25
1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch Sterling, VA February, 2016 FSBPA Coastal Tech

Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

  • Upload
    vandat

  • View
    218

  • Download
    3

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

1

Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance

Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D.

Bureau of Ocean Energy Management

Marine Minerals Branch

Sterling, VA

February, 2016

FSBPA Coastal Tech

Page 2: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

2

Agenda

• Overview of OCS sand resources

• What is rugosity?

• Preliminary evaluation of rugosity as a sand search tool

2

Page 3: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

3

• Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) – authority under Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act (“OCLSA”,

1953, Sec. 8(k))

• Marine Minerals Program (MMP): all non-energy minerals

• Negotiated Non-Competitive Agreement Leasing Process

3

MMP and OCS Marine Minerals

Page 4: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

4

MMP and OCS Marine Minerals

•BOEM is part of the Department of Interior

•MMP is the steward of non-energy minerals, including sand and gravel, located in Federal waters

•Outer Continental Shelf:

•3 Nautical Miles

•3 Nautical Leagues (west Florida, Texas)

Page 5: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

5

Sand distribution 1973

Sand Gravelly-Sand

Silty-sand Geological

Survey

Professional

Paper 529

1973

Page 6: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

6

Sand distribution 1993

OCS

Monograph

MMS93-0037

1993

Page 7: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

7

Sand distribution 2006

usSEABED

USGS Data

Series, 2006

SAND

study,

USACE,

2013

Also:

ROSSI

Page 8: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

8

Sand Search 2016

BOEM study

• Recon of Eastern

seaboard for sand and

gravel

• Hurricane Sandy

• Florida’s allocation:

• 30 cores

• 505 km seismic

• ~10% of total

• Limited resources

require focused effort

Page 9: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

9

Borrow Areas

Ridge and swale

BOEM study 2013-0119

• Surficial Sand

• Ridge and swale

complex

• Inner-shelf sand shoal

(reworked barrier island)

• Ebb-tidal delta

• Low-relief sand ridges and

sheets

• Buried Sand

Sand shoal

Page 10: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

10

Rugosity

•Rugosity

•Roughness

•Ruggedness

•Surface-area ratio

•Measurement of terrain complexity

•Ecological habitat studies

•Shelter

•Living area

•Cover and concealment

•Current rate and direction

•Water chemistry

•Sediments

Page 11: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

11

Calculating Rugosity

•Simple Rugosity =

(

| z(-1,1) - z(0,0) |

+

| z(0,1) - z(0,0) |

+

| z(1,1) - z(0,0) |

+

| z(-1,0) - z(0,0) |

+

| z(1,0) - z(0,0) |

+

| z(1,-1) - z(0,0) |

+

| z(0,-1) - z(0,0) |

+

| z(1,-1) - z(0,0) |

)

/ 8

= ( 4 - 0

+ 4 - 0

+ etc.) / 8

= (32 / 8)

= 0.5

Robbins et al., 2008

Page 12: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

12

Calculating Rugosity •Complex

Du Preez, 2015

Page 13: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

13

Calculating Rugosity •Alternative: Terrain Ruggedness Measure

Pendleton et al., 2016

Page 14: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

14

Florida Bathymetry

Cartographic production for the

Florida Shelf Habitat (FLaSH) map

study: generation of surface grids,

contours, and KMZ files

USGS Open-File Report 2007-1397

Robbins et al., 2007

50 m grid

Page 15: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

15

Florida Bathymetry

Page 16: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

16

Florida Borrow Areas

Regional Offshore Sand

Source Inventory (ROSSI),

2016

Page 17: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

17

Florida Sand

BOEM, MMPGIS, 2016

Page 18: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

18

Space Coast Detail

•Rugosity from 250 meter grid

•Red indicates high rugosity (>= 1)

Page 19: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

19

Space Coast Rugosity

Page 20: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

20

Space Coast Rugosity

250 m 50 m

Page 21: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

21

Canaveral Rugosity

250 m 50 m

Page 22: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

22

Canaveral Rugosity

Canaveral 250 m Canaveral 50 & 250 m

Zoom

Page 23: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

23

Other Rugosity

vicinity Collier vicinity Martin

Page 24: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

24

Applications, Future Efforts

• Geomorphology

• Habitat Classification

• Ecological Tracking

• Formal Statistical

Relationships

• Effects of Varying

Resolution

Page 25: Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance - fsbpa.com · 1 Rugosity as a Tool in Sand Reconnaissance Paul O. Knorr, Ph.D. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management Marine Minerals Branch

25

Thanks!

Paul O. Knorr, PhD

BOEM Marine Minerals Branch

[email protected]