124

Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

������������ ���������������������� ��"!�#%$'& ���(�"� ���!�#��!�#)�� *+�%,-�

.0/

1325476 8:9�;=<�9�8?>A@CBEDGFH2I9�>

JLK 25MNMN9�F�OP8*ON25QR>MPS . T 25ONON9 K OUQ�OP6�9WVRFN8 K S 8*OU9YXZ8*4�S�;5O /

2�>A[ 80F�ON2�8*;+X\S�;E]�;I; T 9�>0OWQ*X^O_6�9`F�9�a S�2�F�9 T 9�>0ONM�XbQRFcO_6�9 K 9�VRF�9�9WQ*X

d`@We�fg@Whi@YjlknmYo\p�@W< @Wkcm�q

1�8*r�QRF�s J MNO_FHQR[ 6 / MN254�M

1t8:ruQ�FGkcF�Q*Xb9�MNMNQRFvs=<�ON9�w?9�>xdzy {W8�|�8*;59�F

obQ*|�8C<�O_8*ON9`}Y>�25w?9�F�MN25O /

JWT 9�M�~�oZQ(|�8

���?�0�

e�QR[ / FH2IV�6?O 4� 13254�6 8*9�;=<�9�8?>�@CB�D�F�259�>+~ ���?�?� y J ;5;�FH2IV�6?ONMYF�9�MN9�F�w?9 K y

Page 2: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

252

� FN8 K S 8*ON9We�Q?;5;59�V?9obQ*|�8C<�O_8*ON9`}Y>�25w?9�F�MN25O /

f�6�25MY25M ONQC4�9�F�OU2�X / O_6 8*O�O_6�9�dWQR4�OUQRFN8*; K 2IMUMN9�F�O_8*OU2IQ�>Q*X

1325476 8:9�;=<�9�8?>A@CBEDGFH2I9�>

6 8:M T 9�O�O_6�9 K 25MNMU9�F�O_8*ON25QR>�F�9�a S�2 FH9 T 9�>?OUM Q*X^obQ*|�8z<�O_8*ON9W}Y>�2Iw09�F�MN25O /

e Q TzT 25ONON9�9W139 TC. 9�F

e Q TzT 25ONON9�9W139 TC. 9�F

e Q TzT 25ONON9�9W139 TC. 9�F

e Q TzT 25ONON9�9W139 TC. 9�F

e Q TzT 25ONON9�9W139 TC. 9�F

1�8:ruQRFcknF�Q:X 9�MNMUQRF

j%QRFcO_6�9W1�8*r�QRF�knF�Q0VRFN8 T

j�QRFcO_6�9 � FN8 K S 8*ON9We�Q?;5;59�V?9

Page 3: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

25252

f�Q JWT`/ ~ T`/ |�2EXb9?y

Page 4: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

25w

������������ �������������

��������������� �!�������!�������!���������������!�������!�������!���������!�������!�������!� "�252I2

��#$��%�%&��(' )+*��%�-,/.�0$��)+*213�%#$&l��0�45�6�%�%)+*21 �%�7&��98�#�)+�%&:.�8;���7<

�6�5���������!�������!�������!���������������!�������!�������!���������!�������!�������!� �

� y � o >?O_FHQ K S�4�ON25QR>3yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �

� y>= @Yw?9�FHwR259�|LQ*X�<�ON9�;5;�8?F�?^w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> yWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y @

� y>= y � ?�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>Af�QzO_6�9 J M / T [�ONQ?OU2I4 � 2�8?>?OYDGFU8?>�476 y�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y A

� y>= yB= Dc9 / QR> K O_6�9 J � D yWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �

� y>= yB@ Ci6�25ON9`dW|�8?FuXD?^w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> y`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �FE

� y>@ f�6�9`kcS FN[ Q0MN9�8?> K k�;�8?>Q*X^O_6�25MGC�Q�FIH yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �+J

��#$��%�%&��LK ��,7,!45�:,/<M�%#$&3������.�&N�����!�������!���������!�������!�������!� �FO

= y � o >?O_FHQ K S�4�ON25QR>3yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �FO

= y>= J M / T [�ONQ?ON254`h�9�;�8*OU2IQ�>�M�XbQRFQPSR\13Q K 9`k 9�F�25Q K M yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y ���

= y>= y � h�Q0O_8*ON25QR> 8*;�j F�9�a S�9�>�4 / < [�;525ONON2�>�V yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y ���

= y>= yB= k 9�F�25Q K < [ 8*4�2�>�V yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y = E

= y>= yB@ 13Q K 9`f=FN80[ [�2 >�V yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y = �

= y>@ e�80S�MN9WQ*XnknS�;5M_8*ON25QR> 2�>$Ci6�25ON9WdW|�8?F X�8?> K kcF�9TRUCi6�25ON9`dW|�8?F X^<�O_8?F�MlyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y =V=

= y>@ y � f�6�9�WSRUX�1-9�4�6 8?>�25M T yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y =V@

= y>@ yB= e�Q�FNF�9�;�8*ON25QR>�M . 9�O�|G9�9�>xd`F�25wR2�>�V8?> K @ . MN9�F�w09 K k 9�F�25Q K M yWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y = J

= y J h�8:ON9�M�Q*Xnk 9�F�25Q K eg6 8?>�V?9 yWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y = O

= y>A < S TzT 8?F / y`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y =VY

��#$��%�%&�� Z �%#$& ��0�45�6�%�%)+*21 8[#$)+�%&\.!8]����<��*�. �%�7&g�^8�#�)+��&

.�8;���7<M���5�����_�������!���������������!�������!�������!���������!�������!�������!� = �

Page 5: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

w

@ y � o >?O_FHQ K S�4�ON25QR>3yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y = �

@ y>= f�6�9�����e�9�ON2�<�O_8?FHM yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y @ E

@ y>@ f�6�9Wd`D�� <�O_8?F�M�y�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y @V=

@ y J f�6�9`k������ 8?> K � C��Y2 FHV?2�>�2IM`kcF�9TRUCi6�25ON9`dW|�8?F X^knS�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y @V@

@ y J y � f�6�9 � C� 2�F�V?2�>�25M`<�O_8?Fgk � �?� A �� E @VA yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y @ O

@ y J yB= J <�9�;59�4�ON25QR>�Q*X�k������ <�O_8?F�M y`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y @ �

��#$��%�%&�� � 8[#2,/4Q& &���� �%# ��&�4Q& � �!,z�%& ,/���6&���� ���%) ,!*���,!< 1�8 ��)+�

�6�5���������!�������!�������!���������������!�������!�������!���������!�������!�������!� JVJ

J y � o >?O_FHQ K S�4�ON25QR>3yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y JVJ

J y>= @ . MN9�FHwR2�>�Vf�9�4�6 >�25a S�9�M yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y J A

J y>@ o >?ON9�F T 9 K 2�8*ON9 � C��Y2�F <�O_80F�M yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y J Y

J y>@ y � k � = � @ ��� EVOVO y`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y J Y

J y>@ yB= k � � Y E Y ��J =VY�y`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y A �

J y J ? "RON9�> K 2�>�Vf=FH9�> K M�|�25O_6Afg6�9`e�QRQ0;I9�MUO � C��Y2 FY<�O_8?FYyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y AVY

J y J y � f�6�9�C ?nf d`8*O_8C<�9�O yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y OVE

J y J yB= j+F�9�a S�9�>�4 / o K 9�>?OU2�]�4�8:ON25QR> y`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O �

J y J yB@ k 9�F�25Q K < [ 8*4�2�>�V?MWyWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O A

J y J y J f�6�9�1�8*MNM�8?> K p�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / Q*X�k � E � =V= y`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O Y

J y>A o T [�;52I4�8:ON25QR>�M-yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O?�

��#$��%�%&���� 1-�7,!0�i�%�-, ��&�� ��)+& ��,!< �%#$&l�%0�4 �����%)+*21 �%�7&��98�#�)+��&

.�8;���7<M���5�����_�������!���������������!�������!�������!���������!�������!�������!� O?�

A y � o >?O_FHQ K S�4�ON25QR>3yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O?�

A y>= @ . MN9�FHw?9 K f�9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9`f F�9�> K MYQ*X=O_6�9Ck � �?� A � knS�;5M_8*OUQRF�M3y`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y Y E

A y>= y � 1�8*MNMgdW2IMUO_F�2 . S�ON25QR> y�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y Y E

A y>= yB= k 9�F�25Q K dW25MNO_FH2 . S�OU2IQ�>Ay�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y YV@

A y>@ J ��9�|L<�9�O Q*X^knF�9TRUCi6�25ON9`dW|�8?FuXD?^w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / 1-Q K 9�;5M yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y YVA

A y J <�9�;59�4�ON25QR>�?���9�4�ONM�~Rd`FH2Iw�2�>�V�~�8?> K O_6�9`Dc;�S�9 80> K h�9 K ? K V?9�M y`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y Y O

A y J y � f�6�9C@ . MN9�F�w?9 K�� Dn;�S�9��8?> K�� h�9 K ��? K V09�M yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y Y O

Page 6: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

wR2

A y J yB= f�6�9��iw09�F�M_S�M������-f F�9�> K y`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y Y �

A y J yB@ d`F�25w�2�>�V �+Q�>�9WdW9�[�O_6+~����� ?~�8?> K O_6�9`h 9 K ? K V09zyWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y Y �

��#$��%�%&���� 45,7,���)+*�1 < ,/�N�%#$&3*$&�0�����)+*2, �6) 1-*����%0��7& �!�������!� � J

O y � o >?O_FHQ K S�4�ON25QR>3yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y � J

O y>= �g9�S�O_F�2�>�Qe�QRQ0;I2�>�Vz2�>�knF�9TRUCi6�25ON9`dW|�8?FuX�o\>0ON9�F�25QRF�M yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �VO

O y>@ kcF�9TRUCi6�2IOU9WdW| 80F X�<�9�a S�9�>�4�9�MW|�25O_6 dW2 ��9�FH9�>?O��g9�S�O_F�2�>�Qh�8*ON9�MCyWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y � Y

O y J kcF�Q?M_[ 9�4�ONM�XbQRFc1-9�8:M_S F�2�>�V �g9�S�O_F�2�>�Q e QRQ?;52�>�V�?���9�4�ONM`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y � =

��#$��%�%&���� �60���� �����L��*�.)�� �%4Q) ���%��) ,/*2� ���������!�������!�������!� �VO

Y y � < S TzT 8?F / y`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �VO

Y y>= <�Q T 9 J [ [�;5254�8*ON25QR>�M yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �?�

Y y>= y � �gQR> RuknS�;5M_8:ONQRF�M�|g2IOP6�2 >�O_6�9`o >�MNO_8 . 25;525O / <�O_F�2�[�� y�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �?�

Y y>= yB= f�6�9�d`F�25wR2�>�V 139�476 8?>�25M T h�9�wR25MN25ON9 K yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �?�

Y y>= yB@ f�6�9�j�QRF T 8*ON25QR> 8?> K ?^w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>Q*X Ci6�25ON9`dW|�8?F X=<�O_80F�M yWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �FEVE

Y y>@ f�6�9Wj+S�O_S F�9W2�>A@ . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>-80> K f�6�9�QRF / yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �FE �

Y y J e�Q�>�4�; S�MU2IQ�> yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �FE =

��`��&�*$.�)�� ��#�&�� ����)�� 0�� �%&��7) ,/.\�����!�������!���������!�������!�������!� �FE @

��)+��4 ) ,71-�7��%#�� �!�������!���������������!�������!�������!���������!�������!�������!� �FE A

Page 7: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

w�2I2

��� �D�\�� ���������!�

f 8 . ;59 J y � k 9�FH2IQ K 254�25ON259�MWQ*X�k � = � @ ��� EVOVO X\F�Q T C ?nf d`8:O_8 y`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y A E

f 8 . ;59 J y>= < S�MP[ 9�4�ON9 K k � � Y E Y���� ����� � E k 9�F�25Q K M yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y AVY

f 8 . ;59 J y>@ k 9�FH2IQ K 254�25ON259�MWQ*X�k � E � =V= XZF�Q T O_6�9 C ?nf d`8*O_8C<�9�O yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O @

f 8 . ;59 J y J k 9�FH2IQ K 254�25ON259�MWQ*X�k � E � =V= XZF�Q T ���?�VO <�2�>�V?;59TRu<�25ON9Cd`8*O_8 yWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O J

f 8 . ;59 J y>A k 9�FH2IQ K 254�25ON259�MWQ*X�k � E � =V= XZF�Q T ���?�VE f�|�Q Ru<�25ON9Wd`8:O_8 yWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O A

f 8 . ;59 J y O e Q T [ 8?F�25MNQ�>3Q*X�O_6�9 k � E � =V=k 9�F�25Q K < [ 9�4�OPFNS T |�25O_6)k^8:ONON9�FN>�MWQ*X <�O_FH2I4�O

= ����FE Mn8?> K �FO = J Mn< [ 8*4�2�>�V . 9�O�|�9�9�>�13Q K 9�M^Q*X�e�QR>�MN9�4�S�OU2Iw09 h�8 K 2�8*;+o\> K 9+"�� O Y

f 8 . ;59 J y>Y < S T T 8?F / Q*X �n8?F�2�8 . ;59�k C d k^80FN8 T 9�ON9�FHMGyWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O?�

Page 8: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

wR25252

��� �D� �� � ������� ���

j^25VRS F�9 � y � mg9�F�O���MP[ FNS >�V Ruh�S�MNMU9�;I; K 2�8*V�FN8 T M_6�Q*|�2�>�V>�9�8?F .0/ 8?> KA. F�25VR60O MUO_8?F�M�ych�9�[ F�Q R

K S�4�9 K XZFHQ T o . 9�>� ���?� �� yLyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y J

j^25VRS F�9 � yB= p�Q?V�P ;IQ0V ����� K 2�8*VRFU8 T |�25O_6CO_6�9�Q . MU9�F�w?9 K ;5Q�4�8*ON25QR>�MnQ:X�k C d MNO_80F�M�� d`F�9�2>R

��;59�Fc9�On8*;by ���?�?� y ?nFNFHQRF . 8?F�Mn8?FH9 >�Q?O^M_6�Q*| > . 9�4�8?S�MN9YQ*X OP6�9�2 F�6�S�V?9�9+"�ON9�>0O�s

O / [�254�8*;5; /�� E A32�> ;IQ0V P 80> K�� �FE�TEVEVE�� = E�TEVEVE { 2�> � ��� y ?�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> R

80F / O_FN8:4 H0M�8?F�9YX\F�Q T C�Q�Q K�� j+8?S�; HR>�9�F�� ���?� O ~?MNQ0;I2 K ;I2�>�9�M 8?> K � 8?S�ONMN4�6 /

� ���?� Y ~ K 8*M_6�9 K ;I2�>�9�M y yWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �FE

j^25VRS F�9�@ y � JWT [�;525O_S K 9WM_[ 9�4�O_FN8WQ:X�MU2 " k � � � 80> K � C �Y2�FnMUO_8?F�M�~*2�> QRF K 9�F^Q*X K 9�4�F�9�8*M R

2�>�V � ��� XZF�Q T ONQR[ ONQ . Q?ONONQ T �"XZFHQ T {W8�|�8*;59�F ���?�VO y yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y @VA

j^25VRS F�9�@ yB= k Q�F�ON25QR> Q*X�OP6�9Wj�QRS F�259�F�OPFN8?>�M�XbQRF T Q*Xnk � �?� A � K 8*O_8 XZFHQ T O_6�9 ���0�?� C ?cf

FUS >+~ M_6�Q*|�2�>�VzO_6�9�O_F�2�[�;59�O MNOPFNS�4�O_S F�9YQ*X^O_6 F�9�9 T Q K 9�M�y yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y @VY

j^25VRS F�9 J y � j%QRS F�259�F�O_FU8?>�M�XbQRF T Q*X^O_6�9`k � = � @ � C ?nf K 8:O_8�MN9�O�y yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y JR�

j^25VRS F�9 J yB= C 2�> K Q*| X\S >�4�ON25QR> XbQRF�O_6�9`k � = � @ � C ?cf K 8*O_8�MN9�O�y`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y JR�

j^25VRS F�9 J yB@ j%QRS F�259�F�O_FU8?>�M�XbQRF T Q*X^O_6�9`k � � Y E Y�C ?nf K 8:O_8�MN9�O�y yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y AV=

j^25VRS F�9 J y J C 2�> K Q*| X\S >�4�ON25QR> XbQRF�O_6�9`k � � Y E Y�C ?cf K 8*O_8�MN9�O�y`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y AV@

j^25VRS F�9 J yBA f |GQ MN9�4�ON25QR>�MYQ*X�OP6�9Wj�QRS F�259�FgO_FN8?>0XbQRF T Q*XGk � � Y E Y K 8*O_8�X\F�Q T 2�> K 25w�2 K S 8:;

MU2IOU9�M K S F�2�>�VO_6�9�C ?cf FUS >+~�[�; S�MW13O�y+Dc25V?9�;5Q(| K 8:O_8zOP8VH*9�>OP6 F�9�9 T QR>0O_6�M

;�8*OU9�F�y yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y AVA

j^25VRS F�9 J y O C 2�> K Q*| X\S >�4�ON25QR> XbQRF�O_6�9`k � E � =V=�C ?cf K 8*O_8�MN9�O�y`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O �

j^25VRS F�9 J yBY j%QRS F�259�FgO_FN8?>�M�XbQRF T Q*XnOP6�9�k � E � =V=/C ?cf K 8*O_8 MN9�O��ZS [ [ 9�FY[ 8?>�9�; 8?> K Q*X

MU2 >�V0;I9�MN25ON9 K 8:O_8�X\F�Q T ���?�VO ��;5Q*|�9�F�[ 8?>�9�; y yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y O =

Page 9: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

2 "

j^25VRS F�9�A y � p�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / w?9�FHM_S�M T 8*MUM K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9 K X\F�Q T [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> K 8:O_8 X QRFcO_6�9 H�>�Q(|Y>

� C �Y2�FWMNOP8?F�M`[�;�S�M`O_6�9 k � � � � � e � A E � y�fg6�9zQR[ 9�>t4�2 FH4�;I9F�9�[ F�9�MU9�>?ONM

k � � Y E Y ~*XbQRF�|Y6�2I4�6OP6�9`[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>MUO_FNS�4�O_S F�9W25MWS >�4�9�F�O_8*2�>+y'y�yWyWy`yWyWy�y YV=

j^25VRS F�9�A yB= k Q�F�ON25QR>3Q*X�O_6�9 ;IQ0V�P ;5Q?V�� ��� [�; 80>�9 M_6�Q*|�2�>�V�k C d 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / O_FN8:4 H0M

. 8:MN9 K QR> o\< }�? �Y@Cynf�6�99�FNF�Q�F . Q "R9�MCXbQRF�9�8*4�6�MUO_8?F K 9�F�25w?9X\F�Q T [ 9�F�25Q K

MP[ 8*4�2�>�V 4�Q TC. 2�>�9 K |g2IOP6M_[ 9�4�O_F�Q?MN4�Q�[�2I4�8:;I; /�K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K � � � yGy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y YV@

j^25VRS F�9�A yB@ p�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / � K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9 K S�MN2�>�VzO_6�9`[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�> K 8*O_8 w?9�F�M_S�M K Q T 2�> 8?>0O�[ 9TR

FH2IQ K X QRF�O_6�9�H�>�Q*| > � C �Y2�FcMNO_8?F�Mn[�;�S�M�OP6�9 k � � � � � e � A E � y=f�6�9gQR[ 9�>

4�2�F�4�;59zF�9�[ F�9�MU9�>?ONMYk � � Y E Y ~:X QRF | 6�25476xO_6�9`[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>xMNO_FNS�4�O_S FH9W2IMWS >�4�9�F�O_8:2 >+y�Y J

j^25VRS F�9�A y J fg6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*; ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / XZS >�4�OU2IQ�>�M�~*;5Q?V�� ��� ~�XbQRF O�|�Q K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O^MU2 >�V0;I9TR T 8*MNM

[ QR[ S�;�8*ON25QR>�MYQ*Xnk C d MNO_8?FHM�y�y`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y YVY

j^25VRS F�9�A yBA 1�8 "�2 T S T PSR T Q K 9 [ 9�F�25Q K ~ ���� ?~ w?9�F�MPS�M � ��� XbQRFWO_6 FH9�9 k C d 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>

MU9�a S�9�>�4�9�MYQ*X K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T 8:MNM�y^f�6�9`8 . MNQ0; S�OU9�>�QRF T 8*;52 ��8:ON25QR>Q*X O_6�9Ww?9�F�ON254�8*;

8 "R25M�25MW8?F . 25O_FN8?F / ~ . S�OYO_6�9`F�9�;�8*OU2Iw09�[ Q0MN25ON25QR>Q*X^O_6�9W4�S F�w09�M�25M >�Q?O�y�y`yWyWy�y Y �

j^25VRS F�9�A y O d`FH2Iw�2�>�V`MNOPF�9�>�V?O_6+~���������� E ~�X QRF�XbQRS F K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T Q K 9�;%MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�MG8*O^O_6 FH9�9

K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9CON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9�M�y �^9�FHON254�8*;=;52�>�9�M�FH9�[ F�9�MN9�>0O O_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T

PSR T Q K 9 [ 9�F�25Q K ~%>�QRF T 8*;52 ��9 K OUQ �FEVE E M�2�> O_6�9 E AVY ��� T Q K 9�;�8*O �+J J ~ EVEVE {Cy �VE

j^25VRS F�9 O y � ?�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / O_FU8*4 H0MWXbQRF�O_6 F�9�9 E BO ��� T Q K 9�;GMU9�a S�9�>�4�9�M |�25O_6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O

2�> [ S�OW>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q[ F�Q K S�4�OU2IQ�>AFN8*OU9�M�y^f�6�9`S [ [ 9�FY8?> K ;5Q*|�9�FcO_FN8*4+H?Mg|G9�FH9 4�8*;>R

4�S�;�8*OU9 K |g2IOP6-FU8*ON9�M�QR>�9TR\OP6�2 F K 80> K OP6 F�9�9`ON2 T 9�MWOP6�9�>�QRF T 8*;=FN8*OU9�M�� T 2 K K ;59

OPFN8*4+H ~ F�9�MP[ 9�4�ON25w?9�; / y yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �?�

j^25VRS F�9 O yB= hg8*ON25Q`Q*X�O_6�9Y>�9�S�O_F�2�>�QC; S T 2 >�Q0MN25O / ONQ`O_6�9Y[ 6�Q?ONQR>C;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / 8*Mn8YX\S >�4�ON25QR>

Q:X � ��� ~ X QRF O_6 F�9�9 EBO � � T Q K 9�;�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�MW|�25O_6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O 2�> [ S�OW>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q

[ FHQ K S�4�ON25QR>�FN8*ON9�M�y y�yWyWy`yWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �?�

j^25VRS F�9 O yB@ j+FN8*4�ON25QR>�Q*X�ONQ?O_8:;�>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 4�QR>0O_F�2 . S�ON9 K).0/ O_6�9z[�; 8:M T QR>�80> K

. FH9 T MNMNO_FU8?6�;�S >�V [ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M�~ 8*M�8�X\S >�4�ON25QR> Q*X � � � ~?XbQRFcO_6 F�9�9 EBO � � T Q K 9�;

MU9�a S�9�>�4�9�MY|�25O_6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q[ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR>AFN8:ON9�M�y yWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y �VE

Page 10: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

"

j^25VRS F�9 O y J fg6�9�F T 8*;*MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9n8*O�OP6 F�9�9 K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O�9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / MNOP8*V?9�M�~���� � � �+J E�TEVEVE {

�ZS [ [ 9�F`[ 80>�9�; ~ � E� EVE E { � T 2 K K ;59[ 8?>�9�; ~^8?> K @ E� E EVE { ��;5Q(|�9�FW[ 8?>�9�; ~

XbQRF EBO � � T Q K 9�;IMW|g2IOP6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q[ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR>3FN8*ON9�M�yiyWy`yWyWy�y � �

j^25VRS F�9 O yBA ?�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>xQ*X � � � |�25O_6 ON2 T 9WXbQRF�OP6 F�9�9 EBO � � T Q K 9�;�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�M |�25O_6 K 2EX R

Xb9�F�9�>0O�2�> [ S�O >�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q [ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR>�FN8*ON9�M�y3yWyWy�yWyWy`yWyWy`yWy�yWyWy`yWyWy�y � =

j^25VRS F�9 O y O hg8*ON9WQ*Xn[ 9�F�25Q K 4�6 8?>�V?9 X QRF E>O � � T Q K 9�;5M |�25O_6 K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O >�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q FN8:ON9�M�y � @

Page 11: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

"R2

�$ ���� �� ����� � ��� �������

���� ������� �������������������� �"!��"��#$�&%'�����()�*��+,�.-/���0��1�*�2(�%0�3�" ������5436

7 m�9�F T 8?>139�;5w�2I;5;59?~98 �1:/;=<>�+/?�@3A5BDC�AFE

1 / X\8�w?QRF�25ON9WMUONQRF�259�M�;59�8�w?9 T 9W|�QR> K 9�F�2�>�VF�25VR60O S [ ONQzO_6�9W;�8*MUO [ 8*V?9`6�Q*|iO_6�2�>�V?MY|�25;5;=OPS FN> QRS�O�~

. S�O`8�XbON9�F�|�8?F K MgO_6�9`9�> K 2�>�VAMU9�9 T M 2�>�9�w�25O_8 . ;59?y�fg6�9 [ 8:O_6Ao�OUQRQ H OUQzO_6�9C4�Q T [�;59�ON25QR>�Q*X�O_6�25M O_6�9�MU2IM

|�8*MW8?>A8�|�X\S�;=;5Q?OY;52 H*9zMNQ T 9`Q*XnO_6�Q0MN9`MNOUQRF�259�M�yY1�8?> /K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O`[ 9�QR[�;59C4�QR>0O_F�2 . S�ON9 K OUQzO_6�9C4�S FNF�9�>0O

M_6 8?[ 9 Q:X T�/ ;52EX 9?~�80> K O_6�Q�S�VR6zo 4�8?>+B Oc2 T 8*V?2�>�9W25O�O_S FN>�2�>�VCQRS�OG8?> / Q?O_6�9�F�| 8 / ~�o HR>�Q*|lOP6 8*OGo |�QRS�; K

>�Q?O 6 8�w?9`80FNF�25w?9 K 6�9�F�9�|�25O_6�QRS�O�O_6�9`S > / 2I9�; K 2�>�VAMPS [ [ QRF�OgQ*X�9�w09�F / Q�>�9WQ*X�OP6�9 T y

o ;59�8?FN>�9 K 8:MNO_F�QR>�Q T`/ XZF�Q T O�|�Q T 8*MNOU9�F�MzQ*X OP6�9AO_FN8 K 9?~n<�ON9�w?93{W8�|�8*;59�FC8?> K e�6 F�25M e�;59 T 9�>�M�y

f�6�9 / 4�QRS�; K >�Q?O . 9 T QRF�9 K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O�2 >tO_6�9�2�F�80[ [ F�QR8*4�6�9�MWONQMN4�259�>�4�9 �b8?> K ONQ;52EXb9 ~ . S�O . Q?O_6 . 8*MN9

O_6�9�2�F�;59�MNMNQ�>�M�QR>8 XZS > K 8 T 9�>?OP8*;�F�9�M_[ 9�4�OgXbQRF�8?> K 6�Q�>�9�MNO / 8 . QRS�O�O_6�9W4�FN8�XbO�Q*X=MN4�259�>�4�9?y5?n8*4�6 9+"�4�9�;IM

2�> K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O�|�8 / MG8*O�M_6�Q*|�2�>�V T 9YO_6�9W9+"ROU9�>?O�Q*X T�/ 25VR>�QRFN80>�4�9`8?> K O_6�9Y; 8:4 HCQ:X�[ Q?;525M_6x2 > T�/ |�QRF H�y

<�Q T 9�OU2 T 9�M O_6�9C6�25VR6�MNO_8?> K 8?F K M�O_6�9 / F�9�a S�2�F�9 K Q*X T 9`;59PX O T 9`8 . 25OYM_6�QR4+H*9 K 8?> K 4�6 8*VRF�2�>�9 K ~�S >0ON25;

oWF�9�8*;52 ��9 K O_6�9 / 6�9�; K 9�w?9�> 6�2IV�6�9�FCMNO_8?> K 80F K MWXbQRFWOP6�9 T MN9�;5w?9�M�yAfg6�9 /). Q?OP63;52 H:9ONQAM_8 / O_6 8*O�| 6 8*O

O_6�9 /�K Q2IM �2��#G; 8*MNOPF�QR>�Q T�/ ~ . S�O oUB w?9z>�9�w?9�FYMN9�9�>�O�|�Q [ 9�QR[�;59 T QRF�9�2�>3;5Q(w09�|g2IOP6AOP6�9�2 FY|�QRF H O_6 8?>

<�ON9�w?9 8?> K e�6 F�25M�yzj^2�> 8*;5; / ~^o�;59�8?FU>�9 K X\F�Q T O_6�9 T OP6 8*OWMN4�259�>�4�9 FH9�MNONM`S�;5ON2 T 8*ON9�; / S [ QR> T 9�OP6�Q K y o

K QR>+B O T 9�8?>�O_6�9 / O_80S�VR6?O T 9CO_6�9z<�4�259�>?OU2�]�4 139�O_6�Q K ~�<�ON9�[�M � O ~ . S�OWOP6 8*O OP6�9z|�8 / |�9C8?[ [ F�QR8*4�6

[ F�Q . ;59 T M�~n8?> K O_6�9 |�8 / |�9 4�Q TzT 2�>�254�8*ON9| 6 8:O`|�9z] > K ~cS�;IOU2 T 8*ON9�; / K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9�MzQ�S F`MPS�4�4�9�MNMz8*M

MN4�259�>0ON25MNONM�y oC6 8�w09A83;5QR>�V)|�8 / ONQ V?Q . 9PXbQRF�93o T 8:MNON9�FCO_6�9 T 9�O_6�Q K M Q*XWMN4�259�>�4�9?~ . S�O o�Q*|�9O_6�9

K 2�F�9�4�ON25QR>3oNB T O_8VH02�>�VzONQ*|�8?F K O_6�25MYV?QR8*;+ONQ <�ON9�w?9`8?> K e�6 FH2IM�y

o 4�QRS�; K >�Q?O`6 8�w?9 T 8:2 >0O_8*2�>�9 K T�/ MNO_S K 259�MC8*M`8VRFU8 K S 8*ON9CMNO_S K 9�>0OW2�>�8*MNOPF�QR>�Q T�/ |�25O_6�QRS�O�O_6�9

M_S [ [ QRF�OWQ*X T`/ |�2EX 9?~ J T�/ yz< 6�9 6 8 K OP6�9 S >�9�>?w�2�8 . ;59 OP8*M HQ:XG|�8*25ON2�>�V| 6�25;59 . Q?O_6�QRS FgX\8*ON9�MW|�9�F�9

K 9�4�2 K 9 K�.?/ a S 8*;52E]�9�FY9+" 8 T 4�Q TzT 25ONON9�9�M 80> K O_6�9�MN25M�4�Q TzT 2IOUON9�9�M 8?> K 6�2�F�2�>�V 4�Q TzT 25ONON9�9�M�~ 8:;I; . 8*MN9 K

Page 12: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

"�2I2

QR>3|�QRF HM_6�96 8 K >�Q�4�QR>?OPF�Q?;^Q*w?9�FY9+"�4�9�[�O`2�>�MPS [ [ QRF�O�Q*X T 9?ym�9�F 4�8?F�9�9�F�6 8*M�8*OW;59�8*MUO`O_6�9zMP8 T 9

[ F�Q T 2IMU9 8*M T 2�>�9?~ / 9�O`M_6�96 8*M . 9�9�> S >�MN|�9�F�wR2�>�V32�>)6�9�F�|�25;5;52�>�VR>�9�MNM ONQA8*;5ON9�FC6�9�F`8 TC. 25ON25QR>�MCMNQ3o

4�QRS�; K ] >�25M_63MN4�6�QRQ0; y J > K X\FN8?> H0; / ~+M_6�9`25M T QRFH9WX\S >AOP6 8?>A8?> / QR>�9W9�;5MN9 o H�>�Q*|`y mgQ*|i4�QRS�; K o�6 8�w?9

4�Q T 9WOP6 F�QRS�VR6 |�25O_6�Q�S�O�O_6 8*O �

fg6�9 ;525MNOYQ*X�[ 9�Q�[�;I9�| 6�Q K 9�MN9�F�w?9W4�Q Ru8?S�O_6�QRF�MP6�2 [ Q�>zO_6�25M�OP6�9�MN25M . 8*MN9 K QR> O_6�9�2�F�4�QR>0O_F�2 . S�ON25QR>�MYONQ

T�/ 4�QR>0ON2�>�S�9 K 6�QR[ 9 8?> K MP8?>�25O / V?9�OUMW;IQ�>�V-8*OWO_6�25Mz[ Q02 >0O�~ 8?> K 25O`9+"�ON9�> K MWX\8?F . 8*4 Hx2�>�ON2 T 9?y f�6�9

] F�MNOgOu|�Q [ 9�QR[�;59zo�F�9 T 9 TC. 9�Fg9�>�4�QRS FN8:V?2�>�V T 9�2�>MN4�259�>�4�9 8?FH9 T`/ X\8*O_6�9�Fg8?> K-T�/AT Q?OP6�9�F�B McXZ8:O_6�9�F

� � FN8?> K [ 8`@CB dW9�9�VR8?> y 1 /CK 8 K O_8?S�V�6?O T 9 OUQ`[�; 8 / 4�6�9�MNM�| 6�9�> o |�8*MnMN2 "+y^o ;I9�80FN>�9 K XZFHQ T 6�2 T O_6�9

r�Q / Q*X MNQ?;5wR2�>�Vz[ F�Q . ;59 T M�~�8?> K | 6�9�> o |�8*McO�|G9�;5w?9YQRF�O_6�2�F�ON9�9�>6�9YVR8�w?9 T 9W8WON9�;59�MN4�Q�[ 9?y�<�QRQR> 8�XbON9�F�~

o`80> >�QRS >�4�9 K ONQ3O_6�9 XZ8 T 2I; / ��ONQ�O_6�9 4�6 8*VRFH2 > Q:X T 8?> / O_6 8*OzoY|�8*MCV?Q?2�>�V3ONQ . 98?> 8*MNOPF�QR>�Q T 9�Fvy

� FU8?> K [ 8�MNO_8?F�OU9 K MN9�> K 2�>�V T 9 . Q�Q H0MzQR> 8*MUO_F�QR>�Q T�/ O_6 8*Ozo 9�8*V?9�F�; / F�9�8 K � oWMUON25;I;Y6 8�w09A8*;5;GOP6�Q?MN9

. Q�Q H0M�ynp+Q0ONM�Q*X H?2 K MW[�;�8 / VR8 T 9�M�|�25O_6 O_6�9�2�F K 8 K 8?> K ;5Q�Q H O_6 F�QRS�VR6 OU9�;I9�MU4�QR[ 9�MW|�25O_6�Q�S�O . 9�4�Q T 2 >�V

MN4�259�>0ON25MNONM�~ . S�O�XbQRF T 9?~%O_6�Q?MN9W;525ONON;59CO_6�2�>�V?M 7 4�6�9�MNMW8?> K 8:MNO_F�QR>�Q T`/ . Q�Q H?MY8?> K 8COU9�;I9�MU4�QR[ 9 7 F�9�8:;I; /

4�6 8?>�V?9 K-T�/ ;52EXb9?y

oZO�B MA8 T 8 ��2�>�Vl| 6 8*OV0QR9�M2�>0ONQ 8 O_6�9�MU2IM�y f�6�9�F�9?B MA<�ON9�w?9)e�80FNF�B M[ Q�9�O_F / ~`80> K h�254 H @Yw?9�FHONQR>

;525MNON9�>�2�>�VCONQ T�/ |�QRFNF�259�M�8?> K MN9�;EX R K QRS . OcXbQRF�] XbON9�9�> / 9�8?FHM�~?8?> K T�/�. FHQ?O_6�9�F�Mne�6 FH2IM�8?> K f�2 T M T 2I;52�>�V

| 6�25;59�;59�ONON2�>�V T 9 FU8 TC. ;I9�8 . QRS�O^M_S >�MN9�OUMn8?> K O_6�9�4�Q?;5QRF�M^Q*X�FN8*2�> . Q*|�M�~?8?> K X\S >`|g2IOP6�eg6RS�4+H C 2�> F�25476+~

132 H*9�<�2�> K�. 9�FHV�~=8?> K 132 H:9�8?> K 1�8?F�2�> 8 h�9�9 K y f�6�9C| 6�Q0;I9Cf�9+" 8*M�C ?nf VRF�QRS [+~ dWQ�>A8?> K ? K 8?> K

<�4�Q?O 80> KJ ONM_S H*Qz8?> K f�Q K K 8?> K�� S K 2b~ >�9�w09�FcXZ8:2I;59 K ONQzO_F�9�8:O T 9W;I2 H*9 XZ8 T 25; / ~%8?> K O_6�9 / 8?F�9`8*;5|�8 / M

F�9�8 K / |�25O_6z4�6�Q?254�9YMNONQRF�259�M�8 . QRS�O T�/ VRFN8 K S 8:ON9 8 K w�25MNQRF�M�ycp+9�9 J > >�9 C 25;I;5MNQ�>+~�kn6�25; J [ [�;59�ONQ�>+~ egS F�O

<�O_FNS�4+H%~ hgS�MNM p�8�w?9�F / ~01�8?FIHzD�FN8?>�MHX QRF K ~RDc9�> dW9�6 >�9�F�~ �n8*MNMN25;525M eg6 8?F T 8?> K 80F�25M�~ 8?> K OP6�9 F�9�MUOGQ:X=O_6�9

obQ*|�8W<�O_8*OU9 8:MNO_F�QR>�Q T`/ X\8*4�S�;5O / 8?> K VRFN8 K S 8*OU9GMUO_S K 9�>?OUMnO_8?S�V�6?O^8?> K M_S [ [ QRF�ON9 K T 9 K S F�2�>�V`MU2 " / 9�8?F�M

Q*X�VRFN8 K S 8*OU9�MU476�Q�Q?;byC1 / S > K 9�FHVRFN8 K S 8*OU9 8 K wR25MNQRFv~�d`F�y�h�9�2 T 80> >+~�80> K O_6�9zF�9�MNOWQ*X�O_6�9zVR80>�V . 8*4 H

8*O DcQ?25MN9C<�O_8*ON9?~ 6�9�;�[ 9 K�T 9W|Y6�9�>Aoc|�8*M_>+B O�M_S F�9W|Y6�9�F�9�o T 25VR6?O . 9`6�9�8 K 9 K 2�>x;I2EXb9?yGp�9�MN;52I9z{W8�|�8*;59�F

r�Q?2�>�9 K <�ON9�w?9Y2 > 6�9�;�[�2�>�V T 9Y| 6�9�> o |�8*M �3����#*#G;�K Q*| >+~�QR>�4�9WS [ QR>8 ON2 T 9?y^1 / XZ8 T 25; / ~%8?> K T�/ |�2EXb9

JWT`/ B M X\8 T 25; / ~ >�9�w?9�F X\8*25;59 K 2 > O_6�9�2�FnMPS [ [ QRF�Oc9�w?9�>C| 6�25;59WO_6�9 /zT S�MNOn6 8�w?9�|�QR> K 9�F�9 K 2�X=o |�QRS�; K���!"�"�

] >�25M_6 MN4�6�QRQ0; ycf�6�9 . 9�MNO�|�8 / o 4�8?> O_6�2�> HzQ*X�ONQ�O_6 8?> HC9�w09�F / . Q K / 2IMgONQW] >�25M_6 MN4�6�Q�Q?; 8?> K V?9�O�8�r�Q . y

mg9�F�9WV?Q�9�M�y

Page 13: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

"R25252

���$�D� ���$ ��

@W>�9WQ:X�O_6�9W;59�8*MUO S > K 9�F�MUONQRQ K 8*M_[ 9�4�ONMYQ*X=| 6�25ON9 K | 80F X�9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 25M O_6�9`[ FHQR4�9�MNM .0/ | 6�254�6O_6�9 /

8?F�9 X Q�F T 9 K yWf�6�9C2�>�2IOU2 8:;nMNO_8:V?9�M Q:Xn| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F Xn9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>-80F�9`4�6 8?FN8*4�OU9�F�2 ��9 K).?/ 6�25VR6t; S T 2 >�Q0MN25O / ~

6�25VR6W9 ��9�4�ON25w?9cON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S F�9?~*8?> K 2 >�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�V?; / 6�2IV�6WM_S F X\8*4�9cVRFN8�wR25O / ~ T 8 H?2�>�VY2IO K 2 � 4�S�;5O^ONQ�4�QR>�MUO_FN8*2�>

O_6�9�2�F�[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M�O_6 F�Q�S�VR6CO_FN8 K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;�M_[ 9�4�O_F�Q?MU4�QR[�254WQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M�y C 9 8?F�9W8*2 K 9 K ~ 6�Q(|�9�w?9�Fv~ .0/ O_6�9

X\8*4�O�O_6 8*O T 8?> / [ F�9TR\| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM �bk C dWM 8?F�9 T S�;5ON2�[ 9�F�25Q K 254�P R T Q K 9W[ S�;5M_8*ONQRFHM�y^f�6�9�MN9WMNO_80F�M^X\8*;5;

2�>?OUQ�O�|�Q`4�;�8*MUMN9�M�~�O_6�9Yw(8?F�2�8 . ;59C[�; 80>�9�O_8?F / >�9 . S�;�8 >RS�4�;59�2 �Zk � � � 8?> K O_6�9 � > 8 H*9 K � � C��Y2 FcMNOP8?F�M�y

knS�;5M_8:ON25QR>�Mn2�> k C dWM�[ FHQ(w�2 K 9 8`S >�25a S�9 Q�[ [ QRF�OPS >�2IO / ONQ`[ F�Q . 9�O_6�9�2�F^2�>0ON9�F�25QRF�M�~0| 6�25476 8?F�9�Q?OP6�9�F�|�25MN9

2�> 8*4�4�9�MN2 . ;59zONQ K 2�F�9�4�OgQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>+y�} >0ON25;=>�Q*|`~ 6�Q*|G9�w09�F�~�O_6�9`> 8*O_S F�9WQ:X�O_6�9`[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> T 9�476 80>�2IM T ~

O_6�9 [ FH9�4�2IMU9 . QRS > K 8?FH2I9�M Q*X�O_6�9z2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNOPF�2�[+~�80> K O_6�9 T 8*MNM K 2IMUO_F�2 . S�ON25QR> Q*X�O_6�9k C dWMW|�9�F�9

4�Q T [�;59�ON9 T�/ MNOU9�F�259�M�y fg6�9�MN9-[ F�Q . ;I9 T M T S�MNO . 9-8 K K FH9�MNMN9 K . 9PX Q�F�9|�9A4�8?> 8?[ [�; / H�>�Q*|�;59 K V?9AQ*X

[ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�Vk C dWM�ONQC2 T [ F�Q*w?9`S > K 9�FHMNO_8?> K 2�>�VQ*X=|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F X X Q�F T 8*ON25QR>+y

fg6�2IM�O_6�9�MU2IMg; 8 / M�O_6�9WVRF�QRS > K |�QRF HWXbQRF�X\S�O_S F�9YO_6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*;+2�>0w?9�MNON25VR8*OU2IQ�>�MGQ:X=O_6�9�MN9WMNOP8?F�M�y C�9`S�MN9

Ci6�Q?;59�?c8?F�O_6f�9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9CQ . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>�M�ONQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9`O_6�9 T 8*MNM 80> K ; S T 2 >�Q0MN25O / Q*X^O_6�9 T 8*r�QRF�25O / Q*X

O_6�9 � C �Y2 Fc[ S�;5M_8*ONQRFHM�y C 25O_6 O_6�9�MN9�Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>�M�~?|�9�2 K 9�>?ON2EX / O_6�9�4�Q TzT QR>C[ F�QR[ 9�FHON259�MG8?> K OPF�9�> K M

k C dWM�9+" 6�2 . 25O`8*MY8C4�;�8*MNM�y

C 9 ] > K O_6 8*O [ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�M�Q*X ;5Q*| T 8:MNM�6 8�w09n6�2IV�6�9�F�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / ~?MPS�V?V?9�MNON2�>�V�OP6�9nFN8?>�V?9^Q*X 2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O /

25Mn6�25VR6�; / T 8*MNM9R K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>?O�ycf�6�9�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K O_FH9�> K Q*X K 9�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V`[ 9�FH2IQ K Mn|g2IOP6 K 9�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�V`;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O /

T 8*OU476�9�Mn8 K 9�4�F�9�8*MN9g2 > O_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T O_6�9�Q�F�9�ON254�8*; P R T Q K 9�[ 9�F�25Q K 8*4�4�F�Q0MNM^O_6�9�2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_F�2�[+y C�9

M_6�Q*|iO_6 8:O�O_6�9�FH9 K 9 K V?9`4�8?> . 9�4�8?S�MN9 K�.?/ O_6�9�;I9�>�V0O_6�9�>�2�>�VQ*X�OP6�9 K F�25w�2 >�VOU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59 . 9 / QR> K O_6�9

T 8 "�2 T S T M_S�MUO_8*2�> 8 . ;59z[ 9�F�25Q K y fg6�2IM`FH9�M_S�;5O 25MWV?9�>�9�FN8:;+X Q�F�25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR> R . 8:MN9 K3K F�25wR2�>�V T 9�476 8?>�25M T M�~

8?> K 25OW9+" [�;�8*2�>�M�OP6�9 T 8*MNM R K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>�4�9 Q*XGO_6�9 F�9 K 9 K V?9?yzf�6�9z9+" 8*4�OWQ . MN9�FHw?9 K X QRF T Q*XGO_6�9 T 8:MNM9R

K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>�4�9[ F�Q*w�2 K 9�MC8 wR25O_8:;=MNOP8?F�ON2�>�V[ Q?2�>0OWXbQRF�X\S�O_S F�9CO_6�9�Q�F�9�ON254�8*;^2�>?w09�MNON25VR8*ON25QR>�MWQ:XGO_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V

Page 14: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

"�2Iw

T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T y C 9 8:;IMUQWM_6�Q*| O_6 8*O^O_6�9 . ;�S�9 9 K V09 [ F�Q . 8 . ; / F�9 T 8:2 >�M�S > K 9�ON9�4�ON9 K . 9�4�8?S�MN9YQ*X MU9�;I9�4�OU2IQ�>

9 ��9�4�ONMG80F�25MN2�>�VzQRS�OnQ:X�FN8?[�2 K 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y^j^2�> 8*;5; / ~�|�9�MP6�Q(| O_6 8*O�O_6�9�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K FN8*ON9gQ*X�[ 9�FH2IQ K 4�6 8?>�V?9

2�> 4�Q�Q?; � C �Y2�FA[ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M|�25;5;W4�QR>�MNO_FU8*2�>i>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Ql9 T 2IMUMN25QR> 2�> O_6�9�2�F 4�QRF�9�M�~ 80> K |�932 K 9�>?OU2�X /

8?[ [ F�Q�[ F�2�8*ON9WO_8?FHV?9�ONMcX Q�FcXZS�OPS F�9WQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>+y

Page 15: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

������!�7� � � � � � �$�� �� � � � ������� � � �D��� �F� ��� ������� � ���

� � � � � �D��� � �

��� �) ��2��;�������#G�5%� %/�� ��1+/�����)���� � ��#G�����#G�0����� �� �%��D+,����D���(�%�����:F� 4�4"4 6

7 J ;EX\F�9 K p�QRF K f�9�> > / MNQ�>+~ �� 8 �" ������*�2 ���4�� 4��04 @3A5B�����E

����� �������� "!$#&%'��() ��

fg6�9 K 9�w09�;IQ�[ T 9�>?O�Q*X�8*;5;WMN4�259�>0ON2E]�4�]�9�; K M�~YX\F�Q T 8*MNOPF�QR>�Q T�/ ONQ ��QRQ0;IQ0V / ~YV?9�>�9�FN8*;5; / [ F�QR4�9�9 K M

O_6 F�Q�S�VR6)FH9�4�Q?VR>�2 ��8 . ;59MNO_8*V09�M�y �g9�| [ 6�9�>�Q T 9�> 838?F�9 ] F�MNO`4�8:O_8*;5Q?V?9 K 8?> K QRF�VR8?>�2 ��9 K 2�>?ONQ3VRFHQRS [�M

M_6 8?FH2 >�V 4�Q TzT QR> 4�6 8?FN8*4�ON9�FH2IMUON254�M�y J M K 8*O_8 . 8*MU9�M VRFHQ(|�~�S > K 9�F�; / 2�>�V 2�>?ON9�FUF�9�;�8*ON25QR>�M_6�2�[�M-80F�9 K 2IM R

4�Q*w?9�F�9 K |�25O_6�2�>�8?> K 8 T QR>�V K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O�VRF�QRS [�M�y j^2 > 8:;I; / ~ 9�>�QRS�VR6t2 >0XbQRF T 8*ON25QR>38*4�4�S T S�;�8*ON9�MWONQ X\S�9�;

MN9�8?FH476�9�MYXbQRFW8?> K OU9�MNONMWQ*X�V?9�>�9�FN8*;nFNS�;59�M�O_6 8*O`S >�2EX / O_6�9 Q . r�9�4�ONMWQ*XGMUO_S K / 2 >0ONQA8 4�QR6�9�FH9�>?O�| 6�Q?;59?y

Ci6�9�>�O_6�25M ;59�8?[ 7 X\F�Q T 4�8*OP8*;5Q?V?2�>�V OUQ MN4�259�>0ON2E]�4zS >�2�]�4�8:ON25QR> 7 O_8VH*9�MC[�;�8*4�9?~�>�9�|iX\F�QR>0ON259�F�MYQ*XnMNO_S K /

2�>�9�wR25O_8 . ; / QR[ 9�> O_6�9 T MN9�;5w?9�M OUQ�2�>�a S�2�F / y J [ [�;5254�8*ON25QR>�M38?F�9 XbQRS > K ONQ)8?F�9�8:M [ F�9�w�2IQ�S�MN; / O_6�QRS�V�6?O

S > F�9�;�8*ON9 K ONQzO_6�9`[ 6�9�>�Q T 9�> 8 FH9�4�9�>?ON; / S >�2E]�9 K y ��9�| ]�9�; K M 8?FH2IMU9?~�8?> K OP6�9`[ F�QR4�9�MUM F�9�[ 9�8:ONM�y

fg6�2IMY25M�O_6�9�MNONQRF / Q*X�Q�>�9`M T 8:;I;�MNON9�[ ONQ*|�8?F K S >�2E]�4�8*ON25QR>�2�>A8�]�9�; K ;59�MNM OP6 8?> O�|G9�>0O /z/ 9�8?FHM�Q?; K y

f�6�9CVRF�Q�S [AS > K 9�FYMNO_S K / 25M`8 4�;�8*MNMYQ*XnMNO_8?FHM�4�8*;5;59 K O_6�9z[ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�VA[ F�9TR\| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�y+*Af�6�9�MU9�MUO_8?F�M

M_6�Q*|l[ 9�FH2IQ K 254 . FH2IV�6?O_>�9�MUMnw(80F�2�8*ON25QR>�MGS [ ONQ 8gXb9�| [ 9�F�4�9�>0OnQ*X+O_6�9�2�F ONQ?O_8*; . F�25VR60O_>�9�MNM ��2�>C| 6�25ON9�;525VR60O

QR>�ON2 T 9�MN4�8:;I9�M XZFHQ T T 2�>RS�OU9�M`S [3ONQ8*; T Q?MNO`8?>36�QRS Fvy�}Y>?OU2I;nFH9�4�9�>?ON; / ~�;I25ONOU;I9 |�8*M HR>�Q*| >38 . QRS�O`8*;5;

. S�O`Q�>�9 7 k � �?� A � R E @VA ~+O_6�9z4�;�8*MUM [ FHQ?ONQ?O / [ 9?y�C 25O_6�OP6�2IM�|�QRFIH%~�|�9C9+" 8 T 2 >�9 Q?O_6�9�F T 9 TC. 9�F�M�2�>

K 9�O_8*25;b~�8?> K [ F�Q*w�2 K 9W8C[�254�O_S F�9WQ*X�O_6�9�2�F�VRFHQRS [z[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M�ynfg6�2IMg2 >�9�w�25O_8 . ; / ;59�8 K M�ONQz>�9�| a S�9�MNOU2IQ�>�M�~

8?> K |�9W|�25;5;�80>�MN|�9�F�MNQ T 9WQ:X=O_6�9 T y,.-0/�1)/325476./�158�9:/�;=<./"6?>�/&2�@�1)A5BDC�EGFIH�J�47AK1MLOND1)/�PQ9R>�ST6./&UD9R2K1.4.V W

Page 16: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

=

J ;5; MN2�>�V?;59�MNO_80F�M . QRFN>�|�25O_6�;59�MNMnOP6 8?>W9�25VR60O^ONQWON9�> ON2 T 9�MnO_6�9 T 8:MNM=Q:X�QRS F^< S >�|�25;I; . 9�4�Q T 9G|Y6�2IOU9

K |�8?F X�MNO_80F�M�y � < S�476 MNO_80F�M`9�w?Q0;Iw09 O_6 FHQRS�VR6 T S�;5ON2�[�;59MN9�F�259�MzQ*X�9+" [ 8?>�MN25QR> 8?> K 4�Q�>?O_FU8*4�ON25QR> . 9PXbQRF�9

[ 8*MNMU2 >�V O_6 F�QRS�VR6 OP6�9W9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / MNO_8:V?9 FH9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ON9 K-.0/ OP6�9`[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V k C dWM�y dWQ 8:;I;�M_S�476 MUO_8?F�M

. 9�4�Q T 9z[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V-k C dWM�~ QRF K QMNQ T 9�9�>?ON9�FgO_6�9C| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X^MNO_8*V09`a S�2I9�OU; / � o\>�Q?O_6�9�Fg|�QRF K M�~ 2IM

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 8>�9�4�9�MNM_80F / [ 6 8*MN9z4�8?S�MU9 K).?/ 4�Q�Q?;52�>�VAO_6 F�Q�S�VR6�8?> � 2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / MUO_F�2�[+~ �A8*M�2IO�25MWXbQRFYO_6�9

4�Q�Q?;59�FWd J |Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F XbM`[ 8*MNMN2�>�V3O_6 F�QRS�V�6AOP6�9 � �le 9�ON2^MNO_F�2�[ � j�QR>0O_8*2�>�9z9�OC8*;by ���?� = � � F�9�9�>�MUON9�2�>

���?� = �f�6�9�F�9C8?F�9`>�QR> Ru[ S�;5M_8:ON2�>�VAk C dWM�~�MNQ T 9`80[ [ 8?F�9�>0ON; / 2 K 9�>0ON254�8*;=MP[ 9�4�O_F�Q0MN4�QR[�254�8*;5; / OUQ/H�>�Q*| >

[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M � C�9�FN>�9�Fv~�m�9 . 9�F�~ � mYS >�V?9�F ���?� �� y`m�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~%M_S F X\8*4�9zOU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9z8?> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 7| 6�254�6F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0O 8�MNO_8?FvB MG8?[ [ FHQ "�2 T 8*ON9Y9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / MNO_8:O_S�M 7 8?F�9 K 2 � 4�S�;5O OUQ T 9�8*M_S F�9gX Q�FG8Ck C d

MNO_80F�y=k 9�FN6 80[�M T QRF�9 [ F�9�4�25MN9 T 9�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0ONM�|�25;I; K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 O_6 8:OnO_6�9W[ S�;5M_8*ONQRFHMG6 8�w?9�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9�M

QRF�;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IOU2I9�M K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O�X\F�Q T O_6�Q0MN9WQ*X^O_6�9`>�QR> Ru[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M�y

J >�Q?O_6�9�Fg[ Q?MNMU2 . 25;525O / 25M OP6 8*O�[ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�MgM_6 8?F�9`8C4�Q TzT QR> 4�Q T [ Q?MN25ON25QR>+~+8C476�9 T 2I4�8:; � MN25VR> 8*OPS F�9��

XbQRF [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>+yzf�6�25M . 9�8?F�MWQR>�O�|�Qza S�9�MUON25QR>�M�y�j^2 FHMNO�~�8 4�6�9 T 254�8*;^MN25VR> 8*O_S FH9 T 2IV�6?O`[ F�Q*w�2 K 9 8 4�;�S�9

ONQ�O_6�9 4�80S�MN9 Q:X=O_6�9�2�F�[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>+y�<�9�4�QR> K ~�2�Xn[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�MG8?FH9�XbQRS > K ONQ�F�9�[ FH9�MN9�>?O�QR>�; / 8WM_S . MU9�OGQ:X=O_6�9

MNO_80F�M K 9�MNOU2 >�9 K OUQ . 9�4�Q T 9W| 6�25ON9 K | 80F X M�~?O_6�9�>7HR>�Q*|�;59 K V?9YVR8*2�>�9 K 8 . QRS�OnOP6�9 [ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M T 25VR60OG6 8�w?9

T QRFH9W;I2 T 25ON9 K 8?[ [�;5254�8*ON25QR>�ONQCa S�9�MNON25QR>�MYQ*X^| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X X QRF T 8*ON25QR> 2�>V?9�>�9�FN8:; y

Ci6 8*OYO_6�9�>+~ 8?F�9CO_6�9zO_FUS�9 [ 80FN8 T 9�ON9�FHMW| 6�25476 K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9z| 6�254�6�k C d MNO_8?FHM`[ S�;IMP8*ON9 �if�6�25M�2IM

O_6�9C] FHMNO`a S�9�MNON25QR> |�9�|g2I;5;�8*ONOU9 T [�OWONQ-80>�MN|�9�F�~�O_6 FHQRS�VR6�O_6�9zMNOPS K / Q*XGMU9�w?9�FN8*;^2�> K 25wR2 K S 8*;Wk C dWM

M_[ F�9�8 K Q*w?9�FC8�;�8?F�V?9FN8?>�V?9Q:X ;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / 8?> K 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9 ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9?y C 25O_6�OP6�2IM 4�; S�9�2�> 6 8?> K ~

|�9A6�QR[ 9�ONQ�] > K O_6�9�4�Q TzT Q�> O_6 F�9�8 K Mz|Y6�2I4�6 . 2�> K O_6�9-[ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�Mz2�>0ONQ)83VRFHQRS [+y C�9|�25;5;W8*;5MNQ

9�>�4�QRS >0ON9�F�MN9�w09�FN8*;�>�9�|ia S�9�MNON25QR>�M [ Q?MN9 KA.0/ O_6�9WS >�S�M_S 8*;=> 8*OPS F�9 Q:X�O_6�9�MU9WMNO_8?F�M�y6C�9WM_6 8:;I;�MN9�9WO_6 8*O

8*;5;^Q*XnO_6�9Ca S�9�MNON25QR>�M`8?FH9�F�9�;�8*ON9 K ONQ O�|�QzX\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*;^[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M�sgO_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�VQ*X�[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>�2�>3O_6�9

MNON9�;5;�8?Fg2�>?ON9�FH2IQ�F�~�8?> K O_6�9CF�9�M_[ QR>�MN9WQ*X^O_6�9WMNO_80F�ONQCO_6�25M K FH2Iw�2�>�V�y

@W>�9Q:X O_6�9A[ FH2 T 8?F / V?QR8*;5MzQ*XYO_6�25M 2�>0w?9�MNON25VR8*OU2IQ�>+~nO_6�9�FH9PX QRFH9?~n25MzONQ 8 K K F�9�MNMzOP6�94�8?S�MN9Q*XWO_6�9

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 8:; K F�25wR2�>�V S�MU2 >�V OP6�9A4�;�S�9�M-[ F�Q*w�2 K 9 K .0/ OP6�9AQ . MN9�FHw?9 K [ F�QR[ 9�FHON259�MQ*X`O_6�9AV�F�QRS [+y]C�9

|�25;5;n9�w*8*;�S 8*ON9CQRS FW8?>�MN|�9�F�M . 8:MN9 K QR>36�Q(|L|�9�;5;^O_6�9 / 8*4�4�Q�S >?OYXbQRFgO_6�9CQ . MN9�F�w?9 K XZ8*4�OUM�y J K K 25ON25QR> 8*;

Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�Mz8?> K OP6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*;�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�Mz|g2I;5; . 9A>�9�9 K 9 K ONQ3ON9�MNOCQRS F�6 / [ Q?OP6�9�MN25M�~G80> K |�9 |�25;I;��� /�1)C��TA59 E 2�<.<�<.6.2K1)<09 S����78�>=A59R/�� /�158�6.2��/"E 25BDC 6?STE /3<�6?>=/"@�;D1.1)/�BD6 2��/"AK4 6?>=/ ;DB�S�� /�1)<./ 6.A UDA <.A�V

Page 17: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@

M_S�V?V09�MNO 6�Q*| MNQ T 9WQ*X^O_6�9�MN9 T 2IV�6?O . 9`4�8?FUF�259 K QRS�O�y

�g9�| HR>�Q*|�;59 K V?9 Q*XbON9�>t] > K M 8?[ [�;5254�8*ON25QR> 2�> S >0XbQRF�9�MN9�9�> 8?F�9�8:M�yAj+F�Q T QRS F�[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> MUO_S K 259�M�~

|�9C|�25;I;�[ F�9�4�25MN9�; /)T 9�8*MPS F�9zO_6�9 T 8*MUM`8?> K ; S T 2 >�Q0MN25O / Q*XG2�> K 25wR2 K S 8*;�k C d MNOP8?F�M 7 |�25O_6�MNQ T 9zS > R

9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K 2 T [�;I254�8*OU2IQ�>�M�y f�6�9�MN9 T 9�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0ONMz8*;5;IQ*|'S�MzONQ T 8VH*9[ F�9�4�25MN9�4�; 8:2 T M 8 . Q�S�O 8�MNOP8?F�B M

9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / MNOP8*O_S�M�y�o >AOP6�9`4�8*MN9CQ*XG8:O�;59�8*MNOWQR>�9Ck C d MNOP8?F�~�F�9�MPS�;IOUMYXZF�Q T QRS FY[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�MNOPS K 2I9�M

2�> K 254�8*ON9z25ONMY9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>�25M K Q T 2�> 8*ON9 K�.0/ >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q9 T 25MNMN25QR>+y�Ci6 8*O�25M T Q�F�9?~�MU2 >�4�9C25O`[ S�;5M_8*ON9�M�~�|�9

4�8?> 2�> OP6�9�QRF / K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9A25ONM FN8*ON9 Q*XW9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> X\F�Q T 4�6 8?>�V?9�Mz2�> 2IOUM [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ 9�F�25Q K y < S�4�6 8

T 9�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0O�|�QRS�; K F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0O OP6�9Y] F�MNO�ON9�MUOGQ:X�MNOP8?> K 8?F K ;59�[�ONQR>xO_6�9�QRF / 2�> K 9�>�MN9C[�;�8*M T 8 y

��� � ����I���&(���� ��0��� �����R�����0 ���#"��() ��

<�OP8?F�M�4�QR>0O_8*2�>z|g2IOP6�2 >xO_6�9 T 8CF�9�4�QRF K Q*X=O_6�9�2�FY[ F�25QRFc9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y�m�25MNONQ�F�254�8*;5; / ~%|�9`6 8�w?9 FH9�8 K O_6�25M

F�9�4�QRF K .0/ T 9�8*M_S F�2�>�V�O_6�9�2�F�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / ~ ��~^OP6�9�2 F 9 ��9�4�OU2Iw09ON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9?~�� � � ~n80> K O_6�9�2�FCM_S F X\8*4�9

4�Q T [ Q?MN25ON25QR>+y�13QRF�9CF�9�4�9�>0ON; / ~�|�9`6 8�w?9`;59�8?FU>�9 K OUQ K 9�;5w?9`2�>0ONQ OP6�9`2�>?OU9�F�25QRF [ FHQR[ 9�F�OU2I9�MWQ:X�[ S�;5M_8*OU2 >�V

MNO_80F�M`S�MN2�>�V3O_6�9 OUQRQ?;5M�Q*X 8*MUON9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V / ��ONQ . 9 K 25MN4�S�MNMU9 KlT QRF�9CX\S�;5; / 2�>�O_6�9e�6 8?[�OU9�F%= y�C�9

6 8�w?9zO_6�9�> 2�>0ON9�FN[ F�9�OU9 K O_6�9�MU9 Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>�M S�MU2 >�V MNON9�;5;�8?F T Q K 9�;5M�y�@WS FCS > K 9�F�MUO_8?> K 2�>�V�25M 8*;5|�8 / M

2�>�4�Q T [�;59�ON9?~ 8?> K 2�> T 8?> / 4�8*MN9�MYQRS F T Q K 9�;5M�[ F�9 K 254�O . 9�6 8�w�25QRF`>�9�w09�FYQ . MN9�F�w?9 K 2�>3F�9�8*;^MNOP8?F�M�yY@W>

O_6�9YQ?O_6�9�Fc6 8?> K ~�O_6�9�MNO_80F�MnMNQ T 9�ON2 T 9�M . 9�6 8�w?9 2�> |�8 / M^|�9 80F�9 S > 8 . ;I9YONQCF�9�[ F�Q K S�4�9W2 > QRS F T Q K 9�;5M�y

mgQ(|�9�w?9�Fv~ K 9�MP[�2IOU9 T 8?> / F�9 T 8*2�>�2�>�V [ FHQ . ;59 T M�~+8`V09�>�9�FN8*;=[�254�O_S F�9C6 8*M�9 T 9�FHV?9 K y��

j^25VRS FH9 � y � M_6�Q*|�M�O_6�9Gm Ruh K 2�8*VRFN8 T X QRF�MNO_8?F�M�2 >�O_6�9^MUQ?;�8?F=>�9�25VR6 . Q�FN6�QRQ K �"X\F�Q T o . 9�> ���?� � y�f�6�9

T Q?MUO�MNO_F�2 H02�>�VzXb9�8*O_S F�9W2�>xO_6�25M [�;5Q?O�Q:X�;5Q?V � w?9�FHM_S�M�;5Q?V � � � 25MYO_6�9 K 2�8*V0QR> 8*;�MNOPF�2�[ Q*X�MUO_8?F�M FUS > >�2 >�V

X\F�Q T S [ [ 9�Fg;59PX OYONQC;5Q(|�9�F�FH2IV�6?O�~ H�>�Q*| >8*M�O_6�9`1�8*2�><�9�a S�9�>�4�9 ��1�< y f�6�9�MU9�8?F�9YMNO_80F�M�| 6�25476+~%;52 H:9

QRS FY< S >+~ . S FU>-6 /�K F�Q?V?9�> �bm a S�2I9�MU4�9�>?ON; / 2 >�O_6�9�2�FY4�QRFH9�M�y�<�O_8?F�MY2�>O_6�9zm Ruh K 2�8*V�FN8 T QRS�ONMN2 K 9CO_6�9

1�< K 9�FH2Iw09 O_6�9�2�F�;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / 2�>zQ?OP6�9�Fn|�8 / M�y=f�6�9�MU9 |�9�F�9W8*;5;�QR>�4�9W1�<CMUO_8?F�M�~ . S�O�6 8�w�2�>�VzS�MN9 K OP6�9�2 F

4�QRF�9 m MPS [ [�; / ~ O_6�9 / ;59PXbO`ONQA[ S F�MPS�9 Q?OP6�9�F T 9�8?>�M`Q:XGM_S [ [ QRF�O�8:VR8*2�>�MNOWVRFN8�w�25O / yzfg6�9z476 80FN8*4�ON9�FYQ*X

O_6�9�MN9WMPS [ [ QRF�O T 9�476 80>�2IM T M�~ 4�Q TC. 2�>�9 K |�25O_6 O_6�9 T 9�O_6�Q K M .?/ |Y6�2I4�69�>�9�FHV / 25M�OPFN8?>�M_[ QRF�ON9 K ONQCO_6�9

MNON9�;5;�8?FgM_S F X\8*4�9?~ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9�M | 6�9�FH9W2 >xO_6�25M K 2�8*V�FN8 T MNOP8?F�M�Q*Xn8CV?25w?9�> T 8*MUM F�9�MN2 K 9?y

?c8*4�63MNO_8*V09zQ*X�9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 25M�4�6 8?FN8:4�ON9�F�2 ��9 K .0/ 8 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T 9�8?>�M�Q*X�MNO_8�wR2�>�V3Q � VRFN8�w�2IOP8*ON25QR> 8*;

���=AK1"2 E A51)/$@ A�E$ND1)/�>=/�B�<?S�� / �/�B=/�1)2 � U�ST<.@�;=<.<?STAKB�AK4 <.6./ ���T2K1 /���A� ;�6?STA5B'8 <./ / 47A51"/���2 E$N �T/�����/)B������ �!�#" 25B�U -02KB=<./�B$&% 259R2 �T/�1'���(� � )*"�V

Page 18: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

J

j^25VRS F�9 � y � m�9�FHO���M_[ FNS >�V RuhgS�MNMN9�;5; K 2�8*VRFU8 T M_6�Q*|�2�>�V>�9�8?F .0/ 8?> K'. F�25VR60O)MNOP8?F�M�y h�9�[ FHQ K S�4�9 KXZFHQ T o . 9�> � ���?� �� y

4�Q?;5;�8?[�MN9?y @W>�9zQ*XGOP6�9 . F�QR8 K 9�FYV0QR8*;5MW2�>�O_6�9CMNOPS K / Q:XGMNON9�;5;�8?F 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>�6 8*M . 9�9�>3OUQ2 K 9�>0ON2EX / 8?> K

4�6 8?FN8*4�ON9�FH2 ��9�O_6�9�MN9�M_S [ [ QRFHO T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T M�y J >�Q?OP6�9�F�25M`S > K 9�F�MNOP8?> K 2�>�VQ*X�9�>�9�FHV / O_FN8?>�MP[ QRF�Og|�25O_6�2�>

O_6�9YMNON9�;5;�8?F�2�>0ON9�F�25QRF�ynDcQ?OP6�H02�> K M�Q*X�S > K 9�F�MUO_8?> K 2�>�V 8?F�9W>�9�9 K 9 K OUQ�S >�2EX / O_6�9 T�/ F�2�8 K H02�> K M�Q*X=MUO_8?F�M

|�9�Q . MN9�FHw?9�2�>?OUQ 8 MN2�>�V?;59 4�Q�>?ON2�>�S�QRS�M�476 8:2 > Q*X�MNON9�;5;�8?Fc9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+~�Q*X�| 6�254�6zOP6�9 k C dWM T 8VH*9 S [ QR>�9

M T 8:;I; . S�O�wR25O_8:;�;52 > H%y

Page 19: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

A

' � K6� ' &g& !+�b�+ ��"!�# �c!� *+� �� � ,��� �!% ����21 �"�+#� ��C���+#��0

Ci6�9�>�8 T 8*2�>WMU9�a S�9�>�4�9�MNO_80F+9+" 6 80S�MNONM 2IOUM�mtXZS�9�;b~02IO 4�8?>�>�Q�;5QR>�V?9�F T 8*2�>?OP8*2�>`8Y[ F�9�MNM_S F�9cVRFN8 K 259�>0O

O_6 8*OY25M`M_S � 4�2I9�>0OWONQA[ F�9�4�25MN9�; / |g2IOP6�MNO_8?> K VRFN8�w�25O / yWoZONMW4�QRF�9 . 9�V02 >�M�ONQ4�QR>0O_FN8*4�OWF�9�;�8*ON25w?9�; / FN8?[�2 K ; /

MNQ8*MYONQ FU8*25MN9�FN8:2IMU9�OP6�9`2�>?OU9�F�25QRFYON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S F�9?~+8*MYVRFN8�w�2IOP8*ON25QR> 8*;=[ Q?ON9�>0ON2�8*; 9�>�9�F�V / 25MW4�QR>0w?9�F�OU9 K ONQ

6�9�8*O�ycf�6�9WMNO_8?Fc;59�8�w?9�MYO_6�9W1�<8*O >�9�8?F�; / 4�QR>�MNO_80>?O�;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / ONQ*|�8?F K ;5Q*|G9�Fg8?> K ;5Q(|�9�F � � � y�fg6�2IM

K 9�4�F�9�8*MU9z2�>3ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S F�9 6 8*;5ONMW|�25O_63O_6�9 QR>�MN9�OWQ*X�4�QR>?w09�4�ON25QR>32�>3O_6�9z9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9?~=|Y6�2I4�634�8?> T S�4�6

T QRFH9G9 � 4�2I9�>0ON; / O_FN8?>�MP[ QRF�On6�9�8:O XZF�Q T O_6�9�4�QRFH9�ONQYO_6�9�M_S F X\8*4�9?y j F�Q T OP6�2IMn[ Q?2�>?OcQR>�O_6�9�MNOP8?F�9�w0Q?;5w?9�M

ONQ6�25VR6�9�FW;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 8*OW8*; T Q?MNOY4�QR>�MNO_80>?O�� ��� 8:;IQ�>�VO_6�9 � FH9 K V02 80>?O . FN80>�476 � �bh � D Q*XnO_6�9zm5Ruh

K 2�8*VRFN8 T yGfg6�9`MNO_80F�25M >�Q*|i4�Q�Q?;59�F �b8*O�O_6�9�M_S F X\8*4�9 ~ T Q�F�9W;�S T 2�>�QRS�M�~�8?> K XZ8?F ; 80F�V?9�FgO_6 8?> | 6�9�>�25O

;59PX OYO_6�9W1�<+y J O�O_6�25MW[ Q?2�>0O�~ K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O O_6�2�>�V?MY6 8?[ [ 9�> K 9�[ 9�> K 2�>�VQR> OP6�9 T 8*MNM�Q:X�O_6�9WMUO_8?F�y

o >MNOP8?F�M 8 . Q*w?9�8 . QRS�O � � � ~%4�9�>0O_FN8*;�OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9�MY9�w?9�>?OPS 8*;5; /3. 9�4�Q T 9 6�25VR6�9�>�QRS�V�6ONQ . S FU>

6�9�;52�S T �Zm�9 2�>0ONQA4�8?F . QR> �be 80> K Q " / V?9�> �b@ ~�6 8*;5ON2�>�V�4�QR>?OPFN8*4�ON25QR>�2�>3O_6�9z4�Q�F�9?y�<�Q�QR>39�>�Q�S�VR6+~

4�QRF�9Cm�9�25M 9+" 6 8?S�MNON9 K ~+8?> K O_6�9Ce��?@L4�QRF�9�4�QR>0O_FN8*4�ONMYS >?ON25;^6�Q?O�9�>�QRS�V�6AOUQ . S FN>2�>0ONQ 9�w?9�>A6�9�8�w�2I9�F

9�;59 T 9�>0ONM�yWf�6�9�[ FHQR4�9�MNMW4�Q�>?ON2�>�S�9�M�~+;59�8 K 2�>�VONQ8 f / [ 9�o�ogM_S [ 9�FU>�Q(w*8z9+" [�;5Q?MN25QR>+y`fg6�9`9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>�Q*X

6�25VR6 T 8*MNMgMNO_8?F�Mg2IM`80>2�>?OPF�25VRS�2�>�V ]�9�; K Q*XnMUO_S K / ~ . S�OYM_S�4�6MNOP8?F�M K QR>+B O T 8VH*9�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX M�y�j+F�Q T

6�9�F�9�QR> |�9W|�25;I; O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9WF�9�MNOPF�254�O QRS F�8*OUON9�>?OU2IQ�> ONQzO_6�9WQ?OP6�9�F �VE�� QRF�MUQzQ*X^MNO_8?F�M�| 6�254�6 K Q�y

Ci6 8*O�6 8?[ [ 9�>�M OUQzMNO_8?FHMG|g2IOP6 T 8*MNM . 9�;5Q(| � ��� |Y6�9�>O_6�9�2�F�4�QRFH9WON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9�M . 9�4�Q T 9C6�2IV�6

9�>�QRS�VR6xONQz25VR>�25ON9zmg9 K 9�[ 9�> K M�QR> | 6�254�6AQ:X�O�|�Q K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O T 9�8?>�MgQ*XnM_S [ [ Q�F�O 8:VR8*2�>�MNO�VRFU8�w�25O / O_6�9 /

9 T [�;5Q / 8*O�O_6�9`OU2 T 9?yG<�O_80F�M�8 . Q*w?9`8 . QRS�O�= y>= = @ � � 8?F�9WM_S [ [ QRF�ON9 K3.?/ 2 K 9�8*; VR8*M�[ F�9�MNM_S FH9�8*O mg9

25VR>�25ON25QR> �bo . 9�> � h�9�> ��2�>�2 ���?� @ yce�QRF�9�4�QR>?OPFN8*4�ON25QR>6 8*;5ONMY2�>3F�9�M_[ Q�>�MN9`ONQ O_6�9�>�9�|L9�>�9�F�V / MNQ�S F�4�9?~

8?> K O_6�9 MNO_8?F 9�>?ON9�FHM�8?>�Q?OP6�9�F�FH9�; 8:ON25w?9�; / MNO_8 . ;59A[ 6 8*MU9 Q*X�4�QRFH9 >�S�4�;59�8?F . S FN>�2�>�V�MN2 T 25;�8?FCONQ�O_6�9 m

. S FN>�2�>�V31�<+y Ci6�9�>�8*;5;�8�w*8*25;�8 . ;59 mg9z6 8*M . 9�9�>34�QR>0w?9�F�ON9 K ONQAe 8?> K @C~+O_6�9z4�QRF�9C4�QR>0O_FN8:4�ONMWQR>�4�9

8*VR8:2 >+~0O_6�9Y9�>?w?9�;5QR[ 9 9+" [ 8?> K M�~ 8?> K O_6�9�MNO_80F^QR>�4�9 8:VR8*2�>C4�;52 T�. MgONQ*| 80F K O_6�9WF�9 K V02 80>?O . FN8?>�4�6+y�fg6�2IM

MNO_8:V?9C2IM�4�8*;5;59 K O_6�9 8*M / T [�ONQ?ON254CV?2�8?>0O . FN8?>�4�6 � J � D y Ci6�25;59 4�Q�F�9zON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9�M`>�9�w?9�F`F�25MN9 6�2IV�6

9�>�QRS�VR6 ONQ�2IV�>�2IOU9WO_6�9 e��?@ 4�QRF�9?~04�QRF�9Y4�Q T [ 8*4�OU2IQ�> 8?> K O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9gMNON9�;5;�8?F�FN8 K 2�S�M�8?> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / 8*;5;

. 9�4�Q T 9 T S�4�6 VRF�9�8*ON9�FcO_6 80> K S F�2�>�VO_6�9`[ F�9�w�2IQ�S�M F�9 K V02 80>?O . FU8?>�476[ 6 8:MN9?y

<�OP8?F�MC|�25O_6 T 8*MNM . 9�;5Q*| 8 . QRS�O�= yB= = @ � � 2IV�>�2IOU9-mg9A8*OzO_6�9ON2�[ Q*X OP6�9V?2�8?>?O . FN8?>�4�6 2 > 8

4�QRF�9MPS [ [ QRF�OU9 K >�Q?O .0/ >�QRF T 8*;�VR8*M [ F�9�MUM_S F�9 . S�O .?/ 9�;59�4�O_F�QR> K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8*4 / [ F�9�MUM_S F�9?y m�9�F�9�O_6�9

Page 20: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

O

FN8?[�2 K ; / 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V9�>�9�F�V / QRS�OP[ S�OGQ:X�mg9`F�9�8*4�ON25QR>�Mg4�8?> >�Q?O �b8:OG;59�8*MUO�2�>�2IOU2 8:;I; / K F�25w?9`80> 9+" [ 8?>�MU2IQ�>

Q*XWO_6�94�QRF�9?~ . 9�4�80S�MN9AO_6�93[ F�9�MNM_S FH9A[ F�Q*wR2 K 9 K .0/ K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8*ON9 T 8*ON9�FH2 8:; K 9�[ 9�> K MQR>�; / |�9�8VH?; / QR>

ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9?y�fg6�2IM�4�QRS�; K. 9 K 25M_8*MNO_FHQRS�M^XbQRF ;5Q*| T 8*MUMGF�9 K V02 80>?OcMNO_8?F�M�y=f�6�9Y4�QRF�9 FH9 T 8*2�>�Mn4�Q T [ 8*4�O

8*M�OP6�9`9�>�9�F�V / V?9�>�9�FN8:ON25QR>AFN8:ON9 2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9�M�y�o\>�F�9�M_[ QR>�MN9?~ O_6�9�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S F�9`FH2IMU9�M FN80[�2 K ; / ~+2�>�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�V

O_6�9`>�S�4�;59�8?F FH9�8*4�ON25QR>FN8*OU9�M�~ | 6�254�6 X\S F�O_6�9�F�2�>�4�F�9�8*MU9`O_6�9WON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9?y J O_6�9�F T QR>�S�4�;59�8?F�FNS > 8�|�8 /

T S�MNO�Q�4�4�S F�y

q^9�OzF�9�8:;nMNO_80F�M�8?[ [ 80F�9�>?OU; / K QR>+B O K 9�MNO_F�Q / O_6�9 T MU9�;Iw09�M 8*OCO_6�25MCMNO_8*V?9?y$C�9�HR>�Q*| O_6�25M . 9�4�8?S�MU9

|�9zQ . MN9�FHw?9C;IQ*| T 8*MNMWMNOP8?F�MW| 6�254�6 T S�MNOC6 8�w09 [ 8:MNMN9 K O_6 FHQRS�VR63O_6�9 V?2�8?>?O`[ 6 8:MN9?~^S > K 9�F�V?QR>�9 O_6�25M

� 6�9�;52�S T�� 8:M_6+~ �z8?> K >�Q*|iF�9 T 8*2�>w09�F / T S�476 2�>0O_8*4�O�y^oZO�25M�O_6�QRS�VR60O�O_6 8*O�MNO_80F�M�[ F�Q . 8 . ; / O_FN8?>�M_[ QRF�O

9+"�4�9�MNM`9�>�9�F�V / 8�|�8 / X\F�Q T O_6�9C25VR>�25ON25QR> MN25ON9CwR2�84�Q�>?w?9�4�OU2IQ�>+y �g9�S�O_F�2�>�QA9�>�9�FHV / ;5Q?MNMU9�MWM_6�QRS�; K 4�Q�Q?;

O_6�9C4�9�>0ON9�F�~%2 > K S�4�2�>�V�8 ON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9C2�>?w09�F�MN25QR>�2�>3O_6�9`4�Q�F�9?yWf�6RS�M`mg9C25VR>�25ON25QR>32�>�;IQ*| T 8:MNM MUO_8?F�M

O_8VH:9�M [�;�8*4�9WQ � R\4�9�>0ON9�F�~�4�;5Q?MN9�FcONQCO_6�9W4�Q�>?w?9�4�OU2Iw09 9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9?y�f�6�25M�25M�QR>�9WQ:X=MN9�w?9�FN8:;�4�8*MN9�Mg| 6�9�F�9YQRS F

O_6�9�QRFH2I9�MYQ*Xn;59�[�ONQR>�2�>0ON9�FN8*4�ON25QR>�MW8?F�9�4�FNS�4�2�8*;^ONQzMUON9�;5; 80FW8*MNO_F�Q�>�Q T�/ yndW9�V?9�>�9�FU8*ON9 T 8*OU9�F�2�8*;b~+| 6�25476x2IM

6�25VR6�; / 4�Q�> K S�4�ON25w?9?~ K QR9�Mz>�Q?O�M_S [ [ QRFHO`4�QR>0w?9�4�ON25QR>+yAfg6�9 [ F�9�MN4�F�2�[�ON25QR>�M 9 T [�;5Q / 9 K 2�> T Q?MNOWMNOU9�;I;�8?F

T Q K 9�;�4�Q K 9�M ONQ K 9�MN4�FH2 . 9C4�QR>?w09�4�ON25w?9W9�>�9�F�V / O_FN8?>�MP[ QRF�O�8?> K3T 2 "R2�>�V�~%6�Q(|�9�w?9�Fv~ 80F�9 ���)�D��+ 8*O . 9�MUO�~8?> K O_6�9`9+" 8*4�O F�9�8:MNQR>MUO_8?F�M�M_S F�w�25w?9CO_6�25M MUO_8*V?9WQ*X^9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>�25MW>�Q?O�|�9�;5;�S > K 9�F�MUONQRQ K y�obOY|�QRS�; K-. 9

6�9�;�[0XZS�;gONQ K 2�F�9�4�ON; / 4�QR>0X\F�QR>0O�Q�S FWO_6�9�QRFH2I9�M |�25O_6�Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�MCQ*X�MNO_8?F�MCS > K 9�F�V?Q?2�>�V�OP6�9 mg9 � 8:M_6+y

< S�4�6Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�M T 25VR6?Og9�w?9�>A[ F�Q*w�2 K 9WON9�MNONM�Q:X K 2 ��9�FH9�>?OYO_6�9�QRF�259�M�Q:X�>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q[ 6 / MN254�M�ycm�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~

O_6�9 6�9�;52�S T�� 8*MP6325M`w�2 FHO_S 8*;5; / 8?>�2�>�MNO_80>?O_80>�9�QRS�M`9�w?9�>0O`2�> O_6�9z;52EX 9 Q*X 8 MNO_80F�~=8?> K |G9 6 8�w09 / 9�O`ONQ

H�>�Q(|g2 >�V0; / Q . MN9�F�w?9WQR>�9 � 2 >xO_6�9`8*4�O�y �

j%Q?;5;5Q(|g2 >�V 4�QRF�9Cm�9C25VR>�25ON25QR>+~+O_6�9�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S F�9�9�w?9�>0O_S 8*;5; / F�25MN9�M`6�25VR6�9�>�QRS�VR6xO_6 8*OW>�QRF T 8:;�VR8*M

[ F�9�MNMPS F�9 . 9�4�Q T 9�MW2 T [ QRF�O_80>?O�~�80> K OP6�9 [ FH9�MNM_S F�9C2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�M�~ K F�25wR2�>�VA4�Q�F�9C9+" [ 8?>�MU2IQ�>�8?> K O_6�9�>3F�9TR

M_S�;5ON2�>�V2�>�O_6�9�F T 8*;^F�9�VRS�;�8*OU2IQ�>QR>�4�9 T QRFH9?y�m�9�;52�S T . S FN>�2�>�V4�QR>0ON2�>�S�9�M T QRF�9�QRF�;59�MNMW8*MY25O K QR9�MY2�>

O_6�9z6�25VR6�9�F T 8*MUM MNOP8?F�M K 2IMU4�S�MNMN9 K 8 . Q*w?9?~�|g2IOP6-8 M_6�9�;5;nQ:XGm . S FN>�2�>�V-[ F�Q*w�2 K 2�>�V38 K K 25ON25QR> 8*;^9�>�9�F�V /

8*O�O_6�9Y4�QRF�9TR\9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9�2�>?ON9�FuXZ8*4�9?y J O�O_6�25M [ Q?2�>?OgO_6�9 [ Q?MNO9Ru6�9�;52�S T�� 8*M_6 MNO_8?F�F�9�MN2 K 9�M�Q�>zO_6�9WMUQ R\4�8*;5;59 K

mgQRF�2 ��QR>0O_8*;=D�FN8?>�4�6 �bmYD Q*X^O_6�9`m5Ruh K 2�8*VRFN8 T yn@ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�MWQ*Xn6�QRF�2 ��QR>0O_8*; . FN80>�476xMNO_8?F�M�;59�> K S�M

4�;�S�9�M 8 . QRS�O T 8?> / K 2 ��9�F�9�>?OW8*M_[ 9�4�ONM�Q*X^MNON9�;5;�8?F�9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y���3H / 251)/ 25STU�/3U S B 6?>�/)S 1 <.6?;=UDC �DC 6?>�/�>�25N�NDC @�S 1)@�;=E <.6.25B�@3/&6?>=2�6R<.A E / -���<.6.2K1)<RND; �T<.2 6./�VR>=/�1)/ 251)/ 6Q9RA"6?C�N�/ <�A54

ND; �T<.2 6?S B <.6.251)<�S B 6?>DST< 1)/�KSTA5B�A54 6?>�/&-�P�� U ST2�K1)2�E� �6?>�/������'C�1)2 / �52K1.ST2#� �T/ <$A5B 6?>=/$-���N�1)A5N�/�158 2KB=U 6?>�/"1)/3@3/�BD6 �TC

Page 21: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

Y

<�OP8?F�M K Q->�Q0OW2 > V?9�>�9�FN8:;n9�w?Q?;5w?9 8*;5QR>�VAO_6�9 m D K S F�2�>�V34�QRF�9zmg9 . S FU>�2 >�V%y fg6�9 / 9�w0Q?;5w?9 K Q*| >

X\F�Q T O_6�9WV?2�8?>0O . FN8?>�4�6+~�8?> K OP6�9`[ 8?F�ON254�S�;�8?F�M_[ Q?O�O_6�9 / |�25;5;=Q�4�4�S [ / 8*;5QR>�V O_6�9`m D K 9�[ 9�> K MWQR> O_6�9

T 8*MUM^Q*X O_6�9�m 9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9Y;59PX On8 . Q*w?9�O_6�9 mg9�4�QRF�9?y f�6�9�M T 8:;I;59�F�O_6�9�9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9?~�O_6�9�6�25VR6�9�F^OP6�9�M_S F X\8*4�9

ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9`8?> K O_6�9YX\8?F�O_6�9�F�OUQ�OP6�9W;I9PXbOYO_6�9WMNO_8?F�F�9�MU2 K 9�MYQR> O_6�9`mYDYy�<�O_8?FHM 8:O�O_6�9YX\8?F�9�> K Q*X^O_6�9

mYD 6 8�w?9Ww�2�F�O_S 8*;5; / >�Q mi;59PXbO 8*O�8*;5;by

d`S�9gONQ`O_6�9W[ Q�QRF�9�F�9�>�9�F�V /z/ 259�; K Q*X=m�9 . S FN>�2�>�V�~ 8?> K O_6�9 6�25VR6�9�Fc;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / ~ MNOP8?F�M^M_[ 9�> KAT S�4�6

;59�MNMnOU2 T 9�QR>CO_6�25M�m�9 �_T 8:2 > MN9�a S�9�>�4�9���O_6 8?>CQ�>`OP6�9�1�<+y*j�QRF 2�>�MNO_80>�4�9?~R8WO / [�254�8*; � � � MNOP8?F M_[ 9�> K M

�FE * � / 9�8?F�M �b8 . QRS�O �VE�� Q:X 25ONM ONQ?O_8*; X\S�MN25QR> . S FN>�2�>�V�9+"�25MNON9�>�4�9 Q�>3O_6�91�< . S�OCQR>�; / 8 . QRS�O �FE��

/ 9�8?FHM�QR> O_6�9`mYDYy Ci6�9�>4�QRF�9`mg9W25M 9+" 6 8?S�MNOU9 K ~�m D MNO_8?F�M�;59�8�w?9YXbQRF�O_6�9 J � DYy

J � DL9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 25Mz4�Q T [�;59+"+y-fg6�9 . F�Q�8 K [�254�O_S F�925MCQ*X 8�M_6 F�2�> H?2�>�V�4�Q�F�9?~ 4�Q T [ Q0MN9 K Q:X MUQ T 9

4�Q TC. 2�> 8*ON25QR>CQ:X�e 80> K @C~?M_S FUF�QRS > K 9 K.?/ 8WM_6�9�;5;�Q:X�>�9�80F�; / [ S FH9 m�9Y8?> K O_6�9�>z80>C9+"ROU9�> K 9 K ~ m RuF�254�6

9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9?y o\>3V?9�>�9�FU8*;b~�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9�M`8?F�9z6�25VR639�>�QRS�VR6-X QRFW>�S�4�;59�8?F . S FU>�2 >�V�ONQO_8VH:9 [�;�8*4�9 8*OWO_6�9

. 8*MN9WQ:X . Q?O_6 O_6�9`mL8?> K mg9`;�8 / 9�F�M�y^@W>�4�9WX\S�;5; / 9�MNO_8 . ;I25M_6�9 K QR> O_6�9 J � DY~ T Q?MNO�Q*X^O_6�9W;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O /

4�Q T 9�MYX\F�Q T OP6�9 m . S FN>�2�>�V3M_6�9�;5;b~ | 6�25476 4�QR>0ON2�>RS�9�M�ONQ . S�25; K S [3O_6�9zmg9z;�8 / 9�F . 9�>�9�8*OP6+y f�6�9 mg9

. S FN>�2�>�V`MP6�9�;I; 2�>COPS FN>W4�QR>0ON2�>�S�9�M^ONQ 9�>�;�8?FHV?9�O_6�9�e��?@ 4�QRF�9?y J M^O_6�9�4�QRFH9nVRF�Q*|�M�~�O_6�9�ONQ0O_8*;?;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O /

2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�MY|�9�;5; . 9 / Q�> K O_6 8*OY8*476�259�w?9 K QR> O_6�9`h � DYy

?�w?9�>0O_S 8*;5; / ~=OP6�9 . 8:MN9zQ*X�O_6�9zmg9z;�8 / 9�F . 9�4�Q T 9�M`MN;525VR60ON; /�K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8:ON9?~�4�8?S�MU2 >�V�8 MNQ�F�OWQ*X T 2 >�2>R

6�9�;52�S T�� 8*M_6 H�>�Q*| >�8*MC8 � OP6�9�F T 8*;n[ S�;5MN9?y � f�6�9 FH9�M_S�;5ON2�>�V-9+" [ 8?>�MN25QR> 8?> K 4�QRQ0;I2�>�V3Q*X�O_6�9zQ�S�ON9�F

;�8 / 9�F�MCON9 T [ QRFN8?F�25; / M_>�S ��MCQRS�O�m . S FU>�2 >�V%~n| 6�25;59 . F�259 ��/ 2 >�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�V)OP6�9 ONQ0O_8*;^;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / Q:X O_6�9

MNO_80F�y < S . MN9�a S�9�>0ON; / ~ � K 9�4�F�9�8*MU9�MA8*VR8*2�> |�25O_6 O_6�9�F�9�O_S FN> ONQ T QRF�93MNO_8 . ;I9�mg9 . S FN>�2�>�V�y <�Q�QR>+~

4�QRF�9 4�QR>?OPFN8*4�ON25QR>3F�9�M_S T 9�M�~^8?> K m . S FN>�2�>�V�F�9�4�Q*w?9�F�M`S >0ON25;GOP6�9zQR>�MN9�OWQ*X�O_6�9 >�9+"RO�O_6�9�F T 8*;n[ S�;5MN9?y

}Y> K 9�F�MNO_8?> K 2�>�V O_6�9�[ F�Q�4�9�MNMAQ:X�O_6�9�F T 8*;`[ S�;5MN2�>�V 25M34�F�25ON254�8*;C>�Q?OQR>�; / ONQ 9+" [�;�8*2�> O_6�9�Q . MU9�F�w?9 K

[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�MYQ*X J � DlMUO_8?F�M . S�O 8*;5MNQCONQ F�9�[ F�Q K S�4�9`O_6�9 . 9�6 8�w�25QRF�Q*X^[ Q?MNO R J � D | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�8*M�|�9�;5;

�bo . 9�> ���?� J ~ ���?� �� y

J >�Q?O_6�9�F 2 T [ QRF�OP8?>?O X 9�8*OPS F�9 Q:X J � D 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>25M T 8*MNMg;IQ0MNM�y J � D MNO_8?F�M�8?FH9WQ . MN9�F�w?9 K OUQz;5Q?MN9

T 8*MUM 8:OG2�>�4�F�9 K 2 . ;59 FN8:ON9�M�~RS [ OUQ 80> K [ 9�FN6 8?[�M . 9 / QR> K�� �FE���� � � / F � * �bp+QRS [ 9�O�8*;by ���0� @ y <�Q T 9

T 8*MUM=25Mn[ F�Q . 8 . ; / ;5Q?MUO K S F�2�>�VWO_6�9�F T 8*;�[ S�;IMU2 >�V%yGmgQ*|G9�w09�F�~�DcQ*|G9�>�8?> K C 2I;5;5MNQR> � ���?� � MPS�4�4�9�9 K 9 K 2�>U�ST<.@3A��/�1)/3U�� ��)� ���� �52K1.ST2#� �T/3<:9 >DST@.> A�@3@);�NDC&2R>�S�5> 6./3E$N�/)1)2�6?;D1)/ LQ6.2KS��TW"A54�6?>=/RU�ST<.6?1.S���;=6?STAKB ��B�A59RB 2 < 6?>�/� ��6./�B=UD/3U- A51.S��3AKBD6.2� �I1)2KB=@.>���I-���"�V

Page 22: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

F�9�[ F�Q K S�4�2�>�VzQ . MN9�FHw?9 KAT 8*MNMc;5Q?MNM FN8:ON9�Mn|�25O_6 T Q K 9�;5M�Q*X�[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�> 8*;5; /K FH2Iw09�> T 8*MNM�;5Q?MNM�~�4�8*;52 . FN8*OU9 K

S�MN2�>�V�HR>�Q*| >[ F�Q�[ 9�F�ON259�MYQ*Xn[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V J � D MNO_8?FHMG4�8:;I;59 K 132�FN8Cw(80F�2�8 . ;59�M�y

J � D 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 4�Q�>?ON2�>�S�9�M�ONQ . 9WO_6�9 OP8?F�V?9�O^Q*X 2 >0ON9�>�MN9WQ . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR> 8*; 80> K O_6�9�Q�F�9�ON254�8*;+MN4�FNS�ON2�> / y

@YO_6�9�FCQ�S�ONMNO_8?> K 2�>�V�[ F�Q . ;59 T M 4�QR>�4�9�FN> O_6�9M / >0O_6�9�MN25MzQ*X >�9�S�OPF�QR> RuF�254�6 9�;I9 T 9�>?ONM K S F�2�>�V mg9 MP6�9�;I;

� 8*M_6�9�M�~=|Y6�2I4�634�8?> . 9 K F�9 K V?9 K ONQO_6�9 M_S F X\8*4�9 .?/ 4�QR>0w?9�4�ON25QR>+~^8?> K OP6�9�>�;5Q?MNO�ONQO_6�9z2�>0ON9�F�MNOU9�;I;�8?F

T 9 K 2�S T w�2�8 T 8*MNM^;5Q?MUM�y^f�6�9c] > 8*;�FN8*ON25QWQ*X e OUQ`@l2�>COP6�9G4�Q�F�9�2IMn8:;IMUQW2 > VRF�9�8*O K QRS . O�~ K S�9 [ F�2 T 8?F�25; /

ONQO_6�9S >�4�9�F�O_8:2 >0O / |�25O_63| 6�254�6�O_6�9 * � e � � � X *��N@'FH9�8*4�ON25QR>�FN8:ON9z25M�H�>�Q*| >+y J M�|�25O_6 T Q?MUO J � D

[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M�~*Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR> 8*;?4�QR>�MUO_FN8*2�>0ONM�QR> O_6�9�MN9G[ FHQR4�9�MNMU9�M�8?FH9n6 8?F K OUQ�4�Q T 9 .0/ y^k^8?F�O+Q*X�O_6�9n[ F�Q . ;I9 T

25M�O_6�9 4�8:;I2 . FN8:ON25QR>zQ:X�OP6�9 F�9�a S�2�F�9 K [ 6 / MN254�8*;+[ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F�M�y^f�6�9 / V09�>�9�FN8*;5; / QRS�O_>�S TC. 9�FcO_6�9 8�w(8:2I;�8 . ;59

Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR> 8:; [ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F�M T 8?> / OUQ`QR>�9?~�;59�8�wR2�>�VzS�M�ONQ`VRS�9�MUMn| 6�254�6 O_6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*;%a S 80>?ON25ON259�M�ONQC6�Q?; K

] "�9 K 8?> K | 6�254�63ONQw*8?F / yzj%QRFW8 4�Q T [ FH9�6�9�>�MN25w?9 FH9�wR259�| Q:X J � Di9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>+~=MU9�9 o . 9�> � h�9�> ��2�>�2

� ���0� @ y

Ci6 8*OU9�w?9�F�OP6�9�9+" 8*4�O T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T ~+Q�FY4�Q TC. 2 > 8:ON25QR>3Q*X T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T M�~=F�9�M_[ QR>�MN2 . ;59zXbQRF T 8*MNM R\;IQ0MNM

2�> J � D MNO_8?FHM�~�O_6�9 / 9�w?9�>0O_S 8*;5; / MPS�4�4�9�9 K 2�> 9�ru9�4�OU2 >�V O_6�9 . S�; HzQ*X O_6�9�2�F�9�>?w09�;IQ�[ 9�MY2 >0ONQCM_[ 8*4�9?yc@W>�4�9

�FE � � ����Q*XGmL25M�8:;I; O_6 8*OWF�9 T 8:2 >�M�~+O_6�9 / 9�w?Q0;Iw09 FU8?[�2 K ; / ��2�>�8 . QRS�O � E � / F ONQ 6�25VR6�9�FW80> K 6�25VR6�9�F

ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9�M 8:OG8*; T Q?MUOn4�QR>�MNOP8?>?Oc;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / ~�F�9�w?9�8*;52�>�VC| 6 8*Oc| 8:MG[ F�9�w�25QRS�MN; / OP6�9 2�> >�9�F T Q0MNO�4�QRF�9

Q*XnO_6�9 J � D MNO_8?F�y�f�6�9C> 8VH*9 K 4�QRF�9�2IM . F�25VR60O 9�>�Q�S�VR6�ONQz25QR>�2 ��9zO_6�9�9+" [ 8?> K 2�>�VM_6�9�;5;^Q*X^25ONMYXbQRF T 9�F

9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9?~+4�F�9�8:ON2�>�VA8 . 9�8?S�OU2�X\S�;n[�;�8?>�9�O_8?F / >�9 . S�;�8 y J O�O_6�9z>�S�4�;59�S�MWQ*XnO_6�9`MP6�QRF�OY;I25w?9 K >�9 . S�;�825MW8

>�9�|�; / XbQRF T 9 K k C d |g2IOP6A>�9�8?F�; / O_6�9WMP8 T 9W;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 25OW6 8 K QR>OP6�9 J � D . S�OYQR>�; / 8 T 25;5;I25QR>0O_6

25ONM�XbQRF T 9�Fcw?Q0; S T 9?y C 2IOP6zO_6�9W;�8*MUO�] F�9�M�Q*X�>�S�4�;59�8?F . S FU>�2 >�V K / 2�>�V QRS�O�>�9�8?Fc2IOUM�M_S F X\8*4�9?~�O_6�9`>�9�|�; /

XbQRF T 9 K k C dLMNO_80F�25M F�9�8 K / ONQ . 9�V?2�>AOP6�9Y] > 8*;�MNO_8:V?9 2�>x2IOUM ;5QR>�Vz9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y

' � K6� K ��� � !�#�� * � ��1-�

fg6�9�2�>�25ON2�8*;�8?[ [ 9�8?FN8?>�4�9z8?> K)T 8VH*9�S [�Q*X 8k C d MUO_8?F K 9�[ 9�> K MCQR>�O_6�9 [ 6 8*MU9zQ*XnO_6�9zOP6�9�F T 8*;

[ S�;5MN9z4 / 4�;59 8*OW| 6�254�6325OW;I9PXbOWO_6�9 J � D y�o XGO_6�9CMNOP8?F�;59�8�w?9�M K S F�2�>�V�O_6�9z[ 6 8*MN9zQ*XnMUO_8 . ;59 m . S FU>�2 >�V

. 9�O�|�9�9�> M_6�9�;5; � 8*M_6�9�M�~�O_6�9�> O_6�25M . S FN>�2�>�V�|�25;5;�4�QR>0ON2�>�S�9O_6 F�QRS�VR6tO_6�9A[�;�8?>�9�O_8?F / >�9 . S�; 8 >�S�4�;I9�S�M

MNO_8:V?9��b<�476��Q�> . 9�FN>�9�F ���0� � ~ ���?� O y�C 6�9�>t| 6 8*OW25M`;59PXbO`Q*X�O_6�9 m 9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9 . 9�4�Q T 9�M`OUQRQO_6�2�> 8?> K

ONQ�Qz4�Q�Q?;b~�O_6�9Cm F�9�8*4�ON25QR>�MY|�25;5; ] > 8*;5; / M_6�S�O Q ��~%8?> K O_6�9�MNO_8?F |�25;I; . 9�V02 >�ONQ 4�QRQ?;^8?> K3. 9�4�Q T 9C8 m

Page 23: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

8*O T Q?M_[ 6�9�F�9 ��d J |Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F XNy

o XnO_6�9`MUO_8?F�;59�8�w?9�M�O_6�9 J � D ���D�����( 8CO_6�9�F T 8*;=[ S�;5MN9?~+| 6�25;59CO_6�9�mLM_6�9�;5;^25MY9+"RON2�>�VRS�25M_6�9 K ~�O_6�9�>

25OW4�8?>;5Q?MU9�25ONMW9�>0ON2�F�9zm RuF�2547639�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9?~+9+" [ Q?MN2�>�VAO_6�9Cm�9C;�8 / 9�F . 9�;5Q*|`y`< S�4�6-8 MNO_80F�25M`[ F�Q . 8 . ; / 8

[ F�9�4�S F�MUQRF�ONQ 8 d`D �Zm�9 K Q T 2 > 8:ON9 K | 6�25ON9 K | 80F XHy

o X�Q�> O_6�9`Q?OP6�9�F�6 8?> K O_6�9�MNO_8?Fc;59�8�w?9�M�O_6�9 J � D 4�;5Q?MN9�9�>�QRS�VR6 ONQzOP6�9WM_6�9�;5; � 8*MP6[ 6 8*MN9?~%O_6�9�>8

] > 8*; � 8:M_6 T 2IV�6?O�Q�4�4�S F K S F�2�>�V QRFc9�w?9�>8�XbON9�FcO_6�9`[�;�8?>�9�O_8?F / >�9 . S�;�8 [ 6 8*MN9?~ 4�8?S�MU2 >�V 8 . F�259PX�FH9�O_S FN>

ONQ�O_6�9 J � D . 9PXbQRF�98 ] > 8:; . S FHMNO`Q*X T 8:MNM`;5Q?MNMzF�2 K MC25OCQ*X�2IOUM�9�>0ON2�F�9m 9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9A8?> K 9�w?9�>�MUQ T 9

Q*X�O_6�9 mg9 8:MW|G9�;5;by fg6�2IM�25M�8 ;52 H*9�; /)T 9�O_6�Q K Q*X�[ F�Q K S�4�2�>�V�k � �?� A � MNO_8?FHM�~+| 6�25476tM_6�Q*| MNO_F�QR>�V0; /

9�> 6 8?>�4�9 K ei8?> K @ 8:O�O_6�9�2�F�MPS F XZ8:4�9�M �bo . 9�> ���0� J ~SC�9�FN>�9�F � hg8?S�476 ���?� J y

J M T 8*;5; K 25VRF�9�MUMN25QR>325M`2�> QRF K 9�FY4�QR>�4�9�FN>�2�>�V�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X�8?> K k C d M_[ 9�4�O_FU8*;^O / [ 9�M�y�Dc9�4�8?S�MU9

Q*X�O_6�9�2�FW9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / 6�2IMUONQRF�259�M�~�O_6�9�MN9zMNOP8?F�M`8?F�9CMN9�w09�F�9�; / MUO_FN8*ON2E]�9 K 2�>34�Q T [ Q?MU2IOU2IQ�>�|�25O_636�9�8�w�2I9�F

9�;59 T 9�>0ONM . 9�>�9�8*O_6 8?> K ;52IV�6?ON9�FxQR>�9�MA8 . Q(w09?y f�6�9�2�F6�25VR6 M_S F X\8*4�93VRFN8�w�25ON259�M9�> 6 8?>�4�9�O_6�25M9 ��9�4�O

O_6 F�Q�S�VR6WVRFU8�w�25O_8*ON25QR> 8:;(MU9�ONON;52�>�V`8?> K`K 2 �=S�MN25QR>+ynf�6�25M T 9�8?>�M T Q?MNO 6 8�w09nw?9�F / MN2 T [�;59�M_[ 9�4�O_FN8gM_6�Q*|�2�>�V

QR>�; / ;52�>�9�M Q*XWQR>�9QRF�O�|�Q39�;I9 T 9�>?ONM�y d J | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbMCQR>�; / MP6�Q(| ;I2�>�9�M Q*X`m'2�> OP6�9�2 F M_[ 9�4�O_FU8 y

�gQR> R\d J | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbMY2 >�4�;�S K 9O_6�9Cd`D �bmg9�o�;52�>�9�M ~ d`@ �bmg9�ouog;52�>�9�M ~ d � �beL;52 >�9�M ~ d�� ��Q?O_6�9�F

T 9�O_8:;IM ~=8?> K 9�w?9�>3O_6�9zd`e MNO_8?FHM �b>�Q;52 >�9�M yA@YO_6�9�F 2 T [ QRF�OP8?>?OW4�;�8*MUMN2E]�4�8*ON25QR>�Mz9+"�25MNO`M_S�4�6�8*M�O_6�9

k � �?� A � k C d MNOP8?F�M�~c| 6�25476 M_6�Q*|';52�>�9�MAQ:X mg9�o�oN~�e�o ��~�8?> K @ �WoNy�}Y>�;I2 H*93O_6�9 T 8*2�> MN9�a S�9�>�4�9

M_[ 9�4�O_FN8*;�4�;�8*MUMN2E]�4�8*ON25QR>�M / MNON9 T ~ OP6�9`d J d`D �*d`@ | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X=MP[ 9�4�O_FN8:;=4�;�8*MNMU9�M 8?FH9`>�Q?O F�9�;�8*ON9 K 2�>

8?> / MU2 T [�;I9C|�8 / ONQCON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9 ��O_6�QRS�VR6 d`@YMY8?F�9`6�Q?ONOU9�F�O_6 8?> O_6�9Wd`DcM y

o X J � D T 8*MNM R\;IQ0MNMn|�8*M^4�QR>�MUO_8?>0O�~*O_6�9Y9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K FU8*ON25QWQ*X�d J ONQ`>�QR> R\d J | 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX MnF�9�MPS�;IOU2 >�V

X\F�Q T J � D 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> |GQ�S�; K 4�Q�FNF�9�M_[ QR> K F�QRS�VR6�; / ONQ3O_6�9AFN8*OU2IQ3Q*XYO_6�9ON2 T 9�MzM_[ 9�>?O K S F�2�>�V)9�8*4�6

[ 6 8*MN9�Q*X^O_6�9`O_6�9�F T 8*;=[ S�;5MN9C4 / 4�;I9?y�}Y>0XbQRF�O_S > 8*OU9�; / ~ T 8*MUM�;5Q?MNMW[ F�Q . 8 . ; / 4�6 8?>�V?9�MYFN8?[�2 K ; / >�9�8?FgO_6�9

ON2�[ Q*X^O_6�9 J � D �b8*V�8*2�>+~RMU9�9�DcQ*|G9�> 8?> K C 25;5;IMUQR> ���0� �� y^f�6�9`[ F�Q . ;I9 T V?9�ONM�|�QRF�MU9 | 6�9�> Q�>�9`8 K K M

ONQ3O_6�9 T 2 ")O_6�9AS >�4�9�FHO_8*2�>?O / Q*XY| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XgX QRF T 8*ON25QR> K 2�F�9�4�ON; / X\F�Q T O_6�9�9+"RON9�> K 9 K 6�QRF�2 ��QR>0O_8*;

. FN8?>�4�6+y^@ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> 8*;5; / ~ MNQ T 9 �VE�� Q*X=8*;5;%| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbMn8?F�9�d J M�y�13Q?MNO^Q:X�OP6�9 F�9�MNOn8?FH9�d`D�|Y6�2IOU9

K |�8?F XbM�y J XZS > K 8 T 9�>?O_8:; [ F�Q . ;59 T 25M�O_6 8*OnOP6�9 9+" 8*4�OGFU8*ON25Q`Q*X�d J ONQ�>�QR> R\d J | 6�25ON9 K | 80F X Mc476 80>�V?9�M

|�25O_6x9 ��9�4�OU2Iw09WON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9?y C 9W|�25;I;^F�9�O_S FU> ONQzO_6�25M�25MNM_S�9�M_6�QRF�OU; / y

Page 24: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�FE

' � K6� Z 8 ��" �� . �C����� &g&+! �Z� ��"!�#

J M O_6�9n;�8*MNO^F�9 T > 80>?ONM Q*X >�S�4�;59�8?F . S FN>�2�>�VW2�>z[ Q?MUO9R J � DtMNO_8?F�M K 2I9�QRS�O�~*O_6�9nMNOP8?F�M�9�>0ON9�F�O_6�9�2�F�] > 8*;

MNO_8:V?9 Q:X=4�QRQ0;I2�>�V8?> K 4�QR>0O_FN8*4�OU2IQ�>+y�D / >�Q*| OP6�9�2 F M_S F X\8*4�9WON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S F�9�M�8?FH9 8 T QR>�VCO_6�9`6�25VR6�9�MNO�Q*X

8?> / MNO_8?FHM�HR>�Q*| > ��O_6�9C6�Q?ONON9�MNOY6 8�w09 ����� �

�� Y E�TEVEVE { y+f�6�9�2�F�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 25M`8*;5MNQ 6�25VR6+~+2�>�9+"�4�9�MNM

Q*X �FEVEVE � � ~ . S�Og|�25O_6�QRS�OW6�QR[ 9WQ*X X\S F�O_6�9�F�>�S�4�;59�8?F . S FU>�2 >�V%~�O_6�9 / 6 8�w?9`>�Q*| 6�9�F�9WONQ V?Q . S�O K Q*| >+y

j^25VRS FH9 � y>=`MP6�Q(|gM 8�;5Q?V�PSR\;5Q?V�� ��� K 2 8:VRFN8 T XbQRF�8`MP8 T [�;59WQ*X=MNOP8?F�M�>�9�8?FcO_6�9WMNQ R\4�8:;I;59 K � HR>�9�9��CQ*X

O_6�9W[ Q?MUO9R J � D 9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / O_FN8*4+H%y=p+2�>�9�M F�9�[ FH9�MN9�>?O�O_6�9W[ 8*O_6�M�MNOU9�;I;�8?F T Q K 9�;5M�XbQ?;5;IQ*|i8�XbON9�F^;59�8�w�2 >�V

O_6�9 J � DYy�f�6�QRS�VR6 OP6�9�2 FgM_S F X\8*4�9WVRFU8�w�25ON259�M 8?F�9`8:; FH9�8 K / 6�25VR6 �b8 . QRS�O�;5Q?V�P�� Yz8*O T 8 "R2 T S T � ���

8

7

6

5

5.4 5.0 4.6log Teff

log

g (

cgs)

PG 1159-035

PG 0122+200

PG 1707+427PG 2131+066

PG 1151-029

PG 1144+005

H 1504+65

MCT 0130-1937

HS 0704+6153

PG 1424+535HS 1517+7403

K 1-16RX J2117.1+3412

RX J0122.9-7521

Lo 4

Lo 3

NGC 246

PG 1520+525

Jn 1

VV 47

NGC 650

HS 0444+0453

IW 1

Abell 21

HS 2324+3944

0.6 M

0.7 M0.76 M

0.89 M

j^25VRS F�9 � y>= p+Q?V�P ;5Q?V�� � � K 2�8*VRFN8 T |�25O_6 O_6�9zQ . MN9�FHw?9 K ;5QR4�8 RON25QR>�M�Q*Xnk C dLMNO_8?FHM ��d`F�9�2 ��;59�F�9�O�8*;by ���?�?� y ?cFNF�QRF. 8?F�M�8?F�9W>�Q?OnM_6�Q*| > . 9�4�8?S�MN9WQ:X�OP6�9�2 F�6�S�V?9Y9+"RON9�>0O�sO / [�254�8*;5; /�� E AC2�> ;5Q?V�P8?> K�� �FE�TEVEVE � = E� EVE E {2�> � ��� y ?^w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / O_FN8*4+H0M 80F�9zX\F�Q T C�QRQ K �j 8?S�; H�>�9�F � ���?�VO ~*MNQ?;52 K ;52�>�9�M 8?> K � 8?S�ONMU476 / � ���?� Y ~K 8*M_6�9 K ;I2�>�9�M y

Page 25: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�?�

k C dWM^4�QR>0ON2�>�S�9 ONQ�M_6 F�2�> HzS >0ON25; K 9�V?9�>�9�FU8*4 / 6 8*;5ONMcO_6�9�2�Fn4�Q�>?O_FU8*4�ON25QR>z8*On8 . QRS�O�;5Q?V P�� � y^o\>�25ON2�8*;5; / ~

9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> K S FH2 >�V O_6�25M [ 6 8*MU92IM FN8?[�2 K s|�25O_6�2�> 8 . QRS�O�A EVE ~ EVEVE / 9�8?F�M�~ � ��� 25M 4�S�OC2�>l6 8:;�XN~�8?> K p

[�;�S TzT 9�ONMYONQC;59�MNMYO_6 8?> � � � ynfg6�9`2�> >�9�F FH9�V?25QR>�M�Q*X^O_6�9`>�9�|�; / XbQRF T 9 K | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X=MNOP8?F�8?F�9W>�Q*|

4�Q T [�;59�ON9�; /�K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8*ON9?~ M_S FNF�QRS > K 9 KA.0/ 8�O_6�2�>+~ >�Q�> R K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8*ON9�9�>?w09�;IQ�[ 9?y

@ . MU9�F�w?9 K |Y6�2IOU9 K | 80F X T 8*MNMN9�M�4�;�S�MNOU9�F�4�;5Q?MN9�; / 8?FHQRS > K 8 T 9�8?>xw(8*;�S�9�Q*X E yBA O� E A � � � �bDc9�F�V R

9�F�QR>+~^< 8���9�F � p+259 . 9�F�O ���?� = ~ C�9�2 K 9 T 8?> > � {YQ�9�MNON9�F ���?� J yAf�6�9[ F�2 T 8?F / F�9�8*MNQR>�M�XbQRFWMPS�476 8

ON25VR60O T 8*MNM K 25MNOPF�2 . S�ON25QR> K 9�MP[�2IOU9 8 |�2 K 9FN8?>�V?9CQ*X�[ F�Q?V?9�>�25ONQ�F T 8*MNMW2�>0w?Q?;5w?9zO_6�9 . 8*MN254CXb9�8*O_S F�9�MWQ*X

J � D 9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>+s�6�25VR6 � 8?> K 6�2IV�6 �� y f�6�9A;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / Q:X 8?> J � D MNOP8?FC25M w09�F / MN9�>�MN25ON25w?93ONQ

O_6�9z4�Q�F�9 T 8*MUM �bk^8*4 � / >�M H?2 ��� Y E yC1�8*MUMW;IQ0MNM�8*4�4�9�;59�FN8:ON9�MC| 6�9�>3O_6�9zOP6�9z4�QRF�9 T 8*MNM�~ ��~ F�9�8*4�6�9�M

8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9�; / E y O � � ~�|�25O_6tO_6�9 6�25VR6�9�F T 8*MNM J � D MNO_8?F�MW;5Q?MU2 >�V T 8:MNM T QRF�9CMN;5Q*|�; / 8*O`8 V02Iw09�>

;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / OP6 8?> J � D MNO_80F�MnQ*X�;5Q*|�9�F T 8*MUM�y^f�6�9 OP6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*;�6�25VR6 R T 8*MUMG;52 T 25O�Q*X J � D 4�QRF�9�M 7 80> K

O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9Q:X | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XWMNO_8?F�Mz8*M |G9�;5; 7 25M � y J � � ylf�6�25MF�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONM O_6�9VRF�9�8:ON9�MNO 8 T QRS >?OCQ*X

T 8*MUMn25On25M�[ Q?MUMN2 . ;I9WOUQWM_S [ [ QRFHOGw�2�8W9�;59�4�O_F�Q�> K 9�V?9�>�9�FU8*4 / �be�6 80> K FN8*MN9FH�6 8?F ��� @ � y�@W> O_6�9�;5Q*|5R T 8:MNM

MN2 K 9?~%MNO_8?F�M�|�25O_6 ��

�E AV@ ��� |�25;5;�>�9�w?9�FgF�9�8*4�6 O_6�9 J � D 2�>OP6�9Y] F�MNO [�;�8*4�9 ��dWQRF T 80>+~Rh�Q�Q K ~ �

@CB�e�Q�> >�9�;I; ���?� @ y

}Y>0ON25;�8 . QRS�OYOu|�9�>0O /z/ 9�8?F�MW8*V?Q%~ O_6�9�[�;�8*4�9 T 9�>?OWQ*XnMUO_8?F�M�2�>�O_6�9�O_FN8?>�MN25ON25QR>3F�9�V02IQ�> . 9�O�|�9�9�>�O_6�9

k � � O_FN8*4+HC8?> K O_6�9`S [ [ 9�Fg9�> K Q*X=OP6�9W| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X=4�Q�Q?;52�>�VzMN9�a S�9�>�4�9`|�8*M�[ F�Q . ;59 T 8*OU2I4?y�f�6�25M�|�8*M

K S�9W>�Q?O�QR>�; / ONQ`OP6�9 FN8?[�2 K 25O / |�25O_6 | 6�254�6zMNOP8?F�M T S�MNO T 8VH*9gO_6�25MGOPFN8?>�MN25ON25QR> � T 8VH02�>�V`Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�> 8*;

9+" 8 T [�;59�Mn6 8?F K ONQY4�Q T 9 .0/ . S�On8*;5MNQWONQYO_6�9 K 2 � 4�S�;5O / Q*X MP[ 9�4�2EX / 2�>�V`;5Q?V�P�8?> K � ��� X Q�F�M_S�4�6�Q . r�9�4�ONM�y

dW9�ON9�F T 2 >�2�>�V3O_6�9�MN9 a S 8?>?OU2IOU2I9�M�X\F�Q T M_[ 9�4�O_FN83F�9�a S�2�F�9�MCO_6 8*OW|�9z4�QR>�MNOPFNS�4�O�8�F�9�8*MNQR> 8 . ;I9 T Q K 9�;nQ*X

O_6�9�MNO_8?F�B M 8:O T Q?M_[ 6�9�FH9?ynf�6�25MW25M w?9�F / K 2 � 4�S�;5OYXbQRF�4�Q T [ 8:4�O�MNO_8?FHM�|�25O_6�� � � 2 >x9+"R4�9�MUM Q*X A E ~ EVEVE {Cy

f�6�9 8:MNM_S T [�ON25QR> Q*X ;5Q�4�8*;�O_6�9�F T 8*;�9�a S�25;52 . F�2�S T �bp�fG? ~*MNQ`S�MN9PX\S�;�2�> T Q K 9�;52�>�VCO_6�9�M_[ 9�4�O_FN8YQ*X+4�QRQ0;I9�F

MNO_80F�M�~ . F�9�8VH0M K Q*| > MN9�w?9�FH9�; / 8:OGMPS�476�6�2IV�6ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9�M 8?> K VRFN8�w�25ON259�M�y

k C d'9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 4�8?> . 9 K F�25w?9�> .0/ 9�>�9�F�V / ;IQ0MNMN9�M K S�9ONQ->�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q�2�>?ON9�FU8*4�ON25QR>�Mz2�> O_6�9 4�Q�F�9?y

}Y>�;I2 H*9�MNQ?;�8?F�>�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q?M�~ O_6�9�MU9�8?F�9W>�Q?O�OP6�9 .?/ Ru[ F�Q K S�4�O�Q*Xn>RS�4�;59�8?FcX\S�MN25QR>+~ . S�O�2�>�MNON9�8 K FH9�M_S�;5O�X\F�Q T

9�;59�4�O_F�QR>tMN4�8*ONON9�FH2 >�VA[ FHQR4�9�MNMU9�M`2�>3O_6�9z6�Q?O�~ K 9�>�MU9 F�9�V02IQ�>�MWQ*XGO_6�9zk C d 4�QRFH9?y J > K S >�;52 H*9 [ 6�Q0ONQR>

9�>�9�F�V / ~�| 6�254�6 T S�MNO K 2 �=S�MN9WF�9�;�8*ON25w?9�; / MN;5Q*|�; / O_6 FHQRS�VR6CO_6�9g9�>?ON2�F�9YMNO_80F . 9PXbQRF�9�9 T 9�FHV?2�>�V�2�>0ONQ`MP[ 8*4�9?~

>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q?MY4�F�9�8*OU9 K >�9�8?F�O_6�9�4�9�>?ON9�F Q*X�OP6�9`k C d 9�MN4�8?[ 9 K 2�F�9�4�ON; / y�f�6�25M >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 4�Q�Q?;5M

Page 26: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� =

O_6�9W4�9�>0ON9�FgQ*X=O_6�9�MNO_8?F�~ T 8:2 >0O_8*2�>�2�>�V8CON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S F�9W2�>0w?9�F�MN25QR>xMN2 T 25;�8?F�OUQzO_6 8*O�|g2IOP6�2 >xMNO_8?FHM 8:O�O_6�9

ON2�[ Q*X^O_6�9WF�9 K V?2�8?>0O . FN8?>�4�6+ynf�6�9W2 T [ QRF�O_8?>�4�9WQ:X�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�QF�9�8*4�ON25QR>�M�OUQ k C d 9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> | 8:Mn] FHMNO

F�9�4�Q?V�>�2 ��9 K 2 >tO_6�9 ���VOVE M ��MN9�9�XbQRFg2 >�MUO_8?>�4�9 < 8�w?9 K Q �n~ �n8?>3m�Q�FN>+~ � � 25;�8 ��� O?� . 9PX QRFH9zM_S�4�6AMUO_8?F�M

|�9�F�9z4�QR>0] F T 9 K OUQ9+"R25MNO�ye�8:;I4�S�;�8*OU2IQ�>�M�Q:X OP6�9 F�9�;59�w(8?>0OzF�9�8*4�ON25QR> FN8*OU9�MW|G9�FH9 [ 9�F XbQRF T 9 K 2�>�2IOU2 8:;I; /

.0/ Dc9�8?S K 9�O�~ k 9�O_F�Q?MU2 80>+~R8?> K < 8*;�[ 9�ON9�F � ���VO Y . 8*MN9 K QR>zOP6�9�O_6�9�QRF / Q*X�|G9�8 H`2�>0ON9�FN8*4�OU2IQ�>�M [ F�QR[ Q?MN9 K

.0/ j�9 / > T 8?> � � 9�;5;>R\1�8?> > � ��� A � yp�8*OU9�F�~ dW2I4�S�M�� ��� YV= 8?> K dW254�S�MC9�O 8:; y � ��� Y O F�9�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9 K

O_6�9�MN9zFN8:ON9�MW2�>3O_6�9zS >�2E]�9 K 9�;59�4�O_F�Q*|�9�8VHxO_6�9�QRF / Q*X C�9�2�> . 9�F�V38?> K < 8*;�8 T � C�9�2�> . 9�F�V ��� O Y ~+< 8*;�8 T

���VO0� y J ;5;^Q*XGO_6�9�MU9�4�8:;I4�S�;�8*OU2IQ�>�M 80F�9CO_6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*;b~ 6�Q(|�9�w?9�Fvy C�9 6 8�w?9z>�Q K 2�F�9�4�O`9+" [ 9�FH2 T 9�>?O_8:;^QRF

Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR> 8:;�4�QR>0] F T 8*ON25QR> Q*X=>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Qz[ F�Q K S�4�OU2IQ�> FN8:ON9�MGS > K 9�Fc4�QR> K 25ON25QR>�M�8?[ [ F�Q�[ F�2�8*ON9YONQ�k C d

2�>?OU9�F�25QRF�M�y

j%QRF�O_S > 8:ON9�; / ~?O_6�9GH�>�Q(|Y>CM_8 T [�;59�Q:X�MUO_8?F�M^| 6�254�6zQ�4�4�S [ / OP6�2IM�[ 6 8*MN9�Q:X�OP6�9�9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / [�254�O_S FH9

6 8*McVRF�Q*| >�Q*w?9�F^O_6�9g; 8:MNOnO�|�Q K 9�4�8 K 9�M�ynfg6�9 T Q0MNO^2 T [ QRFHO_8?>0O K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F / |�8*MnOP6 8*O^Q*X=8`>�9�| M_[ 9�4�O_FU8*;

4�;�8*MNM�4�8*;5;59 K O_6�9 k � �?� A � MNO_8?FHM�y=@Yw?9�F�O�|GQ K Q ��9�> 8?FH9�HR>�Q*| >+~�FN8?>�V?2�>�VC2�>�� � � X\F�Q T Q*w?9�F � Y E ~ EVEVE {

K Q*| >�ONQ �VE ~ EVEVE {Cy JW. QRS�O�6 8*;EX=8?F�9n4�9�>0O_FN8:; MNO_8?F�M Q*X�[�; 80>�9�O_8?F / >�9 . S�; 8 yGf�6�9 T Q0MNO^9�w?Q?;5w?9 K k � �?� A �

MNO_80F�M T 9�F�V09W|�25O_6O_6�9�;5Q?V�PA8?> K � ��� Q:X�O_6�9C6�Q?ONON9�MUO >�Q�F T 8*;�|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F XbM�ynf�6�25MY4�;�8*MNMYO_6RS�MgXbQRF T M

8 4�Q T [�;59�ON9C9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / MU9�a S�9�>�4�9 XZFHQ T k���� ONQ O_6�9C| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F Xn4�Q�Q?;52�>�VAO_FN8:4 H � C 9�FN>�9�F ���?� A ~

d`F�9�2 ��;59�F � m S . 9�F ���?�?� y

k � �?� A � MNO_8?FHM [ FHQ . 8 . ; /)K Q�>+B OzF�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0OzO_6�9[ F�9�4�S F�MNQ�F�MzQ*X OP6�9 T 8*r�QRF�25O / Q*X | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�~

6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�y j^2�F�MNO�~ 8*;5; . S�O�QR>�9WQ*X=O_6�9Wk � �0� A � k C dWMGMP6�Q(|i>�QC9�w�2 K 9�>�4�9�Q*X�m 2�> O_6�9�2�F�M_[ 9�4�OPFN8 ~ 8?> K

25O�2IM�S >�;52 H*9�; / O_6�9 / 4�8?> O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9Y9�w?Q?;5w?9�2�>0ONQCd J | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�y^obOn25M T QRF�9�;52 H*9�; / OP6 8*OnO_6�9 / 9�w?Q?;5w?9

2�>?OUQzd`@ 8?> K d`D | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�y

JW. Q�S�On6 8*;EX�Q:X O_6�9 k � �?� A � MNOP8?F�Mn8?F�9�[ S�;5M_8*OU2 >�VCw*8?F�2�8 . ;59 MUO_8?F�M�~�M_[ F�9�8 K Q*w?9�F O_6�9�9�>?OU2 FH9 FN8?>�V?9�Q*X

;5Q?V P 8?> K � � � Q�4�4�S [�2I9 KA.0/zT 9 TC. 9�F�McQ*X�O_6�9�M_[ 9�4�O_FN8*;%4�;�8*MNM�y^f�6�25M�F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONMcO_6�9 |g2 K 9�MUOn2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O /

� MNOPF�2�[ ����ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9TR\|�25MN9 2 > O_6�9Am Ruh K 2�8*VRFN8 T y e 9�>?O_FU8*;�MNO_8?F�w(80F�2�8 . ;59�M 8?FH9 S�M_S 8:;I; / K 9�>�Q?OU9 K

8*MWk � � � MNO_8?FHM �b[�;�8?>�9�O_8?F / >�9 . S�;�8A>�S�4�;59�S�M`w(80F�2�8 . ;59�M y �n8?FH2 8 . ;I9zk � �0� A � MNO_8?F�Mg|�25O_63>�QA>�9 . S�; 8

T 8VH:9 S [CO_6�9 � C �Y2�F�V?2�>�25M ��QRF MU2 T [�; / � C �Y2 F MNO_80F�M�y=k � �0� A � MN9�F�w09�Mn8*MnO_6�9Y[ F�Q?ONQ?O / [ 9cXbQRF . Q?O_6

8�M_[ 9�4�OPF�Q?MN4�QR[�254 4�;�8*MNM 8?> K 84�;�8*MUMzQ*X�w(8?FH2 8 . ;I9�MNO_8?FHM�yj 80F�O_6�9�F K Q*| > O_6�9 | 6�25ON9 K | 80F X�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9?~

|�9�] > K O�|GQ8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*;c2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNOPF�2�[�M�y J OYM_S F X\8*4�9zON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9�M . 9�O�|�9�9�>-8 . QRS�O%= E ~ EVEVE 8?> K

Page 27: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� @

=VA ~ EVEVE { �Z{YQR9�MNOU9�F^9�On8*;by ���?� A � p+259 . 9�F�O�9�On8*;by ���?�VO � fg6�9�ru2b~ �^9�> >�9�M�~ � < 6�2 [ T 8?> ���?� �� ~�|G9 ] > K O_6�9

d`D�� � w(8?F�2�8 . ;59Cd`D MNO_8?F�M�y ?^w?9�> 4�Q�Q?;59�FY8?F�9WO_6�9�� � e�9�ON2 ��w(80F�2�8 . ;59�d J MUO_8?F�M�~�|�25O_6 � ��� . 9�O�|�9�9�>

�?� ~ EVEVE 8?> K � @ ~ EVEVE { � � F�9�9�>�MUON9�2�> ���?� J � C�9�2 K 9 T 80> > � {YQR9�MNOU9�F ���?� J � Dc9�F�V09�F�QR>+~ C�9�MN9 T 8*9�;b~ �

j�Q�>?O_8:2 >�9 ���?� = y��n8?F�2�8 . 25;525O / 2�>8*;5;�OP6 F�9�9 MUO_F�2�[�M F�9�M_S�;5ONM XZF�Q T PSR T Q K 9`[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> �"XbQRFcO_6�9 ���-e 9�ON25M�~

MN9�9We�6 8?> T S�VR8 T ��� YV= ~ C)8?FN>�9�F � h�Q . 2 >�MUQR> ��� YV= � X QRF�O_6�9�d`D��YM�~?MN9�9�C 2�>�V?9�O�9�OG8*;by ���?� = � X QRF�O_6�9

k � �?� A � w(8?FH2 8 . ;I9�M�~=MU9�9 <�OP8?FNF ]�9�; K 9�O`8*;by ���0� @ y`fg6�9 [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>�[ 9�FH2IQ K Mz[ F�Q*wR2 K 9 8FH2I4�6 T 2�>�9zXbQRF

[ F�Q . 2�>�V O_6�9WMNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9WQ*X^| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX�8?> K k C d MNOP8?F�M�y

kcS�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M 4�8?>l6�9�;�[ OUQ)8?>�MN|�9�FCO_6�9�a S�9�MUON25QR> Q*X |Y6�9�O_6�9�F O_6�9-k � �?� A � MNO_80F�M 8?> K O_6�9Ad`D

| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbMnM_6 8?FH9 8 4�Q TzT QR> 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / ;52EX 9W;52�>�9?ynj%QRF^2�>�MNOP8?>�4�9?~SC 2�>�V?9�O�9�O�8*;by � ���?� J ~*MN9�9W8*;5MNQ

D�FN8 K ;59 / � C 2�>�V?9�O ���0� J S�MN9 K 80>-80> 8*; / MN25MCQ*X�O_6�9 [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ 9�F�25Q K M�Q:X OP6�9�d`D�� MNO_80F � d @VA �

ONQ T 9�8:M_S F�9zO_6�9 O_6�254 H�>�9�MNMCQ*X�25ONM�mg9z;�8 / 9�F�y }gMN2�>�V3O_6�9zON9�4�6 >�25a S�9�M K 25MN4�S�MNMU9 K 2�> e�6 8?[�ON9�F�@ ~�O_6�9 /

Q . O_8:2 >�8zmg9W; 8 / 9�FgO_6�254+HR>�9�MNMYQ*X �FE � � � � y�f�6�9`MP8 T 9WON9�4�6 >�25a S�9z8?[ [�;5259 K ONQzO_6�9WQ . MU9�F�w?9 K [ 9�F�25Q K M

Q*X=k � �?� A � / 2I9�; K 8Cmg9 ;�8 / 9�F T 8*MNMnQ:X � E�� � � � ycf�6�25M [ FH9�MN9�>?OUMG8C[ F�Q . ;59 T 2EX=O_6�9YOu|�Q`8?FH9 8*MUM_S T 9 K

ONQ . 9 F�9�;�8*ON9 K y m�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~+dW9�6 >�9�F � ���?�VO 8?> K dW9�6 >�9�F � {W8�|�8*;59�F � ���?� A M_6�Q*|�9 K OP6 8*O K 2 ��S�MU2IQ�>

8*O�OP6�9 . 8*MN9CQ*X^O_6�9Cm�9�; 8 / 9�Fg4�8?>x4�8?S�MN9z8CM_6�2EXbOW2 >�O_6�9C8?[ [ 8?F�9�>0O�;5Q�4�8*ON25QR>�Q*XnO_6 8*O . 8*MN9?~%4�QR>�MN25MNON9�>0O

|�25O_6 . Q?O_6 T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>0ONM�~ K S F�2�>�V 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> XZF�Q T OP6�9 �+J E ~ E EVE { Q*X�k � �?� A � ONQCO_6�9�=V@ ~ E EVE {LQ*X

� d%@ A � y

J >�Q?O_6�9�F^[ FHQ . ;59 T 25M�;52�> H?2�>�VzO_6�9Yk � �?� A � MNO_8?FHM^ONQWO_6�9�d`D�� | 6�25ON9 K | 80F X M^25McO_6 8*On>�Q`d`D MUO_8?F�M

8?F�9CQ . MU9�F�w?9 K 2�> O_6�9 8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9CON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9 FN8?>�V?9!@ E ~ EVEVE�SJ A ~ EVE E { � � F�9�9�>�MUON9�2�> ���?�VO ~�<�2IQ�>

���?� J y fg6�2IMCd`D � VR8?[ �;5259�Mz2�>�OP6�9 9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / [ 8*O_6tXZFHQ T k � �?� A � ONQ � d @VA � y j�Q�>?O_8:2 >�9 �

C�9�MN9 T 8*9�;�� ���?� Y [ F�Q�[ Q?MN9�O_6 8*O 8:;I;�d`D MNO_8?FHM F�9�O_8*2�>�8zM T 8*;5;=8 T QRS >0O�Q*XG6 /�K F�Q?V?9�>x| 6�25476 K 2 �=S�MN9�M

ONQ�O_6�9�2�FCM_S F X\8*4�9S >?ON25;b~�8*Oz8?F�QRS > K J A ~ E EVE {C~^>�Qtmg925MCM_[ 9�4�O_FHQ?MN4�QR[�254�8*;5; / wR25MN2 . ;59?y J O!@ E ~ E EVE {C~

4�QR>0w?9�4�ON25QR> T 2 "R9�MO_6�93m . 8*4+H 2 >0ONQ O_6�9AMPS . M_S F X\8*4�93; 8 / 9�FHM�~�8?> K OP6�9Ad`DcM FH9�8?[ [ 9�8?Fvyim�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~

dW9�6 >�9�F�� ���?�VO M_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8*O�O_6�9`8 T QRS >?OgQ*X�6 /RK F�Q0V?9�>F�9�a S�2 FH9 Kt.0/ O_6�25M�MN4�6�9 T 9`M_6�Q�S�; K�K 2 ��S�MU9`ONQ

O_6�9zMPS F XZ8:4�9zMNQAa S�254 H0; / O_6 8*O�25O`|�QRS�; K 8:; FH9�8 K /�. 9 9�8*MN25; / wR25MN2 . ;59A8*O�O_6�9 k � �?� A � MNO_8*V?9?y dW9�6 >�9�F

� ���0�VO [ Q?2�>?ONMYQRS�OYO_6 8*OW8zM T 8*;5;�8 T QRS >0O 8 T 8*MNMY;5Q?MNMW4�QRS�; K �_T 8:M H � O_6�25M`8 T QRS >0O Q:XG6 /�K F�Q?V?9�>x2�>

k � �?� A � MNO_80F�M�~ . S�O K 9�O_8*25;59 K 4�8*;54�S�; 8:ON25QR>�M`Q*XnOP6�2IMW[ F�Q�4�9�MNM`6 8�w?9`>�Q?O . 9�9�> T 8 K 9?yY<�2�>�4�9 T 8*MNMY;IQ0MNM

Q�4�4�S F�M 2�>�k � �iMNOP8?F�M�~�O_6�25M�MN9�9 T M 8�;52 H*9�; / MNQ?;�S�ON25QR>xONQzO_6�9`[ FHQ . ;59 T y

Page 28: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�+J

fg6�9zO_6�254 H�>�9�MNM�Q*X�O_6�9CM_S F X\8*4�9z;�8 / 9�F�M`2�> . Q?O_63d J 8?> K d`D O / [ 9z| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM`8?> K k C dWMW2IM

2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O�XbQRFY8?>�Q?O_6�9�FYF�9�8*MUQR>+y @W>�4�9zOP6�9�2 FY4�Q�F�9�M 80F�9`4�Q T [�;I9�OU9�; /3K 9�V?9�>�9�FU8*ON9?~+| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�4�Q�Q?;

8*O�8*; T Q?MUOG4�Q�>�MNO_8?>0O�FN8 K 2�S�M�~ . Q?O_6 �l80> K � � � . 9�4�Q T 2�>�V M T 8*;5;59�F�ycd`S�9WONQCO_6�9`6�25VR6 4�QR> K S�4�ON25w�2IO / Q*X

K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8:ON9 T 8:ONON9�F�~ 8?> K O_6�9WX\8 K 2�>�V Q:X�>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q9 T 2IMUMN25QR>+~�OP6�9`4�QRF�9�a S�254+H?; /3. 9�4�Q T 9�MY25MNQ?O_6�9�F T 8*;by

f�6�9�Q*w?9�F�; / 2 >�V`mg9n;�8 / 9�F �b80> K m ;�8 / 9�F�2�>Cd J M OP6�9�>�8:4�ONM�8:M�8gO_6�9�F T 8:; . ;�8?> H*9�O�~*4�QR>?OPF�Q?;5;52 >�V�O_6�9�FN8*ON9

8*O�|Y6�2I4�69�>�9�FHV / ;59�8VH?MW8�|�8 / ONQCM_[ 8*4�9�80> K O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9WOP6�9`FN8*ON9WQ*X^9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>�Q*X^O_6�9WMNOP8?F�yn<�2�>�4�9CO_6�9

mg9W; 8 / 9�Fc4�Q T [ F�25MN9�M�O_6�9 . S�; H Q*X=O_6�9W9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9W9�w09�> 2 >xd J MNOP8?F�M�~�25ONM�Q*w?9�FN8*;5; T 8*MNM�25M 8?> 2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O

X\8*4�ONQRF�| 6�25476 K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9�McO_6�9�M_[ 9�9 K 8*O^| 6�254�6z8Y| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX O_FN8�w?9�;5M K Q*| >�O_6�9�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX 4�Q�Q?;52 >�V

O_FN8:4 H�� C�QRQ K ���?� = ~SC 2�>�V?9�O � �n8?>mgQRFN> ���0� Y y

fg6�9zON2 T 9zMN4�8:;I9 XbQRFW| 6�25ON9 K | 80F XG4�Q�Q?;52�>�V�4�8?>�[ F�Q*w�2 K 9 8AF�Q . S�MNO K 9�ON9�F T 2�> 8*ON25QR> Q*X�O_6�9 8*V?9CQ*X

O_6�9CVR8*;�8*4�OU2I4 K 2IMTH � C 2�>�V?9�OW9�O`8:; y ���?� Y yW<�2�>�4�9z| 6�25ON9 K | 80F X MY4�Q�Q?; T QRF�9CMN;5Q*|�; / 8:MWO_6�9�2�FWON9 T [ 9�F R

8*O_S FH9�M K 9�4�F�9�8:MN9?~+|�9`Q . MN9�FHw?9 T QRF�9�;IQ*|5R\OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9C| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�O_6 8?>36�25VR6 R\ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9�Q�>�9�M�y

mgQ(|�9�w?9�Fv~ . 9�;IQ*| 8 . Q�S�O J ~ EVEVE { ��� � �FE�� � � � � � ~�|�9M_S K K 9�>�; / ] > K XZ80F�X 9�|�9�FC|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?FuX M

O_6 8?>x9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K y�f�6�25MW25M 8:ONO_F�2 . S�ON9 K ONQzO_6�9 ] >�2IOU9 8:V?9WQ*XnO_6�9WVR8:; 8 " / snMU2 T [�; / ~�>�Q | 6�25ON9 K | 80F X MY8?F�9

Q?; K 9�>�QRS�VR63ONQA6 8�w?9 4�QRQ?;59 K . 9�;5Q*| �FE � � � � � � y f�6�9 9+" 8*4�OC[ Q?MU2IOU2IQ�>�Q*X�O_6�25MC4�S�ONQ �n~+4�QRS [�;59 K |�25O_6

H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09`Q*X=OP6�9WON2 T 9`25O�O_8 H*9�M�8CMNO_8?FcONQCV?9�OgO_6�9�F�9?~ V?25w?9�MY8C;5Q(|�9�Fc;52 T 25OWONQCO_6�9`8*V?9WQ*X O_6�9WVR8*;�8 " / y

J X\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*; 2 >�V�F�9 K 259�>?OW2�>3O_6�25M T 9�8*M_S FH9 T 9�>?OY25MWO_6�9�mg9C;�8 / 9�F T 8:MNM�Q*Xn| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM 8?> K 7 .0/

9+"�ON9�>�MN25QR> 7 k C dWM � C�Q�Q K ���?� = ~ C 2�>�V?9�O � �n8?>�m�QRFU> ���?� Y y

����� ���'� � #&��� ���� �R�$! ��� �:� ���$(� � ����

C 9n|�QRS�; K ;I2 H*9gONQ S�MU9�O_6�9nQ . MN9�F�w?9 K [ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�MnQ:X [ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V�k C dWM ONQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9�O_6�9�2�Fn[ 6 / MN254�8*;

MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9?~+4�;�8?F�2EX / OP6�9�2 F 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / FH9�; 8:ON25QR>�M_6�2�[�OUQQ?O_6�9�FW[ Q0MNO9R J � D MNO_8?FHM�~�8?> K 6�9�;�[34�8*;52 . FN8*OU9

T 9�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0OGQ:X�OP6�9 8*V09 Q*X O_6�9 V�8*;�8 " / O_6 FHQRS�VR6 O_6�9 |Y6�2IOU9 K | 80F X�; S T 2 >�Q0MN25O / X\S >�4�ON25QR>+y C�9W|�QRS�; K

;52 H*9 OUQ�H�>�Q(| |Y6�9�O_6�9�FcO_6�9�O_6�9�QRFH2I9�McQ*X�;59�[�ONQR> 2 >0ON9�FN8:4�ON25QR>�Mn4�QRFUF�9�4�ON; /zK 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 O_6�9W[ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR> FN8*ON9�M

8?> K O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9�>�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q4�QRQ?;52�>�VQ*Xnk C d 9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y J T 9�8:M_S F�9 T 9�>0O Q:X�>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q4�Q�Q?;52�>�V9 ��9�4�ONM

T 25VR60O�;52 T 25OWO_6�9WMN9�O�Q*Xn[ Q0MNMN2 . ;59 T Q K 9�;5MYO_6 8*O�4�QRS�; K 6�9�;�[�MNQ?;5w?9WO_6�9WMUQ?;�8?F�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q[ F�Q . ;59 T y

C 25O_6�QRS�O^8?>CS > K 9�F�; / 2 >�V�Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> 8*; V�F�QRS > K |�QRFIH%~�|�9c4�8?>C8*4�4�Q T [�;525M_6z>�QR>�9�Q*X+O_6�9�MN9�9+"�4�2IOU2 >�V

8?> K [ Q0ON9�>?OU2 8:;I; / S�MU9PXZS�; V?Q�8*;5M�y C�9�|�25;I;%;�8 / O_6 8:O=VRFHQRS > K |�QRFIH%~?[ 8�w�2�>�VWO_6�9�|�8 / X Q�F�XZS�O_S FH9 FH9�MN9�8?F�4�6�9�M

Page 29: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� A

ONQA8?>�MU|G9�FgO_6�9�MN9 a S�9�MNOU2IQ�>�M�~ .?/ [ F�Q*w�2 K 2 >�V�O_6�9�] F�MNOW4�Q T [ F�9�6�9�>�MN25w?9zMNOPS K / Q:XnO_6�9 [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ F�QR[ R

9�F�ON259�M�Q:X�O_6�9 � C��Y2�F�MNO_8?FHM�y C�9W|�25;5;�2 K 9�>?ON2EX / O_6�9�2�F S > K 9�FH; / 2�>�V [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>A[ 8*OUON9�FN>�M 8?> K S�MU9WO_6�9�MN9

[ 8*ONOU9�FN>�M�ONQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9CMNON9�;5;�8?FgMNO_FNS�4�OPS F�9?y5C�9`|g2I;5; ] > K O_F�9�> K MY|�25O_6�2�>�O_6�9`V�F�QRS [ Q*X � C �Y2�FW[ S�;>R

M_8*OUQRF�MW| 6�254�6�Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�> 8*;5; / K 9P] >�9 �9�D���AK S FH2 >�V3O_6�9�2�F�9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> 4�9�8*MN9�M�~^8?> K �9�1; 25OK Q�9�MWMNQ�y�C�9C|�25;5;^M_6�Q*| 6�Q*| O_6�25MW2�>0X Q�F T 8*ON25QR>�4�QR>0O_8*2�>�MWO_6�9�MN9�9 K M`Q:XG8?>�9�w?9�>?OPS 8*;=9+" [�;�8?> 8*ON25QR>�Q*X

O_6�9�QRF�25V?2�>�Q*X�OP6�9�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�MWOP6�9 T MN9�;5w?9�M�ygj^2 > 8:;I; / ~+|�9`|g2I;5;n8?[ [�; / QRS FY>�9�| HR>�Q*|�;59 K V?9CQ*X � C �Y2 F

MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9YONQCM_6�Q*| 6�Q*| XZS�O_S FH9 [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�> MNO_S K 259�M 4�80>zON9�MUOGOP6�9 S > K 9�F�; / 2�>�V >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q [ 6 / MN254�M�| 6�254�6

4�QR>0O_F�Q?;5M�OP6�9`FN8*ON9WQ*X^k C d 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y

fg6�2IM K 25MNMU9�F�O_8*ON25QR>t2IM K 25w�2 K 9 K 2�>0ONQMN9�w?9�>34�6 8?[�ON9�FHM�y`f�6�9�] F�MNOWQ�>�9 6 8:M`[ F�Q*wR2 K 9 K 8 4�QR>0ON9+"ROYXbQRF

O_6�9Y2�>?w?9�MUON25VR8*ON25QR> .0/ MNO_8:ON2�>�V`QRS FcV?9�>�9�FN8:;�V?QR8:;IM�8?> K QRS�ON;52�>�2�>�V OP6�9 4�S FNFH9�>?O�MNO_8:ON9�Q*X=Q�S F H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09

Q*X MUON9�;5; 80Fz9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?> K O_6�9AF�9�;�8*ON25QR> Q*X QRS F 2 >0w?9�MNOU2IV�8*ON25QR> ONQ325O�y f�6�9MN9�4�QR> K 476 80[�ON9�FCF�9�wR259�|�M

8*MNOU9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q0;IQ0V / ~ K 9�w?9�;5QR[�2�>�V�O_6�9zONQ�Q?;5MzS�MN9 K ONQAO_FU8?>�MN;�8*ON9 [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> [ 9�F�25Q K Mz2�>?OUQ H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09 Q*X

MNON9�;5;�8?F�[ FHQR[ 9�F�OU2I9�M�y J XbON9�F�OP6 8*On|�9`[ F�9�MN9�>0O�8CM_S TzT 8?F / Q*X QRS F�[ F�25QRFGH�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09WQ*X�[ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�Vz|Y6�2IOU9

K |�8?F X`8?> K k C d MNOP8?F�M�y e�6 8?[�OU9�F J [ F�9�MN9�>0ONM Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> 8*;YF�9�M_S�;5ONM X QRFC8 K K 25ON25QR> 8:; k C d MUO_8?F�M

8?> 8*; / ��9 K 2�>3O_6�9C4�QRS F�MU9�Q:XnO_6�25MWO_6�9�MN25M`|�QRFIH%y ��9+"�O�~+|�9`2 K 9�>0ON2EX / O_6�9C476 8?FU8*4�ON9�F�25MNON254�MWQ*XnOP6�9�V�F�QRS [

8?> K O_6�9�> 9+" [�;�8*2�>3OP6�9 T 2�>ON9�F T M�Q*Xn8CM_S�V?V?9�MUON9 K O / [ 9WQ*X K F�25wR2�>�V T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T y�fg6�9WMN2 "RO_6x476 80[�ON9�F

K 9�w?9�;5QR[�M�O_6�9Y2 K 9�8WXbQRFc8WON9�MNOcQ*X�MNO_8?> K 80F K ;59�[�ONQR> O_6�9�QRF /z. 8*MU9 K QR> Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M�Q*X=[ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�V k C d

MNO_80F�M�yo\> O_6�9 ; 8:MNOC476 8?[�OU9�FW|�9 MPS TzT 8?F�2 ��9 QRS FW4�Q�>�4�; S�MU2IQ�>�M�~n9+" 8 T 2�>�92 T [�;5254�8*ON25QR>�M Q*X�O_6�25MC|GQ�FIH

XbQRF�XZS�O_S FH9`MNO_S K 259�MYQ*X=O_6�9YXbQRF T 8*ON25QR> Q*X=|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F X=MUO_8?F�M 80> K O_6�9`8*V?9WQ*X O_6�9`VR8:; 8 " / ~ 8?> K QRS�ON;52�>�9

X\S F�O_6�9�F�8�w?9�>�S�9�M�Q*X^2�>?w?9�MUON25VR8*ON25QR>+y

Page 30: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�FO

������!�7� � � ����� �]�� ��� �N� ��� � �

�7��#G��D� �"(2� ��D��(1�3������ �3-�� �D�)?5����� #G���,(D� � %��"!��"����+�+��� � ��� �*��� :/;�� � �3� � �������������#9(1� �2���� �3-����1��/%/��� ��2����� -���D���1� ? � ����� ��� %/���� ��#G�3���2��;��"� ���*��#G�������)%/��;���D��� ��� �D��!��

� �� ����2� ��1��� �9�D�*+,� � %� �����)+�� �"(2�D�

� �D�0����� ��� �D# %/�����*�2� %��3-���D��������#G�� �2������� ��2%'�+� ����5%��D�����(�� �D�

� �D��%/��� � %0� - � � �� 4 6

7 h�25476 8?F KAJ y�knF�Q�4�ONQRFv~�� ��1�"��� �2��#G�5%0��D�2� � �D�F%�@3A5B��FE

� ��� �������� "!$#&%'��() ��

?�w?9�F / [ 6 / MN254�25MNO HR>�Q*|�M�OP6 8*O�QR>�9�Q*X�OP6�9 . 9�MUO |�8 / M�ONQ ;I9�80FN>A8 . QRS�OYO_6�9 T 9�4�6 8?>�254�8*;�[ FHQR[ 9�F�OU2I9�M

Q*XG8?> / [ 6 / MN254�8*; M / MNON9 T 25MWONQ MUO_S K / 25ONM`>�QRF T 8:; T Q K 9�M Q*XnQ0MN4�25;I;�8*OU2IQ�>+y`f�6�25MW25MWO_FNS�9`Q:X T 9�O_8*; . 80F�M

8?> K T Q?;59�4�S�;59�M�~�8?> K 8*;5MNQ3Q*X MNOP8?F�M�y�Ci6�9�>�9�w?9�F |G9 ] > K 8AV�F�QRS [ Q*X MNO_80F�M`O_6 8:O�[ S�;5M_8*ON9?~c|�9 6 8�w?9

O_6�9QR[ [ QRF�O_S >�25O / ONQ3MNOPS K / O_6�9�2�FCMUO_FNS�4�O_S F�92�> VRFH9�8*ON9�F K 9�O_8*25;�O_6 8?> 25M >�QRF T 8*;5; / 8�w(8:2I;�8 . ;59�ONQ3QRS F

2�>�MNO_FNS T 9�>?ONM�ynp�S�4+H?25; / ~�[ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�VzMUO_8?F�Mn8 . QRS > K 2�>zOP6�9 m Ruh K 2 8:VRFN8 T ~�8?> KT Q?MNOcMNO_8?F�Mc|�25;5;�S > K 9�FHV?Q

MN9�w?9�FU8*; K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O�H02�> K M Q*X`[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> K S F�2�>�V)OP6�9�2 F ;I25w?9�M�y o > O_6�9A4�8*MU9| 6�9�F�9MN9�w?9�FU8*; T Q K 9�M 8?F�9

9+" [ F�9�MNMN9 K.?/ 8`MUO_8?F�~*|�9Y4�8?>+~�2 > 8?> 8*;5Q?V / ONQ`OU9�FNF�9�MNO_FH2 8:;�MN9�25M T Q0;IQ0V / ~ S�MN9 . S�; H wR2 . FN8:ON25QR>�M�ONQ`M_8 T [�;59

K 9�[�O_6�M�2 > 8:4�4�9�MN2 . ;I9OUQ K 2 FH9�4�O`Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>+yzfg6�2IMz8?[ [�;5254�8*ON25QR> Q*X�>�QRF T 8*; T Q K 9 8?> 8*; / MN25M`25M�H�>�Q*| >

8*M 8:MNON9�F�Q?MU9�2IM T Q?;5Q?V /

fg6�9 . 9�MNO R^HR>�Q*| > [ S�;5M_8*ONQRFHM`2�>�4�;�S K 9AO_6�9e�9�[ 6�9�2 K w(8?FH2 8 . ;I9�M�~^| 6�25476 8:;IOU9�FWO_6�9�2�F . F�25VR60O_>�9�MNMCQR>

8OU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59Q*X K 8 / M�ONQA|�9�9FH0M�~^8?> K O_6�9h�h p / FN8*9 MNO_8?F�M�~�| 6�254�6�w*8?F / QR> 8ON2 T 9�MN4�8:;I9Q:X MU9�w?9�FN8*;

6�QRS F�M�yGf�6�Q�S�VR6 T QR>�QR[ 9�F�25Q K 254?~+O_6�9Ce�9�[ 6�9�2 K M`8?F�9YX\8 T QRS�M X QRF O_6�9�[ 9�F�25Q K R\;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / F�9�;�8*ON25QR>�M_6�2�[

| 6�254�6 V?Q*w?9�FN>�M O_6�9�2�F ;52IV�6?O9R\4�S FHw?9�M�y f�6�25M-F�9�;�8*ON25QR>�MP6�2 [L8*;5;5Q*|�MAS�MONQ 4�8*;52 . FU8*ON9�O_6�9 K 25MNO_80>�4�9�MAONQ

Page 31: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� Y

Q?O_6�9�F VR8*;�8 "�2I9�MW2�>�| 6�254�6O_6�9�MN9 . F�25VR60O M_S [ 9�F�V?2�8?>0ONMW8?F�9 K 9�OU9�4�ON9 K y f�6�9C[ 9�F�25Q K MWQ*Xnh�h p / FN8*9`MUO_8?F�M

��| 6�254�6Q�4�4�S [ / O_6�9�6�Q�F�2 ��QR>?OP8*; . FN8?>�4�6Q:X�MNOU9�;I;�8?Fg9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F�9`S�MN9 K OUQ T 9�8:M_S F�9WO_6�9�2�F T 8*MUM 8?> K

;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / yif�6�9 / 8?F�92 T [ QRF�O_80>?OCXbQRFC4�8:;I2 . FN8:ON2�>�V)O_6�9 K 25MNO_8?>�4�9�M ONQ�MNOU9�;I;�8?F 4�;�S�MNON9�F�M |�25O_6�2�> 8?> K

8?F�Q�S > K QRS F�Q*| > VR8*;�8 " / y

<�OU2I;5;b~ MN2�>�4�9YO_6�9�MN9�MUO_8?F�Mn[ S�;5M_8*OU9 2�> 8WMN2�>�V?;59WFN8 K 2�8*; T Q K 9?~�O_6�9 [ FHQ . 9W8���QRF K 9 Kz.0/ OP6�9�2 F�[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>

25M^;52 T 2IOU9 K y Ci6�2I;59�OP6�9 � X\8 T QRS�M � [ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�VWMNO_80F�M=S > K 9�F�V?Q`8gFN8 K 2�8*; [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>+~ � ��� RuFU8 K 2�8*;?Q?MN4�25;5;�8*ON25QR>[ F�Q*w�2 K 9�MC8 w?9�F / ; 80F�V?9 >�S TC. 9�FWQ:X [ Q0MNMN2 . ;59 T Q K 9�M�yzf�6�9 VRF�9�8*ON9�FgO_6�9 >�S TC. 9�F Q*X K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T Q K 9�M

|�9z4�8?> K 9�ON9�4�O`2�> 8MNOP8?F�~�OP6�9 T Q�F�9z2�>0X Q�F T 8*ON25QR>t|G9 6 8�w09z|�25O_6 | 6�25476 ONQAOU9�MNOWQRS F T Q K 9�;IM�yAf�6�9

VRFN80> K 4�6 8 T [�25QR>�[ S�;IMP8*ONQRFc2�>O_6�25M�MU9�>�MN9W25M�QRS FcQ*| > < S >+ycd`S�9YONQC2IOUM [ F�Q "R2 T 25O / ~ |�9W6 8�w09 K 9�ON9�4�OU9 K

T 25;5;52IQ�>�M�Q:X K 2 ��9�F�9�>0OYX\F�9�a S�9�>�4�259�MCQ*Xnw*8?F�2�8*ON25QR> �bmY8?F�w?9 / 9�O`8:; y ���?�VO yYk^8?F�ON; /A. 9�4�8?S�MN9zQ*XnOP6�2IM�~+QRS F

H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09`Q*XnO_6�9�MNQ?;�8?F�2�>0ON9�F�25QRFY25M T QRF�9W9+"�ON9�>�MN25w?9CO_6 8?>xO_6 8*O�Q:X�8?> / Q?O_6�9�F MNO_8?F � MN9�9WXbQRF�2�>�MNO_80>�4�9

D�8?6�4�8*;5; � k^2�>�MNQR> >�9�8?S�;5O ���0�VO y�j�QRF�OPS > 8*ON9�; / ~ O_6�9W| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X=w*8?F�2�8 . ;59�M`8?F�9`>�QR> FU8 K 2�8*;=[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M

8*M�|�9�;5;by

J M T 9�>0ON25QR>�9 K [ F�9�w�25QRS�MN; / ~�O_6�9�F�98?F�9OP6 F�9�9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O F�9�V?25QR>�M Q*X [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 8:;�2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / 4�QR> R

>�9�4�ON9 K |�25O_6 | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XW9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y f�6�9�] F�MNO�~�8?> K O_6�93M_S . ru9�4�O Q*X`O_6�25M O_6�9�MN25M�~�25MO_6�9�k C d

2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_F�2�[ QR4�4�S [�259 K .0/ O_6�9k � ��� 8?> K � C �Y2�F�MNO_8?F�M�y-k � �?� A � ~ O_6�9[ F�Q?ONQ?O / [ 9zQ:X O_6�9

� C � 2�FY4�;�8*MNM�~+25M`8 T QR>�V OP6�9�F�254�6�9�MNO`[ S�;5M_8*ONQRFHM%HR>�Q*| >+y J MW|�9`|g2I;5; K 25MN4�S�MNM�2�>AOP6�9 >�9+"�OW4�6 8?[�ON9�F�~

Q*w?9�FcQR>�9�6�S > K F�9 K�K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O [ 9�F�25Q K MW6 8�w?9 . 9�9�>x2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K 2�>25ONMg;I25VR60ON4�S F�w09?~�[ F�Q*wR2 K 2�>�VMNO_FH2I4�OgON9�MNONM

XbQRF�MUON9�;5; 80F T Q K 9�;5M�y�f�6�9zF�9 T 8*2�>�2�>�V| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F Xn2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MUO_F�2�[�M`8?F�9�O_6�9z8�X Q�F�9 T 9�>0ON25QR>�9 K d J �

MNO_80F�M �b8*;5MNQz4�8*;5;59 K � ��e�9�OU2 MUO_8?F�M�8�XbON9�F�O_6�9�2�F�4�;�8*MUM [ F�Q0ONQ?O / [ 9 8?> K O_6�9Wd`D��LMNO_8?FHM�y

<�OU9�;I;�8?F [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M^4�Q T 9n2�>�O�|GQ . 8*MN254 � 8�w?QRFHM�~�4�Q�FNF�9�M_[ QR> K 2�>�VWONQ�O�|�Q K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O H?2�> K M^Q*X�F�9�MNOUQRF�2�>�V

XbQRF�4�9?yCknS�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M�2�>3O_6�9 < S >�80> K 2�> T Q?MNOWQ?O_6�9�FW[ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�M�~+2�>�4�;�S K 2�>�V)e�9�[ 6�9�2 K Mz8?> K h�h p / FN8*9

MNO_80F�M�~+8?F�9 � R T Q K 9�M�~+MNQ 4�8*;5;59 K . 9�4�8?S�MN9CVR8*M`[ F�9�MUM_S F�9CMN9�F�w?9�M`8:M O_6�9zF�9�MUONQRF�2�>�V XbQRF�4�9 � ;I2 H*9 2 >tMNQRS > K

|�8�w?9�M y�@W> O_6�9Q?O_6�9�FC6 8?> K ~cO_6�9Ak � ����~ � C �Y2�F�~ ��� e 9�ON2b~G8?> K d`D�� MNO_8?FHM 80F�9 8:;I; P R T Q K 9

[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M�y^m�9�FH9 . S�Q / 8?>�4 / MN9�F�w09�M 8*M�O_6�9WF�9�MNONQRFH2 >�V�XbQRF�4�9?y j�Q�FG8�V?25w?9�> T 9�8?> K 9�>�MN25O / ~ � R T Q K 9�M�8?F�9

V?9�>�9�FN8:;I; /T S�4766�25VR6�9�F�2�> X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / ��MP6�QRF�ON9�F�2 >[ 9�F�25Q K O_6 8?>�PSR T Q K 9�M�~?MN2�>�4�9�[ FH9�MNM_S F�9Y25M 8 T S�4�6

MNON2 ��9�F � M_[ F�2�>�V �CO_6 80> . S�Q / 8?>�4 / y+*zm�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~ . 9�4�8?S�MN9WQ:X=O_6�9WMNON9�9�[ VRFN8�w�25O_8*ON25QR> 8*;%VRFN8 K 259�>0O�2 > |Y6�2IOU9, R>=/ � A �!��S B AK4 2 @3A51 � S B 2 N�A�A � A54R9:2�6./�1�ST<�4 2K1"< �TA59R/)1"6?>=2KB 6?>=/$A <.@�S����T2�6?STA5B�<$A54R6?>=/&<.AK;DB�U ST6 E 2��/3<�S B U�A5S B

<.A�V

Page 32: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

���

K |�8?F X=8?> K k C d MNO_8?F�M�~?O_6�9�2�F�4�6 8?FN8*4�OU9�F�25MNON254�P R T Q K 9W[ 9�F�25Q K M 8?F�9Ya S�2IOU9WM_6�QRF�O .0/ MNON9�;5;�8?F T 9�8*M_S FH9�M�~

8?> / |Y6�9�F�9 XZFHQ T 8-6�S > K F�9 K ONQ MN9�w?9�FN8*;cO_6�QRS�M_80> K MN9�4�QR> K M�y o\> MPS�476 MNOP8?F�M�~ � R T Q K 9�Mz|�QRS�; K 6 8�w?9

9�w?9�>xM_6�QRF�ON9�FY[ 9�FH2IQ K M�~+O_6�Q�S�VR6+sG8 MN9�4�QR> K QRF ;I9�MUM �b< 8*25Q�~ C 2�>�V?9�O � h Q . 2�>�MNQR> ���?� @ yG<�9�80F�476�9�MYXbQRF

w(80F�2�8 . 25;I25O / Q�> M_S�476 MP6�QRF�O�ON2 T 9�MU4�8*;59�M 2�>|Y6�2IOU9 K | 80F X MY6 8�w09 . 9�9�>AMUQ`X\8?F�S >�MPS�4�4�9�MNM�X\S�;��b{W8�|�8*;59�Fc9�O

8*;by ���0� J y

o >e�9�[ 6�9�2 K M�~ T Q?ON25QR> 25M MNOPF�254�ON; / FN8 K 2 8:; yQ?n8*4�6[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>x4 / 4�;59W4�8?S�MN9�MgO_6�9WMNO_8?FvB M�Q(w09�FN8*;5; FN8 K 2 S�M

ONQ 9+" [ 80> K 8?> K 4�QR>0O_FN8*4�O .?/ A R �FE�� ��MN9�9?~+9?y V�y"~ �g2 H*Q?;5Q*w � f�MUw?9�O H*Q ��� YV= yWf�6�9zFN8:ON25Q Q*X�O_6�9z>�QR> R

FN8 K 2�8*;gONQ�O_6�9AFN8 K 2 8:; 4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0OzQ*X T Q?ON25QR> 2�> | 6�25ON9 K | 80F X [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 25M8 . QRS�O 83O_6�QRS�M_80> K ONQ

QR>�9 7 ONQC6�25VR6 [ FH9�4�2IMU2IQ�>+~ O_6�9 FN8 K 2 S�M�F�9 T 8*2�>�MG4�Q�>�MNO_8?>0O^O_6 F�QRS�V�6�QRS�OnO_6�9Y[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> 4 / 4�;59 �bh�Q . 2�>�MNQR>+~

{Y9�[�;59�F�~ � � 8:O_6�9�F ���?� = y�f�6�9�e�9�[ 6�9�2 K MG8?> K | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X w(80F�2�8 . ;59�M K Q 6 8�w?9cQR>�9nO_6�2�>�VY2�>`4�Q TzT QR>+~

6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�y j�QRF . Q?OP6+~?O_6�9Y;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / w*8?F�2�8*ON25QR>�M�|�9�MU9�9 8?FH9 K S�9YONQ`4�6 8?>�V?9�M�2�> M_S F X\8*4�9 OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9

4�8?S�MN9 K.0/ OP6�9 T 8*MNM T Q?ON25QR>�M�y�o >z|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F XbM�~*O_6�9 T 9�8?> M_S F X\8*4�9�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9 4�6 8?>�V?9�M .?/ 8 . QRS�O

= EVE { Q*w?9�FY8 [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>�4 / 4�;59 �Zh�Q . 2�>�MNQR>+~�{Y9�[�;59�F�~ � �Y8*O_6�9�F ���?� = y�f�6�9CON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9�w(8?F�2�8*OU2IQ�>

2�>�e�9�[ 6�9�2 K MC25M�8 . QRS�O`ON9�>tON2 T 9�MWVRF�9�8*OU9�F�~+9�>�QRS�VR63OUQ476 8?>�V09zO_6�9CM_[ 9�4�OPFN8*;^4�;�8*MNM�Q*XGO_6�9 MNO_8?FgX\F�Q T

|�9�9FHzOUQz|�9�9FH �b{WS H�8?FIH02�>9�O 8*;by ���VO?� y

fg6�9�MU9�O`Q*X�[ 9�F�25Q K M�9+"�4�25ON9 K ONQ K 9�ON9�4�O_8 . ;59 ;52 T 2IOUM�2�>3|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F XGMUO_8?F�MW25M K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9 K .0/ O_6�9

2�>?OU9�FN[�;�8 / Q:X MN9�w09�FN8*;?[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M�y^f�6�9�] F�MNO+25M=O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�VYQ*X�[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> .?/ MNQ T 9 7 8*M / 9�O=S >�MP[ 9�4�2E]�9 K 7T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T �b>�Q T 8*ONON9�F�6�Q*| T 9�;IQ K 25QRS�MWO_6�9 . 9�;5;b~�25O T S�MNO . 9`MUO_FNS�4+H ONQ . 9C6�9�8?F K y�<�9�4�Q�> K 25MYO_6�9

F�9�M_[ QR>�MN9 Q*X�O_6�9 MNO_8?FYONQ�O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V�O_8 H?2�>�V-[�;�8*4�9MUQ T 9�6�9�F�9 2�>�25ONMC2�> > 8?F K M�y J [ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�V)k C d

MNO_80F�25M 9�MNMU9�>?ON2�8*;5; / 8 ��M_[ 6�9�FH2I4�8:;I; / M / T T 9�O_F�254 F�9�MNQR> 8?>0O�4�8�w�2IO / ~ 4�80[ 8 . ;59�Q:X�M_S�MUO_8*2�>�9 K w�2 . FN8*ON25QR>38*O

8 4�6 8?FN8*4�ON9�FH2IMUON254zMN9�O`Q:XnX\F�9�a S�9�>�4�259�M�yf�6�Q0MN9CX\F�9�a S�9�>�4�259�Mz8?F�9 K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K .?/ O_6�9zMNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9zQ*X�O_6�9

MNO_80F�~�2IOUM T 8:MNM 8?> K ; S T 2 >�Q0MN25O / ~�8:M�|�9�;I;^8*M�OP6�9WO_6�254 H�>�9�MNMWQ*X^25ONM MPS F XZ8:4�9W; 8 / 9�FHM�ynj^2�> 8*;5; / ~+O_6�9C8*4�O_S 8*;

[ 9�FH2IQ K M`|�9CMN9�9z8?F�9z8���9�4�ON9 K�.0/ O_6�9 T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T O_6 FHQRS�VR6�| 6�25476t2 >0ON9�FN> 8:; T Q?ON25QR>�MW8?F�9CO_FN80>�MN;�8*ON9 K

2�>?OUQ`Q . MN9�FHw(8 . ;59W;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / w(80F�2�8*ON25QR>�M�ynfg6�2IM�25M�O_6�9�MNQ R\4�8*;5;I9 K�� O_FN8?>�M�Xb9�F�X\S >�4�ON25QR>+~ �z8?> K 4�; S�9�M�ONQ�25ONM

> 8*O_S FH9`8?F�9WONQ . 9YX Q�S > K 2�>O_6�9WQ . MN9�F�w?9 K w*8?F�2�8*ON25QR>�MW8*M�|�9�;5;by

o X |�9�|�25M_6 ONQ T 8VH*9O_6�9 T Q?MNOzQ*XWO_6�9�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K [ 9�F�25Q K M�~�|�9 T S�MNO S > K 9�F�MNOP8?> K 8*;5;YQ*XWO_6�9�MN9

T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T M2�> 8*M T S�4�6 K 9�OP8*25; 8*M[ Q0MNMN2 . ;59?y m�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~c|�9A4�8?> ;59�8?FN> 8�V�F�9�8*O K 9�8*; .0/ MN2 T [�; /

4�Q T [ 80F�2�>�V�OP6�9 [ 9�F�25Q K M�Q:X=Q . MN9�F�w09 K ;525VR60OGw*8?F�2�8*ON25QR>�MgONQ`O_6�9W>�QRF T 8*;>R T Q K 9`[ 9�F�25Q K MgQ*X T Q K 9�;+MNOP8?F�M�y

Page 33: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

���

C�9 K 25MN4�S�MUMGOP6�9�MN9�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�M 80> K | 6 8*O^O_6�9 / ON9�;5;+S�Mn2�>zOP6�9 >�9+"ROcMN9�4�ON25QR>+yno > � = y>@ ~*|�9 K 25MN4�S�MNM�O_6�9

[ F�Q . ;59 T Q*X K FH2Iw�2�>�V [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 2�> | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X=8?> K k C diMNOP8?F�M�y J XbON9�FcO_6 8*Oc|G9 K 2IMU4�S�MNM 6�Q*|lMNOU9�;I;�8?F

9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 4�80> 8���9�4�O�[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>[ 9�FH2IQ K M�~�80> K 6�Q*|l|�9Y4�8?> T 9�8*M_S F�9YO_6�9�MN9Y4�6 8?>�V?9�M�y C 9�M_S TzT 80F�2 ��9

8*;5;^O_6�9�MN9z8*MUON9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V?254�8*; ONQRQ0;IM�~�8?> K 6�Q(|L|�9C4�8?>38?> K |�25;I;�8?[ [�; / O_6�9 T OUQ [ S�;5M_8*OU2 >�V3k C dWM�~

2�>O_6�9Y] > 8:;�MN9�4�ON25QR>+y

� � � � ����� �"�� R��(�%��&� � � ��(� �� � ���� �'� "! � ��� ��(� "! �

fg6�9 >�QRF T 8:; T Q K 9�Q?MU4�2I;5;�8*ON25QR>�MgQ*X | 6�25ON9 K | 80F X�8?> K k C d MNO_8?F�Mn80F�9 T Q?MNO^4�Q T [ 8*4�ON; /CK 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 K

S�MN2�>�V�O_6�9 . 8*MN25MzMU9�O`Q*X MP[ 6�9�F�254�8*; 6 8?F T QR>�254zX\S >�4�ON25QR>�M�~��� ~ 4�QRS [�;59 K |�25O_6 8?> 8?[ [ F�QR[ F�2�8*OU9 MN9�OCQ*X

FN8 K 2�8*;c|�8�w09CXZS >�4�OU2IQ�>�M ����yAmg9�F�9 � 25MCO_6�9 >�S TC. 9�F�Q*X >�Q K 8*;�M_S F X\8*4�9�MC2 > O_6�9FN8 K 2�8*; K 2 FH9�4�ON25QR>+~ �

K 9�>�Q?ON9�M�O_6�9z>RS TC. 9�FWQ*X >�Q K 8*;n[�;�8?>�9�M�[ 9�FN[ 9�> K 254�S�; 8?F ONQM_S�4�63M_S F X\8*4�9�M�~�8?> K � 25M`O_6�9z>�S T�. 9�FWQ*X

O_6�9�MN9`[�;�8?>�9�MW|Y6�2I4�62�>�4�;�S K 9CO_6�9`[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 8:;�8 "�25M�Q*X^O_6�9`MUO_8?F�y

K � K6� ' � !� �� ��"!�#+��� <=����� � �%# � � ��� � �" � ��b#��

j%QRF T Q K 9�M�Q*X�8CV02Iw09�> �:~ OP6�9�F�9`8?F�9 = � � � 8�w*8*25; 8 . ;I9Cw*8*;�S�9�M�XbQRF � s � � ��� � � � �� � � � � � �� � �?y

e�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONMnQ:X K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O � |g2I;5;�6 8�w?9�O_6�9YM_8 T 9 [ 9�F�25Q K 2�> O_6�9W8 . MN9�>�4�9YQ*X=8 � / T S�O_6 8:;I; /CK 9�[ 9�> K 9�>0O

[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M ;52 H:9 F�Q?O_8:ON25QR>YQRF 8 T 8*VR>�9�OU2I4c]�9�; K yn<�ON9�;5;�8?F^F�Q0O_8*ON25QR>+~PXbQRF�9+" 8 T [�;59?~*2 >�4�FH9�8*MN9�M^O_6�9�XZF�9�a S�9�>�4 /

Q*X � �LE 4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONMA8?> K K 9�4�F�9�8*MN9�M O_6�9xXZF�9�a S�9�>�4 / Q:X � � E 4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONM |�25O_6lF�9�MP[ 9�4�OONQ

� � E y`f�6�9�XZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[�;525ONON2�>�V�~����+~%XbQRFY[ 9�8VH0M`Q:Xn4�QR>�MN9�4�S�ON25w?9 � 25MWMN9�O .0/ O_6�9zF�Q0O_8*ON25QR>�[ 9�F�25Q K

�������n8*4�4�Q�F K 2�>�V ONQ

����� � � � *� ��� � � �"! � � � = y �

| 6�9�F�9 ! � $# � � � � �A� � � * XbQRF�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X�MNOP8?F�M �bD�F�254 H�6�25;I; ��� YVA y C�9�O_6�S�Mn6 8�w?9�8Y|�8 / OUQ T 9�8:M_S F�9

O_6�9WF�Q?O_8:ON25QR>z[ 9�FH2IQ K Q*X=[ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�VzMUO_8?F�M�~02EX=|�9�4�8?> 2 K 9�>0ON2EX / 7 X\F�Q T OP6�9 >�S TC. 9�FcQ*X�4�Q T [ QR>�9�>?OUMG2�> 8

T Q K 9?~*QRF .0/ Q?O_6�9�F T 9�8?>�M 7 O_6�9�w(8*;�S�9�Q*X �n|�9GQ . MN9�F�w?9?y f�6�25M T 25VR60O . 9 8?> 9�>�QRF T QRS�MU; / 4�Q T [�;I254�8*OU9 K

[ F�Q . ;59 T 2EX T Q K 9�MgQ*X T 8?> / K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O � 8?> K � |�9�F�9`8:;I;�9�wR2 K 9�>0O`8*O�QR>�4�9`2�>A8 MNON9�;5;�8?F�;525VR6?OY4�S F�w?9?y

j%QRF�O_S > 8:ON9�; / ~R|�9 K Q >�Q?On9+" [ 9�4�O�OUQ�Q . MN9�F�w?9 T Q K 9�MG|g2IOP6 � T S�476 VRF�9�8*OU9�F^O_6 8?> ��� =�QRF @ y�fg6�2IM

25M . 9�4�8?S�MN9W8*MnO_6�9Y>RS TC. 9�F�Q*X�>�Q K 8*;%;I2�>�9�M�QR>COP6�9�M_S F X\8*4�9�2�>�4�F�9�8*MU9�M�~ . F�25VR6?OU9�Fn8?> KzK 80FIH*9�F^F�9�V?25QR>�McQR>

9�25O_6�9�FcMN2 K 9�ON9�> K ONQW4�8?>�4�9�;%9�8*476 Q?O_6�9�F QRS�O^| 6�9�> w�2I9�|�9 K X\F�Q T 8(XZ8?Fvy C 9�Q . MN9�F�w09GQ�>�; / O_6�9�476 8?>�V02 >�V

Page 34: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

= E

��������# . F�25VR60O_>�9�MNMzQ*XW8AMUO_8?FW2�>0ON9�VRFN8:ON9 K Q*w?9�F 25ONMz9�>0ON2�F�9 w�25MN2 . ;59-MPS F XZ8:4�9?y�f�6�25Mz|�25;5;GOU9�> K ONQ-F�9�> K 9�F

T Q K 9�M�Q*X^;�8?F�V?9 ��S > K 9�ON9�4�OP8 . ;59 ��d ��259 TC. Q*|�M H02 ��� YVY y

K � K6� K �Y� �(�"!�� ����� �?�Z# �

fg6�9 [ 9�F�25Q K MCQ*XQP R T Q K 9�MWQ*X�V?25w?9�> � 8?F�9C9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K ONQ2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9 T QR>�Q0ONQR>�254�8*;5; / 8:MWO_6�9 >�S T�. 9�F

Q*XGFN8 K 2 8:;�>�Q K 9�M ��2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9�M�y`f�6�9CF�9�8*MNQ�>25MWO_6 8*OYO_6�9 . S�Q / 8?>0O F�9�MNONQ�F�2�>�VzXbQRF�4�9C25M`[ F�QR[ QRF�ON25QR> 8*; ONQ

O_6�9�ONQ?O_8*; T 8*MNM K 25M_[�;�8*4�9 K ~=8?> K O_6�25M T 8*MNMYV?9�ONMYM T 8:;I;59�FW8*MYO_6�9C>RS TC. 9�FYQ:XGFN8 K 2�8*;^>�Q K 9�MY2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�M�y

J |G9�8 H*9�F�F�9�MNOUQRF�2�>�VCXbQRF�4�9Y2 T [�;I259�MC8C;5QR>�V?9�F�[ 9�F�25Q K ��MN9�9?~�9?y V%y�~ e�Q " ���0�VE y

@W>�9CQ*XnOP6�9�MU2 T [�;I9�MUO T 9�O_6�Q K MWQ*X�4�8*;54�S�; 8:ON2�>�VAO_6�9z8*4�O_S 8:;=Q?MU4�2I;5;�8*ON25QR> [ 9�F�25Q K M�8�w(8*25;�8 . ;59 |�25O_6�2�>

8?> / F�9�MNQR> 80>?O 4�8�wR25O / 25M^O_6�95C {WD 8?[ [ F�Q "R2 T 8:ON25QR>+~�XZ8 T 25;I2�8?F OUQ 9�w?9�F / MNO_S K 9�>0O Q*X�2�>?O_FHQ K S�4�ONQ�F / a S 8?> R

O_S T T 9�476 80>�2I4�M�ynf�6�9 . 8*MU2IMcXbQRF O_6�25M�8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON25QR>C25MnOP6�9 8*MUM_S T [�ON25QR>COP6 8*O^O_6�9 FN8 K 2 8:;�|�8�w?9�;59�>�V?O_6

25M�w?9�F /zT S�476CMP6�QRF�ON9�F�O_6 8?>C;59�>�V?O_6 MU4�8*;59�MGQ*w?9�F |Y6�2I4�6 O_6�9 FH9�;I9�w*8?>0O [ 6 / MN254�8*;+w(8?F�2�8 . ;59�M�8?F�9g476 8?>�V02 >�V

|�25O_6�2�>3O_6�9C4�8�w�2IO / y`fg6�2IM�|�25;5; . 9 T Q�F�9�>�9�8?FH; / O_FUS�9`XbQRF P R T Q K 9�MWQ*Xn;�8?FHV?9��=yCo\>�O_6�25M � 8*M / T [�ONQ?OU2I4

;52 T 25O�~ � O_6�9 Ci{WDi8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON25QR> / 2I9�; K MWO_6�9WMU2 T [�;I9zF�9�;�8*OU2IQ�>�M_6�2�[

��� ��� �

� � � � � ���� *�� � � � ���� ��� � � � = yB=

| 6�9�F�9����A25MWO_6�9�PSR T Q K 9z[ 9�F�25Q K XbQRFY8 V?25w?9�>�w(8*;�S�9zQ:X � ~�8?> K � � 25M�8 4�QR>�MNO_8?>0OYO_6 8*O K 9�[ 9�> K M�QR>

O_6�9WQ*w?9�FN8:;I;�MNO_FNS�4�O_S FH9WQ*X=O_6�9�MNO_8?F ��MN9�9?~ 9?y V�y�~ f 8*MNMNQRS�; ���0�VE ~ {W8�| 8:;I9�F ���?�VO y �

?�a S 8:ON25QR>�M � = y �� 8?> K � = yB= ;59�8 K S�M ONQ 9+" [ 9�4�OA8�F�9�;�8*ON25w?9�; / Q�F K 9�F�; / [ 8*ONON9�FU> Q*X T Q K 9�MzX\F�Q T

Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�M�Q*X [ S�;5M_8:ON2�>�V-|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F X 80> K k C d MNO_8?FHM�y�o >�[ 8?F�OU2I4�S�;�8?Fv~D?�a S 8:ON25QR> � = y>= 2 T [�;5259�M

O_6 8*O T Q K 9�M^Q:X 8�V?25w?9�> �nM_6�QRS�; K X Q�F T 8gMN9�a S�9�>�4�9 . 8*MN9 K S [ QR>C8�X\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*; [ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V�� �

� � ��� � � � � �� y j F�Q T ?^a S 8*ON25QR>�� = y �� ~�|�9�M_S�M_[ 9�4�OnO_6 8*O^9�8:476 T Q K 9Y2�>CO_6�25M�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9 T 25VR60O^9+" 6�2 . 25O

= � �i� 4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONMYM_[�;525OW9�a S 8*;5; / 2�> XZF�9�a S�9�>�4 / ~+9�25O_6�9�F .?/ F�Q0O_8*ON25QR> QRFgMNQ T 9WQ?OP6�9�F T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T ~+8*M

;5QR>�VA8*M��� � �� � � � y f�6�25MW25MWO_6�9CQ*w?9�FN8*;5;=[ 8:ONON9�FN>x|G9�MN9�9FHOP6 F�QRS�VR6xO_6�9`Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>�M K 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 K

2�>O_6�9`>�9+"�OYOu|�Q�476 8?[�OU9�F�M�y

@W>�4�9|�9 2 K 9�>?ON2EX / OP6�9A[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V3X\F�Q T 83[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V�MNO_80F�B M`;525VR60ON4�S F�w?9?~c|�9 4�80>�4�Q T [ 8?F�9

O_6�25M�M_[ 8:4�2 >�V ONQCO_6 8*O�2�> T Q K 9�;5M�ONQ K 9�4�2�[ 6�9�F�O_6�9WMUO_8?F�B McMNO_FNS�4�OPS F�9?yn{W8�|�8*;59�F � ���?�VO X Q�S > K O_6 8*O�O_6�9� R>=/I2 U�U�ST6?STAKB=2 � @3A5B�<.6.25BD6� 'ST< 2�<.<?;=E /3U&6.A ��/R<.E 2���78�6?>�A5; 5>$ST6.< /(��2�@36 �52 � ;=/RUD/�N�/�B=UD<IA5B 6?>=/�� AK;DB�UD2K1)C&@3AKB=U�ST6?STAKB=<3V

� S B�@3/&6?>=/"2�@36?;=2 � ��A5;�B=UD2K1)C @ AKB=U ST6?STA5B�<&U�/)N�/�B=UA5B 6?>=/ N�/�1.STA�U�8� �ND1)A �=2 � �TC U�A�/3<38=6.A�A�V

Page 35: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

= �

[ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F � � 2�> MNO_8*ON254 k C d T Q K 9�;IMC25M K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>0Oz[ F�2 T 8?F�25; / Q�>3O_6�9 Q(w09�FN8*;5;^MNON9�;5;�8?F T 8*MNMC8?> K

;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / ~ |�25O_6�8|�9�8VH K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>�4�9QR>t4�Q T [ Q0MN25ON25QR>+y {W8�|�8*;59�F � D�FN8 K ;59 / � ���?� J [ FH9�MN9�>?O�O_6�9

8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9`F�9�;�8*OU2IQ�>

� ��� � A A � �� ��� � * � � � �

�FEVE � ��� � � � � � � ������FE � � � � � � ��� � * � � = yB@

| 6�9�F�9 ��� 25M�O_6�9 XZFU8*4�ON25QR> .0/ T 8:MNM�Q*X�mg9�8:OGOP6�9WM_S F X\8*4�9?y �

K � K6� Z �L!���� �������=� �Z# �

J ] > 8*; 4�Q T [�;5254�8*ON25QR> 4�QR>�4�9�FN>�2�>�VAO_6�9C9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K [ 8*ONON9�FN>xQ*X T Q K 9�MW4�8?> . 9z4�8?S�MN9 K�.0/ 4�Q T [ Q R

MN25ON25QR> K 25MN4�Q�>?ON2�>�S�25ON259�Mz|�25O_6�2�>�OP6�9�MUO_8?F�yCh�9�4�8*;5;�O_6 8*OW[ Q?MUO9R J � DLMUO_8?F�MW8?F�9CMNO_FU8*ON2E]�9 K ~�|�25O_6 8e��?@

4�QRF�9CQ*w?9�F�;�8*2 K�.0/ 8F�9�;�8*ON25w?9�; / [ S F�9zmg9�;�8 / 9�FW8?> K [ 9�FN6 8?[�M�8:;IMUQA8zO_6�2�>3;�8 / 9�FYQ*XGm 8*OYO_6�9CM_S F X\8*4�9?y

f�6�9�Ci{WD 8*MNM_S T [�ON25QR>�Mz8?F�9w�2IQ0; 8:ON9 K >�9�8?FCO_6�9 O_FN80>�MN25ON25QR> ��QR>�9 X\F�Q T QR>�9;�8 / 9�F�ONQ�8?>�Q?O_6�9�F�~c8*M

O_6�9 T 9�8?> T Q?;59�4�S�;�8?FC|�9�25VR60O`4�6 8?>�V?9�M T S�476 T QRF�9 a S�2I4+H0; / O_6 8?> 9�w?9�> O_6�96�2IV�6�9�MNO�� |�8�w?9CX\S >�4TR

ON25QR>+ynmgQ*|�9�w?9�F�~?OP6�9 9 ��9�4�O�Q*X=O_6�9�MU9 K 2IMU4�QR>?OU2 >�S�25ON259�M 25M�X\8*2�F�; / MN2 T [�;59?~�8*Mc] F�MNO K 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 K 8?> 8*; / ON254�8*;5; /

.0/ e�8?FH;=m 80>�MN9�> � ���0� Yz[ F�25w(8:ON9C4�Q TzT S >�254�8*ON25QR> 80> K 9+" [�;IQ�F�9 K).0/ {W8�|�8*;59�F � C�9�25MNM � ���?�VE 8?> K

D�FN8*MNMP8?F K 9�O 8*;by � ���?� �� y

Ci6�9�> QR>�9Q:X O_6�9A>�Q K 9�Mz2�>l8�FN8 K 2 8:;G|�8�w?9 XZS >�4�OU2IQ�> 4�Q?2�>�4�2 K 9�M |g2IOP6 O_6�9O_FU8?>�MN25ON25QR> . 9�O�|�9�9�>

;�8 / 9�F�M�~�25ONM8 T [�;525O_S K 9 . 9�;5Q*| O_6�9AOPFN8?>�MN25ON25QR> F�9�V?25QR> 25MVRFH9�8*ON; / K 2 T 2�>�2IMP6�9 K 7 O_6�9 T Q K 9 . 9�4�Q T 9�M

� O_FU8?[ [ 9 K �32�> O_6�9QRS�ON9�F�;�8 / 9�F�MCQ*X OP6�9 MNOP8?F�y�f�6�25Mz|�25;5;�MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0ON; / 8*;5ON9�FCO_6�9[ 9�F�25Q K 4�Q T [ 8?F�9 K

ONQ3O_6 8*O�2EX O_FU8?[ [�2�>�V K 2 K >+B OzO_8VH:9 [�;�8*4�9?y)< S . MN9�a S�9�>0O T Q K 9�MC|�25;5; 6 8�w?9 >�Q K 9�Mz| 6�254�6 XZ8:;I;�QRS�OUMN2 K 9

O_6�9 K 25MN4�QR>0ON2�>RS�25O / yzf�6�9�2�FW[ 9�FH2IQ K MC|�25;5; . 9z4�;5Q?MN9�FYOUQO_6�9z8*M / T [�ONQ?ON254�w(8*;�S�9�M�XZFHQ T ?�a S 8:ON25QR> � = yB= y

?^w09�>?O_S 8:;I; / ~%4�QR>�MN9�4�S�ON25w?9zFN8 K 2 8:; T Q K 9�M |�25;5;n6 8�w?9`>�Q K 9�M | 6�254�638*VR8*2�>A80[ [ F�QR8*4�6 O_6�9 K 25MN4�Q�>?ON2�>�S�25O / ~

O_FN80[ [�2 >�V3|�25;5; 8*V�8*2�> . 9�4�Q T 9 MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0O�~�8?> K O_6�9[ 8*ONON9�FN> |�25;5;�F�9�[ 9�8*O�y�f�6�25Mz4 / 4�;59�Q*X�w(8?F�2�8*OU2IQ�>

8�|�8 / XZFHQ T 8?> K O_6�9�> . 8*4+HCONQ`8?> 8�w09�FN8*V?9 [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�VC25MGHR>�Q*| >z8:MnO_6�9 ���3� � � �*�2(�+�; +�#G� �bD�FN8 K ;I9 /

���?� J y�f�6�9 ���3� � � ���( � ������"� ~?| 6�254�6`25McO_6�9G>�S TC. 9�F^Q:X T Q K 9�M^Q:X�4�QR>�MN9�4�S�ON25w?9�� . 9�O�|�9�9�>�9�8*4�6�FH9�O_S FN>

ONQ38�w09�FN8*V?9zMP[ 8*4�2�>�V�~ K 9�[ 9�> K M QR>�OP6�9 K 9�[�O_6 Q:X OP6�9 O_FU8?>�MN25ON25QR>���QR>�9 4�80S�MN2�>�V�O_6�9 O_FN8?[ [�2�>�V�y3f�6�9

VRF�9�8:ON9�FcO_6�9 K 9�[�O_6 Q:X�O_6�9 K 25MN4�Q�>?ON2�>�S�25O / ~+OP6�9WM T 8*;5;59�F�OP6�9WO_FN8?[ [�2�>�V 4 / 4�;59?y��0A�6./"6?>=2�6�6?>=/"<?S�KB AK4 6?>=/"/���N�A5B�/)BD6 S B 6?>=/��6./�1)E ST<�S B /�1.1)AK1�S B % 259R2 �T/)1 $ �I1)2 U �T/ C������ � )*"�V

Page 36: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

=V=

C 9�8?F�9C>�Q*|i9�a S�2�[ [ 9 K |�25O_6xMNQ T 9C[ Q*|�9�F X\S�;=ONQ�Q?;5MgX QRF O_6�9z[ Q?MNMU2 . ;59zMUO_S K / Q*Xn| 6�25ON9 K | 80F XG8?> K

k C d MNO_8?F�M�y6C�9�|�25;5;�MN9�9�2�>CO_6�9cXbQ?;5;5Q(|g2 >�V�476 80[�ON9�F�M^O_6 8*O ONQW8Y;�8?F�V?9�9+"�ON9�>?O^OP6�9�2 F^[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>z[ 8*ONOU9�FN>�M

F�9�8*;5; /�K Q�4�QR>0X Q�F T ONQO_6�9 9+" [ 9�4�O_8*ON25QR>�M�|�9 6 8�w?9YrHS�MNO�QRS�ON;52�>�9 K yA@YO_6�9�F a S�9�MNOU2IQ�>�M�~^6�Q(|�9�w?9�Fv~+|�25;I;

QR>�; /z. 9 80>�MN|�9�F�9 K XZF�Q T H�>�Q*|�;59 K V?9�Q*X�O_6�9g4�8?S�MN9�Q*X OP6�9G;525VR60Onw*8?F�2�8*ON25QR>�M^|�9 T 9�8*M_S FH9?y�o >CO_6�9�4�8*MN9�Q*X

O_6�9Wk C dWM�~0O_6�25M�25M�476�259PXn8 T QR>�V�O_6�9 T`/ MNON9�FH2I9�M�|�9Y|GQ�S�; K ;52 H*9WONQCMNQ0;Iw09?y�fg6�9 T Q?MNOcON9�;5;I2�>�V 4�;�S�9W|�25;I;

. 9YO_6�9Y9+"ROU9�>?OcQ*X�O_6�9 FH9�V?25QR>zQ:X�2�>�MNOP8 . 25;I25O / 2 > OP6�9 m5Ruh K 2 8:VRFN8 T 7 K 9�FH2Iw09 K 2�>[ 8?F�O�XZFHQ T [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�> 8*;

8?> 8*; / MN25M�Q*X^O_6�9YMNO_FNS�4�O_S FH9WQ*X=MNO_80F�M�| 6�25476 . FN8:4 H*9�O�O_6�25M FH9�V?25QR>+ynf�6�9`>�9+"�O�MN9�4�ON25QR>[ FHQ(w�2 K 9�M�MNQ T 9 Q*X

O_6�9 . 8*4+H0VRF�QRS > K |�9W|�25;5;�>�9�9 K ONQ 8*OUO_8*4+HCO_6�9�MN9W25MNM_S�9�M�y

� ��� �R# ���G � #'� ��� ��(� �� (�� � �&( ��� �&� �R� �R�&! � � � ��� �&( � � �&� �R� ��0���R���

o >z8WMUO_8?F�~09�>�9�F�V / V?9�>�9�FN8*;5; / � Q*|�M K Q(|Y>CO_6�9�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9 V�FN8 K 259�>?O�XZFHQ T O_6�9Y4�9�>?O_FU8*;�F�9�V?25QR>�M�ONQ

O_6�9YM_S F X\8*4�9Y2 >8�M T QRQ?OP6+~RF�9�;�8*ON25w?9�; / S >�2 T [ 9 K 9 K X\8*M_6�25QR>+yn@gX=4�Q�S F�MN9YM T 8*;5;b~�FN8?> K Q T [ 9�F�O_S F . 8:ON25QR>�M

ONQ3O_6�25MzM T QRQ?OP6 � Q(| 4�QR>�MUO_8?>0ON; / 8?FH2IMU9?y fg6�9MN25O_S 8*ON25QR> 25MzMNOP8 . ;59A8*Mz;5QR>�V)8*MCM_S�4�6l[ 9�F�O_S F . 8:ON25QR>�M

a S�2I4+H0; / K 8 T [tQRS�O�~=FH9�MNONQRF�2�>�V�9�a S�25;52 . F�2�S T y�C�9 6 8�w09 8*;�F�9�8 K /3K 25MN4�S�MNMN9 K O�|�Q T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T MC| 6�254�6

ON9�> K ONQ*|�8?F K 9�a S�25;52 . F�2�S T snOP6�9 F�9�MNONQ�F�2�>�V�XbQRF�4�9�M^Q*X . S�Q / 8?>�4 / 80> K [ FH9�MNM_S F�9�|Y6�2I4�6 K 9P] >�9�OP6�9 > 8:O_S F�9

Q*X PSRG8?> K � R T Q K 9�M�y fg6�9 / F�9�MN25MNO T 8*MNM T Q?ON25QR>�MW8?> K ;IQ�4�8*;^4�Q T [ F�9�MNMN25QR>xQRF�9+" [ 8?>�MN25QR>�Q*X T 8*ON9�F�2�8*;

8�|�8 / XZF�Q T 9�a S�25;52 . FH2 S T 4�QR> K 25ON25QR>�M�y

fg6�9�F T Q K / > 8 T 2I4 a S 8?>0ON25ON259�MCM_S�4�6)8*MWOP6�9 K 9�F�25w(8*OU2Iw09�MzQ*XGOU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9 8?> K QR[ 8*4�25O / 8���9�4�OWO_6�9

a S�9�MNON25QR>�Q*XG;5Q�4�8*;^9�a S�2I;52 . F�2�S T yzo >3V?9�>�9�FN8*;b~+2EX T 8*ON9�F�2�8*; 2�>�8zMUO_8?Fg2IMW4�Q T [ F�9�MNMN9 K ~+25ONMWOU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9

V?Q�9�M�S [z| 6�25;59W25ONM�QR[ 8:4�2IO /CK 9�4�F�9�8*MU9�M�ynf�6�9W6�25VR6�9�F�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9 4�8?S�MU9�M T QRF�9 FN8 K 2 8:ON25QR> ONQ � Q*| QRS�O

ONQzOP6�9WM_S FNF�QRS > K 2�>�V T 8*ON9�FH2 8:; ~ | 6�25;I9C;5Q*|�9�FnQ�[ 8*4�25O / K 9�4�F�9�8*MU9�M O_6�9W9 � 4�2I9�>�4 / |�25O_6|Y6�2I4�6AFU8 K 2�8*ON25QR>

25M�8 . MUQRF . 9 K yCj+F�Q T O_6�9 ] F�MNOW;�8�| Q*X�O_6�9�F T Q K / > 8 T 254�M�~=8?>t2 >�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�VAON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9 8*4�4�Q T [ 8?>�259 K

.0/ >�9�Oz6�9�8*O�;5Q?MNMC2 T [�;52I9�M O_6 8*O`|�QRF H25M . 9�2�>�V K QR>�9 QR>3O_6�9[ 8?F�4�9�; .?/ 25ONMCM_S FNFHQRS > K 2�>�V?M�yA<�2 T 25;�8?F

8?F�V�S T 9�>?OUMzM_6�Q*|'O_6 8*O |�QRFIH 25M K QR>�9�QR> OP6�9-[ 8?F�4�9�; K S F�2�>�V 9+" [ 8?>�MN25QR>+~�8*;5MNQ�yifg6RS�M8?> / 2 >�25ON2�8*;

[ 9�FHO_S F . 8*ON25QR> |�25;5; . 9 a S�2I4+H0; / K 8 T [ 9 K QRS�O 7 9�8*4�6 [ 8?F�4�9�; K 9 T 8?> K MC|�QRFIH�ONQ K Q-Q0O_6�9�F�|�25MN9?y3f�6�9

F�9�a S�2�F�9 T 9�>0O O_6 8:O 83F�9�V02IQ�> ;5Q?MN9A6�9�8*O | 6�9�> 4�Q T [ F�9�MUMN9 K 8?> K V�8*2�> 6�9�8*Oz| 6�9�> 9+" [ 8?> K 9 K 25M O_6�9

X\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*;�4�F�25ON9�FH2IQ�> XbQRF MNO_8 . 25;525O / y Ci6�9�> O_6�9AQR[ [ Q?MN25ON9325M OPFNS�9?~�8?> K |�QRF H 2IM K QR>�9 .0/lT 8*MNM

9�;59 T 9�>0ONM Q�>O_6�9�2�FgM_S FNF�QRS > K 2�>�V?M K S FH2 >�V 4�Q T [ FH9�MNMN25QR>A80> K 9+" [ 8?>�MN25QR>+~ T 254�F�Q?MU4�QR[�254 [ 9�F�O_S F . 8:ON25QR>�M

Page 37: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

=V@

4�8?> VRFHQ(| ONQ . 9�4�Q T 9�O_6�9WQ . MN9�FHw?9 K w(8?FH2 8:ON25QR>�M 2�>�[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V MUO_8?F�M�y

K � Z6� ' �C+� W �9X �L� �0+�+#����*,

}Y> K 9�Fg4�9�F�O_8*2�>�4�2�F�4�S T MNO_80>�4�9�M�~+O_6�9`MU2IV�>AQ:XnO_6�9`QR[ 8:4�2IO /K 9�F�25w*8*ON25w?9z4�6 8?>�V?9�MY4�Q T [ 8?FH9 K ONQ O_6 8*O

K 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 K 8 . Q*w?9?yzo XGO_6�9zQ�[ 8*4�25O / ~ W�~�2 >�4�FH9�8*MN9�MzS [ QR>t4�Q T [ F�9�MNMU2IQ�>+~=OP6�9�>�6�9�8*O � Q*|�2�>�VAO_6 FHQRS�VR638

T 8*MUMn9�;59 T 9�>0O�25MGOPFN8?[ [ 9 K O_6�9�F�9 T QRFH9 9 � 4�259�>0ON; / y C 25O_6�2�>F�9�V?25QR>�M�| 6�9�FH9 O_6�25M�25M�O_FNS�9?~0|�QRFIH�25M K QR>�9

QR> O_6�9YM_S FNF�QRS > K 2�>�V T 8*OU9�F�2�8*;bynf�6�S�MnO_6�9�MN9WF�9�V?25QR>�M�4�8?> 6�9�;�[ K 9�MNO_8 . 25;52 ��9`O_6�9YMNO_80F�~?2EX=O_6�25M K F�25w�2 >�V 2IM

>�Q?O Q*w?9�F�4�Q T 9c9�;5MN9�| 6�9�F�9�2�>�O_6�9�MNO_80F�y=mgQ*|G9�w09�F�~�Q0O_6�9�F=FH9�V?25QR>�M�~?|Y6�9�F�9n|�QRFIHY25MnF�9�a S�2�F�9 K ONQY4�Q T [ FH9�MNM

8?> K 9+" [ 80> K T 8:ON9�F�2�8*;b~ ON9�> K ONQ K 8 T [ M_S�476 [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> QRS�O�y � ;IQ . 8*;n2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / 80F�25MN9�MCQR>�; / |Y6�9�>

O_6�9C|�QRFIH[ 9�F X Q�F T 9 K).0/ O_6�9 K F�25w�2�>�V-F�9�V?25QR>�MWQ�S�Ou|�9�25VR6�MWO_6�9C|�QRFIH K Q�>�9zQR>�O_6�9 K 8 T [�2�>�V-FH9�V?25QR>�M

Q*w?9�FY8 [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>34 / 4�;59?y`o >�O_6�25MW4�8*MN9?~+O_6�9 � Q*| Q:XnO_6�9�F T 8*; 9�>�9�F�V / 4�8?> K Q T 9�476 8?>�254�8*;^|�QRF H�~+8?> K

O_6�25MY|GQ�FIHC25M 4�Q�>?w?9�FHON9 K 2�>?ONQ O_6�9`[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�MY|�9WQ . MN9�F�w?9?y

fg6�2IM T 9�O_6�Q K Q:X K F�25w�2�>�V`[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>W25M 4�8*;5;59 K OP6�9 W T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T y J FH9�V?25QR>W|�25O_6�2�>C8�MNOP8?F+|�25;5; K FH2Iw09

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> w�2 8xO_6�25M T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T 2�XY2IOUMWQR[ 8*4�25O /-K 9�FH2Iw*8*ON25w?9�MCM_8*OU2IMHX / O_6�9z4�QR> K 25ON25QR>���MN9�9CXbQRFY2�>�MNO_80>�4�9

e�Q " ���0�VE ���

�W � �

W��� � �l� � � E � = y J

| 6�9�F�9

W ������� � W�� � � � � � W � �

��� � W�� ��� � � � 8?> K � � � � �

���� � ���� ��� ��

mg9�F�9�� FH9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONM OP6�9�MP[ 9�4�2E]�4z9�>0O_F�QR[ / ~ Wt2IMWOP6�9�Q�[ 8*4�25O / 2�>34 T � �*V%~ 8?> K O_6�9Cw*8?F�2�8 . ;59�M �~�� ~+8?> K

� 8*;5;=6 8�w?9WOP6�9�2 FYS�M_S 8*; T 9�8?>�2�>�V�y

?�a S 8:ON25QR> � = y J 25M M_8*ON25M�]�9 KlT Q?MNOz4�Q T T QR>�; / |Y6�9�> MNQ T 9M_[ 9�4�259�M|�25O_6�2�> 83MNO_80F`25M[ 8?F�ON2�8*;5; /

25QR>�2 ��9 K yGo >[ 8?F�ON254�S�;�8?F�~ W � S�MPS 8*;5; / 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�Mg2 > OP6�9 6�Q?OUON9�F ��2�> >�9�F [ QRF�OU2IQ�>zQ*X^8`[ 8?F�OU2 8:; 25QR>�2 ��8*OU2IQ�>

��QR>�9 80> K�K 9�4�FH9�8*MN9�Mn2�>COP6�9G4�Q�Q?;59�F � QRS�ON9�F [ QRFHON25QR>+y^f�6RS�M^OP6�9�2�> >�9�Fn[ 8?F�O^Q:X 8?>�2IQ�>�2 ��8:ON25QR> ��Q�>�9 T 8 /

K F�25w?9Y| 6�25;59WO_6�9 Q�S�ON9�Fn[ 8?FHO K 8 T [�MG[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>+yGf�6�9Y8 K 2�8 . 8*ON254W9+" [ QR>�9�>0O�~�� � �3� ~�2IM�8*;5|�8 / M�[ Q?MU2IOU2Iw09

. S�O S�M_S 8:;I; / F�9�8*4�6�9�M 8 T 2�>�2 T S T | 6�9�> T 8*ON9�FH2 8:; 25M�[ 8?F�OU2 8:;I; / 25QR>�2 ��9 K y�f�6�25M�9�> 6 8?>�4�9 T 9�>0O�Q*X=OP6�9%W

T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T 2IMY4�8*;5;59 K O_6�9 X T 9�476 80>�2IM T yGkc6 / MN254�8*;5; / ~+O_6�9 X T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T FH9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONM�O_6�9�4�QR>?w09�F�MN25QR>

Q*X�MNQ T 9�Q*X�O_6�9�|�QRFIHYQ*X+4�Q T [ F�9�MNMU2IQ�>`2�>0ONQYX\S F�O_6�9�F�2IQ�>�2 ��8:ON25QR>zQ:X�O_6�9�M_[ 9�4�259�Mn2�>Ca S�9�MNON25QR>+y^f�6�25McON9�> K M

ONQ4�Q T [ F�9�MNM`OP6�9 [ 8?F�4�9�; T QRF�9?~�8*2 K 2�>�V3O_6�9z2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / yAh�9�;59�8*MN9 Q*X�O_6�25M`25QR>�2 ��8*OU2IQ�>�9�>�9�F�V /-K S FH2 >�V

Page 38: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

= J

9+" [ 8?>�MN25QR>�;52 H:9�|�25MN9C2 >�4�FH9�8*MN9�MWO_6�9`[ S F�OPS F . 8*ON25QR>+y�<�2�>�4�9CO_6�9 / S�M_S 8*;5; / Q�4�4�S FYONQ?V09�O_6�9�F�~�2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525ON259�M

4�8?S�MN9 K3.?/. Q0O_6 O_6�9WQR[ 8*4�25O / 8?> K 25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR>�9 ��9�4�ONM�8?F�9%H�>�Q*| >8*M�OP6�9%WSRUX T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T y

fg6�9 [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>�MzQ*X e�9�[ 6�9�2 K 8?> K hgh'p / FN8*9 w(8?F�2�8 . ;59�M�~cXbQRF 2 >�MUO_8?>�4�9?~�8?F�9 K F�25w?9�> wR2�8�O_6�9�W RUX

T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T QR[ 9�FU8*ON2�>�VC|�25O_6�2�> 8�F�9�V?25QR> | 6�9�F�9Wm�9�o^8?> K mg9�ouo^6 8�w?9gMN2 T 25; 80F�8 . S > K 8?>�4�9�M�ycf�6�25MGMP8 T 9

[ 8?F�OU2 8:;=25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR> ��QR>�9C25MW8?[ [ 8?F�9�>0ON; / O_6�9CMNQRS F�4�9�Q*Xn2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / XbQRF�OP6�9`d`D�� | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�y�f�6�9

w(80F�2�8*ON25QR>�MzQ . MU9�F�w?9 K 2 > � � e�9�ON2c| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�6 8�w?9z;5QR>�V . 9�9�> 8*ONOPF�2 . S�ON9 K OUQ-[ 8?F�OU2 8:;G25QR>�2 ��8*OU2IQ�>

Q*X m�y^m�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~ � Q?; K F�9�25476 � C)S�� ���0�?� 6 8�w?9F�9�4�9�>?OU; / M_6�Q*| > O_6�9 � � e�9�ON2�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�Mz4�80> . 9

K F�25w?9�>xO_6 F�QRS�VR68 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T 2�>x9 � 4�259�>?OYM_S F X\8*4�9W4�QR>0w?9�4�ON25QR>+y � � F�9�8*O�9 ��QRF�ONM�6 8�w?9 . 9�9�>

9+" [ 9�> K 9 K�.?/ O_6�9�QRFH2IMUONM 8:ONON9 T [�ON2�>�VzOUQ�9+" [�;�8*2�> � C � 2�FY8?> K k � ��� [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>�MY2 >�ON9�F T M�Q*X�MUQ T 9

4�Q TC. 2�> 8*ON25QR>3Q:X e 80> K @'[ 8?F�OU2 8:;^2IQ�>�2 ��8:ON25QR>��Z<�O_8?FNF ]�9�; K 9�O�8:; y ���?� @ � <�O_8?>�VR6�9�;5;52�>�2 ~ce�Q " ~ � <�OP8?F R

F ]�9�; K ���?�?� y J [ FH2 T 8?F /3K 2 � 4�S�;5O / 8?F�25MN9�MWX\F�Q T OP6�9 K 8 T [�2�>�V39 ��9�4�ONMWQ*X m�9 2 > O_6�9 K FH2Iw�2�>�V ��QR>�9?~

| 6�254�6z4�8?> � [ Q?25MNQR> �`OP6�9 K F�25w�2�>�V�y^13QRF�9 FH9�4�9�>?ON; / ~ < 8*25Q�� ���?� O 80> K � 8?S�ONMN4�6 / � ���?� Y 8*ONON9 T [�ON9 K ONQ

9+" [�; 8:2 > K F�25w�2 >�V32�>3ON9�F T M Q:X 8?> � QR[ 8*4�25O /-. S T [ �2�>3O_6�9 T Q K 9�;5M�~�|�25O_6�QRS�O`[ 8?FHON2�8*;^25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR> 7 2�>

Q?O_6�9�FY|�QRF K M�~�S�MN2�>�VAO_6�9!W T 9�476 8?>�25M T 8*;5QR>�9?y J X\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*;n[ FHQ . ;59 T 6 8*M . 9�9�>3O_6�9z;�8*4+HQ*X�2�> R

XbQRF T 8*OU2IQ�>QR>xO_6�9`9+" 8*4�OY9+"RON9�>0OYQ*XnO_6�9C2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNOPF�2�[A8?> K O_6�9�MNO_FNS�4�O_S FH9`Q*XnO_6�9z[ S�;5M_8*OU2 >�VMUO_8?F�M

O_6�9 T MU9�;Iw09�M�y`@WS FYV?QR8:;=2�>�O_6�9z>�9+"ROWOP6 F�9�9C476 8?[�OU9�F�M |g2I;5; . 9CONQ K 9P] >�9 8*MW[ F�9�4�25MN9�; / 8*MW[ Q?MNMU2 . ;59 O_6�9

Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR> 8:;�8*OUO_F�2 . S�ON9�MW| 6�254�6-80> / [ F�Q�[ Q?MN9 K3K F�25w�2�>�VAMNQRS FH4�9 T S�MNOWF�9�[ F�Q K S�4�9?y Ci6�9�O_6�9�FgQRFY>�Q?O

O_6�9 T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T |�9W2 K 9�>0ON2EX / 2IMY4�QRFNFH9�4�O�~�|G9`6�Q�[ 9`OUQz;�8 / O_6�9WVRFHQRS > K |�QRFIH�XbQRFcX\S�O_S F�9WMNOPS K 2I9�MY| 6�254�6

|�25;5;=9�w09�>?O_S 8:;I; / [ F�Q*w�2 K 9�8 K 9P] >�25ON25w?9z8?>�MN|�9�FcONQzOP6�2IMga S�9�MNOU2IQ�>+y

K � Z6� K �`!+�(��� ��� ��"!�#�� � �R P�C�R�%# .�*�"&=�b#�� �+#�� , � �v� ��&+� � �Y� �*��!�� �

Ci6�9�>3[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> K Q�9�MWO_8VH*9C[�;�8*4�9z2�>38 MNO_8?F�~%|�9`|�25M_6�ONQ�H�>�Q(|L| 6 8*O`FH9�; 8:ON25QR>�M_6�2�[3O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V

6 8*M�ONQ�O_6�9 [ 9�F�25Q K MY|�9�Q . MN9�FHw?9?yno\> V?9�>�9�FN8:; ~%>�Q�MUO_8?F^|g2I;5;�F�9�M_[ QR> K ONQ K F�25w�2 >�V 8*O�rNS�MNO�8?> / 8?F . 25O_FN80F /

[ 9�FH2IQ K � O_6�9 FN8?>�V?9CQ*X�Q . MN9�FHw?9 K w(8?F�2�8*OU2IQ�>�M�25MCF�9�MNO_F�254�ON9 K .?/ O_6�9 K FH2Iw�2�>�V T 9�476 80>�2IM T y e�Q " � ���?�VE

M_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8:O O_6�9z8?[ [ FHQ "�2 T 8*ON9C[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�[ 9�F�25Q K 2IM K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9 K).0/ O_6�9CO_6�9�F T 8*; ON2 T 9�MN4�8:;I9 Q*XnO_6�9� � ;=@ >�@3A5B ��/3@36?STA5B �3AKB=/3<&AK476./�B 2�@3@3A E$N=2KBDC1)/�5STAKB=< AK4�N=2K1)6?ST2�RSTAKBDS��32�6?STA5B 2�<.<.A�@�ST2 6./3U 9RST6?> 6?>�/���P���E /3@.>=2KBDST<.E V

- A59R/ ��/�158�6?>=/ U�1.S���S B $N�1)A5N�A�<./ U �DC�� A�TU 1)/�ST@.> $ H ; ST< B�A 6RU S 1)/ @36 �TC 1)/ �T2�6./3U 6.A"STAKBDS��32�6?STA5B'V��76 ST< N�A�<.<?S�� �T/$6?>DST<R6?>=/3AK1)CE$S�5>D6�/ ��/�BD6?;=2 ���TC���/ /���N=2KB=UD/3U 6.A&2�@3@ AK;DBD6 4 AK1:J � � N�; �T<.2�6?STA5B�2 <I9:/ ���7V��76 ST<R;DB � S�� / �TC 6.A���B=U 25N�N � ST@32 6?STAKB S B F H�J0<386?>=AK; K> 8�<?S B�@3/&E A�UD/ �T< A54 F�� � � � <.6.251)< /�B=/�1)2 ���TC UDA$B=A�6 <?;DNDN�AK1)60@3AKB � /3@36?STAKB V

Page 39: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

=VA

K F�25w�2 >�V ��QR>�9?s

� � ����� ����� � ���� � = yBA

mg9�F�9 ����� 25MWO_6�9�O_6�9�F T 8:;=ON2 T 9�MU4�8*;59?~ ��� 25M`6�9�8*OW4�8?[ 8*4�25O / ~ 80> K ��� 25MWO_6�9 T 8*MNMW8 . Q(w09`O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V

��QR>�9?y f�6�25M 9�a S 8*ON25QR> V?25w?9�M O_6�9-8?[ [ FHQ "�2 T 8*ON9OU2 T 9A25O OP8VH*9�MCO_6�9AMUO_8?FCONQ�FN8 K 2 8:ON9-8�|�8 / 7 w�2�8325ONM

>�QRF T 8*; ;�S T 2�>�Q?MNO / ~� 7 O_6�9�9�>�9�FHV / 4�QR>?OP8*2�>�9 K 2�> O_6�9�;�8 / 9�F�MG8 . Q*w?9�O_6�9 F�9�V02IQ�>C2�>za S�9�MNON25QR>+ynfg6�QRS�VR6

e�Q " K 9�F�25w?9 K OP6�2IMCF�9�;�8*ON25QR>�M_6�2�[�XbQRFWFN8 K 2 8:; T Q K 9�M�~ C 2�>�V?9�O � ���?� �� M_6�Q*|G9 K O_6 8:O 25O`8?[ [�;5259�MC9�a S 8*;5; /

|�9�;5;�ONQ >�QR> FU8 K 2�8*; PSR T Q K 9`[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>+y

fg6�9 . 8*MN254`2 K 9�8 . 9�6�2�> K ?^a S 8*ON25QR>� = yBA 25M�O_6 8*Og9�>�9�F�V /T S�MUO . 9 T Q K S�;�8*OU9 K 8*O 80[ [ F�Q "R2 T 8*OU9�; /

O_6�9�M_8 T 9CFN8*ON9`8*OY| 6�254�6A25OY4�8?> . 9 K 8 TzT 9 K S [-80> K F�9�;59�8*MN9 K�.0/ O_6�9 K FH2Iw�2�>�V ��QR>�9?y e QR>�MN2 K 9�FYO_6�9

a S�9�MNON25QR> Q*X�| 6�9�O_6�9�F�8�V?25w?9�> ��QR>�9W4�8?> K F�25w?9W[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>>�9�8?F�8�4�9�F�O_8*2�> [ 9�F�25Q K yGo X=O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9

25MCONQRQ�M_6 8*;5;5Q*|`~ O_6�9�>�OP6�9 O_6�9�F T 8*;nOU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59 25MCM_6�QRFHON9�FWO_6 80>3O_6�9[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> [ 9�FH2IQ K y J > / 9+"�4�9�MNM

6�9�8*O�2IMzFN8 K 2 8:ON9 K 8�|�8 /3. 9PXbQRF�9 O_6�9z4�Q T [ F�9�MNMN25QR> 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�MCMN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0ON; / y-fg6RS�M�~�25O�4�80>+B O K Q�|GQ�FIH

ONQ 4�F�9�8*ON9 T 9�4�6 8?>�254�8*;cQ?MN4�25;5; 8:ON25QR>�Q�>AOP6�9�OU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59z2�>3a S�9�MNON25QR>+yCo�X�O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9z25M`ONQ�Q K 9�9�[

� ����� � � ~+O_6�9�>�9+"R4�9�MUM�6�9�8*O . S�25;5O�S [ K S FH2 >�V�4�QR>0O_FN8*4�ON25QR>�25M`>�Q?O`FN8 K 2 8:ON9 K 8�|�8 / a S�2I4+H0; / 9�>�QRS�VR6

K S F�2�>�VC9+" [ 80>�MN25QR> � 2IOcO_6�9�>C|�QRFIH0M^8*VR8*2�>�MNO^O_6�9Y>�9+"ROc4�QR>?OPFN8*4�ON25QR>�4 / 4�;I9?yc@gX�4�Q�S F�MN9?~?OP6�2IM�F�9�;�8*ON25QR>�M_6�2�[

25MWQR>�; / 8?[ [ FHQ "�2 T 8*ON9?~+8?> K Q?O_6�9�F X\8*4�ONQRF�M T 25VR60O 2�>0ON9�F�w?9�>�9CONQ ;52 T 25O�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>tONQ [ 9�F�25Q K M XZ80F�X\F�Q T

X\F�Q T O_6�Q?MU9�2 T [�;5259 K .0/ ?�a S 8:ON25QR> � = y>A yC@W>�9zM_S�4�6�XZ8:4�ONQRFY25M`O_6�9 FN8?>�V?9zQ:X [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�Mz8 MNOP8?FY4�8?>

M_S�MNOP8*2�>2�>�O_6�9WXbQRF T Q:XnMNO_8?> K 2�>�V | 8�w?9�M�yGmY8?>�MN9�>+~ C 2 >�V09�O�~ � {W8�| 8:;I9�F�� ���0� A M_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8*OgO_6�9�F�9

25M 8 T 8 "�2 T S T [ 9�F�25Q K XbQRF�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F Xn8?> K k C d MNO_80F�M�8 . Q*w?9W| 6�254�6�Q?MN4�25;5; 8:ON25QR>�MW|�25;5;�[ F�Q�[ 8*VR8*ON9

QR>�; / 8*MCFNS > >�2�>�V3| 8�w?9�M�O_6 8*OWa S�254 H0; /)K 8 T [3QRS�O�yf�6�9 / 8:ONON9 T [�OWONQ�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9 O_6�25M T 8 "R2 T S T P R

T Q K 9 [ 9�F�25Q K ~����� ?~?OUQ`9+" [�; 8:2 > OP6�9 Q . MU9�F�w?9 K O_FH9�> K Q*X � �Ae 9�ON2 [ 9�F�25Q K M�|�25O_6 � ��� y^m�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~*MUQ T 9

Q*X^O_6�9`a S 8?>0ON25ON259�M`F�9�a S�2 FH9 K XbQRF�80>9+" 8*4�O 4�8:;I4�S�;�8*OU2IQ�>-80F�9`Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�> 8*;5; / S >�4�QR>�MNO_FU8*2�>�9 K yGC�9�|�25;I;

O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9g4�QR>�4�9�FN> QRS F�MN9�;5w?9�McXbQRFn>�Q*|lQ�>�; / |�25O_6COP6�9 K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>�4�9`Q*X ���� Q�>Cw(8?FH2IQ�S�MGV0;IQ . 8*;�MNOU9�;I;�8?F

a S 8?>?OU2IOU2I9�M�y C�9W4�80>F�9�4�8*MNO�OP6�9�2 Fg9�a S 8*ON25QR>�M � O OP6 F�QRS�VR6 � � 8:M�O_6�9`[ F�QR[ QRF�ON25QR> 8:;I25O /

� ��� � � �

� � � � �i���� � ��� � = y O

| 6�9�F�9 � 25M`O_6�9CMNOU9�;I;�8?F�FN8 K 2�S�M`8?> K �C25MWO_6�9 [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>t2 > K 9+"32�>0O_F�Q K S�4�9 K 9�8?F�;5259�F�yCj�Q�F 8 4�Q T [�;I9�OU9

K 9�F�25w(8:ON25QR>�Q*X=O_6�25MY9�a S 8*OU2IQ�>+~ MN9�9`OP6�9`8?[ [ 9�> K 2 "+y

Page 40: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

= O

j%QRFc4�QRQ0; |Y6�2IOU9 K | 80F X M�Q*X^8CV?25w?9�> T 8*MUM�~�O_6�9`FN8 K 2�S�M�25M F�Q�S�VR6�; / 4�QR>�MUO_8?>0OG|g2IOP6 ON2 T 9?~�8?> K � ���

25M 9+" [ 9�4�OU9 K OUQz2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9C8*M MUO_8?F�M�9�w?Q?;5w?9�ONQz;5Q*|�9�F � ��� 8?> K O_6�9 K F�25w�2�>�V ��QR>�9�MN2�> H?M K 9�9�[ 9�F�y�e�Q�Q?;59�F

� ��e 9�ON2�8?> K d`D�� MNOP8?F�M�M_6�QRS�; K 2�>xV?9�>�9�FN8*;�6 8�w?9W;5QR>�V?9�F�[ 9�F�25Q K M � |G9Y|�25;5;=MU9�9W2 >xO_6�9`>�9+"�O�476 80[�ON9�F

O_6 8*O�~?XbQRF�OP6�9�� ��e�9�ON25M 8:O�;59�8*MNO�~ OP6�2IMg2IMY2�> K 9�9 K O_6�9W4�8*MN9 y

mgQ*|�9�w?9�F�~ 2�>3k C dWM K 9�V?9�>�9�FU8*4 / 25M`>�Q?O / 9�OYM_S � 4�259�>?OWOUQ 6 8�w?9`6 8*;5ON9 K 4�QR>0O_FN8:4�ON25QR>+~ 80> K OP6�9 �

K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>�4�925MC[ F�Q . 8 . ; / MNON25;5;n8 XZ8:4�ONQRFY2�> K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�2�>�V�6�Q*| ���� �w*8?F�259�M`OP6 F�QRS�VR6�O_6�9C2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O /

MNO_FH2 [+y C�9Y4�8?> >�Q?O / 9�O^M_8 / | 6�25476 K Q T 2�> 8*OU9�M�s O_6�9�M_6 F�2�> H02�>�V FN8 K 2�S�M�| 6�25476 ON9�> K McONQ K 9�4�F�9�8:MN9 ���� *~

QRFgO_6�9�XZ8:;I;52�>�V � � � |Y6�2I4�636 8*MWO_6�9CQR[ [ Q?MN25ON9z9 ��9�4�O�y�C�9C4�8?> >�Q?OW9�w09�>-[ FH9 K 2I4�O�2�>-8 K w(8?>�4�9z|Y6�9�O_6�9�F

���� z25M�8 XZ8*4�OUQRFY2�> K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�2�>�V�O_6�9 [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> [ 9�F�25Q K M 8:O`8*;5; yo >�e�6 8?[�ON9�F�A ~�|�9z8?>�MN|�9�F O_6�9�MN9

a S�9�MNON25QR>�MY2 >xwR259�|LQ*X=O_6�9�Q . MN9�F�w09 K [ F�QR[ 9�FHON259�M Q*X . Q0O_6 O_6�9`k � ��� 8?> K � C� 2�FgMNO_8?F�M�y

� � � �&�I��� � � � � () "! �'�R�����

J M^| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX Mn8?> K k C dWM=9�w0Q?;5w?9?~?O_6�9Y[ 9�F�25Q K MGQ:X 9�8*4�6�Q*X O_6�9�2�Fc[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> T Q K 9�Mc|�25;5;�4�6 8?>�V?9

2�>)FH9�M_[ QR>�MU9zONQA4�6 8?>�V?2�>�V�MNON9�;5;�8?F�MNO_FNS�4�O_S FH9?yzd`S�9zONQ�O_6�9 F�9�;�8*OU2Iw09�; / FN8?[�2 K 9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>�9�MP[ 9�4�2�8*;5; / Q*X

k C dWM�~*OP6�9�MN9�[ 9�F�25Q K 4�6 8?>�V?9�M�8?F�9 T 9�8*M_S FH9�8 . ;59?y=j%QRF O_6�9 � C �Y2�F^8?> K k������ MNO_8?F�M�~ T 9�8:M_S F�9 T 9�>0O

Q*X K � � K O 4�8?> 6�9�; [ 4�QR>�MNO_FN8:2 > O_6�9�[ F�Q?V?9�>�25ONQ�F T Q K 9�;5M�y]C�934�8?>l8:;IMUQ ;I9�80FN> O_6�9A2 T [ QRF�O_8?>�4�93Q*X

K 2 ��9�F�9�>?OA[ 6 / MN254�8*;`[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�MAOUQ k C d 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y o\>ieg6 8?[�ON9�F O |G93|�25;5; K 25MN4�S�MNM�O_6�9�[ Q?MNMU2 . ;59

4�8*;52 . FN8*ON25QR> Q*X`Q�>�9-MPS�476 [ F�QR4�9�MUM 7 >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Ql9 T 2IMUMN25QR> 7 wR2�8 T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?O Q*X�[ 9�FH2IQ K 4�6 8?>�V?9�M 2�>

4�Q�Q?; � C� 2�FgMNO_8?FHM�y

}Y>0XbQRF�O_S > 8*OU9�; / ~cO_6�99+" [ 9�4�ON9 K 476 80>�V?9�M 8?F�9 ONQ�Q�M T 8:;I;�ONQ K 9�ON9�4�OCX\F�Q T MN2 T [�;59A4�Q T [ 8?F�25MNQR> Q*X

O_6�9[ 9�F�25Q K XZFHQ T QR>�9 / 9�8?F ONQAOP6 8*O`Q*X�O_6�9>�9+"�O�yAf�Q K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9 K � � K OC2�>)k C d'MNO_8?FHM�~^8 . 9�OUON9�F

ON9�4�6 >�25a S�9W25MnOUQ T 9�8*MPS F�9�O_6�9�4�S T S�;�8*ON25w?9W[ 6 8*MN9Y4�6 8?>�V?9�2�> 8 T Q K 9�|�25O_6 8WMN;5Q*|�; / 476 80>�V?2�>�V [ 9�F�25Q K y

f�6�25M�25M 8:4�4�Q T [�;525M_6�9 KA.?/ 4�Q T [ 8?F�2�>�V�O_6�9 Q . MN9�F�w?9 K ON2 T 9�MnQ:X T 8 "R2 T 8 ��� 2�> O_6�9�;525VR6?O�4�S F�w09 ONQ�O_6�9

ON2 T 9�M�Q:X T 8 "R2 T 8�� ! 4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9 K X\F�Q T 8?>8:MNM_S T [�ON25QR> Q:X�4�QR>�MUO_8?>0O [ 9�F�25Q K y�f�6�9`F�9�MPS�;IOU2 >�V[�;5Q?O�Q*X

��� � ! M_6�Q*|�MWO_6�9z[ 6 8*MN9 K F�2EXbO`8*MNMNQ�4�2�8*ON9 K |g2IOP6-8 4�6 8?>�V?2�>�VA[ 9�F�25Q K y J 4�QR>�MNO_8?>0O`FN8*OU9`Q*X�[ 9�F�25Q K

4�6 8?>�V?9?~ K � � K O�~ 9�>0ON9�F�MY8*M�8Ca S 8 K FN8*ON254`OU9�F T 2 >xON2 T 9?s

��� � ! #�=

�� ���

� ���� ��� � � � � � MU9�4 � � = yBY

Page 41: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

=VY

| 6�9�F�9�� ��� 2IMCO_6�9[ 9�FH2IQ K 8*OWON2 T 9 � � ��MN9�9CXbQRFW9+" 8 T [�;597C 2 >�V09�O�9�OC8*;by ���?� A ~ ���?� � 80> K {Y9�[�;59�FC9�O

8*;by ���?� A yzf�Q T 9�8*M_S F�9 K � � K O�|�25O_634�QR>0] K 9�>�4�9?~^OP6�9zMNO_8?F T S�MNO�Q*XG4�Q�S F�MN9 6 8�w?9zMUO_8 . ;59 8?> K XZS�;5; /

F�9�MNQ0;Iw09 K [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�[ 9�F�25Q K M�~%|�25O_6F�9�;52�8 . ;59 [ 6 8*MN9 T 9�8:M_S F�9 T 9�>0ONM�X\F�Q T MN9�8*MUQR> ONQzMN9�8:MNQR>+y

{W8�|�8*;59�F�9�Oz8*;by � ���?� A 8?> K {W8�|�8*;59�F � D�FN8 K ;59 / � ���?� J [ F�9�MN9�>0O [ F�9 K 254�ON9 K w(8*;�S�9�M Q*X K � � K O

XbQRF T Q K 9�;5M-FH9�;I9�w*8?>0OONQ � C �Y2 F�8?> K k � � � MNO_8?FHM � O_6�93QR>�; / Q . MN9�F�w?9 K w*8*;�S�9�Q*X K � � K O�~gO_6 8*O

XbQRF`k � �?� A � 25ONMN9�;EXN~^25MC4�QR>�MN25MNON9�>0OC|�25O_6�OP6�9�MN9 T Q K 9�;5M�y3m�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~ 8*M�{W8�|�8*;59�F � D�FN8 K ;59 / � ���?� J

K 9 T QR>�MUO_FN8*ON9 K ~�X QRFC83MUO_8?FC8*M 6�Q?Oz8*M k � �?� A � ~ K � � K OC2IM MNO_FHQR>�V?; / 8���9�4�ON9 Kl.0/ T Q K 9O_FU8?[ [�2�>�V�y

f�6�9 / 8:;IMUQAM_6�Q*| OP6 8*O�~�2�> V?9�>�9�FN8*;b~ K � � K O`M_6�Q�S�; K . 9[ Q0MN25ON25w?9?y-fg6�2IMCF�9 � 9�4�ONMCO_6�9zQ*w?9�FU8*;5;n4�Q�Q?;52 >�V

Q*X�O_6�9 T Q K 9�; � C 2�>�V?9�O�9�Oz8*;by ���?� @ yf=FU8?[ [ 9 K T Q K 9�M�~n6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~=80F�9 4�Q�>�4�9�>?O_FU8*ON9 K 2�> O_6�9zQ�S�ON9�F

;�8 / 9�F�M�~0|�25O_6�2�> | 6�25476 4�QR>0O_FN8*4�ON25QR> K Q T 2�> 8*ON9�M�4�Q�Q?;52 >�V � O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9�OPFN8?[ [ 9 KT Q K 9�Mn4�8?> M_6�Q*| [ 9�F�25Q K M

| 6�254�6 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN9�|�25O_6COU2 T 9?ynf�6�S�M�~ T Q K 9 O_FU8?[ [�2�>�V`4�8?>C4�Q T [�;52I4�8:ON9�O_6�9�2�>0ON9�FN[ F�9�OP8*ON25QR>CQ*X T 9�8:M_S F�9 K

[ 9�FH2IQ K 476 8?>�V09�M`2�>)6�Q0O�k C dWM�y J M � C � 2�F MNO_8?F�M�4�QRQ0; ~�O_6�9 M_S F X\8*4�9z4�QR>0O_FN8*4�OU2IQ�>-FU8*ON9 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN9�M

F�9�;�8*ON25w?9OUQ�O_6�94�Q�Q?;52 >�V FN8*OU9 Q*XWO_6�92�>0ON9�F�25QRF�y <�Q�~c| 6�25;59 T Q K 9O_FN8?[ [�2�>�V�4�80> MNON25;5; 2�> � S�9�>�4�93O_6�9

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ 9�FH2IQ K�K 25MNO_FH2 . S�OU2IQ�>+~^O_6�9zFN8*ON9�MWQ:X [ 9�FH2IQ K 476 8?>�V09 . 9�4�Q T 9 T QRF�9CMN2 T 25;�8?F X\F�Q T T Q K 9zONQ

T Q K 9`2�>�4�QRQ0;I9�F � C � 2�FgMNO_8?F�M�yG{W8�|�8*;59�F � D�FN8 K ;59 / � ���?� J XbQRS > K O_6 8:O�O_6�9`MU2IV�>AQ:X K � � K OY4�QRS�; K

. 9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0OcX QRF K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O T Q K 9�M�2�>6�Q?O � C��Y2�F T Q K 9�;5M � .0/ O_6�9YON2 T 9WO_6�Q0MN9 T Q K 9�;5M�9�w?Q?;5w?9YONQCO_6�9

4�Q�Q?;�9�> K Q:X=O_6�9`MUO_F�2�[+~ O_6�9`[ 9�F�25Q K 476 8?>�V09�FN8*OU9�M 80F�9`8*;5;=[ Q0MN25ON25w?9?y

� � � �"#�� � �R���

C 9 6 8�w?9Y>�Q(| 4�Q T [�25;I9 K 8W;525MNOcQ*X a S�9�MNON25QR>�M�|�9�4�8?>z8?>�MN|�9�F .0/ Q . MN9�F�w�2�>�V�k C di[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M�y C�9

4�8?> T 9�8*M_S F�9�2�> K 2Iw�2 K S 8*;�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX T 8*MNM 80> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / O_6 F�QRS�VR6x2 K 9�>?ON2E]�4�8*OU2IQ�>3Q*X^O_6�9z[ 9�F�25Q K

M_[ 8*4�2�>�V�y } >�2EXbQRF T X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V |�25O_6�2�> T Q K 9�MCQ*X V?25w?9�> � 2�> K 254�8*ON9�O_6�9AFN8*OU9zQ*X F�Q0O_8*ON25QR>+~

8?> K 8*2 K 2�> K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�2�>�VlO_6�93Q*w?9�FN8*;5; [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>i[ 8*ONOU9�FN>+y JW. FNS [�O4�Q T [ Q?MN25ON25QR> VRFN8 K 2I9�>0ONMM_6�Q*|

O_6�9 T MU9�;Iw09�MO_6 F�QRS�VR6 [ 9�F�25Q K 254 K 9�w�2�8*ON25QR>�M-8�|�8 / X\F�Q T 4�QR>�MNOP8?>?O[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V%~ 8*;5;5Q*|�2�>�V S�MONQ

T 9�8*MPS F�9 9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9; 8 / 9�F T 8:MNMN9�M�y3f�6�9�MN9A8?FH9 a S�9�MNON25QR>�MCQ*X MUON9�;5; 80FCMNO_FNS�4�OPS F�9?~^8?> K OP6�9�2 F 8?>�MN|�9�F�M�~

K 9�F�25w?9 K 2�> e�6 8?[�ON9�F J ~�|�25;I;+ON9�;5;�S�MnOP6�9 [ F�9�4�25MN9 . QRS > K 8?F�259�M�Q:X�OP6�9�2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MUO_F�2�[+~?2�> Q?O_6�9�F�|�QRF K M�~

| 6�9�> O_6�9�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M . 9�V?2�>i8?> K 9�> K 2�> O_6�9A9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> Q*X�k C d MNO_8?FHM Q*X`w*8?F�25QRS�M T 8:MNM�y fg6�2IM

H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09?~R4�Q�S [�;I9 K |�25O_6 O_6�9 OU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M�Q*X K FH2Iw�2�>�V 8?> K O_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T PSR T Q K 9W[ 9�FH2IQ K 2�> T Q K 9�;IM

Page 42: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

= �

T 8*OU476�9 K OUQ`O_6�9�Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�M�~�|�25;5;�[ FHQ(w�2 K 9 MUO_F�254�On4�QR>�MUO_8*2�>?OUMnQR>COP6�9 8*;5;5Q*|�8 . ;59�XbQRF T Q*X�O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V

T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T yif�6�25M 2�>0X QRF T 8*ON25QR> 2IM8 . MNQ0; S�OU9�; / >�9�4�9�MNM_8?F / ONQ 8?> / FH9�MN9�8?F�4�6 [ F�Q?VRFU8 T K 9�MN25VR>�9 K ONQ

K 25MN4�Q*w?9�Fg| 6 / k C dWM [ S�;5M_8:ON9`2�>�O_6�9Y] F�MNOW[�;�8*4�9?y�obOg|�25;I;n8:;IMUQ 8*;5;5Q(| S�M�~ 2�>3e�6 8?[�OU9�F O ~ ONQ [ F�9�4�25MN9�; /

2 K 9�>?OU2�X / |Y6�2I4�6Ak C dWMGMP6�QRS�; K-. 9 T Q?MNO K Q T 2�> 8*ON9 K3.?/ >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q 4�QRQ?;52�>�V�yQC�9`4�80> O_6�9�>M_6�Q*|i6�Q*|

T 9�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0O Q*X`OP6�9�2 F[ 9�F�25Q K 476 8?>�V09�M�~�S�MN2�>�V O_6�93ON9�4�6 >�2Ia S�9�MQRS�ON;52�>�9 K 2�> � = y J ~c|�25;5;WON9�MNO QRS F

X\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*; H�>�Q*|�;59 K V?9WQ*Xn>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q 2�>0ON9�FN8*4�OU2IQ�>�M 2�>OP6�9 K 9�>�MN9�[�;�8*M T 8CQ*Xn8CMNON9�;5;�8?Fg2 >0ON9�F�25QRFvy

o > O_6�9�>�9+"RO4�6 8?[�ON9�F�~�|�93|�25;5;WQRS�ON;52�>�9�O_6�93MNO_8:O_S�M Q:X`QRS F�HR>�Q*|�;59 K V?93Q*X�k C dWM . 9PX QRFH9�O_6�25M

2�>?w09�MNON25VR8*ON25QR> |�8*M`S > K 9�F�O_8 H*9�>+yDn9�4�80S�MN9 Q:XGO_6�9�2�F T 8?> / MN2 T 25; 80F�25ON259�M �b8?> K OU9�;I;52�>�V K 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�9�M ONQ

O_6�9 � C��Y2 FY8?> K k������ [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>�M�~%|G9W8*;5MNQ [ FH9�MN9�>?OY8CM_S TzT 80F / Q*Xn[ F�9�w�2IQ�S�M�� ��e�9�OU2�80> K d`D �

Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�M�~ 2�> O_6�9 6�Q�[ 9�M�O_6 8:OGOP6�9 / |�25;5;=[ F�Q*w�2 K 9`6�2 >0ONM�OUQ 6�9�;�[ VRS�2 K 9�QRS F�8?> 8*; / MU2IMgQ*X�8 K K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;

k C d ;525VR60ON4�S F�w?9�M�2�>�e�6 8?[�ON9�F�M J 8?> K A y

Page 43: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

= �

������!����� � ����� � � � �D��� �F� � � � �F�7� � � � � � ��� � � ������ � � ���

� � � � � �D��� � �

��� � �D� %'���2� %� ��2%��D���9�D� % � �"�F% �� :/#G���� #G;�� �1���� ��� :�� %0����!�� � ��+"�3�5%�%���D��%�? ;��

�3�� ���D� ���5%/��� � #G��+��/%0+��� ��/%0�)+"��;D � ���� ��1�� ��1� % -/� �2 ��D����;5���()%��D� 4"4"4� 6

7 J ;EX\F�9 K p�QRF K f�9�> > / MNQ�>+~ �� 8 �" ������*�2 ���4�� 4��04 @3A5B�����E

�"��� �������� "!$#&%'��() ��

f�Q [ S�O�OP6�9na S�9�MNON25QR>�M^FN8*25MN9 K 2�>�e�6 8?[�ON9�F =�2�>?OUQ�4�QR>0ON9+"RO�~�25O 2IM 2�>�MNO_FNS�4�OU2Iw09nONQ�4�Q�>�MN2 K 9�F�O_6�9c4�S FNF�9�>0O

MNO_8:O_S�MWQ*X 8*;5;^4�;�8*MNMN9�MCQ*X�[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V3| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuXGMNO_80F�M�~+2�>�4�;�S K 2 >�V O_6�9zd`D��YM�8?> K � � e�9�ON25M�y j^2 FHMNO

K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F�9 K 2�> ���VO0� ~ O_6�9z>�S T�. 9�FYQ*X � � e�9�OU2�[ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�MY2IMW4�S FUF�9�>?OU; / = J y�?^w09�>AOP6�QRS�VR6�2�> K 2Iw�2 K S 8*;

� � e�9�ON2cMNO_8?FHM�6 8�w?9>�Q-4�;59�8?F [ 8*ONON9�FN>�MC| 6�254�6 S > K 9�F�; / O_6�9�2�F�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K [ 9�F�25Q K M�~Ge�;59 T 9�>�M � ���?� J

M_S�4�4�9�MNMHXZS�;5; / M_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8:OG|Y6�9�>zO_6�9�2�F�[ 9�F�25Q K MY8?F�9Y4�QR>�MN2 K 9�F�9 K OUQ?V?9�O_6�9�F�~�8�MN2�>�V?;59�[ 8*ONOU9�FN>C9 T 9�F�V09�M�y

o\>38 K K 25ON25QR>+~ . Q?O_6xO_6�9 � �)e 9�ON2=8?> K d`D�� 2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNOPF�2�[�M 8?FH9�[ F�9�4�25MN9�; /3K 9P] >�9 K |�25O_6�2�>3> 8?FNF�Q*|

FN8?>�V09�M�Q*X^;IQ0V!PA8?> K � � � y5?n8*4�6AFH9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONM 8 T QRF�9`6�Q T Q?V?9�>�QRS�M�V�F�QRS [ Q*XnMNOU9�;I;�8?FY[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�MYO_6 8?>

O_6�9`k C dWM�y

fg6�9�F�9A8?F�9�9�2IV�6?O�H�>�Q*| >lk������ MNO_8?F�M�~G8?> K X Q�S F � C �Y2 F MNO_80F�M��be�2�8?F K S�;5;5Q � DcQR> K ���?�VO y

@gX�O_6�9�MN9?~�QR>�; / O�|�Q6 8�w09 6 8 K O_6�9�2�F`[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>�M`MNO_S K 259 K 2�>)8?> /AK 9�OP8*25; y f�6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9?~+9�8*4�6�[ S�;5M_8*OUQRF

T S�MNO . 9Y9�w(8:; S 8:ON9 K 8:;IQ�>�9 2�> ON9�F T M^Q*X�25ONM�[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> [ F�QR[ 9�FHON259�M�~�2 > QRF K 9�F�ONQW9�MNO_8 . ;I25M_6 25ONMc2�> K 2Iw�2 K S 8*;

[ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F�M .0/ 4�Q T [ 80F�25MNQR>�|�25O_6OP6�9 T Q K 9�;5M�yWo�XG|�9W|�25M_6�ONQ T 8VH:9WM_[ 9�4�2E]�4z4�;�8*2 T MCF�9�VR8?F K 2�>�V O_6�9

VRF�Q�S [�[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�MCQ*XG9�25O_6�9�F�4�;�8*MNM�~ |�9 >�9�9 K ONQ9+" [�;IQ�F�9 2�> K 9�O_8*25;nOP6�9 [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�MCQ*X T QRFH9zQ*XGOP6�9�2 F

T 9 TC. 9�FHM�yno\>xO_6�9`e�6 8?[�OU9�F J |�9W|�25;5; T Q*w?9YONQ*|�8?F K O_6�25M�V?QR8:; y

Page 44: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@ E

o >LO_6�9 >�9+"RO�O�|�QlMU9�4�ON25QR>�M�Q*X OP6�2IM 476 8?[�OU9�F�~`|�9 [ F�9�MN9�>0O . F�259PXAM_S TzT 8?FH2I9�M3Q*X O_6�9�� � e�9�ON2

�b8 y>H�y�8 y^d J � 8?> K d`D�� 2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_F�2�[�M�y DnQ0O_6 O_6�9�2�FxMN2 T 25; 80F�25ON259�M-OUQ�~�8?> K K 2 ��9�FH9�>�4�9�MX\F�Q T ~

O_6�9Ak C d w*8?F�2�8 . ;59�M |�25;I; . 9�2�>�MNO_FNS�4�ON25w?9�| 6�9�> |�9 9�w(8*;�S 8*OU9AO_6�9�VRF�QRS [ [ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M Q:X O_6�9;�8*OUON9�F

2�>)eg6 8?[�ON9�F�A yo\> O_6�9 ] > 8*;�MN9�4�ON25QR>+~ |�9 |�25;5;�M_S TzT 80F�2 ��9 F�9�MPS�;IOUM`X\F�Q T O_6�9zO�|�QAM_S�4�4�9�MUM�XZS�;�k C d

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> MUO_S K 259�MG4�Q T [�;59�ON9 K [ FH2IQ�FnOUQ`O_6�25M�O_6�9�MN25M�s O_6�Q?MU9 Q*X�O_6�9 � C �Y2 FcMNOP8?Fnk � �?� A � ~?8?> K Q*X�O_6�9

k � ��� MNOP8?F � � e � A E � y

�"� � ���'����� � ��( � ���:���

fg6�9W] F�MNOWw*8?F�2�8 . ;59z| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F Xn|�8*M K 2IMU4�Q(w09�F�9 K Q*w?9�F�O_6�2�F�O /�/ 9�8?F�MW8*V?Q .?/J F�;5QAp�8?> K Q0;IO�~+| 6�Q

XbQRS > K O_6 8*O�O_6�9 . F�25VR60O_>�9�MNM^Q*X�O_6�9cd J MUO_8?F�mYpf=80S%Y O 476 80>�V?9 K [ 9�F�25Q K 2I4�8:;I; / .0/ 8 X 9�| [ 9�F�4�9�>0O^9�w?9�F /

Xb9�| T 2 >�S�ON9�M��bp�80> K Q?;5O ���VO?� y j+S F�O_6�9�F`80> 8*; / MN25Mz9�MUO_8 . ;525M_6�9 K O_6 8*O�O_6�9 w*8?F�2�8*ON25QR>�MC|�9�F�9 2�>?O_FH2 >�MU2I4?~

MNO_8 . ;I9?~ PSR T Q K 9�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M �be�6 8?> T S�VR8 T ��� YV= ~+C 8?FN>�9�F � h�Q . 2�>�MNQR> ��� YV= ~�@YM_8VH02 � mY8?>�MN9�> ��� YV@ y

@Yw?9�F�OP6�9`>�9+"RO K 9�4�8 K 9?~�8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*; w(8?FH2 8 . ;I9�d J | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�|�9�F�9�XbQRS > K ~�80> K 2 > ��� YVY ~?134 � FN8�|

K 9 T QR>�MUO_FN8*ON9 K OP6 8*O OP6�9 / F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0O 8 |G9�;5;>R K 9P] >�9 K 4�; 8:MNM Q:XG[ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�MY>�Q(| H�>�Q(|Y>A8*M�OP6�9 � � e�9�ON2

MNO_80F�M�y�f�6�9 � �ze�9�ON20MNO_8?F�M�QR4�4�S [ / O_6�9n8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9^ON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9GFN80>�V?9 �?���TEVEVE { �

� ��� �

�� @ �TEVEVE {

� � F�9�9�>�MNON9�2�> ���?� J � C�9�2 K 9 T 80> > � {YQ�9�MNON9�F ���0� J � Dc9�F�V09�F�QR>+~SC�9�MN9 T 8:9�; ~ � j�QR>0O_8*2�>�9 ���?� = y=fg6�9�2 F

T 8*MUMN9�M�~ K 9�FH2Iw09 K XZF�Q T M_[ 9�4�O_F�Q?MN4�Q�[�2I4 T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>0ONM�Q*X�;5Q?V�P � � � 8?> K � � � ~?4�;�S�MNON9�F�4�;5Q?MU9�; / 8 . QRS�O

8 T 9�8?> Q*X E A O � � �bDc9�F�V09�F�QR>+~ < 8���9�F�~ � p+9�2 . 9�F�O ���?� E ~R80> K O_6�9�2�F�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25ON259�M`8?FH9 8*;5;�;59�MNMgO_6 8?>

EBE � � �ny�j�QRFg9+"�ON9�>�MN25w?9 F�9�w�259�|�M`Q:X � � e�9�ON2^[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M�~�MU9�9 {Y;59�2 > T 8?>�� ���?� A ~�e�;59 T 9�>�M � ���?� J ~

8?> K C 2�>�V?9�O � ���?�?� y

fg6�9 [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>[ 9�F�25Q K M Q*X � �3e�9�ON2�MUO_8?F�M�;5259W2 >xO_6�9WFN8?>�V?9YQ*X �FE E ONQ � = E E MN9�4�QR> K M�~ |�25O_6 8`4�;59�8?F

O_F�9�> K ONQ*| 80F K ;IQ�>�V?9�F`[ 9�F�25Q K M 80> K ;�8?F�V?9�F�8 T [�;525O_S K 9�MC|�25O_6 K 9�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�V � � � � C 2�>�V?9�O � j�QR>0O_8*2�>�9

���?� = ~ e�;59 T 9�>�M ���?� J y^f�6�25MY25M V?9�>�9�FU8*;5; / 8:ONO_F�2 . S�ON9 K ONQCO_6�9`MN2�> H02�>�V Q*X^O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9`ONQ ;IQ�>�V?9�F

O_6�9�F T 8*;+ON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M`8*M�MUO_8?F�M�9�w?Q?;5w?9WOUQz4�QRQ0;I9�FgON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9�M�O_6 F�QRS�V�6 O_6�9W2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_F�2�[+y5?^a S 8 R

ON25QR> � = y>A O_6�9�>�2 T [�;5259�M�;5QR>�V09�FW[ 9�F�25Q K M�y J MWO_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V���Q�>�9 K 9�9�[ 9�>�M�~�OP6�9�8 T Q�S >?OYQ*XGQ*w?9�FH; / 2�>�V

T 8*OU9�F�2�8*; 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�M�~�| 6�254�6z2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9�MnO_6�9Y6�9�8*On9�>�9�F�V / 8�w*8*25; 8 . ;I9gXbQRF^4�QR>0w?9�F�MU2IQ�>CONQW|�QRFIH%~*9+" [�;�8*2�>�2�>�V

O_6�9�; 80F�V?9�F�8 T [�;I25O_S K 9�MWMU9�9�>A2�>x4�QRQ?;59�FW[ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M 8*Mg|G9�;5; �bh�Q . 2�>�MNQ�> ��� Y � ~�134 � FN8�| ���?� E ~ C 2�>�V?9�O

� j%QR>0O_8*2�>�9 ���?� = � 4?y XNy C)S ���0�?� y

Page 45: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@ �

dW9�MP[�2IOU9nO_6�9c; 80F�V?9nMP8 T [�;59�Q*X � �ze�9�OU2IM^8�w(8*25;�8 . ;59�XbQRF+Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>+~*2IO^25M K 2 � 4�S�;5OnONQ�2�> K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>?ON; /

2 K 9�>?OU2�X / OP6�9`[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> T Q K 9�MYMN9�9�>2�>�8?> / QR>�9WMNOP8?F�ynf�6�25MY25M . 9�4�8?S�MN9`OP6�Q?MN9W|�25O_6xO_6�9 T Q?MNOgMNO_8 . ;59

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>C[ 8*OUON9�FN>�M V?9�>�9�FN8*;5; / [ S�;5M_8*OU9G|g2IOP6`OP6�9^Xb9�|G9�MUO T Q K 9�M�y^e�QR>0w?9�F�MU9�; / ~*OP6�9nVRF�9�8:ON9�F+O_6�9�>�S T�. 9�F

Q*X T Q K 9�M�Q . MN9�F�w09 K ~ O_6�9 T QRF�9Yw(8?F�2�8 . ;59CO_6�Q?MU9 T Q K 9�MY8?F�9W2�>A8 T [�;I25O_S K 9 7 MUQ T 9 K 25M_8?[ [ 9�80F�2�>�V�b8?> K

MNQ T 9�ON2 T 9�MC; 8:ON9�FCF�9�8?[ [ 9�80F�2�>�V 8*;5ONQ?V?9�O_6�9�F�QR> ON2 T 9�MN4�8:;I9�M Q*X K 8 / M�~ T QR>0O_6�M�~^8?> K / 9�8?FHM �be�;59 T 9�>�M

���?� J ~ {Y;I9�2�> T 80> ���?� A ~�{Y;I9�2�> T 80>39�O 8*;by ���0�?� y

J [ Q?MUMN2 . ;I9 . F�9�8VH0O_6 F�Q�S�VR6�2 > 2 K 9�>0ON2EX / 2�>�VCO_6�9�w(8*;�S�9�McQ*X �8?> K � XbQRF=80> / Q*X O_6�9 � �e 9�ON2 MNO_8?FHM=|�8*M

.0/ e�;59 T 9�>�M � ���?� J y���QC2�> K 25wR2 K S 8*; MNO_80FG[ S�;5M_8:ON9�M�2 > 9�>�Q�S�VR6 MNO_8 . ;59 T Q K 9�M�ONQ`9�MUO_8 . ;525M_6A8?> Q*w?9�FN8*;5;

[ 8*ONOU9�FN>zMPS�4768*MgO_6�9WQR>�9`[ F�9 K 254�ON9 K 2 >$?^a S 8*ON25QR> � = yB= y^e�;59 T 9�>�M F�9�8*MUQR>�9 K 8*M�XbQ?;5;5Q(|gM�s O_6�9`> 8?FNF�Q*|

FN8?>�V09 Q*X T 8*MUM 80> K � � � MP[ 8?> >�9 K-.0/ T 9 TC. 9�FHM�Q*X^O_6�9 4�;�8*MUM T 9�80>�MGOP6 8*O�O_6�9�2�F [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>�M T 25VR60O 8*;5;

XbQ?;5;IQ*|LO_6�9WM_8 T 9`[ 8*ONON9�FN>+ycm�9 X QRS > K O_6 8*O�2EXG6�9�;I25MNOU9 K O_6�9 T Q?MNO � MNOP8 . ;59�� [ 9�F�25Q K MgXZFHQ T O_6�9C6�Q?ONON9�F

d J MWONQ0V?9�O_6�9�F 7 8*MW2EX�O_6�9 / 4�8 T 9�X\F�Q T 8xMN2�>�V?;59 Q . ru9�4�O 7 OP6�9 / XbQRF T 9 K 8MU9�F�259�M`Q*X�[ 9�F�25Q K 4�;�S T [�M�y

f�6�9�MN9CVRFHQRS [�M�4�QR>0XbQRF T 9 K ONQ8 [ 8*OUON9�FN>Q:X�9�a S 8*;^[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V4�QR>�MN25MNOU9�>?OY|�25O_6�?^a S 8*ON25QR> � = yB= y

f�6�25MnMPS�V?V?9�MNON9 K 8?>�2 K 9�>0ON25O / XbQRF � 8?> K � XbQRF 9�w?9�F /�T Q K 9�2 > 9�w?9�F / MNO_8?F�2�>CO_6�9�M_8 T [�;I9?yco\>z[ 8?FHON254�S�; 80F�~

6�9zM_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8:OWO_6�9zVRF�Q�S [3|�25O_63O_6�9 ;5Q*|G9�MUO`[ 9�F�25Q K M_6�Q�S�; K . 9 O_6�9 � � � ~ � � � T Q K 9?~�80> K 25ONM

Q . MN9�FHw?9 K [ 9�F�25Q K 2 T [�;5259 K 8�;�8?F�V?9zw*8*;�S�9 X Q�FWO_6�9 6 /�K F�Q?V?9�> ;�8 / 9�FWO_6�254+HR>�9�MNM�y-h�9�4�9�>0ON; / ~n{Y;59�2�> T 8?>

� ���0� A ~ ���?�?� M_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8*O�O_6�25MYM_8 T 9`[ 8*OUON9�FN> 9+"�ON9�> K M�ONQzOP6�9W4�QRQ?;59�F � ��e�9�OU2 MUO_8?F�M�8*M�|�9�;5;by

J M |G9 T 9�>0ON25QR>�9 K 2�>Ce�6 8?[�ON9�F = ~*O_6�9c9+" 8:4�O=MNQ�S F�4�9nQ*X K FH2Iw�2�>�VW2�>`OP6�9 � � e�9�ON2?MUO_8?F�M=6 8:M=;5QR>�V . 9�9�>

8*ONOPF�2 . S�ON9 K OUQ�4 / 4�;5254�8*;=25QR>�2 ��8*OU2IQ�> Q*X�6 /RK F�Q0V?9�>8*OnOP6�9 . 8*MN9YQ*X=O_6�9Y4�QR>0w?9�4�ON25QR> ��QR>�9 ��134 � 8�| ��� YVY ~

8?> K dWQ?;59 � � �n8?S�4�;�8*2�F ���?� � ~ C 2�>�V?9�O ���0� �� y J ;5O_6�QRS�V�6 T Q K 9�;IM . 8:MN9 K QR>xO_6�25M`O_6�9�QRF / F�9�[ F�Q K S�4�9

O_6�9Q . MU9�F�w?9 K O_F�9�> K MWrNS�MNO T 9�>0ON25QR>�9 K ~nOP6�9 /�K Q)83[ Q�QRFYr�Q . F�9�[ F�Q K S�4�2 >�V O_6�9 Q . MN9�F�w09 K F�9 K 9 K V?9

��;5Q*| � ��� ;52 T 25O Q*X�O_6�9YMNO_F�2�[ 7 2�>Q0O_6�9�Fc|GQ�F K M�~?OP6�9 / 4�8?> >�Q?OcON9�;5;�S�M�| 6�9�> 2�> O_6�9Y;52EX 9WQ*X=8�d J |Y6�2IOU9

K |�8?F X�[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>�|�25;I;�9�> K y

fg6�9GF�9�4�9�>0O=|�QRF H�Q*X C S � ���0�?� ~�MUQ T 9nQ:X�| 6�25476�|�8*M=8?>0ON254�2�[ 8*ON9 Kz.0/ D�F�254 H�6�25;5; � ���?� @ ~�8*ONOPF�2 . S�ON9�M

K F�25w�2 >�V3ONQOP6�9 4�QR>0w?9�4�ON25QR>���QR>�9z25ONMN9�;EX FN8:O_6�9�FYO_6 8?>3OP6�9 [ 8?F�ON2�8*;c25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR>���QR>�9 8*OW25ONM . 8*MN9?y�C)S

[ Q02 >0ONMCONQ�MN9�w?9�FN8*;�[ 8?F�ON254�S�;�8?F K 2 � 4�S�;5ON259�M |�25O_6 O_6�9 T QRF�9zO_FU8 K 25ON25QR> 8*;GWSRUX T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T 2�> � � e�9�ON2

MNO_80F�M�y=fg6�9nO_6�9�F T 8*;ROU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�2�>�O_6�9 W RUX K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9�2IMn8:4�O_S 8*;5; /�T S�476�M T 8*;5;I9�F OP6 8?>WO_6�9�Q . MU9�F�w?9 K

[ 9�FH2IQ K M�y�f�6�9 ��QR>�9�2IMY8?[ [ 8?F�9�>0ON; / OUQRQzOP6�2 > OUQzQ*w?9�F�4�Q T 9WFN8 K 2�8*OU2Iw09 K 8 T [�2�>�V 2�>xO_6�9W2�>?ON9�FH2IQ�F�y^13Q?MNO

Page 46: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@V=

O_6�9�QRFH2I9�M Q*X�W RUX K FH2Iw�2�>�VlF�9�a S�2 FH9AO_6 8*O O_6�94�QR>0w?9�4�ON25w?9 � SS" . 9-6�9�; K ] "R9 K K S F�2�>�V [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> 7 8?>

8*MNMPS T [�ON25QR>MP6�Q(|Y> .?/ D�F�254+HR6�25;5; � ���?� @ ~ ���?� � 8 ~ ���?� � . ONQ . 9`2�>�4�QRFNFH9�4�O�y5C)S M_6�Q*|�M�OP6 8*O�O_6�9 . 8*MN9

Q*X=OP6�9W4�QR>?w09�4�ON25QR> ��QR>�9W25M OP6�9W;I2 H*9�; / MNQ�S F�4�9WQ*X K F�25w�2�>�V�~ . 8:MN9 K QR>D�F�254 H�6�25;5; B M`8*MNM_S T [�OU2IQ�> O_6 8*O�O_6�9

F�9�MNOgQ*XnO_6�9`4�Q�>?w?9�4�OU2IQ�> ��QR>�9CF�9�M_[ Q�> K M �� %/���������2��������%/#G; ONQzO_6�9�476 8?>�V02 >�V � SS" K S�9CONQ K F�25w�2�>�VA>�9�8?F

25ONM . 8*MN9?y�@W>�9Q*XYO_6�9 T Q?MNO`4�Q T [ 9�;5;52�>�V 8*OUO_F�2 . S�ON9�MCQ*X O_6�25MzOP6�9�QRF / 25Mz25ONMz8 . 25;I25O / ONQ T QRF�9 QRFW;59�MNM

4�QRFNFH9�4�ON; / F�9�[ FHQ K S�4�9�O_6�9`Q . MU9�F�w?9 KA. ;�S�9 �����)�3��� 9 K V09�M�Q*X^O_6�9�� ��e�9�OU2 2�>�MNOP8 . 25;I25O / MUO_F�2�[+y

fg6�9 O_6�9�Q�F / Q*X=4�QR>0w?9�4�ON25w?9 K F�25wR2�>�V K 9�w?9�;5QR[ 9 KA.0/ D�F�254+HR6�25;5;�80> K C)S 25M�2�>?OPF�25VRS�2�>�V�~ . S�O�S >0X Q�F�O_S R

> 8*ON9�; / |�9W[ F�Q . 8 . ; / |�QR>+B O . 9C8 . ;59`ONQzS�MN9�25O�ONQ 6�9�;�[AS�MWS > K 9�F�MNOP8?> K O_6�9�k C d MNOP8?F�M�y^f�6�25MY2IM K S�9

ONQzOP6�9WMN2 T [�;59`X\8*4�O�O_6 8*O T Q K 9�;5MYQ*X=O_6�9Ck � �?� A � MNO_80F�M�6 8�w09W|G9�8 H�~�2EX�80> / ~ 4�Q�>?w?9�4�OU2IQ�> ��QR>�9�M�y *

�"��� ���'� � ��� � ���:���

J XbON9�F m 25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR> | 8:M 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K 8*MWOP6�9 [ FHQ . 8 . ;59z4�8?S�MN9CQ*XG[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>32�>3O_6�9 � � e�9�OU2=MNOP8?F�M�~

C 2�>�V?9�O � ���?� � K 9�w?9�;5QR[ 9 K-T Q K 9�;5M�| 6�25476 M_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8*O�m�9Y25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR> 4�QRS�; K K F�25w?9 [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> 2�>zd`D

| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX MW8*MW|�9�;5; yC<�2�>�4�9 6�9�;52�S T 6 8*M`86�25VR6�9�FW25QR>�2 ��8*OU2IQ�>�9�>�9�F�V / O_6 8?>36 /RK FHQ?V?9�>+~�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M

8*OCMN2 T 25;�8?Fz[ 9�F�25Q K M |�QRS�; K F�9�a S�2�F�9AMUO_8?F�M�|�25O_6)6�Q0ONON9�FC8*O T Q0M_[ 6�9�F�9�M�~n80> K C 2�>�V?9�OzM_S�V0V?9�MNON9 K O_6 8*O

w(80F�2�8 . ;59)d`D MNO_8?FHM M_6�Q�S�; KL. 9�MNQ�S�VR6?O2�> OP6�9 = E ~ E EVE { ONQ @ E ~ EVEVE { FN8?>�V?9?y f�6�25MAO_6�9�QRFH9�ON254�8*;

2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_F�2�[C|�QRS�; K 4�Q�>�MNON25O_S�ON9 80>C9+"ROU9�>�MN25QR>CQ*X�O_6�9�4�;�8*MNMN254�8*;�e�9�[ 6�9�2 K 2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_F�2�[CONQW;5Q*|�9�F

�l80> K 6�2IV�6�9�F�� ��� y

C 2�>�V?9�O�M_S . MN9�a S�9�>?ON; / K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F�9 K [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>�Mz2�> � d @VA � � C 2�>�V?9�O`9�Oz8*;by ���?� = ~=8d`DL|Y6�2IOU9

K |�8?F XW|�25O_6 8?> 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9�ON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9Q*X`8 . QRS�O�= J ~ EVEVE {Cyn<�9�w?9�> Q?O_6�9�FCd`D�� MNO_8?F�M 6 8�w09MN2�>�4�9

. 9�9�> K 25MN4�Q*w?9�FH9 K ~�8*;5;+X\8*;5;I2�>�Vz2�>xO_6�9 80[ [ F�Q "R2 T 8*OU9 ON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9 FU8?>�V?9 = ��� A EVE { �

� � � �

= J � EVE E {

�b{YQ�9�MNON9�F 9�O 8:; y ���?� A � p�2I9 . 9�F�OC9�Oz8*;by ���?� O � f�6�9�ru;5;b~ �^9�> >�9�M�~ � < 6�2�[ T 8?> ���?� �� yf�6�9 / 8?F�9 T QRF�9

;�S T 2�>�QRS�M�O_6 8?>COP6�9�� �e�9�ON2 MUO_8?F�M�~?8:O � E�� EBE @ � � ~ . S�OnO_6�9�2�F�9+" 8*4�O P 8?> K � � � 8?F�9 T QRF�9 K 2 � 4�S�;5O

ONQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 . 9�4�80S�MN9WQ*X=O_6�9�2�F�6�25VR6�9�F�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9�M�8?> K ;�8*4+HCQ*X^6 /�K F�Q?V?9�> ;52�>�9�M�yGDc9�4�8?S�MU9 Q*X O_6�25M�~

8?> K O_6�9�2�FWM T 8*;5;59�F`>�S T�. 9�F�M�~+25O`25M`S >�4�;59�8?F | 6�9�O_6�9�FWOP6�9 / 9+" 6�2 . 25Oz8?> / Q*XGOP6�9�OPF�9�> K MYX Q�S > K 2�>3O_6�9

� � e�9�ON2�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M�y � d @VA � 25M 8?> 9+"RO_FH9 T 9�; / F�25476 [ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�~^6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~^8?> K O_6�9 80> 8*; / MN25MzQ:X 25ONM

;525VR6?OU4�S F�w?9 �Z8*M�|G9�;5;^8*M�25ONM K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F / 25MYQR>�9WQ*X^O_6�9WVRF�9�8:OGMPS�4�4�9�MNM MUONQRF�259�M�Q*Xn8*MNOU9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q0;IQ0V / y, R>=/3C�UDA�8 >�A59R/�� /�158I>=2��/ N�251)6?ST2 � STA5B�S�� 2�6?STAKB �3A5B�/3<3V H / >=2��/ >�A5N�/�8R6?>=/�1)/�4 AK1)/�8:AK4"UD/36./�1)E&S B�S B 6?>�/�S 1MU�1.S���S B

<.AK;D1)@3/"9RST6?>=AK;=6�1)/3<.A51)6?S B 6.A&6?>�/ S B � /�BD6?STAKB AK4 /���/�B E AK1)/"/(��A�6?ST@&6?>�/3A51.ST/3<���6?>�A5; 5>�A54 @3AK;D1)<./ ST6�@3AK; �TU @3A E / 6.A 6?>=2�63V

Page 47: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@V@

o > ���?�VE ~ � d3@VA � |�8*MWQ . MU9�F�w?9 K |�25O_6�O_6�9!C ?nf y C 2�>�V?9�OW9�O`8*;by � ���0� J F�9�[ QRFHOWO_6�9�2�FW8?> 8*; / MU2IM

Q*X OP6�9 w�2�F�O_S 8*;5; / S >�2�>?ON9�FUFNS [�ON9 K ;525VR60ON4�S F�w?9 7 MP[ 8?> >�2�>�V 8*; T Q0MNOCOu|�Q�|G9�9FH0M 7 O_6 8:O FH9�M_S�;5ON9 K y @Yw?9�F

���VE K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ 9�F�25Q K M |�9�F�92 K 9�>?ON2E]�9 K ~�4�QR>0XbQRF T 2 >�V ONQ�8-[ 8:ONON9�FN> Q*XW9�a S 8*;�M_[ 8:4�2 >�V 8*M

2�> ?^a S 8*ON25QR> � = yB= y 1t80> / Q*XCO_6�9�MN9 T Q K 9�M|�9�F�9AO_FH2 [�;59�ONM�~ MPS�V?V?9�MNON2�>�V O_6�9 / |�9�F�93;I2 H*9�; / � � �

T Q K 9�M�y � f�6�9cXZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[�;52IOUON2�>�V`w(80F�259 K M / MNON9 T 8*OU2I4�8:;I; / X\F�Q TLT Q K 9�ONQ T Q K 9?~*O_6�9�;�8?F�V?9�F M_[�;525ONON2�>�V?M

4�QR>�MN25MNOU9�>?O |�25O_6`8 MNON9�;5;�8?F=FHQ?O_8*ON25QR>W[ 9�F�25Q K Q*X E y �0� K 8 / M�~�O_6�9nM T 8*;5;I9�F�|�25O_6 � y O K 8 / M�y=f�6�Q�S�VR6Y2�>�2IOU2 8:;I; /

2�>?OU9�FN[ F�9�ON9 K 8*MW8zMU2IV�> 8*;=Q:X K 2 ��9�F�9�>0ON2�8*;nF�Q?O_8:ON25QR>+~�{W8�|�8*;59�F�~ <�9FH0252 � � QRS�VR6� ���?�?� M_6�Q*|LO_6 8*OYO_6�25M

4�8?> >�Q?O . 9WMNQ�ycf�6�9 � � E 4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONM�Q*X^O_6�9WO_F�2�[�;59�ONM�|�9�F�9`8:;IMUQzMN;525VR6?OU; / Q �-4�9�>0ON9�F�ONQ*|�8?F K ;5Q*|�9�F

X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / y � QR>�9�M�9�O 8:; y � ���?�?� 6 8 K 8:; FH9�8 K / MP6�Q(|Y>zO_6 8:O 8�MNOU9�;I;�8?F T 8*VR>�9�ON254Y]�9�; K 4�QRS�; K 4�80S�MN9WO_6�25M

H02 > K Q*X 8*M / TzT 9�O_F / y m�9�FH9O_6�9M_6�2EX O Q*X OP6�9 � � E 4�Q T [ QR>�9�>?OUMz|�8*MC4�QR>�MN25MNON9�>0Oz|�25O_6 8AV0;IQ . 8*;

T 8*V�>�9�ON254z]�9�; K Q:X � @ EVE � @ E E � � 25O�25M [ Q?MNMN2 . ;59O_6 8*OCO_6�25M�]�9�; K 4�QRS�; K 8*4�4�QRS >0O�X QRF O_6�9 476 8?>�V02 >�V

T 9�8?> MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�VA8:M�|�9�;I;by

D�FN8 K ;I9 / � C 2�>�V?9�O � ���?� J K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9 K O_6 8*O�O_6�9 . 9�MNO T 8*ON4�6zOUQ�OP6�9 � d @VA � [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 9�4�OPFNS T

|�8*MG8:476�9�25w?9 K.?/ 8 T Q K 9�;+|�25O_6 8 T 8*MNMcQ*X EBO � � E>E @ ����~�8�; S T 2 >�Q0MN25O / Q*X EBE A E � EBE � = � �c~ 8?> K

� ��� � = J � E EVE � ��� E EVE {Cy^o >)[ 8?FHON254�S�; 80F�~ O_6�9z;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 4�Q�S [�;I9 K |g2IOP63O_6�9 T 9�8*M_S F�9 K 8?[ [ 8?F�9�>0O

. F�25VR60O_>�9�MNM�2�> K 254�8*ON9 K O_6 8:O � d @ A � ;I259�M`8*O�8 K 25MNO_8?>�4�9�Q*X J = � @z[ 4WX\F�Q T O_6�9%?c8?F�O_6+y^f�6�25M T 80FIH*9 K

O_6�9C] FHMNO�S�MN9 Q*X 8*MNON9�F�Q0MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V / 8*M�8 �UK 2IMUO_8?>�4�9 2 > K 254�8*OUQRF�y � j^2�> 8*;5; / ~n[ 9�F�25Q K 254 K 9�wR2�8*ON25QR>�M�X\F�Q T

O_6�9 T 9�8?>�[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�VA2�> O_6�9 K 8*O_8 2 T [�;5259 K 8A6�9�;52�S T ;�8 / 9�F �� = � �FE � � � � O_6�254 H%y f�6�25M�; 8:MNO

F�9�M_S�;5OW6 8*MY2 T [�;I254�8*OU2IQ�>�MWXbQRF�8 [ Q?MNMU2 . ;59z9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / 4�QR> >�9�4�OU2IQ�> . 9�O�|G9�9�>xO_6�9`d`D�� 8?> K � C �Y2 F

MNO_80F�M ��dW9�6 >�9�F � {W8�|�8*;59�F ���0� A ~�8*M�|�9W|�25;5;=MN9�9W|Y6�9�>|�9 K 25MN4�S�MNMWk � �0� A � 2�>O_6�9`>�9+"�O MU9�4�ON25QR>+y

�"� � ���'� �!��� � �:�$! � � � ()� �0()�$(� � ��� ��� �&(.��� � � �R� � # ����I�� ����

j^2�> 8*;5; / ~^|�98?FNF�25w?9 8:O`O_6�9k � � � 8?> K � C � 2�F�MNO_80F�M�y J O � E ~ EVEVE {C~ O_6�9 4�Q�Q?;n9�> K ��QRF � F�9 K

9 K V?9�� Q*X OP6�92 >�MUO_8 . 25;52IO / MNO_F�2�[ T 9�F�V09�Mz|�25O_6 O_6�9�9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / F�9�V?25QR> Q�4�4�S [�259 K .0/ O_6�9A6�Q0ONON9�MNO

�b[ F�2 T 80F�25; / d`@ |Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F XbM�y�f�6�9 �_. ;�S�9�9 K V09�� QR>xO_6�9`Q0O_6�9�F 6 80> K 25MWQR4�4�S [�259 K).0/ MNQ T 9WQ*XnO_6�9

6�Q?ONOU9�MNO MUO_8?F�M�H�>�Q*| >+~%MNQ T 9�|�25O_6�ON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9�MY2�>39+"R4�9�MUMWQ*X � Y E ~ EVEVE {Cy�@gXnO_6�9CO_6 F�9�9C[ Q?MNO R J � D��� 6?>=/�1 251 K;=E /�BD6.<M<?;�NDN�AK1)6 6?>DST< @3AKB=@ � ;=<?STAKB 8 S B�@ � ;�U�S B �6?>�/ � /�1)C �TA59 E A�U�/ � E 2�<.<�� 1.; �T/ U AK;=6 �DC /���/�B @�1.;=U�/

E /32 <?;�1)/ E /�BD6 A54 �TA ��M2KB=U���� � 1)/���;�S 1)/3U 6.A$1)/�ND1)A�U ;=@3/&6?>�/&E /32 <?;�1)/3U �52� ;�/&AK4� �� S 4 6?>=/"6?1.S N �T/ 6.<"9R/�1)/���� �"9RST6?><.A�E /"@3A�E$N AKB=/�BD6.< L?E$ST<.<?S B �V W

Page 48: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@ J

2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNOPF�2�[�M�|�9 6 8�w?9 K 2IMU4�S�MNMN9 K ~cO_6�25M�25MCO_6�9z;59�8*MUO�|�9�;5; K 9P] >�9 K Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR> 8*;5; / ~^XbQRFWMU9�w?9�FN8*;

F�9�8*MUQR>�M�s O_6�9 6�25VR6FN8:ON9�Q*X=k C di9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>+~�| 6�25476 K 9�4�F�9�8*MN9�M�O_6�9YM_8 T [�;I9YMN2 ��9W8�w*8*25;�8 . ;59WXbQRF^MNOPS K / � �

O_6�9 K 2 � 4�S�;IO / Q*X K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�2�>�VA[ 8?FN8 T 9�OU9�F�M�M_S�4�6A8*M Px8?> K � ��� XbQRF�MUO_8?F�M�8 . Q(w09 �VE ~ EVEVE { 8?> K |�25O_6

;5Q?V�P � O � � 80> K O_6�9gX\8*4�O�O_6 8*OnMUQ T 9YMNO_8?F�Mc2�> O_6�9 MUO_F�2�[ 80F�9 [ FHQ . 8 . ; / MNON25;5;=8?[ [ FHQR8*4�6�2 >�V T 8 "R2 T S T

� ��� | 6�25;59 Q0O_6�9�F�M`8?F�9 8*;�F�9�8 K / 4�QRQ0;I2�>�V�ONQ*| 80F K | 6�25ON9TR K |�8?FuX K Q T ~ T 8VH02�>�VA25O K 2 � 4�S�;5OCONQ9�MNOP8 . ;52IMP6

O_6�9�2�FY[ F�9�4�25MN9`9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / MNO_8:O_S�McXZF�Q T OP6�9`Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�M�� C�9�FN>�9�F ���?� A y

@gXzO_6�9 Ou|�Q O / [ 9�MAQ:X k C d [ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M�~WO_6�9 � C � 2�F�MNO_8?FHMON9�> K ONQ 6 8�w09t6�25VR6�9�F�VRFU8�w�25ON259�M

��;5Q?V�P �

Y ~�8?> K ~ .0/ K 9P] >�2IOU2IQ�>+~�O_6�9 / 6 8�w?9A>�Q)>�9 . S�;�8 yifg6RS�MzOP6�9 / 8?[ [ 9�8?F ONQ . 9�MN;525VR6?OU; /lT QRF�9

9�w?Q?;5w?9 K O_6 8?>xO_6�9�k������ MNOP8?F�M�y�f�6�9�k������ MNO_80F�M�2�>�V?9�>�9�FN8*;^[ S�;5M_8*ON9C8*O ;5QR>�V09�F [ 9�F�25Q K M �b80F�QRS > K

�FEVE E� @ EVE E M OP6 8?> O_6�9 � C��Y2�F�MNOP8?F�M ��|Y6�2I4�68*;5;^[ S�;IMP8*ON9�8:O [ 9�F�25Q K M Q:X�;59�MNMYO_6 8?> �FE EVE M ycf�6�9�F�9

25M`8 |�9�;I;>R K 9P] >�9 K O_F�9�> K ONQ M_6�QRF�OU9�F [ 9�F�25Q K X\F�Q T O_6�9 T Q?MUO ;�S T 2�>�QRS�MCk � � � MNO_8?F�MYONQ O_6�9C4�QRQ0;I9�MUO�~

X\8*2�>?ON9�MUO � C � 2�F^MUO_8?F�M�y f�6�25Mn25Mn4�;59�8?FH; / 9�w�2 K 9�>?O�2�>Cj^25VRS F�9�@ y � ~�| 6�25476 M_6�Q*|�M^O_6�9�8 T [�;525O_S K 9YM_[ 9�4�OPFN8

Q*X�MN2 "Ck � � �l8?> K � C �Y2�F MNO_8?FHM�~�Q�F K 9�F�9 K |g2IOP6 � � � K 9�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�VYX\F�Q T ONQR[WOUQ . Q?ONONQ T y�h�9�4�8*;5;�O_6 8:O�2�>

O_6�9����e�9�ON2 MNO_80F�M�~*O_6�9�Q�[ [ Q?MN25ON9gO_F�9�> K 25M�MN9�9�> 7 4�Q�Q?;59�FnMUO_8?F�Mn6 8�w?9�;5QR>�V?9�Fc[ 9�F�25Q K M�~ 8YX\8*4�O^9+" [�;�8*2�>�9 K

.0/ O_6�9WMU2 > H02�>�V Q:X=O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V ��QR>�9WONQC;5QR>�V?9�F O_6�9�F T 8*;+ON2 T 9�MU4�8*;59�M�yGo X�OP6�9`[ 9�F�25Q K M 2�> � C �Y2�F�8?> K

k � ��� MUO_8?F�M^8?F�9�;52 H*9�|�25MN9 K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K.?/ O_6�9 K 9�[�O_6CQ:X O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V���QR>�9?~0O_6�9�>Cw*8?F�2�8 . ;59 k C dWM=Q*X�8

V?25w?9�> T 8*MNM�M_6�Q�S�; K XbQ?;5;5Q*| OP6�9 M_8 T 9�O_F�9�> K ~�MN2�>�4�9W9�w?9�F / QR[ 8*4�25O / Xb9�8*O_S F�9�2�>k C d T Q K 9�;+9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9�M

MN2�> H0M K 9�9�[ 9�F�~ ONQ*| 80F K ;IQ�>�V?9�FcON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M�~ |g2IOP6 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN2�>�V�� ��� 8*Mn|�9�;5;byGf�6�9W[ 9�FH2IQ K O_F�9�> K 25M�8�4�;�S�9

O_6 8*O�[ 9�FN6 8?[�MYMNQ T 9 T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T Q0O_6�9�FcO_6 8?> O_6�9W4�6 8?>�V?2�>�V K 9�[�O_6 Q*Xn8 K FH2Iw�2�>�V ��Q�>�9`V?Q*w?9�FN>�M�k C d

[ 9�FH2IQ K M�y

@W>�9z[ Q?MNMN2 . ;59 4�80> K 2 K 8:ON9z25MWO_6�9C476 80>�V?2�>�VAw(8:; S�9 Q*XnO_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T PSR T Q K 9z[ 9�F�25Q K y�o X���� �2IM

MNQ T 9�6�Q(|LF�9�;�8*ON9 K OUQ�OP6�9�FN8?>�V09WQ*X�[ 9�F�25Q K MW|�9WMN9�9�2�>A8z[ 8?FHON254�S�; 80F k C dz~ O_6�9�>O_6�9 � K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>�4�9

T 25VR60OnQ ��MN9�OcO_6�9 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN2�>�V�� ��� 2�>7?^a S 8*ON25QR>�� = y O 9�>�QRS�VR6 ONQC8*4�4�QRS >0O^XbQRF^O_6�9gO_F�9�> K |G9gMN9�9?~�MN2�>�4�9

k C dWM 80F�9W9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K ONQzM_6 FH2 > H8:M�O_6�9 / 9�w?Q?;5w?9�O_6 F�QRS�V�6 O_6�9`2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / MNOPF�2�[+yG}Y>0X Q�F�O_S > 8*ON9�; / ~%O_6�9

[ F�9�4�25MN25QR>3Q:X�M_[ 9�4�O_F�Q?MU4�QR[�254 T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>0ONM�Q:Xn;IQ0V!P X Q�F�O_6�9�MNO_8?FHMG2�>�j^25VRS F�9�@ y � 8?FH9`2�>�M_S � 4�259�>0O`ONQ

K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9�O_6�9�2�F FUS > Q*X�FU8 K 252 y

J MNON9�FHQ?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V / V?25w?9�MnS�M^O_6�9 T 9�8?>�M^ONQ K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9�MNON9�;5;�8?F^[ F�Q�[ 9�F�ON259�M T QRF�9�[ F�9�4�25MN9�; / ~R2�>CQ�F K 9�F�3J0/3<?NDST6./ 6?>=/�S 1 �T251 �/ 1)2KB �/ A54 2KB=U ��� 8�F H�J <"<?N /�B�U �T/3<.< 472K1&6?STE /$S B�6?>DST<"S B�<.6.2#��S�� ST6QC <.6?1.S N 6?>=2KB /�ST6?>�/)1 6?>=/

J � ��AK1 ��� �R/36?S <.6.2K1)<�<?N�/�B=U S B 6?>=/�S 1)<3V

Page 49: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@VA

0

2

4

6

NGC 1501

0

1

2

3

Sand 3

0

1

2

3

4

RX J2117

0

2

4

6

PG 1159

0

5

10

15

PG 1707

02468

10

PG 2131

500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000

Am

pltu

de [m

ma]

j^25VRS F�9%@ y � J T [�;I25O_S K 9YM_[ 9�4�O_FN8YQ*X+MN2 "�k � ��� 8?> K � C �Y2 F MUO_8?F�M�~*2�>CQ�F K 9�F�Q:X K 9�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�V� ��� X\F�Q T ONQR[ ONQ . Q?ONONQ T �"XZFHQ T {W8�|�8*;59�F ���?�VO y

ONQ 80>�MN|�9�F�O_6�9�a S�9�MUON25QR>Q*Xn|Y6�9�O_6�9�F�OP6�9`O_F�9�> K 25MW4�8?S�MN9 K-.0/ O_6�25MW8 T [�;525O_S K 9TR\;52 T 2�ON2�>�V�XZ8*4�OUQRF�y�@W>�9

Q*XCQRS F V?QR8*;5M�2 > 8?> 8*; / ��2�>�Vi8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*;Ck C d [ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 9�4�O_FN8 2�>Le�6 8?[�ON9�F J 25M�ONQ 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9 O_6�9

[ F�9�4�25MN25QR> Q:X ;5Q?V�P T 9�8*M_S FH9 T 9�>?OUM�yif�6�25M|�25;5;`[ F�Q*wR2 K 9�S�M |g2IOP6lOP6�9 K 8*O_8 >�9�9 K 9 K ONQ)[ F�Q . 93O_6�9

4�QRFNFH9�; 8:ON25QR> . 9�Ou|�9�9�> O_6�9`[ 9�F�25Q K O_FH9�> K [�2I4�OPS F�9 K 2 >xj^25VRS F�9%@ y � 8?> K O_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T [ 9�F�25Q K 2 T [�;I259 K

.0/ ?�a S 8*OU2IQ�> � = y O y

C 9 8*;5MNQWMN9�9FHCOP6�9 [ F�9�4�25MN9 . QRS > K 8?FH2I9�M�Q*X+O_6�9�2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / MUO_F�2�[+~?2�> 6�QR[ 9�M�O_6�25Mn|g2I;5;%2I;5;�S T 2�> 8*ON9�O_6�9

MNQRS FH4�9zQ*X K F�25wR2�>�V .0/ ON9�;5;52 >�V�S�MzS > K 9�F�| 6 8*OW4�QR> K 25ON25QR>�M k C dWM`[ S�;5M_8*ON9?y J >�Q?O_6�9�F�[ F�Q . ;59 T O_6�25M

T 25VR60O`6�9�;�[3MNQ?;5w?9C25MWO_6�9z8?[ [ 8?F�9�>0OY;IQ�4�8*ON25QR>tQ*XG8 . Q�S�OWON9�>3>�QR> Ru[ S�;5M_8*ONQRFH2 >�V3k � �?� A � MNOP8?F�MY|�25O_6�2�>

O_6�9`k C d 2�>�MNOP8 . 25;I25O / FH9�V?25QR> Q*X^O_6�9�m Ruh K 2�8*V�FN8 T y^obO T 8 / . 9`O_6 8*Og|�25O_6 T QRF�9`[ FH9�4�2IMU9�H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09

Q*X=OP6�9W2 >�MUO_8 . 25;52IO /A. QRS > K 8?F�259�M�~%MNQ T 9YQRF�8*;5;�Q*X O_6�9`>�QR> Ru[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M�4�8?> . 9WQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> 8*;5; / 9+"R4�;�S K 9 K

X\F�Q T O_6�9GF�9�V02IQ�>+y�@WS F�] > K 2�>�V?M^|g2I;5;�S > K QRS . OU9 K ; / FN8*25MN9G>�9�| a S�9�MNON25QR>�M�~*| 6�25;I9Y8*;5;IQ*|�2�>�V`S�M^ONQW8?>�MN|�9�F

QR>�; / MNQ T 9WQ*X=O_6�9 T y�j�QRF�OP6�9`F�9�MNO�~�|�9W|�25;5;�[ Q?2�>?OYQRS�O K 2�F�9�4�ON25QR>�MWO_6 8*O T 25VR60O�9�w?9�>0O_S 8*;5; / ;59�8 K S�MYONQ

Page 50: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@ O

8?>0|�9�F�M�ynDc9PXbQRF�9`|�9WV?9�OgMNQzX\8?F�~ 6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~ |�9 T S�MNO�] FHMNO MPS TzT 8?F�2 ��9�| 6 8*O�|�9`8*;�F�9�8 K / H�>�Q*| 8 . QRS�O

M_[ 9�4�2�]�4zk C d [ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�M�y

Z � � � ' �C+��1�8 �A��� �+�b#����7� �����/1 ' ' � ����� Z �

k � �?� A �� E @VA �b8 yBH�yE8 � C �Y2�F�~R6�9�F�9�8(X ON9�F^k � �?� A � 25M�~R8:M T 9�>?OU2IQ�>�9 K [ F�9�w�2IQ�S�MN; / ~ROP6�9 [ F�Q?ONQ0O / [ 9

Q*X�O_6�9 k � �0� A � M_[ 9�4�O_FN8*;c4�; 8:MNM�~ | 6�25476 2�>�4�;�S K 9�M 8*MC8M_S . MU9�O T Q?MUO`Q*X�O_6�9zw*8?F�2�8 . ;59Ak C dWM�y obO�2IM

8*;5MNQCO_6�9W[ F�Q?ONQ0O / [ 9gQ*X=O_6�9 � C� 2�F�V?2�>�25M [ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M�~ 8?> K 25O�|�8*MnO_6�9g] F�MNO�MNOP8?F^ONQ�| 6�25476 T Q?MNOnQ:X=O_6�9

8*MNOU9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q0;IQ0V?254�8*;�ONQ�Q?;5M�X\F�Q T e�6 8?[�ON9�F =C|�9�F�9WM_S�4�4�9�MNM�X\S�;5; / 8?[ [�;5259 K y

J XbON9�F O_6�9 K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F / Q*X 25ONMcw(8?FH2 8 . 2I;525O / .0/ 134 � FN8�|)9�O�8*;by � ��� Y � k � �?� A � . 9�4�8 T 9�OP6�9�O_8?F�V09�O=Q*X

8?> 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V?; / 2�>?OU9�>�MN9 Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR> 8*;�[ F�Q?VRFU8 T O_6 8:OG8*ONOU9 T [�ON9 K ONQ�S > FN8�w?9�;%O_6�9 T 8?> / � XZF�9�a S�9�>�4 /

. 8?> K M �W2�>COP6�9Gj%QRS F�259�F O_FN80>�M�X Q�F T Q:X�2IOUM^;I25VR60ON4�S F�w09 � C 2�>�V?9�O^9�On8*;by ���?� A y ?^w?9�>0O_S 8*;5; / ~?25O^|�8*M M_6�Q*| >

O_6 8*OWOP6�9�MN9 . 80> K M`|�9�F�9zMN9�[ 80FN8*ON9 K).0/�T S�;IOU2 [�;59�MzQ:X 8 X\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*;�[ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�V�~ � - O_6�9 / |�9�F�9

8*MNMPS T 9 K OUQtFH9�[ F�9�MN9�>0O � � � T Q K 9�M �Z{W8�|�8*;59�F ���?� O ~ ���0� Y y3m�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~ 25O F�9 T 8*2�>�9 K 2 T [ Q?MNMU2 . ;59

ONQz8*MNMUQR4�2�8*ON9WOP6�9YXZF�9�a S�9�>�4 /A. 8?> K MY4�Q T [ 9�;I;52�>�V?; / |g2IOP6M_[ 9�4�2�]�4Cw*8*;�S�9�M Q*X �=~ MN2�>�4�9`O_6�9�2�FYS > K 9�F�; / 2�>�V

T Q K 9WMNO_FNS�4�OPS F�9W4�QRS�; K >�Q?O . 9�FH9�MNQ?;5w?9 K |g2IOP6 MN2�>�V?;59�MU2IOU9 K 8*O_8C8*;5QR>�9?y

C 2�>�V?9�O 9�O 8:; y � ���?� � F�9�[ Q�F�OzO_6�93F�9�M_S�;5ONMQ*XWO_6�9 ���?�?� C ?nf Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�M Q*X`k � �?� A � y J

[ Q�F�ON25QR> Q*X O_6�9 j�QRS FH2I9�F�O_FU8?>�M�XbQRF T Q:X OP6�9�C ?cf ;525VR60ON4�S F�w?925MCM_6�Q*| > 2 > j^25VRS FH9-@ y>= y�Ci6 8*Oz6 8 K

. 9�9�> MU9�9�>3XbQRF T 9�FH; / 8*MCO_6 F�9�9S > F�9�MNQ?;5w?9 Kl. 8?> K MCQ*X [ Q(|�9�FC8?F�9 6�9�F�9AF�9�MNQ?;5w?9 K 2�>?OUQ-OP6 F�9�9 K 25MNOU2 >�4�O

O_F�2�[�;59�ONM�y3f�6�9CX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V . 9�Ou|�9�9�> [ 9�8VH0MC25M >�9�80F�; / O_6�9 M_8 T 9CXbQRF 9�8*476tO_F�2�[�;59�O�~n8?> K O_6�9

O_F�2�[�;59�ONMn8?FH9 >�9�80F�; / 9�a S 8*;5; / M_[ 8:4�9 K Q�>�9nX\F�Q T 8?>�Q?OP6�9�F�2�>z[ 9�F�25Q K yno >C8*;5; ~0O�|G9�>0O / 4�QR>�MN9�4�S�ON25w?9�O_FH2 [�;59�ONM

;52 H*9CO_6�9�MN9C|�9�F�9`2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K 2�>AOP6�9 k � �?� A � OPFN8?>�M�XbQRF T ~ |�25O_6A8?>�8�w?9�FN8*V?9C[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�VQ*X = � y>ACM

� C 2�>�V?9�OW9�O`8*;by ���?� �� yWf�6�9z8�w?9�FN8*V?9 XZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[�;52IOUON2�>�V-|g2IOP6�2 >tO_F�2�[�;59�ONM`|�8*M J =���m �?yCf�6�25M`|�8*M

MN9�9�>8*M�MNOPF�QR>�VC9�wR2 K 9�>�4�9�O_6 8*O�O_6�9�MN9`8?FH9 ��� � T Q K 9�M�~�|�25O_6 O_6�9WO_FH2 [�;59�O�MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V 4�8?S�MN9 KA.0/ MNOU9�;I;�8?F

F�Q?OP8*ON25QR>+yCj S FHO_6�9�FW9�w�2 K 9�>�4�94�8 T 9CX\F�Q T O_6�9 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR> Q:XGMN9�w?9�FU8*;^a S�2�>0O_S [�;59�ONM�~^9�8:4763|g2IOP6�8?>

2�>?OU9�FN> 8*; X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[�;525ONON2�>�VAQ*XGY BE ��m �?y`f�6�9z8�w?9�FN8*V09�[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V . 9�O�|�9�9�>�a S�2�>0O_S [�;59�ONM`|�8*M

XbQRS > K ONQ . 9 � = yBA�M�ycj F�Q T ?^a S 8*ON25QR>� = y �� ~0O_6�9`9+" [ 9�4�OU9 K FU8*ON25QzQ*X���� XbQRF ��� � ONQ ��� = T Q K 9�Mg2IM

E y O ~�| 6�254�6�2IMn>�9�80F�; / O_6�9cM_8 T 9�8*M=OP6�9GQ . MN9�F�w?9 K FN8*ON25Q . 9�O�|�9�9�>WO_6�9�O_F�2�[�;59�On8?> K a S�2 >0O_S [�;59�OnF�Q?OP8*ON25QR> 8*;

M_[�;525ONON2�>�V?M�y�?^a S 8*ON25QR>� = yB= [ FH9 K 2I4�OUM`8FN8*ON25QzQ*X � yBYV@ . 9�O�|�9�9�> � � XbQRF � � � 8?> K X QRF � � = T Q K 9�M�y

Page 51: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@VY

.00175 .0018 .00185 .0019 .00195 .002

0

Frequency [Hz]

Pow

er

j^25VRS F�9%@ y>= k QRF�ON25QR>�Q*X�O_6�9zj%QRS F�259�FYO_FN8?>�MHX QRF T Q*X k � �?� A � K 8*O_8 X\F�Q T OP6�9 ���?�?� C ?nfFNS >+~ M_6�Q*|�2�>�VzOP6�9`O_F�2�[�;59�OYMNO_FNS�4�O_S FH9WQ*X=O_6 F�9�9 T Q K 9�M�y

f�6�9[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�VtX QRF O_6�9Ak � �?� A � O_F�2�[�;59�ONMz25M � yBYV=OU2 T 9�M�OP6 8*O�X QRF O_6�9 a S�2�>0O_S [�;59�ONM�y f�6�25MC2IM

MNO_FH2 H02�>�VA4�QR>0] F T 8*ON25QR>�Q*X�O_6�9zO_6�9�QRF / Q*X�8*MNON9�F�Q0MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V / 8*M`8?[ [�;5259 K OUQ| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XnMNOP8?F�M�yCf�6�9

T 8*MUMn8?> K F�Q?OP8*ON25QR>CFN8*ON9�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9 K.0/ C 2�>�V?9�On9�O�8*;by � ���?� � X\F�Q T O_6�9�MU9 F�9�M_S�;5ONMc2IM E A � � E>E � � �

8?> K � y>@ � K 8 / M�~�FH9�M_[ 9�4�ON25w?9�; / y

{W8�|�8*;59�F � DGFU8 K ;59 / � ���?� J 4�Q T [ 8?F�9 K OP6�9 k � �?� A � [ 9�F�25Q K MCONQ�O_6�Q?MN9 XZF�Q T 8VRF�2 K Q:X MUO_8*ON254

k C d T Q K 9�;5M�~^8?> K XbQRS > K OP6 8*OWO_6�9 . 9�MNO T 8*ON4�6�QR4�4�S F�9 K 2EX k � �?� A � 6 8*MC8 ;5Q?V�P�Q*XGY @ � � E�� ~

;5Q?V � ��� � � = = � � EBE A ~(80> K 8 M_S F X\8*4�9 6�9�;52�S T 8 . S > K 8?>�4�9YQ*X=8 . Q�S�O @ E�� y J MNON9�F�Q?MU9�2IM T Q?;5Q?V / O_6�S�M

9�MNO_8 . ;I25M_6�9 K O_6�9CV?;5Q . 8*;^[ F�QR[ 9�FHON259�MWQ*XGk � �?� A � T S�476 T QRFH9�[ F�9�4�25MN9�; / O_6 8?> � . S�O 4�Q�>�MN25MNON9�>0OW|�25O_6

O_FN8 K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;+M_[ 9�4�O_FHQ?MN4�QR[�254 T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?ONM�O_6 8:OG[ S�O�25ONM � � � 8*O �+J E�TEVEVE � �FE�TEVEVE { 8?> K 25ONM�M_S F X\8*4�9

VRFN8�w�25O / 8*O�;5Q?V�P�� Y BE � E A � C�9�FN>�9�F�~ mg9 . 9�F � mYS >�V?9�F ���0� �� y

k 9�FH2IQ K 254 K 9�w�2 8:ON25QR>�MYXZFHQ T S >�2EXbQRF T [ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�VMN9�9�>32�> . Q?O_6�O_6�9 � � � 80> K � � = T Q K 9�M

8*;5;5Q*|G9 K {W8�| 8:;I9�F � D�FN8 K ;59 / � ���0� J ONQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9CO_6�9�O_6�254 H�>�9�MNMYQ*X�OP6�9`6�9�;I2�S T ; 8 / 9�F 2 >�k � �?� A �

Page 52: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@ �

8*M5@ � �FE � � ����y^f�6�25MGFH9�M_S�;5OG2 T [�;5259�M 8�6�9�;I2�S T ;�8 / 9�F O_6 FH9�9 QRF K 9�F�M^Q*X T 8*VR>�25O_S K 9YO_6�254+H*9�F^O_6 80>CO_6 8*O

T 9�8*MPS F�9 K 2�>O_6�9�d`D �LMNO_80F � d @VA � y^f�6�25MY|�QRS�; K MN9�9 T OUQ [ FH9�4�; S K 9CO_6�9`[ Q?MNMN2 . 25;525O / O_6 8:O � d @VA �

9�w?Q?;5w?9 K X\F�Q T 8 k � �?� A � R\;52 H:9�[ F�9�4�S F�MUQRF�y`mgQ*|G9�w09�F�~ dW9�6 >�9�F � {W8�| 8:;I9�F � ���?� A M_6�Q*|G9 K O_6 8*OYO_6�9

6�9�;52�S T >�9�8?F O_6�9 MPS F XZ8:4�9Q*X 83k � �?� A � T Q K 9�; K 2 �=S�MN9�MzONQ*|�8?F K O_6�9M_S F X\8*4�9 K S F�2�>�V�M_S . MN9�a S�9�>?O

9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+~�| 6�25;59�6�9�8�w�259�Fn9�;59 T 9�>0ONM K 2 �=S�MN9WONQ*|�8?F K O_6�9Y4�9�>?O_FU8*; F�9�V02IQ�>�M K S�9WOUQ`VRFN8�w�25ON25QR> 8*;�MU9�ONON;52�>�V�y

f�6�9 / M_6�Q*| O_6 8*O`8k � �?� A � MUO_8?FY|�25O_638?>�2�>�25ON2�8*;�M_S F X\8*4�9C; 8 / 9�FY4�Q T [ Q?MU9 K Q*X @ E�� 6�9�;52�S T 8?> K 8

O_6�254+HR>�9�MNM Q*X �FE � � � � 4�8?>�9�w0Q?;5w?9 2�>0ONQ�8d`D | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X�|�25O_6 8M_S F X\8*4�9 ;�8 / 9�F`Q:Xg8:; T Q?MNO�[ S FH9

6�9�;52�S T QR>�; / �FE�� � � � O_6�254 H%y�f�6�9MNOP8?F`6 8*MCO_6�9 M_8 T 9 8 T QRS >?OCQ*X 6�9�;52�S T 8:M . 9PX Q�F�9 � MUQ T 9 Q*X 25O

MN2 T [�; / . 9�4�Q T 9�Mn4�Q�>�4�9�>?O_FU8*ON9 K T Q�F�9�ONQ*| 80F K O_6�9�M_S F X\8*4�9?~*|�25O_6 O_6�9�O_FN80>�MN25ON25QR>�X\F�Q T [ S F�9Wm�9Y8*O^O_6�9

M_S F X\8*4�9�ONQ!@ E�� mg9 T Q*w�2�>�V 2�>0| 80F K M 8*M�OP6�9`MNO_80Fn4�Q�Q?;5M�y�f�6�S�M�O_6�9C6�9�;52 S T ;�8 / 9�F�MgMN9�9�>�2 >�k � �?� A �

8?> K � d @VA � 8?F�9W4�QR>�MU2IMUON9�>?OY|�25O_68C4�Q TzT QR> 9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / QRF�25V?2�>+y

J >�Q?O_6�9�F�8*MUON9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V?254�8*; � ] F�MNO ��8*4�6�259�w?9 K 2�> MNO_S K 259�M�Q:X�k � �?� A � 4�QR>�4�9�FU>�M K 9�ON9�F T 2�> 8*OU2IQ�>

Q*X�25ONM�FN8*ON9gQ*X�9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> wR2�8 T 9�8*M_S FH9 T 9�>?OcQ*X �� � � � � ��� � y�fg6�9 9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K FN8*OU9�Q*X=k C di9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>

;59 K ONQ 8?> 2�>�25ON2�8*;n[ F�9 K 254�ON25QR>�O_6 8*OgO_6�9�RbX Q?; K 2�>�VON2 T 9 X QRFg[ 9�F�25Q K 4�6 8?>�V?9�MY2�> � C �Y2�F�MUO_8?F�M�MP6�QRS�; K

. 9 Q*XGO_6�9 QRF K 9�F �FE � / 9�80F�M�yCf�6�25M`O_FN80>�MN;�8*ON9�MW2�>?OUQ �� � �FE � *5* M �*MYXbQRF A EVE M`[ 9�F�25Q K M�y f�6�9 [ 9�F�25Q K M

|�9�F�9�9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K OUQ`2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9W|g2IOP6CON2 T 9W8*M�8`F�9�M_S�;5O�Q*X�O_6�9YQ*w?9�FN8*;5; 4�Q�Q?;52 >�V Q*X�O_6�9 MUO_8?F�y�1-9�8:M_S F�9 T 9�>0O

Q*XnM_S�4�6M T 8*;5;=4�6 8?>�V?9�MWF�9�a S�2�F�9�M / 9�8?F�MYQ*Xn4�QR>�MU2IMUON9�>?OYQ . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�M�~ S�MN2�>�VO_6�9���� �"!� ON9�4�6 >�25a S�9�M

K 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 K 2�>)eg6 8?[�ON9�F�= yAmgQ*|G9�w09�F�~�| 6�9�> C 2�>�V?9�OC9�O 8:; y � ���?� A ] > 8*;5; /)K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K O_6�9 FU8*ON9zQ*X

[ 9�FH2IQ K 4�6 8?>�V?9�XbQRF k � �?� A � ~%O_6�9 / XbQRS > K O_6 8*O �� K 2 K 2�> K 9�9 K 6 8�w?9CO_6�9C[ F�9 K 254�ON9 K T 8*VR>�25O_S K 9 . S�O

O_6�9W| FHQR>�VzMN25VR>+s^OP6�9`[ 9�F�25Q K Q:X�O_6�9%A �FO M T Q K 9`|�8*M ����+"�3���&%'���( 8*O�O_6�9CFN8*ON9YQ*X # �FE � *5* M �*M�y

<�2�>�4�9�4�QR>?OPFN8*4�ON25QR> ON9�> K M�ONQ K 9�4�F�9�8:MN9 T Q K 9`[ 9�F�25Q K M�~ 25O�|�8*M�2�>�2IOU2 8:;I; / O_6�QRS�VR60O�O_6 8*O�O_6�9W4�Q�Q?;52 >�V

FN8*OU9�2�>k C d T Q K 9�;5MG|�8*Mc2�>�4�QRFNF�9�4�O�~ K S�9 ONQC8 XZ8*25;�S F�9WQ*X�QRS FcS > K 9�F�MNO_80> K 2 >�V Q*X�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�QC9 T 25MNMN25QR>+~

QRF MNQ T 9�Q?O_6�9�F T 9�476 8?>�25M T yno�X�O_6�9 T Q K 9�;5Mn4�Q�Q?;59 KT QRF�9�MU;IQ*|�; / O_6 8?>C8?>0ON254�2�[ 8*ON9 K ~�O_6�9�>C4�Q�>?O_FU8*4�ON25QR>

T 25VR60O . 9WO_6�9 K Q T 2 > 80>?O�9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / T 9�476 8?>�25M T O_6 8*O K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9�MW6�Q*| OP6�9 [ 9�F�25Q K MY476 80>�V?9W|�25O_6

ON2 T 9?ynmgQ*|�9�w?9�F�~?{W8�|�8*;59�F � D�FN8 K ;59 / � ���?� J M_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8*O^OP6�9 A � O M T Q K 9�25M�8WO_FN80[ [ 9 K T Q K 9?~ 8?> K

O_6 8*OYMN2�>�4�9zO_FU8?[ [ 9 K�T Q K 9�M`8?F�9C4�QR>�4�9�>0O_FN8*OU9 K ONQ*|�8?F K O_6�9CM_S FuXZ8*4�9?~+OP6�9�2 FW[ 9�F�25Q K 476 8?>�V09�M`8?F�9CV?Q*wVR

9�FN>�9 K3.?/ 4�Q�>?O_FU8*4�ON25QR> 2�>O_6�9YQRS�ON9�F ; 8 / 9�FHM�y^f�6�9�[ 9�F�25Q K MYQ*X�>�QR> R\OPFN8?[ [ 9 K3T Q K 9�M 8?F�9YMNON25;5;=9+" [ 9�4�OU9 K

ONQ2�>�4�F�9�8*MU9 |�25O_6 ON2 T 9 . 9�4�8?S�MN9 Q*XG4�Q�Q?;52�>�V�Q*X�O_6�9z4�QRF�9?~�| 6�9�F�9 O_6�9�2�F`8 T [�;I25O_S K 9�M 8?F�9C;�8?F�V?9�F O_6 8?>

Page 53: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

@ �

O_6�Q?MU9WQ*X�OPFN8?[ [ 9 KAT Q K 9�M�y �

fg6�2IM�4�Q T [�;5254�8*ON9�MCO_6�9z2�>0ON9�FN[ F�9�OP8*ON25QR>3Q*X �� T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?ONM�2�>)6�Q?O � C �Y2�FC8?> K k � ��� MUO_8?F�M

| 6�9�F�9?~c8*Mz{W8�|�8*;59�F � DGFU8 K ;59 / � ���?� J M_6�Q*|�9 K ~ O_6�9 4�QR>?OPFN8*4�ON25QR> Q*X�O_6�9QRS�ON9�F ;�8 / 9�F�MC4�8?>�4�FH9�8*ON9

;�8?F�V?9 K 2 ��9�FH9�>�4�9�MW2 > �� X\F�Q T'T Q K 9CONQ T Q K 9?yYo�Xn|�9`|�25M_6xONQ ON9�MNO�QRS FgO_6�9�QRF / Q*XGk C d 4�QRQ?;52�>�V�~+|�9

T S�MNOW9�25O_6�9�F T 8VH*9 [ F�9�4�25MN9 T Q K 9z2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR>�MzQ�F T 9�8*MPS F�9 �� 2�> T Q K 9�MWXbQRFY| 6�254�6�4�Q�>?O_FU8*4�ON25QR>

25Mz>�Q?O�8 XZ8*4�OUQRF�yf�6�25MC|�25;I; . 9 O_6�9 4�8*MN9 X QRF ��## O_6�9 [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> T Q K 9�MC2�> � C � 2�F�MNO_80F�M`>�9�8?F�O_6�9

;5Q*|5R � ��� 9�> K Q*X�O_6�9z2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / MUO_F�2�[+~ | 6�9�F�9z4�QR>0O_FN8:4�ON25QR>325Mz8*; T Q?MNO�4�Q T [�;59�ON9?yo\> e�6 8?[�ON9�F O |�9

|�25;5;^9+" [�;5QRFH9�OP6�2IMW25MNMPS�9 T QRF�9WX\S�;5; / ~�| 6�9�>�|�9`4�QR>�MU2 K 9�FYOP6�9�a S�9�MNON25QR>�Q*XGS�MU2 >�V �� T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>0ONMY2�>

4�Q�Q?; � C� 2�FgMNO_8?FHMGOUQzON9�MNO�QRS F�OP6�9�QRF�259�M Q:X�>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q 9 T 25MNMN25QR>x2�>Ak C dL2�>?ON9�FH2IQ�F�M�y

k � �0� A � M_6�Q*|�9 K S�M�| 6 8*Oc4�8?> . 9W8*4�4�Q T [�;I25M_6�9 K | 6�9�> 9�>�QRS�VR6 [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> T Q K 9�M�8?FH9�2 K 9�>?ON2E]�9 K

2�>3O_6�9 [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 9�4�O_FNS T Q*X�8MNO_80F�y`mgQ(|�9�w?9�Fv~+QR>�9zMNO_80F�25M`2�>�M_S � 4�2I9�>0OCONQAF�9�w?9�8:;^O_6�9C4�8?S�MN9zQ*X�O_6�9

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�McQRF QRS�ON;52�>�9YO_6�9 . Q�S > K 8?F�259�MnQ*X+O_6�9�2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / MNO_FH2 [ XbQRF^S�M�y Ci6�25;I9YO_6�9 8:MNO_F�Q?MU9�2IM T Q?;5Q?V?254�8*;

8?> 8*; / MN25M^Q*X�k � �?� A � FH9 T 8*2�>�9 K O_6�9cMN2�>�VRS�;�8?F^9+" 8 T [�;59?~?|�9c4�QRS�; K >�Q?O^8?>�MN|�9�F=80> /WK 9�O_8:2I;59 K a S�9�MNON25QR>�M

8 . QRS�OzO_6�94�;�8*MNM [ F�QR[ 9�FHON259�MzQ*X`k C d [ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�M�y o\> e�6 8?[�ON9�F J ~c|�9 9+"�ON9�> K 8*MNOU9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q0;IQ0V?254�8*;

8?> 8*; / MN25MCONQO_6�9zQ?OP6�9�F � C �Y2 F MNO_8?FHM�~�| 6�254�6�4�Q*w?9�FW8x|�2 K 9 FN8?>�V09zQ*X�MNON9�;5;�8?F`[ FHQR[ 9�F�OU2I9�M�y fg6�QRS�VR6

>�QR>�9CQ*X�O_6�9 T M_6�Q*| a S�25ON9zMNQF�254�6�8 [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 9�4�O_FUS T 8*MWk � �0� A � 25ONMN9�;EXN~�|�9C4�8?>�MNON25;5;^M_6�Q*| O_6 8*O

k � �?� A � 25Mz>�Q?O`S >�25a S�92�> 25ONM�[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>)[ 8*OUON9�FN>�M � 4�; S�9�M�X\F�Q T O_6�9 Q?O_6�9�F � C �Y2�F�MNO_8?F�M`6�9�;�[ S�M

4�QR>�MNOPFNS�4�O 8C4�QR6�9�FH9�>?O [�254�O_S FH9`Q*Xnk C d [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>�2�>Ae�6 8?[�OU9�FGA y

Z � � � K � � � �"� �* ��"!�# !��W�%*�* � �+ ����*�

fg6�9�] F�MUOGk � ���iMNO_8?F K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F�9 K |�8*MnOP6�9 >�S�4�;59�S�M�Q*X=O_6�9W[�;�8?>�9�O_8?F / >�9 . S�;�8z{ � R �FO � � FN80S�9�F �

DcQR> K ���0� J yWf�6�9�F�9�8(X ON9�Fv~+MN9�w?9�> T Q�F�9`|�9�F�9�XbQRS > K ~�MN2 " K S F�2�>�VAOP6�9 ege�d M_S F�w?9 / Q*X @�� oY>�S�4�;I9�S�M

MNO_80F�M K 9�MN4�FH2 . 9 K-.0/ e�2�8?F K S�;5;5Q � DcQR> K � ���?�VO y J ;IMUQ�~�|�25O_6zOP6�9 K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F / Q*X�8YX\8*2�>0O >�9 . S�;�8z80F�QRS > K

O_6�9 � C �Y2�FYMNO_8?FYh�� � = �?� Y y ��� @ J�� = ~R25OW4�6 8?>�V?9 K 4�;�8*MNMN9�M`80> Kt. 9�4�8 T 9z8 k � � � MNO_8?F�� J [ [�;I9�OUQR>+~

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~ � ?^25ONOU9�F ���?� @ yWj^2�> 8*;5; / ~ O_6�9Cw*8?F�2�8 . ;59 @��Wo�MNOP8?F < 80> K S�;I9�8 H @ 25MCS�M_S 8*;5; / 4�QRS >0ON9 K 8*M`8

T 9 TC. 9�F � K 9�M_[�25ON9 25ONM`;�8*4+H�Q*X 8 M_S FNF�QRS > K 2�>�V�>�9 . S�;�8 . 9�4�8?S�MU9 Q*X�25ONM`;5QR>�V�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ 9�FH2IQ K Mz8?> K� ��/3@ /�BD6 �TC�8 �RA�<.6.2 $ % /)N �T/�1������ ���*" ;=<./3U$B=/39 U�2 6.2"6.A�1)/3UD/36./�1)E&S B�/06?>�/R1)2�6./:AK4�N�/)1.STA�U @.>=2KB �/RS B F � � � �D8 �DB�U�S B

2�������� ���� 1)2 6./ 6./�B�6?STE /3< �T2K1 /�1 6?>�25B 6?>�/ AK1)/36?ST@32��N�1)/3U�ST@36?STA5B�<3V �R/3@ 2K;=<./ A#��<./)1 �K2 6?STAKB=< AK4�F � � � � B=AK9 <?N�25B 6?9:AUD/3@32�UD/3<38=6?>�/3C 9R/)1)/�2#� �T/&6.A&@3AKB ��1)EG6?>DST<R1)/3<?; �T6 �DC @3A E$N=2K1.S B 6?>=/�N /�1.STA�U�<0A��/�1�E 2KBDC C�/3251)<�6.A$E / 2�<?;D1)/"6?>�/�1)2�6./ A54N�/�1.STA�U @.>�25B /"U S 1)/3@ 6 �TC�V

Page 54: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

J E

M_[ 9�4�O_FN8*;YMN2 T 25;�8?F�259�M3ONQ�O_6�9�k � � MUO_8?F�M 7 2�>�4�;�S K 2�>�V 9�wR2 K 9�>�4�93XbQRF 4�QR>?OU2 >�S�2�>�V T 8*MNM ;5Q?MNM X\F�Q T 25ONM

M_S F X\8*4�9 �bDcQR> K ~%e�2�8?F K S�;5;5Q�~ � 139�8VH*9�M ���?� � y

fg6�9`[ Q?ON9�>0ON2�8*;�S�ON25;525O / Q*X�k������ 8:MNON9�F�Q?MU9�2IM T Q?;5Q?V / 25MW8*O�;59�8*MNO 8*MgVRF�9�8*O�8*M�O_6 8*OgQ*X=O_6�9 � C��Y2 F

MNO_80F�M�y�f�6�9 / 8?F�9 T QRF�9�FH9�4�9�>?ON; / X QRF T 9 K ~�MUQ O_6 8:O�MNO_S K 259�M`Q:XnO_6�9�2�F [ F�Q�[ 9�F�ON259�M`[ F�Q*w�2 K 9 T QRF�9 K 2�F�9�4�O

H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09 Q*X�9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>3X\F�Q T O_6�9 J � D y k^;�8?>�9�O_80F / >�9 . S�; 8:9 XZS�9�;�8;�8?FHV?9 8?> K 8*4�ON25w?9C]�9�; K ~c|�25O_6

T 8?> / Q�S�ONMNO_8?> K 2�>�V�a S�9�MNOU2IQ�>�M�OUQ| 6�25476�[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> 8*; K 8:O_8 T 25VR60OWM_[ 9�8VH�y j^2�> 8*;5; / ~�O_6�9�F�9 8?FH9 T QRF�9

Q*X=OP6�9 T OP6 8?> � C �Y2�F�MNO_8?FHM�~�MNQCO_6�9 [ Q?ON9�>0ON2�8*;%X Q�FGS >�;5Q�4 H02�>�V OP6�9�2 F VRF�QRS [ [ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M�25M�2�> 6�9�F�9�>0ON; /

VRF�9�8:ON9�FcO_6 8?> XbQRF�O_6�9 � C �Y2�F�w(80F�2�8 . ;59�M�y

}Y>0XbQRF�O_S > 8*OU9�; / ~+OP6�9 k � � �'8*MUON9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V / 25M�[�;�8*VRS�9 K .0/-T 8?> / Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR> 8*; K 2 � 4�S�;5ON259�M�y

e�6�259PXG8 T Q�>�VzO_6�9�MN9W25MYO_6�9W9+"R25MNOU9�>�4�9�Q:X=O_6�9`MPS FNF�QRS > K 2�>�V>�9 . S�;IQ0MN25O / ~%| 6�254�64�Q T [�;5254�8*ON9�MYMNO_80> K 8?F K

8?[ 9�F�O_S F�9 [ 6�Q0ONQ T 9�O_F / y C 2IOP6�2 > 9�w?9�>�O_6�9zM T 8*;5;59�MNO�8?[ 9�F�O_S F�9�M�~�[ 8?F�ONMWQ*X�O_6�9 >�9 . S�;�8|g2IOP6 K 2 ��9�FH2 >�V

. F�25VR60O_>�9�MNM K F�2EXbOn2�>C8?> K QRS�O 2�>CO_6�9�[ F�9�MN9�>�4�9gQ*X 2 T [ 9�F X 9�4�OcON9�;59�MN4�QR[�254�O_FU8*4 H02�>�V�y^f�6�9�F�9�M_S�;5ON2�>�V`MU2IV�> 8*;

T Q K S�;�8*ON25QR> 4�8?> 9�8*MN25; / MN|�8 T [ OP6�9t[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> MN25VR> 8*;YX\F�Q T O_6�93MNOP8?Fz25ONMU9�;�XNy e�e d [ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�ON9�F�M

8?F�9 M_S [ 9�F�25QRF�XbQRF`F�9�4�Q�F K 2�>�Vtk������ ;I25VR60ON4�S F�w09�M�~ . S�OCO_6�9 / ON9�> K ONQ . 9F�9�;�8*ON25w?9�; / MN;5Q*| � T Q?MNOC8?F�9

K 9�MN25VR>�9 K XbQRFC;5QR>�V 2�>?OU9�VRFN8*ON25QR> OU2 T 9�MA8?> K 8?FH92I;5;>R\M_S�25ON9 K ONQ)6�25VR6 R\M_[ 9�9 K [ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�O_F / ~�8?> K O_6�9 /

6 8�w?9Y;IQ*| MN9�>�MN25ON25w�25O / 2�> O_6�9 . ;�S�9 7 | 6�9�FH9�OP6�9�MN9 6�Q0OGMUO_8?F�M�8?F�9 . F�25VR60ON9�MNO�8?> K O_6�9�2�F�[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>�M 6 8�w?9

O_6�93;�8?F�V?9�MUOA8 T [�;525O_S K 9?y f�Q K 8*ON9?~gQR>�; / O�|�Q k������ MUO_8?F�M6 8�w?9 . 9�9�>iQ . MU9�F�w?9 K |g2IOP6 T S�;IOU2IMU2IOU9

e�e�d 4�8 T [ 8*25VR>�M�y ��9�|�~�XZ8:MNO�~ . ;�S�9TR\MN9�>�MN25ON25w?9z2�>�MNO_FUS T 9�>?OUM 8?FH9`S > K 9�F K 9�MN25VR> X Q�F�S�MN9`2�>�6�2IV�6 R\M_[ 9�9 K

[ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�O_F / OP6 8*O�|�25;5; . 9�8?[ [�;5259 K ONQCQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�MYQ*X�k������ MNO_8?FHM�y

J MN9�4�QR> K [ F�Q . ;59 T 25MzOP6�9 ON2 T 9�MU4�8*;59AQ*X k������'w*8?F�2�8 . 25;52IO / y 13Q?MUO�6 8�w?9[ 9�F�25Q K M Q*XYQRF K 9�FC8?>

6�QRS F 7 4�;5Q?MU9-OUQ)8?> K . 9�;5Q(| OP6�9A;5Q*|5RbXZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / 4�S�ONQ �iQ*X C ?cfQR\MNO / ;I9�Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�MS�MN9 K X Q�FCO_6�9

M_6�QRFHON9�F�[ 9�FH2IQ K | 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX 8?> K � C � 2�F�MNO_8?F�M�y ?^w09�>Y2 >�MNOP8?F�M+|�25O_6W;5Q*|5R\M_S FuXZ8*4�9 . F�25VR60O_>�9�MNM=>�9 . S�;�8*9

O_6 8*O 6 8�w09 T 2�>�2 T 8*; 2�>0ON9�F Xb9�F�9�>�4�93|�25O_6 MNO_80> K 8?F K 80[ 9�F�O_S FH9A[ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�OPF / ~G8:O T Q?M_[ 6�9�FH2I4�9+"ROU2 >�4�OU2IQ�>

w(80F�2�8*ON25QR>�Mz4�8?> MU| 8 T [�OP6�9MNON9�;5;�8?F [ 9�F�25Q K 254�25O / y @W>�4�9A8:VR8*2�>+~Gege�d Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�Mz|�25;5; MUQ?;5w?9O_6�25M

[ F�Q . ;59 T y

Dc9�4�8?S�MU9 Q*X�O_6�9�MU9 K 2 � 4�S�;5ON259�M�~ T S�;IOU2IMU2IOU9 Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>�M 6 8�w?9 . 9�9�> S > K 9�F�O_8 H*9�>�MUQX\8?FYXbQRFYQR>�; /

O_6 F�9�9zk������ MNOP8?F�M�yWf�|�Q 7 < 8?> K S�;59�8VH�@ 8?> K O_6�9C4�9�>?OPFN8*; MNO_8?FgQ*X�� � e � A E � 7 |�9�F�9`Q . MU9�F�w?9 K�.?/

V?;5Q . 8*;W>�9�O�|�QRFIH0MzQ*X�e�e�d 4�8 T 9�FN8*M�yifg6�9-Q0O_6�9�F�~�h�� � = �?� Y y ��� @ J�� = ~�6 8*M8?> 9+"�4�9�9 K 2�>�V?; / XZ8*2�>0O

Page 55: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

J��

>�9 . S�;�8 80> K O_6�9 MP6�QRF�ON9�MNO�[ 9�F�25Q K MYQ*X�8?> / k������ MUO_8?F�y obO�4�QRS�; KA. 9`Q . MN9�FHw?9 K 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9�; / ~%O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9?~

|�25O_6xO_6�9 C ?nf >�9�O�|GQ�FIHzQ:X�[ 6�Q?ONQ�9�;59�4�O_F�254z[ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�OU9�F�M�y

@W>�9W[ F�Q . ;59 T |�25O_6 k������i[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> MNO_S K 259�M�| 6�25476 >�9�25O_6�9�F�e�e d 4�8 T 9�FN8*M�>�QRF T S�;5ON25MN25ON9Y4�8 T R

[ 8*25VR>�Mc4�8?>CQ*w?9�F�4�Q T 9G25M�O_6�9 S >�MUO_8 . ;59 > 8*O_S FH9�Q*X OP6�9�2 F�[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�> T Q K 9�M�y^p+2 H*9 T 8?> / Q*X+O_6�9�� ��e�9�ON2

MNO_80F�M �b8?> K S >�;52 H:9zO_6�9 T QRF�9`MUO_8 . ;59 � C �Y2�FW[ S�;5M_8*ONQRFHM k������ MNO_80F�M�M_6�Q*| 8 T [�;525O_S K 9Cw(8?F�2�8 . 25;525O /

QR>8COU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59CQ*X K 8 / M�~ |�9�9FH0M�~ 8?> K-T Q�>?O_6�M�~ |�25O_6 MNQ T 9 T Q K 9�MW8?[ [ 9�8?F�2�>�V Q�F K 25M_8?[ [ 9�80F�2�>�V4�Q T R

[�;59�ON9�; / Q�>AMP6�QRF�O �Z>�2IV�6?O9R\OUQ Ru>�25VR6?O ON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M��b{W8�|�8*;59�F ���?� A yCDn9PXbQRF�9 T Q*wR2�>�VAQ�>3ONQ-8 K K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;

� C � 2�F Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�M^2�>Ce�6 8?[�OU9�F J ~*|�9c|�25;I; K 25MN4�S�MUMn| 6 8*O 6 8*M . 9�9�>�;59�8?FN>�9 K X\F�Q T O_6�9cO_6 F�9�9�k � � �

Q . MN9�FHwR2�>�V 4�8 T [ 8*25VR>�M^rNS�MNO T 9�>?ON25QR>�9 K y

*21��\' � � ' J X ON9�F O_6�9 K 2IMU4�Q(w09�F / Q:X = A T 2 >�S�ON9 w(8?FH2 8 . 2I;525O / 2�> O_6�9 ;525VR60ON4�S F�w?9Q:X O_6�25M�C e J

4�9�>0O_FN8*;?MUO_8?F �bDcQR> K � e�2�8?F K S�;5;5Q ���?� @ ~�<�O_80>�VR6�9�;5;I2�>�2b~ {W8*;59�F�~ � < 6 8�|�� ���?� J S�MN9 K O_6�9�m�9�o�o ��80>�MNO_FN8

ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9^ONQ K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9 � ��� � �VE� E EVE � �FE�TE E E {l8?> K � �:= ���FEVE � YVA E � � y o\>��gQ*w?9 TC. 9�F ���?� � ~

8CV?;5Q . 8:;�>�9�O�|�QRFIH Q*X�e�e�d [ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�ON9�F�M�|�8*M�QRF�VR80>�2 ��9 K ONQCQ . MN9�F�w09�� � e � A E � X Q�F � J 4�Q�>�MN9�a S�OU2Iw09

>�25VR60ONM�y)DcQR> K 9�Oz8*;by � ���0�VO [ FH9�MN9�>?O O_6�9 FH9�M_S�;5ONMzQ*X OP6�2IM 4�8 T [ 8*25VR>+y f�6�9 / 2 K 9�>0ON2EX / � E MN9�[ 8?FU8*ON9

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>C[ 9�F�25Q K M�~�FN8?>�V?2�>�VgXZFHQ T �?� A J M=OUQ�AV=V@VA M�y^Dn9�4�80S�MN9nQ*X�OP6�9nMNO_80F�B M=6�25VR6�; / 2�FNFH9�VRS�;�8?F ON9 T [ QRFN8*;

M_[ 9�4�O_FNS T ~�O_6�9 / 8:;IMUQ FH9�; / QR> 80F�476�25w*8*; K 8*O_8WOUQ�6�9�;�[ O_6�9 T 2 K 9�>?ON2EX / 8 T 9�8?> � � � [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�VCQ*X

=V= y>@WM�ynfg6�9`F�Q?O_8*OU2IQ�> FN8:ON9 Q:X � � e � A E � 25M � y � Y K 8 / M�~ . 8*MN9 K QR> OP6�9 Q . MU9�F�w?9 K X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V

Q*X ��� ��m �?y

fg6�2IMF�9�M_S�;5O 9+" [�;�8*2�>�M�| 6 / MN2�>�V?;593MN25ON93Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M |�9�F�9MNQ K 2 � 4�S�;IOOUQ)8?> 8*; / ��9?s3O_6�9 K 8*25; /

T Q K S�;�8*ON25QR> S . 2Ia S�25ONQRS�M�2�> MN2�>�V?;59YMN25ON9 K 8*O_8W25M�>�9�8?F�; / 2 T [ Q?MNMN2 . ;59WONQ�MN9�[ 8?FN8*OU9�XZFHQ T O_6�9 T Q K S�;�8*OU2IQ�>

Q*X � � � T Q K 9�M^4�8?S�MN9 Kz.0/ � � e � A E � B M=FHQ?O_8*ON25QR>�FN8*ON9�Q*X 8:; T Q?MNO^9+" 8*4�ON; / QR>�9 K 8 / y J ;5MNQ%~�X QRF^[ 9�F�25Q K M

>�9�8?F � A E E M�O_6�9 =V= yB@ M [ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�Vz2 T [�;52I9�MW8 -/�3� � �D����+�;�K 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�9WQ*X=8 . Q�S�O � E ��m ��XbQRF T Q K 9�MQ*X�4�QR>�MN9�4�S�ON25w?9 � yzf�6�25M`25M`w?9�F / 4�;5Q?MN9 ONQO_6�9zF�Q?OP8*ON25QR> 8*;�XZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V3Q*X ��� ��m �?~ T 8VH02�>�V

2 K 9�>?OU2�]�4�8:ON25QR> Q*X`O_6�93Q*w?9�FN8:;I;W[ 8*ONOU9�FN> w?9�F / K 2 � 4�S�;IO�y f�6�25M K 9�V?9�>�9�FU8*4 / . 9�Ou|�9�9�> O_6�9xXZF�9�a S�9�>�4 /

M_[�;525ONON2�>�V K S�9CONQ F�Q0O_8*ON25QR>8?> K O_6 8*O K S�9CONQ O_6�9�[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V[ 8*ONON9�FU>25M 9+" [ 9�4�OU9 K OUQ [�;�8*VRS�9z8*;5;

k � ��� MNOP8?F�M�|�25O_6 T 8*MNMN9�M 80> K F�Q?O_8*OU2IQ�>FN8*ON9�M�MN2 T 25;�8?FgONQ � � e � A E � y

D�8*MU9 K QR>3O_6�9 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K [ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V�~^DcQR> K 9�O`8:; y � ���?� O MU9�O`O_6�9 T 8*MNM`Q:X�� � e � A E � 8*O

E A A � EBE @ � � ~�4�Q�>�MN25MNON9�>0O |�25O_6xO_6�9�[ FH9�wR25QRS�M � . S�Og;I9�MUM`[ F�9�4�25MN9 K 9�OU9�F T 2�> 8*ON25QR>�Q*XG<�O_80>�VR6�9�;5;I2�>�2b~

Page 56: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

J =

{W8*;59�F � < 6 8�| � ���?� J y

� ���6K�' '�� � '���Z �6' Kif�6�25M MNO_8?F+|�8*M K 2IMU4�Q(w09�F�9 K 2�>WOP6�9Gh�@W< J f �GRuFU8 / ON9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9�8*;5;BR\MTH / M_S FHw?9 / ~

8?> K 25O`|�8*M`2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K 8*M�8 T 9 TC. 9�F�Q*X�O_6�9 k � �0� A � M_[ 9�4�O_FN8*;c4�; 8:MNM .?/ 13Q?ON4�639�O�8:; y � ���?� = y oZO

|�8*MYa S�254+H?; / w09�F�2E]�9 K 8*M 8 [ S�;5M_8*ONQRFY|g2IOP6A8 K Q T 2�> 8?>0O`[ 9�F�25Q K >�9�8?F �VEVE M � C)8*OUMNQR> ���?� = ~ �n80S�4�; 8:2 F

9�OW8*;by ���?� @ y�h�� � = �?� Y y ��� @ J�� =��Z6�9�F�9�8�XbON9�F�h�� � = �?� Y 25MWQR>�9CQ*XnO_6�9C6�Q?ONON9�MUO H�>�Q*| >MNOP8?F�M�~%|�25O_6

8 � ��� 8?F�QRS > K � Y E ~ EVEVE {C~�80> K 25O�2IMMPS FNF�QRS > K 9 K .0/ Q�>�9-Q:X`O_6�9�;�8?F�V?9�MUO 8?> K Q?; K 9�MNO3[�;�8?>�9�O_8?F /

>�9 . S�;�8*9z9�w?9�F K 25MN4�Q*w?9�FH9 K � J [ [�;59�ONQR>+~ {W8�| 8:;I9�Fv~ � ?^25ONOU9�F ���?� @ y f�6�S�MW25O`[ F�Q . 8 . ; / FH9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONM`8?>

2�>?OU9�F T 9 K 2�8*ON9z9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / MNO_8*V?9 . 9�O�|�9�9�>�O_6�9zk � � MNO_80F�M 80> K O_6�9z> 8VH*9 K k C dWM�yWoZONM K Q T 2�> 8?>0O

[ 9�FH2IQ K 2IMA8:;IMUQ 2 >0ON9�F T 9 K 2 8:ON9 . 9�O�|�9�9�> O_6�93;5QR>�V?9�F�[ 9�F�25Q K k � ��� 80> K MP6�QRF�ON9�F [ 9�F�25Q K � C �Y2 F

[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M�y

D�8*MU9 K Q�>`MU2 >�V0;I9YMN25ON9�Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�M^Q*X�h � � = �?� Y ~ �n80S�4�; 8:2 F�9�On8*;by � ���?� @ ] > K ON9�>?OP8*ON25w?9�9�wR2 K 9�>�4�9

XbQRFcOu|�Q K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V [ 8*OUON9�FN>�M�~ = E y>AWM�8?> K � = y O M�~�|�25O_6 8CFN8:ON25Q�4�;5Q?MU9WONQ`O_6 8:OG9+" [ 9�4�OU9 K

. 9�O�|�9�9�> � � � 8?> K � � = T Q K 9�M�y-o X 4�QRFNF�9�4�O�~^O_6�9�MN9 M_[ 8*4�2�>�V?MC2 T [�; / O_6 8*OCh�� � = �0� Y B M T 8*MNM�2IM

8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9�; / EBO ���c~�8*M�9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K ~ . S�O�O_6�9 �n80S�4�; 8:2 Fg9�O 8*;by � ���0� @ [ 8:ONON9�FN> K 9�[ 9�> K M QR> MU9�w?9�FN8*;

2�>�MN9�4�S F�9 T Q K 9�2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR>�M�ycd`8*O_8gX\F�Q T 8 C ?cf FNS > ONQWQ . MN9�F�w09 h�� � = �?� YW8?F�9gMNON25;5; 2�> 8?> 8*; / MN25M�~

8?> K 25O^|�25;5; . 9�2�>0ON9�F�9�MNON2�>�VWONQYMN9�9�2EX O_6�9�[ 8*OUON9�FN>WMPS�V?V?9�MNON9 Kz.0/ �n8?S�4�;�8*2�F^9�On8*;by � ���?� @ 4�8?> . 9�w?9�FH2�]�9 K y

�+�+#��^��������� Z J >�Q0O_6�9�F�w*8?F�2�8 . ;59�k C d |�25O_6[ 9�F�25Q K MW2�>?ON9�F T 9 K 2�8*ON9 . 9�O�|G9�9�> OP6�Q?MN9WQ*Xnk � � �

8?> K � C �Y2�FYMNO_8?F�MY25M`< 8?> K S�;59�8VH�@ �b6�9�F�9�8(X ON9�FY< 8?> K @ yYobOW6 8*M`8?>x9 ��9�4�OU2Iw09�OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9�80F�QRS > K

� @ E ~ EVEVE {C~^8?> K 25O�2IMz8�w?9�F / 4�Q T [�;I9+" [ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�~ |�25O_6 O / [�254�8*;�[ 9�F�25Q K M >�9�8?F �VEVE MU9�4�QR> K M��bDcQR> K ~

e�2�8?F K S�;5;5Q � {W8�|�8*;59�F ���?� @ y`o\> ���?� = ~�8 V?;5Q . 8:;ne�e�d'>�9�O�|GQ�FIHQ . MU9�F�w?9 K < 8?> K @ 2�>0ON9�>�MN25w?9�; / XbQRF

Q*w?9�F�QR>�9W|�9�9FH%yGfg6�9�MN9 K 8*OP8���4�S FNF�9�>0ON; / 2�>A8?> 8:; / MN25M .?/ {W8�|�8*;59�F�~�DcQR> K ~ 9�OW8*;by M_6�Q*| O_6 8*O < 8?> K @

4�6 8?>�V?9 K 25ONMA[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> M_[ 9�4�O_FNS T MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0ON; / 2 > rHS�MNO O�|�Q / 9�8?F�M�~�8?> K 2 > K 9�9 K 476 8?>�V09 K K S FH2 >�V

O_6�9z4�Q�S F�MN9 Q*X�O_6�9 ���?� =FNS >+yAf�6�25MC4�Q T [�;5254�8*ON9�MCO_6�98?> 8*; / MN25M�MU2IV�>�2�]�4�80>?ON; / 4�Q T [ 8?FH9 K ONQAMU2 T [�;I9�F

[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M�~=80> K O_6�9zMNOP8?FY25M�MUON25;I;�>�Q?OWX\S�;5; / F�9�MNQ?;5w?9 K y obO�2IMz6�QR[ 9 K OP6 8*O K 8*O_8 X\F�Q T MN9�w09�FN8*;^MN9�8*MUQR>�M

T 25VR60O�[ F�Q*w�2 K 9 8x; 80F�V?9z9�>�QRS�V�63M_8 T [�;59 Q*X T Q K 9�M`ONQ K 9�4�Q K 9O_6�9 S > K 9�F�; / 2�>�V�M_[ 9�4�OPFNS T yf�Q*|�8?F K

O_6�25MW9�> K ~+< 8?> K @z|�8*M T 8 K 9`O_6�9CMN9�4�Q�> K 8?F / O_8?FHV?9�O�XbQRF�8�C ?cf FUS >A6�9�; K 2�> J [ F�25;b~ ���?�0� ~ . S�O K S�9

ONQ . 8 K |�9�8*O_6�9�Fc8*O T 80> / MN25ON9�M�~ K 8*O_8 |G9�FH9�QR>�; / Q . O_8:2 >�9 K XbQRF O_6�9W[ F�2 T 8?F / O_8?FHV?9�O �b8����Ae�9�ON2 |Y6�2IOU9

K |�8?F X y

Page 57: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

J @

C 9 6 8�w?9z>�Q*| 9+" 8 T 2�>�9 K MU9�w?9�FN8*;^w*8?F�2�8 . ;59 k C dWM�~ . S�O�QR>�; / QR>�9?~=k � �?� A � ~ / 259�; K 9 K OUQA8F�9�;>R

8*ON25w?9�; / 4�Q T [�;I9�OU9-8*MNOU9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q0;IQ0V?254�8*; 8?> 8*; / MN25M�y 1t80> / Q:X 25ONM[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> T Q K 9�M 6 8�w09 . 9�9�> 4�QR> R

4�;�S�MN25w?9�; / 2 K 9�>?ON2E]�9 K ~�[�;�8*4�2�>�V-MUO_F�254�OC;I2 T 25ONM QR>325ONM T 8*MNM�~�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / ~n8?> K 6�9�;52 S T ; 8 / 9�F�O_6�254+HR>�9�MUM�y

JWT QR>�V`OP6�9�4�9�>?OPFN8*; MNO_80F�M�~R80>CQ*w?9�FN8*;5;�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ 8*ONOU9�FN>z6 8*M . 9�9�> 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K XbQRF � � e � A E � ~ . S�Oc2�>

V?9�>�9�FN8:;�O_6�9�k������ w(80F�2�8 . ;59�MWM_6�Q*| 6�25VR6�; / S >�MNO_8 . ;I9 T Q K 9�[ 8:ONON9�FN>�M�~ T 8VH02 >�V K 9�O_8*25;59 K 8*MNON9�FHQ?MN9�25M9R

T Q?;5Q?V02I4�8:;�80> 8*; / MN25M K 2 � 4�S�;5O�yGfg6�9�MN9`[ F�9�;52 T 2�> 8?F / MNO_S K 259�M�MPS�V?V?9�MNO�O_6 8*O�O_6�9 T Q?MNO�[ F�Q T 25MN2�>�Vz4�Q�S F�MN9

ONQ9+"�ON9�> K O_6�9zM_S�4�4�9�MNMCQ*X�k � �?� A � OUQQ?O_6�9�FWk C dWM�;I259�MC2�>�Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�M`Q*X 8 K K 25ON25QR> 8:; � C �Y2 F

MNO_80F�M�y o >)eg6 8?[�ON9�F J ~ |�9 K 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 O_6�9 Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�M�QR>3| 6�254�6�OP6�2IMCO_6�9�MU2IM�~�80> K [ 8?F�ON254�S�;�8?F�; / O_6�9

8?> 8*; / MN25M [ FH9�MN9�>?OU9 K 2�>Ae�6 80[�ON9�FGA ~ 8?F�9 . 8:MN9 K y

Page 58: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

JVJ

�� ���!�7��� � � � �������� ����� �7������� � �!� ��$� ��� ����� � �� �;��

� � � ���_�D��� � �

�7��� ��� ��#G� (1; -'� �D� �����)��� �)%/�*�2(D#G���*� %'���2��+����D�5%0� ��#G�F(D�+���#&-'���3+�� 4 6

7 h�25476 8?F KAJ y�knF�Q�4�ONQRFv~�� ��1�"��� �2��#G�5%0��D�2� � �D�F%�@3A5B��FE

� ��� �������� "!$#&%'��() ��

fg6�9G8?> 8*; / MN9�M^Q*X�k C d [ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M QRS�ON;52�>�9 K 2�>CO_6�9n;�8*MUO^476 8?[�OU9�F=8?FH9GOP8?>?OP8*; / ��2�>�V�y C 25O_6Ck � �0� A � ~

|�9�;I9�80FN>�9 K OP6 8*O^|�9�4�8?>z8?[ [�; / O_6�9�OUQRQ?;5McQ*X�8*MUON9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V / OUQ`MNO_S K / � C � 2�FcMNO_80F�M�y=fg6�9 k � � �

MNO_80F�M`8?F�9 T QRF�9 K 2 � 4�S�;5OCONQA4�FU8*4 H%~ K S�9 ONQO_6�9�2�F�;5QR>�V?9�F�[ 9�F�25Q K M�~nS >�MNO_8 . ;I9[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 8 T [�;525O_S K 9�M�~

8?> K OP6�9 >�9�80F^9�a S 8*;52IO / Q*X�[ 9�F�25Q K 8?> K F�Q0O_8*ON25QR> 8*;0X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[ 8:4�2 >�V0M�yn<�2�>�4�9 |�9�MN9�9FH�ONQWS > K 9�F�MNO_80> K

O_6�9YVRF�QRS [ [ F�QR[ 9�FHON259�MGQ:X�k C diw(8?FH2 8 . ;I9WMUO_8?F�M�~0|�9 T S�MNOnO_6�9�FH9PX QRFH9 8*M H%s | 6 8*OnQ:X�OP6�9�Q?O_6�9�F � C �Y2 F

MNO_80F�M �

k � �?� A � 25MCO_6�9 6�Q?ONOU9�MNO�~ . FH2IV�6?ON9�MUO � C �Y2�FC[ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�yf�6�9�FH9 8?F�9zOP6 F�9�9 Q0O_6�9�F�M�>�Q*|(HR>�Q*| >+~

M_[ 8?> >�2�>�V T QRF�9CO_6 8?>�O�|�Q Q�F K 9�F�MWQ*X T 8:VR>�25O_S K 9z2�>3;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 8?> K 8 ;�8?F�V?9zFN80>�V?9CQ*X �����)8*MY|�9�;5; �O_6�934�Q�Q?;59�MNO-6 8*M;525ONON;59 T QRF�93O_6 8?> 6 8*;EXzO_6�939 ��9�4�ON25w?9�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9-Q:X k � �?� A � y]C 25O_6 M_S�4�6 8

M T 8:;I; M_8 T [�;I9?~%MNO_8:ON25MNON254�8*;=8?FHVRS T 9�>0ONM 8?F�9�Q*X^w?9�F / ;52 T 25ON9 K S�MN9?y <�ON25;5;b~+V?25w?9�>OP6�9�[ F�9�4�25MN9!H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09

Q*XWO_6�9�2�Fz[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M O_6 8*Oz8*MNON9�FHQ?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V / 4�8?> [ Q?ON9�>0ON2�8*;5; / [ F�Q*wR2 K 9?~�|�94�8?> 8?>�MN|�9�F�2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O

a S�9�MNON25QR>�M�y7Ci6 8*OW25M`O_6�9 M_[ F�9�8 K 2�> T 8*MNMC8?> K M_S FuXZ8*4�9 VRFN8�wR25O / 4�Q�FNF�9�M_[ QR> K 2�>�VAONQ�O_6�9�2�FW9�>�QRF T QRS�M

FN8?>�V09�M 2�>3;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 8?> K � � � � C�9z8*;�F�9�8 K / HR>�Q*|LO_6�9 / 9+" 6�2 . 25Oz8 O_F�9�> K ONQ*|�8?F K M_6�QRFHON9�F [ 9�F�25Q K M

|�25O_6 K 9�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�VON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9?yGC 25;I; T QRFH9�[ F�9�4�25MN9!H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09�Q:XnO_6�9�2�F [ F�Q�[ 9�F�ON259�MW9�MNOP8 . ;52IMP6AQ0O_6�9�F

O_F�9�> K MgO_6 8*O T 25VR60O�25;5;�S T 2�> 8*ON9CO_6�25M Q�>�9 �

C 25O_6�QRS�O K 9�OP8*25;I9 K Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�MnQ*X�8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*;+[ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�M�~?O_6�9 FH9�V?25QR>CQ*X+MNON9�;5;�8?F�[ 8?FN8 T 9�OU9�F M_[ 8*4�9

| 6�254�6 T S�MNO . 9MN9�8?FH476�9 K X Q�FW4�;�S�9�MCONQAO_6�9[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> T 9�476 8?>�25M T 25MC9�>�QRF T Q�S�M�y�Ci6 8*O`MPS . MN9�O`Q*X

Page 59: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

J A

T Q K 9�;5M M_8:ON25M�X / 2�>�V)OP6�9A|�9�8VH Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> 8*;�4�Q�>�MNO_FN8*2�>0ONMz|�25;5;WM_8*OU2IMHX / O_6�9 T | 6�9�> O_6�9 / 8?F�9 T QRF�9

ON25VR60ON; / 4�QR>�MNO_FU8*2�>�9 K ��f�Q�Q T 80> / K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O T Q K 9�;IMg]�O�2�>�MN2 K 9zO_6�9`6�S�V?9�9�FNF�QRF . 80F�M�Q*X^4�S FNF�9�>0O�M_[ 9�4TR

O_F�Q0MN4�QR[�254 T 9�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0ONM^Q*X ;5Q?V�Pz8?> K � ��� ONQYON9�;5; S�M�8?> / O_6�2�>�VWM_[ 9�4�2E]�4`8 . QRS�O^OP6�9G4�Q�> K 2IOU2IQ�>�MG2�>�MN2 K 9

8 MNO_8?F�OP6 8*O [ FHQ K S�4�9z[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>+y J > / FH9P] >�9 T 9�>?OYQ*XGk C d ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 8?> K 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9`OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9

F�9P] >�9�MYO_6�Q?MN9`FH9�a S�2�F�9 K 4�QR> K 25ON25QR>�M�y

o >zOP6�2IM�4�6 8?[�ON9�F�~0|�9 [ F�9�MU9�>?O�O_6�9 FH9�M_S�;5ONM�Q*X C ?nf Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M�Q*X � C �Y2�Fnw*8?F�2�8 . ;59WMNO_80F�M�y^f�6�9

>�9+"�O`MN9�4�ON25QR> V?25w?98?>3Q*w?9�F�w�259�| Q*X�ON9�4�6 >�25a S�9�MzS�MN9 K ONQQ . MU9�F�w?9[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V�k C d MNO_8?F�M�y!C�9 O_6�9�>

9+" [�;IQ�F�9CQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�MWQ*XnO_6�9�O�|GQ MNO_8?F�MYQ*X^2�>?ON9�F T 9 K 2�8*ON9�� ��� �Zk � � Y E Y ��J =VYz8?> K k � = � @ ��� EVOVO y

o\> � J y J |�9 [ F�9�MU9�>?O`8?>t2 > R K 9�[�OP6)8?> 8:; / MN25Mzk � E � =V= � = E E ~+O_6�9zMNOP8?F�OP6 8*O K 9P] >�9�M�O_6�9 � F�9 K 9 K V?9��

Q*XnO_6�9zk C d 2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNOPF�2�[+y�C 9 K Q2�> K 9�9 K ] > K 8 K K 25ON25QR> 8:;^O_F�9�> K M�~+2 T [�;5254�8*ON25QR>�MCQ*Xn| 6�254�638?F�9

. F�259 ��/ QRS�ON;52�>�9 K 2�>3O_6�9�; 8:MNOWMN9�4�ON25QR>�Q*XnO_6�25MW4�6 8?[�ON9�F�y�o\>3e�6 8?[�ON9�F�A ~+|�9�S�MU9�OP6�9�MN9CO_F�9�> K MWONQ6�9�;�[

8?>�MN|�9�F�MUQ T 9WQ*X=OP6�9`a S�9�MNON25QR>�M�|�9`6 8�w?9`FN8*25MN9 K y

� � � � ���I���&()� � � �I%��&�$(��"#'� �

fg6�9 Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>�M K 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 K 2�> O_6�9`>�9+"RO�O�|�QCMN9�4�ON25QR>�M�|�9�F�9WV?9�>�9�FN8*;5; / S > K 9�F�O_8VH*9�>S�MU2 >�V 6�2IV�6 R

M_[ 9�9 K [ 6�Q?ONQ�9�;59�4�O_F�254 [ 6�Q0ONQ T 9�ON9�FHM�~*| 6�25476 F�9�4�QRF K [ 6�Q?ONQ�> R\4�QRS >?OnFU8*ON9�M^8*O^9�a S 8:; ON2 T 9�2�>?OU9�F�w(8*;5M �bS�M_S R

8*;5; / 8?F�QRS > K OU9�> MN9�4�QR> K M QRF�MNQ)[ 9�F 2 >0ON9�VRFU8*ON25QR> y <�9�w?9�FN8:; K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O [ 6�Q0ONQ T 9�ON9�FHM�|�9�F�9AS�MU9 K ONQ

Q . O_8:2 >tO_6�9 K 8*O_880> 8*; / ��9 K X Q�FYO_6�25M`2�>?w09�MNON25VR8*ON25QR>+~ O_6�9 T Q0MNO . 8*MN254 K 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�98 T Q�>�VO_6�9 T . 9�2 >�V

O_6�9>RS TC. 9�FWQ*X�MN2 T S�;5O_8?>�9�QRS�M K 8*O_8x476 80> >�9�;IM 9�8*476 F�9�4�QRF K M�y�<�2 >�V0;I94�6 8?> >�9�;�2�>�MNO_FNS T 9�>?ONMCF�9�a S�2 FH9

X\F�9�a S�9�>0OC2�>?ON9�FUFNS [�ON25QR>�Mz2�> O_6�9O_80F�V?9�O`MUO_8?F�B M�;52IV�6?ON4�S FHw?9ONQ T 9�8*M_S F�9O_6�9 ��4�6 8?>�V?2�>�V . 8*4+H?V�F�QRS > K

M H /z. F�25VR6?OP>�9�MNMcX QRF 4�8:;I2 . FN8:ON25QR> [ S FU[ Q?MN9�M�y � S�2 K 2�>�V T S�MNO . 9W[ 9�FuX QRF T 9 K |g2IOP6z8WM T 8*;5; e�e�d 4�8 T 9�FN8

QRFCQ0O_6�9�F K 9�w�2I4�939+"�ON9�FN> 8*;gONQ�O_6�9A[ 6�Q?OUQ T 9�ON9�FCOUQ)8�w?Q?2 K XZS FHO_6�9�FC2�>?OU9�FNFNS [�ON25QR>�M 2�>lOP6�9;I25VR60ON4�S F�w09

8?> K H*9�9�[O_6�9�MNO_8?FGXZF�Q T K F�2EX OU2 >�VQ�S�O�Q*XnO_6�9C8?[ 9�F�OPS F�9 K S F�2�>�V O_6�9�>�25VR60O�y5C 25O_6A8 MN9�4�QR> K 476 80> >�9�; ~

VRS�2 K 2�>�V3O_8VH*9�MW[�;�8*4�9z2�>?OU9�FN> 8*;^ONQ O_6�9z[ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�ON9�F�~+O_6�QRS�V�6AMTH / 4�8*;52 . FU8*ON25QR>3MNOU2I;5;�F�9�a S�2�F�9�MWOP6 8*OWO_6�9

O_8?FHV?9�On4�6 8?> >�9�; . 9W2 >0ON9�FNFUS [�ON9 K QR4�4�8:MN25QR> 8*;5; / y�f�6 F�9�9TR\4�6 8?> >�9�;=[ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�ON9�F�M K 9�w?Q?OU9 8?> 9�>0ON2�F�9W4�6 8?> R

>�9�;^ONQ 4�QR>0ON2�>RS�QRS�M T QR>�25ONQRF�2�>�VQ*X�8 �_. ;�8?> H �A[ 8*ON4�6�Q*XnM H / ~�8?> K O_6�9CO_8?F�V09�O�476 80> >�9�;n>�9�9 K QR>�; /-. 9

2�>?OU9�FNFNS [�ON9 K X QRFcQR>�9�QRFcO�|GQ . F�259PXnM H /T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?ONMYS�MN9 K XbQRF�4�F�Q0MNM9R\4�6 8?> >�9�;�4�8*;52 . FN8*ON25QR>+y

fg6�9 MNOP8?F�O`OU2 T 9zXbQRF�9�8*4�6)>�25VR60ON; /)K 8:O_8AFNS > 25MzMN9�O �_.0/ 9 / 9��3ONQ34�QRQRF K 2 > 8:ON9 K }Y>�25w?9�F�M_8:; f 2 T 9

Page 60: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

J O

�b}Yf�e ~*|g2IOP6 8�[ F�9�4�25MN25QR> Q*X=8 . Q�S�O E y � M�~ S�MN2�>�VCO_6�9�2�> K 25wR2 K S 8*; Q . MN9�F�w*8*ONQRF / B M^M / >�4�F�Q�>�2 ��9 K 4�;5Q�4 H QRF

8�C C � FN8 K 25Q�y+*Af�6�9�FH9�8�X OU9�F�O_6�9`;59�>�V?OP6Q*Xn9�w?9�F / 2 >0ON9�VRFU8*ON25QR> 25MW4�QR>0O_F�Q?;5;59 K-.0/ 8?>Q0MN4�25;I;�8*OUQRF . S�25;IO

2�>?OUQzO_6�9`[ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�ON9�F�9�;59�4�O_F�Q�>�2I4�M�~ 8*4�4�S FU8*ON9`8*O�OP6�9 �FEVE �+M ;59�w?9�; � Q(w09�FnQ�>�9�6�QRS F y

d`S FH2 >�V K 8*OP8-FH9 K S�4�ON25QR>+~nOP6�9AFNS >�MUO_8?F�OCON2 T 925MCO_FN8?>�MHX QRF T 9 K OUQ-OP6�9 . 8?F / 4�9�>0ON9�FCQ*XYO_6�9 MUQ?;�8?F

M / MNON9 T ~ ONQ�8*4�4�Q�S >?O�XbQRFWO_6�9 4�6 8?>�V?2�>�V�;525VR6?O R\O_FN8�w?9�;nOU2 T 9 K S�9ONQAO_6�9 T Q?OU2IQ�>�Q*XYO_6�9-?c8?F�O_6 2�> 25ONM

QRF . 25O�y < S . MN9�a S�9�>0O-F�9 K S�4�ON25QR> F�9 T Q(w09�M . 8 K K 8*OP8)[ Q?2�>?ONM�~�M_S . O_FU8*4�ONM O_6�93M H /l. 8:4 H0VRF�QRS > K ~Y8?> K

4�QRFNFH9�4�ONM �bF�QRS�VR6�; / XbQRF�8*O T Q0M_[ 6�9�F�254 9+"�ON2�>�4�ON25QR>+y�o\> MNQ T 9Y4�8*MN9�M�~ 8�;5Q*| QRF K 9�F�[ Q?; / >�Q T 2�8*;+25M�]�O�8?> K

F�9 T Q*w?9 K ONQ`8:2 K O_6�9�M_[�;5254�2�>�VzONQ?V?9�OP6�9�F Q*X 4�QR>�MU9�4�S�ON25w?9 K 8:O_8WFNS >�M^Q . O_8:2 >�9 K X\F�Q TLK 2 ��9�F�9�>?O^Q . MN9�F�w�2 >�V

MN25ON9�M�yWf�6�9zF�9�MPS�;IOU2 >�V�;52IV�6?ON4�S FHw?9C2IM K 25w�2 K 9 K .0/ 25ONM T 9�80>4�QRS >0O`FN8*ON9?~+8?> K S >�2IO / 2IM�M_S . O_FN8:4�ON9 K Q �ny

C�9z8?F�9C;59PXbO`|�25O_638F�9�4�QRF K Q:XnX\FN8*4�ON25QR> 8*; w(80F�2�8*ON25QR>�M�8�|�8 / X\F�Q T OP6�9 8�w?9�FU8*V?9�80[ [ 8?F�9�>0O . F�25VR6?OP>�9�MNM

Q*X^O_6�9WMNO_80F�~�| 6�25476�6 8*M . 9�9�>�>�QRF T 8:;I2 ��9 K ONQ���9�F�Q T 9�8?>+y

fg6�9�Q . MN9�F�w�2 >�V38?> K�K 8*OP8 F�9 K S�4�OU2IQ�>�ON9�4�6 >�25a S�9�M�|�9 6 8�w?9YrHS�MNO K 9�MU4�F�2 . 9 K O_F�9�8*OY;5QR>�VAON9�F T M H /

. F�25VR60O_>�9�MNM`8?> K 9+"RON2�>�4�ON25QR>tw(8?F�2�8*OU2IQ�>�M`QR>�; / 80[ [ F�Q "R2 T 8*OU9�; / y�j�Q�FW[ 9�F�25Q K M`2�>39+"�4�9�MNM`Q*XG80>-6�Q�S FYQRF

MNQ�~�O_6�25M�8?> 8:; / MN25M`4�80>�[ F�Q K S�4�9 S > F�9�;52�8 . ;59-F�9�M_S�;5ONM�y J MU9�4�QR> K ~ T Q�F�9CMN9�F�25QRS�Mz[ F�Q . ;59 T 80F�25MN9�MWX\F�Q T

O_6�9 K 8:2I; / VR8?[�M�O_6 8*OW8*;5|�8 / MWQ�4�4�S FW2�>�MU2 >�V0;I9 MN25ON9 K 8:O_8 ��MN2�>�4�9 >�QON9�;59�MN4�Q�[ 9?~^9+"�4�9�[�O`QR>�9z>�9�8?F QR>�9

Q*X�O_6�9!?n8?F�OP6+B M [ Q0;I9�M�~�4�8?>3Q . MN9�F�w?9C8?>�Q . r�9�4�OW4�QR>?OU2 >�S�QRS�MN; / XbQRF T QRF�9CO_6 8?>�8 O_6�2�F K ONQ6 8*;EXGQ*X�O_6�9

ON2 T 9 y^f�6�9�MU9WVR8?[�Mn4�FH9�8*ON9 8*;52�8*MN9�Mg2 > O_6�9Yj�QRS FH2I9�FcO_FU8?>�M�XbQRF T Q:X�|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F X=8?> K k C di;525VR60ON4�S F�w?9�M

| 6�254�64�8?> 4�QR>0XbQRS > K QRS F�8*ONOU9 T [�ONM�ONQ K 9�4�2�[ 6�9�FYO_6�9 T y

fg6�9WMNQ?;�S�ON25QR>�ONQzO_6�25MW[ F�Q . ;59 T 2IMYONQzQ . MN9�F�w?9�|�25O_6A8 T S�;5ON2>R\MN25ON9CON9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9z>�9�Ou|�QRF HzM_S�4�6A8:M�O_6�9

Ci6�Q?;59�?c8?F�O_6f�9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9�� C ?cfW~ �Y8*O_6�9�F�9�O 8:; y ���?� E ynf�6�9 C ?cf 4�8?>A8:476�259�w?9C>�9�8?F�; / 4�QR>0ON2�>�S�QRS�M

;525VR6?OU4�S F�w?9�McX Q�F^|�9�9FH?M�8*On8WOU2 T 9 S�MN2�>�VCON9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9�M�8*OnMN9�w09�FN8*;�;5QR>�V02IOPS K 9�MGOUQWXbQ?;5;IQ*| 8WMN2�>�V?;59WMNO_80F�y J M

O_6�9YQ . r�9�4�OGS > K 9�FcMNO_S K / MN9�OUM � QRF O_6�9W< S > F�25MN9�M 8:OnQR>�9�MU2IOU9?~ROP6�9 >�9+"�OnMN25ON9Y2�> O_6�9 >�9�O�|�QRFIH�O_8VH:9�MnS [

O_6�9�|�8*OU476+~?8?> K MNQ`QR> 8?F�QRS > K OP6�9�V?;5Q . 9?ycf�6�9GC ?nf 6 8*MnF�9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>�2 ��9 K O_6�9gMNO_S K / Q*X�M_6�QRF�O Ru[ 9�F�25Q K

w(80F�2�8 . ;59zMNO_8?FHM�y J ;I;^Q:XGO_6�9z>�9�| 80> 8*; / MN9�MWQ:X [ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�V3k C dWM [ FH9�MN9�>?OU9 K 2�>3O_6�25MWO_6�9�MN25M�80F�9 . 8*MN9 K

QR>7C ?nf Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M�y

�gQ*| O_6 8*O^|�9�H�>�Q*| MNQ T 9�O_6�2�>�V�Q*X�O_6�9�O_6�9�QRF / Q*X�[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�VCMNO_8?F�M�~?8?> K |�9 S > K 9�F�MNOP8?> K 6�Q*|lO_6�9 /

8?F�9WQ . MN9�F�w?9 K ~ |�9W4�8?> MP6�2�XbOYQRS F�8*ONON9�>0ON25QR> ONQzOP6�9WQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M�O_6�9 T MN9�;5w?9�M�y,��+B 1)/3@3/�BD6�C�/ 2K1)<38 � F � @ �TA�@ �D< >=2��/"@3A E /�S BD6.A&;�<./�8=2KB=U 1.;DBM<.6.2K1)6R6?STE / <�@ 2KB � / @32� S���1)2 6./3U/ �T/3@36?1)AKBDST@32���TC B=A59 2�6

<.A�E /"<?ST6./3<3V

Page 61: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

J Y

� ��� ������� � � � !$(��I��� � � � (�� � ���:���

� � Z6� ' ��1 K ' Z ' � � ���

k � = � @ ��� EVO O �b8 y>H�y�8 y=o\h k 9�V�~^6�9�F�9�8�XbON9�FCk � = � @ �� |�8*MCO_6�9 O_6�2�F K � C � 2�FCMUO_8?FWOUQ . 9O_6�9

O_8?FHV?9�OWQ*X 8�C ?nf 4�8 T [ 8*25VR>+~^8�XbON9�F�k � �?� A � 8?> K k � � Y E Y y � J X OU9�FWO_6�9 2�>�2IOU2 8:; K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F / Q*X�25ONM

w(80F�2�8 . 25;I25O /i.?/ DcQR> K 9�O8*;by � ���?� J ~�2IO |�8*Mz;525ONON;593Q . MN9�F�w09 K ~�[ 8?F�ON; /l. 4�80S�MN9A25O 2IMF�9�;�8*ON25w?9�; / XZ8*2�>0O

��� � �FO BO��� � � � �GE @ J � DcQR> K 9�O 8*;by ���?� J y J ;5MNQ�~%;52 H:9 k � � Y E Y ~ h�� � = �?� Y ~�8?> K k � E � =V= ~

25OM_6�Q*|�9 K w09�F / X 9�| T Q K 9�MA[ F�25QRF OUQ C ?nf 80> 8*; / MN25M�y � FHQRS > K . 8*MU9 K QR[�ON254�8*;YM_[ 9�4�OPFN8 2�>�2IOU2 8:;I; /

2�> K 254�8*ON9 K 25O 6 8 K 8?> 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S F�9Q:X �VE � EVEVE � � E� EVE E { 80> K ;5Q?V P Q*X%Y A � E��

� C�9�FU>�9�F ���0� A yc13QRF�9`F�9�4�9�>0O }�� M_[ 9�4�O_FN8 O_8VH*9�>x|�25O_6O_6�9Cm < fL6 8*MY;59 K OUQ 8 F�9�w�2IMU9 K 9�MNON2 T 8:ON9`Q*X

� ��� � � A � EVE E � �FE�TEVEVE ��d`F�9�2 ��;59�F ���0�?� y

@W>�9CO_6�2�>�V O_6 8*OYMN9�ONMWk � = � @ � 80[ 8?F�OgXZF�Q T Q?O_6�9�F � C �Y2 FYMUO_8?F�M�25M`8 F�9 K 9+"�4�9�MNMW2�>�25ONM Q�[�ON254�8*;

M_[ 9�4�O_FNS T O_6 8*Oz4�Q T 9�MzX\F�Q T 8 T 8*2�> MN9�a S�9�>�4�934�Q T [ 8?>�25QR> 8 . Q�S�O E yB@�80F�4�MN9�4�QR> K M8�| 8 / y J O 8?>

8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9 K 25MNO_8?>�4�9 Q*X J Y E [ 4?~ O_6�25M`MN9�[ 8?FU8*ON25QR>34�QRFUF�9�M_[ Q�> K M`ONQA8 T 2�>�2 T S T QRF . 25O_8:;nFN8 K 2�S�M`Q*X

8 . QRS�O �+J E J }`ycf�6RS�M�~�O_6�9�F�9A25M ;52IOUON;59-4�6 8?>�4�9xX QRF 2 >0ON9�FN8:4�ON25QR> |�25O_6�2�> O_6�25M . 2 > 80F / M / MNON9 T y f�6�9

F�9 K 4�Q T [ 8?>�25QR> 25M K 9�ON9�4�ON9 K .0/ O_6�9�C ?nf B M . ; S�9TR\MU9�>�MN25ON25w?9)[ 6�Q?ONQ0O_S . 9�M QR>�; / 8:M 83MN;525VR60O F�25MN9�2�>

. 8*4+H?V�F�QRS > K 4�QRS >0ONM�y

j%QRFWOP6�9 <�9�[�ON9 TC. 9�F�~ ���?� = ~6C ?nf FNS >+~^>�2�>�9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0OCON9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9�M Q . O_8*2�>�9 K 8AOUQ?O_8*;^Q*X Y E ~BAVA =

A R\MN9�4�Q�> K 2�>?OU9�VRFN8*ON25QR>�MgQ(w09�F�>�2�>�9 K 8 / M�ynf�6�9WQ*w?9�FU8*;5; K S�O / 4 / 4�;59 K S FH2 >�V O_6 8*OgON2 T 9`|�8*M J A � y^d`8*O_8

F�9 K S�4�ON25QR>-X Q?;5;5Q*|�9 K O_6�9z[ F�Q�4�9 K S F�9zQRS�ON;52�>�9 K 2 > e�6 8?[�ON9�F =8?> K K 2IMU4�S�MNMN9 K 2�> K 9�O_8*25; .?/ � 8:O_6�9�FY9�O

8*;by � ���?� E y3f�6�9AF�9 K S�4�9 K K 8*O_83F�9�[ FH9�MN9�>?OCO_6�9 X\FN8*4�OU2IQ�> 8*; K 9�[ 8?FHO_S F�9Q*X OP6�9 4�QRS >0OzFN8*ON9 X\F�Q T O_6�9

T 9�8?>+~�|�25O_6)FUS >�M`X\F�Q T 9�w?9�F / MU2IOU94�Q TC. 2 >�9 K 2�>0ONQ�8MN2�>�V?;59�;I25VR60OC4�S F�w?9?y�f�6�9 j�Q�S F�259�F`OPFN8?>�M�XbQRF T

��jnf Q*X O_6�25M�X\S�;5; K 8*O_8�MN9�O�~ K 9�[�2I4�OU9 K 2�>j^25VRS F�9 J y � ~�M_6�Q*|�M�O_6�9 �_T Q K S�;�8*ON25QR>�8 T [�;525O_S K 9���� 2 >S >�25ONM

Q*X TzT 8 � T 8�� �FE EVE ~+| 6�9�F�9 T 8 � �� ��� Q*X�w(8?F�2�8*OU2IQ�>�M`2�>�OP6�9 K 9�ON9�4�ON9 K 2�>?ON9�>�MU2IO / ��8*O�8 V02Iw09�>

X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / y�j^25VRS F�9 J yB= M_6�Q*|�M�~+Q�>AOP6�9�MP8 T 9WX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MN4�8*;59?~�O_6�9C|�2�> K Q*|LX\S >�4�ON25QR>�XbQRF�OP6�2IM K 8*O_8

MN9�O�yYf�6�9C|�2�> K Q*| F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONMYO_6�9`jnf Q*XG8 MN2�>�V?;59 >�Q?25MN9TRbX\F�9�9CMN2�>RS�MNQ02 K M_8 T [�;59 K 8*OYO_6�9CM_8 T 9�ON2 T 9�M

O_6 8*O�O_6�9 K 8*O_8�|�9�F�9YM_8 T [�;59 K y�f�6�9Y4�9�>?O_FU8*;�[ 9�8VH 2�> O_6�25M [�;5Q?O�4�QRFNFH9�M_[ QR> K M�ONQCO_6�9YX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / Q:X=O_6�9� R>=/"2KB=2 �TC�<?ST<&AK4 6?>=/"F�� � ��� �&H 1.;�B 8�<?;=E E 2K1.S�� /3U S B 6?>�ST<0<./3@36?STA5B'8�9R2 <RN�;!� � ST<?>=/3U��DC % 259R2 �T/�158 � � 1.ST/�B /36

2 �7VDS B 6?>�/ � /�N=6./3E ��/�1 � 8 �(� � �8�ST<.<?;=/$A54��� ��� ���� � �� �� ��������� ������ ���� V

Page 62: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

JR�

2000 2500 3000

0

5

10

15

j^25VRS FH9 J y � j%QRS F�259�F�O_FN80>�M�X Q�F T Q*X�OP6�9`k � = � @ � C ?nf K 8*O_8CMU9�O�y

MN2�>�S�MNQ?2 K � 8*;5;^Q?O_6�9�FW8*;52�8*M�[ 9�8VH0MWQR>�9�2IOP6�9�FWMN2 K 9 8?FH9 T Q K S�;�8*ON25QR>�M�4�8?S�MN9 K�.0/ OP6�9�V�8?[�M 2�>3OP6�9 K 8*O_8

MN9�O�y^f�6�9�MU9`8*;52 8:MN9�M�|�25;5;�8���9�4�OG9�w09�F / O_FNS�9YMNON9�;5;�8?Fcw(80F�2�8*ON25QR> XbQRS > K 2�> O_6�9Yjnf Q*X�O_6�9 C ?nf K 8*O_8�MN9�O�y

}gMN2�>�V 8z>�Q�>�;I2�>�9�8?FY;59�8*MUO9R\MNa S 8?F�9�M [ F�Q�4�9 K S F�9 � K 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 K 2�>@CB�D�F�259�>�9�O 8*;by ���0�VO ~0|G9Y]�OUON9 K O_6�9

ON2 T 9TR\MN9�FH2I9�M K 8*OP8ONQ�Q . O_8*2�>3O_6�9 X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / ~^8 T [�;I25O_S K 9?~c8?> K [ 6 8:MN9 Q:XGO_6�9>�2�>�9 K Q T 2 > 80>?O T Q K 9�M

MN9�9�> 2�> O_6�9 jnfWy J XbON9�F�M_S . O_FN8*4�OU2 >�V MN2�>RS�MNQ02 K M |�25O_6 O_6�9�MN9[ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F�M�XZFHQ T O_6�9 ;525VR6?O 4�S F�w?9?~^|�9

F�9�4�Q T [ S�ON9 K O_6�9�jnf ONQWMN9�9Y| 6 8*O^|�8*M^;59PXbO�ynf�6�25M � [ F�9�| 6�25ON9�>�2�>�V �z[ F�Q�4�9�MNM�| 8:M^O_6�9�>zF�9�[ 9�8*ON9 K ~�|�25O_6

8?> 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9 K >RS TC. 9�F�Q*XW[ 9�8VH0Mz2�>�4�;�S K 9 K 2�> 9�8*4�6 M_S�4�4�9�MNMN25w?9�;I9�8:MNO9R\MNa S 8?F�9�M�]�O�y�o > O_6�25Mz|�8 / ~ |�9

XbQRS > K = E 2�> K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>?OW[ 9�F�25Q K 254�2IOU2I9�M�y J MG2�> K 254�8*ON9 K 2�>f=8 . ;59 J y � ~0O_6�9�F�9Y25M�QR>�9W[ 9�8VH O_6 8*Oc2IM�8*; T Q0MNO

F�9�MNQ0;Iw09 K 2 >0ONQzO�|�Q��b8*O5= � AV@ ��m � � 25O�M_6�Q*|�M . F�QR8 K 9�>�9 K ;52 >�9�M_6 8?[ 9�M�2�>O_6�9WON9 T [ QRFN8:; MP[ 9�4�O_FN8 ynf�6�9

=VA E @ ��m �C[ 9�8VH 6 8*M�O_6 F�9�9W4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONM�2�>O_6�9W4�Q T�. 2�>�9 KK 8*OP8`MU9�O � |G9W4�Q�S�; K FH9�MNQ?;5w?9WO�|�Q`Q*X=OP6�9 T ~

. S�O�O_6�9�;5Q(|�9�F�X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / 4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0O�|�8*M >�Q0O F�9�MNQ?;5w?9 K ycf�|�Q 8 K K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;=4�;5Q?MU9�; / MP[ 8*4�9 K [ 8*2�F�MY8?F�9

Page 63: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

JR�

2000 2500 3000

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

j^25VRS FH9 J yB= C 2�> K Q*| XZS >�4�OU2IQ�>XbQRFcO_6�9`k � = � @ � C ?cf K 8*O_8�MN9�O�y

[ F�9�MN9�>0O�2�>Af 8 . ;59 J y � O_6 8*O�|�9�F�9`F�9�MUQ?;5w?9 K 2�>OP6�2IMY8?> 8*; / MU2IM�y

C 25O_6 O_6�9`6�Q�[ 9�80> K 9+" [ 9�4�O_8*ON25QR>xO_6 8*O�|�9W|GQ�S�; K MU9�9`O_6�9WMN25VR> 8:O_S F�9WQ*XnF�Q?O_8:ON25QR> 8*;�MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V%~�|�9

MN9�8?FH476�9 K O_6�9zjnf XbQRFY9�a S 8:; XZF�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[ 8*4�2�>�V�yCj^25w?9z[ 8*2�F�M`Q*XG[ 9�8VH0M�8?F�9CM_[�;525O .0/ 80[ [ F�Q "R2 T 8*OU9�; /

A J ��m �?y f�6 F�9�9�M_6�Q*|�9 K 6�2�>?OUMQ*X�8)[ 9�8VHl8:; T Q?MNO 9+" 8*4�OU; / 2�> OP6�9 T 2 K K ;59?~YM_S�V?V?9�MNOU2 >�V OP6�9 / 8?F�9

O_F�2�[�;59�ONM|�25O_6 M_[ 8*4�2�>�V Q*X%=VY ��m �?y }Y[ Q�>l[ F�9TR\| 6�25ON9�>�2�>�V�~W8*;5;g]�w?9-[ 8:2 FHM M_6�Q*| MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0OA[ 9�8VH0M

|�25O_6�2�> � yBA ��m �3Q*XWO_6�9 T 2 K [ Q?2�>?O2�> XZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / yif�6�9�MU9]�w?9O_FH2 [�;59�ONMMP6�Q(| 8 T 9�8?> M_[�;525ONON2�>�V Q*X

=VY J � �� = ��m �?yno X�OP6�9�MN9WO_F�2�[�;59�ONMW8?F�9WF�Q?O_8*OU2IQ�> 8*;5; / M_[�;525O � � � T Q K 9�M�~ OP6�9�> XZF�Q T ?�a S 8:ON25QR> � = y �

O_6�9`F�Q0O_8*ON25QR>[ 9�F�25Q K Q*X�k � = � @ � 2IM�A BE Y � E =V=C6 F�y

mY8�wR2�>�V2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K O_6�9C4�9�>0O_FN8*; � � � E X\F�9�a S�9�>�4�259�M`XbQRFgO_6�9�MN9�]�w?9CO_F�2�[�;59�ONM�~�|�9�MU9�9�OP6 8*O OP6�9�2 F

[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V?M�8?F�9 J = y � = ~ ��� y OVO ~ =V= y J @ ~?8?> K =V@ y � =�M�y J MNM_S T 2 >�VCO_6 8:O^O_6�9�F�9�25MG8 T Q K 9�M_S [ [ F�9�MNMU9 K

. 9�O�|�9�9�>�O_6�9!@ J�� 8?> K @ � J M T Q K 9�M�~+O_6�9 T 9�8?>3[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V�25M%= � yBY O M�y J T QRF�9zF�25V?QRF�Q�S�M |�8 /

Page 64: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

A E

f=8 . ;59 J y � k 9�F�25Q K 254�2IOU2I9�M�Q*X�k � = � @ ��� EVOVO X\F�Q T C ?nf d`8*OP8

j FH9�a S�9�>�4 / k 9�F�25Q K JWT [�;525O_S K 9 f ���� 4�Q TzT 9�>0ONM �� ��m � � M � TzT 8 ��M �

= � AV@ y>=VA � E = A @V@ � y O �FE � EBE = � � y J = � E J�� O?� � @VY R � �C� yB= ��m �`M_[�;525O= � = � y OVO � E @ � @ J�� y J AV@ � EBE @ O � y>=VY � E J�� � Y � � J�� E= �VEVE y �?� � E�� Y @ JVJ yBY �?� � EBE = E = y>=V@ � E J�� = O J � =V@ � p�< �

= O = � y JVJ � EBE O @ �VE yB@ E?� � EBE E?� O y>@ J � E J�� =V= � � � R � p�< �

= OVE = y>@ J � E�� J @ � J yB= O?� � EBE = � = y O?� � E J�� = O � =V= E s=VAVYVA y>AVA � EBE J @ �?� yB= OVO � EBE EVO �0� y E � � E JR� � Y � A � p�< �

=VA E @ y>A E � E�� A @ �?� y J J�� � EBE = J = y � @ � E J�� @ J A � =V= R � s=VA EVE y O @ � E���� @ �?� y �0�?� � EBE =VY = y>= J � E J�� @ Y � � = �= J YVA y O Y � E = A J E @ y � @ E � EBE J�� � y O = � E J�� @ �VO � @ � E s= JVJ Y y � Y � EBE J J E?� y O @VA � EBE E Y � y>YV@ � E J�� J E J � O � p�< �

=V@VYV@ y>A O � E�� @ J = � yB@ E Y � EBE =V@ @ y � � � E A E @ � = � =V= R � s p�< �

=V@VYV= y ��� � E�� J J = � yBA AV@ � EBE = J @ y>@ � � E A E = �?� � =VA p�< �

=V@ J A y J A � E = � J = O yB@ A � � EBE @ � � y �VE � E J�� ���?� � @ J E s=V@ ��� y � A � E�� E J @ � yB= JR� � EBE ��� J y E A � E J�� �0�FE � �FO � p�< �

=V= JR� y>= J � E�� O JVJVJ yBA � A � EBE @V= = y O?� � E J�� @ �?� � = � R � s p�< �

=V= J Y y>A O � E = O JVJVJ y � =VY � EBE A � � y>Y � � E J�� @ � � J O=V=V= E y �VO � E = � J A E yB= Y O � EBE AVY � y J = � E J�� J%��� � JR� E= ��� = y>@ � � E���� J A O y � @ � � EBE @VA = y>= � � E J�� @ � = � @ � �

= �FO = y O?� � E��0� J O = yB@ �VE � EBE = J @ y>Y E � E J�� @ Y � � ��� R � p�< �

���VO?� y � Y � E���� A E Y y � EVO � EBE JR� = y E = � E J�� @ �VO � @ � R � s� f�2 T 9`Q*X ] F�MNO T 8 "R2 T S T 8�XbON9�F�D � ?�d = JVJR�?�0�VO y � J J YV=� � p�< � � ;�8 . 9�;5M O_6�9 � [ 9�8 H?M�2�> ] F�MNO�;59�8*MNO R\MNa S 80F�9�M�]�O�ONQ QRF�25V?2�> 8*; K 8*OP8

Page 65: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

A �

ONQ K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9`O_6�25M�MP[ 8*4�2�>�V 25MYONQC]�O�O_6�9 T 9�8*M_S F�9 K w*8*;�S�9�MWQ*X � � ONQ 8C;52 >�9�80F�9�a S 8*ON25QR>xQ*X=O_6�9 X QRF T

��� � � � � � � � � �� � � � � J y �

| 6�9�F�9 �� 80> K ��� � 8?F�9CF�9�;�8*ON9 K 2�>�8?>Q . w�25QRS�MW|�8 / ONQ�� � 8?> K � XZFHQ T ?^a S 8*ON25QR> � = yB= y J ;I2�>�9�8?F

;59�8*MNO9R\MUa S 8?FH9�M�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�Q*X^O_6�25M O / [ 9 / 2I9�; K M`8�w(8:; S�9CQ*X �� � = �� A � � E @VY�M�y

� 25w?9�> O_6�9�O�|GQ T 9�8*M_S F�9 K a S 80>?ON25ON259�M �� � XZF�Q T O_6�9-[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> K 8*O_8 80> K ����� �"XZFHQ T M_[ 9�4TR

O_F�Q0MN4�QR[ / MNON9�;5;�8?F T Q K 9�;5M�4�8?> . 9`S�MU9 K ONQz[�; 8:4�9W;I2 T 25ONMYQR> O_6�9 T 8*MUM 80> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / Q*X�8C[ S�;5M_8*OU2 >�V

k C d MNO_8?F�y�j�QRF k C dWM |�25O_6z8gV?25w?9�> T 8:MNM�~�O_6�9�[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V`2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9�Mn|�25O_6 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN2�>�V`9 ��9�4�ON25w?9

ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9?yAo\> 8 K K 25ON25QR>+~ XbQRF T Q K 9�;5MC|�25O_6 8V?25w?9�> 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9 OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9?~^[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V32�> R

4�F�9�8*MU9�MG|g2IOP6 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN2�>�V T 8*MNM�y^f�6�S�McX QRFck � = � @ � ONQ T 8*2�>?O_8:2 > 8`[ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�V 8*; T Q?MNOc2 K 9�>?ON254�8*;

ONQWO_6 8:OnQ*X�k � �?� A � 7 |Y6�2I4�6C25M^X\8?F^6�Q?OUON9�F^O_6 80>�k � = � @ � 8*O �+JSE ~ EVEVE { 7 25O T S�MUO . 9 T QRF�9 T 8*MUMN25w?9?y

D�8*MN9 K QR>MNOU9�;I;�8?F T Q K 9�;5M�~ �� �]= �� A � MY2 T [�;5259�M�8 T 8:MNM�XbQRF�k � = � @ � Q*X E>O � � EBE = � � y�f�6�9

;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 4�QRFNF�9�MP[ QR> K 2�>�V ONQCO_6�25M T 8:MNM�FN8?>�V?9Y25M �FE � A � � y �j^2�> 8*;5; / ~�2EX^O_6�9WO_F�2�[�;59�O T Q K 9�MY8?F�9

F�9�8*;5; / � � � |�25O_6xMNQ T 9�4�Q T [ QR>�9�>?OUM �_T 2IMUMN2�>�V �O_6�9�>OP6�9�= � y>A � MW[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V 2 T [�;I259�Mz8 T 8*MNM

. 9�;5Q*| E J � � 7 . 9�;5Q*|iO_6�9 T 2�>�2 T S T T 8:MNMGF�9�a S�2�F�9 K ONQ T 8VH*9 8�e��?@ 4�QRF�9�|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F X�MNOP8?F�y=fg6�2IM

M_S [ [ QRF�ONM�Q�S F�2 K 9�>?ON2E]�4�8*OU2IQ�>AQ:X�O_6�9WOPF�2�[�;I9�O T Q K 9�M 8:M ��� � y

� � Z6� K ��1\'�� � � � � K��

k � � Y E Y ��J = Y �b6�9�F�9�8(X ON9�F�k � � Y E Y |�8*McO_6�9WO_8?FHV?9�OnQ*X O_6�9 MU2 "�O_6�C ?nf FNS >+~�| 6�25476 OUQRQ H [�; 8:4�9

X\F�Q T 1�8?F�4�6 � =zONQ7= J ~ ���?� � y�Dc9�4�8?S�MU9�Q:X�25ONM K 9�4�;52�> 8*ON25QR> � ��J E � ~�Q�>�; / >�QRF�O_6�9�FU>MN25ON9�MW|�9�F�9CS�MN9 K y

@gXGOP6�9W]�w?9CON9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9�M�~�OP6 F�9�9 7 O_6�9C134�dWQR> 8*; K = y � T ~+OP6�9�@ y O T e�jnm fL8*OY1�8?S > 8 {Y9�8 ~�8?> K p�8

k^8*; T 8 B M%= yBA T o � f 7 [ F�Q*wR2 K 9 K O_6�9 . S�; H3Q:XGO_6�9 K 8:O_8 y o >3M_S [ [ QRF�O`Q:X OP6�9 FNS >+~�OP6 F�9�9 8 K K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;

>�25VR60ONMnQ*X�Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>zONQ�Q HC[�;�8*4�9WS�MN2�>�V�OP6�9�13O�y?Dc2IV09�;IQ*| � yBA T O_6 FH9�9 T QR>0O_6�Mn;�8*OU9�F�~?2�> � S >�9 ���?� � y

p+2 H*9Ak � = � @ � ~=k � � Y E Y 25M FH9�; 8:ON25w?9�; / X\8*2�>?O���� � �FO Y � � � � � �GE BO � 6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~ 25O�|�8*M�O_6�9

M_S . r�9�4�OnQ:X�8?>C2�>0ON9�>�MN9 ��MN2�>�V?;59WMN25ON9 Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> 8*;+[ F�Q?VRFU8 T 2�> O_6�9�;�8*ON9 ���?�VE M^O_6 8*O^X\8*25;59 K ONQ�FH9�MNQ?;5w?9

25ONMzS > K 9�F�; / 2�>�V [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ 8*OUON9�FN> � � FN8?S�9�F�~ � F�9�9�> � p+259 . 9�FHO ���?� = yj�Q0;I;5Q*|�2�>�V�O_6�97C ?nf FNS >+~

j�Q�>?O_8:2 >�99�O8*;by � ���?� �� [ S . ;525M_6�9 K 8?> 8?> 8:; / MN25M Q*X 25ONM ON9 T [ QRFN8*;�M_[ 9�4�O_FNS T . 8*MN9 K QR> O_6�9-e jnm f� R>=/3<./ 2K1)/ B=A�6"6?>=/ <.2 E / �52 � ;=/3<$ND; � � ST<?>�/ U S B % 259R2 �T/�158 /36$2�7V ���(� � "�V ��;D1"B�;�E ��/�1)< 2K1)/ �=2�<./3U A5B 6?>�/ <.2 E /

UD2�6.2$S BD6./�1.ND1)/36./3U ;=<?S B 6?>=/ B=/39 /���A� ;�6?STA5B�E A�UD/ �T<0U�/3<.@)1.S���/3U S B��� V � "�V

Page 66: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

AV=

M_S . MN9�OgQ*X�OP6�9�FNS >+ynfg6�9 / 4�; 8:2 T ONQC] > K 9�wR2 K 9�>�4�9�XbQRF�8z[ 8*OUON9�FN> . 8*MN9 K Q�>��� � ��� @�M�ycm�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~

T Q?MUOnQ*X�O_6�9 [ 9�F�25Q K MgO_6�9 / M_S�V?V09�MNOn9+"�25MNO�2 > O_6�9 e jnm f K 8*O_8`80F�9 >�Q?Oc9�wR2 K 9�>0O�2�>zO_6�9gX\S�;I; C ?nf K 8*O_8

MN9�O�y

fg6�9`jnf Q*XGO_6�9�4�Q TC. 2�>�9 K�K 8*O_8 XZFHQ T f�9+" 8*M�~+m 8�|�8*252b~�8?> K p�8 k^8:; T 8 2IMWMP6�Q(|Y>2�>�j^2IV�S F�9 J yB@ ~

8?> K OP6�9z4�QRFNF�9�MP[ QR> K 2�>�VA|g2 > K Q*| XZS >�4�ON25QR> 25M`M_6�Q*| >�2�>3j^25VRS F�9 J y J yzf�6�9 T Q0MNOWMNO_F�2 H02�>�Vt8:M_[ 9�4�OWQ*X

O_6�9 k � � Y E Y jnf 25MCO_6 8*O�~�|�25O_6 O_6�9z9+"�4�9�[�ON25QR> Q*X�O_6�9 ;�8?FHV?9�MNOWVRF�Q�S [3Q*X [ 9�8VH0M��b>�9�8?F�=V=V@ O ��m � ~

9�w?9�F / MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0O T Q K 9 25M�8?[ [ 8?F�9�>0ON; / 8WMN2�>�V?;59�O�y�f�6�9�Q�>�; / Q . w�25QRS�M T S�;IOU2 [�;59�O�25M�O_6�9 JSEVE M K QRS . ;59�O�~

| 6�254�6�M_6�Q*|�M`8 XZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[�;525ONON2�>�V3Q*X � y �VO ��m �?y!C 25O_63QR>�; / 8 MU2 >�V0;I9 X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[�;52IOUON2�>�V-OUQAV?Q

.0/ ~�25O`25M`2 T [ Q?MNMN2 . ;59ONQ4�;�8*2 T |g2IOP634�9�F�O_8*2�>�; / O_6�9 w(8*;�S�9zQ*X ��X QRFW80> / Q*XGO_6�9 [ 9�8VH0M`2�>3j^25VRS F�9 J yB@ y

�gQRF T 8*;5; / ~ O_6�9Y2 K 9�>?OU2�]�4�8:ON25QR>Q*X=8?> 9�a S 8*;�[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V [ 8:ONON9�FN> T 2IV�6?O . 9WQ:X=MNQ T 9Y6�9�; [+~ . S�O�O_6�9

4�;5Q?MN9�MNOgM_[ 8*4�2�>�V . 9�O�|G9�9�> T Q K 9�M�25M�OP6 8*O . 9�O�|�9�9�> O_6�9 JVJ Y�80> K J��+J M � =V= @ O 8?> K = J�� Y ��m � [ 9�8VH0M�s

1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000

0

5

10

15

20

2200 2400 2600 2800 3000 3200

0

5

10

15

20

j^25VRS FH9 J yB@ j%QRS F�259�F�O_FN80>�M�X Q�F T Q*X�OP6�9`k � � Y E Y�C ?nf K 8*O_8CMU9�O�y

Page 67: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

AV@

1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

j^25VRS FH9 J y J C 2�> K Q*| XZS >�4�OU2IQ�>XbQRFcO_6�9`k � � Y E Y%C ?cf K 8*O_8�MN9�O�y

@V@�M�y j%QRF�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X T 8*MNMU9�M 8 . Q*w?9A8 . QRS�O E yBA A � � ~nO_6�25MzMP[ 8*4�2�>�V)25MzONQ�Q�;�8?F�V09ONQ�F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0O

4�QR>�MN9�4�S�OU2Iw09 � T Q K 9�MzQ*XWO_6�9M_8 T 9 �?y o�XWO_6�9�F�925M8 T Q K 9 T 25MNMN2�>�V . 9�O�|G9�9�> OP6�9Ou|�Q�~�O_6�9�> O_6�9

[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V25M�8 . QRS�O �FO yBA M�~�[ Q?MNMN2 . ;59 Q�>�; / 2EX�O_6�9CMNO_8?FY6 8*M`8 T 8:MNMWQ*X � ���lQ�FYVRF�9�8*ON9�Fvy`f�6�9

8*;5ON9�FN> 8:ON25w?9W25M O_6 8:OGOP6�9�MN9`O�|�Q T Q K 9�MW8?F�9YQ*X K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O �?~ . S�O�|�25O_6�8WX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[�;525ONON2�>�VQR>�; / MU9�9�>

2�>�Q�>�9 Q*X�O_6�9 T ~=|�9 4�8?> >�Q?O�ON9�;5;G2EX OP6�2IMC25MCO_6�9z4�8*MU9?yAf�6�25M [ F�Q . ;59 T 6�25VR6�;525VR6?OUMzO_6�9 S�MN9PX\S�;�>�9�MNMzQ*X

] > K 2�>�V T 80> / 2�> K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>0O [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>3[ 9�8VH0MW2�>AOP6�9`jnf Q*X�8 � C � 2�FYMNO_80F�y5C 2IOP6Ak � �?� A � ~ Q*w?9�F

�FEVE K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T Q K 9�M�|�9�F�9gXbQRS > K � XbQRFnk � = � @ � ~0|�9YX QRS > K O�|�9�>?O / y^m�9�FH9 |�9`6 8�w?9YQR>�; / MN9�w09�> 7 >�Q?O

T S�476 K 8*O_8 |�25O_63|Y6�2I4�6 ONQ2 K 9�>?ON2EX / 8A[ 8:ONON9�FN>+~�S >�;59�MNMCO_6�9 [ 9�8VH0M�8?F�9 4�QR>�MN9�4�S�ON25w?9 � ~�| 6�254�6�O_6�9 /

4�9�F�O_8:2 >�; / 8?FH9`>�Q?O�y

fg6�9 [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>�MnQ*X k � � Y E Y�9+" 6�2 . 2IOcQR>�9 8 K K 25ON25QR> 8:;�[ 9�4�S�;52�8?F�25O / ~�6�Q*|G9�w09�F�~�|Y6�2I4�6 T 25VR60O^4�QR>0O_8*2�>

O_6�93MN9�9 K M�Q*X�8?> 9�w?9�>0O_S 8*;YMNQ?;�S�ON25QR> ONQ O_6�25M-[ FHQ . ;59 T y fg6�9-OP6 F�9�93; 80F�V?9�MNOMN2�>�V?;59�O3[ 9�8VH0M2�> O_6�9

O_FN80>�M�X Q�F T ~R8:O � @ J�� ~ = J�� Y ~ 8?> K = �?�?� ��m �`8*;5;�M_6�Q*|i8C;�8?F�V?9�F�8:;I2�8*MgQR> O_6�9W;5Q*|5RbXZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / MN2 K 9�O_6 8?>

Page 68: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

A J

QR> O_6�9C6�25VR6+y � f |GQ 8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*; � . S�O T QRFH9 T 8?F�V?2�> 8*; T Q K 9�M 8*O �?� EVE 8?> K = E @ J ��m �z8*;5MNQzMN9�9 T ONQ

6 8�w?9z2�> � 8*ON9 K ;5Q*|5RbXZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / MU2 K 9�;5Q . 9�M�yAo >�M_S T ~�9�w?9�F / VRFHQRS [32�>�OP6�9zO_FN8?>�MHX QRF T M_6�Q*|�MW9�wR2 K 9�>�4�9

XbQRF�8C>�9�8?F .0/AT Q K 9WM_[�;52IOgX\F�Q T O_6�9W;�8?FHV?9�MNO [ 9�8VH .0/ 4�;IQ0MN9`ONQ � � K 8 / QR> O_6�9�;5Q(| RbXZF�9�a S�9�>�4 / MN2 K 9?yGo >

8*;5; . S�O�O_6�9W;�8?F�V?9 =V=V@ O ��m � K QRS . ;59�O�~ O_6�25M�9�wR2 K 9�>�4�9�2IM ������!"����1��##$; w?9�F / |�9�8VH%~ . S�O�O_6�9 S . 25a S�25ONQRS�M

> 8*O_S FH9WQ*X�OP6�9`8*M / TzT 9�O_F / T 8VH*9�M�25O�|�QRFHO_6 XZS FHO_6�9�F�MNO_S K / y

C 9 T 25VR60O 9+" [ 9�4�OWOP6 8*O�2EXG9�w?9�F / VRF�QRS [ 25M T 8 K 9CS [�Q*X�O�|�Q [ 9�8VH?MWMP[�;I25O .0/ 8*; T Q?MNOg9+" 8*4�OU; / QR>�9

4 / 4�;I9[ 9�F K 8 / ~ O_6�9�>3O_6�98 T [�;525O_S K 9 Q*X�9�8*4�6 T Q K 9zM_6�Q�S�; K 9+" 6�2 . 25O 8 K 8*25; / T Q K S�;�8*ON25QR>+~^8?> K O_6�9

[ 6 8*MN9 Q*XGO_6�25M T Q K S�;�8*ON25QR>3M_6�Q�S�; K F�9 T 8:2 > F�9�;�8*ON25w?9�; / 4�QR>�MNOP8?>?OWQ*w?9�FYOP6�9z;59�>�V?O_63Q*X�O_6�9�C ?nf FNS >

�b8*MUM_S T 2�>�V`O_6 8:OnO_6�9 . 9�8*OG[ 9�F�25Q K 25McMN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>?OU; / ;5QR>�V?9�FcO_6 8?> O_6�9�;59�>�V?O_6 Q*X�O_6�9GC ?nf FNS > 7 2�> O_6�25M

4�8*MN9CQR>�9C|�9�9FH yWf�6�25MW|�25;I; . 9CO_6�9C4�8*MN9C2EXGOP6�9�MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V�25MW4�;IQ0MN9�FWO_6 80> E yBA���m � ONQ 9+" 8*4�ON; / � � K 8 /

� �?� yBAVY ��m � y

j^25VRS FH9 J yBA M_S�V0V?9�MNONM�O_6 8*O`OP6�2IM T 25VR60O�~ 2 > K 9�9 K ~ . 9 O_6�9z4�8*MN9?y�<�2 >�4�9 O_6�9 O_6 F�9�9!C ?cf MN25ON9�MC8?F�9

M_[ 8*4�9 K F�QRS�VR6�; / 9�a S 8*;5; / 8?F�Q�S > K OP6�9�V0;IQ . 9?~�OP6�9 / |�QRS�; K 8*;5;nMN9�9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O`[ 80F�ONMWQ*XnO_6�9 . 9�8*OW4 / 4�;59

. 9�O�|�9�9�> O_6�9 O�|�QW4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONM�Q*X�9�8*476 T S�;5ON2�[�;I9�O�ynj^25VRS F�9 J yBA M_6�Q*|�MnOP6�9�MN9�4�ON25QR> Q*X�O_6�9Yjnfl80F�QRS > K

O_6�9 � @ J�� 8?> K 8?> K = J�� Y ��m ��VRF�QRS [�M�XbQRF�~ X\F�Q T ONQR[ ONQ . Q?ONOUQ T s O_6�9 X\S�;I; C ?cf FNS >+~nOP6�9O_6 F�9�9

2�> K 25wR2 K S 8*;�MN25ON9�MW| 6�254�6 T 8 K 9zS [�O_6�9zFNS >+~�8?> K O_6�9`13O�y+Dc25V?9�;5Q(| K 8:O_8zOP8VH*9�>�O_6 F�9�9 T QR>0O_6�M ;�8*OU9�F�y

o�X�O_6�9�F�9C|�8*M�QR>�; / 8 MN2�>�V?;59 [ 9�8VH�[ F�9�MN9�>0OW2�>AOP6�9�MN9COu|�Q FH9�V?25QR>�M�~+O_6�9�>�O_6�9C;�8?F�V?9�MUO [ 9�8VH2�>3O_6�9�jnf

X\F�Q T 9�8*4�6�MN25ON9|�QRS�; Kl. 9O_6�9 MP8 T 98*MC2 > O_6�97C ?cf K 8*O_8 y�@gX 4�Q�S F�MN9O_6�9 K 8*O_838?F�9>�Q?25M / ~�8?> K

O_6�25M T 2IV�6?O T 8 H*9z8*;52 8:M�[ 9�8 H?MC8?[ [ 9�8?FY;�8?FHV?9�FYO_6 8?>3OP6�9 � F�9�8*;^O_6�2�>�V�y � mgQ(|�9�w?9�Fv~�8 4�8?F�9PX\S�;^;IQ�Q H38*O

O_6�9 T 2 K K ;59AO_6 F�9�9 MN9�4�ON25QR>�MCQ*XYj^2IV�S F�9 J yBAAF�9�w09�8*;5M�OP6 8*OCO_6�9 ;�8?FHV?9�MNO�8 T [�;52IOPS K 9-[ 9�8 H�F�9�MNONMz8*O�O_6�9

[ Q0MN25ON25QR> Q*X 8 K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O � 8:;I2�8*M �)[ 9�8VH 8*OC9�8*476 MN25ON9?y f�6�25M�25Mz4�Q�>�MN25MNON9�>0Oz|�25O_6 O_6�9 . 9�6 8�wR25QRFCQ:X 8?>

�?� y>AVY ��m � K QRS . ;59�OzQ:X S >�9�w?9�> 8 T [�;525O_S K 9?~nMP8 T [�;59 K 8*O K 2 ��9�FH9�>?Oz[ 8?F�OUM`Q*X OP6�9 . 9�8*OC4 / 4�;59?y �gQ?ON9

8*;5MNQ�OP6 8*O`O_6�913O�y^Dc25V?9�;5Q*| K 8*O_8 ��4�;5Q?MN9 2�> ;5QR>�V?25O_S K 9�ONQ�f�9+" 8*M 25M 8*;5MNQ3MN|g2IOU476�9 K ONQ-8 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O

� 8*;52�8*M�~ � 4�QR>�MU2IMUON9�>?OW|g2IOP6 T 2IV�FN8*ON25QR>x2 > ��� �� ONQ 8 K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O`[ 6 8*MU9�2�>�O_6�9 . 9�8*OW4 / 4�;59?y �gQ?25MN9 T 25VR60O

. 9 9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K ONQ K Q�O_6�25M�X QRFYQ�>�9 QRF T QRF�9 [ 9�8VH?MCQR>�4�9 2 > 8|Y6�2I;59?~ . S�Oz6�9�F�9 ��#*# OP6�9 VRFHQRS [�M`M_6�Q*|

9�w�2 K 9�>�4�9�Q*X T Q K S�; 8:ON25QR> .?/ 8C>�9�8?F .0/ [ 9�8VH � � K 8 / ;IQ*|�9�Fc2�>CX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / O_6 80>CO_6�9W[ F�2 T 8?F / T Q K 9?y� R>=AK; K> 6?>�ST<"ST< B=A�6 25N�N=2K1)/)BD6 47A51"6?>=/$6?>=/ �#) � ��� - �"N�/32 � S B �'S�K;D1)/ )DV �D8'9R>=/�B 6?>�/ � S�K>D6.@�;D1 ��/ ST< ND1)/39R>�ST6./�B=/3U

�DC 6?>�/ �T2K1 / ��� � � � - � E A�UD/�8=6?>�/ � ) � ��� - �02 � ST2�<./ <"2�<.<?;=E /"6?>�/0<.2�E /"2 E$N � ST6?;�UD/$1)2�6?STA @ �T/32K1 �TC ��ST<?S�� �T/&S B 6?>=/ � 5;�1)/47A51 6?>=/ ��� ) �"25B�U �#��� � � - �"E A�U�/ <3V

Page 69: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

AVA

1300 1350 2400 2450

XCov 6

La Palma

Texas

Hawaii

Mt. Bigelow

j^25VRS F�9 J y>A f�|�QMN9�4�ON25QR>�M�Q*X�O_6�9zj�Q�S F�259�FWO_FN80>0X QRF T Q*Xk � � Y E Y K 8*O_8�X\F�Q T 2�> K 25wR2 K S 8*;cMN25ON9�M K S F R2�>�V�OP6�9GC ?nf FNS >+~ [�;�S�M�1-O�y?Dn25V?9�;5Q*| K 8*O_8O_8VH*9�> OP6 F�9�9 T QR>0O_6�M�;�8*ON9�Fvy

fg6�9`QR>�; / 9+"�4�9�[�ON25QR>3MU9�9 T M OUQ . 9�OP6�9�;�8?FHV?9�MNOW8 T [�;525O_S K 9 T Q K 9`2�>3O_6�9�jnfW~%| 6�25476�25MWM_[�;525O`>�Q?O

.0/ �?� yBAVY . S�O FU8*O_6�9�F � y �VO ��m �?y�obOY2IMYM_[�;525O Q�>O_6�9WM_8 T 9WMN2 K 9?~ 80> K |�25O_6�8CMN2 T 25;�8?FW8 T [�;525O_S K 9�FU8*ON25Q

. 9�O�|�9�9�>4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONM�~ 8*Mg|G9`80F�9`[ Q?MU2IOU2 >�V XbQRF�O_6�9WQ?OP6�9�F T Q K 9�M�yno�XnOP6�9 �?� yBAVYC8?> K � y �VO ��m ��M_[�;52IO R

ON2�>�V?MC8?F�9 . Q?OP6�F�9�8*;b~�OP6�9�>3O_6�9�F�9 80F�9CMN9�w?9�FN8*;n[ Q?MNMN2 . 25;525ON259�M�yA@W>�9z25M`OP6 8*OWO_6�9 / F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0O T Q K 9�MWQ*X

O�|�Q K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O �?y f�6�9zFN8:ON25Q . 9�Ou|�9�9�> ��� =8?> K � � � F�Q?OP8*ON25QR> 8*;�MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V�25MW9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K ONQ . 9 E y O �6�9�F�9z25O�2IM E yBYVA y J >�Q?O_6�9�F�[ Q?MNMU2 . 25;525O / 25M`OP6 8*OWO_6�9�=V= @ O ��m � K Q�S . ;I9�O�25M�8*4�O_S 8:;I; /)T 8 K 9zS [�Q*X�QR>�9

� � � 8?> K QR>�9 � � =�4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0O � 2�> Q?O_6�9�F |GQ�F K M�~�25OC25M 8?>�8:4�4�2 K 9�>0O_8*; K 9�V?9�>�9�FU8*4 / y3j^2�> 8*;5; / ~c25O

4�QRS�; K). 9zO_6 8*OW8*;5;^O_6�9 T Q K 9�MW|G9�MN9�9z8?F�9 � � � y`o >3O_6�25MW4�8*MN9?~+|�9 T S�MNOY2 >0w?Q H:9�MUQ T 9 T 9�476 8?>�25M T

.0/ | 6�254�6O_6�9%= =V@ O ��m � K QRS . ;59�OW2IMgV?25w?9�>A8?>8:O / [�254�8*;�M_[�;525ONON2�>�V�y

Page 70: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

A O

oZOnO_S FU>�MnQRS�O^O_6 8:OnO_6�9�F�9 T 25VR6?Oc2�> K 9�9 KA. 9YM_S�476 8 T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T y C 9 6 8�w?9 8*;�F�9�8 K /zT 9�>0ON25QR>�9 K O_6�9

6�25VR63[ F�Q . 8 . 25;525O / OP6 8*O OP6�9/= =V@ O ��m � T Q K 9C25M`8 � T 8 / . 9`MU9�w?9�F�9�; / OPFN8?[ [ 9 K�T Q K 9?y J 4�4�Q�F K 2�>�VAONQ

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~?<�9FH?252 � � Q�S�VR6 � ���?�?� ~vO_6�9�a S 8?>0ON25O / ! � 2 >�?�a S 8*OU2IQ�> � = y �� 4�80> . 9�8���9�4�ON9 Kz.?/ O_FU8?[ [�2�>�V�y

f�6�9Y9 ��9�4�OG25M�[ F�QR[ QRF�ON25QR> 8:; OUQ`O_6�9YO_FN8?[ [�2�>�VCMNO_FH9�>�V?O_6+y^m�25VR6�; / O_FN8?[ [ 9 K T Q K 9�M 6 8�w?9gM T 8*;5;59�F�w(8:; S�9�M

Q*X ! ��O_6 80>zO_6�9`8:M / T [�ONQ?ON254Yw(8*;�S�9`Q:X E yBA �"X Q�F � � � T Q K 9�M y^o X�O_6�9 �0� y O ��m �WM_[�;525ONON2�>�V FH9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONM

� � = ~?80> K OP6�9GMP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V�Q*X OP6�9 = =V@ O ��m � T Q K 9G25M � � � ~�O_6�9�>CO_6�25M^4�8?>�|�QRFIH%y=f�6�9 T 9�8:M_S F�9 K

[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V . 9�O�|�9�9�>3O_6�25Mz8?> K >�9+"�OC4�;5Q?MN9�MNO T Q K 9 25M�@V@xM`QRF � �FO A M�yo�XN~�XbQRFY2�>�MNO_80>�4�9?~^O_6�9

8�w?9�FN8*V09 [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V |�9�F�9%= � M��b8*M�2�>Ak � �?� A � 8?> K k � = � @ �� ~�O_6�9�> O_6�9`FU8*ON25QzQ*X=OP6�9`O_FN80[ [ 9 K

ONQ O_6�9 T 9�8?>�M_[ 8*4�2�>�V25M E yBY � ��2EXnO_6�9CO_FU8?[ [ 9 K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V�2IM � O yBACM ~+| 6�25;I9 O_6�9zFN8*ON25Q Q*XnO_6�9 T 9�8?>�ONQ

O_6�9 O_FN8?[ [ 9 K X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V |GQ�S�; Kl. 9 E y O Y� � A Y � � �E�VO y f�6�9MN2 T 25;�8?F�25O / Q*X�O_6�9�MU9AFN8*ON25Q?M

25Mz4�QR>�MN25MNOU9�>?Oz|g2IOP6�O_6�92 K 9�83OP6 8*OCO_6�9-= =V@ O S 6 � T Q K 925Mz9 � 4�259�>0ON; / O_FN8?[ [ 9 K ~^4�8?S�MN2�>�V�OP6�9; 80F�V?9

K 9�[ 8?F�OPS F�9�M�X\F�Q T'. Q?O_68�w?9�FN8*V09 [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V 80> K X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V Q . MN9�FHw?9 K XbQRFcO_6�25M T Q K 9?y

e QR>?OU2 >�S�2�>�V)|g2IOP6 QRS F 8*MNM_S T [�ON25QR> O_6 8:O 8*;5; OP6�9 T Q K 9�M 80F�9 � � � |�25O_6 8 � � K 8 / XZF�9�a S�9�>�4 /

M_[�;525ONON2�>�V�~ |�9Y4�8?> 8*M H%s K Q�9�M 8?> / F�9�8:MNQR> 8 . ;59W[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V�]�O�O_6�9WQ . MN9�FHw?9 K [ 8:ONON9�FN>CQ:X�[ 9�8VH0M �3o�X

O_6�9W;5Q*|5RbX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / 8:;I2�8*MW8?> K [ F�2 T 8?F / [ 9�8VH 2�>9�8*4�6V�F�QRS [F�9�[ F�9�MU9�>?O�OP6�9 � � � � 4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONM�Q*X

� � � T S�;5ON2�[�;I9�OUM�~ O_6�9�>�O_6�9C2 >0Xb9�FNF�9 K [ Q?MN25ON25QR>tQ*XnO_6�9 � � E� � � � [ 9�8VH0MW25MW;I25MNOU9 K 2�>�f 8 . ;59 J yB= ~

8*;5QR>�V|�25O_6tO_6�9z[ F�9 K 254�ON9 K [ 9�F�25Q K M . 8*MU9 K QR>�O_6�9C9�a S 8:;^M_[ 8*4�2�>�V-[ 8*OUON9�FN>�O_6 8*OY]�ONMWOP6�9 T . 9�MNO 7 2�>

O_6�25Mz4�8*MU9?~ �� � ����� Y�M�y f�6�25MC]�Oz25M V?Q�Q K ~^9�MP[ 9�4�2�8*;5; / 4�Q�>�MN2 K 9�F�2�>�V)O_6�9;�8?FHV?9AFN8?>�V?92�> [ 9�F�25Q K

Q*XWO_6�9Q . MN9�FHw?9 K T Q K 9�M�~�8?> K OP6�9|GQ�F�MNO�]�O T Q K 9A25M Q*X 4�QRS F�MU9AO_6�9�=V= @ O ��m � � JVJR� M K QRS . ;59�O�y

� 25w?9�> 8MP[ 9�4�O_F�Q0MN4�QR[�254�8*;5; /)K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K ON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9zQ:X � EVE ~ EVE E {C~�O_6�25M [ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�V-2 T [�;5259�M

O_6 8*O`k � � Y E Y 6 8*MC8 T 8*MNMWQ:XGMNQ T 9�O_6�2�>�V;I2 H*9 EBO Y � � yzf�QA[ S�O�25O T 25; K ; / ~^OP6�2IM�w(8*;�S�9 M_6�QRS�; K). 9

O_8VH:9�>8*M�ON9�>0O_8*ON25w?9W8*O . 9�MNO�y

fg6�9`VR8 T 9W4�8?> . 9�[�;�8 / 9 K3K 2 ��9�F�9�>?OU; / O_6 8?>x|G9`6 8�w?9C[�;�8 / 9 K 25O`6�9�F�9?y�f�6�25M`8?> 8*; / MN25M`[ Q?2�>0ONMYQRS�O

O_6�9Y;52 T 2IOP8*ON25QR>�MY2 >0w?Q?;5w?9 K |Y6�9�> O_6�9�X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V0M�V?9�O�4�;5Q?MN9WONQ�QR>�9W4 / 4�;59`[ 9�F K 8 / 7 9�w?9�> XbQRF

T S�;5ON25MN25ON9WQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M�y J K K 25ON25QR> 8*;�Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M 8?FH9 >�9�9 K 9 KA. 9PX QRFH9W|G9Y4�8?> M_8 / 8?> / OP6�2 >�V 4�9�F�O_8*2�>

8 . QRS�O k � � Y E Y ~ 80> K 25O 25M�9�MP[ 9�4�2�8*;5; / 4�FUS�4�2 8:;=ONQ MN9�8?F�4�6 O_6�9�80F�476�25w*8*; K 8*O_8 ONQz4�QR>0] F T QRF�FNS0X\S�ON9?~ 2EX

[ Q0MNMN2 . ;59?~ O_6�9 >�9�8?FH; / 9+" 8*4�O � � K 8 /CT Q K S�;�8*OU2IQ�>+yno�X�O_6�9 � � K 8 / MN25VR> 8*;%25MGF�9�8*;b~0O_6�9�>z9�w09�>�XZS�OPS F�9GC ?nf

FNS >�M�|g2I;5; . 9WQ*X^w?9�F / ;52 T 25ON9 K S�MN9 � 25O T 25VR60O . 9 . 9�ONON9�F�ONQCMN9�9FH � 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR>�O_6 F�QRS�V�6zMNQ T 9 Q0O_6�9�F

Page 71: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

AVY

f 8 . ;59 J y>= < S�M_[ 9�4�OU9 K k � � Y E Y ��� ��� � � E k 9�F�25Q K M

�� � ��� y � Y`M� � ��� ��� ����� � � � � � � ��� � �� ������M ��M ��M @V@ A yB@ @V@VA y>@ E 7J�� J yBY J���� y � J �GE"�JVJ�� yB@ J A J y>A O �GO =JR� @ y E JR� J y>@ � �W�� @AV@ � y � AV@ J y E �FE ��J "�Y J�� y E YVAV= y O = � � @ >O� � @ yBY � �?� y>A = � � = =

T 9�8?>�M�~%X QRFY2�>�MNOP8?>�4�9zO_6�9 T 9�O_6�Q K MWQ*X�ON2 T 9TR\MN9�F�259�M`MP[ 9�4�O_F�Q0MN4�QR[ / F�9�4�9�>0ON; / 8?[ [�;52I9 K .0/ h�Q . 2�>�MNQ�>39�O

8*;by � ���?� A ONQ T Q K 9 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR> 2�>�OP6�9 � �le 9�ON2^MNO_8?FHM�yz} >0ON25;nOP6�9�>+~=|�9z4�80>3QR>�; / M_8 / OP6 8*OWO_6�9

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>[ 8:ONON9�FN> Q*X�k � � Y E Y 2IMY>�Q?O�4�;I9�80F�; / 2�>�4�QR>�MN25MNOU9�>?O�|g2IOP6 O_6�Q?MN9YQ*X=O_6�9YQ?O_6�9�F � C��Y2 FcMNOP8?F�M�~

O_6�QRS�V�6 QR>�; / 8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*;�Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>A8?> K 8?> 8:; / MN25MY|�25;I; M_8 / 6�Q(| X\8?F�O_6�9WMU2 T 2I;�8?FH2IOU2I9�M�V?Q�y

� � � � �"��� �$!&()� � �M� � �&! ��� ( ��]���'� � " �� � ��� � � � ()� �0���R�

fg6�9zw(8?FH2 8 . ;I9 MNO_80FWk � E � =V= � = EVE �bD�D k^MU4?~=6�9�F�9�8�XbON9�FWk � E � =V= � � � � �FO�� @ 25M�O_6�9z4�Q�Q?;59�MNO

w(80F�2�8 . ;59 k C dz~ |�25O_638?>�9 ��9�4�ON25w?9CON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9`Q*X �VE ~ EVEVE { 8?> K 8 ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / OP6 8*O 25MW;52 H*9�; / Ou|�Q

QRF K 9�FHM�Q:X T 8*VR>�25O_S K 9 QRF�MNQX\8*2�>?OU9�F`OP6 8?>�OP6 8*O`Q*X�O_6�96�Q?ONOU9�MNO � C � 2�FCMNOP8?F�~=k � �0� A � � d`F�9�2 ��;I9�F

���?�0� y�dW9�OU9�F T 2�>�2�>�V 6�Q*| 8*;52 H*9�QRF K 2 ��9�F�9�>0OYO_6�9�MN9WO�|�Q�MUO_8?F�M�8?F�9Y|�25;5;=MP6�9 K ;525VR6?OgQR> O_6�9W2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O

a S�9�MNON25QR>CQ*X�6�Q*| w(8?F�2�8 . ;59 k C dWM^476 8?>�V09 . 9�O�|G9�9�> O_6�9 . ;�S�9 8?> K FH9 K 9 K V09�MnQ*X+O_6�9�2 >�MUO_8 . 25;52IO / MUO_F�2�[+y �

J M K 25MN4�S�MNMN9 K 9�8?F�;5259�F�~CO_6 F�9�9lk C dWM36 8�w?9 . 9�9�> MNOPS K 2I9 K MPS�4�4�9�MNM�X\S�;I; / |�25O_6 T S�;5ON25MN25ON9 K 8*O_8 s

k � �0� A � � C 2�>�V?9�O 9�O 8:; y ���0� �� 80> K k � = � @ � �Z{W8�|�8*;59�F 9�O 8*;by ���?� A ~ . Q?O_6 Q . MU9�F�w?9 K |�25O_6 O_6�9

C ?nfW~�80> K O_6�9 4�9�>?O_FU8*;nMNOP8?FYQ*X�O_6�9 [�;�8?>�9�O_80F / >�9 . S�;�8 � � e � A E � �bDcQR> K 9�Oz8*;by ���0�VO ~+Q . MU9�F�w?9 K

|�25O_6�8>�9�O�|�QRFIHxQ*X ege�d'[ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�OU9�F�M�y�C 25O_6tO_6�9z[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> M_[ 9�4�O_FU8 Q*XGO_6 FH9�9zMNO_8?FHMW2 > 6 8?> K ~�|�9

4�8?>�>�Q*| . 9�V?2�> ONQA8 K K F�9�MNM K 9�O_8*25;59 K a S�9�MUON25QR>�M�8 . QRS�O`OP6�9zw(8?FH2 8 . ;I9Ak C dWM`8*M`84�;�8*MNM�Q*X�Q . r�9�4�ONM�y

JYK K 2 >�V 8WXbQRS F�OP6zMNOP8?F 7 k � E � = = 7 ONQ`OP6�2IMg;I25MNO T 8 H*9�M�O_6�9 MUO_S K / Q*X=25ONMY[ 9�F�25Q K 2I4�25ON259�M`8?> K MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9� R>=/"2KB=2 �TC�<?ST<"A54 6?>�/"F �� ����� H 1.;DB'8=<?;�E E 2K1.S��3/ U S B 6?>�ST<0<./3@36?STAKB 8�9R2 <IN�;!� � ST<?>�/3U �DC � �I1.ST/�B / 6�2�7V�S B 6?>=/

� 2K1)@.>���8��(� ���D8�ST<.<?;=/ AK4 �� � � � � � � �� ���� ������� ����� ���� V

Page 72: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

A �

9�w?9�> T QRF�9Y9+"R4�25ON2�>�V�y

J XbON9�F K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F / Q*X`25ONM[ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�O_F�254Aw*8?F�2�8*ON25QR>�M .0/ DnQ�> K � � FN80S�9�F�� ���?� Y ~^O_6 FH9�9AMN9�[ 8?FU8*ON9

9 ��QRF�ONMW|�9�F�9 T 8 K 9zONQ3S > FN8�w?9�;Gk � E � = = B MW4�Q T [�;59+"�;525VR60OC4�S F�w?9?ym�25;5;b~ C 2�>�V?9�O � �Y8*O_6�9�F � ���?� Y

Q . MN9�FHw?9 K O_6�9�MUO_8?F�QR>�XbQRS F 4�QR>�MN9�4�S�ON25w?9W>�25VR60ONMn2�>C;�8*ON9 ���?�VO |�25O_6 O_6�9�= �� T OU9�;I9�MU4�QR[ 9W8*O^134�dWQR> 8*; K

@ . MN9�F�w*8*ONQRF / 8?> K OU9�>?O_8:ON25w?9�; / 2 K 9�>?OU2�]�9 K 9�25VR60OnMU9�[ 8?FN8*ON9�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> T Q K 9�M . 9�O�|�9�9�>�@ EVE Mn8?> K Y EVE M�y

f�6�9 / [ F�Q�[ Q?MN9 K 8 T 9�8?>A[ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�V Q*X � O J M�~%| 6�254�62 T [�;5259 K 8 T 8*MNMgQ*X � E Y � � . 8*MN9 K QR>

T Q K 9�;5M`O_6�9�>38�w(8*25;�8 . ;59?yCm�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~%O_6�9�2�F`8?> 8:; / MN25M`F�9�MNOU9 K Q�>AOP6�9�OU9�476 >�25a S�9zQ*X 8�w?9�FU8*V?2�>�V OUQ?V?9�O_6�9�F

O_6�9�j�QRS F�259�F O_FU8?>�M�XbQRF T MzQ:X`MN9�[ 8?FN8*OU9->�25VR60ON; /lK 8*O_8 MN9�ONM�~�8)[ F�Q�4�9 K S F�93| 6�254�6+~ 8*M 25OO_S FN>�9 K QRS�O�~

;59PX OS > F�9�MNQ0;Iw09 K O_6�93F�Q?O_8*OU2IQ�> 8*;�M_[�;52IOUON2�>�V ; 8:ON9�F�XbQRS > K 2�> MU9�w?9�FN8*;�2�> K 25w�2 K S 8:; T Q K 9�MzQ*XWO_6�25M MUO_8?F�y

e�Q T [ 9�;5;52 >�V T Q K 9�2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR>�|�8*M�6�9�>�4�9`2 T [ Q?MNMN2 . ;59CXbQRF�m�25;5; 9�O 8*;by � ���?� Y y

J K 9�4�8 K 9;�8*OU9�F�~^8?F T 9 K |�25O_6 6�2 > K MU2IV�6?Oz4�FH9�8*ON9 K .?/ MPS�4�4�9�MNMN9�MC|�25O_6 k � �?� A � 8?> K k � = � @ � ~

@CB�D�F�259�> 9�O8*;by � ���?�VO ~n6�9�FH9�8�X OU9�Fz@We�{Yd F�9�80> 8*; / ��9 K O_6�9 K 8*OP83Q . MN9�F�w09 Kl.?/ m�25;5;W9�O 8*;by � ���?� Y y

@We�{Ydi2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K � @Y2 > K 25w�2 K S 8*;+X\F�9�a S�9�>�4�259�M�~�4�Q T [ F�25MN2�>�V�MU2 >�V0;I9�OUM�~ K QRS . ;59�ONM�~ 80> K QR>�9�4�;59�8?FcO_F�2�[�;59�O�~

2�>�O_6�9�O_FN8?>�M�XbQRF T Q*X�O_6�9Gmg25;5; 9�On8*;by � ���?� Y K 8:O_8 y6C 9n2 K 9�>?OU2�]�9 K X QRS F [ F�Q . 8 . ;I9 � � � T Q K 9�M�~?8?> K QR>�9

[ Q0MNMN2 . ;59 ���;= T Q K 9?y�f�6�9 ��� � X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[�;52IOUON2�>�VA|�8*M�@ >O ��m �?~+|�25O_6A8 T 9�8?>A[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V

Q*X�= �� = M�yf�6�9�MN9>RS TC. 9�FHM`2 T [�; / 8�F�Q?O_8:ON25QR>3FN8*ON9zQ:X � ��BO K 8?> K 8 T 8*MNM`Q:X E y O J E YV= � � XbQRF

k � E � =V= yGmgQ*|G9�w09�F�~�@We�{Yd T 8 K 9`MU2IV�>�2�]�4�80>?O`S�MN9�Q*X^O_6�9`ON9�4�6 >�25a S�9CQ*XG[ FH9�| 6�25ON9�>�2�>�VONQzMN9�[ 8?FU8*ON9

O_6�9�[ F�9�M_S T 9 K F�9�8*; [ 9�8VH0M X\F�Q T O_6�9�9 ��9�4�ONM Q*X MN9�w09�F�9�8*;52 8:MN2�>�V`2�>?OPF�Q K S�4�9 K .?/�K 8*25; / VR80[�M^2 > O_6�9 K 8*O_8 y

f�6�S�M�O_6�9�MN9W2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR>�MW|�9�F�9WON9�>0O_8*OU2Iw09 � Q0O_6�9�F�[ Q?MNMU2 . ;59 � MNQ0; S�OU2IQ�>�M �zONQzOP6�2IM K 8*O_8CMN9�O�4�QRS�; K >�Q?O

. 9zFNS�;59 K QRS�O�y�o >3[ 8?F�ON254�S�;�8?F�~+O_6�9�MNO_F�Q�>�V?9�MNO�9�w�2 K 9�>�4�9CX Q�F�O_6�9 ��BO K F�Q?O_8:ON25QR>A[ 9�F�25Q K |�8*MgX QRS > K 2�>

O_6�9WO_FU8?>�M�XbQRF T B M K Q T 2�> 8?>0O T S�;5ON2�[�;59�O 8:O J EVE M�y J F�Q?OP8*ON25QR> FN8*ON9WQ*X E�� K 8*4�4�Q�S >?ON9 K XbQRFcO_6�9C[ 9�8VH0M

2�>O_6�25M�OPF�2�[�;I9�O T Q K 9C8*; T Q?MNO�9�a S 8*;5; / |G9�;5;�2EX^25O�|�8*M�8*MNM_S T 9 K OP6 8*O�O_6�9WO_6�2�F K ;�8?F�V?9�MUO [ 9�8VH XbQRS > K 2�>

O_6�9WO_FH2 [�;59�OY|�8*M F�9�8*;5; / 8?>8*;52�8*MYQ*X=O_6�9 � O_FNS�9��z[ 9�8VH �?��BO ��m ��8�|�8 / y

o >z@Y4�ONQ . 9�F ���?�VE ~?8YMN9�[ 8?FN8*OU9GV�F�QRS [�QRF�VR80>�2 ��9 K 8 . 2I;5QR>�V02IOPS K 2 > 8:; 4�8 T [ 8*25VR>CONQWQ . MN9�F�w?9�k � E � =V=

|�25O_6 O_6�9 � yBA T <�ON9�|�8?F K 13O�y?p+9 TzT Q�>zON9�;59�MN4�Q�[ 9?~ O_6�9 � yBA T <�ON9�|�8?F K 13O�y?Dc25V?9�;5Q*|iON9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9?~�8?> K

O_6�9�= yBA T h�Q�a S�9 K 9 ;5Q?MC1�S�476 8*4�6�Q?M �gQRF K 254 @W[�OU2I4�8:; f�9�;59�MN4�Q�[ 9?y�D�8*MN9 K QR>�Y J yBY6�QRS FHM�Q:X K 8*O_8

Q . O_8:2 >�9 K Q(w09�F �?� K 8 / M�~ �n8?S�4�;�8*2�F�9�O`8*;by � ���?� A ~�6�9�F�9�8�XbON9�F �Wk � M_S�V?V09�MNON9 K 8 X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V

2�> K 254�8*ON25w?9Q*X�8 � � �� K F�Q?OP8*ON25QR>3FN8*ON9�XbQRFWk � E � =V= ~+4�Q�>�MN25MNON9�>0O ��|�25O_6�2�>39�FUF�QRF�MW2�>3O_6�9 XZF�9�a S�9�>�4 /

Page 73: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

A �

K 9�ON9�F T 2 > 8:ON25QR>�M |�25O_6 OP6�9AF�Q?O_8*OU2IQ�>�FN8*ON9 K 9 K S�4�9 K .0/ @We�{Ydzy^} >0XbQRF�O_S > 8:ON9�; / ~nO_6�9�2�Fz8:ONON9 T [�OCONQ

]�O-8 [ 8:ONON9�FN> Q*Xz9�a S 8*;WM_[ 8*4�2�>�V ONQ O_6�9�[ 9�FH2IQ K M3|�8*M XZFUS�MNO_FN8*OU9 K .0/ O_6�9)8 . MU9�>�4�9�Q*XzMNQ T 93;5Q*|5R

8 T [�;525O_S K 9 T Q K 9�MWMN9�[ 80FN8*ON9�; / 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K .0/ @Weg{Ydzy�@gXGO_6�9CO_6�2�F�ON9�9�> [ 9�8VH0MW2 K 9�>?ON2E]�9 K .?/ @We�{Yd

2�>�OP6�9 O_FU8?>�M�XbQRF T Q*X�O_6�9 ���?�VO K 8:O_8 ~�Q�>�; / MN9�w?9�> |G9�FH9z2 K 9�>?ON2E]�9 K 2 > O_6�9 ���?�VE K 8:O_8 K 9�MN4�FH2 . 9 Kl.?/

�Wk � y �Wk � B M�M_S�V?V?9�MUON25QR>Q*XG8 �FO M [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V|�8*M . 8*MN9 K QR>xO�|GQ K 2 ��9�F�9�>0OW8?F�VRS T 9�>0ONM�yYf�6�9

] F�MNO`80F�VRS T 9�>0O K 9�F�25w?9�M�XZFHQ T O_6�9zM_S�V0V?9�MNON25QR>3Q:X mg2I;5;�9�O`8*;by � ���?� Y O_6 8*O�~+V?25w?9�>�MU2 T 2I;�8?F�MNOPFNS�4�O_S F�9?~

k � E � =V= 8?> K k � �?� A � MP6�QRS�; K 6 8�w?9�[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V?MA2�> OP6�9�M_8 T 9�FN8:ON25Q 8*MO_6�9�2�F�F�9�M_[ 9�4�OU2Iw09

K Q T 2�> 8?>0Oz[ 9�F�25Q K M�y)mgQ*|�9�w?9�F�~ O_6�9F�9�M_S�;5ON2�>�V�9�MNON2 T 8:ON9 K [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V3XbQRFCk � E � =V=�F�9�a S�2 FH9�M 8

T 8*MUM Q*X T QRF�9AOP6 8?> E Y � � ~cX\8?F VRF�9�8*OU9�FCO_6 8?> O_6�9 E A � � � Q:X�k � �?� A � ~n2 T [�; / 2 >�V O_6 8*O O_6�9

O�|�QAMNO_80F�Mz6 8�w09MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>?OU; / K 2 ��9�F�9�>0OzMNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9?y)fg6�9�2 F MN9�4�QR> K 80F�VRS T 9�>0Oz8*MNM_S T 9 K OP6 8*OCO_6 F�9�9

Q . MN9�FHw?9 K T S�;5ON2�[�;59�ONM 6 8 K � � � yAfg6�9 / 9+" [ FH9�MNM K QRS . ONM�8:M`ONQ�O_6�9 9+" 8*4�OC> 8*O_S F�9 Q*X�QR>�9 Q*X�O_6�9�MN9

T Q K 9�M�~ 6�Q*|G9�w09�F�~*M_S�V?V?9�MUON2�>�V`O_6 8*O�8?> ��� = 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR> T 2IV�6?O�8*;5MNQ`9+" [�;�8*2�> O_6�9 Q . MN9�F�w?9 K [ 9�8VH0M�y

@We�{Yd 2�> K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>0ON; / 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K OP6�9`[ F�Q . ;59 T 8*ON254 T S�;5ON2�[�;59�O`8*M 8 ;I2 H*9�; / � � = T Q K 9?y

fg6�9AO_6 F�9�938*ONON9 T [�ONM 8*O K 9�4�F / [�ON25QR> Q*XWO_6�93k � E � =V=t;I25VR60O 4�S F�w?9 K 25MN4�S�MUMN9 K 8 . Q(w09MNO_F�QR>�V0; /

M_S�V?V09�MNON9 K O_6�9 >�9�9 K XbQRFn8 T QRF�9�4�Q T [ F�9�6�9�>�MN25w?9`8?> K 4�QR>�4�9�F�OU9 K Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�> 8*;+4�8 T [ 8*25VR> ONQ�FH9�MNQ?;5w?9

O_6�9c2IMUM_S�9�M=Q:X T Q K 9n2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR>C8?> K 6�9�>�4�9GF�Q?OP8*ON25QR> 8*;*M_[�;525ONON2�>�V`8?> K [ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�V�y^o\> K 25M_[ S�O_8 . ;59

T 9�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0O=Q*X+O_6�9�MN9�a S 8?>?OU2IOU2I9�M^|�QRS�; K ~*2�>C4�QR>�rNS >�4�ON25QR>C|g2IOP6`OP6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*;�MNON9�;5;�8?F T Q K 9�;5M�~R[�2�> [ Q02 >0O

O_6�9 T 8*MNM=80> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / Q*X k � E � =V=�8?> K F�9�w?9�8*; T S�4�6`8 . QRS�O 2IOUM=9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / MNO_8:O_S�M�y=o >`8 K K 25ON25QR>+~

O_6�9 T 8*MNM�Q*X k � E � =V=�6�9�;�[�M K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9O_6�9F�Q?;59 |Y6�2I4�6 >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q�9 T 25MNMN25QR> [�;�8 / Mz8*MC8AMUQRS F�4�9zQ*X

4�Q�Q?;52 >�V � MN9�9Ge�6 80[�ON9�F O y=o X�O_6�25M T 8*MNM�25M^2�> K 9�9 K ;�8?F�V09 7 QR>�9�[ Q?2�>0O=QR> | 6�25476C8*;5;�O_6 F�9�9�[ F�25QRF^8?> 8*; / MN9�M

4�QR>�4�S F 7 OP6�9�>8*4�4�QRF K 2�>�VCONQCMNON9�;5;�8?F T Q K 9�;IM�~�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�QC;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O /K Q T 2�> 8*ON9�M�O_6�9Y9�>�9�F�V / Q�S�O_[ S�OnQ*X

k � E � =V= T QRF�9CO_6 80>-80> / Q?O_6�9�FYk C d MNO_8?F�y�f�6�25M�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q�4�QRQ?;52�>�VAMP6�QRS�; K [ F�Q K S�4�9 T 9�8*M_S FU8 . ;59

MN9�4�S�;�8?F�4�6 8?>�V?9�Mg2 >xO_6�9`[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>[ 9�F�25Q K MYQ*Xnk � E � =V= y C�9 K 25MN4�S�MNM�OP6�2IMW[ Q0MNMN2 . 25;I25O / 2�>e�6 80[�ON9�F O y

fg6�9AF�9�w?9�8*;52�>�V . S�O MNQ T 9�| 6 8*O 8 TC. 25VRS�QRS�M F�9�M_S�;5ONM Q*X MU2 >�V0;I9�8?> K K Q�S . ;I93MN25ON9�Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> Q*X

k � E � =V= T 8 K 9�25OC8?>�2 K 9�8:;nM_S . r�9�4�OWXbQRFYQ . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>3|�25O_6�O_6�9!C ?nf y�obOW|�8*MWO_6�9 [ FH2 T 8?F / OP8?F�V?9�O

XbQRFYO_6�9�C ?nfL4�8 T [ 8:2IV�>-6�9�; K 2�>�<�9�[�ON9 TC. 9�F�~ ���?�VO y`o\>3OP6�9 >�9+"�OWMN9�4�ON25QR>+~�|�9 K 9�MU4�F�2 . 9 O_6�9!C ?nf

Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�MW8?> K O_6�9�2�FWF�9 K S�4�ON25QR>+yY<�9�4�ON25QR> J y>@ yB@�QRS�ON;52�>�9�M`QRS FYF�9�M_S�;5ONMW8?> K O_6�9�2�Fg2 T [�;I254�8*OU2IQ�>�M`XbQRF

[ F�9�w�25QRS�M T Q K 9Y2 K 9�>?OU2�]�4�8:ON25QR>A8?> K [ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�Vz8?F�V�S T 9�>?OUM�y^o\> � J y>@ y J ~*|�9 K 25MN4�S�MNMgO_6�9 [ 6 / MN254�8*;

Page 74: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

OVE

[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�MnQ:X�k � E � = =�2�>C;525VR60OGQ:X O_6�9�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ 9�FH2IQ K M�y C 9�M_S TzT 80F�2 ��9 8?> KzK 25MN4�S�MNMcQRS F ] > K 2�>�V?M

2�> � J yB@ yBA ~�2�>�80>?ON254�2�[ 8*ON25QR> Q*X�2�>?w09�MNON25VR8*ON2�>�VYO_6�9nV�F�QRS [W[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M^Q*X O_6�9 � C � 2�F�MNO_8?F�M�2 >�e�6 8?[�ON9�F O y

� � � � ' �C+��8[&�� . � �� �+�R

C 25O_6 8 . 8*ONOU9�F / Q*X 8 K Q ��9�> QRF�MNQ3Q . MN9�F�w*8*ONQRFH2I9�M XZF�Q T |Y6�2I4�6 ONQ3|�8*ON4�6)8tMN2�>�V?;59AO_8?FHV?9�O�~ O_6�9

Ci6�Q?;59 ?c8?F�O_6 f�9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9WV?9�>�9�FN8*;5; / 9�>�r�Q / M�8 K w(8?>0O_8*V09�M . 9 / QR> K OP6�9�Q . wR25QRS�M�8 . 25;525O / ONQYXbQ?;5;5Q(|i8 MNO_8?F

XbQRFc;IQ�>�V?9�F�OP6 8?>8 X 9�| 6�Q�S F�M 8*O 8�ON2 T 9?yce�6�259PXnQ*X�OP6�9�MN9W25M O_6�9W|�9�8*OP6�9�F�s T S�;5ON2�[�;59zF�9 K S > K 8?>�4�259�M`8*O

MN9�w?9�FU8*;+;IQ�>�V?25O_S K 9�M�V?25w?9WO_6�9�C ?nf . 9�OUON9�F�8�w09�FN8*V?9�|�9�8*OP6�9�Fn4�Q�> K 2IOU2IQ�>�M O_6 80>z4�8?> . 9W4�;�8*2 T 9 K 8*O�8*;5;

. S�O`OP6�9 . 9�MNOCMN2�>�V?;59 MN25ON9�M�yo\>tO_6�9 [ 8*MNO�~�O_6�25Mz6 8*M�FH9�M_S�;5ON9 K 2�>�FH9�; 8:ON25w?9�; / S >�2�>0ON9�FNFNS [�ON9 K K 8*O_8 MU9�ONM

XbQRFc9�w?9�F / C ?cf FNS >+ynobO K 2 K >�Q?O�2�>OP6�2IMgQR>�9 � 6�S FNF�254�8?>�9�M�2�>O�|�QCQR4�9�80>�M�4�QR>0O_F�2 . S�ON9 K ONQzOP6�9W;IQ*|�9�MNO

Q*w?9�FN8*;5; K S�O / 4 / 4�;59Q*X 8?> / C ?nf FNS >)6�9�; K ONQ K 8*ON9?y3@Yw?9�FC8O_6�2�F�OU9�9�> K 8 / [ 9�F�25Q K 2 > <�9�[�ON9 TC. 9�F

���?� O ~�Q . MN9�F�w?9�FHM 8:4�4�S T S�;�8*OU9 K � @ ~>YVAVY �FE M�2�>0ON9�VRFN8*OU2IQ�>�M 7 8?> Q*w?9�FN8*;5; K S�O / 4 / 4�;59�Q*X � J � ~0XZ80F . 9�;5Q(|

O_6�9%A E �VE�� >�QRF T 8*;5; / 8:476�259�w?9 K3.?/ O_6�9 C ?nfWy

fg6�9`V?9�>�9�FN8:;=a S 8*;525O / Q*XnOP6�9 K 8*O_8 4�Q*w?9�FN8*V09`25MW9+"R9 T [�;I2E]�9 K .?/ OP6�9�MP[ 9�4�O_FN8:;=|�2�> K Q*|`~+M_6�Q*| >x2�>

j^25VRS F�9 J y O y^f�6�9�MN25VR> 8:O_S F�9YQ*X O_6�9Y;�8?F�V?9 K 8*25; / VR8?[�Mn25M�9�w�2 K 9�>0O�2�>zO_6�9Y>�Q?ONQRF�25QRS�M � � K 8 / 8*;52�8*MN2�>�VCMN2 K 9

;5Q . 9�M�| 6�254�6 M_S FNF�Q�S > K O_6�9Y4�9�>?O_FU8*;�[ 9�8VH%yn<�2 T 25;�8?F�8*;52�8*MN2�>�V T S�MNOG8 ��9�4�Oc9�8*4�6z[ 9�8VH 2 > O_6�9�OPFN8?>�M�XbQRF T

Q*X^O_6�9 C ?nf ;525VR60O�4�S F�w?9?y

j^25VRS FH9 J yBY M_6�Q*|�M�O_6�9zjnf�MYX\F�Q T O_6�9!C ?nf FNS > ��;5Q*|�9�FW[ 8?>�9�; 8?> K O_6�9 ���?�VO MU2 >�V0;I9 MN25ON9FNS >

8?> 8*; / ��9 KA.?/ @We�{Yd �bS [ [ 9�Fg[ 8?>�9�; ynf�6�9Y]�VRS FH9 M_6�Q*|�M�O_6 8:OGk � E � =V=W25M 80[ [ 8?F�9�>0ON; / 8�w?9�F / MNO_8 . ;59

[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�~�|�25O_6A8*; T Q0MNO�9�w?9�F / VRF�QRS [ Q*X�X\F�9�a S�9�>�4�2I9�MWMU9�9�> 2 > ���?�VO F�9�O_S FN>�2�>�V XZ8:2IOP60XZS�;5; / X Q�FnOP6�9 ���?�VO

C ?nf FNS >+y ? "R4�;�S K 2�>�V X\F�9�a S�9�>�4�259�M . 9�;5Q*| �FEVE ��m �?~cO_6�9�F�9A8?F�9 ]�w09Q . w�25QRS�MzVRFHQRS [�MC|G9�;5; 8 . Q*w?9

>�Q?25MN9?~ 8*;5;n; / 2�>�V32�>3O_6�9 FH9�V?25QR> . 9�O�|�9�9�> � A EVE 80> K @ EVEVE ��m �?yz<�2 "�Q:XGO_6�9C9�25VR60OWX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / VRFHQRS [�M

XbQRS > K .0/ @Weg{Yd 8?F�9�8?[ [ 8?FH9�>?Oc2 > O_6�9GC ?nf jnf ��OP6�9 [ 9�8VH0MG>�9�80F �FO JSE ��m �?~ = � @VY ��m �?~S=V=V= E ��m �?~

=VA E E ��m �?~V= O @ E ��m �?~�8?> K = �?�VE ��m � ~?|g2IOP6�FH9�; 8:ON25w?9�8 T [�;525O_S K 9�MnMN2 T 25;�8?F�ONQ OP6�Q?MN9�2�>`OP6�9 ���?�VO K 8*O_8 y

@W>�9�8 K K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;�[ 9�8VH >�Q?O [ F�9�MN9�>0O�2�>9�25O_6�9�F ���?� O Q�F ���?�VE 25MW[ Q?MNMU2 . ; / MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0O`>�9�8?FG= �VEVE ��m �?y

Page 75: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

O �

1500 2000 2500 3000

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

j^25VRS FH9 J y O C 2�> K Q*| XZS >�4�OU2IQ�>XbQRFcO_6�9`k � E � = =%C ?cf K 8*O_8�MN9�O�y

� � � � K < ����� �+��# � � )����%#� �� � �:� ���!�#

J > QRF�25V?2�> 8*; 6�QR[ 9 2�> 8*MNMN25VR>�2�>�V)k � E � =V=38*MCO_6�9 OUQR[ Ru[ F�25QRF�25O / C ?nf O_8?FHV?9�O K S F�2�>�V�OP6�9j 8*;5;b~

���?� O 4�8 T [ 8:2IV�> 7 . 9�MN2 K 9�M O_6�9 [ Q?MNMN2 . 25;525O / Q:XG] > K 2�>�V >�9�| T Q K 9�M 7 | 8:M`ONQ38*4�a S�2�F�9A8 K 8*OP8MN9�O�MNQ

4�Q T [�;59�ON9W8*McONQ�8*;5;5Q*|iS > 8 TC. 2IV�S�QRS�M�MN9�[ 8?FN8*OU2IQ�>CQ*X�4�;5Q?MN9�; / MP[ 8*4�9 K [ 9�8VH0Mn2�> O_6�9�j%QRS F�259�FcO_FN8?>�M�XbQRF T y

f�6�9WF�Q?O_8:ON25QR> 8*;�MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V 4�;�8*2 T 9 K 2�>[ F�9�w�25QRS�MN; / [ S . ;I25M_6�9 K3K 8*OP8`4�Q�S�; K OP6�9�> . 9`8 . MNQ0; S�OU9�; / F�9PX\S�ON9 K

QRFC4�Q�>0] F T 9 K ~�|�25O_6 O_6�9A2�> 6�9�F�9�>0O4�QR>�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�M X Q�FCM_S�V?V?9�MUON9 KlT Q K 9A2 K 9�>?OU2�]�4�8:ON25QR>i8?> K [ 9�F�25Q K

M_[ 8*4�2�>�Vl8?> K 6�9�>�4�93XbQRFzOP6�9A4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9 K T 8*MNM 8?> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / Q:X`O_6�93MNO_8?F�yi}Y>0XbQRF�O_S > 8*OU9�; / ~gO_6�9

4�Q T [�;59+"�25O / Q*X`Q�S F M_[ 9�4�O_FU8*; |g2 > K Q*| T 9�80>?OO_6 8:O |�9�8*VR8*2�> 6 8 K ONQ F�9�MNQRFHO ONQ [ F�9�| 6�25ON9�>�2�>�V ONQ

K 25MN4�9�FN> T S�;5ON2�[�;59C4�;5Q?MN9�; / M_[ 8:4�9 K [ 9�8 H?M�~%8*M�|�8*M K QR>�9`|g2IOP6[ F�9�wR25QRS�M K 8*O_8 y

}gMN2�>�V O_6�9CM_8 T 9C[ F�9�| 6�25ON9�>�2�>�VAON9�4�6 >�25a S�9�M`S�MU9 K XbQRFYk � = � @ � ~ |�9WXbQRS > K Q�>�9 8 K K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;n[ 9�8VH

>�9�8?F O_6�9z;�8?F�V?9�MUO T Q K 9 2 > O_6�9�= =V= E ��m � F�9�V?25QR>+~ T 8VH02�>�VAO_6�25M`V�F�QRS [�8 K QRS . ;59�O�y7C�9 8*;5MNQXbQRS > K

O�|�Q-8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*;�[ 9�8VH?M >�9�8?F�O_6�9 ;�8?FHV?9�MNO T Q K 92 > OP6�9 O_FU8?>�M�XbQRF T 8:O�=VA E E ��m �?y�fg6�9 O_6 FH9�9A[ 9�8VH0M

Page 76: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

O =

1500 2000 2500 3000

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

1996 (WET)

1500 2000 2500 3000

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

1986 (Single-site)

j^25VRS F�9 J y>Y j�QRS FH2I9�F�O_FN8?>�MHX QRF T Q*X O_6�9Yk � E � =V=�C ?nf K 8:O_8YMN9�O �ZS [ [ 9�Fn[ 80>�9�; 8?> K Q*X�MN2�>�V?;59MN25ON9 K 8:O_8 XZF�Q T ���?�VO ��;5Q*|�9�F�[ 8?>�9�; y

XbQRF T 83O_F�2�[�;59�O Q*X 9�a S 8*;�X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[ 8*4�2�>�V�~�|�25O_6 � ��� � �L@ A � � � EBE EVO ��m �?ylf�6�25Mz25M8?>

2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O 4�Q�>0] F T 8*ON25QR>�Q*XnOP6�9 FH9�M_S�;5ONMWQ*XG@We�{Ydz~%| 6�Q 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K O_6�9�MN9CM_8 T 9�O_6 F�9�9�X\F�9�a S�9�>�4�259�M�~

O_6�QRS�V�6C;59�MNM�4�QR>�4�;�S�MN25w?9�; / y�f�6�9 OPF�2�[�;I9�O�MNOPFNS�4�O_S F�9�MPS�V?V?9�MNONM�8?> ��� � T Q K 9 � O_6�9Y[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V���MN9�9

� J yB@ yB@ 25M�4�QR>�MN25MNON9�>0OY|�25O_6 O_6�25M 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR>+~ X Q�F�F�9�8*MNQ�> 8 . ;59`| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X T 8*MUMN9�M�y

o >A8*;5;b~%|G9YXbQRS > K >�2 >�9�2�> K 2Iw�2 K S 8*;G[ 9�F�25Q K 254�25ON259�MC2�>O_6�9 C ?nf K 8*O_8 ~ T 8VH?2�>�V S [ X Q�S F�MN2�>�V?;59�ONM�~+8

K QRS . ;59�O�~�8?> K 8 O_F�2�[�;59�O�yWf=8 . ;I9 J y>@C;52IMUONMWO_6�9 T Q K 9�M 8?> K O_6�9�2�FY2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR> ��w*8*;�S�9�MWQ*X ��8?> K � y

o\> MUQ T 9W4�8*MN9�M�~ T Q K 9W2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR>|�8*M�8*2 K 9 K3.?/ 4�Q T [ 8?F�25MNQR> |g2IOP6 O_6�9 [ 9�8VH ;I25MNOUM Q*X^@We�{Yd 8?> K

�Wk � ~ F�9�[ FHQ K S�4�9 K 6�9�F�9W2�>f 8 . ;59�M J y J 8?> K J yBA ~RF�9�M_[ 9�4�ON25w?9�; / yGfg6RS�M�Q*X=OP6�9 MN2 " VRF�QRS [�McXbQRS > K 2�> O_6�9

C ?nf K 8*OP8MN9�O�~�]�w?9 . 9�;IQ�>�V-OUQ � � � T Q K 9�M�~ . 8:MN9 K QR>3OP6�9zQ . MN9�F�w09 K XZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V%yAf�6�9

8�w?9�FN8*V09W4�QR>�MN9�4�S�ON25w?9 � XZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / M_[�;52IOUON2�>�VXbQRF�8*;5;^O_6�9 � � � T Q K 9�M 25M � ��� � � @ A � E = ��m �?~

| 6�254�6 X\F�Q T ?�a S 8*OU2IQ�> � = y �� 2 T [�;52I9�MC8zF�Q?OP8*ON25QR> FN8*ON9WQ*X ��BO � E"� K y

Page 77: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

O @

f 8 . ;59 J y>@ k 9�FH2IQ K 254�25ON259�M`Q*Xnk � E � =V= X\F�Q T O_6�9 C ?nf d`8:O_8C<�9�O

k 9�F�25Q K j FH9�a S�9�>�4 / ��� J T [�;525O_S K 9 ��� ��� �������M � ��m � � ��m � � T 8 � T 8 � � � ��m � � ��m �

OVE0� yBAVYV= � �FO JSE y JR� @ E y EVE J = yBY E yB= � � �W� � Y y � � � = � @ �� A E yB=

J O Y y �VO A O = � @ Y yB@ OVO E y EVE @ J yBA E yB= y�y�y y�y�y y�y�y y�y�y

J A E y � YVA @ =V=V= � yB@VAVY E y EVE = A yB@ E yB@ � �C� � @ yB@ @V= E y EVE @JVJ�� yBA E � E =V=V= J y O?�?� E y EVE = A y � E yB@ � E � y�y�y y�y�y

J E � yBAVAVA � = JR� E yB@ �+J E y EVE = � y � E yB@ � �C� @ yBA � A E y EVE JJ E E y � Y � A = JR� @ y �?�?� E y EVE @ J yB= E y J � E @ yBA YVY E y EVE JJ E E y J E J = = JR� Y y J Y O E y EVE = � yBA E yB@ � �W� y�y�y y�y�y

@ � E y �?�?�0� = O @ E y � �FE E y EVE J = y O E yB= � � �C��� E � @ yB@ � E yB@

@V@ O yB= �VE J = � Y @ yBY E?� E y EVE = A y J E yB= � �� � �W� �� � @ yBY E �� � E yB=��Q?OU9�M 7 � S TC. 9�F�MW2�>�[ 8?F�9�>0O_6�9�MN9�MWM_6�Q*|LO_6�9 T 9�8?>�4�QR>�MN9�4�S�OU2Iw09 � M_[�;525ONON2�>�V32EXGO_6�9CQ . MU9�F�w?9 K

K QRS . ;59�OC25M�8*MNMPS T 9 K ONQAF�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0O � � � ��� � � � y J 4�Q TzT 8zMN9�[ 80FN8*ON9�M`[ Q?MNMN2 . ;59 � 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8 RON25QR>�M�| 6�9�F�9 4�QR>�MNO_FN8:2 >0OWONQ38MN2�>�V?;59 w(8*;�S�9 | 8:M�>�Q?OC[ Q?MNMU2 . ;59?yj+F�9�a S�9�>�4 / 8?> K 8 T [�;I25O_S K 99�FUF�QRF�MK 9�F�25w?9 XZF�Q T 8 XbQRF T 8:;�;59�8*MNO�MUa S 8?FH9�M 8?> 8*; / MN25M�Q*X^O_6�9 K 8*O_8 y^f�6�9`8 T [�;52IOPS K 9�S >�25ONMW8?F�9 T Q K S�;�8*OU2IQ�>8 T [�;525O_S K 9?~ T 8�� � � � � y

� D�8*MN9 K QR> O_6�9YX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / Q:X�8z>�9�80F .?/ [ 9�8 H 2 > K 8*O_8 X\F�Q T @We�{Ydzy� D�8*MN9 K Q�> O_6�9YXZFH9�a S�9�>�4�259�MWQ*Xn>�9�8?F .0/ [ 9�8VH0M�2�>O_6�9 K 8*O_8�Q*X � k � y

Page 78: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

O J

f=8 . ;59 J y J k 9�F�25Q K 254�25ON259�M`Q:X�k � E � =V= X\F�Q T ���0�VO <�2 >�V0;I9TRu<�25ON9 d`8*O_8

k 9�F�25Q K j F�9�a S�9�>�4 / ��� J T [�;525O_S K 9 �����M � ��m � � ��m � � T 8 � T 8 � �O � = y JVJ �FO @V= y � E yB= = y O E y>@ � � � � �C� �

A Y E y EVE � YVA J y J E yB= = yBA E y>@ � �

JSOVO yB@VY = �+JVJ yB= E yB= @ yB@ E y J � �JSO A yB= E = �+JR� y O E yB= = yB@ E y J � �

J A E yB=VA =V=V= � y E E y � O yB@ E y J � � � � �W� �� �

JSE � y O � = JR�VE y E E y � Y yB@ E y J � �C�JSE � y E @ = JR� @ y O E yB= @ y E E y J � EJSEVE yBA E = JR�VO y � E y � � = yB@ E y J � �W�

@ �VE y E?� = O @ � y E E yB= � y � E y J � �C��� E@ Y � y O � = O @ J yB@ E yB= = y � E y J � E���W�

@ @VY y � @ = �VOVO yB= E yB= @ y � E y J � �C�@ @ O yB= � = � YV@ y O E y � A y � E y J � �W��gQ?ON9�M 7 d`8*OP8A8?F�9 X\F�Q T @CBEDGFH2I9�> 9�Oz8*;by ���?� O ~ . 8*MN9 K QR>�MU2 >�V0;I9�MN25ON9

Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�MYX\F�Q T ���?�VO ygj F�9�a S�9�>�4 / 80> K 8 T [�;52IOPS K 9z9�FNF�QRFHM K 9�F�25w?9CX\F�Q T8 XbQRF T 8*; ;59�8*MNOWMNa S 8?F�9�M`80> 8*; / MN25M�Q*XGO_6�9 K 8*O_8 y`fg6�9 8 T [�;525O_S K 9 S >�25ONMC8?F�9T Q K S�;�8*ON25QR>A8 T [�;52IOPS K 9?~ T 8 � � ����� y

� D�8*MN9 K QR> O_6�9 XZFH9�a S�9�>�4 / Q*X^8z>�9�8?F .0/ [ 9�8VH 2�>O_6�9 C ?cf K 8*O_8�MN9�O�y� DG8:MN9 K QR> O_6�9 XZF�9�a S�9�>�4�259�M Q:X�>�9�8?F .?/ [ 9�8VH0MY2 >xO_6�9 K 8*O_8 Q*X �Wk � y

fg6�9^] > 8*;�[ 9�8VH�~?8:OD= � @VY ��m �?~0;52I9�M�8*O O_6�9�[ Q?MN25ON25QR>�Q*X 80>�8:;I2�8*M^Q:X 8 [ 9�8VH`[ F�9�w�25QRS�MN; / 2 K 9�>?ON2E]�9 K.?/

@We�{Ydzy�fg6�2IMg4�8*;5;IMW2�>0ONQza S�9�MNON25QR> O_6�9�2�Fg2 K 9�>?ON2E]�4�8*OU2IQ�>AQ:X=O_6�25M T Q K 9?~ . 8:MN9 K QR> X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / MP[�;I25ONOU2 >�V

8?F�V�S T 9�>?OUM�~=8*M � � = y J O�[ F�9�MN9�>0OCO_6�9 w(8*;�S�9Q*X �zXbQRFWOP6�2IMz[ 9�8VH�F�9 T 8:2 >�MzS >�4�QR>�MUO_FN8*2�>�9 Kl.0/ O_6�9

K 8*O_8 y

@WS Fc2�> 8 . 25;525O / ONQzF�9�MNQ?;5w?9YO_6�9W2 K 9�>0ON25O / Q*X=OP6�9%= � @VY ��m � T Q K 9W25M K 25M_8?[ [ Q02 >0ON2�>�V�~ X Q�FnOP6�2IMYF�9�V?25QR>

6 8*M . 9�9�> 8 MNQRS F�4�9zQ:Xg[ 80F�ON254�S�;�8?F K 2 � 4�S�;5O / y7C 6�25;59A@We�{Yd'OU9�>?O_8:ON25w?9�; / 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K 25Oz8*M`8?> � �(=

T Q K 9 . 8*MU9 K QR> O_6�9A;�8?FHV?9�FCM_[�;525ONON2�>�V X QRS > K 2�> | 6 8*O | 8:M�OP6�9�>l8 K QRS . ;59�O�~ �Wk � M_S�V?V?9�MUON9 K O_6�9

[ Q0MNMN2 . 25;I25O / Q*XG80>-8:4�4�2 K 9�>0O_8*; 4�Q?2�>�4�2 K 9�>�4�9Q*X . Q0O_6 � � � 8?> K � � = T Q K 9�M�~+O_6�QRS�V�6O_6�25MW2 K 9�8|�8*M

���2�=. 8*MN9 K QR> Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�Q*X . Q0O_6 ��� � 8?> K ���]=CM_[�;525ONON2�>�V|�25O_6�2�>�O_6�9 T Q K 9?y�o K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR>�Q*X

Page 79: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

O A

f=8 . ;59 J yBA k 9�F�25Q K 254�2IOU2I9�MWQ:X�k � E � = =WX\F�Q T ���?�VE f�|�Q Ru<�25ON9Wd`8*OP8

k 9�F�25Q K j+F�9�a S�9�>�4 / JWT [�;525O_S K 9� M � ��m � � T 8 � �J A E y � @ = =V= � y O � y � � �C�

JVJR� y J J = =V=VA y E � yBA � EJVJR� y �0� = =V=VY yBY � yB= � �W�

J E � y E O = JR� @ y J � y O � �J EVE y � E = JR� J y J � y � � EJ EVE y J = = JR� Y y J J yB= � �W�

@V@ O y O0� = � Y E yB= E yBY � E@V@ O yB= � = � YV@ yBY � y � � �W��gQ?ON9�M 7 d`8*O_8 8?F�9X\F�Q T �n8?S�4�;�8*2�F9�O8*;by ���0� A ~ . 8*MN9 K QR>

K QRS . ;59�MN25ON9�Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�>�M XZF�Q T ���?�VE y=f�6�9�8 T [�;525O_S K 9�M�~0V?25w?9�> .?/�Wk � 2�>�S >�25ONMWQ*X TzT 8*V%~ 6 8�w?9 . 9�9�>t4�QR>?w09�F�ON9 K ONQ T Q K S�;�8*OU2IQ�>8 T [�;525O_S K 9?~ T 8�� � � � � y

O_6�9Ww*8*;�S�9�Q:X �YX Q�F�O_6�25M T Q K 9`25MY2 T [ QRF�OP8?>?O . 9�4�8?S�MN9�Q*X^2IOUM 4�;5Q?MN9`[ FHQ "�2 T 25O / 2 >�[ 9�F�25Q K ONQCO_6�9 T Q K 9

8*O�=V=V= E ��m �?yAf�6�25Mz[ F�Q "R2 T 25O / ;59 K �Wk � ONQ�M_S�V?V?9�MNOC8?> � � � [ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V�Q*X � �FO M�~�|Y6�2I;59

@We�{Ydi4�;�8*2 T 8W[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�VCQ*X�= � =YM�y^f�6�9 [ Q?MNMN2 . 25;52IO / Q*X Q . MN9�F�w�2 >�VCMN9�w09�FN8*; 4�Q T [ QR>�9�>0ONM^Q*X�O_6�9

= � @ Y ��m � T Q K 9z8?> K O_6�9�F�9 .0/ 4�QR>�4�;�S�MN25w?9�; /�K 9 K S�4�2�>�V325ONM Q�F K 9�F �`|�8*M OP6RS�M`8?>x9+"R4�25ON2�>�V3[ F�Q?M_[ 9�4�O�y

}Y>0X QRFHO_S > 8*ON9�; / ~�8�X OU9�F�[ FH9�| 6�25ON9�>�2�>�V)Q*XWO_6�9�C ?nf ;525VR60Oz4�S F�w?9A8*OCO_6�9MU2 >�V0;I9�Q . MN9�F�w09 K XZF�9�a S�9�>�4 /

O_6�9�F�9`FH9 T 8*2�>�9 K QR>�; / 8?> 2�> K 25MNON2�>�VRS�25M_6 8 . ;I9�rNS T�. ;59W2�>OP6�9WO_FN8?>�M�XbQRF T s�8 [ Q?MNMU2 . ;59�9 ��9�4�OgQ*X�8:;I2�8*MU2 >�V

2�>?OU9�F X 9�FH9�>�4�9 . 9�O�|�9�9�>CO�|�Q QRF T QRF�9�F�9�8*;�[ 9�F�25Q K 254�25ON259�M�Q*X+MN2 T 25; 80F�~�M T 8*;5;�8 T [�;525O_S K 9?yn}Y>0ON25;�|�9�Q . O_8*2�>

8 T QRFH9G4�Q T [�;59�ON9 FH9�4�QRF K Q*X OP6�9�;52IV�6?Oc4�S F�w?9�Q*X�k � E � =V= ~*O_6�9�= � @VY ��m � T Q K 9�|g2I;5;+F�9 T 8*2�>z8�[ S � ��;I9?y

� � � � Z �Y� �(�"!�� ����� �?�Z# �+�

fg6�9n[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V k C dWM�MNO_S K 259 K |g2IOP6 T S�;5ON25MN25ON9 K 8*OP8nMUQ�XZ80F 7 k � �?� A � ~�k � = � @ � ~�8?> K � � e � A E � 7M_6�Q*|'8A[ 8*OUON9�FN> Q*X � � � T Q K 9�MCM_[ 8:4�9 K 8*O T S�;5ON2�[�;59�M Q*XW8X\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*;�[ 9�F�25Q K 2�>0ON9�F�w(8:; y�fg6�2IM

2�>?OU9�F�w(8*;%25M K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9 K.0/ OP6�9�MN9�O^Q*X T Q K 9�M ��!����#$�1:/#G� XbQRF^[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> � >�Q?O�8*;5; O_6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*;5; / 8�w(8:2I;�8 . ;59

T Q K 9�MG8?FH9G9+"�4�25ON9 K ~�;59�8�w�2�>�VCVR8?[�M^Q*X+QR>�9�QRF T Q�F�9 �_T 25MNMN2�>�V �C[ 9�F�25Q K MG2�> 8Y476 8:2 > T Q?MUON; / 4�QR>�MN9�4�S�OU2Iw09

Page 80: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

OVO

2�>lFN8 K 2 8:;G2�> K 9+" � y J M [ F�9�MN9�>0ON9 K 2�>le�6 8?[�OU9�F�= ~nO_6�9 X\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*;�[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V)25MzOP6�9 T Q?MNO

2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O�[ 8?FN8 T 9�OU9�F T 9�8*M_S F�9 K 2�> O_6�9`[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>M_[ 9�4�O_FNS T Q*X^8`|Y6�2IOU9 K | 80F X=MNO_80F�~ 8*M�2IOg2IM K 9�ON9�F R

T 2�>�9 K 8*; T Q0MNOW9+"R4�;�S�MN25w?9�; /).0/ O�|�Q [ 8?FU8 T 9�ON9�F�M�s�O_6�9CMNON9�;5;�8?F T 8:MNM`8?> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / y�f�6�9�] F�MUOWMNON9�[

2�> K 9 K S�4�2 >�V3O_6�25MWM_[ 8:4�2 >�V25MW2 K 9�>0ON2E]�4�8*ON25QR> Q*XnO_6�9`Q�F K 9�F �`Q*Xn9�8*4�6�Q*XnO_6�9 T Q K 9�MW2 >�O_6�9z[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>

M_[ 9�4�O_FNS T ~ 8[ F�QR4�9�MUMW2 >tO_6�25M`4�8*MN9CQRS�OU;I2�>�9 K 2�>3O_6�9 [ F�9�w�25QRS�M`MU9�4�ON25QR>+y J M T 9�>?ON25QR>�9 K 8 . Q*w?9?~ . Q?O_6

�Wk � 8?> K @We�{Yd 6 8�w?98*;�F�9�8 K / 8*OUON9 T [�ON9 K ONQ39+" [�;�8*2�> O_6�9 [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 9�4�OPFNS T Q*X k � E � =V=�|�25O_6

K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O�w*8*;�S�9�MGQ:X�OP6�9 [ F�2 T 80F / M_[ 8*4�2�>�V�y C�9Y4�8?>z>�Q*| S�MN9 8:;I;%Q*X�O_6�9YQ . MN9�F�w?9 K [ 9�F�25Q K M�ONQ�8:ONON9 T [�O

ONQ K 9�4�2 K 9 . 9�O�|�9�9�>O_6�9�MN9WO�|�Qz6 / [ Q0O_6�9�MN9�M�y

f 8 . ;59 J y O 4�Q T [ 8?F�9�MCO_6�9Q . MN9�FHw?9 K [ 8:ONON9�FN> Q*X � � � T Q K 9�MCONQ�[ 9�FH2IQ K M[ F�9 K 254�ON9 K .0/ MUO_F�254�O

[ 8*ONOU9�FN>�M�Q*X = ���� E MY8?> K �FO = J M�M_[ 8*4�2�>�V�ynfg6�9�MN9`w*8*;�S�9�MW|G9�FH9WQ . O_8*2�>�9 K-.0/ O_8VH02 >�V O_6�9`;52 H*9�; / w*8*;�S�9

Q*X �� � � � � �� X Q�F 9�8*476 T Q K 9 . 8*MN9 K QR>�; / QR>z8?[ [ FHQ "�2 T 8*ON9gM_[ 8*4�2�>�V?M�Q*X = � MG80> K �FO M�8?> K O_6�9�>+~

XbQRFcO_6�9WO�|GQCF�9�M_S�;5ON2�>�VzMN9�OUM�Q*X �� ��QR>�9YXbQRFc9�8*4�6z9�MNOU2 T 8*ON9WQ*X � ]�ONON2�>�V 8�;52�>�9`ONQ!?�a S 8*OU2IQ�> � J yB= y

�� � = � ��FE M 8?> K �FO = J M�F�9�[ F�9�MU9�>?O�O_6�9WO�|�Q . 9�MNOc]�ONM ��2�>8`;59�8*MUO9R\MNa S 8?F�9�M�MN9�>�MN9 OUQ�OP6�9 Q . MU9�F�w?9 K

[ 9�FH2IQ K M�~%V?25w?9�>A8:MNM_S T 9 K w*8*;�S�9�M Q*X ��3;525MNON9 K 2�>Af 8 . ;59 J y O y

fg6�9GM T 8*;5;59�MNOnQ . MU9�F�w?9 K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V�2�>CO_6�9�[ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 9�4�O_FNS T . 9�O�|�9�9�> T Q K 9�M^4�QR>0] K 9�>0ON; / 2 K 9�>?ON2E]�9 K

8*M � � � 25M � = � M�~ . 9�Ou|�9�9�>xO_6�9 T Q K 9�MW8*O J E � MW8?> K @ �VE M � = A EVE ��m �z8?> K = O @ E ��m � ~ 8?> K O_6�25M

XbQRF T 9 K O_6�9�MU9�9 K Q*X OP6�9�QRF�25V?2�> 8*; M_S�V0V?9�MNON25QR>CQ:X�= � Mn8*M^OP6�9 8�w?9�FN8*V?9�[ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�V�2�>COP6�9�M_[ 9�4�OPFNS T

Q*Xnk � E � =V= y^f�6�9�@ �VE M T Q K 9W2IMW8*;5MNQzQ�>�9WQ*X�O�|�Q���O_6�9WQ?OP6�9�F . 9�2�>�VA8*OGAVY E M | 6�254�6O_6�9C[ F�QR[ Q?MN9 K

�FO =YM [ 8:ONON9�FN> T 2IMUMN9�M�FN8*O_6�9�FcMN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0ON; / yGfg6�9 = � �� M�[ 8*ONON9�FN>+~0QR>CO_6�9YQ?O_6�9�F�6 8?> K ~0X\8*25;5M 8:OG8 . QRS�O

O_6�9�MP8 T 9�;59�w?9�;�ONQW9+" [�;�8*2�>zOP6�9 T Q K 9 8:O J A E M � =V= =VA ��m � y J ;5;�Q*X+O_6�9�MN9 �_T 2IMUMN9�M �W4�QRS�; K F�9�M_S�;5O^X\F�Q T

9 ��9�4�ONM�Q*X T Q K 9WOPFN8?[ [�2�>�V�~ MNQCO_6 8:O . Q?O_6[ 8*OUON9�FN>�M�8*4�4�QRS >0O�XbQRFcO_6�9 K 8*O_8C8*; T Q?MUOG9�a S 8*;5; / |�9�;I;b~%|�25O_6

�� � = � �� MWMNQ T 9�| 6 8*OW[ F�9PX 9�FUF�9 K y C�9z[ F�9�w�25QRS�MN; /�T 9�>?OU2IQ�>�9 K 80>-8 K K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;n[ 9�8VH�O_80>?O_8:;I2 ��2�>�V?; /

4�;5Q?MN9 ONQ � � 8 . Q(w09zO_6�9z;5Q�4�8*;�>�Q?25MN9 . 80> K 8*O%= �VEVE ��m ��� @VAVY �� M yf�6�Q�S�VR6 .0/ 25ONMN9�;EX >�Q?O�MNO_F�254�ON; /

MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0O�~%2�XGFH9�8*;�O_6�25MW[ 9�8VH |�QRS�; K ]�OYO_6�9%= � �� M [ 8*OUON9�FN>[ F�9�4�25MN9�; / 7 4�Q T [�;59�ON2�>�V�8C4�6 8*2�>Q*X XbQRS F

4�QR>�MN9�4�S�OU2Iw09 T Q K 9�M 7 8?> K |GQ�S�; K 2�>l8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*;5;IQ*| S�M ONQ�FNS�;59AQ�S�O 8 �FO =AM [ 8*ONON9�FN> |g2IOP6 6�2IV�6

4�QR>0] K 9�>�4�9?yQCi6�2I;59YO_6�25MG[ 9�8VH�2IMcO_6�9�;�8?F�V09�MNO^2�>zO_6�9�O_FU8?>�M�XbQRF T . 9�O�|�9�9�>CO_6�9 ��� � VRFHQRS [�MG>�9�8?F @ @ O M

8?> K @ �VE M�~?|�9�4�80> >�Q?O^4�;�8*2 T |g2IOP6z4�9�F�OP8*2�>?O / OP6 8*O^25OG25M�8`F�9�8*;�[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> T Q K 9�2EX=4�Q�>�MN2 K 9�F�9 K 9�>0ON2�F�9�; /

QR> 25ONM�Q*| > T 9�FH2IOUM�y C�9Y|�25;5;�QR>�; / MP8 / O_6 8:OG|Y6�2I;59 �� � = � M�25M�O_6�9 T Q?MUOG[ F�Q . 8 . ;I9WMUQ?;�S�ON25QR> ONQCO_6�9

Page 81: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

O Y

f 8 . ;59 J y O e Q T [ 8?F�25MNQ�>AQ:X OP6�9 k � E � = = k 9�F�25Q K < [ 9�4�OPFNS T |�25O_6 k^8*ONON9�FN>�MWQ:X<�OPF�254�O = ��"�FE Mn8?> K � O = J Mn< [ 8:4�2 >�V . 9�O�|�9�9�>C13Q K 9�M^Q:X�e�QR>�MU9�4�S�ON25w?9hg8 K 2�8*;�o > K 9+" �

�� � = � y � E M �� � �FO yB= J M�� � � � � � E � ��� � � � � � � �

� � � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � � � �� � � � � ��� � �

� M ��M ��M � M ��M O �?� y E � O � = y E �C�FE �W��BE O � = �� �C� @ �W����

AVY E y E � ��� * � �� * � �

A O?��� �W� � E = ��� * � �� * � �

A O @ J �C�FE � OBO ��� * � �� * � �

J JR� yBA JVJ @ yB= � = � O @ J JR� Y � @ �GE =JSE � y E J E � y E E y�y�y JSE ��BE E y�y�y

@VY � y O ~B@ �VE y � @VY � y � �W� �GE @ � � E = @ � J �� �W� � A = ���5J Y@ @ O yBY @V@VY yBY � @ �W��BE @ @ O y E �5J �GE Y��Q0ON9�M 7 k 9�F�25Q K < [ 9�4�O_FUS T 8*O � � � ��� � � E y J >C8*MNON9�FH2IMTH`2�> K 254�8*ON9�McO_6 8*O^O_6�9Y[ 9�F�25Q K

F�9�[ F�9�MU9�>?ONM^OP6�9G4�8:;I4�S�;�8*OU9 K 4�9�>0ON9�F Q*X�8 K QRS . ;59�OnM_[�;525ONON2�>�V�y �YS TC. 9�F�M^2�>z[ 80F�9�>?OP6�9�MN9�MnM_6�Q*|O_6�9W9 ��9�4�ONM�Q:X�8*MUM_S T 2�>�V 8Cw*8*;�S�9�Q:X � Q?OP6�9�FnOP6 8?> � � E XbQRFcO_6�9�2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K [ 9�8VH%y

� 13Q K 9W2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K).0/ @CB�D�F�259�>x9�O 8*;by ���?� O y ��Q?OgQ . MN9�F�w?9 K 2�>xO_6�9 C ?nf K 8*OP8`MU9�O�y

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> MP[ 9�4�O_FNS T Q*X=k � E � = = ~ �� � �FO M�4�8?> >�Q?O�~�8*O�O_6�25M�[ Q?2�>0O�~ . 9WFNS�;59 K Q�S�On4�QR>�4�;�S�MN25w?9�; / y

� � � � � �C+� �L�����C�+#��:4�� ,t�Z#+! ���" � !��W��1 � ' K K

j%QRF O_6�9gX Q�S F�O_6CON2 T 9?~�|�9�9�>�4�QRS >0ON9�F�8`k C di|�25O_6 8W;52 H*9�; / [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�Vz>�9�8?FQ= � MU9�4�QR> K M�y J M

|�25O_6Ck � = � @ � ~�ONQ T 8*2�>0O_8*2�>z8W[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V�MNQY4�;IQ0MN9�ONQYO_6 8*O Q*X OP6�9nX\8?F^6�Q?OUON9�F=k � �?� A � ~?k � E � =V=

T S�MNO . 9 T Q�F�9 T 8:MNMN25w?9?y^o�X+O_6�9G[ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�V`25M^9�w?9�>�M_6�QRF�OU9�F � � O M 25O T S�MNO . 9 T QRFH9 T 8*MUMN25w?9�MNON25;5; y

D�8*MN9 K QR> 9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F /T Q K 9�;IM���MN9�9 � A yB@ ~?O_6�9WO�|�Q`w*8*;�S�9�M Q:X �� K 2IMU4�S�MNMN9 K 8 . Q*w?9Y2 T [�; / 8 T 8*MNM

XbQRF=k � E � = =�Q*X�9�25O_6�9�F EBO?� � EBE J � � �"XbQRF �� � = ���� M QRF ��BEVE � EBE?� � � �"XbQRF �� � �FO =gM y �

f�6�9W;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25ON259�MY4�QRFNF�9�MP[ QR> K 2�>�VzONQCO_6�9�MU9WOu|�Q T 8*MNM�FN8?>�V?9�M�8?F�9 A = � = �� � � 80> K �� A � E�� � �

F�9�M_[ 9�4�ON25w?9�; / y ?�25O_6�9�FcMNQ?;�S�ON25QR> T 8VH:9�MGk � E � = =WO_6�9 T Q?MNO T 8*MNMU2Iw09 8?> K ;I9�8:MNO�2 >0O_F�2�>�MN254�8*;5; / ;�S T 2�>�QRS�M

� C �Y2�FYMNO_8?FGH�>�Q*| >+y�f�6�25MWF�9�M_S�;5O`6 8*MY2 T [ QRF�OP8?>?Og4�QR>�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�MWXbQRF�O_6�9�476 8?FU8*4�ON9�F�Q*XnOP6�9`4�Q�Q?;52 >�V

T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T MWF�9�M_[ QR>�MN2 . ;59`XbQRF�OP6�9WMNO_8?F�B MG4�Q�>?ON2�>�S�2�>�V 9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>+~ 8*M�|�9 K 25MN4�S�MNMW2�>Aeg6 8?[�ON9�F O y�#�+4 6?>=/3<./"E A�UD/3<�2K1)/ �� ��8D6?>�/�STE$N � ST/ UE 2 <.<RST< �T/ <.<�6?>=2KB � ) ��� V�� �25S B'8=6?>�ST<RST< ��/ �TA59 6?>�/"E&S B�STE";�E E 2 <.< 4 AK1

2 ��� ��9R>DST6./"U�9R251.4 2KB=U <?;�NDN�A51)6.< AK;D1�STU�/)BD6?S ��@32 6?STA�B ��� � V

Page 82: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

O?�

f 8 . ;59 J yBY < S TzT 80F / Q:X �n8?F�2�8 . ;59zk C d k^8?FN8 T 9�OU9�F�M

�Y8 T 9 ;IQ0V�P � ��� � � P ��� � � � � � � � ��� � e � A E � � OBE �VE � � E HR{ @ @ � E @ E AVA � EBE @ � = = @�M

k � �?� A � Y =V= � EBE O �+J � � E HR{ = @ � E = E AVY � EBE � = � A � E�� M

k � = � @ � Y >O Y � E�� = � A � � E HR{ ��BE � E = E BO � � EBE = = � BO � E J M

k � E � =V= Y E� Y � E�� A �VE � � E HR{ E Y � E = E BO?� � EBE J = � �� � E J M

� � � ��� �'��()% �I��() �� �

C 9`6 8�w09�>�Q*| K 25MN4�S�MNMN9 K XbQRS F�k C dWMgO_6 8*O / 259�; K 9 K ONQ 8*MNOU9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q0;IQ0V?254�8*;�MN4�FNS�OU2 > / ~+k � �0� A � ~

k � = � @ � ~+k � E � =V= ~�80> K OP6�9z4�9�>?OPFN8*; MNO_8?FYQ*X�O_6�9z[�;�8?>�9�O_8?F / >�9 . S�;�8 � � e � A E � y C�9CM_S TzT 80F�2 ��9

O_6�9W[ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F�MnQ:X�OP6�9�MN9�XbQRS FcMNO_80F�M^2�>f=8 . ;59 J y>Y y J ;5; MP6�Q(| [ 8*ONON9�FU>�MGQ:X�9�a S 8*;�[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�VCw?9�F /

4�;5Q?MN9 ONQ = � M�yAf�6�25MC2IMz83F�9 T 80FIH�8 . ;59 O_F�9�> K ~ QRF T QRFH9 8*4�4�S FN8*OU9�; / 8AF�9 T 80FIH�8 . ;59;�8*4+H3Q*X 8OPF�9�> K��

o�X�O_6�9�MN9CMNO_80F�M�XbQ?;5;5Q*| O_6�9z> 8?FNF�Q*| T 8*MNM K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR> Q . MN9�F�w09 K 2�>3|Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?FuXnMNO_8?F�M�~�O_6�9�> [ 9�F�25Q K

M_[ 8*4�2�>�V325MC9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K ONQA2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9 |g2IOP6 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN2�>�V ����� 8*M�O_6�9 / 9�w?Q?;5w?9 XZFHQ T O_6�9 . ; S�9OUQAO_6�9F�9 K

9 K V?9Q*XYO_6�9 2�>�MNOP8 . 25;I25O / MNO_FH2 [+y�@ . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�> 8*;5; / ~gO_6�25MC2IM >�Q?OCO_6�9 4�8:MN9?y)o > O_6�9 >�9+"�OC476 80[�ON9�F�~^|�9

K 25MN4�S�MNMYO_6�9 K 9�9�[x2 T [�;52I4�8:ON25QR>�MWQ*X^O_6�25M�4�S F�25QRS�MWF�9�M_S�;5O�y

Page 83: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

O?�

�� ���!�7��� � ���$�� � � �$ �!����� �F��� �� ����� � � � �D��� �F� �

� ������ � � ����� � � ����� ��� � �

�?���"�3�0�����3���)� �1 �: ���.� -�%'���3���2(D��-/��+��% 9%'���" ����(1#$; ���"�)��� %'+����3����� �������)���"� � ��� � #G� � ���(����)���� ��� �3-:F�"���(��������� � � �������14����"���2������� %'+���!"����;=����#G;����5%0���2�������( ��� :,�����( ��D�� �2#*# ��������1��� %'��� 436

7 h�25476 8?F KAJ y�knF�Q�4�ONQRFv~�� ��1�"��� �2��#G�5%0��D�2� � �D�F%�@3A5B��FE

� ��� �������� "!$#&%'��() ��

dW9�MP[�2IOU9 O_6�9Y|�9�8*;5O_6 Q*X=[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> 8*; K 8*O_8�8�w(8*25;�8 . ;59`ONQCS�M�2 > MNO_S K / 2�>�VzO_6�9Yw(8?FH2 8 . ;I9`k C dWM�~?O_6�9 /

6 8�w?9 MNQX\8?FCF�9�MN25MNON9 K 4�QR6�9�F�9�>0OzV?9�>�9�FU8*;52 ��8:ON25QR>�MzQ*X�O_6�9�2�FCVRFHQRS [)[ FHQR[ 9�F�OU2I9�M�y�< S�476 8x4�; 8:MNMN2E]�4�8*ON25QR>

25M�F�9�a S�2�F�9 K XbQRFWS > K 9�F�MNOP8?> K 2�>�Vt[ Q?MNMN2 . ;59 K F�25wR2�>�V T 9�476 8?>�25M T M`QRFY9+" [�;�8*2�>�2 >�V O_6�9CQ . MN9�F�w?9 K [ 9�F�25Q K

K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR>+y�}Y>?ON25;�>�Q*|`~*O_6�9g9�FNF�QRF�M . 8?F�M�8*MNMNQ�4�2�8*ON9 K |�25O_6 K 9�OU9�F T 2�> 8*ON25QR> Q*X T 8*MNM�~*;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / ~ 8?> K

� ��� XbQRF�8CV?25w?9�>xw(8?F�2�8 . ;59�MNO_8?F�MP[ 8?> >�9 K 8CMU2IV�>�2�]�4�80>?OgXZFU8*4�ON25QR> Q*X^O_6�9W2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_FH2 [+y

?�w?9�> V?25w?9�>xO_6�9`;52 T 25ON9 K 2�>0X QRF T 8*ON25QR>[ F�Q*w�2 K 9 Kt.0/ M_[ 9�4�O_FHQ?MN4�QR[�254 K 9�OU9�F T 2�> 8*ON25QR>�MWQ*X^;5Q?V�PA8?> K

�����=~ T 80> / 8*OUON9 T [�ONMW6 8�w?9 . 9�9�> T 8 K 9�OUQzXbQRF T 8 4�QR6�9�F�9�>0OWO_6�9�QRF / Q*XGOP6�9�2 FW[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>�M�yC< [ 9�4�O_F�Q R

MN4�QR[�254�8*;5; / ~cO_6�9 k � �?� A � MNO_8?F�M`80F�9 K 9P] >�9 Kl.0/ OP6�9 8?[ [ 9�80FN8?>�4�9 Q*X�;I2�>�9�MzQ:Xgmg9�o�oN~^e�o ��~ 8?> K @�� o

�b8?> K MNQ T 9�ON2 T 9�M � � 2�> O_6�9�2�FCM_[ 9�4�O_FN8 y3<�O_8?FUF ]�9�; K 9�Oz8*;by � ���?� J [ F�QR[ Q?MN9 K O_6 8*O`OP6�9�MN9 MUO_8?F�MC8?F�9

K F�25w?9�> .0/ 4 / 4�;I254�8*;�25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR>tQ*XGe 8?> K @Cy�m�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~%O_6�9�2�FW[ F�QR[ Q?M_8*; M_S ��9�F�MYX\F�Q T O_6�9 K 2 � 4�259�>�4 /

O_6 8*OY8 mg9 T 8*MNM�X\FN8*4�OU2IQ�>Q*XnQR>�; / �FE�� 2�>�O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9C|�25;5; � [ Q?25MNQ�> �Ae��?@ K FH2Iw�2�>�V�y J >�Q0O_6�9�F

[ F�Q . ;59 T 2IM�O_6�9C9+"R25MNOU9�>�4�9zQ*X >�Q�> Ru[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�VAMNOP8?F�MW|�25O_6�2�>3O_6�9CMNOPF�2�[3|�25O_63>�9�8?F�; / 2 K 9�>?ON254�8*;cM_[ 9�4�OPFN8

ONQCO_6�9`[ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M � C 9�FN>�9�F ���?� A y�13QRFH9 [ F�9�4�25MN9�Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M�4�80> ] > K M_S . ON;59 K 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�9�M . 9�O�|�9�9�>

O_6�9z[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M`8?> K >�QR> Ru[ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�M�y�j�Q�F�2�>�MNO_80>�4�9?~�d`F�9�2 ��;59�F � ���?�?� ] > K M ��� 2�>3O_6�9CM_[ 9�4�O_FN8 Q*X�8*;5;

O_6�9W[ S�;5M_8*ONQRFHM . S�O�QR>�; / MNQ T 9YQ*X=OP6�9 >�QR> Ru[ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�M�ycobO�F�9 T 8*2�>�M�ONQ . 9YMN9�9�> 2EX^O_6�9�MN9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�9�MY8?F�9

2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O�y

Page 84: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

Y E

{W8�|�8*;59�F � ���?� O M_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8:O [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> 4�8?> 8*;5MNQ3O_6�9�QRFH9�ON254�8*;5; / 80F�25MN9 2�> k C dWMCw�2�83O_6�9 ; 8:MNO

F�9 T > 80>?ONMgQ*XG>RS�4�;59�8?F . S FN>�2�>�VO_6 8*O T 25VR6?OYMNON25;5; O_8VH*9`[�;�8*4�9C2�>�O_6�9�2�F�9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9�M�y f�6�25MY2IM`FH9PX 9�FNFH9 K ONQ

8*MYO_6�9 � T 9�476 8?>�25M T y oZO 4�80>QR>�; / |�9�8VH0; /K F�25w?9CO_6�9C;5Q(|�9�MNOgQRF K 9�F P R T Q K 9�M�~+6�Q*|G9�w09�F�~�8?> K�T Q K 9�M

|�25O_6xO_6�9�MN9`[ 9�FH2IQ K MW6 8�w09`>�Q?O . 9�9�>xMN9�9�>+y

13QRFH9 FH9�4�9�>?ON; / ~ < 8*25Q � ���?�VO 8?> K � 8?S�ONMN4�6 / � ���0� Y [ F�QR[ Q?MN9 KzK FH2Iw�2�>�V .?/ 8 �PT 9�O_8*;5;5254�2IO / . S T [+~ �

| 6�9�F�9 O_6�9 QR[ 8*4�25O /3K 9�F�25w(8*ON25w?94�6 8?>�V?9�MCMN25VR> K S�9 ONQAO_6�9[ F�9�MN9�>�4�9 Q*X T 9�O_8*;5M`M_S�4�6 8*M`2�F�QR> 2�> O_6�9

9�>0w?9�;5QR[ 9?yf�6�25M`25Mz8�W T 9�476 80>�2IM T MN2 T 25;�8?F�ONQO_6 8*O�4�S FNF�9�>0ON; / O_6�QRS�VR60OWONQ K F�25w?9 [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>�2�> O_6�9

T 8*2�> MN9�a S�9�>�4�9 � Ru<�4�S�ON2 w*8?F�2�8 . ;59�M�y } >0XbQRF�OPS > 8*ON9�; / ~�O_6�9�2�F FU8*O_6�9�FC4�FNS K 9 T Q K 9�;IM8?F�92�>�4�QR>�MU2IMUON9�>?O

|�25O_6�O_6�9C9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / MNO_8*O_S�MYQ*XGk � �?� A � MNO_80F�M�yY13QRF�9`2 T [ QRF�O_80>?ON; / ~�O_6�9�2�FW[ 9�F�25Q K MNO_FNS�4�OPS F�9�M K Q

>�Q?O T 8*ON4�6zO_6�9�C ?nf Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M K 9�MN4�F�2 . 9 K 2�>Aeg6 8?[�ON9�F�M�@ 8?> K J y

C 25O_6 MNQ T 8?> / K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 8*; K F�25wR2�>�V T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T M�~RMUO_F�254�ON9�Fc4�QR>�MNO_FU8*2�>?ONM�QR> O_6�9YQ . MN9�F�w R

8 . ;59C4�QR> K 25ON25QR>�M`Q:XGO_6�9C[ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�M`80> K >�Q�> Ru[ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�M`80F�9 . 8 K ; / >�9�9 K 9 K y`f�6�9 T Q0MNO 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9C|�8 /

ONQ�O_6�2�>zO_6�9WFN8?> H0MnQ:X�4�Q T [ 9�ON2�>�VCO_6�9�QRFH2I9�M �b80> K [ 9�FN6 8?[�M�[ Q?2�>0O�O_6�9 |�8 / OUQ`9+" [�; 80> 8*ON25QR>�M [ F�9�w�25QRS�MN; /

S >0O_6�QRS�VR60OWQ*X 25M�ONQ Q . O_8*2�> . 9�ONON9�F H�>�Q*|�;59 K V?9zQ*X�| 6�9�>�O_6�9z[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M . 9�V?2�>�8?> K 9�> K XbQRFWk C d

MNO_80F�M�Q*X�8 V?25w?9�> T 8:MNM�y

@gX 4�QRS F�MN9?~�|�25O_6 MNQ�X 9�| MNO_8?FHMG8�w(8*25;�8 . ;59`OUQ�MUO_S K / ~�9�w?9�>z4�Q T [�;59�ON9`8*MNON9�FHQ?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V02I4�8:;�MNQ?;�S�ON25QR>�M

XbQRF 8:;I; Q*XnO_6�9 T T 25VR60O >�Q0O [ F�Q*w?9�MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0ON; / 25;5; S T 2 > 8:ON2�> V�y%?�w?9�>�2EXGO_6�9�2�FY[ F�QR[ 9�FHON259�MYX Q?;5;5Q*| F�9�4TR

Q?VR>�2 ��8 . ;59z[ 8*ONOU9�FN>�M�~%2IOY25M K 2 � 4�S�;5O�ONQzM_6�Q*|LO_6�25M 4�Q T [ 9�;5;52 >�V0; / V?25w?9�>�QR>�; / 8CXb9�| 4�8:MN9�M�y�}Y[ONQ O_6�25M

[ Q02 >0O�~+|�9z6 8�w?9 K 2IMU4�S�MNMN9 K O_6�9�2�F . 9�6 8�wR25QRFYQ�>�; / 2�>�ON9�F T MWQ:Xn2 > K 25w�2 K S 8*;�Q . r�9�4�ONM�y C 25O_638*MNON9�FHQ?MN9�25M9R

T Q?;5Q?V02I4�8:; 2�>0XbQRF T 8:ON25QR>zQ�> O_6�9 T 8*r�QRF�25O / Q:X�OP6�9`[ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�M�>�Q*|l2�>6 8?> K ~ |G9Y4�8?> ] > 8*;5; / 2 >0w?9�MNOU2IV�8*ON9

O_6�9�2�F . 9�6 8�w�25QRF�8*MY8`4�;�8*MUM�Q*X�F�9�;�8*OU9 K Q . r�9�4�ONM�y J Mg|G9WMP6�Q(| . 9�;IQ*|`~ O_6�9 w*8?F�2�8 . ;59�k � �?� A � MNOP8?F�M�8?[ R

[ 8?F�9�>0ON; /K Q X Q?;5;5Q*| 8C4�Q T [ 9�;5;I2�>�V3O_F�9�> K 7 Q�>�9�MP[ 8?> >�2�>�VO_6�9�2�F�9�>0ON2�F�9zFN8?>�V?9�Q*XnMNON9�;5;�8?FY[ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F�M�y

J > /T Q K 9�;�Q*Xnk C d [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> T S�MUOG4�Q�>0X QRF T ONQzO_6�25M�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K [ 8*ONON9�FN>+y

� � � � ���I����� !]� � � ���I���I��#&����� ��� �$! � �� �G� � ��� ��� � # ����I�� ����

� � K6� ' �L������.� �v ��(� � � ��"!�#

Ci6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX Mc9+" 6�2 . 25O�8Ww?9�F / > 8?FUF�Q*| T 8*MNM K 2IMUO_F�2 . S�ON25QR>+~ 4�9�>0ON9�F�9 K 8*On8 . QRS�O E A O � � y^o XH~0XbQRF^8

V?25w?9�> ������~�w*8?F�2�8 . ;59 k C d T 8*MNMN9�MY4�QR>0XbQRF T ONQ O_6�9�M_8 T 9 K 2IMUO_F�2 . S�ON25QR>39+" [ 9�4�ON9 K Q*XG>�Q�> R\w(8?F�2�8 . ;59�M�~

Page 85: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

Y �

O_6�9�>3|�9z8?F�9C;59 K ONQ4�9�F�O_8*2�>39+" [ 9�4�OP8*ON25QR>�M`4�Q�>�4�9�FN>�2�>�V-OP6�9 [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M�MN9�9�>32�>�OP6�9`XbQRF T 9�F�yzD�8*MN9 K

QR>�?^a S 8*ON25QR> � = yB@ ~�[ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�V �b[ F�Q�[ QRF�OU2IQ�> 8*;=OUQ � � M_6�QRS�; K 2 >�4�FH9�8*MN9 T Q�>�Q?ONQR>�254�8*;5; / 8*MWO_6�9

;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 8?> K � ��� Q*XG8 V?25w?9�>�MNO_8?F K 9�4�FH9�8*MN9?yYj�QRFg2�>�MNO_8?>�4�9zk � �0� A � ~ |g2IOP6-8 � ��� Q*X �+J E ~ EVEVE {C~

M_6�QRS�; K MN9�9`25ONM [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9 .?/ 8 . QRS�O�= E�� ~0XZFHQ T = � MYONQ!= O M�~ .0/ O_6�9`ON2 T 9W25OWF�9�8*4�6�9�M

O_6�9Y9 ��9�4�ON25w?9 OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9YQ*X=k � E � =V= 7 � E ~ EVEVE {Cy�o\> Q?OP6�9�F^|�QRF K M�~0O_6�9gXZ8?FHO_6�9�Fnk � E � =V= B M�[ 9�F�25Q K

M_[ 8*4�2�>�V25MYX\F�Q T = O M�~%O_6�9�XZ80F�O_6�9�F�25MW25ONM T 8*MUM�X\F�Q T OP6 8*O Q:XGk � �?� A � y�o\>xXZ8:4�O�O_6�9�MN9CO�|�QzQ . r�9�4�ONM�~

F�9�[ F�9�MU9�>?ON2�>�VCO_6�9 6�25VR6 8?> K ;5Q*| � ��� 9+"�O_F�9 T 9�M^Q*X�O_6�9 � C �Y2 FcMNOP8?F�M�~?6 8�w?9�8*; T Q?MUOn9+" 8*4�ON; / O_6�9 %/�� ��[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V K 9�M_[�25ON939�>�QRF T QRS�M K 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�9�M 2�> ; S T 2 >�Q0MN25O / 80> K ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9?ylj%QRFCk � E � =V= ~

25ONM`;5Q*| � � � [ S�MP6�9�M�25O�ONQ*| 80F K ;IQ�>�V?9�F�� � O_6�25M T S�MNO . 9zQ ��MN9�O .0/ 8A6�25VR6�9�F T 8*MNM�y�C 2IOP63M_S�4�6�8

MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0O�� ��� K 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�9?~*O_6�9 T 8*MNM K 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�9 . 9�O�|�9�9�>`k � E � = =G80> K k � �?� A � T S�MUO . 9cMN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>?O

8*;5MNQ�~%8?> K 25O 25M�s E BO?� ��� w09�F�M_S�M E A � ���cy

f |GQgMNO_8?F�M�|�25O_6C8�4�Q?2�>�4�2 K 9�>0OG[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V 7 K 9�M_[�25ON9�|�2 K 9�; /CK 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T 8*MUM�8?> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 78?F�9�MN2 T [�; / 4�S F�25QRS�M�yco\> XZ8:4�On8*;5;�X QRS F^k C dWM=|�25O_6CF�9�;�8*OU2Iw09�; / 4�9�F�O_8*2�>C[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V K 9�ON9�F T 2�> 8*ON25QR>�M

6 8�w?9�O_6�9�M_8 T 9�M_[ 8:4�2 >�VWOUQW|�25O_6�2�>!=YM�~*QRF �FE � y=f�6�25Mc2 >�4�;�S K 9�M�O_6�9�4�9�>0O_FN8*;�MNO_8?F Q:X � � e � A E � ~�| 6�254�6

6 8*Mz8;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / Q*w?9�FWO_6 FH9�9zQRF K 9�F�MCQ*X T 8:VR>�25O_S K 9 ;�8?FHV?9�F�O_6 8?>3O_6 8:O`Q*X k � E � =V=8?> K 6�9�>�4�9A8?>

9�w?9�>3;5Q*|�9�F T 8*MNMWOP6 8?>�k � �?� A � 2�>34�Q T [ 8?F�25MNQR>+y j^2IV�S F�9�A y � M_6�Q*|�MWO_6�9 T 8*MNMWw?9�FHM_S�M`;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O /

XbQRF�O_6�9�HR>�Q*| > � C � 2�FCMUO_8?F�Mz[�;�S�M � � e � A E � ~ . 8*MN9 K QR> K 9�OU9�F T 2�> 8*ON25QR>�MzQ:X �� [ F�9�MN9�>0ON9 K 2�>

e�6 8?[�OU9�F�M!@�8?> K J y��bk � � Y E Y�25Mz2�>�4�;�S K 9 K 8*MCO_6�9QR[ 9�> 4�2�F�4�;59?~�MN2�>�4�9�2IOUM [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V 2IM >�Q?O

] F T ; / 9�MNOP8 . ;52IMP6�9 K y

j^25VRS FH9 A yB= M_6�Q*|�M�O_6�9c2 T [�;I254�8*OU2IQ�>�MnQ*X O_6�9GS . 25a S�25ONQRS�M = � R^= =�M=MP[ 8*4�2�>�VYX QRF�O_6�9n2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / � MUO_F�2�[ �

2�>�O_6�9W;5Q?V!P ;5Q?V�� � � [�; 80>�9?y�f�6�9`Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�> 8*;�FH9�V?25QR>Q*X^2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / 6 8*MYM_6 FNS > H MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0ON; / y oZO

9+" 6�2 . 25ONM M_S�476 8MUO_F�2 H?2�>�V3MN;5QR[ 9 2�> O_6�9C]�V�S F�9 OP6 8*O�~=S >�;52 H*9 T Q0MNO`Q?OP6�9�FW2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / F�9�V02IQ�>�M�2�> O_6�9

m Ruh K 2�8*VRFN8 T ~R25O�4�8?> >�QC;IQ�>�V?9�F . 9`FH9PX 9�F�9 K ONQz8*4�4�S FN8:ON9�; / 8*M�8?> 2 >�MUO_8 . 25;52IO / MNOPF�2�[ ��2�>zON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9

8*O�8*;5; y �g9�w?9�F�O_6�9�;59�MNM�~ |G9g|�25;I;�4�QR>?OU2 >�S�9WONQCF�9PX 9�FcONQCO_6�9WF�9�V?25QR> Q*X=2�>�MNOP8 . 25;I25O / [�2I4�OPS F�9 K 2�> j^25VRS F�9 A yB=

8*M�O_6�9 � C �Y2 F � 2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNOPF�2�[ �A|�25O_63OP6�9 S > K 9�F�MNO_80> K 2 >�V3O_6 8:OWO_6�9z9 ��9�4�ON25w?9 ON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9�MWQ*X

O_6�9`F�9 K 8?> KA. ;�S�9C9 K V?9�M 8?F�9`6�25VR6�; /�K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>0O QR> ;5Q?V�P���Q�F � y

Ci6 / M_6�QRS�; K O_6�9Yk C dl2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / MNO_FH2 [C8?[ [ 80F�9�>?OU; / MNOPFN8 K K ;59�8Y;I2�>�9YQ*X�80[ [ F�Q "R2 T 8*OU9�; / 4�QR>�MNO_80>?O

[ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V ���gQRF T 8*;5; / ~+O_6�9�QRFH2IMUONMWMN9�8?F�4�6 XbQRFg9+" [�;�8?> 8:ON25QR>�MYX Q�F�O_6�9CQ . MU9�F�w?9 K-. QRS > K 8?F�259�M ��O_6�9

Page 86: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

YV=

j^25VRS F�9%A y � p�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / w?9�F�MPS�M T 8*MNM K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K XZF�Q T [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> K 8*O_8 XbQRF�O_6�9 H�>�Q*| >� C � 2�F3MNOP8?F�M-[�;�S�M O_6�9lk � ��� � � e � A E � y fg6�9 QR[ 9�>L4�2�F�4�;59 FH9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONMk � � Y E Y ~:X Q�F�| 6�25476xO_6�9`[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�MNOPFNS�4�O_S F�9Y25M S >�4�9�F�OP8*2�>+y

F�9 K 8?> KA. ;�S�9W9 K V?9�M Q*X�8?> 2�>�MNOP8 . 25;I25O / MNO_FH2 [ 2�> O_6�9 . 9�6 8�wR25QRF�Q:X�8C[ F�QR[ Q0MN9 K [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> T 9�476 80>�2IM T y

f�6 8*O . 9�6 8�wR25QRF�2IM K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K.?/ O_6�9�O_6�9�F T 8*;�[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�MnQ:X�8`k C d MUO_8?F�~�| 6�25;59W2IOUMn[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V

25M K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9 Kz.?/ 25ONM T 9�476 8?>�254�8*; MUO_FNS�4�O_S F�9?y o\> K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8*ON9cQRF�>�9�8?FH; /WK 9�V09�>�9�FN8*ON9cMNO_8?F�M�~�O_6�9nOP6�9�F T 8*;

[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M 8?FH9 K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K .?/ OP6�9 25QR>�M�~�| 6�25;I9OP6�9 T 9�4�6 8?>�254�8*;�MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9 2IM K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 Kl.0/ O_6�9

K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8:ON9W9�;59�4�O_F�QR>�M�~%8?> K >�QRF T 8:;I; / O_6�9WO�|�Q�80F�9WM_8�Xb9�; / O_FH9�8*ON9 K 8*M�MN9�[ 8?FU8*ON9?~�25MNQ?;�8*ON9 K M / MNON9 T M�yno�X

O_6�9G= � R^= =�Mn[ 9�F�25Q K MP[ 8*4�2�>�V`25MnMNQ T 9�6�Q*| 8 � �3��� � � �1� %'���� X QRF [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>+~�O_6�9�>�O_6�25M^2 T [�;5259�M 8?>�2�>?OU2 T 8*ON9

4�QR> >�9�4�ON25QR> . 9�O�|�9�9�>O_6�9 T 9�476 8?>�254�8*; Q?MN4�25;5;�8*ON25QR>�MW8?> K OP6�9WO_6�9�F T 8*;�[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�> T 9�476 8?>�25M T y

fg6�9 8:;IOU9�FN> 8*ON25w?9�25McO_6 8*O O_6�9 T 8*MUM9R\;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / FH9�; 8:ON25QR>�M_6�2�[ 8:;IQ�>�VWO_6�9�2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_F�2�[C25M^4�8?S�MU9 K

.0/ MNQ T 9 Q0O_6�9�F�[ F�QR4�9�MUM 7 QRF�4�Q TC. 2�> 8*ON25QR> Q:X�[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M 7 | 6�254�638?[ [ F�Q "R2 T 8:ON9�; / 4�Q?2�>�4�2 K 9�MW|�25O_6 O_6�9

F�9�;�8*ON25QR>�MP6�2 [ O_6 8*OzV?Q*w?9�FU>�MzO_6�9-[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V%y o\> O_6�25M4�8*MN9?~�MNQ T 9 T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T T S�MNOzM_6�S�O Q �

Q . MN9�FHw(8 . ;59-[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> 2 > ;5Q(| T 8*MNMzk C dWM . 9PX Q�F�9O_6�9 / F�9�8*4�6 ;5Q*|'ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S F�9?~�8?> K K 9�;�8 / Q . R

Page 87: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

YV@

5.2 5 4.88.2

8

7.8

7.6

7.4

7.2

j^25VRS F�9%A y>= k QRF�ON25QR> Q*X=OP6�9W;IQ0V�P ;IQ0V � � � [�;�8?>�9�M_6�Q*|�2�>�V k C dL9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / O_FN8:4 H0M . 8*MN9 KQR>o\< }�? �Y@Cy�f�6�9Y9�FNF�QRF . Q "�9�M�XbQRFc9�8*476 MUO_8?F K 9�FH2Iw09WX\F�Q T [ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V 4�Q T R. 2�>�9 K |g2IOP6 M_[ 9�4�O_FHQ?MN4�QR[�254�8*;5; /AK 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K � � � y

MN9�F�w*8 . ;59 [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>t2 > 6�2IV�6�9�F T 8*MNM`k C dWMWS >0ON25;^O_6�9 / F�9�8:476x;IQ*| ON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9?y+* C�9C|�25;5;^9+" [�;5QRFH9

T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T MY| 6�25476 T 9�9�O�O_6�9�MU9W4�F�25ON9�F�2�8z2�> � A y J y

� � K6� K �Y� �(�"!��:.� �v ��(� � � ��"!�#

fg6�9^Q?O_6�9�F+4�;59�8?F�Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> 8*;�O_F�9�> K 9+" 6�2 . 25ON9 K .0/ O_6�9�k C dl[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M�|�8*M�2�>0O_F�Q K S�4�9 K 2�> � @ y J s

O_6�9�2�F^[ 9�FH2IQ K M K 9�4�FH9�8*MN9�|�25O_6 K 9�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�V`;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / � 2 >�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�V`M_S FuXZ8*4�9cVRFN8�w�2IO / y+j^25VRS F�9GA yB@gM_6�Q*|�M

O_6�9�;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / w?9�F�M_S�M K Q T 2�> 8?>0OG[ 9�F�25Q K XbQRF^OP6�9�M_8 T 9gMNO_8?F�M X\F�Q T j^25VRS F�9�A y � y=f�6�9YO_F�9�> K 8?[ [ 8?F�9�>0O

2�> O_6�9C]�VRS FH9 25MC2�> T 8?FIH*9 K 4�QR>?OPFN8*MNOWONQ3O_6�9 QR>�9 MU9�9�>�2�> O_6�9 � �le 9�ON2nMNOP8?F�M�~�| 6�25476 M_6�Q*| ;IQ�>�V?9�F

[ 9�FH2IQ K MY|�25O_6z;5Q*|�9�F � � � y^h�9�4�8*;5;�O_6 8*O�O_6�9 � �3e�9�ON2�[ 9�F�25Q K O_FH9�> K 2IMY8`4�Q�>�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9WQ:X=O_6�9Y476 8?>�V02 >�V

O_6�9�F T 8*;nON2 T 9�MU4�8*;59 2�> O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��Q�>�9?~=|Y6�2I4�6 MN2�> H0M K 9�9�[ 9�F���ONQ�;5QR>�V?9�F�ON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M 8*M�O_6�9 MNO_8?F,.H /�;=<./"6?>=/�ND>�1)2 <./ L?A �=<./�1 �52 � �T/"N�; �T<.2�6?STA5B�WM6.A S B=U ST@ 2�6./&6?>�2 6IN�A�<.<?S�� �T/ <.A� ;�6?STA5B�<0E$S�K>D6R1)/3<?STUD/ S B <.A E / @3A E �DS B=2KP

6?STAKB A54 A �=<./�1 �52�6?STA5B�2�R<./ �T/ @36?STAKB / � /3@ 6.<�2 <�9R/ ��� 6?>=/ S BD6?1.S B=<?ST@ � /�>�2��STA51&AK4 2 U 1.S���S B E /3@.>�25B�ST<.EMV

Page 88: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

Y J

j^25VRS F�9%A y>@ p�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / � K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9 K S�MN2�>�VAOP6�9 [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> K 8:O_8 w?9�F�M_S�M K Q T 2 > 80>?OC[ 9�F�25Q KX Q�FYO_6�9-H�>�Q*| > � C �Y2�FWMNO_80F�M�[�;�S�MCO_6�9 k������ � � e � A E � yzf�6�9 QR[ 9�>34�2�F�4�;59F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ONM k � � Y E Y ~0X Q�Fn|Y6�2I4�6OP6�9`[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>�MNO_FNS�4�OPS F�9W25M S >�4�9�F�O_8*2�>+y

4�Q�Q?;5M�y�o�XnO_6�9�M_8 T 9W9 ��9�4�O K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9�MWO_6�9`[ 9�F�25Q K MW2�> � C �Y2�F 8?> K k � � � MUO_8?F�M�~ O_6�9�>j^25VRS F�9�A yB@

T 25VR60O�2 > K 254�8*OU9WO_6 8*OnOP6�9 K F�25w�2�>�V ��QR>�9 . 9�4�Q T 9�M T QRF�9�MP6 8*;5;IQ*| |�25O_6 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN2�>�V ��� �=y C 9 |�25;5;�M_6�Q*|

O_6 8*OYO_6�25M`25M`>�Q?OWOP6�9�4�8:MN9`2�>�k C d T Q K 9�;5M�y C�9C4�QR>�4�;�S K 9 O_6 8*OYMNQ T 9CQ?OP6�9�F T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T T S�MUO . 9

F�9�M_[ QR>�MN2 . ;59�X QRF MN9�ONON2�>�VzO_6�9 K Q T 2�> 8?>?OW[ 9�FH2IQ K 2�>�k C d w(8?FH2 8 . ;I9�M�y

J F�9WO_6�9�O_F�9�> K M�MU9�9�>2�>j^25VRS F�9�M A y � O_6 FHQRS�VR6�A yB@ F�9�;�8*ON9 K ��f�Qz9+" [�;IQ�F�9`O_6�25MYa S�9�MUON25QR>2�> K 9�OP8*25; ~

|�9 K 9�w?9�;5QR[ 9 K 8�>�9�|lMN9�OcQ*X�k C d 9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F /zT Q K 9�;IM�~R|Y6�2I4�6 |G9gM_S TzT 8?FH2 ��9g2 > O_6�9 >�9+"�OnMU9�4�ON25QR>+y

o\>tO_6�9�] > 8*;=MU9�4�ON25QR>3Q*XnO_6�25M�476 8?[�OU9�F�|�9z8?> 8*; / ��9zO_6�9 . 9�6 8�w�2IQ�FYQ*X K F�25w�2�>�V���QR>�9�MW2�>�k C d T Q K 9�;IM

2�>;525VR60O Q*X 7 8?> K ONQ MN9�9FH 80> 9+" [�;�8?> 8*OU2IQ�>XbQRF 7 OP6�9WO_F�9�> K M^rNS�MNO K 25MN4�S�MNMU9 K y

Page 89: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

YVA

� ��� � � ��� � � � � � � ��� �&( � � �&� �R� ����0 ��)# ��() �� �:� � � "!'� � �

f�Q S > K 9�F�MUO_8?> K O_6�9nw*8?F�25QRS�M O_F�9�> K M^S >�4�Q*w?9�F�9 K 2�>�O_6�9�6�Q?O�[ S�;5M_8:ON2�>�V`k C dWM�~�|�9G80[ [ 9�8*;�ONQ�MNOU9�;I;�8?F

T Q K 9�;5M�yW13Q K 9�;5M`6 8�w?9 . 9�9�>39�MNMU9�>?ON2�8*; XbQRFg9+" [�;5Q?25ON2�>�V�O_6�9CMN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V?254�8*;^Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�Q*Xn2�> K 2Iw�2 K S 8*;

MNO_80F�M�y+j�Q�F�O_6�25M |�QRFIH%~�O_6�Q�S�VR6+~�|�9�>�9�9 K 9 K T Q K 9�;5M^Q*w?9�F+O_6�9�FN8?>�V?9cQ*X O_6�9 � C � 2�F�MNON9�;5;�8?F^[ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F�M

Q*X T 8*MNM 8?> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / yi@WS Fz[ F�2�>�4�2�[ 8*;W4�Q T [ S�O_8:ON25QR> 8*;�ONQ�Q?;�25M OP6�9MNON9�;5;�8?Fz9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>l[ F�Q0VRFN8 T

o\< }�? �Y@C~�| 6�25476 25M K 9�MN4�FH2 . 9 K 2�> MNQ T 9 K 9�O_8*25; .0/ dW9�6 >�9�F � ���?�VO � MN9�9�8*;5MNQ)dW9�6 >�9�F � {W8�|�8*;59�F

���?� A y o < }�? � @ 25M`8 � MNOP8?> K 8?F K � MNON9�;5;�8?FY9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>t4�Q K 9CO_6 8*OY25MWQR[�ON2 T 2 ��9 K X QRFgO_6�9C4�QR>�MNOPFNS�4�ON25QR>

Q*X T Q K 9�;IMYQ*Xnk C dWM�8?> K | 6�25ON9 K | 80F X M�y

fg6�9^MN9�9 KzT Q K 9�;:X QRF�O_6�9 T Q K 9�;5M�S�MU9 K 2�>�O_6�25M=MN9�4�OU2IQ�>W|�8*M�V?9�>�9�FU8*ON9 K |�25O_6�o\< }�? � @ .0/ 9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>

Q*X�8%@ � � T Q K 9�;�XZF�Q T O_6�9��+9�F�Q J V?9�1�8*2�>z<�9�a S�9�>�4�9YO_6 F�QRS�VR6 O_6�9�O_6�9�F T 8*;5; / [ S�;5MN2�>�V J � D)[ 6 8:MN9?y

J X ON9�F�F�9�8*4�6�2 >�VW8�MNOP8 . ;59nO_6�9�F T 8*;5; / [ S�;5MN2�>�VWMNOP8*V?9 �b8 . QRS�O � AcO_6�9�F T 8*;R[ S�;5MN9�M ~ T 8*MNM�;5Q?MUM�|�8*M�2�>?w0Q H*9 K

S >0ON25;^O_6�9 T Q K 9�;c9�w?Q?;5w?9 K ONQA6�25VR63OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9�M�y`fg6�2IM T Q K 9�; �bF�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0ON2�>�VA8k � � 6 8 K 8 ] > 8*;

T 8*MUM�Q*X E AVYV@ � � ~ 8?> K 8z6�9�;52�S T RuF�25476�QRS�OU9�F�;�8 / 9�F�y

f�Q3Q . O_8*2�> MN9�;EX R\4�Q�>�MN25MNON9�>0O T Q K 9�;5Mz|�25O_6�2�> 8�M T 8*;5;�FN8?>�V09Q*X T 8*MNMN9�M�~^|�9 S�MN9 K OP6�9 E AVYV@ ���

T Q K 9�;b~�8?> K MN4�8*;59 K OP6�9 T 8*MNMzS [ Q�F K Q*| >+y j%QRF�9+" 8 T [�;I9?~�OUQ-Q . O_8*2�> 8 T Q K 9�; 8*O EBO E � � ~n|�9

MN4�8*;59 K 8*;5; [ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F�M .?/ O_6�9 X\8*4�ONQRF EBOVE � E AVY @ X QRF 8?> 2�>�2IOU2 8:; T Q K 9�;bylh�9�;�8 " 8*ON25QR> ONQ O_6�9A>�9�|

4�QR> K 25ON25QR>�M�| 8:M 8*4�4�Q T [�;52IMP6�9 K .0/ O_8 H?2�>�V T 8?> / w?9�F / M_6�QRF�OYON2 T 9zMUON9�[�MW|�25O_63o\< }�? � @Cy+j%Q?;5;5Q(|g2 >�V

O_6�25M F�9�;�8 " 8*ON25QR>+~ O_6�9 9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>Q*X O_6�9 >�9�| T Q K 9�; [ F�QR4�9�9 K 9 K 8*M . 9PXbQRF�9?yno > O_6�25M�|�8 / ~?|�9`[ F�Q K S�4�9 K

T Q K 9�;5M O_6 8:O�|�9�F�9 8:M�MN2 T 25;�8?FW8*M�[ Q?MUMN2 . ;I9?~+|g2IOP6 T 8*MUM . 9�2�>�VO_6�9WQR>�; /K 2 ��9�FH9�>�4�9?y

e Q T [ 8?F�25MNQ�>Q*XnQRS Fg9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / O_FU8*4 H0MW8?> K O_FH9�> K MW|�25O_6�O_6�9C9�8?F�;5259�F T Q K 9�;^V�F�2 K M Q*X�dW9�6 >�9�F

� ���0�VO M_6�Q*|�M�w?9�F / 4�;IQ0MN9�8*V�F�9�9 T 9�>0O�~ V?25w?9�>xO_6�9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O 9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / 6�25MNONQRFH2I9�M�y�dW9�6 >�9�F�B MY2 >�25ON2�8*;

T Q K 9�;5MG|�9�F�9 K 9�F�25w?9 K X\F�Q T 8WMU2 >�V0;I9 T Q K 9�;�|�25O_6 8WMN2 T [�;52E]�9 K 2�>�2IOU2 8:; 4�Q T [ Q?MU2IOU2IQ�> [ F�Q:]�;I9?~�| 6�25;59YQRS F

T Q K 9�;5MG8?F�9YF�QRQ0ON9 K 2 > 8YMN9�;EX R\4�QR>�MU2IMUON9�>?O�9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / MN9�a S�9�>�4�9?y C�9 >�Q?OU9GOP6 8*O^O_6�9�|�QRFIH .0/ dW9�6 >�9�F

� ���0�VO 2�>�4�;�S K 9 K 9�;59 T 9�>0O_8*; K 2 �=S�MN25QR> �b[ FH2 >�4�2�[ 8*;5; /A.0/ V�FN8�wR25O_8*OU2IQ�> 8*;�MN9�OUON;52 >�V ~?| 6�25;59WO_6�9 T Q K 9�;IM�|�9

S�MN9�6�9�F�9 K 2 K >�Q?O=2�>�4�;�S K 9 K 2 �=S�MN25QR>+y C 25O_6�2�>COP6�9nON9 T [ 80FN8*O_S F�9�FN8?>�V?9cQ*X�O_6�9 � C �Y2�F MNO_8?F�M�~(6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~

O_6�9W9 ��9�4�ONM�Q*X K 2 ��S�MU2IQ�>A6 8�w?9YQR>�; / 8CM T 8*;5;+2 > � S�9�>�4�9CQR> OP6�9YX 9�8*OPS F�9�M�Q*X=O_6�9W9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>O_6 8*O�|�9W8?F�9

9+" [�;IQ�F�2�>�V�y

Page 90: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

Y O

� � � � � ���I%'��() �� � � �I%'����� � ��(��&(������ �:�$! ���'�����)#'� �R�&! �&� !]��!���� �

� � � � ' �C+��, � ��� ��&+� ���S�C�b�+��� �+#����S� � �� &Y� �%� �

o >�9+" [�;�8*2�>�2�>�VCO_6�9�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K�K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR> Q*X [ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�V�MNO_8?F�M |�25O_6CF�9�M_[ 9�4�O^ONQYMNON9�;5;�8?F^[ 8?FN8 T 9�ON9�F�M�~

|�9 T S�MUO K 2IMUON2�>�VRS�25M_6�Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR> 8*;^MN9�;59�4�ON25QR> 9 ��9�4�ONMYXZFHQ T 4�80S�MN9�M`2�>0O_F�2�>�MN254 OUQ O_6�9 Q . r�9�4�ONM S > K 9�F

MNO_S K / yW}gM_S 8*;5; / ~=S > K 9�F�MUO_8?> K 2�>�VMN9�;59�4�ON25QR>39 ��9�4�ONMY25M`8?>�2 T [ QRF�OP8?>?OW[ 8?F�OYQ*X K 9�4�Q K 2�>�VAO_6�9�M_6 8?[ 9CQ*X

O_6�9 K 2IMUO_F�2 . S�ON25QR>32�>OU9�F T MYQ*X�[ 6 / MN254�8*;^9 ��9�4�ONM�Q*XnO_6�9�;�8*ONON9�F�y�o\>�O_6�25MY4�8*MN9?~%O_6�9 . ;�S�9z8?> K F�9 K 9 K V?9�M

9+" 6�2 . 25O�8gMN2 T 25; 80F^MN;5QR[ 9�2�>CO_6�9�;5Q?V�P ;IQ0V �����z[�;�8?>�9?~ . S�O^|G9 T S�MNO^MNON25;5; MN9�[ 8?FN8:ON9nQRS�O^MU9�;I9�4�OU2IQ�>C9 ��9�4�ONM

X\F�Q T O_6�9`MP6 8?[ 9�Q*X=QR>�9�QRF . Q?O_6xQ*X=O_6�9 T y

f |GQ�Q*X=O_6�9 T Q?MUOG4�Q TzT QR> MN9�;59�4�ON25QR>9 ��9�4�ONM�9�>�4�QRS >0ON9�F�9 K 2�> MNOU9�;I;�8?Fg8*MNO_F�Q�>�Q T�/ 8?F�9 T 8*V�>�2IOPS K 9

8?> K ;I2EXb9�ON2 T 9 . 2�8*M�y f�6�9 T QRF�9nFU8?[�2 K O_6�9c9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>�O_6 F�QRS�V�6`8�[ 8?FHON254�S�; 80F^F�9�V?25QR>WQ:X O_6�9�m5Ruh K 2�8*V�FN8 T ~

O_6�93;59�MNMA;52 H*9�; / MNOP8?F�M |�25;I; . 93XbQRS > K O_6�9�F�9?y � F�9�8*OU9�Fz;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�M�O_6�9 K 2IMUO_8?>�4�9�Q*XCO_6�9

K 9�ON9�4�ON25QR> O_6 FH9�M_6�Q?; K 8?> K O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9�O_6�9�F�9�;�8*ON25w?93M_8 T [�;I9 w?Q?;�S T 9?y <�Q T 934�Q TC. 2�> 8*ON25QR> Q*XCO_6�9�MN9

9 ��9�4�ONM`|g2I;5; K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9 OP6�9 Q K K MCQ*X�] > K 2 >�V MNO_8?F�M�Q*X 8A[ 8?FHON254�S�; 80F T 8*MNM�8:O�83[ 8?F�ON254�S�;�8?FC[ Q02 >0OC2�>

O_6�9�2�Fc9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+yn@W>�9YQ*X�O_6�9 T Q?MNO^4�Q TzT QR>C|�8 / M^ONQ K 9�[�254�OGOP6�9�MN9 4�Q T�. 2�>�9 K 9 ��9�4�ONMn25M�ONQW4�QR>�MNOPFNS�4�O

8�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / XZS >�4�ON25QR>+~%| 6�254�6 2IMYMN2 T [�; / 8C[�;5Q?O�Q*X^O_6�9Y9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K >�S TC. 9�F K 9�>�MN25O / Q*X=MUO_8?F�M�[ 9�FgS >�2IO

;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / ~ . 8*MN9 K QR> 6�Q*| . F�25VR60O`O_6�9 / 8?F�9 8?> K 6�Q*| X\8*MNOWO_6�9 / 8?F�9z9�w?Q0;Iw�2�>�V�8*O K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O�OU2 T 9�M�y

j^25VRS F�9%A y J M_6�Q*|�M�MN4�6�9 T 8*ON254Y;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / XZS >�4�ON25QR>�M X QRF�k C d MNO_8?F�M�Q*X�O�|�Q K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T 8*MNMU9�M�~ . 8*MN9 K

QR>xO_6�9 T Q K 9�;IM K 9�MU4�F�2 . 9 K 2�>AOP6�9�[ F�9�w�25QRS�M MU9�4�ON25QR>A8?> K >�QRF T 8:;I2 ��9 K 8*4�4�QRF K 2 >�V ONQzOP6�9`| 6�25ON9 K | 80F X

T 8*MUM K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR> ��MN9�9CXbQRF 2 >�MUO_8?>�4�9�C�Q�Q K ���?� = y@W>�9 2 T [ QRF�O_80>?OzF�9�M_S�;5OCQ*X�O_6�25M�]�VRS F�9 25MzO_6 8*O

6�25VR6�9�F T 8*MNM T Q K 9�;5M 8*;5|�8 / M�8*4�6�2I9�w09`8CV?25w?9�>>�S T�. 9�F K 9�>�MN25O / [ 9�F�S >�25O ;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / ;�8*ON9�F �b8*On;5Q*|�9�F

�i8?> K � ��� O_6 8?>�;5Q*|�9�F T 8*MNM T Q K 9�;IM�y J ;5MNQ�~�OP6�9 >�S TC. 9�F K 9�>�MN25O / [ 9�FWS >�25O`;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�M

XbQRF�8*;5; T Q K 9�;5M 8:M�O_6�9 / 9�w?Q?;5w?9WONQz;5Q*|�9�F � ��� y

fg6�9�MN9n9 ��9�4�ONM�OUQ?V?9�O_6�9�F+2 T [�; / O_6 8*O�~ � - k C dWM�Q*X 8:;I; T 8*MNM=[ S�;5M_8:ON9�8*;5;?O_6�9n|�8 /YK Q(|Y>YONQ �VE ~ EVEVE {C~

O_6�9�> O_6�9 K 2IMUO_F�2 . S�ON25QR> Q*X H�>�Q(|Y>z[ S�;5M_8*ONQRFHMGMP6�QRS�; K . 9 M H:9�|G9 K 6�9�8�wR25; / ONQ*|�8?F K O_6�Q0MN9 |g2IOP6 . Q?OP6z;5Q*|

� ��� �2��� ;5Q*| T 8*MNM�y7C�9 K QR>+B OWMN9�9 M_S�4�6�MUO_8?F�M � O_6�S�M`O_6�9F�9 K 9 K V?9 T S�MNO`9+"�4�;�S K 9O_6�9 T X\F�Q T O_6�9

K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR>+y

Ci6�25;59O_6�9zQ . MU9�F�w?9 K F�9 K 9 K V09 8*4�OPS 8*;5; / T 8?FIH0M`O_6�9 K 25MNM_8?[ [ 9�8?FN8?>�4�9Q:Xg[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> XZFHQ T k C d

Page 91: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

YVY

j^25VRS F�9%A y J f�6�9�QRF�9�OU2I4�8:;`;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / X\S >�4�ON25QR>�M�~W;5Q?V � � � ~gXbQRF O�|GQ K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O�MN2�>�V?;59TR T 8*MNM[ QR[ S�;�8*OU2IQ�>�M Q*Xnk C d MNOP8?F�M�y

MNO_80F�M�~�MN9�;59�4�ON25QR>C9 ��9�4�ONM 476 8?>�V09nQRS F�476 80>�4�9�M^Q*X ] > K 2�>�V�6�25VR6 R T 8*MUM�~?6�25VR6 R � ��� [ S�;5M_8*ONQRFHM�y=o >`OP6�2IM^4�8:MN9?~

|�9z9+" [ 9�4�OCO_6 8*OWO_6�9 ;I2 H*9�6�Q�Q K Q*X�] > K 2 >�V3MNOP8?F�MWQ*X 8V02Iw09�> T 8*MNM�|�25O_6�2�>�OP6�9z2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_FH2 [t|�25;I;

2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9CO_6�9C4�;5Q?MN9�FgO_6�Q?MU9�MUO_8?F�M�V09�O ONQ O_6�9zF�9 K 9 K V?9?yWf�6�25MW|�QRS�; K ON9�> K OUQ F�9�> K 9�FYOP6�9`O_6�9�QRFH9�ON254�8*;

. ;�S�9`9 K V?9 �Z8*M K 9P] >�9 K-.0/ O_6�9YQR>�MN9�OgQ*X�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>x2�> T Q K 9�;5MYQ*X�8�V?25w?9�> T 8:MNM S > K 9�ON9�4�ON2 . ;59C2 >�F�9�8*;

k C d'MUO_8?F�M 7 V02Iw09�>3O_6�9 M T 8*;5;G>�S TC. 9�F�Q*X�H�>�Q(|Y>3w(8?FH2 8 . ;I9�M�y�o\> Q?O_6�9�FW|�QRF K M�~�MNOP8?F�M �P. S >�476 S [ �

8*VR8:2 >�MUOWO_6�9 F�9 K 9 K V09 K S�9zONQO_6�9�2�F 4�QR>?OU2 >�S 8*;5; / MN;5Q*|�2�>�V-FN8:ON9CQ*XG9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>+~=4�80S�MN2�>�VAO_6�9 � � � ���3�����. ;�S�9 9 K V09zONQM_6 8 K Q*| O_6�9 MN;5QR[ 9zQ:XGO_6�9 FH9 K 9 K V?9z2�>3O_6�9 ;IQ0V�P ;5Q?V � � � [�;�8?>�9?y f�6�25MC9+" [�;�8*2�>�MCO_6�9

8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9�; / ;52�>�9�8?FC;5Q�4�S�M�Q:Xg[ S�;5M_8:ON2�>�V�MNO_8?FHMYX QRS > K |�25O_6�2�> O_6 8*OC[�;�8?>�92 T [�;52I9 K .?/ O_6�9�2�F�ON25VR60O

K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR>�Q*X ���yC 9 8?F�9�;59PXbO�ONQ`9+" [�;�8*2�> O_6�9 Q . MN9�F�w?9 K FH9 K 9 K V?9Y2�>zOU9�F T MnQ:X�OP6�9 2�>0O_F�2�>�MN254`[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M�Q*X�O_6�9 MUO_8?F�M

O_6�9 T MU9�;Iw09�M�~?| 6�254�6C|�9 K 9PXb9�F ONQ � A y J yB@ y+j^2�F�MNO�~?6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~*|�9�|�25;5; K 25MN4�S�MNM�O_6�9�9 ��9�4�ONM^Q*X+O_6�9�Q . MU9�F�w?9 K

T 8*MUM K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR>�8*;5QR>�V OP6�9WMNO_F�2�[ QR>xO_6�9`[ 9�F�25Q K O_FH9�> K MN9�9�> 2�>j^25VRS FH9�A yB@ y

Page 92: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

Y �

� � � � K �C+� � & � �*�*��� ����� ������#��

J M T 9�>?OU2IQ�>�9 K [ F�9�w�2IQ�S�MN; / ~=OP6�9 K 9�[�OP6AQ:XG8?>�2IQ�>�2 ��8:ON25QR> R . 8*MN9 K K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9C2 >�4�FH9�8*MN9�M 7 T Q*w?9�M

ONQW;�8?F�V09�F^O_6�9�F T 8*; ON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M 7 |g2IOP6 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN2�>�V � � � XbQRF^k C d MNOP8?F�M^Q*X�8WV?25w?9�> T 8*MNM�y^f�6�25Mn2 T [�;5259�M

8 [ 9�F�25Q K OPF�9�> K QR[ [ Q?MN25ON9CONQ O_6 8*O�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K 2 >�j^25VRS F�9�A yB@ y5Ci6 8*OgQ?O_6�9�F T 9�476 80>�2IM T M T 25VR60O 8���9�4�O

O_6�9YQ . MN9�F�w09 K [ 9�F�25Q K M �3@W>�9WM_S�4�6 T 9�476 80>�2IM T 25M�O_6�9Y476 80>�V?2�>�V�w*8*;�S�9WQ*X�O_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T M_S�MNOP8*2�> 8 . ;59

PSR T Q K 9[ 9�FH2IQ K ~����� ?y�j%QRF�O_6�9 � � e�9�ON2�MNO_80F�M�~ ���� [ F�Q . 8 . ; / K Q�9�M >�Q?OC2�> � S�9�>�4�9-OP6�9A[ 9�F�25Q K

K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR> T S�4�6+~�MN2�>�4�9YXZF�Q T ?^a S 8*ON25QR> � = y O 25OG2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9�M�O_6 F�QRS�VR6 O_6�9����-e 9�ON2�2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / MUO_F�2�[+y

o\> k C dWM�~*6�Q(|�9�w?9�Fv~*O_6�9 � K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>�4�9W2�>!?^a S 8*ON25QR> � = y O T S�MNO . 9gO_8VH*9�>�2�>?OUQ`8*4�4�QRS >0O � |�9G4�80> >�Q?O

. 9C4�9�F�OP8*2�>O_6 8*OYO_6�9�O_F�9�> K 2 T [�;5259 K .?/ 8 ;59�>�V?O_6�9�>�2�>�V K F�25w�2�>�VON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59C|�QR>+B O�] > K 25ONMN9�;EX 8:O Q K K M

|�25O_6�8 K 9�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�V ���� ?y

j^25VRS FH9�A yBAYM_6�Q*|�McO_6�9 �b80F . 25O_FN8?F�25; / >�QRF T 8*;52 ��9 K FUS >CQ*X ���� �w?9�F�M_S�M � ��� XbQRF O_6 F�9�9Wk C d T Q K 9�;

MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�MCQ*X K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T 8*MNM�y e ;I9�80F�; / ~ ���� K 9�4�FH9�8*MN9�MCMN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0ON; / 8*M T Q K 9�;IMC9�w?Q0;Iw09 8*;5QR>�V38*;5;

O_6 F�9�9cMN9�a S�9�>�4�9�M�~?|�25O_6C6�25VR6 R T 8:MNM^MNO_8?FHM�9+" 6�2 . 25ON2�>�Vz8�M T 8*;5;59�F������ cO_6 8?> ;IQ*|5R T 8*MNM MNO_8?F�M 8*O�8:;I; � ��� y �

f�6�9�MN9CO�|�Qz9 ��9�4�ONM�~%| 6�9�>�4�Q TC. 2�>�9 K |g2IOP6AOP6�9 k C d T 8*MNM K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR>+~�2 T [�; / O_6 8:O ���� `MP6�QRS�; K

[�;�S TzT 9�O�[ F�9�4�2�[�2IOUQRS�MN; / |�25O_6�2�>�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�VC;5Q?V�P`2�>CO_6�9 T Q K 9�;5Mn2�>Cj^25VRS F�9GA yB= y�j�Q�F�9+" 8 T [�;59?~?OP6�9 FU8*ON25Q

Q*X������ �XbQRFWk � �?� A � ONQO_6 8*OYQ*X�k � E � =V=z25M�9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K OUQ . 9 � �� J = s � ~ | 6�25;59 OP6�9 FN8*ON25QQ*XnOP6�9�2 F

Q . MN9�FHw?9 K K Q T 2�> 8?>0Oz[ 9�F�25Q K M 25M�A JSE s J EVE � � yB@VA s � y-f�6�9A[ 9�F�25Q K K 25MNO_F�2 . S�ON25QR> MN9�9�> 2�> j^2IV�S F�9�A yB=

25MzO_6�S�Mz4�QR>�MN25MNOU9�>?Oz|g2IOP6 O_6�92 K 9�83O_6 8:O�OP6�9Aw(8:; S�9�Q*X ���� K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9�M O_6�9 K Q T 2 > 80>?O [ 9�F�25Q K 2�>

k C dLMNO_8?FHM�y J M�|G9Y|�25;5;�MN9�9W2�> O_6�9W>�9+"RO�MN9�4�OU2IQ�>+~����� [ F�Q . 8 . ; / 8*;5MNQz[�;�8 / MY8?>z2 T [ QRF�O_80>?O�[ 8?F�O�2�>

K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�2�>�VO_6�9 T QRF�9YX\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*;+a S�9�MUON25QR>Q*X �9�D��� 8CV?25w?9�>�k C dLMNO_8?Fc25M ;52 H*9�; / OUQ [ S�;5M_8*ON9?y

� � � � Z .�*��& �b#����^!�# � . � �� *�������� �� �+#�� * ���z� �:& � ���

o > � = yB@ yB= ~�|�9 K 25MN4�S�MNMU9 K O_6�9F�9�;�8*ON25QR>�M_6�2�[ . 9�O�|�9�9�> O_6�9 K 9�[�OP6 Q*X O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�98?> K O_6�9

[ 9�FH2IQ K Q*X P R T Q K 9�Q?MN4�25;5;�8*ON25QR>�M�y5?^a S 8*ON25QR>�� = yBA 2 T [�;52I9�MgO_6 8*O^O_6�9 K Q T 2�> 8?>?O�[ 9�F�25Q K MP6�QRS�; K 2�>�4�F�9�8*MU9

2�>�F�9�M_[ QR>�MN9CONQ O_6�9 K 9�9�[ 9�>�2�>�V K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9?~�8*MW;5QR>�VA8*MYQ?O_6�9�FW8 T [�;I25O_S K 9 ;I2 T 25ON2�>�V39 ��9�4�ONM K Q>�Q?O

2�>?OU9�F�w?9�>�9?y j^25VRS F�9GA yBA�MP6�Q(|gM�6�Q*| QR>�9G[ 8?FHON254�S�; 80F 9 ��9�4�O 7 O_6�9 K 9�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V T 8 "�2 T S T [ 9�F�25Q K 7 T 25VR60O�#�+406?>�ST< 6?1)/)B�U�@ AKBD6?S B�;=/3U�2��� 6?>=/ 9R25C6.A 6?>=/ @3A�A �T/)1 9R>�ST6./MU�9R251.4�S B�<.6.2#��S�� S 6?C�<.6?1.S N�<38 6?>=/�B � � �R/36?S:<.6.2K1)<&@3A5; �TU

AKB �TC N�; �T<.2�6./&2�6 ��/�1)C <?>=AK1)6RN�/)1.STA�U�<38��D;�6 � � ��/�KS B=< 6.A&UDA�E$S B=2�6./ ��/ �TA59 2K1)AK;DB=U � D8 � 6.A � D8 � % 8�N�;=<?>�S B �����=2�@ � 6.A �TA5B /�1"25B�U �TA5B /�1"N�/�1.STA�UD<"AKB=@3/"6?>=/$<.6.251)<�25N�ND1)A�2 @ > 6?>=/�S 1"E$S BDSTE";�E 1)2 U S ;=< 2 6�6?>�/&6.AKN AK4 6?>=/"9 >DST6./&U�9R251.4@3A�A� S B M6?1)2�@ ��V

Page 93: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

Y �

j^25VRS F�9%A y>A 1�8 "R2 T S T PSR T Q K 9 [ 9�F�25Q K ~����� ?~cw?9�F�M_S�M�� ��� XbQRF�O_6 F�9�9Ak C d 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> MN9TRa S�9�>�4�9�MgQ*X K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O T 8:MNM�y^f�6�9W8 . MNQ?;�S�ON9`>�QRF T 8*;52 ��8*ON25QR> Q*X�O_6�9Yw?9�F�ON254�8*;�8 "�25M�2IM8?F . 25O_FN80F / ~ . S�O O_6�9`FH9�; 8:ON25w?9�[ Q?MN25ON25QR>Q:X�O_6�9W4�S FHw?9�M�25M >�Q0O�y

F�9�w?9�FHMN9WO_6�9`OPF�9�> K 4�QR> >�9�4�ON9 K ONQ K FH2Iw�2�>�V ��Q�>�9 K 9�[�O_6+~+8?> K O_6�9�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K [ 9�F�25Q K MWQ:X � C �Y2�F�MUO_8?F�M

M_S [ [ QRF�ONMCO_6�9 M_S�V?V?9�MUON25QR> O_6 8*O������ 25MzO_6�9�H*9 / X\8*4�ONQRF 2�> MN9�ONON2�>�V3O_6�9 K Q T 2�> 8?>0O [ 9�F�25Q K y Ci6�25;59

���� ;52 T 25ONM�OP6�9 FN80>�V?9�Q*X=[ 9�FH2IQ K M�O_6 8:OG4�80> F�9�MP[ QR> K ONQ K FH2Iw�2�>�V�~ ����� 2�> O_6�9 K FH2Iw�2�>�V ��QR>�9Y;52 T 2IOUM�O_6�9

[ 9�FH2IQ K MzO_6 8:OW4�8?> . 9 K F�25w?9�>+yAmgQ*|�9�w?9�F�~ ����� 2 >�4�FH9�8*MN9�MzMNOU9�8 K 25; / X QRFW8:;I; � C �Y2�F`MUO_8?F�M�~ 8?> K ����

K 9�4�F�9�8*MU9�M`MNON9�8 K 2I; / y7?^w?9�>0O_S 8*;5; / ~�O_6�9�FH9PX QRFH9?~�9�w?9�F / [ S�;5M_8*ONQRF |�25;5;GF�9�8*4�638 MNO_8*OU9�|Y6�9�F�9 ����� ������

Q*w?9�F�O_6�9 9�>?ON2�F�99+"�ON9�>0OCQ*X O_6�9 K F�25w�2�>�V ��QR>�9?y)o > M_S�4�6 8AMUO_8*ON9?~^OP6�9 MNOP8?F�4�8?>)>�Q ;IQ�>�V?9�FCF�9�M_[ Q�> K

ONQ K F�25w�2 >�V 8*O 8:;I;b~�8?> K [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> |�25;5; 4�9�8*MU9?y o X ���� AF�9 T 8*2�>�MzO_6�9 T Q?MUO�2 T [ QRF�O_80>?O 8 T [�;52IOPS K 9

;52 T 25ON2�>�V XZ8*4�OUQRF�X QRF MNO_8?F�M�8?[ [ FHQR8*4�6�2 >�V O_6�9`F�9 K 9 K V?9?~ O_6�9�>xO_6�9`F�9 K 9 K V?9�25ONMN9�;EXn4�QRS�; K-. 9`4�8?S�MN9 K3.?/

O_6�9WMN25O_S 8:ON25QR>CrNS�MNO K 9�MN4�FH2 . 9 K y

C 9W4�8?>ON9�MUO O_6�25MY2 K 9�8 .0/ 8*M H02�>�V 2EXG25OY;59�8 K M OUQzO_6�9�H02�> K Q*X T 8*MNM9R K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>?O`F�9 K 9 K V?9C|�9WMN9�9?y

f�Qt80>�MN|�9�FWO_6�25Mza S�9�MNON25QR>+~^|�9 >�9�9 K OUQ2H�>�Q*| 6�Q*| O_6�9 K 9�[�O_6�Q:X O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9 �b8*M T 9�8:M_S F�9 K

Page 94: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�VE

.0/ � ��� 476 80>�V?9�M�|�25O_6�F�9�M_[ 9�4�OYONQ�� ��� XbQRFcMNO_8?FHM�Q*X^w(8?F�25QRS�M T 8*MUM�y^j^25VRS F�9%A y O K 9�[�254�ONM OP6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V

F�9�V?25QR>�M�X Q�F�X QRS F K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T Q K 9�; MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�M ��� � E AVY �TEBOVE�IE O @G80> K E Y E � � 8*O^O_6 F�9�9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O

9 ��9�4�ON25w?9`OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9�M � �+JVJ ~ EVEVE {C~ �FEVE ~ EVEVE {C~�8?> K Y � ~ E EVE { y fg6�9 K F�25w�2 >�VMUO_F�9�>�V?O_6+~ � ������~�2IM

K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9 K X\F�Q T ?^a S 8*ON25QR> � = y J ~�| 6�9�F�9 ��F�9�[ F�9�MU9�>?ONMCO_6�9 9+" [ F�9�MNMN25QR> 2�>�MN2 K 9-[ 8?F�9�>0O_6�9�MN9�M�yAf�6�9

/ Ru8 "R25M 6 8:M >�Q?O . 9�9�>A>�QRF T 8*;52 ��9 K 8?> K 25MYO_6�9WM_8 T 9 MN4�8:;I9�2�>A8*;5;+XbQRS F�[ 8?>�9�;5M�yLf�6�9�M_S FuXZ8*4�9 Q*X�9�8*4�6

1000 2000 3000 4000

j^25VRS F�9%A y O d`F�25wR2�>�ViMUO_F�9�>�V?O_6+~ � ����� � E ~YXbQRFxXbQRS F K 2EX RX 9�FH9�>?O T Q K 9�;nMN9�a S�9�>�4�9�M 8*OCO_6 FH9�9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O�9PX RX 9�4�OU2Iw09`ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9�M�y �^9�F�ON254�8*; ;52�>�9�M`F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0OO_6�9 T 8 "R2 T S T PSR T Q K 9 [ 9�F�25Q K ~^>�QRF T 8*;52 ��9 K ONQ�FEVEVE M�2�>xO_6�9 E AVY � � T Q K 9�;=8*O �+J J ~ EVEVE {Cy

Page 95: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� �

T Q K 9�; 25M QR> O_6�9�;I9PXbO�~�8*O � ��� � E y f�6�9�w?9�F�ON254�8*;�;52�>�9�MA2�> O_6�9]�VRS FH9-F�9�[ F�9�MU9�>?O � ��� ~cXbQRFC9�8*4�6

T Q K 9�;b~=>�QRF T 8*;52 ��9 K ONQ �FEVE E MY2�>3O_6�9 E AVY � � T Q K 9�;n8:O �+J J ~ EVEVE {Cy C�9C6 8�w?9 T 8 K 9�>�QA8:ONON9 T [�O

ONQ 4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9zO_6�9z8*4�OPS 8*;=w*8*;�S�9zQ*X ���� � O_6�9C2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O OP6�2 >�V25MW25ONMW4�6 8?>�V?2�>�VAF�9�;�8*ON25QR>�MP6�2 [ ONQ O_6�9

K 9�[�O_6xQ*X�OP6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9`|�25O_6 4�6 8?>�V?2�>�V T 8*MNMY8?> K � ��� y

J 4�QRS [�;59AQ:X 2 T [ QRFHO_8?>0OzO_F�9�> K M 80F�9 4�;59�8?F 2�> O_6�9 ]�VRS F�9?y j^2 FHMNO�~^O_6�9 K FH2Iw�2�>�V��Q�>�92 > T Q K 9�;IM

Q*X`83V?25w?9�> T 8*MNMzMU2 > H0M ONQ�;5QR>�V?9�F ����� ~G80> K V?9�ONM ; 80F�V?9�Fz8?> K MNO_F�Q�>�V?9�F�~^|�25O_6 K 9�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V � ��� ylo >

O_6�9A8 . MU9�>�4�9AQ*XWQ?O_6�9�FC9 ��9�4�ONM�~nO_6�25M O_F�9�> K |�QRS�; K ;59�8 K ONQ39�w?9�F 2 >�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�V [ 9�F�25Q K MQ:X ;�8?F�V09�Fz8?> K

;�8?F�V?9�Fc8 T [�;525O_S K 9`8*M � � � K 9�4�F�9�8*MU9�M�y^139�8?>0| 6�25;I9?~����� �4�6 8?>�V?9�M T QRF�9 T Q K 9�FN8:ON9�; / ~ T Q(w�2�>�VCONQ*| 80F K

MN;525VR60ON; / M_6�Q�F�ON9�FcON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M�|g2IOP6 K 9�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V�� ��� 8?> K 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V T 8:MNM�y^o�X^|�9 T 8 H*9�O_6�9WMNQ T 9�| 6 8*O

4�FNS K 9`8*MUM_S T [�ON25QR> O_6 8*OcO_6�9 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9 K F�25w�2 >�V ��QR>�9 4�Q�>�MN25MNONM�QR>�; / Q:X�OP6�Q?MN9W[ 8?F�ONMcQ*X=O_6�9�X\S�;5; K F�25w�2 >�V

��QR>�9Y|�25O_6 � ��� � � ��� ~�O_6�9�> 8C[�254�O_S F�9WQ:X�OP6�9 F�9 K 9 K V?9W9 T 9�FHV?9�M�y J O ��� � � �+J J ~ EVEVE {C~�O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V

��QR>�9z25MCF�9�;�8*ON25w?9�; / S > 8���9�4�ON9 K 2�>�8*;5;^O_6 F�9�9 T Q K 9�;^MU9�a S�9�>�4�9�M�y J M � � � K 9�4�FH9�8*MN9�M�~ 8?> K O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V

��QR>�9�MN2�> H?M ONQ3;5QR>�V?9�F ����� ~nO_6�9 ���� IR\2 T [ Q?MN9 K ;52 T 2IO9�>�4�FHQR8*4�6�9�MzQR> O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9 T Q�F�9A8?> K

T QRFH9YX QRF 9�w?9�F /AT 8*MUM�ynf�6�S�M OP6�9W;IQ�>�V?9�F [ 9�F�25Q K M�~+| 6�25;I9 K F�25w?9�>+~+8?F�9W9�;52 T 2�> 8*ON9 K ~ T Q*wR2�>�VzOP6�9`;5QR4�S�M

Q*XG[ Q(|�9�FYONQ M_6�QRFHON9�F [ 9�F�25Q K M�O_6 8?>�|�QRS�; K�. 9CMN9�9�>�2EX���� �| 8:M >�Q?O`8 X\8*4�ONQRF�y ?�w?9�>?OPS 8*;5; / ~ �2#*# O_6�9K F�25w?9�>z[ 9�F�25Q K M�8?FH9G;5QR>�V09�F^O_6 8?>�O_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T [ 9�F�25Q K 8*O^| 6�254�6z8YMNO_8?F�4�8?>zFH9�M_[ QR> K ~�8?> K [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>

4�9�8*MN9�MY8*;5ONQ?V?9�O_6�9�Fvynf�6�25M 25M�OP6�9�F�9 K 9 K V?9?y

kcS�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M�|�25;I;�>�Q?O`MP6RS�O K Q*| >�8:OWO_6�9zM_8 T 9 � � � 2 > MNO_80F�M Q:X 9�w09�F /-T 8:MNM�yzmg2IV�6 T 8:MNM T Q K 9�;IM

F�9�O_8:2 > T QRF�9WQ:X�O_6�9�2�Fg9 ��9�4�ON25w?9 K F�25w�2�>�V ��QR>�9�M OP6 8?> ;5Q(| T 8*MUM T Q K 9�;IMW8*O 8 V?25w?9�> � � � y�f�6�25MWQ�4�4�S F�M

. 9�4�80S�MN9z8*O 8 V?25w?9�> � � ��~%O_6�9�ONQR[Q:XnO_6�9 K F�25w�2�>�V ��QR>�9 T Q*w?9�MYONQ*|�8?F K O_6�9`MPS F XZ8:4�9 ��ONQ M T 8*;5;59�F � ���

|�25O_6 2�>�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�V T 8*MUM�y^f�6�25M�9 ��9�4�O�Q*X K 9�4�F�9�8:MN2�>�V ����� 8*O�O_6�9WONQR[ Q*X^O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9WQRS�ONMNOPF�2�[�M�O_6�9

O_F�9�> K ONQ;5Q(|�9�F ���� C|�25O_632�>�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�V T 8:MNM�yCf�6�9 F�9�M_S�;5O�2IM�O_6 8*O�~�8:O%Y � ~ EVE E {C~+O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V ��QR>�9

2�>O_6�9 E AVY � � T Q K 9�; �bS [ [ 9�FY[ 8?>�9�; Q*X=j^25VRS F�9�A y O 6 8*M T Q*w?9 K ONQzON2 T 9�MU4�8*;59�M 9�>0ON2�F�9�; / 8 . Q*w?9WO_6�9

���� �;I2 T 25O�~�| 6�25;59�O_6�9 E>O @ � � 8?> K E Y E � � T Q K 9�;5M �Z8?[ [ F�QR[ F�2�8*OU9nXbQRF k � E � =V= � O�|GQY;5Q*|G9�F^[ 80>�9�;IM

2�>j^25VRS F�9%A y O MNON25;5;�[ FHQ K S�4�9�MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>?O K F�25w�2 >�VA8:OGOP6�9�F T 8*;�OU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M . 9�;5Q(|����� (y

h 9�4�8*;5;nX\F�Q T f 8 . ;59 J yBY80> K j^25VRS F�9�A yB= O_6 8*O � C �Y2�F`MUO_8?F�MWQ*X�;5Q*|�9�F � ��� 6 8�w?9 6�2IV�6�9�F T 8*MNM�y

Ci6 / �MC�9 4�8?>)>�Q*| V?25w?98?> 8?>�MN|�9�F�sC8*OC;IQ*| � � �=~ O_6�9 ;5Q*| T 8*MNM�MNO_8?FHM�6 8�w?9 MNONQR[ [ 9 K [ S�;5M_8*OU2 >�V

. 9�4�80S�MN9AO_6�9 / QR>�; / K F�25w?9A[ 9�F�25Q K M ;5QR>�V09�FCO_6 8?> O_6�Q?MN9A8:O�|Y6�2I4�6 O_6�9 / 4�8?> F�9�M_[ QR> K ONQ�[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> �

Page 96: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� =

mg2IV�6�9�F T 8*MNMzMUO_8?F�M 6 8�w?9�M_6 8*;5;5Q*|G9�F 25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR>���Q�>�9�M��b8:O 8�V02Iw09�> ��� � O_6 8*OzMUON25;I; K FH2Iw09t[ 9�F�25Q K M

M_6�QRFHON9�F�O_6 8?> OP6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T 8*;5;5Q(|�9 K PSR T Q K 9`[ 9�F�25Q K ~+9�w?9�>8*O�;5Q*| � ��� ynfg6�2IMY4�8?S�MN9�MYO_6�9`F�9 K 9 K V?9

ONQ T Q*w?9WONQ6�25VR6�9�F T 8*MNMY|�25O_6 K 9�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�V;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / 8?> K � � � ~ ��1��%/�� ������3�"� � -'��##G��������:/;)#$����,%�3-�+���� %/������� � ������"� % � ��+"���( 4 f�6�9C2�>?ON9�FU[�; 8 /3. 9�O�|�9�9�> K FH2Iw�2�>�V���QR>�9 K 9�[�O_6 8?> K ���� C9�>0X Q�F�4�9�MWO_6�9

MNO_FH2 H02�>�V?; / M T 8*;5;=FU8?>�V?9WQ*Xn[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8*4�2�>�V?M � � � = �� A�M MN9�9�>x2 >�f=8 . ;I9 J yBYC8?> K j^2IV�S F�9%A yB= y

fg6�9�MN9z4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�Mz8?F�9 >�Q?O�8?> 8*ONON9 T [�OWOUQA[ F�9 K 254�O�OP6�9z9+" 8:4�O`;5QR4�8:ON25QR>�Q:XGO_6�9 FH9 K 9 K V?9 8*O`8

V?25w?9�> T 8:MNM�y C�9`8?F�9WQ�>�; / 2�>?OU9�F�9�MNON9 K 8*O�O_6�25M [ Q?2�>?OY2�> K 9 T QR>�MNOPFN8*ON2�>�V 6�Q*| O_6�9`[ Q0MN25ON25QR>Q*X O_6�9`F�9 K

9 K V?9�25M�9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K ONQ`w*8?F / |�25O_6 T 8*MNM�~*V?25w?9�> 80>C25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR> R . 8*MN9 KK FH2Iw�2�>�V���QR>�9 |g2IOP6z8?>zS [ [ 9�F�;52 T 2IO

[�;�8*4�9 K QR>C25O .0/ ����� ?y^o >CO_6�9W[ 8?F�ON254�S�;�8?F T Q K 9�;5M�M_6�Q*| >�2�>zj^25VRS F�9�A y O ~*O_6�9gONQR[CQ*X+O_6�9 K F�25w�2�>�V ��QR>�9

4�QRFNFH9�M_[ QR> K MCONQ3O_6�9 25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR> ON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9 Q*X @�� oU~ . S�O�OP6�9 . 9�6 8�w�25QRFCQ*XYO_6�9 FH9 K 9 K V?9MP6�QRS�; K

. 9CO_6�9CM_8 T 9�>�Q T 8:ONON9�F�| 6 8:O M_[ 9�4�259�M`4�8?S�MN9�MWOP6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V%y�oZONM 8 . MNQ?;�S�ON9C;5QR4�8*OU2IQ�>+~+O_6�QRS�VR6+~+|�QRS�; K

[ F�Q . 8 . ; /. 9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O�V?25w?9�> K F�25w�2�>�V .?/ K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O�M_[ 9�4�259�M�y�o\> QRF K 9�FnOUQ S�MU9 O_6�9W;5Q�4�8*ON25QR> Q*X O_6�9`F�9 K

9 K V?9cXbQRF+MNO_80F�M=Q:X K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O T 8*MNM ONQY2 K 9�>0ON2EX / O_6�9�9+" 8*4�O=MP[ 9�4�259�MnO_6 8:O�8*4�4�Q T [�;52IMP6�9�M K F�25wR2�>�V�~0|G9�|�QRS�; K

>�9�9 K ONQ`4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9 � ��� [ F�9�4�25MN9�; / X QRF^8:;I;%O_6�9 T Q K 9�;5M�2�>zj^25VRS FH9�A y O 8?> K. 9�OUON9�FnS > K 9�F�MUO_8?> K 9+" 8*4�OU; /

6�Q*| O_6�9 w*8*;�S�9`Q*X������ W8���9�4�ONM�O_6�9W8 T [�;525O_S K 9�MYQ*X T Q K 9�M >�9�8?F .0/ 2�>[ 9�FH2IQ K y�< S�4768�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>x2IM

. 9 / QR> K O_6�9WMU4�QR[ 9�Q*X�OP6�2IMgO_6�9�MN25M�~+8?> K |�9W;I9�8�w?9W25OYONQ�XZS�OPS F�9`2�>0w?9�MNON25VR8*OUQRF�M�ONQ 8*OUON9 T [�O�QR>�9?y

J ;5ON9�FN> 8*OU2Iw09�; / ~+OP6�9 K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F / Q*X T QRF�9 � C �Y2 FYMUO_8?F�M�|�QRS�; K 6�9�;�[3S�M . 9�ONON9�FYS > K 9�F�MNOP8?> K O_6�9�MN9

[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M .?/�K 9P] >�2 >�V�O_6�9 F�9 K 9 K V?9 |�25O_6�VRF�9�8*ON9�FYQ . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR> 8*;n[ F�9�4�25MN25QR>+yzf�6�9CMN2 T [�;59�MNOCON9�MUO Q*X

QRS F�OP6�9�QRF�259�M�|�QRS�; KA. 9�ONQ�] > K ;5Q*|5R � ��� � C��Y2�F [ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�M�Q*X^;5Q(| T 8*MNM�y^o X�O_6�9 / 9+"�2IMUO�~ O_6�9�>�����

25M [ FHQ . 8 . ; / >�Q?OY8CX\8*4�ONQRF 2 > K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�2 >�VOP6�9�2 FY[ 9�FH2IQ K M�~�8?> K w*8?F�2�8*ON25QR>xM_6�QRS�; K�. 9CMNQRS�VR60O�2�>OP6�9�2 F

;525VR6?OU4�S F�w?9�MW8*O�;5QR>�V?9�F�[ 9�F�25Q K MWOP6 8?> 2�>O_6�9 � C � 2�F�MUO_8?F�M�XbQRS > K MNQ XZ8?F � j^25VRS F�9%A y O M_S�V?V?9�MNOUMGOP6�9�2 F

K Q T 2�> 8?>0OW[ 9�F�25Q K MWM_6�QRS�; K). 9�2�>AOP6�9`O_6�QRS�MP8?> K M Q:XnMN9�4�QR> K M�yYobOY2IMW[ Q0MNMN2 . ;59zO_6 8*OYO_6�9�MN9�MNO_8?F�Mg4�QRS�; K

. 9Ca S�25ON9 >�S T 9�F�QRS�M �b8?> K %��D���1#$�z. 9Ca S�25ON9z>�S T 9�F�QRS�MW2EXGOP6�9 / 9+"�2IMUO`8*O 8:;I;b~+V?25w?9�>�O_6�9�2�FYMN;5Q*|�9�FWFN8*ON9

Q*X=9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80> K MNON25;5;�9�MN4�8?[ 9 K 9�ON9�4�ON25QR>+~ MN2�>�4�9`MNO_80> K 8?F K ON2 T 9TR\MN9�FH2I9�MW8?[ 9�F�O_S F�9`[ 6�Q?OUQ T 9�O_F / 2IMY>�Q?O

V?9�>�9�FN8:;I; / 9 ��9�4�ON25w?9 8*O�O_6�9�MN9 ON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M�y13Q?MUO`4�S FNF�9�>0O�ege�d [ 6�Q?ONQ T 9�ON9�F�MC8?F�9za S�25ON9 4�80[ 8 . ;59 Q*X

MN9�8?FH476�2�>�VCXbQRFcM_S�4�6w(80F�2�8 . 25;I25O / ~+6�Q(|�9�w?9�Fvy�D�8*MU9 K QR> O_6�9�MN9`F�9�MPS�;IOUM�~ |�9 9�>�4�Q�S FN8*V?9YX\S�O_S F�9WMNOPS K 2I9�MYONQ

K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9�| 6�9�O_6�9�FgQRF�>�Q?O�;5Q*|5R T 8*MUM�~�;IQ*|5R ��� � � C � 2�F�[ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�M K Q 2�> K 9�9 K 9+"R25MNO�y

o >zMPS TzT 8?F / ~0O_6�9YQ . MN9�F�w?9 K O_F�9�> K ONQ*| 80F K M_6�QRFHON9�F K Q T 2 > 80>?O�[ 9�F�25Q K M�|�25O_6 K 9�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V�� ��� [ F�Q R

Page 97: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� @

w�2 K 9�Mg9�wR2 K 9�>�4�9`OP6 8*OnO_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T PSR T Q K 9 [ 9�FH2IQ K ~�� ��� ~�25M 8?>C2 T [ QRF�O_8?>0OcXZ8:4�ONQRF^2�> K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�2�>�V

O_6�9WFN8?>�V?9gQ*X=[ 9�F�25Q K M�Q . MN9�F�w09 K 2�> � C �Y2 FcMNOP8?F�M�y ?^w09�>?O_S 8:;I; / ~ T Q K 9�;5M�M_S�V?V?9�MUOnO_6�9 K FH2Iw�2�>�V ��QR>�9Y2�>

8*;5;=k C d [ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M�|�25;5;�MN2�> H ONQCO_6�9�F T 8*;+ON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�MY;IQ�>�V?9�F�O_6 8?>����� ?~�80> K [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>|g2I;5;�4�9�8:MN9?y

<�2�>�4�9AO_6�25M O_8VH*9�Mz[�;�8*4�938*OC;IQ*|�9�F�� ��� XbQRF�MNO_8?F�MCQ*X`6�25VR6�9�F T 8:MNM�~cO_6�25M [ F�Q�4�9�MNMz25M 4�Q�>�MN25MNON9�>0Oz|�25O_6

O_6�9 Q . MN9�F�w09 K F�9 K 9 K V?9?~^|Y6�2I4�6 M_6�Q*|�Mz8MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0OzM_6�2EXbO�OUQA;5Q*|G9�F�ON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9z|�25O_6 2�>�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�V

T 8*MUM�y^f�6�9 . ;�S�9`9 K V?9Y25M >�Q?O�4�QR>�MUO_FN8*2�>�9 KA.0/ O_6�25M T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T ~ . S�O X QRF � C� 2�F�MNOP8?F�M�O_6�9Y2 >0O_F�2�>�MN254

. ;�S�9C9 K V?9W25M S > K 9�ON9�4�OU9 Kt. 9�4�8?S�MN9�Q*X�MU9�;I9�4�OU2IQ�>A9 ��9�4�ONM K S�9`ONQ FU8?[�2 K 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+ycdW25MN4�Q*w?9�F / Q*Xn8 K K 2>R

ON25QR> 8*; � C��Y2 F MNO_8?F�M T 25VR60OG9�w09�>?O_S 8:;I; / 8*;5;5Q(|LS�M�ONQ�[�;�8*4�9�MNO_8*OU2IMUON254�8*;�;52 T 25ONMYQR>zOP6�9W;IQ�4�8*ON25QR> Q:X=O_6�9

� 2�>0O_F�2�>�MN254�� . ;�S�9C9 K V?9?s^2by 9?y"~ |�9WM_6�QRS�; K ;5Q�Q HCXbQRF�6�25VR6�9�F T 8*MUM ��M T 8:;I;59�F � �1��� [ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M�y

Page 98: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� J

�� ���!�7��� � � ��� �F� � � � ��������� � � � �F� � ���2����� ��� �

�?����� %/+"��"� +��� ��"�3��#$; ����5%��D�3��� ��D� %� ��� �1����!"����������*�2� .��D�)�����F? ��� �D#G� �1��!"� (D�!"��� %'����� ? ���(���!"���������+����3-���D�)� � �2+"� % � ����*� �� �9�D�+/� ��"� �3-����D�=����; ������#������ ���2�.�D�3��# � �1�"���2 ������D4�� �1� %/+"��"� +�����5%�������� ��1+/� ����3�54 � �D��!"�2����������� %��3-���D� %� ��� �1����!������*�������� �����3������: �=�*� � �1�*�3���������� � ��D���*�

� ������"�)���5%���� :F��%/�����3+/�D��� -/��� � ��1��#G���9%0:/;=�9�D�*+,� ��1�";������ � �3� ('�D#G�������� ��� ��:/;��9�1�*+,� ��D���*� � �"���*��� �� (2�D� � �"�F�D� � %���%/�"# - :F���3��������� ��� !�������D:,#$� ������ � ��� :F��� � �� ������� ��������� � ��##$; ��D�"����3��#$�2���*��� �������D���0� ���.�D�3��# #$�2�9%0���5%0����: � %/����(��D� �3-'�����'4 6

7 h�25476 8?F KAJ y�knF�Q�4�ONQRFv~�� ��1�"��� �2��#G�5%0��D�2� � �D�F%�@3A5B��FE

� ��� �������� "!$#&%'��() ��

o > V?9�>�9�FN8*;b~�MNOP8?F�Mz8?F�9ONQ�Q�F�9 T Q?OU9 7 8?> K Q . MN9�F�w*8 . ;59�MONQ�QAXb9�| 7 ONQ T 8VH*9O_6�9 T [ FN8*4�ON254�8*;�9+" R

[ 9�FH2 T 9�>?O_8:;G[ 6 / MN254�MzOU9�MNO9R . 9 K M�s`QRS F K 8*O_8�8?F�9zM_[ 9�>?O�2�>�MN2 T [�; / K 9�MN4�F�2 . 2�>�V�O_6�9 K 2 T 9�>�MU2IQ�>�MzQ*X�O_6�9

Q . r�9�4�ONM S > K 9�FgMNO_S K / y�o\> T 8?> / 4�8:MN9�M |�9 T S�MNO�9+"�O_FN80[ Q?;�8*ON9W9+" [ 9�FH2 T 9�>?O_8:; K 8*OP8CQ*w?9�F T 8?> / QRF K 9�F�M

Q*X T 8*VR>�25O_S K 9?~ QRFWF�9�MUQRF�OWONQAS >0ON9�MNON9 K 4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�M�X\F�Q T ] F�MUO�[ F�2�>�4�2�[�;59�M�~^ONQAF�9�8:4763OP6�9 F�9�V?25QR>�MWQ*X

[ 6 8*MN9�M_[ 8*4�9WO_6 8:O 80[ [�; / OUQzMNON9�;5;�8?Fg2 >0ON9�F�25QRFHM�y

o X |�9 6�QR[ 9ONQAQ*w?9�F�4�Q T 9 OP6�9�MN9 [ FHQ . ;59 T Mz8?> K [ S FHM_S�9 � 9+" [ 9�F�2 T 9�>0O_8*; �)8*MUO_F�QR[ 6 / MU2I4�M�~=|�9 4�8?>

9�25O_6�9�F�8*OUON9 T [�OnOUQ�2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9WO_6�9W>RS TC. 9�F Q*X�Q . MN9�F�w*8 . ;59�M QRF�] > K MN2 T [�;59�F�MUO_8?F�M�y J Mc] F�MUO FH9�8*;52 ��9 K3.?/

139�MNON9�; � ��� AV= ~*O_6�9�9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> Q*X�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX M�8?> K k C dWM^2IMY[ F�2 T 8?F�25; / 8 MN2 T [�;59W4�QRQ0;I2�>�V [ FHQ . ;59 T y

o\> V?9�>�9�FN8:; ~�QRS F�VRF�Q*|�2�>�V-S > K 9�F�MUO_8?> K 2�>�V�Q*X |Y6�2IOU9 K |�8?F X�2�>0ON9�F�25QRF�Mz8?> K 9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>)6 8*Mz[ 8?FU8*;5;I9�;59 K

8 K w*8?>�4�9�M2�> O_6�9�O_6�9�QRF / Q*X K 9�>�MN9�[�;�8*M T 8:M�~�|�25O_6 OP6�9-F�9�4�Q?V�>�2IOU2IQ�>lQ:X 2 T [ QRF�O_8?>0O 2 > � S�9�>�4�9�M�;52 H:9

9�;59�4�O_F�QR> K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8*4 / �Ze�6 8?> K FN8*MU9FH�8?F ��� @ � ~�e�Q�S�;IQ T�. 2�>0ON9�FN8*4�OU2IQ�>�M �b< 8*;�[ 9�OU9�F ��� O �� ~�4�F / MNOP8*;5;I2 ��8*OU2IQ�>

�b{Y2�F ��6 >�25O�� ���VO E � JW. F�2 H*Q?MNQ*w ���VOVE � < 8*;�[ 9�ON9�F ��� O � � <�ON9�w?9�>�MNQ�> ���?� E 8?> K >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q 4�Q�Q?;52�>�V9 ��9�4�ONM

�be�6�2�>+~�e�6�2�S+~ � <�ONQ0O_6�9�F�M ���VO O � C 2�>�V?9�O�~�m 80>�MN9�>+~ � �n8?>zmgQRFN> ���0� @ � {W8�|�8*;59�F�~?mY8?>�MN9�>+~ � C 2�>�V?9�O

Page 99: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� A

���?� A y�o . 9�> � f S�O_S H*Q*w � ���?� J M_S TzT 8?FH2 ��9�O_6�9gw(8?F�25QRS�M T 9�476 8?>�25M T Mn| 6�254�6 K Q T 2�> 8*ON9�| 6�25ON9 K | 80F X

9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> XZFHQ T O_6�9�[�;�8?>�9�O_80F / >�9 . S�;�8>�S�4�;59�S�M��bk���� MNOP8*V?9YONQzO_6�9W4�Q�Q?;59�MNOY| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�y

fg6�94�QRQ?;52�>�V Q*X 8 � C �Y2 F 2�>?OU9�F�25QRFCON9�> K MzOUQ�2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�O_6�9A[ 9�F�25Q K M Q:X 9�8*4�6 V?25w?9�>l[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>

T Q K 9?y�f�6�9�2�F 6�25VR6�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / � ;IQ0V � � E � @ T 9�8?>�MYO_6�9 / 4�Q�Q?; T S�4�6 T QRF�9CFN8?[�2 K ; / O_6 8?> 9�25O_6�9�F

� � e�9�OU2=QRFYd`D�� w(8?F�2�8 . ;59�M�y � C �Y2�F`[ 9�F�25Q K 4�6 8?>�V?9�MC8?F�9CO_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9C9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K ONQ . 9 T QRF�9�FU8?[�2 K

8*;5MNQ�y C 2 >�V09�O�~�m 80>�MN9�> � �n8?>3mgQRFN>� ���?� @ M_6�Q*| O_6 8:O�O_6�9�RbXbQ?; K 2�>�VAON2 T 9 X QRFY[ 9�FH2IQ K 4�6 8?>�V?9�MY2�>

� C �Y2 F MNO_8?FHMWM_6�QRS�; K . 9 8 . QRS�O �FE � / 9�8?FHM � M_S�4�6�FN80[�2 K 476 8?>�V09�M�8?F�9 T 9�8:M_S FN8 . ;59 2 > � � @ / 9�8?F�M�y

f�6�25MW25M`8?>�9+"R4�25ON2�>�V3[ F�Q?M_[ 9�4�O�s�ONQ T 9�8*MPS F�9 K 2�F�9�4�ON; / ~�QR>36RS T 80>AOU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M�~+O_6�9zFN8*OU9`Q*Xn9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�>

Q*X 8tMNO_8?F�~^8?> K MP[ 9�4�2E]�4�8*;5; / OUQt[�;�8*4�9�MNO_F�254�OC4�QR>�MNOPFN8*2�>?OUMzQR> O_6�9 T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T Mz| 6�254�6lF�9�V�S�; 8:ON9O_6�9

9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> Q*X=8�MNON9�;5;�8?Fc2�>?ON9�FH2IQ�F�y^@Yw?9�F5@ E / 9�80F�MG8*V0Q�~?e�6�2�>+~�e�6�2�S+~ 8?> K <�ONQ?O_6�9�F�M � ���VO O M_6�Q*|�9 K O_6 8*O

8*OYMNQ T 9`[ Q?2�>?OW2�>3k C d 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>3>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q;5Q?MNMN9�MYM_6�QRS�; K3K Q T 2�> 8*OU9 8:;I; Q?O_6�9�Fg4�Q�Q?;52 >�VA[ FHQR4�9�MNMU9�M�y

J MNON9�F�Q?MU9�2IM T Q?;5Q?V?254�8*;+8?> 8*; / MU2IM�4�8?> ON9�;5; S�M�| 6�254�6zMUO_8?F�McO_6�9�MN9 8?FH9?~R8?> K O_6�9�> T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?OcQ*X=[ 9�F�25Q K

4�6 8?>�V?9�M�4�8?>xON9�;5;=S�M�2EXnQRS F�>�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q [ 6 / MU2I4�MY25M F�25VR60O�y

< S�4�6l8�ON9�MUO 6 8*Mz2 T [�;5254�8*ON25QR>�MxXZ8?F . 9 / QR> K OP6�9AMNO_S K / Q*X`k C d 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y j�QRFC2�>�MNOP8?>�4�9?~�2�>

e�6 8?[�OU9�F � |�9 T 9�>0ON25QR>�9 K OP6 8*O`QR>�9 Q*X�O_6�9 T Q?MNOWX\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*;ca S�9�MUON25QR>�MCQ*X�MNON9�;5;�8?FC8*MNO_F�Q�[ 6 / MN254�M

25MO_6�9A;59�>�V?OP6 Q*X`ON2 T 9�MNO_8?FHMzM_[ 9�> K QR> O_6�9 T 8*2�> MU9�a S�9�>�4�9?y J >�MN|�9�F�2�>�V)O_6�25Ma S�9�MNON25QR> F�9�a S�2�F�9�M

[ F�9�4�25MN9!H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09�Q:X�O_6�9z[ Ru[�8?> K e � @ >RS�4�;59�8?FWFH9�8*4�ON25QR>AFU8*ON9�M�y�e�S FUF�9�>?OU; / ~%O_6�9 . 9�MNOW;�8 . QRFN8*ONQ�F /

XbQRF T 9�8:M_S F�2�>�V3O_6�9�MN9FN8*ON9�M�2IMCQRS F�Q*| >�< S >+~�MN2�>�4�9ON9�FNF�9�MNOPF�2�8*;n;�8 . MC4�8?> >�Q?O�2�> V?9�>�9�FN8*;�F�9�[ F�Q K S�4�9

O_6�9�4�Q�> K 2IOU2IQ�>�M�Q*X�O_6�9�MNOU9�;I;�8?Fc2�>0ON9�F�25QRF�ynmgQ*|�9�w?9�F�~ T Q K 9�;5MG|Y6�2I4�6 M_S�4�4�9�MNM�X\S�;5; / FH9�[ F�Q K S�4�9YO_6�9�H�>�Q*| >

MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9AQ:X�O_6�93< S >i[ F�9 K 254�OA8 >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q � SS"lO�|�Q ONQ)OP6 F�9�9AON2 T 9�MOP6 8*O T 9�8*M_S F�9 Ki.0/ 9�8?F�OP6�; /

K 9�ON9�4�ONQ�F�M��ZDG806�4�8*;5; � k�2�>�MNQR> >�9�8?S�;5O ���?�VO ~�8?> K F�9PX 9�FH9�>�4�9�MO_6�9�F�9�2�> y j%QRF8�;5QR>�V OU2 T 9?~ 25O|�8*M

O_6�QRS�V�6?OO_6�9 [ F�Q . ;59 T T 25VR60O-FH9�MN2 K 9�2�>iQRS F 2�>�4�Q T [�;I9�OU9 HR>�Q*|�;59 K V?9�Q:X�4�QR> K 25ON25QR>�M32�> O_6�9�MUQ?;�8?F

2�>?OU9�F�25QRF�y h 9�4�9�>?ON; / ~W6�9�;525Q?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V / [ FHQ?r�9�4�ONMzM_S�4�6l8*M O_6�9 � ;5Q . 8*;W@YMN4�25;5; 8:ON25QR> �g9�Ou|�QRF H � F�QRS [

� � @ � � 6 8�w?9�F�9�MPS�;IOU9 K 2�>�O_6�9 T 9�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0O Q*X T 25;5;52IQ�>�M�Q:XnMNQ?;�8?FY[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>xXZFH9�a S�9�>�4�259�M �Zm 8?FHw?9 /

9�O 8*;by ���?�VO y C 2IOP6MNQ T 8?> / [ 8?FN8 T 9�OU9�F�M�ONQC4�QR>�MNOPFN8*2�> T Q K 9�;=[ F�QR[ 9�F�ON259�M�~%O_6�9`[ Q?MUMN2 . 2I;525O / O_6 8:O�O_6�9

MNQ?;�8?Fg>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q [ FHQ . ;59 T 4�8?> . 9�MNQ?;5w?9 K O_6 F�QRS�VR6 w(80F�2�8*ON25QR>�MY2 >xO_6�9WO_6�9�F T Q K / > 8 T 254�M�QRF T 9�476 80>�2I4�M

MN9�9 T M�ONQ . 9Y9+"R4�;�S K 9 K �bD�8?6�4�8:;I; � k^2�>�MNQR> >�9�80S�;IO ���?�VO y=f�6�9W[ F�Q . ;59 T ~�O_6�9�>+~ 8*; T Q?MUOn4�9�F�O_8:2 >�; / ;52I9�M

|�25O_6xO_6�9W|�8 / |G9`6 80> K ;I9�O_6�9�>�S�4�;59�8?FY[ 6 / MN254�M�y

Page 100: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�VO

}Y> K 9�FcO_6�9 T Q0MNOn2�>0ON9�>�MN9YMN4�FNS�ON2�> / 25MGOP6�9�MNO_8?> K 80F K O_6�9�QRF / Q:X�;59�[�ONQ�>z2�>0ON9�FN8*4�ON25QR>�M�yn@WS F^4�8*;54�S�;�8 R

ON25QR>�M�Q:X�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Qz9 T 25MNMU2IQ�> X\F�Q T k C dWM 80F�9 . 8:MN9 K QR> O_6�25M�M_8 T 9YO_6�9�QRF / yno\>k C dWM�~R6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~�O_6�9

9�>�9�F�V / ;5Q?MNM FU8*ON9 K S�9WONQz>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q?MY2IMgO_6�QRS�M_8?> K MgQ*X=ON2 T 9�M�V�F�9�8*ON9�FcO_6 8?> 2�> O_6�9`< S >+y�1-9�8:M_S F�9 T 9�>0O

Q*X�O_6�9 9 ��9�4�ONM`Q*XW>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q32 >0ON9�FN8:4�ON25QR>�MC2 > k C dWM`|�QRS�; K 8 ��Q�F K 84�FH2IOU2I4�8:;G2�> K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>?O ON9�MNOC>�Q?O

QR>�; / Q*X�OP6�9WMNO_8?> K 8?F K ;59�[�ONQR>xO_6�9�QRF / . S�O 8*;5MNQzQ*Xn>�QR> R\MNOP8?> K 8?F K O_6�9�QRF�259�M . F�QRS�VR60OcX Q�F�|�8?F K ONQCMNQ?;5w?9

O_6�9WMNQ0; 80F�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q[ F�Q . ;59 T y

f�Q`9+" [�;5QRF�9YO_6�25M�[ Q?MNMU2 . 25;525O / ~�|�9�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9 K k C d 9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / OPFN8*4+H?MnS�MN2�>�V K 2 ��9�F�9�>0OG>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q

[ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR> FN8*ON9�M�y^o >zO_6�9W>�9+"�OnMN9�4�ON25QR> |�9 K 9�MN4�F�2 . 9WO_6�9 4�8:;I4�S�;�8*OU2IQ�> Q*X�O_6�Q?MN9 FU8*ON9�MG80> K M_S TzT 80F�2 ��9

O_6�9 . 8*MN254C2�>?OU9�FN8*4�ON25QR>�MWO_6 8:O�;59�8 K ONQ >�9�S�OPF�2�>�QA9 T 25MNMN25QR>�2�>�k C d 2�>0ON9�F�25QRF�M�y <�9�4�OU2IQ�> O yB@ K 9�MU4�F�2 . 9�M

k C d MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�M |�25O_6 w(8?FH2I9 K >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q [ F�Q K S�4�OU2IQ�> FU8*ON9�Mz8?> K 9+" 8 T 2�>�9�M 9 ��9�4�ONM QR> T 9�8*M_S FU8 . ;59

a S 8?>?OU2IOU2I9�MYM_S�4�6A8*M� � �=~ M_S F X\8*4�9�VRFN8�wR25O / ~ 8?> K FU8*ON9WQ*Xn[ 9�F�25Q K 476 8?>�V09?y�j^2 > 8:;I; / ~+2�> � O y J |�9 K 25MN4�S�MNM

[ F�Q?MP[ 9�4�ONM XbQRF�[�;�8*4�2�>�V`Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR> 8*;�4�QR>�MNO_FN8:2 >0ONM QR>`>�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q`[ 6 / MN254�M�~R80> K |�9n2 K 9�>0ON2EX / 8?[ [ F�Q�[ F�2�8*ON9

O_8?FHV?9�ONMcX Q�F^X\S�O_S F�9�Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>+y

� � � � � # � � ()�& � " �)()� � (�� � ��� ��� �$(.��� �&� �R� ������� � () ����

}Y>�;52 H*9zO_6�9�MNQ?;�8?FW>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q � SS"+~�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q9 T 25MNMN25QR>t2 > k C dWM�25M`>�Q?O`8 .?/ Ru[ F�Q K S�4�OWQ*XG>RS�4�;59�8?F

X\S�MN25QR>+y�o\>�MNOU9�8 K ~^O_6�9 K 9�>�MN25O / 8?> K ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9 2�> O_6�9�2�F�4�QRF�9�Mz8?F�96�25VR6 9�>�QRS�VR6���;5Q?V ��� O� Y ~

;5Q?V���� Y � ONQ�[ FHQ K S�4�9W>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q?M K 2�F�9�4�ON; / O_6 F�QRS�VR6 MN9�w?9�FN8*; K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O�MN4�8*OUON9�F�2�>�V�[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M�ynf�6�9

O�|�Q T Q?MUOG2 T [ QRF�O_80>?O�[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M 80F�9 � �D�1�������� :/�3�� � %/���3�5�D#+�D�2( 8?> K � #G�5%/ ���� MN4�8*ONOU9�F�2�>�V�y ��9�S�O_FH2 >�Q. F�9 TzT MNO_FN8?6�;�S >�V 25M T S�4�6�;52 H:9�OP6�9�>�QRF T 8*; . FH9 TzT MNO_FU8?6�;�S >�V [ F�Q�4�9�MNMYX\8 T 25;52�8?FYONQ 8*MUO_F�QR[ 6 / MU2I4�25MNOUM�~

2�> | 6�25476 6�25VR6 R\9�>�9�F�V / 9�;59�4�O_F�QR>�MzMU4�8*ONON9�F�Q � >�S�4�;59�2 ~�9 T 2IOUON2�>�V �GRuFU8 / M�y J OCO_6�9A6�25VR6 K 9�>�MU2IO / 8?> K

ON9 T [ 9�FN8*O_S FH9�Q*X k C d 2�>0ON9�F�25QRF�M�~ 6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~Y>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q?M34�8?> . 9)[ F�Q K S�4�9 K 2�>�MNOU9�8 K y f�6�93MN9�4�Q�> K

T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T Q*X=>�9�S�O_F�2�>�QC9 T 25MNMN25QR> K 9�F�25w?9�McX\F�Q T O_6�9 K 25M_[ 9�FHMN25QR>F�9�;�8*ON25QR> Q*X=8`[ 6�Q?OUQR>z2�> 8?>C9�;59�4�O_F�Q�>

VR8*M�~RV02Iw09�> .0/

� ���� � � � ���� � � � � �� � � � � O y �

| 6�9�F�9 � 25MWO_6�9z[ 6�Q?ONQR>�8?>�VRS�;�8?FgX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / ~ ��25MWO_6�9C| 8�w?9`>�S TC. 9�FYQ*X�O_6�9�[ 6�Q0ONQR>+~�8?> K�� � 25MWO_6�9

MNQ R\4�8:;I;59 K [�;�8*M T 8 X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / yzf�6�9z[�; 8:M T 8 X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 /3K 9�[ 9�> K M`Q�>AOP6�9z9�;59�4�O_F�QR>3OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9z8?> K

K 9�>�MN25O / ~=8?> K w*8?>�25M_6�9�MC2 >-XZF�9�9CM_[ 8:4�9?y J [ 6�Q?ONQR>�Q . 9 / 2�>�V ?�a S 8:ON25QR> � O y �� . 9�6 8�w?9�MW;52 H*9 8[ 80F�ON254�;59

Page 101: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� Y

|�25O_6z80>C9 ��9�4�ON25w?9 T 8*MUMnQ*X �� � � � �� ~�8?> K 25MnOP6�9�F�9PX Q�F�9�4�8*;5;59 K 8 � #G�5%/ ��2� y^f�6�9�2�F^9 ��9�4�ON25w?9 T 8*MNM T 9�8?>�M

O_6 8*O �bS >�;52 H*9-[ 6�Q?OUQR>�MC2 > X\F�9�9 M_[ 8*4�9 [�;�8*M T Q�>�M�4�80> K 9�4�8 / K 2 FH9�4�ON; / 2�>0ONQ39�;I9�4�OPF�QR> Ru[ Q0MN25O_F�QR> [ 8*2�F�M

| 6�254�6O_6�9�>�8?> >�2�6�2I;�8*OU9�2�>0ONQz9�;59�4�O_F�Q�>A>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q?MW8?> K 8?>0ON2�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q?M�y

fg6�9 [ Q?MNMN2 . ;59F�9�;59�w(8?>�4�9 Q*XGOP6�9 [�;�8*M T 8A[ F�Q�4�9�MNMWONQMUON9�;5; 80F`8*MNOPF�QR[ 6 / MN254�MW|�8*Mg] F�MNO`[ Q?2�>?ON9 K QRS�O

.0/ JYK 8 T M�~%h�S K 9�F T 8?>+~ � C�Q�Q�� ���VO @ ~?| 6�Q M_S . MN9�a S�9�>?ON; / 4�8*;54�S�; 8:ON9 K FN8:ON9�M . 8*MN9 K Q�> O_6�9WO_6�9�QRF /

Q*Xnj%9 / > T 80> � � 9�;5;>R\1t80> > � ��� A � y Dc9�8?S K 9�O�~�k 9�O_F�Q?MN2�8?> � < 8*;�[ 9�OU9�F � ��� O Y |�9�F�9�O_6�9�] F�MNOWONQ 2�> R

4�QRFN[ QRFN8*OU9`O_6�9 T 2�>0ONQ MUON9�;5; 80FW9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�M�y�p�8:ON9�F�~%dW2I4�S�M � ��� Y = F�9�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9 K O_6�9zFN8*ON9�M

Q*X�w(80F�25QRS�M�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Qz[ F�QR4�9�MUMN9�M�2 > OP6�9 S >�2E]�9 K 9�;59�4�O_F�Q R\|�9�8VH�O_6�9�Q�F / Q*X6C�9�2�> . 9�F�V 8?> K < 8:; 8 T � C�9�2�> R

. 9�FHV ���VO Y ~ < 8:; 8 T ��� O?� y f�6�9�FN8:ON9�M�S�MN9 K 2�>OP6�9`MNON9�;5;�8?F�9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>4�Q K 9 K 9�MN4�FH2 . 9 K 2 > � A y>@ K 9�FH2Iw09

X\F�Q T S [ K 8*ON9 K 4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�M .0/ obOUQR639�Oz8*;by � ���?�VO ~�80> K 2�>�4�;�S K 9AO_6�9[�;�8*M T Q�>+~ . FH9 TzT MNO_FU8?6�;�S >�V�~

8?> K MN9�w09�FN8*;�;59�MNMY2 T [ QRFHO_8?>0O >�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q [ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR>�[ F�QR4�9�MUMN9�M�y

f�QCMNO_S K / O_6�9 K 2�F�9�4�Og9 ��9�4�OUM�Q*Xn>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q ;5Q?MUMN9�M�QR>k C d 9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>+~ |�9W2�>?O_FHQ K S�4�9 K 8?F�ON2E]�4�2�8*;5; /

8*;5ON9�F�9 K FN8*ON9�MW|�9�;5; . 9PXbQRF�9zOP6�9�9�w0Q?;5wR2�>�V T Q K 9�;5MzF�9�8*4�6�9 K O_6�9 k C d O_FN8:4 H%y`o�X�|�9CMN2 T [�; / 4�6 8?>�V?9 K

O_6�9WFN8*ON9�M . 9�V?2�> >�2 >�V8*O�O_6�9`6�Q?O�9�> K Q*X�O_6�9`k C diMN9�a S�9�>�4�9?~�O_6�9YO_6�9�F T 8*;+MNO_FNS�4�O_S FH9 Q*X 9�8*476 T Q K 9�;

|�QRS�; K O_8VH:9�MN9�w?9�FN8:; O_6�9�F T 8*; OU2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M�ONQ�F�9�;�8 "CONQC8`>�9�| 9�a S�25;52 . F�2�S T 4�QR>0]�V�S FN8*ON25QR> . 8:MN9 K Q�>CO_6�9

>�9�| FN8*ON9�M�y^}Y>0X Q�F�O_S > 8*ON9�; / ~ OP6�2IMWF�9�;�8 " 8*ON25QR>xON2 T 9W25M Q*X^O_6�9�M_8 T 9WQRF K 9�F�8*M�O_6�9`k C d 4�QRQ?;52�>�V ON2 T 9?~

8?> K MUQQR>�; / OP6�9z4�QRQ0;^9�> K Q*XGOP6�9zMN9�a S�9�>�4�9 |�QRS�; K MN9�9 O_6�9�XZS�;5;n9 ��9�4�ONMWQ:X OP6�9 >�9�| FN8*ON9�MWQ�>AOP6�9�2 F

9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / ON2 T 9�MU4�8*;59�M�y`f�6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9?~+OP6�9�9�> 6 80>�4�9 K 8?> KAK 2 T 2�>�25M_6�9 K FN8:ON9�M K 9�MU4�F�2 . 9 K 2 >�O_6�9z>�9+"�O

MN9�4�ON25QR> |�9�F�9W2�>0O_F�Q K S�4�9 K 2�>0ONQz9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / 4�8:;I4�S�;�8*OU2IQ�>�M . 9�V?2�> >�2 >�VA8:OGOP6�9 . 8*MN9WQ*X=OP6�9 J � DYy f�6�9

F�9�M_S�;5ON2�>�VCO_6�9�F T 8*; MNO_FNS�4�OPS F�9�Q*X+O_6�9 2�>�25ON2�8*;�k C d � MN9�9 K � T Q K 9�;IM�|�8*M^O_6�9�> 8*;�F�9�8 K / 4�QR>�MN25MNON9�>0O�|�25O_6

O_6�9`>�9�S�O_FH2 >�QFN8*OU9�M S�MN9 KAK S FH2 >�V O_6�9`[ F�25QRF 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>OP6 8*O [ F�Q K S�4�9 K O_6�9 T y

� ��� � � � ��� �&( � � �&� �R� �� � �"# � �&% � � � (.��� � ( � � ���I����� � #"����(��& �&�I��� �

<�OP8?F�ON2�>�V|�25O_63OP6�9 k C d MN9�9 K T Q K 9�;5MC8 . Q*w?9?~�|G9C9�w?Q0;Iw09 K O_6�9 T Q K 9�;5M�XZF�Q T 6�2IV�6��i80> K � ���

K Q*| > ONQ*|�8?F K OP6�9�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X`4�Q�Q?;52�>�V O_FN8*4+H�y f�6 F�9�93MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�M3|�9�F�934�8*;54�S�; 8:ON9 K y f�6�9 . 8*MN9

MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�S�MN9 K OP6�9`>�QRF T 8*;�>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q[ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR>AFU8*ON9�M�y J >�Q?O_6�9�FcMN9�a S�9�>�4�9 S�MU9 K FN8*ON9�M K 2 T 2�>�25M_6�9 K

.0/ 8�X\8*4�ONQ�F�Q*X^O_6 F�9�9 �b8*OY8?> / V?25w?9�> � 8?> K � 2 >�O_6�9WMUON9�;5; 80F�2�>0ON9�F�25QRF Q*w?9�FcO_6�9�>�QRF T 8*;�FN8*ON9�M�~R|Y6�2I;59

O_6�9�O_6�2�F K MN9�a S�9�>�4�9zS�MN9 K FU8*ON9�M�9�> 6 8?>�4�9 K�.0/ 8�X\8*4�ONQRF�Q:X�O_6 FH9�9?y�f�6�25M O_FH2IQ M_[ 8?>�MW>�9�8?F�; / QR>�9`Q�F K 9�F

Page 102: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�?�

Q*X T 8*VR>�25O_S K 9�2�>A>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q [ FHQ K S�4�ON25QR>+y

fg6�9nF�9�M_S�;5ON2�>�V E BO � � 9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�M�8?FH9^M_6�Q*| >Y2�>Wj^25VRS F�9 O y � ~PX\F�Q T � ��� � � Y E� E EVE � 79�a S�2Iw*8*;59�>?OCONQOP6�9 6�Q?ONON9�MUO`k C dWM H�>�Q*| > 7 K Q*| >3ONQA8 . QRS�O%@VA � EVEVE � y p�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O /�K 9�4�F�9�8*MN9�M .?/

8*; T Q?MUO�XbQRS F�QRF K 9�F�M Q:X T 8*VR>�25O_S K 9�2 >38?[ [ FHQ "�2 T 8*ON9�; / ]�w?9 T 25;5;525QR> / 9�8?FHM�y�f�6�9 � C �Y2 Fg2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O /

MNO_FH2 [ Q�4�4�S [�259�MWO_6�9W;59PX OY6 8*;EX�Q*X^O_6�9Y]�VRS FH9?~�8 . Q*w?9�� ��� � �VE � EVEVE � � ;IQ0V�� ��� � J �� ~R8COU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9

F�9�8*4�6�9 K-.0/ O_6�9`k C d T Q K 9�;5MW2�>Q�>�; / A EVE ~ EVEVE / 9�8?F�M�y

fg6�9 T Q?MNO^MUO_F�2 H?2�>�VC8*M_[ 9�4�OcQ*X�j^25VRS F�9 O y � 2IMcO_6�9�MN2 T 25;�8?F�25O / Q*X+O_6�9�O_FU8*4 H0M�s�476 8?>�V02 >�V�O_6�9 >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q

FN8*OU9�M=MN9�9 T M^ONQ 6 8�w?9c;52IOUON;59�9 ��9�4�O=QR>�O_6�9�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 8*O^8�V?25w?9�> � ��� 8*O ����; [ Q?2�>0O^2�>zk C dl9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>+~

K 9�M_[�25ON9CO_6�9W2 T [ QRF�O_8?>�4�9�Q*Xn>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q;5Q?MNMN9�M 8:M 8C4�Q�Q?;52�>�V T 9�476 8?>�25M T Q*w?9�F T S�4�6Q*X^O_6�25M FU8?>�V?9?yno >

j^25VRS F�9 O y>= ~?|�9g] > K O_6 8*O�~:X QRF�8*;5;+O_6 F�9�9WMU9�a S�9�>�4�9�M�~%>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Qz;5Q?MNMN9�M�8?FH9 O_6�9 � ��� �����; 4�Q�Q?;52�>�V T 9�4�6 R

j^25VRS F�9 O y � ?^w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / O_FN8:4 H0M�XbQRF�O_6 F�9�9 E>O � � T Q K 9�; MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�MW|�25O_6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0OY2 > [ S�O>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Qz[ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR>zFN8*OU9�M�y^f�6�9 S [ [ 9�F�8?> K ;IQ*|�9�F O_FN8:4 H0M^|�9�F�9�4�8*;54�S�; 8:ON9 K |�25O_6FN8*ON9�M�QR>�9TR\O_6�2�F K 8?> K O_6 F�9�9cON2 T 9�M=OP6�9G>�QRF T 8*;RFN8*OU9�M�� T 2 K K ;59�O_FN8:4 H ~�F�9�MP[ 9�4�ON25w?9�; / y

Page 103: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�?�

j^25VRS F�9 O y>= h�8*ON25Q Q*X`O_6�9�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / OUQ)O_6�93[ 6�Q?ONQR> ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 8:M 8tXZS >�4�OU2IQ�>Q*X � ��� ~ X QRFcO_6 FH9�9 EBO � � T Q K 9�;�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�MY|�25O_6 K 2 ��9�FH9�>?O�2�> [ S�OW>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q[ F�Q RK S�4�ON25QR>AFU8*ON9�M�y

8?>�25M T Q*w?9�F�O_6�9`8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9 FU8?>�V?9 �FEVE�TEVEVE � � ��� � � @ E� E EVE � y�k^;�8*M T QR> F�9�8*4�ON25QR>�M K Q T 2�> 8*ON9

Q*w?9�F^OP6�9 . F�9 T T MNO_FN806�; S >�Vz[ F�Q�4�9�MNMcXbQRF E y O � � T Q K 9�;IMY8*OG8*;5;+MNO_8:V?9�MnQ*X=k C d 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+~�8*McM_6�Q*| >

2�>j^25VRS F�9 O yB@ y

fg6�9GFN8*OU2IQ � � ����8*;5MNQ 2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9�M^|�25O_6�MNON9�;5;�8?F T 8*MUM�y=o >`OP6�9 ������FN80>�V?9 �VE ~ EVEVE�+�FEVE ~ E EVE {C~�� � ���

XbQRF�8 E y OVO � � T Q K 9�;�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�25M >�9�80F�; / @ E�� 6�25VR6�9�FgO_6 8?> XbQRF�8 E y O E � � MN9�a S�9�>�4�9?y

j^25VRS FH9�M O y � 8?> K O yB= M_6�Q*|lO_6 8:OnO_6�9 K 2 ��9�FH9�>�4�9�M 2�> � 8?> K � � � 8?FH9�M T 8*;5;59�MNO�|Y6�9�>zO_6�9W>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q?M

8?F�9�2 T [ QRFHO_8?>0O�y�f�6�25M 25M . 9�4�8?S�MN9CO_6�9�[ FH2 T 8?F / %/��� �1+"�.�1�3��# 9 ��9�4�O Q:Xn476 8?>�V02 >�V O_6�9C>�9�S�O_F�2�>�QAFN8*ON9�Mg2IM

QR> O_6�9WFN8 K 2�S�M�Q*X=OP6�9 T Q K 9�;5M ��j^25VRS F�9 O y J ~?4�8?S�MU2 >�V O_6�9 OPFN8*4+H?M�ONQC8*MNM_S T 9W8C[ Q?MU2IOU2IQ�> 2 >xO_6�9 � � ���

[�;�8?>�9�>�Q�F T 8*;5; / Q�4�4�S [�259 K�.?/T Q K 9�;IMYQ*X=MU;I25VR60ON; / 6�25VR6�9�F T 8*MNM �"XbQRFc9�> 6 8?>�4�9 K FU8*ON9�M QRFc;5Q*|G9�F T 8*MNM

�"XbQRF K 2 T 2�>�25M_6�9 K FN8:ON9�M y�mgQ*|G9�w09�F�~�8*O`;5Q*|�9�FWON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9�M`9�;59�4�O_F�Q�> K 9�V?9�>�9�FU8*4 /�. 9�4�Q T 9�MC2�>�4�F�9�8*M R

Page 104: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�VE

j^25VRS F�9 O y>@ j FN8:4�ON25QR> Q*X-ONQ0O_8*;>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 4�QR>0O_F�2 . S�ON9 K .?/ O_6�9 [�;�8*M T Q�>'8?> K. F�9 T MNMUO_FN8?6�;�S >�VA[ F�Q�4�9�MNMN9�M�~�8:M 8 XZS >�4�OU2IQ�>AQ:X � � � ~ XbQRFgO_6 F�9�9 EBO � � T Q K 9�;^MN9TRa S�9�>�4�9�MY|�25O_6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q[ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR>AFU8*ON9�M�y

2�>�V?; / 2 T [ QRF�O_80>?Oz8*Mz8 T 9�476 8?>�254�8*;gM_S [ [ QRFHO 8:VR8*2�>�MNOCVRFN8�w�2IO / �b8?> K O_6�S�MC2 > K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�2�>�V O_6�9 ] > 8*;

MNON9�;5;�8?F FN8 K 2�S�M � >�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q�4�QRQ0;I2�>�V QR>�; / 8���9�4�ONMCO_6�9O_6�9�F T 8*;�[ F�QR4�9�MUMN9�M [ 80F�ON254�2�[ 8*ON2�>�V)2�> O_6�9 T 9TR

4�6 8?>�254�8*;�MNO_FNS�4�O_S FH9?y-?�w?9�>�8*OC6�25VR6�;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / ~n6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~ K 2 ��9�FH9�>?Oz>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q�FN8*OU9�M`F�9�M_S�;5OC2 > QR>�; /

M T 8:;I;�4�6 8?>�V?9�M�2 > T 9�8*M_S FN8 . ;59a S 8?>0ON25ON259�M�MPS�476 8*MCM_S F X\8*4�9 VRFN8�wR25O / yAe�S FUF�9�>?O�Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> 8*;�ON9�4�6 R

>�25a S�9�MY4�QRS�; K >�Q?O�6�QR[ 9�ONQ F�9�MUQ?;5w?9WM_S�4�6M T 8:;I; K 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�9�M�y

j^25VRS FH9 O yBA M_6�Q*|�M`8 T QRFH9�OP8?>�V?2 . ;59z9 ��9�4�O`Q*X�476 8?>�V02 >�V�O_6�9zFN8*ON9�M�y�?�w?9�>3O_6�QRS�V�6 T Q K 9�;5MC|�25O_6

K 2 ��9�F�9�>?OzFN8:ON9�M`;5Q�Q H T S�476 O_6�9 M_8 T 98*OC8AV02Iw09�> � ��� ~ O_6�9 / V?9�OCO_6�9�F�98*O`|�2 K 9�; / K 2 ��9�F�2�>�V�OU2 T 9�M�~

MN2�>�4�9zO_6�9zFN8:ON9`Q*Xn9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>�8*;5QR>�V8 O_FN8*4+H 25M K 2�F�9�4�ON; /3K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>0O`QR>�O_6�9C2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>�4�9CQ*XG>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q

9 T 25MNMN25QR> 8*M`8 MNQ�S F�4�9zQ*X�4�QRQ?;52�>�V�y j�Q�FY9+" 8 T [�;I9?~ O_6�9 T Q K 9�;^|g2IOP639�> 6 8?>�4�9 K >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q�FN8*ON9�MW4�Q�Q?;5M

X\F�Q T �FEVE � EVEVE { K Q*| >COUQ O A �TEVEVE { 2�> O EVE� E EVE / 9�8?F�M�~*| 6�25;59WO_6�9 T Q K 9�;%|�25O_6 K 2 T 2�>�25M_6�9 K >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q

Page 105: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� �

j^25VRS F�9 O y J f�6�9�F T 8:;�MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9 8*OcO_6 F�9�9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O�9�w?Q R;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / MUO_8*V?9�M�~ � ��� � �+J E�TEVEVE { �bS [ R[ 9�F [ 8?>�9�; ~ �VE � EVEVE { � T 2 K K ;59 [ 8?>�9�; ~8?> K @ E�TEVEVE { ��;5Q(|�9�FY[ 8?>�9�; ~+XbQRF EBO � �T Q K 9�;IM3|�25O_6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O3>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Qi[ F�Q K S�4TRON25QR>FN8*OU9�M�y

FN8*OU9�MzO_8VH*9�M �� @ T 25;I;525QR> / 9�8?F�M�~ T QRF�9�O_6 8?> Ou|g2I4�938*Mz;5QR>�V�~gONQ�4�Q�Q?; .?/ O_6�9�M_8 T 9A8 T QRS >0O�yif�6�9

T 8 "�2 T S TLK 2 ��9�F�9�>�4�9Y2�>CO_6�9�MU;IQ�[ 9�Q*X+O_6�9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O^4�S F�w?9�Mn2�>Cj^25VRS FH9 O yBAgQR4�4�S FHMG8*O�� ��� � � E� EVE E {Cy

f�6�S�M�O_6�9�9�[ Q�476x| 6�9�F�9`OP6�9�FN8*OU9WQ*X�9�w0Q?;�S�ON25QR>25M T Q?MNO�MU9�>�MN25ON25w?9CONQzO_6�9`8*MUM_S T 9 K >�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q [ 6 / MU2I4�M

4�QRFNFH9�M_[ QR> K M�ONQ�O_6�9W[ Q?MN25ON25QR> 2�> O_6�9Wm5Ruh K 2�8*V�FN8 T Q�4�4�S [�259 K-.0/ O_6�9�4�Q�Q?;59�MNO [ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�Mc2 > OP6�9 k C d

2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_F�2�[+yz@W>�O_6�9zQ0O_6�9�FW6 8?> K ~+XbQRFgMNO_8?FHMW2 >tO_6�9CMNO_F�2�[�6�Q?OUON9�FYO_6 8?> �FEVE � EVEVE { j^25VRS FH9 O yBA

M_6�Q*|�M�OP6 8*O�9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 8?F / FU8*ON9�M K Q >�Q?O K 9�[ 9�> K QR>>�9�S�O_F�2�>�QFN8*ON9�M�y

@WS F 9+" [ 9�4�O_8*ON25QR>�MC8?F�9 . QRFN>�9zQ�S�OW2 > j^25VRS F�9 O y O ~+| 6�254�6�M_6�Q*|�MWOP6�9 FN8*ON9CQ*X�476 80>�V?9z2�>)[ 9�F�25Q K ~�� � � � � � ��;�>�� ��� � ~�8*M 8 XZS >�4�OU2IQ�>AQ:X�[ 9�F�25Q K ~ ��~ XbQRFYk C d T Q K 9�;5M`8*O �+J E � EVEVE { ��;5Q(|�9�F�[ 80>�9�;

Page 106: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� =

j^25VRS F�9 O y>A ?^w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> Q*X � ��� |�25O_6 OU2 T 9YX QRFcO_6 FH9�9 E>O � � T Q K 9�;�MN9�a S�9�>�4�9�M |�25O_6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O2�> [ S�O >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q[ F�Q K S�4�ON25QR>AFU8*ON9�M�y

8?> K �VE � EVEVE { �bS [ [ 9�F [ 80>�9�; ~nV?25w?9�> >�QRF T 8:; ~c9�> 6 8?>�4�9 K ~Y8?> K K 2 T 2�>�2IMP6�9 K >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q [ F�Q K S�4�OU2IQ�>

FN8*OU9�M�y^f�6�9 FN8*OU9�Q*X=[ 9�F�25Q K 476 80>�V?9 �� � � 2 > OP6�9�4�QRQ0;I9�F T Q K 9�;5M�476 8?>�V09�M .0/ 8YX\8*4�ONQRF�Q*X+X Q�S F . 9�O�|�9�9�>

O_6�9z9�> 6 80>�4�9 K 8?> K K 2 T 2 >�25M_6�9 K FN8*ON9�M�yze�6 8?>�V?2�>�VAOP6�9 >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q-FU8*ON9�M`6 8*M�;I25ONOU;I9 9 ��9�4�O`QR> �� � � 2�>

O_6�9 6�Q0ONON9�F T Q K 9�;b~^4�QR>�MU2IMUON9�>?O�|�25O_6 O_6�9 F�9�M_S�;5ONM�X\F�Q T j^2IV�S F�9 O yBA y�C 9 >�Q*| O_S FN> ONQO_6�9 9+"�4�2IOU2 >�V

2 T [�;5254�8*ON25QR>�M Q*X O_6�9�MN9AFH9�M_S�;5ONM�~n8?> K 9+" [�;IQ�F�9O_6�9A[ Q0MNMN2 . 25;I25O / 8?> K [ FN8:4�ON254�8*;52IO / Q*X T 9�8*M_S FH2 >�V �� � �

2�> 4�QRQ?;W[ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�Vlk C d MNO_8?FHM�y:C�934�8?> OP6�9�>l2 K 9�>0ON2EX / ;52 H:9�; / O_80F�V?9�ONMCXbQRF XZS�OPS F�9AQ . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�> 8*;

4�8 T [ 8:2IV�>�M�y

� � � � � �� ��� %'��� ���� � � ��#&��(���� � �I#"����(��& � " ���()��� � � �I%'��

139�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0ONMCQ*X MU9�4�S�; 80F [ 9�F�25Q K 4�6 8?>�V?9?~ �� � ��~c2 > | 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX Mz6 8�w?9 . 9�9�> 8*ONON9 T [�ON9 Kl.?/

8>�S T�. 9�FWQ*X�2�>?w?9�MUON25VR8*ON25QR>�M�~�|�25O_639�25O_6�9�F T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?ONM T 8 K 9CQRFYON25VR60O`S [ [ 9�F�;52 T 25ONMCMN9�OYXbQRFYO_6�9

Page 107: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� @

300 400 500 600 700

0

2

4

6

.2

.4

.6

.8

j^25VRS F�9 O y O h�8*ON9�Q*X�[ 9�F�25Q K 4�6 8?>�V?9 X QRF E BO � � T Q K 9�;IM|�25O_6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O >�9�S�O_F�2�>�QFN8*ON9�M�y

� C � 2�F�MNO_8?F k � �?� A � � C 2�>�V?9�O=9�O^8*;by ���?� A ~ ���?� � ~�e�Q?MUO_8 � {Y9�[�;59�F ���?�0� 8?> K � �?� Y RuD � A J �Z{Y9�[�;I9�F

9�O�8*;by ���?� A y=}Y>0XbQRF�O_S > 8*OU9�; / ~%>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Qz4�Q�Q?;52 >�V 25M >�Q?O�9+" [ 9�4�ON9 K ONQ . 9�8?> 2 T [ QRFHO_8?>0OG9 ��9�4�OcXbQRF�8?> /

Q*X OP6�9�MN9 MUO_8?F�M�y�@W> OP6�9 Q?OP6�9�F�6 80> K k � E � = = ~ |�25O_6)8 � � � Q*X � E ~ EVEVE {C~ QR4�4�S [�259�M O_6�9MNO_8*V09z2�>

� C �Y2�F�9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> T Q?MUO 6�25VR6�; /AK Q T 2�> 8*OU9 K-.0/ >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q 9 T 25MNMN25QR>+y�o >3e�6 8?[�ON9�F J ~ |�9YX QRS > K O_6 8*O

k � E � =V=�25MY2 >�8 K K 25ON25QR>�O_6�9 T Q?MUO T 8*MNMU2Iw09 � C � 2�FgMNO_8?Fv~R|Y6�2I4�6MP6�QRS�; K 9�> 6 80>�4�9�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q 9 ��9�4�ONM

8*M�|�9�;5;by

o > QRF K 9�FCOUQ T 9�8*M_S F�9 �� � � |�25O_6 4�QR>0] K 9�>�4�9?~�83MNOP8?F T S�MUO 6 8�w?983MNOP8 . ;59A8?> K XZS�;5; / FH9�MNQ?;5w?9 K

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>+~ |�25O_6tMNO_8 . ;59 [ 6 8*MU9 T 9�8*M_S FH9 T 9�>?OUMWX\F�Q T MN9�8*MUQR>�ONQMN9�8*MNQ�>+y k � E � =V= 25M 8 w09�F / MNO_8 . ;59

Page 108: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� J

[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�s^Q*w?9�FcO_6�9`[ 8*MNO K 9�4�8 K 9?~%25O 6 8*M�MP6�Q(|Y> 8C4�Q�>�MN25MNON9�>0O [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>xM_[ 9�4�O_FUS T ��MU9�9 j^25VRS F�9 J yBY ~

|�25O_6 OP6�9�;�8?F�V?9TRu8 T [�;I25O_S K 9 T Q K 9�M-[ F�9�MU9�>?OA8*OOP6�9�M_8 T 9�X\F�9�a S�9�>�4�2I9�M K S F�2�>�V 9�8*476 Q*X�O_6�9 O_6 F�9�9

2�>?OU9�>�MN25w?9CQ . MN9�F�w�2�>�V MN9�8:MNQR>�M�2�> ���?�VO ~ ���?�VE ~ 8?> K ���?�VO ycf�6�9�8 T [�;I25O_S K 9�MWQ:X�9�8*4�6Q:X�O_6�9 K Q T 2�> 8?>0O

T Q K 9�MnF�9 T 8*2�>�9 K 8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9�; / 4�Q�>�MNO_8?>0O�8:M=|�9�;5;by+* f�6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9?~*k � E � =V=�25Mn8?>�9+"�4�9�;I;59�>0On4�8?> K 2 K 8*OU9

XbQRF T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?O�Q*X=OP6�9`FN8*ON9YQ*X=MN9�4�S�;�8?Fg[ 9�F�25Q K 4�6 8?>�V?9Y4�8?S�MN9 KA.0/ O_6�9Y9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / 4�Q�Q?;52�>�V Q:X=25ONM

2�>?OU9�F�25QRF�y

o >�8 K K 25ON25QR> ONQO_6�9 [ 6 / MN254�M�V0Q(w09�FN>�2�>�VA>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q�[ F�Q K S�4�OU2IQ�>+~�k � E � = = 2IMC8?>32 K 9�8*;cO_8?F�V?9�OYXbQRF

T 9�8*MPS F�2�>�V >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q9 T 2IMUMN25QR>3FN8*ON9�M . 9�4�8?S�MN9CQ*XnO_6�9 T 2�>�2 T 8*; 2 > � S�9�>�4�9 Q*XG8?> /AT Q K 9�O_FN8?[ [�2�>�V QR>

2�>?OU9�FN[ F�9�O_8*OU2IQ�>�Q*X�25ONM �� � �`y J M�|�9zMP6�Q(| 2�> e�6 8?[�ON9�F�= ~ O_6�9 MPS F XZ8:4�9 4�QR>0O_FN8:4�ON25QR>�FN8*OU9 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN9�M

|�25O_6 K 9�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�V�� � � F�9�;�8*ON25w?9CONQ O_6�9�4�QRQ?;52�>�V-FU8*ON9WQ*X � C � 2�FYMNOP8?F�M�y�j%QRF�MUO_8?F�M . 9�;5Q*| �FEVE ~ EVEVE {C~

O_FN80[ [�2 >�V >�Q ;5QR>�V?9�F MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>?OU; / 8���9�4�ONM �� � � X\F�Q T'T Q K 9WONQ T Q K 9?y

j+F�Q T j^2IV�S F�9 O y O ~?|�9Y9�MNON2 T 8*OU9 O_6�9Yw(8:; S�9WQ:X �� � � X Q�F^O_6�9 J EVE M T Q K 9W2�> k � E � = =WONQ . 9`8 . QRS�O

O � �FE�� * � MN9�4 � * y C 25O_6 O_6�25M FN8*OU9 Q*X=[ 9�F�25Q K 476 8?>�V09?~ROP6�9 [ 9�F�25Q K M_6�QRS�; K 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9 .0/ 8 . QRS�O EBEVE � M

2�> �FE / 9�8?F�M � O_6�25M 2IM M T 8:;I;59�F O_6 8?> O_6�9A[ 9�F�25Q K S >�4�9�F�O_8*2�>0O / X QRFC8�FUS > ;59�>�V?O_6 Q*XWMN9�w?9�FU8*; T QR>0O_6�M

�b8*MUM_S T 2�>�V�8X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / [ FH9�4�2IMU2IQ�> Q*X ** � � ������� � ��� ���

y3mgQ(|�9�w?9�Fv~=OP6�9A8*4�4�S T S�; 8:ON9 K [ 6 8*MN98 K w(80>�4�9

Q*w?9�F�8CON9�> / 9�8?F�[ 9�F�25Q K M_6�QRS�; K-. 9 ��������#G;������ -��1#*# +�;5+"#G�/% y}gMN2�>�V O_6�9z[ 9�F�25Q K M`8*;5QR>�9�XZF�Q T O_6�9 ���?�VO ~ ���?�VE ~�8?> K ���?�VO K 8*O_8 ~ |�9�4�8?>38*ONON9 T [�OgONQ 4�8:;I4�S�;�8*OU9

�� � � K 2�F�9�4�OU; / y j+F�Q T O_6�9 . 9�MUO [ 9�F�25Q K MzX\F�Q T ���0�VO 8?> K ���?�VO ~ |�94�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9A8�[ 9�F�25Q K 476 8?>�V09 Q*X

�GE�� E � E =�M�~ 2 T [�; / 2�>�V �� � � � � � Y � � A � �FE�� * �YMN9�4 � * ycf�6RS�Mg2 >�[ FN8*4�ON254�9�O_6�9 K 8*O_8�4�S FNF�9�>0ON; /

8�w(8*25;�8 . ;59zQR>�; / 8*;5;IQ*| 8?>�S [ [ 9�FY;52 T 25O`ONQ . 9CMN9�OYQR>xO_6�9z8 . MNQ?;�S�ON9 T 8*VR>�25O_S K 9CQ*X �� � � XbQRF k � E � =V=

Q*X �� A � �FE � * � MN9�4 � *�y^o\> w�2I9�| Q*X�O_6�9Y2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>�4�9WQ*X T 9�8:M_S F�2�>�V �� � � X QRF�O_6�25M�MNO_8?F 7 8:Mn|�9�;5;�8:MnXbQRF

O_6�9�Q0O_6�9�Fc4�QRQ?; � C � 2�FcMNO_80F�M 7 |�9 T S�MNOn4�Q�>?ON2�>�S�9 80> 8*; / MN25M�Q*X=8?F�4�6�25w(8*; K 8*O_8�8?> K T QRS >?O^Q . MN9�F�w�2 >�V

4�8 T [ 8:2IV�>�M 2�>�O_6�9z>�9�8?F XZS�O_S FH9`ONQ T QR>�25ONQRFY8*;5;=O_6�9!H�>�Q*| > � C �Y2�FYMNO_8?FHM�|�25O_6�� � � �L�FEVE�TEVEVE {Cy

C 25O_6 X\F�9�a S�9�>?OYQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>+~+8?>A8:4�4�S T S�;�8*OU9 K [ 6 8*MN9z8 K w*8?>�4�9`Q:XG6 8*;EXG8z4 / 4�;59?~+4�Q TC. 2 >�9 K |�25O_6xO_6�9

ON9�4�6 >�25a S�9�M K 9�MU4�F�2 . 9 K 2�> � = y J ~�4�Q�S�; Kl. 9 S�MU9 K ONQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 �� � � X Q�F`k � E � =V= ~ k � = � @ � ~ 8?> K

k � � Y E YW2�> O�|�QCONQ`O_6 FH9�9 / 9�8?F�M�y^f�6�9 K 8*O_8C[ F�9�MU9�>?ON9 K 2�>e�6 80[�ON9�F J [ FHQ(w�2 K 9`8�H*9 / 80>�476�QRF�XbQRFcO_6�25M, R>=/ 2 E$N � ST6?;=UD/3< S B ��� �� �8=2�<I1)/�N AK1)6./3U��DC��I25;�@ �T2KS 1"/ 6R2 �7V������ � ���<./3/� 2 � �T/ )�V "�8�2��/)1)2 �/ �DV �&6?STE /3<�<.E 2���T/�106?>�25B

47A5;�B=U�S B ��A�6?> �(��� � � 2#� �T/ )�V ) " 25B�U���� � � � 2#� �T/ )�V � "�VM- A59R/�� /�158 /���2 E$S B�2 6?STAKB AK406?>�/ A51.S�KS B=2 �"UD2�6.2 4 1)A�E ��� � �8��S B=U �TC ND1)A��STU�/3U �DC � � ��1)2K;=/�1'����� � � N�1.S��52�6./&@3A E E ;DBDST@32�6?STA5B�" <?>=A59�<�6?>=/$2 E$N � ST6?;�UD/3< S B���� � 9:/�1)/"/3<.<./�BD6?ST2���TC6?>=/<.2�E /"2�<RS B���� � � 2KB=U��(� � �DVR>=/"2�E$N � ST6?;�UD/3< 1)/�N AK1)6./3U �DC �I25;�@ �T25S 1"/36�2�7V ����� � "�2KNDN�/3251"6.A � / S B /�1.1)AK15V

Page 109: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� A

2�>?w09�MNON25VR8*ON25QR>+y

C 9 6 8�w?9�M_6�Q*| >�O_6 8:O^O_6�9�[ F�9 K 254�ON9 K FU8*ON9�M^Q*X�[ 9�F�25Q K 4�6 8?>�V?9�2�> � C �Y2 F�MNO_8?FHMn>�9�8?F O_6�9�4�QRQ0; 9�> K

Q*X�O_6�9�2�>�MNO_8 . 2I;525O / MNO_F�2�[C8?F�9�MN9�>�MN25ON25w?9�ONQYO_6�9�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�QC[ F�Q K S�4�OU2IQ�>�FU8*ON9�M^S�MN9 K 2 > MNON9�;5;�8?F T Q K 9�;IM�ynf�6�9

[ 9�FHMN25MNON9�>�4�9YQ*X�O_6�9�MNQ?;�8?F^>�9�S�O_FH2 >�QC[ F�Q . ;59 T 6 8:M T 8 K 9�O_6�9�MNO_8?> K 80F KzT Q K 9�; Q:X�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q�2 >0ON9�FN8:4�ON25QR>�M

QR>�9Q*XWO_6�9 T Q0MNOC2 >0ON9�>�MN9�; / MN4�FNS�ON2�>�2 ��9 K O_6�9�QRF�259�M 2 > 8:;I;YQ*X [ 6 / MN254�M�yldW9�OU9�F T 2�> 8*ON25QR> Q*X �� 2 > O_6�9

� C �Y2�F^MNOP8?F�MGk � E � = =`8?> K k � = � @ � |�25;5;�[ F�Q*wR2 K 9W8?>C2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0OnON9�MUOnQ*X+O_6�9 MUO_8?> K 8?F K T Q K 9�;+8?> K

Q*Xn8?> / >�9�|iOP6�9�QRF�259�M [ S�O X QRFH| 80F K OUQ FH9�[�; 8:4�9�25O�y

Page 110: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�VO

�� ���!�7����� � � � � � ��� ��� � ��� �!� � ���� � �� �

�7� %.�� ��������"� �3-9-'��+��? ��D� ��D���2��; ��� �D��!"� +/�D�&%'��� ��2;�:F� � �3�"����;0#G���2%/;&4 ��9 ���;�+���� �������+��������3���2�*+ ������� %� ��� ��2;�+������ �+"�9���������"## � ? � ����� -/��+"�%� ��� ���;�: ��+��D �:F�"�F%'�2 �� �1��+�#G�����K ������D��+0�� ����+�� %/�!"�

� #G��+��/%� ��� ��%'�=��� 4 � �D� �*�� ���; %/���*## :F��:F�"������� ��D��� ����;�����D������D������;���D�2� � %.��!"�2�*#G�D:,#$� ������D� ���* �� 4�� ��2;����-/��+"� :F����D��: �,%'� #$� ��%/;���D������;���D�"�3��� %04"4"4 6

7 k^8?S�;�j�9 / 9�FN8 . 9�> K ~ ����� ����<���-/�"� ��� ��+"��"��; � (D���� %/� � +��*����+���@3A � "CFE

C 9�4�Q T 9CXbQRFW>�Q*| ONQAO_6�9C9�> K Q*XGQ�S FW2�>?w09�MNON25VR8*ON25QR>�M�yzf�6�25M�4�6 8?[�ON9�FYMPS TzT 8?F�2 ��9�M�QRS F`F�9�MPS�;IOUM�~

F�9 � 9�4�ONM^Q�>WO_6�9�2�F T 9�8?>�2�>�V�~*9�w*8*;�S 8*ON9�M^QRS F [ F�Q?V�F�9�MNM 2 >C[ S F�MPS�2 >�V�O_6�9G[ S FU[ Q?MN9�M^;�8*2 K QRS�O 2�>ze�6 8?[�ON9�F � ~

8?> K ] > 8*;5; / ~�8*M H0M�| 6 8:OG25MY;59PX O�OUQ . 9 K QR>�9?y

�0��� �"#�� � �R���

@WS FW[ S FU[ Q?MN9C25MWONQAS > K 9�F�MUO_8?> K 6�Q*| 8?> K | 6 / k C d MNO_80F�M [ S�;5M_8:ON9?~+MNQ O_6 8*OW8*MNO_F�Q�>�Q T 9�F�MY4�8?>

4�QR>0] K 9�>0ON; / 8?[ [�; / H�>�Q*|�;59 K V?9zQ*X�k C d'MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9 7 VR8*2�>�9 K w�2�8A8*MUON9�F�Q?MN9�25M T Q?;5Q?V / 7 ONQAMNOPS K / 6�Q*|

| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbMcX Q�F T 8?> K 9�w0Q?;5w?9`8?> K. 9�ONON9�FgS > K 9�F�MNO_8?> K OP6�9`[ 6 / MN254�M�O_6 8*O�V?Q*w?9�FU>�MnO_6�9�MN9`[ FHQR4�9�MNMU9�M�y

C�9 6 8�w?9Y[ S F�M_S�9 K k C d MNO_FNS�4�O_S FH9�wR2�8�O_6�9 [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> [ 9�F�25Q K M�8?> K O_6�9 8 K K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;�4�QR>�MUO_FN8*2�>0ONMnO_6�9 /

[ F�Q*w�2 K 9 X QRFgQRS F T Q K 9�;5M�yzDc9PX Q�F�9zO_6�9 . 9�V02 > >�2�>�V3Q*X�O_6�25M`|�QRFIH%~�OP6�9 [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>3MP[ 9�4�O_FNS T Q*XnQR>�; / 8

MN2�>�V?;59 � C � 2�F�MNO_8?FY|�8*M`S > K 9�FHMNONQ�Q K 2�> K 9�O_8*25;by!C�9 S�MN9 K Ci6�Q?;59�?c8?F�O_63f�9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�M

ONQ MNO_S K / O_6�9z[ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>�MWQ*XnO_6�9CO_6 F�9�9�Q?O_6�9�F�HR>�Q*| > � C �Y2�FYw(8?F�2�8 . ;59�M � |�25O_6�O_6�9`OUQRQ?;5MWQ*XG8:MNON9�F�Q R

MN9�25M T Q0;IQ0V / ~�|�9�M_S�4�4�9�M�X\S�;I; /3K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9 K O_6�9 T 8*MNMY8?> K ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / Q:XnOu|�QCQ*XnO_6�9�MU9 �bk � E � = =z8?> K

k � = � @ �� ~ 8?> K�T 8 K 9 8 X\8*2�F . 9�V02 > >�2�>�V�OUQ(|�8?F K S > FN8�w?9�;52 >�V�O_6�9 [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>3M_[ 9�4�OPFNS T Q*XGOP6�9�OP6�2 F K

�bk � � Y E Y y

J M_S FU[ F�25MN2�>�V�MU2 T 2I;�8?FH2IO / 9 T 9�F�V?9 K 8 T QR>�VWO_6�9Y[ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�V k C dWM�s�O_6�9�2�Fn[ 8*OUON9�FN>�MnQ:X�9�a S 8*;+[ 9�F�25Q K

M_[ 8*4�2�>�V M_[ 8?> 8�w?9�F / M T 8*;5; FN80>�V?9 XZFHQ T = � =V@�M�yio\>�4�;�S K 2�>�VlO_6�93k � � � MUO_8?F � � e � A E � ~cO_6�25M

Page 111: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� Y

S >�2EX Q�F T 25O / 9+"�ON9�> K MWQ*w?9�F�OP6 F�9�9CQRF K 9�F�MYQ*X T 8*V�>�2IOPS K 9�2�>�k C d ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / y`<�2�>�4�9 [ 9�FH2IQ K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V

2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�M^|g2IOP6 K 9�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�VW;�S T 2�>�Q?MU2IO / 7 8?> KzK 9�4�F�9�8:MN9�M=|g2IOP6W2�>�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V T 8*MNM 7 OP6�2IM^F�9�M_S�;5O 2 T [�;52I9�M�8

O_F�9�> K ONQ*|�8?F K MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0ON; / 6�25VR6�9�F T 8:MNM^|�25O_6 K 9�4�F�9�8:MN2�>�V`;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / O_6 F�Q�S�VR6�O_6�9�2 >�MUO_8 . 25;52IO / MUO_F�2�[+y

f�6�25M�O_FH9�> K 6 8*M�MN9�w?9�FU8*;+2 T [ QRF�OP8?>?O�2 T [�;5254�8*ON25QR>�MYXbQRFcQRS F�S > K 9�F�MUO_8?> K 2�>�V Q:X�k C d [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>�M�y�f�6�9

2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / 2IMgMN9�w?9�F�9�; / MN;5QR[ 9 K ONQ*| 80F K ;5Q*|G9�F � ��� |�25O_6 T 8:MNMn2�>�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�V K Q*| > O_6�9W2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MUO_F�2�[+y

f�Q-S > K 9�FHMNO_8?> K O_6�25MzMN;5QR[ 9 K 2 >�MUO_8 . 25;52IO / MNO_F�2�[+~^|�9 >�9�9 K 9 K 2�>0XbQRF T 8:ON25QR>�2�> 6�9�F�9�>0Oz2�> O_6�9 Q0O_6�9�F

X\S > K 8 T 9�>0O_8*;�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K O_FH9�> K s=OP6�9 K Q T 2�> 8?>?On[ 9�F�25Q K 2 > k C d [ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M K 9�4�F�9�8*MU9�Mn|�25O_6 K 9�4�F�9�8*MU2 >�V

;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / y C�9�X QRS > K O_6 8*O�OP6�9 K Q T 2�> 8?>0O�[ 9�F�25Q K 25M=4�Q�FNF�9�;�8*ON9 K |�25O_6WO_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T PSR T Q K 9n[ 9�F�25Q K ~

���� ?y^o�X ���� �25M�8gXZ8*4�OUQRF�2�> K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�2�>�VCO_6�9�FN8?>�V?9�Q*X�[ 9�F�25Q K M�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K 2 > [ S�;IMP8*ON2�>�Vzk C dlMNOP8?F�M�~

O_6�9�>C25O^M_6�Q�S�; K [�;�8 / 8WFHQ?;59 K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�2�>�V�|Y6�9�>z[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 4�9�8*MN9�M�~ . 9�4�8?S�MU9�O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V���QR>�9�OU9�> K MnONQ

K F�25w?9�;IQ�>�V?9�F 80> K ;5QR>�V?9�FY[ 9�F�25Q K M 2�> T Q K 9�;5M Q*X^V?25w?9�> T 8*MNM�~%8*M�O_6�Q?MU9 T Q K 9�;5M 9�w?Q0;Iw09`ONQz;5Q*|�9�F ������y

J O�;IQ*| 9�>�QRS�VR63ON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9?~ O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V���QR>�9z25MCQR>�; / 4�8?[ 8 . ;59 Q*X K F�25wR2�>�V�[ 9�F�25Q K Mz;5QR>�V?9�F O_6 8?>

���� ?~=8?> K [ S�;IMP8*ON25QR>�MCM_6�QRS�; K O_6�9�>34�9�8*MN9?y<�2�>�4�9 O_6�9zONQR[tQ*X�O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V ��QR>�9 T Q*w?9�MWONQAMP6�QRF�ON9�F

ON2 T 9�MN4�8:;I9�Mg|�25O_6 2�>�4�F�9�8*MN2�>�V T 8*MNM�~�8?> KK Q�9�M�MNQ�XZ8:MNON9�F^OP6 8?> � ��� ����+"�3���5%/�/% |g2IOP6 2 >�4�FH9�8*MN2�>�V T 8*MNM�~

6�25VR6�9�F T 8:MNM T Q K 9�;5MzM_6�QRS�; K [ S�;5M_8:ON9A8*OC;5Q(|�9�F � ��� O_6 8?> ;5Q*|�9�F T 8*MNM T Q K 9�;IM�y fg6�2IM . 9�6 8�wR25QRF 2IM

4�Q T [ 8:ON2 . ;I9�|�25O_6OP6�9WQ . MN9�F�w?9 K MU;IQ�[ 9CQ*X=O_6�9CF�9 K 9 K V?9�2 >xO_6�9W;5Q?V�P ;5Q?V�� ��� [�;�8?>�9?y

fg6�2IM T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T K Q�9�M >�Q0OG8*4�4�QRS >0O^XbQRF�O_6�9�;�8*4+HCQ*X�Q . MN9�F�w09 K 6�25VR6 R T 8*MNM�[ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M�8*OG6�25VR6 ������~

6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�y=fg6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*;�;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / X\S >�4�ON25QR>�M XbQRF�O_6�9�k C dlMNOP8?F�M�2�> K 254�8*ON9�OP6�9GQ . MN9�F�w?9 Kz. ;�S�9�9 K V?9c2IM

[ F�Q . 8 . ; / MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0ON; / 8���9�4�ON9 Kz.?/ MN9�;59�4�ON25QR> 9 ��9�4�OUM K S�9 FU8?[�2 K 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>z8:O�6�25VR6�� � � y�<�2�>�4�9 6�25VR6�9�F

T 8*MUM T Q K 9�;5M 9�w0Q?;5w?9 T QRF�9Wa S�254 H0; / ~=8?> K 8?F�9`;59�MNMW;�S T 2�>�QRS�M�~�8*O 8 V?25w?9�> � � �-O_6 80> T Q K 9�;5MWQ*X�;5Q*|�9�F

T 8*MUM�~�|�9 8?FH9 T QRF�9z;52 H*9�; / OUQ K 9�ON9�4�O`;5Q*|5R T 8*MUM`O_6 8?> 6�2IV�6 R T 8*MNMCk C dWM�8*O`8xV?25w?9�>3ON9 T [ 9�FN8*OPS F�9?y

f�6�25M |�25;I;W4�80S�MN9AMNOP8?F�MzONQ �_. S >�476 S [ � 8:VR8*2�>�MNOzO_6�93F�9 K 9 K V09A2�> O_6�9AQ . MU9�F�w?9 K 2�>�MNOP8 . 25;I25O / MUO_F�2�[+~

8?> K O_6�938?[ [ 8?F�9�>0O . ;�S�9A9 K V09A|�25;5; OP6RS�M � 8?F�ON2E]�4�2�8*;5; / � F�9�MN9 TC. ;59AO_6�9�M_6 8?[ 9AQ*X OP6�9-F�9 K 9 K V?9 7 >�Q

T 8*OUON9�F�|Y6 8*OWO_6 8*OWM_6 80[ 9 T 25VR60O . 9?y f�6�25M`MN9�;59�4�ON25QR> T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T ~�2 >t2IMUQ?;�8*ON25QR>+~ |�QRS�; K 2 T [�; / O_6 8*O

;5Q*|5R T 8*MNM�~*;IQ*| � ��� � C � 2�Fc[ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�M^MP6�QRS�; K . 9 T Q?MNO^>RS T 9�FHQRS�M^Q*X�8:;I;bynfg6 8*O=|�9�2�>�X\8*4�O ] > K����2���MNO_FH9�>�V?O_6�9�>�M�QRS F 4�QR>0] K 9�>�4�9CO_6 8*O�O_6�9 T 8*MUM9R K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>�4�9zQ:X=O_6�9�FH9 K 9 K V?9W25M 8zFH9�8*;�9 ��9�4�O 7 O_6 8*O�|�9

] > K >�Q ;IQ*|5R T 8*MNM�~�;5Q*|5R ����� � C �Y2�F�MNO_8?FHM . 9�4�8?S�MU9`O_6�9 / K QR>+B O�9+"�25MNO�y

j^2�> 8*;5; / ~ |�9Y9+" [�;5QRF�9 K OP6�9W9+"R4�25ON2�>�V [ Q?MNMN2 . 25;52IO / Q*X 4�QR>�MNO_FN8:2 >�2�>�VzOP6�9 2�> [ S�O�;59�[�ONQR>[ 6 / MN254�M�2�> QRS F

Page 112: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�?�

MNON9�;5;�8?F T Q K 9�;5M .?/ 9+" [�;5QRF�2�>�V�O_6�9�9 ��9�4�OUM^Q*X�>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q R\4�QRQ?;52�>�VC2�>C;5Q(| R � � � � C �Y2�F T Q K 9�;5M�y C�9�XbQRS > K

O_6 8*On>�9�S�OPF�2�>�Q`;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 2 > k C dWM^2�>�4�F�9�8*MN9�McMN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>?OU; / 8*M�8gX\FN8*4�OU2IQ�>`Q:X ONQ?OP8*;R9�>�9�FHV / QRS�OP[ S�On8*M

k C d T Q K 9�;IMY9�w?Q?;5w?9�ONQC;5Q(|�9�F�OU9 T [ 9�FN8:O_S F�9�M�ynfg6�2IMg9 ��9�4�Og2IMY9�> 6 8?>�4�9 K 2 > T Q K 9�;IMYQ*Xn6�25VR6�9�F T 8*MNM�~

MNQzOP6�9`k C dWM T Q?MUO K Q T 2�> 8*ON9 K-.0/ >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q 4�Q�Q?;52�>�V 80F�9`6�25VR6 R T 8*MNM�~ ;5Q(| R � � � MNO_8?FHMG;52 H*9zk � E � =V= y

C�9`[ F�9 K 254�O 8CFN8:ON25QzQ*X�>�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q ONQz[ 6�Q?ONQR> ;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / 2 >�k � E � =V=WQ*X^>�9�8?F�; / @ s � y f�6�25M [ F�9 K 254�ON25QR>

4�8?> . 9`ON9�MNOU9 KA.?/ Q . MN9�F�w�2�>�V OP6�9`FN8*ON9WQ*X^[ 9�F�25Q K 4�6 8?>�V?9?~ ��`~�2�>Ak � E � = =`Q�F�2�>Q?O_6�9�Fc4�Q�Q?; � C��Y2 F

MNO_80F�MW;52 H:9 k � = � @ � 80> K k � � Y E Y yzf�Q4�6�9�4 H�O_6�9 X 9�8*MU2 . 25;525O / Q*X�M_S�4�6�8xON9�MNO�~+|�9z9�w?Q0;Iw09 K)T Q K 9�;IM

|�25O_6 K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q�9 T 25MNMU2IQ�>lFN8*OU9�M 80> K XbQRS > K O_6 8*O �� 25M 8�MN9�>�MN25ON25w?9A2�> K 254�8*ONQ�FCQ*X >�9�S�O_FH2 >�Q

4�Q�Q?;52 >�V 9 ��9�4�OUM�y J 4�Q�>�4�9�F�ON9 K Q . MN9�F�w�2�>�V�4�8 T [ 8*25VR> 4�QRS�; K K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 ��l2�> k � E � =V=�8?> K Q?OP6�9�F^4�Q�Q?;

� C �Y2�F�MNO_8?FHMG2�>xOu|�QCONQzOP6 F�9�9 / 9�8?F�M�y

�0� � �" � � � � � �)(�% � ��(� �� �

� � K6� ' *!�# �N� ������� �!+�(� � �" *��Z#l *+� )�#��v �� � ��� �" � �+ ��(��� �

fg6�9 . QRS > K 8?FH2I9�M Q*X OP6�9 k C d 2�>�MNOP8 . 25;I25O / MNO_FH2 [ K 9�FH2Iw09 K X\F�Q T QRS FC[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> MNO_S K 259�M 8?F�9 X\8?F

M T 8:;I;59�F O_6 8?>3O_6�Q0MN9 . 8*MN9 K QR>�M_[ 9�4�O_FHQ?MN4�QR[�254 T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?ONM`8:;IQ�>�9?y f�6�QRS�V�63O_6�9 8*4�OPS 8*;nFN8?>�V?9CQ*X

;5Q?V�P 8?> K � ��� M_[ 8?> >�9 K-.0/ O_6�9 H�>�Q(|Y> [ S�;5M_8*OUQRF�M�25M >�QCM T 8:;I;59�F�OP6 8?> . 9PX Q�F�9?~ O_6�9W>�9�|�; / K 25MN4�Q*w?9�FH9 K

T 8*MUM9R\;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / F�9�;�8*OU2IQ�>�M_6�2�[2 T [�;5259�M O_6 8:OnO_6�9Y|�2 K O_6 Q*X�O_6�9YMNO_F�2�[ 2�> � � � �2���0(1�*!��"� #G� ( P 25M�a S�2IOU9M T 8:;I;b~�8?> K wR254�9�w?9�FHM_8 y C�9�4�8?>�O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9�>�QW;5QR>�V?9�F M_8 / X QRF�4�9�F�O_8:2 > O_6 8*O ����; >�QR> Ru[ S�;5M_8*ONQ�F�M^QR4�4�S [ /O_6�25MW>�9�|�; /K 2 T 2 >�25M_6�9 K 2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_FH2 [+~ MN2�>�4�9�OP6�9�S >�4�9�F�O_8:2 >0ON259�MY2 >�;5Q?V�PA8?> K � � � 8*M K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K

X\F�Q T M_[ 9�4�O_FHQ?MN4�QR[ / 8?FH9�;�8?FHV?9�FW>�Q*| O_6 80>AOP6�9�Q . MN9�F�w?9 K |�2 K O_63Q:XnO_6�9CMNO_F�2�[�25ONMN9�;EX 8*O`8zV02Iw09�>3;5Q?V7P

QRF � � � y

fg6�2IMY6�2IV�6�;I25VR60ONMYO_6�9W2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>�4�9�Q*X�] > K 2�>�V 8 K K 2IOU2IQ�> 8*;�[ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�M�|�25O_6x| 6�25476 ONQ XZS F�OP6�9�FGFH9P] >�9

QRS F�HR>�Q*|�;59 K V?9�Q*XnO_6�9�2 >�MUO_8 . 25;52IO / MNO_F�2�[ . QRS > K 80F�259�M�y o >-[ 80F�ON254�S�;�8?F�~%|G9�MNON25;5;�6 8�w?9C>�Q Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�M

|�25O_6�| 6�254�63ONQ 4�QR>�MNO_FN8:2 >�O_6�9�Q�F�259�MWQ*XnO_6�9 . ;�S�9z9 K V?9?~+MN2�>�4�9z25OW25M�S >�;52 H*9�; / O_6 8*OYO_6�9 �� %/������ %/�*+Y. ;�S�99 K V?9�;I259�MW>�9�8?F�O_6�9W4�S FUF�9�>?O �D:'%'����!����W. ;�S�9C9 K V?9`8*O 8?> / 9 ��9�4�OU2Iw09WON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9?y

o X O_6�9�O_FH9�> K |�9�6 8�w?9 K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F�9 K 4�QR>0ON2�>�S�9�M^ONQW9 ��9�4�ON25w?9�ON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9�M . 9�;IQ*| O_6�9�4�QRQ?;59�MNO H�>�Q*| >

[ S�;5M_8*ON2�>�V k C dWM�~�O_6�9�> 6�25VR6 R T 8*MNM � � � � � QRF^VRFH9�8*ON9�F | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbMGMP6�QRS�; K [ S�;IMP8*ON9`8*O�ON9 T [ 9�F R

8*O_S FH9�M�[ 9�FU6 8?[�Mz8*M`;5Q*| 8*M�A E ~ E EVE� OVE ~ EVEVE { �b8?> K ;IQ0V�P � � y f�6�9�2�F K Q T 2�> 8?>0O�[ 9�F�25Q K M �b8*VR8*2�>+~

Page 113: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�?�

8*MNMPS T 2�>�V)O_6�9 / XbQ?;5;5Q*| O_6�9�O_F�9�> K M QRS�ON;52�>�9 K 2 > e�6 80[�ON9�F�A |�QRS�; K . 93M_6�Q�F�ON9�FCO_6 80>l8?> / H�>�Q*| >

k C dWM�~+[ 9�FU6 8?[�M�8*MY;5Q*| 8*M%= EVE R^@ EVE M�y`< S�4�6�MNO_8?FHM |�QRS�; K >�Q?O . 9 k C dWM 8:O 8*;5; . S�O`FN8:O_6�9�F�|Y6�2IOU9

K |�8?F XbM�[ F�QR[ 9�FvyGf�6�9�2�F K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F / |GQ�S�; K 4�Q T [�;59�ON9`8 � 476 8*2�> � Q*X^w(8?F�2�8 . ;59�MNO_8?F�M XZF�Q T k���� MNO_80F�M�ONQ

� > 8VH:9 K ��k C dWMcONQ�6�Q?O�| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�~R80> K 8*McM_S�4�6zO_6�9 / |GQ�S�; K F�9�[ F�9�MP>�9�>?O�8W2�>�4�8*;54�S�;�8 . ;�9 . Q�QR> ONQ

8*MNOPF�QR>�Q T 9�FHMG|Y6�QzMNO_S K / O_6�9W;�8*ON9�MNO_8*V?9�M�Q*X^MNON9�;5;�8?Fg9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+y

� � K6� K �C+� .�*��&=�Z#�� �L� �0 �+#�� �:, � �R& � ���� �� �

fg6�9 F�9�MPS�;IOUMzQ*X`e�6 8?[�ON9�F�A�M_6�QRS�; K 80[ [�; / 9�a S 8*;5; / |�9�;5;�ONQ�8?> /�K F�25w�2�>�V T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T . 8:MN9 K QR>

25QR>�2 ��8*ON25QR>+~ 2�> K 9�[ 9�> K 9�>?OYQ*X=M_[ 9�4�259�M�yGfg6�9 K F�25w�2�>�V F�9�V?25QR> 2�>zQRS F T Q K 9�;5M 8?F�25MN9�McX\F�Q T O_6�9 25QR>�2 ��8*OU2IQ�>

Q*X=@�� oU~ . S�O�|�9G4�80> >�Q?On4�QR>�4�;�S K 9WO_6�9�FH9PX QRFH9�O_6 8*O�@ �Wo 25MnO_6�9YMNQRS F�4�9gQ*X�O_6�9�Q . MN9�FHw?9 K 2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / yGo >

[ 8?F�OU2I4�S�;�8?Fv~+O_6�9�MN9 T Q K 9�;IM K QA>�Q0O 2�>�4�;�S K 9 8 MN25VR>�2E]�4�8?>0OWX\FN8*4�ON25QR>xQ*Xn9�25O_6�9�F`>�25O_FHQ?V?9�>�QRFY>�9�QR>+~+9�w?9�>

O_6�QRS�V�6 >�25O_F�Q0V?9�>z25M�Q . MN9�FHw?9 K Q�>�; / 2 > OP6�9 k C dL[ S�;IMP8*ONQRF�M ��d`FH9�2 ��;59�F ���?�0� ~R80> K >�9�QR> M_6�QRS�; K 9+"�25MNO

2�>Ak C dLMNO_80F�M�8*O�8 T 8*MNMcX\FN8*4�ON25QR> Q:X�8 . Q�S�O � � y^f�6�9 K F�25w�2�>�V ��QR>�9W|g2I;5; QR4�4�S Fg8*O K 2 ��9�F�9�>0O K 9�[�O_6�M

2�> T Q K 9�;IMCQ*XW8V?25w?9�> T 8:MNM�8?> K � ��� ~ K 9�[ 9�> K 2�>�V QR> O_6�9 25QR>�2 ��8*OU2IQ�> ON9 T [ 9�FU8*O_S F�9 Q*X�O_6�9 M_[ 9�4�259�M

F�9�M_[ QR>�MN2 . ;59zXbQRF K F�25wR2�>�V�yCf�6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9�O_6�9CQ . MN9�F�w09 K [ Q?MN25ON25QR>3Q:XnO_6�9zF�9 K 9 K V?9?~�8*;5QR>�V|�25O_6�25ONMWMN;5QR[ 9

2�>3O_6�9C;5Q?V7P ;5Q?V � � � [�;�8?>�9?~�4�Q�>?O_8:2 >�MW2�>0XbQRF T 8:ON25QR>�QR>�O_6�9���QR>�9CQRF T QRF�9 M_[ 9�4�259�MzF�9�M_[ QR>�MN2 . ;59zXbQRF

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>+y

o X�O_6�9 F�9 K 9 K V09z25M�4�80S�MN9 K).0/ 2�>�4�Q T [ 8*ON2 . ;59ON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59�M . 9�O�|�9�9�> K F�25w�2 >�V�8?> K ����� ?~�O_6�9�>3|�9

>�9�9 K OUQ S > K 9�F�MNO_80> K 6�Q*|iO_6�9C8 T [�;525O_S K 9�MWQ*X T Q K 9�MW8?F�9`8 ��9�4�OU9 KA.?/ O_6�9�2�FY[ F�Q "R2 T 25O / 2 >3[ 9�F�25Q K ONQ

� ��� y^o\>e�6 8?[�OU9�F A�|�9 F�9�MNO_FH2I4�OU9 K QRS Fn8?> 8:; / MN25M�ONQ�O_6�9W[ F�QR[ Q�F�ON25QR> 8*;525O / Q*X � ��� ONQ T 8:MNMG8?> K ������y

J K 9�OP8*25;I9 K 4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR> Q*X ���� z6 8*M`>�9�w?9�F . 9�9�>�[ 9�FuX QRF T 9 K XbQRF 8k C d T Q K 9�;b~ . S�OW2EX�|�9C4�QRS�; K

K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9`6�Q*| O_6�9 4�6 8?>�V?2�>�V K 9�[�OP6zQ*X�O_6�9 K F�25w�2 >�V ��QR>�9WM_6�S�ONMnQ �-[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> 2�>F�9�M_[ Q�>�MN9 OUQ ���� *~

O_6�9�> |�9�4�Q�S�; K S�MU9zO_6�9zQ . MU9�F�w?9 K F�9 K 9 K V?9zOUQA4�8*;52 . FN8*ON9�� ��� 2�>�Q�S F T Q K 9�;5M�~^8*MNM_S T 2�>�V K F�25w�2 >�V

w�2 8t2IQ�>�2 ��8:ON25QR> Q*XWw(80F�25QRS�M K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O M_[ 9�4�259�M�ylfg6�2IM T 25VR6?O > 8?FNF�Q*| O_6�9FN8?>�V?9Q*XW[ Q?MNMU2 . ;59 K F�25w�2 >�V

T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T M�y J ;5ON9�FN> 8:ON25w?9�; / ~+2�X^|�9W4�QRS�; K MNQ T 9�6�Q*| 4�8*;52 . FN8*ON9������ WMU9�[ 9�FN8*OU9�; / ~%O_6�9�> |�9W4�QRS�; K S�MN9

O_6�9WQ . MU9�F�w?9 K FH9 K 9 K V?9WONQz2 K 9�>0ON2EX / O_6�9�M_[ 9�4�259�MWF�9�M_[ QR>�MN2 . ;59CX Q�F K FH2Iw�2�>�V�y

Page 114: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� EVE

� � K6� Z �C+� <�!+�0,-� ��"!�# �+#�� &g&+! �Z� ��"!�# !%��8 ��" �� . �C����� � ����*�

J > 2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O [ F�Q . ;59 T ONQC| 6�25476x|�9 T 25VR6?OY8?[ [�; / k C d MNO_S K 259�MY2IMYO_6�9 T 9�4�6 8?>�25M T .?/ | 6�254�6

| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX MW8?F�9�XbQRF T 9 K yCf�6�25M�F�9�a S�2�F�9�MCO_6 8*OY|�9�;52�> H3ONQ0V?9�O_6�9�FYO_6�9 K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O�H?2�> K M�Q*XGQ . MU9�F�w?9 K

| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbMn|g2IOP6zO_6�9�2�Fcw(80F�25QRS�M [ F�9�4�S F�MUQRF�M�y^<�2�>�4�9`O_6�9Wk � �?� A � MNO_80F�MnM_6�Q*| >�Q�w�25MN2 . ;59�6 /RK F�Q0V?9�>+~

25O�MN9�9 T MYS >�;I2 H*9�; / O_6 8*O�O_6�9 / 4�8?> X Q�F T d J | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�y dW9�6 >�9�F � {W8�|�8*;59�F � ���?� A 8?> K dW9�6 >�9�F

� ���0�VO 9�MNO_8 . ;525M_6�9 K 8?> 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / ;I2�> H . 9�O�|G9�9�> k C dWM;52 H:9 k � �?� A � 80> K d`D�� MNO_80F�M;52 H:9

� d:@VA � y�fg6�2IM^;52�> H�4�S FNF�9�>0ON; /`K 9�[ 9�> K MnQR> Q . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR>�M Q*X 8�MU2 >�V0;I9 � C � 2�F MNOP8?F�8?> K 8gMN2�>�V?;59Gd`D��Cy

}Y>0X QRFHO_S > 8*ON9�; / ~*>�QR>�9nQ*X O_6�9^4�Q�Q?;59�F � C � 2�F�MNO_8?F�M+MNOPS K 2I9 K 2�>`OP6�2IM�O_6�9�MN25M=MP6�Q(|�9 K 9�>�QRS�V�6W4�QR>�MN9�4�S�OU2Iw09

T Q K 9�M OUQ K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�9�83O_FN8?[ [�2�>�V�4 / 4�;59�8?> K O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9�ONQ T 8VH*9A8 K 2 � >�25ON25w?9 T 9�8:M_S F�9 T 9�>0OzQ*X`8

6�9�;52�S T ; 8 / 9�F O_6�254+HR>�9�MNM�~�8*M |�8*M K QR>�9xX Q�Fzk � �?� A � y+* mgQ(|�9�w?9�Fv~n>�Q*|'O_6 8*Oz|�93S > K 9�F�MNO_8?> K O_6�9

. 8*MN254 T Q K 9MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9��2by 9?y�~�O_6�9A[ 9�F�25Q K M_[ 8:4�2 >�V X Q�F`OP6�9Q?O_6�9�F � C �Y2 F MNO_8?F�M�~^|�9 4�8?> [ FH9 K 2I4�O

8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9�; / | 6�9�FH9z2�> [ 9�F�25Q K 8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*; T Q K 9�M 7 [ F�9�M_S T 8 . ; / ONQ�QAM T 8*;5;n2�>)8 T [�;52IOPS K 9ONQ . 9

K 9�ON9�4�ON9 K 2�>A[ F�9�w�25QRS�M Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�M 7 M_6�QRS�; K�. 9?y

fg6�9 . 9�MNO[�;�8*4�93ONQ�;5QRQSH X QRF 8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*; T Q K 9�M 25M 2�> w?9�F / 6�25VR6 MN25VR> 8*;>R\ONQ Ru>�Q02IMU9-;525VR60O 4�S FHw?9�M

Q . O_8:2 >�9 K 8:On;�8?F�V?9 � J y E T 4�;�8*MNM�QRFc;�8?F�V?9�F ON9�;59�MN4�QR[ 9�M�yn1�S�;5ON2>R\MN25ON9 K 8*OP8�80F�9 >�Q?O�>�9�4�9�MNM_80F / XbQRFcO_6�9�MN9

Q . MN9�FHw(8*ON25QR>�M�~ . 9�4�8?S�MU9|G98*;�F�9�8 K / HR>�Q*| O_6�9 . 8*MN254A[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> [ 8*OUON9�FN>tXZF�Q T O_6�97C ?nf Q . MN9�F�w*8 R

ON25QR>�MW[ F�9�MN9�>0ON9 K 2�>-eg6 8?[�ON9�F J y�j^2�> K 2�>�VA8zMU2 >�V0;I9 8 K K 25ON25QR> 8*;n[ 9�FH2IQ K 8*OYO_6�9�8?[ [ FHQ "�2 T 8*ON9C[ Q?MU2IOU2IQ�>

[ F�9 K 254�ON9 KA.0/ O_6�9 [ FH9�wR25QRS�MN; / K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9 K [ 8*OUON9�FN>C25M�>�Q*|l9�>�QRS�VR6 ONQ T 8 H*9 8`FH9�; 8:ON25w?9�; / ] F T T Q K 9TR

2 K 9�>?OU2�]�4�8:ON25QR>+yGfg6�9 � �3��+�� %/� [ Q?MU2IOU2IQ�>Q*X=MPS�476 T Q K 9�M�4�8?> OP6�9�> ]�;I;�2 >xO_6�9YO_6�9`6�Q?;59�M�2�>O_6�9`[ 8:ONON9�FN>+~

8*;5;5Q*| S�M OUQ�2 K 9�>0ON2EX / 8CO_FN80[ [�2 >�V 4 / 4�;59?~+8?> K ;59�8 K ONQ T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?O�Q:X�O_6�9`6�9�;52�S T ;�8 / 9�F�O_6�254+HR>�9�MNM�y

fg6�9 6�9�;52�S T ;�8 / 9�FYO_6�254+HR>�9�MNM�Q*X � C �Y2�FWMNOP8?F�MW8*;5MNQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9�M`O_6�9z4�Q�Q?;52�>�V-FN8:ON9CQ*XGO_6�9�2�F K 9TR

MN4�9�> K 9�>0ONM�y�C�Q�Q K � ���0� = 8?> K C 2�>�V?9�O � �n8?>3m�Q�FN> � ���?� Y M_6�Q*|�9 K OP6 8*O OP6�9 6�9�;52�S T ;�8 / 9�F T 8*MNM

8���9�4�ONMYO_6�9z8?[ [ 8?F�9�>0OW8*V?9�MYQ*XG| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM�yWf�6�9C| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F Xn;�S T 2�>�Q?MN25O / XZS >�4�OU2IQ�>A25M�QR>�9CQ*XnO_6�9

T Q?MUOn[ F�9�4�25MN9 |�8 / M^ONQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9�|Y6�9�>zO_6�9gVR8*;�8*4�ON254 K 25M H�|�8*M XbQRF T 9 K ~�8?> K O_6�9�F�9PXbQRF�9 T 9�8:M_S F�9 T 9�>0O

Q*XG8 K K 25ON25QR> 8:; � C � 2�FW6�9�;52�S T ;�8 / 9�FYO_6�254 H�>�9�MNMN9�M�25M`8?>2 T [ QRF�O_8?>0O T 9�8?>�MWOUQ 4�8*;52 . FN8*OU9�OP6�9 8:V?9`Q*X

O_6�9WVR8:; 8 " / y, % 259R2�T/�158 � � 1.ST/�B'8=/36 2 �7V ���(� � "I<?; /3<.6�/���STU�/)B�@3/"6?>=2�6:6?>�/�>�/ � S ;=E �T2KC /�1�S BMF���� ���!� ST<R@3A E$N�251)2 � �T/ S B E 2�<.<:6.A

6?>=2�6 47AK;DB�U S BMF��&� � ��8 �D;�6:6?>�ST<I1)/ <?; �T6IST< ��2 <./3U AKBMAKB �TC 6?>D1)/3/ E A�UD/3<R6?>=2�6 UDAKB 6R<?N=2KBM/�� /�BMAKB=/ @3A E$N �T/36./ 6?1)25N�NDS B @3C�@ �T/ V

Page 115: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� E �

j^2�> 8*;5; / ~c2�X � C � 2�FCMUO_8?F�M�9�w?Q?;5w?9ONQ�9�w?9�>?OPS 8*;5; /l. 9�4�Q T 9d`D MNO_8?F�M�~=OP6�9A[ F�Q . ;59 T F�9 T 8:2 >�MCQ*X

9+" [�; 8:2 >�2�>�V3O_6�9�d`D VR8?[ . 9�O�|�9�9�> @ E ~ EVEVE 8?> K J A ~ EVEVE {Cy+o\>3e�6 80[�ON9�F � ~%|G9 T 9�>0ON25QR>�9 K O_6 8*O T 8*MNM

;5Q?MNMW6 8*M . 9�9�>�2 K 9�>?ON2E]�9 K 8:M 8 ;52 H:9�; /�T 9�80>�M ONQ T 8*M H 6 /�K F�Q?V09�>2�>�O_6�9�8*O T Q?M_[ 6�9�F�9�MYQ*XGk C dWM�yGo >

O_6�25MY4�8*MN9?~ 25OY2IMY2 T [ Q�F�O_8?>0O OUQzMN9�O�Q . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�> 8*;�;52 T 25ONMWQR> T 8*MNM9R\;5Q?MNMYFN8*ON9�M�X\F�Q T � C � 2�FgMNO_8?FHM�~ ONQ

X\S F�O_6�9�F�ON9�MUO�O_6�9W9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 80F / ;52�> H . 9�O�|G9�9�>�k � �?� A � MNO_8?F�MY8?> K d`D�� M�y

h 9�4�9�>?ON; / ~�8 MNOP8?F�|�25O_638 M_[ 9�4�O_FUS T w?9�F / MN2 T 25;�8?FYONQ O_6�9zk � �?� A � MNO_8?FHM�~ 9+"�4�9�[�OWM_6�Q*|�2�>�VMN25VR>�M

Q*X=6 /RK F�Q0V?9�>+~�| 8:M K 25MN4�Q*w?9�F�9 K ��d`FH9�2 ��;59�Fc9�O�8*;by ���?�VO y=f�6�25M�MNO_8?Fv~RmY<�=V@ = J � @ � J J ~*25M 8*;5MNQ�8C[ S�;5M_8*OUQRF

�b<�25;5w?Q?ONOU2 ���?�VO 80> K MNQ�M_6�QRS�; KC. 9n4�;�8*MUMN2E]�9 K 8:M=8�>�9�|��b6 /�K F�Q?V?9�> RuF�254�6 � C �Y2�F�MNOP8?F�y�f�6�9�[ Q?MNMU2 . 25;525O /

O_6�S�M 80F�25MN9�MWQ*X K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�2�>�VA25ONMW9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / MNO_8:ON9`w�2�8 [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>3MNO_S K 259�M�yWk 9�FN6 8?[�M T 8*MUM9R\;5Q?MNMW6 8*M

4�9�8*MN9 K 2�>�mY<�=V@V= J ~%4�8?S�MN2�>�VO_6�9z6 /RK FHQ?V?9�>�ONQ a S�254+H?; /3K 2 ��S�MU9zONQ wR25MN2 . 25;52IO / yzf�6�9zm 8?> K m�9C;�8 / 9�F

O_6�254+HR>�9�MNMU9�MWXbQRF�OP6�2IM�MNO_8?FY8*;5MNQA[�;�8*4�9z;52 T 25ONM�QR> . Q?O_6�25ONMW9�w?Q0; S�OU2IQ�> 8?F / [ 8*MNO ����� X\S�O_S F�9?~ .0/ OU9�;I;52�>�V

S�M�8:OW| 6�25476 MNO_8*V09 K S FH2 >�V�8 O_6�9�F T 8*;n[ S�;5MN9 4 / 4�;59 2IOC;59PXbO`O_6�9 J � DY~�8?> K 6�Q*|LX\8*MNOW25O`|�25;5;�4�QRQ0;n8*M

8 | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XNy j^2 > 8:;I; / ~Y|�25O_6 [ F�9�4�25MN9 T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>?O�~�w�2�8)[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>+~�Q*X`;5Q?V Pl8?> K ;5Q?V � ��� XbQRF

mY<�=V@V= J ~ |�9`4�8?>xON9�MNO�Q�S F�2 K 9�8*MYQ*XnO_6�9 . ; S�9z8?> K F�9 K 9 K V09�MWQ*X�OP6�9 � C �Y2�FY2 >�MUO_8 . 25;52IO / MNO_FH2 [x;�8*2 K

QRS�O�2�>�e�6 8?[�ON9�FGA y

�0��� ���'���"#"��#&� �G()� � ��� �����I��() �� �R�&! ���'� ����

13QRFH9Gk C d O_80F�V?9�ONM^8?F�9�>�9�9 K 9 K ONQWF�9P] >�9�QRS F H�>�Q*|�;59 K V?9�Q*X OP6�9n2�>�MNO_8 . 25;525O / MNO_F�2�[+y o\>z[ 8?FHON254�S�; 80F�~

|�9z>�9�9 K ONQMUQ?;5w?9 T QRFH9/H�>�Q*| >3k � � �YM�80> K � C �Y2�F�MNO_8?F�M�~�ONQOU9�MNOWQRS FWOP6�9�QRF / Q:XGO_6�9 FH9 K 9 K V?9

8?> K ONQ`[�;�8*4�9WMNO_8:ON25MNON254�8*;�;52 T 25ONM�QR> O_6�9�;5Q�4�8*ON25QR> Q*X�O_6�9 . ;�S�9W9 K V?9?y j%QRF^2�>�MNO_80>�4�9?~R|�9 [ FH9 K 2I4�OgO_6 8*O�~*2EX

���� K 9�ON9�F T 2 >�9�MgO_6�9 FN8?>�V09�Q*X�Q . MN9�F�w09 K [ 9�F�25Q K M 8*Mc|G9�;5;+8*Mn| 6�9�> [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR> 4�9�8:MN9�Mn2�> 8`[ 8?F�OU2I4�S�;�8?F

MNO_80F�~?O_6�9�> O_6�9�F�9gM_6�QRS�; KA. 9W>�QC;IQ*|5R T 8*MNMG[ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�Mc|�25O_6���� � MN2 T 25;�8?F�ONQ�O_6�9�4�Q�Q?;59�MNO � C �Y2 FcMNOP8?F�M�y

o�XN~�QR> O_6�9YQ?O_6�9�F�6 8?> K ~ MPS�476 w*8?F�2�8 . ;59�M 8?F�9gXbQRS > K ~ O_6�9 / |g2I;5;�;52 H*9�; / 6 8�w?9 T S�4�6 ;5QR>�V?9�F�[ 9�FH2IQ K MYO_6 8?>

O_6�9�Q?O_6�9�F � C �Y2 F MNO_80F�M�ylo > O_6�25M 4�8*MN9 ���� A25M ����� 2 T [ QRF�O_8?>0Oz2�> K 9�OU9�F T 2�>�2�>�V O_6�9�2�F [ 9�F�25Q K M�~

| 6�254�6z2�>�MNON9�8 K ;52 H*9�; / XbQ?;5;5Q*| OP6�9�;59�>�V?O_6�9�>�2�>�VzO_6�9�F T 8*; ON2 T 9�MN4�8*;59WQ*X�O_6�9 K F�25wR2�>�V���QR>�9?ynoZOn25M�[ Q?MNMU2 . ;59

M_S�4�6 MNO_8?F�M K Q)2�> K 9�9 K 9+"�25MNO�~�MU2 >�4�9 T Q?MNOzMU9�8?F�4�6�9�M X QRF k C d [ S�;5M_8*OU2IQ�>l4�Q�>�4�9�>?O_FU8*ON9AQ�>lMP6�QRF�ON9�F

[ 9�FH2IQ K MYO_6 8*On|�9W[ F�9 K 254�O�;5Q*|5R T 8*MNM�~R;5Q*|5R � ��� k C dWMcM_6�QRS�; K 6 8�w?9?s A EVEVE�+�FEVEVE M�y J 4�Q T [ F�9�6�9�>�MU2Iw09

Q . MN9�FU8�w*8*ON25QR> 8*; [ F�Q?VRFN8 T 25M 4�8*;5;59 K XbQRF�ONQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9C2EXnM_S�476xMNO_8?FHM�9+"R25MNO�y�?^25O_6�9�FgQRS�ON4�Q T 9YX Q�F�M_S�4�6

Page 116: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� E =

8�MNO_S K / |�QRS�; K MN9�w09�F�; / 4�QR>�MUO_FN8*2�> O_6�9 [ Q?MNMN2 . ;59 T 9�476 8?>�25M T M F�9�M_[ QR>�MN2 . ;59AXbQRF�[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> 2�> k C d

MNO_80F�M�y

J 4�Q�>�4�9�F�ON9 K 9 ��QRF�O�M_6�Q�S�; K 8*;5MNQ . 9 T 8 K 9`ONQ T 9�8*M_S FH9`O_6�9CFN8*ON9�Q*XG[ 9�F�25Q K 476 8?>�V09`2�>3O_6�9�O_6 F�9�9

4�Q�Q?; � C �Y2 FYMUO_8?F�MWk � E � = = ~ k � = � @ � ~+8?> K k � � Y E Y y J > /-T 9�8*MPS F�9 T 9�>0O Q*X �� X Q�F�O_6�9�MU9�MUO_8?F�M

|�25;5;�4�QR>�MNO_FN8:2 >tQRS FWO_6�9�Q�F�259�M�Q:X >�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q39 T 25MNMN25QR> 2�> k C d 2�>?ON9�FH2IQ�F�Mz8?> K [ F�Q*w�2 K 98AS >�25a S�9ON9�MNO

Q*XnO_6�9CMNOP8?> K 8?F K ;I9�[�OUQR>3O_6�9�QRF / 2 > K 9�>�MN9 [�; 8:M T 8 yW<�9�w?9�FN8:;�8*;5ON9�FU> 8*ON25w?9�MWONQ O_6�25MWO_6�9�QRF / 6 8�w?9 . 9�9�>

XbQRF�|�8?F K 9 K 2�>8?> 8*ONOU9 T [�OnONQ�MNQ?;5w?9YO_6�9YMNQ?;�8?F�>�9�S�O_F�2�>�Q [ F�Q . ;I9 T yne�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�M�Q:X�OP6�9 [�;�8*M T QR>8?> K

. F�9 TzT 9�MNO_FN8?6�;�S >�V3>�9�S�O_F�2�>�QA9 T 25MNMU2IQ�>�FN8*ON9�MY2�>�k C dWM . 8*MU9 K Q�>AOP6�9�MN9zO_6�9�QRFH2I9�MWMP6�QRS�; K). 9 T 8 K 9?~

ONQzMU9�9W2�XnOP6�9 / 4�8?> . 9`9+"�4�;�S K 9 Kt.0/ k C d �� T 9�8*M_S F�9 T 9�>0ONM�y

@W> OP6�9 MNOU9�;I;�8?F 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> MN2 K 9?~%|G9W>�9�9 K ONQzS > K 9�F�MNOP8?> K 6�Q*| k C d MNOP8?F�MGFH9�8*4�O�ONQ K F�25wR2�>�V>�9�8?F

O_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T PSR T Q K 9`[ 9�F�25Q K y�<�O_S K 259�MWM_6�QRS�; K-. 9�S > K 9�F�OP8VH*9�>OUQ K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9�O_6�9�8*4�OPS 8*; T 8 "�2�S T

[ 9�FH2IQ K 2�>Ak C d T Q K 9�;IM�yGk C dL9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>xMN9�a S�9�>�4�9�MWM_6�QRS�; K-. 9`4�QR>�MNOPFNS�4�ON9 K O_6 8*O�4�QR>0O_8*2�>�8*;5;�O_6�9

9�;59 T 9�>0ONMWO_6�QRS�VR60OYONQz9+"�2IMUOW2 >3k C d MNO_8?FHM�y5C�9z6 8�w?9WQ . MN9�F�w*8*ON25QR> 8*;^2�>0XbQRF T 8:ON25QR>ONQ ON9�MNOY8*;5;^O_6�9�MN9

4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�M�~+8?> K |�25O_6 O_6�9WQ . MU9�F�w(8*OU2IQ�> 8*;�[ F�Q?VRFN8 T [ F�QR[ Q?MN9 K 8 . Q*w?9?~�|G9Y|�25;5;�VR8*2�> T Q�F�9?y^f�6�9�F�9Y2IM

T S�476 OUQ K Q�y

�0� � � ��$% �)# �=(� ��

fg6�9�Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�8?> K OP6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*; T Q K 9�;52�>�V-Q:X k C d w(80F�2�8 . 25;I25O / |�25;I; . 9 FH2I4�6�8?> K F�9�|�8?F K 2�>�V

]�9�; K M�X QRF MNQ T 9-OU2 T 9�ONQ 4�Q T 9?y 1�8?> / [ F�Q . ;59 T M-FH9 T 8*2�> ONQ . 9�MNQ?;5w?9 K ~W8?> K O_6�9�Q . MN9�F�w(8:ON25QR>�M

8?> K 8?> 8*; / MN25M [ F�9�MN9�>0ON9 K 2 > OP6�2IMCO_6�9�MU2IM [ F�Q*wR2 K 9 2 >�25ON2�8*;g4�QR>�MNO_FN8:2 >0ONMCONQ�ON9�MNO�XZS�OPS F�9 2 K 9�8*M�y J MCQRS F

H�>�Q(|g;I9 K V09`Q*Xnk C d [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�MW2�>�4�F�9�8:MN9�M�~%MNQ K Q�9�MYO_6�9`4�QR>0] K 9�>�4�9z8?> K MN4�QR[ 9`|�25O_6x| 6�25476x|G9�4�8?>

8?[ [�; / O_6�9AF�9�MPS�;IOUMzQ*X`[ S�;IMP8*ON25QR> MUO_S K 259�M ONQ3O_6�Q0MN9A[ F�Q . ;59 T M | 6�25476 S�;5ON2 T 8*ON9�; / 2�>?OU9�F�9�MNO S�M T Q?MNO�s

| 6�25ON9 K |�8?FuX�XbQRF T 8*OU2IQ�>+~?MNON9�;5;�8?F�9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR> 2 > V?9�>�9�FN8*;b~ 8?> K O_6�9Y[ 6 / MN254�M�Q*X MNOU9�;I;�8?F�2�>?ON9�FH2IQ�F�M�y � F�9�8*ON9�F

S > K 9�F�MNOP8?> K 2�>�V�Q*X�O_6�9�MN9 9+"ROPF�2�>�MN254-[ F�Q . ;59 T MC|�25;5;�O_6�9�> Xb9�9 K . 8*4+H32�>0ONQAVRFH9�8*ON9�F`S > K 9�FHMNO_8?> K 2�>�V�Q*X

2�>?OPF�2�>�MN254-a S�9�MNON25QR>�M Q*X`k C d MNO_FUS�4�O_S F�9-80> K 9�w?Q?;�S�ON25QR>+~ 80> K MNQ)Q�>+y k 9�FN6 80[�Mz|�9|�25;I;g] > K O_6 8*O

? K K 2�>�V?OUQR>|�8*M�F�25VR60O�~ | 6�9�>�6�9W4�;�8*2 T 9 K�. 8*4 H 2�> ��� = O O_6 8*O

� 4"4�4/���� %��3���5%/��� �D:/#G�������D� � ����D��� �*� ��D��� �������"���2� %/�������1-��1�.�D�3������%��D��## : � +��� � �"���"� ������1������� %/����� ��%/�)%'� � #G�0� ��D���( �5%0�=%/�����'4 6

Page 117: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� E @

��� �!��� � ��� ��� � � ��� ��� � � �!��� � ��

J w*8?F�2�8 . ;59�[ F�9TR\| 6�25ON9 K |�8?F X`MNOP8?FC25M 8 F�9�MNQ�> 8?>?O 4�8�w�25O / X QRF >�QR> RuFN8 K 2 8:;GPSR T Q K 9AQ?MN4�25;5;�8*ON25QR>�M�y

f�6�25MCM_[ 6�9�F�254�8*;5; / M / TzT 9�O_F�254z4�8�wR25O / 25M . Q�S > K 9 K .0/ O_6�9zMNON9�;5;�8?F 4�9�>?ON9�F ��QRF O_6�9zQRS�ON9�FY9 K V09zQ*X�O_6�9

K 9�V?9�>�9�FN8:ON9`4�QRFH9�2�> � ��e 9�ON2�80> K d`D�� | 6�25ON9 K |�8?F XbM 8?> K M_S F X\8*4�9?y J OYM_S � 4�259�>0ON; / ;IQ�>�V [ 9�F�25Q K M�~

6�Q*|�9�w?9�F�~%O_6�9CM_S F X\8*4�9C; 8 / 9�FHM`>�Q ;5QR>�V?9�F�F�9 � 9�4�OW2�>?OU9�FN> 8*; | 8�w?9�M�y fg6�9 [ S�;5M_8:ON25QR>39�>�9�F�V / O_6�9�>3;59�8VH0M

QRS�O�O_6 F�QRS�VR6tO_6�9 MPS F XZ8:4�9?~ K 8 T [�2�>�V�OP6�9 [ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>+y3f�6�25MC2 K 9�8�|�8*M ] F�MNO�80[ [�;I259 K ONQ�| 6�25ON9 K | 80F X

[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>�M .0/ mY8?>�MN9�>+~SC 2 >�V09�O � {W8�|�8*;59�F � ���?� A ~*| 6�Q�8:ONON9 T [�ON9 K ONQ`4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9WOP6�9 8?[ [ F�Q "�2 T 8*ON9

4�F�25ON254�8*;cX\F�9�a S�9�>�4�259�MCONQ�9+" [�;�8*2�> . Q?O_6tO_6�9 FH9 K 9 K V?9 8?> K T 8 "�2 T S T Q . MN9�FHw?9 K [ 9�FH2IQ K MC2�> � � e�9�ON2

MNO_80F�M�y J MUM_S T 2�>�VA8?>�? K K 2�>�V?ONQ�>3VRFN8 / 8*O T Q?MP[ 6�9�F�9?~+O_6�9 /AK 9�FH2Iw09�OP6�9`XbQ?;5;5Q*|�2�>�VA9+" [ F�9�MNMN25QR>�XbQRFgO_6�9

K 2 T 9�>�MN25QR>�;59�MNM�4�F�25ON254�8*; PSR T Q K 9YX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / s

� �� #

� � � � ��� �

� J y ��

| 6�9�F�9

� � �@ P � �A���� � � � � � J yB=

mg9�F�9�Pt80> K � F�9�[ F�9�MN9�>0O`O_6�9 [ 6�Q?ONQ?M_[ 6�9�FH2I4 M_S F X\8*4�9zVRFN8�w�25O / 80> K FN8 K 2�S�M�~^8?> K ���?~ �+~=8?> K �l6 8�w?9

O_6�9�2�FYS�M_S 8*; T 9�80>�2 >�V%y

fg6�9 K 2 T 9�>�MN25QR>�;59�MNMWX\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / ~ � ~ 25M FH9�; 8:ON9 K ONQzO_6�9`[ S�;5M_8:ON25QR> X\F�9�a S�9�>�4 / ~ � ~%8*4�4�QRF K 2�>�VzONQ

� � � � � �P

� J yB@

f�6�9z[ S�;5M_8*ON25QR>3[ 9�F�25Q K 25M � � = � � ~ MNQ 4�Q TC. 2�>�2�>�V ?^a S 8*ON25QR>�M � J y �� OP6 F�QRS�VR6 � J yB@ |�9C8?FNF�25w?9z8*O

O_6�9 T 8 "R2 T S T PSR T Q K 9`[ 9�F�25Q K s

����� # � J E� � �

� � � � �� � � � � � �EBE = � � � � ������FE � { � � � � � � � J y J

Page 118: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� E J

QRF�~ S�MN2�>�V O_6�9�FH9�; 8:ON25QR> � � � � � J � � �� � ~

���� # � J E� � �

� � � � � � � � � � �@VA�� � � � � � � � � ��FE � { � � � � � � J yBA

j%QRF�k � �0� A � ~�|�25O_6�� � = E E � � 8?> K � ��� � �+J E�TEVEVE {C~V?^a S 8*ON25QR> � J yBA [ F�9 K 254�ONM ���� �� Y � E M

XbQRF ��� � T Q K 9�M 8?> K J A E MgX QRF ���]= T Q K 9�M�y � k � E � =V= ~R|g2IOP6 � � A BO � � 80> K � � � � �VE � EVEVE {C~

|�QRS�; K 6 8�w?9�� ��� �;AV@ E M�XbQRF ��� � 8?> K @ �FE MgX QRF ���;= y�Dn9�4�80S�MN9`Q*XnOP6�9`MN2 T [�;5254�25O / Q*X^O_6�9�VRFN8 /

8*O T Q?M_[ 6�9�F�9z8*MNMPS T [�ON25QR>+~�OP6�9�MN9z>RS TC. 9�FHM�8?F�9 T Q�F�9�S�MN9PX\S�;n2�>34�Q T [ 8?F�25MNQR>�ONQ9�8:476�Q?O_6�9�FYOP6 8?>38*M

a S 8?>?OU2IOP8*ON25w?9 K 2 8:VR>�Q?MNON254�MzQ:X O_6�9 T 8 "�2 T S T [ 9�FH2IQ K y�j%QRF�2�>�MNO_8?>�4�9?~nmY8?>�MN9�>+~ C 2�>�V?9�O � {W8�|�8*;59�F

� ���0� A ] > K O_6 8*O�O_6�9 w(8*;�S�9�MzQ*X ����� K 9�F�25w?9 K XZFHQ T O_6�25M 80> 8*; / MN25M 80F�9 � |�25O_6�2�> 8xX\8*4�ONQRF Q*X�= �AQ*X

O_6�Q?MU9 . 8*MN9 K QR> T Q�F�9 F�25V?QRFHQRS�M`4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�M�y�C�9 8?F�9 T Q�F�9z2�>?OU9�F�9�MNON9 K 6�9�F�9 2 > O_6�9FNS >3Q*X ����

|�25O_6�F�9�M_[ 9�4�OgONQzV?;5Q . 8*;�MNON9�;5;�8?F�a S 8?>?OU2IOU2I9�MYM_S�4�6A8*M �l8?> K � ��� y

o X ����� K 9�ON9�F T 2�>�9�M�O_6�9�;5QR>�V Ru[ 9�F�25Q K 4�S�OUQ �A2�> � C � 2�Fn[ S�;5M_8:ONQRF�M�~0O_6�9�> O_6�9�O_6�9�;5QR>�V09�MNO�[ 9�F�25Q K

� � � T Q K 9�MWM_6�QRS�; K�. 9��b80[ [ F�Q "R2 T 8*OU9�; / 8 XZ8*4�OUQRF�Q*X � y>YV@CON2 T 9�MW;5QR>�V?9�FYOP6 8?>O_6�9C;5QR>�V?9�MUO`[ 9�F�25Q K

��� = T Q K 9�M�ynk � �?� A � 2IMYO_6�9WQR>�; / � C �Y2�F�MUO_8?Fc|�25O_6A[ Q?MN25ON25w?9�; / 2 K 9�>?OU2�]�9 K � � = T Q K 9�M�yno\>xO_6�9

[ 9�FH2IQ K ;52IMUO Q*X C 2�>�V?9�O 9�OY8*;by � ���?� �� ~?OP6�9`;5QR>�V?9�MNOY[ 9�F�25Q K �Z[ Q?MN25ON25w?9�; / 2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K ��� = T Q K 9�6 8:M 8

[ 9�FH2IQ K Q*X J =VA�M�~ | 6�25;59CO_6�9W;5QR>�V?9�MNOW[ 9�FH2IQ K ��� � T Q K 9C6 8*M 8z[ 9�F�25Q K Q*X � J E M�ycf�6�9�FN8:ON25QzQ*X^O_6�9�MN9

O�|�Q [ 9�F�25Q K MW25M � y �?� ~ 4�;5Q?MN9�ONQ O_6�9�[ F�9 K 254�ON9 K FN8:ON25Q�y�f�6�9�[ 9�F�25Q K MWOP6�9 T MN9�;5w?9�M`8?F�9`8:;IMUQ M_S FU[ F�25MN2�>�V?; /

4�;5Q?MN9�ONQCO_6�9`4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON9 K w(8*;�S�9�M�y

fg6�9 [ F�9 K 254�ON9 K FN8*ON25Q?M . 9�O�|�9�9�> O_6�9 ;IQ�>�V?9�MNO [ 9�F�25Q KlT Q K 9�M 8*;5MNQ�6�Q?; K XbQRF�2�>?ON9�FH4�Q T [ 8?F�25MNQ�>�Q*X

K 2 ��9�F�9�>?O MNO_8?F�M�y)f�6�9;5QR>�V?9�MUO [ 9�F�25Q K T Q K 9MNQ�X\8?F�2 K 9�>0ON2E]�9 K X Q�F�k � E � =V=25M O �?� M�~ � y>@VY�ON2 T 9�M

M T 8:;I;59�FCOP6 8?>�OP6�9 ;5QR>�V?9�MUO [ 9�F�25Q K 2�> k � �?� A � ~=8*V�8*2�> w?9�F / 4�;5Q?MN9 ONQ3O_6�9[ F�9 K 254�ON9 K FU8*ON25QAQ*X � y J @

X\F�Q T ?^a S 8*ON25QR>�M � J y J 8?> K � J yBA yzf�6�9 8*V�F�9�9 T 9�>0O . 9�O�|�9�9�> � �� XZFHQ T QRS F`FHQRS�VR6�4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�M

8?> K O_6�9`Q . MU9�F�w?9 K-T 8 "R2 T S T [ 9�F�25Q K MW2 > � C �Y2�F�MUO_8?F�M�25MY2 T [ F�9�MNMN25w?9 9�>�QRS�VR6OUQz|�8?FNFN8?>0OcXZS FHO_6�9�F

MNO_S K / yCo\> [ 8?F�ON254�S�;�8?F�~ T QRF�9CF�25V?QRF�QRS�MWOP6�9�QRF�9�ON254�8*;^4�8*;54�S�;�8*ON25QR>�MCQ*X ���� CM_6�QRS�; K). 9 S > K 9�F�O_8 H*9�>3ONQ

4�QRFNFHQ . QRFU8*ON9YQRF�F�9PX\S�ON9WO_6�9�MN9`FH9�M_S�;5ONM�y

� �0<.<?;�E&S B M2 E$S � AK4�� � -0/ � DV ) DV � DV � �DC E 2 <.<38�STE$N �TC�S B � � � ���DV

Page 119: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� E A

� �F��� � � ��� � � �

JW. F�2 H*Q?MNQ*w+~ J y ��� OVE ~ � ! � ����� ����~ � � ~ � Y � Y

JYK 8 T M�~ � y�DYy�~ h�S K 9�F T 8?>+~%1 y J y � C�Q�Q�~ eWy�m�y ���VO @ ~�� �1;"%"4�� ��! 4 ~ A � ~ � @ � @

J [ [�;I9�OUQR>+~ k y ��y�~ {W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy � ?�25ONON9�F�~ � y � y ���?� @ ~ ��� ~ A ��� ~ ��� YV@

D�8?6�4�8*;5;b~ � y �`y � k^2�>�MNQR> >�9�8?S�;5O�~+1 y�m�y ���?�VO �&� � � ~ A&B � ~ A O y E �

Dc9�8?S K 9�O�~ � y�~ k 9�O_F�Q?MU2 80>+~ ��y � < 8*;�[ 9�ON9�F�~ ?�y>?�y ���VO Y ~ � � � ~ A�C� ~ � Y �

Dc9�F�V?9�F�Q�>+~�k y�~SC�9�MN9 T 8*9�;b~%j�y � j�QR>0O_8*2�>�9?~ � y ���?� = ~ � � � ~ ��B ~ = �?�

Dc9�F�V?9�F�Q�>+~�k y�~ < 8���9�F�~�hWy � p�2I9 . 9�F�O�~ � y ���?� = ~ � � � ~ � ��� ~ =V= �

DcQR> K ~�m�yB?�y"~ e 2 80F K S�;5;IQ%~�hWy � 139�8VH*9�M�~�1 y � y ���?� � ~�2�> � :��'��+"���!"� � � ��� %' ��� � � ��D��� �R�D��!"��;"%� ��8 �� �����;=�3-����*+,�D��#G�5% � ��� ���1#$���5? ~ 9 K y J y � y dzy�kn6�25;52�[ �LJ yEhWy�}Y[�VRF�9�>+~ �b<�4�6 >�9�>�9�4�O_8 K / sd`8�wR25M ~ [ � �

DcQR> K ~�m�yB?�y � e�2�8?F K S�;5;5Q�~ h y ���0� @ ~?2�> �)�D�*��� <>����� -�%�� � ��!�����+��/%��*� � :'%'����!������*�2� %������ � �D������; ~9 K y 1 y J y DG80F�MNONQ*|`~ ��dWQRF K F�9�4�60O�s^{Y; S0|�9�F ~�[ J�� �

DcQR> K ~�m�yB?�y"~ e 2 80F K S�;5;IQ%~�hWy � {W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy ���?� @ ~ �.+���� � %/� 4 ~ � � ~ J =VA

DcQR> K ~�m�yB?�y"~ � FN8?S�9�F�~ J y dzy�~ � FH9�9�>+~�hWy j�y � p�2I9 . 9�F�O�~ � y ���?� J ~ � � � ~ �� ~ YVA �

DcQR> K ~�m�yB?�y 9�O 8*;by ���?� O ~ ��� ~ A�A ~ = O?�?�

DcQ*|G9�>+~ � y�m`y � C 25;5;5MNQR>+~+p^y J y ���?� � ~ � � � ~ ��C ~�p6AV@

D�FN8 K ;59 / ~+k=y J y ���?� J ~�� ��< ��D�/%/� % ~ } >�25w+y f�9+" 8*M 8*O J S�MNON2�>

D�FN8 K ;59 / ~+k=y J y � C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?�y ���?� J ~ � � � ~ � ��� ~ � A E

D�FN8*MNMP8?F K ~ k y�~ j�Q�>?O_8:2 >�9?~ � y�~SC�9�MN9 T 8*9�;b~ j�y�~ {W8�| 8:;I9�Fv~�<+y dzy � f 8*MNMNQ�S�; ~ 1 y ���0� � ~ � � � ~ ��� ~ OVE �

D�F�254 H�6�25;5; ~ J y � y ��� YVA ~ 8 ��� � � ~ A �� ~ J E A

Page 120: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� EVO

D�F�254 H�6�25;5; ~ J y � y ���?� @ ~ 8 ��� � � ~ �� � ~ AV@VY

D�F�254 H�6�25;5; ~ J y � y ���?� � 8 ~�8 ��� � � ~ 1C�A ~ O Y @

D�F�254 H�6�25;5; ~ J y � y ���?� � . ~ 8 ��� � � ~ DC ~ @ @ J

e�6 8?> K FU8*MN9FH�6 8?F�~R<+y ��� @ � ~ � �)������3�"� �D+����*��� ��� � ����#*#G��� � �����D+��.�D�3� ~ �beg6�2I4�8:V?Q�s^} >�25w+y�e�6�254�8*V?QzkcF�9�MNM

e�6�2�>+~+eWy C y�~Reg6�2 S+~+m�y q�y � <�ONQ?O_6�9�F�M�~ h y ��� OVO ~ � � � �1; ~ � � ~ = � E

e�2�8?F K S�;5;5Q�~+hWy � DnQ�> K ~�m`y>?�y ���0�VO ~ ��� ~ A�A�A ~ =V@V@V=

e�;59 T 9�>�M�~ � y�e y ���?� J ~�� �2< ��D�,%'� % ~ }Y>�25w y�f�9+" 8*M 8:O J S�MNON2�>

e�Q?MUO_8 ~ � yB?gy�<+y � {Y9�[�;59�F�~+<+y�@Cy ���?�0� � ��#G� 4 � %'� 4 ~ ~ � @

e�Q "+~ � y�k y ���?�VE ~ � �D���2��;�� - � ���"##G��� � �1# %'�2���*��� ~ �bknF�2�>�4�9�ONQ�>+snknF�2�>�4�9�ONQ�>A}Y>�2Iw+y+knF�9�MNM

dW9�6 >�9�F�~�DYy�f y ���?�VO ~ � �2< ��D�,%'� % ~ oZQ(|�8C<�O_8*OU9`} >�25w+y

dW9�6 >�9�F�~�DYy�f y � {W8�| 8:;I9�Fv~�<+y dzy ���?� A ~ � � � ~ ����C ~+p �+J��

dW254�S�M�~%dzy J y ��� YV= ~ � �D;�%,4 � �"!54 ~ <�� ~ � J��

dW254�S�M�~%dzy J y"~R{YQ?; . ~ ?�y C y�~ <�4�6 FN8 TzT ~�dzy ��y � f S . . M�~%dzy�p^y ��� YV= ~ � � � ~ DA� ~ JR� �

dWQ?;59 �?~ ��y � �n80S�4�; 8:2 Fv~ � y ���?� � ~ � � � ~ A�� ~ @VYVA

dWQRF T 8?>+~ D y"~ h QRQ K ~ h y � @CB�e QR> >�9�;5; ~+hWy ���?� @ � � � ~ � A � ~ A � O

d`F�9�2 ��;59�F�~+<+y ���?�?� ~ � ��#G� 4R� %'� 4 ~ ~ Y �

d`F�9�2 ��;59�F�~+<+y�~ C�9�FN>�9�Fv~�{Cy�~ m�9 . 9�F�~+}`y � ?c>�V?9�;5M�~%dzy ���?�VO ~ � � � ~ ��� � ~ � = E

d`F�9�2 ��;59�F�~+<+y � mg9 . 9�F�~%}`y ���?�?� ~ � � � ~ ��� � ~ O ���

d ��259 TC. Q*|�M H02b~ C y ��� YVY � +"���14R��%/� 4 ~ ~ �

j�Q�>?O_8:2 >�9?~ � y�~�134 � FN8�|`~ � y�fWy"~ dW9�8?F . QRFN>+~�dzy�<+y�k y�~ � S�MUO_8�XbMNQR>+~ � y � p�8:4�Q TC. 9?~+k=y ���0� = ~ � � � ~ 1C5B ~O A �

j�Q�>?O_8:2 >�9?~ � y�9�O 8*;by ���0� � ~ � � � ~ � /B ~�p J��

j�Q�>?O_8:2 >�9?~ � y � C�9�MU9 T 8*9�; ���0� Y ~?2�> � �D�� ��+��2����� �2�/-/�"�3�"� +�� ��� �2�*� � � #+�1�� �����F% ~ o J }e�Q?;5;5Q�a y � AC9 K M�y J y � y dzyRkn6�25;52�[+~�dzy�<+y mY8 / 9�M � � y�p�2I9 . 9�F�O�~ �b<�4�6�9�>�9�4�O_8 K / snd`8�w�2IM [ @ ���

j�9 / > T 8?>+~%hWy�k y � � 9�;5;>R\1�8?> >+~%1 y ��� A � ~�� �D;�%,4 � ��! 4 ~ A� � ~ ��� @

� 80S�ONMN4�6 / ~ J y ���?� Y ~ � � � ~ � �� ~ � �0�

Page 121: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� E Y

� Q0; K FH9�2I4�6+~+k=y � C)S+~ qCy ���?�?� ~ � � � ~�2 >�[ F�9�MNM

� FU8?S�9�F�~ J y dzy � DcQR> K ~�m�yB?�y ���?� J ~ � � � ~ ~ = �?�

� FU8?S�9�F�~ J y dzy�~ � F�9�9�>+~�h y j�y � p+259 . 9�FHO�~ � y ���?� = ~ � � � ~ � � � ~ O?�VO

� FH9�9�>�MNON9�2�>+~ � y�p^y ���0� = ~ � � � ~ DC5B ~ OVO �

� FH9�9�>�MNON9�2�>+~ � y�p^y ���0� J ~ � � � �G~ ��� ~ O =

� FH9�9�>�MNON9�2�>+~ � y�p^y ���0�VO ~ � � � ~ ��� � ~ @V@ J

mY8?>�MN9�>+~�eWy � y � {W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy ���?� J ~ � ���"##G��� �� ���"���*���F% � � �D;�%'�+��2# � �����+�� � #$�,% � �����1+"�.�1� � ��� �� !���#+�D������ ~ � ��9�|iq^Q�FIH�sc< [ F�2�>�V?9�F R �^9�F�;�8*V

mg2I;5;b~ � y J y�~SC 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy � �Y8*O_6�9�F�~ hWyB?gy ���?� Y ~�2 > � ��+��2����� �2�/-/�"�3�"� +������ ������ � #+�D� � �����F% ~9 K M�y J y � y dzyRkc6�2I;52�[+~+dzy�<+y�mY8 / 9�M � � y%p+259 . 9�F�O�~ �b<�4�6�9�>�9�4�O_8 K / snd`8�w�25M [ O =VY

mY8?F�w?9 / ~ � y C yR9�OY8*;by ���?�VO � +"��"��+�� ~ � ~ � = � J

mY8?>�MN9�>+~�eWy � y�~SC 2 >�V09�O�~ dzyB?gy � {W8�| 8:;I9�Fv~�<+y dzy ���?� A ~ � � � ~ � ~ A JVJ

o . 9�>+~ oUy � F�y ���?� J ~ � � � ~ ~ @V@V@

o . 9�>+~ oUy � F�y ���?� � ~ � � �'�:� � � ~ � ~ AVA

o . 9�>+~ oUy � F�y � h�9�> ��2�>�2b~ J y ���?� @ ~ ��� � � ~ DA ~ =VY �

o . 9�>+~ oUy � F�y � f S�O_S H*Q*w ~ J y �Cy ���?� J ~ � � � ~ �B� ~ O � A

obOUQR6+~ ��y�~ m 8 / 8*MP6�2 ~%m`y�~ �g25M_6�2 H�8�|�8 ~ J y � {YQR6 / 8 T 8 ~ ���?�VO � � � �R� � � ~ A�� ~ J��0�

� QR>�9�M�~�k y C y�~ k 9�M_>�9�;5; ~ C y dzy�~ mY8?>�MN9�>+~�eWy � y � {W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy ���?�0� ~ � � � ~ ����� ~ J E @

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy ���?� O ~�� ��< ��D�,%'� % ~ }Y>�25w y+f�9+" 8*MY8*O J S�MNON2�>

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy ���?� Y ~�2 > � �D�� ��+�������� ���/-/�"�3�"� +����2� ������ � #+�1� � �����F% ~�o J }Le�Q?;5;5QRa+y � A ~9 K M�y J y � y dzyRkc6�2I;52�[+~+dzy�<+y�mY8 / 9�M � � y%p+259 . 9�F�O�~ �b<�4�6�9�>�9�4�O_8 K / snd`8�w�25M [ = � Y

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy � C�9�25MNM�~+k y ���?� E ~?2�> � �3� (D�3�,%�%��3- � �"� %' ���#G�F(D;��3-0��D���R�D� ������� �����F% ~9 K M�y qCy�@YM_8 H?2 � m�y�< 6�2 . 8?6 8*MP6�2 ~+p+9�4�O_S FH9 �gQ?ON9�M�2�>Akc6 / M�y @ O Y ~ [ J @ �

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy ���?� A ~ � �2#$� 4$� %'� 4 ~ � ~ @ = �

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy ���?� O ~�2 > � ����#*#G����� �� �� �����% ~ < J J < R\j�9�9Ce�QRS F�MU9%=VA ~ � �g9�| q^QRFIH%sn< [ F�2�>�V?9�F R �^9�FH; 8:V

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy�~ mY8?>�MN9�>+~�e y � y � C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzy>?�y ���?� A ~ � � � ~ ��C ~ A J Y

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy � D�FN8 K ;59 / ~+k=y J y ���?� J ~ � � � ~ � ~ J%� A

Page 122: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� E?�

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy�~ DcQR> K ~�m�yB?gy�~ < 6�9�F . 9�F�O�~�p^yB?gy � C)8:ONMNQR>+~ fWy�{Cy ���0� J ~ � � ~ A� ~ = �?�

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy�~ @CB�D�F�259�>+~ 1 y�<+y 9�O 8*;by ���?� A ~ � � � ~ � ~ J�� A

{W8�|�8*;59�F�~�<+y dzy�~ <�9FH0252 ~+fWy � � QRS�VR6+~ dzy ���0�?� ~ � � � ~�M_S . T 25ONOU9 K

{Y;59�2�> T 8?>+~�<+y � y ���?� A ~ � ��< ��D�/%/� % ~ }Y>�2Iw+y+f�9+" 8*M 8*O J S�MNOU2 >

{Y;59�2�> T 8?>+~�<+y � y 9�O 8*;by ���?�0� ~ � � � ~�M_S . T 25ONON9 K

{YQ�9�MNON9�F�~ dzy�9�O 8:; y ���?� A ~ � � � ~ A�� � ~ J =V@

{Y2�F ��6 >�25O��?~+dzy J y ���VOVE ~ � ! � � ��� ���G~ ��B ~ A E @

{WS H�80FIH?2�>+~+DYy ��y 9�O 8*;by ���VO0� ~ � �"�����3��# � ������#G� ('�D���3-���������D:/#G� � �����F% ~ @0F K 9 K y ��13Q?MN4�Q*|`s�� 80S H�8

p+259 . 9�FHO�~ � y 9�O 8*;by ���?�VO ~ � � � ~ � � � ~ = J%�

p+QRS [+~%eWy�~ j%QRF�w?9�25;5;59?~ fWy"~ @ T QR>?O�~ J y � k^8?S�;b~ � y j�y ���?� @ ~ � � � �:� � � ~ � � ~ = � �

@CB�D�F�259�>+~%1 yE<+y�~ e�;59 T 9�>�M�~ � yEeWy�~�{W8�|�8*;59�F�~ <+y dzy � dW9�6 >�9�F�~%D yEfWy ���?� O �Z@We�{Yd � � � ~ � � ~ @ � Y

@CB�D�F�259�>+~%1 yE<+yR9�OY8*;by ���?�?� � � � ~ ���C ~ J A �

139�MNON9�;b~�p^y ��� AV==8 � � � � ~ A�A ~ A � @

134 � FN8�|`~ � y�fWy ��� YVY ~�� ��< ��D�/%/� % ~ }Y>�2Iw+y+f�9+" 8*M 8*O J S�MNOU2 >

134 � FN8�|`~ � y�fWy ���?�VE ~ � � 4�� +�� 4 � ��! 4 ~ ~ O E �

13Q?ON4�6+~ eWy�~SC�9�FN>�9�F�~%{Cy � k^8VH�S�;5;b~�1 y C y ���?� @ ~ � � � ~ ��5B ~ A O �

�Y8*O_6�9�F�~�h yB?�y�~SC 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzy>?�y�~ e�;59 T 9�>�M�~ � y�eWy�~%m 8?>�MU9�>+~�eWy � y � m�2�>�9?~+D yEk=y ���?�VE ~ � � � ~ ����A ~ @ E0�

�g2 H:Q?;5Q(w+~ ��y � f�MNw09�O H*Q�~ fWy ��� YV= ~ ��%/� 4�� � 4�� +"��4 ~ � � ~ = � �

k^8*4 � / >�M H02 ~%D y ��� Y E ~ � +"����� %'� 4 ~ �� ~ J Y

h�Q . 2�>�MNQ�>+~ ?gy�p^y ��� Y � ~?2�> �)�D�*��� <>����� -�% ~+o J }Le�Q?;5;5Q�a y AV@ ~ [ @ J @

h�Q . 2�>�MNQ�>+~ ?gy�p^y�~ {Y9�[�;59�F�~�<+y�@Cy � �Y8*O_6�9�Fv~�hWyB?gy ���?� = ~ � � � ~ DC � ~ = ���

h�Q . 2�>�MNQ�>+~ ?gy�p^y 9�O 8:; y ���?� A � � � ~ � ��B ~ � E?�

< 8*25Q�~�m�y ���?�VO ~R2�> ��;5���3� (D��� <>� � +"��"� � � �����F% ~R9 K M�y�eWy�<+y � 9 �=F�9 / � }`y mg9 . 9�F�~ J < kl<�9�F�259�M �VO ~ [ @ O �

< 8*25Q�~�m�y�~ C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?�y � h�Q . 2�>�MNQ�>+~ ?gy�p^y ���0� @ ~ � � � ~ ���C ~ �?� =

Page 123: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

� E?�

< 8*;�8 T ~ J y ���VO?� ~�2�> � #$�� ��"�����2��; � �2�����+"#G� � �D;�%/�*+,% ~�9 K y �`y <�w*8?F�O_6�Q?; T ~ �b<�ONQ�4+HR6�Q?; T s J ; T a S�25MNO �C 2 H?MN9�;5;5M ~+[ @ O Y

< 8*;�[ 9�OU9�F�~ ?gy ���VO � ~ � � � ~ A�� � ~ OVO?�

< 8�w?9 K Q �n~�1 y�k y�~ �n8?>m�Q�FN>+~�m�y 1 y � � 25;�8 ~�<+yEeWy ���VO0� ~ � � � ~ A�C�C ~ =V= �

<�4�6��QR> . 9�FN>�9�F�~%dzy ���?� � ~�2�> � �D;�%'�+���# � �3�"+��/%�%'�,%.�� � ��� � ������% ~�9 K M�y�oNy+o . 9�>+~ � F�y �LJ y�h�9�> ��2�>�2b~�bh�9�2 K 9�;bs�dWQRF K FH9�4760O ~�[ J O @

<�4�6��QR> . 9�FN>�9�F�~%dzy ���?�VO ~ � � � ~ A�� � ~ ���?�

<�25;5w?Q?ONON2b~+hWy ���0�VO ~ � � � ~ ��� � ~%p6=V@

<�25QR>+~ ?�y 1 y ���?� J ~ � � � ~ �B� ~ O � =

<�O_8?>�V�6�9�;I;52�>�2b~�p^y�~�e�Q " ~ J y ��y � <�OP8?FNF ]�9�; K ~ <+y � y ���?�VE ~?2�> � ���,-'�3��� �������*�2��: ������������� ���"##G��� � �1# %/����������� � � !"��#+�1���*��� ~�9 K M�y e y eg8*4�4�2�8?F�2 � � y e�;59 T 9�>0ON2�>�2 ~ J < kle QR>0XHy%<�9�F�y �^Q?;by �?� ~ [ A = J

<�O_8?>�V�6�9�;I;52�>�2b~=p^y"~ {W8:;I9�Fv~ � yED y � < 6 8�|�~�hWy J y ���?� J ~ � � � ~ ��A ~ O E J

<�O_8?FUF ]�9�; K ~�<+y � y"~ e Q "+~ J y �`y�~%m�Q K MNQR>+~�<+y C y � k 9�M_>�9�;5;b~ C y dzy ���?� @ ~ � � � ~ ��5B ~�p =VY

<�O_8?FUF ]�9�; K ~�<+y � y"~ e Q "+~ J y �`y�~%{Y2 K�T 8?>+~�hWy�DYy � k 9�M_>�9�;5;b~ C y dzy ���?� J ~ � � � ~ �B1A ~ �VEVE

<�ON9�w?9�>�MUQR>+~ dzy � y ���0�VE ~ � � �D;�% ~ ��A ~�eG=

f 8*MNMNQRS�;b~ 1 y ���?� E ~ � � �'�:� � � ~ � � ~ J O0�

f�6�9�r�;5; ~+k y�~ �^9�> >�9�M�~+<+y � < 6�2�[ T 8?>+~+m�y�p^y ���0� � ~ � � � ~ ��� ~ @VA A

�n8?S�4�;�8*2�F�~ � y�9�OW8*;by ���?� @ ~ � � � ~ 1A�C ~�p � Y

�n8?S�4�;�8*2�F�~ � y�9�OW8*;by ���?� A ~ � � � ~ � � ~ Y E Y � � k �

C)8*OUMNQR>+~ {Cy ���?� = ~ � � � �*�3+54 ~�� A O E @

C�9�FN>�9�Fv~�{Cy ���?� A ~ � �2#$� 4 � %/� 4 ~ � ~ @ J E

C�9�FN>�9�Fv~�{Cy�~�mg9 . 9�F�~%}`y � m S >�V09�F�~�{Cy ���0� � ~ � � � ~ ��� ~ J @VY

C�9�FN>�9�Fv~�{Cy � hg8?S�476+~%fWy ���?� J ~ � � � ~ �B � ~�p = � J

C�9�2 K 9 T 8?> >+~ �Cy � {YQR9�MUON9�F�~ dzy ���?� J ~ � � � ~ A��� ~ ��� A

C�9�2�> . 9�F�V�~+<+y ��� O Y ~ � �D;�%,4 � �"!54�� �������"�F% ~ A � ~ � = O J

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy ���?� � ~�� ��< ��D�/%/� % ~�}Y>�25w y%h�QR4�6�9�MNON9�F

Page 124: Pre-White Dwarf Pulsation - Variations on a Theme

�0�FE

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy ���?�?� ~�2�> � ��!�����+��/% �*� ���"#G�*� � �2��� � %'����� � � %/�"� %' ���#G� (1; ~Ro J } < / T [+y � =V@ ~9 K M�y � y�e�6 F�25MNON9�>�MU9�> R\d`8*;5MNVR8?8?F K�� <+y j+FN8?> K MN9�>+~ �Zh�9�2 K 9�; s�dWQ�F K F�9�4�6?O ~R[ @ E A

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy � j%QR>?OP8*2�>�9?~ � y ���?� = ~�2�> � �1# %'�2���*��� %>�� � #$�&%�%/�*+���# ����� � ������+�#G;"%/ ��*+ ��������D:/#G� � �����F% ~9 K M�y � y�k y�e�Q " � e y � y m 80>�MN9�>+~ �bDcQRS�; K 9�F�s�} >�25w+y e Q?;5QRFN8 K Q ~ [ JSO

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy�~ h�Q . 2�>�MNQR>+~ ?�yEp^y�~ � 8:O_6�9�F�~�hWy �`y � j%QR>0O_8*2�>�9?~ � y ���0� = ~ � � � ~ �� ~�p �0�

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy�~ m 80>�MN9�>+~�eWy � y � �n8?>mgQRFN>+~�m�y 1 y ���?� @ ~ �����.�1� � ~ ����� ~ Y � �

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy�~ {Y9�[�;59�F�~ <+yE@Cy�~�h�Q . 2�>�MNQ�>+~ ?gy�p^y�~ �Y8*O_6�9�F�~ hWyB?gy � @CB dWQR>�Q?VR6�S�9?~�dzy ���?� A ~ � � � ~ � ~OVEVO

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy � �n8?>mgQRFN>+~�m�y 1 y ���?� Y ~�� �D�� ��+������ � ���/-/�"�3����+��0��� ������ � #+�D�� ���2� % ~�o J }e�Q?;5;5Q�a y � AC9 K M�y J y � y dzyRkn6�25;52�[+~�dzy�<+y mY8 / 9�M � � y�p�2I9 . 9�F�O�~ �b<�4�6�9�>�9�4�O_8 K / snd`8�w�2IM [ @ O @

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy�9�O 8*;by ���?� Y ~ � � � ~ �DA2C ~�p6YVY

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy�9�O 8*;by ���?� � ~ � � � ~ �,B ~ @V= O

C 2�>�V?9�O�~ dzyB?gy�9�O 8*;by ���?� J ~ � � � ~ � � � ~ � @ �

C�Q�Q K ~ 1 y J y ���?� = ~ � � � ~ ��B�� ~ AV@ �

C)S+~ qCy ���0�?� ~�� ��< ��1�/%/� % ~ e�8*;5ON9�4�6

@� ��;�6.A E 2�6?ST@ 47A51)E 2�6.6?S B �DC � F � ��� � ����"8�2 ND1)A�U ;=@36&AK4��7AK9:2 � 6.2�6./���B�S�� /�1)<?ST6?C �RA E$N�;=6.2�6?STA5B � /)BD6./�158'UD/�P<?S�KB=/3U��DC ��A�<.25B�B=/ �$V F A�6.6./�1 2KB=U���A�/ � 6?1.;=<.< �RAK1.S�5S B�2� ��� � ��� UD/3<?S�KB �DC ��A <.2KBDB�/ �$V F A 6.6./�1 2KB=U � 6./ ��/�B �IV% ;DB���V