I~h~~~~~~HH~t.Qih~lS0(;~~~t~ihh'~~~~~h"lh~ijl.Q~l~~~~~bl~~141b~~l~~~~JlJs~l:l:hltl~!!:~l~hb~~~l~Q~ltJUlt~H~~~~~2lblt

l,btleI~~~ijl.a~~}Q~l!!:!illh~~S~~llt~~~~l~~lt!~l}!l~lll:hlltllill1'«J~Q~!ef~.Iij~l~nH!&~~!~lJa~@t~~!h~':h~l~t~llh2~U!~lt~~lll:ltl:~~I&~!~11l11~(lh~)1h~.If~~blh~,:2h9Z~,h~l,.tU;t~~Ih~I~~l:~~~~~ll.Qft~bQhhhltl~~lt-~~~ij'lli~I~l~~~:yrn~.QftI~~lt~ijlli~~~~ltl~~lt~~QIlhlJlJ~~~~lt~lthlI:h~21l:~1D~l!i!1D1J8llill:~~h~~Q~IR~f~~lh~~ijS~J~h~ijl..tihIlt~lt~~h~ltllel'hIH~j~,~uie.&~,b~~QI~~h~~le''h~h~}-'ht-\~lJIt..Qll'~§06

[I~!It~~~~~~lll'hlo~12~~12~~:ijl)~~&'~]

I~~~~Qh:.Q~llfth"ll:lt:tlt,baltl!!:tl~llfUlt~~lt1u:~lt'~ll:lt:tlthJa.l:h.'\~lh~hltlh~-\f~alltl~Jlt~l!fltl~~~l!!;~Jl~~I~~I~~~1~lttl:h2h~~Jyl£~Jlt11~~:.Q!,Jltl.hll~H~lh:tlt.Hbl~lt~·:ij.l:h2.b~ltll.b~Jt~I&~lills~l~lt2lelhh':!,h~ltl!!:~)lltHble-b:YllS1

·l:h2!1t~~.I5:~Js!~l:llll:h2~:1D$~~~l!!:~~Jl~~lJs:ll~l:h~~l!~,ll\ll!~tltltIl!I~~~llillhIb!!UJJll:,b2~-&h~~hlli'l\§

I:~~~l~~h~le'~~Qb~l.Q~l:~~ll1ras~:t~leI:h~~·ltJ~~l!i!lSh~~lo~~ijS'l,.h£~J~~U~l.Qah2I~ltJl:~l:1~ab2~1ij~~~'S'l~tijll:ltlt~l!!:ll~~1!.Ptl~JlJs'~~t~~~~~b~h2~hn1h~~~lh201~~h~hh~~~.bHl~lh~l:ltl:~~Ih~h~lS!lli~lS~:};~~~~1~.Qlh~!!~1lo~.b~t~~h2~R!Mtl~ltH~l~~~Sll:hle'~hlli~1'«J~.~~~h~li~~J}~leI~faQh'~!illS-~~}.Q'~§

[Ib~M:.ltlYQ!l2.~I~MUt:tlh·~:ij!)l2.t!2~&~~~~Js'e]I~t~S~~~lh!!~-Wltllol$lilli:~1h!~!h~~~lltltS

·t~~J!fa~hh~l.~)~~l~~JIltJl~l~fh~~~,':@h~hh~OO~-JY~l:2~l:~l~it~~~~h~Js~Wl2~fJ!f~lij}h~~~~~lS:.Q~J,b~~ijh~illltllt!lhl~~taleI&a~.Qlt~UUJs~hill~~Js.~~:~~1~!!.·1D~~l!~l~h!~'~h!~:~~

IlhUt~~~C

••I

!&!h!h~~~~'b')DlJ~~~IU~h2~~~hl8lh1RUstOS-l%hhh~~!Jnlh~~~tth»1ij1Sc~lllhl1lth~IUll\...hh\!ll

-~~lh2f»il~~~lill,1El~1~.~~lhl=h~,~I:~bb~~l:b.un-~~S~~lll~OO2!)Qf~f~~mH:h~S.@~h~l:l~h!ltltl:n1~~~rnij.t~\!l~~~~6:~~~J4:l~~h~~l:l\~H~hJ~~l!''h~h~teU!U~~~f~JYt~~hU!nFa~l%lY~~h2~l:2~h!e!!llb~J

96I:hi~J~~~n@~h1~ij1!l:hll.lSIh:i1iJUShhlY~hI~W~~Jlhh~~~~lh-*J~i~~~l1l:2'~~g,~liltll1t:l!Q~f~~~t~~t!Ut~hl(~)b~ltl\,.Q1hh~~~~1~~ijtl:H~~~~J~~~IlU:2~I!I~lMBlS~!hb~l1lli1-lh~ijb~~h.'~bijbhiah2~!tlIh~'~Il~llilltlh21U:1ehlt~I!hl?~2'tI}Je1J!l:t!f~f~.ijShh~.l1~J,:eh.l!~l.t~l:.I!,~!&~

061~~~j~!JbI!h:!1.l1~~~h~h~eI:):J~):~#lg,bll.l1:Beh!htl~~~t~~l:lUlhtl~~nll:~!tllJ~~~ill:slehh~h~hl:~~t~~U!Ll-~hb~~h~~':l%ehI!~li~1~Jhbtl'!!~~~lh~~lhQB1!i:ltl~~l:·~1~~.:~~*l.~lh~1:~~~llil~l=l1.l:Jlt~aa~'.\:~~~~h~,a~~AI:~'hl!t1elltltJllli~~lJilltl~lh~~!ij~l:li:1~~l:~~lhrl~~~JB~'(h2)

sr·JhH~lh.b~~lJ.o~Jl:J~~l!1.l11:~:£l~l:l~~l:e~'~le.l}:2~~t!bl%e'!!~l=Jlt-hisf~f%~~liU\.~lhb~ll~s~iae,.\:!i:lsel:b~!l:-'\y~I:~b1l1:2·~~:l!tl!~}~:l~!e~~~~lb~1hb~li~ill!ih!~~Ihh!~':~lijalil:~~h$l!~ij1!i:bll.1s~~lt·~hl!'!B~~~h~~l':!~h·~h~1:it'"§

[Ihl!~ltJHi~W!l:hlUs~~§l'il!1t~~Ish.'~~U!:ht~.I1~.'t!]

orI~lJ.o~~U!~.l!QhH~'iu:):ht:Sl~~1~1I!1l&~J~~l~il~l~1IDillh~lb~ltll~~S~~~~l!l~bi}lih1}d~''iu~lU~~~~~~tu!l~lh~!l!!~ij~lli.:l~~Uill!~1!i:!Q~t!Ja~~1lt~~~l:~!~l~h~~&I!Wtb~1:l%1hltijl~2hhb~lt~ltU:~1't2~.lU:ltU~liil't!l~~~b~~

9I.&s!lWthltlQ'h1::l~ltl~~Ql.oijb~}}~I3&''hb~tl~!~!Ull~~J~~·~~ij.bhhltl~l2!&!lnl~#t~!tlQ~lJ.o1b:i~~~l!tbJlJt~!I!-'hI!~b!~~~S~S~~!i:~~~b2I.&}ltl:~h~':}ll):11!~h2-:Jal~l~l%I:ltl-l:~-:}ll@!ll:1£IltBMn~l~ll.o~lShlh~):~-ltl!Ij;Wh'9§

[I~h.,\~~U!:~~~lli~hH~~Iij1t.~]

~1:R~hlnllt.l1•&

~ ~~~~~I

~~~ WI ~Tftf ~; SIV!l; JRUl It ~: t WI (I RIVlI,I ~~~RtOt~ oq~!fU ll'Rftftf WI ~~{it (j(;C;cilfQ:;~~lr«('ISI(-ire1qll{fq ~~lfQ:t '1~~ ~q;cilf'(~lqltq4i1~oq~r.m{, t

~~¥tqtl!;~;r ~: SN~~\if;ciI~I(1;4{Cfm; ~~<>qtqr~.5 'R~sfq ~;tf1'qmq o~'1T"JOO~~+!1q.l¥tf(, 'q~~~ ~~t:

3I'~ ;n It;r:' (Rr qi{:~~~~f(, 3f1fm ~;rT lfT'WfT~ 3'{~-q;r-{ AOfTq;rn)sWl~:I ~ ;rq~~ oq~owtR( (Rr ~~ I

[ ~. atqA~ fit~lt. I ]

§~. ~~qitTq:iilRl&qlgol~oq4i~qOfT~fti (1TqT;qR~ 3T'tm{: I10 $~ Qj( 'aWl fQi( ~~~TQ:' ~ v,;rT~:,<PI' fQ~lg~~HTf{~T¥fT'{l~Rf

~; WI; '~;~/ {ftr ~ ~, ~!ffitTta;f?ri\"t6ql"qot"\ffiUI''m''11:r Iqta; "t 'fQ;~sq~ ~'Cq"m~~ ~~ Q(T ~~q~~4ifc1Ti!;'tr-"!f~~4i(tll{T(q)fq4ifcf..m I ~lWl{ijJ{-'~;iJSq~ ~fu(tT¥tl;Qferit'fJf{QT'f·tq~{fc{!f{~~ij(J{, ~~~~J{-'~ l{1~ql~: ~'~.1\"tq) ~(, 0{ G~~t:

15 ~~~ra:q:' (i;l1tTmt':-(F<r; ltif1l.; 3I'fQ~1fTt~ql mSl'Rrfllij.U\;~T·sqrq~~ ~ift4i~~u~itI:Jq?4lfTSoq"~'qij~l~ I f.fi~, '~;~Sq~{ftr ~'O{(;%)fQ~tt<lRll"t~ ~~oqttRtqq{'~~O{~C{llfttt f"""~ql{1{,m "t OWlitas'il (t;~~nRl Q1.~uf3'{~~.!1qtt((T't~~4i1~ ~ smr-q~q~, (1 ~ oq~o{T"~4iAl~qf{wq (m q~fiJ(~ I 0{~~-'4i

20 ~" ~;~:' (llJ fQ~~<f(~~"tq.~"q~If.r~~~ '~~sq~ ~ql'tiR: ~"T~·3Il.TS+!1ltq(fu ~if..;O{; '~1{: ~;~:' (fu ¥WIifi~~ ~uri{(~ 3f't'ifJltSOlt'ffi'-fQi~~F{Q'(~~ ~ f.\~~~, 3{Oq~~q '0{ (1T~~q-~~lUqqmq~"t(\;q Q;q,:{f.Aq~~ I q~ '" oq~fcnlt 1ffi6q~~i(II{1Jff¥t~ij ij(T~ e e\11~q~(if~{: ~til~, 3T't~ti nur~ I

25 ~~. ifiR~-'(tlQT~~~f.tlfi~\;q ~TQlf1:{~q 'lr~,q ijT1lFqn·IIT~, qftROOq~ ffitrn~q ~l ~~~~maprT '~O{ ~~ ~~.

~tT(J:'~ WlT~qt{'lS((-~~ll:; ~,,; ~ ft 6qmm't oq'ffi~.i!\~'otliRr·

~ ~~R(s(QI~ I if ~:; '" 1~Rf 'Ii ~ ~:' ~~~ti~q'fc(~q\jihMC4I~, q;6t.¥ta~rq ~~ '11ltulq·lfufuro'(f~~I:lli·

30 R{1JTT~~~ I§ to. 3{;lf ij-'~~OI'l~.¥t~~, Q3fT~)"tO{~~mQTlH·

t. sr;IT~~~: I ~

;1{JlTf{,~cUf(f~ij'~o'Ht",,~mqJrrtTftJ Of e.~qqfu:' -~~; ij'~;l«f 3f~ oq5"'1"'~ l{.~ ~~, q~(r, ~ ~ -n Y emr:; ~oqT-i-~ll~ f.r.n ~~ I Ofmr'A:; oq5f;nqJf{l;:P:m1lit~Jf{~ro~-~~OfTomiMq: I Of~(rq:; oq5fiTT"lJf~<r OfTijT;:ij~ifi{OIlq:t ij~ :;n~-~-q~;n~Tit~~~: I f::fi., amn~~U f?r-n ~~~m:: ~ 5~tn1( Y ~llq~JltT 'l~llij~ijlIqit,",1 ifi~ q~~ Y ~RrR~RIll1q~ I-';:l{'1Jf&:sfIff~ro~~~"'mtI'Q6lAit~~ t ~'{q~ '<ITf~-ftlf6 ~; Of;(fffiI~'fIl{qrq~~ / ifiT{Utifil~rof~T"IJf{~SJRr-q~-.~,~f,{~ f.I~~~mT'ImI'q~~ I

§ H. 3fW ~ flf;(1i{:-~~fq<1i:, oqm.Tftifi~ I ~: 6Tl{l- 10

~qJ~JfTtT/ mnq~ f;(~·tf",q: ~~{i'l~itt::fit~'1~6:r~:/ ~~T3f"IJf(R~SJ6~ ~ fai?I('{1~~ftJ:, 3f!J~ :;u~qft ijTOf-Sltf~~q6~lO{oq«R ~ftJ ~!Otl~ I

[ II. i~T~qroJfAt ~) fi:I~~t{ I )

§ t~. 3f"I~!Jfcc~fOfl{-t{T, oqfij~ifi~f.:f\Tifi~Ofl{Us;:qq\:'{+t-15~~) ;iN ~ ~ ~-f~fcn~OfT SfTti\'~Of~~Ofllf'fQoq~'it~~~~fcf«f. ~r~-.r' 'fT{ftJ I -.~ m~; ij'~;m \:'{fi{fOfm{OfT91T~r.t~~, 3f~'i f.f~~U~~~",~~~ I

§ H. «l:<i~ f.«~,f.toi~S<{lq':, qtn_I~~ ~"'llf1{, I~ ~~'

(~ 'IT I 20

§ tV. ~ ~ "«~T~~TIf1I) 1i{ROfTI m ~ f~f<l1i{l-~f;(~Rt:, ~fu:,'lT60fT'it I ij'~i:fiT~~m6fij'~rfOftfu: 3ff~Rr: I 'i~qcntifq~~q ifiRir·~~ 1m' ~~m~u~~ ~f6: I 3fqp.nf{ij: ~~Rt~: *ifiRT "!HATI{qR'nf{l'R~Jf(*" 'it fu~f \l11:on-.t \IT{Of~~ f.lllTllOtfrqJij': I

.§ ~~. ifi~~-3lqOfq",itqlq:, 1:'ROi :q 1i{l~Ut~~~lRlI~GmftOf:- 25'3T~~!JT~oqftl~"1i{l'{UIllqrq:, ~~~~~oi ~ \:lT~r'-~1l:;~; ~m~oqftl~~, 'fi~C(;CCq~ll1{~ ,m;qt¥lT;qrtrllfll~msqT~1i f.f.rt~ m:T~ I ~~ ~\TN~~ ~: q~ltc(,~<tq~ I ~"'~ ll'fi(fllllij'T\:IT\UtRtlt~{!t!t{l(q)oqtqTa:; Q~rft:-i!'t~~ iIif 0{T1f \TRonY ~~)qijTij'~~~Ofr ~~~~qT~~ I 30

I:a~~lt)~~1.QJ2Jl~~~~~~~~!l!''hhfu:~.-~l£IR1Bl~lh.Ql:~~h2.QlillJo~~Jb''hl!i\t~k[I~~lh.Q.Q~ns-!hBl~J'h~~J~J~l.Q~I:~~l~~~~~!ltili~'ItIU'cJ~J~~!l!]Ilu~!t!ll:SSlh~~~'i.Q~J~»2thl£I~~b.h~.Qbi~J~¥~'i~J~Jt~21hI~~~J~~lt~H~:J;ItJs~hffi.Q}I~~~Jhl:l!~')tlS~

»ih~l£I~1~!l:l~~.Q~:tl!ltl\b~):UJl~N~J''hB~h~~thI£~~UU-l~~.Ql::tl!hhih~l~b~Jh2~~J1I.&~llH!l-t~'Itb~h£Jh~tht90-hlER»HhkI'hihhlS~l!lhllH~'lulillt'&h~~h~~2~1£I:~h~t~l!~-:yhlllh~Jh~b~~~@Jl£.ltllabll~~I:f:t?&~1)2b~~l.QJl12-ltt&

ts~~l:l~Jl,-~ll!l~~~~lh~lf~~~J!!:-~lh.Q!:~¥hhl:Jll1~&h~I.Q~hlt~lId~1@J~~l!!:bJ~e~!h~llt\Y~~lt~~-!l~blu!Sa:tR-.Q&J~-.Q~J~S·JJs~-h~h-lhll:bkI.Q:tleJt~~!t~.&O~-~12lf:~Jt1}t:lJU:ll!~2~lltJlltll~~:~~J~h~~alil:l}dt~.QI~~~~~Wh1~~1:)~~~h2.Q.&~~:.s~~~h2l:1h.~1U~~~}HJ:!lh2tlltblhS~h:t~!&I~h2lkll:i~~~~l.Ii~~-~2~4~.bh~~~~~#h1lh~~h!J1!t~l..JililIil!ll:~'&\,§

I~~lB~ll!~91-l~~~.l.Iilo~U=hJlll!l!~l!!:ijsl!~hil!lIihhl:2:lhl~lf~hlhlhi~~~~-~~~.Q21hlhilteb~~~!!:1nl~~l.Ii~1t2'~~llU~~:li&2l!lJ:~~l1lU:t-g:~2~l&~ltJJs:~~.I~r~l~ijJJi»1hh~~~l!)g:~lt:l~lm~&ltJh.Q-ih2lJW12ih2!~!~~}.Q.£h.llUlhJyJ!!:~~~1h\!t1h~ltliah~~l!:~~m~'lu~IhllilH.Ii~~~alth~a!~~hh~s~bhW:emI£J~~~l~~~!~£U:llt~~lj;!~Lhhl~hnllt-~.Q6:~hijlt~~l~!I:~181~'~h~~~~~~lE~.Q'~~~h~~lo:t.lilli.l.li~~&t~fhlnll1JslllJ:~lli.Q~~~~~~~ij1t2lY~ltl~'~6§

I£Ih~!!:~h:tlhlhkkW~lflhIh~~.I;t-!!hlh.l.2~'b21111oijhhlhu.ellsh2halht1t2JyJ,~.Q,h2~~.Il~l~l}29

-:tb!l:1':er;"''t.Il£~~~~llBhlb~lh~~~J!l~~h~1Shlhl£f~f~.ij~ll:!1t~!hJlollhJh~hh~h~lRhb~llthJk~I!!1X?l!!:

'~~l.!llsh2~~~~~.llDill\~~ill:~21~~),l:~,l!:lh'~lW1h~S~lf1h~1.Ii~aJ:t~a~~~l!:Ih

IW1t!!t~s

Ih~~I"~~~I~»!'A~Iila~~~~llti!uh~~~-lb!~ltl11t~"h"ijJot~a:~hl~hli:.I!Jl£lhh'~~~1~~

OS-~IJ.Allth~b~l\lb,!,b~~b~~~~A~''hl!1.lt~~~J1:tll!~h.ijlbll-hh~ln~~~IJ~.lJt~b~~~hhtl~~l:))~~tY~~~~'h~~ltb,~~~~~W;t~h2~!Il:&~llirlSlhh,~.Wl~lS''h!h~lIt~lJ.Alt'!>lli~hh~l:))~leJ~I~lijllilHlt~lthJLttl@~l!JSl~l!t~hll~~RQ0.~'ijh.Qlh!&~~lJ:~ijhna~lt~~lS

9(::~llltl~llS:&l!l:.IU9:illtlhh'~lSU!211t'h!l:~u&1ltJ.Allt~~-hllJ:h~2~~~~~I~U~lh~lS.J.A1.lt~~'l!Jll!bU~A~IhJ.Al:§.~~hJ.Am~~lJi!ltltH~'hhlQ~!l:hhltl~~!I:.QI~12~a!t-h~:l~lt.~h~hl'\.ty~~Ib!l:~~lh~~1Ji1.lt~lhlh2lU!~lAb~~2'~~§

[I!t1D~hIUthlsltE:1tJaJ1h!8J!'a1'Uls~~}J.lUJb''0]

06Ib~~~\:J~~lS!n~~~~~~~1~~!&~~~I~lY~~:t~M~~JJs~~Ih~~1hlnl!~!tllS·kIh~~~!1:~~:hlls~l~lltb!!:~l!~IhQl!21h~1l!tllS~~la~~IlIJe21ltltl~12~~~ll!~h~h.Q~I~~h&hl!t&:~lh!.QtclH:llt'b1n1~e~llihhQ~&~~~l~~'~J~l?J.Ilh~J:~'J2!~Jle

91.~!ele@~~!e~Ib!l:~llilllli!l:h~~~tc~l:llt1~~a~hQ~.Q:~~~~I~l:U~tc~J:~'J2!~J!ltl&t~~b2~~!&I~~J!~~!b3•~~b~~~ltt.Q1::~~~llb~b~b~h~'~l!~~~¥:2~¥lh2ihh!e~l~llth~~~~bili~h~~!b34j~1tijhiJltb:ta-ll!klt

'"' i!Jh!~~~~1l:2I~~lb~~~~~~'hi~li~l:i.Ltb~~~b:t&01Ib~~.Qb~~~~IbQ~~J.Q~h2~h.QI:~~l~li!l:~

-~l&h~~~s~~~~~Hhl.h2l:~!=.11~b~~~l:.Qh~~bh~Jt1J<h~I'llli:!Lt~lJ.Am~l~l,bhS~&,.tys~~'~l::~~~~l:llt~h~'~~Q~~J.Al£I~lLt!~!&l~h!itultl1n!b~~!ftl''ID~2h~ltJ!2Q.l!!1;~~~1::~J.A~~~Uufi.ijh1l!l~~~!I:1J.A~''hh~11l1e~le~

9~~hMll-ll:~&hl!t&Jn!J:12~':J.tl!thl~:~~hh~l~~b~~I~~eh~@l-~nl!!lt1n1.lthilll~&l~~b!i'~~~l\-'tlih~&lts.QI~h~~.~h2·lt:sll-lli",~~l~I~JS~~tc~b~Js.Q:~~a~l!:ls-~l1-~l:~h.Q.~!&·~h:t.Q·:§~J:H&l£~-~~l~~R'7~§

[I!t~~~l~taa~~.~]I:ltf~~lblDJJtJ5•~

6'1

~ ~ri~t

~ iTq~Wf1{., ~iI"l4'(NI~r"Ef~m~t q?tT~~~ ql{~q6 ~~ ~~ I ~~,q •••.(j( f.f~"l~ ~fij,~~~, q~ Q<mf \m'lll'"" ~ ~ ~~~ ~~ mfit I IIT~-~: 3£T1RurT{T3f'4R1g.u••~ ~lfTRf, ~,q~ ~(i"~~I~~~'

5 ~~~'iT~~1

[ ~o. ~:qqt""'1W ~~ I]no, Qiit,"3(QIl!JI(ifiIf\ lfOl:qq'4(W1~ I lI'f{:qqitfTf.l~ ~~.

~~, '11~1"'ti't~~~,,~s~~ ~~~1~ ~o'l1{.l ~<{f{f.ll4~-~lI'Rt-A'~qRriRH'", I ~ mmO:Qmftuil lI'rn: ~f<r: I

10 ~¥u~~~ssr A'~q~~qijlfr~~~:, 3ft:q'ff Qlqlr~ql!l~ lI'ot:.f{q~~"S{~ I fcf~~r fcf~'{1fTftaft~~fa': I ~!if ~q~ tm·~~"l Rf.:tf~fflf« ,(qij, fcf~ tI lA~')~ ~({ Ifft:~~{Rr I ~ ~ t "i\' H~~f.I'fqfoTlft:~q' qft~~ I

( H. ~~mw ~'Qf~ I )

~:; 15 § ~ t, f.\Rs~(6q~QI'4I~lft ~~~ I 3f~ ~~,,~ql!J~ I(' ~i'Clq(QI~ ~( ••qlii(f(61{ I 3fT~ut ~ ~;r, ~~~ssrt~TS'

~(I~Tm QI'4(uI~'4r<l:t3(ri~,{l«\' oqTfil~~~t QF{(IJR'tf-m~~IfIf~1f I ~q •••dun ~uf\l", Q~f.lr~'" ~"f-~fWnRr ~~~I

20 §~~, '~~ll(hfq;{\~ •.Q~~?\q\\1' (fa~; ~,,;~~.;ni1t 1Rm q~~CR:~ m~qffi<l: I

§ ~~. ,~: \~~ " m' (fa ~!R::; ~'I;3fTU(q'qMm-~~?\;ft.ni(~R:SI'1('jq1 ~iVq( %"4(!qlf.l(\~, ~fijriQnlR ~N"~ I ~1fl'fiqmit ;r Al~qRtf(jij- ~; ••~ ~~'"

25 ~srt;r ~ I ~., 3l~fti:fi~6(R'q(ij: lfi1{ ~~ f€r.n lftT·ct~:~ I 3f••~;flq~~•• <If fcf;rr~q~i) 0'11(t1liC(tIlqlqtqqft:fl«t~~-~t ~llTlt: ~qt~~q •.q3( R~(: I ~ srmJ'l. I

[ ~~. ~ qs~ qpr ~~?:J 'I{ ~~~!Il~ I ]

§ ~\l, 3f'i QUI8UQCd-ami1fU~1 ~~ ~·JRlifw"·ij~-Sill'RT·30 sS'l'fiWT: qilSlltil(1( I 3(3¥t ••ql!il~•.q ffii rout~, qtrr ~<l:(ft~¢'iITtP(I

08I~~ij~l~~-ltlh~lhi~~).IH!.ltl~:&2'~~1h~~l~lh~,:l!:~lffiQ~,{h~~~~,~bb2~~~lillsaJU~tya~Ulli.b~~l~~D~~lth~tl~~,l!~4~~.I!~ijijhU~L~lslll~~~.Iij~,1tlll!lkltJ~ls,'~~JIIDIalS-~~1Ul!.lh~!e\..~bb~~l!h~~m~llfUJU!ijlh~~lhil!l~~~~~h

9ZIhh~Illi!~~l~~:&2hi~hlli(b~ld~R~f~h~~~\ph~l.b!li~hJ-h!lS~~hJhaal~r&'l\h!~\!!ls11~~>.t~ijll!J}~~1~~~~iIh!e'6\e§

I~.lllHt'~Jb~~~l!~~~Jh~-hhlsIh~!e'~~!l!lhhlt~1~~tij~~ijh2b.l:!llU~~lm~llih:k-l!l~hlli':~aJltill:!)ijl~ltl~~~ijh2~~~fllQf~~.ij),~

0<:~~~bi~k!ll1~ll:Htllliltl~~~~~h~l.tdt,~Il~I:~b~1h~~~a.t,l~(b~ll~lll~;~~~.I!hll!lA~iij1U~fut~\illl!l~~l£,~b~!eI~l~!hb~J~~~tyhlh2~~~tylb!l:\fl!f~~~h~'~ll:lhlhhltlI~l=!l!~~hl::l1~hJhlli~i}@~~l~iitblS~i!il!hllhll:lllsWhlliH'~ll:~~hhlt~lhi~b1t1?~"l-lit~.ijs~4Hill£fll~

9I£:h~-~~H~ih.hil:ll!illhJ~lS~~~l!ll!i:lib2Wl:.bi~~~~'~e§

I~l~,a~)~JIS~2~~),;hh-ijtlt~hl~~,)t11~lh2~~),,:h:ijht~~~~,,~h~:~~~l::tIlt,4:~2H~l~1.l:Jla,,:hl:l!~lti~,,:h~~~U:Jlh\PJ~Q,lhhIhl!l~-~lS~~~ltH~.l.a~\!t~l~lhlli~!-•••~ij~~1U~b'~e§

or[I'hl.oh~J~~.~~]

I~Q~reJ!ijl!~JltJ~i!~JI~hi!J\Pht4Ih!1ti:~lliliIHltsln~~~~f1!~PJIl1h~Jij:tb1JIhthJ~~ll::&lQlIlS1l!~-h~Il::tI~l2~lltllS~l~lU~.I£~~:gh~~h~l~!iyLb~~l~~l1~l!~f~~.IYlUh=~~lht ~~s~~~Ubhh!}~2Hh~~lh.b~lh~~ij:th~~

9I~h~~1l:2~~~hhli~ht'~~~~h~h~~~b~~~1r2fl!f~

~hJh~~lht~~{\hhhl:J'l~~Uhl~~~jbI~1Ilt1s~llilltl~~-llhl:Hhls~lill~h2~l~~fl!f~~lillltlS1llInc.·P)lbl:llhh·~ltr£JtI~lhh~ll!lh~l9:h~JY~Wt~afl!f~.ij~~JnUtls~~~-hh~~~~~QW!eI~llill!:~~.1£~m~h'&lDlhhh~l!

..

•

~

\I:~\!::ijhJol.lt.l1.~~

~~l!tt~,~lh~Q,f~f~~~ahtal~~~h~l.bm~1h2.)I)~btAh~llUa~!tUt41as~lWb.lD~~~~~~a:~08-~hltla:hl~hl!lbIh~ho~~~lhlli~m~h.lh~hl£•~£§

Ih~hi}JBlhij~lS~Ql::tI~Q2Q~~~llllyh~1o~2~.I}~~hm·~mQI})lQlo~ll~b!l~ht~huth~lli~a:~il4:~Jll!a~lb~hh~-~.l:1Qh1&hH1~~~l1t~~ijh2ht:~~lJa~~lt.J!ilhl!!hUll~~H~-ltJh~Sl~hiU-l:J1hQI~Hill,hh~ll:~t2h~,;h!h~lbh22h~HtgZ

'" -2!tlh,41?:1~lt ~11:1~~~ta4ijlaltla~~l:~1&:h:t!lcJ~~t:lh,lhh4:~2l~hllttl~U:1lt~Rillh~ut~~~t~a·0£§

[I'hlnh.~ht!LQ•A~]~

I~~ltJlYh~!lta~l:~~lYtill11h~~tt.ij},4Jl~JJtitl~tt,I~lSlill%~lh~JtU~1hbftlli~~Hl~JltIlulU{lijl1~lU~l.bttOZ~h~~~l~J,&h~~m~l£,~l!.I}~~ll:~ijh~~~!1~J~~}~l!!:~hll£12Q~h~lhlollllS~JijliltJhli1~~~ttij},:h~l.bihh.bl.t~1€,A~hI~Dhh\..~b!l£ItltQl!~l~,:b~l.b:2hlt~!tl£,ija~~}~h2~~.~J~~wthb~Ql:~Li~~lh~J,~J~:a~~~AtJ!lh".l::tIQ~

I:lthh~~~hh~h~Jh~hl:t.~~~I1lQ~~t.:\b'1!1hJ!~ijl~~~~l:~lt}:h91lo~I1M~~~Ill~l:~liltJ~tt'luh~~ill~altJb!ttt.ilh2!lJ:ill~·hlaHelllihl:lt\.~l!~l.ijl:lt~Q~nhlltQh!!:~lh~ijJ-&~Jltha

·h~~h~~~~~lllft:£ll~J,:h~ll:~hl:11!t~,h!h!lh1h!a~~l!.h~-atJltlhUlJi~Ill~~i~t~ij~,:hl:11~lB~,-~~Jl.~e§

I~lI11lSQ1hJhQlhO)}.»l.ollttt ~lijl~llU4.~hll.tylhlllli~~lh~,:h~lt01

~lll~\!!,Jhb~l£I~~ij~S1~liltJJill1lUl!Ji~J,:hl:11~lB~,hi!i!~l~~1t:\!!AlURlt~lU.ir~~~.tybllHa~fJl.Qf~}

[~E-f>\Eo~oh~oJ~@']

"II~IIl~1AJtlJ1l!lhh~!ijst~b.lb~alt!~I~~..~11~~J.&~S~aJ~b:tlS9

IILII~~ftwUt!Ull&ldJ!Jbhlih~!sI&J.i~~l!t!~la).}1b~).}w~~b~~~"

-h~'~~~lth1.!U~lihUut~lt~A~11~l~h'J:.I!1illtbl~llhUlJi'~lt~~ls~1!Sb)!h~.A~-:lt1t11t.l£·,e§

1W1t~0..1

I

/'~I

Illj),:~l<"llddtnLlt

!:lib!j~:il.\,ijhJl!l.IrH"Jmol!r.J.Ii£llh.(/·•••H·~~·~)"tpHt..!l!l.lJlb~1:/.iliili61·d'~~!d!p\l'\~.(NJ:J"I

I&~~~hJ~!h:.Qh~h.llt~~~~!tb~P~!~~h:t.~B~h~Jlal:h21~IH~~l:~i~Jl~JtU:t1~1~I~~::.~lt~~hh2~;i~ll!lh~

g6(l;~)~~th~l:t-~I1nblt.lihhnlhl.lihi!!:~~"!!ll~l:l:;!~1~11: hilI~111~ 0;::t'~,).,)~,).·h~Ih~~2h~Jilhlln.1n~~1l::2Ilh~!!:2h~l.In.~t~l~~~Ul~~hh~~IJh~M:nU~Jy~~~!a~lhi~~~h1tJllb'~ll:llilhlS:~12~~~hJIBl::hilll:Jhl~Mh~~Jlh2f~~f~h!ij~~lh~~J)tlolhls:.Ql::i~ll:~I~lili~llil$!!:~l:;!mtg\!~'~l!!:~ltl;lhlolhlS~~l!ll~n.~~}~~},j

03·h~ltl1:ItI:~~~l£B.I1~1l.lh~blh21n~Q!hl}lhsh:lUt2, ~'n§

I~ll~lJill~~~l~.QthB~ij.l:h2~l11<~1:Ih~!hll1:~slh~hhltl.~l~~~llJlth~hlli~l~h1::J~h2l:1hl:l1U~hfuh~h~flh~~~It~~}

"II:~~~~hl~.HYlh:tJ~~b~bst1I:th~UJll:U!lltbA¥Jl£~~)~!.l\Ut~"

91-1t~~':~~llltJ!b~~il-:lliJijl~ll!ll~h-hilibfu~b!lS~ltl1h:t~h~~lI~)1t:t~h~h:ll~ht~~~S@:t~h~}Jf~l1'ch'&~h:l~hIi~~ihl~~ih:tr!M.l!hl~~~~~':~Dh:tr!h~lhiht~hlS~~~-~~Jh2hl.llJ~-fuhI:~~JshnlhllS:~lJ~l:h!!~~h~~hlllli~12hIhlb11h~S~Hhl:;!~2tkll!ll:~1nJhJs~h~l~h:llhihh~h~lhllthi~hi&ll~rl!ltlh

01-lh!!h~llU~jlh2~lll!h!!=B~~~~lBhh~ll;lh~~~hlli~l~btl!lllY~ltl1h-m~tUJsf~.Q[;ilj~~l!J1nlhJs~l&l~b:ib~~.l;JlltBb~till1'e£§

IIb~l:~l~~~hl!~~t~lSl~~l!:tB~-~h."bml.Qhl\..hhi ~ll~~lfJt~~h!~JsB~ili:~~1:~kI~~ll!l!~1Ut~lS-~l1t!lle:l.l;telh&.lll~al;fhIiH:h2~!!!lt!h:t1hl~~ll!lk.Qh~ll!hJtUJs!llh~

9.1~~ll%hh~hlli2~t.Ql:;!~h\..1nlh2.l;ht!.l:1·1nI:~.l:htllll!S(~h)~~hllM:S.~!n.!~!h~~~l~1nli!!!~.Qhj:~.l:hl~hill~~Jshl~ll1!!h.11H:~~~-!!!~~JsI~ill:t~l!t~12!~~!!:lt~~2.Q'~h%lll:lh~~~S~Ul!ll1:1.l;h~~I&~h~~b~h~ltlli~~m~~1~~~!£'~ll:1ltl1nlhJs~h~~-~l:tl~Js1nlQ~h!lhml~hh@ilY1h2~}~hD~h~~Bmh~~ltl:~t~

A~!:;'~hlnl.l:tls.a

( ~ IJ,. at~m;t~~rr..~~m'fi~~ ~~otll. I J§ ~ 'J. ml:'{f{l~ijr~fcJ~",~-3f~moPll (I{ fm~~,~qwl '<l I ij~ t«-

~{O"(-~~;1:'t~n:O"(,,"~O"(~ijT\iqR~r.{ ~'n~q" titn 1l\'T(flq~q ~~(f~lfi1'JiP:j'

fq~~ t{f~qT;{~fij ~H",~I 3f:{ t{!~O"(-ijl~~~O"(q.: ij8~(/til~'l ~T~O"(·

5 ~"q<tijq\, ~~?tr fci~(JTSffu~~i(~l{l1l\'T(JfQ1f\~ 'if cti~qm~·

m.u~ql~SfQWT({.I

[ ~~.~~~"~«R~ I ]

§ ~'1.f",f~(fT;:q~r~q~~~ijoTt t{!:, it {J f~(.1j~ctir~: I ~'tTf(-

~~~O"( ~ ~i!ftRl.n~rh ~1:'t1h~~sfmS(oq~~, ijq~ ~::f~<tT-

10 m:q ~~~~;r0!i~ij~q;fofq~sij't:rf.f~t~ "'l!t1f\T~\'A>fo(f.trntnQ;~~-

itT~flt~SffuU~~qqitftfu; (f1S{; ~I-tlf~;rr~l~sfq~f(f ~'Jiiif~cf.l~-

tJl~, ~qft ijP-f(f( ~ir~(~1f\~'t<t({, 3l~(f itlT~;:jJ ~~~~T'-f311T",·

~~",r~ I it '<ll:{lfq f~T(.1jT<nT~T~;t~f.I'"q~3iit~qT~q~ fjf~it~T~ll-

~"T( ~~~ q~~~)qqf~~fu ~~; 3lit3\{~lftiNfflf;t'(~~~~i{ qijl:'{lf-

15 fc()qqT~;r ~~p~~qt iliT'Ji'fiTfroqitqra~"t, ••itq~q,N ijt"f.Uqtt~: I

~ ~ ~. it~ ti~~ q~I:'{&(fl's3fllar itrW ~ lIi~ ~ q~lWrlfi{qll ~RI~; 1fiR~~T~qq~q~'JiijqT Jf(1JtT~~lfR' tJ~T it1f~iJJ~wi' fcr.rr~(.1j~~S~qlf;l ~~:{, lfiRIIf tGlf{IJfTf"1~O"((ftJT tJ'ft tR~ "rt'llO{l~Fl~:rr~~:{ "{q~q qci~ Jf{OTrmflt~:r lTt",fllfu I sqTmlf{~ltit {J

20 qciQ~q ij~~t~{"q1fr~it it !f{ ~RI I

§ ~~. tJ~ "'liaoqlt7lT q~qm\itJaTI:'{",ar.ro:l:'{lf{~ IlaJm\iq«ij~qTi{l{,

(f~~-"q~¥5l'( ~ ~qq ~T\iA~q~r~q",••qrm{~\ra:, ~;q!if~ Iff{;qlfu:" ($I.rr. ,., <:) (fu; (f1S{; ~il(lttiT ~): {{1~~TtiOffir

{{~t ifftoqlmr,,",~qf<t!{fu~it (1m: m~(~Ts)oqfltm~~-25 ~<{~q, iff{oq,~" ij{~n:l{~fc(~q tn1fll, mif~qT ~TRfit"lf~~?{O"(

~~~ l~:q~;rr~I it ~~~ ~(foqlfillf{1f\~ ~ l{<f(lfrr(.1j~) q~m"ltij~-m~~'Ilo{\~(1i)~q{qf\: fcfi{fq~)~flq-r~qsrot~flIfu q~nI~ me{-

I. Though this view has been accepted by a school of Nyaya,Vaisesika and Sankhya also. yet since the Buddhists laid specia]

emphasis on this. it has been attributed to them. See Dr. Kothia,D.L., Jaina tarkasastra merit anumana vicara, P: 191

IlIu,.ltbhU!t~llkM~.I!~!U~1l:~~!C~.tLi.I<l1UrJ.t>Ji~I:l2lUr

k~lhSj.~~hl!.I2Jh1l!.l!t:UJ!!~J1.lt.illEI~~JIS~l.!b.21l>1lWtbJlli1h~\p!

I~JtnaJISb.2tnJ!!R~~J.I!~llbS~JhltJllUb~.bl~h<lw}io~~g£e;·d'"p'J~)r~Ul~J~p~"p~AS'I

i!~mIh~~~hl!~lat~Ih:~Ut~~lli!}tB~Jllhn~hi~96-lhl!!111t11h:~IUtBt~J1Jls:a&J~~h~hhlhl~hIlIh&~l1J1~h~h~ls

-9!~U&ll~1:l~hhf!}a1'! U~h!k'~hBh~mIh~"'lbhJ1.lD}lIullhg•6~§ ""').~~Ih~l~hl~~~~~l~~~lJ1

-:lt~l.t:lhi~llbI&l!:lBltJht~h~lhf!!hllh~S~l:U=1~lhf!!hll:2Il'!tl·~h~lU~hmi~i'I1~I'!!!a2hQ1~lhh!~h~~[lh~~~Blli~]Ihl1bn~h)~~l:t

'--'1 03·ia&~lJ!~~~~lH~~~Ihh!l£I1EJh.'\I1J(!t~1J1~!!o)~111l:!!h~~lh~lhlS.~hltll.l:;lh~l.lHh~lh~h~l!ia1'C!hl1h1'C1'!l'! IRll:lt11110!!:~1~~lh~ls-!l11'!l{ltjll!2b~~l:'l:~&~nlhl!~ltll'!J1~~l£I~l.1:~h~lli#hlh~hil'!

..tyll!~~ll1lS:~l11h~~hltnll:~ls~l~.lp~~ijltll'!!i:l1~lt•0~§

I~l1::~~i~h~stl!~~~lhltJmhil'!IDhi~~:nl!lhls~lhf!hlalh!!!~~~~~Il!:~~~

'~12lsl~~~l!st.l!th!h~1~i~~~.l:;bj'IDl:lt:tllli~ls~l1~ml~Jhlltl:t?~lh.~hltll:hj~ml1~jh&l!~~lt1I1ln~l1h&1h.1h~ll!~ml.~&hlh1111~&h~n2·l~i~h.ltl!&l'!(~&j9:lllltl~~t-u11hih~ml:~21'!)J&~hlh~.~£§

Ihln~I'!I1~ij.tS~~h~h~h~1111illhltll!kI&1n~1'!fl!1:t01'~jh~2J~~mlsIh¥~h~mh2l:~~~l&h~lsIh.lDb~ltlr:J1!jI'!Ullil1~h~hijls

'll'!h:\H!!~~il:~ltlth!\l!lI'!Qhld~~~Ihh~mh:~11~~l1~!i:l:tltll1I'!U~lsl£-~~~~~~l1jh.\m.lp&~%1.l:;1'!Ihb21'!111fut.h~m~~~f!l!.,£~

[IJf:b:h3t~~hda'51~]

IIDh~SJl~ln&~i!~l=~lth~~hbf!lhb~I!&JeJI.IJ:~119'ID~iElhJYS~Udl:~~~h~~lJ:H.ilH~:111h~It1:~}ijll::~:th~!tB&hJ,:th!hJ

.~&~ltl~~f&l'!21hhilil'!h!l:hJlh~IllJ;&In&~~~):iJ!e1hhl~)l1h.l:;hi,~fills~~Uh!~h~ls~Ul.1:~hh.ltlr:Bjlbl£hlln:tl.l:~l1ls~lh:~h~J:lHt~l~

'~h~H~J~ll:~t!l'!:~~H~~~I~h~l'!tyla~l~~l::~!:bU!!:~J1~n·h~lll:~J:ltlsll:)j~~Jl~1St)!:bWUI1~l.Q~!lbth:~~I:ltj~Jt~~

HI:l!@'-'ijhlnlltl5.~

111~~l!llts~JS!1h~~.t!wJitl~[J.lt].IUAh~~ltl~lh&'~~11·.als~Jhnllilt~U.th~Uo.l!t~~\tlkh~llijh~~-&~~~.~~S

I~Jij~hh~lh~I!JjHI! lJ:ltlJss~\tlh:§:ltlha!U~! ':»-jllJ:lltit~H~hh~ll:~~·~1!~~2QIij,jy1.tt.t~~~~21~lJth\.lH1J~'t1~JlhHQlhls1h2h~!UJ •~~§

I:~bJ~lh~~l1&h!h~~1\~~!i:~~I.I:!!t:§:h~h~~~!l!fp~~J)96['eb'"ol.l:!lnlli.H]

,,116hb~~b"l&11:6&1&bilalh~l~~~t.l:t.h

I:b~Jbb.~Ie.~b~j,/ij~t.l:t~ltUt.~l::ijJ.l!H

-l%1.}~'~l~h1l!hlll~J!Il~llthl!tl.1}:(1hs~Qltl)lhJhQ'tll!:~t~~I:~~~illl!lhl~~ijit':~1~41h2~t~~I:~!lJ!lthJ:llt!tJ~tl~!1JitO~':'f!-'.I2lshlitIl~lh~lhIhhhlltit':hl.1l:11:tlbHt ':hhl:l1:t·:lHl:~1hlh~m "'i:j~,\:.••.~~"•

!hl~aJ:QbitI~~lhl;~~l&~hil~J~JJl:~~.I2~ij:t~lh~J:1h)Jt: '~I:lln1S·Mlt~lh2l!lh~l~iJs~.12~~~~)!u~~~~lh~~",mIMtl!4!J~Jt'\~Jh~·!l:~1h1;~11~~hl.l21~1l~~lh~l!1l~thl!1h2~lhl~.12:~.~1:lf;•E1\§

I.ijJ[n.~o~b]91,,~~la-t)t~&~1:2!J~~lijb~!l:.ty,,-&~~~I:hh~J~J~.uh"'lli~~~.I21~.12~\tlp.~~!lJb~!i:ltll:H~hl!ti~",m:\,ln~I~~~!1Jhh\.lnlhtILith~~h~!l:ltl1ll1hJ1~LlthlUs!!,!lli':hili~!tiltl&~Slltlll~lt'!hdl·R!ill1(:~)l!lh~h~It.':~!JSl:~~l1:~!l:I!!lijtll1l:yh:~!JSIhh1.11h~ltl·hlt~I~~h~1;~'hIls!h1~J~h~I!ijl~l:H~tlh:~!J!~~!l~1:1£IItlolhOT.~~J:)~:\IJ2~~~~ll!~lp~ll!l?lh~!J:)ll:tGit':~flt~!\Ili~H~~h~~lt~'1IlIhls!i:hl~blt11HI!~J~fi I!~S~~!llt4h!4th~~b~!!:ltll~h1.~lln~h~lS~~.12':~~h~"'l.I2~~hJ1J~lJ:~Ht}.. Ibni,hh~~lnl11ls1:~I&l:~~~1S'h~1tl1ll1h~~~hIiliJh~1QIIM:~~~h~ltlfn~~hh~tholh1lslholhlJ1.I!~J~J£I&}:t~~1s101hlS~~~hhlh~h~nlRhH1!!:holhltl1l>cJl!J.l:~IItlh:t9·lb~~~101hls~!Il~l~~~~!Il~lo1hlS~~!Il~~ltlJ1:lLI\tlh'ell.§

I&h2n~~l&bJbRhltll1~l~~~lh~h1U1")!~tGh:ln~hh2SJSJltl~hh"'llt'.I;lh~!blJ:2~ihtij~~\.&hJl:hitI~l~t~~lH~lh~-(~h!\llt)~lh:\l.12IhI!B~h~!lklkrl!~~tlh!hhh"'l!l:l!1ILhh'l!~~h1h

IJhUt9!~ ~.•..'!i

t~~·d'OP!qIOJ:)o£t~~-£~~-d(~ll!~~Ull!Jl!P~AP~AS]:)Or.

9°£°d'l!A~AUl!P~A"J:J°1

£h:Uh~~Ih:tW.h~ht~l1l!~n!l:tlb~~~Jt:~l~~~~~ltll:~\;1!l:hJh!ll!~.~Ul\;.1£~~l~~hla&J~~~~~~~h2hih~hltl~11'~.ld~~hJl>cItl~~l!hll!21hl~~~~lhH!(J:)~llt1!~~~J:n~~h(.t!)~llh~h!l:ll!hh?!!I6~1~

96-ll!.lltmeIh~'@h?htltJ:!!:\;JI!~Q~~~lt~h,@S~h~lllhllth!!:lll!:tJ~lt~~1!I~lBl~~~l!hl~\;h~s~llhn:tlltllllt~l~~hI~l~l:tl1~jJijh~1ltlUl~~Inh!.if;':~b~l1~hDlltll1ltlln~~lh~J1~l.1:!'lt~Il;~2l!~~!~1~h:tllh.n:tll?~(I!~.l)~it:~~fi !=~lt~h~l~l!~J:.if;I'ltl!lbiiih~;:klli~~.l:2h~l;~-lt~h~1l!~~!~l!llih'hl!llti!~hnh!!l:.I:h2~1~~~~Hltl.tl.l£'~~§

~l~~~~~~hlUl1~ltll!~lt~!lt~ltlJDlijl~~':hiill~S~1J~&l.tl!t}H~~I~

~lltti!llhI~S~i~hi:l&tt\;llt~Jil1l:~hU'~~bl1l!IjthlhUl»l~~~1!ll.t~l1:lhl~~l1'~~Iij~l~ltll.1:hlt~lU~h~L~l1ijlt~lt'~i

1-----·lt1S1Hh:!hi!hl~~hll!1lth:tll.I:~l.Qlh!h~~ltltIhh!.I£'~ll!~lllhl~~l!

91·~hl&~~~lh:th?l.Q~.l:l!e.l:H~!1hft~h~h~J111l!!tB~Jh~hltl~11 :~~~~:!l.th·n:tle!:t~E.if;I~l.l:~~h:tll\!t111hl~hhll:!llth:tlll:S~~l&hl~h~ll:!!::t.l!~l!·hhlhhlJ:l!lbi!l~l1~ll:~hq~h~hh!l1Bh!hll:l~U~Js~h:~l1kth~n9~.Ql!l1}:Yhhil!l:~~~h!&~!:~iiW~~1l~Js21l:~l!llth:tl.t ~121l:~h~~hI~ll!l'I~~ll!\;llti!:t~~l!~'~nH~hftl!lbi!h!!!ltHl!l:l:~~~h~l:th'G\~§

01[I'h~1lJb~J.ISlil~llt~hl~b.;?6]

I:.ttJ~~2·hl11t1hl:2!t*~llthJh:t.ltijlami!~~h~J~lltl~~lt.lhltllh~~U~-~lltl~j;hS~nhlllhh~!nll~.2~lt.l?lb~ltl ~llzn~~ll:1hlnbl.tlJlI1~~J:ltl!t&llW.h~J~l1h~l!J~!l:llI:P~lhh~~ll:~~J,~~ll!Jpl1.ty~,l:~~21l!

s!D11~!l:t~~lth91lt~l~J[8G\~d0llt0JB~~],,1~~by!!J~a~"lUlJll£Ih~~H..~l!l'Illi.t:~~~l~~~~S~td.2h~~.I1:~~~Q~2l:'38§

I~l~~h:t.t:lh~~~h~h~lQ.\!blE!~h~~ijh:thl!\;RlltlU~-Qijll!l:hllD&~1:lliSl~l:t~!j:&~~!ktlt 'h:t.t:~~llUJD~~~lllil!:~~'1h9.~l)~:~~~ll:~It~l~!!:ijIhih~hlll.l£~~:~hi![ll!]ll~h2s~t

~~I:l!~.lDlltls•~

~9<;·d"P!qI:J:J.£<;<;~-t<;~·d'·P!qIJ:)-z

{-<;<;·d'eJl!){~Ull!Jl!P~hP"!1ASJ:)·1

-~~~~h~t:Jhh':H~~l ~~IJH~hu&~hl!!h21011!i!1!~.Q'ilh!!&~~~e~~Jltlll~l~l!i!;l\dl~ls~h~hl.a~h~nfbhllif~~~~h-hlt!t~a~l!~lHe''It!i!blh~lhJ.!i!~~!Il~l!.I:t:t.a~S~llt!hl!i!~I.ijh-hlt~h~~l!i!l!2~l.l!!ih'~ijIt'~~h.l!t~ij~h~hh~)hJ!:a~ijsa'ij~~~~lhh':~Jrill~JlIlI~hlili~lSll!lhl1hW~lh~:J:;l\~~:~~~':h'ht~ij~bh")b~Uhl>.~lhl!lhhS~~hJhh"~~~.!liJ!i!I:l:J}tIl~~b)l't)h~}Ihlb~~:M':~)li(t)~h2lulhilill~-b!hl!i!~)h~IJUI~a:~~~hi~hhI~~~h~~~ll:~.Sl~lhh'.1::0h)I.tt~!i!-lhh.Q'J1~:!llt~Ia!i!l\llil\~~lll!i!hlli~\JO~-:l\~tl~i~ijt~Ialli~~ll:.bi.lyIY-:J.:\.~J:ij ~u=.&.~•.•§

[Ilte~lIb~IIDI)!t"k~~·'o~]

I.ijh2l!~h:»~~hl:l~~~SlQ£~ijlh~~Ud&h.~ls~~hijlsltlhiJ:UJ~hI'ltl!hl1~e~ls~~!i!lli~h~I~S~h~US~'~~~ty~~!tl!~H:aJ~»,hI~S~~l~SY~~'~lh2l!lUlnlhlsllDijllil\:!l!Jij.ls illhI~s~hJU.Is~':~~-~h~l!lll!~h2hI:~~lll!~~~~ls~'JUl:lta~h.aHltJl!hl!ll.bS-llDt~ln~h2lDlh.ls!llllll\:!l!ijls~lh2~l~.bIl\!Ol!J~lhWh~h~~i&:h-~.lh~'~~~S~~~lQ:~~tij~lh~hillUU1~~h.,•.•§

I6JUl;~lhlslhh~\.lUIhtitijtlslh•0Yl!h.QJ.!'lt~kl.Ql!lltll!lYu~~i~h~ll~l.b~~lll!il~l~~~~hlt

Il>c~~lh~IRli~~~~1l!~l!h.hij.ls:~U~:!l~h2.Q~l£'::;lijl!t~-~~~&h~lh2lnH~~~4)u~~l!h1l~1llU~l!.ijls':~h.ijlsl.b1!~1l~~~~'hl!el!~l~l!~WlJWU.b.l!.I!hlJ:ht:h~~el!~h•••.•§

I:~.b~l);!t!t~lt~lsh~J~9-hijlsh~Ull!~lslQ~l!~I!~~hHtl£:~hh~~l!~lliI~lh-~l!lQ~hIhh':~~~~1b1~b~lbh=Akhhl~1lt:~~'b~§

-r.'Il~»ij~~)IA2."ts~1h!~b2IDIItI1!i!hIh&hij!Ult-l~h~~~J'd~t~Jt!th~IltJS.1~~~lJ~I~

llUktQ~~kA

~ttTrq~T~qqwft~~ ~fffiil~qT"~~ i[iJ~ f<J~" ~lfit~~~riiJ {RI'f)f~~T«q: 'l~""n~: ~~it<=:q qqqR'f I ~T~~ ~~~""h,q~<=:f(f~fUt:sn~, fjT~~~q,~~q:r '6~<iT<=:q:,'6~;f.'t~~ ~ ~~Q!i<=:~~""m qqq-~ftRr il~oq"\lT;r.n,,~: ~t~~r;qf ~<=::I <tiI~ «{",,~:, q~t ltHXfaW~q<{~fctijl{(ffl'~<{~Trq~~q~ft~~~ ~~n,~m ~ f.l~" ~'Hr~""~Q:, 5Q~ltr?r~q~l{t"~~l{qR'f, q~~rH~:t~qqR~qTmtrn~lt-W1rqq)ltf<{,+qt~-ltFFfiT~'fil~;qTS~ ~~: I q;~l<=:ll~ilt~ llmq~<tTlrq{~ ijl~~Q"T\q,«~t<l;fl ~,;r~qr Q;%fij~NijN'fifctN~qr~<I ~"'f<l~~q~~ ~~ll",ij I

~,,~. ft(f'T~~ r.iq\l~~<iT f<l~:itq~(i\l"'ltr t ij' "" ~'l~rqf<t~-<I{~TO]'T~q~\l~~ ij8\lT I ~~r "T~" ij'~~T ~'fitr<l:, af.'t~,rG- 10

~Wl~~ I "'~~ ij~'l~"'ll:, Q:r ij'rW~ I "t~~ ~~q-~T~G:, <{«'li?t'fiT~~:I ""~~llHJ0i """:, ~,ql~'fi~Ti'Q5JT'l'fi~Q~ql~Iwlt~fltmlij- Um ~Qt~, il~~~~n~ I ;{f~~a~ ~~~:,\;{'iiT('ii)C!g~~~ I 9fT~~1l fq~~~i{, ~~'lT~ I 3{~n~<tiIrG:5ffuq.\-q~'fir;~q ~:tltT<{ijTfq~: I ~:{ijt=~~~ 5fRilf\iqQ~"f.t~qf.t~:a-15<l1\f.t~qoqT~q:I q~"f.t~T~T~~ sitm-q~ltf.t~:a~~q~'fiT~1{ I Uql~-'fi~fl~~T'lf.Ji~~H~"'T~r..~q~HlI1l{ I uftQlI~~ ~QTU~ltf<l~:a·~q~'T",~q'l'i"'~: I ~~rlI«q~ ~q~«q~~q~~T'ij~~~: I ijlq~-<::~;{"" f;{~q~'lr..~:aij;q;~r{ij~~~f;{fu I

§ ~ \1. Slra~TsA t~fir..\l:-f.lNm\lf.Ji: 5ffijq.~m\l~~fu I am.) 20f<t~q~f;\l'lTltr fii~qf<l~'fiT~~m;roqTq'fiij'iI~~~;lt~q?l·\ll I q~ 3H~ umftr~:, ;ftUf(oqTqRt~~~: I fcrq~s!i ~q:, ~~ir~-mlft<iT~I q~il~nf~'fiTr(fH~, Q;'fir;a~;rm"~ I ~!i ~~Tq"~q~~~: I 3H~~ f;{~<mlT'lq:,~~,~q~~ftfa I

§ ~~. frn~Sr..~~~ri\l'lTltT 5ffuq.\-qt~~ltT<{oqrq~~'fit~ - 25'l~~U'(l~~~ij'{~~I~q~liq~t~ ij'tN' tq~ r{~5( ~a~ ~lt:, ~q~-~~HI~q ~ltt~~Wlllt~ I ~~ 'r.H{:, ql~q~q~~: I "'~~-~r~fu'ij~fui~ ~~, 3{iUr{~~~ I 0{ ij'r~ 5f~5f~ij'~ mttT!,~ifT~~ I .n~ftt~R\' U{Q~ ~tfa:, ~~q~{J~ I oil<=:-

r_ The varieties of different types of causes are given as four(Sthanangasatra, P: 309-310) ,fifteen (Pramanasamgraha, :l9-30)twenty-eight [Pramanaparlksa, pp_ 72-75), twenty-two (Parlksamukhe3/57-90);, sixty-four (Pramal)anaya, 3/5°-99) eleven (Pramal)amiinamsa,1-2-12)" or nine (Nyayadlpika, pp 95-99)

~,

'-"

-·~thltlb~~~4:~1lt!.1hl!~~~~~l!~UillIb!t~.h2~~I:~:el~~~hJ~!I!~~l!~U:illsJij~~11l1h~li~~·1~I~JUblb2~l~~2!1!li~ah2~1~h~lbhdt4iUt-h~~~lli2lU~~h~&th!I!~h~l.!I!¥~&12:~I:,hijUJIhl!h~~~l!~

96·ll\UsJij~!ill~IJllh2~hI.ij~~~~~l!'l!t~~lltl~:~lilhI~RJ-l.!I!~~lllhl!4~~~~&J~:~~I~~~I~~tt·I!I!~'l!~~l.!I!~~:~~Il!~~~~l!4l!~~~}.lh:~h2~~~1lhij~~ltI*bl~.1li1h~~hia2~h!l<-~h21:Ih4!thlSIhl!b~~lYl!~lMl1"llJa·!illli~h2!:~I~hbhllh~l!ll~l1h~IH1~lliJ~~Ii&~~lh~~&.I;t

0(:·hleJli&~1l1&PD!lthl:\~li&.I!!hh~lS~la~~Illia2:~1I1~1m:hlhl1~~ll\.Ii&U~~~l.!I!ll~Ihl!h~!I!:l,!l~l!J~lYftl,!l~h&:l,!l~hae~~~2ml:l!l,!l~h!ili!b~~1h~h-~h~~~~lia~!t.'£9§

[I~ti~IJUt!U~'ce]Ilt~

91~lYhnlltll1~t~~ijS~Ql1t1lS1~l!1!b~~llt~!I!h1lS~lliQlQ~~l}b2lt-t~Htl1&~1li!!!~~1~2sl2h»lihI~W-b~lIhlQ~~YHdl~~s~~JIl~~,)ul~hQlhll1!!!li~l~~~li~hll1~~tnlijhl:~QIJY~l!·~h~hlil:t%!ll\RhJlt~lJ:2lhtl~JW1hJEJ!:~&JpUtJsltl!lhR~JQ'e9§

IIth~1litill!l:t!~11nlQl!lh~sth~ltI~li01-Q~a~I:!!!~ID~:~lllis!!OEI'hl!~lQ~lh!uh~h~hI:lilltloElS

'~l~!I!~l!aijh~lQh~lhhI'laJ~!I!h~~lh2l1:Je.~:~l!~~:lli~lha !hm~-&1hill=QilllllEl1lohi~lnh!hl!l!2~~':~Q~S~~1h2~hh'hl1~~lh·.ijlS~~hillliJlhaal!I:lthJlt~~~ltQ}~L21l!2:.t:lUlt'~9§

[I'h1nh~~1nHt.ls~.Ae]sI:~.I;t~lE!hQ~lEh~aJs~l'C~~bh~h~~l!hllih!\lalt!l1~Jh~Q

~hl~W&h!t.~~lli~~~'~~JY~~s~1II1!!!lSI:haQ~~t~~~1h~~l.!I!~~I:~blh~~ll:~~~hllh2b~~JQ~ln':~~~s~~~~~hl!:Q2~&hlih2:l!I~~ij~l!l~~ftlhJQbh!k-J.»!llil!J••b2Qh2h.l~~lhlShllh2h~~ij1thb~~J.Ylh~l\ffi~J

'bAI:l1~hlnUtls.A

••

-b~l~le'~~~~~~~h~t\"M~I~~hltllolileleOSJl1!d£,~~~~~1h~ltl.\~'~~pa~lh~'~~h2b~h~J.ltl!~.1!~!~11olilell!I'»lJjHSR~JUhk~~~ltiQ''»ua-It:tlllill!UrJilell!~~h~'.ij~ltiQ:~~ltll!llDtil!D~~lills.!l!~b-!nhl!~lhlnfi!!:~lhUI~bbb~~UShl!~lhU~lh1DIi~!t!~lh~hb':~l~ll!~!&J~H.blh~!t!~~~l.l:)t~:~~~h1!t!h~~hh~£6.~iJs~&1ij~11~.I:)thI:}t~~~~~hlJ~:ta~llilSR~}tlR~-~ltijnfiI:l~JJ.~Uo~!!JijlY1i¥.I:)t~:~~h1.1:~~ijsl~h~I"?1••!t:~l!~hI:~lRl!I~~~I~fiIijlYlh~.I:)tlZh1mijs~2t~:~~:l!~J:llhI:~n~IJn~l!t!b~l~~~lZ~h~!p.)JtI"~l!~ijs~b~thhI:AJ1~1~hillJijltllh~)t~lU~ijs~:l:lltWlYl~06l:~hI:AJ~1l!~~~llilh!hbb~~lZh~ijs~~!t1s(Q)~b~JabhI:~~I~~l~1Jnfi~~lh"l"~P~~l~h1~.~~~Ja~hI:~n~l~~!-h~Jij~!i!~lah~P!l!~:l~(~)~~~ijhlc!~hth~t~l!~~~n~h1titI@DUR!.&:!tlZ!i:.&~fi:ll!t!h~~:!&hb::ihllk21!!-~~IA:h~.l!t:l!t!t!.~~§91

I)mhh1!11l:h:t"~)lblijts:l!~h2-~h~!t:~h21l.bUtll}!i!h~lRIt l!~~Uills~~~~~h~~~-1hAll!~~~~llc!l!t!!In!lthJa~DanI:h~_h~~.t!llS~-l!l:~12~Jti~~lt~~!t!!In!hh~~ijlRh-~~IAlwhl.t~Ih!tJ':It!!i:!t!~l!I:~~~~~hlhltJllil.l!-*Will:,b~~~01-lh1lS»:Jn~b1!t~hh2~.i~ll~hl!I:~lZa~Ja~lil!~hl.h.lllli~h~R1b~h1lS~R~lltJ~llc!l!!:l!»2l:!t!~1llhlijkloIII1$l:~Il:allt~~1tll.\llt~~H~!i:lZ(¥):lh.ijli~Ra~~•1\~§

I~ltRa&Jh~b~!i:t\l!..~~J-,bunIh~b~~~~Jij~bi~Rlh2l:~llJh1~h2I:ibl!:9Ih~~J~hh~Ihl!b~ltl~ho!p."Rlh2"~?2I"lh1I:l1.khl:Ih~~b~ty~hl1tiIhl!b~tylY~~h~Rlh1!?~~lh1Illi~-lbh~~~llnllJ!h2t\~illIRh!i!~~ijlijlli~s~~hhbJA!!le~l.t:~-l~~~I~ll!b~hl!tUo~~1~~'.llZ~.t!l~alte~trej?JeI~b£&

'"Ii;

11h~o~

f~~~~r~ I a: fit;qij{IJl~~ "'f SJrijf.lq~~~~nt.,3T~~~q'iiT~f~: fit;qij{IJl~)qiiiT~~~q fqn~1(l, I ~fUr~~~q "'f SJre~~1{1((, ijC::~~ f~~T~rrrrqrq. ~fUr~~T~C::SJijirQ.I ~~~ll "'f SJfo~ijffl~T({" oC::~~ imffl~~~u~~ I ~~~ll SJfofqq~ o{T;n~, ~gIJlT;niT-'fi~C::q~QTqf ij'lr~o{Tit'f.~;;;C::'lT~qorq~~fu ~~~f~{ll~lWJTq~q- 5~H: fSfiqij I tl;;f ~~RHr~q~m<lfit ;n~qTRffl I q~mro W~~ I ijij~'f;{~fqij: SJqTlJlqc::r~:I

~f« +iitr~ittj'r~r~~'T'fi~~ll1lfC{~?tnfl1lf~~qf~a''>fTt?ntfC{~nfU!f~tlfTCl'ij-~qfO:gQ'>fT:itC(f,,~~nfl1lB"Q'T~qf~~~fc(~?tnfl1Iro~ qfosQ'>fTq~-

f"~~l1tar~~~l1l qfOGc(?t~f"~~nfl1l<fT ~iT~r ~"f'Ff;- 10• t> " •mG'I<iT SHnl1ltj'I{~: ~~'1?f:I

•

r-- ....~. c:J~qr~~<::: I[ ~. "f~rrlT~«~~I{ I ]

§ ~. SJltTUTl;~lf<{ I 3T~ <{tiT i3'~rij I SJllrlJlqftF:~~~T;{;cr"lllRij-

'fi~lf tf~~ tl;'fi~~!tI~IJl~Qra:ij\t~T!lra~fqoTt5~q<fmllfq~"r <{qr: I SJqr~- 15tr.i!:~~itT({,ijqf ijij) ~;::: I q~ r~ ~ij~'fi~ OJ ij'ij~ ;n~Hij~d~r OJllr3ffq OJSJijTOr<{<lTSSJlllO'JfqfoI ij ~ f~m - ~QQIN'liq<lrqy(ij'ii~i\I<!,I ij~SJl"lI~<{ 3:oqm;j'!n~ 3:0'nffl'fi: I Sfl"lr;it<{trlTQl{T;r!trtt IfIlrllrffi<li: I ij;j'

3:oQT~;r.r~~T ~i{qq~~oq'lilT\~~T~ I qqrqTf.q'fi~t!"lr ~1l?f~o;::ijijf~~-

lct~Q~a:Ii!, I ~~«;iT~oQT~'fi~~it ~a: ~fij ij f~o{.~l3:qtur!~r~~_r~ntl 20

§ ~. Vi ijrqT;qnr~qTq~'f.qmq ••q<{qnS••q<Hfl<Jt ilql{:, q~ qqr·

ll~~lfll): qqfq3:olf~~ ~ql~~~qijqr f?t'f~urq,: I 3BT~ij;:qijT~q.ftfQ •••

I. Cf. 1 attvarthaslokavartika, 1.6.21,.'i'fT"f'( ."'" 1fTJtq) Wmffl"" ~:

flImf,""n~ ~i'f1tlrl'~I1r<'l: II;nq ~ "f .-T~ .~n: ~ I

'fTlf,!r: ",!r) 1fT "~rtn) 1:j'f~if 1&

'2. Cf. Visesavasyakabhasyabrhadvrtti, Ga thas 75, i7,2262