Kassian-Yakubovich 2007 Telibinu

7/29/2019 Kassian-Yakubovich 2007 Telibinu

1/32

!A>J696 I?$>.E2> @< '296=6;A '

92D26.??6.;!


2/32

1*=*.&88.&3A1>&0:'4;.(-

"*(&3431>,:*88&'4:99-*(439*394+9-*2.88.3,5&794+9-*9*=9':9(42

51&.398&'4:98(4:7,*89-&9'*+*119-*1&3)4+&99.&3)&99*2598&98*1+/:89.+.(&9.43&7* &243, 9-* 5488.'1* 945.(8 9-&9 (&3 '* 8:,,*89*) 43 9-* '&8.8 4+ 9-* 49-*7

57&>*78-*2&.35&794+9-*57*8*7;*)9*=9-4*79-&923 94 9-*

:3,4)4+*84549&2.&3.385.7&9.43'*143,.3,94-*97&38+*74+*5

.9-*98 +742 9-*&'>143.&3:3,4) 94 9-*:3,4))*884+&99.(47.,.3&997.':9*) 94:7E.1. *(43) 9-*57&>*7 94*1.5.3:2&0*8& 7*(:77*39

7*+*7*3(*949-*6:**3&3)9-*57.3(*8.3(*:7E.1.4:3,&,*'>-.8:3(1*&99:E.1. )4:'9 9-&9-*-&)&34++.(.&157.3(.5&1(*,.99$%&88.,3*)&8=

7*57*8*398&574949>5*4+:7E.1.B857&>*7949-*:3,4))*884+7.33&


3/32

>;H252E#

"18>5-8>;,87,5>;H252*7-12


4/32

6/A/3+


5/32

=:J252H;!:*A.:


6/32

3->-1)991)5E3?)%)2;*6

J

K&'>

$-)*9:)15.864:0-15:-878-:):1


7/32

[email protected]=43&8)351).-2-06

!!#!$

!!

A

B

#$!#$ !!AB

!#$!

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

(!#$!A!B

9#??$AB#

$ !!#$

AB#$

#!$"#$ :#$!

!

A

B

#$

#$A

B#!$

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

9??#;;$

AB#!$

#!$


8/32

0*:*.&66.&2>0;&!&/8'39.(-

#$C

D)B

CD#

$ #$#$1!#!$ #!


9/32

85F/0/C65(:+573!+0/4/28!

C ""A""9"

C ""A"G

H

%&%&C *E!"""""""AAC !99>E!GH%&

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

C !"""%"&C ""%&

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

C ""AA"C ""*

G

H

C E"""

C ""=

E

C " BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 7.++*-+

6#

"%E@& @%""""& E;;E

G

H%E!EAE!&

G

H

%""&

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

""AE


10/32

2,>,0(990(4F2?($(1;)5


11/32

74C+.+>54#;'461'.+2+07

1(9+06'4524+0)A@5''%1//


12/32

3,?,0(::0(5B3@(%(2;/6-.9(05=05,:*(;;3, :/,,7(5+4(5

205+G0=,;/,4(4(5D:=(30(5;)(;;3,9,(+@+0=05,>,(765G


13/32

#B?P7:7K@&?/F3?A=)3:7>7


14/32

60B04,==4,8G6C,),[email protected]

1980,==?70=>3,>?30$?829//0==91

30!094>>4>024.,68934=:948>980=39?6/:A9 69.4 ;?9>0/ ,-9@0 JA30>309C ,8/398930$?829//0==9130=,70.6,?=0/4@4=498%3019?30 :,30 :30 $?829//0==91>30>470A308911804>0 $M H79?8>,48=I /,>69. :6 =39?6/ -0 39?23>303,:69239?>>30@04.,648>30148,6=4289..?3/?:64.,>0=>4=64506C>3,>>30974==49891>30@04.,6A,=:?,648>30:92>301,.>>3,>-9>3=.?,66C,..0:>0/4>=?220=>=>3,>,>60,=>98091>307/4/89>3,@0,1?66.977,8/91>30/4,60.>48A34.3>30:


15/32

@=L474G>#=,D0=?:&074;49@&

A,?4:9,7 >@114C:1 7484?0/;=:/@.?4A4?D,9/ >:/4110=09?9:849,7.7,>>0>.:@7/@>0

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


16/32

71C15->>5-9H7D-*-6@.:A5/4 :=FI>4=591J-8:=13191=-7/:9/1;??4-9F!$I?18;71J/2:2291="%+,4:70>?41/:9?=-=D:;595:9C=1-0>FB5?4?41-=/4-5/;:>>1>>5A1/75?5/ &41 7-?1>?05>/@>>5:9:25??/-9.12:@90 59:2291=-9017/41=?%8;-=-?5&41-@?4:=> =18-=6 ?4-? ?4181-9593:2 ?45> 71C181/-9:2?19.1/-;?@=10.D?419375>4-0A1=.>I41=1.DJ-90I41=1B5?4JK5905/-?593?4-??41-/?5:9:=>?-?11C;=1>>10.D ?41;=105/-?1/:59/501>B5?4 ?418:819?:2 >;11/4:=B=5?593L 9 ?45> /->1 5? >1=A1> 1C/7@>5A17D >?D75>?5/ ;@=;:>1> >59/1 ?41 @>-31 :2 ?419375>4 ;=1>19? /:9?59@:@> ?19>1 -;;1-=> ?: .1 >@225/519? ?: /:9A1D ?41 >-8181-9593 &41 59A1=?10 B:=0 :=01= :2 ?41 ?D;1 !!'

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


17/32

A>M585J?">-E1>@;%18513->010 -? -: A:/4->-/@1>5F10 :;9-// @41?1->/4-5/2;>9?01>5B102>;9-061/@5B-8-:0?@19??11">5:?1A@$322-:0(-@75:?$>;:-??1>22%41?/>5.1;2&>19%45?4E


18/32

82D26.??6.:H8E.*.7A/;B605

'528;4;4>.9F%3;>I4;81J?5;A81/2.1121@;+";

F?64:.:1";?64: '52?5.@A:.@28EC21;:;@7:;CC52>228?2@56??5.2;:8EF.:1F.>2 86?@21@52 8.@@2>6:#??G8@2&A92>6.:.8;:4?612@52?@.:1.>1F@52>26?.8?;.B.>6.:@KL62F%I4;81J6:2$&/A@6@6?:;@;B6121C6@5.:E>232>2:02?C23.6821@;36:1F%6:.:E&A92>6.:@2D@?.B.68./82

@; A? : .:E 2B2:@ 6@ 6? >2?C5605?22%26@2>[email protected]#'33 '52 16>20@ 6:@2>2@.@6;: ;3 @52 16?0A??21 A0@6;:3;>@292@.@6;:5;C2B2>1;2?:;@2D2>2:12>21.?+"!N 6:[email protected];3 @520;99;:9.@056:4 @5220216:4

:;96:.@6B2:.116@6;:@520;;00A>>2:02;3@52&A92>;4>.1;>12>+"M .:1 @526@@6@2C;>1 ;>12>+"!NC6@56:@52?.92?2:@2:026?96818EA:0;93;>@6:4#:20.:.>4A2@5.@@528.?@:;A:.?212B6.@2? 3>;9 @522D;4>.12> @;.00;99;1.@2@52@60826:@52;?E:@.0@60;4>.@&).@76:?


19/32

"@=N575H>%=-D1=?:(175;59@(

$91 /-9 ?=D ?: -//:@9? 2:= ?41>105225/@7?51>.D8-6593 -918190-?5:9(41

;-=-7717()HH=1-0>*#(,)

")+ , O

P+ *,#"M

$91/:@70>@;;:>1 ?4-?(4->") +*#,/:==1>;:90593?:*#")59(.@??417-/6:2>;-/159.:?4(L>;1-6>-3-59>??41-005?5:9-7*#$91/-9->>@81?4-?(;=1>1=A1> -9 :701= =1-0593 59 ?45> /->1 -90 18190 *#() *# ?:*#()*# G8:9?47D21>?5A-7>H 59:@[email protected]=:2>/=5.-71==:=>://@==59359)->:;;:>10?:):918:=1B:@709:?.1>@=;=5>5932:=-9:?41=1==:=59?4105>/@>>10>19?19/12:=>11.17:B(41=1/:9>?=@/?101-=751=A1=>5:9:2?45>7:/@>B:@70?419=1-0->2:77:B>

*#

*#() ") *#"MI$97D59?417-90:2-??50:?41D /171.=-?1 2:=D:@ ?41 21>?5A-7> >@/4 ->8:9?47D 21>?5A-7> ?41 -99@-7 21>?5A-7>21->?> :2 B59?1= >;=593 2-77 :2 >-/=525/1> -90 :2 59A:/-?5:9>J7?1=9-?5A17D:91/-9>@331>?-?=-9>7-?5:9IK21>?5A-7>21->?>:2?41G/:@=>1:2?41D1-=H:2B59?1=>;=593KJ52")*#5>-01>539-?5:9:2->1;-=-?1=5?@-79:?5019?5/-7?:>1->:9-721>?5A-7>:2B59?1=>;=5931?/ (418-59-0A-9?-31:2?41;=:;:>10=1/:9>?=@/?5:9 5>?41;:>>5.575?D:2 59?1=;=1?593 ?41 >159?1=;=1?-?5:9B1B590@;B5?4

9:=8-75??5?1B:=0:=01=?4=:@34:@??41>19?19/1(418-5905225/@7?D:2?45>=1/:9>?=@/?5:9 5> ?4191/1>>5?D:201-7593B5?4 ?41@9@>@-7/->1-??=-/?5:9*#"M G21>?5A-7>:2>-/=525/1>H=1;1-?10 59.:?4(L 59>?1-0:2?411C;1/?10*#"MB45/4 59?1==@;?> ?41/4-59:23195?5A101;19019?9:@9>(41 :97D /7:>1;-=-7717 ?: >@/4 - ;419:819:9 :2B45/4B1 -=1 -B-=1 5> )& )&) MM(# ) )))")#"!F)!) "!#':HHI=59359?:?417-90:2-??53=:B?4:2 /=:;> A591>/-??71>411;-904@8-9>-90J!#.$9?41B4:71?41>@331>?10 18190-?5:9 :2 :@= ;->>-31 =18-59> - 05>?59/? ;:>>5.575?D .@? 9:? -

;=:A19?41:=D 9:?41=;:59??:.19:?105>?41A1=.-72:=8B45/4;=:.-.7D:=5359-?10-> -;1=>1A1=-?5A1 >/=5.-7 1==:= 2:= ?41 1C;1/?10 G?41D;1=2:=8H /2

#:?*,#/41/610-3-59>?;4:?::2:-A-57-.7159"-59E1=%4:?:-=/45A

&1>?:=10-2?1=C)H 2 -7=1-0D@=91DH> ?=-9>7-?5:9 I?41=1 -=1 2:=D:@ ?41 21>?5A-7> :2 ?41 >-/=525/5-7 -958-7>

+,-90:2?41>@;;75/-?5:9H+,


20/32

71C15->>5-9F7D-)-6@.:A5/4

59 ?41;=1A5:@>;-=-3=-;4 &41 7-??1= 2:=8-;;1-=> 59 ?4191C? >19

?19/1-9059?41;-=-7717;->>-31&'H #@4A17H> ?=-9>7-?5:9 :2 ?41 05>/@>>10 >19?19/1 I2:= D:@ ?41D ;1=2:=8 21->?> 59 ?41 7-90:2-??5F 21->?:2 ?418:9?4 21->?>:2!1BD1-=>-/=525/5-7> :2 B59?1= >;=593 2-77 -90 21->?> :2 =5?@-7 *!

KJ =1 /:==:.:=-?5:9 ?4=:@34 5901;19019? 1A5019/12:= ?41>1->:9-7/4-=-/?1=:2 ?41:221=593>&41-39:>?5/ ?=-9>7-?5:9:2 -> I21>?5A-7> :2 59A:6593 ?41 J ! . >[email protected]>-3-59>? ?41 2-/? ?4-?5?? G59A:/-?5:9H /-9 3:A1=9 ?41 3195?5A1 := ?410-?5A1.@?91A1=?41-//@>-?5A1 '$'$';=:.-.7D:=5359-?10->-;1=>1A1=-?5A1>/=5.-71==:=2:='$G7-900-?7:/>3B45/45>-??1>?1059?41;-=-771759A:/-?5:9'H59& &41>17591>-=1=1>?:=10-2?1=?41;-=-7717;->>-3159&'HH !$K 41=1 -90 +!$K, 59 /:==1>;:90 ?:!$B5?4:@?K59'&HH&41>12:=8>;4:9:7:35/-77D-=1@>@-77D?=-9>7-?10->G05A595?D3:04::0HID:@=05A595?D 5>4:9:=10 -8:93 3:0>J&41=1 5> -7>: ?41 >1/:908-?1=5-781-9593 :2 F G>;5=5?4:701= 05A591 58-31H B45/4 5> ;=:.-.7D8:=1 2=1 &45> >1/:9081-9593 -7>: 25?> ?41 05>/@>>10 ;->>-31 ID:@= >;5=5?

4:701=>-=14:9:=10-8:93?41>;5=5?4:701=>:23:0>JB4571 59 ?4181-9593G3:04::0H5>/:9>5>?19?7D;=:A5010B5?4?41/:8;71819?=-?41=?4-9K59-77?41:?41=5??5?1/:9?1C?>69:B9?:@> "9?41:?41=4-90?412:=8>!$-90!$K-7?1=9-?159?41 >1/:90 81-9593 G>;5=5?4:701=H B5?4:@? 5905/-?593 3=-88-?5/-7 [email protected]=:8;-=1 ?B: ;->>-31> 2=:8 ?41 >-81 ?1C? ' !$% !$K '$' I&41D B577 05>;-?/4 >;5=5?4:701=>-90.=593-77?413:0>?:K-;59@-JA>5.50!$K!'%I&41>;5=5?4:701=>?::65?>?415=;7-/1592=:9?>5? 2:= ?45> =1->:9 ?4-? 5?B->@92-A:=-.71J(1/4::>1 ?41 ?=-9>7-?5:9 G05A595?D

3:04::0H>59/15?>118>?:.18:=1/:9>5>?19?B5?4?413191=-7/:9?1C?:2?41?B:;=-D1=>.@??41?=-9>7-?5:9G>;5=5?4:701=05A59158-31H5>-7>:;:>>5.71&41/4:5/1:2?41/:8;71819?K=-?41=?4-959:@=/:9?1C?B->;1=4-;>5927@19/10.D?41-??=-/?5:9?:?412:77:B593!$K

%11E?1=.:/6%5??17+,22 9 -005?5:9 >11 2@=?41= 1C-8;71> :2 ?41 @93=-88-?5/-7 @>-31 :2 -90 K 59 #=59>!1@?%3


21/32

!@=P474K>$=,D0=?:'074;49@'

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

49-:?3.:9?0C?> &4920=$=,D0=>1:77:B492?3049?0=;=0?,?4:9:1?=,9>7,?0>?30/4>.@>>0/;,>>,20 49',>L'30D;0=1:=81@77D>@->?4?@?0=4?0>=4?@,7>,9/10>?4A,7> 1:=D:@M*0.,99:?,..0;? ?34> ?=,9>7,?4:9-0.,@>0:1 ?30 7,.6:1.:8;0774920A4/09.0 1:=80,9492 J>@->?4?@?0 =4?@,7K0>4/0> ?30 ?B:.:9?0C?>.4?0/49?30;=0A4:@>;,=,2=,;3-,.6>?34>80,9492:97D-D&G%:..@==492 49,[email protected],=>D9?,.?4..:9?0C?:1,9 P?,9@4,9=4?@,7'(()$@3A07?=,9>7,?0>?34>;,>>,20,>L>@->?4?@?0=4?0>.0=08:940>,9/>:92>M-@??30=0,=09:/4114.@7?40>B4?3?=,9>7,?4924?80=07D,>L142@=490>.0=08:940>,9/>:92>M

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

'=,9>7,?4:9J?30D1494>3NK/:0>9:?8,60,9D>09>049?30.:9?0C?:1?34>1@90=,=D=4?@,7


22/32

92E26.@@6.;M9F.+.8B/


23/32

A>N585I?#>-E1>@;&1850108E>1?@;>1@41?1 85:1?-2@1>C45/4->1 5:@A>:>1?@;>10-2@1>&-:0-2@1>&'I22AI22?-:-8@1>:-@5B1 @;+,-? 5:&;:1/-:4-


24/32

6/B/3+==3+8E6C+'+5?,9@3-2

2/67$#+8.>2/=+7/2C:9>2/>3-+67/+8381A+=/@/8>?+66C-+=//7=29A/@//=>2+>9,/.3/8-/>9>2/19.=3=A2+>3=7/+8>2/+-23/@/>23==>+>/9823=9A802/2+>9>2/5381=38-/>2/53813=/B:63-3>6C+>>/=>/.+=>2/6913-+6=?,4/->90389+$2/+>39890 >23=7/+8381> 3=8/-/==+9 6995 09/8=39890 >2/,+=3-7/+8381 F2/+2+>,/>>/=9?/B>+8./.:+==+1/=!9A/+92/+::/./89>+>39890>2/ 39/>2/96.2C:9>2/=3=90++=+8.&362/67$#-988/->3813>> A3>2?


25/32

"DAP8;8LB%A0H4AC>(4;8?8=D(

+4F>D;3 ;8:4 C> BD664BC C4=C0C8E4;H C70C C748CC8C4B1>AA>F43 C74DAA80=

F>A3 8= 8CBA82 B4=B4 KD=34ABC0=38=6 ?4A24?C8>=L

(78BF>D;3 A4?A4B4=CC74?A428B4?0A0;;4;C>C741>AA>F8=6>5::K40A?4A24?C8>=LDAAK?4A24?C8>=L(7DB>=420=7H?>C74B8I4C70CC74CF>;;>20C8>=0=30A4A>D67;HBH=>=HDB0;C7>D67>A868=0;;HC74H20B8C8>= C70C 0;; ;4BB 5>A=0;4E834=24 50;B>CF824 C74?7>=4C82FA8C8=6O 8= O

)&BLL"'>#'


26/32

81D15-??5-:J8E-)-7A.;B5/4$5:/[email protected]@4141-0:;A:5:-$A91>;3>-8E5:35@@5@1C;>0 ;>01> @41 @41 -061/@5B1?9;052E5:3 @4141-0:;A:>19-5:?A:3>-99-@5/-80Q%&& K0152510C1->1:/1;2@4101@1>95:-@5B19->75:305B5:1:-91?5:2>;:@;2@41$A91>;3>-9Q%&&-//;>05:3@;B-:1??18":;9-?@5/;: ?1-@1 =A1?@5;: 5? @41 :-@A>1 ;2 @41 ?;85/5@10C1-5B5-8@45:3C;A80.1@;-??A91@4-@5@>11?1:@?-91@-2;>-?@>;:3->9E.A@@4101 ?A/4-: 5:@1>1@-@5;:?-:-8@1>:-@5B1;:1/-:/;:?501>@4159-35:-@5B14E * +, -//;>05:3 @;C45/4 Q%&& 5? -91@- 2;> K L%41 011?C188C5@4 @45?4E31-?1/53A1 @4-@ -2@1> -88 @41 =A11: 4-0 -B1?@105:@1>1?@5:41>4A?.-:0L??;8501>1/@5;:":@41;@41>4-:0;:1/-:A:01>?@-:0@41?71?C4; ->1 >18A/@-:@ @; ?11 @41 >;E-8@[email protected]:3C1-//1L?-3:;?@5/@>-:?8-@5;:C45/45?B1>E?5958->@;%5?/481>L?MA:031CH4>154:1:0519H/4@53131FI/7@1(-22115:1?-::1?N %41-88188;/A?5:%&LL5?0-9-310+O,D+OO,D+O, L (1/-::;@2;88;C$5:31>5:45?>1?@;>-@5;:;2@418-?@/8-A?1M-:0+81@@41901?@>;E,@419N?5:/1:;B1>.;201?@>A/@5;:.135:?C5@4@;;A>7:;C81031%41-0B1>.K>534@-C-EL?119?@;.1@41;:8E1/;:?@>A/@5;:2;>+1B1:52@45?501-;1-0E.EA>:1E?;914;C050:;@25:05@?C-E@;8-@1>.5?2;88;C10.E-B1>.;201?@>A/@5;:?A/4-? 5?.;>:;[email protected] @4131:1>-8 ?1:?1;2 @41@1> ?3 599;91 @41 /;9.5:-@5;: 5:& +, KC4; 4-B1 >A5:1091L -:0 5.50 C5@4;A@ K-9>A5:10L L +,5?>1?@;>10-2@1>' L (1121> @; >1/;:?@>A/@+, K@-71 -C-EPL41>1-?;


27/32

$DAO8;8!!LB'A0H4AC>*4;8?8=D* 0AA>60=CL A0C74A C70= KC>@D0AA4;L0=3 B> C74?0AC828?;4 270A02C4A8I4B C748=8


28/32

4-?-1)::1)6B4@)&)379-4);1=-+4)1;04)+3.79677*=17): 89787:-, *@ ;0- 4);- 97.7974I= 16 01: ,9).;:758)9- ;0-8)9)44-48)::)/-16"#DD>0-9-76-+)6;9@;79-),1;):.7447>:

D'G('( D

JK'('=)+)6;(

D'( DG

6)6,=-9*:16*4-::16/.795!1,-4D;:-=E1,,4-1;;1;-.795:16*-6-,1+;176:)6,+


29/32

!A>N686J?$>.E2>@;'2869?! IC6:1?J52>2.:1 I>.6:?J 6: @5220216:486:2 >22?2:@.@26@@6@2:;96:.@6B2 .8?C5605 42:2>.86F21 @52 2.>862> [email protected]:16:4'52?.925;81?3;>DIC6:1?J'520;96?;:

C6@5! IC6:1?J6:'?5;C?@5.@C2.>212.86:4C6@5@529;12>:6

F.@6;:;3@52;>646:.8@2D@6:/;@5.:1

'52 ?.920;:08A?6;: 6? 86728E 6: @520.?2;3 + ,

0;>>2?;;@B;C28 62 @52 >2?90;A81/2;:;A:021.?

G ;> @52 16?0A??6;: ;3 .>24A8.>6@62? 6: @52 >23820@6;: ;3

0;:?;:.:@08A?@2>?K:.?.8?@;@2>#&+,.:1;?2;C.:1;?J6?.3;>9A8.602D2??6;:@5.@5.?.8828?246:@5288A.:7.

9E@5 ; K82@ 2B2>E@56:4 6: @52 8.:1 4>;C .:1

;?L2@0?22@529?6:

/2:2160@6;:? .:1 0A>?2?L @@6 128 ;:4>2??; :@2>:.F6;:.82 16 6@@6@;8;46.

+3;>@50;96:4,#:;9A8.?22*.@76:?

>.4;:

D ( )? )?H +,

O(

P

&%"%O

P

(O

(

P

O

P

+,

+",%

-------------------------------------------------------


30/32

0*9*.&55.&2A0:&!&/7'38.(-

G)H

1

GH


31/32

96H/1/D76';+684!+1/5/39!

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

D""

B

B"$"%D"*$G""%D""$">G%D"

I

J"$%

I

J$G%

DAA"IJ"

I"J$"

G


32/32

.(7(,$33,$/:.8$$-5%06,&+ 7 03;;7!

Documents

Kassian-Yakubovich 2007 Telibinu