20
R R E E L L E E V V A A N N T T  D D E E C C I I S S I I O O N N S S  O O F F  T T H H E E  C C O O U U R R T T S S  I I N N  I I N N D D I I A A 1 1 . . I I n n H H a a r r m m e e e e t t a a  S S i i n n g g h h  v v  R R a a j  j a a t t  T T a a n n e e j  j a a  1 1 0 0 2 2  ( ( 2 2 0 0 0 0 3 3 ) )  D D L L T T  8 8 2 2 2 2  t t h h e e  w w i i f f e e  w w a a s s  d d e e s s e e r r t t e e d d b b y y  h h e e r r  h h u u s s b b a a n n d d  w w i i t t h h i i n n  6 6  m m o o n n t t h h s s  o o f f   m m a a r r r r i i a a g g e e  a a s s  s s h h e e  w w a a s s  c c o o m m p p e e l l l l e e d d  t t o o  l l e e a a v v e e  t t h h e e  m m a a t t r r i i m m o o n n i i a a l l h h o o m m e e  w w i i t t h h i i n n  3 3  m m o o n n t t h h s s  o o f f   j  j o o i i n n i i n n g g  h h e e r r  h h u u s s b b a a n n d d  i i n n  t t h h e e  U U S S . .  W W h h e e n n  s s h h e e  f f i i l l e e d d  a a  s s u u i i t t  f f o o r r  m m a a i i n n t t e e n n a a n n c c e e u u n n d d e e r r  t t h h e e  H H i i n n d d u u  A A d d o o p p t t i i o o n n s s  a a n n d d  M M a a i i n n t t e e n n a a n n c c e e  A A c c t t  i i n n  I I n n d d i i a a , ,  t t h h e e  H H i i g g h h  C C o o u u r r t t  d d i i s s p p o o s s e e d d  o o f f   t t h h e e i i n n t t e e r r i i m m  a a p p p p l l i i c c a a t t i i o o n n  i i n n  t t h h e e  s s u u i i t t  b b y y  p p a a s s s s i i n n g g  a a n n o o r r d d e e r r  o o f f   r r e e s s t t r r a a i i n n t t  a a g g a a i i n n s s t t  t t h h e e  h h u u s s b b a a n n d d  f f r r o o m m c c o o n n t t i i n n u u i i n n g g  w w i i t t h h  t t h h e e  p p r r o o c c e e e e d d i i n n g g s s  i i n n  t t h h e e  U U S S  c c o o u u r r t t  i i n n  t t h h e e  d d i i v v o o r r c c e e  p p e e t t i i t t i i o o n n  f f i i l l e e d d  b b y y  t t h h e e  h h u u s s b b a a n n d d t t h h e e r r e e  a a n n d d  a a l l s s o o  a a s s k k i i n n g g  h h i i m m  t t o o  p p l l a a c c e e  a a  c c o o p p y y  o o f f   t t h h e e  o o r r d d e e r r  o o f f   t t h h e e  H H i i g g h h  C C o o u u r r t t  b b e e f f o o r r e e  t t h h e e  U U S S c c o o u u r r t t . . T T h h e e  C C o o u u r r t t  m m a a d d e e  s s o o m m e e  o o t t h h e e r r  o o b b s s e e r r v v a a t t i i o o n n s s  w w h h i i l l e e  p p a a s s s s i i n n g g  t t h h i i s s  o o r r d d e e r r , ,  m m a a i i n n l l y y  t t h h a a t t  e e v v e e n n i i f f   t t h h e e  h h u u s s b b a a n n d d  s s u u c c c c e e e e d d e e d d  i i n n  o o b b t t a a i i n n i i n n g g  a a  d d i i v v o o r r c c e e  d d e e c c r r e e e e  i i n n  t t h h e e  U U S S , ,  t t h h a a t t  d d e e c c r r e e e e  w w o o u u l l d d  b b e e u u n n l l i i k k e e l l y y  t t o o  r r e e c c e e i i v v e e  r r e e c c o o g g n n i i t t i i o o n n  i i n n  I I n n d d i i a a  a a s s  t t h h e e  I I n n d d i i a a n n  c c o o u u r r t t  h h a a d d  j  j u u r r i i s s d d i i c c t t i i o o n n  i i n n  t t h h e e  m m a a t t t t e e r r a a n n d d  t t h h e e  j  j u u r r i i s s d d i i c c t t i i o o n n  o o f f   t t h h e e  U U S S  c c o o u u r r t t s s  w w o o u u l l d d  h h a a v v e e  t t o o  b b e e  e e s s t t a a b b l l i i s s h h e e d d  u u n n d d e e r r  S S e e c c t t i i o o n n  1 1 3 3 , ,  C C P P C C . . T T h h e e  C C o o u u r r t t  t t h h e e n n  s s a a i i d d  t t h h a a t t  t t i i l l l l  t t h h e e  U U S S  d d e e c c r r e e e e  w w a a s s  r r e e c c o o g g n n i i z z e e d d  i i n n  I I n n d d i i a a , ,  h h e e  w w o o u u l l d d  b b e e  h h e e l l d d  g g u u i i l l t t y y o o f f   c c o o m m m m i i t t t t i i n n g g  b b i i g g a a m m y y  i i n n  I I n n d d i i a a  a a n n d d  w w o o u u l l d d  b b e e  l l i i a a b b l l e e  t t o o  f f a a c c e e  c c r r i i m m i i n n a a l l  a a c c t t i i o o n n  f f o o r r  t t h h a a t t . .  T T h h e e  c c o o u u r r t t a a l l s s o o  s s a a i i d d  t t h h a a t t  s s i i n n c c e e  t t h h e e  w w i i f f e e ’ s s  s s t t a a y y  i i n n  t t h h e e  U U S S  w w a a s s  v v e e r r y y  t t r r a a n n s s i i e e n n t t , ,  t t e e m m p p o o r r a a r r y y  a a n n d d  c c a a s s u u a a l l , ,  a a n n d d s s h h e e  m m a a y y  n n o o t t  b b e e  f f i i n n a a n n c c i i a a l l l l y y  c c a a p p a a b b l l e e  o o f f   p p r r o o s s e e c c u u t t i i n n g g  t t h h e e  l l i i t t i i g g a a t t i i o o n n  i i n n  t t h h e e  U U S S  c c o o u u r r t t , ,  t t h h e e  D D e e l l h h i i c c o o u u r r t t s s  w w o o u u l l d d  b b e e  t t h h e e  f f o o r r u u m m  o o f f   c c o o n n v v e e n n i i e e n n c c e e  i i n n  t t h h e e  m m a a t t t t e e r r . . 2 2 . . I I n n V V i i k k a a s s  A A g g g g a a r r w w a a l l  v v  A A n n u u b b h h a a  ( ( A A I I R R  2 2 0 0 0 0 2 2  S S C C  1 1 7 7 9 9 6 6 ) ) , , t t h h e e  S S u u p p r r e e m m e e  C C o o u u r r t t  h h a a d d  b b e e e e n n a a p p p p r r o o a a c c h h e e d d  b b y y  t t h h e e  N N R R I I  h h u u s s b b a a n n d d  w w h h o o s s e e  d d e e f f e e n n c c e e  h h a a d d  b b e e e e n n  s s t t r r u u c c k k  o o f f f f   i i n n  a a  m m a a i i n n t t e e n n a a n n c c e e  s s u u i i t t f f i i l l e e d d  b b y y  t t h h e e  w w i i f f e e  i i n n  t t h h e e  H H i i g g h h  C C o o u u r r t t  a a s s  h h e e  h h a a d d  n n o o t t  a a p p p p e e a a r r e e d d i i n n  t t h h e e  H H i i g g h h  C C o o u u r r t t  d d e e s s p p i i t t e e  t t h h e e H H i i g g h h  C C o o u u r r t t ’ s s  o o r r d d e e r r  d d i i r r e e c c t t i i n n g g  h h i i m m  t t o o  p p e e r r s s o o n n a a l l l l y y  a a p p p p e e a a r r  a a n n d d  g g i i v v i i n n g g  h h i i m m  s s e e v v e e r r a a l l  o o p p p p o o r r t t u u n n i i t t i i e e s s . . T T h h e e  H H i i g g h h  c c o o u u r r t t  h h a a d d  d d i i r r e e c c t t e e d d  h h i i m m  t t o o  p p e e r r s s o o n n a a l l l l y y  a a p p p p e e a a r r  t t o o  g g i i v v e e  c c l l a a r r i i f f i i c c a a t t i i o o n n s s  t t o o  t t h h e e  c c o o u u r r t t o o n n  t t h h e e  c c i i r r c c u u m m s s t t a a n n c c e e s s  i i n n  w w h h i i c c h h  t t h h e e  U U S S  c c o o u u r r t t  h h a a d d  p p r r o o c c e e e e d d e e d d  w w i i t t h h  a a n n d d  g g r r a a n n t t e e d d  d d e e c c r r e e e e  i i n n  a a d d i i v v o o r r c c e e  p p e e t t i i t t i i o o n n  f f i i l l e e d d  b b y y  t t h h e e  h h u u s s b b a a n n d d  i i n n  t t h h e e  U U S S  d d e e s s p p i i t t e e  o o r r d d e e r r  o o f f   r r e e s s t t r r a a i i n n t t  h h a a v v i i n n g g  b b e e e e n n  i i s s s s u u e e d d b b y y  t t h h e e  I I n n d d i i a a n n  c c o o u u r r t t  a a g g a a i i n n s s t t  t t h h e e  p p r r o o c c e e e e d d i i n n g g s s  i i n n  t t h h e e  U U S S . .  T T h h e e  H H i i g g h h  C C o o u u r r t t  h h a a d d  a a l l s s o o  r r e e j  j e e c c t t e e d d h h i i s s  a a p p p p l l i i c c a a t t i i o o n n  f f o o r r  e e x x e e m m p p t t i i o o n n  f f r r o o m m  p p e e r r s s o o n n a a l l  a a p p p p e e a a r r a a n n c c e e  o o n n  t t h h e e  b b a a s s i i s s  t t h h a a t t  h h e e  a a p p p p r r e e h h e e n n d d e e d d t t h h a a t t  h h e e  w w o o u u l l d d  b b e e  a a r r r r e e s s t t e e d d  i i n n  t t h h e e  c c a a s s e e  u u n n d d e e r r  S S e e c c t t i i o o n n  4 4 9 9 8 8  A A , ,  I I P P C C  f f i i l l e e d d  b b y y  t t h h e e  w w i i f f e e . . ( ( 1 1 6 6 ) )

NRI Imp CaseLaws

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 1/20

RR

EE

LL

EE

VV

AA

NN

TT

DD

EE

CC

II

SS

II

OO

NN

SS

OO

FF

TT

HH

EE

CC

OO

UU

RR

TT

SS

II

NN

II

NN

DD

II

AA1

1

.

.

II

nn

HH

aa

rr

mm

ee

ee

tt

aa

SS

ii

nn

gg

hh

vv

RR

aa

j j

aa

tt

TT

aa

nn

ee

j j

aa

11

00

22

((

22

00

00

33

))

DD

LL

TT

88

22

22

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

aa

ss

dd

ee

ss

ee

rr

tt

ee

dd

bb

yy

hh

ee

rr

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

66

mm

oo

nn

tt

hh

ss

oo

ff

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

aa

ss

ss

hh

ee

ww

aa

ss

cc

oo

mm

pp

ee

ll

ll

ee

dd

tt

oo

ll

ee

aa

vv

ee

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

hh

oo

mm

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

33

mm

oo

nn

tt

hh

ss

oo

ff

j j

oo

ii

nn

ii

nn

gg

hh

ee

rr

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

.

.

WW

hh

ee

nn

ss

hh

ee

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

aa

ss

uu

ii

tt

ff

oo

rr

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

AA

dd

oo

pp

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

aa

nn

dd

MM

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

AA

cc

tt

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

dd

ii

ss

pp

oo

ss

ee

dd

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

ii

mm

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ss

uu

ii

tt

bb

yy

pp

aa

ss

ss

ii

nn

gg

aa

nn

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

oo

ff

rr

ee

ss

tt

rr

aa

ii

nn

tt

aa

gg

aa

ii

nn

ss

tt

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ff

rr

oo

mm

cc

oo

nn

tt

ii

nn

uu

ii

nn

gg

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

aa

nn

dd

aa

ll

ss

oo

aa

ss

kk

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

mm

tt

oo

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

aa

cc

oo

pp

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

bb

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.TT

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

mm

aa

dd

ee

ss

oo

mm

ee

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

oo

bb

ss

ee

rr

vv

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

ww

hh

ii

ll

ee

pp

aa

ss

ss

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ii

ss

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

,,

mm

aa

ii

nn

ll

yy

tt

hh

aa

tt

ee

vv

ee

nn

ii

ff

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ss

uu

cc

cc

ee

ee

dd

ee

dd

ii

nn

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ii

nn

gg

aa

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

,,

tt

hh

aa

tt

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

uu

nn

ll

ii

kk

ee

ll

yy

tt

oo

rr

ee

cc

ee

ii

vv

ee

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

hh

aa

vv

ee

tt

oo

bb

ee

ee

ss

tt

aa

bb

ll

ii

ss

hh

ee

dd

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

,,

CC

PP

CC

.

.TT

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

hh

ee

nn

ss

aa

ii

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

ii

ll

ll

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ww

aa

ss

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

zz

ee

dd

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

hh

ee

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

hh

ee

ll

dd

gg

uu

ii

ll

tt

yy

oo

ff

cc

oo

mm

mm

ii

tt

tt

ii

nn

gg

bb

ii

gg

aa

mm

yy

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

nn

dd

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

ll

ii

aa

bb

ll

ee

tt

oo

ff

aa

cc

ee

cc

rr

ii

mm

ii

nn

aa

ll

aa

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

aa

tt

.

.

TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

ss

aa

ii

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ss

ii

nn

cc

ee

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

’’

ss

ss

tt

aa

yy

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

ww

aa

ss

vv

ee

rr

yy

tt

rr

aa

nn

ss

ii

ee

nn

tt

,,

tt

ee

mm

pp

oo

rr

aa

rr

yy

aa

nn

dd

cc

aa

ss

uu

aa

ll

,,

aa

nn

dd

ss

hh

ee

mm

aa

yy

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

ff

ii

nn

aa

nn

cc

ii

aa

ll

ll

yy

cc

aa

pp

aa

bb

ll

ee

oo

ff

pp

rr

oo

ss

ee

cc

uu

tt

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

ll

ii

tt

ii

gg

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

,,

tt

hh

ee

DD

ee

ll

hh

ii

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

oo

ff

cc

oo

nn

vv

ee

nn

ii

ee

nn

cc

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

.

.22

.

.

II

nn

VV

ii

kk

aa

ss

AA

gg

gg

aa

rr

ww

aa

ll

vv

AA

nn

uu

bb

hh

aa

((

AA

II

RR

22

00

00

22

SS

CC

11

77

99

66

))

,,

tt

hh

ee

SS

uu

pp

rr

ee

mm

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

bb

ee

ee

nn

aa

pp

pp

rr

oo

aa

cc

hh

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

NN

RR

II

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ww

hh

oo

ss

ee

dd

ee

ff

ee

nn

cc

ee

hh

aa

dd

bb

ee

ee

nn

ss

tt

rr

uu

cc

kk

oo

ff

ff

ii

nn

aa

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

uu

ii

tt

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ss

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

nn

oo

tt

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

dd

ee

ss

pp

ii

tt

ee

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

’’

ss

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

mm

tt

oo

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

yy

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

aa

nn

dd

gg

ii

vv

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

mm

ss

ee

vv

ee

rr

aa

ll

oo

pp

pp

oo

rr

tt

uu

nn

ii

tt

ii

ee

ss

.

.TT

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

hh

ii

mm

tt

oo

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

yy

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

tt

oo

gg

ii

vv

ee

cc

ll

aa

rr

ii

ff

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

ii

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

aa

nn

dd

gg

rr

aa

nn

tt

ee

dd

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ii

nn

aa

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

dd

ee

ss

pp

ii

tt

ee

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

oo

ff

rr

ee

ss

tt

rr

aa

ii

nn

tt

hh

aa

vv

ii

nn

gg

bb

ee

ee

nn

ii

ss

ss

uu

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

gg

aa

ii

nn

ss

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

.

.

TT

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

aa

ll

ss

oo

rr

ee

j j

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

hh

ii

ss

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

oo

rr

ee

xx

ee

mm

pp

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

rr

oo

mm

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

aa

ll

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

aa

nn

cc

ee

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

bb

aa

ss

ii

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

rr

ee

hh

ee

nn

dd

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

aa

rr

rr

ee

ss

tt

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

44

99

88

AA

,,

II

PP

CC

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

.

.((1166))

Page 2: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 2/20backafterthemarriagewhenshereceivedthepetitionforannulmentofmarriagefiledbyherNRIhusbandintheUScourtShefiledasuitfordamagesinsuchcircumstancesasshehdffdtjttilldtllbthdlgihjbitiitifhdhUSThil ddfR22lkhThHihC

Page 3: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 3/20

bb

aa

cc

kk

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

,,

ww

hh

ee

nn

ss

hh

ee

rr

ee

cc

ee

ii

vv

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

oo

rr

aa

nn

nn

uu

ll

mm

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

hh

ee

rr

NN

RR

II

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.

SS

hh

ee

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

aa

ss

uu

ii

tt

ff

oo

rr

dd

aa

mm

aa

gg

ee

ss

ii

nn

ss

uu

cc

hh

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

aa

ss

ss

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

ss

uu

ff

ff

ee

rr

ee

dd

nn

oo

tt

j j

uu

ss

tt

ee

mm

oo

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

yy

aa

nn

dd

mm

ee

nn

tt

aa

ll

ll

yy

bb

uu

tt

hh

aa

dd

aa

ll

ss

oo

gg

ii

vv

ee

nn

uu

pp

hh

ee

rr

j j

oo

bb

ii

nn

aa

nn

tt

ii

cc

ii

pp

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

hh

ee

rr

dd

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

uu

rr

ee

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

.

.

TT

hh

ee

tt

rr

ii

aa

ll

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

aa

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

oo

ff

RR

ss

.

.

22

22

ll

aa

kk

hh

ss

TT

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

ll

ss

tt

aa

yy

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

oo

pp

ee

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

pp

ee

nn

dd

ii

nn

gg

ff

ii

nn

aa

ll

dd

ii

ss

pp

oo

ss

aa

ll

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

nn

dd

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

dd

ee

pp

oo

ss

ii

tt

oo

ff

RR

ss

.

.

11

LL

aa

kk

hh

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.

OO

nn

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

ll

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

tt

hh

ee

SS

uu

pp

rr

ee

mm

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

mm

oo

dd

ii

ff

ii

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

’’

ss

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ii

nn

ff

aa

vv

oo

uu

rr

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

bb

yy

ee

nn

hh

aa

nn

cc

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

pp

oo

ss

ii

tt

aa

mm

oo

uu

nn

tt

tt

oo

RR

ss

.

.

33

LL

aa

kk

hhE

E

vv

ee

nn

tt

hh

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

hh

ee

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ww

aa

ss

oo

nn

aa

ll

ii

mm

ii

tt

ee

dd

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

ii

nn

aa

nn

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

ii

mm

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

,,

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

ss

hh

oo

ww

ss

tt

hh

ee

ff

ee

aa

ss

ii

bb

ii

ll

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

ss

uu

ii

tt

ff

oo

rr

dd

aa

mm

aa

gg

ee

ss

bb

yy

ww

ii

ff

ee

ii

nn

ss

uu

cc

hh

cc

aa

ss

ee

ss

.

.

II

tt

ii

ss

aa

ll

ss

oo

pp

ee

rr

tt

ii

nn

ee

nn

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

ss

oo

mm

ee

oo

bb

ii

tt

ee

rr

oo

bb

ss

ee

rr

vv

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

,,

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ww

ee

rr

ee

aa

ss

ff

oo

ll

ll

oo

ww

ss

::“

“

FF

ee

aa

ss

ii

bb

ii

ll

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

aa

ll

ee

gg

ii

ss

ll

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

aa

ff

ee

gg

uu

aa

rr

dd

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

ee

ss

tt

ss

oo

ff

ww

oo

mm

ee

nn

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

ee

xx

aa

mm

ii

nn

ee

dd

bb

yy

ii

nn

cc

oo

rr

pp

oo

rr

aa

tt

ii

nn

gg

ss

uu

cc

hh

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

aa

ss

--(

(

11

))

NN

oo

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

bb

ee

tt

ww

ee

ee

nn

aa

NN

RR

II

aa

nn

dd

aa

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

ww

oo

mm

aa

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

hh

aa

ss

tt

aa

kk

ee

nn

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

aa

nn

nn

uu

ll

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

;;(

(

22

))

PP

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

mm

aa

dd

ee

ff

oo

rr

aa

dd

ee

qq

uu

aa

tt

ee

aa

ll

ii

mm

oo

nn

yy

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

pp

ee

rr

tt

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

bb

oo

tt

hh

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

nn

dd

aa

bb

rr

oo

aa

dd

.

.((

33

))

TT

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

gg

rr

aa

nn

tt

ee

dd

bb

yy

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

mm

aa

dd

ee

ee

xx

ee

cc

uu

tt

aa

bb

ll

ee

ii

nn

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

bb

oo

tt

hh

oo

nn

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

oo

ff

cc

oo

mm

ii

tt

yy

aa

nn

dd

bb

yy

ee

nn

tt

ee

rr

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

tt

oo

rr

ee

cc

ii

pp

rr

oo

cc

aa

ll

aa

gg

rr

ee

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

ss

ll

ii

kk

ee

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

44

44

--

AA

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

ii

vv

ii

ll

PP

rr

oo

cc

ee

dd

uu

rr

ee

CC

oo

dd

ee

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

mm

aa

kk

ee

ss

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ee

xx

ee

cc

uu

tt

aa

bb

ll

ee

aa

ss

ii

tt

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

hh

aa

vv

ee

bb

ee

ee

nn

aa

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

aa

tt

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.

””5

5

.

.

RR

aa

j j

ii

vv

TT

aa

yy

aa

ll

vv

.

.

UU

nn

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

&&

OO

rr

ss

.

.

((

11

22

44

((

22

00

00

55

))

DD

LL

TT

55

00

22

::

22

00

00

55

((

88

55

))

DD

RR

JJ

11

44

66

))

ii

ss

aa

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ss

hh

oo

ww

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

aa

ll

ss

oo

hh

aa

ss

aa

nn

aa

vv

aa

ii

ll

aa

bb

ll

ee

rr

ee

mm

ee

dd

yy

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

00

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

PP

aa

ss

ss

pp

oo

rr

tt

AA

cc

tt

ff

oo

rr

ii

mm

pp

oo

uu

nn

dd

ii

nn

gg

aa

nn

dd

//

oo

rr

rr

ee

vv

oo

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

ss

ss

pp

oo

rr

tt

oo

ff

hh

ee

rr

NN

RR

II

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ii

ff

hh

ee

ff

aa

ii

ll

ee

dd

tt

oo

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

ss

uu

mm

mm

oo

nn

ss

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ssI

I

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

tt

hh

ee

NN

RR

II

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

hh

aa

dd

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

aa

ww

rr

ii

tt

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

ee

ee

kk

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

qq

uu

aa

ss

hh

tt

hh

ee

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

CC

oo

nn

ss

uu

ll

aa

tt

ee

GG

ee

nn

ee

rr

aa

ll

oo

ff

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

NN

ee

ww

YY

oo

rr

kk

,,

UU

SS

AA

,,

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

MM

ii

nn

ii

ss

tt

rr

yy

oo

ff

EE

xx

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

ll

AA

ff

ff

aa

ii

rr

ss

,,

GG

oo

vv

ee

rr

nn

mm

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

NN

ee

ww

DD

ee

ll

hh

ii

,,

ff

oo

rr

ii

mm

pp

oo

uu

nn

dd

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

ss

pp

aa

ss

ss

pp

oo

rr

tt

.

.

HH

ee

aa

ll

ss

oo

cc

hh

aa

ll

ll

ee

nn

gg

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

TT

rr

ii

aa

ll

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

dd

ee

cc

ll

aa

rr

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

mm

aa

‘‘

pp

rr

oo

cc

ll

aa

ii

mm

ee

dd

oo

ff

ff

ee

nn

dd

ee

rr

’’

TT

hh

ee

NN

RR

II

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

hh

aa

dd

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

PP

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

vv

ee

nn

aa

ss

hh

ee

cc

oo

nn

tt

ii

nn

uu

ee

dd

tt

oo

rr

ee

ff

uu

ss

ee

tt

oo

j j

oo

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

pp

ee

nn

dd

ii

nn

gg

bb

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

MM

ee

tt

rr

oo

pp

oo

ll

ii

tt

aa

nn

MM

aa

gg

ii

ss

tt

rr

aa

tt

ee

ll

aa

rr

gg

ee

ll

yy

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

ww

aa

ss

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

UU

SS

AA

aa

nn

dd

ss

uu

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

mm

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

rr

ii

mm

ii

nn

aa

ll

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ss

ss

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

aa

nn

uu

nn

ff

aa

ii

rr

bb

uu

rr

dd

ee

nn

.

.

TT

hh

ee((1188))

Page 4: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 4/20

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

rr

aa

ll

ss

oo

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

mm

ee

bb

rr

ee

aa

tt

hh

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

ee

nn

ss

ee

rr

vv

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

ss

uu

mm

mm

oo

nn

ss

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

vv

ee

ss

tt

ii

gg

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

tt

oo

bb

ee

cc

oo

nn

dd

uu

cc

tt

ee

dd

bb

yy

ss

ee

nn

dd

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

mm

aa

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

nn

aa

ii

rr

ee

aa

nn

dd

hh

ee

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

aa

ss

kk

ee

dd

tt

oo

j j

oo

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

vv

ee

ss

tt

ii

gg

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

cc

cc

ee

pp

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

oo

ff

ss

uu

cc

hh

aa

pp

ll

ee

aa

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

gg

ii

vv

ee

aa

pp

rr

ee

mm

ii

uu

mm

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

aa

cc

cc

uu

ss

ee

dd

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

j j

uu

ss

tt

bb

ee

cc

aa

uu

ss

ee

hh

ee

hh

aa

pp

pp

ee

nn

ee

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

aa

bb

rr

oo

aa

dd

.

.

MM

ee

rr

ee

ll

yy

bb

yy

gg

oo

ii

nn

gg

aa

bb

rr

oo

aa

dd

aa

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

cc

ll

aa

ii

mm

aa

ss

tt

aa

tt

uu

ss

ss

uu

pp

ee

rr

ii

oo

rr

tt

oo

tt

hh

aa

tt

oo

ff

aa

cc

ii

tt

ii

zz

ee

nn

oo

ff

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.

II

tt

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

tt

hh

ee

nn

bb

ee

oo

pp

ee

nn

tt

oo

ss

uu

cc

hh

aa

nn

aa

cc

cc

uu

ss

ee

dd

tt

oo

mm

ii

ss

uu

ss

ee

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ss

ss

oo

ff

ll

aa

ww

aa

nn

dd

tt

oo

mm

aa

kk

ee

aa

mm

oo

cc

kk

ee

rr

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

j j

uu

dd

ii

cc

ii

aa

ll

ss

yy

ss

tt

ee

mm

bb

yy

aa

ss

kk

ii

nn

gg

ff

oo

rr

ss

uu

cc

hh

aa

ss

pp

ee

cc

ii

aa

ll

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

dd

uu

rr

ee

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ii

ss

ii

nn

aa

nn

yy

cc

aa

ss

ee

tt

oo

tt

aa

ll

ll

yy

oo

pp

pp

oo

ss

ee

dd

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

rr

ii

mm

ii

nn

aa

ll

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

pp

rr

uu

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

hh

ii

ss

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

aa

ll

ss

oo

ll

oo

oo

kk

ii

nn

gg

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

nn

dd

uu

cc

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

aa

cc

cc

uu

ss

ee

dd

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ss

ii

nn

cc

ee

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

rr

ee

ff

uu

ss

ee

dd

tt

oo

j j

oo

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

ee

vv

ee

nn

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

bb

ee

ii

nn

gg

rr

ee

pp

ee

aa

tt

ee

dd

ll

yy

aa

ss

ss

uu

rr

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

ee

xx

tt

ee

nn

dd

ee

dd

ss

uu

ii

tt

aa

bb

ll

ee

pp

rr

oo

tt

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

gg

aa

ii

nn

ss

tt

hh

ii

ss

aa

rr

rr

ee

ss

tt

oo

rr

aa

nn

yy

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

pp

ee

nn

aa

ll

cc

oo

nn

ss

ee

qq

uu

ee

nn

cc

ee

ss

ii

nn

rr

ee

ss

pp

ee

cc

tt

oo

ff

hh

ii

ss

pp

aa

ss

ss

pp

oo

rr

tt

,,

bb

uu

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

ll

ii

nn

ee

dd

tt

oo

dd

oo

ss

oo

aa

nn

dd

ii

nn

ss

ii

ss

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ss

uu

mm

mm

oo

nn

ss

mm

uu

ss

tt

bb

ee

ss

ee

rr

vv

ee

dd

oo

nn

hh

ii

mm

bb

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

hh

ee

ii

ss

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

dd

tt

oo

aa

nn

ss

ww

ee

rr

ii

tt

,,

tt

hh

uu

ss

tt

aa

kk

ii

nn

gg

aa

hh

yy

pp

ee

rr

tt

ee

cc

hh

nn

ii

cc

aa

ll

pp

ll

ee

aa

.

.TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ww

aa

ss

nn

oo

mm

ee

rr

ii

tt

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

’’

ss

pp

ll

ee

aa

aa

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

vv

aa

ll

ii

dd

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

00

((

ee

))

&&

((

hh

))

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

PP

aa

ss

ss

pp

oo

rr

tt

AA

cc

tt

bb

ee

ii

nn

gg

vv

ii

oo

ll

aa

tt

ii

vv

ee

oo

ff

AA

rr

tt

ii

cc

ll

ee

ss

11

44

,,

11

99

aa

nn

dd

22

11

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

nn

ss

tt

ii

tt

uu

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

pp

ll

ee

aa

oo

ff

cc

oo

nn

ss

tt

ii

tt

uu

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

vv

aa

ll

ii

dd

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

ss

uu

cc

hh

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

tt

hh

uu

ss

ss

tt

oo

oo

dd

rr

ee

j j

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

.

.66

.

.

MM

aa

rr

gg

gg

aa

rr

aa

tt

ee

PP

uu

ll

pp

aa

rr

aa

mm

pp

ii

ll

vv

DD

rr

.

.

CC

hh

aa

cc

kk

oo

PP

uu

ll

pp

aa

rr

aa

mm

pp

ii

ll

((

AA

II

RR

11

99

77

00

KK

ee

rr

11

))

,,

ii

ss

oo

nn

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ee

aa

rr

ll

ii

ee

ss

tt

cc

aa

ss

ee

ss

bb

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

aa

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

vv

oo

ll

vv

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

ii

ss

ss

uu

ee

oo

ff

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

’’

ss

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

ii

nn

NN

RR

II

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

.

.

II

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

ff

KK

ee

rr

aa

ll

aa

nn

oo

tt

oo

nn

ll

yy

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

zz

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

ii

mm

pp

oo

rr

tt

aa

nn

tt

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

oo

ff

““

rr

ee

aa

ll

aa

nn

dd

ss

uu

bb

ss

tt

aa

nn

tt

ii

aa

ll

cc

oo

nn

nn

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

””

tt

oo

ee

ss

tt

aa

bb

ll

ii

ss

hh

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

’’

ss

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

dd

ee

cc

ii

dd

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

ii

ss

ss

uu

ee

,,

bb

uu

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

zz

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

aa

vv

aa

ii

ll

aa

bb

ii

ll

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

mm

ee

dd

yy

oo

ff

ww

rr

ii

tt

oo

ff

hh

aa

bb

ee

aa

ss

cc

oo

rr

pp

uu

ss

tt

oo

cc

ll

aa

ii

mm

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

ww

hh

oo

hh

aa

ss

bb

ee

ee

nn

ii

ll

ll

ee

gg

aa

ll

ll

yy

rr

ee

mm

oo

vv

ee

dd

bb

yy

aa

pp

aa

rr

ee

nn

tt

.

.

HH

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

mm

oo

vv

ee

dd

bb

aa

cc

kk

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

yy

ee

vv

ee

nn

tt

hh

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

hh

aa

tt

mm

ee

aa

nn

tt

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

mm

oo

vv

ee

dd

oo

uu

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

’’

ss

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

,,

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ff

ee

ll

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

ee

ss

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

ww

ee

rr

ee

oo

ff

pp

aa

rr

aa

mm

oo

uu

nn

tt

cc

oo

nn

ss

ii

dd

ee

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

nn

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

mm

aa

dd

ee

ii

tt

nn

ee

cc

ee

ss

ss

aa

rr

yy

tt

oo

gg

ii

vv

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

yy

.

.

TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

ll

aa

ii

dd

dd

oo

ww

nn

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

ff

ee

gg

uu

aa

rr

dd

ss

ff

oo

rr

ee

nn

ss

uu

rr

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

ee

nn

tt

aa

ll

rr

ii

gg

hh

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ww

ee

rr

ee

nn

oo

tt

tt

oo

tt

aa

ll

ll

yy

cc

oo

mm

pp

rr

oo

mm

ii

ss

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ss

ss

bb

yy

pp

aa

ss

ss

ii

nn

gg

aa

ss

ee

rr

ii

ee

ss

oo

ff

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

tt

oo

bb

aa

ll

aa

nn

cc

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

nn

ff

ll

ii

cc

tt

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

ee

ss

tt

ss

::(

(

ii

))

TT

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

rr

ww

ii

ll

ll

ee

xx

ee

cc

uu

tt

ee

aa

bb

oo

nn

dd

tt

oo

tt

hh

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

oo

pp

rr

oo

dd

uu

cc

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ww

hh

ee

nn

ee

vv

ee

rr

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

oo

dd

oo

ss

oo

.

.((1199))

Page 5: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 5/20

22

.

.

AA

nn

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

aa

kk

ii

nn

gg

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

CC

oo

nn

ss

uu

ll

aa

tt

ee

AA

uu

tt

hh

oo

rr

ii

tt

yy

ii

nn

MM

aa

dd

rr

aa

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

yy

ww

ii

ll

ll

rr

ee

nn

dd

ee

rr

aa

ll

ll

aa

ss

ss

ii

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

pp

oo

ss

ss

ii

bb

ll

ee

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

ii

mm

pp

ll

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

aa

nn

yy

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

ii

mm

ee

tt

oo

tt

ii

mm

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ff

rr

aa

mm

ee

ww

oo

rr

kk

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

LL

aa

ww

ww

ii

ll

ll

bb

ee

pp

rr

oo

dd

uu

cc

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

rr

.

.33

.

.

TT

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

rr

ww

ii

ll

ll

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

aa

nn

dd

ss

ee

nn

dd

aa

rr

ee

pp

oo

rr

tt

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

PP

aa

rr

ii

ss

hh

PP

rr

ii

ee

ss

tt

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

PP

aa

rr

ii

ss

hh

ii

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

yy

pp

rr

oo

pp

oo

ss

ee

tt

oo

ll

ii

vv

ee

ee

vv

ee

rr

yy

tt

hh

rr

ee

ee

mm

oo

nn

tt

hh

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

gg

ii

vv

ii

nn

gg

ss

uu

ff

ff

ii

cc

ii

ee

nn

tt

dd

ee

tt

aa

ii

ll

ss

aa

bb

oo

uu

tt

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

,,

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

hh

ee

aa

ll

tt

hh

aa

nn

dd

ww

ee

ll

ff

aa

rr

ee

aa

nn

dd

ss

ee

nn

dd

aa

cc

oo

pp

yy

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

oo

ff

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

.

.44

.

.

TT

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

rr

ww

ii

ll

ll

ii

nn

ff

oo

rr

mm

tt

hh

ee

RR

ee

gg

ii

ss

tt

rr

aa

rr

oo

ff

tt

hh

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

hh

ee

aa

dd

dd

rr

ee

ss

ss

oo

ff

hh

ee

rr

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

ii

mm

ee

tt

oo

tt

ii

mm

ee

aa

nn

dd

aa

nn

yy

cc

hh

aa

nn

gg

ee

oo

ff

aa

dd

dd

rr

ee

ss

ss

ww

ii

ll

ll

bb

ee

ii

mm

mm

ee

dd

ii

aa

tt

ee

ll

yy

nn

oo

tt

ii

ff

ii

ee

dd

.

.55

.

.

SS

hh

ee

ww

ii

ll

ll

nn

oo

tt

tt

aa

kk

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

oo

uu

tt

ss

ii

dd

ee

WW

ee

ss

tt

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

yy

ww

ii

tt

hh

oo

uu

tt

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ee

vv

ii

oo

uu

ss

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ee

xx

cc

ee

pp

tt

ii

nn

gg

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

yy

aa

rr

ee

bb

rr

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

tt

oo

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

aa

ss

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

.

.66

.

.

OO

nn

cc

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

rr

ee

ee

yy

ee

aa

rr

ss

,,

ss

hh

ee

mm

uu

ss

tt

bb

rr

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

tt

oo

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

ff

oo

rr

aa

mm

ii

nn

ii

mm

uu

mm

pp

ee

rr

ii

oo

dd

oo

ff

oo

nn

ee

mm

oo

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

oo

ww

nn

ee

xx

pp

ee

nn

ss

ee

.

.

AA

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

ii

mm

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ww

ii

ll

ll

hh

aa

vv

ee

aa

cc

cc

ee

ss

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

oo

nn

tt

ee

rr

mm

ss

aa

nn

dd

cc

oo

nn

dd

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

tt

oo

bb

ee

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

hh

aa

vv

ee

rr

ee

aa

cc

hh

ee

dd

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

.

.

TT

hh

ee

tt

hh

rr

ee

ee

yy

ee

aa

rr

ss

’’

pp

ee

rr

ii

oo

dd

ww

ii

ll

ll

bb

ee

dd

ee

tt

ee

rr

mm

ii

nn

ee

dd

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

dd

aa

tt

ee

oo

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

aa

rr

ee

tt

aa

kk

ee

nn

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

.

.

TT

hh

ee

yy

ww

ii

ll

ll

bb

ee

bb

rr

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ee

aa

rr

ll

ii

ee

rr

aa

ss

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

dd

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ii

tt

ii

ss

nn

oo

tt

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

aa

yy

ee

aa

rr

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

oo

dd

aa

yy

,,

ii

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

ss

ww

ii

ll

ll

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

mm

ee

ee

tt

tt

hh

ee

ee

xx

pp

ee

nn

ss

ee

ss

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

tt

rr

ii

pp

ff

rr

oo

mm

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

yy

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

nn

dd

bb

aa

cc

kk

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

.

.77

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

,,

ii

ff

hh

ee

ii

ss

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

ii

nn

gg

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

yy

,,

ww

ii

ll

ll

bb

ee

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

aa

cc

cc

ee

ss

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

oo

nn

tt

ee

rr

mm

ss

aa

nn

dd

cc

oo

nn

dd

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

aa

ss

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

nn

mm

oo

tt

ii

oo

nn

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

tt

ii

mm

aa

tt

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

ss

dd

ee

ss

ii

rr

ee

tt

oo

gg

oo

aa

nn

dd

ss

ee

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

aa

nn

dd

rr

ee

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

nn

gg

ff

oo

rr

pp

ee

rr

mm

ii

ss

ss

ii

oo

nn

ff

oo

rr

aa

cc

cc

ee

ss

ss

.

.88

.

.

WW

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

aa

rr

ee

bb

rr

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ee

nn

dd

oo

ff

33

yy

ee

aa

rr

ss

tt

hh

ee

ww

hh

oo

ll

ee

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

rr

ee

vv

ii

ee

ww

ee

dd

ss

uu

oo

mm

oo

tt

uu

bb

yy

tt

hh

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

rr

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

oo

rr

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

,,

mm

oo

dd

ii

ff

ii

ee

dd

,,

aa

ll

tt

ee

rr

ee

dd

oo

rr

cc

aa

nn

cc

ee

ll

ll

ee

dd

.

.

””7

7

.

.

II

nn

SS

uu

rr

ii

nn

dd

ee

rr

KK

aa

uu

rr

SS

aa

nn

dd

hh

uu

vv

.

.

HH

aa

rr

bb

aa

xx

SS

ii

nn

gg

hh

SS

aa

nn

dd

hh

uu

,,

AA

II

RR

11

99

88

44

SS

CC

11

22

22

44

tt

hh

ee

SS

uu

pp

rr

ee

mm

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

tt

oo

dd

ee

cc

ii

dd

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

//

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

ww

hh

ii

ll

ee

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

aa

ss

ss

tt

ii

ll

ll

ii

nn

EE

nn

gg

ll

aa

nn

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

hh

aa

dd

cc

ll

aa

nn

dd

ee

ss

tt

ii

nn

ee

ll

yy

tt

aa

kk

ee

nn

aa

ww

aa

yy

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa((2200))

tohisparentsplaceevenastheEnglishCourthadalreadypassedanorderonthechildrenscustodyinEnglandTeCourtlookedintoalltherelevantfactsofthecasetodecidewhatithbtittfthhilddltitlthbifthiidtididhdfhhildbihh

Page 6: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 6/20

tt

oo

hh

ii

ss

pp

aa

rr

ee

nn

tt

ss

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

ee

vv

ee

nn

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

EE

nn

gg

ll

ii

ss

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

aa

ll

rr

ee

aa

dd

yy

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

aa

nn

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

’

ss

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

ii

nn

EE

nn

gg

ll

aa

nn

dd

.

.

TT

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ll

oo

oo

kk

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

oo

aa

ll

ll

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ll

ee

vv

aa

nn

tt

ff

aa

cc

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

tt

oo

dd

ee

cc

ii

dd

ee

ww

hh

aa

tt

ww

aa

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

bb

ee

ss

tt

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

ee

ss

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

aa

nn

dd

uu

ll

tt

ii

mm

aa

tt

ee

ll

yy

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

bb

aa

ss

ii

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

nn

ss

ii

dd

ee

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

tt

oo

bb

ee

gg

ii

vv

ee

nn

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

.

.88

.

.

EE

ll

ii

zz

aa

bb

ee

tt

hh

DD

ii

nn

ss

hh

aa

ww

vv

.

.

AA

rr

vv

aa

nn

dd

MM

.

.

DD

ii

nn

ss

hh

aa

ww

((

MM

AA

NN

UU

/ /

SS

CC

/ /

00

33

11

22

/ /

11

99

88

66

))

ww

hh

ii

ll

ee

dd

ee

aa

ll

ii

nn

gg

ww

ii

tt

hh

aa

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

mm

oo

vv

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ff

rr

oo

mm

UU

SS

AA

cc

oo

nn

tt

rr

aa

rr

yy

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

ii

nn

ff

aa

vv

oo

uu

rr

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

,,

tt

hh

ee

SS

uu

pp

rr

ee

mm

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

bb

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

bb

aa

cc

kk

tt

oo

UU

SS

AA

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

nn

oo

tt

oo

nn

ll

yy

bb

ee

cc

aa

uu

ss

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

oo

ff

cc

oo

mm

ii

tt

yy

bb

uu

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

bb

ee

cc

aa

uu

ss

ee

,,

oo

nn

ff

aa

cc

tt

ss

--

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ww

ee

rr

ee

ii

nn

dd

ee

pp

ee

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

ll

yy

cc

oo

nn

ss

ii

dd

ee

rr

ee

dd

--

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

ee

ss

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

bb

aa

cc

kk

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

nn

aa

tt

ii

vv

ee

SS

tt

aa

tt

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

mm

oo

vv

aa

ll

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

’’

ss

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ww

ee

rr

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

ss

ii

xx

mm

oo

nn

tt

hh

ss9

9

.

.

II

nn

KK

uu

ll

dd

ee

ee

pp

SS

ii

dd

hh

uu

vv

.

.

CC

hh

aa

nn

aa

nn

SS

ii

nn

gg

hh

((

AA

II

RR

11

99

88

99

PP

&&

HH

11

00

33

))

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

ff

PP

uu

nn

j j

aa

bb

aa

nn

dd

HH

aa

rr

yy

aa

nn

aa

aa

ll

ss

oo

tt

oo

oo

kk

tt

hh

ee

vv

ii

ee

ww

tt

hh

aa

tt

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

bb

ee

ss

tt

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

ee

ss

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ww

hh

oo

ww

aa

ss

ii

nn

CC

aa

nn

aa

dd

aa

bb

ee

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

tt

oo

tt

aa

kk

ee

bb

aa

cc

kk

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ff

rr

oo

mm

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

tt

oo

CC

aa

nn

aa

dd

aa

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

cc

oo

nn

tt

ii

nn

uu

ee

dd

tt

oo

ll

ii

vv

ee

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

yy

ww

ee

rr

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

pp

aa

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

ll

gg

rr

aa

nn

dd

pp

aa

rr

ee

nn

tt

ss

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ss

tt

ii

ll

ll

bb

ee

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

CC

aa

nn

aa

dd

aa

aa

nn

dd

aa

ss

,,

ii

nn

aa

nn

yy

cc

aa

ss

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

hh

aa

dd

bb

ee

ee

nn

aa

ww

aa

rr

dd

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

bb

yy

aa

cc

oo

mm

pp

ee

tt

ee

nn

tt

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

CC

aa

nn

aa

dd

aa

.

.11

00

.

.

DD

hh

aa

nn

ww

aa

nn

tt

ii

JJ

oo

ss

hh

ii

vv

MM

aa

dd

hh

aa

vv

UU

nn

dd

ee

((

11

99

99

88

))

11

SS

CC

CC

11

11

22

tt

hh

ee

NN

RR

II

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ww

aa

ss

aa

ll

rr

ee

aa

dd

yy

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

tt

oo

aa

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ww

oo

mm

aa

nn

aa

nn

dd

dd

uu

rr

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

ss

uu

bb

ss

ii

ss

tt

ee

nn

cc

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ee

aa

rr

ll

ii

ee

rr

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

hh

aa

dd

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

ss

ee

cc

oo

nn

dd

ww

ii

ff

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

DD

hh

aa

nn

ww

aa

nn

tt

ii

JJ

oo

ss

hh

ii

.

.

DD

hh

aa

nn

ww

aa

nn

tt

ii

hh

aa

dd

aa

ss

oo

nn

ff

rr

oo

mm

hh

ii

mm

aa

nn

dd

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

ww

aa

ss

j j

uu

ss

tt

33

55

dd

aa

yy

ss

oo

ll

dd

ss

hh

ee

ll

ee

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

aa

nn

dd

cc

aa

mm

ee

bb

aa

cc

kk

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

ff

aa

nn

tt

ss

oo

nn

.

.

TT

hh

ee

SS

uu

pp

rr

ee

mm

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

tt

hh

ee

oo

cc

cc

aa

ss

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

dd

ee

cc

ii

dd

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

ww

hh

ee

nn

hh

ee

ww

aa

ss

mm

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

aa

nn

11

22

yy

ee

aa

rr

ss

oo

ll

dd

aa

nn

dd

dd

ee

cc

ii

dd

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ee

vv

ee

nn

tt

hh

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

mm

aa

yy

hh

aa

vv

ee

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

,,

tt

hh

ee

bb

ee

ss

tt

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

ee

ss

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

dd

ee

mm

aa

nn

dd

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

bb

ee

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

tt

oo

cc

oo

nn

tt

ii

nn

uu

ee

tt

oo

ss

tt

aa

yy

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ww

hh

oo

hh

aa

dd

bb

rr

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

uu

pp

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

ss

ii

nn

gg

ll

ee

--h

h

aa

nn

dd

ee

dd

ll

yy

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

ss

uu

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

tt

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

rr

ii

gg

hh

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

.

.11

11

.

.

II

nn

SS

aa

rr

ii

tt

aa

SS

hh

aa

rr

mm

aa

vv

SS

uu

ss

hh

ii

ll

SS

hh

aa

rr

mm

aa

((

[[

22

00

00

00

]]

11

SS

CC

RR

99

11

55

))

,,

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

rr

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

hh

aa

dd

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

aa

cc

aa

ss

ee

ff

oo

rr

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

ii

nn

AA

mm

ee

rr

ii

cc

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

aa

nn

dd

ww

hh

ii

ll

ee

tt

hh

ee

ll

ee

gg

aa

ll

bb

aa

tt

tt

ll

ee

ff

oo

rr

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

ww

aa

ss

ss

tt

ii

ll

ll

oo

nn

,,

bb

oo

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

hh

aa

vv

ii

nn

gg

bb

ee

ee

nn

aa

pp

pp

oo

ii

nn

tt

ee

dd

aa

ss

mm

aa

nn

aa

gg

ii

nn

gg

cc

oo

nn

ss

ee

rr

vv

aa

tt

oo

rr

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

,,

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

bb

rr

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

aa

ll

ll

ee

gg

ee

dd

ll

yy

ww

ii

tt

hh

oo

uu

tt

ee

vv

ee

nn

ii

nn

ff

oo

rr

mm

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

.

.

II

tt

ww

aa

ss

aa

ll

ll

ee

gg

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ww

ee

rr

ee

ii

nn

ii

ll

ll

ee

gg

aa

ll

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

SS

aa

rr

ii

tt

aa

SS

hh

aa

rr

mm

aa

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

nn

dd

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

SS

aa

rr

ii

tt

aa

tt

oo

rr

ee

ss

tt

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

tt

ww

oo((2211))

Page 7: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 7/20

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

.

.

TT

hh

ee

pp

aa

ss

ss

pp

oo

rr

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

tt

ww

oo

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

hh

aa

dd

aa

ll

ss

oo

bb

ee

ee

nn

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ee

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

hh

aa

nn

dd

ee

dd

oo

vv

ee

rr

tt

oo

hh

ii

mm

.

.

II

nn

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

ll

,,

tt

hh

ee

SS

uu

pp

rr

ee

mm

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

aa

rr

ee

ll

ee

vv

aa

nn

tt

ff

aa

cc

tt

oo

rr

bb

uu

tt

ii

tt

cc

aa

nn

nn

oo

tt

oo

vv

ee

rr

rr

ii

dd

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

nn

ss

ii

dd

ee

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

ww

ee

ll

ff

aa

rr

ee

oo

ff

mm

ii

nn

oo

rr

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

aa

nn

dd

ee

xx

pp

rr

ee

ss

ss

ee

dd

dd

oo

uu

bb

tt

ww

hh

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

ii

nn

pp

oo

ss

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

tt

aa

kk

ee

pp

rr

oo

pp

ee

rr

cc

aa

rr

ee

oo

ff

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

bb

ee

cc

aa

uu

ss

ee

oo

ff

hh

ii

ss

bb

aa

dd

hh

aa

bb

ii

tt

ss

aa

nn

dd

aa

ll

ss

oo

bb

ee

cc

aa

uu

ss

ee

hh

ee

ll

ii

vv

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ii

ss

aa

gg

ee

dd

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

ww

ii

tt

hh

nn

oo

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ff

aa

mm

ii

ll

yy

ss

uu

pp

pp

oo

rr

tt

.

.

II

tt

ff

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

dd

dd

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

oo

rr

dd

ii

nn

aa

rr

ii

ll

yy

tt

hh

ee

ff

ee

mm

aa

ll

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

tt

oo

rr

ee

mm

aa

ii

nn

ww

ii

tt

hh

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ss

oo

tt

hh

aa

tt

ss

hh

ee

cc

aa

nn

bb

ee

pp

rr

oo

pp

ee

rr

ll

yy

ll

oo

oo

kk

ee

dd

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ii

tt

ii

ss

nn

oo

tt

dd

ee

ss

ii

rr

aa

bb

ll

ee

tt

oo

ss

ee

pp

aa

rr

aa

tt

ee

tt

ww

oo

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ff

rr

oo

mm

ee

aa

cc

hh

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ww

aa

ss

nn

oo

tt

ii

ll

ll

ee

gg

aa

ll

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

.

.AA

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

mm

pp

oo

rr

tt

aa

nn

tt

ee

xx

pp

oo

ss

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

cc

aa

mm

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

SS

uu

pp

rr

ee

mm

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

NN

aa

rr

aa

ss

ii

mm

hh

aa

RR

aa

oo

vv

VV

ee

nn

kk

aa

tt

aa

LL

aa

kk

ss

hh

mm

ii

[[

11

99

99

11

]]

22

SS

CC

RR

88

22

11

.

.TT

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

hh

aa

dd

vv

ee

rr

yy

ss

ii

mm

ii

ll

aa

rr

ff

aa

cc

tt

--

ss

ii

tt

uu

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

::

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

oo

ff

dd

ii

ss

ss

oo

ll

uu

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

CC

ii

rr

cc

uu

ii

tt

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

ff

SS

tt

.

.

LL

oo

uu

ii

ss

CC

oo

uu

nn

tt

yy

,,

MM

ii

ss

ss

oo

uu

rr

ii

,,

UU

SS

AA

ww

aa

ss

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

bb

yy

aa

ss

ss

uu

mm

ii

nn

gg

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

vv

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

,,

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

hh

aa

dd

bb

ee

ee

nn

aa

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

SS

tt

aa

tt

ee

oo

ff

MM

ii

ss

ss

oo

uu

rr

ii

ff

oo

rr

99

00

dd

aa

yy

ss

pp

rr

ee

cc

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

mm

mm

ee

nn

cc

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

aa

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

mm

ii

nn

ii

mm

uu

mm

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

.

.

SS

ee

cc

oo

nn

dd

ll

yy

,,

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

hh

aa

dd

bb

ee

ee

nn

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

oo

nn

ll

yy

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

rr

ee

mm

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

nn

oo

rr

ee

aa

ss

oo

nn

aa

bb

ll

ee

ll

ii

kk

ee

ll

ii

hh

oo

oo

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

bb

ee

tt

ww

ee

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

rr

vv

ee

dd

,,

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

hh

aa

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

““

ii

rr

rr

ee

tt

rr

ii

ee

vv

aa

bb

ll

yy

bb

rr

oo

kk

ee

nn

””

.

.

TT

hh

ii

rr

dd

ll

yy

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

ww

ii

ff

ee

hh

aa

dd

nn

oo

tt

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.TT

aa

kk

ii

nn

gg

oo

nn

ff

rr

oo

mm

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

ll

ee

ff

tt

bb

yy

SS

aa

tt

yy

aa

vv

.

.

TT

ee

j j

aa

,,

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ee

xx

pp

ll

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

ii

mm

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

oo

ff

ee

aa

cc

hh

cc

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

rr

ee

ll

ee

vv

aa

nn

tt

pp

oo

rr

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ii

ss

ww

oo

rr

tt

hh

qq

uu

oo

tt

ii

nn

gg

::C

C

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

((

aa

))

::“

“

11

55

.

.

CC

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

((

aa

))

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

ss

tt

aa

tt

ee

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ss

hh

aa

ll

ll

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

dd

ii

ff

ii

tt

hh

aa

ss

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

ee

nn

pp

rr

oo

nn

oo

uu

nn

cc

ee

dd

bb

yy

aa

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

ff

cc

oo

mm

pp

ee

tt

ee

nn

tt

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

.

.

WW

ee

aa

rr

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

vv

ii

ee

ww

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

pp

rr

ee

tt

ee

dd

tt

oo

mm

ee

aa

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

oo

nn

ll

yy

tt

hh

aa

tt

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

ii

ll

ll

bb

ee

aa

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

ff

cc

oo

mm

pp

ee

tt

ee

nn

tt

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

AA

cc

tt

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

ll

aa

ww

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

aa

rr

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

ss

aa

ss

aa

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

ff

cc

oo

mm

pp

ee

tt

ee

nn

tt

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

ee

nn

tt

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

dd

ii

ss

pp

uu

tt

ee

.

.

AA

nn

yy

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

aa

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

ii

tt

hh

oo

uu

tt

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

uu

nn

ll

ee

ss

ss

bb

oo

tt

hh

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

vv

oo

ll

uu

nn

tt

aa

rr

ii

ll

yy

aa

nn

dd

uu

nn

cc

oo

nn

dd

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

yy

ss

uu

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

tt

hh

ee

mm

ss

ee

ll

vv

ee

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

aa

tt

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ee

xx

pp

rr

ee

ss

ss

ii

oo

nn

““

cc

oo

mm

pp

ee

tt

ee

nn

tt

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

””

ii

nn

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

44

11

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

EE

vv

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

AA

cc

tt

hh

aa

ss

aa

ll

ss

oo

tt

oo

bb

ee

cc

oo

nn

ss

tt

rr

uu

ee

dd

ll

ii

kk

ee

ww

ii

ss

ee

.

.

””((2222))

Page 8: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 8/20

CC

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

((

bb

))

::“

“

11

66

.

.

CC

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

((

bb

))

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

ss

tt

aa

tt

ee

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

ii

ff

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

hh

aa

ss

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

ee

nn

gg

ii

vv

ee

nn

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

ee

rr

ii

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

ww

ii

ll

ll

nn

oo

tt

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

ss

uu

cc

hh

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

.

.

TT

hh

ii

ss

cc

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

pp

rr

ee

tt

ee

dd

tt

oo

mm

ee

aa

nn

((

aa

))

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

oo

nn

aa

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

aa

vv

aa

ii

ll

aa

bb

ll

ee

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

ll

aa

ww

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

aa

rr

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

,,

aa

nn

dd

((

bb

))

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

aa

rr

ee

ss

uu

ll

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

ss

tt

bb

ee

tt

ww

ee

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ll

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

ii

ss

ff

uu

ll

ff

ii

ll

ll

ee

dd

oo

nn

ll

yy

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

ii

ss

dd

uu

ll

yy

ss

ee

rr

vv

ee

dd

aa

nn

dd

vv

oo

ll

uu

nn

tt

aa

rr

ii

ll

yy

aa

nn

dd

uu

nn

cc

oo

nn

dd

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

yy

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

ss

hh

ii

mm

ss

ee

ll

ff

//

hh

ee

rr

ss

ee

ll

ff

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

nn

dd

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

ss

tt

ss

tt

hh

ee

cc

ll

aa

ii

mm

,,

oo

rr

aa

gg

rr

ee

ee

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

ss

ss

ii

nn

gg

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

oo

rr

ww

ii

tt

hh

oo

uu

tt

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

aa

nn

cc

ee

.

.

AA

mm

ee

rr

ee

ff

ii

ll

ii

nn

gg

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

pp

ll

yy

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

ll

aa

ii

mm

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

pp

rr

oo

tt

ee

ss

tt

aa

nn

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

oo

uu

tt

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

tt

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

,,

oo

rr

aa

nn

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

aa

nn

cc

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ee

ii

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

oo

rr

tt

hh

rr

oo

uu

gg

hh

aa

rr

ee

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

aa

tt

ii

vv

ee

ff

oo

rr

oo

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

,,

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

cc

oo

nn

ss

ii

dd

ee

rr

ee

dd

aa

ss

aa

dd

ee

cc

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

ee

rr

ii

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

.

.

II

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

rr

ee

ss

pp

ee

cc

tt

tt

hh

ee

gg

ee

nn

ee

rr

aa

ll

rr

uu

ll

ee

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

aa

cc

qq

uu

ii

ee

ss

cc

ee

nn

cc

ee

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

vv

aa

ll

ii

dd

ii

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

ss

aa

nn

dd

aa

rr

ee

aa

ss

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

ii

gg

nn

oo

rr

ee

dd

aa

nn

dd

dd

ee

ee

mm

ee

dd

ii

nn

aa

pp

pp

rr

oo

pp

rr

ii

aa

tt

ee

.

.

””C

C

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

((

cc

))

::“

“

11

77

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ss

ee

cc

oo

nn

dd

pp

aa

rr

tt

oo

ff

cc

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

((

cc

))

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

ss

tt

aa

tt

ee

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ii

ss

ff

oo

uu

nn

dd

ee

dd

oo

nn

aa

rr

ee

ff

uu

ss

aa

ll

tt

oo

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

tt

hh

ee

ll

aa

ww

oo

ff

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

ii

nn

cc

aa

ss

ee

ss

ii

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ss

uu

cc

hh

ll

aa

ww

ii

ss

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

bb

ll

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ww

ii

ll

ll

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

.

.

TT

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

ss

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

aa

kk

ee

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

cc

aa

nn

oo

nn

ll

yy

bb

ee

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

ee

ii

tt

hh

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

mm

aa

rr

yy

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

ss

tt

aa

tt

uu

tt

oo

rr

yy

ll

aa

ww

ii

nn

ff

oo

rr

cc

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

.

.

HH

ee

nn

cc

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

oo

nn

ll

yy

ll

aa

ww

tt

hh

aa

tt

cc

aa

nn

bb

ee

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

bb

ll

ee

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

dd

ii

ss

pp

uu

tt

ee

ss

ii

ss

tt

hh

ee

oo

nn

ee

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

aa

rr

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

,,

aa

nn

dd

nn

oo

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ll

aa

ww

.

.

WW

hh

ee

nn

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ii

ss

ff

oo

uu

nn

dd

ee

dd

oo

nn

aa

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

rr

oo

nn

aa

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

nn

oo

tt

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

ss

uu

cc

hh

ll

aa

ww

,,

ii

tt

ii

ss

aa

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ii

ss

ii

nn

dd

ee

ff

ii

aa

nn

cc

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ll

aa

ww

.

.

HH

ee

nn

cc

ee

,,

ii

tt

ii

ss

nn

oo

tt

cc

oo

nn

cc

ll

uu

ss

ii

vv

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

ss

aa

dd

j j

uu

dd

ii

cc

aa

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ii

nn

aa

nn

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

uu

nn

ee

nn

ff

oo

rr

cc

ee

aa

bb

ll

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

.

.

FF

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

mm

ee

rr

ee

aa

ss

oo

nn

,,

ss

uu

cc

hh

aa

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ww

ii

ll

ll

aa

ll

ss

oo

bb

ee

uu

nn

ee

nn

ff

oo

rr

cc

ee

aa

bb

ll

ee

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

cc

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

((

ff

))

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

,,

ss

ii

nn

cc

ee

ss

uu

cc

hh

aa

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

oo

bb

vv

ii

oo

uu

ss

ll

yy

bb

ee

ii

nn

bb

rr

ee

aa

cc

hh

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

ll

aa

ww

ii

nn

ff

oo

rr

cc

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

.

.

““C

C

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

((

dd

))

::“

“

11

88

.

.

CC

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

((

dd

))

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

mm

aa

kk

ee

ss

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

uu

nn

ee

nn

ff

oo

rr

cc

ee

aa

bb

ll

ee

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

ii

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ii

tt

ii

ss

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

aa

rr

ee

oo

pp

pp

oo

ss

ee

dd

tt

oo

nn

aa

tt

uu

rr

aa

ll

j j

uu

ss

tt

ii

cc

ee

,,

ss

tt

aa

tt

ee

ss

nn

oo

mm

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

aa

nn

aa

nn

ee

ll

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

aa

rr

yy

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

oo

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

aa

nn

yy

cc

ii

vv

ii

ll

ii

ss

ee

dd

ss

yy

ss

tt

ee

mm

oo

ff

j j

uu

ss

tt

ii

cc

ee

rr

ee

ss

tt

ss

.

.

HH

oo

ww

ee

vv

ee

rr

,,

ii

nn

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

ss

cc

oo

nn

cc

ee

rr

nn

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

mm

ii

ll

yy

ll

aa

ww

ss

uu

cc

hh

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

dd

ii

ss

pp

uu

tt

ee

ss

,,

tt

hh

ii

ss

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

hh

aa

ss

tt

oo

bb

ee

ee

xx

tt

ee

nn

dd

ee

dd

tt

oo

mm

ee

aa

nn

ss

oo

mm

ee

tt

hh

ii

nn

gg

mm

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

aa

nn

mm

ee

rr

ee

cc

oo

mm

pp

ll

ii

aa

nn

cc

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

tt

ee

cc

hh

nn

ii

cc

aa

ll

rr

uu

ll

ee

ss

oo

ff ((2233))

Page 9: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 9/20

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

dd

uu

rr

ee

.

.

II

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

uu

ll

ee

oo

ff

aa

uu

dd

ii

aa

ll

tt

ee

rr

aa

mm

pp

aa

rr

tt

ee

mm

hh

aa

ss

aa

nn

yy

mm

ee

aa

nn

ii

nn

gg

ww

ii

tt

hh

rr

ee

ff

ee

rr

ee

nn

cc

ee

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

ii

nn

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

,,

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

pp

uu

rr

pp

oo

ss

ee

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

uu

ll

ee

ii

tt

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

dd

ee

ee

mm

ee

dd

ss

uu

ff

ff

ii

cc

ii

ee

nn

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

hh

aa

ss

bb

ee

ee

nn

dd

uu

ll

yy

ss

ee

rr

vv

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ss

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.

II

tt

ii

ss

nn

ee

cc

ee

ss

ss

aa

rr

yy

tt

oo

aa

ss

cc

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

ww

hh

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

ww

aa

ss

ii

nn

aa

pp

oo

ss

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

oo

rr

rr

ee

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

hh

ii

mm

ss

ee

ll

ff

//

hh

ee

rr

ss

ee

ll

ff

aa

nn

dd

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

ss

tt

ee

ff

ff

ee

cc

tt

ii

vv

ee

ll

yy

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

ii

dd

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

.

.

TT

hh

ii

ss

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

aa

pp

pp

ll

yy

ee

qq

uu

aa

ll

ll

yy

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

tt

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

ii

ff

aa

nn

dd

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

yy

aa

rr

ee

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

ee

ii

tt

hh

ee

rr

pp

aa

rr

tt

yy

.

.

II

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

ss

nn

oo

tt

aa

ss

cc

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

aa

nn

dd

ee

nn

ss

uu

rr

ee

dd

ss

uu

cc

hh

ee

ff

ff

ee

cc

tt

ii

vv

ee

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

ss

tt

bb

yy

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

rr

tt

oo

mm

aa

kk

ee

aa

ll

ll

nn

ee

cc

ee

ss

ss

aa

rr

yy

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

tt

oo

dd

ee

ff

ee

nn

dd

ii

nn

cc

ll

uu

dd

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

ss

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

rr

aa

vv

ee

ll

,,

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

aa

nn

dd

ll

ii

tt

ii

gg

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

nn

ee

cc

ee

ss

ss

aa

rr

yy

,,

ii

tt

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

aa

rr

ee

ii

nn

bb

rr

ee

aa

cc

hh

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

ss

oo

ff

nn

aa

tt

uu

rr

aa

ll

j j

uu

ss

tt

ii

cc

ee

.

.

II

tt

ii

ss

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ii

ss

rr

ee

aa

ss

oo

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

ww

ee

ff

ii

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

uu

ll

ee

ss

oo

ff

PP

rr

ii

vv

aa

tt

ee

II

nn

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

!!

LL

aa

ww

oo

ff

ss

oo

mm

ee

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

ii

ee

ss

ii

nn

ss

ii

ss

tt

,,

ee

vv

ee

nn

ii

nn

cc

oo

mm

mm

ee

rr

cc

ii

aa

ll

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

ss

,,

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

aa

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

ff

ee

nn

dd

aa

nn

tt

ii

ss

ee

ii

tt

hh

ee

rr

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

dd

oo

rr

ii

ss

hh

aa

bb

ii

tt

uu

aa

ll

ll

yy

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

tt

.

.

””O

O

nn

tt

hh

ee

bb

aa

ss

ii

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

aa

bb

oo

vv

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

pp

rr

ee

tt

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

,,

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

hh

ee

nn

ww

ee

nn

tt

oo

nn

tt

oo

ll

aa

yy

dd

oo

ww

nn

aa

gg

oo

ll

dd

ee

nn

rr

uu

ll

ee

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

aa

ss

bb

ee

ee

nn

rr

ee

pp

ee

aa

tt

ee

dd

ll

yy

ff

oo

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

aa

nn

dd

rr

ee

ll

ii

ee

dd

uu

pp

oo

nn

ii

nn

ss

uu

bb

ss

ee

qq

uu

ee

nn

tt

cc

aa

ss

ee

ss

::“

“

22

00

.

.

……

TT

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ss

ss

uu

mm

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ss

ww

ee

ll

ll

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

ss

oo

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ll

ii

ee

ff

ii

ss

gg

rr

aa

nn

tt

ee

dd

mm

uu

ss

tt

bb

ee

ii

nn

aa

cc

cc

oo

rr

dd

aa

nn

cc

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

ll

aa

ww

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

aa

rr

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

.

.

TT

hh

ee

oo

nn

ll

yy

tt

hh

rr

ee

ee

ee

xx

cc

ee

pp

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ii

ss

rr

uu

ll

ee

ww

ee

rr

ee

aa

ll

ss

oo

ll

aa

ii

dd

dd

oo

ww

nn

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

tt

ss

ee

ll

ff

aa

ss

ff

oo

ll

ll

oo

ww

ss

::(

(

ii

))

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

aa

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

ss

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

ii

ss

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

dd

oo

rr

hh

aa

bb

ii

tt

uu

aa

ll

ll

yy

aa

nn

dd

pp

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

ee

nn

tt

ll

yy

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ll

ii

ee

ff

ii

ss

gg

rr

aa

nn

tt

ee

dd

oo

nn

aa

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

aa

vv

aa

ii

ll

aa

bb

ll

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

ll

aa

ww

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

aa

rr

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

;;(

(

ii

ii

))

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

vv

oo

ll

uu

nn

tt

aa

rr

ii

ll

yy

aa

nn

dd

ee

ff

ff

ee

cc

tt

ii

vv

ee

ll

yy

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

aa

ss

dd

ii

ss

cc

uu

ss

ss

ee

dd

aa

bb

oo

vv

ee

aa

nn

dd

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

ss

tt

ss

tt

hh

ee

cc

ll

aa

ii

mm

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ii

ss

bb

aa

ss

ee

dd

oo

nn

aa

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

aa

vv

aa

ii

ll

aa

bb

ll

ee

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

ll

aa

ww

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

aa

rr

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

;;(

(

ii

ii

ii

))

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

cc

oo

nn

ss

ee

nn

tt

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

aa

nn

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ll

ii

ee

ff

aa

ll

tt

hh

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

ii

ss

nn

oo

tt

ii

nn

aa

cc

cc

oo

rr

dd

aa

nn

cc

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

ll

aa

ww

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

.

.

””B

B

rr

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

bb

ee

nn

ee

ff

ii

tt

oo

ff

cc

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

tt

yy

aa

nn

dd

pp

rr

ee

dd

ii

cc

tt

aa

bb

ii

ll

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

ll

aa

ww

,,

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

aa

ii

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

““

……

tt

hh

ee

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ss

aa

ii

dd

rr

uu

ll

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

tt

ss

ss

tt

aa

tt

ee

dd

ee

xx

cc

ee

pp

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

hh

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

mm

ee

rr

ii

tt

oo

ff

bb

ee

ii

nn

gg

j j

uu

ss

tt

aa

nn

dd

ee

qq

uu

ii

tt

aa

bb

ll

ee

.

.

II

tt

dd

oo

ee

ss

nn

oo

ii

nn

j j

uu

ss

tt

ii

cc

ee

tt

oo

aa

nn

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

.

.

TT

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

dd

oo

aa

nn

dd

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

tt

oo

kk

nn

oo

ww

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

rr

ii

gg

hh

tt

ss

aa

nn

dd((2244))

Page 10: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 10/20

oo

bb

ll

ii

gg

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

yy

mm

aa

rr

rr

yy

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

aa

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

cc

uu

ll

aa

rr

ll

aa

ww

.

.

TT

hh

ee

yy

cc

aa

nn

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

hh

ee

aa

rr

dd

tt

oo

mm

aa

kk

ee

aa

gg

rr

ii

ee

vv

aa

nn

cc

ee

aa

bb

oo

uu

tt

ii

tt

ll

aa

tt

ee

rr

oo

rr

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

tt

oo

bb

yy

pp

aa

ss

ss

ii

tt

bb

yy

ss

uu

bb

tt

ee

rr

ff

uu

gg

ee

ss

aa

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

cc

aa

ss

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

rr

uu

ll

ee

aa

ll

ss

oo

hh

aa

ss

aa

nn

aa

dd

vv

aa

nn

tt

aa

gg

ee

oo

ff

rr

ee

ss

cc

uu

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

ss

tt

ii

tt

uu

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

uu

nn

cc

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

mm

aa

zz

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

uu

ll

ee

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

PP

rr

ii

vv

aa

tt

ee

II

nn

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

LL

aa

ww

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

ff

ff

ee

rr

ee

nn

tt

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

ii

ee

ss

ww

ii

tt

hh

rr

ee

gg

aa

rr

dd

tt

oo

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

nn

dd

mm

ee

rr

ii

tt

ss

bb

aa

ss

ee

dd

vv

aa

rr

ii

oo

uu

ss

ll

yy

oo

nn

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

,,

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

ii

tt

yy

,,

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

——

pp

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

ee

nn

tt

oo

rr

tt

ee

mm

pp

oo

rr

aa

rr

yy

oo

rr

aa

dd

hh

oo

cc

,,

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

,,

pp

rr

oo

pp

ee

rr

ll

aa

ww

ee

tt

cc

.

.

aa

nn

dd

ee

nn

ss

uu

rr

ii

nn

gg

cc

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

tt

yy

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

ss

tt

vv

ii

tt

aa

ll

ff

ii

ee

ll

dd

oo

ff

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

ii

ff

ee

aa

nn

dd

cc

oo

nn

ff

oo

rr

mm

ii

tt

yy

ww

ii

tt

hh

pp

uu

bb

ll

ii

cc

pp

oo

ll

ii

cc

yy

……

.

.

””A

A

cc

cc

oo

rr

dd

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

,,

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

dd

ii

ss

ss

oo

ll

vv

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

aa

ss

ww

ii

tt

hh

oo

uu

tt

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

aa

ss

aa

cc

cc

oo

rr

dd

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

HH

MM

AA

AA

cc

tt

nn

ee

ii

tt

hh

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

ww

aa

ss

cc

ee

ll

ee

bb

rr

aa

tt

ee

dd

nn

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

hh

aa

dd

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

tt

oo

gg

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

nn

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

aa

tt

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.

TT

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ww

aa

ss

aa

ll

ss

oo

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

oo

nn

aa

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ww

aa

ss

nn

oo

tt

aa

vv

aa

ii

ll

aa

bb

ll

ee

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

HH

MM

AA

AA

cc

tt

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ii

ss

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

bb

ll

ee

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

.

.

FF

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

rr

,,

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

hh

aa

dd

bb

ee

ee

nn

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

bb

yy

rr

ee

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

MM

ii

ss

ss

oo

uu

rr

ii

SS

tt

aa

tt

ee

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

cc

oo

rr

dd

ss

hh

oo

ww

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

ww

aa

ss

oo

nn

ll

yy

aa

““

bb

ii

rr

dd

oo

ff

pp

aa

ss

ss

aa

gg

ee

””

--

HH

ee

hh

aa

dd

,,

ii

ff

aa

tt

aa

ll

ll

,,

oo

nn

ll

yy

tt

ee

cc

hh

nn

ii

cc

aa

ll

ll

yy

ss

aa

tt

ii

ss

ff

ii

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

oo

ff

99

00

dd

aa

yy

ss

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

oo

nn

ll

yy

pp

uu

rr

pp

oo

ss

ee

oo

ff

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

rr

ee

ii

tt

ee

rr

aa

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

dd

oo

ee

ss

nn

oo

tt

mm

ee

aa

nn

aa

tt

ee

mm

pp

oo

rr

aa

rr

yy

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

pp

uu

rr

pp

oo

ss

ee

oo

ff

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ii

nn

gg

aa

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

,,

bb

uu

tt

‘‘

hh

aa

bb

ii

tt

uu

aa

ll

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

’’

oo

rr

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ii

ss

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

dd

ee

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

pp

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

ee

nn

tt

ff

oo

rr

ff

uu

tt

uu

rr

ee

aa

ss

ww

ee

ll

ll

.

.TT

hh

ee

ff

ii

nn

aa

ll

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

ss

ii

nn

cc

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

rr

ee

gg

aa

rr

dd

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

aa

ss

ww

ee

ll

ll

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

oo

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

,,

ww

ee

rr

ee

nn

oo

tt

ii

nn

aa

cc

cc

oo

rr

dd

aa

nn

cc

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

AA

cc

tt

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

ww

ee

rr

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

,,

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

hh

aa

dd

nn

oo

tt

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

rr

cc

oo

nn

ss

ee

nn

tt

ee

dd

tt

oo

ii

tt

ss

pp

aa

ss

ss

ii

nn

gg

,,

ii

tt

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

aa

nn

dd

ww

aa

ss

uu

nn

ee

nn

ff

oo

rr

cc

ee

aa

bb

ll

ee

.

.TT

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ff

ii

nn

aa

ll

ll

yy

ss

aa

ii

dd

::

““

WW

ee

bb

ee

ll

ii

ee

vv

ee

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ll

ee

vv

aa

nn

tt

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

dd

ee

aa

rr

ee

cc

aa

pp

aa

bb

ll

ee

oo

ff

bb

ee

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

pp

rr

ee

tt

ee

dd

tt

oo

ss

ee

cc

uu

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

dd

cc

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

tt

yy

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ss

pp

hh

ee

rr

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ii

ss

bb

rr

aa

nn

cc

hh

oo

ff

ll

aa

ww

ii

nn

cc

oo

nn

ff

oo

rr

mm

ii

tt

yy

ww

ii

tt

hh

pp

uu

bb

ll

ii

cc

pp

oo

ll

ii

cc

yy

,,

j j

uu

ss

tt

ii

cc

ee

,,

ee

qq

uu

ii

tt

yy

aa

nn

dd

gg

oo

oo

dd

cc

oo

nn

ss

cc

ii

ee

nn

cc

ee

,,

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

uu

ll

ee

ss

ss

oo

ee

vv

oo

ll

vv

ee

dd

ww

ii

ll

ll

pp

rr

oo

tt

ee

cc

tt

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

nn

cc

tt

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

ss

tt

ii

tt

uu

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

uu

nn

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

ff

aa

mm

ii

ll

yy

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

aa

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

rr

nn

ee

rr

ss

tt

oo

nn

ee

ss

oo

ff

oo

uu

rr

ss

oo

cc

ii

ee

tt

aa

ll

ll

ii

ff

ee

.

.

””V

V

ee

ee

nn

aa

KK

aa

ll

ii

aa

vv

JJ

aa

tt

ii

nn

dd

ee

rr

NN

.

.

KK

aa

ll

ii

aa

AA

II

RR

11

99

99

66

DD

ee

ll

55

44

ww

aa

ss

aa

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

cc

aa

ss

ee

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

NN

RR

II

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

ee

xx

pp

aa

rr

tt

ee

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ii

nn

CC

aa

nn

aa

dd

aa

oo

nn

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

nn

oo

tt

aa

vv

aa

ii

ll

aa

bb

ll

ee

tt

oo

hh

ii

mm

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.

TT

hh

ee

DD

ee

ll

hh

ii

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

nn

oo

tt

oo

nn

ll

yy

dd

ii

dd

ss

uu

cc

hh

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

nn

oo

tt

bb

aa

rr

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

bb

yy

ww

ii

ff

ee

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

ss

ii

tt

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

aa

cc

tt

aa

ss

rr

ee

ss

j j

uu

dd

ii

cc

aa

tt

aa

,,

ii

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

dd

ii

dd

nn

oo

tt

bb

aa

rr

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

ff

oo

rr

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ii

nn

hh

ee

rr

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn((2255))

Page 11: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 11/20

TT

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

ll

oo

oo

kk

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

ii

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

dd

ii

dd

nn

oo

tt

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

ss

tt

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

’

ss

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

CC

aa

nn

aa

dd

aa

--

tt

hh

aa

tt

ss

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

nn

oo

mm

ee

aa

nn

ss

tt

oo

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

ss

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

oo

ff

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

ww

aa

ss

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

aa

ss

ss

hh

ee

ww

aa

ss

uu

nn

aa

bb

ll

ee

tt

oo

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

aa

nn

dd

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

ss

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

hh

ii

bb

ii

tt

ii

vv

ee

cc

oo

ss

tt

oo

ff

gg

oo

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

CC

aa

nn

aa

dd

aa

aa

nn

dd

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

dd

ii

ss

aa

bb

ll

ee

dd

hh

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

hh

ee

rr

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

tt

oo

oo

kk

ff

uu

ll

ll

aa

dd

vv

aa

nn

tt

aa

gg

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

aa

nn

dd

ii

cc

aa

pp

.

.

AA

ll

ss

oo

,,

tt

hh

ee

oo

nn

ll

yy

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

oo

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ss

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

aa

dd

bb

ee

ee

nn

aa

pp

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

ee

nn

tt

bb

rr

ee

aa

kk

dd

oo

ww

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

,,

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ww

aa

ss

nn

oo

tt

aa

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

oo

ff

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

dd

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

ll

aa

ww

.

.TT

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

rr

ee

ll

ii

ee

dd

uu

pp

oo

nn

aa

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ii

nn

MM

aa

gg

aa

nn

bb

hh

aa

ii

vv

.

.

MM

aa

nn

ii

bb

ee

nn

,,

AA

II

RR

11

99

88

55

GG

uu

j j

11

88

77

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

cc

rr

ee

aa

tt

ee

ss

ee

ss

tt

oo

pp

pp

ee

ll

oo

rr

rr

ee

ss

j j

uu

dd

ii

cc

aa

tt

aa

bb

ee

tt

ww

ee

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

mm

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

dd

ee

dd

ss

uu

cc

hh

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

ii

ss

nn

oo

tt

ss

uu

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

tt

oo

aa

tt

tt

aa

cc

kk

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

aa

nn

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

ll

aa

uu

ss

ee

ss

((

aa

))

tt

oo

((

ff

))

oo

ff

ss

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

33

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

.

.

PP

.

.

CC

oo

dd

ee

vv

ii

dd

eeA

A

nn

uu

bb

hh

aa

vv

VV

ii

kk

aa

ss

AA

gg

gg

aa

rr

ww

aa

ll

((

11

00

00

((

22

00

00

22

))

DD

LL

TT

66

88

22

))

ww

aa

ss

aa

cc

aa

ss

ee

ii

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

ii

ss

ss

uu

ee

ww

aa

ss

ww

hh

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

oo

ff

‘‘

nn

oo

ff

aa

uu

ll

tt

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

’’

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ff

rr

oo

mm

aa

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

UU

nn

ii

tt

ee

dd

SS

tt

aa

tt

ee

ss

oo

ff

AA

mm

ee

rr

ii

cc

aa

((

UU

SS

AA

))

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

ee

nn

ff

oo

rr

cc

ee

dd

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

ww

aa

ss

ss

oo

ll

ee

mm

nn

ii

ss

ee

dd

aa

ss

pp

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

rr

ii

tt

ee

ss

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

hh

aa

dd

nn

oo

tt

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

UU

SS

AA

aa

nn

dd

hh

aa

dd

nn

oo

tt

cc

oo

nn

ss

ee

nn

tt

ee

dd

tt

oo

gg

rr

aa

nn

tt

oo

ff

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

.

.TT

hh

ee

ff

aa

cc

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

ww

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

ll

aa

ii

nn

tt

ii

ff

ff

,,

tt

hh

ee

yy

oo

uu

nn

gg

ww

ii

ff

ee

,,

ww

aa

ss

ss

ee

ee

kk

ii

nn

gg

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

oo

ff

dd

ee

cc

ll

aa

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

ss

hh

ee

ww

aa

ss

ee

nn

tt

ii

tt

ll

ee

dd

tt

oo

ll

ii

vv

ee

ss

ee

pp

aa

rr

aa

tt

ee

ll

yy

ff

rr

oo

mm

hh

ee

rr

NN

RR

II

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

ff

ee

nn

dd

aa

nn

tt

,,

aa

nn

dd

aa

ll

ss

oo

ff

oo

rr

aa

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ff

oo

rr

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

ii

nn

hh

ee

rr

ff

aa

vv

oo

uu

rr

bb

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

ee

ll

ii

tt

ee

ee

xx

pp

ee

nn

ss

ee

ss

aa

ss

ss

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

bb

ee

ee

nn

dd

ee

ss

ee

rr

tt

ee

dd

aa

nn

dd

aa

bb

aa

nn

dd

oo

nn

ee

dd

bb

yy

hh

ii

mm

vv

ee

rr

yy

ss

oo

oo

nn

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

,,

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

bb

ee

ii

nn

gg

ss

uu

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

tt

oo

cc

rr

uu

ee

ll

tt

yy

.

.

DD

uu

rr

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

nn

dd

ee

nn

cc

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ss

uu

ii

tt

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ll

ee

aa

rr

nn

tt

oo

ff

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

hh

aa

vv

ii

nn

gg

bb

ee

ee

nn

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

AA

,,

ss

hh

ee

aa

ll

ss

oo

aa

pp

pp

rr

oo

aa

cc

hh

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

oo

rr

ee

ss

tt

rr

aa

ii

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

rr

oo

mm

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

AA

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

uu

pp

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

rr

ee

ss

tt

rr

aa

ii

nn

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

ff

ee

nn

dd

aa

nn

tt

ff

rr

oo

mm

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ff

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

SS

tt

aa

tt

ee

oo

ff

CC

oo

nn

nn

ee

cc

tt

ii

cc

uu

tt

,,

UU

SS

AA

ff

oo

rr

aa

pp

ee

rr

ii

oo

dd

oo

ff

tt

hh

ii

rr

tt

yy

dd

aa

yy

ss

.

.

HH

oo

ww

ee

vv

ee

rr

,,

ii

nn

ss

pp

ii

tt

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

““

NN

oo

FF

aa

uu

ll

tt

DD

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

PP

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

””

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

.

.

WW

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

ff

aa

cc

tt

ww

aa

ss

bb

rr

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

nn

oo

tt

ii

cc

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

aa

nn

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

aa

ss

kk

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

ff

ee

nn

dd

aa

nn

tt

ff

oo

rr

rr

ee

cc

oo

rr

dd

ii

nn

gg

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ss

tt

aa

tt

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

OO

rr

dd

ee

rr

XX

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

PP

CC

aa

nn

dd

oo

nn

hh

ii

ss

ff

aa

ii

ll

uu

rr

ee

tt

oo

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

,,

hh

ii

ss

dd

ee

ff

ee

nn

cc

ee

ww

aa

ss

ss

tt

rr

uu

cc

kk

oo

ff

ff

aa

nn

dd

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

mm

pp

tt

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

ww

ee

rr

ee

ii

nn

ii

tt

ii

aa

tt

ee

dd

.

.

AA

ff

tt

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

oo

ff

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

dd

ee

ss

pp

ii

tt

ee

aa

ll

ll

tt

hh

ee

ss

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

rr

oo

ss

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

mm

oo

ss

tt

ff

oo

rr

dd

ee

tt

ee

rr

mm

ii

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

aa

ss

ww

hh

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

oo

ff

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

tt

CC

oo

nn

nn

ee

cc

tt

ii

cc

uu

tt

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

UU

SS

AA

dd

uu

rr

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

nn

dd

ee

nn

cc

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

gg

ii

vv

ee

nn

ff

aa

cc

tt

ss

aa

nn

dd

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

ww

aa

ss

ee

nn

ff

oo

rr

cc

ee

aa

bb

ll

ee

ii

nn

ll

aa

ww

oo

rr

nn

oo

tt

.

. ((2266))

Page 12: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 12/20

Page 13: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 13/20

ff

ii

rr

ss

tt

ww

ii

ff

ee

//

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

tt

oo

AA

ff

rr

ii

cc

aa

.

.

TT

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

hh

ee

gg

aa

vv

ee

bb

ii

rr

tt

hh

tt

oo

aa

dd

aa

uu

gg

hh

tt

ee

rr

,,

tt

hh

ee

ss

ee

cc

oo

nn

dd

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

.

.AA

ss

dd

ii

ss

pp

uu

tt

ee

ss

aa

rr

oo

ss

ee

bb

ee

tt

ww

ee

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

,,

hh

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

rr

bb

aa

cc

kk

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

pp

rr

oo

mm

ii

ss

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

ss

ee

nn

dd

hh

ee

rr

mm

oo

nn

ee

yy

ff

oo

rr

hh

ee

rr

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

bb

uu

tt

dd

ii

dd

nn

oo

tt

dd

oo

ss

oo

.

.

II

nn

tt

hh

ee

yy

ee

aa

rr

11

99

66

00

,,

hh

ee

cc

aa

mm

ee

bb

aa

cc

kk

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.

WW

hh

ee

nn

hh

ee

ww

aa

ss

aa

dd

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

ll

yy

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

aa

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

44

88

88

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

dd

ee

oo

ff

CC

rr

ii

mm

ii

nn

aa

ll

PP

rr

oo

cc

ee

dd

uu

rr

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

ff

LL

uu

dd

hh

ii

aa

nn

aa

,,

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

ww

hh

oo

ss

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

ww

aa

ss

ss

tt

aa

yy

ii

nn

gg

aa

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

ii

mm

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

aa

ss

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ff

ii

rr

ss

tt

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

oo

nn

bb

ee

hh

aa

ll

ff

oo

ff

hh

ee

rr

ss

ee

ll

ff

aa

nn

dd

aa

ll

ss

oo

aa

ss

ll

aa

ww

ff

uu

ll

gg

uu

aa

rr

dd

ii

aa

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ss

ee

cc

oo

nn

dd

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

,,

ww

hh

oo

ww

aa

ss

aa

mm

ii

nn

oo

rr

,,

cc

ll

aa

ii

mm

ii

nn

gg

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

ff

oo

rr

bb

oo

tt

hh

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

dd

ee

ss

ee

rr

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

nn

dd

dd

ii

dd

nn

oo

tt

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

aa

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

.

.TT

hh

ee

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

ll

ww

aa

ss

ww

hh

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

MM

aa

gg

ii

ss

tt

rr

aa

tt

ee

oo

ff

LL

uu

dd

hh

ii

aa

nn

aa

hh

aa

dd

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

ee

nn

tt

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

44

88

88

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

dd

ee

oo

ff

CC

rr

ii

mm

ii

nn

aa

ll

PP

rr

oo

cc

ee

dd

uu

rr

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

uu

rr

nn

ee

dd

uu

pp

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

pp

rr

ee

tt

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ll

ee

vv

aa

nn

tt

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

oo

ff

SS

.

.

44

88

88

((

88

))

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

,,

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

dd

ee

mm

aa

rr

cc

aa

tt

ee

ss

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ll

ii

mm

ii

tt

ss

oo

ff

aa

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

oo

ee

nn

tt

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

aa

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

ii

dd

ss

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

.

.

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

44

88

88

((

88

))

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

dd

ee

rr

ee

aa

dd

ss

::

““

PP

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ii

ss

ss

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

tt

aa

kk

ee

nn

aa

gg

aa

ii

nn

ss

tt

aa

nn

yy

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

ii

nn

aa

nn

yy

dd

ii

ss

tt

rr

ii

cc

tt

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

oo

rr

ii

ss

,,

oo

rr

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

ee

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ii

ss

ww

ii

ff

ee

,,

oo

rr

,,

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ii

ll

ll

ee

gg

ii

tt

ii

mm

aa

tt

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

.

.

””

.

.TT

hh

ee

cc

rr

uu

cc

ii

aa

ll

ww

oo

rr

dd

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ss

uu

bb

--

ss

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

rr

ee

,,

““

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

””

,,

““

ii

ss

””

aa

nn

dd

““

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

ee

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ii

ss

ww

ii

ff

ee

””

.

.

TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

nn

oo

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

oo

ll

dd

CC

oo

dd

ee

oo

ff

11

88

88

22

oo

nn

ll

yy

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

DD

ii

ss

tt

rr

ii

cc

tt

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

oo

rr

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

,,

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

mm

aa

yy

bb

ee

,,

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

,,

hh

aa

dd

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

.

.

LL

aa

tt

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

aa

ss

dd

ee

ll

ii

bb

ee

rr

aa

tt

ee

ll

yy

mm

aa

dd

ee

ww

ii

dd

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

ii

tt

gg

aa

vv

ee

tt

hh

rr

ee

ee

aa

ll

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

tt

ii

vv

ee

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

ss

,,

oo

bb

vv

ii

oo

uu

ss

ll

yy

tt

oo

ee

nn

aa

bb

ll

ee

aa

dd

ii

ss

cc

aa

rr

dd

ee

dd

ww

ii

ff

ee

oo

rr

aa

hh

ee

ll

pp

ll

ee

ss

ss

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

tt

oo

gg

ee

tt

tt

hh

ee

mm

uu

cc

hh

nn

ee

ee

dd

ee

dd

aa

nn

dd

uu

rr

gg

ee

nn

tt

rr

ee

ll

ii

ee

ff

ii

nn

oo

nn

ee

oo

rr

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

tt

hh

rr

ee

ee

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

ss

cc

oo

nn

vv

ee

nn

ii

ee

nn

tt

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

.

.

AA

ll

ss

oo

kk

ee

ee

pp

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

mm

ii

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

cc

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

ii

ss

ss

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

rr

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

nn

aa

tt

uu

rr

ee

oo

ff

cc

ii

vv

ii

ll

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

;;

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

mm

ee

dd

yy

ii

ss

aa

ss

uu

mm

mm

aa

rr

yy

oo

nn

ee

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

ss

ee

ee

kk

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

aa

tt

rr

ee

mm

ee

dd

yy

ii

ss

oo

rr

dd

ii

nn

aa

rr

ii

ll

yy

aa

hh

ee

ll

pp

ll

ee

ss

ss

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

,,

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ff

ee

ll

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

ss

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

ll

ii

bb

ee

rr

aa

ll

ll

yy

cc

oo

nn

ss

tt

rr

uu

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

oo

uu

tt

dd

oo

ii

nn

gg

aa

nn

yy

vv

ii

oo

ll

ee

nn

cc

ee

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

ll

aa

nn

gg

uu

aa

gg

ee

.

.II

nn

tt

ee

rr

pp

rr

ee

tt

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

tt

hh

rr

ee

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

ss

,,

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

aa

ii

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

xx

tt

aa

pp

oo

ss

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

ss

““

ii

ss

””

aa

nn

dd

““

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

””

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ss

uu

bb

--

ss

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

ss

oo

tt

hh

rr

oo

ww

ss

ll

ii

gg

hh

tt

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

ee

aa

nn

ii

nn

gg

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

””

.

.TT

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

ii

ss

””

cc

oo

nn

ff

ee

rr

ss

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

nn

aa

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

bb

aa

ss

ii

ss

oo

ff

aa

cc

aa

uu

ss

aa

ll

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

ee

xx

pp

rr

ee

ss

ss

ii

oo

nn

““

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

””

ii

nn

dd

ii

cc

aa

tt

ee

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

LL

ee

gg

ii

ss

ll

aa

tt

uu

rr

ee

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

hh

aa

vv

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

dd

ee

dd

tt

oo

uu

ss

ee

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

””

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

tt

ee

cc

hh

nn

ii

cc

aa

ll

ss

ee

nn

ss

ee

oo

ff

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

””

cc

aa

nn

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

gg

ii

vv

ee

nn

aa

mm

ee

aa

nn

ii

nn

gg

dd

ii

ff

ff

ee

rr

ee

nn

tt

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

””

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ee

xx

pp

rr

ee

ss

ss

ii

oo

nn

““

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

””

aa

nn

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

dd

ee

rr

mm

ee

aa

nn

ii

nn

gg

ff

ii

tt

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ss

ee

tt

tt

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

””

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

ss

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

””

ii

mm

pp

ll

ii

ee

dd

ss

oo

mm

ee

tt

hh

ii

nn

gg

mm

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

aa

nn

aa

bb

rr

ii

ee

ff

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

bb

uu

tt

nn

oo

tt

oo

ff

ss

uu

cc

hh

cc

oo

nn

tt

ii

nn

uu

ii

tt

yy

aa

ss

tt

oo

aa

mm

oo

uu

nn

tt

tt

oo

aa

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

tt

hh

oo

uu

gg

hh

ii

tt

ii

mm

pp

ll

ii

ee

dd

ss

oo

mm

ee

tt

hh

ii

nn

gg

mm

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

aa

nn

““

ss

tt

aa

yy

””

aa

nn

dd

ii

mm

pp

ll

ii

ee

dd

ss

oo

mm

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo((2288))

Page 14: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 14/20

rr

ee

mm

aa

ii

nn

aa

tt

aa

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

aa

nn

dd

nn

oo

tt

mm

ee

rr

ee

ll

yy

tt

oo

pp

aa

yy

ii

tt

aa

cc

aa

ss

uu

aa

ll

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ss

oo

ll

ee

tt

ee

ss

tt

,,

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

hh

ee

ll

dd

,,

ww

aa

ss

ww

hh

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

pp

aa

rr

tt

yy

hh

aa

dd

aa

nn

ii

mm

uu

ss

mm

aa

nn

ee

nn

dd

ii

,,

oo

rr

aa

nn

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

ss

tt

aa

yy

ff

oo

rr

aa

nn

ii

nn

dd

ee

ff

ii

nn

ii

tt

ee

pp

ee

rr

ii

oo

dd

,,

aa

tt

oo

nn

ee

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

;;

aa

nn

dd

ii

ff

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

ss

uu

cc

hh

aa

nn

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

tt

ii

oo

nn

,,

tt

hh

ee

nn

aa

ll

oo

nn

ee

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

hh

ee

bb

ee

ss

aa

ii

dd

tt

oo

““

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

””

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

ss

““

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

ee

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ii

ss

ww

ii

ff

ee

””

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

oo

nn

ll

yy

mm

ee

aa

nn

hh

ii

ss

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ii

ss

ww

ii

ff

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

tt

ee

rr

rr

ii

tt

oo

rr

ii

ee

ss

oo

ff

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.

II

tt

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

oo

bb

vv

ii

oo

uu

ss

ll

yy

mm

ee

aa

nn

hh

ii

ss

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ii

nn

gg

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

,,

ff

oo

rr

aa

nn

AA

cc

tt

cc

aa

nn

nn

oo

tt

cc

oo

nn

ff

ee

rr

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

nn

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.II

tt

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

bb

ee

aa

ll

ee

gg

ii

tt

ii

mm

aa

tt

ee

cc

oo

nn

ss

tt

rr

uu

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

ii

dd

ee

xx

pp

rr

ee

ss

ss

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

hh

oo

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

ss

tt

rr

ii

cc

tt

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

ee

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ii

ss

ww

ii

ff

ee

mm

uu

ss

tt

bb

ee

aa

dd

ii

ss

tt

rr

ii

cc

tt

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.

TT

hh

ee

mm

oo

ss

tt

uu

ss

ee

ff

uu

ll

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

pp

rr

ee

tt

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

aa

ss

mm

aa

dd

ee

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

ii

ss

””

.

.

TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

aa

ii

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

ii

ss

””

cc

oo

nn

nn

oo

tt

ee

ss

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

xx

tt

,,

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

nn

cc

ee

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

ee

xx

ii

ss

tt

ee

nn

cc

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

ss

tt

rr

ii

cc

tt

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

aa

rr

ee

tt

aa

kk

ee

nn

.

.

II

tt

ii

ss

mm

uu

cc

hh

ww

ii

dd

ee

rr

tt

hh

aa

nn

tt

hh

ee

ww

oo

rr

dd

““

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ss

””

::

ii

tt

ii

ss

nn

oo

tt

ll

ii

mm

ii

tt

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

aa

nn

ii

mm

uu

ss

mm

aa

nn

ee

nn

dd

ii

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

dd

uu

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

nn

aa

tt

uu

rr

ee

oo

ff

hh

ii

ss

ss

tt

aa

yy

.

.

WW

hh

aa

tt

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

ss

ii

ss

hh

ii

ss

pp

hh

yy

ss

ii

cc

aa

ll

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

nn

cc

ee

aa

tt

aa

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

cc

uu

ll

aa

rr

pp

oo

ii

nn

tt

oo

ff

tt

ii

mm

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ii

ss

mm

ee

aa

nn

ii

nn

gg

aa

cc

cc

oo

rr

dd

ss

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

oo

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

aa

pp

tt

ee

rr

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

nn

cc

ee

rr

nn

ee

dd

ss

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

ss

.

.

II

tt

ii

ss

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

dd

ee

dd

tt

oo

rr

ee

aa

cc

hh

aa

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

,,

ww

hh

oo

dd

ee

ss

ee

rr

tt

ss

aa

ww

ii

ff

ee

oo

rr

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

ll

ee

aa

vv

ii

nn

gg

hh

ee

rr

oo

rr

ii

tt

oo

rr

bb

oo

tt

hh

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

hh

ee

ll

pp

ll

ee

ss

ss

ii

nn

aa

nn

yy

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

cc

uu

ll

aa

rr

dd

ii

ss

tt

rr

ii

cc

tt

aa

nn

dd

gg

oo

ee

ss

tt

oo

aa

dd

ii

ss

tt

aa

nn

tt

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

oo

rr

ee

vv

ee

nn

tt

oo

aa

ff

oo

rr

ee

ii

gg

nn

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

,,

bb

uu

tt

rr

ee

tt

uu

rr

nn

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

aa

tt

dd

ii

ss

tt

rr

ii

cc

tt

oo

rr

aa

nn

ee

ii

gg

hh

bb

oo

uu

rr

ii

nn

gg

oo

nn

ee

oo

nn

aa

cc

aa

ss

uu

aa

ll

oo

rr

aa

ff

ll

yy

ii

nn

gg

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

cc

aa

nn

tt

aa

kk

ee

aa

dd

vv

aa

nn

tt

aa

gg

ee

oo

ff

hh

ii

ss

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

aa

nn

dd

ff

ii

ll

ee

aa

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

ss

tt

rr

ii

cc

tt

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

ee

ii

ss

,,

dd

uu

rr

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

ss

ss

tt

aa

yy

.

.

II

nn

ff

aa

cc

tt

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

ee

nn

tt

ee

vv

ee

nn

ff

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

ss

aa

ii

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

,,

ii

ff

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ww

hh

oo

dd

ee

ss

ee

rr

tt

ss

hh

ii

ss

ww

ii

ff

ee

,,

hh

aa

ss

nn

oo

pp

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

ee

nn

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

,,

bb

uu

tt

ii

ss

aa

ll

ww

aa

yy

ss

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

vv

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

cc

aa

nn

ee

vv

ee

nn

cc

aa

tt

cc

hh

hh

ii

mm

aa

tt

aa

cc

oo

nn

vv

ee

nn

ii

ee

nn

tt

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

aa

nn

dd

ff

ii

ll

ee

aa

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

44

88

88

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

dd

ee

oo

rr

ss

hh

ee

mm

aa

yy

aa

cc

cc

ii

dd

ee

nn

tt

aa

ll

ll

yy

mm

ee

ee

tt

hh

ii

mm

ii

nn

aa

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

ee

hh

aa

pp

pp

ee

nn

ss

tt

oo

cc

oo

mm

ee

bb

yy

cc

oo

ii

nn

cc

ii

dd

ee

nn

cc

ee

aa

nn

dd

tt

aa

kk

ee

aa

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

gg

aa

ii

nn

ss

tt

hh

ii

mm

bb

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

hh

ee

ll

ee

aa

vv

ee

ss

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

ii

dd

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

.

.II

nn

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

cc

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ii

nn

aa

nn

yy

cc

aa

ss

ee

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

hh

aa

dd

““

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

””

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ww

hh

ee

nn

hh

ee

cc

aa

mm

ee

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

nn

dd

ll

ii

vv

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ii

ss

ww

ii

ff

ee

ii

nn

hh

ii

ss

hh

oo

uu

ss

ee

ii

nn

vv

ii

ll

ll

aa

gg

ee

ii

nn

LL

uu

dd

hh

ii

aa

nn

aa

,,

aa

ss

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

aa

cc

ll

ee

aa

rr

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

tt

ee

mm

pp

oo

rr

aa

rr

ii

ll

yy

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ii

ss

ww

ii

ff

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

.

.

HH

ee

dd

ii

dd

nn

oo

tt

gg

oo

tt

oo

tt

hh

aa

tt

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

aa

ss

aa

cc

aa

ss

uu

aa

ll

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

oo

rr

bb

uu

tt

ww

ee

nn

tt

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

ff

ii

nn

ii

tt

ee

pp

uu

rr

pp

oo

ss

ee

oo

ff

ll

ii

vv

ii

nn

gg

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ii

mm

ww

ii

ff

ee

ii

nn

hh

ii

ss

nn

aa

tt

ii

vv

ee

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

aa

nn

dd

hh

ee

ll

ii

vv

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

aa

bb

oo

uu

tt

66

mm

oo

nn

tt

hh

ss

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ee

rr

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ss

ee

cc

oo

nn

dd

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

rr

ee

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

oo

nn

ll

yy

aa

ff

ll

yy

ii

nn

gg

vv

ii

ss

ii

tt

tt

oo

tt

aa

kk

ee

hh

ee

rr

tt

oo

AA

ff

rr

ii

cc

aa

.

.

II

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

ll

aa

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

ww

ii

tt

hh

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

aa

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

LL

uu

dd

hh

ii

aa

nn

aa

.

.TT

hh

aa

tt

aa

pp

aa

rr

tt

,,

ss

ii

nn

cc

ee

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

aa

dd

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

ww

aa

ss

ii

nn

aa

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

ii

dd

MM

aa

gg

ii

ss

tt

rr

aa

tt

ee

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

dd

aa

tt

ee

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

hh

ee

rr

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

oo

rr

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

aa

gg

aa

ii

nn

ss

tt

hh

ii

mm

,,

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

aa

nn

yy

cc

aa

ss

ee

hh

aa

dd

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

ee

nn

tt

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

,,

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd((2299))

betakenagainstanypersoninanydistrictwhereheisThecourtsjurisdictionwasthereforeupheldThthijdtjiditidlidbthKlHihCiMPlilDChkPlil(AIR1970K1)

Page 15: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 15/20

bb

ee

tt

aa

kk

ee

nn

aa

gg

aa

ii

nn

ss

tt

aa

nn

yy

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

ii

nn

aa

nn

yy

dd

ii

ss

tt

rr

ii

cc

tt

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

ee “

ii

ss

”

.

.

TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

’

ss

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

uu

pp

hh

ee

ll

dd

.

.TT

hh

ee

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

vv

ee

rr

yy

pp

rr

oo

gg

rr

ee

ss

ss

ii

vv

ee

j j

uu

dd

gg

mm

ee

nn

tt

oo

nn

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

aa

ss

dd

ee

ll

ii

vv

ee

rr

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

KK

ee

rr

aa

ll

aa

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

MM

aa

rr

gg

gg

aa

rr

aa

tt

ee

PP

uu

ll

pp

aa

rr

aa

mm

pp

ii

ll

vv

DD

rr

.

.

CC

hh

aa

cc

kk

oo

PP

uu

ll

pp

aa

rr

aa

mm

pp

ii

ll

((

AA

II

RR

11

99

77

00

KK

ee

rr

11

))

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

bb

aa

ss

ii

ss

oo

ff

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

oo

ff

““

rr

ee

aa

ll

aa

nn

dd

ss

uu

bb

ss

tt

aa

nn

tt

ii

aa

ll

cc

oo

nn

nn

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

””

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

rr

oo

aa

cc

hh

ee

ss

aa

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

,,

oo

vv

ee

rr

rr

uu

ll

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

aa

tt

oo

ff

ww

ii

ff

ee

aa

nn

dd

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ff

oo

ll

ll

oo

ww

ii

nn

gg

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

//

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

’’

ss

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

.

.II

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

,,

tt

hh

ee

11

ss

tt

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

,,

aa

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

NN

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

,,

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

ee

dd

aa

ss

pp

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

ee

cc

cc

ll

ee

ss

ii

aa

ss

tt

ii

cc

aa

ll

rr

ii

tt

ee

ss

,,

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

ww

ii

ff

ee

,,

aa

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

,,

ww

hh

oo

hh

ee

hh

aa

dd

mm

ee

tt

ww

hh

ee

nn

hh

ee

ww

ee

nn

tt

tt

oo

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

yy

tt

oo

ss

tt

uu

dd

yy

mm

ee

dd

ii

cc

ii

nn

ee

.

.

TT

ww

oo

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ww

ee

rr

ee

bb

oo

rr

nn

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

bb

uu

tt

tt

hh

ee

nn

dd

ii

ff

ff

ee

rr

ee

nn

cc

ee

ss

aa

rr

oo

ss

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

rr

oo

aa

cc

hh

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

ss

ee

ee

mm

ss

tt

oo

hh

aa

vv

ee

bb

ee

ee

nn

aa

ll

mm

oo

ss

tt

ss

ii

mm

uu

ll

tt

aa

nn

ee

oo

uu

ss

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

hh

ee

rr

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

.

.

TT

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

ss

kk

ee

dd

ff

oo

rr

aa

cc

cc

ee

ss

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

,,

ww

hh

oo

ww

ee

rr

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

,,

ss

hh

oo

rr

tt

ll

yy

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

ss

ee

pp

aa

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ss

uu

ee

dd

ff

oo

rr

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

.

.

SS

oo

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ff

oo

rr

hh

ii

ss

aa

cc

cc

ee

ss

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

.

.

TT

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

aa

gg

rr

ee

ee

dd

oo

nn

nn

ee

ww

tt

ee

rr

mm

ss

rr

ee

gg

aa

rr

dd

ii

nn

gg

aa

cc

cc

ee

ss

ss

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ww

ee

rr

ee

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.II

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

ee

aa

nn

tt

ii

mm

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

’’

ss

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

aa

ss

dd

ii

ss

mm

ii

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

.

.

TT

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

rr

ww

ii

ff

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

ll

ee

dd

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

aa

tt

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

ww

hh

ii

ll

ee

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

ll

ww

aa

ss

pp

ee

nn

dd

ii

nn

gg

,,

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

,,

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ww

aa

ss

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

oo

pp

aa

yy

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

.

.

SS

oo

oo

nn

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

,,

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

tt

oo

oo

kk

oo

uu

tt

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

oo

nn

ee

dd

aa

yy

bb

uu

tt

ii

nn

ss

tt

ee

aa

dd

oo

ff

rr

ee

tt

uu

rr

nn

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

mm

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ee

vv

ee

nn

ii

nn

gg

,,

dd

rr

oo

vv

ee

tt

hh

ee

mm

ii

nn

aa

tt

aa

xx

ii

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

AA

ii

rr

pp

oo

rr

tt

aa

nn

dd

tt

oo

oo

kk

aa

pp

ll

aa

nn

ee

ff

oo

rr

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

.

.

TT

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ww

ee

rr

ee

tt

ww

oo

aa

nn

dd

hh

aa

ll

ff

yy

ee

aa

rr

ss

aa

nn

dd

11

00

mm

oo

nn

tt

hh

ss

aa

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

ii

mm

ee

.

.TT

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

dd

ii

dd

nn

oo

tt

ii

nn

ff

oo

rr

mm

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ii

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

bb

oo

uu

tt

hh

ii

ss

dd

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

uu

rr

ee

nn

oo

rr

dd

ii

dd

hh

ee

cc

aa

bb

ll

ee

hh

ee

rr

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

rr

ee

aa

cc

hh

ii

nn

gg

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.AA

ff

tt

ee

rr

mm

aa

kk

ii

nn

gg

ff

rr

aa

nn

tt

ii

cc

ee

nn

qq

uu

ii

rr

ii

ee

ss

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

mm

oo

vv

ee

dd

aa

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

nn

ee

xx

tt

dd

aa

yy

bb

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

tt

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

yy

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

ww

aa

ss

pp

ee

nn

dd

ii

nn

gg

aa

nn

dd

oo

bb

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

aa

nn

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

bb

yy

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

hh

aa

nn

dd

oo

vv

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

.

.

NN

oo

tt

hh

ii

nn

gg

hh

aa

pp

pp

ee

nn

ee

dd

pp

uu

rr

ss

uu

aa

nn

tt

tt

oo

tt

hh

ii

ss

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

cc

oo

nn

tt

ii

nn

uu

ee

dd

tt

oo

mm

aa

kk

ee

ee

nn

qq

uu

ii

rr

ii

ee

ss

aa

bb

oo

uu

tt

tt

hh

ee

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

aa

bb

oo

uu

tt

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

.

.

SS

oo

mm

ee

tt

ii

mm

ee

ll

aa

tt

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

ll

tt

aa

kk

ee

nn

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ii

nn

gg

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ww

aa

ss

dd

ii

ss

mm

ii

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

aa

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ss

aa

ll

ss

oo

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

’’

ss

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

ll

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

ww

aa

ss

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

ww

aa

ss

dd

ii

ss

ss

oo

ll

vv

ee

dd

ii

nn

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

yy

.

.

OO

nn

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

mm

ee

dd

aa

yy

aa

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

ww

aa

ss

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

aa

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

dd

ii

rr

ee

cc

tt

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

bb

ee

gg

ii

vv

ee

nn

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

.

.

WW

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

cc

aa

mm

ee

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

nn

dd

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

aa

hh

aa

bb

ee

aa

ss

cc

oo

rr

pp

uu

ss

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

uu

rr

nn

oo

ff

hh

ee

rr((3300))

Page 16: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 16/20

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

,,

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

aa

ss

cc

oo

nn

vv

ii

nn

cc

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

oo

ff

oo

rr

ii

gg

ii

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

ww

aa

ss

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

.

.

EE

vv

ee

nn

tt

hh

oo

uu

gg

hh

aa

cc

cc

oo

rr

dd

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

nn

oo

nn

ss

oo

ff

PP

rr

ii

vv

aa

tt

ee

II

nn

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

LL

aa

ww

,,

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

hh

aa

vv

ee

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

’’

ss

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

,,

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

tt

hh

ee

rr

,,

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

,,

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ww

ee

rr

ee

oo

ff

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

aa

nn

dd

aa

ss

pp

ee

rr

tt

hh

aa

tt

rr

uu

ll

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

hh

aa

vv

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

,,

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

cc

oo

mm

pp

ee

tt

ee

nn

tt

GG

ee

rr

mm

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

ii

ll

ll

hh

aa

vv

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

pp

aa

ss

ss

aa

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

ff

oo

rr

dd

ii

vv

oo

rr

cc

ee

oo

rr

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

gg

ww

ii

ff

ee

hh

aa

dd

aa

““

rr

ee

aa

ll

aa

nn

dd

ss

uu

bb

ss

tt

aa

nn

tt

ii

aa

ll

cc

oo

nn

nn

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

””

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

oo

ff

tt

hh

aa

tt

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

nn

dd

aa

ll

ss

oo

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

ww

ee

rr

ee

oo

rr

dd

ii

nn

aa

rr

ii

ll

yy

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

nn

tt

ii

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

.

.II

nn

aa

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

cc

aa

ss

ee

tt

hh

ee

SS

uu

pp

rr

ee

mm

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

SS

uu

rr

ii

nn

dd

ee

rr

KK

aa

uu

rr

SS

aa

nn

dd

hh

uu

vv

.

.HH

aa

rr

bb

aa

xx

SS

ii

nn

gg

hh

SS

aa

nn

dd

hh

uu

,,

AA

II

RR

11

99

88

44

SS

CC

11

22

22

44

,,

oo

bb

ss

ee

rr

vv

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

,,

““

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

dd

ee

rr

nn

tt

hh

ee

oo

rr

yy

oo

ff

CC

oo

nn

ff

ll

ii

cc

tt

oo

ff

LL

aa

ww

ss

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

ss

aa

nn

dd

,,

ii

nn

aa

nn

yy

ee

vv

ee

nn

tt

,,

pp

rr

ee

ff

ee

rr

ss

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

SS

tt

aa

tt

ee

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

hh

aa

ss

ii

nn

tt

ii

mm

aa

tt

ee

cc

oo

nn

tt

aa

cc

tt

ww

ii

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

ii

ss

ss

uu

ee

ss

aa

rr

ii

ss

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

.

.

JJ

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

ss

nn

oo

tt

aa

tt

tt

rr

aa

cc

tt

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

oo

pp

ee

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

rr

cc

rr

ee

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

ff

oo

rr

tt

uu

ii

tt

oo

uu

ss

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

ss

uu

cc

hh

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

aa

ss

tt

oo

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

,,

ww

hh

oo

ss

ee

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

ii

ss

ii

nn

ii

ss

ss

uu

ee

,,

ii

ss

bb

rr

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

oo

rr

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

tt

ii

mm

ee

bb

ee

ii

nn

gg

ll

oo

dd

gg

ee

dd

.

.

TT

oo

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ss

tt

hh

ee

aa

ss

ss

uu

mm

pp

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

bb

yy

aa

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

SS

tt

aa

tt

ee

ii

nn

ss

uu

cc

hh

cc

ii

rr

cc

uu

mm

ss

tt

aa

nn

cc

ee

ss

ww

ii

ll

ll

oo

nn

ll

yy

rr

ee

ss

uu

ll

tt

ii

nn

ee

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

aa

gg

ii

nn

gg

ff

oo

rr

uu

mm

--

ss

hh

oo

pp

pp

ii

nn

gg

.

.

””

II

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

aa

ss

ee

ww

hh

ii

ll

ee

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

hh

oo

ww

aa

ss

ss

tt

ii

ll

ll

ii

nn

EE

nn

gg

ll

aa

nn

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

hh

aa

dd

cc

ll

aa

nn

dd

ee

ss

tt

ii

nn

ee

ll

yy

tt

aa

kk

ee

nn

aa

ww

aa

yy

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

tt

oo

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

tt

oo

hh

ii

ss

pp

aa

rr

ee

nn

tt

ss

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

aa

nn

dd

ww

aa

ss

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

EE

nn

gg

ll

ii

ss

hh

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

’’

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

’’

ss

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

dd

ii

dd

nn

oo

tt

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

hh

ii

mm

tt

oo

dd

oo

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

EE

nn

gg

ll

ii

ss

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

aa

ll

rr

ee

aa

dd

yy

pp

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

aa

nn

oo

rr

dd

ee

rr

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

’’

ss

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

ii

nn

EE

nn

gg

ll

aa

nn

dd

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

aa

nn

dd

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

’’

ss

hh

oo

mm

ee

ww

aa

ss

ll

oo

cc

aa

tt

ee

dd

.

.II

nn

DD

ii

pp

aa

kk

BB

aa

nn

nn

ee

rr

j j

ee

ee

vv

SS

uu

dd

ii

pp

tt

aa

BB

aa

nn

nn

ee

rr

j j

ee

ee

((

AA

II

RR

11

99

88

77

CC

aa

ll

44

99

11

))

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

dd

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

oo

ee

nn

tt

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

aa

nn

dd

tt

rr

yy

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

ii

nn

ii

tt

ii

aa

tt

ee

dd

bb

yy

ww

ii

ff

ee

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

22

55

ff

oo

rr

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

,,

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

nn

dd

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

aa

tt

nn

oo

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

hh

aa

dd

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

ss

ee

nn

ss

ee

tt

oo

tt

rr

yy

ss

uu

cc

hh

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

aa

ss

hh

ee

cc

ll

aa

ii

mm

ee

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

cc

ii

tt

ii

zz

ee

nn

oo

ff

UU

nn

ii

tt

ee

dd

SS

tt

aa

tt

ee

ss

oo

ff

AA

mm

ee

rr

ii

cc

aa

aa

nn

dd

hh

ii

ss

ww

ii

ff

ee

’’

ss

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

aa

ll

ss

oo

ff

oo

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

hh

ii

ss

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ii

ss

cc

oo

nn

ff

ll

ii

cc

tt

oo

ff

ll

aa

ww

ss

ee

vv

ee

rr

yy

cc

aa

ss

ee

mm

uu

ss

tt

bb

ee

dd

ee

cc

ii

dd

ee

dd

ii

nn

aa

cc

cc

oo

rr

dd

aa

nn

cc

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

LL

aa

ww

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

uu

ll

ee

ss

oo

ff

pp

rr

ii

vv

aa

tt

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

aa

ww

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

ee

dd

ii

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

ii

ee

ss

mm

aa

yy

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

aa

dd

oo

pp

tt

ee

dd

mm

ee

cc

hh

aa

nn

ii

cc

aa

ll

ll

yy

bb

yy

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

.

.

TT

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ff

ee

ll

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

kk

ee

ee

pp

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

vv

ii

ee

ww

tt

hh

ee

oo

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

aa

nn

dd

ss

oo

cc

ii

aa

ll

pp

uu

rr

pp

oo

ss

ee

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

11

22

55

aa

nn

dd

11

22

66

,,

tt

hh

ee

oo

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

rr

aa

ii

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ww

aa

ss

nn

oo

tt

tt

ee

nn

aa

bb

ll

ee

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

aa

ss

uu

pp

hh

ee

ll

dd

aa

ss

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

ii

tt

hh

ii

nn

ww

hh

oo

ss

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

hh

ee

oo

rr

dd

ii

nn

aa

rr

ii

ll

yy

rr

ee

ss

ii

dd

ee

dd

.

.II

nn

MM

rr

ss

.

.

MM

vv

MM

rr

.

.

AA

II

((

11

99

99

33

))

DD

MM

CC

33

88

44

))

ii

nn

aa

nn

aa

pp

pp

ee

aa

ll

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

BB

oo

mm

bb

aa

yy

,,

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

gg

hh

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

ww

ii

ff

ee

hh

aa

dd

pp

rr

aa

yy

ee

dd

ff

oo

rr

aa

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

oo

ff

nn

uu

ll

ll

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

hh

ee

rr

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

ss

oo

ll

ee

mm

nn

ii

ss

ee

dd

aa

tt

HH

uu

ss

tt

oo

nn

,,((3311))

Page 17: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 17/20

Page 18: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 18/20

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

AA

dd

oo

pp

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

aa

nn

dd

MM

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

AA

cc

tt

,,

ww

hh

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

ss

cc

oo

nn

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

ii

nn

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

22

00

oo

ff

CC

PP

CC

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ii

nn

cc

ii

pp

ll

ee

ss

cc

oo

nn

tt

aa

ii

nn

ee

dd

ii

nn

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

22

66

oo

ff

CC

rr

.

.

PP

.

.

CC

.

.

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

gg

oo

vv

ee

rr

nn

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

mm

oo

oo

tt

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

tt

oo

aa

dd

dd

rr

ee

ss

ss

ii

tt

ss

ee

ll

ff

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

rr

oo

pp

rr

ii

aa

tt

ee

ss

tt

aa

gg

ee

bb

uu

tt

oo

nn

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

aa

dd

oo

pp

tt

aa

pp

uu

rr

pp

oo

ss

ii

vv

ee

aa

pp

pp

rr

oo

aa

cc

hh

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

aa

dd

vv

aa

nn

cc

ee

dd

j j

uu

ss

tt

ii

cc

ee

.

.

WW

hh

ii

ll

ee

ll

ee

aa

vv

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ii

ss

ii

mm

pp

oo

rr

tt

aa

nn

tt

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

ll

aa

ww

tt

oo

bb

ee

dd

ee

aa

ll

tt

ww

ii

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

nn

aa

pp

pp

rr

oo

pp

rr

ii

aa

tt

ee

ss

tt

aa

gg

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

cc

uu

ll

aa

rr

cc

aa

ss

ee

ee

vv

ee

nn

ii

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

22

00

oo

ff

CC

PP

CC

ww

ee

rr

ee

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

ee

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

ll

aa

ii

nn

tt

ii

ff

ff

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

pp

aa

rr

tt

oo

ff

aa

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

rr

oo

ss

ee

ii

nn

DD

ee

ll

hh

ii

aa

nn

dd

ss

oo

tt

hh

ee

DD

ee

ll

hh

ii

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

hh

aa

dd

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

tt

ee

rr

.

.II

nn

SS

oo

nn

dd

uu

rr

RR

aa

j j

ii

nn

ii

vv

SS

oo

nn

dd

uu

rr

GG

oo

pp

aa

ll

((

22

00

00

55

((

44

))

MM

hh

LL

j j

66

88

88

))

,,

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

cc

tt

ss

ww

ee

rr

ee

aa

ss

ff

oo

ll

ll

oo

ww

ss

::

TT

hh

ee

aa

pp

pp

ee

ll

ll

aa

nn

tt

ww

ii

ff

ee

’’

ss

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

aa

ss

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

--

aa

ll

ii

aa

ss

ee

ee

kk

ii

nn

gg

j j

uu

dd

ii

cc

ii

aa

ll

ss

ee

pp

aa

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

00

oo

ff

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

MM

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

AA

cc

tt

,,

cc

uu

ss

tt

oo

dd

yy

oo

ff

mm

ii

nn

oo

rr

cc

hh

ii

ll

dd

rr

ee

nn

aa

nn

dd

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

ee

nn

aa

nn

cc

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

NN

RR

II

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

tt

oo

oo

kk

tt

hh

ee

oo

bb

j j

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

aa

ss

nn

oo

tt

mm

aa

ii

nn

tt

aa

ii

nn

aa

bb

ll

ee

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

ww

ee

rr

ee

cc

ii

tt

ii

zz

ee

nn

ss

oo

ff

SS

ww

ee

dd

ee

nn

aa

nn

dd

nn

oo

tt

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

nn

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

FF

aa

mm

ii

ll

yy

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

aa

ss

bb

aa

rr

rr

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

((

22

))

oo

ff

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

MM

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

AA

cc

tt

.

.

AA

ss

aa

gg

aa

ii

nn

ss

tt

tt

hh

ii

ss

,,

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

ss

ee

tt

uu

pp

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

oo

ff

oo

rr

ii

gg

ii

nn

ww

aa

ss

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ww

aa

ss

nn

ee

vv

ee

rr

gg

ii

vv

ee

nn

uu

pp

oo

rr

aa

bb

aa

nn

dd

oo

nn

ee

dd

tt

hh

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

hh

ee

yy

hh

aa

dd

aa

cc

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

dd

cc

ii

tt

ii

zz

ee

nn

ss

hh

ii

pp

oo

ff

SS

ww

ee

dd

ee

nn

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

nn

mm

oo

vv

ee

dd

tt

oo

AA

uu

ss

tt

rr

aa

ll

ii

aa

.

.

TT

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

’’

ss

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

ww

aa

ss

aa

ll

ss

oo

cc

hh

aa

ll

ll

ee

nn

gg

ee

dd

bb

yy

hh

ee

rr

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

gg

rr

oo

uu

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ee

vv

ee

nn

ii

ff

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

aa

ss

ss

uu

mm

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

hh

ee

aa

cc

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

dd

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

ii

nn

SS

ww

ee

dd

ee

nn

,,

ss

hh

ee

nn

ee

vv

ee

rr

cc

hh

aa

nn

gg

ee

dd

hh

ee

rr

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

aa

nn

dd

cc

oo

nn

tt

ii

nn

uu

ee

dd

hh

ee

rr

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.

II

nn

tt

hh

ee

aa

ll

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

tt

ii

vv

ee

,,

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

cc

oo

nn

tt

ee

nn

dd

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ee

vv

ee

nn

ii

ff

ii

tt

ww

aa

ss

aa

ss

ss

uu

mm

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ss

hh

ee

aa

ll

ss

oo

hh

aa

dd

aa

cc

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

dd

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

oo

ff

SS

ww

ee

dd

ee

nn

,,

tt

hh

aa

tt

ww

aa

ss

aa

bb

aa

nn

dd

oo

nn

ee

dd

bb

yy

bb

oo

tt

hh

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

ss

hh

ii

ff

tt

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

AA

uu

ss

tt

rr

aa

ll

ii

aa

aa

nn

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

oo

ff

oo

rr

ii

gg

ii

nn

ii

.

.

ee

.

.

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

,,

gg

oo

tt

rr

ee

vv

ii

vv

ee

dd

.

.

II

nn

ss

hh

oo

rr

tt

,,

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

ss

hh

ee

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ss

pp

oo

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

bb

oo

tt

hh

ww

ee

rr

ee

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

nn

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

tt

hh

ee

FF

aa

mm

ii

ll

yy

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

MM

uu

mm

bb

aa

ii

hh

aa

dd

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

tt

oo

ee

nn

tt

ee

rr

tt

aa

ii

nn

hh

ee

rr

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

ee

ee

kk

ii

nn

gg

aa

dd

ee

cc

rr

ee

ee

oo

ff

j j

uu

dd

ii

cc

ii

aa

ll

ss

ee

pp

aa

rr

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

.

.

SS

hh

ee

aa

ll

ss

oo

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

oo

nn

cc

ee

tt

hh

ee

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

MM

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

AA

cc

tt

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

ee

ss

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ii

ss

nn

oo

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

ii

dd

AA

cc

tt

ss

tt

aa

tt

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

aa

tt

ii

tt

cc

ee

aa

ss

ee

ss

tt

oo

aa

pp

pp

ll

yy

aa

tt

aa

nn

yy

ss

uu

bb

ss

ee

qq

uu

ee

nn

tt

ss

tt

aa

gg

ee

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

ii

ss

ss

uu

ee

oo

ff

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

rr

aa

ii

ss

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

ww

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

tt

oo

tt

aa

ll

ll

yy

ii

rr

rr

ee

ll

ee

vv

aa

nn

tt

kk

ee

ee

pp

ii

nn

gg

ii

nn

vv

ii

ee

ww

tt

hh

ee

ss

cc

hh

ee

mm

ee

oo

ff

AA

cc

tt

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

,,

aa

cc

qq

uu

ii

ss

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

cc

ii

tt

ii

zz

ee

nn

ss

hh

ii

pp

aa

nn

dd

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

aa

rr

ee

ii

nn

dd

ee

pp

ee

nn

dd

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

ee

aa

cc

hh

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

aa

nn

dd

ii

nn

aa

nn

yy

cc

aa

ss

ee

ii

tt

cc

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

ss

aa

ii

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

bb

yy

aa

cc

qq

uu

ii

rr

ii

nn

gg

cc

ii

tt

ii

zz

ee

nn

ss

hh

ii

pp

oo

ff

SS

ww

ee

dd

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

yy

aa

ll

ss

oo

aa

cc

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

dd

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

ii

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

.

.

BB

yy

mm

aa

kk

ii

nn

gg

rr

ee

ff

ee

rr

ee

nn

cc

ee

tt

oo

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

99

oo

ff

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

MM

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

AA

cc

tt

ss

hh

ee

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

mm

uu

ss

tt

ss

aa

tt

ii

ss

ff

yy

aa

nn

yy

oo

nn

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

ss

oo

ff

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

99

tt

oo

ii

nn

vv

ee

ss

tt

aa

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

ii

tt

hh

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

nn

aa

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

nn

dd

SS

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

11

99

dd

oo

ee

ss

nn

oo

tt

ss

pp

ee

aa

kk

oo

ff

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

aa

tt

aa

ll

ll

.

.

SS

hh

ee

ff

uu

rr

tt

hh

ee

rr

ss

uu

bb

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

ii

ff

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

mm

ee

nn

tt

oo

ff

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

ii

ss

hh

ee

ll

dd

tt

oo

bb

ee

nn

ee

cc

ee

ss

ss

aa

rr

yy

ff

oo

rr

aa

pp

pp

ll

ii

cc

aa

bb

ii

ll

ii

tt

yy

oo

ff

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

MM

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

,,

ii

tt

ww

ii

ll

ll

ll

ee

aa

dd

tt

oo

gg

rr

ee

aa

tt

hh

aa

rr

dd

ss

hh

ii

pp

tt

oo

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

hh

oo

’’

ss

rr

ee

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

dd

tt

oo

gg

oo

ff

rr

oo

mm

pp

ll

aa

cc

ee

tt

oo((3333))

Page 19: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 19/20constantandcannotchangewithvagariesorthewhimsofthepartiestothemarriageIthasalsobeenuniversallyrecognisedthatquestionsaffectingthepersonalstatusofahumanbighldbgdttlbdthlitifhhhbfhhfiiihihdIfh

Page 20: NRI Imp CaseLaws

8/8/2019 NRI Imp CaseLaws

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nri-imp-caselaws 20/20

cc

oo

nn

ss

tt

aa

nn

tt

aa

nn

dd

cc

aa

nn

nn

oo

tt

cc

hh

aa

nn

gg

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

vv

aa

gg

aa

rr

ii

ee

ss

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

ww

hh

ii

mm

ss

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

.

.

II

tt

hh

aa

ss

aa

ll

ss

oo

bb

ee

ee

nn

uu

nn

ii

vv

ee

rr

ss

aa

ll

ll

yy

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

ss

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

ss

aa

ff

ff

ee

cc

tt

ii

nn

gg

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

aa

ll

ss

tt

aa

tt

uu

ss

oo

ff

aa

hh

uu

mm

aa

nn

bb

ee

ii

nn

gg

ss

hh

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

gg

oo

vv

ee

rr

nn

ee

dd

cc

oo

nn

ss

tt

aa

nn

tt

ll

yy

bb

yy

oo

nn

ee

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

mm

ee

ll

aa

ww

,,

ii

rr

rr

ee

ss

pp

ee

cc

tt

ii

vv

ee

oo

ff

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

hh

ee

mm

aa

yy

hh

aa

pp

pp

ee

nn

tt

oo

bb

ee

oo

rr

oo

ff

ww

hh

ee

rr

ee

tt

hh

ee

ff

aa

cc

tt

ss

gg

ii

vv

ii

nn

gg

rr

ii

ss

ee

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

qq

uu

ee

ss

tt

ii

oo

nn

mm

aa

yy

hh

aa

vv

ee

oo

cc

cc

uu

rr

rr

ee

dd

.

.

II

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

oo

ss

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

ss

tt

aa

kk

ee

nn

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

tt

ii

mm

ee

aa

tt

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

ii

ss

tt

oo

bb

ee

dd

ee

tt

ee

rr

mm

ii

nn

ee

dd

ii

ss

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

MM

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

AA

cc

tt

aa

rr

ee

cc

oo

mm

mm

ee

nn

cc

ee

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

nn

ee

vv

ee

rr

yy

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ff

ii

ll

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

ww

hh

oo

ss

ee

hh

uu

ss

bb

aa

nn

dd

mm

oo

vv

ee

ss

ff

rr

oo

mm

oo

nn

ee

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

tt

oo

aa

nn

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

ff

oo

rr

tt

hh

ee

pp

uu

rr

pp

oo

ss

ee

ss

oo

ff

j j

oo

bb

oo

rr

ff

oo

rr

aa

nn

yy

pp

uu

rr

pp

oo

ss

ee

ww

hh

aa

tt

ss

oo

ee

vv

ee

rr

,,

hh

ee

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

bb

ee

aa

bb

ll

ee

tt

oo

ff

rr

uu

ss

tt

rr

aa

tt

ee

aa

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

bb

rr

oo

uu

gg

hh

tt

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

ww

ii

ff

ee

bb

yy

cc

hh

aa

nn

gg

ii

nn

gg

hh

ii

ss

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

ee

vv

ee

nn

bb

ee

tt

ww

ee

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ee

ss

ee

nn

tt

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

hh

ee

aa

rr

ii

nn

gg

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

cc

aa

ss

ee

.

.

TT

hh

ee

rr

uu

ll

ee

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

rr

ee

cc

oo

gg

nn

ii

zz

ee

dd

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ww

aa

ss

““

oo

nn

cc

ee

cc

oo

mm

pp

ee

tt

ee

nn

tt

,,

aa

ll

ww

aa

yy

ss

cc

oo

mm

pp

ee

tt

ee

nn

tt

””e

e

vv

ee

nn

ii

ff

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

yy

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

tt

ii

mm

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

hh

aa

ss

ss

ii

nn

cc

ee

cc

hh

aa

nn

gg

ee

dd

hh

ii

ss

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

,,

dd

ii

ss

aa

ss

ss

oo

cc

ii

aa

tt

ee

dd

hh

ii

mm

ss

ee

ll

ff

ff

rr

oo

mm

tt

hh

ee

dd

ee

tt

ee

rr

mm

ii

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

hh

ii

ss

ss

tt

aa

tt

uu

ss

bb

yy

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.TT

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

pp

oo

ss

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

ll

aa

ww

cc

aa

nn

vv

aa

ss

ss

ee

dd

,,

tt

hh

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

tt

ii

mm

ee

aa

tt

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

tt

hh

ee

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

ii

ss

tt

oo

bb

ee

dd

ee

tt

ee

rr

mm

ii

nn

ee

dd

ii

ss

ww

hh

ee

nn

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

cc

ee

ee

dd

ii

nn

gg

ss

aa

rr

ee

cc

oo

mm

mm

ee

nn

cc

ee

dd

,,

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

ff

oo

rr

ee

,,

ww

aa

ss

nn

oo

tt

aa

cc

cc

ee

pp

tt

ee

dd

,,

bb

ee

ii

nn

gg

aa

gg

aa

ii

nn

ss

tt

tt

hh

ee

pp

uu

bb

ll

ii

cc

pp

oo

ll

ii

cc

yy

ii

nn

tt

hh

ii

ss

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

aa

nn

dd

ww

hh

ii

cc

hh

mm

aa

yy

cc

rr

ee

aa

tt

ee

aa

ss

ee

rr

ii

oo

uu

ss

ss

oo

cc

ii

aa

ll

pp

rr

oo

bb

ll

ee

mm

.

.

TT

hh

ee

cc

oo

uu

rr

tt

ss

aa

ii

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

oo

nn

cc

ee

tt

hh

ee

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

hh

aa

vv

ee

ss

ee

ll

ee

cc

tt

ee

dd

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

MM

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

AA

cc

tt

aa

ss

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

aa

ww

,,

tt

hh

ee

yy

CC

OO

UU

LL

DD

nn

oo

tt

aa

bb

dd

ii

cc

aa

tt

ee

tt

hh

ee

ss

aa

mm

ee

aa

tt

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

ff

rr

ee

ee

ww

ii

ll

ll

oo

rr

aa

ss

pp

ee

rr

ee

xx

ii

gg

ee

nn

cc

ii

ee

ss

oo

ff

ss

ii

tt

uu

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

rr

aa

cc

cc

oo

rr

dd

ii

nn

gg

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

ww

hh

ii

mm

ss

aa

nn

dd

ff

aa

nn

cc

ii

ee

ss

.

.

AA

ss

aa

nn

aa

tt

uu

rr

aa

ll

cc

oo

rr

oo

ll

ll

aa

rr

yy

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

oo

ff

,,

ee

vv

ee

nn

ii

ff

aa

pp

aa

rr

tt

yy

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

tt

rr

ii

mm

oo

nn

ii

aa

ll

pp

ee

tt

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

ee

ss

tt

aa

bb

ll

ii

ss

hh

ee

ss

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

ff

tt

ee

rr

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

hh

ee

aa

cc

qq

uu

ii

rr

ee

dd

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

oo

ff

ss

oo

mm

ee

oo

tt

hh

ee

rr

cc

oo

uu

nn

tt

rr

yy

,,

ii

tt

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

nn

oo

tt

tt

aa

kk

ee

aa

ww

aa

yy

tt

hh

ee

j j

uu

rr

ii

ss

dd

ii

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

ii

ff

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

dd

aa

tt

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

hh

ee

ww

ee

rr

ee

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

.

.

II

tt

ii

ss

uu

nn

j j

uu

ss

tt

tt

hh

aa

tt

aa

pp

aa

rr

tt

yy

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

cc

aa

nn

cc

hh

aa

nn

gg

ee

hh

ii

ss

ee

nn

tt

ii

rr

ee

ss

yy

ss

tt

ee

mm

oo

ff

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

aa

ww

bb

yy

hh

ii

ss

oo

rr

hh

ee

rr

uu

nn

ii

ll

aa

tt

ee

rr

aa

ll

dd

ee

cc

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

.

.

II

ff

tt

hh

aa

tt

ww

ee

rr

ee

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

ii

tt

ww

oo

uu

ll

dd

mm

aa

kk

ee

tt

hh

ee

pp

oo

ss

ii

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

aa

ww

ii

ff

ee

vv

ee

rr

yy

mm

ii

ss

ee

rr

aa

bb

ll

ee

oo

rr

hh

ee

ll

pp

ll

ee

ss

ss

.

.

TT

hh

ee

pp

rr

oo

vv

ii

ss

ii

oo

nn

ss

oo

ff

HH

ii

nn

dd

uu

MM

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

AA

cc

tt

ww

ii

ll

ll

cc

oo

nn

tt

ii

nn

uu

ee

tt

oo

aa

pp

pp

ll

yy

tt

oo

tt

hh

ee

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

oo

ff

pp

aa

rr

tt

ii

ee

ss

ww

hh

oo

ww

ee

rr

ee

aa

dd

mm

ii

tt

tt

ee

dd

ll

yy

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

dd

ii

nn

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

oo

nn

tt

hh

ee

dd

aa

tt

ee

oo

ff

tt

hh

ee

ii

rr

mm

aa

rr

rr

ii

aa

gg

ee

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

yy

cc

aa

nn

nn

oo

tt

bb

ee

hh

ee

aa

rr

dd

tt

oo

mm

aa

kk

ee

aa

gg

rr

ii

ee

vv

aa

nn

cc

ee

aa

bb

oo

uu

tt

ii

tt

ll

aa

tt

ee

rr

oo

rr

aa

ll

ll

oo

ww

ee

dd

tt

oo

bb

yy

--

pp

aa

ss

ss

ii

tt

bb

yy

ss

uu

bb

tt

ee

rr

ff

uu

gg

ee

ss

.

.TT

hh

ee

CC

oo

uu

rr

tt

aa

ll

ss

oo

ss

tt

aa

tt

ee

dd

tt

hh

aa

tt

uu

nn

dd

ee

rr

bb

oo

tt

hh

tt

hh

ee

II

nn

dd

ii

aa

nn

aa

nn

dd

EE

nn

gg

ll

ii

ss

hh

pp

rr

ii

vv

aa

tt

ee

ii

nn

tt

ee

rr

nn

aa

tt

ii

oo

nn

aa

ll

ll

aa

ww

tt

hh

ee

rr

ee

aa

rr

ee

ff

oo

uu

rr

gg

ee

nn

ee

rr

aa

ll

rr

uu

ll

ee

ss

ii

nn

rr

ee

ss

pp

ee

cc

tt

oo

ff

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

::

NN

oo

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

cc

aa

nn

bb

ee

ww

ii

tt

hh

oo

uu

tt

aa

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

;;

NN

oo

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

cc

aa

nn

hh

aa

vv

ee

ss

ii

mm

uu

ll

tt

aa

nn

ee

oo

uu

ss

ll

yy

tt

ww

oo

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

ss

;;

DD

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

dd

ee

nn

oo

tt

ee

ss

tt

hh

ee

cc

oo

nn

nn

ee

cc

tt

ii

oo

nn

oo

ff

aa

pp

ee

rr

ss

oo

nn

ww

ii

tt

hh

aa

tt

ee

rr

rr

ii

tt

oo

rr

ii

aa

ll

ss

yy

ss

tt

ee

mm

oo

ff

ll

aa

ww

;;

aa

nn

dd

tt

hh

ee

pp

rr

ee

ss

uu

mm

pp

tt

ii

oo

nn

ii

ss

ii

nn

ff

aa

vv

oo

uu

rr

oo

ff

cc

oo

nn

tt

ii

nn

uu

aa

nn

cc

ee

oo

ff

aa

nn

ee

xx

ii

ss

tt

ii

nn

gg

dd

oo

mm

ii

cc

ii

ll

ee

.

.

((3355))


NRI Misplaced Nostalgia

NRI Misplaced Nostalgia

Documents
NRI Newsletter - kksfusa.org

NRI Newsletter - kksfusa.org

Documents
Av. LOS CASTANOS IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML ... · IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MMLIMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP -IMP - MML IMP - MML NOTAS (1) El

Av. LOS CASTANOS IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML ... · IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MMLIMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP -IMP - MML IMP - MML NOTAS (1) El

Documents
25'(1$1=$ 1 IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP ...munirimac.gob.pe/portal/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/PLANO-DE... · IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MMLIMP -

25'(1$1=$ 1 IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP ...munirimac.gob.pe/portal/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/PLANO-DE... · IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MMLIMP -

Documents
Nri Singlepages

Nri Singlepages

Documents
Water NRI ServeAgraam

Water NRI ServeAgraam

Documents
NRI Share Trading Equity India PIS NRE NRO NRI

NRI Share Trading Equity India PIS NRE NRO NRI

Documents
Nri Emails

Nri Emails

Documents
2011 nri-pratiques tests-avancees

2011 nri-pratiques tests-avancees

Technology
Nri Sample Email Ids

Nri Sample Email Ids

Documents
INSTALLATION UND PFLEGE ......KOMPATIBELWÄHLER NRI G13 24 VOLT WÄHLER Der benutzte Wähler soll mit den 24 Volt Wähler standard Mars MS130 (z.B. NRI G18, NRI G40, FAGE Wähler 24V,

INSTALLATION UND PFLEGE ......KOMPATIBELWÄHLER NRI G13 24 VOLT WÄHLER Der benutzte Wähler soll mit den 24 Volt Wähler standard Mars MS130 (z.B. NRI G18, NRI G40, FAGE Wähler 24V,

Documents
NRI Ac OpeningForm

NRI Ac OpeningForm

Documents
Snapshot NRI Online 2008

Snapshot NRI Online 2008

Documents
NRI, IDI et ompagnie - hug.ch–Problème quantitatif: Le NRI combine le NRI event et le NRI non-event indépendamment de la prévalence •Exemple: –NRI event =0.20 et NRI non-event

NRI, IDI et ompagnie - hug.ch–Problème quantitatif: Le NRI combine le NRI event et le NRI non-event indépendamment de la prévalence •Exemple: –NRI event =0.20 et NRI non-event

Documents
NRI: IBF0000145-210001

NRI: IBF0000145-210001

Documents
Godrej Nri Faq

Godrej Nri Faq

Documents
PAN appl Nri Poi oci 49aa

PAN appl Nri Poi oci 49aa

Documents
NRI Banking

NRI Banking

Documents
IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP ... de Zonif Abril... · imp - mml imp - mml imp - mml imp - mml municipalidad metropolitana de lima instituto metropolitano

IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP ... de Zonif Abril... · imp - mml imp - mml imp - mml imp - mml municipalidad metropolitana de lima instituto metropolitano

Documents
Toplines - JuxtConsult NRI Online 2008

Toplines - JuxtConsult NRI Online 2008

Documents
Uud Nri Tahun 1945

Uud Nri Tahun 1945

Documents
Presentation _ NRI

Presentation _ NRI

Documents
Hcca Rev Nri 2005

Hcca Rev Nri 2005

Documents
シンセティック・メディア - NRI

シンセティック・メディア - NRI

Documents
imp ant . imp ant . imp 11

imp ant . imp ant . imp 11

Documents
NL N UL Nri Nzhri Nri Ud AUh FOSSAPIN Nzh NRI Nzhri NRI ... › wp-content › uploads › 2018 › 07 › zonage_… · Ud NLri N Nzh A Ne A Arg Arg AUh Nri N Ari Nri AU AUe AUd

NL N UL Nri Nzhri Nri Ud AUh FOSSAPIN Nzh NRI Nzhri NRI ... › wp-content › uploads › 2018 › 07 › zonage_… · Ud NLri N Nzh A Ne A Arg Arg AUh Nri N Ari Nri AU AUe AUd

Documents
Rosedale Nri Garden-exe Tow

Rosedale Nri Garden-exe Tow

Documents
Contoh Soal Lcc Uud Nri 1945

Contoh Soal Lcc Uud Nri 1945

Documents
IMP - MMLIMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - …

IMP - MMLIMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - MML IMP - …

Documents
NRI Brochure -2016

NRI Brochure -2016

Documents