(misconduct)

/

/ / 1

2

fabrication, falsification plagiarism3

Fabrication, falsification, or plagiarism

fabrication

falsification

plagiarism

A

( )

(Science)

(JAMA Journal of American Medical

Association)

1974 5-9

Science 4,5

JAMA 15 1 5 6

(

1)

St. Louis Cardinal Glennon

(1)

2017 61 2 82

(

1)

/

(Watergate scandle)

1972 1974

8 9 Summerlin Sloan-

Kettering

(New York Post)

Saturday Review 7

The Patchwork

Mouse 8

9 3

The Evolution of the "Scientific Misconduct"

Issue: An Historical Overview10

/

Dr. Good

(sadder and wiser)

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Robert Good

Sloan-

Kettering Institute for Cancer( 1)

Dr. William T. Summerlin( 2 )

(President and Director) Dr. Robert Good

( 2 )

(the most

remarkable achievement in transplantation

medicine).

Dr. Robert Good

2017 61 2 83

Minnesota

8 ( ) 5

1970 Dr. Good

Albert Lasker Award

1990

Dr. E. Donnall

Thomas

1973 Sloan-Kettering Institute

1973 (Time)

1973

War on Cancer

( 3)

Dr. Robert Good

ROBERT A. GOOD ARCHIVES &

MEMORIAL11

Dr. Good

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Good 1922 1944 Minnesota

( ) 1947

MD, PhD

25

(thymus)11

Regent's Professor 1973

Sloan-Kettering Institute

(

1)

2. Drs. Robert Good Summerlin( 6 JAMA )

1. Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center ( Wikipedia)

2017 61 2 84

D r. W i l l i a m Summerlin

William T. Summerlin12

1938 Geogia

Atlanta Emory

1964

Institute for Surgical Research

Burn and Trauma Unit

Stanford12 Sloan-

Kettering

1969 Dr. Good

Dr. Good Minnesota

Dr. Good

1973 Dr. Good

Minnesota

Dr. Good

Sloan-Kettering Institute

Dr. Summerlin

Sloan-Kettering Institute (full

member) Full member

35

Dr. Good

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Good

Dr. Good Dr.

Summerlin

Dr. Good

Dr. Good

1974 3 26 Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Good

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Good

Dr. Good

(

1)

3. Dr. Robert Good ( ) 1973War on Cancer

( Wikipedia)

2017 61 2 85

Dr. Good Dr. Good

Dr. Good

D r . G o o d D r .

Summerlin Dr. Good

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Summerlin

Dr. Good

Minnesota

old

man ( )

Dr. Good

C3H A

Dr. Summerlin

Dr.

Good

Minnesota

1. /

/ / : h t t p : / /

albertjenyihchu.blogspot.com/2014/07/blog-

post_81.html (2017.12.31)

2.

2017 28 ( )

http://teach.med.ncku.edu.tw/

newsletter/index2.asp

3. PART 689 RESEARCH MISCONDUCY,

National Science Foundation.

h t t p s : / / w w w. n s f . g o v / o i g / _ p d f / c f r / 4 5 -

CFR-689.pdf (2016.12.31)

4. Culliton BJ The Sloan-Kettering Affair:

A story without a hero. Science. 1974 184:

644-50.

5. Culliton BJ The Sloan-Kettering Affair(II):

An uneasy resolution. Science. 1974 184:

1154-7.

(

1)

4. Dr. Summerlin(

6 JAMA )

2017 61 2 86

6. Anon: The Sloan-Kettering Affair: Could

it have happened anywhere? JAMA 229

1391-410.

7. Yuncker B: The strange case of the painted

mice. Saturday Review. 11/30/74 issue: 50-

53, 61.

8. Hixson JR: The Patchwork Mouse. Anchor

Press/Doubleday. Garden City, NY; 1976.

9. 2 0 1 6

12 21 ht tp : / /www.

peoplenews.tw/news/be2d009f-f6fa-4357-

a219-4deef6edc699 (2016.12.31)

10. Lafollei tei MC The Evolution of the

"Scientific Misconduct" Issue: An Historical

Overview. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med. 2000,

224:211-5. http://journals.sagepub.

com/doi/pdf/10.1177/153537020022400405

(2016.12.31)

11. R o b e r t A : G O O D A R C H I V E S &

M E M O R I A L h t t p : / / w w w.

robe r t agooda rch ives . com/ index .h tml

(2016.12.31)

12. W i l l i a m S u m m e r l i n , M . D .

h t t p s : / / w w w. f l i c k r. c o m / p e o p l e /

williamsummerlinmd (2016.12.31)

(

1)

2017 61 2 87