Sentenci de Npotario

8/17/2019 Sentenci de Npotario

1/52

"PRIMER JUZGADO ESPECIALIZADO CIVIL DE CAJAMARCA"CORTE SUPERIOR DE JUSTICIA DPRIMER JUZGADO CIVIL-SEDE QHAPAC - ÑAN.

EXPEDIENTE N° : 00558-2014-0-0601-JR-CI-01.

DEMANDANTE : YURY RICHARD GAMARRA VIGO.

DEMANDADO : JURADO CALIICADOR E!PECIAL DEL

CONCUR!O

NACIONAL DE M"RITO PARA INGRE!O A

LA

UNCI#N NOTARIAL Y OTRO!.

MATERIA : PROCE!O DE AMPARO.

V$A PROCEDIMENTAL : E!PECIAL.

JUE% : ROGER MENDO%A HERRERA.

E!PECIALI!TA : !ILVIA MARIANELA JARA !&NCHE%.

''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''

'''''''''

SENTENCIA NÚMERO N° (29-201!

RESOLUCI"N NÚMERO CATORCE.

C()(*(+,( /, /,3+

D (/ / *7 79,.

I.- PARTE E#POSITIVA

$%&')*&+, $/+/,.

1. M7(9 ,+7/ *(9( /)( ;2 ( 4(+

G(*(++( V7?/ (, ( ( @( ,/97,7/9( 79(9/ ( #+?(9/

J+77,,7/9( ( ,/ ,(+ N( ( E9+@7(

EB(*9 O+( = A,( ,/979 / +(/ C/9,+/

P37,/ A,,/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7( ,>( 04 3++/

2014 /+ *7/ ( ,( (,,7/9(9 ((+, ,/*/

(+/3(/ = ++/+(=9/ ( ,/( ( (/ (9+7/+ ,7+ >(( ( (( @((,79 ,+7( 9 ( ,( +,++9


2/52

(,+/ ( 9() 9,9+( 9 +7*+ ?(+ /+9 (

J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( C/9,+/ N(,7/9( (+( I9?+/ (

( 9,79 N/(+7( @@( ( +(7(+ ( @((,79 9+@7(

+/9( B(*9 /+( ( +,++9 = 9 ,(/ (+/3(+ (

@((,79 9+@7( +/9( /+9: ! ! (3/+ 9 9@/

,(+/ *K+7/ B(*9 /+( D7+7/ N/(+7(

C()(*(+,( 79,=9/ ( // / /(9 (+/3(+/9

++7/ ,/9,+/ ! ! ,(+ ( 97( ( R/,79

M797+7( N° 0060-2014-JU! ,>( 2 3++/ 2014

+@ 9/*3+(+ ( /+ D=@7 A9+K P(3/ R/)( ,/*/ N/(+7/

7+7/ C()(3(*3( D(+(*9/ C()(*(+,( D7+7/

9/(+7( C()(*(+,( = /! ! ,(+ ( 97( ( R/,79

M797+7( N° 0061-2014-JU! ,>( 2 3++/ 2014

+@ 9/*3+(+ ( /+ (3/?(/ H*3+/ J(7* U+379( V

,/*/ N/(+7/ D7+7/ L/ (/ I9,( D(+(*9/

C()(*(+,( D7+7/ 9/(+7( C()(*(+,(. A?( 37,(*9

>( +/,7/ ( @9+(,79 ,/97,7/9( +,>/ (

+(3()/ ( 37/ +/,/ = ( ( 37( */7@(,79 (

+/,7/9 (*797+(7@( 9 (9/ @((,79 /+( 9

9 9( (( 7*(,79 ,/9+( +,++9 ( >(,+ ++9,7( (

N/(+7/ ( +/@79,7( D/,/+ M7? L*( I9/+/(

B *(/+ 9( 9 +/,/ )7,7( 9 +*7 /+ 7++?(+

(++// (3/+ ( (*37K9 9 9 / +F,/

799,7( +,/ N/(+7/ P37,/ ( +/@79,7( M(+,/

A9/97/ V7?/ R/)( 79 (7/ @(+7( @, 9 (++//

++7/ B(*9 = 9 ( +7+(( +?9( 7 >(3(

(9,7/9(/ 9 (,( ,9+/ (3/+ OF,79( R?7+(

C()(*(+,( *+/ ( 7(,7/9 +/9 *97( 9

+7*+ ,(/ /+ +/7/ N/(+7/ M7? L*( I9/+/(

*7(9 OF,7/ N° 2-2014-MLI-NC ,>( 05 3++/

2014 9 ?9/ ,(/ ,/9 ( D,(+(,79 J+(( ,/9 F+*(

?(7(( +/7/ N/(+7/ M(+,/ A9/97/ V7?/ R/)( = 9

+,+ ,(/ (( >7/ * 9( +?9( ( +,/


3/52

( ,/9/+* ,/9( / /,*9/ >7/ ?(+

+/7/ )?(/ (@7+ *,>/ (9 ( ,>(

9+@7( =( 9(9 ,/9/,7*79/ 9/ >(3( 7/ (9,7/9(/

(*797+(7@(*9. A?+?( ?/ /*(+ ,/9/,7*79/

( 7++?(+7( ,/9 ,>( 15 3++/ 2014

+,,7/9(( 1 3++/ *7*/ (/ /7,7 ( J+(/

C(7F,(/+ +//+,7/9 /,*9/ / /,*9/ (

>(, ++9,7( J+(/ 9 B(*9 /+( +/97K9/ (K

,/9 OF,7/ N° 128-2014-JU!OGA-TRAN!P ,>( 21 3++/

2014 9/ B7 79/+*(,79 (?9( +9 ( / ,( ( ( @

/7,7(+ ( +,/97+(,79 ( 7,79 ,/9 ,>( 22 *(+/

2014 +,,7/9(/ ,/9 ,>( 24 *(+/ *7*/ (/

/+*( 9@/ 7/ = +,7K9 ,/9 K 7*/ B7

OF,7/ N° 251-2014-JU!OGA-TRAN!P 9 ,( 9@(*9 9/

>(, ?(+ / 79/+* / /,*9/ @7+/9 /

79?+(9 )+(/ ( */*9/ @((,79 *+/

>(, ?(+ (,( @((,79 B(*9 /+( 7*( ((

((9/ ,/9 ( +,,79 +,7(/ /F,7/ /*(

,/9/,7*79/ (,( 7@/ / +7*+/ ( (3+7 /

9 ( ++7( (,( @((,79 ,//,(9 ( 9/( *( 9/

(( 7 (+/3(/ / (+/3(/ ,/9 / * 9(*9/

,7,/ = )+7,/ B/9.

2.- M7(9 +/,79 9*+/ 9/ /)( 50 ( 51 (*7 (

+*7 ( *(9( ,/97,7/9( (/ ,/++7K9/ +((/ ( (

(+ *(9(( (+( 9 (/ ,79,/ ( >37 (

,/9 /97K9/ 9 ,/9/,7*79/ P+/,+(/+ P37,/

M797+7/ J7,7( = D+,>/ H*(9/ = /+ /+,7/ /

*7/ +/3(/+7/ +9(/.

.- E ,/*(9(/ D=@7 A9+K P(3/ R/)( *7(9 ,+7/

/)( 6 ( 81 (+/9( ( +/,/ , B,,79

P+,+7,79 EB797@( = ,/9( ( *(9( 9?9/( =

,/9+(7,7K9/( 9 3( ( / 9(*9/ ,7,/ = ?( (

B/ 79/ *7(9 +/,79 9*+/ + /)( 82 (


4/52

8; 79 /+ 79+( 7,>( B,,79 ,/++ +((/ ( (

(+ *(9(9 /+ (/ / ( >37 97K9/ /+

/+,7/ / *7/ +/3(/+7/ ((.

3.- E ,/*(9(/ M797+7/ J7,7( = D+,>/ H*(9/

++9(/ /+ P+/,+(/+ P37,/ A3/?(/ L7 +9(9/

M/+9/ ++/ *7(9 ,+7/ /)( 1;8 ( 152 (+/9( (

( I9(9,7( 9 9/*3+ = ++9(,79 M797+7/ 9

++9,7( = J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( C/9,+/ N(,7/9(

MK+7/ (+( I9?+/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7( (9( (

*(9( 79,+( 9 ,(( 7*+/,9,7( ,

B,,7/9 (( (?/(*79/ ( @( (*797+(7@( =

+,+7,79 B797@( (9( ,79 +@7( = ,/9( (

*(9( /7,7(9/ ( ,(+ 7*+/,9 =/ 799((

/( 9 9,79 / (+?*9/ ,7,/ = )+7,/ B/9

79/ *7(9 +/,79 04 /)( 15< ( 160 97K9//

/+ (+/9(( = /+ 79+( ( B,,7/9 (9 +,7((

,/++7K9/ +((/ ( *7*( ( ( (+ *(9(9 /+

(/ / ( >37 979/ /+ /+,7/ *7/

+/3(/+7/ +9(/ (7*7*/ 79 /+ ,/9(( (

*(9( 7?(*9 /+ /+,7/ *7/ +/3(/+7/

+,/ ( K( 7*(.

.- C/9 ( (3/,7/9 ( B,,7/9 ,7( /+ ( (+

*(9(( *7(9 ,+7/ /)( 156 ( 158 = /)( 1; (

181 +,7@(*9 *7 ( +/,79 9*+/ ,79,/ /)(

182 *7(9 ( ,( ( 79 /+ (3( ( B,,7/9

,79 +@7( = ,/9(,79 *(9( /+ (+

*(9(9.

4.- E ,/*(9(/ H*3+/ J(7* U+379( V *7(9

,+7/ /)( 206 ( 21


5/52

//+97( K( ( ,(+(( 7*+/,9 =/ 799(( 9 3(

( / 9(*9/ ,7,/ = ?( ( B/ 79/

*7(9 +/,79 9*+/ 7 /)( 220 ( 221 79 /+

,7( ( B,,79 +/( /+ (/ / ( >37

97K9/ /+ /+,7/ / *7/ +/3(/+7/ +9(/ = /+

,/9(( ( *(9( (/ 97K9/ 7?(*9 /+

/+,7/ *7/ +/3(/+7/ (9/ +,/ ( (

/7,7 79,/+/+(,79 ( +/,/ ( C/?7/ N/(+7/

C()(*(+,( +7+ ( *(9(/ +,7 9 K ,(7(

/7,7( 79?+/.

5.- C/9 ( (3/,79 ( B,,7/9 ,7( /+

,/*(9(/ H*3+/ J(7* U+379( V *7(9 ,+7/

/)( 228 ( 2;6 = ,/9 ( +,779 ,(( /+ ( *7*( (+

+/,( *7(9 ,+7/ /)( 2;8 ( 2;( B,,7/9 = ( ,/9(,79 ( *(9( /+ ( (+

*(9(9 ,/++7K9/ +((/ ( ( (+ +/,( /+

(/ 0; ( 7/ 79,/+/+(,79 ,/*/ 77,/9/+,7(

C/?7/ N/(+7/ C()(*(+,(.

6.- C/9 ( (3/,79 K 7*/ 7/ /+ (+

*(9(9 *7(9 ,+7/ /)( 24 ( 248 B7 (

+/,79 9*+/ /,>/ /)( 24( (3/,79 (*37K9 +(7((

/+ ,/*(9(/ D=@7 A9+K P(3/ R/)( *7(9 ,+7/

/)( 26; 9 / K+*79/ ( B/ 97K9/ /+ ( 9 (

+/,79 9*+/ 9@ /)( 26.

9.- C/9 ,+7/ /)( 2( 04 3++/ 2014 Q C/9,+/

P37,/ N(,7/9( MK+7/ (+( 79?+/ ( ( 9,79 9/(+7( (

,/*/ ( ,/7( B+/?+F,( ?(7(( ( +(9(,,79 B+()7,7(


6/52

,>( 12 7*3+ 2014 /+7/+ ( ( 79+/7,79 (

*(9( 79/ *7(9 +/,79 9*+/ 7 /)( 2/ (+( + +/ 79/ *7(9

+/,79 9*+/ /9, /)( ;02 ( ;26 ,(+( 7*+/,9

( ,(( 7*+/,9,7( ( ,/*/ ( ,79 +@7( +/(

(7*7*/ 7*+/,9 ( +(,,79 ( *(+7( /+*(( /+

,/*(9(/ H*3+/ J(7* U+379( V 7*+/,9 (

+979 77,/9/+,7/ 9,(+7/ (7@/ /7,7(/ /+ K(

*7*( (+ +/,( 799(( ( B,,7/9 +,+7,79

B797@( (( (?/(*79/ ( @( (*797+(7@( = ((

?77*7( (+( /3+(+ (7@( *(9(/ /+*(( =

F9(*9 ,/++ +((/ /+ (/ + ( ( ( (+

*(9(( ,+7/ ,/979 / *7/ +/3(/+7/

/+,7/ /+ *(9(9 = >(9 7/ ((/

(9+7/+*9.

10.- M7(9 ,+7/ /)( ;;< ( ;46 M797+7/ J7,7( =

D+,>/ H*(9/ ++9(/ /+ (3/?(/ E(+/ R((

M/=( C>@ 79+/9 +,+/ ((,79 ,/9+( ( (,/((

+/,79 9*+/ /9, *79+( /+ ,+7/ /)( ;6; ( ;64

,/*(9(/ D=@7 A9+K P(3/ R/)( /7,7( B+/*779

+/,/ = /+ (+ P+/,+(/+ P37,/ *7*/

M797+7/ A3/?(/ !( E9+7 A/9/ A*+/ G// *7(9

,+7/ /)( ;5 ( ;6 (,/*(( /,*9( = ,/**9(

+,+/ ((,79. !79/ /+ +/,79 /)( ;85 ( ;8

9+ /+/ (,/ ,/9, 79 ,/ 97@/ = 79 (

,(7( 7+7( +,+/ ((,79 79+( /+

M797+7/ J7,7( = D+,>/ H*(9/ ( +(@K P+/,+(/+

P37,/ M97,7( ,/9 / ,/ ,/++/979 ,/++7K9/

+((/ ( *(9(9 ,+7/ +9(/ /+ ,/*(9(/

D=@7 A9+K P(3/ R/)( /+ (/ ,79,/ ( (+(

(3/,79 ,(+9/ 7*+/,9 ,+7/ ,/9 ,(

P+/,+(/+ P37,/ M797+7/ J7,7( = D+,>/ H*(9/


7/52

(,/*(( /,*9( = ,/**9( +,+/ ((,79 /+

B*/+9/ ,/9 ( 79,79,7( ,/*(9(/ C>+7/>+

A)(9+/ 7 C(3++( *7(9 ,+7/ /)( ;/ @(/+ = +79,77/

37,/ = 9(*9( 79 *(=/+ ++,79 9 ( @7( (

+/9( 79/ 3 @+7F,(+ 7,>/ ,/9)9/ 9/+*(7@/

( +(*9 (7,(/ = ,*7/ /+ ( 797,7/9 = +/9(

/ ,( 9 ,(/ ,/97,/ @+9 /3+ ( *(+7( //

/?+(+ ( +(@K / +/,/ ,/97,7/9( ,/9

K/ 79 ( (?+(+ ?/, ,7@/ / +,>/ (9

,(7+ @7/(,79 / (*9(( +7( +(3,79/ ( 9/+*(7(

,/97,7/9( = )+,7,7/ ,7@/ / *7*/ ( /9 >(=(9

7/ +/(9(/ ( /+ 9 (+7,(+ / ,(7+ (/+7(

9,7/9(+7/ / +@7/+ 37,/. E9 ( 9( 9(*79/

+,7(*9 79,7/ 2S (+,/ 200° ( C/97,79 P/7,(

(3, ( (,,79 (*(+/ +/, ,/9+( / (,/

,(7+ (/+7( 9,7/9(+7/ / +/9( @9+(9 /


8/52

(*9((9 / +,>/ +,/9/,7/ /+ K( (9 779/ ( (

73+( 797@7( 79 *3(+?/ >( +@7/ (*37K9 9/ +/,

(*(+/ ,/9+( 9/+*( ?( 97 ,/9+( +/,7/9 )7,7(

*(9(( 9 +/,7*79/ +?(+.

SEGUNDO E9 +7*+ K+*79/ ,/9@79 +,7(+ ( (+

*(9(( >( /7,7(/ 9 ,+7/ ,/9(,79 *(9(

,(+ ( 7*+/,9,7( K( 7*( /+ ,/97+(+

7/+7/ 9/ ++7/ 9 /+*( 7+,( ( ,/997/

,/97,7/9(*9 +/?7/ +,>/ 79@/,(/ ,/9/+* /

(3, 9*+( 1S (+,/ 5° C7?/ P+/,(

C/97,7/9( ((9/ ( @( 79( (+( +(*7(+( ( +/,/ ,/99,7// (*797+(7@/ /+ 9+ (,79 +/3(/+7( (

7+9,7( +/,/ (*(+/ 9/ ( 79 = (+( K

7*/ ,(/ 7?(*9 (7,( ( ,(( (3,7( 9 9*+(

2S (+,/ 5° +,7(/. A* (?( ( +(,,79 (

*(+7( 9 (9/ ,/9,+/ 37,/ *K+7/ 79?+/ ( (

9,79 9/(+7( 9 D7+7/ N/(+7( >( ,/9,7/ /

,/9/+*7( ,/9 9*+( 5S (+,/ 5° (,/(/. !/3+ (+7,(+ 3 ((+ (9 ,(9/ ( (9/ >( 7/

(9(7(/ *7(9 +/,79 9*+/ /9, /3+(9 /)( ;02 (

;26 (+ +799 ,(+(9/ 7*+/,9 ( ,79 +@7( =

( +(,,79 ( *(+7( /+*(( 3 (+ (9)(( (

,79 +,7(9/ +,/ ( ( +7*+( ,79 ,/9/+*

(3,79/ 9 ( (,/(( +/,79 / +,>/

,/97,7/9( (?( *(9(9 ++7/ ( +(3()/37/ +/,/ = 37( */7@(,79 ( +/,7/9

(*797+(7@( 799 ,/997/ ,/97,7/9(*9 +/?7/

,/9/+* / (3,9 9( +/,7/9 9+/ T+739(

C/97,7/9(1 = /+ / *+,9 + (9(7(/ ( +(@K

1 STC N° 1124-2001-AA/TC, Fun!#n$% 12& STC N° '''0-2004-AA/TC, Fun!#n$% '0& STC N° '()0-2004-AA/TC, Fun!#n$% 4& STC& N° 0'*+1-2011-PA/TC, Fun!#n$% 1&


9/52

+9 +/,/ ,/97,7/9( 7 >(9 7/ (73

@9+(,79 / 9/ 9 ( +( )+7,( *(9(9. A7*7*/

?9 9(*9/ ( 99,7( T+739( C/97,7/9(

+,(( 9 EB79 N° 0;87 ,/97+( 7?(*9 (+( +9

,(/ +( 797 = /+ (9/ 79)/ /37?(+ ( *(9(9 (

+(97(+ 9@(*9 /+ /+( @( )7,7( (+( ?(+ ( 9 79/

( ( / >,>/ ,+7/ = ( / *7/ +/3(/+7/

/3+(9 9 (/ +*79 +@7(+ ( ,79 ,/9+/@+7(. !79/

(( ( 9(+(( / +,>/ 79@/,(/ = (9/ ( /

F9 / +/,/ ,/97,7/9( = / +79,77/ +/,(

/ /+79(9 +@7/ 9 / (+,/ II = III T/ P+7*79(+

C7?/ (,/(/ ,/++/9 J ,+73 ( +9

+/,79 +/99,7 /3+ ( +979 (/. Y +,/

( ?9( ,79 79 *7(9 D,+/ L?7(7@/ N°

12;2 37,(/ 26 7*3+ +9 (/ 9 DK,7*/

!B( D7/7,79 C/**9(+7( T+(97/+7( = 79( >(

,/9*(/ ) 79 ,/ ( !K7*( D7/7,79

C/**9(+7( T+(97/+7( ( L= N° 2


10/52

()7,(,79 (+(9 (( 9/ ,37+( / /(9

(+/3(/ 9/ >37+(9 (,(9(/ (( @(,(9 9 7+7/

9/(+7( ( / / >(37K9/( (,(9(/ +F+(9 +99,7(+

/+9 /7,7(+ /*+ ( ( ,,79 (( @(,(9

+(9 9 / /+/ 7+7/ 9/(+7( ( 97@ 9(,7/9( ( ,(

+9 7?9(( /+ /+9 *K+7/ (,(9(/ 9 ,/9,+/

79/ (7,(3 +/,7*79/ ((/ 9 / 9*+( 24.4 =

24.5 +9 (+,/ 9 / ,/++/9( = +/,/

+(7(+ >(( ,3+(9 /( ( (( / ,( 7*7,( 9

(++// ,/9)9/ +/,/ (,,/ ( ( 9,79 9/(+7( (

97@ 9(,7/9( = 9/ (7(/ 79979 / ,7+,9,+7/ ( 9

+*79(/ D7+7/ N/(+7( ,/*/ +9+ (F+*(+ /

*(9(/. A7*7*/ +,/ ( K (,/ T+739(

C/97,7/9( >( 7/ 97,/ 9 +,7(+ 9 ( !TC N° 0;8(377( ( /7377( *77+ 9 +/99,7(*79/

7*(/+7/ / ,/++/9+ +*79(+ 9 (7/ +/,(

,/++/979 *( 9/ ( +(@K +,>(/ 7*79(+ 79 @((+

/9/ (9/ *B7* ,(9/ (+,/ III T/ P+7*79(+

,7?/ ()7@/ (,/(/ 7/9 ,(9/ 9 9 +/,/

,/97,7/9( +9 9( ( +(/9(3 +,/ 7

+/,/ 3 ,(+(+ ,/9,7/ J = T+739( ,(+(+9

,/979(,79. E9/9, 9 (9,79 ( / B/ (,(+(/ (

3 6u# !7u#! # R#3!#n$% # C%n8u% P98% N!8%n! # M:$% 7!! # In3#% !! Fun8;n N%$!!, # 8%n


11/52

(,/ 3 +/?7+ ,/9 ( *779 ( ,779

+@( /9/ ( ,/9+/@+7(.

TERCERO.- E *(9(9 9 +9 +/,/ 79@/,( (

@9+(,79 +,>/ ,/97,7/9( ( +(3()/ ( 37/

+/,/ 9 ,7( ( ( 37( */7@(,79 +/,7/9

(*797+(7@( = +,>/ ( ( +9,79 79/,9,7( /+

,(9/ /79 J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( C/9,+/

P37,/ N(,7/9( MK+7/ (+( I9?+/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7(

+/,7 ( (+/3(+/ 9 ( (( @((,79 /+( 9(/

97,(*9 9 9( 79/+*(,79 >(,( (79 ( 9( ((

7*(,79 ,/9+( +,++9 ( >(,+ (3+ ,(+(*9 9

7,>/ (,/ N/(+7/ ( +/@79,7( D/,/+ M7? L*(

I9/+/( B *(/+ 9( 9 +/,/ )7,7( 9 +*7 /+

7++?(+ (++// (3/+ ( (*37K9 9 9 /

+F,/ 799,7( +,/ N/(+7/ P37,/ ( +/@79,7(

M(+,/ A9/97/ V7?/ R/)( 79 (7/ @(+7( @, 9

(++// ++7/ B(*9 = 9 ( +7+(( +?9( 7

>(3( (9,7/9(/ 9 (,( ,9+/ (3/+ OF,79( R?7+( C()(*(+,( *+/ ( 7(,7/9 +/9 *97( 9

+7*+ ,(/ /+ +/7/ N/(+7/ M7? L*( I9/+/(

*7(9 OF,7/ N° 2-2014-MLI-NC ,>( 05 3++/

2014 9 ?9/ ,(/ ,/9 ( D,(+(,79 J+(( ,/9 F+*(

?(7(( +/7/ N/(+7/ M(+,/ A9/97/ V7?/ R/)( = 9

+,+ ,(/ (( >7/ * 9( +?9( ( +,/

( ,/9/+* ,/9( / /,*9/ >7/ ?(+ +/7/ )+(/ (@7+ *,>/ (9 ( ,>(

9+@7( =( 9(9 ,/9/,7*79/ 9/ >(3( 7/ (9,7/9(/

(*797+(7@(*9.

CUARTO.- A +,/ 9 +7*+ K+*79/ +( 9,(+7/ +,7(+

( 9,79 9/(+7( 9( 9,79 37,( /+ *(9(/

(+,/ 4° TB/ 97,/ O+9(/ R?(*9/ D,+/


12/52

L?7(7@/ N° 104< Q D,+/ L?7(7@/ N/(+7(/ (+/3(/

/+ D,+/ !+*/ N° 010-2010-JU!5: “El notario es el profesional

del derecho encargado, por delegación del Estado, de una función

pública consistente en recibir y dar forma a la voluntad de las

partes, redacta los instrumentos adecuados a ese n, les conere

autenticidad, conserva los originales y expide traslados que dan fe

de su contenido. Su función tambin comprende la comprobación de

hechos y la tramitación de asuntos no contenciosos previstos en las

leyes de la materia. El notario no es funcionario público para ningún

efecto legal! (,(+(9/ 7 379 9 ( 7*( (+ ((

9/(+7/ 9/ 9,7/9(+7/ 37,/ (+( 979?9 ,/ ?(

/ 9 9(( 9+@( ( 9(+(( 37,( ( 9,79 )+,9

9( ,/( ( )+7,/ 9/(+7/ = /+( 7+9 (

9(+(( ( 9,79 )+,9 79/ 79,/ *37/

9 79+( ( 9,79 9/(+7( (*797+(7@/ /+

+((+ )+,7,7/ 9( 9,79 37,( ?(( /+ E(/

= /+ ( 9(+(( (*797+(7@( )7F,(/

( ( 9,79 37,( 9/(+7( (,,( *7(9 ,/9,+/ 37,/

*K+7/ ,/9/+*( +?(/ 9 (+,/ 6° ( L=

N/(+7(/ Q D,+/ L?7(7@/ 104


13/52

*(+7(7( 9 (+,/ 1


14/52

T+739( C/97,7/9( >( *77/ (39(9 )+7+9,7( 9 (

>( (3,7/ ,/9,+/ *K+7/ = ,/9/,7*79/ (

+(@K ,( (,, ( ( 9,79 37,( ,/97+(/ ,/*/

9 +/,/11.

QUINTO.- A>/+( 379 ,(( 7,>( (,(+(,7/9 +/,+

( +@7(+ ,(( 9/ / +,>/ ,=( @9+(,79 >( 7/

79@/,(( /+ (*(+7(. A 79 ,/997/

,/97,7/9(*9 +/?7/ '*7*/:, < +7, ,/9*(/

9 (+,/ 22° 9+( C/97,79 P/7,(12 9 >(

+,>/ ( ( 73+( +(3()/ ?9 / (3,7/ /+ 9+/

T+739( C/97,7/9( 9 (39(9 )+7+9,7(1; 7*/+( +(9/ +,>/ ( ?7+ 73+*9 9( +/79 /F,7/

E(/ 9/ / 3 ?(+(97(+ +,>/ ( +/9( ( (,,+

( 9 / +(3()/ / +/?+ ( +(3()(/+ +9 ( 7/

(+37+(+7/ (+,/ 2° ( C/97,79 79/ (* 3

?(+(97(+ ( 73+( ?7+ ( (,7@7( *7(9 ( ,(

+/,+(9 / *7/ 9,(+7/ (+( ( 379,7( ,7+ 3

+/?+ (9/ ( +(3()(/+ 979 ,/*/ ( ( +/9( +(7( (,7@7( ,/9*7,( /+ ,9( +/7( )+,79/ (

73+( *+( ( C/97,79 +,/9/,. A7*7*/

T+739( 9 ( *7*( 9( >( /97/ : “"#$ la libertad de

traba%o, en cuanto derecho fundamental, detenta una doble fa&. 'or

un lado, constituye derecho de defensa y, por otro, derecho de

protección. En cuanto derecho de defensa, proyecta su

vinculatoriedad t(pica, cl)sica, oponible al Estado y a particulares,como esfera de actuación libre. En cuanto derecho de protección, la

libertad de traba%o reconoce a la persona el derecho a una acción

11 EP& N 002)-200)-PI/TC 002-200)-PI/TC, Fun!#n$% +&

12 Protección ( )o&ento del e&pleo Artículo 22.- E $!!% # un ## un##85%& E !# # #n#$! %8! un #% # #!!8;n #

! 7#%n!&

13 S#n% !3un! # #!, ! 8%n$#n! #n # EP& N&° 040)*-2011-PA/TC& Fun!#n$%

4, STC 2*02-200)- PA/TC, '''0-2004-PA/TC, #n$# %$!&


15/52

positiva, que vincula al Estado a la protección activa del bien

iusfundamental protegido * libre traba%o * a travs del

establecimiento de normas, procedimientos e instituciones

orientadas a hacer posible el e%ercicio de tal derecho fundamental.

En virtud de ello se constituye para el Estado y el poder público en

general lo que el +ribunal onstitucional alem)n ha denominado en

su %urisprudencia como “deber de protección!-.

E< '*7*/:, < '*', =7,/*, ,/9*(/ 9 79,7/ ;S

(+,/ 1;


16/52

indiscutiblemente vinculados a la arta 7agna, de modo que si sta

resuelve sobre asuntos de inters de los administrados, y lo hace

mediante procedimientos internos, no existe ra&ón alguna para

desconocer las categor(as invocables ante el órgano %urisdiccional!-8,

“En este sentido, y como tambin ha sido precisado por este

+ribunal, el derecho al debido proceso comprende, a su ve&, un ha&

de derechos que forman parte de su est)ndar m(nimo, entre estos

derechos constitucionales, especial relevancia para el presente caso,

adquiere el derecho a la motivación de las resoluciones "#$! -2. A

(*37K9 >( (3,7/ /+ 9+/ T+739( C/97,7/9(

“"#$ 9icho atributo por lo dem)s y de cara a lo que establece la

%urisprudencia, admite dos dimensiones, una formal o procedimental

y otra de car)cter sustantivo o material. 7ientras que en la primera,

el debido proceso est) concebido como un derecho que abarca

diversas garant(as y reglas que garanti&an un est)ndar de

participación %usta o debida durante la secuela o desarrollo de todo

tipo de procedimiento 4sea %udicial, administrativo, corporativo

particular o de cualquier otra (ndole5, en la segunda exige que los

pronunciamientos o resoluciones con los que se pone n al proceso

respondan a un referente m(nimo de %usticia o de ra&onabilidad! :;

(?+?(9/ : “9eterminar el nivel de %usticia o ra&onabilidad de

una decisión no es sin embargo y cualquiera que sea el )mbito de

donde provenga, algo que pueda medirse conforme a un %uego o

interpretación sustentada en la libre discrecionalidad. En realidad

depende de varios factores que aunque en ocasiones pueden darse

por separado, tambin pueden presentarse de modo concurrente,

siendo pertinente mencionar, como supuestos en los que proceder(a

el control en salvaguarda del debido proceso sustantivo< a5 el

respeto o su%eción a los derechos y valores constitucionales, b5 la

interdicción a la arbitrariedad, c5 la exigencia de sentido común o

18 I#, Fun!#n$% 14&

19 I#, Fun!#n$% 1)&

20 STC& N°&02+*-2012-AA/TC& Fun!#n$% 10&


17/52

racionalidad en la toma de decisión! :-. A( : “=iscali&ar el

car)cter arbitrario que pueda asumir una determinada decisión,

implica por otra parte cote%ar las prescripciones normativas

invocadas en la resolución o pronunciamiento ob%eto de

cuestionamiento con las nalidades perseguidas por la onstitución.

En este sentido, no basta con que una situación o controversia

%ur(dica sea encarada con su%eción a lo que dispone una determinada

norma o con%unto de normas> es necesario, en trminos del debido

proceso sustantivo, vericar si los ob%etos perseguidos por las

mismas est)n siendo correctamente utili&ados. Se trata, en otros

trminos, de constatar la correcta utili&ación del derecho,

proscribiendo de plano todo tipo de abuso o distorsión de sus

propósitos! :: /979/ : “Exigir racionalidad o sentido común

supone, por último, el evitar que la decisión o pronunciamiento

ob%eto de examen se sustente en fórmulas absurdas, incoherentes o

simplemente extravagantes. En tales circunstancias la resolución

con la que se concluye un proceso deber) evaluarse caso por caso a

n de vericar si la aplicación de la norma ha sido adecuadamente

ponderada de modo que las respuestas dispensadas se adecúen a

est)ndares como los aqu( gracados! :1.

E< '*7*/:,


18/52

9 +/,/ ( ,( 9(+(( 3+ (+ ,9( (

),79 ( +,>/ ( F9 )(+ ,(7+ /,>(

(+37+(+7(26 = 79,/ ( B7?9,7( )7,7( /+*(

7?(*9 *// 9/ ,(9/ >( /*(+ 9( ,779 ,/9

3( 9 9( /( 7,+,7/9(2. A7*7*/ 9 ( 99,7(

+,(( 9 EB79 N° 04( 7/ *(+7( 9/

+/99,7(*79/ /+ 9+/ T+739( C/97,7/9( 79/ :

“El derecho de presunción de inocencia garanti&a que toda persona

no sea sancionada si es que no existe prueba plena que, con certe&a,

acredite su responsabilidad, administrativa o %udicial, de los cargos

26 I#& Fun!#n$% 1(&

27 I#, Fun!#n$% 21 22&


19/52

atribuidos "#$! :8 = “Esta presunción, nacida del principio pro

homine, demanda del %u&gador la suciente capacidad de equidad

para no asumir la responsabilidad de los acusados antes de que se

realice la investigación o el procedimiento. 9e esta forma, la

presunción de inocencia no requiere de una causalidad entre un

hecho y supuesto sancionable, sino un ra&onamiento %ur(dico a travs

del cual se determine una culpabilidad "#$! :2 9+ /+/

SE#TO.- D /+/ (/ (@7+ / '*7*/:, < '*',

=7,/*, *& 7**(9/ ,/*/ ,/9)9/ 379 >*(9/ 37/ ( ( +/9(

= ,=/ //+?(*79/ ,/9,,79 / (?+(*79/ +*77+

/?+(+ ?+(/ +,,7/9(*79/ 9 799/ (,(9(+ (

* 9( +(7(,79 /73 ,/*/ F9 9 *7*( . L(

P+/9( 79 9( 7?97( F9 ( (+7+ @(/+

(3//: @( ,/*/ F9 9 *7*(. E + *7/ = 9/ F9 )7F,(

9(*9 ( /9 ( 9@@( ( ,/97+(( ,/*/

F9 99,( ,/*/ *7/. L/ ,( ?9+( ( /37?(,79 ,(9/

9?( ,77+ /3+ ( +/9( ,7( ,/9 )7,7( 79/

(+( ( ,/ 3 *(+ 9 *7/ 79/ (+( ,/9?7+

9 ( *(=/+ *7( /73 ( ,779 )( = ( *7/ /

28 E.7& 2**-2004-AA/TC # 24&11&04&

29 E.7& '1+4-2004-KC/TC # 2*&12&04&


20/52

,/97= 9 +/,/ 9 ,( +,/9/, 9( +7 ?(+(9(

/+*( = *(+7(*9 +*7(9 (?+(+ 9 ( *(=/+ *7(

/ /73 / ,7( /3+ 9( +/9( + )/ 9

/+( ((3+( +( 9 +/,/ )/. A7*7*/ ,/*/

B7?9,7( E(/ C/97,7/9( +,>/ 37/ +/,/

7*+( (+( 7*7(+ / /+ 37,/ /3+(9/ “"#$ cuyas

competencias puedan e%ercerse de cualquier manera "#$ 'or ello

este +ribunal ha sostenido que< "#$ no pueden admitirse como

ra&onables o coherentes interpretaciones tendientes a convalidar

e%ercicios irregulares o arbitrarios de las funciones conferidas a los

órganos públicos!1;. C/9,9*9 ( 9,7/9 37,(

?(( ,/*/ ,(/ ( 9/(+7( 9/ )+,+

*// 7++?(+ / (+37+(+7/. E 9( B7?9,7( E(/

C/97,7/9( D+,>/ ,( ,/9+= /3+ ( 3( 9(

C/97,79 ,/97,7/9(7( B7?9,7( )7,7(

/+*(9 = (+( ( +/9( = 9( +(7( 9(*9

9/+*(7@( 9/ (*7 ( B79,7( /9( B9(

@79,(,79 ( ( C/97,79.

E9 / (( ( ( G7&+8 '*


21/52

(*37K9 ( 7*(+,7(7( +?(9/ >( ,77+. L(

7*(+,7(7( + 997( /77@(*9 ,/*/ ( 799,79

(@/+,+ 79+K 37,/ *(97(/ 9 ,/9,+/

*K+7/ = 9?(7@(*9 ,/*/ ( +/>737,79 ,77+ 979/

9 )7,7/ ++*79(/ /77@( / 9?(7@(*9 /3+ 9/ / *

/ ,(97(/. !/ 7 )?(/+ 73+ 9( +,/9,,79

+,/ 9( ( (+ +/,/ + /73

,779 (3+(, ( B7?9,7( )7,7(. D *// 9 )+(/

,(7F,(/+ 9?( 9( 797/7,79 B+(( +,/ 9/

/ ,(97(/ ( 9/(+7/ /9 9 +7?/ *(97F/ ( 3,((

)7,7( ( ,779.

D /+/ (/ ( *@*&/ '* 7,&,>/

++9,7( ( ?(+(9( 7+,(*9 /,(9

9@/@7*79/ +/,/ 79 *3(+?/ // ,*7*79/

( B7?9,7( /+*( 9/ (?+( 9,(+7(*9 ( )7,7( (

,779 /+ / +? ( 9,7( ,/*+/3(+ 7+,(*9

7 9( ,779 ,/9+(@79 / 9/ ( B7?9,7( +(/9(377( =

)7,7( 9,7(*9 /37?(9. E/ 7?97F,( +,/9/,+ 9

+/,/ (,,/ ( ( 9,79 37,( 9/(+7( B7?9,7(

*(+7( )7,7( / 9/+*(*9 ,/9/, ,/*/

7*979 *(+7( 37/ +/,/.

P/+ (+ '*7*/:, %&')*&+< '* //*, / 9(*9( +,>/ (,,/ ( ( 9,79 37,(

9/(+7( 9/ /3(9 T+739( C/97,7/9( / >( ,/97+(/

,/*/ +,>/ 9(*9( 7*,7/ ( (+7+ (+,/ ;° (

C/97,79 = ( (+7+ +,/?7*79/ 9 +((/

79+9(,7/9( @79,(9 (+( P+: (+,/ 2;.1., (

C/9@9,79 A*+7,(9( /3+ D+,>/ H*(9/ = (+,/ 25.,

P(,/ I9+9(,7/9( D+,>/ C7@7 = P/7,/.


22/52

C/9 3( 9 +,/9/,7*79/ T+739( C/97,7/9( >(

97/ //+97( F97+ ,/997/ 9,7(. P+7*+/ >(

797F,(/ 379 >*(9/ 379 )+7,/ 9 ( 3(

+,>/: “el acceso a la función representa en s( mismo el bien

%ur(dico protegido por este derecho fundamental!1-, “el derecho de

acceso a la función pública detenta un bien %ur(dico autónomo de

protección< el acceso a la función pública, la participación en la

función pública!1: (+( ?/ >(,+ ++9,7( ( ,/997/

9,7( 9 / K+*79/ 7?79: “Este +ribunal entiende que los

contenidos de este derecho son los siguientes< a5 ?cceder o ingresar

a la función pública> b5 E%ercerla plenamente> c5 ?scender en la

función pública> d5 ondiciones iguales de acceso11. En referencia al

primer de los elementos que conforman el contenido esencial de este

derecho fundamental, el acceso debe producirse una ve& cumplidos

los requisitos de acceso, “requisitos cuya valide& est) condicionada a

su constitucionalidad!1. +ales requisitos son manifestación del

principio de acceso por mrito, que rige el acceso a la función

pública no representativa como es la notarial, as( “el mrito es el

único criterio selectivo para acceder a la función pública!1A. 'ues

bien, la vericación del cumplimiento de tales requisitos para

determinar el mrito de los candidatos a acceder a la función pública

“habr) de respetar los derechos fundamentales!10 del postulante.

E/ 7?97F,( 7 9 ( ,/*+/3(,79 7 9 /(9 ,* /

9/ ,/9 *K+7/ (+( (,,+ ( ( 9,79 37,( 9/(+7( @9+(

(?9/ +,>/ 9(*9( ,/*/ (,/9,+ /+ (

+(9?+79 (?9( ( ?(+(9( 37/ +/,/

31 EP& N&° 02) 02-200)-PI/TC, Fun!#n$% '+&

32 I#& Fun!#n$% 41&

33 #& Fun!#n$% 4'&

34 #& Fun!#n$% 4&

35 #& Fun!#n$% 4+&

36 #& Fun!#n$% 4(&


23/52

@9+( (*37K9 = *// 9,(+7/ ,/997/ 9,7(

+,>/ (,,/ ( ( 9,79 37,(.

SKTIMO.- E9 +9 ,(/ ( @((,79 / *7/

+/3(/+7/ (/+(/ ( +/,/ 79 (*(+7( >((+7,7(/ 9 C/9,+/ N(,7/9( MK+7/ (+( I9?+/ ( (

9,79 P37,( N/(+7( D7+7/ N/(+7( C()(*(+,(

,/9/+* (@7+ /)( 4 ( 8 >(379/ (+/3(/ B(*9

,++7,(+ = ,+7/ ,/9 ( 9/( 14.(3(9 F)(/ *7+(( 9

+/9( 79,/ (+,7 9/ / D/,/+ C(+/

E9+7 ,++( P(/*79/ */+ 9 /,*9/ ( ( D/,/+( +7(R/B(9( &?7( T( P+79( C/9)/ N/(+7/

79?+(9 J+(/ (?/ *+*+(3(9 = +/9/ K(

7*( +/, ( (3(9/9(+ ( 79((,7/9 (7/+7/ 9 /9

+(7(3( ( @((,79 ,/ ?9+(+/9 9 (/

9+@7/7*/ = 9 /( ,/9,7+/ (?+?(9/ (9 ( (7(

79+(( 79)7F,(( ( D/,/+( 9 *9,79 J+(/

,/9/+*(/ 97,(*9 /+ + *7*3+/ D/,/+ +,7(/,/*/ P+79 J+(/ R( M(+9 V7( C/+/9(/ = "?(+

%99 C>7+79/ E9 ( G+(3(,79 9 (7/ = @7/ (

@((,79 /+( +//+,7/9(( /+ +/7/ J+(/ C(7F,(/+ (9

/7,7 (+,7( ( >(, ++9,7( ( N/(+7/

( +/@79,7( M7? L*( I9/+/( B *(/+ 9(

9 +/,/ )7,7( 9 +*7 /+ 7++?(+ (++//

(3/+ *+/ ( 7(,79 *97( /+ +/7/ N/(+7/ (+(@K OF,7/ N° 2-2014MLI-NC ,>( 05 3++/


24/52

2014 @79,79/ 9( (( 7*(,79 ,/9+( +,++9

T(*37K9 7* 9 / +F,/ 799,7(

79@/,+9/ ( /+/ N/(+7/ ( +/@79,7( C()(*(+,(

D/,/+ M(+,/ A9/97/ V7?/ R/)( 79 (7/ @(+7( @, 9

(++// ++7/ B(*9 *+/ K 7*/ >( *77/

9( ,(+(,79 )+(( ,/9 F+*( ?(7(( 9 ( ,( ((

97,(*9 99,( 799,7 / +( 799,7(+ 9

@((,79 ,/9 / (,+7( /+( (( 7*(,79 = E9

(++// B(*9 /+( ,/9/+* @+7F,( @7/ ()9(/

9/ / )+(/ +?9( * 9( @ 7 >(3( 7/

(9,7/9(/ 9 (,( ,9+/ (3/+ OF,79( R?7+(

C()(*(+,( ( ,/9/+* ,/9( / /,*9/

>7/ ?(+ +/7/ J+(/ (@7+ *,>/ (9 ( ,>(

9+@7( =( 9(9 ,/9/,7*79/ 9/ >(3( 7/

(9,7/9(/ (*797+(7@(*9.

OCTAVO.- !/3+ (+7,(+ (+,7( (+( (,+7(+ (

B+*/ *(9(9 >( +9(/ 9+ /+/ /,*9/ !

( *9,7/9(( A,( EB(*9 O+( 9 ( ,( 9 (++799 97,(*9 (( +,/ ( /(9 = >/=

(*(+7( Y+= R7,>(+ G(*(++( V7?/ +/, ( ?7+

3(/( /3979/ N° 100 D+,>/ P+/,( C7@7 R*(. Y

,/*9 ( (++/(+ *( = +*79(( B/7,79

+/,7 ( (++// +?9( (,(K*7,( +(=,/+7(

+/9( ,+( ?9+( = +79,77/ K7,/ +(7(( /+ ,(( 9/

/ *7*3+/ J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( (9/9/ (*37K9 K ,/9,7( ( @((,79 ,(( *7*3+/ J+(/

79?+ ( 9 /3+ ,(7F,(,79 797@7( 79/ ,++(/ = (,+(/

9 (,/ 37,/ ?/ +3+7,(/ /+ / *7*3+/ J+(/

C(7F,(/+ E,7( +9 79?+(/ ( 9 9/+( (+(

,/7( )9/ ,/9(9,7( 9 ,(9/ ( E@((,79

A,(K*7,( /+ / J+(/ 1 2 = ; ( 9/( 10 11 = 08 =

+,/ T+(=,/+7( P+/9( C+( G9+( = P+79,77/"7,/ ( 9/( 2 1 = 2 +,7@(*9 79/ ( *(/+7(


25/52

12 12 = 10 ,=/ +/*7/ 11.;;; ! L( C+7F,(,79

N/(+7( ,>( ;0 (3+7 2015 +,/ B(*9 /+(

,>( 04 3++/ 2014 Q C/9,+/ P37,/ N(,7/9(

MK+7/ (+( I9?+/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7(; /3+(9 /)( 288 (

2((

*79/ ;6:4;;8 ,/++/979 ( ?9/ 7,/ ,/*(,/

9+ / J+(/ 1 = ; ,/9/+*(/ /+ / D/,/+ C(+/ E9+7

,++( P(/*79/ = R( M(+9 V7( C/+/9(/;( +?9(/ / @, / *7*/ +,/ 7

/(9 >( 7/ )/ (?9 +/,/ 9 / R?7+/ P37,/

( 7?79 *(9+(: J+(/ ;: “B# traba%ando ahorita en los

Cegistros 'úblicos Dd. o ha tenido ninguna sanción por algún

proceso! /3979/ ,/*/ +( /(9: “9esde el :1

de diciembre del aFo :;-1 me encuentro laborando y no he sido

ob%eto de ninguna sanción! 79779/ J+(/ ;: “o ha sido

su%eto tampoco de ningún proceso! +/979/ /(9: “9e

ninguno! *79+( J+(/ 1 >( +?9(/: “B en l#Dd.

Est) traba%ando en Cegistros 'úblicos ahoraG P/(9:

37 L! 8u! # =!%! #n =$u # u# #n # 8#$% #!n$# #%u8;n n9#% %n8## 8%# $!!% 7% # 7!% # 0' ! ! ! 7!$# #!n!!, #7#8$% # 85% #%7%!$%%, #7#% n% # =#8! ! 8%n$!n8! # n%$8!8;n # :$! 9$! 7!$#7%8#! # ## $#n# #n 8u#n$! u# n% # # 3#n#! n#


26/52

“?ctualmente s(, desde el :1 de diciembre del aFo :;-1! J+(/ 1:

“B ha recibido alguna que%a en Cegistros, alguna denuncia!

P/(9: “o, ninguna!. P/+ /+( (+ (@7+ (*37K9

/ J+(/ 1 = 2 ,/9/+*(/ /+ / D/,/+ C(+/ E9+7

,++( P(/*79/ = "?(+ %99 C>7+79/ M(9+7 79,79 9 (

+(,79 9( /(9 >/= *(9(9 ,/9 N/(+7/

L*( ( ,/*/ 9 ( 799,7( N/(+7/ M(+,/ V7?/ R/)(

/3+ +/9( ( 7?79 *(9+(: J+(/ 2: “7i respetable

9octor, nuevamente le tengo que preguntar, eh vamos a ver, usted

traba%a en la actualidad en la SD?C' de a%amarca, anteriormente

Dd. Ha traba%ado en una notar(a con el 9octor! +/979/

/(9: “=laminio Iilberto Jigo SaldaFa! ,/979(9/ 7,>/

J+(/: “omo como! +779/ P/(9: “=laminio Iilberto

Jigo SaldaFa! ?/ 79++/?(/+7/ (++/( (: J+(/ 2:

“o ha traba%ado Dsted con un otario @edesmaG! P/(9:

“?ntes de..! J+(/ 2: “? ver a ver, vamos por partes P/(9:

“En orden cronológico! J+(/ 2: “uando yo estuve en la

Dniversidad en cuarto aFo tuve la oportunidad de que uno de mis

docentes fuera el doctor 7iguel @edesma! J+(/ 2: “Kue era

notario! P/(9: “Kue es notario actualmente de la provincia de

a%amarca y l me invitó para hacer pr)cticas en su ocio notarial, y

luego me invitó para traba%ar con l! J+(/ 2: “u)nto tiempo

practicó o laboro ah(! P/(9: “Dn aFo realic pr)cticas y 8 aFos

he traba%ado con lG J+(/ 2: “on l, total casi 2 aFos! P/(9:

“Si! J+(/ 2: “S(!, J+(/ 2: “'osteriormente se pasó usted a otra

notar(a! P/(9: “Estuve un tiempo en los Cegistros 'úblicos y

luego el 9octor =laminio Jigo SaldaFa me dio la oportunidad de

traba%ar con l y he regresado a Cegistros 'úblicos! J+(/ 2: “En

total traba%ó en dos notar(as y en la actualidad traba%a en la SD?C'

y tambin los Cegistros 'úblicos! P/(9: “En la SD?C', en la

Superintendencia acional de los Cegistros 'úblicos! 79/

79,/ 79,/ *7*/ J+(/ +?9 , ( +(9 /+ (

,( +F+7K9/ 7+ (++(9,(+ ( @+( (K )( (


27/52

N/(+7( L*( ( / ,( /(9 +/9 *(9+(

,79(: “En ese tiempo hubo doctor "#$! 9/9/ 79

+*79(+ +/9+ *7*/ J+(/ +/7? ,/9 ( +?9(

7 / 77+/9 / /+ +/7( @/9( +9 ( / ,(

+/9 : “o, o, o, me fui por mi propia voluntad!

79779/ 7,>/ J+(/: “'or su propia voluntad! +9 ( / ,(

/(9 +/9: “S(, s(, no he sido ob%eto de despido!

+/7?79/ J+(/ 2: “B se fue a traba%ar a otra otar(a despus

me dice, donde el 9octor Jigo Co%as! +/979/ P/(9:

“Jigo SaldaFa! J+(/ 2: “?hhh, Jigo SaldaFa! P/(9: “Hay un

notario que es Jigo Co%as en a%amarca s(, pero yo no he traba%ado

con l! J+(/ 2: “Jigo Co%as# B Jigo Co%as es su parienteG!

P/(9: “o! J+(/ 2: “o, muy bien, pero Jigo Co%as donde

tiene su notar(aG! P/(9: “En el Lr. Lun(n! J+(/ 2: “Eso

queda# en MaFos del Nnca! P/(9: “o, no, en el entro de

a%amarca, en el Lirón Lun(n! J+(/ 2: “B Dd. Si der notario

escoger(a Dd.! P/(9: “El distrito, si si es que se me da la

oportunidad el 9istrito de MaFos del Nnca, que es un balneario de

aguas termales!. L?/ / (*37K9 +?9( 7 >(= 9

,/*/99 9+ K = N/(+7/ V7?/ R/)( 7 / @( ( >/(+ 7

@( ( (+ ( (+9(7@( (+ ( (,77( 9( /F,79( +9 ( /

,( +/9 /(9 “o habr(a porque 9octor yo soy un

profesional como lo es tambin el 9octor y tendr(a que desarrollar

como la propia @ey del otariado lo establece una profesión de

manera personal!. P/+7/+*9 J+(/ 2 @@ ( 79,77+ 9 (

+?9( ,*/ ( +(,79 ,/9 D/,/+ L*( 9 (

(,(7( +/97K9/ /(9: “7uy buenas doctor! ( /

,( +7+( 7,>/ J+(/ ,/9 9( +?9( ,/9@((

((9(( 9( +( 7 /9 7*(W 9/ >(= 979?9

+3+()(*79/ 9/ >(= 9 97*79/ (97*(@+79 9/ >(=

9(( /W +9 ( / ,( /(9 +/9: “unca lo ha

habido el 9octor @edesma es un caballero, es un seFor mi salida fue

de los me%ores trminos, yo creo que l estuvo contento porque sab(a


28/52

que ten(a mis hori&ontes! ,/9,=9/ ( ( +?9( 7,>/

J+(/ 2 ?/ , (/ ( D/,/+ C(+/ E9+7 ,++(

P(/*79/ J+(/ 1 79 @@ ( +?9(+ 7 D/,/+ L*(

@/ (?9 +/3*( ( +( (+7,7(,79 9 (?9 +(3()/ 9

9/(+( ( / ,( /(9 +/97 : “o doctor.

7ientras he traba%ado con l no hemos tenido ningún problema con

mi actuación!. L?/ ,/979 +?9(9/ 7 /(9 9/

+/,(/ 9 L(*3(= ( / /(9 ,/9: “o

doctor!. D 9@/ +?9: “? que problema se reeren ah( en la

información que tenemos nosotros! +/979/ /(9:

“o, si usted, me la seFala, yo le podr(a decir, pero %am)s he sido

sometido a ninguna sanción, ni he sido denunciado ni

administrativamente, ningún proceso!. C/979( J+(/ 1: “9ice

que el 9octor @edesma tuvo un problema en la orte de @ambayeque

por causa suya, a ra(& de que usted en otras palabras le hi&o algo

que estaba mal y lo complicó al notario, a que se reere esa

información! +/9 /(9: “Bo le voy a dar alcances pero

esa información no es cierta y hasta cierta parte me parece

maliciosa, porque es verdad el doctor @edesma tiene un problema en

hiclayo por la certicación de unos poderes, pero yo nunca he sido

parte de esa investigación doctor, si : empleados del doctor "#$!.

C/979( 7,>/ J+(/: “B usted este renunció a la otar(a del

9octor @edesma! +/979/ /(9: “Si doctor renunci!>

J+(/ 1: “9e modo voluntario! P/(9: “+otalmente voluntario

"#$! J+(/ 1: “Osea no es verdad que usted fue despedido!

P/(9: “o doctor es como le vuelvo a repetir que alguien me

quiere hacer daFo! J+(/ 1: “o es verdad que a usted le pidieron

la renuncia tampoco! P/(9: “+ampoco doctor "#$! J+(/ 1:

“PB porque renuncióG, P/(9: “+en(a la necesidad de hacer otras

cosas 9octor de me%orar mi perl, es por eso que luego que sal( de la

notar(a fui a Cegistros 'úblicos, vengo a traba%ar con el 9octor

=laminio Jigo y luego estoy en Cegistros 'úblicos. 'ero lo que

quisiera ser redundante y claro doctor es que las informaciones que


29/52

ustedes tienen me trata de per%udicar que es maliciosa y no se a%usta

para nada a la verdad, yo lamento que estas cosas de alguna forma

se puedan dar pero no es as(, vea mis antecedentes, yo nunca he sido

doctor, investigado, el 9octor @edesma nunca ha tenido ningún

problema conmigo! J+(/ 1: “B al 9octor =laminio Jigo si lo

conoce ustedG P/(9: “'or supuesto 9octor he traba%ado con l

desde el primero de abril del :;-- al :1 de diciembre del :;-1 que

pas a Cegistros 'úblicos! J+(/ 1: “P B al 9octor 7arco ?ntonio

Jigo Co%asG, P/(9: “Ql es integrante del olegio de otarios de

a%amarca, lo cono&co doctor! J+(/ 1: “B que tal se lleva usted

con el 9octor Jigo, bienG P/(9: “@e dir 9octor siempre lo

saludo cortsmente pero no he tenido oportunidad de confraterni&ar

con l!.

A7*7*/ *(9(9 >( +9(/ ( /)( 2 9 ,/7(

?(7((: /! L( D,(+(,79 J+(( N/(+7( D/,/+ M(+,/

A9/97/ V7?/ R/)( 79 (( +9 ( ( /7,7 +9((

/+ /+ Y+= R7,>(+ G(*(++( V7?/ ,>( 1< (3+7

2014 9 979?9 */*9/ >( 7(/?(/ ,/9 +/9( 97 (9 97

+(9 ,/9,+/ 37,/ 9(,7/9( *K+7/ 9/(+7/ *9/

>( +/,7/ ( +,/*9(+/ ( 9(7 / 97 77+( 79

9*+/ ,(+ 9/ >(379/ 97/ ,/*97,(,79 ,/9 +/9(

9 979?9 */*9/ 9?(9/ (* ,(7+ >,>/

(+73=( 9 ,(9/ ( +,/*9(+ (+( ,/9,+/ 9/(+7/

+F+79/ 9/ / 9 (/ (*77(+7( (+( ,/9 +/9(

(7*7*/ 79: '! E OF,7/ N° 2-2014-MLI-NC ,>( 06

3++/ 2014 /3+(9 /)( 21 ( 22 /+ *7/ ,(

N/(+7/ P37,/ ( ,7( M7? L*( I9/+/( ,/*97,(

( / /+ J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( >(379/ /*(/

,/9/,7*79/ 9 B(*9 /+( /(9 Y+= R7,>(+

G(*(++( V7?/ +(7 *(+ 04 3++/ 2014 >(

(7/ 7+,(*9 ( +/9( *(97(9/ ++7/

/(9 >(3+( 7/ 7/ / /37?(/ ( +99,7(+

(* /+ (,(+ ,/*/ *(/ /F,7/


30/52

9/(+7( >(3+( 79(+(/ 9 +/,/ )7,7( 9 D7+7/

J7,7( L(*3(= : '.1! El seFor Bury Cichard Iamarra

Jigo, reali&ó pr)cticas profesionales y luego laboró por varios aFos

en su ocio notarial, la referida persona renunció voluntariamente,

nunca fue conminado a renunciar, y mucho menos fue despedido>

'.2! o es cierto que se le haya instaurado un proceso %udicial en el

departamento de @ambayeque por su actuar como su empleado, si

bien es cierto existe un proceso ste est) relacionado con el mal

actuar de un ex empleado, ?lberto Seminario J)sque&. A?+?(9/

9 ,/9,79 /+ Y+= R7,>(+ G(*(++( V7?/ 9/

7/ /+ +/9( *,>/ *9/ /37?(/ ( +99,7(+

((9/ 9 7*/ (3/+ 9 /F,7/ 9/(+7( */+

9 ,/*/+(*79/ +// +/9(3 = (,(/ 9/

>(379/ 7/ /3)/ (9,7/9 97 (*(( (9,79

F9(*9 (( 9,9+( 9 +*7 9 +/,/ )7,7(

/3+ N7( A,/ J+7,/ ++7/ ( 9( ,(+(,79

P+,+7,79 A777@( D/*797/ 9 ( ,( ++7/ /(9

!,+(+7/ N/(+7( A9/ N/ C/99,7// +/

,/9/+* ( / (,(/ /3+(9 9 (+,>7@/ 9/(+7(

(+,7(+ +/,/ (9 ++7/ (++/ ,/9/+* ( =.

T(*37K9 79 9 ,9(: *! L( ,/7( ?(7(( ( T+(9(,,79

EB+()7,7( ,>( 12 7*3+ 201440 *7(9 ( ,(

/ O/+?(9 N/(+7/ P37,/ M7? L*( I9/+/( =

*(9(9 Y+= R7,>(+ G(*(++( V7?/ 9 +(,79 ( /,*9/

( 9,9+( 79+/ = ,+7/ /+ ++7/

N/(+7/ >(,9 ( 7?79 +,77/9: e.1) El otario 7iguel

@edesma Nnostro&a no tiene ni ha tenido la intención de interponer

acciones en contra del seFor Bury Cichard Iamarra Jigo, ya que en

ningún momento fue per%udicado por su actuar cuando fue su

empleado, tampoco fue negligente en las labores desempeFadas en

la otar(a 7iguel @edesma Nnostro&a> e.2) El seFor Bury Cichard

40 6u# $#n# 7% n!! !8!! % 5#85% n#.!8$% #n # %8u#n$% ! n#$%,8%n


31/52

Iamarra Jigo renunció a la notar(a 7iguel @edesma Nnostro&a,

renuncia que no fue intempestiva, fue comunicada con anticipación

al empleador> no fue despedido ni obligado a renunciar, tampoco se

fue de la notar(a por los asuntos no contenciosos antes detallados, ya

que los proceso %udiciales, de tr)mite regular, se iniciaron con

posterioridad a su renuncia> y, e.3) El otario 7iguel @edesma

Nnostro&a maniesta que no conoce el contenido exacto de la

información respecto del seFor Bury Cichard Iamarra Jigo

proporcionada por la 9ecana del olegio de otarios de a%amarca

al doctor arlos Enrique Mecerra 'alomino "miembro del Lurado

alicador del oncurso 'úblico de acceso a la función notarial$ y al

Lurado alicador Especial, pero en todo caso, se compromete a

tratar de obtener y entregar posteriormente copias de los informes .

D 7?( /+*( @(/+(: ! L( +( ,/997( 9 OF,7/ N°

2;;-2014-JU!CN!TAH ,>( 1< 3++/ 2014 /+ (+

!,+(+7/ TK,97,/ A H/, C/9,+/ P37,/ N(,7/9(

MK+7/ (+( I9?+/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7( M(+9 E(+/

N(@(++/ C((9/ +9 ( ( /7,7 /(9 ,>( 1

3++/ 2014 *7(9 ,( 797,( ( /(9

,/9 +,/ ( 7/+7/ ,/7( 7* / /,*9/

>(=(9 7/ +*77/ ( J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( /+ 97(

37,( = +7@(( (9 = K B(*9 /+( ,>( 04

3++/ 2014 >(,79/ ( 3( 9 (+,>7@/

(@7+ 9/ B7 79/+*(,79 (?9( ( ,/*/: @! L( +(

,/997( 9 OF,7/ N° 282-2014-JU!CN!TAH ,>( 26

*(+/ 2014 /+ (+ +,7(/ !,+(+7/ TK,97,/ +9 (

( /7,7 /(9 ,>( 24 *(+/ 2014 *7(9

,( 797,( ( /(9 (,+/ ( ( 79/+*(,79

/7,7(( +,/ ( +7*+ 7/ +*7 OF,7/ N° 6;-

201;-!GGYT ,>( 06 7,7*3+ 201; +*77( /+ (

A(*3( N(,7/9( R,/+ ( +(@K !,+(+7/ G9+(

()99/ +/+ N° 01;-2014 R?7+/ N(,7/9(

G+(/ = T/ OF,7/ N° 018-2014MLI-NC ,>( 06 3++/


32/52

2014 +*77/ /+ N/(+7/ P37,/ M7? L*( I9/+/(

= +,/ ?9/ 7/ (( +*7 ,/7(

@7/ B(*9 /+( D/,/+ Y+= R7,>(+ G(*(++( V7?/

9+?( 9 02 C +,/ ( +,+ 7/ +*7 ,/7( (

(+ +799 A,( EB(*9 O+( ( 04 3++/

2014 ,/979 ( 79/+*(,79 /7,7(( +,/ ,(+/

7/ 9/ B7 /,*9/ 79>737,79 ( P+79

C/9)/ N/(+7(/ /( @ /7,7 79( (+(

(9(+ */+(*9 9 ( @((,79 /+( ,/*/ ,/9( 9

(,( B(*9 /+( ( 04 3++/ 2014 ()9(

9 7/ 9*+/ 0; ( 79/ = B/ 7/ 9/ B7 (

79/+*(,79 /7,7(( = ( K7*/ 7/ +*7 ( (

79/+*(,79 ()9(( 9 7/ 1.

NOVENO.- !79/ ( ( ,/( (9/ ( ( (+ *(9((

/+ +79,77/ (77,79 / ,/*97( +3( /+, /

*7/ +3( /+,7/ /+ ( (+ *(9(9 9 ,+7/

/(/+7/ = 979/ 9 ,/97+(,79 ( (( B(*9

/+( (K( 9 ( ,( +*7 * (*7/ *+?9 (,,79 3)7@( (+( J+(/ (@7+ ( ,779

(+/3(/+7( 9 7,>( (( ,/9,+/ ,(( /+ J+(/

C(7F,(/+ E,7( ( /(9 @79 9 7++(/9(3 9 (9/

(@7+ ,(+(*9 >(9 /+*(/ +?9( *(7,7/( =

*(97F(*9 7++(/9(3 @79,(( ,/9 ( F9(7( (

@((,79 9,9+( ,/9*(( 9 (+,/ 25°

A9B/ D,+/ !+*/ N° 021-2012-JU! Q R?(*9/ C/9,+/ P37,/ N(,7/9( MK+7/ (+( I9?+/ ( ( 9,79

N/(+7( ,/9/+*7( ,/9 ( P+7*+( = !?9( D7/7,79

C/**9(+7( = T+(97/+7( ( L= N° 2


33/52

numeración correlativa al referido Malotario. ?dicionalmente, el

examen oral comprender) preguntas sobre su trayectoria personal,

cultura general y principios ticos!. A* 79 9 ,9(

,(+(*9 (@7+ ( +(9,+7,79 @/ ut supra

,7(*9 / J+(/ 1 = 2 >(9 97/ +@7(*9 ( (

@((,79 9 *9,79 9 )7,7/ @(/+ 9?(7@/ +,/

/(9 9 / (( ( +(,79 ,/9 9/(+7/ M7?

L*( I9/+/( 79 (( @/ 9 +/3*( 9 ( C/+

L(*3(= ( +( /(9 >7/ (?/ (3( *(

= / ,/*7, >(,79/ ++9,7( ( 9( 79/+*(,79 ,/9 /

,/9(3(9 9 7,>/ */*9/ = 9 +(,79 ( 9( ( 799,7(

N/(+7/ M(+,/ A9/97/ V7?/ R/)( @9+(9/ ( *(9+( (

@7&+8 '* )=7/( ,77+. !79/

( 7*(+,7(7( + 997( /77@(*9 ,/*/ (

799,79 (@/+,+ 79+K 37,/ *(97(/ 9

,/9,+/ *K+7/ = 9?(7@(*9 ,/*/ ( +/>737,79

,77+ 979/ 9 )7,7/ ++*79(/ /77@/ / 9?(7@(*9

/3+ 9/ / * / ,(97(/ *// 9 )+(/

,(7F,(/+ 9?( 797/7,79 B+(( +,/ 9/ /

,(97(/ ( 9/(+7/ /9 9 +7?/ *(97F/ ( 3,(( )7,7(

( ,779. !79/ ( ?(+(9( +/,( +,/9/,7(

B+(*9 9 (+,/ 8° 79,7/ 1S ( C/9@9,79 A*+7,(9(

/3+ D+,>/ H*(9/ ( ,/*/ 9 (+,/ 14° 79,7/ 1

P(,/ I9+9(,7/9( D+,>/ C7@7 = P/7,/ / ,( /+*(9

(+ +,>/ 9(,7/9( 9 @7+ (+,/ 55° (

C/97,79.41 MB7* 7 79,/ (*(+7( >( @7+(/ /

((/ /+ J+(/ C(7F,(/+ ,/9 ( +9(,79 (

D,(+(,79 J+(( N/(+7/ P37,/ M(+,/ A9/97/ V7?/ R/)(

41 EP& N&° 0'*++-2010-PKC/TC, Fun!#n$% *&


34/52

*(97(9/ 79,/ 97?( ,(7+ >,>/ (+73=(

9 ,(9/ ( +,/*9(+ (+( C/9,+/ N/(+7/ = ,/9

OF,7/ N° 2-2014-MLI-NC = T+(9(,,79 EB+()7,7( *9,7/9(/

ut supra (*37K9 +9 N/(+7/ M7? L*(

I9/+/( 97,/ ( ((+ /+ Y+= R7,>(+ G(*(++(

V7?/ +99,7 @/9(+7(*9 7 379 >( 79(+(/ 9

+/,/ )7,7( *7*/ +(,7/9(/ ,/9 *( (,(+

B *(/ A3+/ !*79(+7/ V = /+/ +/,/

)7,7( N7( A,/ J+7,/ 7 379 9 +*7 =

++7/ /(9 !,+(+7/ N/(+7( A9/ N/

C/99,7// (K (++/ ,/9/+* ( = 9 979?9

*/*9/ +)7,(/ /+ (,(+ ,(9/ *(/ =

(*/,/ 9?7?9 9 ( (3/+ *(( 9 (

N/(+( ( ,(+?/ *(97(9/ 79,/ 9/ ,/9/, ,/997/

B(,/ ( 79/+*(,79 +,/ /+ Y+= R7,>(+ G(*(++(

V7?/ +//+,7/9(( /+ ( D,(9( C/?7/ N/(+7/

C()(*(+,( ( D/,/+ C(+/ E9+7 ,++( P(/*79/ *7*3+/

J+(/ C(7F,(/+ C/9,+/ P37,/ (,,/ ( ( 9,79

9/(+7( = ( J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( ,/9 / @79,7(

( /(9 *(9+( 7++(/9(3 79)7F,(( 7*(

,/ 9 39( ,9( *+,(9 +(=,/+7( +/9( =

+79,77/ K7,/ / ,( /+*(3(9 (+ @((,79 /+(

>(,79/ (79 79,/ ( 9( 79/+*(,79 ,7(*9

J+(/ 1 +F+ 799 9 /+ 79/ *= 7*7(/

+,>/ 9( /(9 ( /++9+/ ,/9 (

79/+*(,79 9 7,>( (( @((,79 /+( 79 /+ ,/9(+ 9

*/*9/ ,/9 / *7/ +/3(/+7/ ,/++/979 (+(

/+ @7+(+( ,/*/ >( /7/ >(,+/ *7(9 +/,/

,/97,7/9( *,>/ * 7 ,/*/ +F+ (*(+7( (

79/+*(,79 ()/ 9+ 9 /+ J+(/ C(7F,(/+

E,7( 9/ +9(( ,/9/+* ( +/,7*79/ (,>( ( /

/(9 9,9+( +?(/ 9 (+,/ 18° A9B/


35/52

D,+/ !+*/ N° 021-2012-JU!42 (* >( +/,7/ 9

( *9,7/9(( @((,79 ,/9 9( (9,7( +(/9(377(

/+?(9/ +,>/ 9(*9( +9,79 79/,9,7( (

(,/+ *7*/ ,/97= 9 9 @+(+/ +,>/ 3)7@/

( + ,/97+(( /( +/9( 79/,9 ,(7+ 7/

(+73=( 9 (9/ +/9(377( ( +*79(( /+

(/+7( 79 *3(+?/ /3)7@(*9 J+(/ C(7F,(/+

*((/ 9/ >( ,/9(/ ,/9 / *7/ +/3(/+7/ F,79

(+( ,/++/3/+(+ ( 79/+*(,79 ( ,( ( 9(9 9

/+ 7*79/ ( 7*(+ 9( +*79(( ,/9,( *B7*

7 ( >(3+ 7/ /7,7(( /+ /(9 7,>( 79/+*(,79 (

J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( ,/9/+* (@7+ ut supra *7*/

( +(@K !,+(+7/ TK,97,/ A H/, M(+9 E(+/ N(@(++/

C((9/ >( +/97/ ,/9 OF,7/ N° 2;;-2014-JU!CN!TAH

;%* &, *+* &,7)/B& (=(9 7/ +*77/ ( J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( /+ 97(

37,( = +7@(( (9 = K B(*9 /+( ,>( 04

3++/ 2014 +@7( 3( (+,>7@/ >(379/

79,/ +7+(/ * ((9 ,/9 ( *779 OF,7/ N° 282-

2014-JU!CN!TAH 9/ B7 79/+*(,79 (?9( +,/ (

/F,7/ / ,(7+ ,/*97,(,79 (9/?( ( P+79

C/9)/ N/(+7(/ ,/*/ 79?+(9 J+(/ C(7F,(/+ / 9

)+,7,7/ (+73,7/9 >(=( 7+7?7/ ( ( D,(9( C/?7/

N/(+7/ C()(*(+,( /,/+( E= A)(9+79( L/(9/

G7K++ ( (+7+ ;0 9+/ 2014 ( ( ,>(

+9(,79 /7,7 = 97,(*9 B79 +

42 A$8u% 1*"- D# ! T!85! ! % 7%$u!n$# 1'.1. En # 7!% B.% # 8n8% ) !8!#n!%, 8%n$!% ## ! 7u8!8;n !u! #n # nu#! 1( &1 # !$8u% 1(° #7##n$# R#3!#n$%, 8u!u# 7#%n! 7%B


36/52

/,*9/ ++7/ (: OF,7/ N° 6;-201;-!GGYT ,>( 06

7,7*3+ 201; OF,7/ N° 018-2014-!UNARP!G ,>( 08

9+/ 2014 = OF,7/ N° 2-2014MLI-NC ,>( 06 3++/

2014 ((/ ut supra. D / ,( ,/9,= ( ,779

(+/3(+ ( /(9 (/ 9 ( (( @((,79 /+(

>( 9(/ 97,(*9 9 9( ( 79/+*(,79 9/

>( 7/ 37(*9 ,/++/3/+(( (?+(@9/ * ( 7(,79

,(9/ *7*/ J+(/ C(7F,(/+ (( 9/ B7 (

79/+*(,79 *79+( 9 ( +/7( 9+@7( ,/9/+*

@+ +(9,+7,79 9/(+7( ,F,(*9 J+(/ 1

+F+7 9(9 9 /+ 7,>( 79/+*(,79 ,/9 / ,(

@+7F,( >( 79,*7/ ,/9 9( B7?9,7( )7,7( 37,(

*(9( J?(/+4; B+ ( *(=/+ /3)7@7( 9

(++// +/,/44 / ,( (+7,(+*9 3 +9(+

9 / +/,/ 9 / ,( B(*79( ( 7/97( / / *K+7/

9 /(9 (+( (,,+ / +*(9,+ 9 9 ,(+?/ 37,/

>(379/ 79,/ ((/ 9+/ T+739( C/97,7/9( 9 (

*7*( 9( 9(*79/ : “El funcionamiento adecuado de

todo órgano calicador y examinador es otro elemento esencial para

prevenir el abuso de poder por parte del Estado y, por ende, para

proteger los derechos de la persona! A > /( @ ,/*/ 797

J+(/ E,7( C/9,+/ P37,/ N(,7/9( MK+7/ (+(

I9?+/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7( 9/ 3 9+ 979?9( /7,79

++*79(( +,/ / /(9 ( ,/9,+/ 37,/

*K+7/ (+( 79?+/ ( ( 9,79 9/(+7( ( F9 9

*37/ (,(,79 (9 + / * 9+( /73 *+/

/ 9/ >( ,7/ 9 ,(/ (/ @+7F,( 9(9

9( /7,79 ++*79(( ( */*9/ @((+ ( /(9 (

++7+ +?9( @79*9 ?7@(46 = >(( ,7+/ 9/

7*+799 9/ (3(9 ++7( ( ( ,79 (

43 L% 8u! # 5!8# #.$#n# ! Ju!% C!8!% #7!!%&

44 EP& N 000-200-PI/TC, Fun!#n$% 12&

45 EP& N° ''1-2004-PA/TC, Fun!#n$% '1&


37/52

@((,79 79/ (9(3(9 ( /(9 (, >(3(

7/ 7/ =/ /37?(/ ( +99,7(+ ( ( N/(+( P37,(

D/,/+ M7? L*( I9/+/( 37/ ( (,(+ 9?7?9 =

(*37K9 (, 9( 9( *(+,(( (*7( ,/9 D/,/+

M(+,/ V7?/ R/)( 79,/ +F+7 ( /(9 K / @(

( >/(+ @( ( (+ 9( (,77( 9( /F,79( = /+ /+/

(/ >( +?9(/ 9 +7+(( //+97( 7 >( +,737/

(?9( )( / 99,7( 9 R?7+/ P37,/ !UNARP ,(9/ (

*7*( (+ *(9(( ( (+ +( *7(9 OF,7/ N° 282-

2014-JU!CN!TAH >( ()9(/ OF,7/ N° 018-2014-

!UNARP!G ,>( 08 9+/ 2014 ( +(@K ,(

(9B( ( ,/9(9,7( +,/ ,7((9/ Y+= R7,>(+ G(*(++(

V7?/ ++7( ( ( +( @(7(,79 79/+*(,79 /7,7((

/+ ( !,+(+( TK,97,( CPNMIN 9 9 /( 2 /7/

79/ 9 ( +,7(( C/9(9,7( /3+( /)( 20 ,>(

0; 9+/ 2014 ,/97?9( ( +@779 ?()/

+/9( ,7((9/ 9 *9,79 9/ /3+( (9,79 (?9( 9 K.

P+,7(9/ 9 9/ 7 379 +3+/ T+(=,/+7(

P+/9( C+( G9+( = P+79,77/ "7,/ 9( 9 *B7*/

9() 5 = ( E@((,79 A,(K*7,( 15 9/ ,/9/+* ( /

(3,7/ 9 (+,/ 26° A9B/ D,+/ !+*/ N°

021-2012-JU! *9,7/9(/ ut supra 6 79 *3(+?/ ( *(/+7(

(*3( /+ ,(( J+(/ >( (/ ?(+ ( 9( 9/( F9( @((,79

/+( (+,79/ 9/9, +3+/ “+rayectoria 'ersonal,

46

Pregunta sugestiva # ! u# n8! % 7%=%8! un! #7u#$! !!$=! 8%% 9n8!8%n8u;n !8%n! # ! !!8%n# 7#=! u# # =#n # u$#n$%& S# #n! !%78;n # un! #7u#$!


38/52

ultura Ieneral y 'rincipios Qticos! >( 7/ +*79(9 (+( (

@((,79 (+/3(/+7( /(9 7 79 9 ,9(

/(9 D=@7 A9+K P(3/ R/)( 79 9/( 7*7(+ ,/9

*(9(9 9 ( @((,79 (,(K*7,( 10 10 10 = 06 /9

,/97+(( 9/( (+/3(/+7( ?9 99+

M797+7/ J7,7( *+/ 9 ( T+(=,/+7( P+/9(

(7?9( /+ J+(/ 1 9 9() *B7*/ 5 = /+ / /+/

J+(/48 ( 9/( 2 2 = ; ,/9 ( ,( ,=( *(/+7(

+( (+/3(/ 9 @((,79 /+( ,/9 9 9() 12.000

*79+( ( /(9 (/ / J+(/ 1 2 = ; (7?9(9

/ 9() *97*/ 2 1 = 2 /3979/ 9( ,(7F,(,79

(+/3(/+7( 11.;;; +,7@(*9 ,/9 / ,( @7+(

( (?(,79 M797+7/ J7,7( = D+,>/ H*(9/

++9(/ /+ P+/,+(/+ P37,/ L7 +9(9/ M/+9/

++/ ,(9/ +F+ (*(+7( (+/3(/ 9

(3/,79 ( *7,( (,(K*7,( /+ / )+(/ ( (,(+ 10 11

= 08 /( @ / ,/9/+* (@+7+ 9/ ( ?(+ (

(+/3(+ ( (( 979/ 9 ,9( (+*+/ F)(/ ,/9

/(9 D=@7 A9+K P(3/ R/)(. L/ (9+7/+ ?(+( +(,79 ,/9

>,>/ 79/ ( ,779 9 ( (( @((,79 /+(

9( +/@979 9( *+( /+(,79 *(*7,( ,/9+7(

/3+ ( 3( ( ,77/9 J+(/ C(7F,(/+ (9 *

B7?9 ,*7*79/ ( ?(+(9( /+*( = *(+7(

26.2. A $#n! # #.!#n %! # 8!! 7%$u!n$#, 8!! #% # Ju!%

C!8!% E7#8! 8%n3n!B ! n%$! 8%#7%n#n$# ! % L$#!# ! #7##n$# !$8u%, ! 8%% ! u!$%! # !! 8!8!8%n#, ! u# #Bnn$%u8! #n un %# 8#!% 8%n # n%# # 7%$u!n$#, # % u# ##n$#3!B #n 8u$%! # S#8#$!% T:8n8% A K%8&26.3. A 8%n8u # #.!#n %! # $%% % 7%$u!n$#, # Ju!% C!8!% E7#8!7%nB u# # S#8#$!% T:8n8% A K%8 !! % %# 8#!%, 7%8##n% #P#n% ! 8%%8! ! n%$! # 8!! 7%$u!n$# #n %#n #8u#n8! # !% ! #n%, !#


39/52

37/ +/,/ 9 ,(( 9( ( (( +/,/ ( *7*(

9 + 3+(9(( 7 ,/9+(7,9 9 ,/997/

9,7( ( ( >/+( (/(+ 9( ,779.

DKCIMO.- E9 ( 97/ (9/ ( / B/ 9 /,/97+(9/ +,9 ( ,(7F,(,79 (,/+ 3()/ /

/ >(9 *9,7/9(/ ut supra 9/ +@7

+(/9(377( (+( + ,(7F,(/ +*(+(*9 9/ *+,79/

(*(+(+ / ((/ /+ P+/,+(/+ P37,/ M797+7/

J7,7( ( ++7+ 9 ,/9(,79 *(9( / +(/

,(( (( /9 7*79(/+7/ 7++@7(3 797*?9(3

,/9/+* ( (+,/ 1


40/52

@((,79 /+( 9 / ,/++/979 ( +3+/ ( +(=,/+7(

+/9( = +79,77/ K7,/ >(9 ,/977/ 9( 3(+++(

/3,/ 9+/ +/,/ (,,/ ( ( 9,79 37,( 9/(+7(

79,*79/ ,/9 ( B7?9,7( *(+7( )7,7( ,7+ ,/9

( 7*979 *(+7( 37/ +/,/. A (*37K9

79(3*9 79 9 ,/97+(,79 ( @9+(,79 ( (

@7&+8 '* ),+/B& '*


41/52

)+7,( +,/ )+,7,7/ 9 +,>/ 9(*9( ,/*/

,(/ +,>/ (,,/ ( ( 9,79 37,(. L( +(/9

)7F,(9 ( ?(+(9( >(9 7/ (@+7( /+ T+739(

C/97,7/9( ,(9/ ((: “El derecho a la motivación

constituye una garant(a fundamental en los supuestos en que con la

decisión emitida se afecta de manera negativa la esfera o situación

%ur(dica de las personas! 2 = : “+odo órgano que decide a travs

de un proceso, sea cual fuese su naturale&a, deber) dar cuenta de

esta su%eción "al derecho$ a n de despe%ar cualquier sospecha de

arbitrariedad!A;. I9,/ ( B7?9,7( )7,7( /+*(

7?(*9 *// 9/ ,(9/ >( /*(+ 9( ,779 ,/9

3( ( 9( /( 7,+,7/9(. A / >( )(/ ,(+(*9 7,>/

(3,7/ T+739( C/97,7/9( ,(9/ ((: “este

+ribunal reitera que un acto administrativo dictado al amparo de

una potestad discrecional legalmente establecida resulta

arbitrario cuando solo expresa la apreciación individual de quien

e%erce la competencia administrativa, o cuando el órgano

administrativo, al adoptar la decisión, no expresa las ra&ones que lo

han conducido a adoptar tal decisión!A-. D *// : “@a

proscripción de que los actos discrecionales de la ?dministración del

Estado sean arbitrarios exige que stos sean motivados> es decir, que

se basen necesariamente en ra&ones y no se constituyan en la mera

expresión de la voluntad del órgano que los dicte!A:. A7*7*/

3 9(7(+ ( ,(7F,(,79 / /(9

9,9+( +?(( *(9+( B+( 9 (+,/ 20° (9(

@, *9,7/9(/ A9B/ D,+/ !+*/ N° 021-2012 79/

: “:;.- @os postulantes ser)n descalicados en cualquier estado

del proceso por las siguientes causales< a5 Suministrar información

falsa o adulterar los documentos exigidos en cualquier etapa del

49 EP& N&° 0'*+1-2011-PA/TC, Fun!#n$% 1&

50 I#&

51 #, Fun!#n$% 21& E #!$!% # ! #$! # !!%&

52 EP& N&° 00+0-2004-PA/TC, Fun!#n$% 1)&


42/52

concurso, sin per%uicio de las acciones legales pertinentes> b5 Jalerse

o pretenderse hacerlo a travs de in/uencias o recomendaciones

para obtener venta%a en los ex)menes o en la calicación, incluyendo

pagos, d)divas o promesas de pago> sin per%uicio de la

responsabilidad civil, penal o administrativa que se deriven de este

hecho> c5 Suplantar o ser suplantado y plagiar o intentar plagiar

durante las etapas de evaluación del concurso> d5 @a inasistencia o

impuntualidad del postulante a cualquier etapa de evaluación del

concurso! +,+7379/ * ((9 “:;.:. En los casos

seFalados en los incisos a5 y b5 el Lurado alicador Especial emitir)

resolución y en los comprendidos en el inciso c5 y d5, el Secretario

+cnico ?d Hoc o un funcionario autori&ado de%ar) constancia en

acta, que suscribir) con%untamente con el 'residente y un miembro

del Lurado alicador Especial, en la que indicar) el nombre

completo del postulante y la ra&ón de la descalicación!. C/9 /

(@7+ >(9 (3,7/ +?(*9(+7(*9 +*79(/

/ 3()/ / ,( 9( @ ,/*+/3(/ 979

9,9+( 9(*9 )7F,(3 ( ,(7F,(,79 ,(7+

/(9 9 ,(7+ (( +/,/ 79/ ( ,/9,(

7*(( /+ J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( ( (,,7/9(9 9/

9,9+(9 (3,7( 9 7,>/ *(+,/ ?( = 7 379 ( / */

/+( 99+ 9( ( @/ ++7( ( ( ,(( 3S 9

*9,79 7,>/ / 9/ >( 7/ 37(*9 ,/++/3/+(/ = 7

/ >37 7/ ( 3( +/,+ ,/9/+* ( / +?(/ 9

9*+( 20.2 / J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( 3( *77+

+/,79 79 *3(+?/ / 9/ >( /,++7/ ,/9/+* (@7+

(/. Y 7?79/ (+*+/ (3,7/ 9 +,7(/ (+,/

/ >,>/ 7*(+ 9( ,/9,( 9?7?9,7( (+

/(9 9 (9+7/+ +(3()/ 9 ( N/(+( L*( I9/+/(

7*/+( 9 >,>/ +@(9 (+( ,77+ (,,/ ( ( 9,79

37,( 9/(+7( B7?( 9 +/99,7(*79/ B+/ ( +(@K

9( +/,79 37(*9 */7@(( ,79/ / *7*/ 7

J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( ,/9((3( /(9 >(3(


43/52

*797+(/ 79/+*(,79 (( +,/ 9/ 9+ (?9( (9,79

(*797+(7@( 7*( /+ ( !UNARP R?7+/ P37,/. !79/

79,/ 7 ( (,( 9/ 9 +@7( 9 R?(*9/

/ +@ ((9/ ( 97,( D7/7,79 C/**9(+7(

79( (3,: “@os supuestos no previstos en el presente

Ceglamento ser)n resueltos por el Lurado alicador Especial del

oncurso 'úblico acional de 7ritos para el Nngreso a la =unción

otarial hasta su conclusión con car)cter inimpugnable, salvo

aquellas facultades establecidas por el presente Ceglamento al

7inisterio de Lusticia y 9erechos Humanos! ,/9 / ,( ?(+(97(

( +(/9(377( = /3)7@7( ( ,77/9 3 (/(+

J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( 9 (,,/ ( ( 9,79 37,(

9/(+7( ,7(*9 9 ( (( @((,79 /+( 79

(*7/ *+?9 3)7@7(.

D /+/ (/ (*37K9 (@7+ ( @9+(,79 '*7*/:,

/,&++%/,&< < +7, *7*/ 9,9+( 97*(*9

@79,(( ,/9 +/=,/ @7( 797@7/ ++7,,79

7*7,( 9 /3,/ ( (++// ( +/9( = (9 @7(. E9

( ,/ +,>/ ( ( 73+( +(3()/ //9 (9/ (

(+7,(+ ,/*/ ( ( (,,79 (( ,( 3 9 ( *7( /

/73 +?(+ (,(,79 ( /+*( ( 79+@9,79 *97*(

/3+ +,>/ ( )7F,(/ 79 *3(+?/ ,/*/ @79

79779/ >( ++79?7/ 79)7F,((*9 (,,/ ( (

9,79 37,( 9/(+7( = /+ 9 >( (/ +?(/ +,>/

( +(3()/. P/+ ( +(/9 3 (*(+(+ ( +979

*(9(9 /3+ ( N7( ( E9+@7( B(*9 /+( =

(,( ,/979 / +(/ ,/9,+/ 37,/ (,,/ (

( 9,79 9/(+7( ,>( 04 3++/ 2014 9 B+*/

(,,7/9(9 ((+, ,/*/ (+/3(/ = 9 ,/9,9,7(

+7=9/ ( ,/( ( (/ (9+7/+ ( ( @9+(,79

+,>/ ,/97,7/9( / >(( ( (( @((,79

,+7( 3 7/9+ J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7(

C/9,+/ N(,7/9( (+( 79?+/ ( ( 9,79 9/(+7( @@( (


44/52

+(7(+ ( @((,79 9+@7( +/9( B(*9 /+( (

+,++9.

DKCIMO PRIMERO.- C/9 +,/ ( ( +97/9 9

,(/ (+/3(+ ( @((,79 9+@7( /+( /+9

(3/+ 9 9@/ ,(+/ *K+7/ B(*9 /+( D7+7/

N/(+7( C()(*(+,( 79,=9/ ( // / /(9

(+/3(+/9 ++7/ ,/9,+/ = (7*7*/ ,(+ (

N7( ( R/,79 M797+7( N° 0060-2014-JU! ,>( 2

3++/ 2014 +@ 9/*3+(+ ( /+ (3/?(/ D=@7

A9+K P(3/ R/)( ,/*/ N/(+7/ D7+7/ C()(3(*3(

D(+(*9/ C()(*(+,( D7+7/ N/(+7( C()(*(+,( = (N7( ( R/,79 M797+7( N° 0061-2014-JU! ,>( 2

3++/ 2014 +@ 9/*3+(+ ( /+ (3/?(/

H*3+/ J(7* U+379( V ,/*/ N/(+7/ D7+7/ L/

(/ I9,( D(+(*9/ C()(*(+,( D7+7/ N/(+7(

C()(*(+,( 3 ((+ 7 379 (*(+( ( +979

(,/+ ( ( +(7(,79 9( 9@( @((,79 /+( = (9

9,/9+9/ 9 / + K( (+/3(/+7( ,/*/ +F+ (,,7/9(9 9 7/+7/ / 9/ (*+7( 9,(+7(*9

@9+ +,>/ / * /(9 >(=(9 7/

9/*3+(/ 9/(+7/ 9 ( +,7@( /,(7( (7?9(( (

>(3+ 7/ 9/*3+(/ ?/ 9 +/,/ +?(+ +,/ ( /

*7*/ = /+ (* (,/+ / ( D7+7/ N/(+7(

C()(*(+,( * 9/ ( 9( (( ,F,( ?9 ( +/7(

9(*9(,79 *(9(9 9 *(9( 9(*9/ 1B79 @(+7( (( @(,(9 9 D7+7/ N/(+7( /

7*7,( +,>/ *(9(9 9,9+( ?(+(97(/

+97/9 /3+ ( ,( 9/ 79,7 +/,/ (*(+/

( ,779 +*79(+ 7 /(9 (+3( / 9/ ( 9+@7(

/+( ,/9 ( 37( ?(+(9( /+*( = *(+7( 37/

+/,/ = 7 9 ,(/ 7 (K( (7(,/+7( +(7(+ (

(,,7/9 ((( 9 (+,/ 2° R?(*9/ C/9,+/P37,/ N(,7/9( MK+7/ (+( I9?+/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7(


45/52

,/9/+*7( ,/9 ( P+7*+( = !?9( D7/7,79 C/**9(+7(

T+(97/+7( ( L= N° 2/ B+*/.

DKCIMO SEGUNDO.- P/+ /+/ (/ ,/9 +(,79 ( ,+7/ ,>(

0< )7/ 2015 *7(9 ,( ,/*(9(/ D=@7 A9+K

P(3/ R/)( /7,7( ( EB+/*779 P+/,/ F?+( 9/

53Artículo 2/.- Del resultado %nal 2/.1. C%n ! 8un!8;n # ! 8!8!8;n ##.!#n %!, # Ju!% C!8!% E7#8! #$!#8#B # 7%#% n! # 8!!

7%$u!n$# !7%!% #n ! $# #$!7! # 8%n8u%, !78!n% % 7#% 7#=$% #n #A$8u% 1+° # 7##n$# R#3!#n$%&2/.2. En # 8!% # 7%$u!n$# n%$!% #n ##88% u# n% $#n3!n !n8%n# #n %9$% 8n8% ) !% % $#n3!n un! !n$3#! n% #n% # $# ' !%, # !78!B !%n8!8;n ! u# # ### # A$8u% (" # D#8#$% L#3!$=% # !n#! ! !% n%$!% 8%n $!!% $#7%! 7u#$% #39n ! 6un$! D7%8;nC%7##n$!! T!n$%! # ! L#& En 85% u7u#$%, ! %n8!8;n # !78!B8%n


46/52

,/9*(( B+(*9 9 9+/ C7?/ P+/,(

C/97,7/9( 79 *3(+?/ (979/ ( (+,/ 10° C7?/

P+/,( C7@7 (7,(,79 /+7( ( +9 ,(/ Q ,/*/ /

+@K (+,/ IX T/ P+7*79(+ C7?/ P+/,( C7@7 Q

Excepcionalmente, en cualquier momento el Lue& por resolución

debidamente motivada, puede separar del proceso a un tercero

legitimado, por considerar que el derecho o inters que lo legitimaba

ha desaparecido o haber comprobado su inexistencia. E9 97/

/ /7,7(/ /+ +,++9 @79 9 (*(+(3 ( >(3+

@+7F,(/ 7 379 7,7/9(9 @/ 797,7(*9 ( ,/97,79

)/ +/,( *(9(/ ( ,/97,79 9/ ,/++,(

( +@779 ( 9(*9(,79 ,7,( ( *(9( (/

(@7+ 9/ 79 ( ,(7( 79/ ( +,+/ ?77*(/54 /+

,(9/ >( (?(/ ( (,(,79 +,>/ ,/97,7/9(

97,(*9 (+ J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7( C/9,+/

P37,/ N(,7/9( MK+7/ (+( I9?+/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7( =

M797+7/ J7,7( = D+,>/ H*(9/ *( 9/ /7,7(9

*B7* 7 (9/ ( 9 ( ,/97+(,79 (9+7/+ >(

(3,7/ ( + 7*( +97/9 *(9(9 +9

,(+(( 7*+/,9 /+ ,(9/ 7*7,(9 ( @9+(,79

+,>/ / * /(9 >(=(9 7/ 9/*3+(/

2/.'. E P##n$# # Ju!% C!8!% E7#8! 8%un8!B ! Mn$% % Mn$! # Ju$8! D##85% Ku!n%, # #u$!% # C%n8u% P98% # M:$% 7!! #In3#% ! ! Fun8;n N%$!!, 8%n


47/52

9/(+7/ 9 ( +,7@( /,(7( (7?9(( ( >(3+ 7/

9/*3+(/ ?/ 9 +/,/ +?(+ +,/ ( / *7*/ >(

@(9,7/ 79+K = ( (,(,79 +,>/55 /

7?97F,( >( ,/*+/3(/ >(,79*9 +,+/ 9

*9,79 9/ 79 979?9 +,>/ 97 79+K 9 7,79 9

+/,/ /+ / 3 + B,7/ ( +(,79 )+7,( +/,(

379/ ( ,(+(+.

DKCIMO TERCERO.- D /+/ (/ (@7+ ( 7(,79

+/,( (9 797,(( (*37K9 (7,( +,/ /(9

C>+7/>+ A)(9+/ 7 C(3++( 79 7 379 (*37K9

797,7(*9 ,/97+(/ ,/*/ (+ *(9(( 9 +(7( ,/97,79 (*37K9 +,+/ ?77*(/ /+ / ( >(3+

@(9,7/ 79+K 9 +/,/ /+ ,(9/ ( +979

+79,7( /7,7(( /+ (,/+ 7*(9/ 9/ 7*7,( (

(,(,79 +,>/ ( 9/*3+(*79/ ,/*/ N/(+7/ >(

/397/ ?/ ( *779 ( ,779 F9( +,(( 9

EB79 N° 001-2014-80-0601-JM-CI-01 ?9 (@+7+

!IJ Q !7*( I9?+(/ J7,7( 9 (7,(,79 +,7(/(+,/ 10° C7?/ P+/,( C7@7 3 /+9(+ /F,7/

B,79 +9 +/,/ 7 79 9 ,9( )

/F,7/ / ( 7/ (+ (,(/ ( ,77+ ( (+(,79

+/,( 9 +,+/ ?77*(/ 79 /+ (,/ +/,( (9+7/+

/ >(3( (*77/ ( +/,/.

DKCIMO CUARTO.- 79(*9 +,/ ( ,/( = ,//

+/,/ 979/ 9 ,9( (+,/ 56° C7?/ P+/,(

C/97,7/9( = 79/ ( *(9( + ,(+(( 9(( 9

(+ +( +(/9(3 7/9+ ( B/9+(,79 (?/ K/

55 E% $#n#n% #n 8u#n$! ! n$#7#$!8;n #.$#n=! # 7#8$!% !$8u% 10(°, u#%7#! 8u!n% # #.$#n# # !8!n8# # ! n%! ! u7u#$% n% 8%7#n%#.7#!#n$# #n #!, 7% 8%n#! u# 5!! % =%un$! # #3!%8%7#n# #n ! n%! ! !78!, $!# u7u#$%&


48/52

,/9,/ 9 (7,(,79 /+7( (+,/ 412° C7?/

P+/,( C7@756.

II.- PARTE RESOLUTIVA D*/B&.

P/+ ( ,/97+(,7/9 = 9/+*( ?/(( = (,+/ (*

,/9 / (+,/ 1;8 1;


49/52

PÚLICO NACIONAL DE MKRITOS PARA EL INGRESO A

LA $UNCI"N NOTARIAL = MINISTERIO DE JUSTICIA

DERECHOS HUMANOS 9 9/9, ++9(/ /+

D/,/+ D(97 A?/ 7?(/ R7@(9=+( = (,(*9

*(/ /+ D/,/+ G(@/ A+7(9K9 O(=(. E9

,/9,9,7(: (.1! ! DECLARA NULA ( 9+@7(

B(*9 /+( = (,( ,/979 / +(/ C/9,+/

P37,/ A,,/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7( ,>( 04 3++/

2014 *77( /+ J+(/ C(7F,(/+ E,7(

C/9,+/ P37,/ A,,/ ( ( 9,79 N/(+7( 9

B+*/ (,,7/9(9 ((+, ,/*/ (+/3(/ (.2!

REPONIENDO LAS COSAS AL ESTADO ANTERIOR ( (

@9+(,79 / +,>/ ,/97,7/9( ( +(3()/ 37/

+/,/ = 37( */7@(,79 ( +/,7/9

(*797+(7@( ORDENO / *(9(/ +797,79 (

@((,79 9+@7( +/9( B(*9 /+( ( +,++9

,/9/+* ( +/,7*79/ +@7/ /+ / (+,/ 255 = 2658

A9B/ D,+/ !+*/ N° 021-2012-JU! 9 +7,(

57 Artículo 2!.- Del desarrollo del ea&en E #.!#n %! # #


50/52

/3+@(9,7( ( ?(+(9( /+*( = *(+7( 37/

+/,/ (9 (++/(( EN EL PLAZO PERENTORIO E

IMPRORROGALE %& /%&', %*7 =* E Ju# 7u## #8 u# ! u$! !8uu!$=! !8#n!n 5!$! # 8#n 7% 8#n$%7% 8!! ! 8!#n!%, 5!$! # !8!$!#n$% # !n!$% u8!&

E %n$% #8!u!% 7% ! u$! 8%n$$u# n3#% 7%7% # P%# Ju8!, !=%u# ! 7!$# !8!$# # !n!$% u8! #n$% # % $# ! 7%$#%# ! ! 7%8;n# ! u$!& En #$# 9$% 8!%, # %n$% #8!u!% #B #=u#$% #n u n$#3! !u $$u!&

60 Artículo !9.- ",ecución de *entencia Sn 7#u8% # % #$!#8% #n #!$8u% 22 # 7##n$# C;3%, ! #n$#n8! # u# #8!!


51/52

(IV! DECLARAR IMPROCEDENTE ( +979 ,/97,7/9(

(*(+/ ,/997( 9 ( *(9( /)( ;2 ( 4( 2

3++/ 2014 +@ 9/*3+(+ ( /+ (3/?(/

D=@7 A9+K P(3/ R/)( ,/*/ N/(+7/ 7+7/

C()(3(*3( (+(*9/ C()(*(+,( 7+7/ 9/(+7(

C()(*(+,( = (.! ! ,(+ ( 97( ( R/,79

M797+7( N° 0061-2014-JU! ,>( 2 3++/ 2014

+@ 9/*3+(+ ( /+ (3/?(/ H*3+/ J(7*

U+379( V ,/*/ N/(+7/ 7+7/ L/ (/

I9,( (+(*9/ C()(*(+,( 7+7/ 9/(+7(

C()(*(+,(.(V! PULQUESE ( +9 99,7( 9 D7(+7/ OF,7( E

P+(9/ 9 ,(/ ,/997(.(VI! SIN COSTAS NI COSTOS.

(VII! NOTI$QUESE ,/9 (++?/ ( =.

En $%% 8!%, # Ju# #$!#8#B % #B # Cu!n% # %3!% ! 8u7 ! #n$#n8! #! un


52/52

Documents

Sentenci de Npotario