Notulensi Pre Workshop 5

8/12/2019 Notulensi Pre Workshop 5

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/notulensi-pre-workshop-5 1/7

!"# %&"'()&* +

!,-./0120340 140 !,03,.5.440

146 7/./%203 6,74-4 8,-!412

95.4:5-46/ ./0846 6,985- 140 8-406 905%.,13,

9;<;=>;"?#= .?=@'A=@#= B?CA*

/D 7484840 !-56,6

:43/40 !,-84E4F !,E:29440

B#"?G8#=@@#H F IJ KA=? LMIN

-A#=@ F -A#=@ 9&<?(? 3;CA=@ // :!!8 H#=>#? JO KHD EBD 8)#<"?= 0&D PO K#'#">#

%#'>A F MQDJM R (;H;(#?

1?SA'# &H;) ';>A# >?< C#"? 9.BD /SA 461,!E;H?)#> *&H?TU *#*;"O #*# @&#H C#"? <#(?=@L (>#'; )&HC;" C#"? *;<;"?=>#)O (V#(># <#A*A=

.6EO ?>AH#) U#=@ #'#= C?';HA#"'#= C#H#< @"#=C V&"'()&*D B#"? ?=? <;=U;<*A"=#'#= '#W?#=

*"&@"#< U#=@ (AC#) #C# C#= (AC#) C?T&S# A=>A' C?"#=@'A<D 9?># #'#= <;H?)#> '&=C?(?

'#"#'>;"?(>?' C#= >?*&H&@? 146 7?H?VA=@ X(H?C; U@ C?*;"H?)#>'#= #C#H#) >) LMMPO <;<?=># <#(

-#C?> A=>A' <;=T#"? U@ LMIJY

8AWA#= C#"? '&=(;* *#*;" ?=? #C#H#) A=>A' <;=U?#*'#= (A#>A C&'A<;= U@ >;"?=>;@"#(? C#=

'&H#S&"#>?Z (;)?=@@# <;=W#C? C#(#" A=>A'W *;=@;H&H##= 1#( 7?H?VA=@D

E&<;=>A< ?=? (#=@#> >;*#> (;'#H? '#";=# #'#= >;"W#C? *;"@#=>?#= *;<;"?=>#)#= (;)?=@@#

S;")#"#* #@#" C&'A<;= ?=? S;>AHL (A#>A C&'A<;= U#=@ ?<*H;<;=>#>?Z (;)?=@@# C#*#>C?(#<*#?'#= ';*#C# *;<;"?=>#) U#=@ S#"AD 1#"? )#(?H ;[#HA#(?O S#)V# ';S?W#'#=L U#=@

(AC#) #C# S;HA< <;<#(A''#= \!"#$%#&#'$(") C?<#=# C#>#S#(;=U# (AC#) #C# >;>#*? 'A"#=@

H;=@'#*D B#"#*#==U# H;S?) W#A) #'#= C?S;=>A' *$+,-./0. 2"$"0.3.$% 4.$%.5 U#=@ (AC#)

C??<*H;<;=>#(? U#=@ =#<#=U# <#(?) C#H#< V#T#=#D K#C? T#*#?#==U# C;=@#= #C#=U# (A#>A

"A<A(#= A(AH#= ';@?#>#= U@ >;"?=>;@"#(?D 9;<AC?#= C#H#< (>"#>;@?T *H#==?=@O ?=? WA@#

>;=>A=U# *;=>?=@D K#C? *;"<#(#H#)#==U# S?(# '?># "#(#'#= C#= '?># H?)#> C;=@#= #C#=U# C#U#

CA'A=@ #?" U@ >?C#' S#?'O C#U# "A(#' #?"O (U(>;< ?=Z&"<#(?O C#= >;"=U#># WA<H#) '&=>"?SA(?

S;S#= *;=T;<#"#= #?" >;"A( <;=?=@'#> (;)?=@@# 'V#H?>#( C#"? 1#( 7?H?VA=@ ?=? >;"T;<#"D

E#( -#C?> S?(# C?[#HA#(? S;"#*# S?#U# U#=@ C?';HA#"'#= C#H#< *;"?&C; *;<;"?=>#)#=

(;'#"#=@ W#C? IM >) ?=? S;"#*# S?#U# U#=@ >;H#) C?';HA#"'#=O W#C? S?#U# (;'?#= >"?H?A= SA'#=

<;=W#C? 1#( 7?H?VA=@ <;=W#C? H;S?) S#?' >;>#*? <#H#) (AC#) >;"T;<#" S;"#>D

4@;=C# ';C;*#==U# '?># WA@# ";Z;" '; E1@(O >#"@;>=U# #C#H#) *;=U;C?##= #?" <?=A< ?>A

)#"A( T#'A*#= *;"*?*##==U# X>#"@;> E13?( <?HH;==?A< C;[;H&*<;=> @&#H(]Q^Y C#= ?=?

>;"=U#># S;HA< #C# (#>A*A= U#=@ >;"T#*#?D 1#"? 46,40 ?>A #C# 6A(>#?=#SH; 7?>UO (#H#) (#>A

*;"(U#"#>#==U# #C#H#) <;H?)#> S#@#?<#=# *;H#U#=#= A=>A' #?" <?=A<D 1#"? '&>#L U#=@

C?A(AH'#= (##> *;">;<A#= C? 6A"#S#U# C?#=>#"#=U# C#"? :#H?'*#*#= C#= E#H#=@O >;"=U#>#



T"?>;"?# <;=@;=#? #?" <?=A< ?=? C?*;">#=U#'#=D 1?(?=? W;H#( (;'#H? S#)V# '?># >?C#' *A=U# C#>#

(#<# (;'#H? <;=@;=#? )#H ?=?D K#C? >;"=U#># C#>#S#(; ?=? (#=@#> *;=>?=@O >#># T#"#

<;=@A<*AH'#= C#># ?=? WA@# *;=>?=@O '?># (C) S#=U#' <;H#'A'#= A*#U#L >;>#*? >?C#'

>;"*ASH?'#(? C#= >;"?=Z&"<#(?'#= (;)?=@@# )#=U# &"#=@ U#=@ <;H#'A'#= ';@?#>#= ?>A (#W#

U#=@ >#A S#)V# C?# (AC#) S;"SA#> (;(A#>AO W#C? <#(U#"#'#> S;HA< <;=@;>#)A?D 8;"'#?> WA@#

C;=@#= *"&@"#< -!KE ';C;*#= ?>A ';>#)#=#= *#=@#= C#= ';>#)#=#= ;=;"@UO ?=? (#=@#> ;"#>(;'#H? WA@# <;=@;=#? *;=C#U#@A=##= #?"D 1#( ?>A >;"<#(A' V?H#U#) (;*#C#= (A=@#?D

!;=;@#'#= )A'A< WA@# *;=>?=@ >;"'#?> C;=@#= S#@#?<#=# C;=@#= *;"#>A"#= U#=@ (AC#) #C#

C??<*H;<;=>#(?'#= U#=@ *#H?=@ =U#># >;"H?)#> #C#H#) <;=@;=#? !;"#>A"#= 8#># -A#=@ >)

LMM]D 8#># -A#=@ ?=? C?SA#> !;"#>A"#==U#O C?SA#> -28-1=U# -22%O >;>#*? >;"=U#># C#H#<

?<*H;<;=>#(?=U# H;S?) S#=U#' <;H#=@@#" *;"#>A"#= U#=@ (AC#) C?>;>#*'#=D !;=C;'#>#=

)A'A< C#= *;=@#V#(#= <#(?) >;"(;'<;=>#(?D

E;=@;=#? *;"#= (;"># <#(U#"#'#>O (#=@#> *;=>?=@ '#";=# S#@#?<#=#*A= *;"#= (;">#

<#(U#"#'#> (#=@#> C?SA>A)'#=O ?>A (;S#S=U# S#@#?<#=# <;<SA#> ?=Z&"<#(? C#=

<;=U;S#"'#==U# C;=@#= S#)#(# U#=@ <AC#) C?<;=@;">? C#= (#"#=# A=>A' <;H#*&"'#= W?'#

#C# *;=T;<#"#= #?" (A=@#?D E#(U#"#'#> WA@# S;HA< <;=@;>#)A? S#@#?<#=# T#"#

*;=@;H&H##= H?<S#) C&<;(>?TO '#";=# ?=Z&"<#(? U#=@ (#=@#> 'A"#=@D

!;"HA #C#=U# H;#C?=@ #T>&" (;S#@#? *;=@;H&H##= (;T#"# >;"*#CA C#"? T?H?VA=@ ?=? *#C#

V&"'()&* '; N C?T;>A('#=O S#@#?<#=# W?'# 9.B <;=W#C? H;#C?=@ (;T>&"=U#D

1#"? *"; V&"'()&* I (GC NO '#<? (AC#) <;<SA#> (A#>A *;"#>A"#= C#= ";@AH#(? (;"># *"&@"#<

U#=@ (AC#) C?H#'(#=#'#= &H;) (;HA"A) (>#';)&HC;"D 6;S;>AH=<U#( ';@?#>#==U# (AC#) S#=U#'

>#*? >?C#' >;"H?)#> )#(?H U#=@ H;S?) <#_?<#HD

1#( 7?H?VA=@ C? (;'<;= 6AC?"<#=O 8)#<"?=O 9A=?=@#= C#= (;<A#=U# )#=U# <;<S;H? #H#>A=>A' <;=W;"=?)'#= #?" (#W#O '?<?#=U# S;HA<O W#C? Z?(?' (#W#D K?'# #C# >#<A #(?=@ (?#*#*A=

U#=@ #'#= <;H?)#> S#@#?<#=# *;=@;H&H##= #?" C? /=C&=;(?# ?=? (AC##) #C# T&=>&) U#=@ S?(#

C?S#=@@#'#=D

9;=C#H#=U# C#H#< *;H#'(#=##= *"&@"#< 146 7?H?VA=@ ?=? TA'A* S#=U#'D 6AC#)

>;"?C;=>?Z?'#(?O #=>#"# H#?= #C#H#) [&HA<; H?<S#)=U# U#=@ <;=?=@'#> >;"A( C#= S;"S#C?=@

HA"A( C;=@#= WA<H#) *;=CACA' U#=@ #C#O ';<AC?#= <#(#H#) *;=U;C?##= *;=C#=##==U#O

'#H#A A=>A' *;<;"?=>#) C#;"#) (;H#HA >?C#' S?(# <;=TA'A*? A=>A' <;<SA#> #'(? =U#>#D KA@#

';(#C#"#= <#(U#"#'#>O <;('?*A= (AC#) S#=U#' V#"@# C?(;*#=W#=@ 1#( 7?H?VA=@ U#=@ (AC#)

(#C#" >;>#*? (;S#@?#= <#(?) <;<#=Z##>'#= #?" (A=@#? >;"(;SA>D 4H?) @A=# H#)#= <#(?) >;"W#C?<;('?*A= (AC#) (;"?=@'#H? C?*;"?=@#>'#=O C?(?=? >;"H?)#> S#)V# :A*#>? #>#A %#H?'&>#=U#

S;HA< #V#"; C;=@#= <#(#H#) >;"(;SA> C#= *;"HA ;CA'#(? >;=>#=@ <#(#H#) >;"(;SA>D

E;=A"A> '#<? #C# N )#H *;=>?=@ U#?>AF

RD E#(#H#) ;CA'#(? C#= #V#";=;((

RD 9;S?W#'#=O ';S?W#'#= ?=? S;HA< ';S?W#'#= U@ S;HA< <;=@;"ATA>

RD /=Z"#(>"A'>A" C#=



RD :#@#?<#=# '?># <;=@;<S#H?'#= ZA=@(? 1#( >;"(;SA> (;)?=@@# ZA=@(? ;'&(?(>;<=U# S?(#

';<S#H? (;*;">? (;C?# '#H#D XT&=>&)` (A=@#? B#= C? 9&";# S?(#O (;)#"A(=U# '?># WA@# S?(#Y

B#H U#=@ S#"A U#=@ <A=@'?= S;HA< #C#O #C#H#) 9=&VH;C@; E#=#@;<;=> 7;=>;"O (A*#U#

(?#*#*A= S?(# <;=@#'(;(D E#(U#"#'#> S?(# <;H?)#>O W#C? <#(#H#) (&(?#H=U#O <#(#H#)

;'&=&<?=U#O ?=? (;<A# S?(# '?># (#<*#?'#= C#H#< 9=&VH;C@; E#=#@;<;=> 7;=>;"O U#=@=#=>?=U# <;<*A=U#? S#)#(#O C?<#=# S?(# C?<;=@;">? &H;) <#(U#"#'#> (;T#"# <AC#) C#=

C;=@#= V;S(?>;O <#(U#"#'#> S?(# H#=@(A=@ <;=U#<*#?'#= *;=@#CA#==U#D

9=&VH;C@; E#=#@;<;=> 7;=>;" ?=? C?S;"? =#<# 9=&VH;C@; E#=#@;<;=> 7;=>;" &= 0#>A"#H

-;(&A"T;( O C#= C?C#H#<=U# =#=>? #C# )#HL #>#A #(*;' ';<#<*A#= C#H#< )#H ?=? ('?HH U#=@

)#"A( C?*;=A)?O ';<AC?#= U#=@ (AC#) #C# #'#= C?>#<*?H'#= C#= S?(# C?";*H?'# C?H&'#(?L U#=@

>;H#) C?>;=>A'#= C#= <;=W#C? C#(#" A=>A' *;=@;<S#=@#= '&>#O U#=@ >?C#' )#=U#

*;"';<S#=@#= '&># >#*? WA@# C?H?)#> S#@#?<#=# 1#( <#A*A= 8#>#"A#=@ U#=@ #C# C#H#< C#(

?=? S?(# >;"#'&<&C#(? (;)?=@@# >?C#' >;"W#C? ';"A(#'#= *;=T;<#"#=D

4@;=C# ';C;*#==U#`

!;">#<#O T#"# <;=@?=Z&"<#(?'#= ';*#C# <#(U#"#'#> )#"A( C?';<#( (;T#"# S#?' (;)?=@@#

C#*#> C?<;=@;">? &H;) (;HA"A) H#*?(#= <#(U#"#'#>D

9;CA#O <;=@;=#? ';>#)#=#= *#=@#= U@ >;"'#?> C;=@#= *;=@;H&H##= 1#(D

9;>?@# ';(;C?##= ;=;"@UO ?=? WA@# (AC#) S#=U#' (;'#H? S=#@#?<#=# <#(U#"#'#>

<;<#=Z##>'#= H?<S#) C#"? >;"=#' <#A*A= H?<S#) <#(U#"#'#> ?>A (;=C?"?O C#= )#"A(

C?A*#U#'#= C#"? (V#C#U# <#(U#"#'#>D

!;"AS#)#= /'H?<O ?=? )#"A( C?#=>?(?*#(? C;=@#= #C#=U# *;"AS#)#= *&H# #=@?=O <#(# >#=#<CHHD

9;>#)#=#= #?" A=>A' '?># S#"A V#T#=#L (#W#O W#C? '?># )#"A( <;<*A=U#? '&=(;* U#=@ W;H#(

S#@#?<#=# ';>#)#=#= #?" '?># S;HA< <;<#=Z##>'#= (A<S;"C#U# H#A> C#= S;HA<

<;<*A=U#? (A#>A (>"#>;@? >;")#C#* ';>#)#=#= #?" '?>#O #*#'#) #?" C#"? H#A> ?=? S?(#

C?<#=Z##>'#=D 9#";=# >;"=U#># '?># <#(?) <;=@?<*&"> @#"#< C#= (;S;=#"=U# "A<*A> H#A>

'?># #C#H#) U#=@ >;"S#?' C?CA=?#O >;>#*? W?'# '?># '; K;*#=@ #>#A 9&";# '?># <;<S;H? "A<*A>

H#A> C#"? (#=#D -A<*A> H#A> SA'#= )#=U# (;S#@#? <#'#=#= >;>#*? WA@# (;S#@#? ;=;"@UD

4@;=C# U#=@ H#?= #C#H#) <#(#H#) 8#>#"A#=@ X!! L]YO *;<S;"C#U##= <#(U#"#'#>D E#(#H#):;=T#=#O S#@#?=#< <?>?@#(? <#(#H#) S;=T#=# U@ S;=T#=# ?=? (;>?#* >#)A= C?"#(#'#= >;>#*?

<?>?@#(? S;=T#=# 65!=U# '#H#) CAHA#=O (;H#HA S;=T#=#=U# H;S?) CAHA (;>;H#) ?>A 65! S#"A

';HA#"D :0!: (AC#) <;<*A=U#? >#>#T#"# 65! A=>A' <?>?@#(? S;=T#=#O (;'#"#=@ >?=@@#H

?<*H;<;=>#(?=U# (#W#D



2=>A' '&H#S&"#>?Z *"&W;T> ?=? 9.B S;';"W#(#<# C;=@#= 9&";#O #'#= <;H#'A'#= ";(>&"#(?

7?H?VA=@ C? /(>?aH#H X#C# (H?C;Y #'#= #C# *;"T&=>&)#= U#?>A ,T& ,CAT>?&= 7;=>;"D X9#H?S#>#O

9#=#H :#=W?" 8?<A"O 9#<*A=@ !AH&O E8 )#"U&=&YD

9;(?<*AH#= F

6;@;"# <;<S#=@A= C#>#S#(;E;=@;<S#=@'#= 9=&VH;C@; E#=#@;<;=> 7;=>;" (;S#@#? V#C#) *;">A'#"#= ?=Z&"<#(?

E;<S#=@A= ';<?>"##= C;=@#= (;HA"A) (>#';)&HC;"D

E;=@'&&"C?=#(?'#=O<;=@?<*H;<;=>#(?'#= 76-O '#";=# (;'#"#=@ ?=? 76- (#=@#> S#=U#'

>;>#*? >?C#' >;"'&&"C?=#(? (;)?=@@# '?># >;"'V#=>?Z?'#(? C;=@#= 76-O *;"HA #C#=U# '&=(;*

A=>A' S#=>A#= U#=@ #'#= C?C#*#> 76-L ?=?

E;<S#=@A= '&<A=?'#(? U#=@ ?=>;"#'>?Z C;=@#= <#(U#"#'#>D

:43/40 9,124 F 6,6/ !,E4!4-40 XE,84!.40Y

/SA bA= C#= -#C?>F

E;<Z#(?H?>#(? *;=@A<*AH#= <;>#*H#= U@ S;"A*# c 9#">A C;=@#=c V#"=#O I '#">A S;"?(? I

*;"<#(#H#)#= C#= (&HA(?D

9;S?W#'#=R9A=?=@O 8#>#"A#=@R!A>?)O 9;S;=T#=##=RE;"#) EAC#G!?='O .?=@'A=@#=RB?W#AO

!;<S;"C#U##= E#(U#"#'#>R7&'H#>O 8;'=&H&@? /=Z&"<#(?R:?"AO /=Z"#(>"A'>A"RK?=@@#G5"#=@;

b#=@ C?>AH?( C? '#">A #C#H#) *;"<#(#H#)#= C#= (&HA(?=U#D

9#H#A #C# ?(A U#=@ H#?= C#= >?C#' <#(A' C#H#< '#>;@&"? ?>A #'#= C?S?T#"#'#= C? %)?>;S&#"CD

9&=(;* *#*;" >#C?O (;S;=#"=U# #H>;"=#>?[; (&HA(? S#(# <;=W#C? <#(A'#= A=>A' ';C;*#=(;(A#? C;==@#=*;=C#*#> <#(?=@LD E;('?*A= C?H#'(#=#= &H;) (;T>&" H#S U#=@ H#?=

:43/40 9,8/34 F 6,6/ !,E4!4-40 G 1/6926/G840b4RK4%4: :,-94/840 1,0340 E,84!.40

2(AH#= `

ID 2(AH#= ̀ :;=>A' .;<S#@# :#"A

9;S?W#'#= (C) S#=U#' C? V?H W#S&C;>#S;' S&*A=WA" C@= ';**";(O >#*? (?#*# U@ *A=U#

<#=C#>; U@ S;(#" C#= 'A#> U#=@ C#*#> <;"=(?=;"@?'#=O <;=@)#"<&=?(#(? C#=

<;=@?<*H;<;=>#(?'#= '#";=# :!1#( >?C#' TA'A* 'A#>O '#H#A C?(;"#)'#= '; <#(?=@L(;'>&"D 2=> '#(A( 19/ C#= (;'?>#"=U#O )#"A( #C# I H;<S#@# U@ H#=@(A=@ *A=U#

<#=C#>; C#"? *";(?C;=O W#C? >C' )#=U# (;';C#" :!1#( U#=@ C?S#V#) (#>A ';<;=>"?#=D

8#*? (A#>A H;<S#@# U@ H#=@(A=@ S;">#=@@A=@ W#V#S '*C *";(?C;= U#=@ S?(#

<;=@'&&"C?=#(?'#= (;HA"A) ';*#H# C#;"#)O V?H#U#) U#=@ S?(# <;=@)#"<&=?(#(?

(;<A# ';S?W#'#=D

LD %#'?H C" 610`



9&&"C?=#(? H?=>#( (;T>&" (#=@#> 'A"#=@O *;"HA C?#C#'#= (A#>A H;<S#@# U@ S?(#

';"W#(#<# U#=@ S#?' C#= >A@#( C#"? (;>?#* H;<S#@# )#"A( >;@#( C#= W;H#( #=>#"# !2

9;)A>#=#= !;">#=?#=O W@= #C# CA#H?(<;D

JD 4C#=U# :#C#= 5>&"?>#( 7?H?VA=@D

ND /SA bA= ` 1?=#?''#= (#W# H#=@(A=@ '; *";(?C;=O (;S#S C? 0;@#"# H#?= S;")#(?H '#";=#

*";(?C;==U# *;CAH? C#= '&<?><;=

+D 6;*;">? C? T?H?VA=@ '?># <;<*A=U#? *;"#>A"#= A=>A' *;=@;H&H##= T?H?VA=@ C#"? )AHA

'; )?H?" C#= (;<A# (>#';)&HC;" (AC#) <#(A'D 1H< *;"W#H#=#= (>#';)&HC;" C#= U#=@

>;"'#?> '&<?><;= <#(?) S;HA< ?=@?= <;=U;H;(#?'#= T?H?VA=@ XLMM] d ('"Y 1?)#"#*'#=

*;<?<*?=G*";(?C;= U#=@ #'#= C#>#=@ <;<*A=U#? \)#>?eD

]D -?=?R!H#=#(O &"@#=?(#(?=U# #C#H#) !;"'A<*AH#= 6'#H# U#?>A!;"'A<*AH#= WA"=#H?( U#=@

S;';"W# A=>A' ?(A S;=T#=# C#= *;"AS#)#= ?'H?<D!#C# (##>S;"@#SA=@ C? %4.B/O #V#H #C#=U# #C# 37:O?'A> C#H#< "?(;> T?H?VA=@O (#U#

'A"#=@ (;>AWA C;=@#= #C#=U# H;<S#@# S#"AO '#";=# (;S;=#"=U# U#=@ C?S#=@A=

S;"C#(#"'#= "?(;> #C#H#) @;"#'#= <#(U#"#'#> U#=@ H;S?) 'A#> '#H#A @;"#'#= ?>A

<;=W#C? 'A#> WA(>"A #'#= S?(# <;=C&"&=@ *;"AS#)#= ';S?W#'#=D :;S;"#*# V#'>A H#HA

*C (##> S#=W?" S;(#"O (;<*#> S;">;<A K&'&V?O C#= K&'&V? (C) <;=@#@;=C#'#=

P>)

';C;*#=O >#"@;>=U# T?H?VA=@ W#A) H;S?) S#?' C#= S;S#( C#"? *;H#=@@#"#= C?

(;*#=W#=@ 1#(D /=? #C#H#) *?=>A A=> >;<#=L <;=C&"&=@ *;"AS#)#= ';S?W#'#=D

6;>;H#) (>#>;<;=> W&'&V? U@ P>)

>(S >;<#=L K#'#"># <;<SA#> Z&"A< H?=>#( (;'>&"#H

W#C? S;"S#@#? <#T#< C?=#( S;"@#SA=@ 76-R76- WA@# #C# C?(#=#O S#)'#= 6?=#"<#(

(C) <;=#=C#>#=@#=? E&2 C@= :!:1 19/ A=> ";[?>#H?(#(? T?H?VA=@D K#C? H;S?) (;>AWA

<;<S#=@A?= @;"#'#==U# C#"? ';(#C#"#= <#(U#"#'#>D

cD :0!: X<S#'Y` 8#C? S#=U#' C?(?=@@A=@ (&#H S;=T#=#O >";#><;=> C#= ;CA'#(? A=>A'

<#(U#"#'#> >;"'#?> C;=@#= ';S;=T#=##=O <?>?@#(?=U#O '&<A=?>#( ";H#V#==U# C#=

*;H?S#>#= <#(U#"#'#> V#"@# C;(# C#H#< *;=#@@AH#=@#= S;=T#=# C? C#;"#)=U#D4C#

*"&@"#< C;(# >#=@@A) S;=T#=# >#*? (#<*#? (;'#"#=@ >?C#' #C# C#;"#) U#=@ C#*#>

C?W#C?'#= T&=>&) C;(# >#=@@A)

PD :0!: XS*'Y` 9#H#A '?># S?T#"# ;#"HU V#"=?=@ (U(>;< <#'# '?># S?(# S?T#"# (&#H ;CA'#(?

U@ <;=W#C? *ASH?T '=&VH;C@; WA@# S#@? <#(U#"#'#>D ,#"HU V#"=?=@ (U(>;< C?(?=? SA'#=

U#=@ T#=@@?)O >;>#*? WA@# U#=@ S;"C#(#" <;C?# H&T#H U@ *;"HA C?';<S#=@'#=O '#H#A C?K#V# #C# ';=>&=@#= X#C# S#=U#' <#T#< T#"# <;<A'AH ';=>&=@#= (;(A#? C;=@#=

S;=T#=# U@ C#>#=@YD B#HL (;<#T#< ?=? U#=@ )?H#=@ C? K#'#">#O &H;) (;S#S ?>A *;"HA

C?';<S#=@'#= (;S#@#? (;SA#) <;C?# <#(U#"#'#>O '#";=# <;C?# U#=@ (;'#"#=@ ?=?

"#>#L ';<A#C?#= <;=W#C? (?;=>?Z?' (;)?=@@# <#(U#"#'#> #@#' 'A"#=@ *#)#<D

QD 610` ,#"HU V#"=?=@ (U(>;< SA'#= )#=U# A=>A' S#=W?" (#W#O >;>#*? WA@# A=>A' H;";=@L



U#=@ >;"W#H C#= "#V#= H&=@(&"O (;*;">? C? K;*#=@D K#C? (;S;HA< H&=@(&"O *;=CACA'

(AC#) C?S;"?>#A A=>A' (;@;"# <;=@A=@(?O >;"A>#<# *#C# (##> <A(?< *;=@)AW#=D

!;"HA #C# *#';> ';@?#>#= *;"#(= (;"># <#(U#"#'#> C?C#;"#) 1#( C#= 6;*#C#= (A=@#?D

IMD :#@#?<#=# '?># <;=T?*>#'#= <#(U#"#'#> U@ *;CAH? C#= *#)#< H?=@'A=@#= U#=@

<;<*A=U#? H?Z;(>UH; "#<#) H?=@'A=@#= C#= WA@# <;=@;">? >;=>#=@ *;=S;@#''#=)A'A<D K#C? "A<#)L U#=@ >#=*# /E: )#"A( C?@A(A"D

IID K#C? )#"A( #C# *;=C#<*?=@#=D 9#";=# *;=C#<*?=@#= ?>A 'A"#=@ (;'#H?D 6;W#A) <#=#

#C# H;#C;"()?* C? '#V#(#= T?H?VA=@ U@ (#=@#> S;"*;=@#"A) >;")#C#* <#(U#"#'#>

A=>A' <;=@;H&H# H?=@'A=@#= T?H?VA=@D !;=C;'#>#= SAC#U# WA@# *;=>?=@ A=>A'

<;=T?*>#'#= <#(U#"#'#> U#=@ <#A <;=@;">? >;=>#=@ H?=@'A=@#= (;'?>#" T?H?VA=@D

XT&=>&) C? '#H? T&C;O C;=@#= *;=C;'#>#= SAC#U# ';*#C# <#(U#"#'#> <#'# '#H? T&C;

S?(# <;=W#C? >;<*#> Z;(>?[#H (A=@#? T&C;Y !;=CA'A=@ SAC#U# H&T#H S;>#V? (;'?>#"

T?H?VA=@ WA@# )#"A( C?@;"#''#=D

ILD -?=?` )#"A( C?T?*>#'#= #T>&"G>&'&) 'A=T? (;*;">? '?#U U#=@ ?(# <;<SA#> *"&@"#< '?>#

<;=W#C? (A(>#?=D 9;>?'# '?># *;"@? <;=?=@@#H'#= >;<*#> ?>AO <#'# >&'&)L 'A=T? ?>A

U#=@ <;H#=WA>'#= *"&@"#< >;"(;SA>O W#C? >?C#' #C# ';>;"@#=>A=@#= C;=@#=

Z#(?H?>#>&"=U#D

IJD /=Z&"<#(? C#># (;>?#* (>#';)&HC;" #>#A ?(>?>A(? (#=@#> <;=U;S#" '?># >C' >#A #=C#

*A=U# C#># #*# >;"'#?> C;=@#= ?(A U@ #C#O W#C? '?># ?=@?==U# S#)V# ';C;*#=

?=Z&"<#(?=U# C?<#(A''#= C#H#< (#>A V#C#) ';<AC?#= C?<#=#@; (;C;<?'?#= "A*#

(;<A# (>#';)&HC;" C#*#> <;=@#'(;( C#># >;"(;SA> C#= :!!8 (?#* <;=T&S#

<;<S#=@A= ?>A ';<AC?#= =#=>? #'#= C?>;<*#>'#= C?<#=#O '?># )#=U# <;<S#=@A=O

U#=@ *#H?=@ *;=>?=@ #C#H#) \()#";e C#># C#= ?=Z& (;>?# (>#';)&HC;" #*#'#) ';C;*#=

'&<?><;==U# (;*;">? #*#O '#";=# S#@#?<#=#*A= C?*;<;"?=>#)#= ?>A <A=@'?= (#=@#>

(;<#=@#> A=>A' ?>A L >) ';C;*#= #*#'#) >;"W#<?= S#)V# A*C#>?=@ C#># (;>?#*

?=(>?>A(? #'#= <#(A' CH< (U(>;< U#=@ #'#= C?S#=@A= W#C? )#"A( #C# '&<?><;=

S;"(#<# <;<S#=@A= 9E7 ?=? <;=W#C? V#C#) U#=@ (#=@#> );S#> A=>A' <;<S;"?'#=

?=Z&"<#(? C#= C#># ';*#C# <#(U#"#'#>D

IND -?=?` !H#>Z&"< =#(?&=#H (##> ?=? (;C#=@ S;';"W#(#<# C;=@#= 8;<*& (##> ?=? (;C#=@

<;<S#=@A= (;<#T#< *&">#H >;=>#=@ C?(#(>;"O >;>#*? '?># ?=@?=O SA'#= C?(#(>;"=U#

>#*? >;<#=L C#"? 9.B C#= !2 #>#A U#=@ H#?==U# A=>A' <#(A' C#H#< *&">#H >;"(;SA>

C#= S?(# S;")ASA=@#= C;=@#= <#(?=@L V;SD 9;=#*# '#<? >;">#"?' S;';"W#(#<#

C;=@#= 8;<*&O '#";=# C#H#< I )#"? 8;<*& S?(# C?'H?' &H;) L WA># &"#=@O C#= (;>?#*SAH#= #C# cM &"#=@ U#=@ <;=@'H?' 8;<*&DT&D .#HA >;"S#U#=@O '#H#A ?=Z&"<#(? ?=? S?(#

(#<*#? ';*ASH?'O #">?=U# S?(# <;=T;"C#('#= &"#=@'#";=# ?(A C?(#(>;" ?=? )#"A(

C?';>#)A? <#(U#"#'#>D

I+D !H#>Z&"< =#(?&=#H ?>A #C#H#) U#=@ <AH>? (>#';)&HC;"O #C# + *?H#" ';#=@@&>##==U# ?>AO

*;<;"?=>#) .6E !;"@A"A#= 8?=@@? C#= !"?[#>; 6;T>&" X2=?H;[;"O 6#<*&;"=# CHHY



fA=@(? Z&"A< ?>A '&&"C?=#(?O '&=;'(? (;S;=#"=U# Z&"A< ?=? <;=@)ASA=@'#= #=>#"#

U#=@ (#>A C;=@#= U#=@ H#?=D 1#H#< ';"#=@'# <;=?=@'#>'#= '#*#(?>#( <#(U#"#'#>

(;T#"# HA#( <;H#HA? ?=Z&"<#(?O <#'# '#<? <;=T&S# <;=@@#=C;=@ 8;<*& (;S#@#?

(#H#) (#>A #=@@&># !H#>Z&"< =#(?&=#HD 8;<#=L '#<? C#"? !;<;"?=>#)O .6EO !;"@A"A#=

>?=@@? <;<*A=U#? S#=U#' ?=Z&"<#(? U#=@ >;"T;T;"D 4C# IQ"?SA "?(;> >;=>#=@ T?H?VA=@

(;W#' IQQMD

I]D 8;"'#?> <;=@;=#? C#># C#"? <#(?=@L (>#';)&HC;"O U#=@ C?S#=@A= #C# V;SO '?># S?(#

<;=#"?' C#># C#"? (;>?#* (;T>&"O W#C? >?C#' *;"HA <;<SA#> (#>A (;"[;" C;=@#= (*#T;

U#=@ S;(#"D 1#= ?=? (;S#@#? *;<#=>#A#= *ASH?T WA@# >;")#C#* '?=;"W# C#"?

?=(>?>A(?G*;<;"?=>#) U#=@ <;<*A=U#? ';V#W?S#= A=>A' <;H#'A'#= A*C#>?=@ C#>#D

1#= S?(# C?>#"?' C? *&">#H=U# >;<*&O W#C? <#(U#"#'#> S?(# <;H?)#>G<;=@#'(;(

?=Z&"<#(? U#=@ C??=@?='#=D

8"?<# '#(?) /SA 461,!

Documents

Notulensi Pre Workshop 5