62
(Time: < 60 minutes) Dennis Golabiewski June 17, 2010 1 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop "If you have a difficult task, give it to a lazy person; they will find an easier way to do it." Hlade's Law.

Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

  • Upload
    letuyen

  • View
    213

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

(Time:  < 60 minutes)

Dennis GolabiewskiJune 17, 2010 1ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop

"If you have a difficult task, give it to a lazy person; they will find an easier way to do it."  —Hlade's Law.

Page 2: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 2

Orientation is Required For Everyone Submittingmanufacturing drawings to the Machine Shop for the production of components.

Job Submission & Trackinghttps://fultonapps.asu.edu/shop/

Log in using your asurite logon

Orientation   http://ets.fulton.asu.edu/machine-shop/supplemental-information

Machine Shop     http://ets.fulton.asu.edu/machine-shop/machine-shop

FROM THE DEANS OFFICEAll students, whether submitting jobs for research faculty or their own 490  or Capstone projects, must have first completed the one hour machine shop orientation session and be registered with the machine shop before any job requests can be accepted!  As of January 1, 2009 labor fees will be put in place.  Please check our webpage.

It is not enough to do your best; you must know what to do, and THEN do your best. W. Edwards Deming 

Page 3: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

6 weeks prior to last day of semesterSummer Projects must be < 3 days work.

ALL JOBS ARE NOW SUBMITTED ONLINE

Any submissions for class projects cannot be guaranteed for the end of a semester if they are submitted after the due date.

Work backlog in the shop is generally   3 – 6 weeks.

All jobs are now submitted on line.                    SolidWorks files can be e‐mailed (with job #) to :      https://fultonapps.asu.edu/shop/ [email protected] [email protected]

Professors & ResearchersIf you need your parts completed sooner, there is the option to pay for HIGH PRIORITY (see mshop webpage) to have your work moved forward in the job queue. 

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop

3

Page 4: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

Instrument & Prototype Machine Shop Personnel

Manager:  DENNIS G.

[email protected] 96(5 –7163)Room 170a R.S.S. Bldg 2

SHOP LEADS: BUTCH BAUER & MARTY JOHNSONR.S.S. Bldg. 1 Room 130Phone 96(5–6030) shop

Shop Hrs. 7:30am / 11:45pm ‐‐ 12:15pm  CLOSED / 3:00 pmStudent computers ( RSS 2 Room 170B ) accessible during shop hours only.

– Staff:

– MACHINIST

– David Mushier [email protected]

– MACHINIST SR.– Forest (Ben) Schwatken [email protected]– David Gillespie  [email protected]

– INSTRUMENT MKR/DESIGNER

– Martin Johnson [email protected]

– INSTRUMENT MKR/DESIGNER

– Harold (Butch) Bauer [email protected]

June 17, 2010ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop

"In theory there is no difference between theory and practice, but in practice there is.“Yogi Berra 

Page 5: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

Shop Location

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 5

The Science Graduate asks "How does it work ?"The Economics Graduate asks "How much does it cost ?"The Engineering Graduate asks "How can we make it ?"The Liberal Arts Graduate asks "Do you want fries with that ?"— Jesse N. Schell.

Tyler street parking

officeshop

Page 6: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

Shop Rules • Never! walk into the shop without permission! Wait inside the door for 

someone to assist you.

• Never! come to the shop with open toe shoes, sandals or flip‐flops, you will not be allowed entry!

• Because this is a continuous problem.• Read RULES 1and 2 several times if needed!

• Safety glasses are available inside the shop door.  Once you receive permission.  Put them on before walking any further into the shop to speak with your machinist. 

• PLEASE Return our SAFETY GLASSES  or Leave $6.00 with SHOP LEAD

• Not following these rules may result in termination of your use of the machine shop services and cessation of your “work in progress”!

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop

"Nothing in the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity." ‐Martin Luther King Jr. 

Page 7: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

List of TOPICS in this PPT

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 7

Q: What is the difference between Mechanical Engineers and Civil Engineers?

A: Mechanical Engineers build weapons, Civil Engineers build targets." 

Page 8: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

TERMINOLOGYCAD (computer aided design)

(computer aided drafting)

CAM (computer aided manufacturing)(computer aided machining)

CNC (computer numerical control  “G‐CODE programs”)

CAE (computer aided engineering)

FEA (finite element analysis ‐ pretesting)

RP (rapid prototyping = FDM, SLA, SLS, LC, 3d printing … )

GD&T  (geometric dimensioning & tol’s)

PLM (product lifecycle management)  concept to distribution management

BD&T (SHOP REQUIRES BASIC DIMENSIONING AND TOLERANCING )

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 8

“It's a damn poor mind that can only think of one way to spell a word.” Andrew Jackson

Page 9: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

Cars, lawnmowers, computers, vending, copying

Milling machine, extruding machine, drill press… (fabricating )

Axe, hammer, wrench, pencil, pc mouse, SolidWorks, Cosmos, a Big Stick

Endmills, lathe bits, grinding wheels, lawn mower blade

“We do not loan out any tools, OF ANY KIND”dg

Page 10: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 10

Machine Tools & Mfg. Tools@the

Vertical & horizontal knee milling machinesTool room lathes2 & 3 axes CNC vertical knee mills3 axes Tool Room Mills2 ‐ 4 axes Machining Centers2‐ ½  axes CNC tool room lathePedestal Surface GrinderPedestal I.D. / O. D. Cylindrical Grinder Metal cutting band sawsShears, Brakes, Punches and Presses

Page 11: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 11

Machine Shop & Mfg. Processes

• What they are called.  How they work . What they do.• The tolerances they are capable of achieving. • The types of surface finishes they generate.  

Understanding your manufacturing options will help you design prototype parts that will include: • Improve performance • Reliability for testing • Reduced re‐design and/or manufacture time. 

Even if you're on the right track, you'll get run over if you just sit there. Will Rogers

Page 12: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 12

There are 3 machine tool groups that do the majority of work in our machine shop.  They are:  

Mills (INCLUDING CNC Machine Centers)Lathes Grinders. 

For your projects at ASU, if you plan on using the Machine Shop, learn as much as possible about the capabilities of these machines. The time spent will: 

Aid in designing parts we can produce. Cut down production time.Leave you with a better understanding of what we must do to manufacture your parts    and leave you with a greater appreciation of the skills of machinists.  

Page 13: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 13

Milling Machines

Milling is the process of removing material from a workpiece (part) by moving the workpiece (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed position head/ram, rotating multi or single tooth/flute milling cutters (tool bit). 

The cutting action of teeth around the center axis of the milling cutter provides a fast, accurate method to machining. The machined surface may be flat, angular, or a multi dimensional curve or curve surface. 

The adjoining surfaces or edges (features) may also be milled to produce any combination of shapes and contours. The machine used for these applications is properly referred to as a milling machine tool or a machining center. 

Today live tooling lathes can duplicate some of these operations eliminating the need for multiple set‐ups on separate machine tools.

The shop has both CNC and manual, vertical and horizontal knee mills. 

Precision) ±0.0005”or ±0.013mm.  These tolerances are operation and operator dependent and under ideal new equipment conditions and unlimited time constraints. These are the current shop capabilities relative to specific operations.      

OPERATIONSToday milling machines are also used for drilling, reaming, 

boring, counter boring, counter sinking, tapping, grooving and chamfering holes. 

Know the difference between the operations above. They are different in their degree of accuracy and function. Learn ( www.youtube.com ) these terms and use them in your drawings. It will clarify the requirements of a feature for the machinist.

Knee

Spindle

Spindle

Page 14: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 14

CNC Machining Centers(ALSO MILLING MACHINES)

The Fulton Machine Shop has 2 Machining CentersAccuracy on these machines can be as good as: ±0.0005” or ±0.0127mm

These tolerances are operation depend.

VF3YT VF4

Page 15: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 15

Tool Room Lathe Machine Tools• Operations commonly done with a lathe:• Turning……machining (cylinder) the OD (outside diameter)• Boring………machining (cylinder) the ID (inside diameter)• Facing………machining a smooth surface on the end of a piece• Thread Cutting……making threads on either the OD of ID• Taper Cutting……turning/boring a conical OD or ID• Drilling……clearing a hole thru the center (rotation axis) of a 

piece.• Grooving……for O‐rings, E‐clips, snap rings, oil grooves, etc.

• Turning or boring are the machining operation that produce cylindrical features on parts. It is defined as machining external diameter (O.D) and internal diameter (I.D.) surfaces. With the workpiece mounted on one of several types of head stocks. The workpiece rotates about the centerline of the headstock . A single‐point lathe tool‐bit moves parallel to the axis of rotation of the workpiece and at a distance from the workpiece that will force contact between the work piece and the tool bit.  This interference of the tool bit on a workpiece will remove a portion of the O.D. or I.D. surface of the part.

• Taper turning is similar with the exception that the cutter path is at an angle to the work piece axis. Similarly, in contour turning, the distance of the cutter from the work axis is varied to produce the desired shape. This is usually achieved by the use of templates on tracer lathes and G‐code programs on CNC machines.

• Various types of single flute lathe bits are used to generate the best result with respect to feature shape & type of material being machined

Spindle / ChuckOr Head Stock

Tool Post

Cross slide

Page 16: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 16

Tool Room Surface & Cylindrical Grinding Machines

Surface grinding is the process of passing a workpiece fixed to a table moving longitudinally and transversely under a fixed location, high speed, rotating grinding (generally stone) wheel. Diamond and other material wheels are used for harder or softer materials.

Cylindrical grinding is the process of moving a rotating piece (as in a lathe) against a rotating grinding wheel. The grinding wheel can be moved either across the outer or the inner diameter of a cylindrical work piece. Newer CNC grinders can finish grind tapers, contours and steps in a single operation. The grinders in our shop is similar those on this page.

Precision, NEW MACHINE TOOL 0.0001”or 0.0025mm (average human hair±approx. 0.003” or 0.076mm)

Our grinders do not do contoured surfaces. 

Page 17: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 17

Perishable ToolingMill, Perishable Tooling Lathe, tool bits Grinding, wheels

END MILLSFor milling outside shapes, inside 

pockets or 3d‐5d surfaces

DRILLSFor hole making.  This is the fastest way to remove material!

TAPSFor 

inside threads

O.D. TOOLSFor  cutting outside 

diameters or finish faces

I.D. TOOLSFor boring inside 

diameters

FINEFor very tight 

tolerances and 

excellent finishes

DIAMONDFor very hard materials

i.e. super alloys orHeat treated 

Steels

COURSEFor ruff finish

Taper drillsFor  

roughing tapered holes

Page 18: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 1 8

A few more Types of ManufacturingLaser Cutting / Etching Water Jet  Wire EDM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0qkiNzH0cE

Die SinkingInjection, Gravity Molding, Extruding, Die Casting, Foam Molding, Hot Forming, Investment Casting, Rapid Injection Molding CNC Graphite Laminating Die CastingInvestment Casting   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7VIeMHCSOg

Liquid Metal InjectionPart Stamping   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p48EKMhlu50

Hot FormingSpecialty Machine Tools

SEE WWW.YOUTUBE.COM FOR VIDEO FILES DEMONSTRATING THESE METHODS

Rapid Prototyping  SLA (obsolete…. kind of), 3d Printing, SLS, FDM, LC SLSC: 

SLS (or selective laser sintering). Actual production materials (nylon, glass filled, alum. Filled, metal filled) can be used. FDM (or fused deposition modeling). Builds in ABS and other plastics, good for functional testing of parts. LC (laser consolidation) FDM for metalsSLS Composite for metal, plastic and dry resin mixtures

"If you can't fix it with duck tape  you haven't used enough.“Red Green

Page 19: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 19

Rapid Prototypes & Time Compression Rapid Prototyping, SLA, SLS, FDM, LC:  Gives an accurate, smooth surface, with fine detail. The resins and powders used can now produce many plastic, glass filled plastic, metal and metal filled plastic parts. 

SLA Stereo lithography Apparatus  (the first of all R.P.) HTTP://EN.WIKIPEDIA.ORG/WIKI/STEREOLITHOGRAPHY HTTP://YOUTUBE.COM/RESULTS?SEARCH_QUERY=RAPID+PROTOTYPINGHTTP://WWW.YOUTUBE.COM/WATCH?V=GGVZCGDZSTC&FEATURE=PLAYLIST&P=D3DD2FEB0C0A976D&INDEX=0

SLS (or selective laser sintering). Actual production materials (nylon, glass filled, metal filled) can be used. Even difficult features such as live hinges are possible. The finished surface can have a resolution as small as 0.002  or 0.05mm.  Now metal & plastic composites HTTP://EN.WIKIPEDIA.ORG/WIKI/SELECTIVE_LASER_SINTERING

FDM (or fused deposition modeling). Builds in ABS and other poly plastics, good for 

functional testing of parts. HTTP://EN.WIKIPEDIA.ORG/WIKI/FUSED_DEPOSITION_MODELING

LC (laser consolidation) a type of FDM only for metals. Including S.S. 316 & 420, Inconel 625, CPM‐9V, H‐13 and Titanium alloys.  New metals are being added to the list daily.  Extremely accurate. High cost. Prices will continue to drop.

Most of the materials above can also be machined after (secondary operations) they are processed by R.P.

Page 20: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 20

Rapid prototype examples

3D printing & other RP’s reduce the need for prototype MOLDS and/or machined pieces.

To view some rapid prototype videos type in rapid prototype at www.youtube.com

With table in the up position a layer of resin or powder is rolled on.  Then, a laser or solidification compound is  used to harden the material for part definition.

The table lowers to accommodate for appropriate part resolution and the process is repeated until  the part is complete.  

Page 21: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 21

Finish Chart

Different features may require better finishesYou can call out special finish requirements in your drawings as needed

Page 22: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 22

PARTS WE DO NOT BUILDAny part that can be purchased in a hardware store or instrumentation supply store will not be made in the shop.  The Shop does not supply ANY Hardware or Tools.

ExamplesO‐ring e‐clips screws nuts bolts washers cotter pins shear pins lock pinsbushings bearings electrical  carpentry adhesives tools  plumbing hosesfiles (metal) saws gages brackets

If you need to have purchased hardware altered and the changes are something the shop can do, we will. There are some things we can not machine. Check with the shop to see if we can or will need to be machined outside.

Materials are purchased by you through the shop office. Outsourced work and Special tooling is @ your cost. We don’t make DO-OVERS without charging shop time and material costs. Your job goes to the bottom of the queue.

All pipe over  6" (152mm) in diameter must have the words "large pipe" painted on it, so the  Contractor will not  mistake it for small  pipe.U.S. GovernmentPurchasing Spec.’s

Page 23: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 23

Har

dwar

e an

d Fa

sten

ers Determining what hardware to use and how to fasten assemblies is an 

engineering function. 

You need to decide how your parts will be held together.  The shop cannot make that decision for you.  If you are looking for recommendations on where and how to use fasteners and adhesives the internet can supply that information for you.

Adhesives are quickly replacing typical hardware in many designs.  Remember though, with the use of adhesives there is the possibility you parts will never come apart!

If you are using hardware such as screws, nuts, bushings or bearings be sure to supply them to the shop.  This will ensure that the machinist knows exactly what you need for fit and function.

The shop can purchase hardware for you but, in addition to the charge for the hardware there is an ASU fee, “up to 28% required handling ”.

Page 24: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 24

Weldments & Sheet Metal We do welding, brazing and silver soldering in our 

Machine Shop.  There are limitations.  See the Shop Lead

Question, What at can be welded? Answer:  Only like metals.

There is also a Weld Shop on campus.

Sheet metal bending, folding and hole punching can be done at the shop, again there are many limitations.

If you have more questions about these operations check with the shop leadman.   Fred Sierra R.S.S. 1 Rm. 130

The Development Shop can do some Chemical welding.     Check with us.

Page 25: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop

25Intelligent Design & Design Intent

Spend more time visualizing your finished part or assembly before you start your design.

Use a Solid Modeler, they’re easy to learn and help with visualization.

Check the Manufacturability of Designs. Understand the function of each feature. Discover what can go wrong.

What is the real intent of your design? Limit your design accordingly. Adding unnecessary features is generally not a good practice.

Know Parts vs. Assemblies. This is a common problem with new

Engineers and Designers that don’t understand manufacturing methods.

Find cost effective, functional and machineable materials.

Determine at the onset all manufacturing capabilities available to you.What are their costs? Which methods are needed?

Know Machine Tool & Rapid Prototype limitations

Know the needed tolerances required for the functionality of each part and feature.

Test in F.E.A. software (as needed) to determine potential problems.

"An engineer makes a $500 item with $50 worth of parts. A designer then adds $450 worth of crap.“anonymous    

Page 26: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 26

Design Stage IntegrationEvery day new tools for project development are introduced. Concept,

Prototype and Manufacturing designs are now a single process. The introduction of CAD/CAM, CAE, FEA, RP and PLM (product lifecycle management) has moved the actual work from the old “Concept, Prototype, Testing and Production” stages to the Computer generated Prototype & Production stage. Concepts can change with a few clicks and retesting can be done in minutes instead of days or weeks.

At the development stage, designs and material can be changed and manipulated as well as tested for structural integrity, functionally and production time. These are all things we really would like to know as soon as possible. These CAD/CAM/PLM/FEA tools are your crystal ball!

Now that the Prototype stage of component and assembly development has been radically changed. Old school techniques of build and test then build again are becoming historical foot notes. Today's CAD (computer aided design) and FEA ( finite element analysis ) coupled with RP (rapid prototyping) are pushing industry into the Time Compression mode with either single or no physical testing required before releasing for production.

Projects that engineers and designers spent six months to a year developing are now                             

being moved from concept to market in less than six weeks.I am careful not to confuse excellence with perfection. Excellence, I can reach for; perfection is God's business.Michael J Fox

Page 27: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine 

Shop27

FROM: http://w

ww50.sap.com

/businessmaps/991F613D

6C6E4325ADFB06D

CE294F352.htm

CAD‐Driven Design Process

Page 28: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 28

Prototype ConsiderationsRemember, concept sketches are not appropriate for

submission to any Machine Shop. If they are photos, artist rending or paper napkin sketches, they will very likely not contain the information needed to re-produce parts. Submission to our shop will require fully defined prototype designs and detailed drawings. This also applies to repairs.

http://www.engineersedge.com/

These requirements are for all engineering disciplines.

Although a concept sketch is not suitable for shop submission it is sometimes helpful to bring one to the shop as a reference for any questions you may have about the direction you are moving with regard to the manufacturability of your part. Just make sure you’ve placed some over all dimensions, tolerances, material call out and quantity required.

Please don’t come to the shop and try to draw a picture of your part in our heads. We don’t go there!

Using CAD for your prototype design is an advantage in the overall process at several different levels. If you do not know a CADpackage learn one as soon as you can.

Page 29: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 29

Typical PrototypesPrototypes generally fit into 1 of 3 categories.

Non-functioning display models. Used for marketing and display purposes.

Partially functioning models. Also used in marketing or for testing specific features of a component. This is a prototype that generally demonstrates function and form. It may also be used in obtaining patents and licenses.

Fully functional models. Generally used for physical test. This is generally a prototype that appears to be a product purchased off the shelf in a store .

All of the prototypes have a commonality in that they require fully defined drawings in order to build them to specifications needed for functionality or esthetic requirements. Again, using CAD software to create a virtual prototype can save you and the shop time and effort. CAD Parts will automate the process of generating useful and accurate drawings. When Engineers and Designers do this it saves time and effort in ever subsequent process and identifies weak designs & parts.

Page 30: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine 

Shop30

SolidWorks, SolidSimulation

& Ansys

Page 31: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine 

Shop31

SolidWorks, Cosmos and Ansys and other engineering software is available for everyone in the Fulton School of Engineering.

Software will be installed on ASU computers and student laptops and have a 1 semester license.  Authorization by a faculty member is required.

Be aware that other F.E.A. software packages work inside SolidWorks.  (i.e. Comsol, Abacus, FRED, Nastran, Algor and others)

http://www.screencast.com/users/SolidWorksDemos/collections/COSMOSDesignSTAR/media/211c7c73‐d423‐49c0‐beb0‐c9a2533aea0b&preview='1

WHERE TO GO:

Student Desk in the ECG Lobby

Page 32: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine 

Shop32

Submission Data & Files

CAD (computer aided design) part and drawing files need to be submitted with hard copies of your drawings (We can accept most types of scan able media). This will help expedite your work through the shop in a timely manner. This will also insure that we build your parts the way you intended or at least the way they were drawn.

Any errors you make in the design of your part will show up in your final part. If we notice something that appears to be problematic we will contact you.

There is no guarantee we will find or ever see your mistakes!

Just because you can draw it doesn’t mean we can build it. We will do an initial quick review of your drawings. Check back in a day or two, to see if your submission has been placed in the Queue. We will also be able to give you an approximate start date.

Hand drawn parts must meet the same standards as CAD filesThe ideal engineer is a composite ... He is not a scientist, he is not a mathematician, he is not a sociologist or a writer; but he may use the knowledge and techniques of any or all of these disciplines in solving engineering problems.

N. W. Dougherty

Page 33: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 33

CAD Parts & DrawingsAll drawings must be to scale and the scale must be called out in the title

block.

Drawings can be in either Inch OR Metric dimensions but the two units must not be mixed in a drawing unless both units are attached to every dimension. (dual dimensioning).

All drawings must be done using third angle projection.

Drawings must contain enough views to fully define the part.

Some drawings will need only 2 views, most will need at least 3 views. Do not put ( )’S around every dimension!

Drawings should be dimensioned from DATUMS (start points). As the designer it is your responsibility to make a decision as to where the datums for each view are to be located.

Datums are generally chosen by functionality of a feature such as a mating edge or hole centerlines.

We cannot use CAD part files as MFG. drawings. They do not contain tolerance information or datum locations. We need your CAD drawing files.

Page 34: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine 

Shop34

Realistic Parts

These parts cannot  beproduce…Although these are  extreme examples,  they are indicative of theproblems the shop

sees from bothR.A’s and students           that rush through the design 

process 

“The I.D. (inside diameter) of all pipe must not exceed the O.D. (outside diameter) –otherwise the hole will be on the outside.”

U.S. GovernmentPurchasing Spec.’s

Page 35: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine 

Shop35

Realistic Parts

Don’t put too much workinto a bad design.

Page 36: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop

363rd Angle Projection

Page 37: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 37

3rd Angle Projection

YES

Page 38: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 38

1st Angle Projection

No

Page 39: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 39

Machine Shop Design Service for Researchers

Would youtry these On paperdrawings.

Page 40: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine 

Shop40

Enough views to fully define a part.

Page 41: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 41

Example of a title block w/ tolerance call-outs

Tolerances are called out for 2, 3 and 4 place dimensions.  There is a material  box and  a comments box in this TITLE BLOCK.  Title Blocks can be customized for your individual needs.

To  override the title block callouts attach tolerances directly to the dimension.

Page 42: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 42

Drawing Requirements All drawings must contain a specific material call out. All drawings need a quantity call out or only one will be produced .  

Hole features should be labeled and dimensioned to the centerline of the hole. This will avoid confusion with regard to the function of the feature.       ( What about spines?... You do not need to dimension splines if you supply us by way ofCAD files.) 

Face features should be dimensioned to edges or edge points.  Dimension angles from horizontal or vertical edges if possible. CAD drawings must be submitted as both data files and hardcopies. (part and drawing data files must be included) 

Drawings done by hand must meet the same detailing requirements as CAD drawings. (next slide). If you are using a different CAD system (SW‐ASU) check with the shop to determine the type of data file you will need to export to our system. We have direct translators for most major CAD systems, not all. 

USE NOMINAL SIZES WHEN POSSIBLE ( metric mm or english inch )

“I have never let my schooling interfere with my education.”Mark Twain

Page 43: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 43

Hand Drawings

Hand drawings will be held to the same standards as CAD drawings. We do not have time to verify the accuracy of non-associative drawing software applications. (NO VISIO,PC paint, or other non-CAD software DRAWINGS) DO NOT USE THEM!

Every drawing must be TO SCALE. The scale of your drawing must be CLEARLY noted on your drawings. If a view is out of scale the scale for that view must be noted with that view.

Any drawing not to scale will be returned for correction (if we can reach you). We should be able to measure your hand drawings for quick verification of accuracy.

I am unaware of any engineering or design firm using hand drawings.

It is a good idea to learn CAD A.S.A.P. "I find that the harder I work,the more luck I seem to have." 

Thomas Jefferson (1743‐1826)

Page 44: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 44

Quick Tips Pg 1 TIP

Position parts in the easiest to understand arrangement and most efficient way to dimension.

This way                           Not this way

“Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not one bit simpler.”Albert Einstein

Page 45: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 45

Quick Tips• Internal sharp corners tend to weaken a piece and are difficult to produce. External

sharp corners create hazardous edges.

• Sharp corners are general seen as stress, fracture or injury points. Avoid using them whenever possible. In most instances internal sharps are not machineable in our shop.

• External edges should have chamfers, radii or call outs to “break” sharp edges.

• Generally the larger the corner radii are the stronger the piece becomes. Lean toward larger radii when possible.

• When designing pocketed areas inside sharp corners for a single component cannot happen unless the pocket is a through pocket or the job is sent to a shop equipped to perform that type of machining. One option is to split the component into a component group for assembly.

• When a sharp corner is needed it best to note so on your flat sheets. If it is not designated some machining operations will automatically leave small radii due to the design of cutting tools.

Pg 2 TIP

Page 46: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop

Quick Tips• Depth of holes are generally dictated by the diameter of the hole and the density of the 

material. 2 ½ ‐ 5 times the diameter is a good rule of thumb.  Depth/Diameter ratio.

• Deep hole drilling is possible but you should check with the shop before proceeding too far with your design of deep features. 

• Draft on parts is easier to machine if the draft is in standard increments. ( ½°, 1°, 2°, 3°, 5°, 10°, 15°).  These degree increments are used extensively in the aero‐space and molding industry. ( reason = tooling) 

• Thin walls and razor edges should be avoided in prototype machining. This type of work usually requires specialty machining. 

• The Thin Wall Rule is  Wall depth to be no more than 3‐½ times the thickness of wall.

• NO razor edges. This problem manifests itself differently with a range of materials. 

• The shop will not do feather edges…  A minimum of  0.032”or approx. 0.80mm thickness on walls and edges is required.  (the thin wall RULE applies here)  

• If you insist and we agree to try, we will not guarantee the outcome!

Pg 3 TIP

Page 47: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 47

Quick Tips / Charts Pg 4 TIP

Use and notate the correct fit for the intended function of the feature.This is true in both single component and assembly design.

Page 48: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 48

Quick Tips / Charts Pg  5 TIP

Holes are generally started with drills. There are however, other methods employed to create holes requiring

greater precision. Tolerancing holes and shafts independently.

Page 49: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 49

Quick Tips 

GD&T is the international standard for detailed part drawings. It clarifies a part drawing in an accurate way leaving few or no questions during the manufacturing process. 

Understanding GD&T requires a high level of commitment and an eye for detail on the part of engineers and designers. If used incorrectly it can add confusion rather than clarification during the manufacturing and inspection stages of part production. 

The shop does not require that you use GD&T but welcomes it on the condition it is used correctly. For information on the correct employment of this tool there are numerous sights on the internet. 

Pg  6 TIP

Page 50: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 50

ASME Y14.5M-1994 symbols for geometric tolerancing & specs.

Page 51: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 51

Feature Control Frame

________________

___

Page 52: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 52

Feature Control Examples

Page 53: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 53

It is okay to submit an assembly file and assembly drawing but, only as a supplemental submission to all component part and drawing files.  In S.W. files are associative.  Remember, if you do not submit all your associated files we will not be able to open any of them.

When designing, an understanding of manufacturing and machining will help you to recognize the difference between a single part and assemblies.

PLEASE DO NOT bring in an assembly and expect us to determine breakout points. We are not the engineers, we may not know the functionality of your parts.  If you need some advice please come and talk to us.

Assembly drawings are for your design verification and use with F.E.A. software. They help the machine shop only as a visual aid and (reference only) verification. ( )’s = ref. Dim. Only. 

Each component in your assemble will require a minimum of one fully detailed drawing. (understand stack tolerances) 

If your assembly contains exactly mirrored or duplicate components only one needs to be defined. The call out for a mirrored or duplicated piece can be made on the drawing sheet.

Page 54: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 54

Cosmos F.E.A.Cosmos‐ lite (now SolidSimulation) is an F.E.A. package already availably in 

Solidworks. Simple static stress, flow and circuit analyses can be applied directly to your components prior to manufacture. Additional Cosmos F.E.A. modules work directly inside your part and assembly files. (Ansys 10 is also available) Availably through E.T.S. Help Desk (Goldwater Bldg. For ASU computers and student laptops only )

Just a few Examples of Cosmos Applications 

Steady state (static) or transient thermal analysis

Radiation, heat flux and thermal stresses

Mold flow analysis / Circuit flow analysis (library and definable materials)

Fluid and gas flow analysis (library plus definable fluids and gasses) 

Kinematics and motion analysis (for wear, movement interference and stresses) 

Isotropic and directional analysis on all of the above

If your project (490) is too time consuming for the shop to complete in the allowed time and the information you require can be derived from the F.E.A. software, you may need to consider using that option for your project.

Page 55: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 55

Cosmos Examples:

Page 56: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 56

Page 57: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 57

Page 58: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 58

Thanks to computer simulators and other cutting edge tools of the trade, racing safety is no longer something achieved only through crash and burn, trial and error.  Anti‐lift flaps prevent body lift during the sideways motion of an uncontrolled car. This stops the car body from lifting into the air and gain uncontrollable flight. This was achieved through F.E.A. and computer simulations. Modern Marvels: Racetrack Tech* 

http://express.howstuffworks.com/200mph‐tech4.htm

Page 59: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 59

Page 60: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 60

Page 61: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 61

Some Helpful Links

http://www.engineersedge.com www.matweb.com

www.compositesworld.com www.deskeng.com

http://jjjtrain.kanabco.com/vms/library.html www.immnet.com

www.prototypemagazine.com www.tctmagazine.com

http://www.solidworks.com/sw/products/cfd‐flow‐analysis‐software.htm

www.americanmachinist.com www.azmetalworker.com

www.draftingzone.com www.youtube.com/results?search_query=rapid+prototype

www.magnoliaplastics.com www.precisionboard.com

www.generalplastics.com www.copperstate.com

http://www.freemansupply.com/MSDS/fmsc.htm www.imsmetals.com

www.Cosmosm.com www.solidworks.com

Page 62: Orientation is Required Everyone Submitting · "In theory there is no difference between theory and ... (fixed to the movable table) past a fixed ... milling cutter provides a fast,

June 17, 2010 ASU Instrument and Prototype Machine Shop 62

Cad Workstations

• 4 CAD workstations @ The Shop OfficesR.S.S. Bldg. 2 Room 170B

• 7:00am/3:30pm Monday - Friday

• Questions? [email protected]