Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
toki@kyotoradiation 2019.05.25
「アセスメント科学」 - 社会が要請する課題を対象とする科学 -
土岐博 大阪大学名誉教授 原子核物理理論研究
科学者の社会的責任と科学者コミュニティー 広渡清吾2010年学術会議「日本の展望ー学術からの提言」 「学術のための学術」と「社会のための学術」を
不可分一体の本質的契機とする営みとして学術を捉える
2011年9月「東日本大震災からの復興と日本学術会議 の責務(幹事会声明)」の中の政府に対しての提言
1。助言の内容が「多くの専門知に基礎ずけられる俯瞰的、 中立的検討を通じて総合的な知」として形成されるべき 2。政府の側が「科学者コミュニティーの自律的活動を保証 し、情報を開示し、助言を政策的判断の基礎として考慮す る」という立場をとること 3。学術会議の側もこのような学術的助言が「政策決定が 依拠しうる根拠の一つにとどまる」ものとして了解する
具体的には1。低放射線の生物への影響2。人の健康(寿命)の理解(医療費削減)3。持続的なエネルギー(太陽、水、化石燃料、原子力。。)4。核廃棄物の低減と処理(現在は自然放射線の100分の1)5。地球の温度変化への人の営みからの寄与6。その他
社会が要請する課題を対象とする科学 それを「アセスメント科学」と呼ぶ:長我部提案(日立)Assessment science : 科学で答えを出す(上限:下限)
(Trans-science : 科学によっては答えられない課題)
福島事故と甲状腺がん (低放射線の生物への影響)
1。瞬間的に強い放射線の効果は定量的にわかっている 2。年間100mSv以下の放射線の生物影響の定量化は難しい
3。どんな事故でも必ず低線量の問題が出てくる 4。福島から学ぶ必要がある
Many collaborators M. Bando, T. Wada, Y. Manabe, T. Higuchi, S. Hirota,
I. Tanihata, K. Satoh
Earthquake 2011.3.11
No.1 and 3 hydrogen explosion 2011.3.12 and 14
Saito, Tanihata et al.Radiations in soils and air dose
(2011.6.14)
Journal of Environmental Radioactivity 139(2015) 308-319.
June 4~July 8 400 volunteers 1734 locations
PBLS FSSPreliminary baseline survey
Full-scale survey
300,000 children
先行調査
本格調査本格調査2
131I
K. Saito, I. Tanihata et al.J. Env. Radioactivity 139 (2015) 308
Total dose 131I
Numbers of cancer case and air dose rate and 131I
T(131I)=8 days
Natural radiation dose = 2.4mSv/y
1y = 24⇥ 365h = 8760h<latexit sha1_base64="nhGlzwVTEllekYDwRi6XftI1C/E=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Em4Q7qdb4XfpL1devyKW7CUwEek=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Em4Q7qdb4XfpL1devyKW7CUwEek=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="U7J+wj5rxpAVxhWtgN2g5ZuRkKY=">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</latexit>
PBLS cancer case
N = �3.58 x+ 45.01<latexit sha1_base64="wwcb9+7bmONv5Bt4+GUb2rYU5Ek=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="CzaL+XkfdsqaMAf4rrDGtJ1w900=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="CzaL+XkfdsqaMAf4rrDGtJ1w900=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="bSb1X2Hz95A0OEfTXRl/WEzf7aw=">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</latexit>
(�6.81, 1.50)<latexit sha1_base64="ciIF9If+1j5ce3N7NT8hiQpwudQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yZw2QDSasPMHpZ1dW6/ZcfX794U=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yZw2QDSasPMHpZ1dW6/ZcfX794U=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="U0LAka/WjNumLgBOLsum2NG4pc0=">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</latexit>
Slightly decreasing tendency(Screening schedule effect?)
No/105<latexit sha1_base64="T5SiAxEZRBJOI6n2ontesNwK3Ww=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="stfHEMBvzikYfSPcHMoL/KTzxHU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="stfHEMBvzikYfSPcHMoL/KTzxHU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="NRZQk4MIR51+TKpguelqrzXf5ZE=">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</latexit>
95%
FSS cancer incidence vs air dose rate75 out of 270,454 children
The tendency is positiveN = 5.05 x+ 26.54 (0.44, 11.61)
<latexit sha1_base64="DF0o51XBs5u+CrPf9O4OwP0LzYo=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dnjOI7HJYT71IaReA8VC6egw92I=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dnjOI7HJYT71IaReA8VC6egw92I=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="jOhEW9sguDPcsD9VHJPoDIVxFdc=">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</latexit>
95%
No/105<latexit sha1_base64="T5SiAxEZRBJOI6n2ontesNwK3Ww=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="stfHEMBvzikYfSPcHMoL/KTzxHU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="stfHEMBvzikYfSPcHMoL/KTzxHU=">AAACZ3ichVHLSsNAFD2NrxofrQoiuFFLxVW5EUQRxKIbl76qhVoliVMNpklI0oIWf8CF2wquVETEz3ChPyDSTxCXCm5ceJMWREW9w8ycOXPPnTMzmmMank9Ui0hNzS2tbdF2uaOzqzsW7+ld8+ySq4uMbpu2m9VUT5iGJTK+4Zsi67hCLWqmWNf25oP99bJwPcO2Vv19R+SL6o5lFAxd9QNKoc2JrXiCUhTG0E+gNEBi9k6ecS4e5UU7foUNbMOGjhKKELDgMzahwuOWgwKCw1weFeZcRka4L3AImbUlzhKcoTK7x+MOr3IN1uJ1UNML1TqfYnJ3WTmEJD3QNb3QPd3QE73/WqsS1gi87POs1bXC2YodDay8/asq8uxj91P1p2cfBUyFXg327oRMcAu9ri8fVF9WppeTlVE6p2f2f0Y1uuUbWOVX/XJJLJ9C5g9Qvj/3T7A2nlIopSxRIj2HekQxiBGM8XtPIo0FLCLD5+7iGFWcRJ6kmNQvDdRTpUhD04cvIQ1/AFMCjc8=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="NRZQk4MIR51+TKpguelqrzXf5ZE=">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</latexit>
FSS: 131I vs cancer incidence
The slope is smaller than the case of air dose rate Intake of 131I may not be the main cause of cancer
N = 2.35 x+ 29.03 (�0.78, 7.27)<latexit sha1_base64="QzMPp3ux+TZGt1Je5/U4jtegJak=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="cABBN7rLIvU7uzDWn+pDh6TzvQM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="cABBN7rLIvU7uzDWn+pDh6TzvQM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Yw6es3ECX2fr/iFBBe9Is0rklBY=">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</latexit>
No/105<latexit sha1_base64="T5SiAxEZRBJOI6n2ontesNwK3Ww=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="stfHEMBvzikYfSPcHMoL/KTzxHU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="stfHEMBvzikYfSPcHMoL/KTzxHU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="NRZQk4MIR51+TKpguelqrzXf5ZE=">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</latexit>
95%
Poisson regression analysis (glm @ R)
We use all the data of 59 municipalities. We use the statistical mathematics method.
(Error bars are large.)
(Akaike Information criterion)
FSSNo/105
<latexit sha1_base64="T5SiAxEZRBJOI6n2ontesNwK3Ww=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="stfHEMBvzikYfSPcHMoL/KTzxHU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="stfHEMBvzikYfSPcHMoL/KTzxHU=">AAACZ3ichVHLSsNAFD2NrxofrQoiuFFLxVW5EUQRxKIbl76qhVoliVMNpklI0oIWf8CF2wquVETEz3ChPyDSTxCXCm5ceJMWREW9w8ycOXPPnTMzmmMank9Ui0hNzS2tbdF2uaOzqzsW7+ld8+ySq4uMbpu2m9VUT5iGJTK+4Zsi67hCLWqmWNf25oP99bJwPcO2Vv19R+SL6o5lFAxd9QNKoc2JrXiCUhTG0E+gNEBi9k6ecS4e5UU7foUNbMOGjhKKELDgMzahwuOWgwKCw1weFeZcRka4L3AImbUlzhKcoTK7x+MOr3IN1uJ1UNML1TqfYnJ3WTmEJD3QNb3QPd3QE73/WqsS1gi87POs1bXC2YodDay8/asq8uxj91P1p2cfBUyFXg327oRMcAu9ri8fVF9WppeTlVE6p2f2f0Y1uuUbWOVX/XJJLJ9C5g9Qvj/3T7A2nlIopSxRIj2HekQxiBGM8XtPIo0FLCLD5+7iGFWcRJ6kmNQvDdRTpUhD04cvIQ1/AFMCjc8=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="NRZQk4MIR51+TKpguelqrzXf5ZE=">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</latexit>
Iwaki10mGy
External dose (1y)
Air dose rate ̶> External dose
本格調査では甲状腺がんと判定された数は放射線量と比例 するように見える??ーーそのままに受け取って良いのか?
Critical discussion 1. Why the high dose area follow the increasing
tendency? 2. No internal radiation (131I) 3. If external radiation, why the effect of 131I
is small? 4. Can the increase of the thyroid cancer cases
with air-dose related with the stress in life? 5. Can we quantify the stress, and relate with
the amount of radiation?
Escape from the high dose area
Hayano, Adachi (2012) using GPS of mobile-phones
People within 20km have evacuated from the area People further than 30km remained in the area
Proc Jpn Acad, Ser B 89 (2013) 196-199.
Fukushima
IwakiTotal
<latexit sha1_base64="JIkMo70i3If8U+dfnI7aV1ky2Pc=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="YLnMmKkbsQwCPuqAWoLV+XRdhNw=">AAACaHichVHLLgRBFD3TXqO9BgvERkyI1eS2DZEIYWOJmUGCSHcrVPR0d7prJhkTP2BjiVghIuIzLPgBEZ+AJYmNhTs9kwiCW6mqU6fuuXWqyvIdGSqih5hWU1tX3xBv1JuaW1rbEu0dC6GXD2yRtT3HC5YsMxSOdEVWSeWIJT8QZs5yxKK1PV3eXyyIIJSem1FFX6zmzE1XbkjbVExlM54ynbVEklIURd9PYFRBcuJGH/fP7vVZL3GBFazDg408chBwoRg7MBFyW4YBgs/cKkrMBYxktC+wC521ec4SnGEyu83jJq+Wq6zL63LNMFLbfIrDPWBlHwboji7phW7pih7p/ddapahG2UuRZ6uiFf5a2153+u1fVY5nha1P1Z+eFTYwGnmV7N2PmPIt7Iq+sHPwkh6bHygN0ik9s/8TeqBrvoFbeLXP58T8MXT+AOP7c/8EC8Mpg1LGHCUnp1CJOHrRjyF+7xFMYgazyPK5Evs4xFHsSUtoXVpPJVWLVTWd+BJa/webG47p</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="YLnMmKkbsQwCPuqAWoLV+XRdhNw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="iEVJmZTBVCepO+mBPF6syJesNUw=">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</latexit>
Total<latexit sha1_base64="JIkMo70i3If8U+dfnI7aV1ky2Pc=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="YLnMmKkbsQwCPuqAWoLV+XRdhNw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="YLnMmKkbsQwCPuqAWoLV+XRdhNw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="iEVJmZTBVCepO+mBPF6syJesNUw=">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</latexit>
137Cs<latexit sha1_base64="Sj8H8KQ12oZtV8mIAkOKDkBckyM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DR0DDctf67aJLw2qqfNO4YJX5UI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DR0DDctf67aJLw2qqfNO4YJX5UI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="AUXlOfZw6rurcDY/UQLtV5nZMgo=">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</latexit>
131I<latexit sha1_base64="JtOcpyeA4f7pzLHgBAh51a/te6c=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QGj0zv825mZ85iZiepeJX7Csi28=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QGj0zv825mZ85iZiepeJX7Csi28=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="zsHDAYvrNXYw76UJkuhNKAF07aA=">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</latexit>
131I<latexit sha1_base64="JtOcpyeA4f7pzLHgBAh51a/te6c=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QGj0zv825mZ85iZiepeJX7Csi28=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QGj0zv825mZ85iZiepeJX7Csi28=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="zsHDAYvrNXYw76UJkuhNKAF07aA=">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</latexit>
134Cs<latexit sha1_base64="wbTcjCTn5kMFRBiHamkr+UQqBKM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="b+4/plHdWPWtGmy7FXzyKq4cjVI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="b+4/plHdWPWtGmy7FXzyKq4cjVI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="phT+OupcWLlshegVZHrUYTOL88c=">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</latexit>
134Cs<latexit sha1_base64="wbTcjCTn5kMFRBiHamkr+UQqBKM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="b+4/plHdWPWtGmy7FXzyKq4cjVI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="b+4/plHdWPWtGmy7FXzyKq4cjVI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="phT+OupcWLlshegVZHrUYTOL88c=">AAACa3ichVG7SgNBFD1Z3/GRqI2oRTBErMJdFRQr0cYyPmICMYbddYxL9sXuJhCDP2BpY6GNgoj4GTb+gIWfIGKlYGPhzWZBNKh3mZ0zZ+65c+aO6hi65xM9RqSOzq7unt6+aP/A4FAsPjyy7dlVVxNZzTZsN68qnjB0S2R93TdE3nGFYqqGyKmV1eZ+riZcT7etLb/uiKKplC19X9cUn6n8bkOemz9a9UrxJKUpiEQ7kEOQRBgZO36NHezBhoYqTAhY8BkbUODxV4AMgsNcEQ3mXEZ6sC9whChrq5wlOENhtsL/Mq8KIWvxulnTC9Qan2LwcFmZQIoe6IZe6Z5u6Yk+fq3VCGo0vdR5Vlta4ZRix2Ob7/+qTJ59HHyp/vTsYx+LgVedvTsB07yF1tLXDk9fN5c2Uo1puqRn9n9Bj3THN7Bqb9rVutg4Q5QfQP7Z7nawPZuWKS2vU3J5JXyKXkxgCjPc7wUsYw0ZZIM+n+AM55EXaVQalyZbqVIk1IziW0ipT1w+jGY=</latexit>
137Cs<latexit sha1_base64="Sj8H8KQ12oZtV8mIAkOKDkBckyM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DR0DDctf67aJLw2qqfNO4YJX5UI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DR0DDctf67aJLw2qqfNO4YJX5UI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="AUXlOfZw6rurcDY/UQLtV5nZMgo=">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</latexit>
Day
Day
1y
1y
2y
2y
External dose (March 15)30mGy
rate̶>dose
ストレス大ストレス小
生活環境の変化で腫瘍の発生が変化する
Book of Sado (P.440)
マウスの年齢(日) 500 page (many data)
人へのストレス
2015年 ストレスの強さと地域性
放射線量が高い地域ほどストレスは高い
高 低
しかしどんなメカニズムでがんに関与するかは未明!!
Conclusion and Discussion 1. In PBLS, the cancer cases do not increase
with the air dose rate 2. In FSS, the cancer cases increase with the
air dose rate 3. Why the high dose area follow the increasing
tendency? 4. Why the effect of 131I is small? 5. The increase of the thyroid cancer cases
may be related with the stress in life? 6. We should consider risks other than radiation
on equal footing
タイトルへの結論 Assessment Science
1。社会のための学術(学術会議) 2。社会が要請する課題に取り組む(チャレンジ)
3。定量的にする(上限や下限を出す) 4。結果に対する原因は一つではない
5。分野を超えて真理のために葛藤(勉強)する 6。「多くの専門知に基礎ずけられる俯瞰的、 中立的検討を通じて総合的な知」(学術会議)