Ilenkovskie chteniya 2010

" "

" " "

2010.

II

13-14 2010

.

2________________________________________________________

101.1+101.8 15

2010. : II (13-14 2010 ., . ) / . . .. . .: "", 2010. 420 .

.

II " 2010. ", - .

101.1+101.8 15

ISBN : .. : .. ([email protected]), .. ([email protected]) : .. ([email protected]) ISBN , 2010

________________________________________________________3

:

.. (. , ) . .................. 16

.. (. ) : , , . ......................................... 19

.. (. , ) - ........... 28

.. (. ) ......................................................................... 29

.. (. , ) ................ 31

.. (. ) ................................................. 32

. (. , ) " " ................................ 33

.. (. , ) ................................................................................. 35

.. (. , ) ........................................................... 37

.. (. -, ) ............................ 38

.. (. , ) ................................ 39

.. (. ) causa sui ........................................................ 41

.. (. ) .............................................................. 42

.. (. ) ....................................... 43

.. (. , ) "-" ...................................... 44

.. (. , ) - .................................................... 47

.. (. ) "" .................................................................................... 48

.. (. ) .......... 55

.. (. , ) ......... 57

.. (. ) , .............................................................................................. 59

.. (. -, ) . .......................................... 62

4________________________________________________________

.. (. ) ........................................................................................ 63

.. (. ) ............................................................... 64

.. (. ) . . ................................................................ 73

.. (. ) ....................................................... 75

.. (. ) " " ......................................... 77

.. (. ) : ...................... 78

.. (. ) ............................................................. 80

.. (. ) .. : -? ............. 81

. (. ) ..................................................................................... 83

.. (. , ) ............................................................................................. 84

.. (. ) ................................... 85

.. (. , ) ..................... 87

.. (. ) - ............ 88

.. (. ) "" "" - .............................. 90

.. (. -) (. , .. , .. ) ................................................ 91

.. (. , ) ...................................... 92

.. (. ) "" ......................................................... 93

.. (. , ) - ............................................................................... 95

.. (. , ) . . : .......................................................................................................................... 96

.. (. ) , ...................................... 97

________________________________________________________5

.. (. ) .......................................................................... 99

.. (. ) XIX-XX .................................................................................. 101

.. (. ) .................................................... 102

.. (. , ) ................................................ 104

.. (. ) ( - . ) .................. 105

. (. , ) .................................................................. 106

.. (. ) "" ........................................... 111

.. (. ) , .............................................. 112

. (. ) .......................... 113

.. (. ) : ............................................................... 114

.. (. ) "" ................................ 115

.. (. ) - ............................... 117

.. (. ) ........... 118

.. (. ) ............................................................................. 120

.. (. ) ..................... 121

.. (. ) ................................................... 123

.. (. , ) " " ........ 124

.. (. ) ................................................. 125

.. (. ) .................................................................... 126

6________________________________________________________

.. (. ) ? .............................................................. 128

.. (. ) . ........................................................ 129

.. (. ) . .......... 131

.. (. ) ............ 133

.. (. ) "" .............................................................. 134

.. (. -, ) ....................................... 135

.. (. ) .. ....................................... 137

.. (. , ) ................................................... 138

.. (. ) ........................................................................ 140

.. (. , ) , ....................................................................... 141

.. (. ) ............................................................................................ 142

.. (. , ) " " .. .................................... 144

.. (. , ) .. 145

.. (. ) .............................................................. 146

.. (. ) ? ........................................ 148

.. (. , ) .. .................. 149

.. (.) .. ....................... 151

.. (. ) ........................................................................ 152

.. (. ) ...................................................................... 153

.. (. ) ............................................................................... 154

.. (. ) .. ................................................... 156

________________________________________________________7

.. (. --, ) . .: ...................... 158

.. (. ) .. ....................... 159

.. (. ) ........................................................... 163

.. (. , ) .................... 164

.. (. ) ? ........... 166

.. (. ) "" ("ideelle") ................................................................... 168

.. ( .) ........................................................................... 169

.. (. , ) .......................... 171

.. (. ) .............................................................................. 172

.. (. ) . , ......................................................... 173

.. (. ) ............................... 174

.. (. , ) .................................................. 176

.. (. , ) "" ..................................... 177

.. (. -, ) .......................................................... 178

.. (. ) ................................................................................. 179

.. (. , ) ..................... 181

.. (. , ) - .................................... 182

.. (. ) .. ................................................... 183

.. (. ) Solitudinem faciunt, pacem appelant .............................................................. 185

.. (.) .................................................. 186

8________________________________________________________

Kobzeva N.A. (Tomsk, Russia) Teaching critical thinking skills based on board game scrabble at english classes .................................................... 187

.. (. ) ............................................... 189

.. (. , ) "homo economicos" ............................................................ 191

.. (. ) ? ................................................... 192

.. (. , ) ? .................................................. 193

.. (. , ) .................................. 194

.. (. , ) ? ........................................................................... 196

.. (. ) : ........................................................................... 197

.. (. ) ? ............................................................................. 199

.. (. , ) ............................... 200

.. (. ) .................................................... 202

.. (. ) : , ? .................................................. 203

.. (. ) .......................................................................................... 204

.. (. ) , ..................... 206

.. (. ) .................................. 207

.. (. ) .................................................................... 208

.. (. ) ? .......................................................................... 210

.. (. , ) .. .. ........... 211

.. (. , ) ................................... 212

.. (. , ) - ................................................. 213

________________________________________________________9

.. (. -, ) .............................................................. 215

.. (. -) , : ............................................. 216

.. (. ) . .................................. 217

.. (.) .............................................................................. 218

.. (. , ) ......................................... 220

.. (. ) .................................................... 225

.. (. ) "" "" ..................................................... 226

.. (. ) .......................................... 228

.. (. , ) ............................................................................. 229

.. (. , ) .............................................................. 231

.. (. , ) : ? ......................................................... 233

.. (. ) : ............................ 234

.. (. ) ......................................................................... 235

.. (. -) "" .................... 237

.. (. , ) ? ........................................................................... 238

.. (. , ) .......................................................................... 239

.. (. ) "" ................. 241

.. (. ) ........................................ 242

.. (. , ) - ..................................... 243

.. (. ) : ...................................................................................... 244

.. (. ) - ................... 245

10________________________________________________________

.. (. ) ....................................................... 246

.. (. ) ................................................ 247

.. (. ) ........................................................ 250

.. (. ) .................. 251

.. (. --, ) .............................................................. 252

.. (. ) .................................... 254

.. (. ) - " " . ................................................................. 255

.. (. ) ........................................................ 256

.. (. ) "" ..................................................... 258

.. (. , ) ................................................................. 259

.. (. ) ...................................................................... 260

.. (. ) .. .............................................................. 262

.. (. , ) .................................................................... 263

.. (.) : " " ................................................... 265

.. (. ) ................................ 267

.. (. ) .................... 268

.. (. , ) " " ........................................ 270

.. (. ) , ........................... 271

________________________________________________________11

.. (. ) .................................................................... 273

.. (. , ) ....................................... 274

.. (. ) "" ........................................................ 275

.. (. , ) : ..... 276

.. (. ) .............................. 278

.. (. ) .......................................................... 279

.. (. ) ............................... 281

.. (. ) " " . ....................................... 283

.. (. ) ................................... 284

.. (. ) ................................................................... 285

.. (. ) : ............................... 286

.. (. ) ....................................................... 288

.. (. , ) .................... 289

.. (. ) ..................................................................... 291

.. (. ) .. . ........................ 292

.. (. , ) : ................................................................ 294

.. (. ) .. .............. 295

.. (. ) ................................................................................. 297

.. (. ) .................................................................. 299

.. (. , ) - ........................... 300

12________________________________________________________

.. (. ) ? ................................ 301

.. (. ) .. ......................................... 303

.. (. ) ............................................................ 304

.. (. ) ................................................... 307

.. (. , ) ..................................................... 308

.. (. , ) .............................................. 310

.. (. ) : .................................................... 310

.. (. ) ..................................................................................... 312

.. (. ) ............ 313

.. (. , ) ......................................... 314

.. (. ) "" : ......................................................................... 315

.. (. , ) - ............................................................................ 317

.. (. ) ............................................................ 318

.. (. ) ......................................................... 319

.. (. ) ...................................................................................... 320

.. (. ) ........................................................................................ 322

.. (. ) .......................................... 323

.. (. ) .............................................. 325

.. (. ) .. ...................................................... 326

.. (. ) ................................... 330

________________________________________________________13

.. (. , ) : .. .......................................... 331

.. (. ) ........................................................... 332

.. (. ) ................................................................................... 333

.. (. ) ............................................................ 335

.. (. ) "" "" "" "" ......................................................................................................... 337

.. (. , ) .......................................................................... 338

.. (. ) " " .................................. 339

.. (. --, ) .. ................................................. 340

.. (. ) . - .................................................... 342

.. (. ) ? .... 343

.. (. ) ............................................................ 344

.. (. , ) .. . ...... 346

.. (. ) ....................................................................... 347

.. (. ) ..................................................... 348

.. (. ) - ................................................................ 349

.. (. ) .. . ............... 351

.. (. ) ................................................................................ 352

.. (. ) .. ............................ 353

.. (. , ) : .. . ............................ 355

.. (. , ) ................................................................... 356

.. (. , ) ............................ 357

.. (. ) ................................................................................... 358

14________________________________________________________

.. (. ) - ............. 360

.., .. (. ) : ....................... 361

.. (. , ) : ................................... 363

.. (. , ) ................................................ 364

.. (. ) ....................................... 366

.. (. ) " " .................................................................... 367

.. (. ) ........................................... 368

.. (. , ) ................................................................ 370

.. (. ) - ......................................................... 371

.. (. ) ....................................................................... 372

.. (. --, ) .. ........................................ 374

.. (. ) ..................................................... 375

.. (. ) : ..................... 376

.. (. ) ....................................................................................................... 377

.. (. ) .............................. 379

.. (. ) .................................................... 380

.. (. ) : ......................................... 381

.. (. , ) " " ................................................................ 383

.. (. ) ....................................................................................... 384

.. (. ) "" .............................................. 385

________________________________________________________15

.. (. ) .............................................. 387

.. (. ) .............................................. 388

.. (. ) "" "" .......................................................... 390

.. (. ) : - .................................................. 391

.. (. ) ................................... 392

.. (. , ) - ................................................. 394

.. (. ) "" "" : ............ 396

.. (. ) ................................................................. 397

.. (. ) .................................................................... 399

.. (. ) ................................................................... 400

.. (. , ) ............................... 401

.. (. ) - ............................... 403

. ( 2 . - ) ...................................................................................... 407

. ( 2 ) ? ................................................................. 409

. ( 2 . - ) .......................................................................... 411

. ( 2 . -. ) . ................................................................................ 412

. ( 2 . - ) ? ................................................. 414

. ( 2 ) .. " , ". ........... 415

. ( 2 . - ) ? ....................................................................................... 417

. ( 3 . - ) ................................................................................. 418

16________________________________________________________

.. (. , ) [email protected]

.

" " , , "". . , , , .

, . , , .

, , . , . , . a priori.

: , . : " , ", . , , !

, , , , , , ? , , , , .

, , , , , , : "" .

, : , , . , , , . ?

________________________________________________________17

, , , . , , , , . . , .

: , , , . . : " ". , . : , , , .

, , , .

. , . , . , , , , , , .

"", . , , . , , , "" . , , .

, , , . , .

. , .. . . . , , . , .. , , , . - , . , .

- - ,

18________________________________________________________

- , . . , , - , . , , , , , .

. - . , , , , .

, , , .. , - . .

, , ?

. , , .. .

, , ... , - , , .

" ",

" ", . ..

________________________________________________________19

.. (. ) [email protected]

: , , . . . .

. : . , . : " ". ,

, ; , ( ) , , . , , (, ) ( , ), , , , . , , , .

; , , , , : , , , , , , , , , etc.

( ) , (), , , , , , , : , , , : , , . ,

20________________________________________________________

, , , , , , , , : .

, , , , , , " ", ( , , , , ) , , , , . . , , , , , , "" . , . , , -, ( ) , , "", "", "" "" (, ) , .

. . . , , "" , , , , : . . . (, , "": . )

(); , , ( ) ().

" " , : (: .: "", , "", , , ; ; , ) . (); (); , . , ( ),

________________________________________________________21

. , : , .

, , -, , , . , . , , , , , , "", () (, , -, , etc.) , . ( , , , . , , . , , . , " " , "". , , , : , " "; , , , " ". . , , , . , ).

, , , . . , , , . .

, , .. , , . ( ) , , . . , , ( : ) , - , , - . , , (, , , , , , ., .), (: ,

22________________________________________________________

) . . , . . , : " , ".

, , , .. , - , : - , , (, , etc.) . () , , , , , . , , , , . , , , , . , , , , , , , , , , , , . ( ) () . , , , .

, , ( , , ), , "" : ( : , ) ( ). , , , ...

: . , - , , , : ; , - , ( ) (-) .

________________________________________________________23

: , . , . , , "" , . , . : " ". , , .

, : , , : , . - , . . () , ( , , , , , , , , - , etc.), , () .

. , , , , , , , , , .

, . , , , , , , , , , , , . ( , ) () , "" , , , "" , .

, , , , , ,

24________________________________________________________

, , . , , : ( ) () , -, . () , . , " " , , (, ) .

, ( ) , , , , (), , , .. , . . , (, , ), .

, , , " ", ( ) ? : . , , ( ) . , , , , , : . (, ) , - : ( ) , .. . , .. , . , , . . , . . .

, " ", " ", " ", " " etc.

.. , , ,

________________________________________________________25

, : , , -, , ..

, , , , , , ( : ) , - . , , (). , ( ) , ( ). "". , , ( , ). , . "" . : (, , , ) , , , , , , , -

, , ( ) , , () . , . "", "", "", "" .

( , , , ) . , , , , ( ) . , , , (). , , , , ,

26________________________________________________________

() , , , , . , .

, , , ( ), "" ( ) ( ). , , , , .

, , (), . (). , - (: " ") ( ) , , , , ( - ) . . . ( . : .. , . , 2005 ., 332 .).

(, ) ; . () , , : , , , , , etc.; . . " . " (. . ).

(, ) , . , ( ), , ( ), (, ) , , : , , , . , ""

________________________________________________________27

(. ), "", , , , . . () .

: .. ? , , ! "", .

,

" "

. ..

28________________________________________________________


-

. , , . , , , . , , "", , . , , , , .

, . , , , , , . , , , . , . , , . , . , . , , - , , , , , , , , . , .

. , , , - . , .., - , , , , , , , ..

, ( , .) , , , "" . "" .

________________________________________________________29

, "" . , . , .

, , , , . - , , , , - .

, . , , , , , .

, , , , , , , , , .. , , , - .


. , .

, , . , " " , , . .

30________________________________________________________

.

, -. . , - . , , , . , . , , - .

, , , . , , , , , .

, , . " " .. , , , , . ", , , , , , , " ", , , , " [ . . . .: , 1991.; . 169] .

, , . . . " ": " , . "" , ".

________________________________________________________31


, , - . , , . , , , . , . , , . , .

, . , , , . , , , , .

, , , . , , .

. , , , , , .

- . -

32________________________________________________________

. , . , - . , - , . . , , , " ".


, . .

. - -. , , : " , , ".

, , . , . - - . , , . , , . . , , , "" . . . , . , , , " , ".

, : , , ,

________________________________________________________33

, . , , , .

, , , , , , , . , , . , - . , - .

, , , , - , . - .

. (. , ) [email protected]

" "

- . . , . , , , , .

, , . . - - , . "" .

34________________________________________________________

, , , , , . , , . . , ( , ). , , , , . ., , , : ". , ". , , , . . -, , . : . . , . , , , . , , , , .

. , , . . . , . , . , , .

? : . " , ( ) , , , , , , , , ". , . : ,

________________________________________________________35

, , . : , , . - , .

, .

, , , " ". , .


"" ""

, . ? , . .

, . , , ( ).

, , , , . . , , .

"", . , " - , " [ . . , 1939. 236 . C. 103-110], , , . , , , .

, . , , , , .

36________________________________________________________

, "". , : " , " [ .. // . -: , 1993. 144 . C. 34]. , ( ; . , , , ; , . , ) , , (, , , , .) , , .

. ( , , ) " ", " ". , , , , , . .

. -- , , - .

"". "" "" . - ( -) - (- . ) [ .. // . : , 2002. 179 . . 41-93(51-52)].

- (), " " [ .. . ( ) // . 1980. 6. . 36-37], , (-, -, ), , " " " , , " [ ].

________________________________________________________37

, - , . () , , , .., , .

, , , " ". , - (. ), . .


, , , . , , , . . , . , , , , "", . , , , , . , . . .

, . , 90- , ,

38________________________________________________________

. , .. , , .

. , , , . , , , , . , . , .

, . .

: . .

.. (. -, ) [email protected]

, . , , : ( ) . , , , , , : ) -, ) -, -. ( ), , , , .

- , , - .

________________________________________________________39

; .

. . , , , .

, , . [.: ., . ., . 25. . 1, . 116]. , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . . : " , , " [ . . . . 40. . 315]. , "".

, , ( , , ), . , "" "" "", , "" "", "", , , [. . , . . , . . ]. - .


, , , , ,

40________________________________________________________

, , .

, . , , : , . " , " [ .. . ., 1971. . 136].

. .. , , , , . , , , . , , , . "", [ .. // "". . ., 1967. . 29]. , , , , . , , , .

, , . , . , , , . "" , , .

. , , , . , , , . , . , . , , , . , .

________________________________________________________41


CAUSA SUI ,

, ( ) -, . , , , , , , . causa sui, ? : . "", "", (. . : " ").

? ? : ? , . , , , - ( ) , ( ) (, , --) causa sui. - ( ), ( ) .

. " " (.. ), , . , . () - - . ? -, -, -, - (.. ). , . , -.

, , , . "": ( ), -. "" , -, "" - ( ) . , (). "" , - , , , ( , , -, ).

42________________________________________________________

causa sui, , ? , , . . , "", .

? . ; - (, ) .


. , , , , . , , , , . , , . , , , , , , .

. .. .

, . , : ( ); (, , ""); , , ; ( ); ( , , ); , , ; . ,

________________________________________________________43

, , , . ; , . . , , , , . . [ .. . .: "", , 1998. 176., .26-27].

. , , .


, , . , , , . , , , , , . - (= ) , . , . , , .. " " , , , , .

, , . , " - ". I : , . ,

44________________________________________________________

. .. , " , ". I- , - " " . , "" , .

, "-", "-" . , , . . . . - , .


"-"

"-", . - .

"-" , ( ) , . , , , () . , .

________________________________________________________45

"" " " . , - , . , . , , , , , . : 1) "" 2) , .

, , . ( ) ( ) . , , , . . , , .

: . . . .

, . . . - , , "" . , , . , " ", , .

46________________________________________________________

, " " " ", . , . , , " " .

, , - , "" . - , , . , , , , , . , , . , , .

( ), . - , . ( ).

, , , , , . . , , , .

, , , , , "" . , , , . , , , ,

________________________________________________________47

( , .. ) . , / , . , .

"" - . " " [ .. . . 1991. .269]. . , -.


-

,

, .. , , , . , , .

, , . () , () , . .. , . , , .

, ,

48________________________________________________________

"" "". , "" , , , "" . .

: , , ; , , "", "" , ..; , , ; .

, "", , . , . , ( , , , , ), .. " " - , . - .

.. (. ) ""

" , ", , , .

.., " ". , . , , " "", , - ".

, , ,

________________________________________________________49

, , , ?

" ", , (..)... "", "" " ", ... , . " ", " ", .

, , , ... , , , " ", , , ... .

, ", ", , , , . .

- , . . , - " " ---- , . , - -, : ( ) , () () , "" , .

, ( ), ( ), ( , )

50________________________________________________________

... . . , . , , . - - : , . , . , , -.

- ..: " , , , , , , . , , . , , .., , " [ . .1991. C. 9-10].

" ..." .. . , , , , . , " , , , " ", , " [ .. . (- , ) : http://caute.net.ru/ilyenkov/texts/phc/cosmologia.html].

, , , , , , , , , --, . !.. , ( "", ) . .

?

________________________________________________________51

, .. " ". " , ". . . , .

, , , , . , , " " , -, ""... .

, , . , , - , " , , , ".

, , , - . " ", .. "" ... , "" .

. .., , .. . , .. .., .

" ", ... , " , ... ": " , , , ... ..., .. , , , , ".

.. .. "" " ", ; " "; "". : --.

.: " ! .., , , , " ", , ,

52________________________________________________________

, . ... , " " [ . . 3- . .3: . .: i, 1987].

, - --, , . , , , , ... " ", ..

, " , ", .. , , , -- , , , --. , .

, ... , ..: " ... , . , , , ".

, "-" (complicatio-explicatio) ., "-" (nveloppemens developpemens) . (e-volutio, ex-plicatio, Ent-wickelung) (in-volutio, im-plicatio, Ein-wickelung) . : - ..

, : (.), (.), (.), - - (.), -- (.), (.), - (.). - , . .

.., "

________________________________________________________53

--". : " , , , ". .., , " " .., " " " ".

, , , . , , . , , - .

- -, , , " , " (.), - ---: " ", , , , . " ". "" : --, , . , , ... ... "", "". "" , .. "" " --".

, , . ..: , " " .

, .. . , , , . , .. (.-.).

., ", , ". ,

54________________________________________________________

" ". , " " " " ...

, , , , , .

, . " ", .. " , ", ... .. , , - -: ---... . , , "" ... " , ...".

.. " " , , , , , .. -- " , " , " " (.). , (...), (.), (..), .. , " " , , .

, - - - . , , " ", , , , , , , .. --.

: , , , , , "" , , , , , ...

________________________________________________________55

(.), , : . - " ", , , : () () (). , " " (..), . , .

, -- - , , - ( ) , .. (..).

- , ( ) - , , , : " " (..).

, , .., " , ". : , - , .


, , , . , , , , , , . ,

56________________________________________________________

"" idiotes, . , , "", , . , , , , , , , : .

, . " ", ( .. " ") , , , , . "" , .

, "" , , "" , , , , . , , , - . , , . , , , , . "" : , , , , , , . , , .

________________________________________________________57

.. (. , )

, : , , , , , , , : " " , ? : ? , , ""?

, , , "" . , , , . "" , "" . , , " ", " ".

, , , , , " " ", " " , .

, , , "", , "", "", " " "": , " " .

"", , "" , : , , , , , ( , , , ) (? ?) . . .

"" : , , ()

58________________________________________________________

. . .. , , . . , , - . , .

, (-) , . , . , - . ? , .

" - " 80- , - , - . , , , , , , ,.

: , , , , ; , . . ? , . . - . .

________________________________________________________59


, , ,

, . . , , . , . . .

- , . , . , . . ( , , "", "", "" , , "Sambucus nigra" ( ebulus) , "" "" , ). , , , . "- : , , , " (-).

, , . , , , , , , , ", ", " ". ( , , , "" . . . "" , , -). , . , ( , ), , " ", , . . , , "". . . , (- , ) ( ). , , .

( ) "",

60________________________________________________________

, , , . .

, "" , , , , , . . . , , " ".

, , , , " ", . , , . . , . "" . "" "", , , , , . . . , " ", , , , , "". " ", , " ". , " , ". . .

, . , , . , . . . , . , () , - , . , - " " () -. , , , , , , .

, , , , , .

________________________________________________________61

- : " ", . , , . . . " " () , , "", , , " ", " " , , , .

(, ) , , "". " , " " " , , , , , , . . . ? . . " , ", . .

, , . , , . -. , , . , . . , , , , , " . ". ( .., .., .., .. . ., 2001).

, , " ", , " , , , "", . ( . , , , , " ", " ", " ", " " ( ), " ". . , . , "Flammentod" ( ) . , , . , " ?", : " , ". ,

62________________________________________________________

, , . . " , ", , - , . , " , ", . , . , . :

" , , ".

.. (. -, ) [email protected]

. ..

. "" .

" " .. , . , , .

.. , " , ". , " , " [ .. . .: , 1991. C. 19]. . , " , , , , " [ , . 21].

, , . : " " " "? .. , " , " [ , . 25]. , . "" .

.. ", , , . , , , , , " [ , . 29].

.. : , ,

________________________________________________________63

.. , , , .. , , , [ , . 36]; , .. : " "" , " [ , . 45]; " ", , .. " ", , ; , , .

.. , " , , , ", " " [ , . 49].


, ,

, , , , " ". , , , , , .

. , .

, , , , , . , " ". , . , .

, , , . , 18

64________________________________________________________

; , ; ; - , ..

" " .

? , , , , , .

, . , , , 18 , . .

. . , .

, , , .

, , , .

, , .

, . , ,

, , , " " " ". , . , ..

. , , , , . , - , .

.. (. )

-

( . "" ) , -, , "" , , , ("" ).

________________________________________________________65

, , , . , , : , , , ? , , , ( ). , , , . (), ( ) , , , . .. "" (. ), , "" , ( ) "" , . , , , . , , , .

, . , , ( . "" ) . , , (. , , ). ( ), , . , .. .

" " , , "". , , , : " ". , , , . , , , , . () , , . , .

. , , , , , .., , .

66________________________________________________________

- () , , , . , .

. , , . . , , , , , - .

, , - (, ) , , , ( . "" , , ). , , - . , , . - () , . "" "" ("" ) "". "" , ("") ( . "" , "").

, , .

(244 ...) , . , . , ( ). " ", "", - "", "", . " " " ", " , ", " " " , ". , "-", . , , , . , "" . " " (. emanare, . ), , .

, , " . , (""

________________________________________________________67

, , , , "" ), " , (, , ), , . , "", . , ; " " " ". , - , " ", "".

( ) "", "", "" ("") , "" ("", "- " ..). " " -, "" () "" , "", "", "" .

("-) , "", , , " ", "" "" (. ). "", "", (. "" ) -.

, , , , , ( ), , , . , . , "" - "" , () .

( , ) .

*** VI-XVIII .,

() , .. , "" (), (). 1845 . ., ., ( , , ) (1- ):" , , , , , , , ( ., . . , .3., .1). ,

68________________________________________________________

, , , , , .

, , "" , "" , "" "" .. " ", . .

, X . , , ( , "", "" "-" , ), ( "" "" ) "", , , . 60-80- , . .. , 60- (.3) "" "" ( 1953 ., , " ", "", 60- ., " " " ").

***

.. " " . , , ( .) . . ' , , . () . , " " ", "-" existentia. , , , , "" , , , . "" ,

________________________________________________________69

"" () (, ). , ( ) . , " " ("") "" , , , " " , . "" "" "" XIX XX . "" 3. (1856-1939). "" , "" (Unbewsstsein) " ". , , , ( ), " ". " ", . , (" ") "" , "" "" .. "" (Vorbewsstsein) "". "" "" , "" ("") . "" "-" , " "". "" "" "" . "" "" (Bewusstsein), "" "" (. "" ), - , , "" . ("") ( , , . ( (), "" . , , , " " (" ").

. (1859-1938) ( . intentia "") . , . , . , , , . " " ( . ),

70________________________________________________________

"" (). "" (. ), (. ""). "" "" ( "" ), . , , " " (" ", "", "" "", .. "") "", . , "", "", "". , ( ) ( ), "" . , "" ("", ) . "" "" ( "" " "). . (, ). , "" ', , , , , , , . ( , "" . . , , . "" "" ( "") , "" , "" .

"" , " " . , () "" , " ", "" , "" , , . , . "" ( ), , " " . , "" "" , : " ", , , , , . "Lebenswelt",

________________________________________________________71

, . . ( ) , - . "Lebenswelt" : - , - , - . "Lebenswelt" . "Lebenswelt" ', , .

- "-" ( ), - "". . "" ("" ). , "", , . .-. "-" "-". . "" "-". , . " ", "-" (Leib) "-" (Krper). .: " ", "", "" "" . "--" : "" (Stelle), " " (Ort). " ", , , " " : "" "" . " " ( "" ). " , , "" (Krper), (Leib). . .-. " " ("") "". "" , "" " " " (notre average dans un monde). "" "" . - "", "", " " .

""

72________________________________________________________

( ) " " . ' , ( ) , " " : , , , (-V ...) , 70-80- . XX ' ( . "" ), , , , .

" ", ( ). , . ( . , ). , .. " " ( " "). , .

. (" "). " " "". - , . , , , , " " , ( "" "" ""). ("") , . "" ("") . ( ), "" "". "". " " ( ' ). " ". , . ,

________________________________________________________73

. ( . "" , ) () , . " " "" , . (, ) "" . . ("") (), "" ( "" , ). " " , "" ( ).

, " " () . " ", "" ( ), "" '-' , "" ("") "" . , . , , " " (). . , " ". , "" ("") .


. . .. , "

. , " [ .. // ... . 42. . 278]. , . . , .

, , "" . , " , " . , " " . , , . . , , .

74________________________________________________________

, , , .

. . , , , , , . , , . , , - , .

: .. () () , . . , " " (.), , , , . , " " , , " " , , , . .. . ( . . ) () , , , , , , , , , , , .

. , , , , . . . . , . , . , . .

________________________________________________________75


.. .. ,

.. " " [ .. / 2 2010 . . 134-140], .

, . .. : ? : " , , . , , , !" [ .. / 2 2010 . . 136] , , .. . , , , , , . . , . , . , . , , . , , , , . , , , , . , . , , , . , , . , , : , , . , ( ) , , , , . , .

: ", , , . "" " " " ", "" . ,

76________________________________________________________

. , , , . , , " [ .. / 2 2010 . . 137]. , " " " , ", , , , "". ( -, ), , , () - , , . , , , , - ( , ), , , , . " " , , , , .

, . , , . , , . , . , , , , - , . : " , , , . , ( ..), , , " [ .. : . 2- . 1984, .46] , , , .

________________________________________________________77


" " " "

. , , , - . . . " " , , ( ) , , .

, "" . , "". . ( ""), . ( ), , , , , .

, , . , . , , .

, , , .

. . " ": ( . . ), - "". , . . - , - , , , , .

. . " " , "" . " " , (: ) . ? , ; , , . " ", . . ,

78________________________________________________________

( ), , "" - " " , , , " ". : , , " ", -, -, , .


:

: ( ) ; ; . : "" "", .

, . "". , , . Gallup International, . "", " ", " " " " "".

, , , () (, (), , ), . , 15% [ .. : . / .. . .: , 2003. 512 . ( )]. ? ? ? , , . ., ( .) " " . , , , , . " , " [ . . . . . .: , 2004. 480 . ( " "), . 216] , . , ? (, . ), , , . . .

. ,

________________________________________________________79

. " ", ( ) ( "" , "" )?

", " (altruism born of suffering): , , [Ervin Staub, Johanna Vollhardt, Altruism Born of Suffering: The Roots of Caring and Helping After Victimization and Other Trauma \ American Journal of Orthopsychiatry Copyright 2008, 2008, Vol. 78, No. 3, 267280].

, , . , , . " ". , , , (, ), , .

(, ), : , , . . , , . . . , . ( ) . . . ", ( )" ? . , , . .

( ) , ? -, ( , ). , . , . , , " ".

: ( , , , , ), , , , .

, , , . . , . " " (, -) , , , , : 1) ; 2)

80________________________________________________________

, , , ( , ); 3) , . , , .


-

. " () () , - " [ .. . ., 1977., . 151]. " ", : " , . " [ ., . . / 2- . .: , 1955 . 3. . 3.], .

, , , " ", "" . , " " , , () .

, "", ' , [ .. [ ] http://caute.net.ru/ilyenkov/texts/personab.html ( 25.03.2010)]. , . , , , . , , , . , , .

, " ". , , . , . , ( , , .. ) ,

________________________________________________________81

" ". ' , , - , "-". , , , , .

, , , .

, ? , , , , . , , , , , , . , , , . , , , .

.. (. )

.. : -? - ,

, , , , , . . , , , .

, , , " ", , ( ).

, , "". , , ( ), , , , , etc., ""?

,

82________________________________________________________

; , . , ", ", . ( , ) , , " " , " " (.)? , Windows , ( !) , . "- , , , - , "[ . . 2- . .: "-", 2006,- .312].

, " ", - , - . , " ", , - , "" [ . , , . , ( - ) .

, . , , , . . . , , , ( ""). " , "? , , , , , etc., , " ". . - -, . , ( ) , . , , , , . -, -,- , , , " " (.). "" " " , " " ( ) .

________________________________________________________83

. (. ) [email protected]

. , , , , " ", , .

, , , , . , , , . , . , " " , - , . , - . , , , . , " , , ", " , ".

, , . , , , , , , .

, , , , . - , , ,

84________________________________________________________

.

" " " - . , ".

, , , .

.. , : , , , , , "", . , , , .


? ? ,

? , ? , ? , " "

, - "" ? , . ? , . , , - . , , , , , , . . () , , . , " ". " , " ( // . . 2006. .156). " , " ( . . 172) . , .

: . :

________________________________________________________85

, ? , , ? ? ?

. , , , . , . . . . . () , . (.. ). . , .

. ? . () . , ... .

. , . . . .

. , . , . , -, . -, (" "). , , . .


, . , . , , . , , . "" , , "" , .

86________________________________________________________

, [. 1994, 304 .], , , . , . , . . , , . " " , [. : . ... - .-. : 01.04.02, 2001, 33 .]. - , , , [.. - , , 1988, .100]. , . , , . [ .. , ., 1983, 605 .] . . , , , .. , , (.. , , ), , . , " ", - . - ( ) ( ) , - , [ . . , ., 1980, C.164].

, , , , , .

________________________________________________________87


. , , , . . . : ", , , , , ... ... , " [ .. . // : - . . 2. ., 1996. .14].

, , . . , , . - -, - . , , : , , , .

, . , , , . " , , . : " !" " [ .., .. . .: . , 1997. .189].

, , , , , , , , . , , , "" , " ", , , () , [ . . ? ., 1984. . 355].

, , ,

88________________________________________________________

, , . , , - . , . . . , : " "" "" "-". "" "homo sapiens", , , "" "", - , , " [ . . ? ., 1984. . 329].

, , , , , . , , . , . , , , , . , , . , , -. , , - , - , , .


-

. . ? . ? . , . . (, ) ( , , , . ).

terra incognita, ( ).

________________________________________________________89

"".

.. . "", "",

"" , - .

, , .. " !", ( !) . , , (, , . . ) "" , , , . -, , - - , ( ); : - , , . , , . , , ( ) - (), . , , , , -, -, ( ).

( , - .. ): ( ) . , ( ). "", - , () ( ) . , , , , .. , . - , .

90________________________________________________________

.. (. )

"" "" - -

( ), - , - , - , " " , " ", , , , . , , - . -, - . , , , , , , , ..

, , , . "", .

, "" - . , , - ( ) , .

() , , .. . , , , .. . , , . , , "" . .

. , , .. .

" "

________________________________________________________91

" " , . : "", "", "", "", "" .. . . , .. , - .

, , ., " ", "" "" .

.. (. -) [email protected]

(. , .. , .. )

" " . - , . , . . . . , ? .

-, "" , . , . . ( . . . . ).

( . ) , ; , -, . , - - "", . , , , , , , , , , "" , , . .

. , . . , . . .

. . , - , , , .

92________________________________________________________

, , , , . . , .

. . , - - . , . -, , , - , .

, . . , " ". " " (. ), (), , " " (. . ) , ( : ?); , , .


. , . , , . .

, , . , , . . , , , , , . , .

, . , , , , . ,

________________________________________________________93

: . , , [.: . . 1995, . 61; . . 1995, .27-29 ].

. . , , , , , . , , , . ", , , " [ . .89 ].

, , , . , , . , , .

, , , , . , " , , " [ .. . 2005. . 509].


"" 1977 .. " :

". , . , , : ", ", " "" - , , , " [.. " " ", 1970], . , .

94________________________________________________________

, - , , , . , , ( ).

, " , ", " ", , " , ". "" , - . " " " ", " " [.. " ", 1965]. .

: " , ", , " " , .. " " (1968) - .

, " , , , " " - " [.. " ", 1975].

, .. " " (.) , " ", , [ " ", 1965].

" , ( ) , " " " ( ..) " [.. " ", 1977]. "" .

________________________________________________________95

"" . , - . , , , , . [.. " : ",1977].

, , .


-

. . , - . , , . .

[A.Giddens. "Elements of the Theory of Structuration"// The Constitution of Society. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1984.]. , . , , . . ( ) . , . , , . , . .

96________________________________________________________

- . , , . , "" , , . , . , : , . . , [ IV " " (, 16 2010 .)]. , , . .


. . :

. , " " . . " " , , , , , , . . , , , . ,

________________________________________________________97

, . , , , , "", , ", ".

, , , . , , . , , - - - . , , , , , , , , , .

, , , , . " , , ", " " .


,

, , . , , . ,

98________________________________________________________

, .

( ) . , " ", , . , , " ", , , . , , , - , , -. " " , , , . , , , , . , , .

, , . , , , -. , , "" "", "", "", "", . , "" "" . , , , . , , , .

, . " , " [ . . " : ", 1984 ., .108]. , . . . , , , , . "" , , " , , , .

________________________________________________________99

, , " [ , .188]. , .


, , , . , , . 40 , . , , , 40 50 . .

. . , , , , , . , , - , . , , . . .

40 . . , : " , , " [ .. . 2002, .89]. , : "" . , , "", "", , ,

100________________________________________________________

, . , . ! !" [ .. . 2002, c. 13]

, - , , , . , . , , , , , , .

.. , : ", , , , , , , , , ( , ) " [ .. . 2002, c. 89] , . . "" , , .

, . , , , , , , . , , , , . . , , , , .

________________________________________________________101

.. (. )

XIX-XX XIX -

. . : , , , , , . , .

XIX-XX -, , , , " ". , .

, , , . , . ., , , - . , , , , , . , , .

: - . . . . " " " " , , . . ., . , ., . - . , . , , , .

XIX-XX , , -, -. , , .

102________________________________________________________

, , . " ", .

, . , , , , , , .

- , "-" , . , , , , , - .


-

( ) , , . , . (), (), , , , , .

" ". , " , , , " [ .. : . 9. . ., 1984. . 189]. .. " , , , -, - . " [ . . 188]. " , " [ . . 201]. , ,

________________________________________________________103

.

, , , , . ", .. , , " [ .. . . 1961. . 117]. , . , , , . , , , . , , , .

, ( ) - , . " , .. , , .. , "", "" , , , " [ .. : . 16. . ., 1984. . 309]. ", , ". " " " , .. , - , .. , " " [ . . 317].

, - , . " - , "", , , - , "" , " [ .. . ., 2002. . 21].

, .. , . , -, . , ,

104________________________________________________________

, . , , .


" ". , . , "" , .

, , . , . , , . , . , , , - . , , , , , , . , , , , , . , , . ( , ) . , . , .

, , , , . ( ) , ,

________________________________________________________105

. , , " " , . , -, , (, ) . , . , , "- " .. " " ... , , , .


( -

. ) -

. . - , , , , , -.

, . , " " [ . . 2- . .: "-", 2006. . 23.] . , , - , /, , .

, . . " , , " [ . . 2- . .: "-", 2006. . 21-22.], -

106________________________________________________________

. ,

, , , " , , " [ . . 2- . .: "-", 2006. . 64.]. , " - , . " [ . . 2- . .: "-", 2006. . 108.].

- . , , "" . , "" . : " "" "" , , " ", " [ . . 2- . .: "-", 2006. . 40.].

, . , "" . "" "" "" , "" "" - .

. (. , ) [email protected]

- , ,

() , .. . ( .. ) [" ". .. .//, , . ., 1994, .103]. , , , , , , , , . : "Krinai de Logoi!" ( ) [ , " " (",

________________________________________________________107

"" , ) " " ( , ) .. " " . , , , , ]. (), , , .

" " (" " , "ogito ergo sum" , " " ), , , , , , , , " " ("Logique du coeur" , "Amo ergo sum" , , "rdo amoris", " " ) [ . . .: : 2000. . XV, . 22. . 755]. , , . " !". : " " (. 6.21). , , .. , . ", ens cogitans ( .) ens volens ( .) ens amans ( .)" [Scheler M. Ordo amoris//Sheler M. Gesammelte Werke. Bd. 1. Schriftnen aus dem Nachab. Bern: Francke, 1957. S. 356]. . , , , " ", . , , "" , " " , , . , "" "", . "Le coeur a ses raisonsque la raison ne connait pas" ( , ),

108________________________________________________________

[ . . . 1999. 78]. , " , "" .. , , , "", "" " " (. : " , ; -: " , !"). , () (), , " ". "In te redi: in interiore homin habitat veritas" ( : [ . // . : 4 . . 1: : ; 2000. . 39, 72] [ (..)]). , , , , . theosis, .. , , , .

, , . , , , , , , , , [" , ". -- " " // . --. . ., 2000. . 255], (), , (, , ) (" , , "Was wirklich ist, ist vernunftig und was vernunftig ist, ist wircklich" ) [" , , , " (.) . . ., 1994. . 2. . 3 . 10. 204].

" " , , . . , .

________________________________________________________109

, , .. : " , , , - , . , , , " [ .. .// . ., 1990. 4. . 71].

, "" " ", , , , . " , , , " [ . . 71]. , , , , , . (" " . ), , , , , , . , , , , [. . . . 1996. 2. . . 26 , "" , , , " , , , ". ( ..)]. .. : " (" "), (" "), (" "), , , " , ". , , "" , " [ .. .// . ., 1990. 4. . 71 72]. , , , [ .: . "" . // . ., 1996. 1. . 28].

110________________________________________________________

- . " ", , " ", . , " , " [ .. // .. . ., 1993. . 276].

" " , , , , , " , , . , , , , " [ .. .// . ., 1990. 4. . 69]. , XIV , , , , , , .. , , " " " ", , " ". " , "" , , , "" [ .. //. . ., 1995. . 95]. , " , " [ .. . // .. . . , 1994. . 310]. () , , , , theosis .

________________________________________________________111


""

, "" , . , , , . . , , .

, " " ., , . ... , - , . - . . . , , , : , , . , , " " .

, , , ; , .

- "". , , . - . XXI

112________________________________________________________

, , , , , .


,

,

, , . , , , , , . : , , , , , . , ( ), , .

, , , . - : ( ), ; , ; . , , , (, , - ), , , .

,

________________________________________________________113

, " --". , , , . , , : " , , ". , , , , , . (), , , , , , , , ( ), , , . , , , , , , .

. (. ) [email protected]

, . , . , " ", . ., " , . , " ", . " ", " [ . : .- .: ,2004.- .65.].

, , "" , , , , .

, - , . ", , .,- , ,

114________________________________________________________

" [ . // . .- .,2002.-.34.].

. , , . ,

, . , . , , ( ), , , , . , .

, , : " , , , , , ?"


:

-, . , 1 . (), , , . -, -, , -.

, . - , ,

________________________________________________________115

, , . , , , - , . "" , - .

, , , . . , , , , . , (, , ), - .

, , , . , , , , , . , , , . , "" , " ", , , . , , .

, , , , , , .


""

, , .. , .

116________________________________________________________

: , , . , . , , . , , . , .

, .

.. , - , , , . , , , , , .

, . , , , . .. : , , . .

, - , , . , - . .

, .

________________________________________________________117


-

- , , . . , , , , , . , . , . ( ) , , , . . , , .. - .

, . , .

, , .. [ "" . . , 1960; . . , 1974 .]. , , , , , .

. .,

118________________________________________________________

- .. .. , . - [ . : // , 2009, 5, .121-127]. , , , , .

Documents

Ilenkovskie chteniya 2010