7

Index of second image - University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/pritchett98a.pdfRTS r?S VXUMÐ PI5d`d\S"PLTS"o7VOS"U5RTI5dGRgenI?V LTW\N RBe0UMNQÐiZ`VTS × v5vÚ] K\ZkLJLOW\S

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Index of second image - University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/pritchett98a.pdfRTS r?S VXUMÐ PI5d`d\S"PLTS"o7VOS"U5RTI5dGRgenI?V LTW\N RBe0UMNQÐiZ`VTS × v5vÚ] K\ZkLJLOW\S

� ������������ �������������������� �����! ��"��#

$�%'&)(*&)+,$�-.&0/213%'45/./7698':<;=8':�-.4?>A@B&)C"C.4D-"EF6G8HJI5K9IMLONQP"RJHJS"RTS"U5VOPXW�Y�VTI?Z\[^]\_�S�[`U5VaLObcS�dDLJIMe�fgd\h?Nid\S"S�VONid`hcjkP�NiS"d`P�S

l�m enI5VXoqp�d`Nir?S�VXRaNiLts5] l�uwv�x5y{z`|

}�~ ^�'�����B�

���\���5�0���X���)���3���a���n�������!�3�T�����=�������`�Q�3�*�D���n�\�����Q�2�X���t��X�3�����T�=�c�M�*�0�M�\�����3�c�����0�X���� 9�  `�3�i�M�w�?�X�3�����*�¢¡��3��£=���¥¤�"�?���X�3�¢�O�¢�) `�3�9£?�����X�¢���O�M�¦�X���X�3�� 9§k���X£¨�M§k�©�M�c�M�*�0�X�M���ª¡5«�������^���?�����ª�����3�������c�M�©�X�������w�X���)�!�X���=¬�§k������£3���) `�3�T�M�©���.�0���'�­ ���0£?�®�X�3�����ª�������¢�����T�X�?«�¯�!�°�O±?�©���\�¢�0�M�\�²�3�T�²�c�?£5�³�©�´���`�µ��§k�¢�T���G���¢�c�M���

�X�2�����ª���9�¶�M� �?�M�¢�����k�w��·<¸g�X�¢�0¹��M�9£º���2�¢������ \�M�¢�©�M�`�)�ª¡2¹���.�0���9 `�3���G�c���`�3�3�¢�0�3�G�c�c�X�2�¢§k�T������£5���2���i�O `�X£=���3���2�X�����O�¢¤���������`���t»¨�`���)¡��a�=�X�3�¢�����7�9���¼�.�`�X�3§k�T�\�.�.£2���3�3���=���c�"�?� `�3���X�X½!���X�X�3��£2¹��M� �D�3�¢���n���¥�®�3�T�¾�5���2���c���3���D���9���T�3�)���D�¿ 9§k¤���3�)���2�c�X�3�¢���������3���X�\���¥�O���)�!�O�����������D�� `�3���X�¿§��¢���D�q�i�.�O�M��`�3���T�5�T�O `���0����«q�¯�!�w���3�3�������.�X�T�2�¢�)�¢§`���)§k�T�¾£5���2���i�X 9�����G�0��M�T���3�À����£?�¢�����¢�0�O�X£?·��n�\���M§k�©�M�c�M�*�0�Á�D���9���T�3�)�0�3�,�t�q�i�.�O�M��`�3���T�5�T�O `���0���X¹��M�9£F�n�\���X�3�������9�3�)�0�3�µ�a�q \�3�O�¢�0���ª¡,�X�3�`¤Â �0���*�����®�����*�¾�a�����3���O�`�¢�{ 9�¢�0�M�¾�©��Ã�Ä�žÆ\Ä¥Ç��¢�¢�)���c�M�*�0�M�9«���\�È���0£5�F�X�2�����¼���9���c�M�©�X�������<�3� �?�M�¢�����k�����È£5���c�M�`¤

�¢�)�T�3���X£��M�,���G§k�c�X���=�a�q�������D�¥ `�3���X�7�����n���2�M�¢¡3���D�È�T��¤�i�M�*���3�q�c�M�*�0�M�\¹��M�9£����M�q£3� É����T���`�����X���9���)¡O `�¢��«qÄ����9 ��T�3¤�X���O�¢�����Á���w�3§k���3���3�)�0�.«Ê Ë �®�����Á��Ì��B�����®�

Í©L¿N�R�d\I3ÎÏ[GIDRTRTNQK\ÐiS®LOI�UMZkLOI5b�U3LONQP"UMÐQÐis�P�I5bc[\ZkLOScLTW\SqS�[\NiÑ[9I5Ð�UMV�h?S�I?b®S�LTVOs<UMdGoÒ[9I5NQdDL�P�I?VTVOS"RT[9I5d`okS"d`P�S.R=KGS�LtÎ{S"S�dLtÎBIÓNib�U5h5S"RÔI5e�UÓRTS"ÕDZ\S"d`P�S¶enVOI5bÖNib�U5h5S¶Nid\enI5VObcUMLTNQI5dU5ÐiI?d\S�× v.Ø ]TÙ v�Ú©|�Û W\N�RgRTNib¥Z\мLXUMd\S"I5Z`R�P�I5bc[\ZkLXU3LONiI?d¥I5e�P"UMb®ÑS"VOU¾h?S�I5bcS�LTVOs®U5d`o®enS"UMLTZ\VOS�b�U3LXPXW\S"R!W`U5R!KGS"S�dÁS m LOVTS"bcS�ÐQsRTZ`P�P�S"RORtenZ`Ð\NidcK9IMLOWÁRtLOS�VOS�I�UMd`o®bcIMLONiI?d�UM[\[\ÐQN�P�U3LONiI?d`R |�Ü I?VS m U5bc[\ÐiS?]�NiL�W`U?R�UMÐQÐiI3ÎBS"o,LTW\SÔb�U3LXPXW\Nid`hFI5e¥[\VONQb®NiLTNQr5S.RLOW\VTI?Z\h5W,RTS"ÕDZ\S"d`P�S.RÁI5e x5ÝDÞ NQbcU5h5S.RÁÎJNiLTW\I?ZkL7VOS"ÕDZ\NQVTNQd\hU5dDs�ßDd`I3ÎJÐiS.okh5S=IMe�LTW\S x _àRTP�S�d\S�RaLTVOZ`P¢LOZ\VTS�I?VÁP�UMbcS"VOUNQdDLTS�VOd`U5Ð^P�UMÐQNQK\VOUMLTNQI5d7I5V�P�U5bcS�VXUwbcIMLONiI?d�× v ]TÙ ÝMÚ)|Û W\S�P�I5bc[\ZkLXU3LONiI?d®N�RgU?PXW\NiS"r5S.owK�s¿LOW\S�P�I5bwK`Nid`UMLTNQI5d®IMe

LtÎBI®LTS"PXW`d\I5ÐQI5h?NiS.R�á�â`VXRtL.]\VTS"ÐiN�UMK`ÐiS�ãah?S�d\S"VTN�P�ä¥r�NQRTZ`U5Ðå[\VTNQb®ÑNiLTNQr5S.RåæçNQd?LOS�VOS"RaL�[9I5NQdDLOR¢è�ãOP�I5VOd\S"VOROä¾× é Ú æAÎJNiLTWcU�b�U3LXPXWkÑNQd\h�U3ê�d\NiLts�RTP�I5VOS¥KGU5RTS"o�I?d�P�VTIDRTRaÑ�P�I5VOVOS�Ð�U3LTNQI5d�I5e{d\S"Nih?WkÑK9I5Z\VOW\I�IkoqNQdDLTS"d`RaNiLTNQS"R"ë`RTS"P�I5d`oå]kVOI5K`Z`RtLJRaLOU3LONQRaLTN�P�U5Ð^S"RaLTNQb®ÑUMLTNQI5d�U5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\b�R�LTW`UML¾P"UMd�LOI5ÐQS�VXU3LTS¥bcNQRTb�U3LOPXW`S"R�NQd�[\Z\ÑLXU3LTNQr5S¥b�U3LOPXW`S"o�RTS�LXR�]�RaZGPXW�U5R�H�ì�í�jkì�îï× ð Ú ]9U5d`o�ñ¯S"U5RaLò�S.okN�UMdºIMe¿jkÕDZ`U5VTS.R�× Ù v�Ú©|Ól dGP�S�S�[`Ni[9I5Ð�UMVÁh?S�I?b®S�LTVOs�N�RU2r3UMNQÐ�UMK\ÐQS�LTW`S�RaLTS"VTS"IÈb�U3LOPXW`Nid\h¨ÐiNiLTS"VOUMLTZ\VOS�I5e¿LTW\S¨óÀé Ý ó R

U5d`oÔó ô Ý ó R�[\VOI3r�NQo\S"R�b�U5dDs=bcS�LOW\Iko\R�U5d`o�P�I5d`RaLTVXUMNQdDLORJenI?VokS�LTS"VTbcNQd\Nid`h�P�I5VOVOS"RT[GI?d`okS�dGP�S"R¾I5eJIMLTW`S�V¿NQb�UMh5ScenS.U3LOZ\VTS.RRTZ`PXW�U5R�ÐQNid\S.RJUMd`o�P�Z\VTr?S"R |õ�I3ÎBS�r?S�V.]FLTW\SöP�Z\VOVTS"dDL²h5S�d`S�VXU3LTNQI5d÷I5eºU5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\b�R

ÎJW\N�PXW¿P�I?bc[\ZkLTS!bcUMLOPXW\S.R^UMdGo¾S�[\NQ[GI?ÐQU5V^h5S"I5bcS�LOVTs�e0UMNQÐ5Z\d\ÑÐQS"ROR'LTW`S�VTS"ÐQUMLTNQr5S�P"UMbcS�VXU�b®I5LTNQI5dÁU5d`ocPXW`UMd\h?SJNid�NQdDLTS"VTd`U5Ð[`U5VOU5bcS�LTS"VORgKGS�LtÎ{S"S�dÁLOW\S�r�NQS�Î�R{NQRBVOS"RaLTVONQP�LTS.o |�Û W`S�VOS�UMVOSRTS�r?S�VXUMÐ�P�I5d`d\S"P�LTS"o7VOS"U5RTI5dGRgenI?V�LTW\N�RBe0UMNQÐiZ`VTS�× v5v�Ú ]�K\ZkLJLOW\SokI?bcNid`U5dDLcI?d\S=NQRcLOW`U3LÁP�VTIDRTRaÑ©P�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5dÔI5d¶P�I?VTd`S�VcNid\ÑLOS�d`RTN¼Ltsqd\S�NQh5W�K9I5Z\VOW\I�Iko\RBe0UMNQÐQRBLOI�[\VOI3rDN�okS�U®r5S"VTN�okN�P�UMÐåUMe�Ñâ`d`N¼LtsqROP�I?VTS�enI?VJbcUMLOPXW\NQd\h�P�I?VTd`S�VXR |Û W\S�b®S�LTW\Iko\R7[\VOS"RTS�dDLTS.oºNQdºLTW\N�R7[`UM[9S�V=S m LTS"d`o¶LOW\S

ãTS�d�r5S"ÐiI?[GS.ä¥I5e�bcUMLOPXW\NQd\hcLOS"PXW\d\N�ÕDZ\S"R�LTIÁI3r?S�VXP�I?b®S�LOW\S"RTSVOS"RaLTVONQP�LTNQI5d`R | ìø���0£5�ï�X�2�����ª���9�³�¢�����O�O�µUMÐQh5I?VTNiLTW\bùN�RokS"r5S"ÐiI?[GS.oúÎJW`NQPXWûP�U5dûP�I5[9SàÎJNiLTW�RTNih?d\N¼â9P�UMdDLVOIMLXU3ÑLONiI?d`R�]!LTVXUMd`RTÐ�U3LTNQI5dGR®U5d`oFPXW`UMd\h?S"R®NQdFNQdDLTS"VTd`U5Ð�[`UMVXUMbcS�LTÑS"VOR�K9S�LtÎBS�S"dºr�NiS"Î�R |¦Ü Nih?Z\VTS v NiÐQÐiZGRtLOVOUMLTS"RÁLTW\S�P�Ð�U5ROR�IMebcIMLONiI?d`R�enI5V¾ÎJW\N�PXW�LOW\ScÎJNQo\S®KGU5RTS�ÐQNid\ScUMÐQh5I?VTNiLTW`bàNQR�U5[kÑ[\ÐQN�P�UMK`ÐiS |Û W\S"VTS�WGU2r5S�K9S�S�d,UÈdDZ`bwK9S�VqI5e�VTS.P�S�dDLÁ[\W`IMLTI?h5VXUMb®Ñ

bcS�LOVTs�U5[\[\ÐQNQP"U3LTNQI5dGRwÎJW\S"VTS�RTZ`PXWÈÎJN�okS7KGU5RTS�ÐQNid\S=b�U3LXPXWkÑNQd\h�N�R¿VOS"ÕDZ\NQVTS.o |7Û W\S.RaSÁU5VTS�h?S�d\S"VOU5ÐiÐQs�U5NibcS"o�UML¿VTS.P�I?dkÑRaLTVOZ`P¢LONiI?d`R�enVTI?bübwZ`мLONi[\ÐQS�r�NiS"Î�R�]�ÎJW\S�VOS®LTW\ScK`U?RaS"ÐiNQd\ScN�RÐ�UMVOh5S®LTI�Nibc[\VOI3r5S®LTW`SqU5P"P�Z\VXU5P�s�IMeJVOS"P�I?d`RaLTVOZ`P¢LONiI?d�I?V¿URTb�UMÐQÐ�d�Z\b¥KGS"V�IMe®rDNQS�Î�R�P�I3r5S"V=U5ÐiпU?Ra[9S"P�LOR=IMe¥LTW\S�I?KkÑý S.P¢L�× þk] v þk]OÙ Ý3Ú©| î{Z\VTVOS�dDLOÐiscRaI?bcS�IMeåLOW\S�P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"RenI?V�LTW\S.RaS�UM[`[\ÐiN�P�UMLTNQI5d`RJU5VTS¾S.RtLXUMK\ÐQNQRTW\S.oqK�sÁW`U5d`o |ì�ÐiLTW`I5Z\h?W,S m LTS"d`RTNiI?d`RcLTI¨Rab�UMÐQÐ�KGU5RTS�ÐQNid\S�U5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\b�R

W`U2r?S¾KGS"S�d�[\VOI5[9I?RTS"o�× v Ùk]OÙ Ý ]OÙ v�Ú LTW\S"s=U5VTS�d\I5L�RTZkêÁP�NQS�dDLLOIÿP�I5[9SFÎJNiLTW³LTW`SF[9S�VXRT[GS.P¢LTNQr5S¨enI5VOS"RTW\I?VaLOS�d\NQd\h<S��9S.P¢LXRÎJW\N�PXW�P�UMd=IkP�P�Z\VJNid�ÎJN�okS�K`U?RaS"ÐiNQd\S¾Nib�U5h5S"R |Û W\Sºß?S�s²S"d`UMK\ÐQNQd\hÒN�okS.U¦Nid³LTW\N�R�[`U5[GS"V�NQR�LOW\SºZ`RTS

I5e��i�.�O�M��[\ÐQU5d`UMV�W\I?b®I?h5VXUM[\W`NiS.R��0[\ÐQU5d\Sc[\VOI ý S"P�LTNQr5SwLTVXUMd`RaÑenI?VTb�U3LONiI?d`R�� |¯Û W\S.RaS{UMVOSgZ`RTS"o¾NQd�LtÎ{I�ÕDZ\NiLTSBokN�RtLONid`P�L�V��I5ÐQS"R |Ü NQVORaL"]�LOIco\S�â`d\S¿U®r�NQS�ÎJ[9I5NQd?LJNQd�r2U5VTN�UMdDLJU3ê�d\NiLtsÁbcS"U?RaZ\VOS�*RaS.P¢LTNQI5dqÙ��¢ë�UMd`o�RTS"P�I5d`o^]5LOI¿VTS.RtLOVTN�P¢L!RTS"U5VOPXWcÎJW\S"d�h5S"d\S�VTÑUMLTNQd\hc[\ZkLOUMLTNQr5S�P�I?VTd`S�V�b�U3LOPXW`S"R�0RTS"P�LTNQI5d�ð |Qv � |õ�I?bcI5h5VXUM[`W\NiS.RåW`U2r?S�KGS"S�d¿Z`RTS"o�enI?V^LOW\S"RTSgV��I5ÐQS"RåK9S�enI?VTS?]

K\Z\L=I?d\ÐisºÎJW`S�d,LOW\S�S�[\NQ[GI?ÐQU5V7h?S�I?b®S�LTVOs¨N�R=ß�d\I3ÎJdµ× ô Ú©|Í�d¨[`UMVTLTN�P�Z\Ð�UMV¥W\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W\NQS"R¥UMVOSqZ`RTS"o�Nid¨VTS.P¢LON¼âGP"U3LONiI?d^]ÎJW\S"VTS7LTW`S7NQb�UMh5S.RcUMVOSqb�UM[\[9S"o�LTI�LOW\I?RTS7I5e�U�[`UMVXUMÐQÐiS"ÐP"UMbcS�VXUBh5S�I?bcS�LTVOs | õ�I3ÎBS�r5S"V"]�Nid¾LOW\S"RTSg[\VOS�r�NQI5Z`RåP"U5RTS"R�LOW\S

Page 2: Index of second image - University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/pritchett98a.pdfRTS r?S VXUMÐ PI5d`d\S"PLTS"o7VOS"U5RTI5dGRgenI?V LTW\N RBe0UMNQÐiZ`VTS × v5vÚ] K\ZkLJLOW\S

NQbcU5h5S Ý NQb�UMh5S x NQbcU5h5S Ø NQb�UMh5S

Ü NQh5Z\VOS v á{ij���X¬�§`���9�X�®�X�3�\�¢���¢�)���D�=�t�¾�¢���3���^�)�T�3�`�¢�i�3�)�0�3�`�¿�X���*�!�X�����.�0���'�X¹!�����n���O�3���3�)�0�3�\�¿���J¸�±D�M�©�®�3�����`�¾�`�3§����.«c���`���T����w�c�¢���3���'�O�3�����ª�����c�O���)�!�O�����M�`¡��)�!�q�X�3�`���O��§k�)���2�w���c�"�?���¥�t�¾�n�\�w���X¬�§`���9�X��¹��\�3�!���3���c�O���)�!�O�����n�\�{¸g�X�¢�B�M�9£q�i�2�¢�B���c�"�?��n�\���T�w���¿�Á���0£5�c�X�2�����ª���9�.«Á���\�®�t»¨�`���)¡Á�c�X�3�X§k�O�w�t�¿���`�¥�X�3�¢�����X���k�¼�.�k�ª�¼�.�k�©�X£7�������k���©�c�M�T���5���3�������¥¸��5§k�T���D«

W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs¾N�R'okS�â`d`S"o¥I5d\ÐQs¿K�s¾LTW\S�P"UMbcS�VXU�bcI5LTNQI5dcUMd`oNQdDLTS�VOd`U5Ðk[`UMVXUMbcS�LOS�VXR �0N | S | LTW\S�S�[`Ni[9I5Ð�UMV'h5S"I5bcS�LOVTs���UMdGowN�Rh?ÐiI?K`UMÐ�enI?VgS"U?PXW®NQb�UMh?S | Í�dÁP�I5dDLTVXU5RaL�NidcLOW\SJÎJN�okS�K`U?RaS"ÐiNQd\SU5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\büLOW\S�VOSqUMVOSÁb�UMd�s�ÐiIkP"UMÐ!W`I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W\NQS"R�enI5V®UMdNQb�UMh5S®[`U5NiV.]åUMd`o�LTW\S.RaS�UMVOS¥o\S�â`d\S.o�K�s x _ÏROP�S"d\ScRtLOVTZ`P�ÑLOZ\VTS7U5R¿ÎBS�ÐQÐ!U?R¿S�[`Ni[9I5Ð�UMV¿h?S�I?b®S�LTVOs |�Û W\SqRTNQd\h5ÐQSÁh5ÐQI5KGUMÐW\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs®enI?VJS"U5PXW=NQbcU5h5S¾N�RBLTW\S"d�U®RT[9S"P�N�UMÐ^P"U5RTS |Û W\S�ÎJN�okSgKGU5RTS�ÐQNid\SgU5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\b<WGU5R^U�d�Z\b¥KGS"V¯IMe\RaLOU5h5S"R |

Ü NQVORaL"]3W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`W\NiS.R¯K9S�LtÎBS�S"d¿LOW\S{NQb�UMh?S"R�UMVOS{h?S�d\S"VOUMLTS"o�*RaS.P¢LTNQI5d x � |�Û W\S"RTS=W\I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W\NQS"R®UMVOSqZ`RTS"oÈLTIÔh5S"d\S�VTÑUMLTS�RTS�LXR=IMe¿[\ZkLXU3LONir?S�b�U3LXPXW\S"R��0RTS"P�LTNQI5dÒð�� | ì enZ\d`o\UMÑbcS�dDLXUMÐ�bcUMLTVON m �0VTS"[\VTS.RaS"dDLTNQd\h�LTW`S�S"[\Ni[9I5Ð�UMV7h5S"I5bcS�LOVTs��U5d`o�U®P�I5d`RTN�RtLOS�dDL�RaS�L�IMe�b�UMLOPXW\S.R�UMVOS�LOW\S�d�I?KkLOU5Nid`S"o7rDN�UH�ì�í�jkì�î��0RTS"P¢LONiI?d�þ�� | HJS.RaZ\ÐiLOR�I5d�RaS"r5S�VXUMЯNib�UMh?S¿[`U5NiVXRU5VTS¥h5NQr5S�d�U3L�LTW\ScS�dGo�IMe!LTW\Sc[`U5[GS"V | ì�ÐiÐ�LTW`ScRaLOU5h5S.R�UMVOS[\VOIkP�S.RTRTS"o7UMZkLOI5b�U3LONQP"UMÐQÐis |� } � ���������¥�"�®� ��� � ���g���¿�®� ��� ���X���

� ����'����

Í�d÷Rab�U5ÐiÐ�K`U?RaS"ÐiNQd\S´UMÐQh5I?VTNiLTW`bcR<LTW`SU3ê�d\NiLtsàKGS�LtÎ{S"S�dP�I5VOd\S�VXR�NQR¿o\S�LTS"VTbcNQd\S"o�K�s�P�VTIDRTRaÑ�P�I5VOVOS�Ð�U3LTNQd\h�LOW\SÁP�I?VTd`S�VNQdDLTS�dGRaNiLtsÒd`S�NQh5W�KGI?Z\VOW\I�I�o`R |çÛ W\N�R�UMê�d\N¼LtsÿbcS"U?RaZ\VOSÈN�RZ`RTS"o7LOIcU?RTRTS"ROR�P�I?VTd\S"V�bcUMLOPXW\S.R�I3r5S"V{LOW\S¾LtÎBI®r�NQS�Î�R |y W\IMLOI5bcS�LOVTN�P�U5ÐiÐQs5]åP�VOI?RORaÑ©P�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5d�NQR¾NQd�r3UMVONQU5d?L�LTI�U

ÐQNid`S"UMV��0UMêcd`S��'LOVOU5d`RaenI5VObcUMLTNQI5dcIMe^NQb�UMh?S�NidDLOS�d`RTN¼LONiS.R�æ�UP�I5d`RaLOU5d?L�U5o`okN¼LONiI?d¥U5d`o¥P�I5bcbcI5d®RTP"UMÐQNid\h | Y�S"I5bcS�LOVTN�P�U5ÐiÐQsP�VTIDRTRaÑ©P�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5d7NQR�d\IML¾S�r?S�d�NQd�r2U5VTN�UMdDL�LOI7U7RaNQbc[\ÐiS®VOIMÑLXU3LTNQI5d�I5e�LOW\S�NidDLOS�d`RTN¼Ltsqd\S�NQh5W�K9I5Z\VOW\I�Iko |gÛ Î{IcS m U5bc[\ÐiS.RÎJNQÐiÐ�NiÐQÐQZ`RtLOVOUMLTS¾LOW\S¿d\S"S"o=enI5V�Uch5VOS"U3LOS�VJh?S�I5bcS�LTVONQP¾NQd�r2U5VTNiÑU5d`P�S¾NQd7LOW\S¿U3ê�d\NiLtsÁbcS"U?RaZ`VTS?á "!$#&% j�Z\[\[9I?RTSÿLTW`UML¶LTW\S¦bcIMLONiI?döP�I5d`RTNQRaLORFI5e�U

RTb�UMÐQÐ!Ð�U3LTS"VOU5Ð�LTVXUMdGRaÐ�U3LONiI?d�enI?ÐiÐQI3ÎBS"o�K�s�U�Ð�UMVOh5S�VOIMLXU3LTNQI5dU5KGI?ZkL�LTW\S�[\VONQd`P�NQ[`UMÐ^U m NQR�*P�skP�ÐQIMÑ©VTI5LOUMLTNQI5d'� | j�NQd`P�S¾P�VTIDRTRaÑP�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5dÈN�Rcd\IML�NQd�r2U5VTN�UMdDLcLTIÔVOIMLXU3LTNQI5dGR�]gNiLqokI�S"R®d\I5L[\VOI3r�NQo\S�U�Z`RTS�enZ`Ð`U3ê�d\NiLtswbcS"U?RaZ`VTS�NQd¥LOW\N�RgRaNQbc[\ÐQSJb®I5LTNQI5dP"U5RTS |'Û W\NQR{RaNiLTZGU3LTNQI5dÁP"UMd�K9S�VOS�bcS"okNQS"ocK�scU�h5ÐQI5KGUMÐ\VOIMLXU3ÑLONiI?dwIMeGLTW\SBNQbcU5h5S�UMK9I5ZkL�LTW`SB[`VTNQd`P�NQ[`U5Ð�U m NQR�KGS�enI5VOSBP�VTIDRTRaÑP�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQd\h`]{I5V�K�sÈZ`RTNid`h�VTI5LOU3LONiI?d`UMÐQÐQs�Nid�r3UMVONQU5dDL�P�VTIDRTRaÑ

P�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5d�× v Ù Ú)| "!$#)(µjkZ\[\[9I?RTS�LTW`UML�LTW\S��0d\I5dkÑ�P�skP�ÐiI*�¯VOIMLXU3LONiI?d¥I5eGLOW\S

P"UMbcS�VXUqU5KGI?ZkL¾LTW\ScI5[\LTN�P�UMÐgP�S�dDLTVOS®NQR�RTNih?d\NiâGP�U5d?L.]^I5V�LOW\SLOVOU5d`RaÐ�U3LONiI?d�IMe�LOW\S¥P"UMbcS�VXU�N�R�RTNih?d\NiâGP�U5d?L | î{I?d`RaN�okS"V�LOW\SNQb�UMh5SJI5e^U¾[\ÐQU5d`UMV{RaZ\VTe0U5P�S | ì,ROÕ?ZGUMVOS�P�I5VOd\S"V�d\S�NQh5W�K9I5Z\VTÑW\I�Iko�NQd�I5d\S®Nib�U5h5SwKGU5PXßDÑ)[`VTI ý S"P¢LXR�LOI=U7[\Ð�UMd`U5V�e0U?P�S�L¾NQdLOW\SÁÎBI5VOÐQoå]�UMd`o�LOW\SÁNQb�UMh5S�I5e�LTW\N�R�e0U?P�S�L¥NidÔLOW\S7RTS"P�I5d`oNQb�UMh5S�N�R�UqÕ?ZGU5okVONiÐ�U3LOS�VXUMÐ)]\NiLOR�RaW`U5[GS¥okS�[9S�d`o\Nid\h7S�dDLTNQVOS�ÐQsI?d�LTW\S®VOS�Ð�U3LTNQr5S¥[GIDRaNiLTNQI5d`Nid\h7IMegLOW\ScP�UMbcS"VOU?R�UMdGo�[\Ð�UMd\S |Û W\S"VTS!bcU2s�K9S{RTS�r5S"VTS�[`VTI ý S"P¢LONir?SgokN�RtLOI5VTLTNQI5d�IMekLOW\N�R�ÕDZ`U?o�ÑVONiÐ�U3LOS�VXUMÐ�okZ\SBLTI�okN+��S�VONid\h¾[9S�VXRa[9S"P�LTNQr5S{enI5VOS"RTW\I5VTLTS"d\NQd\h?R�IMeLOW\S{[`ÐQU5d\S!NQdwS.U5PXW¿NQb�UMh5S |�Û W\N�R�P�U5RTS{P"UMd\d`IML�K9SBVTS"b®S.okNQS"oK�sÓU,h?ÐiI?K`UMÐ¥VTI5LOU3LONiI?dÓIMe�LOW\S¨NQb�UMh?S¨UMK9I5Z\L�LTW`S¨[\VONQdkÑP�Ni[`U5ÐåU m NQRBK9S�enI?VTS¾P�VOI?RORtÑ�P�I?VTVOS�Ð�U3LONid`h | õ�I3Î{S"r5S�V.]5NiL�P�U5d7K9SVOS�bcS"o\NiS.o�K�s�U�[\Ð�UMdGUMV¾W\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�s�IMe{LTW\S�NQb�UMh?S5]^K\Z\LRTNidGP�S�LOW\NQR®W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs�okS�[9S�d`o`R¥I?dÔLTW\S=VOS�Ð�U3LTNQr5Sq[GIDRaNiÑLONiI?d\Nid`h¥I5e¯LTW`S¿P�UMbcS"VOU?R{U5d`oq[`ÐQU5d\S5]kNiLJbwZ`RaL�KGS�okN+��S�VOS�dDLenI?V�okN,��S�VOS�dDLJ[\Ð�UMd\S.R |Í©L�NQR®S"rDN�okS"d?L®LTW`S�d¨LTW`UML®NQd�K9IMLOW¨S m U5bc[\ÐiS.RwÎ�UMVO[\NQd\h

K�s�U�W`I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�s�NQR�RaZ\ê�P�NiS"dDLåLTI�b�UMß?SgP�VOI?RORtÑ�P�I?VTVOS�Ð�U3LONiI?dh?S�I5bcS�LTVONQP"UMÐQÐis�Nid�r3UMVON�UMdDL | î{I?d`RTS"ÕDZ\S�dDLOÐis?]MU�r�NiS"ÎJ[GI?NidDL'Nid\Ñr3UMVON�UMdDL¯U3ê�d\NiLts�bcS.U5RTZ\VTSgP"UMd�K9S!okS�â`d\S"o¿KDs�LTW`SgNidDLOS�d`RTN¼LtsP�VTIDRTRaÑ©P�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5d�I5ek[\N m S"ÐQR�U3L¯NQb�UMh5S�[9I5NQdDLOR-!cNidwUJROÕDZ`UMVOSd\S"Nih?W�KGI?Z\VTW`IDIko�I5e^LTW`S�â`VXRaLBNQb�UMh5S�ÎJN¼LOW7[`N m S�Ð�R�U3L�Nib�U5h5S[9I5NQdDLOR"!/.�NQd�LOW\S®RTS"P�I5d`o�Nib�UMh?S5]9ÎJW\S�VOS0!�N�R�b�UM[\[9S"o�LOI!/.åK�s�LOW\S�W\I?b®I?h5VXUM[\W�s |ì�ÐiLTW`I5Z\h?W LOW\SÓbcIMLONir3U3LONiI?d WGU5R¶K9S�S�d NQdöLTS�VOb�R¶IMe

[\Ð�UMd`S"R"]9U?R�ÎJNQÐiÐ�KGS®okS�bcI?d`RtLOVOUMLTS.o�Nid�LTW\S®RaS.Õ?Z`S�Ð)]`LOW\S¥UMe�Ñâ`d`N¼Lts®bcS"U5RTZ\VOSJ[GS"VaenI?VTb�R!Î{S"ÐiÐ`enI5V!RTbcIDI5LTWÁRTZ\VTe0U5P�S.RgRTNid`P�SÐQIkP�UMÐQÐQsqLOW\S¥W`I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�s7okS�â`d\S"o�K�s7LOW\S¿LXUMd\h?S�dDL�[`ÐQU5d\SN�R�RTZkêÁP�NQS�dDL | ì�Ð�RaIG]kLTW\S¥P�Ð�U5ROR�IMe�W\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�s�d\S"S"okS.oqLOI[\VOIkokZ`P�S�UMd7Nid�r3UMVON�UMdDL!bcS"U?RaZ\VOS�o\S�[9S�d`o\RBZ\[9I5d7LTW`S�P"UMb®ÑS"VOU?R�ó2NQd?LOS�VOd`UMÐ�[`U5VOU5bcS�LTS"VOR"]3bcIMLONiI?d^]5UMdGo¿LOW\S�VTS"ÐQUMLTNQr5SB[GI5ÑRTN¼LONiI?dqI5e¯LTW`S¾RTZ\VTe0U5P�S | Í©LJNQR�d\I5L�UMÐQÎBU2skR{d\S"P�S"RORTU5VTs®LTI®Z`RTSLOW\S�bcIDRtLBh5S�d`S�VXUMÐ9[\VTI ý S"P�LTNQr5S�W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs1�0ô®okS"h5VOS�S"R!IMeenVOS�S.okI5b��0o\IMe2��]5okS�âGd\S"o�K�s�enI5Z`V�[9I5NQdDL'P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"R�� |ì�êcd`S3� Ø okIMet] x [9I5NQdDL�P�I5VOVOS"RT[GI?d`okS�dGP�S"R��{UMd`o=RaNQbcNiÐ�UMVONiLts�0ðco\IMet]GÙ¥[9I5NQd?L�P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5dGokS�d`P�S"R��gI5e�LTS"d=RTZkêÁP�S |Û W\S�P�I5d`RaLOU5d`P�s�IMe�LTW\S�r�NQS�ÎJ[9I5NQdDLÁNid�r3UMVONQU5dDL�UMê�d\N¼Lts

Page 3: Index of second image - University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/pritchett98a.pdfRTS r?S VXUMÐ PI5d`d\S"PLTS"o7VOS"U5RTI5dGRgenI?V LTW\N RBe0UMNQÐiZ`VTS × v5vÚ] K\ZkLJLOW\S

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 90

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

Index of second image

Cro

ss−

corr

elat

ion

scor

e

Ü NQh5Z\VOSÔÙ\á³Çg�M�� `�3�¢�����3�ï�t���¢�©�M�9£?�3�T£º���T�2�X�¢¤a�X�3�¢�T���i�M�*�0�M�4 £5�3�T�\�X£¦�ª�����65ÿ�������³�n�\�¶�.�0���9 \�M���`�����G�2�M�¢�0�3�G�����O�3�¢§k�T�4 ���3�ª�0£��ª�����65®���3�7�X�3�¢�O�¢�) `�3�9£M���D�È�X�M�¢�9���Á�9���¼�.�`�X�3§k�T�\�.�.£2��«���\�¥�n���T�X�¥�O�M�¢�9���X�w�3�T�w���`�2���c�t��¸��M§k�T��75«

bcS"U?RaZ`VTS�N�R�okS"b®I?d`RaLTVXU3LTS.o=Nid�â`h?Z\VOSwÙk]\ÎJW\S"VTSwN¼L�N�R�P�I5b®Ñ[`U5VTS.o¶LTI¶RaLOUMdGo\UMVXo<P�VTIDRTRaÑ©P�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5d8�nN | S | UMd<N�okS"d?LON¼LtsW\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs��BU5R�LTW\SwK`U5RTS�ÐQNid`S¿NQR�S m LTS"d`okS.o |:9 IMLTW�UMê�dkÑNiLts¾b®S.U5RTZ\VOS"R^ZGRaSBU�é<;�é{[\N m S�ÐDd\S�NQh5W�K9I5Z\VOW\I�Iko¿okS�âGd\S"o�NQdLOW\S�=�S"VTI5LTWcNib�U5h5S |'Ü I?V'LTW\S�RtLXUMd`o\U5VOo®P�VOI?RORaÑ©P�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5d¿Ué�;¥é�d\S�NQh5W�K9I5Z\VOW\I�IkowI5eGLOW\S�ROUMbcSJI5VONiS"dDLOU3LONiI?d¥N�RgZGRaS.o¥NQdLOW\S�IMLTW`S�VcNib�U5h5S |ÈÜ I5V®LTW`S=r�NQS�ÎJ[9I5NQdDL®NQd�r2U5VTN�UMdDL®b®S.U5RaÑZ\VOS�LTW\S�P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\Nid\hF[9I5NQd?L�N�R�P�I?b®[`ZkLTS.oÒr�N�U¨UFW\I5ÑbcI5h?VOU5[\W�s5]�U5d`oºLOW\S�NQdDLTS"d`RaNiLtsºU3L�RaZ`KkÑ)[`N m S�оVOS"RTI5ÐQZkLTNQI5dokS�LTS"VTbcNQd\S"oÿK�s<K\NiÑ©ÐiNQd\S"U5V�NidDLOS�VO[GI?ÐQUMLTNQI5d | Û W`S>�0U3ê�d\S?�W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs�N�R�P�I?b®[`ZkLTS.o�NQd�LTW\N�R�S m U5bc[\ÐiS®enVOI5bàLOW\VOS�SP�I5VOd\S�VJP�I?VTVOS"RT[9I5d`okS"d`P�S.RBI5d7LTW\S¿ROUMbcS¾[\Ð�UMd\S |Û W\S{r�NiS"ÎJ[GI?NidDL¯NQd�r2U5VTN�UMdDL�UMê�d\N¼Lts�bcS"U?RaZ\VOSgN�R^e0U5V¯bcI5VOS

RaLOU5K\ÐiS=LOW`UMdFRtLXUMd`o\U5VOo¨P�VOI?RORtÑ�P�I?VTVOS�Ð�U3LONiI?d�æøokS�LOS�VONiI?VOUMLaÑNQd\h�LOI�I?d\Ðis Ý`| ék]'P�I5bc[`U5VTS.o�LTI Ý`| Ù�enI5VcRtLXUMd`o\U5VOo�P�VTIDRTRaÑP�I5VOVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5d |

@ } Ì7��� � ������� #w�����������'���®� �0A� ���B

� �w#¥������ �����

Û W\N�RÁRTS"P�LTNQI5dºokS"ROP�VONQKGS.Rcb®S�LTW\Iko\R�enI5VÁI?KkLOU5Nid\NQd\hÔW\I?b®I5Ñh?VOU5[\W\NQS"R7KGS�LtÎ{S"S�d,LOW\SÔNib�U5h5S"R |Û ÎBI¨P�I?dDLTVXU5RaLTNQd\h¨U5[kÑ[\VOI?U?PXW\S"R�UMVOS¥h?Nir?S�d |¿Û W`S¥âGVORaL�KGU5RTS"o�I?d�enS.U3LTZ`VTS®h5VOI5Z\[P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"R"]'LTW\S�RTS"P�I5d`o�I5dF[Ds�VXUMbcN�o�LTS.PXW\d\N�ÕDZ\S"R |Û W\S.RaS¾W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`W\NiS.R{U5VTS�Z`RTS"o7Nid�RTS"P¢LONiI?d7ð®LOI®h?S�d\S"VOUMLTSRTS�LXR�IMe'[\ZkLOUMLTNQr5S�P�I?VTd`S�VJb�U3LXPXW\S"R |

CEDGF HJILK:ILM�N<OQPGK:R S:T UVTWRXM�NZY"S"P[IL\ ]�M�T U]�I/N<O�^:M�I8RXM_TW^:Y�\

Û I�I?KkLOU5NidwP�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5dGokNid`hJenS"UMLTZ\VOS!h?VTI?Z\[`R^ÎBS!WGU2r5S{UML�I?Z\VokN�RT[GIDRTU5Ð`LOW\S�Ð�UMVOh5S�VTS"[GIDRaNiLTI?VTs®IMe¯N�okS.U5RBokS�r?S�ÐQI5[9S"o�NQdÁLOW\SRaLTS"VTS"IJbcUMLOPXW\NQd\h�U5d`o¾I5K ý S"P¢L�VTS.P�I5h?d\NiLTNQI5d¾ÐiNiLTS"VOUMLTZ\VOS |�Û W\SenS.U3LTZ`VTS�enIkP�Z`R7× Ù Ú UM[\[`VTIDU5PXWÔNQR¥[`U5VaLONQP�Z\ÐQU5VTÐQs�RTZ\NiLOU5K\ÐiS�æ

Z`RTNQd\hwÎJW`UMLTS"r5S�V�okN�RtLONidGP¢LTNQr5S�enS"UMLTZ\VOS"RBU¿[GUMVTLTN�P�Z\Ð�UMVBNib�U5h5SRTS"ÕDZ\S"d`P�S¾[\VOI3r�NQokS.RBZ`R�ÎJN¼LOW |õ�S"VTS�ÎBS�NQÐQÐiZ`RaLTVXU3LOS�LOW\SÔNQo\S"U¨KDsºZGRaNQd\h¶P�I5VOVOS"RT[GI?d`o�Ñ

S"d`P�S.R�IMe�P�ÐQI?RTS"oÔVOS�h?NiI?d`R¾K9I5Z\d`oÔK�s�enI5Z\V¥ÐiNQd\SqRTS�h?bcS�dDLOR |Û W\N�R�enI?ÐiÐQI3Î�R¾LOW\S7U5[\[\VOI?U5PXWÔI5eE`�S"d\ß3U3LOS"RTÎBU5VwUMd`o�î{W`S�ÐiÑÐ�UM[\[GU=× v Ú ]`K\ZkL�okI�S.RJd\IML�NQd�r5I?Ðir?S�b�U5NidDLOU5Nid`Nid\hcVOS�Ð�U3LONiI?dkÑRTW\NQ[`RqK9S�LtÎBS�S"d,LOW\S�P�ÐiIDRaS.oºVTS"h5NQI5d`R |³Ü I5Z\V=ÐQNid\SÔP�I?VTVOS"RaÑ[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"RwU5VTSÁRTZkêÁP�NQS�dDL¿LOI�P�I?bc[\ZkLTS7U�[\VOI ý S"P�LTNQr5S�W\I5ÑbcI5h?VOU5[\W�s |�Û W\VOS�S¾ÎBI5Z\Ð�o=KGS¿RTZkêÁP�NQS�dDL�enI?V�UMd�U3ê�d\S�W\I5ÑbcI5h?VOU5[\W�s |ñ^NQd\SJenI?Z\V!P�s�P�ÐiS.RgUMVOS�h5VOI5Z\[9S"o®K�s¥RTS"U5VOPXW`Nid\h�enI?Vg[`UMVXUMÐiÑ

ÐQS�ÐQI5h?VOU5bcR'U5b®I?d\h?RaLgÐQNid\S�RTS�h?bcS�dDLOR�I?KkLOU5Nid`S"o®K�swS"o\h5S�okS�ÑLOS"P¢LONiI?d^]9ÐiNQd\ß�Nid`h`]�UMd`o�ÐQNQd\S�â\LTLTNQd\h |�Û W\S¿LOI5[9I5ÐQI5h5s7IMe�LOW\SS.okh5S.R�N�R�[\VTS.RaS"VTr?S"o�okZ`VTNQd\h=ÐiNQd\S¥â\LaLONid\h�U5d`o�LOW\NQR¾RTNibc[\ÐQNiÑâ`S.R{LTW\S¿RTS"U5VOPXW |'Û W\S¾h5VOI5Z`[\Nid`h¥P�I?d`RaLTVXUMNQd?L�I5d`Ðis�VOS"ÕDZ\NQVTS.RU5[\[\VOI m NQb�U3LOS=[GUMVXUMÐQÐiS"ÐiN�RabúUMd`o¶ÐQS�d\h5LTW¶S"ÕDZ`U5ÐiNiLts¨enI5VÁI?[kÑ[9I?RTN¼LOS�RTN�okS"R |�l e�LOS�d=I5d\ÐQs x Ñ�P�skP�ÐQS"RBUMVOS�I?KkLOU5Nid\S.oqU5d`o�LOW\SVOS�b�UMNQd\NQd\h¿ÐQNid`S�N�RgNQdkenS�VOVTS.ocLTI¥P�ÐQI?RTSJLTW\S�VOS�h5NQI5d |�Ü Nih?Z\VOS xRTW\I3Î�R�UMd=S m UMbc[\ÐQS |l d`P�S�[`UMVXUMÐQÐQS�ÐQI5h5VXUMb�R®W`U2r?S=K9S�S"d,h5VOI5Z`[GS.o�LOW\S�s¶UMVOS

b�U3LXPXW\S"oÒ[`U5NiVOÎJNQRTSÔKGS�LtÎ{S"S�dÒLTW\S�NQb�UMh?S"R | Û W`NQR�W`U?R�UÕDZ`U?okVOUMLTN�P'P�I5bc[\ÐQS m NiLts5].K\ZkL�h5S�d`S�VXUMÐQÐisJLOW\Sgd�Z\b¥KGS"V¯IMeDenI5Z`VP�s�P�ÐiS.RcNQR7Rab�U5ÐiÐ)]JRaI�LTW`S�P�IDRtLÁN�RÁd\I5L�LTI�I�W\NQh5W |¦y Z\LOU3LTÑNQr5SJ[`U5VOU5ÐiÐQS�ÐQI5h?VOU5b¦bcUMLOPXW\S.RgUMVOSJr5S"VTNiâ`S.o¥K�s®P�I5bc[\Z\LTNQd\h¿U[\VOI ý S.P¢LONir?SgW\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�s0�nenVTI?bÒLOW\S{enI5Z\V�ÐiNQd\SBP�I5VOVOS"RT[GI?d`o�ÑS"d`P�S.R2�®UMdGoFP�VTIDRTRaÑ�P�I5VOVOS�Ð�U3LTNQd\h�LOW\S�[\VOI ý S.P¢LTNQr5S"Ðis�ÎBU5VT[9S"oVOS�h?NiI?dqS�dGP�ÐQI?RTS"o7KDsÁLTW\S¾enI?Z\VaÑ�P�skP�ÐiS |

CEDba HJILK:ILM�N<OQPGK:R S:TWUcTXRWM�NZY"SdPeIL\ ]�M�T UPGUVNZRXIfYhgEM_NZUiPGjd\

õ�S�VOScY¾U5Z`RTRTN�UMd�[�s�VXUMbcNQo�LTS.PXW\d\N�Õ?Z`S"Rc× x ] Ø3Ú U5VTS®Z`RTS"o | ìRTNibcNQÐQU5VTNiLtsÔLTVXUMdGRtenI?VTb�U3LONiI?d�N�RcS"RaLTNQb�U3LTS.o�K�sÈI?[kLTNQbcNQRTNQd\hNQdDLTS�dGRaNiLts®P�VTIDRTRaÑ�P�I5VOVOS�Ð�U3LTNQI5dwIMeåLTW`S�S�dDLTNQVOS�Nib�U5h5S�I3r?S�V�LOW\SenI?Z\Vw[`U5VOU5bcS�LTS"VORwU3L¿LOW\SqW\NQh5W`S"RaL¥ÐQS�r5S"Ð!I5eJLTW\S7[Ds�VXUMbcN�o |ò�I3r�NQd\h¨o\I3ÎJd<LOW\SÔ[Ds�VXUMbcN�oå]�ÐQIkP�U5оUMê�d\S�LTVXUMd`RaenI5VOb�U3ÑLONiI?d`R�U5VTS{P�I5bc[\Z\LTS"owU3L�S.U5PXW�ÐQS�r?S�ÐDNid®U�RaNQbcNiÐ�UMV�b�UMd\d`S�V^LOILOW\SwS.RtLONib�U3LONiI?d�IMe!LTW\S®RaNQbcNiÐ�UMVON¼Lts |�Û W\S®NQd\W\S�VONiLTS"o�LTVXUMd`RaÑenI?VTb�U3LONiI?d�enVOI5b�LTW`SÁÐiS"r5S"Ð!UMK9I3r5S�[\VOI3r�NQo\S"R�LTW`SqRtLXUMVTLTNQd\h[9I5NQdDLBenI?V�LTW\S�d`S�ÎÒLTVXUMd`RaenI5VOb�U3LTNQI5d7S"RaLTNQb�U3LTNQI5d |k l �����������'�"��#��J�¥�g����� � ���'�! ���

Í�dÿLTW`NQR�RTS"P�LTNQI5dÿN¼L�N�R�RTW\I3ÎJdÿW\I3Î�U¶W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDsºP"UMdK9S�Z`RTS"oÿLOI<h?S�d\S"VOUMLTSÈUºÐ�UMVOh5S�RTS�L�IMeÁ[\ZkLXU3LONir?S¨P�I?VTd`S�Vb�U3LXPXW\S"R | j�S.P¢LONiI?d,ð |Qv NQd?LOVTIkokZGP�S"RÁLTW\S�K`U5RTN�P�P�I?bc[GI?dkÑS"d?L�P�I?bcb®I?dÈLOI�U5ÐiÐBLTW`S7h?S�d\S"VOUMLTNQI5d�RaLTVXU3LOS�h5NQS"R¿æ LTW`UMLU7LTVXUMdGRtenI?VTb�U3LONiI?d�RTNQb®[`ÐiNiâ`S"R�LTW\SqP�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5dGokS�d`P�S¥[`VTI?KkÑÐQS�búKDs¨[\VOS"okN�P�NQd\hÔLTW`S�[GIDRaNiLTNQI5dFenI5VÁLTW\S�b�U3LXPXW |ÒÛ W`S�dRTS�r?S�VXUMÐåRtLOVOUMLTS"h5NQS"RJUMVOS�I5Z\LTÐQNid\S.o=ÎJW\NQPXW�UMLaLOS�bc[kL�LOI�h5VOI3ÎU5d�Nid\NiLTN�UMÐBRaS�LwIMe�b�UMLOPXW\S.R�]�h5S"d\S�VXU3LOS"o�enVTI?b U�ÐiIkP�U5Ð!W\I5ÑbcI5h?VOU5[\W�s |ÁÛ W\N�R�N�R¿UMdÔNQbc[GI?VaLXUMdDLwRtLXUMh?S®NQdÔLTW`S�I3r5S�VXUMÐQÐÎJN�okS=K`U5RTS�ÐQNid`S7UMÐQh5I?VTNiLTW`b U?R¥NiLORcRTZ`P�P�S"RORwÎJNQÐQÐBb�U m NQbcNQRTS

Page 4: Index of second image - University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/pritchett98a.pdfRTS r?S VXUMÐ PI5d`d\S"PLTS"o7VOS"U5RTI5dGRgenI?V LTW\N RBe0UMNQÐiZ`VTS × v5vÚ] K\ZkLJLOW\S

Í�bcU5h5S Ý Í�b�U5h5S Ø

Ü NQh5Z\VOS x áqÄ�§k���3���3�)�0���T±?�)�T�5���*�0�M�¶�a�¾ `�3�T�M���i���i�T�5�T�M���ª�������¡5���Q�¢��«����\��mq�3��£n���¡5���i���w�3�T���a�`�3�����X�*���3�T�� \�M�T�3���Q���i�M¤�5�T�3�à�X�3�� 9�i���)�0�3�9«Á���`���T�c�M�T��7�o¥�5�T�M§. 9���D�M�¿�����������D�qp2¹�M�9£r�Qs��������c�"�?�rs5«

LOW\SÁd�Z\bwK9S�V¥IMe�[\ZkLXU3LTNQr5S7P�I5VOVOS"RT[GI?d`okS�dGP�S"R�LOW`U3L®P�UMdÔK9Sh?S�d\S"VOUMLTS"oqh5NQr5S"d=U5d=NQd\NiLTN�UMÐåÐQIkP�UMÐåW`I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�s |Û W\S.RaSÔRTS�LOR�U5VTS�Z`RTS"oÿU5R7LTW`SÔP�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5dGokS�d`P�S"R7Nid¦U

VOI5K\ZGRtLwS.RtLONib�UMLTNQI5dÈI5eBLOW\S7enZ\d`o\U5b®S"dDLOUMÐ{b�U3LTVON m ]gU?RwokS�ÑROP�VONiK9S"o7NQd�RTS"P�LTNQI5d�þ |

t:DGF uvN<O�w_S"PeKdRyx:P[NVNyS:T UVTWRXM�NZY"S gÍ�d�U5o\o\N¼LONiI?d7LOIc[\VTI3r�N�okNQd\h¥U5d7NQd�r2U5VTN�UMdDL�U3ê�d\NiLts�bcS"U?RaZ\VOSenI?VJNid`o\Nir�N�okZ`UMÐ^P�I5VOd\S�VXR"]�U®W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs�P"UMd�UMÐ�RaIch5VOS"UMLTÐQsRTNibc[\ÐQNiens�bcUMLOPXW\NQd\h7enI5V¾RaS�LOR�IMe{P�I5VOd\S�VXR�K�s�VOS"okZGP�NQd\hÁLOW\SRTS"U5VOPXW=P�I5bc[\ÐQS m NiLts |j�Z`[\[GIDRaS�LOW\S�W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs�S m U5P¢LOÐis¨VTS"[\VOS"RTS�dDLTS.oÈLOW\S

b�UM[`[\Nid`hºKGS�LtÎ{S"S�dÓNQbcU5h5S�[9I5NQdDLOR"]�LTW\S"d²P�I?VTd\S"V�[9I5NQd?LXRb�UM[`[GS.o�enVOI5b�I5d\ScNQb�UMh5S®LOI�LTW\S�I5LTW\S"V�Î{I?Z\ÐQoÔP�I5NQd`P�N�okSS m U?P¢LOÐis�ÎJNiLTW®LTW`S�NQVgP�I5VOVOS"RT[GI?d`okS�dGP�S"R | Y�S�d`S�VXUMÐQÐis?]3LTW\S�W\I5ÑbcI5h?VOU5[\W�s�N�R¿I5d`Ðis�UMdÈUM[`[\VTI m NQb�U3LTNQI5d�IMeBLTW`Sqb�UM[\[`Nid\hG]�0S | h | ÎJW\S"VTS�LOW\S¿RaZ`Vae0U?P�S¾NQR�d`IML�[\Ð�UMd`U5V��BRTI®LTW`UML�bcU5[\[9S"oP�I5VOd\S�VXRcokIÔd\IMLÁP�I?NidGP�N�okS�S m U5P�LTÐQs | Í©e�LOW\S�W\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�sN�RcP�I5bc[\Z\LTS"o�enVOI5b÷enI5Z`V®P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\Nid\h�[GI?NidDLXR�]�enI?VcS m ÑU5b®[`ÐiS?]5LOW\NQR{okN�Ra[`U5VTNiLtswh?S�d\S"VOU5ÐiÐQswNQd`P�VTS.U5RTS"R'ÎJNiLTWqokN�RaLOUMdGP�SenVOI5búLTW\S�K`U?RaN�RÁZ`RTS"o |µÛ W\S�U?P�P�S�[kLXUMd`P�S�IMe¿UÈ[`ZkLOUMLTNQr5SP�I5VOd\S�VBb�U3LOPXW7LTW`S�d�okS�[9S�d`o`R�I5d=KGI5LTW7LTW\S¾r�NiS"ÎJ[GI?NidDLJNQdkÑr3UMVON�UMdDL�UMê�d\N¼Ltsqb®S.U5RTZ\VOS5]kUMd`o=UcRaS.UMVXPXWÁÎJNQd`okI3ÎÒo\NQRT[`UMVTÑNiLtsqÎJW\N�PXW=r2U5VTNQS"RJU?P�P�I5VXokNid`hwLOIco\NQRaLOU5d`P�S�enVOI5bLOW\S�K`U?RaN�R |

t:Dba HJM�T-z{PeKdRcUcN<O�w_S:I-\Û W\S�U5NibúW\S�VOS�NQR�LTI�I5K\LOUMNQd¶ÐQU5VTh?S=RTS�LXR�IMer�n[`ZkLOUMLTNQr5S�ÐQs��b�U3LXPXW\S"o=P�I?VTd`S�VXR{RaLOU5VaLONid\hwenVTI?b°U®RaZ\[`[\ÐiNQS"o7ÐQI�P"UMÐ�W\I?b®I5Ñh?VOU5[\W�s�æ okS"RT[\NiLTS7LTW\S7e0U5P�LwLOW`U3Lch5S"d\S�VXUMÐQÐis�LTW`SqW\I?b®I5Ñh?VOU5[\W�sÁokI�S"R�d\I5L�UM[\[\ÐQs�LOIcLTW\S�S"d?LONiVOS¾Nib�U5h5S |Û W\Sqâ`VXRtL¥RaLTS"[�N�R�LOI�I5K\LOUMNQd�U5dÈNid`N¼LONQU5ÐBRTS�L®IMe�P�I?VTd`S�V

P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"R¾P�I?d`RaN�RaLTS�dDL¿ÎJNiLTW�LTW`SÁW\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�s�Z`RaÑNQd\hÔLTW`S�okN�Ra[`U5VTNiLtsÈb�U3LXPXW\NQd\h�IMe¿RTS"P¢LONiI?d¶ð |Qv5|<Û W\S�UMNQbN�R�LOW\S�d�LTI,ãTh5VOI3Î�äqLOW\S"RTSqP�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"R"]�ÎJW\NQÐ�RtLcUMÐ�RaI[\VOI3r�NQo\Nid\h�U�W\I?b®I?h5VXUM[\W�s�enI5V�KGI5LTW¿LOW\S!r�NQS�ÎJ[9I5NQdDL�NQd�r2U5VTNiÑU5d?L¿UMêcd`N¼Lts�bcS.U5RTZ\VTS�U5d`o�b�UMLOPXW\NQd\h | j�NQd`P�S�h5S�d`S�VXU3LTNQd\hU5d®NQd\NiLTN�UMÐ\ÐQIkP�U5Ð\W\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�s�N�R�Nidch?S�d\S"VOU5Ð\U¾b®I?VTSJP�I?RaLTÐQs

[\VOIkP�S.RTR¯LTW`U5dwZkLONiÐQN�RaNQd\h�LTW\SBW\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�s5]2NiL�N�R�Nid¥I5Z\V'K9S"RaLNQdDLTS�VOS"RaLOR�LTI7I5KkLXUMNQd�U5R�b�U5dDs=b�U3LXPXW\S"R�U5R�[GIDRTRTNiK`ÐiS�enVOI5bU®h5NQr5S"d7W`I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�s |j�S"r5S�VXUMÐ�h?VTI3ÎJNQd\hïRtLOVOUMLTS"h5NQS"R¶W`U2r?SÿK9S�S"düokS�r?S�ÐQI5[9S"o

S.U5PXWör2U5VTs�NQd\hÏNid NiLORºh?I?UMÐ�U5d`o U5RORaZ\bc[kLONiI?d`R | f{U5PXWRaLTVXU3LOS�h5s�W`U5R^U�KGU5RTNQP�LOVOU5d`RtenI?VTb�UMLTNQI5d�LtsD[9S'æAUMd¿U3ê�d\S�I?V[\VOI ý S.P¢LONir?S�LOVOU5d`RtenI?VTb�UMLTNQI5d^]kÎJNiLTW=LTW`S�b®S�LTW\Iko\R�okN,��S�VONQd\hU?P�P�I?VOo\Nid\hÁLTI�ÎJW\S�LOW\S�V¾I?d\Ðis�b�UMLOPXW\S.R�P�I5d`RTN�RtLOS�dDL�ÎJNiLTW�URTNid`h5ÐQS!LOVOU5d`RtenI?VTb�UMLTNQI5dwU5VTSBRaI?Z\h5WDL'I5V'ÎJW\S�LOW\S�V'b�UMd�s¿RTS�LXRI5e`b�U3LOPXW`S"R'S"U?PXW¥P�I5d`RTNQRaLTS"dDL�ÎJNiLTWcU�ÐiIkP�U5ÐDLTVXUMd`RaenI5VOb�U3LTNQI5dU5VTS�enI5Z\dGo |Û W\S7â`VXRtL®b®S�LTW\Iko�æ RTNid`h5ÐQS�LTVXUMd`RaenI5VOb�U3LONiI?d�æ P"UMd

K9SwLOW\I5Z`h5WDL�IMe{U?R�UMLaLOS�bc[kLTNQd\h=LTI7â`d`o�UMÐQÐ'b�U3LOPXW`S"R�LTW`UMLU5VTSJP�I?d`RTNQRaLTS"d?LgÎJNiLTWÁU�RTNQd\h5ÐQS�[\ÐQU5d`UMV!W\I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�s | Í©e�LOW\SNQd\NiLTN�UMÐ\ÐQIkP�UMÐ`W\I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�swUMVON�RaS.R�enVTI?b³U�okI?b®NQd`U5d?Lg[`ÐQU5d\SNQd�LTW\SÁROP�S"d\S5]¯LTW\S"d�LOW\N�R�bcS�LTW`I�o�ÎJNQÐiÐgâ`d`o�LTW\SqbcUMLOPXW\S.RI?dqLOW`U3L�[\Ð�UMd`S |Û W\S=RaS.P�I5dGo�bcS�LTW`I�oÔæ r3U5VTs�NQd\h�LTVXUMdGRtenI?VTb�U3LONiI?d�æ

UMLaLTS"bc[kLOR{LTIwâ`d`oqd\S�κW\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`W\NiS.Rd�*U3ê�d\S�I?V{[`VTI ý S"P¢LTÑNQr5S?��enVTI?büLTW`SÁNid`N¼LONQU5ÐgW\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�s5]�UMd`o�Z`RTS�LTW`S"RTS�d\S�ÎW\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`W\NiS.R�LOIcP�I5bc[\ZkLOS¾d\S�ÎÿRaS�LORBIMe�bcUMLOPXW\S.R�]�ÎJW\N�PXWÎJNQÐiÐ�K9S¾Z`RaS.oÁNQdqLOW\S�RTU5bcS�b�UMd\d`S�V |'Û W`NQR�bcS�LOW\IkoqU5ÐiÐQI3Î�RUcRTS�L�IMe'b�U3LXPXW\S"RBLOI�KGS�K\Z`NiÐiL�Z\[�I3r5S"VJU�P�Z\VOr5S.o7RTZ\VTe0U5P�S?]U5d`owU5ÐQRTI�U5ÐiÐQI3Î�R¯b�UMLOPXW\NQd\h�LOI7ã ý Z\bc[`ä�I3r5S"V¯[\Ð�UMd\SBK9I5Z\d`okÑU5VTNQS"R |Û ÎBI¥I5e¯LTW`S"RTS�U5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\b�R!ÎJNQÐiÐåd`I3Î,KGS�okS.RTP�VTNQK9S"oqU5d`o

NQÐiÐQZ`RaLTVXU3LOS"o |

t:DbC |�}[N$K:I~]�TW}e}eTLz{PGK:Ry^"\*PeK:RcNy\*PeKdRW}[I~YdM_TZ�� ILw)O�P6x IfS:T UVTWRXM�NZY"S g

Í�d\NiLTN�UMÐ{b�U3LOPXW`S"R¿U5VTScâ`VXRaLwI5KkLXUMNQd\S"oÔU?RwokS.RTP�VTNQKGS.oÔUMK9I3r5SZ`RTNQd\hwLOW\S�RaZ`[\[\ÐQNiS.oqÐQIkP�UMÐ�W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs | ì¦H�ì�í�jkì�î<UMÐiÑh?I5VON¼LOW\b�N�R�Z`RTS"oFLOI�RaS"ÐiS.P¢L7U�RTZ\K`RTS�L7IMe¾LTW\S.RaS�bcUMLOPXW\S.RÎJNiLTW\NQdU¦â m S.oïVTS"h5NQI5dÏÎJW\NQPXWU5VTS,P�I5d`RTN�RtLOS�dDLÈÎJN¼LOWU[\VOI ý S.P¢LONir?S¨W\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`WDs | Û W\S,RaN�=�SºI5e7LOW\SºVOS�h5NQI5dÏN�RLOW\S�d�NQd`P�VOS"U?RaS.o7U5d`o7LTW\Sw[\VTIkP�S"okZ\VOS¾VTS"[GS.U3LOS"oå]GZ`RaNQd\hcLOW\SH�ì�í�jkì�îÿo\S�LTS"VTbcNQd\S"o�[\VTI ý S"P�LTNQr5S�W\I?b®I?h5VXUM[\W�sÁNQd`RaLTS.U5oI5e�LOW\ScRaZ\[`[\ÐiNQS"o�W\I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�s |JÛ W\S®RaN�=�S¿NQd`P�VTS.U5RTS¿IMe�LOW\SVOS�h?NiI?d�NQR�d\I5L�W\I?b®I?h5S"d\S�I?Z`R�].K\ZkL�N�R¯h?I3r5S"VTd\S.o¾K�s�LOW\SB[\VTI5Ñ[9I5VTLTNQI5dÈI5e�d\S�ΰbcUMLOPXW\S.R¿enI?Z\d`o |�Û W\S.RaSqLtÎ{I�RtLOS�[`R®UMVOSLOW\S�d=N¼LOS�VXU3LOS"oå]kUMdGoÁLOW\S�U5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\bïLTS"VTbcNQd`U3LOS"RBÎJW\S"dqLOW\Sd�Z\b¥KGS"VJIMe'd\S�ÎÒbcUMLOPXW\S.R�NQR�KGS"ÐiI3Î<LTW\VOS"RTW\I5Ð�o |ì�d�S m U5b®[`ÐiS¥NQR¾RTW\I3ÎJd�NQd�â`h?Z\VTS¥ð | î{I?[\ÐQU5d`UMV�[GI?NidDLXR

U5VTS®P�ÐQS"UMVOÐQs=I?KkLOU5Nid`S"o |wÛ W`S®RTZ`P�P�S"ROR�IMegLOW\S�UMÐQh5I5VONiLTW\b N�RNQd`okN�P�UMLTS"o�NQd�LOU5K\ÐQS v5| f!U?PXW�RaZ\[`[\ÐiNQS"o�W`I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�sÁh5S"dkÑS"VOUMLTS"R'U�RTS�LgI5e9I3r?S�V v"Ý?Ý P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"R"]3IMe�ÎJW\NQPXWcI3r?S�VØ?Ý�� U5VTS7P�I5dGRaN�RtLOS�dDLwÎJNiLTWÔLOW\SÁâ`dGUMÐ!S.RtLONib�UMLTS"oÈS�[\NQ[GI?ÐQU5Vh?S�I5bcS�LTVOs |

Page 5: Index of second image - University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/pritchett98a.pdfRTS r?S VXUMÐ PI5d`d\S"PLTS"o7VOS"U5RTI5dGRgenI?V LTW\N RBe0UMNQÐiZ`VTS × v5vÚ] K\ZkLJLOW\S

NQb�UMh5S Ý NQbcU5h5S Ø

Ü NQh5Z\VOS�ðGá����M�©�X�\���=�D�������O�3���O£=�X�T�M� ���X§. ? 9�ª�0�X£º�a»�����`�3���T�5�T�O `��¡ 4 ����£3�0�X�3���X£Á��¡®�n�\�����k���©�¥�X�2�¢�����)�¢�0�3���M�i�[5c§��X¤�������w 9�i�M�9�J���M���i�3���������M� �D�3�¢���n����«Ô���k���®�����O�3�¢����m��X�T�M����5���i��75«

�����6��� �"�������[�,��� �d�,�����,�G�[� �"���[���X� �d�,�����,�G�[�� ���[�e����� �[��� � ���[�e����� �[��

� ��� ��� � ��� ��¡� ¢�£ ��£ � ¢�� ¡��� ¤�� ��� � ��� ¢�£

Û UMK\ÐQS v á�Å�§k���O���=�a�=�c�M�©�X�\���c�D�������O�3���O£���¡����`�¥ 9�Q�3�9����M���i�3���������3� �D�3�¢���n���²���M�����k�T�X�¥�a»������`�3���T�5�T�O `���0����«

t:D¥t ¦�^:M�]�N$w�I ]�TW}e}eTLz§PeK:R ^d\*PGK:R N<¨iKdIOQM�N$Kd\�]�TXM_UcN<O�P[TWK"\

Í�d\NiLTN�UMÐ{b�U3LOPXW`S"R¿U5VTScâ`VXRaLwI5KkLXUMNQd\S"o�U?R¿okS.RTP�VTNQKGS.o�UMK9I3r5SZ`RTNQd\h�LTW\S�RTZ\[\[\ÐQNiS.o�ÐQIkP�U5ÐJW\I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�s |�Û W`S�RTS�ÐQS"P�LTNQI5dÎJNQd`okI3ΨNQR�LOW\S�d�RTZ\K9o\Nir�N�okS"o¥NidDLOI�enI?Z\V.]5UMd`o¥enI?V�S.U5PXWcRaZ`KkÑokNQr�NQRTNQI5d�b�U3LXPXW\S"R�P�I5dGRaN�RtLOS�dDL�ÎJNiLTW¥UMd¿U3ê�d\S{W\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�sU5VTS�o\S�LTS"VTbcNQd\S"ocZGRaNQd\hwH�ì�í�jkì�î |*© W\S"VTS�RaZkêÁP�NiS"d?L�RaZ`[kÑ[9I5VTL�enI5VJUMd�U3ê�d\S¾W\I?b®I?h5VXUM[\W�s®S m N�RtLXR�]�LOW\VTS"S�P�I5dGRaN�RtLOS�dDLb�U3LXPXW\S"R�UMVOS!PXW\IDRaS"dwU5R�UJK`U5RTN�R�U5d`o¿UJd\S"Î�VTS"h5NQI5d¿P�S�dDLTVOS"oZ\[9I5d�LOW\SwP�S�dDLTVOI5N�o=IMe'LTW\SwK`U5RTNQR�NQR�bcUMLOPXW\S.o |�Û W\S¿S���S"P�LN�RJLOW`U3L�d\S�ÎÓb�U3LXPXW\S"R�UMVOS�ãah?VTI3ÎJd`ä®I?d�LTW\Sw[GS"VTNQ[\W\S"VTs=IMeS.U5PXW¥RTS�ÐQS"P�LTNQI5d¥ÎJNid`o\I3Î | í�I3r5S�ÐDb�U3LXPXW\S"R�U5VTSBRtLOI5VOS"o |�Û W\SU5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\b²LOS�VOb®NQd`UMLTS"RgÎJW\S�dÁd`I�d\S�κU3ê�d\S�K`U5RTS"RgP"UMd�K9SenI?Z\d`o |ì�d�S m UMbc[\ÐQS�NQR�RaW\I3ÎJd�NQd=â`h5Z\VOSwþ | fgr?S�d=LTW\I?Z\h5W=LOW\S

NQd\NiLTN�UMÐ'�*U3ê�d\S?��W\I5bcI?h5VXUM[\W�sJN�R�enI5VåLOW\S�enVOI5dDL^IMe�LOW\SgW\I?Z`RaS?]P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"R�UMVOS�I5K\LOUMNQd\S.oÔI5d�b�UMd�s�IMLTW`S�Vw[`ÐQU5d\S"R |Û UMK\ÐQS¥ÙÁNid`o\NQP"U3LTS.RJLOW\S®RTZ`P"P�S"RORJI5e�LTW\S®UMÐQh5I5VONiLTW\böNid<ãaNQdkѪ UMLTNQd\h?ä�LTW`S�dDZ`bwK9S�V�IMe�b�U3LOPXW`S"R"á7LOW\S�RTS�L�IMe�bcUMLOPXW\S.RP�I5d`RTNQRaLTS"dDL!ÎJN¼LOW�LTW`S�S.RtLONib�U3LOS"ocS"[\Ni[9I5Ð�UMV{h5S"I5bcS�LOVTs®NQR{NQdkÑP�VTS.U5RTS"o�LOI�I3r5S"V v.Ý5Ý enI5VJS.U5PXW�RaS�L�I5e�NQd\NiLTN�UMÐ^b�UMLOPXW\S.R |« ¬ � � ��Ì7���������¥� �0A �' �� ­�Ì������"B

� ���®�'�¿ �� �����g� ®

Û W\S=[\VOS�r�NQI5Z`RcRTS"P¢LONiI?d¨RTW\I3ÎBS"oÔLOW`U3L�U�[`ÐiS"d?LON¼enZ`Ð�RaZ\[`[\ÐisI5e'P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"RJP�U5d�KGS�h?S�d\S"VOUMLTS"oqenVOI5b U®enS"ΦÐiIkP�U5ÐW\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`W\NiS.R | Í©LwLTW\S"d�VTS"bcU5NidGR¾LTI�P�I5bc[\ZkLOSÁU=enZ\d`o\UMÑ

NQb�UMh5S Ý NQbcU5h5S Ø

Ü NQh5Z\VOSBþ\á$���3���O�`�¢�!�D�������T�M�©�X£��X�O�3�Ï�¾�X§. ? 9�ª�0�X£¿�a»����{�`�3¤���T�5�T�X \��¡ 4 ����£3�0�X�3���X£q��¡®�n�\�¿���������w�X�2�¢�����)�¢�0�3�D�5�i�[5®§��¢������È�¢§k�n���5�X�®���3���i�M�����D�,�M� �?�M�¢�����k�c« �������������X�2�¢���¯n��X�T�3����5���i�0�D«

�����6��� �"�������[�,��� �"���������2�[� �"���[� �X� �d�,�����,�G�[�� ���[�e����� �[��� � ���[�e����� �[���

� ��� ��� ��¡�¢ ������ ¢�£ ��£ ����� � ��¤� ¤�� ��� ��°�£ � ���� ¢�° ��� ����¢ � ���

Û UMK\ÐQS¥Ù\áBÅ�§k���X���®�t�¿���3���X�\�����?���9���T�M�©�X£=��¡7���`�¿�¢§k�n���?�O����M���i�3���������3� �D�3�¢���n���Ó���3�{���3§k�w�t»¨�9�¾�\�M�c�O�5�T�O `���0����«

bcS�dDLXUMÐ'b�U3LTVON m enVTI?b LTW\S.RaS�P�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S"R | ì�R�LOW\S�VOSb�U2s¾KGS�U�RTNQh5d\NiâGP�U5dDL�[\VOI5[9I5VTLTNQI5d¿I5e`bcNQRTb�U3LXPXW\S"R�VTS"b�UMNQdkÑNQd\h�NQd¥LOW\S�b�U3LXPXW�RaS�LOR"]MLTW`S�VTI?K\Z`RaL�S"RaLTNQbcUMLTNQI5d�UMÐQh5I?VTNiLTW`bH�ì�í�jkì�î<N�RJZ`RTS"o=LOI�I5KkLXUMNQd�U®enZ\d`o\U5b®S"dDLOUMÐ�b�U3LTVON m LTI5Ñh?S�LTW`S�VJÎJNiLTW�UcRaS�L�I5e'P�I5d`RTN�RtLOS�dDLJbcUMLOPXW\S.R |Û W\S{NQRORaZ`Sgd\I3Î�N�R^W\I3Î�LTI�P�I?bwK\NQd\S�LOW\S{RTS�LXR¯I5e\bcUMLOPXW\S.R

[\VOI3r�NQo\S"o KDs LTW`S²r3UMVONiI?Z`R¶Nid`N¼LONQU5Ð�W\I?b®I?h5VXUM[\W`NiS.RFU5d`oh?VTI3ÎJNQd\h�UMÐQh5I?VTNiLTW\b�R |�l d\Sw[GIDRTRTNiK`NiÐQN¼Lts7NQR�RaNQbc[\ÐQsqLOI�LOU5ß5SLOW\S{Z`d\NiI?dwI5eGUMÐQÐDLTW\SBb�U3LOPXW`S"R |�Û W\N�R�W`U5R¯LTW\S�[9I?RORaNQK\ÐQS{okN�RaÑU?okr3UMdDLOU5h5SJLOW`U3LJU¿[`U5VaLONQP�Z\Ð�UMV{P�I5VOd\S�V{bcNih?W?L�K9S�U5ÐiÐQIkP�U3LOS"obcI5VOS�LTWGU3L!I?d\S�P�I?VTVOS"RT[9I5d`okS"d`P�S.R'KGS.P�U5Z`RaS�N¼L!N�RgNQdqRTS�r?S�VXUMÐI5e�LTW`S�RaS�LOR | õ�I3ÎBS�r?S�V.]!H�ì�í�jkì�î°bcNih?W?LÁÎBS�ÐQÐJK9S�UMK\ÐQSLOI�P�I?[GS7ÎJN¼LOWÈLOW\NQRcRTNidGP�S7U�bwZ\ÐiLTNQ[\ÐQS�P�I5VOVOS"RT[GI?d`okS�dGP�S�N�RRTNibc[\ÐQswU�okN+�9S"VTS"d?L'Lts�[9SBI5eGbcN�Rab�U3LXPXW | ì�d\I5LTW\S"V�[GIDRTRTNiK`NiÐiÑNiLts5]�ÎJW\N�PXW7N�R{LTW\S¾I?d\S�U?okI5[\LTS"o7W\S"VTS?]DN�R{LTIcS�d\enI5VXP�S¾RaNQd\h5ÐQSP�I5VOVTS.Ra[9I5d`o\S�d`P�S |i© W\S�VOS�LTW\S"VTS�NQR�P�I5d ª N�P¢L�LOW\S�b�UMLOPXWÎJNiLTWÁW`Nih?W\S�VBr�NiS"ÎJ[GI?NidDL{NQd�r3UMVONQU5d?LBU3ê�d\NiLts®bcS.U5RTZ\VTS�NQRBRaS�ÑÐQS"P�LTS"o |Èl dGP�S7LTW\N�RcRaS�L®I5e�[GI5LTS�dDLONQU5ÐBb�UMLOPXW\S.RwW`U?R®KGS"S�dh?S�d\S"VOUMLTS"o^]5LOW\S�enZ`d`o\UMbcS"d?LXUMÐ�b�U3LOVTN m NQR�P�I?bc[\ZkLTS.oÁZ`RTNQd\hH�ì�í�jkì�î,K`U?RaS.oqI?d=RTS�r?S�d�P�I5VOVOS"RT[GI?d`okS�dGP�S"R |

Í�dºU�LtsD[`NQP"UMÐ�S m UMbc[\ÐQS5]{â`h?Z\VTS Ø ]{LTW`S�VOS�U5VTS x Nid`N¼LONQU5ÐW\I?bcI5h5VXUM[`W\NiS.Rch5S"d\S�VXU3LONid\h x ð x ] x?Ý �U5d`o¶ð v.Ø bcUMLOPXW\S.RS.U5PXW |¿Û W\S.RaS®LOW\VTS"S®RTS�LXR¾P�I5b¥K\NQd\SwLOI=enI5VObüUqd\S"γRTS�L¾IMeð?ð Ø [\ZkLXU3LTNQr5S�bcUMLOPXW\S.R�IMeåÎJW\N�PXW v"x Ù¾UMVOS�P�I5d`RTN�RtLOS�dDL!ÎJNiLTWLOW\S¿H�ì�í�jkì�î,S"RaLTNQbcUMLTS�I5e¯LTW`S�S�[\NQ[GI?ÐQU5VJh5S"I5bcS�LOVTs |

Page 6: Index of second image - University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/pritchett98a.pdfRTS r?S VXUMÐ PI5d`d\S"PLTS"o7VOS"U5RTI5dGRgenI?V LTW\N RBe0UMNQÐiZ`VTS × v5vÚ] K\ZkLJLOW\S

± } �#¥�w�g�¢�' � �Ì �²� ���Z� �¿��� �E®rB� � �� ���

v?| ì�ZkLTI?b�U3LTN�P�U5ÐiÐQswh?S�d\S"VOUMLTSJU�RTS�LgIMeåÐQIkP�UMÐ`W\I5bcI5h?VOU5[\WkÑNQS"R |¾Ü I5V�S m U5b®[`ÐiS?]GK�s�b�U3LXPXW\Nid`h�enS"UMLTZ\VOSwh?VTI?Z\[`R�I?VZGRaNQd\h�U®[Ds�VXUMbcN�o7RTS"U5VOPXW��*j�S.P¢LTNQI5d x � |

Ù | p�RaS�S.U5PXW7W\I5bcI5h?VOU5[\W�s®LTI�h5S"d\S�VXU3LOS�UcRTS�LJIMe�P�I?VTd`S�Vb�UMLOPXW\S.R�*j�S.P¢LTNQI5d�ð*� |

x`| jkS�LOR�IMe�b�UMLOPXW\S.R�h5S�d`S�VXU3LTS.oÁenVOI5b°S"U5PXW7ÐiIkP"UMÐåW\I?b®I5Ñh?VOU5[\W�s7U5VTS¿P�I5bwK`Nid\S.oå]�UMd`o�UcenZ`d`o\UMbcS"d?LXUMÐ�b�U3LTVON mU5d`o�P�I?d`RTNQRaLTS"d?L�bcUMLOPXW\S.RåS"RaLTNQb�U3LOS"o�Z`RTNQd\h�H�ì�í�jkì�î�)j�S"P�LTNQI5d�þ�� | ìò�ñ�f¦IMe�LTW\SÁenZ\d`o\U5b®S"dDLOUMÐ{b�U3LTVON mN�R�LOW\S�d�I?KkLOU5Nid\S.o7enVTI?bLTW`S¿Nid`ÐiNQS�VXRJr�NQU�Ucd`I5dkÑ©ÐiNQd\S.UMVbcNQd\NQb®N�="UMLTNQI5d |

Ü NQh5Z\VOS"R Ø LTI v ðÔRaW`I3ÎS m UMbc[\ÐQS"R®I5e�LTW`S=ÎJN�okS�K`U?RaS"ÐiNQd\SP�I5bc[\ZkLXU3LTNQI5d |ÖÛ W\S¶â`h?Z\VOS"R�RTW\I3Î�LOW\S<U5ZkLTI?bcUMLTN�P�U5ÐiÐQsb�U3LXPXW\S"oÒ[9I5NQd?LXR�]�S m U5b®[`ÐiS�S�[\NQ[9I5Ð�UMV�ÐiNQd\S.R�]¾UMd`oÒVOS"P�I?dkÑRaLTVOZ`P¢LOS"o x _ÓROP�S"d\S¾[GI?NidDLXR |

³ ¬ �¥���� "Ì�����¥��ö�¿���´A5Ì7�'Ì����µ�Ï�¥�$¶

© S�WGU2r5S�okS"bcI5d`RaLTVXU3LOS"oFLTW`S�U5ZkLTI?bcUMLTN�P�S.RtLONib�U3LONiI?dºIMeS"[\Ni[9I5Ð�UMV�h5S�I?bcS�LTVOsÒU5d`oÓP�I?d`RTNQRaLTS"d?L�b�UMLOPXW\S.R�enI5V�rDNQS�Î[`U5NiVXR�RaS"[`UMVXU3LOS"o7K�sqU®ÎJNQokS¾K`U?RaS"ÐiNQd\S |gÛ W\S¾S�[\NQ[GI?ÐQU5VJh5S"IMÑbcS�LOVTs�[`VTIkokZ`P�S"o�K�s¾LOW\S{ÎJN�okSBK`U5RTS�ÐQNQd\S{U5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\b¦NQR�LTW`S�dLOW\S�RaLOUMVTLTNQd\h¶[9I5NQd?L�enI5V�h5S"d\S�VXU3LONid`h¶U?o\okNiLTNQI5d`U5Ð�enS"UMLTZ\VOSb�U3LXPXW\S"R�ZGRaNQd\hch5Z\N�okS.o7b�UMLOPXW\NQd\h |l LOW\S�V�RaLTVXU3LTS"h5NQS"R�enI5VÔI?KkLOU5Nid\NQd\h¦W\I?b®I?h5VXUM[\W`NiS.R�UMVOS

P�Z\VTVOS�dDLOÐis¿K9S�NQd\h¾NQdDr?S"RaLTNQh?UMLTS"owNidGP�ÐQZ`okNQd\h ý I5NQdDLg[\W\IMLOI5bcS�LTÑVONQP2è2h?S�I5bcS�LTVONQP�NQd�r3UMVONQU5d?LXR¥× v ô Ú ]åU5d`o�ÐQIkP�UMÐ'h?VOU5[\W�b�U3LXPXWkÑNQd\h�× v"ÝMÚ)| ì�ÐQRTI`]9ÎBS¥UMVOS�NQdDr?S"RaLTNQh?UMLTNQd\h�LTW`S¥UMZ\LTI5b�UMLTN�P¿RaS�ÑÐQS"P�LTNQI5d�IMe�ÎJW\NQPXW�RaLTVXU3LOS�h5scLOI�UM[\[\ÐQs |© N�okS¿K`U?RaS"ÐiNQd\SwU5Ðih?I5VON¼LOW\b�R�UMVOS¿UMÐ�RTIÁKGS"Nid`hqokS�r?S�ÐQI5[9S"o

enI?V¿IMLOW\S�V�b¥Z\мLONi[`ÐiSÁr�NQS�ÎÏVTS"ÐQUMLTNQI5d`R�ÎJW\N�PXW�P�Z\VOVOS�dDLTÐQs�UMVOSI?d\Ðis�S"RaLTNQb�U3LTS.oÔUMZkLOI5b�U3LONQP"UMÐQÐis�enI?VwRab�U5ÐiÐ�K`U?RaS"ÐiNQd\S.R |7l e[`U5VaLONQP�Z\Ð�UMV®Nibc[9I5VTLOUMdGP�S�NQR¥LOW\S�UMZkLOI5b�U3LONQP=P�I?bc[\ZkLOUMLTNQI5dI5e�LTW`S7LOVTNienIkP�U5ÐBh?S�I?b®S�LTVOs>�nVOS�[\VOS"RTS�dDLOS"o�K�s�LOW\S=LTVON¼enIkP�U5ÐLOS�d`RTI5V¿× \] v.x ] v ð Ú �!enI5V�LTW`VTS"S�rDNQS�Î�R�× v é Ú)|

· w_¸EKdTLz§}[ILjdRXILUcILK O�\

© S®U5VTSwh5VXU3LTS�enZ\Ð�enI5V�â`d`UMdGP�N�UMÐ'RaZ\[`[GI?VaL�enVTI?büj�W`UMVO[�HJS�ÑRTS"U5VOPXW�ñ¯UMKGR�IMeJfgZ\VOI5[9S�UMd`oÔf{pÏì�î Û j y VTI ý S"P¢L`'ì�í�ÑY¾p�ì�H�_ |�© S�ÎBI5Z\Ð�o®ÐiNQß5S�LOI¾LTW`U5d\ßcì�d`okVOS�Î Ü N¼L2=�h?NiK\K9I5d¯]y W\NiÐ Û I?VTV.]`UMdGo y U5Z\Ð 9 S"U5VOo`RaÐQS�s�enI?V�okN�RTP�Z`RORaNQI5d`RJU5d`o�U5RaÑRTNQRaLOU5d`P�S | Í�bcU5h5S.R¿ÎBS�VOS�[\VTI3r�N�okS"o�K�sÔHJI5K9IML2`�N�RwÍtí�HJÍtìj�I?[\W\N�Ucì�dDLTNQ[GI?ÐiN�R"]`UMd`o Ü VOU5Z\d\W\I5enS�V�ÍaY¾_ |

¹à�:A5���������J��

º »6¼d½_¾ ¿W¾�À�ÁeÂ�ÃbÄ?ÅÇÆ�Á6È�Éʽ�¾ ËW¾ Ìʾ?ÍQΠÃbÃeÉ�Â�Ï?Ä�¿ ¾ÊÐÊÑ�ÅbÅÇÁeÃÇÒ:Â�Ï�¾)Ó ÔÕÒ�Î�Ä?Á[ÆÂ�Öe×�Ø?Ñ�ÅÇÑ ÙbÑ�ΠÏÚ+ÃbΠÒ�Á6Û�ÙbÁ[Ï?Ä?Á[Ä�Ñ�Ò:Â�Ü Á ÅÇÁe×�Ø?Á[Ï?Ö[Á[ÅG¾ Ý$ÞLÞ<ßáà�â�â�ã2Éä Â�Ü Á[Å<å æ Ó2çèå é ê�É�Ì ä ÃbÑ�Ï?Ü Á[Ã¥çìë)Á[ÃÇÆ�Â�Ü?É�»eé é å�¾

º í2¼"îX¾ ï<¾�À�ΠÆ�Æ�ÁeÅ/Â�Ï�Ä�î$¾ ¿ ¾�ïðÂ�Ñ�Ï�¾_î/ÁeÖ[ΠܠÏ?Ñ�ñ[Ñ�Ï?ÜEÂ�Ï?Ä"Æ�Î�ÖeÂ2ÙbÑ�Ï�Ü ä Â�Ã¥çÙbÑ�Â�Æ�Æ È�ò�Ñ�ÅbÑ�ó�Æ�ÁhΠó�ô¥Á[Ö6ÙbÅeõ$Ùbö?Á�Æ�Î�ÖeÂ�Æ çìÚ+ÁGÂ2ÙÇØ?ÃÇÁ[ç�Ú�Î�Ö[Ø?ÅXÒ�Á[ÙÇö?Î�Ä�¾:÷ùø�úûýüGþ øÊÿ û���� øÊÿ���� ���þ øÊÿ� �� ������� û��������/ü��ùü ÿ þ���� É*»�ìÓ��ùÉQ»eé æ í�¾

º Ó2¼d½_¾ �?¾$À�Ø�ÃÇÙe¾��ÊÂ�ÅÇÙ ��Æ ÙÇÁ[Ã�ÙÇÃùÂ�Ï�ÅÇÚ+ΠÃbÒ�Å�Ú+ΠÃ�Ñ�Ò:Â�Ü Á ä ÃÇÎ�Ö[Á[ÅbÅÇÑ�Ï?Ü?¾Þ"!'÷$#/É�»eå�õ í%�&�ê�» ÉQ»eé æ�» ¾º '�¼)(�¾ ¿ ¾*��Ñ�ÅÇÖùö?Æ�Á[Ã)Â�Ï�Ä:îX¾ ï<¾ À�ΠÆ�Æ�Á[Åe¾Êî-Â�Ï�Ä?Î Ò ÅùÂ�Ò ä Æ�Á)ÖeΠÏ�ÅbÁ[Ï?ÅbØ�ÅGõ ä Â�ÃbÂ�Ä?Ñ�Ü ÒáÚ�ΠÃ�Ò�Î�Ä?Á[Æ�?Ù¥ÙbÑ�Ï�Ü,+LÑ ÙböX ä�ä Æ�Ñ�ÖeÂ2ÙbÑ�ΠÏXÙbÎ-Ñ�Ò:Â�Ü Á)Â�Ï?Â2çÆ È�ÅÇÑ�Å'Â�Ï�Ä�Â�Ø�ÙÇΠÒ:Â2ÙbÁ[Ä�ÖeÂ�ÃÇÙÇΠܠÃù ä ö�È�¾ðÞ ��-.-/� ø1032 �4����� 0_Þ �-,5 06 ÿ �7� 0�É�ò�ΠÆì¾Êí*'?õ Ó æ�»4&�é ê�ÉQ»eé æ�» ¾

º ê2¼)8W¾:9<Á[ΠÃbÜ Ñ�ÅeÉ:(�¾Q½�Á6ÙbÃÇΠØ�É'Â�Ï?Ä;�?¾ ëh¾=<ZÑ Ù¥ÙÇÆ�ÁeÃe¾ ><ó�ÙbÂ�Ñ�Ï?Ñ�Ï?ÜÖ[ΠåçÃbÁ[Å ä ΠÏ?Ä?Á[Ï?Ö[Á[Å'Ú+ÃbΠÒÕí Ô ä Á[ÃbÅ ä ÁeÖ6ÙÇÑ ò�ÁLò�Ñ�Á�+LÅ:+LÑ ÙÇö.+LÑ�Ä?Á/Â�Ï?Ü Ø?Æ�Â�ÃÅbÁ ä Â�ÃùÂ2ÙÇÑ�ΠÏ�Î�Ú�Ï?ΠÏ�çýÖ[Î ä Æ�Â�Ï�Â�à ä ΠÑ�Ï�ÙbÅe¾?# þ$��� 0 ��Xû���ü Ý ��þ$��5�ü ÿ�ø�úÞ �@� ø ü��6üBAB� þ�C*���D�75E� ø¯Þ �- 53��ûýüGþ ß �F�4��� ø�ÉÊÓ�G�å�&�Ó�G�é�ÉQ»eé é ê�¾

º å2¼H�/¾I9<Æ�Â�ñ[ÁeÃeÉ39 ¾Êî/Á6È�Ï�ΠÆ�Ä?ÅGÉÊÂ�Ï�Ä�½�¾?¿<Ï?Â�Ï?Ä�Â�Ï�¾�Ì�Ö[Á[Ï?ÁXÒ:Â2ÙbÖùö�Ñ�Ï?Üó�Èdö?Ñ�Á[ÃùÂ�ÃÇÖùö?Ñ�ÖeÂ�Æ�Ö[ΠÃÇÃbÁ[Æ�Â2ÙbÑ�ΠÏ�¾ Þ<ß�# �KJ�L ÉI'�Ó í�&�''?» ÉQ»eé æ Ó�¾

º GG¼�ïZ¾ 9 ¾�Ë<Â�ÃÇÃbÑ�Å�Â�Ï?ÄM(�¾ Ì�ÙÇÁ ä ö?Á[Ï?ÅG¾�¿¯Ö[ΠÒhó?Ñ�Ï�ÁeÄ Ö[ΠÃbÏ?Á[Ã_Â�Ï?ÄEÁ[Ä?Ü ÁÄ?Á6ÙbÁ[Ö6ÙbΠÃe¾�N ���þ6ûF� 2 � O ü�P ß ������� ørÞ � ø [üeþÇü ø �ùü É�»7'�G�&Ê»eê�» É*»eé æ æ�¾º æ2¼"îX¾�Ë-Â�ÃÇÙÇÆ�Á6ÈrÂ�Ï?Ä3î$¾:9<Ø ä ÙbÂ�¾qïðÎ Ò ä Ø�ÙbÑ�Ï�Ü (Â2ÙbÖùö�ÁeÄ�çýÁ ä Ñ ä ΠÆ�Â�ý)ÃbÎ2ôÇÁ[Ö6ÙbÑ�ΠÏ�ÅG¾XÞ<ß�# � à�â�â L É ä Â�Ü Á[Å-ê*'�é.&:ê ê ê�É*»eé é Ó�¾º é2¼"îX¾ÊË-Â�ÃÇÙÇÆ�Á6È�¾L¿ Æ�Ñ�Ï?ÁeÂ�Ã<Ò�Á6ÙÇö?Î�Ä"Ú�ΠÃLÃbÁ[Ö[ΠÏ?ÅÇÙÇÃbØ�Ö[ÙÇÑ�ΠÏ�Ú+ÃbΠҧÆ�Ñ�Ï�ÁeÅÂ�Ï?Ä ä ΠÑ�Ï�ÙbÅe¾?QýÏ�÷ Þ/Þ<ß à�â�â�R É ä Â�Ü ÁeÅ<æ æ í�&�æ æ�G�ÉQ»eé é ê�¾

º »�%2¼"îX¾�ËLΠÃùÂ�Ø?ÄhÂ�Ï?ÄEÍ$¾�Ì@S Î ÃÇÄ�Â�ÅG¾�Ì�ÙbÁ[ÃbÁ[ÎXÖ[ΠÃbÃÇÁeÅ ä ΠÏ?Ä?Á[Ï?Ö[ÁLÙÇö?ÃÇΠØ?Ü öÚ�ÁeÂ2ÙÇØ?ÃbÁ'Ü ÃbÎ Ø ä Ñ�Ï�Ü<Â�Ï?ÄXÒ:Â2Û�Ñ�Ò:Â�Æ�Ö[Æ�Ñ�×�Ø�ÁeÅe¾@#�2 6 ÷6É�» »�¥» »��6õ�» »eå æ�&» »eæ%�É*»eé æ é�¾º » »6¼d½_¾ ï<¾ð½'ÃbÑ ÙÇÖùö?Á6ÙÇÙÂ�Ï?Äá¿ ¾LÐÊÑ�ÅbÅÇÁeÃÇÒ:Â�Ï�¾UT Ñ�Ä?Á0ó�Â�ÅbÁ[Æ�Ñ�Ï?Á�ÅÇÙÇÁ[ÃbÁ[Î

Ò:Â2ÙbÖùö�Ñ�Ï?Ü?¾áÍQÁ[Öùö?Ï?Ñ�ÖeÂ�ÆZÃÇÁ ä ΠåÙGÉLÔ-Á ä Â�ÃÇÙÇÒ�ÁeÏ�ÙdÎ�ÚKV)Ï�Ü Ñ�Ï?Á[ÁeÃÇÑ�Ï?ÜÌ�Ö[Ñ�ÁeÏ�ÖeÁ É1WLÏ?Ñ ò�Á[ÃbÅbÑ ÙýÈ:Î�ÚX>-Û�Ú+ΠÃbÄ�É�»eé é�G�¾º »eí2¼�ïZ¾�Ì�Öùö?Ò�Ñ�ÄhÂ�Ï?Ä�î$¾�(�Πö?ÃG¾3(Â2ÙÇÖùö?Ñ�Ï�Ü$ó�ÈhÆ�Î�ÖeÂ�Æ?Ñ�Ï�ò Â�ÃÇÑ�Â�Ï�ÙÇÅG¾�î/Á6ç

ÅbÁeÂ�ÃbÖùöXÃÇÁ ä ΠåÙ�í å*''?É*QY8-î"Qý¿3î/ö[ZΠÏ?Á6çý¿-Æ ä Á[ÅeÉ�9<ÃbÁ[Ï?Πó�Æ�Á�É*��ÃùÂ�Ï?Ö[Á É»eé é ê�¾º »eÓ2¼d¿ ¾2Ì�ö�Â�ÅÇö�Ø�Â�¾�ÍQÃÇÑ�Æ�Ñ�Ï?ÁeÂ�ÃbÑ ÙýÈZÑ�ÏZò�Ñ�ÅbØ?Â�Æ�ÃÇÁeÖ[ΠܠÏ?Ñ ÙÇÑ�ΠÏXó�ÈWÂ�Æ�Ñ�Ü Ï�Ò�ÁeÏ�Ùe¾

QýÏÝXÞ/Þ<ß à�â�â�\�É ä Â�Ü ÁeÅ"'�G�é�&�'�æ*'?É�Ì ä ÃÇÑ�Ï?Ü Á[ÃÇçìë'Á[ÃbÆ�Â�Ü?É�»eé é*'?¾º »7'�¼)(�¾ V-¾�Ì ä Á6ÙÇÅùÂ*S�Ñ�Å$Â�Ï?Ä �?¾Ê¿<Æ�ΠÑ�Ò�ΠÏ?ΠÅe¾-Ì�ÙÇÃbØ?Ö6ÙÇØ?ÃbÁWÚ�ÃÇΠҧÒ�Î�ÙÇÑ�ΠÏØ?ÅbÑ�Ï?ÜhÆ�Ñ�Ï?ÁZÖ[ΠÃbÃÇÁeÅ ä ΠÏ?Ä?Á[Ï?Ö[Á[ÅG¾/÷4��ÞZßQÉ ä Â�Ü Á[ÅW»�G�»4&Ê»eæ Ó�ÉQ»eé é%�¾º »eê2¼�ïZ¾�Í�Â[È�Æ�ΠÃeÉ�½�¾�Ô<Á[óÊÁ[ò�Á[Ö É�Â�Ï�Ä)�?¾@(Â�Æ�Ñ]Sʾ*î/Á[ÖeΠÏ�ÅÇÙÇÃbØ?Ö6ÙÇÑ�Ï?Ü ä Î Æ È�çö?Á[Ä?ÃùÂ�Æ?Ò�Î�Ä?Á[Æ�Å�Î�Ú�Â�ÃbÖùö?Ñ ÙÇÁ[Ö6ÙbØ?ÃbÂ�ÆÊÅbÖ[Á[Ï?Á[Å'Ú+ÃbÎ Ò ä ö?Î�ÙÇΠܠÃù ä ö?Åe¾3QýÏÝXÞ/Þ<ß à�â�â�ã2¾�Ì ä ÃÇÑ�Ï?Ü Á[ÃÇçìë'Á[ÃbÆ�Â�Ü?É�»eé é å�¾º »eå2¼d½_¾ ËX¾ Ì�¾?ÍQΠÃÇÃ<Â�Ï?Ä�Ô ¾ TÕ¾I(�Ø?ÃbÃbÂeÈ�¾^><Ø�ÙÇÆ�Ñ�Á[Ã<Ä?Á6ÙÇÁ[Ö[ÙÇÑ�ΠÏ�Â�Ï?Ä�Ò�Î�ç

ÙbÑ�ΠÏ"ÅbÁ[Ü Ò�Á[Ï�ÙbÂ2ÙbÑ�ΠÏ�¾?QýÏB_`#)÷¥Ý�â L É*»eé é Ó�¾º »�GG¼d½_¾ ËX¾ Ì�¾)ÍQΠÃÇÃ:Â�Ï?Ä ¿W¾/ÐÊÑ�ÅbÅbÁ[ÃÇÒ:Â�Ï�î/Πó?Ø?Å¥Ù ä Â�ÃùÂ�Ò�Á6ÙbÁ[ÃÇÑ�ÅùÂ2ÙÇÑ�ΠÏÂ�Ï?Ä�Ö[Î Ò ä Ø�ÙbÂ2ÙÇÑ�ΠÏ�Î�ÚQÙbö�ÁXÙÇÃbÑ Ú+Î�ÖGÂ�Æ�ÙbÁ[Ï?ÅÇΠÃG¾ba 6 ß)Þ�É*»eé é å�¾º »eæ2¼Hc)¾�ë)Â�Ïd9<Î�ΠÆðÂ�Ï?ÄqÍ$¾[(�Î�ΠÏ?Å Â�Ï?ÄqÔW¾=W-Ï?Ü Ø�ÃbÁeÂ�Ï�Ø�¾�¿,eEÏ?ÁHf

ä ö?Î�ÙÇΠÒ�Á[ÙÇÃbÑ�ÖÑ�Ï�ò Â�ÃÇÑ�Â�Ï�ÙÇÅ:Ú�Πà ä Æ�Â�Ï�Â�ÃdÑ�Ï�ÙÇÁ[Ï?ÅbÑ ÙýÈ ä Â2Ù¥ÙÇÁeÃÇÏ?ÅG¾gQýÏÝXÞ/Þ<ß à�â�â�ã2É ä Â�Ü Á[Å-å*'�í�&�å ê�» É�Ì ä ÃbÑ�Ï�Ü ÁeÃ¥çìë'ÁeÃÇÆ�Â�Ü?É�»eé é å�¾º »eé2¼:ëh¾?ë'Á[Ï`S�Â2ÙÇÁ[Å�+/Â�Ã<Â�Ï?Äî$¾ ïðö�ÁeÆ�Æ� ä�ä Â�¾/Ë-Ñ�Á[ÃbÂ�ÃbÖùö?Ñ�ÖeÂ�Æ�ÅÇÙÇÁeÃÇÁ[Î:Â�Ï?ÄÒ�Î�ÙbÑ�Î Ï Ö[ΠÃbÃÇÁeÅ ä ΠÏ?Ä?Á[Ï?Ö[Á3Ø?ÅbÑ�Ï?Ü3Ú+ÁGÂ2ÙÇØ?ÃÇÁrÜ ÃbÎ Ø ä Ñ�Ï�Ü ÅG¾ ÷4��ÞZßQÉ

ä Â�Ü Á[Å<í*'�ê�&�í å é�É�»eé é ê�¾º í%2¼�ïZ¾-ÐÊÁ[Æ�Æ�ÁeÃe¾h# þ$�$ieü��Gû�� O ü�j 2Xk3ø ü ÿ ø3l3Ý �`� � � l ü ÿ�ø{Þ_ÿ�� ���[þ ÿ û���� ø

� ø Þ �-,51��ûýü ß �F�4��� ø�ÿ ø3l û���ü 2 5�5 � ��� ÿ û���� ø ��nm���þÇübüMop�F-Eü ø�ú�4��� øÊÿ�?# üeþ��bü�5Êû���� ø�¾�½)ö�Ô&Ùbö?Á[ÅÇÑ�ÅGÉ)îLΠóÊÎ�Ù¥ëZÑ�Åq9<ÃÇÎ Ø ä ÉbQY8-î"Qý¿Ì�Î ä ö?Ñ�Â2çý¿-Ï�ÙÇÑ ä ΠÆ�Ñ�ÅGÉ�»eé é å�¾

º í�»6¼�Ð�¾2Ð�ö�Â�Ï�Ü?É�îX¾GÔ<Á[ÃÇÑ�Öùö?Á É�> ¾��ÊÂ�Ø?Ü Á[ÃùÂ�ÅeÉ Â�Ï?Ä/r ¾�c*Ø?ΠÏ?Ü?¾�¿rÃbΠó�Ø?ÅÇÙÙbÁ[Öùö?Ï�Ñ�×�Ø?ÁdÚ�Πà Ò:Â2ÙbÖbö?Ñ�Ï?Ü�Ùs+ðÎ�Ø?Ï?ÖeÂ�Æ�Ñ�ó?ÃbÂ2ÙbÁ[Ä3Ñ�Ò:Â�Ü Á[ÅWÙÇö?ÃÇΠØ?Ü öÙbö?ÁXÃÇÁeÖ[Îeò�ÁeÃ¥È�Î�Ú�ÙÇö?ÁXØ?Ï`S�Ï?Î�+LÏÁ ä Ñ ä ΠÆ�Â�Ã-Ü Á[ΠÒ�Á6ÙÇÃÇÈ�¾"2 þ6û�� t?��� ÿ��÷6ø ûýü ��� �]u�ü ø �ùü É3G�æ�õ æ�G�&Ê» »eé�ÉQ»eé é ê�¾

Page 7: Index of second image - University of Oxfordvgg/publications/papers/pritchett98a.pdfRTS r?S VXUMÐ PI5d`d\S"PLTS"o7VOS"U5RTI5dGRgenI?V LTW\N RBe0UMNQÐiZ`VTS × v5vÚ] K\ZkLJLOW\S

Ü NQh5Z\VOS Ø á�v��c�"�?���p��M�9£3s��a���n�\���\�3§����.«��9�`���O�w�3�O��7Êm�����G�ª¡3���D�w�c�M�©�X�\�����t���¿�©�M�©�M�`�t�Xn�n)s 4 ���G�ª�0���X���3�9£¥�3§k�)�ª�0���X�b55«

Ü NQh5Z\VOSwé�á¿Çg�3�¢�O�¢�) `�3�9£M���D���� 9�  `�3�i�M�w�ª�����¢�¥�M�9£� \�M���`�*��§��X¤�����Á�n�\�®�X�3�� 9§k���O£��X§k�9£?�3�����G�©�M�^�c�M�*�¢�¼±�«

Ü NQh5Z\VOS�ô\áwv¢�����D���¥�t�w�7�O�M�*�)�i�w������� m�s�s����G�ª¡3���D�7���3���O�`�¢��a���,���3���3�®�t�&o�n'7 4 ���`�ª�0���X�¨�3��£Ò�M§k�*�ª�0���X�ù55«çÅw�M�©��¹����`����3���O�`�X£��X�3�¢�����X�Á���Q�O�M�¢�ª¡�����£3�0�X�3���Á�n�\�=�X�3�®�c�M�È�T�©�5�0�3�\��a�����`�¿�)�!�c�������D�¢��«

Ü NQh5Z\VOS�`áwx�±��3�� 9�i�¥�© ��  \�M�i�3�¿�¼���9�����M�9£Á�X�3�¢�O�¢�) `�3�9£?�����X�¢�§��¢���D�q�n�\�w�X�M�� �§k�©�X£��X§k��£5�M�c���`���3���c�M�*�¢�¼±�«

Ü NQh5Z\VOS v"Ý á"v¢�����D�¢�B�a�B�¾�X�\�X \���k��������71y�o����`�¼¡3���D�¾���3���O�`�¢��a�{���©�M�©�M�D�a� m�7�o 4 ���`�ª�0���X�B�3��£¾�3§k�)�ª�0���X�ù55«pv��c�"�?���B�X�3§k�¢���¢�¢¡�a�)zå�O�3§k���`�t�����HvI{p|®«

Ü NQh5Z\VOS v5v á,xg±D�M�� ��i�J�� 9�  `�3�i�M�B�¼���9���{�3�9£¾�X�3�¢�O�¢�) `�3�9£?�����X�¢�§��¢���D�Á���`�¥�X�M�� �§k�©�X£��X§k��£5�M�c���`���3�^���3�)�¢�¼±�«

9 IMLaLOÐiS î{WGUM[9S�Ð

Ü NQh5Z\VOS v Ùká.}��i�3���"�0���'�¥�t��m@|Ó 9�T�t���X���)���2�®�O�O�X�M�\�¢�*�¢§`���)�0�3��a���n�\�¥�X�3�)�*�i�¥�3��£Á�O�`�O `���¯§��X���������G�ª¡3���D�Á�c�M�©�X�\���w�3�9£����`��X�3�� 9§k���X£q�� 9�  `�3�i�M���D�X�3�����)�¢¡5«

Ü NQh5Z\VOS v"x á"v¢�����D�¢�J�t�{���`�E~G�3�Q�O�M�`�����O�k§k�T�X�¿�����n�qo�p����`�ª¡3¤�����¿���3���O�`�¢�¾�t���w�©�M�©�M�9�a�qy�n 4 ���`�ª�0���X���3��£¥�M§k�*�¼�0���X�ù55«wv��¥¤�"�?���w�O�M§k�¢�©���¢¡q�t�qvTÅ�ÃqvOÄ�¹�Æ��X \�k�0�®Ä��G�*�  `�3�ª����«

Ü NQh5Z\VOS v ð`á,xg±D�M�� ��i�J�� 9�  `�3�i�M�B�¼���9���{�3�9£¾�X�3�¢�O�¢�) `�3�9£?�����X�¢�§��¢���D�Á���`�¥�X�M�� �§k�©�X£��X§k��£5�M�c���`���3�^���3�)�¢�¼±�«