61
Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany - August 19, 2009 Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 1

Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Probing Supersymmetric

Cosmology at the LHC

Probing Supersymmetric

Cosmology at the LHC

Alfredo GurrolaOn behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow)

Karlsruhe, Germany - August 19, 2009

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 1

Page 2: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Outline

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 2

Motivation

Goals

General approach to extracting Dark Matter relic density

Case studies:

Co-Annihilation

Focus point

Over-dense Dark Matter region

Work in progress

Page 3: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Motivation: Content of the Universe

“Normal” MatterStill Unknown

Does not interact with light (“invisible”)Relic Density: A measure

of the density of dark matter left in the universe

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 3

Page 4: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Our main goal is to develop techniques/methods to extract the relic density from measurements at the Large Hadron Collider.

Relic density calculation depends on the particular case of interest:

Goal

3 22eqnnvHn

dt

dn )( 3 22 SnnvHn

dt

dneq

Standard Cosmology Non-Standard Cosmology

[Case 1] “Coannihilation (CA)” RegionArnowitt, Dutta, Gurrola, Kamon, Krislock, Toback, PRL100 (2008) 231802

For earlier studies, see Arnowitt et al., PLB 649 (2007)

73; Arnowitt et al., PLB 639 (2006) 46

[Case 2] “Over-dense” RegionDutta, Gurrola, Kamon, Krislock, Lahanas, Mavromatos, NanopoulosPRD 79 (2009) 055002

[Case 3] “HB/Focus Point” RegionArnowitt, Dutta, Flanagan, Gurrola, Kamon, Kolev, Krislock

Supercritical String

Cosmologye.g., Rolling dilation in Q-cosmology

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 4

Page 5: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

General Approach We want to take a general approach that is “independent” (to the largest

possible extent) of the particular model or scenario we are targeting:

Measure the global SUSY scale- Allows us to filter out models/scenarios that are not consistent with the global scale

1

Identify smoking-gun variables- e.g. Different points in SUSY parameter space can allow for similar global scales. We need to find the “smoking-gun” variables to discriminate between them

2

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 5

Page 6: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

General Approach We want to take a general approach that is “independent” (to the largest

possible extent) of the particular model or scenario we are targeting:

Parameterize variables in terms of “physical” values (SUSY masses) & model parameters- The parameterization is done by varying one SUSY mass or model parameter at a time, while keeping other masses/parameter constant

3

Determine SUSY masses4

Determine model parameters- We can also use the determination of the SUSY masses to test e.g. gaugino universality.

5

W ≟ ?6Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 6

Page 7: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

mSUGRA (Benchmark Scenario)At the Grand Unified Scale:

4 parameters + 1 signm1/2 Common gaugino mass at MG

m0 Common scalar mass at MG

A0 Trilinear couping at MG

tanb <Hu>/<Hd> at the electroweak scale

sign(m) Sign of Higgs mixing parameter (W(2) = m Hu Hd)

4 parameters + 1 signm1/2 Common gaugino mass at MG

m0 Common scalar mass at MG

A0 Trilinear couping at MG

tanb <Hu>/<Hd> at the electroweak scale

sign(m) Sign of Higgs mixing parameter (W(2) = m Hu Hd)

Determines the particle masses at the electroweak scale by solving the Renormalization Group Equations

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 7

Page 8: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

mSUGRA (Benchmark Scenario)At the Grand Unified Scale:

4 parameters + 1 signm1/2 Common gaugino mass at MG

m0 Common scalar mass at MG

A0 Trilinear couping at MG

tanb <Hu>/<Hd> at the electroweak scale

sign(m) Sign of Higgs mixing parameter (W(2) = m Hu Hd)

4 parameters + 1 signm1/2 Common gaugino mass at MG

m0 Common scalar mass at MG

A0 Trilinear couping at MG

tanb <Hu>/<Hd> at the electroweak scale

sign(m) Sign of Higgs mixing parameter (W(2) = m Hu Hd)

(WMAP3) 129.0094.0

SM fromdeviation 2.3 :)2(

105.4)(102.2

GeV 104 GeV; 114

2~

44

~

01

1

h

~g

sbB

MM Higgs

Key experimentalconstraints

Jegerlehner and Nyffeler,arXiv:0902.3360

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 8

Page 9: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 1: Co-Annihilation RegionWithin this framework, let’s look at the 1st dark matter allowed

region: Co-Annhilation region

tanb = 40

A0 = 0, m > 0

ab

c

m0 (

GeV

)

m1/2 (GeV)

Coannihilation Region1

Excluded by1)Rare B decay b sg 2)No CDM candidate3)Muon magnetic moment

a

bc

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 9

Page 10: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 1: Co-Annihilation RegionAt the Grand Unified Scale:

4 parameters + 1 signm1/2 Common gaugino mass at MG

m0 Common scalar mass at MG

A0 Trilinear couping at MG

tanb <Hu>/<Hd> at the electroweak scale

sign(m) Sign of Higgs mixing parameter (W(2) = m Hu Hd)

4 parameters + 1 signm1/2 Common gaugino mass at MG

m0 Common scalar mass at MG

A0 Trilinear couping at MG

tanb <Hu>/<Hd> at the electroweak scale

sign(m) Sign of Higgs mixing parameter (W(2) = m Hu Hd)

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 10

Case 1 benchmark point:

m0 = 210

m1/2 = 350

tanb = 40

A0 = 0

sign(m)>0

GeVM

GeVM

GeVM

GeVM g

6.10

141

260

831

01

02

~

~

~

01

~~ MMM

Page 11: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

1. , Production is dominant SUSY process at LHC ( )g~ q~ ggqqgqpp ~~ ,~~ ,~~02

02

021

02

01

~~ ,~~ ,~~

11102

~~ ~~

2. Interested in events with or pairs

3. & Branching Ratios are ~ 97%

Case 1: Signature at LHC

TEJets ' sExcess in 3 final states: , ,TEJets 2 2 TEJets 4 TEbJets 3

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 11

Page 12: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 1: Event Selection In order to target events with , we require ≥ 2 hadronic t’set = 50%, ffake = 1% for pT

vis > 20 GeV (CDF based)

Require large Missing Transverse Energy to target events

with

High PT jets are required to target events with squarks/gluinos

[1] References

• hep-ph/0608193, Phys. Lett. B649 (2007) 73. R. Arnowitt et al

02

~a.

b.

c.

d. GeVP

GeVEEEH

GeVEGeVE

GeVE

visT

jetT

jetTTT

jetT

jetT

T

20 ,40)(

600

100, 100

180

21

21

02

~

01

~

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 12

Page 13: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 1: Smoking Gun ObservablesSort τ’s by ET (ET1 > ET2 > …) & use

OS-LS method to extract t pairs from

the decays on a statistical basis

2~

2~

2~

2~

~

1

01

02

102

11

M

M

M

MMM end

02

~

Minpeakagives ~~ 01

02

MMm Smaller Smaller Smaller 0

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 13

Page 14: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 1: Smoking Gun Observables0

1~~

What is the dependence on the other SUSY masses?

Slope of the soft t PT distribution has a DM dependence

hep-ph/0603128

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 14

Slope of PT distribution contains ΔM Information.

01

~MX

02

~MX

MX

gMX ~

Page 15: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 1: More Observables

p p

g~

q~

01

~

02

~

~

1

~

q

q~q

q

~ 0

1~

We can combine the t’s to the jet from the squark decay to

provide another mass peak

endj

peakj MM

2~

2~

2~

2~

~

02

01

02 11

M

M

M

MMM

qq

endj

Mtt < Mttendpoint

Jets with ET > 100 GeV

Mjtt masses for each jet

Choose the 2nd largest value Peak value ~ “True” Value

Squark = 660 GeV

Squark = 840 GeV

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 15

Page 16: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

ETj1 > 100 GeV, ET

j2,3,4 > 50 GeV [No e’s, m’s with pT > 20 GeV]

Meff > 400 GeV (Meff ETj1+ET

j2+ETj3+ET

j4+ ETmiss) [No b jets; eb ~ 50%]

ETmiss > max [100, 0.2 Meff]

Case 1: More Observables - Meff

m1/2 = 335 GeVMeff

peak = 1220 GeV

m1/2 = 351 GeVMeff

peak = 1274 GeV

m1/2 = 365 GeVMeff

peak = 1331 GeV

)~,~( LqgfAug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 16

Page 17: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

We have 6 observables defined as functions of 5 SUSY masses

Case 1: SUSY Mass Determination

)(

)(

) (

)(

)(

)(

6peakeff

01

025

(2)peak2

01

024

(2)peak1

01

023

(2)peak

012

01

021

peak

L

Lj

Lj

Lj

q~,g~fM

~,~,M,q~fM

~,~,M,q~fM

~,~,q~fM

~,MfSlope

~,~,MfM

)91.5( 8.09.5/

)19.3( 2.01.3/

0.26.10

;19141;15260

;21831 ;25748

01

02

01

02

~~

~~

~~

~~

theoryMM

theoryMM

M

MM

MM

g

g

gqL

Inverting Eqs. 10 fb-1

14119 GeV

(GeV) 01~

M

Testing gaugino universality at 15% level.

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 17

Page 18: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 1: mSUGRA ParametersEstablished the Co-Annihilation region

• detected low energy taus (pTvis > 20 GeV)

• observed the “smoking-gun” ditau mass

Determined SUSY Masses• e.g. LSP mass was measured to ~14%• tested gaugino universality to ~15% (10 fb-1)

Determining mSUGRA parameters• mSUGRA parameters cannot be determined

directly from the SUSY masses → we need an observable that can provide us with another independent function of A0 and tanb

• In general, it is NOT true that the determination of the SUSY masses from the mSUGRA parameters will give correct results (e.g. gaugino universality does not hold true)

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 18

),tan,,(?

),(

),tan,,(

),(

002/14

02/13peakeff

002/12peak

02/11peak

AmmX

mmXM

AmmXM

mmXM j

Page 19: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

ETj1 > 100 GeV, ET

j2,3,4 > 50 GeV [No e’s, m’s with pT > 20 GeV]

Meff(b)

> 400 GeV (Meff(b)

ETj1=b+ET

j2+ETj3+ET

j4+ ETmiss) [j1 = b jet]

ETmiss > max [100, 0.2 Meff]

Case 1: More Observables - Meff (b)

Meff(b) can be used to probe A0 and tanb without measuring stop and

sbottom masses

tanb = 48Meff

(b)peak = 933 GeVtanb = 40Meff

(b)peak = 1026 GeVtanb = 32Meff

(b)peak = 1122 GeV

Meff(b)peak (GeV)

Arb

itra

ry S

cale

u

nit

s

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 19

Page 20: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Solved by inverting the following functions:

140tan

160

4350

5210

0

2/1

0

A

m

m

),tan,( 02/102

~01

AmmZh

1fb 10 L

1fb 50

)fb 70( %1.4

)fb 30( %2.6/1

12~

2~ 0

101

hh

),tan,,(

),(

),tan,,(

),(

002/14peak )(

eff

02/13peakeff

002/12peak

02/11peak

AmmXM

mmXM

AmmXM

mmXM

b

j

10 fb-1

Case 1: mSUGRA Parameters

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 20

Page 21: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Conclusion

Case No. 2

SuspectOver-dense DM

ReportPRD 79 (2009) 055002

Minimal SUGRA

)( 3 22 SnnvHndt

dneq

m1/2

m0

Lahanas, Mavromatos, Nanopoulos, PLB 649 (2007) 63

A0 = 0, tanb = 40

Smoking gun signals in the region?

Dilaton effect creates new parameter space.

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 21

Page 22: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

m1/2= 440 GeV; m0 = 471 GeV

m1/2= 600 GeV; m0 = 440 GeV

86.8%

77.0%

2 Reference Points

Appendix

Appendix

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 22

Page 23: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 2(a) : Higgs

1~

Lu~

01χ~

02χ~

g~

h

1χ~

m1/2=440, m0=471, tanb=40, mtop=175

Re~

u

87%

10411044

500

393

181

341

114

46213%

Z91

N(b) > 2 with PT > 100 GeV; 0.4< DRbb < 1

ETmiss > 180 GeV;

N(jet) > 2 with ET > 200 GeV; ET

miss + ETj1 + ET

j2 > 600 GeV

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 23

Page 24: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

w/ side-band BG subtraction

where:

Meff ETj1+ET

j2+ETj3+ET

j4+ ETmiss

[No b jets; eb ~ 50%]

Meff(b)

ETj1=b+ET

j2+ETj3+ET

j4+ ETmiss

Meff(bb)

ETj1=b+ET

j2=b+ETj3+ET

j4+ ETmiss

)tan(

)tan(

)(

)(

00214peak )(

eff

00213peak )(

eff

0212peakeff

0211point end

A,,m,mXM

A,,m,mXM

m,mXM

m,mXM

/bb

/b

/

/jbb

4 Kinematical VariablesSide-band BG subtraction

(GeV) (2)bbjM

(GeV) bbM

71)4(fb 500 01 m

4801/2 m

4001/2 m

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 24

Page 25: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Band = Uncertainties with 1000 fb-1

Kinematical Templates

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 25

Page 26: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Determining mSUGRA ParametersSolved by inverting the following functions:

)tan(

)tan(

)(

)(

00214peak )(

eff

00213peak )(

eff

0212peakeff

0211point end

A,,m,mXM

A,,m,mXM

m,mXM

m,mXM

/bb

/b

/

/jbb

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 26

Page 27: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Determining Wh2

Solved by inverting the following functions:

1839tan

950

15440

50472

0

21

0

A

m

m

/

),tan,( 02/102

~01

AmmZh 1fb 1000 L

%~h/h ~~ 150ΩΩ 2201

01

)tan(

)tan(

)(

)(

00214peak )(

eff

00213peak )(

eff

0212peakeff

0211point end

A,,m,mXM

A,,m,mXM

m,mXM

m,mXM

/bb

/b

/

/jbb

1000 fb-1

Note: These regions have large Wh2 if one just calculate based on standard cosmology. We put a factor of 0.1 for this non-standard cosmology.

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 27

Page 28: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 2(b) : Stau and Higgs

1~

Lu~

01χ~

02χ~

g~

h

1χ~

m1/2=600, m0=440, tanb=40, mtop=175

Re~

u

20.5%

13661252

494

376

249

462

114

46277%

Follow Case 2(a) and Case 1

)tan(

)tan(

)(

)(

00214peak

00213peak )(

eff

0212peakeff

0211(2)peak

A,,m,mXM

A,,m,mXM

m,mXM

m,mXM

/

/b

/

/j

)tan(

)tan(

)(

)(

00214peak )(

eff

00213peak )(

eff

0212peakeff

0211point end

A,,m,mXM

A,,m,mXM

m,mXM

m,mXM

/bb

/b

/

/jbb

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 28

Page 29: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Determining Wh2

Solved by inverting the following functions:

340tan

450

6600

23440

0

21

0

A

m

m

/

),tan,( 02/102

~01

AmmZh 1fb 500 L

%~h/h ~~ 19ΩΩ 2201

01

)tan(

)tan(

)(

)(

00214peak

00213peak )(

eff

0212peakeff

0211(2)peak

A,,m,mXM

A,,m,mXM

m,mXM

m,mXM

/

/b

/

/j

500 fb-1

b/c stau helps to determine tanb accurately.Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 29

Page 30: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 2 SummaryOver-dense Dark Matter Region: sOD-CDM ~ sCDM /10

Implication at the LHC: Region where c2

0 decays to HiggsdWCDM /WCDM ~ 150% (1000 fb-1)

Region where c20 decays to stau and Higgs

dWCDM /WCDM ~ 20% (500 fb-1)

Future Work: o More over-dense and under-dense cases?

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 30

Page 31: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case No. 3

Suspect HB/FP

Report In progress

Minimal SUGRA

3 22eqnnvHn

dt

dn

Prospects at the LHC A few mass measurements are available: 2nd and 3rd neutralinos, and gluino

QuestionCan we make a cosmological measurement?

g~

0i

~

q~ l~ Z

ZZ

Z

Abram Krislock’s image of HB/FP, October 18, 2008

m0, A0, m, tanb

m1/2, , m tanb

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 31

Page 32: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

0

0

0

0

2

1

0

scMssM

ccMcsM

scMccMM

ssMcsMM

WZWZ

WZWZ

WZWZ

WZWZ

0

0

0

0

2

1

0

scMssM

ccMcsM

scMccMM

ssMcsMM

WZWZ

WZWZ

WZWZ

WZWZ

A4x4 (m1/2, m, tan b )

g~M 01

02

21 ~~ MMD 01

03

31 ~~ MMD

Part 1 : New to Probe Wh2

)tan( 212

01

,,mZh /~

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 32

Page 33: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

dD21 and dD32 dm and d tanb

dD21/D21 dD31/D31

d

tan

b

/ tan

b

d

tan

b

/ tan

b

dm/m dm/m

0g~g~ M/MassumingExample (m = 195, tanb = 10):

%.D

D71

21

21

%.D

D11

31

31

%.M

M

g~

g~ 54

(1) D. Tovey, “Dark Matter Searches of ATLAS,” PPC 2007(2) H. Baer et al., “Precision Gluino Mass at the LHC in SUSY Models with Decoupled

Scalars,” Phys. Rev. D75, 095010 (2007), reporting 8% with 100 fb-1

(1) (1) (2)

300 fb-1

Let’s test this idea:

%M

M

h

h 1

arbitrary scale

arbitrary scale

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 33

Page 34: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Wh2 Determination

LHC Goal: D21 and D32 at 1-2% and gluino mass at 5%

%.70

%~ 31tan

tan

%~h

h282

2

%.m

m65

1/2

1/2

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 34

Page 35: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Reconstructing two top quarks!e.g., "Perspectives for the detection and measurement of Supersymmetry in the focus point region of mSUGRA models with the ATLAS detector at LHC,"U. De Sanctis, T. Lari, S. Montesano, C. Troncon, arXiv:0704.2515v1 [hep-ex] (Eur.Phys.J.C52:743-758,2007) No gluino mass measurement.

Question (& HW)Can we improve the gluino mass measurement by using a simultaneous detection of neutralinos and tops?

Part 2 : Mass Measurements

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 35

Page 36: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

CSI Summary Reports: mSUGRA

tanb = 40

A0 = 0, m > 0

ab

c

Excluded by1)Rare B decay b sg 2)No CDM candidate3)Muon magnetic moment

a

bc

m0 (

GeV

)

m1/2 (GeV)

Over-dense DM Region

Coannihilation Region

HB/Focus Point Region

Note: g-2 data may still be controversial.

1

2

3

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 36

Page 37: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

))()(())()((

01

01

02

~lljjbjjb

~llWbWb

~ttg~

“Smoking Gun Signal” Snapshots

tanb = 40

A0 = 0, m > 0

ab

c

Excluded by1)Rare B decay b sg 2)No CDM candidate3)Muon magnetic moment

a

bc

m0 (

GeV

)

m1/2 (GeV)

01

02

~~~

01

01

02

~bb

~h~

LS

OS

OS-LS

PRL100 (2008) 231802

PRD 79 (2009) 055002

T. Kamon, Talk at“The LHC and Dark Matter”Univ. of Michigan, Jan. 7, 2009

1

2

3

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 37

Page 38: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Goals

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 38

Our main goal is to develop techniques/methods to extract the relic density from measurements at the Large Hadron Collider.

Standard Cosmology vs. Non-Standard Cosmology

Standard:

mSUGRA Co-Annihilation Region mSUGRA Focus Point Region

Non-Standard:

Over-dense Dark Matter Region Minimal vs. Non-Minimal scenarios

Minimal: mSUGRA Non-Minimal: Work in Progress (see backup slides)

Page 39: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Goals

[Case 1] “Coannihilation (CA)” RegionArnowitt, Dutta, Gurrola,*) Kamon, Krislock,*) Toback, PRL100 (2008) 231802 For earlier studies, see Arnowitt et al., PLB 649

(2007) 73; Arnowitt et al., PLB 639 (2006) 46

[Case 2] “Over-dense Dark Matter” RegionDutta, Gurrola,*) Kamon, Krislock,*) Lahanas, Mavromatos, NanopoulosPRD 79 (2009) 055002

[Case 3] “HB/Focus Point” RegionArnowitt, Dutta, Flanagan,#) Gurrola,*) Kamon, Kolev, Krislock*)

[Case 4] “Non-universality” Arnowitt, Dutta, Kamon, Kolev, Krislock*)

[Case 5] New project 1Dutta, Kamon, Krislock,*) Gupta

*) Graduate student, #) REU student

3 22eqnnvHn

dt

dn )( 3 22 SnnvHn

dt

dneq

W - 1Constant in

time?e.g., Quintessence – Scalar field dark energy

[Case 6] New project 2 Allahverdi, Bornhauser, Dutta, Kamon, Richardson-McDaniel*)

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 39

Page 40: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

SummaryGoal: Develop technique(s) to test minimal and non-minimal scenarios and extract Wh2 (standard and non-standard cosmology cases) at the LHC where a limited number of SUSY mass measurements are available.

So far 4 cases were studied or are being studied:Case 1: Coannihilation regionCase 2: Over-dense DM region (sOdCDM ~ sCDM /10)Case 3: HB/Focus Point regionCase 4: Non-universal HiggsFuture: Further improvements New cases … in progress

CSI: Cosmology at the LHC

Collider Scene Investigation

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 40

Page 41: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Backup Slides

Page 42: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case No. 4

SuspectNon-universal Higgs

Report In progress

Non-minimal SUGRA

3 22eqnnvHn

dt

dn

[Non-universality Case] Is a cosmological measurement possible?

1) Start with over-abundance region in SSC-like mSUGRA (e.g., m1/2 = 500, m0 = 360, mHu = 360)

2) Reduce Higgs coupling parameter, m, by increasing mHu (m1/2 = 500, m0 = 360, mHu =732) Extra contributions to Wh2

More annihilation (less abundance) Normal values of Wh2

3) Find smoking gun signals

4) Technique to calculate Wh2

%%~~%%~%.%~W~

9992

9858

4242

SSCU-Non

102

1

011

Page 43: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

W’s

Page 44: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Start with “JW”N(j) > 2 with pT > 30 GeVN(b) > 0 with pT > 30 GeVN(t) = 0 with pT > 20 GeV

ETmiss > 180 GeV;

N(J) > 2 with ET > 200 GeV; ET

miss + ETJ1 + ET

J2 > 600 GeV

Note there might be b-jets and/or t-jets in event, but not counted as “J” nor “j”.

500-360-732

Endpoint = 774 GeVTure = 739 GeV (c4

0)

MJW

Ture = 739 GeV (c40)

&Jet Mix to

extract W’s

&

Ture = 714 GeV (c1+/-)

Appendix

[Vetoing events with any t’ s with pT > 20 GeV]

Page 45: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

m1/2-m0-mHu 500-360-732 500-360-694 500-360-582

Wh2 0.110 0.211 0.462

MJW(q~C1W+N1) 714 (0.20*0.42) 813 (0.31*0.48) 867 (0.57*0.31)

MJW(q~C2W+N2 /t h) 727 (0.46*0.92) 650 (0.35*0.54) 652 (0.087*0.30)

MJW(q~C2W+N3Z) 652 (0.46*0.18*0.46) NAN (0.35*0.00) NAN (0.087*0.00)

MJW(q~N4W+C1) 739 (0.24*0.74) 654 (0.19*0.85) 650 (0.053*0.56)

MbW(t1C1W+N1) 485 550 594

gluino 1161 1161 1161

uL, uR 1113, 1078 1111, 1077 1111, 1076

b1, b2 ; t1, t2 946, 989; 781, 992 948, 993; 787, 996 954, 1005; 787, 996

C1, C2 291, 427 329, 442 376, 511

N1~N4 199, 293, 316, 432 202, 328, 368, 445 205, 375, 482, 511

500-360-694

MJW, shifting with mHu500-360-582500-360-732

867813739

Endpoint = 774 GeVTure = 739 GeV (c4

0) Endpoint = 856 GeVTure = 813 GeV (c1

+/-)Endpoint = 900 GeVTure = 867 GeV (c1

+/-)

Page 46: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Extraction of Model Parameters

Work in Progress …

Observable Model ParametersMeff(m0, m1/2)

m0, m1/2MJtt(m0, m1/2)

MJW(m0, m1/2, m(mHu), tanb), m(mHu), tanb

MWtt(m1/2, m(mHu), tanb)

Meff(b)(m0, m1/2, m(mHu), tanb, A0) A0

Page 47: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case No. 5

Suspect Hints from Tevatron

Report In progress

Minimal-type SO(10)

3 22eqnnvHn

dt

dn

Work in Progress …

Page 48: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case No. 6

Suspect ?

Report In progress

Non-minimal SUGRA

3 22eqnnvHn

dt

dn

01

~01~

01~

Work in Progress …

Page 49: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Bsmm

Page 50: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

From the Tevatron

Page 51: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

B (Bs ) : “Prospect in 2002” and Now

CDF(3.7 fb-1)

CDF(1.9 fb-1)

51

Page 52: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Cases 1 & 2

Page 53: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

OS-LS Slope (pTsoft )

Uncertainty Bands with 10 fb-1

(GeV) g~M

Independent of the gluino masses!

)( ),( 01

01

02

21peak

~~~ M,MfslopeM,M,MfM

Page 54: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Mjtt Distribution

endpeak jj MM 2~

2~

2~

2~

~

02

01

02 11

M

M

M

MMM

qq

endj

1) Mtt < Mttendpoint; Jets with ET > 100 GeV; Mjtt masses for each jet

2) Choose the 2nd large value Peak value ~ True Value

Mjtt(2) (GeV)

)( 01

02

3(2)peak

~~q~j M,M,MfML

)( ), ( 01

02

01

02

5(2)peak

24(2)peak

1 ~~q~j~~q~j M,M,M,MfMM,M,M,MfMLL

Page 55: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

c20 Decay Branching Ratios

m1/2= 500 GeV, m0 = 470 GeV

m1/2= 600 GeV, m0 = 440 GeV

Page 56: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 3

56

Page 57: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Gluino Decays 12 ~Z~

ETmiss > 150 GeV

GeV) 50( )( TEjN

(GeV) )(M

2)( jN

stotal = 3.1 pb

OSDF

OSSF

GeV) 10( 2)( TpN

01

032 ~~

,

19%5.3%11% 10%

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 36

Page 58: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

1fb 500

(GeV) )( jjbM

))()(( 01

02 ~bWbW~ttg~

Simultaneous Detection of Neutralinos and Top(s)

1fb 300

Working on the gluino mass estimate …

ETmiss + Dilepton + Jets

[1]

N(ℓ) > 2 pT > 10 GeV; |h| < 2.5

[2]

ETmiss > 150 GeV

[3]

Selection of W jj pT(j) > 30 GeV; 0.4 < DR(j,j) < 1.5M(jj) < 78 15 GeV

[4]

Selection of t Wb pT(b) > 30 GeV0.4 < DR(jj, b) < 2

(GeV) )(M

)OSDF(OSSF eee

Aug. 19, 2009 Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC 37

Page 59: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

Case 4

59

Page 60: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

JetMix: Hunt for Wjj

N(ji) > 2 with pT > 30 GeV

ETmiss > 180 GeV;

N(J) > 2 with ET > 200 GeV; ET

miss + ETJ1 + ET

J2 > 600 GeV

For each ji in Event X, M(ji jk) is calculated with jk in Event X-1

M(ji jk)

M(ji jk)

M(ji jk) = M(ji jk) - M(ji jk)

M(ji jk)

Page 61: Probing Supersymmetric Cosmology at the LHC Alfredo Gurrola On behalf of TAMU (full list of collaborators in the slides to follow) Karlsruhe, Germany -

g

e

e

01~

02~

[1] So far, the world of physics has been described by the Standard Model (SM). SM does NOT provide a solution to the Dark Matter problem.

[2] Supersymmetry

Every SM Fermion (Boson) has a Boson (Fermion) supersymmetry partner (example: )

[3] Supersymmetry (SUSY) extensions of the SM naturally provide a weakly interacting massive particle as a Cold Dark Matter candidate: Lightest SUSY Particle (LSP)

[4] We choose to work with a theoretically and experimentally well motivated model: Minimal Supergravity (mSUGRA): LSP =

[5] Within the mSUGRA framework,

is required to produce the correct DM abundance.

Dark Matter and Supersymmetry

Region)ation (CoAnnihil GeV 155~01

~~ MMM

01

~

XX~

03/22/08 Dark Matter at the LHC 5