View
261
Download
12
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
참여연대 사법감시센터(소장 : 하태훈, 고려대 교수)는 2009년 3월 25일, 이명박 정부가 출범한 지난 해 2월부터 올 2월까지 검찰 인사와 수사, 그리고 수사와 관련한 주요 정책을 정리한 ‘이명박 정부 1년 검찰 보고서’를 발행하였다.
Citation preview
1
MB1
| 2009 3 25 |
1
MB1
31 1 52 1 263 1 694 1 / , 79
3
1 . 1, .
1994 , . , .
, 1999 2003 . 2004 . 1997 . 5 . , , , . , . .
1 180 .
4 1 , , . , . .
, , , . .
, . .
5 , 1 . 2008 2 2009 2. 1 , , 1 ( ) , 1 .
, , . 2 .
51. 1
1. 2008 19 ()
() () 19 .
- - - : , .( 13 )- - - : (, ) , , , ( ) , , , ( 10)- : 1, 2, 1 .- : 1, 2 , 1 ( 8))
6- : , , ( 8)- 1 : 1~8 .( 12)- 2 : 1,2 1,2, .( 12)- 3 : 1~3, , , 1,2 .( 12)- : , , , , , ( 6) .- : , , , , .( 8)- : , , , ( 1 ), , , ( 2 ) .- 1 : .- 2 : .- 1 : , , , , ( 8)- 2 : , , , ( 8)
19 (2009 2009 2
7 1. 19
2008 1
2009 1
2008
9
2009 9
2008 10
2009 11
2008 11
2009 12
2008
10
2009 12
2008
13
2009 13
2008 13
2009 14
2008 13
2009 14
2008 15
). 19 , 2008 ( ) , , , 1, 3, , 2 (2009 2 , , . 3, 1 )
8 2009
16 3
12008 15 1
2009 16 1
22008 16 2
2009 17
32008
16 2
2009 17
2008
17
1
2009
17
2008 17
1
2009 18
2008 17
2009 17
1
2008 19
2009 19
2
22008 20
2009 21
12008
20 2
2009 21 2
22008
21
( )
2009 22
9 2.
2008
2009
1
11
10 ()
9
10
10 ()
10
11
12
11
12
2. 2008 ()
( ) 11 3 , , .
( ) ( ) 41 8, , , , , 1, , ,
10
3.
2008
2009
15
13
14
13
14
13
(
)
15
3
14
13
14 /
() 14 1
13
15
15
14
14
15
15
1
15 1
11 ()
13
11 ()
()
14
13 ()
11
12
14
()
11
13
14
14
12
1 15
12 ()
12
1 14
2
14 1
13
13 ()
13
14
13 ()
4. ( )
2008
2009
3. 2008
- , (), (), , , , , (), - 265 14 251 50 ( )
12
17
21
19
2
20
1
21
5
21
3
21
19
1
20
20
6
4
21
22
2
21
22
5
20
2
2
21
4
22
5
23
()
20
6
17
21
18
1
17
1
20
5
1
2
21
1
17
13
()
21
21
3
17
1
3
17
1
2
20
2
21
1
19
2 20
2
22
1
20
2
3
2
21
20
()
22
22 2
1
20
2
1
2
21
(
) 1
22
1 19
4
2
20
2
2
16
2
3
16
2
1
18
2
19
1
3
19
1
4
19
3
14
5
19
6
19
7
19
2
8
19
2
1
19
2
2
20
6 1
1
18
1 2
2
19
3
20
1
1 19
2
19
1
20
19
20
20
5
1
19
2
20
7
19
16
2
1
19
2
2
20
4
3
20
6
4
20
4
2
5
21
4
6
21
1
21
3
16
15
1
19
2
2
19
1
3
20
3
1
4
20
8
5
21
6
21
2
21
(
)
16
1
19
2
19
2
1
3
20
2
4
20
2
5
20
5
2
6
21
31
*->
16
1
19
2
2
19
3
3
20
4
20
1
5
21
2
21
1
16
2
()
1
19
2
19
2
3
20
2
4
20
2
16
5
21
15
1
17
20
2
21
3
1
16
2
17
1
18
2
19
3
20
1
4
20
5
5
21
2
21
()
21
22
()
22
15 ()
17
20
21
1
16
1
2
17
1
1
18
1
2
19
3
20
1
4
20
3
2
21
2
17
21
3
22
6
22
(
)
15
()
17
20
4
1
21
22
4
15
1
17
20
4
2
21
3
22
27
21
23
15
1
1
16
2
2
19
4
3
20
22
()
16
20
5
23
2
17
18
18
1 8 2
19
()
3
21
4
()
4
22
5
(
)5 ()
22
22
23
3
23
15
17
1
22
5
23
2
17
1
18
2
19
4
3
20
3
4
22
5
22
3
21
3
22
23
()
23
15
()
17
1
21
4
19
2
22
3
23
16
1
19
2
20
3
1
3 ()
23
23
5
16
1
19
1
2
22
3 ()
23
23
4
15
1
18
2
19
3
1
3
22
6
23
23
23
23
16
18
5
22
23
16
21
20
23
17
22
5
23
21
1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2
1 2
4.
1)
2)
3) 1
22
2 1 2
3 1 2 3
1 2
4) 2
5) 3
23
5.
,
/ 1 / 1 /
: , , , / 2008 (, , , ) / / 3()
1
1 () /
2PD ( )
3 (, )
4
24
() ()
KBS ()
2
1 () / () / () / (, ) / () / () / ()/ () / , ()
2 ( ) / ( ) () / / 2005 () / ()
3
12008 () / , , , 2,3 /
25
22008 () () / () / / () / / ()
() /
1 ( , ) / () / PD ()
2 () / (, ) / () / KT () / KTF / /
32008 (, ) / () / / ()
26
2. 1
1. 2. PD 3. 4. 5. KBS 6.
7. 8. 9. 10.
11. 12. 2,3 13.
27
14. 15.
16. , , 17. 18. KT KTF
19. 4.9 20. 21.
22. 23. 24. 5.18 25.
28
1.
1. 2008 4 18 5 2 100 ( ) , , ,
2.
, , 1
- 1 , ,2 , 3 - 4 , 2 ,
3. - 2008 5 27, , , - , , , - 7 16, - 11 8, 5 - 11 24, 5 - 10 2 , 34 , 90 , 1100 50~400 (12 6 70)
4. - 70 - 90 - 1100
29
5. - - , - ( )
6. ,
2. PD
1. 2008 4 29 MBC PD (. , ?) .
2.
- 1 - 2 (2009.1)/6 (2009.2)
3. - 2008 6 19, , - 7 3, 7, , MBC (PD, )
30
- 7 11, 4 (PD, )- 7 16, 1 , " "- 7 24, , - 7 29, , PD
19 - 9, 3 PD - 2009 1 7, 2, , PD , - 2009 2 6( )
4.
5. , . , , .
31
3.
1. , 24 .
2.
- 3 - - ()
3. - 2008 6 20 ,, - 6 20, , - 6 23 ( ) (, ) ( : 1, , 1
, , , )- 7 3, ( ), ' 10 .- 7 8, , 20 - 8 19, , 6 - 8 21, , ' ' 2 . 4 - 8 29, , 24 (2 , 11 , 300~500 )
32
4. - 2- 11- ( )
5. - 1 2009 2 19 10 2 . 23 4 2, 6 2, 100~300 . 100 10 ( 2 )
6. 1 , , ,
4.
1.
2.
33
- 3 - * 1 - 5
3. - 2008 12 29, , 12 29 - 2009 1 2, , - 1 7, , - 1 9, , 2008 7 30 12 29 (10 )- 1 16, ,
* 5 - 2008 12 , ( 5), , .
4. -
5. -
6. , . ,
34
, ,
5. KBS
1. KBS 2008 ,KBS 2005 1 556 , 2448 1892 ( )
2.
- 1 -
3. - 2008 5 14 KBS , .- , 6 17 19, 26 1,2, 3 - 8 12, , - 8 14, ,
35
- 8 20, ,
4. -
5. -
6. , , KBS ,
6.
1. ,
36
2.
- 3 - 3
3. - 9 8, 3, - 9 19, , - 10 13, ( ) 2 (15, )- 10, , ( ) - 10 31, () - 11 7, , - 11 10, () - 11 13, , - 11 19, , 2 - 12 1, , (3, )- 12 19, , 2 - 2009 1 15, 2 24, 3, 4 * 2009 3 6 76
4. *
5.
37
,
7.
1. 2005~2006 ,
2.
- -
3. - 2008 9 , - 11 19, , - 11 22, - 11 24, , - 12 4, - 12 10, - 12 16, ,
38
- 12 22, , , ,
4. - ( )- ( )( )- ( ) ( )- , ( )- , (, )- , ()
5. *
6. , ,
8.
1. ,
39
, ,
2.
(2008), (2009) - 3 (2008), (2009) - (2008), (2009) ( 4 1~2 )
3. - 2008 7 28, , ( ) - 7 30, , 1 - 8 1~2, , - 8 5, - 8 8, - 9 17, *
4. -
9.
40
1. 2004 450 () , 1
2.
- 3 - 2 ()* 2
3. - 2008 2 2, , , 1 - 3 , , ( ) 2( ) - 4 24, , - 5 1, , - 5 29, .:
4. - , (1 , )- , ( 68 , , 3 )- , (2 , 3 )- , 2
41
5. - , 1 : 2008 9 5, 23, - , , 1 : 36, 16
6. , ()
10.
1.
2.
- 3 - 2 - ()
42
3. - 2008 5, , ( ) 2 - 5 - 7 18 .- 7 20 (5 3 8 )
4. - ,
5. - 1 , : 2008 10 10, 24 , 2, 7.650 - 2
11.
1. , , ()
43
2.
- 3 - 1
3. - 2008 2 , , ( ) - 4, , ( ) - 4, , 1 , - 9, , - 2009 1, - 2009 1 12, , () (PG) ( 300 )*
4. *
5. ,
12. 2,3
44
1. , (LG), (), (), () 23 () .
2. * : - ()* : - 3 /1 - 1 / * , : - 3 - 1
3. * ( LG 6 )- 2008 6 19, , - 7 9, , ( )
* ( )- 7 8, 1, - 7 28, , - 8 18, , ( )- 2009 1 29, , 20 ()
* ( , )
45
- 6 26, 1, - 11 28, , - 12 16, , , ( 362 )
* ( , )- 9 2, 1, , .- 12 30, ,
4. - (2008 7 9, 250 , )- - -
5. - , 1 , 2009 1 22, 25 : 3, 172 ,- , ,
5. ,
46
13.
1. .
2.
- 1 - 4 - 4 ,
3. 2008 6 19, 6 30 7 8 , * 4 1 * 1 2009 2
4.
5.
47
14.
1. 2008 2~3 2008 4
2.
- 3 - 2 - * ,
3. - 2008 5, - 2008 7, , - 2008 8 1 , - 8 13
48
- 8 14
4. - , ,
5. - 1, 2008 10 29 21, : , 3, 318: , 1 6: , 1- 2, 2009 1 9, 6, :
15.
1. 2008 1 5% 5 5 .
2.
- 3 - 3 - ()
49
3. - 2008 8 7, ,- 8 8, - 8 11, , - 8 13, , - 8 20, 25, , (20), (25) .
4. - , , ,
5. - 1, 2008 12 5, 22, : , 1 6, 23: , 2 6, 1 5 : , 2, 11
16. , ,
1. , 2006. 2. 20 ,
50
322 , , 242 , 37 , , 2005 6 2005 12 259
2.
- -
3. - 2008 7 , - 9 - 11 , . , - 11 19 , - 11 23 - 11 24 , - 12 1 - 12 2 , - 12 12
4. - (, , )- (, , )- ()- ()- 2008 12
51
*
5. *
17.
1.
, ,
2.
* , , , - -
- 3 - 1 ( ), 2 ((KAMCO) ), 3 (, - )
52
()
3 , 4 44(5)
2 , 3
3 29
26(6)
3
, 2 5(2)
, , 6(1)
LNG , 5 9
6 (, )
3. - 2008 3, ,- 4, - 5 12, - 5 13, 14, 15, , , (KAMCO),
4. - 30 , 82 , 168 .
()
53
, 4 (5)
, IT 1 2(1)
, 1(1)
1 , 2 3(1)
1 , 4 5(1)
4 4(4)
2 3(3)
2 2
5 5(4)
2 , 1
3 , 1 4(3)
PF 2 , 2 4(2)
5 5
2 2
2
6(2)
2
1
()
, 2 5(2)
7(5) 2
54
()
4 5(4)
1 1(1)
3 , 3 6(3)
5 5
IT , 3 3(3)
,
23(7) 5
, 15
, 4 5(1)
1(1)
, 2 13(3)
, 10
2(2)
,
3 , 5 8(3)
5. (1 )- (, ) (2008 12 18)
55
- (, ) (2008 11, 23, )- 2( ) (2008 10 16, 27, )
6. 6 , .
18. KT KTF
1. KT KTF
2.
- 3 - 2
56
3. - 9 22, , KTF ( ) - 10 16, , KT - 11 5, , KT ( ) - 11 7, , , ( KTF )
4. - KT ( )- KTF ( )
5. - KT , 1 , 2, 4, 27, 200: 2009 2 12, 25, - KTF , 1 , 3, 2428 : 2009 2 12, 25,
19. 4.9
1. 2008 4 9 , ,
57
2.
, , 1
, , : - 2 - 1 - () : - 3 - 2 - () : - 2 - 1 - ()
3. ( ) - 5 30 , , , , - 9 20, , - 9 26 , , () , ()()() , () , ()()
, () * 2009 1 5, , ( ) . 1 ( , , , )
- 2009 1 20, ,
58
4.
(, 08.9.29), (, 08.7.18), (), (), (, 08.5.30), (, 08.9.22), (), (, 08.9), (, 08.10.9), (, 08.10.7), (, 08.9.26), (), (, 08.9.22), (, 08.9.26), (, 08.5.30), (,08.9.29), (), (, 08.5.30), (), (,08.9.30), (), (), ( 08.5.9), (), (, 09.1.20), (), (, 08.9.29), (), (, 08.9.30), (, 08.9.29), (, 08.9.26), (, 08.8.28),()
( 08.7.17), (, 08.5.9)
5. - 1 80 - 1 80, 2 50() - 1, 2, 3 () - 1, 2, 3 400() - 1, 2 1(3 ) - 1 80 - 1, 2, 3 500() - 1, 2, 3 16() - 1, 2 90 - 1 8, 2 - 1 70 - 1 500, 2 300 - 1, 2 80 - 1, 2 80
59
- 1, 2 16 - 1 80 - 1, 2 150 - 1, 2 10, 2 - 1 70() - 1 50 - 1, 2, 3 150() - 1, 2, 3 300() - 1 2( ), 1( ), 2 2( ), 6( ) - 1 90() - 1 3, 250(), 1(), 2 3, 150(), 1() - 1 80 - 1, 2 80 - 1 50 - 1 70() - 1 80() - 1, 2 - 1, 2 300 - 1 50 - 1 500 - 1 80, 2 30
60
20.
1. 2008 7 () ,
2.
- 2 - 1
3. - 2008 9 29, , - 10 7 , - 12 11 , 5 - 12 15 , M - 12 16 , (18 )- 12 17 , - 12 19 , - 12 22 , , 5 - 12 24 , - 12 30 , . - 2009 1 1 , , - 1 7 , - 1 12 ,
61
: , 1 4 .: , 9 : , 6 1 - 1 22, , ( ) 13
4. - , (, , )- , - , - 6, , 13
5. - , 1 : 2009 3 10, 150 ( 21, ): 1 : 4 -
6. ,
62
21.
1. (6) 2008 4 ( ) (28) 35
2.
- 2 - 1 - ()
3. - 7, , , - 9 5, , 28 4 25 , 4 (1 )
4. - , 28
5. - ,: 1 , 16( 1,
63
6), 2008 10 17, 21, : 2 , 1( 8, 4, 2009 1 15, 2, - ( ): 1, 60~80 , 50~100 (), 2008 10 17, 21, - 4( ): 1, 4~8 , 2, 200~600 , 2008 10 17, 21, : 2, , 6, 1, 200, , 4, 1, 200 2009 1 15, 2,
22.
1. 2009 1 20 4 2 5 50 , () 5 1 24 , .
2.
64
- 1 (2009 ) 6, 1 * 3
3. - 2009 1 20, , , , 22 - 1 22 5 , - 1 23 - 1 24 - 1 25 - 1 28 (30 )- 1 30 - 1 31 - 2 3 , - 2 4 , , - 2 5 9 - 2 6 5 - 2 8 5 - 2 9 : 5 , 15 , 1 , 6 ( ): , : 7
4. - 5 , 15 , 1 (6 )- 7
65
5. -
6. ,
23.
1. 2008 2 23 , ,
2.
- 2 - 2
3.
66
- 2008 8 28 , ()- 11 17, , ()- 12 4 , - 12 23 2, ( ) - 12 30 .
4.
5. 2 5 , , 60
24. 5.18
1.
67
() 5.18 5
2.
3. - 2008 7 31 - 10, - 10,
4. -
5. ,
25.
1. 2000 6.15 2000 10 21
2008 9 27 ( ) 24 , 4
68
5 .
2.
- 2 - 1
3. - 2008 9 29, 1, 5 ( , , , , )(30, 4 , 1 )- 10 24, , , 4 - 12 2 5 ()
4. - ,
5.
6. , ,
69
3. 1 ()
2008 1 2009 2 () , () . () , () .
, .
70
2008. 3. 19
, , , , , , , 2008. 4
, 1 1 (2009 2 )2008. 5. 7
, , 2008. 5. 12
, (), 20 *
71
11 10% 33, 250 2008. 5. 26
, , , , 2008. 5. 27
, 3 () , , , 3 2008. 5. 29
, * 9 5, 1 2008. 5. 30
, , , , 2008. 6. 8
, ,
72
2008. 6. 20
2,3 * LG (6 21), 4 (8 18), (12 16)* 2009 2
2008. 6. 20
() , () ,
( )
2008. 6. 20
, * 6. 20 , 2008. 6. 23
, , 1/, 1/, , , , 2008. 6. 23
, PD 2008. 6. 24
73
, , ,
, . 56 2008. 6. 30
, , 2008. 7. 8
20 2008. 7. 16
, , 2008. 7. 20
2008. 7. 22
, , ,, , ,
74
, , 2008. 7. 28
2008. 8. 1
BBK , 2 2008. 8. 11
, 2008. 8. 14
2008. 8. 20
KBS 2008. 8. 28
()*11 17 ()2008. 8. 29
24 2008. 8.
, * 5.18 ,
75
(2008.10) 2008. 9. 3
, , 2008. 9. 6
, 28 ( 24, 4)2008. 9. 8
, 2008. 9. 9
, , . 2008. 9.
, 3 , 2008. 9. 26
, * 2009. 1. 5
76
., 1 2008. 9. 29
5 2008. 10. 31
60 , , .2008. 11. 3
, , 2008. 11. 4
, , , , 2008. 11. 7
77
, 2008. 12. 2
, 2008. 12. 3
, ()2008. 12. 29
, , , (), ()2009. 1. 2
, , .2009. 1. 7
, ( ) *1 9 2009. 1. 7
PD
78
PD 2, . * 6( ) 2009. 1. 12
, , 2009. 1. 20
. 8 13 2009. 1. 21
, 2005 2009. 2. 9
, . 6 , 15 , 7 , 2009. 2. 11
, 2008 12 29 , 12
79
4. 1
80
1, 5
()
I.
1 . 1 . . 30% . 3 1 , . , , . , , . 1 . , . . , . 1 . 1 1 .
81
. , . 1 . , PD, , , KBS , , . 1 . 5 1 . , . . , . , . , . 2009 . . , , .
II. , ,
1. 6 . . .
82
. 2005 10 . .
2. 1 3 . . . , . . . . . . GDP . . . . . . , , . 2008 . .
83
7, 80 . . , . . 200 . . . 5 PD , . .
3. 1 . . . 60 (2008.10) . . , . 2009 , .
84
. . , .
III.
1. 6 . . . 6 . 6 . . . , , . .
2. 1 . , . . . . . . . . .
85
, . 1 . KBS . . . . (2008 12 29 ) , . 2009 1 3 , 12 29 , 1 5 12 . 11 , . , PD, . , .
IV.
. . . . . .
86
. 3 .
V.
2008 10 60 . 20 . 60 . 10 . 60 . 20 . , . . . , . . . , . . . 7 . . . . . . . .
87
. . . . . . . . 60 , . . . . . . 1 .
VI.
, . 8 . . , . . . , . . . . . .
88
.PD . PD , 10 . . . . 6 . . . . . 6 . . . 442 .
VII.
. . 5 . . 6 . . . . . , . . , .
89
. . . . 1 . MB 1, .
90
,
(, )
1.
2008 1 . 10 1 . . .1) . . . . 1 MBC PD , , , KBS , , , , , . , ,
1) 2004 9 (IPA) . 2003 10 2004 5 8 50 . . . .
91
, , . . . , , . . . . 20 . - 2) - . . . . . 2009 10 . . . 1 , MB 1 .
2) 1 . . , , , . .
92
2.
MB , , . . . MB . . MB YTN KBS . . MB . 8 12 KBS 8 20 . 2005 1 556 , 2448 1892 . KBS KBS . KBS . ? KBS 1,892 ? KBS , . .
93
.MB MBC PD . . . MBC PD . MB MBC PD , PD . MBC PD 7 29 PD 19 . MBC . PD . MB . MB . MB . . , 8 29 24 . . 2 11 80
94
. , , . . , , . . . . MB , .3) , . ? ? , ? .
3) 2008.11.3 . .
95
. . MB () . , ,, . . . . MB . .
3.
. MB . . . 30% , . . .
96
.MB . , . 5 1 . , . . . 13 . () . . 10 60 . . . . . 2005 7 2008 10 , , , , , , , 38 9 .
97
. . ? 9 ' 60 ' " , " " ." . . . . MB . .
4.
MB . , , GDP 1% . . . . . .
98
. . . . . . 2009 . , . . . . 2005 3 . 2009 . . 200 . 8 . ? ? MB . 1 , . .
99
. . , , . .
5. MB 1
MB 1 . MB .. . . . MB . BBK . ? ? ? ? . . 13 . . .
0%, 02-723-4251 www.peoplepower21.org 02-723-0666 blog.peoplepower21.org/Judiciary