1

jkT; ljdkj us ou Lo:i {ks=ksa ds fu/kkZj.k gsrq fuEukuqlkj ekud fu/kkZfjr fd, gaS] ftls ek0 loksZPp U;k;ky; }kjk fnukad 11-01-2008 dks Lohdkj dj fy;k x;k gS %& ou Lo#i fu/kkZj.k dk ekud %& • o{̀kksa dh izfr gsDVs;j U;wure la[;k fuEukuqlkj gksxh %&

HkkSxksfyd {ks= U;wure {ks=Qy ¼gs0½ o{̀kksa dh U;wure la[;k ¼izfr gs0½

foU/; ,oa cqUnsy[k.M {ks= 3 100 rjkbZ ,oa eSnkuh {ks= 2 50 • o{̀kksa ls rkRi;Z izkd`frd #i ls mxs cgqo"khZ; iztkfr ds o{̀kksa ls gSA • o{̀kksa dh la[;k dh x.kuk esa >kM+h ,oa #VLVkd lfEefyr ugh gksxkA • Hkwfe dk U;wure {ks=Qy dk vk/kkj xkVk la[;k okj gksxkA ijUrq futh Hkwfe ds izdj.k

esa tgkW ,d xkVk esa dbZ O;fDr;ksa ds uke featwewyk ds #i esa ntZ gS ogkW izR;sd featwewyk IykV dk {ks=Qy ds ekin.M gsrq vk/kkj ekuk tk;sxkA

• futh ;k lkoZtfud Hkwfe ij fd;s x;s o{̀kkjksi.k ou Lo#i {ks=ksa gsrq fpfUgr ugh fd;s tk;sxsaA

ek0 loksZPp U;k;ky; dk fu.kZ; fuEu izdkj m)fjr fd;k tk jgk gS %& ITEM NOS.301+302 COURT NO.1 SECTION PIL SUPREME COURT OF INDIA RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS I.A.No.1784 in 703 In W.P.(C)No.202/1995 T.N. GODAVARMAN THIRUMULPAD Petitioner(s)

VERSUS UNION OF INDIA & ORS Respondent(s) (for seeking leave to regularise pre-1980 encroachment of Doyang Reserve Forest) AND I.A.No.979 in I.A.Nos.443, 1204, 1245, 1357 & 2110 in WP(C) No.202/1995 (For recommendation of C.E.C in I.A.No.443, report of C.E.C. in I.A.NO.979, direction and exemption from filing O.T.) WITH I.A.NOs.991, 1004, 1185, 1273, 1280, 1294, 1443, 1611, 2018 & 2073 in in W.P.(C)no.202/1995

2

(For recommendation of C.E.C. regarding illegal mining in Chousil Reserve Forest Lalitpur U.P. & direction and exemption from filing O.T.) AND I.A.No.1354 in 1154 in W.P.(C)No.202/1995 (Recommendation of C.E.C. in I.A.No.1154 & directions) AND I.A.Nos.1358 in I.A.No.992 in W.P.(C)no.202/1995 (Recommendation of CEC in I.A.No.992 and directions) AND I.A.Nos.1362-1363 in W.P.(C)No.202/1995 (For modification & direction & interim stay and recommendation of CEC) AND W.P.(C)No.202/1995 etc. I.A.Nos.1373, 1389 & 1696 in W.P.(C)No.202/1995 (For directions and note on I.A.No.1373) AND I.A.No.1383 in W.P.(C)no.202/1995 (State of Forest report, 2003) AND I.A.No.1433 & 1477 in W.P.(C)No.202/1995 (For directions & exemption from filing O.T.) AND SLP(C)No.25068/2005 (With prayer for interim relief) AND SLP(C)No.21322/2007 (With appln.(s) for c/delay and exemption from filing c/c of the impugned order and with prayer for interim relief) WITH SLP(C)No.22718/2007 (With prayer for interim relief and office report) I.A.No.2142 in 2071 in W.P.(C)No.202/1995(For impleadment) Date: 11/01/2008 These applications were called on for hearing today. CORAM : HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE ARIJIT PASAYAT HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.H. KAPADIA Mr. Harish N. Salve, Sr. Adv. (A.C.) Mr. U.U. Lalit, Sr. Adv. (A.C.)(NP) Mr.Siddhartha Chowdhury, Adv.(A.C.)

3

W.P.(C)No.202/1995 etc. For the petitioner(s) Mr.P.K.Manohar, Adv. In person (NP) in SLP(C)No.21322 Mr.Tapesh Kumar Singh, Adv. Mr.Dinesh Chandra Pandey, Adv. Mr.Ajit Kumar Sinha, Adv. For the respondent(s)/ Mr.G.E.Vahanvati, Sol.Genl.for India applicant(s) Mr.R.MOhan, ASG Ms.K.Amareswari, Sr.Adv. Mr.Haris Beeran, Adv. For Mr.P.Parmeswaran, Adv. I.A.No.991 Mr.Ranjit Kumar, Sr.Adv. Mr.V.B.SIngh, Sr.Adv. Mr.Virendra Parmar, Adv. Ms.Sunita Singh,Adv. Mr.Varun, Adv. Ms.Shefali Jain, Adv. Ms.Binu Tamta, Adv. Mrs.Sushma Suri, Adv. I.A.NO.1784 Mr.Ng.J.R.Luwang, Adv. Mr.Riku Sarma, Adv. For M/s.Corporate Law Group, Advs. Mr.K.K.Venugopal, Sr.Adv. Mr.S.U.K.Sagar, Adv. Ms.Bina Madhavan, Adv. Mr.Hemal K.Sheth, Adv. For M/s.Lawyers' Knit & Co., Advs. Mr.Manish Goswami, Adv. Mr.Ashok Panigrahi,Adv. For M/s.MAP & CO., Advs. For Intervenor Mr.S.Balaji, Adv. Ms.Lakshmi Jayashankar,Adv. Mr.M.L.Lahoty, Adv. Mr.Paban K.Sharma, Adv. W.P.(C)No.202/1995 etc. Mrs.Rachana Srivastava, Adv. Ms.Rani Chhabra, Adv. Mrs.Shobha Dixit, Sr.Adv. Mr.Anil Kr.Jha, Adv. M/s.Fox Mandal & Co., Advs.

4

Mr.J.K.Bhatia, Adv. Mr.Sridhar Potaraju, Adv. Mr.Pramod Dayal, Adv. Mr.Anil Kr.Srivastava, Adv. Mr.Ritu Raj, Adv. Mr.Ramenswar Prasad Goyal, Adv.(NP) Mr.V.K.Verma, Adv. Mr.Ajit Pudussery, Adv. Mr.G.Prakash, Adv. Ms.Suparna Srivastava, Stg.Counsel Mr.Manish Sharma, ADv. Mr.Rajesh Srivastava, Adv. Mr.Jitendra Mohan Sharma, Adv. Mr.Gopal Singh, Adv. UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following ORDER I.A.No.979 in I.A.Nos.443, 1204, 1245, 1357 & 2110 in WP(C) No.202/1995: These matters relate to the identification of the "forest like areas" in the various districts in the State of Uttar Pradesh. Now the guidelines have been issued as to how these areas are to be identified. Learned senior counsel for the State of Uttar Pradesh submits that steps would be taken to identify "forest like areas" in all the districts in the State of Uttar Pradesh within a period of four months and such areas would be handed over to the Forest Department except the private areas, if any. ITEM NO.MM-E COURT NO.1 SECTION PIL

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

I.A.No._______In W.P.(C)No.202/1995 T.N. GODAVARMAN THIRUMULPAD Petitioner(s) VERSUS UNION OF INDIA & ORS Respondent(s)

5

Date: 11/01/2008 This application was mentioned today. CORAM : HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE ARIJIT PASAYAT HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.H. KAPADIA Mr. Harish N.Salve, Sr. Adv. (A.C.) For the petitioner(s) :Mr.P.K.Manohar, Adv. For the respondent(s)/ :Mr.Rajiv Dutta, Sr.Adv.(Mentioned by) applicant(s) Mr.D.K.Garg, Adv. UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following ORDER List on 25.1.2008. (G.V.Ramana) (Veera Verma) Court Master Court Master (Mentioned slip enclosed) ITEM NO.MM-F COURT NO.1 SECTION PIL SUPREME COURT OF INDIA RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS I.A.No.2101 In W.P.(C)No.202/1995 T.N. GODAVARMAN THIRUMULPAD Petitioner(s) VERSUS UNION OF INDIA & ORS Respondent(s) Date: 11/01/2008 This application was mentioned today. CORAM : HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE ARIJIT PASAYAT HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.H. KAPADIA Mr. Harish N.Salve, Sr. Adv. (A.C.)

6

For the petitioner(s) :Mr.P.K.Manohar, Adv. For the respondent(s)/ :Mrs.Rekha Pandey, Adv.(Mentioned by) applicant(s) Mr.D.K.Garg, Adv. UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following ORDER List on 25.1.2008. (G.V.Ramana) (Veera Verma) Court Master Court Master (Mentioned slip enclosed)

7

~..,iCf) 20.oe.os ~ ~ CA :fl'<19Cf) /3J64et. ~ 'k'l~<~ 'ttfitRt. ~ u-cm. (iiftl"'fd) ~ ar&llltdl 1l CR :tq'(liq ~ "$ ~"§iCf)"'f tg •t~tl ~ 'k1~4

'ftfit~ ~ tocl; "iM Cf) tdgro I

ftc ~tlti"f ~202/95 tto~ •1'1••4"'1 ~ ~ ~ cr ~ <t C~PJ lf ~o~o msm-979 1f ttri'f~ll a'tilott ~rlllt'lll ~ tnfto ~ ct 'IJ)l'f 1l <R ~ ~ '* ~ot:ict>"t ~ ¥1Rf"fj~!(ll "ffiJm-7116/ 14-2-1996, ~ 23 ~~ .... ~ 1996 irnT ~ ~ ~

-qq' ~ ~ ~ "Cf>T ~ ~ "Tlrr en 1 \3tmiiut tr-RT <t ~ '* tfit1't<h'•>q lllWf ~

ct>lllft14 lrftf~700/14-4-49 ~)/2004, ~ Oft06.04 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~'1 • foOJ filxrr "lfllTI tu~.,,~,, ~3583/14-2-2007-49 ~)/2004. ~ 17.12.07 SRT

~ ~ ~ cfi 1f60'f lf ~ 'lit~Eiif ~ "lfllT I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 19.12.07

Cf>T ~ 3114)~i'1 ifR "lfPf ~ ~ ~ qRafJIII ~ 1A ~ eFif 7(; ~~iCf>"t ~ ~

~~o ifR 31tA\ 'li~fi'<~i ~ "1A ~. ~ m <t ~ w ~ ~275/"!fto~o/3flto~o 979 {lA ~). ~ 20.12.01 ~· l1"ffi"f <1iT ~ ctR eft 1 lTRR

~ ~ "tffij~4l <1if 'f<ftct>I'C ~.~ ~~ $_ ~~iit>"t ~ 4R'afllll ~ lfRit>, ~

qar ·~~ ifi"foilll \3'iiit<iif o:Qilllt'l<l ~ ~ JRWf ~I ¥11"1.-ft<l \3&1i'llf o:QI<II(IIf<l lJRf ~

~ ~ 1 1 ~. 2008 ID"'<l Aoffim ~ ~ \JC'fR rtw if CfOf ~ !Wit q;r ~~ict>or ~

1A ~ S=if "if)) "\3tffi ~ CfOf ~ ~ t''k'II"'~CI ~ ~ uml I

'lt"'':fl<l \36Qi'llf "'414it1<1 7(; ~ 7(; lPl" lf fti'tMI~i ~120/

14-2-2008/ 49 ~o). ~ 1s.o1.oa em \'ffif'C m lTRR ~ ~ ~ ~ =td~f~<~l ~

f.l~llm ~err ffl> "lfPf ~ H "ct>T Rl~ictR <~R ~ ~ f.M{~a ft'r1iJ (!"if)"~~

~<1if~ CfR eft ~I

"\3(ftf '"'ft.,,e" <t 31jQit1"1 1f ·~ ~ mRl <t 67 vt"''Q~ ~ Vft(f <A ~

~ <t ~~l<t>"t qft ~tl'1131l cr;r ~ ""' m;;q ~ ~ -:m ~ 'li'kjf?i<li lTffl'1" ~

~ Cf'1 ~. "\3(\'R ~. cl'&'1\Ji <t ~ 1076/ 3&--3-2. ~ 06 ~. 2008 ~ ~ ~ "Iff efi J \iAQG t'ldlif!f(, ilt'I'U'1~'<. ~Sictz.G Cl'ft ~t1'11~ \ffi lPPt ~ ~ eft I ~ ~ ~

'Cj..off"114 il'f1<f ~ cf; ~ ~ 20.06.2008 ltiT ~ ~ ~ &m ~ ~tl"ftaif "if)f ~

~ "lJl'lT I ~ 03 UI"''Qc{f if ~ 252 "lfTif lf 1A ~ ~ ~ Tf1n. ~'f{Cf>l ~ ~

lkt,.·: -

8

3842.642 ~ t 1 ~ 'fl' 240 ?JTt m1f ~ (lil'!lllfSC'I 3777.033 to) nt!fr 12 7fl't (e'!llifSC'I

65.809 to) ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ "IJ"l) (tfCifi .. ~1)

~ 03 """'q~' 71; atftt~4't"' ~ fil\11~'( ~ 31"'tl'fo ~ m ~ ~ ufPf Jl1WT ~

lA ~ n ~~n ~ ~ ~ "1ft ~ ~ ~ "$" 'lfi'EZPf ~ JITit1" rt 1 liWfit ~ ~

~ ~ ~ 1:1'<1' ~ fi~Gif!£'< "if CA' ~ h ~ lf1'm ~ TJliT ~. ~

~\il[!f< "$" &•t'l'fo ~ m ~ ~ ufPf ll'IT7T ~ lA ~ ~ 71; ~=&1¥=1 1Ift <rsl4411f! \ffi"

~ ~ ~ ~ .P eft 1 ~ cr>r441t'l srifl•fl~ 4•nliactilift. ~ lRf ~ l1ln7T i;T'<T 'fl'fr"'lr"t'''< ~

'fl' ~ UfT ~ ~ I ~ lfltl•fl~ 4"111fict>lift. lit\ilf!f< i;m "Gil- CA' ~ ~ 7/; ~~ct>"' "tg ~

atfflct>l~ e}, iff'<T 1l'f ~ ~ ~ ~ 3ICPTC'f "=rtf ii'R!m -rnn r Q)C'Itct'M ~ oe "ft. 2008 "Cfi\

~ eM ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~\il[:fC ~ ~ ~ ~ * "lJlft eft I ~ ~ 20.06.

2008 em ~ litGif~'< ~ ~Ciii·I'R'I4l~ ~ J;'RT Vf1m ftq)t ¥ ~ fi~Gif!l'< \iA"'R ~ "1ft 10

'tfre'f ~ lA ~ ~ 1itRJr -rnn t I ~ ~ ~ fi:Mf!£'< ~ lift ~ em :flt'ilfiao ~

GI'AT &14t'<tcti t 1 3Rr. PlGil!fC ~ ~ ~ <M :flt'il~o 'ctl'<"ff ~ "'f'lft"' ~ ct; 3II"EJR 1R

Pl\ilf:rc ~ ~ 10 ~ (lil'3icp(i1 213.115 to) lA ~ 7/i ~ ~ ~ ~ 1'f'lt t 1 'iii'l•.,._1

(1)

"ilJ JlCt>R ~ 7/; ~ 70 GI"'Q~l ~ 'fl' ... , \11"N~l"if CA' ~ ~ t I

29 GI"'Q<il ~ ~ 698 ~"if (~ 8645.201 to) CA' ~ ~ f$vr 1'f'1lT ! 1 t=Pl liTif ~ ~ 620 7JTt (~ 7751.643 to). 'CIUI<tft~ "ftit 1R ~ ~ (lii'31Q)C'I 1•.00 to ) ~ ~ ~ 77 (lll'31CfiCill 879.358 to) ~ ~ ~ f (flfti.,._2. 2 (1). 2 {2) lA ~ 71;

~. "fff'fict>=t 1;[li e'(fli"'C'1'(0j <t; ~ ~ ~ ~ '{If ~ :fl~Rt<ti rtt'J 71; "'fl'ift \II"'IQ<il 71;

~~I

~ ~ :fltgftt<il ~ ~ <)tl'<16'l t I

(1) V11'J WifTUT ~ t"g ~ ~ ~ chft t ~ 'flf~C:I~cti ~ 'VT1J ~ ~ ~

~ rilr ~ ._ e'R'Ir"'<1~o 1IR " ~ at~~lfl'f ¥- 111~11:ff 7/i a=t~•ftt ¥tr=t4hl ei!iln'f

"'4141C'I<t ~ di:Jotftt 1fl'l<'r 'Ct>'C', Wll 1A' mf1m ctRCt ~ <A' ~ 76 'lf!'EZPf ~ nf.\.lo ~

;;;m)' I

(2) f.!lutt .1ffit ¥- CA' ~ lfll em "''""'""<~ =cti<IIC'Ilf * ~ * ~ ~ ~ "ffRR ~ l!!ffll=tt~o '=ftl ~ UfT"11 t 1 ~ ~ "$" ft1fll ~ ~ ~ ~ \iJmT t ~ ~

9

~ ~ ctmf4\\'iit .,l <t; ~ * f$'Qr ~ ~ ~ ctmhil.\il"11 t11:a~~ fltR lPf ~ 1:'RT

...,.~,

(3)

~ ~ ~ ~ p ... .,~.,. ~ '4R ~ ~ ~ em .. 'qlf ~ """i.., ~ ~ ctSI¢41~ ~ ~ umt ~I

~~. '1f1"'q ~ ~­~ vnr. ae.,aor

~-'t: 3flR~lFf~/ ~.

~~~. ~~. ae.,•r

~L1~A -

~ (i(lsutc; ~ lR'lll ""'~tl¥ / ~

~~~. ~~. Ci'l8"1'dtl

( ...,., qe.,l4ctS ) ~ lFf ~ /31RRr. ~ ~ ~. ~ Vttw.

(if • .,.,

~~ ~"lFf~. ~\ih/ ~.

~~~ ~riw.~

10

• (il{ ~0

1

1. .. . --2. :

I 3. I

'PI "flo . 1 !

1

2

i '3

:

-· ~liD

1 I

1

2

<r'f~~~~ ~ ~'<ii'1J< ~. 4it'l'<t'l~'<. 4:::.Ji?i....,':4~ctl.,.~C!

\iFJ"CR ~ I ~~

2 3 (t('! '(( ... ~'( 1 ' J --

. ('!{§! ( .,~~ 17 i

I I .. ~c 234.

WI' 252

- -~ 1Jro ~ 2 3

tl <'I'W 1 ~ '< 1

;:r 1.2

227 ,..,. ~ 240

'\iFNl\ ~ 'll'rel' -- . 2 3

~~11~..: 5

l'tl?l ·:n..,c: 7

mTr '

12 . ·--· ·-- -·- '

... ~ ": imm {tD)_l a.noo .

165.048 . I

·-3669.594

~ ---1 --3842.642

CA' ~-ifiT "'?I 'iH'I {Sii) j

4

8.000 ·-129.764

3639.269 .. ... am.ooa

CA l<ffitr· ifiT 111~~ t'! (t.o) • 4 .

.. 35.28'1

30.325

65.609

f - -- -/"1 ~-- - ~ -·-- oJ-J.

·---:1~1~ ~-

y

11

v -·

2 3

10

10

12

<6 l'l' Oj Cj) 2

~~ .70 ~~lf't~nf~~ (..,.,'!Jtj ·-<A til-r ~ I ~lfrel I 11'1'~~~~)

1 T 2

'lj8if 11'1' ~ . ... ~ .. -· fi ~ T 3 ::r.:=-.. ..

1. lijlf 3 8JJ48 . 2. 2 12.327

3. -~l!lll~~~~l'~ 4 - 2<4.Ci00

•• ~ 6 46.918 . .

5. 'll<'ll'lm 6 22.795 lmf 21 114.596

~11'1'~.~6~ - .. . ..

6. -~-

' 2.241 .. 7. ~til 6 24.357 .. ~ .. -.

~-..

a. 7 31.794 -- ·-. 8. "''R fj 23.S9S 10. ~ " 10.003 . 11. 1 8.001! -. 12. 17 1e5.()(8

·~ 42 . .

2B6.M7 1fll!r 11'1' flo, 'dFt h. ~illil~l~

13. ~ 1 7.533

14. ~ 19 74.419

15. ~ sa 2067.604 16. ~~'~'~'~ 1 13Ua -17 . flf<jjfi{. 10 2,.,,~

llllT ...

128 2tll8.561

~ 11'1' ~. llll E;t • ., -18. ~ 1 S.!t32 -19. 1 4 .310 2Q. aJJUJit1J(i; 6 91.186 -- - · -21. JJ6l~l\illivt 11 186.357

I ll)1r 19 :115.784

1 ~11'1'~. ~ a 11M . . .. 22. t11('f~'( 29 404.027

+1~) · + 14.00 • 23. lihff 22 137.o80

24. ~ 139 580.219

25. ~ 25 342.115

ll&. ~ 2:5 213.820

27. '1m 10 108.684

ll&. ~"'m 2 10.284

~ - .

29 234 3669.594

<187 :1478.023 ... ~ - ~· • ~ftttnf~!J

'ITe :- 41 ~ il11'1' ~ n'f ~ 'f.'FIT l];ll t I

~vt lU:

13

'tii511"'1if;'- 2 (1) 1JTlf ~ qft '@ w 'dkl-.:t'l <r-1 ~ l9=:i'f ~ ¥=!!

. ?4ill w ~ '!@ 7JreT ~~~It!~~~} . .

1 2 3 "' ~ 'if"'l' ~. "'~ ... ..,.-~ fi ~ " . .

1. ~ .3 8 .04S

2. l'll!'l'll~l ;:pj~ 4 24.508

3. ~ 4 32.445

.~ ·-11 65.001 . . • • . . ~ 'lfif ~. CU'"l<l<t 0 t:l~~\); -· ... .... .

4 . 'fll~l~"( 1 . - . .... . . 2 .241 ,•, I""

5. '<1"'1~ "(1."1 1 6 24.357 - "4 ~ -· .... -·

6. 7 31.794 ~ atl'i!l ;gq;~ ~

·-·· 7 . 6 23.598 8 . ill!l'<illtl 2 5.18El -. -~· ·

9 I" 1 ~·

8 .000 -10. ~'<!11"1):1,"( 12 ·- 129.764

'ltPr 35 224.940

~ lF'J ~' C0J4tull ~. ~('tliJiiiiC:: .. _ .. 11. '11\lll~'< 1 7.533 -· 12. \11 1 "1~'< 19

~ ........ 74.41 9 " -

13. '(1 J., '1 I< 69 1855.509

~ 89 1 937.461

~ lA' ~~<fi. 1[lft R "II'IUJ::t"'

14. ~ 1 3.932

15. 1'11~ /~ "1 " 1" 1 4.310

16. 311 \il'l111:i 6 91 .185

m1T I 8 .... . ······· 99..427 . . .

~ lA' :fi;aacr;, ~- ... ,, ........... fi smft . ·.· .·.·. ·-· 17. ('11 ('1 \1~'( 29 404.027

+ 1 l""'"''"'l • + 14.00 ('iUl$11:1) •

18. ~ 22 137.080 --19. ~ 139 580.219

20. ~+tl'< ~'( 25 342.115 . "

~ "

21. 25 213.620 ... 22. ~ 10 108.684

" .... -23. J'q-:l!QlC 227 3639.269

'$r 478 5439.0'14 - ·-... 01"41'1 621 . 7785.843

~: -

14

mDr dk;ZoR̀r dk vuqeksnu 'kklu ds i= la[;k fjV&493@ 14&02&2008&40 ¼,y½@ 2004 fnukad 27-10-2008 }kjk dj fn;k x;k gSA

lEcfU/kr ftys ds izHkkxh; oukf/kdkjh ls foLrr̀ tkudkjh izkIr dh tk ldrh gSA