f l n p o l u y sac n o ~ o p t ~ e f i m e , KaK n o e n e T e B ne- ~ e p 6 y p 1 , C K X H T e BCeM TBM BeJlbMOXaM Pa3HblM:

CeHaTOpaM U aAMHpaJlaM, qTO, BOT: B a W e Cufl-

TeflbCTBO HAH IlpeBOCXOIIHTeJlbCTBO, X U B e T B Ta-

KOM-TO rOpOAe n e ~ p M B ~ H O B M ~ ~ O ~ Y H H C M R ... Aa ecnu 3 n a ~ n rocynaplo n p u n e r c f l , TO c K a m u r e

H r o c y A a p l o : B T ~ K O M - T O r O p o R e m n e e T n e ~ p M a a t r o s n ~ ~ 6 0 6 q u ~ c ~ u i l .

H. B. fozo,ib. Peausop

Bcex nwnefi M o m H o p a 3 n e n M T b H a

nee r p y n n b l . O ~ H H M OT 3TMX CnOB XOWTCR RnaKaTb . A p y r M e - MJIM no- cMeIoTCH ( K O M ~ ~ M R B C ~ - T ~ K U ) , MnM nOXCMyT HeAOyMeHHO I lneYaMM

( K O M ~ A U R , a H e C M ~ U H O ) . HO I IOqeMy Xe JI.JlR ~ o ~ o , ' I R TaK BaXHO, YTO-

6b1 Mbl y3HaJIM 06 3TMX MHTeHUMRX ~ O ~ Y ~ . I H C K O ~ O M, M a B H O e , 0 H e M Ca-

MOM, o n y c T o M , n C~IQHOCTU, q e n o ~ e ~ e ? Korna n O J I r 0 npenapHp)'euIb M C T O P M Y ~ C K U ~ ~ MCTOqHI4K (AH~BHMKO-

m e 3an~c11, ~ K T O B ~ I ~ ~ M a T e p n a n , n o n ~ n ~ ~ ~ n ) M c T a p a e u r b c a c n e n a T b ero npMrOAHbIM JI.JlR cepMaJ IbH0f i MCTOPMA, 3arOHffR CBeneHMff B v a @ b 1 ~ a 6 - nHU, rOTOBR MX JIJW 6 a ~ ~ a AaHHbIX, TO CTaJlKMBaeUlbCfl C HapaCTalOl4MM c o n p o T u B n e H M e M h laTepMana . I.i B n p y r n e n a e u r b orKpb1TMe, YTO nepen T O ~ O G - XCMBble JlIOAM, CO CBOMhlM C Y A L ~ ~ M M , CBOMMK He~OBTOPMhtb lh I l l O C O ~ ~ H H O C T R M U - ~ O ~ ~ O ~ ~ T ~ ~ S I M U , nOpOKaMU U MaJleHbKMMH HeDOC-

TaTKaMII. M TOrfla D H e 3 a n H O B03HMKaeT YflMBMTeJlbHOe M H e 3 a 6 b l ~ a e ~ o e

O U y w e H u e n e p B o r o m u B o r o KoHTaK-ra - nepen ~ 0 6 0 6 p e a n b ~ b ~ f i qeno- BeK, M ~ e f i Y a ~ I T p 0 ~ 3 0 f i ~ e ~ qTO-TO O q e H b BXKHOe. 3 a ~ e ~ npOAOIDKaeulb

pa6ory, M B03HUKaeT MHOXeCTBO npo6ne~, CBR3aHHblX qaUe DCerO C

oUeHK0fi pelTpe3eHTaTMBHOCTI.i MaTepAaJ l a ("H~T, BbI CKXKUTe, a CKOJIb-

KO nPOUeHTOB OT 3~0fi B ~ I ~ O P K I I W a J l M M n0CTYIIaJlM MMeHHO TaKMM

o ~ P ~ ~ o M ? " ) , C MeXaHW3MaMM reHepaJlU3aUUM ( K ~ K , n e p e f i ~ K O ~ L U ~ M ~ ,

C o X P a ~ ~ ~ b M I I e p e n a T b UeHHOCTb ~ H M K ~ ~ J I ~ H O ~ O / Y ~ C T H O ~ O M, C npyroR C T o p ~ ~ b ~ , KaK 1.13 3~0fi YHMKaJbHOCTM MOXCHO ~ 0 0 6 u e M3BJIe'Ib YTO-JIM-

064ee?). HO 3a BCeMM XJIOnOTaMM OCTaeTCR H e 3 a 6 b l ~ a e ~ b I M A3yMne- HMe OT n e p B O r O KOHTaKTa. no 3npaBOMy p a 3 M b I U n e H l ~ I O HenOHRTHO,

qeMy y n M n n n e r r r b c n 6 o n b m e : CaMOMy JIK KOHTaKT)' HIIM c~0efi PeaKUMM

Ha H e r o . B e n b , B C~IUHOCTM, TO 3 n e c b ~ e 0 6 b l q a f i ~ 0 1 - 0 - pasne MCTOPMK

He 3 H m sapa~ee , YTO 3a MCTOYHAKOM CTORT KOHKpeTHble nlonu? He o c M e n M n c R 6 b 1 n e n a T b n p e n M e T o M p e @ n e ~ c ~ ~ CBOM ~ M O U M M , ec- ~ L I O n b l T MHOrOJIeTHerO 0 6 ~ e ~ n f l C MCTOPMKIMU, COCTIBMBUIMMM

~BTOPCKHR KOHTHHRHT WIbMaHaxa "Kasycn, H e nonasan, TO HWTO

non06~0e ncnblTblBaIOT H e K O m p b i e ( o J J H ~ K ~ A ~ ~ K O H e ~ c e ) H3 MOMX K o n n e r Ha 3acena~nnx r a c T o MOXHO 6 b i n o y c n b l m b @ p a n : " 9 ~ 0 Mo-

X ~ T 6 b l ~ b L U ~ R YenoBeKa n H r e p e c H e e , q e M npymk qenoBeK9, nnn ~ e p - MHH: " O X W B ~ ~ H W ~ 6 y h l W ~ b 1 x Y e n o ~ e ~ ~ o ~ " , nnw neuapaqwm: l'Mon 3 ~ ~ a - Y B H ~ T ~ @pa~uysoe XVI BeKa BO ~JIOTW", a T o n K ~ H K AYUM OnHOrO I43 CaMblX YBaXaeMbIX H a U H x ylraCTHHKOB: "Aa BbI YTO, H e no- HnMaeTe , YTO nepen s a M n x n B b r e nun !" . M B OTBeT H a 3TOT "oxHBH- T e n b ~ b l R n a @ O c n - HeH3MeHHblk H p e 3 0 ~ ~ b l f i BOnpOC n p ~ r ~ f i 4aCTH

WaCTHHKOB: "A 3a'le~?". B b l T a c ~ l l e a ~ b H 3 H ~ ~ ~ ~ T H I I , ~ a T e p H m H 3 0 -

BblBaTb II ~ 0 0 6 4 a T b ne~ep6yp1-y H Mwpy o CylQecTBoBaHnH B HCTOPHM

n e ~ p a M B ~ H O B H Y ~ 6 0 6 s n ~ c ~ o r o M O X H o H name AOnXHO (C 3THM Te-

n e p b c o r n a c H b r nown B c e MOM ome ern), HO T o n b K o ecnn 3a ~ T H M CTO-

HT KaKaff-TO BHAHMIR HCCneAOBaTenbCKU u e n b . H a em n P H - M e p e PeKOHCTPYZiPOBaTb T H n MenKOIIOMeCTHOR3 ilpOBWHUWaJlbHOr0 nBOpRHMHa H H K O ~ ~ ~ B C K O # 3nOXH HnH MOXHO nOpaCCy>KAaTb 0 HOpMe

W OTKJIOHeHHH B nOBeneHHH nHYHOCTM B T)' Xe 3nOXy, H a xyA0f i KOHeU,

B K J I ~ ~ H T ~ n O n W e H H b l e AaHHbie B 0 6 ~ n p ~ o e npoconorpa@nqec~oe M c c n e n o s a H n e .

Ho ecnn xe nocnenylouei3 re~epanw3auwn H e n p o n c x o n w T , ecnn ycnnnx no p e n H K a p H a u n n n e ~ p a k i e a ~ o s n ~ a R ~ I O T C R C a M o u e n b m ,

eCnH HCTOPHK ~ Y A ~ T n H U b ~ a 6 n p a T b n o 6 o n b m e WH@OPM~UHM 0 K m -

n 0 M BCTPeqeHHOM HM n e p C O H a X e , TO n O A y Q I 0 3 0 # OKa3biBaeTCR CaM MeTOA MHKPOMCTOPHYeCKOrO, A a H BCRK0I-U AP)TOrO HCTOPHYeCKOrO

HCCnenOBaHHR. Tor~a nyl rUMM 0 6 p a 3 ~ 0 ~ HCTOPHKa MOXeT C'IH- TaTbCR T ~ A ~ @ O H H ~ H KHHTSI.

M TO pasro~op "cpenn CBOHX"; a K o r n a me npnxonmcrr s b r x o n w ~ b

H a 6onee mnpor<ym a y A n T o p n l o , n y c ~ b name coc~o~ruyro ws K o n n e r - n c -

TOPWKOB, H e B K Y C H B ~ ~ I X ewe nnona o ~ n p e ~ a M H K ~ O H C T O ~ H W , TO 3 ~ e c b

HenOyMeHMR 6 y n e ~ Kyna 6 0 n b U I e , H naXe B WlbMaHaXe "Ka3ycn YBHAHT

B n y l r u e M c n y l r a e K o M M e p q e c K o e npennpwrr~we, nonyn~pn3as~lo, no- TaKaHHe BKYCaM TOnnbl .

B o 3 p W a T b H a 3 T 0 MOXHOAOJIm H CO BKYCOM. C O C ~ ~ T ~ C R H a CeHca- U H O H H ~ I ~ ~ ycnex y n y 6 n n ~ n " l l e c ~ n o Bonre" Peso ra6pna~3e: C T a -

n n H r p a 4 c K a R ~ H T B ~ H a @ o ~ e T p a r e A n n MypaBbff , ~ o T e p m u e r o c B o e r o

MypaBbeHKa B 6 0 ~ 6 e x ~ e ! Y ~ a 3 a T b H a BO3pOXAeHne 6 f l o r p a @ H ~ e c ~ o r o X a H p a - KaK HOBOrO, o ~ o ~ ~ L L ( ~ H H o ~ o MeTOAOnOrHYeCKHMH HaxOn~aM&l

n o c n e n H n x neT, TaK H B n o n H e T P ~ M U H O H H O ~ O , n P o B e P ~ H H o r 0 BeKaMu. H ~ ~ O M H M T ~ 0 TaMHCTBeHHOM "MOPMOHCKOM ~ P O ~ K T ~ " , 0 KOTOPOM

BnOnrOnOCa c y n a q a T apXHBHble ~ ~ ~ O T H H K H BO BCeM MMpe ( 3 a Y e ~ 3 T 0

npennpHHMYMBb1M a M e p M K a H q a M M 3 UITaTa m ~ a n o H a 4 0 6 H n H c b

" ~ e p T B b 1 e nyLLIH" HaLLIHx ~ ~ ~ A K o B ? ) . M HaKOHeU, COCnaTbCR H a npo- CTpaHHym 6 ~ 6 n ~ o r p a @ ~ 1 0 BCeB03MOXHblX "Gechichte von untenn, "microstoria", "personal history". l l o c n e ~ ~ ~ k p R n a P W e H T o B , K ~ K

npaonno, o ~ a 3 b r u a e ~ c ~ p e m a w r q w M , s e n b n c ~ o p n o r p a @ w ~ e c ~ a ~ CHTY-

sum, n c ~ o p n o r p a @ n ~ e c ~ a ~ M o n a - TO TO, YTO M a r n Y e c K n A ~ ~ ~ C T B O -

~ a n o H a K o n n e r eue B c o s e T c m e BpeMeHa. M T ~ K , pa30qapo~a~ue B ~ o ~ ~ J I H c T c K W X Monens ix , n p u B n e K a T e n b -

H O C T ~ '"leno~eqec~oro W ~ M ~ P ~ H H R " , K o H e u B e n n m x meR n meono- mW, n o a n e ~ l r r n f i sa co6oR ~ e n d e x ~ o e MenKoTeMbe. Bce TO aepao, HO B AaHHOM Cny.rae HeAOCTaTOYHO. B e ~ b "KOMI~JI~KC ~ O ~ Y M H C K O ~ " ( H ~ ~ O B ~ M TaK 3TOT UIOK, B b l 3 B a ~ ~ b l f i OC03HaHWeM, YTO I lepeA ~o6ofi - msok I r e n o s e K , H poxaamuui4 c T p e M n e H n e K M a K c n M a n b H o n o n H o M y

BOCCTaHOBJIeHHlo STOR3 ' I e n ~ B e K a ) B 0 3 H H K m H Y MeHII, H Y MOWX KOn-

ner He3aBnCHMO OT 3HaKOMCTBa C TpYAaMH Kapno rki~s6)'pra n, B03-

MOXHO, 66111 C B O ~ ~ C T B ~ H HaUMM Ilp~AUIeCTBeHHIlKaM 3aAOnrO no MWK-

ponc-ropnqecicnx n a p a a w r M .

B e c b ~ a n O y q H T e n b H 0 0 6 p a T H T b ~ f f K IIOHCKIM, KOTOPble Ben B 3TOM

H a n p a B n e H H H CTOnb l r ~ k f ~ b l f i HbIHe n.n. K ~ ~ c ~ B u H . B MOHOTPI@HM

"OCHOB~I C P ~ A H ~ B ~ K O B O # penHrH03HOCTH B XII-XIII B e K m n p e U M y -

WeCTBeHHO B MT~J'IHH" (1915) OH AeKJIaPHPYeT CBOlo 3 W a Y y "BbUle-

nHTb, a 3aTeM H3)"4HTb 065em penWrH03HOCTH B XII-XIII BB. OH OCTB-

HeTCR B B e p e 3a BbIYeTOM ee OKaMeHeBlrrHX @ O P M Y ~ , C OAHO# CTOPOHbI,

3a BblqeTOM pe3YnbTaTOB YHCTO ~ O T O C ~ O B C K O ~ pa60Tbl Ha i l He lo , CLIP)'-

r0# ... n p H 3TOM M3)"4eHMlo IlO,&JleXMT H e penHrU03HOCTb TOT0 H n l l

H H O m llpeACTaBHTenR H ~ ~ B ~ H H O ~ I 3nOXU, BenHKOrO HnM M U O r O , a pe- nHrH03HOCTb LLIWPOKMX KpyrOB, KOTOPaR IlpORBJlHeTCR W B B e n H m X , H

B ~ a J l b l ~ " I . %O niUI0 BOJMOXHOCTb mBOPMTb 0 eNl nPMOPMTeTe B M3YqeHHW

" M ~ H T ~ J I ~ H O C T H " ~ . K O H ~ ~ H O , B W e T b B HeM nPOB03BeCTHHKa UKOJlbl

"AHH~JIOB" H COpaTHHKa M a p ~ a 6 n 0 K a H e 6onee O ~ O C H O B ~ H H O , YeM B Cn)"4ae C TBOPYeCTBOM B ~ H C T ~ K ~ H T O ~ O B H Y ~ ~ , - CnHllrKOM pX3JIW'IHblMli

6 b i n n MeTOflOnOrHYeCKHe H MHPOB033~)DleCKMe YCTIHOBIUI. OAH~KO OpHeHTauKH H a H3)"4eHHe KOMeKTHBHbIX penHTH03HblX n p e ~ . ~ ~ a m e ~ H f i

BnOnHe OYeBWlHa. %OM)' Xe cnoco6crsye~ BBeAeHHOe K ~ ~ C ~ B M H ~ I M no- HRTIle " C ~ ~ A H I I ~ ~ Y ~ ~ o B ~ K " , ~epeKJIMKaloI4eeCR C " H n e i U I b ~ b l ~ H TMna- MU" Be6epa. n l o 6 0 I l b i ~ ~ b l f i llapa@pa3 MOAHOMY HblHe " W ~ K n l o Y ~ ~ e n b -

H O W H O P M ~ ~ H O M Y " MOXHO H&TH B KaPCaBHHCKOM nOHIITUM " T H ~ H Y ~ - ~mfi 'len0BeK". CK)AI OTHOCRTCR BbIJlaloIUHeCR nMqHOCTW, KOTOPble

OKa3blBaloTCII 0~060 nOne3HblMH H Y ~ ~ O ~ H ~ I M M NIR n03HaHMII CpeAHerO.

"B HMX ~a n n ~ H H ~ H Y e p T a n o c T n r a e T s b r c l l r e r o H a n p m e H m n P ~ ~ B H T ~ ,

a CJlenOBaTenbHO - H H ~ ~ ~ H A H o c T M " . ~ O A O ~ H O ~ 3aMeYaHHe IIOBTOpRnOCb

M IIOBTOPReTCII CTOPOHHWKIMW MHKPOHCTOPHYeCKMX nOAXOLlOB - HO Tpy-

n H 0 H e 3aMeTHTb, YTO H B AaHHOM Cnylrae n e B TOHOB HOB MY OTHloAb H e

CKnOHeH yBJleKaTbCR YHMKmbHOCTblo Ybefi 6b1 TO HM 6 b ~ 1 0 JIHYHOCTH.

y R H H R " e c ~ b H HeKOTOPble TOnbKO eMy n p H C m H e Y e w . HO OHH HaC H e 3aHHMaloT H H e BXO.IIJIT B 0 6 n a ~ T b HaUIerO H ~ ) " ~ ~ H H R " ~ . M KaK 6b1 HM

OUeHMBaTb B3~JlRAbI H MeTOAbI er0 B TOT IIepHOn, e M y BnOnHe MOXHO ne- P e w p e C o B a T b T e YnpeKM B O ~ ~ ~ ~ M ~ ~ H H O C T H , KOTOpbIe 6pocam~ C ~ R Y ~ C He TOnbKO COIlHiUIbHblM HCTOPHKIM, HO H WCTOPMKaM M ~ H T ~ ~ ~ H O C T ~ # .

?pornno B c e r o n n r b ner (HO KPKMX ne~!), w 80 " B n e n e ~ H M * M C ~ O -

P M m HBnXBrneMCX, no 3 a M b l c n y a a T o p a , p y r < o ~ o n c ~ ~ o ~ DX HaqMHa- mqero MCTOPHKa, aKUeHTbI yxe p a c c T a ~ n e ~ b 1 MHaqe . K a p c a B M H ~e OT- Ka3bIBa:TcR OT CBOHX ~ ~ O ~ H M ~ I X A e T M u - OT "cpen~ero q e n O B e K a sno- X M " M TMnMqeCKOrO q e n ~ ~ e ~ a " , HO OHM 3aHMMamT B era HO*" cMcTeMe n o n o x e H M e XBHblX a y T ~ a f i ~ e p o B . 0 ~ u x ynOMXHyT0 6 y ~ ~ W b - H0 Ha n O c n e n H M x CTPaHMUaX 3 ~ 0 h 6 p 0 m I O p b 1 M rOBOpMTCX B C K O A ~ ~ ~ ,

~ Y X O G O T C ~ I ~ K O # K K H H r e 1915 r. A B ~ O ~ a n e p B y m O q e p e A b 3 a H H M a e T MbICnb COBCeM MHOrO pons:

' M C T ~ P M X Msf l aeT eAMHM' l~b1f i ITpOUeCC PlJBMTHX BO B ~ e f l t!I-0 KOH- KPeTHOCTH W ~ A M H H ~ H o c T M H e KaK 3 K 3 e M n J W p pa3BHTMX p O n O B O r 0 M H e

KaK ~ o f l ~ ~ o f i MnM o 6 u ~ f i npOUeCC, ~ ~ O X B J ~ X H > ~ H ~ ~ C X B qaCTHbIX M XU- ~ X K ) U I M ~ ~ C X m X HHX " ~ ~ K O H O M " ... 0 6 % ~ ~ MCTOpMqeCKOrO HCCneAOBa-

H U H B c e r n a n p e n c T a B n X e T ~06010 H e K o T o p o e o p r a H u q e c K o e enMHcTBo

KaK T a K o n o e , OTnMqHoe OT O K p y x a w u e r o n B C B O ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ U H c B o e M He- 3aMeHMMOe - HenOBTOPMMO ~ e ~ ~ b 1 f i MOMeHT P ~ ~ B U T H R , ~ .

M H ~ I M M CnOBaMM, r -H ~ O ~ ~ M H C K M ~ M O r 6 b 1 6 b 1 ~ b U e H e H &JIX n b ~ a H n a ~ o ~ o n ~ q a c a M no ce6e, a B o B c e H e KaK qacTH61fi cnyqah n e f i c ~ n ~ n m 0 6 W l b ~ b l x 3aKOHOB M H e KaK 0 6 ' b e ~ ~ m X r e H e p a H 3 a U M M . b0nee TO-

r0, H a q M H a l o u I e M y MCTOPMKy TaK n p X M O U PeKOMeHnyeTCX 3aHXTbCR M3YqeHMeM T I ~ ~ H er0 n)WJM B n e p B y I O O q e p e n b : " ... ~ ~ ~ A M ~ T O M MCTOPMM

XBnHeTCX M3y' ieHHe COUMWlbHO-nCMXH9eCKOrO n p 0 U e C C a . ~ O H H M ~ H M ~

e r 0 , KaK M nOHMMaHHe V)'Xofi AYUlM BO3MOXHO TOnbKO n y T e M C O n e p e -

XMBaHHn MnM BXHBBHMX B H M X " ~ . B ~ Y B C T B O B ~ H U ~ (Einfuhlung), C o n e -

PeXMBaHMe n e X M T B OCHOBe MCTOpUqeCKOrO MbIl l lneHMR, n 0 ~ ~ p e n n n X

3TyneKJIapaUMKl CCbInKaMM H a MHeHMe C ~ M O H O B ~ ~ ~ W H X no TeM B p e M e -

H a M 3 w ~ ~ e m H A H ~ ~ T ~ X , K a p c a ~ w ~ K a T e r o p u q e c K u H e cornaceti c C Y ~ L ~ K T M B M ~ M O M n O C n e n H e r 0 . C Y ~ L ~ K T H B H ~ I ~ n e p e X M B a H H R M CBMO-

O q y q e H M e MCTOpMKa HMKOMM 06pa30~ H e A O n X H b I OTBneKaTb OT man- HOrO: " P e q b MneT H e TOnbKO U H e CTOnbKO 0 C ) ' ~ ' ~ ~ K T M B H O M I I e p e X k i ~ a -

HUH MCCJlenOBaTenX, HO 0 P e m b H O M nPOHMKHOBeHMH B A ) W J ~ B H ~ I ~

npouecc, nO&rlMHHOe CnHXHHe C HUM, KaK 661 H H H a 3 b I B m O C b TaKOe

BrnMnaHMe B qyxw ~ ~ n ~ ~ u n y a n b H Y l 0 MnM KOIUIeKTHBHYIO nymy". " H ~ C O M H ~ H H ~ , TO, M3yYaX n a ~ ~ b l i i K O H K P ~ T H ~ I ~ ~ ~ P O U ~ C C , Mbl no- CTMraeM CTpOeHHe e n H H O r 0 M C ~ 0 p U q e C K o r o f l P o U e c c a KaK e n M H C ~ n a .

n o c T M r a e M H e n y T e M oTBneqeHMX OT n a ~ H 0 f i KOHKPeTHOCTM, a n p e ~ BXMDaHMX B CaMO 3 T 0 ~ A H H C T B O " ~ .

K ~ K O p r a H M 3 0 B a T b 3 T 0 " B X H B ~ H H ~ " , MOXHO TOnbKO n O r i i n b 1 B a ~ b ~ X .

BOJMOXHO, TO 6 b 1 n a A a H b MHTYMTMBM~MY - B e n b Fmnera K ~ P ~ ~ B H H ~ n . M . 6 M u ~ n n ~ 3 an~cm ero B s a n n n b l e cTOPOHHHKU 6 e p r c o ~ a ~ . M n e k c ~ B M T e n b ~ 0 , MHTYMQMH MCTOPMKa KapcaBHH oTnoAMT 6 0 n b ~ y ~

p O n b . HO 3TO H e ~ a ~ o e - T O B p O W e H H O e KaqeCTBO. T ~ M nee ~ ~ ~ T O H O -

B M ~ H n p M n n e K a T e n e H Ann H a c , TO OH H e 661.~1 qMCTb1M MeTOnonot-OM

MnM M c ~ o p ~ o c o @ o ~ . nponenrr M H O ~ O BpeMeHM B a p x M B a x , OH OHM- bran, qTO MaCTepCTBO M C T ~ P H K ~ M eTO MHTYHUHX PO)(CnaOTCX OT TOTO,

qTO OH Y)Ke " K O H ~ W K ~ M M l X l J l b ~ e B " 3 H a e T M a T e p U a , n0m)'XeH B H e r o .

M n o n p o 6 ~ b r e HHCTPYKUHH 0 TOM, KaK nMCaTb WCTOPMIO, eMY, B C W -

HOCTM, H e H w H b I . O T C I O ~ ~ er0 CKenTMqeCKOe OTHOWeHMe K nyPM3MY

" @ ~ ~ H U Y ~ C K H X MeTOAOnOrOB, nbITaIOuMXCR CIIaCTM HaYqHOCTb MCTO-

P U H n p e n ' b X B n e H H e M PMrOpMCTMqeCKMX M 3aqaCTYIO HeBblnOnHMMbIX ~ p e 6 0 B a ~ M f i "9.

HO AJlH " B X M B ~ H M R " B COUMWlbHO-IICWXMqeCKOe enMHCTBO OAHOrO

y I l O p H O r 0 T p y n a U npOTepTbIX B apXMBaX 6 p m ~ HenOCTaTOqHO - H W H O

ewe H e K O e 0 3 a p e H M e : < n p H TIOHMMaHHW 'l)?U0# n y L l I e ~ ~ o # XM3HH KaK

UenOrO, n p M nOCTMXeHHM qw0fi MHnMBMnYWIbHOCTH B ee enHHCTBe

H a K o n n e H u e ~a6nloneti~fi c a M o no ce6e n a e T ewe o q e H b M ~ J I O - MOX-

HO 3 H a T b 0 n P Y r O M BeCbMa 6 0 n b m o e KOnHqeCTBO @KTOB H BCe-TaKH

er0 H e nOHMMaTb. H ~ ~ ~ o T M B , q a C T 0 O n H a K ~ K ~ H - H H ~ Y ~ ~ q e p T a , n X e H e 3 H a q M T e n b H a R VaCTHOCTb: TOH rOnOCa , n B M X e H H e , IlOBOpOT rOnOBb1

H T. n. n03BOJLRIOT C p a 3 y OXBaTMTb M nOHRTb BCIO JIM'IHOCTb, BCIO WHAH-

BMAYZUlbHOCTb 3 T O r o l i enOBeKa , n O q T U q y n e C H b I M A H e O X W a H H b I M 06- p a 3 O M nOCTMqb H ~ O ~ X O A M M O C T ~ er0 BHyTPeHHerO pa3BMTHX, nOAnMHHO

nOHXTb er0. Ta~oe IIOHMMaHMe npyrofi MHAWBWnYaJIbHOCTH B03MOXHO

M I lpM M W O M C HeIO 3HaKOMCTBe, n0 "II~PBOMY B n e q a ~ n e ~ M I O " , HO, KaK

npaeuno, OHO n o r r B n n e T c X B npouecce H ~ ~ ~ I O ~ ~ H H X , o c B e q a r r H o6be- nHHRX n 0 3 H a H M e ~ ~ 0 6 ~ 0 H O T P ~ I B O ~ H O ...*I0.

Y B e p e ~ , qTO M H O r H e H 3 MOMX K O n n e r C 3HTY3Wa3MOM COrJlaCRTCff C

~ O ~ O ~ H ~ I M H H ~ ~ J I ~ o ~ ~ H M X M M . n p ~ q e ~ n e B ~ ~ ~ T O H O B M ~ B n O n H e OCO3-

H a H H O 6 2 J t a ~ c M p y e ~ H a ~ 0 f i m a H M , q T O O T ~ e n X e T HCTOPHKa OT n H T e p a -

T o p a . B 1920 K OH O n p o B e p r a e T A u ~ ~ T ~ H : " K o H c T ~ ) Q ~ ~ o B ~ H H ~ HHOrO

n)'UIeBHOrO IIpOUeCCa no aHaJlOrMU C MOHM M TOnbKO H 3 MOeTO. .. c6nu- x a e T M C T O ~ M I O c n033nefi, HO H e n a e T BOJMOXHOCTH c e p b e w o ome- CTMCb K BblBOnaM MCTOPHM M O ~ O C H O B ~ T ~ ee KaK ~ a y ~ y " " . HO T P H rO-

na CnyCTX, B @ ~ H A ~ M ~ H T M ~ H O ~ ~ U )'Xe KyAa 6onee C ~ O X H O ~ "@M~oco-

(PHM M C T O ~ M H " , OH OXOTHO n e n a e T mar H a B c T p e q y n u T e p a T y p e ,

nOHCHXR BBOnMMOe nOHXTMe " M O M ~ H T B B C ~ ~ ~ ~ U H C T B ~ " : QXOPOLIIHM H

BnYMqMBbIM XynOXHMKaM-POMaHHCTaM, MCTOPWKaM M A a X e q H T a T e n R M

HanHCaHHbIX TeMU M nPYrMMH ~ P O H ~ B ~ A ~ H M ~ ~ H e TpYAHO nORCHHTb

B3aMMOOTHOUIeHMe MOMeHTOB BO BCeenUHCTBe - MbI n 0 3 H a e M YenOBe-

K a H e n y T e M n p O C T O r 0 C O ~ H ~ ~ H H R C B ~ A ~ H H ~ ~ M ~ a 6 n I O n e ~ M f i 0 HeM: no- no6~oe c o 6 ~ p a ~ n e , c a M o no ce6e, c o e e p m e H H o 6ecnone3~0, w n H no- n e 3 H O n H W b KaK CpeACTBO COCpenOTO'-IllTbCX H a qeJ lOBeKe. BO BpeMX

3TOrO C O ~ M ~ ~ H M X , a q a C T 0 H n p M n e p B O M 3HaKOMCTBe "C n e p B O r 0

l l 3 m X n a " MbI BnPYr, BHe3aIIHO M H e O X H n a H H O n O C T H r a e M c ~ o e o 6 p a 3 -

H o e CYIlleCTBO q e n O B e K a , er0 nMqHOCTb. M b t 3aMeTUnU TOnbKO 3TY eTO

nosy, 3 ~ y ero apasy, M R HMX, B no3e M n u apase, cpa3y c x s a T n n n TO, y e -

ro H e Morn.nH ynoRMTb B M t I o r o q M c n e H H b I x npextinx H ~ ~ ~ I O ~ ~ H H X X , ec- nM TaKOBbIe y HaC 6 b m M . M H e cnyWfi~0 n I O 6 0 B b , KOTOPaX eCTb BMeCTe

C TeM H BbICUaR 0 0 p ~ a l l03HaHMX, B03HMKaeT BHe3anHO. O n p e n e n M ~ b ,

n e p e n a T b c n o n a M M c x o a l r e l l H o e H a m L ' ~ e q ~ ~ " M ~ I H e B c ~ n a x , 1 2 .

p a c c o p u B ~ H c b co B c e M l l (a c HaXpanHCTb1Mn ~ a p ~ c H C ~ a M k f , H

q O n O ~ ~ O f i ~ ~ T ~ P ~ Y P I - C K O R npo@eccypofi), a B T o p , ~ ~ ~ n e ~ ~ b l h OT n P H P o n b 1 e n m M K P A T U ~ ~ C K U M YMOM, n o - n p e x ~ e ~ y c H w c x o a n T e n e H K ~ ~ I B U I H M K 0 n n e r a M . A e m a p ~ p y ~ H ~ O ~ X O ~ ~ M O C T ~ M e r o n o n o r u w , CMc-

TeMbI qtX'KUX WCTOPUVeCKHx ~ O H R T N ~ ~ , OH n p ~ s ~ a e ~ , TO y 60nb luHHCT-

B a MCTOPMKOB ( W 6 n e c ~ ~ u 1 . 1 ~ HCTOPHKOB) H e T H e TOnbKO CHCTeMbI no- ~ n ~ ~ f i , HO H CHCTeMbI MHPOB033PeHHH, HO 3 T 0 HM HHCKOnbKO H e Me-

UIaeT. B e n b HCTOPHK AOBOnbCTBYeTCH H H T Y M U W ~ ~ ~ , Ha3b IBaR ee YyTbeM, " n e B k i ~ a 4 A e f i " ~ ~ .

Ynop~oe H e m e n a m e HCTOPHKOB onpenenmb n c c n e n y e M y m HCTO-

~ H ~ e c ~ ~ H H n H B H A Y a b H O C T b , 6 y n b TO " @ ~ ~ H U Y ~ C K W # K ~ ~ C T ~ R H M H " , H ~ M ~ u M ~ H a p o n " MnH "~I IoHHR", " M O X ~ T n 0 6 y n H ~ b TeOpeTMKa MC-

TOP UH K BeCbMa P e I I l H T e n b H O M y UIary. OH CKaXeT, YTO HCTOpHff H e AOJIXHa CqWTaTbCR HaYKOlO, a e C n H XOYeT 6 b 1 ~ b el0 - AOJIXHa YCOBep-

UIeHCTBOBaTb C B O ~ MeTOA. OH, M O X e T 6 b 1 ~ b - TeOPeTHKH 8 0 0 6 ~ e OT-

JIHqaIOTCII KaTeTOPHqHOCTbH) H CMenOCTbH) C B O H X f l e f i c ~ B H f i - B b I f l m a -

e T HOByIo HaYKY. .. MCTOPUKH Xe T e O p e T H K a H C n y l u a T b H e CTaHyT, a 6y- n y T IIpOnOJIXaTb CBOe ~en0"". M T a K y l o 6 e 3 3 a 6 0 ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ b K ~ ~ C ~ B M H H e

o c y x n a e T , n o c T y r r a R c C O ~ P ~ T ~ R M H K y n a B e n u K o n y l u H e e , q e M ero co- B p e M e H H H K (H BO MHOrOM ~ ~ H H O M ~ I U I ~ ~ H H W K ) K O ~ ~ H H ~ B Y A , HaCTaH-

~asurwii H a TOM, TO B C R K H ~ ~ MCTOPWK n o n x e H 6 b 1 ~ b ewe H XOPOUIMM

@ H ~ o c o @ o M ' ~ .

I l o ~ a B c e C K ~ ~ ~ H H O ~ , K a K n p e n c T a s n R e T c R , B n o n H e ITOHHTHO

' I H T a T e m M , 6 n A 3 ~ 1 4 ~ K "Ka3ycy", MbI 0 6 ~ m a e . M I l p H M e p H O T e me n p o 6 n e ~ b 1 . Ho TO x e ~ce- am npousoluno M e m y 191 5 H 1920 rc, n o q e M y flea ~ ~ ~ T O H O B M ' ~ B n p y r yBepOB2Ul B n p H O p H T e T b 1 U3yVeHHR H e -

~ O B T O ~ H M O ~ HHnHBPiAyNlbHOCTH, n 0 q e M y OH OTHbIHe H e ~ O H T C R TOTO,

TO UCTOPHR paCCbIneTCR H a M03aHKY H e CBR3aHHbIX @BKTOB H @IKTI.I-

KOB, I lOqeMj ' OH, 3HaTOK ~ p e n ~ e ~ e K 0 ~ 0 f i @NIIOCO@HH, H e 0 n a C a e T C ~

T e n e p b HoruI . rHanncTI . rqecKorO McKyca? Aeno B TOM, TO B TOT n e p ~ o a e M y OTKPbInOCb B e n H q M e meu A6conm~a K a K B c e e n u H c T s a : " q ~ 0 6 b ~

M O r n H CymeCTBOBaTb p a 3 B H T U e M HaYKa 0 HeM, ~ y 6 ' 6 e K ~ Pa3BHTHR A o n -

X e H 6 b 1 ~ b BCeBpeMeHHbIM U BCenpOCTPaHCTBeHHbIM ~AHHCTBOM. . .

E~UHCTBO cy6 '6e~~a n O J I X H 0 COBMeUaTbCR C M H O T O O ~ P ~ ~ H ~ M ero npo- R s n e ~ A h , 6 b 1 ~ b MI-10rOeAWHCTBOM ...I7 M b 1 n 0 3 H a e M H ~ c e 0 6 u ~ m 3 ~ a - ~ U M O C T ~ n a H H o r o npouecca, H e B c M b r c n e ~ P M ~ H H H O ~ ~ ero CBR3aH-

HOCTH c n p y r H M H , a B C M b I c n e yKOpeHeHHOCTA era B 0 6 m e ~ c ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ - C K ~ M " . ~ O ~ T O M Y H H A H B H A ~ ~ ~ ~ H O C T ~ - n H q H a R H n H K o n n e K T k f B H a ~ ,

HBnReTCR n M U b MOMeHmOM BCeellHHCTBa. Ho 3TO H e M m O , 3TO n p H n a e ~

n m 6 0 ~ y 0 6 ' 6 e ~ ~ y OrpOMHYH) UeHHOCTb. ''B HCTOPHH BCRKOe, name ca-

M O e YaCTHOe HCCnenOBaHl l e B ~ ~ H M O O T H O ~ ~ I ~ H H ~ ~ Mew)' HeCKOnbKHMH

PyKOIlHCRMH O n H O r O HCTOSHHKI CaMO C O ~ O ~ 6yJle~ HCCnenOBaHHeM

o 6 ~ e ~ c ~ o p u S e c ~ o r o xapamepa H BO~MOXHO T o n b K o H a nowe ero CBR-

3 U C n 0 3 H a H H e M L [ e ~ O ~ H O C T ~ COUHNlbHOrO p a 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ f l " 1 8 .

AOCT~TOSHO I I O n W T b C R no OCO3HaHHH 3TOTO BCeenMHCTBa, U MCTO-

PHK O C B O ~ O X J M ~ T C H OT rpy3a ~ e p a 3 p e m u ~ b r x p a H e e np06ne~, C H H M ~

npOTMBOpeqHH o6uero H SaCTHOrO, O ~ ' ~ ~ K T M B H O T O H C Y ~ ~ ~ K T M B H O ~ O .

"ZIepe3 n o c T M m e H H e c a M o r o Y a c T H o r o H o r p a H H q e H H o r o npouecca I I p O H C X O ~ H T npno64e~we H a W e K H e M y H B H e M K e n H H 0 M y 06qewc- TOpHqeCKOMY IlPOUeCCY Pa3BHTMR MnH, B e p H e e , O n 0 3 H a H H e H a M H H a -

UIe rO C HUM H B H e M enHHCTBa. 3 ~ 0 ~ ) XHBOlO CBR3bIO ~aulefi CO BCeM

npOUIJIbIM U CO BCeM COUHiUlbHO-nCHXMYeCIU1M p a 3 B H T H e M H O ~ ' ~ H C H R -

lOTCR 060raue~ue H a U e r O CO3HaHHR B H C T O P M ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ pa6o~e H TOT

HHTepeC , C KaKUM MbI OTHOCUMCR K @ ~ K T ~ M M U H ~ B I I ~ ~ ~ O " ~ ~ .

He 3~a10, KaK MOMX K o n n e r , HO MeHR, H a n p u M e p , B c e TO B n o n H e

YCTpaHBaeT. Aa H I l y T b K ITOCTHXeHHlO 3~0fi HCTHHbI B I l O n H e I lOHRTeH H

nOCTOHH yBXUeHHR. T B O P S ~ C K ~ A pa60~a B apXMBaX BbI3bIBaeT y M o n o -

nor0 HCCnenOBaTeJW Heyf lOBneTBOpeHHOCTb r0CnOnCTB)'K)WHMH I l03H-

T H B H C T C M M H H H ~ p O X . 4 ~ I O ~ H M M C R HeOIl03HTHBHCTCKMMB H H T e p n p e -

T a q H O H H b I M H MOflenRMH. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ B O C X H T H B H H T e p e C K MeHTNlbHOCTH M K

' L H ~ ~ l O q ~ ~ e n b ~ ~ ~ y H O ~ M N ~ ~ H O M Y " , P ~ C C M ~ ~ HCTOPHK H a 3TOM H e OC-

TaHaBJIHBaeTCH, HO B r O n b I COuUNlbHbIX KaTaKIIH3MOB H JIUYHMX HCnbI -

TPHH# n p O n O n x a e T r H o c e o n o r M ~ e c K l l e UCKaHHR H O ~ O C H O B ~ I B ~ ~ T ~ 0 6 - C T B e H H F ~ e ~ a @ k i 3 H q e c K y m CMCTeMY, OCHOBbIBaACb H a T p a 9 H u H R X HeO-

n n a ~ o ~ m ~ a H H a C p e n H e B e K o B o M @U~OCO@CKOM H a c n e n n H (B

O C O ~ ~ H H O C T H H a Y e H M U H U K O ~ ~ R K Y ~ ~ H C K O ~ O 06 " e x g l O m e r a t i 0 et ~0ngl0merati0 centri", 0 CBepTbIBaHHH H p a 3 B e p T b I B a H H H A6conro~a KaK B c ~ ~ ~ H H c T B ~ ) . f l e x a ~ e e B OCHOBe CBCTeMbI K ~ P C ~ B H H ~ OHTOnO-

I I iYeCKOe OTHOlUeHMe 6ora H Y e n O B e K a n a e T B03MOXHOCTb O ~ O C H O B ~ T ~

HCKnlOYWTenbHYlO 4 e H H O C T b HHAMBM~YiUlbHOrO ASUI I IOHHMaHHR O p r a -

HHYeCKOrO enHHCTBa HCTOPH'IeCKOTO pa3BHTHR.

K a ~ m B e n u q e c T s e H H a R H c c n e n o B a T e n b c K a R n e p c n e ~ ~ ~ ~ a ! MCTO- P U K MOXeT, O T ~ P O C U B BCRKUe COMHeHHff , 3aHRTbCR KasyCaMH, I l epCO-

H m H R M H H I lPUAaTb H a K O H e u @ H r y p e n e ~ p a Msa~osnqa ~ O ~ ~ H H C K O -

r0 nono6amuue eii KOCMHqeClu l e M ~ C U T ~ ~ ~ I B KaqeCTBe MOMeHTa CTR-

X e H H O r O BCeeflUHCTBa; H T e n e p b I ~ ~ o @ ~ c c H o H ~ U ~ ~ H O ~ MaCTepCTBO

3aKJllOYaeTCR B TOM, S ~ 0 6 b 1 n O K a 3 a T b yKOpeHeHHOCTb er0 B 3 n O X e H

3 n O X H B H e M , a H e rOHRTbCR 31 lTpH3paqHbIMM " I I ~ M ~ M H ~ M H " A "@K-

T O ~ ~ M U " . Aa, n O 3 y H c B b l f l B H ~ y T b l f i M.A. ~ O ~ ~ L [ O B ~ I M , B n O n H e M O X H O

6bmo 6b1 n O I l O n H H T b CJIOTBHOM: "Bnepen, K K ~ ~ c ~ B M H ~ ! " . HO M C T O P H O T ~ ~ @ H ~ ~ C K H ~ ~ X3IInH-3HP, I lOnyVHnCR H e CnHlUKOM y6e-

nMTenbHb1M. Benb C a M aBTOp , C 0 3 n a B CTPO~~HYH) CHCTeMY H I I P H M e H H B

ee B s a ~ e q a ~ e n b ~ o f i K H u r e o &KOPABHO 6py~020, n o B e n c e 6 ~ 3 a ~ e ~ HeCKOnbKO CTPaHHO. BC~CTOPOHH~ O C H ~ U ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ , 3TOT 0 n a p e ~ ~ b l f i

UCCnef lOBaTenb, HCTOPHK MHnOCTblO 60x~efi , K a 3 m O C b , n O J I X e H 6 b l n

r o P b 1 C B e p H F b . Aa M 6 u o r p a @ ~ ~ ero c n o x c i n a c b c q a c T n u s e e , q e M Y ~ O ~ ~ U H H C T B ~ COBpeMeHHUKOB. C O B ~ T C K ~ R B n a c T b n o 6 p a n a c b A 0 H e r o

J H U b YeTBePTb BeKa C n y c T R , e M y y~mocb OCTaTbCR npo@eccopo~ B c e - o6urefi HcTOPMM B YHHBepcMTeTe B w T a y T a c a Bena~oro, c n o x ~ o c ~ e f i c pa6o~oti B apXUBaX H 6 M 6 n M o ~ e ~ a x y H e r 0 H e 6b1no . BOT TOnbKO KaK

" n p a ~ ~ u ~ ~ I O u I k f f i ~ c T o p w K " OH KOHllMnCH. Ero @wnoco@c~we M 601-0- c n o B c K M e T P Y A ~ I , ero " n o s ~ a o C M ~ P T M " , ero A u a n o r M H me n a r e p H b r e

3 a n H C a rny6o~w U TaJIaHTnUBbI, H O MCTOpHKy TaM ~ O X H B M T ~ C H H e -

q e ~ 2 1 .

TO Xe nPo~30mn0, 6 ~ o r p a @ ~ r e c ~ u R n e p e n o M nnn o p r a H M q e c K a r r 3BOnloUHR TanaHTnHBOrO Pi MPOHHqHOrO HCTOpHKa B C ~ M O ~ ~ I T H O ~ O Ae-

HTenR pycc~oro penuruo3~0-@~noco+c~oro B 0 3 p o ) ) ( q e ~ ~ ~ ? n p 0 ~ U U a ~ e n b ~ b l f l M.A. E 0 f i U 0 B O T M e r a e T 3 ~ a q e ~ n e 3KCnepMMeHZ

T ~ J I ~ H ~ I X c ~ ~ n u 3 a u u f i K a p c a ~ u ~ a - "Saligia" H "Noctes petropoli- taIlaev2' - H BCnOMHHaeT 0 CTpaCTHOM er0 YBneqeHHH TeaTpOM. "He O v n a n H M UAeH BXHBaHHH B n p O L u n O e KaK r J t aBHOr0 CpeACTBa er0 no- ~ H ~ H M R ? " ~ ~ Ho, KBK H C T H H H ~ I ~ ~ CbIH CBOerO C ~ ~ ~ ~ P H H O T O BeKa, Kap- c a B u H H e M o r B u A e T b B urpe n u m b urpy, a B T e a T p e n u m b T e a T p . B e n b

" O P ~ H ~ C T A ~ ~ C K M ~ 6 a p a 6 a ~ b 1 " , KOTOPbIe, n O MbICnH C ~ e + a ~ a re0pre ( ~ W T ~ J ' I J I B p ~ c T a K ~ H T o ~ o B u ~ ~ ) , AOIDKHb1 ~ ~ L T I M n p e 0 6 p a 3 0 ~ a ~ b MHp, B n o n H e C O ~ B Y ~ H ~ I n p o p o q e c T B y B~qecnaea M B ~ H O B ~ - " c ~ p a ~ a no- KpOeTCH @ U M ~ ~ ~ M U M 0 p x e ~ T p a ~ k f " . K y n b ~ y p ~ b ~ t i KOHTeKCT 3nOXH

nOACKa3bIBaJl, q T O UlJlbI n b ~ a ~ ~ ~ T O H O B H ~ ~ CBli&?TenbCTBOB&JIH 0 er0 m a 6 o n b u r a x ~ M ~ H U H H X , q e M ~ M C T O a K i i q e M u q e c K M e U ~ H H . XOPO- mn# HCTOPUK B POCCHH B c e r n a , YBLI, 6 0 n b ~ 1 e , q e M HCTOPHK.

HO BepHeMCH K " B B ~ A ~ H M I O B MCTOPHW". KPMTHK~R T a M TeOpMlo n p O r p e C C a TO HbIHe T a m e BeCbMa ~ O ~ Y J L I I P H O ) , OH I lHUeT, 9TO cefi anean, T. e. n o n H o T a x1.13~~ q e n o B e v e c T B a BO B c e x ee n p o r r B n e H u H x M

CqaCTbe , HeCOCTORTeneH: "&R TOrO, qT06b1 CTaTb HpaBCTBeHHO npwe- MneMbIM, H A e a n AOJIXeH CAenaTbCR AOCTOHHHeM BCeX nloneR, KaK ewe H e pO>Y4eHHbIX, TaK M HaC H YMepUIMX. C f l p y ~ ~ f i CTOPOHbI, 1.13 H e r 0 ~ e n b s n YCTpaHMTb HM OAHOrO H 3 A O C T M X ~ H B ~ IIPOLunOrO, KOTOpbIe B

C H n y MX H ~ ~ O B T O P M M O ~ H K O H K ~ ~ T H O ~ ~ H H A H B m y a n b H O C T H H e M O W

6b1Tb TaK Xe BOCIlpOM3BeneHbI Q H A Y U H M M flOKOJleHHRMH H AOnXHb1

6b1Tb peanbHOCTbI0 , a H e 06pa3a~i.i BOCnOMHHaHHH. Bce 3 T O AOCTMXH- MO JIWUlb 80 BCeBpeMeHHOM M BCenpOCTpaHCTBeHHOM p e m b H 0 ~ CMH-

T e 3 e BCTOPMqeCKOrO p a 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " 2 4 . H e 3 a 6 s e ~ ~ a R KORneXCKaR p e r H C T p a T O p U a Kopo6os~a ITpM 3 T n x

c n o B a x H e n p e M e H H O flepeKpeCTHninaCb 6b1: H e n p o c T 0 CoXpaHHTb ~ 0 6 - pylo n a m T b o ~ ~ ~ ' I H H C K O M , HO ero c a M o r o c n e n a T b p e m b r r o c m b m ! T a ~ H CnbIUlMTCH ee BOnpOC: "fla KaK Xe, H, n P a B o , B TOnK-TO H e B 0 3 b ~ y ? H ~ ~ T o XOVeLUb Tbl HX OTKanbIBaTb M3 ~ ~ M J I H ? " . H ~ T P M B ~ H O B U Y , ~ b l -

xoflUT, H e 3 p R n p O c M n 3aMOnBMTb 3a H e m CJIOBeqKo - H e T o n b K O er0 He-

n o r n o p H M a n ~ ~ n ~ o ~ n y a n b H o c ~ b B a x H a a n H Hat n m H HaII.IMx qenefi, HO H H a m C K P O M H ~ I ~ ~ ~pyn , o ~ a 3 b r n a e ~ c ~ ~ O q e H b B m e H M rn H e r o .

A K a p c a ~ H ~ n p o n o n x a e T : a P a 3 ~ e p ~ b r ~ a ~ r n ~ C i c R H b r H e nepea H a m M B O C I I ~ M H M M ~ ~ M ~ I R HaMU BO BpeMeHH M B IIpOCTpaHCTBe n p O q e C C ,

n p O U e C C y,4pyllalolllMfi HaC BHnMMblM I ~ o ~ M ~ ~ H M ~ M H yMMpaHHeM, AOn-

X e H CTaTb ,QJIR H a C p e m b H b 1 M BO ~cef i c~oe t i KOHKpeTHOCTM, BO BCeX

CBOMX MOMeHTaX. A ~ T O BOJMOXHO TOnbKO, e C n H " ~ b l MJM~HMMCII" , eC-

nn n p e o A o n e e M npoc - rpaHcTBo , ecnu "~e6eca COB~IOTCR B CBMTOK", a BpeMH n p e 0 6 p a 3 y e T c H B BeqHOCTb. M TaKOe nOHUMaHMe We&JIa MnU

"nporpecca" H e ~ o n b ~ o c o r n a c y e T c n c n p u H q u n a M u HCTOPMH, 113 HHX

BbITeKaH, H O H YCTpaHReT BCe OTMeqeHHbIe HaMH npOTHBOPe'-IMH. OHO, BMeCTe C T e M OnpaBAbIBaeT CMbICn H H a 3 H a Y e H H e BCHKOrO MOMeHTa HC-

TOPHH M BCHKOrO MH.4MBHnyanbHOTO T p y A a ... OHO, HaKOHeU, n03BOnH- e T nOHMMaTb ACTOPMqeCKOe n O 3 H a H U e KaK npu6nuxe~ue K MCTMHHO-

MY BCeBpeMeHHOMy n 0 3 H a H H l o M n p ~ o 6 u r e ~ u e KO BCeBpeMeHHOMy

eAMHOMY 6 b 1 ~ a l o a * ~ .

He H m O 6 b 1 n o 6b1Tb MenHeBMCTOM, q ~ 0 6 b 1 B 1920 C qyBCTBOBaTb,

TO ~ e 6 e c a BOT-BOT COB~IOTCH B CBIITOK. M B c e x e H e 3cxa~onoruqe- c ~ u t i yxac nepen "KOHUOM HCTOPHM" ( M H e no @ Y K O R M ~ , a no Acaxa- pe) 3 a H H M a e T MbICJlMTenH, p a B H 0 KaK YApy l l amT er0 H e W a c 6 1 6 0 n b U I e -

BM3Ma, m J l O A HnM TTH@ CaMM n0 ce6e, a CMePTb KaK RBneHMe, KaK @H-

~ O C O @ C K ~ R npo6ne~a . C M ~ I C J I neHTenbHOCTM MCTOPMKa, na M BCerO

q e n o s e s e c T s a , - B no6ene ~a CMepTbm.

qepe3 n e c m b n e T K ~ ~ C ~ B H H H a n M c a n n p e K p a c H o e n p o ~ 3 s e n e ~ e e - " n 0 3 ~ y 0 C M ~ ~ T H " . T ~ M MOXHO ~ a f i T H BCe CTapbIe HAeM 6 b t ~ L U e r 0 MC- TOPMKa: M " B ~ Y B C T B O ~ ~ H H ~ " - n 0 3 M a OTKPblBaeTCR o 6 p a 3 0 ~ X e H W M -

HbI H a KOCTPe, M B C ~ O ~ ~ ~ Y K ) CBII3b n I O n e f i , M BaXHOCTb MHAMBMAYaAb-

HOrO JIJH B C ~ O ~ L U ~ I - 0 , H npOKllRTMe CMePTM. " K ~ K M ~ - T O H e X H b I e TO-

H e H b K H e HHTOVKU CBR3blBaIOT BCeX H I C , M XMBbIX M MePTBbIX, BeCb

MMP, CTaHOBHTCH BCe TOHbUle M H e P B P C I I . He HMTOqKM - TOHeHbKUe

XMnKki, no KOTOpbIM ~ ~ X H T H a m a 0 6 q a ~ KpOBb. H ~ M HeCJlbIlUMMbIe

B3AOXH CJIWBPloTCH B O n H H ~ H X e n b I f i B3AOX. Haua c n a 6 e ~ b K M e CTO-

H b l - B H ~ B ~ I H O C U M ~ I ~ B O n n b BCerO XHBOrO, B 6 e c c M n b ~ b I e flpOWrHTAH

CTPaAaHHHM H CMePTH. P a 3 B e H ~ O ~ X O A U M O , qT06b1 CTOH '4enOBeqeCTBa

6b1n O ~ ~ H O ~ O ~ O C ~ I M ? OH M O X e T 6 b 1 ~ b H ~ O ~ H @ O H H ~ H ~ I M . T ~ K clue Be-

~ H Y ~ c T B ~ H H ~ ~ " ~ ~ . n, KOHeqHO, B 3TOM na6MpMHTe n l o 6 0 ~ b CTBHOBBT-

CH n y - r e ~ o ~ ~ o f i HMTLH, H OH p a c c y x a a e T o c y n b 6 e c~oefi ~osn106ne~- ~ o f i 3 n e ~ w ~ e nocne CMepTu :

' 'H~T, H e CyUeCTByeT A y U U , KOTOpaH BMeCTe C T e M H e 6 b 1 n a 6b1 1.1

B e q H O yMHpaDlUMM TenOM. Ten0 Xe TBOe n M m b OAHH M3 UeHTPOB 1.1 06- p a 3 O B ~ ~ ~ I Q ~ H M ' ~ H o ~ o MMpa ... B A p y r O M M H p e U B npyrofi n n 0 T H H e MO-

X e T 6 b 1 ~ b 3TOT MOMeHT nYUIM. T o n b ~ o H 3 3 T O r 0 Tens CO3Halo H CBOR MMP. Tonb~o B 3TOM MOeM T e n e OH T a K CO3HaeT c e 6 ~ M C T ~ ~ J I ~ ~ T ...".

*y & I ~ H H T ~ , KaK y ra6c6yproe, HeCKOn b K 0 BbIAaeTCR HKXHRR ry6a, M H a B e p ~ ~ e f i MaJIeHbKaH 60p0AaBKa . H a f i n e T ~ H n H 3TMM " H ~ A O C T ~ T - KIM" MeCTO B " C O B ~ ~ U ~ H H O M " ~ @ M P H O M ~ e n e ? - Ecnu 3 a X O q e U b , 6y- n y T ~ e 6 e H ra6c6yprc~a~ ry6a, a 6 0 p o n a ~ ~ a .

XOY~, ~ 0 6 b l O H a BO BCeM 6 b 1 n a nyyrue npyrax. Ho xosy, Y T O ~ ~ I O H a

O C T m a C b H T a K O m , KaKof i 6b1na . npnnma#-~a nono6~oe ~ e n o ! ~ P K

O A H O ~ ~ MbICnH 0 H e M CMYTHTCR name CB. rperopw# HHCCW#*~'. TOT "Bennm# K a n n a 4 0 K H e u n BCnOMHHaeTCH ~ ~ B O M n n a ~ o ~ o -

BMYeM B H a H ~ b l ~ U l H f i MOMeHT er0 TBOpYeCTBa naJIeK0 H e cJIJJVaRHo.

r p n r 0 p H f i H H C C K H ~ ~ S P ~ ~ B ~ I Y ~ ~ ~ H O B m e H AlIR MMpOB033PeHHR Kapca- B n H a . B 1926 r. B n a p m e OH ~ 3 n a e ~ yqe6aoe noco6we nnrr pycc~ofi C e M H H a p H H ' 'CBRT~I~ OTUbI H y y n T e n H U ~ ~ K B U " . flyqrune CTPaHHUbI

n O C B R U e H b 1 6 b l n H 3TOMY OTUy QePKBH. BOT K a K n 3 n a r a l O T C R eTO

B3rJIRilbI:

ccBce MHpOBOe pa3BHTHe 3aBepUlHTCR " B O C C T ~ H O B J I ~ H H ~ M BCRYe-

C K O ~ O " ( d 7 C o ~ a T d o z a m s T@V 7 C ~ ' G o ~ v ) . O ~ H ~ K O 3 e M H o e 6 b l ~ H e H e Te -

P R e T n p H 3TOM. .. CBOerO eJ lHHOKPaTHOr0 H IJeHTPaJlbHOTO 3HaYeHHR ... Korna B c e nmm POHIITCR, HO H e B c e ewe y ~ p y r , OCTaBWHeCR B X H B ~ I X W3MeHRTCR, a MepTBble BOCKpeCHYT: H T e H A p y r H e ,&TI% B O 3 B p a q e H H R B

H e p a C T O p X H M O e enHHCTB0 P a H e e o & ~ ~ ~ H H ~ H H o K ~ B OnHOM UenOM M no pamoxeauu B H O B ~ c o e n n H n B m e r o c R . B e n b , K ~ K n n m e T C B R T O ~ ~ , ecnw ynpaBJMlOw%I BCeJIeHHOlO CUJla n a C T P a m O X H B U M M C R CTHXHRM 3 H a K

BOCCOeAHHHTbCR, A y l l l a BOCCTaHOBHT U e n b CBOeM) Tens. n p H S e ~ K a X -

n a R YaCTb 6 y n e ~ YCTaHOBJleHa BHOBb COIYIaCHO C nepBOHaY&JlbHbIM

0 6 b l Y ~ b l ~ &Wl H e e COCTORHHeM H I l p H M e T 3 ~ a K 0 ~ b l f i e# B W . .. Boc~pecruee T e n 0 6 y n e ~ TenOM HHAHBUYaJIbHblM. - TO N R Me-

HR BOCKpeCeHHe, e C n H BMeCTO MeHR B03BPaTHTCR K X H 3 H H KTO-TO A p y -

ro2i? K a K y 3 ~ a n c e 6 ~ c a M o r o B ce6e yxe H e ce6~?" M n a u b no B o c c T a -

HOBneHHH M O Y H q e H U H BCerO HaCTj l lHT "JleHb OC~MO#" , " n e ~ b BeJlU-

~ f i " . MCTHHHO H BCeUeJIO 6 y n e ~ b0r "BCRY~CKHM BO B C H Y ~ C K O M " ~ .

" C U C T ~ M ~ ~ P H ~ O P U R HUCCKO~O - OnHO H 3 BblCIIIHX H CaMbIX my6o- KHX M ~ H B H j l y a J I b H b I X 0 C ~ b l C n e ~ H f i XpHCTHaHCTBa, i l a J I eK0 clue H e no- HRTOe H H e O U ~ H ~ H H O ~ " , - A e n a e T BbIBOA ~ B T O ~ ~ ' .

CBRTO~ o T e u H a n p R x e H H o n y M a n HCUI n p o 6 n e ~ a ~ u a n o K a T a c T a c n -

Ca , ~ ~ ' ~ R C H R R , H a n p H M e p , KaKZiM 06pa30~ BO3MOXHO BOCCTaHOBMTb

T e n o mepuero, nocne T o r o KaK OHO p a 3 n o x a n o c b : B n o c M e p T H o M pac- CeRHHH n)Wa W K 6b1 OXpaHReT C B O ~ # ~ e ~ 0 f i K W W YaCTHYKY 6 b 1 ~ -

mero Y e n o B e Y e c K o r o e n n H c T B a . M I I O A O ~ H ~ I X paccyxne~ufi y rparo- p H % HUCCKO~O HeMaJIO. HO HaCKOnbKO B M H b I 6 y J I y I U k i ~ CBRUeHHM-

K I M 3TW ClOXeTbl AlIR " P ~ C K P ~ ~ T H I I ~ ~ ~ B o c J I ~ B H R " ? C O B ~ ~ M ~ H H U K M

o n n o H e H T Kapcaeu~a, o~a3as111ufic~ 6onee H e r o y n a y n n s b I M B npeno- n a B a H M H ~ O ~ O C J I O B H H I l apHXCKUM CTyAeHTaM, - B.H. f l 0 c c K H f i - ro- BOPWT 06 a n o K a T a c T a c n c e n u r u b B OAHOM 143 CBOHX TPYAOB, n p n y e ~

OYeHb KPPTKo: snocne BOnnOlUeHAR H BOCKpeUeHHR C M e p T b H e C n o -

Kof iHa : O H a yme H e a 6 c o n l o ~ ~ a . Bce T e n e p b YCTpeMJlReTcR K & x o l c a T d o ~ d a s T a u 7 C d v ~ 0 v " B O C C T ~ H O B ~ ~ H H ~ O BcRY~cKHx", K non- HOMY BOCCTaHOBJTeHHlO BCeTO, YTO pa3PYUlaeTCR CMePTblO, K OCHRHMm

BCerO KOCMOCa c J l aB0f i b o ~ ~ e f i , K O T O p m CTaHeT " B C ~ BO B C ~ M " . M g

3~0f i IlOnHOTbl H e ~ Y A ~ T MCKJlloYeHa H c~060na K W O ~ ~ JIHYHOCTH, KO-

T O P O ~ ~ 6 y n e ~ AapOBaHO ~ O X ~ C T B ~ H H ~ I M CBeTOM COBepl l IeHHOe CO3Ha-

H H e ~ ~ 0 e f i H ~ M o ~ H " ~ ~ . M H e T a K yx H BenMKH paCXOXC4eHMR er0 C K ~ P C ~ B M H ~ I M , H O RCHO,

YTO ~ ~ O C C K O ~ O HHTepeCylOT BOBCe H e n o n p o 6 ~ o c ~ ~ BOCKpemeHMR, a x p n c T o n o r n y e c K n e n p o 6 n e ~ b 1 , a rpuropn# HHCCKHR y n o M n H a e T c n HM

COBCeM no WHOMY IIOBOnY. T a K a R nO3HUHR KaHOHHYeCKH 6onee O n p a B -

n a H a . B e n b H CaM K ~ ~ C ~ B M H H e 6e3 C O X m e H H R B b l H m e H 6 b l n n p H -

3 ~ a ~ b , YTO y y e H n e 06 a n o K a T a c T a c w c e H e 661~10 c c n p u ~ ~ a ~ o T O Y H ~ I M

B b I p m e H M e M X ~ M C T H ~ H C K O ~ ~ MCTHHbI. OHO A M e KOCBeHHO OKa3aJIOCb

OnOpOYeHO B " O ~ H ~ ~ H M C T C K H X cn0pax" H B KaHOHaX ... nO,4nHCaHHbIX

n a ~ p u a p x a ~ n " 3 0 .

I l o s e ~ y me c n o B a a n o c T o n a I l a ~ n a : "Ilocnen~ufi me spar H c T p e -

~ W T C R - C M ~ P T ~ " , " M H a y e YTO AeJIaloT KpeCTHUHeCR DJ'IR M ~ ~ T B ~ I X ? Ecnu MepTBbIe COBCeM H e B O C K ~ ~ C ~ ~ O T . .." (I K o ~ , 15-26,29) H TeKCTbl

r p H r 0 p H R Hucc~oro IlpOH3BOA%T H a nByX aBTOpOB p a 3 H O e n e f i c ~ B H e ?

K a K M H e n p e A c T a w n e T c r r , B ~ e ~ a n o W c T e n e H n noToMy, TO noccmfi - J I O ~ H K - ~ O ~ O C J I O B , a B ' K a p c a ~ u ~ e X H B e l U e H C T O ~ H K - ~ ~ O @ ~ C C H O H ~ .

HO HaCKOJIbKO no-HOBOMY M0r) 'T 3a3B)'YaTb JlJlR HaC T e n e p b era CnOBa

0 " B X W B ~ H H M " H " B O C C T ~ H O B ~ ~ H M H no Y~CTRM"! B O C C T ~ H O B ~ ~ H H ~ H e -

o6xonu~o &lM nOJIHOTbI ~ceo6wer0, M R K O H ~ Y H O ~ ~ n o 6 e n b l H a 4 CMep-

TblO, Pl IR OCyIUeCTBneHHR KOHUa MCTOPMM, H HCTOPMKY, nOXOXe, OTBO-

A H n a C b B 3TOM n e R H H H 0c06a~ pOJlb.

He 6 e p y c b BTOPraTbCR B 3TY o ~ J ' I ~ c T ~ , HO CMefO I l p e n n O n O X H T b , YTO

f l e ~ TOHOB HOB MY, IlOCTORHHO H a ~ ~ U l a ~ U l ~ l f i n p a B M n a H m b I , IlPMHRTbIe

y HCTOPHKOB M @HJIOCO@OB, H B ~ O ~ O C ~ O B H H OKa3UICR HeCKOAbKO yna- n e H OT n p a ~ o c n a ~ ~ o f i OPTOAOKCHM.

Apyrofi MbICnMTenb, 0 ~ I l a ~ U l M f i OT OPTOAOKCMM, HO H a ~ e f i pa3 - OT

K ~ T O J ~ H Y ~ C K O ~ , n b e p Tefi~p ne m a p n e ~ , HaYHHaR C O B e p m e H H O C

MHbIX HCXOfiHbIX I ~ o ~ H u H ~ , nPMXOfiMT K BbIBOnaM, nOYTH flOCJlOBH0

COBna,QalolIJHM C KIPCIBHHCKWMM. MOXHO CnOPMTb 0 TOM, HaCKOnbKO

n p a B O M e p H 0 C ~ J I H X ~ H H ~ er0 " n y H K T a OM~IX" CO B C ~ ~ . ~ U H C T B O M , HO,

CTOJlb Xe e n K O KPWTMKYR TeOPHlO n p O r p e C C a , KaK H er0 POBeCHHK Kap- CaBHH, @ ~ ~ H u ~ ~ c K U # MbICJlHTenb YBepeH, YTO OTKa3 OT BOCCTaHOBJle-

HAR HHAHBHAYaJIbHbIX ~ 0 3 H a H H f i 6 y n e ~ 0 3 H a Y a T b @WBCKO 3BOJllOUHH:

a P ~ H ~ a J t b ~ b 1 ~ IIOPOK BCeX @ O ~ M B e p b I B n p O m e C C , K O r n a O H a B b l p a -

XaeTCR B n03MTHBMCTCKMX CHMBOJIaX, B TOM, YTO OHH H e YCTPaHRlOT

OKOHYaTenbHO CM~PTH.. .3 ' Ecnu n o c n y m a T b y q e H n K o B M a p K c a , TO Y e n o B e y e c T B y Aoc-caToyHo

l I a K a n n MBaTb nOCJleAOBaTeJIbHble nOCTHXeHHR, KOTOPbIe OCTaBnReT

~aX.Llblfi M 3 HaC IlOCJle CMePTM: HalllM MAeH, OTKPblTHR, TBOpeHHR MC-

KYCCTB ... He RBnReTCR JIM UCe 3 T 0 HeTJleHHOe JlflUlefi YaCTblo H a U l e r O

C ~ U ~ C T B ~ ? . . .Ho TaKMM nKnaj lOM B O ~ ~ H O C T ~ Mbl I l e P e n a e M AUIeKO H e

c a h r o e uewoe. B c a m x 6 n a r o n p u ~ ~ ~ b l x cnyqanx H a M y n a e T c R nepe- AaTb APYrMM Jl l lUlb T e H b c e 6 ~ . Hamu T B O ~ ~ H M R ? HO KaKOe H 3 YenOBe-

qeCKHX T U O P ~ H M ~ ~ l i h l e e T CaMOe 6 o n b u o e 3 H a q e H M e N I R KOPeHHblX MH-

TepeCOB XM3HM B O O ~ U ~ , eCnM H e C O ~ A ~ H H ~ K a m b I M M3 HaC B ce6e a6- C o n r o T H o O P H r M H U b H O r O U e H T p a , B KOTOPOM YHMBePCYM O C 0 3 H a e T Ce-

6~ Y H M K ~ ~ H ~ ~ M , H e n o n p a x a e M b ~ ~ 06pa30~, a MMeHHO H a m e r o "H", ~ a m e k ~ M Y H O C T M ? 6onee r n y 6 0 ~ ~ f i , q e M B c e ero n y w , c a M @owe H a -

W e r O C03HaHHH - BOT TO CYUleCTBeHHOe, YTO A O n x e H BePH)'Tb ce6e O ~ e r a , q ~ 0 6 b l A ~ ~ C T B M T ~ J I ~ H O 6 b 1 ~ b OMer0fi,>32.

P o n b n o ~ r a T e n H H a n y r M K O ~ e r e o T e u n b e p oTBonMT n r o 6 ~ ~ - "KnIOYeBofi K O C M M Y ~ C K O ~ ~ H ~ P T M W " . M CCbInaeTCH OH H a n r o 6 ~ ~ 0 r 0 K ~ ~ c ~ B M H ~ ~ M H M K o ~ ~ R K ~ ~ ~ H c K o ~ o . K C T ~ T U , 06a M c c n e n o B a T e n H H a -

YHHLUIH C B O ~ ~ n y r b C o64ero YBJIeYeHMH AHPH ~ ~ ~ ~ C O H O M .

n p e f l ~ a B J I H e ~ c H , OAHaKo, HeMUfOBMHbIM, YTO T e h p ne U a p n e ~ - n m e o H T o n o r c COnMAHbIM c T a x e M nonemrx pa6o.r. POACTBO ero c K ~ ~ C ~ U M H ~ I M B TOM, YTO 06a H a Y M H U H r e H e p M p 0 B a T b CBOH M ~ T ~ @ M ~ M -

YeCKHe TeOPHH rOJlbKO nOCJIe TOrO, KaK n O n r 0 TpyflMJlkiCb H a BOCCTa-

HOBneHMeM HCYe3Hj'BlIlHx oco6ek H WHAWBMAYYMOB n0 @ P ~ ~ M ~ H T ~ M .

HO nOMMM0 H ~ K O ~ # B H ) ' T P ~ H H ~ ~ ~ JlOrWKW TBOPYeCTBa K ~ ~ c ~ B M H ~ , n p o n u ~ ~ o ~ a ~ ~ o k ero n s ~ a q a n b ~ o i r npo@eccwefi, B ero ~srnmax c ner- KOCTbIO MOXHO 0 6 ~ a p ) W H ~ b M O U H O e BJIMHHMe T o r 0 CaMOrO " K j ' J l b ~ y p -

HOrO @ o H A ~ " , PaCXOXMX H n e k , K M3YqeHMiO KOTOPblX OH CaM H nPM3bI-

B U B CBOHX PaHHHX pa60~ax. f l n ~ pycc~ok KYJlbTYPbl, B TOM YMCne ki W Kj'nbTYPbl C ~ P ~ ~ P H H O I - 0

BeKa , O K a 3 U a C b Y p e 3 ~ b l Y a k H 0 ~ H ~ Y M M O ~ ~ H A M , ~aw6onee n O n H 0

c @ o ~ M ~ J ~ M ~ o B ~ H H ~ H B "Q)MJIOCO@MM 06~e1-0 nena" H H K O ~ ~ R Q)enopo-

oa. n e r ~ 0 6 b m o K ~ ~ c ~ B M H ~ M Tefi~py A e U Z i p ~ e ~ y KPMTHKOBaTb MO-

P U b H O e HeCOBepWeHCTBO TeOPMM n p O r p e C C a - B e n b OHM 3aHMMUfMCb

3THM TOrAa, KOrAa XX BeK Y)I(e RBMn CBOR O C K m . Q)~AOPOB Xe npMII1en

K 3TOMY B ~ a ~ b l k pasrap IIO3MTHBMCTCKOrO OnTMMM3Ma, e q e B 60- 70-x rOAaX n p O L U n O r 0 BeKa: "npopecc COCTOMT B C03HaHHM CblHaMM

c B o e r o n p e B o c x o n c T o a ~a o T u a M M M B C O ~ H ~ H M M X M B ~ U I H M M c B o e r o

npeBOCXOACTUa H a YMePUIHMM. HO B TO Xe BpeMH OH HBJMeTCH CO3Ha-

H u e M cooero n o n H o r o H M q T o x e c T B a npen CMepTbro , npen cnenoro, 6ec- YyBCTBeHHOIO H c T o ~ H ~ ~ ~ . U e n b n p O r p e C C a - p a 3 B M T m JlWYHOCTb CAY-

XMT n H m b ewe 6 0 n b m e ~ y p a 3 a e n u ~ e ~ ~ r o nronefi ... n o n n ~ ~ ~ b r k npo- Q e C C ~ p e 6 y e ~ B O C K ~ ~ W ~ H M H " ~ ~ .

f l n H BOCKpeCeHMH MePTBbIX H e H W H O W a T b KOHUa B p e M e H . OHO n O n X H 0 CTaTb pe3YJlbTaTOM ~ 0 3 H a ~ e n b H o k fleHTenbHOCTki YeJlOBeYeCT-

Ba , CnJlOTMBLUerOCH B 3TOM enMHCTBeHH0 BenMKOM " 0 6 q e ~ neJle", me " B C ~ X M B y q M e AOJlXHbI 6 b l ~ b MCTOPHKIMM, a Bee y M e P m M e - n p e n M e -

TOM MCTOPHM, ~ e 0 ~ n e J l H M O ~ ~ OT eCTeCTB03HaHMH M e C T e C T B O y n p a ~ J l e -

HMH. TO ~ Y A ~ T BCeuenbHOCTb, BOCKpeu leHMe H npeo6pame~we ~ M p a " . E C T ~ C T U ~ H H ~ R Y e p e n a C M ~ P T ~ ~ H O p M m b H a , IIOKa H e n p o 6 y ~ M J I o c b

C03HaHMe. HO YeJlOBeYeCKOe C 0 3 H a H H e H a Y H H a e T CBOe n p 0 6 y > ~ n e ~ ~ e C

OCTpOrO YyBCTBa C B O ~ # HHAHBHAYUbHOCTW M C my6o~oro C T p i i q a ~ M H

OT YTPilTbl APYTOrO. Y H M Y T O X ~ H U ~ YenOBeYeCKorO "H", nMYHOCTM KaK

H e n O n M e H e H H O r O H HepaCTOpXMMOrO nyxOBH0-TeneCHOrO enMHCTBa,

H a e J l e H H O r O YHWKUbHbIM CaMOC03HaHMeM, O q m a e T C R YeJlOBeKOM

KaK Tpa rHYeCKaH K ~ T ~ c T ~ o @ ~ , CTaBHUaH n O n COMHeHMe pa3YMHOCTb

1 BCerO n O p H n K a B ~ u ~ A ~ ~ .

K a 3 m o c b 661, B OTJlHYMe OT MHflHBMnYmbHOrO YenOBeKa ~ ~ C K O H ~ Y - H o e 6ynyqee Y e n o s e q e c T B y KaK CYUHOCTM, ~ a e n e ~ ~ o f i p a 3 y ~ 0 ~ M

n) 'XOM, r a p a H T H p O B a H 0 . O ~ H ~ K O OKa3blBaeTCH, YTO OHTOJlOrMYeCKaR

c y n b 6 a Y e n o B e q e c T s a B q e n o M HMKaK H e M o x e T 6 b 1 ~ b O T n e n e H a OT

~ y n b 6 b 1 enMHMYHbIX n ~ ) f l e f i . M, H e P e U M B n p 0 6 J l e ~ b 1 HX BOCCTaHOBJle-

HMH, YenOBeYeCTBO H ~ H ~ ~ ~ X H O ~ O T M ~ H ~ T B pe3yJ lbTaTe 3HTPOnMM, BCe-

o6qero p a c c e M s a H u H .

O n H p a ~ c b H a C B H ~ ~ H H O ~ IlMCaHMe M H a naTpHCTHK)', H a Q l O M W -

~ b 1 k n n a C T @ M ~ O C O @ C K O ~ O HaCnenkiH M H a eCTeCTBeHH0-HaYqHbIe AaH-

w e , Q ) e n o p o ~ p a 3 p a 6 a ~ b l e m ~ c e c ~ o p o ~ ~ n k n n a H n p e o 6 p a 3 o ~ a ~ w ~ MMpa - PMCyH B n O n H e KOHKPeTHbIe n y T H K PeaJ IbHOMy BOCKpeLueHkiIO,

K p a 3 ~ e q e ~ ~ r o B o c K p e c m H x , K o p r a ~ ~ 3 a u u w HOBO^ X H ~ H M B npeo6- pa>l<eHHOM O ~ W ~ C T B ~ . C ~ M O ~ yflMBMTeJIbHOt?, YTO ~ O ~ ~ U I M H C T B O H e p a s -

peWHMb1X n p o 6 n e ~ MaTepHLWbHOrO I lJ laHa, H a KOTOPbIe YKa3bIBmM

Q ) e n o p o ~ y c K e n T n K M , C O B ~ ~ M ~ H H O ~ ~ ~ a y ~ o i i B n o n H e pemaewr, ecnw yxe H e p a s p e m e ~ b r .

Benwqwe wnek "06qero neJla" 3 a Y a p O B b I B U O ~ ~ O C T O ~ B C K O ~ O M

Tonc~oro, BJlaki~kipa C o J l o B b e B a ; KaK K POnHOMy, K H e M y OTHeCnkiCb

CMMBOJlMCTbI, PYCCKHe KOCMMCTbI, B ~ ~ H ~ c K H # , ~ M X ~ B C K H ~ , Ukf0Jl-

K O D C K M ~ , @)'TYPUCTLI - M n e p ~ b 1 k C p e n H HUX M ~ R K O B C K M ~ ~ , H CTOJlb

p a 3 ~ b 1 e nronn, KaK A ~ n p e k n n a ~ o ~ o e u 6opuc n a c ~ e p ~ a ~ . BTOT cnu- COK MOXHO I l p O n O n X a T b , IIOflBepCTbIBaH B H e r 0 BCe HOBbIe MMeHa M ne- HHHH, BlUIOTb A 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M H ~ o B ~ H M H B O W MHpOBOrO IIpOJleTapMaTa.

B 3 ~ 0 k 6 n e c ~ ~ q e f i n e p c n e K T n B e f l e ~ p y M B ~ H O B H Y ~ 6 0 6 ~ 1 . 1 ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ \

C m e H O 6 b m o BOCKPeCHYTb H e n O n n e p 0 M MCTOPMKa, H e B KOHUe Bpe -

MeH, H e B I IyHKTe O ~ e r a , a B CaMOM CKOPOM 6 y n y q e ~ , B na6opa~opww r e H ~ 0 f i M H X e H e p H H I lOn ~ a 6 J l I O n e H k i e ~ nOKTOpa 36apc~oro. 6pp!

J Ho an^ H a c B a x H o npyroe. Q ) e n o p o ~ H e n p o c T o B c e M y pony Y e n o n e -

q e c K o M y cynwn o s n a e H u e n p o @ e c c l . r e k HcTopMKa. OH H c a M 6b1n "n3

I ~ a m w x " , u3 n p a K T u K y r o u u x MCTOPMKOB. H a Y a B c n p e n o n a s a H n H HCTO-

PMM H reorpa@uw B LuKone , OH n p o c n a B M n c H KaK ~ ~ C C M ~ H H ~ I ~ 6316-

J l M o p a @ P ~ M H ~ ~ B C K O ~ O MY3eR. OH 6 b 1 n r e H M m b H b l M 6~6nuorpa- @OM, JlYYUlMM H e TOnbKO B POCCHM, HO, no ~ce f i BMAMMOCTM, H BO ~ ~ e f i Eopone, HaMHOrO Onepe f lHB BpeMH B O ~ J I ~ C T M HayKkl 0 COXpaHeHHM

i ~ r i @ u p ~ a u u l . r .

~ P O ~ ~ M ~ I B ~ H ~enec006pa3~y10 CMCTeMY OpraHM3auHM IlWCbMeH-

HblX naMHTHMKOB I lpOl l l en l l r e rO 11 I l p O M C X O ~ ~ e r O , PaCCTaBJIHH TOMa,

OH 3 a U C . H UeJlblO YBMneTb XMBbIX JIIOnefi, CO3jlaBLukiX 3TM KHHTM, - r e H H e B M 6 e 3 n a p H o c ~ e k . T U a H T O B ki ~ O C ~ ~ A C T B ~ H H O C T ~ ~ ~ , YMHblX H H e -

YMHbIX, 6 J l a r o p o n H b l x M IIM3KHX. OH n J l a H M p O B m OpraHM3OBaTb pa6o- TY ~ M ~ J I M O T ~ K KaJ l eHnapHbIM IlOPHnKOM n 0 AHRM CMePTM aDTOPOB "no

I I p M H q M I I y e X e A H e B H O r 0 I IOMMHOB~HMR" . OH I I p O n a r a H A M p O B U

cyxylo H a y K y 6w6n~orpa@~lo H a p x n B o R e n e H n e : " B e ~ b YTO T a K o e H a

nene 6 w 6 n ~ o r p a @ ~ f l : B cnyqae cMepTM awopa H a KHHW AOJIXHO CMOT-

p e T b KaK H a OCTaHKH, OT COXpaHeHHfl KOHX KaK ~ ~ I ~ ~ B H C H T CaMOe B03-

B p a U e H M e K XM3HM SIBTOPI ... ~ P ~ A C T ~ B ~ T ~ ce6e, YTO BCTWIH M3 rp060~ TBOpqbI , M ~ m b l f i H 3 HHX, Y K a 3 b l B M H a CBOe COYHHeHHe, KaK 661 A e -

MOHCTPHPYfl er0 06nox1cy, I IpM3bIBaeT BCeX K er0 I IPOYTeHHlo H HCCJIe-

AOBaHHlo ... E c n ~ XpaHMJIMUe K H H r C p a B H H T b C MO~MJIOlo , TO YTeHHe ,

HAM, TOYHee - MCCJIeAOBaHHe, 6 y A e ~ BbIXOAOM H 3 MOrUJlbI, a BbICTaB-

K a - KaK 6 b 1 B O C K ~ ~ C ~ H M ~ M " ~ ~ .

T~KHM 06pa30~, " ~ ~ o @ ~ c c u o H W I ~ H ~ ~ ~ K O M ~ O H ~ H T ~ " B er0 W e H M M

6 b 1 n a AOCTaTOYHO C M J I ~ H O ~ ~ . Ho, KaK Y q H n BCe TOT Xe P ~ H H H # Kapca- BMH, 3 H a Y e H M e ~ b 1 ~ a l o U e f i ~ f l nHYHOCTM ( " T M ~ M Y ~ C K O ~ O Y ~ J I o B ~ K ~ " , no er0 T ~ P M H H O ~ O ~ H H ) B TOM H COCTOHT, YTO O H CKa3WI TO, YTO OT H e r 0 XO-

T e n M YCnbIUlaTb, BbIpa3MJl T e Mew, KOTOPbIe ~ ~ I J I M pa3JIMTbI B O ~ U ~ C T -

Be. K a m b ~ f i , K T 0 CTWIKMBWICfl C MAeflMU @ ~ A o ~ o B ~ , n O p m W I C f l HX CO-

3BYYHOCTH HeKMM COKPOBeHHblM CROUM YYBCTBaM. M A ~ # C T B U T ~ J I ~ H O ,

HAeR 0 6 p e ~ e ~ M f l BCeeAMHCTBa YenOBeYeCTBOM, J I l o 6 0 ~ ~ 0 3aHf lTOrO 06- UMM A e n o M - PYKOTBOPH~IM a n o K a T a c T a c n c o M , ~ a 3 m a c b y K o p e H e H -

~ o f i B M a c c a x B H e ~ e ~ b m e f i c T e n e H n , YeM n p y r a f l q a c T b anorcanwnm- Y ~ ! C K O ~ ~ I I p O r p a M M b I - 6 0 p b 6 a CO 3 n o ~ %i nOCTpOeHMe PyKOTBOPHOrO

T b r c r r s e n e ~ ~ e r o qapcma. n p M ~ e & y JIMlrrb OAMH n p M M e p . B UUKJIe p a C C K a 3 0 B r o p b K o r 0 "no

P y c ~ " e c T b OAMH, HOCRUMR x a p a K T e p H o e s a r n a ~ ~ e - "Knan6~me". M M ~ H H O T a M Y y A a K ~ ~ a ~ b l f i ~ P O B M H ~ H W I ~ H ~ I # nOPYqWK C ~ B B ~ X O ~ B ~ T C ~ H B Y M B O Y B e U e B a e T MOJIOAOr0 n e l r r ~ o ~ a : a n p e ~ c ~ a ~ b ~ e , YTO ~ a X A b 1 f i

ropoa, ceno, K a m o e c K o n n e H M e n w ~ e f i BeAeT s a n ~ c b A e n a M CBOMM.

T ~ K CKa3aTb - " K H M ~ ~ XMBOT~". M - nMUleTCfl BCe. Bce, YTO H ~ O ~ X O -

AMMO 3 H a T b 0 YeJIOBeKe, ~ 0 ~ 0 p b l f i XHJI C HBMU H OTOUeJ I OT HBC.. . m M 3 ~ b BCfl HaCKB03b - BenWKOe A e n O H e 3 a M e T H O - MWIeHbKMX JIH)ae#,

H e c ~ p b l ~ a f i ~ e MX pacow, IIOKaXMTe ee ... XOYy, MOJIOAO~~ YeJIOBeK, 4 ~ 0 6 6 1 HMYTO, A O C T O ~ ~ H O ~ BHHMaHHfl , H e MCYe3nO 1.13 n a M R T H nlonek. A B XM3HM - BCe A O C T O ~ ~ H O B a U l e r O BHHMaHHfl. M - M O ~ ~ O ! x M 3 ~ b HeAO-

CTaTOYHO y I I n O T H e H a , M ~ m b 1 f i H 3 H a C YYBCTByeT c e 6 f l 6e3 O n O P b l B

H e # MMeHHO IIOTOMy, C y A a p b M O ~ , YTO MbI HeBHHMaTeJIbHbI K AH)-

~ I M ...". HO YTO T a M I I p ~ n e ~ a p ~ ~ M f i n H C a T e J I b , K O r A a T a K M e TMTaHbI ,

KaK Tonc~ofi M A O C T O ~ B C K M ~ ~ , CTpeMMJIMCb 3aBf l3aTb KOHTaKT C @ e ~ 0 - POBblM - HaCTOJIbKO BbICKa3aHHan MM MAefl COOTBeTCTBOBalla TOMY, YTO

OHM YYBCTBOBWIM M IIMCWIM 3 m O J I r O A 0 TOTO, KaK n p O C J I b l u l m H 0 YyAa-

K o B a T o M MOCKOBCKOM 6 ~ 6 n ~ o ~ e ~ a p e . B nnqe BTMX m b 1 6 c a M a uaccu - YeCKafl PyCCKaR J IMTepaTypa CIIelrrMJIa 3 a c ~ M A e T e J I b c T B o B a T b CBOe nOY-

T e H n e " O 6 ~ e ~ y ~ e n y " . BOT M H a c T a n a nopa B e p H y T b c n K roronlo, o r n a c M B u r e M y c o K p o B e s -

H o e X e n a H M e n e ~ p a ~ B ~ H O B M Y ~ ~ O ~ Y M H C K O ~ O B c a ~ b I f i , Ka3WIOCb 6b1,

~ e n o . & X o A H ~ M f i JlJ'Ifl T o r 0 MOMeHT. Bce 3 T 0 H e c l l Y Y a f i ~ 0 . B e ~ b H e I I e H b - Ky, H e BOPBaHb , a UMeHHO MepTBble AyI l lH C K y n a e T HYHKOB. T O ~ X ~ C T - BeHHO O H H 3 B n e K a e T HX H a CBeT 6ox~f i U 3 ~ ~ B ~ T H O # UKaTyJIKU: a K o r -

A a OH B3rJIflHyJI nOTOM H a 3 T H JIMCTMKH, H a MYXMKOB, KOTOPbIe, TOYHO,

6 b m M KOrAa-TO MYXHKBMM, ~ ~ ~ O T X I I M , naXXJlH, nbflHCTBOBXJlM, M3B03-

HMYWIM, O ~ M ~ H ~ I B W I H 6ap, a M O X e T 6 b 1 ~ b , M npOCTO 6 b 1 n w XOPOUMMM

MYXMKaMI.1, TO KaKOe-TO CTpaHHOe , HenOHf lTHOe e M y CaMOMy YYBCTBO

OBJIi3&eJIO HM. K s u y n a f l H 3 3anMCOYeK KaK ~ Y A T O MMeJIa K~KO#-TO OCO-

6b1# xapamep, H qepes TO KaK ~ ~ A T O 6 b 1 camre MYXUKM nonyqanu CBOR C O ~ C T B ~ H H L I ~ ~ xapamep. MYXUKM, n p n H a n n e x a B m M e KOPO~OY- Ke , BCe nOYTM 6 b 1 n ~ C nPMAaTKaMM H n p 0 3 B H q a M M ... P ~ ~ C T P Co6a~e- BUYa n O p a X m H ~ O ~ ~ ~ K H O B ~ H H O H ) ITOJIHOTOH) M O ~ C T O I I T ~ J I ~ H O C T M ~ ~ -

HM OAHO M3 KaYeCTB M y X M K a H e 6 b 1 n 0 n p O n y q e H 0 : 06 OAHOM 6 b m o

C K ~ ~ ~ H O ''xopour~fi CTOJIRP", ~ p y r o ~ y n p M n M c a H 0 661~10 "CM~ICJIHT M

XMeJIbHOrO H e 6epe~". 0 3 H a Y e H 0 6 b 1 n o T a m e O ~ C T O R T ~ ~ ~ H O , K T 0 OTeU

1 U K T 0 MaTb , H KBKOJO 06a ~ ~ I J I H nOBeAeHUfl ; y OAHOrO TOJIbKO KaKOrO-

TO @ ~ A O T O B ~ 6 b 1 n o HanHCaHO: ' ' O T ~ U HeH3BeCTHO KTO, a POAUnCfl OT

ABOPOBO# AeBKH K ~ ~ H T o J I u H ~ I , HO XOpOlrrerO H p a B a H H e BOP". Bce CUM ~ O A P O ~ H O C T M I I P U A a B m M K B K O ~ ~ - T O O C O ~ ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ BHP. CBeXeCTM:

KasWIOCb, KaK ~ ~ A T O MYXHKM ewe B y e p a 6 b m ~ XHBbI . CMOTPII A O n r O

H a MMeHa MX, OH YMMnHJICfl &)%OM H, B3AOXHyBWM, npOH3HeC: "6a- TIOUlKH MOM, CKOAbKO BaC 3AeCb H ~ ~ M Y K ~ H O ! TO Bbl, CePAeYHbIe MOM,

n O A e J I b 1 B U H H a B e K y C B O ~ M ? KaK n e p e 6 u ~ a n w c b ? " M r J I a3a er0 HeBOJIb-

HO OCTaHOBMJIMCb H a OAHO# @ ~ M M I I M M , 3 T 0 6 b 1 n M ~ B ~ C T H ~ I # n e ~ p Ca- B e n b e B H e y ~ a ~ a f i - K o p b 1 ~ 0 , I I p M ~ ~ e ~ a ~ l r r l l f i KOrAa-TO J I O M e U M U e

Kopo6o~ ~ e . . .*. Aanee C n e A y e T ~ e 3 a 6 b l ~ a e ~ a f l CepUf l B O C C T ~ H O B J I ~ H U ~ ~ X M J H e H H O r O

nyTM C ~ e n a ~ a n p o 6 ~ ~ , M ~ K C H M ~ T ~ J I ~ ~ T H u K o B ~ , Enusasen BOPO~LII H MHOrMX APYTMX.

MOXHO 6 b 1 n o 6 b 1 BCnOMHHTb 0 H a Y U b H b I X U a r a X r 0 r 0 J I R H a MCTO-

PHYeCKOM f lOnpMlUe H H a 3TOM OCHOBaHHH CYeCTb er0 e q e OAHMM "M3

HBUIHX", A a COBeCTb H e nO3BOJIfleT. Aeno B TOM, YTO B O C K ~ ~ C U T ~ ~ ~ H ~ I # na@oc H e o T n e n n M OT ero n n c a T e n b c K o r o A a p a M ~o f i s e n w s e c ~ ~ e ~ ~ o i i 323,QaYU, KOTOPYH) OH AaBHO nOCTaBMn I I e p e A ~06010. n o M H e H U l o

A 6 p a ~ a Tepqa, "ero noma - TO K y n q a R K p e r I o c T b , ~ ~ K ~ I O Y ~ H H ~ R H a

O C B O ~ O X A ~ H M ~ Y e n o B e q e c T s a OT c M e p M , H a o B n a n e H M e M H ~ O M c no- M O U ~ H ) c n o B a . X a n b , c n e n K a H e c o c ~ o ~ n a c b ...''. M eqe: "B rorone RB-

A e H a 3 a 6 b I ~ a f l C O B ~ ~ M ~ H H O ~ ~ CnOBeCHOCTbH) CBfl3b C M3HaYaJlbH0fi Ma-

rweii, q e M H e K o r A a n p o M b r l r r n R n o UCKYCCTBO, q e M A o n r o OHO o c T a B a -

n O C b M, 6 b 1 ~ b MOXeT, e q e OCTaeTCfl m e - T O B m y 6 M ~ e Ay l r rH no CKPLITO#, B H F P ~ H H ~ # CYTH, J I P ~ A C T ~ B J J ~ H H O # TaK HarJJflAHO B TBOPYe-

CTBe r 0 r 0 J I f l . B H e M CHJIbHee, YeM B K O M - ~ ~ 6 0 , n p O C T y n W I a TeMHaf l na- MIITb 0 B O ~ U ~ ~ ~ H O M 3HaYeHMM HbIHe 6 e 3 ~ p e A H b I x M HUKYeMHbIX np0- q e c c o B . O~qero M XYAOXHUK B H e M 6e3 K o H q a p a 3 ~ ~ p a n c n c r p a x a M H H

O ~ R ~ ~ H H O C T I I M H n o T e p f l B u e r o y n p a a n e H M e H ~ , Q CBOMMM r a p a m s ~ a x a -

PR, n e n c ~ ~ o ~ a ~ ~ l e r o B Y c n o B n R x , K o r n a ero H a s a m n e H M R p a c c M a T p n n a -

nMCb BCeMM no KnaCCy 3CTeTMKH M @ ~ H T ~ ~ M H " ~ ~ . M n0 KnaCCy MCTO-

PMH - A O ~ ~ B M M MbI pro domo SUO. B n p o ~ e ~ , H e n b 3 H Xe BO BCeM BepWTb

Tepuy! TO, M O X e T 661~6, XIX BeK 3 a 6 b m 0 CBR3M CnOBa, J IMTePaTypbI W

MCTOPWM C M B T W ~ ~ , a XX BeK 0 Hef i O Y e H b n a X e BCnOMHMA. HO H e C n O -

P U T b Xe c e f i Y a c 0 nOCTMOnePHW3Me ... B 0 3 b ~ e ~ H ~ B e f i l L l k i # n p W M e p . Ampeii M ~ K M H , " I l M ~ a ~ e n b 3 e M n M

@ P ~ H U Y ~ C K O ~ ~ " , O n n c b r B a e T n e p e x w B a n w R o T p o K a w 3 rnyxoro sa~onx- c K o r o ropona, co3epualoqero T p e x K p a c a e n s c n o x e n ~ e s l r r e R rase^-

H 0 f i BbIpe3KM: "BOT T v - T O M H e H a YM, BHOBb O ~ P ~ T M B U I M ~ ~ C R K T p e M

K p a c a B n u a M , npnrrrna 3 ~ a MbIcnb . II c ~ a a a n ce6e: HO s e n b 661~10 me B c e -

T a m B MX X H ~ H W TO R c H o e , c B e x e e o c e H H e e y ~ p o . B T ~ m e R , ycerra- HaR OnaBWHMW JIMCTbRMW, rfle OHM OCTaHOBWnMCb H a KaKOe-TO MTHO-

BeHMe M 3aMepJ lM nepen O ~ % ~ K T W B O M , OCTaHOBMB 3 T 0 MTHOBeHMe ... Aa, 6 b m o B MX X M 3 H H OAHO RPKOe O C e H H e e yrp0 ... ~ T W HeMHOrWe CnOBa CO-

BepllIMnW q y n 0 . M60 B H e 3 a n H O R BCeMM IlRTbH) YYBCTBaMW O W f l H n

MrHOBeHMe, OCTaHOBJleHHOe y n b 1 6 ~ 0 f i T p e X X e H q M H . OYyTMnCR n p R - MO B ero o c e H H w x sanaxax. H03npn MOM T p e n e T a n M ... Aa, R x n n non- HO, H a C b I q e H H O XWA B WX B P ~ M ~ H H ! " .

repoh M n a n b u r e w c n o n b 3 y e ~ TOT M ~ X ~ H W ~ M : "~peo6pame~we T p e x

KpaCaBWu n03BOJ lRnO HWeRTbCR, YTO YYAO MOXHO IlOBTOPWTb. fi XOPO-

U O HOMHMn TY nPOCTYIO @pa3Y, KOTOPaR eTO Bb13BaJIa ...". H OH C YCne-

XOM I IpMMeHReT 3TOT I l pMeM, 3WyMaBUlWCb I lOCne M 0 POnM 113bIKa B

"OXMBJI~HHM KIPTWH" ... a u a p n ~ ~ a r 0 B O p M n a I I O - @ ~ ~ H ~ ~ ~ C K H . A MOr-

J Ia 6 6 1 M no-PYCCKH. BTO HWYerO H e OTHRnO 661 y BOCC03naHHOrO MrHO-

BeHMR. ~ H ~ Y W T , CYUeCTByeT YTO-TO BPOAe R3bIKa-IlOCpeAHWKa. YHM- B e p c a J b H b ~ f i R ~ ~ I K ! CHOBa BCnOMHUn 0 TOM MeX'bR3bIYbe, KOTOpOe

OTKpb ln 6naronap~ OrOBOpKe , 0 " ~ 3 b I K e Y A M B ~ ~ H H R " . TOT~I-TO B n e p -

BbIe ~ 0 i i YM n p O H H 3 W l a MbICJIb: a YTO, e C n H H a 3TOM R3bIKe MOXHO nM-

c a ~ b ? II cen H a non w s a ~ p b r n rnasa. II ouryuan B ce6e ~ n 6 p w p y r o q y ~ ~ BeUJeCTBeHHOCTb BCeX 3TMX X H ~ H ~ B . . . ) > ~ ~ .

TO AM nOBepYMBbIe @ p a H u y 3 6 1 n n e H W n M C b 3 ~ 3 0 T W K 0 f i RCTWH,

pyCCKWX AUTepaTOpOB BlIOAHe 6 a H a n b H b r x , TO AM BCflOMHWAH, 9 T O 0

YeM-TO I I O A O ~ H O M n M C N l H e K O r n a M a p c e n b ~ P ~ C T , HO, BO BCRKOM C n y -

qae, M ~ K U H co6pan 6 e c n p e u e n e ~ ~ ~ b r f i ypoxafi n n T e p a T y p H b I x npe- M M Z ~ , HaYMHaR C B b l ~ l L I e f i ~ O H K J ' ~ O B C K O ~ ~ . ,&Dl HaC Xe B a X H O nOYTM

IIOnHOe er0 C O B n W e H M e C P a C C ~ e H M R M W K a p c a B M H a 0 " B Y ~ B C T B O B ~ -

HMM" n "conepemw~a~nw" KaK o ~ e o 6 x o n n ~ b 1 x marax H a nyrw K no- CTMXeHHH) B C ~ ~ A M H C T B ~ .

n 0 n B e A e ~ UTOTW. f l H e npM3bIBaH) WCTOPMKOB rHaTbCH HM 3a ~ O H K Y -

po~ceofi npe~weii , HW naxe 3a E y ~ e p o ~ c ~ o i i . 6onee T o r o , HM B K o e M . C n f l a e R H e npM3bIBa lO AX BO BCeM CneAOBaTb n P W M e p Y K a p c a B M ~ a ,

Teii~pa ne Ulapne~a n Qenoposa. B e n b c T o n n o n p e K p a c H o M y wc~opw- KY K ~ P C ~ B M H Y c @ o ~ M ~ J I M ~ o B ~ T ~ CBOlO M ~ T ~ @ w ~ M Y ~ c K Y ~ O CMCTeMY, K I K

OH nOKMHyn H a m y HayKy. T a n a H ~ n W B b ~ f i n a n e O H T O n O r , 0~Kpb1BlLIWfi CM-

H a H T p o n a , T e f i f f p ne LLIapne~ nocne n y 6 n ~ ~ a q w n c B o e r o " Q e ~ o ~ e ~ a Y e n 0 B e K a " OCTaTOK BpeMeHW IIOTpaTWn H a C n O p b I C PWMOM. PYMHHU~B- CKaR 6 w 6 n n o ~ e ~ a OCMpOTena, KaK TOnbKO ~ e H M ~ b H b 1 f i 6~6nnorpa@ Qenopo~ c@op~ynnpoaan H a K o H e q CBOW " Q > n n o c o @ n m o61ue1-o ne- na", n p w c T y n w B K ee n p o n a r a H A e . H ~ T , M ~ I M T a K n o T e p R n w AOCT~TOY-

HO CBOHX KOAJIer, 3MWTpMpOBaBUIMX B 0 6 n a ~ ~ b S W C T O ~ ~ 3nACTeMOnO-

TWW.

Ho, 6 6 1 ~ 6 MOXeT, n p M B e n e H H b I e n p M M e p b I U PaCCyXjleHWR I l O M O r V

H a M JIflUe IIOHRTb c e 6 ~ . ~ O H H T ~ , YTO nOMWMO W C T O ~ M O ~ ~ @ M Y ~ C K O ~

MOAbI M B H y ~ p e H H e f i JIOrMKW HayKM CylI.leCTByeT e 4 e W eCTeCTBeHHaR

T H r a MCTOpWKa K OXWBneHMlO n p O U n O r 0 , yxOP,HlI.laH B CeAylO A p e B -

HOCTb H a U I e f i n p o @ e c c W W , B T e B p e M e H a , K O r n a MbI, n e f i C ~ B W ~ e n b H 0 ,

ewe H e OTflenMnMCb H e TOnbKO OT nMTepaTYpb l MnM OT ~ O ~ O C ~ O B H R , HO

W OT MarMW. M IlOMHWTb, YTO X e n a H M e OTKnMKHyrbCR H a npM3bIB n e~ - pa H B ~ H O B M Y ~ ~ O ~ M H H C K O T O YpeBaTO Cepbe3HbIMM IlOCneACTBWRMM,

M a H R q W M M IlepCneKTHBaMW M B03MOXHbIMH IlOTepRMM. HO B n m 6 o ~ c n y y a e - TO " O C H O B H O ~ ~ MHCTMHKT" M c T o p n K a .

I Kapcaeun 1.n. Oc~oebr cpenHeeeKo- eoii pennrnosHocTn B XII-XI11 6eKa.X npeMMylUeCTBeHH0 B MtaJtnn. C n 6 . , 1915. C . 6.

2 CM., HanpnMep: flcmpe6uyrca~ A.J. Mc- ~ o p n ~ - ~ e n n e e n c ~ n e e n n a ~ o ~ o e n q K a p c a s n ~ (1882-1952). M., 1991.

3 3 ~ c m 0.1 Heuuu jle B n a y c coepe- MeHHOCTbK). "Munepa~op @pnnpnx 11" BpHCTa K ~ H T O ~ O B U ~ ~ B nonnTnqe- CKOA IIOneMHKe BpeMeH B e i i ~ a p c ~ o i i pecny6nn~n // Onncceii, 1996. M., 1997. Kapcaeun 1.n. 0 c ~ o e t . 1 ... C. 12- 13.

5 Kapcasun 1.n. Beene~ne B UCTOPHIO (~eopnn nc~opnn) . nc, 1920. C . 33- 34.

6 T a ~ x e . C. 15. Tau me. C. 26.

8 Guywulu n. M. Oqepm teopnn ncTopn- r e c ~ o i i Haym. npara, 1925.

9 OH ccunancn npn TOM Ha nepeeon m n p o ~ o n 3 ~ e c ~ ~ o i i K H H ~ H : 1anz- Bya N., Cenbo6oc 3. Bsene~ne B N3Y- seHne HCTOPHH. Cn6. , 1899.

lo Kapcaeun 1.n. Bsene~ne B ncTopnK). .. C . 25.

T ~ M me. C. 16. 12 Knpcasun 1.17. @nnoco@nn ncTopnn.

Cn6. , 1993. C. 65.

13 T ~ K , apxeonorn, 3a pensaiilunM nc- WIKNCHHeM, HNKOrna He flPH3HaIOTCfl B ceonx ~ o ~ o r p a @ n n x B TOM, 'ITO oHn oqeHb n d n ~ e 3 a n ~ b B 3 ~ c n e n n u n ~ .

14 Kapcaeun J.n. B~eneHne B nc-ropn ro... C. 29.

15 Kaocasun 1.n. Qnnoco@nn ncTopnn. ~ . ' 1 1 7 - 1 1 6 .

16 Kuccem M.A. P.nx. Konnn~lrsyn - WCTOPHK H @ W ~ O C O @ // KonnnHr- eyn P .nx . m e n ncTopnn. M. , 1980. 6 . 4 2 4 .

l7 Kapcaeun 1.n. B s e n e ~ n e B nc~Opn 0..

C. 10. 18 T ~ M me. C. 26. I 9 T ~ M me. 20 Kapcaeun 1.H. n x n o p n a ~ o I j p y ~ o .

6epnnH, 1923. K ~ n r a 6b1na HanncaHa 3HaYWTenbHO paHbWe H nOnXHa 6bma neraTaTbcfl B ne~porpme, HO B~UIBO- petlne aeTopa Ha " @ n n o c o @ c ~ o ~ na- poxone" 1922 r. cnenano ee rc3na~ne B

POCCW ti HeB03MOXHblM. 21 O c ~ a e ~ c n , npasna, Haaewa, 'ITO KO-

ma-nn6o nepeeenyr c nnToscKom ero np0CTpaHHblfi KypC "MCTopnn eBp0- nei ic~oii ~ y n b ~ y p b ~ " , HO, no ~ c e i i se- PORTHOCTW, H OH OTHOCHTCn CKOpee K

nCT~ptf~C~@nn, YeM K K O H K P ~ T H O ~ ~ ncropnn.

3 2 + M H ~ R MCTOPMR O HeB03MOXHOCTH

22 Kapcasu~ 1.17. Saligia, HnH Becb~a j0 Kapcasu~ 1.17. Cer~ble o~qbi . .. MHKP0BCTOPI.II.I ~ p a ~ ~ o e H nyurenone3~oe pa.3~~1lure- C. 138. tine o Gore, Mnpe, qenoselce, 3ne H ce- 31 Telinp de Urapde~ 17. O ~ H O M ~ H qenose- MH CMePTHblX rpeXaX. ns , 1919; OH ~ a . M., 1987. C. 210. xe. Noctes pet ropolitanae. Ilc, 1922. 3Z T ~ M me. C. 208.

23 60iry08 M.A. He no ~0Hlla3a6bltblfi Me- 33 &dOpos H . 0 . CO'~HH~HHR. M., 1982. nneencr ~3 ~ ~ O X H P~CCKOCO ~onep- C. 8 1. n p n ~ e r a ~ e n b ~ o , VTO mn 60pb- Ha // Kapcasn~ Jl.ll. M o ~ a u ~ e c ~ e o e 6bl c nueek npoIpecca Oeuopos ccbl- cpen~ne s e a . M., 1992. C. 14. nae~cn ~a P e ~ a ~ a H name ~a Orloma

24 Kapcosu~ 1.17. Bsene~ne B HCTO~HIO. . . KOHT~. c. 33. Ce~e~oeo C. Hn~onafi Qenopoe: mop-

25 T ~ M xe. qecreo X H ~ H H . M., 1990. C. 151-152. 26 Kapcaeun 1 . n . noma o cklepm. Kay- 3sTau me. C. 65-66.

~ a c , 1932. C. 15. j6 CUHR~CKUI~ A&. (A6pm Zpy). B TeHn 27 T ~ M me. C. 24. roronn // Co6p. coy. M., 1992. T. 2. 28 Kapcoeu~ 1.17. Csn~ue O T U ~ I H ynre- C. 290-291. Cu. no~a3a~ena~oe mn

nn ueplten: Pac~pmne npaeocnaenn e H ~ C ~ a 3 ~ a ~ n e nocneu~eil mam: HX TBOP~HHRX. M., 1994. C. 138-140. " M e p s ~ e eoc~pecalcrr. Bnepen - K

29 1occ~uli B.H. Aomarnqec~oe 6 o m e HCTOK~M!". ane // Oqep~ MHcrHqeCKOTD 6 0 m o s m j7 Makine A. Le Testament Fran~ais. R, Bocro~~ofi uepmu. M., 1991. C. 286. 1995. l? 168-169, 251.

17.K). Ysapoe

B o c ~ ~ o y ~ a o i i mnre "JIornqe- clure o m n 6 ~ n HCTO~UKOB" A. Qnwep n n u e T : " Y q e ~ b ~ e n o - n p e x ~ e ~ y ~ c e p b e s cnopm, H a n p n M e p , o TOM, c n e n y e T nn MCTOPWKY 0606~ua~b. C TeM Xe YCneXOM M ~ X H O 3WIaBaTbCR BOnpOCOM, C n e n y e T JIH MCTOPHKy

rOBOPMTb CJlOBaMH. 0 6 0 6 q e ~ n ~ my60~0 YKOpeHeHbI B er0 R3bIKe, B

ero M ~ I ~ ~ ~ H H M , B ero cnoc06ax O ~ ~ R C H R T L M M P " ~ . C 3~0fi TOqKH 3 p e H H R BeCb I lpOeKT MHKPOHCTOPMH - O n H a 6 o n b u r a r r

n o r n r e c K a R ourn6~a. B 6onee p a 3 1 3 e p ~ y ~ o R @ o p M e TOT T e 3 n c MOT 6 6 1

BbIlTUIneTb n p H M e p H 0 TaK.

M W K ~ O H C T O ~ H R KaK J T O r H q e C m He3aBHCMMaR no O T H O U e H H l o K

MaKPOHCTOPUM MeTO.5OJlOrHYeCKa(I I lepCneKTMBa BO3MOXHa n p M Bbl-

n o n H e H n n o n H o r o n3 nByX ycno~nji: nn60 ecnn o H a o T K a x e T c f l OT n p e ~ I l O J l a r a l o l U M X 0606me~ne MHTeJLJleKTyanbHbIX CTaHnapTOB, nn60 ecnn O H a ~ b I p a 6 0 ~ a e ~ T a K H e @ O P M ~ I O ~ O ~ ~ ~ H M R , KOTOPbIe 6 y w nOCH-

qeCKM He3aBHCMMbI OT TeX, H a KOTOPbIX OCHOBaHa MBKPOHCTOPHR. TO B T o p o e ycnosne MOXHO n e p e a o p ~ y n n p o s a ~ b KaK co3na~ne c a M o c T o R -

TeJ lbHof i CMCTeMbI MCTOPHLIeCKHX I I O H R T M ~ . B e ~ b MMeHHO B HCTOPHLIe-

ClurX IIOHRTHRX, COBpeMeHHaR CMCTeMa KOTOPbIX CJIOXMJlaCb B CBR3M C

a o p ~ n p o e a ~ n e ~ npoema M a K p o n c T o p n n , 3 a n o x e ~ b 1 npucyqne 3 ~ 0 1

J I o c J l e n H e f i ( ~ O C T ~ T O ~ H O p a 3 ~ 0 0 6 p a 3 ~ b r e ) @OPMU 0 6 0 6 q e ~ n ~ . n03- TOMY n y T b MMKPOWCTOPHH K J l ~ r M q e ~ ~ ~ f i aBTOHOMM1.I M O X e T n p O J l e r a T b

TOnbKO Y e p e 3 C O 3 n a H H e n a p W I J l e n b H 0 f i CMCTeMbI MCTOPl lqeCMX nOHR - TUG ( K O T O P ~ I ~ 6 y p . y ~ OCHOBaHbI H a OTJlHqHbIX OT 3a l IOXeHHblX B C y W -

CTBYIOIUHX nOHRTMRXJlOrM9eCKWX M ~ X ~ H H ~ M ~ X ) . ~ O C K O ~ ~ K Y BbInOnHe-

H H e O ~ O H X yKa3aHHbIX ~cJIoBH# IlpenCTaBJlReTCR ~ ~ o ~ J I ~ M ~ T H Y H ~ I M ,

MMKPOMCTOPMR @ ~ K T H ~ ~ C K M BO3MOXHa JlMIIIb IIOCTOnbKy, nOCKOJIbKy

O H a MCnOnb3yeT MaKPOMCTOPMYeCKMe nOHRTMR M, CJIeAOBaTenbHO, HM-

IlnMUMTHO OTCblJlaeT K M ~ K P O W C T O P M ~ ~ C K O ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ J I ~ M ~ T H K ~ , UHbIMH CnOBaMM - nOCKOJIbKy O H a RBJlReTCR 0 n H 0 f i H 3 HCCJIeAOBaTenbCKHX

TeXHMK MaKpOMCTOPMM. C J ~ ~ ~ O B ~ T ~ J I ~ H O , ~ ~ H H C T B ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ p e a J I b ~ b I #

Bb160p MMKPOMCTOPMM - Mew)' ~ K C ~ J ~ M U M T H O ~ ~ M W M I I ~ M U W T H O ~ ~ 3a- BHCMMOCTbfO OT MIKPOHCTOPHW.