBt<tiIgt</!!

!!! ÄÄwe<je! -vm<sqk<Kg<! gih<hix<xg<%cb! fibgOl"! we<Ejmb!fiuqZ{mie! Lcs<sqe<! uVk<kr<gjt! we<je! uqm<Ml<!nuqp<k<KuqMr<gt<"!!! hXzie!nlz<gtqz<! we<Ejmb! gPk<kqz<! Wxqg<! ogi{<cVg<Gl<!gme<gjt!we<!gPk<jk!uqm<Ml<!fQ g<Gr<gt<"!!! OlZl<!Ke<hl<!Kbvr<gt<!we<je!uf<K!OliKl<!OhiK!nux<jxk<!

km<c!uqzg<g!kir<gt<!ohiXh<Ohx<Xg<!ogit<Tr<gt<"!!! weg<gig!le<xicg<!gjv!OsIg<Gl<!gVj{!ut<tOz"!fie<!hx<xqh<!hqcg<Gl<! NkvUh<! ohiVOt"! kr<gjtk<! kiqsqh<hKkie<! we<Ejmb!fim<mLl<?! Okm<mLl</! -K! lm<Mli@! -Xkqk<! kQ Ih<H! fite<X?! la<]I!jlkiek<kqz<!kr<gtqml<!fie<!Ogm<g!Ou{<cb!ai\ik<Kg<gt<!wk<kje!wk<kjeObi! d{<M"}}! we<hkig! likqa|I! v^|z<?! j]G!^kg<gk<Kz<ziaqz<! gikqiqb<bqz<! giaqiqb<bq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgtqml<! -vm<sqh<H! u Qzi! Okcb! sie<X! Äuqk<iqb<bi! g Q kiuqz<}!

gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!

!



!

!



54

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!!! ÄsqV]<cgtqotz<zil<!sqOv]<mlieuIgOt"!

! NkvU!juh<hkx<G!Olzil<hvlieuIgOt"!! nz<zia<kNzi!kr<gt<!lQ K!gqVjh!osb<kVt<uieig"!! Olzil<hvlie!ogijmbtqg<Gl<!ogijm!ut<tOz"!! g]<mr<gjt!wz<zil<!uqzg<gq!juk<K!dkuq!osb<ukx<G!! ! ! ! ! ! dk<kllieuIgOt"!!! ljp! ohipqBl<! giILgqzqe<! ogijmjbuqm! kr<gtK! dbI!ogijmkie<! Olzil<hvligq! lqjgk<Kuqm<mK}}! we<X! g{{qb! lqgg!a\<vk<!]ia<!uzqb<Bz<zia<!Lak<kqKkqa<zuQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! wl<ohVlieiI! Lal<lK! L <k<khi! ^z<zz<zia|!

njzaq!u^zzl<!nuIgtqml!nhbl<!OkcBt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄnz<zia<Ujmb! kqVk<! K~kvigqgb! x^|zuIgOt"! kr<gtqe<!kqVLgk<jk! uqm<Ml<! kqjvjbs<! sx<X! fQ g<gq! kr<gtqe<! kiqsek<jk!weg<gVTr<gt<"!!! kr<gTjmb! kqVLgk<kqe<! O\ikq! ogi{<M! we<Ejmb!Ofk<kqvr<gTg<Gh<!hqvgisk<jkbtqBr<gt<"!Oux<Xjlbqe<!-Vjt!uqm<Ml<!we<jeg<!gihix<Xr<gt<"!!

! fie<! fz<zuOei! ogm<muOei! wh<hcbqVh<hqEl<?!kr<gTjmbueigq!uqm<OmOe"!nKOu!OhiKl<"!-h<OhiK!Ou{<Mlieiz<!NkiqBr<gt<! nz<zK! ouVm<Mr<gt<"! )fie<! kr<gjt! uqm<M! njsb!lim<Ome<*!!! gh<hOzim<c! fMg<gmzqz<! upqkuxqk<! kqjgk<kix<! Ohiz! fie<!uip<g<jgh<! Hbzqz<! fqjz! kuxq! kk<ktqg<gqOxe</! we<jeg<!gjvOsVr<gt<"!!! fie<! kGkqbx<xueibqVh<hqEl<! kr<gTjmb! gqVjhbqe<! Ohiqz<!weg<G!NkvU!d{<M/!we<je!lkQ eiUg<G!njpk<Kg<!ogit<Tr<gt<"!!! -bzijlBt<t! -f<k! -l<kik<! we<hujek<! kr<gTjmb! gikz<!ujzbqz<! ngh<hms<! osb<Br<gt<"! -k<kV{l<! =VzgqZl<! -uje!uqMkjz!ohx<X!=Omx<xl<!njmbs<!osb<Br<gt<}}"!!



!

!



55

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! Olx<osie<e! uqklig?! OkUhf<kqgt<! njeuVjmbUl<! hQ Vl<?!Liq]qKligqb! NiqH! hqz<zia<! ai\q! aihq <?! ]ia<! Lal<lK!-l<kiKz<zia<!îaqH?!Lai\qI!lg<gQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!LjxbqM!osb<Kt<tiIgt</!!! Gk<H^<! ^lie<?! jkg<gi! îaqH?! uzqBz<ziaq! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! kr<gtK! Äna<lKz<ziaz<! uzQ}! we<x!jhk<kqz<! ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgjt!Äbijgve<ehQ.bijgve<e.hQ }!)fhqliIgtqozz<zil<!sqOv]<mlie!fe<ehqOb*!we<X! njpk<K?! njpk<K! -u<Uzg! sl<hf<klie?! lX! dzg!sl<hf<klie! nk<kje! Ogiiqg<jggjtBl<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtqmOl! OfVg<G! OfI! Ou{<Mkz<! osb<K!-jxR<SgqxiIgt</!!! uzqgt<! kqzgl<! ogtKz<! n0tl<?! o^b<bqKei! Laqb<bqk<kQe<!nh<Kz<gikqI! \Q zieq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjt?!]va|h<Hzq?! j]G! ^kg<gk<Kz<zia<! nh<hi! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!

ne<a|!nuIgt<!OfVg<G!OfI!njpk<K?!! )bi! j^bqkQ !êkQ! ogtkQ!ubi!lkkQ*! weK!kjzuvuIgOt"!WeK!NkivOl"! WeK! -vm<sgOv"! weK! dkuqbitOv"! HjguIgtqe<!kQr<G! WKl<! uf<k[gilz<! we<jeg<! gih<hix<xq?! hiuk<kqz<! fie<! sqg<gq!Olisl<! Ohib<uqmilz<! we<jeg<! jgh<hqck<Kh<! hiKgik<K! dkuq!HiquQIgtig"! nz<zia<Ujmb! gzQ hiouEl<! hqvkqfqkqbig! wr<gt<! hiz<!uf<Kkqk<k! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! N{<mjgbuIgOt"}}! we<X! Lei\ik<K!osb<Kt<tiIgt</!!! Rieg<gtR<sqbl<?! G{r<Gc! l <k<kie<! îaqH! yzqBz<zia<!

vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! -vm<sqh<Hk<! OkcbqVh<hjkh<!hiVr<gt<"!!! ÄÄle<eqb!kuk<kqeIg<!gVt<!kf<k!GVUl<!fQ !! ! liki!hqkiUl<!fQ Ob"!! lm<mX!hug<gmz<okijzg<G!oliV!guqpi!! ! lvg<gzLl<!fQ bz<zOui"!! ne<eqblkie!hqvhR<slil<!ohVofVh<!! ! hmg<Glm!ohVl<!hizlib<!! ne<Hme<!wjeh<!ohx<x!nh<hOe!nVt<!kf<k!

! ! N{<muEl<!fQ bz<zOui"!! we<je!djebe<xq!-eq!bit<uovu!jvbOe!! ! wf<jkOb!wl<hqviOe"!! -ghv!lqv{<cZR<!Sg!Kg<g!lx<Xbie<!! ! =Omx!nVt<!HiqjuOb"!! fe<eqjzblig!oue<!Le<eqjzbqz<!uf<K!wf<! !



!

!



56

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ! fiTl<!vm<sqk<!kVt<juOb"!! fx<G{r<Gc!ogi{<m!hiK]iuie!GV!! ! fike<!Laqb<bk<kQ Oe"}}!! we<X!nuIgt<!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! Gk<Hz<!ngk<kiH?!hIKz<!na<hiH?!j^bqK!nh<Kz<!gikqI?!lQvie<!îaqH?! ]ia|z<! alQK?! fi%I! N{<mjg! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjt!njpk<K?!!! )bi!îaqhe<!eia|iq!Ge<zQ !fi^qiq*!!! ÄÄfi%I! uip<! w\liOe"! WeK! Ogt<uqh<! HzEl<?! hiIjug<Gh<!HzEl<! dXh<Hg<gTl<! ^zilk<kig! -Vg<g! weg<G! fz<zVt<!osb<uQIgtig"! -e<El<! fie<! Gjxf<k! nx<hiBt<! ubKjmbueie!-z<zilz<! fQck<k! ui{it<! djmbueibqVg<g! fQr<gt<! fz<Zkuq!osb<kVt<uQ Igtig"!wz<ziuqk!fe<jlgTl<!yVr<Og!Osgvlib<!ohikqf<K!njlf<k!nh<Kz<!gikqV!ouizq!nuIgOt"!we<X!gibz<hkqbqz<!hqxf<K!

gQ pg<gjvbqz<! nmr<gq! O\ikq! ogi{<czr<Gl<?! gz<uqg<! gmz<?! j]G!^kg<gk<Kz<zia<!nh<hi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!dkuq!OkcBt<tiIgt</!!! fi%I!hiK]i!fibgl<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjt!Ofig<gq?! G{r<Gc! l <k<kie<! îaqH! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<?!!! kqg<Gk<!kqgf<kLr<!ogi{<micOb!uf<K!! ! kQe<!%xq!fqx<hI!Ogic"!

! sqr<giseikqhIgt<!fkOvf<kqOb!uf<K!! ! o\b!o\bi!oue<hI!Ogic"!! ag<geVt<!ohx<x!ohiqObiigotizqliIgt<!! ! n{q!n{qbig!fqx<hI!Ogic"!! nR<Rie!OuvXk<kqm<m!olR<Rieqgt<!! ! nj{f<kVG!fqx<hI!Ogic"!! lg<g!fgviT!Lal<lKI!v^|z<!kf<k!! ! le<eOv!we<hI!Ogic"!! useqk<K!fqx<gOu!ogiZuQ x<xqVg<GLl<!! ! lgqjlosiz!uiBL{<Omi!

! kg<g!ohiqObieVt<!kr<gqOb!fqx<gqe<x!! ! kuvi\!osl<OlVOu"!! kjb!juk<okjebit<!sx<G{r<!Gcogi{<m!! ! ]ia|z<!alQkvsOv"}}!! we<X!Ou{<Mkz<!osb<kqVg<gqxiIgt</!! !



!

!



57

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! a\<vk<!nHz<!aê<!nzq!]iKzQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjt! njpk<K! Ofig<gq?! gibz<hm<m{l<! o]b<G! F~a<! îaqH!nz<zili! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! )bi! ^b<bqkQ !^b<bqk^< ikik<kq!biêkQ ///*!we<X!%xqbqVg<Gl<!Lei\ik<kqz<!!! ÄÄwr<gt<! kjzuvuIgOt"! kjzuIgTg<ogz<zil<!kjzuvieuIgOt"! weK! Nkivh<! ohiVOt"! weg<Gl<! weK!sOgikvVg<Gl<! fim<m! Okm<mr<gjt! fqjxOux<xqk<! kf<kqm! fQ r<gt<!dkuqbig!-Vr<gt</!!! we<je! jguqm<MuqmikQ Igt<"! weK! fim<m! Okm<ml<! fqjxOuX!lm<Ml<?!weK!dkuqbitOv?!fQr<gt<!we<je!jgh<hqck<K!dkuOu{<Ml<!nHz<!aê<!)]iKzQ*!nuIgOt"}}!we<hkigg<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! ^|z<k<kiEz<! l]ibqG?! HIaiEz<! agibqG?! nz<Gk<H!fq\iLk<kQ e<!nUzqbi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjt!Ofig<gq?!ÄÄwz<jzbqz<zih<! hiug<gmzqz<! Np<f<K! fqIg<gkqbig! fqx<Gl<! -f<k!

Wjpjbk<!kir<gt<!jgogiMk<K!dkuqg<!gih<hix<Xr<gt<"!kr<gTjmb!sQ Ihikr<gtqz<! we<Ebqjvk<! kk<kR<! osb<b! we<! kjzjbk<! K~g<gq!uqMr<gt<"}}!we<hkig!oltziei!oltzuq!o^b<bqK!Lal<lK!Lhivg<!nzuqb<bqz<! gqIlieQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! dkuq!OkcBt<tiIgt</!!! na<Zjhk<Kgtigqb!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!djmb! GMl<hk<kuIgt<! lQK! NkvU! juk<kuIgtig?! j]G! ^0kQ !]Q vi Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! -xjui"! hik<kqli!fibgq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!djmb!hqs<str<gtqe<!ohiVm<miz<!

weK!Lcju!!! =lie<!^zilk<Kme<!Ng<gq!juh<hibig"!!! FQ! weK! hqvik<kjejb!Wx<xiZl<! siq?! fqvigiqk<kiZl<! siq?! fie<!fibgl<! x^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK!GMl<hk<kiIgt<! djmb! Lf<ki{qjbh<! hx<xqh<! hqck<kueig!-Vg<gqe<Oxe<}}!we<hkig!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! SVkq?! Bg<k<k! Nkivr<gjt! YvtU! OlOz! gi{<hqk<Kt<Otil</!

-u<uiX!liohVl<!lgik<lig<gTl<?!lgie<gTl<?!]vjah<Oh{q!fmf<k!fikig<gTl<?! kUaQ jkh<! hx<xqh<! hqck<k! Lua<aqkQ e<gTl<?! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgjtBl<?! ogtKz<! n0tl<!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtBl<?! fi%I! ]ia|z<alQ K!N{<mjg! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtBl<?! lx<Xl<!Gk<HliIgjtBl<?! ouizqliIgjtBl<! njpk<K?! %h<hqm<M!



!

!



58

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

ne<euIgtqml<! -vm<sqh<H.dkuq! u Q zi! Okc!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt<! we<hK!Gxqh<hqmk<kg<gK/!Olx<!osie<e!lgiEhiuIgjt!wz<zil<!uqm?!u^Q zi!OkmzigiK! dkuq?! -vm<sqh<Hg<! Ogm<gzigiK! .! bix^|zz<zia<?!biLaqb<bk<kQ e<?!bi! ogtK! we<oxz<zil<! osiz<zg<%miK!we<X!%xq!njzBl<! %m<mk<kqeI! wf<k! ujgbqz<! uqOs]lieuIgt<! we<hKkie<!uqtr<guqz<jz/!!! weOu?! fqs<sblig! ne<hqbig<gt<?! nUzqbig<gt! hiz<! -vm<sqh<H?!dkuq?!dhgivl<! u Qzi!wg<gizLl<! Okmzil<! we<hOk!^|e<ek<! uz<!\link<! dzlig<gtqe<! WOgihqk<k! kQ IlieliGl</! -jk! lXh<hue<!L0k<k^qzi?! ua<aihq! gikqbieQ ! %m<mr<gjts<! OsIf<kue<! we<hkqz<!Jblqz<jz/!OlZl<!-ue<!sk<kqbk<kqx<G!liXhimig!fmf<kuEliuie</!!!!

! ! ! ! gxilik<K!d{<mi@!

!! nUzqbig<gt<! abik<kqZl<?! lUk<kqx<gh<hiZl<! gi{<hqk<KuVl<!gxilik<okEl<!nx<Hkr<gjt!fil<!g{<{ivg<!g{<Ml<?!gikivg<!Ogm<Ml<!uVgqe<x! -g<gizk<kqz<! yV! sqzI! nux<jx! -e<giI! )fqvigiqh<H*!osb<gqe<xeI/!!! fie<G! lKaHgtqz<! bikiuokie<jxg<! gjmhqck<K! yPg!Ou{<cbK! liIg<gg<! gmjlbiGl</!L <zql<gt<! wz<ziVOl! lKajhh<!hqe<hx<xq!fmh<hkigOu!yh<Hg<!ogit<gqe<xeI/!!! wh<ohiPK! lKajh! Wx<xqVg<gqxiIgOti! nh<ohiPK! nf<k!lKaHg<Giqb! ngQ kig<! )ogit<jg*! gjtBl<! nr<gQ giqk<kig! Ou{<Ml</!ne<hqbig<gTjmb!L0\q ik<Kgt<?!nUzqbig<gTjmb!gvilik<Kgt<!d{<jl! we<hKl<! ngQ kig<gTt<! ye<X/! L0\qîk<jkObi?!gxilik<jkObi! yh<Hg<ogit<tuqz<jzbieiz<! nuEg<G! lKaH!-z<jz/! lKaH! -z<jzbieiz<! nue<! ^|e<ek;.uz<.\link<jks<!OsIf<kuez<ze</! NgOukie<! -k<kjgbju! L0k<k^qzih<! Ohie<x!%m<mk<jks<! OsIf<kuoke<X! fie<G! lKaHjmb! dzlig<gt<!wz<OziVl<!gVk<okiVlqk<Kg<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!

!!! ÄÄngQ kiuqz<! Olislie! ogit<jg! djmbuOebz<zilz<! OuX!wuVl<! )nUzqbig<gt<*! lv{k<kqx<gh<hiz<! gvilik<K! fqgp<k<Kujkh<!



!

!



59

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

hx<xq! fqvigiqh<Hs<! osb<blim<miIgt<}}! we<hkig! ]va|z<! Hgiiqbqz<!]ihqT!-HE!a\I!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! nUzqbig<gTg<G! gvilk<K!d{<ome<X!osiz<! .!njk!-z<jz!we<X!-e<giI! osb<huEjmb!osiz<jzk<! kt<tquqM}}! we<X! Ä\u<avi}!wEl<!F~zqz<!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! ÄÄleqkIgTjmb! fim<m! Okm<mr<gjt! fqjxOux<xqg<!ogiMh<hkx<gig! nz<zia<! kNzi! uzqliIgTjmb! gHiqz<! yV!lzg<jgs<! sim<Muie</! lx<oxiVuqklig?! uzqliIgjtg<! gHjv! uqm<Ml<!outqh<hMk<kq! leqkIgtK! fim<m?! Okm<mr<gjt! fqjxOux<xqg<!ogiMg<gUl<! osb<uie<}}! we<hkig! nh<Kz<! ua<ai! H]<]0xieQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! buig<gQk<Kz<! \uiaqiqz<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! fhqliIgtqz<! nOfgiqe<! L0\qîk<Kgjth<! hx<xq! GINe<!]iQhqZl<?!akQK!]iQ hqZl<! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!

nuIgtK! L0\qîk<Kgt<! hx<xqBl<?! âihig<gt<! nOfgl<!OhIgTjmb!gvilk<Kgt<!hx<xqBl<!akQ K]iQ hqZl<!uf<Kt<te/!!! nUzqbig<gTjmb! gvilk<Kgjth<! hx<xq! siqk<kqvr<gtqz<!w{<{qg<jgbqzmr<giu{<{l<! dt<te/! njubjek<jkBl<! -r<G!wMk<okPKuoke<xiz<! sik<kqblqz<jz/! weqEl<?! nux<xqzqVf<K! yV!sqzux<jx!Gxqh<hqMgqOxil</!!! ÄÄabik<kqZl<?! uhik<kqx<Gh<hiZl<! nUzqbig<gt<! gxilik<Ks<!osb<b! sg<kq! ohx<xqVg<gqe<xiIgti@! lUk<kigqh<! Ohiejugjt!

nuIgtiz<! abik<kig<g! LcBli@}}! we<X! -lil<! j]G! Lal<lK!gzQ zQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtqml<! uqeuh<! hm<mkx<G?!ÄÄnuIgt<! gxilik<Ks<! osb<b! sg<kq! ohx<xqVg<gqxiIgt</! lUk<kigqh<!Ohiejugjt! abik<kig<gUl<! nuIgtiz<! LcBl<}}! we<X! nuIgt<!hkqz<!%xqbqVg<gqxiIgt</!-u<uqhvl<! ÄhkiuigzQ zQ }?! 2.uK! higl<! 8:.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! dujlg<Gs<!sqz!fqgp<s<sqgjt!wMk<Kg<!gim<Mgqe<Oxil</!!! nlQ Vz<!&lqeQ e<!a\<vk<!dlIhi'g<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!

nuIgTjmb!gqzihk<kqe<!gizk<kqz<?!âihqgtqz<!yVuvigqb!îiqbi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK!kjzjlbqe<! gQ p<! faiuf<K!we<El<!DVg<G!yV! hm<mitl<!nEh<hh<hm<mK/!Gh<hiIgjt!wkqIk<Kg<!gMjlbigh<! OhiI! osb<K! ogi{<Om! L <zql<gt<! Le<Oexqg<!ogi{<cVf<kiIgt</! -f<ks<! sf<kIh<hk<kqz<! ljzbqe<! g{uib<! upqOb!



!

!



60

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

hqe<hg<gligh<! hKr<gqs<! ose<X! - <zilqbh<! hjmjbs<! $p<f<K! kqCI!kig<Gkz<!osb<b!Gh<hiIgt<!-vgsqb!kqm<mlqm<Mg<!ogi{<cVf<keI/!!! ne<X! out<tqg<gqpjl?! nf<Ofvk<kqz<! gzQhi! dlIhi'g<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!lkQ eiuqz<!l^<\qKe<ehuqb<bqe<!lql<hI!lQK!fqe<X!Gk<hi!Ykqg<ogi{<cVf<kiIgt</!nu<ulbl<!nr<gqVf<K!ogi{<Om?! ouGokijz! K~vk<kqZt<t! faiuf<K! Bk<kgtk<jk! g]<H!)ngg<g{<*!ogi{<M!Ofig<gqeiIgt</!!! Wkqiqgtqe<! skqk<kqm<mk<jk! g]<H! &zl<! d{If<k! nuIgt<?!ÄÄîiqbiOu"!ljzg<g{uijbh<!hiKgih<hQ I}}!)îiqbi!nz<.\hz<*!we<X!sh<kr<ogiMk<kiIgt</!!! gzQhiuqe<! -f<k! ws<siqg<jg! Bk<k! gtk<kqz<! -Vf<k! îiqbi!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! giKg<G! wm<cx<X/! dmOe!nuIgt<!ljzg<g{uibqz<!Le<Oexq!hiKgih<Hs<!osb<K!ogi{<miIgt</!wkqiqgtqe<! -vgsqb! skqk<kqm<ml<! Lxqbcg<gh<hm<mK/! L <zql<gt<!

oux<xqohx<xeI/! -u<ux<Hk! sl<hul<! nuIgTjmb! leigqH! )siqk<kqvs<!sqxh<H!F~z<*gtqz<!ujvbh<hm<cVg<gqe<xK/!!! ÄÄatvk<! x^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgtK! sLgk<kqx<G?! n QKh<Ea|jtI! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgTl<?! dh<hiKh<Eh]I! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTl<! -Vt<! $p<fk! YI! -vuqz<! ose<xqVf<kiIgt</! HqxG!nu<uqVuVl<! ye<xig! kqVl<hq! uVl<OhiK!nuIgTg<G!Le<hkig! -V!O\ikqh<hqvgisr<gt<!Ohib<g<ogi{<cVf<ke/!nuIgt<!hqiqf<K!keqk<keqOb!hqiqf<K! nuvuVme<! Ohib<g<! ogi{<cVf<ke}}! we<hkig! ne <!

vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! iquibk<Ks<! osb<kqVg<gqxiIgt</! -f<k!akQ K!âQ a|z<!Hgiiqbqz<!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! fibgl<! x^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgTg<G!uqVf<ktqg<g!\ihqI!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!keK! uQ m<cz<! YI! Nm<Mg<Gm<cjt! nXk<K! sjlbZg<G! Wx<hiM!osb<kiIgt</! Nm<Mg<Gm<cjbk<! kf<jk! nXh<hjkh<! hiIk<Kg<!ogi{<cVf<k! nuIgtK! &k<kHkz<ue<! ke<Ejmb! kl<hqjbh<! hqck<K!nu<uiOx! nXk<K! uqm<mie</! -jkg<g{<m! nuEjmb! kib<! uqvm<ch<!hqcg<g! YmOu! &k<k! lgeigqb! nue<! licbqOzxq! giz<! kuxq! gQ Op!

uqPf<K!-xf<kie</!!! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!uqVf<K{<{!uf<k!sf<kIh<hk<kqz<!&k< <k!lgEjmbUl<?!-jtb!lgEjmbUl<!lv{!Oskqjbbxqf<K!KNs<!osb<kiIgt</!-jxueVtiz<!nu<uqVuVl<!dbqI!ohx<oxPf<kiIgt</!



!

!



61

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! -u<uvziX! ]uiaKe<! EHu<uk<kqz<! uVukig! ne<uiOv.Nh<k<kiOh.^kgik<?! 3.uK! higl<?! 318.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! %xh<hMgqe<xK/!OlZl<!-a<bidz<GZ~h<!.!hQ !.!lUzqkqz<!la<H,h<!:5.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!osiz<zh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! yV! fijtb! kqek<kqz<! atvk<! ogtKz<! n0tl<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!hGkiK!fgvk<Kg<!gjmk<okV!upqOb!ose<X!ogi{<cVf<k!OhiK?!yV!gqxq^<kuVl<?!yV!L^<zqLl<!kIg<gR<!osb<K!ogi{<cVh<hjkg<!g{<M?!nu<uqml<!fqe<X!gueqk<kiIgt</!!! gqxq <kuI?! fhq! =î! njzaq < zil<! nuIgtK!L0\qîk<Kg<gt<! hzux<jxg<%xq! nuIgOt! OlzieuIgt<! we<X!%xqeiI/! L^<zql<?! fhq! Lal<lK! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgtK! L0\qîg<gt<! hzux<jxg<! %xq! nuIgOt! lqgUl<!OlzieuIgt<! we<X!%xqeiI/! Gjmsqbig?!nf<kg<! gqxq <kuI?! wr<gt<!=î?! liqk<kuIgjt! dbqIh<hqk<kqVg<gqxiIgt<?! dr<gt<! fhq! nu<uqkl<!

osb<kqVg<gqe<xiIgti@! we<X! gmiuqeiI/! -kx<Gh<! hkqz<! osiz<zk<!okiqbilz<! nf<k! L <zql<! sqxqK! kbr<gqeiI/! dmOe! kil<! o\bqk<K!uqm<mkig!nf<kg<!gqxq^<kuI!Nvuivl<!osb<bzieiI/!!! -u<uqVuVjmb! uquikr<gjtg<! gueqk<Kg<! ogi{<cVf<k!ogtKz<! n0tl<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Le<! uf<K!nf<kg<! gqxq <kujv! Ofig<gq?! ÄfQ I! %xqb! nk<kje! uq]bLl<!d{<jlkie</!nux<jx!fir<gTl<!yh<Hg<ogit<tOu!osb<gqe<Oxil</!fie<!yV! L <zql<?! Lal<lK! fhq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgtK! dl<lk<Kg<gtqz<! fiEoliVue<?! -xf<K! Ohie! jlbqk<K!

wjkbiuK! fQ! gi{<hq/! Njk! fie<! dbqI! ohxs<osb<gqOxe<!we<Xjvk<kiIgt</!!! nf<kg<! gqxq <kuI! klK! Le<OeiIgjt! nmg<gl<!osb<bh<hm<cVg<Gl<! yV!jlbqk<Kg<! ogiz<jz?! gz<zjxg<G!njpk<Kg<!ose<X/! hz<zi{<MgTg<G! Le<H! Hjkg<gh<hm<m! yV! Hvikeh<!Hjkg<Gpqjb! gi{<hqk<K?! Ä-kqz<! nmg<gl<! osb<bh<hm<cVh<huI! yV!himgI/! -uI! dbqI! ohx<oxPf<K! we<Eme<! OhSuivigqz<! fie<!dr<gtK! liIg<gk<jkk<! kPUgqe<Oxe</! -z<ziuqcz<! fQr<gt<! weK!liIg<gk<jkk<!kPu!Ou{<Ml</!sl<lkl<kiei@!we<hkib<s<!shkl<!%xqeiI/!

!! ÄÄnh<hcOb?! sl<lkl<}}! we<hkig! a\<vk<! ogtKz<! n0tl<!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! dme<hm<M?! Ädr<gt<! fhq!liqk<Okijv!wu<uiX!dbqIh<hqk<kiIgt<@!we<X!uqeuqeiIgt</!!



!

!



62

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ÄÄN{<muEjmb!dk<kqvU!ogi{<M!wPf<kqV!we<hiIgt</!DmOe!wPf<kqVg<Gl<}!we<X!nuI!uqjmbtqk<kiI/!!! Änh<hcbi"!-h<OhiK!fie<!weK!dk<kqvU!ogi{<M!wPf<kqVg<gs<!osb<gqOxe<"!hiI}!we<X!%xq?!ÄÄweK!dk<kqvU!ogi{<M!wPf<kqV}}!)Gl<hq!-KeQ *!we<X!olipqf<kiIgt</!!! nf<k! dmOe?! lcf<K! l{<O{iM! l{<{igqg<! gqmf<k! nf<kh<!himgI?!uik<kqbk<jk!-jsk<kuvib<h<!hicg<!ogi{<Om!sug<GpqbqzqVf<K!outqOb! Hxh<hm<miI/! nf<ks<! sr<gQ k! uqk<uie<! nf<kg<! gqV <kujv!Ofig<gq?!kqVg<gzqlijug<!%xq!-^<zik<jk!kPu!-e<El<!kilkl<!We<@!we<Xl<!uqeuqeiI/!!! nf<kg<! gqxq <kuI! Ohvis<siqbLx<xuvib<?! ng<g{Ol! gzqliju!olipqf<K!L^<zqligq!uqm<miI/!!! siqk<kqv! H,Iulie! -u<! uvzix<jx! kh<iQ\|z<gik<kqI! 27.uK!

hg<gk<kqZl<?!leigqH!ogtkqb<bi!77.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!hiIjubqmzil</!!! ÄÄuzqliIgTjmb! gxilik<! nx<Hkr<gt<! \Q uqbk<kqzqVh<hKOhiz?!nuIgtK!lv{k<kqx<gh<hiZl<! fjmohXli@}}! we<X!j]Gz<!-^<zil<?!nz<zili?! nz<hg<gQ a<?! j]GLal<lK! ]u<hiQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtqml<!uqeuh<!ohx<xK/!!! nkx<G! nuIgt<?! Älv{k<kqx<gh<hiZl<! nUzqbig<gTjmb!gxilik<K! nx<Hkr<gt<! fjmohx<Ox! uVl<?! nju! wMhm<Mh<! Ohigi/!ne<hqbig<gTjmb!L0\qîk<!nUzqbig<gTjmb!gxilik<kibqVg<Gl</!

-jk! lXk<kiz<! Gh<jvg<! ogi{<M! hbh<hm! Ou{<Ml<}}! we<X!uqjmbtqk<kiIgt</!!! -u<uqhvl<?!lq^<iqz<!Lh<k<kqbibqVf<k!nz<zili!j]G!Lal<lK!hgQ k<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK!]qhid^< qgil<}!we<x!F~Zme<!-j{k<K!outqbqmh<!ohx<xqVg<Gl<!Ä]u<hiq!.!hk<ui}!uqz<?!349.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! dujlg<G!lx<oxiV!sl<huk<jkBl<!gueqBr<gt</!!

! ÄÄyVue<!a\<vk<!o^b<bqKei!nzq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjt! fqf<kqk<K! nuK~xigh<! OhSujkOb! okipqzigg<!ogi{<cVf<kie</! nue<! YiqvU! fqk<kqjv! osb<jgbqz<?! a\<vk<! nzq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! nueK! geuqz<! Okie<xq!nuEjmb! Lgk<kqz<! Yr<gq! njxf<kiIgt</! nue<! hbf<K! kqMg<gqm<M!uqpqk<Kh<! hiIg<Gl<! OhiK?! ke<Ejmb! ^|vk<! )Ogizl<*!



!

!



63

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

lix<xh<hm<cVh<hjkg<! g{<M! jg! Oskh<hm<mie<}}! we<hkig! gqkiHI.'a<!we<x!F~zqz<!osiz<zh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! nUzqbig<gjtBl<?! gvilik<Kg<gjtBl<! fl<Hukx<gqz<zilz<!-e<giI! osb<Bl<! %m<mk<kiIgt<! ohVl<hiZl<! -HEjklqbijuBl<?!nujvs<! OsIf<kuIgjtBOl! uqOs]ligg<! gVkq?! nuIgtK!F~x<gjtOb! Olx<Ogit<gtigg<! gim<MuiIgt</! ua<aihq!sqk<kif<kr<gTg<G! &zGVuie! -HE! jklqbiuqe<! hqvkie! sQ mI!-Hejgbql<! we<huOv/!nuI!-bx<xqb!F~z<kie<! OlOz!Gxqh<hqmh<hm<m?!ÄgqkiHI!'a<}!we<hkil</!nuI!-bx<xqb!nz<ghibqV.hq^<.^|e<ek<kq!uz<!hqKnk<kq}! we<x! F~zqZl<! OlOz! osiz<zh<hm<mK! Ohie<x! gxilik<K!nx<Hkr<gt<!sqzux<jxBl<!nuI!ujvf<Kt<tiI/!!! Äl <euQ .]iQ hqe<}! Nsqiqb! Oljk?!a\<vk<! oltziei! Lal<lK!\ziZk<kQ e<! 'lq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Gxqh<hqMl<!nx<Hk! sl<huolie<jxBl<! dr<gt<! guek<kqx<G! ogi{<M! uVgqOxil</!nuIgt<!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiIgt<;.!

!! ÄgiiQ !yVuI!lk<vîuqz<!GINe<!Ykqg<!ogi{<cVg<gqxiI/! Älf<kqg<}!wEl<! kk<Ku! sik<kqvk<jkg<! gx<x! yVuI! nh<OhiK! nf<kh<! hg<gl<!osz<gqxiI/! nh<OhiK! nf<kg<giiQ ! )Gz<.nv.nb<k<Kl<.-e<!n^<halidg<Gl<///*!!! dr<gTjmb! )Gc*! k{<{Q I! H,lqg<Gt<! ose<X! ux<xq! uv{<M!Ohib<uqm<miz<! YMl<! \zk<jk! dr<gTg<Gg<! ogi{<M! uVhuI! biI@}}!we<x!)78;41*!kqVusek<jk!Ykqg<ogi{<cVh<hjk!nuI!gikqz<!Ogm<miI/!!

! dmOe! nf<kk<! kk<Ku! si <kqiq?! ÄÄWe<"! gmx<hijx! l{<oum<c!ogi{<M! H,lqjbk<! Oki{<c! k{<{Q jv! fie<! outqOb! ogi{<M!uVOuOe"}}!we<X!KMg<gig!djvk<kie</!!! ne<xqvU! nue<! geouie<X! gi[gqxie</! nkqz<! yV! ohiqbiI!Okie<xq?!ÄÄfQ!k{<{Q I!ogi{<M!uVukqVg<gm<Ml</!deK!g{<o{itqjbg<!ogi{<M! ui?! hiIh<Ohil<}}! we<X! %xq! nueK! Lgk<kqz<! Yr<gq!njxf<kiI/!!! dmOe?! nue<! kqMg<gqm<Mh<! hkxq! uqpqk<okPf<K! nlVgqxie</!

d{<jlbqOzOb!keK!g{<o{itq!ljxf<K!kie<!nf<kgeib<!uqm<mjk!d{If<K!jg!OskLx<xie</!!! -u<uqhvl<?! l <euQ! ]iQ h<?! 3.uK! higk<kqz<! osiz<zh<hm<Mt<tK/!kh< Q I?!\iaqkqbqZl<!-KOhie<xOkiI!fqgp<s<sq!Gxqh<hqmh<hm<cVg<gqxK/!!



!

!



64

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! gxilik<jkg<! ogi{<M! nUzqbiju! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<ukx<gig!g0hk<Kz<zi! OhiGli@}}! we<X! -lil<! f^hQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgtqmk<kqz<! uqeuh<hm<mK/! nh<OhiK! -lil<! nuIgt<?!ÄÄgxilik<kiz<! nK! Ohigg<! %Ml</! ^|e<ek<! uz<.\link<Kg<!ogit<jgh<hc! nu<uiX! OhiuK! NGl<}}! we<hkig! uqjmbtqk<kiIgt<!we<x! uqhvk<jk! aehq! lKah<?! gqvf<kligqb! KIVz<.Lg<k<kiiqz<!Gxqh<hqmh<hm<cVg<gqxK/!-jk!nf<F~zqe<!ai]qbi.xk<Kz<!La<k<kiI?!3.uK! higl<?! 795.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! dXkqh<hMk<kh<! ohx<xqVh<hOkiM?!ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqml<!g0hk<Kz<zia<!\qbivk<kqx<Gh<!OhiuK!nuIgTjmb!gxilik<kqZt<tkiGl</! -k<kjgb! gxilik<jk! -e<giI! osb<hue<! upq!ogm<m! L0k<k^qzi! %m<mk<jks<! OsIf<kueiuie<}}! we<hkigUl<!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! ÄÄxihq! nk<Kz<! nkuqb<bi! fibgq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<ai!nuIgjtg<! g0hKz<zia<! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<b! ose<xK}}! we<x! uqhvl<!'a|z<.hbie<?!:.uK!higl<?!223.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?!-a<bi!dZ~Lk<kQ e<?!2.uK!higl<?!353.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!

!! ÄÄa\Vz<! n <ujkuqm?! -e< ie<.gilqz<! )hiqH,v{k<Kul<!njmf<k! nUzqbi*! djmb! jg! Ole<jlbieK}}! we<Xl<?!ÄÄg0hk<Kz<zia<juh<! hiIg<gqEl<! -e< ie<gilqz<! Olzil<hvlieuI}}!we<Xl<!'a|z<!hbie<?!:.uK!higl<?!34.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%xh<hm<Mt<te/!!! a\<vk<! nH,b Q kz<! H <k<kilQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! upqbqz<! j]jgk<! OkceuIgtib</! a\<\|! dl<xiUg<Gh<!Hxh<hm<miIgt</!-Xkqbqz<!yV!Gk<jhbjmf<kiIgt</!!

! ÄÄfQI! osz<uokr<Og@! hqvbi{k<kqx<gig! juk<kqVh<hoke<e@! we<X!Gk<H! nuIgt<! uqeuqbkx<G?! nH,^bQ Kz<! H <k<kilQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! ÄÄfie<! a\<\|g<Gh<! Hxh<hm<Ms<! osz<gqOxe/!hqvbi{k<kqx<gig! 311! kqIar<gt<! juk<Kt<Ote<}}! we<X!uqjmbtqk<kiIgt</!!! nh<hcbieiz<?! kqIajl! weg<Gg<! gi{qg<jgbig! juk<K!we<jek<!kuiH!osb<Bl<?!a\<\|l<?!dl<xiUl<!dlg<G!fqjxOuxquqMl</!^hi?! lIuiuqz<! ^bQ! osb<uKl<! fqjxOuxquqMl<?! N{<mue<! lQ K!sk<kqblig?!nue<!g0hiju!uqm!weg<Gs<!sr<jgbtqk<Kt<tie</!

!! g0hi! u{g<gk<kqx<Giqb! uQ M/! weK! dt<tjlObi! nueK!nglqbk<kqe<! -z<zl</! g0hiUl<! nuEjmb! k\z<zqbik<kqe<!Okix<xf<kie</!Neiz<!-e<îe<!gilqzqe<!lQK!d{<miGl<!k\z<zqbik<K!g0hiuqz<! d{<miukqz<jz/! fQ I! we<jek<! kiqsqk<kK! -jxujeg<!



!

!



65

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

g{<mK! Ohizil</! d{<jl! g0hiju! fQ I! kuiH! osb<Kuqm<CI/! fQI!weg<Gs<!osb<k!Dpqbl<!-jxujeh<!Hgp<f<K!nuEg<G!upqhm<mkiGl</!!! d]iI"! N{<muje! uqm<Ml<! fie<! Ouxieuez<ze</!N{<muEjmb!F~I!dl<lQ K!d{<miukig"!g{<j{k<!kqxf<K!we<je!Ofig<gqh<!hiVl<"!g0hiju!we<Ejmb!uQ M!we<X!N{<mue<!yV!Ljx!kie<! osie<eie</! Äwe<! ncbiOe"}! we<X! we<je! wPhK! uqMk<kl<!%h<hqm<Mt<tie</!!! nhib^Q Ok"! dlg<Gg<! g0hi! gqjmk<kK?! N{<mueqmk<kqz<!dlg<G! F~I! hqvgisLl<?! sr<jgBl<?! lgk<KuLl<! d{<migq! uqm<mK!we<hkig!nf<k!Gk<H!%xqeiIgt</!!! -u<uqhvk<jk! oltziei!\ziZk<kQ e<!'lq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!l^<euq.]iQH?!3.uK!higk<kqz<?!hQ I.LiQK!aqgibk<kqz<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!

! a\<vk<! dlI! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! g0hiju!Ofig<gq?! ÄÄsf<Okglqe<xq?! -jxue<!deg<Gs<! sqxh<jhg<! ogiMk<Kt<tie</!Neiz<?! -jxueqmk<kqz<! L0lqe<! de<je! uqm! nkqgs<! sqxh<jh!djmbue<}}! we<X! %xqeiIgt<! we<hkig?! lqh<kia|z<! dZ~l<.]ia|!l <euQ! oltziei! 'lq?! 8.uK! higl<?! 253.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! yVfit<?!dlI!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! g0hiju!Ofig<gq?! ÄÄdeg<Gh<! ohVjlBl<! sr<jgBl<! d{<M/! nz<zia<uqmk<kqz<!L0lqe<! de<jeuqm! nkqg! sr<jg! djmbue<}}! we<X! %xqeiIgt<!

we<hkig! -HE! dlI! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M!kqIlkq!]iQ hqz<!iquibk<Ks<!osb<bh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! ÄÄgqbilk<K! fitqz<! g0hk<Kz<zia<?! we<Ejmb! gHVg<G! uf<K!Än <^ziL!njzg<g}!we<X!^zil<!osiz<Zl</!Äunjzg<!g^<^zil<}!we<X! hkqz! %xq?! jhk<Kz<zia<Ou?! weg<Gh<! hqxG! we<Ejmb!dl<lk<K! de<etuqz<! uf<K! wu<uiX! fmf<K! ogi{<miIgt<@! we<X!Ogm<Ohe</!!! nu<ulbl<! nK! osiz<Zl<;! ÄÄwe<eqmk<kqz<! uf<kuIgTg<G! fie<!

OhiKlieue</! nuIgTg<gig! fie<! le<xiMOue</! we<eqml<!uvikuIgTg<Gk<! kir<gt<! OhiKlieuIgt<! nuIgTg<gigk<! kir<gt<!le<xiMuQIgt<}}! we<hkib<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<! nVt<! osb<kqVh<hjk! \ihqI! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! iquibk<Ks<! osb<ukig?! - <haieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! ÄÄgqki! Hk<kIgQ hqz<}}! nxquqk<Kt<tkig?! nz<zili?! gi\Q ?!



!

!



66

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

djhKz<zia<! îaqH! lk<xi Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!ÄÄKa<hK^< ibqiQeqz<}}!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!

!!

)Gz<Z!Gk<hqe<!bk<K~H!hqz!jhk<kq!^h<ne<!!

u!nez<!jhk<K!kibqHe<!hq!gqbilQ *!!! ÄÄyu<ouiV! Gk<HliIgTl<! g0hiuqZt<t! -z<zk<jk! WP! Ljx!kuiH! osb<uiIgt</! ! fiOei?! nf<kg<! g0hiuqe<! -z<zligqxK!we<Ejmb! %mivk<jks<! Sx<xq! kuiH! osb<gqxK}}! we<X! o^b<bqKei!Gk<Hz<.ng<k<kiH?! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! nh<Kz<gikqI! \Q zieq! vzqbz<zia|!

kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! kr<gtK! Lhivig<gie?! ÄKh<.hq! aieQ }}!jhk<kqz<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! NgOu?! OlOz! Gxqh<hqm<h<hm<Mt<t! nk<kim<sqgtqzqVf<K! -e<îe!gilqz<! g0hk<Kz<zia<ju! uqm! Olzil<hvk<kqZt<tuI! weOu?!nk<kjgb! kGkq! uib<f<k! nUzqbig<gjt! g0hk<Kz<z<ia<! Okcs<!ose<X!kiqsqg<gqxK!we<hkqz<!uqbh<hqz<jz!nz<zui@!!! ne<hqbi?!nUzqbig<gTg<G!N{<mue<!hg<glqVf<K!wz<ziuqklie!kk<Kur<gTl<! d{<mibqVg<gqe<xe/! nuIgt<! dbqOviM! -Vf<Kuf<k!

sf<kIh<hk<kqz<! nuIgTg<gqVf<k! kqOvg! hzLl</! hiIjubqe<! %IjlBl<?!Ogt<uqbqe<! uzqjlBl<?! Ne<lsg<kqBl<! uhik<kiekx<gh<hiz<! OlZl<!nkqgh<hm<M!uZujmgqe<xe/!!! abik<kqz<?!siQvl<!we<x!%{<cz<!njmhm<Mg<!gqmf<k!Ne<lig<gt<?!uhik<kqx<Gh<!hqxG!uqMkjz!ohx<Xs<!Skf<kqvl<!njmgqe<xe/!nh<OhiK?!nuIgt<! =VzjgBl<! jgg<gMG! Ohizh<! hiIg<gqxiIgt</! ficb!-mr<gTg<ogz<zil<! ofich<! ohiPkqz<! osz<gqxiIgt</! nuIgt<!\Q uOeicVf<k! gizr<gtqz<! wr<rel<! leqkIgTjmb! fim<m!Okm<mr<gjt!fqjxOux<xq!uf<kiIgOti?!nr<reOl/!lv{k<kqx<Gh<!hqe<Hl<!osb<bg<!%cb!Nx<xjz!N{<mue<!nuIgTg<gtqk<Kt<tie</!nuIgt<!wr<gqVf<k! OhikqZl<! siq?! Nhk<K! gizk<kqz<! nuIgtK! kqVfilk<jk!uqtqk<Kg<! %h<hqm<muIgTg<G! dmOe! jgogiMk<Kg<! gih<hix<xq!-vm<sqg<Gl<!kk<Kuk<jkBl<!N{<mue<!nuIgTg<Gg<!ogiMk<Kt<tie</!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gTg<G! N{<mue<! hg<glqVf<K! Gk<vk<K! )sg<kq*!djmb! gvl<! d{<mibqVg<gqe<xK/! wkqI! Ofig<gqh<! hib<f<K! uVl<!



!

!



67

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

nl<jhBl<! %m! OuX! upqbqz<! kqVh<hq! ngx<xg<! %cb!uz<zjlBjmbuIgt<!nuIgt<}}!we<X!l^<euQ .]iQH!Lpr<Ggqe<xK/!!! ÄÄfie<! n <kgqiqbqZl<?! weK! LiQ K! dkbgqiqbqZl<! -Vf<k!OhikqZl<! siqOb/! nuje! Yfib<! gcg<g! uf<kiZl<! weg<Gk<! okiqBl</!DmOe! nkqzqVf<Kl<! nujeg<! gih<hix<XOue</! nk<kjgb! gvLl<!N{<mueiz<!weg<G!ntqg<gh<!ohx<xOkbiGl<}}!we<X!ki\|z<!nUzqbi?!j]G! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! nh<Kz<! gikqI! \Q zieq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!nVtqBt<tiIgt</!!! H,Ozig! \ek<okijgbqz<! Jf<kqoziV! higk<kqevie?! OgimiE!Ogic!L^<zql<gtqz<?!N{<gTl<?!oh{<gTl<!-u<uqVhizVl</!kk<klg<G!Nhk<K?!-mIgt<!sl<huqg<Gl<!sf<kIh<hr<gtqZl</!Nef<k!slbr<gtqZl<?!-f<k! nh<Kz<! gikqI! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! \Q zieq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgtK! kqVfilk<jkk<! kivitlig! ds<siqh<hjkh<!hqvk<kqbm<sligh<! hiIg<gzil</! gmz<! Ohiz<! uqiquie! -uIgtK! nx<Hk!giv{r<gt<?!gxilik<Kgt<?!leig<gqH!ogtkqb<bi?!ha<\k<Kz<!n^<xiI?!

kh<iQ \|z<gik<kqI!Lkzqb!gqvf<kr<gtqz<!fqjxf<Kt<te/!!! ÄÄogtKz! n0tl<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK!nx<Hk! giv{r<gt<! Wvitl<?! Wvitlie! WmgjtBl<! gqvfkr<gjtBl<!fqvh<hqh<!ohir<gq!upqgqe<xe}}!)lz!nk<!Lkuuek<ke<?!GKhe<!Lnzz!hke<///*!we<X!likqa|I! v^|z<?!^kg<gk<Kz<zia<!nh<hi! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! ÄbiGk<hi! lijzbqz<?! sqxh<hqk<Kg<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! yV! himzqOzOb?! nf<k! ogtK! fibgl<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!

ne<a|! nuIgtK! nx<Hkg<! giv{s<! sqxh<jh! ouGuig! njlk<Kk<!kf<K! uqm<miIgt<?! lgie<! G{r<Gc! l <kie<! nh<hi! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!-Oki!hiVr<gt<"!!! gmzqx<!guqp<k<kOkiI!gh<hzi!zik<Kme<!! ! gMgquvOu!bjpk<kQI"!! gl<hLm!OeicOb!uf<kOkiI!gh<hjz!! ! gcH,je!big<gq!juk<kQ I"!! Gcogi{<M!gIh<hujx!Bt<tqVg<jgbqZjlg<!! ! ogijzosb<b!uf<k!Leqjbg<!

! Gkqogi{<M!outq!ose<XlqVK{<Mg{<Mhqe<!! ! %IgIh<h!ujv!HGf<kQ I"!! hqcbqx<!hqck<K{<m!hqt<jt!se<eqbisq!Gmx<!! ! HQ xq!uvOu!bjpk<kQ I"!! hqiqbl<!juk<okjebit!oue<eqmk<kqf<k!uqV!! ! OhjvBf<!K~Kuqm<CI"!



!

!



68

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! fmelqM!hikiv!uqf<koke<!ose<eqBx!! ! fim<osz<Zoli!osiz<Zol"!! fx<G{r<Gc!ogi{<m!hiK]iuie!GV!! ! fike<!Laqb<!bk<kQ Oe"!!! -u<uixig! nx<Hkg<! giv{r<gt<?! ne<hqbig<gjtg<! ogi{<M!fqgp<f<kiz<! ÄÄL0\qîk<K}}! we<Xl<! nUzqbig<gjtg<! ogi{<M!fqgp<f<kiz<! ÄÄgvilik<K}}! we<Xl<?! upr<gh<hm<M! uVgqe<xe/! -u<uqV!hkr<gTl<! -bx<jgg<G! lix<xlie! fqgp<s<sqgjtg<! Gxqh<hqMueuiGl</!NgOu! kie<! ne<eiIgTg<G! ÄguiiqGz<! Nkik<}! .! ÄÄ-bx<jgbqe<!upjlg<G!lix<xlig!nx<Hk!fqgp<s<sqgjt!fmk<kg<!%cbuIgt<}}!we<X!ohbI!d{<M/!!! -u<uqklie!gxilik<Kgt<!-Xkqk<!kQ Ih<H!fit<! )gqbilk<K*!ujv!fjmohx<Xg<! ogi{<Om! -Vg<Gl<?! nXhm<M! fqe<X! uqmiK/! NgOu!nk<kjgb! Nx<xz<! ohx<x! lgiEhiuIgt<! hiz<! Ofvig! fim<m!Okm<mr<gjt! fqjxOux<xqk<! kVl<hc! Ogm<hK! Ä\ibq^|l<}! ÄL <kah<H}!

liGl</!-u<uixig!hk<uig<gTl<!dt<te/!!! ÄÄgxilik<Kg<gjt! -e<giI! )fqvigiqh<H*! osb<kiz<?! ^|e<ek<.uz<.!\link<Kg<! %m<mk<jk! uqm<Ml<! fQ r<gq! upq! ogm<m! L0k qzig<gtqe<!%m<mk<kqzigq! uqMuie<}}! we<X! Ähkiui.gzQ zQ}?! 3.uK! higl<?! 35:.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?! Äkl<aQ K}! 92.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?!]va|hqg<a|z<!ng<hI}! 7:.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<?! Änz<.buig<gQk<K.uz<.\ui! aqI.hQ.hbieq.ngibqkqz<!ngihqI?!3.uK!higl<?!:1.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!uf<Kt<te/!!! -e<El<?! -u<uixigOu?! ]va|! kiQ g<gk<Kz<! Lal<lkqb<bi?!

fhaik<Kz<! GIH! uz<! -k<kqîz<! Lkzqb! hz! gqvf<kr<gtqZl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xe/!!! d{<jl! -u<uixqVg<g?! hqt<jth<! hig<gqbl<?! nUziK!d{<mig!nUzqbig<gtqml<! Ogm<gg<! %miokeUl<?! nK! hx<xq! -pquigUl<! hzI!%xqBl<?! wPkqBl<! uVuOkiM?! kgik?! nmik! osix<hkr<gjtBl<!hqvObigqh<hK! uVf<kk<! kg<gkiGl</! nk<kjgbuIgt<! nxqU?! d{Is<sq!ohXl<!ohiVm<M!OlZl<!sqz!Nkivr<gjtk<!kVgqOxil</!!! ÄÄkeg<Gg<! Gpf<jk! d{<mig! Ou{<Mole<X! uqVl<Hgqxue<?!

a\<vk<?! d <k<kiK?! nHz<! nh<hi <?! ^h<kQ ?! uzqb<Bz<zia<!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! gHjv! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<ujkh<! hx<xqh<! hqck<Kg<! ogit<uieig/! Woeeqz?! nue<!fick<OkMgqe<x! fim<ml<! nuEg<G! fqjxOuxq! nueK! ljeuqBl<!nz<zia<uqe<! Wx<him<jmg<! ogi{<M! Kiqklib<g<! gIh<hligq! uqMuit<!we<hkx<Ogbil</! -K! nEhuk<kqz<! Osikqg<gh<ohx<X! Ofiqz<! g{<M!



!

!



69

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

nEhuk<k! nkqbis<siqblie! -vgsqbliGl<}}! we<X! nz<zili?! -lil<?!nH,! nh<Kz<zia<?! j]G! Ê~ Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<?! ÄL\Ivhik<}kqZl<?! nz<zili! -lil<! jkvhQ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|?!Äailq]i}!63.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!nxquqk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! dzgl<! Ohix<Xl<! dk<kllh<! ohiqbiI! yVuVjmb! hqxh<jhh<!hx<xqBl<! -r<G! dkiv{h<hMk<kqg<! %XuK! lqglqgh<! ohiVk<kole!fqjeg<gqe<Oxil</!!! uiiq! upr<gqg<! ogijm! ogiMk<k! ut<tZl<?! hOvihgivl<! HiquOk!keK! okipqzigg<! ogi{<cVf<kuVlie! Äaik<kql<! kibQ}! GMl<hk<jks<!OsIf<kuVl<?! JOvih<hiuqOz! <ohbqe<! Oksk<kqOz! ÄLI^qbi}! we<x!DiqOz?!aq\<iq! 671!xlzie<! 28?!kqr<gm<gqpjl!-vuqz<! hqxf<K?!-HE!Sxig<gi! we<El<! ohbVme<! ^<ohbqeqz<! 49! uVm! gizl<! uip<f<K?!aq\qiq!6:9.z<?!^<ohbqje!uqm<Ml<!Hxh<hm<M!Nh<hqiqg<gi?!nOvhqbi?!-vig<!Nsqbi! jleI! Lkzqb! hqvOksr<gtqz<! Sx<Xh<! hqvbi{l<! osb<K!ohiqbiIgtK!gHVgjt!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<K?! hz!a\<\|gTl<! Hiqf<K?!

sqxqKl<! ohiqKlig! 39:!F~x<gTg<Gg<! Gjxuqe<xq!-bx<xqh<! Hgp<ohx<X?!89!uVml<?!8!likl<?!:!fit<!GMl<hk<Kme<!lizqg<gQ !lKahqz<!uip<f<K?!yOv!Hk<kqvjeh<!ohx<X!aq\<iq! 749?!xhQ Uz<!NgqI!39?!out<tqg<gqpjl!-vuqz<!uhik<kigq!^qiqbiuqOz!kqlq]<g<!fgiqOz?!gi^Q B,e<!Ge<xqe<!lQ K!nmg<gligq! -Vh<huVlie! nx<Hk! nukivh<! HV]iqe<! hqxh<Hs<! sqxh<H!uqhvl<!uVliX;.!!! ÄÄhqvhz<b!uqbihiiqBl<?!osz<uf<kVlie!^<ohbqe<!uisq!yVuVg<G!wz<ziuqklie!Jsuiqbs<!sl<hk<KgtqVf<Kl<!yOv!yV!ohVr<Gjx?!nK!kie<!Hk<kqv!sl<hk<kqz<zik!Gjx/!

!! kie<! Ogt<uqBx<xqVf<k! ohiqbiIgt<! biuiqmk<kqZl<! Okcs<ose<X!keK!leg<Gjxjb!nuI!okiquqk<kiI/!biuVl<!nuVg<G!uqkqbqOzOb!hqt<jt! hig<gqbl<! ohXukx<G! -mlqz<jz! we<x! hkqjzOb! %xqeI/!nuVl<!lqgUl<!uqbi%zljmf<K!gujzObicVf<K!uf<kiI/!!! gjmsqbig?!a\<vk<!ogtKz<!n0tl<?!o^b<bqKei?!La<bqk<kQ e<!nh<Kz<!gikqV!\Q zieq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK!gQIk<kqh<!hqv^<kihk<jkg<!Ogt<uqBx<X?!nuI!hGkiKli!fgVg<Gs<!ose<X!keK!Ljxh<him<jm!nf<k!laie<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtqml<!

ose<X!%xqeiI/!!! ogtKz<! n0tl<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?!ÄÄzu<ja! Ofig<gqOee</! nkqz<! dlg<Gh<! hqt<jtg<Gm<c! hig<gqbl<!-z<jz!we<Ox!okiqb!uVgqxK}}!we<X!osie<eiIgt</!!



!

!



70

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! dmOe! nl<leqkI! gzr<gqh<! hiqkuqk<K?! ÄÄfibgOl"! -f<kk<!KIh<hig<gqbEg<Gh<! hqt<jt!-z<jz!we<X!wz<OziVOl!%xquqm<miIgt</!-vh<hiIg<G! -z<jz! we<X! osiz<zilz<! Ogm<mjk! =f<K! upr<Gl<!ut<tzigqb! kr<gt<! uibqjzk<! Okc!klqObe<! -f<kg<! Ogiiqg<jgBme<!uf<kqVg<gqOxe</!hiuqbqe<!lQ K!kjb!%If<K!gqVjh!osb<kVtq!-ueK!nOhm<jsjbh<!H,Ik<kq!osb<kVt!Ou{<MgqOxe}}!we<X!le<xiceiI/!!! NuvK! lOeifqjzbxqf<K! lelqvr<gq?!a\<vk<! ogtKz<! n0tl<!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! ÄÄnzqOb"! we<eqz<! fqe<Xl<!dlg<ogiV!hqt<jtjbk<!kVgqe<Oxe/!dlK!LKjg!weK!LKGme<!OsVl</! WeK! LKGk<! k{<czqVh<hK! N{<! Gpf<jk/! nK! dlK!-z<zk<kqz<!hqxg<Gl</!wlK!wz<ziuqk!-z<LgTg<Gl<!nf<kh<!hqt<jtOb!uiiqsiuiI/! nuI! wlI! fiuigOu! -Vh<hiI/! WuVl<! outqh<hMk<kik!nglqb!-vgsqbr<gjt!wz<zil<!nuI!hgqvr<gh<! hMk<KuiI/! HgOpiMl<!gQ Ik<kqObiMl<! uqtr<GuiI/! nuVjmb! ohbI! Lal<lK/! Neiz<?!Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! we<x! giv{h<! ohbVme<! uqtr<GuiI}}! we<X! Nsq!%xqbEh<hqeiIgt</!

!! nuVl<! sf<Oki]k<Kme<! uQ M! kqVl<hqeiI/! ne<X?! nuI! ljeuq!gIh<hukqbigq!nh<hiz<!\eelieuIgt<!kie<?!a\<vk<!j]Gz<!ng<hI?!j^bqKei!Lal<lK!Laqb<bk<kQ e<!-h<E!nvhq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuigtiuI/!!! -u<uvziX?!Äleigqh<.ogtkqb<bi}!87.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?!ÄgzibqKz<.\uiaqI}!gqvf<kk<kqZl<!gi{zil</!!! ÄÄgxilik<jkg<! ogi{<M! kgh<heqe<xq! hqt<jtjb! outqh<hMk<k!

nUzqbig<gTg<Gs<!sg<kqB{<mi@!we<X!NiqHhqz<zia<!j]G!Lal<lK!gzQ zQ ?! ]ihqbQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtqml<!uqeuh<hm<mkx<G! ÄÄnr<rel<! osb<b!nuIgTg<Gs<! sg<kqB{<M!we<hkig!uqjm!hgIf<kiIgt</!!! -u<uqhvl<?! hkiui.gzQ zQ?! 2.uK! higl<?! 8:.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!gim<sqbtqk<Kg<!ogi{<cVg<gqxK/!!! kgh<heqe<xq! a\<vk<! =î! njzaq < zil<! nuIgt<! hqxf<k!uvziX!GINe<!]iQhqz<!%xh<hMgqe<xK/!

!! nUzqbig<gtqe<! gxilik<kqz<! lx<oxie<jxBl<! kVgqe<Oxil</!hiVr<gt<"!!! a\<vk<! ]ia<! aê<! nzQ! n\Q lihikQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! uZh<hlie! uzqBz<zia<uigUl<?! hqIkU^qb<bik!



!

!



71

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

kiQ g<giuqe<!j]gigUl<!-Vf<kiIgt</!nuIgtK!LiQKgtqz<!yVuVg<G!ouG!gizligg<!Gpf<jkbqz<jz/!nuvK!ljeuq!lzcbig!-Vf<kit</!nuI!klK!-g<Gjxjb!j]G!nuIgtqml<!Ljxbqm<miI/!j]guIgt<!nuvK! ljeuqjb! gz<uk<kqzqVg<gs<! osb<K?! ge<eqh<! oh{<! biVl<!nh<hg<gk<kqz<! Ohigg<! %mioke<X! kjmuqkqk<kqVf<kiIgt</!gz<uk<kqzqVf<k!nh<oh{<l{qjb!outqbqzqVf<K!ogi{<M!j]guIgt<!%If<K!Ofig<gqg<!ogi{<cVf<kiIgt</!kx<osbzib<!ye<hK!ubKt<t!yV!sqXlq?! gkU! Kuivk<kqe<! upqbib<! Ofig<gq! hiIk<kit</! j]guIgtqe<!%Ijlbie! Ofig<G! nf<kg<! ge<eqbqe<! lQKl<! uqPf<kK/! nf<kh<!oh{<[l<! gIh<hukqbieit</! nf<ks<! sqXlqBl<! gIh<hlieit</! -u<ux<Hk!uvziX?! ÄÄlqINk<Kz<.gujee<}}! we<x! F~zqz<?! 554.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!osiz<zh<hMgqe<xK/!!! NgOu?! wg<gizLl<! nUzqbig<gTg<G! gxilik<Ks<! osb<b!sg<kqB{<M/!lUk<kieuIgjt!abik<kig<gUl<!kk<KuL{<M/!hqkiuqe<xq!hqt<jtjb! outqh<hMk<kUl<! uz<zjlB{<M/! nUziK! hqt<jtg<Gm<c!hig<gqbl<!Ou{<Mole<X!nuIgtqml<!Ogm<hKl<!NGl</!

!! -ju! wz<zil<! GINe<?! akQ K?! ohiqbiIgtqe<! siqk<kqvr<gjtg<!ogi{<M! <kqvligqe<xe/! -ux<jx! lXh<hue<! sk<kqbk<jk!lXh<hueiuie</!!!

gh<V?!\qbivk<K!%Mli@!!! nz<zia<uqe<! keqh<hm<m! nVTg<Gl<?! ne<Hg<Gl<! hik<kqblie!

-h<OhIh<hm<m!fikig<gtie!nUzqbig<gt<?!laie<gt<!likuh<!HvmIgtK!gh<V! ]iQ HgTg<Gs<! ose<X! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK! N{<?! oh{<! -V!hizVg<Gl<!^|e<ek<Kl<?!L^<k<kah<HliGl</!!! fhq! ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgOt!kr<gtK! ne<jebqe<! gh<Vg<Gs<! ose<X! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</! OlZl<! nuIgt<! daK! Bk<kk<kqz<! ]aQ kie!âihig<gTjmb! gh<VgTg<Gh<! Ohib<! \qbivk<Kh<!Hiqf<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</!âihig<gjtBl<?!lx<xuIgjtBl<!\qbivk<kqx<Gh<!OhiGl<! hcbig! Wuq! -Vg<gqe<xiIgt</! nr<reOl! âihig<gTl<!

gh<VgTg<Gs<! ose<X! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<kqVg<gqxiIgt</! -u<uqhvr<gjth<!hx<xqb!Nkivr<gt<!âQa|^<^qk<ki!akQ K!gqvf<kr<gtqZl<?!lq]<gik<K!]iQ hqZl<!uf<Kt<te/!fhqgt<!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<! âihig<gjt! Ofig<gq?! fie<! dr<gjtg<! gh<Vgjt!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<ujk! uqm<Ml<! Wx<geOu! uqzg<gq! uf<Oke</! )Neiz<*!-h<OhiK! njugjt! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<Br<gt<! )we<X! WUgqOxe<*/!



!

!



72

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

Woeeqz<?!fqs<sblig!nK!lXjl!uip<g<jgjb!fqjeU,m<mg<!%cbkig!-Vg<gqxK}}! we<X! kqVuib<! lzIf<kVtqb! akQK! lq]<gik<! ]iQ hqZl<?!âQ a|! L <zql<?! -HE!li\i?! kqIlqkQ ! nH,! kiU,K?! f^bQ ! Lkzqb!akQK!gqvf<kr<gtqZl<!gim<sqbtqk<Kg<!ogi{<cVg<gqxK/!!! kqV! fhq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK! -k<!kqVuig<jgg<! gueqg<Gr<giz<! gHVgt<! -Vg<Gl<! kzr<gTg<Gs<! ose<X!\qbivk<!osb<b!Ou{<Mole<X!Wx<hMk<kh<hm<m!okz<zil<!fz<z!lejkh<!ohx<X?! fx<gqiqjbgjt!bE]<ck<K?! Olim<s!gkqjb!njmb! Ou{<Ml<!we<hkx<Ogbil</!! ÄÄgHVgt<! lXjljbh<! hx<xq! Rihgh<hMk<kg<! %cbeuig!-Vg<gqe<xe}}!we<x!fibg!uig<gqbLl<!ÄÄâQ a|!L^<zql<}}!gqvf<kk<kqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! weOu! gHVgt<! lXjl! uip<g<jgjb! fqjeU,m<mg<! %cb!RihgiIk<ks<! sqe<er<gtigOu! -Vg<gqe<xe! we<hjk! akQ Kgjt!w{<hqk<Kg<!gim<Mgqe<xe/!

!! wl<ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!uhik<kie! hqe<H?! oh{<gTg<gvsq?! o^b<bqkk<Kei!Nbq]i!^qk<kQ g<gi!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! -z<zk<kqe<! njxbqOzOb!khe<!osb<K!nmg<gh<!ohx<xiIgt</!Nbq]i!fibgq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!kqxf<k!Lgk<Kme<!nf<k!njxg<Gs<!ose<X!kr<gtK!g{uI! ohVlie! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgjtBl<?!OuX!-mk<kqz<!nmg<gligq!-Vg<Gl<!kr<gtK!sOgikvI!nh<KI! va<lie<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! gHVg<Gl<!ose<X! ^zil<! nuIgjt! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<kqVg<gqxiIgt</! kr<gtK!

nVjlk<!kf<jk!o^b<bqKei!nH,hg<gI!^qk<kQg<G!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! uhik<kieKl<! nf<k! njxbqOzOb! nmg<gl<!osb<bh<hm<m! hqe<Hl<! kqxf<k! Lgk<KmOeOb! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK!upg<gl</!!! o^b<bqKei!dlI!hi'g<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!uhik<kieKl<! nuIgTl<! nf<k! njxbqOzOb! nmg<gl<!osb<bh<hm<miIgt</! ne<X! Lkz<! ne<jebiI! Nbq]i! fibgq!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! fi{k<Kme<! Lgk<jk!&ceuIgtib<! ÄÄHIgi}}Ume<! ose<X! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<KuvzieiIgt</!

-u<uqhvl<!lq]<gik<!]iQhqz<!%xh<hMgqe<xK/!!! OlOz! g{<m! akQ jkg<! ogi{<M! oktquigk<! okiqb! uVuK!biokeqz<;.!!



!

!



73

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ÄÄgHVgtqz<! îzqaQ e<gt<! abik<KmOeOb! -Vg<gqxiIgt<!we<hKl<?!nuIgjt!biI!biI!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<gqxiIgOti!nuIgjt!nf<k! îzqaQe<gt<! fe<G! nxqgqe<xiIgt<! we<hKl<! oktquigh<!HzeigqxK/!!! -g<giv{l<! hx<xqOb!nuIgjt!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<huIgt<! ÄÄnkH}}!liqbijkBme<! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<b! Ou{<cbK! gmjl?! ui\qH! we<Xl<!-uIgtqe<! hkuqg<Gk<! kg<guiX! abik<kibqVg<Gr<! gizk<kqz<!nuIgTme<! yPgq! fmf<Kg<! ogit<uK! Ohiz?! u0hik<kqx<Gh<! hqxGl<!nuIgjt! abik<kieuIgtigOu! -Vg<gqxiIgt<! we<hkigg<! gVkq!liqbijkBmEl<?! Oh[kZmEl<! fmf<Kg<! ogit<uK!nk<kqbiusqbligqe<xK/!!! Woeeqz<?!ÄÄke<je!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<Bl<!leqkIgTg<G!nuIgtqe<!yPg<gl<!hg<kqg<Gk<!kg<guiX!lgieqe<!dkuqBhgivl<!d{<mibqVg<Gl<}}!we<X!j]Gz<!aqf<K?!nz<zili!nh<Kz<!ag<G!Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! kI\|li!lq]<gik<! 2.uK!higl<!

767.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!wMk<kxquqg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! OlZl<! ÄÄo^b<bqkk<Kei?! hik<kqli! fibgq! fis<sq! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<ai! nuIgt<! o^b<bqKei!al<\i! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! djmb! gh<jv! \qbivk<! osb<ukx<gig! yu<ouiV!out<tqg<gqpjlBl<! Ohib<! uf<kiIgt<}}! we<hkig?! j]Gz<! -^<zil<!-lil<! hg<Vk<kQ e<! JeQ !aehQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!dl<lk<Kz<.giiQ.]va|!âQa|z<!Hgiiq}}!bqz<!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄN{<?! oh{<! biuVl<! uzqliIgTjmb! gh<V?! \qbivk<kqx<gigh<!

OhiuK! L <k<kah<hiGl<}}! we<X! hkiuial<likqb<bi?! ha<VI.vibqg<?!ÄÄ\ilqdI.V&^<}}?!ÄÄxk<Kz<!La<kiI}}!Lkzqb!gqvf<kr<gTl<!%Xgqe<xe/!!! OlZl<?! ÄÄgHVgjt!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<gqe<x! oh{<gjt!nz<zia<!z0ek<Ks<! osb<gqxie<}}! we<x! akQjk! êK.kzQ z<! hqck<K! sqzI!ÄÄoh{<gt<!\qbivk<kqx<Gs<!osz<zg<!%miK!we<X!osiz<ZgqxiIgt</}}!-f<k!akQ jk!De<Xkz<! hqch<hK!âQ a<! NgiK/! Woeeqz?!-f<k!akQ K!tbQH!we<X!-lil<!Lak<kqK!-HE!a\I!n^<g<gzieQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!ÄÄkg<iQ H!we<x!gqvf<kk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!Njgbiz<!-f<k! tbQ hie! akQ jkg<! ogi{<M! Wuz<?! uqzg<gz<gTg<G! nk<kim<sq!

De<Xkz<! hqcg<gh<hmlim<miK}}!we<X!nz<zili!o^b<bqK!nlQ I!nzuQ !n\<lQ iQ !nuIgt<!ÄÄ-a<zig<Gz<!ua<aihQ e<}}!we<x!F~zqz<!kg<g!êK!Nkivk<Kme<! uqiquig! wMk<Kjvk<Kt<tiIgt</! Olx<osie<e! F~jz!^|e<ek<K! \link<K! dzlig<gt<! hzI! siq! g{<M! yh<hl<!juk<Kt<tiIgt</!!



!

!



74

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ÄÄnUzqbig<gt<?! dzlig<gt<! djmb! gHVgjth<! oh{<gTl<!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK! ^|e<ek<kiGl<?! nK! uqzg<gh<hm<mkz<z}}! we<X!-lil<! j]G!Lal<lK! gzQ zQ!]ihqbQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTjmb! ÄÄhkiui! gzQzQ }}! 3.uK! higl<?! 362.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!osiz<zh<hm<cVg<gqe<xK/!!! - <zilqe<! Nvl<h! gizk<kqz<?! sqz! oh{<gt<! \qbivk<kqx<Gs<!osz<Zl<! sf<kIh<hr<gtqz<! nr<G! fqe<X! yh<hiiq! juh<hKl<?!%g<GvzqMuKlig! -Vf<keI/! nf<ks<! sf<kIh<hk<kqz<?! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<?! gHVgjt! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<Bl<! oh{<gjt!nz<zia<! shqh<hieig}}! we<X! %xqeiIgt</! hqe<H?!fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<?! fie<! Le<H!dr<gjt! \qbivk<jk! uqm<Ml<! uqzg<gq! uf<Oke</! -h<OhiK! fQr<gt<!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<Br<gt<}}! we<X! djvk<K! \qbivk<jkh<! hx<xq! Wukz<!osb<kiIgt</!-f<k!akQ kqe<hc?!Le<H!uqzg<gqb!nf<k!akQ K!)le< |G*!lix<xh<hm<mkigq!uqm<mK!we<X!Lak<kqkQ e<gt<?!Lh^<^qiQ e<gt<!uqtg<gl<!kVgqxiIgt</!

!! a\<vk<! nH,a|jvxi! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTl<?!a\<vk<! -HE! nh<hi <! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTl<!wMk<kxquqg<Gl<! \qbivk<kqe<! Wukz<! hx<xqb! akQ kqe<! uqtg<gk<kqz<?!ÄÄfibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<?! ÄÄfQ r<gt<!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<Br<gt<! )h\|Vai*! we<X! osie<ekqz<! N{<gTl<?!oh{<gTl<! OsIf<K! njmb! ujtk<Ok! osiz<zh<hm<Mt<tK/! -K!ogi{<M!N{<?!oh{<!-VhizVg<Gl<!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<ukx<G!dk<kvU!gqjmk<Kt<tK}}!we<X!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!!

! -u<uqhvr<gt<! ÄÄ]va|hI\g<}}?! n]qnk<Kz<zlNk<! kI\|li!lq]<gik<!Lkzqb!gqvf<kr<gtqz<!kvh<hm<Mt<te/!!! ÄÄN{<?! oh{<! -VhizVl<! fibgl<! x^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgtK!Olzil<hvlie?!kqV!vUti?!gHV!]iQ jh!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<uK!uZh<hlie?!Gvhik<! )LMGkz<*!djmb!H{<{qb!nlz<gtqz<! fqe<XLt<tkiGl</! lx<XL{<mie! ne<hqbi!nUzqbig<gTjmb!gHVgjt!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<uKl<!H{<{qblie!fz<!nlz<gtqz<!fqe<XLt<tOk}}!we<X!-lil<!]l<Sk<kQ e<!xlzQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! ]ihqbQ! lKahqe<! hqvhz<blie?! De<Xkz<!

lqg<g?! Wmie?! ÄÄfqaibk<Kz<! La<k<ki\<.]vaqz<! lqe<ai\<}}! 3.uK!higl<?! 361.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! osiz<zqBt<tiIgt</! -u<uiOx?! ]ihqbQ !lKahqe<! hqvhz<b! lqg<g?! De<XkZjmb! F~zie!ÄÄ-Nek<Kk<kizqhQ eqZl<}}!uf<Kt<tK/!!



!

!



75

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! Gxqh<hqm<m! yV! kqek<kqz<! N[l<?! oh{<[l<! ye<xigg<!GplqbqVg<Gl<! Ofvk<kqZl<! uqzg<gzie! gVlr<gt<! Lx<Xl<!fqjxf<kqVg<Gl<! sf<kIh<hk<kqZl<! nUzqbig<gTjmb! gHVgjt!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<bzili@!nz<zK!\qbivk<!osb<bzigiki@!we<x!Ogt<uq!wpg<%Ml</! nz<zili?! -HE! a\I! jak<klQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! hk<uiuqz<! -u<uqeiuqx<G! uqjm!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!nke<!SVg<gliuK;.!!! ÄÄGxqh<hqm<m! nf<fit<! LPuKl<! uqzg<gzie! gVlr<gjt! uqm<Ml<!fQ r<gqekibqVh<hK! yV! ujg/! nf<fit<! LPuKl<! uqzg<gzie!gVlr<gjtg<! ogi{<mkig! -Vh<hK! -e<oeiV! ujg?! nk<kqel<?! sqz!Oujt! uqzg<gzie! gVlr<gjt! uqm<Ml<! fQr<gqekiBl<?! sqz! Oujt!uqzg<gzie! gVlr<gjt! ogi{<mikiBl<! -Vh<hK! lx<oxiV! ujg/!-u<uqklie! sf<kIh<hr<gtqz<?! Ngik! gVlr<gtqz<zik! Ofvk<kqz<!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK! Olz/! Ngik! gVlr<gTt<t! Ofvk<kqz<! N[l<?!oh{<[l<! ye<xigg<! gzf<K! fqx<hjk! uqm<M! uqzGuKl<?! Ngik!osbz<gjt!ouXh<hKl</! sik<kqblielm<cz<!nux<jxk<! kuqIk<K!klK!

nljzs<!osb<uK!NGl<}}!we<hOk/!!! NgOu! -lil<! -HE! a\I! jak<klQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! ÄÄhk<ui}}! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<Bl<! kzr<gtqz<!uqzg<gh<hm<m! gVlr<gt<! fqgpg<%cb! Ofvk<kqz<! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<Bl<!uqkk<jk! uquiqh<hKme<?! \qbivk<K! osb<ujk! nElkqg<gqxK/! OlZl<!-Khx<xq! nz<zili?! j]G! -HE! NhqkQe<! we<X! hqvg<gqbikq! ohx<x!Lal<lK! nlQe<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ÄÄxk<Kz<.La<k<kiiqz<}}!Gxqh<hqm<cVg<Gl<!uq]bliuK;.!!

! ÄÄ\qbivk<Ks<! osb<Blqmk<kqz<! uqzg<gh<! ohx<x?! Ngik! gVlr<gt<!-Vh<hqEl<?! N[l<?! oh{<[l<! gzf<kqVh<hK! Ohie<x! Gx<xr<gt<!fqgp<ukibqVh<hqEl<?!fQ !\qbivk<jk!uqm<Muqm!Ou{<mil<"!-ju!Ohie<x!giv{r<gTg<gigh<! H{<{qblie!gVlr<gt<!uqmh<hmlim<mi/!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<b! Ou{<cbK! lieqm<e! lQK! ohiXh<hiGl</! HqKnk<kieux<jx!ouXg<g! Ou{<Ml</! -bZlibqe<?!nux<jx! fQ g<g! Ou{<Ml<! we<hKkie<!-lil<!-HE!a\Vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|<!jak<klQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! hk<uiuqe<! gVk<kiGl<}}! we<X! -uIgt<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!

! ÄÄyVue<! uzqBz<zia<! djmb! gHVg<Gh<! Ohib<! nu<uqmk<kqz<!sqxqK!Ofvl<! kiqhm<cVh<hjkg<! ogi{<M!nuEg<Gh<! hqvObi\eL{<M! .!\qbivk<K! se<liIg<gk<kqe<! )]v-b<bk<*! fz<! upg<glie!Ng<gh<hm<cVh<hke<! &z! Ofig<gl</! nkqz! hx<hz! Fm<hliejugTl<?!nf<kvr<gliejugTlie! )n <viV*! -vgsqbr<gtqVh<hke<! giv{k<jk!Le<eqm<Omkie<}}! we<X! -lil<! hg<Vk<kQ e<! xi Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!



!

!



76

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

ne<a|! nuIgt<! ÄÄlikzqh<}}! wEl<! gqvf<kk<kqz<! ÄÄ\qbivk<kqe<! &zl<!njmbh<hmg<! %cb! nVl<ohVl<! hze<}}! we<El<! nk<kqbik<kqz<!ujvf<kqVh<hkib<?! lg<gi!Lnt<tliuqe<! Lh<k<kqbig!-Vf<k!nzzili!-lil</!o^b<bqK!ka<zieQ!lg<gQ?!]ihqbQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!ÄÄkg<iQHz<!d^|z<}}!91.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! wuoviVuI! klK! kib<! kf<jkBjmb! gh<Vgjt! nz<zK!nu<uqVuVt<! yVuVjmb! gh<jv! out<tqg<! gqpjlgtqz<! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<uivibqe<?!nuI!a\<\|!osb<kujvh<!OhiziuiI}}!we<hkigUl<?!!! ÄÄliki! hqki! -VuVt<! yVuVjmb! gh<jv! yu<ouiV!out<tqg<gqpjl!OkiXl<!biviuK!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<uivibqe<!nuVjmb!hqjpgt<! ohiXg<gh<hMuKme<! nuI! fe<xqBjmb! fz<zcbivigUl<!wPkh<hMgqxiI}}!we<hkigUl<!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! Olx<g{<m!-V!akQ KgTl<!Älq]<gik<.]iQ hqz<}!%xh<hm<Mt<te/!

!! ÄÄgh<Vgjt!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<uK!hiuk<kqx<Gh<!hqvibs<!sqk<kliGl<}}!we<Xl<!akQ K!uf<Kt<t!uqhvl<!ka<kQ hqz<}!osiz<zh<hm<cVg<gqxK/!!! OlOzBt<t! &e<X! akQ KgTl<?! ]ihqbQ ! lKahqe<! F~zigqb?!Ä-Nei}?!3.uK!higl<?!277.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!nxquqg<gh<hm<Mt<te/!!! -f<fibg!uig<Ggjtg<!ogi{<M!okiqb!uVuK!biokeqz<?!!! silieqbIgtie! liki?! hqkig<gTjmb! gHVgjt! \qbivk<Ks<!

osb<uOk! a\<\|g<G! yh<hiekiGl<?! hiu! fquiv{ligUl<?! hihOki]!hqvibs<sqk<kligUl<!NgquqMgqxK!we<xqVf<kiz<?!ag<G!kNzi!ntuqz<!heiuigq?!-e< ie<!gilqzie?!hiqH,v{k<Kul<!njmf<k?!ns<sf<!kQ If<k?!nUzqbig<gTjmb! gHVgjt! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<uke<! lIk<khi?! hkuq?!de<ek! nf<k^<K?! kv\i! wu<utU! lgk<Kulqg<gki! bqVg<gOu{<Ml<"!nKogi{<M! hiuqgtie! \er<gTg<G! wu<utU!dbIf<k! hm<sl<! hiu!le<eqh<Hl<?! hiuOki]! fquiv{Ll<! sqk<kqbiuqm! Ou{<Ml<"! -f<k!d{<jljb!fil<!fe<G!sqf<kqk<K!d{v!Ou{<Ml<"!!! -u<uixig! nVjlbie! LcUk<! kQ Ih<jh?! nz<zili?! j]G!

B,SHe<ehaieQ! lq <iQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?!Ä]uiaqKz<.ag<G}! 364.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! lqgk<! oktquig! uqtg<gqk<!kf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄfhqgt<! Ogilie<?! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<?! wuVjmb! gh<Vlqz<zik! Lf<kqe! fhqliIgt<! \er<gTg<G!



!

!



77

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

dhOksR<!osb<K!ogi{<cVf<k!l <\qK!GhiUg<G?!yu<ouiV!uivLl<!ose<X! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<K! uf<kqVg<gqxiIgt<}}! we<x! uqhvl<! âQa|z<!HgiiQ }! âQ a|z<! L <zql<?! Älq]<gik<}! Lkzqb! akQ Kg<! gqvf<kr<gtqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xe/!!! OlOz! %xh<hm<m! -f<k! akQ jkg<! ogi{<M?! ÄÄlgie<gt<! -Vf<k!-mr<gjtBl<! %m! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK! L <k<kah<hiGl<}}! we<hkig!nz<zili?! Lz<zi! nzqgiiQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?!ÄlqIgik<}!2.uK!higl<!559.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvgqe<xiIgt</!!! Njgbiz<! lgie<gt<! hqxf<k!-ml<?!okiPk!-ml<?!gz<uk<sqz<zi!-Vf<k! -ml<! Lkzqbux<jx! \qbivk<kKs<! osb<uKl<! NGlie!giiqbl<kie<!we<hK!uqtr<g!uVgqxK/!!! ÄÄgHVgjt! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<Br<gt<?! )nu<uiX! osb<ujk*!hiuole<Xl<?! ogMkqobe<Xl<! %xOu{<mil<}}! we<X! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! djvk<Kt<t!akQK?! Äkh<xieqbqz<}!

uf<Kt<tK/!!! ÄÄohiKuig! gHV! \qbivk<jk! Ou{<mil<! we! uqzg<GukieK!Gh<jv! d{<mig<Gl<}}! we<hkig?! nz<zili?! Lz<zi! nzqgiiQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! Ä]va|]<.]qhi}! 3.uK! higl<?!262.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! ohiKuig! \qbivk<jk! uqzg<GuK! ogi{<M! Gh<V! Wx<hMlieiz<?!Äheihqz<zia<}! uigq! N{<muetuqz<! ui^qzie! fikig<gTjmb!nUzqbig<gTjmb! gHVgjt! \qbivk<! osb<bzigiK! weg<Gxqh<higk<!

kMk<kiz<!wk<kjgb!hbr<gvlie!hiulig!-Vg<gOu{<Mole<hjk!fe<G!sqf<kqk<Kh<!hiIg<gg<!gmjlh<hm<Mt<Otil</!!! ÄÄ\qbivk<kqx<Gh<!Ohigg<%miK!we!w{<{l<!juk<K!uqzg<Ggqxue<!-^<zik<jk! uqm<M! fQ r<gqbueigUl<?! nz<zia<Ug<Gl<! x^|Zg<Gl<!liXhiM! osb<kueigUl<! NgquqMuie}}! we<hkig! nz<zili!G^<k<KzieQ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|?!nz<zili!Lz<zi!nzQgiiQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!NgqbuIgt<!osiz<zqBt<tiIgt<!we<hkig!ÄluiaqHz<.zKe<eqb<bi}?! 3.uK! higl<?! 494.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<?! ]va|!]qhi}!3.uK!higl<!262.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!uf<Kt<te/!

!! OlZl<?! -u<uixig! Ä\u<aI.Let<tl<}?! Ä]uiaqKz<! ag<G}!Äl]iiqg<Gz<!ne<uiI?!ÄKvV^<.êqb<bi.hQ.xk<kqz<.ua<aihqb<bi?!Lkzqb!gqvf<kr<gTl<!%Xgqe<xe/!!



!

!



78

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! nUzqbig<gjtBl<! nuIgtK! gHVgjtBl<! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<ujkBl<?! nuIgt<hiz<! dkuq! OkMujkBl<! -e<giI! osb<hue<!j]k<kijeh<!Ohiziuie<}}!we<hkig?!GINe<!]iQ hqe<!22.uK!^|vi!55.uK! Nbk<kqe<! uqbig<gqbie! uqtg<gk<kqz<?! kh< Q I! 'a|z<hbieqz<?! 5.uK!higl<?!248.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/!! nUzqbig<gTg<G! Wx<hm<cVg<Gl<! hkuqg<Gk<! kGf<kix<Ohiz<?!N{<mue<hiz<! LmgqbqVh<hkqz<! fqs<sbligk<! kv\ig<gtqz<!kivkl<lqbL{<M?! nr<reOl! nUzqbig<gTjmb! kGkqh<hcg<G?!nuIgjt! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<gqxuIgt<! hqvObi\er<gjth<! ohx<Xg<!ogit<uiIgt</}}!we<X!Äxk<Kz<.La<k<kiI}?!2.uK!higl<?!776.K!hg<gkkqz<!!osiz<zh<hm<cVg<gqe<xK/!!! ÄÄg0hi?! \l<\l<?! ^hi?! lIui?! nvhik<?! L\<kzqhi?! lqei!gz<ozxqBlqmr<gt<?! ne<hqbig<gtqe<! gHVgt<! Ngqb!-k<kzr<gtqozz<zil<! KNg<gt<! nr<gQ givligq! yh<Hg<ogit<th<!hMgqe<xe/! -u<uqmr<gjt<h! Ohiz<! nUzqbig<gtqe<! gHVgtqmk<kqZl<!ÄKNg<gt<}! gH,zigq! Wx<gh<hMujk!nEhuH,Iuligg<! g{<M! Osikqg<gh<!

ohx<xqVg<gqe<xK}}! we<hkig! Äkh< Q I! 'a|z<! hbie<}! 2.uK! higl<?! 3:9.3::.uK!hg<gr<gtqz<!%xh<hm<cVg<gqe<xK/!!! a\<vk<?!^|z<k<kiEz<!NiqhQ e<?! o^b<bqK!na<lK!ghQI?! iqhibq?!NiqH! fibgl<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! kr<gtK!gzQ hig<gTg<Gl<?! LiQ kQ e<gTg<Gl<?! Laqh<hQ e<gTg<Gl<?! lx<Xl<!ohiqObiIgTg<Gl<?! ÄÄfQr<gt<! hGkiK! ]iQ Hg<Gh<! OhiuQIgtibqe<! Lke<!Lkzig!ogtKz<!n0tl<?!nh<Kz<!gikqI?!Laqb<bqk<kQ e<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjt! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<k! hqe<Hkie<! lx<xg<!giiqbr<gjtg<! gueqg<g! Lx<hm! Ou{<Ml<}}! we<X! dhOksl<!

osb<kuIgtibigq!-Vf<kiIgt</!!! iqhibQ !fibgl<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!sLgl<!yV!fit<! yV! leqkI! uf<K! kil<! hGkiKUg<Gh<! Ohig! fim<ml<!ogi{<cVh<hkiBl<! keg<G!dhOksl<! osb<K!hb{!uqjmbtqg<GliXl<!Ou{<cfqe<xiI/!!! nkx<G! NiqH! fibgl<! iqhibQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<?! ÄfQ r<gt<! hGkiKg<Gt<! Fjpf<kiz<! OfOv! ose<X! o]b<G!nh<Kz<! gikqV! \Q zieq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtk<!

kiqsqk<Kg<!ogit<uQ vig/!nuIgt<!abik<kig!-Vg<Gr<!gizk<kqZl<!siq?!uhik<kigq! uqm<m! gizk<kqx<gh<hiZl<! siq?! nuIgjt! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<bilz<! fQI! wf<kg<! giiqbk<jkBl<! osb<b! Lx<hm<M! uqmg<%miK/!uqzibk<KjmbuI! wuvibqVh<hqEl<! siq?! hGkiKg<Gt<! Fjpf<k! OhiK!o]b<G! nh<Kz<! gikqV! \Q zieq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjt!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<buqz<jzbieiz<?!nuVjmb!uqzibk<jkh<!



!

!



79

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

hqMr<gh<hm<Mh<! Ohib<uqMl<! we<X! nuIgTg<G! nz<zia<kNzi!uiIk<jkh<hiM! osb<Kt<tie<}}! we<hkig! dhOksqk<K! uqjm!ogiMk<kEh<hqeiIgt</!!! -u<uqhvl<! Äha<\k<Kz<! n <xiI}! 349.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<! Äkh<iQ \|z<!gik<kqI}!64.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!ÄleigqH.ogtkqb<bi}uqZl<!osiz<zh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! -jkg<!ogi{<M!nxqbh<hMuK!biokeqz<?!wf<k!DVg<Gs<!ose<x!OhikqZl<!nf<k!DiqZt<t!hqvhz<blie!nUzqbiuqe<!kIgiUg<Gh<!Ohib<!\qbivk<jk! Lck<K! uqm<Mk<kie<! -kv! giiqbk<kqz<! =Mhm! Ou{<Ml</!nkqOz! kie<! hvgk<K{<M! we<hOk/!NgOukie<! GKHliIgotz<OziVl<!gh<V! \qbivk<jkh<! Oh{q! nE]<ck<K! uf<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt<! we<hkx<G!nuIgtK!fmucg<jggt<?!siqk<kqvr<gt<!sim<sqbr<gt<!hgVgqe<xe/!!! OlZl<?! ÄÄîzqaQ e<gtigqb! nUzqbig<gjt! RihgR<!osb<Blqmk<kqz<!N{<mueK! xa<lk<K!-xr<Ggqe<xK}}! we<x!akQ jkg<!

Gxqh<hqm<M?! ÄÄne<hqbi?! nUzqbI?! îzqaQ e<?! dzlig<gt<!NgqObiIgTjmb!kIgi!]iQ jh?!gh<V!]iQ jh!fic?!H{<{qbl<! Okch<!hqvbi{l<!osb<K!^hI!OhiuK!L <k<kah<hiGl<}}! we<X!a|\<\k<Kz<!-^<zil<! -lil<! g < izQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!-a<bi! dZ~Lk<kQ e<! gqvf<kk<kqz<! Ähqvbi{k<kqe<! yPr<G! Ljxgt<}!we<El<!nk<kqbibk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄ\qbivk<jk!Le<eqm<<M! bik<kqjv! osz<uK! L <k<kah<H}}! we<X!ÄÄxk<Kz<.La<k<kiI}}! 2.uK! higk<kqz<! \qbivk<kqe< <! nk<kqbibk<kqz<!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!

!! ÄÄ\qbivk<kqx<gig! we<X! hqvbi{h<hm<Mh<! OhiuK! L <k<kah<H}}!we<F!j]Gz<!-^<zil<?!nH,!nh<kqz<zia<!ka<hQ ?!aihqT!j\Ek<kQ e<!-xig<gQ?! aihqT! -HE! a\I! n <g<gzieQ?! aihqT! \ziZk<kQ e<!^|B,k<kq?! -lil<! kQ hQ ?!-lil<! G <k<KzieQ ?!-lil<!nh<Kz<zia<! -HE!^zil<! lg<gQ ?! -lil<! kgqb<Bk<kQ e<! ^|h<gQ ?! -liLz<! avjlg<! -lil<!g^< izQ ?!j]G!nh<Kz<!ag<G!Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuQ ?!gitqz<!Gtik<!-lil<!hg<Vk<kQe<!JeQ ?!-lil<!-Hez<!a|lil<?!Lz<zi!nzqgiiQ?!-lil<!leiuQ ?!-lil<!-HE!nh<Kz<!hIV?!-lil<!Jg<gieQ?!-lil<!-HE!a\I!lg<gQ ?! -lil<! HIaiEk<kQe<! azhQ?! -lil<! jhtiuQ?! -lil<! -Hez<!

ai\<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|l<! Ngqb! liohVl<! OljkgTl<?!lx<Xl<!nOfglie!Lak<kqkQe<gTl<?!Lag<gqgQe<gTl<!%xqBt<tiIgt<!we<x!uqhvk<jk!nz<zili!o^b<bqK!nlQ I!nzuQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!Ä-a<zig<Gz<.ua<aihQ eqz<}!wMk<Kjvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!



!

!



80

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! Njgbiz<?! -jx! Ofss<! osz<uIgtigqb! nz<zia<uqe<!ahQ Hgtigqb! fhqliIgjtBl<?! uzqliIgjtBl<! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK!xa<lk<Kl<?!=Omx<xk<kqx<G?!Lg<kqg<G!u^Q ziUliGl</!!! wuoeiVue<! we<Ejmb! gHjv! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<kiOei!nuEg<G! ]hink<Ks<! osb<uK! we<! Ohiqz<! ui\qhigquqm<mK}}! we<X!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! -e<eLl<?! -lil<! nH,! aeQhi! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTjmb! gh<V! ]iQ jh! -lil<gTgl<?! dzlig<gTl<! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<kqVg<gqxiIgt</! fim<m! Okm<mLjmbuIgt<?! -vm<sqh<H! OgiiqbuIgt<!nuIgjt! u Q ziuig<gq! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<K! nf<kh<hc! nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M! fim<m! Okm<mr<gjt! fqjxOuxh<! ohx<Xt<teI/! vm<sqh<jhh<!ohx<Xt<teI/!!! -KohizOu?!-lil<!&^z<!gitql<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTjmb! gh<V! ]iQ jh!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<ujkg<! ogi{<Ml<! fim<m!

Okm<mr<gjt! fqjxOuxh<! ohx<Xt<teI/! hzuqklie!nVm<hig<gqbr<gjtBl<!njmf<Kt<teI/!!! Ole<jlg<Giqb! ]ihqbq! lk<ahqe<! -lil<! a\<vk<! Lal<lKh<E!-k<iQ <!]ihQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!a\<vk<!-liLz<!n0tl<!nH,aeQ hi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtBl<?!a\<vk<!&^z<gitql<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtBl<! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<K?! nuIgtqmOl! u Qzik<Okc?! ai\k<Kg<gjt! fqjxOux<xqh<!ohx<xqVg<gqe<xiIgt</! -K! iquibk<jkg<! ogi{<M! kiqh<hMk<kh<hm<m!d{<jl/!

!! -u<uixigOu! ÎkiI?! Gk<HI! vh<hieQ?! ogtK <! ^lkieQ ?!Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! nh<Kz<! gikqI! \Q zieq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTjmb! Lhivg<gie! gHV! ]iQ jh! ohiqb! dzlig<gTl<?!Gk<HliIgTl<?!nUzqbig<gTl<!fick<!Okc!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<K!kr<gtK!fim<m! Okm<mr<gt<! jg%mh<ohx<Xl<?! nVjt! njmbh<! ohx<Xl<!hig<gqbljmf<Kt<teI/!!! -e<El<! o^b<bqKei! Gk<Hz<! l\Q K! o^b<bqK! nh<Kz<! gikqI?!]iGz<!alQ K?!fi%I!lQ vie<!îaqH!fibgl<!N{<mjg!vzqbz<zia|!

kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! H{<{qb! gHV!]iQjh! ohVl<! ohVl<!dzlig<gTl<?! uzqliIgTl<?! l]ibqGgTl<?! Gk<HgTl<?!olR<RieqgTl<?! kuObigqgTl<! ai\k<K! djmbuIgTl<! \qbivk<K!osb<ujkg<! ogi{<M! Ogiiqg<jggotz<zil<! fqjxOux<xh<! ohx<X!nVm<hig<gqbr<gjt!njmf<Kt<teI/!!



!

!



81

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! likqa|I! v^|z<?! o]b<G?! ^kg<gk<Kz<ziaqz<! giaqiQ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTl<?! a\<vk<! ogtKz<! n0tl<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK!\qbivk<jk!fic!hGkiKg<Gs<!ose<X! ÄbiGk<hi}! lijzjb! slIh<h{l<! osb<Kl<?! fi%I!N{<muIgt<!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjt! fic! fi%Vg<G! uf<K!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<K?! bi^b<bqkQ ! o]b<gQ ! u^k<v <! îkqiQ}}! lijzjb!slIh<h{l<! osb<Kl<! u Qzik<! Okc! -Vg<gqe<xiIgt</! giIliel<! Okc!-Vg<gqxiIgt<?! -vm<sqh<H! Okc! -Vg<gqxiIgt<?! =Vzgqe<! fx<hbEg<G!dkuq!Okc!-Vg<gqxiIgt</!!! -k<kjgb! d{<jlgjt! d{vLx<hmilz<! yOvbcbib<!\qbivk<Kg<! %mOu! %miK! we<X! ohiKuig! bivigqZl<!%xquqzg<GuiIgtieiz<! ns<osiz<Zg<G! wu<uqkk<kqZl<! lkqh<hqz<jz!we<hK! kq{<{l</! d{<jljb! ljxk<K! nu<uqkl<! %XhuIgt<!L0k<k qzi?! ua<aihQ?! gikqbieQ ! %m<mr<gtqZt<tuIgt<! we<hkqZl<!sf<Okglqz<jz/! d{<jljb! d{If<Kl<! Ou{<Mole<Ox! leLv{<mig!nr<rel<! lXh<Hg<! %XhuIgt<! nz<zia<Ug<Gl<?! x^|Zg<Gl<! liX!

osb<kuIgote<hkqZl<!Jblqz<jz/!!!

\qbivk<kqe<!yPr<GLjx!!! \qbivk<kqx<gigs<! osz<Zl<! N{<?! oh{<! -VhizVl<! ]iQnk<jkh<!Oh{q?!yPr<G!liqbijkObiM?!ficuf<k!giiqbk<jk!Lck<Kg<!ogi{<M!kqVl<Hkz<! Ou{<Ml</! yPr<G! kuxq! fmh<huI! hbjeh<! ohxiK!OhiuKme<?! nl<lgie<gtqe<! Ogihh<! hiIjug<Gl<! Ntig! OfiqMl</!N{<gjtuqmh<! oh{<gt<! kie<! nkqg! guelibqVg<g! Ou{<Ml</!dk<kloviVuI!kil<!hiIg<gh<!hik<kqbjkbx<x!oh{<l{qbqe<!Lgk<jkg<!g{<M! fi{LXuK! OhiZ?! Lgf<kqxf<K! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<Bl<!oh{<l{qgjtg<! g{<M! uzqliIgt<! oum<gljmgqe<xiIgt<! we<hjkk<!okiqf<K!ogit<t!Ou{<Ml</!!! dl<laik<Kz<!&lqeqe<?!a\<vk<!Nbq]i!^qk<kQg<gi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<ai! nuIgt<! oh{<gTg<OgiI! npgqb! Le<likqiqbig!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt</!\Q uqbLt<t!leqkI!Le<H!fmf<K!ogit<uK!Ohie<Ox!uhik<kigquqm<muIgtK! Le<Hl<! fmf<K! gi{<hqk<K! ne<eivK!dbIfmucg<jgh<! oh{<gTg<Gs<! sqxf<k! wMk<Kg<gim<mig!njlf<Kt<tK/!!! Äne<hqbi?!nUzqbig<gjt!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<Bl<! OhiK!nuIgjt!Le<Oeig<gilz<?! nuIgtK! Lgr<gtqe<! hg<gl<! klK! LKGh<hg<gl<!-Vg<Gl<hcbig?! gqHziju! Le<Oeig<gqOb! KN! YkOu{<Mole!gizR<ose<x?! f\<K! nvsI! nh<Kz<! n\Q <! -HE! Û,kqbqe<!



!

!



82

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

fmk<jkjbs<! sqzI! Le<likqiqbigg<! ogi{<M! OhSgqe<xeI/! nuIgt<?!lg<gi?! lkQeiuqZl<! kx<OhiK! -r<reOl! fjmohx<X! uVgqxK!we<hkigUl<! wMk<Kg<! gim<ch<! OhSgqe<xeI/! -ju?! â<aihqbk<kie!osbz<gtiGl</!!! Ä\qbivk<Ks<!osb<Bl<OhiK!gh<V!]iQjh!Le<Oeig<gqBl<?!gqHziuqe<!hg<gl<! Lkjgk<kqVh<hqBl<! nkHme<! fqx<g! Ou{<Ml<}}! we<hKOu?!lk<aHgjt!Wx<hMk<kqk<!kf<Kt<t!fie<G!-lil<gtqe<!upqLjxbiGl</!!! ÄÄgh<Vgjt! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<Bl<OhiK! gqHziju! Le<Oeig<gqOb!osb<b!Ou{<Mole<X!uVl<!iquibk<!vk<Ks<!osb<bh<hm<mkiGl<}}!we<hkig!Ähk<a|z<.gkQ I}?! 3.uK! higl<?! 447.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<?! ÄÎg<gieQ }?! 9.uK!higl<! 416.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<?! Ä]uiaqKz<.ag<G! 57.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<?!ÄK~V^< eqb<bi.hQ.xk<kq.na<zqz<! ua<aihqb<bi}}! gqvf<kk<kqZl<!wMk<Kjvg<gh<!ohx<Xt<tK/!!! a\<vk<! x^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!

nuIgTjmb! Heqk! vUtiuqz<! gHV! ]iQ jh! Le<Oeig<gq! fqe<X?!gqHziuqe<! hg<gl<!Lkjgk<! kqVh<hqbu{<{l<?!n^< ziL!njzg<Gl<!nb<Bae<ehqb<B.uxa<lKz<ziaq.uhvgik<Ka|! we<X! liqbijkBme<!^zil<! osiz<zq! osb<uOk! ^|e<ek<kiGl<}}! we<hkig?! -HE! dlI!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! iquibk<K!uf<Kt<tK?! we<X! -liLz<! n0tl<! nH,aeQhi! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! %xqBt<tiIgt</! -u<uqhvl<! Ägibk<Kz<! nu<k<kiI.kI\|li!KIVz<!Lg<k<kiI}!735.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!osiz<zh<hm<cVg<gqe<xK/!!! ÄÄne <!-HE!lizqg<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!fhq!

ohVlieiI!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgjt! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<Bl<! OhiK?! nuIgtK! Heqk! gHV! ]iQ jh! Le<Oeig<gq?!okiPjgbqz<?! fqx<gqe<x! fqjz! Ohiz! fqe<X/! -mK! jglQ K! uzK!jgjb! juk<K! jggm<c! nkHme<! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<kiIgt<}}! we<x!uisgl<?!Ä]va|]<]qhi}!263.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?!-a<bi!dZ~Lk<kQe<}!5.uK!higl<?!52:.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄ-f<k! nkH! yPr<Gh<hc! \qbivk<K! osb<uK! L <k<kah<hiGl<}}!we<X!fie<G!lKaHjmb!dzlig<gTl<!osiz<zqBt<tiIgt<!we<hkig?!Ä^Q vk<Ke<.ehuqb<bi}?! ÄuhiUz<.uhi}?! \u<aI.Le<tl<}?! hkiui.Nzl<gQ I?!

JKHz<.GZ~h<?! h <Zz<.gqkih<?! hk<a|z<.ag<! Ngqb! gqvf<kr<gt<!%Xgqe<xe/!!! hg<kiK! fgiqz<! Nm<sq! Hiqf<K! nh<hi qb<bi! gzQ hi! nH,! \0hI?!le< |I! kieQ?! a\<\|! osb<K! uqm<M! fhqgt<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgTjmb! \qbivk<jk! fic! lkQeiUg<Gs<!



!

!



83

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

ose<xiI/! nu<ulbl<?! -lil<! lizqg<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! l <\qKe<! ehuqb<bqz<! uQ x<xqVh<hjkg<! g{<M! nuIgjt!Ofig<gq!nz<zia<uqe<!ncbiOv"!-u<ulbl<!fie<!gqHziju!Le<Oeig<gq!Ou{<Mkz<! osb<b! Ou{<MOli@! nz<zK! x^|Zz<ziaq!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgjt!Le<Oeig<gq!Ou{<Mkz<!HiqbOu{<Mli@}}!we<X!uqeuqeiI/!!! nkx<G! -lil<! lizqg<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?!ÄÄdr<gtqe<!Lgk<jk!nuIgjt!uqm<Ml<!kqVh<hquqm!Ou{<mil</!nuIgt<!dr<gTg<Gl<?! hiui! Nkl<! njzaq < zil<! nuIgTg<Gl<!nz<zia<kNzi! ntuqz<! u Q ziuib<! Ng<gh<! ohx<xuIgt</! WeOu?!nuIgjt!Le<Oeig<gq!fqe<Ox!Ou{<Mkz<!osb<K!nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M!u^Qzih<!hqvik<kje!OkMr<gt<}}!we<X!uqjmh<hgIf<kiIgt</!!! -u<uqhvl<?! Ä]uiaqKz<.ag<}! 59.uK! hg<gk<kqZl<! Äl]iiqg<Gz<.ne<uiI}?!66.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!uf<Kt<tK/!!

! ÄÄ\qbivk<Ks<! osb<gqxuIgt<! gHvitqgtqe<! Lgk<jk! Le<Oeig<gq!okiPjgbqz<!jggm<MuK!Ohiz!jggm<c?!yPr<GliqbijkBme<!fqe<X?!^zil<!%xq?!GINeqzqVf<K!nz<al<K?!Äbi^Q e<}!Lkzqb!^|xig<gjt!Ykq! jg! Wf<kq! KNg<! Ogm<M! \qbivk<! osb<b! Ou{<Ml<}}! we<hkig?!KIVz<! Le<tl<}?! -ke<! ]va|! ^|z<Gz<.Lnt<tl<}?! ]va|! leigqz<!hzia<?!Äxk<Kz<.La<k<kiI}?!!Ge<bk<Kk<!kizqhQe<}?!=ziaqz<.lei^qg<G?!hk<a|z<! gkQ I! ]uiaqKz<ag<! l]iiqg<Gz<! ne<uiI! Lkzqbe!%Xgqe<xe/!!! ÄÄx^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK!

Ole<jlbie! vUzi! ]iQHg<G! N\viuQ I"! kjzlim<Ms<! Sux<xqe<!&jzbqzqVg<Gl<! K~[g<G! &e<X! fie<G! Lpk<! K~vk<kqx<gh<hiz<!liqbijkBmle<!fqx<hQI"!GqHziuqe<!hg<gl<!Lkjgk<!kqVh<hq?!-mK!Hxl<!sx<Xs<!sib<uig!fqx<hQI"!nh<OhiK!nuIgtK!kqVLgl<!-Vg<Gl<!hg<gl<!Ofvig! Le<Oeig<gqbkiGl</! liqbijkBmEl<?! hiqH,v{lie!hbhg<kqBmEl<!fqe<X!ogit<uQ I"!Ole<jllqg<g!-f<kk<kzl<!liqbijkBl<?!hbhg<kqBl<!dt<t!-mlijgbiz<!nkqgs<!slQ hl<!ofVr<gikQ I"!Sux<jxk<!okimikQ I"! gHV!]iQ hqz<! gqHziuqe<! hg<gl<! kr<gtK!Lgk<jk! kqVh<hq!-Vg<Gl<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK!kqVLgk<jk! Rihgh<hMk<kq?! Än^< ziL! njpg<g! bix |zz<zia<}!

we<X!%XuQ I"}!we<hkig?!gHjv!Le<Oeig<gq!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<bg<!%miK!we! upg<gcg<Gl<! %m<mk<kiIgt<! kr<gtK! ohiqb! -lil<?! Gk<H! we<X!Wx<X! yh<Hg<! ogi{<cVg<Gl<! oltzuq! x]QK! na<lK! ogir<OgiaQ!we<huI?! Ä\qh<kk<Kz<.lei^qg<}! we<x! F~zqz<! 255.uK! hg<gk<kqz<?!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<Bl<!Ljxhx<xq!OhSlqmk<kqz<!uqtg<gqBt<tiI/!!



!

!



84

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! lXh<Hg<%XhuIgt<!GVUg<Gl<!lqR<sqb!sQ mIgt<!OhiZl<"!!! ÄÄlgie<gtqe<!abik<kqz<! wu<uiX!yPr<G! liqbijkBme<! fmf<K!ogit<t! Ou{<MOli! nu<uiOx! nuIgtqe<! uhik<kqx<Gh<! hqxGl<?!nuIgjt! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<Bl<! OhiK! ÄnkH}?! yPg<gl<?! liqbijk!Oh[uK! gmjl! ui\qhiGl<}}! we<hkib<?! n]qnk<Kz<.zlNk<?! 2.uK!higl<?!747.uK!hg< <gk<kqz<!j]G!nh<Kz<!ag<G?!Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!%xqbqVg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! NgOu?! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK! ^|e<ek<! oke<hKl<! yPr<G?!liqbijk!Oh[uK!ui\qH!wek<!okiqbuVgqxK/!!! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<Bl<! OhiK! nE]<cg<gh<hm! Ou{<cb! nkH?!yPg<gfqjz! hx<xq?! Ähkiui! Nzl<gQ iqz<}! osiz<zh<hm< <Mt<t! uqhvl<!uVliX;.!!! ÄÄ\qbivk<kqx<Gt<t! Olzie!Ljx;!Lke<! Lkzqz<! klK! uQ m<cz<!

-v{<M! vg<nk<K! fhqz<! okipOu{<Ml</! yu<ouiV! vg<nk<kqZl<?!Änz<al<K}! ^|vk<Kl<?! Nbk<Kz<! GI Q bl<! yu<ouiV! uqMk<kLl<?!Gz<a|uz<zia|! naK?! ^|vk<K! &e<X! uqMk<kr<gTl<! Ykq! -v{<M!vg<nk<Kk<!okiPK!Lcf<kKl<!nke<!kuijhg<!gHvitqg<G!ntqk<Kuqm!Ou{<Ml</! -f<k! nljzg<! ogi{<M! -jxue<! nf<kg<! gHiqz<! ÄF~I}!we<El<! hqvgisk<jk! d{<M! h{<[uKme<?! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<gqe<xuIgTg<Gl<! gqVjh! osb<gqe<xie</! -kx<gh<hiz<! \qbivk<kqe<!hqvbi{k<jk! Olx<ogit<t! Ou{<Ml</! upqbqz<?! nusqblx<xGl<!hqvObi\elx<xKlie! wf<kg<! gVlk<jkBl<! osb<bzigiK/! dzg!sl<hf<klie! wf<k! sl<hi]jebqZl<! hvig<gigg<! %miK/! lg<hxiUg<G!

outqOb!hikvm<jsgjtg<! gpx<xquqmOu{<Ml</!gHiqe<! uzK!hg<gk<kqz<!gqHziuqe<!hg<gl<!LKjgk<!kqVh<hq?!gHvitqbqe<!Lgk<jk!Ofig<gq!fqe<X!^zil<!%xq!Ähik<kqai}!Lkzqbe!Yk!Ou{<Ml<}}!we<hkil</!!! GINe<?!hik<kqai?!^zuik<K!Lkzqbe!Ykq!nux<xqe<!kuijh!gHvitqgTg<Gs<!OsIk<K!juh<hkqz<!-Vuqk!gVk<Kg<gT{<M/!! !

)2*!nuil<gtigqb!!lUk<kig<gTg<G!!nju!!^kg<gi!!djmb!!^<kiek<kqzqVg<gqe<xK/! nux<xqe<! ohiVm<miz<! gHvitqgTg<G! nkiH!-Ozsigqe<xK/!=Omx<xl<?!^zilk<K{<migqe<xK/!

!!! Gpf<jkgt<! ohx<OxiIgjtBl<?!-bzik<ke<jlBt<t!ohx<OxiIgt<!uizqh!lg<gjtBl<! wkqIhiIh<hOk!Ohiz!filEh<Hl<!-k<kjgb!gk<kl<?!hik<kqai?! ^kg<gi! Lkzieux<xqe<! kuiHgjt! nf<kg<! gHvitqgt<!wkqIhiIk<k!u{<{lig!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt</!



!

!



85

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! )3*! ne<hqbi?! nUzqbig<gTg<G! gk<kl<?! hik<kqai?! ^zuik<K?!Lkziejugjt! )Ykq! nux<xqe<! kuijh! nuIgTg<Gs<! OsIk<K!juk<kzieK! ÄKa<hi}! wEl<! gi{qg<jg! osZk<KukiGl</! nux<xq <e<!ohiVm<miz<! nz<zia<! nVt<Hiqgqxie</! Okjugjt! fqjxOux<xqk<!kVgqxie</!!! -k<kjgb! ÄKa<hi}g<! gi{qg<jggjt! nuIgt<!wkqIhiIk<kuIgtz<zI/! weqEl<?! nr<rel<! osb<uK! nuIgjtg<!g{<{qbh<! hMk<KukiGl</! NgOu?! ne<hqbi! nUzqbig<gt<! Ohviz<!gk<kl<?! hik<kqai?! ^zuik<! Lkzqbe! YKuK! Ka<hig<!gi{qg<jgbiGl</!!! ÄÄg{qgt<! fqjxf<k! lvg<ogih<H?! kip<jlbigk<! kjz! guqp<f<K!wr<rel<?! H,lqjb! Ofig<gq! ujtf<K! gqmg<gqe<xOki! nr<reOl?!nxqRIgt<!kip<s<sq!ogi{<M!fmh<hiIgt<}}!we<X!j]G!L^<zqa|k<kQ e<?!^ng<kQ ]Qvi\Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIGt<! ÄgiQli}uqz<!dkiv{r<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!

!! weOu?! \qbivk<kqe<! OhiK! kip<jljbBl<?! gQ p<hckjzBl<!nE]<ch<huIgt<!nkx<Giqb!se<liek<jkh<!ohx<Xg<!ogit<uiIgt</!!! NgOu?! \qbivk<Kg<Gs<! osz<zg<%cbuIgt<! kir<gt<! nE]<cg<g!Ou{<cb!nkH?!yPg<g!Ljxgjtg<!gjmhqcg<g!Ou{<cbK!lqg!lqg!nusqbliGl</!!

gHjv!Lk<klqmzili@!

!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gTjmb! \qbivk<kqx<gigs<! osz<huIgtqz<! sqzI!gHjvObi?! nz<zK! uisx<hcjbObi! Lk<klqMgqxiIgt</! -Khx<xq! yV!%m<mk<kiIgt<!-e<giI!osb<gqe<xiIgt</!-e<giI!osb<ukx<G!-mlqz<jz/!Woeeqz?! nu<uiX! gHjv! Lk<klqMuKl<?! uisx<hcjb!Lk<klqMuKl<!NGlie!giiqbr<gt<!we<hkx<G!Nkivr<gt<!hz!dt<te/!!! ÄÄa\Vz<! n <uK! gz<jz! Lk<klqMujk!Nkivligg<! ogi{<M!îzqaQ e<gTjmb!gHVgjt!hvg<gk<Kjmb!fim<mk<OkiM!Lk<klqmzil<!we<X!NiqhQ e<gtie!dzlig<gt<! sqzI! %Xgqe<xeI}}! we<hkib<?!-lil<!

\ziZk<kQ e<!^|B,k<kq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!Äku]Q a<}!wEl<! F~zqz<! Gxqh<hqMgqxiIgt<! we<hkig! Ä-a<zig<Gz<.ua<aihqb<bQ e<}!we<x!F~zqz<!uf<Kt<tK/!!! a\Vz<! n <ujkh<! hx<xq! fil<! nxqf<kqVg<g! Ou{<cbK!nusqbliGl</!



!

!



86

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! a\<vk<! nlQ Vz<! L0lqeQe<?! dlI! hi'g<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<?! a\Vz<! n <ujk! Lk<klqm<Mg<! ogi{<M?! hqe<H?!sf<Okglqe<xq! fQ! yV! gz</! de<je! Lk<klqMukiz<?! fQ ! fe<jl!osb<uKlqz<jz/! Lk<klqm<miz<! fQ! kQ jl! osb<uKlqz<jz/! fhq! giQl<!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! de<je!Lk<klqmikqVf<kiz<! fie<! de<je! Lk<klqm<cVg<glim<Ome<}}! we<X!%xqeiIgt</!!! -jkg<! Ogm<m! a\<vk<! nzq! gIvlz<zia|! u\<aa|! nuIgt<?!ÄÄ)la<ze<"! bi! dlI*! dlI!nuIgOt"! sx<X! fqkieqBr<gt<"! Fijuh<!Oh[r<gt<"! Lk<klqMukiz<! -f<kg<! gz<! fqs<sbligh<! hqvObi\ek<jkg<!ogiMg<gqe<xK?! Lk<klqmiuqm<miz<! f]<mk<jkg<! ogiMg<gqe<xK}}! we<X!djvk<kiIgt</!!! nuIgtK! nf<kg<! %x<Xg<G! uqtg<gl<! kVl<hcbig! dlI!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Ogm<gOu?! nzq! vzqbz<zia|!

kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!hqe<!uVliX!uqtg<gl<!osie<eiIgt</!!! )-z<zi!leqk<kgk.-e<kI!va<lieq.na<ki*!!! ÄÄva<lieqml<! nXkqliel<! wMk<Kt<tujek<! kuqv}}! we<X!kqVljxbqz<!-jxue<!%xqBt<tke<!gVk<K!biokeqz<?!Ne<l!dzgqz<!fil<! nz<zia<uqml<?! nXkqliel<! osb<k! dXkqh<! hqvli{l<! -f<kg<!gz<zqe<!uibqEt<!jug<gh<hm<cVg<gqxK/!!! )nf<k! nXkqlie! uiIk<jkh<hiM?! wPkh<hm<Mt<t! sk<kqb!

filijuOb! fil<! Lk<klqMgqOxOlbz<ziK! gz<jzbz<z?! fil<! nr<G!gim<Mgqe<x!liqbijk!yPg<gl<!biUl<!gz<Zg<gig!nz<z/!!! ÄÄa\Vz<! n <uK! dzgqz<! nz<zia<uqe<! gvl<! )blQEz<ziaq*!we<hkig!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!kqVuib<!lzIf<kVtqBt<tiIgt</!!! dlI! nuIgOt"! -kx<gh<hiZl<! kir<gt<! -jk! yV! sikiv{g<!gz<kiOe! we<Ox! w{<{qg<! ogi{<cVg<gqxQ Igt<! OhiZl<"}}! we<X! nzq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!djvk<K!uqtg<gqeiIgt</!

!! -u<uglqbl<! dlI! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTg<G!outqh<hm<mKl<?!ÄÄnzq!-z<ziuqm<miz<!dli!azig<gigq!-Vh<hiI}}!we<X!dlI!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!%xqeiIgtil</!!



!

!



87

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! -u<uixie!uqhvl<?!lqIgik<.]va|lq]<gik<!4.l<!higl<!hg<gl<!325/!Ädl<lk<Kz<.giiQ .hQ .]vaq.âQ aqz<.HgiiQ }! higl<.3?! hg<gl<! 377?!Ä-I]iK^<! îiQ .]vaQ .âQ aqz<! HgiiQ}?! higl<.4?! hg<gl<! 267!Ngqbeux<xqZl<!lx<Xl<!hk<a|z<gkQ I?!]va|z<!-eibi!nzz<!aqkibi!Lkzqb!hqg<a|g<!gqvf<kr<gtqZl<!gi{zil</!!! ÄÄgqbilk<K!fitqz<!a\Vz<! n <uKg<G! -V! g{<gt<! -Vg<Gl</!nux<jxg<! ogi{<M! hiIg<Gl</! fiUl<! -Vg<Gl</! ke<je!Lk<klqm<muIgjth<!hx<xq!njkg<!ogi{<M!sim<sq!hgVl<}}!we<X!fhql{q!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! djvk<Kt<tiIgt<!we<hkig! -HE! nh<hi <! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M! -HEli\i! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|?! jhag<gQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!-VuIgTl<!iquibk<Ks<!osb<Kt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<?! ÄÄnK! ke<je! Lk<klqm<muIgjth<! hx<xq! sim<sq! %xq!nuIgTg<gig! ]hink<Kl<! osb<Bl<}}! we<X! dl<Lz<! L0lqeQ e<?!Nbq]i! fibgq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<ai! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M?!

khxieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! iquibk<Ks<!osb<Kt<tiIgt<}}! we<hkig?! nz<zili?! gi\Q ! djhKz<zia<! îaqH!lkxi Q! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! ! nuIgt<?! Ka<hk<Kz <!îbqiQ eqz<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! NgOu! lieqmuIg<gk<kqe<! na<Kfili?! sk<kqb! dXkqh<him<M!iqg<giIjmk<! ke<Et<tmg<gqg<! ogi{<cVg<Gl<! a\Vz<! n <ujk!Lk<klqMujk! Nkivligg<! ogi{<Om?! nf<kg<! gz<jzBl<! uqm!Ole<jlbie! -e< ie<! gilqjzk<! ke<egk<Kt<Ot! nmg<gqh<!ohx<xqVg<gg<! %cb! ÄgHjv}! hvg<gk<jk! fic! Lk<klqMkz<! NGlie!

giiqbOl! we<hKkie<! NiqhQe<gTjmb! osiz<ziGl</! -g<gz<jzg<!ogi{<M!fe<jl?!kQ jl!d{<migg<!%cbkigbqVf<kiz<!nUzqbig<gtqe<!gHVgjt! fz<oz{<{k<KmEl<?! K~b! leKmEl<! hvg<gk<jkg<! gVkq!Lk<klqMukqz<! hqvObi\el<! -z<zilzqz<jz! we<hK! -ke<&zl<!oktquigqxK/!!! lIuie<! lkQ eli! fgiqz<! nkqgiiqbig! -Vf<k! gizk<kqz<! yV!sl<hul<! fjmohx<xK/! âihqgtqz<! yVuvie! nH,JHz<! ne< iiQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjt!fhqgt<!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgTjmb! gHV!]iQ hqe<! lQ K!klK!Lgk<jk!

juk<Kh<!Hvm<cg<!ogi{<cVh<huvig!lIuie<!g{<miI/!!! dmOe?! nuI! nf<k! âihqbqe<! hqmiqjbh<! hqck<Kg<! ogi{<M?!ÄÄfQ I!we<e!giiqbl<!osb<gxQ i!we<hjk!nxquQvi}}!we!uqeuqeiI/!!



!

!



88

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! nf<k!âihq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!lIuieqe<!hg<gligk<! kqVl<hq?! Nl<"! fie<! nxqOue<"! l{<[l<! gz<Zl<!-Vg<Glqmk<kqx<G! fie<! uvuqz<jz/! x^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgtK!se<eqkiek<kqx<G!uf<kqVg<gqOxe<}}!we<X!%xqeiIgt</!!!! -f<fqgp<s<sqjbh<! hx<xqb!Nkivl<! -lil<!na<lK!-HE!al<hz<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK! ÄL <eK}?! 6.uK!higl<! 534.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄfhq! hqvie<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!uQx<xqVf<K! Gk<hi! Ykqg<! ogi{<cVf<K! Älql<hI}! hcjb?! nh<Kz<zia<!-HE! dlI! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! klK! jgbiz<!okim<M!Lk<klqm<Mg<!ogi{<cVf<kiIgt<}}!we<hkib<!]va|]qhi!264.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!osiz<zh<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄj^bqKei!nz<-lil<!aê<?!j^bqKei!nz<-lil<!a|jê<!

vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! -VuIgTl<! uiger<gtqz<!nlIf<kqVh<hjkg<!g{<m!nh<Kz<zia<!-HE!dlI!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTl<!lx<Xl<!sqz!âihig<gTl<!nu<uqVuVl<!giz<gjt!okim<Mg<! ogi{<cVf<k! nr<gucgjt! Lk<klqm<miIgt<}}! we<x! uqhvl<!Äh^<Zz<.gqkih<}?!88.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvbh<hm<cVg<gqe<xK/!!! ÄÄkib<! kf<jkbIgTjmb! gHVgjt! Lk<klqMuK! NGl<!we<hkib<?! hkiui! Nzl<gQ I?! ge<\|z<! -hiK! ]va|! lq]<gik<!Ngqbux<xqz<! uf<Kt<tK! we?! nz<zili! Lh<kQ ! la<&K! îaqH!lkxi Q! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ^|z<Gz<! Lnt<tl<!

we<x! F~zqz<! %Xgqe<xiIgt</! OlZl<?! -lil<! jhag<gQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M?!nz<zili!j]G!nh<Kz<!ag<!Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!ÄkI\|li.lq]<gik<}! 2.uK! higl<?! 744.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! iquibk<Ks<!osb<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! fhq! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!sLgk<kqz<! yVuI! uf<K?! ÄÄfibgOl"! SuIg<gk<K! uisz<hcjbBl<?!a|Vz<=e<! oh{<j{Bl<! Lk<klqMukig! fie<! sk<kqbR<! osb<K!ogi{<Ome</!-kx<Gh<!hiqgivole<e@}}!we<X!uq{<{h<hqk<kiI/!

!! nkx<G?! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<?!ÄÄdeK! kiBjmb! gijzBl<?! kgh<hEjmb! Lgk<jkBl<!Lk<klqm<Mg<ogit"}}!we<X!osie<eiIgt</!!! ÄÄkib<?!kf<jk!-z<ziuqm<miz<!we<e!osb<uK@}}!we<xiI!nuI/!



!

!



89

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! ÄÄdeK! kib<! kf<jkbIgTjmb! gHVgjt! Lk<klqMuibig}}!we<X!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!fuqe<xiIgt</!!! lQ {<Ml<! nuI?! ÄnuIgTjmb! gHVgtqe<! njmbitr<gTl<!gi{h<hmiuqm<miz<!we<e!osb<Oue<}}!we<X!Ogm<miI/!!! nkx<G?! fhqohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<?! ÄÄ-v{<M! OgiMgjtg<! gQ xq! nux<xqz<! ye<jx! ne<jebqe<!gHvigUl<?! lx<oxie<jx! kf<jkbqe<! gHvigUl<! w{<{qg<! ogi{<M! fQ !Lk<klqM"!dlK!sk<kqbk<jk!Lxqg<gikQI"}}!we<xVtqeiIgt</!!! -f<k! akQK! Äge<\|z<.-hiK}?! Äkqz<g<g.n]<vk<Ke<.gilqzi}! Ngqb!F~x<gtqz<!uVgqe<xkig?!oki{<c?!gi\q?!lUziei! lUzuq?!Lal<lK!-^<liqbqz<!îaqH!nuIgt<!djmb!hk<uiuqz<!Gxqh<hqmh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! nf<k! hk<uijus<! siqg{<M?! figh<hm<cel<?! nz<zili! nHz<jgI?!

na<lK!-HxiaQl<!nuIgtK!kf<jk?!oltziei!oltzuq!o^b<bqK!Lal<lK!-HE!gi\i!Lal<lK?!fi%I!geq!kl<hq!we<xjpg<gh<hMl<?!oltziei!oltzuq!Lal<lK!Nzql<!îaqH?!fi%I!kIgi!d^<kiK?!nz<zili! ! ofbqeiI! Lal<lK?! îaqH! NgqbuIgTl<! ÄgHjv!Lk<klqMkz<!NGl<}!we<hkigg<!jgobih<hr<gt<!osb<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! Olx<g{<m! akQK?! Ägqhibk<K]<.]|0lQ }}! zqz<! uVukig?! Lh<k<kQ !jakI]i! ohr<gTiQ ! nuIgt<! ÄKz<hgiI.jakiqb<bi}! 24:.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!

! ÄÄuqk<kivlie!se<liIg<g!RieLjmb!-lil<!^|h<gQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! -lil<! fuuQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgtK!gizch<hm<m!-mk<jk!Lk<klqMl<!hig<gqbl<!ohx<OxOe!we<X!Nef<kk<Kme<! %xqg<! ogi{<Om! nf<k! -mk<kqz<! kr<gtK! Lgk<jk!juk<K!Lk<kq!Lgf<K!Hvm<ceiIgt<}}!we<hkib<?!h^<Zz<.gqk<kiH!:9.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?!hk<a|z<LbQ e<!djmb!]va|!-Nei?!2.uK!higl<?!29.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!uf<kqVg<gqe<xK/!!! Ähvg<gk<jk!fic!gHjv!Lk<klqMlz<!fie<G!lKahqe<!hqvgivLl<!NGlieOg}}!we<X!nz<zili!j]G!nh<Kz<!geq!fihz< Q !Lag<gqG?!

aehq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! Ä\l<dz<! n <xiiqz<!%Xukig?! nz<zili! j]G! B,SHe<ehaieq! lq <iQ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! ]uiaqKz<.ag<! 67.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!ujvgqe<xiIgt</!! ÄÄgHjv! uibiz<! Lk<klqMuKl<?! gvk<kiz<! okim<M! Lk<kq!LgVuKl<!NGl</!nu<uqkl<! osb<uK!îzqaQ e<gtie!dzlig<gtqe<!



!

!



90

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

osbziGl<}}! we<X! a\<vk<?! nz<zili?! ]ia<! na<lK! ^bQ K?!L\k<kqKk<kqa<zuQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!ka<gQg<Gz<!ag<gqz<.LhQ e<!44.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqe<!gHVgjt!hvg<gk<jk!fic!Lk<klqMuK!NGl<!we! ohVl<hizie! -lil<gt<! %xqBt<tiIgt<}}! we<hkig! nz<zili?!j]G! B,SHe<! ehaieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!Ä]uiaqKz<!ag<}!68.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!osiz<Zgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄuzqliIgtqe<!gHVgjt!hvg<gk<jk!fic!Lk<klqMuK!NGli@}}!we<X!nz<zili!-lil<!Lal<lK!gzQzQ !lg<k^Q ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtqml<!Ogm<gh<hm<mOhiK?! ÄÄnh<hcs<!osb<uK!uqzg<gh<hm<m!giiqblz<z?! NGlie! giiqbOl}}! we<X! hkqz<! osiz<zqBt<tiIgt</!-u<uqhvl<?!hkiui.gzQzQ !3.uK!higl<!361.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!gi{zil</!!! GINje! Lk<klqMuKl<?! akQ KgTjmb! hGkqgjt!Lk<klqMuKl<?! îzqaQ e<gTjmb! gHVgjt! Lk<klqMuKl<!

NgliejugOt}}! we<X! -lil<! -HE! nhQ j^H?! wleQ ?! ]ihqbQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M!nxquqg<gh<hm<cVh<hkig?! j]Gz<! - <zil<?! aihqT?! -lil<! -HE!a\I! n <gzieQ ?! ]ihqbQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!âQa|z<.HgiiQ !bqe<!]va|gqkihigqb?!hk<a|z<.hiiQ?!4.uK!higl<?!41:.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄfqs<sblig! sqz! îzqaQe<gt<! GINe<! ]iQjhh<!hiIh<hiIgOtbieiz<!njk!Lk<klqMuiIgt<?!akQ K!]iQhqe<!hGkqgjth<!hiIh<hiIgOtbieiz<! njk! Lk<klqMuiIgt<?! îzqaQe<gtqe<! gHV!

]iQHgjtg<! g{<miz<! nux<jx! Lk<klqMuiIgt<}}! we<X! j]Gz<!-^<zil<?!-lil<!hKVk<kQ e<?!la<&K!JeQ !aehQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!Ädl<kk<Kz<giiQ .hQ .]vaqâQ aqz<!HgiiQ}?!5.uK!higl<?!718.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!wMk<kxquqk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄGINe<! ]iQ jhBl<?! fhqgt<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgTjmb!gHV!]iQjhBl<?!ne<hqbi!nUzqbig<gTjmb!gHV! ]iQ HgjtBl</! Lk<klqMuKl<?! dzlig<gt<?! îzqaQ e<gt<?! kib<!kf<jkbIgt<! LkzqbuIgjth<! Ohie<xuIgTjmb! jg! giz<gjt!Lk<klqMuKl<!^|e<ek<kiGl<}}!we<X!-lil<!-HE!nhq^<!j^H!bleQ !

vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Ohie<x! ]ihQ! lKaHjmb!-lil<gt<! osiz<zq! -Vh<hkig?! nz<zili?! nz<ai\<?! nz<Lh<kQ ?!Lal<lK! klQl<! îaqH! lk<xi Q! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! Ädl<kk<K^<.^qh<bie<}! 392.l<! hg<gk<kqe<! ai]qbiuqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!



!

!



91

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqe<! xUzi! gHV! ]iQ hqe<! uisz<hcjb! hvg<gk<jk!NkvU!juk<K!Lk<klqMuK!lg<'a<!we<hK!gqjmbiK/!nK!NGlie!giiqbOl}!we<X!-lil<!]l<Sk<kQe<! xlzQ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!hk<ui!ogiMk<kqVh<hkib<?! Äfqaibk<Kz<!La<k<ki\<.hQ .]vaqz<.lqe<ai\<}?! 3.uK! higl<! 329uK! hg<gk<kqz<! gi{g<! gqjmg<gqe<xK/!Äfqaibi}! uqz<! uVgqxkig?! ]ia<! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! îaqH! OuZ~iQ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! h <Zz<.gqk<kiH! 226.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqm<M?!hz!Nkivr<gTme<!uqiquigg<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! Ähvg<gk<jk! fic! gHVgjtBl<?! nux<xqe<! uisx<hcgjtBl<!Lk<klqMuK!lg<'a<!ne<xqOb!NGl<}!we<X!nz<zili!F~Vk<kQ e<!lq^<iQ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! hzlie! hk<ui!uqMk<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! nz<zili! lGK~l<! ai\Q! Lal<lK! ai]ql<! ^qf<kQ ! aehQ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! aq\<iq! hkqOeivil<!F~x<xi{<cZt<tuIgt</! -uIgt<! akQ K?! hqg<a|g<gjtk<!

kqvm<cbqVh<hKme<?!]va|gTl<!wPkqBt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqe<! gHVgjtBl<?! nux<xqe<! uisx<hcgjtBl<!hvg<gk<kqx<gig! Lk<klqmzili@}}! we<X! nuIgtqmk<kqz<! uqeuh<hm<m!OhiK?!ÄÄnu<uqkl<!osb<uK!NGl<!we<hOk!liIg<gk<kqe<!kQIh<Hl<?!hzlie!osiz<ZliGl<}}!we<X!uqjmbtqk<kiIgt</!!! -u<uixig! Lh<kQ ?! jakI?! ]ia<! gikqiQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! ÄKz<hgiI.jakiqb<bi}! 256.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqMgqe<xiIgt</!

!! ÄÄyzqliIgTjmb! uisx<hcgjt! Lk<klqMuK! nuIgjts<!sr<jgh<! hMk<KukiGl<}}! we<X!Gk<uk<Kz<!NiqhQ e<?!-lil<!L <k<khz<.hg<iQ .aehQ.kql]<g<gQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Äzl<d.hIg<gqz<.lgilk<}kqz<! osiz<zqBt<tiIgt<! we<hkig! nz<zili! j]G!B,SHe<ehaieQ ! lq <iq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?!]uiaqKz<.ag<G?!365.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!nxquqk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqe<! gHVgjt! nz<zK! nux<xqe<! uisx<hcgjt!Lk<klqMuK! ÄkuiTd}! we<El<! h{quie! yPg<gk<OkiM! %cb!

liqbijkjbs<! siIf<kkiGl</}}! we<X! nz<zili! o^b<bqK!]ia<Laqb<bqk<kQe<!îaqH!NiqHhqz<zia<!gikqiQ !OuZ~iQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! h <Zz<.gqkiH! :9.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!



!

!



92

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqe<! kVgig<gTg<Gs<! ose<X! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<b!Ohigqe<xuI?!nf<k!nUzqbig<gtqe<!uhik<kqx<G!Le<H!wu<utU!ofVr<gq!fqx<gg<!%MOli!nu<utUg<G!nuIgTjmb!vUzi!]iQ Hg<Gs<! slQhligq!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK! ^|e<ek<kiGl</! nuIgTjmb! uisx<hcgjtk<!khIVg<Gjmb! fim<mk<OkiM! Lk<klqmzil</! o^b<bqK! na<lK! hkuQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! kIgiuqz<! fjmohx<X! uVuK!Ohiz<! N[l<! oh{<[l<! gzf<k! sf<kcbib<! uisx<hcjb! Lk<klqm!-bziuqm<miz<?! %m<ml<! gjzgqe<x! ujvbqz<! keg<G! Ykk<! okiqf<k!lm<cz<! bikiuK! Ykqg<ogi{<Om! gik<K! fqe<X! nh<hiz<! Lk<klqmzil</!!%m<ml<! gjzukig! -z<jz! we<xiz<! keK! jgjb! ogi{<Omi?!jgbqZt<t! nî! gl<jhg<! ogi{<Omi! Lk<klqMuK! Ohiz! slqg<jg!osb<uKl<!NGl<}}!we<hkig!ai]qbk<Kz<! .!hi\|iq?!2.uK!higl<!429.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! uqiquig<g! gi{h<hMgqe<xK/! fqaibiuqe<! ai]qbk<K!j]G!nzQ !]qh<xilz< Q ?! 3.uK! higl<?! 329.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<! osiz<zh<!ohx<xqVg<gqe<xK/!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gtqe<! gHVgjt! hvg<gk<jk! fic! Lk<klqMuK!

lg<'a<! nz<z?! nK! NGlieOk}}! we<X! -lil<! xlzQ! ]ihqbQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!-lil<!o]b<G!Lal<lK!]u<hiQ !]ihqbQ !lq <iQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTl<! hkui!ogiMk<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! -u<uiOx! Ka<hiuqe<! ai]qbi! ]IuieQ ?! hqg<bi?! hkiui!^|jzliEz<!GIkQ!NgqbjugTl<!%Xgqe<xe/!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gt<?! d <k<kiKliIgt<! NgqbuIgTjmb! gHVgjt!hvg<gk<jk!fic!okim<M!Lk<klqMuK!lg<'a<!nz<z?!nju!NGlie!

giiqbr<gOt}}! we<hkib! Äai]qbk<Kz<! -\<eid}uqz<! uVgqe<xK!we<hkig?! Ole<jlg<Giqb! lih<hqt<jt! ozh<jh! Nzql<! we<X! ohbI!uqtr<Gl<!nz<zili!o^b<bqK!Lal<lK!îaqH!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! Ähk<a|k<jkbie<}! 294.uK! hg<gk<kqZl</! ÄlgieQ }! 299.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!nxquqk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄuzqliIgTjmb! gHVgjt! hvg<gk<jk! fic! Lk<klqMuK?!ÄÄL0k<klK}}! dXkqbie! osix<hc?! lg<'a<! we<hK! gqjmbiK?! nK!NGlieOk}}!we<X!nzzili?!j]G?!Sjzlie<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!Äai]qbk<Kz<!.!Hj\vlQ!.!nzi]vaqz<.lqe<!ai\<}?!

2.uK!higl<?!659.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄgHVgjt! Lk<klqMuK! lg<'a<! we<X! -HE! a\I!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! osiz<zqbqVh<hqEl<!yzqliIgTjmb! hvg<gk<jk! fic! Lk<klqMuK! lg<'a<! -e<xq! %Ml<!we<hOk! ÄL0k<klK}! wEl<! dXkqbie! osiz<ziGl<}}! we<X! hi^qz<!



!

!



93

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

hIliuQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!%Xgqe<xiIgt<!we<hkig!ÄGa<Zz<.dB,e<.hQ .khbq]<.]qh<aq.ut<TE~e<}?! 66.uK! hg<gk<kqz<!ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! GINe<! ]iQjhk<! kuqIk<K?! ne<hqbig<gTjmb! gHVgjtBl<?!wuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! hvg<gk<Kk<! Okmh<hMOli! nuIgTjmb!gHVgjtBl<!Lk<klqMl<!uq]bk<kqz<!sqzI!NGole<Xl<?!sqzI!lg<'a<!we<Xl<! osiz<gqe<xiIgt</! Neiz<! Ole<jlg<Giqb! -lil<! Lal<lK!-KiQ |]<! ]ihqbQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?!khIVg<Gjmb! fim<mk<OkiM! gHjv! Lk<klqMkz<! NGl<! we<X! %xq!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! -lil<! JeQ! aehQ ?! -lil<! \l<a|k<kq! ]ihqbQ ?! -lil<! LgqIiQ !lizqgQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! NgqObiVl<?! -e<El<!dzlig<gtqz<! yV! %m<mk<kiVl<! -lil<! ]ihqbQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! -s<osiz<jz! dXkqh<hMk<kq! nr<gQ givl<!osb<Kt<tiIgt</!

!! ÄÄkhIVg<Gjmb! fqb<bk<jkg<! ogi{<M! gm<Mh<hMk<kh<!ohx<xqVh<hkiz<! lg<'a|g<G! -mlqz<jz! )-e<elz<! n0liZ!hqe<eqb<bik<*! nlz<gotz<zil<! w{<{k<jkh<! ohiXk<OkBt<te}}! wEl<!uqhvl<! Äkuiuqdz<! .! ne<uiI! .! ]va|KIVz<! Lg<kiiqz<}! uVukig!ÄKz<hgiI.jakiqb<bi}!247?!248.uK!hg<gr<gtqz<!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! a\<vk<! -liLz<! n0tl<! nH,aeQhi! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtK!sQ mVl<?!aehq!lKahqe<!L\<k<kaqKligqb!a\<vk<!-lil<!Lal<lK!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M?!

ouizqliIgTjmb!gHVgjt!Lk<klqMkz<! %Ml<! we<hK!^<kqvlig<gh<!ohx<xqVh<hkiz<?! aehqb<big<gTg<G! -Khzlie! nk<kim<sqbiGl</! -K!uq]bk<kqz<! wuVl<! -e<giI! osb<b! -mlqz<jz! we<hkig! Lh<k<kQ!o^b<bqK!]ia<! gikqiQ ! ohr<gTiQ ! nuIgt<! ÄKz<hgiI.jakiqb<bi}uqz<!ujvgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄdgh<HjmbuIgtqe<! gqVjhjbh<! ohx<Xg<! ogit<ukx<gig! fhq!ohVlieI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgTjmb!uisz<hcjb!fie<!Lk<klqMgqOxe<}}!)dgh<hqZz<.ndk<kih*!we<X!-lil<!g^< izq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! -bx<xqbkigs<!

osiz<zh<hMl<!Ä^|HaielUzQ K!]iQ hqz<}!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!! ÄÄwl<! ohVlieiI! Lal<lk<! L <k<khi! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq!u^z<zl<! nuIgtK! kqVOleqjbh<! ohikqf<Kt<t! l{<{qe<!fXl{k<kqx<G!wf<k!l{Ll<!fqgvig!lim<miK?!nfkh<!Heqk!Okgk<jkh<!ohikqf<Kt<t! l{<j{! Lk<kq! Lgf<kuVjmb! hig<gqbOl! hig<gqbl<"}}!)zik<kQh! .! b0kqZ! .! KIhe<! .! tll! .!n0Tla|*! wehkig!-lil<!



!

!



94

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

Lal<lK!H,îQ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! HIki!]iQhqz<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<?! ]va|h<Hzq?! ^kgKz<ziaqz<! giaqiQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! uqk<iqb<biuqz<?! Äîk<}! djmb! hGkqbqz<?!)ai\k<!.!zq!.!kg<hQzq!.!gh<iqaQ !.!u!.!gh<iq!.!nhQ hg<iqe<!.!u!.!gh<iq!.!nhQ! .! ah<^qe<*?! ÄÄklqObEjmb! NjsbieK! nVjl! fhq!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgTjmb!gHjvBl<?!nH,hg<gI!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTjmb!gHjvBl<!nH,ah< <!wEl<!ohbVjmb! dlI! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTjmb!gHjvBl<! Lk<klqmOu{<Mole<X! njz! Olikq! KcKck<Kg<!ogi{<cVg<gqxK}}!we<hkig!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄNkq! Lkz<! nf<kl<<! ujv! wu<uqkk<! kqjvBl<! ljxUlqe<xq!gi{Ou{<Mlieiz<!nUzqbig<gTjmb!l{<j{!SIliuigg<!g{<{qz<!kQm<c! Ofk<kqv! O\ikqjbh<! ohx<Xg<! ogit<uQIgtig}}! we<X! oltziei!Lal<lK! \ziZk<kQ e<! 'lq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!

Äl^<euq.]iQhqz<!hgIf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gTjmb! gHVgjt! d{<jlbie!fz<oz{<{k<KmEl<?! gzh<hx<x! fqI{bk<KmEl<?! K~b<jlbie!leKmEl<! fQ ! Lk<klqMuibieiz<?! nf<k! nUzqbi! lQ K! sk<kqblig!deg<G!hik<kqe<!djmb!F~I!)nf<kvr<g!O\ikqh<!hqvgisl<*!d{<miGl<}}!we<X! -lil<! \u< q! Lak<kqK! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgtK! sQ mI?! j]G! ^0fQ ! ]Q vi^q! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<!Ohi^<k<kieqe<!djvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!

! -ju! fqx<g?! ÄÄ-lil<gtqe<! Ä-\<lid}! WOgihqk<k!nhqh<hqviblqz<zik?!gVk<K!Oux<Xjl! )gqziH*!dt<t!l <nzig<gtqe<!Ohiqz<! -e<giI! osb<K?! Gx<xr<Gjx! %XuKl<?! uqzg<GuKl<?! liIg<gs<!sm<mOljkgtie!ÄHgai}g<gtqe<!d^|z<!wEl<!liIg<g!nch<hjm!upq!Ljxs<sm<mh<hc! %miK}}! we<hkigg<!Gxqh<hqm<M?! ÄÄîBe<g<gV.-z<zi.li.d\<lqn.nzi.le<bqaQ }}! wEl<! Ogim<him<jm! Olx<Ogitig?! nz<zili!Lh<k<kQ ! la<&K! siaqH! lk<xi Q ! nuIgt<?! Ähk<a|z<! ag<}?! 9:.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!nk<kim<sqbig!wMk<Kg<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! -Khx<xqBl<?!-jkh<Ohie<x!sqg<gzie!hz!l^<nzig<gt<!hx<xqBl<!

uqiquig?! hR<sih<?! Z~kqbieiuqZt<t/! gi\Q h\<Z! na<lK! aehQ ?!fg<]hf<kQ! nuIgt<! -V! higr<gtig! wPkqb! Äne<uiOv.Nh<k<kioh.^kigk<}!wEl<!F~zqz<!wPkqBt<tiIgt</!-f<kg<!gqkijh!siqg{<M!hz!DigtqZt<t! 77! hqvhz<blie!dzlig<gt<! jgobih<hl<! osb<Kt<teI/!nuIgTt<! sr<jgg<Giqb! lQ vm<! oltziei! nh<Kz<! nzQ l<! ^qk<kQ g<gQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTl<!yVuI/!



!

!



95

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! gHVgjt! Lk<klqMl<! uq]bk<kqz<! sqz! dzlig<gt<! nhqh<hqvib!Ohkr<ogi{<Mt<teI/! abik<OkiMt<t! lgie<gtqmk<kqz<! yPg<gl<!liqbijkjbh<! Oh{qBl<?! hbhg<kqjbg<! ogi{<Ml<!nuIgTg<G!lqgUl<!slQhk<kqz<! ofVr<gqbqVh<hKlqz<jz/! nuIgjtk<! okim<Mh<!OhSuKlqz<jz/! sx<X! nge<X! fqe<X! sl<hi]qh<hK! kie<! yPg<gLl<?!liqbijkBliGl</! nu<uqklqe<xq! lx<x! silieqblieuIgTme<!hpGuKOhiz! lgie<gtqml<! fmf<K! ogit<uK! ouXg<gk<kg<gkiGl</!nf<k! lgie<gt<! uhik<kqx<Gh<! hqxGl<! abik<Kt<tuIgt</! nuIgt<!\qbivk<Ks<! osb<b! uVgqe<xuIgjt! nxqgqe<xiIgt<?! ^zil<!osiz<ZgqxuIgTg<Gh<! hkqZl<! %Xgqe<xiIgt</! gHVgtqz<! nuIgt<!okiPK!ogi{<Ml<?!a\<\|!osb<K!ogi{<Ml<!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt</!NgOu?!\Q uqbk<kqz<! fmf<K! ogi{<mKOhizOu! lv{k<kqx<gh<hiZl<! fmf<K!ogit<uKkie<!yPg<gLl<!liqbijkBliGl</!!! gHVgTg<Gs<!sx<X!nge<X!fqe<X!K~vk<kqzqVf<Ok!hbhg<kqObiMl<?!nkH.yPg<gk<OkiM<l<! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<uKkie<! yPg<g! LjxbiGl<!

we<hOk! nf<k! dzlig<gtqe<! nf<kvr<g! Ofig<gliGl</!-f<Ofig<gk<KmOeOb! uibiOzi?! gvk<kiOzi! okim<M! Lk<klqMkz<!Älg<'a<}! ouXg<gk<kg<gK! we<hK! kie<! sqz! dzlig<gtqe<!nhqh<hqvibOlbz<ziK?!hvg<gk<jk!fic!Lk<klqMkz<!NgiK!we<hkz<z/!!! \Q uqb! gizk<kqz<! lgie<gjts<! sf<kqg<g! sf<kIh<hl<! Wx<hMl<OhiK!hvg<gk<jkfic!nuIgtqe<!hikr<gjtk<!okim<M!Lk<kqg<!ogit<gqe<Oxil</!gvr<gjth<! hqck<Kg<! g{<gtqz<! yk<kq! uibiz<! Lk<klqMgqe<Oxil</!nl<lgie<gtqe<! uhik<kqx<Gh<! hqxGl<! nOk! w{<{k<Kme<! hvg<gk<jk!fic! nuIgtK! gHV! ]iQHgjtBl<?! nux<xqe<! uisz<hcgjtBl<!

gvk<kiz<! okim<Omi?! okiMuKOhiz<! slqg<jg! osb<Oki! Lk<klqMkz<?!fz<oziPg<g! liqbijkjbs<! siIf<kOk! we<hK! ohVl<hizie!dzlig<gtqe<!nhqh<vibliGl</!!! weOu?! OlOz! g{<m! Nkivr<gjtg<! ogi{<M! hvg<gk<jk! fic!gHVgjt! lm<Mlz<z?! nux<jxs<! siIf<k! uisz<hcgjtBl<?!ohiqbiIgtK! gizchm<m! -mr<gjtBl<! Lk<klqmzil<! we<x! uqhvl<!Ge<xqe<! Olzqm<m! kQ hl<! Ohiz! uqtr<gg<! gqmg<gqe<xK/! -k<ke<jlbqz<!nu<uiX! osb<uK! %miokeg<! %XhuIgt<! d{<jlgjt!&cljxk<OkiviuiIgt</!

!ogic!Wx<xzili@!

!! gl<hk<kqz<! hxg<Gl<! ogicg<G! nzl<! .! fq]ie<! .! \{<mi!we<oxz<zil<! %xh<hMgqe<xK/! fhqgm<Ogilie<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<! OhiILjegTg<Gg<! ogicgTme<! ose<xqVh<hkiBl<!



!

!



96

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

âihig<gt<! Bk<kr<gTg<Gs<! osz<Zjgbqz<! nuIgTg<G! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! ogicgt<! ogiMk<kEh<hqbkiBl<?!oux<xqgTg<Gh<!hqxG!nf<k!-mr<gtqz<!gl<hr<gtqz<!ogicgjth<!hxg<g!uqm<mkiBl<?! lg<gi! fgjv! hk<a|! osb<K! hqck<kKl<! fhqgt<! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! âihig<gt<! sgqkl<!out<jtg<! ogicBme<! hqvOusqk<kkigUl<! Ä-HE! li\i}uqz<! -HE!nh<hi^<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M!iquibk<Ks<!osb<bh<hm<cVh<hKme<!lq]<gik<!]iQ hqZl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! avjleq]<! ]iQ jheqgtqe<! GzhiOb! xi]qkQe<gt<! djmb!dI^|! fim<gtqz<! ogicgt<! Wx<xh<hMukig?! hqvhz<b! dzlig<gt<!jgobih<hlqm<m! Ähk<ui.F~I.ka<gQ g<gik<}kqZl<?! ÄKz<hgiI!jakiqb<bi}uqZl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄouizqBjmb! gHV! we<hjkbxqf<K! biuVl<! \qbivk<Ks<!osb<uiIgt<! we<x! w{<{k<Kme<! Nr<G! ogic! lvl<! fm<MuK! NGl</!nkx<gigs<!oszU!osb<uK!uQ {qz<jz}}!we<X!-lil<!ki]|k<kQ e<!-HE!

\g<giqb<bi?!fg<]hf<kQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!-bx<xqb?!ÄÄg]<Ht<.Tzli! hQ.hbieq.hqIgi.aikqaqz<.dl<li}}! wEl<! F~zqz<!uVgqxK!we<hkig!gibz<!hkqbqz<!hqxf<K!gQ pg<gjvbqz<!nmr<gqbqVg<Gl<!lgiEhiuI! lih<hqt<jt! ozh<jh! NzQ l<! we<x! nz<zilKz<! hitqz<?!j]Gz<! o^b<bqK! Lal<lK! gikqiQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<?!ÄgeQ lk<K^<.îzqg<gQe<}!we<x!gqvf<kk<kqz<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! Gk<Hz<! ng<hI/! o^b<bqKei! nHz<aê<! ]iKzQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! uigek<kqz<! nlIf<K! osz<Zr<giz<?! nVt<!kr<gqb! ohiqbiIgTl<?! Jsuiqbl<! hjmk<k! nkqhIgTl<! nuIgjts<!

$p<f<K!osz<uiIgt</!ogicgt<!nuIgtK!kjzg<G!Olz<!hqcg<gh<hMl</!ÄÄGk<jhh<! hiIg<g! fiMgqxuI! ]iKzQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjth<! hx<xqh<! hqck<Kg<ogit<uivig}}?! we<X! %Xl<hc! gm<cbr<!%XgqxuVg<G! dk<kqvU! osb<uiIgt<! we<hkig?! \ilqdz<.d^|z<!gqvf<kk<kqz<!94.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! ÄÄ\er<gt<!upg<glig!osb<KuVl<!gVlk<jkg<!Gxqh<higk<!kMh<hK!%miK}}!we<Xl<?!!! ÄÄuqzg<gz<! -z<zik! gVlk<jks<! osb<uK! NGl<}}! we<Xl<!

nz<zili?! -lil<?! JIg<g]Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!lh< |k<kqz<!ujvgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄGINjeg<! ogi{<Omi?! akQ jkg<! ogi{<Omi?! âihig<gtqe<!osix<gjtg<!ogi{<Omi?!-lil<gtqe<!user<gjtg<!ogi{<Omi!uqzg<gz<!uvik! yV! gVlk<jks<! osb<uK!NGlieOk}}! we<X! nz<zili!-lil<!



!

!



97

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

-HE!a|lil<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt</!hk<a|z<.gkQI?!2.uK!higl<?!495.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! GINe<?!akQ K?!-\<liUg<G!lix<xlqz<ziK!\er<gt<!upg<glib<s<!osb<KuVl<! gVll<! NGl<! we<hK! nxqbg<gqmg<gqe<xK/! ÄÄL <zql<gt<!wokjk!npgigg<!g{<miIgOti!nK!nz<zia<uqmk<kqZl<!npgieK}}!we<X! âQ aie!akQK?! Lnk<kiuqz<! -HE! l <DK! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M!iquibk<Ks<!osb<bh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! -u<jubgk<kqz<! l{<{ijs! hqck<k! dzg! le<eIgt<! Ohiiqm<M!Ogicg<g{g<gie! ohiVt<gjt! uqvbR<! osb<K! -zm<sg<g{g<gie!leqkIgtqe<! dbqIgjth<! Ohig<gq?! oux<xqbjmf<kkx<G! nxqGxqbig!ogicObx<X!uqpig<gt<!fjmohx<X!uVujkBl<!Skf<kqvl<!njmf<k!Sh!Oskqg<gig! ogicObx<X! juhur<gt<! fmk<kh<hMujkBl<! g{<! %migg<!gi{<gqe<Oxil</!-ux<xqx<G!Lx<xqZl<! lix<xlig! fH^|me<! OhiI! Hiqf<K?!Lu<uijsk<!okimIHl<?!Ll<lzh<!hx<Xl<!uqm<M!Lx<Xk<!Kxf<K?!-HzQ |?!Keqbiuqe<! ncjlk<! kjtgjtobz<zil<! fQ r<gq! Nk<liIk<k! Skf<kqvl<!

njmf<k! o\boux<xq! uQ vIgtigqb! likuh<! HvmIgtie!nUzqbig<gTjmb! dI^|! kqer<gtqz<! ogicObx<XuK! \ibq <! .!NGlieOk! we<hK! oktquigk<! okiqb! uVgqe<xK/! -K! NGl<!we<hkx<G! nkqg! uqiquie! hz! Nkivr<gTme<! oltziei! nz<zili!Lx<gizk<kqb!hqvkl!Lh<k<kQ ?!o^b<bqK!jakI!]ia<!gikqiqb<bq!aehQ!ohr<gTiQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ÄÄKz<hgiI!jakiqb<bi}}uqz<!ujvf<kqVf<gqxiIgt</!!! weOu?! npqf<KOhigg<%cb!dzgk<kqe<! nvsIgTg<Gl<! nvsqbz<!kjzuIgTg<Gl<! leLuf<K! ogicObx<x! -jshuIgt<?! npqux<x!

nz<zia<uqe<! OfsIgtigqb! nUzqbig<gTg<G! lgqjl! ogiMk<K!ogicObx<x!hqe<ejmuK!OhkjlbiGl<"!!!!

dI^|?!gf<K~iq!fmk<kzili@!!! ]|aki?! nUzqbig<gt<! we<Xl<! \Q uEt<tuIgt<?! hbOli!sR<szOli!nuIgTg<gqz<jz?!-l<jlbqZl<!lXjlbqZl<!nuIgTg<Gs<!

Shl<! d{<M! we<hkib<g<! GINEl<?! akQKl<! %Xgqe<xe/! nk<kjgb!lgie<gt<!uhik<kie!fim<gjt!dI <!kqer<gtig!dzgl<!ogi{<mic!uVgqe<xK/!

!!



!

!



98

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

)dk<GV.lai^qe.lu<k<kig<Gl<*!!! ÄÄdr<gTt<! lv{qk<kuIgtqe<! gQ Ik<kqh<! hqvkihr<gjt! fQ r<gt<!hqv^<kihR<! osb<K! ogit<uQ Igtig}}! we<X! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!nVtqb!akQ jk!nH,kiU,Kl<?!kqIlkqBl<!%Xgqe<xe/!!! fibgl<! x^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!]|akig<gTjmb!gHV!]iQ Hgjt!\qbivk<Ks<!osb<ukx<gig!uVmf<OkiXl<! Ohib<! uf<kkigUl<! nVjl! âihig<gTl<! nu<uiOx!ose<X! uf<kkigUl<! akQ Kgtqz<! uf<kqVh<hkig! -lil<! ^|B,k<kq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!Äkh< Q I!KIV!le<K~iqZl<}!-lil<!-HE! a\I! lg<gQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! a| <E.ku <^|zqZl<! ujvf<kqVh<hkib<?! oltziei!oltzuq!Lal<lK! fkQ I!na<lK! gie<siaqH! na<lkihikQ ?! G\vik<kQ ! nuIgt<?! Äl\<&nk<KI.vîbqz<! .! hQ! .! ka<gQ g<gqz<! .! lîbqz<?! 35uK! hg<gk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqm<cVg<gqe<xiIgt</!

! !! OlZl<?! -lil<! -HE! NhqkQ e<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! xk<Kz<!La<k<kiI?! 2uK!higl<?! 776uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?!-lil<!-HE!a|lil<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<?!kh< Q I!ghQiqZl<!wMk<Kjvk<Kt<tkib<!nz<zili!o^b<bqK!nlQ I!nzuQ !n\<lQiq!nuIgt<?!Ä-a<zig<!Gz<!ua<aihqb<bQ eqz<}!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! -e<El<?! \ziZk<kQ e<! ^|B,k<kq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<?! kh< Q I! KIV! .! le<K~iqz<?! ÄÄfQ r<gt<! )dr<gt<! uip<g<jgbqz<!g]<mr<gjth<*!ohiXjlBme<!sgqk<Kg<ogi{<m!giv{lig!dr<gTg<Gs<!

sif<kqBl<?! slikieLl<! d{<miGg"! )dr<gTjmb*! gjmsq! uQ M! lqg<g!fz<zkibqx<X"!)we<X!osiIg<guikqgjt!Ofig<gq!lzg<Ggt<!%XuiIgt<*}}!we<x! 24;35! Nbk<kqe<! gQ p<?! ne <! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! -HE! LekqV! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTl<?!-HE!lIkuqb<bi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTl<!iquibk<Ks<!osb<Kt<tiIgt<!weh<!hqe<uVliX!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!! ÄÄx^|Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!yu<ouiV!uVmLl<!daK!ljzg<G!uf<K!nr<Gt<t!]|akig<gTg<G!^zil<! %xq! fQ r<gt<! Olx<ogi{<m! Olzie! ohiXjlbqe<! ohiVm<miz<!fQ r<gt<! ohx<xqVg<gqe<x! osiIg<g! uQ Om! Olzil<hvlie! uQ M! we<X!

djvh<hiIgt<}}!we<hkig/!!! OlOz!g{<m!uq]bk<jkBl<!ujvf<K!-u<uiOx!nH,hg<gI?!dlI?!dKlie<?!nzq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|l<! NgqbuIgTl<! osb<K!uf<kiIgt<! we<hkib<!Lal<lK!-HE!-HviaQ l<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgjtg<!ogi{<M?!-HE!\iQ I!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!



!

!



99

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

nuIgt<! iquibk<Ks<! osb<Kt<tiIgt</! -e<eLl<! hik<kqli! fibgq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<ai!nuIgt<?!nh<Kz<!Lk<kzqHjmb!GlivI!al< i! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTjmb! gh<Vg<G!uVmf<OkiXl<! uf<k! \qbivk<K! osb<kiIgt<! we<Xl<?! nu<upg<gk<jkk<!okimIf<K! nE]<ck<K! uf<kiIgt<! we<Xl<! iquibk<Ks<!osb<bh<hm<cVg<gqe<xe/!!! -K!Ohie<x!-lil<!xi^Q ?!nH, |DK?!-HE!gkQ I!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!NgqbuIgTjmb!kh< QigtqZl<!%xh<hm<cVg<gqe<xe/!!! nz<zili!j]G!na<lK!-HE!Lal<lK!hi'g<gQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! Äku<tQa|z<a|ki}uqz<! osiz<zqBt<tkig!hk<a|z<!ag<!%XukiuK;.!!! ÄÄnz<zia<uqe<! dgh<Hg<Gs<! osif<klie! fz<zcbiIgt<?!dzlig<gt<?! j]GliIgt<! NgqObiVjmb! gHVgtqz<! %m<mligg<!%cbqVg<g! fil<! g{<cVg<gqe<Oxil</! nu<uiX! Nr<G?! nuIgt<!

%cbqVg<Gl<! giv{l<! GINe<?! hik<kqai! YkUl<?! KNg<gt<! Ogm<gUl<?!kQeqb<bk<Ks<! sl<hf<klie! kr<gtqe<! Ogiiqg<jggt<! fqjxOux?! nf<k!gHvitqgtqe<! 'a|gjtg<! ogi{<M! dkuq! OkMukx<Og! -u<upqgtqz<!he<Ljx! nuIgt<! ohiqKl<! o\bl<! ohx<X! nEhuk<kqz<!d{If<Kt<teI/! Gxqh<hig?! dI^|! fim<gtqz<! kie<! kr<gtqe<!nf<kvr<glie! hqvObi\er<gjt! nuIgt<! ohx<Xt<teI/! -g<giv{l<!hx<xqOb! nuIgt<?! nf<kg<! gHvitqgtqe<! 'a|gt<! hqiqf<k! uhik<!fim<gtqz<! nr<G! kqvt<! kqvtigk<! kQ uqv! nhqzij]! ogi{<M?!aql<lk<OkiM!uf<K!%c?!hik<kqai!Lkzqbe!YKgqe<xiIgt</!silieqb!\er<gTl<! nu<uiOx! nr<G! %m<ml<! %c! hik<kqai! Lkzqbe! Ykq?!

kr<gtqe<! kQ eqb<bk<kie! Ogiiqg<jggOti?! Ke<bi! sl<hf<klie! fim<m!Okm<mr<gOti! fqjxOux! nf<kg<! gHvitqgjtg<! ogi{<M! dkuq!OkMgqe<xiIgt<}}!we<hOk/!!! -e<El<?! hx<hz! ujggtqz<! -ux<Xg<Gs<! sie<xig! dt<t!akQKgTl<! nOfglqVg<gqe<xe/! nux<jxg<! ogi{<Om!-lil<gotz<ziVl<! Nkivl<! OkcBt<tiIgt</! Olx<g{<m! sie<Xgjtg<!ogi{<M! kQ Ez<! - <zik<kqz<! dI^|! fmk<k! hzlie! Nkivr<gt<!dt<te! we<hK! okt<tk<! oktquigq! uqm<mK! we<hkib<! OlOz! &e<X!hivig<gtqz<!Gxqh<hqmh<hm<mux<jxBl<! Olx<Ogitig!ujvf<K?!oltziei?!

oltzuq?! ]aiHk<kQ e<! na<lK! Ogibi?! ]izqbik<kQ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! aq\<iQ ! 2482l<! N{<cz<! hk<ui!ogiMk<Kt<tiIgt</! -f<k! hk<uijus<! siq! g{<M! lkxi <! Lh<k<kQ!nz<ai\<! Lal<lK! ahQ hz<zia<! îaqH! )guIe<ol{<M! hqvkl!gi\qbiI*?!Lal<lK!gzQ ZI!va<lie<!gikqiQ ?!iqtuQ ?!hQ aiiQ ?!fi^qVk<kQ e<!Lal<lK!-HE!gi\Q !djhKz<zia<?!gikqV!nzq!)LkIiq^<?!lk<vî!



!

!



100

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

Lal<lkQ *! we<x! Lal<lK! -HviaQ l<! hisqz<! Oku<hf<K! )LkIiq <?!lk<vî! \lizqb<bi*! NgqbuIgTl<?! -e<El<! hz! dzlig<gTl<!jgobih<hl<!juk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! fhq!ohVlieiI!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!uhik<kigq!-V!fim<gt<! ujvbqz<! gzQhi! fqblek<kqZl<?! nmg<g! ^<kzk<jk!fqI{bqh<hkqZl<! gizkilkligq?! gjmsqbig?! o^b<bqKei! nH,hg<gI!^qk<kQg<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! gzQ hiuigk<!OkIf<okMg<gh<! ohx<x! hqe<! fibgq! Nbq]i! ^qk<kQ g<gi! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<ai!nuIgtK!-z<zk<kqe<!njxbqOzOb!khe<! )nmg<gl<*!osb<bh<ohx<xiIgt</! ne<X! lkQeiuqZt<t! \er<gt<! njeuVg<Gl<!nlQVz<!LlqeQ e<!o^b<bqKei!nH,hg<gI!^qk<kQ e<! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<?! Ä=îz<.kuiH}g<gig! Ou{<c?! d{U! kbiI!osb<kiIgt</! biK! giv{k<kqx<gig! -u<uqkl<! osb<gqe<xiIgt<! we<x!\er<gt<! uqeuqbkx<G! -e<X! x |Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq!u^z<zl<! nuIgtqe<! dI^|! we<hkib<! uq]blxqf<kuIgt<!uqjmbtqk<kiIgt<! we<hkig?!Gk<uk<K^<!îzqg<gQ e<?!]ia<!]IHk<kQ e<!

-HE!na<lK!wa<bi!LeQ iQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!lz<H,tik<kqz<! osiz<ukig?! nz<zili! Lh<k<kQ ! o^b<bqK! nlQI! nzuq?!n\<lQ iq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! Ä-a<zig<Gz<.ua<aihqb<bQ eqZl<}! F~X! ym<mgr<gt<! nXk<K! dI^|! fmk<kqbkig?!lkxi <! Lh<k<kq! la<&K! îaqH! nuIgt<?! hk<a|z<.ag<gqZl<!Gxqh<hqm<cVg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄd' <! )uhik<*!djmb! fijth<! Oh{q?! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<ukqz<!lqGklie! hqvObiser<gt<!d{<M}}! we<hkib<?! o]b<G!na<lK!-HE!Lal<lK! hi'gq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<?! ku<tQ a|z<!

a|kiuqZl<?!nz<zili?!nh<Kz<ag<?!Lak<kqKk<kqa<zuQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! Äli.khk<k.hq^< |e<ei}uqZl<?!nz<zili!Lh<kQ !la<&K!îaqH?!lk<xi^Q!nuIgt<?!Ähk<a|z<.ag<gqZl<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!! ÄÄdV <! kqek<jkh<! Oh{q! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<uK! Lg<gqbliGl<}}!we<X?!Äl\<&dI.iquibk<}kqZl<?!Ähkiuike<hki}uqZl<!uVgqxK!we<hkig!Lh<kQ ! la<&K! îaqH! lkxi Q ! nuIgt<! hk<a|z<.ag<gqz<!Gxqh<hqm<cVg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! la<H,Oh! -ziaq?! j]G! fq\iLk<kQ e<! nUzqbi! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi! ne<a|! Gk<uk<Kz<! nUzqbi! j]G! f Qvk<kQ e<! ]QxigQ !

vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!Sz<kiEz<!nUzqbi!Lal<lK!a|jê<!hf<ki! fui <! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! uzqb<Bz<gilqz<! j]G!haiUk<kQ e<! \giqb<bi! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! NgqbuIgTl<!-e<El<! lx<Xl<! nUzqbig<gTl<! dzlig<gTl<! nuvuIgtK!j]GliIgt<?!him<me<liIgt<?!kib<!kf<jkbI!LkziOeiIgt<!uhik<kie!fim<gtigqb!dI^|! kqer<gtqz<! Ähik<kqai}! gk<kr<gt<! osb<kqVh<hkib<!



!

!



101

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

]ia<! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! îaqH! OuZ~iQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<!Äh^<Zz<.gqkih<}!61.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!wMk<Kg<gim<cBt<tiIgt</!!! j]G! nh<Kz<! ag<! Lak<kqK! kqa<zuQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<?! klK! kf<jkbqe<! uhik<K! fitigqb! dIj^!uVmf<OkiXl<! fmk<kq! uf<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</! oltzuq! nh<Kz<! ag<gQ l<!îaqH!-jkg<!g{<ck<K?!ÄdIj^!hXzig!w{<{q!fQ r<gt<!yu<ouiV!uVmLl<!osb<K!uVgqe<xQIgOt"!we<X!wPkqg<!Ogm<miI/!!! nkx<G!]ia<! îaqH! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!ogiMk<k! uqjm;.! Ä\|h<kk<Ke<.eîbqa|! 53.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! Nkivlie!akQKgjtg<!Gxqh<hqm<M!gi{<hqk<K!%XukiuK;.!!! ÄÄ-u<uqkl<! Gx<xr<Gjx! %XuK! nxqbijljb! nxquqg<gqe<xK/!Woeeqz<?!hXZ?!nz<zikjk!wuVl<!hXZ!we<X!%XuK!gqjmbiK/!gHjv! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<uKl<?! dkuq! OkMuKl<?! GINe<! Ykq! OsiX?!sQ v{q! upr<gq! kuijhs<! OsIk<K! juh<hKl<! L <k<kah<Hl<?! npgie!

gVlLliGl</!nfqk<kqblie!-u<UzgqzqVf<K!fqk<kqblie!nu<UzGg<Gs<!ose<x!RihgiIf<k!fitigqb!dVj^g<!Gxqh<hqm<m!kqek<kqz<!fmk<KuK!%Mole<hK! dzlig<gtqe<! WOgihqk<k! nhqh<hqvibl</! x^|Zz<ziaq!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK! osiz<Zl<! osbZl<?!âihig<gtqe<! fmk<jkgTOl! -kx<Gh<! OhiKlie! Nkivr<gtiGl<}}!we<hOk/!!! ÄÄdV <! gizr<gtqz<! kVgig<gtqz<! hqKnk<Kgt<!fjmohXgqe<xeOu"! nu<ulbl<! Nr<G! osz<zzili@! we<x! uqei!wPgqe<xK/!

!! nkx<Giqb! uqjm! -ke<gQ p<! Gxqh<hqmh<hm<Mt<tK/! g{<[x<X!sf<Okgk<jk!Ohig<gqg<!ogit<uiIgtig/!!! ÄÄdV^|jmb! gizk<kqz<! hqKnk<Kgt<! fmf<kiz<! \qbivk<kqx<gigh<!Ohiukx<G! nju! kjmbig! lim<mi}}! we<X! xk<Kz<! La<k<kiI! 2.uK!higl<!776uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!hkiuiGh<xi!3.uK!higl<!35.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!osiz<zh<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄnx<h! uq]bk<jk! Le<eqm<Mh<! ohiqb! giiqbk<jk! uqm<Muqm!

Ou{<cbkqz<jz}}! we<X! nz<zili! ]ia<! Laqb<bqk<kQ e<! îaqH!OuZ~IQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!Äh^<Zz<!gqkiH}!224.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄosix<h! ogMkzqe<! giv{lig! lqGklie! fe<jljb! uqm<M!uqMkOz! nkqgg<! ogMkziGl<}}! we<X! nz<zili?! j]G! - <libqz<!



!

!



102

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

ag<gQ ?!h'^Q !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!'a|z<!hbie<?!2.uK!higl<?!99.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!olipqf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄdV <! djmb! gizk<kqz<! hqKnk<Kgt<! fmf<k! OhikqZl<!\qbivk<kqx<Gh<! Ohigzil<}}! we<hkib<?! ]l< |z<! dzli! hm<ml<! ohx<x!nz<zili!Gzil<!x^|z<!siaqH!lkxi^Q !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! hk<uig<! ogiMk<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</! njks<! siqg{<M! lkxi <!Lh<k<kQ ! nz<zili! nz<ai\<! klQl<! îaqH! nuIgTl<! nkqz<!jgobPk<kqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄsOgikvOe"! dV <! djmb! hqvObi\er<gt<! nke<!ogMkjzg<gi{! nkqgole<hjk! nxquibig;! )Hgaig<gOt"*! sm<m!fqH{IgOt"!njkk<!kMh<hjk!uqm<M!uqm<M?!kr<gjth<!Oh{qg<ogi{<M!fql<lkqbigUl<?! sf<Oki]ligUl<! -Vh<hQ Igtig"}}! we<hkib<! nz<Gk<H?!nh<Kz<! ua<aiH! ]0xieQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!nz<ha<Vz<.lu<'Kz<.ghQI}! w<ex! gqvf<kk<kqz<! %Xukig! oltziei?!n^<j^bqK! Lal<lK! -HE! n <j^bqK! Lal<lK! Hgiiqb<Bz<!

a|jêqb<bq]! ]ihqbQ?! ]u<gik<kQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<?! Äk]u<Uhz<.-^<liU}! 29.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! osiz<gqxjk/!nz<zili!]aiHk<kQe<!na<lK!Ogibi?!]izqbik<kQ!nuIgt<!siqg{<M!jgobPk<K!-m<Mt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄdV^|jmb! lgqjljbBl<?! hqvObi\ek<jkBl<! nxqf<k! j]G!^0kQ ?! ]Qvi Q ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!ÄHKlih<hqt<jtOhiz<! sbeqh<hQ vig}! we<X! gh<VgtqzqVg<Gl<!fz<zcbiIgjt! Ofig<gq! lzg<Ggt<! Osihel<! %Xl<! Äfl<.g.fu<lk<kqz<.n' <}! wEl<!akQ jk!Nkivligg<! ogi{<M! fQ! =liEme<! lUk<kiGl<!

nf<fit<! sf<Oki]Ll<! lr<gtLl<! djmb! dVîgquqMl<! we<hkib<!Ohi^<k<kieqz<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! dzgh<! hqvsqk<klie?! nz<Gk<H?! o^b<bqK! na<lK! hkuQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! dIj^! -e<giI! osb<k!ng<giz! OlkiuqgTg<G! Wx<hm<m! sl<hur<gt<! hx<xq?! nz<zili?! j]G!B,Shf<! fhaieQ ?! lq <iQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!-bx<xqBt<t! Ä\ilqd.gxilik<kqz<.nUzqbi}! 2.uK! higl<?! 428.uK!hg<gk<jkBl<?!nz<Gk<H?!-lil<!]0xieQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! -bx<xqb! Äkhg<gik<Kz<.Gh<xi}?! 2.uK! higl<! 266.uK!

hg<gk<jkBl<!Ofim<mlqMg/!!! ohiqObiIgTjmb!\qbivk<kqx<gigs<!osz<Zl<OhiK!ogic!ogi{<M!Ohigzili@!GHVgjt!Lk<klqmzili}!we<X!-lil<!gzQ zQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgtqmk<kqz<! Ogm<gh<hm<mkx<G?! ÄÄnUzqbig<gTjmb!\qbivk<kqx<gigs<! osz<Zl<OhiK!ogicogi{<M! OhiuKl<?! khIVg<Gjmb!



!

!



103

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

w{<{k<Kme<!gHjv!Lk<klqMuKl<!NGl</!-jk!-e<giI!osb<gqxue<!upq! ogm<m! hqKnk<Kg<giveiuie<}}! we<X! hkqz! %xq! -Vh<hkib<?!Ähkiui.gzQ zQ }! 3.uK! higl<! 361.uK! hg<gk<kqz<! gi{h<h;Mgqe<xK/!-u<uq]bk<jk! nz<zili?! o^b<bqK! Lal<lK! Hgiiq?! a|jêQ ?!lzhiiQ ! kr<gt<! nuIgt<! Äk]u<Uhz<.-^<lid}! wEl<! F~zqz<!Gxqh<hqm<cVh<hjk!nr<gQgivl<!osb<K?!siq!g{<M!nz<zili!]aiHk<kQ e<!nalK! Ogibi?! ]izqbik<kQ ! )lzhiiQ *! nuIgTl<!jgobih<hlqm<cVg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! nz<zili!-lil<!Lal<lK!gzQ zQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTjmb! hkiuiuqz<! hqe<uVliX! uqei! uqjm?! uqtg<gl<!kvh<hm<Mt<tK;.!!! uqei;!fhqliIgjt! nUzqbig<gjt! \qbivk<Ks<! osb<ukx<gigh<!OhiGl<! OhiK! ogicgjt! Wf<kqg<! ogi{<Ml<?! khz<hi\<! wEl<!ogim<mck<Kg<!ogi{<Ml<?!lq^<aI!wEl<!uik<kqbl<!uisqk<Kg<!ogi{<Ml<?!sqz!%m<mk<kqeI!osz<gqe<xeOv"!-ju!aviliGli!nz<zui@!

!! uqjm;!-u<uq]bl<!wKUl<!uqzg<gh<hm<m!gVllz<z/!!! -u<uixig! hk<uiuqz<! uqjmbtqg<gh<hm<Mt<tK/! Olx<g{<m!uq]br<gt<!uqiquR<sq!SVg<glie!Ljxbqz<!%xh<hm<Mt<tkig!nz<zili!na<lK! Ogibi! ]izqbik<kQ ! nuIgt<! kr<gtK! hk<uiuqz<! -jkg<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! NgOu! Nkq! gizl<! okim<M! lig<gjt! lg<gtig<gq! Lg<kq!ohxk<kg<g! olb<R<Rie! dhOksR<! osb<K?! upqhqsgqk<kMlixqh<!

Ohigiu{<{l<!hiKgik<K!lQ m<M?!Ofvie!hijkbqz<!gjv!OsVl<!dhibl<!osiz<zqk<! kf<k!olb<R<RieqgTg<G!dI^|! fmk<KuKl<?!dI |g<gigh<!hqvbi{h<hm<M?!\qbivk<jk!fich<!hb{l<!OhiuKl<!NGl<!we<hK!fe<G!okiqb!uVgqe<xK/!!! OlZl<?! nf<k! lgie<gTjmb! RihgiIk<klig?! nuIgt<!nmg<glz<zik! -kv! -mr<gtqZl<! nuIgt<! Ohviz<! dI^|!fmk<kziole<hKl<!nxqbg<!gqjmg<gqe<xK/!!

OfIs<js!osb<bzili@!!! OfIs<jsg<G! ÄKa<hi}! we<Xl<! ÄfkI}! we<Xl<! Äfqbi <}! we<Xl<!osiz<uK{<M/!!OfIs<js!-V!ujgh<hMl</!nz<zia<!ohbviz<!jug<Gl<!OfIs<jsg<G! hqg<aq! we<Xl<?! nUzqbih<ohbviz<! jug<Gl<! OfIs<jsg<G!hqg<aq! we<Xl<! osiz<zh<hMl</! -u<uqkl<! ]ia<! nh<Kz<! n\Q <!



!

!



104

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

Lak<kqKk<! kqa<zuQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtqe<!sOgikvI! ]ia<! vhQ Uk<kQ e<! Lak<kq <! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! iq izk<Ke<.FK~iqZl<?!]ia<! îaqh<! OuZ~iq! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!h^<Zz<.gqkihqZl<!wMk<Kjvk<Kt<tIIgt</!!! yV!oh{<?!fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgtK!kqVs<sLgk<kqx<G!uf<K?!Äbiv^|zz<zia<"!kr<gt<!Le<!kh<!nch<hkx<G!OfIs<js! osb<K! ogi{<Mt<Ote<}}! we<xit</! nkx<G! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!ÄÄdeK!OfIs<jsjb!fqjxOux<xqg<!ogit<}}!we<hkib<! %xqeiIgt<! we<x! uqhvl<! lqIg<gik<.]va|! lq]<gik<! 4.uK!higl<?!hg<gl<!679.z<!gi{h<hMgqxK/!!! ÄÄdlg<G!WkiuokiV!OkjubqVf<K!nK!fqjxOux!Ou{<Ml<!we!fQ i! fiMuQ vibqe<?! j^bqkk<K!fhQ i! kiaqxi! lq <iqb<bi! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<ai!Ug<G!yV!jhsi!)hz< <*!gisigqZl<!OfIs<js!osb<K!ogit<uQI/! dlK! fim<ml<! fqjxOuXl<! we<X! fhq! giQl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! weg<G! hqvse<eligqh<! hgIf<Kt<tiIgt<}}!

we<X!Gk<H!j]G!Lal<lK!nHz<!luiaqH]<!]iKzq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!%xq!-Vg<gqxiIgt<!we<x!uq]bl<!khgik<Kz<.Gh<xi!higl<!3!.!hg<gl<!77.z<!osiz<zh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! ÄÄnUzqbig<gTjmb! OfIs<js?! Okjugjt! fqjxOux<xq!juh<hkqz<! ohiqObiIgtiz<! nE]<cg<gh<hm<mkiBl<?!upg<gk<kqZt<tkiBl<! -Vg<gqe<xK}}! we<X! nz<zili! ]ia<! nh<Kz<!n\Q <! Lak<kqK! kqa<zuq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!osiz<ukib!h^<Zz<!gqkih<!63.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%xh<hMgqe<xK/!!

! ÄÄwuoviVuI! wf<k! u <Kju! wf<k! -mk<kqx<G! OfIs<js!osb<gqxiOvi!njk!nOk!-mk<kqx<Og!fqjxOux<xqg<!ogiMg<g!Ou{<cbK!ui\qH!)gmjl*}}!we<X!Lz<zi!nzq!giiQ!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! lqIgik<.]va|lq]<gik<! 4.uK! higl<! 678uK! hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</! n]q0nk<Kz<.zl<Nk<?! 4.uK! higl<! 314! uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!osiz<zh<hMgqe<xK/!!! âihq! yVuI! huiei! we<x! -mk<kqz<! ym<mgl<! ye<jx!nXh<hkx<G! OfIs<js! osb<K! -Vf<kiIgt</! nf<k! âihq?! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtqmk<kqz<! uf<K!

-u<uq]bk<jkg<! %xqeiIgt</! nu<uqmk<kqz<! L]<iqg<GgTjmb!uqg<gqvgl<! WkiuK! d{<mi@! we<X! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!Ogm<g/!nr<G!nh<hcg<!gqjmbiK!we<xiIgt</!!! gihqIgTjmb! kqVuqpi! WkiuK! fjmohXuK{<mi@! we<X!uqeuqbkx<G!nu<uqkl<!-z<jz!we<xiIgt</!



!

!



105

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! nh<hcbieiz<! dl<Ljmb! OfIs<jsjb! fqjxOux<Tl<! we<X!dk<kqvuqm<miIgt<!wEl<!akQ K!nH,kiU,kqz<!uVgqxkig!lq]<gik<!]iQ h<!%Xgqe<xK/!!! -u<uqklig! akQK! -e<El<! sqz! d{<M/! -jkg<! ogi{<M!OfIs<js! osb<bzil<! we<Xl<?! uzqliIgtqe<! kIaig<gtqz<! OfIs<js!osb<bh<hm<m! NM?! liM?! Ogipq! ujgbxig<gjt! nXg<gziole<Xl<!okiqf<K!ogit<gqOxil</!Woeeqz<?!kIgig<gtqz<!wu<uqklie!uqg<gqvgOli?!gihqIgtqe<!kqVuqpiOui!fjmohXukqz<jz/!!! ]ia<!nh<Kz<!n\Q <!Lak<kqKk<!kqa<zuq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! gQp<! uVliX! %xqBt<tK! -kx<G! uqtg<glig!-Vg<gqe<xK;.!!! ÄÄa\<vk<! ogtKz<! n0tl<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgtqe<! Ohviz<! NMutIh<hkiGl</! nux<jx! nXk<Ks<! sjlk<K!

OfIs<jsbqe<! hik<kqai! Ykq! \er<gTg<G! uqVf<ktqh<hKliGl</! -kqz<!biokiV! kjmBlqz<jz/! -k<kjgb! OfIs<js! abik<OkiMt<t!ohiqbiVg<Gs<! osb<Bl<! gi{qg<jgbiGl<}}! we<X! \qh<kKe<! fîbqa|!216.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%xh<hm<Mt<tK/!!! OlZl<! uzqliIgt<! lQ Kt<t! Lah<hk<jk! Le<eqm<M! sr<jgjb!fic! w{<o{b<! DKhk<kq! Ohie<xjugjt! nuIgtK! gHVgtqz<!ogiTk<k! OfIs<js! osb<uK! NGl</! njk! uqzg<gzigiK! we<hkig!nz<zili!GKuk<Kz<!Lh^< qiQe<?!j]G!-^<libqz<!ag<gQ !h'^Q!'lq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!'a|z<!hbie<!4.uK!higl<!511.

uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!nz<zilk<Kz<!Lag<gqg<!-lil<?!nh<Kz<geq!fihqzq^<!kqlq]<gQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! g]<He<E~iqZl<?!Lx<gizk<kqz<! lq <iqz<! Lh<kqbib<! -Vf<k! nz<zili! j]G! nh<Kz<!gikqV! xihqbQ ! hi'gq! aehq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!ka<iQ Vz<.Lg<kiI! 2uK! higl<?! 234uK! hg<gk<kqZl<! uqiquig!wMk<Kjvk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! hg<kik<! ]iQ hqz<! )L^z<zz<.=K*! ohVfit<! okiPjg!okiPlqmk<kqz<! yV! gHV! -Vg<gqe<xK/! njk! gHVe<EK~I.OfIs<jsgTjmb! gHV! we<X! njpg<gh<hMgqe<xK/! fim<mr<gjt!

fqjxOux<xq!jug<gg<!%cb!gHV!we<X!njk!\er<gt<!gVKgqe<xeI/!!! Sz<kiE]<! ]|aki?! o^b<bqKei! -lil<! a|jê<!]aQ okgIhzi! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgtK! &e<xiuK!GlivI!a\<vk<!nh<Kz<zi!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTjmb!gHV! weg<! %xh<hMgqe<xK/! wuI! wf<k! Okjujb! ficeiZl<! nK!



!

!



106

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

nuVg<G! fqjxOuXgqe<x! giv{k<jk! Le<eqm<M! gHVe<EK~I! we<x!ohbI!upr<gh<hMgqe<xK/!!! nz<zilKz<! hitqz<! nH,hg<gI! gk<kqh<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgt<! hg<kik<! djmb! siqk<kqvk<kqz<! OlOz! g{<mux<xj!ujvf<K?!ÄÄnOfg!kmju!fie<!nf<kg<!gHjv!fic!OfIs<js!osb<K!we<!fim<ml<!fqjxOuxh<!ohx<xqVg<gqe<Oxe<}}!we<Xl<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! -u<uvziX!gikqlqz<!fg<Z!osb<bh<ohx<xqVh<hkib<!hkiui!ke<hki!osiz<Zgqe<xK/! -u<uq]bk<jk! lkvi <! Lh<kq! nz<zili! la<&K!îaqh<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgTl<!hk<a|z<!ag<!88.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!ujvgqe<xiIgt</!!! nUzqbig<gTg<G! OfIs<js! osb<K! fqbi <! jug<gzil<?! nh<hc!)fkI*! OfIs<js! juh<hK! NGl<?! njk! fqjxOux<XuK! gmjl!we<hkx<Gh<!OhiKlie!gqvf<kr<gt<!hz!dt<te/!nux<Xt<!sqz;!!

gqvf<kr<gt<!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! NsqiqbIgt<!!hkiui! nhqz<.jzK! hgQ a<! nhqzjzK! ^lIgf<kQ! va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!hkiui!Gh<xi! ! j]G! -HEa\I! lg<gQ! va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!hkiui!gzQ zQ! ! -lil<!j]G!Lal<lK!gzQzQ !va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!

hkiui!n\Q qb<bi! ]ia<! nh<Kz<! n\Q <! kqa<zuq!va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!hkiui!xq\<uqb<bi!!!!!!j]G!na<lKiqîgie<hOvzq!va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!kh< Q I!na<lkqb<bi! Lal<lK! Lz<zi\qB,e<! va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!kh< Q I!'a|z<hbie<! j]G!- <libqz<!ag<gQ h'^q!va<lk<Kz<ziaq!

njzaq!!\ilqdz<! hvgik<?! g]<He<.F~I! ! ]ia<! nh<Kz<! ag<! kqa<zuq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!!!



!

!



107

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

ag<gQ gk<Ke<!.!fkqb<bi!!! j]G! nh<Kz<geq! fihqzq Q !va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!ka<xQ Vz<!.!Lg<kiI! j]G! nh<Kz<gikqI! lq <iQ ! va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!xqîzk<Ke<!.!FK~I! ! ]ia<! vhQ dk<kQ e<! kqa<zuq!va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!h <Zz<!.!gqkih<?!j^Hz<.\h<hiI! ]ia<! Laqbqk<kQ e<! OuZ~iQ !va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!huiiQ g<!.!Lal<lkqb<bi!! j]G! h\<ZI! v$z<! hkiB,eq!va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!u^Q zi!.!\zQzi!! ugQ z<!nalK!^qg<gf<kI! H,iQ ! va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!

!hk<a|z<!ag<! ! Lhkqla<&K!îaqh<lkvi^Q ! va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!-I]iKz<!.!ag<!! j^bqK! nlQ I! nzuq! va<lk<Kz<ziaq!njzaq!!akqb<bi!.!lg<gqb<bi! ua<aihqgTg<G! xk<kig! lg<giuqZt<t!dzlig<gt<!njeuVl<!ye<X!OsIf<K!aq\<iq!2332.z<!wPkqbK/!!

! ÄÄuzqliIgtqe<! Ohviz<! OfIs<js! juh<hK! NGl<}}! we<Xl<!ÄÄOfIs<jsbig! jug<gh<hm<m! gi{qg<jggjt! fqjxOux<XuK! ui\qH! .!gmjl}}! we<Xl<! OlOz! g{<m! gqvf<kgIk<kig<gt<! %xqBt<tiIgt</! fkI?!fqbi <! hx<xq! nkqgl<! nxqb! NuZt<tuIgt<?! -I]iKz<! ag<jg!hiIjubqMg/!!!

gHVgtqz<!OhiIju!OhiIk<kzili@!sfkel<!H,szili@!H]hl<!Ohimzili@!

uisjek<!kqvuqbrgt!sil<Hvi{q!Hjg!Ohimzili@!!! gHVgtqe<! Ohiqz<! OhiIjugt<! OhiIk<kh<hMgqe<xe/!dI^|gizr<gtqz<! sf<kel<! H,sh<hMgqe<xK/! lx<x! fim<gtqz<! nk<kI!he<eQ I! oktqg<gh<hMgqe<xK/! sil<Hvi{q?! DKhk<kq?! sf<keg<! gm<jm?!ngqz<! gm<jm! Lkzqb! uisjek<! kqvuqbr<gt<! Hjgg<gh<hMgqe<xe/!



!

!



108

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

-juobz<zil<!%Mli@!we<x!Jbl<!wPgqe<xK/!gQ Op!ogiMg<gh<hm<Mt<t!uqtg<gr<gjt! fe<G! hck<kxqf<K! nk<kjgb! sf<Okgk<jk! Ohig<gqg<!ogit<uQ Igtig/!!! fhq! ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!uhik<!Ngq!nmg<glieKl<!nf<k!Lhivg<gie!gHV!]iQ h<!lQ K!OhiIju!OhiIk<Kl<!upg<gl<!âihig<gt<! gizk<kqzqVf<K!Nvl<hl<!Ngq!-e<X!ujv!fjmohx<X!uVgqe<xK/!!! gi^ql<! -HE! Lal<lkqHE! nhQ hg<gI! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!a\<vk<!Nbq]i!fibgq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<ai!nuIgtqmR<! ose<X?! ÄÄne<jeOb! v$Zz<zia<! nuIgTjmbUl<! -V!âihig<gt<!)nH,hg<gI?!dlI*!djmbUl<!gHVgjt!weg<Gk<!kqxf<K!gim<Mr<gt<!we<X!Ogm<Ome</!nuIgt<!gHVgjt!kqxf<K!gi{<hqk<kiIgt<!wEl<!akQ K!nH,kiU,jkg<!ogi{<M!n]q0nk<Kz<!zl<Nk<!higl<!.!2?!hg<gl<!727z<!iquibk<Ks<!osb<bh<hMgqxK/!!

! ÄÄv$Zz<ziaq! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK!Lhivg<gie! gHjvk<! kqxf<K! gi{<hqg<Gl<hc! yV! oh{<l{q! Nbq]i!fibgq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<ai!nuIgjtg<! Ogm<Mg<! ogi{<miI/!nuIgt<! kqxf<K! gim<ceiIgt</! nh<oh{<lq{! kiqseR<! osb<K! dbqI!Ohigqe<xlm<cz<! nPkPK! nu<uqmk<kqOzOb! dbqI! Kxf<kiI}}! wEl<!iquibk<K!gqkiH]<]qhi!hg<gl<!2::z<!osiz<zh<hMgqe<xK/!!! fhqgt<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgtK!gHV! ]iQh<! \er<gtqe<! hiIjujb! uqm<Ml<! ljxf<K! uQm<cEt<!-Vh<hkiz<! kqxf<K! gi{<hqg<Gl<hc! Nbq]i! fibgq! nuIgtqml<!

nh<oh{<l{q!Ogm<g!nuIgt<!gHV!]iQh<!lQ Kt<t!OhiIjujb!ngx<xqg<!gi{<hqk<kiIgt<! we<hkib! OlOz! g{<m! akQKg<G! f Q LIiqbit<! .!]va|]qhi!gizQ!-bizqz<!uqbig<gqbiel<!osb<bh<hMgqxK/!!! gHV! ]iQ h<! lQ Kt<t! OhiIjujb! wMk<Kuqm<Mg<! gi{<hqg<Gl<hc!Nbq]i!fibgq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<ai!nuIgtqml<!nh<oh{<l{q!uq{<{h<hqk<Kg<!ogi{<miI/!nuIgt<!gHV!]iQ hqe<!lQ kqVf<k!OhiIjujb!ngx<xquqm<M<g! gHjvg<! gi{<hqk<kiIgt<! we<hkig! gqkiHz<! lkKz<!jhbit<.hq!F~iq]<]qhi!gizQ!-biz<!higl<!3?!hg<gl<!32.z<!%xh<hMgqxK/!-ux<jxg<!ogi{<M!fhq!ohVlieiI!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!

nuIgtK! gHV! ]iQ hqe<! lQK! OhiIju! OhiIk<kh<hm<cVf<kK! we<hK!Nkiv!H,Iulib<!fe<G!uqtr<Ggqe<xK/!!! OhiIjugt<?!kjzh<hijggt<?!K{q!ujgbxig<gt<!nUzqbig<gt<?!îzqaQ e<gt<! djmb! gHVgt<! lQ K! juh<hK! lg<'a<! we<X! sqz!Hgaig<gt<!osiz<gqe<xiIgt</!Neiz<!silie<b!\er<gtqe<!hiIjubqz<!



!

!



109

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

gHxitqgt<! Oguzligg<! gi{h<hmilz<! uZh<hLt<tuIgtiBl<?!lxkqbitVg<Gl<?!kiqsel<!HiqOuiIg<Gl<!liqbijkBl<!hg<kqBl<!d{<mig!Ou{<Mole<x!w{<{k<KmEl</!nu<uqkl<!osb<uK!\ibq^<!)NGlieK*!we<X! fil<! %XgqOxil</! Woeeqz<! )-e<elz<! n0liZ! hqe<eqb<bik<*!osbz<gotz<zil<! w{<{k<jk<! ohiXk<OkBt<te! we<hkib<! vk<Kz<!La<k<kiI! 6uK! higl<?! 367l<! hg<gk<kqz<! ujvbh<hm<Mt<tK/! -u<uiOx!d^<kiK! nh<Kz<geq! fihqzq Q! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgTl<!gqkiH!g]<He<!F~I!ne<!n^<aihqz<!GH,I!we<x!gqvf<kk<kqz<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<?! kqjv?! OhiIju! Lkziejugjt! ouizqliIgt<?!îzqaQ e<gTjmb!gHV!]iQ h<gtqz<! OhiMuK!NGl</!njk!uqzg<gg<!%miK/! nu<uiX! OhiMuK! nuIgjt! sr<jg! osb<K!liqbijkh<hMk<KukqZt<tkib<! -Vg<Gl</! nlz<gt<! fqjxOuXuK!nuvK!fqb<bk<K!hqvgivlib<!-Vg<Gl<!we<X!nz<zili!-HE!NhqkQ e<!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!ke<gQa|z<!hkiui!ailqkqb<bi?!higl<! 2?! hg<gl<! 468?! vk<Kz<! La<kiI! higl<! 6?! hg<gl<! 367z<!

Gxqh<hqm<cVh<hKme<! kh< QI! 'a|z<! hbie<?! g]<He<! F~I?! ka<iQVz<!La<kiI!Lkzqb!gqvf<kr<gtqZl<!fg<Z!osb<bh<hm<cVg<gqe<xK/!!! fhq! ohVlieiI!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgTg<G!dgh<hieux<Xt<! uisjeBl<! ye<X! we<hkib<! fibguig<gqbl<!%Xgqe<xK/! ! lzibqg<gk<Kgt<! l{lie! uijmbqe<! Ohiqz<!hqiqbLt<tuIgtib<! -Vh<hkiz<! gHV! ]iQ Hg<G! N\I! Nujk! fic!ogiR<gl<!sf<kel<!ujgbxig<gt<!H,SuK!lg<'a<!-e<xqOb!NGlieK!.! L <kah<hieK! we<X!-lil<! ^|HgQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<! osiz<ukig! Ka<hk<Kz<.La<ki\<! wEl<! gqvf<kk<kqZl<!

Ä-Kohiz! l{lie!uisje! H,SuK!^|e<ek<}! oke<X! Ka<hiUjmb!ai]qbi! ]IuieqbqZl<?! -u<uqkl<! osb<bK! ^|e<ek<oke<X!ai]qbk<Kz<!hi\|iq!2uK!higl<!432.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!%xh<hMgqe<xe/!!! gHV!]iQ h<gt<! lQK! H]<hr<gt<?! =vLt<t!hSjlbie!u <Kg<gt<!OhiMuK! L <kah<H/! Woeeqz<! fhqgt<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|!njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! kqVUtliekig! nh<Kz<zi! aqh<E!l <DK! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! -h<E!NhqkQ e<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! xquibk<Ks<!osb<ukiuK?! ÄÄyV! L <zqLjmb! gh<iqe<lQK! H,! OhiMuOvz<! nf<k!

lziqe<!k^<hQ jag<!ogi{<M!gh<vitqg<G!nkiH?!-Ozsigqe<xK/!!! OlZl<! H,! Ohim<muVg<G! fe<jl! wPkh<hMgqe<xK}}! we<hkig!nz<zili!-lil<!nH,^b<K!^z<lQ !aehQ !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!]va|.hI\gqz<!Äfgz<}!osb<gqe<xiIgt</!!



!

!



110

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! ÄÄgh<iqe<! Ohiqz<! H,! OhiMuKl<! hs<jsg<! ogih<Hg<gjt! fm<MuKl<!La<kah<Hl<! npgie! gVlLliGl<?! nf<kh<H,! wKujvg<!gibikqVg<gqe<xOki! nKujv! nz<zia|k<kNzijuk<! k <hQ a<!osb<gqe<xK}}?! we<X! -lil<! ^KV]<! ]aQ K! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! ]va|l\<lduqz<! fgz<! osb<bh<!ohx<xqVg<gqe<xK/!!! ÄÄhe<eQI?! H]<hl<?! jvaie<! Lkzieux<jxg<! gh<Vgt<! lQ K!OhiMkz<! npgie! gVlliGl<! we<X! hkiui! Nzl<gQ iqbqz<!osiz<zh<hMgqe<xK/! gh<Vgtqz<! H,g<gt<! OhiMuK!L <kah<H!nkeiz<!gh<vitqgTg<G! xiak<K{<migqxK}}! we<X!ai]qbk<Kz<! hi\|iq! 2.uK!uigl<! 429.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?!-Nei!3.uK!higl<! 251.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄ^|e<ek<.uz<.\li!nk<jks<!OsIf<kuIgt<?!akQ kqe<!xquibk<jkg<!ogi{<M!nlz<!osb<Bl<!ohiVm<M!sf<K~g<!OhiqZl<!gh<V!lQ Kl<!OhiIju!H,! OhiMgqe<xiIgt<}}! we<hkib<! oltziei! ]ia<! nalK! ^bQK!

L\k<kqK?!kqa<zuQ ! vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<! ka<gQGz<.ag<gqz<.LhQ e<!45.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!! ÄÄgh<iqe<! Ohiqz<! sf<kel<! H,SuKl<! H,! OhiMuKl<! NGl<}}! we<X!lkvi <! guIe<ol{<m<! hqvkl! gi\q! oltziei! oltzuQ ! nz<ai\<!Lal<lK! ahQHz<zia<! îaqh<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgt<?! aq\<iq! 2452.z<! lk<hdlg<K~lqb<biuqz<! ns<sigq! -Vg<Gl<!gqhibk<Kz<zhQ h<! wEl<! hk<uiuqz<! %Xgqe<xiIgt</! lkvi^qZt<t!Ole<jl!kr<gqb!dzlig<gt<!njeuVl<!njk!siqg{<M!jgobPk<K!juk<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</!nuIgTt<!2/!nz<zili!Lh<kQ !la<&K!îgqh<?!3/!]l< |z<!dzli!nz<ai\<!djhKz<zi!îgqh<!)guIe<ol{<m<!gi\Q *!

4/!nz<zili!Lh<kQ !nz<ai\<!Lal<lK!klQ l<!îgqh<?!5/!nz<zilk<Kz<!hi\qz<! agQl<! nz<ai\<! Lal<lK! klQl<! îgqh<?! 6/! nz<zilk<Kz<!hi\qz<!agQl<!nz<ai\<!]ia<!Lal<lK!hk<Vk<kQ e<!a|jê<!îgqh<!sqk<kQ gq!gikqiQ !NgqbuIgt<!hqvhz<blieuIgt</!!! -V! gh<Vgtqz<! nkiH! fmh<hjkg<! g{<M! hSjlbie! OhiQk<kr<!Gs<sqjb!-V!gh<VgtqZl<! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<! fim<c! nju! gib<f<K! OhiGl<! ujvbqz<! Oukje!-OzsiGole<Xl<?! nke<! k <hQ jag<! ogi{<M! gh<vitqgTg<G!xiak<K{<migqe<xoke<Xl<! %xqeiIgt<! we<El<! fibg! uig<gqbr<gt<!

gi{h<hMgqe<xe/!!! ÄÄjlbqk<jk! khe<! osb<khqe<! kjzlim<cZl<! giz<lim<cZl<! -V!hSjlbie! ogih<Hgjt! fm<MuK! L <kah<hiGl<?! Woeeqz<! fibgl<!^z<zz<zia|!njzaq!u^z<zl<!nuIgt<! hSjlbie!yV!ogih<jh!wMk<K! njkg<gQxq! -v{<mig<h! hqtf<K! gh<iqz<! juk<kiIgt<}}! we<X!



!

!



111

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

âQa|! HaiiQ! âQ a|! L^<zql<! -V! akQ <! gqvf<kr<gtqZl<!osiz<zh<hMgqe<xK/!!! ÄÄâihq! Hjvki! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!ke<Ejmb! gh<iqz<! -V! hSjlbie! ogih<Hgt<! jug<g! Ou{<Mole!u^qb<bk<Ks<! osb<kqVf<kiIgt</! nuIgTg<G! nu<uiOx! osb<bh<!ohx<xK}}!we<X!Haiiq.]iQ hqz<!%xh<hMgqxK/!!! Olx<osie<e! akQ <! lq]<gik<! ]iQ hqZl<! gi{h<hMukib<!nkEjmb! kI\|li! n]q0h<! nk<Kz<.zl<Nk<! 2.uK! higl<! 294.l<!hg<gk<kqz<! Gxqh<hqm<M?! Ä-f<k! akQj^g<! ogi{<M! dzlig<gtqz<! yV!%m<mk<kiI! gh<xitqgtqe<! Ohiqz<! jxaie<! H,g<gTl<! hs<jsgTl<!OhiMuK! NGl<! we<X! %Xgqe<xiIgt</}}! we<hkib<! j]G! nh<Kz<ag<!Lak<kq^<kqa<zuQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!ujvf<Kt<tiIgt</!!! OlZl<?!ÄÄwr<gTjmb!hqf<kqb!OkipIgtqz<!fqe<Xl<!sqz!-lil<gt<!

Olx<osie<e! akQj^g<! ogi{<M! gh<xitqgtqe<! Ohiqz<! H,! OhiMuKl<!hSjlbie! Gs<sq! fim<MuKl<! L <kah<ohe<X! hk<ui!ogiMk<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt<}}! we<hkig! nz<zili! Lz<zi! nzq! giiQ! lg<gQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! lqIgik<! ]va|lq]<gik<! 2uK!higl<?!397uK!hg<gk<kqz<!fgz<!osb<kqVg<gqe<xiIgt</!!! hik<kqai!YKl<OhiK!DKhk<kq?!sil<Hvi{q!Ohie<xju!Hjgh<hK!aehQ ! gqvf<kk<jkg<! ogi{<M! NGole! <kihqg<gh<! ohx<xqVg<gqe<xK!dl<kk<Kz<! hkiuiuqz<! fqe<X! u Q zk<Ke<.f\ik<! we<El<! gqvf<kk<kqz<!osiz<zh<hMukib<!k^<iQ a|z<!.!nu<kg<! .!kI\|li!]va|hI\gq!hg<gl<!

451z<!ujvbh<hMukiuK;!hik<kqai!YKgqx!Ofvk<kqz<!DKhk<kq!nl<hI!Hjgh<hKl<! l{lie! u <Kg<gjt! juh<hKl<! kihqbQ e<gjtg<ogi{<M!^<kqvlig<gh<! ohx<xqVg<gqe<xK/! a\<vk<! Sz<kie<! nh<Kz<! n\Q <!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! ljeuqBl<! nuIgt<! lgt<!dl<Laieq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<ai!nuIgTlig!âihig<gt<!Le<hig! -u<uiX! osb<kqVg<gqxiIgt</! yVuVl<! Nm<Oshje!osb<buqz<jz/! -u<upg<gl<! ng<gizk<kqzqVf<Ok! -g<gizl<! ujv!fjmohx<X!uVgqe<xK}}!we<X!-u<uq]bk<jk!lh<'g<!wEl<!gqvf<kk<kqz<!-lil<! h\<kuQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgTl<!wPkqBt<tiIgt</! OlZl<! Lh<kQ ! la<&K! sigqh<! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!

ne<a|!nuIgTl<!hk<a|z<ag<!44uK!hg<gk<kqz<!%Xgqe<xiIgt</!!! ÄÄuzqliIgtK!gHV!]iQHt<t!-mr<gtqz<!GOtiH?!jzm<?!uqtg<G!ujgbxig<gt<! olPGuk<kqgt<?! Lkzqbjugjt! Wx<XuK! nuIgjt!sr<jg! osb<K! g{<{qbh<hMk<kq! juh<hkiGl</! -u<uqkl<! osb<uK!npgie!fim<mk<kqe<!dbIf<k!-zm<sqbliGl</!nux<jx!uqzg<gg<%miK}}!



!

!



112

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

we<X!kh< QI!'a|z<!hbie<!4.uK!higl<!511uK!hg<gk<kqZl<?!ka<iQ Vz<!Lg<k<kiI?! 2.uK! higl<! 234uK!hg<gk<kqZl<! g]<He<! F~iqZl<! uqiquig!ujvbh<ohx<xqVg<gqe<xK/!!! NgOu?!-k<kjgb!giv{r<gtiz<!sikiv{lie!gh<VgTg<Gg<%m!osb<uK! %Ml<! we<xqVg<g?! nUzqbig<gTjmb! gh<V! ]iQHgTg<G!uZh<hk<jkBl<?! yPg<gk<jkBl<?! liqbijkBl<?! fe<jljbBl<! fics<!osb<kz<!NGlieKkie<!we<hK!akQ K?!hqg<a|Ggjtg<!ogi{<M!oum<m!outqs<sligk<!okiqbuVgqxK/!!

LcUjv!!! u{g<guitqBjmb!wz<zi!u{g<gr<gjtBl<!uqm!nUzqbig<gtqe<!Ohiqz<! dgh<H! )Lah<hk<*! juh<hkieK! lqgh<! ohiqb! u{g<glig!-Vg<Gl</!!

! NgOu?! nz<zia<! djmb! nUzqbig<gjt! wuIgt<!dgh<Hjug<gqxiIgOti! fqs<sblig! nuIgt<! nz<zia<juOb! dgh<H!juk<kuIgt</!wuIgt<!nz<zia<ju!dgh<H!juh<hiIgOti!nuIgjt!nz<zia<Ul<!dgh<H!juh<hie</!nkiuK?!nz<zia<uqe<!nUzqbig<gjt!Ofsqh<hkieK! nlz<gtqotz<zil<! ohiqb! ku! u{g<gliGl</! -f<k!nch<hjmbqOzObkie<!laie<gotz<zil<!nz<zia<uqe<!nUzqbig<gjt!dgh<H! juk<K! Ofsqk<K! kir<gTl<! nUzqbig<gtieiIgt<! we<hkil</!-OkOhiz! Gk<H]0xieQ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!khgik<Kz<!Gh<vi!2.uK!higl<?!88.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!

! yV! fim<M! nvhq?! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgtK! sLgl<! uf<K! biv^|zz<zia<"! gqbilk<Kfit<! wh<OhiK@!we<X!Ogm<mOhiK!nuIgt<!nujv!Ofig<gq!nkx<gig!fQ!we<e!Osgiqk<K!juk<kqVg<gqxib<@!we<X!uqeuqeiIgt</!!! nh<OhiK!nuI!ÄÄnz<zia<juBl<?!nz<zia<!djmb!v^|jzBl<!dgh<H! juk<kqVg<gqOxe<?! lx<xhc! fie<! okiPjg! Ofie<H! -ux<xqz<!nkqgh<hm!Osgvl<!osb<buqz<jz}}!we<xiI/!!! nh<OhiK! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!

)nz<.lId! .! lnle<.nah<h*! ÄÄleqke<! biI! bijv! dgf<kiOei!nuIgOtiOmOb!NgqbqVh<hie<}}!we<X!%xqeiIgt</!!! ÄÄweK! nUzqbig<gt<! we<Ejmb! hiqum<mk<kqx<Gt<!-Vg<gqe<xiIgt</! we<jebe<xq! OuX! biVl<! nxqb! lim<miIgt<}}! we<X!-jxue<!%xqbkig!akQ K!GK^qbqz<!uf<Kt<tK/!



!

!



113

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! nUzqbig<gt<?!GKHliIgt<!dzgk<Kg<G!LjtgtiuiIgt</!!! nzzia<uqe! hijkbqz<! Nuqgjt! kk<kl! osb<kqVg<gg<%cb!fikig<gtie! nUzqbig<gt<! uhik<kqx<Gh<! hqxGl<! abik<KttuIgt <!wek<! kqVljx! sie<X! hgVgqe<xK/! ne<eiIgOt! agQ gk<kqz<!dzgk<jkg<!g{<gi{qh<huIgt<!we!fibg!uig<gqbl<!Ohikqg<gqe<xK/!!! dzgqe<! wf<k! Ogi{k<kqzqVf<Kl<! lieqmI! wf<kg<! gizk<kqZl<!-ghvk<kqx<gig! fx<gVlr<gjtg<! Gxqk<K! nuIgt<hiz<! dkuq! Okmz<!%Ml</!nux<jx!fqjxOux<xq!jug<Gl<!sg<kqjb!nuIgTg<G!nz<zia<!ntqkKt<tie</! -l<liohVl<! kk<Kul<! nuIgtqmk<kqz<! BgLcU! ujv!-Vg<gOu! osb<Bl</! NuIgtK! kqVfilr<gt<! Nhk<K! gizk<kqz<!nVlVf<kiBl<?!Nef<k!slbk<kqz<!nlqIkliBl<!-Vg<gqe<xe/!!! ÄÄsqxqK! Ofvl<! nUzqbig<gTjmb! sguisk<kqzqVh<hK?!Lg^<Kkqbx<x! F~X! uVm! u{g<gk<jk! uqm! OlzieK}}! we<X!

oltziei!'lq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!l^<euq!]iQ hqz<!olipq<f<Kt<tiIgt</!!! uzqBz<ziju! Ofsqg<gqxue<! nuIgtK! kqVs<se<eqkiek<kqz<!-Vg<jgbqz<! nuIgjt! lxf<K! yV! uqeicObElqviOk"! \ig<gqvjk"}}!weUl<! ^0kQ ! ]Q xi^q! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!Ohi^<kieqz<!ws<siqk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄdbqOviM!-Vg<jgbqOzi?!dzgk<kjk!uqm<M!ljxf<k!hqe<eOvi!nz<zia<uqe<!uzq!-mk<kqz<! osix<h!OfvlibqEl<!-Vh<hK!nlz<gtqz<!

OlzieK}}! we<hkig! îzqaQe<gtqz<! sqzVg<G! fhq! ohVlieiI!^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! geuqz<! gim<sq! ntqk<K!%xqBt<tiIgt<! we<hkig! nz<zili! ]aiHk<kQ e<! -HE! ]|\ibQ !vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! we<x! ohiqbiI! xqîzi.-Khik<K.gxilik<kqz<! nUzqbi! 343uK! hg<gk<kqz<! osiz<zqBt<tiIgt</! ! OlZl<!-jk! akQ g<gk<Ke<.ekqb<bi.hQ.]vaqk<kiQ g<gqz<! Lal<lkqb<bi! we<x!F~zqe<! 3uK!higl<?! 92uK! hg<gk<kqz<!nz<-lil<!j]G!nh<Kz<! geq!fihz< q!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!nxquqk<Kt<tiIgt</!!! NgOukie<?! dzOgil<Hl<! dk<klIgt<! wz<OziVl<! Gk<HliIgt<!

djmb!-z<zr<gtqe<!uibqz<gjtg<!gik<Kg<!gqmf<keI/!OlZl<?!gik<Kg<!gqmg<gqe<xeI/!!! -k<kjgb! Heqklie! laik<lig<gjtk<! kie<! Nk<l! Rielx<x!nxquqzqgt<!sqzI!K~x<Xgqe<xeI/!!



!

!



114

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! Hgiiq! akQkqz<?! nH,a|jvvi! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|!nuIgjtk<!okim<Ml<!iquibk<K!uf<Kt<tK;.!!! ÄÄwue<!yVue<!we<Ejmb!uzqliIgTme<!hjgjls<!osb<uiOei!nue<!we<Eme<!OhiI!osb<ukx<G!kbivig!-Vf<K!ogit<tm<Ml<!we<X!nz<zia<! %xqbkig! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!kqVUtlieiIgt<"}}!!! Hk<kqBjmb!yu<ouiV!&lqe<!lg<gt<!nxqbg<!%cb!uq]bliuK;.!ÄÄnUzqbig<gjt! -e<giI! osb<ujkg<! ogi{<M! azig<G! )fisl<*!djmb!ht<tk<kqz<!uqp!Ou{<mil</!Woee<xiz<!nf<k!-e<giI!Njtg<!ogiz<zg<!%cb!ogicb!uq]l</!nK!dr<gjtg<!ogie<X!uqMl</!-jk!wr<gTg<G! Le<OeiIgt<! gizk<kqZl<! wr<gtqe<! gizk<kqZl<!hqvk<kqbm<slig! g{<cVg<gqOxil<}}! we<X! -lil<! -HE! a\I! lg<gQ!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! kr<gTjmb! hkiuiuqz<! kQ Ih<Hs<!osb<Kt<tiIgt</!!

! wuoeiVue<! ogm<m! w{<{k<jkg<! ogi{<M! nUzqbig<gjt!Ofiuqjes<! osb<uiOebieiz<! kqm<mlig! nue<! ]iQ nk<kqe<! )kibqvi*!wz<jgjb! uqm<Ml<! outqOb! Hxk<kqbqz<! Ngquqm<mie<}}! we<X! atvk<!o]b<Gz<! ng<hI!LaqkQe<! -HE!nvhq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi!ne<a|!osiz<zqBt<tiIgt</!!! ytzqbig<gjtBl<! NzqlQ e<gtie! dzlig<gjtBl<! hjgjl!ogit<ukigqxK! sqe<e! uq]bl<! nz<z?! lqGkl<! OhIgtqmk<kqz<! nK!GHV!we<hkigUl<!hbh<hmh<hMgqxK/!!

! ytzqbig<gjt! fijug<! ogi{<Omi?! gz<jhg<! ogi{<Omi?! nf<k!ytzqbig<gt<! abik<kieuIgtigOui! nz<zK! uhik<kieuIgtigOui!-Vf<kiZl<!siqOb?!wh<hc!NeiZl<!nuIgjt!-e<giI!osb<ukigqxK/!sf<Okglqe<xq! Gh<vig! -Vg<Gl</! lKaHgtqe<! Okm<mvUh<hc!L^<zQ l<gtqe<! -\<lijug<! ogi{<M! gihqvig! -Vg<Gl</! Woee<xiz<?!nue<?!kQEz<!-^<zik<jkBl<?!]iQ nk<K!Lal<lkqb<bijuBOl!-e<giI!osb<K! uqm<mie<! we<hOk/! -u<uqkl<! o]b<G! nh<Kz<! geq! fihqz< Q !vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!akQ gk<Ke<ekqb<bi!2.uK!higl<?!276.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!uqiquigg<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!

! -KOhiOu! ]va|! \uiaqiqe<! F^|z<! 3.uK! higl<! 6:.uK!hg<gk<kqZl<!Gxqh<hqm<Mt<tiIgt</!!! weOu! nUzqbig<gOtiM! Olikk<! K{qgqe<xuIgt<! -k<kjgb!hbr<gv! ws<siqg<jggjt! gueqk<K! fe<jljb! fic! d{<jljb!d{If<K!ogit<tm<Ml</!



!

!



115

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! Wguz<z! -jxuOe"! deK! Ofsk<kqx<Ggf<k! fz<zcbiIgjt!ofR<s!lR<siK! fqf<kqg<Gl<! -f<k! fbuR<sgIgTg<G! fQ Ob! fz<z! Hk<kq!ogiMg<g!Ou{<Ml</!!! ne<hIgOt"!-jxOfss<!osz<uIgtie!nUzqbig<gt<!osb<k!gMl<!kur<gote<e"! -hikk<Kgote<e"! nuIgjtg<! ogi{<M! -u<jubgl<!njmf<kqVg<Gl<! nkqI]<mr<gote<e"! fz<z! f Q Hgote<e"! -k<kjgb!ohXkx<giqb!hig<gqbr<gjt!njmf<kkx<G!fil<!biK!jgl<liX!ntqg<g!uz<Ozil<"! we<hjk! fqjek<K?! ofRSVgq! leliv! -jxuEg<G! fe<xq!osZk<kqk<! Kkqg<g! Ou{<c! -Vg<g! K~x<XuK! we<e! fqbibl<"! nK!lqgh<ohiqb! nfQkl<"! -k<kjgb! nfqbibg<giv! sqx<xxqUjmbuIgjt!oltziei! \ziZk<kQ e<! 'lq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!l^<euq! ]iQ hqz<! Gxqh<hqMgqe<x! uPg<jgk<! kjzBjmb! gqtqg<G!yh<higk<!kie<!osiz<z!Ou{<Ml<?!wu<uioxeqz<;.!!! hzsvg<G! gjm! juk<kqVf<k! yV! uqbihiiq! gqtqobie<X!

utIk<kie</!nK?!-eqb!GvOzijsBl<?!hR<suI{!fqxLl<!ohx<xqVf<kK/!OhSl<!ke<jlBt<t!nf<k!gqtq!nueK!gjmg<G!giuzigUl<!-Vg<Gl</!uicg<jggivIgtqml<! uqgmligUl<! OhSl</! yVfit<! gjmg<give<!uQm<cx<Gh<Ohib<!-Vf<k!slbl<!gjmg<Gg<!giuzib<!-Vf<kK!gqtq/!!! H,jeobie<X!wzqjbh<!hqch<hkx<G!kqCove!gjmbqEt<!Gkqk<kK/!njkg<g{<mKl<! dbqVg<gR<sq! gqtq! uqv{<M! hxf<Okicx<X/! nkeiz<!gjmbqz<! nMg<gq! jug<gh<hm<cVf<k! hikl<! w{<j{! sQ sig<gt<! gQ Op!uqPf<K!djmf<ke/!!

! gjmg<give<! kqVl<hq! uf<kie</! sQ sig<gt<! djmf<K! w{<j{!ogim<c! gqmh<hjkg<! g{<mue</! Nk<kqvl<! ogi{<M! gqtqbqe<! kjzbqz<!ncgt<! hz! ogiMk<kie</! nkeiz<! nke<! kjz! uPg<jgbigquqm<mK/!Ohs<jsBl<!nK! lxf<K! Ohibqx<X/! -e<eqjzjbg<! g{<M! gjmg<give<!jgOskh<hm<M! ke<jek<kiOe! ofif<K! ogi{<mie</! nK! lQtUl<! lKv!olipq!Ohsiki!we<X!Wr<gqfqe<xie</!!! fim<gt<! sqz! gpqf<ke/! gl<htq! Njm! n{qf<k! hvOksqobiVuI?!kqxf<k!uPg<jgk<! kjzBme<!nu<upqOb!ose<xiI/!nujvg<! g{<mKl<!gqtq!dvg<gg<!gk<kq!ÄÄY!uPg<jgk<kjzbiOv"!biK!giv{k<kiz<!fQ Vl<!

uPg<jg! -ek<jks<! OsIf<kQ I"! we<jeh<! OhizOu! sQsiju! djmk<K!w{<j{jbg<!ogim<c!nke<!&zl<!-f<k!gkq!njmf<kQ vi@}}!we<X!Ohs!Nvl<hqk<kK/!!



!

!



116

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

! gqtqbqe<! -k<kjgb! Dgk<jkg<! g{<M! nr<gqVf<k! biuVl<!fjgk<Ks<! sqiqk<keI/! Woeeqz<! gl<htqk<K{q! n{qf<kujv! nK!ke<jeh<OhizOu!hiuqk<kkeiOzbil</!!! oltziei! 'lq! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! OlZl<!nxqUXk<Kgqe<xiIgt</!nK!uVliX;.!!! ÄÄhiqSk<k! laie<gtqe<! osbz<gjt! deK! sqx<xxqU! ogi{<M!LcU! osb<K! uqmiOk! ÄO]I}?! Ä]Q }! we<X! ujvukqz<! wPk<Kg<gt<!)]Q e<?W?Ov*! yk<kqVf<k! OhikqZl<! nIk<kk<kqz<! uqk<kqbisl<! d{<M/!leqkje! nck<Kg<! ogi{<M! Hsqg<Gl<! Hzqg<G! O]I! weh<hMgqe<xK/!nue<! Gck<Kh<! hVGl<! hiZg<G! ]Q I! weh<hMgqe<xK/! Olx<osie<e!-f<kg<!gqtqjbh<!Ohiz<!Hk<kq!hjmk<k!GjxlkqbitIgt<!kh<hhqh<hqvibl<!ogi{<m! giv{k<kiOzOb! dzgk<kqeI! upq! hqsgqh<! Ohib<uqm<meI/!nu<zqbiUz<zig<gtqe<! osbz<gjt! fz<zxqU! hjmk<k! yV! sqzOv!uqtr<gqg<! ogi{<miIgt</! Kx<hig<gqbuie<gtie! lx<xuIgTg<G! nK!hx<xqb! d{<jl! nxqUgt<! d{<migq! -Vg<guqz<jz! Nkzqe<?!

nuIgTjmb! hiIjug<G! fz<zKl<?! ogm<mKl<?! ye<X! OhizOu!Okie<xqe/! kr<gtqe<! kuxie! w{<{k<kqe<! giv{k<kiz<! nuIgt<!ne<hqbig<gjtk<! kr<gTg<G! -j{big<gqeiIgt<?! nUzqbig<gjt!kr<gjth<! OhizOu! sllig!w{<{qg<! ogi{<miIgt</!fiLl<! leqkIgt<!kie<?! nuIgTl<! leqkIgt<! kie<! weUl<?! fiLl<! d{<[gqOxil</!dxr<GgqOxil</! nuIgTl<! d{<[gqxiIgt<?! dxr<GgqxiIgt<! weUl<!slh<hMk<kq! kh<Hg<! g{g<G! Ohim<Mg<! ogi{<cVf<kiIgt</! nuIgTg<Gl<!kr<gTg<Gl<!-jmOb!ljzOhie<x!uqk<kqbisr<gt<!d{<migq!-Vf<kjk!nuIgt<!GVm<Mk<!ke<jlbiz<!nxqf<kqVg<guqz<jz/!!

! hiVr<gt<"! Gtuq?! OkeQ ! -f<k! -V! Jf<Kg<gTl<! yOv!-mk<kqzqVf<Ok?! nkiuK! .! lzIgtqzqVf<Ok! lKju! nVf<Kgqe<xe/!Neiz<! GtuqbqzqVf<K!uq]!ws<sqZl<?! OkeQ bqzqVf<K! lKvlieOkEl<!dx<hk<kqbigqe<xe/!!! -Vujg! lie<gt<! Hz<jzbl<! k{<{Q jvBl<kie<! nVf<Kgqe<xe/!yV! ujgbqzqVf<K! ouXl<! HTg<jgBl<?! uqm<jmBl<! lx<x!ujgbqzqVf<K!g^<K~iqBl<!d{<miguqz<jzbi@!!! -Vuqk! fi{z<gt<! Nx<xr<gjvbqz<! yOv! k{<{Qjvk<! kie<!

nVf<Kgqe<xe/! nux<Xt<! ye<X! ouXl<! &r<gqzigqe<xK/! lx<xK!-e<hvsk<Kme<! gVl<higqe<xK/!-u<uqklig! wk<kjeObi!dkiv{r<gt<!%xzil</!!! -e<El<! hiVr<gt<"! YVue<! d{<[gqe<xie</! nueqz<! fqe<X!ouXl<!nSk<kOl!outqbigqe<xK/!lx<oxiVuVl<!d{<[gqe<xiI/!nK!



!

!



117

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

Lx<xqZl<! -jxueK! )F~I*! O\ikqbig! liXgqe<xK/! kQ bue<!d{<[gqxie</! nkqzqVf<K! Ogihl<?! ohixijl?! Lkzqbju!d{<migqe<xe/! fz<zuI! d{<[gqxiI! nke<! &zl<! -jx! O\ikqh<!hqvgisLl<?!RieLl<?!okb<uQgg<!gikZl<!d{<migqe<xe/!!! fx<gVlr<gt<! HiqBl<! fz<zuI! Sk<klie?! utLjmb! fqzlig!-Vg<gqxiI/!kQ b!giiqbr<gtqz<!kjzbqMl<!ogm<muI!dhObiglx<x!duI!fqzlig! -Vg<gqe<xiI/!Lf<kqbuI!hiqSk<kuieig!-Vg<gqxiI/! hqf<kqbuI!K]<mvigUl<?! nSvvigUl<?! -Vg<gqe<xiI/! Okix<xk<kqz<! nu<uqVuVjmb!dVuLl<!ye<X!OhizOu!yk<kqVf<k!OhikqZl<!we<e@!!! OlZl<! hiVr<gt<"!LKvlie! fz<z!k{<{Q Vl<?!jgh<hie!dh<Hk<!k{<{Q Vl<! hiIjug<G! ye<X! OhizOu! -Vg<gqe<xe/! Neiz<?! fiuqz<!juk<K! Vsq! hiIk<kkx<gh<hiz<kie<! -v{<cx<Gl<! uqk<kqbisl<! okiqb!uVgqxK/! nEhuqk<K! nxqhujek<! kuqv! OuX! wuEl<! nf<k! fQ iqe<!ke<jljb! nxqb! lim<mie</! nh<hch<hm<m! nEhusizqgjtOb! fQ!Okcbjmkz<! Ou{<Ml</! Woeeqz<?! nuIgOt! gsh<H! fQ jvBl<?! lKv!

fQ jvBl<?! hqxqk<kxquiIgt</! hkiIk<kr<gtqe<! Sjujb! Vsqk<kxqhujvk<!kuqv! OuX! biVl<! nxqb! lim<miI/! OkjeBl<! olPjgBl<! wh<hc!OuXhMk<kq!nxqb!LcBl<@}}!!! -u<uixig!oltzie!'lq!vzqbz<zia|!kNzi!ne<a|!nuIgt<!gjk!'hlib<h<!Ohikje!osb<Kt<tiIgt</!!! biuVl<! fe<G! uqtr<gq! nxqBl<! ohiVm<M! Yi! dkiv{l<!%Xgqe<Oxil</! sikiv{!-Vl<jh! biVl<! jgbiz<! okimzil</!Nkeiz<!wk<kjgb! kQr<Gl<! -z<jz/! Neiz<! njk! ofVh<hqz<! Ohim<miOzi!

nkx<Gs<! $M{<migq! squf<K! nKUl<! ofVh<higOu! gi{h<hMgqe<xK/!keK! Sbfqxligqb! gXjljbh<! Ohig<gq! ofVh<hqe<! fqxligqs<!osl<jljbh<! ohXgqe<xK/!nK! slbl<! wuVl<!njkk<! okimLcbiK/!okim<miOzi! giqk<Kh<OhiMl</! -u<uiOx!nz<zia<uqe<! \zizqbk<okEl<!ofVh<Hk<! ke<jljbh<! ohx<x! nUzqbig<gt<! Lkzqz<! sikiv{!leqkIgtib<! -Vf<k! OhikqZl<! nueqe<! G{k<jkg<! ogi{<m! hqxG!keqh<hm<m! lgk<KuLl<! li{<Hl<! sg<kqBl<! ohx<x! Olkiuqgtigq!uqMgqe<xiIgt</!!! weOu!GINe<?!akQ K?!-\<li0?!gqbi^<!Ngqbux<jxg<!ogi{<M!

OlOz! yVuiX! %xqBt<Otil</! nux<Xg<gikivlig! L0khvie!gqvf<kr<gtqz<!sqzux<jx!Olx<Ogitigg<!gi{<hqk<kqVg<gqe<Oxil</!!! GINe<?! akQ K?! -\<li0?! gqbi <! -ux<Xt<! sqzjk! yh<Hg<!ogi{<M! sqzjkk<! kt<TuiOebieiz<! nue<! ^|e<ek<K! uz<!\link<jk!uqm<Ml<!fQ r<gqeueiuie</!



!

!



118

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

!! ÄÄfhqgt<! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<!gizk<kqz<! yV! uqMk<kl<! fmf<k! ^|e<ek<kiguqVf<kiZl<! siq?! hz!uqMk<kl<! fmf<k! ^|e<ek<kiguqVf<kiZl<! siq?! nux<Xt<! ye<jx!-Ozsigg<! g{<miZl<?!-e<giI!osb<kiZl<!Gh<V!d{<migq!uqMole<X!liIg<gk<kqOzx<hm<cVg<g?! YI! uqMk<kl<! fmf<k! ^|e<ek<KkiOe! we<X!osiz<uKlqe<xq?! nf<k! ^|e<ek<jkk<! okimvilz<! -e<giVl<!osb<gqe<xiIgt</! -K! lqg! lqg! Ns<siqbl<"}}! we<X! oltziei! ]ia<!Laqb<bqk<kQe<! îgqH! OuZ~iQ ! vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<!h <Zz<!gqkih<!93.uK!hg<gk<kqz<!oktqUhmg<!%xqBt<tiIgt</!!! ÄÄweK!dl<lk<Kg<gt<!hqx<gizk<kqz<!wPhk<kq!&e<X!%m<mr<gtigh<!hqiquiIgt</!nkqz<!wPhk<kqv{<M!%m<mr<gt<!fvguikqgt</!yV!%m<mk<kiI!lik<kqvl<! =Omx<xljmuiIgt<}}! we<X! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq!u^z<zl<!%xqbOhiK?!ÄÄnf<k!yV!%m<mk<kiI!biI@!we<X!Ogm<gh<hm<mK/!!! ÄÄfiEl<! weK! n^<aihqgTl<! wf<k! ye<xqe<! Ohiqz<!

kiqg<gh<hm<cVg<gqOxiOli! nf<k! ye<xqe<! Ohiqz<! kiqh<hm<muIgtig!-Vg<Gl<}}! we<X! ohVlieiI! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgt<!uqtg<gh<hMk<kqeiIgt</!)kqIlkq!-HEli\i!.!nH,kiU,K*!!! Olx<Gxqh<hqm<mhc! fibgl<! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<!nuIgTl<?! nuIgtK! nVjlk<! OkipIgTl<! wf<kouie<xqe<Ohiqz<!kiqh<hm<cVg<gqxiIgOti?! nf<k! ye<xqe<! Ohiqz<! kiqh<hm<muIgt<kie<!^|e<ek<K!uz<.\link<Kg<!%m<mk<kivig!-Vg<Gl</!-uIgt<!kie<!nf<k!84!%m<mk<kiiqz<!=Omx<xl<!ohx<x!yV!%m<mk<kivig!-Vg<Gl</!!

! OlZl<?! se<liIg<gk<! OkIs<sqohxik! sqz! nuilqgtie! \er<gt<!kh< Q I!RieOli?!akQkqe<!kik<hiqbOli!uqtr<gilz<!klK!lek<kqx<Gk<!Okie<xqb! hqvgivolz<zil<! GINe<! ]iQ hqe<! Nbk<Kg<gTg<G! ^hH!F^|z<! okiqbilz<! kh<Hf<kuXligh<! ohiVt<! %xq! Olx<ogit<! gim<m!Lx<hm<cVg<gqe<xeI/!!! ÄÄGINEg<Gk<! keK! osif<k! Obisjejbg<! ogi{<M!uqbig<gqbieR<! osb<uiOebieiz<! nue<! gihqvigq! uqm<mie</}}! weUl<?!ÄÄwue<! ke<Ejmb! Sb! nxqjug<! ogi{<M! )keK! Ofig<gk<kqe<hc*!GINEg<G! uqbig<gqbiel<! osb<gqxiOei! nue<! ke<Ejmb! -mk<jk!

fvgk<kqz<! OkIf<K! wMk<Kg<ogit<uie<}}! weUl<! kqVk<K~kI! Lal<lK!L^<khi! ^z<zz<zia|! njzaq! u^z<zl<! nuIgt<! kqVuib<!lzIf<kVtqBt<tiIgt</!!! liIg<gl<! -e<eokek<! okiqbikuIgt<?! fir<gTl<!-^<zik<kqx<gigs<! Osju! osb<gqe<Oxil<! .! -]ink<Ks<! osb<gqe<Oxil<!



!

119

Gk<hqb<bi!le<\qz<

weh<!hjxsix<xqg<ogi{<M?!GINe<!Nbk<KgTg<Gk<!kiXlixig!lekqz<!Okie<xqbhcobz<zil<! nIk<kr<! %xq?! neIk<kl<! osb<K?! d{<jlbie!dzlig<gjtBl<?! NiqhQ e<gjtBl<! K~]{qh<hjkOb! okipqzigg<!ogi{<Mt<teI/! ne<euIgTjmb! Ou]l<! ouTk<K! nuVjmb!KOu]s<! osbjz! dzGg<G! d{Ik<k! -u<outqbQ M! dkbligq!-Vg<gqe<xK/!!! GINEg<G! tiaqI?! hik<kqe<! )dt<tvr<gl<?! outqbvr<gl<*!-Vuqkh<! ohiVt<g{<M/! -u<uqv{<jmBl<! gjmh<hqck<K! yPgq!fmh<huIgOt! d{<jl! dzlig<gtiuiIgt</! OlOz?! -Vuqk!nhqh<hqvibr<gjtBl<! gi{<hqk<kqVh<hkiz<! uqtr<gqg<! ogit<ts<!sg<kqbx<xuIgt<! GkIg<gR<! osb<biK?!tiaqI.hik<kqe<! -v{<jmBlxqf<k!dzlig<gtqml<!Ogm<Mk<!okiqf<K!ogit<uiIgtig"!!! gqVjhBt<t! nz<zia<kNzi! fl<ljeujvBl<! nf<k! upqogm<m!wPhk<kqv{<M! %m<mr<gtqz<! fqe<Xl<! uqzg<gq?! =lije! -pg<gilZl<?!Gh<jv!ofVr<gilZl<!gih<hix<xq!oux<xq!ohx<x!^|e<ek<.uz<.\link<Kg<!

%m<mk<kqOzOb!fqjzohxs<!osb<K?!npgie!Lk<kqvir<glie?!a|^<Ez<!gik<kqliuie!fz<Lcjuk<!kf<kVt<uieig/!NlQe</!!! OlZl<!nz<zili?!NiqHhqz<zia<?!-lil<!-^<libQz<!ag<gQ!h'^q!vzqbz<zia|! kNzi! ne<a|! nuIgt<! 'a|z<! hbie<?! 5.uK! higl<?!248uK! hg<gk<kqz<! N{<mue<hiz<! hqxiIk<kqg<Gl<! KNUme<! fil<!H,Ik<kqBxs<!osb<gqe<Oxil</!n0kiuK;.!!! ÄÄnu<zqbig<gjtBl?! nuIgtK! gHVgjtBl<! \qbivk<Kh<!HiqujkBl<! nuIgt<hiz<! dkuq! OkMujkBl<! -e<giI! osb<gqxue<!

wMk<okxqbh<hm<m! j]k<kijeh<! Ohiziuie</! Njgbiz?! -k<kjgb!-egiIgtqz<! fir<gt<! Olisl! Ohiujk! uqm<Ml<!hiKgik<Kg<ogit<Tl<hc?! bi! nz<zia<?! ncbiIgtigqb! fir<gt<!

Documents

Hidhayathul Anam Ila Ziyarathul Auliyal Il Kiram